Transcript of Record — Mercoid Corp. v. Mid Continent Co.

Supreme Court brief1943

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

— Vol. I

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

Supreme Court of the United States

_f *

OCTOBER TERM. 1945

*

: No. 54 =

PEeEPELON POR CERRO EPOR ARE BEEBE Vine

CER DOOR ART GRANTED GUNES

;

i

5

% ba

Oo. IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

- Ocroper: Term. A. D. FO42.

rare ia, No.

THE MERCOLD CORPORATION,

Petitioner,

rs, :

MID-CONTINENT INVESTMENT COMPANY, «4 Cor-

PORATION, AND MINNIE APOLIS-HONEY WELL REG

at LATOR COMPANY,

Re sponde nis,

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCULT COURT

. OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCULD, »

ae

Index to printed record of proceedings in Us 8.

smatrect Cort .. 2.2 wosvis Pree rts eee eens iy en oe

Clerk's certificate to Volume one of — record of

proceedings in U.S. District Court... 4.2... 0... 432a

Clerk's certificate to Volume two of. oDiated record we:

proceedings in U.S. District ¢ pe RR, Nee I ae YU]

INDEX TO. PROCEEDINGS IN U.S

COURT OF APPEALS:

incite 3). s:.. heat ae eae aay ae ecanta ts 903

Appearance Jor Mid ( ‘ontinent, et al. filed May 14,

RP ers rere grease ear Ha ent eee <0 ae

Appearance for Mereaid, filed May 14, 1942..-.. oe oe

Certifieate to Exhibits, filed May 14, 1942. .0......... . 905

Appearance for Mid-Contihent, filed Oct. 12, 1942..... 907.

~~ Order taking cause under advisement, entered OQet. 21, .

WS 6% a oa cen gh eine Tae Soe SC acga we aca aan ee

Onision hy Sp irks, J:, filed Dec. 23, 1942... . - tas hak

Judgement, No, 8008, entered Dee, 23, 1942. ..0..0..... 923 -

Judement, No, SO09, entered Dee, 23, W422... ? 924

Stipulation. extending time to fle Rehearing, filed Dee, .

oe, Pe es ae es Gana wes ep Ty e eee ee 995

Order extending thme to file Jeohearing. entered Dee.’

an. Wee os. 996

Reference to filing Petition for Re hie PAYING. 2... PoE 926

om + es ee 2 eee ee EOS SB Oe Ao 278s" S. BOS we) oS Oe De

” Reference to filing Answer to Pe ‘tition for Re hearing. 926

desi denving Petition for Rehearing, entered Mar.

Serres yey ee ae ere Rae er ene ee oe ee ‘ _ 997

: Natie © and Motion to'St: iv Mandate, filed Mar. 3: 1942 998

Order stavine Mandate. « ente red mee, 4, TORS. soa 920

Clerk’s Certifieate) 0.0.0.2... pee eat oe ea CERO RE

Orders allowing cettiorari on . 2

VOL. IT pp 433 to 899.0 /

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD 7

ee

Brite b Sit Circuit Court if Anpeals

For the we Circuit

peaeen INVESTMENT COMPANY. 3 ;

; MINNEAPOLIS HONEYWELL REG

LATOR COMPANY. : -

No. 8008:

THE MERCODD CORPORATION. nets

HDCONTINENT INVESTMENT COMPANY, . 4

Ties oe APOLIS HONEYWELL REG.

LATOR-COMPANY,. = >

No 8009

PH ME ROCODDS CORPORATEON

paomcha:. a> pre ee wy /

1) , ay

_ :

iss) i i } i)

z

LNSCHTD'T Mm RECORD FY] }) t

Yin the

, Write Statis Girruit Gourt of Hopeais

as For the Seventh Gireait :

nee es INVESTMENT COMPANY, 4 Con,

poration, -axnp MINNBEAPOL IS- HONEYWEL A, REG.

UL ATOR COMP ANY.

‘No. 8008. | ee

Thi E MERCOID CORPORATION, 2

* Saree s De fi ndant-A pp Hee,

Plaintiff s- prea

MID-CONTINENT. INVESTMENT COMPANY; a Cor

poration, axp MINNEAPOLIS-HONEYWELL REG

ULATOR COMPANY, Ee

Plaintiffs. Appellues,

No. 8009. - | vs.

. THE MERCOID CORPORATION, re

. ae : Defontaot- A ppe lant.

® ®

? ee

‘ ie.

o Ss

Appeal from the District Court of the United States-for. the

Northern District of Ilimois, Eastern Division.

e +S

INDEX

Placita of nes eve ca evac ck Os sures ee € aerate es eos a

Complaint, filed Sept. ig” SEA GLE ne ore ai ee

Defendants’ motion for Bill of Particulars, filed Oct.

Ry Sn tv et es cee Pee ee ee ee ee ben. a

Bill of Particulars, filed Oct. 8, 1940........ BPI SURE

_ Answer, filed Nov. 18, 1940. 02.6... eee eee eee Pree yn

( ‘ounterel: RR tere he eras fre gee eee ee

Motion re additional party- plaintiff, filed Jan. 10; 1941 22

. Memorandum j in Support......... Naha wink aH Se

Onder re certain exhibits, entered Jan. 1), 1941, hicks ee

‘Order re additional party- ‘plaintiff, dntered- Feb. h, 1941 26

Reply of Mid-Contitient to counterclaim, filed Feb. a.

¢.. Gane Pa ye as teuc A ee Sad wee as wp seek i a

Reply of _Minneapolis-Honeywell to ounterelaiin, filed

Feb. 26, 1941...... eye state A el ; eens 32

Interrogatoriés.by Defe ndant, filed. Mar. 7, 1941 oy a ¢ 35

Order .re ‘Amendments, entered Mars, 1941... ees Pay

Reply to Inter rogatotie s, filed Mar. “28, ae yi Wad 40

Ametidment to Answer, filed Apr. 3, 141............. 44.

Reply of Mid-Continent to Amendiie nt, filed Apr. 23, 7 °

RE Cas ee. 5!

Reply of Minneapolis. Honeywell to Amendment, filed |

BOE DR Es so osc te ter os eeniah Braet tet: 60

~ - TRANSCRIPT. OF TESTIMONY.

Colloquy ........ rover eterna 80, 182, 301,: i sl 21

WITNESSES kon Miv-Contixent INVESTMENT (Co,

Testimony of: Ene ;

Ce Re es cs hn cn ven et chs a eats are 114,439,

Crosa, Waller MM. 08. 53..2.2222+006 a air 64, 43.5

Vol. I, pages 1 to 432; Vol. I, pages 433 to 899.

ee /

a, } R , i)

/ ° . . ; /

* : wee : rd

.

ee -

*

il

» Worrsesses For Tue Mereom Corperation,

Testimony of : |

Ceibel Meee oo foo ee es

(iwens, James Woo... nah cra oke ed Pore 7

Schultz, Albert N.o........... pie dees Pere? t-

Wrrsess ror Minxearouis-Honrywein Reeeriaror Co

¢ a

Testimony of:

Mwent, FRAPON Woes ss is wns cass .

2

PrainTiFe’s Exnunits. ‘

Intro-

.

_ 424

duced in Repro-

evidence ay

at page at

No. 1--Findings ef Fact, ete, in Court of Ap-

peals for Sth Cireuit in) Smith suit... ... a4

No. 2? ~Decree in Court of Appeafs for Sth

“Cirevit in Smith suits. Het ews Berra rie

No. 3 Mandate of Court of Appeals for Sth

Cireuit in Syath suit..... Se ean i+

Now4—Pave 12 0f Mereoid Catalog 106, dated

Wai Me ee PR er

Noo A Assignment of patent in suit) from

(‘ross O Matie Co. to Plaintitf. A ke eee 6

No. 6 License agreement between Cross-O

red

pare

Matie Co. et al. and Minneanolis- Honeywell a

No. 7 License agreement dated Dee. 31, 1938, —

between Plaintiff and) Minneapolis-Honey- |

WN. Wao es hae ea ee Cael cr, 73

No. $--Cross patent No. 1,758,146... gp)... 65

No. 10 Bulletin: No, 214-4 Mereoid Corpo-

ration Aes ee Sree Oe cea. ae

No. 11—Page 24 of Catalog No, 100, dated

Keb. 1, 1956, Mereoid Corporation. . Paes ss"

Vol. I, pages 1 to 432; Vol. IT, pages 433 to 899. -~ A ini iinet vines et

et

iit

Intro-

duced in

evidence

: ; “ at page

No. 12—Bulletin No, 240 —~Mercoutl Corpora:

SO cae heh ee care kee ak keke ie

No. 14—Advertisement of Mereoid Corpora-

tion in **Coal Heat Mawazine,’* Nov., 1935

‘NO. 15—Form P-90, installation. instructions

of Mercoid, Sept, eae... Sack coe Pees

No | 16—Front pase of*bulletin by Mereoid on

Me reoid Stokatherm type IMV.....0.....

No. 17—Cireular letter daied Aug. 7, 1936, on

_ stationery of Mercoid..... oun way «kee Rees

No. IS—Report by Anthracite Institute Lab-

oratory, No, 2192, on eh Stokatherm,

See Tee Pelee re ry

No, 19 Bulletin No, 242, of Mercoid Stoka-

therm, ty pe JIMV, dated June, 1986. .......

No, 20-—General - Applications *and Wiring

ogee OT FON hc ie exes ae

No. 21—Bulletin covering Mercoid controls,

_— steker, Form A-380..... Shiatateen aes

No. 22 Advertising Circuit of Me reid, VS Ber

No, 28—Form letter, dated Jan. 22, » 1924/ en-

titled **Mereoid) Controls— Manufacturers’

ee eee Perey keer eee ee

* No, 24-Bulleti:nt No. A-51, dated Jan. 15, 19,

entitled ‘Manufacturers. Prices’). 0.0.25...

Noo 25—Clippings frotg American Artisan

and Heating, Piping and Air Conditioning,

We SOs kkecs the wand we pape es nar

No. 26-—-Four clippings, from, Sheet Metal

Worker, Nov., 1829, Sanitary Heating Age,

Aug., 1929, Fuel Oi) Jaurnal, Apr. 2928,

; — Air Heating, Dec. 1929.0 ..65.0.... @°

No. 2 —Copy of Transeript in Missouri Suit

Vol. I, pages 1 to 432; Vol. Ir, pages 433 to B29.

7

OD

Repro-

ducad

at page

472

492

493 -

\

re

4

iv ; a

Intro-

duced in

| - ‘cisacs

No. 29—Page 7 from Mercoid Bulletin Al

Rb ee SR I so Sip cao nccees st)

No. 30—Pave 38 from it ceuk ‘ ‘atalog No.

GRO, Feb, 100... cc5 conn es kes s0

No. 31—Letter,. —_ 15, 1940, Spencer to

— PS Gere Sateee Gig ee In Se eee ee Pe 416

No, 32---Letter, July 16, 1940, “Moore to Spen-

Se ee re alte eee eee 416

No. 33—Letter, eluly 14, a Spencer te

Ee. chee sae RP phe Nps Ae epg o.. 416

No. 34 ie etter . July 1S, 1040, Moore to Spen-

eT .. weet ee ee ee ee ee ee ee 416

No, 30- Lotter: July 24, 1940, Moore to Spen-

Ee ge a See Spee ey POP Eg ee ar

No. 37 —_Wi iring - diagram and infringing in

stallation SRA REN Se a PE ey a ee he pm 67

No. 38—Reproduction of Diagram 1 of: Ex-.

| §: Serer a Ln ehiek eens ux Prec 121

No. 39--Sketeh ofsway V2-3A relay would be

connected in wiring system shown in Exhibit

rere re eer ee re yee re Tee Pee kwns ee

No. 40—-Enlarged replica of solid line -por-

tions of diagram 1 of Exhibit 12 iad SR 721.

No. 41— Reproduction of diagram 9 on page 6

of = — BG eek CAR CARER W AANA ERE ES 128

No. 42—Mercoid Stok: stheres Type, TVS. xt)

No. ve M-11 Pyratherm made by Me reoid : sO

No. = Type JIMV Stokatherm. 0. ..00..5... - 80

No. -Diagranr at lower le ft Wand corner of

= ' page of Exhibit 19.0... Bocce 137

. 46--Drawings of sv mm His submitted to

pote ats Br RE OE rey ee rayne S 145

"Wo. I, pages 1 to 433; Vol! 1, pages 433 to 899. 7

* duced

Repro-

at page

494

425

47

499

501

502

O08

.

Py Mth

oa

Intro- .

duced in Repro-

evidence dveed

atpage at page

No. 47—( ‘ertified Copy Assignment of Errors |

—8th ¢ SNE HIN oc ts Gov ws NS 145

No. 48—P age]: D of Mercoid | Catalog No. 11

Feh. 1, 1936, showing Stokatherm TJV.... 134- . 506,

No. 49—Control M-61, nianufactured by Mer |

WOR <a <ks dwers SSS, Aah g EER ne See ea 303.

No. 50—Sleeve of IMV Stokatherm TEP Se ois See

‘Dere NDANT.’s Exuinits.

eer Bulletin E-1, Mar. 1925: .... .. 196 * 50S

‘B—MeCabe Patent No. 1,734,016..... 00.0... 196 788°

( “—Federah ~Mercoid: Controls, Bulletin D. re

ee” ERROR re heh reer ee 98° 512

by ‘1—Mercoid Bulletin © -1, April, 1923 awwet 19s O16

D—Me reoid No. S48 ¢ ‘ontrol, Industrial tyme. 200 18

E—Pages from Mereoid Catalog H-5, dated :

ep ira re lee ere ae ee ee 521

E1l—Merteoid: M: ee I a se 55h 0 6 heen oo 303 7

F —Mere ‘oid Warm Air F urnace ( ‘ontrol Bulle- .

| eee Ee ee cue ee 201. 595.

. G—-MeUabe Patent No. 15834,288...... 0... . 806

Gi- Funes aes **Mercoid System of Direct.

|” gill TERE ROS Re eri BE Ad Py oe en re |

- H—Pages. from: Me reoid Catalog Now, He,

ot PET ROTC e EPEC eed ee eee ae 532

; Hi- -MeCabe Patent No. 1, ae ee. o TOS

-H2—Mercoid Pyratherm M1...2.........- ., BOR, *

11—Pages from Honeywell Specialties and

~ The Honeywell System of. Hot Water Heat-

ie: Gen RRP EET TS aR ae 215 4

ties iter Pa ere Ma eee s cree epee nee : on Ser

I3—Pages from ‘* Heart of the Heating Plint™’ 216 | dav -

Vol. I, pages 1 to 432; Vol. II, pages 433 to 899.

vi

: Intro- —

duced in

evidence

. at page

- 14-*Pares of * Automatic-Controls** of Time-

EE oc he ey «is eds Rete eee 218

‘JI—Pages from Minneapolis-Honeywell Regn-

a SO en eae 219

Repro-

duced

at page

208

nD9

KK Article Matomatie Controls for Stekers—_—————-:

and Foreéd Draft.’ from Bulletin A-14 of”

Mercoid Corp.) oo... .. Sap ee eae SAPS ES

K1—Copy cof Mereoid ‘Bulletin 230, dated

March, 1933 ....: "AAS rane eas ee

~K2—-Mereoid Control M55........ Pee os wae

I.— Bulletin No. 240 of Mercoid Corp. dated

” March, 1933 .....:..... Sa Le » 228

M—Bulletin No. 240-Bof Mercoid Corp., dated

June, 1935 0... onpeso es rs ae, ele dane 229

N—Mereoid Installation Instructions Forn

Pee, Oet., 1956: ...:... et ee Se ae ee 230)

O—Bulletin No. 241 —* Mereoid Stokatherm

Control System ’!--Oetober, 1985.......... 241

P—Mercoid Installation Instructions Form

P00, Sept., 1937... 52... Pee Pe mate.

Q Pages Prom Catalog No. 400), effective Reb.

2088 oo ck:

R-~Pagves from Detroit Lubricator Co., Bulle-

ie tee, ee, Met, 0, 1998... cee ce 246

S—Pages from Detroit Lubricator Co., Sheet

No. 101-L; Sept. 15,1987 0.....: Tae 24s

T—Pages from Catalog and Price List) of

Minneapolis Honeywell Regulator Co., dated

{ Mar, 30, 1993..:.....

U Pages from: Minneapotis Honeywell Cata-

| Rea a Ce ee ae re . eames YOu)

V—Penn Electric Switch Bulletin No. o6, Pure

2 PRA SS es omer ee Rem ae oe eke 21

- Wol. I, pages 1 to 432; Vol. II, pages 433 to 899.

- a *

.

) : i

i |

4 : vil :

% Intro-

ducedin Kepro-

5 GS oe .

3 pees a in og Sa . Jos

:. » Pateitt No, 1,882,341... .:......:. 260 S14

: W 1 Sines Patent No. 1969136. .00.... whet 260 820

4 _X—Letter, July 2, 1% 30, ‘Browne i” Co. to Mer oe

4 EE Pare eee Weer Ime as wh ne a 316 - 601 =

i ; Copy letter, July 7, = Mere oid to

: “ Brownell Co. .......:-. Se leper ye 316 602

: ee ' Letter, Aug. 13, 19380, Brownell Co, to Mar-

; a. Preven ret as ee S16 2 608

4 {opy letter, Aug. 14, 1930, Mereoid to :

kt eee eee rate re “316° «604

i Letter, Sept. 5, L930, Browne 7 to Me sreord 316 G05"

Copy letter, Bent. 9.1930, Mereoid to. it ok

Brownell .......:..: Pe Poth

“Y—-Letter, June 18, 1929, American Radiator

3 Co.to Me reoid. . er ry ae Cae Eee re 31s 607

: Copy letter, June 92... 1929, Me reold te.

: Cross Coal-O-Matie’ .....5.5...0065) 318.608

4A Shipping slip of Mercoid dated June. 24, ae

: WON 2 nea eee 318. G09"

§ Z—Letter, June 11, 1929, Cross to Mercoid, °

; _ written on advertising folder, .... nee. 610

‘ Copy letter, June 13, 1929, Mereord to

: Gieen 2 is cores We heer are 321. 614

Letter, Oct, 2251929, Cross to Mere oid... 321 -°, Ald

Mercoid-shipping order No, 101892. . 0... 321 616

Letter, Nov, 26, 1929, Cross to Mereoid. 2.2. 82105 GOLF

; Letter, Feb 11, 1930, 4 ‘ross to Mereoid.... 321 61s

= Letter, Aug. 14, 1930/ Cross to Mercoid. ..2. 32 619

= Letter, Aug:)20, 1934, Cross to Mercoid. . 321- - , 620

Copy letter, ‘Aug. - 28, 130, Mercoid

; tb , gaverey Me ree et et te este B21 G21

; Mercoid shipping slip, Aug. 30, 1930. sy - 22

; Volt, pager 2 1 to 432; Vol. II, pages 433 to 899. . pasar

y viii Oy oe

haven ts Repro-

° evidence duced

a ’ : » .atpage at page

Letter, Aug. 22, 1930, Cross to Mereoid.. 2. 321 623

Letter, Sept. 2, 1930, Cross to. Mereoid. 2.2 821° 624

Letter, Nov. 11, A950, Cross to Me reoid 321. 625

71+ Mercoid Bulle ‘tin, Moa, entitled — Bulletin ; r

Mt er ceca, rey ok eae 3821 626

A A—Letier, Sept. 7,. “19: 3, F rederick Tron &

Steel'to Mereoid......... icshw eal aide soe - 630

(opy letter, Sept. 12, 133, Mercoid to ° 3

Frederick Iron & Steet...:.......... Ree 631 -

BB Copy letter, Nov. 2S, L980, Luthe’ to c 7 :

Sweatt o0 20... tip era wie Wee own ee Nice te d26 | , 652

Copy letter, July 3, 1951, Van Ness to :

Sweatt) .. 0.0... Pe ee ere "B87 633

Letter, July 6, Lal Sweatt fo Van aa 327. G34

ps Letter, Nov. YS. 19382, Sweatt to Meredid 327 . 6385 :

. Letter, Sept. 80, 1981, Luthe to Van Ness $27 637 +

EE—Letter, Sept. 25, 1931, Van Ness to Luthie 8340-639

FF Memorandum jon Calendar Pad of ‘Mon- —_

der Dine: FA ee -.. ooo )6=— (Cd S/O ee

GG ‘Letter, Fe be He 132, Brownell Co. to cay t

Mereoid. ... Se Ge Pte rene 3400 «64 i

Letter, Mar. 3, IU, Brownell Co. to , 3 :

~ Mereoid, copy attached... 05.60.72... S40 O42

Copy: letter, Mar. 15, 1932, Mereoid cto’ |

RO TE oi oc eee ee eee . 340 te ies

Letter, Oet. 7, 19382, Brownell Co, to >

‘: a Mercoid, copy attac ‘hed. , oF Brcr ohace aur: teks ee ca) a t> lw

7 I wetter, Se pt. PR 1932, Maid ontinent tw

Brownell 6. cee accep tsa ieeasci es 340) 647

‘HH hetter . Feb-- DO, 1932, Will Burt Co. to Fy

Mercoid, with copy of Minneapotie-Hesex ee. 7

well lefter of Feh, 95, 1082, attache Scns ee

WHI Copy letter, Juné 4, 5931, Mereoid to.

Will-Burt Cd. .:..... pie ee ees Cnn Sa errs

Vol. I, pages 1 to 482; Vol. 11, pages 433 to 899. a

——

ix

"Vol. 1, pages 1 to 432; Vol. IT, pages 433 to 699.

Pann st ' Rep ‘O-.

evidence duced

; 7 ~. si : atpage - at page.

I]—A‘opy detter, Combustioneer letter dated

Jame 14, 1935. to BROROON. . 56 coe cs ck ces 342 602

I1—Guarantee against iifringement suits... 377 604

JJ—Letfer, Oct. 7, 1982, Bardes to Mereoid. 343 655

KK—Letter, Oct. 12, 1933, Paragon Kol: Mas

SEIN 5. 5 bo.cnr ab Ne eae 344 656

nm LL—Letter, Nov. 21, 1932, Mid ‘ontinent to

Meron 2 .s..... . Se en eee Few NaONE aay 345 657

MM—-Letter, June 5, 1934, Fairbanks Morse

to Mereoid, fetter, Piles a 134, Mid-Conti

— hent te Fairbanks. Morse attache * Re Pee 346 658

XN... Letter, Dec. 1s,. L034... grrots Dt Uo. to |

Mereoid, copy lette r, Dee, 21, 1934, Me re oid INIT te eons

thy Brownell attached ..:. a TS ON BERR Se a 5347 660

(4 h_-Sales Chart- Stokers and Controls. -Re-

ports of Department of Commerce, Bureau

- of The € CHSUS, for the Years 1932 1933 ,

1935 to 140, Ine., and affidavit of Me veld? & ;

Sales ‘during years 1931 to 1940, inclusive... 358 662

“PP—Letter, Sept. 16,1985, » Minneapolis- |

Honeywell to Mere oid, eo ee eee OST OS4 -

Letter, Sept. 17, 1935, Mid-Continent: to

Mere6id Dare hones Sess Foe Pee 387 685

Leiter, Nov. 6, 1935, Minneapolis-Honey-

well to Merecoid, ae ‘ shoe ees aise se 387 | O86

Letter, Dee. 12, 1985, Minneapolis- /

. Honeywell to Mercoid.::............. 387 OST

()-- License agreement proposed by Minneap-

olis-Honevwell to Mereoid in 1935...... _.. B87 — . 689

RR—Letter, Nov. 24, 1939, Mid, ‘Continent ie |

Sse SE ea P rah Sees ene 400, 703

Letter, Feb. 5, 1940, Mid- ‘ontinent to — |

I 65 oc bd He RSA wen ces eo 400 704

Intro-.

s ; duced in Repro-

5 evidence duced

! at page at page

Copy. letter, August 1, 1940, Mercoid to

VV—Sub-hicense agreement of July 9.1933,

between Mintieapolis- Honeywell and Detroit

PRG ree hay are ine e'e 6% 0 Aye ha Pe 400 T07

_ Letter, Aug. i, 1940, Spencer to Mereoid 40 soa 709

Letter, Aug. 27, 140, Spencer to Mereoid 400 i] &

’ Copy letter, Sept. 4, 1940, Me reoid to. |

Spencer i oe igo ee 400) 412

SS— Agreement propose “ad by Mid-Continent to |

Mercoid ae ee ewe Rha sew Eee KL es Ah oes .. $02 : 713

“TT. —hetter, Dee. 2, 1935, Sweatt to M@re.... 4050. 717.

UU Shiple¥ Patent No.2,063,898. 000000000. 405 826.

J Shipley Patent No. 17514... 0.0... 405890

Burton Patent No. 2,064, >) ass So SOS

Benjamin Patent No. 2 109, ie \. - $05 "+ 864

Brownell Patent No. 2,064,193. 0 0000.0.. 405 SOS

. . . oe : _s

i RE RE LS PORE TO CEE RE 406 ‘19 |

WW Agee nent as furnis shed by “Minneap-

olis: Honeywell inits pleadings. . 0.0.20... . 406 ~ 731

ae -Breakdown of Exhibit OO... 0.0.0.0... 42:

Mis NEAPOLIS- Hoxrywer 1. -Exrustt.:

No. 1-Form letter, - Mercoid t‘orporation,

al ited Feb. 26, 1930. a Sr et bite enoeee ... 426 507

Patines ot I net, ete. . filed Jan. ‘6, i + Se nee Ce . 236

Conclusions of Law. ......,... 00. PPE amt PoeeeS 742.

Decree, entered Jan. 26, 1942. 033." aie ohne! Ackee agate 744

Withdrawal of Appearance, filed Feb. 14, 1942....... 740

Additional appearance, filed Feb. 14, 1942. .0.000..... 746

Order staving injunetion, entered Mar. .17, 1942..... 6747

Plaintitf*s Notice of Appeal, filed Apr. 25, 1942..:°..,. 748

Statement of Points of Mid-Continent Investment Co. 750

Vol. I, pages 1 to 432; Vol. TI, pages 433 to 899. .

Re rete tal ee Ce

Yael

xl

Statement at Points of Minneapolis. Honeywell Regu-

lator Ae GREG sities iia i eae Ra a Raa aS 754 -

Clerk's ¢ ‘ertificate of: Mailing Notice of Appeal... BP bie :

Appeal Bond ....... ne ah mR rer A ae 7) lees

Defendant's Notice of Appeal, filed Apr, 2, sie alee 79

statement of -Poimts.....:...°.> 73 eres rere ee ees eee

Clerk's ¢ ‘ertificate of Mailing Notice of Appe oy _ 161

Appeal Bond ................. Saag aah Sins Cee wie ee

Plaintiff's designation of record. .......00...... ae ak 764

Defendant’s designation of reeord..............:... 773

Order and stipulation to amend designation... ...... Vio

U NITED STATES LETTERS P ATENT.

No. 17 ie as, 146—W. = & ross, May 13, 1930 oo eee -. 778

No. -1,734,016—I[. Is. MeCabe, Oet. 29, 1929... ; ms te pee THK

No. :1,762,183—I. KE Me ‘abe, June 10, 19: A < 798

No. 1,834,288 BE. MeCabe, at a: Day seer 806

No. 1,882,941—R,-W. Stein, Oet. 11, 1982.0... .. fv... SIF

No. 1,969,136—D. J. Jones; Aug. 7, 1934...... ees 820

No. 2,065, 898—S. i, Shipley, OSS be | 826

No. 2,064,193—J. R- Brownell. et . tp CRA ree .. 838

No, 2,064,194——W. D. Burton, Dee. 1936. See Dun AEN SOS

No. 2,109,939—M. G. Benjamin, Mar 1. . , Benareaame 864

No. 2,117,514—S. C. Bai y; May lt, I! D388. Spree i 390

OE EG Une ae .. 899

\

an oe ——

Vol. I, pages 1 to 433; Vol. 11, | pages 433 to 899.

Dy

.

Testimony vf Walter M. Cross, Jr. 433

820 WALTER M. CROSS, JR.) a-witness on behalf. of

plaintiff Mid-Continent Investment Company, hav-—

ing been previously duly sworn, was ‘recalled’ and

testified in: rebuttal as-follows:

Direct E tamination by Mr. Stone,.

a Mr. Cross, ‘toward the end of ‘what year did the

mandate from the Cireuit Court of Appeals from = the.

Eighth District come.down to the District Court?

A. 1939..

Q. After that occ curred, or after vou did tthe decision

from the Cireuit Court of Appeals, vou wroteva. letter

‘which I believe is in evidence here to The Mereoid Cor-

poration, is that right? .

A. That ts correct. \-

-Q. What were vou attempting to do by Virtue of that «

_ jetter, Mer. Cross, and what ‘ranspired in the following

months?

A. We felt we had validated the patent. Since Mer-

eoid had: been involved in the case they would now admit

the validity of the patent and he willing to make an-

R21 accounting for rovalties on controls which had beet

* “sold for use in the system prior to that time.

Q. Was it vour understanding if the Cross patent was

valid that one-who made controls and prepared diagrams.

and literature showing exactly how those controls could

be uséd-in the infringing installation would be a contribu-

tory infringer? -

A. Yes, it was. There wor not be diuch ghoice: You

could not sue everybody that put in a: stoker-controk

Q. It was your undefstanding they had made it) pos-

sible for the’ public, thé electricians and what not, to effect .

these actual direct infringements ? | bee wg

S\. That is right. : :

_.,..@: You were attempting to obt: iin. an aecounting froin -

- The Mereoid €C orporation onthe controls Which they had

-actually made, is that reht? —

A. That is right. :

(),» In the course of his examination, Mr. ( outs O) made

two statements, one being on page 730 and reading as

. fellows: ‘tit (meaning a license)-was being pressed at

them (that is Mid-Continent) by their licensor, (that shonld

be licensee, meaning. the Minneapolis-Honeywell Com-

-

434 ieee. Transeript of roses

pany) to, get The Mercoid Corporation lined up, that they .

had no choice. in the matter: other than force us; to’

822 take a lie ense.’

And on page 738° Mr. Courteol-made this statement: es

“T made the statement Mr. Cross said he was being |

pressed by his licensor to conclude the agreement witgi

The Mercoid Corporation.”

What. is your understanding about that situation?

A. Just this. Our interest was to collect damages and

either have Mercoid acknowledge the patent and take the | :

license or agree not to make the control any more. They

claimed they were not making the control any more at that.

time, so the proposition evolved around the fact we wanted

them to pay us for what damages had aceraed and whfch

we felt were due ys under the judgment of the court in

Missouri.

(). Did vou institute this proceeding, yourself. or with

the Minneapolis-Honey ‘ywell Regulator Company? . 7.

A. We did it. We acted entirely independent. Minne-

apolis had nothing to do with our ‘action.

‘(). -In the license agreement ex xisting between vou and

‘ Minneapolis-Honevwell what provision is made for- the

disposition of any damages awarded in ‘a lawsuit to’ the

plaintiff?

A. AslI yomenuber, the agreemerit -provides-if Mid-

42 Continent prosecuted an infringement. ease. and is

‘suecessfulit shall retain any damages collected. Like-

wise, if Minneapolis- Honeywell! were to share in the ex- .

pense of prosecuting the litigation then they would receive

an equal sha.e with Mid-Continent of the damages.

Q. Who did pay the ¢ost making up the legal: fees at-

tendant upon prosee utifg the ease down -in Missouri?

A. The’ Mid-Continent Company.

(). And so-who was entitled to any damages that miyht

be obtained from. The Mereeid ¢ ‘orporation?

A. Mid-Continent only. :

Q. You started negotiating directly with Mereoid be-

cause vou alone were entitled. to the damages, ‘is that

correct! pe. Dag te Res 3

‘That is correct. — -

3 Now, Mr. Cress, tell us how blinneapole: Honey well

*. got into this at all,—got into the .1940 negotiations?

A. Well, some time, I believe about six months after

T had a conference with .Mercoid we placed the matter,

in the hands | of our attorney, ‘Mr. Spencer in Chicago,

~

o

:

Py ‘ \

-. ‘ g ale \

: : ' pa

Testimony of Walter M. Cross, Jr. . 435

and after talking to Mr. Moore he felt he could work out

some agreement W hereby it would be unnecessary to sue

Mercoid in Chieago for an accounting. In the course of

_ that it was suggested that a license agreement pro-

S24 posal should be worked out: We informed Mr. Spen-

cer that Minneapolis-Honeywell only had the right to

sublicense. urider that patent. Later we were asked by

Mr. Spencer if we could make a diréet agreement with

Mereoid. At that, time we. asked Minneapolis- Honeywell

if. it would ‘make some arrangement -whereby we could

make a direct agreement and they agreed to do so pro-

vided that Ave modify-the agreement. of 1938 between Mid-

Continent/and Minneapolis-Honeywell allowing us to. make

this one single direct license to Mereoid.’

Q./ ‘Do I understand you-to say Minneapolis. Honeywell .

‘vot into these negotiations only because of some proposal

relating to licensing Mereoid to produce controls for’ its:

partic ‘ular purpose in the future? ; :

‘A.* That is edrrect. | s |

Q. If that had never come vp vou, the Mid-Continent

_Corporation, would sitfiply have conducted these negotia-

tions for the purpose of obtaining an accounting on all | .

controls, made by Mereoid ‘for these -infringer installa. .

tions? . f

A. Yes; providing there was no question of thelr mann-

facturing controls any further.

Q. Did they tell you the had stopped making infring-

ing controls? ,

825 <A. Yes; they told me they were not making those

controls any more.

Q. THey-referred specifically to wil: control?

‘A. I think it was the M-61. T think I am sure.

.Q. The evidence-has been, brought out by Mr. Owens

and by. Mr. Schultz that the M.- 61 was discontinued in -

1938, is that. right? at

A. Yes, sir.

. Was anything said about the TAV, the M. 11 system |

-orthe JIMV? |

A. Not that I recall.

Q. Did they mention that?

A. No, they did not.

Q. So you had no means of knowing whether or not

they were - +ttH putting out a system>whigh infringed the

Cross patent? mt

6

—>

ow

:.

,

436° Transcript: of Testimony.

A. No: V didn't exaniine their books. # aia know

anv, of the details as to their business. Cet

Qe When that firure of four er five th usand, what-

© @ver it is, was determined upon in that Heense agreement

which Was submitted by our office to the defendant in July

or Ame@ust, 1840, was there a basis in fact for vour arriv-

ine at that fieure?

AL Yes, sir, there was. : '

S25 Qo Tt was not just a figure out here in vacuo, ‘and

which vou might have made $20,000 if yon had been

-so inchned?

“A\ No. : , .

Qo What was the basis? See oa

AS “The basis was it approximated our east coutlay in

— iting the patent. ae .

Pid. Mereoid tell vou how many controls they bad

ae out? :

AL Yes, they made e stimates.

Do veu recall an estimate?

A. Well, T think there Was an- estimate based on: pos-

sibly in the ne ighbarhood of 7,000 controls, ef which some

had been sold in foreign countries and therefore, would.

net come under the license agreement, and we finally’

agreed) on en approximate munber for the -saxe of dis:

enussion of a settlenient. T belbeve that nunibe ‘r Was around

four or five thousand controls. <

Q. You are asking abot one dollar for ‘each installa-

tion and vou knew these controls we re“specifieally desigtied

for that purpose and actually did vo into-the installation?

A. The specitie ont ‘dollar, rovalty did) not come. into

the: disenssien but that was the approximate set-up.

PD Sng

*g27. Q.° So that the re lationship between Mid-Continent

and Minnenpolis- Honeywell from late In 1939 to the

institution af thisssuit was really a rekitionship i in: whieh

vonawere asking them:to-do sémething in violation of ‘vour,

own dicense agreement. is that correct? : ‘

A. That is correct. avs

() Did von suéeeed in obtaining the consent.of. the

Minneapolis Honeswell € ompany tO modify. the 1958

Jicense agreement betwoen Mid-Confinent and Minneapolis

Honevwell Company, P laintitt” s EB vhibit i ame ‘

A. Yes, we did... |

Q).° And it was alivakeds vou w would grant-The Mei re oid

Corporation a direct liee nse?

A. ae is correct,

» Testimony ot Walter M. Cross, dr. - 437

@. Was that in coutravention tg the policy of Mid-

Continent-in the previots ten years .

A. Yes, sir, it was.- There had Qever been ANY -«excep-

tion asked to the agreement at all befre.

- ). What Minneapolis- Honeywell (Company really dil

Was to accommodate thé Mid-Continent Investrient: Corn-

pany because of a Very recalcitrant defendant, is, that cor

rect? ? eZ :

A. That is correct. > oie to

Q. Mr. Cross, T call your attention to these two let,

ters which were sent out By Mid-Continent Investment

G28 Compafiy, one was to Fairbanks Morse Company and -

‘ one Was to the Brownell Company, and will ask ‘vou

to state what the policy of Mid- ‘ontinent Was in sending

out notices relating to authority. of the Cross pateat? =I

am not geing to ask you any specific questions. [+ just call

vour attention to those letters. What was your policy?

A. Our poliey, as far as it laid within our power, Was

to notify the trade or the art that we did ‘have such a

patent and we considered the operation wherein controls

were used to nlaintai. fire responsive to temperature, cen-

ditions in combination: with a heating s¥atenr-to heat a

house would infringe the Cross patent. | es

Q. What did you consider about mannufaeturers of con-

‘trols which were specifically designed and sold with fitera-.

ture showing the purchaser how ta use them to set up the

installation? Did vou consider them-to infringe the Cross,

patent? pe ie oe

~ AL. Wesalways considered them .as contributory in

fringers. They were the ‘ones that made: it) possible: to

infringe the. patent if it were held valid by the ultimate

nser and there was very little choice. We had the control

thanntacturers and thie’ stoker manufacturers as the only

two groups af people where vou could reasonably enforce

the patent. .

g20 + Q. Now, Mr. Cross, would a controls manufacturer:

or any other manufacturer of sp cifie equipment put |

into an infringing installation réseut receiving notice Gf a

patentaarning or be pleased to-receive it? 4 fs

_X, 1 should think he would be pleased to be put on

notice there was such a patent’ situation. se

Q. Mr, Cross, did you hear Mr. Owens make the follow

ine statement at the end of dis cross examination by me?

1 am reading from pages 6494nd 650 of the record:

~©Q. So that one ean conclude that at least/a Year or. two

.

438 . iota of Testimony.

years after a eosnvel has left your plant it has been used

some. place fer the purpose for which it was intended, is:

that correct? :

‘A. That is correct.”

A. Yes, I heard him ‘say thaf.

‘Q.° Now, is that generally the fact in- the controls in-

- dustry:so far as vou know?

~ AL Yes, I think it is.

(). Is that the reason why the stoker stack control was

used as the measure for determining the number of in-

stallations in the field?

A. Yes. ,

(). Mirmeapolis-Honeywell apparently: felt it was rea-

sonable to Goncludaa xwitch designed for this purpose

830 and sold with Wiring diagrams showing. how to use

them ‘for this: purpose would get: into. an installation

- of the type intended?

A. Yes; that was the basis for the definition in our-

original agreement with. them. ,

Q. — And that. basis for the definition has never changed?

A ee

). Mid-Continent has never received any income from

any source other than roy alty, is that right?

A. As'to the patent? ° ,

Q. As to this.patent, T mean?

'. A: Yes, that is’@orrect.

Q. This Cross patent in issue?

A. Yes.

"Q. What-is the life of a-stoker stack switch with re-

spect to -the other elements of the combination -in the

Cross, patent? ;

A. : think they are about the same.

Q. Can the stoker switch be considered as a supply

in any ‘way?

Al Yes mean something that would have to be bought

>

frequently ? °

_ Q. Like coal— , :

. A. No. f : »

S31. @. (Continuing.) - —for the furnace?

A. No, under no circumstances.

@. So far as the public is concerned, since 1930, the

date of the Cross patent, what position have the owners

of the Cross patent taken?

A. We hav e made strenuous efforts to work the patent,

/ te

es i 2 . : rs .

re stimony of Junitis FP. Cook, Jr: | ~ 489

as the expression is, wad to ulevelop its validity since that

time.

Q.

A.

When did you first bring suit on the patent?

We brought suit against the Schermes installation

in Kansas City in 1934, “IL believe it was—no, about 1932,

‘and I believe that was’settied in 1934.

‘When did you bring suit against Smith?

1935.

And you brought the present snit, in 19401

. That is correct.

The suit against Smith terminated in 19: 39?

1939. °

. - SO continuously since the time of this patent you

have asserted its validity wherever vou could-nssert it? —

A.

Yes, we have. We have done it in our district

wherever we could do so.

Mr.

Stone: [offer in ev idence as PL AINT IF RUS EX-

HiBIT NO. 49 the M‘61 control which had its seria]

“S32 number read by Mr. Schultz. -

)

dence,

Mr. Moore: That has been already offered in evi-.

1 believe. ; ‘

_ Mr. Ste: I thought not. . 7

As PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 50 Mid-Continent offers

an open ended sleeve with a flange mounting which accom-

panies a JMV Stokatherm manufactured by the defendant.

(The exhibit was so marked.)

Mr.

Mr.

oe

: So >

before?

Mr.

Stone: That is all for this Witness. ‘

Moore: No cross examination, your Honor.

(Witness excused.)

Mr. Stone: Mr. Cook, will vou take tlie stand?

The Court: This is the same Mr. Cook who testified

Stone; << ie: eee

JUNTIUSE. ( ‘O0K, JR. a witness on behalf of the plaintiff

Mid. Continent Investment Company, having been pre-

viously duly sworn, was recalled and testified j in reputtal

as follows: .

Q.

Direct Frammation hy Mr. Stone,

Mr. ¢ ‘aok; did vou hear Mr. Schultz’s comme nts on

the Wiring diagram show nin Plaintiffs’ Exhibit’ No. 392

A.

I did.» “ : ”

,

440) ai Transcript.of Testimony, . >

(). Would vou comment as to the pertiency in so far as

infringement is concerned of the Cross patent in those.

comments 2. .

"A. Mr. Schultz pointed out that Exhibit 30 shows the

high temperature cut out or protection switch connected

into the grounded side of the line and said this would not

be reco mmiie ndgad hiv the Me reoid © ompany, who would ree-

ommend the connection of that switch in. the hot line, but

so far as any pertineney to the patent in. suit is concerned

there is one.

S34. | would say it is i rhaps preferable to connect it

on the high side ofthe line, but whether on the high or

low sid® makes no difference whatever to the ope ration

of the rest of the apparatus.

The other remark was to the. effect Mereoid ~would not

recommend dhe connection of the M61 hold fire switeh in:

the secondary cirenit of the V2-3A relay. However, I have

serutinized the literature of Mercoie and T find no place

where Sielra connection is not recommended, nor do T find

Sany literatura showing M-61 used with the V2-3A relay: in

“whieh the connection is recommended in the primary ecir-

cuit, that.is, in the cireuit of the staker motor. I do find,

however, that’ wherever hold fire switches are shown as in

coimection with the JMV relay or the TJV relay the hold

fire swite ‘his always re ommended before connection or -it —

is actually connected: in parallel ‘With the room.thermostat

connection of the. second: irv circuit of the relay. .

(). Refer reins to Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 37, will you’

point out to the Court the elements contained in the Cross

‘patented system?

Mr. Moore: I thought" this Witness had already pointed

that out.

The Court: T theught’so.

ae) Mr. Stone: -T Want to direct the attention of this,

Witness: to one point.

The Court: © Let’s get to that point, then.

Mr. Stone: All right. | ne

-Q). Of the elements shown in Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 37

are there paterits on any one of them? 0k

- L understand that the M-61-

es Court: [ van't hear you.

PT understand the M-61 deviee is made under a sep

ar wn “pate nf and that the M535 also 1S,

Mr. Stone: Q. 51°.

.

®

-

= : : i

Testimony of %untus F. Cook, Ire 4410

_ A. 51 is also patented. \No doubt there are patents

under which rooni thermostats are made and possibly also

there-may be patent on the relay. :

The Court: Q. Is there a patent on the stoker, too?

A. Depending on the stoker that you might use. The

stoker itself might be individually patented. In fact, all

of the individual elements might be individually patented.

Mr. Store: Q. Was Judge Reeves ttfected by the fact

there were patents on. the systems in deciding whether or

not the systems infringed on the patent?

The Court: What is the question? =

. * (Question ‘read as .above recorded. ) ;

836 Mr. Moore: -I object. How can this witness tel)

~ what was in Judge Reeves’ mind when he wrote his

decision? The decision is a matter of record.

The Court: 7 will sustain the objeetion. - :

Mr. Stones QQ. Did you liear Mr. Schultz. give his tes-

thnony concerning his opinion as to. the construction. and

operation of tlie Mereoid TJV and .JMV types ‘of control?

A. I did. ae | oy oA

Q. You remember he-disagreed with vou, didn’t he?

A. I do. : : .

(). What was the nature of his.disagreement?

A. Apparently Mr. Schultz and I are in substantial

agreement In every respeet except the matter of interpre-

tation of the words ‘predetermined minimunr tempera-

tures’? which oceur in the claims. Mr. Sehultz’s opinion

is based on a very narrow and strict interpretation of that

language. Apparently he feels predétermined means a

rigidly fixed ‘and specific temperature at. which. the. relay

must operate at all times, :

My opinion is based on a somewhat more liberal inter-

pretation of that language, -that it is my understanding

that the patent is to be interpreted.as browdly as possible

ini view of limiting prior ast. Judge Reeves’ décisiori

S27 was to ‘the effect the patemt is entitled’ to extremely

_ + broad interpretation. © Therefore, in. the absence of

limiting prior art, and there is ‘no prior-art in’ this par-

‘ tienlar situation that requires the patent to be limited ‘to

any particular operating temperature, it is my opinion the

language over which Mx. Schultz-and T are in disagree-.

ment is centitled to a broad interpretation, and. so inter.

preted covers pot only the infringing arrangement shown

in Exhibit 87 but also the TV and JMV devices. —

442 5 ee Transcript of Testimony.

Q. Mr. Cook, have you examined Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 6

int the Kansas City suit?

3 A. J have. : ; “°

Q. - What does that show. as to the drop in stack. teri

peratures?

“A. That shows the curve representing the stack tem-

perature against time, It might be referred to as a cooling

curve. _

Q: That is the rate of fall from a given high,—fast or

slow. we /

A. The halk shows that stack temperature-falis-very

rapidly from a high temperature during the first part of —

the cooling cycle. That is because the very high tempera-

“tures in’ the stack’ are primarily ‘caused by the heat

"in the gases which afe passing. through the flue.

S38 Afterthe t temperature has fallen almost vertically on °

the curve to the point where the te.nperature ap- —

prodches the natural temperature of the stack itself,—by

that I mean the temperature due to the heat of the mate-

rials of which the stack is formed—when’ the temperature

-reaches that temperature the stack then proceeds te-céol,

largely by conduction and-radiation, from the stack with-

out the effect of high temperature gases passing through

the stack, because during that period there ts a very little

amount of products, heat products of combustion passing

through the stack and the stack tends to cool off simply

‘as a result of dissipating its own heat through radiation.

* That is a very slow rate of cooling.

Q. In Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 6-+-

Mr. Freeinan: Why domt vou refer to > laintifts’ Eix-

hibit 6 in the former suit?

Mr. Stone: Q. (Continuing. ) of the Paaeiek suit in

the first hdur the stack temperature, speaking in, percent-

tages, drofiped how far toward the minimum level of the

_ Stack whether. the stoker or whatever heating system is

used is not tured, on? . . oan

A. Well, it is easier te say half hour periods. In

“the first half hour the stack temperature on this par-

S39 ticular installation dropped from 1000 degrees Fahren-

heit to 400 degrees Fahrenheit, which is [ would esti-

mate about 4) per eent of the minimum stack temperature.

That was in the first half hour: That was the peried dur-

-ing which this very rapid drop in tempeérature* took place.

After that half hour was over the stack temperature pro-

.

"a e

.

Qa

Testimony of Junius F. Cook, Jr. °' + 4:

ceeded to ioe off af a very much slower rate, ‘represented

by the negrly horizontal pertion of the cooling curve. This

_ curve shows whereas it only. took a half hqnur to cool off

600 degrees. Fahrenheit, it ‘took nine hours thereafter to -

. cool off another 150 degrees.

Q. Now, Mr. Cook, I show you Plainti iffs’ Exhibit: No.

41. Assume the timer is set at 30 minutes and further

assume it is connected to an M-11 and installed in-a system

which shows the exact temperature curve, Plaintiffs’ Ex:

hibit 6 of the former suit, and ask you how the TJV would

Operate after a room thermostat has céased calling for heat

at\any given point?

Nr. Moore: -If the Court please, I think all this ee been

gonp into on his. Gireck examination and it is merely repeti-

tigh.

Mr. Stone: It is not: repetition because Mr. Moore

brought out this thing can function in various ways.

840 The Court: Didn’t he manipulate this, apparatus

‘ when he was on the stand before? .

_ Mr. Stone: Oh, ves, but he is now showing as a matter

of fact on an act ai installation, on an actual experimental

test which was conducted inthe other case this thing will |

_funetion about as the: M-61 functioned.

Mr. Moore: This wae not in the other case.

Mr. Stone: We are proving equivalency. ‘

~ Q. How does this one function as compared to the M-61,

that is, the TJV as compared with the M-61, in a falling

stack temperature such as that shown in Plaintiffs’ _Ex-

hibit 6 in that suit? .

A. If the time adjustment is: made in ‘the fashion ree

ommended in.The Mercoid literature, that is to say in such -

a way as to cause this system, this T.JV system to operate

ina manner to prevent the wastage of fuel, the device will -

. operate to turn the stoker motor in just about the same

identical time and position on the curve as the M-61 ‘switch |

will if properly set. In other words, both the M-61 instal-

lation in Exhibit 87 and this T.JV: system if properly ad-

- justed will work about the same.

Q. How about the JMV_ system, Plaintiffs’? Exhibit

No. 441 : |

A. That-statement is: true also of the JMV.

841 Mr. Stone: That is all.

ae

M4 0 - Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 3

Cross-Examination by Mr. Moore.

Q. -You have not tiade any actual. tests yourself per-

sonally in .vegard to the statement you have just made in

regard to this change of temperature and the operation of

these devices, haye you? \\°

A. No; the only thing T have done is to: take the type |

and cooling curve and the chimney and follow the reeom-

mendation 6f Mercoid to satisfy myself. how the devices

Will operate.

' -(. They are just vour opinion? |

A. That is right.

“Mr. Moore: Cross examination finished on the part of ,

Mercoid. *

(Witness excused.)

oe, SIT 3

a 2 y eg

Mandite of the Cireuit Court of Appeals.

bo gries States ] ae - Sa are

America. j °°:

* (Seal)

To the Honorable the Judges of the Distriet Court of ‘the

‘United States for the Western District: of | Missouri.

(ireeting:

Whereas lately in the Distriet Court of the Unite al States

for the Western District of Missouri, before vou or some

of you ima cause between Mid-Continent investment: Cori

pany, a corporation, Plaintiff and KE. O. Smith, Defendant

No. 115 Tih Equity eperels the decree of said Distriet Court

tw said cause entered on the ISth day of Occ « ALD:

G7 was in the following Words, vjz:.

This cause Coming. on for decisions at this term the

same having been tried and argued on the 16th and 17th’

.. days of February? 1937 and taken under advisement and

upon the Consideration thereof it was: Ordered, Adjudged

. and Dew ‘reed its follows, VIZ:

(1) That. the patent in suit No. 17: DS146 Was duly pri

to Walter M. Cross assignor.to C ross ¢ ‘oat (>) Watic ‘om-

‘pany on May 13th, 1980 and that the same is valid ener

(2) That: all of the right, title and interest in -and to

said Letters Patent of the United -States togetlier with

as

' Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 3. e's)

ss ’ » in io es > ss : R te

the exclusive rights and. privileges granted thereby were

at the time of the consmencement of this action and are now

vested solely and exclusively in the plaintiff by virtue of

written instruments “of assignment duly executed acknowl-

edged and deliyered in the form and manner required by

law;

(3) That the de fe ome in his residenge located at 102

Howard Street, Cathage, Missouri ‘and within this: judi:

district installed a dual thermostatic control mechanism in

connection with the force draft domestic, heating system

(furnace) having a power driver maderton 4d stoking ele-

thent, said dual thermostatic control mechanism. being

connected to the stoker driving means ,of the furnace, cue

‘thermostat being installed in the space to be heated and

the other in-the breeching or stack of the furnace one ,

> thermostat functioning and actuated by variations of the

_ temperature in. the space .to be heated and the other hy

predeterinined minimum. temperatare in the furnace to

prevent extinguishing of the fire when operating under low

heat requirements conditions ;

That the installation’ and use thereof by the de fendant

constitutes, an ‘infringement cof the plaintiff's patent. No.

1758146 and of claims numbered One to Five inclusive of

said Letters Patent; .

S440 (4) That appropriate notice was given to the de-

fendant by the plaintiff informing him of the existence

_ of said Letters Patent and the invention thereby described

and tliat said defendant imusing and employing the inven-

tions Was infringing said Letters Patent and demanding

that defendant cease, and desist from the use of said in-

verition and for an accounting:

(>) That said Letters Patent of the United States No.

1758146 and the five claims thereof are in full respects

valid and that the defendant Lad infringe] ind is con-

tinuing to infringe: said Letters Patent;

(6) That the defendant he and he is kere ‘by ‘perpetually

enjoined:against infringing said Letters Patent. of the -

United States No. 1758146 or any of the inventions covered

thereby;

(7) That the damages inv ava are.too small to’: justify

the expense of, a reference to ag Master; that the plain-

tiff have and ree over from the ‘defendant the sum of One

Dollar ($1.00) for damages by_reakon of the infringement

. of said Letters Patent ;

“60 " Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 3.

*(8) That the Findings of Fact numbered 1 to 16 in-

elysive and the Conélusions of Law numbered ‘1 to 6, made,

by the Court in this cause and filed with the Clerk shall be -

entered of record herein:

(9) *The costs of this action be mer the same cae are

‘assessed against the defendant.

Dated this 18th day of October, 1937.

Albert L. Reeves,

United States District Judge.

as by, the inspection of the transcript of the record. of the

said District Court, which was brought into the. United

States Circuit Court of Appeals Eighth Circuit by virtue

‘of an appeal agreeably to the Act of Congress in such case-

made and provided, fully and at large appears:

‘And Whereas at the May term im the vear of our Lord

one thousand nine hundred and thirty nine the said ¢ause

came on to be heard before the gaid United States Court '

and was argued by counsel. es

“On. éonsideration Whereof it is now here ordered, ad-

judged and decreed by this court, that-the decree of the

said District Court in this cause be and the same is hereby -

affirméd ‘with costs and that the Mid-Continent Investment

‘Company, a corpofation have and: recover against EF. O.

Smith the sum.of Twenty Dolk irs for its costs, herein agi

have ‘ exec ution: tlierefor.

September 12, 1939. |

ou therefore; are hereby commanded that such exe-

eution ‘and proceedings be had in said cause at according

to right and justice and the laws of the: Uniteds States,

ought to be had, the said appeal notwithstanding.

845 Witness the Honorable Charles E. Hughes, Chief

Justice of the United States, the 23rd day. of. October

in the year of. our Lerd one thousand nine hundred and

‘thirty nine. 2°

EK. E. Koch,

Clerk of the U aided States Cir-

& cuit Court of Appeals, Eighth:

Circuit. —

cougll

Costs of Appellee

Attorney—$20.0. e

Filed—-( et. 25, 1939. A. L. Arnold, Clerk. A. Ruffin,

ee >: 7 pee i

Plaintiff's Exhibit 4

- MERCOID COAL STOKER CONTROLS

ALL INSTRUMENTS EQUIPPED WITH THE MERCOID SEALED MERCURY CONTACT Switch

COMBINATION—TYPE H SENSATHERM ia

; AND TYPE V RELAY ;

Fe Low Vonage Thermostatic Regutation TYPe E ust

Tre Mercod Type #4 Sensatnerm® and Type V Relay combinetion is especially recon no PRICE

mecdes for auiomatc coat stoner apolcatons t :

Both of these instruments ere equpped with the Mercois sesied mercury contact n SENSATHERM $7.4

Switch, which «@ Not effected Dy Oust. dirt or Corrosion. Burning, pitting. siiching— / ye-3A RELAY 9.0

sources of service troulAe end expense with open-to-ew contacts.—canmot occur wih (| ;

the sealed Mercond switch : : 5 V2-3F RELAY : 6

+ Tne Type + tow voltage Senszinerm is Not only smell in size ONG Nest in eppeerence.

| put 18 very sensstiwe to room temperature changes. This instrument hes en edysstepie

range trom 36 to G5" F , and © ditlerentia! of plus or munus 4° F (tote! diferente! °F.) For further information on Type

The Type V Relay, by trenstormer action. inducés its own low voltage on the thermostat » Sengatherm refer to page 3 fo:

not used. there can be nc noses trom dirty, rusty of | further information on Type V Relay

unever armature faces y refer to page $

| TYPE V9-34. Singic pole, 10 amp. 110V 40 cycle

< ‘TYPE V2-3F Singie pole, Samp ZACV 40 cycle , , . : -°

| MOTOR RATING 1M.P Repuimon-inuuction, 46 HP Solit-Prase . i

MERCOID STOKATHERM CONTROL SYSTE

” Severs! years :otensiwe study of the needs of the stoner held has resulted in the oe

velopment of @ Control system thet fully meets s

Tre MERCOID STOK ATHERM CONTROL SYSTEM. based on 2 new pncipie of opere

hon. effectively Combenes the advantages of Timer end stack contrcis, and at the same

bee owercomes the former weaknesses Ord Grsadventages of these devices This Type Pusat

syste consists of two units, the Type TJ-V Stokatherm and the Type M,1! Pyratner nO SPECIFICATION PRICE

+ These units operate 9 comuncton ath @ech other to produce the most saustactory |

| and économcal operation attanabie with eutomtic Cos! stoners “ Ti-Vv STORKATHERM $26.50.

| The Stoaathern Contro! System incorporetes the following important features). M-11 PYRATHERM es

FIRE MAINTAINING

The Stoaathers operates tne stoner for only the very shories! periods om easery to

martian @ Temmnum tre while the thermostat is 17 the off postin A \ Be sure and specity both type TJ-V

Tre fring penods are not at Cefiritely med intervels or governed © sed stiact ter and Type M411 when ordering Also

peratures but are automeatrcelly reguistted to meet the veriadie Cons tions enc ourtered . r 4

on each instailaton As domestrc stoners operate soprns mat BO of the neetny specity whether for 110 or 220v 60

seasor on the bre nantaiming controls. the economicel, « ations of the Stome | Cycle .

therm not only Tesult in @ wery decWed tuet saving. but aise “sure agains! overheating ;

. : © fats ) s

. ° =

ag AUTOMATIC COMPENSATION FOR ae "

ft fe’ VARIATIONS IN FUEL PRiee., wtindrnes

: ( | Wt tne fue! delvered to the stoher should heys’e higher oF lower Durning rate thar tnat TYPE TI-V STOKATHERM

‘ e . | formerty used. the Stonatherm System eutometically con: pensates for this and « nanges mat

te hong fend accordingly Ths eprycaies service due to overheating or out tre ore my ° —

$ ’ ; TYPE M11 PYRATHERM

OUT-FIRE OPERATION . :

° | Approsimetety 4% Lbs

Should the tue! become exfeusted. of the fire go the Stokatherm System auto ‘

matically stops the stone’ Ths prevents’ ar empty stoke: and guards egarnet -

fiung the comushe« chamber enth unburned tvet—@ condition most unpleasant to

nd teas a : a a A . ot or compiste information refer to

ne MercowTranstormer Retey tuit into INA control induces #8 own dw voltage on ‘

the therrOstat curcad The Mercod sealed mercury contact sadches, auch are used Catalog Billetin No 241A

trrosGroul, ehrenate unnecessary Serwice as they cannot be atte ted ‘by Gust, dwt oF .

COCOwe gases

ELECTRIC AL CAPACITY Standerd for 10 amp *' 10 OO cyrte Avadatie at wo extra

charge tor Same 270V OO cycle © Tony

MOTOR RATING | HP Repuisior induction. 's HP Solt Prase tr. . —

\

TYPE M-61 STOKER. CONTROL ; A a

| Type 44) «© 8 stack mounted tempersture-opersted contro! demgned to fre ne Tyre ut -

stoner cntermittently during the pened the room thermostat «sin the off position 0 SPECICATION rmct

Thus sone instrument may afso be used as & Mgr stack tempereture bret Controt

Particular attention is called to the diel in the center of the instrument, which 1s clearly M41 With SS Well sis

end accuretery Calbrated from SF to HO” F A simple Souble adiusiment 1s ov owided M4! WithoutSS Wel - 11.68

fon ndreduely cating Doth the “cutin” and “cut-out lemperstures Jes detent -

feature permits quick setting to meet the vernety of ponditons encountered ir stomer

, A : SHIPPING WEIGHT

Another teature (6 the temperature indicator located over the Gal whch incecetes the

tenperature awidter the stack Sernng the seme pv pose @s & thermometer thea ind-cetor «= Appros:matety , 4% Lbs

ensists | determing the proper size of hg required end 1” correctly settingthe controws - ; ies

Stacde-d onstruments are furmaned with @ steniess stee! wel! enclosing the >: reste’ “4

operating con Thrs protects the cor, not onty trom deposits of fy ash but sisc egenst = For complete intormation refer to )

Corromee stec* gases 7 .

ELECTRICAL CAPACITY Ener AC oF OC. 10 amp 110. 5 amp 270v Catalog Bulletin No 2408

MOTOR RATING ' P Repulsion induction, & HP Sot Phase oF OT * j

Sor te

+ Seow 5° -r ek toe .

ot

wa ps Sue : A

“THE MERCOID CORPORATION © 4201 BELMONT AVENUE © CHICAGO, ILLINOIS

Page 2

Plaintiff’ s Exhibit No, 5. 449

andr

847 = This Assignment Witnesseth,. That, Whereas, the ° -

Cross Coal-O-Matic Company, a corporation organ-

ized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the

State of Missouri, and having its principal place of ra.

ness at Kansas City, Missouri, is the sole owner of U.

Letters Patent No, 1, 758,146, and

Whereas; the- Mid-Continent Investment Company,. a

corporation organized and existing under and by virtue

of the laws of the State of Missouri, and having. its pris

cipal place of business at 700 Baltimore, Kansas City,

Missouri, i is desirous of acquiring ay interest in the above -

U.S. Latters Patent, and

Now, Therefore, in consideration of the sum of-One Dol-

lar in hand paid. and other ‘good and valuable considera-

tions, the’ receipt of which is hereby acknowledged, the

Cross Coal-O-Matie Company does. hereby transfer, set

over; and assign unto the said Mid- Continent Investment

Company, | ifs successors, and assigns, all of its right, title,

and interest in and to said invention.

In Witness Whereof, the said Cross Coal-O- Matic Com-

pany has hereunto set its hand and affixed its seal at

Kansas City, Missouri, this 7th day of June, 1932..

Cross Coal-O-Matie Company,.

By (Sgd.) Forbes. Cross.

e«?

848 State -of Missouri, ( . ” ae

County of Jackson. Pouce .

Before me, a Notary Publie in and. ree the’ County and

State aforesaid, personally. appeared Forbes Cross, to

me personally known as Vice President of the Cross Coal-o-

matic Company, who duly acknowledged that he signed,.

sealed, and delivered the foregoing instrumént as his free

and voluntary act and deed and for the uses and purposes

therein set forth. >

In Testimony Whereof, I have hereunto. set’ my hand.

and affixed my ‘seal at Kansas City, Missouri, ‘this 7th Day:

of June, 1932. .

coed (Sed.). Gertrude Clingenpeel,

(Seal). igre eee. anere acai

=

A

»

}

a oe ee esate! 's Exhibit. No. 6 ;

s4g°- 7 ce a “AGRE i MENT

= : greene? it made ‘ind ree into this : 28rd day of De-

¥ cnber, 1981 bysand “between Cross Coal-O- Matic «om:

PAN, a Car rition orgartiged and existing under the laws

of the StateZof Missonri and having: a principal place of

.

Kansas © ity, - Missouri, hereinafter called. ,

d. Butler Manufacturing Company, a’ corpora-

tion ‘erganized aid existing under the laws. ot the State of

Missouri, and having a principal piace of business at 7400

Rast “Thirteenth Street, Kansas City, Missouri, herein

after callers‘ Butler, and Minneapolis. Honeywell Regu-

lator Company, a corporation organized and existing under

>the laws otf ihe Statecof Delaware and: haviag’a principal’

place of business at 2727 Fourth Avenue South; Minne-

_ apolis, Minnevota, Heretnatter called ** Minneapolis”

Witnesseth ;

business aut

‘“Cross””’, &

.

,.

A. bs

Whereas, Cross is the present owner of the entire right,

titleaned mterest, except for the diereinafter recited rights

OF Butle Te on aiid to the following. Vnited States: patents,-

and the inveritions therein set forth;

Number . Inventor Granted Invention

Patent L758a96 Walter MI. Crass) May 18, 1980) Domestic

! a Fata Heating

ie | me, System |

_Batert 758,147 Walter M. Cross Ma av 13 La30: Heating.

oo 2 aa System .

Control

—

Pe’ liereas, Butler js engaged in the mii mat: acture and sale

heating apparatus cand particularly -automatie coal

stokers for-sheating qpparatus and, being desirous of

SOO sing siid system and-or control oe in -com-

. bination with ‘Sates of stokers made by . duly hereto.

“fore entered into on Septe m™m ber 25180, an agreqement

with Cross, whereby Butler received and iS now possessed ..

of the sole and exclusive right and license to make, use

?

oo Plaintiff's Exhibit “Ne: 6. 481 y.

. 7 ; a 7 A cal

and sell said System and Gr Control inventions, snbject te

royalty payments therefor te Cross, .

on es ee

Whereas, Minneapolis is engaged in the’ manntacture

and sale of various control deviees and systems, including —

‘devices and. systems for the control of -heating apparatus,

and is desirous-oK acquiring the seletand exclusive right

‘and license, and the. right to grant sub-leenses, upon

\voyalty payments, to make, vse and sell said System and

(Control inventions, subject only to the right of (ross or

Que of its licenses to purchase from Minneapolis the bere:

inatkter recited stoker switehes made by Minneapolis for

resale by Cross.or one of tts licensees only in combination.

With stokers mannutactared and sold by Cross or one‘ot its

licensees, upon preferred termis as hereinafter set fonh.

Nowy Therefore, in cousideration of One Dollar GOSL.0N)

ireash, each tothe other in hand paid, the receipts whereoX

are jointly and severally acknowledged, and in considyra

tion of the mutual representations, covenants: and agree

nefits herein set aut, the three parties hereto joimtly and

severly represent, covenant and agree as follows:

i. Cross and Butler jointly and severally grant to Min

onenpolis the sele and exclusive right and lieeuse to make,

‘ase and selk and to sub licevsOothers to minke, use and

(SDL sell, the inventions ‘disclosed bY said patents as applted

to coal stokers, and all improvements thereon which

inventions and improventents may he the subject of mate

ents, or divisions, renewals, continuations, and, or reissues

thereot, now or hereafter owned, controlled and or ae?

quired by Cross and er Butler, throughout the territory

of the Lnited States and Its possessions for the fife of

snid patents, unless said rights und license are sooner tens,

tinated in aéecordance with the provisions, hereof.

2. Tt is jointly and severally agreed by all of the par-

ties hereto ‘that rovalty payments to be made hereunder

shall be made or based only upon what are known to the

parties hereto as a ‘combustion stoker switeh’? whieh is

specifically herein detined as a combinations stoker control

Unit including an automatic electric Switch responsive di

rectly to temperatures of combustion gases or botler water

_ produced by an automatic coal-fuel stokersand adapted, ih

452 Plants Eachibit rm

combination with otek: devices and apparatas, for. the

control of automatically operated coal-fuel stoKers, to

“prevent the extinguishment of its fire when operating under

low heat requirement conditions,

3. Minneapolis agrees to pay as camel: revalty ‘for

each Heensed combustion stoker switeh made and sold by

it and by any of its sub-lcensees, pursnant to the provi-,

sions’ of this heer hse, ae sum equal to Five’ Percent (9%) -

oof the net sales: price of each “combustion stoker switch;

provided: however, the mininum royalty per switeh shall

not be less than Seventy Five Cents (7 ne).

4. Minneapelis agrees to pay, during ‘the, existence of

. this agreement, a mkiimum guaranteed royalty of One

Thousand Dollars i$ O00.) for the pe ‘riod be inning

with the. aeadian of ‘this agfeément and-ending De-

cember 31, 1982, one half to be paid -on ry execution of

this Atreer ment and the other 4ialf on July 2.1982, and a

tmhinimunm enarantecd rovalty of Fifteen. Humilbed Dollars

($1,500.) for the calendar vear 1933, and a minimum guar. —

anteed rovalty of Twenty Five Hundred Dollars. ($2,500.) -

for the calendar vear 1934 and each vear thereafter, to be

paid in equal hatfvearly payments on January 1th and

July (th of each vear; provided, however, that if in said

initial perted or im any calends: vear thereafter, the earned

rovaltdes due and payable hereunder exceed ‘the guar-

anteed minim annual rovalties, then only the exeess of

j earned reyalties over said minimum annual royalties, ‘plus

the rainiinum: annual revalties, shall be due and p: avab le by

alan apolis: and, provided, further, that in the event of

ymination of this Aereément= as herein provided, said

minimum anmatt rovalty payment for the then-current year

oshall. be pro-rated and such-pro-rated part for the expired

Jportion Mt the then-current vear shall-constitute the jimit

of hiabiity of Viinne ‘apolis, for minimum-annual reyvalty for

each year, .

“Cross and Butler jointly ar nd Severs ally authorize and

direct that auy and all revalties provided to he paid by.

Mintiegpolis hereunder shall be paid to Butler except in the

event fhat the above recited agreement of Cross and. But.

ler, dated September 22, L981, has been terminated and that

all rights of Butler ae said patents . have reverted to

Cross, in which event, after notice by Cross of such termi-

ation, Minneapolis shall thereafter pay said royalties

sundgr this heerise to-Cross and er its assigns,

~ Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 6. ° 453

853. 6. Pursuant to the preceding authorization and di-

rections, Minneapolis agrees to pay the royalties due

hereunder to Butler and to make djuarterly statements. to

Butler on the fifteenth (Lath) day of January, April, July

and October of each year during the existence of this

agreement, showing the sales made of sail combustion:

stoker switches for the quarterly period ending with the

last.day of the month preceding each such statement, and.

Minneapolistagrees to accompany each such statement with

the license fees thereby shown to be due, less any payment

of minimum gnaranteed royalties theretofore made during

the calendar.vear in which such statement was rendered.

7. Minneapolis agrees. to and will require all its sub-

licensees to keep aceurate hooks of account concerning sales

aml transactions pertaining to said combustion stocer

~ switches ang agrees that Cross or Butler shall be permif

ted, through certified pubhe accountants, to examine -such:

hooks of account at reasoriable times, H being understogd

that such examinations shall be limited to sales and trals--

actions of combustion stoker witches. :

& It is jointly and severally agreed that, for the par-

poses of this Agreement, siridd switehes shall be considered

to be sol@ when billed out.‘or if not billed cut, then when

delivered, or when paid for, if paid for before delivery:

and it is further so agreed that royaltyes paid on switches

which are lost or damaged in transit or otherwise etec.

tive, and not accepted by the customers, may be deducted

from further reyalty payments to be made hereunder.

0. Minneapolis agrees to sell control units to Cross or

one of its lidensees (who at present is Butler) at as low a

price as Minneapolis shall sell similar eontrol units

434 to any other manufacturer of oil hurners or stokers,

provided, however, that Minneapolis shall not be obli

vated te sell (Cross or one of its lieensees Shid contro! nits

ioexeess of the number actually. required by Cross or one

of its Heensees for the eoutre) of stokers as made and sold ,

by (‘ross or one of its licensees, : j

10. Cross or one of its licensees agrees to refrain from

selling said contrels and or systems purchased from’ Min.

neapelis except in eonjunction with stokers made and sold

hy Cross or one of its liwensees. -

11. Butler and Cross jointly and severally agree that

‘Minneapolis shall have the right to sue infringers but such

right ‘shall: be limited to svstems emploving deviees such

-as combustion stoker switches as: herein defined which may

404 . : Plaintiff's Bahibit No, 6.

he an infringement of any patents: subject to this Agree-

ment or any reissnes thereof, jn the name of Cross and/or

of Butler, as may be necessary, but in the event of, the

bringing of any such suit by Butler or Cross or Minneap-_

olisythe party bringing suek suit shall bear all.the expenses:

of such litigation and be entitled to retain wall recoveries,

and Butler and Cross and Minneapolis jointly and severally

agree that in the event any such suit is brought by two or

tioere of the parties, the expenses of litigation and or re-

ccoverivs therefrom shan be equally shared by the parties

britvine such snit and Cross -and one -of its Heensees or

either of thém reserves the right to join and participate in

any suit Which may be brought on the aforesaid patents and -

to share in the expense and recovery thereof. In the event

Minneapolis brings any Such action in the name of Butler

and or Cross:then Minneapolis shall protect. Butler and or

Cross! from all costs expenses and or damages which ae-

erue against Butler and or Cross on aecount of or’

SO crowing out of any such aetion.

1? Tt is mutually agreed between the three parties

that it may sem advantageous to apply for reissue of

either one or both of the above listed patents or on before

May 12. 1932 and it is mutually agreed that in the eveat if

chall be decRled so to reissue either or both said patents,’

the three. parties will cooperate im sach reissue or re-

issues: "provided, however, that the control and expense of

the prosecution of any. such reissie applications shall re-

fonin in said. Cross, and Cross agrees that it will give full:

information to’ Minneapolis and Bitler as to the prepara: |

tin and tiling of-such reissue application or applications ©

and will employ able and duly qualified patent counsel for

that purpose and will give due consideration to the advice

And sudégestions of the other part’ or parties relative

thereto in arder that: the best possible patent protiction

may be obtained. for the benefit of the various parties to-.

.

this Agreement, °

13... Mitinespotis shall have the right to terminate this

Aereement on Detember Sisf of any vear during its con

finaance by previons notice thereof in writing, mailed

postage prepaid, not later than the first diiy of November

neat preceding, fo Cross and one of its Hicensees,* iftany,

addressed ta theirlast. known place of business, whereupon

this Lieense Agreement shall cease and all rights and. tia-

bilities of Minneapolis shall terminate without prejudice -

© Plaintiff's Exhibit. No. 6. 459

to any rights of Butler. or Cross to recover any moneys

then due by wey of rovalties prior to such termination,

“14. Minneapolis agrees that, in the event Minneapolis:

shall grant ‘any. sub-licenses hereunder, each. sub-:

S56 license shall be so. restricted as, to) terminate simul

. taneously with the termination’of this ‘License Agree

ment; and Minneapolis shall pay Cross er one of its

licensees earned royalty foreach sub-licensed conrbustion -

_stoker switch made and sold by each sub-licensee as if

each such sub-litensed switch were made and sold by Min--

neapolis and all earned rovalties so paid by Minneapolis

shall be considered as eearned royalty: payments by. Min-

neapolis for the purpose of determining whethersminimunm |

annual reyalty payments herein provided -have heen ex-

ceeded. a : 7 hd

15. Minneapolis agrees that it will comply with the

United States Patent Statutes with respect to the marking

of caid switches made and sold winder this license with the

word **Patent and the number or nuinbers of the patents

applicable therefo and will insert such requirement in each

sub-license granted. by it. - a

162 -1f the revalties herein provided Shall at any time he’

in arrear for thirty (30) days after they shall become due, -’

or if Minneapolis shall become bankrupt or insolvent or,

-senter-into any settlement with its creditors, or shall make |

any default in performing jany ‘ofthe agreements herein:

contained, then, and in such case, ‘Butler, or Cross in the

event of reversion of Butler's rights to Cross, shall have

- the wight by notice in writing mailed Minneapolis postage

prepaid to its last known place of business, ta rewoke this

License, which, shall hecome void the thirtieth (30th) day

cthéreafter unless Minneapolis shall have previously reme:

died Sachi default or arrear, without prejudice to any right

of action or remedy of Butler or Cross for the recovery, of

anv monevs then due and acerued to ‘the -date of cancel

Jation, to Butler-or Cross herennder, er in respect of any

“antecedent breach of any agreement herein contained,

S77. the Cross patent, No. 1,758,146, shall be ad-

judjcated by a court of competent appellate jurisdic

tion orSiv a trial court) from which appeal ts taken,

vavalid or shall-he thereby so crestricted the its scape as to,

be of no practical benefit: to Mintieapolis by way of pre

venting unlicensed competition, then. and in either sueh

event. Minneapolis shall Rave the right, upon notice in

writing Miniled postage prepaid addressed to Butler and or

-

460 = Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 6

Cross at its last known place of business, to discontinue

any and all further royalty payments here under and there-. =

—apor-thixcontract shatt terminate, ~*- ae a

IS. Butler or Cross agree that they have aot heretofore

nade and will ot make any agreement or do any act in

derogation or contravention of any: right her eby granted

Minneapolis. °

19. Minneapolis agrees that it will not contest the valid-

ity of either of the above-recited” patents during the ex-

tence of this Ligense Agreement and agrees that it will, |

during the existence of this License Agreement, ‘assist

Cross ai the preparation and prosecution of-the above-

rentioned reissue and in upholding. the validity of said

“patents: a

20. This License Agreement. shall-inure:- to the benefit .

ot the suceessors and or assigns of the three parties here

16 provided-such successors and or assigns shall agree to,

ariel aecept,. the obligations and liabilities of sue an) predec es

OF ane or iissigner,

In Witness Where of, the parties hereto hi ive chased this

Agreement to he signed by their respective duly author

izeck officers and thei .r Tespecfive corporate seals to he

affixed, :

Sus. December ord. 1O31,

Butler Manufacturing (Company,

By E. E: — t. .

Attest: . se

F.. A. Rafi, -

: ‘ Secretary.

* December Jord, 10317.

_ Cross ¢ ‘oal OM: atie & ‘ompary,

. By Forbes Cross,

: ; Vice Priside nh.

Attest: . etal, Dee

Walter. M. Cross; Jr., ae:

Necre tary. Z >

December 29th, 1931, ;

ys ! Minneapolis - Honeywell Regulator

; Company, .

By- Julius KK: Luthe,

: | : ers Vane Pre side wt. °

Attest: : ba ,

FOS. Stinson, ee

Asst. Secretary.

Plaintiff's Exhibit Now 6. 457,

State-of Missouri 2. *

County of Jackson |” :

On this 23rd day of December, 1931, before:me, appeared

KE. EB. Norquist, to me personally known, who, being by me

duly sworn did ‘say that he is President of Butler Maiiu-

facturing Company, and that the seal of the foregoing in-

strument.is the corponate seal of said corporation, and that

said. instrument was signed and sealed in behalf of saiel

corporation by authority Gf its board of directors, and-said

KE. EF. Norquist acknowledged Said instrument to be the free —

act and deed of said corporation,

: Louis Brown,

Notary Public.

\

On this 23rd day ef December’, 1931, before me appeared

Forbes Cross, to me personally known, azha, being by: me

July sworn did miiV that -be is Vice President of Cross

CoalQ Matic Company, and that the seal to the foregome

instrument is. the corporates seal of said corporation, and —

that said instrument was signed and sealed tr behalf of

said corporation by authority ofits board of directors, and

said Forhes ¢ Tass acknowledved satd instrument to be the

free act and deed Of saick corporation, fF:

(Seal) '

Comimisston expires Mareh 7, 1932.

SHO State of Missouri / ma

County of Jackson’ \”

ft

° chee Gertrndy Clingenpeet,

, . . 7 ; Notaru Public.

My COTMLDESS On expires dune 7, 1934. . oF

. i « - * &

State of Minnesota, ?

County of Hennepin. \ ie

On this 2oth day of December, 1951; before me appeared:

Jalins K. Luthe.to me personally known, who, being by me

daly sworn, did say that he is the Vice President of Min"

neapotis dtoneywéll Regulator Company, that the eeal af

fixed to the foregoing instrument is the corporate seal of:

said corporation, and that said instrument was executed. in

- behalf of saidgecorperation.by authority of its"*beard of di

458 2 “Plaintif’s Exhibit. No. 7.

rectors; and said Talla AK. Luthe acknowledged said in-

strument to be the tree act and deed of said corporation.

JV. sersocthy i

*- Notary Public, He nne pin ‘ounty,

. Minneseta.

My commission expired Feb, 15, 1933.

. ® *T* A" : ‘ ol ‘ i has bl

SA : LICENSE AGREEMENT.

re reement Made’ as of the Skst day of. December, 1938).

by and between Mid-Continent Investment Company, Ine.,

a corporation org: anized and existing under the laws of

the State of Missouri,-and having a principal place of

business at Natisas City, Missouri, hereinafter called

Mid-Continent", amd Minneapolis-Honeywell . Regulator

Company, a corporation organized and existing under the

laws ef the State of Delaware and having a principal:

plaice of business at Minneapolis, Minnesota, hereinafter .

called ** Minne “apotis’?’ _e s. |

Witnesseth _ ; ; ‘ i

Whereas, Mid-Continent is thie present oa of the .

entire right, tithe and interest in and to the following | .

United State ~ patents and the inventions therein set forth:

Number, Patent 1.758.146; Tnventor, Walter Mo Cross:

Granted, M; ay 1, W980: Invention, Dome ‘stic Heating Sys-

tem.» iy he

Number, Patent 4.758147: Inventor, Walter ML Cross:

Granted, May: 18. 1950; Invention, Meatine System Con- °¢

trol. : Pa el nee $e |

_ Whereas, said patents were formerly owned by Cross

~CoalO Matic Company, the assets of which are now en

tirely owned by Mid Continent ; x.

* Whereas. Cross CoaLO. Matic Company entered into an

agreement September 22, 1981, with Batler Manufacturing

‘ompany of Wansas City, Missouri. and subsequent there

to Cross .CoalOMatie’ C ompany, Butter Manufactoring:

Company, and Miingapolis, on the 28rd day of December

131, entered into a threosparty as sreement granting. te

Minneapolis, among other things, an e Xelusive lice hse under

- said Ctraxs pate nts, ;

S610 Whereas, Butler Manufacturing C ompany he reto

fore gave up its rights under and cancelled said gerree

ment entered nfto with Cross CoalOMatie € ompany Sep.

ee

a

-

P , Plant's Exhibit No.

- &

tember’: 22, 1931, and Minneapolis hi ix HOW terminated said

three-party agreement of December. y HSH, effective as

of the 31st-day of December 195s; ’ ;

Whereas, Minneapolis and Mid.c ontinent are desirous *

of entering into‘a new agreement in relation to sid, Cross

‘patents whereby Minneapolis will be permitted to continue

its manufacture and sale of appears atus ‘and systems under

said Cross patents.

Now, Therefore, in consideration of One Dollar ($1.00)

in cash. paid by Minneapolis te Mid-e ‘ontinent, the rettipt

whereof is hereby acknowledgest, and in, Consideration of

the “mutual répiresent&tions, covenants “and agreements

“herein set out, Minneapoliy and MidtContinent jointly ‘an

severally represent, covenant and agree as follows:

1, Mid-Continent hereby grants to Minneapolis. the sole

and exelusive right and license to make, use and sell and ~

to sub-license others to make, use and sell, the’ inventions

disclosed in said patents. as applied to coal. stokers, and.

all improvements theregn. which inventidns and improve-

ments may he the subject of patents, or divisions, renewals,

continuations, and or reissues ‘thereof, now vor hereafter

owned, controlled and or ,aeqnired by + Mick ‘ontinent,

throughout tlie territory of the United States and its pos-

sessions for the life of said patents, nnless said rights.

and license are sooner te Fminated in accordance with the

_ provisions hereof, é

2. Tris jointly and seve rally aitena by the parties here-

to that royalty payments to be made hereunder shall be

made or based only upon what are known to the par

R62 ties hereto asia “Combustion stoker switel” whieh is

specifically herein defined as-a combustion stoker con-

trol unit “ineluding an antomatie electric sib doetal responsive

directly to temperatures of combustion gases or boiler.

water prodneed by an antomatie coal Fined stoker and.

adi pink in combination with other devices and apparatus,

for the control of automatic ‘ally operated coal fuel stokers,:

to prevent the extinguishment of its fire: when. operating

nuder low heat requirement conditions.

- 3

lowing method of computation : :

At the end of each ealendar vear, Minneagitylis will total

the net sales in dellars of all ‘ealte of comMistion stoker

sWitehes made -to*sthose -enstomers classified as 7* manu-

459 -

Minneanolis agrees to pay an earned rovalty on each

“lieensed combustion stoker switch. according to the fol

4 .

460 + \ Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 7.

Tacturers’’ by Minneapolis and pay an earned. royalty-of

five percent (5) of such dollar tetal. ‘

Also, at the end of each calendar year, Minneapolis will

, determine from its usual annual inventory the total num-

ber of Licensed.combustion stoker switches of- each type

sold during the prereding -ealendar year and will deduct

from each such total the number of such combustion stoker.

switches sold-to ‘tmanufacturers’*’. The remainder wilttie

considered as Chaving been sold to ‘‘dealers*’,- Minné-*

apolis will pay an earned royalty on each such combustion

stoker switch sold to a ‘*dealer”’ at the rate of five per-

cent. (97 ) of the list price on -that partieular type of

combustion stokpr switch minus 25% and 20%. » (ex-

ample 0% of ($5.00 minus 259% and 20% )—$0.15) @&

4. In the event. Minneapolis grants any sub-licenses

hereunder, Minneapolis will pay to Mid-Continent an

earned royalty on each licensed combustion stoker switch

sold by such sub-licensees, the earned rovalty tobe paid:

being biased upon the -tetal dollar sates: and list prices

863 of such sub-licensees arid computed ip the manner set

forth in paragraph three-hereof. nai 3 :

_ oO) Starting with the vear 1940, Minneapolis agrees ta:

make Vvearly reports to Mid-Continent not Jater than -the

fifteenthr day of February of each vear-separatély setting °

out the total numbér-of licensed-conmbustion stoker switches

sold by it and its subdicensees during the preceding vear

fo “manufacturers”? and ‘tdealers’’ together with: the

prices to “manufieturers’’ and the list prices upon which

the ‘dedler’? prices: are based ‘and to‘ accompany eaeh |

‘such report with the royalties thereby shown, to. be due

Mid-Continent, ; . boar

6. Minneapolis “agrees to and avill require all its sub-

licensees to keep -aceurate books of aeeount. concerning

sales and = transactions pertaining to. sr combustion |

stoker switches and agrees. that Mid-Continent) shall be

permitted, through certified public aecdéuntants, to. ex-

amine such books of accéunt at reasonable times, it being

understood that such examinations shall be limited te

sales and transactions of combustion stoker switches.

7. It is. jointly and severally agreed that, for the pur-

poses of this Agreement, said switehes shall he considered

to be sold when hilled out, or if net billed. out, then when

delivered, er when paid for. if aasaid for before delivety.;

and it is further so.agreed that rovalties paid on switches

Which are lost.or damaged in transit or otherwise defee-

,

Plaintiff's: Exhibit et |

_ tive, and not accepted by the customers; may! be deducted:

from. further royalty navment:- ‘to be wmade hereunder.

R. “Minneapolis agrees to sell control units to Mid-.

Continent at as low a price as Minneapolis vhall sell stim-

ilar control units to any other manufacturer of oil burners

_or stokes, prov ided, however, that Minrieapolis shall

864 net be obligated to sell Mid-Continent said control

*

e

units:in excess of the number actually required by’

“Mid-« ‘ontinent for the control of, stokers as made and sold

by Mid-Continent.

9, Mid-Coritinent agreés to refrain from se ling said

controls and or systems purchased from Minneapolis ex

cept in conjunction With ‘stokers made and sold by Mid.

Continent. .

10. Mid-Continent @rees. that Minneapolis shall have

the right to Sue infringers but such right shall be limited

to systefus employing dev ives such as combustion stoker

switches as herein defined which may be an infringement

of any patents subject to this Agreement or any reissues

thereof, in the name of Mid-Continent, but -in- the event

of the bringing of any’ such suit) by Mid-Continent or

Minneapolis, the pagty bringing su¢éh suit shall bear all

the expenses of such litigation and be entitled to retain

all recoveries, and Mid-Continent and Minneapolis jointly

and severally agreefthat in the event.any such- suit is

brought by both parties jointly, the expenses of litigation

"and or recoveries ‘therefrom shall be equally shared by

the parties and Mid-Continent reserves the right to join

and participate in any sit: which miay: be- brought by

Minneapolis on the aforesaid + “patents and.to share it the

expense and recovery thereof. In the event Minneapolis

brings any such action ‘in the name of Mid-Continent then

Minneapolis shall: proteet Mid-Continent from all costs,

expenses and er damages which accrue. against Mid-Contt-

baer on account of or growing out of any sue ‘h action:

» Minneapolis shall have the righf to termin: ate this

Pipes on December Sist of ‘any year, during its con-

tinuanee by. previous notice thereof in writing, mailed

postage prepaid, not later than the first day of November

next pree eding to Mid-Continent, addressed to its last

865 known | place of business, whereupon this License _

Agreement sh: Wl cease and all rights ‘and liabilities of

Minneapolis shall terminate without ‘prejudice to’ any

rights of Mid-Continent to recover any moneys: then due

‘by way of royalties prior | to suc h termination.

*

eo

a. - Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 7.

- .

le. Minneapolis agrees that, in the event Minneapolis

stall grant any sub-licenses hereunder, each sub-license.-

shall be so restricted as to terminate simultaneously with

_ the termination.of this License Agreement. Sac

13, Minneapolis agrees that it will comply with the:

United States Patent Statutes with respect to the marking

of said switches made and sold under this License with the ’

word ** Patent’? and the number or numbers of. the patents

applicable thereto and will insert ‘such requirement. in

~ each sub-license granted by it.

14. If the royalties herein provided shall at any time

be in arrear for thirty (30) days after théy shall become

due, or if Minneapolis shall make -any default in perform-

ing any of the agreements héréin contained, then, and in

any such case, Mid-Continent shalt have the right by notice

in Writing mailed Minneapolis, postage prepajd to its last

known place of business, to revoke this License, which

shall become void the thirtieth (30th) day thereafter ut-

less Minneapolis shall-have previously remedied such de-_’

fault or arrear, Without prejudice to any right of action

er remedy of Mid-Continent for the’ recovery of any

moneys then due and ‘acerued to the date of cancellation,

to Mid-Continent hereunder, or in respeef of any ante-

cedent breach of any agreement ‘herein contained... -

lo. Tf the Cross patent. No. 1,758,146 shall’ be ‘ad judi-

eated bv a court of competent appellate jurisdiction or

bY a trial court from which no appeal is taken, invalid or

shall be thereby so restrieted in its scope as to be of

S66 no practical benefit to Minneapolis by way of prevent-

ing unlicensed competition, then, and in either sue

went, Minneapolis shall: have the right, upon notice in

writing mailed postage ‘prepaid addressed to Mid-Contj-

nent at its'last known place of business, to discontinue

any and all further revalty pavmetts hereunder and there-

npon this coritract shall terminate. b

Wh Mid-Continent covenants that it has the full rieht

~and. authority to make this agreement and that it will not

Inake any agreement or do anv aet in derogation or cen.

travention of any right hereby granted Minneapolis,

17. Minneapolis agrees that-it will net eontest. the

vafidity of either of the above-recited patents during the

existence of this License Agreement and avrees that it

will during the existence of this License Agreement, assist

Mid-Continent in upholding the validity of said Patents.

IS.) This License Agreement shall inure to the benefit

Plaintif’’s.Exhibit No.7 <> 63°

of the successors and/or assigns of the parties hereto

provided. such successors and or assighs shall agree te, .

and accept, the obligations and liabilities of such préde-

cessor and/or assignor. :

In Witness Whereof, the parties hereto * ave caused this

Agreement to be signed by their respective duly author-

ized officers and their respective corporates seals to be .

affixed.

November 1, 19388. :

Mid- ‘ontinent Investment ompany, Ine.

‘ a By Forbes Cross, ;

oe are pam ey j Pro sident,

Attest+ : es

Walter M. Cross, Ir. - a. a

Secretary. oe

November 7, 1938. Oe We ae

‘Minneapolis- Honey well Regulator C omipany,

: \” By ¢ ‘harles B: Sweatt.

Charles C. Buckland,

, Secre etary.

867 State of Missouri, } a cag ee ner .

County of Jackson, 2 eg 4

. On this Ist day of November, 1938 before me, appeared

~ Walter M. Cross Jr, to me personally known, who, being

by me duly sworn did say that he is secretary of Mid-

Continent Investment C ompany, Inec., and that the seal: of

the foregoing instrument is the corporate seal of said

corporation, ‘and that said instrument was signed and

sealed in behalf of said) corporation by authority ef its .

Board of Directors, and said secretary acknow lodged said

instrument to be the free act and deed of said corporation,

; .. © -(Sed.) Trixie Smith,

‘Satiiea Public, Jackson County

‘ ins Missourt, is 3

My commission expires Oct. 6; 1940,

fs

. 464-0 ~—- Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 7.

State of Minnésota, } -

County of Hennepin. (~~

©n this 7th day of November, 1938, before me, appeared

Charles C. Buckland, to me personally known, who being

‘by me duly sworn, did say that he is the Secretary of

Minneapolis-Honeywell Regulator Company, that the seal

affixed to the foregoing instrument is the corporate seal

of said corporation, and that*said instrument was executed

in behalf of said corporation by authority of its Board of

Directors; and said Secretary acknowledged said instru-

‘ment to be the free act and ee

og) . (S¢d.) Ruby~K. Pfaff,

Notary. Public, Hennepin County,

- Minnesota. a. ~

- My cOmmission expires May 2, 1942.

< . »

‘

+ + + + + + FF OF OF OF OH OH FE OF

~~ - _—— Plaintiff's: Exhibit 10

BULLETIN No. 241-A

MERCOID

STOKATHERM

CONTROL SYSTEM

REGISTERED TRADE MARK ‘

Patewts Msemed 1508874 ~ 1.600.800. 1 TANORO. FIRS IRE LIST Aly FOF EOLS CMR. Vemtiny

A

[LISTED AS STANDARD BY UNDERWRITERS LABURATORIES, Inc.|

PYRATHERM”

«

=

Type Ty.

STOKATHERM

A_.NEW STOKER. CONTROL SYSTEM

s

. Incorporating the ‘following important features:

The Stokatherm, System operates | F IRE MAINTAINING ] encountered on each instaliation

the stoker for only the very short- 7 As domestic stokers operate ‘ap-

est periods necessary to maintain a minimum fire while proximately 80%, of the heating Season On the fire main

the thermastat is in the. off position taining controls, the economical, short aperations of the

The firing periods are not at definitely timed intervals. Stokatherm not only result im a very decided fue!

“or governed by fixed stack temperatures, but are auto-. saving, but also insure againsf overheating

matically reqguiated to meet the variable conditions

it the "el delv- T AUTOMATIC. COMPENSATION FOR VARIATIONS IN FUEL | <ompensates fc

ered tothe Stoker this and changes

should have a higher or lower burning rate than that its firing period accordingly. This eliminates service dus

formerly used, the Stokatherm System automatically to overheating or out-fire

. 2.

Should the fuel become ex- 0 U T * F j R ty 0 P E R A T i 0 N [against filling the combust:or

hausted, or tne fire go out, the chamber with unburned fur

> Stokatherm System automatically stops the stoker. a condition most unpleasant to the operator ,

This prevents operatrng an empty stoker and guards ;

RUGGED CONSTRUCTION, EASY TO INSTALL.

' LOWER SERVICE EXPENSE TO THE DEALER,

INCREASED ECONOMY TO THE USER.

‘ List PRICES

TYPE 1). STOMATHERM 110 Of #90 VOLT GO CYCLE -$99.90 TYPE M41) PYRATHER RA srtse

THE MERCOID CORPORATION

OOLs BemuracTvates Ted SERCO SwiTce

401 BELMONT AVENUE e CHICAGO, KLLINOTS, U.S.A

®

.

WIRING DIASRAMS.

eK oro

OCOD Lem wa test

SOSA TOE Oe Ungald on

SR | Beg

atee\.

Trt

do ;

.

a

STORKATHERM CONTROL WIRING FOR SINGLE

PHASE 110 VOLT MOTORS

wcecs

Tere en

MERCED

- | Sista ee

wa]

® pea

La]

o} aan

aw

rweact

af

y

STOKATHERM CONTROL OF SINGLE PHASE

MOTOR AND eee Fan ON WARM AiR

No? 2s No 8 Ne @

, “~—

it —4y O~ .) ‘ten O- Seren 6

: Tet te OF , wetness ©

tee ° ¥ vances

‘ epee E SUmEATHE RN

Let

at 2

ry rer

*

Be °

vem Cea) her

su

‘ c

Sian we j

; etme * Stlan se ie) 2 |

C ) mice — c ve) wanie oe a

J ————_—___ - eie .

° “8 SL F © Comte: FOR oe) enTL® Serr «

- e

= ng gee er STOneer Sa" rOO' Os eB Mane

> ”~ u wi

“Sear aaron Non woven snare STOKATHERM CONTROL OF SMALi THREE INDIRECT HEATER FOR SUMMER ANO WINTER

Switou — PHASE MOTOR ON STEAM OR HOT WATER HOT WATER SUPPLY EATER ANG TANK NOT

System ° ° ee SHOWN. >

* Ne ott Ne ID

RRC mO s&h : Oe

fo Sertce ) Stetprat em 3 Zs) a :

roe () vers

~eC8e > J

wm

conan (He if :

seth |

A, ' a

‘SGooed00

= egut

a TEN como

ors @ Of Of pan!

or

Vi

eesTOL ATR FPL QeE Ratt er) STOR ATHERI TROL OF HEATING aNd

STOKATHERM CONT

wits ELEcTarc

» OF HEATING SYSTEM

TIME SwiTCH FOR auton

MATICALLY CUTTENG OUT TeE@Meostar ar

STORATHERM CONTROL OF HEATING SYSTEM

wits ELECTRIC TIME SwiTCH FOR aUTo

CON

INDUSTRIAL STEAM SYSTEM: OPERATING ON

+1Grt PRESSURE DURING Day AND COW PRES.

SURE AT NIGHT TIME SWITCH aUuTOMATiC.

ALLY TRANSFERS REGULATION FROM HIGH

7O LOW PRESSURE CONTROL USE SPECIAL

LOW PRESSURE CONTAC) (aPaABLE OF STAND

NIG? MATICALLY CHANGING FROM Day TO NIGH?

SETTING OF DUAL SENSATHE RM ING MAXIMUM PRESSURE OF SYSTEM

Ne we MM “Me .'5

’ .

: ’

2M Dew 1945 : "OPM a7 029 Tre MERCOID COMPOMATIONW CHCASO AA Prowse

AMS ash etggueeessap :

ZEFE ~2'§ +t} =3 4: ah ast nT “ S $5.

PT A Sa AL A ean ke fe

Hi s aay i HE : 3 335 - ej 5 fidutsl Hi zt j sf 2425;,\ 5 a sy

ate Hit . ee i ott aa lta He q

aieath HEH a ies Hi GH) pce? ity ies 5 § se

ae, eA, nh an a reinitee : Li E ie? f 3 Say:

Seat ae Hie i i Went eh

G tglyplecttee! cate Hie BHT abate int lt, ont

2 Hs mi i | weg LETT rags Gehl nie

| > aa il r sels oh nits sit a kee ie

eed He cade 8 ie, ig

, il He ae: . H Hit i z i3,?

© 3 tle on, i Fil ee i 2 ys3

= un is HE yall es wena i

S iin fu yi vee

zl eco i t al Hn

ele Webs al ite iit

z iegeteee ij beesh?2 ie senllasaisgs A hao Ay |

oe. Bil ane Me | ae nH

eee i rt rae el u initia! SL HIERIN

ard SEAR lle

a

=| .

a ne i Mest ii

ie Hi: Hi “ ii it tS

<I 1; THe i ate Hi ji |

Y es uf ut iu fe iff

oi ae

BG eit ira _

v | aH eye it ist Hg ii yee

a a aa

( H ATF ti HH ite Ri iii ih Ih Hie i ie : F eh

La teal ae em i GM

SA et melts athe Hi Hi it

2 Fe ee aa a

ll sig ea Ha se Ih Hat

.

(4

FOR

SYSTEM

i

Q|

fe

—

Z|

OF

VY

f i fF init

LEATIOE AUR Eur Mere

i Bah: py if

i Mil il i i is ee tet Hi cit : al ite i

pie thy ay? puke a wile

i alin Peery seetiees eth neste batt Whe

Pt Pg a Re i abt

pestentiy ee ithieeile see bay Lt alt tae a ay |

ie Hint ili Shank pat iy Ha tia ini if ie - if

Sr GE Be cn a

en wae elit Honkeah ie ite all i a

iS EB ee RE i it ikea

i [Est ial it at +H ili ue di! Lt | al! Hi at

bat St ME eet A i i Au

i He nie tapped & ! i ii au

Ms ty asa ii} i Wha

itt p. it inal ache liing pune tii! H ne if Bi, i

Ae ii ie iit i ii ii

iit ui irda Nae ae Ui ial if nit bilil lis

470

ae Ty iarey TH

i a i

VW)

ce

hd

Y

O

-_

WY

: its

tie

ah

AUTOMATIC

Hh

ef pls

dditienal Controls Required te Complete the Merceid Stokatherm System

The Merco:d Stokatherm and Pyratherm make up only part of a complete Stokatherm system. Satisfactory

operation can be assured only when the system is Completed by the use of the Mercoid Sensatherm and Mercord

lf ibe

*

hmit controls. These instruments have operating characteristics which coordinate with the operation of the Stoka

therm and provide assurance of positive and satisfactory stoker performance.

na nema Mee ne

i

ty,

i i ii

,

Las ese

ve ty an it fil § Hi ,

i aaa Vy tad tp Fuk

P ray lea DE AG clit iit .

Hi iti ie jgint ST ig

tia Wel ih i :

L i iil isi Hi i

: ‘MERCOID SWITCHES .

1G Bors

and dependable electric

Mercoid hermetically-sealed mercury contact swvtch ss not affected Dy dust. dwt or

The contact is instantaneous and silent * operation. remains permanently

without detenoratior

the Iughty Gesiradte features of the Mercond switch, manu

thew probiems to our Engineenng Department arc

thew yeers of expenence 9 the apobcatron of these switches

pay ke ote = One etectroge termunates 1n 8 p00! ot. Fig , usT

temperature refractory metera! The other ele trode is ‘ ’

Re pty ey tng bye g as the switch is hoped these two pools No. SPECIFICATIONS PRICE

of mercury jon and close the circuit. Even when opersied very siowiy. the contact §=g§7 . 10 Ampere $2.1¢

opens or closes with # positive end instantaneous action as the mercury jorns Or Giwid@S gay 4 Ampere 1.8

The etectric arc is confined to the hip of the temperature refractory cup. so that os! T 23

© deteriarstion can occur wie yee -

ee Cen ae AC. or OC. 10 amp.-110V., 5 amp -270V .-3 amp (7. Clip 051 Switch 2

e ne. 941 | 7-87 Clip fer 6-61 Switch a

7-167 Clip tor 8-81 Switch a

Fig. 041 6 2 mercury to clectrode type switch. Two electrodes and 8 quantty of mercury ‘

| are hermetcaity sealed within the glass switch. By tipping the swrich so that the merc ury

| flows to the ‘contact end, the circus = closed between the electrodes.

ELECTRICAL CAPACITY: Either'A.C or D.C. 4amp.-1ICV.. 2emp -2720V_. . amd. -440¥ Many standerd Mercoid switches

) . me. oe ’ ere evelteble other than these

O8t 6 &@ magnetceily operated mercury contact switch This switch remans " listed ehors. Tor comptete intor-

fate nr postion ana coerafer by mapranc stiracton thw te sac. ii pervculrhy mation, write for Bulletin SODA -

recommended for use with gent. epperstus. automatic scales photo-etec tric

t epparstus, evtomenc vending machines, etc where @ positwe contact s required ©

Dut very Mite ectuehng power available . j :

ELECTRICAL CAPACITY: 9.10 amp at 4 volts o less Or 110 to 220 volts ether AC | Special net prices quoted to manu

oF D.C. the maxitum capacity 5 25 watts ' facturers requiring switches and

I magnet PP 3-148 can be turmehed « with parts Ths clips in quantities.

omplete

«8 of the heghest quettty magnetic stee! and :s of the correct size erating

‘

MOUNTING CLIP MG 24"

the Fig. 0-8! suntch

MERCOID SWITCH LEAD WIRES, CLIPS, ETC.

|

|

4

7

!

!

jeeds are 7 ie long with No 8 ning termenais. Vervous types of feed

wires are eveiiebie and can de furnished ir any ‘lengths deswed. and ether with oF

| without ming termneis . .

The iustratons to the left show seversi standard nickel silver mounting choses Many

| are ayerlable to meet varous requirements

| PATENT NOTICE |

, Meccoid Controls are manutactured and sold under the following patents:

473.120 ' 648.390 ’ 1.757.970 ' en@.603 1,904,378 963.140

| Se Jac eae ana 491,016 782.180 872,070 ' 908.702 985, 708

1 See s7e 657 eB" 087.988 777.88" 881.32) 308.30" ee

1 S?8 ‘288.013 75 ae 186.078 82.813 "915.683 Oy

1561 474 ame a2 723, P56 805 .96r ae2.6)< ' 922. 6ae 97.925

1.612.777 1674081 eens 317.634 8B4.08° 973,680 97h ae

1e146r 674.801 74.015 87.6% oo 923.68) ) 985.940

1.636.161 ema” 17.6 24.61? ' 44 824,670 | 90.852

1 640.800 | 678.e0e 734.01; 78 me ae 928.30, 2.008.198

1 oe aR? 1 ae) an 1.737.080 53428 DES 87.680 ) 934.200 2.015.962

1 642,997 \ m8 26 14.178 \ 28 OFS 96.560 336. ORe 2.018.310

hee OS ead . '752.987 | RSS aaa an a 9a9.9"* 20W3.143

ore ree =) 4 O17 ak)

DOTMERS PENDING ,

Patent Warranty

We will defend any suit or proceeding Drougm against our customer so far as Desed on @ clair fiat ary apparatus. oF any pert

_ ‘erect tureushed by us. constitutes an infringement of any patent of the United States..provided. that the customer causes us

to De nothed promptly in wntng and giver authority, information and assistance, (at our expense). tor the detense of seme.

and we will pay ei! Gameges enc costs awerded there against such customer in any action of «mich sad notice and authority

and information were gwen to us. in case the apperatus or any part thereot isin such suit eid to constitute infringement anc

use 1s @7pOKNed, we will, at Our expense, erther Crocure for the customer Ihe nght to confhinve usng sad-apperstus oF replaces

same with nonuninngene apoereatus, or mod) it so @ Decomes non infringing OF remove sad apperetus ond refund the pur

chase once thereat ‘The foregone states our entire hebility for patert infongement b> smd epparetus oF ‘any pert thereot

Lage

4261

THE MERCOID CORPORATION «

BELMONT AVENUE ¢ CHICAGO, ILLINOIS

ee

<2 Plaintiff's Exhibit 12 Bulletin No. 240

MEK C-O!1D AUTOMATIC CONTROLS

MERCOID STOKER CONTROL TYPE M-61

FOR INTERMITTENTLY FIRING COAL STOKERS—MAINTAINS LOW AND EVEN FIREBED

IMPROVED TYPE—WITH STAINLESS STEEL PROTECTING WELL OVER BI-METAL COIL

THO ms re Nett ve

ally setting both the ‘‘cut-

in” and “‘cut-out’’ oper-

ating temperatures at any

‘point within the instru-

ment’s range. This desir-

able feature permits

quick setting to meet the

variety of conditions en-

countered in stoker in-

stallations.

Another feajure of, de-

cided importance is the

temperature indicator lo-

cated over the dial, which

indicates in degrees Fah-

renheit the temperature

within the stack. Serving

.the same purpose .as a

thermometer, this tem-

perature indicator assists

at time of installation in

determining the proper

size of fire required and

in correctly setting the

, AN f )

Pere rnst~ isst on

The Type M-61 Mercoid

stoker control has many

outstanding features

which improve the effi-

ciency and general oper-

ation of a coal fired

stoker,

This instrument is gen-

erally employed to fire

the stoker intermittently

during the period the

room thermostat is in the

“off’’ position, but may

be used to limit the max-

imum temperature, or _

stop the stoker if the fire

des out. : Sede Viee etmeet Prete tome Molt

- Particular attention is eae a

_ called tothe: dial in the

. center of the instrument

-which is clearly and ac-

curately calibrated from

50 -to 650 F. A simple

- double adjustment. is .

6 0m es§ Degas piwiww. 9 isms. 0.:

Wes Nebr ( ontred

Sede Vieew Niemtmg Ieprraed blama:

wee Marele.. Merl Mrede trae Well

provided for individu- ee controls. 2

IMPROVED MOUNTING: “*

We recommend the use of the improved type

mounting flange and stainless steel well with

sealed end fof enclosing the bi-metal col. This

protects the sensitive bi-metal coil not only from .

deposits of fly ash, but also against corrosive ac-

tion of the stack gases, so that frequent readjust- ~

ments are not required to compensate for change

in the operation of the bi-metal coil. This new

feature can be supplied for instruments now in the

fieid without this protection.

CONTACT |

tacts,—cannot occur with the sealed Mercoid switch |

The contact remains permanenrtiy clean and the free

flowing mercury insures perfect electrical contact at

every operation.

CONSTRUCTION t ot

The 4°," steel case has a black heat resisting finish. the case. A bakelite shieid wid the , ee posts «

The semi-giass Cover is removable by loosening two prevents possibilities of shock while ghranging th

screws. The wiring 1s gimplified by means of 44” control temperature setting. _ * 9 193° ‘

BX connection at bottom, and terminal posts within ,

—

ENCLOSED

The’ Mercond switch with ‘its hermetically sealed

mercury contact 1s ammune to oxdation, dirt or cor-

rosion Burning, pitting and sticking,—sources of

service trouble and expense with open-to-air con-

; Mpls. HOW yp west

> Minmearo.is M

i ie ll ee

See Other Side For Speciicetions end Prices

eas*: sch ASA CORPORATION

frst i

tm

4201 BELMONT Avi

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS

’

473

MERC OID AUTOMATIC CONTROLS

MERCOID STOKER CONTROL TYPE M-61 (Continued)

OPERATION.

The high temperature bi-metal coil which is the nected in

operating element of this. instrument is carefully

heat treated to inswre uniform ;

and reliable operation. As the — -

stack temperature increases Or

decreases this element-revoives —- = : ;

a stainless steel shaft which ro- e . ———— i

tates the inner mechanism thus ~— INS |} ras

operating the Mercoid switch = - ar

and at the same time indicating ee

Sod

—_

—-_€,

the stack temperature on the

graduated dial-A relief spring is

provided which permits the bi- =

metal coil to continue its natural ' a, of

course after the switchhasbeen =.= f=: ss

thrown to the “on” or “oft’”’ 4 ‘|

position, without straining this aA c~

element. 3

When the room thermostat is in

the “‘off” position the stoker fire

gradually dies down, and may

go out unless it 1s intermittently

fired for short periods. As the

fire dies down the stack temper-

ature slowly decreases. When

the type M-61 control is mounted

in the stack, set for a low oper-

ating temperature, approxi-

- mately 115° to 130° F.,;and con-

nected in parallel with, the

thermostat circuit, it operates

the stoker intermittently for

short periods While the thermo-

stat is in the “off” position. This

not only prevents. the fire going

out, but also maintains a‘ low

and. even fire bed. ‘See wiring

diagrams.) —

When the

Sa ELECTRICAL SPECIFICATIONS

Mercoid stoker controls are furnished standard with anormal = Spit Phase...

rating of 10 amperes at 110 voits,.5 amperes at 220 voits

. either A.C. or D.C. They directly handle without the use of .

relay, motors within the following capacities: é motor starti

Repuision-I induction . 1H.P. witha normal rat

Direct Current. 1g HP. 220 voits, either A.

ORDERING DATA.

When ordering

snaps type number

capacity, and type mounting flange des:red. Uniess other- with |

LIST PRICES .

Merco-d Stoker Cunt rot

Type M61, 50° to 650°, plain flange (enthout well) i"

Type M-61, 50° to 650 , inproved flange with sta:niess stee! well

ess ’ SHOPPING GUGHT, APPROXIMATELY 4 fx. 8 0s

Fig. M-61 Mercord Stoker Control 1s con- opération of the stok

series with the thermostat ‘circuit, and set

for a high operating temperature (from 300° to 450

F., depending upon boiler capa-

city and load on system) the

efficiency of the stoker is in-

‘ creased and fuel saved.

When the stoker is firing con-

tinuously due to the thermostat

. calling for heat, the combustion

gases continue to increase 'n

temperature. -After a certain

temperature ‘8 reached, the

boiler is Operating at its max:-

mum capacity and further firing

only increases the stack tem-—

perature with a resultant waste

of fuel. The Mercoid contro!

stopa, the stoker from the in-

crease in stack temperature,

and the boiler continues to ab-

sorb the heat from the glowing

fire bed. When the stack tem-

perature lowers sufficiently the

Mercoid control again starts the

stoker. This operation is re-

— until the thermostat cuts

The Type M-63 Mercoid Stoker

Control is the same as Type:

M-61 except that it breaks the

' circuit on a dropping tempera-

ture. Set to stop the stoker by

opening the circuit when the

temperature drops to a. low

point (approximately 100° F.) it

prevents filling the boiler with

fresh coal when the fire is out.

A snap switch connected around this contro! permits

er while the fire is being started.

i, HP.

Mercoid controls automatically regulate motors of the largest

size when used as a pilot ewitch |

wm connection with the proper

awitch. For this service they can be furnished

of 4 amperes at 110 volts, 2 amperes at

. or D.C., at reduced list prices.

of instrument, electrical wise apecifidd, instruments arefurnished single pole, 10ampere,

type mounting flange and stainless stee! well,

Sngle Trew.

10 Ame a 4 Amo

"$16.00 $14.50

| ~ 30.00 . | 18.50

THE MERCOID: CORPORATION

4201 BELMONT AVE

WV CHICAGO, ILLINOIS

corvaten? ass, Ts weace'o cparonat on curcaee, He eaimtso mu 8 4.

Plaintiff's Exhibit 14°

oe Nov, 1433

|

—————————

NOTE THE MANY FEATURES OF THE

MERCOID

M-61 STOKER CONTROL

FOR INTERMITTENT FIRING OF COAL STOKERS

TO MAINTAIN | A LOW AND EVEN FIRE-BED

The dial in cefiter is cali-

brated from 50 to 650 degrees

F. Has simple double adjust-

ment for setting both the

_.Cut-in and cut-out operating

; temperatures to meet any con-.

dition encountered in the

stoker field.

Has temperature indicator

__ which indicates tie tempera-

ture within the stacx to de-

and facilitating correct‘ con-

trol adj

switch is immune to oxidation,

; - dirt, pitting or corrosion, there-

Type M61 fore insures perfect electrical

contact at every operation.

Available with an improved mounting flange and stainiess steel!

well with sealed end to protect the sensitive bi-metal coil from

fly ash and corrqsive gases.

FURTHER INFORMATION CONTAINED IN BULLETIN Ne 840

W vee de net hove the complete Mercetd Stoke Contre! Cateleg write ter ot eave

iat MERCOID: CORPORATION |

Sele Manelecturers of The Merceid Switch

4241 Belmont Avenue - ° Chicago, Illinois

termine the right size of fire ©

a a a —

The sealed mercury contact ||

e ae.

_attach fla

INSTALLATION

Plaintiff's Exhibit 15

475

INSTRUCTIONS

MERCOID STOKER CONTROLS

TYPES M-61, M-62, M-63

Penente tnned. 15.521, 1.5984 + 1,640,069, 1,705,909, 1,759,057, 1.757.436, Others Pending

IMPORTANT—NOTE a

After removing ail packing material, note tag warn-

ing not to twist the bi-metallic element. To do so

may distort the metal and disarrange the adjustment

which is correctly made at the factory: The Mercoid

switch is wired in place to protect it during shipment.

This wire must be removed after instrument is

installed.

MOUNTING

_ Carefully determine the location of the instrument

it is usually placed about two feet from the furnace,

on the most convenient side of the stack. The cor-

rect location, however, depends upon the operating

characteristics of the boiler. If the stack tempera-—

tures are high this instrument must be located at a

greater distance ~ ce :

from the boiler:

A location should:

be decided on

where the maxi-

mum stack tem-

perature will not

exceed 650° F.,

and where the

instrument will

not. be covered

with fly ash. If

located close to

the furnace, the

temperature

changes ‘occur

quickly and the

resulting fre-

quent operations -

re objection- : .

. If this contro! is located between the check

and chimney, the check must not be operated,

air admitted quickly cools the instrument

and causes unnecessary operations.

Cut a 15%” hole directly on.the side of the stack so

that the stem of the instrument wil! be horizontal

when mounted. Insert the stainless steel well and

to stack by means of four screws

provided. Insert the instrument bi-metai coil into

= stainiess steel

protecting well

. as far as it will

go, then back

out '4” and se-

curely fasten

instrument in-

to flange by

tightening set

screw. > 4

Before tighten-

ing set screw,

see that the in-

strument is

level and also

** cally. This may

be determined by separating the “high” and “low”

1M—Sept. 1987

_ bined up verti-..

COPTENSHT 192). THE BERESIS CORPORATION. EHICAES. 1L4.. PRINTED Im U8 4

adjustable pointers ,“C” and ‘‘D”, «illustration 1,

until they hold the switch kicking plates away from

the switch tripping arm “E.”” The switch must move

freely from left to right without interference of the

. kicking plates. If the switch remains at either the

right or left after tilting with the finger, the instru-

ment is ready to be fastened by tightening lock nut

ADJUSTMENT

Fhe instrument can 2 H |

now be adjusted to the - J

desired operating

point. When setting .

the cut-in and cut-out,

points, hold the rat-

chet wheel firmly. with

on flange.”

the high or lov

pointer; see illustra-

tion 2. When press-.

ing pointers see that .

the catch between the teeth of the ratchet whee! 's

TMasirange J

. disengaged, as shown in “I,” illustration 3.

‘CAUTIONS

At no time should the instrument be’ subjected to

more than 800 degrees Fahrenheit. If subjected to -

higher ‘temperatures the calibration of the instru-

ment will change and cause unsatisfactory operation

The instrument leaves the factory with the. bi-

metallic element properly formed, heat-treated, sta-

bilized and: calibrated. Should the temperature

reading be in error due to an accidentally twisted bi-

metallic element, if not excessively twisted it may

be readjusted by allowing the instrument to reach

room temperature, loosening the nut in the center

-of the dial and moving dial until correct reading is

obtained, after which the nut should be tightened.

Any manual twisting or bending of the element may

permanently distort it. Not only will this cestroy the

correct calibration of the instrument but also the

accurate performance after adjustment is made. in

‘ case the bi-metallic element is badly distorted a new

element should be ordered for replacement. in

ordering element the serial number of the instru-

ment should be supplied.

DO NOT OIL ANY BEARINGS.

WIRING

" Remove insulating plate indicated

‘as “F” in illustration 2, by remov-.

ing screw located in center of piate.

| Scrape and clean the wires and

carefully place arourd the terminal

screws, and in the groove provided

(see illustration 4). After wiring,

? fasten insulating plate back in

position. Be sure the connected load is not in excess

of the controls rating as shown on the name plate.

Fuses instatied in the line should not exceed 10

amperes at 110 volts or 5 amperes at. 220 voits.

Form P9O

/dustretson 4

$

476 = =——_—s~laintiff's Exhibit 16

HEREIN LIES

_THE SOLUTION

OF YOUR

STOKER

CONTROL

PROBLEMS

‘MERCOID STOKATHERM

TYPE JMV

This control introduces a new and greatly improved

system of complete stoker regulation. it is @ departure

trom present day methods of depena:ng entirety on the

operation of the stoker at definite timed intervais, or at

fixed stack temperatures. » The firing periods of the

STOKATHERM are directly responsive to the som-

bustior condition and are sutomatically reguisted to

meet the veriabie conditions encountered on each

installation. Ths procedure 18.8 More direct approach

to correct stokher performance, with the result thet

- overheating is greatly curtaiied. e The STOKATHERM

Operates the stoher for only the shortest periods neces-

tery to maintain @ minimum fire while the thermostat

is in the ‘off’ position. Consequently, there is siso

. Saving in fuel consumption.« The out-fire feature of this

contro! ‘is important, because it guards egainst the

possibility of filling combustion chamber with unburned

fuel after fire hes gone out oF opprating an empty stoher

Nete With the advent of the die-teed steve. this

Gut-fire control feature becomes “doubly importent

- Write for bultetin No. 948-x

Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 17. 477

- 880 PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 17.

(Letterhead of The Mercoid Corporation, Chicas.) |

To Solve the Stoker Control Problem.

Controlling the pi 4 during the fire maintaining.

periods has been a vexing problem which for years has

kept the best minds in the industry working feverishly for

a solution. — ite ea

’ The enclosed extremely interésting report of the An-

thracite Institute Laboratory ow the Mercoid Type JALV

Stokatherm is submitted for your information. We call

to your attention that this same control is now available

for bituminous as well as anthracite stokers, Z

It is our suggestion that you carefully read the enelosed

Stokatherm bulletin. It will mean dollars and cents sav-

ings and freedom from-service; permitting the dealer io

devote his time to making new sales. instead of servicing

existing installations.

The Type JMV‘Stokatherm is the one stoker control .

thatJs an intelligent answer to the outfire problei,— -.

Where the outfire feature is’not a probleuthe Merceid

Stok-A-Timer may ‘be employed. This control has special

features not found in the conventional type of stoker timer.

Detailed information on the Stok-A-Timer is going to the

printer and will be ready for distribution shortly.

Both the Type JMV Stokatherm and the Mereoid Stok-

A-Timer are equipped with the proven Mercoid Repulsion .

ype Relay, which-provides its own low voltage to the.

therniostat’ circuit. No external transformer connections

are required. . ‘ . Be

__. For an ideal control arrangement equip your stoker with .

Mercoid mercury contact controls throughout. The Mer-

coid Sensatherm provides sensitive regulation of room

temperature while Mercoid Boiler Limit Controls insure

dependabilty over long periods of time. .

The Mereoid Corporation

- J. W. Owens,

JWO:V Vice President.

: ‘August 7, 1986.-, °°

9 ’

478

\ $81 PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 18.7 4

ee

Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 18.

é

No. 2192

; Anthracite Institute Laboratory. |

Mercoid Stokaherm: Tyj pe JMV.

Mfr. : Mercoid Corporation, “4: 201 Belmont Ave, Chi-

“eago, Tl.

Description: ‘All automatic stokers ‘of the on and off

type should be equipped With some ‘device for maintaining

a fire when the thermostat is not calling for heat. ‘If such

controls are not provided, it is obvious that in the spring

and fall and at other periods when heat is not required

over prolonged. intervals, the fire will become: extinguished

through lack of fuel.

It has been customary to use-either a’ simple time switch

operating for a certain number of minutes in each hour,

or a temperature switch in the stack to perform the above

operation. The Mercoid Stokatherm is a tmit employing

a combination of time and temperature to contfol tbe fire.

In addition it includes a feature designed to automatically

stop the ‘stoker in ‘case the fire’ is: accidentally extin-

guished. kd ; aes

_ Resultgof Tests : Tests in the Anthracite Institate

Laboratory indicated*that the Stokatherm was very satis-

factory. It'was shown to be capable of maintaining a fire

by operating a standard stoker between 16% and 14% of

the time. Tis is sufficiently low to represent economy and

a

to prevent heat from reac hing the living quarters. The -

ordinary time switch can be set fora lower interval but

the Stokatherm possesses the additional - advantage «of

automatically adapting itself to draft’ conditions and.

types of fuel, thus it should require less field adjustment

and resetting than either the simple time switeh or'straight

stack temperature controls, The out-fire control. also pre-

vents waste and inconvenie nee-in case the fire — ix extin-

guished,

Aa Plaintif’s Exhibit ‘No. 18. 479

- Data and Specifications,

Control” ‘Tenttees -—Transformer, ‘Relay, Hold-fire

Control, Out-Fire Control. Sao

_ Type of Switches :-Mercury Tube. ,

Thermostat Capacity :—24 Volts, 0.42 Amps.

Stoker Capacity —] H. A Repulsion Induction, $ H. P.

Split Phase.

Electrical C apacity 10 Amp., 110 Volts—5 Amps., 220

Volts, 60, 50, or 25 Cyele.

Dimensions: :

Mechanism Case—4 x 3X 64 inches.

Overall Length—14}3 inches, x

' Distance. Extended from stack—9 to 114 inches.

‘List Price: —2 _— (subject to Muscounts).

~

Pd

Ais]

: ~~ aaenatemmmsamammmmteiemmmms

atiff’s Exhibit 19 a

* MERCOID *

STOKATHERM

REGISTERED TRACE MARK

T % ryt

So ad NA \

AN

OUTSTANDING

STOKER

CONTROL

} »N EASY TO idS TAL

THE MERCO!D CORPORATION - 4

¢ NCREAS SED ECON( MY TO THE USER

201 BELMONT AVENUE - CHICAGO, ILLINOIS

INSTALLATION INSTRUCTIONS

INSTALLING TYPE JMV STOKATHERM—Choose

the location with care. The usual location is about two

feet from the furnace, on the most convenient side of

the stack. :

Cut a 18* hole directly on the side of the stack so that

the instrument stem :s.horizontal. wt.en mounted. Fasten

the flagne sound the hole ae onset ihe sty SU Yrart

two mings “M" (see illustration No 2) on the extension

sieeve. are visible :

BE SURE THE INSTRUMENT IS LEVEL, before tight

ening the flange set screw

WIRING--Check nameplate on.Stokather : and see that

cycle: and voltage correspond ‘with the current used

Be sure the conoected joad is within the motor rating

of the control. Wire 19 accordance with diagrams in

the cover. or if special hook-ups are desired, then in

accordance with diagrams shown on back page

Do not attempt to. make any externa! transformer con."

nections in the Sensatherm circuit as the Merco'd Trans-

former Reiay induces its own low voltage

RIGID CONDUIT MUST NOT BE ATTACHED DtI-

RECTLY TO STOKATHERM OR BOILER LIMIT CON.

TROLS. Use @ short strip (6 or 8 in.) of BX cable between

- contro! and condutt. If ngid conduit comnections are

made. expansion and contraction strains are very apt

to break contro! comnection at boiler

Careless terminal connections are often responsible

for service trouble. Scrape and clean wire and carefully

piace around terminal ‘screw in. the

direction the screw.turnms (See ‘illus

tration No. 6.) :

Use two-wire armored low voltage

cable between the Mercord Sensa

therm and the thermostat terminals

of the relay: Bring the low voltage

cabie through the brass bushing

(see itlustration No 4) and. securely

/dustresen No 6

‘the limits of the primary adjustment

. attach wires to the terminals marked “Thermostat” Pull

out excess cable and firmly clamp cable in bushing

“K" by means of screw provided

ADJUSTMENTS

This control is provided with adjustments to vary the

interval betwaen fire maintaining operations and also

.the time of operation. ,

INTERVAL ADJUSTMENT—This adjustment sets the

period between fire-maintaining operations. Lever “F"’

is adjustable over a dia! calibrated from 10 to 70 minutes

in 5 mihute intervals

FIRE MAINTAINING PERIOD ADJUSTMENT—While

the Stokatherm changes its fire maintaining period auto-

matically to meet vary:ng fire conditions, adrustments

are provided, however,.to change the periods of opera-

tion needed fo maintain a minimum fire on variaus types

of heating piants.

The mounting flange is provided with a metal sieeve

within which the posjon of the bimeta! coil may be

adjusted (See illustrafion 2). This is the primary adjust-

ment for the fire maibtaining period. If the bimetal -coi-

is placed completely wxthin the meta! sieeve “H" the fire-

maintaining periad will maximum. tf completely ex-

the period will be minimum For convenience

hree rings "M" are cut on the mounting stern to indicate

the position of the bimeta! coi! within the metal sleeve

A secondary adjustment ‘R" is provided for increas-

ing or decreasing the fire maintaining period. beyond

: ‘mM’. This adjust:

ment is set at the factory and should not be changed

except to meet abnormal field conditions. Moving to the

right increases the fuel feeding period during fhe fire

maintaining operation : ° ‘

An additional adjustment “L'’ is provided to meet

fuctuating stack temperature conditions Moving this

adjustment: to the left prevents shut-down which

might occur on instailations where fluctuation of stack

temperature occurs during normai thermostat operation

This adjustment is set at the factory and uSually. does

not have to be charged

483

CONSTRUCTION DETAILS OF TYPE JMV STOKATHERM

The Type JM-V Stokatherm isacampact star k-meounted

unit, combining a Tamer Mechanism, the Mer: ned Trans:

former Relay, and a Temperature-Act ated Mechanism

This instrument has been designed to provide fully

automatic regulation of ‘coal, stoker, The important

__ features of the various parts of this control are as follows:

‘

MERCOID TRANSFORMER-RELAY- The Mercoid

Transtormer-Relay incorporated in this control 's @ very’

simple and compact device, which 15 '" principle a low

voltage transformer but also operates as a repulsion-

relay.

Two independent ifsulated coils are mounted on

laminated iron yoke. The primary coils fixed in position

and is connected across: the high’ voltage line The’

secondary coil is movable and is connected to the low-

voltage thermostat circuit. These two coils act as a trans-

former and low voltage is induced in the secondary col

when the primary coil is energized. When the iow voltage

thermostat circuit is closed, the secondary coil instantly

moves upward, due to the repulsion action of the coils,

and starts the- stoker by closing the motor. switch Cif:

cuit “A™. é 2 i

As this transformer relay does not employ the conven-

tional clapper type ifon armature, rattling noses due to

uneven, dirty or custy armature faces, cannot occur

Furthermore, there can be no residual! magnetism to

affect the operation, as there are no metal contacting

. » °

TIMER—The timer is actuated by a positive self-startng

Waltham sypchronaus meter movement of the highest

quality, with heavy cut brass wheels: having pimons of

hardened and polished tool steel. és

TEMPERATURE ACTUATED MECHANISM. The tem:

perature actuated mechanism responds to changes 'n -

stack temperature and, by means of a mechanical inter-

lock. controls the starting of the timer interval penod.

After this period has elapsed, the stoker starts operating

to maintain the fire and the length of operation 'S gov-

-erned also by the temperature actuated mechanism.

The temperature actuated mechanism “J” of the Type

JMV Stokatherm is radically, different from conventional

stoker stack controls. It does not operate at predeter-

mined nigh and low temperature settings. but operates

only on a differential or change in temperature Operat-

ing by means of a unique ratchet assembly on a dif-

ferential in temperature, this instrument differs from

conventional stoker stack controls, in that it continually

readjusts itself, regardless of changes or “sets” in the

bimetai coil, due to excessive temperatures or corrosive

tlue gases

MERCOID MERCURY SWITCHES—Mercoid mercury

contact, switches are used thruout. These switches, with |

thei hermetically sealed mercury contacts, are immune ~

to oxidation, dirt or corrosion. Burning, pitting and stick-

‘ing—sources of service trouble and expense with open-

to-air contacts—cannot occur with the sealed ‘Mercaid

switch. The contact remains permanently clean and the

tree flowing mercury insures perfect electrical contact

at every operation. os ,

OPERATION OF TYPE JMV STOKATHERM

in order to clarify the description of operation of the

_Mercoid Type JMV Stokatherm, we are assuming normal

conditions as encountered with the average domestic .

stoker. Linder such conditions, the normal setting of the

time interval adjustment “F" 1s 45 minutes. -

SENSATHERM CALLING FOR HEAT—At the time the

Sensatherm calls for heat the Stokatherm mechanism

may be at any point in its cycle of maintainiag the tire

The Sensatherm, however, immediately, takeg command

and operates the stoker. Relay cor! “B" FSes/and in turn

closes motor switch "A", As the fire bu p the stack

temperature rises, and the temperature actuated mech.

anism disengages the timer and returns it to its normal

- starting position =No strain 's placed on the dimeta! coil

as the temperature continues to mse, as free movement

is permitted thru the ratchet mechanism.

FIRE MAINTAINING. When the Sensatherm opens its

circuit due to the room's being at the required temper-

ature, the Mercoid Fziay “B" instantly opens its circuit

and stops the stoker The fire now starts dying down

and the stack temperature decreases accordingly. As-

this decrease in stack temperature occurs, the ‘temper:

ature actuated mechanism "J" engages the interval

timer and within the period as set by adjustment F’.

which we have’ assumed at 45 minutes, switch “<C"

closes its circuit and operates the relay, which, in turn

starts the stoker.

UNDER NO CIRCUMSTANCES, CAN ‘THE STOKER

OPERATE TO MAINTAIN THE FIRE, IN LESS THAN

45 MINUTES (ASSUMED SETTING) AFTER THE THER:

MOSTAT SHUTS OFF. DURING THIS 45 MINUTE

DELAY PERIOD, THE STACK TEMPERATURE CON.

TINUES TO DECREASE. On the average installation con: .

siderable drop in stack temperature occurs during this

_first 45 minute delay period, and the temperature ac-

tuated mechanism accordingly follows this change. To

maintain the fire the stoker operates only until @ rise 'n

stack temperature occurs. THE CONDITION OF THE

STOKER FIRE IS ACCURATELY. INDICATED BY THE

RATE AT WHICH THE STACK TEMPERATURE RISES

The firing periods are not at definitely timed intervals

-or at fixed stack temperatures, but are automatically

regulated by this control.

_ The stoker continues to operate intermittently for only

the very shortest periods necessary to maintain the fire

during the time the thermostat is in the off position

This not only results in a very decided saving 1m tuel,

but also insures against overheating

OUT-FIRE OPERATION--Shouild thé@tuel becori¢ “ex;

hausted, or the fire go out, the stack temperature lowers,

causing the temperature’actuated mechanism to engage

the interval timer. Even though the thermostat is in the

“on pesition calling for heat, the Stokatnerm mechanism

operates, and after the out-fire penod (factory setting

6 minutes) has elapsed, switch "G" opens its circuit

“and stops the stoker. When the fire has been rekindled

the stoker may start due to the rise in stack temperature,

or may be restarted by pressing hand reset button eS

in 2

—

.

454

OPERATING . -INSTRUCTIONS

perating with

following adjustment

On the average domestic heating plant

Ace grade ¢ the

are isually bead

1 Hermetal Aral

(2 sings M

_ Interval adjustment —

"3. Secondary adjustments

from: factory setting -

iF THE FIRE HAS GONE OUT WITH FUEL IN THE

HOPPER, causing out-fire shutdown at the controi, this

iS due either to the interval adjustment ‘'F’’ /foeing set

too long or to the fire-ma:ntarning period being too short

This condition can be overceme either by Decreasing

the timer interval adjustment or by increasing the fire-

Nnaintaining period .

Extreme changes in.tnese adjustments should not be

trber al

nserted teall way witha metal sleeve

sleeve exposed)

set at 45 ‘minutes

R" and “L"—no change

made immediately We recommend proceeding astoliows .

1. Change time interval adjustment “F’ from 45 min-

utes to 3 minutes Caution: Do not.decrease beyond

this pornt unless al! following instructions have been

followed or overheating 1s apt to occur

t outfire agar occurs move bimeta!l coi! '9” further

within protecting sieeve “H' (2g rings exposed)

3 i* conditions of instailation are such that sufficient

- fire.maintaiping period 1s not now provided move

bimetai coil entirely within: metal si€eve “H (3°

rings exposed)

4. The adove adjustments wil! take care of all except

very abnormal operating conditions, in which case

‘move adjustment “R™ to the right

OVERHEATING DURING FIRE MA'NTAINING

PERICO—If overheating occurs this can be overcome.

either by increasing the time interval adjustment or by

decreasing the tire-maintaining perfod To accomplish

this proceed ‘as above except reverse al! instructions

IF CONTROL HAS SHUT DOWN ON OUTHFIRE, BUT

FIRE HAS NOT CONC OUT, this 1s uSualiy caused by a

drop in stack temperature ——— Guring period the

thermostat is operating the stoker This condition does

not occur with anthracite stokers tut with bituminous

‘stokers 1s generally due to one of the following reasons

1 COKING COALS forming pyramids which allow free

passage of air thru the fuel-bed

2. IMPROPER CARE OF FUEL-BED resulting in an ex-

cessive amount of clinkers and-an uneven ‘we hec

which allows tree passage of air,

‘extreme left

-

3. COALS THAT ARE HARD TO IGNITE—If green ‘coal

entering the combustion chamber does not ignite

readily, the existing fire will be pushed to the side

and cout au can then treely pass thru the green coal,

Adjustment “Ll 1s provided to take care of tluctuations

in.stack temperature encountered on the average in-

stallation. If above conditions exisi this adjustment should

be pushed to the. left. It must be rememberea, however.

that this Control will not fully take care of extreme condi:-

tions such as. above. and t some other means. must

be employed to overcome them.

After the control has shut down on out-fire. should a

good fire-bed be re-established and a rise in stack tem-

perature occur, the control wiil autamatically reset and

resume operation of the stoker.

"NOTES FOR SERVICE MEN

+. If the stoker has stopped due to fire's gorng out.

rekindle fuel and start stoker by closing ef ge circuit

and pushing reset button “‘D" (Illustration No. 4

2. When kindling a fire an abnormally high stack tem- :

perature generally accurs, which drops off after a sho

period of operation. The large drop in stack tempera

iS apt to put the timing mechanism in Operation, an

after a period of time the contro! would assume an out-

fire position. Before leaving the installation, stop the -

stoker by opening the main switch and. after a delay of

not less than 5 minutes. push reset button ‘‘D” and then

close the main switch. The control will now be ny its

- normal running position

3: Tube “C"' ts fire-maintaining switch. “This switch ts

" parallel with the thermostat, and when it is in the

on” position the stoker operates. This switch is closed

only By the timer motor. .

4 Tube 'G" 1s out-fire switch. When this switch is in

. the off’ position, the stoker cannot operate. This switch

is set at the factory to open its circuit within SO minutes.

This adjustment cannot be changed.

5. Tube “A™ is miulur switci:.

« 6 When the thermostat calis for eat it immediately

takes command of the stoker operation. .

7? When coal is used which leaves a heavy soot deposit

in the stack, the bimetal coil should be cleaned at

regular intervals

8 Overheating may occur if secondary adjustment

“R™ 1s: moved to extreme ght. SS

9 Outfire may occur « secondary “L” is moved €

CAUTION HAVE YOU READ DESCRIPTION OF OPERATION AND INSTRUCTIONS CAERFULLY? KEEP INSTRUMENT COVERS CLOSED oo

NOT OF. ANY PARTS DO NOT OVERLOAD ~ See electric rating on neamepiete DO NOT ATTEMPT TO DISCONNECT OR CHANGE ANY PARTS

ae WIRING DIAGRAMS es i

MERCOID wmeacere steasreen \ weteces merece

| Lom WATER oo RELAY TYPE ves: gy vee wmreee stow atatas

St esatec ee _ t oY

( ED) ea > =)

} ; rere = d

=== 5} unt Oe A a

} acai (ow wares

| Cc - SMusaretan (Fon _ Ly = m8) Let

SS =

Vo eepee- 4

femme |? owe pe fF

a 1EDG:

¥ _f} ne = wre

| wean vow ware

/ j “ drerssen:

fomua(t Te

= 5 : ctt

| ‘ z erence a: & S'tan senes ; = ;

en mores 7 an :

pate ea oes |, Eras SF Bie SSA

’ 1 fam Cam ST waten c

a ma

at

Om

’

. :

1 eee weer

yfrors Bot tae AmD SYOnn WO

Plaintiff's Exhibit 20

GENERAL APPLICA S

485.

AND WIRING DIAGRAMS

Diegrem No. 3

room is up te temperature and the Sensatherm has the retay in the “off”

pogit:0%. Thie-net enty prevents the fire from goihg out, but also marnta:as

a low and even five bed. «

DIAGRAM Ne. 2 shows the hook-up when large stoker motors are om-

ployed which require the use of aittomatic motor starters. Tare same hook -

up applies ale when two or three phase motors of any Sze are employed:

.

The motor starts: affords protection aga:net over-load of singie phasing

Type M-61 steker contro! functions the same as in diagram No. |

DIAGRAM No. 3 is identical to diagram No. | with the exception that «

due! Sensatherm is employed with an siectric Time Switch Relay and af-

fords DAY and ‘NIGHT temperature control. Al a pre-determined Nour in

the evening the clock transfers the room temperature control from the day

setting to the might setting of the Dual Sensatherm. A tower room temper-

ature 1s then maintained until the pre-determined set time in the morning

when the clock again transfers the contro! to the day setting of the Sensa-

therm. Type M-61 stoker control functions to maintain the fre regardiess

of whether the Quel Sensatherm is operating on its day of mght sett.ng

—- -_—_-—_—__- +

a

| —_aew =

—a mae

= we

Pr es: yo

i}

l wre took: f

von :

d 2 Bees |

ig

g~ aus

i me

; -~

! ; -_ care

; oe

hs ae i,

Lh i ; os om

ERE bene H 4

: |

aes, See 4

Dragrem No. 4 !

aie

DIAGRAM Ne. 4 shows the hook-up where DAY and N!GHT temperature

contro! 1s desired in connection with stokers employing large motors or

motors operating on two or three phase current. The controls operate in”

the same manner 0s explained under diagram No. 3, and the motor starter

provides ever-load ard engre phasd protection.

DIAGRAM Ne. 5 shows the hook-up fur large stoker inetaiiations where &

thermestat contrete the room temperature éuring the day, but at mht

when the fire 1 banked an electric time ewiteh opens the thermostat cir-

evit: Phe M-61 steker contro! then prevents the fire going out until early

morning when the time ewiteh agen pisces the thermostat in control.

Thos circuit hook-up applies on jobs where controis were orginally netatied

as per diagram Ne. 2 and the time ewiteh feature added at & later date.

On new installations where this hook-up is desired the time switch and

tranatormer-reiay can be furnished in a combination unit (Type V2-3-116).

DIAGRAM No. 6 shows the application of Type 'A-6! stoker control on

instatiations where high stack temperatures are encountered. jnstrument.

No. 1 intermittently fires the stoker during the periods the room 13 up to

temperature and the Sensatherm has. the retay othe “off’ poston

Instrument Ne. 218 connected in series with the relay, and when set for «

migh operating temperature (350 to 500°F., depending upon borer capacity

and ioad on system) increases the efficiency of the stoker and conserves

“fuel. When the stoker is firing continuously due to the Sensatherm calling

for heat, the, stack temperature continues to increase. After @ certain

temperature it reazted, the boiler is operating af its maximum Capacity

a an firing only increases the stack t ature. The Mercod

rol (No. 2) limite the stack temperature by stopping the stoker and

id conserves fuel. When the stack temperature towers sufficiently the

pod centro! again starts the stoker, and tts operation is repeated

the Seneatherm opens ite circuit.

4201 BELMONT AVE.'

CHICAGO, ILLINOIS

THE MERCOID CORPORATION ~.

A&S6

‘Plaintiff's Exhibit 21

MERCOID IMMERSION TYPE BOILER CONTROLS

Mercoid Immersion Type Controls have proven by their

unfailing accuracy and durability, over years of service, to be

the correct type of automatic limiting device for contral of motor

driven units on Kot water borler installations and vapor vacuum

heating systems

There is no lag in fhe operation

of these controls such as is en-

countered with controls mounted |

on the outside of the boiler or

risers. The brass bu!b is instalied

directly in the bo:vler water and

the volatile liquid charging

quickly and accurately fol

temperature changes

These contro!s are equipped

with a snap action movement in-

suring positive operation of the

Mercoid switch when the water

reaches the temperature for

which ‘the contro! 's set

APPLICATIONS

HOT .WATER BOILERS —As a safety

limiting device. Fig 36 or 37 with range

No. 2 18 recommended.

INDIRECT WATER HEATERS ON STEAM BOILERS — To

supply domestic hot water from a steam boiler the contro!

must operate the burner during the no heat epagiu when the

“thermostat is shut off, and to

_ hold the boiler temperature

ust below the steaming point.

ig. 37 with range No 2

mounted on side of steam

boiler below water line gives

excellent results. This instru-

- ment witli withstand 250° F. (15

Ibs. steam pressure) without

“imypury

VAPOR-VACUUM BOILERS

The temperature

of the water in a

borier changes

according to Fig 37

changes of pressure or vacuum. The Fig. 37 Mercoid control

range No. 3 when instalied on the side of a Vapor-Vacuum

borer below the water line, wil! give very positive regulation

and overcome troubles due to loss-of vacuum. When eet low

this contro! will cut out at 214° (10 of pressure) and will

cut in at 200° (6° vacuum), but can be set to cut out as high

as 226° (444 Ibs. pressuse) and cut in at 214° (10 oz. pressure)

HOT WATER STORAGE TANKS —As a LIST PRICES ,

reguiating instrument, Fig. 36 or 37 is Fig 36 Ranges No. 1 and 2, Single pole, 10 amp. . $18.00

recommended with either range No 1 or No 2 depending | Fig. 37. Ranges No. 1 and 2, Single pole, 10 amo, 20.00

on temperature desired. Fig. 37--Range No. 3, Single pole, 10 amp 22.08

FIG & ANO 37 RANGE AND AQUUSTMENT OatTa

OPERATION e

> tre ca — ee... Se

Cw-te Cut Ow =, Cut-te Cw-Ouw Cw-tn CA -Ow

° _ Tere Tere tore Tore a —

No | 10 to 160° . 30 105 1 425 145 145 160.

No 2 * 140 to 214° 49 "2 140 165 , 178 190 200 214

No 3 200° to 226° 12 200 214 207 720 - 26 226

MERCOID CONTROLS —FURNACE, STOKER, ETC.

" FIG. 46 MERCOID LEVER CONTROL

TYPE M-53 WARM AIR FAN CONTROL

This cnstrument has a simple doubie

adjustment for both “high and “tow

Operating temperatures

The temperature indicator located

over the dia! serves the same purpose

as ihe thersmometer pn a hot water

Dorler .

The Gia! located i the canter of this

Can be quick!y mounted to any fu

nace hood as the new flange is ad; ust

able between 36 and 90 degrees

Etectrical Rating 16 amp -110 voit

5 amp -220 voit

DEALERS’ SPECIAL MET PRICE .

Chvesee F O 8 New You West Coast

$6.50 $6.75 $7.00

CONdit:0Ns encountered :/n stoker install-

mMeruMment ¢ calibrated from SO ‘a

“Lest prices singie pole $16.68

TYPE M-61 STOKER CONTROL

Tne Type M-61 Merced Stoker

Contro! has many outstanding feateres ~ Z

it 18 Sturdely constructéd ard nas the ad-

vantage of a semple double adjustment

for both “high and “low operating

temperatures. to meet the variety of

ations Range adjustable from 50 to

Aw F

The temperatura indicator iqcated | -

over the dal sérves the same purpose

as a thermometer and will ass:st at the

time instaiiation is made in deterrmmn-

ong the proper size of fre requ:red and

in correctiy setting the controls

The efficrency and genera! operation

of a stoker wl! be -mproved hy the use of

the T ype M-61 Merco:d Stoker Contro!

When its contro! is mounted in the stack. set for a low operating

temperature. approximately 115 to-130 .F. and connected in paraiie!

with the thermosta! circuit, jt wil! operate the stoker intermittently for

short periods at a time. when the thermostat is in

lip Mal

The Fig 46 Mercond Lever Contro! opens and closes

the circurt Dy Means of mecharical n.cvement of the

lever arm

Recommended where close regulation # desired on

vapor heating systems that are equipped with d.aphragm

re regulators

Etectrical Rating «= 10 amp -110 volt ery x volt

Motur Rating =| HP -Ind HP "

HP Soirt Prase

Ordering Data Soecity whethe mounting f ange

required af top 6, botiom Whether lever arm requ. red

at left of ght sds of case Whether circu:t +s to close

with lever i" up Of down postion

List price F $is.e8 Fie :

the “of position This wil! not oniy prevent: the fire

from going out. Dut wil! also maintain a tow and eves

fire bed

Erectricat Rat 10 amp -110 volt 5 amp -220 voit

List price. Single $16 00

DEALERS’ SPECIAL NET PRICE

Chicege FO 8 New You West Coon

$6.50 $6.75 $7.00

Cor rote Weer om (ht Bayt are Overet by _ 'S' 6m

| 908 Oe! SAO aes |) Gea tim Oak Ov) 1 aT Oe? 7

Ord 1. 7EROre Y PR WS" | 757 406 | O17 GO | Be 288 others perniny

Tre rg™ be wee fer Gomente of wxhustrie! Resting me o nwre

fytte™ covered by Patent No 1471) « grand only eran Mero

reset & tow wate cortrets ere vest © conne tor Mhreree th

ewrera ~ a.

S10 a LN ODF

LVW OTe

lODy4 NI

CN

N

=

a

<=

at

td

#”

maigre es

—

nee

. bd

=

a.

STOMINOD GIOIHIW 40 JWOH

BU |

Are recommended for all

types of heating equipment .

automatic heat practical ly fool-proof and

within the reach of every home. Avail

~ yourself of this greatest of all modern

conveniences. ;

Automatic heating equipment is no. .

better than the controls that govern: it.

When you specify Mercoid Controls you

may be assured that you will get the

best that money can buy,

LT TO EN D

MERCOID sti

~ CONTROLS

Mercoid Céttroks may be termed

custom-built instruments. All Mercoid

Controls are subjected to rigid tests and

inspection for. proper material, exact

workmanship and positive operation.

Each control has its individual - serial

number for identification. Mercoid Con-

‘trols must be right, far they are built right.

The ‘Mercoid Sensatherm. illustrated

herewith, is acclaimed the most sensitive

thermostat upon the market. It maintains |

an even room temperature within one

degree at all times without the aid of

any internal heater coils or artificial

stimulation.

The Sensatherm is neat, small and

beautiful in. appearance. It will grace

fhe wall of any home. !t harmonizes

with any scheme of interior decoration.

LER E

i]

Apart from appearance, it is performance

that counts, and in this respect it is un-

excelled. The Sensatherm is the modern

thermostat for. accurate and reliable

room femperature controi.

All switches in Mercoid Controls are

of the sealed mercury contact type. They

cannot be affected by duit, dirt or cor:

rosive gases and will operate indefi-

nitely without deterioration.

\\|. + In order that you may be assured of

getting the best results from your auto-

matic heating equipment, insist upon —

MERCOID>

CONTROLS |

USED THE WORLD OVER

oe : : =

Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 23. 2 489

&

890 ”-~ PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 23.

(Letterhead of The Mercoid Corporation, Chicago.).

January 22, 1934.

Mercoid Controls—Manufacturers’ Schedule.« |

Revised price-sheet-(A-51 } applying to Mereoid Controls

is enclosed herewith—

when Type H Sensatherm and Type V Relay: are ordered

in combination— :

‘Thermostat, as well as new intermediate schedule (10 to

24) which affords a reduction on ail controls illustrated in

catalog, ; .

The acquisition of complete manufacturing rights on: tlie

Triplex Time Switch permits a price reduction on this

ttem.. Palo ae *

In addition to new low dist Mercoid cut-off for pressures

up to 30 Ibs. there isa completé line of combination. pres-

sure and low water cut-off controls illustrated in Bulletin

+210 of Mercoid catalog. :

When requesting catalog, please advise type of equip-

ment’ being nianufactured. gros

An opportunity to be of service is solicited.

‘. - Yours very truly,

The Mercoid Corporation

: te J. W. Owens, © nae

~JIWO:C. . - ' Vice President.

Attention is directed to new lower. price now in effect’

Also lower price effective 6n the No. 855 High Voltage -

——

oA

Plaintiff's “Exhibit 24

im ANUFACTURERS PRICES 491

EFFECTIVE JANUARY 15, 4934 | SUBJECT TO CHANGE WITHOUT NOTICE

MERCOID “AUTOMATIC CONTROLS

FOR HEATING, REFRIGERATION, AIR"CONDITIONING AND INDUSTRIAL APPLICATIONS

GENERAL DISCOUNTS

Shipments of 1 to.9,............... 50-5%

Shipments of 10 to24............ 50-10-5%

Shipments af 25 or more... ...... . . 50-20-5%

The above discounts apply to the List Prices of all Mercoid Controls with the exception of those listed below

SPECIAL NET PRICE MERCOID CONTROLS -

ELECTRICAL RATING: 10 AMP.-110 V., 5 AMP.-220 V. saree Guten, 1 tP. Repsision Induction, ‘a LP. Split Phase or D.C.

a

7 : 7 : MANUFACTURERS" NET PRICES

yee DESCRIPTION Baysie List" Single Shipment Quantities

° ; ) “1te9 10 to 24 | 25 or more

~ THERMOSTATS |

‘Low Voltage Combination Sensatherm and Relay: : |

H Sensatherm, 55-85°, Gold Finish w?th Thermometer 100 | $40.00

‘ V- | Transformer Relay, 24 volt Thermostat Circuit |

Capacity, Single Pole, 10 Amp. -110 V. 60 Cyc. or 5 .* j .

Aanp.-220 V. 60 Cyc. 110 15.00

Type H and T pe V Combination, SET PRICE | . $10.00 $ 9.25 $8.55

855 High Volta hermostat, with Thermometer, Single } :

A le-10 p., available Standard Ranges, 56-80", 4

i 38-60", -45-72° ais 120 24.00 | 11.00 10.00 9.00

PRESSURE ¢ |

Fig. 31 — No. 1 (Standard).1 to 10 Ibs., Diff. 3 Ibs. | 200 * 16.00 6:00 5.50 r §.00

Fig. 31 Range No. 2, 0 to 3 Ibs., Diff. 2 ibs. | 200 16.00 6.00° | 5.50 5.00

Fig. 31 Range No.’ 3, 14 to 414 ibs., Diff. 2% Ibs. So 16.00 6.00 5.50 5.00

: : HOT WATER

Fig. 35 Bizerthaym (Clamp-on Type}, 110 to 200° | 220 16.00 6.00 i. 5,50 5.00

. WAR Am | ;

M-51 Furnace Limit Control, 50-650° +0 : 230 16.00 6.00 5.50 5.00

M-53° Furnace Fan Control, 50-650°. sy. : 230 16.00 6.00 | ‘§.50 5.00

‘STOKER - ae J

M-61 Stoker Control, 50-650", Plain Flange (without well). | 240 16.00 6.00 | 5.75 * 5.50

M-61 Stoker Control, 50-650°, Improved Flange with Stain- aS

less Steel. Well 240 20:00 7.60 7.30 \: 7.00

ASSORTMENT:

An order for assorted controls may include list and discount as well as net price ‘items. Each group in the assortment is billed

at the price applying to the total quantity ordered.

SOLENOID VALVES | | :

NUMBER 682 AND 683 :

‘Solenoid Valves may not be included in calculation. of the total of an order for an assortment as above defined )

Shipntents. of 1 to9.. 50% Shipments of 10 to 24 50-5',

Shipments of 25 or more 50-1 0 E -

SPECIAL COMPLETE SET NET PRICES

Manufacturers of equipment requiring Thermostats, Boiler Contrcis and Combustion Controls are requested to write for

Special Net Set Prices. When making application advise approx:maté yearly requirements and number of sets desired in

single shipments.

2°; for cash within 10 days from date of invoice, or net 30 days, subject to approva! of cradit rating. Ali prices F.O.B. Factory.

NEW LOW RANGE : Fig. 72

MERCOID LOW WATER nr iat

FOR PRESSURES UP TO 30 LBS. :

PROTECT YOUR BOILER AT THE WATER LEVEL

~ Construction identical to Standard Fig. 72 shown in Bulletin No. 210

except equipped with Aoat for 30-pound maximum pressure.

List Price... . 530%

» LESS GENERAL DSCOUNTS

THE MERCOID CORPORATION = 4201 ine Ase, ae, IH.

Form No. A-51

,

~.

Mercoid Cerperniron

Adjustment Control.

The Mercoid “Corporatio ~ an-

nowunces a néw double adjustment

control, emploving thé new type of

tipless Mercoid switch independent. *

lv mounted and actuated by a ther

mostatic metal coil This controt is

used as a limiting device in connec:

tion with automatic heating equip

~

The Double Adjustment Control

ment to prevent overheating of

warm @r furmmc- as well as a”

Inwoster fan contro! t- start the ‘fur-

nace fan motor when the: furnace

hol temperature has reached a

predetermined degree and stop the

fan moter on a predetermined drop

in temperature at oa

aa umique feature in this control

ts a pointer which inde ates the tem-

perature in the furnace dint se that

one may see at a glance what heat

the furnace i generating. This in-

formation is useful im determining

the amount of beat required for any

desired condition A quick change

adjustment i< provided for both

high and low points, so that any re-

quired differential and temperature

within its range mav be secured

The control has « class front, bring-| .

ing she dial readings clearly im view. |“

Nu relay or sturting switch is need-

ed where th normal working load

does not exceed 10 amperes at 110

volts or $ amperes at 220 volts,

A.C. of D.C. . ;

[he instrument is’ convement im

size. having a case dimension meas-

uring 444 inches in diameter. This

control may be operated at tempert,

atures up to 650 degrees F. Ad-

justment directions are convement-

ty indscated om thé control. For.

til! infogmation write to the Mer-

oul Corporation, 4 West Adams

“treet. ( heago .

*;,MORICC: ..RTISaAN®

"JULY 19,1932"

__—etement yoes bi

Plaintiff's Exhibit 25°

Controls \ur Pemiperniuss .

HES thermessamt is a low-voltage as temperature

comrel designed to operate im comection with a

tra relay) on altyrnatemg current the voltage m

unde? MBon~ and when used mn comnectn with a re

pulsion setay the sank mstrument can be used on d-c

It was designed wath parteular atteguun panl to senst-

tivity, competes. and peatiess

It is «perated liv means of a spiral bimetalle claerns

sensitive ty changes intemperatre One cud of the ele-

ment om att range a fet lever amd the

ether end is (je aud meves a sinall permanent magnet

attached to 3 hen the tesyerature of the bimetallic

the tenmerature for which the device

is set, the o hekd m chose proxmuty to the switch,

which contams a fized set of contacts and a movable

armature paveted upper end and having a cup con-

tamung mercury @hjts lower end, all hermetically sealed

m glass. The sv.

le armature im the

switch ys drawn te

ward the magnet apd

the mercury cup is in

stich pesition so that

the mercury chines the

circu =ohetween the

fixed comtacts. As the

Jemperature imercases,

the In-inetallic coal

newes the magnet

- away fromthe switch

When the poll of

the. Nieynet can om:

hanet held the arma

ture, the mercury cup

Memes awas from the

cotacts amd the cov

mtiseqened At the

same tune the afrnin

tire swags hack, the

ppl! om the magrect 1s Tverd andl tt yeies hack ite post-

thon where stone beiger alleets the armature. Contact

18 those: aml yao with a penitiwe snap action

Standawi vii rm from SS te SS F and if operates

fn a tenydraiur variates: of '¢ dey. @bowe or belaw |

the pert «t this tetal differential of 1 deg. can be

increased to 2 dey by an adjustment. , The instrument

rwomade by he Mercowl Corporation, 4201 Kelmont

Ave, € hicage .

"HEATING PIP & AIR COND"

"JULY 1932".

fe | : © 493

: Plaintiff's Exhibit 26

. ”

Merccoid Furnace Controls - Furnser Conteol.

Hk Merced ’Corp, anmwncres a»

5 new® |hwhle Adjustment Furnace

trattol employing the new tipless

In the actumpanying illustraticns arc shown two of

the Mercoid controls - designed for use in connection with — ‘ Meremad switch independently mounted

warm-air furnace heating. The thermostat shown jn am! actuated by a thermmstatic metal

(ull front view and. with the cover removed, is designed” - , ia date enn Joe Veniting drvies

lt automate @ il heating equnp

et) te prevent ating warm ary

Mynaces. ako Mhooster tan comer

ty start) aml sfap the furnace tar

° neetor at a predetermined rise of (41!

m temperature m the furnace lwwwl

A wnque feature of tthe conten!

an indicating «= pomrey showing thn

“ tomperature m t furnace duct ©

‘ that the treat th nace os gener ?

ating at ane tome y be read ats

glance aml permitting of variation

to meet any desired , fawls 4

D

simple. quick change wd)

perenveted for teeth high

a

that any reopured di™erennigt,

temperature withen ot ‘

socuredt The contend,

tremnt hrm ing the chal vr

ly m vew No rela

aSitch ms needed where the worm

wetting load des net taco JH

for comrol of air temperature from’ withm the rooms ; amperes at PO volts cn S amperes at

‘Mi volts, A © oe Fh 6

‘The other ‘is an instrument operating from the hood or

pipitig to prevent the overheating Of warm-air furnaces,

controlling either dampers or the operation of a fan ina

jurnace heating ‘ systém. ’

. wee ty ee

‘Purntc. (.# \ 6

; The instrument «oo 4. ue 0 '

haveg @ Case dine rise MCR SUT Hm

4, wm drameter » a ~ conn

mM. he «qe rated af tere we

° - 4 te 5 dew

7 ' Mercoid Furnace Controt Switch .

. "SANITARY HTG.AGE*- ae

These instruments employ a combination of a mercury

switch and metal bellows; which operate ‘a motor that in

turn operates: the «lampers or switches on and off ‘the

cutrent to the fan motor

The thermostat is naturally placed in the room im

"AUGUST 1929" | .

which it 1s desired to control ,the air temperatures, and “Mercod” New Name of ;

_ operates a motor to close and ope the draft dampers of Merged Com panies ‘4

the furmace. The hermetically sealed mercury tube and The Fetert! Gauge Company and th

the metal bellows are shown in the view with the covet | Siok cal ceca macnn’ is

removed 7 OR, are now aperating andel the name

: The secorid illustratien shows a front view of a control = —" s oe ~~

re ‘ which is Connected to a tube imsegted in a furnace bonnet <u sa tie of he tb Sebed teen

* or duct. The tube is charged with an expansive liquid, - ) tompamp, and beth factories oll remap

which on expan:ling operates the device. This, in ten, -

actuates. the switch of the motot which operates the fan ; "FUEL OIL JOURNAL”

or the-dampers, through a motor mechanism. DP "APRIL 1928"

Thus it will be seen that the foregoing instruments :

constitute a dual control for a furnace heating system. - : *M ERCON) Contests fer Heenng

g b cuspenent™” are decribed wm oer attractive

"SHEET METAL WORKER® : ° tipege Uluserered «capaiag featucong the

vermous. types of merceed comeul seucher

“NOVEMBER 19297 - — dermanans, iq ludeng typeal worming

yarns

a ye ‘+. © WARM AFR HEATING”

, "DEC 1929"

ca

Nw

“

Type M.51 end M.52 Warm Au

Furnace ntro's

ae 3 495

Plaintiff's Exhibit 30

MERCOID COAL STOKER CONTROLS

. EQUIPPED WITH THE MERCOID SEALED MERCURY CONTACT SwiTCH

TYPE TV2 MERCOID STOK-A-TIMER - | om _

A compect unit combining the Mercoid Tressformer retsy and 8 synchronous motor | nO VOLTAGE CODE PRICE

thmer mecheniam for maintaining the stoker tre during penods.when the thermortat

Ser aaecat GRRETSY STE TRNTAY Gn Sas | TEMA NM em ee

Gir be warmenn Guts om Tha procerm qvewaunre ond cate tte | TD NS. SEee enguy ONS

renin aoweteane meena ec aate mre rome | N20 1. tie oe

bes eserranes conse, sieececpag som BT | E21 Me an

ea ionsehiemem cea |e oe oe Oe

MERCOID MERCURY CONTACT SWITCHES Eliminate unnecessary service as the | Ty?3) 230V. Deve uvhds =: 18.088

contacts cannot be affected by dust. di? or borrosiwe gases | °

: —-os mone eat 4 Standard tor 10 amp .115V 60 cycle Avaliable at no extra | 5

Tv? STOK.A. amp -Z30V.. @ cycie. | t 5 ibs

; — MOTOR RATING: 1 HP Repuisior inducton WHE Split Pnase | gay

TYPE M-63SW OUTFIRE STOKER CONTROL

Type M-63SW +s @ stack Mounted temperature operated ontro! designed to,act

matic alty stop the stoker in event the tire should go out of the fuel become exhausted

Tres prevents operating an empty stober and quards against filling tne combs

“e chamber with unburned tuel—a conditiog most unpleasant to the operator

Tne Mercord switch 1s of the enclosed mercury contact type It .s fot subyect to oper

arcr COrOosion, OFdation. of pi'ting ard will operate indefinitely atihout detenora TYPE RANGE . List

ton Tre mechanism of this contro! has many outstanding features The tia) located NO AD) ss COE PRICE

fn the center of the nstrument, slowly rotates as the temperature or the bi metal + a

wncreases or decreases This cial is clearly caldeated trom Sto OAOPF and @ parter .

. indicates the temperature in the stack. -enabiing the instatiation or sence mer te ™ 63SW 30 690 f wvosy $10.58

. check the operator

A ample double adjustment 1s provided for setting Doth Ine “gh and ow of eralny

y= IS Ww

Tet STORth

Cm

4

points. The range can be adjusted over the entre. scare. and the differential can be Shipping weight approx 414 ItS

set tor very close operation The usual setting 1s approamately 100°

Standerd instruments are furnished with & stanies* steel wel! en: losing the DB: meta

operating coil, This protects the con not ontygrom deposits of Hy ash, Dut algo auarnst

corrosive stack gases. .

| Furmeshed stendard with a lock type mafiual saitch button to permit, starting Ine

| stomer after the fire has gore out Turning the button locks the switch in the

postion. When the fire «6 @par started the stact te nperstur

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Transcript of Record — Mercoid Corp. v. Mid Continent Co. · 320 U.S. 661 | Frix