Transcript of Record — Chicago v. Fieldcrest Dairies, Inc.

Supreme Court brief1942

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

~

ae Vol HW © o&

one,

“3

eT et 1

os. 7 , - ee Ze o; 30% é

oe

‘ * / 4 %-.

e ° . ; Ps aK yon © wi &

(0

_ TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

Supreme Court of the au States

- OCTOBER TERM, 1941

; °

© No. 706

CITY OF CHICAGO, A MUNICIPAL CORPORATION,

BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE CITY OF CHICAGO,

ET AL., PETITIONERS, — °

Vs.

° FIELDCREST DAIRIES, INC.

ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT

OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH. CIRCUIT

£,

«<

‘ . { : -

———— e

. , PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED OCTOBER 20, 1941. ;

y. ~

CERTIORARI GRANTED NOVEMBER 2%4, 1941.

IN THE

"Supreme Court of the United States

Octoser Term, A. D. 1941.

‘te me No.

CITY OF CHICAGO, (4 Mustorpat Corporation), BOARD -

OF HEALTH OF THE CITY OF CHICAGO, DR. -

ROBERT A. BLACK, Heatrx Commissioner anp Act- -

ina PREswwENT OF Boarp OF Hearn OF THE Crry OF

CHICAGO, ©

. Petitioners,

vs. :

FIELDCREST DAIRIES, (Ire. );

_ Respondent.

bs ON wRIt OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT a

ts OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT.

Sillimeiaitesesssecnaaiaiemnal

Ba eae ¢

al

- INDEX.

Index to Printed Record of Proceedings in U. S.

Baal CA 5 ev oico ys ncpncake ti ci ddcekis vas ie ae

Clerk’s Certificate to Volume 1 of Printed ck gs 6088

‘Clerk’s Certificate to Volume 2 of Printed Record: . . 1224,

Clerk’s Certificate to Volume 3 of Printed = eeales 1779

Index to Proceedings i in U. 8. Court of demele:” |

on ER nT ee ONY, ORD .. 781

Opinion by Major, J., filed Aug. So Serre 1782

- Dissent, by Lindley, D. J.............: engecane 1795

‘ Decree, ‘entered Aug. 4, 1941..... Ae ees 3 pee -1797

Order staying Mandate, entered me 23, 1941. ...1798

cs, Designation. of Record........ <e-a oe ee v.65 oe hu

Clerk’s Certificate ...... cikaeen cote se eeeeees i. -1801 :

Order allowing. certiorari Shee see ore oo

9

VOL. Ill: pp. 1225 to 1777.

hi _ TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

IN. THE

Qnited States Cirruit(Court of Annals

No. 7502

FIEL DC RE ST ._DAIRIKS, ¢(Inc.),

- Plaintiff- Appe llee,

7 U8, . ; .

CITY? OF CHICAGO la MuNIcIPaL - Conrokation),

BOARD OF HEAL TH OF THE CITY OF CHICAGO,

— PREROBERT A. BLACK, Heatran Compissioner ann -

ACTING PRESIDENT or Boarp or Heatru Or THE (4TY oF

+ CHICAGO,

Defendants-A ancblains,

7

f Appeal from the District Court of the United States for ‘

; the Northern District of Illinois, Mastern Division, —

, Fh

/

ar

Sf

a a a -- - _ —-: ——

—— —

a. ANSCRIPT OF RECORD FILED JAN. 20, 1941.

- PRINTED RECORD.

~~

_—_-

‘

: ei @)

: Wy

i

, 3

a

«

aio Sts rat Gor of Haws

Bor the Seventh Circuit

No. 7502

FIBLDOREST DAIRIES, (Isc.),

Plaintif’-Appellee,

vs. !

CITY OF CHICAGO; (a Muvuwrcrpat Corporation),

BOARD OF HEALTH OF THE CITY OF CHICAGO,

DR. ROBERT «A. BLACK, Heatra Commissioner axp

‘Acting Presipent or Boarp OF HeaLTH OF THE: Crry OF

Cuicaco,

* Defendants-A ppellants.

coc

»

Appeal from the District Court/of the United States for

the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division.

ae

“>

pag AS. ile se ele:

IN. <b asas anmteeGe hweranaeren teensex es pre ee

Complaint filed February 2, 1939 ipewksegeaseen shecey ee

Answer filed February 27, 1939.................+-. 16

Exhibit A—Reprint of the Mayor Kelly Milk Ordi-

nance passed by City Council January 4, 1935, |

OO sigu'ewunds vn Gin chk bs dace Cerne pees ress 23’

Order referring cause to. Master, entered May 12, 1939 123 .

. .Notice as to stipulation, filed May ee hy 124

-. Order approvitg stipulation, entered May 25, 1939... 125

_ . Stipulation as to experiments, ete. .............. 125 ©

Stipulation regarding tests requested by City of Chi-

cago pursuant to stipulation filed June 29, 19 . 127

ae approving stipulation with respect to tests, en- |

1 June _ i. See ee Puahie xe ey Sumbddave 131

TRANSCRIPT OF TESTIMONY. \

Statement. by Mr. Schaefer.....-,.., SR ESE

‘Statement by Mr. Gariepy................... casas ee

' Cojloquy .137, 155, 226, 373, 687, 849, 854, 880, 893, 1231, 1271

PLAINTIFF’s WITNEssEs.

aa iii ort SS PES

A, PEE Wa. Bhs dpeicecesccvisseckovss Sas 939

Dante, An@iew ...4....50.0605020c0000 Care

Carpenter, A. E. (deposition of)...............+...-1385

I re NG et ok a Se

OD een peers be opr rr a ', .840, 888, 938, 960

Faust, E. RB. .... 3: rer Eeyere Peta th Ca eredeb el "862.

ee I A? as uk ee Sane udsacanvaceeaeunn 306, 534

a ee ee ee ee ea

“Huber, Philip............ uk bekiwcuws jasaewunh

Johnston, Florence (deposition of) aes ke ney Reape! 1

r, Charles Da sccccbecccccerescccces /...2..360, 372 |

Eerer Paul V., Jr. (deposition i“, iSakakacaneeers 1334

ae. 5 Uh ven w cheeses bees . .. 861,897

¥ Koller, Margaret M............ icon kekweapee pile we. 440

Martinek, Matthew J........... OTS Pe ee sfexeceeke

McNally, William D. ....... Aci bis tek eye A 251,1276-

SARA SRNG | ote | Pee ae on _ 567

Packer, Herbert M. (deposition of). . vac nes oe es ee

Peterson, Howard R. ....... pet andi sivuxanees 942, 966

= UM MUNI 6 oo 8E soc ceveivc je cisco cies 624, 700

I I MIN 6 Foi noc cc cc accsndosrvtucec 144 |

I BAG k hb ea cies dv oye cen sncdutensaues 612

9 oo i es eas aden eens 364

pg Lei ee er eee eee oe 546, 607

i Cican chncedinks es eben e ert Aer 898.

Tracy, Paul Hubert Cav eceetovenpess ssacentserenn 471.

‘Vaughan, BR. T. ........:......045- POP Or reer 1302

IIe cia a5 cob pcwsecatcbceccxe ces cueien 847

I, Bo snc ckwbawenes BS eT eeeestrcccce, OT

- Yunker, Elkan H. (deposition arses: Jets 1377

Stipulation etek WD caterebiaces Peenoceevencegdevac 689

Q

Master’s Wrrwess.

Rice, i wehbe es wenies -- 7

ae ; Drrexpart’s Wrreesses. B ox

Arnold, Lloyd ..... elk sks anes pteades tesco 1061

Black, Robert A. ...... Usha ekatapacielins cia 1225

Bundesen, Herman N. “PVE See Ads caskndenth (iaawn 1206

Dulak, Francis, A. meh die Ma uKKs Meee eae ive aude :.1230 .

oe, sas Nenloaw ote ATCO ERE eee cue 968 -

_GaRe E Daeen 2 0 ons vol a peeve 600 to isos Wok HET pages 1ne0 to

_ Martinek, Matthew J........... Pia cshivencticccees 1001

Ce en ee ee Sui Neca ahas . » 1032:

NOG is Scr eer sviaceecebntscseceustoen 1237

Rudig, Delmar M.'....... Sicnedenbekes ipa hvonk-o ase ee

Tonney, Fred O. ........ pa aitaeneieies Suneken Sori Ff

Report of Conference with Master:................. 1307 °

— of Discussion With ay OEE ate 1328

‘Piarntirr’s Exutstrs.

No. é-Binert of Dr. ‘Arnold; Dec. 4, 1937, ete... . 1397.

No. 5—Letter Nov. 27, 1936—Packer to Silver Seal

ae Dairy Products Co........ alagmeadcatets :..1471

No. 6—Letter Nov. 28, 1936—Sullivan to Fuller... .1471

No. 7—Letter Nov. 30, 1936—Foote to Fuller...... 1472

No: 8—Letter Dec. 1,,1936—Moffett to Silver. Seal

Dairy Products Co. ............¢.... TEE SS 1473

No. 10—Letter Dec. 2, 1936--Grim to Silver Seal.

ch onbhonewseibeenvukckhe tha eaoteecn 1474

_ No. 11—Letter Jan. -5, 1937_-Williams to Fuller. .'. .:1474

No. 12—Arrticle “Sanitation of Paper Milk Con-

ees I, det dad back inn ctddlieatansaness 1477

No. 13—Photograph of pint glass milk bottles and .

DE 63 sueecncrantsaaaneeenes ieee 1493

No.14—Photograph of quart glass milk bottles... ....1495°

No. 15A—Photographs from advertising literature: of

Ex-cell-O Corporation ...........66......... 1498

No. 16—Artiele ‘‘Single Service Containers for Milk

. and Milk Products’”’ ..... Meek dawenuhene tie 1503 ©

No. 17—Article ‘‘Reasonable Sanitary Standards for

i, 26 sitbaddcekaseavnans enn 1507

. No.18—Article ‘‘When ‘are Milk Chestaieies and Equip-

ment Clean and Sterile” .................. 1514

No..19—Report of second ¢énference on Sanitation of __

- Paper Milk Containers, Etc. .............. 1518

soi F vases 3 0 GOn; Val HE paave O00 to tame: Yel HT pages 1008 wo

oS

W

io iv

Article ‘Paper Containers for, Milk; Prin-

ciples of Sanitation to be observed in

their Manufacture and Use’’....... ‘em eacn 1525

' No. 21—Arrticle ‘Proposed Standards for Paper. Milk

Containers’’

No. 24—List of cities using paper milk containers,

SE Bees ly is ws 3.00 6 bea sda ome cae 1546

No. 25—Letter Nov. 14, 1938—Sanborn to Dwyer... .1548

No. 23—Photograph of printing press"feed—Gardner-

I Re i os oe sie dsteesciesvaersas 1549

No. 34—Photograph of carton blanks seaity ae. -* >

ing before capping................4 iene aus 1551

No. 35—Photograph of carton blanks ready for ship-

NE nk Vicks abu edhe 2A aloud baie eee eaw ee 1553

No. 36—Photograph of blank ready for gluing, capped . 1555

No -37—Photograph of carton blanks printed and ready

“) packed for shipment ..<:. 6.2.0... ccecgasese 1559

No. 39—Sheets headed ‘‘Samples of Milk Bottle Car-

tons,’’ tests by Harry C.' Fisher. .:.......... “1561

No. 42—Photograph — Model Geos ’*»—Soaker Bottle —

ME ri A Laas go Se eee kobe bee krea ws 1563

/. No. 44—Photograph of paper bottle and glass bottle -

filled with milk at 15 degrees below zero..... "1565

No. 45—Letter June 23, 1939—Hoffman to Gariepy. .1567

- No. 46—‘‘Study on Self-Purification of Paper’’....:.: 1572 —

No. 47—‘‘ Bacterial — ‘of Pure-Pak Con-

ce ES PT Me EE tre SR OE Pe ER i ae eclal 1573

No. 47A—‘‘Bacterial Condition of Pure-Pak Paraffined

Container as revealed by Four. Different.

Methods” a eEN eas voeah Oise aie es «++ 1574 *

se¥eh F pages 1 $0 006; Vol. HT pages 000 to inn; Vol. HEE magus 1985 te

No. 48—

No.

No.

4 >.

v..

48—‘Bacterial Condition of wealiaih aiid sterilized - :

‘bottles in two plants in Chicago’’.......... 1575

49—‘‘ Bacterial Condition of 132 Pure-Pak paraf-

fined containers from eleven different milk

.. J|0—‘‘Study on the Bocteclobenioal Condition of ©

‘the Paraffin‘ Bath in Pure-Pak Machine’’. : . 1576

. 51—""Bactericidal Property -of Paraffining’’. . ..1578

52—‘‘Contamination of Milk by Pure-Pak-Machine

where practically sterile milk was bottled’*:,.1579 .

. 583—‘‘Number of Bacteria ae in the Pa-

per used for Dairy Products”? ..............1580

. 54—‘‘Bacteriological Condition of Paper Milk .

Containers beford eing)Paraffined’’*....... 1581

. 55—‘‘ Bacterial ae of Milk by the pour- ©

ing lips of Glass ‘Bottles’... 1........... .. 1582.

. 56—‘Number. of Bacteria-on and in Paper for

-Pure- Pak Container Pouring Lip’’........ 1583

—‘‘Bacterial Contamination of Milk by the —

Pouring Lip of Pure-Pak Containers’’...... 1584

. 58—‘ Effect of Paraffining on Bacteria when con-

tainers. were inoculated before Paraffining’’. .1586

No. 59—‘‘Bacterial counts of 50 glass bottles and 50

Pg ee”, gers eer rere ye ere 1587

No. 60—‘‘Bacterial Condition of Adhesives used in

: ~ Pure-Pak Containers” ......-.....- Tiyeiec ae 1588 «

No. 61—Letter Sept. 12, 1939, Fuchs ie... -, .1589

' *Public Health Service Sanitation Advisory

‘Board Action on Single-Service>Contain-

fx. i Ns ccs e Oba swaases cer cewkye ees 1590

No. 62—‘‘Sanitary Aspects of Paper Milk Con- -

ae RT sv gia's Solas tp ass tat atninen agen sn 1591 |

No. 63—‘‘ Are Paper_Milk Containers Sanitary?’’. ..1600

.64—Certificate of Incorporation of Fieldcrest .

Dairies, bt eee 1609

r¥gh # pares 1 to G00; Vol 1 pages 000 to 1e04; Vol. HIE pages 1888 to

1777.

No. 65—Certificate to do business i in Illinois of Field-

7 +2 a

\! ‘oft fa)

v

vi

crest co mis ig besae MEER CELE CLOT TEE OEE 1613

No. 66—Photograph of two trucks containing’ crated

Oe I i i ee ches Praavetees 1619

No. 67—Photograph” of ‘truck containing milk bottle

OD ONE ee Se ee Ree ot 1621 ©

No. 68—Photograph of truck containing milk bottle ©

Ws. ois can Sk oeekeewe oy eee ae

No. 69—Photograph of Blue on Bottle Co. build-

DP ic vawieka fads ale ceva rawness tke ees 1625

No. '70—Photograph of two ‘tac which crates con-

a tnin: wifi bottles. «.: .. ov césccayess ee een 1627.

No. 71—Photograph of truck containing mil&” bottle

; crates with crated bottles in shed in back-

; ground ....... Bihdveus beesecasetaeernee ». -1629

No. 72—Photograph of.. crate with empty milk bottles

Bee ee ere re Nee PPPS re ee tee ra eye 1631

No. 73—Photograph of milk bottle at laboratory with .

oa bs OME ee cease cancees apa geet 1633

No. 74—Photograph of colored man with milk bottle

at junk yard 2048 W. Lake Street ..... tay. 1635

No. 75—Photograph of close-up of bottles i in front of

Gy Se OA Fe i st eae -. 1637

Te ‘76—Photograph of “ucts ‘bettie in = Cen-

SG SE os esate Shgo cadeinkeccdbieees 1639

“No. 77—Photograph of: junk yard employees leading -

empty bottles into a milk dottle Crane 5.5. 1641

..- No. 78—Photograph of milk bottle at County Morgue..1643

No. 79-—Photograph of. ‘pysh cart man “Placing wapty’

ee rer ret eae eee 1645

No. ‘80—Photograph of E. R. Fatst-in front of filled

arate milk bottle crates in junk yard., pe wetness 1647

No. 81—Photograph of man at quarry dump picking )

Ce EPR Serr reverts Petree 1649

Vol. I pages,1 to 608; Vol. I pages G09 to 1294; Vol. III pages 1225 to

777. ~ 9 : cl soo

- No.

No.

- No..

eae

Nox 87—Letter Feb. 7, 1938, -Arnold to Scott........ 1658: -

.No.

%

83—Letter Dec. 17, 1937, Arnold to Scott........ 1651

84—Letter Arnold to Scott...........0...0.00. 1652

85—Letter Nov. 12, 1937, Fuchs to Dean, Jr... .1656

86—letter Nov. 26; 1937; Frank to Dean, Jr. . .. .1657

88—"‘ Arnold’ s suggestions to- Board of Health

BU AG hire vob vise cdedwensessibeseias 1658

No.’ 89—Letter Oct. 6,»1939, Dashiell to Bundesen. . .1661

No.

No.

No.

No.

No.

No.

No.

No.

No.

% No.

_ No.

No.

No:

92—Letter Sept. 16, 1939, Fuchs to Scott........1662

_ Derenpant’s Exuisits. eee

1 and 1B—List of questions by Rall submitted to

Carpenter before his deposition, ete. .......1663 _

1A—Index card containing notes of ‘Cakpenter.; , 1664

2—*Microbiology in pulp and paper manufac-

Pe ee ee pee Tee ep aneny ye Poke neg 1665

7—‘Nymber of bacteria enmeshed in the body

Pe ibe one yds pecs ‘5s 1671

8—Sample receipt stub Board of. Health, Bureau

OF Deity Preagueey . 2.5 05 tgs sscces err .. 1672 -

9—Laboratory card used in bacteriological and ie

chemical examination of milk by. Board of

NGI a ioc hss eevee xe dae eee ieuebeewee 1673

10—Tabulation of bacterial conterit of empty F |

milk bottles examined by Board of —

Sa | Pen ry Rann kee mane OOP ie Spr, Fee 1674

11—Record of bacterial content of empty 1 ‘a

milk bottles examined by Board of Health, etc. 1674

12—Sample as exhibit 11, oe, being tabulation

Pe NI as ys boo ve vac o's anes 1675 “°

‘13—Same as exhibit 11,. ‘but being for 4 quart

- bottles ..... Saas oh Sed ween Ca Kee 1675

14—Same as exhibit 11, but being ~_ 4 pint 3°

I Nero 1 Pa 6c wad ewes nea OE Boke og Chae .1676

15—Tabulation of laboratory record cards show- :

- ing violations but size of ‘bottle unclassified . . 1676

a7¥il F pages 1 to €08; Vol. I pages 600 to 1884; Yol TIT pages 1008 to

_s

a —

.

° No. 16—Seetion 10, U. S. Public Health avigs stand-

‘-ard niftk ordinance .............0....0008. 1677

-No: 17—Copy of section 10, of Publie Health Serv-

ee: ice milk ordinance as amended June, 1939. ..1678

* No. 18—Tabulation of samples of empty milk bottles

a and. results of bacteriological ‘examination,

an, ee es ee eS reeds 1679

“ No. 19—Tabuiation’ showing results of parelle experi:

, * ments Pere eee eee reer, See Terre ee 1687

No. 20—Report of tests using wet ‘and*dry plaques

after being run through paraffin bath, etc. ..1689 _

ie 21—Result of tests as:in exhibit 20, but experi-

ments conducted at later time’.......... Fees ae

No. 22—Letter January 13, 1936, Dean Milk Co. to—

_ Bundesen ..... S Om opie rere rere

No. 23—Letter August 2, 1938, — Corp..to

WN oo ivi s en habedeae sacs Pe |

No. 25—-Regulation adopted Angast 6, 1935 concern-

;, ing type of milk and cream to be used in man-.

ufacture of butter, ete. ..... Save ee css nuns ee

No. 26—Regulation adopted Nov. 12, 1935, requiring

: that milk and milk products be served and

dispensed to’ consumer in original unopened |

container as received from distributor... ..1697

No. 27—Resolution adopted July 18, 1939, as to use of

standard nutrient, agar, prescribed in 6th

. edition of American Public Health. Associa-

tion ‘Standard Methods of*Milk Analysis’’.1697 _

No. 29—Resolution presented to Board of Health Oct.

16, 1939 with respect to puacuariian con-

tainers for milk ...........ctccsegeeees - ++ 1698 ©

| No. 30—Letter June 27, 1939, Ranan to Bundegen... .1705

No. 31—Excerpts from minutes of- ‘Board of Health

- meeting May 15, 1939....... a Sbeeiae nwa ness 1705 .

Vol. ¥ pagve 1 to 008) Vol 1 pages 000 to 18M; Vol HIE pages 1006 to

ivv7?. :

a

’ ix ; ; é ‘ Si

Ckiddice. to depuitiiaine’ filed brit 27, 1940........1709

Master’s report filed April 27, 1940................ 1710

- Notice of objections filed May 7, 1940...... eae Cea 1737

_ Objections to Master’s report filed May 7, 1940..... 1738

Notice of motion filed May 14, 1900.25... ATO

Motion for decree filed May 14, 1940...... foeuae ot 1751

Order continuing motion for- entry. decree entered ‘

| Bs SOO cv citnnn oe ORs vcdceetsetacs ce eateeny 1752

Memorandum: filed October 18, eee ae ...1752

Findings of fact filed October 23, 1940............. 1756

Conclusions of law filed October 23, 1940............ 1758

‘Decree-entered October 23, 1940...0.......... eres

Master’s ‘certificate filed October 23, 1940.:........1761 .

Notice of appeal filed October’ 23, 1940.......... \.. 1762,

Statement of points filed November 15, 1940.:..... .1763 ©

Clerk’s certificate of service: ...........6.ccc ee eee 1765. -

| Appellant’s designation for short record fia hab onus 1766

CET PURE EPC ETTECLTT CLE RT ET ETT CS 1767

-. _ Notice of-motion ............... Ee Pee AT eS es eo | Sale

Motion for stay of decree filed October 24, 1940....:. 1770

-Order denying stay of decree filed October 24, 1940...1771

Designation of record.............+-s6seeeeeeeeees .1772

Order re filing transcript... 2......... ecene ie sacea 1774

-Stipulation as to exhibits............. ae eka 1774

SO Se II oi ee Sip keekswsknsninnasainnny 1775

Clerk’s certificate ..........+..... Seep csees ere 1776.

Stipulation as to printing .. Petra teeeeeeedti athe kas 1777 ©

“Est pages 3 wo oes Vol Ht pases 000 fo Sa04i Vol KI peawe 1A08 to

>

“F

Testimony of Robert A. Black. = = 1225

ROBERT A. BLACK, called as a witness on behalf of

pag’ iow: having been first duly" sworn, testified

» as OLLOWS :

on pears by Mr. Slade:

Will you state your nanie, ‘aie, Doctor?

Q.

A. Robert A. Black.

Q. d where do you live, sir?

A. Prado Hotél.

Q. And your occupation is what?

&@. Ph n, pediptrician.

Q. When w u licensed to practice medicine in

Q. : What educational institutions dia you attend,

: Doctor? :

A. Washington Academy, Iowa State Normal, Soon

Fr University and Northwestern University.

Q. Are you affiliated with any medical societies? .

A: Chicago Medical Society, Chicago Pédiatric.Society,

Chicago Institute of Medicine, American College of Physi-:

are the Ameri As ademy of Pediatricians, the A.

-Q, - “That is the

A. Yes.

7 Q. At the present time, doctor, are you connected with

any educational institution?

'. A. Loyola University.

Q. In what capacity?

- A... Presumably the head of the department of “Pedia-

trics, although I am still on leave, though still teaching.

Q.. Are there any other educational institutions that

you are now connected with, Doctor? —

A. No other educational. . ,

Q. What is the nature of your practice, Doctor?

A. Children, entirely.

Q. Are you connected with the Board of Health of the

__ City of Chicago?

2008 A. Yes, sir.

Q. In what: capacity are you samneaied with the

Board of Health of the City of Chicago?

A. As a member. |

Q. Have you served in, any other capacity? 4

Re aa

Te can Medical Association?

1226 Transcript of Testimony Before Master. |

A. I was acting president from some time in the latter

& of November until some time in the latter: part of

q. aoe of 1938 and May of 19397

es

Q. During th e you- have been connected with the

Board of Health\gf the City of Chicago — you had

occasion to consider the matter of the use of paper con-

tainers for the distribution of fresh fluid milk in the city!

A. Yes, sir.

~-Q. When did that matter first come to your attention,

Doctor, as nearly as you can remember? =

A. Some time in the last part - -of December or the -

early part of January. -

Q. Of what year?

A. Either December of 1938 or January of 1939, in

the very last or the gg | beginning. is

Q. ‘In your opinion, Doctor, is milk an ebeential item

in the diet of infants?

2009 <A. Yes, sir. ;

+ In your opinion is milk an essential item in the

: diet of children? ; .

A. Yes, sir.

Based on your experience as a member of the Board har

of Health and as a pediatrician, do you have any opinion |

as to the quantity of. fresh fluid milk consumed by chil-

dren under the age of twelve years in the city of Chicago?

A. I would not make an authoritative statement, but

I think it would be around 50 per cent.

Q. From the point of view of the health of infants, Doce-

tor, and as a nediatrician, what is your opinion as to

the relative merit and demerit of milk containing no par-

~ affin as contrasted with milk which contains undissolved .

paraffin in quantities varying from one milligram to one

hundred and seven milligrams per quart?

A. I know of no work done on that. I know of nothing

or no proof from either side. I would prefer my milk —

not: adulterated with paraffin. ey F

Q. You mean, as pediatrician?

A. Asa pediatzician, yes. —.

Q. “Doctor, assuming that as a pediatrician you are at-

tending an infant that is suffering from infant diar-

"2010 rhea or from some other diseased condition of the

. stomach or intestines, in the event that vou learned

that that child was being fed milk which contained undis-

os Testimony of Robert A. Black. . 1227

solved paraffin in quantities varying from one milligram

- per quart to one baaivel and seven niilligrams per quart,

what, if anything, would you dof

A. In milligrams it is hard to translate, but. I would

have a very strong feeling that if the paraffin was flaky

or anything of that sort, I would not use it. — —--

. The paraffin is undissolved. |

A. If the paraffin is undissolved, in flakes, I vould not

ase it.

. Q. And in the event that you found that it’ was ue

-ased, what would you do?

_ A. I would discontinue it. S

oS war.” > |

A. . After you handle babies awhile you aveid every

appearance of evil, even. Ifyou know it is not particu-.

‘larly harmful, or if you have no thought that it is par-

ticularly harmful, you are going to.*avoid any chance

whatever, ‘anyway.

Mr. Schaefer: That is all.

Cross-Examination by Mr. Gariepy. ..

. Doctor, do you know any cases of record where

.2011 babies have been afflicted with any disease of the

intestinal tract and that the disease has been aggra- -

vated by reason of undissolved paraffin in milk?.

<

A. I made the statment that I did not know the amount.

Q. This is Just your surmise, offhand.

Q jays .

.: As a pediatrician?

or ay |

-:.Q. When a baby gets mijk, ‘it gets the milk warm,

doesn’t it? gy

oe

Q. And to what iemperature is the milk warmed?

A. It. would be around 98 to 100. |

Q. And when would that paraffin melt that Mr. Schaefer

asked you about, as being in flaky. quantities?

- -A.. T could not’ay, but I think around 120.

Q. And when you feed this milk to the baby you do

not feed it right out of the cup or the bottle, do you?

You feed it through some receptacle, don’t you?

A. It depends on the ‘age of the baby...

. We are talking now avout babies one year old or

under, Doctor.

©

1228 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

% A. You feed them through the bottle.

. ° Q.. You feed them through a bottle?

2012 . A. Yes.

Q. And when Po ou feed them —— the bottle

ie oven a nipple on the bottle. ect

“And is that paraffin so big, that you have 2 in : ied .

that it would not go through the hole of’ the nipple?

‘A. That is what I said; it was flaky.

- Q. Did you ever hear or see any flaky. particle’ of par- ‘&

affin in a bottle of milk that was fed to a baby that did

not go through the n od te

A. Ihave never fed, to the best of my knowledge, milk

to a baby out of a paper bottle. .

Q. Or out-of any bottle that had arc in it?

A. Sé far as I know.

‘ Q. You do not know of any cases of record has they’

- did that, do you?

0. No, fin rt ot?

. Paraffin is an inert matter, is it no

A.- So far as. I know. a

Q. Wh it made out of chemically, Doctor?

‘ma met de of—well, it is a ‘by-product: of oil.

Q. And sometimes children are given oil to secure ac-

' tion in the intestinal tract, are they not?

A. They are.

Q. That does- not give them any bad effects,

does it?

2013 A. There is a little dispute just now about that.

There is some ‘recent, literature which seems to show

that pape C is not absorbed well where the paraffin oil

is us

Do you know what the customary treatment is in.

Cook County Hospital now, in post operative cases, i

reine to secure a bowel treatment easily and without dis. 7

tress ) 7

' A. Ido not. j 7

Q. Do you know whether they give any oil treatments

vat = there? : ;

I give the oil myself.

es 0: And did you ever ‘have any harmful effects. from

— Aoing it?

A. Not that I know of. I am only saying what ‘the

recent literature is oe.

~~ in answering Mr. Schaefer’s question, then, I take it, would _

/

Testimony of Robert A. Black. 1229

needle is used to puncture the hole with. .._.________

Q. And the paraffin that you refer to jn your opinion,

have to be A big as the end of a needle or large, is that sa

’A. Yes.

2014 Q. And you do not know of any cases of that size

doing injury, do you? |

A. I know of no cases because I have. not used it.

Mr. Gariepy: That is all, Doctor. Just a minute, one

more question, please. |

Q. If the paraffin was of a size sufficient ‘to do any

harm, then it would be too large to go. throngh the hole

_of the nipple, wouldn’t it? ke

A. Well, I would not say just that. If for no other

reason, you would be terribly annoyed by/having to take

affin.

Q. But you have had no experiencoin it?

A. I have had no experience in it.

_Q. And have you ever read of wack such experience,

° Doctor, in pediatrics?

_ A.» No, sir.

Mr. wicca ach That, is all. - i

Redirect Beamination y Mr. \aehacter

“— through a — nr

- Yes,'sir. y are gava

Q. What is that?

' A. Fed through a stomach tube.

Q. Doctor, are babies ever fed milk by - method slline 4

2015 Q. At what age do infaits usually start drinking

milk out of glasses, Doctor?

A. Any time from four months on. Usually: the mother ~

stries in about five and a half or six months. -

Q. Doctor, if an infant five and:a half to six months old

was suffering from infant diarrhea, the nipple which you

_ have alluded to in answering Mr. Gariepy’s question would”

_ afford no protection in keeping paraffin from entering the

intestinal tract of the baby, would it?

' A: It would/not.; -

Mr. Schaefer: That is all

Q. How big is this hole usually eupio ed in these .

nipples or made in these nipples used on baby bottles?

A. .It is quite small. Ordinarily it is said the average

: the nipple off, and contaminate it, and shake, out the ei

1230. - Transcrigt of Testimony Before Master. ‘

‘Recross ineenineiion ty Mr. Gariepy.

‘Doctor, have you made any in quiry of pediatricians i

or health commissioners where single service containers

are in use for the distribution of fresh fluid milk in regard

to their experience jn irritating the tender, qonatite tracts

of babies?.~ |

A. I have not.

Or these babies: that Mr. Schaefer referred 5 of

_ four and a half or five months old? - : ;

A. I have not.

Q. Or (igs | children up to twelve years lat

have not..

2016 Mr. Gariepy: That is all. et

__-_ Mr. Schaefer: That is all, Doctor. Thank you. °

(Witness excused.) n

Mr. Schaefer: Doctor Dulak.

_ Oe

FRANCIS: A. DULAK, called as a witness on behalf. of

the . defendants, having been first duly sworn, testified 7

as follows : |

Direct Examination re Mr. Schaefer.

State your name, doctor. ©

Francis A. Dulak.

Where do you live, doctor?

2050 Huinboldt Boulevard, Chicago.

And your occupation?

_ Physician and surgeon.

—When .were you licensed to practice medicine?

In 1916. |

Q. Where did you receive your education, if any,

doctor?

A. Loyalo University and the Dniversity’ of Viewna:

. Are you connected with the Board of Health of the

City of Chicago?

A. Yes, sir. .

mn Q. In what capacity, doctor?

-2017° A. At the present time I gn secretary of the

- Board of Health.

.Q. For how long, have you been connected with =

Board of Health?

pre >rOPopro

Testimony of Franc A. Duta 1231

A. Seven years.

As a member of ‘the Board of Health of the . City

‘of © icago have you had occasion to consider the question

. of the use of papey containers for the distribution of fresh

. fluid milk in the city?

. Yes, sir.- :

- Q. Wher did that matter first come ra your attention?

A. . Why, it is some time ago. I do not remember ex-

actly the date.

he What personal knowledge, if any, doctor, do you

have of the operation of paper mills? .

None whatever. :

Q. Which manufacture paper board for use in paper

milk containers? ,

A. None. - t

Q. Do you have any personal knoeienes of the op-

‘eration of any paper mills? :

‘A. Thave not.

. What personal knowledge, if any, do. you have of

the operation of plants in which paper board for. use in

milk@containers is cut end printed?

2018, ' A. None whatever.

. What personal knowledge do you have, if any,

as to the bacterial effect of paraffin on paper?

A. Ihave none at all: I don’t know much about = :.

.* Q. Doctor, have you any personal opinion as to whether

or not the use of paper containers for the distribution of

fresh fluid milk-should be permitted in the city of Chicago? —

_ Mr. Gariepy: I object to that question, as showing no-

qualifications or ability or knowledge on the part of this

witness to answer that” question intelligently.

. -The Master: I will sustain the objection. He has voted

as a member of the Board of Health. That is official action.

You are now. calling: him to impeach his own vote?

Mr. Schaefer: No, sir, I am not. You expressed some

concern as to why these witnesses were called. —

The Master: Not concern. Just interest.

Mr. Schaefer: Then interest. Let me ‘explain my posi-

| tion, if you will, Master.

What is involved i in this case, as I see it, is the reason-

ableness of an.ordinance of the City of Chicago. Going to

that question, you have been hearing evidente over an ex-

tended period, introduced on behalf of\the plaintiff.

2019 tending or intended: to show the unreasonableness of

that ordinance, and evidence introduced on behalf of

1232 , Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

. the iia cuittes or intended to show the réasonable- -

ness of that ordinance..

The Master: No, I don’t think that is stating the issue

- quite accurately. As I recall the pleadings, there are two

‘points here. First, that the ordinance should be const

- as broad enough to include within the term of Piss ae

milk bottle’’ paper containers. |

Mr. Schaefer: That is right.

The Master: And, secondly, if ‘the ordinance is inter-

preted so as to exclude the single service container, then

_ the ordinance or the acti on of the Board of Health there-

under is arbitrary. and¥discriminatory and unreasonable.

Mr. Schaefer: That is right, yes, sir. It is.to the second

point.that I-was addressing myself, as obviously this testi-

mony has not to do with the first point.

The Master: You are talking about the ordinance. No-

body ‘+has introduced.any evidence here as to the resolution

of the Board of Health, until you just brought it in here this

afternoon, and the Board of Health, up to this time,.in its’

answer at least, made the contention, or made a double ©

* 2020 contention, namely, first, that the ordinance, properly

construed, excluded the single service container, and,

secondly,. that the allegations of the bill of complaint, to”

the effect that the containers are safe and free from any

objection, are not well taken; in other words, you deny all

of their allegations as to safety.

Be a Schaefer: And we assert the ordinance is reason-

e

The Master: All right. -Now then, you bring in the reso-

lution of the Roard of Health, which is a recommendation to

the City Council to amend the ordinance to include the

_ Single service containers specifically. >

- Mr. Schaefer: Yes, sir.

The Master: It is to be assumed that unless they neal

the containers were Safe, they would not make any such

recommendation, so that, if anything, the resolution tends

to establish the contention of the plaintiff here, that there

is no objection to the containers on the ground that they

are unsafe or anhealthful.

Now, you come in here with witnesses from the Board of

Health. I do not know what their purpose’is. You started

* out, by putting them on as witnesses im chief, as just

202i further experts. The case was reopened here to give

you an rapperany to. ae in some evidence concern-

~~

5*

~ we 7

. ba

ee oo es

4 ‘ 4 . >

“<< Colloquy. ee

| % |

ing the resolution. Counsel here have not objected to yout

putting on further evidence of experts, and I have permitted ©

you to do it. Now, you come along with a witness and ask

him whether he has any opinion as to whether the use of

’ paper containers for the distribution of fresh fluid milk is

safe. He ‘ha’ expressed’ himself by his vote on this resoly-

tion. tS

Mr. Schaefer: If I may state my position, it is this: .

Throughout this trial every time that an expression of opin-

ion with respect to the subject matter in issue here has

been made from a new source, from a source that was not

heretofore before you, we have attempted to bring it in and

- have brought it in. For example, the United States adopt-.

. ing these regulations, we brought that matter out on cross-

examination. If this matter occurred before we closed our

proof, we would have brought it in then.” What you have

here:now is the action of the Board of Heakh at its meet-

ing on October 16th, as an expression of opinion by a group

not heretofore heard from. . | Ste.

.The Master: But they are. defendants in this case,

against whose action complaint is made. ; .

Mr. Gariepy: That is right. — oie |

2022 The Master: Who in their answer statéd that they _

thought the containers were unsafe and who, it will

be.argued, by their action in passing a resolution are now

on record as thinking they are all right, excepting ‘that the

ordinance does not permit the use of such containers and

. therefore they recommend an amendment to the ordinance

to include such containers. You bring in the resolution

of the Board of Health, which impliedly says that. now the

-Board of Health considers those containers as unobjection--

able, but not permitted to be used by reason of the language

of the ordinance. Now; the evidence here produced by your -

‘witness is that all of the members of the Board of Health

‘voted for this resolution, excepting Doctor Arnold, who -

was present and did not vote either way. What is the pur-

pose of bringing in this witness now, to impeach this reso-

lution? ae ¥ Sa SPE

Mr. Schaefer: No, sir, I have not attempted to do that

at any time. : as,

Mr. Gariepy: He has spoken by being a party to the =

.. resolution“and a member of the Board. ~~ naan

Mr. Schaefer: May I proceed, Master? 7

The Master: Yes.

1234 Transcript of Testimony Before Master. ,

Mr. Schaefer: You have here an expression of

2023 opinion, ; as I said, as to a matter in controversy, by a

group not heretofore heard from. Their opinion is

entitled to such weight as it gets by reason of their knowl-

edge of this subject and no further, so far as the validity or

reasonableness of the ordinance’ is concerned. : :

The Master: Now, let us see. You are representing

whom heré? an

’ Mr. Schaefer: All of the defendants in this case.

The Master: You are representing the Board of Health?

‘ Mr. Schaefer:. And the City of Chicago:

The Master: And the Board of Health has stated that .

it considers the use of the single service container as ob-

jéctionable. That is, in its answer. Now the Board of -

Health states that it thinks it is unobjectionable and recom-

. mends that the ordinance permit its use. That is, just some

of the defendants. Do you object to the use of that-opinion ©

as against the City of Chicago, which is also a defendant?

' Mr. Schaefer: I do not object to the use of it. I want

to show-ou what it i is based, that is all. It is like any other

opinion. |

The Master:.- In other words, you want to attack

2024 the weight—

Mr. Schaefer: I am ot attacking ‘anything. I: am

‘just bringing the facts before you, so that you can give — :

proper weight to that opinion.

‘The Master: In other words, you want me to give it as

little weight as possible?

Mr. Schaefer: Well, if pressed, I suppose I would state

that. It seems to me that the knowledge of the men who

have expressed an opinion is pertinent in determining what

weight to give to that opinion.

The Master: Well, personally, I cannot see how you,

_ representing thé Board of Health, 3 which has filed an answer

here stating that the single service containers are unsafe,

can let the Board of Health come in and express an opin-

ion, based upon the opinion of, the United States ‘—

“Health Service, that they- are safe.

Mr. Schaefer: If that is what it is based on, that is

what I want to show. ‘I want to show on what that opinion

is based, and I submit I have a right to do that. Now, so

*far as our putting it in or the-plaintiff putting it in, 1

have no illusion as to-whether or not it should have gone

into evidence.

nr

¢

Colloguy.- ~~. a)

‘ The Master: They probably would have. brought it in

themselves. | a

2025 Mr. Schaefer: I think so, but it is an opinion as to

__one of the issues in-this case, and I think you are en-

titled to know on what it is based...

‘The Master: It is something occurring after the suit,

but in the course of trial, in which the defendants, the Board

of Health, have apparently changed their opinion or have

changed their position on this subject of safety, That is

something that the plaintiff might bring in to.show the pres-

ent opinion of the Board of Health. Then the only question

remaining if this case, if that action is to be taken as-con-

clusive on the part of the Board of Health, would be whether

the ordinance is to be considered as discriminatory and-un-

reasonable because it excludes containers, which the Board

of Health says are safe. ' aes |

Mr. Schaefer: That is right.

The Master: Now, if you were representing only the ~

Board of Health, I doubt whether you could come in here

and say that the. Board of Health’s action is not to be given

. full weight, which the plaintiff would contend for. But you

_ come in and say that you also represent the City of Chi-

7 Mr. Schaefer: Yes, sir. As a matter of-fact, I submit

_ * that the relation between the clients that we here rep-

2026 resent and ourselves as their counsel is a matter lying

between the defendants and their counsel. No defend-

ant has. objected. It seems to me no one else has any right

to. Here is opinion evidence, and I want to show you on

what that opinion is based. I want to find out and I want

~* you to know. It is a factor which obviously you are going ©

to consider in deciding this case. = \

The Master: In other. words, if the Board of Health

asks the City Council to pass an ordinance in which the

Board of Health says it is safe, I must in this trial before

me, in which the Board of Health has said that it is unsafe,

tell the Board of Health they are wrong about it, after they

solemnly say they think that the container is safe.

Mr. Schaefer: No, sir, that is not what Iam saying. As

a matter of fact, the inclusion ofthe individual members

of the Board-of Health as defendants is a matter of law and

is not necessarily involved. What is involved: is an ordi-

nance. The ordinance can be attacked without individual

defendants. The fact they are individual defendants here

é

- 1236 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

is just because ‘the plaintiff so framed its case. The es-.

sential question ‘is still the) same, the reasonableness

2027 of that ordinance, and I submit that you ought to hear.

opinion evidence as it is advanced on that question.

Mr. Gariepy: We object to hearing any opinion evi-

dence, Master, when an official action, of the. Board is

If he attempted to impeach their action for fraud or any-

thing else, that is another question, but the counsel is.

bound, as is-the City of Chicago, by the action of the -

defendants as to the merits of this litigation. It is always —

+f brought in by the defendants, as shown by Mr. Schaefer. ~

the rule that they are bound by such action. It is not a-

‘matter of opinion evidence. It is an official action of the’

- Board, passed by resolution, where all of the members were

present = took a part, in voting for it, with Doctor Arnold

— so

5 te You put your question again now, Mr.

Schester.

. Mr. Schaefer: Q. Doctor Dulak, do you have anv: per-

sonal opinion as to whether or not, from the point of view

-of the public health, the use of paper containers for the

- distribution of milk in the city of Chicago — or should

not be permitted?

Mr. yay DP I object to that anestion.” —-

i * oe ter: You object on the ground that there i is

2028 no qualification shown?

‘- « -Mr.Gariepy: That is one of the grounds on which:

I object, and also that the doctor has already expressed

himself as a member of the Board of Health by officially

voting on the matter. .

The Master: ‘Your first objection is that he is nat! or

fied. I will sustain the objection, and in order to shorten’

it I. will let you make your record, Mr. Schaefer.

_ Mr. Schaefer: I haven’t any record to make. a cannot

make an offer of proof. os

‘That is all, Doctor.

“Mr. Gariepy : That is all, aaa

vd

‘The Master: Ask your quection: and put it in the record, :

if you wish.

- Mr. Schaefer: No, I do not care to. — |

The Master: I am offering to let you ask the question

of the doctor, if you wish, and have it in the record.

Mr. Schaefer:. Yes, sir.

oe

3)

V

' Pestiniony of Harr oH J. Reynolas. 1237

that?

Mr. Schaefer: No, sir. ° a

The Master: Very well.

(Witness excused.) : &

2029 Mr. Schaefer: Mr. Reynolds. ,

The Master: You do not care to put him on then, for

HARRY : REYN OLDS, called as a witness: on behalf of

. the defendants, having ‘been first -duly sworn, testified as

follows :

Direct Ecamination by Mr. Schaefer.

Q. Will you state your name, please!

A. Harry J. Reynolds.

Q. Where do you live, Mr. Reynolds?

A: 3240 Lake Shore Drive.

Q.

ty

A.

Are you a member of the Board ‘of Health of the

‘City of Chicago? -

I'am.

—Q. For how long have you been a | member? |

A. Six years.

Q. _What personal knowledge, if any, have you,.Mr.

Reynolds, as to-the operation of paper mills which manu-

-. facture board for use in paper milk containers?

_ Mr. Gariépy: I object. There have been no qualifica-

tions shown on which this witness could answer.

' Mr. Schaefer: That is just the reason for the question.

~The Master: Overruled.

_ Mr. Schaefer: Read the question, Mr. Golding.

2030 ° (Mr. Schaefer’s last question was read by the re-

porter as above recorded.) Re cette

The Witness: I have none.

Mr. Schaefer: Q. And what personal knowledge, if

any, have you, Mr. Reynolds, as to the eperation of plants

in which paper board to be used in — milk containers

is cut, formed and printed?

A. -I have none. | | ,

Q. What personal knowledge, if any, have you with

“respect to. the bactericidal action of hot paraffin upon

paper?

A: Will you iiet that question?

Mr. esata Read it, Mr. Golding.

‘a

1238 . Transcript of Testimony Before Master. |

_ (Mr. Schaefer’s last question was read by the —

as above recorded. ).

The Witness: A. I have none.

Mr. Schaefer: Q. What personal senate have you,

if any, with respect to the filling of paper milk containers

ae with milk?

The Master: What is that?

Mr. Schaefer: Filling them with milk.

The Witness: A. I have none.

Mr. Schaefer: Q. Do you attach ‘any public neater

| significance, Mr..Reynolds, to the fact that paper milk

tainers are uniformly absorbent?

2031 .Mr. Gariepy: I object to that question. er

has been no showing on the part of this witness that

he knows or that he is qualified to answer that question as

a public health expert:

he Master: Read the question..

(Mr. Schaefer’s last question was read by the reporter

as above recorded.)

Mr. Gariepy: I object to that question, Master. Itisa

subterfuge and attempt to impeach the official action of this

officer and this member of the Board of Health, and there

is no qualification shown on which he — answer that

question intelligently at all.

The Master: Q. Do you know whethin they | are ab- |

sorbent or not?

A.. Well, I can qualify that in this respect: That after

having numerous discussions with the members of the .

~Board of Health at the various meetings, namely, hearing

al

Doctor Black, Doctor Bundesen, Doctor Dulak and Doctor’ -

Artiold, who I consider an outstanding bacteriologist, and

having iit explained to me by him on these occasions, I think

the paper is. absorbent.

Mr. Gariepy: I move to strike that, Master. His opinion

is based on what he heard from somebody else and not of

his own knowledge,. ability or research. .

The Master: Yes, that may be stricken.

2032 ~Q. You know nothing outside of what somebody

else has told you?

A. No. Only after seeing a lot of samples that were

té&ted by Doctor Arnold, it proved to me from a layman’s

standpoint that they were absorbent.

Q. You never. performed any experiments yourself?

A. None whatever.

. © 4

Testimony of Harry J. Reynolds. 1239

The Master: What is Mr. Schaefer’ s question again,

-Mr. Reporter?

(Mr. Schaefer’s question was read by the reporter as

follows: ‘‘Do yon attach any public health significance,

_ Mr. Reynolds, to the fact that Paper milk containers are

uniformly absorbent ?’’)

The Master: I will let him answer. ay

Do you attach any significance to it?

. Yes, I do. 5

Mr: Schaefer: Q. What significance do you attach to

the fact that paper containers are absorbent?

Mr. Gariepy: I am making the’same objection, Master,

to that question. - He is attempting by subterfuge, by ask-

ing this witness questions, to impeach his action as a mem-

ber of the Board of Health in recommending the use of

single service containers. It is quite artful and astute

_. 2033 on the part of counsel, but I thin‘ it is very obvious

- to the Master. )

The Master: If they are absorbent to a considerable

degree, I think it is conceded that there is some health

Be ny et is it not?”

. Mr. Gariepy: Yes, >but he has already gone on record,

by Exhibit 29, in saying the ordinance should permit their

‘use, and he cannot impeach his own action.

- The Master: That is another question. I think it. is

“agreed here that if paper ‘board containers are absorbent,

there is somésignificance to it. -

Mr. Gariepy >. . There cannot be any public health sig-

. nificance that means anything, otherwise _ would not

have passed a resolution ai

- The Master: | He says he does regard it ‘as significant.

‘Q. Now, you‘Have said that you regard it as of some

public health significance? ay

A. Yes. —

Q. ‘Do you have any teeksisioal eta as to in what

respect and what effect it may have? :

A. Well— - &

Q. Let me put it this way: Do you leks any technical :

pr pc concerning the e oat of the absorbing qualities

ns Gans milk containers ?.

Only that the United States Public Health Service

also ioien that they aré absorbent.

2034 - Q. I say, do you have any technical knowledge on

-¢ . the subject as to the effect on ‘the public health?

Am

1240 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

A. Only what I have been told by the Seton or mem--

bers. of the Board.

Mr. Schaefer: That is not my question. That questien

assumes that technical knowledge is necessary to dete!

"mine whether or not there is public health significance in _

the fact a milk container is absorbent. That I submit is a

matter that does not require any technical knowledge to.

_answer. Some of the other questions may, but that ques-

tion does not.

The Master: He has stated whatever he. knows about the

subject is based upon somebody’s else statements to him.

I think it is conceded here that if paper board containers

are absorbent, it is a question of public health significance.

Now then you proceed to ask him in what respect.

Mr. Schaefer: Yes, sir.

The Master: How can he now 3 in what respect?

_ sMreSchaefer: Let us sée whether he can answer that.

The Master: He stated he has no knowledge of the sub-

ject.

Mr. Sehasler: He stated in answer to-your question that ;

he had no technical knowledge.

2035. The Master: Yes.

___-Mr.-Schaefer: That, is a question for whith tech-

nical knowledge i is not necessary.

The Master: Let us see now. -

Q. Do you have any knowledge of any kind upon that

subject, of your own?

A. Only that if it is absorbent and milk is put into

the- paper centainer, the milk naturally will absorb any |

ingredients or bacteria that may. be in the paper.

Q. That is the extent of your knowledge on the subject?

A. (Witness nods affirmativ ely.)

Mr. Gariepy: The witness is shaking his head, ee

_ Reporter, yes. |

‘ . The Master: Anything further?

Mr. Schaefer: Q. Do you attach any public. health

significance to the fact that paraffin gets into’ the milk

which is placed in paraffined paper milk containers?

“Mr. Gariepy: I object to that question. It is an assump- -

tion on the part of counsel that it does. If this witness-~

is not qualified to answer from a public health a

‘then he should not*be permitted to answer.

The Master: Q. What is your business?

Colloquy. . | . 39a |

2036 A. What is my line of business? ,

_Q. Yes. I notice he called you Mr. Reynolds. 1.

don’t know whether he asked you your occupation.

A. Iam the layman member ofthe Board of Health. I

am president of the Independent Boiler and Tank Company.

The Master: How is this witness qualified to give an

opinion on the subject of the effect of paraffin?

* Mr. Schaefer: Here again I say it does not require any _

technical knowledge, bacteriological, medical or otherwise. _

Mr. Gariepy: Then you can ask a layman about it,

Master. ~ , ae ee 3 :

- The Master:. Yes. #§£#-- oe ie

Mr. Schaefer: That is what I am doing. ;

Mr. Gariepy: Then the Master takes notice of it as a

matter of common knowledge.’

’ . Mr. Schaefer: That is all, Mr. Reynolds.

Mr. Gariepy: That is all.

(Witness excused.) : | eee

The Master: Off the record.

_ (Disevission had off the record.) |

- Mr..Schaefer: I offer in evidence Defendants’ Exhibits

29 and 30. !

. The Master: What arethey? —_.

2037 . Mr. Schaefer: Defendants’ Exhibit 29 is a copy

__of a resolution adopted by the Board of Health of

the Cit} of Chicago on October 16th, 1939; with respect to

_ single service containers for milk, consisting of seven

pages, ;

Defendants’ Exhibit 30 is a photostatic copy of a letter

from Thomas Parran, Surgeon-General of the United

States of America, addressed to Doctor Herman N. Bun-

. desen, dated June 27th, 1939, received by the Board of

- Health July 5; 1939, transmitting to Doctor Bundesen

_ copies of the regulations adopted by the United States

Public Health Service with respect to paper containers.

That consists of three sheets. . ; seo at Paine

of agreement of counsel, the last two pages of the De-

fen ants’ Exhibit 30 are withdrawn,,because they are

identical with the last two pages of Plaintiff’s Exhibit 61.

The Master: Defendants’ Exhibits 29 and 30 may be

“(Said be st seni

id documents, being copy of resolution adopted by -

Board of Health, October 16, 1939 with respect “4 stiglo

service containers, and a photostatic copy of letter from

”

f

2

1242 Transcript of Testimony Before- Master.

Thomas Parran to Doctor Bundesen, dated June 27,

2038 1939, were received in evidence and marked respee

tively DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBITS 29 and 30, and

are attached hereto and made a part of the record hereof.) ry

Mr. Schaefer: That is-all, sir. We close now. .

Mr. Gariepy: We have Thureday, I understand, for |

_ our rebuttal?

The Master: Yes. ‘Let the vend show that this hear-

. ing will-be resumed at 10:00 o’clock A. M. on next Thurs-

day..

(Whereupon an adjournment was taken in the above en-

titled cause to 10:00 0 ’clock A. M., Thursday, October 26,

_ ) 7

Eoerwra of David J. Davis. | 3043

2039 ee oe (Caption) °

Thifrsday, October 26, 1939, .

10:00 o’clock a. m.

Met, pursiant to adjournment. —

Present: °

Mr. Gariepy, Mr. Rall, on behalf of plaintiff.

Mr. Schaefer, Mr. Horan, on behalf of defendants.

2040 Mr. Gariepy: Swear the witness please, Master.

“DAVID J. DAVIS, enlied an 0 wiknnes on teal of the

plaintiff, in rebuttal, — been first duly sworn, testi-

fied as follows:

Direct Sissies by Mr. ‘Gariepy.

‘ Q. State your name, please.

A. David J. Davis. 4

Q. And _ address, residence.

A. 721 Elmwood avenue, Wilmette.

Q. What is your business or occupation?

_ A. Dean of the College of Medicine, University of Illi-

nois.

Q. And hew long have you been such ?

A. Fifteen years.

Q. Is Doster Lloyd Arnold.one of the professors at the

University of Illinois, under your jurisdiction?

pe

Yes

Q. I iaiesiened you té produce the contract of employ-

ment between the University of Illinois and Doctor Lloyd

Arnold concerning his services there.

oA. Yes. Al road

Q. a = ‘that ith you?

. 2041 ny Will you. uce it, please! |

A. Yes (han ing document to Mr. Gariepy).

Mr. Gariepy: Mr. Golding, will you mark that Piain-

-tiff’s Exhibit 20 for identification? - . 7

(The document Yeferred .to was thereupon-.marked —

Plaintiff’s areas No. 90 for eenention.)

' ” 1711, to be exact, that he had a

ye

1244 ‘Transcript of Testimony Before Master. .

— Gariepy: Doctor, showing you Pluintiff’s Ex-

hibit No: 90 for i entification; which 4g just handed to

me, a blue piece of paper dated July 1939, is thatthe.

resent existing contract of the University of Illinois with

Bestes Lloyd ;Arnold for his professional services as a

professor and ember of the staff ? j

A. Yes.

. Q. Is there any other. contrast with Doctor Arnold con-.

‘cerning his services and the time he is to put in at the —

. University and the time outside? —

A. No.

. That is all?

—That is = a

Mr. Garie ‘I offer that in evidence, counsel. as

PLAINTIF % ‘EXHIBIT 90. -

Mr. Schaefer: The only objection to that is as to the

"a We are running up a record here. I do not

t Doctor Arnold’s contract with the University

2042 is pertinent. I do not have any feeling ®ne way or

the other, if. P ap want to let it in.

Mr. Gariepy : answer to that is that this is compe--

tent. - Doctor | Arnold 4: in the record, Page

act with the Board of

Trustees of the ‘University of IlMefois for 80 per cent of

his time.

_ Mr. Schaefer: That is what I say. If you want to put

‘it in, O. K.; I don’t care. To save time, I will withdraw

the objection. :

Mt. Gariepy: No, we withdraw the offer, ther’

- Q. Is there any other contract that you have with Doe- 4

os —_ concerning his services?

oO ;

Mr. Gariepy: You keep this paper pe doctor. ‘Is

‘there any cross-examination?

Mr. Schaefer: No.

; Pres a Doetor\Lioyd Arnoid, will ‘you take the ©

stan

Mr. Schaefer: Are you Rey with Dean Davis?

‘Mr. Gariepy: Yes.

(Witness excused.) — - 7

_ Mr. Schaefer: I am just asiibihie what the stehes of.

the tecord is. “ | .

The Master: This is rebuttal, now.

2043 ~Mr. Schaefer: Yes, I am wondering with respect

to this point. Doctor Arnold’s testimony is to the —

a

a

Testimony of Lloyd Arnold. 1945

effect. that his contract called for 80 per éent of his time

has been challenged and the contraet has been produced.

The Master: It shows in the record.

Mr. Schaefer: It has been subpoenaed all over; town.

It has been here. Os : ;

' The Master: The record now shows that he spends 80

per cent of his time under his contract or he igs obligated

to spend 80 per cent of his time. You made that state-

ment that the contract shows it and it is conceded by Mr.

Gariepy. | z

Mr. Behscten: If ‘that is conceded, all right. >

The Master: Although I do not know what the mate-

- riality is, whether he spends 80 or 50 or 40 per cent of his ©

time there. I don’t. know what that has to do with the

case. : .

‘LLOYD ARNOLD, recalled as a witnéss on behalf of the:

plaintiff, in rebuttal, having been heretofore duly sworn, -

. Tesumed the stand and testified further as follows: y

: . Direct Examination by Mr. Gariepy.

Q. Doctor Arnold, you are the same Doctor Ar-

2044 nold = testified here the other day? :

Q. And did I understand: you to say you were professor

of bacteriology at Loyola University in 1922?

A. ‘In 1921. I think I came there in 1921 or 1922, yes,

sir. Aen > | .

At what office, what position?

A. I came there in bacteriology, pathology, public

health and clinical diagnosis.

Q. As professor?

A. I came there as associate professor and ther was

‘promoted-to professor. _ sa

Q. And what year were you promoted to professor?

A. I have forgotten. The first or second year I was

there. I think the second year. |

Q. That would be what year? - Cee

A. About 1922, I expect, or 1923, I don’t know which. |

Q. Will you look at a bulletin of the Loyola University —

_ School of Medicine for the year of 1921-1922, especially

. with reference to page 18, listing you.as a-member of the

1246 §=Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

' faculty, and tell me ‘ibaa that is a correct listing on

. the lefthand sheet there? |

A. Yes, sir.

. Q. As assistant iia

2045 <A. Yes, it must be, if it is in there.

. Then you want to stand corrected as to being

an associate professor and full professor, is that right?

A. Yes, sir.

Mr. te a 7 What year does that cover? -

Mr. Gariepy: It is the fall, I take it, of 1921, and the ©

whole year 0 1922. These are put out in the fall by all

of these universities.

Mr. Schaefer : You mean, the scholastic year of..1921 .

and 1922, running ‘to about June of 1922?

—Mr. ‘Gariepy: That is right. wipe iaetoy

. Doctor, you were subpoenaed to nee ‘the car- :

tons or containers and materials that you testified on di-

» rect examination you received from the Ex-Cell- O Corpo- .

ration in the year 19387 — ;

. Yes, sir, these are the ones. That i is all I have left

of them (handing cartons to Mr. Gariepy).

Mr. Gariepy: Is this the way they came?

- A. No, they came in a package. The outside package

is gone. They came to my home address. I picked up

those at home this morning. That is all I had left.

Q: Referring to these that you handed me. —

A. Yes, sir.- -

Q. Not those?

A. Tose that I handed you, I think, are Pure-

2046 Pak containers. %,

- Was there any letter in connection with that!

A. No, sir, I don * remember ‘a letter at all, Mr. Ga-

riepy.

Were there any Risdon Dairy contanegrn, rom the.

Risdon Dairy in Detroit? ; ;

A. I don't remember any of them.

. Q. These are blanks of Sylvan-Seal? © .

A. I don’t.remember. I didn’t look at the dairies.

Q. These are all Sylvan-Seal? - ‘ .

A. I didn’t look at the dairies. |

Q. Are those the ones: you referred to in your direct

examination, doctor, as coming from Petroit? —.

A. Yes, sir. Early i in 1938. I don’t just remember the-

date. . .

| Testimony of Lloyd Arnold. | 1247

Q. -You testified on direct also that you did work for

-Seal-Rite Corporation during the last six, months, from .

- June to December, 1938, and I asked you ty produce this

morning, if you have them, vouchers for services in con-

nection with the last research work and the date you did

it in the year 1938 for Seal- Rite Corporation. Have you

anything on that? .

A. No, sir. I was consultant to Seal-Rite. I was on a |

monthly remineration fee.

Q. What I wanted was the last time you received

2047 any remuneration from the Seal-Rite Corporation in

- connection with their research work on that paper

bottle that. you referred to on direct.

A. T received the last check from them i in December for

November’s services.

Q. If I understood you correctly on direct examina- .

tion, doctor, you stated that one hundred and thirty-eight

tests.were performed in the Board of Health under your

direction and Suggestion, from Febrnary 2, up until the

present time, is that right?

. A.- Ido not reca so

a ee

A. No, I would not remember’ any definite number of

tests at all.

: .Q. ° You do not?

A. No, sir, I do not.

Q. Do you know exactly how. many tests were per: -

formed over there at the Board of Health?

A. I do not, no, sir. &

_ Mr. Gariepy : That is all, doctor.

The Master: Any-questions, 0 Mr. Schaefer?

Mr. Schaefer: No.

_ (Witness excused.) :

2048 = Gariepy: mr. — will you take the

stand?

“One hundred and. thirty-eight tests? |

&

| 1248 Tronscrie of = Before Master.

- in connection w

‘with you? ..

- A. IT have. 7 ian

MATTHEW J. MARTINEK,*was recalled as a witness

on behalf of the plaintiff, in rebuttal, having been here-

tofore duly sworn, . resumed the stand and testified fur- -

ther as fo ows:

Direct Examination by Mr. Geriany.

Q. . You are the same Matthew J. Martinek who testified

= before?

Yes, sir.

I -subpoenaed you to produce ‘original documents

wi rire to oe tests that you testified you ‘performed

ith paraffin suspension. ave ) you those °

A>

May I see them? . {oye

Q.

ve “ Yes. (Witness hands cards to Mr: ariepy. ).

A.

Are thesé inthe order they were made out, by dates?

-They are mixed. We had to get thein at random

this morning. We would have to bring in three hundred

of them, to bring them all in.

Q Can you pick out any of these cards by: —. tests,

Mr. Martinek, on Pure-Pak containers?

2049 A. These were all picked 4s Pure- Palthis 1 morn-

ing. The numbers were referred to, the ones we have

there, on the bottoms of the cartons. I can pick out any.

one you wish. | 13

Q. You say these are all Pure*Pak?

. Yes, sir. .

Q. What shows that?. ‘These are just blank numbers.

How do you refer to Pure- Pak or another container on |

there?

‘A.> This dairy number will be found on & Pure- Pak.

container.

Q. “Where are those sidiitdheasa®’

-A. They are right here, these cards here, right back

| there. I will bring them out for you.

Q. No, I will get them. Are these the folders in which

they came? .

- A. Yes. .

Q.° These’ are Bowman folders? :

A... We. just saved them. I don’t know that they ex-

actly came in those, bat we kept the carton: forms, those

. folders. .

6

Testimony of Matthew J. Martinek, 1249

. Where is there anythin on there about Dean or

'-Fieldcrest, on these folders? Ue got them around Cook _

an or within a radius of seventy-five miles didn’t

you

A. I suppose so.. I don’t know .where they got.

them. « :

2050 The Master: Q. You did not get them?

A. No, I didn’t get those, no. -

- Mr. Gariepy: Q. And these are the total inmhae of

- Pure-Pak containers that you say you performed these

tests concerning paraffin suspension in milk on? g

' » Avs No, sir, they are not.all. °

Q. How many more of them arg there, Mr. M artinek?

A. I don’t know. :

‘Q. There is about thirty of them? |

A. Here is the only. thing. When I counted these up

I counted them with the others, with the American Can,

so I don’t know. |

Mr. Schaefer: Mr. Martinek, you might explain ma the

_ Master at what time this subpoena was served on you.

A. It was brought in at 9:00. 0’clock his. morning. |

Mr. Gariepy: Q. These numbers that you refer to on

the cards, are these nurhbers indicated on the flaps, is that

‘right? - ab v4 ;

A. Xe. + ‘|

' Q. You don’t know. anything ‘about the condition: in

which these containers that you brought in here this ‘morn-

ing. were taken from the plant, do yout

A. I do not.

2051. Q. Or whether they were taken from the. plant?

_ A. I do not.

°. How many altogether, do you know, Mr. Martinek,

by looking at these cards, can you tell the Master you per-

— araffin suspension tests on?.

Oh, about twenty or’ so. : i '

Twenty or eof: =. on ae eee

Is. that all, or just Pure-Pak?

Well, nb.. There were three hundred, but my chem-

ran some pf the tests. I supervised the work.

oo ere threé hundred on Pure-Pak?

ae 3

‘Or three hundred altogether? ;

"A. .I don’t know how many on Pure- Pak. ; -I absolutely

have 1 no idea. ,

és Per

ist

>) re

g

1250 . ‘Transcript of Testimony Before. Master.

- Q And that applies ‘to the testimony you gave in the

record from page 1602 to page 1612 concerning this paraf-

fin suspension test on all of them? You sel |

ones it pertains to, is that it?

‘Mr. Schaefer: I fone to that. How can {the witness

: Q. De yon kao? ZS

2052 Mn scones If the Master please, he has not °

> seen the transcript. ;

The’ Witness: What is that? .

- The Master: Read the question.

z (Mr. Gariepy’s last question was read as above re-

corded.

Mr. Gariepy: Q. Whether Pure-Pak or another da

of container. -

fo I do not.

Q. ‘Did you perform any tests in connection with these

_ containers concerning lead content in milk?

wee {fF yf

Mr. Gariepy: That is all, Mr. Martinek.

~The Master: Any cross?

Cross- Examination by Mr. Schaefer.

Q. To the’ best .of your recollection, Mr. Martinek, how

many of ‘the containers that you examined for paraffin

suspension*in milk were ‘containers of the Pure-Pak type,

which is the type that you have here? ——

A. It is pretty hard to say, because wé had theni mixed.’

At one time we had quite a few Pure-Paks and then we

had the American Can also. It would be pretty hard to

tell, because it would be purely a guess and I wool not :

want to guess. -

2053 ‘ Q. The records would show? :

mtg. The records would show, if we sorted them

out. t is what we are doing now.

Mr. Schaefer: ‘That is all.

Redirect Examination by Mr. Gariepy.

Q. - Are they in the same condition, ‘these containers

you brought over this morning, as when you received

them ?. |

Testimony of William D. McNally. 4951.

A. They also have the methylene blue streaks in them

30 they might he slightly damaged. T would not —

t ;

Mr. Gariepy: I see. That is all. .

Mr. Schaefer: That is all. Thank you, Mr. Martinek.

(Witness excused.)

“ Mr. Gariepy: I have’ not had an opportunity to say

have néver him. So I am going to ask Mr. Rall, who has

talked to him, to ask him the questions.

2054 “WILLIAM D. McNALLY, called as a witness on be-

half of the plaintiff, in ‘rebuttal, having been first

| duly sworn, testified as follows:

ee noah a, a asntiatio’ by Mr. Rall.

‘Will you state your name, please?

William D. McNally. ;

Where do you live? é

3734 North Harding avenue, Chicago, Illinois. .

What is your profession or ‘occupation?

I am a physician and toxicologist. :

; Are you licensed to practice medicine i in the state of

- Tinois? .

A. I have practiced medicine and have been licensed -

over twenty years in the city of. Chicago, Cook County,

Illinois.

Q. Did you attend any schools in aki caress for the

practice of medicine?

A. I did..

'. Q. Where? |

. A. Phe University of Michigan, University of Illinois,

and Chicago Rush Medical College. —

Q. Did you receive any degrees from any of these

_ schools? -

2055 <A. Idid. .

eae Q. What were they? . ,

A: A.B. from the University of Michigan, V. D. from -

the University of Chicago, Rush Medical College.

Q. What has been the nature of your practice, doctor? |

_ A. My practice has been largely that of a physician

and a consulting toxicologist.

”Q. Have you held any official position?

‘eperebe

a word to this next witness this morning. The fact is, I~

» 1252 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

<A. Yes. I was toxicologist to Coroner of Cook County

for about seventeen years. I established the first .lab-

oratory. of toxicology in ee

Q. at is toxicology? - ‘ v

A.~ Toxicology is the science that treats of poisons,

their origins and their detection .by chemical: or other

} means. v:

Q. Of what did your duties consist while you ‘were

~ Coroner’s chemist?

: A. Examination of the organs of human bodies for

poison, examination of medicines for poisoning, ‘and ex-

amination of clothing and weapons for tains, blood stains,

examination of clothing for seminal stains, and research,

and the publication of my research. ,

Q.. Have you published any book?

A. I have published two books.

. Q.. On what subject?

2056 <A; On the subject of toxicology and médical j juris-

prudence.

-Q. Have you written any articles, other than books?

A. Yes. -Probably two hundred articles on various

phases of poisons apd their detection.

Q. Are you familiar with the literature relating to

poisons?

‘A. Very much 80. _-

Q. Your referred to being a consultant in toxicology.

Of what does that practice consist? .

_ A. That-consists of consulting arid conferring with

industrial concerns or manufacturing concerns regarding

hazards in their plants, the examination of employes, ex-

amination of the secretions of those people for the. pres-

ence of poisons, examination of the blood, to see whether

there is destruction of dhe hemoglobin, blood counts, physi-

‘cal examinations, interpretation of X- -Tays regarding sili-

, | .

ae Are you consulted by other physicians?. 9

A.- I am.

. Are these eonsultations, frequent. or infrequent?

A. They: occur —— uently..

Q. What is the definition of a poison, doctor?

A. A poison is a substance which when-absorbed into

the blood stream is capable of seriously affecting

2057 the health or causing death, and that is its chief

action.

Q

- Lestimony of William D. McNally. —S—-1253

; -Q. Have you made any. special study of metal poison-

ings? i

A. Yes, sir, I have.

Q. .Of what does that study cunalat’

A. I have made special studies of arsenic, lead and

manganese, and published exhaustive articles on the latter

metal, manganese.

Q. Of what did your ‘special studies of lead poisons

consist? f

A. Considerable experimental work with animals and

work with human beings, showing the elimination of the

“lead by various agents and diets. 2

Q. Does lead poisoning have a more technical fame?

A. Well, it is sometimes-galled plumbism. Most of the

lead intoxications, it seems, come from men working with

solders or in the smelting of lead. In other words, forms

of finely subdivided lead are the chief sources of poisoning.

?.Q. You referred to lead intoxication. Is that synony-

mous with lead poisoning? .

A. Yes, sir, it is. The laity call it plumbism probably

, more often thaf they do lead poisoning.

Q. You say the laity do?

A. Yes. They know it as plumbism.

‘2058 Q. What are the effects of lead poisoning on the

human system?

A. Well, we have acute intoxication where a person has

taken half an ounce to an ounce of lead acetate, which,

causes vomiting and diarrhea. Then we have the acute

effect of inhalation, where large quantities of lead fumes |

are-inhaled, gausing great muscular weakness, destruction ©

‘of the blood cells and constipation:

Then we have the chronic form of lead intoxication,

where there is great muscular weakness and pain in the

part of the anatomy that is used most by-that individual.

Painters get it in the wrist. Men who are shovelling metal

into furnaces get it on the anterior front: part of the legs

and thighs. There is abdominal cramps. There develops

a lead line in those individuals having pyorrhea or.a defec-

. ture denture.

. Mr. Schaefer: Q. A lead. line, did you say, doctor?

Pyorrhea or a defective denture.

The word I missed was, I thought, lead line?

. Yes, sir, lead line.. L-e-a-d 1-i-n-e.

Lead line?

Per!

+ 1954 Pronsoript of Tcidinidng Before Master.

A. Lead line is caused by the abserption of lead in the

- system. It.is taken by the blood to the s which

2059 are diseased and there is hydrogen sulphide . there

o from the decaying of the foods and there is a deposi-

tion of very minute particles of lead, which can be seen

with the aid of a magnifying glass. :

The Master: Q. That’is on the gums? —

A. On the gums, as they come in between the nts; It

. is very rarely seen. Sometimes there is confusion among *

physicians in diagnosing colored people, seeing an African ~ -

line and calling it a lead line, which is not so at all. Neces-.

sarily all colored people have this blue discoloration below

the gums. But this other can be detected by a microscopical

examination .of a small portion of the affected material

squeezed from the gums. :

' Mr. Rall: Q. Have you seen cases— .

A. That is not all. I have a lot more: ‘to tell you 1 about

that. —

Q. All right, continue, doctor.

A. The blood is changed. One of the first: things we

note.in chronic ca8es of lead intoxication is a reduction in

the hemoglobin. Hemoglobin is the red coloring matter

of the blood. There is a destruction of the red blood cells,

so that in an adult having a count of five million red cells’

per cubic millimeter of blood, it may be reduced down -

‘2060 to as low as 3,600,000. .

These people have arthritic pains in the joints. —

There is loss of appetite. They lose weight because they

have lost: their appetite. The pains in the abdomen have ©

been confused with colitis and appendicitis, and thése peo-.

ple have bc2n operated on for appendicitis occasionally be-

cause of the confusion in the diagnosis.

. Diagnosis of lead poisoning can only be made by an ex-

* amination of the blood showing basophilic stippling or by

running a basophilic aggregation known as the McCord

test, which is applicable only in acute cases of grey

The other is chronic cases of poisoning, and the de

stration of abnormal amounts of lead in the urine bets

and after potassium iodide treatments. This is a diagnostic

test and my name is connected with the potassiam iodide

=

ree pw in the Chicane area eliminate from ‘mere ‘tra va

_ of lead up to .09 of a milligram per liter of urine every

Q. Are you there ager to the pais. ois

Testimony of William D. McNally. | 1955

A. Yes, normal. Anyone in this room would chow lead

from mere traces up to .09 of a milligram. . .

’ The Master: Q. Where do they get this lead? ©

2061 <A. Thislead comes from everything we drink and

- everything we eat. There is not an article which

- enters your table but what has lead in it. ;

Mr. Rall: Q.° Is that a normal or abnormal condition?

A. That is a normal condition.

Q. And not harmful, I take it?

.A. No, sir, it is not. |

Q. Have you completed your answer, substantially?

A. I think that covers it.

The Master: Q.-..Is any part of the lead absorbed in

the system as nourishment?

‘ A. No, sir, lead is not a factor, as far as I know, in

the metabolism of the human-body. The lead taken in these

. foods, part of it is eliminated in the urine and stool and

some of it is deposited-in the bones as a tribasic calcium

phosphate, an insoluble form, which does not get ont into

the blood stream, unless the person has an infection, like

influenza, pneumonia, or is becoming an alcoholic, when his

resistance is lowered and the lead then goes out into the

blood stream.

Mr. Rail: “9. Have you seen cases of lead poisoning in

adults?

A. Yes, sir, many hundreds of them.

2062 Q. And in children? af,

| -_A. Yes. -I have only seen a ‘couple i in children.

Q. What, in your opinion, is one of the causes:of lead

poisoning in children?

A. The cause of the poison in the children was due to

eating the paint off of white painted cribs containing lead

— acetate. - | |

The Mastery Q. What kind of cribs? :

A. Cribs painted with white lead. The children would

poe tga woodwork of the cribs and in that’ vind get the

pain

_ _ Mr. Rall:. Q. From your own personal experi nee or

from a reading of the literature or from consultation with =

any other physicians or from any source whatever, do you ~

know of any instances where lead poisoning was attributed

. to or suspected to be caused by the rs eases of milk

from printed paper cartons?

A. Ido not. .

te

1256 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

What are the principal causes of lead poisoning?

“A. ~The principal causes. of lead poisoning are the in-

halation of fumes of finely divided lead, from the smelting

of lead, from removing it from steel articles with torches,

- from "the -manufecture ef lead itself, from the lead car-

bonate, lead acetate, white lead.

2063. Q. Do you know or have’ you heard from any

source of any instances where lead poisoning was at-

tributed to or suspected to be caused by printing inks used

on any type of food container?

A. I have not. I never have been consulted in a case —

of lead intoxication from that. I have never séen anything

in the literature regarding intoxication in foods that were .

— in cartons.or’paper printed with a lead-containing.

"6 ‘And that “. to liquid foods as well as s solid

Wh: Tee, aire

Q. In connection with your study and so forth of lead

poisoning, have you studied the question of what quantities

of lead cause lead poisoning?

A. Yes. In these large number of people that I have

investigated, when the quantity of lead i in the urine is over

one-tenth of a milligram per 1000 cc.; then we know that

they are suffering from mild forms of lead intoxication,

that is, from lead not being eltminated normally. After

the potassium iodide treatment, this may be increased three .

or four times. That, of course, is not lead that is causing

any trouble. That is lead that has been stored up in- .

.. the -bones, which we have eliminated by our chemical

means.

2064 Q. You site this morning, have you not, scimsiand

: a number of flat paper’ cartons, including two cartons

which are sealed at the side?

A. Texamined similar cartons. I did not put my initials

- on them and number them ‘to see whether they ‘were the

same ones, but they were similar to these.

~The Master: Let the-record show that counsel Mek ex-.

hibited to the witness flat containers.

' Mr. Schaefer: ¥ think they are called blanks, for the

record, Master.

The Master: What is that? 9 .

Mr. Schaefer: I believe they.are called blanks. — _

The Master: Blanks, yes. The flat ones are made by

34

.

Testimony‘of William D. McNally. 1257

- the. Gardner-Richardson Company and the ‘Ex-Cell-O Cor-

poration, or as produced for the Ex-Cell-O Corporation by

Gardner-Richardson Company, Middletown, Ohio.

. Mr. Rall: ‘In order not to encumber the record, when

Mr. Fisher, and, I believe, Mr. Taylor, were testifying, a

considerable ‘lumber of these unformed cartons and some

that had the side seal seam, but were otherwise not formed,

were produced and examined by witnesses.: It is my 9

pose here, Mr. Schaefer, to get the worst example of offset

with the type of ink that contains the largest amount of

‘ lead in the evidence here, so that havigg that in mind,

2065 if-these ¢artons do not have enough offset on em)

I would like you to get ones that do.

_ The Master: .What do you mean by offset, for the re¢-

ord?

' Mr. Rall: The offset being the impression of ink. on

the blank or inside of the carton. .

‘The Master: You mean the — from another

container or another blank? a aes

Mr. Rall: Yes-

- The Master: With which this surface has. come. in con-

tact? |

Mr. Rall: a

I would liké to have the reporter mark this blank Plain-

* tiff’s Exhibit 91 for identification. © °

(The blank carton: referred to was thereupon marked

by the reporter Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. St for identifica-

tion.)

Mr. Rall: Q. I show. you. Plaintiff's Exhibit 91 for

identification, doctor. In your examination of the cartons,

_* printed cartons, is that the worst ease of what we call.

offset that you observed?

- <A, Yes, I think that is the heaviest that I have seen.

Q. Assume, doctor, that paper intended jo be used for

: the packaging of fresh fluid milk is printed with a |

_ 2066 printing ink containing fron .2,of'1 per cent to 35.

per cent of lead, and that in the printing operation—

Mr. Schaefer : Just a minuté.- What is thats Ten per

‘cent?

Mr. Rall: Wren: 2 of 1 per cent to 35, per cent.

Q. (Continuing). —the ink on the prihted surface offsets

against and adheres to the paper lying next to it, so as .

leave an offset or smear of the ink-on the part of the pa

: intenged to a the inside of the: milk container ; t

"1258 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

the paper is stored and cut’ so that at this point in the

operation the paper is in substantially the form of Plain-

tiff’s Exhibit 91.

Further assume that this paper is then sealed at the

sides to form what is we ay a blank, with the ends open,

but the side seams sealed, \in remand the form of

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 3.

Further assume that these open ended cartons in that

form are placed on a machine, which opens the carton and

folds over the bottom flaps so as to form a container, with

the side seam and the bottom seam saled, and that in that

condition the container is immersed in liquid paraffin U. 8S.

Pharmacopoeia 12, with an American melting point of

approximately 125 to 127 degrees Fahrenheit, but as-

2067 sume that in the paraffining operation the ’ paraffin

does not, cover the ink offset on the inside of the

container.

Assume further that the container in this. condition is

cooled at approximately 40 degrees Fahrenheit, until the

paraffin is hardened, and that in that condition ‘it is filled

‘with cool liquid “milk, cream,: buttermilk or chocolate milk,

and that the machine referred to then closes the top of the

-. container thus filled with one of the products mentioned

_ and, under pressure, staples the .top flaps, so that the con-

_ tainer filled with milk is then sealed in the way that Plain-

. tiff’s Exhibit 2 is sealed. )

Assume that the pouring spout has not been opened at

the time referzed to. :

Further assume that this package is delivered to a per- <

son’ who places:it in the refrigerator for a period varying —

from twenty-four to ninety-six hours and that the milk or

‘other liquid products referred to is then drunk by said per-

son, or some member of his family. -

Do you have an opinion whether or not the presence of

the ink on the inside of the carton or any of the other factors

which I described in the question presents-any hazard

2068 to the health of the person so consuming the milk, or

other liquid produets mentioned ?

A. I have an opinion. 7

. Will you state what that opinion is?

A. ‘That the hypothetical carton as described by you con-

taining milk, that has been allowed to remain to the extreme

time of ninety-six — would not be a health rare be-

cause, first— -

‘care

Testimony of William D. McNally. 1259

_ Mr. Schaefer: May I have the last part of that question

read?

(The portion of the question referred to was ynerenpen |

‘read by the reporter.)

The Witness: A. (Continuing.) —the ink—

Mr. Schaefer: I submit that the question asked what

the effect would be on the person who consumes that milk.

I do not want to interrupt, but the doctor’s answer so far

indicates that he is not answering the particular question

which was asked. 3

The Master: ‘Let us have the question again.

(The question was read as above recorded.)

The Master: Off the record—

(Discussion off the record.) ;

The Master: Objection overruled. Go ahead, doctor.

The Witness: A. (Continuing.) —because, first, the

pigment contained in these various inks may be lead,

2069 manganese or cobait, and they are in @ base of a gum.

and linseed oil.

These pigments are heated to a high temperature, to make

. theink. The ink.as printed upon these cartons forms a film,

due to the oxidation of the linseed oil, or a lead linolate,

’ which is difficultly soluble in water, milk and dilute acids.

In order to separate that lead for.a chemical analysis, it

is necessary to ash it or oxidize it with. strong acids, like

nitric acid.

Secondly, in addition to the film which is formed on these

“inks due to the oxidation of the linseed oil, we have a cover-

| ing of ng coer

chaefer: Now, I iat to that, if the Master

siya I would have objected to that questin before,’

pape when the questioner framed the questid: he’ very |

ully excluded the paraffin covering of the cq ntainer.

The Master: Yes.

Mr. Schaefer: However, I will withdraw tha objection.

_ The Master: All right. Read as far as the witness got.

(The witness’ answer was read as above recorded.)

2070: —- The Master: Continue.

The Witness: A. (Contifining. ) That was so de-

. seribed in the hypothetical container, such as I have to con-

sider here. That eves a double. coating to this ink. The

paraffin is insoluble «in milk. Therefore, the milk would

not get to the lead compound if it were soluble. So you

have two barriers for this lead tompound getting into the

(Cea

Pes

1260 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

milk, which would eliminate your ink as a lead hazard or as

a cause for lead intoxication.

The Master: Have you reompleted your answer?

. The Witness: <A. Yes, sir.

Mr. Rall: Q. Assuming that at, the place where this .

ink is present the paraffin coating, for some reason, is not

present. - Does that alter, your opinion as to whether. that

presents a health hazard?

A. You would still have your film of oxide of linseed.

oil present, which is insoluble in the milk. It would not

release the lead. .

The Master: Off the record. e

(Discussion off the record.)

Mr. Rall: Q.° The Master suggests that if the first film -

is not. present, which you referred to as the result -of

oxidation—

A. It would always be present.

2071 The Master: Q. Assume that for some reason it

had been, taken off.

A: .. When it dries there would have to be séme of it there,

3 because it is just like the paint on a wall or the outside wall

of your home, that has got linseed oil, turpentine and the

pigment in it; which is subjected to the weather, the rain,

the elements, snow, heat, cold and ice, which is the greatest™

- factor for removing: that pigment. In other words, that

pigment will. stay until ‘the linseed oil has become disinte-,,

grated by the ice and sléet,

Q. Mr. Rall started to\ask you, assuiming there were

not present either one of those two films, is there enough »

ink constituting that offset or is there.enough lead there

preseut to present a health hazard, which lead might get: -

into the milk?

‘A. If it was in an insoluble form, no, as the maximum

amount of offset as I see-it in that See here would not

present a hcalth hazard. 9

Mr: Schaefer: Will you read the Master’ s question? .

(The record was read as above recorded.) -

The Witness: The answer was: ‘‘No.’’

__ The Master: Q. That'is to say, the amount of lead i in

the ink would not be soluble? :

A. It would not be soluble in milk, no, sir. - But

2072 you have that double protection here. You have the

oxidation envelope of lead, because this ink is manu-

p factured with heat — to the gums =e the linseed oil.

EE, ee ee

Testimony of William D. McNally. 1261

Q. Let us go one point further now. Let us assume there

_ is not a film of paraffin, there is not the oxidized film, ‘and

that the lead.in the ink is not in insoluble form, but is

- golubleis there enough lead present in that ink consti-

tuting this offset to present a, health hazard?

ae eo my opinion, no. 3

Mr. Rall: Q. And is that opinion baaed upon your

knowledge of chemistry, your practice of medicine ahd your

_ ‘study of toxicology? :

: A. Yes, sir. Set ;

-Q. In the hypothetical carton ‘ua the circumstances sur-

rounding it which I gave, do you have an opinion whether

there is any hazard to the public health involved?

A. From the milk contained in any carton similar to .

what I have been sven no, sir; I cannot see any health

hazard.

—Q. In the case’ of lead poisoning, are there any —

of it which are peculiar to infants?

2073 A. Yes. Infants absorb the lead and it is- ‘fixed

in the cranial bones, the epiphyseal or long bones of

the infants, and that can he demonstrated by the X-ray.

The faster: Q. What are the epiphyseal bones?

A: That is where the bone is not ossified. Our bones

are not. completely ossified until we have reached the age .

_» of eighteen, and then there is a calcium deposition at the

“ s of the bones.

Mr. Rall: Q: In. giving your opinion ‘and the reasons

-therefote; have you considered the health: hazard as it re-

lated to infants as well as to adults? -

A. Yes, sir. : =

‘Q. And that under the hypothesis ziven it i is your opin-

._ ion that there is no health problem either as to adults or

infants, js that correct? |

‘A. Yes. By the administration of milk you are giving

» one of the best antidotes that we know in toxicology for

lead intoxication, because of the calcium in this milk. It

eauises a deposition of the lead in the.bones. In industrial

plants,-in which I have been a consultant, I give them milk

to drink, where they are exposed to high concentrations of ..,

"lead during the mixing of lead paints, with the end results

that we have. not had lead intoxication in those plants

207A where they are taking milk.

Q. At the — end of the life scale, take a senile

™~.

«

Tid 4 8

4262 * Transcript of Testimony Before Master. .

person, would your opinion that.no health hazard i is pre- .

sented apply equally to such a person? on

_ A. Oh, yes. They are still drinking -milk, which, as I

said, is one of our. best antidotes, and there would not be

- enough coming off of this offset to be a health hazard.

. Are familiar with paraffin, pure refined paraffin,

meaning U.S. Pharmacopoeia Standard 11, with an Ameri-

can melting point of approximately 125 to. 127 degrees

Fahrenheit?

A.“ I have: used paraffin i in: the’ tuhoretory.. I have seen

it used at home, in the capping of jells and jams.’ It has

been used in my home for a good many years in that man-.

ner. I have used large quantities of. that same sort: o

araffin in cutting sections of -human organs, when I was

interested in pathology. .

Q. ‘I believe the last editionof ne U.S: Pharmacopoeia

is 11? . ®

“A. Yes. ‘.

Q. And my hypothetical question I referred to U. S.

Pharmacopoeia 12. Without objection may that be

changed? *

2075 The Master: Q. .Does that make any difference i in

your opinion, doctor? ._..

‘A. No, because it will be 12 now instead of 11. The new -

one is under revision at the present time.

Mr. Rall: Q.° Do you have.an opinion as to whether

the taking of paraffin in quantities of from 1. milligram to

‘107 milligrams, of the kind described, through the mouth,

is harmful to health?

eMr. Schaefer: I object to that, ‘if the Master please,

because the question is not proper rebuttal and the answer

-will not be proper rebuttal. The only pagers that was

asked with respect to that. subject dealt With infants under

the age of one year. No question was asked with reference

to’ adults. So far as infants are concérned, Doctor Mc-

Nally’s qualifications have not yet been demonstrated.

Mr. Rall: So far as the general question of. whether it

* must be limited to infants under one year is- concerned,

‘Doctor Arnold referred to what he called : the. ingesting

of paraffin. | No, I am wrong. He was taJking about the

ingesting of: the milk. He talked about the presence of

paraffin being an adulterant and referred to the fact that ~

while it might not ‘be harmful to adults, upon which,

2076 as I recall, he expressed no ae, or at least no

°

Testimony of William D. MeNally. . 1263,

adverse opinion, nevertheless he did refer to. adults,

‘and I think I am entitled to show it both generally and

specifically. — .

The Master: Yow have’ not qualified this witness, have

you, on that? You ¢ greg him as an expert on poisons.

Mr. Rall: Well, I will withdraw the quéstion and ask

him this:

Doctor, have you an opinion as to whether paraffin

of the kind described is a poison? it

‘A. It is not.

The Master: Q. Either to. adults or infants!

A, To anyone.

‘Mr. Rall: Q. Is there anything about its chi istry

' . which in your opinion is harmful to human health, -¢ither

adult or infant?

A. It is nvi.

Q. Is there anything -about its physical propertioe, in

the quantities described, from .1 milligram to 107 milli-

grams, which if taken through the mouth, either by an

infant or by an adult, is harmful to health?

- Mr. Schaefer: I object to that, on the ground the wit-

ness is not err, to express ‘an opinion on. that

question.

2077, _ The Master: What other qualification ‘do you want

‘him to have? | ’ eget

Mr. Schaefer: What does the doctor know about the

- health of infants?

The Master: Do you want te, qualify him. along. those

_ lines, Mr. R 1?

Mr. Rall: Yes, I will go a little ‘further.

. be age if any experience have you had in the use:

of — n or paraffin products in connection with your

medical and professional work?

A. I have. never given paraffin internally: as medicine. %

I have given mineral oil, which is a higher grade’ of- min-

‘eral product than paraffin, I have never bie

ally and it is not given internally in. the United States

Pharmacopoeia.

, Q. What has been your experience with the products

. —do you say mineral oil?

Yes.

Q. What hes been your experience in. that ‘aaa

A. I have given lots of mineral oil asa laxative. It is

not digestible. Neither is the paraffin — It passes :

through — in the stool.

ven it intern-'-

©

\

1264 . Transcript of Testimony Before Master..

Q. If the taking of paraffin were to cause disturbances

to the human body, would that be the type of case that

2078 would come to you professionally, in conneetion with

your consulting work? = ———_- ae |

A. Yes. If paraffin had been considered by physicians

as an irritant or some firm was manufacturing a product

which was encased in a paraffin-coated receptacle, { would

_be one of the people in the United States to be cbnsulted

along that particular line. Oa j :

: 2. ie you familiar with medical literature generally?

_Q. vou know of any instance, either it/ the litera-

ture or ffom your own experience or from consultation

with other physicians, or from any source, when bodily

disturbances of any kind were attributed to or suspected -

to be caused by the taking of paraffin, the accidental or

other taking of paraffin through the mouth by any indi-

vidual?

A, J do not. I have chewed paraffm. I have seen

numbers of other people who have chewed paraffin half .

* a day, day after day, and undoubtedly swallowed particles

—_ were more than 100 milligrams, without .any ill ef-

; ects.

The Master: Q. Would you recommend its presence

in milk?

Ae It would be-a foreign body in milk. It would -

2079 not conform to the Pure Food Act, if it was there to

add bulk or weight tp milk. In a receptacle like this,

the paraffin that would come off would be extremely small,

If I should crush one of these corners, the particles under

the microscope would probably be not larger than six

‘ times the size of a blood cell, which would not hurt any-

body in. swallowing it. There is no place on this carton

' where one piece would come off of the size of-a 100 milli-

a,

_ . Q. You would not find any objection to milk because it

contained paraffin? : Sets “

A. In what quantities? It would not be harmful to the

individual, no, sir. - ie

ix In any quantity would you find any objection to

. milk, if it contained paraffin? — ,

4.. If the paraffin were of the size of peanuts or

marbles, I would not want to drink milk containing par- ~

affin like that, no, sir, but it would not be ascertained in

milk any more than the chocolate-would in chocolate milk.

° poe: e Testimony of William D. McNally. | 1269

Q. Let us assume a little different case. Let us assume

you have a person with colitis or with diarrhea, a person

’ with a sensitive bowel, either adult or infant. Would you

‘gay that the presence ‘of paraffin in the milk might present

a health problem?

2080 <A. If it was in large particles, several grains in

size, and a person had an inflamed bowel, it might act .

as an irritant, but such particles I cannot conceive of com-

ing off from a parcel-or package such as has been exhibited

_-to me in this court room.

_ Does that answer your uecliont

Mr. Rall: Q. Doctor, I forgot one question on the

matter of your experience. Are you a member or have -

you been 7 member of: any professional societies or or-.

ganizations?

‘A. Yes. I am a-member of the American Chemical 4

Society, Chicago Chemical Society, American Public Health

Association, Illinois Medical Society, Chicago Medical So-

ciety, American Medical Association. .I guess that is all.

. In what types of publications have your articles

or you referred to been printed?

A. They fe -ac in Journals of Public Health, Amer-

ican Medieal Journal. They appeared in Medicel Record,

Michigan State Medical Society Journal, India ‘a State

Medical Journal, the Journal of Industrial Medicine.

Q. You were requested to appear. her by Mr. Fred

Gariepy, is that correct?

Yes. and ‘

1 Q. You never saw Mr. Garlepy or me before

‘today?

A: No, sir.

Q. And you have conferred with me before your ie.

timony?

A. Yés, sir. ;

And you expect to be compensated for your consul-

tation and for your appearance here?

A. Ido. .

Mr. Rall: You may cross examine. »

The Master: There is one more question.

Q. I mentioned the case of an irritated or sensitive:

tng Let us take the case of a diseased gall bladder or

| weet ver or some other organ which has to do with digestion.

° ould you say the presence of paraffin would make any

difference?

< ¥ Absolutely not, becausé the — would be elimi-

Lb

J

1266 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

. nated by the gastro-intestinal tract. Not being soluble, it

would not get to the liver, which is the filter of the human

body, nor to the gall bladder, It would not cause an ir-

-ritation in either instance.

Q. .Would it impose any work upon the. activities of

thase organs?

' A. No, sir, it would not, engnin nothing is' needed to

digest this piece of paraffin. It is not digested by the .

2082 various. ont the and juices that are present in the

stomach and the gastro-intestinal tract, including the

duodenum, ilium and colon. Those are just subdivisions

of the gastro-intestinal tract. With your stomach there

you have a complete gastro- -intestinal tract. Starting

with your mouth and going to your stomach and running

down to the rectum, you have a complete GT tract.

Q. Does raw milk contain any bacteria?

fie: Yes, sir, it does. I have seen it in the city of Chi-

cago, wheh I was in the. Health Department, contain many

millions of organisms. :

Q. Would you say that bacteria from the milk adhere

to particles of paraffin in the milk?

If that particle of paraffin contained protein or

other substances found in the milk, yes; it could grow

around the protein, just the same as it could grow on

the edge of a bottle. '

. Let us assume that the bacteria are already grown.

Do you think—

A. Paraffin would be an un-nutrient medium and there-

fore would not offer a suitable food for bacteria. In other

words, bacteria would not grow readily on paraffin, unless

this paraffin was surrounded by. food elements which are

contained in milk, like lactose, protein, fats, salts.

2083 Milk affords a suitable medium for bacteria to grow,

at a suitable temperature.

Q. Let us assume this: The bacteria do not grow as

you a let us say, but may, nevertheless be in the

paraffin

A. ’Well, they could not be in the paraffin, unless the

oni had been rolled around in some putrid material,

use the bacteria would nof penetrate the paraffin.

Q. “You say the bacteria do not penetrate paraffin?

A., It would not penetrate paraffin. It would not grow

in it: It has no nutrient in it at all. .

Q. Could not bacteria go through the paraffin?

A. No, it could not.

eo

|, Testimony of William D. McNally. —-1267

- Q. From ‘the milk into the. walg of the container and

back ey : , -

ic “A. No. You look at your home, as the Mrs. cans Jams

and jellies, and you have an observation to show why par-

affin is used for the cappings of these bottles, because they —

revent bacteria and yeasts entering the jams and jellies. |

hey -can light on the outside and they will never go -

‘through. . hee

Q. Your opinion then is that bacteria do not penetrate

paraffin? eer , ;

A. That is right, they do not penetrate paraffin. :

Q. And if there are any bacteria in the wall of

2084 these paper containers, they cannot get in mi

through the ;

A; That is right. ..

Q. And vice versa— : :

_A. They would not get out into the—

Q. And vice versa, the bacteria from the milk could .

not get into the-wal] of the container?

=. Unless there was a break in the paraffin. Then they

could.

Mr. Rall: Q. In the hypothetical quéstion, Plaintiff’s

Exhibit 91 was referred to. I want you to assumé for the

urpose ‘of this next question that the offset ink on the

inside of the hypothetical carton was even, greater in

amount than that which you see on Plaintiff’s Exhibit 91,

considering the amount of ink on the outside of the car-

ton and assuming that the inside of the carton was offset

with even more of the same type Of ink than appears on

.~ it. Would that change vour opinion as to whether or not

the presence of that offset presented a health hazard?

. No, it would not. :

| Why? b

Because, for the reasons stated, you ,have an in-

soluble compound here, due to the oxidation of the

2085 linseed oil and. the forniation-of an insolpble lead

_ compound, or, if-it-happens to be manednes¢, the-same

——applies-which is insoluble in water and which i€ insolyblé”

in milk. ete ih * %

Q. Would the auantity of lead, assuming as much as

_ 35 per cent of lead im the ink, which could, in your opinion,

be offset upon the inside of such a carton, would such an

amount, in your opinion, be sufficient to cause. lead in- -

toxication? .

A. It would not.

é

1268 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

Mr. Schaefer:. I object to that, for the reason that

the witness is not qualified to express an opinion as to#

/how great an offset there may be. The question calls for

the witness’ opinion on that point.

_ The Master: . I will let it:stand. You may cross ex-

amine. It will ge to the weight of his testimony. .

Mr. Rall: Without putting all of these things in the |

record, I am frank to say that I want the worst case of

offset that-counsel can find or describe. I am unable to

. know exactly how to describe it in words.

The Master: I would like to. ask a question that may

@ perhaps throw some light on fhe amount of offset.

Mr. Rall: Yes.

. The Master: Q. As.I understand you, doctor,

2086 the lead in the ink would not be soluble in the milk

for two reasons. One is that you have an oxidation ©

film and the other is that you have a paraffin film.

A. That is right.

- And you say that ink when it dries just takes this

_ oxidation film? . ‘

A. It forms a film, due to the oxidation of the linseed

oil and the ester gums which might be in this —

preparation.

Q. If that is true as to the offset, wouldn’t it also be

‘ true as to the face of these containers, where you have the

full printing?

“A. Yes. I would be willing to dtink milk day after day

with the ink on the inside of the package and have dint

milk seventy-two hours old.

Q. That i is what I am getting at.

A. Yes, sir. I would absolutely not. “ afraid to drink

any inilk in a container like that. -

“The Master: , Then it does not ftnake any difference, Mr.

Rall, how heavy the offset is.

Mr. Rall: In my humble way that is what I was trying

+ to describe, and I did not do-a very good job of it.

‘The Master: In other words, the doctor says it @oes not -

_make any difference whefher you have merely or whether

you have the full printing on _— — of the con-

. 2087 tainer.

Mr. Rall: Yes. .

Q. Now, doctor, in answer to the first hypothetical ques-

tion you stated that milk kept under the conditions de-

scribed in the —— question for ninety-six hours,

Testimony of ‘William D. McNally. ae 1269

did not, in your opinion, ane: a health hazard. “Would

that also be true— —- aire | |

A. As to lead.

Q. -\s to lead, yes.

- A. Because in ninety-six bonis the bacterial count is

several million.

Q. But I was referring only to the lead.

‘A. Kept in an ice box, then it becomes a. health hazard,

because of the increase in the bacterial count...

Q. But what relationship does the time have in the

answer to the question as concerns the possibility of ‘lead

poisoning?

A. With this film, nothing.

. Q. So your answer was ‘an answer * to what you consider

an extreme case?

A. Yes.

Q. And would include and: cover-—

A. With the one proviso that after ninet -Six hours

there are no defects in this paraffin that would loosen the -

: paper. Suppose’this was folded inside. If it would .

2088 loosen all of this and the person would get the lead

into his system mechanically,.then he might show

some ‘signs of intoxication, if he got all of thedead from

this paint at one dose. We do not believe that would be

possible, or I do not.

Tle Master: May I ask him another question here?

Meise Rall: Thpgis all right. He is here for that purpose,

aster.

The Master: Q. You say that the ‘paraffin does not

. permit the passage of bacteria from the milk into the wall

of the container, that it prevents it?

A. Yes, sir.

Q. And it does not,” by the same sia inal the

passage of any moisture or any of the milk into the wall —

- _ of the container, is that correct?

A. That is right. t protects it.

Q. Then you would say that the wall of the container

_ is non-absorbent?

A. It is rendered impervious. “é the coating of paraffin. -

That i& the purpose of it. .

Q. That is your opinion? .

A. Yes. Any defects in the paraffin, however, ‘would

allow moisture to get through and would undermine that

paraffin. )

1270 Transcript of Testimony Before Master:

Q. Does this ink have any odor? -

2089 A. When it is being made, yes, it would Seis an

= odor, but there is very little. odor to any ink, unless

it has & preservative like phenol.’ Take your writing

_ fluid e the fluid the court reporter is using here; that

\ probably has got phenol init, to preserve it. That type of

\. ink does not require the skill ‘of, manufacture that this type

“does. That kind of ink will run._.F can put my hand on

this and it will make a splurge. I can rub this and there -

will be no splurge, because there is a film on it. That,

under the miscroscope, looks like a thousand little dots.

Q. You mean the court reporter’ 8 ink?

° A. Yes, the court reporter’s ink.. If I put it under a

- microscope, as I have done, for many years, it looks like

millions of little dots. This will not have’that ae.

Q. Referring to the ink on fhe container?

A. Yes.

Q. This ink on the container you say has no: smell

whatever? 4

' A. Yes, there is an odor. When you have these cartons

piled. up in ‘six foot piles in the printing shop, there is _

somewhat of an odor, due hy the pigments, but as it is here,

| there is no odor at all

2090 Q. Would you say that if a container is freshly

printed — shortly thereafter sealed and made into

a form of container such as is shown here, and if the print-

_ing were on the inside of such a-container, would you say

that some of the ink odor might get into the milk?

A. No, that is very small. e only way you smell that

ink odor is where there are big piles of these ‘lithographs

on the floor of the printing plant. You can take a large

pack, like he has at hand there, and there would be no

odor at all. But, freshly printed, yes, there is an odor.

Q. Have you ' performed any experiments to ascertain

whether paraffin will permit the passage of bacteria?

A. Well, I have not performed any experiments to. show

that paraffin will permit the passage of bacteria through a

ackage like this, no, but I know that is why it is used,

6 tormee off it does not permit the passage of yeasts and bac-

- teria. That is common household knowledge. That is why

that is used. .

Q. Is that also your medical knowledge? nae

A: On, yes. It gives a coating that bacteria will not _

penetrate.

The Master: pind ti more, Mr. Rallt

ha a | 1271

. . Mr. Rall: Noy

2091 The Master: >We will have a recéss of a few

minutes, then.

o

Mr. Schaefer: ahis i is off ~ ‘Fecord. It j is now 12:00 i

o’clock noon.

(Discussion off the record.) .

The Master: We will recess until 1 :30, in this room:

(Whereupon a recess was taken to 1:30 o’clock p. m.

of the same day, Thursday, October 26; 1939.)

2092 : oe * eee

Thursday, October 26, 1939, —

1:30 o’clock P. M.

Met pursuant to recess. | .

Present: Same as before.

_ The Master: You may proceed.

Mr. Rall: While we are waiting for the witness, there

are some exhibits which we want to offer that we might

consider. Mr. Horan and I went over the list. of exhibits

yeaterday.

Plaintiff ’s Exhibit 42, being a picture of a soaker bottle

washer, which was identified at Page 487 of the transcript,

. simply to show the type of machine the witness was dis-

cussing,’ was not offered in evidence, and we now desire

to offer it.

_Mr. Schaefer: . I have no objection.

(Bei b geod It may be received. .

hotograph of soaker bottle washer so of-

oe re naive in evidence, was marked PLAIN-

TIFF’S EXHIBIT NO. 42 and is attached hereto and made

‘a — hereof.)

r. Rall: plaintiff ’s Exhibit 47-A was included in a

general offer, identified at Page 946 of the transcript, but

was omitted in the list of exhibits received at Page 1025.

We re-offer that, to correct the record. __-

The Master: "Any objection?

Mr. Schaefer: No.

The Master: It'may be received.

(Said document so offered and received in ‘evidence, was

marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 47-A and is attached

hereto and made 8 part hereof. )

, :

@ ; . °

oe

: 1272—Trans cript of Testimony Before Master.

Mr. Rall: Plaintiff?s Exhibit 57, referred‘to by Doctor

. Prucha, was identified at-Page 988 of the Pacts. t, but .

was erroneously omitted in the offer of the exhi its at

Page 1025 of the transcript. We would like to offer that

' at this time.

The Master: Any objection? .

Mr. Schaefer: No objection. ha ess

The Master: It may be received.

(Said document so offered and received in evidence, was

marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 57, and is attached -

hereto and made a part hereof.

2094 Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 58 was identified at _

: ' Page 990 of the transcript, but was erroneously

omitted from the offer of, exhibits on poet: 1025 of the.

_ transcript. We desire.to offer that. |

The Master: Any objection?

Mr. Schaefer: No. . .

The Master: It may be received. 7 .

(Said document sa offered and received in evidence, was

marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 58, and.is attached

hereto and made a part hereof.)

Mr. Rall: Apparently there was no exhibit described as |

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 82, but the transcript at page 1369, in

connection with the. offer of exhibits, refers to Exhibit 82,

so it will be understood that the exhibits should havé ended

at 81 in that offer, instead of 82.

_ Mr. Schaefer: Is there an exhibit 82 in the record at all?

Mr. Rall: There is not.

- Plaintiff’ssExhibit 83, identified on cross-examination by

Doctor Lloyd Arnold, is a letter from Doctor Arnold to

George D. Scott, dated December 17, 1937. We offer that

in evidence. It waa identified at page 1877 of the tran-

script.

¢ The Master: Any objection to that?

2095 Mr. Schaefer: - No, sir.

The Master: It may be received.

(Said letter from Doctor Lloyd Arnold to George D. °

Scott, dated December 17, 1937, so offered and received in

evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 83, and

is attached hereto and made a part hereof.)

Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 84 is a two-page original

letter of Doctor Lloyd Arnold to Mr. George Scott, dated

December 9th, 1937, a special delivery envelope, and-a pur-

rted carbon copy of a letter from Doctor Arnold to (

Sais Thomas Parran, snc mia dated December@

r

Colloquy. } 1273 7 ,

9th, 1937, identified “ Doctor Arnold on his cross-exam-

ination. , ;

The Master: Any objection?

Mr. Schaefer: No objection.

. The Master: It may be received.

(Said letter from ‘Doctor Lloyd: Arnold to Mr. George

Seott, dated December 9, 1937, special delivery envelope .

and carbon. copy of letter from Doctor Arnold to Doctor.

’ Thomas Parran, dated December 9, 1937, so offered and re-

ceived in evidence, were marked PLAINTIFF ’S EXHIBIT

84 and are attached hereto and made a. part hereof.)

2096 Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit.85, a o letter,

‘dated November 12, 1937, from A. W. Fuchs, Senior

Sanitary -Engineer, to S. E. Dean, Jr., was identified by

Doctor Arnold on cross-examination, at page 1888. I now

offer it.

. The Master: It may be received.

(Said letter dated November 12, 1937, fro A. W. Fuchs

to S. E. Dean, so offered and received in evidence, was

marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 85, and ‘is attached

hereto.and made\a part hereof.)

Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 26. is a photostat of -a

letter dated November 26, 1937, from Leslie C. Frank,

Senior Sanitary Engineer, 'to 8. E, Dean, Jr., identified at

Page 1888, is offered in evidence. :

The Master: Any objection?

_ Mr. Schaefer: No objection.

The Master: It may be received.

(Said photostat of letter, dated November, 1997, from

‘Leslie C. Frank to S. E. Dean, so offered and received i in

evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 86 and is

attached hereto and made a part hereof.)

Mr. Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 87 is a one ‘pa e letter

dated February 7th, 1938, from Doctor Lloyd Arnold

2097 to George D. ‘Scott, identified at page 1951 of the

transcript.

The Master: Any: objection?

Mr. Schaefer: No abjection. .

The Master: It may be received.

(Said letter dated 1 February 7, 1938, from Doctor Lloyd

Arnold to George D tt, so offered and received in

evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT 87 and is

attached hereto and made a part hereof.) 4

Ma, Rall: Plaintiff’s Exhibit 88 is-not offered. ~

Plaintiff’s Exhibit 89 is a copy of a letter dated October ~

rf”

127 “Pranscript of Testimony Before Master. |

6th, 1939, from Walter N. Dashiell, Assocf&te Public Health

Engineer, United States Public Health’ Service, to Doctor

Herman N. Bundensen, to which he attached four type- —

_ written sheets, dated October 7th, 1939, entitled, ‘‘Section —

10 as it will appear in-the 1939, printed Public Health ©

Service Milk Code,’’-said four sheets being identical with

’ the text of pages 2, 3, 4, and 5 of Defendants’ Exhibit 29,

which is already in evidence. By agreement, the four. pages

g this exhibit already included in the. record as part of

efendants’ Exhibit 29 are omitted. ey o.. .

Mr. Schaefer: That is agreeable. 4

2098° The Master: Exhibit 89 is received. _ |

ee (Said letter dated October 6th, 1939, from Walter _ —

N. Dashiell to Doctor Herman N. Bundesen, so offered and

received in evidence,’ was marked PLAINTIFF ’S EX.

HIBIT NO. 89 and is attached hereto and made a part.

hereof.).

Mr. Schaefer: I have two documents which I want to

offer, and that will straighten out: this portion of the

record and we will have it allin one place. = - . .

- I want to offer Defendants’ Exhibit 7, which was iden-

tified by Doctor Prucha while he was testifying and which

‘is a table showing the reports of certain experiments fper-

formed by him. It was overlooked at the time the other

exhibits identified on that day were offered in evidence.

Mr. Rall: No objection. —

The Master: It may be received... :

(Said table identified by Doctor Prucha so offered and

received. in evidence; was marked DEFENDANTS’ EX-

-HIBIT ‘NO. 7, and is attached hereto and made a part

a ag 9 g ; oe seats

Mr. Schaefer: The other document which I would (ike

to take up is Plaintiff’s Exhibit 88, which was identified at

the last hearing, and referred to by counsel for the p\ain-

| tiff in examining certain of the witnesses who tes-

2099 tified on that day. That document was a r@port of

certain proceedings taken by the Board of Health on

May 15th, 1939.. I have here an excerpt from the minutes

of the Board of Health on that day, which show the action

of the Board boca Ea” aay to that matter, and. I would like

to have that marked for identification and received in evi-

dence as Defendants’ Exhibit 31. The plaintiff has not

seen fit to offer tts Exhibit 88. ~- | bees

The Master: Do you object to this, Mr. Rall?

Mr. Gariepy: Yes.

Colloquy. aces as 1275

Mr. Rall: Unless we Gan get an agreement as to who |

was present, so we can make the record in that respect

— lete.

e Master: You have already testified to this, haven’t.

you to who was present?

ll: No. Doctor Bundesen referred to the minutes, |

but t dia not say who was present.

Mr. Gariepy;: Let us find out who was there. .

The Master: What is this supposed to be?

Mr. Schaefer: That is action taken -by the Board of

Health in respect to— .

eg Master: What is it, minutes” ot what?

Schaefer: Those are minutes of the Board of ,

we iealth yes, sir. That is what I stated at the out-.

2100 set. These are minutes of the. Board of Health of &

meeting held on that day. F

-Mr. Rall: Our objection is that it is not complete, but

-. that may be’obviated by his later information.

2

. i

Mr. Gariepy: Showing who was ‘present, to make it

complete. °

The Master: Subject to putting in the facts as to who

were presént—

Mr. Rall: And the vote on the cenolation.

The Master: (Continuing.)’ —and the vote on the reso-

roy agg document thay be’ received as Defendants’ Ex-

it

(Said excerpts of minutes of Board of Health meeting,

held on May-15, 1939, so offered and: received in evidence,

was marked DEFENDANTS’ EXHIBIT 31, and is at-

tached hereto and made a part hereof.) -

‘Mr. Schaefer: -It is stipulated that at the meeting of

the Board of Health on May 45th, 1939, all of the members

of the Board of Health were present, except Doctér Bunde-

sen, and all present voted in favor of the resolution.

‘ The Master: How about these cartons that were iden-

tified this morning? Do you want to put those in?

2101 Mr. Rall: We will offer im ‘evidence Plaintiff’ .

Exhibit 91 the green. printed carton referred to in |

Doctor McNally’ s testimony.

The Master: Is that the only one?

Mr. Rall: Yes. 3

The Master: It may be received. |

(Said green. printed carton so offered dod. Teceived in

evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 91, and is

attached hereto and made a part héreof.) —

\ |

\ ,

"1276 Transcript of. Testimony Before Master.

* Mr. Rall: Mr? Reporter, will you mark that Plaintiff’s

Exhibit 92 for identification? -°

(The document referred to was thereupon marked by the

reporter Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 92, for identification.)

Mr. Rall: I offer in evidence Plaintiff’s Exhibit 92, an

original one page lé$ter, dated September 16, 1933, from

A. W. Fuchs to George Scott.

The Master: A. W. Fuchs is of the United States Public

Health Service? ’ :

Mr. Rail: Yes. .

_ The Master: And Mr. Scott is sales manager of the.

Ex-Cell-O Corporation,:the Pure-Pak division?

‘Mr. Rall: Right.

. ‘The Master: It may be received. .

2102 . (Said letter from A. W. Fuchs to George Scott,

| dated : September 16, 1939, so offered and received in

evidence, was marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 92 and is

attached hereto and made a part hereof.)

The Master: , Are you ready for the witness now? |

Mr. Schaefer: Yes. * ie

Mr. Rall: There is one question that I would like to .

ask before the cross examination.

WILLIAM D. MeNALLY, a witness ied by the Plain-

tiff, in rebuttal, having ‘Ween heretofore duly sworn, re-

sumed the stand and testified further as follows:

Direct Examination (Continued) by Mr. Rall.

Q. We referred this morning, doctor, to milligrams of

paraffin. Can you give the Master some equivalent as to

- describing what a milligram of. paraffin is? ©

A. Yes, I can tell you what a grain is in milligrams and’

give’the English picture of how the grain*and milligram

came into existence. : 5

The grain is the average weight of a well dried kernel of

“ ._ wheat. That was our early English system of desig-

* 2103 nating weights. As this measure was transposed -into

the metric system or the French system, we _ then

' began to use grams and ‘fractions of a gram.. A. gram is

15.45 grains. A grain is 0645 grams. So if you can picture

a well dried kernel of wheat, you have the pitture of a

grain which is 64.5 milligrams. 3

Testimony of William D. McNally. 127

Q. Is that the measurment by weight?

A. That is the measurement by weight, given in the

United States Pharmacopoeia, National Formulary, United

States Dispensary, and a recognized measure used by the

pharmacists and the practicing physician. |

Q. About how large would a piece of paraffin ef 107

-milligrams be? — |

_ A. It would be a little larger than “Gin of wheat.

Mr. Rall: ,That is all.

é

' Cross-Examination by Mr. Schaefer. |

Q.: Doctor, what do you mean by a hazard to health?

A. Anything that would cause injury. to that particular

individual’s well being.

Q.. Is lead taken, into -the human body through the.

‘mouth beneficial to health? ee. 5

A. No, sir, it is not. Tn small cailbiias it would have . |

“?

* no effect. :

2104 Q. Just answer the questions that I ask you, doc-

tor. You have testified a good deal’and you under-

stand. So just answer the questions that are put to you.

Does milk contain lead? |

A. Yes, sir, it does.

Q. Does milk, fresh fluid milk 3 as it comes from the cow,

contain lead? “9

-A. It contains lead as I have examined it from. glass

containers. I have never examined it as it came from the

udder of a cow and put into pyrex bottles.

-Q.. Pyrex what? 2

A. Pyrex bottles, which are lead-free. They are glass

Cz, ;

. containers which are lead-free.

Q. How much lead does milk contain?

A. That varies: :

. Q. With what? :

A. With the length of time that the milk has been in

' that container, with the type of food that that— .

Q. What container, doctor?: . ‘

A. Glass container. . ;

. Are you saying that the lead gets into the milk ies

the glass container? 7

A. I believe so, yes, sir. I can take water and put it

in a glass bottle, distilled water, and ‘that water after a

mumber of days shows traces of lead.

1278 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

2105 Q. What have you done with your glass bottle _

before you put the water in it

A. It has been washed out with distilled water first.

2 Ringed out with distilled’water?

. Rinsed out with distilled water, yes, sir. ©

9. That is the a. treatment that you gave it?

.* Yes, that is

2. Where was it befgre it was rinsed out?

. I ecouldn’t tell you that. It was probably around

the laboratory for weeks or so before it was rinsed out

or it may have been one that was just used a day or two

before, with milk contained in it and then used for this

riment.

-How would lead get on to the glace. milk bottle?

Lead is a substance that is found in all cheaper

| "a ‘of commercial glass. It is not found in the pyréx

or chemical glass. It is nd in glazes, in chemical work,

in enameled ware.

Pe Is glass porous, doctor?

No, it is not, in the usual sense of the wonl, of

_— Would you explain how the lead that is in the glass

- gets inside of —

A. That is a matter of solvent action. The glass

2106 is gow alkali.

. Wait until I finish, doctor, please. Will y

uestion so far, Mr. Golding?

red the uation ’s last question was read as recorded.)

o " Schaefer: Q. (Continuing.) —dgets into the liquid

which is placed in the glass bottle?

A. The glass as it is fabricated into bottles contains

lead, and water or other things take up this lead in traces

of definite cmounts that we can estimate in 8.

Q. Now, after the bottle has once been rinsed, will the

et ae into ‘the bottle continue to take up lead from the

A. Yes, it will continue to take up lead.

.Q. Where will that, lead come fron?

' &. It comes from the inside of the coating of the Vidieiee

There is a little silicate formed there.

2 How does if get out? ‘

It is‘a sodium silicate that breaks. up and liberates

cate lead. sine’ some lead silicate with the sodium sili-

ca

Testimony of William D. McNally. 1279

"What do you mean by a lead silicate?

_A. The lead ‘i is there. We put lead in glass: We put

manganese in glass.

2107 Q. No, I want to know what a lead silicate is.

_.. A. It forms with the silicon oxide when it fuses.

Q. What does a lead silicate look like, doctor?

A. White.

Q. Is it visible to the naked eye? -

A. In the form of the amount there, it.is not visible. It

is transparent. :

Q. It is transparent? :

A. It is transparent. It is just like your glass, part of

the structure of that glass. Sodium silicate is water-white

also and in thin portions it would not be discernible to the

eye, until it is ty but if it is fised into glass you would

not notice it at al

_ Q. ‘What tests have you employed to determine the

presence of lead in glass bottles?

A. The Fairhall method. BD

. What is that?

A. ‘And I have used the dithizone method.

Q. Describe that method.

A. Fairhall is the method: I have used in ‘reporting on

lead cases in court.

Q. Will you describe that method?

A. Yes, I wiil be glad to go into it in detail. |

Mr. Rall: How do you spell the other method?

2108 The Witness: The other method is the dithizone

. method... That is the colormetric method. |

We will start with 1000 cc. of water or urine. Let us

‘start with urine. Make it more difficult. To‘ this 1000 ce.

of urine ina silica dish, fused silica dish, we put 15 ce.

of nitric acid. Evaporate this to dryness and ash it.

The nitric acid oxidizes the organic matter in the urea

and sometimes goes’off with a flash, due to sudden combus-

tion of the organic matter.

Then you take it up with distilled water, after it is,

cooled. Add hydrochloric acid and tartaric acid, so if

there are phosphates present the phosphates will not inter-

fere with the lead determination. It will break up any .

calcium phosphates that might be present, :

The acid is completely neutralized, after it has been

filtered from this incineration process. ‘It:is filtered into

an Erlenmeyer flask and neutralized with sodium hydroxide.

To it there is added an indicator, such as methyl orange..

—T

1280 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

We now pass in hydrogen sulphide, this gas ob-

tained from sulphide of iron, to which 1 to 7 a ¢ acid

is added. That is dilute sulphuric acid. s.

_, 2109 Before it is passed into this ‘solution, while we are

. trying to find out whether lead is present, it is washed’

through water and passed into the unknown solution.

The lead sulphidg will precipitaty It may be-in very.

small quantities so. Pest you can hardly see it.. Any iron

that is there will also be taken down as a sulphide.

This is filtered off through a filter paper, washe? with

‘warm water, and dissolved and washed through into

other Erlenmeyer, by means of nitric acid, 1 to 1. e

The nitric acid is now boiled, to free this second filtr

from hydrogen sulphide.

It is then taken up with more water, usually 50 cc.,

~ mame again with sodium hydroxide, until it is alka-

ine

It is then acidified with strong acetic acid, and at this

point one-half cc..of a 10 per cent potassium chromate,

normal chromate, is added.

‘This solution is now boiled for several minutes, covered

and allowed to stand over night, so that the lead will have

an opportunity to be Dae emis as lead chromate, a diffi-

cultly soluble substance

2110 This is now filtered off through a very small filter

paper, washed with warm water, and when found to

be free from chromate by. using dithizone solution we add

hydrochloric acid, 5 to 10 ce. of 1 and 1 strength, washing |

the material into a third clean Erlenmeyer flask.

To this is added 1 ce. of a 20 per cent potassium iodide

solution, also a few drops of hydrochloric acid. In the

presence of lead a blue color will be obtained.

This is now titrated with an N/200 normal solution of

sodium thiosuiphate, and a blank is run using all of these

re-agents as enumerated above, and the blank is subtracted

from any titration that we may obtain in the unknown.

The Master: Off the record, please. | :

(Discussion off the reeord.)

Mr. Schaefer: Q./ When you get ieee what deter-

mination do you have?

A. The determination of tlie lead.

In what?

A. In that sample of water.

Q. In that sample of urine you started out with.

inony of William D. McNally. - 1281.

‘The Master: Just a minute.

Mr) Schaefer: Will you read the question that I

2111 asked the witness? It is quite aways back.

- (The record was read as follows: |

“‘Q. What tests have you employed to determine the

’ presence of lead in glass bottles?

‘A. The Fairhall method.

““Q, What is that?

“A And I have used the dithizone method.

Will you describe that method?’’) ’

My Schaefer: Now I move the answer be stricken.- |

The Master: He is telling you what he did.

Mr. Schaefér: That isn’t what I asked him. What I

am asking the witness is how he determined the presence

‘of lead in glass bottles. He is telling me how he deter-

mines the presence of lead in urine.

The Master: Do you have any different answer than

what you stated, doctor?

The Witness: I stated what I thought was a Bane

answer. ‘If the attorney, young attorney here, will just

clarify what he wants—

Mr. Schaefer: Let us just cut that out. . If the Master

please, I resent that.

The Master: You don’t have to tell us whether the at-

torney is young or old: You can answer the question.

The Witness: Hehad it read to him, sir. Why have it

repeated?

2112 e Master: You have no/ ‘right asa witness to

: chide or take the lawyer to task. Now, you can just

answer the question. What is the question now? You

asked him how he determined the presence of lead in glass

ny ‘

. Mr. Schaefer: That i is right.

_ The Master: Now, is the answer that you gave the

answer you would give to that question?

The Witness: The answer is exactly the same. The

procedure would 8 the same.

Mr. Schaefer: Q. Now, a

ppl |

_ A: I have not finished yet. Seven put me ta finish

it? -

Q. Applying that procedure, doctor, what you deter- .~

mine is the lead content in the material which is placed in

the bottle, is that correct?

Mr. Rall: I am going to object. If the witness is not

permitted to finish the answer to the question, which was

1282 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

for him to describe the method, counsel ought not to be \

permitted to proceed, unless he withdraws the whole ques-

tion.

The Master: Well, let the record stand as it is. made

now. What is the question now?. .

( Mr. Schaefer’s last question was read as above re-

corded.) :

2113 The Witness: A. That is right.

rf Mr. Schaefer: Q. Now, what I want to ‘en |

decker, 1 is how you determine the liad which you have de- ~~

. scribed as being contributed from the glass bottle to the

liquid placed in that bottle. :

A. ell, the same method,. using the same chemical

procedure.

_ Q. You have said that by that procedure you deter-

— the amount 5 lead in the material placed in the bot-

tle?

a .

Q. Now, how do _— determine what percentage of that

lead came from the bottle, if an

A. By taking this same eiedks and evaporating it

in a platinum, dish or in a silica dish which is free from

‘ lead, and running that as a bJartk.

Q. When did you perform such tests with yeapest to

glass milk bottles?

- A. T have been doing that for years and years.

Q.. For what purpose? -

A. Determining the lead content of foods sae foods

stored inglass. ;

2114 from g es a the” i Tien ‘pila

Wisc Thafis all I am interested in.

” I have so answered you.

2 Now, what tests have you performed to deteinhie he

what amount of lead, if any, is contributed from place milk

bottles to the contents of those bottles? fete ass eet

. <A. Applying this same procedure which I “have _just

given you, __.

4 When did you perform those tests? -

I have = them off and on for the last twelve -

or ‘—

Q. wg what purpose? é :

A. Te determine blanks on samples that came. in tor

Sistbiannas of William D. McNally. ' - 1283

the determination of lead. I not only used milk bottles,

‘ but used gallon bottles, brown bottles.

Q. As I understand you, doctor—perhaps we do not

understand one another—as-I understand you, you are say-

ing that what you have done over a period of years was

done in an effort to determine the lead contact of certain

substances? «

A. That were stored in certain kinds of receptacles.

. And —, glass milk bottles? :

a Well, I have had glass milk bottles as one of

them. . .

2115 *Q. Iam interested just in glass milk bottles. +

: A. ¥es, I see..

Q. And your purpose in doing that was to determine

how much, lead was contributed to the milk from the glass

milk bottle? ;

A. Yes. Because I got samples of urine from glass -:

milk bottles and then I found ] in them, and then I

‘would have to run a blank with distilled water to see how

much came from the bottle itself. |

Q. But you don’t know what was done with the bottle

before the urine was put into it, do you?. .

A. No, I do not.

The Master: Q. Have you done that more than once,

doctor?

A. Oh, yes, I havi dorie that repeatedly. :

‘Mt. Schaefer: Q. Now, doctor, I want to know .what

tests you have performed to determine whether or not

once the bottle is rinsed out it continues—rinsed out 80

. that’the liquid in the bottle as it comes from the bottle is

‘entirely free of léad—what tests have you then performed

to determine whether or not another liquid not containing

_ lead;will pick up lead from the glass bottle? |

“ +A. I was only interested possibly in two“or three dif-

‘ferent fields. I was not interested to see whether

2116 sodium hydroxide in milk bottles would pick up more

‘lead, if that is what you are referring to.

Q. No, that is not what I am referring to at all. That

question Was-perhaps not clear. What I want to know is

’ how many times you have repens a glass milk bottle so

that it was free of lead. ,

A: Never could do that.

.Q. What?

, or Never could do that, because it would siwers have .

> 1284 — Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

Q. How many times have you tried to do it?

A. I could not tell you how many times.

Q. Did you ever try to do it?

A. Absolutelys - .

A 9. Now, doctor—

What do you think I am 5 hills you here? A bunch

of falsehoods? Iam a research man. -

The Master: .No, he is just asking you questions.

The Witness: Yes, but I don’t-want him to try any in-

sinuations like that.

‘. The Master: He is not making any insinuations. -

The Witness: ‘‘Did you ever try it?’? What do you

think I am telling you here?

‘The Master: - He j is just asking you and you ean telf

him.

2117 The Witness: Certainly.

Mr. Schaefer: Now, Mr. Golding, will yon read’

the last question before the witness’ most recent outbreak?

(The question referred to was read as follows: ‘‘What

I want to kndw is how many fimes you have prepared a

glass milk bottle so that it was free of lead.’’)

Mr. Schaefer: .Q. Now, what I want to know now, doc-

tor, is the procedure that you- employed in attempting to

prepare a glass milk bottle so that it was free of lead. ;

A. Ecould not do that.

The Master: Q. Let us put it this way. You put in ©

some ogee water to wash ‘it out?

es

Just how carefully did you wash itt

It will always take up some lead again.

The water ould? -

Yes. i Gets

ms How long would you let this distilled water | remain

in the bottle?

A. As long as the fluid contained i in it had been. submit-

* ted to me. If the fluid had been in there seventy-two.

__ hours, then I would run a blank seventy-two hours.

2118 mm” ba © you mean by a blank?. Just an empty

ee

A. You take this bottle. Suppose it contains 800 cubic

centimeters of urine. JI don’t know whether all of that

lead in that urine came from an individual. Some of it

might have come from the glass container. That is not—

onl id bottles, but other bottles. oe

ee |

aor"

Prerers

- ‘Testimony of Wilkam D. McNally. 1285

It-will do the same thing. So we allow the same _

amous Auid to stay in that container.

Distilled water? , .

rom the time the party submitted it to us, and

they say this was in this bottle twenty-four hours. Then

I am only. satisfied with distilled: water. staying there

twenty-four hours, and then I run that right through this

process, and it may show a trace and it may show—

°Q. . The idea is to make a comparison?

A. We have to subtract the amount of lea#from this

particular container. oe

Q.: Now, the distilled water would,not contain any lead? —

A. No. It is distilled. | if

_ °Q. You put that into the glass bottle? _

.2119 <A. That is as free as far as possible.

Q. And you permit that distilled water to remain

in the glass bottle the same length of time that the—

A. That the ‘unknown was in that same condition,

whether it is a milk bottle or another kind of bottle.

The Master: Does that answer your question?

Mr. Schaefer: Pretty well, yes, sir. "Cena

_ QQ. The tests that you have described then or that you

have referred to were your control blank tests?

A. That is the blank test. We have to run those on

everything that comes in.

Q. I thought you testified on direct examination that —

everything contained lead. Did I misund’rstand you?

A. Practically everything does contain lead, as you

say: The water that you are drinking every day has got

lead in it. If you drink beer, it has got lead in it. If you

drink whisky, it has got lead in it. °Jf you drink wine it

has got up to 124 milligrams of lead per liter of wine. So

there is hardly a thing that you can touch—oysters, grains,

De epi * ag has got lead in it. .

Q. Now, this distilled water to which you referred,

-however, does not have any lead? bodes 2S eee

“f A. It does-net-have any lead that we can deter-

2120 mine by the Fairhall method. Using the dithizone

method, which is a more delicate test, it might- show

the presence of some metal there, because it is frequently —

distilled from metal. That is why we do not use the dithi-

zone method on metals, because it gives the results from

/ other metals here, like a host of metals, unless it is espec- -

lally’ carried out. eect | .

oy .

o

_ 1286 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

Q. . That is, you cannot segregate one metal from an-

other? : | ;

- fA, Yes.

Q. I don’t know whether I got your figures correct on

your direct examination or not, doctor. You said that -nor-

mal people in the Chicago area eliminated 9/100 of a milli-

gram from a liter of urine?

A. That is the maximum we ‘find i in students and other

people not. engaged in lead industries.

? ®. Now, the other figure I was not sure that I got right. -

is this: “You said, as I understood you, 1 milligram \ ap

of a milligram per liter in urine would indicate—

A. @bsorption of lead. :

“2. ey ould indicate absorption of lead?

A. From one-tenth of a milligram. ;

Q. Per liter? | ; ten

A. Per liter of urine, yes. Poet y

2121 Q. Then. your margin is— .

A. Only one hundredth of a milligram,. yes. Most

of them in this area run near eight hundredths, but occa-

sionally we find one that runs nine hundredths, ‘80 we

have to use that figure.

Q. Now, .will you describe the way these ink offsets -

' to which you referred in your direct examination appear

gander, the microscope?

A. They do not appear like the ink that I said the —

stenographer is using. Can I have your paper - —_

Master?

. ' The Master: Yes. Take a plain sheet.

The Witness: Take @ne liter. There are innumerable p

little dots. They are all microscopic.- Wherever he. has —

taken this pen there is a deposition of pigment, under the _

‘ microscope. Now, with this other we do not get these fine ~

* dots. s—

The Master: _Q. What other? / a

A. With the linseed.oil inks. |“ ? PhO ®

ai + / Q. Which was used on these containers?

A. Yes. We get these things in little shining particles.

They are not little dots. Some of them will be very small,

like this, but many of them will be confluent, or where

| they have run together. So then you get a form

: 2122 _ you consider mpre of a smear under the micro-

a than this other would be.

Mr. "Se efer: Q. Regular or irregular?

A. _ spd are — Some of them are very

/

Testimehyof William D. McNally. | 1287

fines Some of them are made of particles one hundred

times the size of these small particles. In other words,.

it would be like a daub of your ink being pressed on there

and squashed out, in contradistinction to these little dots

. here. \. “ Neshe , |

” Q. Would it be entirely flat under the microscope?

A. No, it is raised. py ;

. Q. Raised uniformly?

A. No, it is not. - :

Q. iItisirregular? —

A. _It is irregular. Anything that is stamped is ir-

- ‘regular. Look at your hazor blade and you will see a

‘saw tooth edge on at that will surprise you under the mi--.

-eroscope, where ae i you look at it with your eye it is

‘perfectly smooth. “£lvat is the way it is with ink. ; :

.Q. Now, in answering Mr. Rall’s question as to the

health hazard to a person drinking milk from the hypo-

thetical container which he described to you, you based

your answer that there would be no health hazard upon

the insolubility of the ink and, hence, upon the i

2123 possibility of the lead in the ink getting into the milk?

_ A. On the insolubility of the lead linolate, lea

pigment, getting into the milk, yes. You see, it is eovered

over by this film of linseed oil and it is also covered by a*

film of your.paraffin. Both of thése things are insoluble

in fresh milk./ Si.

. Now, let us assume as you did in responding to

Mr. Rall’s question, that the application-of paraffin has

_not, for some reason, been effective. Then your answer

is based entirely on the insolubility of the ink in the milk,

_ is that-correct? |

“i ee, < ue :

by Master: Q. Which is it? Of the ink or of the.

lead? ae et ,

- A. The insolubility of the ink, the ink being made of

-this pigment, whether it is manganese, cgbalt or lead. ,

Q. That is, no part of the ‘ink would be ‘soluble in

A.’ In the fresh milk, no. - s

Mr, Schaefer: Q. The lead is the pigment, is it not?

A.’ That is only part of the pigment. rs

Q. The oil is the vehicle? .” aathge: . .

A. The oil and the gums are the vehicle and they

2124 usually have a coloring matter.in there.” Sometimes

_ it is lead chromate or it may be other things that are

1288 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

used for color. ‘Where it is green or red, ‘they might use

an iron. Those are called the pigments.

- Q. Now, assume that that offset in the rough, irregular

form in which you ‘have described it, gets inte the milk

by means of handling the container, by: means of friction,

_ or by any other means, in insoluble form. Would that be’

beneficial to the health of the person drinking the milk?

0. a the offset, ip the amount you refer to?

es.

- A. You are talking about the inside, under the worst

-possible condition, as exhibited here today. 1 dori think

“enough lead would come off thefe, if it was all scraped

off, to do any harm

Q. What I asked you, ieee was whether or not it was

beneficial to health.

_A. Lead.taken in is not: Beneficial, in my opinion, in

any form. Whether taken in in food, wine or anything

else, it is going to be deposited in the bones. it may cause

- e no ill effects at all.

Q. Now, I will ask the other question : els it disad-

vantageous to the health of ‘he individual who ~

2125 drinks that milk?

- « A. I know of no ill effects coming frou peo

‘consuming foods containing one hundred or more mi i

‘grams, up to four hundred milligrams a day of lead, as is

found in our foods, since I have said that/all foods ‘would

contain some lead.

_. Mr. Schaefer: Now, will you read the question to the

witness? mes

; (Mr. Schaefer’s last question was read to the witnéss as

& ~-above recorded,)

The Master: Q. Apply to that the amount of lead

that may be found in this offset.

A. That would:be very much legs, from the appearance

- of the offset on the inside. : at.

~ Q. Do you have any idea as te the amount of lead if —

the printing itself were on the inside of the container?

A. No, I have not any idea how much those letters

_ would contain.

Q. ‘Would you say it was up to this one/hundred or four

hundred milligrams you were just talking about? «.

A. The whole: amount there? ° @

Q.. Yes. ° :

A. Could I have one of. these and ‘cut. it er , Sane

2126 pare ee you more. Give me one that is: not an’

1 ao . a Pad

> <2.

t

an a

Testimony of William D. McNally. 1289

(Wi itness cuts into a carton.)

“This is the one that contains the most lead, as I un-

derstand, contains 30 per cent of lead. i om

Q. You mean the ink?

A. The ink contains 30: per cent of. lead. I think if

_all of this ink in here were to be put in a—

Mr. Schaefer: Referring to the printed surface of the

container?

The Witness: A. (Continuing.) —platinum dish—

- Mr. Rall: Referring to the outside or obverse of a“flat

blank similar to Plaintiff’s Exhibit 91.

Mr. Schaefer: Printed: side.

‘Mr. Ralle Printed side. - -

The Witness:' Ax I.think this would contain a hundred

milligrams, easily, if this were all oxidized. If-we could

just remove all of these letters as is and subject it to a

chemical examination, we could tell: There is quite a.

little pigment segregated here, Apthough it is a vi thin

coating. | The coating is microscopic in size.

Master: Q. It is what? :

Aw’ The coating is microscopic in size. It is very thin.

All of this’ ink, or as much of it as could be

. 2127 rubbed off into, the 1 milk, you say would contain less

than a milligram of lead?

A. I think it would contain close to a hundred milli-

grams. It might bea little-bit more. The bands are quite |

-heavy on the bottom ‘there and they are widg.

Q. Would you consider that a detrimental to health?’

' .A. No. I could take a hundred milligrams of lead, and. —

probably | do, and probably all of us do take several ‘hun-

dred milligrams of lead every day in our food. |

Q. Would you say that would be j injurious to an infant

five months old? —

A. Nothing so insoluble as this; I doubt whether it

would hurt anybody. It is only when it becomes soluble

and entérs the blood stream. If you got.my definition of

a ‘poison this nforning, a poison is a substance. which,

‘when it enters the blood stream and acts chemically is.

‘ eapable of seriously affecting health or causing death.

- So this stuff would have to go in solution. I could give.

you a teaspoon full of barium sulphate and it would not

hart you at all, aan if Sint 3 give you a teaspoon full of barium

another salt, I could kill ygu. It is the’

nes solubility of. these — that makes them act as

poisons.

“

ais

_ 1290 i Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

Q. Even though that. may not be soluble. in the milk,

ean that become soluble in the system? |

A. No, I doubt very much if that would become soluble.

I think most of this would be eliminated.as a lead salt by |

the gastro-intestinal tract in the feces. . 3

.Q. Let us assume now that this lead in the ink on. the

container would amount to, say, six hundred milligrams?

A. And it were soluble or insoluble? .

' Q. No, also insoluble. And it got into the milk and

were consumed by a person. Would that lead, six hun-

dred s, or even a thousand milligrams ‘affect the

_ health or be detrimental to the health of that individual?

"A. When you get up into large figures: like that, yes,

because there might be some of this lead—I don’t know

‘what form.they use, outside of the lead oxide. They may

use a litharge. A litharge is slightly soluble in gastric

juices and intestinal juices. But the form of the lead in

a linseed oil preparation is difficultly soluble, and I think

that “ be eliminated unchanged.

‘Even though you on a thousand milligrams?

. 2129 A. Ninety-eight per cent of it would be eliminated

_. unchanged, because its solubility is ‘only about 2. 3

per cent in gastric juices.

Q. Let us assume you had a thousand one in a

cantainer of milk and an infant less than five months old

should consume some of this milk; would you say that

would not hurt the infant.in any way?

A. It depends on how much went into solution.

Q. That went into solution i in the body?

A: That went. into solution in the body, yes, sir.

Q. It would. not go into solution in the ?

A. No, sir.

. . Then the mere fact it is insoluble in the milk does

‘not indicate that it may: hot be partially soluble in the

“— ey

o, sir. Some of it might go into solution in ‘the

MS. B+ acid and gastric’ juices in the stomach, which .

' I know does happen, and ‘also in the bile. But in dog

experiments, where I used lead acetate, a very soluble

_ substance, I recovered over 94 per cent of the lead found

in the urine and stool. Those experiments covered over

a.year’s time. Metabolism cases. -

Q. Would you say then, a thousand milligrams of lead

: contained i ir this sort of ink, in a container of milk,

2130 and fed to a baby less than five — old, might |

or might not cause injury? }

o

, Testimony of William D.. Metall 1293

.A. It might, yes. A thousand is a lot of

satis "Tate ‘one gram or 1545 grains t has a lot of

foreign materials ut into a body of a baby. |

Q. But a hund milligrams, which you say is the .

amount contained here, would not cause any damage? :

_ A. I don’t think that would hurt, because we are tak-

that much in our food all the time.

But a child? ;

ee A child is. getting that in its dextrose maltose and °

in the milk it is taking. : *

The Master: -Go pay Mr. Schaefer.

that-normal people in the Chicago area eliminated nine

hundredths: milligrams per liter of urine? :

. The Master: In the weight. = a

The Witness: A. Nine hundredths of a ‘iis: 09.

The. Master: The weight of the lead in a liter?

Mr. Schaefer: That is what I mean.

The Witness: That is the maximum normal.

eee ce ‘Mr. Schaefer: Q. How much would that be in-

| 2131, creased to eliminate one hundred milligrams of lead?

@. Po. How much would that have to be increased?

es.

“A. ‘That would have to be tiioreaned: many thousand fold

to get a hundred milligrams. You see, if it is increased ten

- times we would have nine-tenths milligrams and that would

— to be increased ninety-nine times, practically, i in order.

et a hundred milligrams of lead.

st Yes. Now, you had a margin, I understood you to

‘say, of one-hundredth of a milligram between the indica-

‘tion of lead intoxication and the normal amount of lead

eliminated in urine?

A. That is right. Anything over nine hundredths. That -

is the high normal. That begins to show manifestations of

lead. . But that has to be modified; too. I find people every

now and then that have eighteen hundredths, twice that

amount, and still do not: show any signs: of lead intoxication,

no lead. line, no gastric disturbance: and no decrease inthe

lead count or hemoglobin. So there are exceptions to that.

I had a case just last week where double the amount was

found in the urine, and the man was not suffering from

__ lead poisoning. He happened to be suffering from a

2132 dysentery or food poisoning, but he was a painter, so

we had to examine him to see if lead was a factor. ~-

_ Q.. But where you get double the normal elimination of.

» Mr. Schaefer: Q: Now, going back a ‘moment, you said

ee

1292 Transcript of Testimony Before Master.:

lead, without getting indications of lead intoxication, other

- indications, the occurrence is rather abnormal? ;

' A. . That is abnormal. Anythirig over .09, or 90 Series

of the cases where it is over .08 would give you that.

my book I give the figure of .08, but we have run a lot ame

_ that figure, and I believe now that 09 for Cook County and

' Chicago is probably the figure.

2 Now, for a person to get rid ‘of 100 milligrams of

lead taken into the system through the mouth would require

that volume of de elimination to be increased substan-

tially, wouldn’t it? I think you said ten times. -

A. You are figur guring on urine, of course. : All of that

. would not be eliminated by the urine. 90 per cent and over .

_ of these animals, 94 per cent was all eliminated by the stool.

- Doctor, when you testified to your figure of pine

hundredths of a milligram per liter, you were not con-

2133 sidering the amoutit eliminated by the stool either, -

.. Wereyouf* §-

A. No, but we know it is liminated all the same. ;

Q. So we know that we fre comparable. |

_ A. That person could have been taking two hundred

milligrams of lead a day and that amount show a speci-

men which we are taking into consideration.

_ Q. Now, doctor, agsuming that lead from p&per milk

containers is taken into the humah body in the manner I

have described ;.will th béneficial upon the health

of the individual + who takes i ,

Mr. Rall: I am going to. object to that question. There ,

_ is no evidence here that any lead is taken into the human

body from milk containers. .

‘The Master: Overruled. Go ahead und answer.

The Witness: A. In what amount did youstate?

‘ net Schaefer: Q. First, i in any amount, will it be bene-

’ fici :

‘A. I know of no pathological chan es in the human body

from the normal ae of lead from our — lay

foods.

| °Q. Translate it. “That mea we iv ;

~ A. In other words, it means the lead we are taking in

our foods, which would include this milk, dees not exert a

change in the liver, the kidney, the heart, the lungs,

-2134 the stomach or the bowels. ©

That is, you know of no beneficial effect?

A. I know of no pathological changes seen in the organs ©

of some twelve thousand — whose organs . I have

“ 3

a

‘Pestinenp of William D. McNally. | 1293 ;

examined, and_all of them were taking lead every day into

their systems.

Q. “Now, tlie effect of lead on the human body depends,

I sappowes quite largely on the quantity taken?

the manner in which it is takeny By the gastro

intestinal route the effects are the least. By inhalation the

bey on damage is done, because is it inhaled by the in-

ividual arid does not go through the portal system and is

| immediately taken up in the blood, and goes to all the or-

gans of the bedy and is deposited in the ones as basic tri-

calcium lead phosphate.

Q. “And the quantity taken in is an important factor?

A. The quantity taken in is an important factor.

‘Q: Now, the total quantity of lead in the human body is

one of the factors which determines whether or not that

person will suffer from lead intoxication, isn’t that correct?

‘A. That person, yes. If that person has absorbed ‘a con-

siderable amount of lead from his daily intake of food,

2135 which contains lead, and then he is subjected to insults

of something that contains more lead, he is storing up

_ lead in his bones that some day might come out with a rush

and cause illness.

bere. “h Q: Provided that this léad j is: taken’ i in in

aolanee for

as ve be in soluble form in order to get in the

‘blow stream. It has got to go through the little ventricles

and capillaries to get into the blood stream and then it is

carried to all parts of the body and finally takes the place

of the calcium in the bones and is deposited there as basic

- phosphate.

Mr. Schaefer: Q. Is an increase in the amount of lead —

taken into the human body desirable?

‘A. No. Lead is not a desirable factor, any more than

arsenic or manganese. Any metal that does not enter into’

_ the metabolism of the human bodpshould not be taken into

the system, if we can prevent it, but in the form of food we

cannot separate the lead from the food, from. our beer, our

wine, our drinking water.

Q. . Now, doctor, when you determined the presence of

lead in glass milk bottles, in what quantity did you find it?

- A. That varied from traces, where distilled water _

2136 had stood only over night, eighteen to twenty-four-

-hours to water that had stood in similar bottles where

2.12 milligrams of lead were found in a thonsand cc. This

ee ore of — was es chowing that water had

1294 ‘Transcript of Testimony Before Master.

acted on it or other things had acted upon the bottle itself.

All milk bottles gradually become cloudy; or if water stands

in them for some time you can find a ring formed at the top

of this water. That not only ap — to milk bottles, but —

other types. of bottles. Even our. glassware will get a

cloud i in it where solutions have Bes m or for some time, :

showing that the water and other substances in

- had acted upon: the glass. Glass always has some sodium

sailfeats present, and that makes it alkaline, and that alka-

ey we there dissolves out some lead. |

rom what? .

3 Dissolves. The alkalinity of that water from the

sodium silicate dissolves out lead. |

Q. From what?

A. From‘the glass itself, in the water.

~ And the highest you found was what?

A. It was 2.12.

Q. What was the average? ~

. A. Well, the lowest was a trace. If I ron thirty

2137 or forty of these I would simply have to add up all of

them. 7 could not give you the average, because. I

oy got ali of the figures.

he at do you mean by a trace? A measurable quan-

ti :

A. No. Where we could not titrate it. ‘But we knew

there was a coloration, either by the dithizone method or

by the Fairhall method, up to where I titrated enough in

the end where two hundred solutions gave me 2.2 milligrams

of lead, and that would have to be subtracted from the

1000 cc. of the unknown, in: ‘order to arrive at a: proper

factor.

Q. You do not remember now the average?

A. No, I would not remember it. That has been done

over a period of, years and I would. not have the records

back when we were doing that.

Q. _ Do you know of your own knowledge whether or not:

paraffined paper. containers, like Plaintift’ ’s Exhibit 2, are

absorbent? .~* oy

A. Absorbent in what way?

Q. Absorbent in any way.

A.. — anything t

‘ Q

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Transcript of Record — Chicago v. Fieldcrest Dairies, Inc. · 316 U.S. 168 | Frix