Record P — Nye & Nissen v. United States (No. 228)

Supreme Court brief1948

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

ee

1982. Nye & A

a,

7

-

S80 n ond A. Moneharsh

> e. ©:

(‘Testimony of C. A, W ith. At: as

' ae oe They were too badly shrimkén. The avhites:

-was broken down, too. thin’ and runny. Phe volks

é

- were flat. i" oa

_Q. Now,. in. the’ vera what is the method of

candling, as to whether the candling. is done pre-

vious to their being proc essed, or oiled? —

* A. The common smethod in the trade is to can-

dle the eggs, -get them ready for shipment, and

‘ then,process them and ship them.

Q.: Why are. they not candled afte - being | bro-

cessed ? : 7 ;

A. After being processed. they are apt-to be

-ouly. It. is very disagreeable for the eandlers: to

handle them. It costs money to process eggs, arid so

they remove ail the checked eggs’ and the odd-—

shaped eggs, the rots, and. the off-grade eggs, he-

fore abatement It is not economical to do it othe T

wise. a ets vide 8 eee |

QQ. Are you. able to state whether these eggs

peas been candled within a pe riod of three or four.

weeks? | i |

“A. If they had ‘been candled nothing had heen

removed. There was’ no indication of any: candling

having heen done within that jieriod of time.

~Q. And why do you. say that ? ?,@..

A. The type of rots found, the shrinkage of.

cheeks—or_ the shrinkage in’ there of the éges—

none of them had been removed.:,The extreme

_ shrinkage. ain is se

Q. You mean by that if they had: he ‘eR eat naied

: the bad. eggs had rot heen rethoved as resi ts of the

barat A. Yes. ae eee eh $s

>

\ e @ he

‘ ae tee ee irae

a : ; ie

BO. Sic

s me ° ——s we |

Pay. “We he & :

Ray al S : : es

: TT eLn® d'Stetessof America TORS.

Mr. Faulkner: aol

Mr.Pratt: That is all, 9 —

eo The Court 2 CalF your text witness. Step down

ee Mr. Prait: Mr. Mills is heing recalled’ “if vour

Honor please. Te is the manager: of the Terminal

“Warehouse Compan, the rvefrigeyator company at

Los Angeles. He was to. bring his record of re frig-

eration, as your Honor will reme mber.

WILBUR J. MILLS,

| -

recalled as a wigwess for the Government, having

been previously duly sworn,, testified as follows:

The Court: He: has already been, sworn.

“Direct ‘Examination i |

Mr, ‘Pratt: @ Mr. “Mills, you testitied, a other

day, 1 think, that you were assistant manager of, the

Terminal Refrigeration’ ComPany of Los Angeles.

A. That. is correct... Stee a

Q. And you are back: today with the records of

refrigeration of the room. in which these eggs, lot

B73T, “were stored. How is the ‘ree cord -kept as to

the refriger: ation of the rooms in your warehouse ¢

» AS There is amanual chart kept up by temper ‘a>

ture meén and reeord six times a day; and also. a

recording device, such asa cloc ‘+k, whieh Tecords the

‘témperature for one week.

—Q. “And that is in the reom! t

i oe, That is in the room.

o : @. That is an automatic ‘instrument

oe A. That As correct.

€

.

—

6

al Nye & Nissqa and A. fonchar sh

;

ba]

. _t ©

(‘Lestimony of f- Wilbur Z: Mills) : we

(), which oie ai k of the tenmperattre hy '

on Hak tine? 7A: That is eorrect, Z

Q. That’ goes creatnd and records temperature A

ra ery moment, is that right / ,

Bhat is right.:

‘ @

> According to the record which you produced,

your ledger sheet, 7 think is was, yon showed, did

you net, the number. of the room in Which. these

eggs were stored i n your ware Shouse ?°

“Mr Faulkner: | I beg your pardon. There is no

| testimony at all dhout these eggs coming from Mr.

Mills, not one ‘word. About these cases—3737;

Mr. Pratt:. These cases which were marked

Lot 3737. cron eg Se enna ae

“Q. 1 direct your attention to this exhibit No, 123.

Does this show where the eggs were stored? , wie

A, It shows Room 41. That. is where the eggs |

were originally stored. } :

- * Q. And, how long did they remain in room 41) Poe

. ° Mr. -F: aplkcacr? Just a moment. You mean the - ,

eases marked - 3737, ; ore g .

Mu. Pratt: Marked 3737. 2 fs

Paes,” How long did ‘Lot 3737 remain in: roonr-#T? 7

Mr. Faulkne rz: We object to that as’ ingompe- .

tent, irréle ‘vant, and imnigterial, not hinding on the » ee

defendants. Se Were

The Court: The objection will be nib

Mr, Faulkner: | Exception. — Cel

A. Approximately August 25, 1943,

“Mr. Pratt: Q. Where were fhese* eggs then

" moved -to ? “AL To root 63.

°

.

i

es. Dnilid States of ‘America 1925

=

- 7 ret . °

(Testimony of Whur J. Mills.)

Q. Have vou with vou the record showing. the

temperature of this foom 41 fromthe 8th of Febru-,

ary; 1943, until what: date. did you say, August.

“25th?.° ° A; August 25th- ind

Q. . You have that record, have you?! -,

me *[ do. Ih: ave heth records here. Do: Vou Wish -

one “at a time?

*

Q. Let us have the coe kk record. Is that what

you call it ?: ~ A. Yes, sir a

: =

Q. These ‘clock records that. you have now.

_ handed me are’ from February 12th to 19th, 1945,

first? °-A. That’s ‘hght——_:___ f

Q:. When did they go into that-room ?

A. February: llth. f£ helieve.

Q. Febr uary ‘th. Now, the first of these, whic h

——

is dated. February 12th, to February 19th, Ee.

shows by the ink mark what as to temper rate

Mr. Faulkner: Just a nioment, if your ae

please. In other words, Mr. Mills is not the éngi-

neer. He cannot testify to the. temperature.

The Court: He ‘is testifying here whht these

records lisclose, % | aie

~ Mr. Faulkner: Yes, but the records are not

binding. The method of proving the temperature

is not by proving a corporate record.

The Court: ° Tam allowing this to go to the jury.

You asked for them.

Mr. Faulkner: 1 didn't ask for the m.-I asked |

for the’ proper evidence cone erning 1 refriger: ition.

The Court: Isn't this it? ° |

Mr. Peiallcigne: Your Honor, on ‘a. book of: ac-

fe

1936 us N ye Niss We and A. Moncharsh .

(lgstimony of Wiex i Mia

eount a man ean establish that a book of account Is *

KE] a The INST? e here. Is the yefrigers ition of-a room.

Certainly, the engineer ean read his records kept

at ‘the time of the Ocenrange and: si stv that the root

teniper: attire-On sie ‘h and such a date is so and, so-

I, grant that—but T could hot: testifas if DT owas the

president of this company, that my show.

this. That is hearsay. That ix not binding. upon the,

defendants: ae

The Court: Are vou,asking for the best evi-

dence? - - Bee we, aoe ae

Mr. Faulkner: Yes, your Honor., res

The Court: ~W hat is the best evidance ? : a

Mr. Faulkner: The testimony “of the man “who -

Reece

‘kept the record:

—e

The Court : " Are. these. ‘yeeoule kept under”

your supervision ? A. Yes, sir® ti °

Mr. Faulkner: May 4 ask Mr. Mills a a question?

The rn You may.

| Mr. Faulkner: Q.. Mr. Mills, have vou Ne ny , =

thing a do with prepiaritig the record you said )

your hana ?-—-—A.__No, sir.

(). You de mot, do vou?

A.: 1 do not prepare this. record. | °

Mr. Pratt: Q. The -record prepares itself, does

itnot? —. A. This record does prepare itself.

Q. That is, it is an automatic: machine -which

registers tempe rature: continuonsly, each of these

sheets being fay a period. of one week, is that right | :

A. That is correct. : RSW ee “a

Q. Now, referring, to the first of. these vireular

é -

=

7

have here, they are, made by a dial? nek

each week.

a \ 7

o. United States of America” 1937

; : : . f : . . oan ; . rn - . m :

(Testiniuns of Wilbur J. Mills.) es .

recording sheets, will you state ‘what, the teriapera-

“ture was slaving that pe ‘ie ! rae ~

Mr. Fyuilkner: That is Just the point, .vour

“Honor, Mr. Milis is pot ay compete nt Withess to that» |

testimony. There is no rule of law that permifs: it.

The, man. who is the engimcer on a ship can read his:

Q

engineer ‘x log. Ina pl: uit like that IT would assume

that the engineer could, testify from. the, records

. that were made in the conduct of his duties.

Phe Court: -Q. How “are. these records made?

A. “These records are made.from a clock. The Se

J

records are. made by three different temperature

men (indicating).

Q. . In relation to, these automatic ones th: it you

A.” By a diathves-

Q. Who has charge of the dial? |

“A. The chief-engineer would have ‘charge ‘of the

dial, and they would be placed in the clock, itself,

by. the temperature man.

Q.. ‘Then what- becomes af them?

A. They are returned to the offic 0 at the end . G if

Q. And 1 aske a you if these Inatters that you!

have here are ‘under your supervision,

A. Yes, sir, under my supervision,

Q. In what -respert are they, and how do ¥ou.

come in vontact with: them? . |

=.

“

We are interested in the snrveillanee of the.

temperature recordings which Ae set down from

Hay to day, so that'we know that the work ts being

&

) 1933 3 N ye « Nisse: n. ‘nial A. Wonchareh mag

| ‘Testimony of Wilbur J- Mills.) oa. .)

cote Pt ‘Ope thy: ; the temp 1 Anes are heme recorded

and handled property. | + Plog tis a

; Q. . Did vou see those from day to day? -

A. Surely, {5° | reece a

OR ES PATS eee ee reac

\. These come up each day, your Honor.

Q.°. Each elay? |. |A. Yes, sir.

IM Pratt: -Q.. You ane t talking yhout the bieeor

—shects ?- A. That is correct. ae =

The Court: Q.. And what about the others ?

A. These come. up at the end of eae ‘h week,

The Court: I will allow. the. testimony. rat.

Mr. Faulkner: Exception,

. The Court: “Note an -exe eption, “Mr. _ Reporter

e

“

*

y

ee us proweed. 7 s, oe .

~The Witness: Mr. Pratt, I beheve your question

is for: me to give you what this’ record shows—is: -

‘that it ? . ; oe Cah a8 d Be a

Mr. Pratt: Q.« Yes, -on that first week. :

A. I shows at the time the chart was plac ‘ed in

room was sca purine 34> degrees.

ae ‘The Court; Friday, what date? =.

ra Tae Be ae

A... Friday, would be the 12th of. February.

A et. Berk tet es st

A. ‘Phat is right..The temperature variation at

that time went to Satyrday up to approximately

, 38, and chme down Saturday morning to about 36.

— Sunday it. went up just a bit. We were probably

working thi ut Sunda Lv.

the clock, on Friday, that the temperature in’ that_

——

ae, ate d States of Aimerieca 1939... ne

2 Testimony of Watbur I. Mills) - E sige a

Mr. Pratt: Qa U p te: Wwhate? , W hat is the bigh

on Sunday ? ot - a | ey ee ae

A. On Sunday the high is. 42. On Monday

Q: °° Give the high eon date. “ ey

A. ‘The high is 42 AI right, gir. On Munday the:

high. was 38. On Tuesd: iy the temperature had. re-*

© — ..ceded to 36, arid remained practicatly constant, On é

Wednesday the temper: ature had recedéd to ApProx-

— Imately 34 and. remained approximate ‘ly constant

"there. On. Thursday morming at six it was Approxi-+

_ mately 32 and reniained at 32 until approximately

six a. m.. that morning, when. it arrived. at almost

a dase That takes us into Friday again, where .

it was approximately 31 at the time this avas Te

———a

Jamoved | from _| the clock... —_____—_—_

°Q. On the next week, the week. of February

_19th, the temperature was——

Mr. Kk ‘aulkner : May my "objection: go to all this

testimony t . : |

The Court: Very well.

Mi. Faulkner: : May | see the! nop het rent — 3

Mr. iad: 1g That ext week the temperature

Was practically the same all week, was it not. °

A. It was. ese des ee ike jets

. Q.° 3 what temper: ature’! Mm JA, --30 to 31. -

~Q.. And the next week, the. week. of February

26th, it was also sti ahte during the entire weeks j Was -

wnt: > A, ‘It was. uy

Q. With-a high of what?

‘A. 31 Tuesday, 12 midsight.

— > =

\e

- % é

“ - sien (o . : nw : |

WN Nye & Niessen and AL Moxcharsh

(Lestimony of Wilbur J. Mis 2g

~Q:. And ou ‘egit next week ?

A. .The week of Mateh Sth %-

Q). It was das ee wasn t it?

A. it was. The recotding ts practic: sally cireula

Which means right on the riese at 30 degrees with -

very Bos variation. .

’ The ne xt wee k of M: We i 12th the same -is

“true, eraye not / ? Ae oti ak pats

A. - It is. “The same i is true -on.that.

Q. And’ T direet your attetition to the siiecoeding

* sheets for the sueceeding wecks up te August 25th.

‘Thht-is the date they have changed, vou say, when

they moved,these pack: ages to another reom. [ will

____-_ask whether all of these sheets do not indi¢ate that

the temperature. was stable at: , approximately o2

degrees 7 ROTA ot 7

A. ¥ am- sorty to take all this time. Thee re- |

-cordings are as stated, pr eviously. ash coe

Mr. Pratt: I ask that these cireular decords be.

marked, collectively, that have already ‘been identit

fied, as one-exhibit and received -in: evidence,

The Court: They will be.admitted and marked

next in order, + | ot |

<o (T he documents were inarked. U. S. Exhibit

_ “131m evidence, ) Rae cee ‘

Mr. , Faulkner: Subject to “my objection that!

they are incompetant, irrefevant, and immaterial, |

ind no foundation has been Taid, in that there is no -

evidence that ‘those. are records made by this wits

ness, . > >

“The oe > The dhjection will he overruled.

‘SS

‘

wv

“ 2 _— es 4+. * ; nes o

“ * ; rs: Daited States of A DORI CH 1941

‘ ate # fo ; f ‘ a! .

. , (Testimony of Wilbur. J. Mifls. :

Or. Pratt: Q: ‘Now, you said/ that this Lot

< eee was moved to room 63 on the 25th of Atigust..

/approxiiately.. Will vou produce the. sinfiilar rec- :

_ords of the automatic device ‘covering the peridd -

from August Fith to October 15th, these “records |

be ing of room ieee A.” That’ is correct ~ °.

Q. Examining these, Mr. Mills; ‘thes show, do).

tags they not, all of them, that the temperature a oe aes

room - remained ‘practic ally: ‘the _same—during that-

entire period at about 30°to | 32 degrees? |

gee. ar That is correct. see ees peas ect

ig - Mr. Pratt: "These circular: ree ording sheets for 3

room 63 from August 27 +t sees 15 are offered

#

in evidene e as,one exhibit number. PoE Sai a we

Mr, Faulkner: - The: same objection: incompe-

tent, irrelevant, immaterial, and hearsay as to the

defendants, and ne “foiindation laid: in t ye instances

oS “pointed out te your Honor in the: oral, aneyinent én

| the admissibility. - oe ist

T he Court: The objection will be oyer ruled.

* .(The loc uments were marked U: S. Exhilfit

“ .. 332 in evidence. ) SEY eae ae este

Mr. Pratt: Tf the Court please, L.would like to

hand these to the jury for: their observation:

Mr. Faulkner: _ Mr, Pratt, may I suggest that

: there are so. fhany “there, that you pic +k ont ane or

two and we ‘will xgree that they are typical? For

. instance, these two ate about the widest, departuies

from an ordinary one where the refrigeration is :

pet, ‘constant at about j2 | . n _- aio

>... Mp Pratt: Allrighti: -.-\- gee” arent

Pa

i>) 5 ; ' « = ¢. :

oy é .

df . ; ; :

:

12 . Nye ro N2ss¢ n anid ® A: Moncharsh - "es

C eotineiey: of. Wilbur J. Mills.) A

°

jury, but To dheyn’ there are so many: They at: alte

) atures. .

. 2, prae ae “ally: the: sante consi: uit Lenny

oT ae Mr? Pi ‘att :, This is Ax. | Abit 132) these “ several

| * sheets, fre” aleatike, practically, with Pr Complete

-_cirede Showing a stable temperature,

—_

oe QM. - particularly, direct your attention: —— :

.Mxr FE aidkner: * ~The jury wis “examining those

sheets. ssf eee 3

Mr. A ig att: L particularly’ direet your attention,.:

Ma . Mills, to this cireular ree ‘ord, which is the first.

of E xhibit’ 131, being arecord off temper atures dur-.

. ing the week from February be 1943," where there

i aa variation. indie ated by the ved mark, ‘and you

—~ . " havé testifie ze that the teinper ature went = to wnat

&

maxinuimn 2 ae 2.

- fe T think 1-festified t te 42: onde

= a Q.- How: Tong did ‘the temper ature remain at 42 |

degrees?’ A. Just-an hour or thereabout.” *

Q). About an hour? A.- That-is correct.

Q.. -Are you able to state whether, during an

our’s period, the temperature of the .eggs that

were in these eases would also go up to 4270 Bee’

A. Ff hose eggs had probably not reached [1746]

a temperature of 42 degrees as yet. The r easons'for

‘the Variations: there, of course, are: that we -were

loading that re an, and naturally the eg oes hath been .

= out” of the refrigerator cars far. a period of: tine.

-. ad’ had gone to outside temper ratire: . They were

, » still in the process. of doming down to a "82 degree

tempel ALUrey uaturally, SRI

= - : ER

a ° SAG '

; a ’

Mr. Faulkyer:,, You may. handy then all to the

°°

a“

Se “SY

a—

%

ee te US, u nit States of. ae rea 2 Je

en ? "* e

ae “ Cestimony of Witbur-J. Mills.) ”

A” understand’ the. eges would hot have been

S giffected by “the fact’ Tat -the temperature. of the

_ Tgom: went up to‘as high as 42?" A. Nb.

with you, what are. those? Pe! ae 3 8

*. be. moy ok from time’to. time, but there ¢ are in extent

~~ about® three’ to@tive thegmomete vs in each room,

‘whieh, are read at different elevations; and again: st,

o “the side walls of a. room, or the floor of a room, Ue

ap effort to get a very ¢lose gpproximation of the

temperature throug hout the room.

~ <Q. And who A ah these reading rs and mfilzs this

record? “A, Ouir temperature . men. |

~Q. Do they work under your immediate super-

vision? | a7

hes TheyAvork ‘under. the. immediate supervision ‘ve

of the chief engineer, ‘subject to ahy- orders that

we may give. . at ae :

Qe And. a whole process is under your r direc;

_tiflon ? = That is-correet.,°

Q. And a keeping of these- records is under

\ whose direction? [1747] - | Beige -

| oA. .[t would-be under niy direction. ~~ ae

QQ. Are these part of the regular records of your

| Corporation kept in the regular COURSE of business? 2.

A. They are. pe erst iso eee

Qu I would like- youl to iprodun ‘the’ records ter

the-8th of Februa ry, or the date when this Lot 3 a7t

went info room 41 of your refrigerating plant.

iC Rete ring to the other records that vou‘lave =

“A, Those were the manual records. W e have

thermometers: placed through ihe rooms: whieh age y i

7 ¥

ey

é : . . © . +9 .

i : ‘ "4% Lt eee 7)

1 bid Nye a Nise neand A::Moicharsh. . :

. re ’

? Tostinonyol \V Tbur Jd. Mills.) ee es

it AL sed reeall, “Mr, Prait,’ tlie merchandise: wis

fo ordered@in&y stor: we ow thet lih-of February.

Qe And it actu: went Into storage on What

ste? a fe eee :

ote date? --; © ga 5

- a ‘ i fn . «a

4 ™~

3, ‘duit he: mo Wor the 1th. We would ‘not

know Which date sthat ” was, depending on the day - _

ithad thes vy ordered | them into storage. it, _ could pe :

eithe r date. | as. ham °

Q. And this sheet that you se handed me is

the vecord for F ebruary 10, 19433

“A. . That is correet. se <

‘), And this.is posted at the time?

2) That is posted’ each time the temperature ,

nan vomes back from his tour throughout the ware-

J muse! . if) s

a4 And how many. times a ‘day dogs he 20 into

the warehouse to determine the température ?

Mr. Faulkner : We‘ object to that as calling for

the opinion and conelusion of the witness, There is

_no way Mr. Mills knows how many times a man goes

“a “into a_place.- 2

~

Mr. Pratt: We will s see if he does.

Q. Do you know how this work is done ?

Aa, They 0. into it six times a day, [1748] ©

Q. . Under your supervision ? :

A. That is correct. |

Q. — The times meitioned on. this sheet are + a.m.,

c

8am. 1 pme4 pam, 8 pin, ma and: 12 p.m. ?

A." ‘That is correet.

Q. That is about every four hours—first every —

four hours, from 8 ‘aang to-F p.am.—that is five hours’ |

—<

©

& : , es °

a 2»

(Testimony af Ww ilbur h a Milts, )

—und then the next peripd . Is ‘to 4 pau: Which ps

Reis hours, then: four hou, ‘and again four hours,

* is that right? A: T hat is cortect. Shy

Q, The left- hand column “1s the number Of the

‘room, is it not? - , A. That is might. a4

Q. So that when you get down to- roomy +1 oes

this show what the. contents of the room, weré, on

. that dafe, on the 10th of February?

A. ‘If says, ‘* Pears, Persitimons, Apples and. ¢

Cheese.”’ VO ee &

vs. United States of America’ 1945

Q. And that is on the oth? a Ee gs warts

A. That is right. Ree at Ce ae

Q. -Now, on the 11th of February, in room 4},

: 7 what de it show as to the cértents ?

Mr. /Waulkner: - | object te. all: of this, your

Honor, as incompet tent, irrelevant aind: immaterial,

‘not within the issues of this case, e not binding: ——

the defendants, ne foundation laid:

Mr. Pratt’: The defendant asked for it.

Mr. Faulkner: 1 did not ask for any such thing,-

your: Hauor, whether there. were) ‘apples, cheese, or

something else in a roonr. I aid not. ask for “this:

. record, at all.

The Court: 4 may be mistaken, my self, but the re

were [1749] records called for here, were the re hot?

Mr: Faulkner: No, [ asked for the Dest t evider oe

of the temperature of the chill.room. >

The Court: . That was the record:

Mr. Faulkner: Yesyyour Honor. .

. The Court: Is this the record ?.

a

1946 : N ye & Nias and A, Mondera

fh

(T estimony of W ilbur J. Mills. )

‘ihe ke spt them.

Mr. Faukkner: No, the best evidence is the man

-

a

“The Court: IT have riled on ‘that: You’ havea,

“record. L: hitve determiped that they: were ‘under

this witness’? superv.sion -and therefore «he can.

testify. . : By

- Mr. Faulkne 2 out Hogor cis d that. . an’ not

trying to avoid” your Sonor’ S ruling. ‘Your Honor

-knows | do not do that. But whether there were

cheese, or apple s in the reom d do not:see where it

: em eee cane, - f :

‘Wie Court: What relation Tins that? ? , § oN

Road

Mr. Pratt: This is the date pre vious to the PLES

going in..

“The Court: 1 will allow it as a 1 preliminary ques-

tion in the interest of time.

‘Mr. Faulkner:. If the w ines. is going to testify

from these records on whic he “Mr. Pratt is already

examining him, Ll want my objection to go in here

very ' detinitely that we object to this record being

used by this witness to refresh his recollection upon

the ‘ground that it is.a reeord which [1750] he did

not keep, which does not. record acts or ‘transactions

ey/

- &

on his- part, a and that the evidence is incompetent, i

irreleyi int, and inimaterial, he arsay as to the de-

fendant, and nO foundation. laid. and not the best’

é evidence. eye ae

?

‘The Court:: The objection will ‘be overguled.

Proceed.” eget eee as

- Mr. Faulkner: Exeeption.: -

- oF

«

= 7

.

. =

a . . 5

.

. '

‘

6

. ° :

4 ‘

‘

‘

ng *

‘

’

. bi

*

. %

2 :

. A 4 ‘

V

: F

fae “

: e

?

© b ~

F

- 7 cms

qn?

e %

-

fe :

a) rae

.

7 .

f

‘ay

‘ Ms ,

-

. Y!

. + .

; .

“3 6 .

*

.

:

:

* .

. N

. id .

2 , .

4 * . .

- ,

s ,

> .

- ‘

. .

°

- .

r .

.

: ; . )

w . >

3 e

Q ’

S

Ls eee F

‘ hd x ry

:

. ;

o

”

» O..--

. ?

.

‘

.

‘ e ‘

=e * . 3

2

5 -

: e

. .

A

. a : e

: .

- = i

% .

®.

7} 4 J

. 2 ; .

. + .j 4

; ‘

. . m

. od es

. c -

: iad

.

4 .

~ @ :

. - :

. . . a

PA

° . a

-

a ‘

{os

.

*

. * » , ;)

A

2 *

aR

ane - ©

2 A .

.

: eas

' : :

, ie

: .

é

zy ba e° e .

. ¥

4 ‘% :

, .

° ; j fs ,

~ .

.

. ° A ;

2 . > E

- . . rf

; ’ 3

rs . e« z

= .

: .

- ay

ps

.

-“

of

vs. United States of America oe “1947,

(Testimoiiy of Wilbur d. Mills.)

Mr. Pratt: ge Will you interpret the record for

‘the ith day of I ‘ebfuary, 1943, as to room. 41?

Mr. Faulkner: :- Your. Honor, 1 do net want to

be objecting all the time, butt here is a bunch of

papers that hi ave not® been offered. in evidenc a

Mr. Pratt: 1 will offer them.,

Mr. ‘Faulkner: Then he wante them interpreted. |

— The Court: Q. What do these records disclose ?

A. Temperature, sir.

The Court: Proceed. . |

| Mr, Pratt: Q. On the 11th day of February->—

Mr. Faulkner:. We object to any testimony in-

_ terpeting a record that is net in evider nee.’ * |

Mr. Pr ait: i will otfer it in e\ ide “11ee ih = a

oe moment, your Honor. ;

Mr. Faulkner: You cant get it in the record or

have vit testified to until it is in evidence. That is

the rule, as I understand. » | |

The Court: W hat is this that the Witness has | in

his’ — [1751] ao |

Mr. Pratt: Q. What-are these papers? _

wor” T emperature records.

ve Q. ‘Temperature records, that. is, records kept.

by your company in the ordinary course. of busi-

“ness? ° “A. That is right. oe

_ Q. Under your supervision? :

A: That is right. |

~ Q.- - Have you ‘the records as to. room 41 for the

©

period from. February | 1th to August: 25th, and -

4

also the vecords Gf ream 62. from Ausast 85th to-

October Mth? ~ A. Ihave:

&

1948 Nye & Nissen ed A» Moncharsh S

(Testimony of Wilbur J. Mills.)-

~Q. Will you produce them all! ? Pe

A: Ihave them all here. eas @

~ Mr. Pratt:. Poffer them in_evidence.

Mr. Faulkner: May Lask the witness a ——

The Court: You mays, . ee ; ae

Mr. iaulkner: Q. “Mr. Mills, these records thi it

you hold in your hand®are records: kept under the

“supervision of your chief engmeer, are: they not? ?

A: They are prepared under his. supervision. :

Q. - In other: words, he isthe man who prepares _—

the records and isin rharge of the temperature, of

: the room, isn’t that correct ?. ee .

A. The records, Mr. Faulkner, are prepared by

ae temperature men under liis supervision,

‘Mr. Faulkner: Allright. I renew the objection,

°.- your Honor 3 crag \ oi ‘

“The Court: Q: Then is this engineer ander your

ee supervision ? ° f \ Yes, sit. | O° |

Q. And where are these doc “uments kept?” De

you keep them, or [1752] does the engineer keep

-them? . “-< : ys i. eee eer ve

A. T hey are. Kept i in the office—under my ‘diree-

tion and in the offices a te Fes tes |

"The Court: Proceed. Let them be admitted and

marked. Rael ,

+

Mr: Faulkner: Exception. :

© Mr. Pratt: I ask that they be marked as one

éxhibit. eae my | ae

: (The ‘documents were ‘thereupon marked .

U. S. Exhibit 133. in. evidence.)

vs. Unite d States of America ~*~ 1949

(Testimony: of Wilbur J. Mills.) ane

Mr. Pratt: “Now, will you interpret the ‘record:

as to the Filth day vf, February, 1945, and, state

What kind of products were in reom>4 i mi evour

Q ; :

plant % P os

A. This. ree cording rec ordss, cheese, apples. pears

and persimmons.

Q. And, how, about the next day, the. Ith?

A. ‘The same ‘items. *~ biota

Q. How about, the next das

‘AL The seme items. ie

* Q. When do’ vou show any eggs ii reom 41 ae-

cording to that record ?

AL That room shows. having heen ‘whitewashed

, ‘on the A4th of February and the ‘commodity is left

blank on the Thth, but it is loading,._v which was eges,

of course.

*@. And when did eggs go into, it, aceording to

that: record 2 eae. Ve “The 15th of Fe bruary.

Q: And what does the record’ disc lose ‘as to thé

contents of the room on the bth of February ?.

A. ‘It is left blank for some reason. :

Q. -And the next day? ~A. Megs.

~Q. And from. that time en to the 25th’ of

August, 1943, what is shown as to. the contents of

the room? ; ae Pa ws

A. It is eggs. | £1753] think. at some port we.

“put Kome milk iv there, but the “re are eges all the

way through. here. . : ai }

Q. I direet your-attention now te room 63. be-

ginning ot, the 2ist of August, 4945.° What was in

i

the.room at (hat time, 622. A. -iggs. =o

1950 ‘ Nye & Nissen and A. Moncharsh a eo

(Testimony of Wilbur J. Mills) ~~

q). And-from that time‘on to the Mth of Ocvober '

are eggs indic ated in reom 63 during that entire

Been “i: fi, They are. |

Q.. Now, the: tempe rature of room. 41. and. the

eipomiene of room 63 are shown on cach of these

days-—- -. ‘A. ‘ That: is correet.

_ Q. For these various times of day.: Four a.m,

+ eight aM, one’ p.m., faur p.n., eight p.m., and

twelve p.ni., is that right? |

7. mae | hat-is right. eg

Q And they are shown opposite the figure in the

left-hand wolunm, the ro6m No, 41? i fit

A. Correef. — Soa ee eae ty Wee

Q. And again of room 63, is that right ?

A. That is right. pees aie

Q. So that the records speak - for themselves so

far as the temperatures at these times are ¢on- |

cerned, is that right? | A. That is right.

-Mr. Pratt: You may CYOSS, examine,

- Cross ; Examination 12 ess “

_ Mr. Faufknei~: Q. Mr, Mills, I show? you this |

top. disk, U. S. Exhibit No. 131, which appears to

“be a record made én Febru: uy 12th.

‘A. That, is right. | |

.@. Nr. Mills, there isn’t Any question that on

that day .orsthat week the. temperature was not

regular in that plant, was it? [1754] : oo

A.. In-the plant? . :

Q. That is, in that particular place, wherever on

that clock. was bet |. Yes sha ere }

[- o : : be Pas

se:

Us. UVrited. States of America 1951

>

(Testimony: of Wilbur z Mills.)

a We were transferring that room at that time.

(). You were whiat ?

A. ‘Transferring that, rdem,

@. How do you inean, transferring that room?

A. Removing one commodity to make room for

another. ! 7

Q. Why was the temperature SU varied ?

A. Doors opéning, and this clock, of course, sits

on a post. I do. not think you would: find quite as

amuch variance. This is only one poimt, in the -roem.

Q. What? |

A. This happens to be only one point we have,

which! Kasei to be on a post: Naturally, the ‘men

—_—————— '

a ene

go eS a ‘Variation in, the tem-

perature. :

Q. In other words,” in a refrige ration plant the ~

frequeney with Ww hich the door is opened will cause

the temperature to vary? o..

A. > If, stuff is being pulled. out and teak stuff

coming en, we would have. a ‘temperature of ap-

proximately. 50 or 60 degrees... That would naturally.

cause your tempcrature to fluctuate.

—Q. Do ee abs of your own knowledge what —

caused the temperature to: fluctuate: the week of

February 12th? eee. tet in and out,

—Q. Were you present at that time?

A. Lawas pt the plant’ ee time.

| Qo Yon saw that londing it and out?

A.. OW yes. [1755] :

~Q. How frequesitly was the door open, Mri er

>

°

. o>

e C2.

——

'.. 1952. Nye & Nissen and. A. M oncharsh :

(‘Testimony of Wilbur J. Mills.) .

ee couliln't tell you that. “Each time a load

. goes in and out it would be apen. eae

Q.° Was it open ten times a day?

a "AL. Oh, yes. .

eee Q. Was it open- twenty times’a day? 5

eae yresume it would be, ves. ™

, ).. How often was the door open in the week

of July 16th? - | ' |

A. Very freqnently, The temperature man, and.

. there might. be, small orders ‘foing | one A reona,

would. be. Ibaded, of course, at that. time, and the”

i only _reason—te oper that ‘dost

— temperature ‘man. or for orders to be withdrawn

Axould | he for the

from that particular room. | - reece

Q. Now, from the period that is reffected in— .

what do yeu call these? ane ye 3 3

A. Those ‘are™ temperature charts, “recording

teniperature charts. fae

. QQ.” In the per riod that. is refle ted in Pheke tem-

-perature charts, apart from the contents of these

- boxes, there isn’t any question: that your company

did ev sensi bi ie. powe r to peserve the te mipera-

ture in that room at or ‘as near as peassible te BD

degrees, is that right ?. _

A. That is rortet. We would naturally hold

thése tempe ratures. “*.. . | 7

zz W hy aN you higld the temperatugys: to

32 degrees, Mr. Mills?

Oe Z. de rrees IS an ace sted tempe ‘rature. for

£

é

onl

Rani |

.-t

: 2

:

”

Dis

4 .

i

:

.

. .

-

>

us. United States uf America. > 1953

A ‘Testimony. of W ilbur J. Mills. ) of

ea: [sin t Oo degrees ali aece Hed Terpe rature for

egg? A. Not for storage [1756] paaed

2. In other words, in vour opinian im the matter

of the re frige ration “of CRES, the accepted tempera,

ture is 32 degrees? A. 30 to B2.; _&

Q. Whi: at: will happe n When the te mperi ature LORS ,

higher than that, Mr. Mills? ;

A. For what period of time, Mr. Faulkner?..——"—_-

er ~

(). For a wee ‘kk. os es

Oa x probably would not, affect’ it A creat Pay

Merchandise, of course, Would not go ip that high.

Q). Suppose | the temperature Avent to 10 de--

re far a week 2

* J can't tell you. ' x neyer had any experience:

of ome kind. © a ste af oF

Q. 1 did not ask yon about your plant. *T am

talking about. what will happen in any re frigeration

plant where temper rature goes high.

ae ee wouldnt know that.

Q. Y ow have never had that experience, is that

it? A: No, sir.

Q. Are you an expert on ‘fefriger ation?

ms | believe T have a “fundamental knowledge -

of it,’ ves. ‘ abs S Ls

e Do gou go further than a frindatne ntal -Know!-

edge? A. Yes. FT do. |

(). Based? por that, in your epini on; the pro) ai

temperature for the presen: ation of eges’ ix 32 de

> grees ? A. 30 to .32 “degrees, fie

Q. And if there is . aniance the pre fe rence: AS... ;

that it he shghtly under, is that it? |

_—

. 1... Nye é Nissen and A. Moncharsh

( ‘Geatinuens of. Wilbur J. Mills.)

A. Will you repeat that question ?

Q. if tliere is a variance, the preferenge is that.

it be just slightly under, isn't that coreret 2.

A. ‘IT wouldn't: go under 30- degrees. [1757

Q: But be’

degrees, the _ variance abowe 34, the preference

would be that it bye, a little under*32 than over 34?

ee ee a

ng in mind a temperature of 32° to

ecient

A. You are talking about a long hold. deal, are

you not? ?

Q.. A long hold deal. oe. ‘Oh, yes.

Q. How long. will it take eges to thaw out that

had been m a temperature of 32 degrees for a

period of 24 hours, 48 hours ?

A. They would not have to he thawed out. 'Phey _

wouldn't be: -frozen.- ;

Q. 1 do not mean thawed out. How long weuld

it take them to aequire a substantially higher tem-

_ perature, stich as the temperature of a room, after

they had been in storage for twenty-four .hours,

forty-eight hours? > * ete, Pa

A. Lam not. quite sure I follow’ that question, I

wish you would repeat it.

Q. In other words, some eggs are placed in your

plant at a temperature of: 32 degrees, — | :

A. Yes. 2

>

Q. Affer they are there for a certain ‘time the

exes » thensselves, are at the same temperature. as

the. room, ‘isn’t that correct?

-A. After they have been there a certain length

of time, that is :eorreet.

vs. l nited States of America , 1955

(‘Testimony of W ilbur J. ies SS eo

GQ. How long: does it. take spon to get th: at oor

perature ?

AL. That depe ia on the amount. of me iniedaaialiae

‘vou are placing ina room, foy imstance, You lod

a complete room with high tenperature merehan-

dise, naturally the amount of temperature necessary

to. remove that heat from that product) varies con |

siderably, SO gl couldn't ere. you a deffnite answer

won that question. he

-Q. Sometimes ‘it. will” acquire the heat of ‘the

chill room. er the refrigeration roonr?

A. It will acquire ‘the wes ech ure.

.Q. The temperature? A. Phat - is correct.

Q. ‘Assuming that they are siaieed and placed, :

we Will say, in this room, how long: would it take

those articles to acquire the — of the

room? |

A. ®What is the Jiobiascnigtne of this room? P

—Q. Well, whatever it may -be. |. ,

A.- It ‘would take about. two’ days, I gather—a

day and a half to two days, probably. You are

talking’ of a case of eggs? : i

Q: Yes. It would take a couple of days?

oe. That is right. . |

>» Q. In respect to-any of the « eggs that went into

this room on the 15th of February, I understood

you to say that those eggs still pr eserved the: chill

from the freight CAR; did I unde rstan@ you to” ‘say

ee oa oy ee

; ie think my testimony at the time,. Ma. Fantk-

ner, was that the eggs were unloaded out of the car

ee ee e

. . «

.

eo

#3

1956 _ Nye & Nissen ana A.M oncharsh ae:

(T estimony of Wilbur J. Mills.) ete |

on the 8th of February, which was the 25 cases. we’

handled, and they were: ‘orde ‘redsinto storage on the ©

afternoon of the 10th of February; "se they - would

-have been out of storage that long at least. . The

eggs which- wer e- delive red to us, that is, ‘the 80 3

cases, of. course, ‘| w ouldw’ t have any backer ound on

‘that. T dé not know how long they had been out |

-of storage.: [1759] | ; ene

ae understood you on your direct examination

4 today to say, that those eges when they went into

\ hot seen.

this chill | ‘Toe 41; would niot have lost the coldness

that resulted froni their bei ing ‘artied in. the rail

road cags?. ~ >. .e 2 rays

‘A. <1 do not hetieve there ° was any ‘question put

to me of that nature. If thier e was, T did not unde Y-

Ra.

stind it nt Way. — | gat

5

*Q. You have ‘some doeuments’ there that | have

one % .

The Court: It is. time, for adjournment. You

-. may examine them during the recess.

a.

Mr. Faulkner: JT have onl) y about two questions

and IT will finish with ie witness. There was. just

one there Sage Fe is \,

a Q.\ You said the eggs Ww ent in on the XL Sth? ~

A. Of February, do you have. refe rence to? \

Q... "Ves, February 5th: 92° 0. 8 \

A. I helieve that is. correct. . \

©

Cin:

La.” Mir. Faulkner: We had hetter take the adjourn-

>

meiit, -hecause there. is-one other [ want to Jook at.

The: Court: ae he jhirans nay gbe ‘e NEUSE: d until

two o'clock. 4 \, “ - -

(A recess was taken until two: 0 ‘clock p- m.)

\

~~ *

e

»

os vs. United States of America "1957.

ABterason Session ‘February 26, 1946, 2:00 p. m.

. The Court: | The jurors are present. You may

“pr oceeds . 3

WILBUg J. MILLS,- + ©

“recalled. he

of =~ Chie Ld -

Cross’ Examination (Resumed)

. : a“

. - Me

Mr. Faulkner: Q. Mer. Mills, |, L. |, think thesé

; cards start on ‘2 ebri vary Otlt—at least, 7 didn’ t tind

“any. earlier ones... 2° (A. Yes, “. @

Si

Q. It appears on this one marked Al, there Was

‘fruit in that. © vA. That is correct. .

“3 contin’ yead, Mr. Mills, - what the fruit

wis? ~° : Serre

a

A. Rooni- 41, on this temperature record; dated

the 9th, which w aS pears, persin umons, cheese and

apparentty eranberries.’

Q. That appears, according, ‘to “this record,

have: been ‘contained in that box. up. to the 15th? _

- A, That is correct. |

Q. | And on the 15th. something happened. in the

box ; a think. ‘vou told 1s the box.was w Sait washed.

A. Of course, the box showed: on the’ Oth ds WAS -

defrosted. We were in the process of preparing for:

the. transfer on tlie 9th. and it oeeurred, T believe-— |

Q. This is the I! ith—that is blank! + |

A. That’ s right; it “shows loading -on the 1 15th.

That is the time. we went into that, room with C2es. °

*

Q.. Pardon me? DcMinfen cg a ere

A. That is the time we went into that, room

with 17260) tig oe ee

ery

1958 Nye & Nissen oul A. Monchdrsh

(‘Tes stimony of W bur J.-Mills. )

_ _Q.. The record shows. the eggs were in the room

on the 36th? a 3 |

A. We know it is the 1 5th here, bec “AUSe” it shews

\ loading here, and it would be Joading of eggs.

Q. os mean, ipegling that rooni? : os

A. Yex sir. : ais fi” >

. Q. What. eggs went into ‘the room, do vou know.?

“A. You mean the lot nuiibers? Be

SS te ve

A.. Well, don't kriow—other pe ae: 3737.

Q.: There is nothing on that récord to show what

lot went. in?

»* : —

‘A. Oh, no, the room, contained up to 5400 eases

- when. it ‘is: filled. That eowldn’t be shown on the m)

record. | : ay . |

Q. In other words; ther would ie mein ak

records ? A: That’s right. .

, Q». What was the: ‘burpaee £% whitewashing thé

POdmaT sss fh Y

4

_ A. We “always, before éges are placed there, the-

“room is completely cleaned, and the walls white- Br

washed, and make it a ‘cleans sanitary room.

. Q. Why do. you do that ? | .

A. If any” possible ‘mold growth would be on a

- wall, we use: whitewash with a copper sulphate solu-

tion to make sure fi room in which eggs are placed

«ty 4

mo

“,

' is free, absolutely, from mold growth, and ina clean ,

condition. )

. A eléan condition also means free of odgrs?

A. Yes, sir. Ait , ae ie

“Q. In other words, it -wouldn’ t be good practice

: e

$8

( Testimony of Wilbur 5. Mills. ) oi ery ey aoe

to put those eggs inte the- storage: with the veze-

‘tables’ or fruits you dese Tibed 2

A.

Terminal Distuilinting Company never stores

fruit with eggs.

Q

“A.

Why? bpicikiaee Ue oe ee hig et

vs

Bee ‘ause of the, dors and contamination that

might result.

Q.

“vegetables will permeate the shell of the ne. arid -

_ Q. In addition to the calcimining ‘of the room—

! is it sodium sulphate you: use ?~ | .

A. Copper. sulphate. ae Rete |

* - -Q. You do something to the floor, du’ vou not? —

A. The floors are merely scr ubbed and cleaiied.

Q. What dé you use on the floors? — |

A. Soap. | Ser ;

Q. Where is the copper sulphate used ?

A. The copper sulphate is used a ‘in the sahi-*

vs. U aited States of America 1959

In other words, the odors from the fruit oe ey

affect. the egg? ae Yes: ee

tion’ of the whitewash.. 3

.Q.

Then, after that has een done, in your’ opi n-.

ion then and only then is the réom, the re frigerating

room, fit for the storage of eggs? ae

A: T hat is correct. ‘ ee eee a re

Q).. Is that. correct ? ;

A.

- Q.

“ > A.

«

Be)

:

S

: .

ah

- Yes, the room has been: ‘elean up, yes”

yee

You mentioned, Mr. Mills, that. at sume time e

gy ot these were transferred. I tried to: find the flate,

but. I have forgotten the date—is August?

-Augnst 25th, | hefieve, we started todransfer

oO

: 1960 | Nue & —— and. A. Moncharsh

(Testimony of Wilbur Jo Mills.) ear get

‘that room. That i is my recollection of the dateinto -

the new ‘room vou. have: re fe ‘rence to?

(). Nes.

A... J believe Aurust o5th, vou will find it. ae 3]

@. Where, were these eggs you put into the—

RaQ . Av 3737,

fe ae W here were those?

A. They would he held in the holding room. ee '

would have a number of rooms and leave’ ‘the eggs,

until we were ready to put the m Into that -room

under refrigeration. 7 i ee oe

@: Now, here is the ¢ard: a Gueust 95th. What

was in the roam on the-25th? A. Eggs.

‘Q. 4Tf A. Eggs; butter and milk.

Qe What was in room’61?

A. I believe- we are talking Abang 63.

QQ. TE mean 63. “oA. Eggs: ee,

Q. Is that the ¢ard that shows the transfer?

Ay. ‘Yes,.it shows the room was in the process of

- being transferred.

Q. How do: you follow, whic h went into which? =.

i A. GE course, there are no lot numbers viven.

T bt hows here *'41 transfe rred.’

agen

Q. All of them? A. The whole room.

Q. That. is wheny ou tr ansferred the entire room

into {oom 632. 2 J _ Yes

-And then on the »

the Rent after’ the transfer, ix that corres 7

hat is correct.

1. YOu still have eggs in

A. Yes, sir; in addition to temperatures, the

Inunidity there is given, but it Shows transfer, still.

Q. ° On. your reogtdl bares: —E xhaat AD, the only.

bea ary

: P 4) cm a alas

vs. United States of America 19612

(Aeatimony of Wilbur J. Mills. ) so

“notation .as to the. loc ality of the lot No. 3737 in so

far as vour record goes, which starts on Pebrnary

8th ang ends on the ith, is « [1764] that wot ‘Fight ?

A, ‘Phat is, correct

, Q.. On what do yéu inks your tater ‘ret that:

the hoxes that were numbe red 3% 34 were transferred

out of 41 into 632 *

A. Because tie “room shows transfer as of

August’ 25th. You see, the marking of the reom

én that ledger sheet Is of -no COTIREQUEH LE to @is.

It doesn’t indicate: in ordinary, events where the

merchandise is placed. Why. that is on them f

cannot fell you. | ae

7. . Tite. only‘ record vou have is a “record | which,

oes room 41° and then.it shews a transfer, ~ Do,

these records - show that ultimately an eggs were,

&

removed from 41? :

_A.. Yes, and if von follow it, vou will find about

" the 28th, I helieve i it is, the room is no longer cooler:

Q. Do vou know thie date when it was finished,

so T wen’t have to. go through all of these?

“-_ 4 thought it was the 28th. IT haven’t all these

dates in mind, but FE believe it-ts indicated, howeve ..

The Court: Step down and show qounses

Mr. Faulkner: Q.@This is the 20th?

oA. All right, the 29th—it is still all right.

Q. The 2 28th shows the eggs are still there ?.

“A. The 28th, ves

Q, The 29th ies they. Are still there?

AX. ‘That's right, the temperatures 2re right on

30) and 31, there. : . |

Vv

.

a.

1962 i N ye Nissen and A. Moncharsh

“(Testimony of W iliur J. Mills.) iA ; ic "|

().. Wkat date is that?

A.~ August 30, : - ©

Q.: What date is that?

A. Between the 3rd and 4th is- when we [1765] |

brought it down. ©: . nae

~Q. In other words, the, transfer a completed

sometime between the 25th and the 4th of Septem-

ber? - A. Yes.” Fre ae. he

Mr. Faulkner: That is all/ Just a moment—

that is all, Mr. Mills. | ines

cy

: ed

G ) WALLACK RYNERSON,

ealled aS +a witness for the Gov ceoneit sworn.

The ¢ Clerk: | Q. W ill you state your name to the m

court and jury ? ie ig tere

-A.- G. Wallace. Rynerson:

| Direct eae 3 eee ae

Mr. Pratt: Q. ‘Mr., Rynerson, where is your

- home? _- A. In Los Angeles. : paee.

(). W hat-is your occupation ? :

A, I-am. inspeetor of the United’ States Food

and: 9 Apapeghigess a

(). hat is of the Department of-——.

A. Tt is under the Federal See “unity -Agency.

- Q. Formerly known as the. Depatpent of Ag-

riculture 2

AL It was known as the De parte nt..of Agr icul-,

» ——

ee a ee

vs. U nited States of A merica °° 1963

é

(‘Testimony of G. W allace Ryne rsbn. )

ture until 1938. ° Tt wai reorganized and ‘placed -

-under the F ea Security Agency. Sie

Q. In your offieia capacity as an mMspector of

the Food and Drug office, do vou have any, oceasion

to exercise any duties. in regard -to eggs?

A. I examine eggs on oce asions.

Q. Do- you recall an oceasion early in November

of 1948 when [1766] you went to the steamship:

William S.C lark in the harbor at Long’ Beach?

A. Xes, 1 recall that,

Q. With whom did you go?

Ad accompanied State Inspector Wirth atid

C ounty Inspector Bradway.

Q. You all went together? A. - Yes.

Q. W hen you got down the re to the ste ‘amship,

‘what did you do? ee ;

A.. We: contacted the stewara and he took us

down. into the. hold and. showed us where a lot t

eges were stored. | We

Q. What did you do then, as far ats those swe re

coneerned ? :

“A. W e candled the- eggs to see what “the condiy

tion was.: Fae wy for

Q. .How many Cases of: segs did you examine

there on the boat? eae . ,

vhs We opened six erates of eggs on the hoat.

Q.. Who. removed the covers of the cases of eggs?

3 JAY Well, all three of. us: worked together—o ie

or the other of us Tre ‘moved the lik. T don't recall.

in each’ particular instince, but there was one of

s

the.three of. us in ereh case.

og

1964 Nye & Nissen and A. Moncharsh

(Testimony of G. Wallace Rynerson:). a 6)

Q. You examined them ong case ata time, Re

assume 2 , A. : That?’s iaie. :

(). And ‘on the. first sae se lid the work dae

eandhng the eggs? a

A. Mr. Bradway -andled- the first case. ,

Q: |How-many eggs of the first . qase did he. :

‘candle ? Re oe

A. It was the entire ¢ase—30. dozen.

Q. “Did you have anything, yourself, to do in the

candhneg lof those’ eggs 2 f |

A. Lobserved the candlifig and checked the eén-.

dition in each case, and nade notes of it. [1767

(). - Did you make notes—4z—. _ . ee

A. Yes, sir. .

of your work in eandling the eggs?

“A. Yes, sir. |

Q. Have you got those notes? ap Yes, sir.

‘Q. Do those notes include the record of eandling

the first case? ne A. Yes.

Q. When did vou make these notes?

Al ‘On November 3; at the time they were——e»

(). At the time the work was being done?

A.” That's right.. = > |

Q. Refreshing your reeallection from your notes,

will yéu state what the result of your « candling Wis;

that Is, whit conclusion. you arrived atin regard to

the eggs in that first case? 0 768]

Mr. Faulkner: May ‘I see the notes, please?

Mr. Pratt: Q. What was the dé ite?

A. Novensber 2. 1943.

Q. Will you answer the question, please?

vs. U nited States of America 1965

of Testimény of G. Wallace, Rynerson.)

Mr. ®aalkner: I object to the Withess answering

, the question ‘because the récord shows he did ‘not

‘andle the eggs. - a ;

The Court: "He was there at the time. —-.

_Mr.. Faulkner: But he merely made rT note of.

- What somedne else told him. ,

Mr. Pratt: No, he said he observed what was |

done and the results of the candling. Rt,

Mr. Fanikner: Mr. Wirth just left: the stand

and said Mr. Bradway candled the eggs.

The Court: Read the’ question, tb:

(Quest ion ead.) -

The Court: * Giieuinn overruled,

Mr. Faulkner: May Lask Mr. Rynerson a eoitple

of questions about these notes ?

The’ Court: Proceed. | ;

“Mr. Faulkner: -Q. Do those notes represent the

observation. of the eggs at the eandling process

made by you? ? a ae .

A. Lactually didn’t handle the eggs: 1 watched

them while they were being candled. |

Q. Did vou watch each egg being Pandled?

A: Yes, sir.

Q. Pardon me? AL Yes, sir. [1769]

Q. Are your, notes kept separately and inde-

pendently from the others? |, fa SeRy BE

° Q. And Mr. Bradway candled. them and: vou’

Watched hiny candle them? . A. Yes.

Mr. Faulkner: W e renew the. objection,

The Court: The obje ction is overruled.

Mr. Faulkner: . Exception.

ee =)

>

1966 | Nye & Nissen and A. Moncharsh

= (Testimony of G. Wallace Rynefon.)

Mr. Pratt; Q.. State the result ‘of your exami-

. nation of the eggs. ae

‘ A. On the first case there were three eandled —

. - eggs ‘out of the thirty doze n: in other words, three

mixed rots.

Q. Go ahead. ,

A. ,On the second case Mr. W ixth did the eand-

jing and. on the other five cases Mr. Wirth did the

e

ef candlinig and I observed the results at the time and

made a note,

@. he cases subseque nt to the first case, only.

half of the eggs in the case were ¢ actually ¢ indie ad,

is that right? cee :

A. Fifteen dozen in each case were candled.

Q. Referring, again, to the first case, have. you

any further: recollection, .refreshing it if need 1 be

from your notes, of the eggs in the first c ase other

than the fact that there were three mixed rots? *

A. ‘Well, the’ only-t thing F could add was that

they did‘ not approach the AA grade.

-Q. What grade were they? Are you able. to

state. what grade they were?

3 A. As far as grading, I am not ‘able to-qualify

“as an expert on gi! rades, although I have a. general

Seti knowledge [1770]. of grades; that is, I

know in. general terms the differetice in air. cell’

space ia a Grade AA, for instance, and a

Grade B. | ; reek

Q. Then, the only thing: vou observed at that

time definitely is the fact ‘that: in this first. case

-. there were three mixed rots, is that right? ~

. mo sa oe, «4 ss

* . é ’ dis . . -

¢ F r

ae piel te ee ‘ F) “)

vs. United States of Amertca .. 1967 ©

(Testimony of Gi Wallaces Rynersen.)

A. That is all f counited.. 20.

ee hat do. vou mean by a mixed rot?

A. It is an ége In which the interior is-all mixed

up and addled: It doesn't have a full volk. Tt has

the appearance of being stirred, up.

cone

3 Q. Now, as to the second Oss, whet i you

find ? E - = Leet

A. In the fifteen doze ne there were six. ade

eggs and nine spot rots;

Mr. -F aulkner : -T understood the witness. to tes-_

tify that in the first case he observed the waren

“and in the seeond case he merely took the results of *

the candling. fe

The Court: Q. “Did you observe the second and

third? : : =i

_A. IT observed the results.”

. Mr. F: aulkper: Q). You observed the doeulia’

_A.~ T observed ‘the egg in each. cane.

“Mr. Pratt: (). And in the second case, vou say,

of the fifteen dozen you say there were six addled

eggs? rae 8 SPs Sante oR ; me

A. There were.six ey eggs and nine “spot

rots. < Pan: : rahe ; seas aoe |

Q. . And nine spot rots? A. Yes, sir.

Q. What are spot rots?

A: That is a type of rot w here the volk Is acitled

and it adhered to the shell of the CEs.

Q ‘On the third CARL what did you “observe ?

A. Three: addled eggs, twenty- -one moldy ‘and ten

- spot rots. [1771]

Q.. And. on the fourth cease? Sa

°

o

1968 — Nye & Nissen and A, Moncharsh

8

(Testimony of G. Paenee Ryne SOD.)

A. Six addled eggs: twe ity nine mole Iv. and tive

Mot rots. . Ta ESE :

oe, And on the fifth ? |

ree. F our ~ addled, one Tr rot, a nd one molded,

(). And on the sixth? are oe

A. Four addled, three ‘spot rots, and one moldy.

Q: Mr. Rynerson, did you observe the markings.

on these eases? - A.- Yes, I did.

:

Se Ee ee erat cia ie acm mane

.

°

Q. “What did you observe in that connection?

A. I made a tracing of matkings. see

- Mr. Faulkner: May I have the book marked for

identilication that the witness just’ used ?

The Court: It may-be admitted and marked. -

(The book was marked Defendants’ A-K for

Adentifies ition, ) rs fo

The, WwW nese: Shall 1 describe the markings? _ ey

Mr, Pratt: -Q.The_paper whic ‘h vou have pro-

a

duced, can you separate it from these other papers 2.

AL Yes, sir. a pes eles,

Q. Do; yeu want to use this 2 JA. X68 OS

(). Are these. tracings” ar just copies of what -

“was on the v various ease ss? |

AL Those are trac ings. a ‘ ,

Q. The top word of this page “Mediuni’ on

“how mame of _the cases: did that word appeat car

you -tell? , .

e's * Frean’t say exactly ee miayay pant of the.

_ cases bore ¢ * Medium” tiarking such as that and

the seer, hore ‘a “Medinm’ ‘markinggtike’ that

(indieating). [1772 es

Us. ede: Statés of A sia 1969 —

seer oF Gi. War Hinvee® Renerson. =

<a sike the Totti ward on thus piper, is that:

vee Oh oan ee enact oN

pa le They werd 2 all anarked ‘*Mediuny’’; some had

; Pies a

one bind and some another. 7 oe

~Q But all were tharked ** Medium’ ¢-

A. That's right. ee .

Q. On chow many of the Cases did that number (©

a ee

3737 appear? 9 A. That was on all CASES,

Q On all cases. Now, the lettermg here, ‘* Nye

& Nissen, Ine. S. F.. Cal. 325," ou how many. cases

did that appear, if you know ?

A. 1 don’t know exaetly; it was on almost all

of the eases. There were a few on whieh it did not

appear. Pa | |

Q. And the size of these markings’ on ‘the case,

was it the same as the size that appears on your,

paper? A. Yes, as nearly as I ean make it:

_, Mr. Pratt: 1 offer this in evidence, if the Court

please, this piece of paper. . -

Mr. Faulkner: Objected to. as ‘incompetent,

irrelevant and immaterial; and it is my understand:

ing all this evidence goes in under the basic objec-

-tion-that we hive addressed to the Court. .

The Court: Tn any event, you have your abjec-

tion in the record, and the olsjectiion is ove rruled.

, Mr. Faulkner: Eowanted it’ clear in the: record

amin your Honer’s rnc, and Mar. Pratt's mind.

The Court: Very well. :

— (The domument wast mmactend U.S. Exhibit

N4 in evidence, } VTS] .

~

Now, Ma. Rynerson, after you had examitied

Y .

1970 Nye & Nissen and A: Moncharsh— -

(Testimony ‘of G. Wallace Rynerson.)

these vases in the mainer that you have deseribed

and miaide this record? of the markings on them,

what did you then dé? : |

A. As far as my own activities were concerned:

-. at the time, I went to the steward and made a copy

of his invoice covering the sliipment of eggs and

obtained from him a statement. to the effect the it

this lot of eggs was covered by that “invoice.

Q. ° Never mind the character of the statement

from him. You madea copy of the invoice, did you?

A; . Yes (handing « doetment to i. Pr ratt ).

A). And w hat else did you do?

A. After obtaining a statement from him, that

‘was all that I did, per sonally, on that day.

q). How long weré you there ‘at the boat?

“A. It was about three hours, [ would ‘say.

Q. What Lae the day was that, Mr. Rv-

nerson ? - Z

A. We gat- there a little hefor'e line h: It would

be about eleven o'clock, 11:30. And. we finished

-. ,up, probably two, two-fhirty—in that neighborhood,

Q. ‘You had lunch on the hoat; did you?

A." Yes, sir. panne oe ease at :

(). “After that, non you ‘had oimiipheind the |

work, there, what did vou do? :

A. Well, I did: nothing more until the next rane

on this particular lot of, eggs. ‘On the 4th in the

afternoon T went tothe premises of Nve & Nissen.

the address was 400, Fast Fourth Place, Los Angeles

arid met Inspector Wirth there, and together we

eatidied ten more half-erates of egus [I774] from

the same--— aaa far ;

Us. United States of Ameri¢a | 1971 |

( Testimony of (i. W iii Rynerson.).

QQ. You ccandled: 10 half- crates?

A. Half of each of ten crates.

OP eS ee a ee

.

: Q. You examined half the, exes in each?

. A. Y CS, si ,. Conee :

“ng Me What was the result of that candlinig? ong

» A. I will have to refer to my notebook on. that.

Lc Well, I have identified as_case 7, which was the es

ae eee ma

\.. next case handled, one mixed rot, one moldy, one ,

: spot rot, one black rot, 84 eggs” grade B, 92 ges

a a

grade ¢ Lie

~ Q.. How did you i determine the grade of those

eggs? Sr eee et Gabe

A. ‘That was detetmined in. conjunction. with

Inspector Wirth. | : | “

Q. Was that his judgment rather thian ye as

to the grade of thosé eggs? :

‘A. The gtade would be his judgment. I would >

— @onfirm it in general terms. As T say, I am not.

qualified to—- 7 Ae

Q. Now, as to the rots

Mr. Faulkner: He had not finished.

Mr. Pratt: Q. Pardon me. Did you finish?

A. ,Not exactly. qualified to distinguish the fine -

points between gr ades, although I can say the best

grade m there was grade B. | .

~ Q. In other words, there were no gr ae AA’s¢

: ie That’ ~ right.

Q. Nor were there any grade A's?

A. Well, | couldn't say- positively on that. T

do not think the re were:

(). * AS to. the appearance ' ‘of rots or other in->

\

\

is

1972. Nye & Nissen and A. Moncharsh. °

(‘Testimony vf Gi. Wallace Rynerson.

edible eggs, wis that. vour Judgment, or. the Judg- . ~~:

ment-of Mr. Wirth? 0 oe |

oe A Dheat [177 5] was the judgment of both of us.

Q. That Was your ewn individual — judgmeé nt,

was it? - °A.' Yes" | . ; Gey 2

Q). ‘That was the first of there: ea ASeS, “(OF you Pall

it: case ‘No. 7. do you? ae ies es. sana ee RS

{).. How about the next ease, No. 82> d te

AL In that case. there were two Mixed rots. ee ae

didn’f make any ‘note of the grades‘ in that one.

Q). How about the next case, the. 9th? F

A. The 9th ease, there was one mixed rot, three

spot rots, one black ret; 65 B’s and 110 C's.

Q. How about @he case No. 102 > \

A. There ‘were three. mixed rots and one moldy.

I do not know the grades in thi it one, ed

Q.. And the case Ne. 11? po

A, “Three: mixed rot, threeéspot rots, 107 Fa) rade

B and 67 grade‘.

' Q. And the 12th ec “ise ?.. = ie

: A. 8 mixed rots, 4 moldy, 3 spot. rots, 64 gr ade.

B's cand 100 grade C's OGG TS ated Dare ery ood

?

Q. Speaking of the moldy eLEs, where Wi as thi at

. mold?

“AL Weil, it. varies trom stall ttkek spats to:

large spots covering the area inside of|the egg. |

Q.. On the what? . - ae eae

A, In each case where it was called: moldy, the:

. mold was on the inside of the cee.

- On the inside of the: shell, is that )

r “ ets ; ~ -

A. \ eS, ; — : . 2 . : >, /

e Coe Geer eee

vs. niled States of America $973

(Testimony of: °G. WwW vilace - ‘Rynerson, )

; — Hew about the thirteenth of these eases?

OAL There were 5 mixed rots, 1 moldy, and 4

spot rots. | : ain i se

~Q. And the fourteenth caset af Sheet ea

ties F mixed rots, S mol Iv, % [1776]. spot rots,

atid 1 black rot; 69 grade B's and 82 vrade C's,

*Q.. And the fifteenth case ? hed el ea eae

. ‘Four nioldy, 9 spot rots. tae eae

And “the sixteenth? Eee oe

i — 21 mix red rots,. z moldy, and 29 spot rots:

37 grade 5, 80) grade | ian et

Q. Is that the last ofthe ¢ ‘ASES you examined on

| that occasion? - A. Yes, sir. r Ne

Q. Mr. Rynerson, in these ten cases were there ras

‘any: grade AA eewet. ¢ 2 “ed et

A. As far as I know, I do not-——= >

Os. W hat is it? Pas ce isa

A. <E would say there were. no grade AA eggs. -

Q: “After you had completed this ‘candling of

eggs om that.oceasion, there at Nye & Nissen’s ware-

house, what did you then de? =

A. Wel, I atte mpte ‘d to trace the lot: beck; to its

origin. I checked the 1 récords at the Terminal Re-.

frigerating Company. T checked the records at

railroad companies, . | on a a ae 8

(. Did-vou eheck any, aaeauie at Nye & Nisse n’s

there at Los Angeles?

7 A. No, i do not

| to cheek. :

().: How tong were Ve

gis that the, V had any records

oie ae Saal

1 there es this Nve & Nissen

warehouse on: that oreaskon ? ss °

1974 Nye a Nisaan and A, Monchar sh

(Te atimony of GW allace Ryngrsoi:)

A. ‘Two or three hours. : _*

- Q. Were these cases that you examine there.

» marked in the same manner that yon have indicated

on this slip of paper, Exhibit 1342,

A. Yes, it was the same lot.. — s

—Q. How many cases “altogether were opened —

while: you were: present on the’ two occasions, both -

at the boat and in the. warehousg? Hae op Ue Oo

Q.. Did you observe the nail holes in the cases |

after the tops had been re moved|t |

" A. Yes, [took note of that. |

“ Q. What did you observe in ‘that connection?

Mr. Faulkner: We object ‘to that as not the best.

Ge evidence, and ¢ alling for the opinion and conclusion

of the witness, not binding upon the defendants.

The Coir: He may state what he: obser ved... The

objection will be overruled. . oe eae

Mr.. Faulkner: Exception. |

A. As-I observed that there were no nail holes

that did not have nails i in them. Z

Mr. Pratt: Q. Is that true of all these cases ?

A. Yes, sir. Mio as amie oe ae.

Mr. Pratt: Cross-examine.

: 7)

Cross- Examination Reg

Mr. -F auliner: Q. May I have your book,

ples we? Mr. Rynerson, on the syd of Ahgust you

went down to this ship with Mr. W irth and another

man and yourself ?

A. On the ord of Noveniber Ta

= . »

vs. U nitied Siates, of America | 1975 ;

_ (Testimony of Gw allace Ryne ‘TSOl. )

Q. What ae On the 3rd af November.

The Court: The 3rd.of November.

-Mr. Faulkner: ‘Phat is,what I said.

Mr. Pratt: YY ou said August. 2

Mr.- Faulkner: a November 3, W943 ¢

A. Yes, sir. : .

‘Q. There were tees of yout

_ A: Yes, sir. [1778]. ;

Q.° ‘The first thing you did was to have luneb

inane “ie 7 sir, we went down and looked at "the bet

ae eggs first. — - Dies P

Wet Ss |

A. -We went dow n and looked at the lot of elu

Pe te . hes .

Q. Then you had lunch? ates _* Yes, sir.

Q. And then you candled seven cases of eggs, or, °

rathei, six cases of eggs on board of the ship?

A. Yes, sir. : |

Q. What fime did you get. through janeli

‘A. Oh, it was possibly: 12:30. ° ;

—-Q. And you. spent from 12:30.to about 3 :30 or

2:309 - A. I think it was more nearly. 2 2:30.

-. Q.’ That you left? the You" /

Q. In connection with ‘the candling of those.

- eggs, what experience had you had, Mr. Rynerson,

in candling eggs” ? r :

&.* ] have hail. oceasion to BX amine Cys or,

rather, | had had © occasion . to, examine eges at

intervals daring ‘the previous two vears In Comnec-

tion with the enforcement of the Federal Food and —

» Drug “et. pa es SC ah tb

or

es) =

» 1976 Nye & Nissen and ALM oncharsh

(‘Testimony of G. Wallace Rynerson.)’ » |

Q. Did vou candle them ? Ae Yess

“Q. How many times did you candle « eps “prior

ie “ko Navember 3, 1943? .

oA. PF eouldn’t say exactly. ‘It is not a continual

job. We do lots of other things hesides candle eggs.

Q. Pardon me? er || bes ee

~AL ‘Tsay we do lots of other things beside candle

Q. Paaion me? eo Sle NS oo °

A. Tsay we do lots’ of other things be sides candle

eges. And 2 < had candied eggs on, oh, tive or six

" occasions. [1779] eat i; is ‘ Bass

| .Q. What is AMAL \.ege? How would you deter-

mine a AA egy in the cohdling light. . |

AS Et would show’ HO defects in the way' of rots

~ and. it would have an aie space of net more than

one- eighth of an inch,

ie ™~y . .

Q. - What air space is involved: In 2 standard

ere? A. LI-don't know it by “that term,

(). Ww hat air space 1s involved | in anegtra erg?

A. f wouldn’ thaow, oS eo

~~

‘Q. What air space in invalved in a special egg ?~

A. wouldn? t -know:* >.’ pat See :

tO. hattair space is involved ina B egg?

. -A.. Let’s see. j | think * Be. of an ineh.

es ‘Q. ‘And aC?

. AL That would be mere than of an ‘indh..

CRS ° P ardon me? ve

A. hat would be: more than 3, ot an inch.

Qo Have vou ever read the. regul: ations. of how to

Pr

eandle PRESS Miro Renersen >

ng,

, Us. t/ nited ‘States of America” 177

(‘Testimony of: G. Wallace Rynergon:)

Ay OL did not know that there Y regulations

on how to candle them.

Q. Llave you read them?

A. 1 slo not know) what regulations: vou sare.

+ referrmg to.. : : : tthe a

Q. Any regulations at. all. Have vou read any,

regulations an how you candle eggs ! ai

A,- Are you referring to Department of Agri-

culture “reg ulations on grades? [have read them,

~Q.. What? - A. I have read the Th.

AQ. Have you read them recently 2,

A. .No, sir. | Py ee |

— What? A. No, sir. [1780] | |

Q. (Qn the: occasion that you were on. this ship,

T unde stand that you observed certain markings on

certain cases, is that correct 2 . +A. Yes, sir.

(). And one of the words yo observed was the

word ‘Medium’? 2 | A. ‘Yes. me 7

Q. And on other cases you observed the: plural,

the word Mediums” t- Ls that correct?

A.” Do’ y you re fer to the tracing? That ‘Ts right.

Q. ds that right ? (ASS. Dee; BRS |

‘Q. You observed on some of. the cases the words, |

“Nye & ‘Nissen, Ine, S.F Cal, 335°...”

A. Yes, sir. ay ee.

Q. — How did thi at appear on the'ease ?

A. It had been placed on with a rubber stamp:

(). ‘Then vou. obse ved the figures ‘'37 377°9

A. . Yes’ ee saree

Q.. ds that correct ? : A; ‘Yes, sir. =:

me

1978 , Nye & Nissen and A, Monéhaysh

(Testimony of G. W a oe ‘rsoni.)

Rote QL. Ind I understand you to say that on 1 most ‘of

the eases °°3787"* appeared 2 ra

Mr. Pratt: All of them.:. nee

. A, All the cases. ox

Mr. Haulkner: Just a moment, if your —

please. 7 Rhee . ‘

Mr, Pratt:, “It eertamly is not a r for eoun-

sel to misquote: the witness. .

‘Mie Faulkner: You may make your objection.

1 thought | had heard the witness correctly.

The Court: . He said you misquoted the witness.

Read the [1781] question and answer, Mr. Reporter.

(Record read. tte - 4

M r, Maulkne rc: ‘Q> On all cases.

A. Yes, sire * | f :

» QQ. When did youamake this mie morandum, here?

.A. What memorandunt are you re ferring to!

Q. With the 87 mediums, Nye & Nissen.

= A. Oh, I madé that ‘the time we were on the:

boat. Pe hee

Q. Onthe beat? 7 AL Yes, sire |

_ Q. That would be November 3, 19438, is that

right? . A. Yes, sir. ae ° * ;

(). But you wrote the date * November 4th

1943" on the memorandum, is- ink Cor reet ! ?

A. Yes. That was a date with whieh our ree

ords were ide ntified covering this particulny exon!

nation. Nosauic ed the examination on the dh,

. « @ .Previeus to the 4th, is that right !

tth and L ideniufied my records w ith thai ea

M :

Bi No, we cainple ted the exam natias ih] thie,

1.

e

vs. United States of America, - 1999

(Testimony of Ci. Wallace -Rynerson.) .

(). Us that your practice to Hark a memorandum

the day after itis made witha date? :

A.” Well, we mark all our records, with the scime

x Rs

| ; date for purposes of ide ntific ation.

Q. But in this instance you remiember that this Re

a particilar paper, which new contains the mark

i U.S. Exhibit. 134, was made on. November 3rd?

| 7 A. Yes, sir. a :

I ~ Q. Now, on November 3rd did you go down inte

a _ the hold of that: ship? A. Yes, sir. ,

I: — Q. Did you examine every ‘ase of eggs in the

4 hold? A. No. [1782] 7

Q. | Later there were how many. cases brought up.

fi on. deck? | eae ;

4 A. Later they were all brought up on deck.

Q. Well, on that day? ~ Ae Yes,- |

Q. Were all the cases brought on deck on that -

ae day—the whole 40 cases jn your presence ?

. | A. Yes, sir, brought. out and put on a tri om

: 2 Q. Pardon me? ? te .

: A.: They were brought out and put on a truck,

; - Q. . Were you there at that time?

: 4 sca A. Yes, sir. goes ee

es Q. Who else was there at that time? |

4 “A: Inspector Wirth, Inspector Bradway, and |

3. the shipping ee | | 7

4 Q). What time did that oceur? a) ae y

ie Ay That was about two-thirty ov three o’clock.

ie : Q.. At-that tine, when Mr. Bradway was-catidl

4 ing eggs, how long did it take him to eandle 360

egus i the first case?

Se ee ae a

1980 Nye & Nissen and A, M oncharsh

(Teaimony of ty. Wallace Rvinerson.}-

A. I don"t know. It didn't take, very lone.

Q. Pardon me?- a. |

A. T don’t know. It doesn'tytake very lone.

— Qe Tn other words, the matter of candine is‘

very rapid, is it not?.. — - A. ht woes pretty fast.

@. Pardon me? - A. It goes ae ‘fast.

Q. How many eggs were: handled 1 1 his hands

Ata time, both ands ?.

‘A. He usually -handied tyo ata time, T believe.

Q. 7 Two in the right and two in the. left?-

A, | Yes. oe . | ;

Q. Now, late T, after Mr. Bradway had fintshed

eandling the eke Mr. Wirth took over the candling,

isn't that correct ? A." Yes. [1783]

Q. Did he eandlé pretty. fast? A. Yes.

Q. Tell me just what you.saw Mt. Bradway do .

in réspect to candling those éges.

A. Held the eggs up before the light. —

You mean the candle light? ot

That is Tight. |

And whe re was it?

,

it was on a table in the valley Way,

ote ae

W here we re Vou When, he Yas doing. thant ?

A. [was right behind him. ¥

Q. You weregbehind Mr. Bradway?

A yen. ar *: a oe

“0; Did vor abseryve ench eee im the ight?

\. Yes:

Did vou form a eonelusion as te the quia

“of each egg as Ho passed threugh the lehs

9 . )

A:~ Yes, as far asthe rots are concerned,

Ps

us. United States of America - 1981

ryy . 3 , rr ’ : @

( Pestimouy ot Wallace Rynerson. ¥

(). Ii other words, the only part of this meme

ragdun relating to the eggs concerning whieh Vou.

haye made.a note thatcin reality ts a note of your

owh-opinion, are the Hotes in relation to the black

rots, is that right? | |

AL Tn relation to all rots. ee

QQ. And the other rots a per eae

Q., That-is the inferior eggs, Is that right?

A. Yes. toca. | |

Q. And the notes in vespect to the grade DB and

C throughout this memorandum do not refleet an

opinion of vou, is that correct 2 2 |

-A. As far as my opinion eves, | won ud hold to If.

Q. You what? ; . rae

A. For what my opinion is worth, | would hold

to that grading. ie toes ae

Mr. Faulkner: © 1 do not follow. the witness,

The Court: Read the answer Me Reperter. —

"(Answer read.) _ »

-

Mr. Ranikner: Q. Mr. Rynerson, did vou make

ra record as this pragressed ?. A. -Yes.

Q. . Isn't this what vou did, Mr. Rynérson: After

the ‘things was completed, Mi. Bradway and Mr. |

Wirth, on the first case, counted the mumber of ees

in ae particular’ position on the box and told vok

~that those eggs were grade B's, and: then counted

cd

the number of eggs an anothe: position. an a crate

or a filler and eave vou the number of grade C's

aud Vou put it in a hook, isn't that right 2:

A. When we were on the boat I made: ne note

of the grades atall ° ®

1982 :

e ‘ ™~

eo

Nye & Nissen and A. Moncharsh

(Testimony of G. Wallace Rynerson. )

().

A.

().

other

You made no note of the grades on the boat ?

No. | |

Where is the nofe about the grading of. the

teu cases? Is that im that book?” May L ask |

you: this,.Mr. Rynerson: Are there any other egg

grading operations of yours — in this book ¢

“ — down.

Q.,

No, I do not think so. Purn it over, That is °

Now, you prepa d a column here, case, = AF

and age is at the top of the column ‘in your ;

book ?

A.

rots,

Q.

A.

Q.

A.

1 have a notation of the case number, mixed

moldy, spot, black, and B’s.

| And B ‘st _ A. Yes.

Have you any: C's?

The C’s were the balance of the——

‘The balance were the C’s, is that it?

Yes,

©

“And you sropared that as this oper ation: of

_candiling those [1785] ten ca ses was in progress?

Yes, sir. °

Is that correct?

The actual writing was done by another

‘inspec tor who was with me.

instance Was to-make a heading for the column, is

W ho? é

Inspector Price, who accompanied me. |

Which is your handwr ‘iting, and which ts his?

My handwriting is in the blac k peneil,

So that the only writing that vou did in this

vs. United States of America — 1983,

(Testimony of G. Wallace Rytierson.) ;

* that right, aid you have -some figures here: 92,

2084, M102, 693,"" is that rghit :

A. "Wh: aut WwW as that?

(Q). The he ading is im pencil? | ae fone

Q. The figure "7" is in peneil 2 A. Yes, )

QM. And you have those figures that | qjaist’ read

off to you in penc ‘il, and that is all the writing. on...

that page that is in vour hand writing?

A. No, sir, 1 didnt notice the figures correctly,

Q. 92084,° 11. 52-“maybe that iss—vou real what.

is in your handwriting on, that page.

AL 92 C, 84 B, 110-C, 65 B.

Q. In other words, the only writing you made

? on the ty tr, ransaction relating to the 10 cases is eges,

Medium, **M” , “Spots,” “ Bik."* “B's,” and then

the “92 C84 B, 110 ©," and ‘+65 By and the one

. figure 7" ? Is that right? aay. "Far, f. Maire is +

: - Q. How did you come to put those figures down?

: A. L put the: hee adding: on there and Inspector

a Price wrote the amount down as they were called

. off. [1786] . te ie PL eee

‘ eee * He wrote the amount down. as they. were

i called off by whom? .

: : A. Inspector Wirth and myself. |

a ‘a’ Q. Did you observe Thspectar: WV irth candle each

: o ‘of thesg cases? 1 A ey aa et ene

2 Q. Did vomstand behind him?

: A. We we re working side’ by side.

Q. W hat? ae :

A. We were working side by side. a

“Q. Who wasdoing the candling ? :

’

-

«

- -

9

4

1984 | Nye & Nissen and Al M oncharsh

(Testimony: of G. Wallace Rynerson. )

OAL We were candling at the same time,

Q. Were vow eaindling eges ? AL Yes.

QQ. Pardon me?. a * Yes,

Q. flow many Grade B- egys did you i candle ne

the ape ration involving ten cases? *,

a4 did't count the grade B's iM ‘the « ‘ases that

Teandled. pees! i os

Q. What?-. ; o

re AT didn't count the arade: x's or C’s it} the

cases that L candled. “het

Q> What did. you ‘do with the cues after you

‘andled them ? | ee

“Ay I would-set the rots to one side and place —

the good ones back in-the crate: °

2 Q. Then what was done with the balance of the

eggs that you candled. A. W hat balance?

Q. Well, you took some eges, you took some

rots, spots, Sal moldy CES out ; What" did vou do.

With the other eggs? pit

A. Placed'them back in the case,

Q.. Then what happened to them? —

A. Weill, call I know from then on is he: arsay.

(). ay hat 2 2.

“AL AIT know from the re on Is hearsay: LE know

wh: it happened to them,

Q. Did Mr.: Wirth recaudle the eges that vot

jhad candled? A. No. ¢

A). Lhe did net? | A. No.

(). Did Mr. Price? A. Ne.

“Q Or Mr. Bradway ? 3

A. Mr. Bradway Wasn't ranean

QQ. He wasn't there. Now, how. many eases of

t's. United States of America — 1985

(Testimony of i, Wallace Rynerson.) -

eges did vou handle on this day?) A. Save

Q. Four, So that four of the’ cases of eges Were.

ungraded as to quality, is that cor reet 2 Four of the

@

ten cases were ungraded as to quality : 7

A. So farnias 1 know we did not grade them.

Q. What? - aie

A.- So far as | know : we didn’t grade them.

QQ. Now, on tye Sth case, that record vou made

-at the time of the transaction, or Ht Was made unde Yr

yotn direction, was it? -- A; Yes, Si.

* Q. Tt was made jointly “by -you “and ‘a. maaan, in

vour department ? ‘A; Yes, sir. 4 a

Q. - What was the purpose of the ee ? Ww hit

was the purpose of the record ?

“A. So we would knew later what transpired.

Q: Pardon me.? :

A. So we would he, able to: know later. whi ut ‘ ad

transpired, Ly J

Q. hi othe y words, the purpose: was te have a

‘record to show what transpired Later, is. that right ?

A. > That is right. [175s] ‘ {

().. In that record you set up a method of de to r-

mining “whether there wert any ovade 15 eees, Is

that right? You pre pared a chi ut with a scheme to

‘show whether there were any ¢ rade Bb eggs?

1. we See tae ee

Q. Did you pre Hare the hart before you started

the candling ? . A. Yes. :

Y. Why didn't veu prepare a chart to show AA,

A, Hand C egys? | ; )

:ae We knew fram looking at the first SIX x@that

the ‘re Weren't any of that grade.

“a

‘ 1986 Nye dé Nissen and A. Moncharsh

. (Testimony of -G. Watlace Rinerson.).

“QQ. What?

A. We knew from looking at the, lirst six that

there werent any of that grade, —

Q. You knew there weren't any of that grade ?-

A. They had not been: encountered m the first

Six Cases. | ae

—Q. How tid you know that ¥’

A. That was from Inspec tox w irth’s statemetit.

Q. It was. quite apparent to you, even with, your’

limited experience, that these were eggs which were:

in the. process of deterioration, was it not?

A. Yes. _ 7 Seo aa

Q.° So you assumed when you prepared ‘your

‘chart on the 4th that there would be no AA eggs,

no 4 ‘eggs, ‘and you prepared | a chart with, a letter

“B,’* is that. right? oe gt

A. Thatisright. a

Q.. And then you made no notations whatever -°

of any B eggs in that ‘column, is that right?

“A. No, that is not right.

Q. Is that yight? :

| ey here As a notation Of the B eggs 11. in

cases that Inspector Wirth candied. [1789]:

”

Q. Have you any notation of the B eges in your

memorandum? aes eee |

A. It is rteht here (indicating).: ~ . -

~Q.. What thave.vou_got under the column *B'?

‘A. In case: No. 7 there was a total. of 84 B's, -

Case - No. 9 there W: as a total of 69 B's, case No. 11

107 1s" s, Case 12 b4 B's, 14 69 B's, case 16 37 B's

2 WW hat were, in é other cases that‘ you did

.

ee eee oor

.

Us, United States of America Le oe 1987

( ‘Testimony of i. Wallace Ryne ‘rsomy

~ not call? Were there ne B eggs In the. cases vou

did not mention ?

i I didn’t make aiy note of? it.

Q. In other words, vou had places the re of eases

of eggs. that vou were. creating a reeord for to

show what happened in whie h the quality of the

ege’s is not noted, isn't th: it correct ? ?

A. It was not noted. © See ee ‘

Q. It was not noted? neh

A. Not in writing. ae

-Q. What? - A. Not in writing. .

~Q. Well. it was ‘net noted in your book ?

- AD No. - mene |

‘Q: At‘all, was it?..°, A. No.

Q. Those are. the cases you looked ’ ‘at? ?

_A.. That is right.

Q. . Now, the real purpose of ‘this entire. inspec-:

tion by you and Mr. Wirth and everybody else was.

- to remove the inedible egs out of those eases, wasn’t

it ? ees

A. No, PE wouldn’t say that. It was to determine

how many inedible eggs. there were in. there.

Q). Yes, and to remove or case them to be re-

moved, or direct that they be removed?)

A. Tnispector. Wirth did that. —

Q. What?: “ : ae

A. Inspector Wirth ‘ditected that they he. re- |

moved, | | as : a,

4). This candling was done in the firm of Nve

& Nissen 2° A. Yes. aes, Se ae =

- Q. Reece is, of the 1 10 cases ? ‘A. Yes.

. ane os N ye ‘ad Nisse n and A, Monicharsh

(Testimony’ of G. W allace Ryvnerson, )

QL Am T corréet in that? + Ay Yes.

os What is this on the it page? ne

“AL That is a continuation of the first page,

Q. W hile you were eandling these eggs, these.

—

four cases; was Mr. Wirth eenenne the other six?)

Sd Ne, Foss

A. —— es, . ! 2 > , : :

CG. You had not, at the dae you were doawwn there

1 ‘November, reached that stage’ of profficiency -

where you could be eandling four “aSeS of eggs and

observe Mr. Wirth’s opel ration. at: the same_ time,

had you?

A. Well, ey set wat the rotten .eggs and we.

checked them. . aC. ; :

Q W hat?

A. He w ould set out the aren eges at met time .

and we w ould check them together.

Q. Did you stand back of Mr. Wirth’s shoulder .

and w vatch’ him candle stx cases of eggs and-at the

saine time candle four cases of eggs, yourself?

“the quality of a Single: egg candled by Mr. Wirth

from personal obseryation, have.vou ?

“A. Twas standing beside him, adjac ent.

Q. You were watching the eg gs in your four.

cases and he was looking at the eges in six, is that

right? .. A.. Yes, sir.

Q. ‘And you have no knowledge, whate ver, as to

>

A. T wouldn't say that. [1791] |

Q. What? ©. A..1 wouldn't: ‘sav that.

Q). How many of the six cases. did you observe —

Mr. W irth classify asa Begg? .

A. 1 couldn't say on the Bis.

~

i LD aes a States of Amer rica. oS 1989

Mestimoniy of GOW addin we Rynerson: 7 \

Q). On the -¢ & 1 Pee > : a

a L coulk bt t say that. [| saw most of the mn We Ne :

Bes or C'S. which avere not rots.,

Qe What?

A. I saw most of them were B’s and C's < that.

were not rots, 2 aya .

Q. How conld you do that if-he was. eandling

six cases at fhe sane time you were candling four?

A. I could glance over that.

Q. WwW hat“ ?

A. It-was easy to clance oxer there\.

Mr. F aulkner: May T have the answe¥svead?

‘ (Answer reads}

Mr. Faulkner: Q. In other words, von

results, didn’t you, of the manner in _ whie h he

plae ‘od them i In a case after he was through eandling |

them, isn’t that right ? ‘pied . 2

A

A. Well, whenever he encountered a rotten ege.

he showed it to ee = ee

Q.. The only ‘eges you saw, then, were the rotten

-_ isn’t that correct, before the ¢ anidle light?

1 saw some, of the athers, too.«

= Well, that is what I do not unde “stand, How

many ‘candles did ven brave? . AL Pwo.

(). You steod at one candle and candled four

cases of. eges, isn't that right?’ 7

A. That is right, [1792] - a

@. And at the same time he. Was at. another

candle candbin v six eases of eges,-is that. correct ?

A. .Yes.

saw’ the

'

v-

1990 “Nye Nissen and A. Moncharsh —

(‘Testimony of G. Ww allate Rynerson,)

. Q. What T want to know is, how. you could: sre

the eggs he was candling before the candle light ?

, ae W olf, he wasn't so far away from me. Is

wasn't so far to look. |

Q, So you saw every egg that you candled, your-

self, and every, egg that Mr. Ww ith ea; dled?

A. | wouldn't say I saw every ove that. he ©

eandled. J saw all the rots he candled and I saw.

most of the. others.

‘QQ. You saw most of the others, is that right?

A. ¥ es, sir. Se

aay Now, of the ten. cases that were: \ dpnilled. you. -

candied a half ease to each ease, is that right!

; A. Y es, ;

a Q. So that ore ® were 15, 000 eges or, Yate 1500 ¢

\ -eandled, ‘is that right? A, 1500. ¢

\ Q. All together, isn’t that*correct?

N\A. : No, it would be 150. dozen. ..

“QW Oh, .a good many more eggs. In other words,

there were 1500 ‘dozen cases of eggs: examined, is

that right? » & No.

Q. Tiere were 15 dozen toa case, is that right 2 ?

A.” Yes:\

Q. And there were - 10 cases?

A. Yes, sir; . Tie

Q. That: is 150 Ment" A Yes.

Qa. I am right ‘that far, am 12 same Yes. >.

Q). And there are 1 eges to a dozen ?-

FA, “Yes, sir. Nic Feet |

Pha ( ‘ourt: If would be well for you to observe -

: q ; |

the clock now. Itvis time for recess, [1793]

\

ws. United States ‘of America . 1991

(Festimeny of Gi. Wallace Rynerson.)

Mr. Faukner: Q. There were. in exéess of 1500

CLES examined; ani] coreet in that? -

"A. 1 believe that is right. Ay Ace

Q. And you éxamined 600 of thon. four cases?

A., Four: times——

Q. [mean you examined about 600?

A. 48 times. 15, whatever that. is. |

Q.- You examined about 600 eggs, didn't yon?

A. Yes, that is about right:

Q. And while you were examining them: you also

obseryéd “approximately ‘900 eggs that Mr. Wirth

was examining before the eandle, am I correct? |

A. T wouldn't state any specific number that 1

saw him eandle, hut. LT saw all ‘thie rots that he

candled, — Bary es “

Q. You: testified hee you knew What a mouldy

egg. was. - In respect to the 10 vases on the, 4th. of

~~ November and the 6 cases on the 3rd, did. you se re

= any eggs at alk out of the 20 eases of eges—I16 cases

of eggs—that had tnould on the outside? , Soe

A. Well, I don’ ‘t recalh. We did not make parti--

ilar note of mould on the ontiide tnless there Was |

mould on the inside as We |

~ Q, Ww hat is your best rebolicheit of the external -

appearance e of these’ eggs? | Were they mouldy on

tlie outside, or not?

me 5 think 0 i the last Case Che-were some eggs. :

that were moulfty on 74 Ree but | dé net know

how many. |. ee eis

Q. The last; ease} You: mean the last cease lon

November ith? . A. ‘Yes. .

2

+ ae : o

et j 4 as

“$1902 |. Nye € Nissen and As. Moncharsh

pen

Be iy st itty of a. Ww ‘ill ie Rynerson, )

me 7: J Is th ut thi only’ FASE that vou Yenc mabe . any:

3 egys that, hac [17 4] mould on the outside? | 7

SA Ves: ~My recollection is hot definite on that. ;

AS Wie did yet make particular nete. of the mould On.

: the outside inilgss the ‘Te was mould on the Inside.

-Q.: Now, “on the. boat id) yous examine the 6

| CASE s the se Did you examine the OXte nal appear-_- 7

cit ey eges, the six ¢ ases on the boat ? eo

5

| 6° And: did any of them have anv mold-on the

‘ ; Se : an Sins : . 4 . breathe led

f outside ? “gn ee Sere

As I do nist ‘ree all: that ‘they 3 did:

Qe oW hen mold i is on the. inside: how is it observ:

Sable : at’ the: ( andle light? tf A ee ae ‘

ae Is shows up.as a black” Spot. Sa POLE TA SS

#2 Q). How does the Dlack- “spot appear ufder the

a candle light? -. WA. .A black pots;

— 2. es. . ae You mean a black rot?

Q.* Yes. 2 ae

ap Faas Has a wide Whack are ur ACE,

ewe

ee It has” a wide liek appearatie e. The’ diffe ‘y-

enet isa moldy - egg, a dpatndhioriix. to ‘the shell,

: whe re as in- a blac k rot it extends inte the: volk.

ee. The. lac k vot extends into the yolk?

Q.. W es iS “the block. spi that yeu Wor to?

ME z re. does that appe: ar? :

oft would he on the inne r surfec 10 of. the she M.

About what size. is it? -

.

/

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.