Brief for the Petitioner — Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board
Supreme Court brief1949
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
LIBRARY —
SUPREME COURT.US ©
INTHE
Supreme Court ‘of> the. United States
Ocroser Term 1948
“* : No. 387
- 6
” ° -r .
TRANSCONTINENTAL & WESTERN’ AIR; INC,
Petitioner,
a
CIVIL AERONAU TICS BOARD,
Ow. Wait or Certrionaki tro THE Unrrep States Court
or ApreaLs FoR FHE District or CoLUMBIA
"BRIEF FOR THE PETITIONER
« ‘ OP, .
. Geravp B. Broprry,
Attorney for Petitioner.
' (CHarLes Piekert,
Josern S. leeman,
of Counsel
Respondent. ae
INDEX.
i. P
? PAGE
Opinions Below ....0....6000...06. SOROS reer
eee CET RS PEER T CLS Ay SNe ei
Statement of the Case . : eucawes us sesecceacss re = Sivsecsn ' @
Specification of Errors pele ieee ie hese eradhcr nasa Ses
; Summary ‘of Argument seas eee? pe oe Pree oe i
Point I. .The Act clearly delegates to the Board the power w hich | |
has been held non-existent ..-@p-.--+ +--+. +5 +0-- ba aaens ales ‘11
Point II. The Court of hemeska” relied on, an inapplicable
presumption against *trospective oe settee eee
Pont III. The cola Appeals —— on a false analogy to.
public utility ‘Tate statutes ........5. eee eee eidesewsenas
-Point 1V. The Act ‘inne dhateves restrictions may have
ee
existed under earlier mail pay statutes .....6....... eee
A. Mail pay prior to the Railway Mail Pay Act of tof.
The Railway. Mail Pay Act of OE oi hoc cde an cexs
C. The Air Mail Acts of 1934 and 1935. Peer T Fa a
ant
D. The changes made by the Civil Accousestics | OCTET
E. The‘ ‘Legislative History” of Section, 406 (a) ( RD éevasa »
Point. V. The decision below thwarts the basic policies of. the
Act and defeats the. airlines’ constitutional right to just com-
"pensation ee €60600600808662080'8 © Me pe enter ee made eelsseescees
‘CONCLUSION . ta Hees Reece Lene des mimes feo ee eee ee see eeeeee
Arrenpix A—The Board has often fixed rates Basi ged
as of a date prior to the institution of a rate proceeding .
A. The new route cases .......0.... aaa Spies g pre career
B. The “nune pro tune” petition device ......... \icahaae
C. Retrospective “reopening” of “final” rate orders ........
.
J ay .
ae
a . ¢ ) a
tsi \ i we
v as °
ii
‘ PAGE
D. The “system” cases ....... Melaens Hea pas ree
erie, Mor i eae ee
E. ‘Significance of the: Board's action ... Nar “SEEpEN Da 96
‘Supplement to Appendix A—Civil ediaiiseillca Board's Memo-
‘anda of “May 22 and June PE CEe Sep rrer ry ass. 798
Appr NDLX BARelev ant statutory provisions Be ee ee 81-123 |
: TABLE OF CASES CITED*: ,*
“Addison v. Holly Hill Fruit Products, Inc., ae ‘U. S..607, 88
L: Ed. 488; 64 S. Ct. 1215 «..2.....;... Soins heehee eee aes 62
Air Mail Compensation, 206.1. C.C. "pp ve... 21,'53,. 55, 58.
* Air Mail Compensation, 216 1. C. C.. 366... . gees. . 6 5 387, 65, 69
Air .Mail Compensation, 222 I. C. €. 602 .0...... BY, 56, 57, 58, G6.
Air Mail Compensation, 232 1. C. C. 608 ........ ph paneweat 58, 66
Air Mail.Rates for American Airlines, Inc., 2251. C..C. 12 . cy aa
‘Air Mait Rates for Braniff Airways, Inc., 226 . oS tees: 57
Air Mail Rates for Route No; 2, 231 1. C. C.. gor conkaats Aes ° 56, 5?
~ Air Mail Rates fof Route No., 62291. C. C. 88% 2.0.0... 000. 58
Air Mail Rates for Route No. 8, 227, 1.-C. Cc. pry inhi Pe
Air Mail Rates for ‘Route No. 13, 231 1.C. C. 673 2.00... . ei
Air Mail Rates for Route No: 26, 22% Rg@® ©. B78. Me cee en 57
’ Air Mail Rates for Route No. 29, 229 1. Ct oe Deke ere ny
Air Mail’Rates for Route No. 31, 214 Can Ca Me cays dee kane 5b
Air Mail Rate for Route No. 33, 216 F.C, C, 381. ....56,66,69 >
Alaska. Airlines. :Inc., Mail Rates, Order No. E- 1665, June 4, '
th Cae Ee Sra rete Eaters Cr ee a Aura mt Mair ap rere a aan 43
Alaska Airlines; Inc., Mail Rates, Order No, E; 1885, ‘Aug. 13,
BOGS. sce ness PEPE eee COT eS cr Seah heck tes e an ae den 86
> All American Aviation, | Inc., i Mai Rate for. Route No: ih 3
tee ee a tee eA alae he ee cn ee ae | ee
All American Aviation, ra “Nail Rate for Route No. 4, "pate
as ee ew Lees VA CaKaei aera Leeee pecan enn 22,41 ©
| Allman v. United States, 131 ws 5. 31; 33 L. Eu. 51, 9S a. Ae 632. 33.2.
lent
Alvord vy. United States, 95 -U. S. 356, : 24:L. Ed. 414 2.......6. $6
American Airlines, . Inc.—Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 C, -A. -B: pre
ee Wine tks nase see oes 27, 38, 39, 51, 58-59, 61,-76, 79, 83
American ‘Airlines; Inc.*Mail Rate Proceeding, 3-C..A. B. 770. ts
American Airlines, Inc. et al., Mail Rates, 4 C.A. B. 90 temas 1, 1
*“Full citations for .decisions ‘ot the Supreme Court of mh \United ‘States
appear in this table; in the body of the brief - references ak given only.
_ to the United States ——- ope ay
ee | sae : aN ‘¥
are . af
“8:
. : : F | z ij :
$52. PAGE 7
- American Airlinés, ake Mail Rates, 6-C. A. B. 564» re nt
- American . Airlines, Inc., Mail Rates, ‘Order Nv. 1351, April 7%~
4 ae ore asco B ae SERA eT RE ae 21
a ~ American Export ‘Kvloces, Ihc.—Certificate of Public Con- rd
.. .- ‘venience and Nesessity, 2.C.°A. B. 16.0 06.......... cece 37. Of
Amtrican President Lines, Ltd., et al. Petitions 7'C. A: B. 799. . 39 \e
- American Smelting & Refining Co. v. United States, 259 U. S.-
> YB, 46. Li- Ed: 883,42 .S. Ct. 420: 2... ec ecec ieee nse eas : nae
Ses . American Stevedores, Inc. Vv. Porello, 330. oe 446, i, Et * 2
133,67 S. Ct. 847°...... eae ees Age wr ee 1) ei
«Anderson National Bank v. Luckett 321 U. S. 233, 88 L. Ee. ee
Pe MN RR er ee was Be.
Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe. Ry. Co. v. U. +» 225 U, - G40, 56
| L. Ed. 1236, 32 S$. Ct. 702 rae vue PS POE Pee Tee 1
{a Bankers’ Mutual. Casualty Co. v. Minnéapolis; St. Paul & S:
"am "SM, Ry. Co., 117 Fed. STEN OD ois cick cce ss 2 30
Bs _ The Bayonne, 159 U. S. 687, 40 L. Ed. 306, 16S. Ct. 185 ...0.. 88
3 ’ Beaver’ Valley Water To. v. Driscoll, 28. F. Supp. ages . 35
Board = Public Utility Commissioners v. New York Telephone —.
; - Go, iF U.S. 23, 70 L., Ed. 308, .46°S. Ct. 363 ... 0.055. Ym | at tad
A _Boatinien’ s Banke. Atchison, Topeka &. Santa Fe Ry. Co., 2-F...- *
GO) SEU AR as fe sacs, 88
‘ Boston-Maine’ Airways, Inc. Base Rate Mileage, 229 I. Cc. C. 343 57 -
Boutell y. Walling, 327 U. S. 463, 90 L.. Ed. 786, 66 S. Ct. 631.. 97
’ Bowles v. Willingham, 321 U.S. 503, 88 L. Ed: 892, 64 . Ct.
Ws Saker dk hob cab REV Aa KE RORRE SAAS AD eS AOE ee |
_ Bragg v. Weaver, 251 U. S. 5%, 64 L. Fd. 135; 40 S: Ct, 62 82
5B Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail’ Rates for Routes Nos. 9, 15 and 50, :
* ee Oe re isa oe ae . 22
a ‘Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail Rates, Order No. E- 966, ‘Nov. eres
i es Ma es is ae ee rs a 86
'; . Braniff Airways, Inc., * Mail. Rates, Order No.. E: 2129, Oct.. 28,
Bre Serene Pirenaor eer er oe ae
Brewst®r y. Gage, 880 U 5. 337 74 Aas 45%, 50 S.Ct. 115. oe :
Burrill v. Locomobilh , 258 U. S. 34, 66-L. Ed. “450, 42S
j . m3 256 ....... ce eS ig pee n ted yeas C444 14 SRDS Ob Oa 82
ee * Capital Airlines, tic: v. c ivil Aeronautics Board (Court ‘of oe es
4 * peals, D. C., Docket ee CSE pee ee eae ae
Caribbean- Atlantic. Airlines, Inc., Mail Rates, 6C. A. B. 407.... 85°":
Caribbean-Atlantic Airlines, Inc, Mail Rate, 7 C. A. B, O43, 23, 41.
—— Milwaukee & St. Paul Ry. Co. v. United States, 104
VS. OR, 96-Le BM BOB Foo os ccs yeni pce ceks. coed, 48
e } ae
. Kb : "|. RAGE
Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Ry. Co. v. U.S. 198 U.S. 385, 8
SD idc. TOG ROUGE, BG... Ch. GOR sia cca cancecécrasss ; : ol 47
Chicago & Northwestern Ry. Co. ¥ United States, 104. U.
SG A Ba Se UE Kin eda ncceanececnaiar as etapwedy “1a, 48"
Chicago & Southérn Air Lines, Inc. oo Mail Rares Xor Routes+
eR OT ag ES RP Ey paren Oey eo - 59.
Chicago “& Southern Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, Order No. * ;
Rit ORO soc cvcrcddkescincv ihe deeasuekusi ae
Chicago & Southern sAir Lines, ‘Inc., Mail Rates, Order. No.
nee Be 7) 0. n son ShocaukeanaReteen scenes 85 —
*-CIncage & Southern Airlines,’ inc., Order No. om 182: 5, duly 28 3
RO Aaah bas ehh Pane es oc Ons gannteadss el conuees s 29, 45
Chicago.& Southern Air Foe, ‘Inc. Rate Reviews, 223 I. C. C.
BE Sotuanacde WSs ba RCRA be ON eK ak eae ete tees pee Sea}
Chicago & Sou — Air Lines, Ine. -v. Waternian Steamship *
* ‘Corp., 333 U.$..103, 68 S. Ct. 431° ea etblewewanenes keene dt.
Chorpenning v. U nited States, 94 we . 397,°24. L. Ed. 126... 13 -
Colonial Airlines, Inc., Mail Rate, 7 ¢. A.B. 415 a ee
Colonial Airlines, Inc., 7 C. A. B. ORG Spina ken eee ac ow ous nets 95 D s
- Colonial ‘Airlines, Inc., Bermuda Servi ices Mail Rate, Order No. --. \
E-1153, Jan. 26, 1948 ....... SO ST PTE aE EOE LP RE 86
’ Colonial Airlines, Inc:, Mail Rates, Order No. E-12 63, March
By TOURS ce usuwensetavakdvegevacsy: leectit chcel ink os 95
Colonial -Airlities, Inc., Mail Rates, Order "No. E- 1340, —_ |
‘Mg (ROO. Viaviss esse caseeucneseiase awipsdueds Tee wcaacst 95
Commissioner of Internal Revenue v. Sunnen, 333 C S.- 591,, °
- 92°L, Ed..653, 68 S. Ct: 702 ....... Pegs SORE Pree Papegee
Conboy v. First Nat. Bank of Jersey City, 203 U. s. M41, 51
Li, ee RO Oe My Wace cerercvcds tuieteguseds eenes 88
Continental Air Lines, Ine. —Mail Rates for Routes. Nos. 3 and :
le ay LG RCS Wee | Bose 20.
Continental Air Lines, Inc. —Mail Ses for Roitte No 45,
CCA. A. 188 2.65.5 RTT TTL TORT OPT PELE CT ETT TO LTPPRPT. 86 :
Cox v. Hart, 260 U. S. 427, 67 L.4Ed. 332, 43 S. Cte 154........ 26
* Credit Co. Ltd. v. Askansas Central, Ry. Ce. 128 LU. S. 258, 32,
L. Ed. 448,.9'S RE DOE deeb ccelvesvdtsgcsranvovaiveess ~ 88
‘Delaware, Leckawanne & Western. Rd. Co. v. Rellstab, 276. \
U: S. 1, 739 LE. 408, 46-3. Ct. 908 5 cc cscsccccscedacces P 1
Delaware, Lachawanna & W estern Rd. Ca v.-United States, 219 .
OS, S: S08, 6 1, dk 680,90 S.Cn. B06 ow dvcateciccecets ‘ 47
. Delta Air Corp., Mail Rates, for Routes Nos. 24 and D4,
SP a wo xdGuhddncbad Kaceoeteeetoceieeas webiec “Ste Be
">
: al ?
ae
. gS j v :
i PAGE
Delta Air Linda, Inc., Mail Rates, Order No. Bayo Oct. 28,
SE act duowenéka dente sbaebaendnckonbaneshéuseekébnks 43
+ Driscoll v. Edison Light & Power Co., 307 LS. 104,.83 L. _ Ed.
f=: 7 MOR OO 8, 98 2... 5005605..5 Apr tee eee, Be 35
3 Eagle Cotto Dil Co. v. Souther Ry. Co., 51 F. (2d) 443...../ 76
z= Eastern Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rate Proceeding, 3°C. A. B. 733 _ 38,
a 2 = Gans, "> 78, 93
& Eastern Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, 6 C. A. B. 551.......00... » 12
~p Eastern Rd. Co: v. U. S., 129 U.S. 391, 32 L: Ed. 730,9S°Ct.
OBR SAREE IIS ace one RR a OU RUIN 6 SOA ty ey pe a »i4,47- -
Edwards v.earzey, 96 U. S_595, 24 L. Ed. 793° ...... pee $2.
Empire Air Lines, Inc. ., Mail Rates, Order No. E-896, Oct. 20,
eR ae. ARE prey oe Be pain ae STE TD 85
_ Essair Inc., Temporary Mail Rate, 6 C. A. B. 687 Ae sae ie Pe 42
. Federal Power Comm. v. Hope Natural Gas Co., 320 U. S. 591, .
88 L. Ed. 333, 64.8. Ct. 281.22... 9.22.6 ERE RE SENOS 7%
- | Federal Power Comm. v. Natural Gas Pipeline €o., 313 U. S.*
= € . ee Oe ac ee: Pe: Oe Bs Ge, SO i kates ehcccecsnkanncs 34, 81
Federal: Trade Comm. v. Bunte Brothers, Inc., 312 U. S. : 49, 85
Ras es Ms, sy OD nok nd sin > Sad veendaawed Scaueueas 49
diese. gma Bank’ y.. Missourt, 265 Us . 640, 68 L. Ed. 486,
o( Dele SE dad nn shatutel acess bhi eddebnxlccedaxisante a.
- Fleming v. Mohawk Wrecking & Lumber Co., 331 U. S. 111, ~
‘9 91 L, Ed. 1378,,67. S. Ct. R489 2.2 20:. ~denvessadewadees 4 97
Florida Airways, Inc., Order No. E-765, Aug. 19, 1947 ....: oe
Florida Airways, Inc. “s Mail - Rates, Order No. E-897, — 20,
SOG .cnwne FEE AP PEE PP Lee ae SPT Or ErY ee rere TTT rrr 8&5
Freund v. United States, 260 U. S. 60, 67 L. Ed. 131, 43'S . o.* ~
$ Mh, Palkiens, ieee Nip eS spore Bis ahs sve eseceo age sns cee 46°
ll oie
Cline v. Us 193 U.S. 451, 48°L. Ed. 45, 21S. Ct. 510.... 88
Gemsco, Inc. v. W alling, 324 v. S.. 244, 89 L. Ed. 921, 65 S.
3 Ces a lek oes ba eae ae SNS bo Ok hood KOO rae ade ee kee 74
Grand Trunk W estern: Ry..Co.°v. U.-S.,.25¢ U: S. 114 64 LS -
Me, BOG, 20 By Oe. BO 8a onic ccadonc yp oV bes cctste “2.33, 79, 97 --
Great Northern Ry. Co.-v. Sunburst Oil & Refining Co. 287 . -
U. S. 858, 77 L. Ed. 360, 53 S. Ct. re ras aceet el caved 76
Great Northern Ry.Co. y. Sutherland, ‘ ar3 U.'S. 182, 71 L. Ed.
Pe ae ee MP vidcdns kv eudinoced ceeWasuaetess 2
Great Northern: Ry, Co. v..U. S., 315 t. S262, 86 ~ Ed. DS aa
OE RAPE AD asivcaedpbadsdasccyobseseesasucaenass an ee
Gryger v. Burke, a. U. S. 728; 68 S. Ct. 1256 2000s. Seaeaans par
Halstead v. U.-S., 55 Ct. CL OS seus caoueavecseenee sens roe
bs a tne
Vi
: PAGE
Hanford Airlines, Inc. Rate Review, eA Oe ees
Helvering v. Reynolds, 315 U.S. 428, 85 L. Ed. 1438, 61 S.Ct.
PRE rere rae ye ase Kec (Ween esgendennawaw nese s ia ee
erin ater Co, v: Corporation Comm. of North Carolina,
" 269-L. $278, 70 L. Ed, 273, Bay AE ae) ene Ser ew pe to
Hicsbayashi +. U. ss $20 yy 81, 87. L. Ed. 1774, aa Ree
BGGO sce scadecapaavage ities FE Se ee a PP ng NE NAD Oe co ae
: Hooton ¥, United States, 38 ¢. Cl. 639 Ae Se ee wee ees : Pe PC ene.
Hunt v. United a. 5% U.S. 9125, 66° L. ‘Ed: 163, 42.S. -
is Eee as Od yh reer POET Briere Pers 46
Hurley, v. Kincaid, ' 235 Us 95, 76:1... Edd. 643. “52 SL Ct. 273 . 82
" Ilinois Central Rd Co. v. Minnesota, 309 U. S. 187, 84 L.. Ed.
670760 S. Ct: 419 .....: (Gadhbss ws eaes Rada w ee ks eee Re 27
Ink: Air Lines, Ine.—-Mail Rates for Routes Nos. 28 and 35,
Pe SOON eae cece s ica coke uee ba vee ae oF
inf ter- tala Airways, Limited, Rate Reviews, 225 1.C.C.115.. 56-°
a. |
Lapras Pensacola & Mobite Rd. Go. -v. U. S., ‘Tas U: S
626, 30 L, Ed. 273, 7 S.Ct. - beleeseess ipectesience Rea
~ Kendall v. United States, 12 Pet: {U, S.] 524. Rig eRe ars: 13
Lewis. v. Fidelity & Deposit Cy. of ‘Shanland 292 U. S. 559,
28 L. Ed. 1000,. 54 §. @t. 568 2... cece esac eee cteces 26
Lichter v. United States, 334 U. S. 742, 68S. Ct. 1294......... “41-
Luckenbach Steamship Go. v. U. S280. U.S. 494, 20 &. nee hs
356, 50S. Ct. VAS eeepc eee chee eee eee eens cm Wee taee gd
Macon, Dublin '& S Savannah Rd. Co. v. U.'S., 78 C. Cl. 25),
We CER SOE ae eae 51-A2
Mail Divisor Cases; The, 251. U. S. 326, 64 L. Ed. 290,.40.S. °
i Sa ee tl oh ee
Manhattan General E ‘quipment Co. v. Commissioner. of Internal
- Revenue, a97 &. S. 129, o¢ L.. Ed. 526, 66 S°CO OT...
Mat ter of Maul Compe nsation of Pennsylvania Central Airlines
Corp.; Docket No. 484 2.23... 24/0 Pee CLE eee CREE Se 24
agree bea Co., In Re, 218 U. S. 312, 54 L. FA 1051, |
) ee oA | APs Se a are ee: ak ik de Oe Ea eS . nd) AS ee
Pr Fest oral ‘Airlines, Inc., Mail Rates, 1 C. A. A. ‘txaw 38
Mid-Continent .Airlines, Inc. —~Meail Rates for Rontes pei 26
and 48,°3 C. A. B. pr eae ig See Are Lo LEP PES wm tae
| Mid-Continent Airlines, Inc. > Mail Rare’ for ere No. 48, 2
C. A. B. 32 .. ; 86. 93
—_—
J ri js ow :
, et . - . ty .
Missouri, Kansas & Texas Ry. “Co. v. U. a 256 U. S. 610, 68
L, Ed. 1J18, 415. Ct. 617.23 ee ete enesesdedaeecsessys 14
Monareh f\ir Lines, Inc.. Mai! Rates, Order: No. E-8Us, Oct.
ot A RO, ed or FR eels Warn ey Need Kine G Arne MIE oe 85
Mulford v. Smith, 307 UAS. 38, 821. E d. 1092, 59S. Cr. 64 26
National Airlines, ay Mail Rates, Order No. E-1271, orcs
5 ates Pinas parce aE ee ed ae ae 12
National Airways; fac, Rate hey: iew, 226 1; C. c re ae Da ; an
National Parks Airways-—Base Rate Mileage, 220 1..C..C. 149... 0 57
_, Neild. District of Columbia, 71° App. D. C. 306, 110 F. ¢ 2d)
246 Be ee oes we pay epee eta SA dete o. on an Lone, eae Sm oe reese 25, 26
Newton v. Consolidated Gas Co., 258°. 165, 66 1. Kd. S38
wy eG See” eter purr astute ehar pn eatin (arnt erne ie ete are ey O4
‘New York, New Haven & Hartford Rd. Co: v. United States, ta
251-U. S. 123,64 L. Ed. 182, 40 S, Ct.-67 ...... GPE Sen 46,47
Northeast’ Airlines, Inc., Mail Rate—Route No. 27;:4C. A. B: |
Be. Ware ere we eer PPPS ee perro ree Died elects 95
Northeast -Airlines, Inc., .Mail Rates, Order No: E 1230, ‘Feb.
So WE SRM yatta yaneuel aa ae en en Gee ee 43, 96
Northwest Airlines, Inc, Mat Rate Proceeding for Route No.
we Se, eae | GE Drea eg. Lhe ABP Ns Beer on py Re a ee
Northwest Airlines, Inc., Mail Rates, Order No. E-721, July
SO TONE GS kana yan teen Gea ih oak Pe te Pe oo
Bees in’ Nitrogen Products Go. v. U. Ss 288 U. S. 294,
YL. Ed. 796, 53°S Ct. Peat eds Sunes rica PACES
- :
Oklahoma Natural. Gis Company v. Oklahoma, 258 Sop 24, *:
«° 661. Ed. oh, 42 RS Se eae pte > cE Ty aay ' 34
‘Oklahoma Natural Gis ce v. | Russell 261.U. ‘Ss. 290, 67 -L. Ed.
Coe Se Oe Ba es Gh es cae haces eb oi eee eee 34,80.
Old Nick Williams Co. v. U. 5. 215 U. < 541, 54 1. Ed.
SEG, OO AS PE sik ccaned eeeeeceue i iivacets errr yr’ 88
Osborn v. U. S., 50 F. (2d) 712 Seer ewks panes aes eau ey ke aa”) ee
— Pacific Air Transport v. United Statesy:98 C. Cl. 649 ......:. 54
* Pacific Alaska Airways, Inc., et al., Alaska Mail Rates, 6 C. A. B.
OE £64 MCR e KAA EE RRC ES R RAR ET EN Ena) eee . -2e, 30, 93
. Pan American Airways Co. (ot Delaware )—Mail Rates, 1
CoA A. OR oe eee 20... 38, 86, 89, 94
‘Pan American Airways Co. (of Delaware) —Transatlantic Mail
Rates, rhs ar ONC ahi re eee ee ee eee eee 40
‘Pan American Airways Co. (of Nev ada) — -Mal Rates, ic. AA.
ee ory ree Sek Ng Se En Sea peaeake ne scp eRe
-
fa.
oO
vill he
; - PAGE
Pan American, Airways, Inc. v. Civil Aeronautics Board, 12
F. (9d) O16 (0. GAL Dy scccisaa savers csancucaceas ‘sce Oe
‘Pan American Airways, Inc.,. Latin-American Rate Case, 3
NG Bic TS OBE cian cae cas AT TAT ASA ES RENE CARER ROT 78, 90
Pan . — Airways, Inc., Latin- American Mail Rates, &
ie Gs | pee eere Pee Pee Pe ORL rr Pere eT Toe RT ere Mi)
Pan jue aS Airways, ‘Inc., Latin- Ainedican and Miami-
Leopoldville Servic es Mail Rates, Order No. E-738, Jaly 24.
RE 7 ee i Re Pa eer a arr ey er $2, 4:5, 0
Pan American Airways, Inc., Order No. E-771, Aug. 25, 1947.. 22
Pan American Airways, Inc., ‘Transatlantic Mail Kates, &
Ca bd PTT er eey et Peeve eee CLT e eT TET. 12,45
Pan American Airways, Inc., Transpacific Mail Rate, IC. Aw
L)) oer ere rere re Tere TE Teer rere TT ET eT Tere LY eee ~. 42
Pan Aieciease Grace Airw ays, Inc.—Mail Rates, 3 C. 2
MP canes ee ee eee
Pennsylvania- Central ‘Airlines Corp., Mail rents 4c. A.B.
OM i ¢iacu sn ‘Naka digas ba esaginweaess ak eek daw een aen ees 93
Pennsylvania- -Central Airlines Cotp,,. 7:0. A. Bi 966 05.65. ek. ae
Piedmont Aviation, Ine., Mail Rates, Order No. E-1277, Mar.
pO. tr 86
Hes Air Lines, tae. , Mail ies S&C. A. B. 175 .....241, 42, 85
Prendergast v. New York Telephone Co., Ss U.S. 43, 67 L. Ed.
es ee es a oa es ha kes cee ea aaa alae 4
- Price v: Johnston, 334 U.S. 266, 68 S. Ct. 1049............. 19
‘Public Utilities Sous of : Chic v. United Fuel .Gas Co.,
S17 U. S. 456, 87 L.. Beds 396, 63-S. Ct. 369 os ccd 18
Railway— Mail Pay; 56 1.C..C.1.............. aki vias exe | Per
Railway Mail Pay, 185.1. C. C. 715........ ree Te ae ae
Railway Mail Pay, 269 1. C.C.857 00.6... cee cue a Pe ee
Realty Acceptance Corp. v. Montgomery, 284 U, . 547, 76 L.
Bad. 496, 62S. Ce. B05 oo osc ce ne as Morne FORRES Maeskes 91
Reynolds v. U, $. , 292 U. S; 443, 78 L. Ed. 1353, 54S. Ct. 8004. 26-
Richmond Hill: Electrical Supply Co., Inc., In re, 47 F. (2d)
Pee ene ie Sec Poe ae SEEK ie ® ae cx 88
Roberts v. United States, 92 U. S. Qt 98 ha OG eas cele: 13
St. Louis Southwestern Ry. Co. v. U. S., 262 U. S. 70, 67 TL. Ed.
” 868 7 eM OR Cr eae ee Pe Ree lye hee ea ene 15, AT
St. Paul & Duluth Rd. Co. v. United space 112 U. 733, 28
Sc Oe & OM, de es eacicle ise ret eek 14,4
- Securitigs & Exchange Comm. -v. Chenery Corp. 8 332 U.S. 194,
9PL. Ed. 1995, 67 S. ‘Ct. 1575
% |
Shapiro v. United States, 335 UL S. 1, 68 S. Ct. See eh cna cee ae
Shwab v. Doyle, 255 U.S. 529, 66 L. Ed>% Sug 42S. Ct. $91, :..°. 25
Social Security Board ¥. 3 Nicrotko, 327 U.S. 358, 90 L. Ed. 71%,
/ 668, Ct. 637 Sew ey eee oe eee ee ee ee eo ee been ee ee ee esas 97
Cohn -v. Watterson, 17! Wall. {U. $.J-596, 21-L, Ed. 737.0... 82.
Southwest -Airways, Cu, , Mail Rates, Order No. E-899, Oct. 20,
DEC iak aC S eee Ce UD See ane Rode bee oe ek eee 85
Springfield Gas & Electric Co. v. Barker, 231 Fed. 391 ........ 34-
Staten Island Edison Corp. v. Maltbie, 267 N. Y. App. Div. 72,
45 N.Y. S. (2d) 337, afd. 292 N.Y. 611, 55 N. E. (2d) 376 33.
Stock v: Mann, 255 N.Y. 100, 174 N.E. 76 Pa “S. eckiethneeee oe
Trailmobile Co. v: Whirls, 331 US. 46, 91 L. Ed. 939,67 S:
ee ae ar an na Gag a eke hee eke Nee A a REE 72
Transcontinental & W estern Air, Ine. oli e Ratés, 4 C. A. B. ~
Ce ata P Ed Ack ARAMA pA TER LASER ROLE WKS 22, 92, 93 -
Transcontinental, & Western Air, tec, Mail Rates, 6 C. A. B ,
Ee | a Peer HS AR Spey ee eae ee ee eee ee ee ee ee 3, 12, 85
Transcontinental & Western Air, Tnc., Trapsdblaiitie Mail R: ite,
7C. A.B. fs Se ee eee Cee See eee ee ‘prey re <
Transcontinental & Western Ait Mail Bid, 223 1.C. C. 281 ,..:. 60
Trans- Texas Airways, Order No. E-900, Oct. 20, 1947 eer ery 86
ties Pacific Rd. Co. %. United States, 104 U: S. 662, 26 L.
; BG. S84 -.:... ap ek ee” FE POG ee Cr en ae ee rire eee ee
United Air ‘Lines, Ine. v. Civil Aeronautics | Board, 81 App.
Py. 89, 356 F. (3d) B68 is OTE PTR T CETTE Cee sass 13
United. Air Lines,-Inc.. Mail’ Rates, 6 C. A: B. 584 Catan he 12
United Air Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, Order No. E-1355, April
ee ER ee ec 3 CO a Pee ere pe Peet ee rie
United Airlines Transport Corp., Mail . Rate Proceeding 3:
At ata oa ist aast cena ds ; on ee 89
_ Enited Airlines Transport ee Mail Rate for Route No. of,
ee a ci eae ae as a ee a a es 85
United Fruit Co. v. United Sisters: 33 F. (24) 664 (C. C. A. 5) 30
United States v. Alabama Great Southern Rd. box 142 U.-S.
615, 35 L. Ed.. 1134, 12S. Ct. 306..... rs eee ola oes Poe. 4
United States v. American Trucking Assn. Inc., 310 U_S. 534,
a ee ee Ce Ess Ch bce ka boo kes cab ana 9%
United States v. Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co., 249
U.S. 451,631. E ee OR re Be ty
United States v..Atlintic Coast Line R. Co., 206- Fed. 190, Pray 30°
United States v. Carr, 132. U. S. 644, 33 L. Ed. 459, 10S. Ct.
ey. Dt ve seer ere er Seika. Srey teehee ee Miwa tie wee a
x !
mee be Ke PAGE)
* United States v. Griffy, 303 U. S. 226, 82 L. Ed. 364, 58S.Ct. /
WOE. Sedu vdscdacs es akbawsssapacrsecsbewaseces 29, 36, 47, 49,50
‘United States v. Hamburg-/ ae eae Packet fahrt Actien
Gesellschaft, 313 Fed. 40 (C. C. A..8) 21g. ccececcaandes 30
United States v. Jacobs 306 U. S. 363, 83 L: Ed. 763, 59 S. Ct.
| Oe Lee CeCe CETTE TUTL OTE TET eee eee 26
"United States v. Jonés,. 109 U.S. 513, 27 L. Ed. 1015 §,35.Ct. j°
eR ee ae ee esa eau ada Nh eecnens ees A eee
United States. v. Sayer; 235 U. S..55, 159 L. ae 129, 35 |
ew a ee iea stakes ciceba ca skuneasdabruves esa cehc ae
United States v. Morena, 245 U. §. 98 62. L. Id. 359; 38 7 -
oe eer rer eee Trey Terre Wace # 82
United States v. New pos Central Rat. Co., 279. U. S273, 73
i. ae. O19, 49 SB. Ct. 260 565 0<.. ooo, 11, 16, 27, 47, 51, 65, 81, 83
United States v. Sih ri *, (3 *d) 162 (C. Cc | =e | eee 88
United States v. Sullivan, 332 U. S. 689, 68 S. Ct. 331 ...... : | 28
United States v. Utah; Nevada. & California Storage Co., 199.
U.S. 414, 50 L.Ed. 251, 26S. Ct.-69 6. teen -4 46
Vasques, In re,.00 F. (2d) Ceres leet Tre rrr ee ele 88
PY
Western Air [xpress Corp., Rate Review, 225 I. C. C. 743 .. 59, tp
Western Air: Lines, Inc.—Mail Rates for Routes Nos.*13, 19
and 52, 4.C. A. B. 441 ...... Ee eer aos 91-98 |
White. v. United States, 191 U.S - 545, 48 L. Ed. 295,.2 24 S. Ct.
Se ad a eae AA Re AWAD A OR LOR O's SeekeNestaas 25
Wickard v. Filburn, 314 U.S. 111, 87 L. Ed. 122, 63 S. Ct.
in ie dee wad ee aeee eee e Sebi SaaS ee eeeenedn es va xs whaee ss » 26
Wightman v. United States, 23 C. Cl. 144 ........ aepeeeeees ae
Wilson v. Iseminger, 185 U. S. 55, 46 L. Ed. 804, 22 S.
EA Ee Pe error ee Lee ee ene oe Pe ee a
a Wisconsin Central Rd. Co. v. U. S., 164 U. S. 190, 41 L. Ed. -
a nes oh bana oes an. 14,33, 79
Woods v. Stone, 333 U. S. 472, 68 S. Ct. 624 ..6...; es 26, 27
Wyoming Air Service, Ae Rate Review, 225 1. €.C.1..... ae
. Yakus v. ‘United States, 321.U. S. 44, 88 L. Ed. 834, 64S. Ct.
ae etd eae ge FOS EWEN ON GO OPEN ROO 81
, Yearsley v. W. AY boas Construction Co., 309 U. S. 18, 84 L.
Ed. 54, MG RE | Bea Recekavecsentas eaers a
/
x1
° .~ _ {2
STATUTES °
; PAGE
Act of February 20, $298) ¢:-9 (4 Seat B90) oi ccs,
Act of May 8, 1794, ¢. 23 (1 Stat. 354)... ERE TNR Fa 30
Act of May 14, 1856 <2 Stat. eta cad Dae weed oe eet es: .. 34
Act of July 7, 1838, c. 171.05 S Stat. 268) ..c..0.. Pero ee Tree 30
Act of March 3, 1845, c. 44 (5 Stat. 732; 39-U. S. ss $521) .. 50-31
Act of June’8, 1872, ¢. 385 (17 Stat, 283) .:........ =. 31-32, 48
Act of July 12, 1876, c. 179 (19 Stat. 79) ........ ralgncats eae
hs al “August 24; 1912, c. 389 (37 Stat. 539, 554,557; 39 -
7 OR ES SIN rie oat eae FER i oP OEY FET 14
Act of March 4, 1913, c. 143 (37 Stat. 197) . # ree ey ‘Seine 15
Act of July 28, 1916, ¢, 261 (39 Stat. 425) Senos a tye aes ey 15
Act of Fedruary 2, 1925 (43 Stat 805) fee ues rasa es +33
Act of June 3, 1926 (44 Stat. 692) ...../..... eee 53°
_Actof March 8, 1928, ¢. 149 (45 Stat. 249) Dave eee ne
Act of May 1%, 1928, ¢: 603-(45 -Stat..594) ............. eee 53
a Act of April, 29, 1930° (46 Stat. BOP ict kav ewan wes * nee ae . 53
Act’of February 28, 1933, c. 131 (47 Stat. 1 1349) .:... . vesters OL
~ Act of _ September 1s, 1940, c. 122, $322 (54: Stat. 955, 49 =
U. S. C. $66) +37 pe ane es- i Qprc este teense nese ee
Air Mail Act of June 12, 1934, c- 466 (48 Stat. 933 ff. ) amended
by Act of August 14, 1935,.c. 530 (49 Stat, 614) +, 15-16, 32, 35,
: 53- 59, B5
Civil es, Act of. June 23) 1938, c. 601 (52 Stat. 977 ff. a
49 U.S. C: S$401-691) ..... De aes ao ean <r
Section 2, ietace of Pol cy (a Stat. 980, 49 U.S.C.
ME oc aekeen PETROL OPN EES Mee ie geeseee 19,Bl
Section sof), Application \for Abandonment (52 Stat:
6, OU. S.C. FAM F655 cde 11, B3
Section 401(m),° Requirement as to Carriage of Mail (5
Stat. 990, 49 U.S. C. dt) 2 ane ce - 11, 28 58, B2
Section 403/c), Notice of tariff change (: ae Stat. 992, 4%
ie ee es) OER hee errr Toren 18, B21
iy _
y
xii *
PAGE
Section 401(a), Carrier’s duty to provide service, rates and
divisions (52 Stat. 993, 49-U. S.C. $484(a)) .-- 2. eee 18
Section 405, Transportation of Mait (52 Stat. 996, 49
U. S. C..§485) ...... Bi ceata teks have nupassacdas ee
Section 404, Rates for Transportation of Mail (3 Stat.
vox, 49 U.S. C. §486) st
‘ (a) Authority to fix rates ........-- &. 43. 16-17, 19, 23,-
; a : . || 28,45, 61-74, B8
_ (bp) Rate-making elements ..’.....--.- 17, 37-40, 61, B12
(c) Statement of Postmaster General and car-
: “PEE ca cagencincesedidesossccnsocsenss 21, 61, B17
Section 901(a), Safety-and postal offenses (4° Stat. 1015,
he 0: S.C. SORA os cas PSOE TT ote re Ba.
Seetion 902(a), Criminal Penalties—General (53 Stat. %8
1015, 49 U. S. C..$622(a)) Ve eeesewnnee PERE Peete r
Section 1002, Complaints to and investigations by the Au-
thority ¢52 Stat. 1018, 49 U.S. C. $642)
~ (d) Power to prescribe rates. and practices of air
eee Oe eee Te setesssaawes ianave TO EOS
(e): Rule of rate making .....-.... eel eset eeses B22 .
(h) -Power to prescribe divisions of rates ....:.. 19, B23
Section 1005, Orders, notices and service (52 Stat. 1023,
49 be S ee $645) oor ee eek oe ire ra ei es eT ee SS .& age 91
Section 1006, Judicial review of. Authority’s, orders (92 -
Stat. 1024, 49 U. S.C. §646) ....... err yer ree -. 2, B18
Section 1108(b), Pending administrative_proceedings (52
Stat. 1020, 49 U.S. C. §678(b)) iieeen es erie errs al
Riilway’ Mail Pay Act of Waly 2x; 1916, c. 261 (39 Stat: 425
¥., 39 UL S.C. $§$b24 ff) oe cece eee eee eee ...- 32, 49- sisal
28 U.S.C. § 2o4 (see Pub! L. 733, 80th Cong., 2d Sess.) . 2
- BO U, S. C. $8441, 448, 450, 541... cece cece ew enten cee 32.
OTHER AUTHORITIES
Americar Aviation Daily November 14, 1947 oes Sg akee ws 20
Civil Aeronautics Board, Annual Reports .
1939 (First Report) ...... 2. eee eee eee eee ee eee 75, 83
1940 (Second Report) . 0.0... eee eee eee ee ee reece eee 85
xiii tae
: PAGE
1942 (Fourth i So a ee re ree 79
1947 (Ninth Report) ...:..... ies ge Le eee a oe 38
Civil Aeronautics Board, Memoranda oe.
, UREae SB, FMR i eas gee vecaes PPM TSE ye eT ae
es SS Beeererre tpeedeaseen incaes eo peveee sess 102
Civil Aeronautics Board, Recurrent Reports of Financial Data... 13
Civil Aeronautics Board, Report of Formal Economic Proceed-. ;
mes; Bete OBOE: 5 i ccccdactivaseus Pune ee Ne Ee
78 Cong. Rec. 7617, 1623, 7628 RP RU area! Cdieet ae
Sh Cong: Bac. 029; WOR, oo ass clea nvarerdage . 68, 72,
83 Cong. Rec. 8961- 063%... 54. Mabaar eee es Peet sh adn's® 45 Ee
Hearings before a:Subcommittee of Senate Interstate Commerce
Committee on S. 2 and S. 1760, 75th Cong., Ist Sess. 53, 60, 62- “1
Hearings before House Committee on Interstate and Foreign
Commerce: on H. R. o234 and H. R. mae 3 T5th Cong., ist
SEPT ee Lee SEN Leet WEP TE Yt yw ere ee Oe 63
Hearings before Subcommittee of Senate Comm. on Appropria-
tions, 80th Cong., Ist Sess., on H..R. 2436, p. 574 .......... 36
Hearings before Subcommittee of House Comm. on Appropria-
tions, 80th Cong., Ist Sess., on Post Office Appropriations Bifl
: OM MRE cease SPOT Mere OR rae
H. R. Rep. No. 911, 75th Cong., 1st ick PEST EE CONE Te oon i
H. R. Rep. No. 2635, 74th Cong, 3rd Sess., June 7,-1938 ..... 45
Interstate Commerce Commission, Annual Reports 5
1936 (50th-.Report): ............ eae eeetees tian scea,
1937 (51st Report) .:....... PPP eer on eer Te rer T er 60
National Aviation Policy, “Report of. Congressional, Aviation
Policy Board, 80th Cong., 2d Sess., March 1,.1948. ...:...° 74
Reorganization Plan No. IV, June 30,. 1940, 54 Stat. 1235, 5
Wem. Bil: BOGE is cia avn catsnasassdeakcewans és
Senate Document 15, 74th Cong., Ist Sess. ...... ah eae eas 67
Statutory Maximum Mail Rates, House Doc. bias 141, 7: 75th |
Cong., bet Oe SET ET ECE TE TEN PET Ser re ree tery 60
Subcommittee Hearings (see supra sailler Hearings before a°
Perereg gs of Senate. Interstate Commerce Committee on
2 and S. 1760, 75th Cong.,. 1st Sess.) .
Survival in the Air Age, Report by ppeaitent s Air Policy Com-
“mission, January +1, 1948 .. ;
.
2*
Ix THE °
“Supreme Court of the Anited States
- Ocroser Term 1948
eee rere ee 80 Fag Fee nents ane
No. 387
hy.
my
TraNsconTinentaL & Western Am, Inc.,
Petitioner,
against
“Crviz Agronavtics Boarp, s |
' Respondent.
On Writ oF CEeRTICRARI TO THE UNITED States Court
or APPEALS FOR THE District or CoLUMBIA
. >=
2 7
BRIEF FOR THE PETITIONER
Opinions Below
. +, The opinion of the-Court of Appeals is reported in
169 F? (2d) 893. It appears at pp..111-115 of the Transcript
of Record. The majority opinion of the Civil Aeronautics
- Board, which-has not yet been officially. printed, appéars at
pp. 60-91, and the dissenting sured — at pp- 92- 108,
of the Transcript of Record.’ .
' For brevity, the following abbrev iations will be used hereafter.
Numbers in parentheses refer to the pages of the Transcript of
Record. The “Act” means the Civil Aeronautics Act .of 1938, as
_
_ Jurisdiction,
The jurisdiction of -this Court is invoked undef 28
U. S. . $ié 24 (see Pub. L. 773, 80th Cong., 2d Sess., e. 646)
and * 1W06(f) of ‘the Civil Aeronautics Act of 1938 (32 Stat.
1024; 49 U.S. €. 646(f)). a order of the Court of Ap-
peals was entered on August 2, 1948. Petition for-a writ
vedhinetouaiers was filed on October 30, 1948, and granted on:
December 6 , 1948 (93 L. ed. adv. op. 12 3). ;
Statement of the ole
Petitionér is ate air carrier engaged in transporting’
- persons, property and mail by aircraft in the United States
and elsewhere under certificates of public convenience and
necessity issued under the Act by respondent, Civil Aero-
nautics Board. : ;
Section, 406 (a)(1), ‘the Act empowers ited directs the
Board, upon its own initiative or upon petition of the
Postmaster General or an air carrier, ‘to fix and determine
- from time to time, after notice and hearing, the fair and
reasonable rates of compensation for the transportation of
mail by aireraft-... by each holder of a certificate author-
izing the transportation ef mail by aircraft, and to make.
such rates effective f rom such date as it shall determine to
99.
be proper eis soe? ae
amended Act of June 23, 1938, c. 601, 32 ‘Stat. O73, as amended,
9 UL S.C. $$401-691. See Appendix .B, infra. The Civil Aero-
nautics "Board and its predecessor, the Civil Aeronautics Authority,
‘will be called “the Board,” (The functions of the Authority were.
transferred to the Board by pry wg Plan No. IV, effective
June 530) P40. 54 Stat, 1255, 5 Fed. Reg. 2421). Petitioner will
sometimés be called “TWA .
Unless otherwise stated, all italics are ours.
The basic question is whether the Board has any pow er
to determine that a new rate for carrying the mail should
_ be made effective from a date prior to the filing date of
the airline’s petition. Whether TWA should obtain such
relief, on the merits, is not the question here. The merits
have not been ‘examined—the Board has been held power- .
less. to examine them. _ The question of power arose in the:
following manner. . 5. | oe \ =
1. ‘The Petition for a. New Rate -
. -By petition filed March 14, 1947 (8-13), TWA’ applied
—~ to the Board, pursuant t’ §406 of the Act, for an order
fixing and determining fair and reasonable rates of com-
pensation, effective J anuary 1, 1946, for transporting mail
by aircraft over certain routes (designated as routes Nos.
2, 38, 44 and 58) operated by it wholly within the United
States. That petition stated, in substance, the following.
- By order dated October 26, 1945, the Board reduced —
TWA‘'s rate for carrying mail over its domestic routes to ©
45¢ per ton mile, retrospectively effective as of January
1, 1945 (10)?. TWA suffered losses in every month after
the issuance of that order except June-1946 (9-10): These
losses were partly due to a common postwar experience:
costs kept rising while: mail revenue declined (&).° They
were largely caused, however, by conditions peculiar to.
TWA first received new ‘4-engine Constellation air-
-eraft in September 1945 (8). Because of certain contro-
versies, these airplanes were not’placed in service until
* Transcontinental & Western Air, Inc., Mail Rates, 6 C. A. :
595. ; ks
: . *< .
“4 ‘ 3 bad ty tS
February 1946 (8- 9), By June 1946 enough Constellations ;
were in operation to enable TWA to. report a net profit for
that one month (9). .
On July 11, 1946, adi er, all Constellations were sad.
denly grounded by the. Administrator of Civil Aéronanties ;
(9). This’ grounditig was beyond TWA's ‘control.. No ;
other domestic airline then had Constellations in operation
My ‘Because of the gr ounding, all LW A’s Constellations
were out of reyenue service until.the middle of September
1946, and many for even longer (9). - Meanwhile virtually
all TWA’s costs continued (9). Wisteaa of enjoying an-:
ticipated profits from summer operations, TWA suffered
serious losses (9). ak aA lee
That blow was hardly over w vhen,- “on einbes 21, 1946,
‘TWA’s operations were completely shut down by a-strike |
- of its pilots (9). The pilots had demanded higher wages.
A ‘Fact Finding Board appointed by the President. of the.
United States under the Railway Labor Act, which is ap-.
plicdble to’ air carriers, recommended ,an increased nay
scale. TWA promptly put the recommendation ‘iito effect
(9). Nonetheless the pilots served an ultimatum detnand--
ing an even higher wage scale within 30 hours (9). If TWA -
had granted the pilots’ demand, its costs would have been
even higher (9).. The strike-then ensued. The shutdown
following the strike.continued for almost four weeks and
caused further severe financial losses (9). se :
The petition alleged that the. old 45¢ rate had not been
fair and reasonable since January 1, 1946 (10) and, pur- : vF
suant to $406(c) of the Act, proposed a new rate (11).
\
qe 6 oor
—_
® The Procedure Below
\On- May 27, 1947,° Public Cianee of the Board moved
that ‘the Board, without he ‘aring: the merits, dismiss so
much of TW A’s petition as requested a new mail rate for
the period ‘froin January 1, 1946 to March 14, 1947, the
date the petition’ was filed. The. principal ground of this
motion was that “as a matter of sound general policy’’
the Board. should not make such a retrospective adjust-
ment (15).
\ On June Ui, 1947, TWA answ ered this motion, poiriting
a tlrat the Board had the duty to hear and consider the |
merits of any petition involving matters within its juris-
_ diction (22-25). There after, on June 23, 1947, Public Coun-
sel\ amended their motion to.dismiss by adding a new
ground: that the Board had “no authority’’ to a?
rate retroactively (38). :
. After oral’ argument (41-96), the Board granted the
motion by an order dated December 2, 1947 (91). Dismis-
sal was not on the merits, nor in the axercise of discretion,
' but, solely.on the ground—adv anced by a majority, of three
members—that the Board lacked power to fix a rate effec-
tive before the date the petition was filed (63-90). Member
Lee dissented with an opinion (92-108).
On January .30, 1948, TWA applied for 1 review of the 7
Board’s order by the United States Court of. Appeals for
the District of, Columbia which, on August 2, 1948, affirmed
the Board’s order: with an opinion by Judge Prettyman
; (111. 115)., Petition for eertiorari was granted by ‘this
Court on: Dees ‘mber 6, 1946" (118). : x
-"e
Specification of Errors
1. The Court of Appeals erred in holding that the Act.
does not empower the Board to pass on the inerits: of
TWA’s petition of March 14, 1947, asking that a new mail
rate be made effective from a daie prior to the filing of the
petition.
2. ‘Lie Court of Appeals erred in failing to hold that
- the Act, and particularly &406(a) (1) thereof, delegates to
the Board the power of: Congress to set a new rate for
TWA retrospectively effective as of a date whicli the Board -
, determines to be proper, whether or not it antedates March
14,1947. ‘
“ © on. , sae eo ’ ‘
3. The Court of Appeals erred-in holding that the
Board’s power to fix mail compensation under the Act is .
limited by an ‘‘almost.- conclusive +presumption against,
power to take ‘retroactive action,’’? when no such presump-
tion applies. |
4. The Court. of Appeals erred in holding that
-— ~§406(a)(1) ‘of the Act should be judicially circumscribed
by false analogies to other statutes differing. completely in
language and purpose, and particularly to statutes regulat-—
ing the rates of public utilities engaged in two- —
activities. |
5. The Court of Appeals erred in holding that the Board
is empowered to change mail rates retrospectively . only
from the initiation’ of the rate _proceeding and in. failing.
to hold that the practical considerations which compel pub-
eae 6k wie
oe
lic utility rates to be changed only prospectively have no
io wianeny to mail « _mpensation.
6, The Court of Appeals erred in holding that the Board
has no power to determine that a mail fate was excessively.
high prior to the initiation of a rate proceeding and ‘tliat
in consequence tlie Board is likewise powerless to determine
that a mail rate was unreasonably low prior to such initia-
tion.
7. The Court of Appeals erred in holding that the legis-
lative history of the Act shows that the provision of $406 (a)
giving the Board power “*to make such rates effective'f rom
such date.as it shall determine to be ase ical should be
given a limited effect.
8. ‘The Court of Appeals:erred in failing to hold that
the Board’s previous exercise and acknowledgment of its.
power to make mail rates effective as of. dates prior to the ¥
institution of a rate proceeding constitutes an administra-
_ tive*interpretation entitled to particular weight in the con-
struction of the Act.
9. The Court of Appéals erred in failing to hold that
the Act, if interpreted. to ‘deny the Board any ‘power to
increase mail rates effective from a date prior: to initiation
of a proceeding: to. revise an old rate; would violate the
Fifth Amendment .to the Constitution of the United States,
in that it would deprive petitioner of property without due
process of law and take its property witliout just compen-
sation.
‘>
_ 10. The Court of Appeal erred: in affirming the order —
of the Board.
\
necessary.
Summary of Argument
Whenever the Board fixes a future mail rate, it makes’
-a propheey. In the-field 6f-air transportation, mail pay i
prophecies are peeuliariy speculative. When events show:
that a prophecy was wrong, the Board is required to ‘cor-
rect it. So the Act provides, Indeed, since the airlines are
required to carry the mails, revision is constitutionally
Mail rates must always he- suffic sient to ae the air-
lines to carry out the Act’s objectives, as expressed prin-
“ecipally in $2 and 6406(b). Hence §406(a) (1) both. empow-
ers and directs the Board ‘*to fix and determine from time.
to time, after notice ne hearing, ‘the fair and ‘reasonable
rates of compensation. for the transportation, of mail by air-
craft... and to, make such rates effective from such ‘date as
» 33. : \
it shall determine to be proper. Ve
x w . 4 .
The basic issue inthis "ase-Is simple. » Changing a mail
rate for the future does not remedy its past ulfairness.
* Concededly the Board» has: full power to adjust the rate
back to the filing date: of the proceeding broug shit to revise
the-rate. The question here is“whether its power to fix a
prope r effective date is arbitrarily limited by: the start of
that proceeding, or whether it has pawer, after hearing the |
facts and weighing the merits, to det termine that arate ad-
justment shou’. properly. be made effective as of a day
—"= tbat filing date.
It is hog. Afocossary to speculate as to the Congressional ~_
‘intent. The Board was. given power to make its Fates
“effective from such- date as it shall determine to -be
ame ree roe + aee ,
-proper.’": "Those are not words of limitation Wut of com-
“lets delegation of discretion. For Inany years: Congress
.
«
.
he
itself exercised the power:to adjust mail pay retrospec-,
tively. By §406(a)(1) Congress delegated to the Board.
full power to correct false prophecies by adjusting mail
rates retrospectively, not a limited power to adjust them
back only to the filing date ofa rate proceeding and 1fo
further. -
Read asa whole, the.Act compels the same -conclusion.
Its purposes require that the language be given its plain
meaning. When Congress gave the Board power to change
**publie utility’
- tinguished from mail compensation, it expressly limited the
Board to making changes effective only for the future or
‘from -the date of filing’’ of the proceeding, ‘rather than
from any date ‘*it shall determine to be proper.”’ Thé dis-
tinction reflects long-standing ‘practical. differences between
_. publie utility and mail rates. It underscores the breadth
g
ae
Ay
”
Be
of the power conferred by §406(a) (1).
For ten years the Board has been making rates effective
as of dates: ~prior to the start of a rate proceeding. Its only
statutory authority for . this action was derived from
- $406 (a) )(1). After a decade it set out to discover ‘whether
the section was not intended to have a somew h@t\narroywer
meaning’? (68). Suddenly -it feund that language which
it had earlier termed’ **plain’” had somehow become “‘am-
It and the Court of Appeals created, and then
“resolv ed, that ambiguity by a series of false analogies and
unsdund policy arguments.
99
bigtous.
Thus, yh was’ claimed that-a narrower construction is
_ justified by am analogy to usual publie utility rate de-
termination statutes S-although® the Act itself refuses to
draw the analogy: It was contended that to interpret
“406(a) (1) the’ way it reads would guarantee’
4
4
rates—passenger and cargo rates—as dis- .
a profit to
10.
every airline regardless of the character of its service, to-
tally ignoring the standards prescribed in §406(b). It
was argued by the Court that our contention would em-
power » “the Board to. lower rates retrospectively. | To that
we agree, and we are ‘puzzled by the Court’s concern. If
the airlines are to be protected against- unreasonably low
mail rates, the Government should be protected against.
unreasonable profits accruing from excessively high mail
rates. Numerous other arguments of like nature were
advanced. eee ;
While all these arguments are unsound, as we shall .
show in detail, their basic fallacy is that they erect variable
polic y considerations into a rigid limitation on the Board’s
power, Questions of poliey are for Congress to resolve.
Congress resolved them in no uncertain terms. Its only
statement as to what it Was:trying to accomplish, contained
in the Couferenee Report on the Act as it was finally passed,
confirms the fact that $406(a)(1) was intended to give the
soard the broad, flexible power to fix rates as of any date
caters to be proper after hearing the evidence: pro
“and con.. | ;
The dais question involved here is whether TW. A shall
have the opportunity. to present evidence on the ‘‘proper”?’
effective date of an adjusted rate. A decision granting
TWA a hearing. will merely enable the five- man Board to
weigh the facts. If thafacts. do not justify the Board in
increasing thy rate retrospectively, the Board will not be
bound to take that action. By refusing ait hearing on the
point, the decision bclow frustrates the basie policy of the
Act to afford full relief to an airline whose economic sound-
Jess has been impaired. by events unforeseen when the
Board's previous rate prediction w was made.
od .
;
sa on
_}t = Sor:
POINT 1
The Act ibaa: delegates to the Board the power
whith has been held non-existent.
"Under the Act, ie aly sald is not a matter of
choice. Every air carrier authorized to carry mail must
‘*transport mail whenever required | by the Postmaster Gen-
eral.” §401(m), 49 U.S. C. $481(m); cf. §401(k), 49 U.S.C.
§481(k). From this statutory duty flows a’ constitutional
right to just compensation,’ as the Act recognizes. ‘Such
air earrier shall be entitled to reeelve reasonable compen-
ed.’? Tbid.
owered and directed
sation therefor as hereinafter provi
Consequently the Board is ‘‘en
. to fix and determine from timg to time, after notice -
and hearing, the fair and reasonable rates of compensation
for the transportation of miail by aireraft, the facilities
used and useful therefor, and the services connected there-
with . . . and to make such rates effective from such date .
as it shall determine to be ‘proper.’ $406(a) of the
Act, 49 UL S.C. g486(a). The ‘trates so fixed and deter-
mimed shalk be paid by the Postmaster General from a
propriations for the transportation of mail by aircraft.’
Ibid.
‘The rates: which the Board i is to.‘‘fix and determitie frome
time to time’’ are not, therefore, rates in the abstract.
99
They are ‘‘rates of compensation’’—more precisely, ‘‘fatr’
and reasonable rates of compensation. ”’
Determining a reasonable rate of compensation for ear-
rving the mail ix Ho — matter ev én whe n, the services
% United States v. New York Central. Rd re 279 U. S: 73, 78,
*9. ne
“
have already been performed and the actual™results of
operation are known. It-is far more difficult, however, to .
forecast what fair compensation for, carrying the mails
will be in’ the future. Every such forecast involves a
propheey.. ‘That is true in the relatively stable ‘field of
‘rail transportation, although the forecaster has over a
century of past experience on which to draw. It is espe-
cially true in-the much newer and less stable field of air
transportation. Se He | iar? .
“In air sig shasig we can see but dimly the shape
of things to come.” American. Airlines, Inc.—Mail Rate
Proceeding, 3 C. A. B. 323, 339. ‘The determination of a
fair rate necessarily“includes consideration of the suscepti-
bility of the industry to large and unpredictable fluctuations
of net operating income.’’ Delta Air Cérp.—Mail Rates for
.Route Nos, 24 and 54, 3-C. A. B. 261, 285. Recently the,
Board remarked again: on “the -paibore weakness in.
“prophecy as to revenues and expenses.”?’ Pan Americay
. Airways, Inc., Order No. E-771; p. 6, Aug. 25, 1947. When
it set TWA’s mail rates in 1945, it emphasized that fact
time and again.’ 2
‘
* Transcontinciital & Western. Air, Inc., Mail“Rates, 6 C. A. B.
595. Thus, it’ remarked that “accurate forecasts of future operations
are complicated not only by uncertainty as to-the direction. in which
these curves will move in the future but also becatise of uncertainty
as to the relative timing and rate of movement of each individual
curve” (pp: H9YT-D98). “. 2. it is not possible under existing
circumstanices.to arrive at a fully reliable determination of the prob-
able future mail costs” (p. 600). Likewise it referred to “the
dynamic conditions now developing” (p. 601). * °
This decision appeared simultaneously with others setting the
same 45¢ mail rate for three other domestic airlines. Eastern Air
Lines, Inc., Mail Rates, 6 C: A. B. 551; American Airlines, Inc.,
Mail Rates, 6 C. A. B. 567;°United Air Lines, ‘Inc., Mat Rates,
6 C. A. B. 581. -It is revealing to ‘compare the Board's predictions
» ue ve
Peal
3 = } BB
» Any determination of. air mail rates for the future. is’
therefore: peculiarly ‘‘a forecast subject to all the frailties
of propheey.”’ United Air Lines, Inc, v. Civil Ae ronauties
Board, 81 App. D.C. 89, 955; 1 Lao F. (2d) 169, 175. When
the forecast proves false, revision of the prophecy in light
of the actual facts is desirable and, wher the rate becomes
unreasonably low, constitutionally. mandatory.
‘Congress could, of course, undertake thé revision itself.
In fact, several times it has ‘adjusted mail rates retro-
spectively by special legislation. Sometimes private laws
have been passed to remedy specific past -injustices.® At.
other times general statutes have made retroactive changes
in mail rates—both upw ards and downwards."
of these sidelines? annual profits (on press it hased on 4: i¢ rate.) with
the actual profits or losses reported for 1946 and. 194% ( Civil Aero-.
nautics Board, Recurrent Reports of Financial Pata): :
Net Operat- |
ing Profit Actual Net Operating Profit or Loss
Predicted by _
vs Board 1946 _ 1947
TWA -| ”. $3,459,000 $-9,675,898. -$- 4,747,098
American 5,997,000 - 318,31 - 4,159,124
United , 7,162,000 976,402 - — - 5,203,699
* Eastern 3,754,000 _ 8,221,376 2,859,703
5 Congress has Suthorized, by. private bill, mail carriers to sue
in the Court of Claims to recover compensation to which, for some
reason, they. had no contractual right. Kendall y? United States,
" 2 Pet. (U. S: ‘| 524; Roberts v. United States, 92 U.S. 41; Wightman
. United States, 23 C. Cl. 144. Of course the consent te suit could
o withdrawn by a later statute, leaving the mail carrier ‘remediless.
Chorpenning v. United States, 94 U. S.-397, } oe .
® Thus, the Act of July 72, 1876, ¢,.179 at Stat. 79, 82) directed
the Postmaster General “to pial art compensation to he’ paid
from and after the. first day of July, 1876, for transportation of .
mails on railroad rdgtes by reducing the poniedinesitne to all railroad
companies for the transportation of mails ten per centum per annunt
from the rates fixed and allowed” by a prior act. . By its very terms
14.
‘For example, when Congress established the. parcel post
system in 1912, it- failed to provide for a general increase
in mail rates. For ) years railroads were unable to obtain :
this statute Was retroactive. Tr was held ineumlcaide ¢ to certain
railroads, on the ground that under their contracts no right tad been
Tese ‘rved: to change the pay if mail service were ae Chicago
» Northwestern Ry. Co. v. Untted States, 104. U.S. 680; Chicago,
M: Tmaukee & St. Paul Ry, Co. v. United States rie U.S. 687; see
St. Paul & Duluth Rd, Co. v. United States, 112 U: S. 733, 7385.
As to other railroads, however, the statute was held applicable: and -
given effect. Jaéksonville, Pensacola: & Mobile Rd. Co. v. United
States, 118 U.S. 626; Eastern Rd. Co. v. United States, 129 U.S.
391,° 395-3596; Wisconsin Central. Rd. Co. v. United States, 164
UL S. 190; cf. Chicago, Mili vaukee & St. ‘Paul Ry. Co. v. United .
States, 198.U. S. 885, 3389. ; ;
Similarly, the Act of August 24, 1912 ¢. 389, $4 637 Stat. 539,
554; 39 U. S.C. $474) provided for readjustment of mail - pay in
certain cases vice mail was diverted’ from: a railroad; “readjust--
ment made hereunder shall not take effect before. July first. nineteen
hundréd and twelve,.and shall) be. for diversions occurring .after
January first, nineteen hundred and twelve.” This statute was ap-
plied in Missourt, Kansas & .Texas Ry. Co. ©. United States, 256
U. S. 610, Plaintiff was carrying’ mail ‘under’ a 1910 contract,
Early in 1912 it discontinued a ‘fast train which had been operating
when the 1910 contract was made. “After the statute was passed,
the Postmaster, General ‘ordered the mail diverted from plaintiff's
line to two other raileoads. In 1913 the Postmaster General di-
minished plaintiff’s mail ee and increased the two other lines’
“compensation; as of July 1, 1912. This Court sustained his .order.
Mr. Justice Holmes said (p. 614): ;
“The statute itself contemplates a readjustment in respect
of past services, since it was not approved until August 24,
1912, and allows a readjustment from .the first of the pre-
vious July. As the change in pay is made in respect of a
change that has ‘occurred in the service by which the current.
pay was fixed, the railroad suffers no injustice, and, as we
have said, by the terms of its iste came it took the risk
of such a statute being passed.”
-
7 The parcel post system was inaugurated effective January I,-
— 1918... Act of August 24, 1912, ¢. 389; 37 Sta*. 557. At that time
‘mail rates were based’ on the weight of. the mails carried, rather
7.)
‘adequate relief, although seme legislation was passed to
improve their situation.® - Finally in 19167 Congress au-
_ thorized increases in their pay for, carrying parcel post, |
‘retroactive to stated dates in 191; 3 and 1914.2 At the same _
‘ime—July 28, 1916—the Railway Mail Pay Act ‘‘author-
ized and directed”’ the Postmaster General “to réadjust
the compensation to be paid to railroad companies from
‘and after the thirtieth day of June, nineteen hundred and
sixteen, or as soon thereafter as may be practicable’’ for
mail of all kinds at the rates hereinafter providéd.’*!" .
Likewise, the revision of the Air Mail Act of 1934 in
August 1935 provided that compensation under existing
contracts, for carry ing air mail ‘‘shall be paid at the rate
fixed py order. of the Commission under this act’? from—
a ctr ee ete enn enemecnee ———— ween cone ne eee — nn ee
than the space ‘occupied. sine sek “weil ie a pro-
portionate to the space occupied, than- regular. mail. Hence the
new system acted to reduce the carriers’, compensation. ‘The original
act authorized an increase in the compensation of “star.rotttes and
*screen*wagon contractors” on proof of inadéquacy. See 37 Stat.
558; Halstead ’v.: United States, 55 C. Cl. 31%; Hooton v. United
States, 58 C. Cl. 639: -No such ’inerease was authorized for rail-
roads; “there was.a widespread belief that the railroads were over-
paid.” St. Lows Southwestern-Ry. Co. v; United States, ° 262.0. a.
TO, 75.
‘While the Act of March 4, 1913, ¢. 143 (37 Stat. 797) per-
mitted the Postmaster General to make a limited increase in the
railroads’ compensation after July 1, 1913, it was purely discretion-
-ary. If he failed to exercise his discretion, the railroads; were left
witliout r-medy. United States v. Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry.
Co., 24 .S. 451; St: Louis Southi vestern Ry, Co. v. United States
262 U. >. 20, 73.
* Act of July 28, 1916, c. 261, $$5 ok 4 (39. Stat. 425). quoted
infra, pp. Bi0-B1l. See St Louis Southwestern Ry. Co. v. United
States, 262 U.S. 70, 73, footnote 2. : \;
1 Act of July 28, 1916, ¢. 261, 85, subdivision 1 (3% Stat. 425),
quoted infra, p. B11. . ,
fe oe
“on and after March 1, 1935.°°" Decisions under this
statute are reviewed infra, pp. 03-09, is
Adjusting inequitabie mail rates by special legislation -
s, however, a-cumbersome and slow. precess at best. Re-|
Vision by an’ adininistrative agency can be: more flexible
and less dilatory. Hence Congress created the Board to.
take over the burden. for it in. the field of air transporta-
tion. es
The Act conferred on the Board sufficiently Nil power
to enable it to cope with all situations that might arise, thus
: reducing appeals for legislative relief to a Minimum.” By
the unique language of §406(a)(1) of the Act—itself
unique statute—Congress delegated to the Board plenary
power to correct its false prophecies by adjusting mail
rates retrospectively, ‘without regard to: any ‘arbitrary
filing date. | }
By §406(a) (1) the Board is ‘Ceinpwered aa directed”?
to ‘‘make such rates effective from such date as it shall
* On its face, this language is
pertectly clear. Indeed, in 1943 the Board remarked on
“the plain language of the statute relative to the Board’ 3.
> determine to be proper.’
discretionary power make rates effective from such date
as.it deems proper.’’. American Airlines, Inc. et al., Mail
Rates, + C. A. B. 90, 93. Curiously enough, in 1947 it
thought that ‘ambiguity ix clearly present?’ (68).
More comprehensive words than are found in 406(a) (1)
would be hard to ‘imagine. Ax the Board pointed out in
| ee
1b Act of “August 14, 1935, c. 530, §8; 1 Stat. 617, quoted mifra,
pp. BlO-BIL. oes 7 es cers
Ok, United States v. Newe York Centrat Rd) Co., 279 U.
13, 79: . “Obviously: Congress intended the Commission to: dt
the whole bustness, not to leave a straggling residuum to look out for
ityatt, with possible danger to the validity of the Act.”
,
Oo
NS
re Ww
ove of its first mail rate cases, it is given broad diseretion
to select any date deemed proper. ‘The language of see-
tion 406 (a) gives to the Authority {Board| the right to’
exercise a sound discretion in determining the prope r date
on which a rate shall be made effective. Pan American
Airways Co. (of Nevada)—Mail Rates, he, A. A. 389, 409.
s°
No limitation on that discretion is imposed, although’ of
- course the. Board must regard the statutory abiectiyes.
The Board stated this forcefully. i in Ame rican Airlines, Ine.
—Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 C. A. B. 323, 331:
“We conclude that section 406 (a) of the Act:
vests in the Board complete discretion to determine
the date upon which its orders theteunder shall be-
come effective. ‘In exercising this discretion, we are.
limited only by the procedural requirements of no-
tice and hearing and by the necessity of promoting
the broad objectives of the Act.’’"%
Thus the unwieldy process of petitioning Congress for
special legislation to cor rect past Jnequities has been obvi-_
ated. Of course the Board is not compelled to make re-
trospectiv e changes regardless of circumstances—any more
than was Congress. It must, however, after hearing and
Ww eighing all the facts-of: the particular case, select a proper: ;
effective date. It can be the day on ‘which its order. is
issued, or even a future day. Likewise it cajn’ be a past
day which may or may lot-antedate the institution of the.
rate proceeding. Complete pliability- is the essence of the
statutory scheme in this respect.
8 The Board reiterated this conclusion im olmerican Airlines, (ne.
vt al. Mail Rates, 4 C. A. B. 90, 92. ‘The statutory objectives are
set forth inf Sections 2 and t06¢b) of the Act; see pp. 37-39, B1-B2,
Bi2z-BL3 mnfra.
18
: ~ ‘ .
The sweeping scope of £406(a)(1) is illuminated by its
contrast with other parts of the Act dealing with changes
, in public utility rates for carrying passengers and cargo.
All air carriers must file with the Board “tariffs show-
ing all rates; fares and charges” for passenger’ and cargo
transportation, under §403(a4 of the Act, 49 y. S. Cc.
S483(a). The carrier. may ¢hange threse rites, but only pros-
pectively. ‘*No change shall be made in any rate, fare, or
charge... specified in any effective tariff . .. except
after thirty days’ notice of the proposed change . Such
notice shall plainly state . . . the time such cate shall
_ take effect. The Board may in the public interest... . al-
low such change upon notice _ than that herein specified
. .’* §403(¢c) of the Act, 49 U. S. C. §483 (ce). So too the
Board may review the filed rates and fix different’ ones,
but only in futuro, for §1002(d) of the Act, 49 U.S. C.
-§642(d), provides: | _ §
‘‘Whenever, after notice and hearing ... .- the
Board shall be of the opinion, that any individual or,
joint rate, fare, or charge demanded, charged, col-
lected or received by any air carrier ... is or will
‘be unjust or unreasonable ...°. the Board shall de-
_termine and prescribe the lawful rate, fare, or charge
. thereafter to be demanded, charged, collected
or received or the lawful classification, rule, regula-
tion or practice thereafter to’ be made effee-
Ee lites
Similarly, (404(a) of the Act, 49 U.S. ¢. ‘484(a), re--
quires air carriers to ‘establish just, reasonable, dnd
‘cadeaaekos ‘
'§ Manifestly. the Board's power under this’ section - is purely
prospective, Cf. Public Unhities Cominission of Ohio vy. United Fuel
Gas Co., 317: U. S, 456, 464." ;
19.
equitable divisions’’ of joint’ passenger an: cargo rates
‘tas between air carriers."’ The Board may ‘‘upon com-
plaint or upon its Owar’ mitiative’’ investigate ‘the divi-
sions of joint rates’? and ‘‘prescribe the just, reasonable,
and equitable divisions thereof to be received by the, sev-
eral air carriers.”’ (1002(h), 49 UL S.C. §642(h). That
section goes on to say: ¢
‘*The Board may. require the adjustment of divisions
sy between such air carriers from the date of filing the
complaint or-entry of order ef investigation, or such
other date subsequent thereto, as the Board finds to
be just, reasonable and sac tiie
-
‘Thus when Congress. wanted to prevent the Board from—
taking any retrospec tive action, it said so. W hen it wanted
to prevent the Board from taking retrospective action back -
of the date of a proceeding, it said so. It said! nothing of
the sort in §406(a)(1).! Instead it gave the Board fall au-
-thority to make mail pay rates “effective from such date”’
-—past, present or future—‘‘as it shall determine to be
proper.’’ This marked contrast betweeti §406(a)(1) and
the other provisions of the Aét v was completely ignored be-
low. . mae
| The opinion below reads into the flexible langnage of
§406(a) (1) a rigid limitation on the Board’s power.’® .The: .
Board ‘is to determine ‘‘fair and reasonable rates of com-
pensation,’’ and it may make the rate ‘‘effective from such
date as it shall determine to he proper”? —but not if that
date i is earlier than the filing date of the rate proceeding.
A rate may become unfair and unreasonable on one day.
_— —
15
. we should not write in limitations which Congress did
not see fit to make.” Price v. Johnston, 334 U. S. 266, 284.
\ e 20
«
-
If -the rate proceeding does not start until a month later,
however, the Board is held powerless to remedy the- past
injustice, for it may not make the fair rate effective as of
the day wien the. old one becanie confiseatory. Full relief
may be granted only if, by some lucky coincidence, a rate
proceeding happens to be pending on that day for Some
* totally different reason.’
For, example, on March 1 two sites may be sank
* affected by the: sudden grounding of airplanes which, they .
both use.” If a rate proceeding involving airline X ‘hap-
pens to be pending at the time, the Board is free to adjust
.X’s mail rate to allow for the increased. costs due.to the
grounding. If-no rate proceeding involving airline Y. is
pending 6n March 1, liowever, the Board is unable to adjust
Y’s mail rate back to March 1, although Y’s need for
increased mail pay may be exactly the same as X’s. It
‘must stop short’ at‘the later date when the rate proceeding
involving: Y got under way."
16 Rate ace before the Board ° generally . take from one
to four years. See Civil Aeranautics Board, Report of Formal Eco-
nomic Proceedings, March 31, 1948, p. 41, showing one mail -rate
“proceeding which had been pending for over four years, four pro-
ceedings pending: for over three years, fivé proceedings pending for
over two years, and fifteen proceedings pending for over one year,
'In Braniff - Airwiys, ‘Inc., Order No, E-2129, Oct. 28, 1948
the Board pointed’ out that “costs attributable to the grounding of
aircraft types are neither normal nor recurrent in nature,” aiid “are
neither predictable nor capable of actual measurement on a prospec-
tive basis” (P. 18).
18 Such a situation has actually geveloped. On, November 1, 194%,
all DC-6 airplanes were-grounded. American Aviation Daily, Nov.
12, 1947, p. 210. Both United Air Lines, Ine. and American Air- |
lines, Inc. were using DC-6 aircraft and receiving the same mail rate.
U ‘nited had a rate proceeding pending; ‘Ameriean’ had none. The:
DC-6" ‘airplanes were gradually restored to service between | March
.
The Act contains no such arbitrary limitation on the
Board’s power. It has simply been imported into the
Mn
statute by main force. This-amendment of the statute by.
judicial fiat is the more unwarranted because it makes it
impossible for an airline to obtain full redress when a rate
prophecy is mocked by events.
Even when-a sudden catastrophe occurs, and rates are
-bound: to be affected, it is not physically possible for an
airline. to act instantly. .The Act requires a petition to
-be:more than a routine ‘piece of paper. The airline must
make a conscientious estimate of a fair rate. ‘*Any peti-
tion for the fixing of fair and reasonable rates of compensa-
‘tion under this Section shall inelude a statement of the rate
the petitioner believes to be fair and reason»ble.”’ §406(e),
§49 U.S.C. 6486(c). If an airline i is to. comply ‘sincerely
with §406(e),.it cannot possibly file a petition. the-moment
a disaster occurs. Especially is that true when the calamity
is of uncertain duration, stich as a strike or the grounding
of airplanes, so-that one can only speculate whether its
effect will pass quickly or persist indefinitely.
The rule adopted below operates just-as arbitrarily when Nef
the unfairness of a rate develops imperceptibly, as it usu-.
ally does. ‘It is impracticable to determine when. a rate,,
reasonable at the time of establishment, ‘will become unrea-
sonable.’’ Air-Mail re aentatoie 206.1. C. C. 675, 725.
nm a ee eee — a
11 and June 1, 1948. On April 7 7, 1948, the ‘Poecd piopoeed to in-*
- crease United’s rate temporarily bagk to January 1, 1948. At the |
‘same time it instituted a proceeding proposing to increase American's
mail rate—but only as of April 7,,1948, since no proceeding was
pending before then! See Orders Nos. E-1351 and’ E-1355, -Apr.
7, 1948, The proceedings are still pending, and United may expect
‘to receive compensation reflecting losses arising cut of the grounding,
but. American may not.
r
Y
It is equally impracticable to detect exactly when a‘ fair
rate becomes unfair.. Even after unfairness is suspected,
the airline may quite reasonably attr ibute its lossés to other
causes, No ins
rument exists which ‘records the precise
moment when a f ir rate passes into confiscation. ° With all
the advantage of knowledge after the event, the Board’s
attempt (years later)\ to fix the day when the rate became
unfair will be only an ‘juformed guess.
Yet the airline is now told that it must rush to fhe Board |
‘with a petition whenever it\y ‘emotely suspects that a rate
-may--have become unfair, or ‘isk losing part of its just.
‘eompensation. It delays at its peril, for the Board ‘will be
powerless to grant relief if hindsight shows that the rate
was unfair before. the petition was filed. Thus a premium
is put on hasty, ill-considered petitions s, and a penalty is
‘imposed on the airline which files a petition only after
events have actually indicated that its fears were well-
fourided. It is a curious theory indeed which: re; wards ‘the |
rash and penalizes the prudent airline. \
Actually the Board has repeatedly exercised ‘the pow er
to obviate such untoward consequences which is now disa-
vowed. Until the decision below, it never denied that it
had power to make mail rates retrospéctively effective,
from any date. The most that it stated wasthat ‘‘as a
matter of sound general policy there should be no adjust- >
ments in mail rates during periods when a rate case is not
pending.’”’ ‘Braniff Airways, Inc., Mail Rates for Routes
" Nos. 9,15 and 50,3 C. A. B. 633, 63 6."9 It would be idle to
ae
’% For other similar “policy” statements, see Transcontinental’ &
Western Acr, Inc., Mail Rates, 4 C. A. B, 139,.142-143; All American
‘Aviation, Inc... Mail Rate for Route No. 49, 4 C. A. B. 354, 356-357;
Pacific Alaska dirways, Inc., Mail Rates, 6 C. A. B. 61, 70; Carib- ;
.
-talk of a ‘‘general”’ rane if tlie Board lack cod power to
vary oe
-Moreover, time and again the Board has both aacealiail
and exercised the power to make. rates effective as of a
time earlier than tht start of a rate proceeding. As the
‘cases are ‘rather lengthy and somewhat technical, they are
reviewed i in detail in “Appendix A hereto. When these. cases
are read with the decision below, it-would seem that the -
Board mast regard 6406(a) (1) as providing that:
ee Board is empowered and directed * * * to make
"such rates effective from such date as it shall deter-.
mine to be ] proper, but only if that date does not an-
tedate the date when the Board institutes a proceed-
ing on its own initiative or when the carrier or the.
Postmaster General files a petition, unless (a) the.
rate is belng established for a new route, or-(b) the -
-rate changes a rate previously established by con-
tract only, r (c) the rate changes a previous rate
which the Board labelled a‘‘temporary’ or ‘tentative’
rate, or (d), the Board perniits the petition tosxbe
filed or amended nunc pro tunc some date earlier
than its. actual filing, or (e). the Board decides to
‘reopen’ an earlier proceeding and’ issue an
‘amended’ or ‘revised’ order, or (f) the carrier be-
gins a new route and the Board desires (although
it is not réquired) to adjust comperrsation retro-
spectively to an earlier date on a ‘system’. basis,
but in that event it may make the adjusted rate —
retrospective to such-earlier date-only if it is lower
than the’ previous rate.’’
—- EE eee rt Mee ee
‘bean-Atlantic Airlines, Inc., Mail Rate, 7-C. A. B. 943, 946. ‘Ta o ty -
ewo cases did the Board specifically leave open the question whether
power existed. * Continental Air Lines, Inc—Mail nates for Routes
Wos. 29 and 43,3 C. A. B. 395,401; Mid-Continent Airlines, lic.—
Mail Rates for Routes Nos, 20 and 48, 3 C. A. B. 464, 466.
Se ag om ee es Sg Sane = 4
os = IPhis complicated hodge spodie of. Ure -efied: dnd me: ming-
1 ~3- ‘distinctions is now offered as What Congress is sup-
posed fv have intende d by. the <imple, clear words of
406 (aL, It is little wonder that, awhe nm the. Board’ s
Public: Counsél originally moved to- “Ainpaies TWA’s peti-
tion, they did not Claim that the Hoard. had. no power, to.
wr aunt it. “Indeed, as late: as April 18, 147, Public C ‘oursel
“asserted: pane eet ONT RS aan \
ee 3 J aE ea ee
+: Although the Board: Tias. the power to fix a rate to
i effxtive prior to the dute of the ‘institution of. a
U/ hate proceeding, it has consistently held as a
should be niade in mail rates during "periods: {when
a2 folers rates pr oceedings: ‘ire not piesa 0 os |
The: clear, express wands: of “£406 (a) (1) show that ‘Pie
Board has the power ta fix a rate to be. effective prior to.
_“the. alate of the institution ofa mail rate proceeding.” The
Act. ‘means “fisewkat it —
« iS % © a . F . -
fie ‘Motion of. ‘Public Curbed Bice ek Redding to dismiss. peti-s
[tiem Yer a retrospective “rate, Wafter of Mail Coinpe nsation of Penn-
4
Veyfitrud Cen: ‘ral Airlines Corp, Docket No. 484. As the cases. cited
\
a ji \ppend ix A show the. Boatd has:not “consistently held” even to ~
hetooreral polity” to Wwaich Pt Public: Caunsel referred: © 4
P iahhic ( sourisel > origyn UKAmotion in’the present case argued -only_
*, the propriety of the TACT increase (43-21). TAWA’s answer
—ovited .faritiliar® authorities showing that t] ic Boaril could not abdicate
its, pt wey hy denying a heating on the merits” (22-24)... Then,. two
Spednths after the original motion, Publi 4¢ Counsel amended the motion
ca Bs to cost tend that no*such .pawery existed (38). The claim’ of
Tacky oi poms ‘Wi as a sheer ‘afte rthought, ai CF he Na °
atter of sound. general policy’ that. no adjustments .-
>
5 eee
POINT IT. 2 00.
The Court of Appeals relied on an inapplicable pre-
sumption against a retrospective ee
The Court of Appeals admitted that the Act uses lan-
guage which could aptly confer power to make ret rospective-
changes in, rates.”! To] pare it down, it resorted to a’ series:
of false analogies. ae
“In the first place,” ‘said the Court, ‘we are met with
the almost conclusive presumption. against power ‘to’ take’
retroactive action unless Congress | plainly ‘specifies , such:
power”? (112). If there were any such ‘presumption, ’? the
er language of (406(a)(1.) would be more than. ample to rebut
it. ‘But, as the Court’ s citation of Nedd v. District ‘of €o-
lumbia, 71 App. D,_C..306, 110 F. (2d) 246," shows, it com- .
pletely misapplied the familiar principle that ‘‘unless the
contrary plainly appears a statute ‘applies prospectively
only.”? 110 F. (2d), at p. 254. Since the Act has been in
effect all along, it ‘‘applies prospectively only”’ no matter
-- how it is construed. - : av :
‘Ordinarily, statutes establish. rules for the future,”’
Brewstér v. Gage, 280 U- S. 327, 337,:an@gsince ‘‘the court
will presume that the lawmaking power is acting for the
: “future only and not for the past,’’ W hite v. United States,
191 U.S. 545, 552, “ ‘laws are not to-be considered as apply-
ing to cases which arose before their passage ee as
intention be clearly declared, Shwab v. Doyle, 258 U.
529, 534. That is all as presumption against: retroactivity
— : ey
—e
* te eee s , ' ae , .
““1°The language of the disputed clause 1s not -necessarily re-
troactive. It-is as apt in reference to the future as it is to the past”
Li) eee ane aes, 3 | -
The presumption ‘has’ no. application to Judicial or
administrative action taken purguant to a statute after its
passage., To be sure, in certain respects the meaning of a
statute may not become known until after, it has been judi-
cially construed. In that sense, every case of :first impres-
sion interpreting a statute necessarily has some retrospec-
tive effect, since it determines what the statute meant as
well as what it means. Manifestly, however, the presump-
tion against a retroactive interpretation. ia no relation.
. whatever to the unavoidable fact that.often the meaning of
a law is not known until it is judicially + dec lared later.
Securities & Kxchange,Comm, v. Chenery Corp., 33210. S.
194, 203:204. Rather the presumption is intended to insure
that the legal effect of acts will be determined: ordinarily
by the statutes then in existence (whenevér judicially Cou-
strued) instead of by later legislation.
Hence. a statute - ‘is not interpreted | retroactively when,
as here, it operi ates. only on situations coming into existence
after its passage. “Muljord v. Smith, 307 U. S. 38, 51;
Wickard v. Filburn, 317 U.S. 111, 153. Indeed, a ait
‘is not rendered retroactive merely because the ‘facts or.
requisites: upon whieh its subsequent action depends, or
some of them, \re drawn from a time antecedent to the en-
actment.’’ Reynolds v. United States, 292 U. S. 443, 449.22
In fact, the Neild ease so held: 110 F. (2d); at p. 250.
_ This is not {he case of ‘a new law reaching backwards.’
Woeds v. Stone. $33 U. S. 472, 477. The Act has been in
- effect since 1938. This pane concertis the fairness of
22 See also, Cax v. Hart, ee Lis 23, 435; Great Northern Ry.
Co. Vv: Sutherland, 273 U. S. eo uae we Fidelity o Deposit
Co. of Kfaryland, 292 U. S. oe 5t1: United Sta ites Ve Jacobs, 306
LoS. 365, 367; ef. Gryger v. Burke, 334 U.S. T28, 732.
a rate during 1946 and 1947. . Throughout the entire period
involved in this case, the Act was in force. There can be
10 ‘tclaim of -retroactivity’’ where-a statute Involves a
F ‘recomputation by the state | Board | of, taxes [mail pay |
under a statute whic h was e xistent’ through the whole pe riod
in question.’’ JHinors‘€ ‘entral Rd. Co. v. Minnesota, 309
U.S. 157, 164. ‘*Readjustment under these conditions can-
not be said to be retroactive law making.’ W oods Vv. Stone,
333 U.S. 472, 478. The ‘almost conclusive presumption’
on which tlie Court of Appeals relied is non-existent.
«
P «
POINT HII,
The Court of Appeals relied on, a. false analogy to
public utility rate statutes.
¢
The Court of Appeals also rested heavily on a supposed
* analogy to public utility rate statutes. ‘The whole is cast
in the form of the usual public utility -rate-determination
measure. “Such-measures are frequently mage effective as of:
the date of the inauguration of the proceedings, but never,
so far as we know, for periods prior thereto’ (114). There.
fore the unique language of 406(a)(1), which is found in
no publié utility rate statute, was cut down to mean some-
‘thing less than it says.
‘Even if the Court’s assumption- —that §406 of the Act
is the ‘‘usual public utility rate-determination measure’’—
were correct, its conclusion would not follow. ‘‘A restric-
\ wr r
“8 See also, Manhattan General Equipment Co. v. Commissioner
of Internal Revenue, 297 U S. 129, 1357 Helvering v. Reynolds,
sey, 428, 433\ Cf. Usiited States Vo New York Central Rd. Ce..
279 UL S. 33, 79: Nmerican Airtines, Inc —Mail Rate Proceeding,
3C.°A. 8 323, 328. \ : ‘ ;
%
.
tive interpretation ‘should not be given a statute merely
beeatse Congress has chosen to depart from = custom.’’
Uuited States v. Sullivan, 332 U.S. 689, 6932 And there -
were excellent reasous why Congress did not choose to
apply public utilityirate principles to airmail pay.
1. Undoubtedly in many respects the Act embodies
publie utility procedures.. The Act -is hybrid in origin.
Its provisions as to certificates of public conyenience and
necessity, passenger and cargo rate regulation, disclosure —
of ownership, interlocking relatignships; and so forth, are
directly derived from sections of the Interstate Commerce.
Act, particularly those dealing with motor: carriers. But,
as will appear shortly, the Act’s mail pay provision, $406,
has an entirely aia and different purposes.
The only similarity between the ‘‘usual public utility rate-
determination measure’? and $406 is. that both employ the
‘word ‘‘rates’’,”° and that the agencies used to fix the
‘frates”’ are called Boards. ee |
Of course, the fact that’ mail pay is determined by a’
Board of five men rather than (as in earlier days) by one
man, the Postmaster General, is of no significance. It is
equally irrelevant that ¢406-uses the word “rates.”
. Basically ‘the airline is ‘entitled to receive reasonable
compensation’’ for ‘carrying the mails, as §401(m) of the
-Act provides. The’ ‘‘fair and reasonable rates of compen-.
Z
z
(
sation’? which the Board fixés -under (406 are,only the’) @”
. ° ie . f t
a
——————nne
*4 See also. Shapiro v. United States, 335 U. S.1, 31, footnote 40,
. * The Court of Appeals seemed to attach considerable significance _
te the word. “This is the method ordinarily employed by authori-
tics in regulating the charges of public utilities. The word ordi-
narily used is ‘rates’ ” (113).
S
means whereby the end result of ‘‘reasonable compensa-,
tion’? is computed.*® As an-airline is not obliged to trans-
port a stated quantity of mail during any given period, it
‘total’compensation for that period cannet be fixed in ad-
| ] ] Y
vance, Necessarily the ¢ ompensation is expressed in terms
of a ‘‘rate”’ per unit. Multiplying the yumber of units car-
ried-by the rate gives the total ‘‘reasonable compensation.’”
When the facts are known, however, the process works just
as easily in reverse. Thus, when the Board adjusts mail
pay retrospectively to the date of institution of a proceed-
ing it first hits upon a total figure which it believes will
provide reasonable compensation, then divides it by the
rumber of units and (reasoning backwards) arrives at an
applicable rate.?7 |
-It is simply bad logie,. moreover, to ‘conclude that. the
Act takes over in a body all the rules peculiar to public
utility rate determination because both public utility
charges and mail pay are expressed in terms of. “rates”?
As a matter of fact, fh was settled long ago that Carrying
see Hee
+ Cf, United States v. Griffin, 303 U. . 226, 237: “While the
compensation fixed in a tajlway mail pag bao is ordinarily meas-_
ured by a rate, the ultimate question decided by the Commission: is
. the proper compensation to be paid by the Government to the —
railroad for services and the use of its property—the quantuin me ruit
for carrying the mail.” ; J
“t-For instance, in Chicago & Southern Air Lines, Order No.
E-1825 (July 28, 1948), the Board fixed a per unit rate from and
after, January 1, 1948, but at the same time awarded the Jump sum
- of °$3,139,000 as additional mail pay for the two-year period freriiy
January 1, 1946 to December 31, 1947. As an afterthought it added
in a. footnote: “This amount of mail pay is eq te 20.69 cents
per airplarte mile flown in scheduled service” (Orders. 2), Thus
was the “rate” determined. For other examples,/ see infra notes
415 and 47. .
ea se re
the mail is not a public utility funetion. ‘The company
in carrying the mails was not hauling frtight, nor was it
acting as a common carrier, with cor responding rights and |
liabilities, but in this respect it was serving as anagency
of government.”’ Alchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v.
United States, 225 U.S. 640, 649.2% Yet for a century both
legislation and judicial opinions have referred to mail pay
‘as being ‘‘fixed’’ by ‘‘rates.’’
Even before railroads were used to carry mails, mail ,
pay Was expressed in terms of ‘trates’? or ‘rates of com-
pensation, ’**° In 1845 a statute was passed to insure an
‘‘equal and just rate of secmaod for the railroads
*“ See also, . United = v. Hamburg-Amerikanische Packet-
fanrt, cleticn Gesellsghaft, 212 Fed. 40, 45 (@ C. A. 2); Bankers’
Ag utual Caeeony Co. Vv. Uigeee St, Paul & SOS. M. Ry. Co, WF
Fed. 434,.439 (C2 C. A. 8); United Fruit Co. v. Unite d States, 33
- (2d) 664, 666 (C.C. A. 5); United States v. Atlantic Coast Line
R. Co., 206 Fed. 190, 194; ; Railway Mail Pay, 269 1. C. C.-357,-36%
** Railroads were. first désik gnated as “post routes” by the ee
of July 7,°1538, c. 171, $25 Stat. 268, 283. ;
8 Section 2 of the Act of February 20, 1792, c..7, 1 Stat. 282,
fixed maximum mail pay in terms of the ‘postage rates which were
stipulated in $$ and 10. Tt authorized the .“Postmastér General.
to entér into contracts, for a term of not exceeding eight years, for
extending the fine of. posts, and to authorize the person or persons,
so contracting, to receive, during the continuance of such contract,
‘according to the rates by this act established, all the postage which
shall arise on letters, new or and packets, conveyed by <a -such °
post,” 1 Stat. 233. ,
See also §2 ef the Act of May 8, 174, 23, 1° Stat. 354, 357;
which prescribed that the é “compensation” icaiad by mail carriers .
‘ should be “at rates” not exceeding the postage on the mail carried;
and the Act of May 14, 1536, 5 Stat. 132, which authorized the Post~-
‘master General, “provided the same can be done at the. present
rates uf compensation, to extend the term of the existing contracts
for the transportation of the mail...”
31.
carrying mail.*' A consolidation of the mail pay statutes
in N72 contained six references to “rates, “rates of com.
vensation’’ and the like? Many muatl pay statutes still on
; 2 * ] ee. : i ;
.
*! See $19 of the Act of March 3, Isddce. 44. 5 Stat. 732, T58-
739: 3 Renee
mae “That to-insuée, as far as may be practicable, an equal and
just rate of compensation, according to the service performed,
among the several railroad companies in the United States.
for, the transportation of the mail, it shall be the duty of
the Postmaster General to arrange and: divide the railroad
routes . . . into three classes... and it shall be lawful
for him to contract for conveying the mail with any such rail- ¥ :
road company . ... Provided, That, for the conveyance of the *
mail 6n any railroad af the first class, be shall not payoa ngher
rate.of compensation than is now allowed by law’. . . [And in
case the’ Postmaster General shall not be ablé té conclude a con-
tract for carrying the mail en any of such railway routes, at
a compensation not exceeding the aforesaid mevinium rates,
or for what he may deém a reasonable and fair compensa- |
tion for the service to be performed, it shall be lawful for him
} tosseparate the letter mail from the residue. of the mail, and
to contract ... . for.conveying the letter mail . . . -by horse
express or otherwise . . .| nd provided further, That if it. :
shall be found Necessary to convey over any railroad route
more than two mails daily, it shall be lawful for the Post-
master General to pay such additional compensation as he
may think. just and reasonable, having reference to the servy-
iges performed and the maximum rate of allowante established
by this act.” ‘hee ese ‘
The bracketed portion of the statute survived in paraphrase until.
quite recent days, the words quoted in italics being retained. See -
39 U.S. C.-$521, repealed by Act of February 28,-1933, c. 131, $1,
AT Stat. 1349., Ve es org. eR ce mies
32 Act of June 8, 1872, c. 335, 17 Stat, 283.. See $210. (“each F
railway company shall receive, so.far as practicable, a proportionate
and just rate of compensation, according to the service: performed”) ;
S211. ("the Postmoster-General may pay twenty-five per centum in
addition .t6 the above rates”); $212 (a codification of the. statuté
quoted in brackets. supra in footnote 31): $214 (“until such price
“is fixed by law, the Postmiaster-General may fix the rate of com-
,
32
the books contain like refere nees.** The word ‘“r utes?” Wass
commonly employ ed in earlier air mail statutes which were
not ** public utility rate-determination measures’? by. any
stretch of the imagination."* Legislation adjusting mail
*?
pay retroactively has been phrased in terms of “rates,
and even ‘“‘rates’’ to be fixed in futuro.®*’ = age numer-
ous opinions had referred to the ‘fixing’? of ‘‘rates’’.of
mail pay.* —- .
* sesination” ); $257. (“The Postmaster-General shall provide for-.
the carrying of the mafl on such route at as low rate as possible”) ;.
$265 (“The Postmaster-General may allow.* *-* such additional
coupe usation * * * as he may think fit, not jexcceding, however, ifty
per centum of ‘the said rales)... 8
33 See, ¢.g., 39 US. C. S441 (‘The ‘Postmaster General shal not
R elie the service under: any contract either now existing or
hereaiter given toa rate of pay exceeding 50 per centum upon the con-
iract as originally let’); 39 U. S.C. $448 (“Such payment shall
not in «any case exceed the rate of pay per annum of the contractor
‘or subcontractor”); 39 U.S. C. $450 (“when there is no. compe-
tition for inkigd transportation . . . and the rate of-compensation
asked is excessive .*. . the Postmaster General may require that
the mails be carried eas freight or express”); 39 U.°S. C. $541la
(“the compensation for such service to be a rate not in excess of the
rate that wovld be allowed for similar service by railroad or electri¢
car”), Bass bam Wee
$4 See infra, note 64. - - prt Danes '
+
%9 ‘Thus, the Reiley Mail Pay Act, enacted. July 28, 1916, pro--
vided for a readjustment of mail compensation back to. June 30,
1916, “at the rates hereinafter provided.” See supra, note 10 and ;
infra, p. BV. Similarly, the Air Mail Act of 1935, enacted in August |
1935, provided that compensation under existing mail contracts “shall
be paid’ at the-xate fixed by the Commission ‘under: this Act” from
“on and after March 1, 1955:" Sce supra, note 11, and wfra, p, B11.
For other examples, see supra, note 6.
#8 See, ¢.g., Jacksonville, Pensacola & Mobile Rd. Co. v. Uiited—
States, 11S U.S. 626, 6280 After the termination of this contract:
the petitioner continued to carry the mail. as préviously, without any
notice from the Postiaster-General that the price to be allowed: for
33
Plainly (406 did not take over peculiar public utility
9
principles when it used the word ‘‘rates.’? On the con-
trary, it was merely’ employing’ traditional mail pay lan-.
guage, in vogue long before public utility statutes came
into being. In short, it isa gross fallacy to draw any infer- |
7
ence from the faet that the word ‘‘rates’
this Act and public utility. rate legislation.
appears both i m
‘
2. Moreover, the rule—-already referred to—that carry-
ing the mail is not a public utility function reflects vital
practical differences between mail pay and public utility:
rates, which are made in this very Act.
+, As a common carrier of: passengers and eargo by ‘air,
TWA deals directly with the general public—a large, fluc-
tuating group of travellers and shippers. It collects its
charges from each customer individually. Every change
in its passenger or freight rates directly hits the pocket-
books. of its customers. Retrospective increases of those
rates ¢ are: not practically feasible, any more than a retro-
the service would be in any respect different, until the’ 21st March,
de when he fixed the rate of compensation at a less sum”) ; Allman
United States, 131 U. S. 31, 34 (“These allowances did not ex-
ceed 50 per cent of the rate of compensation fixed -by the contracts
as originally let, though they did exceed 50 per cent of Wie sum
named in those contracts’ "); Wisconsin C éntral Rd. Cov. United
States, 164 U. S. 190, 205 (“We agree entirely with the. can of
Claims that the terms and conditions imposed on this gtant embraced
_ the condition that the’ mail should be carried at such rates as Congress
. night pe ¢ i a Lackawanna & Western Rd. Co. v. United
States, 249 U. 385, 387 (“The rate thus fired was paid for two
years”); The pr Divisor Cases, 251 U. S. 326, 330 (“The rates
were fixed and reduced in their maxima but that was all that was
~ done with — to them’\); Grand ‘Trunk Western Ry. Co. v
United States, 252 U.S. 112, 120 (‘I fAhe railroad was ‘and-aided,
payment of more than exghty per cent: Of the full rates otherwise pro-
vided by law was énauthorized”).
»’
spective increase vee other public utility rate is feasible
in practice.” Onde a customer has paid the published tariff,
he does not have to concern himself with future changes 1 in
it; it would be intolerable to make an individual passenger
or shipper pay a higher rate years later,,even though strictly
he had been charged too little. Neer F
Theoretically a court could say that an electric company,
for example, was entitled to collect a higher rate from each
of tenthousand persons who had already paid their bills,
retrospectively to some past day. As a practical matter,
the increase could hardly. be put into effect, for ‘*eon-
sumers of electricity are constantly changing, and .
additional charges could scarcely be enforced against those »
who had not enjoyed.the lower rate.’ Springfield. Gas &-
Elec. Co. v. Barker, 231 Fed. 331, 335. That-is-‘fhe very rea-
son why enforcement of a utility rate which prima facie is
confisc: atorily low can be temporarily: enjoined. - ‘‘If the
‘Supreme Court of the State hereafter shall change the rate,
even nunc pro tunc, the plaintiffs, will have. no adequate
remedy for what they may have lost before the Court shall _
haye acted.’? Oklahoma Natural Gas Co. v. Russell, 261
UzS. 290, 293. See also, Henderson Water Co. v. Corpora-
tion Comm. of. rclies Carolina, 269 ws e. 278, 281."
37 Retrospective decreases’ in public utility rates are sometimes
possible. Thus if the utility is permitted pendente lite td collect. a
rate which may turn Out to be too high, the individuai custonier may
be prote ‘cted against an overcharge by requiring the utility to post
a bond, Prendergast v/ New York Telephone Co., 262-U. S. 43, 51;
Fedcral Power-Comm, v. Natural Gas Pipeline Co., 315 U. S. 375,
598, or by. impounding part of the. amounts collected, Newton v.-
* Consolidated Gas Co., 258 Us S. 165. See also Oklahoma Natural
Gas Company v. Oklahoma, 258 U. S. 234, 239. There -is no way
to give the utility comparable relief retrospectively when the rate
charged turns out to ‘be too low. Hence a few statutes have per-
”:
‘Because of these practical considerations, public utility
_rates look to the future. The Act recognizes that fact. As
already seen (pp. 18- 19), TWA’s, public utility rates—
its passenger and cargo rates-—may be changed only pr Os-
pectively. = :
The practicah situation is entirely difexcat W ave: mail
pay is coricerned. As a mail carrier, TWA deals with only
one customer—the Government. Compensation for earry-
ing the mail is paid, by the Post Office, not by every man
who buys an airmail. stamp. ** Changes. in mail pay do not
directly impinge on any one individual. ~The Government,
as sole customer, never changes its identity ; it is always
available to bear the cost-cf retrospeetive increases, or
receive the benefit of retrospective decreases, of mail pay.
Retrospective adjustment is practically f feasible, and, as.
noted abeve (py. 13-16), has frequently been undertaken.
~The difference in treatment was pointed out on May 1,
_mitted temporary reductions in utility rates on condition that, if the
teniporary rate praves too low, the future final rate shall" be high
ee to make up the resulting loss. See Driscoll v. Edison Light
r Power Co., 307 U.-S, 104, 114-115; Beaver Valle x UW. ater Co. Vv
Driscoll, 28 F. Supp. 723;.Staten sland Edison. Corp. v. Malthie,
267 N. Y. App. Div. 72, 45 N. Y.S. (2d) 337, affd. 292 N, Y. 611,
‘55 N. E. (2d) 376 nae
*SMoreover, no attempt is now made to compute airmail pay
on the basis of antic ipated airmail postage revenue, Under-the Air
Mail Act of 1934, the Interstate Commerce Commission was directed
to “keep the aggregate cost of the transportation. of air mail on
and after July 1, 1938, within the limits of the anticipated postal
revenue therefrom.” s6(e), 48 Stat. 936, quoted in full infra, p.. —
That provision was deliberately omitted when the eek ‘Aeronaujg
Act was‘passed. In fact, $1108(b) of the Act, 49 U. S. C. $678: i
expressly provided that in proteedings pending when the Act was
passed “the rates determined’ byl the Interstate Commerce, Commis-
sion shall be determined without regard to that portion of section
6(e) of the Air- Mail Act/approved June 12,°1934" quoted above.
36 .
1947, hy a member of the Board when testifying before a
Senate sub-committee :
“Mr, Ryan. When we fix passenger and cargo .
rates, those rates are prospective in their operation.
| They: do not relate back. | :
“Now, of course you. can “understand the ‘pric-
tical reasons for that. Passengers are scattered all
_ over, and their identity is lost.
oa ‘‘Senator Saltonstall. You have only. one mail
‘customers \ |
“Mr. Ryan. That is right. ‘There is just the
Postmaster General, and if he overpays. as.a resulf
of one of our decisions, he will-not pay the cuoedite
year and evenup.’”*°
_ Since the underlying considerations are different, mail
pay has never been controlled by public utility analogies. |
United States v. Griffin, 303 U.S. 226, 237-238. It is hardly
‘sur rising, therefore, that ¢406(a)(1)—unlike the provi-
e . 2S ; ae te ,
* Hearings before Subcomm. of Senate Comm. on Appropria-..
tions, 80th Cong., Ist Sess-on HR. 2436, p. 574. See also tes-
timony of Mr. Maclay, Assistant General Counsel of the Board,
Hearings before Subcomm. of ‘House Comm. on Appropriations,
~ 80th Cong., 1st Sess., on Post Office Approp. Bill, 1948, p. 2
. “With respect to the Civil Aeronautics Board, gem is
never a retroactive rate with respect to shippers of express" Pe
anything like that.
“The situation, as you know, is entirely different between
mail pay and the rate whicir you are fixing for members of
the public to pay, “It is mechanically not feasible to fix a
retroactive rate — the members of es public aré- paying
- it.
* “On ‘the other hand, the Civil Auamiales Act provides:
: .with respect to mail pay that the Board can fix the rates in
any way it'-sees fit, as to time, method, type, or anything.”
este
37 ree
sions of the Act dealing with public ulilily rates—does net
.. Board ‘‘shall determine to be proper.”’
embody the-traditional public utility rule but permits mail
pay rates to be changed ‘effective from such date as’’ the
3. Tedeod, in other respects £406 of the Aet departs .
radically from the ‘*usual public utility tate- determination
measure.’’ ean is) :
“Tt must not be forgotten that the Civil Aeronautics Act
is fashioned toa a. ‘elopmental as Well as a regulatory ob- -
jective. Nowhere is this fact made clearer than -in ‘those
provisions which set forth. the standards for the Board's
guidance in the exercise of.its air mail rate-making func-
tion.’’ Pan: American-Grace Airways, Inc—Mau Rates,.
3-C. A. B. 550, 563.. ‘‘Certainly, the declaration of policy
“contained in section 2 differentiates the Act: in ntany- im
portant respects. from the usual form of public “utility
regulatory statutes.’? . American Export Airlines, Sess ‘
C ertificate of Public Convenience and Necessity, 2 C. A. B.
16, 30; appeat’ dismissed Pan American Airways, Tne. ve’
Civil Acronautics Board, 121 F. (2d) 810 (C. C. A. 2).
Under the Act, mail pay is not determined by “public
utility’* principles. « “This Board in exercising its rate-
_ making functions has never and does not iow measure the
reasonableness of the rate in terms of a fair return upon —
the sotcalled ‘fair value’ of the property used and useful
in the public service.’ American Airlines, lic., Mail Rate
Proceeding, 3 C. A. B. 770, 788. Section 406(b) prescribes
. . . . “i . " . . * |
distinctive standards for determining mail’ pay: ‘*In
determining the rate in each\gase, the Board sual take inte
miei ae: other factors . the need of eachi
; “T air carrier. or compensdtion \ for the transportation: of
.
ts & a
mitil ‘sufficient to insure the performance of such ‘service,
and, together with all other revenue: of the air carrier; to.
enable such air carrier under honést, economical, and effi-
> Clout management, “to maintain and continue the déevelop-,
- ‘ment of-arr- transportation lo the extentsand of ‘the chagac-
ter and quality’ required for the commerce of the United
‘Stafes, the Postal Service, and the national defense.’ _
a -‘*Seetion 406(b), more than any other passage of the
_ Givi Aeronautics Act, discloses the basic difference between
* the dual developmental: and regulatory objective of this Act
. “aaid the | regulator v “objective: of the ordinary statute de-
~ signed for the: control of public utility rates.’’ * American
~ Hirlines, Tne. Maik Rate Proceeding, 3-°C. A.B, 323, 335.
. The Board’s “mail. pay: task differs ‘fundamentally from
that’ ‘which faces the public. regulatory body in-the’ fixing
of rates for the transportation’ of passengers and property *.
or in “the fixing of rates for publie utility. services.”’ Pau
_ American “Airavays Co. (of “Delaware y—Mail ; Rates, | 1
r C. A A. A. 220,9952- 953. sg too, Eastern Aur Lines, Int.
‘Mail Rate Proceeding, 8 C. A. B. 733, 75d. °° |
74 | Actually: mail compe nsation is, wader the Xet, “Govern.
, mey subsidy i in the form of mail pay.’’ Annual Report off
the Civd Atveumeliog Board (1947), p. ® - “The u use of. the:
mail payments is.a statutory device for the ackomplishment
of national objectives’ that transcend the interests. of ‘the
postal sertvica ..; .-The ‘compensation’ which the carrier.
re ccives thus cee compensation* not only for carrying
-the majkbut for the building Fp of a system of air trans--
i. portation which will serve. the nation’s commerce and se-
curicy as. well.’ Ame rican Airlines, Inc., Mail Rate Pro-:
c®eding, 3 ©. A. B. 523, os ete
~ #49 U. SC. §486(b), quested, in full it enjya pp. RIe- Bis
.
“~ oe
ry 7
firs
-:
o D. j . ©
“Thus section. $6 (b)’ of the Act departs. from the cus-
enla ‘ate standards.’", Amerigan Preside nt Lines, Ets,
et.al, Petition, 7 C. A. B. 799, SAB, note ¥ 9. T hat was pada
clear in the Board's. very first tail pay case, Mid-Con-
tinent ‘Afrlines, Inc., Mail Rates, (@ A. AL 45 (at pp. o4-:
Pe above factors whict the [Board] is directed to
* take into consideration in fixing and determining fair
and ‘reasonable rates under the act, difer:trom the
_tests which, under the influence of judicialdecision
duritfg the past 40 years, have been set up,for the
a guidance of public regulatory bodies in fixing rates
oe 23 Buble utilities and common carriers . . . See-
tions.2 and 406, as well as other sections of the Civil
Aeronautics Act, disclose the clear intent of C ongress
that the problems. ot civil aviation require ‘special
‘treatment.’’
ih
Precisély: because “the problems of civil aviation require:
special treatment, ” §406(a)(1) of the Act uses special |
s language ‘% appearing in no other statute.
| Hence it is doubly* fallacious to try to define the Board’s
| mess to change. mail rates retrospectivdly by analogy to
_ |pablie utility rate cases. That fallacy ‘Was riddled by the
Beard when it rejected ‘an argument that, because a ease -
had held: that public utility rates gould be reduced ‘only:
prospectively, it could not reduce magpay retrospectively.
American Aindines, Inc.—Mail Rate Proceeding, 3 C. A. B.
323." “There the Board said (pp. 330-331):
a
involve ure sear between a private shipper and
a.common carrier _If it,did, then the earrier’s argu-
_
? The same argument had been rejected in Av Mail Com pensa-
tion, 222 I. C. C. 602, 603-604.
‘i . oF
rae 6 inlike that case, the instant proceeding does not”
-
-
‘
ee eek
ment that. the. Board may “retroactively” increase
‘rates apparently has no force in view of the principle
that a private shipper, once having paid a published
rate, need not concern himself with subsequgntly hav:
ing oe io more.. On the contrary, the Postmaster
‘pi SR
General, wnlike the private: shipper, ts the medium
o
‘through which ‘continuous financial support neces-—
sary for the carriers to fulfill the purposes of the Act
is extended: Our obligation is to. see to it that the
“rates he | pays cre at all times'sufficient to enable the
carrices to accomplish and maintain those purposes.
Likewise, our obligation is also to see that the rates
do not at any.time excéed those which are proper
., under the statute. We, must discharge both obliga-
© tions.” : | ae Bes
- 4> The P0urt. was led to espouse its false analogy to
- public utility rate cases s by the assumption that its only real
alternative was to regard mail service as rendered under a
‘“cost- plus’? contract in which ‘‘the net to the contractor is
the same nd matter what the quality of the performance
may be, and he bears none of the risks of the oper ration”?
(114). ae egannot f find in this statute any language which
indicates that Congress intended to guarantee’ to every
‘earrier a profit”’ (114). joe. Sen an
. Noone claims that Congress intended to ‘‘guarantée to
every. carrier a profit ’—much. less a profit regardless of
“the ‘quality of the performance. *" It. had to,. awd did,
* gue rantee that ‘*reasonable - compensation’” ‘for carrying |
mail w ‘ould be received. The Board can, Must and always
does review costs.” Iti as ever alert to allow only reasonable
. ® & :
42 Section 106: b) expressly refers to the carricr’s need for com-
pensation to enable it to fulfill the — objectives * ‘under honest,
economical, and e fficte, nt manage ment.
e
4
eee : - Seer are
> .
an waste ite the Keht Sf ope rating expe rience. The buyaboo
conjured up-by the Cc air is simply imaginary. oon
- Moreover, the dite which the Court posed is non-
existent. Even in the fiel eld of Government contraects—and
of course carrying airmail is no longer a matter of contract
—the alteynatives are got between a “public utility’ * sys-
tem ‘‘where a price per unit is fixed’?/(11 3): and a }‘cost-
plus’’ system in which ‘‘the net to the contractor’? is. fixed
(114). As procurement experience during the war ae s,
many devices are available ‘whereby a unit price is stipu-
lated in adv ance'but later adjusted retrospectively so that
it: does not result in undue advantage to either party.“ .
The broad, flexible provisions of. 6406 likewise ‘enable
the Board both to stipulate mail. rates on a per unit badis -
in advanc€ of performance, and to rectify past er rors in its
forecasts on the basis of actual] experience. lr practice the
Board does just that. For instance, it often fixes avowedly
‘*temporary’’ rates for the future, which it later revises re-
trospectively after the results of: operation are known. At
one time, to be sure, it ‘declined to promulgate mail rates
on a ‘tentative basis, subject to change according to future
operating results’? because that ‘‘would, in effect, result:
3 in the establishment of a ‘cost-plus’ system of rate mak-
=. ing.”? All American Aviation, Inc., Mail Rate fér Route
+ #No. 49, 4c. A.B. 354, 357. ,But it has long sinee recognized
the fallacy of that argument, and row regularly fixes “tem
aoe, ee
43 See, C.9., : aitikens. Atlantic Airlines, Inc., Mail Rate, rC. A. B.
943, 951-953 ;|Pioneer: Air Lines, Inc., Mail: Rates, 8 C. A. B. 1%
_ 185-186; Bragiff Airways, Ine., Order No. E-2129, Oct. 28, 1948,
pp. 15-16.
44 See Lic her 4 ‘nited States, 334 U. S. 742, 7 762-763, 768-773
= e >
relevant factors in the light of actual experience. Then, 1
ae *. ; oe ;
,
. ay tid | Liptiake
* porary’ rates both for new routes® and established routes
a
on which ‘*permane nt’? rates were previously in effect.**
After operating results” are known, it revises the former’
rates—retrospectively as well as* prospectively—on_ the —
basis of audited aetual costs and other factors deemed
pevtinent. Clearly in these situations the Board usés both ;
thé so-called: ‘‘ post-audit”’ method to es mail rates
for past periods and the “price per unit’’ or,“ prophecy”
method to fix rdtes for the future.,
Moreover, admittedly: the Board is required- to re
rates back at least to the date when a proceeding
. @
new :
begun, Whenever it does that, necessarily it audits.a
Sat actual revenues, and wejghs them and all other
a
See, c.g., E ssair, duc., Temporary Mail Rate, 6-C, A. B. 687,
690-6913 ! Presitoaliaatadl & Western Air, the., Transatlantic Mail.
Rate, 7 C. A. B. 421, 423; Pan American Airways, Inc., Transpacific
Mail Rate, 7 C.: A. B. 615, 618. Sometimes, indeed, the Board, does '
not-even profess to fix'a “temporary” rate where ‘new or experi-
mental services are ‘involved, but waits for several years to obrain
actual operating results, occasionally making “temporary” payments .
on account. Usually in such instances it awards lump sum pay-
ments for past periods, which of course: can be expressed’ mathe-
matically.in terms of “rates.” See, e:g., Pan-American Airways, Inc, .
y: q- ;
—Transatlantic Rates, 8 CC.‘ A. B. 367 (June. 9, 1947), awarding |
$1,484,000 for the year 1945; Pioneer Air, Lines—Mail Rates,’ 8
C_A.-B. 175 (July 2, 1947), awarding $505,420 for mail service on
anew. feeder line from August 1, 1945, to August 31, 1946; Pan
American Airways, Inc—Latin-American: and — Leopoldville
Mail Rates, Orders. Nos. E-738 and E-739 (July 24, 1947), award-
ing approximately $4,500, 000 for services from fan .F,.1944, to
£ ap} y y:
August’31, 1945, In each of these.cases the Bagard went through the -
ritual of dividing: the lump ° sum payment by the mileage actually
flown to obtain a‘“‘rate.
416 See, e jes Pennsylvania- Central Airlines Corp., TCA B. 988,
990: Chicago & Southern Air Lines, Inc., Order No. E-510, p..7
.( May 6, 1947);: National Airlines; Inc., Order No. E-1271, pp.
5°6 ( March 5, 1948). . ‘
¢
¢
Oy
: \
its past forecast has proved too low, it is corrected-for the
* past—often for as much as two or three y ears—and anew
oe
compensation”? which the C ourt thought were mutually eXx-
_ elusive. ae |
Several times the Board itself bad pointed out why the
“eost: plus”’ spectre affords ng reason to adhere doggedly
e «|toa false propheey: when events have: proved. it wrong.
“Although at is not the Board’s intention in rate proceed-
ings involying the fixing of mail rates for past periods
zs $6 determine mail rates merely on a cost-plus basis, it must’
be recognized .that the process of fixing rates for a ‘past
Tatesis set for the future? Here again there coexist, in
actual practice the two metliods of arriving at ‘reasonable’
“-.. , period’’. on a retrospective basis. ‘‘does assure the air.”
- _ carrier substantial protect tion against unforeseea de > con-
tingencies for which a prospective fair-sand reasonable rafe
might well have made inadequate allowance.’ Pain Ameri--
can Airways,.Inc., Transatlantic Mail Rates, 8 C. A. B.
267, 291, note 22,8 @ertainly C on#ress yas amply: justified.
oR not... : ,
‘ & Pe : eens oe
“ea. 7 See cases cited notes 27, 45 supra; Northeast Airlines, Inc.,
a Order No. E-1230 (Feb. 26,1948) awarding $2,107,578 in increased
‘ compensation for the period from May 1, 1945 to April 30), ‘1947 and
“setting anew rate for the future.
Sf BQ
41 (June 4,°1948). “It has been the practice to provide a some-
what lower rate of return for a past period than for a future period
mM view of the fact that for a past period the-probability of error in
estimates of operating results is removed and other operating risks
have been realized in stibstantial part.” Braniff’ Airways, Inc.
Order No, E;2129, p..36 (Oct. 28,°T948). See also, Chicago &
‘so Southern A@lines, bic., Order No. E-1885,*p. 29 Cpuly 28, 1948) ;
Delta Air satitg ine. , Order No. E- ruts \e 21 (OG. 2s, 148).
-
. ‘ ° .
* 5 re ?
a ‘ sa 7 o
d x ; .
ee
in xecepting that view, whether the Board now likes it or_
* See also, Pan American’ Airways, Inc., Latin-American and.
Miami-Leopoldville Services Mail. Rates, Order No. E-738, p. 47°
( July 24, 1947); Alaska Airlines, Inc., Order No. E-1665, pp. 40- -
~~
44
PA ee
. ° ° e
*
1. In short, the Court relied on a wholly non-existent.
dilemma to -find an analogy in the practice under publié .
utility rate statutes.. That meneey ignores the practical
ditferbnegs between public utility ‘rate statutes and $406
of the Act—differences which explain why the Act care-.
fully distinguishes between the Board's purely prospective
power to change passenger. and cargo rates and its power --
to change mail pay’ r
spectively.» It ignores} ae ‘fact that mail pay has never.
‘been governed by trad tional publie utility rate principles,
-and that $406 deliberatkly departs from those. principles. .
And it-ignores the admonitt
lines, Inc. v. Waterman. Steamship Corp., 333 U. 8. 108,
where, after noting that all forms of transportation had
“common: features,’” this Court j warned against exactly the
kind of reasoning by false analogy that was. indulged in
below (353 U. S.,-at pp: 107-108): - .
%
‘‘But these resemblances must ndt. blind us to the .
—ftuct-thatrlegally as well as literally, air commerce,.
1 whether at home or- abroad, soared into-a différent_
realm than any that had gone before... . . However
useful paraltels with older forms of Pasisit may. be
in adjudicating private rights, we see no reason why
the efforts of the Congress to foster and regulate
“development of a revolutionary commerce that op-
erates in three dimensions should be judicially cir--
cumscribed with analogies taken” over from two-
dimensional transit.”
s both retrospectively’ and pro- .
thicago & Southern Air-
Tim
jot |
POINT IV.
The Act removed whatever vesistetbens may have ex-
‘isted under earlier maif pay statutes. ;
The Court ‘thought that “406 (a) (1) “appears to have
been designed -to establish in the Board? thle same powers |
which had theretofore existed at the Interstate C commerce:
Commission in Yespect. to railw ay mail’ and it “had never
been claimed that the. Interstate Commerce Commissior
had. unfette red retroactive power’” (11: 3). ‘It found justi-
9
tive purpose
If ¢406(a) (1) w ere merely designed to codify the powers
of ‘the Commission over railway: mail rates, the ques-
tion naturally arises why the Act did not simply copy the’
words of the Railway Mail Pay. Act. Actually the novel”
language of §406(a)(1) removed any, lintifations on the
"power to adjust mail pay rates which existed under earlier,
restrictive statutes. ae it conferred lems authority
_ fication for w hitthing down the Act in the ‘*limited Jegisla-_
| which. it. thought was “apparent from the. ;
history! (113). ae
inh this respect is in Dy xpression of Con-
gress on the point, whieh appears in “the Conference Re-
port on the final bill:
‘*This section empowers the Authibedey {Board} ‘
fix mail rates and sets-forth, the congressional policy
to guide the Authority [Board] ini fixing such rates
and enables the Authority [Boarg] to adjust rates
so that the policy of Congress may be properly car-
ried out in the case of each carrier or class of carriers
according to the needs of the ‘particular case . ;
These provisions appear in the conference agreement
as section 406(a), (b) and (c).’?”
” he R. Rep. No. 2035, 75th Covg. 3d Scss., June 7, P9358, pyr
11-72. The same report was mide to and adopted by the Senate
on ps 13, 1958. -83. Cong. Ree. 8961- 8963. The: bill was .ap-
proved by the President on June 23, 1938, j ,
.
*
a 46
6
a
Yet the decision below holds that even whe n the pe >
of the particular case’
‘rates’
require that the Board. rey ters
retrospectiv ely so that the dirline May; ‘properly’
carry: out ‘‘the policy of ( “Ougress, * the Board i is powerless
to. achieve that result. ‘aes
.
° 3 Os 3 s
A. Mail Pay Prior to the Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916.
Prior’ to the Railway Mail Pay Act, mail was normally
transported pursuant’ to contract's made with private car-
~ylers by the Postmaster General under statutory authority.” ‘
Details of the contracts were largely left to the Postmaste rT
General, but ordinarily the maximum rates which he could
pay were prescribed - by statute, though: of course he was
free té contract at lower rates. if he could obtain them.*
It was settled doctrine that, except for certain land-:
: grant roads,” ‘‘railroads were not requi red -by law to carry
the mails." They were perfectly free, as a matter of law,
2,
: %© In rare instances a mail carrier was Called on to render serv-
ices entirely beyond those covered by its contract, or after expira-——_—
—tion-of-a contract-—In_such situations the carrier was entitled to.
recover reasonable compensation. Alvord v. United States, 95 U.S.
356, 359; United States v. Utah, Nevada, & California, Storage Co.,
199 U.S. 414, 423-424; Hunt v. United States, 257 U.S. 125, 128.
Reasonable compensation iftcluded “a. fair es: Freund v.*United ©
‘States, 260 U. S, 60,
"' The Mail . Divisor Cases} 251 U. Ss. 326, 330. °
52 Usually land- -grant railroads were obliged chy the statutes
wiser whack we erunts were made to transport mail ° ‘at bent peibe.
a
.. statutes were star sini that “fair ahd ‘anita rates of
- ‘compensation, not to exceed the amounts paid by private parties fer
the same kind of service” should be paid. fer carrying mail, et al
stores, ete. See Union Pac nia Rd. Co. 2 Unite d State s, 104 U.
662, 665. ~ 3
ws ge we} ork, New Haven & "Hartford Re. Co.v.U nited States,
21 U. S. 123, 125,
to reject the Government's terms and refuse to carry:
‘the mail. Carriage of the mails was regarded as a purely |
voluntary matter of contract.” Therefore if a’railroad kept |
carrying mail, it was not entitled to ‘sadequate compensa-
tion to be judicially determined?” but only what the Gov-
ernment allowed. -* a °°
- ‘As a practical matter, therefore, mail rates were. largely
fixed by the Postmaster General within the limits set by
statute. ‘Either Congress by statute, or the Postmaster.Gen- ’
eral ‘by regulations read into the contracts, took care.
fo reserve the power to change the rates. Of course the
railroads were not compelled to keep transporting mail if -
they did-not liké the new rates, but if they continuedto carry .
mail they could not recever more fhan the changed rates no
matter how much they protested.° — - |
-
: 4 Eastern Rd. Co. y. United States, 129..U: S. 391, 395-396 ;
Chicago,-Milwaukee & St. Paul Ry, Co. v. United States, 198 US.
384, 3 3899 Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co. v, U inited States,
225 U. S. 640, 6504 United States v-New- York Central Rd... Co.,
8895, 185 Chled States v. Griffin, 303 U: S. 226, 229, feot-
note 2, “It may be that any: railroad by failing to carry the mails
would incur the hostility of those living along its lines and as a--
consequence suffer Serious financial losses; but the fear of such re-
sults certainly does not’ ameunt“to compulsion by the United States
and cannot constitute the basis of a justiciable claim, against them
~ for taking property.” New York, New Haven & anions Rd. Co.
he S.-640;-650- a
v. United States, 251 U. S. 123, 127: igi
53 Atchison, Tope ka & + Santa Fe-Ry-Go- V. United ‘States, 225
8 See, C.9., Eastern Rd. Co, ». Ualted States, 129 U- S. 391,
395- oa Chicago Mikwaukee & St. Paul Ry. Co. v. United. States, °
198 U. S. 385, 389; Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry: Co. ¥. United
States, 225, U.S. 640, 650; Pagocagesd Lackawanna & Western. Re.
Co, v. United — 249 U. S. 385, 388; New York, New Haven &
Hartford Rd. Co. hag retcea 251 U.S. 123, 127; St. Louis:
Southwestern Ry. Co; v. United States, 262 U. S. 40, %3- 75.- The
rule was otherwise ‘as tw apron contracts in which,-1t was concluded,
¢ ay a.
48
e ; : ; OF. ¢
Thus the’ re- 1916 system of railroad mail pay was in-
elastics. The only modicum of flexibility in the strueture
_resulted, when, Congress finally ‘passed statutes permit-
ting or directing an increase or “decr@yse. in compensa-
“tion or prive ate bills ‘to ‘take care of partic ular situations.
In some instatices, as already seen {supra, pp. 13-15) both
increases and decreases in mail pay were ultimately made
by retroactive statutes. Years often went by, however,
before remedial legislation was enacted.’ ** Since changes
affecting the railroads, the principal mail carriers, were
relatively inffr ‘equent, the inflexibitity of the rate structure
was not as serious as it would have been in the field of air
transportation, which is subject to rapid, unpredictable
fluctuations in earnings and expenses. ‘Nonetheless the sys-
tem produced results which were regarded as. inequitable
and a certain amount of elasticity was imported into it by
the passage of fhe sented Mail Pay Act in 1916. -
the right to change the rates was not 1 46s ved. Chicago & Nok
western Ry. Co. v. United States, 104 U, S. 680; Chicago, Milzaukee
> St. Paul Ry. Co. v. United States, 104 . S. 687; see St. Raul &
Duluth Rd. Co. v. United States, 112 U.S. 733, 735, ip
“7 -For instance, railway mail pay was ‘jie fixed on a mile-
age basis. In 1864 railway, postal cars were introduced for distribu-
o
ts up for a, weight hasis. See The Mail Divisor, Cases, 241 U. S. 326.°
furnishing postal cars
tion of mail en route, -but no additional ‘compensation, was provided.
Railroads protested without avail. Qnly in 1872 did Congress pass*
a ‘statute permitting the Postmaster General to callow. any railroad
now. allowed by law, as he may think fit, mot exceeding, however,
50 per centum of the said sates.” Agt-of June 8,.1872, ¢. 335, §265;
17 Stat, 283, 316. Seé Railway-Mail Pay, 56 1. C. C. 1, 4,
‘bhe ext year the mileage basis of coniputing mail Pay was given
The effect on the railroads of this weight basis of fixing compensa-
tion when the parcel post system was inaugurated, and ‘the years) |
it took before the railroads obtained rehef, have already been noted,
ns pp.. 14-15, : :
such additignal compensation. beyond that”
*)
649.
B. The Railway Mail Pay Act of 1916.
‘‘ Translation of an implication, drawn from the ‘Heeial
aspects of one statute to a totally diffé rent statute i is treach- |
exodf busings.’ > Federai Trade Comm. ¥. Bunte Brothers,
Inc., 312 U, 8.349, 353. - This warning is especially pertinent
when comparing the Civil Aeronautics Act with the Rail-
way Mail Pay Act of 4916" and the Air Mail Acts of 1934 .
- and 1935." Appendix B contains a detailed comparison of.
the thre statutes, ar
**The Railway Mail Pay Act siciaanil the system _
>
tracts.’’ United States v. Griffin, 303°C: S226, 229. Rail-
+ ° roads were compelled: to carry ‘mail. Necessarily they were
‘entitled to receive fair and . reasonable compensation. xslt
= 39 U.S.C. 6541. Oe eG ,
This compensation was fixed purely: on a quantum meruit
basis. United States v. Griffin, 303 U.S 26, 237. [Under
ce $e the Civil Aeronduties Act, airlines are not paid f for trans- |
a porting mail on any such restrictive basis. ] Mail ratés welt
ee to be fixed by the Commission, after hearing. ‘‘At\the con-
tlusion of the hearing the Commission shalfestablisi by
a order a fair, reasonable rate or compensation to be-received, .
at such-stated times as may be named in’ the order, for the
| transportation of mail matter .. .”’ a9 U. S. C. 9551, [No fe
~ such, language appears in the Cevil Aeronautics Act.] ©
“J “Once fixed, the rates were: to .remain,jn effect -uhtil
: changed. The Commission was ‘‘to fix ee Met aston from
“sr time to time the fair = sacrteer eed rates and compensa.
58 Act of July 28; 1916, ¢. 2615-39 Stat. A426 ft; 39 U, S: C. ‘
$$524-579. .
® Act of June 12; 1934, c. 466; 48 Stat. 933 ; sabia by Act of
—— 14, 1935, e. 530 ; 49 Stat. 614. “@
@ : 8
Oe
theretofore prevailing of- service under voluntary con. |
a ‘ , i . s - : of o
.
4 . e . as . . = -
tion for the transportation of such.mail matter by ratlway.
‘common carriers ......and to publish.the same, ‘and orders .”
SO made and published shall continue in force until changed
by the Commisston’ after “due notice and’ heaving.” ° 39
U..S. C. $542, [The difference betw retween this language: and
§406(a) (q)of the, Civil Aer ‘onauties Act is obvious.] No
provision fér jiidiciat review existed:. The statute’ per mit-—
ted only * ‘administrative review by ‘reexamination’ of an
order.” °U nited States v. Griffin, 303 U. Se 296, 231. [The _
Civil Aeronduties. Act contains anh express ‘provision for’
"judicial review. 51006; 49.U. S. & 9649.)
After it fixed a rate, the Commission. had nothing fur ther
to do, with-it until somebody petitioned it for reexamination.
It could not #reexamine’’ the rate on its own initiative:
Reexamination could be applied for only by the Postmaster
General or the raifroad affected. 39 8. S.-C. $053." [The ;
Board js not only “empowered”? but ‘directed’? to proceed
‘at all times “upon its own Anitiative’’ as well‘as — ig
pétition , of the Postmaster. General or‘an air carrier.
§406(a),, 49 U. 8. 1 $486 (a). J
‘ Moreover, a rate order could never be reexamined ‘until
it had remained in effect six month®@. ‘“‘Bither the Post--
" master General or any such, carrier may at any time after
the lapse of six mouths from the.entry of: the order assailed *
appl y fora reexamination and thereupon Substantially simi-
dar proceedings | ‘shall be had with respect to the rate or
rates covered‘by said application’. . .*’ 39 U, S. C. $553.
[No such limitation appears in the Civil Aeronautics es
Act. | And, of course, the Commission was not authorized
to make its rate orders “effective from such date a as it shall
determine to be proper.’ st |
Once the Commission fixed a rate, ‘it. had to remain in
effect: at. least s six months ; no > one—the Cominission, the tail-
-
Share eg
pee’
: or > -
$a
tt ‘ 7
~
: : oan «-
- aes, .
> se ed B
road ¢ or r the: Postmaster Genet al—could change it. In view
“of itshighly restrictive language, it is hardly surprising that
«at was: claimed that no. power whatever existed under, the
Railway Mail Pay Act to increfse mail pay retrospectively.
Yet this Court: held that power to increase tlle rate. re-
trospectively:to the date of the petition for reexamination’
. e ‘ : , ¥ oh re . . . . -— .
existed by ‘‘reasonable -. impjication,. ’* although it was
“quite. ‘aware that minutiae of expression may, be. found
that show Congress to have been thinking of the futufe. tam
Upited States: yy, New York® Central Rad. Co., 279 U.S. 73,
79,0 yr Ae as
&
No i issue existed 1 in the New York Cc ‘Entral case whether
mail pay could be increased as of a-date earlier than the.
applic: ation, for reexamination, and the Court: ™ passing
- perform these services,and -aécept pay without protest t
:
assumed that it could not." © The* problem actually arose’
in: the ‘‘short- line’?. caséyof Macon, Dublin & Savannah
Rd>Co.veU nited States, 78 C. Ci. 251.-
was “This -crncleicte was reached despite the fact that the ap-
plicable statute contained no express authority, such as is Contained
in section 406(a) “of the Civil Aeronautics’.Act, to determine the
date on which rate ordérs shisuld become effective.” American Air-
_ lines, ‘TInc:—Mail a Proceeding, 3°C. A. B. 323, 326-327 ‘
- See 279 U.S. fae p. 78: bo “We asstunv that while hg railroads
ley get no .
ground for -subsequént complaint. - American Smelting & Refining
Co. v. United States, 259 U, & 75, 78.” In the case: cited, plaintiff
claimed: that it was,not bound to deliver copper under a contract
because the coppet could have been requisitioned, and therefore the
contract was “made under duress. This argument was rejected, the,*
od Court pointing out” that if plaintiff “had desired to stand upon its
legal fights it should have saved the question of the-prices It did
not do-s0; but on the contrary . ‘so,far.as appears. was: willing ‘to
contract and was content. tn the main with what was offered” (259
U..S., at’p. 78). Manifestly a mail carrier can-no longer save “the
question of the price’” and is no longer, free ‘to decide whether it
will be “willing to contract.” Indeed, “the “price” is no longer a
-matter of “contract” at al]. ees | of ae
>... i oy
- Under orders of the Commission, **separatelyoperatal™!
_.short-line railroads were entitled to-higher mail pay rates — *s
than other roags. In May 1931 plaintiff and other short-
line railroads filed petitions for reexamination on “the
ground. that sincg Jul 3, 1930 they had been separately “d
Ceperated, uber a ugdor adopted ‘that day. ~ The
Commission made findings in ‘their faver but refused to
’ award ‘additional compensation for serv ices rendered
prior to the filing of their applications with us.’? - Railway -
Mail. Pay, 185 [. C. ©. 715, 720. * PlaintitfAhen sued in the os
Court of Claims forthe additional pay from July 3, 1930,
to May 1931. A demurrer to its. complaint was overruled.
**Congress reposed ‘in the Commission the primary duty 7.
of determining just compensation, : not whether by some a
act on the’ part of the carrier it was estopped as a matter :
of law from receiving just compensation. in its éntirety.’ *
78 C. CL, at p. 206. Final judgment was aa given for
plamtiff, 79 C.-Cl. 298... i
While the case primarily. i involved the question whethir
plaintiff was entitled to one previously determined rate
rather than another, it: shows that.even ‘under the Railway
Mail Pay Act—despite its severely restrictive language—
it was sometimes possible for a_railroad to obtain an -in-
‘¢rease in mail‘pay retrospectively to a time antedating its’
cy . , fo rat : 3
Be ee ee ee ee | Pe ee ee ee ee eee
petition for reexamination. No court décision has been
found holding to the contrary.
’
© The Court conduiet that the period of underpayment without 4
_ protést was not “so protracted as to establish, affirmatively, with all te
the other: circumstances, including the fact that plaingiff was not free
to decline performance, the defense of acquiescence.” © #8 C, C., at a
p. 258. 4
63 The “short-line” cases ( although not the Macon case by ndica’ ;
° were referred ‘to inthe hearings on the predecessor bill- ‘of the Civil
‘ ¢ . Fs
ko e 4 : ? . 4 .
_
ma, ie
ru > Oe
> ° <=
=
+h es dy
ah te
Septic tngw Gy
rtbe'ey’s
“Air Mail Compensation, 206 1. C. C, O75, 727.
- Act of February 2, 1925, 43 Sta.
C. The -Ajr Mail Acts of 1934 and 1935
. Betore 1934, aif mail rates wersefixed by contracts be-
tween the Postmaster General and fhe airtines, made af yr
competitive bidding.” Early in 1934 the contracts were
_ cancelled by a new Postmaster. General on ‘the ground that
they had been improperly nuitie, and the uirlines were un-
| Aeronauti¢s’ Act: Hearings before a Subcommittee ‘of Senate In-,
terstate Connierce Committee-on S. 2 and S¥ 1700, 5th Cany.,
oat Sess|, at pp. 162-165 This document is referred fo mney
“Subcommittee Heariggs.” ’
* Prior to 1925 the: Post Office transported . air mail itself.
- $4 of the Air. “Mail
805, authorized the Postmaster
General to contract for the transportation of air nrail “at a rate”
not to exceed four-fifths of the revenues derived from air mail.
The Act of June 3, 1926, 44 Stat. 692 2, enabled the Postmaster Gen-
eral to make contracts
certain maximum limits.
vd
to pay for such Service at fixed — per pound or per “mile.”
of March 8, 1928, c. 149, 45 S .t. 248. ©
In 1928, ‘the Air Mail Act *y 1923 was amended by adding a —
.new §6, which. permitted the Postmaster General to substitute for
certain contracts “an airmail réute certificate” effective for a period
of ten years. “The rate, of compensation to the holder ofuch an air
mail certificate shall be determined by periodical negotiation between”
the certificate holder and the Postmaster General, but shall never
exceed the rate of compensation provided for.in the Jriginal contract
_of the air mail route certificate holder. ws Act of May 17, 1928, ¢. 603,
45 Stat. 594.
would have the right
The Watres-Act of April 29, 1930, c. 223,46 Stat. 259, authorized
the Postmaster General to award contracts by cOmpetitive bidding “‘at
fixed rates per mile” not to exceed $1.25 per mile, and to substitute
for an air mail contract a “route certificate’ under which the holder
“to carry air mail over the route set forth
in the certificate or any modification thereof at rates of compensation
to be fixed from tinte to time, at least annually,” by the Postmaster
General, ” not exceeding the same amount.. ;
“at fixed rates per pound” not exceeding )
In ‘1928 the Pestmaster General was’
‘authorized to make contracts to carry air mail to foreign countriés
and insular possessions. for periods of not more than ten years “and _
Act |
3
&*
;
2 e
\,
=
A
‘
\e
Bo a
ever, by the eal
‘tive.’ (6(c), 48 Stat.
’
dera cloud. re This had the efegs ofgfarthering the ev olu-
tion. of Le wislation which has ryoulted in our, present air
., transportation ~¥stem. NJ
From the standpoint of rater tle sibility, ie 1934 statute,
passed shorth thereafters was far more “res restrictive than
‘the Railway Mail Pay Act-on whith it was based, Unlike
rail rows, airlines were not. compelled by law to varry |
maui They -tssumed that obligation voluntarily, by mak-
ing contracts “with the Postmaster’ General. 43(a),. 48>
Stat, Uo3-004, The contracts could be, t@minated, .how-
: te og
NCLUT nf ie option upon sixty days’ no-
3°
tracts, which were let ~ COM
ject toa specified ceiling. $3(4), 48 Stat. 954. Contracts
were to be “Subject. to any reduc Kol in the’ rate of payment
therefor.’ ' Gc), 4 8 Stat. 939.
Although rates were ‘determined by contract,. the In-
terstate. Commerce Coueiininn was also directed to fix
ae syrder rH rates of compensation for the transportation of
alr adl by airplane and. the serv ice connected therewith
but not im excess of the rates proyided for in this
Act... . and to-publish the same, which shall continue in
force until changed by the said Commission after due
notice ‘inl hearing.’ §6(a), 48 Stat. 935. ‘The limited.
procedure under the Railway Mail Pay Act, for reexamina-
I
tient ‘only uftey” six nfonths, was t taken over ‘bodily by a see-
tion making applicable the whale. pre eedure ‘for the ad-
justment of rates for.carriage of mail by railroads.’’ 6(d),.
8 Stat. 985. In addition, a special requireme nt w as im-
posed. thit rates be review ed annually **in order to be as-
° F é aK : ; ° 5 "5 ;
3 Pacific Air Transpori v. United States, 98 8 C-C1 649, reviewed
at Jength the facts relating to the cancellation.
<
io. Rates. Were stipulated i in the con-.
itive bidding, but we re sub- .
Y anh
2”
eC:
' ¢ . Sa , x
sured: that no unreasonable profit 1K resulting or accruing.”’
<6(b), 48S Stat..935.. 2 edn” a Lease a
Thus Eohgress” whole effort was to keep air mail pay
as low as possible." « The act was not interpreted as em-
powering the C ommission to increase rites. Indeed, it took
extremely elaborate: ‘reasomlug to establish that the .Com-.
mission had any pow erwhatever under the 19: 4 “Act even to
find that a rate should be higher than that stated ‘in. the”
- contract: Air Mailky ompensation,.206 I. C. C. 675, 688-694.
- In August 1935, however, the statute was radically
amended, “It w as made ¢lear that thao ommission could in-
ease as well as decrease thte contract rates.” ; Further-
more the August amendment provided. that contracts in
force on March’! . 1995, or let and satisfactorily Rororned a
for certain: periods thereafter, should be continued in-\—~
definitely; ‘and compensation there for, on and’ after,.Warch
Y, 1435, during such period of indefinite continuance, shall
be p Aid at the rate fixed by order of the Commission.’ 49
a |
— —— -
*6 From a consideration of “the amount of air. ma so carried,
the facilities supp tied by the carrier, and its” revenue and_ profits
from all sources . ~ . and other niaterial elements” the Commission
was to fix rates for each route “designed to, keep the aggregate cost
of the transportation of air mail on dhd after July 1.1938, within the
‘limits of the anticipated postal revetiue therefrorh.” $6(e), 48 Stat.
936. This provisiog was amended in 1935 to require the Commission
to disregard lasses resulting from the unprofitable maintenance of
ry *
non- -mail schedules. 49 Stat. 616. ° a :
« Thus, 86(e) “of the -statute was amended to provide that if
the holder of a contract contended “that the rate of compensation
in force for the service involved is msufficient, the burden of estab-
lishing such insufficiency: and the extent thereof shall be assumed ‘hy
him.” Act. of August | 14, 1935, @9 Stat. 616. Likewise S6ic) was -
amended to delete the provision that. contracts should be continued .
“subject to any, réduction in the rate of payment therefor.” 49
Stat. 617. - ,
- %
56 | +7 an
‘ *.
Stat. 617. ° “This was, clearly a retroactive ‘application of a
rates, which goes much beyond a mere publi ‘ation of rates.
as of the date of an applic ation oF sich subsequent date:
is the rates brought Jn iscue -by the application. became
unfair and unreasonable.’? Air Mail Compensation, 222
I. C. C. 602,606.
Before euactment of the £935 amendme nt, the Commis-
sion had made findings as to the rates for all except two.of
the domestic routes. After'the amendimest, air mail pay was
rdjusted retrospectively back to March 1, 1939, at the rates
so fixed. Rates on the other. two domestic routes were
not determined until after thie amendment. . In both in-
stances the € ommission fixed rates which were higher than
the contract rates, cffe ctive retrospectively to March 1,
1935, although the proceedings had been begun after that,
me ; : ss .
Few cases arose.involving requests for dondbuakaiens of
rates previously fixed by the Commission. at was held that
on reexamination rates could’ be increased nét merely pro-
spectively but? retrospectively to the date of the application:
pe
68 See, e.a., fo & Southern Air. Lines, Inc., ‘Rate Reviews,
223 1. C. C. 535, 546; dir Mail Rates for Route No: &, 227 ae i ee
909, 510; Air Mail Rate for Route No. 2, 2?1 1.C, C. 229, 231.
69 Ty ‘Air Mail Rates for Route No: 31, 214 1.,C.. C. 38%, se
proceeding: was begun’ on. March 21, 1935. In Air Mail Rate for “
gay No. 33; 216 1. C. C. 381, the proceeding was begun on July
22, 1935. 4In the latter case Commissionér cere ‘hee had not
sat in the former case) dissented on the ground: tha
prescribe compensation retroactively” (p. 403). ° In 1937 the Post
Office was still declining to give any retrospective effect to the
Commission's finding. —/nter-Island Airways, ‘Limited, Rate Re--
views, 225 1, C. C. 115, 117.
e could “find -
nothing in the law under which we operate that authorizes us to —
«/-
‘ a :
e . = ‘ ‘ E é a
-
.
°
for reexamination.””’ It was never held that rates could not
be adjusted retrospectively toa time antedating ‘the petition
for reexamination. In three ‘cases, airlines sought te have
rate increases made effective earlier than the time of the
application for reexamination.” In each case they had a
hearing on the merits. The requests were denied on the
merits, not for.lack of power”! The Commission actually
.
. . dl
7° Here too Commissioner Mahaffie: dissented. His argurhent
was that’ the decision in the New Pork Central case under the Rail-
way Mail Pay, Act was inapplicable because airlines—unlike rail*
roads were not obliged to carry mail. Air Mail Compensation, 216°
\.C. C. 166, 192. On appeal to the full Commission, this decision
was sustained by an 8 to 2 vote, with only Commissioners Mahaffe
cand Lee dissenting. Air Mail Campensation, 222 I. C. CT. 602, 610.
The Post Office Department never attempted to test the point in the
courts (as it had done in the Nete York Central case, by declining to
pay dn the basis of the Commission's findings), but Commissioner
- Mahafhe continued to dissent thereafter. dir Mail Rates for American
Airlines. [nc., 2251. C. C.12, 46; Air Mail Rates for Braniff Airways,
Inc., 226 1. c C. 752, 768; Air Mail Rates for. Route No. 8, 227
1. C. C. 509; 516; Air Mail Rates for Route No. 26, 229 1. C. C.
373, 383% Air Mail Rates for Route No, 29, 229 1. C. C. 623, 632;
Air Mail Rates, for Route: No. m1 € Cc. 3, 250:° Air Mail
Rates for. Route No. 13, 231 1. C. C. 673, 683.
1 “As* previously stated,’ petitioner seeks to. have the. findings
herein fade effective from May 1, 1936, prior to the date its peti-
x tion was filed. In Air-Mail Compensation, 216 1. C. C. 166, the .
rates found fair and reasonable for Toutes nos. 3 and .16 were, for .
the reasons there stated, made applicable from the date .of filing of
_the petition, This record. affords no basis for any different conclu-
sion, especially, in view of the fact’that the relief sought will, in
part at least, be obtained through the ‘proper application of the order
n Air Mail Compensation, supra, during the period prior to the
date of filing the petition,” National: Parks soc a Rate
Mileage, 220 I. C. C. 149, 154. _
_ there is no indication on this record that any modification
of the base rate formerly determined and fixed as fair and reasonable
is warranted.” Boston-Maine Airways, Inc., Base Rate Mile a.
229 1. C. C. 343, 350.
“We find that the rates of compensation for the transportation
of air mail by airplane and the service connected therewith ever air
~ F
-.. a
_~
‘made, however, such a retrospective increase in a case in-
sishn. — wll the airlines.? It also decreased rates
mail route 6 have not been shown to be unfair and unreasonable.”
Air Mail Rates for Route No. 6, 229 1. YC. 357, 369-370,
An order issued in 1935 in Hir- Mail Compensation, 206 1. C. C.
675, established a sliding scale of rates tor all but two of the do-
mestic routes. As pointed out in Air Mail Compensation, 322 1. C. C.
602, GDS, it was recognized that this “might result, in Sme indi-
vidual instances, in a-carrier receiving higher compe nsation for per:
forming a given number of miles of service than it would have
received for performing a greater number,of miles, but there then
seemed To be little probability Gf such a result in broad application
of the scale. Since that time, however, the inauguration or cessation
of partial schedules and changes in route mileages have resulted
in sych. situations with increasing frequency.” © Gonsequently. in
1937-the Commission changed. its order so as to include a retrospec-
tive proviso “to the effect that the compensation payable.under any
_ rate Netoctaied under the scale should not exceed the minimum
compensation payable under the next lower rate so deterntined.”
Air Mail Compensation, 222 1. C. Ceh02, 608° Commissioner Ma-
haffie dissented. The effect of this proviso was to reduce the com-
pensation considerably: (For details, see: -the comparative chart 4
ir Mail. Compensation, 232 1. C. C. 608, 615.) | The aoeeies
General regarded the proviso as effective as of March 1, 1935,- and
required “stibstantial refunds from the carriers” back to that date.
See dir Mail Compensation, 232 1. C.-C. 608; 610; American Air-
lines, Inc.—-Mail Rate Proceéding, 3 C. A. B. 323, 327 note 12.
Thus the compensation was reduced retrospectively. . ¢
Later in 1937 the Commission reopened the proceedings’ as to
all airlines, after one had protested. It‘ultimately vacated the pro-
-Viso and inserted a new one. “We have authority upon. ourcown
motion to correct an error in our-former findings and to make such
finding in the forni of an amendment .to our original findings and
order.” . tir Mai] Conepeisation, 232 1. C. C. 68, 613. Once again
Commissioner-Mahaffhe dissented. Under the.new proviso the air-
are received even. more. than under the original 1935 .order. 232
.C.C. at p, 615, Here again the Postmaster General readjusted
Sacre hack to March 1, 1935. ee American Airlines, Inc.—
Mail. Rate Proceeding, 3 C. A. B.. 323, 32% note 12. Thus:the in-
crease was also retrospective. Deities this second readjustment of-
compensation, it appeared that one of the airlines “had been overpaid
>
°
09
retrospectively to a day antedating the start of. the rate
review sateen tile ee | oe
_ D. The Changes Made by the Civil Aeronauties Act
The Civil Aéronautics Act of 1938 completely revolution =:
ized the Status of the airlines and the nature of mail pay.
Congress ccucluded that air c&rriers subserved national |
interests of far greater importance e than cheap postal ser-.
_ vice, and that air mail pay should be the means of develop-
ing the infant aviation industry to effectuate those inter ests.
Hence - Congress enunciated a ‘‘new national poliey’’
to foster ‘*the continued development of an air transporta-
‘tion system adequate to the paramount national needs, not
only of the postal service but also of our commerce and our
national defense.
oe
( ‘hicago & Southern Air Lines, Ine.—
Mail Rates for Routes Nos. 8 and 53,3 << A. B. 161, 191.
No longer were airlines free to withdraw .from their
obligation to.carry mail. They. were compelled to carry
the mails, ¢401(k), (m),°(n), i) U. S.C. §§481(k) (im),
(n), and 6902 (a), 49 U..S. C. $622 a). - Necessarily they
were afforded .just iemamaie 1 as a matter of right,
$$401(m) and siaiehae ,
dexinng the. period from March 1, 1935; to the date of the last order ;
tle Post Office Department collected this excessive compensation
x 4
;
‘by withholding. certain sums from current payments until the sum
was restored.” American | Airlines, Inc—Mail Rate Proceeding,
3C. A, B. 323, 327 note 12. er
78 See note 72 supra. The Commission consistently reviewed
operations for periods antedating the proceeding for revision, ¢.g.,
Wyoming Air Service, Inc., Rate Review, 225 1..C. C. 1; Western
Air Express Corp. Rate Review, 225 1. C. C. 743; National Airways,
lic. Rate Review, 226 1. C. C. 409; Hanford Airlines, Inc. Rate Re-
view, 227 1. C. C. 593, but actually lowered its rates*Gnly in‘the in- -
stances mentioned in note 72... - 3 ‘ .
Yr,
uot
ae ks
Congress abolished the former system under which both
the Post Office and the Commission had ‘fauthority over
the compensation to be. paid for the transportation of air
mail.’’""* Instead a new agency was created’ to devote its
exclusive attention to the subject of air. transport and given
wide latitude to a !just mail rates.
Provisions desigyed to hold mail pay as low ag mn eee
30 that it would not exceed postal revenue, disappeared.”
The voluntary contract system—under which airlines would ,,
bid nominal rates in order to obtain certificates to NE a
—was eliminated. Ceilings‘on maximum rates were re- | *
moved. Mail pay was no longer to be computed on a narrow
“quantum meruit basis. It was.to be ample enough to enable
the airlines to ‘‘maintain and continue the development of
air transportation to the extent and of the character and.
- : ad
™. Subcommittee Hearings, pp. 40, 42. The Commission had
frequently pointed out the undesirable effects of the “divided au-
thority over the compensation to be paid for the transportation of
air mail.” S0th Annual Report of the Interstate Commerce Coim-
mission (Nov. 1, 1936), p. 31; 31st Annual Pgs of the Interstate
Comme rce Commission (Nov. 1, 1937), p.
73 The Commission 1 had pointed out: the ee of determining a
the postal reveque fron: air-tnai! + Statutory Maximon “Mail Rates, :
H, Doc. No. 141, 75th Cong., Ist Sess., p. 10), that’ * ‘unless’ a. phe-
* nomenal increase occurs in the revenue from air-mail postage by |
~ 1938, compensation measured by rates confihed to such revertue would 2
.* not enable the carriers to operate the present class of mail service, if | %
it would permit them to operate at all” (50th Annual Report of the
Intezstate Conimerce Com mission |Nov. 1, 1936], p. 31), and that
there “is;-of course, no necessary relation between. the reasonable
compensation paid for the transportatiort of the mail and the rev-
enues received bx the Government from thé public for such seryiee” “
(Sst cinnual Report of the Interstate Commerce Commnssion:
| Nov. 1, 1937], p. 34). .
™ See, eg., Transcontittental & Western Air Mai Rid, 223.1. €. C.
281, nvolving a bid tu carry mail at 1 null per airplane mile.
omy
~~)
61
quality’ required for the comme ree of the United States, the
“and tha yptional defense,”’ 406(b). ‘The
Postal Servic
mail provisions :of the Act “enacted the policy of gove eri-
9957° ie
‘mental financial aid to the air lines.
Likewise the rate-making “proe ‘edure under the earlier
acts was completely overhauléd, Congress struck out the
provision that rates should remain in effect until changed.
It dropped the requirement that six months had-to elapse
before mail rates could be ‘‘reexamined.’’ The newly -cre-.
ated Board was ‘‘empowered"’ to review rates at all times,
s
)406(a). A petition for a rate had to state the 1 ‘ate helieved..
fair, 6406(e). . bas 9
- Nor did Congress leave the dev lopment of. air trans--
portation to the voluntary action of the airlines. - The
. Board was not: to be a passive umpire between the Post
Office and the airlines, sitting with folded hands until it was
petitioned to act. Congress did not allgw the Board. ‘‘to
rest upon the assumption that so long as the carrier inter-
poses no ‘objection to-an existing rate, the situation requires
no. particular relief’ (87). By {406(a) (1) it not only++eni-—
powered’ Lbut ‘directed’? the Board to take action **upon
its Own initiative.’ It placed on the Board the independent
responsibility of effectuating the legislative purposes stated |
in 42-and $406(b), whether the airline acted or not. ‘*Our
obligation is to see to it that the rates heo{the Postmaster
General} pays are at all times sufficient to — the ear-
riers to accomplish and maintain those purposes.” Ameri-
can Airlines, Inc.—-Mail Rate Proceeding, 8 C. A. B. 323,
330, By the same token, Congress pave, the: Board full
«
.
— =.
. . he
Survival in the Air Age, Report of the President’ s Air Policy
Commission (Jan. 1, 1948), p. 100,
woe oe ae eee
RS -
ry Se 62
e
power to effectuate thosé purposes When the carrier did
act. ; , ans. 7
+ Thus Congress swept away Whatever restrictions existed
under dirlier laws to hapfper the flexible adjustment of
mail pay. Limitations « on_the power to mike retrospective
rate increases might be appropriate in ‘statutes primaril¥
. concerned. with keeping the cost ef postal operations low.
They would only defeat the broad national objectives of the
new Act, «when Congress wants to give wide disere-
_ tion it uses broad language.*’ Addison v. Holly Hill Fruit
. Products, Inc., 322 UL S. 607, 616. -In §406(a) (1) iteeon-
‘ferred the widest discretion by using the proadest possible
. words. “Phe Board was ‘empowered. and .direeted
to make such. rates effective from such date as -it shall
_determine to be proper.”’ ;
‘ o. : "a . °
E. The “Legislative History” of Section 406(a)(1)
' . The only valid legislative history of (406(a)(1) appears
; . ————— ; Zz Pare a alate ‘.
in the Conference Report issued in June 1938, 16 days be-
fore the Act was approved."* The ‘‘make effective’’ lan-
guage .had been suggested in the spring of 1937 during
hearings on a bill which was not enacted into law.’ The
‘witness proposing it, Mr. Gorrell, représenting the Air
= : . Co 3 . é +
Transport Association, told a Senate subcommittee: ‘*the
wee 8. 4 epee. SC eee te) :
be —y- were under, primary consideration by the Senate
subcommittee, S. 2 and an anéndment thereof. (Stmilar bills were
introduced in ‘ Hyoyse. ) ection $11 of the orginal S. 2. printed
in Subcommittee Hearings/p. 9, was modified in several tespects by.
the Jamendment, and §3%0-dq)- (i), ot the amendment, printed “in
Subsommitioe Hearings. p. 2%, conterms much more ch scly to the
present Act Practically everybody agreed that the: amendment was
preterable and it was the chief subject of discussion m the hearmys.
When we refer to the “193 pitt.” we shall mean amended ’S. 2,
>
o ect a
S
a
y
ie
zs - {3
63
‘present authority of the Commission to fix appropri-
ely the effective date of ifs rate decisions is... specitically *
preserved.
(74-76) and the Court below (113) as the Keystone of an
argument tliat Congress intended the Act to be construed,
some
This sentence. was relied on by: the Board
to permit fate increases retrospectively only to the filimg
date of the proceeding. The contention is grourfdless.
_. The Board’s argument prosesds about as follows. (a)
Under the Air Mail Acts of 1934 and 1939, there was a dis-
sagreement whether rate changes could be made. efféctive
back to the institution of a prageeditig. (b) The bill under —
consideration ‘in 1937 contained provisions ‘;practically
identical *? with those i in the Air Mail Acts. (c} Fhérefore
‘that disagree ment was bound to bé perpetuated if that bill
was passed. (d) No dther disag reement as to the Commis-
sion’s power existed; the implication is that it was settled.
that a rate change could: not -be made effective as of a day
aitedating the proceeding. (e) Recognizing that this’ one
ee of disagreement would persist, and’ solely to resolve
t, Mr. Gorrell. suggested the ‘‘make effective’ language ’
aa (f) it was added to the bill for the same limited pur:
poser (x) Consequently, despite its palpably broader lan-
guage, itymfst be given a meaning limited by the narrow
: disagree ‘ment which alone it "was designed to resolve. . (h)-
W hen C ongress passed the Act in 1938, over a year later,
‘it had all this past fistory in mind—although no one re-
ferred to it. (i) Therefore the clear words of the Act must
be interpreted to mean something less than they say.
This argument is unsound from start to finish.
Subcom mittee -Heartwngs, p. 525. See also Hearinis hetor
House Committee on H. FR: S234 and H. R. 4652, 75 C mg., Ist Sess,
p. 108. :
64
Admittedly there was disagreqnent within the ¢ ‘ommi:
sion on the question of retrospective: rate-making. Com.
Inissione or Mahatlie dissented from every decision changing
rites retrospectively, The disagree ment was not. limited
to .the narrow question whether thé Commission could |
chiinge rates retrospectively to the date the proceeding was
begun, but no earlier. Nor would a disagreeme ‘nt on. that
narrow question have been per petuated if the 1937 bill were
passed. For it simply is- net true that the 1937 ‘bill con-_
tained provisions | practically identical with those contained
__—-inrthe Air Mail Acts. ©‘. ee hed ea “Rg
for one. thing, the rate-making provisions of the 1937 _
bit were entirely different from those _of the Air Mail
«
Acts.” All the ‘minutiae of expression . . . that. show
a e
_§t Section” 308(d). of “amended ee rhage Dae etaeatet
Hearings, p. 28):
“eo “6 d)) The Commission is pete. ee pee directed, mponi
its own initiative, or upon petition of the Postmaster General .
“or an air cartier, (1) to fix and determine from time to time,
- after notice and hearing, the fair and reasonable rates of
compensation for the transportation of mail by aircraft, and
the facilities devoted to and servicés connected therewith, by
- each holder of a certificate authorizing the transportation of
. ‘ mail by aircraft; (2) to.preseribe the method or methods, by
. aircfait-mile, pound-mile, weight, space, or any combination
< _ thereof, or otherwise, for ascertaining such rates of compen-
% sation for each air carrier or class of air r carrie rs; and (3) to
publish the same; and the‘rates so fixed and dete rmnined shail
be paid by the Postmaster General frort - “appropriations for
_ the transportatton of mail by- cadrcrait: Provided further, That
the Commission shall as soon as practicable initiate proce ed-
ings under this section to fix such rates for air carriers to
w! hich payment at the former contract rates ts authorized: and
shall deeide all such proceedings as speedily as possib le,’
The changed standards to he considered in fixing fates were
dontained in $3041.06), Subcomnettee Hearings, p. 22. —
e
\
“
2
(Congress to have been thinking ofthe future,’ ‘2 which were
carried over bodily into the Air Mail Acts from the Railway °
Mail P ay Act, were eliminated. ‘\’ More important, the 1937 »
‘bill—unlike The Air’ Mail Acts—obligi ited airlines to carry
mail. Commissioner Mahaffie’s disagreement with the
majority of the Commission, when it held that pow er-ex xisted
under the Air Mail Acts to. make rates effective back to the ”
start of proceedings, was wholly predicated on the ground ‘
.that no obligation to carry mail was imposed by tliose
SO
Statutes.” The 1937 bill imposed that obligation. Once car-
riage of mail became the statutory duty of the airlines, no
doubt could reniain as to’ the existence of that power in -
view of this-C ourt’ s holding i in U uaee States v. New York
de ; ,
8 United States V. New York Central Ra. Cé., 279 U. « 13, 79.
-~ For instance, rates were no jonger to. be fixed “by order” which
was to“coniinue in force until changed.” More in Aportayite the pro-
vision permitting “reexamination” of an_order only after’a 6-months
waiting period Was eliminated, and the ‘Commissjon | awas “directed”
to act at all time§ “upon its-owa initiative. : aos
Se $305(¢),. Subcommittee Hearings, p. 23, and piedy
thid., p. 31. For the corresponding Agrpes of the original S. 2,
see $$305¢h) (1) and 305(n), ibid, pp. 4 and 5
oh Aig Maw Kompensation, 216 1. Ce C. 166, 192, Commis: 5
sioner Mahaffie, dan stated :
“For the power to require « retroactive Increase in the
‘campensation of the apphcant the majority rely greatly on
, the. decision of the ee Court in United States v. New: +
York Central, 279 U.S. 73. That decision was based, o1
“the fact that carriage of the mail by railroads is required by —
law.. Retusal is puftishable by a fine. Because the service >
is compelled, the constitutional rights of the srailroads were,
considered of impertance. Here we_have a very different
situation. The air mail is carried ‘by contractors. - ‘Fhe air ©
, line jis under no degal compulsion to become a contractor. ¢It .
may’, on 60 days’. notice, terminate its contract, and end Jits
* undertaking to carry mail.” :
.e
.
on,
. -§
as
(entral Rd, Co.—whether or not the ‘‘make effective’’
Yuuite was added. Plainly, therefore, the ore point of dis-
. 5 A a &. rs s * 7 ad » : . » " A
agreement on which the Board’s argument is foeu ee
. would ‘nol have bee ‘n perpetuated’ had the. 1937 ‘Dill
passed without the ‘‘make effective?’ ¢lause: a iy =o ;
But the errors an the basic premise of the Board’s argu-
ment go even deeper. It is ‘not correct to say that the only
een
‘point of disagreement was whether r retrospective changes ;
could be made back to the start of ‘the rate proceeding.
Nor is it correct to neal that it was Settled, under the Air’
Mail Acts, that a | rate could not be ‘changed retrospectively
effective.as of any earlier day. ‘No case under the Air Mail,
‘Acts ever held or: said that. 6 On the contrary, in certain
_instances where such retrospective, changes were deemed
appropriate, the Commission actudlly made them—and°
those changes ‘also. elicited dissents by Commissioner Ma-
haffie. For instance, he dissented when a co
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.