Brief for Petitioner — Kimball Laundry Co. v. United States

Supreme Court brief1949

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

°

Supreme Court «

_~

: _ OCTOBER TERM, 1948 _

/ NO: 63 % #3 j

~~ hall

KIMBALL LAUNDRY /COMPANY? A. Cér

cee? ; MN iisncrce

z . : E

; 7

UN] STATES OF AMERICAN

. ; , Ui Jan

: ;

BRIEF OF PETITIONER ~*~ °

J cr ZW i id

| B\weee MO oreo SS

Wipuiam J. dborz, Pt

Winns FDA

> PASO. City. Nati Sank Bldgs, *

Omaha, Nebraska: c

* Im the

rf the United States:

%)

f / ? / ‘er ; ®

baad ’

* ® e

e * :

ee eee ee

e .

e

> na : ‘ ‘¢

. * ° - :

Saeeeeane 1

é aor : : .

" 6 + :

; riot SUBJECT INDEX

; : : ; : Page

The Ojninion and Judgment in Courts Below wo... osnisehcsaedimlthcnctanaee ae 3

: a derernceas ee eI NAOT TOR AE NOTE gocucky Al

: The Statutes Involved wo... seaedesaeestoasanguescnensnansesisensseascesanggananens MEE DOm vil 2 De ce

Statement of the Case and the Proceedings ~~ Re ee ee a

: Asefgnmeed of Errors, with Diseission and Argument . «js... eee POL EE oy”

F ee ; yA Summary of the Errors aatinastnipicstarsticinias aceite a : 8

! es "EL Errors Were ‘discussed and argued os ly Detain aes Be ee”

: x { TH Error in refusing evidence of fair marke value ae <ixeiteaenepssnaaes ene oe

- TV. Error in refusing evidence. that Petitioner driven ye busifess:... 25

; , V. Error'in refusing evidence of audits showing productivéness eandese a

: . VIO Errer‘in refusing evidence of trade route values :..........0 Seek, ies on;

»- OVE: Error of Cour? in: stating* hearsay exhibits were official geyern-

ice ment “doe uigents gethasiebtesgakia

v

VIII. Error in receiving: Weber and Sholes: interest on capitalized in-

’ s So OUI os ca va sisk jes dea sapcocsccaaisunia rig skenshalaaasenoncs stiabdantgicak tak’ ED ON eIaeee, |E

. mt Officers ces right to give rental value wc. Cit AE oe ee Sey |

bey . ; ia X.- Error in Cotirt’s composite instructions to jury ..... oi La Sea 28

R : ‘ OXT. Error in refusing f'etitioner’s rebuttal testimony ese Needs Savpiscaaten Tame

XIt. Error Py Cayrt’s stutement that case is not for damages, awe

> ye. XTM.*Error in cautioning jury to disregard evidence not offered eee og

XIV. Error in denying additional compensation af Go% from 11/21/42...

. : i i .

. XV. Error in assuming General Motors case authorized —: of reute

: RMN 555 index tinescncidpendatinaensntinkadteadadeidpseaudanllnesadahealaciaccancibhiedaanterauicaiant

z XVI. Error in Court of Appeals rejecting Petitioner's statement of the

.

uy Il. ‘Die! in 1 denyi ing measure of diate on before and after value........

* Points Relied Vpon for Reversal Herein and in the Cgurt Below, with Dis-

"* . ¥ eussions and Arzument ee ae

Pitas, = By Cm MN caeccinceescniccincctachcomsndnboiditncicncsinioiapnentace

of If. Error in overruling: @titioner's exceptions to Court's instructions

. Tf. Error int ‘failing to give ‘Petitioner's pesuunted instructions ecovesasideengens

fj 4 IV. Error in giving gov ernment’ ~ requested instructions over objections

% of P etitioner ssbsseienseaqeessasacaeasusscnssaqeenessasnsosssnssssseasorecssusssssnsseessenssseossenseton

Gi Error of C ourt in striking Petitioner's pleadings spits sglen eigenen

~ ° 2 Jia

os ee ; -

-~.¢@

‘ 3 ‘

4D

“@

e

- INDEX—Continued | ;

¥ Vie Error uw Gourd’ s assumption that Petitione ag claimed damages for »

- good will: how question arose piicdat lin edbaanannistiidbiskteeansidieateiane

VII. Error in rejecting all of Petitioner's fipancial statements -.........cscie0

Vv a? bi. Error in denying. Petitioner’ s offer to prove contents of exhibits

audits... sacecvogecccstoqnatessepaceastoos stsreneleaneceseneeeeancsnstanetesassesesenenentenase pacacens

7

VIE. Witness McDougal’s audits on ORR: WRI ec ctiscne

Es: es i in denying difference in-value of machinery when taken ond.

when returned seeseesensnnsnssosessnransasscsccsensasenensesesasensassnsqieausanenenneassacseransees ie

. | 2 ca 7 7 me aaer: ‘Pase

46

“45

53

58:

: “© Latenser exhibit on reproduction building cost as of 1942 Ro

“XI. Exror in: ruling “petindage” instead of income thereon as the only

proper basis to determine value of property oosecesscscsasueevecnseeerecsonaeses

6O

NUL. Plant unsafe at time of trial—Error in Court ERA to ara

NIL. Fair market velen at date of- P taking emt coe PR iiwessiciccdpatacens MOM

Rati

Evidence of A of A. Le dacobberger re value of “use” stricken ...c.ccccccccd:

* XV.-Wit itness Fesa denied right to prove. $340,516. SD as value of trade

“routes as part of the damage ....n.... neceicgpeoeccccnscceseccads ap datcshanaesieendioes

ty4

Bt

a

XVI. Evidence of cost per year of ton years to re-establish —

denied? .Tokal S412,580.007%..... saapsesaicaeais deimiiwatetas4 FO TA

XVII2 Nallifieation- by court of testimony of Ifarry A.- -Tuevbbercer pres-

ident, en fair market value EE seitscnesincrincgurtlecaniddbgnaan tania:

XVIIT. Nullification by court of.testimony of president re “use value” aoe

XIX: Rejection ‘of evidence of- president re inability to start business

.

elsewhere ,........ seinaeseaesneeaeseensesseesnen tonne iecweadas mi bgsehaihiehinhidawasdenas

moe: Xullification of Fred Jacobberge7's 8 er on use value by

court's instructions. we sevscSeosoncedecsecasesersassersiesssssecseanecsescceccosacns

XXII. Denial of Fred Jacobberger of the + right to confirm exhibits on cont

td build ‘trade TQMLOS ceesetesesesrereriscnrssenanesenssenceneneneareneenenes sapaenossecongsees

my

ba

, 74

TD

81

RS

» Sf

XXII. Error in denying 6% interest frora date of ‘ieee sangescconsssacaanssanstsess . &

Axi. Petitioner's expense pefore appraisers _ denied tticionimtiienten R

XXNAV.*

Gov ernment ‘proceeded with incompetent evident re POPAIPS cesses

> OXYNV.*Error in permitting repair expense to be same as seplacement

value Pot eclte ssetbiasuslighoennsintedareauabusdaveseassscesdvangeonaqescejcnstoorssicasessnagiphinesioct@ass

"XXVL ‘Wncémpetent testimony of government: witness, C. R. Crowder on

* XXVITI.

XXVIII.

Cost fo repair é eaese

Adusleslon of evidence ff government wi vitness ‘Weber on measure

of damages as ‘inferest on investment. Secshibaejubnictadee rites Sobap kioniaicessbiacs

Adanission of testimony of government witness Sholes on measure

ef damages as interest based on. a capital pes aig henceoniad a aad

*8¢-

* 86

90

2

95

8

. . se

_ ° .

i.

iii <, ea Sew Laas

; . a.

°. .- 2

SINDEX—Cont inued -

? . *

a ie : Page

XXIX. Rebuttal testimony of Dahlquist nullified. law Court in instructions.. Os :

XXX. Rebuttal ev idence on cost of painting and decorating—rejeeted....192 ‘

XXXL Dénial of téstimont of Bet Kiewit’ rebutting “eost of restora: +

THOM” ceecseeiagenerseeeneseenseeeessesarersnaneneansanseeres sooggeteagyeseeestnencenssencencessssntes 108

XXXIL Error. in delention the. rebuttal — ore OI. P Hannighen

Co. on. botier expense soseunsawoavececerennnnnanansnsssssisees gree chosnesslagsineeec AOS

y | - f

ae

LAW POINTS: a ie a Grae <

1. Pair market value at time of aking. as’ Dbinsie- starting poiit aE. “an1° Serres

scien

dL 5B Tousequential damages: argued scp iaihlamaemaamenenaarneiaeeduiieaiesspitiareeil seecoodrA 17

a » Z 7 = A

IIT. Value at time of return subtracted from value when taken argued oes kee. >, P=,

: & Condemnee. entitled to additional compensation of ie from date of A

. taking argued Senin ssasesesssscsessscsoscsesesessoricnsaseenscaccecsassedasssssguecacossaveianenenengueceesees 129

¥. The law announced in General Motors and Petty Motors cca ae

VIL. Petitioners entitled. té faingtrial argticd’ ......s.csecsssssctencessssssssssssessnnenseesiens@e ld

é

¢ a

a % S

: SH as ote) Mlle

2 s °

7 e . % > ~ °

‘ z rss Ste ti “K>-& es

. . 3 ~ “dae e a

“ Ss .

ee . ‘ 5 Bo

; E : é tied,

on i te °

'

!

e <4 .

= PREM d

\

iv : . “2 »-

; CASES CITED

U.S. te Bowman (Ore. 4943), CB. Supp. 100 ceeccecssssssecsssneseneeqecee I-67

Boyd rv. l »S. 41886), 116 = p: O16, O85, G&S. Ot; GPF oi. a 19, 112

Q. “ v. Breitling, 6& U. oe OP MNS NOM sipsicesnnstarinicsssscansabcanientininds Wt-l4e

. - Brooktgn Union Gi! et al (2 Cir, 1948), 168 F. 2a 301. 109, 116

cae. ‘Sednlon Corp. 0. U, (1924). 265 0. 8.106, rv St. Ct. ails dlisanaek 110, 116°

Cal-Bay ier v. U. &. 9 G ir., 1948), 169 FP. 2d 15... .agecsstscaiserceres scsi 136-140

U8. (. B&O. RR. , 82 F, 20,13 1, 141. Cert denied, 208 US.

’ “G89, So: ‘S.. Ct. 257 is 117, 118, 120

rs Dac, ts 't. George BL Newton ( ‘oal Co, (1925), 267 U. &. 292, Wb S.Ct. 305 *

TE Sete ube ohaaspserasebaaioaecetiee takaapaed abcde aoa ootne: seconsnedin OQ, 112, 125 -

*. 11,000 “Aeres in Texas @ Ww, < (2O45), 158 F.Bd BOG oasescscccsncocresenioccscessareated tt’

to cs Fleming v. Husted (8 Cir., ies, 164 F: “ Ac chic scicmmastauie 137-140

Sita acaatii tr Nat -Eomepel Mators. Corp. 41945), 323 U. 8. 373, 65 8: Ct. 257..05...134.136

‘U.S. vr. Hotel, Oakland, Calif. (c (Calif, “TOHSy PEs IU. steiibiial 124-5-6-7

a | US. ee dndian C ‘reek- Marble Co. (Tenn. ., 1941), 40 F. Supp. S11... 1234-567

>» ©. 8.0. Katz Drug Co. (8 Cir., 1945), SO Ws BO GE ncinininnscisissanae 117. 118, 191

{. 8. 7, Nlamath & Moadoc Indians (1938), 304 U.S. 119, ‘123, 58 i

ee levees 801, and cases . therein GONE ccscapercicedensncassnitenicaniduidstcimsuiiaaps 128-133

U.S: v. Land in Charleston (8, €. 1! MBS, 51 F. roa LEEDS stivasdaceos "124-5-6-7

us hoes in Marin County, Calif. (1946), 65 FD Supp. 44 0... 123-4-5-6-T

“Basngdoh ve Loup River (1944, Neb, GBB, 18 N. W. 2d GB ....ceccccccoes cose 137-140

God . Lynah, 188. ©. S. 445, 23 Be Ce. FAD ccdsecccccccscisccese eisiepuaaion 124-5-6-7

: ‘scosieakit Nar. Co. v. U. S. (1898), 148 U. S..312, 13,8. Ct. 622%

| 109, 112, 145.5;

NORE REE Ree OT ERE RHE mE TEER EH OE EEE TEE EGEEEEEE SER ESEEEESH HEE EE EEE EHESEE EE EEH EEE ERT OEE EERE TESEE TEESE EEE ES

McClelian v. Hein (A898), BG Neb. G00, T7-N. W. 120 csctccfsccssnesssses 137-140

National Brick Co. v. U.S. (Dist. Co., 1942), 131. F. 2d 30............ a 116, 130

2.8.4. New Rever Collierics Co. (1923), 262 U.S. 341, 48 S . 265-7

iscsi hcatchdecidlaeGnad bee kel disease aka lceagnanmeoebeselasabtds witghusianabioaciaochahiashienadigthcsiad 10), 112

UL NS. v. Northern Pacific R. R. Co. (Wash., 145), 51 F' Supp. 749........129-183

Olson-v. UL S., 292 U, S.. 246, 4 S.Ct. TOR ceeescnsnses eisstecdcacunneshasacic ty Ry, dae

Olson v.U. 8. ANS4), 202 U.S. 246, D4 S. 708 Seas avsadbsaceh wicaheaniehie 110, 116

U. 8. e. Petty Motor (o. (1946), B27 UV. S. = 66. S. Ct. 596..,.....:.00005. 134-136

bog sale U=-S.- €1927), 274 U. 8. 341, 47 8. Ct. G11 ........:..2 Deccisikctedtaretins 129-13:

U. 8. Powelson (1943), a ¢ S. 266, 63, . ae 1047 seseeees 109, 112, 115, 114

eS. v. Rogers "(AM 21), 255 TT. S. 1638, 47 S. aes gidsléandateoans 129-133

Ul SNS. v6.87 Acres of Land re Bhp ARE ea Mk OR sass sasccssuchakinastassodcacccasving 129-123

Ui. S. 4 v. Seaboard Airline (1923), 261 U.S. 299, 48.8 _ 304 peaicdaene 129-153

U.:Ai ve. 257.654 ats & hand, ete. (1947), T2-F. lay 003 Socata AIT, 119, 121

Sponenbarger v-T.. 8., 308 U.S. 256, GOS. Ct. 225 ..ccceccsssssscsssssoees 110, 112, 116

Virginia Railroad Ce or iraeeiger ‘4 Cir, 148), 166 F.2d 400 Lo. 157-140

at eo (A910), 217 U.S. 882, 80 S.Ct, 527 cacicsessntntes 117,120, at

40 ns . See. QS (a. isin SRh GEIR ash a cacitnsdnassonsesagiaitidastsicene eR b+) 5

Peedi ea ar Powers vAct, March 27,. M2, “Acquisition and , Disposition

of Property.” amending Title 1), See, 171, by Secs 682, 636, R36 6a),

Title WOU. S.C. Feund in appendix pee wossnseee sersenes aiinctlcaudevmbeisde 1W24-5-4-7-8 |

- “Return of Property to Original Owners, “TOU. &. C. See. 722. . Pound

; in ap petidix eaten becuesessesnenensascaneassnssesnasnanssnsaneacensussncnsansaneessasteG cansenees al: 24 lb. 7-8

.

=

Eran

"6

719. eter Art. 3. R.

34-314, Re S

95, RLS. N.

20.

21.

Chapter 11,

Defense

Ch.

nent “Domain by State. we eae

Sec.

See.

. Ch.

of

Art. 6,

83-605, R.

APPEND

IX INDEX ,

oe

Appendix

lage

Acquisition of and Expenditures on Land for National-

Purposes Tithe Ta, t.

S. C., See. 171

Vol. IV-— Revised’ Statutes of Nebraska, 1438—Emi-

. Ne 1943 :

“N. 1948 siesnasees

13. Vol. 1, p. 233

. a

. e

eenceccosergococscobssceoseoose PPrerTOeri Ctr iri tt eee

°

teenee PPPeTerrrritirt iii t titted

*

-

o

*

‘ ‘ ,

~ =

A >

. *

.

-

. .

ad >

°

e*

Tithe 50. S. Ba WORMED el h css cSia i etiaincidilieskesecnisanus ssn cadedeasenboasaaheie 2

: Second. W ar Powers Act. Ho Pitle HU. Ss. abe App. p. 255, See,

TIF acca ninnsieg ctinaonnincnagpsinsvttaneninatanansiaiinnots panboetai Seabtssonsesens iprsenenenes toicenesenseecedhiibocs 3

‘Title 40 C. 8 ace OT i punemasen Le ipvohaniosenpeniapabiabeaasoclians 4

: Title 40 U.S. Ch See. 2S Siabion ieee ie lesctabthaiecseibussiginpivetpniniehienncckasqnaibaln m

Title 40 U. S.C. See. 258 (a)... PELE Sa Meee A ee ae 6

Title 50 U. S.-C... Sec. 621-#Time Limit and Short title «First: War

NR IRR SIDI Dc oabnnes esa he idbibedomeububesnenisscusahsontepashsaahienn 7

5 S8- Title HOTS. C™ Sec rag Care easel wastes sale Plc ES NIE PII OK aiid 7

Tithe HPP. SCL. See. TUG cccsesecsseeeetecssmesensesnetecneanenntoned nccacseassssessoscasnessees 8

Title 50 ULS. €., See. TA wees EO AA Fs pamiennanesannddadiibneiaiiaendsaibeinie '

Seeond War Powers Act, 1942, Title 50 1. S. C., See. B86. asc 1

Title: 50 U. 8. Cu SEES CBG (a) salesececsecemeetecoee Licatanolagiaciioptne OT

Title BO U. 8. Cu; S00. 92D nnniscasncssessrnnesis Eon ROO Pa opie Sev serine oon ON 12

Title 50 T.'S.-C..° Se e. 721. re limitation ef T. 8. Dist, Court on.

mieunt im controversy" en eepenuesedeses seescsersenesecsncsensees guskensasheessda 2a

Fifth Seniesa toConstitution dendaninoe’ phiavignshsdabinsasicins ; iathansbbvasendeansiinted 13

- Art. . Sec. 21—Constitution of Nebraska cepsongesocccsceresesoncoosscses Soqseenocestacesos 13

SOE sepiaatiidacasenaiggtltonenlaepimngitile a

ro

Inthe |. | S

Supreme Court of the United States

oO ; ‘ we

Uv % oz ,

OCTOBER TERM, 1948

KIMBA ALL LA \UNDRY COMPANY, A Corporation,

- .Pe titioner,

vs.

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

;

o

pee ey

BRIEF OF PETITIONER

To: THE Howorasi. E Tue Su PREME ‘Cov RT OF THe U NITED

STATEs :

The petitionér, Kimball ‘Laundry Company, a corpo- —

ration, of Orgaha, Nebraska, was granted a hearing ‘by

this Court upon petition for certiorari, October 11, 1948.

The writ was directed to the United States*Court of Ap-

,

}

peals, Kighth. Cireuit. The decision of that court, to be

. reviewed. was rendered March 11, 1948, affirming a_ judy-

: ment of the United States District Court for. the District

_ of Nebraska | given in a condemmnition’ proceedings whe re iar

,

the pe titioner s laundry and dry cle: ming plant consisting

of real. and personal property was totally t tame for an

Army military laundry, on November 21, 19427 The ease

was tried to a jury on March 4 20, 1946. On March 22,

1946, two days afier the, case was closed, the Army de-

-elared the property surplus and abandoned it to the peti- :

tioner.: The gove rmment prevailed in limiting its liabslity

to the 3.6 years of operation, measured by interest on its

separately appraised value of Jand, building, and machin-

ery, plus its estimate of what would be the-eosts-to re- ,

place and res store broken parts: of ‘the. buildipe and ma.

. chinery. The petitioner as owner and operator was. de--

nied all of ihe measures for compensable damage which

it offe red to ‘prove, as hereinafter set forth aid explained

under the heading, “Statement of the ( Case ‘and Proceed-

ings Below.’?

‘Petitioner seeks. reversal and trial in accordance with

this Court’s. mandate based upon’ the applicable law pre-

sented in’ ‘this review. © : : iat wets

i ae Ps

ray

Vv

*

. i \ ‘

‘THE OPINION AND JUDGMENT IN THE .

se - COURTS BELOW

2. The Opinion dated. March 11, 1948, sought to he:

reversed is K imhall Laundry € ompany, a Corporation, ap-

| aa dellant, versus U nited States of America, appellee, Civil

Ls 13494, found in Volk IV of’ the certified: reeord 166 F. .

20 85 6, May 10, 1948, Court ef Appeals, Kighth Cireuit.

~

« s ° Pie

me The paki. of the: jury and the judgment of: the

. tei Al Court helow are found in Vol. 1,:95 ‘and 10] to. 107. :

?

om

JURISDICTION

This Court. has jurisdiction. to- review the ‘decigion

questionéd, upder Section nets Judicial Code (28 U. pe

| C. 347a).

Tos ie 3: 20%). . | Be

pendix to this br ief.

The enations ‘presented arose .in condemnation pro-

ceedings instituted by thé United States against the pe-

ee wherein the federal courts have jurisdiction (40

.

°

af}

ary

‘THE STATUTES INVOLVED

The following stafutes involv ed are Gopied’ in thes aip- ak

é

at 28 U.S. @. § 391 (Sudicial Code, § 269).

50 hee S.C. 4171; 171a; 621: 632: 636, ameiding

— -721;°636a, further amendments; 721; 422 (pro-

viding methods to pay’ gav ernment . ‘upe: ho re-.

turn of property to owner; 77 03 776).

40-U. S. Cu. 257, 258,,258a. Fed. Rules 81a(7).

Fifth Anisadianat, to- Federal Constitution a

‘just compensation.” poco

Constitution of. Nebraska, Art. <I, § 21 -(Vol. II,

"Rev. Stat. Neb. 1943, on ‘just compensation.”

((Aplt’s. br. ssi App. #- :

; or

-:

sy

Vv

se .

‘STATEMENT - ‘OF THE CASE AND’ THE —

es ee PROCEEDINGS BELOW ~

Rote: {The footnote son the following pages direc Pat

tention. to the points re lied upon for reversal 4 in the ont

ot Appeals. These points were discussed and argued-as er-

ror in petitioner's brief in the Court of Appeals. By stip

lation of counsel when thie record on that appeal was pre-

pared, the: points. were ‘placed. in ‘the appellant’s: brief”

‘rather than in the record (Vol. , 142). ° Thus the brief:

below becomes a part of the cade for review herein to

that extent to deter rmine the fact : that these points. ware.

presented, digeusse cd ind brieféd: be ‘low. “These same points

with same numbers are set forth herei ‘ins Infra, pp. 84-108, ,

Th: 180, paints: relied upon for reversal were discussed

and argued in petitioner’s brief ( Aplt’s. br. below, 14-88),

followed by the sup; sorting propositions of law (Aplt’s. br.

below, 89-126). Thus the liécessity of reference. herein

to. appellant? s brief below hee: ‘ause the court below said/ ;

in referetice-to the presentation of the points,’ “most of .

them are not argued in “the brief,’ and that “errors as-

signed, byt not ar gued int the brief are waived. ah 4V ol.

IV, 6), Infra, pp. 54-108..

- The court below: made no -sta tement of which points”

it ‘domed were, or were not argued. Petitioner ‘contends »

* all were sufficiently argued to ‘fully apprise the court. of

the érrors. The points. relied upon are sét-forth Herein,

infra, pp. oH. 108, and may be referred to herein the SAMe

as found in“ Aplt's s. br - below.’ go eae 7 m

¢

1.. Thé petitioner, Kimball Laundry ‘Company, is a

Nebraska‘ corporation... If owned ‘tlie fee title, free from

re

eo

. J .

. «es “dl 9 . 2

E . > . . 2 . ne

« . . . ,

. . A

. : ~ be .

liens, to aij its real: estate. Its -persenal property was

free from. tie ns or clainis. it was weing ad its facilities,

as a going ,concern, to. edbiaie an: exceptionally — larve

aundry and dry cle aning establis Hine vt in Omala.. Ne

braska. It was neither ithe Jessee or loss@r wot any of: the ‘

property | involved. it had the ‘temporary: use’? of none

of its real or p ‘sonal property for any, purpose.’ It was >

- doing a gross annual business of $400,000. It served .a

large pat of the population ot. 250,000. of the city. This

was the condition or. Saturday, Nov ember. 21, 1942, -the

4

day on. whieh the petition in condemnation was. fied: in’

the United States C onrt. The Army Quéttermaster C orps

took complete possession the following ‘day of all appel-

lant’s plant with all its. facilities, machinery, and equip- |

ment," The petitioner was, by force of the t taking, put eut-

of business.’ The Army continued witliout interruption

the operation of this plant as a laundry. and dry’ cleaning:

establishment, re taining 180 employees and the manager ial |

staff. Soon, prisoners of war (100) replaced ‘the skilled

“employees. The Army operated the plant to service, for

pay, the. laundry and. dry’ ‘cleaning 1 requirements of the

soldiers, officers, and all the Army hospitals, t ‘aining:

cehters, and forts in the Seventh Service Command, all ..

from this property taken by rorcum ane

1. Complete word picture of plant, Vol. I, 273-285, Previous i yeark audits

to show value, Vol. IL, 200 also to 221) rejected by the court. .

2. FPet.. Vol. J, 1 to &. Condopns “right to use and oceupy” p. 2. Also

right to use and oceupy— “all aersonal property used in connection with

Said laundry.” ‘Order’ of taking recited— “prior, tu taking over bnsiness of

said property.” Vol. 1, 11; and taken for—“the establisbméat of'a military

_ jaundry loeated in the ¢ ‘ity of Omaha. Vol... 12.

3. The trial pourt re jected the evilence of the president of the company. th: at it

was completely driven out of business as-immaterial: Vol. Il, AST AX Error

discussed Aplt’s, br. below, NOX, a1. Infra’ heret: 34-108. i

4: Votocll, 266 270. Prisoners of war © 100) by replacing skilled eraployees

“added to the destruction ‘of the mac hinery nnd equipment.

41 Vol. 11. 478. Court refused to permet. anatint soldiers personally paid

‘the army fer their laundry services, Yoh, IT, 448. e.

|, The Rrmy WAS a mitteddy in the. continuous, un-

ter tuptod: possession dnd loperation: of the property to.

the cke Huston, ot the petitkorner frow the time of the taking

to the day. yt was declared surplus anc abandoned. to the

petithoner, its unrestored: condition two days after the

jurvts verdiet on Mareh 20, 1946. aut whieh, time the prop-

ost was hy ihe army ‘found and declared to. be surplus

Sas of Miareh p83 14682 it. Was abandoned «to. the peti-

.

toner. with out rep wre, r€placeme nts or any atte ‘mipt hy the

army to redelger what chad, been conde mined. Just com,

4

pensation m easured in. money ‘is. now. involved, :

he ¢ Ae oe

3. When eee the: company Was doing ain annua!

eross business as above stated of approximate LY S400 000, -

"00. Fi inanel inl staténie nts: showed. a continual growth in

Volume and’ income. since 1933.5 Tt W as one of the most

efficient and expensively equipp wed laundries West. of Chi-

cago. . Its building, Was built of steel and concrete, five

stories, 132 feet: square. Its business. Was obviously that

(Of a se eviciny corporation, for those it ag reed to service,

on sold: no me rchandise ; it manufactured: none. Its value’

. for condemnatign. or sale. purpose depended * upon the’

extentlof the se rvices “performes _and_the _profits—on- that.

work by this company. Its gross income ,since +924 was

. \ <4 t

/

42 Ya 0, OFS 328 :

5. Atl the certified publie accountants’ evidence ner exhibits 3 were rejected

/ save one column showing volume: that. was of no value witheut the com-

‘spite adit. Una servicing COMPANY Rue as this vetitioner, the business

Fs ure wees te arrive at value besides fhe hg anil mortar,”

Vol. fxd. ds Bx. 2, 1907" Ex, 3, 20; Ex. 4; 204) Ex. 5, 200,

ky, 6. “5 IS: ie "4; ek : “

Error im rejections. Aplt's. bese on “¥ II, 28-33 astind each exhibit is

dhiserssed fully, with trial court's ruling'‘hey page reference to record, where

net decipiod “In the Propositions-of Law these exhibits and testimony are-

J further rlisetussed, Aplts.. be. below, 9%, Tit, a8 to S$400.000> business :

Vol il. eon : » 2

6 Vol TE, 308-407,

; Xe) Fs

+2

. ’ 4 a .

#60 28,454.64? The aed showed what part. af this in-

" eome was expended (F273,054- 83 ove r lst 6 ve ars) to build:

and develop As Wassets EE is known to.the tr ade as trade

routes.’ The cost of the machinery and equipment at the »

tine of the, taking in 1942 Was $405,294.81! Its appraised

-value-at that: time was $27 4a 83 39° and the’same men in

1945 shortly before « abaidoned, appraised it at $120,699, 7b.

"The vost of. the: building at the time ef the ‘t taking was”

— $209,035.12. The reproduction Value of the building on

November 1, 1942, was $280,348. 00.2 The porter, edjuip-

ment was'valued when taken at $62,928.08, T ‘he land upon

which . the building and equipment’ stood was valued at

$30,000.00, - Its location was in downtown Omaha. The

following is an itemization of the 4 values comprising the

plant without- good will or ‘apitalization of future earn-

, sgn or prospective profit on November 21, 1942:

; Building. S ioe $280,348.00 *

ee Machinery and equipment | 273,831.39

: Power equipment and. :

: a incidental installations "62,998.08 Y

i.) rns _ 30,000.00 a,

ae Customers’ routes : os § 840,516.85

‘Total Pees - $987, 624: 7

; (Rejected as intmhaterial ‘by trial ( ‘ourt. yi :

ee Tea 2

% Oy Re se Hiimer’s pee sere on Exhibits Volo, s0aa1, rejected,

“ef, footnote > above.) ve II, 24-4.

8. Vol. Il, 245-! 262, Ex. 21-3. 260. Shows value+of machinery par equipy

nent: in 1942, and by same : eitieieada in UMS before the trial. Difference

_ in*-value—$153,'31.54. --This evidence was .taken. from jury by Court’s in-- °

‘structions. Error discussed Aplt'’s. br., below, 34, IX: argued under Prop.

ositions of Law, 113. It will be seen by the references that stich measute

of damages was denied considération by the jury, Vol. I. 152-155,

9. Vol. IT, Ex. 19, 264. perth:

10.. Vol. II, Ex. 28, 272-3. This before and after valuation of power equip-

ment was denied peice ester bythe jury in the trial eaurt’s. Instrictione

“Argited Aplt's: br. below, 15-21. Thetructions requested buat not given, <L

26. Interest on “brick and: niortar’ values ajone were permitted for the

jury's consideration. Argue d under Prop. Taw I and If, Aplt's. br. below,

S89 and 109. : 2 y

g 3

4-° To permane: ithy estab lish. itself by the expertise of

- building up trade routes, men had been. employed to inter.

view various families and commercial houses throughout

the City of Om: tha for the solicitation of their I: undry ane

dry cleaniig require ments. These men during the prev fous

six Years built up for. petitioner 15,093 regular trade

route custor ners, all of which we re heing serviced on No-

vember 21, 1942, Under the priee and: ‘caceommodation

terms of the coiitracts made by the petitioner, the articles:

tor laundry, and dry cleaning service were picked up.

wittiout further contract and when serviced were returned

Without ‘ther contr acts between such persons and the

‘company. To further illustrate actual values in the con-

demned property, there were 1509 ‘desk! customers who

were thus personally serviced across: the countér. There

were 4648 special customers .who. required special: sery-

ices at times throug! iout the yea oe Tre were 20,802 ens--

tomers: who from time to time sent table linen, spreads,”

‘rugs, comforts, blankets, cand lace eurta ins. _ These per-

sons avgregited 42,043, + alled : by -the trade “trade route

s

customers."’ There were no duplications in the figure,

The petitioner paid to these route men to build cand.

keep these routes during the said 6 years previous to the

taking, $237,054. 83, in salaries and commissions.” This

“sum vas the principal but ‘not the only item of expense

to keep. and maintain the routes against the- competition

froni other laundries who likewi Ise had route men at work

i te Apit's, br. below. XIII, 44-48, Vol. IT, 273-9: trial court's’ ruling, Vor:

MH, 315. All rejected by Coyrt exeept land. building and machinery

= ba ‘is for inte rest on each valte fis the only mensure of damages permitted

: Enstructions, Vol. 4, i165: _& xeeptions 165, 167: Appellant's In-

me dons requested but refused, J72-178. -Assigigd and discussed; Apit's.

‘br. below, 7: 52M} Argued. P rop. jaw Pand TT, 80, 100, ;

. Vol. Il, 244; .234 ‘shows$ temizution of gross ineome past five years,

- $400,000 far 1992.. MeDougal, Vol. TF 244, Ex. 13 refused. Error VIII,

3338, Aplt's. br. below, argued,” Prop. Law Il, ‘106.

°

- ‘ e

®)

a ae Ae

—— .

on guaranteed salaries -and: commissions. These routes .

(similar toa newSpape r’s cireulation) had a market: value

“in the trade as an inherent part of the ‘conee rh, of $340,-

oa when the lant Was taken These were valued by

rade practices as follows: $20 for ei ich of 15,093 trade

a customers; 50e for each of 4648 pillow customers ¢

50e for each of 6810 table linen customers; 50€ for each

of 5814 rug and blanket’ customers ; 90¢ for each of 8178

lace curtain customers: $10 for each of 1500 call custom-

ers; and for 44 commercial ‘customers which produced

$34,253.13 revenue for. 47 weeks during 1942, ‘such as

hotels, railroads, clubs, éte., evaluated in the trade ‘at

$728:79 per-week at 15 times the wee ‘kly amount, thus

proving the sum total of $340,516.85 as the value of the

trade routes at the time of the taking."* These routes were

‘totally destroyed by the taking and the retention of the

property by the Army. for three years, seven ni ‘and

‘eight days." The army. rejected all customers ; except .

soldiers and officers and the army hospitals, forts, ete.,

i-the Seventh Corp Area. The part of the population

Ben by the petitioner went immediately to other com-

péting lautidries ‘as the obvious result of the. taking. No

money was paid at the taking and no opportunity what-

ever afforded appellant to cfntinue elsewhere. Obv iously

this was the result of the necessity for Jmmediate t taking :

to be later compensated in money.

dD. "Tie Certified Public iocentne' s reports proved

that no sums were®arried for good will, trace name, .ad-

| vertising, or anticipated profits, future busines ‘$8 OT esti

18. The witness Judd qualified AS an é spert to give. these trade route eaienae

as a matter of trade practice. The trial court denied all consideration -of

-theth either as -separate items or as a part of the composite value in 1942,

or fpé auy other. purpose whatsoever, Vol. If, 367: Fx. 14, Vol. Il, dat,

14. Vol. TL.487-9. Error predicated on rejection argued SP Aplt's. br. below,

61, XIX; Vol. II, 237, explanation of ‘Ex. 11. é ae

®

“Heriences: and fully itemized in exhibit form, the cost to

ae y

-. 10

nates of the value" of the business, Oaly the realty .and

pe rsonalty Valued as tangible assets were shown of record,

Obv iously. these audits contained no evaluation, of - the’

trade. routes! ns good will, (Fable. supra, page 7)

. io ee expert tosthaony based upon the. actual eXx-.

build up again in-the City of Omaha these trade routes:

was offered in evidence. During the first year the gross

income would be $100,000, while the total expense for that

period wou lie $251,680.00, which, after figurine income,

would show-a net 6perating loss at the end ‘ef ‘the first.

vear ef sTQt, GSO.00, For the second vear the eross ite

come. would: be $150,000.00 with an expense of $280,366.89,

or an operating loss the second: ‘Year of $130,366.80. For

the third year there would be a gross: income pf $200,000.00 -

“With an expense item of S850483.20) and an “op@ating

‘loss of S130,183.20, In the fourth vear the: eomipany shontd’

he able, then, te operate w ‘ithout farther Josses and build

up its previous profitable. i income. But for the three years

the net cost to. ‘re vstablish. its laundry’and dty cleaning

‘routes with the plait, and facilities.to be maintained. and.

operated while so doing would be S411, 450.00,!° * or a net

loss of that sum of money,

tm. . Vol. If, 200 C. P. A. ‘Tlillmer stating, ‘These items which were a factor

in vetting the increased business have heen charged ta expense and have

. Net been enpits lized as good will.” : Pe

1h, Vol. If, 872. 876.880, ALD this evidence was rejected, with. the -trade route

Valnes, us not within the issues, “Nevertheless inthe opinion of the Court

of Appeals the statement is made wholty without foundation and eon--—

trary to the above offered’ proef at Vol JV. S. “No doubt the xove rument’s,

occupation of the plant, disrngted and ginmaged the coripany’s business,

although it could hardly* have de sstroyed the demand fer laundry service in.

the City of Omaha or disabled the’company from ever re-establishing its

business. This imports: int part of the opiniaty érroneousty infers that the,

evidence of cost to retmild the re vutes, and the time it wonld take, and their

Vvaine, When destraved by the taking. were absent from the reeerded testi-

mony. The evidence was offered and rejected. Vol. IT, 367, 370, 487-9. If

the topic Was Hnpertant.erteeh for the Court of Appeals to rule upon, eit,

should have done so based upon the: compe tent evidence offered in the rec-

ord us above tedexed, Aplt's. br. below, 53, Error XVI and discussion.

.

°

a

Li .

gq 2 The buiiding previons) valned at #280,! 348.00 and

the lawd at $30,000.90 were, declared surplus after 3.6

-Years and abandoned ‘to the jb titinner., the power equip

ment ar ML incidental installation were rendered useless

or ‘destroyed to. suc ‘h anextent that by orders of the Army .

commanding officers the plant was “declared a danger to

human life because of the unsafe condition of fhe. héile Ts

except for limited. use at: the time of surrender)? This

near useléss condition. was occas toned. by the necessary

overloading and long hours of hi: nd use. Phe power equip-_

ment was valfied: at $62 928.08 at the time of the taking

and — rat the time of trial, a loss of. $27,667.55

on such) iter 3.18, :

8. The buile ling had nevada ‘able structural PR

resulting from ihe overle: ding of hoilers, causing shaking, e

and also: from the rough usage in the’ rus sli to turn-out the

‘ast amount of work necessarily required by the army in

the prose cution of the w: ar. The very. best’ of expert testi-

mony ot petitioner’ S Witnesses gave det: Lite estimates of

cost of the repairs | to the building to place it in the con-

dition that it was at the time of the t aking ats $53,970.00,"2

thus reducing the ‘alue ot the building from $286,548.00

te $226,378.00, exclusive of painting or .repairs. to plumb-

“ing, heating, boilers, power plant, ete. The painting. nee-

essary - cafter the 3.6 ‘years Was estimated at $17,281.60°°

by the best of expert painting contractors, ‘(hus reducing.

~ i

!

aus VO; ea, s101e Ex. 22-l warning by command Major General Craig.

Vol. Il, 297-8. This. offer to prove the. laundry ceuld not be operated at-

all in if condition invoked - this trial Court's remark, “I can go down —

“and operate one by myself, and I don't know anything about a laundry.’

This remark was obviously highly prejudicial and contrary to all the evi-

dence. Error discussed Aplt’s. br. below, XPD. 13 Prop. of- Law UU.

18, Vol,’ Ts 2a3 -

19, Peter “Kuen it Vol. TT, 831; Ex. 43. 885. Rejected.

20 Vol. FLL, S23; Ex. 52, 820 (Steinheimer). Rejected.

? ‘ a ' n

ee ; : ea 1°

again the valuation of the building“ by sneh amount at-

the tinfe of it ‘ubandonme nt. This evidence was rejected.

ns indexed. in footnotes. i, : &

9 Thus it might have been argued to the j jury from’

this evidence, had it beef received, that the baliding was

valued, when returned, At #280.548.00 Tess $53,970.06 and’

~ $17,281, 00, or reduced to $209,097 00; the’ inachinery dnd

“equipment at $1 20,699.75 322. the power equipnient and in-

cidental oe. $335,260.53 5 the land retaining -at—

the same value ef $50 900,00 : and the trade routes were’:

totally -destroved tS the taking. These items aggregate

$595,007.28. The difference in. the ‘aluation. of ‘fe prop-

erty of $987,624.32 when taken, and $ 395,097. °8 in vadue

when returned, has resulted in a loss of $592,587.04, to

petitioner on the basis. of the ‘fore and after ¥ alues, The

followir ne. tah les: il} ustr aie the. difference;

:

Date of taking Nov. 21,1942. Mar. 25. 1946 Date of return,

Land - & 30,000.00 $ 0,000.00. —

‘Building are 280,548.00 209,097.00

Power eqaipment 62,928.08 35,260.53

Mach., equip. 273,831.39 120,699.75 »

live ute ‘alues | S40,16,85 ‘none —

987.624. 32 >. "395,057:28 : - : ;

- Petitioner ’s Loss-on before Se

and after value ie eee 2 567 si

Verdict under the court 5 ve

nstrue oe ee 297,776.03

ADSI GHEN Siaiticatio: de-

med completely by the ; |

ies A MOMs ae

=

20] Vo IT, 248, 262 : Ex. 21 .3, 260. Rejected -by Instructions. Vol. I, 257-

Hiv. Assigged as errer an d.dise ussed Avlt’ss bre helow, S2. 83,87: also 39; °

Prep. of Law, Ll and IT, SO, 30%. nae

20.2 Vol I, 106-162. Requested Instructions Refused, To. £433: Exceptions,

Vol. i, 165. sei

ae

7

~~

10. The ‘pital stock Was owl ‘J hy Harry A. Jacob

berger, his brother, A. 1, Jacobhe reer, and a son of Harry,

Frederick, and their families, Iateh head spent his life in

the laundry business. Frederick became a major in the

United States Army-in charge of the ‘Kove rment hinds

at Camp Carson, Colorado, -and «qualifted as an expert

with unusual experience. A. l.. Jaceoberger: its general

manager for years, offered to prove that the laundry had

a fair, reasonable, market Y¥alte asa going coneern “on

November 21, 1942, of $987.624:32. This was re jected. =

*For the ‘purpose of verification and explanation ‘of. the:

composite value, exclusive of: any. value for good-will or

trade. name, he offered 10 prove and corroborate the evi- °

. dence of the other witnesses shown in the table supra,

page 6. raey. sae Aree

99

11. The jury swede for Pee use| ‘alue!? was

$252,000.00, whieh’ is exclusive of the $45,776.03 returned

under the instruc tions of the court?!" onthe estimate of ‘the

damage to physieal property suffered by the petitioner

“making the ger leva. judgment of : wail 776.03.

12. Assuthing that ‘all hor losses Ww ere included: in

the difference in the values -of the property/in 1942 and ~

1946 as $592,967.04, it is app: went. from the. evidence

thiat should have been submitted t to the jury, under proper

instructions, that the verdict might. readily have resulted

in the sum of $592,567.04 rather than the verdict of

ee $297 16.03 which was based on, the evidence as limited

by the trial court, the dental of requested. instructions,

-and the exceptions, ta the ruling"!

oO”): 3 Vol. Ik. 312 31a, > —— ° ; .

24 Vol 1 Oi 101, Jesse ep ae ae ml

SY Vol. ft, 1na-1ti2 = htc: 160. a i

°

aft o>

4 Sco oa Stee

o

wt

133.

Value af the plant as a going concer Noon November 1,

The court, hy mulin o out afi the evidence as to the.

194, either for the prrpose-of. ; showi ing the hasis for de-

termining use or for the. purpose of showing hefore and

after value to -. termitie proper pay for 1 user? denied pe-

titioner substantial rights.

° .

14, If the government's Witnesses We re permitted to

testify that the proper measure of damages was the isolat-

ed value of the building, the isolated value of’ the anachin-

‘ery and the | land, and to figure a percent: gd. of inter ‘est .

couse | as the government’s : theory, and accepted by the

court, then most certainly: the eq@ut should have permitted

tlie petitioner*s offsetting evidence of what it considered:

-the fair, reasonable ‘rental’? value of the property when

oifered by the petitioner.’ This was denied directly or nul- |

ified by the court ’s instruetions, The court for all intents

“and purposes instrueted the jury.to. disregard ey erything

that the owners liad stated as to Values. for temporary use

dnd left for the jury only thie testimony of the” govern-

ment? 8 inexperience c “ad Witnesses, 22.1

At the very outset of the trial the court’ struck

the ae of the petitioner??? ‘The court refused the

applications previously .made for-a pretrial hearing and

failed to enter any order or direction as to the method or

manner of proof for the measure of damages,?3 but the

court stated, ‘‘in a sense we are. plowing néw ground,

"trying to arrive at a-reasonable basis to afford the * *

owners just oe ition under the C ‘onstitution.’”?4 Ce ‘on- 3

: Law iL Apli’s. br. below, S98, 92, 108, 108-9; Vol. 1, 155,

22.1 Vol. I, 157-162. :

/ 22.2 VolmH, 1833 °Vol. IIT, S63.

22.3 Infra pp. --G. i

2.4 Vol. IT, 262-3.

.]

22; Vol, 315-6; cr Aplt’s. br. below, XII, “44-6. Argued under Prop, |

\

™

,

- - 7

fe lo ye :

- ~

-s@nently, the petitione r opie nig the trial, took the post.

fion that ‘the fair, reasonable market, valut of the | prop. 3

erty at the time of taking would Ge proper for all pur-

poses during the trial, This: positiag: the court denied*. ne -

vithe? refused to hear or ruled. out on instructions to the

jury evidence of the fair, reasonable market value when

taken, for all purposes, ax hereinabove clearly set forth

‘and indexed in the footnotes, supra, p. 7,

16. However, the petitioner sought to‘show the fair,

reasonable Compensation for the usé, of the premises dur.

ing the period’ because the court re pe ‘atedly so ruled, must

be tlie sole nifasure of dainages. These “use” sums given:

by. Harry <A. Jacobberger, A. L. Jacobberger, and Fred

Jacobberger were $600,000, $570,000, and $570, O00 resped:

einen see Those { igures imbladee all items. of eom-

3. A. L.-J; Vel. It, 318-267: After pages of examination to substantiate

> SSTO.0000 as just compensation for ‘the use, including. all damages except

to trade routes’ atid business, the court said it would withhold ruling. Yo.

Il, 331—""We will take your motion (to, strike the testimony of the owner) ,

under advisement.” Further at’ the close of the testimony, Vol. II, 367-—~

“I will insfruct the jug with reference to these items when the time

~ eomes.”” Later the-ecourt'S instructions nullified the evidence, Vol. T, 155_

165, Apit’s. br. below, Error XIV, 48 discussed. Instructions, Aplt’s. br.

below, . < Argued, [trop. Law If, 111, Apit’s. br. below, Vol. 1, 172-8.

- 23.1 Harry. J.. Vol. HE, 421- By 441-3. The court assumed without cause the

witness's estimate of. $600,000 for the term inchided damages for trade

route destruction, good will, and Joss of business; So under such erroneous

impression the ey — nullified. Vol. IT, 421-443. Error. assigned.

Aplt’s. br below, XVII, 54; argued under. Prop. Law “IL.

22.2 Fred J. —inusual avaifetins as Army Major in charge of Army laundry

at Camp Carson, Colorado, and Jefferson: Barracks, Mo., Vol. TT, 443-58.

~~ His testimony re use’ compensation, &570,000 for 3.6 years, Vol TT, 4545,

excluded “loss of customers, routes, loss of business, or good will.” Vol. IL.

- 458-9. Ruling of court an objection was, Vol. 11.400, “I will instruct the -

jury.on these items when the proper time comes.” Inst. Vol. cs int-368 and.

, Inst. denied, Vol. I, 47238. .

23.5 Aplt’s. br. below, Error: or 63. Instruction of court specifically renoune-

ing the witness, Fred Bip 0 Oe Ma ‘157: renouncing. A. L. J. testimony. Vol.

I, 156; re nouneing Harty J. testimony. Vol. I. 146. Errors, Aplt's..br. be

low, XVILE, 5; XIV, 48. Briefed and, argued Trop. Law T, 89: 1. 110.

{f the itemization of what the owners had in mind te .base their “use”

compensation contained items not compensadle as the trial court viewed

them, the specific items should have been ruled out rather than the de

nunciation of the court finalky+saying, after the nbeve comments (Vol. I,

157). “With these considerations in mirid, how-are we going to find the

o a i

«

pensation except damage to trade routes,’ business and

goodewill. Nevertheless the evtulence Was excluded by def-

‘unite itistruetions ef the eouirt 3 ae:

é ei

An each instance, as shown in footnote 23) 23a,

"yo

23.2, 2 23.3, 23h, 23.5, the court either ruled out the -testi-|

mony or by speciffe reference to each of the three owner-.'

witnesses renoune ‘ed their testimony so completely that

the jury were left with no. practic al solution but to find

as desired by the government witnesses. |

oe 2 z here were three principal gover ‘nynent witness-

es: ng :

(a) ©. R. Crowder, who never use “«l, hought, or “sold

laundry machinery and equipnient, nor Was: he familiar

with such property or the plant u 1 194224 He was oye

of the assistants in the office of the Army Engineers. He

went about the city to pick up information: here and there

about cost of repairs and, replace ments of such machinery

and: equipment. He was net a contractor or builder’s ar:

chiteet. He was pe ‘rmitted> over objections to testify, and

ji compiled his own hearsay exhibits, 594 of them, 0 over ob-

-@ .-

e t

fair rental value for the use of this obaidies’ ? There does not seem.to be

anyone qualified. to help us reach that fit 3%: S Next. thé court said

in his instructions, Vol. I, 159, “Having once arrived: at the. value, you

then ‘can ‘begin figuring and use as a yardstick an interest rate.’ Aplt’s.

br. below, Errors.1-H, 18 and I- - 19. Also erfors on refusal of instructions ;

Aplt's. br. below, Error IFPI, 21-5

24 The: court, by giving the instructions iV» requested by the government.

committed reversilile error in a conemnation- suit, because the jury were

told to disrezard evidence -that did not appear anywhere'as evidence during :

the trial. gError, Aplt’s: br. below, 25-6: Vol. I, 164. These were “inter-_

ference with the business, frustration of the business enterprise, inconven<

ience to the owner, the unwillingness of thé owner to part with bis propérty -

tenporetily : ee" Arzueland briefed, Prop. Law ILL. Apit's. br. below,

Ps F “fitins ix: “The eonduet of the trinl-must be proper, er reversible error

. results.” Citing 144 Neb. 325. S29sine, 13 ONL W. 2d 188. Court-of Appeals | -

rate limiting pates to SS stopped further dise mssion, but the error is ob-

vious arid elementary. ° , *

w35 Vol. I, 157-162.

24. Vel TEL, 656... ; "Ne

7 = act bee

—————————

7 ‘VW Ne (ae :

) e “4 © .,

jection,’® which were received as “official government doe-

‘uments,”’ and: 20 volunteered hy the trial court to the

‘jury’’to appellant's prejudice, Mr. Crowder stated that

the ost tor restore the entire buikling, painting, and ‘all

_ else would he S37. 521, wot: that it would vost $20,471.27 to

restore the machine ry W here it was in 1942, less. ordinary

depreciation, inchiding : excessive. use; and $1,750.40. ‘for

other items of replacemenit.’ His estimates total $59 43.01,

No other figures were affered by either side that’ were

less than this amouft for the restoration of the building

‘and the equipment,: power plant, ete. Nevertheless, with-

out evidence from’ any — source, the jury found. that..this

total damage was $45,776.03. © (‘*Renial’’ $252,000; all .

damages, $45, 776.03: total judgment based on jury’s ver-

dict, $297,776,03.)?7 as an OR ae

/ fis

(b) Witness Weber who never ran a laundry, who ,

never bought or sold laundry- machinery or equipment,

and was not a laundry man, stated as a professional ap-

praiser® for the gov ernment that the total rental for

3.6 vears should be $70,080 per year, ora total of $252,000.

That.was exactly the’ sum the jury found. Under the form

of the Exhibit 22°81 and the court’s instruetion’s? that

intérest on the separate sums would produce a proper re-

. sult, no‘other conclusion was left for the sary. |

(ec) Lewis D. .Sholes, for the government, ‘a: real . |

‘estate man who never bought or sold any laundry machin-

25. Vol. IIT, 634.5 . Ex. it. a ies Laie ; .

26. Ver. TIT, G48; 602 G41, Ex. 18; GH. ee : 4

27. Vol. 1, 95-6. ae eer

28.9 Vol TTL, 735-7; 723 °725; T28-; 135-7; T4H4y 747; 749: Ex. 25, 750; Ex.

ye Zz 7: 3, * ; 3

28.1 Voll HI. Ex. 22. ora Paes.

28.2 Voi. 1, 149..." *

te

ap EF

ery or gquipment, never operated a daundry, was permit- ;

tetl to testify, that’ the annual rental, including excessive

use, should he $65,663.00 per year, plus additional costs

of restoration above normal: depreei ation Of $16,680.00.

Mr. _ Sholes’ total of all compensation was for the period |

$253,066. 80.29 | ao ‘

Fe x

ae 19. Tir the opinion of the Court, of Appeals® the

court said, ‘*The jury’s verdict was-well within the evi-

dence: While the total award was much. less than the: -

amount claimed by. the company, it is exceeded by about.

S40, 000. 00, the highest estimate made by any government

2

expert witness.’

20. This will be seen from the record was not the fact.

‘While the trial court is the judge of the credibility of wit-

ness and the admission of evidence, nevertheless these |

*

abuses of discretion. avc-so Numerous as to sum AP to-

an unfair trial generally, The Court ‘of Appeals should

have so. found. |

Tt will be seen ae a careful analysis of the exhib-.

its pics r ferred to'and. which were received in évidence ..

over objection, that the jury’s verdict was less than the

‘estimate for-restoration made by Mr. Crowder ($59,543.-

01) by approximately $15,008700. The verdict for the,

‘‘rental? ” was that fixed by the witness Weber ($252,000.-

60)" and was almost identical with the total sum for all

parposps “fixerk by the Witness ‘Sholes for the gov ernment,

a 22 {: nder the instructions of the court for all prac?

ae

tical purposes the jury was denied the 1 ‘ight to consider ,

any evidence of the pefitioner’s $ witnesses generally, and

29,- Vol. ut ~— Bx. 24, TIO-80-3-4.

30. Vol. ty, : P

a

é g . °

19

be upon the jury: by. the court.

.

\

\

Re has been denied as he Somacia id e shown: by proper

refer ‘eTice to the ree ord. "

’

upon for. reversal. and each was specifically argued and

discussed Min appellant? s bri ief

\ therefore: these governine geet witnesses’ figures | Ww veré toveed. pees

24° All the. foregoing Were set up as points relied.

a

\. ~ Error Jias ‘thus been committed, said. substantial

s before thie ‘Court of . Ap-

peals, “Kiglith Cirenit.? By fae ation of counsel thie

points relied a for reversal below wet re presented in

the brief below \nstead of in- the reeord.? Is ach error was

discussed and ariued under the propositions ,ot law ap-

‘plicable in appellant's brief below. io

2

A summary of the evidence on the estimated cost to

restore and replace property destroyed. discloses the fol-

lowing: : \:.

Admitted by oar

Jovt. witness Crowder’s es-

timates for restoration of |

damages to structures.

Bldg. & Painting $37,521.34

Machinery _ 20,471.27

Replacemer is 1,750.40 —

(Received) $59,743.04

RE een

33: Vol; I, .157-162. .

32. Aplt’s. br. below le ft with Clerk of U.

Appellant’ s witnesses: rejected. except

ie Dahlquist. :

7 Bldg. (Kiewit) "$53,970.00 Rejected

| ainting (Steinheimer) ;

17,281.00 Rejected

Boilers (Hanighen) ers

\ «+ 21,678.00 Rejected

. Boilers . \ ; 6, 183.00 Rejected

*. - «'\

Mach. & Equip, re-.

pairs (Dahlquist) $4,309.42 Reeeived

$133,421.42 Rejected

(See footnntes p. 10 supra.)

Ss. ‘Sup. Ct. for. proof of proper dis

cussion of points to the Court of Appeals. ;

32. Vol. I, 142.

[ BW ee “

4

Of) ; 2 < ® ; .

. Za. i ine Jury's verdict for estimated restoration ;

“damages: w: 1s S45. 770,0302 ‘Phe petitioner, of course, cout

not arene to the jury auy item to contrandiet Crowder &x--

cept Dahiquist’s $ $54,509.42 by virtue of the rejecting of

. these exhibits’ and testimony by the court as above shown | |

and all arefully: ; indexed to the record in the foregoing ai

footnotes. x

5 |

26. Title 40.0. 8 C4 § 257-8 (a) (appre ndix Aplt's, ;

br. herein) spe cifically provides that in questions ‘of pro- | |

_ cedure the’ state “practice sh: al] he followed. No substan- }

tial rigat w ould iave heen denied the. gove rnment sby the

-iidmigsion of the testimony of the witnesses Kiewit, Stein- og

~ heimer, and Hi: anighen in rebuttal to Mr, Crowder’s. These .

witnesses’ For petitioner are reputable men in their re. 7

spective lines .of business, They wholly. discredited wit. 7

ness Crowder’s siate: nénts. The trial Court. ordin: arily -

is the last word in sucle matters but that court shall not .

- abuse ttscdiscretion, when .gr ave in justiee oby lofisly will j

result 35 |

“Written pleadings. are required. under the Ne-

braska. practices? ‘The court struck all-of petitioner's an-

swer?? | ails ae

The trial Court reversed “itself by first” stating -

. this ver y. rebuttal evidence AWwould he allowed ‘because as.

-the trial proeceded: petitioner offered’ eviden nee of before

and after values, offered evidence of ‘total values at time

of taking for pueposes of use value; then to meet the

court's theory offe rod evide nee of use value all as above.

4a Vol. I, 06: 101-7. |

oo, Vol. ITE, Sve: SBS-9- 821 &; S47. ? o

° 36. Appx. p. 2] this brief, - 7

“Bi. Vol. 17, 188. ; ry

Py

> hee sent Va Re

21

a

related. This ev iilenee Wis all éithe r de vied at the time of

0-1

offer oF substantially ruled aul hy the court ’s iN~ ~fructions.

as above shown in the footwotys.

{ ‘onsequently, when the

. anticipated: restoration cos ts of $105,421. 42 were offe rel

this further

77 N. \. 120).

LTi ave

Under

> in rebuttal to meet the € ‘rowder testimony of = O47. $3.01,

and’ was ré jected,

error

28 U."B. -C.:§ 391,

~ petent testimony affecting substantial rights of one p: urty

“gives grounds: for ‘eXamining the entire record and grant-

ing retri: uf to insure that, justice will be done,’

28, ‘The

following

table may be used to illustrate

the manner ip which petitioner was oe interest from

. the date of taking i in violation of 40 U.

“Date or Onven

OF TAKING

—~

Nov. 21, 1042 |

te 2) :

May 11, 1943

Aug. 12,°1944

db.

May 28, 1945

. =

Fudgment

$297. 776.638

April 9, M6 |

Pd. by purehase

of govt. mach.

Q

3s. - Vol. TIL, 812;

“To Waar Date

june 3 30, 1444

June 30, 1945

June 30, 1946

DATES OF

Derosir

June 30, 1943. June 21, 46

Apr. 6. 44

baal *

Ang. 10, “44

Aug. 8 “45

_« sJune 11, °

Mar. 23. 46

S15: 826-831: S11; 833-5; S47

¢

ie - 28a >

- :

a DATE

sAMOENT = WiuoripRawn

$30,140 — Féb. 1, 1944

F (1, 53)

Apr. 12) 144 ©

TA), 0O

; (1, 50)

ALLL Aug, 18, 1944

(1,68) (1,72)

65.000 Aug. 11, 1945

wee Sie oe) 2:

9S, 124. 27 Aug. W. ‘1946

ST5.00R OO.

(and)

WesINn +

.Stips TT. i84).--

.

» Se. SH.

by the trial.

(‘ourt oceurred. “Ht Was not merely. procedural irregularity

a (56 Neb.. 600,

- Jud. Code § 269. as interpreted, the raling out of any-com-

._ “e

ry

ai), Lhe petitions - claims interest ate 66) con the

297.4 6.00 jirlement as alditional, damage tor the tatkinie, ;

De srnriiiee with the data of the taking to “the-time eleetes [

by the govern: nent to te riminate ‘the taking, ‘June. 30, 146,

The property was dee! ared surplits anil ‘abandoned to the

Company on “March 25, 146 (1, 97). Admitied|y from

the dite: the furids shown on the foregoing tible were a

paid: into the: Registry of Court, ‘he 6% would abate.

There remaius in the Registry of Court tinder court or-

“der: and by stipulation of counsel some ‘funds to avoid,

Satis fection of the Judgment. pending Sppes “1, 1) (Us = &

oA 3.0. 28a). Appendix Sepia or es ae) Ver

.

“30. “'Ehe court eranted no iterest whuitev ey On, SO,

FOG A of the, jndeipent whieh, was the award for restora-

thom Can s to repnir and restore the prope rity, the re-

ei . «

. . ° ’

ri ’ ?

“spon th BUN Adel wile capt “HON the | laundry company to

AG what it eould best do with this noney. The court should- coreg Til

chav Avi ante “4 interest at 6 the reon. row the. date of tak-

zis THY on Npvic mie 21/1942: Instead of g ranting interest ow

92,000, au Bs? from: November’ 21, “1942 (except on the

payme ints riale- on, the deposit iiade 7 | the Registry of

+

Cou rt’ ‘as nbovy* shown), the court after ee theated each

yi sear ais anew taking, without: re lerence: to- “they original

t “dhe nt. reblloted w as = de nied saa #2, at time of fie Goer

: ‘

for iiterest: as Drager comperisation uitder the\ said

: Status e (40 a ae Sa), This ‘Alenial of interest} was

Na isines alas brroy,, dase and irene to both court A bo.

Stow. Neither court, Would correct This, port relied Ap.

oo oy tue ayirue “ad: iN shawn?

laa - ‘

et - ° ee oY 3 Pape © stn sf (

_ ipa am a oe ’ ; ‘ Ss / , . <

ry / 6% — . “en - © ‘s e ‘ 5 - , \ Te we — - .

SY Pol AE. ODT Val 2 S. motion in errest. fer new trial, Vodo FL WT... a EE

ob fe-fi a: Bae = \ Sy ‘ ;

aos , s . i . , > - E

oor : * ao

~

Ne he

‘ . eo

tn

2 urther the court: Tus od to er ant interest on |

Sas S75. oO in sup ilies that svere. condemned ‘and taken | iV

the govern nit On, Novembe f.2T, 1942, and not pand: for un- |

til July S, 19433, This iuterest ‘up ts the time of the judg

ment on April 9, 19208 amounted to SE3BNTAL. Soth these -

items of inte rest were ei riv. before the trial, court! 2 dnd

the U nited: States Court « f Appeals, Neither granted the

interest claimed, The fede ‘al statute’ cited: c learly covers

thie situation of allowing intefest as contended: "by petition:

er. Both items now aeeregate in EXCE ss of § 25,000, . The

Statute refers ‘to interest from date of ae for all pur-

poses and makes no such permissive’ &xce tion as erro-

neously made by thre trial court and affirmed hy: the Court’

of Appe 5 ee eee, : et

: *

32° The trial court ‘erred in refusing to allow $5,-_

153.97 expenses before the. appraisers: (Vel. I, 40), ass

--—~taxable- costs, These eshould tollow: the final qudgme nts

: we

. Q:

« “% ()

ASSIGNMENT OF ERRORS ;

with Discussion and Argument —

Simmary: Did the trial court comnyit reversible

harmless error under 28° U.S. C.°§ 391, Sod. Code § 269,

and the decisions applic able to: a1 trials; (1) by refusing’

2

to admit evidence, (2) by refusing. to: receive e certain ma-.

sat ciousihaneinintangieciniobicils

ij ®

40 “Misizned as Error Apit's. br. below, 66, argued, on ppe 125-6. Contained in

te Aftiswer stricken, Vol. 1, 80. Tet.'in error, T, 51025. Discussed by Court,

Vol. 11, IN3! Motion in arrest. of judgement denied, Vol. T, 98, JIL Motieir

for new trial denied, Vol. I, 108¢4). There was no disagreement regard-

-ing this igem and when paid’ The facts are not in djspute. Phe.government

Claims because it voluntarily paid the item ‘and the check was accepted,

that conefuded the mutter. PPowever, the subphc “were “taken” along wth

all else. Payme “nts bag be recer¥ed without: pre judiee ‘to further rights

wider See, 258a 1. . Title 40-2 2. ) \

— ast \

hh, ot. ¥, On: 101-7 4 (Tudzwent on Verdict) Vol. IV.: °

j ‘

» @ : :

? yo, <

oy ; : 5

terial © Vidence offe red, (3) Ii receiving rertaim evide ace

over u jection, 4) bye giving the court, 's ‘instruc Hons Cone

sidered al tovether, rr 5) hy refusing to vive certain in-.

“structions requested: hy, petitioner, (6) Dy the court mak-

_ lng * innurire ‘rable commie nis: hefore the jury ‘that obviously

»

Were made to carry intone xecution, by the jury the court’s

wishes rather than w itnesses’ state ments, and. (7) by over-

ruline the motion in arrest of’ judeme ut amd overruling

the motion for new trial. Vol.-1, 403-97; 107.

es . I Lou,

0 ‘ ;

. . ‘ ¥ 6

Is not the opinion of. the United States: Court of

“Appeals in error by stating. that the judgment reflected -

‘all the elements: of value which lawfully might be eensid-'

ered in y determining the issue of just compensation to

which, the petitione® wes entitled and that no errors of

law were ‘committed hy the trial court: that would War-

rant a reversal? | The - record shows thirty- two points re-

tied upon fer reversal, each of which was discussed with

record page references given. ‘(Aplt’s. br. below, 14/88;

discussed. and argued Prop. i. tp 3h, 1H, aaa IV, Aplt’s.

br. below, 89-124.) These: references ‘sufficiently refute

1

tis opinion of the eourt below that most of the points ,

relied upon for reversal ‘fare not-argued in the brief and

virtually all. of them reflect the di¥ergenée of views of

_ counsel for the Company and those of the irial court

relative t6 the proper standards for. ascertaining ‘just

compenst ation?” Such statemont in the opinion becomes im-

portant hecause tha’ court held, ‘terrors assigned, but

not afeued ir this brief, = waived.”™ (Vol. TV, 6-7.)

‘LAT these “questions? were presented to the Court of

Appe ‘als as shown: thy the index in the footnotes and: Ree.

|

ae |

{

nas

ord references herein above given under Statement af the

_ Case. The trial court procedure and the judgment were af:

* firmed’ Vol:-1.0; 11-7; Vol IV, 3-14.) Lotra, pp. 34108.

‘ ; ML. iy

In attempting to arrive at just compensation, was it -

not error for the trial court to deny the petitioner the

right to prove: the fair, reasonable market value of. its:

plant as-it. was at the date of taking, when the evidence

shows that the condegmor took and destroyed, as a direct

result of the. taking, with knowledge that such damage °

would result, all tlie existing routes ‘constituting the most

valuable of the componeni parts of the composite prop-

erty? (Aplt’s. br. below, Mrror XT; 44-7; supra 8-9;°12

with footnotes ) ;

ris 2 -TV:

Did not the trial court err in ruling out the evidence

, of the petitioner that it) was ‘completely and entirely

driven from business by virtue of the taking and could |

not re-establish itself because, of the obvious result of the

taking. and the delayed *piee cemeal”’ pay plan adopted

by the. government! (Table;-supra, pe 19; Error XIX,

/ Apit?s. Dr. below, p. 61; Prop. L. 1, 109; Vol.«II, 437-9;

/ fa 53.) ) . 4 ;

Vs

Did not ‘the trial court err in re jecting’ audits of the

petitioner company, competently prepared, from which

might be argued the facts” that any dealer for. the prop-

erty for auy purpose would desire = know! (Vol H, |

Ex. 1-7, 188-221; Error VE, Aplt <. br. be low, 28-33; ar-

gued Prop. LL. I; 95-8 eeupra, 6.) aa ae

NI. :

Did not the trial court err in rejecting the evidence

of the von pe tent wittiess . Judd. who offered to prove for

the Consideration of the ‘tall mn assessing pe titioner’s dam.

ages thie aetual, value of the trade routes in the course

of business and.as an inherent part of ‘the business of this

servicing company, vind Who ‘offered to prove what. it’

would cost the petitiotier based upon the-gxperience. of

that company, it thé City of Omaha to re-establish those

routes over the stceecding, three years after the plant

was abandoned to the appell: int?) (Supra, 9-12; Vol. II,

367; Ex. 14, 370-1, 872, 376, 380.” Error: XV,- Aplt’s. br.

a ‘51, and XVI, 53. Discussed, a s. br. below, P rop.

L. 1, 89. )

a ‘i se

.3 Did not the court°err, after +the petitioner’s case was

closed, by permitting a voygrnment witness (Crowder),

who failed to qualify properly as a competent authority.

on costs, to.give his .estimates of the probable cost to:

restere the’ property, ineliding the building and machin-.

ery i which estimates consisted of 494 hearsay items, and |

over objection, the court remarking in the presence of

the jury that such 594 documents were ‘ ‘vovernment doeu-

ments’? and, “official reports’? and with ‘such. prestige

were admitted!, ( Aplt §. br. helow, Errer. XXVI, 70; ar-

gued Prop. Li 11, 1093 créss-exam., Vol. TL, 641; 648;

656-69. Supra, 16-21.) 7 , :

VIEL rie

Did not the court err in receiving the evidence, over -

objection, of the government witnesses (Weber and

°

wl

Sholes), neither of whom was qualified to state that the

fair, reasonable, compensation for ‘temporary use’? was

a sum- of monéy based upon ‘their idea of interest on the

‘value of the building separately, the machinery and equip.

_dthent separately, and the land separately, as appraised by

these witnesses themselves, when the witnesses themselves

could give no preeedent in.the laundry business. or any

other basiness for such a method for just compensation,

when the court had hefore it a more fair and just method

of arriving at. just compe nsation. by the difference in the

values of the property before and-after taking, or. by

fixing a percentage compensation, based upon the fair,

reasonable value of the whole property as-a going con-

g" ;

cern at: the. time of takine ? (Weber, Vol. TI, 721- TO03 Er-.

"ror AXV Il, Aplt’ s. br. below, 72-9; aryued P rop. L: -H,

111. Sholes, Vol. 11, 760-801; Error XXVIII,- Aplt’s.

_——

br.. below, 75-8; argued Prop. .L. 11, 111. ‘Supra. 17,18.)

| Tals IN. t a : aes

Did not the trial court err in nullifying’ the eviderice

. of the three-officers and owners of the company w hon they

offered their ésti imates of the fair, reasonable rental val-

ue of the physical ‘assets, exclusive of good will, trade,

routes, /and ‘trade namé, when such witnesses were. the

_ only qualitied Witnesses to give such testimony? And fitr:.

ther, did not the trial court err in*withholding i its ruling

on the government’s objection to sueli testimony and then

eondemning and ‘rejecting it by- instructions thus leaving

no other t testimony. before the jury’ on such subject, as s

stated in the instructions of the court except the “oxpert

witnesses’? who gave as a proper measure of damage, in-

terest on land, building, and semua Ae (H. A. J.,. Vol.

por

\u

Q

properly. in the main case

OQ

Ti, 42) 443; Mirror XVUIL, Aplt *S, br. below, 06-61. Fide

Vol. UW, 454. 460. Error XX, Aplt’s. br. below, 68-4. AL

L. J., Vol. MH, 367; Error XIV, Aplt’s. br.. below, 48-5f.

cee court’s instruvetions, Voi. 1, 152-161. Error I, Aplt’s.

be low, 15-19... Argued, Prop. L. I, Uh, Aplt’s. br. below,”

Rx, 109. Supa, 15-16.) 7 hee 0

- Were not the composite instructions : of the trial

court so at variance with both the fact ts andthe applicable

law as to, substantially prejudice | the rights af the peti-

tioner “by denying 4t_just compensation, even unfler the.

measire of damage plan adopted by the court for the

conduct of the,case? (Court’s Tnst.. Vol. 1, 157-165 3 EFror

I, Anplt’ s. br. below, 15-19; Prop. L. Ul, 124° Inst. re-

quested by petitioner, r refuse dy A ol. 1, 172-8, /Supr: a, 12-15, )

~~ . , XI.

Did not the court, ¢ommit reversible error in refus-

ing the rebuttal testimony of the petitioner's witnesses

to rebut the government’s witnesses ‘on the probable cost

to repair and replace the broker. pants of the building,

adopted by the trial judge? (Ap!t’s. br. -helow, 82, 833 873

argued Prop. L. HL, 124.‘ Petitioner submitted as a. Prop.

L.-that +, ‘Rebuttal testimony, if substantial and material,

~ shall he received (55 Neb, 600, 6054 77 N. W. 120): —

$9

| -

; supra, 19-21).

>

x. oS ae es

‘In an action in condemnation for just compensation,

is it error, for the court to instruct the jury that the’ case

x ; aul :

°

“machinery, equipment, boilers, and power plant, especially

-under ‘the indefinite plan for: measuring damages finally

n"

ae

before them is. not’ one for “damages? but. is. an? f*in-

quest’’? .(Mrror I-g, Aplt’s. br. below, 16, Discussed Prop.

lL. 1, S&; Vol. I, 154-5.,)

Oe ee

Did not the court commit reversible error when itsin-

structed the jury to disregard evi lence on’ a subje -et—natin-

ing it—which wascentirely absent from ‘any testimony or

ae evidence offered or received by either side at the trial?

The. court. instructéd the- jury to allow just compensation

‘‘without any sentimental values, without any good will,

is ae the fact that it Was. a goingseoncern, or the fact that

they were put to a lot of consequential damages. That.

is what they refer to: Consequential damages are just

their hard luck that they shappened to be selected, the

_same as if would be the hard |luck of your son if he were

ealled into the army.’’? (Vol. 4, 159; Error Li, Aplt’s. br.

below, 18; Pro a L. I]; 109.) | oc. ‘

Also “You are not te consider the fact. that the own-

ers of this property have a sentimental value there, having

spent a lifetime working to build up: theinstitation and

they did not want to sell.”’ ‘You cannot. take into consid-.

eration the fact that these brothers and their families

did not want to sel] their property or did not want to

lease it. > (ol. 1,154.) Also the many similas e<pressions

= ° oncerning matters not Jan ev idence, Vol. Ty 1 5-6,

‘©

sy ; 8 ; :

Did not the court err in failing. to interpret 4.UL S.C,

208a_as amended (appendix) as gr ranting petitioner as

7 -a matter of statutory law 6° interest on the entire judg-

“ment of-the jury from the date of the taking? Did not

30

°

the-« ourt err by deciding’ without judicial precedent 6%

interest only from the beg ginning of. each fiscal year as ~

if in. fact-there- had been a separate taking of - same,

property at the beginning. of each fiscal. year! (Ih ror

XXUH, Aplt’s. br. below, 66;-argued Aplt’s. br. below,

| Prop, L. IV, 125.) To the samé effeet, did not the court

err in failing to grant interest on $34,875.50 of laundry

soap, chemicals and other supplies. condemned “and taken

on November 22, 1942, but not paid for until July &, 1943?

~ Points raised in answer,, Vol. I, 30; stricken Vol. 11, 183;

raised in pet. in error, Vol. I, p. 52; raised again. mh mo-

tion in arrest of judgment, Vol. 1:98, overruled: and in

motion for new trial, Vol. I, 108, overruled; judgment

entered denying: interest as: claimed, Vol. 1,°103-7. Ere

ror XXII, Aplt’s s br. below, 66; Prop. L. LY, 125; 40 U.

S.C. § 258a.° (Infra erpendix: of this brief.) (Also the

‘denial of costs beZore appraisers. of $3,153.97, Vol. I, 40, ,

was crror, and should follow the judgment.) ;

es

. “Did not the trial court commit reversible error when

repeatedly throughout the trial and in its-instructions to

the jury stated that the law announe ed by the Supreme-

Court of nol United States in U.S. v. General Motors

Co. , 323 U.S. 873, decided January 8, 1048 5, and in U.+S.

. Petiy Motor Ca., 327 U. S. 372, decided Febr uary 25,

1086, required the ~ to inst ynet that.1io damages could

‘be considered (Vol. J , 159); just © compensation must ;

“be limited to “erent”? < the exclusion of other ‘competent /

measures: ot “damages of record (supra, 7-14; 19), -fig-

ured as an arbitrary rate of interest. on the land, ‘the

building, and the ummebinery, separately valued (Vol, %

159) with: an additional sum, exclusive of general depre-

ol.

ciation, Nor Ahe estimated 6r prohable cost to repair: and

replac broken narts? (Trial court refused to set case

for frial until General Motors ease — Vol. I, 74_

60; motion for new’ trial, Vol. 1294, pars. 25-63

ourt’s Inst., Vol. ‘TL, 152; Vol. I, i 32.) Court made

2

rujing to limit ‘petitioner’ s®case to “rules laid down “in

the Utah case and i in the Chicago easé, the Gener al Motors .

ease.”? Vol. 11, p. 939. Neither of said cases ‘ifivolves the

taking over: from the: owner a going eficern to be: run .

and operated by the 3 army for its tse as the same eniter-

prise, as in the ease af bar. F

XVI. I

‘Did not: the United States Court. of Appeals, commit

error when it held an the decisions in U.S. v. General

2, Motors Co. and U.S. v. Petty Motor Co. w ere its author-

ity for stating, a éannot accept this proposition of

law’??? The said proposition of law is Prop. L. 1 set forth

in ‘petitioner’s ‘briet ini the court below; 89, and is copied -

from the opinion below; V ‘ol: IV,-p. 8, as follows: ;

“When all. the vhivsiealasaste’ of a going’ busi-

ness, such as a laundry and dry cleaning corporatién,

are. condemned for the: purpose of governmental op-.-

eration of the same business for the exclusive use of

the army, thus putting the Gondemnee ¢or poration out.

of business entirely, the fair, reasonahle market val--

ue to the corporation as a going. concern on the date

of the taking forms the proper legal basis upon which

- to measure such just compensation. The established

: 7 aot traile roufes, when so ‘proven to have a read-

—Giy ase ertainable value onthe market, form a part of

the composite fair mayket valué on the date of tak-

ing. These rotites aré distinguished from the. non-

compensable items of good will, Joss of profit, amd

loss of further business. ‘If it,is proven that these

-O

2.)

reel:

routes would he destroved’ as a. natural comseq it: nee

known to ‘the condemnor as. a’ dircet. and proxtinate

result ‘of the taking of the plrysical ‘plant owned. by

the -condeninee, their value es a part of-the total

value of-the eompensable property taken, The re ‘fusal

of the tria! court to receive competent evidence of-

fered to.prove such value is re versible error, =

2

: (By idence on-factual’ matters embrae ‘ed in‘above a

inent of the law was rejected by the trial eourt: Cf. pomts

relied upon for revers sal, Appellant’s, brief he sui aorror

‘YI discussed, 27; VET, 28; VIII, 37-8; XIII,,44-8: XV,

» ° 51-2; XVI, 53-4; XVII, 54-5; XIX, 64; XII, 43. Errors

argued in’ the Propositions of Law, Aplt's. .br. below,

«

Prop. tae, 89-109.) (Court’s ead Vol. 1, p. 154, stated:

Under the Constitution and. under the law, you cannot

make any allowance whatever for pom that is not

taken.’ *) Supra, 6-13 @ 0 | f

5 eat ee , UXVIL - 3 ,

a

“Did not. the court. err» a failing to properly interpret.

and apply the, condemnation statutes (supra, 3; found. in

_appéndix to. this brief) relied pos .by the government

‘an its petition (Vol. I, -5) > filed November 21, 1942,

and the same statutes pleaded in defense by the-condem-

nee in answer (stricken, Vol. il, 183) and in its request-

ed instructions (refised,” Vol. I, 172), priveipally in the «

following csopcian “peas. : .

1: These statutes should properly he interpreted. |

in pari materia. fae ee Er

“ger aes

amchded, does not clearly eover the case at bar, heeatise

‘the | dondenne possessed land but did not POSSeSs ‘“the

e “5 mi eel

2. When ‘so interpreted, Seetion 174, 50 U.S. C., as ’

—

.

‘

—_

x ig

«~

temporary use thereof or other interest thérejn.’? hustead,

the government created a ““temiporary use?’ of its own

by its petition. tn so doing it ‘teok over an operating

company indefinitely but witlr powey ‘to terminate:

3. The reall of the taking rathoks than the form of

the petition det: ermines the. extentof the condemnation. for.

the purpose of paying just compensation for ithe. t taking,

and this power of de te rmination of just compe nsation. is .

lodged exclusively in the judicial branch of the govern-

"ment... | eer. ere ne a

4+ Congress has protected previous owners and the

— ——governnient as well | by enacting Section (22, a as-an ‘amend-

ment to the-Act of October 16, 1941, 50 U.S. c . entitled, |

“Return of Property to Original Qwner.’? -So- that the:

ralue before and the value after or when ae to’ the

previous owner or offered to, has deen legalized in this

-statutory manner. Prop. L. If, Aplt’s. “br, below, 112-125 q

brought this.point tothe attention of: the Court of Ap-

peals. It failed to recognize, the point.

. This difference in the value at time of taking arid

at time of return, while reeognized by Congress and asa

/ proper method. by competent courts, was erroneously

denied the laundry company in this: “ese (ef, petitioner’s.

instr. refused, Vol. I, Inst. No. ILA72:/No. X, 175; No.

XII, 177;,No. XIV; 177. “Ansxer, V6l. I, pleading/the .

statutes, Mall 21, at pars. SV’ , XVI, XVIII, 28-9: Order |

7 strikin. g same, Vol. I], 188 Vol. I’ 863. Motion for 1 new

trial, Vol. T, 107, overruled. Special exhibits comprising

these statutes were attached to the motion, v ol. I, 126-134

“Error. in striking them from consideration. set forth cal

‘discussed, Apld br. below, 26; Prop. L. ‘argued T and-

Il, Aplt’s. br. below, 89, 109; - - /

#

GH

. . ~) ‘ ° / . .

All condemnation sta4utes in question aré eapied in

full in the appendix to. this brief.

a

The references above to “Aplt’s. br. below’ are on points for reversal

herein presented with same numbefs, [ to XXXII following.

7

w

POINTS RELIED UPON FOR REVERSAL —

. AND IN COURT BELOW WITH DISCUSSIONS

AND ARGUMENT... ;

[All oral testimony and. all rulings of nm rare

eourt’s instructions (1, 150-169), instructions tendered by.

petitioner (1, 172), exceptions (T, 165), and the rulings

on ul evidence and objections are. set forth verbatim in

the rdcord. “As above stated, counsel agreed to the desig-

nation of the revord (1, 145). Only some. of the volumi:

nous exlibits are viven in part, as cléarly indie: ited, ‘and

~ the remainder are deseribed by agreement of counsel 7 eS

3-9). All else in the record i+ ptinted verbatim. ]

‘Under decision : and rules. wheré error is predicated

upon evidence: offered aid rejected the proc ‘eodings there.’

oO

on must be set out in full. Accordingly that has heen

_ done. | 8 Pe emeawe d

. : . ae : .

a. Appellant helow is: Petitioner herein.)

The court erre d in. giving the following as portions

of its insiruétions to the: jury (I, 150),-becanuse the state-

ments are in conflict with the court's instruction: that.

“was given. that the petitioner was -entitled to- the fair,

reasonable market value of its property as, of November —

22 , 1942, and was entitled to be placed infas good a post

tion be cunianily as a was on November ‘22, 1942,

“0

ry F ; :

>... ¢

; Tea | \

‘The cotrt has gone further and said that the t

» measure for juries and courts is the-fair, reasonable 3

' market: value of: the property at the time it is taken. }

That rule. worked very nicely in actions where they \

took the fee title..* * * ” iT, 152:) ' 4

I-b ; : 3

“The inoue. however, comes from the fact that

there. is no fair market price for the temporary use

_ of lawnilries for

a term of months.’ *.€, 1 13

‘ ° rh sy . “y

™

redede

\

a A * Led

or es hai sin come to deal: with laundries,

there is no evidt

ce Of, anyane having rented a laun-.

dry for three and. ane- halt ve ars, or three years. and

seven ‘months, :

-- ane rch is no evie ence of any laundry

having been sold ou ns (T, 153.)

“I, ic

“TRIs case" is being conducted in ‘the nature of ©

an inquest to detertuine just why position is,

and in-making that inquest,;we have to gather and

consider any fact or cireumstances that. may he con-

. sidered and keep within} the line of just. compe nsas

‘ta? = * ?

our

cz 154.) , 7

. iP te ;

nee i ‘

i The ‘property taken was the use of the

laundry machinery,

the. building, (thé grounds,

everything ‘connec ‘ted therewith, except.

the

ee deli¢ery service that: was net taken.’

constittition «and under

and PS

trucks

Under the = *

che law, you can not make

any allowance whatever for property pant is. not.

taken” (, mad

‘ = * i f ‘ a °

“In seareh of a’ vardstick, T have vermitted: evis

att, here of the value of: the prope arty itself, “Not

*

\

°

Yo

e

fice 8" Ce degen 2 836 pie oe, at “a oak i ame

that. it was necessary. for. the euatailie of the Lisi 3;

Ok. secu ft hut it was a vardstick’ that* we might

s eons siden - P trying. to find what avas just: As Pohave .

a 8a, * ther Te is no’ evidenci “eof diny ‘sales, there is. nd

eat evdenc © of: any leases, or ankthing of that kind in

Cae onnection with laundries. re 135 154.) ;

. -\ . Py . of.

pik 66 e Ee . The facts that the: iRimbal ‘Laundi v Com: :

ypany undertook to place some: element of, value’ on,

‘thee “property, sinée. it was .a -going conecrn, is. noe / ;

ce : permissible, aan ik not comipetéyr It is nét the thingy»,

that’ we- o herb oA that we are holding “a

the inquest, lage ‘ he Spaccng ne ra Asi ‘tliat ‘this is

not a ‘diinaze, suit: ee hy = 158)

id

es et ‘oe

>

Pre OS ,/1b6y In this case T properly -permitted the i

\ . ownel rs_ of the } prope rty.. to give their opinion of the.

++, 2walua of the property: It develop d in the seross-ex- =

a ' -amination of fhese pwners, when fley -were fixing the’ t

figures that they-used, that théy, were considering, ey

elements’ they had in: mind that: were ot _ propet to Ay

ct be: veonsitlered. ae “pee ; .

Be prey “Tic first witness, in tht respect is Mr... Asda: 7

_Jacabbitrger. On his eross- examinatior, after ‘fix- ” Ere

ug what he colisidered a fair allowance, he was asked — ae

i a ow iat the élemets were that he had in tind .amd *

SB he ‘reflirred to the fact that, there wa's additional ae

PeYysy he would be put to as a gesult of\thetaking- > a.

J Of thet usiness. In- this. expense there. were many

differ] gienis, Some “of .them . eure storage of mer-. } |)

chatidis@@hat was riot: takeneStorage of trucks that...

ee. they had: hee using on their: {leliveries, storage. SERA

“\Vecustomers’ clothing, and theseftems he, had consid; <-> + uf

Bred ‘all making ap his firuré.: He also’ testified that ° he

as a’ result of thet taking” he hadtaken into consider->

: ition: hat: tye had heen’ put, to » the expe nse of apprais-* - ;

J‘

_» Tan.into, the neighligchoad of elt ht 3 or sine “thote a:

> dollarsagy > of these items: are allowahfe jn-this ~~

action be@ttse. they are pessopal to the owner, The-

a

property taken has nothing to do with this, and so

T insteact von that ‘these elements Mr. A. TL. Jacob-

_ herger has. referred to Moule #ot be considéred by

.you In appraising his opinion. of the “value the

* propertyand you,should not, consider any of ese |

matters he has soemirhz shy: included in making. S Roa

’ As

sum total. ei : Bo east cay *

’

Ty addition to Min. re Lo Jaeobberger, IT find

“that Mr. Harry Jacobberger, im lis cross-examina-.-

. tion, referred fo the elements @ had taken into con- .

sideration. He, testified that he had faken Ingo” con-

* sideration the “fact that the plant was a going eon-

cern. That is not 7an‘element- -of just compensation,

¢ and you are instance ‘ted to’ disreg gard it’

My: Fred Jac obberger, wheh he. tentified: was _

asked . what elements, h@ took into ednsider ation and

amofig other thistgs. he thought ‘they -were ¢ntitled

2

. to anvamount he fixed, stating that he would’ certainly

ask. at of anvane (1,: 157) who y ranted. to rent ‘the -

place. from him. He also testified to a ‘figuré for

-'taixes, instrancé and a few minor expenses, such

as gtorage uf. these ‘trucks. ‘These are ele ents you

cannot.take into considefation. “You: may consider

‘taxes and insurance in a’ collateral way, inetrying | to-

get. at oy rental value. |. tes

“Ww ith these. consideration’ I) ‘mind, hoWw: are We

- “going to: fine the 4 fair rental valuk fot the use of this -

property? “There does not seemrto be’. anyeie quati-

fied to hg Tp, us reach that figire. on Se

a) : ‘ae it ats ; % i .

Pa s--4 ne A ° Ti fe 3 op % -

% » 2 08

pit © © In that samicalaidon all of the haaaekts

_figurifig rr Phat it would. cost to put the property back *

_as it was, “as near as you can, re just, oo

. J ne oe

: Pr tat.

try a eats ; o ° : oe

ty

s

a °

_

© e me . a =

ie — * eS -* $2. > Ae TRS 5 . e

: & *, - f a 2 ia

. sak % . ‘ ~ BS

*s g2 s 2 \ rm aa e> e

® : s : \ ay: mit : are i : rn = ‘ Se

sation” for the “use. of .the property, withont . any r

sentimental , values, . without any good wills or® the

_ ‘fact™that it was A going concern, or. the fact. “that thev =

- wefe put to a lot of consequential damages. That -

cr heat they refer to. Censequential! damages are...

a hard - luck, that, they happened ‘to be se-

lected~the: same agit “Would-be the:hatd luck of you~

PO oar Son. if » were ‘ealled into the army-.”’ Cl, ey

; = .

Sa a ee eC aS

‘ . : 4 : ; ‘ % en)

TT ee eye ge you. én’ not find ‘an éxpert, who: is

An a position to qualify: and tell you that. it ‘is worth 7 -

‘so much maney, tien you ‘have to figure it out’ fer - ”

yourself ‘by? considgAing what it cost: when it .was:

- built, how it has been:-used, -ywhat itsFeapacity is—

*. a of jlwese. things that, will occur to you when: you |

~ are trying to arrive, at a value, ~Having-once. arrived

at_the. value,.¢out then, can’ begin figuring and use?

as a- -yardstick an interest rate. That is a very’ c6n-9. >,

5 Asap yardstick for courts fo use and we use ‘it i

whengyer we. can. because: it is in general use; ‘Fre-

quently it js med in Segre! cases. It is fair for it”

“+ tovbe used here. ae Me,

Ve ree dear = oe ;

Sct aioe ee i. Nous acstion is the value of the prop- =

erty at the time it. was taken n, not now.. It is the.

value -of’ the use of the property and when we get »

your figures ‘the court will then allow such ipterest

-*as the law permits. waeuiend ages «7 161.) eon

o 2.

Se. “Whe Kimball Laundry C9. was granted. exceptions _

od, 166), to eac h ae all of the: forezoing instructions,

‘on

.

~ x e ; .-

s .. Py a. ; ° .

, e “3 ' .

ad ae s

2-5 . . - om °

.

er The’ pare erred in overruting the following Excep =

tions OF Petitioner to the Court’s Instructions:

s. ¢6

>». . . ~ ad ’

‘ bs é . : , & .

» : ” : af ' Ps

° :

- a . ; a

e - . . p ie

: “s : < -

“Nese

PT.

ea Tes — =

i, 165) “Mr, Hotz: The * ‘respondent, Kimball

Laundry Company: excepts to that portion. of? th

Court’S instructions, which, referred™to- the: words. ,

going concern’ taken. from the testimony ‘of Mr;

SA. TE: Jacobber ger and Mr. «tarry ‘Jacobbergér, ‘for +:

the’ reason that in their. t testimony they specifically +

excluded, under the’ rulings’ of the’ Court, all ref-

erente to trade routes, “busitioss- and good’ will, and

5 Bo stated in, their testimony, 3

6 31 k.

“69. "Phat. the. instructions : are not Pein enough

in reference to ‘the matter of-the. element of. damage —

based upon the value ofthe property, especially the

ldundty machinery and equipment as it éx xisted in

= November of - 1942, and. at the present time. While

the instructi tion Was given, it seems’ to counsel for’,

Kimball Laundry Company. that it-~was. detracted °

-. frown and modi ted? in the subseqtent instruction that -

seemed to leave to the’ fury no other alternative but

_ the repair items té place the property in ' the condi-

tion that it. was: in. A942. ° LE Ade

. e3. That. the refaieies by. *the Court, to conse-

‘quential damages not being: permitted is “contrary to

- the law and. the decisions in- the Unite¢ States Cir-\:

‘qit Court of Appeals for this, circuit and that con--

Sequential damages which inhere -in- and are directly.

connected with property and are destroyed, are a

part there of dnd beteme. an element of damage for |

_the consideration. of the jury... - eo

. = “4, That .the word ‘rental? ‘as used we the

Court .in the:instructions and also as referred to in

the general verdict (I, 166) of. the jay submitted by.

.

ae

the Court, is nota preper term either. under the |

_, Statute or the’ decisions, and while. if may be -used.

as fin illustration, it is confrary, to. law, as it all is

matter of damage for “use, whether temporary or

* Dermianent. ‘ | the a

om

ml

5

bee 65.” The Kimball awidte Company: furtlier’ ex-

ba CORES: to the failure of the — ‘to. give all of the!

°* . dnstructions requested hy the <imball Laundty Com-.

<a any, being numbers : i ae

The Court sp will get specifi exceptions. an -

- those. ett _

etic | > Hotz: We inet to, b the Jnejroctions given:

by the court from instructions suggested by the gdy-

~ ” ernment; numbers*ly 2, 3/.4, 6 and 8, and especially.

in connection. with Tnstraction 6, because of ‘the ele-

ore of consequential damages therein: referred to.

The general exception .is- made ttfat- the court’ has...

"<- failed and refused at this time ard throughout, the : -

+ ial. to sreedgnize as ah element ‘of damage the de-

_ stknetion of the trade routes and the customers lists +

-beckuse of fheir contractual relationship to the Kim-.

“pall Saundry Company and as‘an-element of damage

inhered in and, as a part of the: property.

Oe, “The Kimball’ Laundry. Lomyriny also: objects 2

-» to the request’ for the findings of. different. el leménts ee

to. make ‘up the- fotal: damage, it being ‘the law -that-

the damage should be ‘fixe in one luinp.sum dnd that

the only purpose in arriving at the separate elenients

of damage is to aid. in arriving af the one sum of

= damages.’’ . . ny, LOE een cecil Ree D

‘ ‘ 4 * toy e 2 cent, cage :

: “oD ie Court: - The’ exceptions wilt be noted ena he

‘overruled aud the instructions -in that’ regard will _ .

‘stand as they are. *.* *.” ay

(I, 167 ) “Gentlemen; my attetition has been called

particularly to the. fact that there was testimony.of- . ——-_

fered by Mr. A. LL, Jaegbberger and Mr. Harry Ja- ae

- ,eobherger with reference to..an *item— of $70,000.00

“which they said would cover fhe use of the property

while they were pitting it back in shape. T withdrew

a P .. . . ‘ & , ; — baal ,

that” question from vowr conside ration by veteinine

_-+ Jurisdiction and any question that may arise hereafter

as to any damage in that. re spect, the court will

theh be. in a position, to. take care ‘of. You cannot:

“anticipate. now that there @#l-he jafiy such occasion

arise. . Have’ I made myself clear? sini alg Ra age, S

ees eer se

? ra ,

. The court erred in failing to give the *folloiving in-

structions reque ste deby the pe titianer: ;

° e . : 4 ; ° a.

. . e . 2 e . " °

.

ee a

*_:e (1174) N VL (Not Given)

Hage ou are instruct onl in a condemnation proveed-

ings when you arrive in yoyr deliberation at the val-

ue of the property as a- unit, tocansider its special:

, use to” the Kimball Lautidry ‘Company as a laundry

w -and dry cleaning establishment: and: the ‘eriterion ¢.

‘test of what the value was on November 29.1942.

Ne is not what the property is worth ta the cecondemnor

but its value ‘to the condemnee, imball’ Laundry

Company. The question is what has’ the owner lost,

not Ww what has the t taker gained.”

*.

>

; o——— Se are

/ 7. OX. (Not Given).

(I, 175) “You are MStructed that’ the Govern-

iment. took frpm the Kimball Laundry Company, the

temporary’ use of land and tlie’ personal, property

‘ thereon or used in connection theerwith. You,are

instructed that the term included the Kimball Laun- rn

dry Company's property on the ‘northwest corner

15th and—Jenes_ Streets, and that: it covered: the

land, the ,five- story® building, all the mgchinery and

equipment contained tyerein, and the (1, 176) power

plant and power équipment, and all Fersonal prop-

erty used thereon or connected therewith exce epting.

- “ ~s

. °

.

a

\

* that said property at the time of the faking \was ran’

7]

.

. . = ,

» 7 P ° P - Ale

» . te

= : 42 a vee % ees

= ee ee

‘the Kimball Laundry « OMPANY | ~ delivery! trucks’

.. and operated by the Kimball Lanidry Company: as

a fully « equipped modern and efficient Tantidry. and

dry cleaning establishment, located in the busine ss

section of the City of Omaha, and that said property

was.of such capacity as %.service the. velinne of.

— pisiness: necessary for the Gove®iments Reeds, and”

that ‘all these elements bf. valre should he ‘eombined

by yo in arriting. at the ‘value. of said plant’ as a -

unif/on Novembey 22, 1942. And iQ arriving at vour

cpoflusions of value véu shall take: into eonsidér: a-

-' tion the trade routes : established ‘by the Kimball

Laundry Compas as distinguished from the loss..of”

‘business or eood will. Tf vou find that onid —o

routes, -both residential | and commercial and others,

yrad a definite intrinsie value, re: idily determinable:

‘that the Kimball Baundry Company was. under* obli-

gation to service said trade reute customers and. was

doing. so at-the time of the taking: and that by the

taking these routes were destroyed -aid -heeame val-

uéless - to. the Kimball Laundry Company—then* you

‘shall:include that trade route itém, in addition to a.

other items of yalue, in making up your award | for

damages and inelude the sime- dine the total. anos —

ws, ee IM ae

eee ;

. wh 176) No. XT, (Not Given) .*

“You are further inatradted that 7 in arriving at :

just compensation to be

you may take into

customers’ routes, th

ume .of business; and fit you find that such customers’

‘routes and customer had: a value which inhered: in

the Kimball Laundry Compiny’s property as a ‘part

thereof and that the sime was damaged or destroyed.

id to. the Kimball Laundry,

sideration the value of the

“directly by the taking, then yew shall find for the

Kimball Laundry Company to ‘the extent of the valu

/‘~, ila a a |

ns oa? ‘ ¢ vee

Qn

mmber of customers , the vol-

io

-_ . oe ig

of the rants: 80 dénivoyed in thé taking. even thourk-

you find the Gover:hient hdd’ noe ocension to, take aie

aids ‘hot take or operate. said Jaundry's customers’.

route be” pans - “d Me Soc 2 on

pees! ° TH. —

EERIE eel (, 17 7) No. NTL. (Not Givep) : a

~ “¥on are. instructed tiy’ fmd the total yalue, rath@r

.than the separate value, df the. parts of the. Kimhall

Laundry Company tliat Inhered in. the. property at),

the time.of the takitix. In that regard there is hefore |

_ you.separafe evidence of [the ‘alue- Of the real estate,

' the machinery, ‘the eq pment, the power plant, and ° -

- other. elements, Seach Acparately valued: These are

before vou separate’ only. to show the value’ of. the |

totak or the value oXthe whole Jaundry as: it extsted

on‘ November 22, 1942\when taken by the government;

and. you may not value each item Se ‘parately and add

them to make up the whole, but. instead you must, val.

. ue the whole plant as a going unit, and determine its -

value in‘dollars.and cents: for the purpose of arriv |

ing at just compensation,” vino ‘aes See eee :

a : ‘ ay

oo = a a : ea

aie ee “Tie

| (L, 177) No. XII. (Not Given)

ssshel tess ha

“You are instructed that it is not necessary,

for you to. gauge the damages .for just compensation

to be paid by the government in ternag of ‘a -pereen-.

tage of. the land,: a percentage of the building,, and

a percentage of the equipment, as the. measure of vour -

verdict, bat. you. may gauge the full measure of | your.

award based - “upon what vou. consider fair and just

conipensation for the taking of .the whole, In -de-.

terthining just compensation tobe awarded forthis——

—pFoperty, ‘for the period in controversy, you may con-

sider the after-value of. the porperty and stbtraet it.‘ rq

from the before? value; fhat is, the | ‘alue we stance!

: r @.. °4 3 * p

a

es ee : Se es

, are instructed’ to find the fair, reasqnables dket

'_. value of the Kimball Li aundry Company at

of. the taking :on November 22, 1942, with all the

*.

Hee = (I, {77

on Nove eine 29, 7942, and Substract the yRue. ‘of the

“property at, this: time.*’ ae : :

a

ce °

“You are instrue ‘ted that the petition filed hy

a Government in“this case condemued a temporary

use of said premises, and that the property sought *

to be condemned .was only. the physical, assets," ext

Jfowever, ee

clusive of trade - routes and business:

vou find front the weadenea that the effect of ‘the tak.

ing, eves. though the petition statés ‘temporary use,’

* actually resulted_in. appropriating the Kimball Tann-

- dry Company as ‘a’ going’ business with the result in

™* effect that said property..was. completely (T. 78):

taken from thie Kimball Laundry Company, then you

elements that go te make up the vi ue. of a large

going laundry and- dry cleaning:

In such event’ you are instructed.

fer said amount.

that the’ regl and personal prperty would remain _

-as.an asset of the Government forthe purpose - of

resale to the Kimball Laundry Company or to, some’

other purchaser or .to rentain the property of the.

federal Govérnment. if ‘it. so- ‘desires, ‘in which eon=

' tingéncies you need ‘not. be concerned in this action. 5 ae

@.

eect ae

. <a -

e 2.

The court. erred in giving, over petitioner’s objec:

Hee govern nt

™~

> 7 : a

: = ; Iva . q ; . -

ee (i, 163) “Here are some ins iiadliqns ‘that haye

heen requested by the Kove rn nt and the; ‘y ate like:

FO. XIV: (Not Given) . re ree

qme

business and render

> judgment in favor of the: Kimball Latndry Company:

_@

-

tions, the folianwing: instruction t hy ves ae

‘wise entitled to cons me ution Jie “line they are siven

fn =e you by the court Ane COTE? HI® state tiie law ;

- ® ve e ‘

poh IVb. ‘

- . (I, 164) OTe: jury. are jistructed that the just,

‘

+ gg COMpensation to be ‘paid in. this case is the v: ature’ of

the praperty taken, im this case, the risht to use the

. physical property, » Only ii) the sense that the owher

meters . IS fo receive this value isthe owner to be put ip ds

o 2) Meda eas _ good a pesition. financially or pecuniarily-as if his

property fas not been faken. This value. is not .the

‘Value to the owner for his particular purposes or to

4 SS the Gondemnor for some special use, but a so-called

— “rharket valne.”* Since ‘market value’ does not _ flue-

Sa tuate with the- néeds- of.condémnor or condemnee

‘ * \ but with general demand: for the. property, evidence

of loss of profits, damage to good will, the expense of ’

relocation and other’ such consequential losses are

not:to be considered in-de termining just compensa

= : . -tion;in this proceeding. . Interference with the busi:

ness, frustration of dhe. business enterprise, incon-—

verttence to the owner, the unwillingness of the owner

to part with -his property temporarily, or the need |

-—-——6f the government (I, 165) for the property are not.

to*be. considered and aré not*to be the basis for the

. allowance of just compensation.’ You will, therefore,

disregard. all evidence of such items,

. Bi

“The Jury. are ‘instructed that no consideration

shall be. given to or allowance of. just compensation”

made for any litigation, . auditing and appraisal ex.

. pense incurred by the owner and one of such

Coes " expense shaH be disregarded. wie sa Dak .

o

‘

Vv ‘ov 5" . »

° . .

™

Bete 7 striking pléadings ‘of petitioner.

- a» the court ‘eta at the outset of the Trial on Mave h

4, 1946 (II, sins in. i aie ail of pounoner | ‘8 answer

eo.

. 4 t °

é @* * ‘ pe °

. Ais — ~2B.

; © es , : . sas oe : ‘ “” * ss

=A : bie y nag. ey z 46 * : -

(filed. Aughst, 23, 143; 21). and | al of petitione rs pe-

‘tifion in error “Ql ede trom thé board of appraise s

~ (filed. Dece amber 1s, 1943; Ty 44), and in’ striking dusting

the trial on Mareh | 208 1045 (IH, 863), anotlier ‘petition ¢

on-appeal (filed March 18, 146; 1 91). So rulings were —

made en the petitioner’s application foy’ pretrial hearing °

‘filed on April 3, 1944: (I, 55), ine luding request for pre--

_ trial decision on propositions of ku (1, 126). The court

at Yhe openjng of the ‘trial: rad presented to. it the mo-

tion of the Kimball Laundry Co. that the court ‘‘fokow

the State of Nebrask:? practice, and precedtire as nearly.

‘as may be ji in this condemnation case (40 U. S° Cc. 258a). "

‘(This staiute in 40 U. §. Cc is found by gppendix herein, =

pp. 4-5.) “Exceptions ' were allowed L183) Errorgoe-'

. curred’ in these -rulings because” petitioner -av as placed. in

the trial without. the issues: being formed in writing, as

prov ided in both «the federal and state. courts in eon- i

demn: itior pr oceedings (State Court, statutes, appendix p..

15). The prejudicial ‘result ofthis ¢ group of errors during” c |

~ the progress of thie ‘trial. will appear in Ye ‘onjunetion with 2)

other resulting errors set forth (IT, 183- 7) Tereinafter: -—

.

\

& q “s VI. hg Ns \

.

- aS ae — “ a ‘ K

; a © ”

'—~ Error in court's assumption that the Betitignes r Sphime vd.

damages for good | w il How question areaé. *. * af

> . A

’ “The court erred. throughout the trial in? Hissuming/

the

without any suppordng evidence that the peters W

‘claiming damages to* its Dusinegs and. ood. will :

tinguished from trade routes as elements of vail ‘The

contrary appeared of record from the sti atenygiet of. the:

witriexses, Page reference’ will he mi ade to. AY siimony.

4 :

af ? — er e a

e

S

fidis- *

ma

hos

*The court's first ruling is. Ne 1S7. (Whenever the fame of

4

.

counsel ‘Murphy’ * appears, he was counsel for the ‘gov- > °

-

ernnicnt, See eee = as ae

‘3

= 4 . ; >

Ja . a 187) 4M. ; = Pétitioner objects to

ary statement &y eounsel as to the vilue of the laun- ~~

dry truck routes or the value, or supposed value-nt * =

the business or ‘good will as incompetent-and, i imma-,

terial and not within the issies in‘nis case, and not

-within anything bape) °by~-the government “in this

action.....--/ .

The Court: I think that ‘is true, Let ns keep

‘tym the question until we can méet it Squarely

"ev idence you offer; Let’s confine: vour opening

nent to matters. that will not. be’ in “dispute until

yoa get to them. ”

a ee

‘ «

met. ary io oH ye |

A : Error int rejecting =< financial state-

. f

f

4 mete,” °°... FES , re ra tae re |

“ - . ed . c . a

¢ Pte ae zl

The. court erred in ruling out aJk the audits made by

the petitioner’s | first witness, C. L. Hillmer, whose quali-

fications were’ admitted and who had made: all the audits ©

. for the. company for 26“years. .The books of original”

entry were in the courtroom (IT, .187- 8). These audits

ruled out by the court-were vomplete. Gross i income from

laundry operations from 1924 to ‘date of condemnation

was shown to, be’ $6,728, Ag. 64 (HI, 1909 3Fx.. 1). Among

* the * disposition of funds were shown officers’ salaries,

$393,242. 99 (IT, 191); dividends paid $147,900 (ITI, 191).

and other items customarily needed to determine the

_ value of a, plant, These: were ruled. out as follews;: |

2

~" <

oO

et Alay 48: ee 3

roe or a eee oe ese

oes “The. Courts” That’ objéetion: will he good.- Vin

will have-to soparate the vears so that we can deter-

TiLees “which is remote and whieh is note. Mr. Hotz: -

Tn the exhibits that we -have that. are following we

-do that by the growth of the Any siness and the’ pro.’

ductivity, The. ‘Court: , Let us Ber. the. foundation...

We ‘will-dod the figuring afterwards, Objection wil

7

or. . sustained. oe “Ci, 189. wpaast ae elie = =

e 1

. "ay . (Bx. § 2) aes eS ae =a

s Pr

Exhibit 2 2 of the: Witness. Hillmer was refused (Ik, 198).

‘It showed all costs an the books ta the compa ny on- De-

_cember 31, 142, exclusive of good will; trade ‘name, and.

advertising, -The itemized totad Was, $6; 3,360.7 1. The .ad-

Vertising : “4 ring the period 1924 ta 1942 was “$148,910.01

(TI, 2003 kx, 2), and contributions to: ghar oe and busi-

. |: P

“Hess ore ranizations, $5, 119.50 (II, “200; Ex. | . both were

chara to expense and not capitalized as 00d will. >

2. (I, 198) “The. Court +: These. statements inelndo-

‘so many other. items as to confuse the issue. You

‘have thaShooks hee. and_ if» he has these statements’

separatelyswe will be glad to: have them and examine

‘them. It. will: probably.save time-by doitg that. Other- .

- Wise, you have book values and date and amount that

was paid gnd when -vouw get the evidence, we will de-

termine “whether sr—not it is of: evidential value, .

‘or whether it too remote, or whether it - ‘is within

the Saas season, ree | 3 é +

This ruling. is contrary to the. face of the. exhi

“and the court erred accordipgly.

= pee (Ex. 3) poo

‘Exhibit 3 contained the same “items as Exhibit t

except was the’ 5- year period from. 1938. to Decémber 31,

4 tS

Pee ke ky a

. 1942, For that. period Exhibit 3 showed. officers’ s splaries,

‘ ey 7")

$112 O76. ; repairs ‘to buildings $1, ING repairs ‘to,

equipment, R20: 1.143 purchases OPequipme ‘nt, R30,940,18 5

divide nits paid, $97,900; and? othe? items shown: (LT, - 207;

“Ex. 3). This exhibit wasgr ‘aled. ah with Exhibit 2 (II, 198)

for the sanie retison : It yas, riot ‘remote, i .

woe \ * Si

= 6: : |

2 2 . : ‘ (Ex) Ma im 2

Exhibit 4 was refused (I, 203 -4), Tt was a compata- =: ;

November “1, 1942. < sors peer ras ;

“The Court: Due to the faet that tite: exhibit

contains items that T think it should not properly. eon-

tain in its present form, ] must exclude it; but if-

tive statement and analy: sis of net: profit, ‘itemized. vear —

-by vear from. Phe beginnings of the butiness in’.1924 to

@ counsel will segregate in a separate statement ‘the ~

item showing the nét earnings of this laundry. from

‘1924 to 1942, until November 1942 (TT, 203), and; -the

other item of. depreciation taken, I will receive it.

., L-ean not receive it with a lot of other items T think’

Should nat he. i in here,’

Mr.. Hotz: There - were no sthay items except.

ing’ incident to the. laundry business. They are com-

:

‘paratively in. the*® second column—for: ex xample, you

take the year 924, fhe net profit from laundry opera-

_ tions before deducting depreciation. and income tax;

giving the date’ ‘and cer tain figures; the net profit

from all sources before dethicting depreciation. and

‘income tax, is’ ‘the. Same figure, and it goes on down.

There are comparatively. siviall items ‘and interest and

‘ things of ‘that sort that came from their. surplus ae-

count. « It- does. not amount, over a long period of

>

1!" years even, to a great deal, I One. shows their

» - total Net profit from laundry Sperations, shows the

_ total, of that up to November 21, 1942. Then it shows

the income tax p paid. Naturally that might be. of in-

Le ‘Exhibit o. (Tl, 206} shows: for the 0-year period to”

: a

“Novembe 2H, 1942, a total net profit of ‘$498,512.35 be-.

Nee . 2 by ’ .

. " f ‘ 5 hp .

7 e °

‘ bs - ‘ .*

terest to.know What that“is. | If might have probative

~ force to see what that ix. Then depreciation taken

on Income, tax teturns—that. ne ans on ‘the Whole: ,

plant—and_ net’ profits after. deducting depreciation

and incoine -tax, but that, second column hasn't any

“great significahes, ‘and if they’ had their .surplus. i

the. bank and got & little interest on\it, that wis show .

properly: as an mattér of bookkeeping and “ace ‘ounting.

| oP rk The Court: The Court has-ruled,”’ ( Refused.)

‘°

o:@

° $ °

.

_ (Ex, 5) j ia

fore deducting depree lation, income taxes, and officers’

"salaries, .It “then shows officers’ salaries, income taxes,

- de ‘prec iation taken, for imeome tax ‘purposes, thie hip ad-

ditions td surplus. from laundry operations, « ' $121,-

458.14. dy 206),° and the surplus aeeéunt increase from .

+ $173,538. 26 in 1933 to #1953: 6.61 at the time of taking

in eee The court ruled out ‘the: exhibit and stated (II,

Bac) |

ive “The. Court :, ‘That will be sustained, ° Pievare

'/ /a’ statement. -T wil nat perntit anything to go. to

the jury exeépt. what I think. is competent to be re-

_ ceived, =n 4s Seraate? xt oe ;

he court ‘did not. state, what, was competent to be re-

/ ceived, The state ements contained in this exhibit and the

PCO ipanying Hillmer audits were exactly in accordance

_with proper bookkeeping methods to show the status of a

misiness concern. about whie h a - buyer, would wish to”

learn. The. refusal was error.

_ *

e

t

\J

eo VM

a 7 = a

Ey ae ae ee oe gale

Exhibit § Was a comparative. balanc e. sheet showij rg

_ othe zrowth of the company by years to the date of taking... +

The amount of invested capital, the officers’ “salaries :

drawn each : year,*the increase or decrease in the inyest-

ments: in fixed’ assets, cq@st of ‘real estate, building, laun-

dry mac hinery, power mac ‘Iypery, dry Cleaping equipment,

“old storage equipment, feather imac hinery, office equip- .

te mient, ete., each| set forth (IT,: 214).: Also the comparative -

balance: sheet separated into *shorter term, -as -suggested °

by the court, showi ing the pereentage of cost to’ repairs té

the building year hy vear (IT, 217) and the pere entage

of. repairs to tke cost of machitiery. and equipment year

‘by yedr (Tl, 218). . The cost of fequipiment as of 1942 at

the time of taking wae $405,294.81, and $205,035.12 edst

of the buildin vit time of. taking ais 217). This eshibit’.

** was ruled out; * court stating (I, 212): oe

“Mr. Hotz:.-1 offered the w hole exhibit ‘and fot

the one page, because the exhibit is a composite ex-

hibit: It isa comparative balance. sheet, and unless ‘

_ it: is offered with’ the balance of > the _oxtiibit + it is

- almost unintelligible, I. offer ‘the. exhibit in its en- |,

tirety, Exhibit 6. 2°. 2. 4. este pear

The ‘Court: It i is: the rating of the ‘Court that

all of the exhibit is incompetent and not material to - i

‘the issue, the second to the-tast page, w hich 1 may be ,

received, if. counsel so elects. il

_. The court. er Fed in so ruling; be CAUSE it mas: evidence

to support the fair, ‘reasonable market value / of the Kim- |

ball: Laundry Co. a as it ‘stood on November. 21, 1942, -ex-- °

clusive of trade name, good will, cand. future busines ‘sy aml *

similar items which were not in -controversy and were

not included i in the exhibits. “a Ca fae 5 ware

& ; ee: . 5 (Ex?7) 3 J 7 ee ‘ “

-* | 1. Exhibit 7 sKows roy income .of the Kimball Laun-

ary deo: year hy year, itemized” from WR to Novembe T

ss 24, 1942. Itsavas refused’ by the courte The pucpore “ot!

* thee vhibit. Was’ fully explained to the court (II, 21-221)!

, This eghibit ‘did’. not’ show net profits, Tt was a gross |

: doliera aIehceends ‘volute of. busistess, upon which the pe-

titione i basect its ‘estimate of $400,000 as its aeiehl KyOSS

“Dbusiiiess at the. time of. taking—an- increase from: a low. ,

_ of $374,913.90 in 1935, ‘When considered swith otter Hikd-

ther exhibits, or separate hy, “the value of: the. property

° | taken,’ bee ase it was productive, Wag material. The court

«

.

. exred mn roling out the exhibits.

‘ R ; a : . .

Tints ere ae ee pet) Bae

PARA ila . Offer - fo) Bore 2% pe nts of alt foregoing e@ xhibits from

A a books in court was erroneously demieday

3>.°

Ay tee At I, (991.3, an offer. Was made to prove the con-

tents of: the exhibits from the jooks. of record and. of

~ original’ entry in the courtroom, “avith which the witness

Wilmer. was familiar. The exclusion . from evidence of

all these exhibits: is assigned as _prejudiciat error, be--

ease » 1c petitioner. was left with no figigres upon which:

to base the financial condifion of the petitioner, or its.

gross income, its earnings, the cost- of its property. as

earr ried on its. books in “1942, or any other simil data.

Expe aiditures for repairs and upkeep of the machinéry

and equipment wer -gtled out.: Obviously the court tat

aot seem’ to understayd that .the exhibits. actually. con-

tained ald the éridenof éssential to show va Ine, not ware-

house space: ir space, or similar data not in 1 the: case,

P ta eer asad ; ; 2 #

ad

?

. 4

* © could be received énly under: the, following conditions (Ll; -.

« . "

°@ = ‘. oe y ad

. P - 2

.¢ . : *,

* © . e . . > ?

. e os e

as 3) Oe & 2 ae

— . : \

e

z a , . ®

° J & 6 ‘ Pad

> F ad : . eho : we:

- ‘ a w. 3,

o . a

a

- Ee eee cna, eon rer —— { sf we = iz oa

- but for a géing busipess dealing sontt in services, not

merchandise, upon which launeleSinert would. basé valne.

ne C ee ‘ere Se ene E

Re neh ee ee WE eo ON

: is Os rte ; *

3 Witnéss cDougal’s audits on trade routes.

’

°

PRs Ae

:. The eourt erred in. ruling that. petitioner's Exhtbite< :

*, 10, compiled by witness: McDougal (11, 234), whieh showed aed

the dollars ‘and cents income from 1936 to- Novgmber 21,

1942, broker down into various classifications of laundry |

-*sand .dry cleaning services to shéw value of’ the plant,

.

ce Te) ¢ * |

(11, °230) “Mr, Murphy: If the Court Please,

‘petitioner objects to the offer of Exhibit 10 for the

-veason said exhibit is incompetent and . immaterial

: and covering,.as_ it does, solely business earnings, is

bee jot a_proper element of proof of just compensation °

In this ey¢mdemnation action. L might state -to the

Court that I have in My hands a copy of an opinion

of the. United. States: Supreme Court just handed

down on February 25, 194§, that 1 would like. to-

i have rs |

«(Counsel was: referring to U.S. v. Petty Motor Co.

827 U.S. 372,66 S. Ct. -596.). . wo ;

‘*The Court: I have it right here: ‘I have not had

. Se fac 7 ae aa.’ ® °. : i

time ‘to study it’ yeté I got it just this morning: You

have this in dollars and cents. I am inclined to think

it is admissible if it were in poundage. or volume so °

+ as. to establish ‘the amount of business they were

doing.’’ Rank } oe.

The court remarked@II, 231): 2 $

oJ aa j !

ed

5, |. Se et Gcument, if: it showed the nonndnge,

ag If -it-could be supplemented. with a statement. of

the poundage, wouldshow to some extent the capatity

~of the building and af the plant, what it was eapable

of doing, vind this would be a consideration that ac

prospective Jessee and the owfiers. would necessarily

have: inemind. Jf they were «dealing ‘af: afm *s length.

Under the U ‘ah ease, as under the General Motors |

ease (323 U. S2'373, 65 s. Ct, 357), thar which is per-

‘sonal to thé owners can not be corisidered. [ can not

allow it to-imterfere with the valuation or determina:

9 tion by the Jury of the value, which is ‘the basis .

~ our inquitys “Any kind of evidence,. even though j

“is remote, I have concliidgal that the Fourt should

“permit because of the difficulty in- proving up in

this ‘age, and since this case has to‘stand by itself—~

wt at te ie ontly lau idry’ Wusiness that 1 know of—it

‘is surely the only one ‘in Omaha, anf there are no

records-or deets sions on laundries. 'CorP& ently, we

have thé prohion: of how to. prove up iN gbraska in

pace nant of laundries. ***

‘These two eases (discussed under poirts Xf Taw

hereinafter) do not rovern the ‘mie: isure of damage: in

the ¢& is¢git bar, because in the Petty Motor Co. case a

leasehold was. condemned which the. condeninee had for

storage space, and the expense .of moving and-telocation .

were denied begause the condemnee’s lease was at an end.

Jn the General Motor Co. ease the condemnee also had a’

long term lease which the vove rinent wanted but only

a part , and the court ruled the damages Ww ere ‘recover able’

for the expense of mov ing and r Toeation-: ‘and destruction

of eqnipment, obviousl¥ because the removal «from the.

warehouse of the Gergral Motor Co. would be “only tem:

'- porary and the company would then move back. It was

a simple matter of square foot. re nal plus resulting losses,

enue ‘ated. -- _. | es “a pS

‘ .

“ ,

.

RRMA BRN

seis Cig 32

ais

cases

ae

-

Pos

aetahs

l

oo _s : ut oO.

Wapusteg “ ed eas ’ }

s ae . a P 1° Sg .

. Tn.the case at bar the condemnee owned the property ,

outright.- It had- no’ temporary Use, The~ court’ erred, :

therefore, in ruling out all exhibits and evidence which

would show. the fair, reasonable market value of the Kim.

ball, Laundry Co. at. the date of. taking. This yaluation

was absolutely necessary: for petitionér’s starting point

during the trial of the case. The value of what was tirned

_ back when the property was declared surplus and aban-

doned would likewise Ve material ‘evidénce for the jury’s

consideration as‘the measure of damage. ;

‘The court: erred in denying the exhibit and its only

understandable puypose, i,-e, dollars and cents income

from the various departments, as a‘laundry plant." >

+ At TI, 234:5 the court stated:

_ “The Court: I made the remark that-if he would

break it down into quantity so that we could under-

—

tiyeand if he would give me that assurance T would

receive it now in the record, with the understanding

that if he does not supply the supplemental eviderce

that willkstrike it’? 2, . ss ao

The Witness McDougal stated (IT, 232-3):

“Q. When’ we’ had ‘Exhibit 10 yesterday while

youswere on the Witness, stand, a statement was made

‘with reference -to poundage, ‘If you had any reeord

of poundage. Did -the’ Kimball Laundry Company —

keep any record of laundry as bundles distinguished

from pieces? ema 3

,. Av We did on certain types of laundry, but that.

wouldn’t cover vour Jaundry, due to the fact that

there is no poundage on your finished shirts.

Q. There is no poundage on many other items?

staffd the capacity of the plant it might be deserip- -

Ob ; ©

s

“A. gan many ofher, there is no perindage in the

_ laundry ‘business. : a

(). For mstance, in the.dry cleaning? . +

A. No poundage on your dry cleaning.”’

. . ‘ : ‘

Tn re ‘ference to the. poundage demandéd by the court

asa qualification for the ultimate use of the exhibit; the ~

objection avas made to the court (II, 23) ‘in speaking of.’

poindag ge,. Pee oe a

“sMr,. Hotz: That. acaca t mean | anything unless

you ¢an tell what it is in dollars and cents. se

%,

The total for the 5- year’ period of gross business yn-

mediately. preceding the taking-on November 21, 1942, -.

in that laundry on laugdry operations alone’ was $2,496,

105.55.. This figute was broken down into nine subhead-:

ings as shown at IT, 234, and duly certified by the auditor.

kf, was error for. the court not to -have admitted Ex.

hibit 10 (1f, 234), and all it was worth to show valuation

> -*

‘of the laundry when it was taken, because this statemenf,

coupled with the’ audits of the witness Hillner (Tixs. 1-7,

a clear, definite, and acceptable financial statement of. thiis

particular -] nundry eupor Which other Jaangrymen might

testify as to valuation. : “ge |

; (Bx. SS a

-~ The aati pean in ‘limiting the value of ‘the witness

MeDousal’ s Exhibit 11 (IT, 236: - 4 showing the total |

regular trade route. cnstomers, exclusive. of specialty de- -.

partment, on Noverfiber 21, 1942, to be 15,093 ; “customers

who delivered laundry and. ealled for it at the desk of

“the company, 1,500; special customers, 4,648; customers

-

‘all of? which. were ruled out’ except page 6 ot Ex. 6) .was /

DS NS NE SNE Nar 9 toe Pe, es

PinioReT ROA ARTES his woes ISB ate IR IU Syne UHR Rupes 4 Po ay 4

RII, DRE Sa ok eine Sy

ve Fale

See exhibit, shewed ©

-it up-with the poundage.’

from the jury elements of valuation hased on understand- .-

.

sf

2

requiring seasorial Ww ork consisting of ‘table linen, spreads,

‘rugs, comforts, blan kets, and lace curtains, on SO2:s0r a

total-of ‘customers of 26,07 ), plus 14,092, or a grand total

of 42,043 in which there were 10. duplications (i, 23).

(11, 236) “Mr. Murphys: * * © It is evidence: re-

Idsing solelyto skill or managemenf and good will

and number of customers andes business, rather: than

the plant or its capacity. The Court: I think it is”

. 2° es $9

some ev idence of t Sapacty: ;

-s s

“tes The Government went into, possession of

the Kimball Laundry-on November 22, 1942, and: none

of the customers of the Kimball Laundry Company.

were or have heen fhereaftér serviced by tlie KXim- |

hall ans Company.’” es ctrl

(Ex. 12) |

Exhibit 12 (iT, 241) was an. itemization of the | name

and, amounts in dollars and cents of the Kimball Ls aundry

Co. patrons under: the héading of ‘Special Aecounts for

the Years 1938 to Nov. 21, 1942, Inclusive.’’ These ihe

court received with’ Exhibits 10° and 11, with the same

+, admonition that it was only for the purpose of showing

‘*volume,”’ ‘and (II, 2£0) ‘conditionally that you couple

+]

able dollars and cents ifenis, as poundage meant nothing

to either the court or the jury. ae

_ = . (Ex. 13) «

©

. Exhibit 13 (Il, 244) was refused by the court. This“

exhiit was. made up from. 1936 to: Pia veerse 21, °1942,

The court erred in keeping

58.

and peer the expense incidental and the ‘manner in

which the respective trade. routes were built up and han - ;

dled during that period of time. ‘The offer was made to —

show that. the route men were paid $237,654.85 (1, : 244)

of gua antec salaries and salaries and commissions dur-

ing ‘the Revi ious five years as an item of expense to keep @

‘and maintain trade WN ee é

“Bh Coniaiioaion Aesownt Yoliowing: 3 is ‘for lauai- .

dry trade acquired and held by these routemen over

‘and above their fixed salaries for the years 1936 to

‘November 21, 1942, inclusive.’’

The. court Stated i in ruling out the exhibit. (iI, 244): :- ’

‘*The ruling i is based on: thy proposition that the —

route was not. taken, was not ‘condemned, and is not

involv ed in the sunit.”’ Sac

Error was, com: itted, because the routes were de-

stroyed hy the taking as a- matter of common sense de-

. duetion. Be Sd ei cesear ‘ Crease

: é ; IX. : ‘ : 7 Rote: _

Court’s error in the limitation placed on. Ex. 21,

which showed cost and value of machinery and equipment

“on November 21, 1942, and iv November, 1945, _ by experts————

eS Roodwin 1 4m for-petitioner.

The court duane in limiting the value of the petition.’

er’s* Exhibit. 21 (11, 258-60), consisting of 594 items of ,

‘machinery -and equipment valued at $336,976.09. The ex-*

pert witnesses on values were from the American Laun-

dry Machinery Co. and hail both dippraised laundry ma-

chinery and equipment for the government. The witness

Goodwin hid appraised the same items: with the govern-

~

ee a ae

9

“me ‘nt witness Sholes whe n the peat was ‘aken: over in

Novembers: 1042 (1, 246). (Original Vok. A 1AGG.E to:

> 1066-23: priit HI, 258-9.) - The’ withess ‘Kinder\qualitied

as an expert (IT, 255, and iF ad ‘done, laundr ¥ appraisal

work for the government CH, 252-5).2' These - witnesses |

found the f air, reasonabee mark et value of the machinery

and equipme nt. in November, 1945, was $120,699.75 (11,

-260), and when the plant Was J: iken on November ‘21, 1942,

was $273, 831.39. The difference. in ‘Value-was $153,131.54. -

(11, 260) during that period-oef time. “Ex. 21 Was offered

by the petitioner fer ‘the purpose of. showbiee tlie Value

of the particular items when the business.was abandoned

8 declared surplus*by*the army on March 22, 1946. (I,

3 1L, 310-11), ° : : “*

Further explanation of this, exhibit was given by

the witnesses that in. the bl ink space. in eohimn 3 under

the ‘Value. Installed Nav. “L945, > there w as $1),492.3

of ..items that were in the laundry plant..on November

21, 1942, .ut could. net a foasa when’ the appraisal was

made in November, 1945 (11, 254-8), The court erred

specifically in, referenee—to— ths exhibit of the pétitioner

_ by Tiling. out the clement of cost of the articular ma-

I

chines to. the Kimball Laundry Co.

‘NN

4 While the court’ permiflad_the-vdlue in 1942 and

1945 to\go in, the purpose of the exhibit to show « damages

by the difference was ruled out .by the court? 's Instruetioris. +

to the jury that only fair rental ‘for-ase was’ involved

J

and extraordinary , damage.. The hard ‘usage shown re

duced the ¥alue of the machinery, anid it was er ‘ror to in-

struct the jury that’ there was no method to. judge. the -

,

measure of «am: AB when obviously the difiere: nee in

§

Le ; ; ee. Eee o

FATA

“iy?

Ta 4A

coe nies ae se eo int

we!

value “hefore. and’ after the’ taking herein shown, was .

clear and explicit, (rrr. supra, pp. 34-39) (lifva 64-67). >|

‘ : a ete a R :

.

The’ bide exhibit: on. reproduction building ‘cost

as of t942. .

The C ourt erred ini i limiting. the scope of the ¢ Meet of

‘the petitioner's, Exhibit. 19 (Ud, 4), the witness heing

John Latenser, ge the architect who built. the building

sand. installed all. the. mechanical parts such as heating,

plumbing, ete. The exhibit gave the eost in W925 and. tlie

additional cost in 1935 when the bnilding’ was improved

and one story added. The reproduction cost in November,

1942 was $2803.48, Fhe court. st: ited. in respanse to, the

in the three columns), we could then ascertain what

the fair, reasonable rental valuy’ of that property —

would be. -For-the re asous sti ity your objeetions-are

overruled,’

The court Ae in confining thy consideration of the jury

to an, importatit item sne th as the bfilding as an isolated

objection that the ‘various columns an Exhibit AB. were”

of no. value, and: (II, 263) : pe ae ‘\

Ge tS athe and with that wis a keystane (the- figures’

value upon which interest-was to be awarded as ‘rental? ;

as ‘appears frem the court’s instructions to the jury,

rather than the building as a part of the whole plant as

claimed by. the petitione r (kh rror supra, pp. 87-88),

e » ! 3 an

yeaa: ey ey,

+i The court's ruling in effect: thal “ noundaage "instead

of income was the “only proper basis to dete rine falc

of the property, was erPor,

%.,

« : .

‘ ) “4

es

ae pe ape

’ xX ea? .

c . t acain e

The court cen’ in ruling out: testimony of .A. 14:

a r, 4h years of age; rpiding in Omaha, whe

~ had 4 en an. the laundry business sinee LOIS and’ awvas:

; oe} . F =

hc Sates and OPeri thions Mutagen. of the pe titioner

at the.time it was taken and Continged with 185 other em.

* plovees ip their respective capacities after the’ taking -by

ie gondenmation proceedings “we were put out of: ‘business.’

CH, 266.) The skilled employees’ were replaced with’ a

\ maximum of 100 prisoners of war who -had. no ‘experience.

“in. the operation, of. laundry machinery and equipment..

This’ baud its had efecto on ‘the use of the plant,

ie aden te to satisfy the reqaiest maile by the court on:

poutidage in the exatiination of the witness MeDougal.

A. L.. Jacobbargey offered shibit 24 (11, 282-3): Some af .

the “poundage’ " was-in’ numbers, such. as shirts, there

having been BHO,307 shirts laundered? in 1941 - (II, 282):

The court erred hy limiting the exhibit: to show capacity |

kather than value of the business as a going concern. The

exhibit was brought in at the request of. the court.

wes (LI, 282) “The Court; Suppose we , agree these’

documents, and | take it frem his. testimony ther are

all alike, show on their fice the period they cover,

show the amount, and they niay be received in eVi-

dence for the purpose of showing capacity, or tend.

8" ing to show capacity, without further ide ‘ntification or

objection. J will receive. ye@ur book in evidence, and.

proceed, ah

The: court. then called for a price Tist apd stated

(11, 288): | ee

.— The! Court: The price list for the vear ‘1942

for all rough - ‘lanndry. We don’t ‘care itbout the

°

goverment on November 21, 142, he stated, that by the.

a

on fe che Pte

. be 60 ay

4 : +

Taney stuf, heeaise it is 100 mined work to break it

down, but’ there is (a lot-of taur ndlry, the buitk of i

(Ex. HG, mage potinds 10")

_*

The witness Jacobbe ‘peer produced Exhibit. 56 (1H,

S62) which show ok the ¢ apacity ot certain maac hines, which

is evide ntly w hat the court desire “dl. The court erred de-

‘ause after -receiv ing the capacity of machines and pound-

ao

age (hI, 862), there was ‘nothing ‘conerete .or practical

upon Which the Jury could Jind. f ‘air, reasonable market

- Value of the pl: cut on November 22, 1942... F rror is there-

.

fore assigned: to this last. ruling of ‘the court, principally’

be ‘eause the financial statements” (Exs.. 1-7, Hilhner; TI,

ISS-221) -were all ruled out and the testimony of. the

~ . ie

"witness MeDougal likewise’ nullified. In connection with

the customers lists ‘and amounts (i, “299. 244), because

* confined only to capacity rather than iy support of ‘the:

financial worth of the company.

| ia XII.

Pleat sanaaifc t time f trial

“Plant unsafe at time . rea z Sa

7 ( So sie & si i

The eourt erred in ‘rolin g ont testimony: ef the’ wit-

InOSS, A. 1. “Jacobbe reer, - << en el ae

» 2 ; ad

(II, 297) *Q. i thescondition of the machinery

and « canine How ia) the. building, eh ae one

¢

so that we can get*seine idea of the eapaciy of thie .

phant. | 7 Pe, , |

\ “The Witness: The OLP file, price list. There’ _

isa copy from the (), D, x. edb sake : =aj ee

Mr, Murphy: “(Myjectod to as irrelevant and im

“material; going. into a matter of business operations:

and not the condition of the. Jnachinery, and -not- the

, host evide ‘Ce. wes : Sa:

—-'® ~ Be Court: ‘Sustained. ee Ms ; p

(UL, 298) Mr. Hotz: - We offer to show by .this

Witness that the: plant: can not-be operated at all at

the present, time hy the: ‘Kimball Laundry Company, -

, Nowing’ to ‘the destruction of certain’ mae chine ‘ry which

t

the witness ‘Is ready to describe and show is neces. -

sary for the operation of the laundry, and the- onty

“| reason that it has been operated by the govermment

ix that the government itselffhas put in a temporary

‘machine to. perform the operation, but that-the ma--

chinery of the Kiniball Laundry Company in that

respect is gone ard the plant can not be operated at

alf.’? ° gas :

a The coutt erred: w hen it said: in the Presence -of- the

jury: ea <te | SS

/

(IT, 298) <— can. ‘go down and operaté one liy

myself and I don’t know anytlting : about a laundry. bake

This testimony given by ‘the court itself was highly prej-.

udie ‘ial-and was erroneous for the court. to have so ‘stated.

Further proof is shown leaks E shibit 229A; ‘s letter.

from the commanding Officer, Col. E. F. Ketcham, of the

Corps of Engineers, addressed , tor the Kimbalt Laundry

Co: on January* ‘11, 1946 (it, s1041, which stated that

the boiler Was ‘unsafe and that: : a :

(11,t HH) “4. Thee instruetions should he iseued ce

in. writing and posted with’ the | laundry officer in-

charge and the chief operating engineer in order that

the lives of the operators will not be endangered ‘dir-

‘ing the rémaming few? weeks. this laundry Ww il he op-

"erated by the. Governme oy eh

“

\

cae ae eo

64

ee Command of Major. General Craig:

OO hs peaney Service Cominand ngineer “as

- %,. ss a ; ae b ¢

| XM. :

Peis market value at date of taking dedied.

The court erred in prohibiting the: witness,. A, L. Ja-

cobberger (II, 213-9), from giving the fair, reasonable

“market t value of the property on November 21, 1942 2G,

312). : ae

/ “AT, Hots’ I am. asic for ‘the fair and rea-:

sonable market value of that preperty as described.

in this, real estate deseription @from pee

a a

jury is to determine, and that is the value that we

_ are trying to get now. “They. did not ‘take your ces

erty, They took the use of- your property..

Mr. Hotz: They have to start out- with a valua-

tion of some sort.

aor ‘The Court: The vileation 3 -is the valestion ‘of the ‘e

‘use. We showed the value of the -property, or thought

we did, through the testimony.

-~ Mr. Hotz: We have. a lot of things here and

I ia to get. the owner’s : value of the property.

..The Court: Objection sustained, “Fry it again.

Q. Ww hat is the fair and ‘reasonable value of

all of the property down there at the Kimball daun-

taken~ over ‘by= the government? .

The Court: You mean ihe fee title; -the title 5

all of it? Deg ieee eo ee

KF. Ketcham, Colonel, Corps of Ef Agincers :

“(11,3 als) The Court: That is the question the

-dry- Company, on -November 22, 1942, when’ ‘it was

«

by

a

| Mr. Hotz: T bé Ww hole. business, as he saw. it down n

- + there—the whole thing as ‘an operating conipany,

. down’ there at that time. ve :

' The Court: Not as an oper rating company, “You:

/> © ean-show/and T have permitted you to show the value

a the +f yperty that was used. ie you want. to. sum -

it up with him ‘in total, tound figures, do that’ but

beyond that you will not be permitted to go: prop-'

erly. Do .you understand what T mean, Mr. Witness? _

A. I understand. what you niean, ‘byt I tan” an--.

/swer this -question-— ‘

Mr. Marphy: You said you couldn't answér we!

question, isn’t that true?» ,

A.. .} ean answer the question he asked, me, ves.

The Court: Suppose you tell ‘me ‘what you value

all that property at, at the time. they took the use

of it away from vou; that is, the real estate and -thie

3 machinery and everything in. the building. What do

you eonsider the fair market value of ‘that property! :

A. -Of- the Kiniball Laundry Company ? ?

Seis The Court: Kimball: Le aundry Company: that i is,”

the building and» the> machinery, aside from. -your

> trueks and «your routes and your good will, and afi

~ that sort of thing (II, 314). We are asking you sim-

ply for the fair. market veine of the prenenty di any-

body's possession.

° ems ( o Murphy: May I ‘suggest that the question

be’ limited to the physical property? ;

The Court: I thought T did that. |

The court stated (11,315) : 3 fasta?

“The Court: Let the record. shes that in re.

sponse to the request. ef. Mr. Hotz, the court listened

to counsel, on irguments of the lawyers for a matter ..

of half an hour. and now ‘reconvening, you may pre-'

sent your bh ada! and Ket a ruling upon it, Mr. Hotz.

¢é

en =

66°:

(). What do you consider the fair and reasonable

market. Value of the Kimball, Laundry Company at

, the time of ghe. taking, exclusive of the delivery

trucks, exclusive’ of “good « ‘wall, and exelus ive of loss |

of business? — :

$987,000.00,

Mr. Murphy: Just’ 2 moment.

; The ‘Conrt: Strike the a answer and the jury. wil’

«disregard ite -.° .-. an .

yy.

“Mr. Murphy: "Pedant ‘objects as. inicompetent,

irrelevant and inmaterial; not within the issues of

_ this case; the question being the value of thé Kimball

Laundry Company.

The Court: That will be sfistained.

. “Mr. Hotz: We offer to prove by the witness: that

the value of the Kimball’ Laundry Company on No-

vember 22, 1942, was $987,524.32, exclusive of the

' delivery trucks, exclusive of ;any element of ‘good will,

and exclusive of the loss-of profits, and that this item

was,made up of the fair and reasonable market valie

of the building, of the. machinery therein, the power

plant And customers routes of this partieular laundry,

- which had been’ (11, 316). built up over a period of ten

years: from $275,000.00 to $400, 000 00 of gross income’

in ten years, and that these customers routes-consist-

ed of those shown on Exhibits 10, T1_and 12; and that—

these routes were -inhered: in that property asa part

inse parable therefrom, and that they were destroyéd

in the taking. Further. itemizing this. figure, the wit-

ness will testify, comes about through $280,348.00 of

the value of the building;. machinery and equipment ,

therein. at $273,831.39: power equipment and inci-

dental installations-connected therewith, $62,928.08;

laid, $20'000.90 5 and as a capital asset, the trade

routes evaluated by numbers of customers of dif-

ferent. kinds, $340! (16.85: that— the purpose ,of the

. testimony is to ‘dew the differcdée i in ‘the Vv lie ut

: the’ tithe of ‘the taking. and at this time, and: that, in -

_ the retuen.of said property there is only left: in. ae

tual. value, as of this*time to. the Kimball Haundry ;

Con*pany $4: 26;208 28, and that the proper reasure ;

of damages is-the difference ‘bet ween said “two, of -

. $561, 816042 that there. gXists no agcurate | measure of

‘evaluating these. properties other than ‘aj showing,

and. that these are all in’ ‘ac cordance. with accepted

*. principles 6f accounting in the laundry) business.

~* . Mr. Murphy:' Petitioner objects. to the ofer for.

the game reasons as’ to the question.

The Court: Will you inform mee Fae the offer.

follow the.discussion we hare” just h ud and present .

the. questions for the record that. were raised by. his =

“offer. and by your objections. thereto?

: “Mrv “Murphy:. 1 think $t. does. I think the’ offer -

is -perhaps, a Jittle broader, going nore: Anto. detail,

but involving exactly tlie point in. issue.

The Court: ‘Ts that so, Mr. Hotz?

“Mr. Hotz: Yes, sir. i Pe

a The Court: “With that: assurance “of. Ginnie, the

court will not take time, to have the offer read. Fol-_

’ lowing the rule heretofore made, the a is ‘Tefused

‘and objection thereto is sustdined,’” 2

At this point in, ‘the proceedings at the trial, this val-

uation, exclusive of "goo will and. loss of . business, was

material, and it constituted prejudicial error. to have it.

stricken and the witness, A. L. Jacobberger, an -offiéer, |

denied the right. to answer. -

xr."

The,ev idence of AJL. Jacobbic rger of. vides of ‘“use”’

also Stricke mn,

: 68

wv

The court erred at the close of the testimony of A,

L. dacobbe, or (IL, 367) in effect sustaining the motion |

of cequnisel fer the government to strike all the testimony

ot A. L. Jacobberger in reference to the Wwitness’s opin-

ion of the fair, reasonable niarke; valite for the use ‘of the

- pre mises from November YB 1942, to June 30, 1946, to

be’ $570,000, ee

(it, 31 * Do you understand we want now

your Sieran pe you consider agreeable for the tem-

.porary use of this: property up to June 30, 146, and

t might say, do not nicelude in, that anyéhing In. ref-/

erence to trade rgutes or loss of profits, heeause the -

_emurt dias passed upon-that. Get vour (17, 318) fig-

“ure down to® something” you Carr explain, after you

give it.

- * * ee

The Court: That i is the fair snnicieas value of the

use of the property as of November 22, 1942, through . ’

June 30, 1946, or three years, seven month, eight

days, together with the damage which has ‘been enu-

merated by te. w itfess, added thereto, so that you

may’ state i

questing; Ma. Murphy ?, Is. thot. right?

"+ Mr.-Murphy: Yes!’

Yes.

: at is ‘exclusive Of these other things—a

total of $570,000.007 5 oe

in one item. Is that what. ‘you: are Fe-.

On cross-examination from 11; 319-63, the witness —

Jacobberger justified his ligtires, Nevertheless, at the

elose of his tosfimony, the eourt rade the following com-

ment (CIT, 365), which carried the matter of admissibility

te the’ inistruetions, where the court . definitely , stated to

Gee vee Fh

the jury there was no-evidence of the value of the suse

as possibly. arising

“69 -

\

by wnvone ( Instructions supra, pp. 34-41).

(IT, 365) **Mr> Murphy: Petitioner now moves —

the Court to strike from they record ‘the testinion® -

of the witness Ai L. Jacobberger tq the effect that

in his opif€on the value of the use of: the. premises

>)

here involved for the period from November 22, 1942, :

to June 30, 1946, is the. sum af $570,000.00, for the

reason that said figure under the testimony “of Said

_witness constitutes and comprises and is made up of

certain figures: and faefors not recoverable hetein .

and not constituting items of just compensation, nor, °

evidence of just compensation, and which said (TT,

066) figures and factors are incompetent” and im-

material ‘and. constitute in some ‘Instances purely

business items “and in other instances constitute dn-

plication of other figures.and

factors likewise inehud:

ed-in said totel figure. wi

Petityoner moves the’ Court to strike from the

evidence and to instruct the jury to deduct ‘from the

zross figure of use value of $970,000.00 in the testi-

mony of this witness” A. T. Jacobberger the sum -of

$16,400.00 idéntified by said witness as eavering Costs’ |

of storage of trucks and other items not involved in

this action, and also including ‘business expenses. of

audits and appraisals in-connection with this-action

and not constituting compensable-items in this action, -

Petitioner further moves the Court | to’ Strike

from-.the evidence. and te instruet the jury ‘to deduct

from the gross figure of use ‘alue jin the sum of

$570,000.00 in the’ testimony of this witness, “A. IL

Jacobberger and to entirely disregard the ‘item of.

$50,000.00 to $75,000.00 constituting ‘a ‘part thereof as

testified by ‘said witness, and which said) sum. eom-

prises, speculative business expehse items afiticipated

. es F

¢

>

at some future date and entirely

Cy

se

©

after the peried of possession of these premises ky

petitioner, | oa eRe en pe

Petitioner further moves the Court to strike from

the eyidence and-to instruct the jury to deduct. fronr

the gross figure of use value inthe sum of $970,000.00 —

jin the testimony -of this witness, A. L. Jaedbberger,

and to further disregard the item.and sum of $11,-

327.00, constititing’ depreciation on the. power plant,

for the reason that said item and figure constitutes

a duphication of and is also included in the efaim

of damage to said power plant.in the-sum of $32.-

667.55, as shown by Exhibit No, 23, and. constituting

the full difference in value ofSaid powerplant as of

the time of taking and as of the present date, and

which last mentioned figure includes all depreciation

and said item on the testimony of the witness eansti-

tutes a business’ aecounting deduetion and a prafit’

to-the business a ay pte e

(11, 366) Petitioner firther moves the Court ta.

strike from the evidence and to instruct the jury to

deduct from the gross figure of use value in the <yin

of $570,000.00 from the testimony of this witfiess,

A. L. Jacobberger, and to entirely disregard the fyr-

_, ther sum of $65,098.00, “constituting claini of depre- .

ciation to that extent on the laundry machinery here

involved, for the:reason that said/last mentioned sum

constitutes: a duplication and is included and covered

by, the figure and claim of $153,131.54, constituting.

the difference in value according to respondent’s own

witnesses ef the said laundry machinery between the

Mate of taking and the present time, and which last

mentioned: figure include all ‘items’ of depreciation —

and said item on the testimony of the witness eon-

stitutes a Rusipess accounting deduction and a protit

to the business, . gee !

. t . ‘

The Court: [ will instruct the jury with refer.

ence to these items when the proper time*comes. The .

‘record will slow the same ruling.’ |

Later instruct on of the court eee the sustaining. ol

the motion to. aie the t testimony of the witne: ss, A. Pe

Jacobbire ‘rT, on/II,°315; 367, constituted reve rsible error

(supra, ipp. 34- 09; -G4- a0). :

a

ane he 5 ee

lt nl th

?

The witness Judd denic d vighd ta, prove 340,516.85

as the value 0) the trade routes as¢ yard of the dai niu ge.

i

The court ees in striking: the testimony of the wit-

ness, Harry kK, Judd, a certified public accountant, of

Omaha, | Nebraska, for 22 years, ide ntified with a respon-

sible firm, a law school g1 adugte in 1924, and. an expert

in Jaundry Valuations in’ whic ‘hohe had specialized in the

coifise of his ‘andits and examinations, ;

©

Exhibit 14) “(re Hused ; ‘Ti, 370) identified by the Witness

and compile d hy. bina, gave the trade's valuation of $20,

for each of the TP,093 trade ronte customers ; o0e each

for the 4,648 pillow. customers ;- -00¢ each ‘for the 6,810 .

table jlinen’ customers ; 50¢ each for the. 5,814 rug and

biaikes customers; 50° each fer the “8,178 lace. curtain

customers; $10 each for the 1,500 eall. customers ; and for

the 44, commercial customers producing $34,253.15 rev-,

enue for 47 weeks during 1942 equals $728.79 per week at®

1) times that amount when summed together in, aecord-

ance with Ex. 14 (II, 370) -gave the total valne of .the

customers ‘served ‘at $340.516.8

and records of the Kimball Laundry Co: ‘and in seceord-

ance with trade prac fice, (Adopted by the U, Ss. > Tax Court

ax a proper method cof evaluating of laundry’ routes.) Ob-

jection was made snd sustained by the eourt TI, SHS) :

. a

cone

This exhibit was pre-_

pared hy the ‘witness Judd tron: the data on the .hooks

«

‘o

?

(1, 369) “Mi, Hotz: We offer ‘to prove hy the

Witness the contents of Exhibit 14 aud. the conclu- -

stons therein to be in reference to the standard metd-

oo used by laundries in vevaluating .eastemers and

trade routes, and the witness: also will testify that

the same has been used and adepted in the ease of

Metropolitan Laundry Company before the United

States Board of Tax- Appeals, Volume 2, U.S. Bo

T. A., Page 1062, and more particularly Page 1066;

and also jn the case of be ioneer Laundry Company

found in Volume 5, U. B. T. A, in the -ease’ of

Pioneer Laundry aa vs, Commissioner of In-,

ternal Revenue, ‘and especially on. Page 829.

~The Court: What is it: you are-referring te in

the. law book? ™

“Mr. Hotz: It is. the similar’ method that had

been adopted in laundry evaluation cases before the *

United States Board. of Tax Appeals. oF

ne

Mr. Murphy: Petitioner objects to the offer for.

. the same_reason as to the, question, and for the fur-

ther reason the offer 48-broader than the *question

and is, fora legal conclusion of the witness,

Tire Court: Objection sustained. 45

3

The WKimbail Laundry Co, Was not a merchandising

establishment that had goods and wares to selk to custo-

mers. It was a servicing organization, exclusively depend.

ing upon its established routes..for plant valuation.

a . . : =] . | : .

aN 2. ae mae

“i:

The evride nce of the cost per year for three years to:

reestablis A roittes de stroye d. u as de nie ya

The .same witness Judd hooped three additional

exhibits on tie subjegt matter of expe mse to re-establish

routes, E&hibits 15 - 827-94, 16 (I, 376-9), and 17 (IL,

5

.

73

380-3). These exhibits cave the estimated ross ‘Tneeme.

“2°

and operating expenses, taken from ‘the condemne eS Tree

ords and compiled by and with the assistanee of Harry

A’ Jae ‘obberger tine | A, re AF acobberger, . The f ith tot: i}

expense after credit fro ineome Was first vear, $151,680

(II, 373); second vear, $130,366.80 (I, 370) and third -

year, $130,483.20 CLL, B80)

e=

(II, -868) Mr, aa Objected. to by. peti-

tioner as incompetent, irrelevant and: immi iterial, for

the reason it ts not evidence of the-Tair market’ value

or fair use value of the porperty taken, -and not re-

lating to any issue in’ this ease, and is fvidence relat-

ing solely to the skill and management; and to mat-

ters of the business Gperations, profits: and loss of

profits. - 7 : .

.

“The Court: The objection is sistaine d. 4¢

In each, instance the ° offe “y was made:

; (IT. O71) ‘Mr. Hotz: W e a to_prove by. this

witness the contents of Exhibits 1d, 16 andsJ7, and

to prove through the Witness the faets set forth in

the exhibits, . a :

“ir, Murphy: : Same objection | to the offer ons

to the exhibits and for. the. further reason that the

exhibits .themselves are the best evidence of avhat

they would’ prove, se

“The Court: grea “annie denied.”’

Phas, two methods - were ered by the “witness to

prove hy mothipg” spec ulative or indefinite the value of’.

reversible error resulted,

Igundry’ s trade: routes in the business world.

Ye view 0 the instructions eiven. by the gourt to the

jury later ie the ruling out of this-evidence, pré judicial

-

XVII.

The” festimoangy a the pre sidegh; Harry A Pichia

. geron fair market ralue of the plant, and his S seriplion

of vf, were uullificd by the court.

~The testimony of Hayry A: Jacobberger, the president

of ‘the Kimball Laundry Co, a resident of: the city for

“more than ‘50 ve ars’ “and, in ‘the layndry business since:

1912; gave ‘the history of the organization and the ex-

ceHent pears of the plant in. November, 1942.

(IT; 389) «0, Just explain, in a few ‘instanees,

what you meant by that when vou’ talked — ‘Fe-

placements ard repairs. aind_ p being in first-

of what yeu were t talking about,” SO that we will know.

‘Mr. Murphy: ObjectedE to ~as incompetent, ir-

relevant and lnmateria and, adding nothing to -the.

statement alre: uly made that. it: was in 1 first-class cCon-

dition and as. rood as new

The LS ourt: Sustdined sik ee. -

The cone erred in limiting the witness because of

this particular witness's ability, The: witness’ Was ‘asked

oil —

(1 ee eae

#0), What Ido want to ask of vou, however r," is

the inethod that was adopted hy. vou, as president of

- . this organization,’ as to the condition of the machinery

and equipment, and the building; and boilers, and

power plant, and all, as it existed on November’ 22,

1942. My object in asking the question is to get the

condition, the present condition of operabilit® of that

machinery at that time and that building at that time;

what avas its condition and upkeep as to rehabilita:

tion, replacement, and so forth. Will ‘YOU. answer,

please} 7”?

class condition. Just-give us a “short prada pea

?

4 vit,

: a

The wit Tittss, | In rrs As Jacobberves, gave a

ile ~i vip

tion Ot the bagtdedine osict contents of EL, 26-7). He “CON

é - _ @

aluded by saving GIT, 401);

“AL The Kimball Laundry € GIpany, in '

* and when bo say ‘this ‘aren’. 1 menn West of

and Tsay clear to the Pace ut igast,, ix consi ide

outstanding tmodel - plait. ku@Q@wv jit. is the

.

ae area,

ie ago,

ao the

prac tie ”

of -most of the machinery sole sinen cto bring their

prospects anywhere in this: ttYritory te see’

‘chines they want to.sell in’ oper ration in ou

the yne-

Da e are considered a, napenn Feet Dy ri actie: al}y every

iD

City, cok ‘as eS of” that oa Ta fact, Tey:

say thie 'y thought I was crazy for kee ‘ping up

anad tor

a plant

of that type, sort of. a. show-room plant. It Wits TAY

hobby. I enjoved it.

“Mr. Murphy: } move te strike what he

it was. It Is calling fora conclusion,

know that. it is dama: ging ‘ar. not on either sid

ihinks “a

<a e Court: That is very true, but 7 don’t

e, li ine

just a comments It. is pretty hard to se parate thet

-Which is camment and proper. Overruled,

stand.”’

ae The court erred in making. fide: comme ak It j

nferred

that there Was ne: positive value -to Haryy A. Ji acobber-.

ger’s estim: ite of the type and kind of the plant

‘Later in the court's instructions, the preside Nt's 6

was: nullified by the court’s stating there was

“dence upon whieh ‘the jury: coral arrive at-‘use’?

3

(Inst , SADA, pp. 34-41).

.

a ere.

.

6

it Wits.

v eine

Ho CVI-

~

~

~

Ba

‘Te stimony of the presi: de nt on “ase value’ asked Wy

the court, was. nullified by the court, 3

wat tire rag

~ *

76 he a

e : * OP :

oe?

The court érred, ivfter requiring by rule of court that

the testimony he confined te fe mporary use, -fnornline ent

the testimony of the witness, H: APT ‘A... Jacobberger, Oi

that: mtter.

. 7 a ; ; : .

(Tt, 42 1) “OO. What awonld vou sav was the fair

value ins the: ely oof Oman oneNovember D9 ..1949.

of a temporary use that would be made of the Kime

shall Lanndry' Con npany including the lind, daiikdine.

machinery and equipmie nt fora ferm that wotild Ia

put’ to vou_dt that time of three. and one. half. vears,

OF three years anid) stv-te rth months: that is. aterm .-

a ee | tafe nice,

« xpl: wn ation hy counsel CH, Ae5)

for temiporatynses ‘forthewliole thing as it was asa

unit, for the use of the nit od States” Governme nt,

. Tet’s. sav, or any Similar person that had one: OSSITY

for- fin immediate use?

. Ve CS aie .

ain 409 vee Mr. Murphy Ohjeeted to as: ineom.

petent, “irrelevant and immaterial, for. thie rensan

that it is. net ev idenee al the- fair market Vi afte or

fair réntaly value or the nse value of the property,

taken and is not related: tors inv issue in this case?

is evidence velated toethe manageme ut, te the Operg.

tion of the. business, to the Toss of profits, ‘rood will

and eustoms.

“S“*Question read,.

1 oe & , ras, «6 ae

- “The Court: Objection sustained. 11 Is not the

proper measure of damiiges, * % oe

The petition, was then- read to the witness wath this

. “ME, Hotz: In asking: this question | to this: wit-

tess, foam doing it -in the jizht of the rulings of the

court thet have he ‘retofore heen made, tat has been

excluded, and 1 think T have éxplained ta the withéss

#6, >. that he” won "t be complicat ited with that.

ol

. P ‘

he 4 our: What is. theoceasion fop this os

pla iM ition? ig

ee “eur Hots: | don’ { .w: nt the Witness te be tris

understuacd, as Mr, Murphy is, that 4 am trying’ 1

include somethin th; at ts more thar the land build

ine, 1m rehiine ry and eqiipment,

SP ey ee i eUrt: “Why seet it’ so. com: plic “ated? We

; - are trying to fitd out wv hawt his opinion is of the uss

eta OF thy} property: that was taken: as dy seribed in tty

— petitfon. What further explanation is eee ssarv?) Yor

may answer. the question, i" “Vou understand At

“The Witness: l am not Sure, You. want the

Gente, value of Wie property ? :

The Court: Yes, vale fer: the use art the pre p

oY erty for these. three: years, “seven mont he ane eight

a davs. on thee Do mh day oo " November, 14: te value

2 as ofthat alate. A. Tn my Judgment that. Woould base

nbs <600,000,00.% | y | * "1

s

This ey iFenee in the Withess'’s eross examination ON

“plained (U1, 423-5) Sew he arrived FT the ameunt eiven,

and also On direet exainimition nas zt basis fer his esti

Metes for the ferm **use?*? (TJ, 396-493).- A¢ HH, bio), coun

Sl for the covernnient stated: :

tL, 440) OMp: Murphy: M this time petitionér

struct the jury to entirely disregard ‘the festimony

~of this w itness Harry A. Jacobberger as to the rental’

OP use valde of. the props ‘Thy in question at $100,000.

00 a vear, a total of SA60,0100.00, for the reason thi ith

and figure, ‘acchtding to ‘the testimony of®

the witness Tree lf, is based Ley eeens ht nil is his apinion

Of the vate to thie Kimbal} 1: aundry Company of

es — moves the court to. strike from the record andtte an’

vA

3

ag this preperty as a eding concern, and. is therefore

© Hol @ preper measure of daniages and not within: the.

ge : issue s of this’ cise? TS ' : re :

ek .

thre

ree, On eae 74

“The Caurt: Objectio€g overruled, becanse thie

testimony, part of it +t con\peteny and other ate

ters are meompetents The cotrt expects, at a diter

tine, te instruct the jury toda pecrird all fies inne.

pertaining: to ‘consequential damages. anything per

sonal te the owner op the owners. nnd confine theins

ve rdliet to the property and matters peident. thereta

T have so antiounce:dd at different times, The rule]

am administering. is pretty well under stood, [ Gone

vou will coufine it within that scope, lint We Dawe, . - 3

not been able te? and TP wilf lave fo deal with it when

I: come to instruct the jury finally in this ease. 1

announce this rule in advance at this time so that

counsel max he odvised to spend ne time on any pf

these myatters that 1 have referred tocas not being

elements of danimges cove! hte th thas ne ‘tien, so that

you will not be in ny ow nV pire judiced hy it or takey

ir any way. his Nurprise. a ; pis

(ut) Me, Hotz) T would like to put Mr. Marry

Jacobberger oir the at the for tt ome nt.

“The Courts, ave him come forward.’

On redirect examination of Harry a Jncebberger,

% following took place: a at

(IT, 44h) od. You have heard the cisllonity and ane

stateme nt of the court, ' will put this question te

vou, and. if vow Wish te dhange your ‘testimony, vou

are privileged to Tne Be .\ What did you take into

—e wher vou ep tg the statement) in ‘re-

Sponse to’ the ecunsePs inquiry. or question upon

Wihieh to base the 700,000.00 per’ year for the use

and. the damare, In addition tes 220,000.00, - ‘ta. make

the $ SO80,000.00 that counsebh was talking, about when

he was cross. examining you? If you want te change

vour: te sstimony in that regard, or offer any explana-

tion, you. may do so,

Me Murphy: Objected to for the same reason

* as the original que stion. Tt is an exact repetition of.

Pee a SNe ee ee od

> iA i \ j S&S

the original , 44: 2) question, with» (wo or thre oth.

ers. involved in it, and indefinite aid Nnee rtain,

“The Court: That. will be custalned and the

Court will try to he dp him: out, What did vou tnean

‘when you said in aliswer to Mr. “Murphy's question

‘that vou ‘valued the arse of the property ada going.

concern} What are the cleme Tits you had. iw mind ?

‘OAL TD had’ in .imind that if someone came fe me

and wanted to lease the property for a Inatter ef two

‘or three vears, that is What: it would vost. That \s.. -

the consider ration, am |.

The Court: That is, you mean to take ove:

vour entire laundry business?

\

wv

AL Taki. OVER the physi ‘al plant and start to

operate whe ‘re’ we left off. e°

“@. Did you mean taking Into consider ation the

: eo -

-customii%s routes and athe trade?

‘ Mr. Murphy :. Same ahjection,

“The Court: “Sustained, !

"Q. Did You mean physijeal fissets, alone?

“Mr. Marphy: > Objected ‘to for the same reasin

and repetition and np per redirect, .

“The ourt: “That will be sustained. \

“Q. T will ask: you once more’ whether of vot -in

your statement to Mr. -Murphy, whether you meant

the rental of the Physical assets for the Meriod. of”

three and ane. half vears

*

e

“4

“The Court: That will not be periittted’- It is.

for tKe jury to determine what he meant by his tes.

timony..” hie has repeated it several times, If he

wishes to rinke any change jn any of these state.

‘ments he. has made, or ifche wishes to withdraw: Any

is statement -he 48% made’ he ean do se, but ‘vou cannot

proceed in this aw: wy longer, % sages

2

- to the building, vround,. equipment and all of

“0, Do-vou Wish to withdraw or change. your

te stimony in that respect? i, cme oe

- . Pate” ae

“ALT didn't: know. there was going’ to be any ;

misunde ‘ystanding about my -statemie nt, ;

' : Mr, Murphy; I nove to strike th: uoand ask.

the witness “answer that simple question: Sves* or, a

* ne.’ ; . ° 4 : a

v.

. ©The Court: Sustained. vf ¥

OH, 443) 8 Q. If you twish to change aid with-

“draw your state nient vou made as a going business,

that is the thing we are getting, at. You made’ the

‘statement, JAs a going concern.’

S*The C ourt: In-order to be fair to the. Witness —

we seem to have vot him confused. Maybe. T have, — 7

Fo be fair to the witness, you may state again, Mr.

Jacobberger, what are the’ elements that you con.

sidered as making up your opinion, or arriving at .

your opmion that the fair and. reasonable anarket %

Value of the tise of the Iurildiing, the machinery and. ~ /

the ground, 6n the 22nd day off November, 1942, for”

a term of three vears?seven months and eight days

was the sum of $100,000.00 = Tell ws" again

so there will he no mistake about it. ;

‘$A. That is exactly what T meant with ei renee

thinks we had tq go with the business over there, to :

be worth the sum of $100,000.00, 5 0 0- - > * : :

. ee = ‘e “9 5 * . : :

“The ¢ Court: ’ W hat do You mean by Abe busi-

“ness’?. oie ge . ; ein

AL -There*are a lot of things we havent -enn-

merated. We-have store rooms, cold storage, which

-‘g

is part of the business, | - 5° = ;

“The. Court: We will proce od with the matter

no. farther. : ae eared, | , é

} Mr. Tota: ‘That, is’ all. Be pela fe

\ ;

‘\ o tae

{

2 : ioe = s ae fe

8

pba es “Mr. Murphy : Thi it is all, (Witness exeused.)"

| (See. Court's list. supra, pp. S441; Requested, ‘pp

41-45.) he 3 ee C

Q .

esis XIX.

The ripe evi n. ok ci re 2 aye é > of the - b resid ivf oF. Cin

de Winer thet if was aah to start-hirs sine Ss else adhere ‘aud

a2

ae was. put, out of bus SUHESS 0 nlirely oy the taking, MAS € rror:

The Yiliewine’ thok place at H, 437-9:

“Q. When this laundry was taken over chy. the

government in. 1942.. did the Kimball Laundry A om-

pany have available to it in the launilry van nothe Wy Space

Whe ‘re it mie ht have moved? =~ :

iistaine oi /

‘Mr,! "Marphy: Ob jected 1g as Incompefent and,

“immaterial. ese . esas :

The Cou: Sustained, ‘

(EL, 448) 0), Did fhe Kimball Laundry Company

remain i business, atte 2 Nov ember 22.1 aot |

> Murphy: > That. is < also Ajooted ti as ins |

competent, and immate rials |

“The Cc ourts That will be sustained,

“OQ, Was the Kimball Laundry able to cre remain. Ms

in business aftur, Novetiber 22, 1942

0 **Mr. Murphy: Objected to: as incompe bee and

immaterial | ariel furthe a it is an improper -ane “tion,

“The Court 2 Sustained. —° _ ; . ’

- *Q: Was the “Kimball Laundry Company hnsi-

MOSS AS A Loing concern destroyed: by the taking en.

1 FE

a

November-22, i922 pieces ee

“Mr, Murphy: Objeeted. fo as incompetent and

irrelevant and not ‘within the issues in this e tse and

having been alr

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.