Prologue — Powell v. United States Cartridge Co.
Supreme Court brief1949
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Se
a a <- 7 oe
5 ws 2 ‘ } : ° : : \ .
yee ai ¢
\-
oe COURT, | U.S.
e ‘Vol. oe
_TRanscnrt OF RECORD
i
ae * opToRER TERM, 109
Sa) \ seg J . \
q a : .
° VY .
; oo weg me 0 : é. : iat r: : :
_B. M. POWELL, ET AL., PETITIONERS,
7 ae Phage - ig BOOK
. 7.
Aprais yon et mamie, Cleeer
Jamey
\"
=: LIBRARY. ~ 7 oe.
"Supreme: Court of the United .d States : re
_ ‘THE UNITED STATES CARTRIDGE COMPANY |
on WRIT OF ORRTIORARI TO THE UNITED: stares COURT oF.
perme: ees “> _
PETITION FOR CRETIORARE FILED JUNE 3, 148 :
>: “f
Or , CERTIORARI — OCTOBER 18, 149,
we}
sd
_ OO Pt,
OiK
~ RECORD.
Mol. l
| United Sut Creuit Court of Apps,
_ EIGHTH CIRCUIT.
? ‘nme STATES CARTRIDGE COMPANY, | DN
ener. CORPORATION, — Ra 3
Ties eraes
APPA. yaou 7uB DipraicT COURT OF THR , UNTrED ‘STATES :
; FOR THE FASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURL a if i
« 2 .
‘ - 4'* "FILED NOVEMBER 19, 1947. -
United Suis Cheat. Coug of Appeals, ,
oi .. crRCENT.’
2
No. 13,663. E
CIvIL. ® ite on =
THE UNITED STATES CARTRIDGE COMPANY,
A CORPORATION, | ee
APPELLANT, - ener
Seen ERY
'’ 3 M. POWELL ETAL, =... 23
7 APPELLEES... geass
-&
APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES .
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF MISSOURI.
FILED NOVEMBER 19, 1947. eee te
¢
gs Index,-Volume I.
tied , Original Print
Notice ot Appeal. PSE Ne TT Te CURT Te eT TET T CCT TEL 1 1
Doeket Entry of Filing of Notice of Appeal and of Malling of A
Camy ta Eotmel Bae Fame ao 5 ic cbs chads keane acaesr 2 2
Docket Entry of Filing of Complaint and Issuance of Sum-—
OE hi ni seins cad Ms Cad ab en Rae ge aed ee as dW etemaae exes om 2.
. Docket Entry of. Filing of ‘First Hera Complaint <aeGha ake ae
‘First Amended Complaint .........cccciccccepetesesoces ie er
Order of District Court Granting Leave to Amend First
Ame ided. Complaint Seeks Cee ens VEL OLENS ERE SRA ER 36 30
WI seo 3 es 5 cos Pk eo eee en ad Oks PP Eee OPE ye 37 30
alin tiie Print s
Ainended® ahd Additional ijiervobiaii Propounded by Plain: .
ee Se RID, on coke oan keds Leh ae wie een sak bake ceeds 41 33
Answers of Defendant to: Inverrog: tories. Rropound d by: Plain-
GE ocala se whol Ota cee ee AE ek Ok Oe ERE ee ee 44 “36
Chart in Support of Answer to Interrogatory No. 23....... -61 43
Request of Plaintiffs for Admissions bS. De fetidant... 35 sas 2 45
Reply of Defendant to Request of Plaintiffs for Admissions. 55 7
“Memorandum Relkating to ag og Amended Answer of De-
femGamt to -tnterrogetery No. Ge. 6 acs ec cc cote tae anes 57 49.
Amended Answer of Defendant to Interrogatory No. 22...... 58 , 49
2 Transcript of Testimony and Proceedings Kubek dba deakeae es 60 51
IE Sos oan nas Cae PTs aaa n kaha deine Rae wa bik nae ae. 51
Appearances 6f Counsel ............. cand eee Re See ea are’s a 51
Siete ence wha Gh bnew aa Caen dhe Lew ee ee eee ~ 8 52
Opening Statement on Behalf. of Plaintiffs. PTET CT ETT 65-— - 54
a ee es 5 bBo ccc veen tndeads ane’ Ve seeras , ae | 62
6 =» Ore rere rrr ree rprr ere wer or 77e 62
ae Plaintiffs’ ee PPE ET Pee ere Serer eeserpaches "$7 68 -
F, Excerpt from “Book Issued by Educationa! Division
of Safety Department’ of: United States . Cartridge
“Company Containing? Instructions, etc. ........:.,.. &8 69
‘ Report ef Violations of Safety Regulations err ~~ 77
Enstruiction BhOGE\..). 2... ogc ates ce ewe ee esas 97 78
Safety Inspection Report ....... ak kad eae ok ee 99 80
“Report of Employee's coc perth ae Wades kite 100 ‘$1
. Fire. Extinguistier. Chart ..:.............. waakawed 114 95
Non-productive Departments ...... ae a penta lls 97
, Memorandum from A. B. Johnson, aL Ord. Dept., ‘.
‘Assistant to Safety Officer, September 4, 1942. 117-102
Memorandum from D. C. Storms to G.A. Gilbertson” ;
et al., October 16, 19422...... Pe REE HL f 118 103 --
Ses Safety Equipment List, August BE Ress 4 4% a ae 119 ]it4
ee A-1 to A-3, A-29 and A-47, Statements Relating sto Va-
rious Employees of United» States’ Cartridge Com-
pany ‘and Showing When Employment Commenc ed,
Hours Worked, and Wages Received Pia ete sgl *. 240 ° 221
Pe ie oy eer ie ae 56 ee ae
a Pee 0 Re ee Now fg oo geese 142 196,
A-3, FW. Harris +... . 2 2.av i: Eek gE LEE ETT 2, 146 133
ths one ~ St RMOIBTOF 4... wise. PTI re eT 236 836141
; A-47, D. Burke ...... enbieagite $40 cethceeeekene hla ae. oe
aa B-1 to B-3, B-29 and B- 47, Statements Relating to
Sean 4 Overtime Work by Various. Employees of United
“8 States Cartridge Company .as Cemputed from In-
- formation on Plaintiffs’ Exhibit A................. 387 149
ee os POE ee panne ee eae eek Cee 337 9-149.
+ ey. SN a Mf kb Sk 4 0k kee we eae cesstwans .. 340: 155
saat. aes Ba. F: N. Marie ....... ' ; 345 165
; - B-29, G. Burmeister ...... on 423° 173
B-47, D. Burke ......... or , 484 179
sesame : ~Ordnance Plant” OE PPE PINs, PORE EEE ° oe * pola 189
. G, Memorandum from 8. L. ‘S, T9G8.c.. &. B44
; . Defendatt’s Exhibits:
1, Book Entitled, “Safety Manual For Plant Supervis-
WE ci aieaecoatekadueexian tke ian Nae Kee 660 217
i cn OEE EE EEE EE CEE ee tee Pree Pienek 666 . 221°
- General Repairs & Maintenance SD ala aa ara eae ties 671 223
VOR OR THOR 1k nas ccescs giin sas nee Cexeeen 672 224
Protegtive Clothing ........... S Sere a Ree 673 224
Safety Equipment & Tools. .2.... Pere rey ree 20 «= 225
RE re ke ee od RE ee te -676 226
I SAR Ta a ed _« See 6 2
> . . ” Original Print
- Dermatitis ieyeiea as Sinn ae ek Sct Sa ae'n anne .« 673 238
eeateees f Sores, See Wee ee ee. en) ae
Eating Habits :...:..:.:.. ahead on ic EER OES «G83 ° 229
Office Work ....... Lenin MGSCE We buns aeae Mad what F840 230 he
‘Transportation ...... A eee ets avian scans .- +685" 230.
Housekeeping SUNS ECAORSDER A ade Sead cs danwinnc en. Oh
ee = ck a, ROSY RAMS SAS bls bk ee lat 689 233°
Lighting and W ining : RC ears tear es I eee ace te + 690 © 233
OES ane cen ee SS Sa 234 |
Warehousing and. Seincke ie ded os a Yas RU ey >. 694 ° 235
5 tk IE 3a SEBS ea Peis dees cig ans sss wn re a
me Ladders ....... SAREE Feet DO eR oe See ee ae 697 = 237
wot: ee aoa: Se ce ek Pe ee. Toe). a ae
‘. | Platforms and Runways aaa ad Puaw tan tah cee AG .. 702 239
a sae SRS a ips So aee ee ae et eee > 703- 240
. Floor Openings—Shaftways FLY SS Pee ee en ae 704 24)
SET SENSI art SAS Spec oe en 705 = 241
(ESE igre i ee ge a 707 Ss «243
I Res ao G- TURES SC aue eae AKL 4 grt are 708 243
___,. 2 error ee DS aay or gare oe eee 709-264
Cafpentry ..:..... eA wh wile ae Chr g wakutce aie deel 710 244
ii’ herd a <a a fa ace a ks pie re ee eens. G82. > 366
ee, eee aa kas (oie his Vibe ce Eide ean 505s 712-246
a nen Se ere a ee er en ee eee 713 246
‘ Safety Glasses ......... EE Be ee eae ee reer 715. - 247
ee re NE Se Yer ore rer 716. 248
Fe oon oo he cons Te 717. 248 {
"Hemp and Sisal NG cae Paa kee vu cds eka Sed cis 720 4 3=6 251
‘ EGS, SE Bek Na a 721 251
ae Machinery ....:.... SEO SEE ee pee ee ee 724. 258
IN ed oi aes cae kde Kat csc Gua. 724 253
OF OEE ne Dee 725 - 254.
Machine & Transmission Guards. Raa aathe Ae ts 7260 06254
Abrasive Wheels ..............°. ewe -ieetuiamate tae Ser
ae | a ee eee ors ceed tage 731 258
Pressure Vessels and Equipment - "SIE Chef ae _. ten 6 ©©628
v 5 or OE. ah Kh ot env sew ee ee eee ey 734. 260
- Motors & Electric Power....:................:...8786 261°
PCRS OEE ee Sedge Ste 'F38-° 263
EOE Ene hE i ae 739. 263
- I boos ines du ts eae. ok cs 741. 265
OE WE 9 no ss nn kos oo ceiee roe Pp Re 7420). 266
a NS ake igs sea caw ce Mi hesaes Tere ene mae
Acids—General ...........:.....2 ose pak “1 748. .267
7 a Ranked sth aces yes. ¢ PEGE eee eT Ea 748: 269——
Carben —Ménoxide wud Wloside.:...!..°..<....... * 753 272
SN Ns a Se. +35 77: eae
rE I oe (TRS 27
Recommended Intensity of Light at Working Pies. 757 = 975 ;
|. adie wutn at walk clad a:5 24 759 276 - &
Identification of Piping System eid arn leas x cas» 462.0 278
APES IAS Sah ae REE pei oy aren ae, 764 279
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit H, . Report of ¥itintion of Safety Reg-
Oe et EN gee oh Xa gach bs add oe heR ge Reel, S14 311
dp I ee oe ee 820 315
Frank N. Harris, Recalled........... ee hie Ae angels ara 827. “319
Defendant’ RR DES SERISDESE aR aan et gn a 830 321
a 2°to 6, Anplications of F. N. Harrjs for Pay Dyring
NUN PU cons ck wi ce. le, $36 321
7, Certificate ef Robert Michael Powell that He Isa © ay
Citizen of the United States of America, ete.. $32 325.
, Certificate of Gordon Bowman Darby that He is a
Citizen of the U nited States of America, ete. . 833 -327
Re :
' Original Print
Robert M. Powell, Recalled: Pe Serr ere vrerry er ae
Fletcher John Ejifert ..:...... Pree err tues haat edhe wanis 855 = 3343.
- Ralph Wilson Hughes .............. de teeseseeseeseeese 869 351
Pi EPP PP OCP PT Ter IPE TCPER ET TS TUT eer . 887 362 -
gg EE PO es ee |
*1, Government Bill of -Lading Covering ‘Shipment ol.
from the F. M. Kenyon, ist Lieutenant, Ordnance
OMRESINOOE, Ths Ts De oar in bas cb asedewotntce 891 365
J; Government Bill of Lading Covering Shipment
' from Ralph Charles, , Captain, Ordnance | Depart-
WR Tha he ss cae oaks cbs ewes teeistincawessaces 883 371
K, Bal of Lading Covering Shipment from St. Lénis - ;
‘Ordnance Plant to Supply Officer, Naval Ammuni- . Fea hose
ee thom EAOPOT, ATOMO, TRIAD 6 oi ccsc ac cc catocecsessis 902 . 375
D, Publication of St. Louis Ordfiance Plant Entitled , -
- “Bullets By The Billions,” Memorandum as: to.. 912 381.
E-1 to E-7, United States Cartridge News, Memoran-
GUM BBO once cece ccccccacs’s hemes Gabe ke ee Spee ‘935 _ gsaf
Gordon B. Darby ............: Reon iay Gait ac caxkiveeaeas 992 “384.
Aubert R. Kettenbrink ............ Ahk COKE SES RRO ED *...1008 ~ 393
Arther Clarence Kropp « ..... 0.5.0... .te csc ccceccrecses 1010 = 395.
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit L, Interdepartmental Memorandum. .1020 © 401 —
SR ig oss 4 can bia vaciawesd an benvuirins 1038 8411
RMN SIO 866 205 oc oc Sb adsnc cnt ceteerecen te 1050 419 -
M-1, Purchase .Order, St. este Gidnonee Plant to:
Western Cartridge Company, September 23, 1944. “1050 419
M-2, Bill of. Lading Covering Shipmerit From St. ;
Louis ‘Ordnance ‘Plant to United: States Cartridge
Company-.- ET ae Fe OU oP rar EH or oF an aera 1051 421
M3, ‘Receiving and Inspection Report of. St. Louis — I.
Ordnance Plant Relating to Articles Received From . 4
Mss gg Bras. Company SAW ACs ace Kak bee eens ....1052- / 423
Check, United States Cartridge Company to Na- ~~.
gates Lead Company, $24, 156.65, Maréh 29, 1943...1057 427
O-1, Check, United States Cartridge Company to/
_Trojan, Powder Company, $1,950.00, September. }4,
| ORO RO Rr R eeeeeee 1060 “429
-2, Check, United States ‘Cartridge Company’ to-
Trojan. Powder Company, $1,650.00, Novemper | ee =
Pe eh Serer Peer Te eee Pere Eee Pe 1061 431
0-3, Receiving and Inspection. Report ‘of St. Louis
Ordnance Plant Relating to Articles Regpived from :
Badger Ordnance Works ........... Ae... ss. 1062 433
P, Check, United States Cartridge Cafpany to Cru- ,
cible Steel Compaxy of —T p90 048. 61, Sep- >
tember. 16, — tee Gk we aba eT be eae kia eee .- 1064 435
* Index, Volume II.
‘Resse Ronaine ‘Casteel Pe i temmiaiL 2 oe Cede wie Ek mS Oh Oe 107° 440
Frank N. Harris; recalled..... skeen cee es eer ry 1085 451,
_Defendant’s Exhibits. ..-. 0/4... 0.0. .ccesecceceuseeese 1088 453
9, Time Cards of Various Empléyees of United States
ee ae 108§~ 453
et 9S SR pra ere Pee eT eee 1088 = 453
Motion of Defendant to ‘Dismiss pauper Sak ae Bea ek acne 1142 86456
Testimony for Defendant A aati ae PE, ee PS ee 1142) 457.
. . ¢§ 2 — Se ee ree Pagans rd eer wr | cae |
Defendant's Exhibits as a aaa oe —Eey e Pa ie gee 1145 459
10, Organization Chart of Safety Department. of :
United States. Cartridge Company................. 1145 = 459
11, Manual of Procedure With Respect to Safety ‘En-
gineering Department CSR EGR: Ree 4
- ‘Original Print,
1< Form of Unite d States C artridge Comp any headed
“Administrative Exemption” and relating to Non-
| oa _ super t oapa Employees Earning $217.00 per Month °
ee SN Seer ey A Saerer re yy ery 1235 589
‘13,. Pages Giving Comple te -Job ‘Desc ription of In- i
spector and InstructGr at vanes States Cartridge PR BSA:
OL I a chan. cre ke Ws ck ee oe A ok ee _. 22.1250 597.
‘14, Job Description of Safety Inspectors CIPS PE Pee 1254 609
15,- Weekly Time Card of A. C. Kropp at Uhited Pi
States Cartridge Company :....00.0...0. 0.0.0... «knee 23
16, Sample of Typical Time Card...°..:............ 1274 625.
17° Statem#nt Signed by W. F. O'’Mara.............. 1297 - 640
18, Statément Signed by E. C. Maher WE TOC CE ree 1301 .642-
James L. SRR arr eerre aera et SET ee we ee A 6X4
e Walter L. Schult ....:.....2. 0.600% af REE AE, PPE gai 1394 - 699 |
Defendant's Exhibit 19, Blank ‘Form; of Purchasé 5 0 ‘
of United States Cartridge Company. ns whee ia -+-3+188G 901
Russell Roland Casteel ....... Set See eee pete. 1401 707
Walter L. Schulte, Recalled—~. ov... cee See ey: 1403 708
Defendant’ s Exhibit 21, Purchase ome St. Louis. OFd- z
“nance Plant to Western Cartridge “Compatiy. Septem-
fg 8... PA rey i enn alan cae Lenmar ge pee 1495 709:
_~2" Russell’ R. Casteel, Recalled. 2... -..... FUP ee Peer ee 14130 717
/ * Defendant's Exhibits ............ hicpith en baicg cha wcduan 1421 722
. 22, Contract, Be:ween’ United Statesof America. and
Western Cartridge Company: December 5, 1946... .1421 tan”.
“Schedule A, Key Personnél for Small Arms Ammv- .
ae, EE pase ane cae cde ces cas eneeee 14480 754
: 20, Contract Between United States of America and — ae
' United States ae ‘Company, December 4, OP dooce
. 1940. Reena oats ET OS | TRS i. .1475 2 WER
Performance Bond PP EE te Bah re ep Morea ...1504° 796
23, Supplemegtal Contract Between United States of-
‘America and Urpited States a Company,
(Se BR rere pee meer) poems 95 A RAD
24, Supplemental Contract) hotwecn United States off
-America and United States Cartridge -Company
Bag 30, .1343, Portion of....,....:.. eee ee 2.1536 825
, Article II-V, oo Discrimination of Supplemen-
ba in Contract between United States of America and
? United States Cartridge Company, February 14;
; NTE Gy iat Me lie EL GA gs eae ois Mes 1551: &37
. Harry P. Miller, Recalled. ehh ede Ws oS NG as aie ch ce
Walter L-Schulte, Recalled: ........... ITO Tiere ae
: i ta Se Waleska kb ca ahces es een eo ane 1614 = 862
John. RS er ere Sccka bie cats ~ot---1618 865
Testimony for Plaintiffs in Rebittal.:...............0...: ieee «= 874
7 2k, renee reeR: = = | Ck
Ms te SD. gs onan ep ean ve a Oa Sv OE er bm. ..,--1636 876°
William Stutz ....... Beis la aa ae ee er ee ee -1639 = 878
eS | Seer errr bie EA gist hi Gate a awa ae teks .-1649 884
Alfred C. Kemp ............ Bead eos acta aha eae 1653-886
Piss occ ans ahvea snes cad LPP re LS aes 1667 = &95
William B. Niedringhaus ................... Ap ee ec 1678 $02
Burckhardt ee I co k's cs tk os Soe eee Pos s.
. Further Testimony for Defendant: SEPT err re oe ere Pee. 1685 907
A .1685-. 907
Defendant's Exhibit 26, Letter, M. B. Chatfield. Lt» Col. ;
Ord: Dept., Contracting Officer, to United States Car-
tridge Company, March Wie. Bhs Gis ees ees Pee 1687 = =908 ©
Ek RR eK 66 eens. Sg ea rth 1692 ..913 -
Certificate of Court Reporter to Testimony. Pee Ce ee ee yy 1694 9-915
: . Ke ee Print
? - , ce ‘Original
Findings of Fact and Conctinigues“at Law of District Court..1695 9-916.
Judgment, May 19, 1947). <7...00.0...: PREPS TN TOP eee SEC Ce 1700 QR
Motion of Defendant tor-New Trial. ‘fieargose tla Geese eg LTS © 92S
Affidavit of Harry“P. Miller.....:........ eS Sing pwn Cee
Affidavits on .. Behalf of Plaintiffs opposing eRe of De fend- Seay
_ ant for-Néw Trial .......... ECTREMA Rae eek een om ata aes 1730 945
’ FP. Harris 28s see. pak ee neas cavay Reyree a) Seay b730 - -D45
eee OS Re ee ee uw wert eee eer ey 7300 G4
on 1) EE A oats Cc daue ee egeee ncsneeeen (sive 6 Se kawaan “173000 YAS
Arthur -C. Kropp .......: ES TWEE a Pear o i (ieee dap hah eee 1730. 945 -:
ea Sadi aa ks sa kas KoMe Aho oe ee eas Lue ta ees 1730. 945°
Motion of Plaintiffs for Substitution of LaVerne J.. Ludwig,
’ Adminjstratrix, in the place of.B. J. Ludwig, Deceased; yee ye
Gladys Connell, Administratrix, in the plaee of F. Connell. 41 G54
Letters of Administration issued to LaVerne J. “pop wll
. Administratrix.of Estate of Bennett J. Ludwig, Deceased.1743 955
Letters of .dministration issued to Gladys Connell, Admin
istratrix of Estate of Frank’J. Connell, Deceaséd......... 1745. 958°
- Order of. District Court srvepraligg Motion of Defendant for : '
re FON PEE hve cosh As eA Eo ay rh eRe Oe a werd ee an we o .. L746 9541
Order District, Court Substituting LaVérne J. “tabele, ‘Admin-
istratrix, etc., as Plaintiff in the place of B. J. Ludwig, De-
ceased, and- Gladys Connell, Administratrix, ete. as Plain”
tiff in the place of F. Connell, Deceasdd. .¢.27.,........... 1747960
Order of District Come exten! ‘ing ‘Time to file ea ord on Ap- :
OOS icin te es PE RE LG ES LO py ee Ta er, ae }
Order that Defendant may Deposit” Certain Money into Reg- eds
istry of Court fn Lieu of Supersédeas Bond on Appeal... .«.1749 961
Docket Ertry Showing Deposit Made by Defendant in Regis-
try ‘of Court in Lieu of Supersedeas Bond on Appeal.......1751. 963
’ Statement of Points upon which. Appellant intends os rey ee
ee ee I a cae, ba cael ae eat kak a 1752 m3
Designation of Defendant of Contents of Record on Appeal...1763° 972
Designation of Plaintiffs. of Additional-Matters to be con-
tained in the Record cn Appeal...................2.0.... ..1766 2 975
Clerk's: Certificate to Transcript......... CKerer rT Leet ee .-1767 976
eee as to printing Record.......:....... rreeer terror “.1768 977
_ Proveedings in U. S. Court of Appeals. .*...:.....6.. - ick ses 979 979
Appearance of Counsel for Appellant................'..... cre 979 ;979
- Appearance of Counsel for Appellees. . ; ijn —
. Order denying, Motion for Substitution ‘of Parties Appellee. . 980 . 979°
Order Granting-William R. McComb, Administrator of WVage ee “3
© * and Hour Division, etc., leave to filebrief amicus curiae. . 81 980 ~.
; “Order vacating Ridbentesion, Setting Cause fur Reargument and eget
e as to filing further briefs.............. a Pepe an sede aes 982 980
Order of Submission............ ak bee cs pe ae be has cae Cee 984 982
ER ARNeS ber Tote PP eer rnye eikewneece odes -... . 985 982
‘ Appelices’ Petition.for Rehearing and to Modify Judgment-... -1011 1007 bp
Brief for Adminisirator of Wage and Hour Division, etc. .as “| %
- Amicus Curiae in support of Petition for Rehearing........ 1027 1023
Order Denying Petition of. Appellees for Rehearing and Modi-
fying Opinion, A SS Ree ee eee err ye paseasgesenes .. 1041 “1037
Judgment, ME Be I ca ck Cae ba Koad cay Ads nasukgee uke eee
Application of Appellees for Order Staying Issuance of Mandate 1044 039
Order Staying Issuance of Mandate. ...................... ‘3.. 1046 /1040
Praecipe for Record for Supréme Court, U. Speer eevee 1047/1041 ©
Clerk’s Certificate to Transcript RP TNS aoe a see eeuh een ae 1042
7 °
ae Pe Pe eee oes yh fe es ee Geiais x! Pert
» Praeeipe. for additional, parts of record ter consideration by
Supreme © ourt of the hited. States a —— FOS
Pedapoiari rd s-motion to modify opinion | fo Nee hae ind}
* Exlgbit “A” xe erpts from brief of alefendant, United 0
States Cartridge Company ee DT aah eee
» Exhibit “B’~ Excerpt from reply- brief for’ plaintiffs, ’
RK. M. Powell etah 1.4, : . 10d
Exhibit “C"--E Xeerpts fron mewor andum on oral argie ‘
a. ment-and reply for Adtainistrator of the Wace and Hour’
Division, U hited States Department. of Labor, as amicus .
curiae _ °° : , see lang
- 4. Clerk's certificate +. % “ igs eet Wit
Stipulation as to revord: Z ee : : 1055 -
. aie a a . P74 : i ——
Order allowing: certiorari ee eae 1057 ;
9 we *,
‘ , a ¥
ao ‘
= ¢
‘ . :
J fi i i?) a
: S #0
< a
x an, ws :
/ E 7
Pe : mi
: a -
©
0200
rh)
Note
a Throughout’ this Transcript of Record
there are many blank pages: which apparently 3
have been assigned page numbers, These
blank pages have not been microcarded, and
the user of these cards will be so notified
at each point where this occurs. :
® *
ae 7) wamtthew Bender & Co.
BT eee Sth MI) EOD Sct oe ad
“4
Pleas and proceedings in the United States Court of Ap-
peals for the Eighth Circuit, at the March Term, -
4949, of said Court, before the Honorable Archibald —
e K. Gardner, Chief. Judge, and the Honorable John >>
' B. Sanborn, the Honorahle Joseph W. Woodrough,
- the Honorable Seth Thomas, the Honorable Harvey oa
M. Johnsen, the Honorable Walter G. Riddick and —
the Honorable John Caskie Collet, Cireuit Judges.”
-Attest:; sere «KB. E. KOCH,
os ee ~~ Clerk of the United States Court
We OS of Appeals for. the Eighth Cir-
cuit. : Ree
Be it Remembered that heretofore, to-wit: on the 19th
© day of November, A. D. 194%, a transcript of record pur- |
= snant to an appeal taken fram the District Court of the
* United States for the Eastern District. of Missowgi, = ee
# filed in the office of the Clerk of the United States Cite
+ Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit, in a certain cause
| wherein The United States Cartridge Company, a Corpora- -
¢ _ was Appellant and R. M. Powell, et al., ‘were Appel- °
lees. es 3 . veh
uit
Printed record on which the appeal was heard in, the.
United States Court of Appeals for the. Eighth Circuit, is
in the words and figures following, to-wit: |
we te
if oan
4. 3 ee ee “Notice of Appeal. ihe, | Fs
(F Hed oe li, Vy, )
“4
In the. U nied States District Cied for the Eastern
Divi ision of the Hastern Judicial, District
of Missouri.
R. M. Powell, et al.,
_ ae |
( : - . one , oe
ry, Plaintiffs :
ee a pone ie , > 1 Court Room
eee . ls ie |
g Civil Action
The United States Cartridge Company, No, 3597
, . F e ee a
a corporation,
| Defendant. J
Notice Is Hereby Given that The: United States Car-
tridgé Company,'a corporation, fhe defendant in the above
entitled cause, hereby cappeals to the Cirenit Court of Ap-
pealy for the Kighth Cireuit: from the®final judgment and
decree ente ved inthis action on May 19, 1947, and from the
order entered on September 2, 1947, denving and over--
vruhinge Defendant's Motion fer a New Trial.
RHODES -E. CAVE,
R. H. McROBERTS,
W.€. CONNETT TV, ;
1630 Boatmen’s Bank Building,
St. Louis 2, Missouri,
Attorneys fowDefendant The United —
States € ‘artridge ne
3RY AN, CAVE, MePHEETERS’ «& McROBERTS,
1650 Boatmen’s Bank Building,
St.Louis 2, Missonri,
Of Counsel.
ra ; ar ee
1 5 tiem edie metric: vance ac
») - “—— .
~ [ fol. 2] Docket cntry showing filing of tietice of ‘appeal and
anaiing copy of such notice by the clerk of the court to
attorney of record for plaintiffs.
(September 17, 1947. )
Notice of ine’ of defendant to the United States Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals, 8th Cirgpit, from final judgment and
decree heretofore entered herein May 19, 1947, denying and”
. overruling, defendant’s motion for a new trial, filed and
“copy ‘of aforesaid notice of appeal forthwith mailed by the
Clerk of the Court to Thomas Bond, Hsq., attorney of. ree-
ord for ten sais
~
Docket entry showing filing of complaint by plaintiffs.
ats i
(May 4, 19745.)
Complaint filed and summons issued directe - to- defend-
ant returnable within. tw enty days after service,
(Doe ket Entry of filing of F ivst Amended (¢ ‘omplaint. y
ay * ke (April 5, 1946.) .
On oral motion of plaintiffs, the persons named in Ex-
hibit A to the complaint herein are |joinnd] «as additional -
parties plaintiff. - First amended complaint joining
persons as*parties plaintiff, filed by leave.
said
a
oe Fe hag Th ee
ea hie PDT Rete mee ee
MOO < ted apt's.
reer
[fol. | First Amended Complaint,
(Filed April 5, 1946.)
% the ® “ited States Distriet Court for the
Eastern Division of the. Eastern Judicial
District of Missouri
R. MW Powell, A. C. Kropp, F. NX. Harris, |
Bs M. Tyler, J. C. Marshall, A. W. Me-
Cluing, G..H. Bentine, Joe Reeves, Her-
bert. Hahn, N. W. Myers, B. J. Ludwig,
k.. L. Stoekho, Wilham : Niedringhaus,
William Stutz, SP. Coley, L. W.Trim-
ble, R. M. Stewart, B. HL. Hargate, J. 8.
Schneider, Walter Gorg, Jr, B. MM.
Casey, A. He Erickson, Elmer Maher,
Eiimett Hoskins, K.P. Knight, R.A.
Westra, D. Fo Bateman, Al Herman, ;
(George Burmeister, G. B. Darby, RO FE. ,
Jenniches, J. J. Schwartz, A. €2 Kemp,
Byron Yaneey, J. D. ‘Cavanaugh, W. F.
O'Meara, Roland Carbone, .W. A.
Broad, (, L. Vilei, Mike Malloy, Rus-
sell Barnett,-" William Hirs¢hberger, |
Frank Connell, Floy -L. Jennings, Ster-
ling Cook, Cliff Champion, Don Burke,
W. C.-Viehmami, F. M. Kercheval, Guy a.
Burke, W. C. Viehmann, F. M. Kerche- : ;
yal, Guy Cruce, R. Baxter, N.C. Wal-
ther, George Gillen, James Vollbrecht,
5 ee P syrignn Jack PeLaregy, GC. 4°,
‘Brace, S. F. Peters, A. Lockhart,
- Plaintiffs,
.Court No.1,
Civil Action
*. No. 3097.
VS.
The United States Ca rtridge ‘Company,
. a corporation,
| . a Defendant. }
I
Now comes the above naned plaintiffs, by their attor-
ney, and by deave of court, file this their first amended
4
complaint, and for cause of action state that defendant -is
a corporation duly erganized and incorporated under the
laws of the state of Maryland, duly licensed te do buai-
‘ness in the state of Missouri, and having an office and
agents for the transaction of its business at 4300 Good-
: fellow Avenue in the City of St. ‘Louis, Missouri and in
[-figl. 4] the Mastern Judicial District of Missouri. That
the above named plaintiffs, and each of .them,.were all
employees of defendant and. were and are similarly sitt-
ated within the meaningof section 16 b.of the Fair Labor
Standards Act of 1958 (20 UL S.C. 216b). )
I]
Jurisdiction is conferred on this court by Sec. 41 (8), 28
UL S.C. A. (Judicial Code See. 24 (8),) giving the Umted
States District Court original Jurisdiction of all suits and
proceedings. arising under any law regulating cothmerce
without regard to the citizenship of the parties or the sum
of money or value in controversy, and also by See. 16 b. of
the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1958 (See. 216. (bd), ~—
29 U.S.C.) hereinafter see to as the Act.
7 P
iit.
That during ail-the times hereinafter mentioned: -defend-
ant was engaged in the eperation of a niunitions plant in
the City of St. Lonis, Missouri and in the Easiern Judicial
District of Missouri, wherein it manufactured small arnis -
ammunition, rarticularly 20 or 50 or 60 calibre shells for.
nse in rifles and machine euns, all intended for use by the.
inilitary forces of the United States and its allies and all
intended for transportation and use to and at points ont--
side the state of Missouri. That defendanf puréhased a
large part of the raw materials-that entered inte the mamt-
facture of said aminuitien at points outside of the state
_ of Missonri and cansed same to be transported in “inter:
state commerce into the State ef Missouri and delivered to
defendant at its said plant. That the entire product of
defendant’s said munitions plant was destined for use by
‘{fol. 5] the armed forces of the United States on the then
existing battle fronts and military establishments and con
- ‘oO
fhe seas and in the air, and to supply other munitions °
plants and contractors sadeid the state of Missouri, and
that same’ were. produced for interstate commerce and
were sold, offered for transportation, tr ansported, shipped
and deli vered in interstate commerce from defendant's
plant at St. Louis, Missouri to various points outside the
state of Missouri. That asa necessary part of the said
manufacturing operations at said plant, defendant made.
use of means .of interstate Communic ation, to-wit: the
telephone and telegraph, and im tlie transportation of the
raw material into said plant and the finished product out
of said plant, defendant made use of railroads,airplaues,
steamships, automobiles, trucks and other meas or in-
strumentalities Cf “interstate commerce, and that at all
times herein mentioned, let ndant was engaged) in inter
state commerce, and in’ the production of woods for in-
terstate commerce, and was subject to the ,provisions of
fhe Fair Labor Standards Act of 1958, ~ That plaintiffs,
and ‘each of them, while a ‘defe ndant at said
plant, were employed in interstate
production of, goods for interstate commerce within the
meaning of the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1958. And
that defendant was an ‘¢Emplover’? within the meaning |
of said Act.
—_——_—
oe
The pl ca a andeach of them, we re employed by tlie
defendant at its said -plant for the periods hereinafter
stated in the production of goods for interstate commerce |
at agreed salaries for a 40 hour: work week in the Safety
Department at said plant: in the capacity of safety men, of
whom there were alsout eighty-five on det ‘endant’s pay:
[ fol. 64 } rit who were assigned to ipach manufacturing
unit, ‘and to each special function of plant operation on
ach working shift. "That plaintiffs were all similarly
situated and performed Similar duties: and the regal: iT
duties assigned to them were as follows, to-wit:
After re porting the time, eheeking in and changing into
working clothes, if was the duty of each nfan to patrok his
nait and [made] inspections. These Inspec tions included
rommerce and in the.
a,
6
3
G
the floors, machinery, tools, equipment, materials and the
working practices of employes. When unsafe or unsani-
* tary conditions of buildings or equipment were observed, |
and when unsafe practices of employes Or their failure to —
use or wear safety devices were noted, the dn were re-
quired to report same or ally to the foremen for, Sorrection, -
and thereafter were required to make written réports on 3
prescribed forms of said unsafe conditions or violations of
safety rules. The men were also required to make written
reports,.Qn all accidents and state therein the cause and.
extent of -the injury. “ie ay : Ge
In addition to the aforesaid regular duties, the men
were required to attend meetings of the safety- units and
to attend plant drills‘and té-be on hand during black-outs.
That the aforesaid services and duties performed by the
plaintiffs were necessary fo and interwov en with the inter-
state commerce business of the defendant, and were neces-
sary and contribtited to and were interwoven with the
production of. goods for-interstate commerce by. the -de- —:
fendant, and tended t» and did prevent work stoppage
_and loss of inan hours in-production, and wete and are an’
essential and necessary part of the manufa tur Ing-epera-
tions carried. on-bhy-atefondant, and were and\are ‘essential
to the preduetion of the arimunition produced hy defend.
[fol. 7] ant, and plaintiffsState that in rendering, said Serve — |
jeés and in performing said duties plaintiffs were and are. 7
-engaged’ hu. the production of goods for interstate com- 2
-meree within the meaning of the Act, and were and are
subject to the provisions, and entitled to the benefits and
protection | ‘of the Aet, and particularly Seetions 6 and 7:
thereof, and ‘that plaintiffs were and are entitled to’ be
paid for all overtime worked in excess of 40 hours per.
week at the rate of one and one chal’ tine the. regular +
rate at Which’ they were employed. :
- ¥. -
‘That during the periods hereinafier: stated defendant
employed the plaintiff, and. each of them in interstate
ecommerce. 2nd in the production of goods for, interstate
i
om 9
-commeyee, as aforesaid, for work weeks longer than the
applicable maximum number of hours under Section.7 of
the Act, and defendant in violation of the Act, failed and
refused to compensate them for suclr employment at rates
not less than oné and one-half. times the regular rate at
which they were employed, and that defendant is in idebted
io said plaintiffs, and: each: of \them,. For said overtime
‘compensation, and for equal amounts invaddition: thereto
for liquidated dyinages and for a reasonable attorney's
fee. That plaintiffs do not bave complete-and accurate -
knowledge of the times and hours [or] laggr, the time cards
‘and other records showing the muuber of hours being in
the possession of defendant. — Ph: aintif—s age informed and
believe and upon such information and belief state that
samie are approximately ax stated’ in the following pare-
eraph. ;
. i; Soe
The plaintiff, R. M. Powell, alleges that diring the
Be from November 2, 1942 to Mareh 31, 1944, he was
*
[fol. 8| employed by defendant as a safety man at a base:
_pay-of $51.92 per week fora forty hour week to October
10, 1943, and $110.77 per two. weeks to/ March 26, 1944,
and $46.15 per week to April 9, 144, and that his regular’
hourly: rate was $1.50 per hour to October TO, 1943, and —
$1.38 per honr to April 9, 1944. That during all ‘of’ said
period he was required-to work 640.8 hours overtime, that --
is to-say,‘in excess of the applicable maximum under Sec-
tion 7 of the Act, for which he wis entitled to be: paid
overtitne _ compensation at thecrate of one and Ofe-half
‘times the aforesaid applicable regular hourly rate, amount-
ing in all to-the sum of x1; 252.46,
..The plaintiff, A. . Kropp, Alleges that during the’
ana from Sou a 1410 to April 7 ‘ 1945, he was
employea by defendant as safety man at-a base pay of.
$46.15 per week for a-forty hour week to January 24,
1943, and $51.92 er week’ to Ma 23, 1948, and $97.69 per
week to October 16,943, and $120.00 per two weeks to
Februgdry 1. 1945. and $129.25 per two weeks to March
11, 1944. and that his regular hourly rate was $1.15 per
a
8 -
hour to January 24, 1943, anal $1.30 per hour to May 23,
1943, and- $1.44 per hour to October 10, 1943, and $1.50
per hour to ‘February. 13, 1944, and $1.61 per hour to
March 11, 1944. That during all of said periods he was
required to work 1585.1 hours overtime, that is to say, im
excess of the applicable maximum: under Section 7 of the
Act, for which he was éntitled to be paid overtime. com
‘pensation at the rate of one and one-half times the afore-
said applicable regular hourly, rate, amounting in all to the |
sum of $3,296.51. , "i
- That plaintiff, P..N. Harris, alleges that during the
one from May 31, 1942 to March 10, 1945, he was em-
ployed by defendant as a safety man‘atea base’ pay, of
| $46.19 per week for a-forty hour week to January 24,1043;
[fol 9} and FOL per week to Qetober 10, 145, -and
$110.77 per two weeks to.Qetober 24, 1945, and $128.77. per
twooweeks to Mareh 11, 1944, me ay! his regular hourly —
rate Was $1.10 per hour ‘to Jam M4, 1945, and $1.50
per hour to October 10, 1945, and $1.58 per hour to Octo-
her 24, 1943) and $1,61 per-hour to Mareh 11, 1944. > That
during all of said periods he was required to avork, 1211.1
~ hours overtime, that is to si, in exeess cof the applieable
maximum under Section 7 of the Act, for whith he was
entitled to he paid overtime eompensation at. the rate of
one and one-half times the aforesaid regnlar hourly rate,
nmounting in all to the sam of $2,550.70.
4. That plaintit J. Tyler, alleges that during the
perio Ni ‘am, April 14, ee to August ot, 1945, he was
-emploved by defendant asa safety man atia base pay of
$46.15 per week for a forty hour wk to June 14, 1942,,
and $01.92 per week to June, 1945, and $97.69 per week .
to, Auey- 120, 194 and that his regular hourly rate was
S110 per hour te June 14. 194. and $1.30 per hour te
June 6. 19S and bad per hour to Anmenst 29, 1945. That
during all of said periods he was required to work (142.8
hours evertine; that is to say, in-exvess 6f the appheable
leaxiniin under Section 7 of the Net, for which he was
entitled to be paid overtime conmensation at the rate of
cone and one-half times the -aferesaid applicable regular
Chonrlyorate, aimonnting dnalloto the sam of FRAT 7 :
. ao Saget
ad wand aS
i.
4g
5.. That plaintiff, J.C. Marshall, alleges that during the |
“period frow. January 3, 1943 to August: 28, 1945, he was
employed hy defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
$46.15 per week for a forty hour week to August 29, 1945,
ind that his’ regular hourly rate Was $1.15 per hour to
August 20, 1943.. That daring all of said periods he was
[fol 10] required to work 160.3 hours overtime, that ‘is to
sayin excess of the applicable maximum under Section 7
of the Act, for which he was entitled to be. paid overtime
compensation at fle rate -of one. and one-half times the
aforesaid applicable revuhor hourly rate, amounting in all
to the sim- of F FLTUSG.
That plaintiff, A. W. MeClaing, alleges that. during ~
hig period from Nove ‘maiber 21, W453 tasSeptember 10, 1944,
he was eniploved by defendant as a safety man.at a base
pay of $48.60 per week fora forty .hour week to Septerm-
ber 10) V44, and that his regular hourly rate was $1.21
per hour to September 10, 144. That during: all o@aid .
yw riods he was required to work 487.8 hours o®ertune, that
iste sayy in excess of the applic ‘able maximaun ander See-
tion Trot the, Net, for, aes he was entithed to he paid
overtime compensation at the rate of one and one-half
times the aforesaid app igalle reguli iY hourly rate, amount-
ine in all to the stn Gf RSTRH. “¢
7. That plaintiff. G. UL. coe alleges that’during the
period from Mareh 1, 1945 to Angust 17 140, he was
emploved by defendant asa safety man at a base pay of
$51.92 per week for a forty hour week to October 3, 1945,
dnd $55:98 per week to February d, 1945, and that his:
reemlar hourly rate was $1.00 per hour to October 3, 1948,
and &1.°8 per hone 40 Febru: wy 2, 1995. That during all
of siti periods he w tix reanire “d tay work 106. 6 hours ove r-
— fime. that is te say. in exeess ef the applicable. maximum
under Seetion 7 of the Net, for whieli he was entitled to
he pate overtiine CONTPOUS: ation at the rate of one and one-
half times the aforesaid applicable regular boenoly rate,
mmounting inal te the sum of $2,064.87.
That plaintiff, Joe Reeves, alleges that during the
portion! freer are 14, 14? ta Mareh 10, 1945, he Was -eli-
,
Fs ‘hy
Am
10
°
(fol. 11] ployed bv ‘defendant as a safety, man at a’ hens -
“pay of $46. 1) per week for a forty hour week to January
24. 1948, and $51.92 per week to June 20; 1948, and $57.69
per week to “October 3,-1943, and $60.00 per week to Oc--
tober 24, 1945, and $128.77 per two weeks to February -13,
1944, and $138.46 per two weeks to March 11,- 1945, and
that his- regular hourly rate was $1.15 per-hour to Janu-
ary 2!, 1945—and $1230 per hour to June-20, 1943, and
$1.44 per hour to October 5, 1945, and $150 per hour to
October 24, 1945, and $1.61. per hour to February 13, 1944,
and $i.73 per tour to Mareh 11, .1945.. That during afl of
said periods he was required to work 1460.4. hours over-
time, that is to sav, in exeess of the applicable maximum
under Section 7. of the Act, for whieh he was entitled to.
be paid overtime —— at the rate of one and one-
half times the: aforesai
amounting in-all to the sum of $5,078.05" og
. Phat: pl: Lintiff, Herbert Hahn, alleges that during the
a fron April 13, 1943 to October 28, 1944, he was
‘employed by defendant as a‘safety man at a base pay ot
POLI per, week for a forty hour week to March 1f, 1943, |
and $7 69 per week to 4 Jetober, 3, 194: 3, ‘and $60.00 per
week to Mareh 12, 1944, and that his regular hourly rate
Was $1.30, soy hour to March 14, 1943, and $1.44 "per hour
applicable regular hourly Fate,” ”
to Oc dobar” . 1943. and $1.50 per hour to Mareh 12, 1944.
That ictee ‘all of said periods he was réquired: to work
1136.4 hours. oveftime, that’is to say, im excess of- the ap-
plicable maxiniun under Section 7 of the Act, for which
he was entitled to he paid vvertime compensation at the
rate of one and one-half times the aforesaid applicable
regular dicurly rate, amounting in all to ‘the sum- of
$2,207.64. |
10.° That + paint, ae W. Myers, alleges, that dnving the
period from Aprif 22, 1942 to Mareh 11, 1944, he was em-
[fol 12] plowed by- defendant as a safety pran ata base -
pay of $46.15 per week for a forty hour week to October 3,—
1943; and $48.69 per week to October 24, 1945, and that
his-regular hourly rate was £1.15 per hour to Getober 3,
14S and SL21 per hour to October 24, 1943. That during —
all of said) periods he was required to work 377.8 hours
‘aa
a . aie neers | cae
G >),
overtime, ‘that is to say, in excess of rer applicable .maxi-
mum under Section 7 7 of the Act, for which he was entitled .
to be paid overtime compensation at the rate of. one and —
one-half times the applicable regular hourly” rate, amount-
ing in all.to the sum of $687.39.
11. That plaintiff, B. J. Ludwig, alleges that antae the:
' period ‘from November 1, 1941 to August 17, 1945, le was * |
employed by defendant as a safety man ata base pay of
$46.15 per week for a forty hour week to June 14, 1942, and
$91.92 per week to Febr uary 14,°1943, and $57.69 per week
ef
to October by baits aud £60.00 per week to, October 24,
1943, and: § 8.77 per two weeks to April 23, 1944, and
Z
$158.46 ae — weeks tv August 26, 1945, and that his —
‘regular hourly rate was $1.15 per hour Ao June 14, 1942,
and $1; 30 per hour to February 14, 19483, and $1.44 be
hour to October. 3, 1943 3, and $1.50 pox. hour to October 24
1943, and $1.61 per hour to April 03) 1944, and, $1.75 net
hour to August 26, 1945. That during all of sid periods i
he was required to work 1984.7 hours overtime, ‘that is to
say, in excess of the applicable maximum under Section 7°
of the Act, for which he was‘entitled to be paid overtime
compensation at the rate of one and one- half times the
aforesaid applicable regular. hourly rate, amountimg in all
to the sum of $4,506. OF. .
* 42. That plaintiff, Ik: L. Stockho, shee that during the |
period from, March 31, 1943: to August 17, 1945, he was
employ ed by defendant as a safety man at a base pay of.
$40.58 per week for a forty hour week to November 22,
1942, and $46.15 per week to Febru ry 21, 1948, and $51.92
[fol 13] per week to July 4, 1945, and $57.69 per week to
October 3, 1948, and $60.00 pér week to Octder 24, 1943,
and $128. 77 per two weeks to May @, 1944,: ‘and, $133.85 per
two weeks to August. 12, 145,and that ae regular. hourly
rate was $1.01 per hour to November 22, 1942, and $1.10
per hour to February 21, 1948, and $1.50 per hour to July
-4, 1945, and $1.44 pet hour to October 3: 1943, and $T- 00
per hour to October 24, 1945, and $1.61 .per hour to May 7,
1944, and $1.67 per hour to. August 12, 1945. That during
all of said periods he was required to work 1860.6 hours
overtime, that is tose in excess of the applicab re miaxi-
@
“NY
Laer)
12
imum under Seetion 7 r of the ‘Act, for which® he was ceiited
cto be paid overtime compensation at the rate of one and
we -half times the’ aforesaid applicable regular, hourly
ite, amounting in all to the sum Of $5,874.19:
13. That plaintiff, William Niedringhaus, ‘hieis that
during the perivd from April 20, 1942 to September 7,
1945, he was employed by defendant as a safety man at a>,
hase pay of $91.92. per week for a forty hour week. to ©
~ April 4, 1943, and $57.69 per week to October 3, 1943, and
$60.00 per week to\.October 24.1945, and $128.77 ‘per two
weeks: to May 9, 1944, and’ $69.23 per Week to Septem-
_ber 9, 1995, and that his regular Mourly: rate Was $1.30 per
-hour to April 4, 1948, and $1.44 per hour to. October 3,
1943, and a per hour to October 24, 1948, and $1.61
per hour. to May 9, 1944, and $1.73 per hour to September
9, 1945. That during all of said periods he was required .
to work 1859.2 hours overtime, that is to say, in excess of
the applicable maximum under Section 7 of the Act, for,
whieh he was entitled to be paid’ overtimie compensation
at the rate of ‘one and one-half times fhe aforesaid appli-..
cable regnlar hourly rate, amounting.in all to the sum of:
$4,163.69. ; ae
ffol. 14] 14. That plaintiff William Sais. alleges that
during the period froin June 7, 1943 to March 1, F945, he.
was employed by dfendant as a-safety man at a base. pay
of ' $126.92 }ier two weeks for a’ forty hour week to
October 10, 1943, and. $158.00 per two weeks te March 11,
* 1945, and that his regular hously rate was $1.586 per hour |
to October 10, 1943, and $1.73 per hour to Mareh 11, 1945.
Bs during’ all of said period he was required to work
348.1 hours overtimé, that .is to say, in excess of the ap-”
plicable maximum under Section 7 of the Act, for w hich .
he was entitled to be paid overtime compensation at the
rate of one and one-half times the aforesaid applig sable
“any
regular hourly rate, amounting in all ” —
£3, 321 97.
15. That plaintiff, S. P. Coley, alleges that. dyring the:
“period from December 17, 1941, to February 27, 1945, he’
was employed by defendant as a kafety man at a base pay
gf $51.92) per week ‘for a for th
hour week “to -October
10, 1943, and $110.77 per two weeks to November 19, 1944,
and $127.85.per two weeks to March 1, 1945, and that his
regular hourly rate was $1.50 per hour to Octobér 10, 19438,
and $1.38 per hour to November 19, 1944, ard $1.60 per
hour ta Mareli 11, 1945. That during all ot said perfods
he was required to work-1118.6 hours overtime, that is to
sav, in excess'of the applicable maximum under Section.
7 of the Act, for which he was entitled to: be paid over-.
time conipensation at the rate of one and one-half times .
the. aforesaid, applicable regular hourly rate, amounting -
in all to the sum of, $2,407 42. Peet es
16. That plaintiff, L. W. T: imble, alleges that dudian
the period: from Mareh 25, 1942,. to August 17, 1945,. he’
was employed by defendant.as a safety man at n_ base
pay of $46.15 per week for a forty hour week ta March
28, 1943, and) $51.92 per week to October. 38, 1948,
and $110.77 per two weeks to January .2; 1944, and
$117.69 per twa. “weeks to August 26, 1945, and that his
[fol. 15} regular hourly rate Was $1.15 per: hour to March
28, 1945, and $1.30 per hour to October 3, 1943, and $1.38
per hour. to January 2, 1944, and $1.47 per hour to August —
26, 1945. That during all of said ‘Periods he was required :
to work 1718.3 hours overtime, that-is-to. say, in excess
- of the applicable: maximum under Section 7 of the Act,
fer which, he was entitled to de paid overtime compen-.
sation at the Fate of one and one-half times the aforesaid
' appleable regular’ hourly rate, amounting in all to the sum
‘gt GAGS. .. 3 (
17. That plaintiff, R. M. Stewart, alleges that during
the period from February 21, 1942, to September 2 3, 1944,
.the was employed by, defendant as_a safety man at a base
pay of $46.15. per week for a forty hour week to’ June 14,
"1942, and $51.92 pér week to Marefi 141943, and! ‘$357.69
per week. to Oetoher 3; 194: 3, and S606 er week -to ‘No-.
vember 7, 1943, and $64, 38 per week to February 6, 1944,
and $69.25. per week te September 24, 1944, and that his
reeular hourly rate was $1.15 per-hour to June.14, 1942, .
and $1.30 per hour to March ‘14, 19438, and: $1.44 per
e to October 3, 1943, and $1.50 per hour to Nov ember
. 1943, and $1.61 per hour to February 6; 1944,.and $1.7:
ae hour te September 24, 1944. That during all of a
”
rf
a.
_ periods he Was required to. ule 1465.9 hours overtime,
that is to say, in'excess of the applic able maximum under
Seetion:7 of the Act, for which he was-entitled to be paid
overtime compensation -at the rate of one and one-half
times, the aforesaid applicable regulary heurly rate, ranount-
“ing invall to the sum of $3,082.48. :
18. That plaintiff, B. H. Hargate, alleges that during .
- the period from January 13, 1942, to August 31, 145, he
was employed by defendant as a safciy man at a base pay
of $46.15 per week for-a forty hour week {8 January 24,
1945,*and $51.92 per week fo October 3, 1945, and $110.77.
per tWo weeks to September 23, 1945, and that Mis regular
(fol. 16] hourly rate was $1.09 per hour to June 14, 1942,
and $1.15 per hour to January 24,° 1948, and $1.50 per
hour to October 3, 1948, and $1.38 per hour to September
23, 1945. That during all of said periods he was reauired.
. “ o . S + e yet .
to work 2074.2 hours overtime, that is to say, in excess.
'. of the ‘applicable maxtmum under Section’ 7° of ‘the. Act,
for which he was entitled to be. paid. Geirtine compensa-
tion Wt the rate of one and one-half, times. the aforesitd
applicable regular hourly ‘rate, amounting in all to the Sim
; of $3,873.17.
| . That plaintiff, J. Ss. Schucidor: , alleges that ‘during
tHe period from Jane 20; 1943, to September 15, 1945, ‘he
was employéd by defendant as a safety-man at a Dase pay
of $46.15. per week for a forty hour “week ‘toe October. 10,
1943, and. $97.58 per two weeks to’ June 4, 1944, and
$108.92 per two weeks. to, February 25; 1945, and $127.85
per two weeks to September 25, 1945, and that his regylar
hourly rate was $1.15 per hour. to October 10, 1945, and
$1.21 per -hour to June “4, 1944, and $1.56. per “haur to
February 29, 1945, and $1.69 per hour to September 23,
1945. That during-all of: said periods - he was required to
work 955.3 hours overtime, that is to say, in excess of the
applicable yaximum tinder Section 7of the Act, for which ~
che was entitled‘ to be paid overtime compensation at: the
rate of one and one-half fi) s the aforesaid applicalle
regularly . hourly “date, dmoun.ing in all to, the sum ‘of
41,700.70.
20; That ‘wal: ‘Walter Gorg, ¥ i vr ee that duting
the. period from February 14, 1! ‘at, to. pandary: 3 . 1944, he
\
‘Ene. 7S eA Be
. | 18
was employed by detomdunit hs a sate ty, man at a; base
pay of $46.10 per week for a forty hour week to May 30,
1943, and $51.92 pur week to, Dec ‘tober 3, 1943. dnd $55.38
. per week to January 16, 1944, and that his regular hourly
rate was $1.15 pe Y hour to May 36, 1943 , and $1.50 per
‘hour:to: October 3, 1943. and $1.38 per hour ‘to Janaary 16,
[fol 17] 1944. That during all gfsaid perieds he was re-
quired to work 450.2 hours overtime, that is to say, in éx-
ess of the applicable maximum under Se ction J of the Act,
for whichche Was entitled to be paid overtime. compensation
ut the rate,of one and jine. half times the aforesaid apypli-
. cable regular hourly rate, anfonnting in.all to the smn of:
S87 1.67. é a
21. That.’ ‘il ee. Bs. MM. Casey alleges that Garing the
period from July 4,.1943 to-Mareh 11, 1944, he was em.
ployed by defendant as a‘safety man at a *base pay of
| $4013 ) per week for a forty honréweek to October 3, 1945, °
and $48.69 per week. to October 24, 1949, and $104.77 per
two weeks te Mareli 12, 1944, and that, his regular hourly |
rate ‘wus $1.15 per hour to October 3, 1943, and $1:21 per:
hour to Octoher 24,4943, and $1.51 per hon: to March 12,
1944. That: during a!l of said periods he was. required to
work 315.2 lidurs overtime, that is to say, In excess of the
applicable maxHuyn under Section 7 éf the Act, for which |
he. was entitled to be paid evertime: compensation at the-
rate of one and. one-half times the aforesaid applicable
regular wogery rate, amounfing in all to the sum of $544.01.
_ That niaiptiff AL OWL Erickson, alleges: that durin me
ae oie from May 11, 1942 to March #, 1945, he was
employed by defendant as a saféty man at a base | pay of
$46.15 per week for a forty hour. w eck to June 14, 1942, and:
$51. 92 per week to Ma: ch 14, 1948, and that his regular.
hourly rate was $1.15 -per hour to June 14, 1942,. and $1. 30.
per hour to March 14, 1945. That during all of said periods
he was required te work 530.2 hours overtime, that is to
say, in excess of the applicable maximum under’ Section 7
of the AXet, for which he was entitled to be paid overtime
' (fol. 184 compensation at the rate of one and one- -half times
‘the aforesaid applicable regular hourly rate, amounting in |
all'to the sum of $1,027.74,” <4
16 bee fe \ | |
on That plaintiff, Klner Maher, alleges that during the
period from December iv, 1941 to February 12, 1944, he
was employed by defend lant asa safety man at-a base pay
of $4615 per wytk fora forty hour week to June 14, 1942,
and $97.69 pef week to June 6, 1943, and 4126.92 per two.
weeks to O¢tober 10, 1945, and $158.00 Her two weeks to
February 15, 1944. and that his*regulaky hourly rate was
Si.15 per hour to June 14, 1942, and $1.44\per hour to, Juné
fH, F943, and $1.58 per hour to October 19, 1943, ge cage
per hour ie Seeves 13, 1944. That duriwe all .of said
re sriods he was required to work: 1271 hours ie tiime, that
into say, in excess of the applicable maXximuln under See-
tion 7 of the Act, for which he was entitled to be paid over-
little compensation at the rate of one and one-half. times
the aforesaid applicable regular hourly rate,, amounting
in all to the sum of 82,673.95,
That’ pli Linitift, ‘Kinett Hoskth’, a“ that during:
the wgteeor frone January 1, 1942 to January. 28, 1944, he
Was employed by defegdant as a safoty man ata base pay
of $45.15 pey week for a forty hour week to June 14, 1942,
cand 04.92 per week to April 4,15 W3 3, and $97.69 per week
“to Ovtober 3, Vs 43 , and $60.00 ° per week to October 24, 1943,
and $128.77 per two weeks to Jgafuary o0; 1944, ‘and that -
his regular hourly rate was $1.15 per hour to June 14,
1942, and $1.50 per hour ‘to April 4, 1943, and: $1.44 per
hour to Qe tober 3, 1943, and $1.50 per hour to Oetober 24,
1943. and $1.61 per hour to January 30, 1944, ‘That during -
all of said: periods he was required to. work 1094.2 hours
DM rtime, that is tovsay, in excess of the applicable maxi-
tum under Sevtion % of the Act, for which he was entitled
[ fol. 19] to be paid’ évertime campcnaation at the rate of
ene amd one-half times the aforesaid avpleable® regular
hourly rate, amounting in all to $2,088.29,
That plaintif, F. P. Wnight, siteies that during the
pe siod from January’ 23, 1942 to “September 12, 1943, “he
Was emploved by defendant as a safety manvat a base pay
oot S46.15 pred week for a forty hour. ‘week to June 14, 1942,
and So1.02 per week to March 14, 1948, and $57.69 per
aveek to September 12, 145, and that his regular hourly :
rate wars SED per hour to Sune 14, 1942, and $1.30 per |
ss
ca
. 17
3 .
cue to ML oh 14,1945, an $1.44 per hour to September
12, 1943. That during all of said periods he was required
to work 919.6 -hours overtime, that is to say,-in excess of
the applicable maximum’ under Section 7 ‘Of the Act, for
which he was entitled to be paid overtime compensation at
the rate of one and one-half times the aforesaid applicable
reeular hourly rate, amounting in all to the sum of
$1,952.03. | Oe.
26. That plaintiil, Ro AL Westra, alleges that during the
period from Marche 16, 1942 to February 26, 1945, he was
employed by defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
46.15 sper week fora forty hour week to June 14, 1942, and
$51.92 per week to February 28, 1943, and that his regular
hourly rate was $1.15 fer hour to June 14, 1942, and $1.30
per hour to February 28, 1943. That during all. of: said.
periods he was required to work 603 hours overtime;-that
ix to-say, in exgess of the applicable maximum under See-
“tion 7 of the Act, for which he was entitled to be paid over-
time ¢ compensation at the rate of one and one-half times”
the aforesaid applicablé regular hourly rate amounting m
all to the sum of $1,158.59. ee ee
27. That plaintiff, D. F. ‘Bateman, alleges that during
the period from March 29,4943 to June 1, 1944, he was em-
[fol. 20] ployed by defendant as a. safety manat a base.
pay of $46.15 persweek for a forty hour week to October
10, 1943, and $97.38 per two weeks to January 1, 1944, and
$101.07 per two w Hie to June 4, 1944. and that his regular
-hourly rate was $1.15 per hour to October 10, 1943, and
$1.21 per hour to yar 2, 1944, and $1.31 per hour to
June 4, 1944. That during all of said periods he was re-.-
quired to work 71.2.hhours. overtime, that “is to say, in
excess of the applicable maximum under: Section 7 of the
Act, for which he was entitled to be paid overtime com-_
pensation at the rate of one and one-half times the afore=:
said; applicable regular hoarly rate, arhounting in all to
~ the sum of 926,40.
28, That plaintiff, Al Herman, alleges that during the
‘period from January 1, 1943 to September 12, 1943, he was
employed by: defendant as aw safety man at a base pay of
18
2
$46.15 per week for a forty bee week to. ‘Soult 4, 1945, and
$51 92 per week to Se ptember. 12, 1943, and that his regu’ar
hourly rate was $U15. per hour to April 4, 1943, and $1.30
per lrour to September 12, 1943. That during all of said
periods he was required to work 351 hours overtime, that
[fol 21} is to say in excess of the applicable maximum
under Section 7 of the Act, for Which he was entitled to be
paid ove tinue Compe nsation at the rate of one. and one-
half timeS the aforesaid applicable regular hourly. -rate,
amounting in all te the sume of $659.36. 0: ,
The plaintiff, George Burmeister, alleges that during
‘as. nee from May 1, 1942 toJuly 24, 1943, he-was em-
ployed ty defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
$91.92 per week for a forty hour week to February 2,
1945, and $57.69 per week to July -25,°1949, and that his
regular hourty rate Was $1.50 per hour to February 2k,
1945, and $144 per hour to July 25, 1943. That during ail
of said periods le was required to work 857.6 hours over-
time, that ix to say, in excess of the applicable maximum
under Section 7 of the Act, for which he was entitled to be
paid overtime compensation at the rate of one and ‘one-
half times the aforesaid: applicable regular hourly, rate, _
sunounting In gill to the sum of $1,690.10,
OO. That plaintiff, Ge B. Darby, alleges that during’ the
period from Marek 20; i945, to: August 31, 1945, he was
employed by defendant as a safety -man at: 1 base pay of
$51.92 Sper week for a forty hour week fo October 3 8, 1948,
aml $59.58 per week to November 7, 1943, and $120.00 per
two wesks to Aneust 1, 1g, and that his regular hourly .
rate was $1.50 per houy to October 8, 1943, and $1.38 per
hour to November 7, 1945,-and $1. 50 nee hour to August 9,
1945. That. during all of said periods he was-required. to
work 1246.2 honrs overtime, afhrat ix to say, in excess of the
apphieable mi apg under Section 7 of the Aet, for which
he Was entitled to be paid overtinie compensation at the
‘rate of one and one-half times the: aforesaid applicable
reenlar. hourly rate, amounting “in all té the: sum of
& 572.05. . eee ©
{foi 22] 31. That plaint@l, Ro BL Jenniches, dlleges that
dtfting the period from: Pune oy. 1942 tea December 28, 1942,
oo ae
he was emploved by defendant as a safety man at a’ base |
pay of $51.92 per week fora forty hour week to January 3,
1943, and, that his reguler hourly rate was $1.30 per hour
to January 3, 1043. ‘That during all of said ‘period he was
required to work $623,3 hours overtime, that is to say, in
excess of the applicable maxima under Section 7 of the
Act, for which he was entitled to be paid overtime com-
pensation at the rate of one and one- half times the afore,
said ge peon ye revular hourly rate, amounting in all to the’
sun of $703, Osh. . @
“32. That vlaintift, J. . Sehiwartz, alleges that during the
period frou: January "4 ghee to June ven 1044, he was em-
ployed by defendant as.a satety luan ata base pay of
POLY per weelk for a. fons shour week to October 10, 1945,
and $110.77 per two weeks to June 18, 1944, and that his.
regular hourly rate was $1.30 per hour to October 16, 1945,
aid $1.38. per hour, to June 18, 1944.0 That during all of
said periods | he Was required to work 802.7 hours: “Oyer-
time, that is to say, in excess of the applicabie maximum
“under Section 7 of the Act, for which he was entitled to be
paid overtime compel usation- at the rate of one and one-
half times the aforesaid applicable regular hourly rate,
amounting in all to the sum of $1,990.14.
33. That plamtuff, tae Kemp, pile that during the
period from December 23, 1941 to September 16, 1944, he
was employed by defendant as a safety man ata base pay
of $46.15 per we wk fora forty hour week to June 14, 1942,
and $97.69 per week to January 10, 1943, and $126.92 per
two weeks to April 25, 1943, and $138.46 per-two weeks
to September. 24, 1944, and that his regular hourly rate
was $1.15 per hour to June 14, 1942, atid $144 per, hour-
to January 10, 1945, and $l.o85 per Jiour to April 25, (1943,
[fol. 25] and $1.73 per hour to September 24, 1944. That
during allot said periods he was required to work 162 9.3
hours overtime, that is to-say, in excess of the appliaable
maximum under Seetion 7 of the Act, for rth he was en-
titled to be paid ov ertime compensation at the rate of one
and one-half’ times ‘the aforesaid applicable regular hourly
rate, amounting in all tthe sum of $3,713.28, .
7 a
-o4. That pla aintiff, Byron Yancey, alleges that during che
period from July 3, 1942 to March 19, 1945, he was em-
ployed by defendant as a safety man. at a base pay of
$46.15 ).perweek for a forty hour week to July 4, 1943, and
$51.92 per week to November 7, 1945, and $12 28.77 per two
wecke to July 16, 1944, and $138.46 per two weeks to
March 11, 145, and that tis regular hourly rate was $1.15
per hour to Jaly 4, 1943, and $1.50-per honr to November
7, 1943, And $1.61 ner hour io July 16, 1944, and $1.73 per
hour to Mareh 11, 1945. That during all of said periods he
was required to work 989.7 hours overtime, that is.to say,
in excess of the applicable maximum under Section ¢ of
the Act, for which he was entitled to be paid overtime
compensation at the rate-of che and one-half times the: -
aforesaid applicable re vular hourly rate, amounting” in all
to the sum. of $2,082.05
That plaintifY, J. Ds ¢ ‘avanaingh, alleges that during
the eave from May 7, 1942, to June 15, 1944, he. was em-
- ploved by defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
SOL.92 per week, fer ic forty hour week -to. February: 14,
1943, and $57.69 per week to October 10, 1945, and $120.00
per two weeks to October ‘24, 1945, and $128.77. per two
‘weeks to June US, 1944, and tliat his regular hourly rate
_Whs $1.30 per hour to February 14, 1945, and $1.44 per hour .
to October 10, 1943, and $1.50 per hour to October 24, 1945, —
and $1.61 per hour to June 18, 1944. That during all of
said periods he was required to*°work 1251.3 hours over-
time, that is to say,-in exeess of the applieable maximuin
[fol. 24] under Section 7 of the Act, for which’ he was en,
titled to be paid overtime compensation at the rate of one
and one-half times the aforesaid applicable regular hourly
rate, amounting in all to the sum of $2,629.64. =
That plaintiff, W. F. O*Meara, alleges that ‘during
the neil froni May 2, 1942 to October 5, 1945, he was em-
ployed by defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
$46.15 per week fora forty honr week to January 24, 1943,
and $51.92 per. week to Marel 21, 1945, and $57.69 per |
‘week to Jime 27, 1943, and $126.92 per two’ weeks to
October 10, 1942, and $158.00. per two weeks to October 7,
1945, and that his regular heurly rate was $1.10 per hour
. ? ”]
to January 24, 1945, and $1.50 per hour to Mareh 21. 1945,
and’ S194 per hour to Jnne a S43, afd S1O85 per hour to
October 1a, 1943, and S125 per hour to October 7, 1045.
That during all of said — hie was required .to wark |
2294.2 hours overtime, that is to say, in excess of the ap-
plicable maximuny under Section 7 of the Net, for which he
was entitled te be paid overtime compensation at the rate
af one and one-half times thevaforesaid applicable regular
hourly rate. ginounting in all to the sumof $5,084.61,
“half times. the aforesaid applicable
(fol. 25] 37. That plaintiff, R.«Carbone, alleges that during —
the period frem March 29, 1943 to October 9, 1943, he-was
employed by defendant as a satety man ata base pay of
$91 2 per week for a forty hour week to October 5, 1948,
9
and $55.38 per week to October 10,1943, and that his.
regular hourly rate was $1.30 per hour to October 3, 1943,
and $1.88 per hour to October 10, 1943. That. during: ail
of said periods he was required to work 334.3 hours over-
time, that is to say, in excess of the appheable maximuni
under Section 7 of the Act, for which fle was entitled to
be paid overtime compensation at the rdte of one and one-
Tegular hourly rate,
amounting in all to the sum of $651.83.
38. That plaintiff, W. A. Broad, alleges that during tlie
period from June 25, 1948 to December 11, 1943, he was em-
ployed by defendant as.a safety man at a hase pay of
$46.15 per week for a-forty hour week to October 3, 1948,
and $48.69 per week to December 19, 1943, and -that> his
~regniar hourly rate was $1.15 per hour to October 3, 1943, . |
and $1:21 per hour to December 19, 1943. That during all
of said periods he was required to work 257.2 hours over- -.
time, that is to say, in exeess of the applicable maximum
under Secfion 7 of the Act, for which dhe was entitled to be.
lapid] overtime coripensation at.the rate of one and one-
half times the aforesaid applicable regular hourly rate,
amounting in all to the sum of $466.94. +
39, That plaintiff, «. 1. Valei, alleges that during the
period from July 16, 1942 to September. 15, 1945, he was
employed by defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
$46.15 per week for a forty hour week to Febrnary 24, 1943,
and $ $51.92 per w eek to October 19, 1943, and “2 28.77% per
two weeks to May 6.1945, and $138.46 per two weeks to
noo
TD
[ fol. 2G; | Sept. i ae 45, and that dus regular hourly
rate. was $1.15-per hour to February 21, 1943, and $1.30 per
“Hour to Octoher 10, 1943, and $1.61 per hour to May 6,
1945, and $1.67 per hour to September 28, 1945. That, dur-
“ing all af said periods he was required ‘to work. 1428.5
hours overtime, that is to say, in excess of the applie¢ able
maximum under Section 7 of the Act, for whieh he was
-entitled to be paid overtime compensation at the rate of
oue andr onezhalf times the aforesaid applicable regular
hourly rate, amounting in all to the sum of #3,230.80.
That plaintiff, Mike Malloy, alleged that during the
ore from December 27, 1942, to October 24, 1945, he was _
employed: by defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
~ 15 per week for a forty honr week to October 3, 1943,
ind $47.02 per weck to October 24, 1943, and that his regu-
"vn howrly rate was $1.15 per hour to October 3, 1943, and
$1.21 per hour to October 24, 1945.) That during all of satid
per iods he was. required to work 268.2 hours overtime, that
‘- is fo say, in excess of the applicable mi: iximum under See-
tion 7 of the Act, for which he was entitied to be paid over-
time compensation at tne rate of one and one-half times
the aforesaid’ applicable regular hourly rate, améunting in
all to the sum of $640.47.
41. That plaintiff, Russell Barnett, alleges that during
the period from April 28, 1942 to February 11, 1945; he was
employed by defendant as a safety man at a base pay’ of
$46.15 per week for a foriy hour week to June 14, 1942
vand $51.92. per week to April 4, 1942, and $57.69. per week:
to Cetcher 2 8, 1943, and $60.00 per week ta October 24, 1945,
and $12 8.0 per two weeks to February 13, 1944, and
$120.00 per two weeks to February 11, 1945, and that his
regular howrly. rate was $1.10 per hour to «une 14, 1942,
and $1.80 per hour to April 4; 1945, and? $144 per hour
[fol. 27] to October 3, 1945, and $1.50 per hour to October
94, 1945, and $1.615 per hour to February 13, 1944, and
$1.50. per hour to February 11,.1945. That during all of
said periods he was required to work 1633.6 hours over-_
‘time, that is fo say, in excess of the applicable maximum
under Section 7 of the Act. for which he was entitled to be
paiT overtime cofnpensation at the rate of one and ene-
half times the aforesaid nie yee regular hourly rate,
= 7)
amounting in all to the sum of $3,585.7".
42. That plaintiff, William Hirschberger, alleges that
during the period from August 10, 142, to duly 8, 1944, he
was employed by defendant a&
Rau Safety man at ps pay
+ 4 y
of $51.92 per week for a tort ey OUT week. td Apyl 4, 1943,
and $57.60 per week to July IS1043, and $1.73 gr hour to
July 16, 1944.0 That during all of said periods he was re-
‘quired to work 979.5 hours overtime, that is to say, in ex-
cess of the applicable maximum under Section 7 ef the
Act, for which he was entitled to be paid overtime com.
pensation at the rate ef one and one-half times the afote-
said applicalie regular hourly rate, amounting in all to the
4
sum of $2,075.40. «ee oF sates moe cee tes
43. That plaintiff, Frank Connell, alleges that during the
period from June 22, 1942, to August 4, 1943, he, was eim-
ployed by defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
$51.92 per week for a forty hour week to February 28, 1945,
and $57.69 per week to August 1, 1943, and that liis regular
hourly rate: Was ‘$1.30 per hour, to ‘February 28) 1943, and
$1.44 per hour to Avieust 1, 1943. That during all of said
periods he was required.to work 813.6 hours overtime, that
is to say, in excess of the applicable maximum under See-
tien 7 af the Act, for which he was entitled to be paid over-
time compensation at the rate of one and one-half times
the aforesaid applicable regular hourly rate, amounting in —
all to the sum of $1,644.28:
* 44. That plaintiff, Floy L. Jennings, alleges that during
the period from April 6, 1942.to Mareh 31, 1944, he was
employed. by defendant as a safety man at ar hase pay of
$51.92 per week for a forty hour week to July 4, 1943, and
$57.69 per week to October’24, 1943, and $120.00 per two
[fotr2stweeks ta dpril 9, 1944, and.that his regular hourly
rate was $1.30 per hour to July 4, 19438, and $1.44 per hour
to October 24,1943, and. $1.50 per hour to April 9, 1944.
That during all of said periods he was required to work
1112 hours overtime, that is to say, in excess of the appli-
cable maxifium: under Section 7 of the Act, for which he
" was entitled to be paid overtime compensatignart the rate
of one and one-half times the aforesaid apgiicable hourly
- rate, amounting in all to the sum of $2,246N1. °,
45. That plaintiff, Sterlitig Cook, alieges that during the-
period from Febrnary 10, 1942 to Mareh 31, 1944. he was.
i)
4 . : ? | : 7
emplWed by defendant as a safety mai at a. base pay of
$45.15 per week‘for a forty hour week to June 14, 1942,
and $51.92 per week to March 28, 1942, and $57.69 per week
to’ October 10, 1944 and $120.00 per two weeks to October
4, 1943. and $128.77 per two wee to April 9 M44, and
that his regular hourly rate -was $1.15 per‘hour to June 14,
D942 and SEDO per hour to Mareh 28, 194) and $h44 per:
hour to"Qetober LO, 143, and $1.50 per hour to October 24,
143, and? $61 per hour to April?, 1944. That during all
or said periods he Wiis required to work L280.7 hours dover.
Jfol 29] thue, that is to say, if) @XCess of the applicable
_Jnaxiinutn arider Seetion 7 of the Net, for whieh he was:
ented To hee pebdoxvertime compensation ad the rate. of
one cand one-half tines the aforesaid applicable reguiar
hourly rate, aounting ino all te the sumoof $2 500F 49,
468. That plaintiff, Clit Chainpoon, alleges that during
the period from April 21, 1942, to Inne 7, 1944, he was em
plived be defendant as a safety man at a base pay of
S512 per week for a forty hour week to Feb. 7, 1945, and
$57.60 per week to Sept. 12, 1943, and S126.02 per two
weeks to October 10, 1945, ane F1OS.0 per two weeks to
June 4, 1944, anid that lis regular houriv rate was $1.50 per
hour to February 7, 1945, and S144 per hour te September
12, 1945, and $1.585 per hour to October 10, 1945, and $1.75
per hour to June 4, 1944. That during all of said periods -
he was required to work 1414.1 hours overtime, that ix to
sav, in excess of the applicable maximum under Section 7
of the Act, for which he was entitled to be paid oyestime
compensation at the rate of one and? onechalf times the.
aforesaid applicable regutar hourly rate, amounting in all
‘to the sum of $3,102.61. |
47. That plaintiff Don Burke, alleges that during the
period from: April 16, 1942 to October 25, 1942 and from
December 14, 1942 to Apreh 20, TOES) he was emploved by
defendant as asgfety manat.a base pay of $46.15 per week
fora forty hour week to April 20, 1945, and that his regu
lar hourly rate was $1.15 per hour to April 25, 1945. That
during all of said periods he was required to work 419.9
hours overtime, that is te say, in excess of the applicable *
maxim under Seetien 7 of the Net, for whielh he was.
entitled too be paid overtime compensation at thi rate of
s)*
*
one and Gne-half times the aforesaid applicable’ regular
hourly rate, amounting ip all to the sum -of S751. a.
[tol 30 | 48. That plaintiff, WoC. Viehimanny adleces that
a aluring the bert bicnd bray Janiiars q M442 te April oes A4,
lies Wits tech iss dete: wdatit as a salety tain ata heise
pay Ob ROE per Week for woterty hour weed te Ob ober 3,
S| penser per twe weeks to April 22) 140. and
that bis regular hourly rate was S130 per hour to OQete
Do ae a and SLOSS per how. to April 22. 1459. That
during ali of =e paornands hie Wiis reamined te work 728.1] 5
howrs-sovertinie, that is te sayy in exeess of the applicable
hia tenin Under Sertion 7 oof the Net, for whiels Ae Wiis
eutitted te lee pute Ove rine compensation at the rate of
one qnd ane tint tes the diteresaid applicable regular
hourly rate, wane Ne an all to the sumo of SPAS2 62,
$0.-That plaintiff, PLM, Kercheval, allege? that during
the period fron: November 207 1442.te Nas ust, Pos be
Was emplosed be défendant asa safety mao ata base pray
Po S40.1 per week fora forts hour week oo Februery 21,
1! 43 », and si 3a per week ta th tol: wr TO. Tah. and STD TT
per two weeks to Oe tabes ps Fi eS, and S1T28.77 0 per two
weeks to Aprils, 14h and SISSS per two weeks to An
wast PQ, bo, and that lis regular hourly rate was S115
per fren u to Febru: ary 21.1 M43. and Sb o0 per hour ta Oto.
her TOTORS, and =b44 por hour te Qetober 24, 1948 and
£1.00 per hour to April S. 1945, and $1.68 per hour te Au
cust PESO. ‘That during all of said) pertods he was
quired to work 140). Hiones overtime, that is to SAV, Se
excess of the applicable maXinurm tinder Section 7 of the:
Act, for whieh he was entitled te he paid overtime eat.
pensation at the rate of one and ont half tines the afore.
suid applicable regular heurly rate. amadunting im all te
othe stim af 8.1 47.7%. : ;
That plaintif, Guy Croce. alleges that during the
period from June 2 Ta? te Mareh TO. P43) he was etn
LYol STL played by defendant asa safety man at achase pay
of $OLO2 per week for a forty hour week to Mareh Uy,
143) and that las reenlar hourly rate Was $1.50, per hour,
to M: areh D4, 1843 That during.all of said) period he-wns
reeves | te work yer » hours avertime, that is to San, ini
=
a : -
-?
=
- excess of the “applicable maxim under Section 7 of the
Act, for which he was entitled to be- paid overtime Corti
pensation at the rate of one and one-half times the afore-
said applicable recular hourly rate, amounting in all to
the sum of #79200.
ol. That plaintiff, Ro Baxter, atlefes that during. the
period: fren January 14, 1942 to. October TH, 1948, he was |
employed by defendant as a satety man ‘ta base pay of
S46.15 per week for a forty hour week to June MO, T9AG,
and SOLO? per week to Qetober 10, 1943, and S50.58) per
week to October 24,1945, and that bis regular hourdy rate
was $1.15 per hour to June 2H, 1948, and $1.30 per hour,
to October 10, 1945, and $1.58 per hour to October L4,-
1943. That dnring all of said periods he was required to
work 318.6 hours overtinie, that is ta say, in eXeess of the
applicable maxim under Section 7 of the Act, for which
le Was entitled to be paid overtime compensation at the
rate of one and one-half times the aforesaid applicable
-reenlar hourly rate, amounting in all to the suni of $579,108.
52. The plaintiff, N.C) Walther, allewes that during the
period from April dl, 142 to June 24, 1944, he was em-
ploved by defendant asa safety man oat a base pay of
$45.15 per week for a forty leur week to June 14, 1942,
and $591.02 per week to dune 6. 1945, and $57.69 per week
to October 10, 143. and SPZO.00 peretwo Weeks to Juiy 2, .
1944. and that his regular hourly rate was S115 per hour
to June 14, 1942. and $41.30 per hour to June 6, 145,
and $1.44 per tour to Oetober TO, 145, and $1.50) per
hour to July 2 44. That during all of said periods’ he
was required to Work “PO90,2 hours overtime, that is to
esav, in excess of the applicalite minim under Section 7
ffol. 32] of the Net, for, whieh he was entitled to he paid
overtine compensation at the rate ot cone and one half |
times the aforesaid applicable regular hourly rate, amount -
ine in all to The sum of SD 21S 31.
a3. ‘Phat plaintiff, George Gillen, alle ces that during the
period frei Oeteber 25. 1O4T to Ovetohber 5, 14S, Te was
emploved by detendant as a safety mai at a hase pay ot:
M615 per week fora forty hour week ‘to Jannary 24, 1943;
ind $57.02 ner. week te October 3, 1420 and that) lias.
7 >i
,
7
I
reeular héurly rate was $1.15 per hour to January 24,
143, and $1.50 pyer brour to Octaber 3, 1945... That during.
all of said) periods he was-required: to work 754.9 hours
overtime, that is to say, in exeess of the applieable WHNI-
min under Section @ ef the Act, for which he was entitled
to be Paid overtime compensation at the rate of one and
one-half tives the aforesaid applicable reyvular hougty rate,
amounting in all te the sum of $1,046.08, ae te
v4, That plaintiff, dames Volllrecht, alleges that during
the period frum November 29) 1942 to December 50, 1943, -
che was employed by defendant as a safety man ata base —
pay of $46.15 per week for a forty hour week to Febriary |
21. 1942, and $51.92 per week to October 10, 1943, and
S88 per week to January 2 1944, and that his regular °
hourly rate was $1.15 per hour to February 21, 1942, and.
"$1.30 per hour to October 10, 1943,tand $1.58 per hour to:
January 2, 44. That during all of, said periods he was
‘required to work 604.7. hours overtime, that is to say, in.
exgess of the applicableg@maximum under Section 7 of. the
Aet, for which he was entitled ‘to be paid overtime com-
pensation at the rate of one and one-half times the afore-
said applicable regular hourly rate, amounting. in all to
the sum of 7S NS a a,
nd. That plaintiff, Ro J. Peterson, alleges that during
“thegperiod from April 25, 142 to Aneust 18, 1945, he was
emploved by defendant as a safety man at a base ~pay
of $46.19 per week for a forty hour week to February 21,
1943. and $51.2 per week to Oetober 3.1948, and $55.58
(Yoh 38] per week to November 7, 143, and $128.77 per two
weeks to Npril 9, 1944, and $158.46. per two weeks to De-
eember 3). 944, and £147.69 per two week. to August 26,
1945, and-that his rezylar hourly rate was $1.1 per hour
to Febroary.20, 1943 and S100 per hour to October 3, 1945,
and S108 per hour to. November 7, 1945, and $1.61 per hour
to Aprul 9, 144. and S175 per hour to Deeembere 3, 1944,
and S184 per hour to August 26,1945. That during all oft
-nid periods he was required to work 1705.6 hours pver-
time, that is ta say, in excess of the applicable maximum
under Section 7 of the Aet, for whieh he@vas entitled te
he paid otertine compensation at the rate of one and one
»
caer
<a
‘
“98 J a : ay Tae ae ‘ 4
half times the aforesaid eageg™ le regular hourly rate, |
amounting tr all to the sum of $3,977.02.
56. That plaintiff, Jack DeLar wy, alleges that acing the
period from December 3, 1991 to August 6, 1945, he was
employed by defendant’as:a si afety Imanoat a base pay of
$51.92 per -week for a forty: hour week’ to January 24,
1943, and $57.69 per week to August 8; 1943, and that his
regular hourly rate was $1.30 per hour to January 24, 1945,
“and $144 per hour'to August 8, 1943. That. diring all of.
said per ‘ods he was required to work 992.5 Tiours ov ertime,
lat is to sav, In-exeess of the applicable Maximuny under
Section 7 of the Act, for whie h he was entitled to be paid
overtime compensation at the rate of one and one-half
times the aforesaid“applicable regular hourly rate, amount-
“ing in all to the sum of $2,006.87, 0
[ fol. 34] 57. That- plaintiff, Cc. eaaree ‘wes that during’ *
the period from April 5, 1948 to Novembér 18, 1944, he
was employed by defendant as a. safety man at a base
pay of $46.15 per week for a forty hour week to October
- 3, 1943, and $97.38 per, two weeks to’ November 21, 1943,
and $108.46 per two weeks to November 19, 1944, and that
his regular hourly rate was $1.15 per hour to October 3,
1943, and: $1.21 per. hour to November .21, 1943, and $1.35
per hour te November 19, 1944. That «during. all of said’
periods he was required to work 740.7 hours overtime, that
is to say, in excess of the applicable maximum under See-
tion 7 of the Act, for which he was entitled to be paid
overtime compensation ‘at the rate of one and one-half
times the afor esaid applic ‘able —— hourly rate, amownt
ing invall to the sum. of $1.59 Ps
58. That plaintiff, S. F. Peters, alleges that during the /
period from November: 30, 1942 to Jnme 20, 1943 he was
employed by defendant as a safety man ata base pay of.
$57.69 per week for a forty hour week to June 20, 145.
and that his regular: hourly rate was $144 per hour te
Jnne 20,1943. That -duriig all of said periods he wes
required to work 317.7 hours ay that is to say, in
excess of the applicable maximum under Section 7 of the.
Act, for which fia wis entitled to be’ paid overthine eam,
pensation at the rate of one and one-half times the afory
eet
Se ale Eee ee
ae, eae ahaa ng ear aaa
said applicable regular hourly rate, amounting ineall to
the suin of $689.24. : : 7 .
a? That. plaintiff, A. eres alleges that: during the
period frou, May 15; 1942 to April &, 1945; he was em-
ployed by deferidant as a safety man at a base pay of
— $51.92 per week for id forty hour week to Se ‘ptember 12,
1942, and $57.69 per week to June 6, 1943, and $126.92
per two weeks to October 10, 1943, and $138.00 per two
weeks to April 8,:1945, and that his regular hourly rate
$1.30 per hour to September 12, 1942, and $1.44 per hour
{fol. 89] to June: 6, 19438, and $1.58 per hour to October 10,
1943, and $1.725 per hour to April 8, 1945. That during
Al of said periods he was required: to work 1547.6° fours
overtime, that is to say, in excess of the applicable masxt-
‘mum under, Seétion 7 of the Act, for which he.was\ entitled
to be paid ‘overtinie compensation at the rate of ope and
. one-half. times the aforesaid applicable regukir hourly
rate, amounting in all to the sum of $5,604.82.
eer VIO.
»>Wherefore plaintiffs pray that an accounting be hal
and that the ampunts due from defendant to each of the
plaintiffs herein be ascertained and: determined and that
plaintiffs Nave judgments for’ the amounts thereef, and,
in addition thereto, equal amounts as liquidated damaces,
and for a reasonable attorney's .fee for-the institutian
~ and preseeution of this suit, aad for costs.
THOMAS ‘BOND,
Attorney for Plaintiffs,
705 Olive Street,
St. Louis 1, Mo.
2
I hereby certify that. I served the above First Amended *
Complaint upon defendant by*mailing a copy thereof to,
Mr. Russell Vandivort, its atterney of record, this 3rd day
April, #46, : ;
THOMAS BOND, ae
-Attorney for Plaintiffs.
- s ‘
:
* ° <2 » e
“
. ~, ’
4 ‘ : -.
> F
.
Fy
> 30
+. [Lol BP) Geeay ok: Answer.
~
©
nora
2 ° ms ’
[ fol. 36) (Order granting ‘Siw to ninend First Amended
Compiaint. )
’
July 10, 1946.
9.
On oral application of ‘plaintiffs, plaintiffs are graiited |
Ld .
- leave to amend their first’ amended complaint by -intér-
lineation by adding the word ‘‘The’’ to the corporate title
of deferidant. Said complaint so. amended..
. Filed i in U. S. a Court on ‘July 10, 1946.
o
?
(Filed April 18, 1946.)
First Defense.
* (1) The First"Amended Complaint fails to state a claim
against the. defendant: upon which relief can be granted.
. . oe Second Defense.
(2). Defendant Admits. the allews tions in section num-
-bered 1 of the First Amended ¢ ‘omplaint, except the alle-
gation that the piaintiffs named in the caption, and each :
6f them, were and are similarly sithated: within the inean-
ing of section 16 b of the Fair Labor Standards Act of
1938 (29 U.S.C. 216b), which atlegation defendant Denies;
Admits the allegations in section numbered IL of the said
complaint; Denies the allegations in section-numbered IIT
[fol 38] of the said complaint; Admits that plaintiffs, and
ach of them, were emploved by the defendant for the
periods stated, but Denies cach and every other allegation
contained ill seetion numbered Iv of said eomplaint; Admits
that the time cards and other records showing the number —
of hours worked by plaintiffs are in the possession of de-
fendant, but Denies each aml every other allegation eon-
tained in section: numbered Voof said complaint; Admits ©
that the prlaiatitls were emploved for thre pertods,: and at
°
aM -
the base pay, a> vite ved in the several paragraphs of: sec
tion VI of the said complaint, but Denies that the base pay
was, in any case, fora fortyhowr week, that the regular
hourly’ rates were cas alleged, and each and -every. other -
allegiftion Contained Tn’ the several parad@aphs of section’
numbered V 1 of the anid complaint.
Third ene
ie 3) Mach of the plain iff’. was employed in a bona fide
adininistrative capacity, as sue Wy term is defined and de-
Tiniited) by the regulations of the Administrator of ‘the’
Wave dnd Hour Division-of the Department of Labor, and
hence the provisions of the Fair Labor Standards Act of a
, INS (Q20°UL S.C. 200) do not apply: with respect to ypilain-\ |
tiffs, or any of them. = J ree te Seen .
Fourth Defense.
(4) None of the plaintiffs was engaged in commerce. or
in the production of goods for ecommerce within the mean- 7
ing of the Fair, Labor Standards Act of 1938; or the defini-
tions of such terms contained in the said Act, and he nee
‘the provisions of the said Act do ‘not appty to the pain.
tiffs, or any of them.
>}
Pa
-,£ [oe
[fol ee _ Fifth: Defeyse. ala
(5) The - right of action, if any, set forth in the First
Amended Complaint with respect<to any employment ‘ot:
plaintift A.C. Kropp in excess-of forty hours in any work
weeks prior to May 4th, 1942, did not accrue within three
(3) years next betore the commencement - of this action,
and hence any right of ‘action with respect to any employ-
ment of said plaintiff prior to May 4th, 1942, is barred by
the provisions of Sections 1012 and 1015 of thie Revised
. Statute ~ of Missouri, 198 0, ae
rarer Sixth Defense.
(6) The right of tefion, if any, sét forth ‘in the First
Adie neled: ( ‘orp int awith respect to any employme nt ot
. “~——
2
~
oo
ray, | 3
plaintiffs i. M. Tyler, JC. Marshall, G. 1 Beatie. Joe
ite ev ha NOW, ea B. J. Ludwig, Wiliam Niedringhaus, .
‘S.F Coley; 14. ‘Trimble, R. M. Stewart, B. H. Hargate, |
Walter Core, pi A EL. Erickson, Hiner Maher, Kmimett
Hoskins, FP. P. Knight, R.A. Westra, Al. Herman, George
Burmeister,:G. Be Darby, Ro K. Jerniches, J. J. Schwartz, «
A.-C. Keamp,--Byror Yancey, J. DO. Cavanaugh, W. F. .
()Meara, @ L. Valei, Mike Malloy, Russell Barnett, Wil-
liam Hirschberger, Frank Coinell, Floy L. Jennings, Ster-
ting Cook, Clif Champion, Don Burke, W.'C: Vi ehmann, —
Ms M. Kercheval, Gay Cruce, Re Baxter, N.C. Walther;
feorse Gillen, “James - Vollbrecht, “R. J. ‘Peterson, Jack
De Larey, S. FF: Peters ane A. Lockhapa in.exctss of forty
hours im any work weeks prior to April-5, 1943, did+ not
“acerue within three. ( 3) years snead before the commence-
nent of his action, aud hence any right of action with
respect fo any spe of said plaintiffs, and each of
thein, prior to April 4 , 1943, is barred by the provisions
of Sections 1012 and: DE >of the’ Revised Statutes éf Mis-
our, 1939,
[fol. 40] Wherefore, the defendant prays for judgment that
the First Amended Complaint he ‘dis missed with costs to
the defe ndant, , . .
RHODES. Ei. CAVE,
LR. H. McROBERTS,
W. C. CONNETT EV,
~ 1630 Boatmen’s Bank Building, :
_. St. Lonis 2, Missouri,
Sg) rae ; — ‘for Defendant.
BRYAN, © “AVE, Ne ‘-PHEETERS & “McROBERTS,
1. 30 Boatmen’s Bank Building,
St. Louis 2. Missouri,
Of Counsel.
Wp SR RY AE OTIC
[fol 41] Amended and Additional Interrogatories
: Propounded by Plaintiffs Pursuant
to Rule 33.
(Filed March 36, 1946, ) ie
7
Now come ‘plaintiffs and by leavewot court withdraw the.
Interrogatories heretofore filed herein and in lieu thereof
serve upon defendant and file herein the following
Amended and Additional Interrogatories under Rule. 33
and request that defendant answer. same separately tind
fully andl serve a cepy ofits Answer upon plaintiffs’ attor-
’
ney as provided in said Rule 33, to-wit:
<
Under the laws of what state is defendant invorpo-
rated, and when was it licensed to do business in Missouri?
5 aay
Did defendant operate a manufacturing plafit in St.
Louis for the manufacture of ammunition and, if so, over
‘hat period of time did it operate same: and where was
th isis located?
-
. Describe the product produeed at ‘this plant,
4. For what purpose was this product produced ! 4
What: raw materials were used by defendant in the
P hanes ture of this product? . :
Where and from whom were these raw materials ob-
tained? ; ’
. What method of transportation or common carrier
was used to delivér the raw materials to defendant?’ s plant?
8s. W hat. facilities did. defendant maintain on its prem-
a s? 3 ta eat
~ ¢
Desevibe . the switching facilities in use, particularly,
ren were the tracks located, who. maintained them,
whose crews operated them, with what railroads did they
cgnnect and at. what.points did they: so connect?
[fol. 42] fo. Describe the loading and unloading faciljtics
at said plant and state particularly where the platforms
were located ‘and. who maintafied thei.
———
11. Whose Suiployees loaded and unloaded out. eoing
and in-coming freight?
ises for the receipt of materials and the pieeaiien of its
"y .
eo
w / .
12. Was all the ammunition produced at said plant
shipped to points outside the State of Missouri? If not,
state what percentage went to points outside of Missouri.
13. Name the individual or individuals who designated
the points to which the product was to be shipped and’give
present address of such individual or individuals.’
14. Who did the actual billing on out-bound shipments
a by whom employed?
Who did the actual loading of out- hound <hipae nts"
ne by whom employed?
16. Did the defendant keep records of ihe hours worked?
hy plaintiffs and the men named in said Exh Ny it A while
a were in defendant’s employ? : ™
Did defendant keep records of: the
~*plaintifts and the men named in said Exly
ing plant drills, blackouts-and santa
18. Did the defendant keep records of the wages or mh
aries paid plaintiffs and the men named in said Bshibi \
while said parties were in defendant’ s employ?
r
Y
rs spent by
t A in aftend-
&
19. Did ‘defendant: ‘keep records showing the destination
of the animunition shipped out-of said qlant? ?
20. Deseribe ‘the records referred to in questions 16, 17,
1S and 19, supra, in such manner as to identify them and
stafe where they are kept and who now has’ custody of
them. ; |
°1..Did defendant cause to be published a certain book-
let entitled, “Your Job with the St. Lenis Ordnance
Gini
2, Tf so, when was this hooklet published and how and
“to w ee was it distributed?
23. Deseribe how the Safety J epartmert was org#nized
from January 1, 1942 to May 4, 1945, with the names of
the top personnel, and attach an organization chart to
aoe our answer
ie Defendant’! has heretofore ‘de ibveved to o plaintiff’ at
torney certain information from its records, computed sep-°
arately as to each plaintiff and each cloimant herein, par-
porting to show name, badge number, dates of commence-
ment and termination of employment, payroll periods, oc-
- cnpational code, total ac tial heurs, rate. eross wages, cor
¢
te Sento eens
”
ere 1
tain deductions anid net amount paid. State by who:
these computations were made and give the uame and pres-
ent address of the person or persons ander Whose super. >
Vision they. were prepared,
[fole43].25. Do the columns headed ** Total Actas’ Hours”
show all the time that appears on the time ecards?
i. on Do such columns show all the time the: ele loyees re-
ferred to were, required to he in attendance or on duty!
27. If answer is ‘*no*™* state what. time was not included.
2s, Js it not true that for a cettain period the employees
referred to were i ait to report one-half hour ahead °
“of bts : 2 8
. If answer ds “ves ** state the period over which this
eee was in force. ,
30, Is it not true that all-plaintiffs and claimants herein’
were required to report one-half hour ahead of shift from
- the commencement of their employment until about: Oc-
tober 10, 1948?
31. Is it not true that defendant failed to include this
one-half hour in the colamns headed ‘*Total_Actual Hours’’
in the computations furnished plaintiffs’ attorney as afore- .
. aiok ?
State fully the facts in reference to this requirement
ei employees were made. to report one-half hour
ahead of shift.
THOMAS BOND,
: Attorney ‘for ‘Plaintiffs,
705 Olive Street,
St. Lonis 1, Mo.-
Ns
Served as of March 26, 1946; hy mailing copy of ‘the
above Amended and Additional Interrogatories to. Mr.
Russell Vandivort, Attorney of Record for Defendant..
| THOMAS BOND,
- Attorney for Plaintiffs.
36
. City of St. Louis is, }
[fol. 44] (Answers of Defendant to Tnterrogatories : pro-
pounded by Plaintiffs.)
(Filed April 20, 1946.)
Eastern District of Missouri 2
Ss
Russell R. Casteel, being an officer of defendant compe-
tent to testify in its behalf, having been duly sworn,.
makes, upon-information and belief, the fellowing answers
to the Amended and Additional Interrogatories Pro- .
pounded by or Pursuant to Rnle oo, in the above
entitled: cause: ae . |
Answer to Interrogatéry No. 1:
Defendant is incorporated “under the:laws of the..State
of Maryland, and was liéensed to do business. in Missouri
on September 11, 1941...
Answer to Interrogatory- No. 2::
Defendant ,operated a manufacturing plant in St. Louis
for the manufacture of ammunition, under the terms and”
[fel. 45] provisions of a. certain contract between the
defendant and the United States of America dated Des
vember 5.1940, identified as Contract. No. W-ORD- 491, and
various supplements thereto, over a period beginning in
the month of December, 1941, and ending Aneust 31, 1945.
The plant was located at 4500 Goodfellow Boulevard, St.
Lonisy Missonri. | ;
Answer to Interrogatory No. 3:
230, 50 and .66 ealiber, ball, tracer and armor piercing:
small aris animunition, all of which, ineluding work in
process, at all times belonged to The United States of.
Ame rica and net to defend: ant. :
Answer 10 [nterrogators No. }:
For. the United States of America. *
Answer to Tnterrogatory NO. 9: °
Brass, powder, lead, steel and various other raw tat
‘terials, all of whieh, at all times upon and after their de-
livery to the premises by the. various vendors, belonged ts
The United States of America and not to defendant,
Answer to Interrogatory No, 6
s . 2
~ From varions nlaecs both in the State of Missouri and
in other States of the United States; and from the United
States Government, and qnere than two thousand other
“vendors. | 7 ee
Answer to Interrogatory No. 7:
Railroads, trucks, automobiles and airplanes,
Answer to Interrogatory No. 8s” :
Defendant had no premises, the entire -mannfacturine
plant, including land, buildings, machinery and equips
ment, at all times belonging to and hetng’ in the possession.
of The United States of America and constituting a mili-
tary reservation. On tlie said premises belonging to The
United Staies of Ameriea and constituting a- part of said
plant there. were various facilities for the ati of ima-.
terial, including one (1) bulk recé‘ving dock and approxi-
- [fol. 46] mately thirteen (13) individual receiving “tations.
-On the said premises there were various facilities for the
shipment of the products produced at this’plant, including
approximately thirteen (13) shipping docks located at the
separate production units and storage warehouses. » The
saia. facilities were maintained by emplovees of defendant
pursuant to the terms of s said contract.
Answer to Interrogatory No. 9:
The swit¢hing facilities in use at the said manuf acturing -
plant consisted of four (4) switch enginés and_ various
railroad tracks, all of which were, at all times, owned hv
The United States of America, The tracks were adjacent
to all large production and storage warehouse nnits and
connected with the lines of the Terminal Raiiroad Asso-
ciation at the West Belt Yards. of the said Association:
The tracks were maintained hy emplovee. of defendant and
LP]
a
the erews who operated said switch ngines were also em-
ployees of defendant, pursuant to the terms of-said con-
tract. *
-@
Answer to Interrogi itory No. 10:
There were three (3). covered. loading and ‘unloading
docks for each large production unit, plus one (1) truck-
‘ing dock, all, used both for loading and unloading. At the
-trucks, tractorsg dollies, and at certain places overhead
winches, and at the shipping docks referred to-in the an-.
bulk receiving dock and at the individual receiving sta-
tions referred to in the Answer to Interrogatory No. & there
were maintained a supply of hi-lo lift tractors, and hand
swer to Interrogatory No. 8 there were maintained the
same type of facilities. All of these facilities were at all
times owned by The United States Government and main-
‘tained by the defendant under the terms-of the contract.
The platforms’ which constituted the separate receiving
}
and shipping stations or docks were located alongside of.
each of the eight (8) .main production units and several
storage warehouses.
[fol. 47] Answer to Interrogatory No. 11:
Employees of the. defendant unloaded incoming freight,
and under the direct supervision, directions and. .astrue-
tions of agents of The United States of America, loaded
outgoing freight, all pursuant to the terms of said contract.
Answer to Interrogatory No. ‘12:.
Defendant does not know where The United States of
America shipped all of the ammunition produced at-the
‘said manufacturing planf. :
Answer to Interrogatory PN aan ie
Defendant does not know the names or titredins of the
individual or individuals who designated the points to’
which the product was .to be shipped.. -
Answer to Interrogatory N v0. 14: oe :
Employees of The United States of America did the.
actual billing on out-Nound shipments, the names of the
individual emplovees heing unknown ti this defendant.
a
-
-
30
Answer to Interrogatory No. 15:
Emplovees of defendant, acting under the supervision,
directions and instructions of Chiplovee sor agents of The
United States’of Ame rien, all pursuant to the terms of the
said contract,
Answer to Interrogatory No. 16:
Yes. s ¥ -_ . ‘ Ps be § , . a ieee
“Answer to Interrogatory No. 17:
Yes, to the extent that employees were instructed wher
attending plant drill, Dlackouts. and meetings outside of
their regular shift to ring their time card upon maine
and upon leaving. Some employees apparently didi net
bother to ring in and out, and with respect to snch em
plovees the defendant has no record. Tn mos. instances
these drills, blackouts and meetings were conducted an the
emplovees’ ow n shifts, and no separate record was kept
[fol 48] Answer to Interrogatory No, 18:
Yes.
Answer to Interrogatory No, 19:
No.
Answer to Interrogatory No, ut
The records referred: to in the Answer to Thterrogatory
o. 16 consisted of individual time cards.
The records referred to in the Answer to Interrogafory
No. 17 consisted of individual time-cards. ast
The records referred to in the Answer to Interrogaters
No. 18: consisted of individual .time ecards and -payroll
cheeks... | ) cathe :
<Q .
There are no rec ‘ords referred s in. the Answer to. In-
te rrogatory’ No, 19.- ;
‘
“AM such tases are now kept at. the St. Louis Adwda-
istration Center, 4300) Goodfellow Boulevard, St. Louis;
40
Missouric in the possession of the divdiccudlaiet: The. United.
States Cartridye Company. The individual in whose ce.
~ tedy they are kept is Wo Te Schulte, Corutrotter,
Answer to. Interregatory No. 21:
Yes, in four Separate editions.
Answer:to Interregators Nas SS:
The ditferent edjtions of the: hak bet were published i}
LO4]. 1942. Pag sine }ege. “A cap? ot thy enrreyt baeveobs feet z
was handed ta each emplotes “in miceliatily, after comple
tien ofthe detail of esp ber ine nit. °
Answer to Interrogatory Ne. y5:
The Safety Department was organized and set up andes
the supervision of the Personnel Director of the ade feneant,
The Personnel Director emplowed: at ‘Thief Safety Engineer,
Whig Was poli reed in comple te charge af the Sate tv Depart
ment, Under hifn he dad am assistant ant various sab
department heads, for fire fighting. sanitation, laundry. em:
plovee placement, explosive handling, ete. Under the war
aus arteant heads there were safety engineers, whe
ifol 42] were designated during approximates the first
four months of operation as Safety. Inspectors amet there
after as Safety Engineers. C. Bi. Steiekland was Chief
Safety Engineer fram December 22, MMT, te Mas 21, 144.
A. Ts MeKittrick was Chief Safety Engineer tron: Max 22.
Odd, to Mareh 4, 460 S. KL Bs wdeker was Assistant
“Chief Safety Engineer frou: July 3, 1H, te Oeteber 5,
1945. An organization chart is attached hereto,
Answer to literrogatory NO. 24:
Phe computations were made. ander the superviston cof
WoL. Schulte, Comptroller, whose address is 449 Foresten
Place, Webster Groves, Missouri, and L. Kellev. Par
roll Superviser, whose a Idress is OS882 Cabanne Aven:
St. Louis, Missoni.
The names and addressés of the persons whe actual)
nade the computations are as follows:
8
-
4]
Coab. Hebbal S447 Mer Acenme St. Louis, Missouri
. Apa :
: Williaa Wetinine. 2o27a Senth Dith Street St Louis.
“Missouri.® + - .
BFS Pavwe, Golo Natural Brildee Road. St. Louis,
Wissouri is
Lanes Ho Werner, Reute 14, Affton. Missouri
if. Bo Bisnineter. GO06 West Cabanne Phaee. St. Louis.
-Missonri . ae.
~NAriewer te Pterroeatery No. 2a:
The inferiuition in the colitis brecsbebend: Total ANetualy
Hours” ety thre cote peuatset pens heretofore delivered to qelain-
tiiT.* attornes thoes net show the tie elapsed between the
pmmehing oft the card apd the begiumane ef the shitty other
“Wise if ~ hon ~ all the tiny io thiset PS Fess eri thre a cATn~6~—COS*S~—S
-
-
.Anewer te dnterregatery Neo 26s.” ; rae
Ves, hd, th oredelition, reflect the am half bhovnar lune
three eel clay When they were Dies! reqaired to be in} aft- -
tendance or on duty . .
Answer te ‘Interrogatery Neo 27: fees se anmee. s
Noteappticable, Sha bisa win SO Nea 9°
Answe te Thterrogatory: Nol os:
No. For a certain tithe the emi plivers were reqnested tio
repertoene half benr ahead of shift. but ware not required .
te dose ate were not decked or penalized if they failod
to clo <a, °
Answer te DTnterrocitory: No. wa: -
- ’
Not appheable The request referred te in they Answer
fo Interrogatory Neo 2s was in ferce from the middle .of
adune, MRS, aaitil abont the latter part of September, 1942. -
fol. S05 Answer to Titerregatery No. 30;
‘ No. . , i ‘ - - ©
>
“Answer to Tnterrovatory No. 51:
Not applicable. etn ar Mini gece ek gna eerie a
Answer to interrogators Now 32:
As stated in the anawer to Interros atory No. 28, there
oWas no requirenie nt wherehy the plamtiffs were maeele ty
report one-half hour ihe ad of shift.
Dated April loth, 1046, | ; rs
RUSSELL R. CASTEEL..
Subscribed and sworn to hefore me thers roth day of
April, 146,
My comMtission expires’ Duly 20, 1949.
| MARGARET M. MEYER.
Eo . Notary Publhie
~ RHODES EF. CAVE, .
R. H. MceROBERTS,
W. ¢. CONNETT TV,
1630 Boatmen’s Bank Building, -
St. Louis 2. Missouri,
Attorneys for Defe ndant The U nited
: States | artpeee Conipany,
BRYAN, € AVE, MM. ‘PHEETERS &/
MceROBERTS, ss
1630 Boatmen'’s Bank Bnilding—
St. Louis 2, Missouri,
Of Counsel. |
°
- «.
< : : : :
° :
’
iE i eee
’ i
‘
= Z
-
mi
e
o
7
¢ ; Sige
(This and subsequent missing or blank pages
deleted as per stipulation, Reeord 1050.)
aa
\!
[fol 52], (Request, of Plaintiffs for Adtisstous liv
‘. . Defendant under Rule 36.)
(Filed April. 24, 146, )
To: The U nited States ( ‘artridge C ompany, or Brivan, Cave,
~ McPheeters & McRoberts, and Messrs, Rhodes B.C ave,
R. H. MeRolerts, and W. C. Connett, IV, Its Attorneys
and Counsel of -Ree ord. |
4 Plaintiffs sfate that shipping aici of the outbound
shipment of the ammunition produced at the plant opér-.
ated by defendant herein were made at or about the time
of: said shipments and consist principally of bills of lading |
covering said shipments aid that same are now located
on the premises at which said plant was operated, to-wit,
4300 Goodfellow Avenue, in the City of Saint’ Louis, Mis-.
souri, and that the same are now under the control of
either the defendant herein or the United States of Amer.
¢ /ica and are ‘available to the defendant and are open to
?
einspection by defendant. Plaintiffs also state. that said’
hills of Jading show the destination ‘of said shipments and
recite the route of movement of said shipments to said
destinations, which is information relevant and material to
the issues raised by the pleadings ‘herein and which plead-
ings are now closed. That these, records consist of a very
. large number ‘of documents and in the aggregate “are
extremely voluminous and bulky, dnd to avoid. the. pro-
duction and introduction in evidence of these excessive
- records, and to avoid burdening Yhe-record in this case
with samé, plaintiffs desire to introduce. the following. -
Statement of matters contained théreiy as an admission
and now request ander the provisiqns of Rule 36 of the
new federal rules that defendant ad nit the truth of the
following statement, to-wit: Bs et,
[ fol. 53]° That said hills of lading: contaim recitals and
statements showing that at least the greater part of
to ammunition produced at .the manufacturing plant
located at 4500. Goodfellow Avenue, St. Louis, Mis-
souri,, while samé was. being operdted by: defendant
and during the time plaintiffs were employed therein
Wwas billed and shipped out of said plant by railroad
or otaer form of transport: ation to destinations outside
the-state of Missouri, 2-0 2... ‘
er
46.
. Plaintiffsefurther state that unless the truthfullness of
the foregoing statement is admitted they wil introduce
seconilary evidence as to the contents’ of said bills of
lading ‘in proof thereof. :
Plaintiffs further state that copies of the foregoing said
hills of daditie are not attac ‘hed hereto for the reason {hit
-snine are: available to and open to the inspection of defend.
Lant at the place-where they are now located, and further,
hecause plaintiffs do not have copies thereof and bevause of
the great: miuber and sizeof. said records it would he
-Impractical] to attach, copies hereto.
Plaintiffs state that. at their request and in order to
ice the production and introduction in evidence of a
great quantity of time cards and other pavroll records de-
fendant has heretofore prepared and delivered to plain-
tiffs’ attorney a voluminons set of computations showing
in substance the name, badge number, dates of commencé-
ment and. termination of employifent, payroll ” periods,
occupational code, total actual hours, rate, gross wages,
certain deduetions and net amount paid, computed as to
eaeh of the fiftv-nine. (59) plaintiffs herein and entifled
“Safety Tnspectors Karnings Snimmary’’.
Now, therefore, in or der that there may he. no question
of plaintiffs’ right to offer these computations in evidence
and use them as admissions of the facts and figures therein -
recited, plaintiffs under the provisions of Rule 36 of the.
new federal rules request /of defendant an admission of
the genuineness, thereof, and an admission that the. said
[fol]. 54] computations as prepared by the defendant. as
aforesaid are correct ‘and that they truthfully reflect what
ix contained ‘in the defendant’s records:
Plaintiffs state that copies of said computations are not
attached hereto because defendant and its attorneys ‘and
counsel are [all ready] in possession of copies and also.”
heeause defendant only supplied plaintiffs: with one set of.
copies and that by-reason of their size the making and
attaching ef additional coples is impractical -and plaintiffs,
state that the copies furnished it hv defendant are /avail-
able and open to the inspection of defendant or its repre-
sentatives in the office of ‘plaintiffs’ attorney at any time.
47
3. Admission is requested: as to each and all of the fore.
going matters by Monday, May :6, 1946,
THOMAS BONT, - Peck
ee i Attorney toy Plaintiffs. ee
: 700 OlivetStreet,
St. Lonis 1, Mo.-
I hereby certify that I served the above and foreoine
Request for Admissions Under Rule 360 upon defendant
and its attorneys of record by nailing a copy thereat to
Messrs, Brvan, Cave, MePheeters and MeRoberts, at therr
last Known address, to-wit: 1630 Boatimen's Bank Building,
OSt.. Lonis, Missonri, marked for the attention of Mr.
Rhodes BE. Cave, Mr. R. TL. MeRoberts and’ a wc,
Connett, TV.. on the "4th day of Ajyril, 1946, chee
THOMAS BOND, |
; — Attorney for Plaintiff...
8
Le
[fol 55] (Reply of ‘Defendant to Request of Plaintitfs for
Admissions under; Rule 36.) ;
(Filed May 6, 1946:)
(Comes now defendant in. the above entitled eaase, arid
for reply to the request for-admissions under Rule 236,
states as follows: . .- ar Oi ee
1. With respect to the first request for -an admission,
defendant says that: the shipping records alleged-to von.
sist principalty of bills of lading are wot: now under the.
control of defendant, and are not available to the defend.
ant, and are not open to inspection by defendant: that de
fendant. does not know where@he said records are located, -
and: that the defendant has never seen sneh reebrds and
— does not know the contents thereof. Cae
Wherefore, defendant, states that it cannot. truthfully
ee
— Cither admit or deny the statement: — : Neto ttt on
“Thag said hills of lading contain recitals and state.
ments showing. that at least the greater part of the’
tn a :
ammunition produced at. the amanufacturing plant
located: at 45006 Goodfellow Avenue, St. Louis, Mis
sauri, while same was being operated by defendant and
during the time plaintiffs were. enploved therein was - -
hilled and shipped out of said “plant by railroad or
other form of transportation to destinations .outside ©
the State of Missouri’? ; :
. 2, Wath respect to the second request for an admission,
defendant says that the defendant admits-the genuineness
‘of the set of computations referred to in said request:
admits That the said computations ate correct, and that
they truthfully reflect what is contained in. the defendant “s
records } fm, Ss
except that defendant states, thatthe said computa:
—* tions do not reflect a. deduction wiiich should be made
fol. 56] for the one-half hour lunch period each day when
~ each of the employees covered by such computations:
were off dutv, and to that extent the computations
~ Jnelude one-halfhour’s time each diay foreach em-
‘plovee whien each such employee did not work, and
“which-time ‘should *he deducted: in computing sours —. +
worked in excess of forty hows per week; and except, $
further, that all eomputationssshewing. time beyond
: the employees’ regular shifts were computed on the
—* basis of: full six: minute periods or multiples thereof,
i.e, any number of minutes lessi than six minutes
were disregarded. ~ coun’ |
RHODES EF. CAVE,
R: H. MeROBERTS,
W.€. CONNETT TV, -
| 1630 Boatmen's Bank: Building. -
"St: otis. 2, Missouri; .—
es oe ie ee Attorneys for, Defendant — ..
ea. ome - — The United States Car- re
: ele ace tee prey tridge Company.
BRYAN, CAVE, MePHEETERS & MceROBERTS,
-° 1630 Boatmen’s Bank Building, et a ee .
“< St. Lonis, 2, Missouri,
(>t Coinansel. :
40)
Fastern District of Missouri bia i cs
City “of sr Louis oh. > = «
R, H. MéBoborts, agent ands attorney for defendant,
having. been duly ‘sworn, states upon’ information and
belief that the forigoing Re ‘ply to Reque st for Admission
Under Rule 36 Is true and correct.
R. H. MeR¢ IBIERTS.
.”
tehanciead and sworn to be fore | me hist day of M: AY,
1°46. ;
My commission’ expires July 4, 1949,
‘RUTH F. Ww EAKLY, |
— Notary Public.
ifol-57] (Memorandum relating to filing of Amended An-
swer of Defendant to Interrogatory No. 22.)
By leave, def't. files amended answer ta atu
No. 22,"
; ee WIL L LAM C. CONNETT IV,
| satire Atty. for ‘Deft:
May 15
Approved °
me mF on Ree
Filed, May 15; 1946, ° Ps toon - is
Lol.: 38) ( Mes nded Sues se ee ndant to [Inter ratory ]
No, 22
(Filed May 15, 146 )
Eastern District of Missouri:
|
City of St. Louis _ Sed eh ae
Siinatt R. Castecl bein. an officer of Ribas: it com-
petent to testify An its he alt, having: been duly sworn,
makes, npouinformation and belief, the following amended
™y
mai
oe
op)
-answer to [nterrégatory No, 22 propounded by plaintiffs
in the above cutitled cnuse:
Ame nied Answer to Interrow: tory No. 22:
The first edition of the booklet was published in “1941,
and was distributed during the pe ‘riod from some time in
August, 1941, to some time in November, 1941; the second
~ cdition of. the booklet was published in 1941, and was
dae
a
distributed duri ing the period fyonv some time in November
1941, to some time in April, 1942; the third edition of the
hooklet was published in 1942, and was distributed during
the period: from some time in ‘April, 1942, to some time: in
December, 1942: the fourth edition ‘of ‘the hooklet) was
pubh shed in 1942, and was distributed, during the period
from some time in December, 1942, to some time in EKeb-
ruary, 1944. A copy of the current booklet was handed to
each employee immediately after completion of the details
ef employment., °. yay 7 °
Dated May 13th, 1946,
Mesa one © RUSSELL R. CASTEEL.
Subscribed nad eworn to before me this 13th day’ cof May,
1946, :
My commission expires July 20, 1949,
M ARGARET M, MEYER,
Notary Public.
(fol. 59, RHODES BE. CAVE, -
ie SRS sox R. H, MeROBERTS, .
". ©. CONNE YY iy:
1630 Boatmen’s Bank Building,
St. Louis 2, Missouriie
Attorneys for Defendant
The United States Cartridge
Company.” ey
RRYAN, CAVE, MeP HEETERS & McROB ERTS,
1630 Beg n’s Bank Building,
. Lowis 2, Missouri.
Of Counsel.
-
/
f
a]
Copy of the foregoing amended answer to Interrogatory
No. 22 served upon plaintiffs" attorney by forwarding a
Copy in the U nited States mails on this 14th day of May,
14h, :
W. C. CONNETT IV.
[fol 60] (Transefipt ot Testimony and Proceedings.)
(Filed October LO LOST.)
° ~~
District Court of the Uiited States for the astern
Division of the Mastern Judicial District
dt Missouri. .
RLM. Powell, et al.,
Plaintiffs, |. ,
_ é “U No. 3597,
The U nited States Cartridge Company, |
Defendant. :
Be It Remembered, that beginning on the Sth. day. of
July, 1946, this matter was called for hearing in the United
States District Court in above District and ‘Division, New -
Federal Building, St. Lonis, Missouri, before Hen. George
H. Moore, Indge Court. No. One: Whereupon, the following
proceedings were had:
Anpe AFAnees:.
For*the Plaintiffs:
Thomas Bond, Exq.
For the Defendant:
Robert H. MeRoberts, Esq.
John | « Donnell “sq.
( ‘ounsel Pr exént Listening to the Evidence:
Samnel.P. McChesney, Esq., |
Joseph I. Nachman, Esq.
yy
fol. 61} i Proceedings:
The Court: TF will eall toxins "= low ket. ROM. Powell vs.
L nited States ¢ ‘urtridgve Cor pany.
Mr. Bond: We are ready, Your Honor. °
Mr. McRoberts: We are ready, Your Honor,- with these
sli ht qualifieation=: 4 find in) sone eornputation whieh I
furnished to Judge: Bond earlier in this case there: were
sole errors | Called them te the atte ntion of Judge Bond
hast Frids iWwlas soon as | discovered ther, and we are going
ty have some new comprtations made, “Phey are not ready
teulay, but | assume we will be given tite to make these
coinpuitay ions befare the rmgitter is finally dis posed of,
The Court: Very well.
Mr. Bond: J helieve Mr. Met ‘hesney wants to introduce
his assoc iate Mr. Nachman.
Mr. McChesney: ‘It is for the. purpose of sitting in and
vistening to the evidence in this case, not as an — arance
Mr. Nachman: Ypur’ Honor please, shinee area number
of issues that could be raised in this case which the Admui-
istrator is interested in, and during the course of the day
we would like to ask an order from you wiving us leave to
‘tile a brief. i
Judge Bojul: We would he glad to have his brief, ‘Your
lLonor.
fol. 624 Mr. McRoberts: Before we commence in this, case
1 would like to ask leave to file an amended answer to
Interrogatery No. 25. And ‘tin that connection I might
state that some months age we turnished to Jndge Bond
some aather lengtliv coinputations showing the ltimber of
hours worked by the different, claimants in this case as
shown by the time-carnds. And in’ this Tnterrogatary Zo
the question ts asked whether or net those computations
show ail of tlie hours that are*retlected on the tine
cards. And we made thé answer before that we had
showed allot the hours, with certain exceptions. dndge
Poaoreed stthpoenszed eoptain af these time. cards 40. be bronglit
inte Court, nfl ther were breneht to mow desk fast Priday
<
and on comparing the time-cards against the computations
furnished to Judge Bond, wind the explanation which we
chad given as to the method of making these computations
we discovered tliat the figures were. correct but the ex-
planation was erroneous. 1 immediately advised Judge
Bond, first by telephone and then by. letter, and now ask
leave to file an amended answer which sets fortli the cor-
_ tect theory of the computation.as we now understand, 4.
have. just furnished Judge Bond with-a copy, of thus,
Mr. Bond: I have to object to that, if Your Honor please,
for the reason that I ‘have prepared this case on.the faith
or fact IT would be entitled to.adimissions which were made
“In answer tomy interrogateries, And’ now he comes in”
fol Gay bay application this morning, preceded -by tele.
-phene call last Friday, in which he wants to clarify one
of these admissions, It seeuis that when he gave me. these
pay roll swuinaries that he-told you about, last, January,
containing’ the pay. roll iiformation necessary to support
the claim of the plaintiffs my people advised me that it
didnt include certain half hours which they. were re-
quired to report to the plant before the shift started. To.
be sure of that T asked bim in my interrogatories if he
“included all the time. And whe said Yes, with the excep-
tion of ‘that: half hour,’*. which he admitted was nof in-
rolnded, And then these figures-have to be translated ‘te
hourly rates. And then we computed it at e@reat trouble
and expense. IT have made my computation relying on
-bhe information then furnished, which I any still informed
ix correct. Now, he comes ‘in at the last minute and
wants fo amend that out of time: The time in which to
auswer the interrozatories. has long expired. It would
arry nd extension -ef time. And he comés in and wants
to modity that answer whiely includes not all of it, but,
less than that. “And hessays, later on, he will give us the
fleures,. :
. | think the purpose of these rules’ in asking interroga.
torie ‘sand vetting answers is that von can get admissions
vou ean rely on in preparing your casé and “shorten the
proof. Tf he ean come in the | la®niinute and sav,/“T was
Wwrone about -one,"’ he can withdraw all and put me in
~ [fol, 64] miter contusion.” T submit Tam entitled. for the
, : 3 we
D4
benefit ef this case, to that admission which I thought was
the fact until this morning. -And no doubt. if there is,
some explanation that would have a bearing on his de-
—-fense im that admission, I have no doubt the Court would
hear it and consider it along with the admission. If there
is any inaccuracy in that ‘admissiot it would be up to him
to show corréct coluputations based on ‘the correct facts. -
But Ido not think he can come in here and amend his
_anuswers to the Interrogi itories and disturb the admissions
that have been of yecord for months “and that’ 1 have
relied on in drawing iny ease, Ll object to it.
Me. McRoberts: There: can be no real dispute as to the’
ultimate facts because it is purely a matter, of: arithmetic
or computation. In ether words, we have the time-card
only for each employee for each Week, and there are some
ten thousand of those involved in- this lawsuit. The figures:
are there and we cannot deny tor can Judge Bond deny |
— what those figures. show. There was furnished to Judge
’ Bond, at. his request, certain computations ‘which were
made from these time-cards for Judge Bond’s convenience,
and the only question/in here is as to-how these coniputa-
tions were made... Once the original ‘documents are in.
“evidence there can be no dispute’ as to what they show
and What.the computations are. - But the figures’ furnished
-to Judge Bond are misleading and | think that’ the
(fol. 65] Court would want and everyone would want to
have the actual facts in this case. - é One
(Counsel and the Court confer at Court’s Bench.)
The Court: Do you not suggest that the Court, might
reserve its ruling.
Mi. McRoberts: I divin that would be all right,
The Court: A right, the Court will reserve its ruling.
Mr. seni May I proceed, Your Honor?
The ¢ haat Proceed, | 7 :
Mr. Bond: I believe sinee the proceedings are very
yoluminous it would clarify. and focus the matter if I
made a brief statement of the tacts:
—- -- oa
os ; “ ie : *- ae
I want to prove this is a group action under 16b of the
Fair Labor Standards Act to meéasure the overtime com-
pensation provided in Section 7a of the Act by a eroup ot
‘employees of, the defendant. The answer admits the incor-
poration, the jirisdiction of the Court, the employment it
the plaintiffs for the periods and at the base pay averred,
and denies specifically other averments, but pleads affiema-
tively that those employees were exempted. from the ben-
efits of the act ‘under the Administrator’ s definition of
eae qorid es.
’ Second, that they were not. cngaged in the production of
yoods for commerce Within the meaning of the act. . And,
third, that as to certain plaintiff< prior: te certain defen
the claims are barred by the Statute of Limitation.
[fol. G6], Now the facts are in eeneral, Your Honor, that.
this defendant United States Cartridge C OMpARY Opel rated
what was knewn as the St. Louis Qrduance Plant. That was
an ammunitions plant built as part of the preparedness
program back in 1941, and after Pearl Harbor was used
as a Vast .ammunitions undertaking operated by the United
States Cartridge Company for the production of military
anununition—thirty, fifty and sixty tracer: bukets for the
usp of rifles and machine guns, and was a great bie indus-
trial lavout out here on Goodfellow Avenue comprising a
ereat many very extensive buildings and employing over
forty’ thansand employ ees, And during the period of this
operation it operated what the evidence will show were.
t literally billions of bullets that were shipned to every part
of the world. Now then, at that plant it was equipped with
loading docks and receiving stations, and switch tracks and
-suh-stations, and loading facilities, all of which were main-
tnined for defendant's @mplovees. In the prodiction of
this military. equipment and aemunition if was engaged in
interstate emumerce in that it imported into Missotiri vast.
anantities of raw materials whieh it hought from? indns-
tries ontside of Missonri and. shipped into Missouri, nrin-*
eipally ‘brass, steely lend and newder, most of which owns
produced by the defendant and some hy the United States
f Ordnanee Department, but the greater amonnt of the vol
nine of all of this prineinally raw materials, with the poss]
Pol. G7] ble exeeption of powder,-was shipned in by the
instrumentaiity of interstate commerce.from point. outside
6 ;
of Missouri to points in) Missouriy Records illustrative’ of
that will be produced. Now then, the manuf: aetnred prod:
net was iieued from the plant to the armed forced and
supply depots and to other contractors for transshipment
to the armed forces on the battle fronts. The thyory was
that upon mueaiufacture being conitple ted and acc fee “by
the United States Army Ordnance, the defer ant’s em
ployees would load crates and move them dowy to the Toad.
ing docks, put-them into the ears, seal and byace and dock
themwand they would then be sealed_under the supervision
of the Arniy Ordnance and moved. out to the destinations
designated by the Army Ordnance, All of the work of that
loading and bracing and so forth was dene by employees
‘of the defendant, and defendant’s -emplovees or yvard-
niasters out there’ checked the billing for quantity. and
frouteing] before turning it over to the Terminal avent.
Records disclose and tliose facts will he produced. And
so we will say that the proof will show that the defend-
ant was engaged in interstate commerce, the goods pro-
‘duced, were produced for inferstate commerce, and that
they were heing produced for interstate: commerce.
The: plaintiffs’ evidence will show they had reason to -
helieve that such was the fact at the time of production.
[ fol. 68] The cnrrounding cirenmstances will warrant that
inference, and there. will he written documents introdneed
or prblications at the plant showing ‘aetual knowledge that.
all of this ae. Was “destined for transshipment ont
of Missonri. .Now, in connection with .that-dammunitions
effort that F doceribed thev chaye as an infegral part of
that an oreanized Safety Department, It was net anly
for the humanit: trian purpose. of protecting the employee
but it had a very tmnortang connection with production, in
that the organiziution aid operation of the Safety Der tire
nent. prevented: seeidents. prevented. [heoaddowns), and
prevented absenteeism, and: had an efeet. on pridnetion
and owas infemroven : itty produetion. That Sate tv Depart
ment was under the lines tion of a diree dor whe had same
tigre Sone MAY ns thre directors, cener: ally one or two, that
had ‘snpery ision over about one hyandre d safe Ivopen, centled
at times Safety Puspectors, at other times Gafoty Per,
neers, They inclnded the plaintiffs in thio ense. Theos
hndred or so safefts: meat werecassivned three ta eneh ”
*.
uv
~~
oa
operating unit, one for each sliit'. And one OF the three
Was Cestonazed was foreman or supervisor over the. others,
but he chad no authority over the others and did the sane
vork that the others did, and the omy thing that differed
from the others in the main was to include the re ports tor.
him and transinit them-in his reports to the director and
[fol. 69] director, s assistant. But the’evidence will show
that the poliev-making authority, the exercise of inde pena.
“out Par tact and diséretion, did not eo below the director
and his assistant. Now then, the «duties of these plaintiffs,
as the evidetice will show, the regular duties were to
patrdl, to inspect and report. Phev, were just routine in-
spectors. They patrolled buildings and determined things -
like the existence of slippery floors, or what is called had.
housekeeping. They jpatrolled the machines and noted the
presence of guards and other safety equipment, And they.
noted the employees | to indicate the wearing of safety.
equipment, such as hair nets:and goggles, and observation
“of safety practices, When iae-the. performance of that
patrol and: inspection duty the hundred men forming that
routine duty noted any infractions. And ‘then the further
duty remained upon them to do two things: They first re-
ported evidence of infractions«oef the safety rnles, which
_were dangerous safety practices of omplovees, to the Fore-
man-ot Supervision for correction. Note that it was.the ~
‘production employees’ foreman to w hich théy made the
‘report ‘for correction, and it was his responsibili ty to cor.
rect, not ‘the Safety Departmient’s. + The’ report for-cor-
rection. was made’ to the supervising personnel over the
employee who was hot obser ving the safety practices. Then
at the end of the day in their daily report te their own
foreman or supervisor, they reported the occurrence for
investigation, cand he re ‘laved that report in his report
Hol. 707 to the director's office. But, as‘above stated. ‘no
authority £Oh, T forgot ia-state that in connection with
w these infractions the safety men had no antheritv to take
any corrective action himself. He couldn't speak to or
reprimand gan tmplovee, hor even speak to him. The or. -
ders on that were very explicit, and violations entailed dis.
viissal, Socthe ovide nee will show: clearly that the re Was
no actnal authority below the Director's office. )
Now the nN, as to the employ ment of fheso plaintiffs. if 1.
os
may get a sip of water: They, were employed at stated
salaries ‘for, a. 40-hour ‘week. - At -the time of their enploy-
iment a littl booklet: was given in wieh forty hours was
stated tobe the regular nonovertime work week at. the
plant, and that work in excess of 40. hours would be com-
pensated and was according to the provisions of the Fair
Labor Standards. Act: Notwithstanding they were etu-
ployed at stated salaries for a nonovertime 40-hour work —
week and required to work overtime, this group was let,
compensated in accordance with. Section 7 of the. Fair
Labor Standards Act? which says: they must be paid-at
one and’a half times the regular tate. Section [Oc ot the
‘Act requires ‘fhe defendant to keep pay roll records, and —
he has at my-request given me shintuaries Containing the
pay roll information as to these fifty-nine plaintiffs. It will
be introduced in evidence. It contains: the work week,
the actual hours worked, and gives the weekly wages.
ffol. 71] 1 should mention, here that while-that act, the:
Fair Labor Standards Act, uses the words ‘thourly rates,”
the courts have uniformly heid from the Supreme Court
down that it does not exclude employees whose compensa-
tion is measured by other Standards, suchas piece-workers
cor salaried workers, that in such cases as in Cases of salary
“worker the gross weekly wage must be translated into an
hourly rate. [ have, therefore, translated these gross wages
which they ‘reported. to me into -similar computations
whereby L lave broken them down to the houghy’ rater =
For example, if, the gross wage was. fifty-one ninets-twe
as the first item T see here, and the werk week was 40 hours
per week, the hourly rate would be. fifty-one ninety-two
divided by forty, or one thirty, @ldich was the rezuiar
Hiourly ratéat which he was employed. Then applying
one fifty per cent of one: thirty for, overtime they 1 -port
each week, | get the overtime compensation due that em-
ployee for each week. For example, if the employee worked
48.3.0 hours, applying one thirty. one and a half, and. the
one ninety-five to. the extra, vou- get $16.18. asthe—over-
time dve the entplovee forthat week.” Now, totalling that
on the addiig machine gives the total ¢lain of eaeh, plain:
tiff! So if Your Honor after hearing the ease agrees that
the method of coinputation ix correct then: the record will
shaw in these two eets of-extibits, wh
*
”
ich are numbered to +,
09
correspond, the exact amount due each plaintiff on the
defendants” own figures. - . 4 ¢ ;
[fol. 72] That T believe in a. general wav stites the-ease.
Mr..McRoberts: Your Honor please, £ don’t believe’ we
would ear’ to make a statement at His time; but [ would
like to raise the gtiestion as to the procedure to be -fol-
lowed in this trial.; There are fiffy-nine separate plaintiffs,
each plaintiff has a separate clan, Jmt, no one plaintiff is”
bound by anotlier’s claim. It is obvions that the°testimony
us to-vertain facts will be the same In é@ach case, the busi-
NeSS OF What the defendant is detre and how the defend.
ant conducted its business, that will be thesame, bat the
testinony with respect-to each Individual will be different.
The testifiony as to his duties, his occupation, the exercise
of Judement-and discretion, whether he is or is not an ex-
“empt emplovee, in e@neral that will be different, althouel:
Tecan well understand why-some would be grouped together
and being about the saine tvpes of work, but there are sab-
sfantial differences between the various plaintiffs: -But of
COUFSE, with respect'-to the employment ct the tfereat
Plaintiffs, it varies. They were enploved at different\times \
at different rates of pay, some emploved on an “hourly
basis, Othgm jobs, and ultimately Biassteisca into ‘the
Safety Department. Some. were employed directly in the
Safety Department. And ‘some were -teaehers, sonie in-
<tructors, some supervisors, some plain safety engineers, .
[fol. 73] and so forth. Now, if we have to try-each one of
these cases separately-we are in for a very long, tedions
trial. I dont know what Judee Bond's course of procedure
is eoine to he, or what Your Honor’s thonehts are. T do
‘know this: that in one of these enses that was tried. in
St. Paul last vear whieh involved tlre Federal Cartridge
Company, another company operating a plant identical
with this only. smaller, and operatine it under the same
principle and same contract, they had 140 some odd plain-
tiffs, and the Court there ninde ar order directing the plain
tif to Select ont of the group sonie twelve plamtiffs’ cases
for trial and set them aside, the claims of the other plain-
Nfs. for “urther aetion of the Court: And those twelve
senses wore tried: and Tam cinforined it. took twenty-four.
rel days to try these eases. T think hossihly some consid
eration as te the procedyre here would he in order
‘)
—
60 eee ; 7
Mr. Bond: I don't follow you as: to the burden on the +
plaintiff at all. The Fain Labor Standards Act, the main
purpose is presumed to include all employees engaged im
the prodtiction of goods for commerce, which they adinit
in their answer these men were enmployed by them tor the.
periods they sav they were employed. We expect to prove
that they were e ngaged in the, production of goods for
—— They are, therefore, presumed to be under. the
Act and the burden is upon, you to plead and prove exemp-
[fol 74] :tioy and whatever is necessary to be heard on that
will have to come as part of the defense, “LT don't expect to
yut anything like fifivinine men on the witness sfand. 1°
intend to put a few men on to prove the. eeneral features of?
this case, and that the [other] were similarly situated. —-
intend vo prove the exact amount, due then bv Computations
whieh are mere arithmetic made frou, fires thev have
civen me. T can't see that what [: have here and expec!
to put in can take more than a full couple of Axe? testi
mony, That would seem to me to be all the time Rgvonld
‘need. Now, if he. thinks he isegoing to have to take tore
-
®.
we will have to see, whien Oe et te or ue
The Court: T do not. know that T understand ih wine
o- followed ‘in Minnesota. Thev had 160 defe ndants and
the Court made aa order only twelve. cases he heard.
_ Mr. MeRoherts: Your Honor, the opinion of the “Court
starts out with the statement-—
The € ‘ourt: What; judge was that hefore ?° .
Mr. McRoberts: That, was tiled before Judge Jovee, and’
the opening paragraph sivs: “This is an action, by Frode
Anderson and eleven 6ther plaintiffs for recovery, of vary-
ing amounts of overtime compensation, lig hid: ated damages,
attorneys” fees.and costs ander the Fair Labor Standards
Act of 1988. The action isin. the nature of a class sait
in which there are some 164 individual plaintiffs, employ-
[fol. 75] ees-and former employees of defendant, but pursu-
ant to order of court pl: Vintiff ts counsel has selected dhese
twelve medividnal plaintiffs for trial. The remainder wil!
he held until the determination here.”
~ Now, | telephoned to one.of the Counsel, Mr. Il: sisal
Whose nainne appeared here and as eked ler about the order,
.
?
“a
>
:
how it happened to he made. And he-told me in substance
that either at a pre-trial conferenee or at the opening of,
the trial that when itt appeared that each of these elaitus .
“was a.separate @liim and’ that the plaintiffs did) differént >
work and that it Was going to he a very, lone- winded,
- tedious trial, thet the Court- entered this sort of an order
and these twelve? ‘cases were selected and tried. The V are
not res adjudicata as to the other « cases, but it was fe r
that the disposition’ of these twelve éases, being tvanical
would ui ides the Court ey parties in the disposition: rot the
remaining eases. “And it w as tried that wat. And he
tokd me, incident: ally, ae an appeal w as taken and first
arened luis month, & heheve, 11 the Court of “Appe ‘als,
Mr. eae. q now) niititne in a veneral wav abont the
case, To not think it is in shape where Your Honor cond
find any precedent m what wasdoue. J heard about it ne
long avo, and T gata gaps of the briefyand the thing was
prepared and: briefed jn the most remarkable. fashion in
~ the: world, ° I got the \impression<that the’ Judge and a
ereat ummber of. people who were of different classiften.
tions
¢
. &
fol. 76] The Court: I wonder if each one. of the twelve ”
"were iia en classification ? ? ae pce
Mr. Botid: It was all by stipulation. _ 1 got the impres-,
sion if there was an order made-T think it was in-pursuance:
of an agreement.of counsel in chambers to-meet tlie exi-
gencies of, that particular case. But my point is here, we
_ have a right. to bring. a: group "action on behalf of all
people similarly situated. They can join in the same peti-
You. T expeet to prove fifty- nine men were simi arly situ-
“ated, Twill prove the duties, that they had similar duties,
and the testimony 7 will Zive. as to what the-duties were
will he that they we re the same. as to the whole fifty-nine,
Avid it seems to ine itis purely am: utter of defense to pick
sonie fellow ont and show he was net. Your Honor.
Mr. McRoberts: We will object ‘strennonsly to one wit-
tess vetting on. the witness stand and. saving suet and
wehia thine and the others did a certain thing. In some
Mistiners | Helier: the dnties were tdentieal but von wil.
-
2
=
, OL
find quite a variation in the duties of these plaintiffs, they ‘
differed at different times.. I think we are entitled to have,
the: plaisitiff, i& he is, going to make a claim, get on .the
Ww itness-stand ang say W hat his: duties were, to permit us oo.
to cross examine? . ary
Mr. Bond: I don’t havesto go ) any turthior than to prove.
(fol. 77] they were employed at the plant afid engaged in
the production of goods for commerce, andétben the law.
. is presumed to cover them and it is up to the efendant to
make an. affirmative preof. I only say that for the purpose
of showing work was interwoven with production.
Mr. McRoberts: AVitiesses avg to get upon the. witness
stand, and, show, the burden is on the plaintiff to show
that they in their work did produce goods for commerce:
And I do not see how any eee can make that proof
> without going on the w itness: stand. ; 3 : eS -
Mr. Bond: Well, we ea aaa,
_ The Court: All right, proceed.
Thereupon, plaintiffs to sustain. the issues in their bebalf,
offered and presented the following evidence:. ;
3 FRANK N. HARRIS,
‘of lawful age, produced, sworn and examined, testified on
behalf of plaintiffs as follows: ao. .
Direct Examination hy Mr. Bond:
Q. W ill you state your full name, Mr. Harris? --
i Frank N. Harris.
~ @, And where -dogyou live? | |
A. I live at #6 Lakeview Court, Ferguson, Missouri.
[fol. 78} Q. W hat is your present occupation?
“A. I am office Manager St. Louis County Bus ed
Q. What is your age? A. Forty-three.
af Are you the F. N. Harris, one of the plaintiffs i in this
case? A. I. am.
man r.
: O35
4
. Q. Were you employed during the World War during
the period mentioned in this complaint, with -the United
States Cartridge Company? A, Yes,’ sir. : 7
Q. When did you go to work for them Z
A. My original employment with ‘the Cartridge Com-
pany wasn February, [| think.the loth, 1942. E:
Q. Where did you go to get your job” o
A..1 went to 3000 Locust. -
Q. And what occurred there? fos
A. Well, I was .interviewed by a so-called interviewer. .
_ and at that time was told that the only thing they could.
- consider me for was the position of—in the lobby of the
Administration Building. T think the title of the job was—
T can’t recall the name of the title, but my purpose was to
creat the people that-eame to:the Administration Office to
see the imanagement and to see that they were introduced
to the management. rea Ae se “ re les
[fol. 79}, Q. Did youve to work in that eapacity? A. T did.
Q. And. how Jone did you continue in that capacity,
; What did you receive as pay in that capacity?
A. One hundred and fifty dollars a month.
The Court: What éapacity is, that? :
A. I reeall the fame, ii was Receptionist.
Q..And were vou later or did vou later. transfer into the
Safety Department? A, I did.
Q. What was the date of that?
A. T think it was the Sist-of May. te ota aS 5
(). 1942? A. That is correct, seer
-Q. And in what capacity? A. As a safety inspector.
Q. And what were the employment terntis?
_ Mr: MeRoberts: Just a moment, Object to that, it calls
for an opinion of the witness, °°. reetee brie
(). (Mr. Bond) State the facts in reference to it? «
A. 1 was employed at a salary of $200 a-month. 5
Q. Now, at-or about the time of your employment, were
You given a little booklet entitled, ‘Your Job at the St...
Louis Ordnance Plant?!’ A. Yes, sir, I was.
‘(fol 80] Q. T hand-yvou there what purports to he, four of
them,’ which wonld he in the editions for 1941, 1942, 19423
¢
ad
and 1944. Do you recognize these as the booklets that
-were handed to you and other - ee
ea A. Yés, sir, I do,- :
ie Now, describé in a ceneral way this plant out thet e
when yga went to work in this Safety Department. .
A. It consisted of an Administration Building, and I
believe there were eight. production units. -The plant. was
divided into two sections, one known as the restricted area
and the’ other was a general productive area. There were
two power units in the area, and the entire plant was cov-
ered with railroad tracks and also concrete driveways.
- Q: About how many employees were out there, do you
~ know? :
- . A. I don’t know exactly; but I Helieve the .company
claimed at the peak of their production there were in ex-
‘ cess of 40,000 people emploved. ’
Q. What was produced at the plant!
AY Small arms and ammunition.
Q. Now then, when vou entered this safety depattment
on May 3], 1942, what duties were assigned to you?
A. I was told that I would ‘he. assigned to an inspector
by the name tf Burke, who at that time had: been assigned °
to a ‘certain area: Which—consisted of all. of the loading.
primer insert buildings in the’ plant of whieh there were
[fol. 81] eight of each. T was'told to stay with that man
until told otherwise, observe everything there and hy ob-
servation lgarn what mv duties were. "tee tae
Q. And what did those duties turn ont to he? oe
A. We patrolled this given area. which consisted of eight
.
:
loading and primer insert buildings and the powder maga-
zine, which were part of the-operations. We patrolled and
inspected or laoked with regard to the powder magazines.
_ checked and determined that the amount of powder
in starage there did not exceed the maximum set: hv the
Ordnance Safety Department. , And the buildings were
— checked for good honsekeeping fo see that all emplovees
wore the required safety equipment, such as safety shoes
and safety ,gogeles: and check the machines to see thev-
were properly enarded, that there were no aéeumulations
“of excessive powder or primers in the Primer Building.
and checked fer the same conditions, and in addition
thereta to determine whether there were anv exeessive *
o :
=
° . . al ll
storage of primers in thé magazines, ajd finally to aleter-
‘mine {whather] or not people were observing safe prac. ,
tices. ee : | an ates
“Q. Now then, can you give us an example. of what vou
did out there from the time you went out there until you
checked in in the morning antil you checked out at night,
in a general way ‘froin recollectiong ,This would be in the
Produetion-Department unit, that vou are talking about
now, wouldn’t it?) = A. |
‘A. They were Production units, ves, sir. Although the -
[fol. 82] particular buildings were part of the production
of the Cartridge. On the day shift they arrived af’a little _
prior to 7:30,-which was our time on that shift to be there’
and be ready for duty. We arrived alittle before that
-tinie and went downstairs where we had lockers to keep
our clothes which were furnished us by the company. We
were required, of course, to-wear special-duty clothing ot
uniform, either one. The first joh, of course, was to ‘change.
clothes and get in this uniform.. Then at approximately. a®
quarter of the honr, or a quarter of. eight in this case, we
Were ‘supposed to leave the unit and trayel. to onr. certain
area to whieh we were assigned, where we were supposed
to meet the inspector who had heen on duty the preceding
eight hours and who was about to eo off duty. We con-—
ferred with him and determined what conditions he found,
if any, that hadn’t vet been corrected and’ nedded correc-
.tion.. And by that time, of course the change of shifts oc-
curred, and we then proceeded to onr daily duty of the
day which, as T stated hefare, required us to patrol, in-
spect, and, in the event they found a violation or condition’
that needed correction, we were, instructed to not contact:
the employee who was in violation but to report the occur-
rence to his foreman, and if we -failed to get: any .co-.
operation there, to go to his superintendent# *
Q. That foreman or sunerintendent, would he be a Safety
‘Department foreman or be the emplovees’ foreman?
[fol. 83] A. No, sir, he was the employees* foreman, no -con-
nection with the Safety Department.
Q. Go ahead. _ ac ae .
A. Then an added duty, we kept ‘a log in which we kept
a record of the infractions we discovered or conditions we
discovered that needed correcting. We also .kept a> ree-
a
~.
ee i oe
ord of what we did to get the situation corrected. And at -
‘the end of the day, of course, we were required to file a
written report with our own foréman: or supervisor. who
then in turn, transmitted it to the director. In addition tc
these other duties that I recited before in eacl¥ one of the
eight production units in each of these eight buildings was
a first-aid room and ‘worked three shifts. They employed
a nurse, and it was our job of coursé to keep in tofich with
these first-aid wnits and pick out the report that the nurses
had written on all these-first aid cases. We were then re-
‘quired to take those slips out, find, the employee who had
sought first aid, get a description from him or her.of the
accident, how it occurred, what @aused_ it, and if it was
something that could be corrected we were supposed to .
instruct the employee how to avoid a similar occurrence in -
the future. And they had a form‘that we completed on
each one of the occurrences and filed with. our, supervisor
or foreman at the end of. the day,
(). Now then, these buildings that vou spe: kof that. von
patrolled, these machines that -vou inspected, these em: |
[fok. 84] plovees that you observed, were they the build-.
ings, the machines amd employees. wha were engaged in
_ producing the dimimunition at the-plant? A. They were.
Q. Now then, who was there at the head: of the Safety
Department? A. A man by the name of Striekland. —
Q. What was his title?) A. Safety Director.
(). Did he have-any men under him? -
e
etn . . . : % e . e
A. Yes, sir, originally be had’ T believe three assistants.
Q. And these assistants, who were they? Who came?
A. Well, one was a man by. fhe name of MeKitrick,
another by the name of Hurtling. And-he had several, of
course, during the time that I was there.. Another.was a
man by the name of Hirechburger.
Q. You didn't understand my question. Yon are giving
me the director and his assistants? A. That is right.
Q. Now over whom did they’ have supervision? ~That
is what I. want to know—and anthoritv.
A. That director and his assistants and stipervisors,. the ‘i
large ¢roup. of men of which T was one? ‘
Q. That is the point. And that large group of . men of
which vou were one, did they have any title or designation?
[fol. 85] A. Yes, sir.
Ee -) x a e
°
Pgh SBS tnt 40
Q. What were they called out there? 9 ~Ss*
A..Safety Inspectors at that, time.
(). And later was that title changed
A. To Safety Engineer.
Os
change in duties?.
Mr. McRoberts: Just a.moment.. Limit th@t to this wit-
ness, the change in duty. |
Q: As to yourself? A. None whatever.
Q. Now then, did the défendant get out, “or aia ‘the
‘safety director get out any general instructions out there,
- in typewritten form, to be observed by the safety Meineers ? |
A. Yeu, oir. ars
. Q. I shéw you here a blank book and ask vou w hat it is?
A. This is avset of general instructions,
Q. The first two pages, ‘limiting vourself to a set of on
eral instructions which were issued to all safety inspectors
or safety engineers, hy whom were they issued?
Me They were issiied by the Safety Department through
the Educational Division of the Saitets: Department. .
. To whom wWere they issued? |
A. To the safety inspectors.
~ Q. And whom did the safety in: =e include?
[fol. 86] A, Mvself.
Q. And did it, inelude all other safety inspectors?
A. * did.
. Attendant on that change in title was there any
“anit oF all the units, “these ngaced in general instructions -
under which they acted? A. They were—
Mr. McRoberts: Just a moment.
The Court: Wait a minute. When vou see Counsel get-
ting. up, don’t ‘answer. :
Mr,-McRoberts: Object to this wifhess tnpittying as-to |
what instructions were issued to all other safety engineers
unless-hhe was present at the time the instructions were
‘issued to all of them.
Mr. Bond: He was w orking at that plant. for four years
in that department. -He® knows to whom general instrue:
tions were issned. He i is honnd to know tee
te 7 68 ans ke
Mr. MeRoberts: If he was present when all Nhe were
issued, I have no, objection.
Q W hat do you kpow about the book and its issuance?
A. As I told vou, this’ Pook was issyfed by. the Educa-
‘tional Division of. the Safety Department. And. when |
entered the department as-a safety inspector they set ub,
a provision whereby we were required to attend a meeting
once each week. And I can only talk with reference to men
[fol. 87] who attended the meeting and- on the same shift
I was, of which there-were perhaps some 30 or 35 on my
shift, ‘ond the majority of. these men attended these nteet-
on ings weekly.” “And the first meeting we attended we w ere
given, all of us, this_book ‘and told thepe were the general
instructions for the safety engineers, and they outlined
the duties of the safety engincers -bsefiy, |
Mr.-Bond: T ask that be marked-—in arranging my pro-
<<. I. have got some other exhibits that come, A, B.
D’ and, E—I will ask this be marked ‘Plaintiff's Kx-
hibit F’’. (The book is marked as requested) And 1 now
offer in evidence all that part. of pages 1 and 2-confinencing
with the title, ‘The Duties of the Safety Engineers Shall
Be As Follows, ’ and énding with the words. “this see-
_ tion.’’
Mr. McRoberts: Your Honor please, I think the entire’ Ox- ?
hibit ghould be offered in evidence, since tlie witness hes
_. testified that the entire exhibit» a the instruc-
tions given them.
Mr. Bona: N Now, if Your Honor please, I don’t regard this
entire book as being ‘necessary or material to anything in
the case. .I have identified the book.. If he does, it is up .
‘to him to ‘introduce it.
— The Court: It will be offered ott it S 7
_objection.. rea, A
Ls a
a. Cee -
bee ohign to7 5,
Fines OY Sh beds, tA
Ai Pine
Wink AN
.
XN
: 69,
(fol. $8] Plaintiffs’ Exhibit F.
General Tistructions
The Safety Engineer: eee ae ae eis, Sar ee
One ‘Safety Puistncer will be assigned to each. unit or.
special function of plant operation. —
The Supervi ising Safety Engineer on nad shift is re-
é sponsible and will answer for the Safety Engincers, who
are working on the shift of which he is in charge, all
" questions and problems which occur during the shift and
cannot be handled within the unit.
Once weekly, or at any other time he deems it necessary
to do so, the Supervising Safety Engineer shall have a
‘meeting with all of the Safety Engineers over whom he
‘has supervision. At each meeting all problems incidental
to.the units’ will be discussed, as well as Instructions in-
cidental to trating or departmental ‘procedure.
The Thuties of the Safety Engineers shall be as follows:
1. To see that the proper Safety Equipment ‘ji is caee ided
for and worm by employees at all times.
ve V iolations of the rules pertaining - the use of
personal protective equipment, such’ as the failure to
Wear glasses,. the failure to wear the approved types
of hair coverings; the failure ‘to wear safety. shoes; -
the wearing. of jewelry; the operation. of machinery
that is defective or unguarded or inadequately
guarded will be. reported to the Supervising Safety
» Engineers by the Engineer ‘in each unit on each: shift.”
The procedure to be followed in. making this report
and the corrective action to be taken on these infrac-
tions of rules is as follows: a ae. we
1. Upan. noting infractions of - Safety Rules the
. Safety Engineer will procure the badge number and
the department number of the persdn or persons who ‘
are violating the Safety Rules.
*
{tol. 89 |
ee
. He will then report the badge number. and the °
proses of the violation to the offender’ s foreman or
supervisor. a
3. At the. end. ot each working: shift, anal Safety os
Engineer. will submit a rpport to his supervisor eee
‘regard to. these violations.
This report will be ‘made on the Safety Inspection
Report form, IRS-25 and, will embody the «following
information:.
, 1. The hedge. wumbet ‘of the person who v10-
bee the Safety Rule. ) e-
.. The number of the department in which the
eaoe. is employ ed.
3. The nature of the violation. .
$
@ The name and badge number of the foreman
or’ supervisor. ot the department in which the
violator is employed. ae 3
3. The- reaction of the supervisors upon receiv-
. ing the. -Feports of these violations will be noted
by; the Safety Engineer, and he will incorporate
in his -re sport his — on ‘the supervisor’ S
-attitude. ee
NY
6. The Safety idea wilt n not attempt any
correction of these violations by contacting the: |
individuals who are guilty of these violatio
In ‘all’ cases he will contact the superviso
, of
‘the individual concerned and “will leave corspctive
action to the. supervisor. ;
This report will state the wioking shift dee
a which these incidents .occurred. The shift
check in'the upper right hand corner will not be
“used in making this report. Instead, each Safety
Engineer will write the’ date and the time of his
working shift at the top’ of the _— page in
this manner— a , s ; Ta
AQ
en Hf ribs id bee os i Se 27 vi Ldeinitty ON %, y i i,
{ies ARE Cae ae a
At zs . fesagantbree tee Mies Sep
. *
:
ais a Sn
; " f CLES EEA PMO DANA Me RES Pe TA OD gs ‘: * ‘ ’
Ip atced Tibasers ted Racer a ta tire aa Bia Bae tole he de MN Mra Wy! | SD eg) CRN ; ee Aen are eee 0
y ae on Opens oF Tee Os Tt, ee Dl ee ale ad cag EE Ca) SAE eee Boge ON le ag oAtze je sae ‘ die kate ve p
: "antl oP etek ee ae ae’ a % o . SP se CRE RI oh PPR Nod Mica, ae ye BAT Hoses -
cat Ree ar RxD: : i 6G dy aes PS Og pay a Pilates, arene © ele FM dices, Yan
Oe PUSH ve TGA gh j i M3 - Sei SRS aid eo > % ( Toi. Seg ele OAD Eh,
! ; ; ; ra: é eros 4 pte
P
, wy. .°
nn
o . January pees
ee eek eee
"ge -— 12 Midnight
- Midnight =i; SAM:
Should not violations. exist ‘during the working
shift, a, report of sueh condition will be made in the
- manner as is outlined above. Consult sample report
. Which js included ‘in this manual..
wil
an
An exception to: this rule will be. made. uate an
- employee is engaged in some operation, whereby
‘death or serious injury may -resalt. Should this con-
dition exist the Safety Engineer will stop the haz-
ardous operation | and will immediately seek the super-
eport the incident to him and will explain in.
vile the person who was performing such act and
l
_ de ail why he caused such operation to be ‘stopped.
2.
tions and to, observe and correct. any unsanitary Or, un-.
ie healthful condition.
These observations. will be ‘mebenerated 3 in. the daily log. |
To sbeanie and correct onsale methods and condi-
Items of major importance will be cov ered by a: separate
‘report.. In obtaining corrective action on unsatisfactory
conditions: which may. be found, the same flow will be —
follow ed. as is ‘outlined in item + of this, section.
[fol. 90} - B. (Check list of mechanical items) -
1s Mushines and euiiaaal belts, oiling devices, tools,
and appliances. a
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.