Transcript of Record — Dean Milk Co. v. City of Madison
Supreme Court brief1951
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
a ee aa
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
—
a"
f
Supreme Court of 4 nited States
OCTOBER TERM, 1950
| ae ~ No. 258 |
re ae ner
.
‘DEAN MILK COMPANY, APPELLANT,
Vs,
' CITY OF MADISON, WISCONSIN, A MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION, DR. C. K. KINCAID, AS HEALTH
COMMISSIONER FOR THE CITY OF MADISON,
WISCONSIN, ET AL.
;
i
; APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WISCONSIN
| FILED AUGUST 22,1950. _
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1950 =
No. 258 |
DEAN MILK COMPANY, APPELLANT,
/ vs. Ss
CITY (OF MADISON, WISCONSIN, A MUNICIPAL
CORPORATION, DR. C. K. KINCAID, AS HEALTH
COMMISSIONER FOR THE: CITY OF MADISON,
WISCONSIN, ET AL. ee
©
APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF WISCONSIN
INDEX :
Original Print
Proceedings in Supreme Court of Wisconsin 1 1
Appellant's appendix on appeal from Cireuit Court for
for Dane County . ny 1 i
Index to appendix and exhibits 275 275
Petition for appeal to Supreme Court of the United 8
States ay: Tee 281 281
Assignments of error and prayer for reversal _— 287 284
Order allowing appeal 291 286
Bond on appeal. .... .. (omitted in printing) 294
Citation and service (omitted in printing) 207
Stipulation as to record on appeal _ . . 300 287
«Caption (omitted in printing) 302
Notice of appeal to Supreme Court of Wisconsin 303 288
Bond on appeal . (omitted in printing) 306
Minute entry of argument and submission . 308 2sS9
Judgement. 2 309 290
Opinion, Broadfoot, J... oe Pade \-311 290
Clerk's certificate (omitted in pringing) 319
Statement of points to be relied upon and designation of
record 320 296
Order-noting probable jurisdiction 323 208
Jupp & DerweiLer (INc.), Printers, Wasuinerosx, D. C., Nov. 1, 1950.
—S66
é
STATE OF WISCONSIN
In Supreme Comet
August Term, 1949. No. 216.
DEAN MILK COMPANY, a corporation,
Plaintiff-Appellant,
vs.
CITY OF MADISON, WISCONSIN, a Municipal Cor-
poration, DR. C.-K. KINCAID, as Health Commis-
sioner for the City of Madison, Wisconsin, LEON-
ARD HOWELL, as City Manager of the City of —
Madison, Wisconsin, and THE COMMON COUNCIL
OF THE CITY OF MADISON, WISCONSIN,
Defendants-Respondents.
APPELLANT’S APPENDIX.
Rec.
Page
89 Before Hon. Alvin C. Reis, Judge.
DECISION OF TRIAL COURT.
Plaintiff seeks a declaratory judgment as to the
constitutionality of Madison’s Milk ordinances which
provide: (1) No milk shall be sold as pasteurized
milk in the city of Madison unless it has been pasteur-
ized ahd bottled within-a radius of five miles from the
Capitol Square. (2) The Health Department. shall
not be ‘‘obligated’’ to inspect and issue permits to
farms located more than twenty-five miles from the
Capitel-Square, as to raw milk to be delivered to pas-
teurization plants for sale in Madison.
The Madison Ordinance, as adopted August 27,
1949, contains the five mile and twenty-five mile pro-
visions in sections 7.21 and 7.11, respectively, as fol-
lows:
“7.91, Pasteurization Plants to be Within Five
Mile Radius. It sha be unlawful for any person,
association or corporation to sell, offer for sale
or have in his or its possession with intent to sell
or deliver in the City of Madison, any milk, cream,
or milk products as pasteurized unless the same
shall have been pasteurized and bottled in the man-
ner herein provided within a radius of five miles
from the central portion of the City of Madison
otherwise known as the Capital Square, at a plant
housing the machinery, equipment and facilities, all
of which shall have been approved by the Depart-
ment of Public Health’’.
‘*711.. _Permits * * * On the filing of an appli-
cation for a-permit with the Health Commissioner
he shall cause the source of supply named therein
‘to be inspected and shall cause all other necessary
inspections and investigations to be made. The
Health Department shall not be obligated to inspect
and issue permits to farms located beyond twenty-
five (25) miles from the central portion of the City
of Madison, otherwise known as the Capital
Square.”’
The Madison milk situation is summarized in the
City’s brief (p. 3) as follows:
7
3
**Madison is the center of Dane County which
produced ir 1948 over 600,000,000 pounds of milk.
This is more ih: ten times the milk used in the
City. Large quantities of, milk are shipped to the
Chieago market and: large quantities are made into
cheese, butter, evaporated milk, ete. The area with-
in a radius of 25 miles from the Capital.Sqnare in
the City of Madison includes practically all of Dane
County and portions of adjoining counties. At
present Madison’s pasteurized milk is furnished
entirely from farms located within about 18 miles
of the Capital Square.
‘There are several distributors of milk in Madi-
son, all of whose plants are lochted within 5 miles
of the Capital Square: (1) The University of
Wisconsin has its own vlants for pasteurizing and
‘supplying milk to Universitv Halls and commens;
(2) Rennehohm Farm supplies only the various
ennebchm Drug Stores and does not supply all
of the stores’ needs. There are three retail and
wholesale dealers, the Borden Company, Bancroft
Dairv and Bowman Farm Dairy supplying the city. °
‘“Many of the producers are represented by a
cooperative association which bargains for the pro-
ducer with the dealers on the price of milk, checks
weights .and tests, inspects milk and assists in
milk quality control. The cooperative also owns
and operates a surplus plant throuch which it
markets milk of Madison licensed nrodneers which
may from time to time be in exeess of the milk re-
quired for_consumption in Madison.
‘All producers delivering on the Madison mar-
ket are licensed hy the City Health Denartment
and are inspected hv representatives of the Health
Department as well as bv representatives of the
dealers and of the Cooperative Association.”’
—
4
Plaintiff is an Illinois corporation, with its prinei-
pal’ piuce of business in Chicago. It has pasteuri-
zation plants at Chemung and ‘Huntley, Illinois. Its
milk is supplied by about 950 farms located chiefly in
Illinois. These farms are licensed by the Chicago
Board of Health and are inspected by that depart-
ment. The plaintiff company also inspects the pro-
_ ducers’ farms and makes tests of milk purchased.
Plaintiff applied to the Madison Board of Health
in March, 1948, for a license to sell niilk in Madison.
~ This was refused. On October 1, 1949, plaintiff applied
to the Madison Board of Health for 950 farm permit
— application blanks. These were not furnished. Dr.
Kincaid—the City Health Commissioner—explained
that there was no- point in having Dean’s Illinois
producers apply for permits until it was determined
whether the five mile limit on pasteurization plants
was legal—since admittedly Dean has no intention
of pasteurizing within five miles of Madison but de-
sires to sell milk in Madison which has been pas-
teurized in Illinois plants.
The above reflects with reasonable adequateness
the background of the instant case.
We are constrained to remark that a record has
been built up in the present lawsuit upon miscellane-
ous matters not decisive of the case, in our judgment,
such as the relative merits of the United States
Public Health Service “‘model’’ milk ordinance and
the Chicago milk ordinance as compared with the
Madison general milk requirements’ ordine -e; also
the relative goodness and purity of plaintiff Dean’s
milk compared with Bowman’s, Borden’s and Ban-
.
i
a
croft’s, et al, now consumed in Madison; further, the
relative efficiency of inspection as between the Chi-
cago Health Department and the Madison Health
Department. Counsel even argue the issue whether
the ‘‘nethylene blue’’ or the ‘‘plate count”’ is the
preferable test to determine if the number of bac-
teria in milk. exceeds 200,000 per cubic centimeter!
We shall not exhaust brain tissue on such wander-
ings. <f
This Court’s duty is to decide upon constitutional-
ity, which decision, if it is good law, is good under
the Federal Constitution anywhere in the United
States and that decision cannot be swayed by a con-
sideration of: whether Madison’s general milk re-
quirements’ ordinance is better or worse than some
other ordinance in its provisions that water must be
from state well-code wells, dnd milk must be- cooled
to 50°, while Chicago says 60°; and manure shall be
pitched fifty feet from the barn door, whereas Chi-
cago permits the pitch to be but thirty; the Madison
ordinance requiring plant inspection every thirty days
but Chieago, six months; and the provision as as ‘‘the
trap in the drain from the milk house’’, the ‘‘breeze-
way between the milk-house and the barn’’; ete., ete.
_ How would the constitutional question in California
be changed, even if Hollywood had a better or worse
trap in the drain or breeze-way provision than Madi-
son or Chicago? How would it be changed in New
York is Schenectady called for 48° cooling or issues
a mandate to scurry out the manure at least 70 feet?
The constitutional question still is: Can Madison
or Chicago or Hollywood or Schenectady provide that
g8
93
milk sold in its city must have been pasteurized with-
in five miles of the center of the city and that farms
more than twenty-five miles from the city need not be
inspected (in effect, may not be eligible for a ‘‘per- |
mit’’ to sell raw milk to pasteurization plants serving
the city)?
True it may be, as counsel for the City points out
(brief, p. 17), that the basic local situation as to
whether a city has ten times as much milk produced
in its immediate environs as it needs—which is Madi-
son’s situation—or grenade sepa ay to ‘‘range
far afield’’ for milk (Jbid)—whith may be the fact
in large metropolitan areas—this or some similar
underlying and fundamental economic condition may
effect the reasonableness, and hence the validity, of
an. ordinance.
But blue test or plate count—a pitch of fifty or
thirty feet from the barn—50° or 60° cooling—and
such minutiae ad infinitum—go only to the question —
of whatever Madison or Chicago has the better kind
of milk regvlations as to health and sanitary require-
ments. These details as to how to produce and care
for milk do not hit the constitutional issue of Ge
five mile limit at all, as we view it.
\ Ts Madison’s five mile pasteurization ordinance con-
stitutional? It is. }
Madison’s five. mile pasteurization ofdinance is a
valid regulation under the ‘‘police powbr’’ to protect
the public healt and welfare. It simplifies inspection
of plants by requiring them to be near at hand, thus
permitting more intense and constant inspecting than
BAe
Po
94
~1
if such establishments were located anywhere in the
United States,
A city like Madison, in the interests of public
health, is entitled to set up its own system of milk
inspection if it be a reasonable one. The, City is not
foreed to rely upon inspection by some other govern-
mental unit nor to submit to ‘reciprocal inspection’®
unless some higher authority properly decrees ‘it.
‘One municipality does not have to sacrifice its
standards to those of another community which may
be lower nor is one governmental unit necessarily
compelled to yield its independence to another, even
though the latter’s gauges of inspection purport to
be equal or slightly higher.
The City of Madison—in the publie concern over
health—has an autonomy, a measure of local self-
government, which, if exercised reasonably, need give
way only to a constitutional enactment bv the legis-
lature of Wisconsin or the Congress of the United
States, “if such exists. None .such does exist as yet.
Is this five mile limit valid? The al-sufficient
answer is that our Supreme Court of Wisconsin has
held it valid, i.e., has held that an ordinance imposing
a sir mile limit on pasteurization plants is valid; and
probably no one would seek to split the hair on prin-
ciple between, five and six. The six mile ordinance was
the Beloit. enactment—which our Supreme Court up-
held against _all constitutional objection. — Dyer v.
City Council of Beloit, 250 Wis. 613—The High
court’s decision was on June 10, 1947.
The Supreme Court of Wisconsin as a Court must
overrule its decision of two years ago or else Madi-
son’s five mile pasteurization. ordinance stands.
Petitioner in the Beloit case was one Dyer, a dis-
tributor for the same Dean Milk Company which is
plaintiff in the case at har. The City denied him a
license to sell milk in Beloit because of its ordinance
which provided (as ‘quoted in the Supreme Court
opinion, O. 615):
‘‘no pasteurized milk shall be sold in the city of
Beloit which shall not have been pasteurized in
approved plants within six miles from the intersec-
tion of State Street and East Grand avenue in the
City of Beloit.’
The Supreme Court in the Beloit ease (p/615)
states Dvyer’s (Dean’s) position which is exactly
Dean’s —— today:
‘It is claimed this is a trade harrier, wisksios
the right of contract guaranteed under the Four-
teenth amendment of the constitution of the United
States, and is in conflict with the interstate-com-
merce clause of the United States constitution, sec.
8, art. I.’’
The Supreme Court so thoroughly disposed of
Dyer’s (Dean’s)-contentions—which are the same
‘ contentions of Dean today—and that Court so pre-
cisely stated the factual picture at Beloit which is
quite parallel with the one at Madison—that we quote
at length from the Court’s 1947 Ene (pp. 616-
618) :
“That cities have a right to pass a milk ovina
for the welfare and health of their citizens is not
disputed, and milk ordinances are general in the .
state of Wisconsin and elsewhere in the nation.
Such an ordinance must be reasonable and not
arbitrary, must“not go beyond the reasonable de-
mands of the occasion, and must tend to accomplish
%
27.
9
the purpose of its adoption. Courts will not inter-
fefe with the exercise of police power by a munici-
pal corporation in the absence of a clear abuse «of
discretion and unless it is manifestly unreasonable
_ and oppressive, for it is not within the province
of the courts, except'in clear cases, to interfere
with the exercise of this power reposed by law in
municipal corporations. 11 Am. Jur., Constitutional
Law, p. 1092, sec. 307. Municipal corporations are
prima facie the sole judges respecting the necessity
and reasonableness of ordinances under their police
power, and every intendment is to be made in favor |
of the lawfulness and “reasonableness of such ordi-
. nance. The city*is presumed to have full knowledge
of local conditions, and its adoption of an ordinance
in the light of this kndwledge creates a prima facie
_ presumption that it is reasonable. 3 MeQuillin,
Mun. Corp. (2d ed.) p. 110, see. 951. The redson-
ableness of an ordinance depends upon the purpose
sought to be accomplished and the effect upon all
who must comply with it.
‘“‘The city of Beloit is in the center of an area
producing great quantities of milk, containing a
large number of pasteurization plants, condenseries,
and creameries. The area described in the ordinance
includes pasteurization plants both in Wisconsin
and in Illinois. Over four hundred farms are in-
cluded in the area and slightly over one hundred
farms produce sufficient milk to supply the demand
.of the city of Beloit. Thus three fourths of the milk
produced in the area is not required to supply the
city of Beloit and is shipped elsewhere for such
_ purposes as it may properly be used. .The supply of
milk in the area is ample for a large number of
additional milk‘ plants of any type that may desire
to engage in the business, The ordinance clearly
was not passed for the purpose of limiting the
i
96
10
business to the plants then in operation. Milk is
usually delivered to near-by plants as a matter of
econonty and convenience, which answers the con-
tention that _the location of the farms producing -
the milk is not limited by the ordinance but the
location of the pasteurization plant is. The ordi-
nance in question not only provides for the inspec-
tion of the pasteurization plants, but requires the
inspection of the farms producing the milk.
**Tt is claimed by appellant, and admitted by the
city sanitarian from a few examinations made by
him, that-the milk produced by the Dean Milk
Company complied with the sediment tests, blue
tests, other tests, and coritent requirements of fhe
ordinance of the city of Beloit. -This could well he
true of milk’ purchased from a pasteurization plant
a must greater distance from the city of Beloit. -
Convenience, efficiency, and cost of inspection enter
into a determination of the question of the reason-
ableness of an ordinance. Tt is said in State er rel.
careen v. Minneapolis (1933), 190 Minn: 138, 142,
251 N. W. 121, with reference to the constitution-
ality of a milk ordinance, quoting with approval
from the trial court:
***Tt is obvious that the adequate inspection is
a reasonable precaution. It is obvious that con-
sideration of convenience, efficiency and cost of in-
spection are proper to be taken into account in
determining the question of reasonableness. It is
also obvious that there is somewhere a limit of
distance bevond which inspection by the city’s
agents would he too inconvenient, too costly, and
too likely to he ineffective to be practicable. It
-seems to me there can be no doubt of the right of
‘the city council to fix a reasonable limit beyond
which it will not provide fer inspection, and beyond
which, for that reason, pasteurization plants will
not be licensed.’
ge
11
F ,
“The city of Beloit has two employees in this -
--department, the city sanitarian and an assistant,
and proof was. offcred that to assume the inspec-
tion of the additional plant and farms it would, re- -
-quire the employment of another employee at a
cost of $2,400 per vear, and if other likewise distant, Ps
plants were included it would cost much more.
’ Convenience and efficiency are self-evident. .
‘‘Tt cannot be said that the city, in adopting the
sectioh in dispute, arbitrarily acted on the question
of convenience, efficiency, and cost of it ion,
unless we adopt the rule in the case of Meridian,
Ltd. v. Sippy, 54 Cal. App. (2d) 214, 128 Pae. (2d).
884, where the-court said that milk production is
a legitimate business and so long as persons en-
gaged in the business put out a clean, pure and
wholesome product it should be permitted to flow °
freely on the markéts, unburdened by duplication
of inspection and prohibitive trade barriers, which
rule we do not adopt.’’ (Our italics) 7
It should be noted that the Supreme Court of Wis- «
consin, in the foregoing, refuses to adopt the rule
laid down Sy the some court or courts, namely, that .
if the milk is ‘‘a clean, pure and wholesome product”’,
therefore ‘‘it should be permitted to flow freely on
the markets, unburdened by duplication of inspec-
tion and prohibitive trade barriers’’—which is Dean’s
argument in almost its exact words, infra. |
Our Court then continued and declared the law in
a nutshell (pp, 618-619) :
‘‘Every ordinance must stand or fall n its
own merits, It is either reasonable or arbiffary in
accordance with the facts and ‘purposes it is intend-
. ed to serve, if within the police powers of the
municipality adopting it... The area necessary to be
oy
uw
a
Rec
Page
- 12 ae
E ° ‘J
included in the ordinance could well depend upon
the population to be served, ‘the amount of «milk
produced, and the location of the pasteurization
plants with reference to the population to be served.
A reasonable exercise of police power is not a trade
barrier, and contract rights guaranteed under the
. Fourteenth amendment of the federal constitution
do not have a superior right to the right of a
municipality to reasonably protect the health of its
eitizens.’’
Thus our Supreme Court dealt with Dean’s argu-
ment that due process was denied it, under the Four-
teenth Amendyent of the Federal Constitution.
Dean in the case now before us, as well as in the
Beloit case, advanced also the argument that the local
ordinance interfered with interstate commerce and
hence impinged upon the Federal Constitution.
Dean’s position on interstate commerce is set forth
concisely in its reply brief (p. 6) in the present case:
“The test is, is the food or milk. which the plaintiff
proposes to sell a pure, wholesome product? If it is,
it cannot be barred from interstate. commeree.”’
But ‘the Supreme Court did not agree with this -
argument in the Beloit ease, for with equal concise-
ness the Court stated (p. 619):
‘‘This ordinance does not violate the interstate-
commerce clause of the United States constitution.
Milk may be furnished from farms and pasteuriza-
tion plants in the state of Illinois as well as in the
state of Wisconsin, and infact milk is so furnished.
The production and delivery of milk are essentially
- loeal problems with which congress has not sought
to deal, leaving tl city of Beloit free to act in the
exercise of its police powers.”’
Rec.
Page
98
13
To be sure, the Court indicated that milk was being
furnished to Beloit from both Tllinois and Wisconsin;
and it concluded that interstate commerce was ‘not
impaired. That consideration in the ‘Madison case
would go only to the twenty-five mile limit on inspec-
tion and permits to-farms—the second ordinance
herein attacked which we will disduss, inJra.
There certainly can be no interference with inter.
state commerce by an ordinance reciting that milk
must be pasteurized within five miles of Madison.
' That requirement seizes upon the product after it
has come to rest in the state. That,is not a prohibi-
tion of interstate commerce. It is a purely local
regulation.
We unquestionably could render a_ declaratory
judgment today upholding constitutionality of the
five mile pasteurization ordinance in a one sentence
pinion citing Dyer v. Beloit decided in 1947—except
for the strange aftermath to the Supreme Court’s
opinion in that case.
After the Court’s decision in their favor, the
Beloit authorities changed their mind, amended their
ordinance, and granted Dyer-(Dean) a license. Dyer
had, in the meantime, appealed from our Supreme
Court’s decision to the Supreme Court of the United
States and there the Beloit authorities ‘adopted the
twist of moving to dismigs Dyer’s appeal upon the
ground that their change of heart by granting Dyer
(Dean) a license had made the case moot. Thereupon,
Dean objected to dismissing the appeal for the pur-
ported reason that this would leave the Wisconsin
8
14
2 :
Supreme Court’s decision in effect, upholding the
ordinance. 4
So, the Supreme Court of the United States vacates
the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s decision and remands
‘the case to the Wisconsin high court ‘‘for such fur-
- appropriate.
ther proceedings as by that court may be deemed
> Whereupon the Wisconsin Supreme
Court reverses the Cireuit Court for Roek County
which originally it had affirmed in holding the ordi-
nance valid!—Dyer v. City Council of Beloit, 252
Wis. 249 (March 2, 1948).
We quote in its entirety the text of the denominated
reversal, all of which is printed in the type of a head-
note (252 Wis. 249-250) :
‘‘In this case, the court on June 10, 1947, affirmed
a judgment of the Cireuit Court dismissing the
appellant’s petition for a writ of mandamus to.
compel the city of Beloit to issue to the appellant a
license as a milk distributor, and held a certain milk
ordinance of the city constitutional. The ease is
originally reported in 250 Wis: 613, 27 N.W. (2d)
733. In proceedings on appeal to the United States
supreme court, the respondents moved to dismiss
the appeal on the ground that the case was moot,
the respondents confessing error and setting forth
that the city had amended the ordinance and issned
a milk license to the appellant pursuant to the
amended ordinance. The appellant opposed a\dis-
missal of the appeal on the ground, among others, —
that\a_ dismissal would result in permitting the
judemént and decision of this court to stand as a
valid judgment and decision holding the original
ordinance constitutional and giving the ‘city the
right to re-enact the original ordinanee. The United
o,
%.
v
Rec.
Page
100
15
States Supreme Court on February 2, 1948, entered
a mandate providing in part: ‘On consideration of
the motion of the appellees to dismiss, it appearing
that the cause has become moot, the judgment of
the supreme court of Wisconsin is vacated and the
cause is remanded for such further proceedings as
by that court may be deemed appropriate.’ 333 U.
S. 825, 68 Sup. Ct. 450, 92 L. Ed. 0000. (Reporter.)
‘“‘After the filing of the mandate of the United
States Supreme Court in this cgurt, the appellant |
on March 29, 1948, move at the judgment of
the cireuit court be revefsed and for other relief.
After hearing counsel for Nae_respondents as well
as for the appellant, this court on March 29, 1948,
entered the following mandate:
““By the Court—‘ Judgment appealed from is
reversed and cause remanded with directions to
dismiss the complaint.’ ’’
This pro forma action, the Supreme Court at Wash-
ington hy vacating and the Wisconsin Supreme Court
by so-called reversing, under the circumstances, surely
has not erased and annihilated our Supreme Court’s
decision in tie Beloit case on the merits. ‘©
Said the Supreme Court of the United States in
‘Berry v. Davis, 242 U. S. 468, 470; 61 L. Ed. 441, 442:
‘*An appeal was taken to this court in 1914. In
1915 the Act of 1913 was repealed, and the sub-
stituted act does not apply to the plaintiff. ° ° *
Therefore, upon the precedents we are not called
upon to consider the propriety of the action of the
district court, but the proper course is to reverse
the decree and remand the cause, with directions
that the bill be dismissed without costs to either
party.”’
0 iis
Cc.
ge
16
Plaintiff Dean cites us to a very late case—Septem-
ber 22, 1949—wherein the Supreme Court of Illinois
decides in Dean’s favor and holds invalid a Wauka-
gan ordinance forbidding sale of milk in that city,
unless the milk was produced and pasteurized in Lake
County (wherein Waukegan is located).—Dean Milk
Co, vy. City of Waukegan, .... Til. ..., 87 N.E. (2d) 751.
It is to be observed, of course, that the Waukegan
ordinance demanded that both production and pasteur-
ization of milk must be within Lake County, whereas
Madison’s five mile ordinance on Pasteurization—in
and of itself—contains no mileage limit on produc-
tion. The Wisconsin Supreme Court’s decision in the
Beloit ease and the Illinois Supreme Court’s decision
in the Waukegan case, therefore, may be distinguish-
able.
Let us suppose, however, that the decisions of the
highest courts of Illinois and Wisconsin are in con-
flict. What of it? We have never appreciated the idea
of trying to reconcile the decisions of all. courts
everywhere, which apparently is the strain of most ©
attorneys’ briefs and of many judicial opinions.
Why compare incomparables? Men’s minds and
ideals and backgrounds differ, particularly in that
shadowy domain of what is in the best interest of
public health and the ‘general welfare’. 9
Judges are lawyers. Lawyers differ in their opin-
ions.’ Judges do not cease to be lawyers simply be-
‘ause they don black rohes. Why should they not eon-
tinue to have divergent opinions?
Philosophizing asifle—Mlinois and Wiseonsin high °
courts are opposed, we assume, on a certain issue
Map
17
of constitutional law. Shall we follow the Supreme
Conrt of Illinois or the Supreme Court of Wisconsin?
Which do we have to follow? Perforce it is the Wis- ~
consin Supreme Court, even though we disagreed
with it—which we do NOT in this case.
Accordingly, our conclusion is that the die has
been cast—so far as Madison’s five mile pasteuriza-
.tion ordinance is concerned—by the Supreme Court’s
sustaining of Beloit’s six mile pasteurization. ordi-
nance, supra:
We come now to the 25 mile prdvikion on inspec-
tion of milk farms and the consequence implicit in the
ordinance, that is, that the Health Department need
not inspect farms beyond 25 miles from Madison and
hence these farmers—950 of them in Dean’s territory
in Illinois—-may be ineligible for permits to produce
milk for the Madison market.
We agree with the City Attorney ( betet pp. 2, 22
thatcthe Court need not pass upon this 25 mile ordi-
nance provision as to farmers, in the present litiga-
tion. Dean Milk Company is not a farmer—owns no
farms. The 950 farmers are nut parties in this action
nor is a single Tllinois farm such a party. The
party plaintiff milk distributing corporation is not
privileged to champion the rights oof others and force
an adjudication as to them.
Moreover, there is no ‘‘justiciable controversy ’’—
to use an erudite term—between Dean and Madison
as to the 25 mile limit—and justiciahle controversy
is of the essence in an application for a declaratory
judgment.
ec.
age
()2
18
Dean Milk Company. need not be concerned by
where its farmer patrons live, so long as Dean is not
pasteurizing, and has expressed no intent to pas-
tenrize, within five miles of Madison. The question
is completely academic and moot a&to where Dean’s
milk comes from, if Dean is not going to sell in Madi-
and Dean cannot sell in° Madison without pas-
teurizing inside the five mile limit, if Madison’s five
mile pasteurization ordinance is valid—and we hereby
hold it to he valid.
So. ouredecision is confined to upholding the eon-
_ stitutionality of the five mile pasteurization ordinance
and we do not penetrate the inquiry as to whether
restricting milk production, in substance, to a 25
mile zone, is a violation of anvone’s constitutional
rights. We shall cross that bridge when we get on it
in a proper case, if ever we do.
The City Attorney may prepare and submit. to
opposing counsel a declaratory judgment adjudging
see. 7.21 of the city ordinance of Madison to be valid
in its enactment as follows: |
**7.21. Pasteurization Plants to be Withir Five
Mile Radius. It shall he unlawful for any person,
association or corporation to sell, offer for sale
or have in his or its possession with intent to sell
‘or deliver in the Citv of Madison, anv milk, cream,
or milk products as pasteurized unless the same
shall have been pasteurized and hottled in the man-
ner herein provided within a radius of five .miles
from the central pértion of the City of Madison
otherwise known as the Capital Square, at a plant
housing the machinery, equipment and _ facilities,
all of which shall have been approved by the De-
partment of Public Health.”’
Q
&3
Rec.
Page
on
“I
19
Dated, December 13, 1949.
PLAINTIFF’S SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT.
Now Comes the plaintiff, by McGowan, Geffs, Geffs
& Block, its attorneys, and for a cause of action
against the defendants, complains and alleges as fol-
lows: | ;
1. That the plaintiff is an Illinois corporation,
having its main business offices in the City of Chi-
cago, Cook County, Illinois, and that it operates a
milk pasteurization plant in the City of Chemune,
Illinois, >
2. That the defendants above named are the execu-
tive, legislative and administrative officers of the City
of Madison, Dane County, Wisconsin, and that the
city of Madison, Wisconsin, is a municipal corpora-
tion.
3. That on the 14th day of February, 1930, the
common council of he City of Madison, Wisconsin,
adopted the followang ordinance : ”
‘Section 1. Section 43-of- Subsection E of Ordi-
nance Number 2183, entitled ‘An Ordinance Amend-
ing the Genefal Ordinances of the City of Madison
relating to the License for Sale of Milk and Cream,’
is hereby amended by inserting before the first
sentence thereof the following: ‘It shall be unlaw-
ful for any person, association, or corporation to
sell, offer for sale or have in his or its. possession
with intent to sell or deliver in the City of Madi-
son, any milk or milk products as pasteurized un- |
less the same shall have been pasteurized and
bottled in the same manner provided. in this ordi-
nance within a radius of five miles from the central
Rec.
Page
portion of the City of Madison, otherwise known
as the Capitol Square, at a plant the machinery,
equipment and facilities of which shall have been
approved by the Heajth Department’’’.
that at the time the controversy herein alleged and
referred to, rose, said_ ordinance as above quoted
was in full force and effect. 5
4. That the plaintiff is engaged in the purchase
of Grade A milk from farm producers and in the
pasteurization thereof, and in the sale of said pas-
teurized milk to retail stores in cities and villages
in the State of Illinois and Wisconsin; that on the
8th day of March, 1948, the plaintiff herein made
application to the City of Madison for a license to
distribute pasteurized Grade A milk. cream and milk
products in the City of Madison. That on the 12th
day of March, 1948, the plaintiff herein was notified
by the Health Commissioner of the City of Madison
that its request for a license was denied, and re-—
turned to the plaintiff herein the application fee
deposited by the plaintiff at the time said application
for license was filed; and stated in a letter that the
plaintiff’s request for a license must be denied. A
copy of said letter is attached hereto, marked Exhibit
A and made a part hereof.
_5. That said application was denied, at that time
> because plaintiff’s pasteurization plant was located
in Chemung, Illinois, more than five miles from the
central portion of the City of “Madison, otherwise
known as the Capitol Square, and for ro other rea-
son, as plaintiff is informed and believes.
6. That the milk which the plaintiff. intended, to
: 21
sell to the City of Madison, Wisconsin, if its appli-
cation for license had been granted, complied with
all requirements of the milk ordinance of the City
of Madison.as to place of production, pasteurization,
tind requirements as to quality and sanitary condi-
tions, except that said milk was not pasteurized within
the five mile zone designated in said ordinance.
cf Plaintiff further alleges that had said license
been issued to plaintiff, it was its intention to obtain
the milk which it intended to sell in the City of Mad-
ison from its pasteurization plant in the City of
Chemung, Illinois, after the same had been bottled
and. placed in paper cartons, and then packed into
a refrigerated truck and transported from said city
vot Chemung, Illinois, and sold to various retail grocers
in the City of Madison, Dane County, Wisconsin. That
said facts were made known to the above named de-
fendants on many occasions, before filing said appli-
cation for license, and at the time said application
was filed. a
a
° 8. That plaintiff on several occasions has _re-
quested the said defendants since the request to
i8sue said-license as aforesaid, and in open meeting -
has requested said City Council of Madison to amend
said ordinance so that the plaintiff herein could have
issued to it upon proper application a license to
distribute milk in said .City of Madison as aforesaid,
submitting to said City Manager and said City Coun-
cil that the ordinance for: the sale of milk and
cream in the City of Madison. was unconstitutional
for the reasons herein. stated.
Rec.
Page
59
22
9. That although the said section of the city or-
dinance of the City o& Madison requiring that milk
be pasteurized within the five mile zone. was ‘uncon-
stitutional, the defendants did not grant the plaintiff
a milk license as they should have done, but on Au-
gust 27th, 1949, adopted a new milk ordinance, a
copy of which is attached hereto, and made, a part
hereof, and marked ‘‘ Exhibit B’’; that said new or-
dinance re-enacted in Section 7.21 the provision of the
prior ordinance that it was unlawful for milk to be
sold in the City of Madison which had net been pas-
teurized within the five mile zone.
10. That the said provision in the milk ordinance
of August 27th, 1949, prohibiting the sale of milk not
pasteurized within the five mile zone is unconstitu-
tional, in that it violates the provisions of the Four-
teenth Amendment te the Constitution of the United
States, and deprive this plaintiff of the right to
contract, and the right to do business, in violation of
said amendment, and deprive the plaintiff of its prop-
erty without due process of the law, and said pro-
visions are in .conflict with Section Eight, Article I
of the United States Genstitution, which provides ‘that
the Congress shall have power ‘‘to regulate com-
merce with foreign nations, and among the several
states, and with the Indian tribes’’, and that said
provisions are a violation of the constitution of the
State of Wisconsin.
11. That although the plaintiff made application
on March &th, 1948, for a license to sell pasteurized
Grade A milk and milk products in the City of Madi-
son, Wisconsin, that said license was denied on March
°
D
23
12th, 1948, and that the defendants then took the po-
sition, and still take the position, that the plaintiff
is not entitled to sell milk in the City of Madison be-
cause its pasteurization plant is not located within
the five mile zone; that the plaintiff contends that
the said provision is unconstitutional, and that there
now exists a controversy between the plaintiff and
defendants as to the legality of said provision.
12. That Section 7.20 of the ordinance of August 3
27th, 1949, provides it shall be unlawful to sell milk in
the City of\ Madison from a plant which has not been
licensed by the City of Madison, Wisconsin; said sec-
tion also provides :( that the owner of the plant shall
make application. setting forth (a) name, post office
address and exact location \of the dairy, (b) if the
applicant does | rot keep cows, the source or sources
from which he obtains milk or cream for sale or de-
livery, (c) said applicant shall present written consent
ipraatine the Health Commissioner free and open
access to the dairy plant and its premises for the
purpose of making such inspection as he may deem
necessary, regardless of whether the dairy plant is in
operation or not, (d) the applNeation shall state
whether Grade A pasteurized milk or milk products
or certified pasteurized’ milk are to be sold, (e) such
application shall state the average daily volume of
’ milk processed and delivered and such other infor-
mation as may be necessary to “the Department of
Publie Health, and (f) a license fee of One Doltar
($1.00) shall acompany such application.
That although the plaintiff is able, ready and will-
ing to make a new application and to pay-the One
7
+
&3
24
. 4
Dollar ($1.00) and to furnish all the information
ealled for, that said application would be useless,
because the defendants take the position that they
are not obligated to inspect the. plaintiff’s plant and
issue to it a license because said pasteurization plant
is not located within the aforementioned five mile .
zone.
13. That the farms from which the plaintiff ob-
tains milk and its pasteurization plant at Chemung,
Tilinois, and the vehicles in which said milk are de-
livered, are inspected weekly by inspectors hired by
the plaintiff, and are°inspected by the City of “Chi- —
cago, Illinois, and that the city ordinance of Chi-
~ eago, Illinois, contains provisions insuring the purity,
quality and sanitation of the milk which are equiva-
lent to that of the City of Madison, Wisconsin, under
its present ordinance; that the plaintiff’s milk is
Grade A milk as provided in the United States Model
Milk Ordinance promulgated by the United States
Public Healtlp Service, and that plaintiff’s milk and
milk products’ are produced, pasteurized, bottled,
transported and inspected in compliance with the
United States Model Milk Ordinance which is equiva-
‘lent to the ordinance attached as Exhibit B as to pur-
ity and sanitation; that although the plaintiff made
application on March 8th, 1948, for a license to sell
milk in said city of Madison, the defendants haveqg
made no attempt to inspect the said farms from which
the plaintiff obtains milk, or to inspect its plant or
the vehicles in which said milk is transported, and
have made no attempt to satisfy themselves that said
milk was produced, pasteurized. and transported pur-
©
Peer ; : a5 f :
Page
61 suant to inspections of the city ordinance of the City
of Chicago, Illinois, which has provisions equivalent
to that of the City of Madison, Wisconsin, as above
alleged; that said inspectors of the City of Chicago
are qualified to make inspections under and carry
- out the necessary provisions of said Chicago ordi-
nance, and their inspections are accepted and ap-
proved by other cities and communities; that the
defendants have taken no steps whatsoever to satisfy .
themselves as to the purity, quality and sanitation of
the plaintiff’s milk, and do not propose to do so, and
claim that they have the right not to do so, and to
bar the plaintiff from selling milk in the City of
Madison, Wisconsin, because the plaintiff’s milk is
not pasteurized within the five mile zone.
14.. That Section 7.25 of the ordinance adopted
August 27th, 1949, by the defendant city, provides:
‘“‘This ordinance shall be enforced by the
Health Commissioner in accordance with the in-
terpretation thereof contained in the current edi-
tion of the United States Public Health Service
Milk Code, a certified copy of which shall be
on file in the city clerk’s office, provided tha
case of upward reyisions, the provisions shal
interpreted according to the provisions expressed
in this ordinance.”’
That Section 11 of the United States Public Health
Service Milk Code above referred to reads as follows:
**Milk and milk products from points beyond
the limits of routine inspection of the city of
Sistemas gastiacslonn may not be sold in the city of
Pen SENN ETM DOS , or its police jurisdiction unless
produced and/or pasteurized under provisions
equivalent to the requirements of this ordinance;
62
26
provided that the health officer shall satisfy him- :
self that the health officer having jurisdiction
over the production and processing is properly
enforcing: such provision.’*
That the following comment is made by the United
States Public Health Service following the proposed
section:
‘*It is suggested that the health officer approve
milk or milk products from distant points with-
out his inspection if they are produced and proc-
essed under regulations equivalent to those of
this ordinance, and if the milk or milk -products
have been awarded by the State control agency a
rating of 90 percent or more on the'basis of
the Public Health Service rating method.’’
That plaintiff’s milk and milk products have been —
awarded a rating of better than 90 percent by the
‘State Control Agency.
15. That the milk and milk products: that the
plaintiff proposes to sell in the city of Madison, Wis-
consin, meet all of the requirements of the city or-
dinance of the city of Madison, Wisconsin, including
the requirements in respect to production, pasteuri-
zation, and distribution, except said milk is not pas-
teurized within the five mile zone; that the plaintiff
sells milk in the City of Chicago and over two hun-
dred other municipalities in the State of Illinois,
and the State of Wisconsin, and that the’ health offi-
cers of the City of Chieago are enforcing the pro-
visions of the city ordinance of the city of Chicago
over the production and processing and distribution of
said milk; that under the model milk code promul-
C
‘mended by the United States Pablie Health Services.
gated and recommended by the United States Depart-
ment of Health, the health officer of the city of
Madison, Wisconsin, without undue expense or jp-
convenience could long before this time have satis
himself that the said milk is being produced; pas-
teurized .and distributed under standards equivalent
to those prescribed by the present ordinance of the
eity of Madison, Wisconsin, and that: said standards
were being enforced by other municipalities and by
the plaintiff maintaining inspectors over said farms,
pasteurization plant and delivery vehicles; that the
milk proposed to be sold by the plaintiff meets the
requirements of the milk ordinance and code recom-
16. Plaintiff further alleges that by reason of the
above and foregoing, it is necessary for the rights
of the plaintiff to secure a declaratory judgmeat un-
der Se¢. 26956 of the Wisconsin Statutes.
Wherefore plaintiff asks that a declaratory judg-—
ment be entered herein as follows:
1. That the Court adjudge that the provisions of
the present Madison milk ordinance providing that
milk cannot be sold in the City of Madison unless
pasteurized within the five mile zone be unconstitu-
tional, null and void.
2. That the plaintiff be given a full en complete
determination and declaratory judgment of its rights
in aceordance with the claims and demands of the
plaintiff as set forth in this complaint.
3. For such other and further declaratory jndg-
ment, order or relief as may be just and proper.
Rec.
Page
> 28
And for a further cause of action the plaintiff com-
plains and alleges as follows:
1. The plaintiff adopts and makes a part of this
‘count the following paragraphs of Count One to the
same éffect as if set out in full herein: one, two, four,
Se ke ft °
“six, seven, fourteen and fitteen.
2. That the plaintiff began the action set forth in’
“Count One in October of 1948; that on December 18th,
1948, the defendants served arf answer upon the plain-
tiff’s attorneys, and in said answer. in paragraphs
- 14, 15, 16; 17, and. 18, set forth that milk was being
supplied to the city of Madison from approximately
. four hundred farms located within a radius of twenty-
five miles of Capitol Square of the City of Madison;
that the defendants were informed and believe that
the plaintiff obtained its milk from two-hundred or
more farms located chiefly in the State of Tlinois,
many miles from Madison; that it was inpractical
for the plaintiff to segregate the milk which is proe-
essed at its Chemung, Illinois, plant that would pe
sold in Madison, Wisconsin; and that t6 grant the
plaintiff a license» would place an undue burden upon
the city Health Department and would require: ‘‘at
> Jeast one additional full time qualified dairy sani-
64
tarian on the staff of the City Health Department,
adeq@ately to inspect the plaintiff’s plant and the
farms delivering to it; thus unreasonably adding -to
_ the inconvenience and cost ‘‘of milk inspection’’; that
‘the plaintiff takes the position that the method set
forth in the Model Milk Ordinance promulgated by
the United States Publie Health Service is an ade-
quate method of insuring the purity and sanitation of
—
“Rec.
Page
29
milk and milk products, and that if followed by the
city health department of Madison, Wisconsin, would
not place any undue burden upon the said city health
department.
3. That pending this litigation, the City of Madi-
‘son adopted the city ordinance attached hereto and
marked ‘‘Exhibit B’’ and made a part hereof as
fully as if-set forth-herein; that the said ordinance
contains a provision in Sec. 7.11 that the farms where
the milk is produced must obtain a permit from the
city of Madison, Wisconsin, and provides:
‘The Health Department shall not be obli-
gated to inspect and issue permits to farms lo-
cated beyond twenty-five miles from the central
‘portion of the Capitol of Madison, otherwise
known as Capitol Square.”’
4. That said ordinatice adopted August 27th, 1949,
also provides in See. 7.20 (2) that the milk producer
must ,make application: 7
(a) Giving name and address of the farm owner,
e) Name and address of the tenant, if there is one,
(c) Legal description of ‘the premises,
(d) The nam® of the dairy plant to whom the milk
is to be sold, and
(e) A statement granting free access td the premises
to the Health Commissioner at all times for such
inspection as he may deem necessary.
5. That the plaintiff does not own the farms on
which it obtains the milk which it pasteurizes at Chem-
ung, Illinvis, but obtains the milk from approximately
nine hundred. different farms located in Northern
Illinois and Southern Wisconsin, at distances rang-
ing from forty to one hundred twenty-five miles from
>the city of Madison, Wisconsin; that the plaintiff
ti
does not obtain milk from any@arms, and has no con-
tract with any farmer to furnish it with milk, which
is located within the twenty-five mile radius of the
city of Madison, Wisconsin.
6. That the plaintiff’s business is dependent upon
obtaining milk from the said milk producers located
in Northern IJllineis and Southern Wiseonsin;. that
the plaintiff is able, ready and willing to have each
of said owners of said farms where it obtains said
milk make application to the city health department
of Madison, Wisconsin, but that upon information
and belief, said application by said farm owners
would bea useless gesture, and that the said city of
Madison would deny the said farm owners the re-
spective permits.
7. That the defendants take the position that the
city health department of Madison has a diseretion
as to the inspection of said farms and the issuance
of said permits, and that in the absence of a favor-
able decision by the said health department, have the
right to deny the issuance of said permits to the
id owners, and have the right to deny the plain-
the right to sell its milk and milk produets in the
city \of Madison, Wisconsin; that the plaintiff takes
the position that the health department of Madison
does not possess such rights, and that the said ordi-
nance, in so far as it restricts, limits and prohibits
the plaintiff from selling its milk and milk products
in the city of Madison, Wisconsin, is unconstitutional,
being in violation of the 14th Amendment of the
&
e
9
i
31
United States Constitution in that it deprives the
plaintiff of its right to contract, its right to prop-
erty, denies to the plaintiff the equal protection of
the law, denies to the plaintiff the right to transact
a lawful business, and violates the Interstate Com-
merce Clause of the United States Constitution, and
violates the Constitution of the State of Wisconsin.
8. Upon informatior and _ belief plaintiff alleges
that the health department of the city of Madison
would refuse upon application to inspect the said
farms and to issue the permits, and that said action
is arbitrary, discriminatory and unreasonable; that
Sec. 7.25 of the said ordinance adopted August 27th,
1949, which provides that the, Health Commissioner
shall enforee this ordinance in accordance with the
interpretation contained in the current edition of
the United States Public Health Service Milk Code,
provides the said Commissioner of Health with an
adequate and reasonable means, with little expense,
of satisfying himself that the farms from which the
plaintiff obtains its milk are sanitary, and operated
in accordance with the provisions of said ordinance
of the city of Madison.
9. That there exists a controversy between the
parties as to the said matters, and that it is neces-
sary for the rights of the plaintiff to be declared
under Sec. 269.56 of the Wisconsin Statutes.
Wherefore the plaintiff asks declaratory judgment
be éntered herein as follows:
1. That the Court adjudge that See. 7.11 of the
ordinance of August 27th, 1949, be construed as not
giving the Health Commissioner of the city of Madi-
67
68
32 ;
son, Wisconsin, the discretion not to inspect the farms
from which the plaintiff obtains its milk, if said farm |
owners make proper application.
2. That if said section is not susceptible of eer
interpretation, that it be declared unconstitutional,
null and void. | |
3. That this Court declare that the defendants
have pot the right to restrict, prohibit or prevent
the plaintiff from selling its milk and milk products
in the city of Madison, Wisconsin, by virtue of See.
7.11 of said ordinance. }
104That the plaintiff bé given such further and
other relief as shall be just and equitable.
McGowan, Geffs, Geffs & Block,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
EXHIBIT ‘‘A’’.
"_ ,- City
of
Madison ™
Madison 3, Wisconsin
Board of Health
110 North Hamilton Street
a March .12, 1948 3
Dean Milk Company © %
206 E. Front St.,
Harvard, Illinois. ae os
, Att: Mr. J, W. Mumford
Dear Sir: : we
Your application for a license to Wi ibute pas-
teurized milk, cream, and milk produé¢ts in the .city
of Madison has heeft received and considered.
Rec.
Page
72
*
=
Q
33
Our city ordinance sets up certain restrictions and
requirements concerning dairy plants and farms pro-
ducing milk for the city of Madison.
We are sorry to inform you that under this ordi- -
nance your request for a license must be denied. We
are, therefore, returning your check of March 8th for
one dollar.
Very truly yours,
Louis Fauerbach
Health Commissioner.
Exhibit B of the complaint being the Milk Ordi-
nance of the City of Madison, adopted August 27,
1949 was introduced in evidence as Exhibit 45 and
the material parts will be printed as that Exhibit.
ANSWER TO SECOND AMENDED COMPLAINT.
Now Come The Defendants herein, appearing by
Harold E. Hanson, City Attorney for the City of
Madison, Wisconsin, and as and for an answer to the
first cause of -action of the second. amended com-
plaint of the plaintiff herein, respectfully allege and
show to the Court as follows:
1. Defehdants admit upon information and belief
that the plaintiff is an Illinois corporation having its
main business offices in the City of Chicago, Cook
County, Illinois, and that it operates a milk pasteuri-
zation plant in the City of Chemung, Illinois.
2. Defendants admit that they are the executive,
legislative and some of the administrative officers of
the City of Madison, Dane County, Wisconsin and
that the said City of Madison is a municipal corpora-
tion.
34
Rec. °
Page '
3. Defendants admit that on or about the 4th day
of February, 1930, the Common Council of the City -
of Madison, Wisconsin adopted an ordinance, a por-
tion of which is set forth in paragraph 3 of the plain-
tiff’s complaint and that at the time the controversy
alleged in the complaint arose the said ordinance |
was in full force and effect and still is in full force
and effect. The.glefendants, however, allege that the
portion of the said ordinance so set forth in the
plaintiff's complaint is a mere fragmentary portion
of the then existtpg ordinances of the City of Madi-
73 son dealing with the entire subject of sale of milk
and dairy products within the city and ineluding
standards for production, processing, manufacturing,
transportation, handling, sale and delivery of such
milk and fairy products and requiring regular in-
spection by the City Health Department of all dairy
plants and all farms on which milk is produced for
sale in the City of Madison. Attached to the answers,
to the original complaint as Exhibit 1 and ineorpor.
ated hérein as though fully set forth herein is a copy
of the portions of the Madison City Ordinances: as
they existed in March, 1948 and until August, 1949
dealing with the said subjects of milk and dairy
products, of which ordinances the section set forth in
plaintiff’s complaint is an integral part and which
ordinances had been duly adopted prior to March,
1948 and were then in full force and effect.
4. Defendants admit that on or about the Sth day:
of March, 1948, the plaintiff herein made application
.to the City of Madison for a license to distribute
pasteurized Grade A milk, cream and milk products
Rec.
Page
* @ 30 oa
in the City of Madison and that on or about the 12th
day of March, 1948 the plaintiff was notified by the
Health Commissioner of the said city that its request
for a license was denied and there was returned the
application fee of $1.00 deposited by the plaintiff at
the time said application for license was filed; and
further admit that Exhibit 1 attached to the. com-
plaint is a copy of a letter sent. by the Health Com-
missioner of the City of Madison to the plaintiff
herein on or about March 12, 1948.
. 5. Defendants deny that they have information or
knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to whether
the plaintiff is engaged in the purchase of Grade
A milk from farm producers or fn the pasteurization
thereof or in the sale of said pasteurized milk to re-
tail stores in cities or village in the states of Illinois
or Wisconsin and, consequently, deny the same and
leave plaintiff to its proof thereof. Defendants further
allege upon information and belief. that even if plain-
tiff deals in Grade A milk, plaintiff also deals in
milk other than Grade A. .
6. Defendants admit that the said application of
the plaintiff for its said license was denied because
plaintiff’s pasteurization plant was located in Che-
mung, Illinois, more than five miles from the central
portion of the City of Madison, otherwise known as
the Capitol Square and at a distance of about 75
miles from Madison; but defendants allege that the
said fact of location of the plaintiff’s plant was the
only fact considered in denying the plaintiff’s appli-
cation and further. allege that they cannot now state
that any further application fora license which might |
36
Rec.
Page tae? ;
be made by the plaintiff would be granted, except for
the fact of location of the plaintiff’s plant.
-. 7. Defendants deny that they have\ any informa-
tion or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as tog
whether the milk which plaintiff intended to sell in|
the City of Madison, if its application for license had
been granted, would comply or still does comply with
the requirements of said ordinances of the City of
Madison as to place of. production, pasteurization, or
requirements as to-quality or sanitary conditions and
consequently “deny the same and leave plaintiff to its:
proof thereof. Upon information and belief, de.
fendants allege that plaintiff! maintains that the mick
it intended to sell inthe City of Madison is produced
in conformity with the ordinances of the City of
Chicago, Hlinois and defendants deny upon informa-
tion and belief that the requirements of the Chicago
Ordinances are equivalent to the requirements of the
ordinances of the City of Madison as adopted on or
about August 27, 1949, as hereinafter more fully set
forth.
8. Defendants further deny that they have any
information or knowledge sufficient to form a heyet
as to whether, if the said license had been issued to
plaintiff, it was plaintiff's intention to obtain the
milk which it intended to sell in the City of Madison
from its pasteurization plant in the City of Che-
mung, [llinois, after the. same had heen bottled and
placed in paper cartons and then packed into a re-
frigerated truck and transported from said City of
Chemung, Ilinois and sold to various retail grocers
in the City of Madison and consequently deny the .
7
~)
ou
,
Rec.
y
. 37 >
same and leave plaintiff to its proof thereof’ Defend-
ants aimit that such an intention had been expressed
by plaintiff to the City authorities but allege, upon
information and belief, that the plaintiff does in fact
opérate pasteurization plants other than that located
in the City of Chemung, Illinois and that the milk
from such other pasteurization plants is bottled in
containers similar to those used at its Chemung plani,
. so that if the plaintiff werg permitted to sell milk in
the City of Madison, it would be difficult for city
authorities to determine whether milk sold in the city
had actually been processed and bottled at the Che-
mung, Lllinois plant of plaintiff and whether it had
actually been produced at inspected farms and was
all Grade A milk,
9. Defendants admit that plaintiff has requested
the City Council of the City of Madison to amend
its ordinances to eliminate the requirements that pas-
teurized milk sold in the City of@Mfadison must be
pasteurized within five miles~of the central portion
_of the-city, and further admit that the said City
Council did hold open hearings upon the said request
and that at such hearings the plaintiff appeared
through its agents and attorneys and, among other
arguments, did maintain that the said ordinance was
unconstitutional. Defendants allege, however, that
after full, due and open consideration of the said re-
quest and said arguments, the City Council declined
so to amend the ordinances. Defendants deny tiat
plaintiff has made any formal application for license
since the application of March, 1948.
10. Answering the allegations of paragraph 9 of
Page
3s
§
the second amended complaint, defendants admit that
a milk license was not issued to the plaintiff and fur-
ther admit that on or about August 27, 1949 a new
milk ordinance as adopted by the City Council of the
City of Madison took effect and that the copy attached
to the second amended complaint~as Exhtbit B is a
copy of such new ordinance and that said new ordi-
nfince in Section-7.21 reenacted the provision of the
prior ordinances that it was unlawful fer milk to be
sold in the City of Madison which had not been pas-.
teurized in the said five mile zone.
-
11. Defendants deny that the said provision of the
old ordinance or the said provision of the new ordi-
nance of August 27, 1949 violates any provision of the
Constitution of the United’ States or of the amend-
ments thereto or of the Constitution of the Sygte of
Wisconsin in any respect whatsoever.
12. Defendants adifft plaintiff’s request for li-
cense was denied on or about March 12, 1948 and
that defendants then took, and still take, the position -
that plaintiff is not entitled to sell milk in’ the City’
of Madison because its pasteurization plant is not
located @within the said five mile zone and further ad-
mit that plaintiff contends that the said provision is
unconstitutional and admit that there now exists a
controversy between plaintiff and defendants as to
the legality of said provision.
13. Defe
Ordinane
idants adimit that said Section 7.20 of the
of August 27, 1949 contains the provision
forth in paragraph 12 of the seeond amended
complaint; and defendants allege that substantially
similar information had been required by the Madison
as se
ra
Page
39
°
Health Department upon application for dairy plant
licenses under the ordinances as they existed prior to
August 27, 1949. Defendants deny that they have any
information or knowledge upon which to form a.belief
as to whether the plaintiff is able, ready or willing to
make a new application for license or to pay the
$1.00 or to furnish information called for by the
present ordinances and allege that no application has
been made by the plaintiff since March, 1948. Defend-
- ants-admit that they take the position that they are
not obligated to inspect plaintiff’s plant or to issue
license to said plaintiff because plaintiff’s pasteuriza-
tion plant is not located within said five mile zone,
and also for other reasons.
“14. Defendants deny that they have any informa-
tion or knowledge sufficient; to form a belief as to
whether the farms from which plaintiff obtains milk
.for its pasteurization plant at Chemung, Illinois or
the vehicles in which the milk is delivered are in-
spected weekly or at any other intervals by inspectors
hired by the plaintiff or are inspected by the. City
of Chicago, Illinois. Upon information and _ belief,
defendants deny that the City Ordinances of Chicago,
Illinois contain provisions equivalent to the present
Ordinances of the City of Madison for insuring
purity, quality and sanitation of milk. Defendants
deny any information or knowledge sufficient to form
a belief as to whether plaintiff’s milk is Grade A
milk as provided in the United States Model Milk
Ordinance promulgated by the United States Public
Health Service or whether the plaintiff’s milk or, milk
products are pasteurized, produced, bottled, trans-
6
Rec.
40
ported or inspected in compliance with any United
States Model Milk Ordinance and consequently deny
the same and leave the plaintiff to its proof thereof.
Defendants deny that the provisions of any United
States Model Milk Ordinance are equivalent to the
present ordinances of the City of Madison for insur-
ing purity. and sanitation of milk. Defendants admit
that no ‘attempt has been made by or on behalf of the
City of Madison to inspect its plant or vehicles in
which said milk is transported, and further admit that
the City has made no attempt to satisfy itself that the
milk was produced, pasteurjzed or transported pur-
suant to inspection of the City Ordinance of the City
- of Chicago; and defendants deny that the Ordinances
78
of the City of Chicago have any materiality in this
controversy and further deny upon information and
belief that the Chicago Ordinances are equivalent to
those of the present Madison Ordinances. Defendants —
deny that they have any knowledge or information
sufficient to form a belief as to whether the inspectors
of the City of Chicago are qualified to make inspec-
tions under or to carry out the provisions of the Chi-
eago Ordinances or whether their inspections are ac-
cepted or approved by other cities or communities
and consequently deny the same and leave the plain-
tiff to its proof thereof; but defendants deny that the
said facts, if true, have any materiality in this con-
troversy. Defendants admit they have taken no steps
to satisfy themselves as to the purity, quality or sani-
tation of the plaintiff’s milk and further admit that _
they do not propose to do so and that they claim
they have the right not to do so and further have the
! 3
Rec
41
Page
gy
&
right to.refuse to grant any license to-the plaintiff
because the plaintiff’s milk is not pasteurized within
the five mile zone as provided in the Madison City
Ordinances, and also for other reasons,
15. The defendants admit that Section 7.25 of the
Madison Ordinances adopted August 27,; 1949 con-
tains the provisions as set forth in paragraph 14 of
the second amended complaint.’The defendants admit
upon information and belief that the Milk Ordinance
and Code prepared by the United States Publie
Health Service contain the -provision in Section 11
.thereof and the comment thereto all as alleged in
paragraph 14 of the second amended complaint; but
defendants allege that the City Council of the City
of Madison refused to adopt said Section 11 and
adopted in lieu thereof the five ‘mile pasteurization
limit as contained in Section 7.21 of the present Madi-
son Ordinances. Defendants deny that any provisions
of the said Milk Ordinance and Code as prepared by’.
“the United States Public Health Service are binding
upon the City of Madison in any respect unless they
have specifically been adopted by the City of Madi-
son as part of its ordinance and further deay that
any such provisions not so adopted by the City of
Madison have any materiality in this controversy. -
Defendants deny that they have any information or
knowledge sufficient to form ‘a belief as to whether
plaintiff’s milk or milk products have been awarded
a rating of better than 90 per cent by any State
Control Agency. | ‘
16. Answering the allegations of paragraph 15 of
the second amended complaint, defendants deny that
Rec.
Page
#2
they have any information or knowledge sufficient to
form a belief as to whether the milk the plaintiff pro-
poses to sell in the City of Madison. meets all the re-
quirqments of the Madison Ordinances, except pas-
teurization within the five mile zone, or whether the
plaintiff sglls milk in 200, or any other number,
of municipalities in the State of Illinois and the
State of Wisconsin or whether the health officials of
the City of Chicago are enforeing the provisions of
the Chicago Ordinances on the production and proc-
essing and distribution of’ milk and consequently the
defendants deny the same and leave plaintiff to its.
proof thereof; however, defendants deny that such
sale in such other municipalities or in the City of
Chicago or any enforcement of Chicago Ordinances
by Chicago officials have any materiality in this con-
troversy. Defendants admit upon information and be-
lief that the plaintiff sells its milk in the City of
Chicago, but deny that that fact has any materiality
in this controversy. Defendants deny. that the health
officer of the City of Madison could by any means
other than continual inspection of the plaintiff’s
plants and of the several hundred farms which deliver
to those plants satisfy himself that the plaintiff’s milk.
is being produced, pasteurized and distributed in the
manner required by the Ordinances of the City of
Madison, and defendants allege that such continual
inspection would create undue expense and ineon:
venience to the City of Madison. Defendants den :
that inspection by-the plaintiff or bv other mi
palities has any materiality in’ this controversy and
further dery that they have any information or
/
80
43
knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to whether the
plaintiff’s milk meets the requirements of the said
Ordinances and Code prepared by the United States
Public Health Service and defendants deny upon in-
formation and belief that the provisions of that ordi-
nance and code are equivalent to the provisions of the
Madison Ordinances.
And further answering the second amended eom-
plaint of the plaintiff, defendants allege as follows:
17. The ordinances of the City of Madison and
specifically including the portion in Section 7.21
thereof constitute necessary, reasonable and proper
health ‘regulations for the protection of the lives and
health of the residents of the City of Madison. Milk
and its products are riot only one. of the most im-
portant human foods but also the most perishable and
most easily contaminated. Establishment and enforce-
ment of rigid standards and continual inspection are
required at all stages of. production, transp6rtation
and sale of milk to assure an adequate supply of sani.
tary, healthful milk. ©
18. The City of Madison is located in almost the
geographical center of Dane County, which has an
area of approximately 1230 square miles and is one
of the greatest milk 7 vodueing counties in the entire
United States. Dane County contains approximately
5600 separate farms which annually produce about
150,000,000 pounds of milk; and the City of Madi-
son, including the University of Wiseonsin with its
own processing plant located in the City, consumes
the milk production of only abont 500 of those farms
in an annual amount of about 60,000,000) pounds of
Rec.
Page
44
°
milk, all as defendants are informed and verily believe.
‘ Other counties immediately adjoining Dane County
‘are also very great producers of milk. Great quantities
of milk produced in Dane and surrounding counties
are also shipped to the Metropolitan Chicago markets
and are also made into cheese, butter and evaporated,
condensed and dried milk. All milk now sold as pas-
teurized mk in the City of Madison, being nearly all -
milk sold in the city, is now pasteurized and bottled
at three separate plants all located within five miles
of the -Capitol Square in Madison and owned and.
operated by three separate companies. The natural
result of the plants being located this near to the
Qty and in the center of the tremendous milk pro-
—~dueing area in Dane County, is that all milk pasteur-
‘81
ized in those plants and sold in the City of Madison is
produced on farms located within Dane County and
within a radius of not more than twenty-five miles
from the Capitol Square in Madison. Inspection by
city health authorities of not.only ‘the pasteurization
plants but also of all farms which supply those plants
is thus made convenient and efficient andth: cost of
such inspection to the city and its taxpayers is kept
within reasonable hounds, and the eity is assured of
an adequate supply of healthful and sanitary milk
from known and inspected sources, all as these de-
fendants are informed and verily helieve.
19. Defendants are informed and ‘verily helieve
that approximately 800 or more farms, located chiefly
in the State of Illinois many miles from Madison, fur- .°
nish milk to the plants of plaintiff. Beeause it is
impracticable to segregate in any plant, the milk from —
Page
45
particular farms delivering to the plant, in order to
be assured that’ standards of milk production, proe-
essing and transportation required hy the Madison
ordinances are maintained, as to any milk delivered
from such plant to the City of Madison it would be
nggessary for the city health authorities regularly
to inspect the said plants and 800 or more farms de-
livéring to them, even if the amount of milk from said
plants sold in the City of Madison is very small, as.
defendants are informed ‘and verily believe.
20. Without the portion of the Madison Ordinances
which is complained of in plaintiff’s complaint, any
dairy company with a plant located any place in the »
country could demand a license to sell milk in the
City of Madison which had heen pasteurized and
bottled in such plant, and no matter how small the
quantity of milk that was so sold from sueh plant,
the city would then be put to the unreasonable burden
of Frequent inspection and supervision of not only
the plant itself but all of the farms delivering milk
to such, plant.
21. The Madison Health Department has on its
staff two trained expert dairy sanitarians whose
duties inelude the inspection of milk sold in Madi-
son, of the dairy plants delivering to Madison and
the farms delivering to such plants, which farms
number approximately 400, other than those supply-
ing the University of Wisconsin. Fach of the three
local dairy companies now selling. milk in Madison,
exclusive of the: University, and none of which com-
panies is in’any way. financially connected with any
other,,also maintains a field man for farm inspection
Rec.
Page
82
46
as does the farmers cooperative association, which
represents many of the farmers delivering milk to
the present Madison dairy companies; and these
field men, who are familiar with Madison Health
Department requirements, cooperate with the Madi-
son Health Department in maintaining standards of
production required by Madison, Ordinances; all as
defendants are informed and verily believe. If
plaintiff. were permitted to sell milk in Madison it
would, without doubt, require at least two or more
additional full time qualified dairy sanitarians on
the staff of the City Health Department, adequately
to inspect the plaintiff’s plants and the farms de-
livering to them; thus unreasonably adding to the
inconvenience and cost of milk inspection.
22. Changing economic conditions frequently may
cause operators of dairy plants which serve other
than established local markets, and particularly opera-
tors of plants which may have a variety of markets
available to them, to shift from market to market
from time to time, as defendants are informed and
verily believe. If plants so opérated and located at
a distance from Madison are permitted to supply
milk to Madison, such operations and the frequent
fluctuation in inspection respensibilities of the City
in the inspection of said plants and the farms sup-
plying them would unreasonably burd) n the City of
Madison.
Wherefore, the defendants pray ,that judgment be
entered declaring the portion of the Madison Milk
Ordinanees as sef forth in the first cause of action
of plaintiff's second amended complaint te he eonsti-
Rec.
Page
47
tutional and valid, and for their costs and disburse-
ments in this action and for such other and further
_ relief as may be proper herein.
SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION.
And as and for an answer to the second cause of
action contained in the second amended complaint
of the plaintiff, defendants allege as follows:
23. In answer to paragraphs numbered 1, 2, 4,
6, 7, 14 and 15 of the first cause of action as re-
alleged and ineorporated in the second cause of
action, the defendants®reallege all matters contained
in this answer in paragraphs numbered 1, 2, 4, 5, 7,
8, 15, 16; and defendants further reallege the alle-
gations of paragraphs 17, 18, 19 and 21, hereinbefore
set forth.
24. Defendants admit that their answer to the
original complaint herein contained the allegations
as set forth in paragraph 2 of the second cause of
action in the second amended complaint together
with other allegations and that plaintiff now takes
the position that the method set forth in the Model
Milk Ordinance promulgated by the United States
Public Health Service is an adequate way to insure
purity of milk sold in Madison, but defendants allege
that the City Council of Madison has refused to in-
corporate in its Ordinance the provisions of the so-
called Model Milk Ordinance relied on by plaintiif
and defendants further deny upon information and
belief that the methods set forth im the so-ealled
Model Milk Ordinance are adequate to insure the
48
purity and sanitation of milk sold in Madison with-
out’ continual inspection of milk plants and farms
delivering thereto by the Health Department of the
City of Madison. —
25. Defendants admit that while this litigation
was pending the City of Madison adopted the Ordi-
nances attached to plaintiff's second amended com-
plaint as Exhibit B and that the said new Ordinances
contained the provisions contained in paragraphs
3 and 4 of the plaintiff’s secagfd amended complaint.
Defendants further allege that for many years prior
to the adoption of the said new ordinances the City
of Madison had required permits issued by its Health
Departments to farms whose milk was delivered to
Madison and that approximately the same informa-
tion had been required as is set out in paragraph 4
of the second cause of action of the plaintiff’s second
amended complaint. . :
_ 26. The defendants ‘admit upon information and
belief that the plaintiff does not own the farms from
which it obtains thé milk which it pasteurizes at
its plants located at Chemung, Illinois and elsewhere
and that it obtains milk from approximately 900 dif-
ferent farms located in Northern Illinois and South-
ern Wisconsin and all farms are more than 25 miles
from the City of Madison, and that plaintiff does
not obtain milk from any farm located within 25 .
miles from the City of Madison.
27. The defendants have no information or
knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to whether
the plaintiff’s business is dependent upon obtaining:
milk from the nulk producers located in Northern
49
Illinois and Southern Wisconsin or whether the
plaintiff is eable, willing, or ready to have each of
said owners of said farms where it obtains said milk
make application to the City Health Department of
Madison. Any application by the said farm owners to
the City of Madison to deliver milk in Madison which
fnilk has heen pasteurized outside of the five mile.
pasteurization limit contained in Section 7.21 of the
present Madison Ordinances would be denied; the
City has had no oceasion to consider any applica-
tion by any of said farms for the delivery of milk
which has been pasteurized within the said five
mile limit.
28. The defendants admit that they take the
position that the Madison Health-Department has a
discretion as to the inspection of farms located more
than 25 miles from Madison and the issuance of
permits to such farms and that it has the right to
deny the issuance of permits to such farms And ‘to
deny plaintiff the right to sell its milk products made
from milk produced on such farms, in the City of
Madison and also for other reasons. The defenil-
ants deny that the said Ordinance or any part of it
ix in violation of the Constitution of the United
States or any amendment thereto or of any provision
of the Constitution of the State of Wisconsin.
2G. Defendants deny that any action in refusing
permits to such farms or to inspect such farms would
be. arbitrary, discriminatory or unreasonable, and
further deny that any provision of Section 7.25 of
the present Madison Ordinances effects this contro-
versy in any respect or provides the Madison Health
Rec.
Page
>
Department with adequate or reaconable means, with
little expense of satisfving itself that the farms from
which plaintiff obtains its milk are sanitary or
operated in accordance with the provisions of the
Ordinance of the City of Madison or that the,milk
produced thereon meets the requirements of the
Ordinance of the City of Madison.
we. Defendants allege that in view of the great
supply of milk available within a radius of 25 miles
from the Capitol Square of the City of Madison, the
provision of the Madison Ordinance that the City
need not inspect or issue permits to farms located —
beyond that radius. is entirely reasonable and a
proper health regulation and that said provision ‘aids
the effectiveness of inspection by the City Health
Department and minimizes the cost thereof to the
City and its tax payers.’ |
31. So long as the five mile pasteurization limit
contained in Section 7.21 of the present Madison
Ordinances remains in effect, these defendants deny
that there #& any controversy between the parties*
as to the validity of the provisions of Section 7.11
of the Ordinances complained of hy plaintiff in its
cond cause of action hecause at no time has the
plaintiff given any indication, that it proposes to
pasteurize its milk within the sajd five mile limit
or at any other place in the State of Wisconsin: hence
so long as the provisions of Section 7.21 of the Madi-
son Ordinance are in effect there is no neeéssity for
the richts of the plaintiff to he declared under See-
tion 7.11 of the Madison Ordinances, |
Wherefore the. defendants pray that if the validity
86
103
é fey. D1
of Section 7.21 of the Madison Ordinance as contested
in the -first cause of action herein is sustained, the
second é¢ause of action be dismissed on the grounds
that there is no controversy between the parties; and
if the validity of the Ordinance involved in the first
cause of action should not be sustained, then that.
the Court adjudge that Section 7.11 of the City
Ordinance be construed as giving the Madison Health
Department discretron not to inspect farms located
beyond said 25 miles limit and declare that the said
provision of Section 7.11 of the Ordinance is con-
stitutional and valid; and that defendants have the
costs and disbursements of this action.
Harold FE. Hanson,
° ; City Attorney,
Madison, Wisconsin.
>?
FINDINGS OF FACT, CONCL USIONS OF LAW
AND ORDER FOR JUDGMENT.
The above entitled declaratory judgment action
coming on for trial at the September, 1949, term of
said Court and having been tried before the Court on
the 10th and 11th days of October, 1949, Jacoh Geffs
and Eli Block, of McGowan, Geffs, Geffs & Block, of
Janesville, Wisconsin, appearing for plaintiff, Dean
Milk Company, and Harold E. Hanson for the de-
fendants, and after hearing the allegations and proofs
of the parties, the arguments of counsel and being
advised in the premises, IT hereby make and file the
following Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and
Order for Judgment, constituting my decision in
said action. —
os
Findings of Fact.
1. That the plaintiff is an Illinois Corporation
having its main business offices in the City of Chi-
cago, Cook County, Illinois, and that it operates a
milk pasteurization plant in the City of Chemung,
Iilinois, —
2. That at the times hereinafter mentioned the
defendants were the exeéutive, legislative and admin-
> istrative officers of the City of Madison, Dane County,
104:
Wisconsin, and that the City of Madison, Wisconsin,
is a municipal corporation.
2
3. That at the times hereinafter mentioned there
was and there still is in force an ordinance adopted
by the Common Council of the City of Madison on
February 14, 1930, which is now numbered section 7.21
of the General Ordinances of the City of Madison
adopted August 27, 1949, providing:
: ‘Section 1. Section 43 of Subsection FE of Or-
9 dinance. Number 2183, entitled ‘An Ordinance
Amending the General Ordinances of the City
of Madison relating to the License for Sale of
Milk and Cream,’ is hereby amended by insert-
ing before the first sentence thereof the follow-
ing: ‘It shall be onlawful for any person, asso
ciation, or eérporation to sell. offer for sale or
have in his or its possession with intent to sell or
deliver ‘in the City of Madison, any milk or milk
oducts as pasteurized unless the same = shall
haze been pasteurized and bottled in the same
maner provided in this ordinance within a. ra-
dius ive miles from the central portion of
the ety of Madison, otherwise known as the Capi-
tal Square, at a plant the machinery, equipment
and facilities of which shall have heen approved
hy the Health Department.”
a3
Rec
Page
That said ordinance is a portion of the ordinances
of the City of Madison dealing with the entire sub-
Ject of sale of milk and dairy products within the
city and including standards for production, process-
ing, manufacturing, ‘transportation, handling, sale |
and delivery of milk and dairy products and requiring
regular inspection by the city Health Department
of all dairy plants and all farms on which milk is
produced for sale.in the City of Madison.
4. That the plamtiff, Dean Milk Company, is en-
gaged in the purchase of milk from farm producers
and in the pasteurization thereof, and in the sale of
said pasteurized milk to retail stores in cities and
villages in the states of Illinois and Wisconsin; that
on the 8th day of March, 1948, the plaintiff herein
made gpplication to the City of Madison for a license
10 disiFibute pasteurized Grade ** A’? Milk, cream ‘and
milk products in the Citv of Madison and that on or
ahout the 12th day of March, 1948, the plaintiff. Dean
Milk Company, was notified by the Health Commis-
sioner of the City of Madison that its applieation
for a license was denied.
10% 5. That the application of plaintiff for said license
was denied because plaintiff's pasteurization plant
was located in Chemung, Tlinois, more than five miles
from the ventgal portion of the City of Madison, other:
wise known as the Capitol Square and at a distance
of ahont seventy-five miles from Madison.
6. Madison’s five mile pasteurization ordinance.
simplifies the inspection of plants by requiring them
to he near at hand thus permitting more intense and
constant inspection than if such establishments were
age
D4
located anywhere in the United States, and minimizes
the expense of inspection.
‘7. That se@fion 7.21 of the General Ordinances of
the City of Madison constitutes a reasonable and
proper health regulation for the protection of the
lives and health of the residents of the City of
Madison.
8. That the City of Madison is located in almost
the geographical center of Dane County, which has
an area of approximately 1230 square miles and is
one of the greatest milk producing counties in the
entire United States. Dane County contains approxi-
mately 5600 separate farms which annually produce
about 650,000,000 pounds of milk and the City of
Madison, including the University of Wisconsin with
_ its own processing plant located in the city, consumes
Ai
the milk product of only about 500 of those farms in
an aunual amount of about 60,000,000 poiinds of milk.
Other counties immediately adjoining Dane County
are also very great producers of milk. Great quantities
of milk produced in Dane and surrounding counties
are also shipped to the Metropolit: an Chieago mar-
kets and are also made into cheese, hutter, evaporated,
condensed and dried milk. All milk now sold as pas-
teurized milk in the City of Madison, being nearly all
the milk sold in the city, is now pastenrized and hot-
tled in three separate plants all located within five
miles of the eapital square in Madison and owned and
operated by three separate companies. The natural
result of the plants heing located this neat to the
city and in the center of the tremendous milk pro-
dneing area in Dane County, is that all milk pas-
Rec.
Page
vd
teurized in those plants and sold in- the City of
_ Madison is produced on farms located within Dane
County and within a radius of not more than twenty-
five miles from the capital square in Madison. In-
spection by city -health authorities of not only the
pasteurization plants but also of all farms which
_ supply those plants is thus made convenient and effi-
cient and the cost of such inspection to the city and
its taxpayers is kept within reasonable bounds, and
the city is assured of an adequate supply of healthful
and sanitary milk from known and inspected sources.
9. That plaintiff does not intend to pasteurize milk
within five miles of the central portion of the city,
otherwise known as the capital square, and has no
rights, status or other legal relations affected bv
~ that portion of section 7.11 of the General Ordinances
of the City of Madison which reads as follows:
‘“‘The health department shall not-be obliged to
inspect and issue permits to farms located heyond
twenty-five (25) miles from the central portion of
the City of Madison, otherwise known as the Capi-
tal Square.”’
Conclusions of. Law.
1. That defendants, the City of Madison, Wiscon-
sin, a municipal corporation, Dr. C. R. Kindaid, as
Health Commissioner for the City of Madison, Wis-
eonsin, Leonard Howell, as City Manager of the City
of Madison, Wisconsin, and the Common Council of
the City of Madison, Wisconsin, are entitled to a
declaratory judgment in this action adjudging and
decreeing that section 7.21 of the General Ordinances
of the City of Madison providing:
Ree.
Page
107
56
¢
‘* Pasteurization Plants to be Within Five Mile
Radius. It shall be unlawful for any person, as-
sociation or corporation to sell, offer for sale
or have in his or_its possession, with intent to
sell or deliver in the City of Madison, any milk,
cream, or milk products as pasteurized unless the
same shall have heen pasteurized and bottled in
the manner herein’ provided within a radius of
five miles from the central portion of the City of
Madison. otherwise known as the Capital Square,
at a plant housing the machinery, equipment and
facilities, all of which shall have been approved °
by the Department of Publie Health,’’ .
is eonstitutional and a valid regulation under the
police power for the protection of the public health
and welfare and the application of the plaintiff, The
Dean Milk Company, for a license to distribute pas-
teurized milk, cream and cream products in the City
of Madison was properly denied.
> 2. That no justiciable controversy exists between
the parties as to the construction or validity of that
part of section 7.11 of the General Ordinances of
the City of Madison providjng:
‘“‘The health department shall not be obliged
to inspect and issue permits to farms located
beyond twenty-five (25) miles from the central
portion of the City of Madison, otherwise known
as the Capital Square,”’’
and \the second cause of action contained in plaintiff's
second amended complaint should he dismissed.
Order for Judgment.
Let a declaratory judgment be entered accordingly:
Further “adjudged and declared fhat the seeond
57
Rec.
Page
cause of action of piaintiff’s second amended com-
_ plaint be and the same is hereby dismissed.
‘ Dated December 30, 1949.
By the Court,
Alvin C. Reis
Circuit Judge.
109 DECLARATORY JUDGMENT AND JUDGMENT
DISMISSING SECOND CAUSE OF ACTION OF ;
PLAINTIFF TO SECOND AMENDED
COMPLAINT.
This cause having been tried to the Court and the
Court having made and filed its Opinion ‘in writing
and its Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; &
Now, Therefore, on motion of Harold E. Hanson,
City.Attorney for the City of-Madison;
It Is Adjudged, And Decreed:
“That defendants, the City of Madison, Wisconsin,
a municipal corporation, Dr. C. R. Kineaid, as Health
Commissioner for the City of Madison, Wisconsin,
Leonard Howell,-as City Manager of the City of
Madison, Wisconsin, and the Common Council of
the City of Madison Wisconsin, are entitled to a
declaratory judgment in this action adjudging and
decreeing that section 7.21 of the General Ordinances
of the City of Madison providing:
“Pasteurization Plants to be Within Five Mile
Radius. Tt -shall be unlawful for any person, as-
sociation or corporation to sell, offer for sale or
have in his or its possession with intent to sell or
deliver in the City of Madison, any milk, eream,
Rec.
Page
110
5S
or milk products as pasteurized unless the same
shall have been pasteurized. and bottled in the
manner herein provided within a radius of five
miles from the central portion‘of the City of Madi-
son otherwise known as the Capital Square, at a
plant housing the machinery equipment and facili-
ties, all of which shall have been approved by the
Department of Publie Health,”’
is constitutional and a valid regulation under the
police power for the protection of the publie health
and welfare and the application of the plaintiff. The
Dean Milk Company, for a license to distribute pas-
teurized milk, cream and cream products in the City
of Madison was properly denied.
_That no justiciable controversy exists between the
parties as to the construction or validity of that
part of section 7.11 of the General Ordinances of the
City of Madison providing:
‘‘The health department shall not be obliged to
inspect and issue permits to farms located beyond
twenty-five (25) miles from the central portion of
the City of Madison, otherwise known as the Capi-
tal Square,”’
and the second cause of action contained in plain-
tiff’s second amended complaint is hereby dismissed.
Dated at Madison, Wisconsin, this 30 day of De-
cember, 1949. © :
Myrtle L. Hansen,
Clerk, Cireuit Court,
Dane County, Wisconsin.
F
oO
Rec.
Page
122
119
120
121
122.
59
“Teice )
BILL OF EXCEPTIONS : .
DR. C. K. KINCATD, ealled as an whe erse witness by
the plaintiff testified as follows:
My name is Charleg K. Kincaid, M.D. I am the
City Health Commissioner of the City of Madison,
Wisconsin.
I received my M.D. at Ohio State in 1935; M.S. in
Public Health, Michigan 1940; interned at Methodist:
Hospital in Indianapolis; public health training in
the District Health Department in Indiana; I took
a job as City-County Health Officer in Eau Claire
in 1941 where I stayed until September 1947 except
3 years in the service. Then I went to Will County,
Illinois, as County Health Officer in September, 1947,
and left there to take my present position in July
of 1948.
The Clerk’s office of the City of Madison has just
received a copy of the United States Publie Health
Milk Ordinance and Code which is provided for by
the present Milk Ordinance of Madison.
Exhibit 1 and Exhibit 2 are the United States
Public Health Seryice Milk Ordinance and Code
and proposed. amendments referred to in the present
Madison Milk Ordinance. ae
Exhibit 1 and Exhibit 2 admitted in evidence.
The history and function that the U. S. Model
Milk Ordinance plays in the inspection of milk is as
follows :
Tn 1929 the Publie Health Service, realizing that
there was considerable diserepaney from community
to community and state te state, felt that they should
Rec,
Page
-123
124
60
¥
/
recommend some sort of a standard by which farms
and plants would be required to set up reasonably
similar requirements since milk was milk ‘and that
ordinance has been recommended for that purpose
to communities ever since 1922. It has been occa-
sionally revised. |
When wé revised the Madison Ordinance August
27, 1949, we did not have available Exhibit 2. |
Some. of the improvements over Exhibit 1 we felt
was the definition of milk and milk products.
In addition to the definition of certain products
which we felt were needed and which are, we believe,
.to be considerably improved in the Madison Milk
Ordinance, it also requires that wells on farms be
so constructed as to conform to the Wisconsin Well
Code. The revised edition of the U. S. Model Milk
Ordinance provides: ‘©
‘“‘The water supply shall be easily accessible,
adequate, and of a safe sanitary quality”’
The Madison Ordinance is specific rather than
general; the Wisconsin Well Code- requires well
should be routed in solid rock, casting extending 6 —
inches above the ground surface, arinular. spaces
closed and platform so constructed as to prevent the
entrance of surface water to the well. |
I was health officer of Will County, Illinois, which
is south of Chicago.
Will County was not controlled by the Chicago
Ordinance, but hy a state-wide Grade A which was
a voluntary statute. It permitted any single milk
plant in Will County to:meet the provisions of Grade
/
Rec.
Page
128
61
A. These’ requirements were not the same as the
ee ne but were worded as the exhibit
“sate, /sanitary”’
My experience was that a general requirement
does not give the health officer enough specifie infor-
mation.
There was only one plant in Joliet meeting these
requirements when T was there. J do not-know how .
many farms had fixed up their wells\. There were
many that needed some work. It is impossible for
me to say without asking our sanitarian how many
farms in- Dane County under my supervision are
complying with the well code provision of the Madi-
son ordinance. All of the 400 farms that are being
inspected by my office will probably never comply
with this provision. We hope to pave 90% comply-
ing within a year or so as to make it a Grade
A shed. You never obtain 100% compliance in any
milk shed.
The next item on my list which I consider an
upward revision is requirement that the hall con-
130
‘necting the milk house to the barn be entirely open
or at least one side: th 17. S. Model Milk @rdinance
provides that there he a hatiwny- feet wide or more
with self-closing doors; the Madison Ordinance, how:
ever, is merely a recommendation not a requirement.
The next item is a trap drain.for the milk -house
floor to carry off waste \water.
The U. S. Model Milk Ordinance provides that the
water he carried away so as not to cause a puddle
of nuisance, We believe the trapping is an improve-
ment. There are 500 farms under my inspection in .
Ree.
Page
131
62
Dane County and I believe 50% of them comply with
this provision. The U. S. Model Milk Ordinance
provides’for proper drainage and the Madison speci-
fies a kind of proper drainage.
The last note I have here, the !ocal ordinance pro-
vides for Grade A pasteurized milk only, which is
not an actual upward revision becanse the standard
ordinance (U.S. Model Code) leaves that section
open for the people of the city but that is a dif- .
ference. Our ordinance closes the door to any but
Grade A pasteurized milk.
_ The cooling requirement of pasteurized milk of
60 degrees is the same in the U..S. Model Ordinance
as in ours. The purpose of cooling milk after ‘it is
milked is to stop the growth of bacteria in the milk.
- The Madison Ordinance limits the number of bac-
133
teria to 30,000 per e.c. in the finished bottle.
There are no other differences that I recall. There
are some other of minor importance.
Q. That is all you ean recall and if this man ean
help you let’s get them out in the open.
A. That is all.
Over the course of years there has been between
1500 and 2000 cities that have adopted the U. S.
Model Milk Ordinance.
Q. Doctor, in regard to Grade A pasteurized milk,
in your opinion do you believe that the revised milk
ordinance recommended by the United States Public
Health Service, Exhibit 2, provides for reasonably
adequate and safe regulation for the receiving city
that receives milk? A. If this is enforeed with ef-
fectiveness, ves,
Rec.
Page
134
‘
»
6
63
Q. Now, Doctor, I want to Sk you about the en-
forcement of it. It is a fact:that the United States
Public Health Service, in conjunction with the state —
boards of health, conduct spet surveys and make
tests to determine the efficiency of enforcement in
the various areas of the country. That is enforee-
ment in the producing area. Is that correct?
A. They do on request of a receiving city- and
they do routinely, sometimes, too.
Q. Your answer is ves, they do conduct. tests
in the producing area? A. Yes, a
Q. And they will give the receiving city, free of
charge, all of the information that they have on
any producing area in question, is that correct?
A. Through the particular state board of health.
Q. Then you could request the State Board of
Health here in Wisconsin to get the information
for you, and they could get the information for vou,
is that correct? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And get it for vou free of charge?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where did my Exhibit 1 go te? Somebody
grab it? ; .
(Paper handed to counsel.) Now, Doctor, Teall
your attention to Section 11 of the model milk ordi-
nance and will you read the ordinance, part of See-
tion 14? A. (Reading.) ‘Milk and milk products
from points .vevend the limits of routine inspection
of the city of Blank may not he sold in the city of
Blank or its police jurisdictfn, unless produced
35 and/or’? (to the Reporter). T will give von this—‘*an-
Rec
Page
136
64
less produced and/or pasteurized under the provisions
equivalent to the requirements of this ordinance;
provided that the health officer shall satisfy himself
that the health officer having jurisdiction over the
production and processing is properly enforcing such.
provisions,”’
QQ. Now, Doctor, will you read the suggestion that
is made under Section 11 by the United States Pub-
lie Health Service? A. (Reading.) ‘‘It. 18 sug-
gested that the health officer approve milk or milk
products from distant points without his inspection
if they are produced and processed under regulations
equivalent to those of this ordinance, and if the milk
or milk products have been awarded by the State
control agency a ratifig of 90 per cent or more on.
the basis of the Public Health Service rating method.
Subsection 29."" — |
Q. Now, Doetd, will you read Section 11 of Ex-
hibit 2,.**Revised milk ordinance recommended by
the U. S. Public Health Service’’?
A. (Reading.) ‘‘Milk and Milk Products From
Points Beyond The Limits Of Routine Inspeetion.
Milk and milk products from points beyond the
limits of routine inspection of the municipality of
Blank*may not he sold in the municipality of Blank,
or its police jurisdiction, unless produced and/or
pastenrized under provisions which are ‘substantially
equivalent to the requirements of this ordinance and
which ave enforced with equal effectiveness as deter-
mined by a milk sanitation rating.”’
Q. Now, the rating that they refer to is the 90
per cent, is that correet? A. Yes, sir. °
Rec.
Page
137
65
Q. ” Now, Doctor, I will ask you as an expert in
this field; In your opinion. do you think that a city
could safely follow the provisions of Section 11 of
the milk ordinance and code, the original one, arid
the revised one? :
Mr. Hanson: I object to it as ealling for a con-
clusion and being immaterial.
The Court: The objection is overruled.
A. Are you asking do I trust the United States
Public Health Service?
Mr. Geffs: Q. That is it.
Mr. Hanson: I object to it for the further reason
that there is no such provision in the Madison Milk
Ordinance. What difference does it make whether
under some ordinance of Timbuktu they provide for
reciprocal inspection?
The Court: The objection is overruled.
A. Yes, I think I can trust the United States
Public Health Service:
Mr. Geffs: Q. And, in your judgment, a city could,
with reasonable safety, follow the suggestions of this
Section 11, is that correct?
Mr. Hanson: TI object to it as immaterial.
The Court: The objection is overruled.
A. T am not sure I understand the question.
Would you repeat it?
(Last question read.)
~
Mr. Geffs: Q. And, in your judgment, a city could,
with reasonable safety, rely and depend upon this Sec-
tion 11? A. For the protection of the publie health?
e)
y
Rec.
Page
138
o 66 %
Q. For the protection of the public health.
A. It is a matter of opinion. J] think so.
(). That answers the question. Now, Doctor, when
this ordinance was passed by Madison on August 27,
1949, prior to the passage of it you had some dis-
cussion, did you, with the council members and of-
ficials of Madison in regard to it? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Well, I call ‘your attention to Section 7.21
which provides that pasteurization plants are to be
within a 5 mile radius of the capitol square, and I
will ask you if you recommended that as a measure?
Mr. Hanson: T object to it as immaterial whether
or not he recommended it. . |
The Court: The objection is overruled.
A. here had to be some paragraph concerning
the inspection of plants located bevond the usual
limits of inspection and two paragraphs were sub-
mitted to the council for their decision since I felt
that T wasn’t competent to decide that by myself.
This present paragraph 7.21 was one of those that
was submitted. ,
Mr. Geffs: Q. Then, T take it vou did not reeom-
4
mend it. You say you did not.feel competent to decide |
the question. You did not recommend this—
A. T recommended that the council choose one of
the two paragraphs. |
Q. What was the other one? A. The other one
was similar to the Section 11 of the standard ordi-
nance, |
Q. But you did not make a definite reecommenda-
-
AY)
Rec.
Page
tien that they aecept this Section 7.21, the 5 mile
limitation on the pasteurization plants?
Mr. dlanson: He just said he did.
Mr. Geffs: No, he said he subnftted two.
Mr. Hanson: In the alternative.
Mr. Geffs: Let’s let the doctor answer.
A. 1 did not specify which I preferred because T
felt that milk to the consumers in Madison would
be safeguarded adequately were either of those two
selected. :
139 Q. I see. Now, Doctor, the answer on the part
of the defendant denies that the requirements of the
Chicago Ordinance are equivalent to the requirements
or standards of ‘the City of Madison as adopted on
August 27, 1949. Are you acquainted with the Chi-
eago Milk Ordinance, Doctor? A. Not beyond the
point T made a moment ago that it was my informa-
tion that Chicago Ordinance now in effect was the
1935 edition of the standard ordinance.
(Exhibit 3, a letter, so marked for identification.)
Mr. Geffs: Q. Now, Doctor, I show you plaintiff’s
Exhibit 3 and will vou read that letfer? Read it out
loud. Then I will ask you some questions.
A. (Reading.) ‘‘September 23, 1949. Dr. sw. J.
Corbett, Dean Milk Company, 1126 Kilbourne Ave-
140 nue. Rockford Avenue. Dear Sir: In reply to your
telephone conversation, the following infarmation wy
noted. \
“The Dean Milk Company operating adie permit
from the Chicago Board of Health, which has adopted
the recommended milk ordinance and code of the
68
Rec.
Page
Publie Health Service is included in the last survey
rating of the Chicago milkshed made cooperatively
by the Public Health Service and the Illinois State
Department of Public Health.
‘“‘This survey gave a rating of raw milk sold to
plants of 91.05% and a rating of pasteurization
plants of 93.42%. ;
‘*Very truly yours, Harold Wainess.’
142 The Madison Ordinance of August 27, 1949 pro-
. vides for Grade A pasteurized milk. The U.S. Model
Milk Ordinance provides for Grade A_ pasteurized
milk and B or C or raw milk.
In order for milk to be graded Grade A milk
which is sold here in the City of Madison and labeled
Grade A milk, it must meet the requirements of
August 87, 1949. There is no milk being sold today
x” in the City of Madison that is labeled Grade A milk
under the Madison ordinance. 7
’
143. There are five milk supplies here in Madison and
one of them could qualify for Grade A milk but
none of the dairies selling milk to the public in
Madison is labeling their milk Grade A milk.
144 Since I have been Health Commissioner in Madi-
son, there has not been for, sale in Madison any
milk labeled Grade A pasteurized milk.
IT am the Commissioner of Health and there are
51 full time people and 24 part time and seasonable
people on my staff. Of this number there are two
men whose chief duty is milk sanitation.
145 In inspecting the 500 farms that supply milk to
oa
Rec.
Page
146
69
Madison, one spenas full time and the second man
spends. all but one day a week on milk sanitation.
So that if the approximately 900 farms that the
Dean Milk Company obtains milk from were located
within 25 miles of the Capital Square, it would be
necessary to hire more milk sanitarians if the farms
were going to be inspected.
I do not know how large the Dean pasteurization
plant at Chemung, Illinois, is, and hence I eannot
say whether it would be a bigger job to inspect it
than a plant here in Madison outside of the extra
transportation. |
Exhibit 4 reads: e
A. ‘*Commissioner of Health, Madison, Wiscon-
sin;
‘“In’re: Dean Milk Company.
“*Dear Sir. :
‘Please deliver to bearer 950 blank applications
to be filled out by the owners of the farms which
supply the milk to Dean Milk Company, as required
by your new milk ordinance of August 27, 1949.
Very truly vours, McGowan, Geffs, Geffs &
_ Block, Jacob Geffs.’’
I refused to supply 950 blanks because 1.—I didn’t
have that many on hand and 2—I understood there
was a lawsuit fending regarding the 5-mile limit on
pasteurization plants and saw no need of delivering |
the blanks until the validity of the 5-mile limit was
determined. é
Exhibit 4 received ein evidence.
a °
Ree.
Page
70
o
Attached to the letter is an application blank which
calls for information that would substantially com-
-ply with the present Madison ordinance.
145
Direct Examination by Mr. Hanson.
Q. Do you know what the provisions of the Chi-
cago Milk Ordinance are in reference to the tem-
perature at Which milK must be cooled?
« Mr. Geffs: Just a moment. I object to that. Let’s
put in the Chicago Ordinance and we have got it
here, so we won’t have to guess at these things.
Mr. Hanson: I object to the introduction of the
Chicago Ordinance on the grounds it is immaterial.
We are cofreerned here with the reasonableness of
the Madison Ordinance.
The Court: The objection is overruled. You may
introduce the -Chieugo Ordinance. If we are going
to talk about it, we better see what it is.
Exhibits 5-17 both inelusive, received in evidence.
The Chicago Ordinance requires milk to be cooled
to 65 degrees or less and the Madison requires 60
degrees or less.
It is my opinion that the Chicago Ordinance does
not require a covered lip cap which is required in
the Madison ordinance.
Q. Do you know anything about this spot check
referred to by Mr. Geffs and used by the United
States Public Health) Administration for the pur-
pose of checking plants and farms in the producing
milk shed? A. Yes, sir |
‘Q. What is the machinery of that spot check?
°
vl
How is it conducted? A. When an application is
made to a health department from a plant outside
usual limits of inspection, that health department re-
quests its state health department for a. survey
rating of that plant in question. The state health de-
partmenigthen requests the rating of the United States
' Publie Health Service, who then go to the state in
153
question, if it is another state, to their state health
department, and the two of them go to the plant, if
a rating of a specific plant has been requested, and
after making a survey of the plant, they take the
names of all the farms selling milk to that plant
and select out of the hat what they hope will be a
fair sample of all the farms and then inspect those
farms, score the score of the planf, add the two
ratings, add to that the rating of the local health de- -
partment’s procedures in sanitation and laboratory
procedures, whether or not they conform to standard
methods, and the whole is averaged to vield the
rating that has been mentioned.
In one community’ where one rating was made of
farms there were 20 farms inspected out of | a total
> of 135.
Q. Assuming a situation where a city in Wiscon-
sin with that rating under a reciprocal inspection
provision such as provided in the United States
Health Code and they wanted to get the rating of
some producing area down in Tllinois and they.went
through the proper channels, would the United States
health authorities send to the Wiseonsin community
a spot check that had heen made in the past. or
would thev conduct a enrrent check? e -
-~!
to
Rec.
Page
A. If there had been a recent survey and rating
of that specific plant, that would then be furnished.
If the rating was older than a year, we could refuse
to accept that as being too old. It is a matter “of
judgment enters in there. If they have a fairly |
recent rating, that is the one that is furnished.
Q. So that the check you would get unless a recent
one was possible or forthcoming, might be a check
over a year old and would be a sampling of a few
154 farms out of the total number and would be for a
certain time rather than over a contintied period of
time? .A. That is true bheeause that rating is a
rating of the local inspection methods, you see.
Q. And such a spot check might well skip or
eliminate or not include a number of farms that were
producing insanitary or unclean milk? A. There is
that chance, ves, sir.
°
Cross Eramination by Mr. Geffs. ,
Q. Now, you say there is that chance?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. But, in your, judgment, the probabilities are
it is fairly aceurate and has proved so in the past,
isn’t that right? A. T am not familiar with the
theories of samplving, but IT know an attempt is made
to arrive at a satisfactory accurate size of sample, .
hut there is always that chance that surveys having
their defects that we all know about, there is always
the chance you might miss some.
155 Q. Doctor, vou savy the Chicago Milk Ordinance
provides. that the milk be cooled te 65 degrees or
Rec.
Page.
7 Lo i3
less. “I believe you testified that the purpose of
woolig the milk was to stop the growth of bacteria,
156 is that correct? A. Yes, sir, to slow it.
Q. To slow it down. Your ordinance here provides
for Grade A pasteurized milk that when the milk ts
sold on the market it must not contain more than
30,000 bacteria per cubie centimeter, is tha® right?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, assuming that the milk sold here, the’
Dean Grade A_ pasteurized milk here shows a test
not to exceed 10,009 bacteria per cubic centimeter,
would you state in your opinion that the cooling to
65 degrees or less was adequate to answer the pur-
pose? A. Not necessarily. Growth of bacteria in
milk to be pasteurized must be kept down with all
of our—all possible efforts because while a finished
product might be 10,000 bacteria per eubie centi-
meter, milk coming into the plant of a high count
would not be what we consider to be satisfactory
quality. By that IT mean to say that we don’t want
milk to appear on the market that is loaded with
killed organisms. Killed organisms sometime cause
upsets of the stomach and intestine just, from the
chemicals presepj, so in addition to the count. in the
finished product, the count of the milk in the raw
milk in your plant should be kept as low fis reason
ably possible, also. |
Q. But as we discussed this afternoon, the model
milk ordinance adopts 606 degrees the same as vours.
A. The new amendment.
(). The new amendment. Now, Mr. Tlanson ewas
9
Q
i : 4,
158
159
asking you about this rating furnished by the United
States Public Health Service, and making the infor-
matign available to receiving districts. How do they
make that available, by letter or certificates, or how?
A. It is usually verbal and then’ confirmed by
letter via the. State Board of Health, of course.
Q. They do that in the regular course of business,
do they? A. Yes, sir: a
Q. And they furnish the information verbally,
that is, ‘‘they,’’ the United States Public Health
Service, and then confirm it by letter? A. Yes.
Q. And that is their regular and usual manner
of furnishing the information, is ‘that correct?
A. In my limited experience, yes.
$
DR. W. J. CORBE'RS, called as witness on behalf
of the plaintiff, testified as follows:
My name is Walter Corbett; I live in Rockford,
Illinois; employed by Dean Milk Company; my duties
are to dupervise quality and direction of the labora-
tory for the Dean Milk Company; I supervise the
incoming raw milk; | direct the laboratory personnel;
I supervise the processing and quality of the finished |
product. . 3 |
I specialized in dairy technology, and received a
B.S. degree at the University of Illinois in 1934;
M.S. degree University, of Wiseonsin, 1935; Ph.D.
University of Hlinois, 1942; | majored“in dairy tech-
nology; | am acquainted with the Chieago Milk
Ordinance, and the regulations of the Chicago Board
of Health. It is not possible to get a certified eopy
Rec.
Page
160
164
-eago Board of Health.
165
ie}
| | o
of the regulations ‘of the Board of Health, but these
regulations are enforced by the Health Department
off Chicago. These regulations deal with Dean Grade
A pasteurized milk and milk produets which the
company proposes to sell in Madison, Wisconsin.
Dean Milk Company has permits from the Chi-
_Q. Will you get those permits out for me, please?
A. Well, they are on the table, |
Q. Get the original permits. |
Mr. Hanson: 1 don’t see how this is material.
Assume a man applied to the building inspector of
Chicégo to build a house, then came up to Madisen
to build that house, he certainly would not be per-
mitted to do it. :
The Court: We have some doubts, Mr. Geffs, |
whether this is material. That is, Dean Milk Comm-
pany may comply thoroughly with the. Chicago Or-
djnance and they have good milk but vet the Madison
Ordinance isn’t an ordinance naming Dean Milk
Company. There may be 99 other milk distributors
down there affected by this 25 mile provision in the
Madison Ordinance. It is granted your company
complies with the Chicago Ordinance ‘and that vou
have good milk. What does it prove as to (fhe validity
of the Madison Ordinance?
Mr. Geffs: The Supreme Court of Illinois has jnst
ruled that-those limitations, both of them, that they
contain here; are unconstitutional. {That is a late
decision by the Supreme Court of Hlinois in whieh ~
- they diseuss this Dver ease. It isn't in the advanced
Rec.
Page
166
9
sheets yet. | have a copy,.if your Honor would be
interested in it. (Passing paper to the Court.)
The Court: Thank vou.
Mr. Geffs. Then there is a late ease from Texas
on exactly the same thing. And these cases. hold, -
your Honor, that it is up to the city that tries to
build a trade barrier around it, the burden of proof
is on the city to show the necessity of it. The bur-
den is on the defendants here to show that our milk
is not good milk. a
The Court: That is not the question. The ques-
tion is the validity Of the Madison Ordinances, not
whether your milk or the milk of 10,000 individual
distributors throughout the United States is good.
Mr. Geffs: Here is the issue. raised by the plead-
ings. They say in their answer, your Honor, that
they have got to inspect each and every farm. to
insure a pure and sanitary grade of milk. We say
that the Section 11, reciprocal—the mode] milk or-
dinance is' a satisfactory manner and their own
health commissioner testified it was satisfactory to
him on the witness stand here.
The Court: Suppose you prove that the New
York Milk Company complied with the New York
Ordinance, what would that prove as to the validity
of the Madison Ordinance?
Mr. Geffs: It proves this— ®
The Court: It proves the New York company is
~ probably selling good milk.
Mr. Geffs: Yes, it proves that and in fact here,
your Honor, the State Department of Agriculture
Rec.
Page-
here in Madison right now is framing regulations for
inspection of interstate milk so that Wisconsin milk
can be-sold on Wisconsin inspection in Dallas, Texas,
or Birtningham, Alabama, and all through the South,
and what has happened, your Honor, I suppose at
one time there wasn’t any other method of insuring
pure milk except on inspection, but the last few years
there has grown up this reciprocal inspection and
_ which Dr. Kincaid testified 2,000 cities accepted it
167
and we will have witnesses of other cities that have
accepted it and have found it satisfactory.’ Now, we
say that being the case, Madison can’t draw a 5 mile
limit around themselves and say ‘‘Stay out’’, under
the Constitution of the United States. It violates
the, Interstate Commerce Law. That case holds that.
Exhibit 18, certified copy of the Milk Pasteuriza-
tion Law of the State of Dlinois, received in evidence.
Exhibit 19, certified copy of the Grade A Pas-
‘teurization Law and Grade A Milk Products Law
168
of the State of Illinois received in evidence.
The following exhibits identified by witness:
Exhibit 20, Chicago Milk Plant Permit 338.
Exhibit 21, Chicago Milk Plant Permit #37.
Exhibit 22 22, Chicago Milk Receiving Station Permit
#1619.
Exhibit 23, Chicago Milk Distributor Permit #1521.
Exhibit 24, Chicago Milk Receiving Station Permit
#1578. i
Rec.
Page
169
is
. Exhibit 25, Chicago Milk Receiving Station Permit —
#1534. |
These permits are current and in good standing.
Exhibits 20 through 25 inclusive received into evi-
dence.
Exhibit 26, Ilinois Department of Public Health
Certificate of Approval.
©
The following exhibits marked for identification:
Exhibit 26, Certificate of approval issued by Illi-
nois Board of Public Health to Dean Milk Company.
Exhibit 27, Permit #61 issued by Board of Public
Health, State of Illinois, Grade A Label for milk
and milk products, to Dean Milk Company.
170 These permits were issued to Dean Milk Company
171
for plant at Hantley, Illinois, and plant at Chernung,
Illinois. Exhibits received in evidence.
Dean Milk Company has’ two plants, one at ‘Che-
mung, Illinois, and one at Huntley, Illinois.
The Dean Milk Company does not bottle any Grade
B milk. We use only Grade A milk, and that is the
only product handled in these products in our pas-
teurization plant. .
The Grade B milk is sold as dry dairy product or
evaporated milk.
No Grade B milk is sold as pasteurized fresh milk.
_ The following exhibits were marked for identifi-
cation.
79
Rec.
Page
Exhibit 28, Certificate of Approval to Operate a
Milk Plant, by the Department of Agriculture of .
Illinois to Dean Milk Company.
Exhibit 29, Certificate of Approval by the Depart-
ment of Public Health of Illinois to Dean Milk Com-
pany.
1xhibit 28 was a certificate for the year 1948, and
Exhibit 29 is for the year 1949.
Received in evidence.
178. The purpose of requiring the milk to be cooled
to 60 degrees or under is to keep the bacteria count
down. There is another method set forth in the Madi-
son ordinance whereby it can be determined that the
bacteria count is kept down within the limits pre-
scribed by the Madison ordinance other than cool-
ing to 60 degrees. :
179 =Q. Will you read that pert of the Madison ordi-
nance?
The Chicago ordinance has the same provision.
In plain English it means that the bacteria count ©
before pasteurization cannot exceed 200,000 per c.c.
Both ordinances are similar. Ba
Assuming that milk under the Chicago ordinance is
cooled to 65 degrees, instead of 60 degrees, it »still has
to meet the test of less than 200,000 Rictoria per ¢.c.
which is called the ‘‘clump’’ count.
180 The Chicago ordinance, for all scientifie purposes,
complies with the so pci of the Madison ordi-
nance. aS
The covering on the milk referred to by Dr. Kin-
Rec.
Page
181
182
80
caid refers to glass bottles. All of Dean’s milk is
sold in paper cartons.
(Marked for identification Exhibit 30, a folded
milk carton).
(Exhibit 31, a folded milk carton).
Dean’s Grade A milk is placed in these cartons;
one is bottled in Chemung, Illinois, and one at the
Huntley, Illinois, plant.
(Exhibits 30 and 31 received in evidence.)
These exhibits show the plant that the milk was
pasteurized in and contains the permit number from
the Chicago Board of Health so that the Madison
officials would have no difficulty in determining which
milk plant the milk came from.
The Dean Milk Company obtains its milk from
approximately 950 farms in Northern Illinois and
Southern Wisconsin. Each farm has a permit from
the: Chicago Board of Health. Copies of these per-
mits are on file at the pasteurization plants of the
Dean Milk Company and have to be on file before
the milk can be received.
Q. State briefly after the milk comes to the pas-
teurization plant what happens to it? A. Each
can is opened and examined for odor. It is then
dumped and regularly a sample is taken about twice
a month for sediment test, weekly for bacteria counts
and the bacteria tests which are run are the methy- :
lene blue test and direct microscopic count is run at
least monthly and the laboratory pasteurized count
Rec.
Page
Sl
on each sample of -each producer’s milk is run
monthly. !
Q. Are you in charge of these tests you speak of?
A. Yes.
Q. Tell us what these tests are? A. The sedi-
ment test is 4 test where a pint of milk is taken off
the bottom of a ten gallon milk can or eight gallon“
milk can and that pint of milk is forced through
a smal] cotton pad. It is for the purpose of determin-
ing whether the milk is free from dirt or filth.
The bacteria counts are run to determine the com-
pliance of the farms as to the methods of producing.
In other words, if the milk comes from cows with
diseased udders, it will show up as a high bacteria
count. If unclean equipment is used on the farm, it
will. show up as high bacteria count milk, or if poor
.cooling is practiced upon the’ farm, it will show up
183
as high count milk. ,
Q. Dr. Corbett, Does the Dean Milk Cities
have farm inspectors of their own? A. Yes.
Dean Milk Company has farm inspectors which are
under the supervision of Mr. Davis.
The tests which I have described are eke my
supervision. The method of pasteurization is slightly
more stringent than that required by the Madison
ordinance. The Madison ordinance is 140 degrees
Fahrenheit for 30 minutes or 160 degrees Fahrenheit
for 15 seconds. The Chicago Board of Health is 160
degrees for 15 seconds, or 144 degrees ‘Fahrenheit
for 30 minutes. ris bose
©
82
tec,
"age :
The average temperature of the milk when re-
ceived at the plant is around 58 or 60 degrees.
I have examined the Madison milk ordinance of
August 27, 1949, section by section. |
84 I am acquainted with the sanitation of the farms
where the Dean milk is produced, I am acquainted
with the methods of pasteurization and with the
delivery of the finished product~ The Grade A pas-
_teurized milk and milk products of the Dean Milk
Company from a health standpoint comply with
the Madison Milk Ordinance with a few minor dif- —
ferences but from a broad standpoint, they are essen-
tially the same.
There were brought out some differences this
morning in the testimony as to the cooling but the
clump count takes care of that. .
185 In regard to the differences of the wells on the
farms, I have not seen the Wisconsin Code “but the
U. 8S. Public Health deals in detail with the construe-
- tion of wells and their purpose is for healthfulness,
and the wells on the farms in our producing area
~ are constantly checked by the Chicago Board of
Health inspectors so that they do comply with the
U. S. Public Health Ordinance and code.
Cities other than Chicago inspect Dean plants and
run spot checks on the farms. The City of Kenosha,
Wisconsin, recently checked a large number of farms,
something like 500; and the City of Kenosha issued
a permit to Dean Milk Company on “August 1, 1949.
The Wisconsin Department of Agriculture has->
recently made tests as to the purity and sanitation
7 83
Rec. :
of Dean Milk from samples picked up at stores and
from the delivering trucks.
186 - The reports of those tests are kept by the Dean
Milk Company in the regular course of business.
188 Exhibit 32 is a report to, the Dean Milk Company
from the Department -of~‘Agriculture of Wisconsin
relating to the bacteria count and fat content of
Grade A milk and Grade A half-and-half.
189 (Exhibit 32 received in evidence.)
The exhibit shows for Grade A homogenized Vita-
min D milk a bacteria count of 6000; the Madison
Ordinance allows 30,000. The report shows 3.5 butter
fat and the Madison Ordinance requires 3%. The re-
port shows that the Dean Milk exceeds the demands
* of the Madison Ordinance in both respects.
I have reports from Racine, Wisconsin, Elgin, Ili-
nois, and severat from the Chicago Board of Health.
190 These cities pick up the milk for testing purposes
when it is delivered and the Health Commissioner of
Madison could make the same test.
The Racine report shows bacteria count September
20, 1949, of 1000 which is 29,000 under the amount
allowed by the Madison ordinance.
The next is Elgin, IIEnois, September 21, 1949,
butter fat 3.5%, bacteria 7000, which far exceeds
the demands of the Madison ordinance. _
191 We could multiply those by thousands from all
over the country. I am acquainted with the Public -
Health Service with respect to the rating of milk
sheds. They do not issue certificates. The informa.
&>
“Ree.
Page
192
84
tion is available by writing to them or verbally ask-
ing them.
I received Exhibit 3 from the U. S. Public Health
Service September 23, 1949, in the due course of
mail. It is signed by Harold Wainess, the sanitarian.
I am acquainted with him and know that he holds
that job. I recognize his signature. Exhibit 2 -which
‘shows the rating of the Public Health Service of the |
193
194
Dean Milk Company operating under permit from the
Chicago Board of Health made co-operatively with
the Public Health Service and the Illinois State De-
partment of Public Health shows that the raw milk
sold to the plants was 91.05% and the rating of the
pasteurization plant of 93.42% oferes and received
in evidence.
Cross Examination Made by Mr. Hanson.
I have worked for the Dean Milk Company since
July, 1943.
The bottle milk sold by the Dean Milk Company
is produced under the standards of the Chicago Milk
Ordinance. The company has a pasteurization plant
in Huntley, Illinois, and one at Chemung, Illinois.
It operates other receiving stations.
Grade B milk handled by the company is handled
at its plants at Pecatonica, Illinois; Pearl City, Ili-
nois; and Rockford, Illinois. @ —
Chemung, Illinois, is about 65 miles southeast of
here and Huntley is about 20 miles further on. They
are near Elgin, Illinois. The farms that furnish these
plants with milk are located in an area about 20 to 25
miles around the plants.
Rec.
Page
195
89
I cannot answer your question whether it is econo-
mically efficient for farmers to deliver milk to milk
plants from a greater distance. .
Chicago gets milk from 50 to 60 miles in some
cases where it is a direct haul. It varies with the
market. I don’t know whether the Chicago Milk
Ordinance permits reciprocal inspection. The farms
that furnish milk to Dean Milk Company are all in-
spected by Chicago Board of Health.
It is my position that milk that contains less than
30,000 bacteria per ¢.c., meets the other requirements,
and is properly pasteurized, would be safe for deliv-
ery in Madison.
196 A single bacteria count would not be a sufficient test
197
to satisfy health standards of the Madison ordinance.
The inspection of the barns and of the cattle are
desirable but are not necessary from,a pure health
reason. ra
The Chicago ordinance requires inspection of barns
and cattle and a sanitary condition under which the
milk is produced. The Chicago authorities are not
satisfied with the bacteria count. Both the Chicago
ordinance and the U. S. Public Health ordinance go
into minute detail as to provisions and conditions
under which milk is produced on the farm; they go
into much detail as to construction of the barn, light-
ing equipment, construction of the milk house, cool-
ing, and other matters.
The Chicago milk ordinance allows milk to be de-
livered without cooling if delivered to.the plant with-
in two hours after milking, but it still must meet
the other requirements such-as bacteria count, ete.
|
Rec.
Page
86
198 So far as I know, the Chtiage Ordisianes and the
Illinois State law do not pivhibit the standardization
of milk. Standardization of milk-is not done by the
Dean Milk Company. The Dean Milk Company does
not operate. any farms directly. The Chicago Milk
Ordinance requires inspection of the farms every
6 months but they are inspected every month.
199 Exhibit 32 shows the amount of bacteria in a pas-
teurized bottle of milk picked up in a store in White-
water, Wisconsin. So far as I know the inspector
picked up the bottle of milk but did not inspect the ,
farm where it was produced. In our laboratories we
used a standard plate count for total bacteria and
for coliform; we use a phosphatase test for deter-
mining adequacy of pasteurization which is also out- |
lined in the standard analysis of milk analysis. The
inspectors of Chicago Board of Health use a similar
test. They use methylene blue test for raw milk.
200 That is the only test Chicago inspectors use for
201
individual farmers, and for bulk samples they use the
standard plate count.
I have no more isformation about the spot checks
made by the U. S. Public Health Service than what
was given already in the testimony. A spot check
is being, made of the Chicago milk shed now. A
spot check would, indicate if there is anything wrong
with the farm that was examined.
1 don’t know whether they include every plant in
a spot check. They have always included our plants
_ in each survey.
I believe that rigid inspection and rigid standards
87
Rec.
Page
are necessary to insure healthful milk in a eqmmun-
ity. Passing an ordinance does not insure safe,
clean milk. The ordinance must be enforced! ;
202 . It would not be possible for the Chemung plant
to use containers marked ‘‘Haytley plant’’ because
the Labeling Act of Illinois requires the name of
the plant to be on each container. If we used the
bottles marked ‘‘Huntley plant’’ at the Chemung
plant, that would be a variation of the law and the
milk would be subjeet to seizure and condemnation.
_ About 200 farms supply the Chemung plant direct,
indirect 950. The milk received direct is mixed with
milk received indirect. About 125 supply milk’ direct
to the Huntley plant and 950 indirect. |
We market milk in Wisconsin which is produced
in both plants.
(Witness examining paper) This is the first time
I have seen the resolution of the Chicago Board of
Health, September 28, 1942, which provides, ‘* When-
ever any person or firm refuses to make available
to the City of Chicago all of the milk of such person
or firm, when needed, the inspection given to the
firms and plants of such person or firms shall be
withdrawn. ”’
Redirect Examination by Mr. Geffs.
Dean Milk Company has no objection to the City
of Madison inspecting all of these farms, delivery
. trucks, pasteurization plants, and have no objection
to anyone inspecting and our records are available
and open. to any muripality of the state.
S8 ‘
Rec.
Page
204 The 950 farms that I mentioned that furnish milk
indirectly, furnish to both Huntley and Chemung
_ plants.. The figure 950 involves the same farms.
All the 950 farms are regularly inspected by the
Chicago Board of Health and when I say supplying
milk indirectly, that is milk which we receive through -
our receiving stations. ‘At the receiving station like
- Darien, Wisconsin, the milk i is cooled and transported
by tank trucks to Huntley or Chemung. It is all
inspected milk.
I testified in cross-examination that rigid inspec-
tion was necessary and in my opinion as an expert,
Section 11 of the U. S. Model Milk Ordinance pro-
viding for reciprocal inspection provides a safe plan
from a health standpoint.
205. The spot check that Mr. Hanson was asking me
about is a recognized method of inspe¢tion employed
by a number of cities.
206 In my opinion as an expert, the 5-mile limitation
on pasteurization plants in the Madison milk ordi-
nance is not a health measure.
In my opinion as an expert, the 25-mile limitation
‘in the Madison Ordinance which provides that the
health officer shall not be obligated to go beyond 25
miles in inspecting farms, is not a necessary health
measure.
Os
207 H. J. BURGER, called as witness on behalf of the
_ Plaintiff, testified as follows:
My name is Herbert Burger; I live at Janesville,
Wisconsin; I am and have been for the last eight
Rec.
_ 208
89 S
years the sanitary inspector of the Health Depart-
ment. My duties are inspection for the city of food, .
hotels, restaurants, nuisances, and milk; I inspect
dairy farms within the locality of Janesviile that
supply milk to Janesville; | 4nspect pasteurization
‘
209
210
211
plants. ©
Exhibit 33 is certified a of the Janesville Milk
Ordinance adopted June 29th, 1946; Janesville — ~
adopted ‘the U. S. Model Milk Ordinance with the
exception that they gave dairies already in business
two years in which to reach Grade A -milk.
Exhibit 33 received in evidence.
All milk sold today in Janesville is Grade A pas-
teurized milk.
I am acquainted with Sec. 11 of the U. S. Model
Milk Ordinance providing for. reciprocal milk in-
peas
In my opinion, Sec. 11 of the U. S. Model Milk
Ordinance providing for reciprocal inspection is a —
sound health measure for the city receiving milk from
another community.
In my opinion, the provision of the city ordinance
providing that all milk sold in the city must be pas-
teurized within five miles is not a necessary health
measure. The Dean Milk Company sells Grade A
pastetrized milk and milk products in the City of »
Janesville, and has Wen doing so for the past three
years. I have inspected the Dean Milk Company
plant at Chemung, Illinois.
Q.: What did youw find on your inspection?
213
214
ptt Oe
Mr. Hanson: I object to it as immaterial.
The Court: We are back to the old question,
Mr. Geffs. Are we trying the Dean Milk Company
or trying the city ordinance; this Court would like
to assume the Dean Milk Company is a very re-
spectable organization, and its milk is 3.5, a little
above the average, but how will this be attacking
the city ordinance? That is the question.
Mr. Geffs: If we could stipulate what you would
like to assume, we could save a lot of time. I
offered to stipulate, and Mt. Hanson said it was
not material. I will stipulate. It is material, but
if he will stipulate, we will save time.
The Janesville ordinance provides that the milk shall
be cooled to 60 degrees after it is produced at the
farm. Before Janesville adopted the new ordinance,
outside milk could not be brought in. Under the old
ordinance, we were never able to obtain . @fade A
pasteurized milk in Janesville. We did obtain Grade
A milk under the new ordinance. The reason for
that was Dean Milk coming in to Janesville marked
Grade A practically compelled our dealers to do like-
wise, and become Grade A for competitive purposes.
ba)
\
Cross Examination by Mr. Hanson.
There are four pasteurization plants located in
Janesville supplying Janesville markets. One plant
is just over the line; two of these plants have been
in business fifty years, one for thirty, one for twenty
and one for eight.
The fact these plants were located close at hand
made “for more efficient and convenient inspection.
Rec.
Page
215
216
21
91
Milk is delivered to these plants frem a radius of
about ten miles, i
The Janesville ordinance makes _ no pastries as
to the location of the farms.
I inspect the farms within the ten mile radius,
being about 110 of them.
I am able to inspect these 110 farms conveniently,
and if the number of farms were doubled, it would
not take another jman. I am occupied full time, but
if another 100 farms were added, I would probably
increase my day’s work.
I make spot checks of the farms supplying milk
to the Dean Milk Company. I have visited the Dean
plant twice and made two spot checks of farms at
different times since they started supplying milk to
Janesville. My spot check consisted of examining
twelve or fourteen farms, and took from ten in the
morning until three in the afternoon.
On the second inspection I inspected #2 farms in
4 hours, first inspection 1947, second in 1948. I prob-
ably would not have time to inspect all of the farms -
supplying the Dean Milk Company. I have never
asked nor been furnished a check. of the farms. of
the Dean Milk Company made by the U. S. Public
Health Service. ‘
T dg not know in what respects the Janesville Ordi-
nance is different from the Chieago Milk Ordinance.
There are farms in the Janesville area producing
milk for the Chicago milk market; the Chieago mar-
ket has their own farms and their own inspectors.
I do not think that a mere bacteria count of milk
a
Rec.
Page
218
219
Q?
would be sufficient. We require from the Dean Milk
a phosphatase test and a coliform test so as to make
sure that the milk is properly pasteurized. I do not
accept a mere bacteria count test but I may explain
that when the bacteria test is. made at the State
laboratory they also run a phosphatase test and a
coliform test plus a butter fat test.
I do not rely on these tests alone. I inspect the
Janesville farms twice a year plus other inspection
that is necessary.
Before I became-sanitary~inspector 8 years ago I
ran a dairy plant.
Redirect Examination by Mr. Geffs:
From my inspection of the Dean plant, I believe
that the Dean Company is meeting the requirements
of the Janesville Ordinance.
I have an opinion about the Chicago inspection and
my opinion is that it is adequate.
Recross Examination by Mr. Hanson.
T believe my inspection is good. I don’t know
whether Chicago would rely on my inspection.
Mr. Geffs: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 12, here, page 79.
(77) This is from the Chicago Ondinanse. (Reading.)
**Products Shipped From Beyond Limits. Milk and
milk products from points beyond the limits of in-
spection of the City of Chicago may not be sold in
the City of Chicago unless produced and pasteurized
under provisions identical with those of this article
and approved by the Board of Health. In order that
a 0
Rec.
Page
93
inspections by the Board of Health may be adequate,
thorough, and effective, the Board of Health may
confine its inspections within such points and terri-
torial limits as the Board of Health may, from time
to time, deem necessary to insure economic and prop-
er supervision, and to safeguard and promote the
public health of the City of Chicago.”
So beyond the Chicago inspection, beyond where
the Chicago men inspect, they do have a provision
for reciprocal inspection. Thére it is.
(221
222
DR. FRED B. WELCH, called as witness for the
plaintiff, testified as follows:
My name is Dr. Fred B. Welch. I am Health Com-
missioner of Janesville, Wisconsin, and have been
such since 1919. I am a M.D. I have supervision of
Mr. Burger and the inspection eof milk. I am ac-
quainted with this milk problem.
I have an opinion on whether or not a limitation
of 5 miles on pasteurization plants is a necessary
health measure in southern Wisconsin. I don’t think
such a limitation has any value at all in the pro-
tection of public health of the city as far as the milk
supply is concerned,
In my opinion it is not necessagy that any city in
southern Wisconsin have a 25-mile limitation in which
the city refuses to accept milk produced on farms
located more than 25 miles from the heart of the city.
That is not a health measure.
Rec.
Page
224
225
oO G4
Cross Examination by Mr. Hanson,
The pasteurization plants which supply Janesville
outside of the Dean Milk Company are three located
in Janesville and one just outside of the city limits.
They supply Janesville under our Grade A milk
ordinance. |
I think Janesville at oné time had a provision
which required pasteuriz#tion plants to be within a
certain distance from Janesville and that ordinance
was in effect until we adopted the U. S. Grade A
Public Health-Milk Ordinance. We adopted the U. 5.
Grade A Public Health Ordinance about 3 years ago.
From 1919 to 1946 the Janesville Ordinance re-
quired saatinistanticn plants to be located in the City
of Janesville but you must remember a Health De-
partment is not the legislative ard of the city and
that the Health Department nwt be governed by
the legislation under which it is controlled and under
which it has to work. The efforts I made to have
the ordinance modified commenced in 1923 when the
work of milk inspection was added to the depart-
ment. We tried in every way to modify our regula-
tion so that we could’bréaden the scope of our milk
ordinance. = ‘fact is, we have been working to-
wards a U: S. Public Health Grade A milk regulation :
for many years.
» We adopted the U. 8S. Public Health Milk Ordinance
and gave the local distributors 2“years in which to
comply with it.
IT am fairly familiar with the Chieago | Milk Ordi-
nance.
a
95
Rec.
Page
226 The Chicago Ordinance known as the Kelly Ordi-
nance, may not provide for reciprocal inspection.
There are minor details, insignificant variations be-
tween the Kelly regulation and the U. S. Public
Health Ordinance that don’t amount to much. You
could accept either one of them and produce a good
grade of milk.
I would say from my own observation that the
Janesville Milk Ordinance complies in all respects
with the recommended U. S. Public Health Milk
Ordinance. 3
I would say that merely taking a bacteria count
irregardless of whether it is sold under Grade A
or not, would not be sufficient to guarantee a safe
and sanitary milk supply to a city. oie ose
Q. In other words, it takes constant inspection
and supervision under which the milk is produced?
A. You can tell by the methylene blue test and
also by the phosphatase test on pasteurized milk and
the coliform test and by microscopic test, visual
test, pretty much as to the quality of the milk.
« Q. In your opinion, are those sufficient?
227. A. That isn’t only my opinion, it is the opinion
of the Department of Agriculture and the best men
in the field of public health‘work.
Q. Then it wouldn’t be nécessary to have all these
provisions in the ordinance, the detailed requirements
as to structural requirement, cleanliness of the barns
and so forth? A. That is debatable.
Q. In your opinion that is debatable? A. That is
debatable.
oO
Rec.
Page
9
Q. Those might all be wiped out? A. I didn’t
say that. I said as to these requirements, it might
be debatable.
& ses
Q. In other words, there is room for argument?
A. I have been in the health game so long I know
sometimes what were thought were necessary things |
were again thought. that weren’t necéssary. You
see, as far as the location of the milk house to the
barn and all those things which I don’t think comes
into this argument.
Q. And yet all those provisions ,are included in
the U. S. Model Health Ordinance? A. Yes.
Q. You think they might be practically unneces-
sary? <A. They are necessary if you take the coun-
try as a whole.
Q. But they are not necessary where you have the
methylene blue test? «\. It is necessary you have
all those tests and all those requirements when you
take the United States as a whole because I have been
in various sections of it and made inspections with
milk inspectors, and in various sections our condi-
tions vary. We aren’t all so fortunate as we are in _
southern Wisconsin and northern Illino#. |
Q. You heard the testimony of Mr. Burger in >
reference to the number of spot checks he made of
the farmers producing for the Dean Milk Company?
A. es.
Q. ‘1: your opinion as Health Commissioner are
those spot checks he made sufficient? A. Well, I
helped him make the first group and I would hate to
criticise Inv own work,
o
97
Rec. _ 2
Page
Q. We won’t ask you to do that, Doctor. A. No, I
couldn’t. -
Redirect Examination by Mr. Geffs.
I have an opinion as to the efficiency of the inspec-
tion of the Chicago Board of Health based not only
for the present time but for the last many years,
229 and it is a very high opinion of their inspection work.
I have been very close to their inspectors and I have
_ had complete cooperation from them and gave them
my entire cooperation. I cannot speak highly enough
for the Chicago Health Department. That is my
answer.
MR. JAMES H. DAVIS, called as a witness on behalf
of plaintiff, testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Geffs.
My name is James H. Davis, live at Rockford, Illi-
ngis and am employed by the Dean Milk Company.
230 My position is Director of Farm Relations. I super-
vise the field force that we have out irfspecting the
farms and I have charge of the procurement program
of .an adequate supply of milk of high quality for
our plants.
I have a B. S. degree from the College of Agri-
culture, University of Illinois, majored in dairy pro- _
duction and an M. A. degree from Northwestern
University. :
The Dean Milk Company has 7 inspectors under
my supervision inspecting the farms all the-time. I
“would say that each farm was inspected once a month.
oad
O98
Page
That inspection is in addition to the other inspection
by cities and municipalities in which Dean milk is
sold. I have read the Madison Milk Ordinance of
August 27, 1949.
231 Dean Milk Company receives milk from about 950
farms. In my qpinion these farms and their equip-
ment comply with the present Madison Ordinance.
The Model Milk Ordinance requires a tight top on
the wells that supply water and the Chicago Ordi-
nance and the State law of Illinois require that the
water be pure and sanitary.
232 The Chicago Ordinance provides that the water.
must be sanitary and the Chicago Health Department
inspect the facilities from which the water comes.
The well tops have to be tight.
I have samples of forms which each individual farm
must fill out and furnish.
(Exhibit 34—Form letter from Chicago Board of
Health for permit to farm furnishing milk to the
Dean Milk Company, is identified by the witnes8 as
a farm permit of a Grade A farm.)
There is a similar farm permit for each farm that
ships milk to Dean Milk Company. The permit is
issued by the Chicago Board of Health and a copy is.
furnished to the Dean Milk Company. The copy is
233 kept on file at the Dean Milk Company and is avail-
able to the Madison Health officer or anyone else
that desires to inspect it,
(Exhibit 34 received in evidence)
(Exhibit 35 —printed form of patron’s quality
record kept by Dean Milk Company)
Rec.
Page
234
99
This record is kept by the laboratory technician in
each one of the Dean Milk plants. This record is kept
for each and every farmer furnishing milk to Dean.
It is available for inspection by any health officer.
This record shows the patron’s methylene blue record
for each week that it is taken. It contains a sediment
test which shows the contents of the milk as it comes
in in regard to the amount of sediment each week
as it is taken. It also.shows the temperature of the
milk when it is taken in.
It shows resazurin which is another test, for deter-
mining the quality of milk from the standpoint of
sanitation.
It shows the microscopic or clump count as you
were calling them. ‘‘Pasteurizability’’ on this report
means the condition of the milk after it is pasteurized,
the number of bacteria that are left.
These tests are made by the Dean Milk Company
on each farmer producing and sending milk and are
made on alternate weeks several times a month.
These records are kept and may be inspected by
any health officer.
(Exhibit 35 received in evidence)
(Exhibit 36—a mimeograph form of the Dean
Milk Co. being a seore sheet of farm milk furnished
to plant, identified by the witness.) :
_ This exhibit is kept by each receiving station for
‘each patron furnishing milk to Dean Milk Company.
Milk is received at the receiving stations and trans-
ported to the two pasteurization plants.
| >
i=)
Rec.
F 100
236 These records contain information similar to the
237
238 °
previous exhibit we went through and they are avail-
able and on file for any health commissioner that
desires to see them.
(Exhibit 36 received in evidence).
(Exhibits 37 and 38 marked for identification be-
ing a penny postcard with mimeographed infor-
mation. )
Exhibit 37 is a card that is mailed to each patron
every time we run a microscopic count or ‘‘breed’’
count stating just where he stands.
Each farm producer receives one of them from
the Dean Milk Co, %
g
-Exhibit 38 is a similar card that is mailed to each
patron when we run a methylene blue test to show
him the results. 3
* “(Exhibits 37 and 38 received in evidence).
(Exhibit 39—a printed form entitled ‘‘ Dairy
Farm Inspection Report’’ marked for identifica-
tion).
Exhibit 39 is a dairy farm inspection report made
by our field men and kept on file at the Dean plant.
One copy is usually left with the farmer and another
copy filed with the plant. These records are available
to any health officer who wants to inspect them. These
records take up the health of the cows and follow
the health code.
(Exhibit 39 received in evidence).
The spot surveys conducted by-the U. S. Publie
101
Rec. ' . 3p :
Health Service are not made for the purpose of check-
ing on individual farms but for the purpose’ of
checking on the efficiency of the inspection of some
municipalities. The spot survey rates the degree of
efficiency of the inspection. All farms furnishing milk
*> to Dean are inspected by the inspectors of the Chi-
cago Board of Health and also by Dean’s own in-
spectors.
Cross Examination by Mr. Hanson.
- 239 If Madison had adopted the U. S. Model Milk
Ordinance it would communicate with the U. S. Public’
Health Service to determine whether Chicago was
making good milk inspection.
240 I have examined the Madison Ordinance and the
farms that produce milk. for Dean substantially com-
ply with the standards set forth in that Oxdinance. —
241 There are some differences pointed out this morning. -
‘The Dean Milk Company runs the methylene blue’
test on milk received. The microscopic and methylene
blue tests are used to determine the number of bac-
teria in a sample of milk.
242 Dean Laboratory is set up to use both the micro- ¢
scopic and the methylene blue test. A routine is set
243 up. These tests are made and records kept for the
purpose of seeing that the milk complies with the
standards of the Chicago Milk Ordinance.
Redirect Examination by Mr. Geffs.
244. In my opinion as an expert there is no material
difference as to requirements for sanitation of the
‘milk house by a drain trap in the Madison Ordinance
Gis
102
Rec,
e
and the Chicago Ordinance requiring the milk house
and premises to be kept in a clean and sanitary
manner,
245 DR. W. J. CORBETT, testified as follows:
Recross Examination by Mr. Hanson.
The Dean Milk Company uses both the microscopic
test and the methylene blue test.
246 » Each month each farmer’s milk we run a direct
microscopic test for each monthly period. Each month-
ly period we also run a laboratory pasteurized count. ~
During each month we also run a minimum of one
methylene blue test in the months from October to
April and the months from April-to October we run
our methylene blue test each week in addition to the
direct microscopic once a month and the laboratory
pasteurized once a month, and sedimentation on each
patron’s milk twice a month. z
‘Q. So these tests are concrete? You have three
tests of the same farmer’s milk each month? A. We ©
have more than that. There would be a direct micro-
scopic, at least one methylene blue, a laboratory pas-
teurized, and at least two sedimentations.
Q. I think I understand you now. And whether or
not you are going to use the one or the other depends _
upon regular routine? A, ‘That's right.
Q. Which is set up in advance? <A. Yes.
<&
\
Rec.
Page
247
. 248
103
ROBERT ALDER, called as witness on behalf of
plaintiff, testified as follows: —
Direct Examination by Mr. Geffs.
I live at Elkhorn, Wisconsin; I am a distributor
of Dean Milk in Southern Wisconsin, and I have a
bottling plant of my own. I came from Switzerland in
1920. I have a Bachelor’s Degree in Dairying from
the Federal] Technical Institute of Switzerland. I have
been engaged in the milk business ever since I have
been in this country; my milk plant at Elkhorn, Wis-
consin is inspected by the Wis. Dept. of Agriculture.
The milk I distribute in Southern Wisconsin for the
Dean Milk Company I obtain from the Chemung,
Illinois, plant. It is in cartons when I receive it and ©
I put it in my truck, which is insulated and refrig-
erated, and the temperature in the truck is kept
249
around 40. It is kept around that temperature until
it is delivered to the stores. In case Dean is admitted
to Madison, I would be the distributor. I deliver
Dean’s Grade A pasteurized milk and milk products
‘to the following cities and villages in Dane County,
Wiscensin: Mazomanie, Blac
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.