Transcript of Record — A. B. Kirschbaum Co. v. Fleming
Supreme Court brief1942
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
i
, eat
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD ‘
-
_. Supreme Court of the United States
. “*. OCTOBER TERM, 1941
° .
Rs °
—
(A. B. KIRSCHBAUM COMPANY, PERFITIONER,
ts; :
PHILIP B. FEAMING,, ADMINISTR TOR, OF THE:
MAGE, AND HOUR DIVISION, UAITED STATES
.” © DEPARTMENT OF LABOR eee
J ee
WRIT OF CERTIORARL LO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUTT Cour’
fae "e
OF APPEALS FOR THE THIRD CIRC TT
. .
2
PETITION FOR CERTIORARE FILED JANUARY 29, 1982.
CERTIORARE GRANTED MARCH 2, 1942. fa)
aie INDEX, —
threading in U. s ©. €: A., Third Circuit. ee he
_ Appendix to appellant’s brief Arey De eh SER Bao fe
| Appendix to appellee’ s brieé.....:. Ps Raps ©... 18%
Sede a ee ea esis ore ee 223
% —9248° !
x : : hs a : ¥
eas Lt tae :
- United States Circuit Court of Aomals
, , Eon THE Trip C IRCULT,
ee eee :
> 2 5: eee 2 - ss
: Qoroper TERM, 1941. pest a7) a Noy gi |
es ALS Bo ret ‘ Z = ae eae . 7%
~ HL IP B. EL I MING, At hninistrator of the: ene and
a Hour Division, United, States, De parknent of Labor, ae
ya vs. 4 ere,
A.B. KIRSCHBAUM COMP ANY! a Pennsylvania, us
( ‘or por atlon, \ neh
App Haut. is ete
e ;
“ _ Appendix to Appellant’s Brief: ee
: 2+ st " =A otk EEN
~
APPEAL FROM tHe Disrrier Cover or THE [T NitED STATES
ror THE Kasten District or PENNSYLV ANIA,
e t
pis
. , : . ‘
asic ali titel cia ance cienk ales anlar eegseconalieilase ———<
Martin & Lyle, 302, Penfield Bidg:, Phila., Pen. 0665, Keyetn ‘Race 6067.
.
2
Se INDEX.
oe
ore : : : Page _
Mott We. 8 isi is es daa 1
Aménded Complaint . awe gbak Seater hexhe anes ack ae
Answer to Amended ( ‘omplaint, PS ee RiGee | Geen 8°
Testimony: . ——
Plaintiff's Sts te ORS ee.
Arthur H. Chalker ........ 15 - 3
- William Mentzel . ........ a. ee a
George Simon ..... 2.2.2.2: ‘35 ne ar tae
_ Harry Gallagher padenect. ee? OE is Bs koa
~ Samuel H, Fleming ....:.. © 48. ee Ree \.
George Epps . va tees ete “M4 -.< G1. :
Nick Cattelise .'... c+. 55.55. 62> >: ; * ti
* MeKinley Edwards. ...4.. 65 70 - is:
_ Charles Moetsch . iosdaeD, te 10,
Ben Rash: gisvs3SoT 70. 82 S- .- 8%
; . Louis Casciato . ...,...2.. -94 108 |
Admissions by” Defendant for Purposes of this case 105__
Adolph W. Haber...... wo.a 106: 114 117
Nicholas D’Alonze-—_———— . tt8 129 pee
. Samuel Sharlit ..........:-134 - 141 Sens, i
Irving Glonninger . #.:....144 51 |. 154.
Frederick L..Hewes:....... “155 162, :
>: Deftndant’ S: |
Ed@in G. Frank ........ . 165 °
- Plaintiffs Requests for Findings of Fact and Coneln: |
‘eka ae i prem EL TPECE End ea UP ONSET ECO Ee 168
Opinion, Kirkpatrick, J. Sur Pleadings and Proofs 2 376
mbes eR Tere ree gb tNesas gre tsesececeess 181
Ex ions of Defendant to Findings of Fact. and:
ca ae of wasig SCdaecens Aik beh ee oO bae 183 .
peal See eises rrr EAR eNews oes poss .. 185
co oo; . n
oy mes ?
=i od - au . ad = . ?.
. bad . -
District Coin of. a United States _
For THE HasTexn Disraict oF PENNevivamia.
=e . =) F :
Civit Action Fite No. 798.
=
a: PHILIP B. FLEMING, lhuonedesson OF THE.
WAGE AND HOUR DIVISION, UNITED STATES .
DEPARTMENT OF LABOR, :
Plaintiff,
V.
‘A. Bi KIRSC HBAUM COMPANY, “a Pennsylvania Cor-
a! “Gey >. poration,
3 poe Difentont.
s :
</ ENTRIES,
Mar. 14, 1940 Complaint; filed.
- +“ -T4, —- Suminons exit. ©
& .
‘*. 20, ‘*° Summons: returned: “on Mar. 14, 1940.
ee ““ -. ‘served’? and filed.
© 96 Appearance of ¢ ‘Sidney i. Kranss, Esq,,
“i... 02" jand Wm. Clarke Mason, Esq., for Defen-
~*~ dant filed.
‘Ss. 97, © -Motfon for more definite statement filed.
Apr. 4, 1940 Order to ‘place . case on. ces estes List —
far _. filed.
_ * 1s, “Argued. ‘sur motion for more definite
oie ‘statement: Eo'die: Motion granted.
ee
Ce ee - Doeket Entries.
ae - Amended Complaint filed.
#96, Aiswer to Aniended Complaint filed,
“May 11, 1940° Order to place case on Trial List filed.
-Noy, 15, 1940, - Trial — (Kirkpatrick J. y Witnesses .
ie Goes ~ _ Sworn, er fice
eS concluded by 12/23, 140.
Dee. ; 4 1940 - Testimony filed (2 vol.) -
-Apr. 2, 1941 Opinign, Kirkpatrick, Se granting judg
‘i .* ment for plaintiff filed.
“se. a = Judgment in “favor of Plaintiff. granting —
; as ‘Injunction filed. 4/28/41 noted. 7
“QQ. ts ‘Exceptions. on “behalf sof Defendant to.
‘|. * findings of the Court filed.
Ye > Mr BB eS Defendant's notice of appeal filed. © 4/
pa etan 29/41 Copy to J. M. Gallagher, Esq.
‘«° 28, -** Bond for. costs sur-appeal in sum of" $250 |
‘with Fidelity & Deposit. ieee. ges Be of
Md., surety filed. -. ?
ae Motion for stay of injunetion pending
ea appeal filed.’ |
** 28, (Order of ‘Court suspending injunction
: pending appeal filed. 4/28/41 noted. ae
28, * Supersedeas _ bond in’ sum of $1000 with —
%e _._tashtsecnrity and Order of Court approv- he
a5 “ing bond filed. 4/28/41 noted. ret
28, * Copy ‘ef Clerk’s Notice to U. . Circuit ’
revi ase Corrt of Appeals filed. 3
' May 17, 1941 Statement of Points on which defendant | :
|
|
i pige ' + . intends to rely, filed. - piss
“17, ‘* - Designation of contents of - ‘reeord on ap-
au 7 peal, filed. . . }
‘Ca. * Plaintiff’s requests ine Sadie 08 tet —
and conclusions of. law, filed.
So aa _ Appellee’ s designation of additional por-
tions of record on appeal filed.
4 Acknowledgment of service of designa-
; tion by appellee filed.
6
Plaintiit” 8 Amehded ( ‘eunpilaint: Snahy “ie re,
PLAINTIFF’ 'S Auten DED COMPLA INT.
(Filed Apr » 19, 1940.) -
wk. Plaintiff brings: thris \action ‘to enjoin, defendant hs
from violating the provisions of .Section 15(a).(2) of the. ot
Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 (Act of June 25, 1938, -
* ¢. 676, 52 Stat. 1060; U.S. C., Title, 29, See. 201 et séq.),
hereinafter called the **Act””. es ‘
HL Furiadittion of this action is ‘conferred upon ‘the ; ee
c ourt by Section Ww of the Act. a Gg. a
eis Defendant’ is, arid at all ‘times he, reinafter men. —
tioned was, a corporation -organized: under and existing
by virtue of the laws of the State of Pennsylvania, having |
its principal office.and place of business at Broad and Car- -—
penter Streets, Philadelphia,” Pennsy lvania, within the.
jurisdiction ; of this Court. ven - 8B SN
res: IV, Defendant is the ow ner af a dinabory and. baise-
ment building situated at the southeast corner: of Broad o
and varpenter Streets, ‘in the city of Philadelphia, Penrn- |
~ sylvania, formerly ocoupied by defendant as a factory. saul
the’ production™-of of _men’s, clothing but—new—opetated as 7) eee E EE
~—tott building, port portions of which are leased. by defendant
‘to various tenants who engage in the ‘production in said,
building of goods for interstate commerce, to wit: men’s »
_ clothing, uniforms and pants, boys’ wash suits, and sweat-
ers and bathing suits, and other portions of said building —
are leased to a tenatit engaged. in the receipt and ware- P
housing in. said building of furniture from states -other
__than_ Pennsylvania and the sliipment of -furniture from. ae 4
said building to states other than Peinsy lvania.
V.. All of the tenants who oce ant the first, se ond, °
third, fifth and sixth foors of defendant's building are
- engaged in the production of men’s clothing, uniforms and °
_ pants, boys’ wash suits, and sweaters-and bathing. suits, in,
‘. _@
°
aig eR be eae Plaintiff's Amended Complaint. |
‘the éegurse of which they receive raw materiak,
“ finished gartnents and finished garments from and}through -
vo stfites other tlian: the ‘State. of. Pennsy lvania, and
P
.
° ion
g . s ;
‘ . . a . *
, 5) . i. e . ’
*
ho
ship out
‘naterjals, partly finished garments and finished garments.
from their phaices of business in defendant’s said buildin, -
st Philadelphia, f, into, ‘and - through states. 0 } than:
. the’ State of Pearsylvania, and the tenant occu ving the °
basement: is engaged in inferstate commerce as aforesaid.
/ NA. De fendant, pufédant to agreements of lease with
its said tenants and in- consideration of the ‘rentals paid
by said fenanits and other paymetits by said tenants, em
ploys in said buildiag: employees who are engaged in
interstate cohimerce atid in the production of goods for
interstate. commerce us defined’ by Section 3(j) of the
Act, or in processes, or - occupations necessary thereto, :
such employees being ‘engaged inter-alia in the operation, -
of elevators within the buitding for the use of the tenafts,
their employees, cUstomers ..and- visitors, and for the
transportation of. goods shipped. to. the said tenants from
outside the State of Pennsylvania gnd fot. the transpor-
tation of goods produced by the said.tenants and shipped .
bt them to consignees outside the State of Pennsylvania ;
in the? transportation and handling of the furniture, raw
* materials, partly finished garments and finished garments
iestakae to or produeéd by the tenants in connectiorf
with the shipment of the said articles in interstate com-
merce *or: their préduction + ‘for, interstate commerce; in -
5 production and. generation of steam for the operation
the said elevators, for the heating of the building. and
1e parts thereof - “used by the said tenants in ‘interstate
commerce, and in the production of. goods for interstate
commerce, and for the operation of machines and equip-
inent used by _thegsaid tenants and their employees in the °-
production of goods for ‘interstate, commerce; ’ the
maintenance and repair of niar-eitig
-tures and premises used ly the said tenants and their
- biployees -in interstate “commerce and in the produe-
\ | ? .
8 | i SP eg
sistem fix- ./
-
* Plaintiff’s Amended Coe: 5
tion of ails for interstate, commierce ; in the guard-
ing and watching of the premises, equipment, mater-
jals and merchandise of.the said tenants used in inter-
” state commerce and in the production of goods for inter-
state commerce; in the cleaning, maifitenance and repair
of those portions of the building used and occupied by the
saiQ tenantsyin interstate cgmmerce and in the production
5f goods for interstate commerce and ‘other portions of
“the building used in cominon by said tenants and -their
employees ‘engaged in the production of goods for inter-
state Zommerce and in interstate commerce; and in the
:, performance of other work, duties, processes dnd occupa-
tions iK intersthte commerce, and in the production of
goods for interstate commerce for and on behalf of: the.
said tenants.
YR estan the period bestowing October. 24, 1938, .
the. he effective date of Section 6(a). (1) of the Act, and con-
tinuously through October 23, 1939, defendant paid to
some of its aforesaid @mployees wages at rates less than
twenty-five cents (25¢) an hour for their employment in
interstate commerce and in the production of goods for
interstate cammerce, as aforesaid; and, during the period
beginning October -24, 1939, the effective date of Section
6(a) (2) of the Act, and’ continuously to the date hereof,
defendant has paid to some of its ‘aforesaid employees
wages at rates less than thirty cents (30¢) ‘an hour for’
their employnient in interstate commerce e and in the .pro- -
duction of goods for interstate commerce, as aforesaid.
. By failing and refusing to pay its said employees wages |
“at rates not. less than the said. rates during the said per-
iods, defendant has violated and is violating the provi-
sions of Sections 6 and ‘T5(a) (2) of the Act,
sf III. During the naniod busttining October 24, 1938,
the effective date of Section 7fa) (1) of the Act, and con- |
_ tinuously through October. 23, 1959, defendant employed
certain of its aforesaid employ ees, who Were engaged in.
‘
pee Lees
a aah Te Plaintiff's Amended Complaint.
interstate commerce and in the. production of sonds for
interstate: commerce, as aforesaid, for workweeks longer
than forty-four (44) hours, and did fail and refuse to
compensate, the said empl gyees for their employment in
excess of forty-four (44) hours in such workweeks at rates
not less than one and one- half tiniés the regular rates at
which they were employ ed, and, in fact, did fail and refuse
“compensate them-for such excess hours at «ny rates
greater than the regular rates at which they were em-—
ployed; and, during the eriod beginning October 24, 1939,
the effective date of Section 7(a) (2) of the Act, and-con-
tinuously to the date hereof, defendant has employed cer-
tain. of the aforesaid employees, who were engaged in.
interstate commerce and in. the production of goods for |
interstate Commerce, as aforesaid, for workweeks longer
than forty-two (42) hours, and has failed and refused to
compensite the said employees for. their employment in
excess of forty-two (42) hours in such workweeks at rates
not less than one and one-half times the regular rates at
. which they were empleved, and, in fact, has failed and
refused to compensate’ them, for such excess hours at any
rates greater than the regular rates at which they were
employed. By employing the said employees for work- -
weeks in excess of the sald hours during the said periods
without compensating them for their employment in excess
of the said hours in such workweeks at rates not less than
one and one-half times the regular rates at which they
'. gvere employed, defendgpt has violated and is violating the
' provisions of section?7 and 15(a) (2) of the Act. .
IX. The goods jwodueed by defendant’s tenants. in
defendant’s building at Broad and Carpenter’ Streets,
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, compete with similar goods
produced in other states and defendant’s tenants in their ©
said businesses compete with: manufacturers of men’s
clathing, uniforms and pants, hos’ wash suits, ons eed
ers and bathing suits, and dealers j in furnitufe ocated in -
‘other states, “ -# ;
’
erin
Plaintiff ’s’ Amended onan. | 7
X. Defendant hds, sinee the effective date thereof,
continuously violated the aforesaid provisions of the Act -
and threatens and intends to continue to Violate the said
provisions unless enjoined and, _ restrained, by a judgmént
of this Court.
s-
‘ XI. A judgment enjoining and. restraining the viola--
tions hereinabove alleged is specifically authorized by
Section I of the a
e
* : I . e- ~ ‘ castes ’ ’-
W HEREFORE, plaintiff demands - judgment énjoming. .
© and restraining defendant, its officers, agents, servants, |
employees and attorneys, and all fersons acting er claim-
ing to act in its behalf. and interest, from violating the -
provisions. of Section? 15(a) (2) of the Act, both: perma-_
nently and during the pendency of this action, and such:
other and further relief as may be necessary and er:
priate.
eee’ /e/ Gininok A. MeNttty,
| General Counsel,
a /s/ Ixvine J. Levy,
cc " Assistant General C ounsel,
/s/ J. M. GaLLaGHER,
; Regional Attorney,
/s/ Ernest 'N. Votaw,
Attorney,
Wage ond Hour Division, U nited
Stutes Department of Labor,:
. Altorne ‘ys for Plaintiff.
Post Office Address:
('/o Wage and Hour aon ON wed g
-U. 8. Department of Lat oe
1630 Widener Building
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, © :
2 or :
C/o Wage and Hour Division
G. 8. Dep&rtment of Labor
Washington, D. C.
co “ ‘
‘ eee
—_— y a
4 ieee *
s
ae Defendant ’s Answer to Amended seco aueane
DEFENDANT'S. ANSWER-TO AMENDED
COMPLAINT. - Se
(Filed April 26, 1940.) pale
\
" :
¢ » 4 ~ * wept < °
SS ae aA Ss al se eR acai Risa
t
——-—9
The det fendant, ry B. ‘Nir ekbaumn Company, denying.
that the amended ‘complaint herein is a full or fair com-
pliance with thé order of the court upon the @efendant’s —
motion for a more definite Statement filed in this cau8e —
“and reserving all of its rights to. ‘complain thereof, files
this its answer to the said amended complaint as follows :
I. Adniits that there i is the. “ Act’ described in para-
, graph | of the amended complaint but denies that it is a
‘legal foundation for the action rote by the: plaintiff
herein.. eal.
2
bit Eiaiios the averments contained in, paragraph FH
of the gmended complaing, © 8 ; |
TIL. Admits the avermenits’ contained in paragosen:
UL of the amended complaint.
IV. Denies, or is ‘without knowledge or information.
sufficient to form a belief as to the.truth of, the averments
Tsu e ee ee r : 4) =
a contained in Perro vad HAY +Hhreamremraicst comptaimt, ex-
cept as lgreinafter expressly admitted. —
£27
_* Admits that the defendant is sks iui at a six-story
and basement building situated at the southeast corner of.
Broad and Carpenter Streets, in the City of Philadelphia,
Pennsylvania; that said building was formerly occupied.
by defendant as a, factory for the production of: men’s
clothing but it is.now operated as‘a loft building and that -
y the defendant does not how engage, nor has it since Octo-
ber 24, 1938 engaged, .in any manufacturing, either in said
building or elsewhere; and that: ‘portions, of said building
-.- are now leased by defendant t® various tenants, sonie of:
whom engage in the production i in said building of goods
at 8
fe
mi.
= . ta Paths Bat :
gees
for interstate as well as ‘intrastate commerce, sume of whom |
engage in the’ production in said building ‘of goods for
sale at retail either on said premises wr: in Philadelphia,
and at least two others of? whom make no shipment, of
merchandise from said building to consignees ontside the
City of Philadelphia. a. a
>
Also admits that the basemefit of said building is
Alvania corporatioy, en-
leased to Lit Brothets,. a Penns
| gaged in the conduct and operation ini Philadelphia of a
| retail department store, and: that.said basement is utilized
as a warehouse by Lit Brothers in the conduct and. opera-
tion ‘of said retail business, afd that some of the furniture
~stoyed in.said basement is shipped to Lit Brothers from
states other than Pennsylvania. °
¢
tnt
aie ¥.? ‘ ‘ : o
Penne) /
sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of, the averments
contained in paragraph V of the amended: complaint, eXx-
cept as hereinafter expressly admitted.
Adinite that each of the failowine articles, to wit:
men’s ¢lothing, uniforms and pays. boys’ wash suits, and
first, second, third, fifth sind sixth floors, or portions there-
of. of said building. {Admits further according to the best
of its knowledge that in the course. of the production of
the articles aforesaid, one or more of: said tenants re-
ceives raw materials from and throngh states other than
_ State of. Pennsylvania; that af least two of said tenants
receive partly finished garthetits from points in the State
-—. ship-eut- ‘or deliver finished garments, to, into and through
st&tes others than the’State of Pennsylvania, as well as to
points within the State of Pennsvlv: ania: and that. cat lea&St
one tenanf ships out finished garments to points-in the
State of Pennsylvania only. -.
"@9 On 3 i ier
a oe ae : -
_Betendnt Amer “ Amended (¢ ‘oman HN)
Primes: f Denies: or is ‘without knowledge or information |
sweaters and bathing snits, are produced in said building ©
‘by one or more of the defendant's tenants who oecupy the
__ the State of Pennsylvania, as well as-from points in the.
of Pennsylvania only: that one or more of said tenants °
’
oars
.
10° ~~ Defendant’s Answer to Amended Complaint.
*
e
*
- VI. Denies the averments ‘contained in paragraph VI
.of the amended complaint except as hereinafter expressly
admitted. 6
Defendant admits that as the owner of said loft
buildyae, it employs and has employed: since October 24,
1938, certain persons necessary properly to opergte, mMain-
fain and protect. its said building as a place in which to
perforni the obligations assumed by the defendant‘as land-
lord under the: agreements ot lease with its several tenants,
but it denies that any employee as, its employee while
eligaged in any service for it, is engaged ‘in interstate
,
re “
;
COMmMerCE, or in the production of goods for interstate’
commerce, or in processes or oceupations necessary there-
to, within the meaning of the Act or otherwise.
Defendant: avers that it engages, inter alia, persons
who from time t& time operate the elevators in the said
building, which are madé available tor use by said tenants
and their “employees and sone of which are. made. avail-
‘able for use by said tenants, customers and visitors , and
in one or,more of-which are carried from time to. time
_ goods shipped to one or more of said tenants from points
either within or outside the State of Pennaylyania,” anid
from time to time , .
tenants and eventually shipped Dy o one. or more of tiem to
consignees either within or_outside the State of Pennsyl-
, m ity ° s © .
Vania, as well as other goods, the sale;and delivery of
which-are made at retail to de customers of certain of the
of the building oceupied by .-
Said tenants in she portions
theni for the conduet of their businesses. . Defendant
» denies that said elevator operators or any other employees
of the defendant are émployed by the defendant for or
are engage? in the handling of any ofthe goods belonging
to or produced by the tenanfs of the defendant, whether
shipped to said tenaffts or by; them. ° +. ~
Defendant further avers that it engages, inter alia,
persons who from, time to time engage, in 1 the production
See +e, +
Defendant's Answer to Amended ¢ omplaint.. el
and ‘generation of steam for the: operation ot said’ “le.
Vators, for the heating of said building. and for use by or
_sale to certain of the said tenants for use by them (in the
portions of the building occupied by’ thenr) tor such pur-
poses as such steam-may be, lawfully used by the said*
tenants within the provisions of said leases. The defen-
dant also employs frony time. to time ‘certain persons for
the purpose of guardifig and watching the building and
its contents and for the purpose of maintaining and re-
pairing the said building as and when the same may be—
required and also for the purpose of cleaning those por-
tions of the buildinig not leased: to said tenants. Defen-
dant however. denies. that any employee ‘as an employee _
of the defendanit is engaged in the maiftenance and.répair -
of machines, equipment and: fixtures owned. by or belong-
‘ing to said tenants or*in the cleaning of such portions of
the building leased to said tenants. 3 ;
Defendant is without knowledge or information ‘suff
cient to-‘form a belief as to the exterit to which at any
viven time or times. since October 24, 1938, any tenant of
the defendant 4n the said building was engaged in inter-.
state commerce oF in the production of goods for per
state: commerce as distinguished from intrastate—co
<ttt
treTee-OT the production of goods for intrastate commerce
and if such facts are material, def ‘endant demands proof
‘thereof at the trial of this cause.
Defenc ant, s the owner of the building lenesibad in
the amended fomplaint, by leasing space in the said build-
ing to ‘tenants over which defendant has no control and
with respect to which it: has no re lationship other than to
render service as a landlord in accordance with the pro-
Visions of the leases enter ‘ed into with such tenants, is”
engaged in business exclusively within the (fity of Phila-
delphia, in-the Commonwealf#f of Pennsylvahia, and not
otherwise, and none of the defendant’s activities as such
owner and, operator of the said Intilding , and none of th
pees of its employees for which they are employed by
2 \ G
NS Ua
.
o
-(30¢) an hour. oie ;
: ‘
12 -Defendanit's Answer to Amended Complaint.
5 ee: ed teat bene eet ie
the defendant ‘or for which defendant was liable to, com,
pensate such employees constitute, either directly or indi-
rectly, interstate conimerce or the production of, goods
far interstaty commerce or processes or occupations: neces-
sary ther veto, within the 1 nies ming of the Act; ‘or otherwise.
VU. Denies the avernients ‘contained in paragraph.
VII of ‘the amended complaint, except that defendant ad-
mits that during the Bie begining October. 24, 1938
and ending October.
a
1939, it paid to one of its em-. .
' ployees engaged in andl ‘about said: building to operate,
maintain and protect the same, wages at rates less than .
twenty-five cents (25¢) an honr, and during the period be-
emying October 24, 1939 and ending with the ah ‘hereof,
it paid to some of its aforesaid employees engaged in and
about said building, wages at rates less than thirty cents
VIII. Denies the averments contained in paragraph
VIII of the amended complaint, ex¢ept’ tinit defendant
admits that during the period beginning: October 24, 1938
“and ending October 23, 1939, it employed certain of its
aforesagd emplotees In and ia said building for work-
weeks longer than forty-four (44) hours, and, during the
period beginning, October 24; 1939 and ending with ‘they
date hereof, it employed certain ef its.afoyesaid employees |
‘in and about said building for workweeks longer than
forty- two (42) hours, ‘and did_ not compensate the said
for their employment °in excess of. forty- two (42) hours
during the period last above mentioned, at rates greater
than the regular rates at which they were employed.
IX. States. that it is without kngrisdbe -or -informa-
tion ‘sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the aver-
ments contained in paragraph IX 6f the amended com- '
‘employees for their “employment in excess of forty-four —
(44) hours during the period first Above mentioned, or
plaint, ‘and if material, defendaut demands proof thereof
at the trial of this cause. 3 eae : a
X. Dénies the iiecanits contained . in paragraph Xx |
of the amendedgcomplaint. ” 1 Nee as -%
XI. Denies the ayerments contained i in ‘paragraph <I
- of the amended complaint. Sy ae
é
AS FURTHER, ‘SEPARATE ‘AND ADDITIONAL
“DEFENSES IN LAW TO THE ALLEGED CAUSE OF.
ACTION SET FORTH IN HE Seamer oe:
. PLAINT: - : ) .
XU. Defendant avers “thai the -court lacks jurisdic. —.
tion ov er the subject matter ot the action.
‘XIII. Defendant avers: that the ‘complaint fails to’
state a claim. against the defendant upon which, rélief can
- he granted for the reasons, inter alia; that it is vague,
‘indefinite and insufficient, and has no foundation in the
ae Act”’ upon which said Se Is alleged to be based.
XIV.’ Defendant avers that it as well as its employ. ees
are exempt from the provisions of Sections 6 and 7 of. the
' Act under the provisions of Section 13 thereof.°
XV. Defendant avers that the “ Act’? described in
paragraph I of the amended complaint is properly inter-.
_ preted, is nots applicable to defendant and/or .to?the em-_
ployees of the defendant etiployed in connection With the
operation, maintenance and protection of the premises ,
deseribed i in the complaint. eee : 2
b
guck VI. Defendant avers that the “Net”? described in
paragraph I of the amended complaint .if held applicable .
to the defendant -and/or- to the employees of the defendant —
employed in connection with the operation, maintenance _
Defendant’ $ Answer to Amended Complaint. 13.
9
e
s
»
'e
14 Defendant's. Answer to Amended Venaneant.
and protection of the premises déscribed i in the complaint,
‘is’ unconstitutional. as contravening, Articles V and X of
the Amendments to the Constitution of the United States
and, not within the power delegated to the Congress ."
_Article T Section ¥ clause 3 thereof, or by any other :
“visions of the said ¢ ‘onstitution, or any amendment thereto.
Wherefore, defendant ceca judgment against the’
plaintiff dismissing the amended complaint herein and, for
the costs of this action.
Bere ; As/ Swxey L. Krauss
: Office and P. O. Address, * :
1113-21 North American Bldg.,
Philadelphia, Pa.
/s/ “W M. CLARKE Mason,
Office and P. O. Address,
2107 Fidelity-Phila. Trust Bldg.,
Philadelphia, Pa.
ae for Defendant. ‘
: : :
gaping coe ‘
|
-Arthug A.Chalker--Direct. = 15.
TESTIMONY. as
Before Hox. Wittiam H. Kirxrarnics, J. +
f Philadelphia, Pa{, November 15, 1940.
1. gs 8l4 iS 2 ieginia pe ™
- Present: , Se Sie et Cee Se aM ct
Ernest ¥. Voraw, Esq., - Gee
> - Asner. .BRovire, Esq., and = |.
-Epwarp- J. ROUIneRAr, ; Esq., representing the
Plaintiff ; bake a een Pies
Sipxex L. nS Esq, :
Wo. €1. ARK Mason, Esq., ~~ ig
Freverick H. Kaas, Esq., and: : :
Marty P. Snyper, Esq., ‘representing the Defen-
(‘x
«|= COArTHURgA. CHaLKER, having been duly. sworn, was
-xamined and testified as follows (Tr. pp. 33-46 ine.) +
P he | : ite .
o ; S : k : of
- Di eikonal
. Reser rake
: (Tr. pp.’ 33, » BH) : | P
4 4s By Mr. Veni S ; ’ ete S vf
Q. Mr. Chalker, you are aor cane by. ‘the def endant,
; “* the A. B. Kirschbaum: { ‘ompanyt °
., dant. ; — Rey ry pw % .
PLAINTIFF’S EVIDENCE... © -*". ”..
16 S: Arthur A. Chalker—Direct. rai te 2
e “A
A.lam .*. ee rar a
(). In what capacity? io ores
A. As cashier, ©
Q. How long—
A. And bookkeeper: ~
Q. How lang have you been with them?
A. Since 1890. . *, :
Sitce 1890, that was before they were incorpo-
Q.
eee ote ve 4
A. Yer, : ;
). Do Vou know when they were incorporated ?
A. 1922; I believe, May: 12th—or May 22nd, 6
Q. What are your duties? i a
‘A; To keep the books, send rent bills to our tenants
at the end of: the month, count the pay- “roll and pay it’ to a
our ten or twelve employees, : me ig
Q. What are your hours? 3
A. From eight till four, five days -a-week. I don’t
come in on Saturday.” . geste . Vata ae
(F And with-how long for hiaht. % : : ;
A. An hour for lunch; Rupa SISTER piel:
* “(1r. pp. 35-38 ine.) rer, | eae
e\ Mr, Chalker,—
Tre Coun: It doesn’t look’ to me as though
there are going to be a erent many facts here in this
suit, really, I don’t see why this suit should take a
very long time, but go ahead.
‘By Mr. Voraw: : | :
Q). —did you bring with vou the: lea ses with your af
‘tanants? ; ; ;
We have. » v7 4s eRe
Ris Could you produce them, please?
Tue Ce rr: W ell, is that atl*necessary? It is
° admitted that. they ledse-ine building to a number of
tenants: Can't you just tell us who they rare?
‘ “te
A. He has nentoved.
lay 5 a.
ier °
’ fra |t
aed
§ | ; :
’ Arthur A. Chalker—Direect., | 3.
Mr. Votaw: Well, | would like to have these -
oa irked for identification. 4° |
3 ef THe Court: Well, what .-is the use, what, is the”
. . use of loading up this recon Awith things that are,
“absolutely admitted, gentlenién? ’ Let ‘s not do it if
you can avoid it. aitoas
Just tell us. who your tenants are,’ Ar. Chalker,
You know who they pins ! : ;
| Tue Witness: 1 “will argad them off, i
es :
‘Thr Court: Yes, you read them off,
; Tur Wiryess:, Atlas Ticket Company.
THe Court: Yes... ocmdnens
Tur. Witness: Nicholas, D ‘klonso, N:—N_ for ;
Natha’=—Feldman, Fishman and Tobin, J. B. Haber,
Incorporated, Owl, Advertising Company, Progressive
Clothing Manufacturing, Irving Pinews and Brothers, .
_ J. Reed’s Sons, I. and C. Spivak, Lyéorperated, Pro-
gréssive Tailoring, Trading-as Ridgway Sportwear®
Company. ° | aati 9) Dae Beer
By Tur Court:
Q. Now, were they all tenants on n April 19, 1940! i
A. Yes, ‘
(Q. And they were the oily tendits of the building ?
' A. Only tenants. tor He soon
Tae Courr: All ee eats —
. By Mn, inate: Rie eta) .
—Q. There was one other tenant who has sinee re-
moved, Lit Brothers. was. itr the basement and has since
, AnOved out. es ).
e.
° . eS: oe "ss : { . . ,
> Saabs : 7
- id “ ry
18 - _ Arthur A. Chatkne—Tireit
By Tue Court: “5?
ae ae eetowe in the eniiat on April, ‘19402
» A. Yes, but they removed, August 31st.
se’ (Tr, 40-44 ine.)
~
- By Mr. Voraw:
Q. Pérhaps it inight be well at thi® time, Mr. @halker,
_ if you could describe this building to the Court so “that
Rote the ‘Court may have an idea of whit it is like.
: A, The Kirschbatim building Broad and Carpenter,
+ Was built in about 1902. it is a six- eory building, 372
by 85—
a Tue Court: Now, ‘ defendant ‘adinits it is a’
six-story, and basement building situated at the south-
east corifer_of Broad and Carpenter Streets, in the
city of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, and that it was
formerly occupied by the defendant as a factory for
” the production of men’s ‘clothing’ but it is how oper-
ated as'a loft building. « 3
°-~ That is what it adits. Now, is thse’ keythine
you want to add ta that that i is far importance? Don’t
#0 over all that. ,
a
*
_ By Mr. one. ZS . uae”
Q. Well,. ‘where are ‘the elevators and stairways situ-
ated? .- 7% rb ’
A. The elevators are in wiukt we calf the outside part |
of thé building—I mean, the stairways, rather, both® at’
the north end of the building aud the south end. There
are two elevators at tlie nerth end of the building, and one .
in the rear of the building, at Washington Avenue..-
Q. They are all on the east- side, of the building?
A. All ofi the east side of the building. .
Q. And there is a stairway or a fire tower, is there
not, in the middle.of the building on the east side?
_ A. Yes, there aye fire towers’ and stairways at the
e -
‘
= e
Cy, EE. illiam Mentzel—Direet. ’ ; 19
‘ ‘Carpenter Street eiitrance, in the midayt of the building, :
and also. at Washington Avenue, east. ;
Q. Yes.’ parents :
: 7 THE Covnr: It would be very. simple if we had ©
e a plan or a figure. . ,
Ae Mr. Brovir: I have, sir. It has some of my ?
notes on it, but i will oe ie it to counsel,
Tur Cot rT: -It may be that it is important to
sie know where, these elevators are and ier — do.
: : : Mr. Mason: No objection to that. ©
Tue Cover: All right, *recrived in evidence’ as”
‘ 5
e , in = + :
- (Plan of the building 0 of A. B. Kirschbaum Com- areas!
_ pany was marked Exhibit P-2.) @ ins
Mr Mason: I think we might note atl that point,
; Mr. Votaw, that the stairways reach to all floors jn
the building. o, AS iets dy ed
» - + + By Mr. Mason :
‘Q. Do they not?
A. Yes, sir. '
Mr. Votaw: Cross-examine.
Mr. Mason: No questions - 3 a
Mr. Votaw : tT hat fs all, Mr. Chalker.
ae ts
JZ °
WituuaM MENTZEL, shavin# been «duly sworn, was ex-
amined and testified as follows (Tr. pp. 47-79 ine.)
Divect-cxéuinntion.
ou Mr. Brome: May it please the Court, at the re-
quést of the defegdant, and in prder to avoid incon-
° ; . *
, - e
-
id ‘ od rs
on bd . *
-
°
“venience to it, we have agreed that witnesses will be
produced in relays,——_ .
20... .° +» William Mentzel—Direet.
"Tue Cov rt: All right. Bees is
Mr. Brovie: -—and. so it may be that we at one
point Gr another might run out of witnesses. > ;
2 Tae Covet: Oh,'that is Say all right 65
ecw :
ae Brovie:: I hope that with not happen.
he } -
“ Mn. Bropir: - ee
{Q. Mr. Mentzel, you are on iy Al B. Kirseh-
aun C ompany ? ? :
A. Yes, sir, lam. . bie
().. That company is the owner ‘of a— -
A. Kirschbaum. . af
a6 ,& —-factory building— :
A. Yes, sir. pie * MEPS
(). —at Broad and ne iter Streets, Philadelphia?
A. Yes, sir. :
Q). How long have you been etaplopad by A‘ B. Kirseb.
baum C omipany } ? ;
A. Well, I think it is ahout twenty, or twenty-one
years. : .
~Q. In what capacity ares vou employed? ,
A. Well, I used t& be\g’ building mechanic and elee-
trician, before 1 cay® from the Keystone, Watch Case-to
' the Kirschbaum Building. Then at that time they used.
to have about a hundred steam machines, and after they
went out of business, well, then, they rented the building
out. :
. 2 Just a moment, who wenf out of of Business
~ A. Why? Kirschbaum.
Q. Well, vou mean by that, do you, that they stopped
manufacturing? ,
, ¥ A. Stopped mannfacturing.
| Q. Clothing? ; .
operating: this. factory building?
- single industry itr the building. P
| William Mentzel—Direet. o pies 21
A. ‘Clothing. : ae
Q. But is it not a fact that they are still i in business,
‘Ss
A. As a loft building.
Mr°Mason: I object to the form in which that .
question is put. Obyiously, the witness does not run _
‘the Kirschbaum business,—- g
Tue Wirxess: W ell, they a in, business at
the présent time—
_... Mr. Mason: and I think we “islet now have.
this ‘distinction before us all. The question is that
the Kirschbaum Company operates the manufacturing *
building. The Kirschbaum Company does do no such
thing. ° The Kirschbaum Company, as counsel under-
stands perfectty, is the owner of the building. oe
lendlérd rents the space, and does not. operate ah
- Mr. ‘Bacore: Well, what Mr. Mason is ditkag is
- that he does not agree with our interpretation of the -
law applicable. to this case.
" Mr. Mason; No, I am saying something more
than that, I am saying something about facts, and not
law.
Mr. Misiath: Well, the facts will be dev oped by
witnesses and the Court ea, decide after the facts
are in-—_ : Se
. THE Cour rt: Well, that i is right.
’
Mr. Bropfr.: —-whether ‘Kirsehbaun} operates a
manufacturing btilding or not.
Tue ms ‘rt: That is right, but it is agreed that
_. Kirsehbanm directly, itself, does not do manufactirr- ’
- ing in the building.
Mr. Brovir: At the present, tins we will admit
-
”
_*
22- .-. William Mentzel—Direct.: . J,
that the defendant does no. manufacturing in ‘this
building. :
THE Conk? ‘That is ‘right.
Mr. Bropie: But we do not jekuitt that the defen-,
e dant does not operate this building.
@ 3 THe Court: That is right, I undaistand the
= ‘point. . ,
Sow, Mr. Brovie: Nor do we admit: that the building
is not a manufacturing building. ihre
— er Corr: Yes, that “is all right, i uyderstand.
as Bropre: Mr. Stenographer, will you read the
_ last answer of the witness, please?
‘(The testimony was repeated by the reporter, as
follows: °
Fog as eo ae But i is it not a fact that they aré still j in busi-
"+" "ness, operating this factory ‘building? "
Ky, ae i loft building.’*)
- By Mr. Brovir:
; Q. How long has it heen sinee A.. B. Kirschbaum
_ Company stopped mattufactuxing clothing in this building, :
. Mr. Mentzel? : i :
Mr. Masow : Well, is that important, Mr. Brodie?
A. About nine vears, | think. ieee
Mk. Brovie: Well, if Your Honor please, I repre-
sent to the Court ‘thai this is a material line of testi-
smony. - Xow, if Mr. Mason is so anxious to agree to
_ everything it seems ‘to me that. he@night as well agree
‘to an injunction: This is a material element of. our
ease, and I uvake that re presentation..
« Turd ‘ont: Well; it is only one question and it
isn’t worth Arguing about, and I will receive it.
Ww illiam Montes I-Direet. 23
By Tue Court:
—6Q. They stopped iiiinataetaiviie ‘about nine years, ago?
A. About that, bert Honor. , ‘
Tue C ouRT: AN right. — Nae die
By Mr: Baovm:
Q. And you worke d for A. B. Kirschbaum while*it — :
was manufacturing— ‘Bb _ fears,
A, | certainly—— | *¢ :
. Q. —in the building?
A. I certainly did. S ze
_ Q..When did you become an engineer ? te ic ee nae
__ A. About—as.soon as they give up the business, then °. .
T had to get my license, and be in the. engine room ‘as
engineer and building mechanic at the same time. — °
~**
* *.* (Tr. pp. 51-57 ine.)
- Q. Since you have become an engineer what have your --:
duties consisted of ? Ae Saas
A. Well, my.duties is to come-in the morning, blow
down, the boilers, see that the mud is out, and see that they
vot the right amount of water in the boilers, see that those —
boilers are cleaned out every two months, and ‘pack my
pumps, keep’ my pumps in repair, see that the elevator |
pump is in good condition, watch the elevator rods, be-
«cause they leak sometimes, take care of a hundred toilets
in the Kirschbaum building, and other: repairs sometimes
I have to do for the tenants.
- Q. What kind of pumps do you take care of?
A. Well,-I take care‘of the elevator pump, hydraulic
“pump, that. is one hundred and twenty-five Pounds pres-
" sure, Sap I see: that the fire pump is taken good care of,
and the| vacuum pump that is for the heat.ag system, re- ; ‘
turning’ water back to the heater, for our boilers to get
hot waters then I have a sewer pump,wiave to be blown
down takes the exeess water and pumps in the sewer,
\ y
eae William Mentzel—Direct.,
we aren n’t allowed to have hot water blow right in the
sewer, we have to let. it blow in the well, and“len pump
it-out in the sewer, then we have a boiler feed pump, which
supplies the boilers the amount of water we want, in case
we have a breakdown we ‘change ovér to the sewer pump,
~. then we have a house pump for, drinking water, which
- supplies all ‘toilets and the drinking water and the ice
coolers through the building.
And what force operates these ra f;
. WAL at ninety pound pressure.
im pressure?
S
eam. pressure, ninety “pounds.
Where is that pressure generated? 2
. In the boiler room, by two boiters.
Who takes care of those boilers?
., Well, we have a fireman there that takes care of
es
S
peo oO POs
“those, ‘boilers. There’ is three: shifts, eight. hours to thee
shift? si .
‘Q: What duties have you in connection with those
boilers?
A. Well, I have got to see that the steanr is up and
that everything is running: ©. K., that the place keeps -
" running. 3
Fri (Tr. pp. 59, 60.)
c
.
Q. For what purpose, apart from. the operation of the
pumps, is steam generated in these boilers?
-* A. Why, the elevator pnmp,s—
_Q. No, for what— ff sp spenenoe
- By Tur Court:
Q. Ww hat besides er
he ORs
Q. —is steam pa for? : |
A. -Oh,. for’ the steam machites, ‘for all the ‘steam
& mathines through the paihcing, steam irons and sponging
machines. ! .
Y
Dee’ is oD Aer ae &
W iam, Mentzel—Direet, 5
» »
~Q. What do they, do? “What do those machines do?
A. Well, they press the Sear for the tailors in the
_ -~ tailoi-stiop, like Progressive Clothing Company, Fishman
has machines, Haber has: mace shines, Feldman, and I think
that is about—and Mr. Spivak, I beg your pardon,
By Mr. ‘Buovte: “ ise 7 Ped}
are in the’ building? e
A. Well, that is hard for me to say, because I have—
-one time I Was up there, there. was about, over one hun-
dréd and forty. You will have to ask the chief engineer
_when he comes out. I don’t go pee building and
‘count those machines, pris
*Q, How is steam supplied ‘to these various machines?
. Well, ‘before I ask you that questidn, are these
machines in the defendant’s premises?
.
chines, and ea¢h one is their own— -
Q. Will you describe to the Court vel the steam | is
2 supplied to these machines?
to the sixth floor from the, basement, and: those are
own. Valves and supply their own’ Steam. ~Some lave
_ the Progressive Clothing Company.
tinuous?
. - « A, Well, -at night, there is some of the tenants, like
‘the D’Alonzo turns. his ‘off at night, and ebmsn apd
Tobin turn theirs off then, onthe fourth floor, the Gov-
ernment work; they turn those ‘off, that make the Govern-
ment uniforms, and the third floor leaves theirs on, be-
cause they have yo trap sy stem, there is about sixty ma-
turned off until “Monday morning. ai
oO
>
and Tobin has steam irons, then D’Alonzo, then Pineus .
Q. Do you know how many inressingd adh ines’ thefe
A. Ali olutely, on each floor they have their own mae
- A. Well, there is a riser, a steam main that runs up .
branched off to each tenant on each floor, they have their
traps, and there is one party that has no fraps; inet is
Q. Is the steam turned on and off daily, or: is ‘it! con-
chines stay on all-night, except Friday night they are
™%
me
ee illiam Mentzel—Direct. :
@
>
Then’ thera is Spivak, he turns his off, and Mr. Haber,
and Mr. -Pineus, and Mr. Feldman turns ‘his off, except the —
- third floor is ‘kept.on all night,. because thev have no steam
’ traps at all on that floor. :
poe’ At what pressure is that steam supplied ‘a or |
tenants? ~~ ,
A. At ninety pounds. | oe bee
> . Is that the usual pressure at which steam is Yen-.
erated in a steam heating plant, or is that an unusually
high pressure?
°A.-No, that is the regular pressure we have for the
pumps and for the pressing. We daren’t have lower than
that, because if they. draw- water you can’t press a ‘suit,
and having water in your steam, it would bring the coat
‘ up. It has, got to be absolutely dry, us dry -as you Cat)
"ie ea 4
Q. And is it, therefore, necessary to hav: e steam at a
pressure.of at le: ist ninety pounds ? ¥
A. Yes.
Q. In order to make it effective?
A. You have got to have ninety peunds there. We
always have the charis to keep it, in case they’ kick, we 4
show them, we have a chart there, it is ninety. pounds, un- .— 4
_less their trap sticks on the floor and they don’t 7 :
the water.
Y. Do you know for what other Purposes. steam is
/ generated?
— A. °Well, they. a, on the sponging machine, like -
the Progressive, they have a sponging, machine, ande
Haber,-Mr. Haber, has a sponging machine, ‘too. | ae
© &.Do-vou know what thé function of’ the .sponging..
machine is? ~
A. Well, they. have about an inch BPE at: is hard
to tell— Sag a
Se pit TO Rea te 3 2 ip gh
ites
Klecongx se
Seles
Mr, M ASON : Juat ‘A moment, — :
Tue Court: Have you got somebods else that
att. operates these machines?
\ .
\ ¥ 2 1 iar)
\
-. William Mentzel—Direet. OF
a Ne
* Mr. Brovir: W ell, I will bring that out by the
_ tenants.
« THE Court: All right.
Mz. Bronte All ee sir.
ie ©.
be e : By Mr. Racin’ Dimeslee Sie wemgircd, sec ue
-Q. Is there any other ‘purposé. for the steani ore is
generated by your boilers? ‘ ms
‘A. Well, for the a, to run the engines in the
engine. room.
‘oe
¥
By ‘Dae Cover: :
Q.. Run the engines for what, the eleyatot
A. No, these are. hydraulic elevators, YourgHonor.
Q. What are the engines— :
A. They are run to supply electricity to the tenants, |
Q. Oh. ,
» -
By Ma. Brove:
Q. Is that. electricity which is- generated, I mean, | is
Gat a direct current or alternating current?
A. Direct ,current. cy st est |
Q. De you know for what: purpose it is generated?
A. Well, it is generated for two of our tenants, like
broad ‘D’Alonzo—
«
: By tHe C OURT:. .
° Q. No, but what do ‘they a with it?
A. Well; they use only lights, they have all the lights
on the sixth floor, we have a throw-over switch+there, for
this electricity, Your Honor, to the -direct current, .and
there. is one motor that Mr. D’Alonzo has, a three and a.
quarter: horse power, lie runs that for a iine of sewing
machines, then he has no meter up there, -but then Mr. .
Spivak has a meter, Which they charge him for motors
and lights:
“a
28 Bs Willian Mentzél—Direct.
Then we ‘antl our basement and ‘the toilets up to
- the second floor with our lights, and \ Wwe | used to supply Lit,
ri.
> 8h
3
, Brothers, but they moved out. °
J
°
, By Mr. Brome: s Le ay °
Q. Does the electricity: gencrated i in the building sup-
ply thé lights in the elevators? us © ee x
> A. They do, and the ‘stairway. | °
Q. Now, what other, purpose is steam generated for?
A. Well, the steam for all our pumps. °-
—Q.. Yes, areeue °
A. What I mehtioned. Furs
Q. How is the building heated ?
o
A. That is heated by the exhaust steam from our °
engine, that comes—exhaust that goes in the heater -and
up through the riser, goes through the. heating system,
and the water condenses snd:is pulled Back through’ the
vacuum. pump, and the het water thrown in “the seri
that we can use. The hotter water we get for the boilers
the better it is.” That saves .us coal.
Q. Well, vour answer is that the bnilding is heated
" by the’ &team— j ng
A. Steam > ;
-, Q. —whith ‘is ‘geneygted in these boilers?
, A. But if we ‘haven't enough in the cold weather we
turf the live steam valve on. a
Q. And what foree runs the elevators!”
A. Well, one hundred afd twenty-five ‘pounds pres-
sure, water,-on the hy draulic elevator pump. ,. °
oO
a
By THE Cover: ‘ieg f ;
Q. . was going to say, how do- you get the pressure
‘in the water? —
/
By Mr. Bropre: ~
- Q. How was that pressure generated?
\
—
q
ait
me g | ee 2 Z é | 3 ; a - ; F
| William Mentzel—Direct:* 29 |
ps ora es Shee" oe
Behe That is from a hydraulic pump, from a hydraulic.
‘pump. We.have a tank’ where the water is in,.and, that
pumps up in another tank, which creates a pressure, then
we have to pump air in it once -in-a while to keep: air ou
tp of the tank.
| ‘By THe Court: ue | = :
j 3 Q. W hat runs the pump? -S |
Ao The steam.
id
r N B
By Mr. RODIE : 6
Q. Do you ‘know how many elevators there are?
A. There: are three; two on the Carpenter Street’ en-
trance, one passenger and ene freight, and one on WwW ash-.,
ington. Avenue is one, freight. .
-- Q. When Kirschbaum was operating in tls buitding
do you know how many elevators there were there?” ee
_ A. Three. !
9 Mr. Mason: That ‘is subject to my objection.
Tur Witness: Three, the same ¢fhing.
Fg Mason: My general objection. 7
2.
By Mr. Rgopir :
Q. “Were they the. same elevators!
A. Same elevators. is
Q. Apart from the generation of the steam, which is
; wae your control,-do you hay e anything to dé with the .
elevators? a
E +A. Well, T have got to take care of sioea: pack the
‘2 cylinders when they sink, and I have got to take care of
aity elevator that sticks on the floor, I have got to see
‘what. is the trouble, or the interlocks on the elevator, see
that they are running. . '
Q. What -do’ you mean by packing the plangers?
A. Well, I have _got to tiike—see, : ‘it is up to the ®
> « 4
Jy *,
| safety device, ‘of the davator inspector, to seé that: thoes .
30 | ; W ‘liam Mentael—Dir ect.
* e
elevators dou sink. Well, if an elevator is on the floor,
and that elevator would: sink. while the. man is standing
outside, she will go below the floor, and if she sinks some-
body is liable’ to step in there and get injured, so it ise.
up to ps to keep those elevators on the floor. You have
got to pull packing out and pack it. “It takes about seven
rings. I pack it about every five months or six months,
(). is or is not the packing of the plungers essential
to the ptfectiv e operation of the elevators ?.,
-A..Oh, it.is, you have got-to have the packing there.
\). AnaSto you do anything else in.g mpection “with
the elevators? — '
A. Well, Lhelp the tenants out onee in a“while, when
they call me:up, look at a motor, or light, or steam Jma-
chine, sometime, . .
—Q.Ao, T an referring new to the elevators,
“ AL Oh, well, that. is all we ean, do. _T. don’t put the
cables on. That i is up to oF elevator—<( tis Elevator <‘om-
pany. 9 es
~Q. Are. the cables renewed periodically ?. -
A. They are when thé inspector condemns them and
he thinks it is proper to have new cables on, it is up to
the company to have hew cables put on the elevators. -
A. Has there been anything else done to the elev ators
recently? ae
A. Well, we had safety jeates on on ‘if, three safety .
gates put on it.
— ‘Q: What other’ repairs do you make generally around
the buiding? ;
A. Well, I have my one hundred toilets to take care
of, and the spigots in the washrooms, and the heating sys-
tem. Sdmetimes there is a leak on the floor, Something *
‘like that; just keep everything in repair and running.
Q. Do. vou have anything to do with the sprinklers?
A. I do. . : :
Q. What do voudo? = * =
”
William Mentzel—Direct.
A. Well, I have goi to. take care of the .sprinkler
tank, seé that the sprinkler tank is’ ful, and the fire tank
in the yard is full, the suction tank, and if the sprinkler
aks, I have got to take a head off and put a new head
on the sprinkler, and turn. on the water again, ve as the’
seal on the valve,
Q. Do you have anything.to, do with the iailtentng by
“which the various Sree are heated?
. ‘A. T have.
ee: * What do vou do with: ‘those?
31 .
A. Well; T have got to see that the traps are work- |
ing.. Sometimes those traps stick, and they get a little.
rust in, and then I have: got to take ther: apart ‘and clean
them out and see that they are running 0. a get the
suction for the heating system.
- Q. Have you ever had occasion to move aly radia.
tors’ around? :
A. I have. -T have tikce—pat three in the Atlas
Ticket Company, took two out of Jacoh Reed’s, and re-
naired two up, made two radiators uyi. 3
Q. Do you know. for what uses You moved these
radiators around?
A. Well, they were—the ie ones were’ all out of
commission, so Thad to take them out, disband them and
ut these new: “ones in there. > They were pretty well.
Q. Well; I will put it this way, Was it or was if jar
to suit the convenience of the particular tenants?
A. It was to. suit the tenants, where they che at the
place. ;
Q. Do-vou or do vou not know whether all the ten- .
ants” 9 this building are engaged fn manufacturing?
A.'They are all engaged in manufacturing. There:
one,-I think, one contractor is Mr. Fe eldman, 1 believe] T-
am not sure, he makes—has contract’ work.
Q. Well, by contract work, what do you mean?
A. He is given—has coats by contracting, just making
‘the coats and shipping them out again. ,
. ‘ a
ad
' .
3 32 . = William Mentsel--Cross.
_Q. ‘But does he do the. making, the manufacturing?
A. On the coats, yes, he makes them. ue
(). On these premises? .
“A. You are. right, there,. because it is some contract
work, you know. I am not- through the building, so much. |
Q. What man works with you, Mr. Mentzel? é
A. Well, there is only the fireman and I, we both work
together. If I leave the engine roow I tell him to watch
the engine while I am out. See, I got to leave some-
time. eats nis
Q. What is his name?
A. McKinley, Eddie McKinley.
Q. Do you mean McKinley Edwards? °
° A: That is it, MeKinley Edwards, I beg your pardon, °
I mace o mistake. ’ =
Q. Are there any other firemen-that work with you?
A. There is Pete Rocea,- and hia Rocks. There is _
two Petes, see.
1 eo ep, np, 71:75 ined.)
--C ross-Exarination.
Mr. Mason: I don’t think there is much to ask
this witness, enone to clarify one phase of his tes-
timony, probably.
By Mr. Mason :
Q. Mr. Mentzel, you testified that as ‘engineer—
A. Yes.
Q. —you, were in n charge of ‘Producing steam?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, steam has been referred to here as live |
-stearm—"
A. Live steam.
Q. —and exhaust steam.
A. Exhaust. steam, yes, sir.
Q. And -_ to make it perfectly clear, so we will
7
o ites as ;
fr wep: ‘William Miitised-C ee ae
- knew what"We are talking about, in so far as your iaank
mony is concerned, will you tell us what use is made of,
the exhaust steam which is produced i in the’ building under
your engineer’s job? .
A. Well, that I told them, that ‘tiene steam is used
in the heating syStem, through the steam radiators, and
brought back again through the condensmg pump, arid
throwing that hot water in the heater again, then pumping
that hot water into the boilers, then if we havéen’t enough
in the cold weather with exhaust steam, we turn some, of
the live steam on. ' .
(). All right. Now, then, what do fou use the live .
steam for? at Ne Bi ee
A. Live steam for all the pressing machines, the
engines, and the pumps. as
Q. All right, when you speak ‘of the engine, what - en:
gine are you fglking about?
A. That is what generates electric re the tenants.
- Q. Alb right.
A. For them two tenants,
' 'Q. Now, yon say you generate electricity?
_. A. Yes.
Q. You generate electricity to light the building, do
you oo / ar :
A. Just our part, in the basement, and the stairway
and the elevators, SEAM Ri yee
‘
Q. Well, the whole building?
A. Not the whole -building.
Q. Why: not? .,
A. No, because they are tenants, they get their own
power, some of the tenants have their. own power, only
I’ Alonzo—
Q. Where do they get that? Digs
A. They get that from the nladelphia Blectrie.
Q. Oh, then there is another source of electricity than |
the engine which you operate? — fof,
A. That is » the direct current. |
oe . Ss
‘BA : William Mentzel—Re-direct. § «
Q. I see.
A. The Philadelphia Hlectric ‘supplies A. C. in there.
%. I see. 7
By Tue Court: ; *
Q. You eae supply two tenants with electricity? +)
A. Yes. :
Q. Do they also get electricity from the Philadelphia
Electric? : a
A. They have, yes, double, a throw-over switeh.
Q: Those two tenants?. .
‘A. Yes, they have a throw-over switch, 4 put « one for
Mr..D’Alonzo, throw-over switch, throw-over, see, at night,
He uses from eight o’elock in’ the mor ning, until
‘five’ or ten minutes after five .in the evening, when he
sees it is ten minutes after five he will thrqw over his
‘ switch and use the Philadelphia Electric. And I throw
Mr. Spivak’s switeh over when they that.
‘Q. Why is that? ‘ ;
A. That is a double, throw-ov swi sh, .ce?
i), ae don't they ‘take it all from the Philadelphia
Electric?
‘.A. I think it is "cheaper, they get it cheaper, see!
- < a
-Tue Cover: All right, go ahead.
_ | Mr. Mason: That is » all, I just wanted to clarify
Tw eae That is call.” j fe
Pa rc UP Oo .
By Mn. Brovir:
Q. Just a few questions, Mr.’ Mentzel. Do you know
whether the current ‘supplied by the Philadelphia, Elee-
tric is direet current or alternating current?
A. Alternating current.
¢ ;
° os
¢
ae
George Simon—Direet.- ~ ; 35
yw. Do. you know whether or not alternating curfent
can operate direct current.motors? .
A. No, it. couldn’t, unless it was a universal - motor,
special motor made up for that, universal. —
Q. There has been: some‘reference to exhaust steam.
That exhaust steam which you referred to is part of the -
steang which is generated as live steam, isn’t it?. *°’
A. Live, yes, that is the exhaust from the engines,
pumps. ee ee: |
Mr. Bron: No further questions.
Mx. Mason: That is all, thank you.
“GEORGE Smox, haying been ‘duly sworl, was éxam-
ined and feetited: as follows (Tr. pp. 79-92 incl.) :
Direc t-exétmination.
By Mr. Voraw:.. ° : oe
Q. Mr. Simon, you are employed by A. B. ized:
baum Coppanyt® ieee: As
A. Yes, sir.
'Q. How long ‘have you 1 been employed by them?
‘A. Well, I would say about seventeen or eigateen
years. aaa
. Why, running the freight elevator.
‘Which freight elevator do you run?
. Up at the Carpenter Street gnd. -
And’ when does that ‘start in the morning?
id ge
. And when deées it stop in the evening?
A. Six. ’
_Q. And is it “used fort anything but- freight?
@ ;
A. Well, in the morning I carry up—it is passenger
wt . : .
, °
* ¢
And what is ‘your work with chee) x vow?.
Fight o’clock. - ol
— (386 ; George Simon—Direet. Pind ude ay Soe aibes
and freight too, you bnow, I earry up passengers. That
is, well, about quarter after eight, I get them up. That is
to help the passenger fellow to get em RS
Q). Who are these passengers? .
A. Different people works in ‘the building.
@ They are the people that work in the building?
_A. Work in the building. | , ee
By Tue Court:
~Q. Which elevator do you operate”
A. The freight elevator. :
Q. Freight.
By Mr. Votaw:
ae the'north. end.,
o3
;
A. North end. : .
D THe Court: Oh, north end, all right.
ries By Mn. Voraw:
. ’
Q. Now, how long a ‘time did you—in-.the morning—
did you take. up these passengers and employees?
A. Why, from eight until about quarter after eight. .
ei Q. I see, and is it used for passengers at noon time?
A. I take down about.two or three Joads, about—
~ about five or ten minutes, that is all, and then i in the even-
- ing it is used again. a
__Q. In the evening?.
A. From five yntil about quarter after five.
Q. Now, what kind of freight comes im on that ele-—
vatorf! ¢ ;
A. Well, there is cloth comes in trie different floors,
linings,. stuff like that.
7g How is it. packed?”
aie A, Well. there is some of, it in 1 bundles, and some of
; # is in cases. Poon
Ree tae ee ,
. » .
2 ~ .
sn » = iat ~~ «
<4 ee ee ee
eS re wy
Lee ae Ue
ee
George Simon—Direet. : | 37
Q. What is’ ‘the range in weight, these arious pack-
ages?
A. Well, I couldn’t tell you, I don’t h dle that. The »
only thing, I ask the party if it is—if Ifthink it is too |
heavy to take up, -just to sliow me the bill, let me know -
the weight, and then I know what I am doihg. :
Q, Well, what would those weights be on the bijls? -
A. Well, some of them weighs around—if it is canvas
or stuff like that, % runs around seven hundred’ to a thou-
sand pounds.
Q. What kind of -a package would 08 be int
A. That would be in a case.
-Q. In a case, wooden case? ; .
A. Wooden case.
_Q. How often does the freight come in?
A. Well, it ain’t—it don’t seem to be much coming |
in now. Some days we are pretty busy. Other days just
switch around the opposite way. Woo erst
Q. 1. see. _ Are there any days’ when | none is. com-
ine in? |
A. No, there jis always some comes in.
Q. Always soine ¢oming in. Now, do: you put the
freight on and off the elevator?
ary 5 No, sir, I don’t.
- Whe does do that?
A. The.truck driver. He sce it.on, takes it off. I ‘7
just take him up.
Q. I see. The truck driver ; goes up with the freight?
A. He goes up with the freight, MG
Q. And takes it off. Now; how about outgoing
‘freighf? oP en ee
A. ‘Same way.
Q. Is there some going out every day?
A. Some.going out every day.
—
‘Mr. Mason: Going up every day?
Mr. Voraw: And out, out every day.
‘ cy : :
on
. * 4, .- .
wf George Simon—Direct..
By Mr. Voraw: |
_ QQ. And what type of packages does it go out in?
A. Well,.there is sometimes, they have.a large order, — ~
they send some suits out in cases, and then other times &
in large cartons. > :
~ “Q. Are there any of the tenants whWsend out pank=
ages Tegularly, at a particular time in the day, every
’ day? ae
ee Fishman and Tobin, they sont out their
freight pretty near tlle same honr every day. :
.Q. About what time? P
A. Well, ebout half-past three; T guess, around there.
And then they: might pick up a few—sanie fellow calls
from there, he takes from the third, well, they might have
a couple of eartons, too, to go out.
(). T see, and what size packages ‘would these be?
A. Well, it ain’t always: the same size. Some of thent.
is small, like one suit in some of them, maybe might have
a half a dozen suits in them. oa
Q. Are there packages such as could be carried down-
stairs? )
“A. T don’t think they could. They. are a Jittle too
heavy. ~
Q). Does any clothing ever go fae on jocktet
A. .The only _clothing goes out on racks, there might
_bea few coats go out from Jaevob Reed, like, Jacob Reed’s,
on the first floor: there.
Q. What is a rack Wire? Can you deseribe a rack?
.. . A. Well, it is just a couple of ‘pieces of pipe, like ~
three-quarter pipe. with a top piece, and then rollers on =
the bottom, and they hang the coats on. with hangers, see.” @
(). About how long would it he?
A. Oh, well,’ they are different lengths. Some of
them is longer than others. :
Q. Could they be- carried out?
A.-No, sir. *
Q.. Does it ever happen that more than one truck gets
there at the same time?
&°
°
_ George Simon—Direct. ent 39
A. Yes, there is more than one truck sania: gets:
there. Two or three may . ee get in the yard at
one time.> ~
Q. How doy you tell which to take up first, then?
‘A. The first ones. there. :
' Q. First come, first served?”
A. First come.
Q. Do the trucks wait while— ;
A. Oh, yés.., 3 eee ay
Q. —the freight goes up?. we
A. They wait. :
Q. And they wait iis the driver Bice up to a
freight?
————
A. Yes, they wait, ‘without it is’ s too fog, be i is up
there for a good while, and then IT will come down and
pick the other one-up. . —
oY ee hs moe’ 5 aes 85-87 incl.) —
) Now, what is the size of the-loading platform on
the ground floor? bd 5 |
A. Well, I -couldn’t exactly tél! you. IT guess: ait is a ®-
platform pretty near the size of that jury box there (in-
dicating). am , ter ee
Q. Is it enclosed at all? |
A. Well, it is just one part of it, there is a v top over
it, and just otie end is closed in. .
Q. It couldn't he used for storage there?
A. No.
Q. What type of truckmen come ? 7
Mr. Masow: What is their'eolor?.. +,
A. What do you mean, what concern?
By M k. Voraw:
Q. Yes, what. concern. a
_ A. Well, it is Pennsylvania Railroad, Seott Brothers, *
soe, ippineotts, and different places, firms, like that, tfuck,
drivers, 5
4
*
ae Th George Simon—Direet.
—Q. Do you know where they come from?
.A. No, I -don’t
Q. Do you recall any time when the setae were
shut down for any, reason?
A. How is that?
Q.” Do youw recall any time when the elevators were
shut down?
eae, ‘ A. The only time they were closed a while, that was—
‘one of them was running, the other was closed—w as-when °
they were putting on those safety gates,
Q. I see. Did that have any effect on the—
A. No, sir.
Ses ts Q. —volume of traffic?
_A. No, that didn’t have effect.
Q. -Yow say. you were employed about seventeen or
eighteen years by Kirschbaum?
A. About seventeen or eighteen vears.
Q. That goes: back to the time when they were manu-
facturing? © Laas ee ™
. A. Manufacturing. ED
sete! Q. Clothing? ~~ :
as 3 A. Yes, sir.”
- Q. Were you also an elevator operator at that’ time?
A. No, I was—when Mr. Mentzel“was in tlie shop, [
was in the engine room for a while, |
~ Q.T see. : _
A. Just took care of the engines. ‘
Q. I see. Now, at that tinie, when Kirschbaum was
. manufacturing® clothing, were the elevators used for trans-
porting freight up and down?
A. Oh, they had to feteh their own stuff up. and
>
aoe: , ~ € -? ; +/
Q. I see. Erne iat ie,
A. Gét their own stuff out. tA :
: By Tue Covert: on .
ae
Q. Was the use substantially the same as it is now?
> Te <
Dommartin OO: si ca! acts
ee eee tae | er paar
nee
AO ah
p an oo ig a
Se SRT OE pea ed
a 0
‘get. on.
2
George Simon—Direct. * .. | 41
A. Yes, sir, on, the same -order.
By Mr. Voraw: be
2
- QQ. Do you take anything. hesides Treight down on-
these elevators?
A. Only passengers, only. machinery, like if there is
‘a person moving in or coming in, or moving out, of
+ - course, we got to take that Gown for them..-
Q). Is rubbish removed by these elevators?
‘A. Only at this end where I am at, there is only two
floors, that i is, the. second and Jacob Reed, ‘but then there
is always a man, pushes that on and he takes it off, and
takes it back to the back end.
Q. In the, morning are you able to he the paeven-
gers up.as fast as they arrive? .-
A. Well, don’t take so long to get them up, according
to—they generally come in different timies, vou know. If
they all come im at one time, of course, it jams us Mp a
little, but don't take long to zet them up, beth-elevators. .
~ Q Do some of, them have, to wait?
A. Some of them pave to wait their turn, until they
_ Q. Do voa stop at all ose?
A. No, I only take the third and fifth. ‘The “passen-
___ ger, hhe_stops_at-all floors.
~ Q. T see, you only bas: the third and fifth?
A. Third and the fifth.
_ Q. Would ‘you’ ever. have to skip the third because
you were full up front the fifth?. .
me Oh, yes, I had that, becanse sometimes the third -
wasn’t over there to get on, and T had a whole load for
the fifth, so T went right up to the fifth.
Q). Do vou do anything besides elev ator work now?
A. Yes, T watch. on Saturdays, and on Sundavs, one
Saturday a month I'watch, and then one Sunday a month.
Q. What time Saturday?
A. Well, if IT am, on a Saturday watching. it is ree
three till five.
r we
% . ; @
~ 42
OPOPOPO
\ George Simon—Direct.
an’ on Suiday, watching?
. On Sunday it.is from seven till five.
What do you do.when you are watching? -
. Have to walk threugh the building and ring clocks.
Where are those clocks? -
. On the different floors, clocks on every floor.
What Ame on the floor?
THE Court: Well, now,would you advise me as
to the theory: ‘on which that ismaterial, what position
the watchman’ s clocks are on the floor?
Mr. -Voraw: .Well, I didn’t, want to ask him
’ whether they were inside,the premises ofthe terants.
I thought I could get at that by asking him a non- | °
leading question. °°
oi THE Court: I know, but then what?
Mr. Voraw: I want to develop that he had to go
through the tenants’ premises and watch the whole
premises, not only just in-the hallways.
THE Court: Ww ell, why goo, you: ask “him?
By Tue Court: Soe
Q. Do you watch tenants” preintses as’ well as. the
hallways?
A. Yes, I go right through the floor where they are at.
Q. All right.
A. One at each end, a clock at each end.
THE Court: All right. eg
By Mr. Vou ABW :
Q. Do yon have to wateh for windows that. are open?:
A. ®h, yes.
Q. Radiators that leak?.
A. Yes. %
Harry Gallagher—Direct. © 43.
\
By Tur Cover: - \
; Q. W. ell, you do whatever a wate im does te Reh
A. Yes.
‘THe Court: We all Iniow what that i is.
‘Mr. Mason: In fact, he has been there so 0 Jong he -
does it well.
By Mn Votaw: “G
Q. Just what. is it that a watchman does? That is
just what we are trying to find out. Just what i is it that a
watchman does?
‘y - Tre Covurr: Well, I know what a iia does..
Don’t go into that. So does the Supreme Court.
MyM ason: Maybe some of those ‘that will be,
there when this case gets there won’t. know what a
watchman does. i
THe Court: All right. |
Mr. Voraw: Cross-examine.
( o Mr. Mason :.No Is
Le]
; —_ — A A a ———S
_, Harry GaLiacHer, : have. been duly sworn, was ex-. .
amined and testified as follows (Tr. PP. 93-100 inel. ie
ise petuadion. Figs
.. Ge (Tr. p. 93). F
(3 By Mn! Voraw:
Q Mr. Gallagher, you are employed by the defend.
‘ant in this case? : 7
A. Yes.. o.
-Q. A. B Kirschbaum tps ped
G
er 0) Harry Gallagher—Direet.
A, * ain. ie wine ae
(). How long have you been sere ed by. them ?. -
A. Since. 1934.
Q: During the latter part of 1938 and first part of
1939 what was-your employment? See a
_ A. Well, was a porter. eee sees
Q. Porter?
A. Yes. re.
Q.. Now, as porter what did you dot
A. T attended to all the toilets—lav afories, I meant to
.say—clean windows, and watch, when the watchman was.
_ off I took his place, once a month.”
Q. Once a month?
A. Yes, and then f work in bis place when he is off
at night, or, for: weeks, I worked ninety- eight “hours a.
_ week.
Q. Now, did you have anything’ to do. with the ele:
vators at that time? + rs S nie
= yes, T was. werking on the hag only re-—
lief man. 3
Q. I see. What did that ork sahnkan of ?
fs A. Why, from twelve o'clock to one-thirty.
«= Q. And what did you do from twelve to one- -thirty?
A. Relievis.z the man to go to lunch.
————-9--Fust-o1-one-elevatort- AOE RS OSS
"A. No, three of them. Sea
Q. I see, half an hour on each? |
A. Half an hour on each, yes, sir:
‘@ Q. And ‘what has been your ‘employment since the
latter part of 1939?
A. Well, I-done watching for—and 1 run the elevator.
Q. You run the elevator. Which elevator do you run
now? ;
A. The Carpenter. Street slovaie: passenger,
Q. The passenger elevator at ecpetee Street.. That 3
is what you have been doing’ now? ea
A. Yes; sir.
- €
@ : Harry Gallagher—Direct. aaa 45
‘vators ?
| “A. Just the pak one and there are’ salesmen. |
Q. Employees and salesmen; employees of whom? —
A. Of the different ones in the building. bees
Q, Of the different ones in the building. “ Are there
any customers, also? ;
_—. A. Why, ‘yes, people comes up to D’ Alonzo’ s after
suits, and brings them down. ,
Q. And the tenants themselves, I suppos¢—
_A. Yes, the tenants. : i
Q. —use the elevators. a creqeent is the
use of those elevators? iia.
A. Oh, I am up: and down every—every second, I
‘guess,
| Q. Up-and down all ra time?
= A. All the time.
q. Are there any particular rush hours?
in the nights, coming out.
Q. Then vou have the freight. elevator alongside of
you. to help? | ee Pe Sie .
A. Yes, sir. aes |
___they_congregate? ~~
and a half.
. periods? ie is
A. Well, sometimes I go ‘it floors, if T don’t have
nobody to go. off the floor.
: Q. Is there anv rule ahout ‘floors which, can use the
elevators? .
A.. What?
. the elevators?
A: Well, the fifth floor, the sixth baie and all the floors
can use them,
1 J 2
Q. And ial type of passengers ride on those ele-
A. Well, around twelve. oO ’cloe ‘k, in y the’ mornings, and.
-Q. Are vou able to take them np. and down. as fast as-
A. Well, they time me in about a minute or niinute .
Q. Now, dosyou go to all the floors’ at these rush
Q. Is there any rule abont thie floors which may use
46 Harry Gallagher—Direet.
Q. Can ‘the employ ees onthe first three floors use the
elevators? -
A, Well, no, sir.
Q. They can’t? Why not?
A. Well, the only oties use it’ is pinkers, going up-
stairs, that is the only one that uses the elevator.
'Q. Well, why is that?
A. They go up to D’Alonzo to get the stuff made up,
they take clothes up there.
s
Mr. Mason: I can’t quite uvar you. Will you lift
-your voice a little bit?
. Tue Witness: -I say, they take’ clothes upstairs
to be made. raed :
Mr. Masos: I didn’t get that.. What was that?
Tur Cort: Take clothes upstairs.
Tue Wirsess: Yes, the pinkers takes clothes up-
stairs, !
Tur Cocnr: “The ‘iphslkers takes clothes upstairs.”
*
Mr. Mason: L.see. a
* Tee Wirsess: Up at "Alonzo's,
‘Mr.. Mason: I thought it was something ‘impor-
tant.
/ Tue Wi irNess: No. »
By Mr. Votaw? eee
Q. Was there avy period, when the elevators were
, closed down, that you remember?
‘A, Only, when they pack them and put the gates on,
“oa
that is all
. Q, Wien they pack them and _whon-they_were patting:
the pA on?
A. No/I said when they was packing it aa put the
gates on. .
Pe | /
‘ Harry Gallaghyg —Cross, ; 47
Q.. Yes. vane
A. Safety gates:
» Q. Yes. Did you ever have ta,do any ‘ute elevator
work for the tenants?
A. Yes, I: work on Saturday afternoon after three
o’clock for the Progressive Clothing Company.
Q. Is that regularly every Saturday or énly occa-
‘sionally? ; ~
A. No, two Saturdays i in a month?
Q. Two Saturdays in a month?
-
a-
By Tue Couns: Ce lige te
Q. They. pay you FE
A, Yes, sir.
By Mr. Vouvw: , as
2 What type freight aes up. these elevators and
down?
‘. A, Well, I don't ron no fret ight Ops on iy car, L have
passengers, :
Q. You don’t on your ear? °
A. I just run the passengers.
Q. When you were Gcting as relief elevator operator,
in the early part of 1939, on the freight elevators, at noon
lime, was much freight going up and down then? '
: A. Well,. every once in ‘a while, L would go up and
_ down with a packsge, or, say, for the third floor, lining,
they put that on a truck and took it upstairs.
Q. And what type packages ;would they be?
A. Well, just bundles they put on the track and push . ‘
it on the elevator and take it upstairs, and push it off.
aes C ‘ros s-examination. .
By Mr. Magn
g. I just want to be correct, Mr. Gallagher.. As 1
-
48 es Samuel H. Pine toren.
understood your answer to counsel’ 8 question, it was that
on Saturday afternoon—
A. Yes, sir. .
Q. —you frequently. work overtime for the tenants?
A. Yes, for the Progressive, yes. - ,
Q. And they pay you?
A. Yes.° : + &
/ By Ta aes ,
‘YQ. Twice a‘ month?
A. Well, I work on Sunday, and I do y Saturdays in °
between - — al
y Ms. Masow: -
. QQ. Then sometimes during the week days after your
regular work is done you’work also for some of the ten-
aunts, do you not, sometimes?
A. I work for D’Alonzo, about an hour or so. +
Y. Yes. pits. 9, a
‘A, Two hours. - ° *
Q. And he pays you for that?
A. Yes, sir.
Ma. Masos: That is all.
. Mr. Voraw: Thaf is all. .
- 9
Samvet H. Fiemive, having been duly sworn, was ex-
amined and testified as follows (Tr. pp. 100-109 inel.):
Direct-exramination-
Mr. Magy x: You are calling the. plaintiff dor
cross-examination ? , ‘
* Mr. Bropir: No, this is not the plaintiff.
o > : =
© *-
; . ,
; . “ = $I
: ; on .
4 Me von °
~ Samuel H. ¥leming—Direct. 49
By Mr. Brovi: cae oes |
Q. Where do you live, Mr. ‘Fleming?
A. -2424 South- Watts Street. <= ° !
Q. Where are you employed? hice ae
‘By Tue Court:
\. Where are you employed, lie says.
By Mr. Bropi: oS
y. W here are you employed? ‘ 4.
A. I am employed with A.J. a, now, 1224
Arch Street. ay 4
Y. Have you ever worked for A. B. issih Coms of
“pany, the defendant in this case? | i
2 A. Yes, sir.
Q. Between what periods did you work! .
A.-1 went to work for the-- — . oye
. Defendant. ~*~ :
» A. | went to work in the year of May: 40, 1933.
Q. And how long’ did you work for the defendant?
W hen did you quit?
“A. I quit December. 18, 1929.
(). 192—you started in 1933?
. A. Oy 1939, rather. —
(). Aud what job did you havef
-Aed-was watchman.
Q. As watchman what were your ‘Gatiod? A
A. Well, my duties, from five to seven, I was to stand’
itr the Sard.
(). From five to seven in the morning?
A. In the evening. 4
. Or, in the evening. ; Vs Be a
. A. In the evening. | 2 : 5
' Q. You came to work at. five P. M.4°
A. Gat is right.
Q. I see:
w asi
50 * « Samuel H. Fleming—Direct.
A. At 5 P. M. to seven I stood in the yard, I took all
packages off the people coming out of the. building, and
also watched that no strangers came in the building. —
Q. Well, just a moment, what do you mean by, you
took all packdges off people? .°. =
X. Passe&, passes. “. * ae a fee 4
_ Q. Oh, passes?
A. Yes, see, when they came Sownetairs ‘with a pass
*. and*a package'l had to take the pass off of them.
“ae
By THe Court:
Q). Pertnission to tides the package. out, is “that what
you mean? ~ = be
A. Yes. } = :
Q. Itewas something that aay them to take sae
‘
“ages out?:
Se fe ee . ape
Q. If they didn’t have the permission you took away
the package? * (
A. That is right.
THe Court: —
\
Bw Mr. Bropte:
, ee All right, what else did, you do at the gitet
A. Well, then I waited for the trucks to all get out of
the yard.
6. What kind of trucks ? a
A. Well, they were delivery trucks. Some were de-
- li¥ering goods and some was taking some goods out.
Q. Do you know to where they were making deliveries
and from where they were taking goods out?.
A. No, IT couldn’t tell you that.
*
°°" By Tax Cover:
. o .
. Q. Well, large, numbers of them were engaged in .in-
-terstate commerce, weren't they?
Lal
d
Samuel H. Fleming—Direct. hansen
- Al That is right. |
d Mr. Bropre: Thank you, sif.
3 on j ’ Mr. Mason: If he knows what interstate co- ° c
-merte is— |
Tie Courr: Oh, all right. :
Mr. Mason: he. is a grand. wwiisions,
THE Covnr: That is all right, -surely.
By Mr. Brovie: . oobi
_ Q. Go ahead, what, else did you do?
_ A. When thes yard got empty, I closed the gate.
— Q. Yes.
_, A. And by that time I had to start on my round,
_ Q. What did your round consist off °
a ; A. Well, my_ronnd consisted of, when I went on the
first floor, up through the building, I used to have. to pull
“3, down and shut all the windows, I used to have to walk the -
© fire tower.
y Q. What else?
A. Take care of the toilets.
Q: What else? '
..”" By Mm Mason: bg
Q. What was that last? I didn’t get that, take care _.
of what? foht :
: z= Tux Court: Toilets.
A. Take care of the toilets.
y < i te
Ze ; By Mr. Mason:
Q. Take’care of the toilets? 'b
A. Yes, sir.
By Mn. Bropvir:
Q. What else?
eo.
> Sear cake ape Samuel H. Fleming§-Direct.
x ‘By Mr. Mason: - me
e. That is the buikding toijetsy |
ene oy (Te. ppt gee
By Mr. Bacow:
-Q. Proceed, Mr. Fleming. ne : :
A. Well, I took care of all the toilets in the building,
and then I had to ‘tke ‘care of all the pressing machines
and the irons on the first tloor. ; :
Q. What do you mean when you say you had to take «.,
care of@all the pressing mac chines and the irons?
A. Well, I had to see’ that there was no leaks, that
the machine was—if the machine was shut down J had tu
seé that it ‘was shut down right.
Q. And these machines to which you refer, were they -
in the parts of the building— - :
A. That is right. ra ,
(). —ihat the tenants oceupied? _
A: That is right, tenants, on the tenants’ floor.
~Q. And what did you do when you looked for leaks?’
A. Well, I looked around the machine. If I seen any
water, if the-water was all over the floor, I would have -
to get°down and wipe that water up and ‘put a bucket
underneath thiat- machine. . one
Q. And what else did you do about leaks?
| A. Well, if the leak got beyond my’ control I would she
have to shut the machiné off. : |
q) And what else was included in your rounds? él
_ A. Then I wonld have to walk tke fire tower down to
see that-there was no cigarette butts lit. close all the win-
dows in the fire tower, ‘then T-would have’ to go downstairs,
when I completed | my round, I would have | to.go down-
‘stairs and let the people out. pie? ray Rie
QQ. Let what people out? .
AY The people that were working in the building.
* 4
; Pa ee
Samuel H. Fleming—Direct. pie a8
(). Could they not get out if you weren't there?
_ A. No, sir; they qouldn’t™ get out unless I left them
out, because I had the hese j in my possession.
Q. Did you have any other duties?
A. Well, I used to have to—I have_two firemen work —
there, one man-worked from four to twelve—I think that”
is what -he worked, from four to twelv#. The other man
(worked from twelve to eight.
Q. Did. vou have anything. tq’ do with the heat ?
- A. Yes, I hed to turn the heat on in the morning,
- four-thirty, five 6’clock, something like that, for the—for
the tenants up through the building. 1 had—
*' (. Where did you turn the heat on?
A. Down in the boiler room, and then up through the
; building, I had to turn it on, so many valves ‘on. each
floor. :
Q. How Psiieatis did you make these rounds that
you have described?
A. Every hour. he
‘yQ. Did that give vou any timesfor leisure, or were you
busy al’ the tinie?
A. Oh, I was—well, it took me approximately, I would.
say, forty-five, sometimes fifty minutes, to go through
that building. eae |
-Q. During the hours When you were working as hight
* watchman did you ever receive any packages? ..
A. Occasionally, yes, sir. , :
Q. For whom? '. © :
A. Weil, I received for Tony Marino and for Mr.—
Q. Who was Tony Marino?
. A. He was on the first floor. He isn " pees now, I
don’t. think. ae
Q. For whom else did, you receive packages? ; a,
A. _D’Alonzo. Be ;
-Q. On what flooy is he?
A. He is on the sixth. | -
0. What did you do with those packages?
o
i
ar a ie
a?
ae George Epps—Direet.
A. Well, I took "Mr. D’Alonzo. ‘up and put the mos
age on, his desk, and I took Tony Marinogs merchandise
‘and put it. iit his room.
Mr.. Bropte: W vai subject to the © ourt’s ruling
regardiny these. witnesses’ wages and hours. I have: no
‘further questions. ' :
THE Court: Yes, all right.
*. Mr Brovre: Cr ross-examine, © ele e :
Mr. Mason’: No questions. ot | -§
until two o’elock,. ial
Tie Court: Shed will reces
“- Yibsewie. 12. 30 until 2 20 nieok i: M. Re
AFTER ‘RECESS.
Present: Counsel as before noted.
_ PLAINTIFF'S EVIDENCE (Contitiued). |
‘ ra Ee
Gzorcre Epps, having been duly sworn, was’ examined -
. and testified as.folows (Tr. pp. 109-120 incl.) :
i 4 ° :
Direct-examination. *
? By Mn. Vout.
-e Now, Mr. EPPS, will you please speak up ‘so that
we can all hear you? . :
‘A. All right.
ad a w 2 »
George Epps—Direet. eet}.
WG, You are employed: by’ ALB. ‘Kirschbaum Com-
pany ?.. °. rR re eee
ee lian ete
— Q. How long have you been-employed by them?
About ten or eleven years. et
‘And what is your job?- eta Ap
Elevator. Elevator. — . |
‘You operate aul elevator a
‘Yes. ;
Which one of the evans do. you operate?
. The back elevator, freight.
That is one on the Carpenter Street side?
Carpenter Street—Wshington Avenue side.
Q. Washington Avenue side, that is my error. Do you
do anything but operatent the elevator?
A. Well, earry passengers, bring down trucks of: dirt,
and clean up the yard,-and all.
Q. When do you clean up the y-rd?
A. On Saturdays, after—in the mornings, first thing
& in the’ morning.
~ Q. Saturday, in the morning!
_ A. Yes. if
-Q. Now, what do: you do Saturday’ ‘afternoons?
AL Ws atch the building Satu. day ‘afternoons.
Q. You watch the building Saturday afternoons. Do ©
you ever have any other watching? :
A. On. Sundays, every third Sunday. ae ev.
Q. Every third Sunday. And what goes Up anid down
on thee @levator? : nis pe
3 A. Cases of goods, all like that, eciats, going out.
Q. How do the coats go out? — , Pit:
A. Some goes out on racks:
. Q. Some g6 out on racks:' Do you have any clean- -
‘ug work to do besides sweeping the yards? -
_ A. No, FE hardly do any cleaning, only hale up paper
daring the time T run the elevator, in my spare time.
Q. On, in your spare time vou bale paper? }
~~"?
° .
inne
As
2
2
36 George Epps—Direet. :
A. Yes, Jt :
(). Where does that paper come from? oe
Diiferent, Pray: from each of the tenants: on the
floor. :
.
Q. Sawa ‘you get it?
A. They push it to the elevator, al I carry it’ dow n
-on the car, pull it in and carry it down.
Q. Down where?’ Ses | Sp
A. To the “Sh
Q. I see, and. then you bale? Seek | Hog
A. Yes, sir. - . ‘ non
Q. Do you: have to sorf it? . |
A. Yes, J have to sogt it.
Q. ‘And vhat fype eiscene come in, and. out on the
elevator? ? 7
A.. Well, some comes in cases, _I don‘t know what is
. in them,
°
Q. Yes, who bie them on the elevator?
A. People who brings them there. and those who re-
ceive them, they. generally put them, on,
x.
Q. The receiver-—
Tue Cover: Well, gentlemen, may I ask, is it ad:
riitted that these cases the witness ‘is now referring
/to, in many if Tot all instances, contain goods which. ¢
/ have been’ or will ‘be transported in interstate com--
mer e? rie
Mr. Mason: We couldn’t-admit it, sir, in refer-
ence to any particular witness.
me HE Court: AJL right. °
Mr. Mason: Ww e Jave admitted ay far as we can
_admit,— ae PF, as
Tue Cov RT Y All right, go ahead.
e
“Mr. Masox / —under the facts‘as we know them.
THE Covrr: Well, all right.
<
George Epps—Di rect.
iy
~!)
“Mr. Mason: You see, we don’t know that.
Tre Court: I thought 1. — be rable to sim-
plify that. | ;
By Mr. Votaw:
Q. The truck dviver then goes up with the, freight?
A. Right.
_Q. Or comes down with bean ai aed
” A. ‘Yes. pee
Q. Do you ever gree to carry any freight just be-
tween floors in the’ building?
A. Yes, the Progressive.
as Q. And what floors are these?
-~. A: Third.and fourth .— -
Q. Third and eet | 2
A. Yes. _” : te
().:Third and fous ina does that occur regularly or
just infrequently?) 2}
. A. Well, mostly pretty regularly, .on account of that
Army contract they: have. eS
' Q. I see. What;Kind of material is that? *.-
A. That is like }rar uniforms. ee
_ Q. I see. You smentidned clothing on. racks.” What
a
tenant is that from?— He oe % 2
A. That is from Feldman’ s.
- Q.Feldman’s? . : j
A. And D’Alonzo. | ear: §
Q. How many coats would be on a rack? ?
A. From tw enty-five to fifty.
a» .'Q.° Twenty five to fifty, and where ‘do the trucks un-
load te come into the building?
A. In the rear of the building, at the platform.
-Q. Ig that an enclosed platform? :
Ais. No, it is an open platform.
; Q. Open platform. Can you describe these racks that
you speak of? _
“4
38 ear y "George Epps—Direet. toe.
» ?
A. ‘Yes, according to the ordef, like that one * conte
4 are hanging up. on, only with wheels at the bottom.» | ..
(The witness indicated a rack in the cdurt room.) .
-
»
y Mr, Voraw:
_Whieels ‘at the bottom?
. Yes: :
- Would, they be as’ se as that one, as long as that
‘ one? 4 *.
. Well, they would be as nh as that one.
. Could they be_ carried up and downstairs?
. No, they couldn't be carried up.
. What time of the day do you carry aaiaailt
eee
rorer
, Bae > tte
5 In the morning? Lae cet: Sine i
A. Yes, in the morning, and then from twelve anil.
one, at noon, and’from five until J get them down at night.
ov Qe T age. Ts there a rush of passengers at that time?
e* A. Yes. eats rage :
| -Q. Who are those: ‘passengers? ree
' floor’ -aind the fifth. .
YQ. Employees” on tne -fourth—and- the fifth, and
keep you busy during thos times?
A. Yes. ~
1: Taking them out and int. ged ee ea ia
Aw Yes. a A
_ Q. During/those inte ean You carry any ‘freight?
AY No, not then."
| — Q. Cannot?
, A. Can’t carry freight.
* ° Q. Why not? jae
A. The car is loaded with, people, so I. make the —
freight wait.
a ‘How much of this trash 46 you take down?
rr ——|@ —_ —_
. From seven: thirty up until near nine-thirty. Then
A. They are employees of the building, 0 oni nf the fourth —
|
=]
4 :
a:
J
ee 3 Gori Epps—Direet, oom ie
ALT ‘ta down a bit—k good bit of it fra | the fifth
age at the most, from the fifth.
A
Q
A.
Q
A
~@.
A. Yes.
oo) a
A
Q.
A
Q.
fift
the
©:
. You said you took it in trucks?
; Trucks, and then bundles: of paper, too. —
. What is the ‘size of these trucks? -
They ake a good am:
. About as high as this table; or vii |
.Higher-than that’ a |
-Higher than that table? . |
Are they as big dround,. as big as the tablet
. Not as bix as the table, but I would say half way.
. About half the size of the tablet. hy
. Yes... |
And how many wonld you take dows: a day from.
h floor.
A. Sometimes’ five and six trucks off of there a “day.
Q. Aud you take fhose down i in the basement?
A. Yes. 2 f ‘
Q: And sort them? —
A. Sort them.: :
Q. Do you have to run the elevator at the same time?
A. Same time. : © :
Mr. Mason: Well, now, with a minute, vou don’t
3) mean that, Mr. Votaw.
Mr. Votraw: Well, in between time. ,
Mr. Mason: Well, vol have ‘weked the wifness— ~
I don’t object to Jeading questions that are not unfair .-
to the witness, but he doesn’t sort this stuff in 1 the
elevator.
~-sMr. Vora: I don’t abipaee SO.
THe Wirness: ‘You have to— , Ce niyee
MacsMason ; He. iin’t running the vlevator at the
sametime he is sorting stuff. That was your ques-
tion, and I hope ‘you’ didn’t mean it, “because I am
SURE he does not.:
Peay: 4g
ms) 60. - ‘ ze George Epps—Direct.”
| By Tue Court: | ee
| _ Q.. You, don’t, do yout”
eee A. No. me : cere :
-. By Mr. Voraw: LAL Sas
Q. You have to sort the staff in between. elevator —
RR Le eS ee eT
tripat :
+ A. Trips: ERNE Ae Semeysc ; <=
Q. And during the Same ar during + which . you
are on the siisaeesN 3 + ; , eee
; A. Yes. th oe e
: ‘Q. What. would happen if you. - didn’t remove this
trash? .
2. eae Well, it could bloek pp the f fire escape or—
. By Mr. Mason: yi; ei
, a. What i is that? I can’t: heat that.
Tue Court: It could block up the fire escape,
A. (Cc ontinued) Fire eseape, or either start a fire
if it Jays around that way..
THE’ Cou rt: It could block up the fire escape or
start a‘fire if it lays around that way. ae:
Mr. Mason: Well, that is interesting, but I can’t
See just how fhis witne&8s could give us.any real an-
swer to that question in the form he has given it. If _
Mr. Votaw wants to go ahead and explore it a little
- farther—-we don’t know yet that this stuff was at the
fire escape when he gets it.
Tre Wirness:- They put it in front of the eleva-
tor door and blocks it, ‘and as I have got freight eom-
ing-up and down, sometimes they have ‘to wait until
I get my spare time to go-up to get it.
3 age ; z George: Epps—Cross. <Ggt o ‘61.
| + By Mr. Voraw: -.
. Where. is the- fire. -escape entrance with relation to
. . the front of the elevator? 3
. A. ‘That is on ‘the side. 3 ,
+» Q. It-is tight on the side by the elevator? |
A. Yes. ’ 3 ‘ .
: e- Joe ;
aa Voraw ?Cross-examine. * fs eae ais
. $$ $$ $$$ - —
——————————— - - =
Cross-examinatio+.
~ By Mr. Magoxs
Q. I am alittle uk ous about this iat: You have.
aroused my curiosity, Mr. Epps. Is the trash you speak
of trash that accumulates in the course of the day in vari-
ous tenants’ rooms where the work is going on?
A. Well, some. of them tell me, they even take it down
there, so wrnerd of it, and I am jammed up, I can’t even
handle it all at the same time, some of it ed stay up
‘on the floor.
- Q.: That is," they want you to do it sométimes _When
; you just can’t do it, isn’t that so? : ;
A, I try to do all 1 can during that time.
Q. Yes. :
Ph
A; But I can’t de-but-oneaman’s-job:
Q. Well, now, the trash is something that is ordin.
arily cleaned ub i in the building, isn’t it? -
A. Yes.,
(Q That i is what you are ladies about, and who cleans
it up in the tenant’s place, the tenant?
A. No, they have a porter there. who sweeps the
- floor.
Q. What?. |
A. They have a porter whio sweeps ‘the floors.
QQ. That. i is, ‘the tenant does?
“A. Yes.
Q. And he sweeps = the. floor and the trash is col-
——.
2°, © + Nick Cattelise~Direet. Se ae
’ lected wh and then it is put together in a pile, or in a
. bale, af you eall it, and carried «down-in the elevatar as -
‘ soon ‘as you get a change to ‘take it down to the base-.
ment, ame it is sorted out? 2
Q- That correct, And it is composed of all sorts
ae otatt; is that right? | eset a . |
| _A, Yes. is Rees - a
x Q. Newspapers and all Hinds: of f things, and that i is the
reason you have to sort it out?
wat Be a $ bey
ae .Q. "Mr. Epps, as ‘Kaela the tenants put this
trash, we will call it, in the trucks, and you. take. the
trucks down on the elevator? *
A. Fellow sw eeps up the floor, he puts it in the trick.
.Q. He puts it in the treek?” 2
@ ‘A. He se, ‘it near the elev ator.
Q. Yes. |
. A. And I wnlle it on and takes it downstairs, |
Q. That is it, and then when it gets down in the
*- cellar you are-one of those that helps to sort it out?
A. Yes. -- ;
<< Mr. Mason: Well, that satisfies: my cartualty. That
is all, thank you; ~*~
Mr. Votaw: That is all.
at i ; . : Yr .
Nick Catrenise, having. been duly sworn, was exam-
ined and testified as follows (Tr. pp.. 120-126 inci.) :
aay * 2 i ‘ ue ‘
| Direct-examination:
: . enn tt ve e.
‘By Mr. Brovit:
Q. AVhere do you live?) | |
GS .
: ®
o7 1221 Kimball, Tha is. "bteale WwW ashington 4 Ave-
nue and Carpenter Street, om.12th Street.
‘Q. You are employ ed by A. B. Kirsehbaunr Com-
pany, the defendant in this case?
A. Yes. , 3
te How long have you been employed by: the Kirseli-
A. Why, 1940, 1940.
~ Q. What. month?
, _- A. The third of Janyary.
- 4 Q. Where, do you work?
A. Wliy, I am watching.
°Q. Do you’ work at tle Kirschbaffm Building at: Broad
and Carpenter Streets?
A. Yes:.
Q What is your job?
A: Watchnan. * .o
_ Q. Day or night?” 3
A. Why, I am going ‘on twelve 0 ‘clock, until seven in >
the morning. “es
Q. Twelve clock midnight until seven in the morn-
baum Company? _ I ¢. toe nl See eee
ing? ag, 5 Za a
Me A. Yes, sir. ee ‘
SP Ue fs ISEB inel.)..
' Q@ Your last statement, then, is that you are a night
watchman? |
= o=> A. Yes. 1 : a? teas
=~ Q. Wil you please describe for the C rt just what
“© your duties as night w atchman consist of # What do you
do? .
A. What I do?
Q. Yes. ue |
A. Why, when I start my ‘time, going up the stairs
and ring the clock, and.go through the floor, and watch the
windows, and wateh all the pressing, go around the ‘build-
ing, and if any leak, everything i is O, K., I let them. £0 and ;
don 7 bother.
3 -
a x x .
a) “Nick racer Mate tar
By THE C OURT:
a
Q. Now. you say you go through the floor; do you go
in all the rooms? © . yore
A, Yes, every room, every floor, I got to go every
hour i in the floor. ? nee 7
A. And ring tivo clocks every floor.
_ By Mr. Bropim: 7 :
Q. Do you close windows if they are ‘open?
- A. If they are open I have to close. Bee
* Q. If there’ are any — bone in tenant’ Ss “prem
_ises— a", } ts
. A. If there is. any light j is - on, I put it’ out.
| Q. What do you do about leaks -in ‘the pressing ma-
“—_ and other steam facilities? ,
_ <A. Why, if there is a leak, why, I have to try to
stop ie
. - Q. Do you do—
A. The best I can.
~ Q. Do you do anything about guarding against fires?
A. Well, T have to tend. sprinklers, in case any go, I
_have. to shut the valve, on my. time. a: foe.
- Q. What valve? a nm 3
REPS. T= 7" ; ' 53 ye down or
floor, I have to find out the valve it is on, to shut it off.
* Q. Yes, but do. you do anything about 2 sacha
against: .
A. Wellyat, the’ p:esent time ain't had no Tine. In
ease we hac ay - fires we have to put something on it.
Q Tam sorr ¥,I didn t get the last ais of your an-_-
swer. ;
es You can’t wait until somebody else comes in.
‘Tur Court: Got to wy on it if vou have‘a fire;’
‘Well, part of your job i is to. look out for fires, is it?
THe Wirsess: W ell, I have to lookin case of a
es fire. , Hatin) : ( {
> . - ; 5X: j
« tes era 4 sate : ;
-ever ‘since you started to work-—
\ | McKinley. Edwards—Diréet: : : «65.
ak ‘Tue Cover: All right. :
< By Ma, Brovie:
Da gon have ‘anytling do with, ind turning on of —,
;. ae heat in the cold weather? ¥. | F
_A. Well, I look around the valve, if any valve is shut,
eS have to open. If he is on, I don’t bother. + Uae a
—Q. And do you ‘ever stand guard at ‘the gate?
A. We en I come in, my time in the evening.
Q. What ¢ime? ae teae
A. Five o’clock. eck
- Q. At the gate. |
A. Well, I watch the trucks go out, aid that the peo-° .
? ‘ “2
ples come. up, from up the stairs, watch for any package, | 3
' take them -oyt, if they got any pass, then T take the pass,
' if not, take the package back.
_ Q. Have you been doing: that same wotk regularly.
\
. A. Yes.
> —for the Kirschbaum Company?\ |
ore . Since I Started that. job, { do my duty.
Mr: Bronte: You may cross-examine.
Mr: Masoy : ‘No questions. ;
Mr: Brovie : That is all, thank you. ©
os : >
McKrsury Epwapps, having been duly sworn, was ex-
amined and testified as follows (Tr. pp. 126-137 inci.) :
Direct- ——
a : + f
ie Mr, Bropre:
. Q. Where do vou live, Mr. Edwards? _
A 806 South 15th Street.
Me « Zee
we.
‘5 <
e ‘7 ; Sg
‘ .
. =
66 Be 7 “McKinley Kdwards—Direet.
ere “You. are employed. by A.B. Kirschbaum scat
the defendant in this case? gr cee
i Yon. tet 3 x As
pie. -Q. How long have you. ade eniployed t there? s°
*- A, Twenty-one vears the 1th. of ne ciare aa past
QQ. Doing what? . ;
A. Fireman.-
-(). Have you been fireman all: twenty-one years.
- A. Yes. “#3
pndae (Tr. pp. 126-128 incl.)
earn What do you do now? Do you have more or less
work? pare ah
ae 53 have more., ay este
Q. And what iaddition do you dot”
A. Well, now, will tell you just what I have to do.
When the enginée goes out, J will start theyé, first, when.
the engineer gots out, up through the. buil ah to the.ten-
ants, to do jobs, I have to do.his work, that is watch
a the engine, oil it, oil the. pumps, wateh atid keep it from
running hot until he comes back. «Then I have to pass: —
~ my own coal, T have to unload coal cars. If [ran short:
of coal down in the boiler room:I got to. go down to
Washington Avenue and wheel it up and dump it in the
coal car and threw-it up, and when he fixes. a pump IT have
0 Rive timated tf tre—wwarntts 4 tt:
“a. What pumps?
A. Well, the Gne is the house pump, that starts water
up on the roof of the building, one is a: boiler feed pump, *
one is, the sewer pump, one is the vacuum pump, the fire
pump, the¥ don*t- run that much, aa e elevator pump.
Q.. Do vou know for what. purposes the steam that is -
generated in these boilers you fire is. used?) Rae
A. Well, thev presses with if, they Sponges with it.
That is abont as far as I know.
Q.. Who are ‘‘they’’?
® A. And they run the dyiiamo with it.
Q. Who are ‘‘they’’? | :
A. Well, all of them — ae z
| 7 ae ate McKinley Eawarad’—Direet. . "67
; én. By THE, Cotrt: en ; -
7 Q: Who are ‘they, when you say “they”, who do you eae
mean?
. By Mn. Brovre:
—
—
@. Who do you mean? it
A. Why, D’Alonzo;— ° =
__Q. You mean the tenants in the pailding ee
A. Yes, the tenants, yes.
. .Q. All of them use a the steam?
A. Yes. ° Peg tT
By Tue Court:
Q. Do they all use the steam?
A. Yes. -
Q. All right.
A. They all use the steam.
By Mr. Banoo: ena ee tei ie
-Q. How many of them use the steam for sponging, do
s\~-you ree : ie
A. There is two, ¢ as far as I know.
Va rua * (Tr, pp. 129, 130.)*
Q. Is the ‘gteain which ‘is generated in these boilers |
° that you fire used for running the elevators? Be
_A. Oh, yes.
Q. Is it used to supply heat to the premises?
- A. Oh, yes. :
Q. Do you know shaker it runs the generators which
generate the oo which — the building? — .
_A. Oh, ‘yes> ) : 0.
“2.9. ¢Tr. p. 130.) .
Q. How many boilers do'you fire? : ;
A. > Why, I fire two. | =
- ®
°
nét D®.-
Re. _ MeKinley Edwards;-Diteet. ">
Q. ‘And how many ; engines do you watch?
A. One. : *
~Q: Is there any pody else who does work of a slmaiier
natare to yours?
A. Why, not at the same time that I. does. After I
~ get off, there is another man comes on. eee
Q. Who is that? 5 woes .
A. Why, that is a man: by- the name of Mr. ‘Rocea. 2 a
Q: Is there any other fireman? |.
' A. Yes, there is ne comes on after he goes off, at
‘twelve o’clock, at night. His name is Pete Rocks.
QQ. Does Tie“do the same. kind of work as you?
A. Well, not the’ engine, she don't. do that, because |
° that isn’t rumtfing. ea ae
© -Q) How about work as a firenian?
A. He Jhas to. do everything I do, and. ‘watch the
PIDs. oe | :
* QQ And Rocca does’ the same, too? ° aN
A. Yes, antl he has to wratele the engine, Rocea dines
_ because. he. comes on at four o ‘clock, until it is shut down.
Q. And what time does the engine. shut. down?» ree cre
A: Why, I was told here some time ago. it is supposed
- to have been shut down at quarter after five. — :
Q. What engine are you ga pris tot
AL- Phe one \ «
.Q. The one’that generates the electricity?
, A. The ones that generates the electric. :
Q. Do you know to. whom electricity is supplied by ~
the building? .. - : sae
A: Well, I know .a “sae TI won't say that I know
them all, to be sure, but. I do know: a couple.
: Q. Who are they?- ’
> A. Why, one is Mr. D "Alonzo. ee oe
; Q. Yes. iene
A. And the ila are Spivaks.: One is on the sixth -
rand one is on the second. Now, any other, I don’t know
of any other that uses the electric. If there are any, ;
don’t know of any.
3 . se ; ‘ ;
2
4 .
~«
4.
Q. —regarding the steaiht--
A. No, not often; _ once in a great while.
— Q. Do-you. ever?” Jparaab wees ea
A. Yes, once in a while.’
'Q. What are those, what is the nature, generally Y—
». Why, they conres down—
Q. —of those “complaints?
A. Why, they comes down and says - pe steam.
- Q. Yes, what do you mean by-wet steam?
down, or when the steam goes down, it. is wet, it is damp,
it isn’t dry, see ‘what I meant
- Q. Yes.
4 A. It wets the eaake but then all the time it ism't
“my fault, it is their fault, their traps— : .
Q. I haven’t blamed you for it. coed
A. But ‘I am just only telling you.. eas
Q. I am Just try ing to find out, what | is the objection
. to wet steam,
A. Ww hy, see, why, sometimes when T let the steam go.
sae McKinley’ Edwards—D'rect. > 69
_ Q. At what pressure: is steain maintained? . -
A. Why, I carries ninety pounds. reat
Q.' Do you ever. get any complaints. from any’ of the
tenants— es
‘A. No.
BY THE CQUBT:
. Q: “Why ‘dén! t they like to baid wet ses.
* right, ‘see? | ? ,
ae OF See o
A. After they press, it wrinkles.
THE Cou RT: All right. .
Le By Mr. Brovier *. coe ee
Q. How do xou keep track, or wht method bate you
“for knowing how mach steam pressure you have?
A. Why, that, wets a. _oods and they don’t | press aes
he _ _ MeKinley Edwards—Cross. og ees aes
AY Why, 1 have. a gauge’ to. watch..
_-. Q..And do you have to watch that “gauge fairly “con- .
ea i
.stantly to see that fhe steam’is kept. up?
eT ie Oh, yes. e. et 8
QQ. To the pressure? - ae pate
‘A, Yes, gir, >. ae a
Q Does anybody else also look out dir the g gauge?
A. Why, when-T step-out-the-boiter room, :I tells the-.
engineer when I go out, and then he watehts it, like if I
go to the wash room, I always tell him.
- Mr.- ‘Brove: No further questions. — .
Cross-examination.
‘ Sy Mr. Mason : : 7 | 5
.d Edwards; as I under$tood "it, you were ‘a ‘fireman—
_ A. Yes. ;
Q. —at this time, and your ‘duties required you to be -
‘down where the enginés and the boilers are?
.A. Where the boilers are.
Q. Yes. i sm
A. Not where the engines are.. *
-Q. Yes. Do you havé-any. duties at all that take you
imi of the boiler room? — ie ;
A. Oh, yes,
Qs And what duties. are those? :
A. Oh; that is going in the engine room to ‘take care :
of the engine, when the engineer is ont, that -is to ‘xo down
in the ¥ard and wheel coal wp, so I-ean fire the boilers.
Q. Yes, Now, what duties do you have as a fireman ,
that requires you te v0 upstaits into the tenants’ place of
manufacture? - : :
A. I. don’t x0 up there. p
Q. Well, you told Mr. Brodie that ‘yeu knew that iat
used the steam up there in their: various machines. Did:
you ever go up and see it? - rf ae
by |
“MeKinley’ ‘iawards—Recdired ; 7
«AUS have gone up, ‘when I used to, w len Kirschbaum,
ran it,I used to go up there. :
“< What? ~*~
A. When Kirschbaum was running it I used to go up.
‘there. -I don’t go up there now.
——Q. No, but you told him that all the tenets, that you
guess. that all the tenants used this steam \wp in their
vatious places?
. <A. Yes: Peta :
Q. Now,, you didn't mean. that, did you? -
Rea o Yes, I mean they used it.
— «Q. Well, have you been there yourself to see it?
A. Up there?. I khow they use it because they have
pressing machines up there. .
Q. Have you ever been up. there? ° ;
Q. And you have never been up there in the tenants’
_places in the’ building to see what they do with electricity,
either, have you? .. az hap
A. Oh, no, not while they was workirg.
/ Q. So that you-- |
& A. Not while they was working.
: A. Not_while they was sgoretien, no, not while they
“. Was dperating. ' '
Q. You have never been up there at all?
_ A. Not while they was operating. me eke tts
e
QW So you didn't mean to convey the impression which ©
vour answer did to Mr. Brodie, that you. personally had
heen up there seeing them operate? - aa
A. No, T didn’t, personally, I didn’t go ‘up. 2°
Mr. Mason: That is all, I think, that is all. .
. _ Re- ibehcaes ination. — \
By Mr. Brovir :.
-
| .
Q. Have you exer been. up in the tenants’ premises:
when they were not working? Siok
A. When they were not working? . — -
Sa,
as plied to the, upper floors of the building from the. boilers?
ae
a
a _ + Charles Moetsch—Direct..
@. Yes. Wa et oe ae ae
Re ee gt, i bees
re Have you seén pressing machines there?
. Ween: ¢ ; e : F s
. Do vou kiov,. Mr. Edwards, how the steam is sup-
A. Yes, it has got a six-inch’ main, I think—I won’t:
be sure it is a six- -inch—-to all the: way. to the roof.
Q. Yes.
A. And it branches off .Oll a Six- ‘inch. main’ from the
boiler room alNthe way qo the roof, ‘and then a smaller
“pipe branches off, goes to Tie different tenants.
QQ. Smaller ‘pipes branch off the line to go » to the. aif:
"ferent. tenants, you. say? é ‘
A. Yes, from the six-inek main.
- Q. And do you know what connections are made be-
tween the pipes andthe pressing «machines?
A. No, I really don’t know just what Gonnection
that is. |, . ° ° |
Mr. Brofe : That ig ee
-
*®
Mr. Mason: No questions.
Se)
o
% . : ve 2 ° cy
.
Cuartes Mortscn, having been duly sworn, was ex-..
amined and testified as follows (Tr. pp, 137-152. ine.) :
re Direct-egamination.
By Mr. Bropir: * ey cau i,
Q. Where do you live, Mr. Movtsch Ve
A. 2529 South 17ff.
tr Are you employed’ by A. B: Kirschbaum Company,
the defendant in this case?, Pe
A. Fea, six. ©, Ty
Q. ‘How long have you been employed hy A. B. Kirseh-
baum Company? 8 ; .
‘ 7% ” =
SY ¥ ra] z Ss : § »
Ce = an
aermaens Ss
Charles Moetsch—Direet : 73
A. Next April, veel: Ave years.
-Q. At the present time what is your job? |
A. I am_ supposed to be superintendent and chief
engineer, ‘-
og Well, are you, actually? - ;
ot ee ae.
(). How jong have you been superintendent and chief
engineer
A. I was chief engineer for the time being that I am
in’ Kirse ‘haums, ahd twelve years I am superintendent. |
Q. And under'you do all the building employees work?
- That is rather an inverted sentence ; do all the building
employees work unger you?
“A. T have got twelve men working ander me, yes.
Q. What are their jobs? Describe them by jobs..
By Tue Count: o
Q.. Twelve, is that? . ‘
Mr. Bropre: Twelve. set as oe
_A. Three elevator fellows.
&
By Mr. Brovre:
»Q. Ves, Sian Jr
Three firemen. ce
Yes, ate ee
Two watchmen. et
een. <” ee.
One engineer, a utility, man. ; |
Yes. : Bran tee . ae
One carpenter. — : ee ;
nee . os }
: One helper. | .
And one what? > =
Helper, carpenter helper. <
Is that twelve? !
. Oh, and ane more, porter. } ' %
*
A.
Q.
at
pee
ay
Q.
A.
Q.
A
Q
_ A.
2.
~
‘
74 a Charts Moetsch—Direct.
Q. One? Teal
A. A porter, ‘
.* Q. Q& thank. you.
/h, @aner. That is twelve.
* Q. How long has it been, Mr.. Moetsch, that ys 6.
Kirschbaum Company has not oer a clothing sey
in these’ premises?
A. °28, I believe, since 1928 we stopped.
PF ts eh as (Tr. pp. 139-141 inc.)
-
Q. Will you describe briefly thie functions performed
ne each of the/classes of- employees that you have men-
tioned? | ;
—N A. For instance, how the firemen—
Q. What do the elevator operators. dot
A. They, run the elevator up and down and take the :
pasengers off.
Q. Do they carry freight, too? ee
A. Yes. ‘vuretee
Q. And how about the firemen?
A. The firemen fires me boilers. and keep up their
steam. “4
Q. At what pressure is the steam kept? ~
&X. Between nitiety and hundred. It daren’t go be-
low eighty. | / C ;
Q. Why not?’
A. That is on account of the pressing. machines, and
the steam gets wet after it goes below eighty pounds. Be-—
‘tween sixty and eighty the steam is wet.
(). Yes.
A. And if it goes above eighty. it is too dey. Now,
_ eighty founds is supposed to be.on‘the pressing machines.
_ Q. How many pressing machines are there. in the
building to which steam is supplied; do you know? °
_ A. Oh, I guess about a hundred. gett, oe
_ Q. Is steam supplied for any other machines ?. -
A. For—yes, fer one spenging machine.
.
ee
9
a
-
ee eS ey eer he Tee hae
Teer
? _ Charles Moetsch—Direct. ~ 15
- Q. Whose is that? : :
A. And several irons, what we call steam irons.
' Q. Are the steam irons hand’ ‘operated ?
A. Yes.
Q. Or are they rather large machines operated by
foot power?”
| mee * They are—some of the irons .is handled by foot.
| power as well as by hand, you have to handle it ‘by your
handy and put your foot on the pedal, if you want te put
pressure om. ° :
Q. I see. Now, how about the sponging anaes. do
you know just what - the function of the sponging ma-
chine is? ny
A. Yes, sir, I have been with a good : many of them.
Q. All right, ‘you please describe it to the Court?
- <A. Sure. The comes in the factory. and goes
over the machine, over a roller, and the steam gets turned
_ on, then it goes over the top, then another sponger, steam
roller, then it goes on the outer side over another roller
and there is steam.on. Is that plain enough? — -
Q. Yes, and just what happens to the cloth as it
_ passes over these rollers?
‘4 A, It shrinks.. That is the idea of sbdinking cloth.
/ -- -Q. I see, so that, if IT understand ‘you correctly, what
you are telling me is that the cloth-cannot be cut and sold
imo garments until it is shrunk in this sponging —
‘is that so? ,
_A. IT didn’t say that. | ty
~Q. Well, is that sot? \ x
_A. If you are going to have a suit that isn’t shrunk,
understand, you go in the rain-and you ar@ going ‘to
shrink. . r
_Q. I see. Can the spenging machine be operated with-
out the steam?@ vies)
A. Na.
Q. Now, these various persons—
A. Understand, pardon. me one moment; there is dif-
¢ .
. &
a, Ge area
» 76 - Charles’ MoetschDirect. |
ferent sponging machines, not, ony steam sponging ma-
chines. ek
~ @. All right, -d am. talking about the one—
. b>. Oh. : ~ “© . %
.. Q. —in the buildifig. ea :
> aS Fon:
Q. Can that te operated without steam?
A. :-Ne@. : “¢ o.5-
Q. Can the pressing machines which are in the build--
ing bé operated Without steam?
Ay Why, all depends if the tenants~if they want to-
get their steain off ns or not, then they ‘have to make it
themselves. 6 : ;
QQ. But stepm is essential for the operation “of the
pressing machines, is it? nos é
A. Yes. ie ee pe
(). Now, this‘same steam which is generated in the
boilers, F- understand, operates the elevators, too? ee
". A. Yes, it operates the pump.
Q. Which operates the pump?
A, Which puts pressure on the. water, it is hydraulic |
elevators, builds, up-the pressuré, and this pressure car-.
ries the elevators up and down. - — « ey ;
(. Is-it true, then, that if the steam were to fail the
elevators would fail and the pressing machines would
fail?
A. Yes, that. all depends if the steam goes down below |
fifty pounds: © | rua
. Yes. eee ; Bi ee
. Then it would slack up. auc ad
. What would slack uj? |
Q
A
Q :
A, The pump would slack up. ;
Q
A
Q
. The elovator.pump? = ss .
. Theelevator pump, ves. “ - 7 a
. And there wouldn't be snfficient pressure to oper. - es
ate the hvdraulie elev ator? — 3
A. -Yes.- = | Ni data iat Se HAR
a
eS.
Charles’ Movtsch—Direet.. oe 47.
Q. Is that so? Electricity, ] understand; is ¥ also gen-
erated in that building, is that true?
vA. Yes, a little - bit. | & }
Q. And that is done by dynamos down in ‘the base- °
@- ment?
5 rk:
Q. That electricity, is it Dieis or. alternating current?
A. Direct. :
Q. Do vou know whether any of. the motors” in the —
building are operated on this direct cur rent?
A. Yes, Sir. a>
Q. Whose? : _
A. D’Alonzo Lancaster, three motors.
Q. Any others?
_A. And on the second floor is -five motors.-
“Q. Is electricity supplied for any other Purpose?
‘A. We supply the electric to Spivak, on the second —
floor, and up on the sixth floor for these motors, _three
motors; few lights. -
Q. Electricity i is supplied ° for lights to the sixth floor?
a
A. Few of t them; yes. ‘
Q. How about the second hoor?
A. Second floor got the light and motors. |.
Q. How about your hallways and the elevators?
A. Sure.
Q. Is that, done by outside current or house ieount’
A.’ After five o’clock at night we turn on the outside
enrrent, but. from seven—half past seven in the morning
_ Up until five o’clock it uses the D.C. current. :
. Q. How long— he ce :
A. Which we operate.
»(. Howelong have these—or, how long has electricity
been generated in the building?. - .
” A. Since the building Ji is in existénee. — , z.
'Q. Have you ever had any wai, oan about, the
elevators? é ‘
A. What doy “you mean, complaints 7 pine
ra
~
PP a ‘
.
a ad
78° ~~... Charles Moetseh—Direet.
Q. Well, complaint’ that the’ service’ wasn’t» good
enough, or es 7 because an elevator wasn’t. running
on a particular day when a tenant came in to do some °
work, have you ever had any such complaints?
x No.. @
Q. Well, I will refresh your memory. Has Mr.. D’-
Alonzo ever complained to you about elevators?
A. Not that I know. ‘ ;
-Q. Does the building also occasionally do repairs as
accommodations for tenants?
A. Once in a while, yes, in the case of emergency we |
have to do it. Now, if you want me to explain, for in-
stance, a case, I am going ta,tell you.
Q. Yes, what do you mean byvan emergency ?
A. All right, an emergency case. is, for instance, in
Jacob Reed’s, on the first floor, there-was not so long ago,
he had a blowout on a reducing valve, gasket blew out,
understand, he’didn’t know low to shut it off, the people
were afraid to work there, and he sent for me.
‘*All right,’’ [ said, +1 shut it off, then you are going
to send for somebody else to put that ‘gasket in’’, and I
sent then my mechanic up, and he by- passed 4 reducing
trap or reducing: valve. - -.. >
'Q. That was: on the steam supply line? >:
A.‘ That was on the steam supplgJine. —
© Q. Did you ever do “any other repairs around the —
premises?
A. Oh. yes, onee in ‘a while, for instance, in knothiie’
a leg off a table, anéethey ass me if I would accommodate ©
them, and I said; yes, I do it. °
—Q You-have a carpenter; w orking there, haven't yout:
A. Yes, Bg se .
Q: What is his name? aire:
A. Eli Gionto. | SAT a 8 alae ree a
Q. G-i-o-n-t-of , as ie ee is
? AG: i-a-n-t-o2+~— > eee «gee : ‘
Q. Does he makes repairs ‘to ‘ehidowst-— + eee a,
‘A. Yes, sir. o
S
v=) 1% .
‘Charles Moetsch—Cross. ny 7
&
. Does he replace sash chains? ae
- A. Sure, Sere .
Sash chains are similar to sash cords, are they?
Yes. ii. | :
Except that they are chains! aoe ee
Yes. ©
Instead of rope?
. Yes.
Does he make repairs ‘to doors!
. Sure, but only doors what belong to the building.
Yes. .He also does some painting, doesn’} he? —
. Sure, when the floor is empty,.for instance, then I
ti him on painting, if T have ne other work for him. s
Q. And he paints the vommon hallways, doesn’t he? .
, <A. Sure.
.Q. And the. staircases?
A. Sure.
Mr. Bropre: You may cross-examine.
Po bene® bo}
aaah de " Cross-examination, —
_ By Mn. Masoy:
Q. You spoke of a ssaines in thé building generat-
. ing direct current? / tee
A. Yes,
Q. Do you. have any ‘alternating current: in ‘the build-
A
ing? ;
A. Well, for us, ves, for our pe phe instance, for
the elevator bells and the lights and for the staircases,
after five o’clock. wo
@ Yes. - es ee age ies
A. That belongs to us. :
: Q. Now, is there alternating current used i in the build-
_ ing by any of the tenants? ° o-
A. Practically all the tenants got alternating current.
Q.. Where did they get that?
rf
wee
86 C hatles Movtiscli—-C Toss.
A. From the outside; from the Philadelphia ‘Electric.
Q. And there are: two of the tenants, however, that
still have the old direct current machinery a:
A. Yes,. during the day time, but’ if, they work over-
. time, for instance, then- they have for the light system,
. only, they have alternating current} . Fis |
Q. L- see, so that those machines, for instance, in
D’Alonzo’s‘place, he has got three of them— , -
A. Yes.
Q. —that use direet current!
A. Yes. ae
Q. If he aie those for a different type of ma-
chine—
A. No. | :
' - Qs» —to use alternating—- a | :
° A. He can’t do that. rat ; :
. Q. What is that-?-- ;
- A. He can’t do that, he. shuts those ioe motors, they
will be shut dow@until the tiext morning.
Q. I appreciate that. rer
‘A. He can’t operate that. | £
Q: No, but it is only because they are that type ‘of
~ machine? ried .
= ° A. Yes.
.Q. Yes, if they were a ‘ ieatiios typ pe that inven: that
used the alternating current, he would get it from the ©
Philadelphia Eleétrie Company? : .
A. Sure, he would.
Q. And not from you? |
A. No.
Be Q. Now, then, the electricity which: you generate i is
: used for lighting the various portions of the building to be
: used i in common by all the tenants, is that right?
““ANYes. 7
Q. And you use it in the boiler rooms for moet.
A. Yes. Re °
-Q. In the toilet rooms? :
Charles Meetsch—Cross. “81.
*. Yes.
: Q. You use it to ran your ash machine in the base-
A. What imachinet : aire
Q. Ash machine. + — ee : :
- A. Ice machine? segue ihe: ¢
Q.- Ash? = ass Ue :
A. Oh, ash machine, the ash conveyor, yes. — .,
» Q. Yes, ash conveyor? | i :
A: Yes. ‘
Q. All right. What else do you use pat es for the
purposes of the building? , eee
A. Well, for lighting—that is about all. _
Q. Do.you have any—
A. You mentioned it all.
-Q. Do you have any carpenter shop work that voqeires
electric current?
A. Oh, ves, we have a slseelas saw, and we have an
frou—-emery stone, that is all D. C. :
Q. And you use your 6wn current for that?
A. Yes, our current.
_ Q. Because these are D. C. machines? ~
°A. D.C. machines, We have a drill press, and sO
Q. Yes. ‘Is there any one now. in 4 the: basement :
_A. No; the basement is empty. 2
Q. No tenant in the- basement, basement i is empty?
A. Yes.
sd Mr. ‘Misby: I hive no further questions.
mush? © (Dr. pp.'192,158.) .. -; peo
eames ae Ben. Rash--Direct.
Bex Wie eivine , a duly sworn ‘gccording to law,
was examined and. testified as follows ae PP. 153- 172
-ine.) :
Direct- ccomination.
=
By Mr. ae | :
Where do you tive, Mr. Rash? -
5915 Carpenter Street. ©. _
And where are you‘employed? |
Fishman & Tobin—that is in the Kirechbaum
- Building, mu weet, oo x.
4:-.- . In what capacity are you employed by Fishman &
(. Tobint 7 .
"A. 1 am general manager.
Q. How long have you been employed by them?
A. = ‘three years. :
Q. Arey a familiar with their business ‘and all of its
phases? : a
A. Yes, in general: 3
Q. ‘What i is the business of Fishman & Tobin?
. oA. We, manufacture,boys’- wash suits. .
Q. Out of cotton cloth? .” ;
A. Cotton, yes,—-wool, curduroy. - ~ ‘
Q. Wiil you describe to the Court just how hens wash
. suits are made by Fishman & Tobin in the Kirschbaum
building? ; Fge
A: Well, we get in. the piece i: they are cut in’
* thefe, and they are sewed; they are pressed, and that} is a
finished garment.
_@ Then what happens é the finished garment?
A. That is shipped out to the stores?
Q..Do you know, Mr. Rash, where inost of: the raw
material that you use in making these - ‘garments comes
°o
preee
from? c.
- Well, the majority of it comes from the South.
~ Q. Do you know what States? 3"
A. We can get it from North Carolina, South Caro-
lina—mostly from North Carolina and South Carolina. -
&
Ben Rash—Direct. Soe 88
A a
Q. ‘Do’ you know_by-what types of carrier the goods
comes to Fishman & Tobin?
A. Well, we get it-in by beat, by train. There- i:
most any way it could come in—by train—boat—or—
Q. By motor?
“A. Motor service.
~Q. Motor truck? Motor freight? eit so
Yes... ? Meine oa
_ Q. Do you get any by railway express!
A. Very little—yes.
-Q. Do you get-an¥ by parcel post?
A. Yes.
—Q. Are incoming cifskaxiale brought into the premises
of Fishman & Tobin, or are they unloaded by the carrier’ —
on the unloading platform down at the street level ?.
'- A, They are brought in right onto our floor. Only
we sign for them on the floor itself. © 2. — , |
Q. Who brings them upstairs? Cie \
A. The carrier—whoever brings the goods.
~Q. The truck: driver ‘or railway express employe, or
' whoever it may be? .
A. Yes.
Q. And ° how frequently do you get incoming Taw
materials? |
aw. Every dg.
-Q. In what types of, containers do those. raw ‘materials
come? ‘
A. Get them-in cases? we get them in. baleb:shay be
small. i sometimes, in just wrapping paper. an
Q en, you get ther, i in , cases, how large are the
, eases generally? - yen eae '
* A. Rather Iarge—large size cases. _
‘Q. Well, can you give us a more definite ‘thea of the
size of the’ canst Suppose you dout-by reference to this
table (indicating counsel table).
A. I would say half the size of the table.
Q: Do you. have any idea of their weight?.
; 4
~ v
fh.
be
9 4
4 oF x Ben Rash—Direct. i
a Not offhand; no. ~
Q. Do you know, Mr. Rash, just approximately ‘nai
percentage of the raw materials that come in to Fishman:
& Tobin, come from points outside the State of Pennsyl-
‘vania?
_A. I should say around ninety per cent: 4
Q. Fishman & Tobin, you said, were on the fifth
floor? Ro KALES Fees
A.. That is right: ;
Q. Do you know whether, Mr. Rash, it - would: be pos-.
sible to carry any of were large wooden packing cases. .
_-upstairs? ;
o
A. Carry them? ~~ mar fae
—Q. Carry: them up the staircases?
"A, No. °
°
_ By Tue Cétex: Sn
—Q. You. say you don’t bina or it wil not? |
Af Ido not think it would be possible to carry those
cases up five floors. : :
“the Comer: AN Hebi; -T ida’ kao what your
‘no’? meant.
Fae
By Mr. aie
?
Q. Is there anv reg larity in ‘the time at which 4 ineom- .
ing shipments come-to you?
.
A. No, there is ‘no set time.” ; a ar 3
Ng they ¢come in SP all times during the Gayl: :;
At all times during the day. ne
-Q. After the garments are made up and packed, your
fine ships them out?: cs
A. That is right. *° | F
Q. Have you any’ idea of the percentage of commod-
- ” ities that go to points outside the State of Pentisylvania?
A. I should sav around eighty—eighty per @ent.
Q. Does Fishman & Tobin do a mail order business!
*
S A. » -- Ben Rash—Direct. a oe
A. ge ie . ; Bi
Q. Do they —? by any other eans than parcel
A. Do we ship by any. -other means?
-Q. Yes. i.
| A. Oh, ves. . e i‘. :
‘q- Q. Do you ship by railway express? .
uy A. Yes: : ae . 7 a
Q. Do you ship. by motor freight?
A. Yes. ane,
Q. Do you ship by railroad ?
A, Yes. :
Q. In handjing your outgoing shipments: do 3 vou de-
liv er to the carrier’ at the ecarrier’s place, or does*the car-*
vier pick up at vour: prentises ?
-A. The carrier picks up at our premises: ee
\ Q Is .there any regmarity wi fh whi¢h’ the carrier
comes and picks up?
A. Yes, -
: ? Q. How frequently and at what times do they sehen
A. It is three o "clock and quarter after five.
'Q. Daily? —
A. Daily. | :
-Q. Where do they come—to the fifth Pea or -to the
loading platform downstairs? 1.
A. Fifth floor. ; :
Q. Are the packages addressed; sealed, packed ‘and SO
becuse the fifth floor before they ‘are, ‘handed to the—
carrier? .
LA. Yes. Cone, ee
“Q. And then what does fhe carrier ‘do with them—
take.them down in the elev ator and put: them on his truck?
A. That is right.’ ; :
Q. Does a week’ ever pass, Mn R Rash, ‘darbide Which:
Fishman & Tobin, donot make shipments ‘to points out.»
side the State of Pennsylvania?
A: No.
#6 : ape Ben ‘Rash—Direet,
e
(). ie the Jast ‘two years, since October, 1938,
has a week ever passed in which it has not happened?’
- A, Never.
Q. With respect rags. 2 shipment, has.a week
ever passed in which you did not receive any incomigg
shipments from outside the State of Pennsylvania—in the
. last two’ years?
A. No," 4 "hides bo eee he
“Q. Can- yoa give’ us an approximations of the fre-
“queney with” which you make shipments outside of. the
State of Pennsy lvania? Is it daily, or onee’a week, or
more times a week? ay
A. It is daily. We make shipments daily outside of
- the State.
Q. In describing the process by which you say these °
boys’ wash suits were made, -you said sacar about |
“pressing, I believe ;, is‘that 80? ?
. Yes. °
In pressing, what type machinery do you use?
‘Hand iron. . oe
How are those hand. i irons heated?
. With steam.
Do you know where the steam comes from? -
. Building, : , *»}7%°
perererl
‘
©
By Tur ¢ ounT:
You use the steam inside the iron?
. Yes, :
By a tubing of some kind?
. That is right.
- By Mr. Brovr:
Q: How many irons that are operated by steam fur-
nished by the building are used Kb aaa & Tobin in
manufacturing boys’ suits? 7
A. Around - forty -two—forty -three- ~something like
,
ofp that. ~
.
2 ee ee ee ee
Ee
, Ben Rash—Direct, ie : 87
Q. Is steam used for my éther purpése in ‘the manu-
-factute of these suits? ;
‘A. No.
Q. Do you know, Mr. Rash, whether it would be pos-
sible for Fishman & Tobin to manufacture and press these
* suits without’ steam? »
> A. No, I do not think so.
‘Mr. Mason : I cannot hear that. What?
Aria #5
_ Tue .Wiryess: I do not think we could without .
the steam. We need the steam to‘press the garments. :
oe’
Mr. Minow You say—
“>
THE Wrrvess: We need the steam to preg the
garments.
qo Mr. Mason: That -is not what he, asked you.
Pe Could you do it without steam?
_ THE Court: He says, ‘“‘T do not think’ we could -
_ Without steam.’’ That is his answer.
By Mr. Brobre:
SS Just. at what. point in the produstive. process of
making: the suits is steam used? is it the e ire the middle, .
or the last point?
“A. It is the laste
Q. Does your firm use the elevators that, the building es
has? ©
A. Elevators? 7 Hae Sete Da
.Q. Yes, ;
A. Yes.
Q. For passengers, or freight, or both?
A. Both.
-Q. Do you use all threegelevatorst
A. Yes. ,
Q. Do you ever have customers come up to ‘visit you |
‘on the eleveforst
oe - . Ben Rash—Direct. a ples 7
A.’ Sometimes. . | *
(). I. assume the employes and_ ‘also the members of
| the firm use the elev aters to go to and from work, and at
the lunch hour? ce
A. That is right.. ° res oe |
.Q. ‘Tf the elevators stopped running, Mr. Rash, cou
Fishinan- & Tobin get any ruw materials to manufacture
or ship® out any finished products? . :
A. They équld ship out finished products. If we could
not-—if we did not have the elevators, we probably could
make our packages small enough to earry them down, but
gs far as coming up. I think T said-before we could not
manufaetyre—-we need the elevators to bring the merehan-
_dise up. +
Mr. Mason: I am sorry, but I do not know
whether it is the way you are sitting,-but I just ean- -
‘ not hear your answers. Will vou read that answer’?
Tue Covet: He says they could make the pack- —
- ages smali enough to take them out without using the
elevator, but as far as incoming packages, he does nat
believe they cauld get them nu
Mr. Mason: That aais mds, of course, am how
, they were shipped. - ey
Tre Covrt:, Yes.
By Mr. Bropir: oe .:
>.
Q. Does - the building also satel a watchman, do-
you know?
A. Yes.
iy 4. * (TE: pp. 162, 163.)
Q. Do vou know whether, Mr. Rash, your firm would
,. remain in the Kirschbaum Building as a tenant if the
watchman was not supplied : }
A. Yes, sir.
. .
¢ oo ©
e =a.
’ -
. e- oo”
Pe: Ben Rash—Cross. i By 89
Q. It. would? | :
A. Yes, sir. ‘
ory Mr.’ Mason: Ask another, Mr. Brodie.
Tue Court: That is what you get. It is an old
story, isn’t it?- “ ae
By Mr. Bropiz: ‘ dé
Q. Mr. Rash, let us revert. a moment to the shipment
s
of the outgoing merchandise, which you say could be car- ©
ried downstairs if. shipped in a slightly different form.
Would not mean, instead. gf one large case toa customer,
you might have te split it up ante fifteen, twenty, or more ,
packages? :
-A. That is right.
Q. Would that be a more expensive process? i
‘A. Yes. ‘ gees:
Q. To what extent would that “inconvenience your
- operations?
t
A. I could nét say - exaetty, but it would give us a little -
| hardship—it would be a little more trouble.
Q. The building also supplies heat to the premises i
occupied by-Fishman & Tobin, does it not?
A. That is right. :
-Q. Do you know whether it weéuld be possible to oper-
ate in those premises during the cold winter months with-
out heat? ies .
' A. No, you could not operate without heat.
To Ce pa -167, ine.)
Cross-examination.
By Mr. Mason:
Q. Mr. Rash, in answer to some of Mr. Brodie’s ques- —
tions, you were telling: about the use ‘of heating irons for -
pressing. ae: °
90 Ben Rash—Cross.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. ‘Now, you do a ee deal of pressing : with: what
you . call gas ‘irons, do you not—heating irons? fee
i = enady irons. | :
_ Q., What?- ‘
ee A, Yes: |
Q. And that gas is obtained from the Philadelphia F
Gas Works Company? © You buy it, from what © 78 call
the “UG. 1”, Lguppose? . | .
A. I don’t ‘think q0. .
— Q What? . Weil, where would you get it? You do :
not-make it? . ; | :
- Mr. Mivasibie: Could l answer that?
Mr. “Mason: No, ‘you cannot answer that. '
a Mn. ‘tiene:
¢ Where ‘do you get the gas you use in the irons you
- use to press with? |
A. I would rather not answer that. I may be under
_ the wrong .impression.> I thought we were getting the
steam through the ee ¢ ay
a.
By Tur Court: % one é ™ .A
Q. We are’ not talking about steam—gas. m3
A. Oh, the gas. Gas, we * get through the U, G. he
_ Ry Ma. Mason :
Q. That is right, and you use those. ifons 1 to. press |
with, don’t you? 2
Tue Covet: Do you nit own irons that ¢ are heated
by gas? @ <
Dae Wrrnges: Yes. pps
Tur Covrt: And you use ‘those irons for what! -
Tue Wityess: For pressing of the garments.
Ben Rash—Cross.” Mater | ) a
3 By Mr. Mason: ” Aer oe age
* Q. Pressing of the garments ; and you use steam to
press. some with? — |
A. That ‘is right. We need: steam ti there, toa, yes.
— ae
Ss.
Q. Yes. And did you ever in the old days, hefore._
there was a steam iron, know that you used a heated iron
and a hot rag—a wet rag—in order to’ press with?
A. No; that was pr obably Sefore my time.
_ Q. What? ;
A. Probably’ before my time.
Q. I think it was. You spoke also, of heat as an ab-—’
- solute essential to, your manufacturing establishment.
What heat were you talking about—the heat that: esac
‘your building? --
_A, Heated the building, yes.
Q. For the comfort of the employes? °
A> That is right. :
Q. Were you around in 1918 when: there was no “heat
in many of the buildings in: Philadelphia?
"Mr. Bropre: I object to that.
; Mr. Mason: I want to show you that’ it is ‘not |
necessary. |
+
o
_ THe Covrr: That is proper eross-examination,
since he made that statement.
By Mr. Mason:
Q. Were you around here in 1918—the tinte am
there was no heat allowed in any of these office. buildings
and loft buildings during certain days of the week?
A. I was too,small atthe time to remember.
Q. You were too small at the time to remember.
if they * have the heat there.
Mr. Mason: Fi ortunately that war : a not stay
very long to make it necessary.
THe oe rt: I don’ t believe’ they would stay long
92 . . Ss Ben ,Rash—Cross.
_ ing about in answer to Mr. Brodie’s«question, that came
es in-eotton goods?
THE Court: No, but It mean now.
By Mr.- M ASON :
Q. May I ask you what raw materials you were talk-
from states #fher than: Pennsylvania?
A. Wexget rayon, cotton, wool.
Q. Cotton and wool? :
A. Yes.
, Q. Do you get the cotton raw, or do- ‘you get it made’
A: Goods. ee : re
Q. Gotton goods? * Pace Fabaceae autre
A. Thatis tight." 9 >. |
~Q. Do you ktiow where tlie lsasafnctiver who makes
the cotton goods gets his cotton?
A. Where he get the cotton?’
Q._ Yes.’
A. No, I could not say.
Q. You do not. know?
A. No. : .
Q. You do know what cotton is, don’t yout |
A. Yes. :
Q@ You do ‘know ‘that cotton which is grown in 7
some parts of the South is essential to: Ahe cotton goods _ |
you have been using?
A. That is right. ts es
Q. That ddes not grow to anv very great extent in - 5
Pennsylvania, does it ?. :
_ A. No. Resear
- Q. Now, conting to your wooldp : you get ‘the raw
wuitioaiad in the form of raw wool and process it yourself, °
or do you get it in the form of— -
A. Piece goods.
Q: Woolen goods? | aire on
' A: Goods. wee 3
Q. Andis that America Fool! Mies :
” e& 9
at Ben Rash—Re-direct. ' ai | 93
A. Yes.. I think it is; yes.
Q. That grows on sheep? _ What? :
@A.. Yes.
Q. And do you know where the sheép a are raised that
the wool comes from that goes into the woolen goods that
you get to make these suits out of? =. / . 4a
_ A. No, I don’t. ee rs
-Q. You do not?’ ra eee
A. I do not kfiow. * Wane
- Q. That is, the material itself comes from outatide of
~ the State of Pennsylvania, but ‘the wool might be grown
‘in, Pennsyly ania? Keebey
LA. Possibly.
in your building +-in vour part of the anne? You have
lights there? 7
A. Oh, yes; *o ©
delphia Electric Company? *
A, Philadelphia Electric. Company.
_. Q. And that is for the purpose of lighting as well as
opetating the machines?
- A. That is right. Nene nee ted
‘ Q. Do you operate any of your machines by steam?
__ < A. Other than the—no. . (
Q. None at all—that is all, thank you.
Re-direct- -eramination.
= "By Mr. Buovin: ove eee ga Si
Q. Just one question, Mr. Rash. . These irons which
_ are heated by gas also use steam, do they not?
A. Yes, ‘that is it” : hs
Q. Steam and gas are used in the same iron; isn’t?
e that so?
A. Yes; that is if.
‘
\ 1Q. Did you tell us something about the use of: lights _
Q. And where do yeu get your light from—the Phila-
co. Rie. ">. Louis Casciato—Direet.
‘Louis Casciato, having been duly sworn according to
: law, was examined and testified as follows (Tr. pp. 172-
" 186 i ine. ):
Direct- -examination.
“By Mr. Bronte:
'Q., Where do you live, Mr. Canciatot ss
A. 5646 Warrington Avenue. S
_ Q. In ‘what business are,you? 9
A. I am cénnected with D’Alonzo-Lancaster, Ine, _
tailors to the trade. _ :
Y. Whereis the pkint of D’Alonzo- Lancaster, Ine.t -
A. At Broad and Carpenter, on the sixth floor of the
Kirschbaum Building. 3
~Q. What is your connection with that company!
_ A. 1 am assistant secretary and treasurer.
_Q. Are you completely familiar with all the business
‘done by D’Alonzo-Lancaster? - eres 4
A. Practically ally
Q. Are you familiar with the natuke of their opera
tions? . ;
A. Yes, sir.
Q: You described .their business as ‘‘tailors to the
trade.’’ Just what did yowtiiean by that? -
A. Well, to put it in anothe? way, it is wholesale eus-
tom tailors. We cut one suit at a time, individually.
Q. Men’s duits’ or ladies’ suits? |
A. We do mostly men ’s—we have started ladies’
_ clothes about a year ago. :
. By. Tue Court:
Q. They take your. measure in the store and they ‘send
it in to you? ms :
at A. That is it, and we finish it: according to measure.
By Mr. Bropte: :
Q. And as your plant on the sixth floor of the Kirsch-
‘Louis Casciato Direct. 95.
baum Builditig,” just what operations take . place i in the 2
making of these suits? Was
°A. You mean from-the minute the order gets into the.
house? | ry gt gh
Q. Yes. ie . Loe
A. It is a long process: we open by opening the
mail— =
Q. You can skip thaf. You get the order?
a
“Mr. Mason: May 1 interrupt just a moment, be-
cause I want to get clear the’ relationship ofgthis wit- |
——ness ‘and his company to the Kirschbaum Company:
Did you develop that—as to whether. or not@he has"
any direct: relationship with the building? be ke
Mr. Brovir: I intended_to develop that.
? “Mr. Mason: Suppose you do that before you gete
ae into this: it may shorten it quite a bit if you will.
s
The Court: Is he a: tenant? a @
Mr. Bropre: He is. a, sub- tenant. -
Mr. Mason: He has no yeaa to the land-
lord at all.
By Mr. Maso :
QQ. W ho do you lease trom?’
°A. Nicholas D’Alonzo, also president of the D’ ieee:
Lancaster, Inc. He.is the one that has the lease. with
Kirschbaum. — 3 eo
Q. But who a
A. And we pay him _the proportionate rate of the
lease. :
By Afr, Bronte: - 0
Q. Now, ‘will you please answer ‘the last question that :
I put to you before Mr. Mason—
Mr. Mason: What was that?
. es
%
9G", o ; Louis Casciato—Direct.
-. A. T hope ‘the Court may advist me, because sonie-
\ A. That is: | See
o
‘ “By Ma Bropir : Riga ' cd
Q. The question Was, will you desetibe what happens
in the rai aba of your business?
* Mr. Mason: I object. to thaf, sir, because tliere
_is no relationship here between this witness’s business
and the landlordvat all; -and therefore no’ connection
between the landlord afd whatever this sub-tenant
imay be doing. © bs Fig
THe Court: Well, I will hear it subject | to the
Z objection, J think.
Tue Witness: You want me’ to explain? :
2 1d # ? ° ,
a
By Tue. Count: ay
gz
Q. What happens, is that you get. some cloth in ther.
don’t you?
A. No, first thing we do, we prepare forthe season.
We buy’ woolens aud make what is known as a ‘*sample
line’’ and we send # aut to the tailors ahd dealers,
*Q. Trike W anamaker’ s an@ Strawbr idge’s
ae Yes, you may go to Wanameker’s ani! pick up. a
piece of goods and they measure you. : :
Q. Oh, I have done it. - inet te ay
“A. [ don’t know whether I am speaking out of turn.
— °-Q. T didn’t know whether you, made it’ up— ,
times I may oxive away a name. like this—attorneys may
you, do,vou do business with sq and s6?
(). IT don’t care about that.
A. That is the way it works.
Q. And you make up-the sample line and send |
\around to the stores? aks “See :
-
. Q. After taking a man’s measure in the store, what
Wdhens! ie ee
A, The order’ comes in. and ave. turn it in to Nicholas
D’ Alonzo, who manufactures it for us.
0
ae
Louis Casciato—Direct. a 97
By Mr. Bropre: .
Q. Mr. Casciato, before y you get the goods, do you do
We sponging or shrinking of them?- is :
A. No, the sponging and ‘shrinking is done. by
Schwarzwaelder’s. | 7
Q. Is that done before it comes in your plant?
A. No, the piece goods comes in our plant first; then
Schwarzwaelder’ s man picks then up, examines them,
‘ takes them aut, sponges them, and brings them back to us. . |
—Q. When he picks up the “goods. are the bolts rather Sees
~ largeand heavy?
A. Yes; they average seventy to eighty. yaigls toa
Q. Do you know how ‘much a’ lilt of cloth would
weigh?
., A. Well, your average ‘piece ‘of: goods today runs’
_from: nine and a half ounces to the yard to fourteen
ounces’ to the yard, so if the “bolt. is sixty. Bards, vou got
to multiply one by the other, so a good-average may be
about sixty-five. pounds, or something like that.
Q. Does Schwargwaelder’s man use the elevator to -
‘come up. to your premises to vet the goods?
A. Yes, sir. - us
‘). And when he leaves vour premises with the eoods?
_A. Yes, sir. a
Q. And also when he returns with the rods?
A. Yes, sir. a
Q. Now, then, the goods are back in your plant, hav-
© ing heen sponged, shrunk, and examined?
7
.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. They are cut by vou and then what happens?
A. First, when the goods come back m. our plant, we
give it a number and put it in stock;-then if we get an.
order on that particular goods, we pull that ott of the
bin and ent a suit according: to the order from our tailor. iy:
P
ai
98 .» Louis Casciato—Direct.
By Tue Court: aa eh cnr ri
Q.. How many yards to a suit! |
A. According to the’ size—we averaye three and a
half yards to. the eoueiar. size.
By Mie Disdcas:
. And who doe the sewing? ness 5 aa
Q
A. Nicholas D’Alonzo. Apert Oe Mee
Q..On what kind of basis does he do the seWi for
+ ar
A
you - Bie
: He ieek it on a -contraet hands. w e pay so much.
By Tiyfe Court: Ea ae oer ae
_ Q. Is that at the Kirschbaum Buildiag? ’
- “A, On: ‘the same floor. : ae
; By Mr. Bron:
(). After the suits are ‘sewn does Nicholas D’Alonzo
return them to you? : ’.
A. Finished. SB % ae
Q. Sir? : .
“A, The suits. are finished when we ‘ pet them. from
Nicholas D’Alonzo. F
Q. What do you do with them then? .
A. We, of? course, examine them and ship them.
* Q. Are you familiar with the customers to whom you
ship? | ; ys :
A. Yes, sir.
. Q, Of your total business annually, about what per.
. centage of it is with customers outside of Pennsylvania? . |
A. I would say from seventy to eighty per cent.
: 2 &. Now, these raw materials that vou get in—woolens
that vou have described—do you know where they come
from? .
a oe ee "Sg Oe
| ‘Q. Where? | ath °
. Louis, Casciato—Direct. 2. . 99
se
A. All sections of the.country-—mostly from, the New
‘England States. ,
_ Q. Have you any. idea what pereentage comes from |
states. other than Pennsylvania? a “ae
A. T.would say about seventy- five to eighty per cent.
Q. How frequently do you get in ‘shipments of raw
-materials?>
| A. Daily—almost daily-snot the big bolts, I+ mean,
‘We might miss a few days on a big bolt; but almost daily
something if coming in. It may be just one suit ‘length
coming in, yeu-see, where the customer useg his own cloth. ;
Q. During the last two years has it ever happened ee
’ ‘that a week has passed during which you did not get Fy
shipment of goods from a point outside Pennsylvania?
- A. When you say. ‘‘goods’’ do you mean like for just
one suit? -
Q. I mean any hak st hie 2
A. Oh, no;. we get it almost daily.
Q. And during the last two: vears, has a week ever,
passed during which you did not make a ‘shipment of fin-
ished clothes outside the State of Pennsy lvania?
_ A. No; we ship every day.
Q. By what types of transportation facilities do, vou
ship?
A. Mostly parcel post—I could say about—well.ninet Vv
per cent .parcel post, and railway express is the balance.
Q. In making these shipments, do you take the gar-
ments to the carrier or does the carrier send someone to
Your plant for them?
A. We take them for the paree post shipments to the
post office.
Q. Yes.
A. And railway express+well, T would say even that,
fifty per cent they pick up and fifty per cent we may take
over, but their items are so small— *
, Q. Does the railway express. stop regularly at your
plant to see— Son
”
100 Louis Casciato—Direct.
A. It calls every day to see if we, have anything going
out. ie by ; - . ;
). Every day? ‘ peas abe 8 v.
A. Every day. Re dae
Q. The incoming goods—are they unloaded at the
platform downstairs or are they brought by the? carrier
right up to the sixth floor of your plant?
A. The carrier brings them up to the sixth floor.
Q. Do the goods come up ou the elevator?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. If the elevator were not running could they be
‘setabeliie gotten upstairs?
A. Well, I don’t think it would be —n possipje— :
if we got four or five pieces of goods—on somebedy’s
shoulder up a stairway—something like that.
(). ‘How about. outgoing shipments? ‘Do you ever
qnake them in large quantities, or only one suit at a time?
A. No, there may -be twenty, suits going out to one
dealer, but-as a rule we. use. mostly cartons. We may
- have a case shipment when we send out our display ends.
(). How many cartons do you ship out at a time dur-
‘ing your busy season?
_ A. What we consider a load. In other words, T might
have twenty-five packages and say there is enough fhere
to send ‘the bov out to the post office, .
Q. How many suits do you, ship a week, approx-—
‘imately?
A. T Would say shea seven hundred—elxht hundred.
Q. If the elevators were not running, would your
business be seriously’ impeded t ’ |
A. If tlie elevators were not running?.,
Q. Yes; would it be difficult for you ‘to make these
outgoing shipments? |
yA. Why, ves; we w ould have to walk down six flights
of steps.
Q. Would a man walking down six flights of steps, be
able conveniently to carry twenty-five cartons of suits?
. i (
‘ SS .
res
%
3 ‘Louis , reesadligterss. oC ae
‘No,
Do you wet lights from the Kirschbauin Building
Yes, ° vie
Between what duce!
I think seven-thirty to about fiv eo ‘lock:
Mr. Mason: That is not material, Mr. Brodie.
The Kifschbaum Building does not mean much in this
particular instance. The sub-tenant. relationship is
with the tenant and not with Kirschbaum.
Mr. Brovme: The lights supplic® by the building
are necessary to the productive process,
Mr. Mason: They may not come from the Kirseb-
baum Building; they may come from thie Philadelphia
Electric Company.
Tur Cover: W e will see,
(Question repeated by the stenographer as fol- |
lows: “*Q: Between what hours? A. I think seven-
thirty. to about five o’clock.’’)
By Mr. Bropte:
Q. About five, what happens?
A. Then we get outside current.
~,
___Q. Yon have a switch which switches from house cur-
rent supplied by the building, to outside current? =
A. That is what I understand.
Q. What company supplieés.the outside enrrent?-
A. The Philadelphia Electric. ee
Q. Apart from the carriage of freight, what other
use do vou and your company make of the elev ators in
the building? ° ’
| Fax
A. Well, ali our employes go up and dens nin them.
q. How about the customers? €
A. Yes, we got customers sopiig up
Q. Salesmen? - mee
A. ‘Salesmen.
102 . ‘aed Casciato—Direet.. .
on
Q. Do 3 you ‘find that during the rush hours there is
often a jam ‘on the elevators? —
Mr. Masox : What do you mean. by “Jam”, Mr,
Brodie? | “9 as Sik oe y Mee
: : wth
By Ma. Brovir: *
Q, A crush—-do you find the elev ators fall Do ‘you
sometimes have to wait?
. A. I don’t know—the only: time I experience what .
they are busy—if all the building is letting out at noon-
time, the cleyator comes to the fifth floor—instead of stop-
ping at thesixth, they get their load and go down.
Q. What happens at those times? Do aga walk down.
stairs or do you wait?
A. Oh, 1 wait.
Mr. Medi: A ticdoal American | 9 do
not mind that interjection.
Mr. Brovix: Well, I don’t think it-adds ‘evtetaty
to the case. I am not sure whether it is up to me to
mind or not.’ If the Court does not object—
THE Court ‘ The Cotrt does not object.
By. Mk. Brovie : a
__ Q The premises that ‘are occupied by you are also.
“heated, by the building, are they not? 7
A. Yes, sir.
. ‘Q. Could your .company operate éittadinds without
heat in the winter? i
A. No, I do not think so. > bie
Mr. Brot: That, also, is, I assunie, a. typical
American habit. © -” a i
"Mr. Mason: Very typical. are
oc
Louis Casciato—Cross.. - - 108
By Mr. Bron: 7 7
Q. Does the building supply watchmen’? -
pi. Yes, sir.
Q. If the building | did not wren watchmen would
your firm engage a separate watchman?
@A. Yes, sir. « ‘ ¥
‘Q. Why? |
A. I think it is.common sense. We got a lot of mer-
chandige in there—you have no watchman, you have to
have some protection: system. .
Mr. Brome: You may ¢ross-examine.
Cross-examination,
By Mr. Masow:: falas: a
q. Mr. Casciato, 1. ask you whether or ‘not you engage
-in retail as well as wholesal¢e business.
A. Yes, sir. Py 4
Q. Will you tell us to whet. extent?
By Tue Court: aes tae
Q. Ww hat do you mean by satin S *? What. is yeur
definition ? ~
A. In the, retail, Your Honor, it is mostly done. on’
friéudship. In other words, all my friends know I amin <~ . .
the tailoring business—¢hey come up ‘and say *‘ Louis,
will you make me a spit??? And we sell at retail; but we
don’t advertise it. When I say ‘‘don’t advertise,’’ we
don't put out no signs ‘‘factory to you.’
Q. What. is your wholesale. business? _Who are” your
* customers there? «
A. Tailérs—we will say Wanamaker’ s—we mentioned .
Wanamaker’s—custom tailors. — -
Q. Large stores?
A. Yes, or haberdasheries—it does not necessarily
have to be a large tailoring establishment. |
MEO r oe _Louis Casciato—Cross.
Q. Lahey that saver they make suits ts tomas.
~ A. That is it. hes Coe
Y. They sénd it in to you?
A. That is it. ~ a
Mr. Mason: I have no further‘questions. Is there
anything else? : @
Mr. Bropre: I have one further question to clear
up this matter of rom ‘business. ie
By Mr. Baoom: .
Q. What percentage of vour total business does this
retail. business amount to? «— ‘
» A.“Oh,. it is very, very small: I do inot think it.
amounts to five per cent—not even that.* It is very, very .
small. , °
Mr. Bropm: This witness also has records re-
lating to shipments: there is no controversy ‘over
that?
Tue Court: If there should be, I wil teal you
to have him brought back..
* . Mr. Bropir: Then, sir,—
iJ . ° *
Mr. _ Mason : i will say now. there i is not. I would
like to nove to strike out this witness’s testimony.
Tae Covrt: You may nfake your motion: Twit
. hold it. Ws re OM |
Mr. Mason : : Your Honor wilk reserve ruling on it!
Tar Court: Yes. :
a “Ste ‘Masox: The motion is to strike out testis”
mouy on the ground that aszan occupant of the build-
ing, he has no direct. relationship to the owner 2-
landlord, and the services concerned, and also, may |
suggest—as coynsel for the government appreciates—
?
Admigsions es Defendant for Purposes of — 5
: _. | this Case.
that thinse is an 5 aloaotbie in the Act with respeft te
those engaged i in retail businesses.
_ | Tue Court: All right; shall we’ adjourti soaiit
ten o’clock on Monday? Do you think it will take
« more than Monday? ba
Mr. Bropirt: I think we-should finish during Mon-.
day—perhaps late in the afternoon.
Mr. Mason: We will go on this coming Monday
_ at ten o’clock. ! |
Tue Court: Yes.
(Adjourned until Monday, ‘November 18, 1940, at
10.00 o’@ock A. M. ee
e
o-
ro
.
ADMISSIONS BY DEFENDANT FOR PURPOSES OF
THIS CASE (Tr. pp. 199, 200.)
Denying that it or any of its employees are subject to
or covered by the Fair Labor Standards: Act of: 1938 (Act
of June 25; 1938, c. 676, 52 Stat. 1060; U. S..C., Title 29,
Sec. 201 .ct_seg,), hereinafter—ealled the Aets A B.
KIRSCHBAUM COMPANY, a Pennsylvania corporation,
‘defgndant above named. by its undersigned attorneys, for .
the purposes of this ease only, hereby’ stipulates and
agrees: - , Dee, |
SP
That. with ‘respect to the following ‘named persons.
who are ar have previopsly heen in the employ of the De-
fendant. the Defendant, from time ‘to time, during the
period stated jn the Complaint filed in this cas€@fd' not :
comply with the or tenet of Section’ 7;
4
e
in?)
_ 30 "Adolph W. Haber—Direct.
-
A
~ WILLIAM MENTZEL
i. McKINLEY EDWARDS
PETER ROCK
COLEMAN RUCKER
and with respect to the tollowing named persons, peal
GEORGE E, SIMON —
HARRY J. GALLAGHER
GEORGE EPPS”
SAMUEL H. FLEMING
NICHOLAS CATTELISE
CLARENCE BERKELEY | ;
the Defendant, teen time to tiine, during the-period stated
_© in the Complaint filed in this case did not.comply with the
|, provisions of Section 6 and 7 of the said Aet.
*** (Tr. p. 200.)
we
. ° ° i
ApoLtru W. Haser, havinge been duly sworn, was ex-
amined and testified ais follows ( Tr. Pp. 200-216 ine.) :
=
Su See * Direct- examination.
Pr: © a ; o y
By "ef Vv OTAW; if =
. Mr. Haber, by whom are you ‘employed!
A. Joseph B. Haber, Incorporated. °
~ Q. And where is their place of business?
A. In the Kirschbaum Building, at. 1335 W: cshieantee
Avenue. ;
Q.. What is your. connection with Joseph B. Haber.
Ine.?
: A. I am secretary of the iocaieaiaaitiss
‘Q. Are you familiar with the business of that corpo-
. fation# * §.-
A. ‘I am.
Adolph W. Haber—Dit rect. \chieat ia
Q. What is the tealacne of that corporation?
A. Manufacturing knitted outerwear, sweaters and
- . bathing suits.
.Q. Dé&s it operate coiitinuously throughout the year?
A. It does. ;
Q. And what is the nature of your: production oper-
ations? m
’ A. We take in the raw aatieial | in the sidpe ot yarns,
knit them, cut them, operate them, and ship them in the.
* foym of bathing suits and sweaters.
(. That is all done on your eae?
A: That is correct. :
Q. Do you have to shrink the yarns after | you - cut
them, or process them in any way?
A. Just steaming them to bring the cloth. ‘to the de-
sired width for ewtting and pressing thie finished - gar-. -
ments.
%
use for that operation?
A. We use a decatising machine, which eniploys or
Q. What de you use, what kind of "a machiga do you
uses live‘steam. — ; ro
Q. Where do you get the liv e steam?
A. From the Kirschbaum Building. |
Q. And what machine.do you use for pressing?
A. A. regular Hoffman press, also uses live steam,
also delivered by the Kirschbaum Building.
Q. Could you operate your business without those
machines? 7
A. No, we eould not. eM 5 o
(), Where does this varn come from?
“A. Mostly from New fingland and the South, depend-
ing upon whether it is worsted or cotton; worsted from
New England, cotton from the South. sod giao fe
Q. In what form does it come? How does it come?
A. In cases.
.Q. What size cases?
A. Around three hundred pounds api 1ece, I would say.
~
108
Q.
A,
Q.
A.
Q.
from New England? |
' A. By water, by train, by- motor truck, various
methods, iat me a upon ‘the source
\
—Q.
: Mr. Haber—because you are asking: this witness to»
indulge in considerable speculation. I don’t want to
restrict him too much, but I am just. curious to know,
whether he knows what®e is talking about.
A.
accompanied by bill of lading which shows method of ship-
‘ment, and quite offen we have to call up to find why a |
shipment is delated, and on those occasions I have had |
" 6ecasion to call all three types of ageneies.
Q.
came from, then? — _—
A.
. | beg, vour pardon?
. No, sit, I don’t, we have girts emplayed in the
. But it is al}-ciyertly undeg my supervision.
Adolphi W, Haber—Direct.
od
Which floor-are you ont
Second floor.
How does that yarn get to your floor?
By elevator. |
By what agencies does it come from the South or
co
By Me, “Mason:
How’ « do -you know that?
Mr. Mason: May 1 interrupt—just a moment,
Why, when we get our invoices they an> always
- By Mr. Votaw: =
There is no speculation involved in . where this
No, sir, none whatever.
.
By Mr. flasex: ©
Do you do all of that yourself?
Do you do all of that vourself? 7
All right, go ahead. --
a ae
‘* Adolph W. Haber—Direct. . _ 109
Mr. Mason: Go.ahead, Mr. Votaw. .
By Mr. Voraw: __
‘Q.Is it delivered to you on -the platform: on the
ground floor or at your place of business ?
A. At the platfor m—oh, I am sorry, you will have to
qualify that question.- I can’t auswer it #xactly. —
Q. Well, do your: employees briag it. up from the
ground floor?
A. No, sir. ‘
.Q. Or ‘does the carrier bring it up to you?
‘A. The carrier onings it up and deliv ers it to us on
_ our floor. |
Q. I see.
A. We sign for it on our floor. .
+: Q, ,! ou sigi® for it on your floor?
A. That is correct. Me
Q. Would it be possible to get these shipmients to your
floor without the elevator? G
A. It is possible, but difficult.
Q. Possible, but difficult. Where do you ship the .
completed sweaters and bathing suits?
A, All over the country. !
Q. Have you any idea what per cent of your ship-
ments are made to points outside of the State. of Penn-
sylvaniag? °
A. T should say about eighty to eighty- five per cent.
_ Q. Are: those shipments’ under your superv ision? -
A. Well, yes, : at
Q. They are, and vou are personally familiar with the
places to which the shipments are made?.
A. That is: correct.. — : oe
Q. You have your records with you showing ship- -
ments‘and also receipts, have you not? ,
' A. I brought with me, bills, paid bills, showing pay-
—tent for. yarns received from New &ingland and. the ’
Sonth, both, and I brought with me bills of lading: show-
> : ere
voods.
>
110° Adolph W. HHaber—Direet.
ing shipments made to Chieago and Wisvonsin, and places
of that sort. I didn’t bring but Papconeengeers groups of
that particular type. a :
“Mr Votaw: We understand, ey Honor, simi-
larly to the ruling made hast week, that\ it is not
_hhecessary to ‘put those in evidence. ;
3 Tue Court: You have the right to put them in
2 opin case the evidence of the witness given on the stand
Ts. controverted in any way. ‘ - N
Mr. Voraw: All, right. Meets ak
: _ By Mr. Vortaw: :
Q. What means of transportation do you use for the
outgoing shipments?
-A. The same three means ‘that we use to’ receive
Q. Railroad, motor express an steamship?
A. Steamship. ~
Q. Does any week pass during which a shipnietit’ to
some point outside of the State of Pennsylvania ‘is “not
made?’ ! Toe es
A. 1 doubt that very ’ etromady: 4
Q. Are your shipments regular throughout the year
or they i iti seasons? ;
“A. No,.we have peak seasons, We have one season,
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.