Transcript of Record — United States Ex Rel. Knauff v. Shaughnessy

Supreme Court brief1950

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

~ TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD —

~

| Supreme Court of the United sites

OCTOBER TERM, 1949

: _ No, 54

~~

THE: UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, ‘EX REL:

, ELLEN KNAUFF, PETITIONER, 3

vs.

EDWARD J. SHAUGHNESSY, ACTING DIRECT

OF IMMIGRATION AND NATURALIZATION

. ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO. THE UNITED STATES COURT OF —

APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT

"PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED APRIL 18, 1949.

CERTIORARI GRANTED ace! 2, 1949.

Aon a art a ne ne nae nae inte

INDEX

Order allowing certiorari

a

oa PAGE

Statement Under-Rule 15............. Srp BRT OR a tenet Satoh 1

Writ of Habeas Corpus..... Cory ey ae yoo 2

Petition OP More Wl TOMO «occ cscs Sti en Se 3

Exhibit I, Annexe to Petition. -............... ae

Return to Writ of Habeas Corpus......:..........- 6

Traverse......,/>. Rede eesnhetei swears ces srctnccens 8

Excerpt ee MOINS on 5 sos kee ns 12

NE EE EO een ee 28

meer 10: Show Cause... ....:.......4... Re re: 36

Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson 1 in Support of Order to

_ Show Cause... i icesciv ease e eee ec eee rece cence ee 3

Exhibit 11, Annexed to Affidavit of Gunther Jacob- :

i gos 6 a tee yo ek p05 soe a ih Os 44

Exhibit 12, Annexed to Affidavit of Gunther Jacob- ~~.

ASRS Peete ere ea SE Ee Ee ae ey ee Or eT 48

Exhibit 13, Annexed to Affidavit of Gunther Jacob

ce LEE TEER EO CSTE TL Pe UEC PETE EE CORBET eT 00

Exhibit 14, Annexed to Affidavit of Gunther Jacob-

| a ree Eee errors 00

Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson Amending Previous Af-

-fidavit in Support ‘of Order to Show Cause........ 52

- Memorandum Opmion of Hulbert, J. . 6... veces ee 54

Order Dismissing Writ of Habeas One sic se 55

Notice of Appeal....... ib isie Se sie ales 56

Stipulation as to Correctness of IG oo ess --

Clerk’s Certificate................-. Pr ckiews repre oo

Proceedings in U.S.C.A.,-Second C ircuit 60

Opinion, i 6 hase, * & 7 60)

Judgment , . co See Ine 3. a

Clerk’s certificate. (omitted in printing) / 72

73

il

oe

ReLatror’s Exurpirs®

PAGE

1—Letter of ‘Recommendation of Ellen Boxhornova 12

J—tLetter to Henry A. Hendry fron M. J. Aronson, Z

dated March 20, 1947..... eens seh ew A ee backs 14

3—Copy of War Department Notification of Person-

nel Action of Ellen Knauff................ es: at:

4—Copy of War Department Notification of Person-

nel Action-of Elien Knauff. POPP Le SP

5—Letter to Ellen Knauff from W. WV. Lindsay, dated

Se ae ee rer he ere re rep rire 60

6—Letter from George W. Olson. dated March 9, 1948 21

7—Copy of Internal Route Slip of Headquarters,

European CIN as Givi ks bie ce re 0s chee 22

8—-Letter from Tom, Attorney" General to Joseph D.:

Nunan, Jr., dated October 4, 1948.............. 24

. 9—Letter from Tom, Attorney General to Joseph D.

Nunan, Jr., dated September 9, 1948............

10—Allied/Neutral Extension of Employment Agree-

ment Form (Revised)....... Cro Neer ge aoe

* Admitted into evidence at page 12 hereof.

Rnited States Court of Appeals

For the Second Circuit

ra

Ww

Unitep States or AMenrica, ex rel., ELLEN Kwnavrr,

against

W. Frank Warkiys, District Director of Immigration and

Naturalization Service, —

Respondent-A ppellee.:

oD

Ww

Ss

Siatoenent Under Rule 15 s

This is an appeal from an order of the Honorable Mur-

ray Hulbert, United States District Judge, entered on Jan-

uary 3, 1949. No hearing was held on said writ except that

during the argument thereof held on November 16, 1948,

_ Judge Hulbert permitted documentary evidence to be of-

fered. This appeal from the aforesaid order was taken on

January 4, 1949. |

There was no change of parties or attorneys.

Relator-Appellant, |

2

to

Writ of Habeas Corpus

Unitep States or AMERICA, ~~}

‘ i ’ SS, “

SouTHERN District or New York,

: Civ. 47-585

To: W. Frank Watkins, District Director of Immigration

sf Naturalization for the District of New York and/or

___whomsoever may have the custody of the body of

oe Ellen Knauf.

You ARE HEREBY COMMANDED that you have the body of

Killen Knauff, by you imprisoned and detained, as it ts

said, together with the time and cause of such imprison-

ment and detention, before one of the Judges of the United

States District Court within and for the District aforesaid

on the 13th day of October 1948 at 10:30 o’clock in the |

for noon of that day, in the United States Court House,

Room 506, in the Borough of Manhattan, City of New York,

to do and receive all and singular those things which the

said Judge shall then and there consider of you in this be-

half, and have you then and there this Writ. :

ev

Wirness, the Hoscuania Joun C. Knox, Jadee of this

g¢ Court, at New York, N. Y,, in the said District, this 9 day of

October, 1948.

Wim V. Connell,

Clerk. |

Writ ALLowep Oct. 9, 1948.

VINCENT L. LEIBELL,

U. 2. Bd.

~]

Petition of Kurt W. Knauff

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT,

For THe SovutTuern District or New York.

[Same Tite]

The petition of Kurar W. Kwavrr, a

, this Court:

1. Iam the husband of Ellen Knauff who is, at present

at Ellis Island, detained by respondent, und I make this -

petition for the purpose of inducing this Court to issue a

Writ of Habeas Corpus in behalf of my said wife.

2. Tama citizen of the United States by naturalization,

having been naturalized on April 23, 1943 in the United

States District Court of the Eastern District of South Caro-

lina, number of citizenship papers: 5488116.

3. During the World War, I was a soldier in the Armed

Forces of the United States from November 21, 1942 to

_ January 17, 1946, at which time I received an honorable.

discharge at the Fort Dix, New Jersey separation center.

A photostatic copy of my discharge papers is annexed

hereto and made a part hereof, and marked ‘*Exhibit L"’.

4. On February 28, 1948, I married my above named

wife, EHen Knauff, whose maiden name was Ellen Raphael,

at Frankfurt, Germany. Said marriage was consummated

| With the permission of the Office of the Advocate General.

5. At the time of my marriage, my said wife was au

employee of the Signal Division of the United States Army

in ‘Germany. ! : —

10°

11

12

4

Petition of Kurt-W. Knauff

6. My said wife proceeded to the United States where

she arrived on August 14, 1948. Since said day she has:

been detained by the Immigration and Naturalization Servy-

ice at Ellis Island, New York, subject to admission pro-

ceedings, and I have just been notified by the Office of the

Commissioner of Immigration and Naturalization that

she has been excluded from the United States for security

reasons, and that her appeal from an exclusion order of

the Board of Special Inquiry has been denied.

7. The exclusion of ‘my said wife is arbitrary and illegal,

in that she has ‘been at all times loyal to the United States,

and that she has a right to admission to the United States

under Public Law 271 of December 2§, 1945.

8. My said wife is not being held for the commission

of any crime, or for any other reason except as aforesaid.

No previous application has been made for the relief

herein demanded.

WHEREFORE, it is respectfully prayed that this Court

issue a Writ of Habeas Corpus to inquire into the legality

of my wife’s detention, and to determine the justification

thereof. : : os “

| Kurt W. Kwavrr.

(Verified by Gunther Jacobson, October 8,-1948.)

Exhibit I, Annexed to Petition

Copy or HonorasBLre DiscHarGE FROM LU. BS. z=

(See opposite page agg”)

~ Exhibit I, Annexed to Petition

Honorable Discharge

This & te ceoliy thal

KURT W KN‘UFF 32- 639° 552 TECHNICIAN FOURTH GRADE

HQ BATTERY 100TH DIVISION

| Army of the Matted States ~ =" |

mr hereby Hionoraby Discharged , the mililary

Pa onl aaa :

aad Dept Avec & Me wean

G 6 SEPARATION CENTER

ten al FORT DIX, NEW JERSEY

Dale 17 JANUARY 1946

Pe care

{

J.H.GUNTER. -

AJ IR INFANTRY

f; 7

| % os » | Py .

ENLISTED RECORD AND REPORT OF SEPARATION

saa DISCHARGE 3

- ARMY SERIAL NO. . 3. @RADK | 4. ARM OR GERVICE | S. COMPONENT

AUS

Laey AME - FIRST NAME MIDDLE INITIAL

‘ “ORGAN: ‘nat LON 7. DATE OF SEPARATION 6. PLACE OF SEPARATION

[ae STRY 1 00TH DIVISION Oy: JAN iy | SEP CTR FT. DIX tiv

r 10. DATE OF BIRTH 1. PLACE OF BINA CS

11h 20 1338D ST SO OZONE PK LI NY J CEC 1408 |. GERMANY

2 AODRE 33 eae: WHICH EMPLOYMENT WILL BE SOUGHT t3. COLOR EVES | 14. COLOR MAIR] 18. HEIGHT 16. WEIGHT

Jseesg | | } | | BLUE | BROWN} 6-0 | 190

ore 19. MARITAL STATUS 20. U.S. CITIZEN | 81. CIVILIAN OCCUPATION AND NO.

17. NO CEPEKO

QO

in ot wEcRO “OTHER (epecity) sinqt/@annizo ~ oTner {specify) |\ y NO } = |

_Aaaee Es Ne RADIO REPAIRMAN 5-53.411

age oe — MILITARY HISTORY

2 DATE OV INDUCTION . DATE OF ENLISTMENT | 24. SAT OF EHTRY INTO ACTIVE seavics| 28. PLACE OF ENTRY INTO SERVICE

yal Ncv he 28 NOV h2 Ne ONY

neteins “eeeistenen! 27. iccak 8 6 poARO HO. | 28. COUNTY ANO STATE 20. HOME ADDRESS AT TIME OF ENTRY INTO SERVICE

| sravice NO ;

st be Wis! occ. laerne co wy | SR WEXFORD TERRCE HOLLIS 4

10 MILITARY OCCUPATIONAL SPECIALTY AND NO. — B1, MILITARY QUALIFICATION Ame BATS (ie. infantry, aviation and marksmanehip badgee, etc.)

RADIO CPLRATOR | 776 __ICARBINE SS 171 19 AUG 43

42. Forse pen, AND CAMPAIGNS

-|CENTRAL EUROPE, RHINELAND —

'{G0 33 WO 45 AS AMENDED __

DECORATIONS AND CITATIONS

R cacer bus f# Crk MiDOL EASTERN SERVICE MEDAL, GCOD conpuct MEDAL, WORLD

WeR_11 ViCTORY MEDAL, AMERICAN SERVICE MEDAL |

. WOUNDS RECEIVEO IN ACTION

NOV: ian sew 7 : ; 4

SERVICE OUTSIOE CONTINENTAL U.S. AND RETURN

here iii. = Tee alae (epecily) | sate be DEPARTURE DESTINATION DATE OF ARRIVAL

ebaucl 1yauGhg 314UGK) NONE beer Te TO 20 WT 4k

|.37. "ss TOTAL LENGTH OF SERVICE 38. HIGHEST GRADE HELD | - aise 3 :

aac a eee a } 31 bec 45 | USA — | 10 VEN 46

ai Th ay. 1.4 | ; ne

Sculdiieeeediantieedne ee

' | 3@. PRIOR SERVICE

a Se | oo sje:

| 40. REASON AND AUTHORITY FOR SCFARATION ; ORV Ni] THT E OF THE SAVE RN \

71i0ND RR 1-1 (DEMOBIL IZATION )

42. EDUCATION we ars)

i 4. SERVICE | SCHOOLS ATTENDED .

: i Sie aes : ~ Cramer 1 High Sepec! ( Coilegg

- mb ih. Bm afi ET I en SE SY a SS ee! ode ae ye at eS

—

16

a

18

Return to Writ of Habeas Corpus

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT,

For THe Soutuern Distaict ory New York.

: Civil 47-585

Zz

[Same Tite}

I, Auvin LiesperMAN, an attorney employed by the United

States Department of Justice, Immigration and Naturali-

zation Service, hereby certify and make return to the writ.

of habeas corpus heretofore sued out by the relator herein

as follows: |

1. The relator, a 33 year old female, native of Germany,

last a citizen of Czechoslovakia, presently stateless, arrived

at the port of New York on August 14, 1948, ex USAT

‘Comfort’’, and applied for admission to the United States

under the provisions of Public Law 271. On that day she -

was temporarily excluded from admission to the United

States by an immigrant inspector under the provisions of

8 C. F. R. 175.57.

2. On October 6, 1948, the Assistant Commissioner of

Immigration and Naturalization recommended that the

relator’s temporary exclusion be made permanent without —

the right of a hearing before a Board of Special Inquiry

under the provisions of 8 C. F. R. 175.57. On the same

day, this recommendation was adopted by the Attorney

General, who ordered relator excluded from the United

States.

T

Return to Writ of Habeas Corpus a 19 .

-3. Relator is presently detained at Ellis Island, New

York Harbor, New York, under the aforementioned order

of exclusion. — aes

WHEREFORE, it is respectfully prayed that the writ of

habeas corpus herein be dismissed and the relator remand-

ed to the custody of the respondent.

Dated: New York, N. Y., November 10, 1948.

_Axnvin LIEBERMAN.

| 2)

9

23

24

8

Traverse

_-UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, _

SouTHerN District or New York.

Civil 47-585

see

Pact

[Same Tite]

State or New York | [_

' ¥ bd SS ”

County or New York ge

Ellen. Knauff, the relator, herein, as and for a traverse

to the return of respondent, says:

_ (1) I hereby repeat and re- iterate all allegations of

the petition for habeas corpus.

(2) I applied for admission pursuant to section 232 of

title 8, U. S. C. (Public Law 271, of 1945) as the wife of

a United States citizen having an honorable discharge cer-

tificate from the armed forces of the United States during

the Second World War. Said statute provides, with —

to spouses of such+veterans, that they

‘*shall, if otherwise admissible under the immigra-

tion laws and if. application for admission is made

within three years of December 28, 1945, be admitted.

to the United States.’’ |

Contrary to the-mandates of the s statues I have been

detained without reason at Ellis Island. since August 14, :

1948, and illegally deprived of my liberty.

(3) The proceedings before the Imicaigration and Nat-

uralization Service are illegal and arbitrary in that the

statutory proceedings were not administered to me. Pur-

9

Traverse

suant to 8 U. S. ©. 153 Boards of Special Inquiry shall

have authority to determin whether an alien is allowed

to land. I was not placed before such board. No exclusion

order was entered against me as provided by law. I was

held at Ellis Island and for five weeks refused seeing a

Jawyer and access to the courts. During this time Iwas

secretly examined and questioned by an official and finally

advised that I was excluded from the United States. I

submit that this procedure is contrary to law.

(4) The reason or excuse for my exclusion has been

stated by Attorney General Tom C. Clark in a letter ad-

dressed to Mr. Joseph D. Nunan who intervened in my.

behalf. This letter reads as follows:

“THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

| WASHINGTON, |

: October 4, 1948.

Dear Joe:

Since talking with you last week, I haye aguin °

looked into the case of Mrs. Ellen. Knauff.

I can see no alternative to excluding her. She

was formerly a paid agent of the Czechoslovakian

Government, and reported on America pefsonie

assigned to the Civil Censorship Division in Ger-

many. The Federal Bureau of Investigation feels

that she would be a hazard to internal security.

‘I am sorry not to be able to give you a more

favorable conclusion. :

With every kind wish,

. 3 3 Sincerely,

NUNAN,

Attorney General.

Joseph D. Nunan, Jr., Esquire,

Commonwealth Building,

Washington 6, D. C.’’

tS.

rn) |

26

27

ne

29

30

10 —

. Traverse

(5) I hereby state that the facts stated in this letter

are untrue and that there is no evidence upon which this

charge is based and that I was never confronted with any

evidence to substantiate this charge.

I am of German Jewish descent. Prior to the war I was.

admitted to Great Britain asa refugee. Being a violent

anti-Nazi, | enlisted in the royal air force where | serve!

honorably from January 1, 1943, to May 30th, 1946. At

the time of my discharge I was a flight sergeant and my

discharge papers state:

‘*(c) Cause of discharge Services no longer re-

MO TE I I io oi oso ho ak

(d) General character (1) during service Ver;

Good, (11) on discharge Very Good ............

She is very_ intelligent and of guod personality

and character. She has given every satisfaction.”

/

The discharge-papers were executed by the: Air Com-

modore on July 26, 1946.

(6) Upon ‘my discharge from the Royal Airforce |

found employment with the American War Department,

Occupation Forces, in Frankfurt, Germany. I served there

first for the Civil Censorship Divisions, thereafter for the

Signal Division. I left this employment teniporarily after

my marriage in order to go to the United States, in June

1948. My service record in the War Department was

exemplary and I have favorable certificates from every

American superior for whom I worked. I would still be

with the U. S. Army, had I not had the desire to establish |

residence in the United States within the time limited by f

Public Law 271 of 1945, i.e. before December 28, 1948.

(7) In order to denise w.th the requirebents of said

law I was given leave of absence, with the understanding ]

~,

% ~

11 oF

Treverse

; . {" ad

that after my admission to the United States for permanent

residence I would return to Frankfort to continue my serv-

ice in behalf of the government of the United States.

(8) I married my husband in February 1948 with the

consent of the Commanding General of the Frankfurt mili-

tary post of the U.S. Army. Before such consent is given, -

a thorough check is made by tbe Office of the Judge Advo-

cate General. Only after I had been given a clean bill by

all service commands and intelligence agencies were we

permitted to marry.

(9) I believe that I am a victim of a foul denunciation

_ of a woman jealous of my husband. I submit that I should

not: be treated by the Department of Justice the way I have

been treated, without a hearing and on secret t denuncia-

tions.

(10) I never gave any information to any previous or

present Czech government. I never received a penny in

payment from any Czech Government.

(11) My husband came to this country on a special

furlough, to help me in my trouble. He has to return to

his post on November 22, 1948. Request is made to take his

testimony at once that it will be available before his de-

_ parture.

(12) There is no legal basis for rule 175.57 C. F. R.

and the Star Chamber proceedings administered to me

thereunder.

-WuHeEREFORE I pray this court to release me from custody.

EvLven Kwnacvrr.

Jl

33

12

— 34

Excerpt From Stenographer’ s Minutes.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, .

SOUTHERN District or New YoOrK.

~ Civ. 47-585

[Same Tite |

Before: 3 oe

: Hon. Murrey ‘Sv.sert, :

35 — District Judge.

New York, November 16, 1945,

11:45 A. M..

Appearances:

GUNTHER Jacosson, Esq.,

Attorney for Relator.

— Joun F. X. McGouey, Esq., United States Attorney, |

For the Respondent;

By William J: Sexton, Esq., Assistant United States

3 Attorney.

36 ae

After argument of counsel and presentation of certain

documents to the court, the court ruled as follows:

Let the stenogr apher have these letters so that they cat

be put in the record, and you can have them back.

Mr. Jacobson: Very good, sir. :

(Marked Relator’s Exhibits 1 to 10 inclusive.)

13

: ae

_ Relator’s Exhibit 1_ |

‘GROUP “B” 7742 CIVIL CENSORSHIP DIVISION

: -EvROPEAN ComMAND -

“«

_ APO 757 - U. S. Aany

a 6 August. 1947

~~ ee ey eee

201—Boxnorxova, Ellen

Susyect: Recommendation of Ellen BoxHornova

‘To : Whom it may concern

1. This is to state that Ellen Boxuornova, Allied Civ rilan 38

Employee, has been employed with this organization as

a Relevant Record Analyst and Monitor from 27 May 1946

to present date. / :

peo Employee’ s conduct has been satisfactory and. her

_ last efficiency rating reads: ‘‘Very Good”’.- ,

~ For Tue Commanpinc OFFICER:

: oe tice Mark Wixyn

Ist Lt., CAC

; 3 ‘Adjutant |

Telephone: Frankfurt 85051 a 99

2

3

Mr. Jay J. Van Trawver

40

14

‘ Relator’s Exhibit 2

20 March 1947.

; My dear Hendry,

Learning that my friend, Ellen Boxhornova, was plan-

uing to stop over at Nurnberg on her way ‘to Prague, I

have asked her to drop in to see you and convey my cordial —

regards to you.

te.

_- { have known Ellen practically since my arrival in

Frankfurt, and have had many opportunities of exchang-

ing ideas with her, and generally of appraising her irtelli-

gence and character. My appreciation of her abilities and

her physical charm has grown increasingly with every new |

encounter. In my opinion she is far above the, average

in background and general competence.

Ellen is at present employed as a Research Analyst

with the CCD. - She mentioned to me,. however, that she

was planning to resign shortly in order to rejoin the

WAAF’s with whom she served a number of years during

the war. I tried to dissuade her from this decision because

I feel that her special knowledge of things German, her

perfect command of the English language, and her insight

-into current problems 1s could be used to greater advantage ‘

by the United States Government in Germany at this time.

I am convinced that she would be an invaluable asset

to you in connection with the Nurnberg trials. I strongly

15.

Relator’s Exhibit 200 43

‘recommend Ellen Boxhornova to you for the highest con-

sideration which it is in your power to extend to her.

Witb warm regards,

.: °. .M. J. Aroxson

Be : - Major Jaap.

The Honorable : : :

Henry A. Hendry,

Secretary General,

International Military Tribunal,

Nurnberg, Germany. 44

aah oa. pe * s oe

hee CECORATIONS AND CITATIONS

|: UROPEAN-SFRECAN-MIDDLE EASTERN

IWR Ti MiCTORY MEDAL, AMERICAN

| 34. WOUNDS RECEIVES IN ACTION

no

MEDEL, GOOD CONDUCT MEDAL. WORLD |

MEDS *

seRVice

SERVICE

SERVICE OUTSIOE CONTINENTAL U.S. AND RETURN

DESTINATION

Sos ae

{[ se.

DATE OF DEPARTURE

& CCT 4k

31 DEC 45

LAavesT IMMUNIZATION DATES

. _ T¥PKOIO TETANUS oTman (specify)

NONE

36. HIGHEST GRADE HELD

—

DATE OF ARR VAL

20 OT 457

Saucy 14auGy 14UG4

TOTAL LENGTH OF SERVICE

“3? :

i, ONTINENT AL SEAVICE

| ‘ aus i kis "Ty

“$e. “pRIOR sEAVICE

- WONT.

POREIGN SERVICE

Bere

5

1 10 JEN 46

=

“40. REASON ANO AUTHORITY FOR SCPARATION s | a

JNO RR 1-1 (DEMOBILIZATION) noe es rth Se

at. SERVICE oom ATTENDEO ,

1042

aera nastnvactsnoarnte: sana ni

os CIV RADIO SCii 200 HOURS RADIO OPERATOR

PAY DATA

43 LONGEVITY FOR Pat Pugrosge

_ 44: MUSTERING OuT PAY

vane | — | ines

| 47. FOTAL AMOUNT, NAME OF DISBURSING OFFICER

+ 253 61

.J HARRIS COL fC

~ TOT “300 | 00

IF PREMIUM 16 NOT PAID WHEN DUE OR WITHIN THIRTY-ONE Dave THEREAFTER, INSURANCE WILL LAPSE. MAKE CHECKS OR MONLY CROERS

87. PERSONNEL “Orricun

c white UR iA ; )

IMPORTANT pavaSLe TO THE TREASURER OF THE U. 8. AND FORWARD TO COLLECTIONS SUBDIVISION, VETERANS AOMINIGTRATION, NM, WASHINGTON 28. D.C.

}4e. KIND OF INSURANCE | 49. HOW PAID so pay ‘Date of Allet- | a1. Fo of ext Premlom Bee | 52. paauiue pue|_sa. IMTENTION OF VETERAN rot

ene Ieee ; Aitaseat —. Dtesemtinszsce NONE Caatione Speeds Diecentiaes

eee SS. AZMARKS (This apace for completion of above Meme er @nty of ofber sme apeciiod is W. D. Directives

oe 2 LAPEL: BUTTON ISSUED - * me.

es : INACTIVE ERC FROM 21 o> TO-27 NCV liz

eS & PSR SCORE (2 SEP 1945)-55 Som :

ee + 3/7

BRR = PERSON BEING SEPARA ni

J

wO AGO FORM 83 - SB

1 November 1944 persone

. entitled ‘o an Honcrable Discharge, which

will not Sai used alier receipt of this revision.

STANDARO FORM 5Q. a 1 6

ore, TD STATES on is

: ‘OCTOBER 1946 | WAR DEPARTMENT

\. NAME (MR. —BlS$—MRS.—FIRST—-MIDOLE INITIAL—4. AST) 2. DATE OF BIRTH |

E}len Kneuff : 1-1-15

aes ’

This ie to notify you of the following action affecting your employment: age on 5 : ne

§. NATURE OF ACTION (USE STANDARD TERMINOLOGY) 6. EFFECTIVE DATE =| 7. CIVIL SERVICE OR OTHER LEGAL AL THORITY

D aeei-nnent - Cor~ection Jiorch 1,194% | Schedule A-1-?

— E* ; vo ae

-| ®. POSITION TITLE rie |

Slerk Ty»vist Bs Clerk S+erto

Si¢-PeT-76° | } | 81g-5%-270 .

ae 9. SERVICE. GRADE. |

2eS, 11800 Dare p.ae SALARY - Se7e

Chief Signe? Officer, F 4 4 10. ORGANIZATIONAL Seme

Sienel Tretnin:; \< Survey — ee |

Frenkfurt, Germeny aFC 757 ~ ;

sUCOM : | 11. HEADQUARTERS -Seme — ) | -

| | | i

[% | rie DEPARTMENTAL 12. FIELD OR DEPTL , y | FID DEPARTMENTAL

13. REMARKS | 7

wesictency raving is goo. : wetionielityvs Czech:

Residence : WK :

- Relator’s Exhibit 3 =

Copy or War DeEpaRTMENT NOTIFICATION OF |

- PERSONNEL ACTION -

(See opposite page Bay~)

foe

Relator’s Exhibit 4

Core oF War DEPARTMENT Norirication: OF

PERSONNEL ACTION

(See opposite page Ba~)

aa nen sce bee AO ATEN

IO RE SAPP MOET :

Set AAA ARE LATENT

Relator’s Exhibit 4

4

: ee oS nov * ae ae Seg. fo

STANDARD FoRM SQ ae | Ki ) a ry ron aprsovs’

| UNITED STA © e ‘ | GUDGET GUMLAL NO. Bae

: 3 toes | eG, WAR DEPARTMENT ee 2

: NOTIF ICATION. OF. PERSONNEL ACTION 7 JOJ

1. MAME, (AR. 26195 —DRS.—PIRST—MMDOLE IITIAL—LAST) : 2 DATE OF BIRTH | 3 JOURNAL ORACTION No | 4 DATE

silen ,aauff - oe es ee ee ee

Thie ie to notify you of the following action affecting your employment: ee See

he NATURE OF ACTION (USE STANDARD TERMINOLOGY). 4 EFFECTIVE DATE 7. CIVIL SERVICE OR OTHER LEGAL AUTHORITY

jane change from; Bllea poxhoracva” Feb ad, led) cs Rule xTII

ee | T° | =

| 8. POSITION TITLE | : = sees

Clerk Ty;ist be 2 ae

546 -reTo262 . ee be ;

©.3°9, $1500 base pe@. * SALARY oe aie

Coléu, F& T —_ Traiuing 10. ORGANIZATIONAL |

& survey, TIONS 5a

Fraakfurt, anreeae arO 757 |

EUCOM 1. HEADQUARTERS : S3me

: x FilD | : me DEPARTMENTAL | 12. FIELD OR DEPTL = , x =| FIo ‘DEPARTMENTAL :

1X REMARKS , : af 3 |

‘New® change due to warr iage rebruary. 26, (1548. Jatiouaiity: czech

: 4ployec is married to eae y.s, civilian, cgc-&.. .:;esiaeuce . Us,

’ . Relator’s Exhibit 7

IC Form 1.1 (19 Mer 4?)

mov 16 1948

— se INTERNAL ROUTE SLIP ah

oO ome eae HEADQUARTERS, EUROPEAN COMMAND © 54h

FLE NO: Se: ws | 7 |

SUBJECT: I ee. a tae | pate: 17 Noveter 1947 ©

(Number eech memo or minute consecutively Fill in each cotumn, signed iegibly

drew @ tine across the sheet. Use entite width of sheet for tong memorande )

From | Pass to Date ; : | HAS THIS PAPER BEEN COORDINATED With ALL CONCERNED? 6 \

| Chief} To A7 Nov ; | l. Miss Ellen. Soohernova has teen ‘qa loyed ~

Sig | Whom | 1947 by this office since 1 Se ptember 4947 until ‘the

20g it present time.

26 Qo or about 1 Gevanted! 1947 Kiss

PPT | | Boxhornove wili be availabie for reassignment rs

Liv. | _ tais branch is to te dissclved. .

5- Miss hoxiornove nas proved very capable

as a typist, the only position she held in my employ.

She is reliable, conscientous end trustworthy and I

woulda be. very pleesed to have her work for me agéin.

"ks Tne folowing items are submitted: oS

a. Character; Excelient

~, be &fficiency: kxcellent.

Captain, — Corps

a

20

Relator’s Exhibit 5

HEADQUARTERS °

_ EUROPEAN 4 ‘(OMMAN D

snenanamatisdan dtr)

BAA TRACE EI

APO 403 US. Army ;

18 June 1948 ©

To Wuom Ir May CONCERN :—

y : 4

ee Ellen Knauff has been employed as my secretary

since 1 April 1948. :

Lhave always-found Mrs. Knauff to be discreet, capable,

and siterested in her work. I do not hesitate to recommend

. her Ot sas i emia

W. W. Liypsay

—W. W. Lixvsay

Lt. Colonel

Signal Corps

/ WWL nth

21

Relator’s. Exhibit 6 :

H EADQUARTE RS

EUROPEAN COMM AND

Officé of the: Chef Signal Oileas

APO 757

9 March -1948

To Wuom Ir May Concern: as

1. Miss Ellen Boxhornova has. been under my personal

daily observation during the past six months. Her assign-

ment included the usual stenographic, and typing duties

--and in addition librarian responsibilities for a highly tech-

nical and specialized library for the Signal Corps: Techni-—

eal Board.

2. Miss Boxhornova always exhibited excellent com-

petence in handling her assignment without continuous ,

supervision and while achieving efficient results. Her good

judgement and common sense resulted in work well done. |

I helieve Miss Boxhornova is @apable of sg any position

calling for the above. characteristics.

George W. Olson

GrorGE .W: OLson. ~

Captain, Signal Corps

61

62

63

: _ ne ; ;

Chief Sisnar! JUfticer, r = 4 10. ORGANIZATIONAL seme : |

Signal Tretnin; < Survey sicereeoeiiaies | :

Frinkfurt, sermeny art 7?

zUCOM , 11, HEADQUARTERS = |] Geme | ;

: i : |

[7% | rie DEPARTMENTAL 12. FIELD OR DEPT L Ty |] rep [| oepantwestaL

13. REMARKS | : : : |

affictency rating 1+ goo. ees NetLoielitv: Czech

| " , . > Residence :. AWK

_} 3890.00 Sase 9.2. wate : | oe a : a

] 40.9%O Qtrs. : Z 3 , i ;

— §11.60 Sumber 3 soins

ms *O Gross p.a. rate for 46 hr. wk.

‘thie ‘inetrumen® corrects item Ps of SF 50 dated Marc. l, 1948

to show employee's name sc Ellen peetts instead of Ellen Boxbornova

due to marriage on February 28, "946 2 | ne

e |

: ae Ae SAFI

1S. VETEAAN'S PREFERENCE 7 16. POSITION CLASSIFICATION ACTION

nome srt! epome 2 ia ae pepe wer} a jaca

Sally ees yd ° ew oe

i OSA! wire wine! 7 te _ y, ene

as % A Zt

| ea er, a | / : ie 73

7. | 3 2. TOC. S, | 21. DATE OF OATH 22. LEGAL RESIDENCE

ey * 19. APPROPRIATION | pas oS cs i a , pA

| _ To: ‘ i

coeemeeiaiiihcciaitenaanntnenainieminaaiatineeeminta ees , 7

® © Govenwanst relerine orvves § = 16800881 3 AGL: (81> 3 OR" SERE~ ES" 8807 nN

+? ‘ e

; . off

«yey

oe

-Relator’s Exhibit 7

Cory or InternaL Route Sum or Heap@uakters,

EvuRopEAN CoMMAND —

(See opposite page Bay)

‘6

BUCA | / | 11, HEADQUARTERS — ame

| rin ] DEPARTMENTAL — 12 FIELD OR DEPTL x | Filet fT ] perantmenat

12. REMARKS o | 7 | ee oe

Newe change due to warriage february 25, 1540. ezech

uployec is married to e y,s, civilian, cgc-s. UA

~1500.00 pase 4.a. rate |

180.00 qtre. i

911.00 3udse

ya) tes GOSS peie Tate four 40 are WKke ie oF, eee 2 al

\- |

|

a i a

1S, VETERAN'S PREFERENCE . 16. POSITION CLASSIFICATION ACTION

wone|ser.| sevomr. far | \ oe | vec wale mee

OISAB, wire lw i |

OY aa : ru Lf ai ; A f :

7, | © | 19. TION ir ae | 2. SUMIECT TOC. $. | 21 DATE OF GATH | 2 LEGAL RESIDENCE

FROM: ( YES—#0) ;

WO

= “ ,

ve See eae 6 C eowanemax? pesetios orrnee - 15—<0008-1 MOL-19)-3 20 90M8- e190 I -

1;

r - -

4. Tne fo.lowing items gre submitted:

Be | Character : Sxcelient

be &kfficiency: kxcellent.

cae | 3 | Captain, Signal Corps |

rkfurt 89i2 ; | Chief, Sige TNg&e Suv. Team

- o-oo 7 2 ~ ese e efe e = e@ e© = we ee ewe ewe = es es es e&®& &= = @

7

7

A

ad

(Classification)

(Over) * y

71

72

| ‘I can see no alternative to excluding her. She was

formerly a paid agent of the Czechoslovakian Govetnment,

the

24

Po Relator’s Exhibit 8 ©

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

WASHINGTON.

» October 4, 1948

Dear Joe:

Since talking with you last week, I. have again looked

into the case of Mrs. Ellen Knauff.

and reported on American personnel assigned t Civil

Censorship Division in Germany. The Federal Bureau

of Investigation feels that she would be a hazard to in-

ternal security.

Tam sorry not to be ane to give you a more favorable

conclusion. pune

W ith every “kind wish, : ee.

= Sincerely, —

Z Ce ae TOM -

a Attorney General

Joseph D. N unan, Jr., Esquire

Commonwealth Building

Washington 6, D.-C.

. P. S. Come see us—Mary says she never hears when

Catherine is this:way—Can’t you remedy this?

5

Relator’s Exhibit 9

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

WasHINGToN |

September 9, 1948

Dear Joe:

| ‘This will acknowledge your letter of August 27, on be-

half of Mrs. Ellen Knauff.

‘I recall her case very well and after giving it very

careful consideration, signed the exclusion order, for

security reasons. I regret very much that I haven't a more

favorable report for you. .

Sofeew :

With kindest personal regards, ~

| Sincerely,

TOM

Attorney General

Joseph D. Nunan, Jr., Esquire

Commonwealth Building

1625. K Street, N. W.

Washington 6, D.C. ~

: igton 6, me es.

~.

ei

P. S. When you are this way give.me a ring.

ees,

76

77

| 78

26

-

Relator’s Exhibit 10

ALLigp/NEuTRAL -EXTENSION OF EMPLOYMENT

AGREEMENT Form (ReEvisep)

Part. i, -.

1. My. present employment agreement expires on 26

May 1948 and I (do) agree to extend such employment |

agreement in my present position until 26 November 1945

with C/Sig Officer. ~ (Maximum period of extension is 6

months; minimum period of extension is 4 months.) —

2. I understand that if a replacement for my position

is available before the expiration of this extension, my fF

employment agreement will be terminated upon fifteen

(15) days notice. :

. = KNavurF

Boxuornova, ELLEN

Type name

Sig-APD-54, Clk Typ, CWS-3

Position—-Title-No—Grade

ELLEN KNAUFF

Signature

3 March 1948

Date

1—Employee

(Over)

aaa: an ee

ae

| Relator’s Exhibit1o. i

Part Il.

Check .

x 1. Recommend retention of employee in his present

position. It is not anticipated that position will be

abolished_on or before termination of above. exten-

ik 1 e

sion of employment agreement. wf

2. Do not recommend reiention of employee in pres-

———ent position or elsewhere in the European Command

for reasons listed, below: (be specific—give facts.)

80

Empioyee’s Supervisor W. W. Lindsay

| Signature

W. W. Linpsay

Lt Col Sig C™

3 Mar 1948

Date 7

Comments of Civilian Personnel Liaison Agent: a

$$$ $ <<<

Personnel Liaison Agent-— —_——

| Signature 81

Date

Note: |

i, Cited of this form is to be retained by the

employee. 7 |

2. Duplicate is to be returned to Civitian Personnel

Branch immediately with WD Form 72 attached,

requesting replacement on or about termination

date of current agreement.

3. Extension forms received without WD Form 72

will be returned for proper action.

28

32 ees S

ee Opinion of Hulbert, D. J.

#1608 : ee

UNITED STATES DISTRICTCOURT,

SouTHerN District or New York.

Civ. 47-585

{Same Tite]

83 Appearances :

Guntuer Jacosson, Esq,

Attorney for Relator, —

36 West 44th Street,

New York 18, N.Y.

HonorasBie Joun F. X. McGouey,

United States Attorney for the

Southern District of New York ,

Attorney for Respondent. =~ ae

“WituiamM J. Sexton, Esq, 3

Assistant United States Attorney.

84 Atvin LIEBERMAN, Esq., :

Attorney, U. S. Department of Justice,

——— Immigration and Naturalization Service.

Of Counsel. J

This habear corpus proceeding brings on for review,

consideration and interpretation the provisions of Title

22 U. S. C. §§ 223 et sec (Foreign Relations and Inter-

course), Presidential Proclamation No. 2523, November fF

14, 1941, § 157.57(a) of Title 8 of the Code of Federal ' —&

29 |

Opinion of Hulbert, D. J. 85

Regulations, and Title 9 U. ‘5. C. § 232 (Aliens and Na-

tionality).

Prima facie the Relator’s application appears to have

real merit.

She was born in Germany on JSaiiery 1, 1915. In 1939,

her attorney alleges, she found refuge. Siu: the Nazis in

Great Britain, and thereafter, served from January 1, 1945

to May 30, 1946, in. the Royal Air Force as_a Flight Ser-—

geant, with a character rating of ‘‘very good’’, equivalent

to the United States Air Service rating of ‘‘excellent’’.

Thereafter she was employed by the American Military

Government in Germany, first, in the Censorship Division,

until August 1947, when that office was dissolved, and

then by the Signal Division. That her services were satis-

factory is attested by her officers who were her superiors,

as well'as her character and loyalty in exhibits submitted

with her counsel’s memorandum.

On February. 28, 1948, petitioner married Kart W.

Knauff, which marriage was consummated with the con-

sent of the Office of the Advocate General of the U..ited

States Army, at Frankfort, Germany. The Relator’s hus-

band, who is a native of Germany, became a citizen of the

United States by naturalization on April 23, 1945, in the

United States District Court for the Eastern District of

South Carolina. During World War IJ he was a soldier

in the armed forces of the United States from November

21, 1942 to January 17, 1946, at which time he received

an honorable discharge at Fort Dix Separation Center,

and returned to the American Army of. Occupation in

Germany in a civilian capacity. :

In June 1948 the Relator secured a temporary leave

of absence and left the employ of the Signal Division of

the United States Army in Germany, for the purpose of

visiting the United States in order to make application for

naturalization under § 312 of the Nationality Act of 1940

86

a

Exhibit 11 Annexed to Afhdavit of Gunther P Ppk ale

4

The corner of this vefti’:

cate to be cut off tothe.

airman 'alrwoman i ‘lim

charge] with a“ bad’

character, _or

with disgrace

or if specialiy

— directed by

the” Air

pega,

RA.F. FORM 1394.

aS t—“C(‘ QR AL. AIR FORCE.

BRIEF STAT EMENT. OF SERVICE AND CERTIFICATE

oF DISCHARGE OF.

| SURNAME... .. BOXHORNOVA, js edasebass s¢netenstaccene ..-- OFFICLAL No. — PANGT TZ». ie: yk nah

Cyrustuas NAMES.. Ellen. fer ake caels faethe |

Date ——s ‘at Jamary,1 Ard». . ‘Ferms of ; wegen = i

enrolment

a Date reported tor regular service... .. othe FPebrua

. eee ee Stee eeseeeerestes * Olerk/ -»

branet of Air Force in which enlistod........%° AAP s a. R.A.F. trade on a deca “Sate

Dute of discharge... BOthsMay 1946. .... Rank on aac. Plight Sergeant.

Cause of discharge... Services no longer required. - at, om request, ae teres oe e

(Para. 652. .- Claure... ee. __King’s ‘Miihiieed « and Air Council fnstrnptiorn.) \

‘da’ General character t hist service....... Very Good. aceemnsemeniins (ii) on etnies secs ¥ SFY, Good, Soave

‘e. Devree. of irda penficleney —A... AF cask cesiasa ices danebacieieedn Maas _ Satatactory.,

Special on. om Sa hanssectcakeenae

if: Medals, Clasps, ti yeni:

Mentions - in esse 5k ans uckiccastou-sameinssbun’ suns censunongitdu peated Yess tot ces OAS bec Genie vea-vopshaiye, oben

Special —— eto. . | pes : : | a)

Ne OT Pee eP TTR TETEPeeT CCT Cre ee eee eee eee Se

DESCRIPTION OF ABOVE-NAMED “AIRMAN/AIRWOMAN ON. DISCHARGE.

vace of birth 2. 1st. Jama Vaco. & rignt arm,

weet / vibes Net nee te Marks: or scars [Os drepsitteay seid inn. _erbniy Cee heg Oa Oe |

fad ; at Warn 14 laft erm. Rirthmark lett wie.

son (Exhibit 14 Annexed to Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson

7 4

U

Fortn W-400 c 7 ; | Fortin Approve)

© & DEPAKTMUNT OF JUSTICE Bevust Bvasar Nu. 43 KOTO 42

S igei:haTIUN 2K” NAIURATIZATION Savi :

ier. 1 14 . ; 3

; | : : ; 7 TO is

Application for.a Certificate of Arrival and Preliminary Form for Petition for Naturalization

ber pg For use in scarching records Of arrival: : 5

3 : RECORDS EXAMINED | mAs : RECORD FOUND

as 5k ae ano Shs aie

a a ie as

j Date -...- : Me.

Manner -.. oe ‘i aie

Marital stetue ... -- .. ne cen..

poe eNO SEERgEEEEEET ee - é ee tee PERN __ Manatee of perese mating conrve) Aso:

-— THE APPLICANT: BO NOT WRIT E ABOVE THIS “LINE. READ CAREFULLY AND FOLLOW THE INSTRUCTIONS ON LAST PAGE HEREOF.

we Take or mail this cpplication to:

| IMMIGRATION AND- NATURALIZATION SERVICE, 70 Coluntus AV Date

} : | New York 3, N.Y,

gg. ALLEN AMAUFF Sopa rengt re as eee vressdingat_ C/A 20 of 33 weed A vtech

an Nias Fp ge ABs . Z rytttn fA ata rad at ioe Sand serine ‘to | ® petition for naturalization in the. .

UFF ." Nelliakonaer © of Mid fort”. | _. TF submit herewith a state

J tent of facta tobe used in fling such petition, three phot myself, cach of which I have signed, and wie aus. (Arst paper), if one is required.

. be oa a tereby apply for a Certificate of Arrival (if required) showing my lawful entry into the United States for permanent residence. NOTE.—IF THIS

2 BB vintpce ON IS ACCOMPANIED BY A DECLARATION OF INTENTION (FIRST PAPER) MADE SINCE JULY i, 1929, ANSWER ONLY QUESTION

| BBE NUMBcR 5 ON THIS PAGE.

» (il) aivedin the United Spc heh CTC. NEw...¥O ORR sa ean SES AOI on | AS sselspiiehwiagas be

f_tnlertherameot Es bbe ee on AVGVEST. Ye IEF

Cana. \ :

(aril was through am | [isivid st the Galt af (<5 E SU MEMERE THOR WH OReR - Ciao 1 : mo Rogaes 2 ee

on -—- o =e

on the vessel ; es : }

S

| : mn

if) In whet placcs in the United States have you resided durung the past five years?

ies ee es From <--- ia OO a ee eee

Oe eT seer SORE ORES ite et reap a eis From ape es ee Babess tees! "alah cesta aca

19) What were the names, Reageares AE sro eee

ROYAL AR Fo ORde RAE ais cr ee ‘Lomao NE NGLAND.1 19 43-19%

WAR DEPARTMENT CLERK cial rMincrow. ee ease 59. eh =. th- Ae?

) Have nou Tend the following oath of allegsance?” ys. = a |

| HEREBY declare, on oath, that I abeclutely and entirely renounce and abjure all alegiance and Edelity to any Sis his dein gues ike

or sovereignty of whom or which-I have heretofore been a subject or citizen; that I will support and defend the Constitution and laws of the United

States of America against all enemies, foreign and domestic: eee ee ?

without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion: So Help Mz God. : | te

—Are you willing to take this oath in becoming a citizen? BREET 4 6S ADEE SEES he See OE febtne Bn bale Tee: Car i ain OT

Of what country are you now a citizen or subject? .......... - SURV. G SR a iecwuawenwe BIDS EE TE DD

Gl) If necessary, are you willing to take up arms in defense of the United States? ... Z

‘Have you ever, during the time this country was et war. dasurted the mieary ce naval ares of the Unided Staten or depated frou the jidicion of the

carcllment district or the United States to avoid draft into the military or naval forces of the United States? .. | ___eA SEES EPa areaeecna

(2) How many times have you ever been married? po icstek ok sc te hk nw tsa Sen sie neee iw ntce

(23) Have you ever been an inmate of an insane asylum? Phun. > NORE Aegoe eee etki eAUNE Reba upg NE ahiig end nae eaiacmtinmdns oi ak

00) Have you ever been arrested or'cherged with violation of anplaw of the United Staten or State or aay city endiaance o trafic regulation? .... SIO) adicuicns

: ia 8b a 1p DRE a RE a I RR RIS ATO

aie: fg esetecneeneeneencenennneeenneenneetnnemengissettnnenisetannenieeeteneeetcetet Si aren Se ete NA

Bd o be Hd inie 6 keds ae he anki ne ia ke eee wakathda watt a cp as onc cceccsecees>

Gi) Have you ever Gems deported from ths United Staten, or are deportation proceedings now pending aqust you) W/O). :. 1 MLA WGGALLY.

Weorsterealiincs VEL) AT ELA... MLAMND Outta e 2822s so. eateennens enn nec neeeeen eee nee cee neceeee ones

4) During the last ten (10) years I have been a member of the following organizations and no other YouNc. ‘WouEN. CARUTIAN

ASSOCIATION iN LONDON AND. RO KA Me. AIR FORCE gn Dione Sia

ASSOCIATION.IN LONDON. ep

(27) Wen sour lathes or sattinde cise v citjons of tha Uniaed Stace? 2...

adit a

~ ‘Se SbQaase 16 OO nGed COSA 6+ CHONSOE CORO HHSC DOCABEESSASS ao 3487 -—- eee weer errr we

89

9()

30

\

, X

Opinion of Hulbert, D. J. a

by virtue of the. provisions ‘of Public Law 271 approved

November 28, 1945°($§ 232 to 287 Title 8 U.S.C.) which

Relator claims conferred that right upon her as a War

Bride: provided she established her residence in the United

“States. before December 28, 1948.

~She-arrived at the Pott of New York on August 1,

1948, ‘and ‘Has since been detained at ‘Ellis Island subject

to-an exclusion order.

>

When her husband, who had procured a leave of absence —

from ‘his civilian post under the Wnited States Army in

Germany and came to New York to aid his wife, was noti-

fied by the Office of the Commissioner of Immigration and

Naturalization that Relator had been excluded from the

United States for security reasons, and that her appeal

from an exclusion order had -been denied, he instituted

this procéeditig October 9, 1948, but returned to Germany

prior to the expiration of his leave of absence. :

The Relator, after examination by an Immigration

Inspector, was ordered excluded by the Attorney General

pursuant to the provisions of § 175.57(a) of Title 8 of the

Code of Federal Regulations*, as an alien whose entry

*“Any alien, even though in possession of ‘a permit to enter,

exempted under these regulations from obtaining a permit to see

may be excluded temporarily if at the<time he € applies for admission

at a port of entry if appears rs that ie is or may be excludable under one

of the categories set forth in §175.53. The official excluding the

alien shall immediately report the facts to the head of his department,

who will communicate such report to the Secretary of State. Any -

alien so temporarily excluded by an official of the Department oi

Justice shall not be admitted and shall be excluded and deported

unless the Attorney General, after consultation with the Secretary of |

State, is satisfied that the admission of the alien would not be prejudi-

cial to the interests of the United: States. Any alien so temporarily

,excluded by any other official shall not be admitted and shall be ex-

“cluded and deported unless the Secretary of State is satisfied that the

“admission of the alien would not be prejudicial to the interests of the

United States.”

eee. ons

3l

Opinion of Hulbert, D. J.

into the United States w ould be prejudicial to the interests

of the United States. . . tae

The span asn of this regulation was Se .

by atte 2 22 U.S. C. § 2238, which reads as follows

eS 223. War-time restrictions gene rally. W kas

the United States is at war or during the existence

of the national emergency proclaimed by the Presi-

dent on May 27, 1941, or as to aliens whenever there

exists a state of war between, or among, two or more

states, and the President shall find that the interests

of the United States require that restrictions and

prohibitions in addition to those provided otherwise

than by sections 223-226b of this title be imposed

upon the departure of persons from and their entry

into the United States, and shall make public proc-

ereof, it shall, until otherwise ordered

ssident or Congress, be unlawful. As

amended Jun 21, 1941, ¢.210, §1, 55 Stat. 252.”

\

The Presidential Proclamation issued November 14,

1941°* pursuant thereto is set forth in the margin. | (~

** “Whereas the act of Congress approv ed on May 22, 1918 (40 .

“Stat. 559), as amended by the Act 6f Congress approved on June 21,

1941 ( Public Law 114, 77th Cong. ; chap. 210, Ist sess. ; 55 Stat. 252),

vests authority in me to impose restrictions and prohibitions in addi-

tion to those otherwise provided by law upon the departure of persons

from and their entry into the United States when the United States

\s at war, “*F 4

Whereas the exigencies of the present international situation and

of the national defense require that restrictions and prohibitions, in |

addition to those otherwise provided by law, be imposed upon the

departure of persons ffom and their entry into the United States,

including the Panama Canal Zone, the Commonwealth of the Philip-

pines, and all territory and waters, continental or insular, subject_to

the jurisdiction of the United States;

' Now, #herefore, 1, Franklin D. Roosevelt; President of the United

States of America, acting: under and by virtue of the authority vested

91

92

93

95

32

Opinion of Hulbert, D../.

It is the contention of the Relator that she ts entitled

to admission into the United States pursuant to the pro-

visions of the so-called War Brides Statute, Title 8 U.S.C. |

$232, and the court sets forth the language of the statute

as quoted by Relator’s counsel: 7

‘*Notwithstanding ... the documentary require-

ments of any of the immigration laws or regula-

tions, executive orders, or Presidential proclama-

tions issued thereunder, alien spouses... of U.S.

citizens . . . having an honorable discharge cer-

tificate from-the armed forces of the U. S. during

World War IL shall, if otherwise admissible under

the immigration laws... be admitted to the United

States ...’’

Relator’s counsel further quotes § 236 of Title 8 U.S. C.:

‘‘For the purpose of sections 232-237 of this

title, World War II shall be deemed to have com-

menced on December 7, 1941, and to have ceased on

upon the termination of hostilities as declared by the

President .. .’’

And contends that the termination of hostilities was pro-

claimed at 12 o’clock noon on December 31, 1946, by Presi-

in me as set forth above, do-hereby find and publicly proclaim and

declare that the interests of the United States require that restrictions

and prohibitions, in addition to those otherwise provided by law.

shalt be imposed upon the departure of persons from and _ their

entry into the United States, * * * and I make. the following rules.

regulations and orders which shall remain in force and effect until

otherwise ordered by me: * * * 7 ean

No alien shall be permitted to enter the United States if it appears

to the satisfaction of the Secretary of State that such entry would be

prejudicial to the interests of the United States- as provided in the

rules and regulations hereinbefore authorized to be prescribed by the

Secretary of State, with the concurrence of the Attorney General.”

“aa ee

ag

Opinion of Hulbert, D. J.

‘dential Proclamation 2714, 12 F. R. 1, and consequently, as

far as alien spouses are concerned the war is at an end.

This court had occasion recently in the disposition of

motions to dismiss an indictment against twelve alleged

Communists for conspiracy to state (United States v.

Foster et al., 120 N. Y. Law Journal, 1133, 1134, November

_15, 1948):

‘*Nor is the assertion that we are now living in

peace times technically correct because World War

II has not been brought to a final close, and, as a

matter of fact, we are living in an atmosphere of

threatened strife.”’

But there is a higher authority (Ludecke v. Watkins, ,

District Director of Immigration, 335 U.S. 160 (1948)), in

_which there is an illuminating discussion pages 166 to 170.

It is to be noted that §232 of Title a this lan-

guage, ‘“‘if otherwise admissible under the immigration

_ laws’’, which was discussed and construed by Judge Bone

in Bonham v. Bouiss, C. C. A. ‘9th, 161 F. (2d) 667 (1947),

page 679:

‘*While the legislation was designed to facilitate |

the admission of spouses and children acquired by

members of our Armed Forces while overseas, it is

clear that Congress did not go further and provide °

complete exemption from all immigration require-—

ments. The italicized portions of the statute above

quoted clearly demonstrate that Congress intended

to let down only two bars—one as to physical and

mental defects and the other as to documentary re-

otherwise admissible under the immigration laws’.

a

Therefore, it cannot be said that 6232 of Title 8in any

. Way affected the Presidential Proclamation No..2523 or the

statutory enactment which authorized it.

quirements. All others are retained by the phrase ‘if

aoe bd

98

99

* 100

4

ie

i)

101

7 102.

34

Opinion cf Hulbert, D. J.

It is further urged by the counsel for the Relator that,

> ak

‘* Aliens arriving in the-United States may be ex-

cluded according to law pursuant to Sections 136 and -

137 of Title 8 U.S.C. According to these provisions

there are excluded: Anarchists, opposers of organ-

ized government, advocates of violence, publishers

of subversive doctrines and similar elements.”’

And then he contends that in such cases boards of special

inquiry must be called into action pursuant to section 153 |

of Title 8, U.S. C. But, manifestly, the Relator is not in

that category. On the other hand, the rule set forth in the

Presidential Proclamation 2523 expressly provides that it’

must appear to the satisfaction of the Secrétary of State

that such entry would be prejudicial to the interests of the

United States with the concurrence of the Attorney General.

As stated in Leiba o7b of Title 8: of the Code of Federal

Regulations:

“In the case of an alien temporarily excluded by

an Official of the Department of Justice on the ground

that he is, or may. be excludable under one or more

of the categories set forth in $173.53", no hearing by

_a board of special inquiry shall be held until after

the case is reported to the Attorney General and such

a hearing is directed by the Attorney General or his

representative. . In any special case the alien may be -

denied a hearing before a board of special inquiry

and an appeal from the decision of that board if the

Attorney General determines that he is excludable

under one of the categories set forth in §173.53 on the

basis of information of a confidential nature, the dis-

* Subdivision (h) | ieee

“Any alien whose admission would endanger the public safety

as provided in any Executive order issued in pursuance of the

act of eis approved J 20, 1941 (ch. 209, 5 Stat.

292: Ze U. S.C. Sup. 228, 229

x

44

;

;

3

t

p

€

4

:

#

'

a

'

E

Opimon of Hulbert, D. J.

closure of which would be prejudicial to the pane

interest,”’

Not even the court may have access to the pasoed 3 in the —

Attorney General’s office, nor can the coyrt surmise or

speculate, but in this case, counsel for the Relator has sub-

mitted two letters written by the Attorney General to a>

person, ev idently an intimate personal frieud, whose serv-

ees apparently had been enlisted by Relator or someone on

her behalf. |

. In the first of these letters, the Attorney General wrote

~ on September 9, 1948:

**This will acknowledge your letter of August 27,

on behalf of Mrs. Ellen Knauf.

‘‘T recall her case very well and after giving it

very careful consideration, signec. the exclusion or-

der, for security reasons. I. regret very much that

I haven’t a more favorable report for you.

‘‘With kindest personal-regards,”’

And then on October 4th the Attorney General addressed

another letter to the same person reading :

‘‘Since talking with you last week, I have again

looked into the case of Mrs, Ellen Knauff.

‘‘T can see no alternative to excluding her. She

was formally a paid agent of the Czechoslovakian

Government, and reported on American personnel

assigned to the Civil Censorship Division in Germany, 7,

The Federal Bureau of Investigation feels that she —

would be a hazard to internal security.

____+'T am sorry not to be able to give you a more

hivoratle eonclusion.”’

Accordingly, the writ is dismissed.

Settle order on notice.

December 4, 1948.

Hv.sert,

United States District Judge.

103

104

_

‘¢ TXcree of trade proocrency RE SEA aS APSO SARE SIE TERIA SA ATS se Pe

Special qualifications... ee

-f Medals, Clasps, Decorationg, | :

Mentions in Despatches, { ............. rise sabe Dad abet tieaag Webi Soi tak ce sake eo Pe cages aaeee

Special Commendations, oc. : | } | |

_ DESCRIPTION OF ABOVE-NAMED AIRMAN/AIRWOMAN ON DISCHARGE.

once of birth 1. 8t- Jamar Vaco, 4 right arm.

mght... vs —— Pprerorn ‘

Green, cote anseeee Colour of hair... Brome Se

Airman’s or airwoman's signature ... .

(y) Brief statement of any special aptitudes or qugiities or amy special types of employment for which

—— . Por the past seven months, this .airwoman has been employed as an

instructor under the "Educational Vocational Training” scheme. She has proved

an able instructor in nutrition, cookery and household management, and her

knowledge of German enabled her efficiently to instruct classes in this subject.

Her English though not her native tongue is excellent. |

She is very intelligent and of good personality and character.

She has given every satisfaction. |

f

5 f f ; | | 7 ;

eS , roe ny ae ere ee ) ea stewt :* iano Pe omens een nenes ere ee

TAUFF be, Ahh 12 a eacleronibert ee. 0 Maal fore : _. | subenit herewith a state

oe | | nent of facts to be used in fling such petition, three photogra myself, cach of which I have signed, and my decloreticn of intentice’ (bret paper), if ete ie required.

he be _ I hereby apply for a Certificate of Arrival (if required) showing my lawful entry into the United States for permanent residencee NOTE.—iIF THIS

| APPLICATION IS ACCOMPANIED BY A DECLARATION OF INTENTION (FIRST PAPER) MADE SINCE JULY s 1929, ANSWER ONLY QUEST ION

| NUMBER 3 ON THIS PAGE.

arrived in the Uni os of . NEw YOR SL) aN a Te s

B civtcamed -ERREW. KN Mewes ar te 1858

on the veeed .... Mae A. Tv. -SOMEORT | (Ment, ‘trees —

(Mf aivveal wes theo (Nene) | arrived at the port of. —

a Sess f Ce

arrival by ship) Name eae BG Le ‘ARKE. RAMS ORT. Fa EN ete

a r ph ae DANE peer setae ne ENCES. P

“sen +

Mf wtherwer than by sent. hue manner af errs * od aie URNS EN ENS EEG Ce

awe nes Se aac .- U arrived as « passenger. stowaway, seaman, member of crew, of

| ARC oo o.n 5 sentnncnenksksencsddersnncunennsauxegy : ;

y & (3) The ticket on which I came to this count ss bought at _. nes set Ao ) f wed : ta..L:

(0 The tami tht oo wich ered wa the nme onan Fp ES Sie

(5) Thave abeent from the United States eal aaa ee OG ml

: sededeten Ge aensnrs eeant se ene Ricdcheenentertaned yerte of entey. cherharseo eles

ment i hae: : foes ed aya tne | ~ .

Bw teutomin DOAT.MY ee ae GSRMAMY _-nJauyanr s us

| (7) My father’s full name tmwas ....-----.----- VUSTAVE RA. rn as *. os.

(8) My mother’s maiden name was ............ ELiaa € TSIMWEG...

(9) (If a married woman) My maiden name was . ALL. EW APH AGL. . CRS See

(10) My last foreign residence was .....-----... --- LONDON BVei iM)

| Li) Tho pass vies tah the sip or tina which ended mo ta Oe Uta as cc BREN weaua VEN ey GERMANY

son 9 examined by United States EOE peo f- ‘CR a _, ee a c si psa

14) (IF not examined, state why, and give the circumstances of your ‘on

B15) The persan in the United States to whom ! wns coisinns ‘wes Ae e..._&b ARA Scwuna oe WA- ~< KANSAS

Is) The place inthe United States to which I was going was... AA OWA - AANSAS |

17) The names of some of the passengers or other persons I traveled with, including members of my own family sid tice relationship to me, fa any. are

| PORES BRIERE aac Soares «cere scecm — _- OTOH SSR AERO & een ene ec 7,8 G&S ee eer ene ee ee eee eee nme

‘ORM

7 - - ee ee

eee wmenw ewe wwe me et wre

-—eer ew we ew eee: ewe wee ewe -_——ero-- eeeae +e ew ere “se + oe Peewee enweanenaannnaee

(Me 413al-a | | ; ee aoe - {OVER:

(12) I traveled on (an immigration visa, & passport, or permit to rent. ARM. ¥_ "cette On pers. ee AR -coaegae

is ek in i nie Se EO NN i AMM Mi Missi ne macnn Seong Ss a een a

(3) Have you ever been an inmate of an insane‘asylum? + enen---- > SER en eae ‘ ieee oo eae SNE Sd a

{¥) Have you ever been arrested or charged with violation of any law of the United States or State or any city ordinance or trafic regulation? .. NO. a

in nen keene tress sSeieck eentncnon sien Senha ninceeienbassik pended we ckcecccwecaesncax'ss

pone enrnnennnnentncnnanenroeannesae eRacd en ew eeaawsnsemecwandtenersnnbacsddesdacesnecene cia deed bane ttmaeusue

(35) Have'you ever been deattel from the United States, or are denaiiatiois proceedings now pending against you? NO..:. J M04. YLLEGALLY

theoretesnallacts . MOLE Al. Bik || Vide: pana oi

6) the last ten (10) years I have been a member of the following organizations and no other Yau. NG. IIOMEN CHRISTIAN

ASSOCIATION tN LONDON. AWD... ROYAL. AIR FORGE sea SSSR |

ASSOCIATION IN GOR OOW |

G1 Wa jos hike 6 See ee ee NID... } ; Uinahss quisiinbebicains mab oe mide ihgetoodign

bis Cid van vecte ends din Ain Waa Ack ak VOD Mle - Ce. ee ee I ST . HI. ve 20. OEE LTE

‘If, state the number of your Alien Registration Receipt Card ....S ase. 2€¢ta ed <&aAe Oo 7

ca forebears are ie ar cri OES Si Tsp OOS | SAO Oe apse a eto ON age ;

If 90 state your Draft Board No. ........-.- <..-- Located at -....... tees ggageeetenteeee soe oo gacpreteeeeee ce oo ysaseeee: LARC SOG Ee

Classified in clase’ .....-----.- aya: eee eae ee es ian eae HE SEE eR re

| (20) Did you yourself b typ 28 ih tpeeees ive the name FRO Ser

ae nee Pore aboobtly and f So tcc, wad Gia 6 tcp bala sc.

potentate, state, or sovereignty of whom er which at this time | am a subject or citizen, and. it is my i to reside permanently im the Unsted States.

ram ast acd bots sak toon las ad petted ad beck V0 Goce Geaoedlandy cosadiic a dems ks dace, cea ner u believer in the unlawful

damage, injury, or destruction of property, or sabotage; nor a disbeliever in or opposed to organized government, nor a member of or affliated with any .

organization or body of persone teaching disbelief in or oppoyition to organized government. | am able to speak the English language, unless physically unable

to do so. ee eee ee ee

_ te the good order and happiness of the United States. | | o eae

|CERTIFY tht ll be taternents ade by ein this plication and form ae tr othe bt of my knowns and ei

~ “

al

| ; : = : 3 . : cee | fo. & eae Hes _ | i? a

eal } ee | ; Sao s ¥ ry ote Gee |

| “ak y. me | cope |

oye

107

L08

Dated, New York, N. Y.; December 13, 1948.

36

OrdertoShow Cause —s>__—s:

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT,

SourHerNn District or New York.

—

[Same Tirte)

Upon the annexed affidavit of Gunther Jacobson, sworn

to on December 11, 1948, and upon, the petition, writ of

habeas corpus herein and the documentary evidence sub-

mitted to this Court, and upon the decision of the Hon.

Murray Hulbert, D. J., let the respondent by John F. X

McGohey, United States Attorney, show cause at Room 506

of the United States Court House on December 17th, 1948,

at 10:30 A. M. or as soon thereafter as counsel can be

heard, why the within habeas eorpus proceeding should not |

be reargued; why the decision of. Honorable Murray Hul-

bert, D. J. dismissing the writ should not be set aside and

- modified and why the writ of habeas corpus herein issued:

and served should. not be sustained; why the Relator shouid

not be afforded such other and further relief as may seem °

. just;

And it is further Ordered that satidbeuy the dildsion, on -

this motion the deportation of Respondent be stayed.

Sufficient cause appearing let the service of a copy of

this order together with the affidavit upon which it is based,

‘on the U.S. Aarne on or _— December 14, 1948, be

sufficient.

}

/8/: Baeois R. Mepixa

U.8. Dd.

~

(Seal).

4

37

—_—_

_ Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson in Support of

: Order to Show Cause

seneas STATES DISTRICT COURT,

SouTHERN Disrrict or NEw YOrK.

3 [Same Tire]

State or New York,

' . , SS. :

County or New York, §

GUNTHER Vioiaow, being duly sworn, deposes and says.

‘ J am the attorney for the Relator.

I respectfully apply for: the reargument of this case.

The Relator is a woman of thirty-three years, of German-

Jewish origin, who in 1939 found refuge from the Nazis

in Great Britain. She served from January 1, 1943 to May

30, 1946 in the Royal Air Force as a flight sergeant, and at

the latter date she was honorably discharged from the

Royal Air Force. A _ photostatic copy of the discharge

papers is annexed hereto and marked Exhibit 11. There-

after she was employed by the American. Military Govern-

ment in Germany, first in the Censorship Division until

_ 1947, when that office was dissolved, and then by the Signal

Division of the American Military Government in Germany.

‘I am annexing hereto Exhibit 12,.a photostatic copy of a -

mimeographed sheet signed by Mark Winn, Ist Lieut. C.A.C.,

setting forth the members of the Civil Censorship. Division

who by special order of July 11, 1947, shortly before this

Division was dissolved, were awarded the EAME decora-

tion ribbon for faithful and satisfactory service. The Court

will notice that at the passage marked by a check the Relator

herein under her previous name was mentioned as one ,of

the recipients of this mark of distinction. The Relator’s

services were uniformly satisfactory as is attested by all

4

i ’

ane 4

110

111

112

113

114

38

Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson

\

her superiors who equally confirmed her excellence of

character and her loyalty. -

On February 28, 1948, the Relator sired Mr. Kurt

Knauff. This marriage was consummated with the consent -

of the office of the Advocate General of the United States,

at Frankfort on the Main after considerable checking of

the personalities involved. The Relator’s husband, who is

a citizen of the United States, was a soldier in the Armed

Forces’ of the United States from November -21, 1942, to

January 7, 1946, at which time he received an honorable

discharge at Fort Dix. He returned to the American Army >

in Germany in a civilian capacity and is as such now. con-

nected with the Ameriean—Military Government in Frank-

fort on the Main,

In June 1948, the Relator pee a temporary leave of

absence from:the Signal Division of the U. S. Army for the

purpose of going to the United States. She desired to gain

admission to the United States as a war bride, pursuant to

Public Law 271 of December 28, 1945 (8 U. S. C. 232-237).

She also desired -on the occasion of this trip to make im- —

mediate application for naturalization under Section 312 of

the Nationality Act of 1940, which provides that the spouses

of American citizens stationed abroad who are in the em-

ploy of the American Government may apply for citizenship

if physically present in the United States, in any District

Court, without the necessity of showing previous residence

in this country.

The Relator arrived at the Port of New York on Anos

14, 1948. Immediately thereafter she was taken to Ellis

Island for detention. No admission hearings of any kind

or nature were administered to her. In particular, she was.

never presented to any board of special inquiry which is

the statutory fact finding tribunal that has to decide on the

admission of aliens to the United States. After two and

one-half months of detention during which no charges were

39 |

Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson — - 115

Jevied against the Reiator, nor was Relator given a chance

of refuting any charges, notification was sent to her husband

that Relator was denied admission .to the United States.

__—_Thetetter of notification dated October 8, 1948, is annexed

hereto as a photostatic copy Exhibit 13.

Immediately thereafter Relator’s husband who had come

to the United States upon receipt of a temporary leave of

absence, instituted the present habeas corpus proceeding,

in which’ Mr. Kurt W. Knauff demanded in his own name

and in his own behalf as well as in that of his wife, that

she be released from custody, and admitted to the United

States. aes | ee 116

This matter came on for hearing before Hon. Murray

Hulbert of this Court on November 16, 1948. ,Judge Hul-

bert by decision made and opinion rendered on December

4, 1948, ordered the writ dismissed, No order has been.

entered yet: _-~

: The re-argument herein 3 is sought for the following rea-

: sons:

The gist of Judge Hulbert’s opinion is that pursuant

-to the decision of the U.S. Supreme Court in Ludecke v.

' Watkins, 335 U. S. 140, the United States is still at war

with Germany and therefore the special war powers of the

Government are still in existence. | aa

It is submitted that the Ludecke case does not meet the

particular-issues of the present case. Ludecke was not a

war bride. He was an alien enemy who had resided in the

United States since prior to the war. He was sought to

be deported by the Attorney General pursuant to the powers

granted to the Attorney General in 50 U. S. C. 21 to 24.

In determining whether or not the United States was still

at war so that the extraordinary powers of the Alien Enemy

Act could be exercised by the Government, the Supreme

_ Court determined in a five to four decision that this country

is still at war with Germany.

40

Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson

In the present case reference was made to the Act of

December 28, 1945, 8 U.S. C. 232-237. That Act provides:

és @ @ @

notwithstanding the documentary require-

ments of any of the immigration laws or regulations,

Executive orders, or Presidential prgclamations is-

~ gued thereunder, alien spouses or alien children of

* United States citizens serving in, or having an honor-

able discharge certificate from the armed forces of

the United States during the Second World War

‘shall, if otherwise, admissible under the immigration

laws and if application for admission is made within

three years of December 28, 1945, be admitted to the |

United States Provided, That every alien of the fore-

going description shall be medically examined at the

time of arrival in accordance with the provisions of

section 152 of this title, and if found suffering from

any disability which would be the basis for a ground

of exclusion except for the provision of sections 252. _

237 of this title, the Immigration and Naturalization

| Service wife

The Court will notice that the admission of veterans’

spouses is ordained if they are otherwise admissible under

the Immigration laws. This sentence does not take in the _

extraordinary police pe ers of the Attorney General pur-

suant to Sections 175.52-57 of Title 8 of the Code of Federal °

regulations. The Act of 1945 also does not permit exclu-

sions pursuant to Presidential proclamations. Only the

exclusions under the Immigration laws are maintained and

the Court is respectfully requested to reconsider the finding

that 8 U.S, C. 232 did not affeet Presidential Proclamation

2523 under which the Government has been proceeding.

It is respectfully pointed out that pursuant to 8 U. S. C.

236, the Second World War shall be deemed to have ceased

upon the termination of hostilities as declared by the Presi-

41

Affiidavit_of Gunther Jacobson

dent for the purposes of Public Law No. 271 of 1945. With

respect to war brides, therefore, the Second World War

is deemed to have ceased and the Court is respectfully

requested ‘to examine Judge Hulbert’s finding that under

the Ludecke case cited above we are still at war with Ger-

many. Inasmuch as Ludecke was no war bride, the question

here involved was not decided, discussed or otherwise

raised or touched-in the Ludecke decision.

_ It is furthermore respectfully submitted that while as

Exhibit 13 above, officially no'reasons were given for Mrs.

Knauff’s exclusion from the United States, the Attorney

- General stated-in his private letter mentioned ‘on the last

page of Judge Hulbert’s opinion, dated October 4, 1948:

‘‘She was formerly a paid agent of the Czecho-

slovakian govertiment and reported on American per-

sonnel assigned to the Civil Censorship in Germany.

The Federal Bureau of Investigation feels that she

would be a hazard to internal security.’’

Thea attention of the Court is respectfully directed to

the fact that the Civil Censorship Division as Exhibit 12,

shows, thought otherwise. At the time said Civil Consor-

ship Division was dissolved, Mrs. Knauff was decorated for

faithful and satisfactory service. The Attorney General’s

findings therefore are contrary to the findings of another

Government agency, and the question is raised whether this

Court shall tolerate the situation in which one Government

agency, the F.B.L, spies upon other Government agencies,

the American Military Government in Germany, and does

this outside of the jurisdiction of the United States where

the F.B.I. has no business or standing. .

It is furthermore submitted that the personnel of the

Civil Censorship Division in Frankfort on the Main was

made known to the public by mimeographed - jooatabeseares

121

122

123

124

126

42

Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson

pit - |

similar to Exhibit 12 and that it was no military secret to

show the names of the personnel of the Civil Censorship

Division. While Mrs. Knauff denies that she gave infor.

mation te the Czech government or any other government,

it is respectfully argued that had she done soit) weuld

have been entirely proper. |

It is furthermore submitted that the present Communist

government in Czechoslovakia came to power in 1948; that

in 1947 up to the time the Civil Censorship Division was

dissolved, Czechoslovakia was our ally and that the rela-

tionship between this Government and the previous govern-

ment of Czechoslovakia was friendly and cooperative. The |

charges levied in the Attorney General’s private letter

against the Relator therefore inake no sense and are quite |

obviously on the face thereof derived : from evil aud con-

taminated sources.

The Relator herein raises as a further poimt to sustain

the writ of habeas corpus, the right under Section 312 of

the Nationality Act to be admitted to United States citizen-

ship. AD application for a certificate of arrival and prelimi-

- nary form for petition for naturalization on Form N 400

was submitted on or about the-23rd of November 1948. A

- copy of said petition is annexed hereto and. marked Exhibit

14. Subsequent to the filing of said application for naturali-

zation the undersigned attorney has been advised by coun-

self for the Immigration Naturalization Service that this

application will not be processed prior to Mrs. Knauff’s

admission to the United States. The petition for writ of

habeas corpus herein .is supplementarily based upon Mrs.

Knauff’s right pursuant to Section 312 of the Nationality

Act of 1940 to file her petition for naturalization at once

and an order is requested herein sustaining the writ of

habeas corpus on the additional ground that she is entitled

to immediate processing. of her application for naturaliza-

tion. An order is also requested herein directing the Dis-

43

Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson

trict Divectox of Naturalization to call Mrs. Kuauff for an

immediate hearing in which she may formally: file her peti-

tion for naturalization, —

The Court is finally advised that in the present habeas’

corpus proceedings not only the rights of the Relator for

entry into the United States are the subject matter of dis- |

cussion, but that Mr. Kurt Knauff, who signed the petition

for habeas corpus as an honorably discharged veteran, has

personal rights under public law 271. Mr. Knauff protests

against the exclusion and detention of his wife. As an honor-

ably discharged veteran of the United States Army during

the Second World War, Mr. Knauff in recognition of his

sacrifices for his country was given the privilege of living

with his wife is *®« United States... It is for this reason

that Publie Law 2/1 curtailed the wartime police powers of

the Government. Mr. Knauff personally asks that in any

decision to be made herein his rights to the society of his

wife should be considered and discussed, as distinguished

from those of Mrs. Knauff personally. :

No previous petition has been made for the relief. herein

demanded.

WuHererore it is respectfully prayed that this Court

may grant the argument so that the petition urged in this

_ affidavit may be spread before this Court.

4

GUNTHER JACOBSON.

(Verified on December 11th, 1948.)

129)

: Exhibit papreeser to Affidavit of Gunther Jacobso

‘Copy oF Suk ICE AND Ganrheies OF DiscHARGE FROM

Royat Arr Force

(See opposite page Ba)

*%

Statement of Facts Tu Be Used in Making and Filing My Petition for Naturalisation 2

: (i) My fuil, ‘true. and correct neme i - ELLEN. KBAVEF KBciwHORNO VA Ra PHA GL... y

| & ha enews ebtvevinumm and aay ether come ote» og bear wend Suri erques bared

(2) My perent place of residence “y- 20. 132 +f AS Syget.. Louk Gore Pesde ya WY. a cuene Rnndnekea’

(3) My occupation w - oonce tae or we. *. eee 6 r (4) im 33.. years old

(5) 1 was barn on NV ARY.. os Wc os -QORTMUND Cenc cee | |

(6 My penenal description so fellows: Se. ie bie ‘ color ALR. complesion -F AAR. ede abr thar ea»)

3 “Eig. aes 4912. inches: nit. 1. sete visible distinctive marks - Lenbakuats cn acca?

| jong: stan Se .... rece. wes... > present nationality STATE LESS. - |

Q) Vem... mati fie os Gs ales lao KURT. WALTER | _ KNAV-FE.. kcelad

| wives cant os EIR am hs a «FRANKFORT. 0G. aid Nx

homie was born at ALS tS Gey CaRM AD on DECEA BEI fr 9 2 Sa

entered the United States at. ACE’ Br Ve ay. on BARGE 12... ZIRY for permanent residence i

| the United States and now resides at A/@E E PORK -. AVESNS = N. GE gown Py 9 "TT tia f £4.93...

a foe JS. e pedi a ~~. eetieate Ne a 548 Lh b.. ath jimi wie on ee \.

ee eee ee FESS SS COS SOS SE SSL RLSS © OF CERES SHSSESSDSESSAOS SSG SO NLADEPOSOSHUENEE DF CHESS COSOSSOSCESSCOSCOQESNS eer een ean en ee een ee eee eeaneaneanee -

~e ween we SF PPS SOS SO SSR ALE 6 SODAS SS BDO DOSD OS GODS SE SOBRE BASASDS © SODAS SBOE DS BEBSB OSS OEBDOAS SS SSSBADS’ S @ OFS OSS OHSS HODE SESE SHSSEHETES © VYUSSE Ss 064002690680 5666068

eee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee se ee ee See ee eee tees ewae eres er ewawreweeeseeaecn- einen dint te eee ee ae a |

Crete eR RT EER RO ER RH REE RR EEE EER SHEET EOE ESSE EBA ESSE HEHEHE BSEAROBDEE HEHE EAE EEE ME BDEOMROEBROD DORA mee -_- ee ee ee ee

lintel tailed te ee ee ee ee ee ee a Ree foe Pena Meee een ed Rete I tee eee yO A tae me ae Ra Se IRE TE oe ie LE Oe CR ta OF ERO He iia ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee)

“- PNG Wick a ae a

ENELAMD. oe (10) 1 emigrated to the United States from Kank

Garis, provines, of stow) (Cny or towey

SS ren eer eeerecoeoitoe=cesesaenesecocaceeco= me

a Aabeinad yal aie tom

on the ......._.. a. ESAS ASS RENEE |

i detvorrpers oof Thave - 2 pe eo ae

DEPARTED FROM THE UNITED STATES

- RETURNE!) TO THE UNITED STATES

Port : Dats _| Veaset on Ornem Mans or ~ Dare Vesszi on Otuxe Mgaxs oF

: a | (Month, any: year) Convarance Port ‘Month, day, year) CornvsvaNcs

ae 2 Soe ee ; a ioe pee ee

(0) | chr my intention tobe a con te United Seats on Sie 910 Mbt nie Pe tof ace hia PPX Eo

_ Cour of {Dag) (Tear) foe re

46

4 136 Sommer Exhibit t1

NOTES.

q _ (a) Date of Mobilization, Embodiment or Recall from “De

4 ee ferred”’ Service.

(b) ‘Here insert R.A.F., R.ALF.V.R., AA.F., W.A.A.F,, 01

Class E. or F. Reserve, as applicable.

= — (ce) ** Cause of Discharge’’ should give precise wo! ‘ds as

applicable in K.R.& A.C.L, para. 652.

-(d) °V.G."" is the highest character which can be awarded

4137 < ‘in the Royal Air Force. :

:. (e) The trade proficiency headings A and _.B signify :—

of as - THADESMEN.

X Skill in his trade (applicable to airmen up to

the rank of corporal, inclusive).

B. Abi lity as -technical warrant or non-commis-

See . sioned officer, ie., as foreman manager, fore-

e Pe . o , fA

man, or supervisor in his trade. f

’ ~ AIR Crew PERSONNEL.

=138 A. Proficiency as pilot, nav i sa air bomber, air

— a gunney; ete.

B. Ability. as a warrant. or non-commissioned

officer. | |

aq ie

age The word ‘*None’’ to be inserted where necessary.

“(@S Should be a brief narr.tive statement in the form ofa

testimonial. eet ——

(i)

(i1)

(iil)

47

Exhibit 11°

WARNING.

(To the airman, airwoman named on this: Form.)

You are hereby reminded that the unauthorized com-

munication by you to another person at any time of

any information vou may have acquired whilst in His

Majesty’s Service which might be useful to an enemy

in war renders fou: liable to prosecution under the

Official Secrets Act.

Your discharge does not remove any lability you may

still have to be called up for further national, service

or any rae liability thit may be placed. upon you by

future legislation. 4

yt

é oy

You should on no account part with this certificate or |

forward it by post when applying for a situation, but

should use a copy attested by a responsible person. If

the certificate is lost it will be replaced only when its.

loss can be proved to have been due to very exceptional

circumstances, Application for replacement should be

made te the Air Offieer-in-€ ‘harge of Records, Hoyal

Air Force. ;

'

Any Person finding this Certificafe is requested to forward

it in an.unstamped ‘envelope tothe Under Secretary of

State, Air Ministry, London, W.C.2.

”

\ pr

4

" ¢ a

/

139

140

‘141

48

142 } —-

Exhibit 12 Annexed to Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson

GROUP ‘B’’ 7742 CIVIL CENSORSHIP DIVISION

European COMMAND er

~APO 757 . Us ARMY

11 July 1947

, SpeciaL Orvers | Be anes ; i

Number’ = 19 ff xe

1. Under the provisions of Paragraph 1 a. Section IL,

USFET, CPC No. 24, dated 21 February 1947, the EAME

142: (European-African-Middle Eastern) Theater Ribbon. for

faithful and satisfactory service is awarded to tlie follow-

ing named employees of this Organization.

e ; ~

Baurr, George Zetrscue, Pedro

Brexnarp, Sofie Aver, Betty |

Bins Houz, Freda Apvier, Jakob :

Biav, George | : Back, Lore __..

Diepricn, John BE. Barrer,’ Albert G.

DossensacH, Josette BovtaENper, Guenther

Gimaiz, Warren : Bop.agenver, Ilse

Greensipg, Max y Boxnornova, Ellen

Harner, Louis Brakas, Martin

144 Hars, Ernest 7 Dautix, Alice

; Herypie, Kurt ~ Dorryxer, Henrietta |

Inne, Karl : Drost, Ella |

Lanper, Alfred —- - Ferer, Frieda

Mayer, Sigfried Franke, Gisela

Mvuuuer, Gerda © - Gusert, Maurice

Piate, Johannes . Gotpix, Leonard

Rosseianp, Dorothy © . Hexver,- Ernest - °

Scuran, Henry Hersert, Maurice

VoLkuarprt, Horst _. Heumany, Hilda

Weise, Hennslore . Hinrox, Herta

Tueyrs, Henry or, Hinrox, Leslie

Uumann, Maé - -° Howz,. Edith es

~ Isaac, Bruno

Jensex, Erik

JaxrcENsEN, Vibeke

KELLERMANN, Wolfgang

KorLewicz, Getz

Larsson, Inge H. —

Lenrevpt, Eva R.

Marue, Gertrud

Mautner, Stefan

Meier, Ruth L.

Montes, Lora —

Morawetz, Ludwig

Moses, Emil

Mvuu.er, Erna

Munck, Eva

‘Neunaus, Annelore |

Nevuavs, Ingrid |

NEUMANN, Fritz

Neumann, Maria

NeuMANN, Vilma

NIELSEN, Mabel

- OstaurG, Else

~ oe

Hah ibit 12

PavEL, Hans

» Pecutrur, Maria

Rascukowan, Alfred

Reicu, Samuel

Reiss, Rudolph H.°

Royce, Geoffrey

Sap &r, Paula

ScuILver, Lola

Scumipt, Anna M. L.

SiksSEL, Peter

Nirrenre.p, Inge

SoMMERFELD, Max

SPOEGLER, Lotte

Sremnpacn, Regina

Suss, Grete

SveNvsEN, Axsel '

Uncer, Cecilie

VOXSIN, Gerard

Winer, Hubert

WEINSTEIN, Moses —

WoLPova, Charlotte- ;

Zetscueé, Krista

-- By Orver or Lirutrenant CoLoneL CusHMan:

Mark Winn

Mark Winn

Adjutant

_ @

Ist Lt., CAC

/

oe é

ae

rs

0

50

148 Exhibit 13 Annexed to Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson

UNITED STATES DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE.

[IMMIGRATION AND. NATURALIZATION SERVICE,

70 Columbus Avenue

New York 23, N. Y.

Please refer to this File Numbe:

0300-255620

DEO —

3 : | October 8, $948

Mr. Kurt W. Knauff

~ 114-20 - 133rd Street

(149 South Ozone Park

, Long Istand, New York

Dear Sir:

Information was sent to this office to the effect that an

_/ order has been entered directing that-Mrs. Eten Kyavrr

be denied admission to the United States and that shie be q

returned to the country whence she came:

- Very truly yours,

aw... We Ss Game : ;

7. Acting District Director

150 7 -. New York District eases 4

_. By Pau. G. Werner

eae _Paul G. Werner

Assistatit District Enforcement

Officer s/f

/

: ——

Te

Be 3 ie Seng dierent a

' ' Exhibit 14 Annexed to Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson

Copy oF CERTIFICATE OF ARRIVAL AND PRELIMINARY FoRM

_ FOR PETITION FOR NATURALIZATION

ok

(See opposite page Hay)

nee OGL

SEARO RL OEE AER ARERR BMH 0

154

155

_Srate or New Yorks,

‘ment.

Cour 3}-years ago on the ground of unconstitu-

52

Affidavit of Gunther Jacobson Amending Previou

Affidavit in Support of Order to Show Cause

UNITED STATES DISTRICT. COURT,

Sovutruern Disrrict or New York.

.ae.

ad

[SaME Tire}

g

County or New York, §™

_ Guytuer Jacosson, being duly sworn, deposes and says:

I make this affidavit to amend my previous affidavit on

which re-argument.was granted. va

_ The relator respectfully asks the Court to consider that

the Passport Act of 191%, as amended in 1941, does not

authorize the Immigration Service’to dispense with a hear.

ing. It merely authorizes them to impose additional grounds

of exclusion. The exclusion of the relator therefore is 1

violation of the due process clause of the constitution of

the United States.

-The Passport Act of 191% as amended in 1941, delegates

legislative powers to the executive branch of the govern-

It is urged that for this reason it ‘is unconstitutional

just as the NRA legislation w

ay

tional delegation of legislative powers.

The government is charged with arbitrgrily excluding

Mrs. Knauff from the United States. No hearing was held.

There is a prima facie case’of arbitrary and capricious

action particularly in view of the excellent qualifications

of Mrs. Knauff shown by the documents in evidence. Under

the circumstances, the government, if it wants to justify

its action, should produce its files which it has refused to

do. This shows that mrs. Knaaff's exclusion i is in violation

of due process.

Public Law 552, 0th Congress excludes ‘aliens who are

coming to this country for the purpose of engaging in activi-

‘ties that will endanger the public safety of the United States.

The statute provides that’an exclusion on this ground can

only be had after a statutory hearing-in which the exclusion.

issue is tried. It seems incongruous that an alien like Mrs.

Knauff ean be exeluded without a hearing on the ground

that her entry will be prejudicial to the best interests of

the United States, where if she were entering to engage in

activities that will endanger tle safety of the United States

she. would be entitled to a statutory hearing pursuant to

Public Law 952, It follows that Congress could not have

158

_ wanted to delegate to the government the powers the govern-.

ment is trying to exercise under: sections 175.52 to 175257

CRF.

WHerEFORE, it is respectfully prayed to sustain the -

writ of habeas corpus herein upon re-argument. a

GUNTHER JACOBSON.

(Verified on December 17th, 1948. )

A

159°

eR ace i eebateheipaatcacasececndccs ve | oven”

(11) My lawful entry ent residerice im the United States was at - eh. lela e

wie... eam” Lom ‘ ge teh euamaniah " teeeee

(12) Sence my lawful entry for permanent ress

DEPARTED FROM THE UN TED STATES

RETURNFE!) TO THE UNITED STATES

Dats | Veeset on Ornzn Sinise or neszi

Post - . | (Month, day, year) Coxvgrance Post (Menta ae day, year) . Caseepaeen waeeed

°

Pe tenes tiie petted ie ek eee

eee

and in the State of ........ A kee oe , | Zito AS ™ ppt

” (15) I have &7.__. heretofore made petition for na ; t Nom SPW SOC RE RO... Se A URES *

sealers ites weeds" egeat nao DE oe ek a eo

EST — po A . SR, SR a aR nO ee

such dismissal or denial has since been cured or removed. | ieee |

(16) | wish the naturalization court to change my mame to .. ASO a A stbiniomiisbaamnanuadeamaa nak. ewer E, KNOBS IO acs eee as St eee eee

(7) (ie witness) Prep ULEICH a Ee

residing at. Bes ORI... --@2_*,. ; ee : MERE 2 oh . " Ape ce | me Cea ek

I frst met witnes in the United States on .. Seeeg®. (94 FP. : Su ne eat

_LCER of facts hss been read by or to te and that the stateme Hp <tc Aagg

; A ¥ : : 5 ? : . \ c..

, 2 scp scgeag nnn FO ” ie SL. LLY IC, LV. oy

DO NOT FILL IN BLANKS BELOW | es DO NOT FILL IN BLANKS BELOW

Mavi ol witnems to show residence o petitioner os fallow: Corrections mambered ............ to ....-.--...- in thes Preliminary

; Mined Shaheen PRLS Ia Be | Form for Petition for Naturalization. NAG, were made by me or at-my

REPS Ra OE nalts osc a ss | ee

Exner sisi eesapasibiaeeinsilaiahaicalaiciidbesond dis dined aspiiaiaalenc’ a> cc gdm ihe... Bt Ee

(oan wr a L mga o

ry ft

%

& a \

160

“161

162

54

Memorandum Opinion of Hulbert, J.

Motion of reargument granted and after such rearyu

ment the Court adheres to its former opinion. We ecanno

disregard the letters of the Attorney General of which

relator now complains, They were apparently written in

response to solicitations in her behalf and put into the case

by her attorney. There is no right to citizenship until the

petitioner is lawfully in the country and this Court doe:

not feel authorized to disregard the order of the Attorney

General but believes it was a lawful exercise of statutory

power conferred upon him. The order to be entered will

contain a provision for a stay for a period to be agreed

“upon by counsel, and if such agreement can not be had the

Court will determine and insert the day... Application for

bail is denied so that within such period Relator may appeal

and apply to the Circuit Court of Appeals for bail.

‘New York, vecciahee 24, 1948.

‘HuuBerr,

U.8. Did.

}

55

| Order Dismissing Writ of Habeas Corpus

NITED STATES DISTRICT COURT,

SOuTHERN Disrrict or New York.

(Same Tire} ae

The writ of habeas corpus in the above-entitled matter

having come on to. be heard on the 16th day of November,

1948, before.this Court, and after hearing Gunther Jacob».

son, Esq., attorney for relator, in support of the writ, and

John F. X. MeGohey,; United States Attorney for the -

Southern District of: New York (William J. Sexton, As-

sistant United States Attorney, of Counsel, in opposition,

thereto, and upon the petition for the writ of habeas corpus,

the return thereto, and all the papers and proceedings had

herein, and the Court having filed its opinion dated Decem-

ber 4, 1948, anda motion. for reargument. having been

granted, and the motion for reargument having come on

to be heard. on the 20th day.of December, 1948, and’ the

Court having adhered to its former opinion by a memoran-

dum decision filed on the 27th day of December, 1948, it is

Oxperep, that the writ of habeas ‘corpus be dismissed,

and it is. : tant

cv.

FURTHER ORDERED, that the relator be ‘omunaiadl to the

custody of the Commissioner, Immigration and-Naturaliza-

tion Service, at hillis Island, New York Harbor, New York,

and itis ~ *

Furtuer orperep, that the relator’s deportation be

stayed until January 11, 1949, within which time relator is

to file a notice of appeal and make whatever other appli-

cation for a stay pending any appeal which relator may

take herein.

Dated: New York, N. Y., January 3rd, 1949.

HwvLsert,

U.S. D. J

163

164

165°

166

167

168

6

Notice of Appeal

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT,

Souruern District or New Yorx. —

Civ. 47-585

o

-0-

Unrrep Srares or America, ex rel, ELLEN Knavrr,

Relator,

— agamst

W. Frank Warkrns, Ditsrict Director of Immigration and

ewe _ Naturalization Service,

p | Respondent.

Sir: :

PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that the Relator herein appeais

the United States Court of — for the Second Circuit ,

from the final order herein, dated January 3, 1949, by which

order the writ of habeas corpus was dismissed and the re-

lator remanded to the custody of the Commissioner of Im- ,

migration and Naturalization, and this appeal is from th¢

whole of said order and from each and every part thereoil.

Dated: New York, January 4, 1949.

-57

Nottee of Appeal 169

Yours, ete.,

GUNTHER JACOBSON,

Attorney for the Relator,

Office_& P. O. Address,

| 36 WestHith Street,

New York 18, N. Y.

To:

1. Joun F. x. McGouey, Esq.,

‘ U. S. Attorney for Respondent. | _ 170

2. Cuerk U.S. District Court,

Southern District, N. Y.

ed

- 4

ee ij

A 2

vr a

lil

®

\ er

e,

i >

;

i73

174

58

_ Stipulation as to Correctness of Record ©

-UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT,

SouTHerN District or New York.

a , *

Vv .

Unitep States oF AMERICA, € rel. ELLEN Keratvrr,

Relator-Appellant,

against ;

o

“W. Frank Warkins, District Director: of Immigration

and Naturalization Service,

Respondent-Appellee.

_,*

ey, seve

It is hereby stipulated and agreed, that the foregoing

is a true copy of the transcript of the record of the saic

District Court in the above‘entitled matter as agreed ot

by the parties.

r

Dated, New York, January , 1949.

. GuNTHER JacosBson, |

___—_ttorney for Relator-Appellant.

Joun F. X. McGouey,

U. S. Attorney,

gn

_ Attorney for Respondent-Appeilice.

=

ae

"Clerk's Certificate

>

wy

Usrrep Stares oF America, ee rel. Euros Nya br,

Relator-A ppeliznt ;

against

/

W. Frank Watkins, Di.triet Direetor of lnmigration

and Naturalization Service,

Respendent- Appellee.

",

/

L

i

Usitep States oF AMERICA, ,

: ; : ne.

SourHern District or New York, §

‘ 4

I, Cuanues J. H. Fouumer, Clerk of the District Court

of the United-States-of America for the Southern District

of New. York, do hereby certify that the foregoing is a

correct transeript of the record of the said District Court

in the above-entitled matter as agreed on by the parties.

Ty Testimony Wuereor, I have caused the seal of the

said Court to he hereunto affixed, at the City of New

York, in the Southern District of New York this

day of ~ - , in the year of our Lord one thousand

ine hundred and forty-nine and of the independence ot -

the said United States the one hundred and seventythird.

(Seal)

‘Vis

de 7 . = /.

4 v V

176

/

A

/

]

\

~ \

ee

fo

7

7 {i \ \ ‘s \

rm 2 XV

60

(fol. 69] In Usirep Srares Covert or Arrears ror THE

Seconp Circuit, Ocrosen Tram, 1948

; , No. 187

(Argued February 18, 1949. Decided March 11, 1949)

Docket No. 21254

Unitep STATES or America, ex rel. Ellen Knaunff, Relator-

Appellant,

against y ;

W. Frank Ww ATKIns, District Direetor of Immigration and

Naturalization Service, Respondent-Appellee

Before Augustus N. Hand, Chase and Frank, Circuit Judges

Appeal from an order of the District Court for the

Southern District of New York dismissing a writ of habeas

corpus. Affirmed.

John F. X. MeGohey, United States Attorney for the

Southern District of New York; Attorney for Respondent- _

Appellee,

William J. Sexton, Assistant U nited States Attorney.

[fol.61] Louis Steinberg, District Adjudications Officer,

Immigration and Naturalization Service, United States

Department of Justice. reek

Alvin Lieberman, Attorney, Immigration and Naturaliza-

tion Service, United States Department of Justice, of

Counsel. °

Gunther Jacobson, Attorney for Relator.

Opinion

Cuase, Circuit Judge:

The question which must be answered on this appeal is

whether the wife of an American soldier who is a war

-bride within the purview of Public Law 271 of 1945, 59

Stat. 659, 8 U.S. C. A. § 232, may be denied admission to

the United States without a hearing before a Board of

Special Inquiry. .

_ The relator-appellant is the lawful wife of Kurt W.

Knauff who is a naturalized American citizen now em.

ployed in a civilian capacity by the American Army of Oc-

é

”

61

cupation in Germany. Mr. Knauff served as a soldier in

the armed forces of the United States from November 21,

142 until he was honorably discharged on January 17,

1946. He married, the appellant in Germany on February

28, 1948 after having obtained consent so to do from the

Office of the Advocate Gereral of the United States Anns

at Frankfort-on-the-Meia. The appellant, born on Janu

ary f, 1915, is a native of Germany who is now stateless and

who served in England in the Royal Air Force as a flight

sergeant from January 1, 1943 to: May 30,1946 and later

was employed in Germany in the Civil Censorship Division

and the Signal Division of the United States Army. Her

official record in so far as appears is excellent.

(fol. 62] She obtained temporary leave from her employ.

ment in Germany in June 1948 to enter the United States

to apply for naturalization as an American citizen tinder

the provisions of Sec. 312 of the Nationality Act of 1940,

8 U.S. C. § 712, and arrived at the Pert of New York on an

American ‘Army transport on August 14, 1948. After ex-—

_-_-amination-she was temporarily excluded_by an ieimsiavation

'- inspector. Thereafter she was denied further hearing and

tie exclusion order was made permanent by action of the

Attorney General pursuant to the provisions of See. 175.57

(a) of Title 8 of the Code of Federal Regulations. She has

since been detained at Ellis Island for return to Germany.

The writ was issued on the application of her husband who

~came here for that purpose and who has since returned te

Germany. It. was dismissed after hearing and upon a

rehearing the order of dismissal was left unchanged.

See. 223 of Title 22 U.S. C., 40 Stat. 559, as amended,

oo Stat. 252, provides that: ‘‘When the United States is

“at war or during the existence of the national emergency

“proclaimed by the President on May 27, 1941, or as to

aliens whenever there exists a state of war between, or

among, two or more states, and the President shall find that

the interests of the United States require that restrictions

and prohibitions in addition to those provided otherwise

than by sections 223-226(b) of this title } + imposed upon

the departure of persons from and their entry into the

United States, and shall make public proclamation thereof,

it shall, until otherwise ordered by the President or Con-

gress, be unlawful—

oe

(a) For any alien to depart from or enter or attempt to

depart from or enter-the United States except under such

- 62

reasonable rales regulations, and orders, and subject

to such limitations and exceptions as the President shall

prescribe; * ° °"?

{fol.63] On November 14, 1941 the President did, by

Proclamation No. 2523, impose restrictions and prohibitions

in addition to these otherwise provided by law upon the

_departure of persons from snd their entry into the United

States which were to remain in force and effect until he

otherwise ordered. This proclamation, insofar as now

pertinent, provided that, ‘‘No alien shall be permitted to

enter the United States if it appears to the satisfaction

of the Secretary of State that such entry would be preju.

dicial to the interests of the United States as provided

in the rules and regulations hereinbefore authorized to be

prescribed by the Secretary of State, with the concurrence -

of the Attorney General.”’

Pursuant to the authority thus given them the offic ials

just named did prescribe the rules and regulations which

apply to the entry of the appellant and which are to be

found in Title 8 of the Code of Federal Regulations Sees.

173.53 and 175.57. In See. 175.53’ aliens who are excludable

are classified in some detail and in Sec. 175.57 it is pro.

vided that, ‘‘(a) Any alien, even though in possession of a

permit to enter, or exempted under §§ 175.41 to 175.63,

inclusive, from obtaining a permit to enter, may be ex-

cluded temporarily if at the time he applies for admission

at a port of entry it appears that he is or may be excluda-.

‘ble under one of the categories set forth in § 173.53. ~The

official excluding the alien shall immediately report the

facts to the head of his department, who will.communicate

such report to the Secretary of State. Any alien so tem-

porarily excluded by an official of the Department of Jus-

tice shall rot be admitted and shall be excluded and de.

ported unless the Attorney General, after consultation with’

the Secretary of State, is satisfied that the admission of

the alien would not be prejudicial to the interests of the

United States. Any alien so temporarily éxcluded by any

_ other official shall not be admitted and shall be’ excluded

[fol.64] and deported unless the Secretary.-of State is

satisfied that the admission of the alien would: not he, ‘preju-

dicial to the interests of the United States. >

(b) In the case of an alien temporarily exclided by an

official of the Department of Justice on the ground_that

he is, or may-be excludable under one or more of the cate-

‘ 4

= ‘ °

‘ a =

uy .

_~ .

=.

more

63 4

gories set forth in 4 175.53, no hearing by a board of special

inquiry shall be held until after the case is reported to the

Attorney General and such a hearing is directed by the

Attorney General or his representative. In any special

case the alien may be denied a hearing before a board of

special inquiry and an appeal from the decision of that

board if the Attorney General deterinines that he is exelud.

able under one of the categories set’forth in § 173.53 on the

basis of information of a confidential nature, the disclosure

of which would be prejudicial to the public interest.’*

It was as a result of following the procedure thus pro-

vided and the exercise of the authority thus given to the

_ Attorney General that the appellant was excluded and

_ ordered deported to Germany.

Passing for the moment any rights she or her husband

may have under the so-called War Brides Act, supra, we

- hold that the action taken in respect to her was lawful.

See. 223 of Fitle 22 U. S. C. together with the President’s

Proclamation pursuant thereto and the rules and regulia-

tions promulgated thereunder set up a- basis, and the

applicable procedure, for the exclusion of aliens in —

tion to that found in Sees. 136 and 137 of Title & U.

and the procedure prescribed in Sec. 152 of that Title. I

is not claimed, and the claim would clearly be untenable

if made, that either Sec. 136 or 137 applies and neither

does Sec. 152, either by statute or by the President's

Proclamation, where, as here, the exclusion is ‘‘on the basis

[fol. 65] of information of a confidential nature, the dis-

closure of which — d be prejudicial to the’ sop in-

terest.”’

_an alien who 3 cis entry to the United Staten could be

temporarily excluded by any official of the Department of

Justice and could not be admitted but must be excluded

permanently and deported unless after the temporary

action had been reported to the Secretary of State the

Attorney General was satisfied that the admission of the

alien would not be prejudicial to the interests of the United

States. And the Attorney General could reach the con-

clusion that he was satisfied that the alien should be ad-

mitted only after he had consulted the Secretary of State.

There is no requirement, however, that the Attorney

General need consult the Secretary of’ State in the event |

- that he is not satisfied that the alien may be admitted with-

64

out prejudice to.the public interest. In this instance: it does

not appear whether the Attorney General did consult the

Secretary of State and though the appellant raises that.

point it is of no consequence for the reasons just stated.

The appellant’s other contentions to the effect that the

basis of her exclusion and the procedure followed were

unlawful are that Sec. 223 of Title 18 U..S. C. is too vague

in its attempted delegation of legislative power; that the

regulations do not couform to the President’s Proclama-

tion and that the regulations are themselves too vague. We

find no merit in any of these objections.

‘The power of Congress to deny admission to aliens is

absolute. Fok Young Yo v. United States, 185 U. S. 296;

Kaoru Yamatays v. Fisher, 189 U. S. 86. Consequently

there need be no. such limitations eo the terms of dele-

gation of that power as were held to be a constitutional

prerequisite to the delegation of legislative “power in

Schechter Corp. v. United States, 295 U. S. 495.° Further-

[fol. 66] more, these regulations were within the wide sweep

_ of delegation to executive discretion under the war power,

as to which see Hirabayashi vy. United States, 320 U.S. 81,

and we are still at war with Germany. Ladecke v. Watkins,

335 U.S. 160.

The system which Congress set up and which has been

followed in this instance comprises the promulgation for

the guidance. of subordinate officials of a series of classi-

fications of excludable aliens to supplement. the then exist-

ing laws. If subordinate officials are in doubt as to the

admissibility of any alien under the supplemental regula-

tions, such officials have the power to exclude temporarily

and the duty to report.that action for the attention of offi-

cials of eabinet rank who. ity make the exclusion permanent

without a formal hearing,-or any hearing before a board

of special inquiry;: provided the higher_ official charged

with duty to decide ‘does decide on the basis of con-

fidential information that the alien is-not admissible under

the applicable law and regulations. The obvious purpose

was to enable this country to be protected from the entry

of aliens who were within the excludable categories without

having to make public the proof of that status when in the

judgment of responsible officials the disclosure- of such in-

formation or the source of it would be detrimental to the

public safety” Non-resident aliens have no interest which

may not law fully be dealt with in that way. sleet States

> 45

ex rel. Medeiros. v. Watkins, 2 Cir., 166 F. 2d 897; United

States ex rel. Schlueter v. Watkins, 2 Cir., 158 F. 2d 853.

That being so, the appellant has no grievance which can.

be remedied because some of the classifications in See. -

175.53 may be so broadly stated as to be, as she sayy, Vague. .

Some are very definite and explicit, but since discretionary

action of the Attorney General was based on confidential

information neither the appellant, nor we, can know the

[fol. 67] excludable class into which that put her. A read-

ing of Sees. 175.53 and 175.57 in the light of the authorizing

statute and Presidential Proclamation leaves no doubt,

however, that, insofar as they are explicit, they fall within

the scope of the delegated power to promulgate rules and

regulations which are reasonably drawn to aceomplish the

evident purpose of Congress. Regulations having been

duly adopted, the burden is on one who questions them to

show their inv alidity. Montana Eastern Limited v. United

States, 9 Cir., 95 F. 2d. 897. And this burden can be carried.

only by showing as a minimum that the regulations are in-

consistent with the underlying statute dr are ae

or inappropriate. United States v. More head, 243 U.

607; Boske v. Comingore, 177 U. S. 459. It has not ae

discharged by this appellant. ee |

Nor do the reasons for exclusion stafed by the Attorney:

General indicate affirmatively an arbitrary. action on his

part or an unreasonable basis for determining that appel-—

lant’s entry would be prejudicial to the interests of the

United States. The appellant, having failed to show

affirmatively unfairness either in the regulations or in the

-action of the Attorney General, cannot complain merely

of a lack of procedural due process. United States ex rel.

| Schlueter vy. Watkins, supra.

Yet that is not enough to justify tha order below dis-

missing the writ. The appellant insists that, even though

the regulations are valid, her entry is not barred by them

because she is -entitled to enter as a matter of right under

the so-called War Brides Statute, supra. That she is a

person within the scope of that statute has been established

and whether she is right or wrong in her demand for entry

depends upon the proper construction of See. 1 of that

act, 59 Stat. 659, 8 U.S. C. A. § 232. It reads so far as now

pertinent as follows: ‘4° * ° notwithstanding the docu-

mentary requirements of any of the immigration laws or

[fol. 68]. regulations, Executive orders, or Presidential

66

proclamations issued thereunder, alien spouses * ° ° of

United States citizens serving in, or having an honorable

discharge certificate from the armed forces of the United

States during the Second World War shall, if otherwise

admissible under the immigration laws and if application

for admission is made within three vears of December 28,

1945, be admitted to the United States: * * *’’

— See. 5, 8 U.S. C. A. $236, of the act provides that, ‘‘ For

the purposes of this Act the Second World War shall be

deemed to have commenced on December 7, 1941, and to

have ceased upon the termination of hostilities as declared

by the President or by a joint resolution of Congress.”’

On December 31, 1946, the President by Proclamation No.

2714, while recognizing that a state of war still existed,

did proclaim the cessation of hostilities of World War Il

effective on twelve o’clock noon on that day.

From this the argument of the appellant i is in substance

(1) that 22 U. S. C. See. 223 is not an immigration law and

consequently neither it nor the regulations above discussed

limit the scope of. the War Brides Act; and (2) that as

World War II ceased for the purposes of the War

Brides Act on December 31, 1946 the powers delegated

tiy 22 U.S. C. Sec. 223 were, in so far as the War Brides

Statute is concerned, terminated on that date.

We cannot hy: ctnal with either contention. Though Sec.

223 of Title 22 may properly enough be said not to be one.

of the statutes embraced within the concept of immigration

laws in times of ordinary tranquility and is, as we have

seen, a statute to supplement them as a war measure it.

nevertheless does deal-with matters affecting immigration

into this country and emigration therefrom and is, while

_it is effective, one of the immigration laws subject to which

a war bride is made admissible under Sec. 232 of Title 8

U.S.C. See Bonham v. Bouiss, 9 Cir., 161 F. 2d 678.

[fol.69] It was in effect wlien this appellant presented her-

self at the Port of New York for admission and still is. By

its terms it was made effective not only when the United

States is at war but also during the existence of the nat-

ional emergency proclaimed by the president on May 27,

1941 and as-to aliens when a third named condition was

met. We need not rely upon more than the continued °

existence of the national emergency above mentioned. That

alone makes the regulations under which the dppellant was

excluded still effective as to her though + we do not mean to

eis, ; 67 :

imply that World War II does not still exist for that par.

pose also. We merely find no occasion for decision as to.

that. ~-

' Finally the appellant argues that she is in this country ©

while being detained at Ellis Island and is entitled to apply

for naturalization under the provisions of Section 312

of the Nationality Act of 1940 (6 U. S. C. See. 712). With-

out intimating| that we agree that her presence on Fllis

Island while bing held there under an order of exclusion

is enough to put her ‘‘in the United States’’ within the —

_— of the above statute, we find it a sufficient answer

-~to this’ contention to point out that whatever rights she

may have under the naturalization laws do not exempt her

from the scope of laws pertaining to the admission of aliens.

Affirmed.

_ [fol. 70) In Unrrep StaTEs Court or APPEALS, Scop

Crrcuir -

Present: Hon. Augustus N. Hand, Hon. Harrie B. Chase,

Hon. Jerome N. Frank, Circuit Judges. e

U. S. ex rel. Erten Kwavrr, Relator-Appellant,

v.

v

_W. Frank Watkins, District Director of pepsi

Respondent-Appellee

Appeal from the District Court: ofthe United States for

the Southern District of New York.-

J upoMent—Filed March 11, 1949

This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of rec-

ord from the District Court of the United States for the

Southern District of New York, and was argued by counsel.

On Consideration Whereof, it is now hereby ordered, ad-

_ judged, and | decreed that the order of said Sues Court

be and it hereby is affirmed.

‘It is further ordered that a Mandate issue to the said

District Court in accordance with this deeree.

( S.) Alexander M. Bell, Clerk.

[fol. 71] [File endorsement omitted. ]

[fol. 72 ] Clerk’s Certificate to foregoing transcript omit-

ted in printing. >

“

‘{fol. 73] Supreme Court of THe Usirep Srares

&

OrDER Auiowixe Certionant—-Filed May 2, 1949

The petition herein for a writ of certiorari to ‘the United

, States Court of Appeals for the Second Cireuit is granted.

And it is further ordered that the duly certified copy of

the transcript of the proceedings below which accompanied

the petition shall be treated as ae filed in response to

such writ.

(3055)

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Transcript of Record — United States Ex Rel. Knauff v. Shaughnessy · 338 U.S. 537 | Frix