Brief for Jungersen — Jungersen v. Ostby & Barton Co.
Supreme Court brief1949
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
“LIBRARY: |
SUPREME COURT,US.
| Supreme Court of the Huited States
October Term, 1948 |
Nos. 7, 8 and 48
~
‘Tuoskn Gronperc JUNGERSE N,
Petitioner: Re ‘-sponde nt,
mie Vv.
fu>
°o
Ostspy anp Bartos Company, ef al.,
*
Respondents-Petitioners,
and
THOGER GRONBERG JUNGERSEN, :
Re eee: ; Petitioner,
. 7 .
?
Rosier BaDEN, Rose Baven, Arseat Foss, et al.,
*9
nigaties
SS ee ee
- BRIEF F on JUNGERSEN ©
*
WituiaMm H. Davis,
| Georce E. Farrarvtt,.
’ ioe Kart W. Frocks,
ee ane Attorneys for Jungersen.
New York, N.Y.
October 15, 1948.
e
»
_
‘ ~~
.
- ©
INDEX
PAGE.
Tue Opixioy: MME ac oy Cacen enn ; oY eneee- sh
JURISDICTION ® «04. : Nice wa ks zs . roe Peta Rekeees ;
STATEMENT ie al PO os nao ce eee .
‘The Parties ....... Sas eas oe uaa isi era mee:
The Jewelry Manufacturing Art rior to’ Jungersen 4:
1 he Story of the Jungersen i a ee emer an
The Junsorsen Patent :.... POT rere ues seen Pane
The Effect of Jungersen’ S : Method on Jewelry Man- |
ck, ab OT OT ee Corer yey erry eee i,
Karly Applications in “the. Fine Arts of the “Lost :
Wax’. | eee sree ter ee se eerr Te sae Ae
Sixteenth Century Treatises of Hetievenate Cel-
lini on ‘‘Goldsmithing and Sculpture’’ ...... 13 _
La Gravure publication bt) eee ee > ~
Cire Perdue Process (Enéyelopedia ia Brittanies, .
SE TR Vee MD. iva ties iecet cankaesnss> 16
Die Casting Practice’ , hy Mare Stern (1930). 17
~The Use: of the-*Lost Wax’?-Process in Dentistry. . W
Huseltine’s British Patent No. 2467, of 1875 ...... 18
: Spencer’ s Patent No. 748,996, of 1906 .....<. yack 20
Kralund’s Patent No. 1,238, 789, oe 1917 oe ane ie
MeManus’ Patent No. 1,457 040, « of 1923 ..... <i
SPECIFICATIONS OF Errors Peres canes thaws Deen eees 24
I. The ‘broader claims 5 ands ean be and should.:
INDEX -
ARGUMENT ........ a eae Pere Te ey re Ceceemrans
Despite a long- felt want which had existed. un-
satisfied for many, many years, Jungersen's
method in its entirety had never been assembled
hefore. Its production by him was a substantial
—even revolutionary—tec ‘hnical innovation, for
whieh society is truly indebted'to him. The test
of history, as it appears from the record, con-—-
clusively proves that Jungersen’s forward step
was not obvious; that did require more in-
: gemuity. than the work of a mechanic skilled.
in the art. see e eee eee e cence needa le eeees x
be so construed as to embrace but not. to extend
beyond what Jungersen truly invented; the new
-method specifically described when practiced |
with the substitution off known equivalents for
some of ‘the steps ‘particularly defined in nar- .
rower terms in claims 1 to4 ..... STE Seer e
The Construction that"S Should Be Given to
Claims 5 and 6°. oe ees aa ae We
Use by the. ‘ce: ‘airing of Other In-
jection Forces Than Centrifugal Force. .
Use bv ‘the Alleged Infringers of. Primary
‘Molds Built: Up of Soft Metal Instead of 7
Rubber Cave ace aaws aVunagienve pens when.
gh
| Apeenbix - Eee LEE a ee phe av ek Sane ‘
og
- INDEX AS? eee ”
i 4 mn
ae. ae |
TABLE oF CASES
i]
~ Carnegie Steel Co. vi Cambria ete. Co. 189 U. Ss.
___ PSS Ee ee Pe Pe pee poapiace ae
‘Consolidated Valve Co, v. Croshy Valve Co., is
AS ae ee ree eae Fee eee weee ds 29
Kibel Process Co. v. Minnesota ete. Co, 26h. $. 45.8 29
“Expanded Metal Co. v. Hadford, 214 U. - re 20 |
| Goodyear ete, Co, ¥. Ray-( )-Vae Co., 321-U. S. 275:.. .. 9
Hildreth v. Mastoras, 257 U.S. 27 ....... ae
” Keystone Mfg. Co. v. Adams, tht Us .) S Satis 29
- Krementz vin ‘ottle, MS ULS. 5N6 Foe errr oP TerT er 20°
Loom Co, v. Higgins, 10a U, SLa80 . 2... Pe ogen ae baSecg a
Mae thine Co.'v. M urphy, 7 Otto 120... ne Pep es ade 46
Paramount Publix COFp: \ Amer. Tri: Ergon Corp.,
24 U.S. 464 co leeaeweeces PEPE OT Ere e oe
“Potts v. Creager, 159 yk Os nap eeegs oe ee 29° |
Skelly Oi Co. v0 ‘niversal. Oil Produets ( %, 31 F..
| EB Sap Sneneeranrrs a , 28. .
Smith v. Goodyear ete. Oo. » oo U. co Wee = a a
U nivereal Oil Products ‘Co. v. Globe ete. Co, 322 | U,
Gee Sessa, pene e eat seeene ees nae A eekee et ee 3 ” 90
AvTHORITIES aS
.* Rebinson On Patents, Vol, 2 P ar. 135. 739, pp. 484-491 > 39
28 U. S. Code, See. Wks: err eitvess*- @
35 U.S. Code, See. 38-—R. S.See. 48a... Sataei 38
‘Supreme Court uf the Hnited ‘States
Oc Ti BER Term, 194%:
‘Mos. 7, 8 and 48
7
a oe
THOGER GRONBERG ,J UNGERSEN,
Petitioner-Respondent, .
Vv. ‘a , ;
Ostspy anp Barron Company, et al.,
Respondents-Petitioners, :
and |
THOGER Guownene 30 NGERSEN,
<i eves Petitioner,
| a
f mee | Ropert “‘BaDEN , Rose BAvEN 4 Komiie Foss: et af: ete.,
| Respondents.
|. BRIEF FOR JUNGERSEN
T "a question for sdindicétion is the validity of Junger-
sen’s, patent No. .2,118,468, granted May 24, 1938, for a
Method of Casting Articles of Intricate: Design and a
Product t Thereof. cles pez ) gg eeege
The patent fh fas sis six claims. As to claims 1 tod inclusive,
the single question is whether the method defined in thetn
‘is a “pacentable innovation. In claims and 6, the claimed
| monopoly is stated in somewhat broader t terms. If Junger-
\
> ,
: es es! _ ZL
sen‘s method is a patentable invention, then the question
arises whether claims 5 and, 6: can and should be inter-
preted to embrace that invention (including recognized °
equivalents) and nothing more; and whether certain/of the «
alleged infringing operations are within the moriopoly. of
claims 5 and 6 HO interpreted,
Three writs of certiorari (C ases 7:°-8 and 48) ‘issued’
because of conflict in decisions of the Third Circuit Court
of Appeals and of. the Seeond Cireuit Court of Appeals.
Two writs (Cases 7 and 8): issued to the Third Circuit
Court of Appeals which affirmed in’a per curiam opinion
(378a*; 163 F. 24-312, Case 3) the decision of the New /
Jersey District Court (Meaney, D. J. 65 F. Supp. 653;/
22a) holding claims 1 to 4 valid and claims 5 and 6 inv -alid
* . because anticipated by Kralund patent No. 1,238,789. 1e
writ in No. 7 was issued on the petition of: the patentee
7 Jungersen for a< review of the holding of invalidity of
claims 5 and 6.. In No. 8, the writ issued on‘ petition of
Ostby and Barton Co. and- American Associates, Inc., seek-
ing review of the decision that-claims 1 to 4 are valid.
In ease No.. 48, the writ issued.to the Second. Cireuit
Court of Appeais on the petition of the patentee Junger-
sen for review of a holding of invalidity of all the claims
of the patent. . The District Court for the Southern, District
of New York (Rifkind, J., 26:39; 39 F. Supp. 922) held the
3 ‘alid hi m for_want_of _invention.—The:-
Court ch Appeals fo or r the Second Circuit (Judges L. Hand,
-*In- cases 7 and 8, Volume I of the record, containing: all but |
the prior patents. and publications put in evidewce, has its page
numbers followed by the small letter a. Reference to that volume.
will be indicated as follews: —~ (26a). In No, 48 there ‘is but -
one volume and references to that record will be by simple page
‘number as: — (26).° The prior’ patents and publications put in
evidence are the same in both cases and appear only in Volume IL.
of the record in Cases Nos. 7:8. Here also the page numbers ‘are
‘ “ _ followed by. the small letter a. Roference will * by the volume
‘and Eee pumber as: — (II, 400a).. ;
oe 3°
Augustus Hi nd and Clat a affirmed hy a divided court.
’ There was A majority “opinion written by Judge Clark ”
and a vig Rous dissent by Judge Learned Hand (210-
L219; 166 ret Us| 807).
Juris iction -of this Court*is invoked under Section
~240¢a)/ of the Judicial Code as amended by the Act of
Febrviary 13, 19385 (28 U.S. Code, See. 34a).
oy:
ve _ Statement of the Case
‘The Parties ~ re | Sue
Jungersen, the_ petitioner in Nos. Ke. and 48, is. the
patentee and sole ow ner of the patent in suit.
The respondents in No. 7 and petitioners in No: 8 are:—
Ostby and Barton Company, a rie established firm: of’
jewelry: ‘manufacturers (3538a,,. f -° 1058) ‘manufacturing
_ principally gold and _ silver rings (355a, f. 1063), and
American Associates,’ Ine., which subsequent to the bring-
ing ‘of the suit was added/as a party on its showing that
it had acquired®all the assets ‘of ‘Ostby and Barton Co.
(22a, f. 66)*.
“In No. 48, the respondents, Nain a et al., are a
partnership engaged ‘in jewelry manufacture. “After issue
was joined, seven ‘corporations and fifteen individuals
comprising’ Six partnerships were allowed to intervene
(48, Finding.1).. The intervenors are jewelry manufac-
_ turers and the stated justification for the intervention |
‘was that, “by. mutual agreerffent among themselves and
with defendants, interv ‘enors Mave openly -participated in” oa
- and) contributed to the defensé of this suit, to the knowl-
fen! of és meat (18, f. on DE tap eect e eae a
Cog
*On peer] an ( Istby. and Barton’ Chip was added as a party
appellant (376a) on its showirig | that it had acquired all the assets
of the Ostby & Barton’division of. American Associates, Inc.’ ‘
The jewelry manufacturing art teed to a
The methiod deserihe d and ¢ Jalined-i in- 5 Secncsanes n’s patent
has to do with ‘‘the casting of small. metal. articles, par-
tieularly articles. of intricate detail such as jewelry which +
frequently are designed with hollows, undereut portions
and perforations”’ (185/1/2-5)* to achieve ‘*the formation
of intricate éastings which will so ‘closely resemble the -
original and finished product that the slow and tedious
work of patterning and detail cutting required, in connec--
’ tion with present — methods i is ejygninated’’ os 5/1/11-
15).
- Prior to 1934, when Jungerser made his method avail-’
able to the public, such articles of intricate detail had been
produced (a) by handeraft of skilled. artisans ‘or (b) by
die stamping where. the number of articles to.be produced °
was large enough to warrant the high initial cost of
_ stamping dies, or (c) where’ the number .of articles to be °
produced was insufficient to justify the high initial expense,
by one or another of two casting methods: (1) euttle-fish
casting and (2) sand casting. -
‘Prior to the Jungersen patent diaclosuce, the only
‘known and generally practiced processes in the jewelry
casting art were the ‘Cuttle fish’ and ‘sand’ casting
methods. Neither method was efficient and_admittedly.
of ee:
each was. inferior to the method disclosed. in the
patent in suit. ° Under these prior methods the cast-
ings were without: detail and required, extensive hand -
: tooling and chasing by a master artisan, thus greatly
-inereasing the cost of . the completed article. . The
Jungersen method reduces to a minimum the neces-
sary hand ‘finishing of the cast article and makes
possible the . reproduction in any desired number of
_ ©The auimerats after inclined bars refer to the: column and line
. number in patents. ae i en
ses
q'
eract replicas of the. original model.’’. (Meaney
opinion, 24a, f. 71; and see Findings 13. and 14, 34a-°
poa,- ff. 101-103. Cf. also opinion*of Judge Rifkind,
29-30, ff. 87-90; and 49, here, 4.) | hal
. The making of rhage and. such like ‘articles of ‘jewelry
of intricate design by hande ‘raft of skilled artisans needs
no deseription. * It comes down to us from prehistoric
times. We adopt Judge Rif kind’s description.of di¢ stamp- :
ing, cuttle fish casting and sand. engGng. 4 as follows’ (30,
® ff. 88.89): * ay
“4. Die stamping, Which ‘consists of. stamping out
‘the ring or parts of it by- means of metal dies.. This .
‘process is very efficient: | It is still. in extensive use
when numerous castings of a single design are desired.
Its initial cost is high. The dies. for a ‘single ring-
design cost from $250 to $2, 000. ms
bel
; “2, Cuttlefish casting, which consists of com-
pressing the model of the ring’ to be reproduced
-- between two loaves of cuttlefish bone. -The. yielding _
surfaces of the: bone form a eavity roughly cor-
responding to the form of the compressed model. A
channel or opening between the two loaves permits.the |
molten: gold:to flow into this cavity, to form a rough .
réplica of the model. This casting is then hand-
finished. ine eae
_. 83. Sand casting, which consists of imbedding the _
*model in a sand frame which, wpon the removal -of
the model, leaves a) cavity into which the molten metal
_ is‘admitted by ‘ an opening provided for the ‘purpese.
"ae advantage over cuttlefish casting is that it pefmits.
'° the production of six to“twelve castings from a single
mould: , The anime is -Fough and requires. hand
. finishing.” : -
“,
picture. . SOC ELD So a Senne /
; T he story of the Jungersen invention | i
i 2 §- : a
P 7 ; ' /
/
These were the ‘established. practices. and teitations % In
making small articles of jewélry,of intricate detail such. as
rings, brooches and the like when Jungersen sc into thre
4
a / . <«
Mr. Jungersen is a naturalized citizen/ born ii Den-
mark. : He had been an’ automobile dealer,/a consulting en-
gineer anda ‘manufacturer in Denmark 6f Diesel engines,.
gasoline engines, highway reflectors, and pumps for fire ._
- engines, ‘and was an* inventor and patentee. He had not
heen connected With the jewelry business in any ‘way. In -
‘Decémber 1933 he: was living in T oronto and made . a
-wager ‘with a friend that: he could ‘take any job that he. vi
_couldpick'out of a newspaper. ’’ They took a 104 spaper
and picked out.a jeweler who. was,adv ertising for a caster
re and Jungersen applied for the job and avas refused be-
g
- Cause he was not.a jeweler, but’ ‘he procured from\ the jew-
eler one of the most intricate, patterns He had in order diet
he might see If he could produce ea finished reproduetion to.
'- the jeweler’s satisfaction. He. made the reproductit n, took
et it back to the jeweler‘and got a job for. himself and Iso for
his friend (79-77 and 74a-76a):
In. both records Jungersen ‘deseribes how he papbeeded
to cast an ‘exact reproduction of that intricate pattern
(77-783 Tia-78a).. He sayg he studied the pattern very care-
full nd.thought over how to progeed. He considered sand |
t discarded ‘that thought. He then thought about.
x -pattern and then inelting the wax pat-
: th out’’ as. dentists do—the. dentists’ sere of the
ancient ‘‘lost wax”’ process (see post p. 17).’. As to
tow to make the mold,-he first thought of using plaster e
of Paris; but, put that. aside. He then thought of using”
rubber for the mold. He went into a service station on
his way home ‘and bought some strips of patching rubber
used for’ repairing” automobile - ‘tires. He-.went home and
‘
\
t
a.
}
“y
v.
4
- at 4
\ves 7
~ built ef wood. a reeessed frame. for the inold and ther nN,”
he’ Says:
_**T eut slices-of the With rubber—it was approximately
a sixteenth of an inch thie k—cut that in.a sinall piece
and built them up -dround the piece of jewelry | hed;
and. then -I squeezed it” hetw een the two slabs of wood
~ and inside the frame that | had made éut of wood, and -
— then"T squeezed it with a little clamp and put it into a |
baking oven, regular in the kitchen, and | baked the
mould for a long time until it was cured. I took it out’
several times, I remember, to punch in and see if it was
eared, but as far as | recollect now it took an hour or.
two before the heat had penetrated into the center-and
——eured the ‘rubber. Well, after T had the rubber mould °
-of this piece of jewelry, then the problem was to fill it. > |
I. poured: some wax into the opening. That was an
open mould, if F could express it that way, just like a_
. flat piece of rubber With a design of the pendant on the
‘one side. That was on one side. Then I poured the
wax in there and most jugt stuck | to the mould. ; a
wy
didn’ t get. far with it. ©
.
o
“Then I tried to squeeze it down with my fingers and
‘with a backirg first of plggt or of Paris, later of a piece:
-of type metal, and that di “work. J got fins all over
‘it and I couldn't. get the patterns out.
“Then I came to think about, well, if I pour.the wax
in from one end, if I could fill it that way, and I tried,
oand the wax did not: fill the piece all the way down.
Some place it filled fairly good, and some plaee it did
not. fill at all: Some place there was a very poor im-
pression, like there were on those pictures on that
exhibit.
“AeThen T discarded that. I,took-a cloth — from
approximately. an, eighth of an inch thick steel.”
- 8
— “Q. A coat hanger? A. Yes, one o&-these regular
coat. hangers, - srk
“*Q. Yes, - all right. A coat hanger. A..A coat
changer; and I made a little swing’ out of it and I took
it so I could Swing it with centrifugal foree, and then |
took an old.tin can and made myself a little crucible
out of this tin can and pointed the nozzle of the cruci-
ble into my mould.- Then I melted some wax and ©
poured it into my little crucible and swung it around,
and. that filled the mould with the finest interior that
you- could ever. wish. Then it was: just a question of
some of it may be a little too hot and some of,it may :
be a little too cold; and after yOu try it two or three
times, then yqu get them perfect’’ (77a, ff. 231-78a,
f. 234). | : | re
. e . oe ; e ys
After he had produced the wax-pattern in that way he
went .to ;‘a mechanical dentist * * * one who-had. been
casting for.different dentists in Toronto’? who was ‘‘very
' much interested. It turned out that this gentleman had
been a jeweler before, and he was most surprised to see |
what IL. was doing,- and he said that I could use his shop,
and I-did.’’* fit. the dentist’s shop he made his first casting
in meta} and took it down to.the jeweler. ‘‘I went. back
to Mr. Fremes and showed him the casting, and then he
said it was one of the finest castings he had ever. seen,
or the finest’? (78, ff. 233-4). He* proceeded to work at
this jewelry place ‘to develop it further.and make it a
. well workable. process’” (79a, f. 237). and took out patents
in Canada, the United States, Great Britain, and many —
other countries. . He eventually sold the Canadian patent
for $5,000 (82a, ff. 245-246) and. went on with the exploita- :
tion of hig patents in, other countries, - selling licenses’ in
the United States, England, .Sweden, * Norway, Finland, .
Germany, France, Belgium, Australia, India, Brazjl, Argen- °
tina, Java, etc. He issued somewhere between sixty and |
seventy licenses. in the United States (80, f. 238; SI, f. 242;
ae ey a ee, a i |
$2, f. 244). Fron LOBB te Ocetoher 16, 1945 ‘Sapproximately
~ $120,000"" in ‘royalties were colieeted of which $10,250 was
troni foreign licenses (Werner, 07a). 0 02 a
The Jungersen Patent —— ame ele, oe a mate
_ Jungersen’s method, as ‘described “and claimed in his
| patent, (185-187), ds. a" series of sixyprocess steps in, or-
dered sequence, as follows (185/1/28-2/54):
1.) Producing a model of the piece of jewelry or other .
small article ‘tin wood,. metal, or other suitable material;
and this may have undereut surfaces, hollows or perfora-
ee of any desirable kind”’ (185/1/30-32). ; : :
ase Nee am = setae ;
2. “Producing a Grimary mold by: building up- around
. the model a flexible mold-formiutg waterial such as rubber,
_and then vuleanizing to cause the rubber **to flow intimately
-about the detail structure of the model and thus assumes :
a permanent shape having a cavity the exact ‘shape and
detail of the model embedded therein’? (185/1/52-55), the:
flexible nature of the rubber permitting withdrawal. from
hollows, undereut portions and perforations (185/2/29-31).
od
3. Producing any desired number of dispensable patterns — «
(replicas of the niodel) ‘tofa very low: temperature fusing
- material which” may -be wax’ ora metallié alloy, such as
Wood’s inetal’? which is. melted: and forced into the pri--
inary mold.by centrifugal action.” The melted. wax or like
tnaterial ‘‘is‘poured into the gate and the mold is rotated
rapidly in the centrifugal casting machine. ‘The wax or
metal is thus foreed into the mould and by the centrifugal
‘action displaces the air within the mould, the molten ma-
terial congealing first against ‘the exposed surfaces of the
cavity formed in‘ the ‘mould and any air which may be |
trapped in a-recess of the mould wil) be crowded back into_
the fluid body under the pressury applied thereto and the .—
“ fluid material wit] advanee into the recess as.it crowds the
« Oe
’ .?
e .
A; * : m . ee
10 cae,
air therefrom and will progressively ‘congeal against the
wall of the recess. until ‘the extreme limit is reached.so that
_ the finest of cavities will be completely filled. It is essen-
tial that thé air be expelled from the’ mould progressively
as the molten material flows in so that all interstices
whéther undereut or otherwise, are completely filled’?
alae! ae) BG bbe ene
‘4. Produciig any desirable panier of secondary. cast-
~— dng molds’ by. pouring around the dispensable patterns a-
“fluid mixtire of water ’ and a mold-forming investment. .
material. such as plaster: of Paris (185 /2/33- 40, and
seta -10).
\ 3 |
D. ae and hardening: the ieccubaesitn by heat: to
melt the wax or. other material of which “the | temporary
patterns are made and all traces of the wax are competely
removed from ee mold ‘ese iba ck
a
6. Casting the final products, in any. iigiion: number by
projecting the molten metal ‘‘under applied ‘foree into the
_ fine recesses preferably by- the centrifugal action.”’ Finally;
_the mould is separated from the casting (185/2; /48-54).°
The final result is, as the patentee say s, a cast article”
‘‘which is the exact replica of the original model. It will
he readily understaod that once. the original flexible mould
4s made any desirable. number of the patterns of fusible
material nray be produced to bé invested i in metal-receiving °
material to form moulds and any desirable number of
metal casting moulds may thus be prodneed from the same
model. All will be équally- accurate and as the final moulds
. is a complete investment SF the wax or other fusible pat-
} tern, there will be a minimum of irregularities to be
removed. The ultimate result is that metal, castings
of rings, brooches and many. pieces of jewelry which are |
frequently very fine ‘and intricate ay be produced at the
very minimum of cost’’ (185/2/55- 186/1/15).
-
The patent sp “fication then contrasts the labor and-cost
of his process with, (1). ‘the previotsly-known processes of :
casting r mys (1396/1 645-30) and’ (2) the known die-stamping.
process ( IS621, Bs. 0), :
2
The ideas of decienaia s method
on jewelry manufacture RET a
That the Jungersen method is, far superior to vifher
cuttle ‘fish casting or ‘sand casting and has practically
¥ superseded those former processes is thé concurrent find-
‘ing vf the courts below;‘and the evidence ‘is. that. in so,
superseding the old casting processes the new method, be- -
- cause of its economies and_its capability of reproducing
designs of greater intricacy, encroached even' upon die
stamping, and furthermore made possible thé manufacture
of fine’ and intricate articles that theretofore could be
produced anly by the handwork of master craftsman, if at
‘all (119-120; 120a, 122a, 12 da, f. 368). Bon ee ie es
“We have noted on page 2 ? ahove what Judge Meaney ‘said
in the New Jersey case about. the old casting process andy
Jungerser’s s improvement. He also said (25a, f , T34%
“It was not until Jungérsen: ‘added the vy er
step of casting the wax pattern in the primary mould
by the. use of centrifugai force, ‘that jewelry casting
beeaine a practically and commercially, successful art.
and he found (Findings 14, 15, 35a; Finding 27, 37a) :
“1d, The Jungersen process. -is admitted’ to be far
superior, to either ‘cuttle-fish’ casting or to ‘sand’,
casting. UE ee ‘i ee
**15,.. The Jungersen method of ease reproduces
intricate .pieces having undercuts, hollows and per-
forations without loss of detail and in exact duplica-
‘tion in any number, and reduces to an absolute mini-
-mium the skilled labor necessary to a finished product.
.
- the: New York case, J udge
sol he found (Finding y 5: 45, f. 135): °
fr . : : ° . °
if :
- °
bag” Deinonstration and commercial SUCCESS at st
‘to the success, of. the Jungersen method ot elry’
casting. ‘Such ise : resulting in the repro ele
to the finest detail of. intricate pieces of y elry, are
_.the first to be completely ‘satisfactory, and result. from:
the- combination of steps described inthe, Junge: rsen
seen
ifkind said’ (30, £ 4h): ;
** Today cuttlefish eating and sand ceasting are ot:
‘little commercial Significance. Die stamping and the +
‘lost_ wax? process are pre-eminent: in thre production,
> Of rings. ‘ o
“*The evidencé clearly supports a ealidliae that t, after
Jungersen, the lost wax process. as refined by inn bein
been extensively empltoved’ in’ .the manufacture of
——-——tngs; ; and | shall therefore er to the patent
‘commercial. success,” 72° - piace
“5, Since the introductior into the jewelry frade of;
the Jungersen : process, cuttlefish ca asting and sand —
-easting are of little commercial significance. Die
stamping and. the. process of the Jur¢ersen patent
are the only substantial methods now commercially
used in” the production—of—jewelry. “His process, as’
described and claimed in the patent in suit, has been
extensively employed in the- manufacture of jewelry 7
and is entitled to the attribute of commercial sue-
9% ~
cess.’” ae
- a }
Early Applications i in the Fine. Arts o — 4
the “Lost Wax” Process. | Res
s
The Orig in the fine arts of tha casting’ of bronze by
the *‘iost wax’ * process is obscured in the mists-of antiquity,
ae
It is-said to have been described by the monk Theophilus -
(Encyclopedia Britannic a, k4th Ed; Vol. 4. 248). The ree-.,
ords here-include a. nambe Y of extracts from the sixteenth
century / treatises ’ of Benvenuto Cellipi’ on **Goldsmithing
and Setlpture’’ (1h 448a-469a). “Several applications of
the process are deseribed; The deseription is’ vivid and
fascinating, but not too, easy to: follow. Conece ntrating,
however, on the several ways in which Cellini produced his
wax models .or- patter ns, we can: identify the following pro-
-Onmren : at | :
é ¢
" :
(1) Describing a unique silver vase he made for Francis
I, he explains the painstaking handw ork by whieh the body
of the vase was produced and says (450a): as. “After this
you may -proceed to fashion in wax whatever graces may
have place at lip ar handle,- improving. ‘on ‘the model. or
design with whieh you started”’. “These wax ‘graces’ =
modeled by -hand were reproduced: in metal. by investing
thenrin-a mixtnre-of pulverized: earth; fine ctoth shearing ae
and: ‘‘a little cows’ dung,. sifted. through a sieve, then. I
heat it all well together’’.: After painting - the wax orna-
ments witli a pigment made from tripoli and. adding inlet:
_ holes and vent chanrels, he proceeded with the investment,
heated the investment te. melt the wax and let it run out
. through the vent holes and finally east’ the molten silver.
into the cavity. In this cise the first. part of the invest-
ment was formed -about the “*oraces”’ _while_.they were
still upon the vase, thus making a ‘hollow mold portion like
an intaglio; after melting out the wax the investment was -.
remoy ‘a from ‘the vase and the opening. where the wax
4”
had, Aeen attached tothe vase was closéd up: with the in-
vestinent material (40 AOa-451a). When s‘you have. oe
And suchlike coneéeits to apply to -your -vase'’’ (442a),
f somewhat diferent procedure was followed. After fashion.
ing them care fully in wax, they avere taken off the vase
and molds. ‘made of* them by investment and. baking to
:
— —— ¢
. . 5
P ; ye a .
/ re = ¢ 7
‘* Zee Appendix, 7) fon *
-
ee eee
remove the wax. Then a coating of wax, ‘ta thin knife's
back more or less in thickness, or of such thickness as you
wish your mask to be’’, was laid into the hollow of the’
mold equally all over, the channels*and ventholes added
and the whole filled with clay, bound ‘around with wire,
‘and cast in the saine‘way as before. The cavity was, df
course, the space left between the- hollow mold portions
‘and the clay core by. melting out the thin layer of wax.
In another place (455a), Cellini describes how he made
‘‘the Perseus for the most illustrious Duke Cosimo’’. This
large figure -was first modeled in a clay composition and
finished ‘‘one finger’s thickness under actual size’’, baked
-and modeled over with a coat of wax. -He' then coats
his waxed figure with certain unguents, and with two or ,
_* three coats of clay. to form his investment, and then he
says “‘I cast it’? (455a, ff. 1363-4). Presumably before
made (454a).” Then he makes a gesso mold of ‘‘as many
small pieces as when put together would make. a complete
man, and that without any uhdercutting—as ‘for instance
feet, hands, head’’ -(456a, f. {366). Over ‘these built-up
-. small pieces, he forms a ‘mother mold’? in two or tore
pieces depending on the size of .the figure’ (457a-458a).
Then after all of the little pieces have been fitted into the
mother mold, he coats the inside of the mold with ‘‘about
a good knife’s back thick of wax or clay or paste’’, which’
. he-said-is technically termed the-lasagna. Part of the
|. remaining description is not too clear but, as’ we under-
**Plaster of Paris or gypsum as prepared for painting ‘or in
making. bas-relief” ; Webster. _. eager s
°° ‘ Lhe
stand it, he then builds over an iron frame a clay core :
which fits accurate ‘ly within the mold, heing spaced there-
frdim by the “thickness of the lasagna: ‘The [asagna is then
rel oved, and he Says
pour your wax and -fit the kernel into the mold;
then stand the figure up straight make at Jeast ‘four
vent holes, two at the feet and two at the hands, the 7
more’ vouanake the suref you will be to fill your. figure
with wax’’ (459a, f. 1876).
‘The heated wax ig thet poured into the cavity between the
gesso mold and the core (460a). After the wax has stood
for a day or two to harden or shrink a little, the mold
is opened and the wax pattern nicely polistied to rémove-
all the rough edges Ieft by the joinings of all the different
__+_pieees and-te- touch up the whole. ‘In doing this, morever,
_ the whole to melt it out, and the molten bronze cast into »
‘if you oh apie to add any subtle labor or fancy to your:
work you dre easily able to do it’’ (460a). After this, the.
avax pattern was invested, the wax removed by heating
- the eavity left ‘py. the removal of the wax. By this method
——$——
Cellini’ was able ‘to preserve his original model, which he
says enables you to work to great-advantage because
elie: IB aan
———
“many youths & able workmen can help } you clean the
bronze figure up, while if you have-no model to work.
to, this cleaning up takes a long time, is little to the
poor master’s liking, and has but a sorry result’ |
(454a, f. 1362).
The record also includes a translation of “La Geavine’ a
ete., published in Paris in 1924.” After deseribing. plaster
‘molding, tle author says (470a, f. 1409): -
: “The. moulding of pieces which are not stripped or
ofa full relief piece, is. more. difficult; it is even, in
certain cases, impractieable i in plaster, ‘and we use flex-
/ ible materials —_ as gelatin.”
‘Then you make the inlet Holes in alia you a to -
ma
\
16.
f eno, . << a
The gelatin molds are said to be “perfectly lasting’? and
‘plaster, wax or gylatin may be poured into. it hot without
fear of destroying it, eee Ty making the molds, the
usual practig¢e of forming two separable shells,is followed
~ and vent holes are provided by placing along the meeting
edges ‘seve ‘al grains of lead which, withdrawn frou the
mold, ‘will fonm the corresponding number of cavities.serv-
"ing as vent Holes wlien the wax. or gelatin of the repro-—
ductions are ¢ast’’. . This gelatin ‘mold -is described at’
* 47Ta-479a and the author says: mF AOE i ae
‘the principal advantage is the: obtaining of w res .
in every way, similar to the model and which, cast in
cire perdue* give perfect reproductions altnost with-
out retouching.
' *“Gire perdue, literally ‘lost wax’ is known i this
name. See Encyclopoedia Britannica, 14° Kad, x ol. 20,
P. 229”. : 3 a
The: sett describes: (475a) how in the ‘‘lost Ww wis pee
ess the wax model is removed by heat ‘and s says that for
‘*small pieces of jewelry *.* *. It is then preferable. to cast
the piece ‘in gelatin, to take several proofs of it in wax”
and to go on with the investment and removal of the wax
by heating. Metal is then poured’ into the investinent and
a cover ‘*full of moist clay or containing moistened
asbestos’, is pressed strongly ‘down over the top of the-in-
vestment and ‘the heat from the metak causeswiolent emis-
sion of steam which presses the fluid material into all the
‘interstices. of the mould’’ (II, 475a, f. 1425).
The Encyclopedia Britannica article on‘ the tire perdue
process (14 Ed., Vol. 20, p. 229) referred to-in this ‘*La .
Gravure,’ ‘publication is reprinted as an appendix to this:
‘brief. It describes briefly .but clearly, the forination of a
negative mold which is then lined with a coating of melted .
wax\ applied with a brush until it has aciyuired- sufficient
— to produce a replica of the seupptare | in wax
-
.
(ue
ay hone 9
_sufficiently. hard to permit handling.. It says that the.
“artist ¢: an work on it as much as he pleases, obtaining ~~.
rare results of details which makes this process of: casting
invaluable. “Gates and vents in the shape of wax rods are
then properly attached to the wax figure’. T he wax figure *
with the attached gates and vents is: then inv ested, the wax .
melted out and the molten bronze poured into the prepa ed
cavity.” ei eta ee
cae |
‘inate dsactiption’s ‘of the use of the ‘‘lost. wax’ ’ process :
in art casting is found in the. 1980 publication ‘‘ Diecasting
Practice’? .by Mare Stern (482a). It does not, differ: in
any significant wavy f remy W what has already been discussed:
‘The original hollow Ts s made of plaster or glue. It is
then closed and filled with “molten wax whic he after .a few —
seconds is poured out again, leaxing a wax shell over the
‘surface of the mold of a thickness in proportion to the size
of. the work. The hollow wax pattern-thus | produced is re-
nioved. from the inold ‘*So that. the’ sculptor: may supply any. . .
finishing touches or alterations deemed Advisable. The gates ©
and vents are. then added at suitable points in, the formof,
wax rods of different diameters’ * <The wax pattern is
‘ then invested ina mixture of plaster of Paris, clay a and as-.
* bestos fiber, the wax melted: out, and finally the molten
‘ bronze is a inte the mold cavity. 3 -
The Use ¥ the “Lost Wax" Process in Dentistry
The record does. not ‘ laee any specific douistaticin of .
the making of the original wax. pattern in. dentistry, but
there is,.of cotitse, no building up of a mold into which w ae
ds introduced in a molter state; since the wax pattern is .
_- idles Cc lark, in the Court of: Aiaals opinion jn Case 48, refets at
“iso to another article in the Encyclopedia Britannica, (Vol.,g, 44th ~
: Ed., 240) which we likewise reproduce. This: is.a brief and some:
what generalized description of that’ procedure ’ which: Celtini seems .
to. have uséd in m sett his Perseus and, which: we have already -
,
, discussed. er a ae ; | *
y i
aol
—_—
‘ |
Haseltine’ s British Patent Mo. 2467, of 1875 ( 436)
“™
a casting in metal from a given pattern, which casting
will be a peffect copy of such: pattern without requir-
ing- much, if any, after finishing. or ehiselling: work’’
: é (4280734, sina et ot a ee
ss
on
arte produee ‘such patterns of wax or Siniilar fi material
they are, cast. within pattern moulds. or matrices of |
gum elastic, which pattern moulds’ ‘are first” formed ~
onan original model and removed therefrom by slitting .
and: stretching. The wax patterns are removed from
a made by pressing wae wax into the troublesome cavity
in the, patient’s- inouth. ‘The wax pattern with gate and’
“veiits atta ched is covered with the investment. compound
_—in a small bucket’’ -(485a, f. 1453). ‘The wax as ‘‘lost’’
’ . by heating, and the molten gold « or alloy is.cast into the —
— — cavity ‘by . centrifugal casting (485a).
“This British patent of 1875 adds vuleanized rubber to
‘the list of mold-f orming materials. suitable for making the
primary mold in the “‘lost wax’ ‘procedure.
2
“The main * ohicet of this Invention: is to produce -
the matrices in.the same way and are then used for
» forming the pérmanent clay moulds’’ (429a/8- 13).
.
*
* .* ee Ry: wy.
4 j
‘“‘The said Invention is not restricted to any shape
‘or form of pattern. It avoids the slow and laborious
‘be of such a shape as to
se cores if the object to be ‘cast
essitate the.forming of the
If: - a figure
process. of making
mould in several pieces, as:
or statuette’’ (429a/ 18- 2h).
x
: a,
° &
‘ . . ¢
e% °
4
«
mt
The molds are formed by building up pe ut the mold’
a coating -of rubber “‘about.a quarter of an inch*’ thick
_ by erin of abit layers of Tubber in the form of
ih ;
SY nit the removal of the model’* (43ta-432a), The cuts are
9
"thin sheets: “about 1/32 of an inch thick’', The thickness
of ‘the coating may be. varied aecording’ to the size of the
article. ‘*What is to-be obtained is a thickness of rubber
Ww hic ‘h will retain sts shape after_vulcanizing and bear its
own weight | without collapsing the’ elastic mould”, (431la). ».
The ‘mold is then vuleanized “under: pressure, and. after
vulcanization ‘“‘the rubber is-cut in such away as to per-
rejoined by applying to them a thin rubber solution
: a/20-21). This introduction of the wax is.
effected as: f ollews: ;
“#4 Phen 2. rubber fbuld is euspeied- in cold ‘water
‘for the purpose of cooling: the wax and retaining the
rybber mould in shape.- Then theanelted wax is poured,
slowly into-the rubber mould’ at the-opening cut for
oe “that purpose until full. If the ‘abject is of. such a
nature as to be hollow when cast in metal the surplus
“wax is poured out as soon as the wax has formed a
8) and an opening is cut for the introduction
shell by. cooling on the sides first. When the wax» :
-has fully cooled in-the rubber mould, which: cooling
- takes place in a few minutes, according to the tem-~
perature. the mould is removed from the water, and |
at the place where. the joint is in the ‘Tubber mould a
the sdid mould is easily torn apart, and may be readily
~remoxed_ from the wax pattern without injyring the
" finest parts thereof oy (432a/28-38). Ate
“The aubsequent investing of ‘the wax pattern, i losing”
of the wax, and casting of the molten metal into the cavity
in the investment, are similar to what has been described—
already with this difference, th. t_ Haseltine introduces the
molten metal into the ae. cone pressure of ~
a column of the molten inetal in a standpipe (II, 430a/9- -
17): He constructs.the furnace so ‘‘as to give a pressure
of about 20 -pounds to the basse * inch’* (II, — 10).
a
So :
dl ~
20 a
e
a
fiascltine. explains the ne#d for the use of pryssute: im.
casting the molten, metal as follows’: * : at:
‘In order to produce a mould sufficiently porous to
permit the escape of the gases generated, together
_ with the air in the mould, and to permit the metal to.
lie closely to the surface of. the mould after pouring,
_ it has been customary in casting refractory metals to
_employ for the material of the moulds a coarse loam —
or sand and te pack it somewhat loosely. within the
flask. . 7
One ebfect of the present Invention is my perniit ‘the ;
use of a’ more compaéf and fine loam for the moulds, °
_ and of a very fine facing material to produce the sur-
‘faee or portion of the ifietal which comes in direct con-
tact with the pattern’’ (II, 429a,/22-31) and
Mito will be manifest to those skilled in the art‘that
the use of: a dense material for moulds necessitates -
the. ‘adoption ‘of some mode of* introducing : a metal
other than the simple mode of pouring it from a “pot
-or ladie”’ (i, rennin ne ae
-?
9.
| lhecssaicle Patent No. 748,996, of 1904 (II, 400a)
Spencer is concerned primarily with improvement - of
the built- “up. rubber mold whieh he says may be ‘used to
make duplicates in wax or other suitable material of the
original pattern” (405a/76-79), as in-the ‘‘lost wax’’ proc-
‘ess. As in Haseltine’s British patent of 1875 the. only
| procedure suggested. for getting the wax into the primary
mold i is by pouring it in,
~~.
In preparing his -rubber mold: for filling, Spencer says
that (410a/41-46) :
ha “°° * it should uate any number ‘of small ~vent- holes
pierced ‘throagh” it that. may -be found: necessary ‘to
allow for the escape.of air in any space where it would
“he inclined to collect when the mold is being filléd with
3 , the composition’ used in. making the reprodtetion. sets
1
’ ° i 7 : : &
_ . As to getting the wax into the rubb& figld, Spencer
says (410a/69°76): ° , it os.
; ee PGGEEAP ©
‘the reproduction: is nade ‘by pouring: its the mold
the matérial G, Fig: 7, desiréd either in-a liquid,
in a plastic condition, - he worked ‘in by hand if the
form of the mold will permit it, or if the mold will
‘not permit of the hand being, used_in filling it ‘then.
it may be filled by any other suitable means.” ved
_Kralund’s Patent 1,238,789 of 1917 (414a) |
- Kralund discloses a very special application of the ‘lost
_{Wax"” process to the production of commercial eastihys of
*-Yarge bulk: by ‘the ‘pressure: die-casting profess’’. Thie
pressure die-casting .process is a modern: technique for
__quaritity production.of identical .replicas of a given mode!
or, pattern, based wpon the yse of metal molds into which
the pattern is cut (sunk) by machine tovling.. These costly
machined metal dies ate used over’and over again, distin-_
guishing die-casting from casting. methods in which ‘the |
mold is destroyed after each casting operation. (‘*Die-
- easting Praetice’’, Mare Stern; 478a, f. 1433 and 48%a,
- 1466.) Kralund explains that when pressure die castings |
are made of high fusing’ metals, there, is rapid destruction*
of ‘the metal mold er die from the high temperatures so
_ that economically speaking ‘‘the pressufe die process is
limited to the production of comparatively small castings
.
** *T refer to those castings, the weight of which is from
tw; to three pounds or less” (414a; 1/40-52). By his
thethod. he proposes *‘to produce castings of larger bulk
than.is possible with the pressure die-casting process”
while avoiding “the wastage due to the destruction of ‘the -
- * die from the high temperatures of the metal used in making ~
the casting * * *"" (I. 5464). He says he secures the desired
result ‘by the use in rotation of certain steps and prac--
tices, some of which are old and weil known in the art. of
: , _° \.
seii-liquid or fused state¢ or the material may, if. ”
©
yo
-mnaitehanae dental inlavs, the method or art of liv Invention
differing from those heretofore practiced ‘in that the basis
_of the method or art of my invention is the production of
-a large number of patterns by the pressure, die casting
Process . and in a steel mold * * *"* (iL+70-78) w hile at the
same time avoiding, the delet térious effect of. high tempera-
tures whieh occurs when the pressure die casting process —
is applied to large castings. “ He points’ out that the difii-
cult conditiohs “accompanying the making of larger cast.
ings by the pressure die-casting process do not, oceur in,
the making df-dental ®milays and similar articles. He says
- (415a; 2- 17): '
Tn the. production of - ntal inlays and ‘in the produc
tion of similar articles whereby only one article is re-
~ quired; the conditions above. referred tg do not enter
into the method. It is merely necess@®\ to approxis
niaté the dimensions required in the e: asting and ie
are no cores or obstructions to be taken ‘into cor
Sideration.. In fact none of, the conditions. found in
the dental art are present in the art of making ‘COM
mercial castings for machine parts used in different
‘mechanisms. The natyre of the product is different _
and the metals used in the commercial casting art rah
- entirely different. characteristics. from. those" used i
the dental art. ”
He. dvoids the wastage due to the destruction of the <teel
dies by the higher temperature of: the metal in large bulk
hy applying the “lost wax’”’ procedure 1 in pres ssure die cast-_:
ing with steel molds. Un this way, the original steel die is
subjected onty to-the temperature of the wax and not to the
* high temperature of the cast metal. The wax is forced into
“the steel mold under the high pressure charaeteristic of the
/ pressure die-casting process, the die having been ** provided
“with, the usual vents’’ (415a/72). The purpose of the,
pressure is to give the wax pattern ‘'a spiliciently hard
surface to perinit its handling in Inaking. the plastie mold
* » set Re A) eae
© id
%
23
Ameen, 7 sh ne e .
and in finishing.the pattern prior to the making of the said -
plaster wiohd. This finishing consists mainfy in removing.
any fins at the lime of de rom cation , hetween the mold See-
lions or at the vent ope nings therein’’ (415a/77-83). See
also other, references to the Hints hing of the. wax pattern
~(4142/99- 104 and 416a/4- 9)...
When-the final plaster mold has been complete ‘d by hak-
ing the investment, he no longer uses the high pressure
of the ‘pressure die- casting process to cast,the metal into
, that piaster mold; but introduces the inoltes me tal. into
* the baked’ investment mold ‘by means of a pressure die-
fasting apparatus in whieh metal is yeast under Very low
pressures, the ordinary die-casting method of die pressures.
being inprac ‘ticahle with a mold as fragile as the one above
referred to.”’ "_4405a/114- 119). - He savs that with this >
method Tf is ‘commercially, practice ible’’ to produce’ cast-
mes er eo sueh castings are of sufficiently great
bulk. The method, ‘however, is: not particularly adaptable |
to the production of small eastings by re ason of the rela--
tively greater expense as compared with a pressure die
asting.’’ (415a/128.4162/3).. He ends iis’ specifications:
by: saying that it is aot his ‘‘intention to claim broadly the
unaking of a plaster mold about a-fusible pattern and the -
evacuation of. said mold by. subjeeting it, and the pattern
> therein contained, ‘te a temperature which will fuse. the
pattern. “What I desire to claim, is a method -utilizing
these old practices, and in conjunction therewith the domi-.
nant and essential step of preparing ‘the pattern in a inetal
mold, which step is essential in the — of commer-_
celal castings wiry (416a; 30-52).
~
McManus Patent No. 1 ,457,040, of 1923. ( 417)
bh his patent discloses an improvement in centrifugal
casting machines. Since centrifugal gasting of molten metal -
into investment. molds is conceded to have been common
practice in dentistry’ long before | MeMfungs’ patent, the
, . : y : os 24 | ext
outs part of his disclosure we néed direct attention to is
“the following statement (418a/17 32): :
“While the: macliine. iHustrated in ‘this applic ation
and those illustrated in my former patents have been
designed more with a view to their utilization in con-
-nection with the making of dental castings, sue has for.
inlays, crowns, bridges, porcelain work, ete., the samr -
principle, with slight modifications in the structure of
the ‘apparatus, may be equally as well applied ‘to, the
.castiig of jewelry, suchas gold rings, small trinkets,
ete., where metal or other dies or moulds may be ng
to be filled by centrifugal casting mtethods, and,
course, if larger scale. operations are desired, maitable
modifications in design will readily adapt the appara- .
tus to-such purposes.’
MeManus discloses nothing about how to make initial
molds tor intricate. patterns or spite to‘get wax into such a -
- mold. ; | -
Specifications of Errors e
In case No.7, the errors urged ave that the. Cireuit
Court: of Appeals for the Third Circuit erred { Petition,
No, 467, 1947 October Term, pp, 14- 13) ;
1. In failing to hold claims 5 and 6. of the Fungersen
patent in suit valid,
2. In failing properly to interpret claims 5 and 6 on s
‘the ~— of the ‘disclosure in the specification,
‘Incase No. 48, the errors urged are that tlie- ‘Gireuit :
_ Court of- Appeals for the Second Cireuit er red (Besition
776, 1947. October Term, pp. 3-4) :
1. In failing to hold claims 1-6 inclusive valid.
2 05 holding elainis 1-5 inclusive invalid for want of
‘invention.
3. in holding: claim 6 invalid for lack of ‘nov eltv.
4. In- afirniing the, jitigment of the district court.
Oo
4 , dF ;
ARGUMENT | ee
a * Despite a long-felt wens which had existed unsatisfied
for many ‘many years, Jungersen’s methdd in its entirety
had never been assembled before. Its production by him
was a substantial—even revolutionary—technical innova-
tion, for which society is ‘truly indebted to him. The test-of
history, as it.appears from the record, conclusively proves
that Jungersen’s forward step was not obvious; that it did
require more angemnimty than thé work of a mechanic skilled
in the art. . ;
II. The lneiiina claims 5 and 6 can be and should be so
construed as to embrate but not to extend beyond what.
Jungersen truly invented; the new method specifically de-
scribed when--practiced with the substitution of known
equivalents for some of the steps particularly~defined in
narrower terms in claims 1 to 4. When so construed, -claims
5 and 6 are infringed by the low pressure injection of the.
melted wax into built-up soft. metal molds by the. force of a_
syringe or the like, sometimes substituted for. centrifugal
force by the alleged infringers.
The making of small articles of jewelry of intricate de-
tail with hollows, undercut portions and perforations runs.
back to the earliest times of recorded history.’ in the fine
arts, the casting -of bronze by the ‘‘lost wax” casting °
process also emerges from prehistoric times. The fascinat-
ing sixteenth century manuscripts of Benvenuto. Cettini-~
disclose a number of ingenious and skillful. applications of’.
- the ‘lost wax”’ process by that master craftsman; but not-
its extension to. the: field- opened up by Jungersen—the
repetitive : production of small metal articles of jewelry of.
intricate detail, designed with hollows; undercut portions
and perforations. : , ws
The bafic tools employed by Jungersen ‘in 1933 were
available to Cellini and his confreres 400 vears ago. .The
‘ ) ———_—
a
\
making of the wax model, its investiture, the evacuation:
of the investiture, and Sib casting of the metal into the
: dispe isable mold, were studio: tools in the process of cast-
ing bronze and precious metals. The building up, about
‘the meidel of a primary mold of glue or gelatin was also
known ‘and, With the-advent of vuleanized rubber; that ma-
_ terial was employed for the purpose, as’ disciosed “in the
Haseltine British patent more than half ‘a century before
Jungersen, and again, more than a quarter of a century
‘before Jungersen in Spencer’ s United States patent. The
casting. of precious metals into. itivestment molds “by
centrifugal force has béen practiced in the dental art at
least since the beginning: of this eentury and, in MyManus
“patent: 1,457,040 of 1923, the use of cenfrifugat foree_to
cast molten metal ‘into “metal. or other dies or. molds”’
> to produce ‘ ‘castings of jewelry, such as gold rings, small
‘trinkets, ete.’’, is proposed: Yet such small articles” of:
jewelry continu€d, as the record shows, to be manufac*
~~ tured erty, by handeraft er by die-stamping or by the two
primitive and inadequate casting. nethods, cuttle fish cast-
ing and sand casting, which were incapable of producing
more than a ‘“Geenmny?”? that had to be finished by skilled
artisans. . The diffictilties lay in the inability te establish
and fo maintain through the successive steps of the casté
ing process the intricate detail, with hollows, underetits and
"perforations. | - Jungersen overcame those difficulties and
“revolutionized the procedure in the commercial manufac.
ture of such articles by, his ‘six-step process, and partien-
larly by building up about the first model.a primary mold
_of plastic mold-forming material such as rubber and then
projecting the wax into the fine interstices of the rubber
‘mold by centrifugal force. med
a
a
~The résult: was 4 procedure which rendered, ‘chsolete the
old casting. procésses used in the manufacture of jewelry,
‘and even encroached ‘upon, the old die- stamping process;
extending the art. into the .production of intricacies of de-
sign which cannot ‘be fashioned by. die-stamping, and re-~
ducing the cost wherever, even in —_— designs, the
27 me
quantity of finished articles to be produced ix insufficient
to offset the relatmwety high cost of fhe stamping dies. The
art now has a commercial practicable inechod of casting:
articles which formerly could not bg repetitively, produced
-at all or could he produced in quantity only with the help
of skifled artisans. at substantially vreater expense.
t
Her e is the nub of the ease: There is no dehatable Tale
of law involved. > It is conceded tliat mere absence of
anticipation-——inere novelty alone—-is not enough; that the
subject matter must display invention; more inge nuity
than the work of a mechanie skilled. in the art. The ap-
plication ot that long-established rule-in partic ilar ¢ases
rests in each case, upon. a finding of ultimate fact. The
‘concurrent findings of the lower courts agree as a matter
of fact, that there was the long-felt want unsatisfied for
many, many years;.that with all the prior knowledge of
the men -skilled in the art, they had not gone beyond the
use of the inadequate methods: ‘od vuttle fish casting and
sand casting in’ the production of these intricate articles
of jewelry until Jungersen came forward, and that when
‘“Jungersen did bring his method’ into public know wage it
~ quickly superseded the old casting processes ‘and, as is
usually. the case with such technological icesbattann ‘tee
surpassed their possibilities: Mm intricacy. of detail and =o
eneroached economically: upon the manufacture of such,
articles by die stamping -while extending the manufactur-
ing. possibilities into more refined and. extensive’ fields.
“On this evidence, the factual conclusion must be, we sub-
mit, that Jungersen’s forward step was not obvious and
that it did require more ingemuity than the work of 4
mechanic skilled in the art. ;
‘The validity of the patent should therefore be sustained
unless ‘there ‘is now unearthed in this or in some 6ther
related art.an anticipation of Jungersen’s methods ¢ some:
> thing an whiels the Court can‘say that Jungersen’s method
Was not new; something. of which a jew eler grappling with |
the problem solved by Jungersen, and havi ing: no » know!
edge of Jungersen’s method, wontd say, if his attention
- were directed to ‘it, “That gilyes me what’ wish'’.* .
It is clear that there
fx no such anticipation of Junger-
sen’s method. ee: a |
° er aes
mt
It seents fo ‘us that the nearest approximation to it is,
the, procedure disclosed in British: patent of 1875 to Hasel-”
| tine-or equivalently in the United States patent of 1904
to Spencer. This was recognized by Jungersen in his
British patent where he said (495a/1-19-28):
‘In the casting of metal it i8 not broadly new to
make an elastic mould from an original sample or
“model, to: produce a wax or fusible pattern with the
aid of the elastic anould and to remove the pattern -
from the latter and invest it in a final. mould from
which the wax or fusible pattern is subsequently
melted out to permit of the pouring of met tal. into
the mould’ cavity thus vacated.” | ee
awe ~~
t
And the claims of Jungersen’s British patent were
_ distinguished from that -prior ‘knowledge by. defining. a |
method (496a/112-121) ‘‘characterized by the. centrifugal
_easting of a model of wax or other readily- fusible material
within a flexible, mould which has been prepared from an
original model or sainple, effectively.to displace the air
‘the mould cavity and force the model,forming material
intimately into <all the i and/or pattern forming
recesses of the cavity ‘surface’ : :
ww
' Upon rejection of this spoliontind by ‘the British P atent
. Office, an appeal was taken to the Patents Appeal Tribunal”
of the Royak,Courts of Justice. “Judgment or that anpéal,
an favor of Jungersen, was given by Mr. Justice: Luxmoore
(508a-5t3a}.— In his judgment, Justice bLuxmoore said,
‘The point I think is really in a smajt tompass*’ (509a, f.
iets ee | ‘ ep
* Skelly Oil Co. v. Universal Oil Products Co., 31 Fy 2d, 427, 431.
# - em . omy * eis
126): and, alter reviewing the testimony of expert wit- 2 .
nesses (S10a-912a), b eeoncluded : i‘ as as
“Mr. Cousin in his: decision says’ at pase 7: TE is.
agreed: that on the evidence there is no, dise dosure of
the casting Ot the wax or like model. in- at flexible’ mould
in a centrifugal: ‘“usting machine.’ Then he goes on’
tosay: This step forms the invention of ‘the applic ant's
claim 1, and the question before me ts whether sueli
‘use of a ce ntrifugal casting machine inl carrying aut
one step of an admittedly known sequence: constitutes
an inventive gtep fo justify the xrant ‘of letters patent,
“The real question is whether, that is an obvious step
or not. The evidence shows clearly that. there was a. -
long- felt want ‘for a method of casting artic ‘les. Of the”
particular nature which eat. de produce ed. by this, is *
vention: that in spite of the long-felt want, the welts
tien _te-the-difticatty was not found,until. Mr. Junger-
sen’s invention was made. In those. circumstances |
think it wold: che impossible for ine to hold that the
3
step is gbvious’. ( on: 2a; ff. 1535- 6). ane
°
-
Here is-a concise statement of the basie issue now pre-
sented to this Court, arid we ‘sybmit that Mr. Justice Lux-
moore: < disposition of it was the correct one. - Pre
In, this Court.there is auple authorits, extending over all
the years of our-own patent system, for finding: patentable
invention asx an ultimate fact-where- the evidence estab-.
__lishes, as an historical fact of industrial technology, such
a series of eve nts as those proven: in 1 this Jungersen case."
2 .
“+ Universal Oil Pr oducts Co.w. Globe etc. Co, 322 v. S. 471,
486; Geedyear, ete. (o v. Ray-O-Vae Cé., 324 U. S. 275. 279; Para-
-mount Publix C ‘orp. Amer, Trek "gon Corp., “ey U.S. 464, 474; °
Hibel Process’ Ga NV Minne sotdecte 261 U.S. 45,68; ‘Hildreth °-
v. Mastoras, 257-U. $..27, 34-3; ‘Piyanded i Metal Co: v. Bradford,
-214 ©. S...366, S81; Carnegie Steel Co. v. Cambria ete- Co. 185
U.S. 403, 429- 30, 446: Potts v vr. 188 U: S..597, 008; Key-
* stone Mig. Co. vi: Adams, 131 i}. 139, 144-5 ; Krements v. Cottle,
148 U.S. 556, 500: os | pte Co. Vv Crosby Vale Co, 1s -:
US, 187,179; Loom Co. v Higgins, 105 U.S. 580, 591; Smith vy wee
Goodyear ete. Co., 93 U S: 486, _ 6. -
% a e
°
’
e et
We submit also that, as & matter of wise: public poliey,
where the established facts, as in- ‘the instant CASO, me lose
without. dawbt or equivocation the long existence of ‘the
_ unsatisfied want, the persistent‘adherence of those skilled ;
in the art to other and inferior practices, and the final
-abrupt shifting of the practical technology to new ranges
of. usetulness upen the introduction of the patented pro:
cedure ; then there is: no conclusion more consonant with
the basic purpose of ‘the patent law, than the conclusion
that patentable invention exists, ee ea a :
In such cases there is, of course, alw ‘ays ‘the temptation
-to wonder why the: minds of earlier workers in the Jart did
not arrive by a mere process-of Téasoning at the patented
_ solution tis a trite and familiar remark that probletis -
once solved present no difficulties. Indeed, to proteét our
advancing technology against unjustified and therefore
burdensome nionopolies, it is always necessary to ask
Whether the patented procedure was more than the naty ral
- step-by-step progress of: improved technique among. the
body of skilled. workers in the art; whether it was, on the,
one hand, such a step-by-step ‘advance. or, on the. other’
hand, & leap ahead achieved by the intuitive and créative
faculties of the mind; oy :
_ @
But thy record in this case leaves no doubt about the
answer Ao. that question. Here the technology. of 1933
chens “a6 advance. certainly since Haseltine in 1875; and
really no fundamental change’ since Cellini. © The hasie
purpose of our laws being not so much te reward the
individual as to bring to the public those benefits which
arise from progress in science and useful arts, it is wholly
in accord with the best practice of that patent system to.
” give controlling -weight to histerical evidence w hich shows
the long period of standing still followed by an abrupt and
marked advance, rather ‘than to speculations about the
mental hazards or . the apparent astigmatism of the
men skilled:in. the art; which tay now seem difficult to ex-
Me as aa ee peur
a)
plain, but whieh in fact kept them from taking the step
ahead. (See, |
W hile the “benefit: to the public fies in the advancetie ‘pt
of the arts and se lences rather than in the reward to thie
individual, vet it is the offer of the limited - patent monope ly
which is the inducement to the individual to disclose
innovation and to bring. it * promptly wither Ach. of thie
public. The instant, Gase - shows clearly dhe beneficent:
effect. of that inducement. Jungersen’s process is of (a
naturé that would lend itself very. well to séeret practice.
It would have been well within the possibilities for him to
earry on his proéess in sec rh to his sole cominefcial ad.
tantage, since the finishe product does not disclose the
‘nature ofthe Process , by which it was produced (¢C f. Judge
Meaney’s discussion of the asserted, now withdrawn, prior
“use by Slatis, 27a-28a, ff. 80-84), Jungersen did not follow
that plan. . He immediately disclosed his process to others,
applied for patents on. it afl over the world, participated”
actively in making the new method available to the public,
and sought ‘his reward under our patent system by the -
collection of reasonable license fees from any ard all manu-
factirers who wanted to use his method. He. responded
to the incentive of the patent system and payed its price of.
- dise losure to the manifest advancement of the useful arts
“and prompt benefit to’ the publig.
Judge Meaney in his decision now under réview in -
Caxeg. Nox. 7 and 8: (22a-3 Ya), held that ‘‘ Insofar as claims
1 and 4 are concerned, in the view of the court, the Junger-
sen patent. discloses that ‘flash of ¢ reative genius’ sufficient
to provide: the basis of patentability, and it-is so argu-
ment Yor invalidity to" assert that the use_of centrifugal
,
saliaeatialie the same thing * (26a-27a). As we td
already noted, .Jadge Meaney’ <-conelusions “were affirmed
“by the Third Cireuit, Court of Appeals in a per curiam
opinion, :
_ 32
In Case No; 48, Judge Learned Hand in his dissenting
| ‘opinion (216-219), after_revie ‘wing the prior knowledge :in
the art; said.( 217, f : 690):
g
=
"Nevertheless, in: spite ‘of all these approaches, ‘and |
“ the fact that all the" eleme ‘nts of the dixelosure were
» be found jn the prior art, it remains true that
parte process in its entirety had never been
assembled before; no one had -éver oS com. ”
bining all those steps ina —ee aoqpince. 7
ae and (218, ff. 652- 654) 3 ;
Be In the case at ‘bar ‘the answer inant eae eee depend
_on how -we shall appraise thé departure ftom what had
gone before in terms of creative imagination ; indeed, |
I dé not understand what other test could be relevant.’
**If that: be the test, L submit ‘that Jungersen’s
process meets it. From fitne immemorial. jewelry had -
been manufactured by the earlier ‘processes; so that
the .need, if need there was, had ‘existed for vears.-
Moreover, two of those. earlier -processes— cuttlefish
casting’ dnd ‘sand easting have i how become ‘of little,
commercial rignificarice”; : ‘die-stamping’ and Junger-_
sen’s ‘process . ‘are the only substantial: methods: now
.- commercially used’; and in the manufacture of a hun-
‘ dred rings .or less ‘die-stamping’ ‘is more expensive.’ .
Had some technological advance held up the change,
and had Jungersen made it only a sbort time after the
obstaele had heen removed, I should agree that'the _.
inference of outstanding originality would have been
greatly weakened; but that was not the fact. Indeed,
it is the very basis of the defence that for years all”
‘the elements lay open and available, and that nothing
was needed, but the paltry modification which has)
proved so fruitful... Po that 1 make the answer on *
Whieh courts inthe past used to ring the ¢ hanges with
-. Wearisome iteration, -[f-all the information was at,
} p , . i ”
.
ft
‘hand, why was the new adadhisitien so long delaved?
What better test off invention cam one-ask thin te:
_ detection vot that. which others had all along had i
strong inve ntive* to discover; but had failed to see,
though all the. while it lay be rath their eyes 7” a
It. is idle to sae alate about whit inhibited men skilled
in fhe art from copying the most intricate details in ‘a
primary, mold built cup of rubber and then, making a per-
fect wax replica of the original model by ‘filling’all of the
intricacies ‘of the rubber mold with meélted wax projected
into the mold by centrifugal forge. The facts appear to be
that.the art used under various vircumstanees a number of
re different kinds of force to introduce molten. metal into east- -
jng molds. In casting metal, the problem of air pockets
is taken care of by vents as. in Kralund or by the use of.
porous inv¥stiments in whith theair is forced into the pores :
of. the mold by pressure as in the dental casting process .°
(93, f. 277). There was , always, the weight of ‘the molten
metal itself, and this* had been stipplemented by the some-
What increased. pressure: due to the weight of a column of
the molten metal in a- standpipe, as in Haseltine’s British
patent; there was the use of. steam pressure as. described
in the La Gravure arti¢le ; there was the use of centrifugal .
easting machines to ‘cast molten metal into molds, inclad- ’
ing the investment, type of porots s old resulting from the |
evacuation of the investment from the wax model in the
dental-casting art, and in the disclosure of McManus’ patent |
of 1923. And there was the practice of pressure die casting -
in which the molten metal was f6reed-into and compacted
in vented steel dies .into ‘which the contours of the original
- pattern had been sunk hy machine tooling. - ets B
Up to the time. when Jungersen appeared, the onty
proposal to apply any of these various. forces to the in- |
a @ tf
a
* Crdoubtedly this should he “incentive”.
i
«
oe ae
troduction of wax w as Kralund’ s plan which proposed to,
use the high pressure of pressure die-castipg to feree w “xX
into the metal dies to-protect those expensive dies from: the
-. exéessive temperature of the -molten metal. when large
- pleves were to be cast. Looking back from our “present
» knowledge, we aré inclined to think that the application of
any or all of those different kinds of force to. the intro-
duction of-wax into an intricate mold would be obvious.
-Yet, closer observation shows that fhese different ways of-
foreibly introducing molten anetal into molds would not all ,
of them by omy means he? usefully applicable to the intro-
‘duction of wax into an_ intricate - flexible rubber mold.
.vy There.is no evidence in the ‘procedures followed by the
alleged infringers, or elsewhere in this record ‘that wax
Pad could be effectively introduced ‘nto the intricacies of such,
a mold by the pressure: of the weight. of a column of wax
in-a- standpipe As in Has’ # ine’s metal casting step, or by
using the heat ofthe fluid metal to create steam pressure
in the mold as in. the La Gravure ‘article; and it is clear
” that . the problem that: confronted’ men’ engaged in ‘the
casting of small articles of jewelry could not be: solved: or.
even simplified by Kralund’s plan’ to. produce large. cast-
ings by using the high pressure. of: die casting to force
the wax into vented steel molds. There ‘would be no-
economy—indeed, no sense—in applyin that practice to ..
their problem. © In the: first: place,, the cost of the original ~~
steel: dies for pressure. die casting is at’ least as great as
the cost of stamping: dies; secondly, when once the expense
of making’ metal dies ‘for ¢ asting a piece of jewelry by
pressure die casting had. been. incurred there would be. no
sense in resorting to the “lost. wax’’ procedure’ | at all,
since there;is no difficulty in casting small articles directly
vA
ote
by pressure die casting in the steel dies (Kralund patent ~
* 4140/1 45-52. and 415a/2/129 to 416a/1/3); and, thirdly,
_the plastic molds used by Jungersen to reproduce ‘all of the
. fine intricacies of his: pattern cannot withstand the high
o* : : ~ 2 ie ; < : ; > p
we , _! : . . a y.
35 oo. eo,
ro
pressure of prluye die casting as Krahind “proposed to
use it*— a pressure which he says is too great to he with
stood even by the. pWRter.of Paris. investment molds. (See
also 97a, f. 291; 98d, f. 294; 145a, f. 494.)**. We can nqw see,
therefore, in our backward look after the solution has been,
disclosed, that Jungersen hit upon the only one of the
several kinds of force previously. used for metal casting
‘that would ‘be of any ‘use in the introduction of wax into
the intricacies of the flexible rubber molds.
a
This review of oul hindsight, however, is only anatlaie
way of saymg that it is a w aste of time to speculate about
what might have been When ‘the evidence upon tlose’
examination with all proper safeguards, shows that the’
solution was not appareut to men skilled in the art through-
-out a long, long period of ‘existing want. The probative
force of this evidence is not te be overthrown by any
rationalizations after the event that anyone could have
‘done what Jungersen did.:
*,
; 4 ‘ ‘
* In Jungersen’s patent “th€ effect was the application of force, .
a small amount of force; to catse-it to. flow a_little better into the
- details” Tour, 159a, f. 477), ahd “if * * * the casting , to be made
in: the mould is going to: take’ considerable pressure or ‘must be very
acctrate in dimensions, then the flexible moulds are too, yielding jo.
permitef. the high pressure, ur give the accuracy required” (Tour,
LSla, f. 454).
P ¢ .
Pe act: lx addition, Kralund’s process produces a pattern which must
be finished before it isiuvested and used as a fusible pattern. Fins
- are formed at the joints-of the mold yections ane at the vent
: Ie ces (ante, p. y 4) re ; ,
‘
,
The broader claims 5 and 6 can be ind should a so con-
strued as to embrace but not to extend beyond what Junger-
sen truly invented; the ‘new method © specifically described
when practiced with the substitution of known equivalents
for some ‘of the steps particularly defined in narrower terms |
in claims 1 to’4. When so construed, claims 5 and 6 are in-
_ fringed by the low pressure injection of the melted wax into
built up soft-metal molds by the force of a syringe-or the -
like, sometimes substituted for sentrifagel force by the al-
: leged infringers.
’ When claim 5° is compared with claim 1, for example, it
. is seen -that they. differ: in two significant partic vulars :
(1) Where claim 1 defines, the method of making’ a primary
mold‘as ‘‘then forming about said model a primary mold -
_of a plastic material which will retain ret shape
through subsequent treatment” , claim 5 says mnore broadly
‘then forming about said model a primary mold’’; and
(2) where claim 1 defines the method of introducing the
wax into the’ primary mold as ‘then by centrifugal action
foremg into the primary mold molten wax or other ma-
terial of:a low fusing point -that will not-injure the pri-_
mary mould’’, claim 5 says ‘‘then-intrpdueing into the’
mold “by force ‘sufficient to deposit the material into the
depression or depressions of the primary mould molten
wax or other material of low fusing point: that will not
injure the primary mould.” |
Judge Meaney held that claims 5 and 6 ‘in the light
of the prior art and more particularly in_view of Kralund
Lseruecrs aaah ‘are anticipated and: invalid” (29a, f.
—
4 Jtidige Rifkind found article claim 6 \“alsé invalid because it
describes an old article in terms of a process of manufacture” (39, - °
f. 117).° The Second Cireuit Court of Appeals, having found lack ‘o
invention in Jungersen’ s method said ‘““What we have said, of ee”
disposes of ciaim 6, the product claim. There is’ nothing new infthe
— — f. 647).
cD lend
oi . ae « ¢
Seat
86). That © nelusidn rests upon an interpretation of those:
claims ne extends ‘their beyond Jumgirsen’s. true
inve ntion. © That must be ro since Judge Meaney found
that the method discloSed- in Junge rsen's specification afd
defined i in claims 1-4 was something patentably new he yond. -
“the reach of the man skilled in the art. « ae
se ope
‘Judge Meaney’ (29a, f. 86-3la,. f. 91) ‘ipecadia that the
patentee’s s contention of novelty and validity of elaims %,
and 6 presented the following dilemma: Either those. claims
(1) ‘clearly and specifically claini the use of applied force
in depositing molten wax into the, primary mold’
(2) “by implication they ask: the Court to. read the use of ©
‘centrifugal force into the specifications of “claims 5 and 6°’
(29a, f. 87). He held that ‘*The use of ‘centrifugal force’
' to deposit the material’’ could not ‘*be read into and made
a part of the, specification of claims 5 and "6"? (2 30a, f. SS) -
and the other alternative, construing them so. breadly as
to cover the’ use of any and all kinds of applied free in
depositing molten wax in the primnary mold, led-him tg the
finding of anticipation by the ‘Kralund patent in the light.
_of the prior art... as ~
But the fact is that the éorrect ‘interpretatfon of claims
is 5 and 6 lies between those two extremes... The true posi-_
“tion is
been interpreted to embrace the whole of ‘put nothing more.
than,what Jungersen invented; that they are properly inter-
preted to cover, and are properly restricted to, the use-of
centrifugal foree and any similar fot#e, wv thich ws recognized
to be the equivalent of centrifugal force when applied in‘
the environntent defined by the other steps_of Jungersen’s:
‘ process That interpretation would have excluded Kra:—
lund’s procedure which is not at. all the equivalent of, and.
cannot be siibstituted for, Jungersen's and vet it would
have-avoided a construction of Fungerse n’s patent exelud-
ing all equivalents. /
or else -
, we submit, that élaims 5 and 6 could and should have _
<
.
e
The very'nature and purpose of the patent ‘contract is
cuéh that'a conclusion excluding all equivale nts ought to, be
woided, if it reasonably gan be within’ the statutory re-
juirement ni the patentee must “particularty point out
ind distinet& claim. the part, improvement or coinbination
which he claims as his inv ention or, discovery” (Sec. 45a,
RS. Us. C., Title 39, See. 33).
- Judge Ritkind’s deci isiqn (No, 48) ‘*that, the, claims are
ull invalid because anticipated and for want of invention”’
(39, f. 116) rests, as does Judge Meaney's decision of .in-
validity of claims 5 and 6, upen a reading—a misreading,
ve submit—of the whole patent—all its six cfaims—as an
issertion of monopoly breadly covering: thé introduction of
Je wax by any. one ‘*of the several modes [known in metal
‘asting |: for the applicz ition of force, namely syringes, air
oressure and-centrifugal machines’’, His reasoning was
“Clearly the use of force for casting the meétal is ‘old;
Haseltine, La Gravure and Kralund taught it. The need .
of foree’ for. casting the wax was taught by Kralund who’
ised a die, casting machine. ~ Moreover, by his claim of in-.
‘ringement plaintiff practically concedes -the equivalence of
the several modes for the ‘application of “force, —
‘vringes, air - pressure and centrifugal. machines’ " (26,
[O7)..
This-approach was carried over—into the conelusion and:
he majority opinion of the- Second, Circuit Court of
_ Thus, Judge Clark, in that opinion, said (212,
63s Gea + Me : y
' «Thus plaintiff's patent can be sustained only ‘if the
use of foree to east the wax and the metal is such a
change of a known method as to amount to invention.”’
‘With this ‘ipproach—assuming that no one force was.
lifferent from ay other in its way of operation or result
vhen, used to get the wax into the plastic and ham, 4 ry inus
.
primary waite the court reached the conclusion that Jun--
gersen s method was antic ipated | by Kralunily that it lacked
novelty. ‘If that were the case—if Jungersen’s method had
not been new in the objective sense that ‘no one had ever
thought of combining -all his steps before in ‘a singte
sbquenc e so that his process In its entirety had never been
De assembled before—ther the old’ process could not have been
~ patented merely by turfing it to a new use, as Judge
: ern Hanck pointed out-in his dissenting opinion (21%,
f. 650). But the fact is that Jungersen’s process in its .en-_
tirety had’ net been assembled before for any. purpose, and
so the question arises whether its change from what was -
done before, however trifling that item of change may ap-
. ‘pear to be after the event, is such a change-as to result in
patentable invention ‘under our Constitutional provisions
and our Patent Laws. As we have said, that question really
hecomes, under sue +) cireumstances as are in. the present
case, a-question of ultimate fact rather than a question ot
law. e . Rei mee ho
ais ~The Construction that Should Be Given:
y a to Claims 5 and 6. s
. No patent ‘claim can salidly be construed to extend the
patent monopoly bey ond the inventor’s real invention. An
unambiguous claim for more than the patentee ‘was entitled
to Gaim as n@ is, of course, invalid; and a claim so in-
“definite that, even when illuminated by the patentee’s dis-
closure, it cannot. reasonably be construed to define a.
monapoly within ‘the limits of thé patentee’s real invention
ix likewise: invalid, for failure to, “distinctly elaim’” the,’
invention as the statute requires. -
But when ‘the thing disclosed in the. patent is in truth a
meritorious invention, then the claims will, if reasonably
possible, be construed to-embrace as much of his iftvention |‘
cas the patentee — to secure Dy his patent.* |
°
* Robinson on Patents, ‘Vol. 2, Par. 735-739, pp. 464- 491,
av
— 40 een
Cane ess: :
In the application of these established rules ofe law, the
question Is: W hat is ageequivalent in the combination’ tor
the particular step jr element which the alleged intringer
has changed, and is the thing he has substituted sugh an
“equivalent.” *
os Use By the Alleged. Infringers: af Other ‘Injection Forces
: | Than Centrifugal Force, —
‘The specification of Jungersen’s ‘patent does not name
any equivalent | for. the centrifugal foree under which he
. ptoposed to- project the wax into the rubber mold. The
~ language of claim 5 which evidences his intention to claim
equivalents is, **then introducing into the mrould by force --
sufficient to deposit the material inte the depression or de-
pressions of the primary mold, molten-wax or’ other ma-
terial of low fusing point’’. The patent specifications does,
however, disclose in detail the mode of operation of the
centrifugal force when applied to® the wax. The patentee.
says (185/2/9- 25) :
‘The wax or metal is thus fore ‘ed into the moni and
by the centrifugal action displaces the air within the
mould, the molten material congealing first against the
exposed surfaces of the cavity formed in the mould
and any air’ which may be trapped in a récess of the
_mould wilk-be crowded back into the fluid-hod¥. under
the pressure applied thereto and -the. fluid niaterial
will advance into. the recess as it crowds the air there:
; ye from and will progressively congeal against. the wall
of the recess until the extreme limit is reac ‘hed so that
the finest of cavities will be complete ‘ly filled.’
Thus, the mode 6f operation of the centrifugal force on
the molten wax is seen to be that it-injeets or sarge the.
ee
= oo
_** As to those cases in which the een ee now befe
‘the Court used cetitrifugal force, there is no denial of imfringemen'
Wax’ partic ‘les into, the, inold. unde ‘r the momeé atum impatted
to them-by the : rapid rotation of fhe centrifugal machine.
forcing the wax into the impervious mold and displacing
the air hang it, any Jiajsic oer ar being ¢ sabotage “bac ‘k into
--to so that the fluid wax advances into the recess as it
. crowds the air therefrom, congealjng first against the
exposed surface of the cavity in the mold and progres-
sively -conge: ling against the wall of the cavity until the
extreme limit is reached and the finest. intricacies com-
pletely filled. At. the trial (Nos. 7-8) this mode ef opera-
tion was again described by Mr. Jungersen, in answer to
b soegeree directed to him by- Judge Meaney, as follows
(S6a, ff. 257- 258) : ‘eo
.
>. kis A put it into the ce ntrifugal casting machine
and lay this:in here, with the gate hole up towards the
erncible; then I just take a little spoontul of wax and
pour it in like this here and let her swing. = ™®
‘Tye Court: Now, —- ‘throws the wax into the
R mould. | : sili
“The Witness:> That po the. wax into the
mould, and the air will escape out through the same
entrance where the wax entered in. |
“<Q, It is necessary to have an escape of air so that
the model will be an exact duplicate? “AL The escape
is through my gates.
Pe “Q. Yes, but Tsay it is necessary to have an escape .
of air-— A. Yes, .
“The Court: Through the same aperture through
which thie wax entered! ?
‘The Witness: That is true, a
’ "Phe Court; As the wax: goes in the’ air is forced
out.*” ;
In Case 48 Mr. Jungersen, questioned by opposing coun-
sel dhout the action of centrifugal foree on the wax in his
aa ¥
42:
”
. :
°
°
_ thethod, as compared. with the centrifugal casting of metal
a
into the°plaster investment molds vin dentistry, » testified as
— (92- 93, ff. 277-278) 2 f
oN It jis under an entirely diffe ‘rent’ circumstance.
if yvou.are speaking about a mold that-has been used —
by the dental trade, for filling that: with ce ntrifugal’
force, that is a different mold, and whether (there! :
the metal can enter amd force’the air out through the |
pores in the mold, but that is an entirely different
thing when you cast the wax in there, because the |
wax comes in and that is not a porous mold. | In this
case that is a closed mold where the air ean only OS:
cape out through the gate ordinarily; and if. you pour
the wax in then it: will only come. in halfway ‘and fit.
will stop.”’
It is apparent, from what we have already said’ that the
mode-of operation achieved in- .Jungersen’s s method. cannot |
he brought about by the mere application of pressure to,
supplement the weight of the molten metal or the molten
wax, and signi ificant confirmation of this is found in the
fact that none“of the alleged infringers uses the pressure
anethods of Haseltine’s standpipe or of the La Gr ravure —
article or of Kralund’s pressure die casting. .
In Cases 7 aad 8, the charge of infringement is [baked
upon the proe sya stated in plaintiff. g particulars (20a,
f. 59), as follows Seer ces y a "4
~(b) The master pattern is removed. antl. melted wax
is squirted from an eve dropper . or syringe ‘into a
channel in the mold and thus into. the mold cavities;
which cavities correspond in shape and design to the
Taster pattern ; id ee
s ;
In Case 48, Jardge Rifkind deperibes the prac tices of the
alleged infringers thus (29, f: 86: and see 123-124, ff, 367
370): : ee ba
s
.
3
Ce ree
sg!
a “To inject the wax ipto the primary. mould all use a
centrifuge and some alse use an eve dropper or ss r-
Inge, air-gun, air injection lachine, hydraulic machine.
and vacuum casting eenaipen ees
As to the operation af “aseringe ‘and the other “substitutes
employed ‘by the-atieged, infringers, the. testimony is that:
they are all injection processes, Thus, Mr. Jumgerseh tes.
tified (i,t f. 201) :. Ne any eae Ly.
Q), Yo ¢an Inject Wax with : assy ringe, “ah vou not,
into a rubber or metal. mole i A. Yes; if vau have a
closed—no, | was trying to say if you had i closed
system’vou cannot inject it, but vou‘cvan inject:it into
any void. , . | |
“*@. You can then .injeet wax with a syringe into.
either a multi-part metaF mold or into a rubber mold,
can you not, Mr. Jungersen? A. T helieve’ so, ves,
*Q. And you can do the same thing with molten”
material with an air pressure machine, can't you? A,
I believe so, if vou don’t trap the air. :
*(), And the vacuum machine also, Mr. Suan rsen?
A. ¥es, if you don’t trap the air or freeze it up on the
way in.
—Q. But all of ‘hice instrumentalities are used for
the purpose of injecting a molten material into a mold,
, are they not?. A. I presame so, ves.’ :
Respondents’ [defendants’ ] witness Schneider, a easter for
respondent Axel Bros., testified that they used three Vari
ants to do their wax ‘casting, ‘*the syringe, injector ma-
chine, and-centrifugal machine’’ (131; f. 393). If he were
going to make a few. finished articles. he **would use the
“syringe’’; if he were going to make inany, he ‘would ‘use
the centrifuge, or the injector machine’’, because ,of the
greater speed of operation (132, f..395), and he testified
_ (133, f, 397): 3 AH
“Q. Will vou dese sribe the operation « of the alr_pres-
_sure-injeetion tachine 7 A de is — on the <anne
principle as,the ordinary, eve dropper, or the syringe,
- but only we introdiee compressed” air. Tato the ima-
chine, forcing our wax out into the metal or the rubber
mold. * vis
Re lt consists of the wax pot? ra . 7 eee
“Q. And the mold is pressed against the nozzle!
That is right, and the air comes, out, and it Porees
-the wax into our mold. : ar
In the ‘product, whether the wax replicas were made lv
“the injector process or bY the centrifugal machine, or by:
the sy ringe method, ‘there w as not any difference whats,
ever si f. 401). ay % eae
i se “ the Alege “d ihiidwins rs of pe Motds * Built
- Epof Soft Metal Paatood of Rabber
_In the specification the inventor Says:
* This model is placed upon a base and. a flexible
_mould-forming material sue ‘he as. rubber, 1 is built up
around the model, * * C189 /1/33-35).
-and hes . i ; x§
eat tes
.
“The mould thus coustruvted is préferably made. of,
rubber and when the rubber material completely. sur
c- —_ the model it is suitably vuleanized and. caused
, flow intimately: about. the’ detail structure of the
cain and thus assumes ‘a permanent shape having 2°
cavity the exact shape and detail: of the model em
bedded therein’ * (L/F0-55 ). . Pet
* ees a . . Nes ” e ~* *
°
In the claims the nature of the primary meld is variously
- defined as follows: : :
o
a
. a} -’ ; . é a . "45
8 Cae 2: “then forming subnet wiid- model ¢ primars
apn trae annette ot plastic juatenial whieh will re-
tain a lasting shape Treat “srtbsequent ©’
treatment.” . :
Chitin 227%: then. forming a primary mould inseparable
; . sections, therenpound oof -plastie material
“2 “capable. of assuming intimate contac? .with
‘ the intric ate designs of the anode! and
. | adapted to retain the assumed: shape,’
Claim. 5: ° ‘then foruiini: about said model: a primary
mould”, ra sare e
The evidenee Tn-tCases Zand & is that defendants use
«(.Particujars, 20a, fot) * * aah, a ae
~- metat mold ounprising from three ty five piers,
position| ed}. within a two-piéce-alaminun mold —-
of Standard design, is Auilt! ui) around - “it jnaster pat-.
iad : Tae |
> 2 . Ps .
.
The ‘ytill used is ‘ta soft-alloy” (S48a, Q. 83).
In No. 48, some of the alleged infringers* yse soft me ‘tal
~ moulds cs well as ribber mou I Is°. (Cpiaion, 20, f. 86; and
see 123-B29). ss |
From the evide nee it appears that the satt metal niold is
formed about the origma! model, by castiag a soft metal
alloy which«melts above the beiling point of water about
successively. exposed sections of the original smodel about
which the soft metal flows and takes the shape in negative
ot the mold, ‘This procedure is differentiated fromr.that.
when the die ts formed by Hiae chining . into hard metal as
* Claim 3'1s subordinate to claim ‘1. °
= ‘Taim 4 ts wished to claim 2. : RY Ts ; -
see At the trial eviderice on ve subject was, lithiited to this state
ment m the Partgculars (135a, , 404). tesa
o ;
; ‘ 6. 3
\
\
+
46
jn presstire die casting; im whic li case there ix ne need of
a model (Tour 153, f. 458)", abe
The men skilled in the ayt had known for many vegrs
‘several équivalent ways of forming a primary. mold of a
flexible mold-forming material sugh as rubber abort al
| medel, In. the practice of the ** lox Wax" | Process, oe
Tlie testimony of respénde nt” ide ‘fendants’ expert Tour
in. No . 48 is (161, f. 482):
**Now, you referred to thie several diffe ‘rent types of
mold; the rubber mold of Hazeltine and Spencer, the
gelatin mold of ‘La Gravure’ and the multipart cerami¢
wie} Log Cellini. You have alse referred to the mold or ;
‘die of Kralund. .W ill you eXplain whether or not molds
of these various types are and have been ~~ ‘rally and
infere ‘hangeably used in the casting.art? A. They have. :
been ‘used generally and still are used semerally and .
interchangeably. in the casting art. W herever a specitic
thing or ‘method seems most applicable that is the one
that is used. — 2 : “6
“Q. And for how long has that been true? -A.-Pre-_
sumably ever since the days of C ‘ellini for his me thod ms
and so on for the other methods; certainly as long a
| have. been acquainted with the casting art, whie ‘h is
some 27 years,” a 3 ors °
Just as, when the\hing disclosed by a patentee pos:
sesses: originality the kiowledge and capabilities of men
-. skilled in the art- must be looked at to decide whether it
possesses also the quality -of invention, so in considering
infringement of a- patent for a meritorious invention the
knowledge and capabilities of men trained in the teeh-
nology of the art must be taken. into account, Sue ‘+h men
niay be trusted to find a variety of physic ‘al embodiments
, ‘ "a
ee 7
~
# See 126, f. 377-131, ¢. 391: 137, f. 410;. 138, f.-414; 145,
t. 435. ee i :
“47. . . 2 2
2 ae, od we ss . ‘ ~ .
~
of the dea oaf tiveans whieh is the true. substamee 4 the
pate nted Inve ntions & tubodiments which are the ecfivale nt
of what is disc dosed- anid claimed in the patent. Pi mathe
matties, this gineralizdtion is. expressed incthe. phri ix that
things, which, are eal to the same thing are equal to each
‘other. dm the pate nt\ le AW, a Classie statement Af thi¢ mule |
Was given by Mr.Justice ¢ ‘Vifford: itr Machiive Co. ve Miir-
phy, C Otte 120, 125: , eet
‘Authorities cone ur ahat the. substantial equivalent
of a thing, in. the, sense of the patent law, is the same (
as the thing itself; so that if two devices do the saine
work in substantially, the same way; and acconiplish
2 pt substantially the sad: result, they are the same, even
though they. differ in.\name, form, or shape. Curtis,
Patents (4th ed. sect,’ 310.7 ‘
‘ ‘ \ e ; 4
W e venture the suggestion that: this disteine of equiva”
dents is nothing. more than the reflection of the’ reluctance
ot sophistic: ited judges to be hoodwinkéd by superficial
appearances, and -their determination in the administration
of justice for the public good to look through the form
to the substance of things. Looked at in that way, we.,
~ submit that the use by the alleged infringers,of other
known types of plastic materials than rubber and of other
injection forces than centrifugal force which act upon thre
melted wax-in'the same way to produce the same result,
is an -encréachinent irpon the true invention deseribed and
claimed in Jungersen’s patent and is the eforean infringe.
" nfent.- ss :
Rees -.. Respectfully submitted,
ice ny ; —Winwian JH. Davis,
i Grorce BE. Farruruun,
Kart W. Fiocks,
Attorneys for Jungersen.
*
es rete Appendix
“ - ‘ oe. -
oO. .
Scutprere “PecuNigue. ENevenorenia Burtaystc A,
T4tH_Ep., VoL. 20, pr 229. ‘eo
‘
°
, Cire Perpve, or Low W AX PROCESO = SThe first stage of
this process, after receiving the model}- from the: artist, con-
sists in preparing a negative made of plaster_or velatine.
This is merely a coating of thé outside of the model. In
..this negatiye, which shows all the details of the model im 5.
the reverse, a wax coating is applied in a molten state with
“a brush: until it has acquired \sufticie nt t thic kness, ne
“on the size of the figure. . \ f
At this stage, we will have a’ partes replica of, the se eulp-
ture in wax, and: sufficiently hard to. permit handling. The
artist can work on it as muchas he pleases, obtaining rare.
results of details, which makes fhis process of casting. in--
valuable. Gates-and vents in the shape of wax rods aré
‘then properly attachéd to the wax Tigure,
Finally, the mould for the metal is. formed by blowing:
or pouring ‘inside and around the wax a’ semi-liquid com-
position, which’ hardens in a few minutes. This coamposi-
tion. of silica, plaster and other chemicals can resist high
temperature, and, of course, all the waxginside of it will
inelt away, leaving a hollow space. This operation is ae-
- complished in large ovens, by baking the: moulds over a
slow fire. As soon as all the wax-is surely melted away,
the mould is removed from the oven and packed in foundry
earth ‘in’a pit provided in the floor. The bronze is the
poured from crucibles, ‘and the moltgn ietal will run
through the gates (inelted away) an ne the: space left
empty by the wax figure algo melted away (Iggt wax). The |
figuire im hrenze is then removed froin. the silt ‘a mould and.
dipped in-acid for a propet cleaning. 7 |
. ®& a
“sce F eas
ee 2
a Bes , _ _Appendis eos
a s : ‘
6 Q
Ww ith this process, the cast bronzes require very little
‘finishing or chiselling. and the results are far ahove the
sand process. — | ‘ | °
Bronze AND. Brass Onx~amentaL Work. BM NCYCLOPEDIA
‘Brrrannica,. 14rn Bo.,- Vou. 4¢ p. 240.
\ Bronze AND » BRAss Ouxaiter rat Work. The use of. bronze
~\ dates. from rémote antiqiity. ~This important metal’ is an
7 “alloy ‘composed of copper. and tin, in propostions which
yary slightly, but. may be hormally considered a& nine
parts of copper to one of tin, Other ingr edients. which are
occasionally found are more or less accidental. The -result
‘is a metal of a‘rich gelden brown colour, capable of being
worked by easting—a. process little applicable to its eom-
" ponent .parts, but peculiarly successful with brenze, the
density and hardness, of the metal allowing Tt. to take any
\ > impression of a mould, however "delicate. :
’ This process is ‘inion. as* cire perdue, and. is the most—
“primitive and most conimonly employ ed through the. cen-
turies, having been described by the monk Theophilus, and
alse -by Benvenuto Cellini. Briefly, it is as. follows: <A.
core, roughly representing the size and foym ‘of the object
>. to be produced, is made of pounded brick,’ plaster or other.
| similar ‘substance and thoroughly dried. Upon this: the
artist overlays his wax, which he models to the degree re-
quired in hi: finished wotk. -Passing from the core through
the wax and p ojecting beyond are ‘metal rods. © The model-
ling being completed; thé outer covering which will form
the mould has to he applied; thjs is a liquid férined of clay’
~ and plaster sufficiently thin to find its way into every de-
tail of the wax model, Further coatiffgs of liquid are ap-“
plied, so that there is, when dry, a.solid outer coating and
a solid 1 inner core held toge ‘ther by the metal rods, with the
\ ° “-
\
. ‘ . X
. « $ -
. * : : . -
feniomes teak
Saat A ppendia :
c
. .
“work of art modelled i in wax between. -Heat is applied and
the wax melts and uns out, aml the molten metal ts poured |
in and oceupies every detail which the wax had filed.
Wien: cool, the outer casing is carefully broken aw ay, the
core raked out as far a8 ‘possible, the projecting rods. are
removed and th object modelled i in wax appears: in bronze.
If further finish is required } it is obtained by, tooling.
‘
e o
(wow. W.)
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.