Transcript of Record — Parker v. Motor Boat Sales, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1942
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
Pitt Ah
Bp 4 ER” ft
} Livin]
COURT OF THR U
NITED
beeen Pi gewe, Pd
BEE Ey CCAS rt FO.
STATES ENMPIANEES COMPEASA TION
SION, PETITIONER
Vpordook
STATES
NPE
COONENETS
BOVE SALES. INCOROPORA FED
PE PEGLON
fer’
CEREIOR ARS ELb
CERTIORNR VER! GhANVED MAY
APRIL 3
Pn aie ee
pod
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OcToBER TERM, 1940
No. —
E. V. PARKER. DEPUTY COMMISSIONER FOR THE
FIFTH COMPENSATION DISTRICT OF THE UNITED
STATES EMPLOYEES’ COMPENSATION COMMIS-
SION, PETITIONER
vs.
MOTOR BOAT SALES, INCORPORATED
ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT
—----
INDEX
Original Vrint
Record from ID). C. U. S., Eastern District of Virginia ! 1
Caption [omitted in printing] | 1
Bill of complaint —— -- l 1
Exhibit A-- Compensation order, Jan. 17, 1940 9 7
Motion to dismiss __ _ 13 st)
Order filing answer —_ - : 14 10
Answer a 14 11
Defendant's exbibit A filed at Court hearing:
Statement of evidence before Deputy Commissioner_ 17 12
Caption and appearances 17 12
Statement of defense. _. 18 12
Stipulation re proof of death : 19 13
Evidence on behalf of claimant:
Jessie Armistead 19 14
Exhibit 1— Marriage license (eee 21 15
George W. Todd_-—-- 27 20
George Purcell Armistead, Sr__ — 35 25
Phil Goode. - 36 26
Welford Farl Lloyd_. 39 27
Defendants exhibit 1--Weekly schedule
for George P. Armistead, Jr__- : 43 30
I
ite
II INDEX
Record from D. C. U. &., Eastern District of Virginia—Con.
Defendant's exhibit A—Continued.
Statement of evidence—Continned.
Evidence on behalf of defendant. Original Print
SN SI ck Se exnaws gan snevee sn 49 34
Welford Earl Lloyd... -.-.--.-- a2 57 39
William Crown... ---_----. - ; 59 41
John Samuel Cooper... _— -. piey oe 64 44
S. King Fulton. . Serer 71 4u
Reporter's certificate lomitted i in printing]. et 76 52
Claimant's exhibit 1—Coroner’s certificate... __- 78 52
Memorandum opinion, Pollard, J..........--. ----.—-,. 81 54
Motion of Plaintiff for leave to reargue case, etc. _- ag &4+ 56
Order refusing motion to reargue case, ete... ----- ~~ - 36 57
Final Decree____ - as Be ay REO RO ee 87 58
Peiition for Appeal... <a ae waaee Ser eee epee 90 60
Order allowing Appeal- -- -- RR AP a Eas 93 62
Assignments of Error... -. -. ny 93 62
Clerk's Memorandum as to Appeal Bond and Cc itation_ —- 95 64
Stipulatio:r, of Proctors as to omission of certain pleadings
in the Record on Appeal. __-- 96 64
Stipulation of Proctors as to what shall « constitute the
Record on Appeal _ - ; sare deeton 98 66
Clerk's Certificate (omitted in printi x).- pay! ies 100 67
Proceedings in the U.S. C. C. A., Fourth Circuit _- 101 67
Docket entries. _._---. ee j 101 67
Opinion, Dobie, J____. - : : i 7 103 68
Decree _ ; ; : 118 78
Recital 2s to issuance of mandate —__ — -. 118 78
Order authorizing clerk to use origina] transcripts of records. - 119 79
Clerk's certificate [omitted in printing]... — — -- eer 120 79
Comes -dliowine Cetin... sn ee 6 er ea eaawes 80
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 1
{| Caption omitted. ]
In United States District Court, Eastern District of Virginia
No. 1507—Miscellaneous
Motor Boat Sates, INCORPURATED, PLAINTIFF
Ms,
E. V. Parker. Deputy ComMIssIONER. FIFTH COMPENSATION
DistRIcT, DEFENDANT
Bill of complaint
(Filed February 9, 1940)
Zo the honorable Rosert N. Potuarp, Judge of the District Court
of the United States for the Eastern District of Virginia:
(1) The Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated, a corporation under
the laws of the State of Virginia and licensed to do business
therein, brings you this, its bill of complaint against E. V. Parker,
Deputy Commissioner for the Fifth Compensation District of the
United States Employees’ Compensation Commission, he being a
resident of the City of Washington, in the District of Columbia,
‘vith his offices as said Deputy Commissioner in the City
2 of Norfolk, in the Post Office Building of said City, State
of Virginia;
(2) This bill of complaint in equity is filed by the plaintiff
for the purpose of reviewing and setting aside an order for com-
pensation made by E. V. Parker, Deputy Commissioner for the
Fifth Compensation District of the United States Employees’ Com-
pensation Commussion under the Longshoremen’s and Harbor
Workers’ Compensation Act as enacted by the Congress of the
United States on March 4, 1927, being Section 901 et seq., ‘Title :
of the Code of Laws of the United States, which said C saaeeee-
tion order was made and entered by the said Deputy Commis-
sioner on January 17, 1940, a copy thereof being attached hereto,
made a part hereof and marked Exhibit A;
(3) Plaintiff. the Corporation named in said compensation order
as employer, was during the time stated engaged exclusively in
the business of buying and selling at retail maritime supplies of
all kinds, including the sale of smal! bouts ready for delivery and
io go not larger than the yacht class, and outboard gasoline motors
and parts from its retail store located at 3 West Grace Street, in
the City of Richmond, Virginia, but it was not engaged in the
business of servicing beats or doing any installation, repair, or
on
2 BE. V. PARKER Vs. MOTCR BOAT SALES, INC.
other work on navigable waters: that the defendant, Jessie B,
Armistead. is the purported widow of George PL Armistead. Jr.
deceased employee. and the mother of three minor children, Doro-
thy Marian Armistead, an admittedly legitimate child. born
March v4. 1933. before she was married to George P. Armistead,
Jr: George Percell Armistead TIT. born October 3, 1934; and
William Berkley Armistead, born March 26, 1938;
(4) That George P. Armistead, Jr., claimant's decedent, was em-
proved by the plaintiif as ‘a janitor and handy man” to do the
work of opening plaintiff's said store in the mornings, cleaning up
the store and the several apartments over it, washing windows,
clerning outboard motors, buffing tanks, driving automobile, and
noaking deliveries on land. with instructions not to work or go upon
navigable waters at any time: that on August &, 1938, the
3 date he was drowned, he was directed by another employee
to load two outboard gasoline motors from plaintiff's store
inte sts automobile and to transport them from the store to the
Jaws River, his only duties being to assist in loading these two
outboard motors from the store into the automobile, driving the
automobile from there down to the James River, a distance of
about two miles, and in lifting the two outboard motors out of the
automobile and delivering them to the mechanic, another employee
who was sent and directed to severally attach the outboard motors
toa small boat owned by a Mr. Crown, a third party, for the pur-
pose of allowing him to test the outboard motors out on his small
boat on James River: that the outboard motors were thereafter
separately and successively attached to the end of the Crown boat,
which was up on the bank of the river at the times they were se
attached, and the boat was thereafter shoved into the river; that
therenpon George P. Armistead, Jr.. the deceased employee, after
he had performed the work he had been directed to do, in viola-
tion of his instructions not to go upon navigable waters while
working for the plaintiff, of his own will and accord got into the
Crown boat, without directions to do so from anyone, and of his
own volition, and was riding therein for his own enjoyment and
pleasure when the boat accidentally capsized without any fault or
negligence of the plaintiff or the owner of the boat, and the said
Armistead, Jr.. was drowned at a time when he was not engaged
in performing any work he had been employed or directed to do by
the plaintiff, or otherwise ;
(3) That thereafter, on October 14, 1938, the defendant, Jes=ie
Booker Armistead, as widow of the said George P. Armistead, Jr..
filed a claim with the Deputy Commissioner for the Fifth Com-
pensation District, claiming compensation under the Longshore-
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES. INC. 3
men’s and Harbor Workers’ Act for herself and on behalf of the
above-named three minor children: that the said Deputy Com-
missioner assumed jurisdiction thereof; that the plaintiff, em-
ployer, under date of October 14. 1938, gave notice to the Deputy
Commissioner that the claim would be controverted and all de-
fenses made under the said Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’
Compensation Act that could be lawfully made: that the
4 Act itself did not apply to or cover the plaintiff, Motor Boat
Sales. Incorporated, employer, or deceased eniployee: that
the death of the employee, George P. Armistead, Jr. did not
result from injuries arising out of and in the course of his employ-
ment. and that he was not an employee in “maritime employment”
or within the coverage of the Act; that the plaintiff, the employer,
was net engaged in maritime business; and that the Act, if it
attempted to make the plaintiff. employer, Hable under these cir-
cumstances, was unconstitutional: that the Deputy Commissioner,
on October 13, 1939. took testimony of certain witnesses produced
before him, and, thereafter on January 17, 1940, made findings
of facts and law and an award to claimant, Jessie Booker Armi-
stead, for herself and for the three minor children, all of which
more fully appears from Exhibit A attached hereto, reference
to which is hereby made: that the compensation award was as
follows:
“That the employer, Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated, shall pay
to the claimant death benefits as follows: For herself, as widow,
$4.725 per week, and in addition $1.35 per week each, on account
of the children, Dorothy Marian Armistead, George Percell
Armistead [I], and William Berkley Arimistead. Accrued death
benefits covering the period August & 1939, to January 14. 1940,
amounting to $658.13, shall be paid forthwith. Thereafter, pay-
ments shall be made biweekly in installments of $17.55, to continue
until there is a change in conditions. The employer shall also
pay $190.00 to George P. Armistead. Sr. as reimbursement for
fureral and burial expenses paid by him and 3250.00 fee for
plaintitf’s counsel :”
(6) That the claim for compensation, the testimony taken before
and submitted tu the defendant. Deputy Commissioner, and tie
award, are all in his custody, and it is necessary for the Court to
have possession of all of said records in order to determine
whether or not the claim falls within the coverage of the Long-
sho ‘men’s and Harbor Workers’ Act, ‘Title 33, U. S. C. A.. See-
tio =O1_ et seq., and to determine whether or not the Deputy
Commissioner had jurisdiction, and jus order and award are
4 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BCAT SALES, INC.
without evidence to support them, and are in accordance with
law:
D (7) That the claim of claimant for compensation on ac-
count of the death of George P. Armisiead, Jr., does not
fall within the coverage of the Longshoremen’s and Harbor
Workers’ Compensation Act: that E. V. Parker, Deputy Com-
missioner, was without jurisdiction to entertain such claim, and
that the order and award made by him are without evidence to
support them and are not in accordance with law and are erroneous
for the reasons that:
The death of George P. Armistead, Jr. claims it’s decedent,
was not cansed by and did not result in the trade, business, occu-
pation, or profession of the employer, the plaintiff: that the em-
ployment of George P| Armistead, Jr.. claimant’s decedent, was
not maritime, and that he was not emploved in maritime employ-
ment, in Whole or in part, upon the navigable waters of the United
States: that his death did not occur in the usual course of his
employment or under circumstances which include com pensation
for his death under the Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’
Act. Title 388, UL S.C. A., Seetions 901, et seq.; that he was not
employed as a longshoreman or harbor worker; that he was not
actually engaged in any employment in the usual course of the
trade, business. occupation, or profession of the plaintiff. or per-
forming any work he hat been employed or directed to do; that
he had no employment which required him at the time he was
drowned to navigate, be on, or ride in the vessel, a small boat
owned and belonging to a Mr. Crown, a third party. on navigable
waters, or to do maritime work thereon, and that in and while he.
was riding in said small boat the relationship of master and ser-
vant did not exist; and that he was riding in the boat in violation
of his employment and instructions cf the plaintiff not to go or
work upon navigable waters while engaged in and working for
the plaintiff; that his death resulted from the voluntary act of
claimant’s decedent in riding of his own volition and accord and
for his own purpose and pleasure and outside and beyond his
employment in a small vessel owned by a third party; that the
Congress of the United States may not impose hability on
6 an employer to pay compensation for the death of an
emplovee except where by virtue of the existence of em-
ployment on navigable waters and in the performance of a duty
resulting from the relationship of master and servant: that the
assumption of jurisdiction by the Deputy Commissioner and his
findings of fact and law and construction of the Act, Title 33.
U.s. C. A. 901, et seq.. to the contrary render the Longshore-
men’s and Harbor Workers’ Act unconstitutional, especially as
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 5
to Article 3 and the 5th and 14th Amendments to the Constitution
of the United States; that the determination of the existence of
such jurisdictional prerequisite may not under law and the Coa-
stitution of the United States be left to the decision of adminis-
trative tribunals, but is lodged in and must be determined by a
Court: that the Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’ Compen-
sation Act provides, among other things, that :
“Sec. This Act shall not apply to the injury or death of
* * * (4) An employee engaged in any employment that is
casual and not in the usual course of the trade, business, occupa-
tion, or profession ef the employer” * * *;
that George P. Armistead, Jr., the claimant's decedent's, in going
into and upon and riding in the small boat and on navigable
waters, did so casually, and was not in the usual course of his
employment and of the trade or business of the plaintiff, and that
the employment of claimant’s decedent, George P. Armistead, Jr.,
was local, and that he was not in said boat or on navigable waters
in pursuit of maritime employment or in the performance of any
work he was or had been employed, directed, or paid to do.
(8) Plaintiff herein will be irreparably damaged if an inter-
locutory injunction is not granted and the payment of compensa-
tion under said award insofar as the plantiff is concerned stayed
pending the final hearing of this cause; that the plaintiff herein
has no adequate remedy of law and has no means of redress of the
wrongs of which he complains except through injunctive pro-
ceedings to set aside the award as made and rendered against the
plaintiff, and this Court should, therefore, grant, upon proper
hot:e, an interlocutory injunction staying the payment or
payments awarded by said Deputy Commissioner until the
7 final determination of this cause.
Wherefore plaintiff prays:
(a) That this Court take jurisdiction of the subject matter of
this suit ;
(b) That a mandatory injunction be granted by and issue from
this Court to the defendant, E. V. Parker, Deputy Commissioner
of the Fifth Compensation District of the United States, com-
manding him within a certain number of days from receipt thereof,
to deliver to this Court or its Clerk, a transcript of the record in re
Jessie Booker Armistead, widow of George P. Arniistead, Jr.,
claimant, against Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated, employer, being
case No, 825-1; that upon application of the plaintiff an inter-
locutory injunction be issued staying all payments ordered by the
said Deputy Commissioner in said compensation order and award
6 E. V. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
of compensation herenmabove described, pending final determina
tion of this catise ;
(c) That upon final hearing a pertaanent injunction be granted
and issued, permanently enjoining and staying all payments
ordered by said Deputy Commissioner to be paid in said conpen-
sation order and award of compensation ;
(d) That upon final hearing it be decreed by this Court that the
said compensation order and award of compensation, made by said
Deputy C ommussioner, Was without evidence to support it or con-
trary te the character of the evidence, and was not in accordance
with law, and was in violation of the Constitution of the United
States, and that the said Deputy Commissioner was without juris-
diction to entertain said claim or make said award, and that same
be vacated, set aside, and held to be of no force, virtue, or effect ;
(e} That this Court issue its writ of subpoena directed to said
defendant, demanding him upen a certain day and under a certain
penalty to be therein specified, to appear before this Court and to
answer, but not under oath, answer under oath being hereby
expressly waived, all and singular the matters nd things
herein set forth and complained of and to stand, abide by
8 and perform all orders and decrees ef this Court which
may be entered herein; and that the plaintiff herein may
have such other and further relief as he may be entitled to ip
equity and good conscience.
And your complainant will ever pray.
This suit is brought pursuant to an order of the Board of Diree-
tors of said Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated, dated Feb. 6, 1940.
(Sgd.) Movor Boat Sares, [Ncorporaren.
By (Sgd.) oS. Krne Furtron, /ts President.
(Sed.) M. J. Funton,
Counse d of Re cord for Plaintiff,
Motor Boat Sales, Lncorporite d.
520 Mutual Building, Richmond, Virginia.
[| Duly sworn to by 8S. Ring Fulton; jurat omitted in printing.|
1, the undersigned M. J. Fulton, counsel of record in the above
entitled cause, hereby certify that the above affidavit and applica-
tion made by Motor Roat Sales. Incorporated, are made in good ~
faith by him.
Le (Sed.) M. J. Frito,
r Counsel of Record for Plaintiff.
Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated.
ae
nD
4
7
s
;
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
~j
i)
E-rhthit A to hill of complaint
Unrrep States Employees’ ComrensatioN ComMMISSION
FIFTH COMPENSATION DISTRICT
In the matter of the claim for compensation under the Long-
shoremen’s and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act.
Jessie Booker ARMISTEAD, Wipow oF Gporce P. ArRMISTEAD. JR.
( DecEAseD), CLAIMANT
aR,
Motor Boat Saves, INc., EMPLOYER
Compensation Order—Award of Compensation—Case No, 825-1
No insurance
Such investigation in respect to the above-entitled claim having
beer: made as is considered necessary, and a hearing having been
duly held in conformity with law.
The Deputy Commissioner makes the following
FINDINGS OF FACT
That on .he 8th day of August 1938 George P. Armistead, Jr.,
was in the employ of the employer above named at Richmond,
in the State of Virginia, in the Fifth Compensation District, estab-
lished under the provisions of the Longshoremen’s and Harbor
Workers’ Compensation Act, and that the liability of the employer
for compensation under said Act was uninsured; that on said day
George P. Armistead, Jr., while performing service for the em-
ployer upon the navigable waters of the United States, sustained
personal injury, resulting in his death, while he was employed as
a janitor and handyman; that on said day Armistead had been
ordered by his superiors to assist a mechanic, a fellow employee,
in carrying two outboard motors, the property of the company, to
the river and attach them to the stern of a motorboat for the pur-
pose of testing the same and interesting the owners of the motor-
boat in the sale of one of the said motors: that upon reaching the
river Armistead assisted the mechanic in attaching one of the
motors to the boat and the vessel made a trip about the harbor,
the two owners of the vessel. the mechamie, and Armistead
10) making the trip, the boat being uriven by the mechanic,
Cooper; that Armistead then essisted in taking off the first
&S E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
motor and installing the second one, after which he entered the
bow of the boat and, with Cooper driving, another trip about the
harbor was made; that the two owners did net make this trip,
having to leave because of other engagements: that while the vesse!
was being driven on the second trip it struck an obstruction, was
overturned, and Armistead was drowned ;
Arinistead was to assist the mechanic, Cooper, who was his
superior. The latter gave no instructions as to Armistead ac-
comphnying or not accompanying him on the testing trips: how-
ever, the services of Armistead were helpful to the mechanic. in
that he acted as a look-out man in the bow. Cooper tacitly ap-
proved and acquiesced in the aid given him by the inferior enm-
ployee, and such aid was in furtherance of the employer's interests.
Armistead’s work while in the boat was not fer the purpose of
pleasure, end he acted as would be expected of a colored helper
under the circumstances :
The employer's business was the selling of motor cruisers, siil-
boats, motors for outboard boats, and the sale of boat and mari-
time supplies. Onoccasions its employees (mechanics) went
aboard vessels, serviced them, and tested out ignition on trips on
navigable waters;
That the death of George P. Armistead, Jr.. by drowning, on
August &, 1938, arose out of and in the course of the employment:
that his death occurred upon navigable waters: and that at the
time of death he was engaged in mesitime employment:
That the average annual earnings of George P. Armistead. Jr.
at the time of his death amounted to the sum of $702.00;
That Jessie Booker Armistead is the surviving wife of George P.
Armistead, Jr., and was living with him at the time of his death:
that as widow she is entitled to death benefits at the rate of 34.725
per week; that Dorothy Marian Armistead, born March 24, 1933,
George Percel Armistead, III, born October 3, 1934. and Wil-
liam Berkley Armistead, born March 26, 1938. are the
11 surviving children of George P. Armistead, Jr.. Dorothy
Marian Armistead being an acknowledged illegitimate
child, and each is entitled to death benefits at the rate of $1.55
per week; that the accrued death benefits for the period August 8,
1938, to January 14. 1940, 75 weeks, at $8.775 per week, amount to
$658.13 ;
That funeral and burial expenses were incurred in the amount
of $190.00, and that said funeral bill was paid in full by George P.
Armistead, Sr.:
Upon the foregoing facts the Deputy Commissioner makes the
following award:
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SATES, INC. 9
That the employer, Motor Boat Sales. Inc.. shall pay to the
claimant death benefits as follows: For herself, as widow, $4.725
per week, and in addition $1.35 per week each, on account of the
children, Dorothy Marian Armistead, George Percell Armistead,
Wl. and Wiliiam Berkley Armistead. Acerticd death benefits
covering the period August &, 193s, to January 14, 1940, amount-
ing to $658.13, shall be paid forthwith. Thereafter, payments
shall be made biweekly in installments of $17.55. to continue unt
there is a change in conditions. The et:plover shall also pay
$190.00 to George P. Armistead, Sr.. as retmbursement for funeral
and burial expenses paid by him.
An attorney's fee for services rendered is approved in favor of
Messrs. Parrish, Butcher & Parrish in the sum of $250.00. which
fee shall be a lien upon thts award and discharged by deduction
from the accrued compensation.
Given under my hand at Norfolk. Virginia, this ith day of
January 1940,
(Signed) &. V. Parker.
De pty Commissioner,
Fifth Compensation District,
12 PROOF OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a copy of the foregoing compensation
order was sent by registered mail to the claimant and to the
uninsured employer, at the last known address of each, as follows:
Jessie Booker Armistead, 22 East Hill Street, Richmond, Va.:
Motor Boat Sales, hic. 3 West Grace Street. Richmond. Va.
(Signed) Marcarer W. Larian.
Ch rk.
Mailed January 17. 1940.
Copy to—Messrs. Parrish, Butcher & Parrish, Attorneys at
Law. Matual Bidg., Richmond. Va.: Minitree Jones Fulton, Esq.,
Suite 520 Mutual Bldg.. Richmond, Va.: George Percell Armistead,
Sr. 22 East Hill St.. Kichmond, Va.: Dr. W. F. Bursey. Secretary,
Industrial Commission of Virginia. Department of Workmen's
Compensation, Richmond, Va.
13 In United States District Court
Motion to dismiss
Filed March 28, 1940
Now comes E. V. Parker, Deputy Commissioner, United States
Employees’ Compensation Commission, Fifth Compensation Dis-
trict, Norfolk, Virginia. defendant herein, by Sterling Hutcheson,
10 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
United States Attorney, his attorney, ard moves that the bill of
complaint: in) this proceeding be disnassed for the following
reasolis :
That the said bill and each article thereof is insufficient in
law.
That neither the said bill nor any article therein alleges sufh-
cient grounds upon which this Court should refuse. reverse. suse
pena, enjoin, or set aside the award heretofore made by the Deputy
C page ag me
The findings of fact of the Commissioner are conclusive and
fully justify his award based thereon.
4. The findings of the Deputy Commissioner. fully supported
hy the evidence before him, are conclusive and should not be
refused, reversed, suspenced, enjoined, or set aside,
The findings of fact by the Deputy Commissioner, whicn are
fully supported by the evidence before him, show that the said
Deputy Commissioner had jurisdiction under the Act of Congress
to hear and determine the sid tindings of fact. and the evidence
upon which they are based show that the claim did not come within
the exception of Section 3 of the Longshoremen’s Act.
6. No ground for the award of an injunction and restraiming
crder is shown in said bill.
E. V. Parker,
Deputy Commissioner,
By (Sed.) Strerting Hurcueson,
Sterling Hutcheson,
Tvnited States Attorne y.
v (Sed.) H.H. Hort. Jr.,
Asst, (SN, Attorney.
lt I~ Unirep States Disrrier Court
| Title omitted. |
Order filing answer
Entered and filed March 29, 1940
This day came E. V. Parker, Deputy Commissioner, United
States Employees’ Compensation, Commission, Fifth Compensa-
(ion District. Norfolk, Virginia, defendant herein, by Sterling
Hutcheson, United States Attorney for the Eastern District of
Virginia, his attorney, and asks leave of the Court to file his
answer herein without waiving any rights in his motion to dismiss
heretofore filed, which leave is granted, and thereupen, said
answer is duly filed.
(Sgd.) Ropr. N. Potiarp.
United States District J wd ge.
RicuMonp, Viretnia, Meh. 29. 1950,
Wee ai
eA rae le
*
4
4
ba
a
E. V. PARKER V8. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 11
In United States District Court
Ansirer
Filed March 29, 1940
To the Honorable Ropert N. Potwarp, Judge of the Court Afore-
said:
The respondent, E. V. Parker. Deputy Commissioner, United
States Employees’ Compensation, Commission, Fifth Compensa-
tion District. for his answer to the bill of complaint filed in this
cause by the Motor Boat Sales Incorporated. answering, saith:
1. Respondent admits the allegations of Paragraph 1 of said
bill,
15 2. Respondent admits that the bill of complaint is filed
in this proceeding for the purposes set forth in Paragraph
2 of said bill.
3. Respondent denies that allegations of Paragraphs 3. 4, and
5 of the bill of complaint and adopts as his affirmative allegations
the findings of fact of the Deputy Couunissioner as set forth in the
Commissioner’s findings of fact and award dated January 17,
1940. referred to as Exhibit A in said bill of complaint.
4. Respondent admits the allegation: of Paragraph 6 of the bill
of complaint and files herewith copy of the transcript of the record
of the hearing before him, together with a copy of the award of
the Commissioner made ti these proceedings as Exhibits A and B
wud asks that they be read as a part of his answer as if fully set
forth herein.
5. Respondent denies the allegations of Paragraph 7 of the bill
of complaint.
6. Respondent denies that the plaintiff will be irreparably dam-
aged as contained in Paragraph 8 of said bill and denies that the
plaintiff is entitled to an injunction in these proceedings.
7. As further answer to the said bili of complaint, the respondent
avers that the findings of fact by the hearing Commissioner are
supported by the evidence and are nal and conciusive and are
hot subject to review by this Honorable Court ; that the Longshore-
men’s Act is constitutional and should be liberally construed to
effectuate beneficent purposes for which it was enacted; that the
deceased, George P. Armistead, Jr., and Motor Boat Sales, Incorpo-
rated, were employee and employer, respectively, and subject to thie
provisions of the Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’ Act: and
that the said deceased met his death by accident arising out of
and in course ov his employment upon the navigable waters of
the United States while engayed in Maritime employment under
sere
12 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
such circumstances as to entitle his dependents, as defined by the
said Net, to compensation.
S. Respondent denies that the Longshoremen’s and Harbor
Workers’ Act contains the provision referred to in) Para-
16 graph 7. Page 7. of the bill of complaint.
Wherefore the defendant prays that the bill of complaint
be dismissed at the cost of the plaintiff.
Respect fully submitted.
E. V. Parker,
1h puty Commissioner.
By (Sgd.) Srerting Hureneson,
Sterling Hutcheson,
United States Attorney.
ly 1 fe niaants exrhihit A
Filed March 20, EMO
United States Employees’ Compensation Commission
E. V. PARKER, DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
Fifth Compensation District. Norfolk, Virginia
Jessie ArMisreap. Wipow of Grorck P. ArMisreap, JR. CLAIMANT
t.
Motor Boat Saes. [NcoRPORATED. EMPLOYER
Cuse No, 825-1
Pursuant to notice, this matter was heard before E. V. Parker,
Deputy Commissioner, United States Emplovees’ Compensation
Commission, at Richmond, Virginia, on the 13th day of October
139,
al PPCALTANCES
Jessie Armistead. Claimant, in person. Mr. R. R. Parrish. rep-
resenting the claimant. Mr. M. J. Fulton, representing the
Empiover.
1s The Derpury Com™Misstoner. This hearing, after due
notice to all parties, is on the case of Jessie Armistead.
widow of George P. Armistead, Jr. a former employee of the
Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated, Employer, who was not insured
under the Federal Act. The following report forms were sub-
mitted, in accordance with the Federal Statutes, viz:
E. \. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 13
Employer's First Report to Deputy Commissioner of Accident
er Occupational Disease, Form U. S.-202. dated October 14, 1938,
Proof of Death, Form U. S.-264, dated October 20, 1938.
Notice to the Deputy Commissioner That Claim Will Be Con-
troverted, Form U. S.-207, dated October 14. 1838.
Proof of Burial and Funeral—By The Undertaker, Forni
U. S.-265. dated August 30, 1938.
The Widow's Claim for Compensation, Form U. S.-262. dated
August 30, 1988, and
Notices of Hearing, Form U. S.-226-B, dated September 28,
138, and September 27, 1939.
The Depcry Commissioner. What is the employer's defense,
Mr. Fulton, if you will state it for the record ¢
Statement of defense
Mr. Furvon. All the defenses that can be made under the Act
and under the usual issues, where the facts are controverted, and
that the Act under which the claim is made, does not apply to the
Defendant, Motor Boat Sales. Incorporated: that the employee,
whose death is made the basis of the claum here, that his death
did not result from injury arising out of and in the course of his
employment: that he was noi an employee within the terms of
Section 3 of the Employment Act, and that we were not an em-
plover engaged in maratime business, and that he was not an
employee within maritime employment. and that the Act. if it
seeks to make the employer liable, is unconstitutional,
19 The Deputy Commissioner. The Supreme Court has held
otherwise.
The Deputy ComMisstonrr. With respect to the average weekly
Wage: itis given on the Employer's Report as $13.50.
Mr. Parrisnu. If your Honor please, IT had expected to agree to
that, but T understand the deceased put in considerable overtime.
The Dercry ComMisstoner. We can make that a matter of
proof. Do you want to offer evidence on that point é
Mr. Parrisu. I will call Mr. Todd on that point.
The Deputy Comisstoner. We will make it an issue,
Mr. Parrisu. Mr. Todd, will you have your books here for #
year prior to his death ¢
Mr. S. Kine Furtonx. The Social Security record will be suffi-
clent, and we will have it sent down.
Stipulation re proof of death
Mr. Parrisn. It has been stipulated that Doctor Williams’ Proof
of Death, on Form U.S. 264, which was put in the record by The
14 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Deputy Commissioner, correctly shows the cause of death. Doctor
Williams is present, but we thought we could prove it by stipu-
lating the Form.
The Deputy Commissioner. Is that agreeable?
Mr. Futton. Yes, sir.
* * * * %
Jessie ArMISTEAD, Claimant, witness in her own behalf, having
been duly sworn, on oath testified as follows:
By the Derury Commissioner:
Q. Give your name and address, please.
A. No answer.
By Mr. ParrisH:
20 Q. You are Jessie Armistead ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where do you live?
A. 22 East Hill Street.
Q. You are the widow of George P. Armistead, Jr., the de-
ceased in this case ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How old are‘you, Jessie?
AL 22.
Q. When were you married to George ¢
A. May 26, 1934.
Mr. Parrisu. We offer in evidence certified copy of marriage
license of George P. Armistead, Jr., and Jessie D. Booker, which
is filed herewith as Claimant's Exhibit No. 1.
By M: Parrtsu:
. How many children were born of this marriage /
3.
. Give their names and ages.
. Dorothy Marion: 6.
. When was she born?
. March 24th.
. What year?
1933.
. What are the names of the other children?
. George Purceil Armistead ITI.
. When was he born ?
. October 3, 1934.
. What is the name of the youngest one ?
. William Berkiey Armistead.
,
.
POPOPOPO PO rere
3
;
i
sabes
Stet i
beare
~ BEG BT be Save | oe APE te
so 5 iil ROR AT UA pats Reduioauees Pe
RRA DPE ten SET OY Dee EAD
BAER AYER Aah Maite
aR ye
math)
BE. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 15
Claimant’s Exhibit No. 1
No. 11-P. 66
MarriacGe License
(Seal of Court here superimposed on an adhesive wafer.)
Virginia, City of Richmond, to wit:
To Any Person Licensed to Celebrate Marriages:
You are hereby authorized to join together in the Holy State
of Matrimony, according to the rites and ceremonies of your
Church or religious denomination and the laws of the Common-
wealth of Virginia, George P. Armistead, Jr.. and Jesse D, Booker.
Given under my hand, as Clerk of Hustings, Court of ~-------
County (or City), this 26 day of May 1934.
Watter Curistian, Clerk.
MARRIAGE CERTIFICATE
TO BF. ANNEXED TO LICENSE REQUIRED BY SECTION 5074 OF THE CODE OF
VIRGINIA
Virginia: In the Clerk’s Office of the Hustings Court for the
City of Richmond. Date of Marriage, May 26, 1934. Place of
Marriage, Richmond, Va.
=.
. (Full name of parties) '
George P. Armistead and Jessie DD. Baker. Age of Husband,
21 years; Condition (single, widowed, or divorced), Single. Age
of Wife, 19 years; Condition (single, widowed, or divorced),
Single. Race (white, colored, or otherwise) ef Husband, Colored ;
of Wife, Colored. Husband's Place of Birth, Richmond, Va.
(Present )
Mailing Address, 22 E. Hill St. Wife’s Place of Birth, Amelia
Co.. Va. Mailing Address, Richmond, Va. Names of Parents
Husband. George P. Armisteed and Minnie Berkley.
(Full maiden bpame}
Wife, Junius Booker and Florence Green.
s (Full maiden names
Occupation of Hushand, Teacher.
Given under my hand this 26 day of May 1934.
Watcrer Curistran, Clerk,
H02223--41—2
16 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
CERTIFICATE OF TIME AND PLACE OF MARRIAGE
ae H. Binford Peay. appointed by Hustings Court of the
—————— Church or re ligious order of that name, do certify that
on the 26 day of May 1934, at Richmond, Virginia, under au-
thority of the above License, I j@ned together in the Holy State
of Matrimony the persons named and described therein. I quali-
fied and gave bond aenapewey to law authorizing me to celebrate
the rites of marriage in the Couniy (or City) of Richmond, State
of Virginia.
Given under my hand this 26 day of May 1954.
J. H. Bixrorp Peay.
(Verson Se performs ceremony sign here)
The Minister or other person celebrating a marriage is required,
within thirty (30) days thereafter, to return the License and Cer-
tificate of the Clerk and his certificate of the time and place at
which the marriage was celebrated to the Clerk who issued the
Liceuse: failure to comply with these requirements of the law
makes the Minister or other person celebrating the marriage liable
toa fine of not less than ten nor more than twenty dollars for each
offense (See Section 5074 of the Code of Virginia, 1919).
A Copy Teste:
Tos. R. Mitier, Yep. Clk.
22 Q. When was he born?
A. March 26th.
Q. What vear?
A. 193s.
Q. What did you understand from George were his duties while
working for the Motor Boat Sales, Jesse ¢
By Mr. Fciton:
Q. Just a moment. Over the testimony relating to the first
child; what is the name of the first child ¢
A. Dorothy Marion.
Mr. Fcrron. I move that that child be stricken out. That child
was born before \he marriage.
Mr. Parrisu. Do you want the proof of acknowledgment ¢
The Deputy Comaiussioner. You understand the Act covers
acknowledged children.
By Mr. Parris:
Q. Your first child, Dorothy, was born before you were married?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did he acknowledge that child after the marriage ¢
Mr. Furton. I object.
a
E. V. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 17
The Deputy ComMissioNeR. She can answer the question.
Mr. Fuiron. Exception.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did he consider the child as his own, just as the other two ¢
A. Yes, sir.
(). Did he provide for her as the others ¢
A. Yes, sir.
23 Mr. Funton. I will note an objection and exception to all
that testimony.
Q I asked you what you understood from George his duties
were ¢
A. He had to fix and repair the motors, and, after fixing them,
carry them out and test them.
Q. Do you know whether or not, during the two years he worked
there, he went on the James River and Rappahannock River and
did work for the Motor Boat Sales ¢
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Fciton:
Q. Do you know that of your own knowledge or is that hearsay ¢
I know’s it.
-
.
By Mr. Parrisn:
Q. State whether you knew that of your own knowledge.
A. He told me.
Q. What did he tell you?
Mr. Friton. I object to this t testimony as being purely hearsay
and all like testimony.
The Derury Commissioner. That is admissible if it is corrobo-
rated. She can answer the question.
Mr. Fcvron, Exception.
A. He had to stay down on the boat, and after they sold it he
had to stay down and watch it overnight.
Q. Did you see him at the boat ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did he come home with you on that occasion ¢
A. No, sir.
Q. Do you know what he did?
A. He stayed down there overnight.
“4 Q. Do vou know whether he was sent out of town by
his employer overnight !
A. Yes, sir; by Mr. Todd.
Q. Who did George consider his boss?
A. Mr. Todd.
Mr. Feiton. The same objection to the questions as to whom
he considered his boss.
18 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Q. The record will show he is Vice President. Do you recall
the night he spent on the boat ¢
A. It was Sunday night, but I don’t remember the date.
By the Depcry ComMIssioNeER :
Q. How long before his death ?
A. I don’t know.
By Mr. Parrisu:
Q. Do you remember this occasion he was sent out of town and
spent the night; was it within a year of his death ¢
A. It was over a year.
By Mr. Furton:
Q. Jessie, you said your first child was born March 24, 1933.
How long after that was it that you and George married ¢
A. She was a little over a year old when we got married.
Q. Now, you say that George worked at the Motor Boat Sales.
Incerpor ated, and that he told you that he had been sent out of
town over a year before his death and spent the night; is that
correct; is that what he told you?
A. He told me he spent the night out of town and he had to go
for Mr. Todd.
Q. Mr. Todd was in the employ of the Motor Boat Sule-
25 and stayed at the office and store?
A. Yes, sir.
@. You knew where the stcre of the Motor Boat Sales was
on Grace Street ; No. 3 West Grace Street /
A. Yeo. sir.
Q. And isn’t it « fact that George worked there as janitor and
delivery boy; wasn’t that his work up there ¢
A. No: it wasn't.
Q. Is all you know what he told you?
A. Lused to go and see him there
Q. He was cleaning up and cleaning motors and cleaning. dirt.
had charge of cleaning up the store and would drive the truck
and automobiles and trailers from the store to where they were
going ¢
. He used to fix movors too.
You don’t say he was a mechanic up there?
He used to do the work of a mechanic.
He used to do the work of a mechanic ?
Yes, sir.
Who was the mechanic up there ?
Mr. Lloyd.
Mr. Lloyd?
Yes, sir.
rOrOr® POP;
Seki RAAB S. he is diego “i
acer etd a ea m
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 19
Q. Isn’t all you saw George do about the motors was clean
them up and polish them up after they had been worked on. if in
there for repair, and place them in the store where they wanted
them ¢
A. He used to fix them and put them together.
QQ. All vou know is that you saw him do that up there!
A. Yes, sir.
26 Q. What time would you be up there and see George ?
A. Lused to go downtown and would stop there. IT would
go in the side way and saw him working on the motors.
You don’t know what time it was?
. No, sir.
. What do you mean “side way”?
. Alley way.
. You went in the rear of the store?
. Yes, sir.
Q. You said he told you and yon went down there and saw
him staying in the boat one night and watching the boat one
night ¢
. Yes, sir.
. And when was that ?
The year before he got drowned.
. That boat was anchored and he was simply watching it?
. Yes, sir.
. It was tied to the bank ?
. Yes, sir.
And he was simply watching, see at nobody carried it
away: is that right ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you know whether he was paid by the owner of that boat
to watch it, or who paid him ¢
A. I don’t know.
Q. You don’t know who paid him?
A. No, sir.
By Mr. Parrisit:
Q. There is one thing I forgot to ask you: Did George ever
work beyond his usual hours: put in overtime /
27 A. Yes, sir.
Q. I will ask you whether he brought home one of the
smal] outboard motors to werk on at home ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It was while he was working for the Motor Boat Sales ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It wasn't his boat ¢ :
A, No, sir.
Perere
gO>ererer
A
20) E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
The Derury Commissioner. Have you got the birth certificates
of the children’ Do you want to offer them ¢
Mr. Paxrisn. I do not have them.
The Deruty Commissioner. I was wondering about the dates.
Mr. Parrisn. I checked them with the father.
The Deruty Commissioner. They sent them in, but they wanted
them back, Mr. Bursey said.
Mr. Parrisn. I have them. I will offer them. That is a copy
of them, or, if the Commissioner wishes, I will secure birth certifi-
cates and forward them to the Commissioner.
Mr. Fuuton. Mr. Parrish, do you know that that is a copy?
Mr. Parrisu. No; I can't say I know this isa copy.
Mr. Furren. It corresponds with what you said.
Mr. Parrisn. I can’t agree that it is a copy.
Mr. Futon. We will accept it as a copy.
Mr. P yeaisu. I will secure certified copies of the birth certifi-
cates and file them as-Claimant’s Exhibit No, 2.
And further this witress sayeth not.
Grorce W. Topp, a witness for the Claimant, having been duly
sworn, testified as follows:
t
.
~
Dr
By the Depcry ComMMIssIONER:
Q. Give us your name and address.
A. George W. Todd; 4505 Brook Road,
By Mr. Parrtsu:
Q. On August &, 1938, what was your occupation !
A. Twas Assistant Manager and outside salesman for the Motor
Boat Sales, Incorporated.
QQ. Were vou an officer of the Corporation ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was your official position with the Motor Boat Sale-¢
A. Vice President.
Q. You were at the company’s place of business, 3 West Grace
Street, practically every day?
A. Most every day.
Q. What was the purpose of incorporating the Motor Boat
Sales ¢
Mr. Futton. I object to that. That is not relevant,
Mr. Parris. It seems to me that it is relev t to show what the
nature of the business is, when his defense is that it does not comme
under the Maritime Act and it does not apply. we want to show
what it was chartered for.
The Dervuty Commissioner. He can answer that.
Mr. Fciten. Exception.
eS h a a iet ea ek Ate Brien one
E. V. PARKER VS. MCTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 21
A. I can't answer that question, because I was elected an officer
efter it was formed.
Q. What business did the company transact on August 8 1938 ¢
A. We were in the retail store business, dealing in mari-
29 — time supplies of all kinds. That includes the sate of boats—
nothing in the yacht class—but some outboard motors.
Q. And accessories: it would include the sale of both?
A. Yes, sir; gasoline motors and parts.
Q. Who engaged the services of George P. Armistead, Jr., the
deceased ¢
A. T don’t know. I think he was hired by Mr. Fulton,
Q). Mr. King Fulton, who is present today ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Mr. Fulton spent most of his ti e about the date of his
death in Washington ¢
A. Mr. Fulton at that time was in Wes!.ngton.
Q. In his absence you were the officer in charge of the Rich-
mond Store ?
A. Mr. Hobbs and I jointly. He was in the office and 1] was
on the outside.
Q. After you were notified of this boy's death, you immectately
went down to the river?
A. I was called to see what I could do to notify and help find
the body.
Q. You went down immediately ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. From the investigation, it appeared that the boy had been
drowned in the channel ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Which is vavigable waters ¢
A. I think so, from what IT understand where it happened.
Q. The ocean going vessels come up further than that ¢
34 A. I don’t know where it occurred. Tthink it is a nav:
gable stream where they said the boy was drowned.
Q. Assuming it occurred oppo: ‘te the James River Oil Com-
pany’s dock, that would be navigable water /
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How many employees did your concern have on August &,
1935 ¢
A. George Armistead, John Cooper, Welford Lloyd, Randolph
Hobbs, Miss Johnson, and myself.
Q. You did not come under the Workmen's Compensation Act
of Virginia at that time /
A. No, sir.
Q. And you were not insured under that Act?
A. No, sir.
22 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC,
Q. You have sent for the record as to his wages?
A. I have got it.
Q. You have it?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Parrisn. We will introduce that now. I don’t know what
it shows. We will introduce the chart ard the wage can be
computed from the records,
The Derpury ComMisstoner. Can you read off the figures for
the year prior to his death? IT den’t know whether vou have it
for the year. Can you take it approximately for the nearest
fiftv-two weeks prior to the accident?
Mr. S. Kine Fctron. I will mark it.
Mr. Parrisu. So far as I am concerned, your Honor, the over-
time shown by the record is so small, { don’t think it would have
any bearing on the base rate of $13.50 and we will agree on
that.
31 The Derury Commissioner. You will stipulate that
$13.50 is the average weekly wage /
Mr. Parrisn. Yes, sir.
Mr. Fuiton. That is entirely agreeable.
By Mr. Parrisu:
Q. Mr. Todd, this boy was paid in full for the week during
which he was drowned ?
A. I don’t know. Ther is not for me to answer. I wouldn't
be able to answer that.
Mr. Fciton. We can stipulate what he was paid.
Mr. S. Kine Futon. He was paid for the full week. The last
payment of $13.50 was for the week of August 8th. I don’t know
what day that was.
By Mr. Parris:
Q. Johnnie Cooper, was he employed on Ar yust 8, 1938 ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And he was on the boat which capsized, also; the same beat
George Armistead was on ?
A. As far as I know.
Q. You found him down there ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Fvtton. He didn't handle the transaction, but we have the
gentleman here that did.
Q. Whose boat was it in which they were riding at the time?
A. The boat belonged to Mr. W. M. Crown and his brother and
I think it was owned jointly by the two. It had just been con-
structed,
_
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 23
Q. You all sold it to them ¢
A. No, sir; they built it.
32 Q. Whose motor was on it ¢
A. The property of the Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated.
Q. Outboard motor?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You had sent the motor down /
A. I don’t knew.
Q. The company did?
A. I was their salesman. I don't know about it.
Mr. Parrisn. That is all at this time. I will reserve the right
to recall him.
By the Deputy ComMIssIoNER:
Q. Are you still with the company ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You said the company engaged in dealing in maritime sup-
plies of all kinds?
A. Yes, sir: to cover the boats we handle.
Q. That means that you serviced boats?
A. What do you mean “serviced boats ¢”
Q. Any kind of equipment they wanted to put on the boat,
would you supply it 4
A. No, sir; we didn’t make a specialty of it. I don’t know of
any instance where we did installation work.
Q. You sell the boats /
A. The boats we sell are ready to go.
Q. Did you do any repair work after that ?
A. No, sir: that was for the boat yards.
Q. How often would your employees go aboard any boat; every
A. No, sir; not every day. It was just a rarity that we
33s got on boats. We haven't got any business getting on other
people’s boats.
Q. Suppose a fellow wanted a compass or chart or some other
equipment that you sell, would yeu deliver it ¢
A. No, sir; we don’t have a delivery truck. The only thing
Was my car.
Q. What would be the largest boat you handle ¢
A. 38-foot boat.
Q. Cruiser ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Cabin on it?
A. Yes, sir
24 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
By Mr. Parrisu :
Your company is agent for the cruiser Chris-Craft ¢
That is the largest one we sell.
You sell all the Chris-Craft people’s boats?
We sell all we can.
. If I came to you to get one, I would get it frora you as
age nts you never turned it down?
A. No, sir; not on the stuff we handle.
Your concern has done work servicing small boats?
In our place.
You have serviced beats on the water ?
. We bring in the boat and fix it.
Didn't you have a representative from your firm at the
National Outboard Races?
A. No, sir: not a representative.
Q. Didn't you have a mechanic and service man there?
34 A. No, sir; we didn’t have anything to do with it.
Q. Didn't have any representative there?
A. All we did was loan an outboard and motor.
Q. You did have a boat there ¢
A. Loaned to Mr. Mullen.
By Mr. Furton: ‘
Q. That was outside of your business ‘
A. Yes, sir. We have been helpful “o him,
By Mr. Parrisu:
Q. Hasn't your firm demonstrated boats for sale on the James
River?
A. No, sir: I can’t say we have.
Q. To refresh vour memory: Didn't you take me riding one day,
trying to interest me ina cruiser?
A. Yes. sir; we did. I don’t know what boat it was. It seemed
to me it belonged to a customer and we borrowed the boat to carry
you riding.
2s OF OLE
.
-
2 prere
By the Dercry CoMMISSIONER:
Q. Mr. Todd. you said you serviced your own boats ?
A. If we trade a boat, which we do, and it is brought in by the
customer on a trailer, and if anything is needed to be done to it,
like painting, we do it.
Q. Did you de any work on the water?
A. No, sir: we are not equipped for it.
QQ. Did you repair engines of boats?
A. No, sir; we don’t have any equipment for that.
Q. Any boat while in the water, if the ignition went bad, would
you send a man?
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 25
35 A. Yes. sir; we have done it. The man would not go out
in the water.
Q. The boat would be at the dock in the James River?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What are these boats used for; for pleasure ¢
A. The majority are for pleasure.
Q. What do you use them for, if not for pleasure ¢
A. Unless one of the Indians on the Mattaponi River would buy
a boat for his purposes, to take hunting parties.
Q. Did you sell them for moving supplies of freight and cargo?
A. No, sir: we don’t have that kind of boat. _
Q. They might have used them for fishing parties ¢
A. It is too nice a beat to be used for fishing parties.
And further this witness sayeth not.
George Purcent ARMISTEAD. Sr.. a witness for the Claimant,
having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
By Mr. ParrisH:
. State vour full name and address.
. George Purcell Armistead, Sr.; 22 East Hill Street.
You are the father of the deceased in this case ¢
. Yes, sir.
. Do you know how long your boy had been working for the
Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated ?
A. About two years.
Q. Do you know what his work was?
\. Janitor and Mechanic's Helper.
Q. Did you ever see him en a boat of the Motor Boat Sales;
if so, where ¢
36 A. I saw him on the boat. I taken him, his wife, and
children on twe occasions. He was suppesed to go and
stay all night. and I left him there.
Q. You left him down there ¢
A. Yes, sir. I took his wife and children and carried them
home.
Q. So far as you know, he stayed there ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It was your understanding that he stayed there for his boss,
Mr. Todd?
A. Yes, sir: everything was what Mr. Todd said do.
Q. Do you recall whether he was sent out of town with respect
to his work ?
A. He told me he had to go to the Rappahannock or somewhere
to help the mechanic with a boat.
Q. Do you recall when that was?
Ey ae aoe =
etl TA a Daan
26 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
A. No, sir: IT couldn't tell when that was.
Q. It was after he went to work for the Motor Boat Sales,
Incorporated ?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Furton:
QQ. All you know is what he teld you ¢
A. Learried him to the boat; him, his wife, and children.
Q. You don't knew when that was?
A. No, sir; not exactly. He was working for the company.
though.
And further this witness sayeth not.
Put Goong, a witness for the Claimant, having been duly sworn.
testified as follows:
By Mr. Parrisu:
37 Q. What is vour full name?
A. Phil Goode.
What is your age?
Forty-three years old.
Where do you live, Phil?
Fulton: 14 Orleans Street.
That is about a half-block from the James River?
Not quite a half-block; less than half a block.
Did you see the upset of the boat on which George Armistead
was riding on August &, 1938 ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where were you at the time?
A. U was standing on the hill up by Mr. Sternheimer’s: me and
anoher fellow went over there.
Q. Mr. Sternheimer’s place is some little distance below the
James River Oil Company ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Joins it ¢
A. Yes, sir: and the river comes up there like that [indicating].
Q. That is down stream ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you see the boat upset ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Hew many people were on it ¢
A. Two.
Q. Tell what you saw?
SePErere
Od eabia
E. ¥. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 27
A. The reason I went out there was because the boat went down
the river making a noise like an airplane. When she come
38 back, we were standing out there, and the current was swift.
It was high. When she makes the loop to turn, the boat
capsized and the colored man went down and come up and grabbed
for the boat and went down, and the white fellow grabs hold of the
boat and held it, and, the motor being heavy, it pulied the bow of
the boat three and one-half feet in the air, and he was floating
down the river hollering help, help, help, and when he got down to
where Mr. Mulligan’s barge was, and I said, “Lord, see if we can
save him.” and I went down and was going to get in the boat, but
it was locked, and IT asked another feilow to help me break the
chain, and Mr. Parker’s boat was parked there, but it was a log
chain on it and we couldn’t break it, and this fellow floated oppo-
site Mr. Mulligan’s boat, and Mr. Mulligan rescued him and taken
him and put him on his boat and taken his littl boat and pulled
iton the bank. He had two motors demonstrating—one was a
va lion or sea horse—and I never had met the boy and never had
wen him to say anything to him.
Q. You mean the boy that was drowned 4
A. Yes, sir. I never seen him to speak to him, but I have seen
him with other motors, because I thought it belonged to him. 1
used to go down there because I would hear the noise of the motor,
Which sounded like an airplane.
Q. You were not any kin to him, George ¢
A. No, sir. T don’t know where he lived. They told me that
is his father. I have never seen him to know him.
Q. Where wus the motor to be demonstrated ¢
A. Here is the James River Oil Company, and one was setting
here and one was on the boat and the one was on the shore where
they had demonstrated.
39 Q. Where that boat upset or capsized, was it in the
channel ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where boats come in the City Dock ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Futon. No questions.
And further this witness sayeth not.
Wetrorp Ear Lioyp. a witness for the Claimant, having been
duly sworn, testified, as follows:
By Mr. Parrtsn:
Q. Please state your full name?
A. Welford Earl Lloyd.
28 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Q. How old are you, Mr. Lloyd?
A. 36.
Q. By whom are you employed f
A. At present /
Q. Yes, sir.
A. Tignor’s.
Q. What is your occupation ¢
A. Iam a mechanic and salesman together.
Q. Have you, in the past, been employed by the Motor Boat
Sales! |
A, Yes, sir.
Q. When!
A. For about two years off and on; little more than two years,
off and on.
Q. During what years: just approximately /
A. I think Mr. Fulton hired me in 1937 and I worked until the
latter part of 1938, with the exception of three months.
40 Q. You were working there when George Armistead was
drowned ¢
P Yes, sir.
What was the nature of your duties /
T had charge of the shop.
You would work on motors ¢
Yes, sir.
You knew George, of course ¢
. Yes, sir.
What did he do around there ?
The first thing he did was clean up the place. Sometime it
would take a half day to a day, and he was in the shop cleaning
up motors, buffing tanks, and making deliveries.
Q. General handy man ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And. as far as possible, he assisted in cleaning up and work-
ing on the motors
A. I had another helper.
Q. He did assist you /
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You were in the shop the day he went down the river and
was drowned ¢
A. Yes, sit.
Q. I will ask you if he wasn’t sent down by his employer to
assist in lifting two motors /
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who went with him?
+OPOrorer
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 29
A. Johnnie Cooper.
Q. What was his job?
4] A. He is a Mechanic’s Helper. That is his rating. He
was in there to help me.
Q. He was a white man, was he?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. If a colored helper, like George, would go out on some mis-
sion, the colored fellow would be subject to the orders of the white
fellow ? :
A. Yes, sir; I suppose so.
Q. He had been out with you /
A. No, sir.
Q. He is shown to have been to the river on occasions with
other people ¢
A. I den’t know about that, but he never went with me,
Q. When he went out, he was subject to orders ¢
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Futon:
Q. Mr. Lloyd, you were the mechanic up there, to do the me-
chanical work on the motors ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was George Armistead, the colored boy referred to here,
was he a mechanic ¢
A. No, sir; he wasn’t a mechanic.
Q. The work he did on the motor was cleaning it up?
A. After it was pulled down.
Q. Toclean up the parts and wash them off?
A. Yes, sir: and dry them. I would take them and put them
ipand he would buff the tank—shine the tank—so it would lock
nice,
Q. And that was the only kind of work he did on the
motor?
42 A. Except cleaning. I can't say he didn’t take a nut
off, but he didn’t pull it down, Probably I remember the
time that he would take a wrench and take the nut off, when he
Was waiting for the engine, to clean it up.
Q. His duties up there in the store was cleaning up the store
and opening up the store in the morning, washing windows, clean-
Ing motors, and driving automobile for making deliveries over
town ?
A. He had a schedule to go by.
: Q. I will ask you to look at that and pass it over to Mr. Parrish.
A. I don't know whether it is the same one, but it is similar to it.
: Q. Now. as a matter of fact. above the first floor of the store,
Was two apartments upstairs ¢
30 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did George clean up those /
A. Yes, sir; and dump the trash,
Q. You said that looks like i /
A. It looks Jike it, I think.
Mr. Furron. I would like to file that as Defendant's Exhibit
No. 1,
Q. Now. in delivering any boats, small pleasure boat or out-
hoard motors, would George drive the automobile down or -on-
veyance down to make those deliveries ¢
A. He probably would. sometimes.
Q. He would go along to help do that ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who was the Mechanic’s Helper at the time George was
killed ¢
43 Defendant's Exhibit No. 1
WEEKLY SCHEDULE For Giporce P. Arweatean, Jr.
Monday:
1. Wash front door (woodwork), de-ks, and floor in both offices.
2. Dust and clean one-third of merchandise tables.
Tuesday :
1. Wash windows.
2. Clean boats and motors.
Wednesday :
1. Wash front door (woodwork), desks, and floor in both offices.
2. Dust and clean second third of merchandise tables.
Thursday :
1. Clean boats and motors.
8. Wash front floor of showroom.
3. Wash washrooms.
Friday:
1. Wash front door (woodwork), desks, and floor in both offices.
2. Dust and clean third third of merchandise tables.
Saturday:
1. Wash windows.
2. Sweep shop and clean same.
\
MontTHLY SCHEDULE
First of month:
1. Wash windows and skilights out back.
2. Clean front halls and steps.
3. Shine all brass stock.
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 31
$4. Wash woodwork and walls in offices.
Fifteenth of month:
1. Wash woodwork and walls in offices :
2. Clean down back steps.
3. Clean front hails and steps.
44 A. Johnnie Cooper.
Q. Who was in charge of the office on the particular day
George got drowned ¢
A. Mr. Hobbs.
Q. That gentleman sitting back there {| indicating] ¢
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Parrisx:
Q. I notice on the schedule that two days a week he had to wash
windows and clean boats and motors—Tuesday and Thursday—
that is correct, isn’t it ¢
A. Yes, sir; that is correct on It.
Q. There must have been right many motors on hand to require
two days?
A. Outboard motors. After you have been over it, you can
rub your hand over it and spot it and have to go over it every
day.
By Mr. Futon: ;
Q. Dusting them so they would look well ?
A. Yes, sir; so they would look well to the public.
Q. They would be on the floor?
A. On stands.
Q. And he would go and dust them off ¢
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Parrisx:
Q. During the busy season, from April to August or Septem-
ber, you would have quite a few motors in the shop ¢
A. That isn’t a particular busy season.
Q. When is the busy season !
A. In the Spring and in the Winter we are busy over-
45 hauling motors and I believe we are medium busy all the
year.
_Q. You had enough work to keep a mechanic and helper all the
time ¢
A. Yes, sir.
By the Deputy ComMMISSIONER:
Q. Would you have requests to go to work on boats?
A Service boats! IT have done it.
302224. -41---—-%
32 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Q. About how often would you do that: several times a week?
A. No, sir; it wouldn't average that; no, sir. The most we had
was when the frm sold a Chris-Craft and would put it over board.
My main job was outboard motors. but T have serviced a few
engines.
Q. What would you have to do when you put them out /
A. All that happens is that it has to be slung and put out.
Q. Hew often would you do that /
A. One each week end for three week ends, and that is the
largest number.
Q. But you did service them while the boat was in water /
A. Yes, sir: soon after you do that. We didn't pull it up and
tie it to the dock.
Q. Did you test them ¢
A. The customer had to be on the boat, and we couldn’ t operate
the boat and be in the cockpit.
Q. But you would do it ¢
A. Yes, sir: but the customer drove the boat.
Q. But vou went along?
A. To adjust the carburetor or anything like <nat.
Q. How long was that boat ?
A. One was thirty-five feet and the rest of them were
46 much smaller. The average small boat would run from
twenty-two fo twenty-four or twenty-five feet.
They would ‘ave larger motors?
Yes, sir.
How large?
The largest have two 6-91 grade.
Ninety-one horse power in each motor and there were two?
Yes, sir.
By Mr. Parrisu:
Q. When you would get a new boat in the water. there would
be some adjustments to make before turning it over to the
customer ¢
A. They come on the box car ready to run. They get at least
three test runs in the factory.
Q. Before you finally delivered it, wouldn't you make some
adjustments?
A. Tf it needed it. I was at the Chris-Craft Factory and they
try it out and get it ready to run. /
Q. You would go down and service some ?
A. Some few.
By the Deputy CoMMISSIONER :
Q. What would be the longest trip von made?
A. Fifty or sixty miles. 35
Pore rO®
nj a Reb pik ve ag AG ee eee teen ae Se
Leas RR ae IS RE i Bike ee Tue
ve -8 Beene
bh aE is Bays SRC.
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 33
Q. Down the James and back ¢
. Not on the James, but at West Point.
Did you start from the Richmond dock ¢
. No, sir. I would go down in the car.
. You would have to go in your car
A. A majority of the time the customer took us in his ear.
47 Q. How far would you go in the boat ¢
A. No special distance.
. Just run up and down to test it?
. Had to do that.
It would cover several miles
_ It wouldn't cover several miles.
And then vou would be through and come back in your csr?
. Yes, sir.
-oRKoere
By Mr. ParrisH:
Q. You would, on oceasions, make trips to West Point and Tap-
pahannock and other rivers ¢
. In those directions, but net those points.
. On the Rappahannock River ¢
Yes, sir: some few jobs.
Sometimes you would take a helper?
It depends.
rOvEYE
By the Derury CoMMISSIONER:
Q. It was the same type of boat, thirty-five feet or smaller?
A. Didn't service that farge a one but ence; rest were smaller.
By Mr. Furtos:
Q. I understood you to tell the Court when a beat was sold by
this company to a customer that it had been customary to have it
tested at the factory, and he would take you down and have you
present when the boat was put in the rver, and he weuld operate
the bozt and net yout
A. What do you mean going down ?
Q. On the trips?
a: On the water ¢
Q. You told him that you went down with the customer
47 and would be present when he would take the boat and go
down for him and with him and be present when the engine
was started and the boat was tried out ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you run the boat or the owner ¢
A. The owney.
Q. All you a.d was simply to be there and make any minor
adjustment ?
A. We didn't drive the boat.
34 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
That is what vou went for?
Went more for pleasure.
He sometimes wanted you to got
Yes, sir.
re re&
By Mr. Parrisu :
. You got paid for the pleasure, didn’t you, Mr. Lloyd?
Yes, sir.
By Mr, Futon :
. In that case you didn’t operate the boat ; it wasn’t the Motor
Boat Sales, Incorporated, boat and you were simply present to
see what was done?
A. It wasn’t the Motor Boat Sales boat.
Q. It was the boat of the purchaser ?
A. It wasn’t the property of the Motor Boat Sales, because it
was sold and was not on display.
By the Dervutry ComMIsstoneEr:
Q. You would service it, if the company sent you down
service it?
A. Yes, sir; if it needed anything.
And further this witness sayeth not.
> ©
49 Ranpoten Hosss, «a witness for the Defendant, having
been duly sworn, testified as follows:
By Mr. Fouuton:
Q. Will you state your name and your age and by whom you
are employed ?
A. Randolph Hobbs; 28; employed by S. King Fulton, Inc.
Q. Washington ¢
A. Yes, sir; Washington, D. C.
Q. Were you employed by the Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated,
on August 8, 1938, when it was said that George P. Armistead, Jr..
got drowned ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What were your duties up there?
A. I was Treasurer of the Corporation, in charge of the office.
and more or less Store Manager, in charge of the general opera.
tion around the store itself.
Q. Was George Armistead employed there at that time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long had you been employed by the Motor Boat Sales,
Incorporated, at that time ?
A. I had been with the Motor Boat Sales since May 1954.
Q. What was George employed as; what was he employed to
do up there?
=a
ET ae Se ee ee eae we ns ee
E. V. PARKER VS, MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 35
A. George was employed as a porter.
Q. Did he fill out the Social Security cards and send them in
while you were there ¢
A. Yes, sir. While he was employed at the store the Social
Security Act was put in effect.
mM Q. Would you know George's signature ¢
A. Yes, sir,
Q. I hand you paper here which is headed “Previous employ-
went (last position first)” and what is known as a Sociai Security
Card, to be filed with the Government and reporting to it: look at
that and see if that is George Armistead’s signature ¢
A. Yes. sir; I would say that is his signature,
Q. Would you pass that over to Mr. Parrish? ‘The second Tine
would be the item covering him.
Mr. Parris. What do you want to prove by that ¢
Mr. Fcuvon. He said what his position was at that time and his
former position.
Mr. Parrisu. All right.
By Mr. Fviton:
Q. I want you to read into the record from that card. This is «
copy of the eard, duplicate original, and was filled out by you and
fled with the Government é
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The card is headed “Previous Employment (last) position
first ).” and under that Column four 6 17 36 Motor Boat Sales, Ine.,
3 West Grace Street, Richmond, Virginia: position, Porter: rate of
pay per week, $10.00; and that is then signed George P. Armi-
stead, Jr.; ix he same party that was drowned and about which the
testimony has mentioned here ?
A. Yes, sir.
). Was he a mechanic ?
A. No, sir.
Q. Was he employed as a mechanic ?
A. No, sir.
md Q. Did he have any duties to perform as a mechanic ¢
A. No, sir; not as T recall.
Q. Did he have any duties to perform, either maritime opera.
tions in navigable waters—that is, the James River or other navi-
gable streams? Was he employed to do any work of a niaritime
nature ¢
A. Was he employed for the purpose of working on the river?
Q. Any work on a river?
A. Porter in the store, primarily,
— You were there the day that George went down to the James
iver?
A. Yes, sir.
36 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Q. What was he instructed to do, if you know, when he left your
store ¢
A. George was instructed, to the best of my knowledge——
By Mr. Parrtsu:
Q. Did you give the instructions ¢
A. No, sir.
Q. Were you present when they were given?
A. No, sir.
Mr. Parrisu. I object.
By Mr. Fciron:
Q. You don’t know what he was instructed to do?
A. He was instructed to go——
By the Deputy CoMMISSIONER :
). Who gave the instructions ¢
A. Perhaps I can clarify it.
By Mr. Feutron :
Q). What occurred ¢
wy A. To the best of my knowledge——
Mr. Parrivy. That ts vague and indefinite. We want
the facts.
The Derury ComMisstoner. Whether you remeniber it {
A. (Continuing.) These two gentlemen came by the store with
their boat.
Q). What were their names?
A. Mr. Crown and his brother and we had these two motors at
the store and it was agreed to let these two motors go down the
river. Mr. Lloyd and IT talked with Mr. Crown and we decided
to let the motors go down the river to be operated on the back of
Mr. Crown's boat. George Armistead, at the time, was instructed
to go along to help lift these motors from the car to the boat—
each of these motors weighed a little better than seventy-five
pounds apiece—and to help load them in the car when they got
through.
Q. Do what!
A. Load them back in the car when through.
Q. Help load and unload them ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did he have any directions to get in the boat to go in the
river to do anything ¢
Mr. Parrisn. I object, unless it is shown that this witness in-
structed George Armistead,
By the Deputy ComMMIsSIONER:
Q. Did he have authority to give him instructions any other
time during his employment ?
eS eee
eS el lOO eS me eer tlle
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 37
A. Yes, sir.
Q. ™~ were his immediate superior ?
. Mr. Todd and I and he worked for Mr. Lloyd.
53 o. All three of you?
A. Yes. sir. If Mr. Lloyd wanted a motor carried any-
where or if anybody wanted a hand, George helped.
Q. You can state whether he was going down to the river and
what he was going for?
A. He was not instructed to enter the boat.
Q. Any time?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you see this boat these men were going to try out?
A. Yes, sir. I examined it on the trailer.
Q. Describe it?
A It was fifteen feet long and of good construction, following
along boats of that type. The boat was a V-bottem boat. That
refers to the design of the boat and compares in average and is a
fairly safe boat of itstype. It conforms to the outboard run about,
Q. Did it have a cockpit and deck over the top of the boat?
A. It had a deck over the forward part of the boat and the rest
of the way it was open, with seats, and the stern was fixed so it
could be attached with an outboard motor.
Q. You don't know who gave him mstructions to go down there?
A. Yes, sir; I think I do.
By Mr. Fviton:
Q. But you don't know of your own knowledge ¢
A. No, sir; I can't say . definitely know who gave him instruc-
tions to go down there.
By the Deruty ComMMISsIONER :
Q. It would be you, Mr. Todd, or Mr. Lloyd ¢
A. Yes, sir. J must have given permission to take the
4 motors out of the shop and IT gave that permission to Mr.
Lloyd.
Q. Who went with him /
A. Cooper; Johnnie Cooper.
Q. He was a Mechanic's Helper /
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you instruct him to go down or somebody else to do
that ¢
A. Yes. [didn't instruct Johnnie directly, but T gave my con-
sent. Mr. Lloyd asked me if it would be all right for Johnnie to
go and I gave my consent.
Q. He was allowed to go with your knowledge and approval,
whether you consented or not ?
A. Yes, sir.
38 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Q. You didn't tell him what to do that day ¢
A. Not particularly that day, but George was instructed not
to get on boats and he was particularly instructed about that, but
sometimes he might do some work on motors. We didn’t want
him working on the mechanie’s work: didn’t want people to see
him working on motors.
Q. He would have to get in the boat. if his job was to lift it in
the boat ?
A. Not particularly. The stern was pulled on the shore and
the motor was attached to it.
By Mr. Furton:
Q. You said he was given specific instructions. Did he have
any authority or instructions to ride on boats, perform any duties
on navigable rivers, or any other kind of rivers /
A. No, sir.
By the Derury COMMISSIONER :
Q. Did he ever, for the benefit of the company or with
55 your knowledge, act as watchman for any boats over night é
A. He acted as watchman on a thirty-five foot Chris-
Craft we sold Mr. Warner Moore and he was paid by Mr. Moore
and he was not there at our request and George stayed in the store
and finished his work and was back the next morning.
Q. He wasn't your employee and the other man paid him and
directed him what to do?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Furton:
Q. He never stayed on any boats for you /
No, sir.
»
By the Deputy ComMISSIONER:
Q. You never sent him out on any mission of that kind ¢
A. To stay on a boat or run it ¢
@. Yes, sir.
A. No, sir.
By Mr. Parrisn:
Q. You stated that he worked in the store primarily. He would
do anything that you told him é
A. Yes. sir: I think George would.
Q. The fact that he went out on this occasion, apparently under
somebody else's instruction, shows that you sent him outside of
the store on occasions ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Mr. Hobbs. do you know who told him to go down theyriver
on this occasion ¢
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 39
A. I can’t definitely say that Ido. I think Mr. Lloyd can.
Q. Generally, the purpose was for him to assist in help-
56 ‘ing to take the motors and putting them in the car from
tne shop «nd out of the car on the boat and back off the
boat in the car and back to the shop ¢
Yes, sir.
It usually took two men?
Yes, sir.
You weren't going to put both motors on at the same time?
No, sir.
You were just testing them at the same time?
Yes, sir.
POPoreoe
By the Deputy Com MISSIONER :
You didn’t send them down ina truck?
In Mr. Todd’s ear.
How would you get a boat down there ¢
The Corporation has a trailer and take Mr. Todd’s ear.
And tow them down there ¢
Yes, sir.
Di:ln't George go on other occasions to take 2 motor and
bring back; how often ¢
A. No, sir: George was not there in the capacity of delivery boy.
He would put motors in the car and deliver them to different parts
of town. T can’t recali another instance where George was sent to
the river.
Q. You didn’t send him down with instructions to put motors
on the boat or lift them on the boat ¢
A. No, sir. He was purely in the capacity of strong-arm man,
to help the mechanic get it from land to water.
pOrePrere
By Mr. Parrisu:
Q. Who notified Jessie of George’s death ?
at A. Mr. Todd. I think it was the undertaker first.
Q. From your company ¢
A. Mr. Todd.
And further this witness sayeth not.
Wenrorp Earn Lroyp, a witness for the Defendant, having been
recalled, testified as follows:
By Mr. Fvtrton:
Q. You have previously been called by the other side and testt-
fied that, on the day George Armistead was drowned, Mr. Crown
or the two Messrs. Crown came by the Motor Boat Sales, Incor-
porated, and that they had on their trailer their boat, and that
they came in to look at some outboard motors, being interested in
ime
40 Ee. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
one to we on their beat: just what occurred with respect to your
instructions: what did you instruct George Armistead with refer-
ence to his work ¢
Mr. Parrisu. He has testified to that. He testified that he
didn’t give him any instructions.
A. I didn't testify that I didn't give him any instructions,
By Mr. ParrisH:
Q. Tell us what you said.
A. Mr. Crown came by our place. He asked me to look at this
new boat that he or his brother made. He looked at two engines
in the garage: one was an Elto and one was a Johnson; and I
don't know whether I said first or Mr. Crown that I would like to
try the motors in the boat. The moters, both of these were too
large to put in the test barrel at high speed, because they would
throw the water out. We wanted to try them. as I testified, and I
went to Mr. Hobbs and asked him could he send them down to the
river and help him.
By Mr. Furron:
5s Q. What did vou tell George Armistead to do é
A. He was instructed to get the equipment ready for any
trip I was going on. George was instructed to help Johnnie take
it off the trailer and help pat in on the boat, but he was not
instructed to ride on the boat.
Q. That was the mstructions ¢
A. Yes, sir,
Q. And he left the store under those instructions! Had he au-
thority or direction from you, while there, to go out on the river
riding ina boat that was operated in deep water ¢
A. Not any kind of water. The majority of times he would
leave the store he would delicgr a motor around town which had
been repaired.
By the Deputy ComMMISSIONER :
(. He was instructed to help get the motor out of the trailer
to the boat. and when througi., reverse the procedure ¢
A. Yes, sir; that is right.
Ry Mr. Parrisn:
q. As well as vou can recall, Mr. Lleyd. what was said by you
to George when he left to go down to the river on this occasion !
A. Well, I suppose——
Q. T asked you what you said. not what you supposed ¢
A. As well as I recall, 1 either told Johnmie to take George or
I told George to go and help. T can't say whether I told George
or Johnnie.
FE. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR ROAT SALES, INC. 4]
Q. You don't know whether you gave the instruction to George
or Johnnie ?
A. IT don't know. Usually I may have teld George. I
59 wouldn't transfer the message through the other.
Q. Was that as far as your instructions went; to take
the equipment down and after it was tried out bring it back ?
A. Yes, sir.
And further this witness sayeth not.
Wituiam Crown, a witness for the Defendant, having been duly
eworn, testified as follows:
By Mr. Fuiton:
Q. Are you one of the Messrs, Crown that went to the Motor
Boat Sales, Incorporated. on August 8 1938, with a boat ¢
I am the only Mr. Crown that went by there.
And you were the party that went by ¢
Yes, sir.
And that boat was yours ¢
No, sir: it was my brother's. I had charge of it at that
Baan
ek
. You did take it on your trailer to the James Rive: ¢
N Yes, sir. We had the boat built, My brother built it. He
was a mechanic. T wanted to show it to Mr. Todd and Mr. Lioyd.
We got acquainted with them through our four-cylinder Elto
motor that we had. We put it on the trailer and IT carried it by
the Motor Boat Sales and pulled up in the back alley and went
mand told them T had something I wanted them to see, and they
came and looked it over. T wouldn't say for sure, Mr. Lloyd or
Mr. Hobbs—either one or the other of them, I don't know which
Way it came up—said they had two niotors to try out, and T took
the boat on the tratler and we made arrangements to meet at the
river at two o'clock, and, In the meantime, T goes to the
(4) shop where my brother worked, Sash Doer and Glass, and
told my brother what arr aieiine I made. and he was
anxious to see it, and he got the boss to let him off. He called
the other people, the Miller Manufacturing Company—
Q. You needn't tell about that ?
A. He got off and went down. T don’t know whether we got
there first or George and Johnnie, and we took the boat and put
it inthe river, and one end of it was in the river and one end was
on the bank. It was too heavy for one man te get on the boat
and put the moter on, and George stands on the bank and lifted
it on the boat to clamp on it and shove ic in the water to right it.
Q. Was George Armistead teid by you or by Mr. Johnnie Cooper,
the boy that went from the Motor Boat Sales down, to get in your
boat and ride, or was he ordered and directed not to ¢
42 E. V. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did he have any work to do on the boat ?
A. None at all.
Q. You were present when he was told to go down with these
motors ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you were present when they got down there ?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Ard you never heand anyone tell George to get in the boat
and ride ¢
A. No, sir.
Q. Was it your boat that capsized in the river when George
was drowned ¢
A. Yes. sir. The boat was coming straighg up the river
61 and it hit something and turned towards Uff Manchester
skle, and that is the side that George went out and Johnnie
went out Goward Richmond, and George made a couple of strokes,
like he was gomg to swim to the Manchester side, and Johnnie went
towards Richmond and he got back towards the boat, and it didn’t
seem like George got a good hold on the boat. It was on an angle,
the nose of the boat was upside down, and it drifted down the
river like that, because the weight of the motor held the stern
down.
hv Mr. Parrisy:
Q. What kind of rigging did you have on the boat for the motor?
A. It was just an outboard motorboat. It was made to clamp on
an outboard boat.
Q. Did you have any forward control ¢
A. No, sir.
Q. One man couldn't put the motor on ¢
A. Not very handy; could if he was a good man.
Q. He would have to be a big strong man /
A. He would have to have a good bit of strength, but we dian’t
take a chance.
Q. Did you see the accident /
A. Yes, sir,
(J. Were you there when they went out ¢
A. Yes, sir.
(2. How did they happen to go out in the boat 4
A. Like I said at first, we wanted to try it and they had gotter
down there and they put the Johnson motor on and tried it and
went on and rode the river and
Q. Who went on that trip?!
A. All four of us. There was a rock or a rock pile in the
river.
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 43
62 Q. Big rock in the river about oppesite the City wharf?
A. Yes. sir. They went just this side the rock and turned
around then and came in and IT looked at my watch and I didn't
have much time and they had an Elto motor they wanted to try.
Q. You took the other one off!
A. Took the Johnson off and put the Elto on and we had a little
trouble getting it started. The battery was weak, one of them.
and they took the battery out of our car and tried to borrow one
from the Little Oil Company and couldn't get one and took it from
our car and Johnnie and George went out in the boat,
Q. You didn't have time to go?
A. I didn’t have time to go, but I stayed there to bring the boat
home. It was built to move anywhere you wanted to take it.
They put the Elto motor on and made the trip and came back to
the bank and wanted me and my brother to go. I told them “no.”
and they had a little gas to burn in the carburetor and they made
another trip up the river and down the river; I don't know how
far and they were coming back up the river and got in between the
Little Oil Company and the Standard Oil Company's warehouse,
the boat was coming up the river and hit something and it: was
knocked loose on the bottom, not enough to sink, but we had to
repair it when we got it home. We took some clamps and some
wrenches and fixed it.
Were you there when they got there with the motors 4
I don't know.
But it was approximately the same time /
TI might have been there first.
Whichever got there first would have to wait /
A. Yes, sir.
63 Q. And Johnnie and George put the motors on 4
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And then went through the trips you have explained ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Ry Mr. Furton:
Q. You put the motor on the end ¢
A. Yes. sir. George had hold of the propeller and Johinie had
hold of the motor, inside the boat. He had to clamp it on.
Q. And the outside of the boat was standing on land ¢
A. Yes, sir.
By the Deputy ComMIssioner:
You said something about righting the boat.
Righting the motor. It was standing on a slant.
Who put the boat off the bank ?
All four of us.
Creve
rere
44 E. VY. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Q. Was George in the boat /%
A. He was helping us.
Q. Did he hop in?
A. He got in.
Q. I am talking about the second time they took the trip.
A. I don’t think George got out.
Q. I understood you to say he was on the bank and the other
fellow was inside ¢
A. When they hooked it first Johnnie was inside and George
was outside. Johnnie got in the boat and George handed the
motor over and held the propeller and he clamped it.
Q. That was the first trip?
A. Yes, sir.
64 Q. About the second trip; how about that? Were you
still there?
A. Yes, sir. I don’t know whether George took the battery
out there or Johnnie or one of us. The boat was in the water.
Q. The boat was in the water?
A. Yes, sr,
Q. When it was on the bank was the first trip?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were you figuring on buying it, if you liked it?
A. I don’t know whethe: I was figuring on buying it or not,
but right now we own the motor.
Q. You had some interest in it ?
A. In the Johnson motor.
Q. They were quite interested to sell?
A. To see whether the boat would carry the motor.
Q. They were interested in selling a motor?
A. That is true. They had two moters and they didn’t have
any way to test them in the shop.
Q. Two men were down on company business; we can egree on
that.
A. No answer.
And further this witness sayeth not.
JoHn Samven Cooper, a witness for the Defendant, having been
duly sworn, testified as follows:
By Mr. Futon:
QJ. State your name and your age.
A. John Samuel Cooper and I am twenty-one.
Q. Where were you working on August 8, 1938?
A. Motor Boat Sales.
65 Q. How long have you been working for them?
A. I went to work March 15th.
Q. 1938 ¢
"
5
,
>
bs
‘ E, V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 45
A. Yes, sir. .
Q. And you had been working for them from that time on
up through August 1938 ¢— ;
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You are still working for them ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And have been with them ever since?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What were you employed to do!
A. I was to help Mr. Lloyd, tie mechanic. I worked on motors
and repaired motors; helper to Mr. Lloyd.
Q. Helper to Mr. Lloyd?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What were George Armistead’s duties?
A. Wash up motors and polish them and general helper, and
in the mornings, sweep in the store.
Q. You heard Mr. Lloyd testify, and that was his testimony ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You also heard Mr. Hobbs testify as io that ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. On that day, August 8th, that Mr. Crown came by, what
was George Armistead, the colored boy that was later drowned,
what was he going with you down the river for?
A. To help me.
Q. Do what ¢
66 A. Take the motor off the trailer and put it on the boat
and take it off when finished.
Q. Did he have any duties in running a motor on out in the
water /
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Did you instruct him to get in the boat or did he go on his
own accord, for a pleasure ride ?
A. He went on his own accord.
Q. You were up there when you were told to take the motor
down and he went along to help unlead the motors from the trailer
and attach them to the boat and take them and put them back
in the trailer ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And they were his sole duties?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You heard what was said to him?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You never gave him any and you didn’t hear anybody give
him any duties to go on water?
A. Not to my knowledge.
46 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BCAT SALES, INC.
Q. When these motors were taken off the trailer and each one
was attached to the boat, where was the end of the boat ¢
A, Sitting on the shore, like Mr. Crown said.
Q. Was that true when you took the Johnson motor off the
boat and put the other motor on, that the boat was pulled up on
the shore and one motor was taken off and the other motor was
put on
A. Just the back end was out of the water. The whole boat
was not out of the water: just the back end,
Q. At the time the accident happened, who was driving the
boat ¢
A. I was driving the boat.
67 Q. What caused it to turn over ¢
A. Striking some object.
Q. Was the river clear or muddy ¢
A. Muddy.
Q. The boat capsized and threw you and George out and you
hung on the boat until rescured ¢
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Parrisu:
Q. Mr. Cooper. von were present when Mr. Crown testified,
weren't you /
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You heard all ¢f his testimony ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It is true that the four of you took the first trip with the
Elto motor?
A. With the Johnson motor.
And who took the second trip. you and George, with the
Elto motor /
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You apparently put che motor on to try it out ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You couldn't put it on alone /
A. No, sir. ,
Q. George helped /
A. George and Mr, Crown.
WY. You ‘didn’t tell George not to get in that boat on either
occasion ¢
A. No. sir.
Gs By Mr. Fciten:
Q. You didn't tell him to get in the boat?
A. No, sir.
Q. He had no instructions to operate the boat on the river?
A. No, sir.
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 47
By Mr. Parris:
Q. He had no instructions either way ?
A. No, sir. -
The Derury CoMMISSION®R :
Q. You said the motor was put on when they had taken it to the
hank ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. If they attached it to the boat out of te water, how would
you get it in the water ¢
A. Mr. Crown and his brother helped shove it off.
(). Where was George when you were getting it pushed over
hoard: do you recall ¢
A. The first trip ¢
(). Second one ¢
A. He was in the boat.
Q. He didn't get out /
A. He possibly got out to help get the battery and put that in
the boat.
Q. Did he help take the first motor off and put the other one on ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was che purpose of the second trip ¢
A. Totry the motor out and see how it operated.
Q. You could handle it all right: whether by yourself or
6u with somebody else ¢
A. Yes. sir.
Q. He didn't do anything to assist vou?
A. Novsir. He did sit in the front and keep a lookout.
Q. What was the purpose of that ¢
A. The water was muddy and to see if he saw anything.
Q. Was that necessary or helpful to vou ¢
A. It was helpful.
By Mr. Furton:
¥ Did vou give lim any orders to sit in front 4
A. No, sir.
Q. There was a seat up front and he was sitting there /
A. Yes, sir.
By the Deputy CoMMISSIONER :
Q. And he was to be there until you were ready to go back to the
store ¢
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Parrisn:
Q. What sort of battery was this?
A. Six volt.
SS 225— 41--— 4
ns
48 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Q. Automobile battery?!
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is that the sort of battery you had to start it with?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you have two batteries there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The first battery was not powerful enough to start it?
A No, sir.
70 Q. And that was put on the boat?
A. In the boat.
Q. Did you hook the two batteries up?
A. I believe we did hook thém up.
Q. Was it necessary for George to help hook them up?
A. I did it myself.
Q. Could you start the motor by yourself?
A. Yes, sir. There wasn’t room for but one and I could start it.
Q. It was hooked up by cable ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The ordinary cable, does it have connectns so you can hook
up two batteries ¢
A. The crdinary cable you can hook two batteries if you have
the tools and a piece of wire.
Q. A battery has two poles?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The ordinary cable does not have two connections ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You can have three connections?
A. Three separate cables. ,
Q. How would you hook them up?
A. One cable runs to the positive side.- That went to the starter
and switch on the motor, and the other one went to the ground of
the motor.
Q. How did you hook the other positive and negative ?
A. With a cable.
Q. Who held that cable?
A. It was stationary.
rat By Mr. Furton:
Q. That was a small boat; about what would it weigh?
A. I wouldn't like to have to say. Around about 200 or 225
pounds. It is hard to judge the weight of a boat.
Q. The Motor Boat Sales never sold an eighteen-ton cruiser
while you were up there?
A. No, sir.
E. V. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 49
By the Deputy ComMIssioNER:
Q. How often did you go down to work on boats ¢
A. Not very often. This was the first time T had been down
for some time.
Q. Did you go on other trips?
A. No, sir; [had a boat of my own.
Q. Did ye: go for the company on similar jobs, to put a motor
on a boat or to test it out ¢
A. Not that I remember.
Q. This was the only time ¢
A. Yes, sir.
And further this wiiness sayeth not.
S. Kine Fucton, a witness for the Defendant. having been duly
sworn, testified, as follows:
By Mr. Friton:
Q. State your name and what connection you had with the
Motor Boat Sales, Inc., on August 8, 1938, and prior thereto ¢
A. S. King Fulton; I was President of the Corporation in
August 1938. I was inactive, because T was in business in Wash-
ington, but I made a trip down occasionally; one or two trips a
months; periodic trips.
Q. Did you hire this boy, George P. Armistead, Jr. who
72. got drowned on August 8, 1938?
A. I did.
Q. How long had he been with the Company ¢
A. I think since 1936 or 1937; two or two and one-half years
Q. What were his duties?
A. He wasa porter. We had a porter that lived on the premises,
but when George took the job, he was married, and he did not live
on the premises. He was a porter and operated under mny super-
vision and in December 1937, at which time I went to Wash-
ington——
Q. Were his duties ever changed? You went backward and
forward.
A. No, sir.
Q. What instructions did you give him and other employees.
generally, when they delivered things, about going in other peo-
ple’s boats /
A. George was cautioned never to go into a boat or have any-
thing to do with a boat or motor, as explained by Mr. Hobbs.
The class of boat we sell our customers does not demand a sale’s
technique. IT haa * rigid rules in regard to handling boats.
Prior to November 1‘ I laid the law down very rigidly in regard
to that. I think everybody in the store knew my ruling.
50 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
Q. What was your ruling: not to go out in rivers or boats for
anybody f
A. Yes. sil
By Mr. Parrisn:
Q. Wher did vou lay down that law ¢ Prior to December L437
when vou went to Washington, wasn’t it?
AL Yes. sn
By the Derury CoMMISSIONER :
73 Q. What is the general nature of your business !
haps [ do know it, but I would like to get it in the record.
AL We sell boat supphes, maritime supplies, movors for outboard
Loats, and outboard boats and rowboats, sailboats, and cruisers.
Q. ‘To what extent did vou deliver them on board vessels?
A. They are new bouts and they come in on flat cars. All boats
we sold were put overboard by the Richmond Sand and Gravel
Company, and the ewner went aboard, and when I was here I went,
vnd in some cases The mechanics went, but when I was at the boat.
The only thing that had to be put on the boat was the propeller.
The boat came on a flat car, and the reason that was not on was
because it might get broken. It was put on on the flat car, and
the Richmond Sand and Gravel Company picked them up with
4 orane and dropped them overboard,
You had notiung to do with unloading them 4
A. No.sir. We contracted with the Richmond Sand and Grave!
( “OMAP aN to cle that,
(). When vou furnished supplies, did they get them ?
Thev did. The boats were well equipped.
W. If owned a boat a year or two and wanted some work dove
on it, would you do it ¢
A. Very few boats were kept in Richmend since 1937, wren
iy! obsoleted this harbor. We di lit have a delivery truck: and
f they wanted to bring them down, we would ‘work on them. Tf
M suited then: to bring the boat down, we would work on it.
Q. Would vour salesmen take a boat out
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. What would a person do if le wanted to see the boat on the
river
4 A. The owner would. if he Iiked the boat, get somebods
that had one to take hime.
Q. You sell these boats ¢
A. Yes.su
YY. If you Ww anted to interes people, you would take them out
and ran them around the harbor /
_ The boats are not here.
Q). T thought perhaps-———
Pe;
E. V. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 51
A. Take Warner Moore and Doctor Herring; they would invite
the customer and show them the boat. The big boat would sell
themselves, and there is not much the salesman can do except point
out certain advantages.
Q. You didn't feel that your work was such that you had to
have coverage under our Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’
Compensation Act?
A. The boats were insured until they were put overboard.
Q). Iam talking about compensation coverage.
A. IT don't know. “1 couldn't answer that. Mr. Hobbs could
answer that.
By Mr. Furtron:
Q. Did you handle any boats weighing eighteen tons, such as
are referred to in Section three ?
Mr. Parrisu. Is that material ¢
The Deputy ComMissioner. I don't think it is material, because
the requirement is that for a vessel under eighteen tons the person
going aboard must be engaged by the master.
Nr. Funron. T want to show that he had a small boat.
Mr. Parrisx. We will admit that.
The Depury Commissioner. That may be subject to our Law.
Is that all?
vo Mr. Fevros. That is all.
By Mr. Parrisu:
Q. Mr. Falton, you have delivered a good many boat. in Rich
mond 4
A. Yes. sir: and quite a few throughout Virginia.
By the Depcty ComMMIssioNer :
Q. Did this man have occasion, ander your direction, to act ag
Watchman ¢
AT was here whee that specific case came up that they men-
honed. [took Mr. Warner Moore and carried him to the Chris-
Craft factory and he saw the boats in action and bought one and
lean state definitely that T did not allow hin to go on board the
beat. Creorge was a fine colored boy.
By Mr. Futon:
Was he employed to work on a boat!
No, sir.
It has been in evidence that he acted as a night watchman
Warner Moore engaged him.
Who emploved him to act as night watchman ¢
Warner Moore, Jr.. he employed him,
And further this witnes- suave th not.
Herero ek
52 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES. INC.
- The Depvcty Commisstoner. Do both sides vest /
Mr. Parris. Yes. sir.
Mr. Fcuren. Yes, sir.
Mr. Parris. T overlooked filing the burial expense.
The Deputy ComMissioner. We have it.
Mr. Parrisu. That is considered a part of the record ¢
The Derury Cosmisstoner, Yes. sir. Would vou gentle.
76 nen like to write briefs¢ This is a new pot,
Mr. Fcri1on. We would like to.
Mr. Parrisn. When would they have to be iné TP have a lot of
court engagements.
Tee Dercry Commissioner. How about the 10th of November?
Mr. Parrisn.’ Both file brief< iy the loth of November ¢
The Devury ComMisstonrr. Yes, sir.
Me. Fuitron. IT have some matters that will take me out of town
some. T would tike to have his brief first.
The hearing was thereupon concluded.
| Reporter's certificate to foregoing transcript omitted in
printing. |
7s ( Vadim’ s keirh ‘bit ]
Form U.S. 264
Usitep Srares Eatesovers’ Compensation Leave this space
(OM MISSION blank.
Office of Deputy Comumisstoner 020202002. ——
_...----- Administering Longshore- Cuse No. 25-1.
mens ond Harbor Werkers Conpen Lneprance Carrier's
ation Act No, None.
PROOF OF DEATH
(By Phytera Lua! i: Attendance on Deceased )
Norr.---Verification of this report may snake i unnecessary for
the puysician making the same to attend hearing as a witness.
L Name of the deceased in full, George Percel)] Armistead. J+.
Address, 22 E. Hill St.. Richmond, Va.
Z. Age at death. 24 vears. Married or single’ Married.
3. Name of enplover, Motor Boat Sales. In Address. 3. W.
Grace St.. Rechimend. Va.
4. How long huive Vou beets medical adviser of deceased ¢
3. Date of accident or first ness. August 81838. Date of death,
August &, 193s,
6. Date of your first visit 22-2 - 192... Date of last visit -.22.2
Ee. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 53
7. Place of death (give street number, city or town, and state),
James River, at Richmond, Va.
& Who engaged your services? City Coroner.
9, State in patient’s own words how accident occurred or oecu-
pational disease was caused :
10. Give a complete and accurate description of nature and
extent of injury or occupational disease, as you found it upon first
and subsequent examinations: Drowned accidentally while riding
in motorboat which overturned,
11. State che direct cause of death: Drowning.
rie (Let your answer he explicit and complete)
In your opinion, was the accident or occupational disease
as above described a cause either directly or Indirectly of the
death ¢
13. Give contributory causes, if any:
14. If coroner's inquest held. give coroner's name and address :
Dr. George Williams. Richmond, Va.
15. Was deceesed attended by any other physician during last
ilness? If so, name and address :
16. [ am a physician duly licensed in the State of Virginia,
and graduated in the year 1931 from University of Colorado
Medical College.
(Sgd.) Grorce Z. WinniaMs,
Coroner, Attending Physicum,
Address, Richmond, Va.
Dated October 20, 193%.
9 STATE OF VIRGINIA,
City of Richmond, «x
George Zeer (4) Woilatie. being duly sworn, deposes and says:
That he ts the pRysei ian who subseribed to the above (or attac hed)
report: that he has read the same and knows the convents thereof:
that the sane is Crue to the knowledge of deponent, except as to the
matters therem stated to be alleged on information and benef,
and as to those matters he believes it to be true.
Subscribed and sworn to before mie this vor hay of October
143,
| sear! (Sed.) Eurnor |. Jonson,
Notary Public.
My commission expires January 21. 1941.
Thos blank must be signed personally | y the attending physician
orn hiespital cases personally by the Supe rintendent,
Importrant.—-.rli quest.ons to be fully answered, 9 1231. Ul.
Government Printing OU ice
5A E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES. INC.
») ~ Exhibit B
(Notre.—For Exhibit B, filed March 29th, 1940. in the hearing
- before the United States District Court, see page 9.)
SI In United States District Court
No. 1507-M
Moror Boat Saves, [NcoRPORATED
ves,
E. V. Parker. Deputy Commissioner, and Jessie Booker
ARMISTEAD AND OTHERS
Memorandum hy the Court
Fijed June 11, 1940
This is a suit to review an award of compensation made under
the Longshoremen’s & Harborworkers’ Compensation Act. Title
33. Sections 901-950, U.S.C. A. George P. Armistead, Jr. an
employee of Motor Boat Sales. Incorporated, was drowned in
James River at Richmond, Virginia, on Angust &. 1938. Jessie
Booker Avtmnistead, widow of George P. Armistead, Jr. filed a
claim with the United States Employees’ Compensation Com-
nussion against Motor Bort Sales. Incorporated, asking for an
award of compensation under the said Act. A hearing was had
before a Deputy Commissioner for the Fifth Compensation Ds-
trict, who made findings of fact and an award of compensation
to the claimant and her dependents. This suit was then inst!
tuted pursuant to Section 921 to permanently en, oin the said award.
By order of Court the claimants before the Deputy Conimigsioner
were allowed to intervene. -
The Act affords compensation to certain marine workers “for
accidental tnjury or death arising out of or in the course of the
employment.” The Act provides that the term “employer” im
cludes “an emplover any of whose employees are enmploved in
marine employment, in whole or i part. nen the navigab!.
waters of the United States.”
The complainant alleges many grounds why che award should
be peruanently enjoined. Some of these grounds were mot rarsed
before the Deputy Conunissioner, and many of them do not mertt
serious consideration and were actnaliv abandoned at the hearin
before the Court.
The constitutionality. of the Act is questioned. The Aet
war held te be constitutional by the Supreme Court of th
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 5d
M2 United States in the case of Crowell v. Benson, 285 U.S.
22.
Section 90Ba of the Act provides that compensation may be
awarded only if the accident occurred upon navigable waters of
the United States and if recovery through workmen's compensa-
tion proceedings may not validly be provided by state law. It is
not denied that the accident occurred upon navigable waters of
the United States. and it would seem that the Virginia Work-
men’s Compensation Act is net and could not be made applicable
toa case suchas this. See Southern Pacific Company v. Jenson,
Y44ULS. 205; Noguira v. New York, New Haven and Hartford
Company. 281 U.S. 138; Johnson v. Elliott, loz Va. 121: and the
documents of the Industrial Commission of Virginia in Irwin v.
Friend & Company, 12 O. I. C. 490.
It is contended that the compensation order, findings of the
Deputy Commissioner and award are not in accordance wid law.
The proceedings of the Deputy Commissioner conformed to the
statute, Congress has power to invest the Deputy Commissioner
vith authority to determine whether the death arose out of and
m the course of the employment, and when the Deputy Com-
wissioner, following the course prescribed by the statute, makes
such a determination, his findings of fact supported by the evi-
denve are deemed to be conclusive. Doehl v. Indemnity Insurance
Company, 288 U.S. 162. :
But it is contended that the finding of the Deputy Corioissioner
that there existed the emplover-emplovee relation necessary. for
an award under the Act is without evidence to support it. It ts
not dened that there existed between the complainant and Arm)\-
stead the ordinary relation of master and servant, but it is con-
tended that the death of Armisiead did not arise out of or in the
course of the employment and that the complainant was not an
employer any of whose employees were employed in maritime
employment. in whole or in part. Pthink that the finding of the
Deputy Commissioner on these points is supported by the proofs.
In this connection the name of the complainant company and
the very nature of its business are significant. Not only
“5 is the company engaged in the business of selling boats,
motor.. and marine supplies, but it also serviced and dem
onstrated its boats and motors on liavigable waters. and it. em-
piovees also operated its boats for long trial trips before they
Were seid. Etoas true that Ammistead was employed as a janitor
aid handuiuais on the store and that whtie working there he took
lis orders from Mr. Todd. However, when performing services
outside the store Armistead wes subject to the orders of the white
snployce he Was assisting. On ne occasion in question he was
“nt to the river with Cooper with imstructions to help Cooper
56 E. V. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
and while there was subject to the orders of Cooper. The object
of the trip to the river was to demonstrate for the purpose of
making sale thereof a motor belonging to the company. After help-
ing Cooper to attach the motor to the boat and to connect the
batteries, Armistead went with Cooper on a trip “to try the motor
out and to see how it operated.” While Co »er did not order
Armistead to go with him on the trial trip, .. mistead was in
the boat with the consent and approval of Cooper who for th.
time being wa. his boss. And at the very moment that the boat
capsized Armisvead was keeping a lookout for Cooper who was
operating the boat. Under such circumstances it cannot be sue-
cessfully contended that Armistead’s death did not arise out of
or in the course of work he was employed by the company to
perform or that the company was not an employer any of whose
employees were employed in maritime employment.
An order refusing to enjoin the award and dismissing the com-
plaint may be presented after notice.
(Sed.) Rost. N. Poii-xp,
Cnited States District Judae.
JUNE 11, 1940.
&4 In United States District Court
Motion of plaintiff for leave to rearaue case, ete,
Filed June 24, 1940
This day comes the plaintiff, Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated,
and moves the Court to be allowed to reargue the above cause and
for a rehearing of the same, on the grounds and fer the reasons:
i. That the Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’ Act has two
fundamental limitations :
(1) It deals exclusively with compensation in respect to dis-
ability or death resulting from an injury occurring upon navigable
waters of the United States, if recovery through workmen's com-
pensation proceedings may not validly be provided by state law:
and
(2) It apphes only when the aceidental injury or death arises
out of and in the course of employment of the employee in mari-
time employment, in whole or part. upon such navigable waters.
and the Act as construed in this case by the Distriet Court is in
violation of the Constitution of the United States in that it holds
thatthe Congress may substitute for Constitutional courts, in which
the judicial power of the United States is vested, an administrative
agent, uamely. a single Deputy Commissioner, for the final deter-
mination of the existence of facts upon which the enforcement of
PE CeO
:
|
|
|
|
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 57
the Constitutional rights of the plaintiff depend, and in that it
holds that there is no limitation of such Deputy Commissioner’s
power to determine the fundamental facts and thus oust the Coart
of the deter mination of such facts by vesting the authority to make
them with finality in such Deputy Commissioner or administrative
agency, thereby destroying the judicial power as it exists under
the Federal Constitution and makes the findings of such agencies
in effect finality as to law.
&5 (3) That the findings of the Deputy Commissioner are
not in accordance with law and are not supported by the
evidence and are without evidence to support them, as appears
from the record, and that this Court has erred in deeming such
findings conclusive under the facts and 'aw in this cause—all the
uncontradicted evidence showing that George P. Armistead, Jr.,
the decedent's, injury and death did net arise out of and in the
course of his employment, and that he was not employed to work
upon navigable waters of the United States and that his employ-
ment was not of a maritime character, and at the tinie he was
drowned he was not performing any duties he had been employed
or directed to do, and that the matter of his death was local and
not related to navigation or commerce, and the relation of master
and servant did not exist pro haee death; and
(4) That the death of George P. Armistead, Jr., did not fall
within the coverage of the Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’
Act: that there was no basis for such recovery under said Act and
in admiralty.
For the above and other reasons appearing in the Bill of Com-
plaust and Record, the plaintiff moves the Court to be allowed
to reargue the above cause and for a rehearing of the same.
This Tune 24, 1940.
Motor Boat Saces. [NCoRPOR TED,
By (Sed.) M. J. Furron,
M. J. Fulton,
Tt» Counsel.
Sr In United States District Court
| Title oniutted. |
Order refusing rearqgumcnt, « a
Entered and filed June 24. 1v40
This day came the plaintiff. Motor Boat Sales. Incorporated,
and moved the Court to be allowed to reargue the above cause
for reasons set forth in writing and hereby filed
5S E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
It appearing that the grounds and reasons for the motion to
reargue its said cause have heretofore been argued and considered
by the Court. the motion to reargue is hereby overruled and
denied, to which action of the Court the complainant, by counsel,
excepted,
(Sed.} Ropr. N. Pouarp,
United States District Judge.
JUNE 24, 1940.
<7 In United States District Court
Miscellaneous No. 1507
Moror Boat SaLes. INCORPORATED, COMPLAINANT
as,
E. V. Parker, Depury CoMMIsSIONER, and JESSIE Booker ARMI-
STEAD ET AL., DEFENDANTS
Final decree e
Entered and filed June 25, 1940
This cause came on this day to be heard on the bill of complaint,
the motion to dismiss and the answer of the defendant. E. ¥.
Parker, Deputy Commissioner, and on the petition, the motion to
dismiss and the answer of Jessie Booker Armistead, Dorothy
Marian Armistead, George Percell Armistead. IIL. and William
Berkley Armistead, they having intervened in this cause as parties
defendant by leave of Court. and on the motion to dismiss and
answer of Aubrey N. Heflin. guardian ad litem for the said infant
defendant. and on the award of E. V. Parker, Deputy Commis.
sioner, rendered in this matter, and on the transeript of the evi-
dence and the record of the hearing before the said Deputy Com
missioner, and exhibits filed therewith, said award and transeript
of the hearing having been filed with the answer of the said E. V.
Parker, Deputy Commissioner, and was argued by counsel:
And the Court being of opinion that The Longshoremen’s and
Harbor Workers’ Corapensation Act. under which this proceeding
Was instituted as an equity suit. is a part of the maritime liw of
the Unitea States, ind that the jurisdiction conferred on the Court®
of the United States by said Act is admiralty jurisdiction, it is
now ordered that this cause be henceforth proceeded with as ar.
admiralty cause. and that the pleadings heretofore filed by the
several parties under the designations apphed to such pleading-
Inan equity suit ve treated as pleadings filed by the several parties
under the designations applied to pleadings in an admiralty cause.
E. Vv. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 59
And the Court having maturely considered the ma.cer. and
being of opinion for reasons set forth in the Court’s memo-
88 randum heretofore filed in this cause and hereby made a
part of the record, that the jurisdiction of the Commissioner
and the award made by him in this matter are supported by the
evidence and are in accordance with law,
It is adjudged, ordered, and decreed that the libel herein be,
and it is hereby, dismissed, at the cost of the libelant, to which
action of the Court in dismissing the libel, the libelant, by proctor,
objected end excepted.
And it further appearing to the Court that the respondent,
Jessie Booker Armistead, has filed in writing her consent to the
allowance of an additional fee of Two Hundred and Fifty
($250.00) Dellars to the fign of Parrish, Butcher and Parrish, for
services rendered Jessie BoSker Armistead, Dorothy Marian Armi-
stead, George Percell Armistead III, and William Berkeley Armi-
stead in this suit, and that the said Aubrey N. Heflin, guardian
ad litem of the infant respondents, Dorothy Marian Armistead,
George Percell Armistead III, and William Berkeley Armistead,
has committed the interests of the said infant respondents to the
Court in respect to the allowance of proctor fees, and it appearing
to the Court that a fee of Two Hundred and Fifty ($250.00) Dol-
lars for the services of Messrs. Pacrish, Butcher and Parrish in
this Court is reasonable, the same is hereby approved and con-
firmed, and it is adjudged. ordered, and decreed that the allowance
of the additional sum of Two Hundred and Fifty ($250.00) Dol-
lars shall be a lien upon the award of compensation.
(Sgd.) Rosr. N. Pouvarp.
United Statex District Judge.
Jung 25, 1940.
Due service and receipt of a copy of the within proposed anal
decree is hereby admitted this 24th day of June 1940.
(Sgd.) M. J. Furton,
Proctor for Lihelant.
xy RicuMonp, VirGinia,
June 15, 1940.
Mr. R. R. Parrisn,
c/o Parrish, Butcher & Parrish, Richmond, Virginia.
Deak Mr. Parrisn: Following your discussion with me of the
amount of fee to be allowed you for representing me and the
infant dependents of my deceased husband, George Armistead, Jr.,
I wish to advise that the allowance of a fee of $250.00 to you by
the Court will be satisfactory to me. T unde-stand that the
ameunt of fee to be allowed you is in the discretion of the Court,
60 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
and that if I had any objection to the amount I would have the
right to appear before the Court and state my objections. Under
ail of the circumstances, I think such an aliowance for services
rendered me and my children would be reasonable. It is satis-
factory to attach this agreement to any decree or judgment which
may be entered by the Court evidencing my «pproval.
Very truly yours,
325 (Sgd.) Jesste ARMisTEap.
oD) In United States District Court
Petition for appeal
Filed July &, 1940
The petitioner, Motor Boat Sales. Incorporated, hereinafter
referred to as complainant, by S. King Fuivon, its President,
respect fully represents :
1. That it is a corporation organized under the Jaws of the
State of Virginia, and duly authorized and licensed to transact
business in said State of Virginia, which is within the jurisdiction
of the District Courtof the United States for the Eastern District
of Virginia; and that it has authorized the taking of this appeai:
2 That the defendant, E. V. Parker, is Deputy Commissioner
for the Fifth Compensation District of the United States;
3. That the complainant herein was defendant in proceedings
before said) Deputy Commissioner in a claim for compensation
made against it on behalf of Jessie Booker Armistead. Dorothy
Marian Armistead. George Percell Armistead TIT, and Witham
Berkley Armistead, the alleged dependents of George PL Arn
stead, Jr. deceased :
4. After the claim was duly tiled by the alleged dependents of
said George P. Armistead, Jr, with the defendant, E. V. Parker.
Deputy Commissioner, and the complamant therein, made answer
and defense thereto, the defendant, FE. V. Parker, Deputy Com
missioner, aeld a hearing thereon and, after duly swearing the
witnesses, heard their testimony on January 17th, 140, and che
ssid defendant. E. Vo Parker, Deputy Commissioner, on January
17. 140, made certain findings of fact and entered an order on
the complainant herein to pay compensation, under the Long-
shoremen’s and Harbor Workers’ Compensation Act;
5. That thereafter the complamant therein filed a Bill of
Complaint in the above Court asking that the action of
a} said Deputy Comrissioner, E. V. Parker, be reviewed for
the .aatters and reasons therein set forth, and that he be
enjpotned from enforcing said order, and to set aside certain find-
res of fact therein mentioned :
&. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 61
6. That a motion to dismiss and an answer to said Bill of Com-
plaint were filed by the defendant, E. V. Parker, Deputy Commis-
sioner; the dependents of George lV, Armistead, Jr., deceased, filed
a petition and by leave of Court were made party defendants to
said Bill of Complaint, and after a hearing upon the evidence and
record introduced before the said Deputy Commissioner and after
argument thereon the above Court, through Robert N. Pollard,
U.S. District Judge, filed an opinion in which it was indicated
that a decree dismissing the Bill of Complaint could be submitted.
The Court thereupon transferred the cause to the admiralty side
of the Court:
7. That thereafter the complainant, after leave of Court, filed
a motion for leave io reargue the above cause, which motion for
reargument came up for hearing in due course, and after consid-
eration by the Court wes dismissed, to which action of the Dis-
triet Court complainant excepted, and the Court, through Robert
N. Pollard, Judge. filed an opinion in which it was indicated that
a decree dismissing the decree could be submitted and would be
filed for the reasons set forth therein, which opinions have since
been made a part of the record ;
&. Thereafter, in conformity with the opinion of the Court
referred to, a decree dismissing the Bill of Complaint has been
entered, to which complainant objected and excepted ;
9 That petitioner, above-named complainant, conceiving itself
aggrieved by the refusal of the above Court to grant the prayer
of the said Bill of Complaint and by the entry of the decree clis-
missing the same made and entered on June 25th, 1940, and that
an injustice has been done it, does hereby appeal from said order
and decree to the United States Circait Court of Appeals for the
Fourth Cireuit, for the reasons specified in the assiguments of
error attached hereto and filed herewith, and pray that the
appeal may be allowed, and that a supersedeas be allowed
and an injunction be granted enjoining defendant, E. V.
Parker, Deputy Coaumissioner, from: issuing, recording, or collect -
ng sand award pending this appeal upon the filing of good aid
sufficient security for costs and to abide and perform whatever
decree may be entered in the cause by the Cireuit Court of Appeals
or to its mandate to the District Court,
And petitioner will ever pray.
(pi
Motor Boar Sares, INCORPORATED,
By (Sgd.) oS. King Futon,
Ss. King Fulton, President.
(Sgd.) M. J. Friutosx,
M. J. Fulton, Proctor.
(Duly sirarn to hy Georae W. Todd: jurat omitted in printing |
62 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
93 In United Si.tes District Court
{ Title omitted. |
Order dlowing appeal
Entered and filed July 8, i940
The foregoing appeal is allowed to the Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Fourth Circuit.
(Sgd.) Rost. N. Potiarp,
United States District Jratqe.
JULY 8, 1940.
In United States District Court
Assignments of error
Filed July &, 1940
Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated, petitioner libelant in the above-
styled cause, hereby assigns. in connection with its petition for
appeal, the following errors:
1. The Court erred in refusing to enjoia the award and «ils
missing the Bill of Complaint herein. and in affirming the award
of the Deputy Commissioner, E. V. Parker, and in entering judg-
ment thereon against petitioner-lhbelant.
2. The Court erred in holding that the claim of respondents-
claimants for compensation for the death of George P. Armistead.
Jr., “may not validly be provided for by state law.”
3. The Court erred in holding that the award herein for com-
pensation to claimants for the death of George P. Armistead, Jr..
fails exclusively within the coverage of the Longshoremen’s and
Harbor Workers’ Act, and that the District Court and the Deputy
Commissioner had jurisdiction to make such award under said
Act.
4 The Court erred in holding that the death of George P.
Armistead, Jr., upon whose death the award for compensation was
made to respondents, “arose out. of and in the course of his e:n-
ployment in maritime, in whole or part, upon the navigable waters
of the United States.”
a4 5. The Court erred in holding that the findings of the
Deputy Commissioner were in accordance with law, and
were supported by evidence.
ee, te
TMA eS eee ee
TO RAN nn
Rg ey TNT ye Set eae Pees eee R
E. ¥. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOST SALES, INC. 6.3
6. The Court erred in holdiag that the findings of the Deputy
Commissioner, E. Vo Parker, are conclusive and final under the
facets and Jaw in this cause and that compensation for the death of
George P. Armistead, Jr. may be validly provided under the
Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’ Act.
7. The Court erred in holding that the injury and death of
George P. Armistead, Jr.. was not of a iecal character, but was
maritime, and related to navigation or commerce, and that the
relation of master and servant existed between this petitioner-
libelant and George P. Armistead. Jr., decedent, at the time of
hiss injury pro haec his injury and death.
s. The Court erred in holding that this petitioner-libelant: was
guilty of any act resulting in the death of George P. Arinistead,
Jr.. decedent, and was lable for the compensation awsrded to
claimants.
% The Court erred in holding that the Longshoremen's and
Harbor Workers’ Act, as construed in this cause, is not in violation
of the Constitution of the United States, in that it holds that the
Congress of the United States by such Act may substitute for the
constitutional Courts of the United States, in which the judicial
power is vested, an administrative agent, namely a single Deputy
Commissioner, for the final determination of the existence of
facts upon which the enforcement of the constitutional rights of
petitioner-libelant depend, and in that it holds that there is rio
limitation of such Deputy Commissioner’s power to determine
these fundamental facts, and that such administrative agent has
the sole power to determine if recovery through workmen's com-
pensation proceedings may not be validly provided by state law,
and thus ousts the Federal Courts of the determination of such
facts and Jaw by vesting the sole authority to make them with
finality in such Deputy Commissioner or administrative agency,
thereby destroying the judicial power as it exists in the Federal
Courts under the Constitution of the United States and makes the
finding of such an agency in effect finality as to law.
10. The Court erred in holding that the vessel or motor row
boat which George P. Armistead, Jr.. was in at the time of his
death was a vessel within the coverage of the Longshoremen’s and
Harbor Workers’ Act.
11. The Court’s judgment is without evidence to support it
and is contrary to law and the evidence.
And for other errors that may be hereafter assigned.
4 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES. INC.
Wherefore, petitioner, Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated, prays
that judgment entered herein may be reversed and annulled.
(Sgd.) M. J. Funron,
M. J. Fulton,
Proctor for Petitioner-Libelant.
JcuLy Stu. 1940.
OF In United States District Court
Clerk's memorandum
A pyre al hond
Cash bond of Sixtees; Hundred Dollars ($1,600.00) deposited
with Clerk on July 22nd, 1940, and subsequently deposited in the
registery of the Court.
Citation
Issved July 9th, 1940
MARSHALS RETURN
I certify that on the l2th day of Jaly 1940 T served a copy of
the within citation on E. V. Parker, and at the same time handed
hin a copy ef the Order Granting Injunction Pending Appeal,
in person, at Norfolk, Va., a place within my District.
(Sgd.) R. L. Artwortn.
United States Marshal.
By (Sgd.) H.W. Furiow.
H. W. Furlow,
Deputy U.S. Marshal.
5 In United States District Court
Nivpudation as to omission of certain pleadings in record on appeal
Filed July 8, 1940
It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the parties
hereto, by their proctors:
That the Respondents, Jessie Booker Armistead, Dorothy Marian
Armistead, George Percell Armistead ITI, and Wiliiam Berkiey
&
|
\. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 65
Armistead, by leave of Court filed their petition for leave to inter-
vehe as parties respondent in this suit; that this Court after the
issuance and service of a Show Cause Order, as praved for in the
said petition, in due course allowed the respondents above named
in this stipulation to enter their appearance as parties respondent
in this matter; that by like ieave of Court the said intervening
respondents adopted the grounds of the motion to dismiss and of the
answer heretofore filed by the respondent, E. V. Parker. Deputy
Commissioner, as the grounds of their motion to dismiss and
answer; that this Court in due course appointed Aubrey N. Heflin,
a discreet and competent attorney at law guardian ad litem for the
infant respondents, Dorothy Marian Armistead, George Percell
Arnustead ITT, and Wilham Berkley Armistead: that by leave of
Court. the said Aubrey N. Heffit.. guardian ad litem for the above
named infant respondents, adopted the grounds of the motion to
distniss and of the auswer heretofore filed by the respondent, FE. \
Parker, Deputy Commissioner, as the grounds of his motion to
dismiss and answer, as guardian ad litem on behalf of the said
infant respondents.
It is further stipulated and agreed by and between the parties
hereto, by their proctors, that_ pursuant to Admiralty Rule No. 49,
the Clerk of this Court shall omit from the record on “Appe ‘al herein
the following pleadings:
1. Petition of Jessie Booker Armistead, Dorothy Marian
Armistead, George Percell Armistead II], and William
v7 Berkley Armistead for leave to intervene as parties respond-
ent, filed herein on April 10, 1940:
2. Show cause order on intervening petition, entered herein on
April 10, 1940;
3. Order allowing intervention. entered herein on May 16, 1940:
_ 4. Order appointing guardian ad litem for infant defendants,
entered herein on May 16, 1940;
5. Order extending time for filing answer by E. VY. Parker.
Deputy Commissioner, entered herein on February 28, 1940;
6. Order granting injunction pending appeal, entered herein on
July 9th, 1940;
i
he
bb E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
And that the Clerk of this Court. in lieu of the pleadings referred
to immediately above, shall include in the Record on Appeal a
copy of this stipulation.
(Syvd.) M.J. Furtos,
Proctor for Lihe lant.
Motor Boat Sales, Tne orporate df.
(Sed.) Jno. V. Cocpinr.
Axsf, $8 Ss. Atty,
Proctor for respondents,
E. V. Parker,
Deputy Commissioner.
(Sed.) K. R. Parrisn,
Proctor for nterive ning r¢ xpondents, Je xxi¢ Booker
Armistead, Dorothy Marian Armistead, George Percell
Armistead I1f, and William Berkley Armistead.
JULY Sth, 1940.
98 In United States District Court
Stipulation of proctors as to what shall constitute the record on
appeal
Filed July 10, i940
| Title of Court and stvle of case omitted.
To the Clerk of the said Court:
It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the partes
hereto, by their proctors, that the Record on Appeal herein shall
be comprised of the following:
1. Bill of Comypiaint, tiled heretn on February 9, 1940.
2. Motion to Dismiss, filed herein by E. V. Parker, Deputy
Commissioner, on March 28, 1940.
3. Order filing answer cf E. V. Parker, Deputy Commissioner,
entered herein on March 29, 1940,
4. Answer of E. V. Parker, Deputy Commissioner, filed herein
on March 29, 1940.
5. Transcript of the evidence and the record of the hearing
before E. V. Parker, Deputy Commissioner (with exhibits filed
therewith), filed herein on March 29. 1940. and marked “Fixhibit
A”; Findings of Facet and Award of E. V. Parker, Deputy Com-
missioner, filed herein on March 28, 1940, and marked “Exhibit
B.”
6. Memorandum by the Court, dated June 11, 1940.
7. Motion of plaintiff for ieave to reargue and rehear the above
cause, filed herein on June 24, 1940.
_
ft. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. 04
s. Order of Court everruling motion to reargue, entered herein
on June 24, 1940.
%. Final Decree, entered herein on June 25, 140,
10, Notice of Appeal, filed herein on July &, 1940. |
11. Petition to allow appeal: order of Court allowing appeal.
entered on July 8, 1940.
12. Libelant’s assignments of error, dated July 8, 1940.
ay 13. Citation, issued by this Court on July 9, 1940.
14. Stipulation of proctors as to the omission of certali
pleadings in the record on appeal, dated July & 1940.
15. This stipulation, filed herein on July 10, 1940.
16. Certificate of the Clerk.
(Sgd.) M. J. Furron,
Proctor for Libelant,
Motor Boat Sales, Incorporated.
(Sud.) Jno. V. Coepiii,
Asst, U.S. Atty..
Proctor for Respondent,
EF. V. Parker.
Deputy Commissioner,
(Sgd.) RR. R. Parriss.
Proctor for Intervening Respondents, Jessie Booker
whan: istoad, Dorothy Marian Arm ixtead, Ceord Pe r-
ON Armistead, HT and William Berkley Armistead.
Jciy 10, 1940.
100 [Clerk's certificate to foregoing transcript omitted) in
printing. |
101 In United States Circuit Court of Appeals
For the Fourth Circuit
No. 4695
Moror Boat Sates, INcoRPORATED, \PPELLANT
vs,
E. V. Parker. Deputy CoMMISSIONER, AND JESSIE Booker ARMI-
STEAD, ET AL.. APPELLEES
Appeal from the District Court of the Umted States for the
Eastern District of Virginia, at Richmond
Docket entries
August 16, 1940, the transcript of record is filed and the cause
docketed.
Same day, original citation ts certified up.
os BE. V. PARKER VS. “10TOR BOAT SALES, INC.
August 20, 1940, the appearance of RoR. Parrish and Thos. C.
Gordon, Jr. is entered for the appellees Jessie Booker Arniistead.
Dorothy Marian Armistead. George Pereell Armistead TTT. and
William Berkley Armistead,
Same day. the appearance of M. J. Fulton is ettered for the
appellant. \
Angust 21, 1940, the ap peariaiice of John V. Coghill, Assistant
U.S. Attorney. and H. H. Holt. Jr. Special Assistant to the U.S.
Attorney, is entered for the appellees.
September 17, 1940, brief and appendix on behalf of appellant
aie filed.
October 3, 1940. brief and appendix on behalf of appellees are
fied.
October 21, 1540, reply brief on behalf of appellants filed,
October 23, 1940, cause continued. in Open Court. to the Novem
ber termi 1940,
Jr ARGUMENT OF CAUSE
November 28, 1940 (November term. (40). cause came on to
be heard before Parker and Doine. Circuit Judges. and Chesnut.
District Judge, and was argued by counsel and submitted,
103 Tn United States Cireuit Court of Appeals, Fourth
Cirenit
No, 4693
Motor Boat Saves. [NcoRPORATED, APPELLANT
rs.
— ¥. Parke Derrty COMMISSIONER, AND JESSIE Booker
ARMISTEAD ET AL.. APPELLEES
Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the
Eastern District of Virginta, at Richinond. In Admiralty
(Argued November 23, 18400 Decided Janus, 6. 1941)
Betore Parker and Dosre, Circuit Judges, and Cagsnet. District
Jndge
M. J. Fulton, for Appellant, and Robert Ro Parrish and Harry
H. Holt, ae: Special Assistant tol Ss, Attor ey (Sterling Hauteche-
son. U.S. Attorney: John V. Cogbill, Assistant U.S. Astornes :
T. C. Gordon, Jr. ana Parrish, Butcher & Parrish. on brmef). fo
Appellees.
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. Ga
Opinion
Filed January 6, 1941
104 Donk, Circuit Judge: George Armistead, Jr. (hereinafter
called Armistead), an eniplovee of Motor Boat Sales, Incor-
porated (heremafter called the Boat Corporation), was drowned
when a motorboat in which he was riding was overturned on the
James River. Armistead’s widow and minor children filed a claim
arainst the Boat Corporation under the Longshoremen’s and Har-
bor Workers’ Compensation Act (388 U.S. Cl AL SS 901-950),
herernafter called the Act. EF. V. Parker, Deputy Commissioner
for the Fifth Compensation District of the United States Eim-
ployees’ Conipensation Commission (hereinafter called the Deputy
Commissioner), made an award in favor of the claimants and
against the Boat Corporation. Thereupon the Boat Corporation
instituted an action, under the terms of the Act, in the United
states District Court for the Eastern District of Virginia, to review,
wt aside, and enjoin the Deputy Commissioner's award. The
District Court, by 9 final decree, sustained the award of the Deputy
Commissioner and dismissed the Boat) Cerporation’s complaint.
This appeal was duly taken from that decree.
Armistead was eniployed by the Boat Corporation as a janitor,
porter, or handytan at its store, 2 3 West Grace Street, in the
City of Richmond, Virginia. His duties appear to have been of
the general character usually involved in such a job. He had no
~peclalized knowledge about boats or motors. The Boat Corpo-
ration was engaged in selling small boats, outboard motors, and
inaritime supplies needed in the types of boats *< sold. The Boat
Corporation did not service boats and did not do repair work on
boats, engines, or motors upon navigable waters. The boats it
-old were fully equipped and ready for service. Unlike the situa-
Hien as to automobiles, it was not customary for the Boat Corpo-
ration to demonstrate on navigable waters the boats that it nad
for sale: for in this type of business it seems that a boat,
1 When once phiced in the water and run, becomes, for trade
purposes, a second-hand boat. On oceasions, employees
Were sent. oin the performance of their duties, upon navigable
Waters, but these occasions were rather few and somewhat far-
etween. The testiiiony ts clear that Armistead had been repeat-
edly and specitienls cautioned and instructed that he was not to
eeton boats. ride in boats, or perform any services on navigable
Waters,
On August S. 193s. the day on which Armistead was drowned, a
Mr. Crown and his brother came by the store of the Boat Corpora.
tron with a fifteen-foot rewboat. The Crowns talked with Mr.
Hobbs and Mr. Llovd. Assistant Managers of the Boat Corpora-
al) E. V. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALEs, INC.
non, about the parchase of a second-hand outboard motor for this
boat, and two particular motors were examined by the Crowns.
with the idea that one of these might be purchased. It was de-
cided that these two motors would be sent down to the James River
to be attached to the boat and to be tested and operated. Bot)
Johnnie Cooper (hereinafter called Cooper), a mechanic’s helper
of the Boat Corporation, and Armistead went with the motors.
The testimony is not altogether clear as to Just what instructions
were given by the officers of the Boat Corporation as to Arni-
stead’s duties. It seems, though, that these instructions conten
plated that Armistead was to go along as a strong-arm man to beip
lift the motors from the car to the boat on the river and, after
the motors had been tested, to help in lifting the motors back from
the boat to the car. It would, of course, have been the mark of
wisdom for the officers of the Boat Corporation to caution Armi-
stead then and there against going out on the James River in the
bout. This was not done. These officers testified, however, that
though they said nothing on this particular oecasion about Armi-
stead going out on the river in the boat, Armistead had been pre-
viously given specific warning against going out on boats; and
that they, therefore, fully contemplated that he would not
106 go out on the river in the beat, but would stay on shore and
limit his activities solely to such efforts as were necessary to
carry the motors to and from the boat. The testimony shows that
Armistead had never before been sent by the Boat Corporation on
any Work that might take him upon navigable waters. There was
testimony that Armistead had once acted as watchman on a boat:
but thes was an undertaking completely on his own, outside of hi-
hours of work and not on behalf of the Boat Corporation.
When the party. on the day in question, reached the shore of the
James River, one of the outboard motors was, with the assistance
of Armistead, attached to the boat and a trip on the James River
Was begun. Armistead got in the boat with the others and made
this trip. No one either specifically told hime to go in the boat or
impliedly encouraged him to do so, However, it is equally «leat
that before he got in the boat, no ene told him not to get in, and
that. after he had taken his place, no one told him to get out of the
boat.
After this first trip was completed, when one of the outboard
motors had been tested on the boat, the two Crowns stated that
they had an engagement and left. Thereupon, with Armistead’>
aid, the first outboard motor was removed from the boat and the
second outboard motor was attached. Armistead again got in the
boat and the ill-fated second trip was begun. Cooper occupied the
stern of the boat, operating and navigating the boat, while Armi-
stead sat in the bow. On this second trip, again Armistead was not
\
bE. \. PARKER VS. MOTOK BOAT SALES, INC. 71
askeil to get in the boat: agai no one forbade him to get ta. and
noone later asked him to get out of the boat. Cooper testified that
le gave Armistead no instructions as to any duty that Armistead
was to perform on his ill-fated trip; but Cooper testified further
that Armistead did act as lookout on this trip. The boat struck
some obstruction, was capsized, and Armistead was drowned.
Some questions of administrative procedure under the Act
107 are involved in this appeal. We shall confine ourselves.
however, to a discussion of the single question of whether or
not Armistead’s employment brought him within the ambit of the
Act. As to that inquiry, we think that the answer must be in the
negative and that, in the light of this answer, the judgment of the
District Court must be reversed.
The federal Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers’ Act of 1927
was enacted, with the New York State Compensation Act as a
model, to set up a compensation scheme for injury or death on
navigable waters, provided that ne recovery could be had under
state laws, by reason of the maritime character of the employment
of the person who was killed or injured. The history of the Act
ys outlined by Chief Justice Hughes in Nogueira v. N. Y. ete. Ry.
Vo, 281 U.S. at p. 136,508. Ct. at p. 375: while many of its pro-
visions are sketched by the Chief Justice in the leading case of
Crowell v, Benson, 285 U. S. 22, 52 S. Ct. 285. The Act is ad-
mirably discussed, with ample citation of authorities, in Robinson
on Admiralty, pages 109-133. As we interpret the Act. it was
designed to cover a gap between the rea il seamen and sailors—
“seafaring men with sad, sea-weary eyes”—on the one hand, and
the landInbbers, whose labors never took them upon the bounding
deep, on the other ‘and. Between these two classes was a large
group of laborers whose tasks have been called amphibious—a part
of their work was on the land, another part was on navigable
waters. These were the longshoreme n and harbor workers. For
them a federal compensation act seemed fair; so C ongress enacted
ihis statute.
The Act applies “only if the disability or death results from an
jury occurring upon the nay igable waters of the United States”
(Act, Section 2 (a)). There seems to be no question that this
requisite was completely fulfilled in the instant case. Clearly. too,
the employer-employee relation, another requisite of liability,
existed between Armistead and the Boat Corporation at the time
of Armistead’s death.
10s This same section of the Act also permits recovery under
the Act “if recovery for the disability or death through
workmen's compensation proceedings may not validly be provided
by State law.” And under Section 2 (4), we find: “The term
‘emplover” means an employer, any of whose employees are em-
72 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC
ployed in maritime ensployment, in whole or in part, upon naviga-
ble waters of the United Siates.” Sections 2 and 3 of the Act are
the nub of this case. “Maritime employment” under the Act ex-
cludes matters that are purely “local.” Thus, in 2 Corp. Jur. See.
at p. 132, we find:
“Under the Federal Compensation Act, providing that compen-
sation shall be payable only if recovery may not validly be pro-
vided by state law, an injury received in an employ ment. although
maritime, pertaiming to local matters, and having only an inci-
dental relation to navigation and conimerce, is subject to ‘the appli-
cation of the local vompensation act and without the scope of the
federal act.”
Tt is not necessary here for us to discuss in detail the well-known
hair-line that divides the federal admiralty jurisdiction, on the one
hand, from the purely local jurisdiction of the states, on the other
hand. Landmarks in this field are Southern Pacific v. Jensen, 244
U.S. 205, 37S. Ct. 524; Cathelentis v. Luchenbach Steamship Co.,
247 U.S. 372, 38 S. Ct. 501; Knickerbocker Ice Co. v. Stewart,
253 U.S. 149, 40S, Ct. 438; Grant Smith-Porter Ship Co, v. Rohde,
257 U.S. 469, 42 S. “ Ay 157; Great Lakes Dredge and Dock Co. v.
Kierejewski, 261 U. S. 479, 43S. Ct. 418. We are here concerned
with the difficult problem of a specitic statutory application of the
general rule. Was Armistead engaged in maritime employment
at the time of his death so that a recovery may be had under the
Act? Or was his employment “not so directly connected with
navigation and commerce that to permit the rights of the
109 parties to be controlled by the local law would interfere with
the essential uniformity of the general maritime law”? (2
Corp. Jur. See. 131).
We are forced to the conclusion that Armistead’s employment
at the time of his death was strictly local and thus was without
the scope of the Act. Though it is by no means conclusive, we
think the title of he Act (Longshoremen’s and Harbor Workers
Act) is very informative on our problem. Here is a jamitor im a
city store, who has been forbidden to go out on boats in navigable
waters. To call him a harbor worker or a longshoreman would
seem to be a misnomer. When he was sent by his employer on
the day of his death to the shore of the James River, this, as fer
as the record discloses, was the only instance when his dutiegever
brought him into contact with navigable waters.
Counsel for Armistead laid great stress on the fact that Arm
stead was a colored man, sent to help a white man; that when
Armistead took his place in the boat on the first trip, without any
objection from Cooper, and when be again, without objection from
Cooper. took his place in the boat for the tragic second trip, this
extended the scope of his employment: and that, as a_ result.
E. V. PARKER Vs. MOTOR BOAT SALES, ENC. 73
Armistead, during the second trip, was actually engaged in mari
time employment, as that term is used in the Act. In other con.
vections, and for other purposes, there may well be real force in
this argument. Yet, when it is remembered that Armistead had
been expressly forbidden by his employers to go on navigable
waters in boats, we do not think that Cooper’s passive acquiescence
if such it be) has sufficient legal force to bring the death of
Armistead under the beneficent terms and scope of the Act. His
activities, we believe, were still local, and the control of these
activities by state law works no material prejudice to the general
maritime Jaw which, in turn, is enforced as a matter of federal
concern by the federal courts. We think “the employment
* * * pertains to le al matters, having only an inci-
110s dental relation to navigation and commerce.” Associate
Justice VanDevanter, in Suiran Ry. & Timber Co. vy. De-
partment of Labor, ete.. ’77 U.S. 135,48 S. Ct. 505.
It should be noted here that compensaticn is payable under
tthe Act if, for the injury or death, a recovery “may not validly
'e provided by State law,” (Act, Section 3 (a)). It is not neces-
ary for the exclusion of the operation of the federa! Act that 2
neovery should be actually available under a state compensation
act. This is clearly brought out by the opiniyn of Circuit Judge
Soper in U.S. Casualty Co. v. Taylor, 64 F. @d) 521, certiorari
dene’, 290 0. S. 689. 54S. Ct. 56. The BoatCorporation in our
case was not subject to the Virginia Workmen’s Compensation
Act, because it did not emp'oy the minimum: number of employee-
to bring it uniler the Virginia statute: but we think that Armi-
tead’s employment was so local in character that had the Boat
Corporation employed the required number of employees, an
wtion could have been brought under the state staCute, and that is
determinative. If the state statute can apply. the federal statute
cannot,
The cases under the Act defining its scope and application are
‘erally legion. Many of these cases will be found in the state
varta, when an attempt was made te bring the injury or death
"thin the provisions of the compensation act of the state in
question. These cases, of course, are not al] consistent. We think,
however, that the cases have worked out a fairly well-defined
‘heory and philosophy of the Act: and. further, we believe, that
under this theory and philosophy of the Act, our decision fits
vith the holdings in the great majority of these cases. These
“aes do not prick out a clear and clean-cut line of demarcation
‘tween maritime employment and employment that is purely
veal; yet the cases do furnish valuable guides in a field in which
‘e must proceed largely upon intuitions grounded in experience.
We shall now proceed to discuss some of the more impertant of
‘
74 E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC.
these cases. It is manifestly impracticable even to cite all of
them.
111 First, we shall consider the cases in which the employ.
ment was held to be maritime, not local. One of the bes
considered opinions in all the books, fortified by an ample citation
and discussion of the authorities, is St. John v. Thomson, 108 Vt.
66, 182 A. 196, and note in (1936) 22 Va. Law Rey. 822. St. Johr
was employed to go with his employers to a summer resort on
Lake Champlain, where he was to work on land, and was also te
do what was requ'red of him with regard to a motorboat that was
to be operated on Lake Champlain. The motorboat became dis-
abled on Lake Champlain and a rowboat was procured and moored
to the motorboat. In some way, this mooring was unloosened
and the rewboat drifted away from the motorboat. St. Jorn dove
overboard, in an attempt to retrieve the rowboat, and was drowned.
The Vermont court held that St. John’s employment was mari
time and that he could not recover under the Vermont Workmen’
Compensation Act. It was expressly stated in this case that
since the accident happened on navigable waters, the mere fact
that the major portion of St. John’s employnient was upon land
was unimportant; but this was only following Northern Coal é
Dock Co, v. Strand, 278 U.S. 142. 49'S. Ct. 88. This leading cas.
we think, can easily be distinguished from our case. An apprec
able part of St. John’s employment must necessarily have bee!
on navigable waters in the motorboat. In the insiant case, how
ever, Armistead was hired as a janitor and cautioned never to
on navigable waters.
The employment was held to be maritime in Mangieri ©
Stephens, 232 N. Y. 596, 134 NE. 586, where the employee was
laborer for a wholesale coal dealer and he slipped and fell inte
the water while he was pulling a coxl boat to the dock. The same
resuit was reached in Doey v. Clarence P. Howland Co., 224 N.¥
30,120 N. E. 53. when a carpenter was hurt while making repair
on a steamship: and in Keator v. Rock Plaster Mfg. Co. 24
N. Y. 540, 120 N. E. 56, certiorari denied, 248 U. 8. 544.
112.) when an employee was injured while unloading rock from
vessel. There were like holdings in Wheeler Shipyard
v. Lowe, 13 F. Supp. 863. where an employee, a painter and utili
man in a shipyard company, was drowned while delivering 3
motorboat to a customer: in Buren v. Southern Pacifie Co.. 50 F
(2d) 407. when a brakeman was injured while unloosing brake
upon a train which was being ferried across navigable water
and, also, in Wood Towing Co. v. Parker, 76 F. (2d) 770, whei
the employee, a carpenter and general utility man for a compat)
which operated tugs and barges, was injured while installing ®
engine on a moterboat purchased by the employer. Even rena!
E. V. PARKER VS. MOTOR BOAT SALES, INC. To
ng a completed vessel upon navigable waters has been held to be
naritime. Robins Dry Dock Co. v. Dahl. 266 U.S. 449. 45 8. Ct.
37; John Baizley Iron Works v. Span, 281 U.S. 222, 50.8. Ct.
06.
In Independence Indemnity Co. v. Mansfield, 2.8. W. (2d) 547
Tex. Civ. App. 1928). the employee was cleaning oil tanks on a
vessel and this was held to be maritime, even Chough the general
employment of the employee was nonmaritime. A similar result
was reached in U.S. Fidelity and Guaranty Co. v. Lawson, 15
F.Supp. 116. when the employee, a carpenter employed by an oil
ompany for such work as he might be called on to do. was in-
ured while he was enlarging the cabin of the private yacht of
the president of the company that employed him.
Two other interesting border-line cases. in which the empioy-
ment vas held to be maritime, are worthy of note. In Norton v.
Galt Refining Co., 94 F. (2d) 380, the employee was an oil gauger
who had entered on a barge to take samples of her oi] cargo. In
Moore Ry. Co. v. Pillsbury, 100 F. (2d) 245, the employee was a
ngger who ate and slept at home but worked on a launch on
thich he lost nis life.
Now for the cases in which the employment was held to be
18 local rather than maritime. Fairly close to the instant case
is Johnson v. Swonder, 84 Ind. Avp. 155, 150 N. FE. 615, in
¥hich Chief Justice Nichols said:
“Appellant’s decedent had been employed for years by appellee
#ahelper around a mattress and upholstering manufactory, and
nedental to that employment he was sent on the day of the acei-
dent to assist in upholstering on a small speed boat used for ap-
jellee’s business during the week and on Sundays for pleas-
ue. It is well established that generally federal courts have
‘tclusive jurisdiction of admiralty matters, but where, as here,
the enforcement of the state statute works no material prejudice
‘o the characteristic features of the general maritime law, nor
Merferes with the proper harmony or uniformity of that law in
‘8 international or interstate relations, the general rule does not
apply.”
Equally illuminating is Madderns v. Fox Film Corp., 200 N. Y. S.
“4, in which a moving-picture actor, while enacting a scene on
‘boat in navigable waters, tripped and fell into the water. This
¥as held to be local, and the Court said:
“His work on the boat was merely incidental to his general
duties as an actor, and had nothing to do with the boat, save to use
tas a background for a moving picture, which, except for this
umple incident, was produced upon the land.”
The employment was held to be merely local in Travelers’ Insur-
‘we Co. y. Bacon, 30 Ga. App. 728, 119 S. E. 458, where an em-
76 E. VY. PARKER VS. MOTOR 80AT SALES, INC.
ployee was to fish in the employer's boat in navigable waters, bu:
always in sight of land, his compensation to be deterniined by th:
size of his catch, and he was drowned when he jumped into the
water, after an explosion on the boat set fire to his clothes; aly
in United Dredging Co. v. Industrial Commission, 92 Cal. App
110, 267 P. 763, where a man, employed as a helper and all-around
nan ou a dredge, was drowned while operating a rowboat usec
to carry men from the dredge to the shore.
114 Another leading case is In re Herbert, 283 Mass. 34.
186 N. E. 554, and see notes on this case in 4 Detroit Las
Rev. 36 and 38 Monthly Labor Rev. 99. Herbert worked on «
scow used to ferry garbage to an island about two miles away 1.
Boston Harbor. His job was to sweep the scow after it had bee:
unloaded. He was engaged in this work while the scow was tie:
up at the island when he fell overboard. Said Chief Justic
Rugg:
“It seems to us difficult to conceive of anything more local #
its general nature. * * * It does not appear that the decease
had anything directly connected with maritime affairs * * *°
The Supreme Court of Washington has held in two interesting
ca
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.