Transcript of Record — North American Co. v. Securities & Exchange Commission
Supreme Court brief1946
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Vol. VI |
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
> }
Supreme Court of the United States
—_
OCTOBER TERM, 1042 -- ~-
a No. #21 /
, NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY, PETITIONER,
°
CURLEIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION
CERTIORART TO THE UNEDED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUL
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED FEBRUARY 10, 1943.
CERTIORARI GRANTED MARCH 1, 1943.
nn ee a ene eee eee nee age
uited States Circuit Cattrt of Auprats
1
RANSCRIPT OF RECORD
j
( ‘
.
\ | 4 TT)
COIN { ee PSE ee ee
>
QD
i
a
Vs
~_—
ae | es 1. XP ’ 4 LAF A CA LT
PRLS ANd. BA ( cis LMLISSTON
]? » A yA +
| e: Uwe?
ones |
°
TESTIMONY
Volume VI
(Pages 2044 to 2499)
2
\
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Be are Volume VI.
: PAGE
Testimony ...... eee Tre ee eee eee. cecces wee
RESPONDENTS’ WITNESSES: _
0
Stanley Stoke®: |
Direct by Mr. Hamilton (Continued )
2045, 2249, 2417
Direct by Mr. Browning............. sive S108
John A. Woodbridge:
Direct by Mr. Browning...... sucavbeeees 2358
2044
6130 Bergre THE
Securities and GAchanoe Conunissinn
Docket No. 59-10
4
a
IN THE MATTER
of
THE NORTH AMERICAN COMPANY, et al.
6131 +
Heéariag Room 622, “
Securities and Exchange Commis.
| , sion Bldg.,
4 Washington, D. C.,
Wednesday, October 23, 1940.
Met, pursuant to adjournment, at 10 o’cloek a.m.
§132 ae
Before: W. W. Swirt, Trial Examiner.
Appearances: | ci:
S. PEARCE BROWNING, JR., and CHARLES 8. HAMILTON, JR,
of Sullivan & Cromwell, 48 Wall Street, New York City,
Attorneys for the Respondents.
RaLrH C. BrnForp and Arruvr J. BuSWELL, Attorneys for _
the Securities and Exchange Commission.
—2,634—
ee
24D
Stanley Nokes—By Respondents—Direct
PROCEEDINGS,
‘The Examiner: The hearing will come to order.
Mr. Hamilton: Mr. Stokes, will you resume the
stand? :
Whereupon, STANLEY STOKES resumed the stand and tes-
tified further as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Hamilton (Continued) :
Q. Yesterday, Mr. Stokes,
mission system of the Union Electric Group. Will yeu now
you described the main trans-
describe the sub-transmission system and begin, if you will,
with a statement of what you regard as being your sub-
transmission system? A. The sub-transmission system, as
referred to in this discussion, consists of the lines which
form the connecting link between the main transmission
system and the main power plant, with the distribution sub-
stations. Those sub-stations are step-down transformers
» Stations in most cases, which step the voltage down from
some voltage such as 14,800 or 33,000 volts, to a lower dis-
tribution voltage, such as 2,300/4,000, cr in some cases 6,600,
6.900, and other similar voltages. That is, we have several
such voltages in approximetely the same range.
The sub-transmission system of the, Union Electric Com-
pany, Group is a combination of overhead lines and under.
kround cables. The system includes more than ],200 circuit
—2,635—
miles of both overhead and underground transmission, di-
Vided inte 543.8 miles of 33 kv. pole lines; 43 miles of 33 kv.
6133
6134
3
ee
6136
6137
6138
- PO045-->
s
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
steel tower lines; 159.7 miles of 33 kv. submarine and under.
ground cables; 170.4 miles of 13.8 kv. submarine and unider-
ground cables; 248.2 miles of 12.95. kv. pole lines; 6.8 miles ef
13.8 ky. steel tower lines; 1.6 miles of 11 ky. steel tower lines;
34.2 miles of 11 ky. pole lines; 9.1 miles of 11 kv. underground
‘able; and 18.5 miles of 6.6 ky. underground cable. These
mileages are in addition to'those lines which have been previ-
ously described as main transmission system.
In general, the undergrotind system, so-called, meaning
the underground cable and: the conduit work, is confined: to
the urban and the more densely populated areas, while the
overhead circuits serve the surrounding, lesser populated
districts. Se |
In general, the City of St. Louis is largely supplied by
underground cable except for its 4,000 volt ultimate dis-
tribution circuits, Which are not under d/scussion here.
St.Louis County has both underground cable and over-
head lines, I would say predominantly overhead, The other
less populated districts have a larger percentage of overhead
construction.
The general basis of these circuits is to supply off them
60-cycle energy for practically all of the.growth of the load.
Certain areas which are already supplied by 25-cyele for in-
F —-2,636—
dustrial purposes or railway load, are continued that way.
Q. Now, if you will, describe that portion of the sub-
transmission system in and about the Keokuk plant?. A. The
Keokuk voltage at the plant is referred to as 11_kyv. Most
of our system is 13.2 or 13.8 kv. I would like to explain that
in the use of these voltages that are very close to each other,
2047
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—WDirect 6139
such as 13.2 or 13.8, or 66 kv. or 69kv., those are all used
synonymously. Actually, the voltage varies on such a cir-
cuit, and at the transmitting end the voltage would be some-
what higher than at the receiving end. So when I speak of
13.8 ky. cables, I am talking about the power plant end. If
I speak of 13.2, it merely means that we are talking about the
receiving end. But in any case, they may be regarded as
synonymous. | |
The Keokuk sub-transmission ‘system takes the supply of
power at 11,000 volts from the plant and distributes it in 6140
the vicinity of Keokyk, and by reason of transformation to
33,000 volts, it is also supplied to Fort Madison and other
[/ towns in the vicinity.
The two 11 kv. feeders supply 3,500 kw. of frequency
changers of the Central “Mlinois Public Service Company.
One 11 kv. feeder stpplies a 2,450 kw. frequency changer of
the Ilinois-lowa Power Company.
four 11 kv. feeders go to Hamilton, Tilinois, which is
located immediately opposite the Keokuk plant on the Il-
linois side of the river, where two of these four feeders sup-! |
—2,637— 6141
ply the Ilinois-lowa Power Company; and the other two, the
lowa Union Electric Company.
Three 11 kv. feeders go to the Keokuk terminal for 11
ky. distribution to the Keokuk and Jackson Avenue sub-
stations, and numerous customer sub‘stations.
The Keokuk terminal is just a name for a terminus, not
far from the plant. .
Two 11 kv. feeders supply large customers. Those are
big industrial eustomers who are heavy users of electric
power for electric furnace application. |
6142
6143.
6144
O48
-
*
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—-Direet
Two 33 ky. feededs go to Burlington, supplying nine
sub-stations of varying capacities, which are operated by the
Union Electric Group. The end of those feeders terminates
at the Burlington sub-station of the Lowa Southern Utilities
Company. I should explain that that reference includes the
line which was discussed under main transmission system,
but I have not included it in this mileage. The reason I have
mentioned it here is that those various-sub-stations which are
tapped off of that circuit, weré not included in the previous
discussion. They are smal] stations to-adarge extent.
In addition to the above feeders, part of the sub -tgansmis-
sion system consists of the taps on the main 110 kv. trans-
mission lines at Hull, and Meppen. Those points wefe dis-
cussed and located in the previous testimony, and in
addition to their features as wholesale points, there is some
| —2,638—
sub-transmission carried out to supply loads in the vicinity.
At Hull, seven sub-stations are supplied with energy over
33 kv. lines from that point, and in addition energy is sold
to the Central Illinois Public Service Company for use in.
their own frequency changers located at Hull sub-station.
At the sub-station which taps the main iine at Meppen,
a 9,000 kilowatt step-down transformer, 110 to 66 kv. voltage,
supplies a portion of the power going to the Central Illinois
Pubiic Service Company transformers, and frequency
changers; and a 66 kv. No. 2 single-circuit line, which is
earried to Alton. That line was mentioned yesterday. °
At Alton there is located 6,000 kilowatts in step-dow?
transformers. The line then continues to Hartford, where
8,000 kilowatts of transformers are in operation, and thence —
L049
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
to Lake Avenue sub-station in East St. Louis, which is 15.6
niles south-of Hartford.
“At Lake Avenue, 10,000 Kilowatts in transformers supply
2o-cyele service in the East St. Louis district, with a reserve
supply, over three 13.8 kilovolt submarine cables from the
Ashley. Street plant. That is, the service in East St. Louis
amounting to about 10,000 kilowatts,of 25-eycle load in that
vicinity, has a duplicate source of-cupply, aud in the event
that this circuit from Mappen sub-station wer to be in difti-
culty, the service would be continued within interruption
= —2,639-—
by cables going from the Ashley Street station under the
river and over to Lake Avenue. In that district- we ha&ve
the large packing companies, the National Stockyards, and
this service is quite important. -)
In general, as we go through this sub-tratismission system,
I should like to point out that the facilities are, in almest
every case, if not all, arranged to provide duplicated service;
that the extent to which duplicated service is provided in the
area supplied by the Union Electric Group is a very high
percentage. I think that is one distinctive feature of the
Union Electric system, the extent to which our main cus-
tomers have duplicated service.
Q. State the purpose of that duplication, if you will?
A. The purpose, of course, of the duplicated service, is to_
render less frequent possible interruptions, and not only -
minimize the possibility or probability of interruptions, but
to reduce the length of time if any should arise.
The success which a power company may heve in the long
run with these large industrial] customers is, in my opinion,
6145
6146
6147
1
6148
6149
6150
° : ?OD0
Staniey Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
to a great extent affected by the actual continuity of the
service rendered, as wel! as the voltage regulation and quality
of service. The fact that electric service may be tendered
and be of lower grade is not always appreciated, but it is a
fact that in industrial work, particularly, both regulation
and continuity are of the greatest importance.
ae —2,640—
The supply of. service by these underground sub-transmis-
sion cables is obviously more expensive than to do it with
overhead lines, but the reliability is much higher.
Q. Describe the portion of the sub-transmission system
in and about the Page Avenue sub-station in St. Louis, if
you will? A. The Page Avenue sub-station has been previ-
ously mentioned as a main transmission sub-stution, which
is its chief function; in addition to that, however, there
is a large group of sub-transmission feeders leaving tbis
station, and in addition to that, quite a large building con-
taining a group of distribution feeders which will not be
described at this time. :
When we constantly refer to the Page Avenue sub-station,
it is because that station contains, in the same. general loca-
tion, all of these facilities.
The sub-transmission feeders supplied out of this sub-
station are of considerable importance, The fact is that they
are very important, There are ten 13.8 kv. 60-cycle feeders
which supply ten sub-stations through 104,500 kilowatts of
13.8/33 kv. transformers; and 13.8/4.16 kv. transformers
25-eyele service, at 13,200 volts is provided by 24 feeders
which run to 12 railway sub-stations belonging to the Public
Service ‘Company, which is the local street car company, and
2051
Stanley Stokes—By Kespondents—Direct
sonie of these feeders go to Ashley Street where they in turn
are supplying railway joad.
gai
The 60,000 kw. of frequency changers, previously men-
tioned, are on the bus which supplies all of these facilities,
and I would like to make this point, that when some ques-
tion was raised recently about the possibility of supplying
reliable service to what is known as Lambert Field, an
airport some 9 miles from Page Avenue sub-station, and I
was asked whether I thought we could supply good service
to that point, I said that I could conscientiously reply that
if we couldn’t- deliver it at that point, I didn’t believe it
could be delivered anywhere. And I have summed up the
facilities by saying that we had two hydro-electric plants,
four steam plants, several duplicated types of substation
facilities, and a group of distribution lines—all available at
that point; and any one of which should be able to supply
that service many times over.
The extent of these facilities is a matter of real point
in this particular system. The St. Louis County area, which
_is adjacent to this sub-station, contains the highest grade
residential and some of the better commercial establishments
in the St. Louis area, including University City, which is the
largest single town in that district, and the requirements
for service are very severe at that point.
_ The ten feeders previously mentioned, 7 of which supply
energy to transformers having a total capacity of 82,000
kilowatts, which furnish the service for nine sub-stations,
—2,642—
are divided into two groups: seven 33 kv. feeders, and three
6151
6152
6153
AR ALA NE TA EIB REA a Be
6154
2052
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—VDirect
feeders supplying the Page Avenue distribution station
6155
6156
through 22,500 kilowatts of transformers at the lower voltage
delivered of 4,160 volts, three-phase, four-wire.
The statement there is not sufficient to make it clear, The -
seven 33,000 volt feeders which leave this sub-station, each
one having its own transformer, step up and supply 33,000
volt overhead lines which go out several miles in the different
directions to supply these step-dow n sub-stations, which in
turn handle the district for such towns as St. Charles, for
example, and various other Communities in that area. :
The three feeders which I mentioned. as going through
the 22,500 kilowatt transformers, step down right at the Page
Avenue ‘location, and go into this other large distribution
building which handles the 4,000-volt distribution.
The 25-cycle sub-transmission circuits from Page Avenue,
consisting of 24—13,200 volt feeders, have 8 feeders used as |
tie-lines to the Ashley Street plant. These are underground
cables. Also, ten feeders supplying 12 sub-stations of the
Public Service Company, by underground cables. You ut
derstand that 10 feeders can supply 12 sub- stations by tap-
ping one feeder to more than one. That sub-station probably
has another source of supply from some other location.
Six feeders leave Page Avenue underground, and then are
routed overhead, three going north, and three south, to a
: —2,643--
number of customer sub-stations. eee
That is a rather brief summary of a major investment in
feeders whose average capacity varies from a minimum of
7,500 or 8,000 kilowatts each, to 12,0007
All of these transformers on those feeders that step up
are provided with air-blast equipment which permits the
L058
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
transformer to increase its rating for emergency operation.
The later transformers instaHed on some of these equivalent
feeders are rated 10,000/13.333 k. v. a., that meaning that the
transformer which has a 10,000 kilowatt self-cooied rating,
with the radiators exposed to the air in a normal manner, can
automatically, by the operation of relays, turn on some
motor-driven blowers which blow air rapidly over the surface
of the radiators in the transformer, and raise the capacity of
the transformer. ;
This is used in connection with reserve service. If one
line of any three of ‘those were to go out of service, the other
two would pick up the load.
Q. Now if you will, describe the pertion of the sub-trans-
mission system in and about Ashley Street? A. Ashley Street
station, which was previously mentioned, has been in service
for many years, has the ground around the station for a dis-
tance of about a block almost paved with cables. I believe
that that statement is hardly wuch of an exaggeration.
Literally, it is getting difficult to find room to put any more
eae | ‘ —2,644—
conduits in that immediate vicinity, and the temperature rise
of such cables has to be carefully analyzed as larger numbers
6158
6159
of them are involved in close proximity, and each one con-—
tributes a certain amount of heat and the ground has to
radiate it. aa
Ashley Street both generates and distributes 60-cycle and
25-cyele energy. The sub-transmission system at Ashley
Street may be summarized for 60-cycle energy as: 21 feeders
going to six sub-stations, including the downtown AC low-
voltage network. This network is a relatively recent installa-
tion, and will be discussed in more detail later.
EM AB ra
Ce ee ww
Pe lL lee ES RRO Mle ee Ses CURR
6160
6161
6162
2054
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
The 25-cycle system supplies energy to six sub-stafions_
over 18 feeders, and also serves 13 Publie Service aie
(railw ay company) sub-stations over 13 feeders.
Q. Now have you stated the voltage of the feeders going
out of Ashley Street? A. No, I shall do that.
The steam mains out of Ashley Street are large, and
earry 200-pound steam pressure, and there has to be great
care exercised where the steam mains and the-eables are in
the, same vicinity, and problems of that type are the result
of concentration of load in congested city areas. Such
problems are not encountered in lower-load- den sity districts,
bnt they frequenthy present real difficulty for satisfactory~
solution.
In this case, we have to highly insulate the steam mains,
° —2,645—
and then provide special facilities for cooling the conduits,
and one of aur very large customers is a refrigeration com-
pany which has 10 to 15 miles of distribution refrigeration
service. They pump the refrigerant around the city and
expand it at different locations. Although we work very
closely together to eliminate any problems that may arise,
we get into some street intersections where the refrigerating
company and the steam heating mains, and all the electric
cables, converge. The steam heats the refrigerant, which
causes it to expand and produces difficulties in pumping -
it, and the steam main also may have a detrimental effect
on the electric cables; the electric cables may affect the re-
frigerating line, and they are not very good neighbors.
There is only a certain amount of space left in these
streets, and we have to utilize what there is with the great-
est care.
—
YU
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
Phe voltage at which the energy at 60 cycles is handled
out of Ashiev, is largely at 13,800 volts. There are 25-—
3.8 ky. feeders (four tie-lines tO Cahokia with 48,500 kw.
-in 13.8/33 Kv. transformers). | have got to mention that
at this point because, although it is located there and is
intimately connected with this sub-transmissionm system, it
was referred to and classified with the main transmission
sysiem, that is, those four feeders. They tie between the
Cahokia station and Ashley Street station.
| —2,646—
‘The balance, twelve 13.8 kv. feeders, go to five sub-stations
and customer sub-stations, and six feeders go to the down-
town network transformers.
The sub-station which we refer to as No. 6, and which is
located. within the Ashley Street power plant building, is a
4.160-volt, 8-phase, 4-wire distribution station. —° |
There are three gengrators connected to the 4,160-volt bus,
having a combined capacity of 42,000 kilewatts, and ip*addi-
tion, three feeders connected to the 13.8 kv. bus, through
“7,000 kilowatts of transformers. That is, there are several
, ° > ° ° \ °
uses In Ashley Street, all of which are duplicated, again at
Increased: cost, to obtain better service, and these buses are |
each used to supply certain load at the respective voltages,
and in addition,-each of these buses is connected with one or
hore of the others by a tie-transformer and cable.
The application there sounds complicated, but is re'atively
simple. It simply means that we have generation at/ more
than one voltage, and on more than one bus. We have dis-
tribution. to these sub-transmission cables at more than one
voltage. And in order that there may be available reserve
6163
6164
6165
6167,
6168
\ ——,
‘connected, and to which 25 feeders Are connected.
energy up to 13,200 volts; alsc eight 13,200-volt tie-line
energy can be exchanged.
‘the energy out to primarily the Edison sub-stations for con-
POG
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
service, each of these buses for the other, they themsely<¢
are tied together with sizeable transformer banks.
In the 25-¢ yele portion of the plant, there is a 6,600-volt
bus to which four turbines, aguregating 06,000 kilowatts, are
e —2,647—
i‘ourteen of the 6,600-volt feeders supply five D.C.
Stations with energy for their conversion equipment. Those
stations are going to supply the Edison 3-wire D.C. system.
Seven of the feeders go to five Public Service Company sub-
stations, and four feeders counect to 34,500 kilowatts in what
we call Sub-station Ne. 9, also located at or very close to the
Ashley Street powes plant building,
Substation 9 aas four transformers of a total capacity
of 34,500 kw., as mentianed above, which step the 25-cycle
cables connected to Page Avenue, over which the 25-cycle
More simply, and to clarify the general relationship, the
Keokak energy generated at Keokuk comes to St. Louis over
the high’ volt: we Inain transmission, line, is delivered to Page
Avenue, from which point that energy can either go to the
frequency changers and be converted and placed on a 60-
evele bus, or it can go down over these 13,200-volt under-
ground cables to this Sub-station No. 9, which is Ashley
Street, and there tie in on a 25-cyele bus to which the 25-
evele generating equipment is connected. —Off of that bus
there are distribution circuits, sub-transmission, which take
version (0 direct curtent. a)
A
¢
2057
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—VDirect
I betieve that describes that part of the plant sufficiently.
—2,648—
Q. Now, if you will, a similar explanation as to the por-
tion of the system in and about the Venice plant? A. The
Venice plant is not so complicated, it dees not have so many
facilities. It gets ‘its power away from the plant, in general,
by higher voltage lines and less of them. The Venice plant
at this time has three 33 kv. ‘ables supplying sub-stations
in St. Louis. Those are submarine cables across the river.
It also has two 66 ky. tower lines which supply transformers
of 48,000 kw. capacity in Federal Sub-station at Alton, That
sub-station will be described later.
The I]inois-lowa Power Company receives power at 66
ky. and transmits it over their own double-circuit tower
line into Dlinois tewards the north and east, going to
Staunton and a sub-station site known as Stallings.. We
have no-connection with that otber than to sell them power
at the power plant site, >
i The sub-transmission system at the Venice plant has
three step-down transformers of a combined ‘apacity of 40,-
000 kilowatts, reducing the voltage from 66 kv. to 33. kvy.,
and supplying the cables previously mentioned, which go to
St. Louis, to two sub-stations.
There are also two 66 kv. feeders, previously mentioned,
tor the entire Alton district is supplied. The details of the
capacity of that station. will be reserved for a little later
7 | | —2,649—
discussion, It is rather a major station in our system.
/.
/
/
/
going to feed sub-stations at which point the general service
6169.
6171
61
61
73
74
L2058
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
The Venice sub-transmission system, under discussion
liere, is being modified and supplied in a somewhat different
manner at the present time, due entirely to the construction
of the new Venice station.
The concentration of all of the power in that location
at 66,000 volts, without any segregation by transformers,
would produce, by -the time the plant was extended to its
second section, such heavy short-circuits that system relia-
bility would be impaired. This does not mean tliat we could
not go ahead with the present service as now rendered,
which is highly satisfactory, but it does mean that at some
time in the future we. might be required to change the meth-
ods. We have looked into that matter carefully, und ana-
lyzed the possible effects On service, and have decided that
we are justified in spending the necessary money today to
connect those circuits into the new plant onto the 13,S00-
volt bus, and we are purchasing new step-up trahsformers to
do that. That is a question which in many cases, I think,
might be resolved on the theory that everything is all right,
why not let well enough alone.
We could save the price of four large transformers if
we were willing to risk the reduction in the grade of service
on the system. We have obtained approval to buy, these
SL
I like to bring these points out, because they represent.
transformers.
the added investment that is necessary in acsystem of this
kindif you intend to deliver the very best grade of service
Which you possibly can, and in a concentrated district, I
think that that is the only attitude to take. The service
demands that type of reliability.
nl
2049
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
”
° there at Venice. These three feeders which have been de-
scribed will be removed, the transformer will be removed, and
used elsewhere, and the new transformers will be located in
a row along the river on top of the levee, and each one of
these will be supplied directly from our new 13,800-volt
buses which were mentioned yesterday in the design of -the
new plant, and feed across the river very similarly to the
Cahokia feeders, through the underground submarine cables.
‘Q. Turning. new to the Cahokia plant, will you give simi-
lar information as to the sub-transmission system in and
about it? A. The facilities in and about Cahokia are, of
course, many times more extensive than any of our other sta- ©
tions, and yet there is ample room to get all of these facilities
“out in an orderly and very simple manner, which we now
appreciate. That is to say. the judgment which was used
initially in locating Cahokia and in acquiring adequate land
when the company obtained it, and in anticipating what the
picture wouJd look like 20 years later, has: certainly paid
a
ee” A) 2 65 —_
dividends. That is to say, it is making the station one of
excellent design today, whereas a lack of such foresigt it
would have crimped the situation entirely.
I like to point to Cahokia as being a station with as many
facilities going out of it as any that I know’of, and yet it
does not appear to be congested, and it is operating with per-
feet reliability. ‘s
z
The difficulties at Cahokia are few and far between, ‘ded :
hever Very serious.
I have very little-else that I think need be mentioned |
6175
6176
6177
2060
me
6178 Stanley Stokes~By Respondents—Direct
The plant has two 66 kv. circuits leading from the out- -
door sub-station:in the yard, supplying power to the Illinois. —
Iowa Power Company at Belleville. Those two feeders have
ON ee Oe a Ee
rv
been previously mentioned under our main transmission sys-
tem,: but because we are describing the supply to this area,
I mention them again.
PUNK BALE ISIE DTI.
7
CMS ES TALES B50
% Three 33 ky. feeders go to a sub-station in East St. Louis,
known as Winstanley, as well as one known as Main, and
: Lake Avenue sub-station. |
, 6179 =‘ Three 13.8 k. v. feeders supply a large number of cus-
i tomer sub-stations in East St. Louis, and the surrounding
: industrial area. That is, these three feeders, which have a
capacity of roughly 3,500 to 5,000 kilowatts each,:go around
OSS SE ak A
and tap various industiial plants where the plant itself owns
its own sub-station. We supply them with power. |
| jena — 2,652—
The larger portion of the power from the Cahokia
station crosses the river into St. Louis through a combined
total capacity of 202,500 kw. in 13.8/33 kv., step-up trans-
formers. These cables supply power to 12 A.C. sub-stations
en Re a A Mls aml oe a Ot ae Sli OF
which are connected ‘through 24—33 kv. submarine cables,
where they cross the river, and thence, by. ordinary under-.
ground lead cable in ducts, to the’sub-station. One A.C.
sub-station is supplied with power by two 13.8 kv. cables.
Four D.C. sub-stations receive power oyer four 13.8"
ky. cables. This makes a-total of 17 A.C. ‘and D.C. sub-
stations supplied by 30 cables.
At this point I would like to digress just a moment to
| illustrate that when we were describing, the 25-cycle system”
| ee at Ashley Street going into the sub-transmission feeders,
e
2061
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
we mentioned that some of those feeders supplied the sub-
stations which convert from 25-cycle to D.C. Xow from
Cahokia you have a similar group of 60-cycle féeders which
go to similar conversion sub-stations to convert to the D.C.
for the Edison system.
Thus we have about 34,000 kw. all told of Edison D.C.
load which is about equally supplied from 25-cycle and 60-
cycle systems, Thus, the most severe case of trouble that
you could conceive, which might conceivably, under that
assumption, shut down one whole system, either 25 or 60-
cycle, would still affect only half of the Edison system, be-
cause they are ‘not electrically ‘connected: between the 25
| / —2,653—
and 60 cycles in such a way that they can possibly affect
each other to any extent.
Thus, the degree of reliability Which we have obtaingd
on the Edison system by the use of the two frequencies in
Niat manner, would be impossible, as far as I know, to obtain
otherwise. The record of this Edison system has been very
good indeed. 7
4. Where is the Edison system located? A. That Edi-
son-sygfem represents the main downtown, heavy business
distri¢t, running about 10 or 11 blocks north and south, and
possibly 16 to 18 blocks east. and west. It is a very small
and dénse area. The Joad density in that area is comparable
with any part. of New York except a very few blocks right
in the Manhattan area. It is higher than the density of
New York outside of that point. But it is a very small
area, if only measures .4 square miles. It has, at the present_
time, about 75,000 kw. in that little area, which, if you-
divide it by .4, is a very high-load density.
GO1sl
§182
6183
Ais SIC AS BAN eb LEN I Oi LE hh
we nv <couemeemenh meres ry:
3 ;
Ta
6184
6185
/
6186
2062
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
= additional load in that area is being taken on the
A. ©. low-voltage network.
aes no further details need be mentioned of the tie-
system between Cahokia and Venice, or rather Cahokia and
Ashley Street. There are transformers at Cahokia which
supply these tie-cables to Ashley Street, just as there were
at Ashley. Those cables, by the way, are 450,000 cm. con-
ductors, on those tie- lines, whereas the majority of our cables
—2,654—
are 350,000 cm. Those are large cables. :
Q. Now, similar information as to the portion of the \y
system around the Rivermines plant? A. Rivermines, as you
will recall on Exhibit: No. 51, was located at the southern
/end of our system, and is a major switching station on the.
Osage-Rivermines-Crystal City-Cahokia circuit. That can
all be regarded now as one transmission cirguit.” We de
scribed it in sections yesterdiiy, but it is all eontiguous, and .
this switching station at Rivermines permits the segregation
of that circuit into the section running between Rivermines
\and Osage, or between Rivermines and St. Louis, by auto-
matic, high-voltage switching, in such a way that as long as
any one of the four circuits feeding into Rivermines is
available, service vin, be supplied. The result is that the
St. Joseph Lead Company, with roughly 27,008 to 30,000
kilowatts of mining load, depends exclusively on our service
for their operations, which is quite a compliment to the
service. They,had always felt that in addition to any kind
of outside sérvice supply, they should have a reserve steam
plant, tuv. We have the plant there but we don’t find it :
necessary to operate it; they do not insist upon it. When
2063 -
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct 628% |
they used to carry their own load with their own plant, they
had an insurance policy with Lloyds which would pay the
most fabulous sum in case a tornado took away their plant.
I wish I could recall the exact figure, because it showed a
—2,655—
sei example of the attitude that they had as a measure of
the value of that service. If that plant should be blown
away, they would be paid something on the order of $50,000
- aday for the length of time required to rebuild it.
Q. From whom was the Rivermines plant acquired? 6188
NA. We parchased the plant from the St. Joseph Lead Com- :
ping.) |
Now in connection with this switching station which is
‘the means of furnishing continuous service on these Osage -
3 circuits, we have- located at Rivermines two 25,000 k. v. a.
synchronous condensers. Those are rotating machines which
are used to control the voltage on the transmission lines. It
~is a peculiar fact, ‘well known to electrical people, that what
is known as a leading current, meaning a current in which
the voltage lags behind the current in the ordinary oscilla-
tion, if it were to be plotted you would find the current 6189
leading the voltage by certain angular degrees. When we
_ have a leading current: flowing through an inductance, a
voltage drop is obtained. This voltage drop, instead of sub-
tracting from the generating voltage as un ordinary voltage -
drop would do, is: added in such a direction—this being a
vector addition—is added in such a direction as to cause
‘the voltage to rise’ It is a rather peculiar phenomenon, but.
advantage is taken-of that fact so that by operating a machine ©
. Which is in all respects oquiy alent to a generator or motor,
eral ers: eRe —2 ,656—
6190
6191
6192
_with a very high field excitation, that machine will absorb
2064
Stanley s tokes—By Respondents—Direct
the reactive flow of power, cause a ieading current to flow
in the main transmission jine, and when flowing through a
transformer will actually produce a voltage drop which adds
“to the generated voltage in such a way as to increase the
total. The voltage at the end of the line, removed from the
generator, can be made to rise instead of drop.
Those machines are automatically controlled to maintain
voltage at any point desired, and to maintain the power
factor of the transmission line as required.
Those facilities, again, are a measure of the service re-
liability. One of those 25,000 kw. machines. is adequate to
handle the transmission system. The other one is in there
purely as a reserve unit and for additional reliability.
Off of this sub-station is tapped a transformer station,
and that transformer station supplies a sub-station contain-
ing a number of 6,900-volt feeders. Those feeders suppiy the
St. Joseph Lead Company direct. It has on the order of
50,000 k. v. a. of distribution transformers scattered around
over the mining district there.
In addition to that, this same step-down sub-station from
138 ky. down to 6.9 kv., supplies another sub-station from
which several 33,000-volt supply feeders radiate to handic
that area for normal commercial and residential purposes. .
| Te 7 —2,657—
‘The switching station itself at this point, on: the low
voltage side of the transformers, consists of a four-story
building, filled with oil switches and cells and structures,
just as any power plant would be, and the switchboard itself
is, I should say, approximately 200 feet long, with one panel
right after another. It is a very large installation.
2065
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
I should like to give some detailed figures as to the
number of these circuits which I have just described.
There are twelve 6,900-volt main feeders; two 5,900-volé
feeders go to 15,000 kilowatts of 6.9,/33 ky. step-up trans-
formers, through oii cireait breakers, to a 35 ky. outdoor sub-
station. That is the one thet supplies the local area through
five 33 ky. overhead lines. Those lines go north to Festus,
Missouri-—I don’t believe the town is indicated on Exhibit
51, but it is adjacent to Crystal City, whichis shown on the
exhibit; also to a number of other towns in the surrounding
district there, among which I can mention Farmington, Bi:
marck and Fredericktown, the latter being shown on Exhibit
No. 51.
Two feeders supply the towns of Flat River, Bonne Terre,
De Soto, Vietoria—these towns all within a radius of 25 or
30 miles of, that station—with service. This cireuit, which
was mentioned as going north to Festus; is primarily used
“as reserve supply for that town, it having another source at a
sub-station at Crystal City which is shown on the exhibit.
| | —2,658—
One circuit out of this. Rivermines sub-station delivers
energy to the Arkansas-Missouri Power Corporation for their
_ Supply in Southeast Missouri. That is not a major connec-
tion and I am not sure whether it is shown on this exhibit,
Exhibit $1. Yes, I find it is shown here as “A-16”, the point
of deliveny, ;
At Crystal City, which is indicated on the exhibit, we have
another sub-station which supplies. primarily, first, the plant
of the Pittsburgh Plate Glass Company, a large glass manu-
facturing industry who receive service at main transmission
6193
6194
6195
at Rs NANO N BN Pa BS CRS lr se aS
‘
6196
6197
6108
2066
%
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
voltage of 138 kv., and who transform it down through their :
own transformers, and who own their own sub-station,
That is a very extensive and very interesting connection
at that point. That is just a couple or three spans away
from that river crossing which we described previously, and
the difficulties of construction continued right on over to
the plant. There is a very high blut? and some rugged hills
and then a railroad yard and a small river or creek, with no
place to locate towers. Seo the last spar into the Glass Com-
pany had to be carried for some distance and terminated on
a tower 150 or 175. feet in height, in the Glass Company’s
yard, which they themselves provided.
It is a very rugged structure. Also, due to the alkali
fumes which the Glass Company emits, we had to change
from an aluminum to a copper weld steel in this last span.
It also developed that we had to terminate on this receiving
" 9 659—
structure in a horizontal position and were leaving the top of
this high hill in a vertical posit‘on. The middle arms of
this double-circuit tower had a large offset, that is, they were
Jonger than the top and bottom, and in attempting to rotate
these circuits from the vertical to the horizontal plane, with
that offset in the arm, you cannot obtain safe clearances in.
‘the middle of the span. We anticipated the difficulty and
made up a few model spans, and convinced ourselves that it
just wouldn’t work that way. So we located the long arm at
the top, and rotated the two circuits in opposite directions.
That changed the phase position of the conductors on the
terniinal tower.
We notified the Glass Company of this position, and gave
them a diagram showing the position of the conductors. In
2067
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
other words, if you numbered them they would be A, B, C--
B, C, A, instead.of A, B, C—A, B, C—and even at that, they
got into a little difliculty in the preliminary development. of
the problem, because they didn’t particularly recgive our dia-
gram with suflicient care, having been used to using single-
phase transformers, and figuring that they could. make their
connections anywhere they wanted to on the low-voltage side
. of the transformers. . |
As an actual fact, when they went to make these connec-
tions they found that they had to make a change in the trans-
—2,660—
formers to do it.
Service has been very satisfactory with that customer,—
in fact, it has been one of the satisfactions in my work to
deal with that particular customer. I made the original
arrangements, and have negotiated with them from time to
tine in connection with change of contracts, and in -every
respect the relationships have been extremely satisfactory.
We, in-ene or two cases, felt we were leaning over a
little hackward .in the arrangements that we made with the
customer, but at a later date we wanted to change the service
and extend these lines to Rivermines, and the customer
reciprocated, and we felt well repaid.
The sub-station at this Crystal City plant of the Pitts-
burgh Plate Glass Company is operated jointly by ourselves
and the customer for our mutual economy. .That is a rather
interesting situation there in which they have their own
operators, we have the,cvmmunication lines in there, we
divide the cost of operating the sub-station, and in turn
they supply to us through their transformers, voltage which
6199
6200
6201
620°
6203
6204
2068 oi
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents— Direct
Y
we step up to 33,000 volts, and in turn we supply our local
urea at Festus, Crystal City and Herculaneum, three cities
adjacent to each other. | a fs
- That arrangement has been very much cheaper than for
each of us to do thiathing by ourselves. In addition to
that we have, within the last year, negotiated a contract
: | —2,661—
which gives.us permission anytime we wish, to install our
own transformers, 'of larger capacity, in their_yard, and to
utilize all of the facilities of the high tension spans, towers,’
switches, and so forth, and supply our. own service with them, —
thus giving them the full capacity of their own banks. This _
anticipates a joint growth of load on their part and ours, teo,
and it is interesting tu realize that after operating on a
joint basis since 1925, we are both willing and glad to enter
into an agreement to continue such operations.
That sub-station has..two 10,000 k.v.a. transforimers,
stepping from 132 kv. te 2,2f volts. We step it baek up.
from 2,300 voits to 33,000, through two 3,000 k. v. a. sub-
stations.° At the time this agreement was entered into,
we had just gone into the new district and were supplying
service and had a load of only about 650 kw. ourselves.- That
load has multiplied many times since then, but we could ‘not
‘have justified a separate high-voltage sub-station for our
own purposes. At the present time our load is big enough
so that we could justify it, but we still find it economical
to work this joint arrangement, although we are going to
eliminate the double step-down and step-back-up voltage
practice. }
There is one other sub-station which I should like tb
mention, and it is located on the north route of the 138 kv.
/
2069
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents. Direct
trapsmission line between Osage and Page Avenue, and is
marked as a square with the letter “A” on Exhibit No. 51.
That is located in Franklin County. That is, as far as I
; | —2,662—
know, the only fully automatic, high-voltage sub-station of
its type, although others are in contemplation.
It has been operating with great success for two years,
It has two high-voltage sw itches which connect on the 138 ky.
lines, an automatic transfer system to provide a certain type
of selective service; one bank of transformers which step the
voltage down to 33,000 volts; and the low-voltage facilities.
One of the interesting features of this sub-station is that
it was intended to be a fully automatic, unattended station,
-locited out in a country district some 6 miles from the near-
est town. The requirements were that no operations of this
station should interfere with the service of the main trans-
mission iine in so far as it is at all possible to do sa.
So far, no such interference has been observed. This
requirement, however, placed .very serious restrictions on
the time available for relay and switching operations. The
stability limits of the Osage-Page circuits were snch.that 8°
cycles was the longest time that we were permitted to use in
clearing the circuit in case of trouble. If a short-circuit |
were to occur on one of the outgoing 35 ky. feeders, from this
Franklin County sub- station, and if that short-circuit were
adjacent to the-sub-station, calculations showed that it would
| ‘ —2,668—
be able to interfere with the main transmission line.
. Therefore, we would have to get that service off even
quicker. The result was this, that we developed, in consul-
6°05
6206
6207
6209
6210
2070
Stanley Stokes—By Respondernts—Direct
tation with the General Electric Company, a devire which
they ‘call a relay, but which is really about half a dozen or
sO relays, mounted in a glass case, and those relays measure’
the distance of this accidental fault from the sub-station.
If that fanlt is mere than a mile and a half, we delay the
_ operation of the 33 kv. switching, giving time for the in-
dividual 33 kv. supply lines that go out through that district
to clear. By that 1 mean, if you have 5 such circuits, which
-we have, if there is trouble on one of them, we wouldn't
anticipate that, but we will let it clear itself if it can be done
within 10 or 12 cycles. |
If, however, iat fault is closed to the station, this relay
system uses a little judgment and we clear out the main
switch in the sub-station, which will interrupt all five of
those 33 ky. circuits, rather than interrupt the main trans-
mission line, and then they are all re-closed immediately. I
should have mentioned that this station is not only auto-
matic on the transfer from one circuit to another on the
high-voltage line, but also automatically reclosing and iinal-
ly locks itself out and rings a beli after the third operation.
It has only locked out once, as far as [ know, and that was
due to a snake climbing 30 feet up a steel structure, which
| —2,664—
they are not supposed to do. When I say that, I mean that
it is the general belief out West in the prairies that if you
lay a lariat or steel cable or steel rope around your tent, a
snake will not crawl over it. I used to do it with regularity
when I worked for the Utah Power & Light. But there isa
slight spitting due to corona on these sharp points around ©
such a station, and it makes a little hiss, and the natives
2071
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
| i
have assured us that the snake thought there were some birds
up there, and went up after them. We got the snake, but he
didn’t get the birds.
That instance was the only leck-out- that we-have had,
that IT know of. ae 5
This sub-station in Franklin County is designed to re-
place the present, transformers with larger ones at any time
that the service”requires it, and the sub-station ean readily
be brought up to any convenient capacity, such as 25,000 or
even 50,000 kilowatts. The immediate requirements ure
small, and the present capacity is, I believe, four 3,333 k. v. a.
transformer units.
The units themselves are single-phase. The reason for
that was that the.weight of the 3-phase transformers was
too great to handle over the roads and the bridges, and even
taking the ones we did, we had to block up under some of
the bridges. | |
I think that covers the main sub-stations of Rivermines,
Crystal City, and the Franklin County sub-station.
—2,665—
The Examiner: Let us have a short recess at this
time.
(Whereupon, 2 short recess was taken, after
which the hearing was resumed. )
By Mr. Hamitton:
Q. In addition to the sub-stations you have already re-
ferred ta;,in the sub-transmission system, are there any
6211
6212
6213
6214
2072
ee
a...
Stanley Stokes—By Respondertts-—Direct
other sub-stations of major importance in the system? A.
Yes, there are at least two important stations that I should
like to mention, They are a little different than the stations
so far mentioned, namely, in that they are large sub-stations
at the end of the sub-transmission system.
, One of them is the Federal station at Alton, which covers
what we call the Alton district. The town lies about 25
miles north of East St. Louis, and has considerable heavy
_ industrial load in the area, The sub-station is supplied from
2 the two 66,000 volt lines that go north from Venice to Alton,
and it, in turn, is a switching station and transforms the
voltage to 33,000 volts, and distributes it over a mumber of
rather high capacity 33,000 volt circuits, going to such cus-
tomers as the Laclede Steel Company, and the Owens-Hlinois
Glass Company. |
It also supplies a sub-station for the City of Alton, known
as the Liberty Street station. |
The capacity of that station-at the present time is 48,000
_ kilowatts, and the circuits having been recently enlarged, we
6216
2 5666—
expect to transmit ultimately 45,000 kilowatts on either
circuit, and will expand that sub-station.
The load is growing very rapidly in that district. In-
eluded in the customers supplied from this, I should not over-
look the Shell Company. They have a load which has been
increasing at the rate of from 500 to 1,000 kilowatts a month
for the last six months, and an anticipated load of about
14,000 kilowatts by the end of next year. The present load
is around 12,500 to 13,000. oe |
-"\
2073
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—liirect
Loads of that character are quite a responsibility for an
electric company, and we have had Very successful service
for that refinery. |
The other sub-station which I should like to mention is
the Webster Groves station. This is located in St. Louis
County, west a few miles from the St. Louis city limits.
Three 33 kv. circuits from the Cahokia plant are brought
in to the 33‘kv. outdoor sub-station at Webster Groves. From
this sub-station, two 33 Kv. circuits go west and north, sup-
plying energy to the various towns and villages, and supply-
ing a reserve circuit which goes to Franklin County and ties
in with that automatic sub-station which I have previously
described here. |
In addition to the switching station supplying outgoing
33 kv. feeders at Webster Groves, it also supplies consider-
able capacity in step-down distribution transformers for
local distribution. That will be covered a little more ex-
| | = 2,667—
tensively in our discussion on the lower-yoltage distribution
system: 2
t believe that that covers all of the sub-stations which
(feel should be specifically described. You appreciate that
there ure a large number of these stations which are of a
. Somewhat lesser jmportance than those mentioned, and I
could go into.a detailed description of them for hours. But
the typical larger ones have been described.
(). Is the sub-transmission system in the St. Louis area
designed to insure reliability of service? A. It very definitely
is. That is a’ point that I alluded to a little earlier in my
discussion, that the multiplicity of interconnections of these
eae
§219
2074
6220 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
33 kv. sub-transmission circuits in St.Louis, and St. Louis
County particularly, and to a large extent in the rest of the
area, provide an opportunity to restore service, in the event
of outage, very quickly, and in addition to that, provide sufli-
cient capacity that such outage should have no effect on the
service itself. .
The 33 kv: ¢xCuits in St. Louis County criss-cross in the
form of squares on most of the main roads, and by changing
the disconnecting switch positions, the circuits can be routed
6221 in different configurations, so that our Page Avenue sub-
station could supply the City of Kirkwood, for example, or
Kirkwood could pave been supplied equally well out of the
Webster Groves Gas In the event there is any highway
: Bile a4 —2,668—
work goirg on, of which there has been a great deal in recent
years, we try to keep at least one reserve circuit supplying
these major communities, on a highway which is not being
“» constructed, that is, the pole lines are either parallel with the
highway or back on private right-of-way a few feet. And
there is always the possibility of the highway work causing
222 some damage, due to blasting or otherwise. So the facilities
for intérconneciion are very extensive.
The feeders for this sub-transmission system are operated
_in parallel on the low-tension side of the transformers, that
is, the cables leading from the main high-voltage transmis-
sion system out to this receiving sub-station are usually
operated as a cable and a transformer, each cable having its
own transformey, and the switching being done on the supply
side of the iranaformer at the source, and on the receiving
side of the transformer at the receiving end.
2075 Pe
Stanley Stokes—By Respondcnts—Direct
The result is that we keep the short-circuits down by>
that method. | | |
On the low-voltage side of the receiving sub-statian, we
have a regular standard bus construction with all the low- .
voltage circuits in parallel; supplied through oil switches.
Q. You referred to tl rather extensive use of under-
ground cables in St. Lonis, and the area more or less con-
tiguous to St. Louis, in St. Louis County. Is the matter of
cable loadings a subject of considerable investigation by
—2,669—_
the’ Unien Electric Group? <A. Yes, it is. We have had to
do rather an unusual amount of work in this connection in
establishing suitable cable ratings, the reason \being that
St. Louis has very high ground temperatures in the summer.
Our water mains reach a temperature of 90 and above in
dry, hot summers, and we have Lad a temperature of 94
in the Mississippi River water at thet point. -
—2,670-—
To bring out the extremes to which some of those condi-
tions get to in 1936, which was our all-time hot year, the
: river water going into Caliokia at a temperature above 90,
went through the boiler room concrete fleor and into the
: shower baths, where the men cleaned up after working hours,
and the water got so hot that they couldn’t take a bath. That
Was just due to the temperature of the water all being—
already being 95 when it came into the building, and passing
-through the boiler ro6m floors where there was heat in the
concrete, and the cold water got so hot that they couldn't
Stand it and complained. That condition is not general.
Therefore, other cities can be of little help to us, and we have
to work out our own\ rating by experience.
£99
6224
6225
6226
2076
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
9 We have gradually developed a sort of discount table that
We can apply to what are generally conceded to be conserva-
tive cable ratings, and we have to use a little lower rating
im the summertime. We establish what we call emergency
rating cn a cable, and that, j is the highest load which we will
% ‘put on that cable in the surimertime. Then we have a ‘normal
622
6228
rating which represents thie maximum load that we would be
willing to carry on the cable at all other times. Those loads
have to be taken into consideration with the number of hours
which they operate because the cable and duct system heat up
gradually as the load is increased.
A cable which has been running cool over » Raturdey and
Sunday, can carry much*more steady load Monday than it
—2,671—
could on Tuesday, because it has had 36 hours to cool off. The
result a that the matter of cable ratings is really a com-
plieated subject.
Ouy present conclusions are these. A 450,000 cm. which
‘is the largest\size we use regularly in the 33,000-volt service,
is rated at 13.8 kv. at 7,730 k. v. a.; at 33 kv., at 16,500 k. v.a.,
each. 8
The normal oferation of such a cable would be to have
two supplies to a sub-station. The result is that the normal
load would be 50 per cent. or less, because there will be two
cables supplying this load. And the only time thai the load
would go up to these values would be when one cable is out.
Now, of course, it is >ntirely likely—in. fact, it is verv prob-
able—that neither cable willbe out during the hot weather,
in which case we could have increased that load to possibly
a couple of thousand, kilowatts higher, but we can’t assume—
,
Me
o
stanley Stokes—By Respondents-—Direct
that, so we limit the emergency rating, which is the rating
we will put on the cable when theother cable is out of service,
to these values. :
For a 350,000 cm., 3-conductor cable, which is the one
we use the most of, we. have 6,680 k. v. a. at 13,000 volts, and
14,500 k. v. a. at 33,000 voits.
The other two sizes, which’are in rather general use, are -
“4/0, rated at 5,030 k. v. a. at 13,000 volts, and 11,000 k. v. a. at
—2,672—
33,000 volts. The smaller one, 1/0, is similarly rated at
3,480 and 7,400. .
If we have a large number of these cables in a duct, cr
if we know that there are other cables in the street adjacent
to it, we apply a correction factor and reduce the rating
accordingly. In other words, we have got to make allowance
for the total heat liberated within a yiven ground area, and
as a result of considerable study and analysis of che life —
of cables in the St. Louis district, we feel fairly satisfied.
with these ratings. There is one question, however, and that
is it is entirely possible that some of these emergency ratings
can be materially increased without actually damaging the
cable. That is receiving much study at the present time.
Damage to cables is being carefully anatyzed and a post
mortem, so to speak, carried on after each cable failure, with
extreme care, trying to find ont why the cable failed. We
found that, among other things, the creepage of these cables
‘in the.duets, due to expansion and contraction with tempera-
ture changes, was such as to cause a crystallization of the
lead at the point where the cable leaves the duct and goes
into the manhole, and that many of these failures were
6229
6230
6231
6232
6233
6234
2078
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
attributable to such causes as that, and not directly to the
high temperatures. If those prove to be the majority of the
troubles, then it wiil be possible, by using more care in the
design of cable and duct arrangements, to actually run these
cables to much higher temperatures without ——
2,673—
There are some experiments being carried on to determine
that, and it takes several years to be sure of these figures.
It would mean a great deal to any company to be able to
increase these ratings by even 10 per cent., because the
investment in the cable system is huge. _
One other expedient that has been adopted i is this. Ww here
we go through a soil that we know to be particularly a poor
heat conductor, for example cinders, a cinder fill, we have
learned to increase the size of the cable. We wiil put ina
section of 450,000 em. in ‘a cable where the rest of it is
350,000 cm., thereby reducing the losses in that section, and
hence reducing the heat and es the temperature down
that way.
Q. Are the present. sub- transmission facilities of the
Union Electric group adequate for present loading and fer
presentiy anticipated loading? A. They are, and in addition
they have a large reserve capacity. : The approximate ratio
of loads on some of these cables, to their maximum capability —
or capacity, may be illustrated.
- The particular examples that I am using here are taken
from some alternating current sub-stations in the City of St.
Louis, but it would be equally applicable to any* of the
others. These happen to be more convenient to obtain the
information on.
—2,674—
2079
>
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct |
In a list of 23 stations which I prepared, the highest
loa ing that I could find was 75 per cent. of the capacity of
the transformer banks, and this occurred at the Page
Avenue station. That station is scheduled for an addition
in the near future.
The next highest loading in this group was 67 per cent.,
at a station known as Lesperance. That is still satisfactory .
down there at that station because of the interconnection
with other stations. If that were 100 per cent., we could
still operate satisfactory because we have ties with other
stations that would carry part of that load.
In general, looking over this group, we find figures as
low as 28 per cent., 30 per cent., 32 per cent., and the result
is that the average ratio of load to capacity does not exceed
about 50 per cent.
Q. Now, that percentages, is that the peak on the par-
ticular sub-station? A. The peak on the particular sub-
station, yes. It may not be at the time of the system peak.
That has no interest to a particular sub-station. It is only
concerned with ifs own annual peak.
“I might sh ca there is as much capacity in some
of these stations in reserve as there is. That is, if there
could be any criticism of this ratio it would be that we
haven’t got these stations loaded up high enough.
—2,675—
The answer is that a good many of these stations are
relatively new, and it is not practicable to put in these high
voltage underground cables and ducts ip small sizes. The
duct cost is high, and the cest of a 10,000 kw.-33 kv. cable
is only slightly moré than one of smaller size. In other
6235
6236
6237
\
6238 -
6239
6240
2680
2 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents-—Direct
words, the insulating requirements are the same, the dead
sheath isn’t much different, and whether you put 2 /smalj
wire in or a big wire, you have spent pretty near as) much
money. eee j
Therefore, it is better to put them i in as bigias as you intend
to put them in ultimately, even though you_have to carry
the fixed charges for a few years. The result is that we
change transformers as needed, and ship them from the
larger staticns to the smaller ones, but cables are usually
put in with ample capacity, and in these downtown or city
stations, we put tlie transformers in to match the cable.
Within a few years that ratio will be higher on these low
_ yalues. The lew values will increase, in other words, we
will have the stations Ipjded up toa higher ratic, but the
high values will be kept down for transfer of. load or add-
ing additional capacities. In general, there. is ample
capacity in this systém to handle much additional lead.
Q. Now, will you summarize the number of feedets on
the sub-transmission system, giving a total figure, if you
will? <A. The sub-transmission system has a total-of 226
feeders on both the 25 and 60 cycle systems, and they are
approximately equally divided between hove two.
—2,676—
As an example, I have 66 kv., 60 cycle feeders; 25 cycle
and total. :
There are 6-60 cycle feeders ; 3-25; and 9 total.
Now, if I go through the different voltages and the dif-
ferent frequencies in that manner, I arrive at 117-60 cycle
feeders, of all voltages from 66,000 volts down to 6,600; and
109-25 cycle feeders, or a total of 226. These are not io be
F i
Os]
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
confused with the ordinary small distribution feeder, but
they represent capacities from 5 to 15 thousand kw. each.
Q. At the outset of your discussion of the sub-tranamis-
sion system, you indicated that the sub-transmission system
/
represented the link to the distribution ee
now to ‘the distribution sub-stations, vou are_eble to state
the total number represented in the Union Electric Company
‘ . . * S nn ae . :
group? <A. These distribution substations which receive
their power from the sub-traysmission system and distribute
‘it to the moderate low voltage distribution sub-stations, rep--
resent 63 alternating current and 9 direct current sub-sta-
tions in the Union Eleetric group, with an investment in
excess of $11,600,000 in land, structures and. equipment.
The total connected capacity of these stations is 643,000
kilowatts and they range from a 100-kilowatt station to one
of 42.590 kilowatts. That summarizes the distribution sta-
tions. : |
te —2,677—
Q. I think-you might state at this point; in order to clarify
any description you may give of the distribution sub-stations,
. the general character of your distribution system, whether,
network, radial or direct current? A. Our distribution sys
tem is, to a large extent, what is known as the radial systém,
preponderantly so. This is the result of long years of his-
torical growth, combined with many factors that male this
the most economical arrangement for our conditions.
In addition to the radia] A.C. distribution systetn, we
have a low voltage A.C. network in the downtown district.
This supplies service té the customer at 120/208 volts, and
it is supplied from a series of what are known as network
transformers. |
§241
§242
6244 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
These are in turn supplied from a 13,800 volt sub-trans-
mission system. | o s
At the present time I should like to place tnore emphasis
on the radial system. In the St. Louis district we have, as
previously described, supplied our distribution sub-stations
by means of 33,000 volt and 13,000 volt underground cable,
ayd-in a great part of the city we still are able to retain the
distribution on the low voltage side as an overhead system.
2 We removed 5 miles of this system every year, and replace it
7 es with underground sapply. It is appreciated that this type
- of system is adapted to what is known as the radial system.
The other systems have a feature of using a large number
| —2,678—
of small sub-stations, and a radial system uses a smaller
number of larger sub-stations.
The result is that the radial system economizes on the
cost or investment in the supply facilities of the sub-trans-
mission feeders.
In St. Louis these facilities represent the most expensive
- part of the system and therefore, to economize on the supply
6246 facilities is a little better for us than to reduce the cost of
the low voltage distribution, which is already less expensive.
That is not true in all areas, or in all cities. The 9 sub-
stations supply the 120/240 volt direct current system,
which covers 1.15 square miles in downtown St. Louis. This
: is not what apparently might be regarded as an error in the;
area, which I previously stated as .4 square miles. The
downtown D.C. district extends beyond the particular area
to which I referred as an extremely’dense area,
- In these 9 sub-stations there are 19 motor generators
totalling 27,800 kw. and 10°synchronous converters, totalling
21,400 kw. .
2083
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
I have previously described the extreme reliability with
which this service is supplied, coming from both the 25 and
the 60 cycle systems, each being independent of the other.
The Yesuit of this high degree of reliability permitted us to
do away with storage batteries in 1925, and maintain the
same degree of reliability on cur Edison system that certain
| —2,679—
other companies were obtaining with the addition of storage
batteries. They were the most expensive single part of the
operation of the Edison system, and it has always been our
belief that had storage batteries been eliminated in general
throughout the country in the early days, and had more
automatic equipment been installed on these Edison sub-
stations, that the attitude throughout the country on_the
kdison systems might have been different.
We do not regard it ourselves as being a particularly ex-
pensive. system to operate. We are not extending it, but we
feel that it has a high degree of reliability, and that it is
probably equal to the best grade of service that can ever be
* rendered by any other system. . 7
The new A.C. current network which is being installed
and rapidly-extended is the nearest prototype to the Edison
three-wire system which can be produced with an A.C. sys-
tem. It should give equally reliable service.
I would like to point out here that we obtained the bene-
fit, through these years, of pioneering work] done in the
development of fully automatic sub-stationsyand the public
as obtained the economy of the—in the elimination of these
huge batteries over. many years, because of the successful
6247
6248
6249
6250
6251
6252 |
bid I ho |
y
Stanley Stokes--By Respondents—Direct
operation of the automotized sub-stations. The longer we
stuck strictly to tmanual operation, we could not d6 these
things quickly enough to maintain the service. The storage
; | —2,680—
battery was a necessity.
The total capacity in the D. |. equipment is 49,200 kw.,
23,444 being supplied from the 25 cycle system. You will
notice there wha a nice balance that is, 50 per cent. roughly
being supplied for each system, and by overload and a little
excessive loading of cables, if we lost one whole systeni, either
25 or 60 cycles, we would deliver reasonably satisfactory
service in the downtown area. That is a high degree of re-
serve.
Service on the new 120/208 volt, low voltage, A. C. net-
work, was inaugurated on May 20, 1939. This network now
covers the entire D. C. district, but it is not yet fully loaded, -
nor anywhere near it. It is an unfortunate situation that to
put in a thoroughly reliable A. C. network requires that it
must practically be put in all at one time, and thai ail 6 of the
supply feeders be provided in the beginning. There have been
some sporadic attempts in various locations to economize on
he installation of a A. C. network, and put in only part of it
at a time, hoping to go into the rest. The results were net
very happy. In other words, the fundamental basic principle
of the A. C. network is that these network transformers
located in the vaults, of which mention has previously been
made, shall be supplied from at least three pairs of circuits,
so that the loss of even any one or-two of them will have-ne
effect on the service, and the loss of the whole network vault
will not affect the service. | . —2,681—
2085
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
An illustration could be made in this way. Network
transformers are designed to have at least a 50 per cent. over-
load rating, and also a very high short-time rating. If we
wanted to supply 3,000 kilowatts of very essential service—I
am describing now a type of service where you want to get
the best there is—the two installations which are exactly
equivalent and done in the same manner are the Rad? City
installations, which everyone in the country has heard of, and
one Which so many have not heard of, but which is a complete
and duplicate arrangement, located in St, Louis, being in-
stalled this summer for a very large department store, an air-
conditioning installation.
There we want to have 3,000 kilowatt service for that
‘building, which cannot’ be interfupted for any one of almost
ay nuiber of reasons. The result is that if we were to lose
one of those four 1,000 kilowatt transformers, which are
instavled, we could still supply the 8,000 kw. service. If we
were to lose two of those transformers, the other two would
he operated at overload until the others were repaired, and
we would still supply 3,000 kw. of service. If we lost one of
the main feeders from the main power plant, we could lose
one transformer qad still supply the service, and similarly
if we lost two, we could still supply it.
Not only that, but those transformers are connected to
the customers’ service, and also to our street mains, so if
we lost a little more than that, we probably conld make it
up from our other network stations located at the corners of
the block, or conversely, if the customer has no peak load
on at the time, and has lost no equipment, we have the hene-
62
6
o4
OOD
6
257
25
8
2086
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—-Direct
fit of at least 50 per cent. of that installation for other
customers up and down the street.
This type of service is what is known as service designed
for a second contingency outage. Most service can stand
one type of outage, but it is in difficulty when the second
occurs. Now, the efficiency with which this equipment is
being used under those conditions may be expressed as 75
per cent., in other words, we have only 4,000 kilowatts of
transformers and cable facilities, and we are able to carry
three-quarters of that as effective firm load, and sustain it
through a second, contingency outage.
Naturally, that type of service costs a little more than a
lower grade of service, but it is what builds the business
and the good will. |
‘The growth on that network system is. taking place so
rapidly that I understand that 1,000 kilowatts or so has
been added since I got these notes some two weeks ago, when»
I made this tabulation, and the installations this summer
were anticipated to be 10,000 kilowatts. I don’t believe they
ail came on, but I believe they will all be on by next spring.
—2,683—
Q. What is the function of the network system, is it to
pick up the additional network load growth in the down-
town system? <A. It is expected to ultimately supersede the
older systems of all types, and we hope that if you were to
look many years into the future, you would see one simpli-
fied system of an A.C. network handling: all loads in the
area, and the elimination of all other systemy in that par
ticular area. We don’t care which system we use, we want
to use the one which supplies the service the best, and that
20ST
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
system will be determinedcby the load density in the area.
What we hope to do, insofar as possible, is to not duplicate
the svstem, we want one, but not two, because each system
that overlaps the other in the same area, saps the load and
divides it between two systems; whereas, if only one were
available, your overall efficiency on your investment would
be greater, and we are making every effort to follow that
principle; but in our four ky. radial distribution systems,
we carry all the loads in that area on that system, and would
not hesitate to pick up a relatively large industrial load.
On this 120/208 volt network, we are not hesitating to pick
up a 3,000 kw. customer, the point being that if we can do
the whole thing in a given area, with one system, we wiil
give better service, and greater reliability at lower cost, than
if we let it overlap into two or three. So that even in the
DeC, district we can not avoid building some of this A. C.
—2,6841—
stulf into the same urea in order to pick up the load growth,
but the ultimate pian is to eliminate any duplication.
That new A. C, network system we have just installed is
the very last word in the United States on thet class of
equipment, there is no better. It ought to be, because it has
just been installed. We studied the various systems through-
out the country for several years, anticipating this installa-
tion, because it will be the major investment for the whole
colipany at some time, and to get started right is extremely
important.
We thought we might go into it three or four years ago,
but we studied it carefuliy and decided that there was no
merit in doing so. The fact that that conclusioa was correct
625%
6260
6261
2088
6262 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
has been demonstrated because since that time there hay:
been several changes of opinion in the country as to what the
final A.C. network voltage and type was to be. Some
thought it would be a 5-wire system; others thought it would
be 2-pbase, and all of those installations are available around
the country, but there are now in the neighborhood of five
or six hundred thousand kilowatts of total load in the
United States on network systems at this voltage, :.nd that
is so preponderant that there is no longer any possibility that
6263 some other voltage way become the ultimate future standard,
and we feel entirely safe in adopting it.
To get our system in the best possible condition to make
| —2,685—
the most use out of this new A. C. network, we made a study
of the lamp ultilization voltages on our system, and com-
pared that information with the use of such utilization volt-
ages on other sysiems of the North American Company, and
as a result we decided to raise our voltage about 21% volts
and adopt what is known as the 126-volt lamp;. whereas.
for midany years we had used the 115 volt standard. That
6264 change, we feel, is highly beneficial, and the change was
made without anyone observing it or causing any incon-
venience. It results in this, that we can use the same lamp
downtown on 120/208 volts system, with perfect satisfaction,
that we use out in the radial system. The 115 volt lamp
would not have been so good. And we thereby avoiding
have two different lamp standards on the same system. Tiiat
in itself is worth a great deal, not only to us, but to our
customers. ‘s
Q. Returning to the distribution sub-stations, wil! you
state the general character of construction employed? A. The
- 2089
Stenley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
distribution sub-stations are so different in size that one
cannot describe one type of construction. I can say that the
stations run from 100 kilowatts, and that may be.a little
pole type station, mounted on a steel structure, on a pole
out in a country district, with its own automatic regulation
--up to a station of, say, 42,500 kilowatts, which represents
the latest type of equipment, mounted, jn a modern brick
building with a very nice external appearance.
| -~-2,686—
In this connection, the architect who furnished the ap-
pearance engineering for that building, got the highest award’
at a recent exhibition of architectural photographs in some
salon, carried on last vear in New York, and he showed me
the picture with pride. eo
That is our aew Carondelet sub-station, and a very
heautifal building.
The larger sub-stations are fully equipped with oil
switches, Kuses, and the usual paraphernalia that goes with
those things, and operate on an automatic reclosing ‘cycle.
By that I mean the oil switch, in case the feeder gets into
trouble, will open the circnit, reclose immediately—if it is
still in troublé it will reelose again, and try that three times,
and if some trouble still persists, it will lock it out and ring
an alarm.
The record is that the average trouble record here for
the last several years has been a half a case of trouble per
feeder per year, or cne case of trouble per feeder every two
years, 80 percent. of which reclosed automati¢ally, and
iesuiied in merely .a flicker. If you were to double that
grade of service, you couldn’t tell the difference, it is that
6265
6266
6267
6268
6269
270
- 2090
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
near perfect, in other words, one flicker every two years on
a feeder for 80 per cent. of all of them.
Fellows have wanted to sell me some equipment to im-
prove that service, and I (old them that I just didn’t see
how I could justify it. It probably will be improved some
day, but that is pretty good. |
—2,68T—
Now, in these city sub-stations we were confronted, as all
others have been, with the increasing cost of oil switch ~
equipment, and while some engineers gave consideration
to elimination of switches and using reclosing and repeating
fuses, to reduce the cost, we looked into that a little, and
we decided that the solution of the problem, because we
do want te deliver this service at a reasonable cost, was
to use the best equipment we could get, but to load it to its
capacity. In, other words, an analysis of these various ‘sys-
tems showed that many of these circuits are only loaded to
possibly a fraction of their actual capability, and if we
could keep the equipment going at its rated load, we could
keep our unit cost per kilowatt down. With that in mind
we found that certain of our metropolitgn sub-stations had
a sufliciently limited area of distribution that all feeders
either were or could be made of approximately the same
length. That meant that we didn’t have to have such a.
high degree of regulation, of regulating control, such as
10 per cent. up above or below the standard voltage, We
could do with.o per cent. above or below in these automatic
inductions regulators.
The result was that those regulators, which are con-
structed as 250 ampeves, when operated at 10 per cent., or
500 amperes when operated at 5-per cent. regulation, were
f-
y,
y,
2091
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct — 6271
reconnected and re-rated from 250 amperes to 500, and sup-
plied entirely adequate regulation.
| . —2.688—
The switches could already handle that load. So by that
simple method we doubled the capacity effectively of several
of the downtown stations, and ail we had to do was watch
that any long feeder be eliminated and ‘connected to some
other sub-station. All of these feeders, I Should say, are car-
ried out and terminated at the end of a feeder from some
other station, so that*in the event of any troubie, this one 6272
can be opened up and supplied from some other station.
That is in general, a brief description.
The 13 A.C. sub-stations in St. Leuis supply 124-4,500
volt 3-phase, 4-wire feeders, 112 of which have induction
voltage regulation. The remainder are ifdustrial feeders
and the customers do not care for the regulation and get a
slight discount for unregulated service.
The area covered within the city is 62 square miles, and
the location of the sub-stations is based on an economic study
of the location of loads, using a sort of center of gravity
method of caleulation and we try to determine which one 620
should be installed next.
We have almost obtained a complement within the city
limits, L believe twe more is all we will ever need, and then
those will have to gradually increase in capacity, but we will
dave as many as the area requires.
Of these 124-4,560 volt feeders, 106 of them have single
phase induction regulators, and 6, located at what we call
our Kingsbury sub-station have the regulated bus. By that
\ —2,689—
I mean, we have a very large device which regulates a bus
274
6275
“
6276
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
off of which a number of feeders are taken as a group. That
ugain is a relatively recent change on our part, as a matter
of economy, and no reduction in the grade of service is in- _
volved. It simply means, as the load area is developed and |
new buildings are built, and the density gpadually-builds yp,
at the present time we might have sub-siation aan a space,
and another sub-station which I witrfall C here. The inter.
vening sub-station has not yet been built because it wasn’t
needed.
After all of those sub-stations are in place, when this B
sub-station is installed, these feeders which went from A to
C will be cut in two, and with half the length and half the
load, you-can get about four times as good regulation. Final-
eally
ly you get to the area for which this sub-station was -
ultimately designed. At that time you can convert the sta-
tion to what is known as bus regulation, regulate the whole
bus up and down iogether, take these regulators off and
move them to a new station, and start the process al! over
again. By that method we avoid the unnecessary purchase
of large numbers of feeder regulators.
You must’ keep in mind, though, that that couldn’t be-
done in the beginning, because ip the beginning you have to
supply both long and short feeders, as they go into the dif.”
ferent areas.
That is a rather brief and sketchy description, but it
| —2,590—
gives you an idea of the extent of this system.
The Examiner: Let us recess until two o’clock.
(Whereupon, at 12:35 o'clock p. m. a recess
was taken until 2 o'clock p.'m. of the same day.)
oe —2,691—
20938
Stanley S tokes—-By Respondents—Direct 6277
AFTERNOON SESSION.
_ (Whereupon, at 2:00 o’clock p. m., the hearing recon-
vened. )
The Examiner: Let us resume, gentlemen. Are
‘you ready? :
° Mr. Hamilton: Yes, sir.
The Examiner: Go ahead.
Whereupon, STANLEY STOK¥s resumed the —— and tes- 6278
tified further as follows: i
i
Jf
Direct Examination by Mr. Hamilton (Continued) :
Q. Please continue, Mr. Stokes A. The 4,000 volt dis-
tribution sub-station feeders arg, as a general rule and with
very few exceptions, operated as single-phase feeders.
I should explain that a little more and state that this is
usually referred to as a four-wire system*in which the
voltage is approximately 2,400 yolts between the fourth wire
or neutral arid any one of the other three wires referred to as
phase wires. 6279
This type of feeder starts out from the sub-station with
four wires and at various points along the feeders the neutral
—that is, the fourth wire—and one of the phase wires, is
taken off and goes down some other street and is called a
branch.
The two wires so tapped off of the four-wire circuit are
—2,692—
calle ‘da single-phase circuit gnd that is the one that is used
to sup ply the residents.
2094 |
6280 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
These various single-phase circuits are distributed around
on the various phase wires so that the load at the sub-station
is properly balanced on all three wires—the fourth wire un-
der. perfectly balanced load would not carry any current,
although in a-large part of the country these circuits are
switched, all four wires or at least all three wires with a
single oil switch. oe
In St. Louis, and, a | believe, one or two other cities of the
North American group of properties, the switching is car-
6281 — ried out asa single-phase operation. ;
| In other words, we provide a separate switch for each of
the three wires. By switching in this manner, we interrupt
only one-third of the service which would have been inter-
rupted had we opened all three wires, because the service
difiiculty is, in almost all cases, confined to one or the other
of the wires and rarely involves all three.
By this method of switching, we improve the grade of
service over that which could otherwise have been rendered
with a material yeduction in any possible service outages. [
think that is clear. And that the switching of one wire out
6282 of three should result in a material improvement in the
services. sith
Where industrial feeders are. supplying current where a
large percentage of three-phased motors is involved, those
feeders are called three-phase feeders and we switch them all
re —2,693—
as a unit. |
There have been many developments from time to time .
that have proved very useful. One, which was first applied,
as far as [ know, on our own system, was the use.of a ground
2095
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct 6283
relay connected between the base of the regulator and the
ground. :
_ We were surprised, a few years ago, to learn that tke
number of regulator fires had been very low on our system
compared with some other systems, and, i trying to deter-
; mine why we were a little more successful, we. found that this
ground relay which we had: used for a number: ‘of years, _
operated in several instances. oe
Any one of those instances could have produced a regu-
lator explosion and corresponding fire. Such fires are always 6284
very serious and result in a loss, not*only of property, but
frequently of life. |
There has -been a serious case of that kind within the
i country within the past year and a half.
eee ‘onclusion of this particular discussion on distribu-
tion sub-stations, I should point out that our genera] method
is to start a sub-station in a new area with two transformers,
each terminating two cableOfrom the power plant, each cable
coming from a separate bus section in the power plant, so
that the failure of a bus section or the failure of a eable-will
not affect the service to the other transformer at the sub- gog5
station. &
—2.694—
These transformers are parallel on the low side and the
switching and service from there on has been described. _ :
' -On the high voltage side, which affects the supply cables, -
these are 33,000 volt. We then tap one of those cables and
carry it to-another sub-station.
For example, if we had two transformer stations, we
would have three cables. In other words, we always provide
each station with one cable which has no taps on it and one
2096 ais
6286 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
cable which has one and later two, Werdo nox exceed that.
In, that way we have made an economy in the use of our
supply cables and in no case, over many years operation,
have we ever failed to have the adequate amount of supply.
That is based on the theory and probability that a certain
number of things would have to occur at the same time and
we have, between these various sub-stations, a certain amount
of low voltage tie capacity—that is, by tying the low voltage
_feeders together, a certain amount of load can be supplied
6287 from one station to another and even if we have 50 per cent.
or 75 per cent. overload on one transformer during a case of
trouble, that will not damage it in the length of time that it
takes us to redistribute the load and pick it up from the
' surrounding sub-stations. | iS
The result is that we attempt in that manner to produce
the greatest economy and supply the system without affect-
ing the reliability of the service.
—2,695—-
In the operation of these stations, I should mention there,
as part of the description, that we do have to carry out a
628s thorough system of inspection and testing at all times and
insure that all the equipment is in satisfactory operating
condition. . 7 .
(). Now, how frequently are these inspections conducted?
A. Weli, it depends on the nature of the sub-station and
on the type of service.
For example, in the automatic D.C. stations, the manager
‘is in there some time during the day. He doesn’t stay long
but he goes over a routine. . 7
We learned that by experience. In the early days of
automatic sub-station operation, it was thought that the
~ 6
2097 j
PA HY
n
&
Ntanley meek Respondents—Direct
automatic equipment should take care of itself and that very”
- infrequent inspection would ‘De all that was required. © “
Well, that is more or less the case; you cap get‘by that
way; but-experience has tiught us that it is better to make
a quick, brief inspection of the fundanientals in that station
daily, that one man can cever all of the stations on the
system and do that and that by so doing we simply prevent
accumulation of a number of minor items wiich, in the final
analysis, may combine to cause the difficulty, so that the
automatic stations are checked up in various ways.
Por caumple, we obyiousiy have to keep them clean so that
the janitor and helper is in there at very frequent intervals.
—-2,696—
He is an old, experienced employee and would observe any-
thing of particular irregularity, such as overheating equip-
“ment or smoke.
lburing the day there is always a map that comes in on
a meter reading, »emoving and replacing some charts.» He is °
instructed to observe certain things and at least once a week
a complete check-over is made in tlie automatic D. C. sta-
tions, so that there are not, very long intervals in which
nobody is in the sub-station, but the total mamhours of
Operators in any one station are not very great.
Q. Are your distribution sub-stations of adequate capac-
ity for present loads and for presently anticipated loads?
A. I haven't available the exact statistics on the per cent.
loading on all of these stations other than those that I have
given previously, but, in genéral, they are entirely adequate
and are kept so. | ° 3
‘he way this is done is that the annual peak load is taken
off of each station for the preceding twelve months and com-
~\
’
6
6289
6290
4j
6291
4a
4
2098
6292 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
pared with the previous year. We observe the rate of increase
of both kilowatts and k. v.a.; as a result of those compari-
sons, we provide in the annual budget for additions or
‘transfer of load, as the case may be, so that the same reserve
factor will apply the following vear.
In that way, we never allow the =— to increase beyond
a specified amount.
—2,697—
- This type of operation requires continuous care and must
6208 be kept up because the use of total average load statistics
is not sufficient.
The system load can, for example, be constant and yet
one sub- station might, for some reason, have an increasing
load that year and another one might have decreased due to
—_—
some peculiarity and it would net be observed in the total.
So you have to observe the variations of load in each of
the sub-station areas. |
What contribution has the Union Electric Group made
to the field of operation of distribution sub-stations? A.
The Union Electric group was one of the early operators
6294 : . ,
of any automatic equipment of this type and, I believe, the
most extensive operator in the earlier vears.
Naturally, as one pioneers the use of equipment, the
pioneers make some improvements and, in our case, it was
essential to do so. |
We did develop a number of applications. I can mention
several. One, the method of operating two or more auto
matie direct current machines in parallel on the same direct
current bus using an automatic “load-shifting scheme to
make each machine assume its proper share of the total load.
Pngg
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
This is not a particularly elaborate device, but it has
been very effective. In the ordinary arrangement there is
what is known as an equalizer bus. This ijittle scheme was an
—2,698—-
adaptation of automatic control to insure that the load was
divided as required.
Two, we were one of the first people to use bi-metallic -
element thermostats to protect machines and transformers
against overheating.
Those thermostats‘ and devices were manufactured in
our own utility shop and at least one or two of them were
jater incorporated into commercial devices which, I believe,
ultimately became the Minneapolis Regulator control ther-
__mostats, but I think the first application of one of these
Was on One of our transformers. «
Today, that sort of thing is standard practice. _
The use of pressure wire bus in connection with auto-
matic voltage regulation in direct current automatic sub-
stations, gives better regulation at all points on the direct
current system. <A little more clearly explained, that means
we carry a potential wire, a small wire, from different points
on the system, which carries the voltage back to the sub-
station, this particular wire not carrying any appreciable
current, so that the voltage back of the station will be the
Voltage that exists out on the system and, with those wires,
we are better informed as to the system voltage and can
operate accordingly. |
The newer A. C. network systems are following that orig-
‘inal idea and providing rather elaborate intelligence trans-
mission circuits to give information not only as te voltage,
6295
6296
6
97
6298
6300
2100
Stanley Stokes—DBy Respondents—Direct
but heating or overheating the transformers and many ether
—2 O99—
bits of information that it is desired to have.
Another item was to use automatically operated dampers
to cut off the air supply in case of transformer fires or
fires on rotary converters.
‘You see, when you operate attendant sub-stations in
which you had men operating, if a fire started in the building,
why, you knew that the man had sense enough to either try
to put it out or report it.
Well, the thing was first brought to our attention with
“a small fire in an automatic station and nobody said any-
thing about it. By the time we got down thege, the machine
was pretty well damaged, so we incorporated devices to send
out an alarm to the inain office but, from the experience we
had, we realized that that was not enough and at the same
time, this device euts off the air to the machine by auto-
matically closing dampers.
At the same time it takes the machine off and clears it
from the circuit. This eliminates the chance for the fire to
gain much headyay until someone can get there.
Also, they have CQ2, carbon dioxide, equipment, which
will automatically operate to put ont fires.
The COz equipment is not our development, nor contriby-
‘tion. Our contribution was the use of the automatiealiy
controlled damper. That was quite valuable.
—2,700—
Another item, use of vacuum tube-voltage regulators to
control automatic rotaries and mctor generators on the direct
current system. Although we did not invent the idea, nor the
ae |
2101
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
equipment for automatically reclosing an oil switch on out-
going feeders, we were one of the earlier users of. large quan-
tities of these switches and fonnd them to be very inaccurate
in their operation and undependable.
We were able to improve the reclosing equipment. This
was applied successfully to the South Broadway Sub-station
as early as 1920. | |
=
*
Q. Are they effective now? A. Oh, yes. Yes, I mean, tne
people are using those things now .without knowing where
_they are geiting them. They are regularly applied on equip-
ment today by manufacturers, but when rea are the early
user 6f these equipments you have to do it yourself and when
you do, you contribute something to the art.
In the electrical industry as a whole, I refer to the utility
industry primarily, there is a great freedom of interchange
of ideas, facilities and- information. By that I mean that the
utility industry has never attempted, to much extent, to
patent and tie up sach ideas; particularly among the mem-
bers of our North American group we interchange such ideas
quickly. ,
If we develop these things, we tell the others about it the
very first time we have any kind of a meeting or get-together.
—2,701—
'f there is anything-that is any good, we use it. If it turns
out to be no good, we all quit it.
Another development was the adoption of steel barrier
wails, an isolated phase arrangement for automatic steel dis-
tribution stations, as early as 1925. I was responsible for
the design of that particular station and, at the time, it was
thought by most engineers and operators that steel would
6301
6302
6303
6304
6305
6306
2102
Stank y Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
in some way cause a great deal more trouble, when arcs were
started, than concrete which had been used almost univer.
sally for bus structures. |
We put in this station and had no opportunity to find out
for a couple of years whether there was any operating advan-
tage. We knew that there was a major construction advan-
tage and that we would have a better job. —
Finally, one day, the manager of this particular property
—it happened to be Alton—decided that he would make some
changes in the station arrangement, and in order to be ultra-
careful, he moved into the station an external oil swiich,
set it up, connected it up and made connections preparatory
to transferring the circuits through this switch so that he
could be doubly sure that nothing would happen.
He had an extra source with which to clear the circuit.
He then took his last lead, put it on an insulated stick—
_ what is known as the Johnson Clamp—and clamped it on
to the bus. After having gone to all that trouble, he made
one rather fundamental error—he forgot to open the oil
—2,702—
switch and when he clamped that thing on, he had a dead
short.
Fortunately, he was far enough away from it that it
didn’t get him and after it cleared, the situation showed that
the steel barriers, which had a hole burned in them about an
inch and a half in diameter, had withstood the are and the
repair of that was a very simple matter with an ordinary
welding torch and the man’s life was probably saved, be
cause, had that been concrete, he could not have gotten 4
complete contact. The are would have played around quite
2103
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents——Direct
a bit, would have flared out and, no doubt, gotten him, be-
cause we have had other cases in a matter of such type.
So we were convinced that the steel barrier was satis-
factory.
The various companies have adopted that since and we
are very favorably inclined to vard it, even for major power-
plant installations. Several North American properties are
using it to advantage. )
I have one or two other items which | had intended to
_ wention. ,
Another item. We heiped develop, as well as install,
recording devices in automatic closing timers. A timer is a
device which determines the interval of deiuy in a reclosing
automatic circuit breaker. Pa
In other werds, whether it should reclose immediately or
es —-2,703-—
wait a few cycles or how it ‘operates. It is controlled by
What is called a timer. ;
In order to obtain a record of what actually. took place,
we developed a little automatic device to be incorporated in
these timers.
I: is interesting, when difficulties are cleared, to know
What took place, because you learn thereby and can avoid it
the next time, and it is impracticable to employ such devices
as these automatic oscillographs which we have mentioned
Where you have such a large number of applications.
Another point, which is not a matter of development of
_ apparatus or pioneering, but a device te adopt a certain prac-
tee—in other words, we rather early adopted the reclosing
tycle for 4,500 volt circuits at a time when it was generally
Tegurded as more or less impracticable.
6307
6308
6509
6210
6311
6312
S104
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
We said, “Why wait so long? Why not close them right
in and restore the service in most cases?” And the same type
of reasoning is being applied now, to higher voltage circuits.
That is, today, very common. |
We set ‘up a test circuit and ran it for some mouths and
found that no damage occurred und that we did improve the
service and the device was nade te do it on all of the feeders.
The use of 33,000 volt cabie connecting the transformer at
the source with the receiving transfermer with no high
voltage switches was adopied many years ago by our com-
‘pany as more or less standard practice.
—2,704-—-
We have, to date, found no reason for changing our view.
it has a very good feature in its elimination of high shert
cireuiis.as well as the reduction of high voltage equipment.
Any simplification of equipment should resalt and does in ob-
taining better service. oe
Some years ago, there was quite an investigation made by
the American Telephone & Telezrnaph Company as to the
major short circuits that hed occurred in different cities in
the country and the Commission was sent to St, Louis to in
vestigate us for the simple reason that no complaints had
been had by the Telephone Company as a result of high shert
circuits in our district. |
Q. Sent dy whom? A. By the American Telephone &
7" ‘ ’
Telegraph Company.
The reason for this investigation was that somewhere, I
believe, near Chicago, there had been a heavy short circuit
in a cable which induced a high potential in a wire leading to
the telephone exchange.
PL
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
This caused a flash-over in the telephone equipment and
which, in itself, would not have been particularly serious, but
it frightened the girls and they all ran for the stairway and
there were some girls either injured or killed and the teie-
phone company wanted te avoid any possibility of such a re-
currence,
—2,705—
The conclusion that they reached, after having been at
St. Louis only a few hours, was that there was no reason
why we should have any high short vireuits the way our
system was designed and that the explanation was obvious,
that we did not tie tegether a great quantity of equipment
and subject all of it to the full capacity of the plants.
This, to some extent, at least, in my opinion, was an ad-_
ditional justification for our methods coming from an inde-
pendent source.
(Discussion off the record.)
A. (Continuing) Another item of pioneering application
was the use of an automatic transfer, 128,000 volt sub-sta-
tion unattended, fully automatic, including 33,000 volt
witomatically regulated bus, and a°* numberof outgoing
feeders, ;
The application of this station, which was installed gbout
two years ago, included a number of original features. I,
personally, am net-aware of any other station ef just this
charseter at that voltage operating fully automatic.
“he service obtained from this fully automatic station
does supply the outgoing lines with a continuity that could-
not he obtained by an operator if he were there, because it
6313
63t4
6315"
6316
6317
2106
Stanley Stokes—bBy Respondents—Direct
requires a selection and changing in the time of operating
switches in a period of less than eight cycles.
That is, in other words, this station-has to select between
two ways of operating the switch and do it in less than
uae | —2,706—
eight-sixtieths of a second or it can cause difficulty. No
operator could do these things if he were there; he,swould
have to depend on the equipment.
One other item was the use of a directional distance
relay for ground fault protectien. That, we believe, we
were the first to apply on a major system and it required
many modifications before it was fully effective. 7
This relay, in conjunction with some other similar de-
vices, really represents the brains of this automatic’ station °
that I have been describing.
Q. And you have already referred, have you not, to the
use of ground relays on regulator frames as a means of re-
ducing fire hazards? <A. I did refer to:that. It is one of
those cases where I am not able to show a positive proof
6318 of the extent to which it is valuable, but the negative proof
indicates a situation that if we have, in ‘the operation of that
device, as much as, say, four or five times—if any one of
Those five times had functioned the same way, without the
device in the regularly stated service—the particular kind
of regulator to which I refer was known to be subject t-.
explosion under the conditions in which it was used. |
If any one of those occasions has saved a regulator ex-
plosion, the device was a real contribution.
—2,707—
ae
~
Stanley Stokes-—By Respondents—Direct
Q. I think you have already mentioned, briefly, the pro-
posed change over at Fort Madison, lowa, from 25 cycles to
fil-cyele power. You might just comment on that very briefly,
if you will, at this stage. A. 25-cycle service is not as
satisfactory for lighting as 60-cycle service, and as I have
previously explained practically all of our 25-cycle service
is used for industrial applications or street-railway load
where lighting, itself, is not involved.
There are one or two relatively. small towns in Iowa,
which got service in the early years at the time the dam was
constructed, which have the 25-cycle used fer general distri-
bution. We are now proceeding to eliminate that and
convert it to 60 cycle without any expense to the community.
Q. Now, does this result in better service? A. It results —
in materially better service to that communiiy but involves
some very important expenditures on our part. I would
like to describe that situation. We had to put in a 6,000
k. v.a. sub-station, frequency-changer—jeb, rebuild a small
plant at a cost of about $152,000 but in addition all of these
customers had an abundant supply of appliances which
would not operate at 60 cycles. ‘a
Afier having used the greatest care ih trying to convert
some of the equipment to 60-cycle operation, having made a
survey of all of the equipment, we still had something over
$200,000 worth in just one small town which we had to
furnish. There was no one eise to do it. Since it is property
—2,708—
that we aren’t going to own, you have to look on it alm«>t
as a gift to the customer. I don’t see how you: can regard
it any other way, but it is one of the essential features. of
6319
632
Bt be ar Rang
6321
an
2108
6322 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
such a change-over. The company undertook that obligation.
The city of Fort Madison, itself, is having its distribu-
tion system completely redesigned and the transformer con-
nection and such other changes made as are necessary ta
provide 60-cycle service in pla’ » of 25 cycle.
Q. Turning now to the distribution sysiem, itself, I think
you have given previously an overall statement of the num-
ber of customers served by the Union Electric group. Are
you abie to classify those customers in general by the county
6323 in which they are located in order to indicate the density of
service in a particular county? A. The particular date as
of. which I have this information is December 31, 1939.
The total number of customers as of that date is 349,096,
- distributed geographically as follows: City of St. Louis,
202,308; St. Louis County, Missouri, 74,674; St. Charles
County, Missouri, 3,633; Franklin County, Missouri, 4,773;
Jefferson County, Missouri, 7,794; St. Francois County, Mis-
‘souri, 5,254; Lakeside Division, Missouri, 286. .
Q. Now, that Lakeside Division you just referred to, is
that the territory around the Osage plant? <A. That is the
6324 ‘territory immediately adjacent to the hydro-eleciric plant
: ” | —2,709—
and the Lake of the Ozarks. That was just a natural out:
growth of the construction of the dam; the residents in the
vicinity wanted te obtain electiic service and we supplied it.
East St. Louis and Alton Divisions, 39,090; Keokuk Divi-
sion, 11,284, which totals-to the previous figufe. _
Q. I think you have previously given the distribution of -
| customers by classifications of service, but I don’t think yot
| have stated the amount of kilowatt hours taken by the
2109
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
respective classifications. Are you able to state the number
of kilowatt hours so taken by various classifications within
your own rate schedules? A. I tan subdivide that to about
6 or 8 classificatidns. The annual sale of kilowatt hours,
based on the year ending December 31, 1939 is: residential
classification, 309,987,615; comercial classification, 237,-
653,585; street lighting, 34,102,442. The combined totai for
those three classifications is. 5sl, 743,642.
Other public authorities, 13,5 18.642; other, electric util-
ities, 401,412,412; railways, that is the street-railway load,
123,506,900 ; combined total for that group, 538,406,954.
Large industrial classification, 1,020,297,591. The com-
bined total for ali classes for the year 1939 is 2,140,509,187.
We are having a very rapid increase in kilowatt-hour
generation .this year and I believe that that 2,100,000,000
figure has already gone, I think, even beyond 2%, billion at
: he 710
the rate it is going. Lf we compare that with the year 1919, |
at that time, 20 years ago, we had 353,185,617, and in the
year 1919 we had 112,484 customers compared with the
previous figure of 349,096 for 1939,
Q.. At what voltages’ is electric energy distributed by the
group? A. The general lighting service in all areas is dis-
tributed to the customer at 120/240 volts. By.that we mean
that where you have threé-wire service the potential between
the two outside wires is 240 volts and the potential from
either outside wire to the middle or neutral wire is 120 volts.
The larger-sized motors are’ operated on the 240 volts
and the lighting is always on the 120 volts. A small cus-
tomer will obtain only two-wire. service, which me. him
120 volts. ae
€325
6326
6327
~ 36328
6329
6330
2110
Stanley Stokes—Dy Respo..idlents—Direct
Now, in the aiternating current, secondary network for
the high density. city service, the voltage is, single phase,
120 volts and, three-phase, 208’ volts. Power service in prac:
tically all areas is either 240 or 480-volt, 3-phase voltage.-
Industrial-power service is delivered at the primary side
of the distribution transformer at 4,160, 13,800, 33,000 yolts,
60 cycles or 13,200 Volts, 25 cycles depending on the par-—
ticular district in which the service is rendered. ‘That_
means that the customer has the Ineter on the high ‘voltage
side. of the transformer and distributes his own fecdets-in
the factory or wherever he wants to and does his ewn
transformation. . : 2, 71—
@. And the street-railway load is‘at what yoltage? A. It
is practically uniformly supplied at 13,800 volts, 25 cycles.
Q. Your statistics on sales kilowatt hours indicate a
fairly substantial street-lighting load. Can you comment on -
the extent of the street-lighting distribution? A. The largest
. user of street lights, the city of St. Louis, owns and operates
its own street-ligh#ing system and purchases power from the
Union Electric group. This power supplies some 50,300 street
iamps in streets, parks and public places, such as> bridges
and alleys, all of the power coming from the Union Electric
group. The lights and equipment on the municipal bridge, a
number of alley-lighting systems and a few. private systems
in the city are owned and operated completely by the Union
Electrie group. Outside of the city limits, that is in St. Louis
Ceunty and various other locations, the Union Electrie:group-
‘owns and operates the street lights, themselves.
. . re y . . t . . .
The city of Kirkwood, which is af municipality, owns and
operates its own street-lighting system and purchases the ’
*
2111
: Stanley Siokes—By Respondents—Direct
power from the Union Electric group. Clayton, Missouri
and Washington, Missouri-each own a few lights in their
_business district and all are supplied from the Power Com-
pany System. ‘
Q. By that you mean by the Union Electric group? <A.
By the Union Electric group.
eo me 1D
‘Jn the street-lighting equipment, which is owned and
operated by the Union Electric group, there are a total cf 65
circuits serving over 6,189 lamps, 1,941 of which are orna-
mental standards supplied from underground cables. The
“remaining 4,248 are overhead fixtures supplying aerial cir-
cuits. This latter group is about equally divided between
bracket-type fixtures and center suspension. |
Most of these circuits are supplied from 6.6 ampere, con-
stant current, street-lighting regulators. Although there
are some variations in some cases, the larger lamps are
handled from 20-ampere transformers in the’ ornamental
pote; itself.
Very‘few of these operations are carried on with the mul-
tiple circuits, only in some remote districts where no street-
lighting circuit was available. .
15 of the 65 circuits are controlled by time switches in
the various suburban distribution stations, the remaining 50
originate from series regulators installed along the distribu-
tion feeder. These are automatically controlled by time.
switches, the more recent of them using a separate relay and
. an‘oil switch, mounted at different locations from the relay.
(Discussion off the record.)
6331
6332
6333
6334
6335
6356
Stanley Stokes-—By Respondenta—Direct
The Witness: The street-lighting circuit, as a rule,
causes very little trouble; most of ‘these circuits are
equipped with sectionalizing devices. If any trouble
or anything happens to the loop, that loop of the cir-
cuit is cut out and the rest of it goes on, and it is very
—2.713—
‘simple to operate and leads to very little difficulty.
The service on the street-lighting circuits, as they are ~~
designed and maintained today, is very reliable.
Of course, it involves a constant maintenance and
cleaning schedule to keep the equipment and the lights
in good order. There are, also, some street lights in
East St. Louis and Alton, Illindis which are main-
tained and served by the Union Electric group.
A few of the Whiteway Systems, including 479
standards owned by the cities,-are operated on. energy
purchased from this same Union Electrie group. In
Keokuk and other Iowa communities there are about
1,530 lamps owned and operated by the Union Electric
group. That is about all of the street-lighting equip-
ment. |
By Mr. Hamilton:
Q. What type of distribution is employed in the distribu-
tion system? A. The distribution system, as previously de
scribed, is a 2,300/4,000 volt fonr-wire radial-type system
which, as a rule, is regulatéd by induction feeder regulators
at the sub-station. The urban-type feeders, those in and
around the city, are all operated with the single-circuit oil
switches as previously described. The rural circuits do
not all have the automatic reclosing feature. |
7
~ 2113
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
-In connection with the city and urban-type feeders, St.
* Ae etic —2,714—
Louis is outstanding in its use of heavy conductors; that is,
the standard conductors that we have the greatest mileage
in are the 4/0 size, whereas some cities depend on a 2/0 as a
general rule. 7
We have done some experimental work in using a 750,000
em. feeder for the very heavy distribution and are not con-
vinced: as vet as to whether it is practicable or not, but we
have a number of 500,000 circular mill feeders operating
successfully. This large-sized conductor is only feasible in *
the areas where the load is quite dense. There is no funda-
mental difference in design in the suburban-type feeders as
distinguished from the city feeders except that the conductor.
is usually the smaller size. ,This same comment would apply
to rural feeders, but in their case they usually have some
form of fuse, frequently an automatic-repeater type and the
feeder, itself, is of lighter wire.
Urban and suburban feeders are all closely physically
interconnected so that the loss of one feeder can be picked up
by adjacent ones. The design of such a system has to con-
template that practice and we have a regular practice of
providing from 14 to 14 excess capacity in these feeders so
that two or three feeders can always pick up the load of one
more. Tt is equivalent to providing a reserve cireuit for not
over 3 feeders as a rule and always one reserve circuit for
fas
if.
avr
This distribution system has had a rapid increase in its
T15-.—
size. Since 1919 to 1939 there has bee a very large per-
centage increase in a 20-year period. I should like to de-
bo
Ye year,
6337
6539
6340
6341
6542
2114
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
scribe ‘that with respect to several classifications: Poles,
December 31, 1919, there were 41,958 which by 19389 had be-
come 147,116; Miles of distribution wire in 1919 was/8,379,
this has increased to 29,757; Single conduit in miles, 810 had
increased to 1,306——the conduit, itself, may have more than
one duct but in this case I am giving it per duct miie; dis-
tribution cable in miles, 552 2 and S86. The set of the majority
of this system is overhead and not underground, Meters
have increased from 116,495 to 374,548.
Q. Now, without going into any particular detail and
since it represents a very important purt of the total enter-
prise, could you comment briefly on the development of the
distribution system to amplify the statistics which you have
given? <A. I believe that in previous testimony describing the
general features of the company that I made some partial
reference to the early activities, although I do not believe that
{ gave but just a mere mention.
IT would like to include at this point that St. Louis was -
one of the oldest pioneering electric users in the country and
that the Missouri-Edison ElectrieCompany by 1898 claimed
such outstanding achievements as the operation of alter-
nating current generators parallel, use of induction-feeder
regulators, distribution of power by means of an A. C. net-
work | and the operation of the world’s largest A. C. are light
: —2,716—
°
station.
'Q. Was the company to which you have just referred by
“name 2 predecessor of the present Union Electric C ‘ompany?
A. It was a predecessor of the present Union Electric Com}
‘pany of Missouri.
=,
22115
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
The early system bragged about their loud factor of 20
per cent. compared with our present: -day load factor of 60
“and stated that in their early ree ords that they were active
in the promotion of the sale of single-phase motors, so to that
‘extent we are still at it.
‘There has been a gradual change, as the years go on, as
to the standards for the utilization of voltage, that is the
voltage at which the lights are operated. In the early years
the majority of all lamps sold were sold at from 100 to 110
volts. Then the sales gradually shifted and fur many sue-
ceeding year's and up until the last, possibly, five, the greatest
percentage of all lamps sold fell in the 115 volt class.
For the past five years much more than 50 per cent. of all
lamps sold,—I think it exceeds 60 per cent. today and pos-
sibly a little more,—were sold at 120 volts regularly and this
is the voitage at which beth utilities and manufacturers
would prefer to remain. Our system has been brought in
line with this recent standard and the lamps now being sold
throughout the Union Electric Company group districis are
i120 volts.
This is an important item because you can't afford to have
—2,717—
two or three different types of lamps being sold, because you
never’ can tell where they are going to be used. You can't
contro] their distribution once they leave your hands. Be-
sides, others sell lamps in ordinary stores, consequently, if
there were two lamp standards in the district there would be
bound to be some of them missupplied. If there were two
lamp standards such as 115 volts and 120 volts it would
always cause difficulty. We have made very special effort
to get our system into the condition where the voltages
6343
6344
6345
6340
* 6348
2116
Stanley Stdkes—By Respondents—Direet
delivered on the various distr ibution girenits are ull suitable
for the 120 volt- stadard lamp. That, lamp, will operate sne-
cessfully for two orf three volts above that rating and three
‘or four volts below. It will stand Hore voltage below than
“above to operate ¢qually well i other -words, thes mean
volt ge for which phat lamp is designed is probably 118 volts.
The studies that have to be made to kee p a distribution
system up to date and in good condition are voluminons.
You have to constantly keep at it, study the trend of che
load, the rate of load growth and the load sities by areas
and keep.yvour reserve equipment at the proper percentage it
all the different areas.
The purchase -and installation of electrical equipment
does not, of itself, guarantee good service, that is something
that we bave/learyed over mmny years, that you have got to
constantly study/it and keep it in condition and keep it
adequate, keep ahead of your load.
‘bra | —2,718—
Ifa transformer is severely overloaded for’ a number of
years and burns up, that is not the transformer’s fault, that
is becauge somebody did not do all of these things which I
have ing icated and we make every effort to follow continually
this type of /inspectjon.
‘of the first things you have to know is the voltage
condition on your system. For many years a large number
of companies depended entirely on complaints from cus
tomets, so-called voltage complaints, to determine whether
or npt th¢ir service was satisfactory.
ii would like to relate the reason why that is not partic:
we ¥ a, food way to do it. We checked up our voltage com
/ |
aise
Pd 2117
Stanley Stokes—By Respontents—Direct 6349
plain's for ua iiree-year period. We cHissified them by the
nature of the telephone call and the Distribution Department.
analyzed those figures and seemed to be able to make nothing
of therm. They seemee to be very inconsistent. [ turned the
whole group of figures over to one of my assistants who is
interested in frequency. distribution’ and probability curves
and stich matters, hn
He plotted the cunt of these eymplaints in the form of
what is known as the fraqquency curve with what was then a
rather surprising result. ¢t was that the greatest number of 6350
complaints came at the point of rated voltage,—in other /
words if. 115 volts was our standard voltage that we were
trying to deliver. After these complaints, yon understand,
we went out to measure the voltage, checked it up, The larg- \
es! puniber of complaints cane at the point where the veltage ;
. —2719—
Was the best. This is easily explained if you think just a
“moment.” | . |
If you have 10 customers on an electric system getting
10 volts and 10 customers getting 130 volts and if all 20
of (hose complain, you wouldn't get anything like the num- 6951
ter of calls that you would from 250,000 customers who
think that the voltage is wrong and who cail up for-some
reason. When we get out there we usually locate the reason,
but the answer is you are going to get more trouble calls
becarse there are more people. If you have a good system
and wellregulated voltage, you are going to have a very
high percentage of all the customers on the system there
eet that voltage that they are supposed to get and if you
take 350,000 customers they are gving to call up about
6352
353
6354
2118
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
something, usually because of some of their interior wiring
or their fuses are out and something else is wrong. The
management checks that, but it isn’t the conclusion that you
would arrive at without having checked it up.
( Discussion off the record. )
The Witness: (Continuing) But it is a fact that
you can not afford any longer to use customers’ calls
as an indication of voltage trouble, you have to go and
measure it.
By Mr. Hamilton:
( In order to get a comparative idea of the constant
additions and changes that arebeing made in the distribv-
tion system, are vou able to state the amount of retirements
and additions that have been made to the system in a par
— 2 7M:—
ticular vear? <A. Yes, I can state the figures very closely
for the vear 1939. The distribution system additions were
$3,700,000 and we retired $1,100,000 for the same vear. The
continuous development of additional load apd other im-
provements, particularly highway improvemenis caused us
to spend a very considerable sum of money every year in
addition to which we have an arrangement with the city
whereby we remove every vear five miles of overhead circuits.
That should have been independent of whether we need to
remove them. We do it anyway and thereby reduce the
mileage of overhead lines in the city and we do xot add
any. The result is that in a very definite number of years
all of the overhead svstem will have been removed from the
city streets without any hardship to anyone.
2119
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
Q. You are talking about St. Louis? A. Iam talking
about St. Louis city.
The expenditures brought about by civic developments
and other requirements amounted to $80,900 in the year
1039 and this figure, or even a larger figure, is applicable
almost every veur in some manher or other as our share
in the civic programs.
Substantial Jesses are occasioned by the removal or
abandonment of existing plants under some of these changes’
Which are particularly applicable in the last two or three
yeurs.
2 721—
For example, we have a Jefferson Memorial Project
mong the river front of the Mississippi River, in which many
square blocks of buildings have been razed; and are to be
‘eplaced by se ne form of memorial. The exact plan has not »
vet been determined. We had to remove ail of our service
out of that nrea, and we don’t know what we are going to
have to put back, but our estimates indicate that. our retire-
ments there are likely to run about-—they could run as high
as S370.000, and they ‘von’t run less than $150,060—and
the additions have beex variously estimated at $190,000.
Now phat is merely one of these city improvement proj-
ets. There will always be certain projects of that kind
going on every year, and we hare tc cooperate with the city
aid keep our. service a acres up with their develop-
ments,
The Examiner : We — have a recess of five min-
utes.
is *
t
6355,
6356
6357
+ wy
6359
6360
2120 /
5 /
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
(Whereupon, a short recess was taken, after
which the hearing was resumed. )
The Examiner: Let us resume.
By Mr. Hamilton:
Q. In designing the distribution system, is it necessary
to take into account the occurrence of storms and weather
hazards? A. It is. The design of a distribution system—I
am referring now particularly to the overhead poles and
wires—does not contemplate storms of tornado proportions.
It, is impracticable to design for such icading, and as a
: —2,722—
result of much study over many years, certain standards have
been agreed upon and are published in a circular issued by
the Bureau of Standards, known as Bulletin No. 54.-
That sets out the types of approved. construction for
certain areas in which the loading may be either Light,
Medium, or Heavy. We are in the Heavy loading district,
and carry out the same type of design for these poles, and
with just as great care as we do for our major transmission
towers. x
The reason for that is obviousjthat there are so many
6f the poles and wires and cross-arms that the total invest
ment is very large, and that you can not afford to leave a
big factor of ignorance in your design.
In the éarly days when poles were very cheap, and the
best ones could be had without difficulty, it probably didn't
pay so well to spend too much time in design. Some of the
early systems were just built. But a little at a time, we
found out exactly what poles would do, and the various
2121
“Direct
Stanley Stokes—By Responde
timber is tabulated, allowable stresses are all available, and
we try to stay Within a reasenable factor of safety for what
is known as Class B, or Heavy loading.
There is an allowable variation in such design in which
you can, under certain conditions, operate your conductor
at higher stresses. We prefer to operate and design our
conductor for what is known as 50 per cent. of the ultimate
strength. This is a conservative design. We could go to 60
“ —2,723-—
per vent. without exceeding the code,
The unequal design of structures in a distribution sys-
tem, does no one any good. _ It isa waste of money. If you
have a pole that is a great deal stronger than either the cross-
arm or the wire, or vice versa, you don’t gain any increased
effective strength out of it, and you do spend money. So the
ideal system is ove in which the individual structures are
carefully engineered and watched. it does not require an -
uureasonable amount of time, and you should get a conen
that is consistent.
if you want a stronger pole, design for it, but keep all of
the strengths in a consistent relationship to each owner.
Another thing that is of great importance to an electric
company is the life that you get out of these poles. That
again requires that cure be used in the treatment of the poles,
that is, as to their impregnation. If you are using yellow
pine poles, you have to be careful that you get a high-grade
-pole in the. beginning. That means that you must have speci-
fications on which they are purchased, should have inspec-
tors where they are being treated, and you should see to it
that the pole is what-it is supposed to be.
o
6361
6362
e
6363
6364
6365
6366
A | ede
a ke
‘
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
If a properly treated pole of good quality—and hy good
quality I mean a tree that was not grown in a swamp where
they grow so fast that.there are very few rings per inch, and
—2,f2t—
the woed has no strength—von can take a piece of tir, which
has been grown'in very wet soil, and it. may only have 5 or
6 rings per inch, and it Las all the characteristics of a Nabis-
ca wafer. If you squeeze it in one direction it will ‘crush, ~
particularly if it is wet. That type of timber will not last.
Now then, if you get good timber, and have it properly
treated, and if your hardware is carefully selected, you get
an effective life out of all proportion to a carelessly done job.
That is why continuous attention and intelligent analysis
pays well. | :
We try to do the very best job with that that we can.
The theories of operating electric companies are frequent:
ly stressed, and sometimes not enough attention is paid to
keeping up und every day applying some of the theories that
are enunciated. It is easy to state a theory, but it is hard
work, day after day, to adhere to it. .
I think the latter is the one that probably has almost as
much effect on the ultimate service as the spectacular things
that are done occasionally.
‘The tornados which have visited our areas at various
times have been pretty severe, but it is a fact that the ser-
vice interruption, particularly in the tornado of 1927 with
which I am familiar, it tore a swath right through the City
. —2,725—
of St. Louis, and it biew in one end of our Venice plant and
blew oui. ihe other, blew the roof off, blew the east wali,
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
Which was a tempo ‘ary metal wall, about two niiles into an
adjoining town, Granite City; and did a + oe of very
peculiar things.
The operator who saw the wind coming up rapidly, ran
in under a balcony and the wall fell in on the turbine, which
had just been shut down, but he wasn’t hurt.
Another operator heard'a buzzing noise, a whirring noise,
and he thought the rotary was running away, and he ran
over to attend to that, and it was under a heavy concrete
balcony, and he wasn’t hurt. |
The noise Was due to the running away of a ventilating
fan which was in“the end wail, and was being driven by the
wind, and it threw dts blades all to pieces, and one of them
eat through an oak rail about an inch thick.
The outdoor substatien, which we had: just completed
about three weeks before that, was completely blown away.
One boagd was driven from a Jumber yard across the river
half a mile, and penetrated a transformer tank.
(). [T was just going to inquire whether these calamitous
circumstances happened with any frequency? <A. No, but
‘Twanted to illustrate what really took place with respect
te serviee, ‘
But with all of these factors invelved, the number of
—2,726—
=e
people who were unable to obtain service, and who wanted
it, were very few.’ Keep in mind this, that this plant was
completely duplicated by others, and the loss of that Vengce
punt did not affect anyone. . .
All of our major distributions underground, and the
areas on either side of this swath, knew nothing about it,
»
6367
6368
6369
2124
6370 : Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
/ |
and the people Within the particular area, which -was about
a quarter of a mile wide,—-and this doesn’t go continuously,
it left and;came back down again in two or three places—
they did not require service because the buildinys were
destroyed or damaged, and we were able to restore the situa-
tien to normal with & very moderate loss ‘of ‘service.
I can say, as far as 1 know, that we received no com-
plaints. ‘ , a -
—2,727—
6371 At: a time like that, the publig does not complain, they
~ ~understand’ what is going on-and they compliment you on |
the quickness with which serv ricé is restored.
Now, of course, a tornado like that has occurred only
twice in St. Louis, once in 1896, which di dn’t do as much
damageyand one in 1927.
We have had major sleet storms, one in 1916 and another
in 1924, and we had a 30-hour downpour in 1915. Those all
caused more or less trouble, but that represents all of the
calamitous storms ‘of those proportions that we have been
able to locate as far back as we can find any records, and the
loss of service under those gunditions is not severe, and we
get all of our crews, acer ulate any construction crews, and
crestor e the service as quickly as vossibde. a.
/ In one particniar case, I was building the Crystal City
[ tronstyission, line from Cahokia to Cry -ofAl City, and I had
around 160 men ov that job. There was another construe:
tion job under way,\and this sleet storm of 1924 hit the city.
It didn’t bother the ¢
ty very much, but it bothered the out:
Iving territory more.
9125
Stanley. Stokes—By Respondents—Direct 6373
ning tL tu it, degrees above the surrounding territory, and
ie
~~
ss
ie sleet didn’t form heavily in the city.
We put that crew of 160 men from this transmission line
job, as assistants to the regular crew, and we cleaned up that
i She | —2,728—
area’ there in very short order. )
‘So that, in times of emergency we do the very best we
cai, and we think we do a very creditable job. Those don’t
occur except at very rare intervals.
Q. Your testimony so far has covered the major classifi- 6374
‘ations of the property of the group. In order to complete
the story, however, will you indicate very briefly the riature
and extent of the generai purpose facilities which the Union
Hectric » vroup Owns and operates? A. In running a system
such as that operated by the Union Electric Company of
Missouri and its subsidiaries, the Union Efectric group, there
are required a number of other facilities not specifically
engaged ‘in handling electric current. |
There are numerous general. purpose structures of which
the following list which I propose to read, will be an example.
This classification refers to offices for geferal office purposes. 6375
In the City Division, we have 5 offices including a large
central office building.
In the St. Louis County Divisiou, we have 5 offices, in-
cluding their maiu division office at Webster Groves.
In what we refer to.as our ontlying divisions, and that
comprises the counties surrounding the City of St. Louis and
St. Louis County, there are 9 offices. Those are located in
—2,729—
Franklin © ounty, St. C harles County —-
6376
6377
6378
2126
°
Stanley Stokes—By Kespondents—Direct —*
Q. (Interposing) How many officers do you have in
Franklin County? <A. We have four offices in Franklin
County, one in St. Charles County, 2 in Jefferson County;
2 in St. Francis County; 1 in St. Charles County—-the office
in St.-Charles County operates for the 2 companies in St..
Charles both of which are direct parts of the Union Electric
Company of Missouri, and the second one that I mentioned
had to do with an office for the St. Charles Electric Light &
Power Company, which is one of tne Union Electric group.
Another office is at Lakeside, Missouri, for the Lakeside
Light & Power Company. That is right.on the edge of the
county line, I think it is on the edge of Miller County, but
IT can’t say definitely whether Lakeside is in Miller County
or just over the line. That doesn’t matter and it is very close
to that point. |
The Union Electric Company of Illinois has three offices,
one at Alton, one at East St. Louis, and one at Hartford.
‘The Iowa. Union Electric Company, and the Mississippi _
River Power Company, together, have six offices lecated in
the towns of Keokuk, Ft. Madison, and Dallas City, Iowa.
Q. Now, in general, w hat is the nature of these offices?
A. They. are offices
Q. (interposing) Are they general offices? A. General
/ —2,730—
offices at which the clerical work, billing, accounting and
headquarters in the smaller divisions, as well as the points
to which the foremen of the operating division would report.
In addition to such office building, we hate arr rangements
made, either in our own ‘offices or in buidlings owned and
operated by others, whereby customers can convenienth pay
their bills. There are a large number of such pay stations.
2127
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct 6379
I might summarize those to indicate the extent of them.
The City Divigten of the Union Electric group has 69 pay
stations. The St. Louis County Division has 42, The out:
lying divisions have 36.
Q. And these points at which payment can “be made are
distributed, are they, throughout the territory? A. Dis-
tributed in the most convenient manner that we can devise
for the benefit of the customers. There are a combined total
of 158, if you will add 11 other miscellaneous offices nov
included in that group. : 6380
(). Now, very briefly, can you state the number of points
at which trouble calls are received and repair crews dis-
patched? A. I have the detailed information on the places
at which trouble calls can be received or dispatched, and I
can summarize those.
In the City Division, they are all handled from the 12th
Street office where we 5a quite a trouble force available at
| | —2,731—
all hours. ; ‘
Q. Is that your main office? A. That is our main office
and that is where the main force is concentrated, and where 6381
—we-have the extensive telephone facilities and everything
that is required to-earry on such work.
The St. Louis County Division handles their trouble calls
in a similar manner froin their main office at Webster
Groves, } . /.
The outlying divisions, which are scattered through these
varigus counties, necessarily have to have available a trouble
report point for each of the divisions, and ‘that includes 9,
ca at. Festus, 1 at Flat River, 1 at Washington, 1 at St.
6382
6393
2128
‘Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
Charles, 1 at Pacific, Bonne Terre, De Soto, Union, and St.
Clair.
A similar point is located at the headquarters office in
the town of St. Charles and trouble calls sor Lakeside are
handled at Lakeside. ;
The Union Electric Company of Illinois handles them
from their three offices at Aiton, East St. Louis, and Hart-
ford.
The Iowa Union Electric handles their calls at 5 points,
largely at Keokuk and Ft. Madison, with a smaller quantity
of calls handled at Dallas, Warsaw, and Hamilton. That is
a point just across the dam, that is merely a matter of con-
venience.
In addition to points at which you can pay bills, and .’'
fin which we dispatch our r trouble men, we also haye other
—2,732—
types of facilities, pole yards, for example, which are a very ~~
~~ important. adjunct.to an electric company, where we store
6384
all our poles and some others facilities to go with distribu:
tion, so you don’t have to dul very far to get to any par
ticular point on the system.
The Union Electric Company of Missouri has 14 loca-
tions at which such storage is kept; the Union Electric Com-
pany of Llinois has two; and the lowa Union Electric Com —
pany has five, making a total, I believe of 21. |
We also have garages. Some of them are.rather large,
extensive garages. :
The Union Electric Company of Missouri has, in the Ci
Division, tw6 garages, one of which has just been completed
and is a very modern and up-to-date garage, not only a build-
2129
wee a :
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct 6385
ing, but yard ard other facilities including cranes, material
. handling devices, and other features, in whieh we have a
combined group of facilities to handle both transportation
equipment-as well as material.
Q. Just give the total figures on this, if you will? A,
For the entire Union El¢ctric group?
Q. Yes. A. There are 13 independent locations at which
garages are maintained in the Union Electric Company of
Missouri. : tes
The Union Electric Company of Illinois has 3; and the ani
Iowa Union Electric Company and fhe Mississippi River
Power Company have 5. A
| —2,733—
In addition, we have storerooms, some of which are lo-
cated at the samé points as the garages, and some of which
are not, but we are rather proud of our facilities and opera-
tions. Taney are very modern and up-to-date in all of the
equipment which is expeditiously reguired to handle large
quantities of material. |
There are, for the Union Electric Company of Missouri, 10 638
such siorerooms; for the Union Electric C ompany of Illinois, .
d; and for ‘the Iewa Union Electric and Mississippi River
Power Company—). In addition to that, we have a number
Of repair shops which total, for the entire group, 4. One of
those is a very extensive and complete machine shop with all
modern machine tools’such as milling machines and welding
and cutting equipment. We do a large part of our own re-
/pair work in the shop. We have ‘laboratery facilities for
testing at 5 locations for the Union Electric Company of
Missouri; 1 for the Union Electric Company of Illinois; and
6388
6389
6390
9130
¢
/
Stanley/Stokes—By Respondents—Direet -
2 for the Iowa Union Electric Company and Mississippi
River Power Companys combined. :
These laboratories are primarily for meter testing, but
along with that type of testing they do various other test-
ing, usually electric. They test. rubher gloves and they test
electric ranges and tesi_ new appliances,
‘tric testing. Wedo not maint: iin an ordinary meché —
iy 734—
testing lahoratory such -as is used for cement a, and so
on, as I explained pre ‘viously... ae >
Q “These all-purpose facilities are ostributed rather
generally, are they, throughout, the territor: > A. Yes, they
are generally distributdd, but T wouldn't want. it thought
from that, that they are ctrélessly distributed. They are in
selected locations, selected with great care, You see if we
can analyze the number of trips made'to and from thesé
yards, afyer we get several years of experience, we can ind:
cate the possibilities of economy if the locations are changed, .
We have had occasion to change very, few, practically none.
There is only one yard that I know of that has been con-
cluded to be in not-the best location. This new one will take
care of that.
But the loc ation of a pole yard receives careful study
and analysis as to where these poles are going to go and how
much haul there: will be from that point, and Ww e try to pick
them so as to produce the minimum amount of haulage and
travel.’
— Q. The location o f the pole yards may determine to some .
extent the speed at which a repair is made? A. 4 would.
We do not know of ¢ourse-at what point repair work of
2131
- Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
an emergency type is going to be required. Therefore, we
have got to have these yards property distributed so that no
point on the system is excessively removed.
In general, however, I think the greatest economy is ob-
, : —2,735—
iained In the location where the normal operation, every
day, of hundreds of irucks hauling this material, will not
produce an excessive mileage.
The light type of trouble work is not entirely related to
these pole yards. The trouble man would get to an emer-
yency ina light cur anyway. He would be dispatchéd from a
garage. If the service was of some particular major import-
fince, if there had been some severe breakage of a pole, or
something like that, that pole would have to bé delivered
from the nearest point. |
(). Now, very briefly, if vou will, the nature and extent
of the transportation and construction equipment of ‘the
“group? A. The transportation equipment is an extensive
‘tem in a company of this type, referring to the Electr.c
“onpany of, Missouri, the Union Electric Company of
-lissouri and the group. We have quite a fleet of construc-
tion and miscellaneous equipment. About all I could ‘do
would be to summarize it, the totals, to give an understand-
ing of the magnitude of it. There are 198 passenger cars,
240 trucks, 72 of these large industrial trailers that are
operated from a tractor, 6 tractors; 2 portable cranes, and
one of those is designed to lift heavy foads and was specifi-
'* cally designed to install and remove and maintain these net-
“work transformers which have to be let down through a grat-
ing in the sidewalk from a truck located in the street, and
a) —2,736--
$391
6392
6393
6394
6395
6396
on
2132
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
you cannot afford to obstruct traflic for any length of time
in a busy area. That required ‘rather special design.
We also have concrete mixers——6; and 14 of these gaso-
line driven air compressors on wheels. _
The aggregate cost of this equipment is considerably over
$600,000. : :
We selected the equipment with as much care as we can,
keeping in mind all time the application for which itis-
intended. We do have a lot of street and paving work to do,
and concrete breaking and breaking of pavement, to get into
conduit lines, and economy in that work is very essential, and
machinery helps materially to do it.
Q. The list which vou have inst given includes trouble
cars, does it? A. Yes, that ineludes—well, I listed passenger
curs, but [ am not quite sure whether that figures inclndes
trouble cars or not. The treuble cars, as used by the indi-
vidual treuble men, are passenger cars. I believe that that
figure should include them. .
Q. Do von. mean “should” or does? A. Well, I can’t say
for certain whether it does or not but I can look that up if it
is of any importance. nm
“Q. Now, turning to the operations of the system, will you =
state the base load generating plants in the system and relete
—2,737--
the functions of the other plants to the operating of the base
load plants? A,’ The answer to vour question requires that I
again mention the same power plants that I have previously
mentioned from the standpoint of property, but withthe
intention now of stating something about how they operate
The Union Electric groap has this interconnect¢d gen-
erator system consisting of the 6 plants, 4 steam and 2 had,
21338
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
and the plant which is depended on for the higher load
factor work is Cahokia, where the better equipment is avail-
able in quantity. In combination with the hydro plants, we
assign to the different units in the different stations a load
which they can carry most economically at the time.
The hydro plants in this system are constantly varving
their output, and it requires a very close detailed attention
to keep the steam plants fitted In with the requirements of
the load, and at the same time utilize the hydro power inso-
far as possible.
The operation of such a system is much more complicated
than that of a straight steam system, and is somewhat difii-
cult to explain in a limited time.
The fivst situation which we encounter in attempting to
set loadings is that we have to find out what is the depend-
able capacity for different types of service of each of these
plants. .
‘The drainage area of Osage, for example, is not the same
| ek
as that for Keokuk. Therefore, there should be and is seme
diversity between these two properties. The Keokuk plant
has limited storage, and fhat has to be kept in mind, and if
there is any considerable amount of stream flow, that has
to be used.
Osage has storage, but it has to be scheduled and used
effectively to get the most good out of it.
The basis of our operation may be expressed by stating
that as a result of many calculations and experience to date
which is about 8 years, we are confident that we can safely
assign, as u combination rating for Osage and Keokuk, the
6397
6399
gy
2134
6400 Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
ability to carry 200,000 kilowatts of our system peak for
the entire period of the winter peak.
That is, not 24 hours a day, but to cut 200,000 kilowatts
off of that peak each day for as many days as required.
2, sae
The individual ratings of those plants, of course, are
at various times much larger than that. You can get from
130 to 160 thousand kilowatts out of the Osage, — 135,000
out of the Keokuk plant.
6401 Now to illustrate the actual method of operation, Keokuk
never gets below, in an ordinary year, say, 70,000 kilowatts.
Any reduction below that is of very rare occurrence. That
being the case, that 70,000 kilowatts of water power energy
would either go over the dam or.we must make use of it.
So it is placed first, it carries what I would call the base’
load, 24 hours a day. |
Then the steam plant, the best unit available at the time,
probably 75,000 in our case, would be placed next, and oper.
ated at its maximum efficiency point. °
Then the next less efficient unit, and so-on until we
6402 finally get to the reserve plants, some of which may be
actually shut down cold.
In certain years, Rivermines will not be oper rated at all.
In other years it will be operated for a very short time.
Now that is the type of operation for which the Osage
plant is primarily designed. |
On the other hand, suppose that instead of having a very
Jean or dry year, and what we call a low send-out for wate? -
power, suppose we have a very good vear. Also let us assume
—-2,740—.
a
———
2135
4
y Respondents—Direct 6403
“~
Stanley Stokes—i
that we may have just installed a new large unit such as
the plant which is now under construction. Under those
wnditions we Would not have to reserve Osuge specifically
to cut this*winter peak, we could use it any way we wanted
to for that year. tee
And what we do do is to try to schedule the operations in
such a Way as to get>the greatest number of kilowatts,
‘ilowatt-hours, out of that plant in that year. ;
In the years just before such a unit is to be installed, the
greatest value that Osage can be to us is to make a firm 6404
cut-off of this 200,040 kilowatts, even if we have to sacrifice
afew kHowatt hours. The result is that in making that firm
winter Cut-oif, we schedule the fevel of the reservoir by what
is kuown asa rule curve. We have checked the rainfall for
i) vears, we have checked the records the years the plant
las been running, and we know whai the minimum rainfall
we can count on for the next certain number of weeks is.
lt may be greater than that and probably will be, but
that is the least.
Now, in pulling down the reservoir, you have got to watch
wo factors. One, you must not get it so low that you can't 6405
get it back full ahead of its winter peak, even though you
have got/the lowest rainfall on record. So whenever you
gett down to the point at which minimum rainfall: would
| | 2.741
just bring it up, th you quit drawing it down and start
tuning your lower efficiency steam plants. nae ;
On the other hand, if yea pull it down too far, then, even
_inan ordinary year where you are not concerned about the
winter peak, in trying to get more rainfall in the reservoir
6406
6407
6408
2136
™~ Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
you may overdo the job and have the effect of operating your
storage reservoir at a lower head than could otherwise have
been done. :
So it is really a very nice engineering operation and cal-
culation day by day to watch this operation and see to &
that the plants are sclfeduled to get the greatest good not
only from the equipment, so as to keep fixed charges at a
minimum, but from the hydro plant to get all the kilowatt
hours you can, and from the steam plants to be sure you are
operating the most efficient unit for the particular work at
the time. | ae
~The usual way of expressing this operation is to state that
a duration curve is constructed which can be described as 4
curve in which the ordinate is kilowatts, and the abscissa is
hours per year up from zero to 8,760, or the total year.
The product of hours, times kilowatts, is kilowatt-hours,
or energy. The result is that the area ander this curve rep-
resents, energy, and any particular height on the curve rep-
resents the kilowatts at that point, and the length over
; 5 | —2,742—
to the right of the curve indicates the number of hours per
year at which that particular load is used.
lor example, suppose that the system peak for the winter
of 1940 were to be 500 cr 515 thousand kilowatts. If we took.
200,000 kilowatts off of that, that would: leave us 315,000
kilowatts. Now we would examine this curve at the height
of 315,000 from the bottom, and go horizontally over until
we intersected the curve, and that would tell us how many
hours that 315,000 kilowatts would have to be carried.
At the top of the curve we know that it is just one hour,
and working out each step there, we can determine the num-
2137
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents—Direct
ber of kilowatt-hours that it would take to cut 200,000 kilo-
watts off of our 1940 winter peak.
Then we analyze the storage of the reservoir and we find
that the reservoir just has enough kilowatt hours to do that,
including the rainfall that will be acquired, even on a mini-
mum year. : . | ?
All of these calculations have to be made in advance.
‘They are corrected as fast as the actual figures are available,
but we have to assume in these operations that each esti-
mate ahead is based on a minimum year, and then correct it
as quickly as the actual figures are available.
Ry that process of cut and try, each day, and correcting
a preliminary estimate and finally getting it pretty accurate,
—2,7438—
.we schedule the operation of both the hydro and steam
plants in conjunction with each other, so that the hydro
cuts this firm peak and at all other times, when it has excess
water, we use it for kilowatt hours, and shut down our big
units for overhaul during the period of flush water, and by
that I mean during the spring months, about three months.
It is possible to overhaul two of the largest units on the
system during the period of the plentiful water power in
the spring. At the present time we have occasion to only
overhaul one, because we only have two of those units, and
we alternate them, each one every other year.
‘If we were to acquire another large unit of equivalent
size, or even sligltly larger, there would be' certain years
in which we would want to overhaul two large units in the
same year, and ‘we could schedule both of them in that
period.
6409
6410
6411
6412
6413
6414
2138
Stanley Stokes—By Respondents-—Direct
During the valley of the load, after the summer peak is
over, there is opportunity to overhaul one of our next larg-
est units, such as the 50,000. By that method we operate
with a s
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.