Transcript of Record — United States v. Johnson, United States v, Sommers
Supreme Court brief1942
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
ae
pegs = on
United States Circuit Gourt of Haprals
Bar the Seventh Circuit
THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plawtiff-Appellee,
No. 7500 VS.
WILLIAM R. JOHNSON,
Defendant-A ppellant.
4
THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff-Appellee,
No. 7501 vs.
JACK SOMMERS, er at,
Defendants-Appellants.
Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the
Northern Distiict of Illinois, Eastern Division.
INDEX TO BILL OF EXCEPYioNs.
Celieguy ............. ale sane 1, 330, €12, 717, 987, 995. 100°
Excerpts from opening statement br Mr. Thampson.. 2
GOVEENMEKT’S WITKESSES
Testimany af -
Acheson. Robert iw 1%
Anderson. HE. 9°
Anderson, Norman 128
Arndt. Georre . 263
Barshaw, Chas. F 532
Baier, Arthur Geers G0E
Baker, Lorenzo - 132
Recker, W. J O14
Reckng, 1. W ol€
Ballamy, Clarence Zati
Bibow, Morbert E sve
Rmeen, Adotph 294
Bissell. ATher: of
Biake, Donald 715
Bonfield. James - 247
Roras. Stanlev T 230
Brandt, Henrv ag
419
Rrown. Frank Matthew . 398
Brown. Stuart Solomor (Before Grand Jurr) fii4
Bulger. Florerce. Mr. fl
Canfield. Thomas pe
‘Val. I. pages 1 to Set: Wal TL pages 565 to wens.
Testimony of :
Cargett, Claremce ...........ccccccccccccccseee 253
Cervenka, George H............-..---0002ceee 228
EE i vkcesscccscictecsbevesesnceanes 222
SE EE Bini. wince se vceccccsnsccuavsasesens 735
I oc pncdess cd tendavenessonecncenns 348
I, EE lon vc esccevncsssscdncenvtsssens 315
I MD ooo ec ovccccdcscucsecedeusssceese 388
I I oan ccscc esc cisccnssyecsvvevenne 136
Cusack, Daniel Howard................-..-.+.- 248
I TE kc ose cncsesevewrensccesadseesoexnaen 142
I Oe Ge ines news edcee te tuoensees 232
ee errr rer rrr rrr etre 603
ee a oe 224
Downey, Lillian ................ cin aa eae eeuaun 695
Dooweey, Deweler .... 2.2... cccccccvecsccsesces 696
ee Pere 457
I IE once scccnccccncanncoses*sensas 500
SS SS rrrrrerrer er rrr re 345
BE NR rena ncdbkun inh aneseksen eee ERS 279
en ee oe 594
Bien, BIE PP... ww cc cece cece sev nvenaes 503
PU I 5 os cc ccc cecnseeruscervesceneesee 316
PRE, TT Bian ck ccc cee ecenesccnrssncses 144
Flanagan, Patrick .............-.00eseeeeeeeee 611
I IE Dio cv vn ve vebccesncrccsvneseusnes 283
sc cannayscietescewanns ae te none 290
Goldberg, Robert .............cccccccccesernce 140
Goldstein, William ..............-ccccccescevee 55
ee ie err 53, 775
Greenberg, Gam ......... 2.2 c cece cece cccscceee 233
Geoemepell, Thomry ..... 2... c ccc cccccsececevons 391
NE incu dec ctennctoctsaventsewen vee 460
I ID neds ss ceeseesaeivresvexesee 39
ee ee 308
Vol. I, pages 1 to 544; Vol. TI, pages 545 to 1088.
Testimony of :
I ME fo. ass uhiwanensivaeeccce uel. 317
RE ea emt nt 262
Lk Ek ee ne one ia | 293
CE ooo d kt 4 one ake 559
Hollander, Joseph A. .......................... 272
Shab oo 6 vais bids <adeasuceescoa 996
Huffman, Raymond J.......................... 259
Huston, Sanford K............................. 260
Jiracek, Frank M.............................. 11
Johnson, Chester R. ........................... 506
Jones, Ulysses Grant.......................... 139
Jungwirth, John .............................. 265
I 405
Kehoe, Thomas ............................... 309
on. ere 143
Kilpatrick, Benjamin G........................ 34
Kling, Robert E....................:.......... 229
acs waseon nd vere ences rdsacest. 373
Kolarik, Chas., Jr.............................. 475
I oy e's on te wcknsssrstesenchccece..t. 587
ir he sib vend nec ccs cdu. ks 36
Kudesh, Harry ......... MNauhomwen se geal eauemcn 381
Lang, John P........... FANS REA WENGER ee aeukies 319
sawrenen, Purvis A........:................... 714
matitesnye, Sees, eee 322
Leichsenring, Richard ......................... 261
EE nrcce ne vcs sv kus pubs vee dechaccces 150
Leonard, Raymond A........................... 339
cesstis t..,,, SERIE ESE pee een he 709
Loria, Wdward A.............................. 324
Lutz, William Frank...................... .... 583
NE I 65s ois. dc nacdnedccn cin le 281
sosrtet a. oh kt, SO Ae ee eRe 581
McGinnis, Roy Robert......................... 134
Vol. I, pages 1 to 544; Wol. IZ, pages 545 to 108s.
Ne cece a lhe be eb dk bake bev 192
eae akhcens kau skevs.cosdewee’s 476
cea ka nak ness eeebebnbs vers seevese 326
Bah Dike seek tudes si bees dno eneees 328
SE re 552
caw scncvcccetrrscrevavce 515
ere 208, 697
CS ee 72
Nechin, Abraham ............... CRY ee ee 312
ce dese case bewebevetouns 608
keen d vac ae wed 5, 37
ee eae vnk vague iy ee oe aed 329
O'Leary, Martin Jerome....................... ¥42
a a ee eee 729
Paulsen, Harold .............. Pee ws aire eb toa 145
ee ooo i vd bw n nance sh ese wen 379
I Mh cok vec ccovrvevcesvcseess 93
ccc nw nb ene cnsbdesencavds 566
ea ieee u saws bes cuacebscekoous 170
eis le ise Gke seems oss 693
ee es, baeip cae > eb eon ws 998
a ie no dab nv ow ke on oss oe 8
Ee 767
CE en i
I Te tcc tesenvavoccosvces 274, 727
"ee
aan Wecke skies sbevnesseeas 234
er aka Chae ATO nue oes 516
ee ck Sean sb nse awae s 174
i a eed dh chen ncks es vad eed 48
a ee eee 69, 521
TS ae ses abe a aeees scenes
RT a ne a ee 777
Eee |
I I Ms ccc bok cob eaceseacbcees 510
Vol. I, pages 1 to 544; Vol Ti, pages 545 to 1088.
v
Testimony of :
Sommers, Walter A...................... 45,117
wtensaee leiea rr e 47, 166
ee eon, Oe CTT ae 168
Tavalin, Samuel C.......0.0000000020202~20202@2@2@2@~2~C*~*™” 11
Temple, Louis W............................ 523
Thibert, Robert ...........00000.000000..2~2” 306
|... ene nena 706
Van Spankeren, Herman................ 401
Wadsinski, Peter ............................. 472
Wakefield, Ruth .............................. 406
no E,., Seat Ea 474
Weeks, Joseph George.................... 276
rrr: 119
MR MI eS eis sns vad icccnscee. ct 45, 392
PN W266 oes oss ad ecte ocean 148
Pier 10
ERASE gaat nL lena ets en Ae 387
MP hs boric ot, Sea. Sn es 35
ig. SIREN CP pee nai aetna cs eepeeeias 89
MN WE Weick. et. 11
DEFENDANT’S WITNESSES.
Testimony of:
ne. Se ee 928
coc 0 da 2, ASE RTROC ERD ieee en area see ai 925
S.No ae een. 856
Carroll, Dominic .............................. 891
Chalmers, Florence ............................ 782
Creighton, Andrew J........................... 857
co, See er eee 916
oe eee 918
2 EE eee es ar! 917
i cali ee 784
Vol. I, pages 1 to 544; Wol. II, pages 545 to 1086.
Testimony of :
I civcnpcdvichonevansacedencevens 798
CE Micvcceckubsvcsbovétccsnvennes 931
ci cccphieonseecsssuvasavessed 916
EE cnecesedvcdcavenceddenenas ce 800
aE Dae aR eR ce ie ate MRR” se SAE 914
RRS ar ates Sa tle et AP rane Us 926
EE ns cons ue sae wid dew ates enen 7
Cie cieu ol eay hevh coka enckecon 805
I, I, Bi os oc ce ivewnncuecccucectas 949
EE ee occ weww ae sceessbeoownewew 918
ecu oaks KKRw aS Co URE ED KOS 878
i in cane ee bad eee eees eee en 785
SAE nccccuccatoccccuccdve veeeetvTrer 791
ras ceo. eigace boa Ch wabeuehtacieen 795
i is bak ad neh enas kee aoe eae Kesee 928
0 Serer er eer rt er 850
I ooh ae a a ara oa Ree Bie ea CO 918
ee Oe ee ana age eave ae U Meee 919
a ere rr rrr rie rT 854
SE Ms secs kaks snk vate aGenewaes 851
Re ot os ce erik kemtvewen neater 923
Ne etree rr rr ies re er ye re Tere ee eT 804
ce cL ebeeks bh ouees CL ike son en 920
a Ck. Land ons soe ka eR 923
ce ee aa a eee 809
so oa aun ad cadena beeen Kae 893
ee oe. aan tabs aan eee aKa 991
Ec ca uu hanna vale ee enddaekvaskten 922
eo ck s ckeua eens Sene enced 919
I ons bau oh bc nu na Cee oes 6004 Kat 895
CE EE Neu whkee nee rciacebesoweecaeus 919
Vol. I, pages 1 to 544; Vol. Tl, pages 545 to 1086.
-
Vii
GOVERNMENT’S EXHIBITS.
0-207 Statement of Wm. R. Johnson............__. 410
0-209 Statement in narrative form of James A.
a ons EE ee a ae 462
0-210 Statement in aarrative form of Jack Sommers 467
0-211 Portion of testimony of Stuart Solomon
Brown before the Grand ARENA EIA 614
Statement of motions filed by defendants at close of
government’s evidence for directed verdict, ete., and
OPO TE WO os oo vivo econ oon cess... 781
ni ale dee ee 1005
Defendant’s requested charge to jury............... 1024
Index of government’s exhibits received in evidence. . 1033
Index of defendant’s exhibits refused............._. 1040
Order continuing motion to settle and sign bill of ex-
> ceptions entered January 9,1941............0 1040
Order settling bill of exceptions, etc. entered January
Fs nO aS AI anna eaten 1041
Assignments of error of Wm. R. Johnson, et al... ._. 1041
Judge’s certificate to bill of exceptions..........._.. 1065
Clerk’s certificate to bill of exceptions.............. 1066
Vol. Z, pages 1 to 844; Vol IT, pages 545 to loss.
1 And on, to wit, the 21st day of January, A. D. 1941,
came the defendants by their attorneys and filed in the
Clerk’s office of said Court Bill of Exceptions in words and
figuers following, to wit:
2 In rue Disraicr Court or roe Unrrep Srares
For the Northern District of Illinois,
Eastern Division.
United States of America,
Plaintiff-Appellee,
v3.
William R. Johnson, Jack Som-
mers, John M. Flanagan, James a 0. 32168.
A. Hartigan, William P. Kelly,
and Stuart Solomon Brown,
Defendants-Appellants. }
BILL OF EXCEPTIONS.
(Rule [X— Criminal Procedure.)
Be It Remembered that heretofore on to-wit, August 27,
1940, and from day to day thereafter until the conclusion of
the trial of the above-entitled cause, the following evidence
was admitted and proceedings had:
3 Opening Statements.
Mr. Hurley made the opening statement for the Govern-
ment and, after reviewing the indictment in a general way,
related what he expected the evidence to show on behalf of
the Government.
Mr. Hess (Excerpts from opening statement on behalf
of certain defendants) :
Mr. Callaghan and I represent the defendants (except
Mr. Johnson) frequently referred to as “‘aiders.”’
With regard to Sommers, Creighton, Hartigan, Flan-
agan, Kelly and Mackay, as you have already heard here
about gambling going on, we concede they were ——
gambling clubs, and the evidence will show it. e con-
cede that it was their business and that they operated at
)
2 Bill of Exceptions.
one point or another at some time or another during the
years 1936 to 1939.
The evidence will not show that these twenty-two places
that Mr. Hurley recited to you were being operated at one
time or with any particular regularity. There was an oper-
ation at one point and then that would be closed for reasons
that I do not have to tell you. This line of business is
pushed around. Then they would move to some other club,
* * © and as to the list of clubs referred to by the Gov-
ernment, these men operated some of them at some tinie ;
not all of them. Some of the clubs mentioned, we don’t
think there is any evidence, or we don’t know of any, at
least, that we had anything to do with them.
4 Now this is true of these gentlemen, and when I say
that the; operated gambling clubs, that wipes out
everything that was said by the Government in its opening
statement with respect to detail,—the names of the men
working in there, the kind of game, the door man, and all
of those details that go into the operation of a gambling
> ga into the operation of most of these gambling
clubs.
So we will have no controversy about any of that feature
of ihe case, but as you have been informed by the Court and
by Judge Thompson and Mr. Hurley in their examination
of you to serve as jurors, the question here is income tax,
and not whether we operated a gambling house; we concede
right here that we did operate them. * °* °
I am not speaking for Mr. Johnson. R
5 You have heard what the Government expects to
show with respect to banking and currency exchange
facitities. There will be no question about any of that.
Wherever the records show that any of my clients cashed
7 checks or exchanged currency, that is the fact. We
did exchange currency and we did cash checks.
a e * * . 2
| The help, the evidence will show, in this line of business
is a little different, slightly different, at least. They are
paid every night. * * * Whether it is the night crew or
the day crew.
6 Excerpts from Opeuing Statement of Mr. Thompson.
We have had outlined by the United States attorneys
what they expect to prove. Most of my information about
this case has come to me this morning when the United
States attorney told what they expected to prove. I first
Opening Statement of Mr. Thompson. 3
met Mr. Johnson just a few days ago and I was hired
Monday afternoon to represent him in this trial which
started Tuesday morning as you know.
Mr. Hurley: I object to anything like this as an opening
statement.
The Court: Sustained.
7 The question in this case, as is obvious from the
statement of the Government, is, first, whether or not
Mr. Johnson has had an income larger than that which he
has reported to the Government. The source of that in-
come is altogether immaterial. That is the first question.
The second question is,—Mr. Hurley stated that the second
proposition and the one on which they base their case is
that Mr. Johnson owned this great string of clubs in which
gambling took place and that the income of these gambling
houses was Mr. Johnson’s income. * * *
Now, our proof will be that Mr. Johnson does nct own
any one of these clubs; that the income from these clubs is
not his income. That is the defense. * * °*
Now, we will prove this about Mr. Johnson. He was
born and reared in Chicago. He has been a gambler all his
life. He started shooting craps and playing marbles for
keeps when he was twelve or thirteen years old and he has
been doing it ever since, he has been shooting craps ever
since. He is forty-five years old. He sits there at the end
of the table, with a dark suit on, gray haired, forty-five
years old, unmarried ; lives with his mother here in Chicago
and out on the farm in DuPage County; never has done
anything else but gamble; that is his business.
He has made a lot of money. We will prove he has got
the reputation of being a square gambler and that where-
ever Bill Johnson is stopping to gamble or shooting
8 craps that the game is on the square. We will prove
that very often a gambling house in this town is re-
ferred to as a Bill Johnson gambling house because the
gambling house is on the square and is a place where Bill
Johnson plays and he won’t play where the gambling house
is not on the square. * * *
We will prove that Mr. Johnson had absolutely nothing
to do with this currency exchange, had no interest in it
whatever, he never cashed a check there, he never ex-
changed money there, he never bought a money order there,
he never received a dime of income from the place.
Mr. Johnson owned either the building or an interest in
the building. It was an old bank building that went broke
4 Bill of Exceptions.
when banks went broke in this town. It was put on the
market to be sold by the receiver. Mr. Johnson either by
himself or as partner with somebody bought this building
as an investment. It was there being operated. The safety
deposit boxes were being rented —. operated for the con-
venience of the people in the neighborhood and for others.
We will prove that there was a woman there in charge of
these safety deposit boxes and as Mr. Brown’s attorney,
Mr. Hess, has said, that this building was rented by the
currency exchange for fifty dollars a month, I think it was.
The money was going to the agent who had charge of the
building and being spent for any expenses to maintain the
building. Mr. Johnson got no income from this building
at all, but Mr. Johnson did own the building, that it did
pay an income and that it did return a net result, the Gov-
ernment says in this indictment. ®* ° °
We are going to prove that Mr. Johnson had no knowl-
edge whatever of this so-called destruction of books, he
doesn’t know anything about it, he had no interest in them,
had no connection with them and, therefore, no part of them
is his affair.
fe] There was a lot said about the Bon Air Country
Club and Mr. Hess has already described to you in
sufficient detail at this time that that was a big country
club, golf course and all that and it is now a big roadhouse
with facilities for the accommodation of the public just like
hundreds of other roadhouses in the country. There is
gambling goes on there occasionally, probably, like in other
roadhouses.
Now Mr. Johnson is interested in that property. Mr.
Johnson is a stockholder in the catering company as well
as three or four other people. The books will explain just
who the stockholders are. He owns, as I remember, about
a fourth interest, about a fourth of the company. Mr.
Johnson is also a part owner of the real estate itself, which
is rented to the catering company on a percentage basis,
just like many other rental contracts are and the catering
company as a corporation has made its returns, it has never
id a dividend and, therefore, Mr. Johnson never had any
income from it, but the catering company has made its
returns at all times.
The property, the real estate which is leased to the
catering company has several owners. I don’t know who
the owners are now, maybe only two owners, but anyway
Mr. Johnson is a part owner of the property. All those
facts will come out.
—
Testimony of Helen J. Norton. 5
10 HELEN J. NORTON, a witness on behalf of the Gov-
ernment, being duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Hurley.
I am chief of the income tax assessment list in the office
of the Collector of Internal Revenue at Chicago, Illinois.
The First Collection District includes Cook County, and
persons residing therein file their returns in Chicago. I
have charge of the records and files pertaining to the filing
of income tax returns in the First District of Illinois, and [
am in charge of the income tax assessment list.
Government’s Exhibit R-6 for identification was filed in
the office of the Collector in Chicago. The stamp in green
letters ‘March 15, 1933,” appearing on the document indi-
cates the date the return was received in the Collector’s
office. The stamp in the upper right-hand corner of the
exhibit indicates the receipt of payment of part of the tax
on March 17, 1933. There is also a deposit stamp showing
the date the money for payment is sent to the bank. The
stamp on the upper lefthand corner of the exhibit ‘‘Com-
putation proved,’’ indicates that the comptometer operatc
has proved the computation on the face of the return. Also
appearing on the exhibit in the upper righthand corner in
blue figures is the payment itself. The assigned serial
number 817210 also appears. Also, on the exhibit are the
red check marks of the comptometer operator. The red
circle appearing in the lower right-hand corner of the ex-
hibit is placed there by the auditor showing the tax to be
assessed.
11 Government’s Exhibit R-7 for identification is a re-
‘i — filed in the office of the Collector at Chicago, March
, 1934.
Government’s Exhibit R-8 for identification is a return
filed in the office of the Collector in Chicago, March 15, 1935.
Government’s Exhibit R-9 for identification is a return
oa in the office of the Collector at Chicago on March 16,
Government’s Exhibit R-10 for identification is a return
ve in the office of the Collector in Chicago on March 15,
37.
Government’s Exhibit R-11 for identification is a return
received by the Collector’s office on March 15, 1938.
Government’s Exhibit R-12 for identification is a return
meegusctenapy eumeeee mr peanzweeeeummmatenrt we ROMS Tye “tere tree a gy Aare
6 Bill of Exceptions.
rons in the office of the Yollector in Chicago on March 15,
1939.
Government’s Exhibit R-13 for identification is a return
filed in the office of the Collector in Chicago and received
on March 15, 1940.
The document shown me sdentified as Government’s Ex-
hibits R-6 to R-13, inclusive, are the returns of William R.
Johnson for the years 1932 to 1939, inclusive. As a result
of a personal search and examination of the files in the
office of the Collector of Internal Revenue in Chicago,
which I made, I can say that these returns are the only in-
come tax returns filed by the defendant, William R. John-
son, for the period.
Government’s Exhibits R-86 to R-106, inclusive, for
12 identification are certified copies of records in the office
of the Collector at Chicago known as the income tax
assessment list. The entries on the assessment list are
taken in some cases from the entry made from the original
return, in some cases from a revenue agent’s report show-
ing a deficiency, and in other cases the entry is made on the
assessment list by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue
indicating a deiiciency.
I have made a personal examination of the records of
the office of the Collector at Chicago to determine how much
income tax was paid by William R. Johnson during the
year 1932.
The Court: This is for the purpose of showing ex-
penditures by the defendant?
Mr. Hurlev: Right; moneys paid during 1932 into the
Collector’s office.
Mr. Thompson: We object on the ground that there is
nothing in the indictment or bill of particulars to which
this relates and it is immaterial.
The Court: Objection overruled.
The Witness: There was a payment of $596.03 made
April 2, 1932, and a payment of $786.00 made July 19, 1932.
There was income tax paid in four equal installments:
March 15th, June 8th, September 7th and December 13.
1932, totalling $7,576.64. The amount of income tax paid
by William R. Johnson in 1933 was $8,610.10.
For the year 1934 the amount of income tax paid by
Joknson was $17,767.15, and there is a payment here, tax,
penalty and interest, ‘totalling $11,808.08 made during
1934.
—_
Testimony of Helen J. Norton. ,
13 During the year 1935 Johnson paid income tax in
four equal installments totalling $40,464.13, and also
an additional tax of $909.43.
In 1936, the amount of income tax paid by Johnson in
four equal installments was $11,029.79, and also an addi-
tional tax of $9,032.45.
The income tax paid by Johnson in 1937 consisted of one
payment of $4,686.83, four equal installments totalling
$71,915.35; also $1,223.59 ; and $724.93.
In 1938 William R. Johnson paid income tax in the sum
of $128,399.72.
In 1939 William R. Johnson paid income tax of $34,530.44.
These were all the invome taxes paid by William R. John-
son during the years 1933 to 1939, inclusive.
The various entries made on the documents which I ex-
amined in the office of the Collector of Internal Revenue in
Chicago were made in the ordinary course of business, and
at or about the time the transaction took place, and kept
under my supervision and direction.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Thompson.
The records which I have identified today show that the
income tax of William R. Johnson for the year 1932 was
audited, and all the tax that was demanded of him up to
that date has been paid. I do not know who audited the
returns. The notation ‘‘audited by E:AJ 1936” is put
14 on there by a revenue agent, but I do not know who it
is. Any records which would show whose initials these
are would be in Washington in the office of the Commis-
sioner of Internal Revenue. The report is en file.
Referring to Government’s Exhibit R-7, being the income
tax return of Johnson for 1933 filed in 1934, Schedule A
indicates the kind of business engaged in as ‘‘miscellaneous
betting commissions and gambling.’’ This return was
audited in due course by an agent of the Department with
the result that a deficiency was assessed in 1935. This de-
ficiency was paid by Johnson September 19, 1935. All the
taxes which have been assessed up to date against Johnson
for the year 1933 have been paid by him.
With regard to Government’s Exhibit R-8, being the re-
turn for the year 1934, the net income is shown thereon as
$134,811.46. This is designated as ‘‘miscellaneous specu-
lative income.’’? This return was audited by agents of the
Department and a deficiency was assessed in October, 1936,
8 Bill of Exceptions.
and was paid together with interest on November 16, 1936.
I can state that it was paid from the certified copies of the
assessment list identified as Government’s Exhibit R-99.
I do not know who audited that return.
Referring to Government’s Exhibit R-9, being the return
for the year 1935 filed on March 16, 1936, a deficiency was
assessed in November, 1937. From the name appearing on
the stamp, ‘‘J. T. Blocker’’ made the audit. The deficiency
tax together with interest was paid December 21, 1937.
15 Referring to Government’s Exhibit R-10, being
Johnson’s return for the calendar year 1936, the orig-
inal amount returned for tax was $71,915.35. This return
was audited ps —geory Fu J. T. Blocker.
On the re-avdit of Mr. Johnson’s return for the year
1936, Johnson paid the deficiency together with interest
on December 21, 1937.
Another 1936 assessment ny on our records. I am
referring to Government’s ibit R-106 which is a jeop-
ardy assessment. The amount outstanding is $526,967.26.
The $836.75 appearing as a credit is a payment which was
made June 15, 1940.
A jeopardy assessment is an assessment of income tax
made under Section 273 of the Revenue Act which provides
immediate assessment of the income tax. There is also a
a. assessment against Johnson for the year 1937
and the year 1938. I do not have a jeopardy assessment
among these papers for Johnson for the year 1939. The
records which I have do not show any claim for some $33,-
000.00 and an acceptance of $11,000.00 in settlement of that
claim. If it was a claim that appeared for these years, it
would appear on the assessment list which I have now,
16 and there is no record on the assessment list indicating
any claim for these years. I have a payment here of
$11,808.08 made December 14, 1934, which appears on
Government’s Exhibit R-95 which is a deficiency, a tax for
the year 1931 which was assessed in addition to the reg-
ular return. The amount of the tax was $9,738.90. There
was penalty and interest due thereon. It was an assess-
ment and was paid.
Mr. Hurley: At this time, if the Court please, I wiu
offer in evidence GOVERNMENT’S EXHIBIT, for identi-
fication, R-6-13, inclusive, and R-86-106, inclusive.
Mr. Thompson: We object to those exhibits which are
of periods prior to 1936, because the year 1936 is the first
Testimony of Helen J. Norton. 9
year covered in the indictment or in the bill of particulars;
and we also object to the receiving of these documents on
to ’35, inclusive, except that he should go back and show
the income of the years prior thereto. If he purports to
he has got no right to start with 1932. He should go all
the way back.
The Court: Overruled.
Mr. Callaghan: Your Honor, I want to add to my asso-
ciate’s objection, and make the additional objections on
behalf of our defendants, that these income tax returns on
William R. Johnson are not binding in any way upon our
defendants at this stage of the proceeding.
17 The Court: Proceed.
Mr. Hurley: They may not be at this time. I
think, if the Court please, if the evidence goes in, then it
will. At least I want to make that reservation at this
time until I shall connect it.
The Court: You Propose to connect them up?
Mr. Hurley: Yes,
The Court: They may be received.
Mr. Callaghan: Subject to the objection. May it be
understood, if Your Honor please, that we need not re-
peat objections of other counsel, these various objections:
and that we need not take an exception to each ruling of
the Court?
The Court: All I require is that I know I am ruling on
something. If I know I am ruling on something, then you
may assign an error on any ruling I make.
Mr. Harley: However, they are at this time against the
defendant Johnson. This objection only goes to the other
defendants.
The Court: What is that?
Mr. Hurley: This objection only goes to the other de-
fendants.
The Court: Yes,
Mr. Hurley: Yes, they are admissible against the de-
fendant Johnson.
The Court: You may preserve an exception to any rul-
ing to which you call my atiention.
The Court: Yes. These exhibits are admissible
against Mr. Johnson at this time. As to the other de-
10 Bill of Exceptions.
fendants, they are admitted subject to your promise to
connect them up.
(Said documents so offered and received in evidence
were marked as GOYVERNMENT’S EXHIBITS R-6 to
13, and R-86 to 106.)
LEWIS H. WILSON, called as a witness on behalf of the
Government, having been first duly sworn, was examined
and testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Hurley.
My name is Lewis H. Wilson; I live at Chicago, Illinois.
I am an Internal Revenue Agent stationed at Chicago,
Illinois, for the past twenty-two years and two months.
I did not in the month of December, 1931, have a talk
with a man named William R. Johnson; I did a little bit
later pertaining to that date. A conversation was had on
January 26, 1934. I do see the man in, the court room that
I had the talk with. (Indicating the defendant, William RB.
Johnson). Revenue Agent, John T. Blocker, was present.
The place was in my office, Room 426, this building.
Q. Now, will you state what your conversation with
Mr. Johnson was at that time?
A. In relation to a protest that he had filed.
19 Mr. Hess: This is not binding on us.
The Court: Do you promise to connect this up?
re Mr. Hess: It is not binding on us, conversation with
im.
Mr. Horley: I would say let it go in as against the de-
fendant Johnson unless it is later connected up.
The Court: Well, it may be received as against the
defendant Johnson.
The Witness: I asked him how much he had on Decem-
ber 31, 1931. He said he had his bank roll of $10,000.00
and $68,000.00 in accumulated gambling profits in the
safety deposit box. He said that all the money in the box
was gambling profits. He kept all his gambling profits in
his box; not in his bank, he told me. He said it was in the
form of currency. We discussed several adjustments
made on examination of his income tax return for 1931,
particularly in relation to currency, and he told me at that
time what he had on December 31, 1931.
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 11
Mr. Thompson: I move to strike this testimony as hav-
ing no bearing on the issues made by the indictment and
is not covered by the matter stated in the bill of partic-
ulars,
The Court: Denied.
Thereupon the Government offered and there was re-
ceived in evidence GOVERNMENT'S EXHIBIT 0-1 pur-
the government, having been first duly sworn, was exam-
ined, and after testifying, on motion of Mr. Thompson,
the testimony of the witness was stricken.
FRANK J. ZIMANZL, called as 2 witness on behalf of
the Government, having been first duly sworn, and after
testifying, on motion of Mr. Thompson, the testimony of
this witness was stricken from the record.
SAMUEL C. TAVALIN, called as a witness on behalf of
e Government, having been first duly sworn, testified
as follows:
21 Direct Examination by Mr. Miller.
My business is real estate mortgages; I have been go
engaged for over fifteen years. I have been president of
the General Mortgage Investments since 1928. I have
known the defendant, William R. Johnson, about twenty-
five years. I have had business transactions with him.
My first business transaction was in 1925. I was one of
the members of a Syndicate that had acquired some rea]
estate. The members of the syndicate were Leo Glazer,
Division, known as 1209 North Dearborn Street,—1201 to
09, possibly °13. It is a three-story commercial building,
stores, offices, and apartments and lodge halls. In the lat-
ter part of 1933, we sold out to Mr. Johnson. There were
12 Bill of Exceptions.
considerable negotiations as to the amount, the sale price
for the equities, and I believe it was agreed to be approx-
imately $16,600.00 which Mr. Johnson paid for the interest
of all the other members of the syn icate. It seems to
me that the title to that piece of property at the time of
gale was in the name of the Foreman Bank as trustee. I
handled the transaction whereby Mr. Johnson acquired
title to that building. I received payment of the $16,000.00,
that I mentioned, from Mr. Johnson. There was a first
and second mortgage on the property at that time amount-
ing to approximately $200,000.00. I think that at that
92 time the balance due on the first mortgage was about
$160,000.00; that was about December, 1933. I think
the first mortgage was made with the Penn Mutual Life
Insurance Company. I handled part of the negotiations
for that loan and signed the mortgage. The co-signer of
that mortgage obligation was Samue! Robin. At the time
of the acquisition of title to this property by the defendant
Jobnson, there was an agreement made with regard to the
then existing mortgages, both the first and second mort-
gage. I don’t recall the conversation ;‘the result was that
the mortgage was paid off. I had no conversation with
the defendant Johnson as to the payment of the first mort-
gage. There was a general conversation as to the second
mortgage; it was at my office. Everybody in interest, at
some time or other in the conversation, was present; by
‘‘every’’ I mean all these people just mew + ed that were
part of this syndicate. The defendant Jo.uson may have
been present at that time. I did have a conversation
with Johnson in my office with regard to the payment of
the second mortgage in the latter part of 1933. It was
before Mr. Johnson acquired title to the property. I don’t
remember what the conversation was or where it took place
or who was there.
The Court: What is your best recollection as to where
it took place?
The Witness: Well, it was in my office. I can’t tie up any
one conversation, your Honor; negotiations were pending
over a period of several months pefore it was disposed of.
The amount of the second mortgage that we owned was
paid off at a slight discount by the defendant, William R.
Johnson. It was paid at my office tome. I don’t recall
93 the exact amount; my office had part of the second
mortgage, and other members of the syndicate owned
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 13
part of it. My office held about seventeen or eighteen
thousand dollars; the total principal amount of the mort-
gage was $45,000.00. Some of the balance of the notes
were held by Mr. Johnson, Mr. Robin and Mr. Anixter. I
don’t recall how much these various people held. Mr.
Johnson paid us about seventeen thousand dollars which
was the amount due us according to our records. We may
have accepted payment for some of the other members of
the syndicate.
I have seen Government’s Exhibit E-9 for identification
before; they are general records of our office and reflect
the transaction that I have just been discussing.
Q. Can you from this exhibit refresh your recollection
as to how much was paid you on your own behalf or for
anyone else?
A. It would take a little time to analyze this. It is not
broken up that way. It does refresh my recollection of
what happened in connection with this transaction. I
don’t remember how much was paid to me by Johnson
for everybody ; that does not help me. It was the amount
of the second mortgage less the amount of notes that were
not deposited with us. That amount may be $15,000.00.
The notes not deposited with us were possibly the notes
owned by Mr. Johnson. I do know that Mr. Johnson had
previous to this time acquired about $13,000.00 in notes
secured by this second mortgage. In round figures m
testimony means that he paid me $45,000.00, less $13,000.00.
The amount of $32,000.00 would be approximately correct
if all the notes were deposited with us.
24 Q. Did you examine Government’s Exhibit E-9
carefully, Mr. Tavalin? Would that show the dis-
position of all of the notes secured by the second mort-
gage?
A. It shows a good many of them: I would have to
check them out. They are forty-five and some odd notes.
I do not see any of the last numbers on here. It is a fact
that to my best recollection, Mr. Johnson paid for all of the
notes other than the ones that he held himself.
(Witness examines Government’s Exhibit E-9.) Number
3 indicates it was held by Mr. Johnson, amounting to
$5,000.00; 4, 5 and 6 were owned by Mr. Johnson person-
ally. This sheet does not show the amounts.
I was agent of the building at 1201-09 North Dearborn
Street after Johnson acquired title. As agent I collected
14 Bill of Exceptions.
rents aid leased vacant space; operated the property and
rendered monthly statements to Mr. Johnson. I have been
acting as agent performing those duties since January of
1934. I was employed in that capacity by Mr. Johnson
and make reports to him every month.
T know the defendant, William Kelly. ‘I had a business
transaction with him in my office. Mr. Kelly inquired
about the vacant lodge hall space that we had. There were
some negotiations about the amount of the rent and it was
finally determined. They were the usual negotiations when
a prospective tenant leases space. I did lease premises in
that building to Mr. Kelly; it was, I think, either in 1936
or 1987. The record wil show that. [T charged him $450.00
a month; there was no lease made. It Was an arrange-
ment for the vse of the space; no written lease.
25 Extlubits E-15, 16, 17, 18, 19 and 20 are monthly
rental reports rendered by my offer to Mr. Johnson.
They are part of the original records of my office. It
appears that I first rented the premises to the defendant
Kelly about September of 1936. Relying on the record,
I recall that about September, 1936, I made this arrange-
ment with the defendant Kelly. The arrangement was
$450.00 a month and he does his own decorating and repairs
or Whatever is necessary. | don't reeall whether IT made
similar arrangements with anyone else in the buijding. I
did confer with Mr. Johnson in relation to this arrane-
ment with the defendant Kelly; that was prior to turning
over of possession. J] advised Mr. Johnson that I had an
inquiry from a Mr. Kelly and that Mr. Kelly indicated
Mr. Johnson knew him, and I asked if it would be satis-
factory to let him have the space. IT may have told Mr.
Johnson at that time that I did not have a lease for this
tenant. I do not recall that Mr. Johnson said anything
about that. Mr. Kelly took possession of the premises in
1936. It was the second tloor loft at the north end of the
building.
). One room?
A. Well, there may have been some other rooms. We
gave it to him as is; we call it the lodge hall space. It was
approximately 50 by abont 120 or somewheres about that.
I don’t recall discussing any other space which the defend-
ant Kelly was permitted to use under that same arrange-
ment. I think the defendant Kelly used other portions of
the premises subsequent to September, 1936. After the
y of Samuel C. Tavalin. 15
first arrangeme S made for the lodge hall, he used
basement space. is located in. the same part of the
building with the exception that it is in the basement
26 rather than on the second floor. It was about 50 by
120; no additional rent was paid for that room.
I made a second Inortgage on the property under date
ot July 15, 1932: the principal amount was $45,000.00.
There were twenty-one notes issued and secured by that
mortgage; six notes of $5,000.00 each, and fifteen of
$1,000.00 each. On December 20, 1933, at the time John-
son acquired title to this property, he held £15,000.00 in
second mortgage notes. At that time Johnson acquired the
balance of the notes: he acquired the $15,008.00 in notes
during the years 1932 and 1935, 4
I had nothing to do With the first mortgage in the sum
of $160,000.00 after Johnson acquired title. Tt do not think
T made any payments of interest or principal on aeeount
of the first mortgage; my recollection is that I did not.
I have seen Government's Exhibit E-15-A. It is a copy
of the original statement of receipts and disbursements of
the property at Dearborn and Division Streets tor the year
beginning February 1, 1935; these are carbous of the
originals. The originals were forwarded to the owner,
Johuson, the defendant in this case. To the best of my
knowledge, (rovernment’s Exhibit H-15-A is a true and
correct record ot the transactions kept in the usual ordi-
nary course of business and part of the permanent records
of my company at the present time.
Exhibit E-15-A for identification is a duplicate of the
original record of the receipts and disbursements for the
property at Dearborn and Division Streets owned by Mr.
Johnson, for the year January, 1934, to December 31,
27) 1934. 1 forwarded the original of this record to Mr.
Johnson. This record is part of our permanent ree-
ords kept in the usual ordinary course of business, and the
entries made thereon are accurate, to the best of my knowl-
edge, anc reflect the transactions on or about the date they
occurred.
I i.ave seen Government's Exhibit E-17 for identification
before. It is a statement of receipts and disbursements
for the year 1936 and it is a duplicate of the original ree-
ords which were forwarded to Mr. Johnson, and thev are
part of our permanent records kept in the ordinary course
of business and accurately reflect the transactions recorded
thereon on or about the time they occurred.
16 Biil of Exceptions.
I have seen Government’s Exhibit H-18 for identification
before. They are the records of the receipts and disburse-
ments for the year 1937 for the property at Dearborn and
Divisien Streets, and are duplicates of the original records
which were forwarded to Johnson. They are part of the
permanent records of our company and kept in the usual
course of business, and the transactions reflected thereon
are an accurate record of the same had at about the time
they occurred.
I have seen Government’s Exhibit E-19 for identification
before: it is a copy of the original records of the receipts
and disbursements for the property et Dearborn and Divi-
sion Streets for the year 1938 and are duplicates of the
original records; the originals were forwarded to Mr.
Johnsoa. They are a part of our permanent records made
in the usual and ordiaary course of business, and accu-
rately reflect the transactions stated thereon at or
28 about the time they occurred.
I have seen Government's Exhibit E-20 for identi-
fication before. It is a copy of the original records of
the receipts and disbursements for the property at Dear-
born and Division Streets, beginning January, 1989, [tis
a duplicate set of our records: the originals were forwarded
to Mr. Johnson. They are a part of the per:anent records
of our company made in the usual and oy: vary course of
business. and accurately reflect: the transactions stated
thoreon at or about the time they were made.
I know the defendant, William P. Kelly. He occupied
the second floor space at the north end of the building
facing Dearborn Street, known as the lodge hall, the base-
ment in the same building immediately below the restaurant
and a small store at 1203 North Dearborn Street. The store
was ineluded in the rent paid for the other space. This
store ix somewhere between 11 by 15 or 20; it was a cigar
store. The defendant Kelly oceupied that space the last
couple of years. The 1958 records indicate that he oecu-
pied that space. When he started it, I can’t tell withcut
a detailed check. The street number of the store was
1203: there was no other portion of the premises occupied
by Kelly. The defendant Kelly usually brought the rent
into the office: there were some delinquencies from time to
time—he was in arrears at times. At one time it, was
about three months, I recall, and another time four months.
I am not certain of that, however, without referring to
the records. I did not state in what year he was in arrears.
rt po ttutasl
“ale
ee re
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 7
I ean refresh my recollection from examining Govern-
ment’s Exhibit E-18 as to the amount the defendant
29 Kelly was in arrears. It was $1800.00; I did not col-
lect it; the amount of rent was waived. I[ talked to
the defendant Johnson about the arrearage in rent at
about the time the arrears occurred; I don’t remember the
exact words. It was about the time Mr. Kelly started to
pay rent again and Kelly said he wanted to start to pay
rent, but he couldn’t pay up the arrears. This is what 1
told Johnson. He wanted to know if that would be accept-
able; then, there was a general discussion, but the final
decision was to let him go ahead. I think Kelly paid
maybe $100.00 on the arrears; it seemed that the record
indicated a hundred dollar settlement. I can refresh my
recollection from the records; it was settled for a hundred
dollars. Relying on the records, I have a recollection of
making that settlement.
The defendant Kelly was again in arrears in his rent
subsequent to the year 1937. I can’t state when and in
what amount from meiory. I ean refresh my recollection
from Government’s Exhibit E-20. He was in arrears
$1300.00.
The Court: Have you any independent recollection of
that transaction?
A. I do not have an independent recolleetion of that
transaction only that he was in arrears $1300.00. 1 know
that from the records. I know he was in arrears several
times; by several I mean two or three. I would be guess-
ing as to when they were. When he started paying again,
he couldn’t pay up the arrears. He only paid current rent.
I discussed the matter with Mr. Johnson. He said,
‘Well, if he can’t pay up, leave it go.’’
Mr. Miller: Q. Did he again become in arrears in the
payment of his rent after this last time that you have
80 just testified to?
A. Yes, sir. That was in 1940; the latter part of
1939, I think. It was several thousand dollars; 1 would
have to refer to the records. I have no recollection of how
much over two thousand dollars. I can refresh my recol-
lection from Government’s Exhibit E-20. My refreshed
recollection about that is $1305.00. Two thousand dollars
was not ile last one; that was the last one I looked at now,
$1305.06. Before I was talking about a later delinquency.
The amount of $1305.00 was not paid by the defendant
Kelly; it was waived.
¢
¢
18 Bill of Exce tions.
I talked to defendant Johnson about that—just about
the time that Mr. Kelly started to pay rent again. It was
the same like the first default—couldn’t pay. I asked him
what to do about the arrears in rent; Mr. Keily said he
couldn't pay it. There was some discussion about the pos-
sibility of renting the space, or something. Then, because
of the impossibility of getting a new tenant, he decided to
waive it; Johnson told me to waive it. I can refresh my
recollection from examining Government’s Exhibit E-20
as to a further arrearage on the part of the defendant
Kelly. In December of 1959 it was $3150.00 accrued and
owed by the defendant Kelly; nothing was done about that.
I have tried to collect it from Kelly; I have asked him
about it. I didn’t start any procecdings to collect it.
Whenever he was delinquent, he promised to pay as soon
as he could.
I talked to defendant Johnson about the $3150.00 ar-
rearage, in general, not at that particular time in Deecem-
ber of 1939. I had a talk with defendant Johnson in De-
cember of 1939 about payment or collection of the $3150.00
from defendant Kelly. We have had several discussions
about it—some talk about trying to get a new tenant for
the space. It may have been in November or December
21 of 1939 when I asked Johnson about those arrears, if
there was anything I was expected to do about it. He
didn’t think there was any use of taking any action, because
he did not think we could collect. Thet was the substance
of Mr. Johnson's opinion as stated to me.
The defendant Kelly is a tenant in default in the build-
ing at 1205 North Dearborn Street. 1 don’t know what I
would call him. We are looking for a new tenant. The
building custodian, the janitor, is in possession Gf the
premises now, formerly occupied by the defendant Kelly.
I don’t think there is any equipment in the premises;
I have not been in the premises occupied by the defendant
Kelly. I have been in the premises; the last time was
about a year or so ago. There was a lot of furniture,
chairs, tables and equipment referred to as gambling
paraphernalia in the premises the last time I was there.
That equipment was on the second floor—that part of
the premises designated as the lodge hail.
I was in the basement and the cigar store occupied by
the defendant Kelly; thc last time, I would say, was about
a year or so age. It was vacant at the time; I don't recall
whales tg L ap
¢
Pee Ber DORR Preecime Soe b
OA Aimy Wert aN tal Wes we bd
soya
mre ow
are
. ors ea ee any SS a as —— :
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 19
anything being in the room. I have been in the basement
premises when there was something in that room. At that
time there were tables and chairs. There were some writ-
ings on the walls, on the north walls, cardboards and so
forth; the usual type that they have reports from horse
race results, racing results.
I do not have the keys to the premises occupied by the
defendant Kelly; the caretaker of the premises has them;
1 would not know if Kelly has any keys; maybe he has.
I would say that the tenancy is terminatec. I do not
32 xnow if Kelly still has the keys er not. I ordinarily
take b-ck the keys from tenants whose tenancy has
been terminated. ‘
I do not handle any other matters for the defendant,
William R. Johnson.
I know the premises located at Thorndale and Glen-
wood Avenues in Chicago. I managed the premises for
Mr. Johnson.
I have seen Government's Exhibit E-22 for identifica-
tion before. They are reports of the receipts and dis-
bursements for the apartment building located at 1356
Thorndale Avenue, the corner of Glenwood, for the year
beginning December 1, 1935, and ending January 31, 1936.
They ars duplicates of our original records: the originals
were forwarded to Mr. Johnson. These records are kept
by our company in the usual ordinary course of busi-
ness. They accurately reflect the transactions stated
thereon at or about the time they occurred.
I have seen Government's Exhibit E-22 for identifica-
tion before. It is a report of the receipts and disburse-
ments for the property at 1356 and 58 Thorndale, the
corner of Glenwood, for the period beginning January
31st, 1936, and ending December 31, 1936. They are state-
ments of receipts and disbursements, and are duplicates
of the originai records which were forwarded to M r. John-
son. Those records are kept in the usual ordinary course
of business and they accurately reflect the transactions
stated thereon at or abcut the time they occurred, subject
to typographical errors.
have seen Government's Exhibit E-24 for identifiea-
tion before. It is a statement of receipts and disburse-
ments for the property at 1356 Thorndale Avenue, for
the period beginning January 1, 1937, and ending De-
33 «ember 31, 1937. They are duplicates of our original
20 Bill of Exceptions.
records whieh were forwarded to Mr. Johnson. These
records were kept in the usual and ordinary course of
our business and they accurately reflect the transactions
stated thereon at or about the time they occurred.
Government’s Exhibit E-25 for identification is a re-
port of receipts and disbursemeats for the apartment build-
ing located at 1356 Thorndale Avenue, at the corner of
Glenwood, for the period beginning January 1, 1938, and
ending December 31, 1938. They are duplicates of the
original records; the original records having been for-
warded to Mr. Johnson. These records were kept in the
usual and ordinary course of business and accurately re-
flect the transactions stated theron at or about the time
they occurred.
Government’s Exhibit E-26 for identification is a copy
of a report of receipts and disbursements for the apart-
ment building at 1356-58 Thorndale Avenue, corner of
Glenwood, for the period beginning January, 1939, and
ending February, 1939.
(Thereupon Mr. Thompson stated that he will admit
that the witness will answer the qualifying questions the
same as he has answered all the others.)
1 see the defendant, William R. Johnson, in the court
room, the man that is now standing up.
When Mr. Kelly, the defendant, paid rent to me, it was
sometimes in cash and sometimes by check; I am not cer-
tain about that.
I have seen Government’s Exhibit E-7 for identifica-
tion before. It bears my signature. I have heard of
34 the Harlem Stables; I know of it. I think I have been
there; it is on Harlem Avenue near Irving Park Boule-
vard. The purpose ef my visit there was for recreation
and to try and win some money in the slot machines. I
did not play anything but the slot machines. There were
a lot of people there, tables, gambling paraphernalia:
tables they play dice on, roulette. There may have been
something else; I did not pay any particular attention.
I imagine I did see someone there that I knew. There
were a lot of people there that I knew; I saw Mr. Johnson
there. I don’t recall seeing anybody else that may have
been there. I think I visited the Harlem Stables two or
three times in all. I don’t think Mr. Johnson was there
at each occasion. I just visited around, spent a little
time and went away. I saw a lot of people that I knew,
De
sf —_ 2 =
—_ SF ean ORR ETERS, emer
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 21
friends. I may have seen some of the people in this court
room there; i am not absolutely certain. I may have
seen the gentleman at the end there. (Indicating the de-
fendant, James A. Hartigan.) I talked to the defendant
Johnson on the occasion of my visit to the Harlem Stables
when he was there. The conversation was, ‘‘Hello’’ and
‘‘How are you”’ and ‘‘How is business,’’ the usual con-
versation. There may have been something pertaining to
the building; I don’t recall offhand. I don’t think I met
him there by appointment. When [ saw Mr. Johnson at
the Harlem Stables, he was standing around talking to
people.
The space oceupied by the defendant Kelly wes vacant
for a year prior to his occupancy. There was typical
lodge hall equipment on the second floor and the basement
when they were occupied. The lodge hall equipment was
removed when the lodge vacated the premises. I ihink it
was in 1934 or 1935, but our records wiil show that, I
30 think. My best recollection is that it Was vacant for
about a year. The cigar store occupied by the defend-
ant Kelly was vacant for about six months or a vear, prior
to Kelly being in those premises. Prior to the vacaney
there was a lingerie shop or beauty parlor. Prior to the
time Kelly occupied the premises, people had been in
the building accused of gambling. They occupied the base-
ment space under the Division Street Stores. T was man-
ager of the building at that time: ] Was managing the
building for Mr. Johnson. I don't recall who occupied
the premises just described.
Cross-Eramination by Mr. Thompson.
I have lived in Chicago thirty-four years. During that
period [ have been in the rea] estate investment business
over fifteen vears. General Mortgage Investments is a
corporation. I have been connected with that coneern
since 1928; I am president and principal owner of it. I
transact all my business through the corporation. This
corporation not only deals in mortgages, but also manages
properties. We have close to forty employees, My busi-
ness address is 33 North LaSalle Street. T have been lo-
eated in that building since 1933, commonly known as the
Foreman Bank Building or the American National Bank
Building, right across the corner from the City Hall. I
22 Pill of Exceptions.
moved into that building in 1933; the building was several
years old at that time.
I have known Mr. Johnson for approximately twenty-
five years. I first made his acquaintance—so that I could
really say I had an acquaintance with him—in 1925. I
was never in business with Mr. Johnson; that was
56 when I started this joint venture in this real estate
business I was talking about. That is the only prop-
erty that I ever purchased jointly with Mr. Johnson. Mr.
Leo Field brought the deal to me. The property is lo-
cated at the northeast corner of Dearborn and Division
Streets. It has two fronts; approximately 130 feet on Di-
vision Street and 120 feet on Dearborn Street. The first
floor consists of stores; the second floor is offices and
lodge hall; and the third floor is furnished apartments;
and then the basement. There is an entrance to these
premises from both streets. There is a separate entrance
for the basement from Dearborn Street. The same thing
is true on Division Street. The entrance from the out-
side into the basement is separate from the entrance to
the first floor of the building on both streets. There is uo
elevator in the building. There are nineteen apartments
on the third floor; one room furnished kitchenette; some
are kitchenette and some are just bedrooms. They have
been occupied more or less during the time I have been
managing the building, always as apartments; no other
occupancy of the third floor except as apartments. The
second fioor has offices besides the lodge hall and the
later gambling parlor. There are doctor's offices; at one
time there was a beauty parlor up there; but the principal
tenants are doctors. The offices are on both Dearborn
and Division Street frontage. The lodge hall is located in
the north end of the building with an entrance from Dear-
bern Street; it is a walk up. The Lincoln Park Chapter
of the Masonic Lodge oceupied the premises from the time
the building was built until about 1934 or 1935. My
37 understanding is that the Masons rented their space.
The highest rent, I think, they paid was $425.00, and
then it dropped to $65.00. At one time it was $425.00
and then laier they gave up some of the time and they
only used it for certain evenings, for which they paid
$65.00. The rent was graduated down as times got tougner
and the percentage of ocenpancy was decreased and ad-
justments were made in their rent as these conditions
ee ae ee
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 23
changed. So far as I know, there were never any gambling
parlors up on the second floor in these lodge quarters prior
to the time Mr. Kelly occupied the premises. The premises
were empty approximately about a year when Mr. Kelly
came to rent them. I did not know him when he first came
to talk to me about it. I asked him what he intended
to use it for and he said he wanted to run a club room.
I asked him about what kind of a membership he was go-
ing to have and he said, ‘‘ Well, they play Keno and cards.’’
That is what his answer was. I didn’t rent it to him; I
asked him for references and he said that the owner of
the building knew of him, so I thought before asking any
further questions I would cousult with Mr. Johnson. T
did consult him. I think it was by mutval agreement. be-
tween Mr. Kelly and myself that the amount to be charged
for rent for the premises was fixed. I think the Way it
was, we dickered on the price and finally agreed on $450.00
a month. I think it was about September, 1936, when
he went into those premises. He paid his rent usually
in advance. All rent is due and payable in advance at
the first of the month; that was our usual practice with
all of our tenants, and the same arrangement with
38 Mr. Kelly in that respect as with the other tenants.
He paid his rent fairly regularly as Jong as he was
operating his business there. During the time that he got
in arrears, they were not using the premises. I don’t know
whether he was out of business, but his equipment was
there; he just didn't pay. I would not know if he did op-
erate; [am not at the building that often to express an
epinion on that. He said business was bad and he didn't
have it to pay when I asked him about the rent. I think
that the $1,300.00 due for one period was waived entirely.
The balance owing in December of 1939 was $3.100.00;
that would be seven months; that would make it about
May. I heard that he was not running his elub up there;
I didn’t go up to see. I got that information from the
caretaker of the premises.
In the last three or four years we were managing from
sixty to one hundred properties; I visited these properties
myself more or less frequently. I have thirty or forty
employees; some of them visit the properties too, more
often than I do. I am the general executive head of this
business and the details are left to my employees. When a
man ceases to be a tenant and turns in his keys, he does not
24 Pill of Exceptions.
come and turn them in to me personally. He would gener-
ally hand his keys to the caretaker of the premises when he
iett. We often have tenants who leave the premises without
leaving the keys; we have io have new keys made pretty
frequently. I do not know whether Mr. Kelly turned in his
keys or not. I know the caretaker has access to the prem-
ises; he would not always have access to the premises
39 if a tenant was in there; I do not know what the ar-
rangement was in that respect; there was no special
arrangement. I know that the caretaker did not go in and
out of these premises at will; I know that he didn’t.
This cigar store was just an ordinary cigar store, so far
us I could see, and previous to that, had been a little beauty
parlor.
A horse parlor is a place where they make bets on horses;
I have heard those terms. When Mr. Kelly oceupied the
premises it appeared to me that there was a blackboard
down there with horses’ names on it, odds, and so on. I
have never bet on a horse in my life. I think it had names
on it that looked like they might be horses’ names; I did
not examine them closely. I didn’t pay any attention to
them when I walked in there, but if you ask for an ex-
pression, that is what I would say. This horse parlor had
the use of the upstairs and basement premises. The $450.00
a month rent didn’t start out including the basement and
cigar store, but it gradually developed that way. It started
out with just the lodge hall; the basement was used as a
temporary accommodation. I couldn’t say how long the
basement was occupied; sometimes for a week. Prior to
the occupancy of Mr. Kelly, the Lincoln Park Chapter oc-
cupied the basement for their restaurant equipment, ban-
quet hall. It was used in connection with the lodge hall
prior to Mr. Kelly’s occupying the premises. The basement
premises may have been occupied temporarily prior to Mr.
Kelly’s occupancy by a former tenant that had some trouble
with water leaks in the other space, and we may have let
him use it temporarily while it was getting fixed; no
40 special arrangements. I am quite sure there were
several other lodges that occunied this lodge hall jointly
with the Masonic Chapter after the Masons started using
it only on part time. There was a space under the Division
Street frontage occupied as a billiard hall for a while that
was accused of running a gambling house in the space. I
do not know what kind of gambling was going on there.
It was not any of these defendants so far as I know. I
L.
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 25
think it was in 1935 and also in 1936 that there were charges
that this billiard hall was also a gambling place. There
was quite a turnover in the tenancy of that space. There
were several tenants: I can’t recall their names. There
were none of these defendants so far as I know. Whenever
there was space, I would say over a hundred dollars in-
volved per month, I would usually consult Mr. Johnson;
usually consulted on the stores and basement, but the of-
fices and apartments I used my own judgment. I remem-
ber consulting him particularly about the rental of this
billiard parlor space down there in the basement on Divi-
sion Street. I don’t remember the name of the tenant that
I discussed with him about the rental of that space. I am
still managing this property for Mr. Johnson; this property
was bought in 1925. We paid close to $400,000.00 for it.
About $100,000.00 was paid in cash, and there would be a
balance of roughly $300,000.00 in a mortgage. That was
jointly owned by this syndicate clear through to 1933. I
do not think the syndicate changed during the eight-year
period from 1925 to 1933. There were different percentages
of ownership. Mr. Johnson had a fourth interest in 1925.
He put up a fourth of the cash payment—about $25,-
41 000.00, and he had a fourth interest in the equity of the
property then, subject to the mortgage. The first mort-
gage was already on the property; the second, I think, was
signed by the trustee. I am not quite sure about that.
The trustee, as [ recall it, was the Foreman Bank.
From time to time Mr. Johnson aequired $15,000.00 of
the second mortgage notes, and in 1933 he took over the
property and settled with the other owners of the various
interests. He took it subject to the mortgages. I think
he got an assignment of the certificates of beneficial inter-
ests which were subject to the ontstanding mortgage obliga-
tions. He bought the remaining ontstanding second mort-
vage notes at some discount. It was just a small, nominal
discount, T would say. He paid somewhere about $32,-
00.00 for these mortgage notes, or $30,000.00.
I did not talk to anvbody about my testimony in this
ease after T was excused from the stand at the close of court
yesterday afternoon. Before I eame back on the stand this
morning, I did talk with Mr. Miller, the Assistant United
States Attorney, just for a minute.
I looked over these ledger sheets; that is, this morning.
I am not managing any other property now for Mr. John-
son. Previously J did manage this Thorndale and Glen-
26 : Bill of Exceptions.
wood premises; that was an apartment building. It is a
three-story apartment building containing three fives, nine
four room apartments, and a basement flat. My only con-
nection with it is managing the property.
I do not know who operates or owns the Harlem Stables;
I never managed it. It looks like a stables.
42 The documents marked Government’s Exhibits E-15
to K-20, inclusive, relating to the Dearborn and Divi-
sion Street property, are records of our office. They are
earbon copies of reports sent to Mr. Johnson. These are
not the original entries that were .uade in our books. When
a tenant brought in some rent, this sheet was not made up
right then and there. That sheet was made up from the
receipt book; the cashier made that up: I am not cashier.
All the cashier did was to issue a receipt when she received
some rents; that is what the cashier was supposed to do
under my instructions. After the cashier issued a receipt
to the payer of rent, the bookkeeping machine operator
would enter it on the monthly statement, on the same day
or the next day. Her source of information to make ner
entries was a copy of the receipt. There were ten receipts
to a book and the carbon copy remains in the book. I think
the procedure is that the bookkeeper that operated the
bookkeeping machine took these carbon sheets and made her
entries on the monthly reports. Frankly, I am not sure
that that was the procedure; that is an accountant problem
that I leave to an accountant to take eare of. I think that
is the wav it works, and what IT meant to say when T was
talking about these records, is that I think these records
are out of our office. They look like our records that we
delivered. When I took one of these documents and at the
request of the United States Attorney, thumbed it through
from the first page to the last. I didn’t know any more about
it then when T handled the whole thing. By thumbing
43 it through, I could see that they had General Mortgage
at the top of the sheet. I would not identify these
simply because they said General Mortgage Company at
the top of the sheet. Some of the names there indicated
the names of the tenants that we had. What I mean to say
is that I looked at all these sheets and they looked like they
came out of our office. T don’t know anything about whether
these entries are correct or not, except that I hone they
are. In other words, these went throngh our office in the
regnlar routine. These are not original records at all; they
are copies. This is a copy of the monthly rental statements
;
;
7
ef
'
——_ Se ae ee
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 27
that was sent to Mr. Johnson, and as far as I know, ac-
curately reflects what took place on these sheets of paper.
I do not know that T have a personal knowledge of all these
different transactions; it is cutting it pretty fine.
C. and A. Kosinski had a cafeteria. It occupied the first
floor space at the north end of the building facing Dear
born Street. Mr. and Mrs. Kosinski were the interested
persons. The name was (. and A. Kosinski and they ran
a cafeteria. They got behind in their rent; this record
shows $4810.00. They were behind $4810.00 in April, 1935;
I didn’t collect all that. I talked to Mr. Johnson about it.
He said, if you can’t collect it, forget about it—about the
same thing that he said about Mr. Kelly.
Somebody else got behind in their rent up there; there
were quite a few—an epidemic there was for a while. Mr.
Johnson said, do the best you can.
44 The Lineoln Park Chapter got behind in their rent;
that is the Masonie Lodge. In September, 1934, they
were behind $2700.00. We had a lot of tronble with them,
since 1931, I think. By that I mean, they got broke and
couldn’t pay their bills. I didn’t collect that $2750.00 in
September, 1934. I don’t remember if I settled it: T wiil
have to refer further to the records. TI do not think T col-
lected it. We may have settled it for a nominal amount.
mavbe one hnndred dollars.
I talked to Mr. Johnson about that. He told me to forget
about this Mason Lodge that wasn’t paying its rent. He
didn’t tell me to sue them. From the report I gave him
about Kosinski, there wasn’t anything else to do but to
forget abont it: that is what he said. He said there wasn't
anything else to do abont it excent to forget abont it; the
same thing he did with Mr. Kelly.
45 C. & A. Cafeteria, Ine., are not the same people as
(. & A. Kosinsky on previous accounts. (. & A. Cafe-
teria, Ine. were in arrears $1066.00. (C. & A. Kosinksv oc-
eupied the first floor, North end of the building, Dearborn
Street frontage. CC. & A. Cafeteria occupied the same
space. The (. & A. Cafeteria, Inc., was a successor in
oeeupaney ef the C. & A. Kosinskv space. By April, 193%,
(.& A. Cafeteria, Inc., was $2760.10 in arrears. Thev never
did pay that. I did talk to Mr. Johnson abont it. We dis-
cussed the possibility of effecting collection and he asked
for my recommendation and T was of the opinion that he
could not coliect it. We did not file any suit. We decided
it was not worth while.
28 Bill of Exceptions.
On Exhibit 16, in August, we find the account of Mr.
Silverman. He runs a cleaning and dyeing shop and oc-
cupied stere #16 on Division Street side. In August, 1934,
he was $1121.57 in arrears. The next month the same ten-
ant does not show any arrears. He did not pay the arrears.
It was waived. I talked with Mr. Johnson about waiving
this indebtedness and he agreed to that proposition. Mr.
Silverman continued to occupy the space and continued to
pay his current rent. The yellow carbon sheet following
there is a carbon copy of a letter I wrote to Mr. Johnson,
dated October 2, 1934. I mentioned the Silverman account
in there. I tcld him that the account was in arrears and
that I could not collect it. I told him ‘‘While it is not our
accounts yet I didn’t think I could collect them, and T ought
tu write them off as a dead account.
46 In that same letter I mentioned a Mr. Brizac. He
was $600.00 in arrears at that time. The August state-
ment shows no arrears. I think the $600.00 account was
written off at the end of August. In the letter I said there
is no use carrying those aecounts, that T ean net collect
them. Mr. Brizae continued to occupy space. 1.'s busi-
ness was a French Foed Shop.
Exhibit 18 was for che vear 1937, which is three years
later. Turning to April, it shows his new arrears are
$500.00. In other words, after writing off $600.00, he got
into Mr. Johnson another $500.00. T do not recall collecting
this.
Turning to the first page, January, of Exhibit 20, we
find Mrs. Rose’s Restaurant there. She occupied the
cafeteria space, the first floor, Dearborn Street frontage.
In other words, Mrs. Rose had moved into the place where
the C. & A. Cafeteria had moved eut, and by January, 1939,
she had #2.594.72 in accumulated arrearages. She did not
pay. She finally moved out, too. 1 think she went hbank-
rupt. I did talk to Mr. Johnson about trying to collect that
account.
Looking at Exhibit 25, which is for January, 1938, I
there find the acccunt of one Walsh. He occupied an apart-
ment at 1358 Thorndale. That is getting out to the other
property now. By January, 1938, he had an accumulated
Ep) Ee Oe ON
er
mh Oe A 8
pence IIS
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 29
arrearage of $355.00. Turning to September, 1938, it shows
that he vacated, owing $320.00. I do not remember if we
collected it. I think we did talk to Mr. Johnson about those
little accounts. I do not remember what he said about them.
Mr. Johnson did not pay any attention to the details as to
the renting of the apartments. That is what he hired us
for. We sent him statements every month. He did not ex-
amine our books. He did not come around and talk to us
about each one of these tenants when he would get one of
these statements. He only talked to me about these matters
whe: I nad a large problem, and I submitted that to him
for his consideration. My relations with Mr. Johnson in the
matter of managing his property were very much the
47 same routine relations I had with other owners whose
properties I managed. When I could not cellect the
rent, I wrote it off.
Mr. Miller: If your Honor please, the Government would
ike to offer in evidence GOVERNMENT’S EXHIBITS
E-9, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25 and 26.
Mr. Thompson: We object to receiving in evidence Gov-
ernment’s Exhibits 15, 16, 17, 18, 19 and 20 for identifiea-
tion, which are those voluminous monthly rental reports,
on the ground that proper foundation has not been laid for
the receipt of the documents, on the ground that the docu-
ments contain on many pages matters which have no refer-
ence to any of the issues made by the indictment in this case.
If the object is to show the net income from these prop-
erties paid to Mr. Johnson for the various vears, it is a
simple matter of computation without all this irrelevent
and immaterial detail in here. The documents, we submit,
are confusing and will lend no information as such.
Our point, principally, is the one first made, no founda-
tion has been laid to show that these are original records
at all.
Mr. Callaghan: While your Honor is considering those
documents, I would like to make the additional objection,
so far as the other defendants are concerned, that they are
not bound by the entries in those documents, no connection
to show that there is any association with these defendants
with anything contained in those documents.
30 Bill of Exceptions.
48 Examination by the Court.
Referring to these papers, marked respectively Govern-
ment’s Exhibits E-15-A, for identification; E-16, E-17,
E-18, E-19, and E-20, each for identification, are copies of
the monthly statements furnished to the owner of the build-
ing, showing receipts and disbursements. They were usu-
ally made at the end of each month. The bookkeeper made
up the monthiy records, an orjginal and a duplicate. That
is all. We sent the origina! to the owner and filed the dupli-
cate in our files. We always do that at all times. We made
up reports once a month to send to our customers. We sent
the original to the customer and filed the copy in our office.
We do that so in case we have to refer to them regarding
some disbursements er receipts, we would have a record
of what we send to our customers. That is what these
papers are. These are papers whieh we copied in our office.
Mr. Thompsen: We would like to know whether this wit-
ness did the mailing or what he knew about it.
The Court: That does not make a particle of ditfer-
ence. I think I have asked him everything the statute says
is necessary to make them admissible.
Mr. Thompson: Well, it is vour Honor that is ruling. I
have made my objection.
The Court: T will be glad to have you call my attention
to anything the statute specifies which I have omitted.
Thereupon the objection to the admission in evidence of
Government's Eixhibits ky15-A, E-16, E-17, E-18, E19 and
E-20 was overruled.
49 Mr. Thompsun: As to documents identified as Gov-
ernment’s Exhibits E-22 to E-26, incinsive, which are
income and disbursement sheets with respect to this prop-
erty at Thorndale and Glenwood, we object. No proper
foundation has been laid for the receipt of such documents.
The documents are not the best evidence of the transac-
tions alleged to be reported therein, and the documents ¢on-
tain pages and pages of matter which has no relation to any
issue made by the indictment in this case. The papers con-
tain matter that is immaterial, matter which vou are ad-
mitting. It is confusing.
The Court: Q. Now, Mr. Witness, if [ asked vou with
respect to all of these exhibits, E-22, 23, 24, 25, and 26, for
identification, the same questions which I asked you with
;
4
3
= lS =
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 31
respect to those exhibits I asked you about a few moments
ago, would you make the same answers?
The Witness: <A. Yes, sir.
Thereupon the objections were overruled and the exhibits
received in evidence.
D0 Cross-Examination by Mr. Thompson (Continued).
Referring to Government’s Exhibit 9, the sheet marked
1,2 and 3, is the ledger account of the syndicate which owned
this property prior to its purchase by Mr. Johnson. This
is the ledger account showing the distribution of the sec-
ond mortgage that was made. This shows what the Gen-
eral Mortgage Company did with the $45,000 of the mort-
gage proceeds of the loan. It is a ledger account, entitled
‘*Tavelin-Robin, et al.’’. That is the name of the borrower.
Robin and Tavelin were operating on behalf of this syndi-
‘ate, and that shows distribution of this $45,000 loan, of
which I think Mr. Jehnson had $15,000. This next group
of sheets, marked ‘*‘Sheet Number 9°" is marked ** Purchase
account’’, headed by the same names. It shows purchase
of these notes by several! people. The next sheet, which is
marked ** Number 415°’, headed, ‘* Real Estate Loan Regis-
ter’’, which consists of four pages, three of which have some
writing on them, shows he numbers of the individual notes,
the amounts, the date when some payments were made, legal
description of the land, regarding the documents on the
trust deed. That all relates to the Dearborn and Division
street property. The sheet shows a lot of other things, too.
Julius Anixter, whose name appears on several sheets,
Was the owner of several of the notes. The matter at the
top, about North River and Bosten, is the name of the in-
surance companies in Which the insuratice is carried. None
of the writing on these pages is mine. The clerks in charge
at the time wrote it on there. I know some of the clerks who
wrete it. Different clerks wrete on these sheets. They
are ledger sheets. I do not know if they were transferred
trom the books of original entry. I don’t think this is the
original records, but the other records there are supporting
records, at ieast a supporting memoranda, from which that
ledger sheet was made. I do not know what al! of those
were.
ol It has been several weeks since I saw these docu-
ments exhibited to me here in Court. They were taker
from my office about two or three weeks ago. They were
32 Bill of Exceptions.
first taken four or five months ago. The first time they
were returned to my office immediately. I was in the Dis-
trict Attorney's office, and they sent one of the men over to
our office to get the records, aud he came back with them,
and when I left, they sent records back with our hookkeeper.
Mr. Clifford and another gentleman were in the office and
looked them over. They examined them. This may have
been a month ago, and later they were called for. They
may have been here ever since.
Examination by the Court.
The first three sheets of Government’s Exhibit E-9, shows
the disbursement of the proceeds of the second mortgage
that was made on the property. The third sheet, ‘‘Num-
ber 1°’, is different from the first two sheets. I think that
is more of a memorandum account, showing the purchase
of individual notes. These three sheets I think are from
the ledger in our office, the General Mortgage Investments.
The last two sheets are from the real estate loan register
that is kept in our office. Every mortgage loan we meade
we have a loan register sheet, which indice ites the amount
of ithe loan, the date, the recording numbers of the docu-
ment and Insurance policies, and the persons to whom notes
were sold. In this case, Exhibit 9, there are twenty-one
notes. There were six $5,000 notes and fifteen $1,000 notes,
making twenty-one notes altogether. We make out such
sheets on respective loans handled in our office. The entries
are made at the time the loan is set up on our books. These
entries reflect the transaction as it actually oecurred, and
these two sheets headed, ** Real Estate Loan Register’’ are
made in pursuance of that praccice in our office. The per-
son that prepares the mortgage documents for signature
also makes up the office records, so that when the mortgage
is signed and the file goes to the accounting department,
the accounting department knows the nature of the
o2 transaction. When insurance policies come in they are
noted on the register. The ledger sheets reflect the
proceeds of the mortgage loan. It shows what we did with
the money. The entries are made about the time that the
cheeks are issued, about the time the transaction is shown
by the entries. The entries are correct. That is the prac-
tice in our office. In respeet of all transactions of that
kind that come in to our office, these three sheets were made
in pursuance of that practice in our office.
Thereupon the Court admitted in evidence the GOY-
ERNMENT’S EXHIBIT E-9.
ff
ye sere,
oo ye,
= A EA EI LL LL
ware Ww =
Testimony of Samuel C. Tavalin. 33
Redirect Examination by Mr. Miller.
The store occupied by Mrs. Rhode’s Restaurant and the
(. & A. Cafeteria takes in 1209 or 1211 Dearborn, and I
think probably takes in 13 also. Government’s Exhibit
E-20 would show street number at which Mrs. Rhode’s
Restaurant was located. It show 1207-9. That is the store
at the North end of the building facing Dearborn Street.
It is approximately 50 by 120. It was not the cigar store
that I talked about earlier.
Referring to Government’s Exhibit E-20 in April, 1939,
three lines from the bottom of this page it says **Store’’, in
the second column. The numbers ave 1207 and 1209. That
record indicates who at that time occupied that store. It
says ‘*W. Welly’’, ** Included in lodge hall rent’’. Refer-
ring to the same Exhibi., E-20, in January of 1939, three
lines from the bottom of the page vou have ‘*Store’’, ‘¢1207-
1209"". It says ** Mrs Rhodes*’ ** Restaurant’’.
Q. Would vou say from that record, then, that Mr.
Kelly at one time occupied the same premises that Mrs.
Rhode’s restaurant and the C. & A. Cafeteria occupied?
A. I know they never did.
I recognize the property pictured on Government's Ex-
hibit O-2—-that is the north end of the building: at
038 Dearborn and Division street. It reveals the first,
second and third floors facing Dearborn street. Re-
ferring to Exhibic 0-2 and the floor level even with the
street, there is a door that is 1207. That is the same
restaurant premises eceupied formerly by Mrs. Rhode’s
Restaurant. The defendant Kelly never did oceupy the
premises known as 1201 and 1209 in that building. That is
the first floor. 1 do know how I designated the second floor
premises on our records oecupied by the defendant Kelly.
We referred to it as the lodge hall space. 1 am not certain
whether we did or did not ever allow the C. & A. cafeteria,
C. & A. Kosinsky, Lincoln Park Chapter, Silverman and
Brizac to use another portion of the premises other than
the one that they originally leased. I do not think they
ever did. Silverman may have, while the store was being
remodeled. If I remember definitely now, as we are telkine
about it, Silverman had the space on Dearborn street when
the store he was leasing was being remodeled. T allowed
him to use another space during that time. That is the
only occasion that I remember right now.
34 Bill of Exceptions.
Government's O-3 for identification, is a one story brick
building, garage doors on the side, and a sign indicating
the Harlem Stables. I think I recognize that as the place
I described for counsel for the defense as being the Harlem
Stables. I was there at night and I am not sure that this
is the building. Government’s Exhibit 0-4 looks like the
place. It looks like the Harlem Stables that I testified that
I visited. I never did visit any other gambling establish-
ment, to my knowledge. I did visit the Horse Shoe—may
be six months or a year ago. Two or three times in the
period, three or four years. I, have seen the defendant.
Johnson, at the Horse Shoo. I do not think I was ever at
the Lincoln Tavern. When I wanted to talk to defendant
Johnson I called him on the telephone at home. I do not
recall anything urgent that required any other eall. I am
not certain if I did or not call the defendant Johnson at the
Horse Shoe Restaurant. I-don’t think I ever called him
dt at the D.& D. I do not remember if I ever called any
of those places and left any message for him. When
I saw the defendant Johnson at the Horse Shoe he was
standing around and talking to people.
BENJAMIN G. KILPATRICK, being duly sworn, testified
as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Hurley.
I live at 6151 Winthrop Avenue. I am associated with
the American National Bank & Trust Company as As-
sistant Vice President, a little more than nine vears. My
signature appears on Government's Exhibit E-7 for iden-
tification. That document was executed on or about the
date it bears, February 14, 1934. To the best of my recol-
lection the other signatures appearing thereon were placed
there in my presence. The dates and the first paragraph
of the document is in my handwriting. Trust Number 2691
is now being executed by the bank in which I am emiployed.
The title is held by the bank for the benefit of William R.
Johnson. Government’s Exhibit E-7, for identification, is
part of the file of the American National Bank & Trust
Company, and was produced here by the request of the
Government.
ea | ————
eer me;
Testimony of Roy We''z. 39
Cross-Examination by Mr. Thompson.
This trust was epened January 2, 1934. I believe there
was no previous trust which this bank succeeded. I was
with the Foreman National Bank prior to going with this
bank. This covered the property at the Northeast corner
of Dearbern and Division street. I have no recollection
whether or not, prior to 1934, a syndicate owned this prop-
erty which had a trust agreement arrangement with the
old Foreman National Bank. All I know is that there is
such a trust. This is an assignment of a beneficial interest
by Mr. Tavelin and Mr. Johnson. It is a 45/120th
92 interest and also an assignment by John E. John-
son of 75/120ths.
Redirect Examination by Mr. Hurley.
I believe vou did ask me whether or not this document
was executed in my presence. These signatures appearing
thereon, Mr. Tavelin and William R. Johnson, were placed
thereon in my presence. My recollection is that they were
beth present.
Thereupon GOVERNMENT'S EXHIBIT E-7 was re-
ceived in evidence.
ROY WOLTZ, being duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr, Hurley.
I live at 203 Fifth Street, Wilmette. T am the manager
of the mortgage loan department of the First Management
Corporation, located at 135 South LaSalle. I have been
connected with the First Management Corporation since its
inception. I know William R. Johnson. I see him here in
the courtroom (indicating the defendant). I saw William
R. Johnson on or about December 27, 1934, in our office at
10 South LaSalle Street, Chicago. I had a talk with him
at that time. He stated that he had a mortgage on some
property at Dearborn and Division, and wanted to know if
we would extend that mortgage for a year in its present
amount. As I recall, the amount was $140,000. He wanted
to extend it for a year.
Thereupon the Court ruled on objection that this con-
36 Bill of Exceptions.
ees would be received against the defendant Johnson
only.
The Witness continues: I said I couldn’t extend it in
that amount. He wanted $125,000. He then said, ‘‘If I
pay $75,000, would you extend the balance for a year’’, and
I said, ‘*Yes.’’ The $75,000 was paid by the defendant
56 William R. Johnson about the first week of Apri!, 1935.
It was in the form of a cashier’s check on the Northern
Trust Company. The balance of $50,000.00 was paid about
a year later. As far as I know, it was paid by the defend-
ant, William R. Johnson. I did not receive it, but I know
the mortgage has been paid.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Thompson.
This mortgage was on the property up there at Dearborn
and Division Street.
R. H. KRAMMES, being duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Hurley.
I live at 1332 East Marquette Road, Chicazo. I am vice-
president of the First Management Corporation, located
at 135 South LaSalle Street. I have been associated with
the First Management about eight or nine years. Gov-
ernment’s Exhibit E-12 is our record of a mortgage loan
made on property at the northeast corner of Dearborn and
Division Streets, Chicago. The entries appearing thereon
were placed under my supervision and direction, and they
were made on or about the date the entries bear, in the
regular course of business, and those entries are true and
correct.
Mr. Hurley: I now offer GOVERNMENT'S EXHIBIT
F-12 for identification in evidence.
Mr. Thompson: I object to the document as immaterial,
no identification with any defendant in this case. The
defendants are not bound by the entries there.
The Court: Overruled.
Testimony of Helen J. Norton. 37
HELEN NORTON, testified further as follows:
-
‘i Direct Examination by Mr. Hurley.
I am the same Helen Norton who testified in this case
57 adavorsoago. At that time I stated I was the chief
in charge of the assessment lists in the office of the
Collector of Internal Revenue in the City of Chicago.
Government’s Exhibit R-14. for identification, was filed in
the office of the Collector of Internal Revenue of the Citv of
Chicago. The stamp appearing in the upper right-hand
corner indicates the receivine date of the return in the
Collector’s Office March 13, 1935. The other stamp in the
upper right hand corner is March 13, 1935, and indicates the
date payment was depusited in the bank bv the Collector.
The serial number appearing on the Exhibit is 624472.
The blue figure in the upper right hand corner is the pay-
ment, represents the payment made with the tax return.
That is placed there by the Collector’s Office and also the
red circle indicating the tax to be assessed. The red check
marks are placed there in the Collector’s office. The
stamp has been placed there by the Collector’s Office.
Government’s Exhibit R-15. for identification, was filed in
the office of the Collector of Internal Revenue of Chicago.
That is the individual tax return for William P. Kelly for
the calendar vear 1935. Government’s Exhibit R-16. for
identification, an income tax return, was filed in the office of
the Collector of Internal Revenue of Chicago for the eal-
endar year 1936. Government’s Exhibit R-17, for identi-
fication, an individual income tax return. was filed in the
office of the Collector of Internal Revenne in Chieago fer
the calendar year 1937. Government’s Exhibit, R-18, for
identification, an individua] income tax return for the cal-
endar vear 1938, was filed in the office of the Collector of
Internal Revenue in Chicago. Government's Exhibit. R-19,
for identification, an individual income tax return for the
calendar year 1939, was filed in the office of the Collector of
Internal Revenue of Chicago. Government Exhibit
58 R-35, an individual income tax return for the calendar
year 1932, was filed in the office of the Collector of In-
ternal Revenue of Chicago on or about July 15, 1933. Gov-
ernment’s Exhibit, R-36 for identification, an individual in-
come tax return for the vear 1933, was filed in the office of
the Collector of Internal Revenue of Chicago on Marck 8,
38 Bill of Exceptions.
1934. Government’s Exhibit R-37, for identification, an in-
dividual income tax return for the calendar year 1934, was
filed in the office of the Collector of Internal Revenue in
Chicago on March 13, 1935. Government’s Exhibit, R-38,
for identification, an individual income tax return, was filed
in the office of the Collector of Internal Revenue on March
16, 1936. Government’s Exhibit, R39, an individual in-
come tax return for the calendar year 1936, was filed in the
office of the Collector of Internal Revenue for the City of
Chicago. on March 6, 1937. Government’s Exhibit R-40,
for identification, an individual income tax return for the
calendar year 1937, was filed in the office of the Collector of
Internal Révenue for the City of Chicago March 14, 1932.
Government’s Exhibit R-41, for identification, an individual
income tax return for the calendar year 1938, was filed in the
office of the Collector of Internal Revenue in Chicago on
March 15, 1939. Government’s Exhibit, R-42, for identi-
fication. an individual income tax return for the calendar
vear 1939, was filed in the office of the Collector of Internal
Revenue in Chicago, March 15, 1949. Government’s Ex-
hibit R-58, for identification, an income tax return, was
filed in the office of the Collector of Internal Revenue on
March & 1934. Government’s Exhibit, R-59, for identifi-
cation, an individual income tax return for the calendar
rear 1934, was filed in the office of the Collector of Internal
Revenue of Chicago on March 15, 1935. Government ’s Ex-
hibit R-60, for identification, an individua! income tax re-
turn for the calendar year 1935; was filed in the office of the
Collector of Internal Revenue on March 16, 1936. An in-
dividual income tax return for the year 1936 marked
59 Government's Exhibit R-61, was filed in the office of
the Collecter of Internal Revenue of Chicago on March
13, 1937.
Gervernment's Exhibit R-62, for identification. an indi-
vidual income tax return for the calendar year 1937, was
Aled in the office of the Collector of Internal Revenue on
March 14. 1938. Government's Exhibit R-63 for identifi-
ecaticn. an income tax return for the calendar year 193%.
was filed in the office of Collector of Internal Revenue of
Chicago on March 14, 1939. Government's Exhibit R-f4
for identification, an income tax return for the year 1939,
was filed in the office of the Collector of Internal Revenue
on March 15, 1940.
Thereupon it-was stipulated and agreed that this witnes
would testify that these varions returns, identified br Gov-
-
Testimony of Harry Grushkin. 39
ernment exhibit numbers which they all bear, are income
tax returns filed in the office of the Collector of Internal
Revenue in Chicago, and that the marks that she has here-
tofore testified to as to serial number and the blue number
in the upper right hand corner, the stamp showing the date
the payment was deposited by the Collector’s Office, the
date it was received, and the other red marks appearing
thereon, and the ‘‘Computation Approved’? were placed
thereon in the office of the Collector, and that she would
also testify that they were received for file there on or
about the date received.
The Exhibits for identification are as follows: R-81,
R-82, R-83, R-84, R-85, being the returns of the defendant,
K. H. Wait, starting with the calendar year 1935. Gov-
ernment’s Exhibits for identification, number R-44, R-45,
R-46, R-47, R-48, R-49, being the returns of Flanagan for
the years 1932 to 1939, inclusive.
Government Exhibit R-50 for identification, R-51, R-52,
R53, R-54, R-55, R-56 and R-57, being the returns of
Hartigan for the vears 1931 to ’39 inclusive. For the
60 calendar year 1934 there are Government Exhibit
R-24 for identification, R-25, R-26, R-27 and R-28,
R-28 being for the calendar vear 1938.
Thereupon Mr. Hurley read to the jury the Govern-
ment’s Exhibit R-6, being the individual income tax return
of William R. Johnson for the calendar vear 1932, and
R-7, the individual income tax return for the vear 1933.
HARRY GRUSHKIN, being duly sworn, testified as
follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Hurley.
[ live at 6414 North Albany, Chicago. My business is
air conditioning. At one time I was connected with the Air
Comfort Corporation. Their place of business is in’ the
City of Chicago. I was employed as sales engineer from
about approximately 1936 to 1938. During the time of my
employment I had oceasion to go to a building at the corner
of Dearborn and Division Street in the City of Chicago. I
saw Mr. William P. Keiiy when IT went there, about the
month of May, 1936. I saw Mr. Kelly on the second floor
of the building, in the D & D Club. I had a conversation
with him at that time. I see him in the courtroom (indi-
40 Bill of Exceptions.
cating the defendant William P. Kelly). I went up to get
permission to measure the premises for installing air con-
ditioning.
Mr. Thompson: We object to any conversation with Mr.
Kelly out of the presence of the other defendants.
The Coart: It will be admissible against Mr. Kelly.
Let it be reccived; not against the other defendants unless
it is connected.
The Witness: I introduced myself and told him I would
like to measure the premises for ibe purpose of presenting
an air conditioning proposition, and he gave me per-
61 mission to do so. I asked for permission to make the
investigation for survey, and he said it would be O. K.
to do so, and that I could go to work. As T recall, we made
arrangements to come out the following dav and measure
the premises, which we did. I talked to Kelly at a later
date, after this first occasion. I submitted my proposal to
him and went back a number of times. I do not recall who
was there when I went back that second time. I did see
William R. Jchnson at that building several days after this
original proposition was prepared and taken in. Mr. Kelly
was there, Mr. Johnson, and several others. I had a talk
with Johnson at that time. We discussed the purchase of
this air conditioning apparatus. I remember telling him
the price of the equipment. I remember of telling him
first that I thought it would run twenty thousand, and after
the proposition was prepared T told him the price was
slightly in excess of fifteen thousand. When I told him
90,000 it was at the D. & D. Club. T do not recall anybody.
except Mr. Kelly and Mr. Johnson, being present. There
was nothing said about Johnson the first time I talked with
Kelly. I think Mr. Kellv said later I should come hack at a
certain hour and Mr. Johnson would be there. When I
went back I saw Mr. Johnson there (indicating the defend-
ant Johnson). After I told him the probable cost would be
$29,000 T went back later, and at that time had a concrete
proposal for him. I went into a discussion of the company
and into the merits ef the application. I did not give the
proposal to Mr. Johnson—I left it on the premises, but I
knew that Mr. Johnson had seen the proposai. T had no
further conversation with Johnson at that time. I did have
a conversation at a later date with regard to air condition-
ing at the D. & D. Club. There was a discussion concerning
some other rooms. The only thing I recollect Johnson say-
ing is that if it worked out satisfactorily at the D. & D.
Testimony of Harry Grushkin. 41
apparatus might be installed elsewhere. He just men-
tioned the other rooms. I snbsequently visited a place at
Irving and Cicego. I saw an old bank building. I think
62 the address was 4715 Irving Park Boulevard. J Vis-
ited the rooms at 63d and Cottage Grove—I forget the
name of the place. I saw Mr. Creighton out there. I see
Mr. Creighton here in the courtroom (indicating the de
fendant Creighton). I went to 97th and Western after [
had this talk with Johnson out at the D. & D. I did not see
anyone there—the building was in process of construction.
T went to the place at 4000 North Harlem. I think the name
was Harlem Stables. I went to the Horse Shoe located at
Lawrence and Kedzie. I do not recall who I saw out there.
I went into the room at 63d and Cottage Grove Avenue,
It ‘vas a hand book. Some gambling apparatus was there,
Tle only thing I reeall was chuck-a-luck and roulette. There
Was nothing at 9730. The Harlem Stables was also a big
place and had several pieces of gy ming apparatus, roulette
and chuek-a-luck, and dice tables. T saw the same apparatus
at the Horse Shoe, the same as IT described at these other
places, T remember seeing Mr. Johnson at the Horse Shoe.
The occasion of meeting him there was probably in connec-
tion with the sale of air conditioning apparatus. Kelly ad-
vised me that if ] went out there at a particular hour I would
meet Mr. Johnson there. T went out there at that time and
met Mr. Johnson and had a talk with him at that time. As
I recall, it was midnight, or eleven o’ciock. probabiv in the
month of May, 1936. He asked when the installation would
be completed at the D. & D., and T told him approximately
June 10th. We discussed air conditioning in general for a
few minutes—I can't recall what was said.
Q. Anything said about these other places you visited?
Mr. Thompson: We object to counsel continually put-
ting words in the witness’ mouth.
The Court: Overruled,
The Witness: Something was said to that effect. Mr.
Johuson said that the probabilities are that air eondi-
63 tioning would be installed at other places. There was
nothing else said in that conversation that I ean re-
member,
Q. Was there anything said about whose places these
were vou were putting these air conditioning units in?
Mr. Thompson: We object to leading the witness,
The Court: Objection overruled.
The Witness: There was no auestion about whose places
42 Bill of Exceptions.
they were. That did not come up, as I remember. There
was no discussion.
I was out at the Horse Shoe at this time and I had a
talk with Mr. Johnson about air conditioning. He said
that if the job at the D. & D. worked out satisfactorily air
conditioning might be installed in other places. He men-
tioned Irving Park and Cicero Place—that is the old bank
building I spoke of, and the place at 63d and Cottage. I
do not recall specifically what other places were men-
tioned—he just referred to other places in general. The
only survey I made after the installation at the D. & D.
Club was at the Irving Park Place. I did not talk to Mr.
Johnson about that. He suggested that I go out there
and I contacted Mr. McKay at the Irving Park address.
When I went out there I told Mr. Mackay that I was the
man that made the installation at the D. & D. Club and
that I wanted to survey this place. Mr. Mackay provided
a set of building plans for me, which he permitted me to
take out, and I copied the floor layout and returned it. I
told Mr. Mackay that Mr. Jonnson suggested that I call
on him.
I had a meeting with Mr. Johnson at the D. & PD. Club one
night, late, and he signed the order for me that night.
They had a consulting engineer of some sort there that
night, who discussed the proposition with me. I do not
recall what his name was. TI have related to you every:
thing I recall that was said by Johnson and myself in that
conversation. I have seen the * cument marked *“Gov-
64 ernment’s Exhibit K-14" for atifieation. This is a
contract to install air conditim. z in the D. & D. Club.
That is mv signature appearing in the lower right-hand
corner of the last page, and W. R. Johnson’s signature in
the lower left-hand corner. T saw Mr. Johnson place that
signature there. The second floor of the premises at Dear-
born and Division were air conditioned, and a connection
was made from that apparatus to a fresh air intake at-
tached to the ventilating svstem in the basement. The air
conditioning unit installed at the D. & D. Club is in aecore-
anee with specifications in Government’s Exhibit F.-14 for
identification, at the price specified in those specifications.
pat
+
BR
Testimony of Harry Grushkin. 43
Cross-Examination by Mr. Thompson.
My negotiations with respect to installing air condition-
ing service at the D. & D. Club did not commence about
May, 1936. The date of the contract was April, 1937, and
that is the time. I wish to correct my testimony to that
extent. I was mistaken when I said I talked to Mr. John-
son about this matter in 1936. This contract, April 26,
1937, refreshes my recollection as to the time it was. It is
correct that it was in April, 1937, and shortly prior thereto,
in March, when I had these several conversations with Mr.
Johnson leading up to this contract. The time extended
over a long period of time. I was a salesman. I was not
confined to any particular area other than the county—
wherever I could find business. I was sent to the D. & D.
Club. A lead came into the office. I was advised at the
office that there might be a prospect up at Division and
Dearborn. I followed that lead. When IT got up there I
found Mr. Kelly. He did not tell me I would have to see
Mr. Johnson about installing air conditioning. 1 spoke to
Mr. Kelly at the time and told him who I was, and that I
waited to make a survey of the premises. He gave me
permission to do so. I did submit a survey back to
65 Mr. Kelly. Then he told me I would have to see Mr.
Johnson about it. The question of ownership of the
building did not come up—it was not discussed. After-
wards T got in touch with Mr. Johnson. Negotiations from
that time on with respect to the D. & D. Club, were not
entirely with Mr. Johnson. T went back once and asked
Mr. Kelly about it. Mr. Kelly told me that a consultine
engineer had been hired, and that they had a number of
propositions, and that mine was among the discards, and
T asked for permission to come back and disenss it with Mr.
Johnson. He said that could be arranged, and T did go
back the following night, or the night after, for that pur-
pose. T came back and talked to Mr. Johnson about it. T
finally arrived at this contract. It is fifteen thousand and
some odd hundreds, less two per cent discount—that is
what it says. The contract was entered into for some-
Where around fifteen thousand dollars, round figures, and
the equipment was installed.
And when you were talking with Mr. Johnson about
this joh—when you got this job—I suppose vou said to
him, ‘‘Can you suggest where T can get some other busi-
ness?’’
44 Bill of Exceptions.
A. Well, I don’t recall how the question of this outside
business came up. I do remember that Mr. Johnson said
there might he a possibility of getting additional business.
Q. You were not looking for any other business, were
you?
A. Sure.
The Witness: Of course I talked to a customer to whom
I sold an outfit to see if he can suggest some other place
where I ean go talk to somebody. ! possibly said that to
Mr. Johnson sometime during the course of this conversa-
tion. Of course | did not remember all of the details of
these conversations all of these vears. Mr. Johnson said
to go out and see Creighton out here at such and such an
address. I remember Mr. Johnson called a friend of his
and recommended me to him at the time. I don’t re-
member whether he said over the ‘phone that I would
66 see him. This is just the usual transaction between
the probable owner who wanted to install some air
conditioning.
Q. And the usual conversation about him recommend-
ing other prospects; isn’t that true?
a. The telephone conversation that I refer to, I recall
him asking the man—somebody away out in the country,
on Skokie,—he asked him if he was going to put in air
conditioning out there. I think that place subsequently
was burned down. I do not remember the name of the
place. I went out there, but this fellow said he did not
have any use for air conditioning beeause he had invented
his own system—something connected with pumping water
ont of wells, so I didn’t pursue that any further.
I have related substantially all of the conversation I
had. That is the only contract that was made with Mr.
Johnson about installiig air conditioning, and the only sur-
ver that was actually completed at his request.
I went up to Mackay, at Irving Park, and made partial
survey. We discussed installing air conditioning and Mr.
Mackay furnished some building plans that I took and
copied and returned, but no specific proposal was ever
made on that particular place. This matter of going to see
Mr. Mackay came up while I was there at the D. & D.
Club. Jt was suggested to me in the conversation that I
might go see Mackay, and mavbe get some business there.
I do not recall specifically where the information came up,
but I remember its connection with my trip to the D. & D.
Yivihuah
i
ae
Testimony of Walter A. Sommers. 45
I do not recall whether it was Mr. Johnson, Mr. Kelly, or
somebody else that said ‘‘Why don’t you go up and see
Mackay, up there at Irving Park’’? That has been years
ago.
67 Mr. Hurley: Now, I will offer in evidence, if tlie
Court please, GOVE RNMENT’S EXHIBIT E-14 for
identification.
Mr. Thompson: On the part of Johnson we object to it
as immaterial.
Mr. Callaghan: The same objection.
Mr. Hurley: That is all.
The Court: It may be received.
Mr. Hess: As to the other defendants we wish to add
to the immateriality that it is not binding, with the pos-
sible exception of Kelly. Tle knew something about it.
As to the other defendants I submit it is not binding on
them in any way.
The Court: It is admissible.
68 H. E. WHEELER, called as a witness on behalf of
the Government, having been first duly sworn, testi-
fied as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Hurley.
My name is H. FE. Wheeler. I live at 1333 East 50th
Street, Chicago. I have been President of the Air Com-
tort Corporation since 1935. Our corporation installed an
air conditioning unit in the D. & D. Club, in the building at
Dearborn and Division streets, Chicago. The amount speci-
fied in relation te that unit was paid about the middle of
1937.
WALTER A. SOMMERS, called as a witness on behalf
of the Government, having been first duly sworn, testi-
fied as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. BE. Riley Campbell.
My name is Walter A. Sommers. I live at 10 West Elm
Street, Chicago. I am a Spscial Agent, Internal Revenue,
and Special Deputy U. S. Marshal. I know the defend-
ant, William R. Johnson. I recall meeting him in March
46 Bul of Exceptions.
ot 1940. That meeting occurred at 2840 South Kedzie
Avenue. I handed Mr. Johnson a subpoena duces tecum to
produce records of the Bon Air Catering Company and
Bon Air Country Club. |
Thereupon, over the objection of the defendants,
the witness testified to a conversation had at the time
of the delivery of the subpoena.
The Witness: This subpoena duces tecum was a forth-
with subpoena. It was about the end of the week. Mr.
Johnson said the book and records were all with his ae-
countants. He wanted to know if he couldn’t produce
them on Monday. He had an engagement vith a Doctor
or something. It would be a little inconvenient for him.
It would take him some time to get in touch with his ac-
countants. I told him that would probably be all
69 right. I had the subpoena with me, Government’s
Exhibit E-68, for identification, is the subpoena to
which I have been testifying. The carbon copy of the sub-
poena is attached to the griginal. Thecarbon copy was
delivered to Mr. Johnson. The pile of books and records
there before me are the records of the Bon Air Catering
Co., Inc. These books and records were brought into my
office from the U. S. Court House by Mr. Shaw of the ac-
counting firm on the Monday following the day the sub-
poena was served. The subpoena was served on Thursday,
March 14. 1940. These records before me are in the same
condition as they were when I first saw them.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Thompson.
I have not had them in my personal custody since they
camé into my possession. | know, from the general ap-
pearance, that they are in the same condition. They still
look like the same books that were brought in. I never read
these books. I have related substantially all the conversa-
tion I had with Mr. Johnson when I delivered the subpoena
to him. I prebably had heard Mr. Johnson was an officer
of the corporation named in the subpoena when T served
the summons on him. The books in front of me are the
books of the corporation.
-
asst na ae
sen yt
hn he:
————-
Lh oe
Ramat iain at, peed sae
TGA eeaiaiaiiptision..
PTT)
Testumcny of Tracy R. Stanis. 47
TRACY R. STANIS, called as a witness on behalf of the
Government, having been first duly sworn, was exam-
ined and testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. E. Riley Campbell.
My name is Tracy R. Stanis. I live at 8618 Ingleside
Avenue, Chicago. | am a special agent in the Intelligence
Unit of the Bureau of Internal Revenue, assigned to the
Chicago Office. I first saw that pile of books in front of
me about the middle of March, 1940. They are the books
of the Bon Air Catering Co., Inc. L have had them in
70 my custody and control since the time they were
turned over to me, until today, when they were
brought up here in the courtroom. They are in the same
condition they were when they were turned over to me
about the middie of March. Mr. Sommers brought Mr.
Shaw of Horwitz & Horwitz, auditors, into my office with
those books.
Cross-xamination by Mr. Thompson.
Atter the books were turned over to me I put them in
the vault of Room 881 of this building. There are a couple
of us who have access to that vault—I think the stenog-
rapher up there knows the combination, myself, and Mr.
Campbell probably knows the combination—nobody else
that 1 know of. About the first of July, 1940, we moved
them down to the U. S. Attorney’s Office, and I moved
downstairs to that room and took the books with me at
that time. We have had them in the file down there. The
U.S. Attorney's Office file, the room that [arm using in con-
nection with this case. Nobody but the stenographer and
myself and the agents connected with—dggps case and the
attorneys have access to that room. Thee is possibly five
or six agents connected with this case that have been
working on it from time to time. There are about four at-
torneys, I believe, connected with the case, and one stenog-
rapher. What 1 mean to say is that the books look like
they did when I got them.
48 Bill of Exceptions.
J. O. SHAW, called as a witness on behalf of the Govern-
ment, having been first duly sworn, was examined and
testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. E. Riley Campbell.
My name is J. O. Shaw. I am a public accountant. My
office is at 310 South Michigan. I| live in Elmhurst. I am
associated with Horwitz & Horwitz. We specialize in
71 handling the hotel, restaurant and club class of busi-
ness. I am a graduate of the University of Illinois,
of the accounting school, and experience, I have been in this
field since 1925. I hold a C. P. A. certificate in lilinois. I
have been a C. P. A. since 1930. A Certified Public Ac-
countant is an individual who has passed the state exam-
ination, met the other requirements, and is qualified to
certify to financial statements of corporations or individ-
uals. I have been with Horwitz and Horwitz since July,
1927. Prior to that I was with another firm here in the
city. All told, my bookkeeping and accounting experience
has been about fifteen years. Thirteen years of it has been
in the hotel and restaurant and club industry. I would
say that I cover all fields of accounting so far as it relates
to that particular business—-hotels and clubs. I know the
defendant, William R. Johnson, sitting here by his coun-
sel to my right. I think I met Mr. Jolinson originally in
1938 at the Bon Air Country Club. It was on Milwaukee
Avenue, one mile North of Wheeling. I know, in general,
what that pile of books there before me are. The top book
is the general journal. They are the books of record ot
the Bon Air Country Club, Bon Air Catering Company,
Inc. I believe the corporate name is. Originally we de-
vised and installed the accounting system there and made
monthly audits during the first year during 1938. In 1930
we had a resident auditor there, one of our own men, who
was there during the season, and alsc during tbe current
year 1940. The audit and control of these books and ree-
ords have been under us since the system was installed.
We made audits of those books from time to time. We
did submit reports based on that audit. We submitted
monthly reports—I believe they were addressed to Mr.
Wait, the President of the Corporation. I know Mr. Wait
—I see him in the courtroom (indicating).
Testimony of J. O. Shae. 49
That is the gentleman to whom I submitted the audit
reports of the Bon Air Catering Co. In the pile of
72 books referred to previously in my testimony, Gov-
ernment’s Exhibit K-46, is the general Ledger. E-47
is the general journal. E-48 is the 1938 voucher register
and cash receipts and disbursements records. E-49 is the
cash receipts, cash disbursements, and the voucher reg-
ister and earnings journal for 1939. Government’s Ex-
hibit E-50, for identification, is the accounts receivable and
accounts payable ledger. E-51 is the operating ledger for
the year 1938. K-52 is the operating ledger for the year
1939. E-53 is the corporate records, that is, the by-laws,
and minutes, stock records. E-46 to E-53, inclusive, is
the record of the Bon Air Catering Co., Ine. The first
year they were kept under the corporate control, and we
just made audits. In 1939 and 1940 they were kept under
the supervision of our man. We made audits and submit-
ted reports for the year 1938. We installed that system of
books that I have detailed here, E-46 to 53, for identifica-
tion. The regular course of business of the Bon Air
Catering Company was to make entries in those books.
Gene rally speaking, those entries were made at or about
the time of the transaction to which they refer. I would
surmise that the Bon Air Catering Co. relied upon those
entries in the conduct of its business. The food and bev-
erage, and the golf and swimming activities was intended
to be covered by these books and records.
There is an account between the Bon Air Catering Co.,
the corporation, and the defendant, William R. Johnson, in
this case. Government's Exhibit, K-46 for identification,
contains such an account. That is the general ledger. It
shows the cash transactions of the corporation with Mr.
Johnson. The signature of Mr. Johnson appears on the
first meeting of the stockholders and the corporate record
—that is E-53. I identify Mr. Johnson’s signature in the
minutes of the first meeting uf the Board of Directors,
73 and there is a receipt on the stock certificate stubs.
I can identify the signature of E. H. Wait on Exhibit
f-53—that is the Minutes of the Board of Directors, and
also on the stock certificate stubs. That is the same Mr.
Wait that I identified a moment ago in my testimony.
From these books and records, based on my examination
and audit of them, I am able to state the amount or amounts
advanced by the defendant William R. Johnson to the Bon-
Air Catering Co. over the period °38, ’39 and ’40,
350 Bul of Exceptions.
. You may state the aggregate amount, please.
Mr. Thompson: We object to that because the question
covers a period beyond the limits of the indictment. The
indictment was returned on March 29, 1940, aru, of course,
the transactions subsequent to that are certainly not ad-
missible, 1 should think. Furthermore, the entries on the
books do not prove the conclusion which is comprehended
in this question, that the amounts credited to Mr. Johnson
were advanced by him personally necessarily. The books
speak for themselves, but certainly do not carry the con-
clusion comprehended by this question. Not the best evi-
dence of what moneys Mr. Johnson advanced.
The Court: Will you read the question to me, Mr.
Reporter?
(Question read as recorded.)
Mr. Thompson: Now, if the Court please, the books
would be binding on the Bon-Air Catering Company, if
they were involved, but not binding on the other parties
—they are an alleged b < account—because they are not
the books of Mr. Jounson.
74 The Court: What about this 1940, the date of the
indictment? You included the year 1940.
Mr. Campbell: I think, your Honor, it is a continuing
account, going over a period of time. The fact that there
is some of this that is outside of the year covered by the
counts of the indictment makes no difference because count
five is a conspiracy count and it is a continuing chain of
events. We are certainly entitled to follow that along
just as we are able to show events prior to the year of the
indictment.
Mr. Thompson: Well, they haven't proved any con-
spiracy of any kind yet; no foundation has been laid for
any such conclusion and we except to the statement of
counsel to that effect. And, furthermore, the indictment
is for evading income taxes for the years 1936, 1937, 1938
and 1939. It doesn’t involve any other period.
The Court: This is not a case to recover income taxes,
as counsel has already pointed out.
Mr. Campbell: Now, your Honor, I have an authority
here to support this offer if ihere is any further question
about it. With regard to the showing of conspiracy we
are entitled to put in proof and records at any time on the
question of conspiracy. In the case of McNeil v. U. S.,
&3 Fed. Sec. 698, which is from the Court of Appeals of
etenin een reneaeh Sy
ae
el eases norceisenieerte= Sempron eeeremenmareea
Testimony of J. O. Sheu. a1
the District of Columbia, we are entitled to put in evidence
on a conspiracy charge even though it tends only to elu-
cidate or aid and assist in determining the truth. I sub-
mit, however, here is an account between the defendant
79 and the corporation and there is an expert qualified
on the stand to state the result of his examination
aud audit. Furthermore, these books were kept under his
control.
Mr. Thompson: If the Court please, I think the rules
as to what is admissible in a conspiracy case are simple,
but after all, you have to prove a conspiracy.
The Court: With the undertaking of counsel—an un-
dertaking, I assume, is made to prove a conspiracy, intro-
duce evidence tending to prove a conspiracy. I will
receive the evidence.
Mr. Tompson: Of course, this is corporation books,
you understand.
The Court: I understand.
Mr. Thompson: And the question calls for a conclu-
sion, Which is impossible to state, from the books, which
is binding on Mr. Johnson.
The Court: He is asked to state what the books show,
in effect. You may answer. His conclusion from what
the books show.
The Witness: In round figures, around $334,000, Of
that figure $272,940 was advanced in the year 1938.
$51,000 was advanced in the year 1939, $9,663 was ad-
vaneed in the year 1940. I met Mr. Johnson at the Bon
Air Country Club in March of 1940. I talked with him
about these books and records at that time. Nobody else
was present. It was Saturday afternoon, I would say
around the middle of March. Mr. Johnson had been
served with a subpoena to produce the records of the
‘6 Bon Air Catering, Inc., in the Federal Building, and
he had a list of the records that were to be produced.
I was asked to go out and bring these records in, to iden-
tify them and bring them in. Mr. Geary asked me to do
that. I did meet Mr. Johnson at the Bon Air Country
Club. We went over them and picked out the books that
were designated in the subpoena. I went over them with
Mr. Jolinson and these are Government’s Exhibits, E-46
to 92, inclusive, for identification. I believe they were
in the safe there at the club on the occasion Mr. Johnson
produced them. Mr. Johnson gained access to the safe.
me
52 Bill of Exceptions.
Following that I took them home with me and then brought
them down here Monday morning to Room 280 of this
building. I exhibited those books and records to Mr.
Sommers. I saw him and then we went up to vour office
and delivered them to you on the eighth floor. I do not
remember who else was present. There were two other
men there. I don’t remember their names.
I do have with me the copies of the auditor’s reports
which eover the audits that I made of these records, Gov-
ernment’s Exhibits E-46 to E-53 for identification. I
have those copies. The same stroke of the typewriter
which produced the original produced these copies which
1 have before me. The originals were sent to the Bon Air
Catering, Inc. They were addressed to Mr. Wait, the
president. Government’s Exhibit E-54 is a copy of one
of the audit reports. Government’s Exhibit, [-57, is an-
other copy of such report. CGovernment’s Exhibit, E-58,
for identification, f-59, E-60, E-61, E-62, E-63, E-64, B-65,
are copies of the audit reports. Government Exhibits,
K-55, E-56 and E-66, are our working papers in connection
with the audits of the Bon Air Catering (o., covering
the results of the audits on examination of (iovernment’s ;
Exhibits E-46 to 53, for identification. The working ;
77 papers substantiate the results of the audits shown :
in these reports. In a general way these audit reports
purport to show the financial position of the corporation,
at the date of the balance sheet at the end of the menth
that the report is for, and they also show the result: of
operations for that period. They show that the corpora-
tion was indebted to Mr. Johnson.
Mr. Campbeli: Then I offer in evidence at this time.
your Honor, Government Exhibits E-46 for identification,
the general ledger, E-47 for identification, the journal and
E-48 for identification, the cash receipts and disbursements
and the voucher record for 1938 and E-49, the cash re-
ceipts and disbursements and veucher record for 1939:
E- o the accounts receivable and payable ledger for 193s,
E-51, the operating ledger for the vear 1938; F-52, the
ptt ledger for the year 1939 and E-53, the eorpora-
tion record of the Bon-Air Country Club.
Mr. Callaghan: 1 object, if vour Tlonor please. Thiere
is no sufficient foundation laid for this in this reeord. A
further objection ix that <o far as the defendants I repre-
— ‘ cA PSR CIE RAS Ea
Testimony of Nelson J. Goodsell. 53
sent are concerned, they are not bound by the entries in
the books of the Bon-Air Catering Corporation.
The Court: Well, they may be received. At the proper
time, if you gentlemen think there has been any evidence
received which is not admissible and which should not be
considered against your clients, if you will submit to me
a draft of instructions to that effect and | concur in your
contentious, I will give those instructions.
Mr. Campbell: Now, I make the same offer with re-
spect to the exhibits for identification previously read
covering the audit reports and covering the working
papers relating to the same subject matter.
Mr. Callaghan: The sane objection.
78 The Court: Overruled. They may .be received.
(Whereupon GOVERNMENT'S EXHIBITS E-46 to
E-53, inclusive, and E-55, E-56 and E-66, were received
in evidence.)
Mr. Thompson: Of course, as to all of these exhibits
that have been offered, I want to make the objection that
they are immaterial to any issue presented by the indict-
ment in this case and that they are not covered by the bill
of particulars which was furnished pursuant to defend-
ants’ request.
Mr. Campbell: They are covered by the bill of partie-
ulars, your Honor.
The Court: Overrnled.
No cross-examination.
NELSON J. GOODSELL, beine duly sworn, testified as
follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Eo Rilew Campiell,
I have lived in Chieago for the past fifteen vears. J
have been a certified publie accountant for abont Gfteen
years, under the states of Tllinoi< and Michigan. T have
met the defendant, William R. Jolnscn. at the Bon Air
Country Club on one oceasion—the fire! part of September
or October of 1939. Mr. Clarence Black and Mr. Bud
Geary were present. Mr. Black ic a public aceountant
and Mr. Bud Geary worked for Mr. Johnson. 1 met Mr.
Geary a few davs before that. On that oceasion T had
a conversation with Mr. Johnson. Tt wax related to ac
.
a+ Bul of Exceptions.
counting matters in connection with the Bon Air Catering,
Inc. I -ee before me books and records which were the
subject matter of that conversation at that time. I had
occasion to examine all of these books during the
79 course of an audit, Government's Exhibits E46 to
53, inclusive, already admitted. I talked to Mr. John-
son—something about these books on the occasion to which
I have referred. There was some question whether cer-
tain assets reflected on those books should be on those
books. That was discussed with Mr. Johnson. I also, at
that time, discussed with him the matter cf obtaining
access to the corporate records, the minutes, stock records
and lease between the Catering Company and Mr. Johbn-
son. We discussed the matter of entries on those books.
In 1938, the year prior to the year of my examination,
certain assets had been placed on the books of the Cater-
ing Co. At the time that I started examination in 1939
the question wax raised as to whether those certain axset-
should be on the. hooks of the Catering Co. Mr. Johnson
instructed me in 1939, when I saw him, to take them off.
In regard to the minutes, stock records, and the lease, he
said that he would see that I obtained access to them,
which I did. Certain construction and equipment items
in 1938 that had been purchased were placed on the books
of the Catering Co. as assets. They were purchased by
funds that were provided by credits, four accounts.
Those four accounts were credits to the accounts of Mr.
Johnson, Mr. Wait, Mr. Geary and a small amount to
Mr. Roy Love. I was instructed at that time that these
advance~ for these construction and equipment items had
heen, in realitv, advanced by Mr. Johnson, and should
have heen eredited to him, rather than scattered around
among the four of them. Also that the original con«true-
tion and equipment for 1938 which, ss ven understand.
was prior to the vear of my examination, ~hould never
have been on the books of the Catering (o.. that ther
were assets, J] presume, of Mr. Johnson, and for that
reason, om his instructions, I took these asset aeconnt-
off the hooks, reduced the credit to these four men, and
merged the balance of whatever credit was left, whic!
was 2 small one, into the account of Mr. Johnson. T
QQ «did all that pursuant to the instructions of Mr. Jobn-
son. T see that gentleman sitting in the courtroom
now. I think I do ‘indicating the defendant Johnson).
Testimony of William Goldstein. 55
i iecall having seen Mr. Wait at the Bon Air in connec-
lion with this matter (indicating the defendant Wait).
Mr. Wait's account is one of the accounts which I handled
in the manner I have described. ] made entries in these
books with respect to stock ownership in this corporation.
I refer to Government's Exhibit E-47, page 68. I made
the entries appearing on page 68, This entry is a stock
entry for $10,000, covering 100 shares of the corporate
stock, of which 54 shares were in the name of W. R. John-
son, 20 shares in the name of E. H. Wait, 20 in the name of
Mr. J. Hartigan and one in the name of F. Deshinger, and
that was in agreement with the stock records. That is the
only entry that I know of on those books, anywhere, per-
taining to the distribution of the <tock ownership of this
corporation.
No cross-examination.
Mr. Campbell: Your Honor, I believe I will offer in evi-
dence at this time Government's Exhibit F-68 for identifica-
tion, the same being the original of the copy of the snb-
poena testified to by Special Deputy Marshal Sommers
and I would like leave to withdraw the original and insert
a photostatic copy if there is no objection, at the proper
time,
Mr. Thompson: We object to it as altogether imma-
terial, it does not prove anything. We are not bound by
what the United States Attorney wrote on a piec. of
paper.
The Court: Objection overruled. You may have leave
to substitute the photostatie copy,
(Thereupon GOVERNMENT‘S EXHIBIT E-68 was
received in evidence.)
WILLIAM GOLDSTEIN, called as a witnes« on behalf
of the Government, having heen first duly sworn, was
examined and testified as follows:
8] Direct Examination bu Mr. Hurley.
My name is Willian: Goldstein, IT lige at 415 Aldine
Avenue, Chicago. I am a practicing lawyer in the City
of Chicago. I have been licensed to practice law in the
state of Illinois twenty-five vears. TI did have certain
dealings concerning the purchase of property at 9730
South Western Avenue in the city of Chicago—I think i¢
was in 1937. The property was six or seven vacant lots.
06 Bill of Exceptions.
tovernment’s Exhibit E-27 is an escrow agreement for
the purchase of lots 382 and 33 in the subdivision at 97th
and Western. There were $3,465 deposited in connection
with that escrow in the Chicago Title & Trust Co. by my-
self. on April 26, 1937. I got that money from William
R. Johnson in the form of currency. I paid that money
over to the Chicago Title & Trust Co. for the purchase
of lots 32 and 33 in Frederick HI. Bartlett’s Beverly High-
land Subdivision. I purchased the property at the re-
auest of William R. Johnson. The title for that property
was taken in the name of Isador Goldstein, my law part-
ner. There was a deed executed from Isador Goldstein
to Ann Homan, my stenographer, and a quit claim from
Ann Homan, including the other lots, to William R. John-
son. I delivered the quit claim deed to Mr. Johnson.
Government’s Exhibit I-28, for identification, is an es-
erow agreement made between myself, the seller, and
Chicago Title & Trust Company. The seller was Tim
Quail, represented by Kiigallon. There was $3150.00 de-
posited on that escrow. The property was lots 34 and 30
in Frederick H. Bartlett’s Beverly Highland Subdivision,
97th and Western. I deposited the money myself, and
received it in the form of currency from William R. John-
son. I mad the purchase at the request of Mr. Johnson.
Government's Exhibit, E-29, for identification, is an
escrow agreement I entered into with Mr. Richard J.
Edgeworth on April 26, 1937, to lot 31 in the same
8 subdivision. There wis $2500 deposited with the Title
& Trust Company in the form of currency received
from Mr. Johnson. I made the purchase at the request of
Mr. Johnson. The title was taken to that property in the
name of Isador Goldstein, my law partner. A quit claim
deed was delivered to William R. Johnson by myself.
T handled the eserow contained in Government's Exhibit
E-30. It is concerning the purchase of Lots 88 and 29 in
the Frederick Ii. Bartlett’s Beverly Highland Subdivision.
The seller is Mr. Tim Quail and Mr. Kilgallon. $4,000, in
the form of eurreney, was deposited in connection with
this escrow by me with the Chicago Title & Trust Co.
IT got fhe money from Mr. Johnson. I purchased the prop
erty at the request of Mr. Johnson. Title was taken by
Miss Ann Homan, mv secretary. Subsequently a quit
claim deed was made to William R. Johnson, which was
delivered to hin by myself.
I did have something to do with the purchase of the
property known as the Albany Park Bank Building, at
Testimony of William Goldstein. o7
3424 Lawrence Avenue. I went out to the Albany Park
Building and interviewed a gentleman by the name of Mr.
Larson, who was the chief clerk for Mr. Carter H. Har-
rison, Junior, who is the receiver for a number of banks
closing out. They had an office out at that address. I bad
a conference with him in connection with the purchase of
that building. After making a number of calls and nego-
tiations I submitted an offer. I was requested by Mr.
Johnson to go out there and purchase the building for
him. The offer was submitted to the Treasury Depart-
ment at Washington for approval, and after it was ap-
proved I believe I made a deposit with Mr. Larson of
five thousand dollars at the time. I received the money
trom Mr. Johnson, in the form of currency. There was a
notice, ] think, published in the newspaper that the build-
ing would be sold to the highest bidder at a certain date,
at which time I appeared and bid, I think, around sixty
thousand, fifty-nine thousand and some-odd dollars
85 for it. I purchased that property at the request of
Mr. Johnson. The exact amount of money expended for
the purchase of that property I think was around $59,800,
After looking at the closing statement I ean state that
the amount expended for the purchase of that property
Was $59,887.05. I got that from Mr. Johnson in the form
of currency. Title to that property was taken in the
name of Ted W. Goldstein, my son. Subsequently there
was a quit claim deed delivered to Mr. William R. John-
son by my son. This Albany Park Building property was
purchased July 16, 1937.
I did have a part in the purchase of property known as
the Bon Air Country Club. I acted at the request of Mr.
Johnson. I think it was the latter part of 1937. J handled
the negotiations for the purchase of it and after arriving
at a price went out there, T think, on one or two occasions,
at Mr. Johnson’s request. I went out there and looked the
premises over to see what it was like, and then I got in
touch with Mr. Blumstein, who is the attorney for the
Evanston Bank, in Mr. Poppenheusen’s office, and Mr.
Becker, who represented the bank, came down. We talked.
It took about three or four months until we arrived at the
price. The bank were the receivers. The price arrived at
was $75,000. I think the initial deposit of $7500.00 was
deposited with Mr. Becker at the Evanston Bank and Mr.
Blumstein, the attorney. I reecived the money from Mr.
Johnson in the form of currency. The deposit was made
58 Bill of Exceptions.
in the office of Mr. Blumstein. The balance of $67,500 was
paid over to Mr. Becker and Mr. Blumstein at their law
offices, in the form of currency that I 1eceivec from Mr.
Johnson. Title to that property was taken in the name of
Mr. Ted W. Goldstein. A quit claim deed was subsequently
delivered to William R. Johnson by myself. I think ap-
proximately 180 acres were involved in that transaction.
T had something to do with the acquisition of other prop-
erty out in the neightborhood of this Bon Air Country
84 Club. Government’s Exhibit E-32, for identification,
is an escrow that was executed by me. Seller was Mr.
James A. Flynn. There was $8,000 in currency, received
from Mr. Johnson, deposited on that escrow by myself. The
property was purchased at the request of Mr. Johnson, and
the title to that property was taken in the name of Ted W.
Goldstein. Subsequently a quit claim deed to Mr. Wiliam
R. Johnson was delivered to him by myself. Lot 15 in the
Columbia Gardens Subdivision was involved in <that pur-
chase. The transaction took place on May 16, 1938.
Government’s Exhibit I-33, for identification, contains
an escrow executed by me. Albert Tatge was the seller, and
involves a house located at the Southwest corner of Mil-
waukee avenue and Chevy Chase Avenue. The amount of
money involved is $8,500, deposited by myself on_ that
escrow, and received from Mr. Johnson in the form of cur-
rency. It was deposited in the Chicago Title & Trust Co.,
April 1, 1938. The property described in Exhibit 33 was
purchased at the request of Mr. Johnson. Title was taken
in the name of Ted W. Goldstein. Subsequently a quit claim
deed was delivered to Mr. Johnson by myself.
T did execute the escrow contained in Government’s Ex-
hibit E-34, on May 2, 1938. The amount of money de.
posited was $4,000, with the Chicago Title & Trust Com-
pany. Escrow Department. The property involved is lots
95. 96 and 27, in that Columbia Gardens Subdivision. I
purchased that property at the request of Mr. Johnson and
received the money deposited from him in the form of
currency. Title to that property was taken in the name of
Ted W. Goldstein. Subsequently a quit claim deed was
delivered to Mr. Johnson by myself.
I executed the document contained in Government’s Ex-
hibit E-37, for identification, on June 9, 1939. That involved
about 175 or 180 acres adjoining the Bon Air. $60,000 was
depositied in that escrow by myself. I received the
85 money from Mr. Johnson in the form of currency. At
ES oy
Testimony of William Goldstein. 59
his request IT purchased that property. Title to that
property was taken in the name of Abe Zimmerman. Sub-
sequently a quit claim deed was delivered by Mr. Abe Zim-
merman to Mr. William R. Johnson.
T executed the escrow contained in Government’s Ex.
hibit, F-38, on June 10, 1939. That involved 11 or 12 acres
East of the DesPlaines River, opposite the Bon Air. The
property I just described a moment ago, in connection with
that $60,000 adjoins part of the property on the East side of
the Bon Air and part on the West side of Milwaukee Ave-
nue, within a short distance of this other property. There
was $3800 deposited by myself on that escrow. | pur-
chased that property at the request of Mr. Johnson. from
whom I received that monev in the form of currency. Title
was taken in the name of Mr. Abe Zimmerman. There was a
quit claim deed from Abe Zimmerman to Mr. William R.
Johnson delivered to him by myself.
I executed the escrow contained in Government’s Ex-
hibit E-35 for identification, on November 29, 1936. That
involved § acres on Dempster Road, in the village of Morton
Grove. It is not located with reference to any other prop-
erty out there. It was formerly known as the Dells prop-
erty. $10,000 was involved in that transaction. There was
a deposit of that amount made with the Chieago Title &
Trust Co. by myself. J received that $10,000 from Mr.
Johnson in the form of currency and purchased that prop-
erty at his request. Title was taken in the name of Isador
Goldstein, my law partner, A quit claim deed was subse-
quently made by Isadore Goldstein to William R. Johnson
and delivered to him by myself.
The escrow contained in Government's Exhibit F.-36, for
identification, was executed on February 10, 1937. That
was 4 acres adjoining the & acres of the Dells property,
$9,000 was involved in that transaction, I purchased the
property at the request of Mr. Johnson, from whom J]
86 received the money deposited with the Chicago Title &
Trust Co., in the form of currency. Title to that prop-
erty was taken in the name of Isador Goldstein, who made
a quit claim deed to Mr. William R. Johnson. which T de-
livered to him.
I executed the escrow contained in Government's Ex-
hibit F-31 for identifieation on March 18, 1937. » That in-
volved “72 acres in DuPage County. Mr. Johnson requested
me to get in touch with a gentleman who had an office in the
First National Bank Building, and take up the matter of
60 Bill of Exceptions.
purchasing this particular property. It is known as the
Cutten farm, or Sunny Acres farm, located in DuPage
County, near Wheaton. After taking it up with this real
estate man we finally agreed on a price, and I reported to
Mr. Johnson about it, and arranged for an appointment
with Mr. Jchnson and the sellers. The escrow was executed
on March 18, 1937, at the Chicago Title & Trust Co. $145,-
000 was involved in that transaction. I met Mr. Johnson
by appointment on that date in the lobby of the Chicago
Title & Trust Co. Building. We went upstairs to the 5th
floor, the escrow department, where we executed the escrow
agreement. The $145,000 was in the form of currency.
The bills were different size. It was a pretty good size
package—-I would not know just exactly—I guess it was
wrapped up in paper. Mr. Johnson had that money when
I met him in the lobby. We met this real estate man and
Attorney Stickler of the Escrow Department and we ar-
ranged and executed this escrow agreement. Mr. Johnson
and myself counted the money and went down to the cashier
in the office of the Title & Trust Co. It took about an hour
and a half or two hours to count the money. That is all
that happened that day in connection with that transaction.
Title to that property was taken in the name of Mr. William
R. Jobnson.
87 I have seen Government’s Exhibit F-41, for identifi-
eation, on April 12, 1937. That has relation to the
Sunny Acres. The name was the Cutten Estates. J think
160 acres of land were involved in the purchase, adjoining
to the East of the Sunny Acres farm. I had a conversation
with the defendant Johnson before the purchase of this
property. He told me he wanted to buy this farm adjoin-
ing this property. I got busy and found that an attorney
by the name of George W. Thoma, in Elmhurst, repre-
sented the seven or eight heirs wko owned this property.
We arrived at a price and purchased it. $16,500 was in-
volved. [I received that money from Mr. Johnson and de-
posited it at the Gary-Wheaton bank, in Elmhurst, in
escrow. I received the money from Mr. Johnson. Title to
the property was taken in the name of Isadore Goldstein.
my law partner. Subsequently a quit claim deed was made
to that property by Isadore Goldstein to Mr. Johnson,
which f delivered to him. That was about April 12, 1937.
I deposited the money with the Chicago Title & Trust Co.
in connection with the purchase of some land adjoining the
property to the Curran farm, which has relation to the
RN Pie or.
vs |
“> ere reees ‘a ts oe oe
Testimony of William Goldstein. 61
escrow contained in Government’s Exhibit E-39, for identi-
fication. This property was in between the Curran farm and
the Bon Air properties. $10,000 was involved, covering
some lots and acreage. The money was deposited with the
Chicago Title & Trust Co., in the form of currency. I re-
ceived it from Mr. Johnson, at whose request the deposit
was made, on July 17, 1939. There were no other deposits
made in connection with that property, but there were as to
other properties in the same vicinity. The amount of money
involved was $7,500, deposited at the State Bank of Evans-
ton, in the form of currency, by myself, which I received
from Mr. Johnson. I made the deposit at his request.
I think there was another piece of property adjoining the
Curran farm, of 11 acres, east of the DesPlaines river, that
I purchased. Something like $1,350 was involved. I
88 purchased that property at the request of Mr. Johnson,
from whoni I received the money in the form of cur-
rency. That was about the same date or shortly after the
Curran property was purchased. I think title was taken
in the name of Abe Zimmerman. Subsequently, e¢ quit claim
deed was made to William R. Johnson, which I delivered to
him. I delivered the quit claim deeds to Mr. Johnson per-
sonally. The money delivered to me by Mr. Johnson was
personally delivered by Mr. Johnson.
I never did collect any rent from the property known as
0730 Western Avenue. I understand there was a one story
building placed on that property. I talked to Mr. Creighton
about having collected rent from that property. I see Mr.
Creigliton here in the courtroom (indicating the defendant
Creighton). I think the conversation took place some time
last vear, I believe. I think in February or March of 1940
at my office. He came in to see me, and told me he had been
over at the Federal Building and had a talk with the District
Attorney in connection with the building, and he told him
that he leased that property from me and was paying me
five hundred a month. I told him it was not true. We got
into a little discussion about it. He knows it was not true.
He never gave me any money for rent on that building. I
do not know anything about it. Then he said ‘‘I, of course,
will insist upon that I did.’’ He was going to insist that he
paid me five huudred a month. He told some one ir the
District Attorney's Office that he was paving rent. I he-
lieve it was the time the Grand Jury investigation was going
on. I have spoken of William R. Johnson and I see him in
the courtroom (indicating the cefendant Johnson). That is
=>
62 Bill of Exceptions.
the Johnson I have referred to during my testimony in
regard to these real estate transactions, and with reference
to these quit claim deeds to the property I have testified
about here. That title to the property was taken in the
89 name of Ted Goldstein and Homan and Abe Zimmer-
man, who took title in their names, were recorded by
me and by me delivered to Johnson. The currency which I
deposited in various amounts was in denominations from
$10.00 up to $1,000.00. The denominations of the $140,000
in currency which defendant Johnson brought into the Chi-
cago Title & Trust Co. were some thousands, five hundreds,
hundreds, tens and twentys, I guess. There were some
£100.00 bills in each instance.
Mr. Thompson: It is our desire to reserve cross-exam-
ination of this witness, and ask that he be instructed to
return after we have had a chance to examine the many
documents that have been referred to, all of these trans-
actions that have been discussed here.
Mr. Hurley: I object. if the Court please. Counsel here
has been fully advised. He can examine the records. That
is not a good ground.
Mr. Thompson: There is nothing in the bill of partie-
ulars regarding these transactions.
Mr. Hurley: We mentioned the a:iount of money and
certainly the amount of land.
The Court: I didn’t hear what you said.
Mr. Thompson: There is nothing in the bill of partic-
ulars regarding these transactions. This is the first knowl-
edge I have had of all of these alleged transactions in the
name of this man.
Mr. Hurley: There is everything in the bill of partie-
ulars that the Court ordered; it complies with the Court’s
order.
90 The Court: No. I think we will pursue the usual
order. You may proceed with the cross-examination.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Thompson.
I am a member of the law firm, Goldstein & Goldstein.
The members are Isadore Goldstein and myself. There is
one stenographer employed in the office and two lawyers,
Clarence W. Shaver and William R. Peacock. There are
no other people connected with the office in any way. I have
no other business besides being a lawyer. I devote most of
my time to the practice of law. With the rest of my time I
enw
a |
RPS rresees
Vb Cmmamerone rere
Testimony of William Goldstein. 63
publish a newspaper at Waukegan, Illinois. I devoted all
my time to the practice of law in '37 and "38, up to the latter
part of °39. When I was handling these transactions I was
acting as attorney for Mr. Johnson. I consider hima friend,
being friendly it was not a relationship between attorney
and client; I didn’t consider it that way. I just handled
these transactions as a friend. I consider myself as having
been a friend of Mr. Johnson for ten years or more, and the
relation still continues to exist. There were four different
transactions concerning the property on 97th and Western.
An actual agreement as to the first transaction mentioned
is E-27. Conveyance of the property was to be made by
Isadore Goldstein, my law partner, and the second trans-
action, K-28, the conveyance was to be made to Isadore
Goldstein. The third transaction, evidenced by 6-29, the
conveyance was to be made to Isadore Coldstein. I did not
take title to any of that property. The fourth transac-
“1 tion, H-30, conveyance was not made to me. Anna
Homan took the title of the last property. I think the
trust officer or escrow officer at the Chicago Titie & Trust,
wrote that Anna Homan in there. I do not know what
“G. Ro after her name means.
Q. Why did vou have this stenographer take title to the
fourth tract, whereas the other three were to your partner?
A. Well, they were adjoining property. My object was
that if one party was trying to buy all that property that
the price would be considerable more than what it Was pur-
chased for. Ll always took the title in the name of the nom-
ince. Then after [ consolidated it all I Would issue one
quit claim deed, but it is pretty hard to remember if that is
What I did here. 1 couldn’t remember the details of the
transaction. I know there were deeds executed. That is all
I could remember. 1 could not tell you definitely the detail
about it. Ido know who finally got title to the preperty. 1
believe that I recorded the deeds myself, or had the Chicago
Title & Trust Co. record them. That is, L recorded the deeds
or had conveyed the property to Mr. Johnson. The four
tracts of land covered by the document we are talking about
Were, so far us I remember, conveyed to W. R. Johnson or
William R. Johnson. My best recollection would be Wil-
liam R. Johnson. I did not say that I recorded the deed
to each. I did not record the deed in that instance. I think
I made one quit claim deed to Mr. Johnson With respect to
these four tracts we are now taiking about. I think Anna
64 Bil of Exceptions.
Homan signed it. I am not sure about that. She was a
single woman at that time. No, sir, she was married in be-
tween there sometime—I could not tell you just when. I do
nut remember whether my partner conveyed to Anna Ho-
tuan ur direct to Mr. Johnson—I do not recall. I do not
recall if Mr. Johnson by these deeds that I drafted
got title to all of this property. Naturally, if I see the
gy? deed I could explain it all in detail. My best recollec-
tion is that this property was conveyed to Mr. Johnson
by deeds prepared by me and I delivered the deeds to Mr.
Johnson. Whether the deed was executed direct by Anu
Homan and Isadore Goldstein or whether or not Isadore
Goldstein conveyed to Ann Homan and then to Johnson, or
whether it was all of it or part of it 1 couldn’t say unless I
see the deed. I don't recall that offhand. I know there was
some confusion about that particular piece of property—
I mean om account of the transaction which involved four
or tive or six sellers. I don’t recall. We tried to withhold
information as to who was purchasing that particular prop-
erty. 1 tried to withhold it for the purpose of trying to
purchase it as cheap as | possibly could. I am not sure
whether anybody else was interested in this particular piece
of property, Mr. Thompsony
QY. When did you become uncertain about that, Mr.
Goldstein?
A. | just happened to think at this moment.
Referring to defendant’s Exhibit J-1, for identification,
my recollection about whether or not Mr. Johnson got title
to this property is that he got an undivided one-half inter-
est. Ll prepared that quit claim deed and it was acknowl-
edged in my office. Clarence W. Shaver took the acknowl-
edgmeut. That says that an undivided one-half interest
was conveyed to William R. Johnson. Ann Homan and
Kaymond J. Homan, her husband, signed the deed. It
covers Lots 38 and 39 in Bartlett’s Beverly Highlands Sub-
division, which are covered by the escrow agreement tbat
is under Government's Exhibit E-30. 1 don't know whether
1 delivered this quit claim deed, Defendants’ Exhibit J-1,
for identification, to Mr. Jolinson, or left it for him. I do
not recall that particular instance.
93 Defendants’ Exhibit J-2, for identification, conveys
an undivided one-half interest to these lots to Mr.
Johnson. The grantors are Ann Homan and Raymond J.
Homan, who got title to this property through Isadore
RR.
Se ee
Testimony of Williom Goldstein. 69
Goldstein, who quit claimed to them. They quit claimed
a half interest to Mr. Johnson, and that deed covers Lots
31, 32, 33, 34 and 35, and those are the lots covered by es-
crow agreement identified as K-29, E-28 and E-27. That
was acknowledged before William R. Peacock, a notary
public in my office. He is an employee, as a lawyer, in my
office. This deed was not delivered by me to Mr. Johnson.
The two deeds pertaining to Western and 97th, I don't re-
call whether I left it for him or whether or not I delivered
it in person.
I was a defendant in this indictment when it was returned
and it was dismissed when this case was called for trial. I
did not have any conversation with U.S. Attorney prior to
the dismissal of this indictment. I have talked to the U. S.
Attorney three times about this case, after the dismissal.
1 had not talked to him about these matters in a genera! Way
wany times before that. | am also a defendant in a pending
indictment for perjury. | presume that relates to the in-
Vestigation of this matter before the grand jury. That in-
dictment is still pending as far as | know. | did not have
any conversation with U.S. Attorney as to what disposition
ix going to be made of that indictment. He did not tell me
that the disposition of that in-lictment will depend upon my
performance in this case. We had no conversation what-
soever abo
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.