Brief for the US — Wisconsin Electric Power Co. v. United States

Supreme Court brief1949

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

INDEX

¢ ~ e

Opinions below. ____- , nee:

- Jurisdiction. ____ 2.

Question presented. ___ - , ; -.

Statutes and other authorities involved Secwes

Statement.

Bummary of argument.

Argument:,

i. Introduction... .._... i ch atte Saat ‘a

II. The legislative history atSwe that Congress intended

to tax sales of energy to commercial businesses and to

exempt sales for use in industrs :

III. The long existing. Treasury Regulations and the rulings

of the Bureau of Internal Revenue issued substantially

contemporaneously with the enactmens of the statute

support the construction made by the courts below

IV. The dairies to which the taxpayer sold the-electricity are

milk dealers or distributors-and the electrical energy

furnished them: was for commercial consumption.

_ Conclusion. _- ap ptvibnuahan owawuseean

Appendix. -_. Siernistieeten ised henhaaewnimediowwtatae'sa

CITATIONS

Cases: Mae.

“American Chicle Co. v. United States, 316 U. 8, 450. ____-

Anheuser-Busch Assn. v..United States, 207 U.S, 556... ___

. Better Business Bureau vy. U nifed States, 326 U.S. 279____

Bowles v. Seminole Rock Co:, 325 U.S. 410.....___- “

' Brewstez v. Gage, 280 U. 8. TIES

_* City of Louisville y. Ewing Von-Allmen D. Co., 268 Ky. 6: 52.

: Dairy Assn. v. Bd. of Taz Admin., 302 Mich. 643_.... . -

Fondren, v. Commissioner’ Ss BR ON epee ete eae

Fruit Growers, Inc. v. Brogdez Co., 283 U. 8.1 a

Fulton Market.Cold Storage Co. v.. United States, 43 F. upp.

Ch a wanwes suck wks chen iedde meas re re i

Helvering v. Reynoldg,.313 Pe Miwa écksteanc cerns

Helvering v. Wilshire Oii Co., 308 et Gf Sees

Helvering v. Winmill, 305 U. s. 79... bank wane

Hood, H. P.: & Sons v..Commonweaith, 235 Mass. ! 572. E

Jordan vy. Tashiro, 278 U. 8. 123 Srp in mace

* Larson v. Ives Dairy Co., 154 F. 2d 701

Morriss¢y v. Commissioner, 296 U. 8. 344 te tt

People ez rel: E: S. Dairy Co. v. Sohmer, 218 N. ¥.199___ !

People v. Stevens Co., 178 App. Div.(.N. Y.) 306, appeal

dismissed, 221 (N. Y. ) 622 . ptkéceageSehncl g<cusbnes

81850248 — | » (0 :

II

Cases—( yatinedt — re the Page

Public Service Co. of Colorado \ v. United States,.decided — ©

July 6, 1943 (32 A. F. T. R. 1720), affirmed 143 F. 24 79_. 30, 50

Richmond v. Dairy Co., 156 Va. 63... __ — . 44, 54.

St. Louis Refrigerating & Cold 8. Coey. United States, 43 F;

Supp. PNG Riscskp nthe el aaeetetem anew kane ay ee

Suabedissen-Wittner Dairy v. ee of Treas., 105 Ind.

jG MDGs ar yeti wes ak OD innit ndd exh Bie Lok ee

United States v. Wier. 158 F. 2d 91. Py ae ae 41

United States v. Public Service Co. of Colorado, 143 F. 2d 7. 31, 45

ie. omaR v. San Francisco, 310 U. S. 16... 2... 16

United States v. Underwriters Asan., 322 U.S. 533. EPS AA. 11

. White v. Winchester Club, 315 U. S. 32_..-.-_.--__.- nme. 31

Williams v: Harrison, 110 F. 2d 989___.....-.-..--..-.. ° 43

Wright x. Vv inton Branch, a i ee te ee es << fs site

Statutes: “$

Act of June 16, 1983, c. 96, 48 Stat. 254, See. 6.... 18, 19, 27, 60

Internal Revenue Code, Sec.-3411 (26 U.S. C. 1946 ed.,

Nee Bsn ok Seen dk eek an were Cire ee 58

Revenue Act of 1932, ec. 209, 47 Stat. “169, See. 616 11, 13, 25, 59

Revenue Act of 1938, c. 289, 52 Stat. 447, See. 713.._.. aa |

Revenue Act of 1941, ¢. 412, 55 Stat. 687, Sec. 521____- ‘2 37,59

Revenue Act of 1943,. &. 3, 58 Stat. 21, Sec. 307... __ eas 27

Miscellaneous: ;

Babeock, The Paiteteiadtion of Milk, U. Ss. Deportes of

Agriculture Leaflet No. 177 (1939) 2.---_.. 2-222 ee xt 37

* Bowen, The Cost of Pasteurizing Milk and Cream, U. S.

Department of Agriculture Bulletin No. 85 (F914) 22... 41

NOOE G, Gi. Oh. COR Sy OR Ss on hooked acdea ne 67.

75 Cong. Record: Wy fae De. sexe

Part 10, pp. 11559, 11615-11616. ..2-....2..-..-..-° 13

Part 10, pp. 00-20. 2 ee ccc Boop dass ae

Part 10, pp: 11604, 11605, 11606, 11607, 11608, 11609. 16, 17

Fost 11,:on. 10001; 19017, 13046... =...

* Part 11, p. 12012_- <p ie 1 ae : ue ‘ 15

Part 11, pp. 12027, 12054, 12055, 12056, 12057, 12061, 15.

Part.11, p. 12066. . Low dga eae ace eRe ae ace ee

77 Cong. Re Send: 2 ee ime

Part 2, pp. 2045, 2050_. Rete ae og face

Part 3,. pp. 3212-3214, 3215... © ee

Part 3, pp. 3217, 3222... * sake ie hace oe

Part 3, p. 3218 Paahe es: ee eer GF 20

Part 3, 7. 3220. __- aS nga:

Part 3, p. $242 pera at 8 crac : 2

Part 5, p. 4762, . : ae ae 23 -

Part 6, pp. 5302, 3460 S61, Sanz 2, 5168 . , 19

i - Part 6, pp. S460-54%b 2 6. a a 1u-

Part 6, p: 5462 _- 2 23

Miscellaneous—Continued Page

Dow, Ay Economie Study of Milk Distribution in Maing,

The Maine Agricultural ben riment Station Bulleyini

No. 395 (1939). ___. ' 41

Federal Power C ommissionef, National Electric Rate Book

: 2

Federal Trade Commission, Report on the: Distribution

and Sale of Milk and Milk Products, omg Baltimore,

Cincinnati and St. Louis, hares: Doc. “No 501, 74th,

; Cong., 2d Sess., 146... _- Fe Pee perk PULA pee Spin an . 40

‘Hearings before the House Ways and Shadab Cotamittee, ,

72nd: Cong., it Meas cg vaccs Bee rk ale kee aera rg ee ae 12, 13

Hearing: before: the ee Finance Corainittee on H. R.

‘Ist Sens SAREE EE ALOR CO OR CE ee oe ove

H. Conference fa No. 1492 , 72nd Cong., Ist fleas. yp. 92

(1939-1 Cum. Bult. (Part 2) 539, 548) oe, ined 14

He Rep. No. 708, 72nd a Ist Sess. (1939-1 Cum. Bull.

(Part > | Rae ae ee ‘13:

H. Conference Rep. No. 188, 73rd Cong., “Ast Sess. (1939-1

Cum..Buil. (Part 2) 886)_.6._ 9. FEV OTE Os 19

Kelly and Clement, posit Milk’ (2a ed., 1931):

fy Ree ~ m ney : te 5 38

P. 327... Sues ee leap 38

P. 337. an 41

Pele Sakae Pa 41

P. 416__ Kigtine waa Beet ae os an ae ae 40

ty | Sara A ied OP IL cae ede dui, PaO 54

King, The Pric e of Milk (1920) 1 189, 209. ee ETS 41

‘Massachusetts Milk Control Board, The, 8 Summary Report

‘ on Cost of N arcarpaaicy Milk -in the Boston Market

(1936) 14, 1... Gear PRES alee.) ~ . ae:

a Management of Dairy Plants (1938) 109: Deeb ae 41

Lsalsintine Doe ument Ne, 100 (1938) epee 40

Roadhouse: anid. Henderson, The Market. tilk Industry

(1941) 4,5... _. eee Yes

S. Rep. No. 58, 73rd Cong., tet Sees “s pas (1939-1 Cum.

Bull. (Part 2). 884, 885) 18

’ Sommer, Market . Milk: and “Re lated Products (2d ed. ;

1946): Pa : 3

ewe a oat ere hve Mie e ee

Ek RCRA ae ies Bea = eae

P. 606 _. een oe ere 40

S. T. 464, XT-2 Cum: Bull. 496 (1932). ~~ foe ae

ST. 466, XI-2 Cum. Bull. 497 (1932). a s7 ae

,

a a

ae oe

: ‘Miscellaneous —Contintied ' - Page

_ &. T. 518, XI-2 Cum. Bull. 498 (1932)... 22... 29, 66

8. T. 527, XI-2 Cum. Bull. 499 (1932)... 728s

8. T. 542; XI-2 Cum. Bull. 501 (1932)..-. 0.002 - 28

8. T. 576, XI-2 Cum. Bull. 502 | EC es oe

8. T. 590, XI-2 Cum. Bull. 503 (1932)_....--° . 6 28

8. T. 615, XI-2 Cum. Bull. 504 (1932)._.:-__.” 28

_ 8. T. 637, XIT-1 Cum. Bull. 409 (1933). ! . 29, 30, 35, 49, 66

8. T. 641, XII-t'Cum. Bull. 410 (1933)__.. ee patie mae rae 28

S. T, 652, XII-1 Cum. Byll. WER Reis odin das pece ne ee

S. T.,674, XIF-1 Cum. Bull. 412 (1933)........... ==. 29 °

S. T. 695, XII-2 Cum. Bull. 324 (1933)_./.-. 2. 29

Tinley, Public Regulation of Milk Marketing in California

(1938) - Sat dnnkndbekunduhncdoncadce nadhonnaae . 40

T. DP. 4342, XI-2 Cum. Bull. 495 (1932)..... | 26, 32, 62

T. D. 4393, X1I-2 Cum. Bull. 322 (1983)__. .-.._.._--__ 48, 63

T. D. 4570, XIV-2 Cum. Bull. 391 (1935)_....- -. _.-.. 64"

T. D. 4751, 1937-2 Cum. Bull. 517... --------22-22 22-22. BED

gre 4922, 1939-2 Cum. POPE ee oe SS

T. D. 5099, 1941-2 Cum. Bull. 267... -____. ie baci sonia : 26, 48, 65

Treasury Regulations 42, Art. 40.....-____- rere

Treasury Regulations 46, Sec. 316.190_.___....__. 27, 32, 45, 65

Webster’s New International Dictidnary (Second ed., 1948, :

unabridged), ------~--------2--+--+---+--- Milian me 10

- Sule Saprem Court of the Winited Sites |

Ocrowr: R Tr RM, 1948 9

”

paps 237

eWisconsin ELectric PowER COMPANY, PETITIONER

« ad ° . v.

Unirep Srates oF AMERICA

fie. ites

GN WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES COURT

.OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT

. ©. ~~ BRIEF FOR THE UNITED STATES

ao

il .

oeEN bo OPINIONS ‘BELOW

The opinion of the District Court (R. 134-1405

is reported at 69 F. Supp. 743, The opinion of.

the Court of Appgls: (R.: Core is icin 3 at

168 F. 2d 285. :

JURISDICTION

. ~The judgment of the Court. of Appeals was

_ entered on May 26,.1948 (R.° 159). The peti-

_tion for & writ of certiorari was fited on August ©

21, 1948, and granted on October 18, 1948 (R. 161).

* The jurisdiction of this Court is invoked-undér 28

U.S.C: 1254. ° @

/ ; @ (1)

‘ey

5

_

| QUESTION PRESENTED

The. District Court found, and thes Court of |

Appeals upheld the finding, that the predominant

business of each of twenty-seveif dairies to which

the taxpayer furnished electrical energy was that

of a fluid. = dealer and distributog, that the.

businéss was ‘‘commereial’’. ji nature, ‘and that,

pasteurization of milk by the dairies was only an

incidental part. of that busine B88, .- - 3

The question presented is whether the courts

below correctly held that sales of electrical. éner ‘gy

to thesé dairies for ust i in their plants, in¢luding

the undetermined part of such energy used in

‘pasteurization, were sales - for “commereial. con-

sur ption’? within the meaniffe of Section : 3411 (a)

of the Internal Revenue Code.

‘STATUTES AND OTHER AUTHORITIES INVOLVED

The sti tutes anid other authorities. involved are .

sét forth in the Appe ndix, infra, pp. 58-68,

STATEMENT

Theepertinent fac ‘ts, taken: from the stipulation.

of the parties (Rt. 7-44) and the findings of the

___District Court (141-146), are as follows:

During the peried April 1, 1940/to July 31,

1943, the t taxpayer supplied. electrical energy to

twenty-eight customers engaged in the dairy busi-

ness in and around Milwaukee, Wi isconsin. (R.

13, 141.) Fifteen of the twenty-eight dairies we re

furnished the ene eR throng mere thape one € ‘lee-

je.

~~ ty fun

3

f

, a

trie meter, Provided by the taxpayer; but in no

instances Were ‘the separ ate qn rs so connected -

as to enable. the energy supplie d for one purpose

or another iv the operations of tlie dairy to be

differentiated. * (R. 13, 141-142.) :

During this’ period the taxpayer paid $6,806.84

‘in taxes on sales of energy. fo the twenty eight

customers, computed at the rate of three per cent

to June 30, 1940, and three and one-third, per cent

thereafter. , On May 25, 1944, the t taxpayer filed:

\with the reper Collector of Internal Revenue a

| aim for’ refund-of these-t taxes on the ground that

—itvhad erroneously treated thessalés of energy as

2 sales. for commercial consumption, The claim for

refund. was rejected: by the CommisSioner of

Internal Revenie. (R. Mey es,

The. District Court found that, twenty-seven of

the dairies are pr edominantly. fluid milk dealers

and distr ‘ibutors.: (R.: 146.) . The twenty-seven

operate in much‘ the same way, They make con-

tracts with farm. preducers for purchase of the

~ milk daily and at other regular inte rvals, some-

times the producers delivering the milk to the

dadries and somtimes the dairies supplying the

ticks and dvivers to pick it up; The dairies

One. of the dairies, Pabst Farms. was found to ‘yd en-

raged predomi nantly in the manufacture of condensed and

~ powdered skim milk-and butter fat which it-sold at whole-

sale throughout the United States. The Distri et C ourt held

therefore that sales ‘of electrical energy. to ‘it Were not for

commercial cotisumption. -(RI 142-143.) ° No issue is here

~ Palsed with respect to that dairy, ronan . '

a

i.

_&

?

. then wel igh, test sina mix thé milk to obtain stand-

ard quality, pasteurize it, pour it in clean hottles

and cans and keep the-bottles and gans in cold

: " storage rooms: until the delivery men pick them

up the same day or the following day. The de-

livery -men cover definite territories or routes

“¢ach day, deliyering the milk to regular custom-

“ers, . including homes, “restaurants, hotels and,

stores daily and every other day in accordance

with standing. ahd specific orders. (R. 143-146. ¥

“The dairies pasteurize the milk with —

(ad designed equipment. . The milk “is heated to. 143°. |

/ to 145° BF, kept at that temperature for oie )

“thiity minutes and then cooled rapidly down to

"38408 ‘F. The purpose of pasteurization is to

kill pathogenic bacteria‘in the milk while stayint

within such tolerances as neither to déstroy the | |

| natural creaming properties of mk noximpart . :

ie seorched.tastée to it. “(R. 144-145.) . \ 4

Electrical energy is used ‘by the dairies. for

lighting ‘administrative offices and’ garages. for _

- -¢hé eollecting: and distributing trucks as well.

as. the rest -of the. plants. It is also: used to,

operate electric-motors which pump refrigerants, , -

veres milk to and from pasteurizing vats and

to hottling mac hines where pumps are necessary,

operate bottling machines, operate hottle washers

or sterilizers"and conveyors,- operate cream sepa-

* “gators; operate homogenizers where the dairies

a have them, and perform similar funetions. .The

large r dairies differ from the smaller ones chiefly

° s

.

in the autos of amit’ iivailable for “Bifferent

- pper rations, such as a larger number of pasteuriz-”

“+ ing vats, more hottling machines, ete. (R. 145.) .

;

e

The District Court found that the distribution

f milk, has existed in the United States as a

lis form of enterprise for nearly ¢ 1 century.

. Paste arization of milk on a oes ‘seale was,

not established in this country until. 1897. It.

‘came into use in Milwaukee in 1903, and. by:

~1915-it was quite common practice. But even at

ey: present time there are more raw milk plants

in the United States than those which pasteurize

their milk. “In the cities | of over ‘one-thousand

* population . in the United States, a. majority, ‘of

- the milk dealers distribtite unpasteur ized milk;

more, than twenty-five per cent of all milk sold

mM cick cities. is not pasteurized. Two dairying

experts’ testified at the idl that they had never

‘heard of -a dairy plant’ “whic h’ pasteur ized and

bottled its milk, Which .was nota distributor.

(R:143-144.) We 7 |

It also found that while saetomot tne is an

: _ important. part ofsthe_ business of the dairies in-_

“volved in the” case, they likewise utilize systems

, of * ¥ipid regular distribution of fresh milk to

their customers, and maintain fleets of trucks,

horse-drawn w agons and drivers Ss, garages, loading -.

and unloading facilities, weighing and testing

devicés, ‘storage dnd. refrigeration” rooms, and

‘machinery for putting milk into bottles at high

SISDOL-—48-——-2

at

-

f

F 2

ee, re 6

-

speed. .It-found that the record showed pasteur-

‘zation plays a minor part in the totak*business

_Of- the dairies. It! utilizes only a ‘mall fraction

of “thé total. personnel, ‘uses only a minor part:

of the capital investments and accounts for an

insignificant part of the cost of operations. . The

inyestmenit of the dairies in pasteurizing equip-

ment, including increased ‘cooling equipment, is _.

from. fifteen per cent to twenty per cent of the

total, cost: of their plant’ equipment, but this.

entage figure would be ‘considerably smaller

if the investment ii such items as. trucks and

other: vehicles, horses, bottles, ‘ases, ete., were

taken into ‘consideration. Assuming » the sale

- price of a quart of milk in Milwaukee was six:

teen’ cents, the cost: of theAmilk itself was 9.6

cents, the. distribution in bottles about. four’ certs,

and the entire. plant operations about. one cent.

‘About one-tenth of accent of the cost of .plant

oper ations if attributi aPle to pasteurization. a he

predomiiiant business of the dairies involved. is,

and was, that: of fluid milk dealers and distrib-

utors. The electricity sold to them by the tax-

payer was sold for commercial consumption ‘it

Was sold avid used ina commer¢ ‘lal business. — ( R.

146.) ie , a Sater

Fhe. District Court eopeluded | as a matter of

law that the incidence of the: tax: ee

energy did not depend upon the particular opera-_

tion in which the energy was used ‘but upon the?

business of whic ‘h it formed a part, Since the..

4%

ms a2 . <i8

ete? 24 <>

predominapt gyusiness of the twe nty-seven dairies

is, ‘and was, . that of tlaid. milk dealers and dis-

tributors, the electiitity sold to them by the

’ petitioner was sold for commercial: ‘consumption ; ;

it Was, sold: and used in fay commer cal business.

ts eee ee 7 |

The Cowt of Appeals he eld that the ‘findings

of the District Court correctly, set forth the’ con- .

trolling “facts and applied the: proper test- of

commercial consumption. ‘And it -addpted the

opinion of the District’ Court as its own. (R.

157-159.) ee aon

| SUMMARY. OF ARGUMENT-

eee Q

Pe erie |

‘The tax-at Yssue here is levied upon electrical

energy sold for domestie or’ commercial consump-

tion. ‘Commercial’? has varied meanings, con-

noting in its narrowest sense buying - and selling

- and: in its-broadest sense ever Vv phase of business.

activity. On its face the statute appears to use

the term in a."*broad -sense.: And the éleetrie in- |

, dustry classifications’ of consumers submitted to

Congress ‘at hearings wheti_ the tax’ was_ first

considered in 1932. show that the industry used

the term to cover substantially all business consump-

tion. ae | Pes

| II

The legislative history of the statute shows,

however, that Congress. intended to exempt from

the tax on conswiiption by businesses, consumption

.”

eae

in industry, “In this latter category it appears.

that Congress generally intended to include manu-

facturing’and heavy industry, businesses in which

electrical energy is commonly, understood to be.

| used | in very substantial quantity. as a source Of

power in manufacturing and in which. differences

‘in the cost of energy, even as small as the. three.

- percent tax, would be likely to have an important:

effect upon “the cost of operation — of. tlte entire

business and its ability to withstand the competi-

tion of businesses producing ‘their own untaxed

electrical energy... ;

. Th

-Contémporaneously Ww ‘ith. the first oe

of the law in 1932, the Treasury construed the.

statute in bentaiss with the legislative intent:

It gave the phrase ‘commercial: consuntption’’

a broad meaning in its Regulations covering all

business consumption other than industrial, and. ~

by publie utilities, and. iiot merely buyi ing and

selling activities. And its rulings on specific -

cases likewise followed the same view. In one

ruling in 1933 it expressly held that dairies ob-

taining milk atid converting it. into use for retail

“purposes are commercial in character and there- |

fore their consumption of energy is commercial.

Congress has never ‘disapproved the Treasury’s

construction of the law. And the few reported |

cases Show that the electric: utilities haye gen-

erally acquiesced in the Treasury’s contemporane-

ous construction, and applications.

.

An operation or activity which is a. normal *

integral, incident of .aceommercial business may,

snot be. characterized as industrial mei rely be-

“Use, viewed In isolation, it does not constitute:

* buying. or selling. To interpret the: statute so

P “narrowly would be to nullify, the tax on com- '

mercial consumption, since even iit buying. and —

_ selling businesses (although we submit Congress

“did not intend to ‘confine commercial consump-

tion: merely. to such businesses) electricity is uséd.

only as an ssi of the business, for light, heat ee

or power,

The portion of. the Regulations dealing with

two different uses of energy by thé same con-. |

sumer is intended to refer to consumers in two

types of * business | and to industrial consumers

having separated ‘sales organizations, consuming’

energy through separate meters, problems whieh

the statute does not resolve. It is- not intended

_ to narrow the meaning of the statute.

IV

The application of every reasonable test to

detérmine the character of the fluid milk deal-

ing business’ shows it to be- commercial, ” They

, maintain and operate an effective daily distribu-

tion service between many. producers and many

consumers for a fresh clean food product readily.

subject t to spoilage.

Pasteurizing the milk, which is a process of

he ating and cooling to destroy . possible harmful

10

baeteri ia, is merely. an incident of fluid milk deal-_

ing adopted in businesses already existing for

many years and still not adopted by the. ma-

jority of milk dealers. It is. ordinarily not en-

vaged in independently ofsuch businesses. * The —

cost of pasteurizing is rel latively insignificant, ‘it.

requires only a. relatively small part of the milky |

handling and distributing personnel, and the in-

~-vestment in pasteurizing equipment is relatively

small when compared td its distributing -

ment. Though it'may be ealled a ‘‘process’’, like

many other- processes it is stHl an. incident ‘of a

, commercial business and does not-make the fluid

milk dealers manufacturers or put them in‘in-.

dustry. The courts below therefore properly ‘held

~ the sales of energy to the dairies were for’ com-

es

merciakconsumption. ae ati QU

| ARGUMENT? ‘

le

INTRODUCTION

* Section 3411 (a) of the Internal Revenue Code >

(Appendix, infra)_imposes an excise tax ‘upon

electricak energy sold for domestic or commercial

consumption” ‘to be paid by the vendor.

The statute provides no definition for ““com-

merejal”’.

“Commercial’” is not a word of art ; and die

tionary definitions would support a very ‘broad

and confprehensive interpretation. See, e. 2,

Webster’s New International Dictionary (Second

as

Sb ughete ie ie

TENS: eR

en

| il

ed., 1948, unabridged ). And this Court has noted

that while. “commerce” or ‘commercial’? may ,.

possibly. be used in. a narrow sense to mean only

“the purchase and. sald er exchange of goods anid :

commodities’’, it may also include, unless the con-—

text: indicates: otherwise, “other oce upatipns and

other recognized forms of business enterprise w ore

= not-necessar ily involv e trading i In mer chandise”’

‘in a broad sense it embraces every phase of seis

mercial and business activity and intercourse’?

Jordan Vv. Tashiro, 278 U. g. 123, 127-128; United

States v. Underwriters Assn.,.322-U.-S. 533, 501.

And ef. St. Louis. Refrigerating & Cold S. Co. v.

United States, 43 F. Supp. 476, 484 (C. Cls.). iy

- If -we took only the words of the statute, it

would appe: Tr that Congress intended “domestic

or commercial consumption” to cover “the entire

field of consumption of electric al energy, since it”

found it neeessary to make express exc eption in

Seetion 3411 (¢) (Appendix, infra) for electrical —

energy sold to the United States, or to any_state or,

_tertitory, or politieal subdivision thereof, or the

District of Columbia. Ste,

Moreover, if the meaning of the term‘ ‘commer-

cial’? were sceathe from its usage in the industry

upon which the law has its main impact, namely,

the electric utility ipdust r) v, at the time, the law

Was first enacted, an extremely broad’ meaning of

the term "would have tobe adopted. “The statu-

tory language was first enacted da Section. 616 of

the Revenue Act of 1932, . 209, 47 Stat. 169

oe =

—

eo

12

-

>

a { Appendix, infra). Prior , the drafting of the.

law, hearings were held in which a representative.

of the association of .all électrie light and power

companies was invited to testify. Hearings be- .

fore the House Ways and Me: ms*Committee, 72nd

_-Cong,, Ast " Sess., pp- 1159-1181. - The classifi-

cation of their customers submitted by: the com-

‘panies included. in ‘‘eommercial”’ all: but domestic,

_ municipal, public utilities and a small number of"

miscellaneous consumers. (p. 1167). ' And the data

taken by a Federal Trade Commission . witness

from an industry magazine used ‘“‘commereial”’ in

a similar sense (pp. 1154-1156). Cf. also Fed-

eral Power. Commission, National Electric Rate

Book (1940). .

We do 1 do not srdue dheneces: that state

should ‘be | be construed .so « “as ‘to make sales¢ to al

businesses taxable. The Government recognizes

that. the broad language used by Congress Should

be applied a0 as to give effect to the intention, evi-

&

denced by the legislative history, to exempt such

sales of energy as are used by an ‘industrial’? butgi--

ness for “industrial” | purposes, ~ St: Louis Refrig-

erating & Cold 8. Co.v. United States, 4BF. Supp:

76, 484 (C. Cls. ). If this exemption had been ex-

| pressly made, it would of course have to beat

_Towly construed ; this*is a forliort true “Rial

where the exemption is not expressed and is based :

only on a due regard for the legislative purpose

as manifested by the legislative history. We do

net see how there can. be found in the language ~

: 3 set ; | . . ih PF ary

| hoy aN

and context of the statuté or in its legislative

history support. for the pesition of either the tax-

payer (Br. 22, 27) or the amicus curiae (Br. 13,

21) that electrical energy sold for commercial 7

consumption must~be limited to. that’ used in

-~> buying, selling -and trading dctivities alone.

cs o

THE LEGISLATIVE ‘HISTORY. SHOWS {HAT CONGRESS.

INTENDED TO TAX SALES OF ENERGY TO° COMMER-

‘CIAL BUSINESSES AND 'TO.EXEMPT SALES FOR USE. \

“IN INDUSTRY ~- | , se

The language: of bective 3411 of the Intordial

Revenue Code had its or igin in Section 616 of the

~ Revenue Act of 1932.. Although" the House Ways...

| __and_Means- Committee -hetd~ hearings in 1932. on

_the feasibility of, an ‘electrical energy tax, it did.

‘not provide for it in the revenue bill it reported.’ >

(H. Rep. No. 708, 72ud Cong., Ist Sess. (1939-1.

Cum. Bull. Part 2) 457).) On Maya 1932,

the Senate approv ed a new. provision preposé —

from the e floor, without-prior, consideration by the

-—~" Senate Finance Committee, by Senator Howell of |

Nebraska as an amendment to the then pending

revenue bill. 75. Cong. Record, Part 10, pp.

11559, 11615-11616." This ame ndmett ‘provided:~ q

There is hereby imposed’ upon energy °

-sold by privately owned operating electri-

cal phwer compares a tax equivalent to 3 -

per cént of the price for which so sold.

S1S502 4s

ge

Gh.

| 14 |

: ~ When the Reventie Bill pacar from eonfer- *

_ence of the two. Housés, however, Section 616 had ;

“been changed by the conferees to provide (75 ‘

Cong. Record, Part 11, pp. 12001, 12017, 12046) :

There is hereby imposed a tax equivalent

to 3 per cent. of the amount pid on or

* after .the fifteenth day after the date of.

é the enactment, of | this’ act, “for electrical \

' energy for domestic or commercial con- .

sumption furnished after such date and =

before July 1, 1934, to be- paid’ by the

person pay ing for. such electrical energy,

and to be collected by the vendor. ~

ince the crue ial limiting language: was inserted

— by the: conferees, weight must be attached to their :

explana ns. The Joint’ Conference. Committee _

Report “stated (H. Confer ‘ence Rep,gNo, 1492,

~~ 72nd Coiig., Ist Sess., p. 22 (1939-1 Cun. Bull.

(Part 2). 539, 548)):

The House recedes with an sineainiens

substituting a tax of 3.per cent of the price:

paid for Moctriés) energy for domestic or ;

commercial use (as distinguished from in=

dustrial use), to be paid by ‘the. pur chaser

and collected by the vendor ti aaataty*

Répresentative Crisp of Georgia, a House con-

-feree; explaining the Conference Report on the

floor of the House, declared that thé Senate’ pro-

vision. had been deleted because it. fas unfair to

| investors’ in electric companies ‘and that instead

“the conferees finally agfeed on a 3 per cent:

sales tax one commercial and domestic consumers -

an

oo |

“Ne \

? %

- \

Q-

es |

ee

electric energy.”” 75 Cong: Record, Part 11,

And this explanation of Representative

Record, supra, p. 12066. =,

Cc risp was \also quoted on the Senate floor prior *

to its approval of the. conference e report. 75, 5,Cong. er

-W hile the conferees, ds such, made no ‘addi. |

tional express statements in theirs sreports or.on .

_

the floor of either. House as to the meaning-and-

purpose 0: the ‘limitati ion jptax to sales of elec-

- trical energy- for” domestic or commercial con-

“sumptién, | the attention. of both Houses immedi-’

ately prior to gpproval of the conference. re eport

was called to the fact-that, just before the Senate —

approved the original proposal of Senator Howell

taxing the electric companies. On sales to all.con-

_sumers, two of the Senate conferees, . Senators =

“Smoot of Utah and Reed of. Penns\lv: nia, mem- .

hers of the Finance Committee, hat been de-

s feated ine two attempts. to substitute taxes on

: consumers, in one case dimited : to sales of energy

" for domestic consumptiop and in ‘the other . to-

| sales for domestie and commercial consumption,

in language almost identical to that’ reported. by ©

the Conference Comniittee. 75 Cong. Record,

Part 11, pp. 12027, 12054, 12056, — 12057;

12061; Part 10, pp. 11503-11615... aa

_ At that time the reason advanced by Senators

Smoot and Reed for their substitute amendments

was that the tax would inevitably be passed on

‘by the electric companies to the “consumers. igw—

| any event .and: that. it would be unfair to pro-

£2

LS

yy - ducers in- industry who had-to. buy their elegtric

power in. competition with those who “manu-’

‘-faetured their:. ow 1» -untaxed: powex. “15, Cong.! .

ne Recordg supra; Part 10, pp. 11604, 11605, 11606,

-11607;- 11608, 41609.. THe “discussions on the

- Smoot and Reed preposats aniformly related to

- whether or*ngt manufae ‘turers and manufacturing

businesses, eitabies’ in Sndustry aoe industry.

‘should ‘he exempted, and not as. to whether Mny-

articular ‘operations | i ‘S which electricity Was.

_jised should or should not.be coyered.’ 15 Cong.

Re ‘ord, Patt 10, pp. 11603-11615. For example,

Senator Howell, “the “author of the ‘original pro-

‘posal, stated (p. 11604) :

ihe I under stand that one of the arguments

ea advanced for 1 relieving power consumers— :

rr ie a Tam speaking of power consumers ‘who |

| ‘use electrical energy. for power” only—

was that they would be -placed at a dis-

, Ha) advantage because of this tax as ‘compared

Pape with the manufacturing establishments o

: which. preduece theit own’ energy’: Mr.

President, “assume that a manufacturing

coneern were paying 5 mills for its elec-

‘trical energy—one-half of a cent—under

my. Amendment how much would that

ts.

2Under citcumstances such as are : dae involved the C on-

“ gressional discussions, and particular expositions by those

_ ‘most responsible for the legislation; hav¥e.been lield of con-

_ siderable value in ascertaining - ‘the intent’ of Congress.

Wright v. Vinton Branch, 300 U.S. 440. 463, 464: United

Ntates v. San Fruncixco, 3 U.S 5.16. 2) ‘fy

.&

-* s were passed pn? ee GE

§ f° Senator Reed stated (p. 11606) :

3 .

"The Committee’ on Finance started out with

: ss - out ‘to us that. it would, make -& Serious

'. tween those large producers | in “dustry

‘the smaller proditers who purchase power;

that it would put a handicap on those who

_ have to buy their. power. |

aio In reply toa, question Sy § Senator Bor: ih of

| | Idaho, Senator Reed stated - ‘again (p. 11606) :

If*we put the tax on industrial con- -

. Sumption, Wwe impose a. handicap. upon. the

smaller producers ; everywhere, as against

the larger producers who make their own

power. ae

ia ell Si feet manifactiring establishment pay if thie tax :

‘fa study—a very“hrief one, I am afraid—-

of ‘the Howell qgnendment. It was, pointed

eae ee ‘differenc e in. the competitive ‘situation be- —

which manufacture. their own power and -

ig ae 3

J

&

of

ot At another’ poiut, in.a colloquy betweefi Sena-

tor Reed and Senator. Hiirrison ot Mississippi, t

Was stated (p. 11609) : ot yi heres

he . in “commercial *? 1 notice in the hearings

the words “industrial” and’ ia pak at

i were used. ne pet

| Mr. Rr: ED. No; industrial Is not ine jededt

Mr. Hshnison. Should. not that be

inchided? * _ x | cf :

Mr.-Reep. T do not think so, because

in that case there would-result the inequity

ws

|

|

:

eM, Hakrison. Is “industrial” included |

|

:

.

Pee | Rate

. hetween the big ‘coheern that. makes its

own.-power and the'little one that does not...

Tn. 1933, Congress revised the ‘tax en electrical “a

energy into he fort in which it Has substan-

tially remained at present. It transferred tlie

tax from the consumer to the electric company

‘but continued. to limit it to ‘electrical ehergy:

sold: for domestic or commercial consumption. ”’

‘Act of June 16, 1933, ¢. 96, 48 Stat. 254, See. 6,

Appendix, infra. And here, too, it appears that

what was in the minds of these sponsoring the

legislation was the. nature of the. cousumer’s—

—business- and -net* the-specific operation in that.

business to which the electrical energy was put.

As in 1932, the electrical energy-tax provision

was first introduced as’ a floor amendment to

another tax. bill, but this time in the House. .

77 *Cong. Record, Part 2, p. 2045: “As passed

by the, House the bill did not change the scope

of the tax but merely shifted the burden from

-- the domestic or commercial constimer to the

electric company whigh, sold the energy to him.

77 Cong. Reeord, Payt 2, pp. 2045, 2050. The -

Finance Committée of the Senate, however, “ye

wrote the House bill to decrease the three per

cent’ tax.on. the vendor on sales for domestic

and’ commercial consumption sto two per cent

and added a: one per cent tax upon consumers |

of electrical ‘energy ‘‘for purposes ether thin,

domestic or commercial,” 5. Rep. No. 58, Tard

Cong., Ist Sess.; p. 3-( 193921 Cum. Bull. (Part 2) >

— G i

=

.

Pee CREE OS

884, 885.) And fhe “Senate so. approved it.

H,, Conference Rep. No. 188; 73rd Cong., Lf Suse

(193951 Cum. Bull. (Part 2) 886) ; 77-Cong. Recyrd,

- Part 6, Pp. 54605461. “Then, after disagree

inont in conference as to the form the finial Bit

-, Mould take, the- Senate cone curred in .the -_H use

‘version and: they both passed it in that form. 77

Cong. Record, Part 6, pp. 5392, 5460-5461, 5462,

468. Act of June 16, 1933, supra.

While the formal] report ‘of the Senate Finanee .

“Committee did .not specifically define “commer-

celal consumption,”” the explanation of the report

by: its chairman, Senator Harrison, showed that

what fhe Committee Was concerned with was the -

‘nature of the busiriesses- in which the elec€rical Sie

energy was used and not -the ‘kinds of motors or:

lights or any specific operation or device for

which .the energy vas used. Andehe also indi-

cated to the Senate that’ what was meant by

“commercial” business was the reciproéal of _

“industry, 43 since he referred to the Senate’s

- proposed one per cent.tax- upon energy “for pur-

poses other’ than dompstic or commercial’ as an -

industrial energy .tax. 77 Cong. Record, supra,

Part 3, pp. 3212-3214, 82 15. ‘He stated in part

(pp. 3212-3213) : ?

FD am telling: Senators nothing new

when- I remind them that we Shad a fight

here in 1932 over the imposition of this

‘tax. The Senate imposed a3 percent —

electric-energy tax,.cand it) was . finally

: P 7 a ws "

% i

% “5

|

*

*.

¥ 20

adopted, to be collected. from the consumer.

of electric energy: We applied that only

-on domestic and commer¢éial energy; that

is; eleetric energy used in stores and dwell- -

ings that are classified as commercial and —

domestic. -There was no tax in the 1932

act ‘imposed upon: energy employed m

industry.

* * °.. & *

‘The valet ties co oirind to

the full committee and we discussed it several

days ‘and finally have adopted and recom- |

- amended to the Senate a provisiot? fora tax‘of

> 2 percent on commerei ial and. domestic

. ener gy, to be collected at the souree’ from

the power companies, reducing the House

proposal ‘in that respect from 3 pereent

to -2 percent. Then We. have reepm-_

mended an industrial electric “energy, tax of

1 percent to-be collected from the consumer,

_ Senator Couzens of Michigan, who together

with Senators Barkley. of Kentucky. and Reed of —

Pennsy vania, constituted a subcommittee of the

Senate Finance: Cornmittee to consider the electri-

eal energy tax (17 Cong. Record, — 3, p. 3220),

explained (p. 3318) : ae

I stated that when the Senate_originally

adopted the electrical energy tax in 1932 it

did not include energy used for manufae-

turing, for the reason, as I thought at the —

time, that such a.tax would: ereate an unfair.

acompetitive condition. However, I find I.

was in. Serer that as the Senate adopted

eo ae @

» the’ amendment ‘it included all electric

energy, whether used for Hianufacturing or

for COMMETECL: nh or domestic > pUrpeses, The ~

\ - conferees, anid I think properly so, elimi-

nated the ti ix-on electric al energy y consumed

in manuf acturing. 7 eae

* . ee Je * en ¥

T men, they eliminated that fe ature of

° thestax ; they climiniated the tax on electri i-

eal energy sold to manufacturing pli mts and

left the 4 tax on electricity sed commer-

cially, -that is by stores anckioh bescaaneias

‘used for ee ee es Mhige

*

Senator Barkley made simifitr ee (tions (77

Cong. Record, Part 3, pp.3217, 3222 |

— T presume, regardless af Phether the =

percent, taxis paid on electrical energy

ased.for commercial and domestic purposes, -

~ or whether it is divided, 2 percent on elee-

tricity. used “for those purposes and 1

percent on electricity. used by: industry,

what the Senatér is trving to drive at is

‘to limit the tax to energy produeed by

privately owned’ companies ? 3

“* *- %¥ | °% _ *

Mr. President, as far, as the straight .

3-pereent gross tax upon. the distribution

of industrial “power affecting industry is

concerned, under the amendment offered by

‘the Senator from Nebraska, if there was

any virtue in the argument made «a vear-

ago that this tax ought not to be levied

on industry bee: ‘atise it would make it more

a1sno2— 48~— ‘4

a ce

‘ m . . a

jw

re)

ae 22

difficult. for industry: to carry on during

the depression, and employ the men it was

able to employ, it would be even more true -

with a 3-percent gross tax upon electrical -

energy... .The comnittee felt that a 1-per-

cent tax upon the distribution of industria]

électric power was sufficient *-* *.

‘ fenhine Connally of Texas, still another mem-

ber of the Finance Committee, in discussing ‘an

amendment of his own to tax those-manufacturers

who made their own energy, also made clear. to

the Senate that whether a sale of enetgy was for’

commercial consumption: depended upon whe ther

or not the energy ‘could be considered as-used by.

‘industi-y and not upon the particular operations, |

in the Spent at colloquy se8 Cong. Record, Part

3, p. 8242): 3 | |

Mr. -Mercaur.. Mi. President, thete are

a good many charitable institutions and—

educational institutions whith make their

own electricity. Does. the Senator think

it is. fair to impose the tax on them?

Mr. Connauis® Such a use .of enérgy

‘would not be industrial, would .it ?

Mr. Metcatk. Are they exempt?

-Mr. CONNALLY. Does the Senator refer

to industrial power? ORES als

\ Mr. Metcarr. No; I mean | light and_

‘power used in hospitals. ° -

/ Mr. Connatry. That is. not industrial

power. This applies only to industrial .

power. That to which the Senator refers

is comme reial and domestic.

ee ee eS ee eee

. -

pi ‘

23 | eer

ea es

.

Since no attempt was made.in the House to

.* revisé the-provisions of the earlier law to broaden _

the scope | of the tax, little further iHumination—

may be found. in its debates. But the statement

of the managers on the part of the House with

respect fo a conference report inte rpreted the.

phrase ‘domestic or commercial ‘vonsumption in

the same manner as did Senator Harrison. ‘on-

_cerning the Senate’s one, per cent tax on sales of

electrical energy ‘for purposes other than domes-

tic of commereial,”* it stated that the Conference

. Report ‘omits the prov ision of the Senaty amend-

ment imposing 2 a tax on the consumer of indus--

trial energy." 77 Cong. Record, Part 5, p. 4762.

And in the Sata of a Tater conference re-

port, Representative } Samuel 13. Hil] of Washing-

ton, a confe ree, : explained that: the S Senate bill had

reduced the tax in the Hause bill from three to

two per cent upon electrical’ Onerey ‘for dome Ste

or commercial use” and levied a one per cent tax

om “energy to be used in \adustry”* to be paid by

the consumer. 77 Cong. Recdrd, Part.6, peOse2.

That Congress was considering types ot busi-. -

“nesses” rather than particular operations per-

formed as incidents of a single business must also

he apparent from the fact. that the Senate bill

proposed to tax commercial consumption to the

vendor at two per cont. anil industrial Consump--

tion to-the eousumer at one per cent. The Senate

could hardly have intended to require the electric

companies to install w separate electric meter for

24

each operation of a’ consumer's business or to |

involve the Treasury in the stupendous job of

analyzing every business in the country to ascer-*

tain what percentage of. its. @usumption of elec-

trical energy related to its’ productions and what. .

percentage to its commercial operations.

The legislative historv of the statute thus iad

to the conclusion that in. taxing sales of energy

for comnfercial consumption Congress intended. to”

obtain revenue from sales of energy to homes and

businesses ; but at the same time it intended: to

exempt fromcthe tax sales of energy merely to

those businesses of business activities which are

ordinarily ‘eonsidéred. to be manufacturing or

heavy industry, including public litilities and min-

ing, of the kind in which electrical energy is

commonly understood to be used in very substan-

tial quantity asa source of power and in which

differences in the. cost of energy, even as small ;

as the three per cent tax, would be. likely to have

an-important | competitive effect upon the cost of

opel ration of the entire business.

aD |

THE LONG EXISTING TREASURY REGUL ATIONS AND THE

1 RU 'LINGS OF THE BUREAU OF. INTERNAL, REVENUE

ISSUED SU BSTANTI ALLY ¢ ‘ONTEMPOR ANEOUSL Y with

THE ENACTMENT OF THE STATI ‘TE SUPPORT THE

CONSTRUCTION MADE BY THE COURTS BELOW

The Tr asury *s contemporaneous undérstanding

of the electrical «¢ energy tax at . the time, of its

25 +.

original Shactment 4 gave a broad: meaning to the

term ‘commercial.’ ‘Eleven days after the en-

actment of the cues Act: of 1932,.¢. 209, 47°

Stat. 169, the Secretary of the Treasury approvetl

> Treasury Regulations *-taking the position that

“commercial” Was not intende d-to refer to any

narrow conception of selling and trading activity

_but to businesses generally, except for the special

“er ‘oup which Congress had in its consideration of

. the law lumped together as “industry.” _ The

Treasury considered that the taxable businesses

could more readily be defined by listing typical

examples of the narrower and mare. homogeneous

group which were excluded thar by enumerating

the more numerous and varied types which were

included. Thus, Article 40 of Treasury Regula-

tions 42, as originally promulgated, /Appendix,

infra, separated the untaxable ” from. the taxable

as follows: ee fo eae Bath ee

- ** Electrical energy for domestic or eom-

mercial consumption”’ includes ali electri-

cal energy furnished the consumer except

—.—-eleetrical-energy” furnished for industrial -

consumption. Electrical energy. for indus-

trial consumption includes that used gen-

erally for industrial purposes, that is, in

manufacturing, processing, mining, refin-

ing, irrigation, shipbuilding, building con-

struction, ete.. and by public utilities, -

See

‘. ‘The Revenue : Act of 19: y Was enac tied June 6, 1932. The

first edition of Treasury Regulations 42 containing a chapter

on the electrical energy tax was approved June 17, 1932.

Y waterworks, telephone, telegraph, and radio

companies, - railroads, and other common

carriers. | arias

An: amendment to the * Regulations” a month -

later (T. 1D). 4542, ‘X1-2 Cum.. Bull.. 495 (1932),

Appendix, infra) was apparently made with the

thought that. the, public utilities should be ex- |

_. eluded‘as a separate group rather than as indus-

trial businesses. And charitable institutions were

also excepted on the. theory that they could not.

‘fall within the concept of commercial businesses:

©

But except as these specific exceptions appeared

the Tre: isury Regulations ‘continued to provide

that all electrical energy furnished the consumer:

was taxable.t Article 40 of Regulations 42 there-

after remained substantially unchanged until in

1941 by T. D. 5099, 1941-2 Cam-Bull. 267, 286,

the. provisions: relating to ‘the electrical energy :

*As amended by T. D438 fz, Article 10 of ‘Treasury Regu-—

lations 42° (Appendix, infra) read in part as fallows:

All electrical energy furnished the consumer is tav-.

able except (1) electrical energy. furnished for indus

trial consumption, e. g.. that used in manufacturing.

processing, mining, refining. shipbuilding, building con

struction, ete.. and (2) that furnished fer -other ses

which likewise can ‘not..be classed as dlomesti¢ or cone:

mereial, such as used by public utilities, waterworks,

irrigation companies, telegraph. telephone, and radio

communication companies, ratlroads, other common car

riers, educational Ghstitufions not operated for private

profit. churches, and charitable institutions, Howeve:,

“electrical energy is subject to tax if consgimed jn the

commercial phases of industrial or other businesses, sifeh

as in office buildings, sales and display rooms, retail:

stores, ete. : ae

; /

- ; ; /

27 ar “3

tax were transferred. to Regulations 46. whens: in

substance’ the same provisions ‘may now be found

ut Section 316.190 (Appendix, infra). During:

this entire period, although revisions. and re-

enactments of the revenue laws have been. made,

including several affecting the electrical energy

tax,” in. no instance has the Treasury’s broad

construction of : commercial consumption ‘been

disapproved, and-it must therefore -be regarded

as having been approved by Congress. Helv ering.

mF Winnall, 305 U.S. 79, e Fondren v. Commis-

stonex,-324 U.S. 18, 29-3( a aay

‘As the statute was a new one and the Regula.

tions were- necessarily im general terms, the —

: Bureau of Internal pile pesrgetigaen Sea

— ___te-makenumerotis rulings en individual busi-

lesses shortly, after. the tax - beéame effective. -°

The contemporancous rulings of the Bureau in :

1932 and (1933 ‘on spec ifié eases Which’ we re pub-—

lished also support ‘the -broad construction of:

‘commercial’ whic ‘h we believe to be correct and

—areeontrary to the vie view urged” by. the taxpayer :

(Be... ZH, ‘2 cand the amicus curiae (Br. 13,

20-21) that. “commercial” smust be confined té

“At the same time “processing” was’eliminated from the

list of“consuming business excluded from. tax as industrial

Tonsumpt i ion. = The Government does not believe this Was a

subst antial change. This deletion is discussed di fra. |

: ; * Act of June 16, 1983, ¢ Mi, 4s Mat. 24. Sec, 6: Revenue.

| Act of 13S ce. USO, SY Stat. AIT Sec. 713: Internal Revenue |

( —_ Sec. 3411: Revenue Net of Ide, $12. Oo Stat, 687, ’

Dv’) (ay: Revenue Act of 1943. ¢. 63. “oS Stat. Jl. Sec.

ea . lan in Ss ° ‘ .

.

O

selling. and trading activities, Thus, the Bureau

" ruled in 1932 that these was me duded in commer.

eial consumption; -energy used in the outdoor ad-

. 496); energy & msumed by motion pleture thies iters -

used j Scaled operated for profit. OS. Ts 562,

by S.'T.641, NTI-1 Cam. sill. 410 (1933) ) ; energy.

elev: ators’ | refrigeration, electrie true ks, blowe PS, ®

furnished toa corporation engaged inv the oper

aA!

28°

vertisiny business, (S. Ty 464, NT-2 Cum. “Bud.

(S. .. £66, Ni-2 Cum. Bull. 497); energy fur-

lished grain eles ators predominantly engaged in

purchasing, storage and resale: of i rain for pro- .

ducers (S. T. , N\I-2 Cun. Bull. 499); energy

XI-2 Ao. Bull. 501): energy consumed by radio

broadeasting stations operat ted for commiereial or

entertainment purposeet S."P.o76, N I-2 Gam. Bull:

502) : ene rey furntstied to close = eure ial pla mits

ws 7 590, X<I-2-Ciwn. Ball. 503, modified in part

furnished cole storage warehouses for use hr the

of refrigeration Yor storage purposes

PF. G15, X1-2 Cum. Bull. 504). ° The Bureaus

oe in 1933, among other, things, that electrical

XN

energy furnished toa ware house operated mn con-

nection with Chain stores, for use im receiving, re-

packing ail distributing goods, ape rating freight

COnVEVars, eters on hake ‘ry machinery, air condi-

tloners, pumips and lighting was commercial _

scope _becgyise it Was ine ‘idental to a business

whose predominant character was _commeretal ”

(‘s. T. G32, NTT ‘ Cum. Bull. 4s “that energy

atian and maintenance of a cemetery for use in

{:

lighting a garage was taxable because the: ceme- |

tery was a commercial venture (S. T..674, XTI-1

Cum. Bull. 412); that energy furnished in the:

_ operations of. fasming, incliiding that“ used for

ensilage cutters, cream separators, oat erushers, :

threshing machines, water pumps and miscellane-

ous machinery was t taxable as either domestic or «|

commercial in'scope (S. T. 637, XI-1 C1 Cum, Bal a

409; S. T. 695, XTI-2 Cum. Bul: ees

. In 1933 the Bureau ruled spe¢ifically with ref-—

— erence to dairies (S.T. 637, XII-1 Cum: Bull.

409, 410) (Appendix, in fray: ;

» .° A dairy which obtains milk‘and converts |

it into use for retail purposes is held.to be .

engaged in a bu@iness commercial in char- |

acter.. Electrical energy used. in such

operations will be subject to tax. coe

Electrical energy furnished to dairies

which are engaged in the manufacture. and

sale of, butter, cheése, and similar gairy

a _ products is not subject to the tax imposed

o. by section 616 of the Revenue Act-of 1932." |

* * In 19382 the Sevens insued a ruling that “E lectrigg] energy

furnished for consumption Ay bottling works, milk com-

panies, or creameries engaged in the. pasteurization and

bottling of milk. and in the manufacture of butter, butter-

ilk, chocolate milk, and Cottajge cheese, is not furnished for |

domestic or commercial consumption”.” S. -T. 518, XI-2

Cum. Bulb. 498 (1932) (Appendix,infra). Apparently real- —

izing, however, that this broad ruling, applicable to dairies”

and creameries engaged in a variety of activities. might not’

"be adequate to meet the needs of Collectors rho had to de-

oes on the taxability of sales of may ‘to’consumers s solely

eae

i

Both the contemporaneous Regulations and the

rulings cited thus show that the Treasury Depart-

ment understood ‘commercial. consumption’? in

the.same sense as may_be inferred from the legis- _

—s history, of the law. ‘‘Commercial consump- ¢

ist jot merely thafyenergy used in buying»

a selling ; it includes as-well the energy. used

in all the normal and customary incidents of

businesses not predominantly in industry in the.

sense to which we have previously adverted. @

This contemporaneous construction by the ex-

ecutive department charged with the administra-

tion of the law and ' the: general acquiescence in

such construction by the large utility corporations

_ directly affected by its. application *.ought to be

or predominantly fluid milk dealers or distributors and not

cheese or butter manufacturers, oe after the first ruling,

the bureau modified it by issuing S. T. 637,-above. See

- Bureau’s — explanation (Appendix, infra,

pp. 67-68.)

Although S. T. 637 fias been followed to date by the Bureau |

of Internal Revenue (R. 115), it is significant that for nine

- years, until action was filed against the United States in the —

District Court for Colorado by the Public Service C ‘company

of Colorade in 1942 (Public Service Co. of Colorado v.

’ United States (Colo.), decided nage 6, 1943 (32 A. FLT. R.

1720), affirmed, 145 F. 2d 79 (C., Oth)), none of the.

many electric utility companies of Free A nited States affected

by the ruling brought suit to contest if, and the taxpayer here

(id not file a.claim for refund until: May 1944. -(R. 2, 8,)-

*U ntil Public Service Co. of Colorado vy. United States,

supra, was decided in July 1943, only two other cases had been

‘ brought to contest: the Bureau's construction or application

of the electrical energy tax with respect to. “commercial con-

sumption.” These were St, Louis Pi frigerating & Cold 8.

Co. v. United States, 43 F. Supp. 476 (CU. rad and Fulton -

ag °

Ble a 2G

given great weight in determining its meaning,

even indepet dently of the reenactment rule. -

White vy. Winchester Club, 315 U. S. 32, 41;

Better Business Burtau v. Uniteti States, 326

U.S. 279, 286 Brewetér v. Gage, 280 U. S. ~

Both the taxpay er (Br. 37-40) and the’ amicus

curiae (Br. 14, 15-16, 19) urge, -however, that

a portion of the Regulations lends support. to

the ‘notion that though a business is predomi-

nantly commercial, an operation or activity, ever

if it is merely a_nor mal integyal incident. of the

commercial business, may be /industr lal (or ‘‘in -

industry”’) if the operation or activity, viewed

‘in isolation from the rest of the business, is. not

carried on as a commercial” activity. And. this

vjew was apparently likewise shared by the Court

ys sea for the Tenth Circuit when it stated

in United States v. Public Service Co. of Colo-

rado, 143 F. 2d 79, 82,. that. the electrical energy

used in pasteurizing ‘‘was not used in’ the: ecom-

mercial Phase of the dairying enterprise, but in

Market Cold Storage Cav. U nited States, 43 F. Supp. 485

(C. Cls.), both dee ided March 2, 1942.

During, the hearings held on the 1933 eRe ieee which

tuade the electric companies pay the tax, representative of -

7 percent ofdhe companies testified that they had given a

broader construction to the term “e ommercial” than even the -

Treasury had, and that the Treasury had ex@luded miahy large

commercial consumers and kad claned them as industrial.

(Hearings before the Senate Finance Committee on H. R.:

HO, Amendment to Revenue Act of 1982) T3rd C Ong. Ist

Sess.. May 2-and 3, 1933, pp. 3, 30.)

a =

a

be as amended in July 1932 by T, D. 4342. NR: Grae

a

the processing or: ‘industrial phase of ‘the enter-

prise.”’ | 7 Ee

ina ncbtcan of the "Regulations relied on by .

‘both the taxpayer and the’ amicus are the fol!

lowing (Treasury Regulations 46, Bee: 316. 190, |

Appendix, infra) : ; ee

82°

However, eléctrical energy is subject to”: *

tax if sold for consumption in the com-

mercial phases of industrial or other busi- . ~

nesses, such as in office buildings, sales and.

. display rooms, retail stores, ig re

_o Where electrical energy is sold to a con- .

* sumer for gwo or more purposes, through |

separate meters, the specific use for which:

the, energy -is ‘sold through each meter,

i. @., whether, for domestic or, commercial :

consumption, or for -other use, shall de-

termine its .taxable “status. -Where the-

consumer has all the electrical energy con- |

‘sumed at a given ‘location furnished

through one. meter, the predominant, char-

acter of the business. carried on at such:

- location shall determine the classification

of. consumption for the purposss of this

tax. - - \

- These portions - a ‘the Regulations fibst ‘ap- a

peared. Articlé 40 of Treasury Regulations 42,

RN

We submit, however, that, these additions to — |

the Regulations were not-intended to change the

meaning of ‘commercial consumption”’ so. as to. *

permit classification of particular uses, opera-

\¢

\

tions and activities as industrial” without. re-

gard to their relationship to the nature of the

business as a whole.’ Electr ical energy, is _ordi-

.. narily: used for @ight, power’ or heat. As such”

it may light a rodm or building or it may op-

erate a motor tha® lifts an elevator or com-

presses a refrigerant or, turns a fan or pump.”

But if fhe use is commercial it isnot because

of ‘what the energy. does but because the opera-

tion or activity in which it is used is an incident

to a commercial business. ° If the criterion of a.

«sale of o— for commercial consumption were

whether the’ specific . use of the energy is com-

! mercial apart. from the nature of the business

in which it is an incident, the law would be re-

duced . to an absurdity since no use of energy

would fall within the taxable status.

The portion of the Regulations relied on =

‘the taxpayer and amicus curiae has a far more

‘ reasonable purpose than is suggested by their

arguments. When Congress considered the broad

concepts. of commerce and industry for purposes

-_ of the tax, it apparently did not take into account

the fact that some enterprises engage in more than

one kind of business, and the law made no express

ce provision for this contingency. : The. ‘Treasury

was also. faced with -the-classifieation for pur-

poses of the tax of sales organizations: and

branches of large industrial corporations having

separate buildings and store’, which could hardly

FP is

“a2.h “xz

Nie

come: within the, reason for the statutory exemp- .

— tion of industrial consumption. Since the statute

providet-no express answer to these problems, the

Treasury adopted what it considered was the most

practical and reasonable construction of thé law.

~ It “Qmnended its Regulations to provide that where

there were separate meters measuring the differ-

ent types of ‘consumption, the tax would attach —

only to the énergy sold for commercial consump-

tion, Where there was a single meter, the pre-

dominant nature of the busitiess atthe location

would control.. If the non-industrial portion of

- an industrial business. constituted a separate -.

_ phase of the business, and if it had a separate

' office building; sales and display. rooms, retail

stores, ete., so that the energy used in these sepa-

rate suborganizations could. be separately meas- -

ured, the tax would attach” ‘there too. It is diffi-

cult to see how another construction of the statute

could have been, made which would hare been _

more consistent with the legislative purpose or

Imore reasonable and fair in its appligation. ~ And

we submit’ that the asserted inconsistency between

the Regulations and the decision. of the courts

below is more fancied than real. z .

The language of this Court in Bowles v. Semi*

nole Rock Co., 325 U. 5S. 410, 413-414, is espec ially

pertinent here: o ee

Since this involves an interpretation of ©

- an administrative regulation a court must”

ee

necessarily look ta, the administrative con-

struction’ of the regulation if the meaning

©: °. . of the words used is in doubt, The inten-%

_. tion of Congress or the principles of the

a Coristitution in some -situations’ may be

ss relevant’ in the’ first instance in choosing

‘between various constructions. ‘But the. —

ultimate criterion is the administrative in-

terpretation, which’ becomes of controlling -

weight unléss it is plainly erroneous or:

inconsistent with the regulation.

: A, See ea

THE DAIRIES TO WHICH THE TAXPAYER SOLD THE” ELEC-.

TRICITY ARE MILK: DEALERS OR DISTRIBUTORS .AND

|THE ELECTRICAL ENERGY FURNISHED THEM "WAS FOR »

_-COMMERCIAL ‘CONSUMPTION

: There is no controversy in this case with respect.

to sales of energy to creameries or dairies engaged

predominantly in the business of making and

selling butter, cheese, ice cream and similar prod-_

ucts. In cases wherewit has beeit shown’ that such

is the- predominant business of a customer, the

Government does.not attenipt to assess or colleet

a tax on sales of energy to. it. _(S. 'T. 637, Appen- -

dix, infra; R. 113-115.) But’ with the exception -

of sales to the Pabst Farms, upon W hich taxpayer

apparently inadvertently paid the tax, the energy

‘at issue here was sold to customers whose business

‘the trial court found to"be predominantly that of

a milk dealers and distributors. éR. 31, 142-

* 143,147.) bf on ak t

a,

i

: ri

The milk ‘dealers ° involved take orders from

customers living: in definite territories or routes

in the City of Milwaukee and adjoining communi-

ties for the daily -and sometimes even more fre-

quent delivery of fresh milk. Most of.the orders

are receiv ed from. homes, but in some instances

they are also obtained from restaurants, hotels

and stores. The dealers in turn obtain the milk

in bulk from country producers scattered at vari-.

s ous places in Wisconsin, outside of Milwaukee,

with whom they, make contracts for the deliverg

of fresh milk at daily or other regular intervals | 7

— to their establishments in Milwaukee and the. ad-

_joining communities.” Mu In some instances the pro-°

“ducers bring: the milkt-*to “Milwaukee; ‘in others

the dealers use their ‘own trucks and drivers.

(R. 8, 9,:143.) Eee gs

That the maintenance and | operation. of an

effective daily distribution service: between pro-

ducer and consumer for a food product readily .

subject to spoilage is a -commercial business, the -

) District Court held to be clear./ (R. 137.) The

only questfon. which remains is: Does the fact that

* Pabst Farms will be excluded from this category in the.

discussion, infra, as it may ‘not properly be described as a

“milk dealer.

* At the‘time of trial, however, wartime restrictions caused

the ftroduction of alternate day deliveries. (R. 143. 3

' The bulk. of the milk is broughgein from over an area

extending thirty to thirty-five miles outside of Milwaukee

“ though some as far as fifty miles. (R. 87.)

7

‘. 5

3

the dealers pasteurize the milk make. their busi-

nesses predominantly industrial 2

The District Court held that the fact that the

twenty-seven dairies employ pasteurization to

purify their milk does not cause the predominant ‘

character. of their businesses to-be other than that

_of fluid milk’ dealers «and distributors; that the

‘electricity sold to the m by the*taxpayer Was sold.

and used iti commercial businesses; and that. it

Was sold for commercial consumption. We sub-

init that in so holding the District Court t applied

the most reasonable tests whie h could be, used

‘consistently with the ste tute and Regulations, and

that its’ conclusions are the only ones which it -

could properly have reac ‘hed from the evidence, —

Paste uurization, as practiced in mode rn dairies,

consist$ of an efficient method af heating milk

short of boiling to destroy a maximum quantity

of batteria, if they happen to ‘he present, without

inducing the changes in flaver ordinarily caused’

by boiling. (R. 9, 66, 77-78, 144-145.) The milk

is then cooled sufficiently soon: thereafter to avoid

the possible further breeding or multiplication of - |

(bacteria. CR. 64, 75, 144.)" The main purpose.

Min Baborgk, The. Pasteurization of Milk, Us. Depart-

ment of Agriculture Leaflet No. Tt (1939) 2. the pasteuriza-

- tégn of milk isdefined as follows: | . ee

“The pasteurization “of iiilk for direct consumption, as

applied under commercial conditions, means a process of heat-

ing: every partic de of milk toa temperature not lower than

142° F. for not less than 30 minutes (holder process) or to a

temperature not lower than 160° F. and holding.at that tem-

perature or above for nut less than 15 seconds, - (Short. time,

¢

of this treatment is as a. precaution against the

possibijity that harmful germs may have secumu:

lated he milk, principally from contact with.

disease or dirty handling in the course of distribu-

tion, but also from diseases in cows which may

have escaped discovery ; and another purpose is to

gretard spoilage in the hands of the dealer, by the

destruction | of bacteria which ‘miy be present.

(R. 71, 77-18, 79-80.)

The District Court found frony the undisputed

evidence that the distribution of milk has existed.

ee

in the United States/as a distinct form of busi- |

1s

ness for nearly a century.

milk on a substantial. scale Was not established

inl this. country _until 1897. It came into use. in

Milwaukee in ‘190% and became common practice

there onlycas. recently as 1915. °(Finding 9, R.

143-144 ; It. 81-82. i In cities having over a thou-

h émperature process.) After the milk is pasteurized,

itisi mediately cooled tq:50° F. or lower.”

1 Kelly arid Clement, a seta Milk (2d ed., -1931) 2, it

is stated that shipments of milk in bulk by rail to dealers in

Boston were being made in E838 and in Nv York in 1S#?.

In Roadhouse and Henderson. The Market-Milk: In dustry

Pasteurization of —

(1941) 4, it is‘ pointed out that dealers maintained ret: ail milk

routes in large cities before 1840,

- ™ Tn Kelly and Clement, supra, 327, the statement appears

that it was not until 1904 that any appreciable amount of the

general milk supply was pasteur ized. Roadhouse and Hen-

devson, supra, 5, report that prior to 1900 nearly all the milk

soldi in the United States was not pasteur ized and by 1909 only

5 per cent of New York ¢ City’s milk was paste urized. Anid,

c ie also Soriumer: Market Milk and Related Products (2d ed.,

1946) 106, | * [seus a ee

- %

°

.

rt

WS

ee oe 39

sand pupulation in the United States a majority

_of the milk dairies ‘still distyibute unpasteurized

mk. and more than twenty- -five per cent of all-

milk sold in cities ‘of this size is not pasteurized.”

(Finding 9, R. 143-144; R. 75-76, 119-122, 129-130,

133.) In nearly one-third of the municipalities

none of the milk dealers pasteurize the milk they,

distribute. (R. 132.) . On the other: hand, as

the District Court also found, two expert. wit-

nesses in the field of: dairy opetation and eco-

homies, who were present at “trial, ‘testified that

they had (never heard of a dairy plant which

3 pasteurized and bottled its milk which ‘was: not.

a distributor. (Finding 9, R. 144;.R. 82, 87.) .

The trial court stated that while pasteurization

is an important part of the business of ® the

-_twenty- seven «dairies, ‘they likewise utilize svs-

tems of rapid regular distribution of fresh milk

‘to their-e ustome) rs, and maintain fleets of trucks,

" horse- -drawn wagons, and drivers, caraced> load-

“ing and unloading facilities, weighing and testing

devices, storage and refrigeration reoms, and

machinery for putting milk into bottles af high

speed. (Finding 1 D, R. 146; R. 8-10.) - / .

Lhe court found from the evidence that the

cost of pasteurization accounts for only an. in-

significant part of the costs of operation of the

* The weighted mean for all cities of at least a thousand

pop lation shows that there are 0.8 milk distributors per

thousand . ition Who do not pasteurize against only O17

“whodo. (R. 10-121.) /

Po ad

dairies. Of the quart of milk which, at the time

of trial the Milwaukee milk dealers sold and

de liver ed for sixteen cents, the’ mk itself cost

9.6 cents, the distr ibution im bottles -about Tour,

cents and the'entire plant operations about one

_ cent.” Only, one-tenth of a cent of the cost of

plant operations was attributable to. pasteuriza-

tien. (Finding 15, R. 1465 R. 11, 87-89, 93..)

16 “ee ‘uded in the four POT Was mS the cost of delivering

Whatever other products the milk man delivered.

? Published studies of plant costs iY other areas show

comparable resu Its. Kelly and. ‘Tement. SUPT, $16, report.

that 2 stn “of the ‘Borden Milk: amnees in New York

showed 10 percent, of ue consumer's milk dollar-went for the

operation of the city milk plant. Roadhouse and Hender-

son, supra, stmmarize a study of twelve milk plants in a

large California city, made-in 1938,.which show total plant |

processing and handling costs of .99 cent to 1.64 cents per

quart of milk selling at 12 cents. The Miissachusetts Milk

Control Board, Summary Report cn Cost of Distributing

‘Milk in the Boston Market (1936) 14. 24. ascert: ained that

all operations from the time the milk arvived tn the eity unter

it was stored in bottles, including an allocable portion of the

administrative expenses, totalled .85 cent per quart, while

retail delivery of the bottled milk cost 4.25 cents. The Re-

port of the New York State Commissioner of: Agriculture

and Markets Regarding the Audit of Milk Dealers: Legisla-_

tive Document No, 100 (1938) 7, reports city processing costs

for milk and dairy products of .471 cent per quart of milk

handled. See also Sommer, supra: 606; Tinley, Public .

Regutition of Milk Marketing i in California (1988) 125-126;

. Federal Trade Commission, Report on the Distribution and

Sule of Milk and Milk Products, Boston, Baltimore, Cinein

nati and St. Louis, House Doc. No. 501, 74th Cong. 2d

Sess., 146. :

'S Only a few published studies of the cost of pasteurization

alone have been found. Such a breakdown apparently has

aes al

The: court also found that. pasteurization

utilizes only a small fraction of the total per-

sonnel of the’ dairies.” (Finding 15. R, 146;

R. 95.) | : ire ig

_ttl® practical value. Those studies which have been pub-

lished. although in different areas and for different periods

do not vary substantially from the evidence in the record,

Kelly and Clement. supra, 337, state that the average cogt of

pasteurizing a gallon of milk in.1922 was 49 cent (or 120.

cent per quart). including depreciation, vepairs, interest,

labor, coal, water and refrigeration. In Bowen, The Cost of

Pasteurizing Milk and Cream, U.S. Departiuent of Agricul-*

ture Bulletin No. 85 (1914) a detailed analysis of live city

milk plants shows an-average pasteurizitig cost of 3 cent per

gallow.(.078 cent per quart) including allocations of tangible

me intangible plant costs. In Dow, An Evononiic Study of

ilk Dis tribution in.Maine. The’Maine Agricultu#al Ex-

periment St: ition Bulletin No. 395 (1959) there were vom-

pared the plant costs of seventeen raw milk distributors with

iwenty-éight: larger distributors of pasteurized miik ‘and it

was found that there was only a 3 eent difference in plant

costs forhandling the milk, and part of this difference could

liave been due to es use as well of other than pasteurizing

equipment by the twenty-eight. See also King, The Price of

Milk (1920) 189, 209. and Mortensen, Management of Dairy

Plants (1938). 108 | 7 —

“The number of employees engaged in entire plant opera-—

tions at the milk dealers’ plants is getierally considerably

smaller than these engaged in actual distribution and sales.

See Exhibits'D throngh N of the stipyjation (omitting only

J.Pabst Faris). (R. 15-44.) 2

Kelly and Clement, supra, 3S, state that ini a study of 112

plants made by them in, 1929 they found that in small plants

ordinarily only one mati, was required to operate and clean

_the pasteurizing equipment, while in large plants 1,800 quarts

of ilk were pasteurized peranan- hour of labor _ittributable

to pasteurization, oe

oe a ee .

And, moreover, it found the evidence to show

that pasteurizing causes only, a minor part of the

capital investments. The: investment ‘of the

dairies in pasteurizing equipment, including in-

creased cooling equipment is from 15 to 20 per

. cent of the total cost of their plant equipment,

but this percentage figure would be conside1 ‘ably .

smaller if the investment in such items used in

pick up and distribution as trucks - and: other .*

vehicles, horses, bottles, cases, ete. were taken as

into consideration. ° (Finding 15, R. 146; R. 64,

13-74.) ag |

Still further to emphasize that the milk dealers

sare predominantly in a distributing business: is.

the evidence that seven of the ten whose. business

is described in detail in the stipulation-of the

parties ” engage in the practice of buying, selling

» The: taxpayer argies (Bre 4 F od see. 7, 8, 41) that. °°

pasteurization “is the central activity around which turn the

other activities ofthe pursuit.”) But we are unable to find

support in the record for this statement. 3

*) Luick Dairv Co. sells orange drink which it prepares by’

nixing water with a concentrate it biavs from amanufacturer,

(R. 17.) Layton Park Dairy engages in the same practice.

(R.-26.) Leo Galles purchases ice cream. mix from’manu-

facturers and freezes. flavors and sells it. *(R. 29.) Rolland |

J. Ruby buys orange drink concentrate, butter, eggs, cottage

cheese and buttermilk for résale purposes. (R. 35.) - The.

' Borden Co. buys orange drink concentrate. butter and eggs

for resale purposes. (R. 37.) 0 The South Side Datsy pur-

chases orange and grape drink concentrates, dutter, cottage ,

cheese and butternalk for resale purposes. CR. 41.) The

poeora Dairy purchases orange dritik and b: utter for resile.

(RR 43.)

s

eee a

and making regular deliveries along their routes

of other -fresh perishable foods m addition to,

milk, such. as eges, buttey, fruit juices “and fruit

drinks. (R. 17, 26, 29, 35, 37, 41, 43.) And this —

is common practice among milk dealers and dis-

tributors: -(R. 89-90.) gs oe

That washing the’ reusable bottles and cans-and

then filling them by high speed- automatic methods

to expedite delivery and avoid spoilage does not -

change the character, of the business needs Tittle

elaboration.“. Commereial vendors generally pack- .

age the ends they sell: for suitable handling and

delivery. Milk bottles are not sold but are ‘to be

returned to the déaler; they are not permanently

sealed but only temporarily capped; they do not

change the form of. the product nor improve its,

- quality; the cleaning is 1/0 more than would be

required of any vendor twice using-a container;

and the: automatic operation: is to expedite the

dealer's delivery and does not differ essentially

from filling any other container-by hand, ,

And as an additional indication that this was .

not the kind of business which Congress intended

to exempt from taxation as being engi wed in

industry is the fact that milk dealers do not

come within the reason for the exemption. As

has already been note ‘d, supra, the Stated r ‘ASON

for not taxing energy sold to industrial consumers:

was that the. nba passing on of the t tax by the’

=f. Williams \. Harrison, 10 ¥. 2d ONY (C. ‘ ith).

44

electric “« “company - would © unfairly discriminate ~

against those industrial. consumers who purchased

electrical ene rgy and who" had ‘te compete with.

manufacturers in the sane business who produced

their own energy. . But despite veats-of stidy im

the dairy field adihecot the expert withesses who

testified in court had ever heard ofa uid. mitk

‘dealer or distributer who. did generate his own

electrical energy, since, unlike the common indus-

trial and manufacturing . enterprises “electrical —

energy is but an insignific ant item in the costs of |

.. inlk dealing. (R. 83, 89, 94-95. )

We submit that from the foregoing the Dis-

triet Court’ properly concluded’ that the milk

dairies are predominantly commercial businesses,

that, the sales of energy to them were for com-

mercial consumption and that the pasteurizing of.

the milk could not change the character of the

_ business’ but was merely an ordinary incident of

AP sete Steno

that kind of business. "Cf. Richmond - v. Diary

C6, 156 Va. 63; Suabedissen-Wittner Darr y. Dept.

of Treas, 105 Ind. App. 626°

Tn support of its -argume nt’ that the energy

be

sold.to the milk dairies, was not for commercial

constimption, the taxpayer relies heavily upon

the beasoning of the Court of Appeals for the

Thy. teurieal ion ba< ‘been held likewise to. be merely am:

-Jncident of. agrieultural activity where practiced at farm

dairies, in cases construing the social security tax daws. — Lar-

‘won. Lees Dairy Co. V4 BF. 24-701 (CLA. oth) United States

Vv. Varars ls Flo2d ob oC. AL Sth). 3 °

_pasteurizing of milk was, industrial consumption.

45

Tenth Cireuit in United States v. Public Serv-

ce Co. of Colorado, 143 F. 2d 79, (Br. 20-24,

342) ° There the -court held, that because : ee

Treasury Regulations, until . 1941, included —

> Hrocesinig ~in~indestrial_consun wwption “* the

It reasoned further that as: all manufacturers

sinid processors are engaged. An part in conmer-

cial activities, it can not’ be said that pasteuriza-

tion is merely an ineident to a commercial busi-

ness, since it ean likewise be:said that the selling,

of the manufactured article-is always: but an in-

cident ‘of any manufacturing business ; and to

follow: what the court thought was the Govern-—

ment’s position would be to tax sales to all busi-

nesses. Also, apart from the Regulations, it held

that the sales of electrical ene rev were nontaxable

because the energy was not used in the com-

mereial phase of the dairying enterprises but in

their processing or industrial phase. Pursuing

‘this line of reasoning, the taxpayer urges that

the evidence in the instant case necessitates the

conclusion that pasteur ization is’ industrial

processing of milk, analogous to manufacturing

Whieh converts a raw product into a ‘finished

one, such as manufacturing, steel from iron ore or

gasoline: from erude oil. (Br. 48-49.)

ei e submit. that the reasoning of the Court

-Appeals for the Tenth Cireuit in the Colo-

“ aT dloes not appear, in Section 316, IW of Treasury Regula- -

tions 46. ( Appendix, dnfra.) |

rado case is in error and should not be followed.

We believe, first, ‘that ‘that court construed ‘thie

statutory term: ‘commercial’ in the narrow

sense of buying and selling activity, which, as

we have argued herein, ts erroneous. It- was thus:

able to conclude. that .beeause pasteurizing milk

is not buying and’ selling it was ‘an industrial

phase of the business. Second, even after “aids

struing the phrase **¢ commercial consumption”! in

‘a narrow sense, it erred further in failing to note

that even in buying and selling businesses the

only taxable consumption of electrical energy

must be in some incident of. the business whit .:

is hot in itself buying or selling. 2 | |

Third, the Court of Appeals. for the Tenth: Cir-

cuit. seiciverepthonien the concept ‘industrial coni-

“sunpption.’” As we have argued, the common

meaning of the ‘phrase, which is the sense in

which it was .used by Congress in considering

the statute, is that kind of consumption which is”

ordinarily engaged in by industry rather than by

or as a Common ineident to a predominantly « mn-

mercial business. Pasteurization of milk, the

mere heating and recoohing of milk immediately

prior to bottling it, although by efficient meehauni-

-eal means ‘ine large dairies, is shown by the find-

ings of the District: Court in the instant case

‘to be merely an incident of the business of those

engaged in the distribution of milk, and, as far

as could be ascertained by the trial court, it ts

het engaged in apart) from: sueh distribution.

ee

(R. 144.) .. Pasteurization is, therefore, merely

Ahh -ineidental -activity: to-a commercial business

and not an activity in industry.

Fourth, we believe the Court of Appeals for

the Tenth: Cireuit erred in claiming that it relied

upon the Regulations when in fact it used only

‘that ceca of the Regulations which included the

a—-eeinsewet

word ‘‘processing’’ asa type- of industrial con-

sumption while it disregarded. that part of the”

Re gulations which provided that where there is

‘uo separate metering the predgminant character

of the business shall control. For even if the use

of electrical energy for pasteurization, isolated

from the other-.aspects of. the| milk dealing busi-

ness, could be considered as a use in industry, we

submit that the facts. with respect: to the fluid

milk business, found by. the trial court in the’ in-

stant ease in answer to every reasonable test of .

predominant character we ean think of, show-ade-

quately and’ persuasively that the milk dealers

are “engaged predominantly in the commercial

business of daily distribution of fresh clean milk

and. . the pasteuri ization of the milk merely

subserves that end. as ,

— Fifth, we submit that the reliance by both the

taxpayer and the Court of Appeals for the Tenth °

( ‘irewit upon the w ord ** processing” iy ‘the Treas-

ury Regulations prior to 1941 is misplaced be-

cause it disregarded the context in which the word

~ appeared.

WA :

Article 40 of Regulations. 42, as amended. by.

T. 1D. .4393 (Appendix, infra); contained the

phrase : 3 oe ete a ae

\

The term “electric¢al energy sold for do:

mestic or éommercial , _consumption™ does

not include (1) electrical energy, sold for

industrial consumption, e. g., for use" in

manufacturing, processing,. mining, refin-

ing, shipbuilding, building - rere Sai

re, eee ee

On? November 28, 1941, by T.‘D. 5099, 1941-2 Cu),

Bull. 267 (Appendix, infra), — “Hrocess: \ |

ing’ * was stricken qut.

That, the particular activity in Which electrical

energy is fed may be character ined under the

broad description “processing” can not be de-

cisive, since many kinds. of commerei ial businesses.

engage in processing, pac kaging or ‘preparing of

the product in which they deal and yet it can not

reasonably be considered that: because: of it. the

nature of their business or their entire consump-

tion of electrical energy becomes industrial. For -

example, a restaurant ‘“‘précesses”’ raw foods and

-eonverts them into finished products fit ‘to’ be’ |

eaten. Yet one could not reasonably considers

industrial the energy used in cooking the’ food

(whether electrie, gas’ or other), and certainly 3

not the entire ene rev tied by the business- since

a fair picture of the consumer’s operations neces-

sarily résults in the eonelusion that it is a aye -

s

i

ee s = “A =

mercial business. ” The saline might also be s ae ce

Pi

fad

> the. Treasury issik

Cum, Bull. 409, 410\¢ 1933), Appendix, fra), in.

40

a tailor using electric sewing machines or a dis-.

tributor of fruit or eggs whoemight use electri-

-eally operated devices. for clei aning or pectin

his products. If all those who engaged in “ proc-_

“- essing’: “in its broadest sense were in industry,

‘there would be. included the soda fountain, the _

. drug store, the photographer, the: optician, the

jew eler who sets diamonds and repairs watches, the

- grocer who grinds up: the coffee before selling it,

and even the. Government departme nt which prac-

"eSSeS forms. letters, ‘and memoranda.

It is obvious that. the Regulations were: tiitnmdad

by the Treasury to be construed under ‘the

ejusdem generis rule: aind the processing referred”

‘to: was that engaged in by industries ‘similar to

“mining, refining, shipbuilding, building construe-

_ tign, irrigation, .ete., or else there w ould haye heen.

“nO need to enumerate them: But even more con-

virieing, proof that the Treasury intended by the

phrase “electrical energy sold for inidustri jal eon-

suniption, e.g. for use-in * *.:* processing .

yale “to include only s sales: to businesses pre-

‘dominantly engaged i in processing of an industrial

nature and that the processing meant--did not

include pasteurization of milk is the fact that

shortly after it promulgated this original language

‘dia ruling (S. 'T. 637, NUI-1

held. that a dairy” whie ‘h

x

which it specific ally

obtains milk’ and convents it into use for retail’

>

as é

o

-~..*,

purposes is engaged in a business commercial in

character. and the electrical energy,atsed in such

operations is subject to tax. And, in the inter-

pretation of an administrativ g regulation **a court

must necessarily look toUthe administrative con-.

struction of the regulation if the meaning of the .

‘words used is in doubt.’’/ Bowles v. Seminole

Rock & Sand Co., 325 U. s. 410, 413-414.

‘The arguinent that Congressional re- -enactment

of the revenue laws af 1934 through 1940 codi-

fied the term ‘“processing”’ into the law and that

_the Treasury could not delete the ferm of course

argues too much, even if the term were given the

‘meaning attributed to it by the taxpayer and the

‘Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit in ‘the

Colorado. case. If Congressional acquiescence

constituted approval of the form of the Regula-

tions prior to 1941,-then under the same rule

similar acquiesence from 1941 through 1948, —

including amendment of the specifie section: in

1943, must have had the same effect with respect.

to the deletion of the word “processing” in 1941.

In Helvering v. Reynolds, 313 U. ‘S. 428, this

Court stated (p. 482):

T hat rule is no more than an aid “fn. "

statutory construction. -While it is ‘useful

at times in resolving statutory ambiguities.

it does not, mean that the prior construction

has become so embedded in the law that

only Congress can effect a change.”

———

. ™See also. Koil an Chicle Co ov. United States. 316 U. =.

450, 454- ADS:

a

— On ‘the other, hanid, if taxpayer ‘s argument

were valid that the use of the word ** processing”

in the 1932-1941 Regulations covers pasteuriza- °

tion of milk and ‘that thé Court: is required to

hold the Regulations determinative, then the eol-

‘lection of the taxes would still be proper for

the period subsequent’ to 1941, sinee this Court

has: held that-the Treasury may properly change

Regulations - prospectively. even if ‘Congress > re-

enacted the statute whilé a different .interpreta-

_tion had been put on it by the Treasury, Helver-

ing ¥. Reynolds, supra; Helvering v. Wilshire

- Oil E0., 308 U. 8. 90; Mor rater y v. Commissioner,

- 296-U. S. 344, 355. : he

What‘ is a far more reasonable inference f rem

, the change in the Regulations is that the Treas- _

ury realized, in the light of actual problems en- |

. countered in the administration of the electrical

energy tax, that ‘‘processing’* was too vague and

ambiguous to be of assistance in interpreting the

statute, and deleted it accordingly. It was be- .

lieved that the test of- what was the predominant ,

_ character of the business and the listed types

@ of business which were excluded from the tax,

Was as definite ns general regulations could rea-

sonably be expec ted to go in dealing with the

~ broad éoficepts laid down by the statute and the

. pest must be left te ease analysis.

The taxpayer (Br. 43-44) and the amicus curiae

ee (Br. 20-21) ‘also argue that the decision of the

Z

tN

a

-

courts below: js. in conflict with that portion of |

the Regulations which provides that the predomi-’- .

nant character of the business ¢arried on at a

_ given location, shall determine the classification of

consumption, since, .taxpayer asserts, the commer-

¢ial activities of the milk dealers are carried on

‘ outside the plant. The argumént assumes that

‘commercial’? must be interpreted in the narrow

sense of buying and selling only. The argument

is also. facilitated by their substituting the word |

e “activ ities” for ‘business’? in the phrase “*pre-.

\dominant character of the business earried on at

stich location” ‘Regulations 46. But even

une ui this narrow a eetaineee the law cer-

tainly it ean not reasonably be Maintained that a

distributing of delivery business is not carried

‘ou at its “Mhain office where the merchandise is’

brought, unloaded, sorted, packaged,/stored, kept

under refrige1 ‘ation, made ready for delivery, and

loaded, where the “de ‘livery equipment is main-

tained, drivers. pick ups their goods and receive

their pay and instructions, where records are

maintamed, money. is. turned: Ta. orders are re-

_, eeived and where all the other functions, ne cessary

7 the operation of any business are cartied on.

Moreover, us we. have submitted; pasteurization

nd béttling hel nig mere ‘ly an incident to the. milk

deiling business, it ean not be considered as con-

‘stumption by industry even fv it were carried on

at locattons separate from the ultimate buying, |

z 53

‘selling, distributing and other characteristic

tivities of a commercial business. | =

. The: taxpayer’s attempt to depict the pasteur-.

izing of milk as a manufacture process which |

converts raw. milk into a finished product is, we -

submit, likewise unreal. We do not dispute the

beneficial results of pasteurization. But the ree-_

ord also shows that pasteurization does not change

: the taste, flavor, form or appearance of milk;

it merely cleans or purifies it, in the only practi-

-eal mauner in which such cl ‘ansing can be done

without changiwe it, against the possibility that

the product may have become contaminated at its:

source or in handling. | However, milk obtained

from a liealthy cow is a wholesome and beneficial

food fit for human consumption with or without

pasteurization. | (R. 78.) Like many fruits and

vegetables ‘that must be cleaned against possible

remaining insect sprays, dirt and mold-producing

spores and bacteria, or like eggs which must be

candied and cleaned .befere being sold, milk 1S

still milk after as well as before it is pasteurized.

e Nothing is added by: pisteurization and it will

hot necessarily be healthier or cleaner oer contain |

fewer hharmful bacteria because of it. (R. 9,

77-78.) Pasteurization. may actually “not. be- as

effective in eliminating possible harmful bacterian

as may boiling hy the ordinary domestie houses

wife. ¢R. 77, 86.). Where milk is obtained from

healthy cows through sanitary methods” and)

54

9

proper prec autions are taken against contamina-

tion in the course of. distribution, as in the case

of certified milk, pasteuriziition is not essential.”

(R. 77-78. )

We submit, therefore, that to describe pasteur-

“ized milk as-in the nature of: a manufactured’

product is a distortion and that both from the

evidence-and from common knowledge a more

accurate characterization is ‘that of. a product

which may be cleaner. or purer, like other foods

distributed in their natural form after they have

been washed or cleaned. Cl. Frat Growers, Tne.

v. -Brogdex Co., 283 U. S. 1; Anheuser-Busch

Assn. v. United ‘States, 207 U. S. 556. And this’

view is supported by. the weight of authority, in

the state courts. ¢ uty of Louisville v. “Ewing

Von-Allmen D. Co., 268 Ky. 652; People ex rel

ELS. Dairy Co. v. Sohmer, 218 N. Y.199; Richmond

v. Dairy Cos 156 Va. 63: Suabedissen-Wittner

Dairy v. Dept. of Preas., 105. Ind. App. 626;

People v. Stevens Co., 178 App. Div. (N. Y.)

306, appeal dismissed, 221 N. Y. 622; Dairy Assn.

v. Bd. of Tar Admin., 302. Mich. 643, 649. But

* Until recently the designation “certified milk” (milk

produced and bottled by dairies operati ig under-strict \stand-

-ards of cleanliness and purity). was not permitted to be used

for milk that was pasteurized. (R. 7S.) See also, Kelly

and Clement, spra, 456 and Sominer, eu prd, 12, |

we

"ef. H. P. Hood -&. Sons v.

Mass. 572, 576." :

Commonwe alth, 239

ae 4 ENG - Von- Aime n, . D. an

7In City of Louisville *

supra, p. 655, the court stated :

-* * *. is appellee engaged in the manufacturing of .

milk? We think not, because the process used means

Nothing more than the removing of all impurities from

raw milk; because all raw milk may contain various kinds

of: impurities: coming from an unclean condition of the

_cow’s udder or. from the person doing the milking or

otherwise of the cow. The old-fashioned way was using

the strainer; in fact, suc + instruments are aised now by

the ordinary housewife. Still,.from a healthy cow,

milked by a careful person and properly strained, the

> milk would need no further cleansing. It is not only

~ palatable, but nourishing and healthful. However, in

’ later vears, especially in cities and closely populated com-

munities, it has been thought wise and proper to purify

milk by machinery. We call it “pasteurizing the milk,”

which. means nothing more or less than to remove from

the raw material all germs, _— and other. foreign -

substances that might be i However, when the

process is complete, we ~vtiny Boa i left but milk, the—

same article and raw material that comes fresh from a

healthy cow by the hands of a careful and clean milker.

> after it has been properly strained and prepared for use-

by a first-class, clean and tidy housewife. ‘The milk,

after the pistenrization is complete, contains the, same -

ingredients as it had in it when it came from the cow.

If is only made clean food to’ke used. It has lost none

of its palatable taste as When it came from a healthy

Still, it contains all of the ingredients that it

forme thy had.

oi Ww,

in Peoih or rel, B. \ Dairy 6: 7. “Svhmer, shpra; Pp. yd A

; “4. it Was stated:

+ *

correct or not will be determined by the answer

.

s J y

the question; “owhether sid assessment was

to be

. O6

CONCLUSION

We submit that the courts below properly held:

hat the sales of electrical energy to ‘milk ‘dealers

nd distributérs, wheo ‘pasteurize their milk as an

neident to their business were taxable as sales of

given to the further question whether the pasteurization

of milk in which-relator employed a large part of its

_ capital is a manufacturing process.’ If such business was

one of manufacture the relator was entitled to exemption

from taxation of so much of its capital as was employed

in pasteurizing milk and selling the same * * *. Hf

‘in pasteurizing and selling milk it was not engaged in

manufacturing, then * * * the assessment was

corre.

* * . . * .

. In the light of * * * the description of the proe-

esses through: which the milk is passed and of the results

obtained thereby, it is perfectly apparent that the object

and result of pasteur ization are to free milk from germs

and foreign substances of various kinds without destroy-

ing or changing the inherent and essential qualities of

the milk itself. There is no purpose by the application

of any foreign substance to change its superficial ap-

pearance or by any method_to alter its. substantial form:

and character as would be the case if it were made into

butter or cheese. It is entered upon the process as milk,

and it is taken therefrom as milk. The only change ‘

accomplished has been to relieve it from objectionable

matter which is not properly an inherent part thereof.

and thereby to make it more fit for those purposes to

which milk is naturally devoted. 5

i * * ot Y 6 *

* @® * we are still unable to discover as the result

of pasteurization any such degree of change in the form,

nature or intended use of milk when compared with

ifs original condition * * * that the process pre-

ducing such change could be regarded as one of nunn-

facture,

ad .

od

energy for commercial consumption, and the de- .

cision of the Court of Appeals for the Seventh

Cireuit should be affirmed. j

Respectfully, . |

| Pui B. Peremay,

Solicitor Gene ral. —

THERON LAMAR CAUDLE, |

Assistant Attorney General.

_ Exuis N. Snack,

LEE A. JACKSON,

Puiip R. Miter,

‘Spe cial Assistants to the Seek le Ge neral.

DECEM BER 1948,

\PPENDIX

Internal Revenne Fede:

Src. 3411. TAX ON ELECTRICAL © ENERGY

FOR DOMESTIC OR COMMERCIAL CONSUMPTION, -

(a) There shall be imposed upon electri-

‘al energy sold for domestic or commereial

consumption and. not >for resale. a .tax

equivalent to 3 per centum-of the price for

which so sold, to be paid by the vendor

under such rules and regulations ps. the

Commissioner, with*the appréval of the

Secretary, shall prescribe.. The ‘sale. of

electrical energy to an owner or lessee of a.

building, who purchases such electrical en-

ergy for resale to the tenants therein, shall

for the purposes of this section be con-

sidered as a sale for consumption and not. »

for resale, but the resale to the tenant shall,

not be considered a sale for consumption.

(b) The provisions of sections 3441, 344,

and $447 shall not be applicable with re-

spect es the tax imposed by this section.

(¢) No tax shall be imposed under this

section upon electrical energy sold to the’

United States or to any State or Territory,

or political subdivision thereof, or the Dis-

trict of Columbia. None-of the provisions

of this section shall apply to publicly owned

electric and power. plants, or to electric

and power plants or systems owned and op-

erated) by cooperative or nonprofit cor-.

‘porations engaged. in rural electrification.

The right to exemption under this subsee--

tion shall be-evidenced tm such manner as

the Commissioner, with the sappreval of,

LA

(8)

> +

.

the Secretary, may, by regulation, pre-

scribe, ;

ee eee * eee *

(26 0. 8:0. 146 od. 2 see, tll.

Section niet (a) was ‘uate nded by the Reve nue

~ Act of 1941, ¢. 412, 55 Stat, G87. See. 521 (a) (19),

to change thee three pereent tax to three and |

one-third percent, ts

Revenue Act of 1932, ¢. 209, 47 Stat. 169:

See. 616. TAX ON ELPCTRICAL ENERGY. —

(a) Phere is hereby imposed -a_ tax

equivalent to 3 per ceritum of the amount.

paid on or after the fifteenth dav after the

date of the enactment of this Act, for elee-

trical energy for domestic or commercial |

consumption furnished after such date and

before July 1, 1934, to be paid by the person.

paving for such electrical energy and. to.

be collected by the vendor.

(b) Each vendor receiving any payments

specified in subsection (a) shall colleet the

‘amount of the tax imposed by such. subsee-

tion. from the person making such = pay-

ments, and shall on or before the last day

of each month make a return, under oath,

for the preceding month, and pay the taxes”

_ 7 (so collected, te the collector of the district

. in Which his principal place of Dusiness is

—- Joeated, or if he has no ‘prineipal place of

business in the United States, to the col-

lector at) Baltimore, Maryland. Such ‘re-

turns shall contain seh information and be

made iy such manner as: the Commissioner

with the.approval of the Seeretary may by

regulation. prescribe. The Conanissioner

may extend the’time for making rettrms

and paving the taxes colleeted, under such

rules and regulations as he shall prescribe:

‘60

with the approval of the See ‘retary, but ho

such extension shall be for more than, G0

days, The provisions of sections T71 to.

774, inclusive, shall, in lieu of the -provi-

sions of sections 619 to 629, inelusive, be

applicable in respect of the tax imposed by

this section.

4c) No’ tax shall be ‘inipooed under this

section upon any. payment: received for:

electrical energy furnished to the United

States or to any State or Territory, or

political subdivision thereof, or the District

of Columbia. The right to exemption un--

der this subsection shall be evidenéed in

such manner as the Commissioner with the

approval of the Secretary may by regula-

' tion prescribe.

Act

of June 16, 1933, ©. 96, 48 Stat. 254:

Sec. 6. (a) Effective September 1, 1933,

section 616 of the Revenue -Act of 1932 is_

amended.to read as follows:

_ “Sec. 616, TAx ON ELECTRICAL ENERGY FOR

POMESTIC OR- COMMERCIAL €ONSUMPTION

‘*(a) There is hereby imposed upon elec-

trical: energy seld for domestie or com-

mercial consumption and not for resale a

tax equivalent to 3 per centum of the price

for which so sold, to be paid by the vendor

under such rules and regulations as the’

Commissioner, with the approval of the

Secretary, shall preseribe.’:The sale of

electric al energy to an-owner or lessee of a

building, who purchases such. electrical”

energy for resale to the tenants therein,

shall for thé purposes of this section ‘be

considered as a sale for ‘consumption and -

net for resale, but the resale te the tenant

shall not be considered a sale for consump-

tion,

to the tax imposed by t

61

“(by The provisions of sections 619, 622,"

and 625 shall not be applicable with respect |

ripe ‘ction.

‘*(¢) No tax shall be imposed tinder this

“Section upon electrical energy sold to the

United States or to any State or Territory, |

or pokitical subdivision thereof, or. the Dis.

trict of Columbia. None of the provisions

of this section shall apply to publicly owned

electric and power plants. The right to

exemption under this subsection shall be

evidenced in‘such manner as the Commis-

sioner, with the-approval of the Secretary,

may, by regulat on, preseribe,’

(b) Despite the provisions of this section

the tax imposed under section 616 of ‘the

Revenue Act of 1932 before its amendment

by this section on electrical energy fur-

nished before September 1, 1933, shall be

imposed, collected, and paid in: the same

manner and shall be subject to the same

provisions of law (inechiding penalties) as

if this section -had not been enacted.

Treasury Regulations 42, promulgated under

‘the Revenué Act of 1932: : :

o

Ari. 40. Scope of tax.—The tax: applies

to the amount paid for all electrical energy

‘furnished for domestic or commercial con-:

sumption, either by a privately or publicly. |

owned operating electrical power company.

Electrical energy fer domestic or com-

mercial consumption”: inéludes all electri-

eal energy furnished the eonsumer except

electrical energy furnished for ‘industrial

ronsumption, Electrical energy for indus-’

‘trial consumption includes that used gener-

ally for industrial purposes, that cis. in

manufacturing, processing, mining, refip-

Lge, irrigation, shipbuilding, building eon-

i)

T.

‘

,

waterworks, telephone, telegraph,

- struction, ete, and by publie hand

The tax attaches to all amounts pi iid for

electrical ene rev for. domestie or commer-

cial consumption ltrespective of whether

any of the energy paid for is actually used.

Tn other words, the: tax is due on. all pay-

‘ ments for electricak: energy whethe® in

the. form of ao miiiimum charge, a flat

~ charge, or otherwise.

* * * oo a

D. 4342, XI-2 Cum. Bull. 495 (1932):

and |

radio companies, 1 rilronds, and other/eom-

mon carriers.

‘Article 40 of Regulations 42. is-amended |

to read as follows: j

“The tax applies to the- amount paid. for.

all electrical energy furnished for domes-

tic or commercial consumption: by any per-_

‘som or agency (whether private, public or

quasi public) irrespective of whether such

person or agency preduces the energy so-

furnished. (For definition .of- the word

“person,” see section 1111 of the Act.)

“All electrical energy furnished the con-

sumer is taxable except (1) electrical

energy furmished for industrial « cOnSUIMp-

- tlome. 2, th: it used in manufacturing, proe-

essing, mining, refining, shipbuilding,

bauilding construction. ete. and (2) that

furnished fer other-uses which likewise can

not be classed as doniestte sor. eommereial,

su@ho as used by public ntiliiies,. water -

Works, iritgation ~ companies, ~ telegraph,

telephone, qitd’ radio communication ehme-

paves, railroads, other common carriers,

edneational jastitutions net operated bai

private profi, churehes,- and charitable

‘Sees

> ae a es Pan

institutions, However, electrical cnergy. is —

subject to tax if consumed in the commer-

ial phases .of industrial or other. busi-

nesses, such as in office. buildings, sales and

display. rooms, retail ‘stores, ete.

- . - ©Wihere electrical energy is supplied to

‘a single consumer for two or more pur-

poses, the specific use for which thé energy

is furnished, i. e., whether for domestic,

or commercial consumption, or, for: other |

consumption, shall. determine its taxable

status. Where the consumer has all the

electrical energy used at.a given location

furnished. through one meter, the predom-

inant character: of the busine ‘ss earried on

at such location shall determine the classi-

fication of electrical” consumption for the’

~ purposes of this tax.’

: * * + we 3 *

bi i D. 4393, ‘NIE 2 Cum. Bull. B22. (1933).

* * * * *

Ss - Section 616 of ‘the Revenue Act of 1932

was amended. by section 6 (a) of the Act

of Congress approved June 16, 1983 (Pub-

he, No. 73, Seventy-third Congress). In.

conformity with the law°as so. amended,

Chapter V of Regulations 42, approved

October 22, 1832, is amended, effective with

respect to electrical energy sold on or after

zs September 1, 1935; to read as follows:

- *. * * . *

‘Arr. 3o EB ffectine we mod.— he tax ap-

hie s la élee trival enereyv sell On or after

septe ber “1, 1933. and he foe SRIEAS 1, 19D.

“Arr. 40. SCO pe af fer. be tux is im-

posed Wipreoti el « tries nbener: ]

the oor eominercial eornsum

resale, except as pros tle |

ry” Ni t fer domnes-

tien and net for:

-

tha reduuiter,

“The term ‘eleetrical energy sold for

domestic or commercial consumption’ does

not include (1) elec ‘trical energy sold for in-

~ dustrial constumption, e. g., for Use In manu-

facturing, processing, mining, refining,

shipbuilding, building construction, irriga-

tion, ete., or (2) thattsold for. othe py Uses

Ww hich likewise ean not be classed as domestic

or commercial, such as the eléctrical energy

used by publie utilities, waterworks, tele-

graph, ‘telephone, and adio communteation ~

‘compenties, railroads, other common car-

riers, educational. institutions not operated

for profit, churches, and charitable institu-

. tions. However, electrical energy is sub-.

ject to tax if sold for‘use in the commercial

phases of industrial or other businesses,

such as in office buildings, sales and display

rooms, retail stores, ete. —

“Where electrical energy is sold to a

single consumer_for two or’ more purposes,

through separate meters, the specific use

_for which the energy is sold through each _

meter, i. e., whether. for domestic or com: ’

pare consumption, or for other use, shall

determine its taxable status. Where the

consumer has all the eleetrical - energy used

‘ at‘a given location furnished through ane

‘ meter, the predominant. character of the

business carried. on at such location shall

determine the classification of consumption

for the purposes of this tax.’’*

* * . a .

* These Regulations, consiatentiy with extensions of the

Jaw, were altered as coricerns the provision thereof concern-

‘ing effective date by T. D. 4570. XTV-2 Cam. Bull. 391

(1935): again by T. D. 4751, 1937-2 Cum. Bull. 517; and -

again by T. D. 4922, 1989-2 Cum: Ball. 363. | ;

Treasury Re gulation’s 46 (1940 ed.) :

e

‘Sec. 316.190- [as amended by T. D. 3099,

1941-2 Cum, Bull. 267].- Scope of laz—

“The tax imposed by section 3411 (a) of the’

Internal Revenue Code, as amended, -ap-

plies, except as.provided hereinafter, to all

electrical energy sold for domestic or com--

mercial consumption, and not fer resale.

The term ‘‘electrical energy sold for

, domestic or commercial consumption*’ does

not inelude (1) electrical energy sold for

industrial consumption, e. g., ‘for use in

manufacturing, mining, refining, shipbuild-

ing, buildin’ construction, irrigation, ete.,

or (2) that sold for other uses W hich like-

wise ean not be classed as domestic or com-

mercial, suchas the electrical energy used

by electric and gas companies, waterworks;

_telegraph, telephone, and radio communica-

tion companies, railroads, . other similar

common = e¢arriers, educational institutions

not operated for private profit, BTN

and charitable instituttons in their opera-

tions as such. However; electrical ener gy

is subject to tax.if sold for consumption in

commercial phases of industrial. og other

“businesses, such as in office’ buildings, sales’

and display rooms, retail stores; ete., or in

domestic phases, such as in dormitories or

living quarters maintained by edycational

institutions, churches, . charitable institu-

tions, or others.

Where electrical energy is. ‘sold to a con-

sumer for two or more purposes, through

‘separate meters, the specific use for which

the ener gy is sold through each metci, i. «.,

whether for domestic: or commercial ¢on-

sumption, or for other use, shall determine

its taxable status: Where the. consumer

has allethe electrical energy consumed at a

ne y

Vg

Pa

ee

66

given location’: furnished through — one

meter, the predominant character of the —

Iuisiness carried on at such location shall

‘determine the classification Of consumption

for the purposes of this tax.

* . ‘oe e- .

> *

S. Ty 518, NI-2 Cum. Bull. 498 (1932) :

Advice is ‘requested whether electrical

energy furnished bettling works, milk com-

‘panies, and creameries is taxable under see-

tion 616 of the Revenue Act of 1952,

Electrical energy furnished for consump-

tion by. bottling works, milk companies, ox __

creameries engaged in the pasteurization

and bottling of milk, and in.the manufac-

ture of. butter, buttermilk, choclate milk,

and cottage cheese, is not furmished for

domestic or commercial consumption arid

is not subject to the tax imposed by section

616 of the Revenue Act of 1932. However:

\. the use of electrical energy in branch offices

\ or agencies of such industries is a‘cdmmer--"

\cial.use and electrical energy so used ts:sub-

ject to the tax.

S. 'T. 687, XTI-1 Cum. Bull. 409 (1933):

Adyiee is requested concerning the tax

~~ on eleétrical enérgy imposed by section 616

of the Revenue Act of 1932 when furnished

to a farmer who runs a dary and sells

milk to a commercial dairy which distr?

butes the milk on a retail basis.

* -It is held that electrical energy furnished *

in-the general operations of farming, syeh .

as lighting the homes or dwellings, barns. .

‘and other farm buildings; ensilage cutters;

cream) separators; ‘oat erushers; threshing

machities; Water pumps; ete., and for the «

operation of other miscellaneous nanclsan-

67

ery such’ as is used in general farming

operations, is domestie or commercial in its |

scope and, therefore, is subject to the tax

Imposed by section 616 of the Revenue Act

of 1932.

A dairy which obtains milk and conve rts

it into use for retail purposes ix held to be’

engaged in a business commercial in cliar-

acter. Electrical energy used in-such oper- ~

ations will be subject to tax: -

Electrical eviergy . furnished to dairies

which are engaged in the manufacture and.

sale of butter, cheese, aud. sttuilar dairy

products is not subject to the tax imposed >

by section 616, of the Revenue Act of 1% ae

1948 C. C. H., Vol. 4, par. 2633G: sg

‘>and comme ‘reial,

175 Rulings reconciled —S. T. 637 (045

and, .065) sdoes not amount ta a reversal

of S. T. 518. (.033), but isa modification

and: extension of the opinion. rendered

therein, insofar as it affects dairy farms

“and milk dealers. General’ operations of.

farming are domestie and commereial in

character and electrical energy furnished

for use in these operations is subject to the

tax. The’ mere fact that certain inciden-

tal dairy processes are carried on at a farm:

will not affect the taxability of dh he elee-

trical Geergy consumed at such a location

since the predominant character of the

operations of farming is held to- he domestic

Electrical energy furnisl a commercial

dairy.or milk company? which merely pro-_

duees or purechiases: raw milk in bulk and

-pasteurizes it for sale either in bulk or

bottled quantities, whose“: activities consist

‘principally ino the. Imndling,: distribution

wl sale Of milk, is also’subject to the tax.

. \ >

“

OS

It. is only eleetrical energy, that is fur-

nished for direct consumption by dairies,

which in, addition to pasteurizing and bot-

tling milk are-also engaged in all the es8-

- sential “manufacturing processes. necessary

for the production of dairy products, such

“as the manufacturing of butter, cheese and.’

other dairy products, for sale on the open:

~market .as an article of commerce, that is

not subject to the tax. .

* Bureau Letter, dated May 13, 1933 (sym-

bols MT: ST: BHF),. (333CCH16266.) -

US GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE 1949

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.