Statement as to Jurisdiction — Cleveland v. United States
Supreme Court brief1945
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
“:
. _ .
i t °
tL éas< htt ERE, 9. SENS i
cients “eel cocaine Na IO
_ SUPREME COURT OF THE coma STATES —
OCTOBER TERM, 7 1943
THE CITY OF CLEVELAN D,
A ppe lant.
| US.
THE UNITED STATES ‘OF AMERICA anp FEDERAL
- PUBLIC HOUSING AUTHORITY. | ~
APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNJTED STATES FO}
~THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHTO. 6
STATEMENT AS TO JURISDICTION.
Tuomas A. BurRKE, JR., °
“Director of Law;
“ Josern F. Smiru, -
' Assistant Director of Law,
Ss Counsel for Appellant. *
INDEX.
Sups Ect INvEX..
‘Statement as.to jurisdiction x eh
» The statitery provision believed to sustain the
° . *° - jJurisdietion . SoA kage
~The state statutes which are involved.
° The date of the judgment or decree sought to be
reviewed and the date upon which the. applica-
® " tion for appeal is presented
8h itement showing that the nature of the case
Es ‘and of the rulings of ‘the Court was such as
to bring the-case within the roe pro-
visions ‘relied “on: 20... 2.04... 065:
wa
tended that the questions involved aré sub-
stantial ¢
Cases believed to sustain the jurisdiction
Statement respecting opinions |
Appendix **A’’—Opinion of the District’ Court
Appendix ‘*B’ + Dine nting opinion of Jones, J.
_ Appendix ‘*C’’—Findings of_fact and conclusions of
law’ eae vee | eer Ts
ae . - Taste or Cases CitTen.
Qu: ry v. United States, et al., 316 U.S. 486 | ‘
U nited States v.Certaim Lands in the C ity of Louis-
ville , 18 a d (2d) 684 ;
heiee TES Crren.
, Act of September 1, 1937 (4 49 U.S. C. A. 1405¢)
Constitution of the United States, Tenth Amendment
General (‘ode of Ohio, Section 5328.
Section 5625-3
ms Judici: il ‘ode, Section’ 266, as amended (28 U.S. C. A.
380)
—1678
Statement of the grounds upori “which it is cone.”
_— nit ted. States ( ‘ode ram "aa ‘Title 28, Section 380a |
_ IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR. THE
NORTHERN DISTRICT OF OHIO, EASTERN - ~
DW ISON. = 2s ,
- Cwil aggre )
a“
¢
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA axp FEDERAL
PUBLIC. HOCSING AUTHORITY, :
re Seber Si | | Plaintiffs, _
JOUN J. BOYLE, County Treasurer or Cuyanoca County,
Onto: JOHN A) ZANGERLE, Cotwty Avprror. or Cuya-
nods County, Onto; BOARD OF COUNTY COMMIS:
SIONERS OF CUYAHOGA COUNTY, OHIO, ayn CITY
OF CL EVEL AND, Def OFS |
e
J URISDICTIONAL STATEMENT SUBMITTED BY
j DEFENDANT, CITY OF CLEVELAND.
SRS © cer BI
z ed >
en
a <a
eee
The debaadane: aposiiant; ( ‘ith ef ( ‘leve oe having pre-
sented this day their petition for appe “al, now file this their
Statement on the basis upon which it ts contended that the
_ Supreme Court of the. United States has jurisdiction on
-direct appeal to, review the final order, judgment or decree
it question and should exercise such jurisdiction in this
case. ;
le
*
A. The Statutory Provision Believed to Sustain a . uris-
_ diction. :
This appeal is. prosecuted’ from a final order, aca or
decree which permanently restrains the defendants, tax”
assessing and tax levying officials of € ‘nyahoga C ounty and ©
the deferdanit, the € itv. of (le velaml, i in the State of Ohio,
~frem taking any action jto asse: S levyy or collect taxes on
certain lands owned by the plafatifts in said City, as pro-
vided and required by the laws fof Ohio, and the pleadings
in the casey: particularly the complaint of the plaintiffs
allege that Sections 5328" and 5625- of the General Code of
Ohio and préceedings the sreunder contravel ne ‘the Constita-
~ tion of the United States. eee
The final judgment here appealed from was entered in the
? District Court of the United States for the Northern -Dis-
trict of Ohio, Eastern Division,,on November 19, 1943 by a
statutory court’ consisting of one circuit and two district
judges specially, convoked under and by virtue of the pro-
Visions of Section 266 (as amended). ef the Judicial Code |
28 U.S.C. A. SSO}. : ; aot
It is our contention that said section authprizes a direct
appeal from the District Court to the’ Supreme Court of the
Usted States, and particularly’ in the following exact lan-
guage found at the end of the section:
‘and SEE iw STE to The Supreme “Court may be
taken from the final decree granting or denying « a ts r-
juan injunetion. in such a suit.’
The above intend section provides ihat-a three judge
court be convened to hear either an application for an inter- °
‘loe utory injunction, or to hear the case on its merits whe n
_-anorder is Sought ‘restraining the enforcement, operation °
or execation of any statute of the state by restraining the
NN Oe
mes
bes
ATR con
<
action of any ‘officer of such state in the enforcement or
exec ution of sueh statute,
* * 9
B. The: State Statutes Which Are Involved...
The plaintiffs’ coniplaint set forth that the lands and im-
proverents of tlie United States of America described”
- therein were assessed for taxation by the defendants rh
pursuance of the statutes of the: State of Ohio, and that
those statutes and particularly Ohio General Code Sections
9328 and 5625-3 contravene the Constitution of the United
“States when applied-to property owned: hy the United States
and the Federal Public llousing& Authority.
Ohio General Code Section 5328 provides in substance as
- follows: as Rae es ie .
** All real property in this state shall be subject to
taxation, except only’ such as may be expressly ex:
empted therefrom. : rps All property mentioned in-
this section shall be entered on the general tax list and
duplic ate of” taxable property as ‘prescribed in this
title.’* (Throckmorton’s One Volume Ohio-Code. In
1940 Edition this section is found" at Page .6 of Part
Second. ) :
\
— Ohio Ge neral Code Section 5625-3 provides in- substance
us follows: . A aeee | : 9
‘The taxing authority of ez h subdivision is het eby
authorized te levy taxes annually, subject to the limita-
tions, amd. restrictions of this act, on the real ancdper--
sonal property within the subdivision for the purpose
of paying the current operating expe nses of the sub-
division and the one or construction of perna-
-hent Hnprove ments. * * Ail taxes levied on prop-
erty shall be extended on the tax «luplicate by the-
‘county auditor of the county in which the property js
located, and shall be collected by the county treasurer.
of such county in the same manner atid under the same. -
laws, ‘rules. and regulations as: are prescribed for the’
2
oom,
Soe ts 4
“asse samient ‘and colleetion of founty taxes. a” estes
(Throckmorton. =» One Volume Ohio Code. In 1940
» Edition this section is found ¢ at DP ave 175 of Part
Second, ) aS Ka
In view. of the f fact that ' sites weds to restrain an
“officer from: carrying out thie execution of, the statutes of
the State of Ohio and allege: 's the unconstitutionality of cer-
tain laws of. the State of Ohie, we have exactly the situation -
that is outlined in 28 U S.C. A. Section 380. We might
add to this that the court in its Separate Findings of Law
and Fact made a definite finding to. the effect ph ‘Sa sub-
stantial constitutional que stion was involved.’
. The Date of the J udgment: or Decree Sought to Be Re-
_ viewed and the Date upon Which the Application for
" Appeal Is Presented: | nae ce
* The final order, judgment or decree, here sought tobe
reviewed wi is ente ‘red and spread of record. on. November
19, 1945. On J: anuary: AS, 1944 a motion Was granted ‘allow-
ing a request by this: defe nd: nit for an amendment to the
Findings of Law and Fact, and on. Jiiuary IS, 1944 ‘the
defendant, City of Cleveland” = motion for ne Ww trial was
Ov er ruled. |
‘This petition for ‘appeal herein was presented arid filed
on the: Yth dav of February, 1 _
_ The Statement Showing That the Nature of the Case and
of the Rulings of the Court’: Was-Such as to Bring the
Case within the Jurisdictional Provisions Relied op.
The plaintiffs have acquired by condemnation the lands |
involved in this suit, and. the same were sequired for the
purposes of establishing low-cost housing. The question’
“sinvolved herein arises-out of (ve ownership of lands: that”
were acquired: by ‘the United States of America by con
.
.
A AQ LLIN LOS EON NA AIBN 8S
o 4 e
-
S-
2° —-_ .
dimnation walla the program for National Recovery, ‘rte
does not inivolve property acquired for war housing or for
the housing of war workers. The complaint: alleges that.
the taxing officials and authorities of: Cuyahoga County, |‘
Ohio and of the City of Cleveland have levied general taxes
and spetial assessments against certain properties héld in
the name of the United States of America and on which,
the Federal Public Housing Authority has erected low-cost
—— units. These units have been leased out to the
‘teveland Metropolitan Housing, a State of Ohio Authority, :
aa the jatfer: has: sublet the numerous dwelling units
therein to individual tenants for residential purposes. The
complaint ‘alleges that certain officials of the Taxing Au-
thority of the State of Ohio are attempting to colleet taxes
‘and assessments levied on said properties, and allege that
the taxation laws of the State of Ohio, particularly Sec tions -
5828 and 5625-% of the General. Code contravene ‘the Con-
stitution of the U nited States, and the complaint .seeks to
have the Taxing Authority and the respective officers ‘re-
strained from collecting the taxes heretofore assessed and
do restrain the Authority and officers from further levying
,
taxes against these propertiés.
The complaint hy interlocutory order and perma.
nerit injunction, but
_submitted-on its merits at an early. date without the grant-
agreement of parties the case Was
ing of the interloc ‘utory.order, ‘fhe case came on for hear-
‘ing before a: three judge court, as set up in 28 U. 8. GA;
Section 380. | or re a
_ The court overruled motions to dismiss the complaint,
granted a permanent injunction finding that a substantial
constitutional question was involved, made a declaration that
the taxes and assessments heretofore levied were null and
void, and all notwithstanding: the statutes of the State of-
Ohio requiring the-authorities and officials involved to levy
x . ae . ‘ : e - é a
and collect taxes except on such property as has been ex-,
empted and, further, notwithstanding the factthat no official
of the plaintiffs made application to have said properties: eX-
“mn ted, as required under theslaws of the State of Ohio.
The answer. of the defendant, City of ¢ ‘level and, alleges
that the Act ot September 1, 1937, and particularly ‘that
_ portion of it known as 42 U.S. C. A., H05 (e), is illegal,
invalid and contravenes the Constitution of the. United
_ States, and avers that the power to est tablish low cost hous-
ing is not delegated to the € ongress of the, U nited States
“by the Constitution, and-by-virtne of the Tenth Amend-
“ment to the Constitation it is, allewed that since the power is
not spec ifically délegates:, such powers are reserve to the |
states respectively and_to the people. This raises sang
substantial constitational question which | y virtae of U.
(. A., Title 28, Sevtion 380a is a problegi.to be decided 2
a three judge court and. provides that ‘appeals under this
Le saetion shall be he: ird hy tlie Supreme Court of the United
“States at the earliest: possib létime and shall fake pree ede ee,
*e
over all other matters not of it hike character,
This appeal is prosecuted from the final order of. the .-
three judge court allowing a permaneht imjunetion against
ollee ting ior taxes or assessing future taxes.”
\
S Mtateniant of ‘the Grounds upon Which Tt Is’ 5’ Contended Vs
That the Questions Involved bre Sustained.
The order ‘entered: herein restrains Tax Levying Au-
thorifies and Tax Colléeting Authorities from. pe rforming
duties reqaired of them under-the laws of the State of
Whio.. It must be concluded that this is upon the grounds |
that such laws of Ohio confravene the Constitution of the
United States. Such action affects the revenues available to
the State and its political subdivisions Tor the operation of” ae
the governmental functions and duties thrust upon them by
Dy severe ines
—
-_
COR a dW TAG SER ROTI FEE ERM. i Btn NS
Ae. sAE
a ROA 8 RARE YAR
el pee
-
Pad
such housing developments. If requires the State or its
- political Subdivisions co proceed with improvements such .
as the laying of water inains, pavements, sidewalks, estab-
lishing roads and building bridges, without ‘being able to
tax larg. » areas of lands that are now devoted by the Goy-
ernment to residential purposes, und without giving to the
-taxing subdivision the power to assess suc h property for
special benefits conferred upon it by such improvements,
It compels+ the State to furnish schools for the childrere of
people residing in such projects without atiy contribution
2. or sapport from the prope rty whereii’ they live.
A substantial constitutional question ts-raised bs this de
“fendant? Ss answer wherein it is chimed that the power to
provide low-cost housing is not within the. powers delegated
to Congress by the Constitution of the United States. We.
contend that the Government of the U nited State s has no °
power to acquire, and particularly to mene eb by condentna
tion proceedings ‘ander eminent domain’? ‘private property
for tow “COSY, hoysing purposes, Such a 5 a ee been
“made by thie United. States Cirenit Court. Mf Appeals for
this the Sixth District. The case af United States v. Certain
Lands in the City of Lowistéille, 78 Federal Second, G84, -
; I. Cases Believed to: Sustain the Jurisdiction.
‘We believe that this case comes squarels - ithin the recent
decision of-Qeeriite United States ¢f al, U6 U.S. 486,
wherein in a suit to restrain the enforce ment of a state tax
on the parchase arid ale of gooils at Army Post Exchanze-
on the ground that such exe ‘ange sare federal_instru
* mentalities and are jmmupe from state taxes, and’ stat
taxes as applied to them were icon titution: al, it was bed
‘An appeal trem a decree of in june tion granted. ley
a three-judge Distriet Court under Jud. ¢ ‘ode’ Scetion
266, lies direc ‘tly to thi--Coui, HOT a the Care Court
- of Appe als.’ '
eo.
@
_ Statenient Respecting Opinions.
yy a court be low made certain Findings 0 of Fact and Con:
chision is of Law,.Jater amended upon motion, and de live ‘red
both a majority and a dissenting opinion. Copies of the’
Amended Findings of Faet t and Conglusions of Law and
of these opinions are
-o - me Sa)
attached hereto as Appendices’ ** A"
Respectfully submitted,
,
are Dy BRS °
THomas A. Burke, Jr, \ |
Director of Law;. |
Josern hb. Suirn,
Assistant Dire clor of Law,
Of Counsel,
ari or Hiall,
Phone—( hh. 0970,
Atforncys for City of ‘Cleveland,
2
2
oa \
77
4 \ bad
4 a
aol ‘
” 3 So
a2
i.
s .
is 3 a oak aa
Lee
sed Pes TEM
APPENDIX : ‘A’. ;
Filed: C. BL W aie. Clerk. -U. S. District Court NDO.
“Nov. 12 1943 3:55 P.M. ;
Civil No. 21897
IN-THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR |
THEE NORTHERN, DISTRICE OF OHIO,
~Unirep Staves or America and Feprrat Pusiic Hovsine
: Avutuonsry, Plaintiffs,
_¢« ae f ' j ae Z
dJoux J, Boyis,. County Treasurer-of Cuyahoga cu eae
—Ohie:JousA.-Zaxcente, County Auditor. of Cuyahoga
County, Ohio; Boarp or Country Com MISSIONERS. OF Cuya-
HOGA COUNTY, Onno, and Cary or C LEVEL AN®, De fe ndants.
bee ided - —— 194! 3.
Before Allen, 4 ieeuit Judge, sid Jones ae i reed, District
J Judges.
? .
ALLEN, Circuit Judge:
ae 1 aS
The full court agrees that it has jurisdiction of the peeier
and’ of the subject-matter of. the litigation. - Query +
United States, 316 U.S. 486. But since.we do not unani-
anously aggee that the refl-estat@ is being. devoted to a
public use, it seems advisable to vive this question a more
format considera fon than that embodied in the findings
®
of fact and conciusians of law.
The real estate involved in this controversy was ac-
quired by the “United States through condemnation pro-
ceedings institutéd by the Federal Emergeney Admiinis-
trator of Public. Works, acting pursuant to the authority
ef Title 11, 66 201, 202 and 203%of the National Industrial
Recovery, : Z vet of June 16, 1933, 48 Stat. 200, 201, 202, 40
U.S. C., 66 401, 402, 403. These and related, sections of
' the iictate were held unconstitutional by the Court of,
» Appeals for the | Sixth Circuit in United States v. Certain
Lands in Cityfof Louisville, 78 Fed, (2d) 684, and by a
9
g
10 —
Distriet Court in United States v. Certaim Lands in City
of Dettoit, 12 Fed. Supp. 345, upon the ground that such.
a taking was not for a public ase ane that the Congréss
is net authorized to. appropriate money to promote the
cenerat welfare of even a great.number of residents -of
the community in which the project was ‘situated. While
a 'writ of certiorari was filed to the decision-in United
States Vv. Certain Lands in ¢ “ihy of Louisville, the case was :
disniissed upon motion by the: Government prior to oral
argument in the Supreme Court, for the reasom that in‘
forty-one of the slum-clearance prone existing through-
out the Nation the necessary land had heen secured. by
negotiation, and in eight other cifses, while condemnation
-procevdings were resorted te, no question had been raised
as td the legafity of the Act. It therefore was concluded |
that a Louisville case — oa practic ‘al matte r chad become
moot.. .130 Ai L. KR. 1069, 1072. «°° .
Thereafter the United States, first thréugh the Federal
Mmergency. Administrator of Public Works and later
through the Federal Public Housing Authority, constructed (3
on the land so aequired the buildings necessary for a low-
cost housing slum-cle ‘arance project.
An 1937 the Congress enacted the so-called a nited St ites
Hous sing Act of 1937,°° 50 St: it. Sss, 42.U. S. ¢., $§ 1401-.
“1450. This Act created a Government wa ES to he .
‘known-as the United States Housing Authority, which was
_ to funetionw as an ‘instrumentali tv of the United States in
tending financial assistance to state. and local honsing agen-
cies for the. purpose of improving public housing condi- |
tions. -In addition, 61494 (d). empowered the President
to transfer Qo the Authority’ any right” interest or title
held By¥ any department @r agency of tire: Federal Govern.
ment imany housing of sium-clearance.projects Gonstructed
or in process of constructionton the date of the enactment
of the Act, and pursuant thereto the real estate in question
was transferred to the-Authority Ky exeeutive order No,
+7732, effective Nove mbe r 1, 1937... The property was there-
after leased to the Cleveland | Metropolitan Housiig An-
thority under the provisions of ¢ 1412 {b) and (al).
The prince ipal le ber question in the ease # whether. prop- |
erty so acquired | may, under the restrictions of the United
piers per “
esate hart Ue Cao t toa Sok mare
LN et le LENE ORE VEG OD AT
ee ko ee ad
v
es 11
¢
States ( ‘onstitution, be used by the U nited Riatos ‘ bw:
cost housing and slum- clearance. It is contendéd that the
- employment by the Federal Government of real estate: for
the purposes dese ribed does not prema gay a public use, and
hence does not fall. within the powers of the Federal Gov- -
ernment. : mile Wear
With reference to the constitutionality of the United
States Housing Act of 1937; which is attacked bere, the
question is an,open ene. The previous decisions in this
cirenit which rule upen a Similar que sstion apply only to
the housing and slum-clearance provisions of the National
Industrial Recovery Act, 40 UL S. C., § 401 et seq. _More-
over, in Helvering v. Davis, 3010. S. 619, 640, the Supreme —
Court squarely overruled the doctrine relied upon for those
decisions, and -he Id that Congress has the power to impose .
a tax and appropriate money for the General welfare.
Sheward Machines Co. v. Davis, 301 U.-S. D48 5° United.
States v. Butler, 297 U. S.1, 65. Under these pronounce-
ments the Court-of Appeals for the Sixth Cireuit, in Bas- | ane
tian v. United States, 8 Fed. (2d) 777, deeided that a
resettlement project established under the .authority: of
the Emergeney Relief Appropriation Act of April 8, 1935, |
e. 48, 49 Stat. 115, was valid. Substantially the same con-
tentions as are urged against the constitutionality of the
present projects, were presented in that Case and over-
ruled. :
Under the recent diotis sions of the Supreme Court, it is
significant that the stated purpose of the Act under con-
sideration is much broader than the purpose of the emer-
© geNCV housing sections of the National Industr ial Recovery
Act, 40 UL S, C6 408 (a), which dee laved that. the pro-
Visions in vaucntion | were enacted ‘with a view to Inereasing
employment quickly (while reasonably securing any loans
nade by the Lnited States) * * o The. purpose. of
the 1937 statute-is announced in-the hedy of the Act, ts
follows :—
Tithe 42 U.S... $4401, - os : ie
- > “Tt is hereby ie tsrbe the policy of the v nited
States, to py unote the general welfare of the Nation
° / < a
12
! e :
by employing its funds and eredii, ds’ provided 1 in this
chapter, to assist"the several States and their political .
subdivisions to alleviate present and reéeurring uneim-
ployitent and to remedy the unsafe and “insanitary
housing conditions and the acute shortage of decent,
safe, and sanitary dwellings for fanslies of low in-
come, in rural or urban communities, that are injurious
to she health, safety, and morals. of the eitizéys of
the Nation.” ies
‘It not only is no longer an open question that Congress
er power to appropriate money to promote the general
welfare, but vi determination ef the Congress that the
projects are in furtherance of the general welfare is de-
cisive, unless arbitrarily mitde and cleariy wrong.- Helrers.
mg Vv. Davis, supra., 640, 641. ‘Here there is nothing to
show that the legislative chdice is clearly wrong. While
if is true that in former periods of our history such proj-
ects ight not have heen necessary for the ‘general welfare,
it is also true, as’stated in Welecring-v. Duvis, that ‘*Needs
that were narrow or parochial a century.ago may be inter-
woven in our day with the well-being of the Nation.”’
Despite the difference in character of the sluné areas exist-
ing in diffe ‘rent parts of the country, as was feund by the
National Commission on Law Observance and Enforcemeut
_inits First Report on the Caiises of Crime, the delinqueney
@areas in these cities “display similar characteristies poor
“Nenad conditions; shifting and deereasing populations:
‘great poverty and dependence; a marked shsence of the
home-owning ¢lass; a jargely foreign population: of in:
ferior soc ial status; unwholesome types of recreation; in-
adeqnate: open-air play facHities.°” On the other hand,
it isa matter of Wwidesyiread Knowledge that slum-clearance
ina direet remedy for the insanitary, unhealthful eondi- :
tions that arise out of the crowding and filth of the slum
areas. Where old tenements are tern down, and re placed:
-by’ NOY, clean, healthful buildings, open to light and air.
tere is a sharp decline in disease: and delinquency. . In
Liverpool one such slum-clearauce project regained -7 es;
of the old population, and. oe 99%. Yet after a short
period crime had decrease ‘d among these same residents to.
; “A
-
_ 2
S
ag
less than 25% of the former figure, tuberculosis dropped
from 4 to 1.9 _per thousand, and the death rate dropped
from 50 to 27 per thousand. 14 American -Ene. Social
Science, 99. - S i
The proble m of eliminating the. slum tivoushoat: the
country is national in scope and it lies within a domain
which the individual States calnot- teach, aandover’ which: :
the Congress alone his power.
The inditidual States have long deen held to have power
to enter into such projects within their ‘bordets. Green v..
' Fraz ier, 253 US. 2337 In such cases the power was up-
held on the ground of -public ase, and we think the same
considerations compel’ tlie conclusion here that a ‘public 3 use
grain The fact that private individuals’ receive direct
benefit from these projects does not deprive the public of
the iftse, The public, after. all, is merely an aggregation
of private individuals. Publie Schools, publie universities,
public parks, and many similar governmental institutions
sand projeets, which offer definite publie benefit extend pe-
culiar benefit to tlloose who have immediate access to them.
may) use by the general public is not essential. Strickley .. |
Highland Boy>Mining Co., 200 U.S. 527, 531. Ner
Sih the use fail to ebe public upon the ground that the
ats immediate enjoyment of it is limited toca small group or
evén to a single person. Fallbrook Irrigation Dist. v.
Bradley, 164.U. S. 112, 161; 3/1. ee eee
Duck Cov. Alabama lute Laugh Power Co.., =i U.S. 30, 32:
Rindge Co. v. County of Los Angeles, 262 U. ‘. 700, LOT. at
We think -that a project, so closely cea with the
. public health, safety sind morals af the citizens of the Nation
_axthe abdiition ona national se ope of thy stun, painty .
constitutes a project of public use, and is authorized under
the Constitution of the United States. Oflahoma City v.
Nanders, 94 Feéd.-42d) 323 (C: C, A. 10). Cf. Mousing
rete a of City of Dallas Vi Higginbotham, Ma? ». W:
(2d). 79, 130A. TL. R. 1053. Pa
px ibese reasons, as well as those stated i in the findings
of fact and eqnclusions of law, it follows that the injune-
tion obayitd for‘is-allowed, 9. 2.
. . 14
APPENDIX ‘‘B”’.
Piled. C.B. Watkins, Clerk. U.S. District Court NDO. «?
“Nov. 12, 1943, 3:55 PM. epee : O-. a
3 3 ee. eros 2
Civil No. 21897
IN THE U SITED STAT ES_ DISTRIC T COU RT FOR _
.. THE NOR HWERN DISTRICT OF OHTO.. :-
Usrrep Srates, oF AMERICA and’ Feperat Pusiuic’ Housine -
Avrnorey, Plaintiffs...’
eet
Jous J: Boyie, County ‘Treasurer of Cuyahoga County,
Ohio; Jouyx: A. ZANGERLE, County Auditor of Cuyahoga
County, Ohio; Boarp or Couxtry ComMasstonens oF Cuya-
HOGA COUNTY, Oto, and Crry or CLeveLani, Defendants.
Jone s, J: ( Dissenting) :
I agree that property held by tlie United States, and em-
ploved by it in the execution’ of its constitutional owe rs’.
- er functions, may he held exempt froin State taxation:
- haut i think that inv holding this: property in the name of
© an instrumentality ‘of the United aaa Pary- the use of
special or se lected classes or people, or specially selected —
—rhoips aid with, the intention ‘te Saas: and leasing, it to
ii State-created proprietary WeeTey Mal» such a governs
“mental function-#f purpose as to permit its” exemption
from State, County or Municipal taxation. Ino such gir-
cumstances is presented here, [ am of the Upinion that -
the lands were not acquired and are riot held for a govern-_
_ inental function or purpose within the right of constitu.
- tional sovereignty. I think title and use both are essential
. i testing the right to tax exemption of property held by
the sovereign. If title only is the test, constitutional limita-
tions are without meanirig.
It will be noted that Mr. Justice Gray: in writing the
opinion for the court in Van Broklin vs. State of ‘Tennessee;
117 U.S. 151 (relied upon so strongly by the Housing
Pi
3
%
Z
A
ad
a
%
3 Lad
7.
3
- -
- es ,
OS retin SAR Ne RIAY MOGUEE ID ech tnd? Mi Dk. geri ins
an
ne
15
Authority), repeatedly and consistently refers to tax ex-
cmption of property of thé United States used for govern-
mental functions or pufeposes. In that case, the property
was acquired and hetd by thet nited States to enforce and
liquidate®a tax ten, and: this it seems to me was in further-
ance of tlie eecernmental funetion of protecting and pre-
serving its péyenues. Thus, as I think, property held by the
United Sfates, or by an instrumentality -of the Federal
woverniyent, only may be exenrpt from taxation by a State)
or City in which’ the property is situated, where —
Arvoperty is devoted to or uséd-for a sovernment tal
Whetlon or purpose, : Soa ;
No iatter: how desirable. sluni- clearance and- low-cost
housing may be, it is not in my opinion such a Federal
fmiction as to permit exemption ofthe property used there-
for from State taxation. On the contrary, it consistently
chas been held that the power of the States to protect the
lives, health and property of their citizens, and to preserve
cood ofder and public mordls, isa power: originally and
‘always belonging to the State and not surrendered by them
to the general government. Cooley, Principles of Consti-
tutional Law. If the Rederal government may ‘acquire and
hold’ property free from State taxation and devote it to
any use or purpose not-related to governmental functions,
ye re is no. limifation of Federal power over State sover-
enty. Such right is not tnplicit'in Federal sovereignty,
hor is it express or to be implied in the provisions of the
Federal Constitution. 1 think the» property vitivelved in:
+. this Gase is subject to the taxes assessed.
—~
Considering the matter-from another aspect, what has been
done to impair Staté sovereignty, simply stated, is this: the
Federal government has acquired this property and holds
it through its agency, the Housing Authority, for the pur-
pose of furnishing low-cost. housing’ to special groups or ~
classes of inhabitants. This certainly is a private use of:
_the land. The State. County and City furnish benefits and
services to these residents just as they’ furnish services,
facilities and beneti to other residents: Thus to require:
the State to give serices and protection to this property,
and deprive it of its revenues to be.used for such purposes,
.Nov: 12, 1943, 3 : 39 PM.
16 ;
without im: iking any ubstintial 0 or r adequate provision to
" compensate for such, loss of revenues, seems to me to. be
contrary to all sense of Federal or € ‘onstitutional right, ——
a dangerous de nial of State sovereignty.
e
°
e
&
APPENDIX “‘C””.
Filed. @ B. Watkins Clerk. U.S. District Court NDO.
/
e
: Civ il No. 21897.
IN THE DISTRIE ‘'T COURT OF THE UNITED ST Are Ss
FOR THE NORTHE iN DISTRICT OF OHO
The Iasi ORs
6
Danes Sravres or AMERica and Perunaxs Penge Housing -
Avruority,. Plamtiffs, ;
on i *
Joun J. Boyie, County. Treasurer ‘of Cuvahoga County,
Ohio: Sous Al ZaNcerne, County Auditor of Cuyahoga .
County, Ohio; Boanp Ge Country, COMMISSIONERS OF CUYA-
ay ee ry, Outro, and Crry.or Creve ann, Defendants.
i)
MINDINGS OF Fact anp CoNn@nrsions or, Law
Finpincs of Fact
-T;
The plaintiff, United States of America, acquired the
property invelved* in this proceeding upon the filing of ©
declarations of taking in 1934 and 1935 on the specific Gates |
and in the condenination proceedings as set out in para-
graph V of the complaint. - By F.xecutive Order 7732, ef-
fective. November: 1,.1937, al! right, interest aful title to
said land was transferred to the United States Honsing
Authority. (now known as the Federal Public Housing
Authority), a wholly owned government corporation
created unde ‘r the - Act of September 1, 1937, 50-Stat. SS8,
ra
Shae | rT iNest Tees sale ae
I.
Following acquisition of title by the United States, there»
“was constructed on this property by the plaimtiff the neces-.
sary buildings and structures in connection with its use
as 4 low-cost housing development. . Since completion of
the | project in 1937, the individual units have been rented to-
and oce upied: bey indiv idual families of low income, ’
1 * :
Ke ae ~E.
De aien :
Prior to January 1, 1940,.the project was administered.
by the Federal Public Housing Authority but since that
“date it has beer leased to the Cleveland Metropolitan Hous:
‘ing Authority, a publie housing agency created under. the
laws of Ohio, unde Ta lei ‘ise which requires that the property
he sect onty as a stte for tt low rent hoyspo project, us
tnetisured by standards set by the parties,
\ ate °.' £
Loahe \ : 5
Taxes and assessments for the vears 1935 to 1948,
clusive, have been? assessed ‘against the property in the ~
nime.of the United St: ites of Americavand the total taxes
und assessments ap pearing on the tax duplicates, together
With interest and penalties, approximate , the: sum of $1.
DOS S14. 3 _&
= eer
>
\
From September 1, 1957 to January 1, 1940, payments in
the sum of $16,026.78 per vear Were made by the United
States Honsing Authority undey agreements whereby this
Sam was distributed between the € itv of Cleveland, the
‘and 1942. payments
tao, Jt}
Connty of Curahoga and the Board of Education in lien.
of taxes for services rendered, pursuant to the authority,
to nike such payinents set out in ee. 13-6f the Act of Sep:
tember 1, 19387, ) Stat. S88, 894. For the vears 1940, 1941
4 the Same wearly Amount, $16,026.78
were made each-vear by -the Cleveland Mbtropolitan
Housing Authority under similar agreements. —br-T943,
the County of Cuy: yahogal rese ainded its partgn these agree. -
s
“mengs, ; : ane , ie
¢
Sr eS teed ; ,
ss VL. |
The de fendant, Jolin J . Boyle, 2 as County Treasurer of
Cuyahoga County, is activ ely asserting the validity of the
taxes so assessed and: it is ‘his intention to enforce their
collection against the property by suit to. foreclose tie
clauned tax hen. The defendant, Jolin-A. Zangerle, Cotinty
Auditor: of Cuyahoga County, the -defemiant, Board of
County Comuissioners of Cuyahoga County, and. the de-
tendant, City of Cleveland, are also actively asserting that
this property is subject to taxation and it is their inten-,
tion to continue to assess and levy real property taxes there
against wiless restrained by order of this Court.
‘to . f . e
ConcLusions oF Lat
j
Gay ae im
This € ‘court has jurisdiction of Seuss partigs and of the sub-.
ject matter.
es, aoe
Property owned by the United-States of by the Federal
- Public Housing? Authority, formerly the United States,
Housing Authority, is not subject to taxation. by the State
of Ohio or any of its Jegal subdivisions. Mayo etal.
lnited States, 319 bk. Ss. 441. ;
oe
‘The immunity of fedets atiy owned property extends to
and includes arr. immunity from special assessments,
w
— —
capecece-—~ ae
S |S eae
The use of this property as a. site fora low. cost hotlying
project is a publie use... Rn cx
- Y. Bis /
j ; . - :
The taxes and gssessments Appe: ring of record pte
this property are null and void and, in the absence of con-
cressional consent, seid property wilt. remain immune from
. - ~ ‘ .
19 < ee Es
taxation as long as it is ow ae by the U nited States or the
Federal P ubliy- Housing Authority.
il a ; .
aa ,
,
a 2) . Vv I ° Fath k
ed a ,
Dye : e 3
°
The plaintiffs are entitled to a permanent. injunction
directing cancelation of the: taxes and assessments and re-
straining the defendants froin taking any action to collect
or levy taxes agaist this + property in the future.
“> 0] Cae ' Fiorence BE. Aven
ay eats United States Circuit Judge.
| EK. B. Freep,
oO nited States District Judge.
/
ee
&
{
— : crue te ,
aries bees nailed weed eed ee wt
* .
pj & :
0
“(TOa8) + ee oe
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.