Brief for Link Belt Company — National Labor Relations Board v. Link-Belt Co.
Supreme Court brief1940
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
. e
. « "es + td *
ie oe
. .
‘
e .
ey. ’
.
e -
.
.
- .
- '
.
.
e .
. .
’ ~ .
?
. ~e
‘
. os
‘ ,
bd .
.
4
e .
. .
e
oe
.
. . >
‘'
° ’
‘
- :
e 4
v
©
‘
” . ‘
ni ” ° -
.
.
.
. ° s ‘
‘
- ,
‘
-
‘
.
2
-
. - *
. td
’
4 .
‘*
é .
P .
Te. - | pee
; DEC 12 1910. [oR Lt |
CLERK
o.* ae CHARL ES ELMORE -CROPLEY
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United Stated | 4
- Ocrosze Tznm, 1940. : ane ety | oo Reed
No. 235 -
"NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD, | :
a. | | ne, os oo
ng ao foe _ vs. * See ke ri os
LINK-BELT COMPANY. ate i
ON, WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED, STATES CIRCUIT aga “tS whee aw
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT. * :
er a ‘ | : oF : : ; : re 3
"BRIEF FOR LINK-BELT COMPANY. 89 «+ — re | yk ae
; t $ pe
. é . . %
. e oe °
ae Ace . ef a , j
ete
*e &%
Henry E. Sryrarra,
Owen F'arpwEaTHER, ? —
. Attorneys for Link-Beit Company, s
t ‘120 South La Salle Street,
: i Ses Chicago, Illinois. ©
“oe
‘ TABLE OF CONTENTS.
———
4
Opinions below cedeaoecesal Orr , eakagt ieeeves Poe
Jurisdiction ...::......... PEER RENN RINSE ~
7
Statement... ieee Prete igs Se lladeiessbe ucts ae
Argument: | St ‘ |
me There is no substantial evidence upon ‘which
to base a finding of. domination............ “12
-&. There is no édvidence that the employees
Sei had @ settled cofiviction that ‘the com- \,
- pany. preferred a particular type of la-
hor organization ; and the Act does’ not
- require the company: to issue 8 public.
. és
, » > statement of neutrality ..... ete erie Sa
+ B.-- Employees «were not subjuga or in-
| C. The? Jones &. Laughlin degision ended ..
‘ . °° the Plan-in “the minds. of. the. ampenyens 15..
dD. The: Independent was .a€ new “ organiza-’ -
fluenced under the. BM triste ar tvoss« 14° :
tion havifig no connection with the Plan 17 ae
Eh. The leadership of the e Independent was,
F. find company properly recognized the
d
ependent ‘upon proof of its majority 20
ae the Amalgamated and the Inde-
. pendent solicited and-collected dues on . .
company time but without the knowledge
or permission of the. ‘COMPANY. «+++. 24
free “ 5 Fy é Kile”
Gifforent 2... ceciccseecseceseccosece 18
Be ‘The isolated instances of f activity by su-_
pervisory employees does ‘not show con-
trol of the Independent by the company
The nature and results of’the collective
bargaining demonstrate that the com- -
-pany exercised no control over the Inde-
pendent ...... eeereede Loa ee he wwk das
_ The court, below adopted a. proper inter- |
pretation of the word ‘‘dominate’’ in
deciding that the evidence did not war-
rant a finding of domination and order
of disestablishment .... Rocccecececesas
- The order must conform to the purposes
of the. Act and the standards laid down
by Congress terete 16 pendacesdsss
Karbel was etl discharged for in-
efficiency. Moreover there is positive
evidence that the company had no knowl-
_. edge of his membership in the Amalga-
SUL 0 GR 6 a AR bm Vk 00 ba k'ek béecldlc ce
Cumorich was properly discharged for
‘inefficiency. Moreover there is ‘positive
evidence that the company had no knowl- |
edge of his membership in the Ausalga- :
_ Saree evevsetipeveie bgusieeveds
Kalamarie was properly laid off for lack
. of work. Moreover no one took his job
F.
Conclusion
gaging in extraneous activities on com-
pany time thereby causing inefficiency
and disorganization val the company’s
personnel ehenby kee uee¥ bedneseneverses
The finding of the, Board that the aie
Peter Solinko’s joining the Independent
. has no basis in the FOCOFG. .....2; weeee
There is no substantial evidence of
espionage (oo be eed deroceececoresoses °
eevee e eee eee eee ee et eee eeseee tees eet sieeee
Appendix I—National Labor Relations Act. eeseecce
Appendix II—Extracts from Debates” in ‘the Senate :
and House. of Representatives and
Committee Reports therein relative to
the application of the N ational Labor
3 a Relations Act to Company Unions. .
¥
Salmons was properly discharged for en-
>of Frank Solinko was conditioned on
69
71
aereNrenes=crcenry
te SE Se at
— iit
3° i}
ity 4
| | ‘Appalachian Elec.. Power. Co. v. N. GL. R. B., 98 F,
| on (2d) 985 (C. C. ie) eee ae
} Atchison By. Go. v. U. 8, 295 U. 8. 198............ 29
. : Gah. ' _ Ballston-Stillwater Knitting Co. v. N. L: B. B., 98 F.
: ees |) ae _ (2d) 758 (C. eta MN hcwesin $eendacbarness¥ cits 25, 46
Consolidated Edison Cv. v. N. L. RB. B., 305 U. 8. 197 41
Cupples Co. Manufacturers v..N. L. RB. B., 106 F. (2d)
FU Ae ee Eee sedatechennnees scene 25
Federal Communications Commission v.: Pottsville ~
_* Broadcasting Company, 309 U. 8. 134...... eonane’ 38
i ‘Federal Radio Commission v. Nelson Bros Co., 289
Ae tS gle CR NE a uae eas poe ebb neee Nhs Rewer hscense 38
ia Federal Trade Commisic Vv. Book Hut Co., 257 U.S
1 | GE Sie bciekepeteesenseedecevenssscetereccevecds 36
> anal _ Federal Trade Commission v. Curtis Co., 260 U. 8. :
—- 9aa- "i enn coher FHS Sor ele EE he Se OE Bo 34
i ~ Federal Trade.Commission v. Gratz, 253 U. 8. 421. .36, 41
| ii 3 Federal Trade Commission v. Raladam, 283:U. S.
THe oe 643 Pemedaesi ce ecedsidneuncerdes pec ececcescccees 33, 34 '.
i) Florida v. U. S., 282 ye ay ee ieee 29
1h) | _. Helvering v. Tex-Penn Company, 300 cm See 36
Me Humble Oil & Refining Co..v. N.L. BB, 113 F. (2d)
‘ i - MM EBD ve inniortecosveune | Re IE SNR 37
. al res ‘International Association of Machinists v. N. L. R. B:,
i} 110 F. (2d) 29.(App. D. C.) affirmed by Supreme
| Court, November 12, 1940 .....icccccccccsccees . -20, 31
HL NLRB. v.A-8, Abel Gs, $7. (2) 961 (0. CA i
aha e EEE. Re RO RY eee eer rere Pree oe peer )
my eit a
fie IC RER ie ee ij, .. - N. LB, B. v. American Mfg. Co., 106 F. (2d) 61 (C.
Pas a.) i oalea warmer eubetan ravarveneviveees 20, 31
ee IRR NON ER AIR 26, 30. y.
NLL BB. v. Empire Furnitare Cote. 107 F. (2d)
i le is AEP a hve wes Cost had sdb de Usb Mecente 50
N. L. RB. B. v. Falk Corporation, 102 F. (2a) 388. |
Oh obi. ds adicphnencel coverings 20
N.L. R. B. v.-Fansteel Metallurgical Corp., 306 U, S. . seer
N.L. BB. v. Jones & Laughlin Stel Corp, 801 U. 8. oe
stabs che Oe dds cube dene Weddedéncduueas 6, 15, 21, 24, 57
N.L. BB. Vv. Lund, 103 F. (2d) 815 (C. C. A. 8)..... 20
'N. L. RB. B. v. Newport News Shipbuilding & Dry © , ne
‘Dock .Co., 308 U, 8. 241.........cccccccecceccees 36, 41 ~ °
N. L. R. B. v. Pacific Greyhound Lines, Ine.,.303 U. 8. ‘es
BED cavavetcverccccescvescsstccesesgzoce Duis 30, 41 :
‘N. L. B. B. v. Pennsylvania Greyhound Lifes, Inc,, ie: ie
- 303 U..S. 261 ett eeceeeeeereccencees based eeeees 30, 40
aN. L. B. B. v. Swift & Company, decided Nov. mo
MND 1O. O. BG). seen ni seceses. PEE a ree 22; 23
N. Ll. RB. B. v. Thompson Products, Inc., 97 F; (2d) 13 —
BE ig iionck dooce cans can dave bovenees iis 49
N. L..R. B. v. Union Pacific Stages, Ine.,. 99 F, (24)
153 (CO. A. OF iicick. GES beste bawesiede ws cous 49 _
N. L. B. B. v. Sands Mfg. Co., 306 U. § 382........ 82 + 0”
Pennsylvania R. BR. Co. v. Chamberlain, 288 U. 8. 333’ 15 +
System Federation No. 40. v. Virginian Railway Co, .
il F. Sapp. 621 (D. 0., B. D. Va.) ..ccicschecees 22
In the Matter of Skinner & Kennedy. Stationery Co.; * |
BE Be BD, Be TE sinc seceigcoessceuvecinnss 35
Texas & N. O. R. Co. v. Ry. Clerks, 281 U. 8. 548... aes i
Texas & Pacific Railway v. Interstate Commerce Com. aes e
mission, 162 U. Ss. IM. ssictfersurensesvesersesons ; oe
poms : ‘ ais
ie
F
} i 3 -
eee
Sah :
; te
} ae
-- Webster’s New International Dictionary ...... pine ae
- Wilson ‘& Co., Inc. v. N. L. B. B,, 108 F. (24), 243
CR i'd ovedavebndodetecacdveltesvhesaeseai 49
Westinghouse Electric & Mfg. Co. v. N. L. B. B, 112
F. (2d) 657: (C. C. A. 2), cert. granted No. 447, ‘Oct.
Term, 1940 bisiaduwecdbasedds wedvetiecscedtnces 22
SraTures.
; N ational Labor Relations Act (49 Stat. 449; 29 U.S..
ie ii WO BED Aacinsss Locceedevedseeererteoses 69
Railway Labor Act (44 Stat. 577; 45 U. S. C. A.,
_MiscELLANeous.
_’ Congressional Record, Vol. 79, 74th Cong., 1st. Sess. .37, 43
Report of Senate Committee on Education and Labor
May 26, 1934, Senate Report ‘No. 1184, 14a. Cong.,
gg SE RRC ae eR SEE 5 NETS EE Sih PRES See 33
Report of Senate “Committee on Bancation and Labor,
May 2, 1939, Senate mrpest No. 573, 74th Cong.,
PY. i ch cs ch nd abe ade 46a cee tess ones 33, 36, 38, 39 _
2
wre Court of the United States
OcroszR Trem, 1940. |
*. No. 235.
NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD,
| 3 Petitioner,
3 Beek ee Ba
LINK-BELT COMPANY.
BRIEF FOR THE LINK-BELT COMPANY.
ya)
‘
Opinions Below.
Reported in 110 F. (2d}
are the opinions of Judge.
Kerner with Judge Major and Judge Treanor
dissenting i in part. The majo holds infer alia that there
is no substantial evidence to disestablish the Independent
Union of Craftsmen (hereinafter called the ‘‘Independent’’)
or to reinstate with back pay, Kalamarie, Karbel and
_ Cumorich. The dissent agrees that there is no substantial
‘ evidence to disestablish the Independent, but would in-
erease the scope of the 8(1) order and would reinstate with
back pay Karbel and Cumorich.
The decision and order of the ca saaeh is reported i in 12
N. L R: B. 854. . a
Jurisdiction.
The decree of the Circuit Court. of Appeals was olka )
-April 13, 1940 (R. 1581-1582). The petition for certiorari _
_ Was filed on July 12, 1940, and was granted on Octobergi4,
. ene
Sse ONE RE laN a ORS CAS RS ORAS Ny MERA IONE ’
4 4 ear aro awe
ae ie aN ee ae ona a a Ces 2 SEE
nti Se - —— = : :
othe
(RB 125). He told them
aa i940. This Court’s jurisdiction. is. ‘Senda upon section
me 240(a) of the Judicial Code as amended by the Act of Feb.
_. Tuary 13, 1925,.and upon sections 10(e) and es of the boc
buses Labor Relations Act. ° ' -
jel rs)
Statute Involved. —
+ Applicable provisions ‘of the National Labor Relations
Act’are set forth in the appendix. :
Statement.“ /
Link-Belt Company, ‘an Illinois corporation, Ons and
; operates seven plants. Tfe 39th Street Plant, in Chicago,
_ Tiinois, which employs between 750 and -1,200 employees,
is ihvolved here: It engages in complete ‘steel and iron
' foundry operations, in ‘the production of cranes, shovels,
draglines, mining conveyors, dumps, .washers, driers al”
miscellaneous ous other steel construction.
oe On. April 19, 1937, Berry, the assistant seen manager
in charge of the Company’ s 39th: Street Plant, was visited by
_ three representatives of the Independent who announced
that they were the executive officers of the Independent
hes which Tepresented a group of employees at the plant and
that they wanted the Company to recognize that organiza-
. tion as the sole cellective: bargaining : agency (R. 1143-1144).
Berry called for proof of. majority, whereupon they sub-
mitted their membership tecords containing signatures (In-
tervenor’s Exhibit 2, R. 1420, 1144-1145). Berry told them
that he would have to check the names. because he could not
take their word for it and it would probably take ‘some time
and that they could either wait in his office or go’ b&ck to
their jobs (R. 1145). They preferred to. wait, so Berry
chrefully checked the nanies with his. payroll list (R. 1145-
1146, 725). The records contained pproximately 760 names
out of 1,000 éligible employees on the payroll at this time
tat did not have authority to -
ee
?
recognize the Tlpentinak and he would have to take up |
matter with the executive officers of the Company and that. } +
“he would like to have time to consult them. Thereafter eles renee
talkéd about this demand with his superiors, Carter and
Burnell, vice presidents, and Kauffmann, president of the ©
Company. These officers of. the Company obtained legal —Ss—_.
advice (R. 1146). By letter dated April 21, 1937, Berry re-
"ceived authorization from Kauffmann to enter into a rec-
ognition agreement with the Independent (Respondent’s .
Exhibit 28, R. 1413). Berry signed the recognition agree-
_ment which had been presented to him by the representa-. —S—- ;
‘ tives of the Independent (Intervenor’s Exhibit 1, R. 1147, i a
1148, 1420). -At this time the Amalgamated had net made:
. .a demand for recognition | (R. 163, 146). ;
_- On May 7; 1937, the Company received a: written request ..
. from the Independent for a date to begin negotiations with, ~- —.
the Company (R. 1149, 1150, 1414), Thereafter many collee = ~— By
LQ tive bargaining conferences were held by representatives of q “
’ the Independent and representatives of the Company. The *
executive officers of the Company were present at some a
of the meetings. For the most part negotiations on. behalf. :
of the Company were handled by Berry (R. 1150).°- eats 7]
. The testimony with reference to collective bargaining be- ..
tween the Company and the union is uncontroverted. It
demonstrates that the Company met with the union on May
4, 1937, with respect to an increase in wages to the hourly ©
paid employees (RB: 740). On May 11th the union demanded
a l0 per cent increase in wages, and. Berry stated that the
Company was unable to meet the union’s demand (RB. 741) ;
whereupon the: Independent met with Kauffmann, the presi-
dent of the Company, on May 19th, at the downtown office |
‘and further pressed its demand for a wage increase. Kauiff- wren
mann explained that: the Company. ‘had granted the em-
‘ployees a 6 per cent increase on November 2, 1936, and a , s
10 ge cent increase on ‘May 15, 1936. shescsad the Coni- Sta. z=
NS Be tks poe Hee | ae
e . , pany agreed*to a 5' per cent increase on. all honrly\zates to
_ *... be effective June 1, 1937: (R. 741). On May 21, the Compony
ie || i, po _ -was handed.a draft of a contract on wages, hours and work-
tii /* ing conditioris and on the days following there were nego-
i ; tiations on the térms of a contract (R. 741-742, 1457). On
i, _ Jane 1, 1937, the union demended certain changes ‘in the
1 te seniority policy, and thereafter the representatives of the
- Independent conferred with Kauffmann, Carter and Burnell
on’ this question (R. 742, 743). The company refused
' te sign a contract at that time pending further negotia-
_ tions and the Company agreed to be bound orally by the.
a - terms that had been- negotiated (RR. 743, 1460). On August ©
| _. 18th, the Independent demanded a bonus payment for night
workers. The Company finally agreed to a 5 per cent bonus.
for night workers (R. 744). On-September 17th, the Inde-.
pendent demanded a better vacation policy (R. 744). On
October 2nd, the Independent demanded a closed shop (R. _
744)... On. October 8th, the Independent bronght—up the-
subject of layoffs and seniority (R. 744-5). On October
22nd, the Independent met with Kauffmann concerning a
aE _ closed shop (R. 745): On November 2nd, the Independent
mi ". | again met pith Berry and demanded a closed shop; Berry
1 Wi. . refused to grant it (R. 745). On November 9th, the Tnde-
qe fi, ©. pendent met with Berry on the question of vacations for
ania 1938. On November 15th, the Independent met with Berry
ed , regarding the issuance by the Company of a statement of |
: policy embodying the te¥his which had been agreed upon. .
(Intervenor’s Exhibit 9, R. 745, 1460).- On December 3rd,
' the Independent met with the Cement regarding vacations _
(RB. 745). On Decembef 6th, there was another meeting —
about vacations and the issuance of a statement of policy
‘na (R.,745, 1464). On February 15; 1938, the Independent met
: i , with the Company régarding vacation pay for men bed :
; t
had been laid off during 1937. A further conference on
subject was held on February. 21st, and an agreement was.
finally spnched that a who were laid off in 1937
ba ., .
‘
ee |
Ww ‘ oi
. ‘ . a
o eatery = |
| 3 6 i : > yi. ;
would be paid the sum i which they were entitled in lieu *™ |
_7 of a- vacation (Intervenor’ s Exhibit 11, R. 746, 1467). On hs a .
_ March 3rd, the Independent and the Company met and dis-.
> eussed the layoff of-members of the Independent (R. 746).
'. Matters such as better lighting, better air conditions, and
safety were, the subjects of collective bargaining (R..747), ean
In addition to the subjects covered by the above evidenceof -. a:
collective bargaining, individual grievances were presented oS
: by, various shop. stewards to the foremen and heads. of
departments (R. 747).
For many years Berry had held daily meetings with the
- Supervisory force. The discussions of the group in 1936. 7
turned, to labor problems. D the course of the meet- eats ia
ings - _Berty instructed the sugervisory staff to refrain 7
from engaging, in union activities and, to‘ refuse to give ~
- employees advice on whether they should join a union or
what union they should join (RB. 1153, 1154). hese in- |
structions: were passed on to a ee pid the ws su-
pervisory staff (R. 931). : ‘
The evidence shows. beyond any question that the com- oe
_ peting unions, that is the Amalgamated and the Indepen-
dent, engaged in union activities to a certain degree on
company time and that the matter of keeping the men at
work, avoiding their congregating, talking about unions,
and distributing literature daring wor hours, was a
\ ‘serious problem (R. 901). ae
The record is full of instances of warnings given Sea |
members of: both the Amalgamated and the Independent 22)
(R. 800, 816, 317, 325). In September, 1936, Salmons (a .-
member of the Amalgamated) and Novak’ were discharged ; |
for repeatedly engaging in union activity on Company
time. The management believed they were spending more me Me
of their time organizing than working (R. 1122-1123, 1132). -» . -
_. Salmons admitted” union activity on Company time, buat =§=§8 ~~ a7
‘thought he had the right to do sq under thé Act (R.169, 7 «© g, .
1122, 1132). Salmons was rehired on December:21, 1936, / © 9,
yv - Bs 9 .
ee
aa
after mediation by’ agents of the Board secianed to the
Thirteenth Region (R. 1136-1137). Novak was rehired in
qWanuary, 1937, not. as a result of mediation, but because
Berry believed that Novak’s violations were ‘of the same
_ nature as Salmons’ and after taking back Salmons he
should in justice take. back Novak (R. 1187). fated
e Board has deemed pertinent the following evidence :
. which it contends shows, domination and interference.
After 1983 the. employees bargained with the Company —
‘through the medium of a plan of representation known as _
Link-Belt Employees . Board (heteinafter referred to as
‘ the ‘‘Plan’’). The Plan was abandoned upon the decision
in the Jomes & ‘Laughlin case, handed down April 12,”
“1987 (N. L. BR. B. v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp., 301 -
U. 8. 1). A, written memorandum to dissolve the Plan
was, signed on April 19, 1937 (R. 823), and the Board finds .
that the recognition of the Independent on April 21, 1937,
substantiates the inference that the Independent was an .
outgrowth of the Plan. This alleged carry-over, in the |
view of the Board’is further supported’ by testimony that
some of. the members of the organizing committee of. thie
Independent. were Plan representatives and that the or- |
ganizers of the Independent were hostile to outside labor
. organizations. ——S
The evidencea’ clear that the Company did not ‘dane
“the Plan. -There were no substandard labor conditions
at the plant. The evidence further shows that ‘only three
out of the seven original organizers, of the Independent
were Plan represehtatives, but the founder and the leader -
of the Independent, Linde, was not a Plan representative
- (RB. 713, 720, 762). On the other hand, Salmons, the leader
8 the Amalgamated, and Lackhouse, an organizer of the —
| Amalgamated, were Plan representatives (R. 182, 305).
The evidence shows hgétility on the part of the organi- —
zers of the —— to the Amalgamated, but it does
- not show that the organizers of the Independent were Op-
posed to collective bargaining because the proof of col-
‘lective bargaining by the Independent is overwhelming.
he Board introduced evidence showing that Independ-
ent lists were hectographed on the Company’s machine,
and that bulletin boards of the Independent were made by «
the Company. There was no denial of these'facts by the 2 ——
Company, ‘but evidence’ was introduced, and stands un- «. ~
: eontroverted, that the lists were, hectographed without the
knowledge or_consent of the Company. by one Elsen who
stayed after working hours (R. 1041, 1042) and that the
pilietin boards were bought and paid for by one Kovatch
(B. 863, 1393).. The Board introduced evidence showing. —
that certain supervisory officials conversed with émployees: .
' about the, Independent and orie foreman assisted several. /
~ employees to sign’: an Independent petition, . In(genera! /
there was ‘a weg Bs activities on the part of the ©
foremen involved. Belov,. one of those whom the Board
found engaged im union activities, was not’in a -super-
visory. capacity; he was a mere. workman and was 80
designated ,by the Company’s records (R. 1070, 1079, - .
Ee as eons ae | eo,
_. There is no evidence of any financial aid or assistance lt a
to the Independent at any timé. ; 7 ee ;
—‘The Company ‘had no voice in the affairs of the Inde- |
pendent and exercised no control whatsoever in ‘its ad-
' ministration. The Independent did not meet on company
_ property. The Company did not permit the Independent - ee
to collect dues on Company ‘time. -Its sole contact with eo Biel
the Independent was in bargaining on rates of pay, houts 3 a
of work and other conditions of employment in addition to.
grievances. — : he | Ee Reet
The Company was forced to reduce the number of its — os
employees in Octobér, 1937, due to a sharp decrease in .
_ business. Over 100 ‘men in the foundry alone were laid
set : / : \
. ay
‘off. (R. 1191). tla an iailiee: in 1 the fondiieg
was laid off in accordance with the seniority. policy. of the»
Company. The Board introduced evidence showing that .
he was estoy in the Amalgamated and should have been
given the” in the foundry which he formerly held.
The Company ed out that in conformity with its s
_ oceupatio: niority | policy Kalamarie was. laid ‘off ac.
: cording to his length of service.as an arc welder, and
moreover, that. _— as laid off for lack of work, ‘9 ‘gad that
no one took his job (R. 1374, 958-961).
Karbel. and Cumorich were discharged on May 19, 1937,
» for inefficiency which was clearly observed by their sn-.
_ perior and corroborated by time studies. Tke Board:
claimed they. were laid off.for membership i in the Amalga- .
mated, but proof that the Company knew of their member-.
ship’ in the Amalgamated is’ entirely lacking. Both tes-
tified that they occupied no office in the Amalgamated —
and that neither” wore an. Amalgamated button ( R. 408, '
| 5, 568). :
: Evidence. was pear showing that the Company
belonged to the National Metal Trades. Association ; that °
_ the Association possessed an anti-union poliev ; cel that .
Cousland, an experienced lathe operator and one of the
. Company’ s old workmen, sent reports to the Association
. which were forwarded to the Company. He ‘was paid an
_ average’ of $9 per month ‘for’ the reports by the Associa-
tion which in turn billed the seeps (R. 582, om: 133,
599).
. There is uncontroverted deities that the reports i in:
‘ question had been furnished by Cousland’for over 18 years ~
oe and referred solely to piece work dissatisfaction, tooling
_and production methods and safety hazards. All witnesses.
80. testified. Cousland’ 8 reports ceased in October, 1936,-
Aint long before any organization “activities began at the 39th
: Street Plant. All the witnesses testified to this fact, and —
the Board conceded it @ 118, A ae), sets ge
“The Board’s new ‘ini that it sail found the In-
dependent dominated because the Company failed affirma-
tively to disavow the plan is based upon the assumption
that the employees had. settled convictions that the com-
‘settled coavictions’ in the/record and the Board made
110 finding. of ‘settled convictions’, and, even if there gad
‘does not require the Company to issue a public statement
of’ neutrality.
_ he employees were not peewee] ‘or influenced under
the Plan, and the Jones, and: Laughlin decision ‘ended’ the
apon proof of its majority.
« The isolated instances ‘of union activity by supervisory
- employees did not show the domination of the Independent
_ by the company which was prohibited ‘by Congress. Fur-
"thermore, the nature and resus of the collective bargain-
I * over the Independent. '
The intention of Congress was to prohibit ‘ ‘‘control’’ or
an “overriding of the will’’ of the employees by, the.em-
s ployer. It ‘ocomnplished this by comlemmning Hares 8
oF
26 rf
pany favored a particular type of labor organization when *
tlé Indepéndent was organized. There is no evidence of —
been a finding based on evidence, the failure to disavow
would not have proved domination. Moreover the Act.
Plan in thé minds of the employees. ‘They formed the In-~
- dependent as a new’ organization. which had no co rection ©
with the Plan. The leadership of the Independent ¥ 4s dif-
ferent. The Company — recognized the Independent
‘ ing. demonstrated that the Company exoreisell:s no ve |
its The Act was intended to encourage collective bargaining |
thropgh inside unaffiliated unions as well.as outside anions. °
—
° ©. . Pt 4 |
= |
: .|
f
ve } o
voy, *
es y*
Ries
‘
fis
}
7
: —_— of a “Iabgs iaidlaaitae ‘The ecert: ‘olin adopted an in
sl ta ft -°. > ‘terpretation of Sections 8(1) and 8(2) of the Act tonsistent,
avers | | eee with the intention of Congress and ‘properly decided that
| Se thé. évidence did not warrant‘a finding of domination-atd |
| ae _. Qrder of disestablishment. Both the finding and the order
Se - » . of:the Board must conform to the purposes of the Act and,
se eile a ae - the standards. laid down by’ a aa Se
ai y ; .
z t % é « = .
Sig ans ; > s . I I
2/8 tigi : . ae
pat ie « iv) * Ld .
|) The court below properly held.that Salmons was dis-
| _. charged for reasons other than union activity; that Kala-
a ie marie was laid off in: strict conformity ‘with the company’s.
wat “seniority policy and that no: one took his jab; that. Karbel .
eo “and Cumorich were properly discharged for= -ineffic n¢éy;
"4, \4 and that there was no condition attached to the tei of
> a : ® Frank Solifko. Accordingly, the company did“not by these
Ree "acts violate sections 8 (1) or 8 (3) of the Act. -
a , :
= a <
GRE RSE RR RES pho yraet od rasteve spate
5 ~ 13
‘ ARGUMENT. pak Some ar
” eee :
. ‘ 6 5
Pee ort ; | Sam oe vin Dior SRL
The Board’s brief in suppert of its decision on what it
alls the basic a in this case asserts the proposition
that:
. __ Where one of the consequénces of past violation is
_ the employees’ settled conviction that the emplbyer
‘must take gppropriate steps.to disabuse the employees
of this notfon before they are truly free to exercise an
unimpeded) choice between that type of organization
er. And whether in a particular, case the
action taken by the employer is sufficient For ’ this pur-
__ pose is, of course, a question of fact entrusted to. the
7 ard fo determination”? (Bd. brief, P. 26).° :
‘justify the Board’s suggestion regarding a ‘‘settled convic-
the decision and order; that the Board can. not assume
such a “settled conviction”? ‘merely on account of the exist-
hs ‘requires the Company to conclude that there is a “settled
* affirmative action to remove it; and that the Act confers
“no power upon the Bcard to decide finally whether ‘‘the
a
justification ini the Act for denying the right of the em-
ployees to organize merely because the employer has not
done: Such at assumption of power on thé part of the
‘Board. would afford it the opportunity. to prohibit almost
“all inside unions.
desires a particular type of organization, the employer |
-We.contend that there is no evidence in the-record to.
tion’”’ of the employees and no such finding was made in —
.. ence of the Plan; that there is nothing in the Act which ~
, conviction’’ in the niinds of its eniployees and to take some :
action taken by the ‘emp oyer is sufficient for this purpose.’’ —
_- We shall show that in this case the Board was taking for
granted something that did not exist and that there is no
done something which the Board assumes it ought. to have -
pets: tay .
—
an
Rae aN ee Te
- “e) °
cull ~
= - e
Re nore eee
12 ney
Danaea perso tes OED aon
ne =
Spe nIs ROR,
ne ene nd
rare mere 3e4
.
.
+.
iced a ws 5
agen tn geen
neeesyrat Se
“ar:
7 1%
ae THERX 16 HO SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE UPON WHICH TO BARE
° A FINDING OF DOMINATION. Le
. AS "There Is No Evidence That’ the ihaghedads: Hada
Settled Conviction That the Company Preferred a Par.:
..ticular Type of Labor. Organization; and: the Act Does
- ” Not Require the Company to Issue a Public Statement of
_ Neutrality. | Be : .
_ This is the first time aly em Board-has relied upon ‘the
‘‘settled conviction of the émployees’’ in an effort to sus-. °
tain its order. After taking evidence, it relied “for, the
' mhost part on certain findings of foreman ity and of a
linking of the Independeit, with. the Plan: because of -
similarity in leadership. Its answer to the petitien for
* peview and its request for enforcement of its order to the:
court below. was based on the findings. The presentation. —
in this Court is on different grounds. Without any ‘finding
_ on the ‘‘settled conviction” of the employees and without
any finding that the Company should have taker affirma-
- tive action by a public: announcement of .its -neutrality,
_ the Board for the first time states that on these grounds
\ its order should be enforced. The failure to make’ such .
findings iy the decision and order was due to a total
_ absence a
ployees as to what ‘the Conipany desired or did not desire. -
The Board has no right to present these matters here for |
the first time. # =
Iti is. n0 answer that other ‘finditigs are sufficiently broad
to permit such argument, because its presentation is not
as an argument but as a. proper conclusion from certain 5
evidence. We refer to the Board’s statement: on page 26
of its brief that: ‘‘and whether,-in a particular case |
the action taken by the employer is sufficient for this pur- .
my evidence. of a settled conviction of the em- |.
pose, is, of course, ‘a question of fact oitieeiek to the -
-.Board for determination.’’ } The Board cannot make a
“finding here for the first time and particularly when there
i nothing in the record upon which to base it. - :
The obvious fallacy i in the Board s argument js that it
takes for’ granted a ‘state of mind which does not exist .
- and which the Board cannot say is reasonable: from all
of the facts in this case. The Board admits that its theory
. is based on mére conjecture when it states: *
‘«The employees would naturally regard the new
+ organization which tHey were sponsoring as continu-
ing to enjoy the Company’s favor an _ support.”
(Bd. brief, p. 27.) -(Italics ours.)
o~
Se :
Had the employees had a/‘‘settled conviction’’ that they
would lose their jobs if they did not form. a labor o organiza-
tion to the Company’s liking’ there would be a necessity
. for a public announcenient. However, even assuming that
they had’ a ‘‘settled conviction’’ that the Company pre- — ,
ferred a ‘particular type of labor organization, there would -
be no justification’ fora finding that a public announcement*
was necessary and the abserice of it evidence of domina-
tion. Here there was neither a: finding of ‘settled con-
vietion”’ nor any evidence upon which one eauld be based.
The Board’ s argument that there was no ‘affirmative ac-
tion by the Company to disabuse the employees of such
‘settled conviction”? is not evidence to support the find-
ing that the employees must have linked the: Independent . -,
tothe Plan. The Board has assumed that the employées
had settled convictions in order to support the conclusion
- that they must have linked the Independent to- the Plan.
Rather than answer this argument which was based upon
a pure assumption, we shall point. out that the Board’s
finding that the employees iaust have linked the Independ-
ent.to the Plan is not supported by evidence and that, on the ©
sod there i is -seamiciiloen, uncontroverted ie that the ¢
: -
°
"RRS
Fe Wt he S05 pie
°° *
. s :
| Se ae _ employees viewed the Independent as a new-union which
they were free to join or refuse to yom 9 as they desired.
A eg ‘ : B. Employees Were Not Subjugatéd or Influenced Under
| ae the Plan. |
te There ‘i is no evidence that wages, ‘Shek or working con-
he. ditions were below standard during the existence of the
ae bee ‘Plan. There isno evidence that any employee was ever °
| discharged or reprimanded for failure to participate-in the
: hace There is no évidence ‘that the employees, had a
‘*settled conviction’’ that the Company desired a particular
type of labor organization.
Management’s ‘role in the Plan was slight. The Com-~
pany was only entitled, to haye one representative present, —
He had no right to vote (R. 1299). The constitution and -
by-laws of the Plan encouragéd the representatives ‘‘to
i : speak ott’’ (R. 1 . There was no limitation upon - :
a = right to strike f° Fae ae
gal, fees Board yilies upon a- statement to the Plan. repre- .
Het . . ° sentatives by Berry in 1936 indicating that ‘‘Berry forcibly
te impressed upon the Employees | Board the. respondent’s
ree | 1 ri anti-union ¢sentiments’”’ (R. 1525). ‘There is no evidence .
i | that any member of the Plan was so impressed or felt him-
HH ae self intémidated, but on the contrary, Lackhouse, who-was a
‘Ane ss représeutative at this time and who subsequently joined.
mee ‘and became an active organizer for the Amalgamated, éaid:
‘‘Mr. Berry at the meetings of the old Board never
" did say anything against the C. I..0.; he never did
knock it‘in my presence.’’ (R. 282). +
Moreover, Salmons, iso a Plan representative and subse- —
Bas quently the chief organizer of the Amalgamated, testified en
1 that the fact that he had beer a representative under the
He Bess eet) he rua not ‘affect him in his. C. 1. O.. organizing efforts ~
hak | (B.483) ‘The Board’s inference that the Plan represent-
} _ ativés were affected by! the statement. in 1937 ignores posi-
vie _ tive evidence to the contrary.
”
»
; : . :
‘ . 4
ee @
15 :
s the absence of evidence of cubiceitlins or. Kiama
of the employees. under the Plan, the technical defects can-
not supply ‘‘Compulsions’”’ relied upon by the Board.
(Ba.’ s brief, p. 26). The courts have co condemned inferences ©
when there is positive testimony to ‘to the contrary. Pemn-
_ sylvania R. R. Co. v>-Chamberlain, . 288 UA. 333, 339-348 ;
Appalachian Elec. Power:Co. v.N. L. R. B., 93 F. (2d) 985,
9g9 (C. C. A. 4); Nv. LR. B. v. A. 8. nici Bi (2d)
° 951, 958 (C. C. A. 4).
‘In finding domination from the existence ofa ‘<domi-
nated old plan’? the Board has gon¢ further than resorting
to inference in the face of controverting positive testi-
mony;.it has drawn an inference from an assumed state ~
of mind. aries ay = 6°
| 0. The Jones & Laughlin Decision Ended the Plan in the
_ the Minds of the Employees.
- There is no evidence that the Plan existed in fact due .
its illegality was determined in N..L. R. B. v. Jones G
- Laughlin Steel Corp., 301 U.S. 1. ‘'Theve is no evidence of |
any action by the Plan thereafter except formal dissolu-
“tion. ‘There is no evidence that the Plan was used to as-
sist in the establishment of the Independent. The Inde-
pendent did not spring froma Plan representative | nor
from any action by the.Plan.
_ The Plan was abandoned in fact on April 12, 1937, seven
days before its formal dissolution (R. 825), because the
record cleafly shows that the employees were aware that
the decision in N. L. R. B..v. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp..
301.U: S. 1, applied the Act.to the plant and meant the end°‘
of the Plan (R. 183, 825). The Board’s decision recognized
that the decision in N. L. R. B. v. Jones & Laughlin Steel
Corp., 301 U.S. 1, ‘‘threw out’’ the Plan in the minds of ©
the employees (R. 1526). ‘
Ray: Freling testified . that the Phan was thrown ‘ott he-
ra]
a
e.
ee. ae
a CNR Nee eR ERRORS se
?
*
eat ieee $8 Bide brs rg
eS - me, Ge SET Sigh aes ae a i
CEE ee SS eR TITS
cS Sa eh tae Ne St alee A Pag ts oh ge
' tae a
i a ' : ;
* or sae i ifs) i > ° pee oy
at at Scheer 3 . 16,
AL at. SP Eee S , ’
eal. VRE y
+ ti,
bates it was illegal when the Wagner Act was declared
‘ constitutional (R. 825-826).
Frank Lgckhouse testified that when the Waanet Act
4) ae : was enforced it threw out all of the representation plans
med _.-' and that- Mr. Berry told the Board that the Wagner Act
: 1 was constitutional. and applicable to the Link-Belt Com- :
+ Basa so the Plan was abandoned (R. 305-306).
Louts Salmons testified that after the Supreme Court.
me ee | passed on the constitutionality of the Act the Plan was
oe) | - thrown out (R. 183).
Ue _. George F. Linde testified that : the peste te anxiously
aa - . awaited the desision in the Jones € Laughlin case, know- ~
a - ing that it would affect employee representation (R. 714
/ 7 ARES. TS, 158.759). - ‘
| OB There is uncontradicted ¢estimony that when the Act was
~~. declared constitutional the’ employees knew that they had
AN : the right to form and join a labor Organization of their own
aE * .”- ghoosing without interference, restraint or ‘voercion by the
then eat ' Company. . aN
* ital - ohn Litster testified that he was glad the Wagner ‘Act
ie a “ as constitutional so that ‘the men. could form their own -
fea) -- + umion (BR. 796): ; \
eG , “Ray Frolitig testified that when the Wagner Act was de-
clared. constitutional, ‘“We were entitled to a unign ‘ ‘if we
chose it * * *’’ (R. 825).
. .- GE John J. Kovatih testified that when the Wigner Act was
thee declared constitutional by the. Supréine Court it was a case
A : of getting a union (R. 860). : ¥:
George F. Linde testified that when the Jones & pneere
case was d the employees knew they were entitfed to
form their awh union (R. 715).
i i There ard numerous and. uncontradicted statements, -by
me i _ é@mploy the effect that the Independent was a new
4 ie _ union that started the last of aves the first of May,
Ve |
WY
sath A . eye eas
? , ) . * f>
iH - . ° °
bist NEPA Doe ier eres eta te Cana gb tle Sn a on le Sot
Napa hy “Ss ee x su’ ie vi . U
FIP LE TEETER IY CSET EY ERATE SIO 2g ey
e
} ?
17
: 2
or after the Wagner Act was declared constitutional (R.
. + 570, 715, 527, 796, 165, 314-315, 640, 860, 362)... Paul -
Bozurich, one of the complainants, explained why he went
to an Independent meeting, although he was a member of | 7 :
the Amalgamated, by stating: ‘‘* * . then came another ian eey $
union, the' drive for another union, and there we eas :
certain points which I wanted to clarify to myself as ee ie |
what sort of union that: is thet is coming in’’’ (R. 462).
_ There is no evidence that any of the eniployees | | eard of |
the Independent prior to the Jones & ‘Laughlin decigion. \ tt
Pe Tr Mess ae
—teeatuaitiatiianates re eS a 7 .
é a “ . e
a | ‘ ©.
ae Fie
D. The Independent Was a ‘New Organization Having No.
‘ ‘Connection: With the Pfan. "
“The hae argues that the Independenf-was a mere F re-==—Ct
~ qplacement t of the Plan b becausé it followed it in point of time : = | . :
and that therefore the employees of necessity. linked the = § Oar ee |
Independent to fhe Plan and by so linking the two the en Ee 2 i
ployees were: ‘unable freely to choose the Independent as a : if
collective bargaining agent (Bd. brief, p- 27). Not only
is there no evidence that. the employees were dominated or -
considered themselves dominated under the Plan, but there
‘is no evidence that the employees linked the Independent.
. to the Plan. Instead, there*is uncontradicted evidence, as a
pointed out, (infra, pp. 15-17), that the employees be- _ :
_ lieved that thé Independent was a new bargaining agency
“in a changed | order. of employer-employee. relations and
_ that they were free to join or fefuse to join the Inde- ; ie
pendent: There i 18 . no evidence that the employees ware ha
coerced into joining the Independent. Instead, there | | es
"is evidence that the employees freely chose it as their cole.
__ lective bargaining agent. There i is no evidence that theem- —— a \
ployees chose it becange of a ‘‘settled conviction” that the
. Company preferred that type of labor organization.
We set forth below, in order to facilitate comparison, _ eg
‘some, of the major differences between the Plan and the ms |
Independent. “hese differences show clearly that the em- ~~ ze ct ee
Seed Ne
™
Hi ie. an n organization as the’ Plan.
*, | |) ee _ INDEPENDENT Union: OF -
i ye ape Tae Prax, CRAFTSMEN. :
i hie Dh Name Link-Belt Em- - 1. Name: Independent .
ea ee ‘ ployees ‘Board. . .- - ° Union of Craftsmen.
1 2. No employee joined but 2. Each: member joined
| was‘ automatically a-- . and membership was
'. member and entitled -limited to those who .
: to vote. (R. 1297.) - y Inade- application,
ask ' +, paid initiation fee and.
ye : uf ap were - accepted. (R.
Pr a Gare. Rilig ie ol 1451-56. 3
3. No dues, initiation fee,- 3 Dues, initiation fee, but.
. . buttons or.a bank ac- .. tons,-and a bank ac-
q count. (R. 1197, 281.):- - gount. (BR. 749, 850,
~ Pee ee 854, 337.) .- A
4. Foremen eligible. (R... 4, Foremen ineligible. (RB.
a ‘ 204.) # * °__ 1451.)
Wee 5. Held no general mem-. 5, Held general member-
THE A ; bership meetings. (R. ‘ ship meetings, - (RB.
HW =. P Pre a _ BB 5. aie
Pat - Meetings on company 6, eetings in union ha
Mb , - —~ property. (R. 1196.) off company prop-_
rif : ertys (R. 75C.) .
2) | 7 .No aitorney. (R. 1197.) - 7, Attorney: (R. 71%)
ee | ith 8. Company participation’ 8. Né Company participa-
om ' _ in internal organiza- tion. of any kind. (R..
| @: tion. (R. 1299.) ' 719-721 1451-56.) -
_ 9 No connection with 9, One of twa Locals. (R.
Caldwell-Moore plant. 1452.)
ik (BR. 1296.) ee wae
one “ae 10. No basic agreement. 10. Basic agreement with |
ae : with management. on ' management on work- |
He working. conditions.’ sing: . conditions.. (B.
Hee (BR, 1198) 743, 1460.)
daa 11. Not. incorporated. (R. il. Incorporated. (R, 1448.)
i bi ; 1296.)
et tees zg “The Leadership of the Independent Was Different.
; ik Le Not only were there such differences in all material re-
i Me sa spects that no employee could have supposed that the Inde-. |
t i i ch demcasanig was the- ‘same wes of an organization as the Plan,
ployees formed ; an organisation different from the Plans
Kall so different in all material respects that no employee could -
ce __ have supposed’ that the Independent was the same kind of
Py : , “a ‘ . : 19
"put there was dissimilarity in leadership. At various times ae
the following employees were elected Plan representatives: —
_ Salmons, Lackhouse, Litster, Froling, Brucks, A. Johnston, |
-Kachinsky, Daugherty,.Kvet and. Wendell ‘(R. -1301, 305,
- 152). Of this group, Salmons and Lackhouse hecame active ©
— organizers for the Amalgamated (R. 152, 305, 295).-Litster,
* “Proling and: Brucks were induced to bétome active or- oo or
- ganizers for the Independent by Linde (R. 720), who was its ieee
the originator and. leader of the Independent. ‘Linde was — ae | a
never a Plan’ representative, while Salmons, the leader of .
- the Amalgamated, was a Plan representative (R. 713).
-’ The Independent committeemen as designated in the con-'
- stitution were Brucks, Linde,. Rask, Froling, Rosenbaum, . :
~eske and Litster (R. 1315-1316). Four of. these seve
bad never been Plan représentatives. .- 3 ee
- The first permanent ‘officers of ‘the ‘Independent were
~ Rask, president of Local No. 1, Kovatch, vice president,
Conybear;.. s&cretary, ‘and Rosenbaum, treasurer (R. 737),
none of whom had been Plan representatives.
Phe following were elected stewards of the Independent: =
Walker, Milke, Hacker, Conybear, Heyer, Davis, Paulson, —
Zwart, Boynton, VanBerdandt, Schroeder, Kuehn, Kockin- ©
sky, Masilione, Balton, Robinson, Miller, Wildheim, Ehbert,'
“Monroe, Reidel, Hallet, Ross, Bullard, Fagerstrand, Paldo,
Belanger, Steele and Brucks (BR. 748). Twenty-eight of the
twenty-nine stewards had never been Plan representatives. |
The following members oT thr independent eppearedto | “
be most active in solicitation of members and collection of ———-—____
dues: Kovatch (R. 658), Robinson (R. 660), Petrouski = eee
(R. 529), Jamieson (R. 362), Erickson (R. 349), Linde (R. :
344), Brucks (RB. 348), Johnson (BR. 314), Froling (BR. 283),
Balton (R. 287), Jeske (R. 222), and Kresge (R. 872). Ten
of this group of twelve had never been Plan representa-
tives. ° ie ate . sf .
© S09 ae : . ek pe : ; ‘ se i
99 :
all . -Meooeditigiy, the, record shows that the’ ‘leadete- of the
Hi 4 ne '> ° Independent consisted almost @clusively of employees who
Wado: . had no Prior official connection with the Plan. The. Inde.”
an i pendent Was origifated and gained its impetus through ~
E \ i | aes Linde, who had no, bonnaction with the Plan. :
= aa re Therefore, . the employees. could not have “linked the :
: i. fice > | Independent with the Plan. >
‘i ai _* ¥. The Geilipiny Suhel Recegnised & the iependnt
i Upon Proof of Its Majority. . aM
L er The ae recognized the Independent upon aie?
“geass... CL? quate proof that it represented 760 out. of 1; 000 eligibles —
cl employees. The Analgeeeet had made no- request for’.
: bargaining rights (R. 1 “According to Salmons the
ee | | | \ membership of ‘the ~ gamated never approached - a
aa majority (R. 207, 1934y. The. Independent was ‘recognized «
: after-Berry checked the proof for genwincness and after’
a _the Company executives considered. the request for two
ig days, during which time legal advice was obtained B:
Veg). 1143-1146). :
is His The Board concluded that the haste”? of. recognition
i}... °°.” favored the Independent (R. 1534)... But so'chlled ‘Shasty
1e hi } recognition’? is significant only where there’ are. conflict-
ried - ‘ing claims, and the proof of majority of the union reco
Vik _ hized is‘inadequate. International Association of Machin-
hi ists v. N. LR. B. , 110 F. (2d) 29 (App. D. C.), aff'd ‘No: :
ati 16, October Term, 1940; decided November 12, 1940.
Mit N.L. BR. B.v. American Manufacturing Co., , 106 F, (aa) 61-
‘4 (C. C. A. 2), modified 309 U. S. 629. -
: ‘In the cases cited by the Board in support of the propo- y
sition that a “hasty”? grant of recognition is an indication
ae of.an employer’s support (Bd. brief, p. 41), Tecognition.
was given without prodfef majority, and in N. L. R. B.v.:
SiS! Rt CEL TF
aiterihtx=rr' x sascomnaeahttaatanier, ce aaenanetimamemeamilia Ota
Stake. —. 2 =
| ou Falk Corp., 102 F. (24) 383, 388 (C. C. A. Mee ek L. R, B.
| i ee, :
ad DPW f
. <7 LS eR Bette, xy ESS <i. 1%
Fil Ris ES li Say Le latina ieee, Patan Kat lbs See ss AAR ks nbn ea LS eR e
99
iy Sa: 103 F. (24) | 815,. sit, 818 (0. C. A. 8) ay ae |
‘ the ‘employer. had previously: refused to deal ‘with out-
“side union. mos ie ee .
The ‘Ocenia had?’ no aitérnative undér section. 8 8 ee | Fie
of the Act’ other than to recognize the: Independent... . ..: . . ee
The ‘Board argues at length that under the cirenimstances ° Fetal hee
- - the Company was obligated at the time of the decision in ~"
“N. Lr R. B.'v. Jones €é ‘Laughlin Steel Corp., 301: U: 8. 1 a Einar :;
to take affirmative action by a statement «of public’ with- - wee ae dais, A
drawal f'-backing of the’ Plan representatives of by~a : for
” sta t of public neutrality in order to release the em- eeiat
plo from the ‘‘eompulsion”’ to: which they had been. a
‘subjected, and. the failure to publish such a statement —
rendered | the employees sineapable ‘of organizing an un-
deminated labor organization (Bd. ‘ brief, p. 26). The.- 9°:
Board then argues that whether the action taken:by.the” .. ~\_
« - employer in a'particular case: is sufficient for this purpose ; ¢
is a conclusion of fact entrusted for determination to: the’ _
Board.’ No finding or conclusion with reference to affirma- -
tive action was made in the decision and order.
: ~ Assuming that the men desired the’ Independent, what” ese : Pena ee
.» ebuild they have done to accomplish that result which was = -* > - ae
+ different from the steps taken? The Board’s argument,** — . :
followed to its logical conclusion, means tliat because *the
-men did the right’ thing to get that result, ‘and | acted - Bere
; promptly, it must be assumed that they were in effect ok ae.
merely continuing the Plan;-and the subsequent recognition ae :
by the Company,—even. though the Company had no excise’ - - > ae oe
for not recognizing the Independent—was evidence that ee. ~~.
, Tndependent: was dominated. If the ‘Company fails to do ;
this positive act, which the Board. urges should’ be done, .
no inside unaffiliated union formed by the employees could’. *'. >.
be other than a dominated union; not because of anything °
‘the men should have done, but rapewa of Pesca d sn Res “4
ry did not do, - Meek ae
i
fi
Hy -
i
y HH
1} Hi
$)
f i.
1
\| |
“ithe Board veliga upon’ Westinghouse Electric é. Manu.
ate facturing Co. v. NoL. R. B., 112 F. (2d) 657 (C. C. A. 2)
(cert. grauted, No. 447, October Term, 1940), and N, L.
BR. B. v. Swift & Co., decided November 20, 1940 Ave C. AL
In°Westinghouse Electric & ‘Manufacturing Co. v. _N. L.
. R.B., 112 F. (2d) 657, the Second: Cireuit based its deci- |
Son of domination. on the fact that the independent was
> formed at a meeting of .a representation plan, and because .
.. the representatives under that plan had made a canvass ©
'- ” of the employees i in their’ official capacity while the plan ©
- " was. still in. existence.’ In the case at bar there was no
official action taken: by the -Plan in: the initiation or de- _ a
velopment ofthe Independent. Even if that court was cor- -
rect'in concluding’ that the eniployer had a duty to openly
‘disavow the plan, the court’s conclusion may be justified
on ‘the ground that the employees were led to believe that
the representation plan was the means of initiating, the
Independent, whereas, here’ ‘the. er could not have
“made such an. assumption.
The Board relies on System Federation No. 40. v. Vir-
ginian Railway, 11 F. Supp. 621 (D: C., E. D. Va.) for the .°
proposition that. the activities of former plan representa-
' tives in a successor independent is. evidence of domination ©
"of the latter (Bd. brief, pp. 31, 32). In that case the rail-
‘road was enjoined from attempting to ‘influence’? or
‘‘interfere’’ with the employees. The Court of Appeals
held that there was ample evidence that the railroad had
unduly ‘‘influenced’’ the employees, which ‘is expressly
forbidden in‘ the Railway Labor Act (44 Stat..577; 45°U. S.
C, A. See. 151). ‘The difference between the Railway Labor
Act and the N ational Labor Relations Ket ‘i is pointed out
_ (infra, p., 32). The evidence of ‘undue, influence was in
- the nature of coercién, including threats that the rail-'
“+ road‘would abandon its car ‘shop if- the A. F. of L, came
; arin _ 4 *. |
e ‘ a
— matahieennnemntsaenannnanaiee — a . 8
a a ee ee ee ee
SAO EEL IE RTE SIO IA | ET PA
d
in, and one of the superintendents of the-railroad urged a: : .
membership in-an inside ‘union at the same time that he resi °
purported to explain the employees’ rights under the Rail- = ej, ©
way Labor Act. Furthermore, Hearne, chief ‘organizer of , 3 Mi Be
the successor independent, was-found to be acting for the gener, f
‘railroad and not representing the employees in good iaith.. .
In this case, the ‘prime mover of the Independent, Linde, . Bete a
- had no official connection with the Plan, and the Board does. icc) St Se i
* not even suggest that Linde was. not in good faith repre- - Bas t.
‘senting theemployess. a Fase ie ac: |
Likewise in N. L. R. B, v. Swift éCo., decided November | 3
20, 1940.(C. C. A. 8), the court based its decision ‘of wr |
domination on the, fact that the. association was formed :
by the assembly. plan representatives at the last assembly
plan meeting. The plant superintendent at’ that meeting -
advised those present to choose an inside group of repre-
sentatives and suggested an attorney for the new group.
Tts:first bargaining committee consisted: of 15 employees,
14 of whom were former plan representatives. The court
eoncluded that the company took advantage: of the exist-
ing organization and of the authority of certain-members
‘of its assembly. Here, no such conclusion: would-be justi- —
,fied and the employees .could not have assumed that the —
Plan was the ‘means of initiating the Independent...
We have. pointed out that there is ‘no evidence to show -
that any of the employees entertained a settled belief that .
the employer desired 4 particufat type of organization}
that the emiployees had not been subjected to compulsions ©
under tke Plan; that there could have been no linkiag of ©
the Plan to the Independent in the minds of the employees;
and that the employees were fully aware that the Inde-
pendent: was a new organization fofmed under new condi-
tions. The Board’s view that affirmative action should _
have been, taken by the Company-means that the Board | a
interpreted its own decision as ‘requiring Affirmative action,— Bante Ta |
a, 2
~
' viction’’ from. the minis of its employees, and there is
nothing in the Act which prohibits the employees from act..
silence. *
- The Board, with equal justification, might have con-
cluded that the Company preferred no union at all, and,
“had there been no subsequent labor organization, the Com-
‘pany would have violated the Act by failing to make a
here, only an outside union could satisfy the Board that
‘ any such interpretation of the Act by the Board ig con-.
' lative standards created by that body.
With dismissal by the Company for engaging in union
anepuraneamnsaraman parory —_ Vote
z z ~ Ey
Pe AOS nee ene na 2. : ,
24
Moreover, nothing in the Act requires the Company to
take action which would remove any such “settled con-
ing on their own initiative, even if the Company maintains
public announcement after the decision in‘N. L. R. B. vy.
Jones é. Laughlin Steel Corp., 301 U. 8. 1. The interpreta- ©
tion which the Board gives the Act would place both the
employer and the. employees: under the domination of the -
Board and deprive the employees of the freedom which the
Act intended to-confer. In a situation such as existed
the employees’ ‘‘settled conviction”’ had been removed or
could be disregarded. - It wil! be demonstrated laten that
trary to the intention of Congress and violates thé legis-
cited
G. Both the Amalgamated and the Independent Soli
—~23 Ballaatas Sac an Ca mnonr Mima F "7 : the
Knowledge or Permission of the Company. . ;
The Board has argued’ that the solicitation which the
Company allowed the Independent organizers to carry on
during working hours without interference by the super-
visory staff constitutes Support to a labor organization
and interference with its affairs (Bd. brief, pp: 34, 35).
The Board fails to nute many instances where organ-
izers for the Independent were warned and threatened. .
° . . \
a
activity on Company ‘time. Hubert Sill one -r the
-organizers for the Independent, testified that he solicited
a few men for the Independent on Company ‘time, and
‘ was caught by his foreman, ‘Longwell, who warned him
-to. stop because he was being paid for working (R. 829,
830). Ray Froling testified that he was warned by Fred
' Skeates, superintendent of the foundry, regarding solicita-
tion and was told fo stay by his machine and not run —
around (R. ‘216, 822). John Litster, organizer for the
Independent, testified that he’ was told by his foreman, —
Carlisle, that he was not allowed to go around on matters’.
not Company business and that if he did it again, he
would get fired (R. 800, 802). George. Linde, originator
and.prime mover of the Independent, testified that Long-
well, a general foreman, told him “Don’t let me catch a
you collecting dues or engaging in union business on Com-
pany time or we will fife you”? (R. 781). Linde-also_tes- _
tified that he was. warned by two supervisors ‘‘to cut out
‘the monkey business and stay around the bench’’ (R.
760). Linde complained that he was closely watched’ and
that several of his associates told him that they were
warned about walking around the shop when they were
on legitimate business (R. 760, 781). Ralph Kresge, one
of the organizing committee of the Independent, ‘was
reprimanded by Fred Skeates, foundry — superintendert, |
th was caught talking to an individual with one of
_ the Independent cards in his jand.—Skeates—told: him the
next time it’ would be too bad for him. ( R. 872). ;
The cases uniformly hold that no inference can be
drawn from solicitation on company time by one com-
peting union when the employer has stopped such solicita- |
tion when. it was brought to its attention and when
* both the competing unions engaged in the same practice.
See Ballston-Stillwater Knitting Company v. N, L. R. B.,
98 F. (2d) 758, 761 (C. O..A. 2); Cupples Co. Manufac-
turers v. N. L. R. B., 106 F. (2d) 100, 108 (C. C. A. 8).
“The Board relies. on N. ‘ R. B. y. Bradford Dyeing
Association, 310 U: S. 818; and N. L. R. B.-v. Fanstee|
i] Metallurgical Corp., 306 U. S. 240, to support its state.
Bit | men} that solicitation on company property is an ‘‘organ.
| ization hall-mark’’ of employer support’ (Bd. brief, p. 35).
.. We have ‘demonstrated that the Independent was not per..
mitted the use of Company time or property, and if its.
organizers did. solicit on ‘Company time;, it was without
, the knowledge and permission of the Company. In both’
‘emot these cases cited by the Board, solicitation was. merely
a part, of the program of he policy-making officials. of
"%s the companies (president in the Bradford case, and plgnt 3
manager in the Fansteel: case), who personally initiated
and promoted the respective independent unions. |
i)
eee | Hite : - The Board has also ‘relied on a quotation from Inter. -
ee - ~ national Associggion of. Machinists v..N . L. R: B., Neo. 16,
‘ . this term,» decided November .12, 1940, condemning the
_. —freedom_of _activity- permitted one group as contrasted
with the close surveillance of another. Tn the-ease-at.bar_f
| He { there is ample evidence that the Amalgamated as well as-
mae | | | | Seer the Inflependent ‘solicited membership and collected dues. *
a We én Company time. The. following record ‘pages disclose
_. solicitation or collection of dues’ by the Amalgamated on
-Company time: 917, 918, 921, 900, 904, 889, 910, 913, 894,
895, 862, 822; 826, 827, 1060, 881, 880.
It was so obvious from the testimony during the course _
of the hearing that both sides engaged in union activity
jon Company time that the Trial Examiner stated:
‘‘Trial Examiner MeCarthy: I think the record is’
_ pretty clear that it worked’ both ways’’ (R. 901).
mi i ; ‘There is no substantial evidence that workmen solicited
in the presence of their-supervisors. Union conversations,
solicitations and the collection of dues by. both competing
¢
Bi
af
iB
Lb
Pe MRI SRN LIE FRO LI CUNO 4 Sey rent ase, edb gravest Tne Na SI aR eae he ee ee
e
‘unions were. coeriéd On when supervisors were out of
sight (R. 857, 864, 818, 695). . :
There is ample testimony’ by various. tcbeaein that they:
were instructed specifically on union activity about the
time. the Wagner Act was’ declared constitutional, and
- that tfey knew the men had to be kept at work and would | .
_-not be allowed to’ roam and talk whenever they please |
’ (BR: 1016,. 1017, 1019, 1047, 1048, 1055, 928, 1008, 1004,
1009, 1047, 1048, ‘1055, 1019, 1017-1019). >
The Board ' offers as proof of its argument that the _ ;
Company high-préssured the men into membership in. the _ a
Ts caagay Sy alr 760 employees were en;
rolled in. the _ Independe the- space of three days
(Bd. brigf, p. 20). The Board does not mention the .
- number of employees who were engaged as solicitors for
| the Independent. Although there was no. evidence intro-
duced for the purpose of showing the exact number of
solicitors, it is incidentally revealed that at least 22 em-. = =. *
ployees were active in soliciting the original 760 members c
of the Independent (R. 222, 283, 286, 289, 314, 354, 356, ,
362, 495, 428, 529,747, 797, 831, 851, 857, 871, 8m, § 880, :
905, Re NOE ae Sai seas ‘i
. The Board names only 7 as solicitors for the POR . :
“pendent and does not mention the evidence that the 22
or more solicitors were besieged with requests to. join
the Independent. Linde stated that it (the Independent)
was S0- ‘big a feature that they were all anxious to get
on the -bandwagon and do something (R.. 717-718). Lit-
ster testified that ‘‘They: came to us, flocked to us fo:
_ sign” (R. 797). : :
It is apparent from a careful were of the record
that there were even more than, 22 employees soliciting of
the original members of the Independent (R. 831). The ¢
‘fact that there was a minimum of 2 employees. soliciting
ral
ie a large group of fellow workers who were anxious to join |
t makes. the result of 760 members a natural consequence.
| and not, as the Board would make it appear, a suspicious ;
iy i achievement: ; :
H. The Isolated Instances of Activity. by Supervisory
Employees Does Not Show Control of the Independent
_ by the Company. :
The lower court properly concluded; as a » matter of law,
that the evidence of foremen activity did not justify the
finding of domination and the order of disestablishment.
‘There were between 60 and 70 foremen or supervisors
at the plant. The evidence of union activity is directed at
6 of them, Olson, Nyberg, Siskauskis, Belov, McKinney |
and Staskey. These instances were sporadic and isolated
and fail to disclose a pattern showing a 7 aseapeetee
to assist the Independent. |
The following i is submitted, not for thet purpose of de-_
tracting from the Board’s power to make findings from ©
controverted evidence, but rather to démonstrate that the —
activities of those concerned did not amount to evidence’
of control of the Independent. : ,
According to Lackhouse, Olson told: him of ‘the ad: -
vantages of an.inside union over an outside union (R. 285,
1529). Lackhouse, also stated that Siskauskis signed the
names of several employees to Independent petitions (R.
1530). The employees whose names were signed were un-
able to read or write and Siskauskis signed the name of ’
Thomas only after he ‘said he could, not writé’’ (R. 1530).
The Board states that Siskauskis threatened a number of
_employees with discharge (Bd. brief, p. 17) bit no finding.
to this effect is made by the Board. os
: 1 Via - Siskauskis denied - such. threats and the Boatd in its
Hadi Brief improperly assumés them i in the absence of a finding. ©
The Court cannot be asked. to consider parts of. contro- °
verted testimony omitted from the Board’s finding. Florida
v. U. S., 282 U. S. 194, 244, 215; Atchison Ry. Co. v. U. 8, ;
295 U. S. 193, -201- a ‘ | Pei on
‘The Board. expressly “found that its witness, Balcauski,
stated in reply to Siskauskis that he .(Balcauski) was a”
‘member of the C. I. O. and under the Wagner law foremen
were not allowed to talk to thé men and he (Balcauski)
was not going to waste his time (R. 1530).’ This demon-
strates Siskauskis’ lack of influence: — *
The Board’ found that Siskauskis sttended bor a ipert
_ time the first mass meeting of the Independent, but there °
is no finding by the Board that he participated in the
meeting in any ps Aad stayed for more than a short time e aah pene
(R. 1528; 1530). ;
The Board found that one of the thie: Kalamarie,
_ testified that Belov received written instructions from
‘McKinney ordering him to attempt to get the night
foundry men to sign up in the Independent, and that Belov
asked. Kalamartie’s advice and thereupon tried pena: “ |
fully to solicit, Kalamarie and others ‘(R. 1531). - ey .
Board did not call, Belov to .prove that he had sa. we
‘. any such instructions. The instructions were not intro-
_ duced in evidenee and McKinney denied giving them. The
whole incident is vague and uncertain as shown by the |
* Board’s findings, and it is based upon testimony of a wit:
ness who related ‘what he had read from written. instrue-
tions. .
~ The Board found that Belov was a supervisory cnidlines
(R. 1532). Belov was an hourly paid workman,—a_ truck
driver, burner and checker (R. 983, 1073, 1080, 1092).
Trrespective of whether or not Belov was a supervisory ; 4
employee, the Board’s findings show that he was not
‘influential within the group of workers in the night shake-
out gang. The Board found that he did not know why
3 Pipes on ee
.
J 4 > * , ‘ eh F. ~ il ¢
t <aebaberas 7p Ri aaa he ee WA eae Sy a Eee So ee ne : Vets °
ieee aS a ns Se eae z wee: Sp 4* oe oh Pn PRS ee, ?
ys . e . . .
:
ye
e ,
e .
-- . ® -<
janie
teen ase, ety
_ ,
~e
certain’ men in his group were laid off “(R. 1542). :
_ _Board further found that he was carried on the Sntead
ea : records asa night checker (R. 1531). It is clear from the -
: A eas | Board’s. own findings that the employees could not have
‘ believed that Belov carried any more authority than to
| i hae . transmit simple instructions and his activities did not give
the Company control over their choice of the Independent.
The Board relied on the testimony ‘of Lackhouse to find
that Nyberg said to’'go ahead when Lackhouse asked if he
could soilicit for the Independent (R. 1529). But there
_ is no finding that he was given permission to do this on
Company time and Lackhouse’s testimony shows that he.
~ was not given this permission (R. 291). At this time Lack-
house, according to the decision and order, was a member
of. the Amalgamated (R. 1529). The findings of the Board
.. fie .-. . farther show W that Lackhouse was uneasy about solicitation
on 3 sate 1529).
“ The findings with reference to. Stasky. will be taken up
- under the ‘‘Solinkos’’ (infra, p. 62).. i
‘é The Board relies on N. L. R. B. v. Fansteel Metal-
—. Iurgical Corp., 306 U. 8. 240, 250, 262, in contending that
the activities of these six supervisory. employees are: evi-
‘dence of domination (Bd. brief, p. 37). In that case the
company’s: plant superintendent originated a plan for an
‘inside union in connection with an anti-C. I. O. campaign |
and in both of these causes he was assisted by foreieén.
The Court found there was substantial evidence that the
Independent was organized as a result of these promotiecn
efforts of the plant sunerintendent and, the foreman. In
ft N. L. R. B. v. Bradford Dyeing Association, 310 U. S.
i tee 318; N. L. R. B. v. Pennsylvania Greyhound Lines, Inc.,
it Hi > an S. 261; and N.L.-R R. B. v. Pacific Greyhound Lines, .
ae Inc., 303 U. S. 272; also relied on by the-Board_(Bd. —
Pe | brief, p. 37), the evidence clearly showed" that inde-
epee oes pendent unions were initiated and formed by’ the pol-
“
iey-maxing officials of the: companies ‘involved. In N. L..
R. B. v. American Manufacturing Company, 106 F.. (2d)
61, 64, 68 (C..C. A. 2), modified 309 U.S. 629 (Bd. vrief
p. 37), a foregirl, who had been at one ag active in a
company-dominated union and instrumental in the com-
pany’s plan to establish individual bargaining represen-
tatives, was the principal initiator and promoter of the -
Independent, and on this evidence the Court found she
was acting for the company. 3
Thus all the cases cited by the Board for. the proposi-
tion that the activities of the. six supervisory employees
establishes company domination are clearly distinguish-
-able frentthis:case on the ground that here the company
had no hand in initiating or formulating the Independent:
and there is no evidence that the ery, had any yr
gram to assist the Independent.
The Board relies upon International Association of
Machinists v. N. L. R. B., decided by this Court on Novem-
- ber 12, 1940, to place responsibility upon the Company for
. the statements and:acis of these six employees because of
their supervisory .status (Bd. brief, p. 38). The Board’s
statement implies that the Company is responsible for all
~~ statements and acts of supervisory employees. In that case,
this Court found that the inference that Fouts, Shock, Din-
inger and Bolander were acting for the company and not
independently was supported by the following established
facts: (1) their supervisory status; (2) they were active
‘in the company dominated welfare association; (3) they
headed the drive and were the leaders for the I. A. M.;
(4) the I. A.M. program served the company’s purpose
and served no useful purpose for the employees. ©
In the case at bar, Linde and the other Independent.
‘ organizers did not occupy the position of supervisory em-
ployees. Also those who were supervisors were not caTry-_
ing out any plan or rogram their acts indicated no at-
x Rie es a ee ¢ Bs a
et Ra ies y i
LS ate < *
32 ©
tempt to control or manage the Independent; and ‘the em-.
_-ployees had no reason to suppose that-any of their per-
sonal opinions were spoken on behalf of the company and
- not on behalf of the employees. See Sands Mfg. Ce, v.
N. L. R.B., 306 U. S. 332, 341, 342.
These findings of the Board cafinot weonstitute doinina-
tion. We shali point out later that domyg, atign means |
control. ‘The evidence falls far short of, Mateo Proof \
of interference by the company through statements of
foremen is one thing, but proof . that the company con-
trolled the Independent through such statements is another.
qh
Furthermore the evidence in the aggregate does not even
ii show that degree of employer activity intended by Con-
aah ; gress as a violation of the Act. The intention of Con-
gress in this respect is important. Section 24) of the .
Railway Labor Act prohibits an employer from assisting
or contributing to any labor organization, labor represen-
tative or other agency of -collective bargaining, or from
performing arly work therefor, or to “‘influente’’ or co-
erce employees in an effort to induce them to join or re &
main, or not to join or remain members of any labor
‘+ organization. In Texas & N. O. R. Co. v. Ry. Clerks,
‘ 281 U. 8S. 548, 568, this Court, in upholding the con-
HOM. stitutionality of the Railway Labor Act, set forth standards |
: to be followed by the Board’ and stated that ‘‘influence”’
meant ‘‘pressure’’. We quote from, page 568: -
‘The meaning of the word ‘influence’ in this
clause may be wathered from the context. Noscitura |
By “ —* goes. Virginia v. Tennessee, 148 U. S.: 503, 519.
4
1b - _ The use of the word is not to be taken as ‘interdicting
ie the normal relations and innocent communications.
ee : ‘which are a part of all friendly intercourse, albeit
i. between employer and employee. ‘Influence’ in this
context plainly means pressure, the use of the author- | -
ity or power of either party to induce action by the
. Other in derogation of what the statute calls ‘self-
- organization.’”? .
a | . i cate : J bs “t f ie
In the report of the Senate Committee on Education ‘ |
‘and Labor, May 26, 1934, Senate Report No. .1184, 73d . : OF. ee
Gong., 2d Sess., it is pointed out that the Supreme Court wis ‘
upheld a ' statute: which’ ‘‘was in terms broader than this
bill (National Labor Relations Act). for.it forbade an -
employer ‘not merely to interfere with or coerce his em- -.
: ployeer but even to ‘influence’ them.’’ — 7
Significantly the -word cinfluence?? originally in the | @
Act was removed in subsequent drafts.. Hearings of Senate cy eee ae
Committee on Education and Labor, 74th Congress, Nese tae tired .
Session, Hearings on S. 1958. ‘Senator Walsh stated at
a sernenl: Bares
t.. “EF do not think there is meine in this bill to ; Mga
-prevent an employer ‘when his employees, the men,
and women, are about to orgariize, from posting a
notice, or writing each an individual letter, or per:
sonally stating to each that he thinks their best inter-
est is to form a Company union, that is violently
“opposed to so and so who is attempting to organize
_ a union. I do not understand, there is. anything in
this bill. to-prevent an emplo ef from doing thet, ‘and .
that is why we struck out t ord ‘influence,’ that --
would be ‘influence’ and not interference.” .
]
Changes in legislative drafts may * properly be consid- . .
ered bythe Court as evidencing the intention of Congress. — Y,
’ Federal Trade Comm. v. Raladam, 283 U. S. 643, 648. 7
- The activitjes above referred to constitute at the most
_““influence’’ as was properly: pointed out by the dissent
below. There was no evidence of interference in the
Independent, let alone evidence of control such as we
. Shall later show was intended by Congress 1 in its use : ‘of the —.
word: “domination”. : : 2. <a Ee ‘
6 \
:
*
‘
5
ai
t
i}
Th
Hi
it
“I. The Nature and Results of the Collective Bargaining
'. of law that collective bargaining. had no probative value
' dissenting judge is illuminating:
tribunal. Federal Trade Commission v. Curtis Co., 260
| process of collective bargaining as a means of settling
_ disputes which had been burdensome to commerce (Na-
and must be governed by - ‘the intention of Congress. |
_ Federal Trade Commission v. Raladam Company, : 383 °
’ -suecessful collective’ bargaining by the Independent is
‘strong positive evidence that the employer was not in fact
34
Demonstrate That. the Company Brercised No Control
_ Over the Independent. °
The Board’s decision and order ignored the mass of
evidence submitted by the Independent and the Company’
on collective bargaining. The Board announced as a rule
in this case (R. 1534). ‘The court below considered this ©
evidence of bargaining and the following statement of the
“Tt (the Independent) has carried on aténein '
‘collective bargaining with the company and I am
unable to find anything in the form or. character of’
_ the bargaining transaction which can reasonably be
said to justify an inference that in its bargaining
_ activities the Independent is in any sense controled
‘ .in its freedom of action by the company.’’
The court below had the right to consider relevant evi-
dence which was not. considered’ by the administrative
U. S. 568-580. ; ; ,
*
One of the purposes of the Act was to encourage the
tional Labor Relations Act, sec. 1, sec. 7). Bona. fide col-
lective bargaining is strong evidence that there is no domi- *-
nation and the uncontroverted evidénce of such bargaining
in this case ‘should have been so considered by the Board. .
- The administrative: agency must consider the para-.
mount aim of the law from whieh it derives its authority
U. S. 643. Furthermore, evidence of uncontrolled and
35
controlling, Sissieating or directing the affairs of the
Independent.
In ‘contrast, the Board itself has held that the lack of
bargaining shows domination and has even based findings
of domination under section 8(2) of the Act. squarely awe | ‘
upon the absence of collective bargaining. In the Matter
‘of Titan Metal Manufacturing Company, 5 N. L. R. B.,
577; In the Matter of Skinner and Kennedy Stationery
Company; 13 N. L. R. B., 1186.
. The employees acting through the Independent ob- .
tained a 5 per cent wage increase June 1, 1937. (R. 741);.
a 5 per cent bonus for night workers August 13; 1937
(R. 744) ; a change .in the vacation plan (vacation pay
for men laid off in 1937 (R. 746, 1167)); a change in
seniority ‘policy; and many improved working conditions
_(R. 740-747). The Independent met with the Company
for the purpose of collective bargaining more than 25
times between. April, 1937, and March, 1938, the date, of
the: hearing (supra, pp..3-5). In addition thereto, many
individual grievances were presented by. shop stewards to
the foremen and_-heads of depariments (R. 747). Such
evidence is of primary probative valué in determining the
domination issue and it should have been so considered by
the Board.
J.° The Court Below Adopted a ‘Proper cicieaitidtins of
Section 8(2) of the Act in Deciding That the Evidence
Did Not Warrant a Finding of Domination and Order of
Disestablishment.
‘The Court of Appeals had the ities + right to decide as‘a
matter of law that the findings in the aggregate did not
show domination and interference with the formation and
administration of the Independent or support thereof and
_ hence the order of disestablishment was unwarranted.
“The Act sets forth the scope of review of the Circuit
°
EE
. e 2
tad ” Scene a iE taki 7, Oe per. * PRR COED OP RT ET Cte ta
’ 36
Courts of Appeal in section 10(e). This section is similar
to section 5(c) of the Federal Trade Commission Act. Con-
gress intended that the scope of judicial review provided
in the Act be the same as under the Federal Trade Commis-
sion Act. The Report of the Senate Committee on Education
_ and Labor, May 2, 1939, Senate Report No. 573, 74th Con-
' _ gress, Ist Session, states: — oH
‘*Section 10. Procedure before the Board. This is
the most important procedural section. Despite the
. widespread charges that the bill invokes novel pro-.
i. keer : cedure and vests unusual powers in an administrative
agency, the bill is modeled closely upon numerous Fed-
~ : | * eral Statutes setting up administrative . regulatory
\ bodies of a quasi-judicial character. The common pro-
‘ s cedure is so well known that the committee deems it —
Tas ares : ‘unnecessary in substantiation of this statement to refer
ia . _ to any analogous statutes save the Federal Trade Com-
: ye ore mission Act, section 5.” AiR i
a In Federal Trade Commission v. Gratz, 253 U. S. 421, 427,
“~~ 487, the words ‘unfair method of competition,” not defined
by the statute, were in dispute. It was held that it was for
9 : the courts, not the commission, to detertiine ultimately as
‘a matter of-law what they include. - Mr. Justice Brandeis, .
- concurring in this principle, stated (p. 437) : |
. _ “*The: question whether the method of competition
pursued could on those facts reasonably beheld by the
commission to constitute an unfair method of competi-
tion being a question of law was necessarily left cpen
to review by the court. * * *” - Car Py
To like effect, is Federal Trade.Commission v. Beech-Nut
Co., 257 U. S. 441-453. The same principle is applied’in
reviewing the conclusions of other administrative bodies,
ineluding the Board. National Labor Relations Board v.
Newport News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock Co., 308 U. 8.
241, 251; Helvering v. Tex-Penn Company, 300 U. 8.481, ©
1 + 490; Texas and Pacific Railway v. Interstate Commerce.
. * s. Commission, 162 U. 8.197, | - .
ois | - Section 8(2) of the Act provides: “4
2 shall be an unfair labor practice for an employer
~~,
eS
* to dominate or interfere with the fornistion or admin-
istration of any labor organization or contribute finan-
‘ cial or other support wa
‘Nowhere in the Act is there a definition of the term ‘‘to
dominate.’’ - Webster’s New: International Dictionary de-
fines ‘‘dominate’’ as ‘‘1. to predominate over; to rule; to
govern; %. to have controlling power over; to be the Tuling
_ foree‘in; * * o
*. ** ¢Dominate’ is a strong word | meaning to master, to rule, |
to control.’? Humble Oil and Refining Co. v. N. L. R..B.,
118 F. (2d) 85, 87, 88 (C. C. A. 5).
The meaning of the words ‘‘to interfere withthe forma-
~’ .-tion or administration of any labor organization’’ is clearly
. set out by Senator Wagner (Congressional Record, Vol. 79,
? 74th Congress, First Session, p.7570) :
66%. @ *
exercised over the supposedly free agent of his workers
may take other forms. It may consist in employer
domiuation of the formation of the constitution or by-
laws of a labor organization. The essence of interfer-.
ence is, that the workers’ organization instead of being
absolutely free and independent as an organic entity
is subjected i in some way to the employer’s will.”’
What was intended by the words of the-statute is best
described by the following examples taken from the quo-
tations from Committee reports and debates on the Na-
tional Labor Relations bills pring on pages 72, 75 of
Appendix II:
(1) Employer: participation in framing the’ con- x
_ stitution or by-laws of a labor organization ;
(2) When provisions in the constitution or by-laws
cannot be changed without the consent of the empioyer;.
(3) When the employer participates in the internal
management or elections of a labor organization; —
the procedure of the meetings;
(5) Where the employer engages in seven lesser
interferences so- that he overrides the will of the em-:
ployees ;
(6) Where the employer gives financial support to a |
labor organization.
«
The undue influence which the. a,
(4) When the employer supervises the agenda or :
38 |
| Section 8(2) of the Act was intended to imply ‘‘overrid- .
‘ing of the will of the employees”’ or actual or potential con-
trol over the labor organization. There was no evidence
here from which a violation may be inferred and‘the lower _
court properly concluded as a matter of law that the order.
_ of the Board ne the ns Amana should be set
2
K. The ‘Order Must Conform to the Purposes°of the Act
and the Standards Laid Down by Congress.
‘The Board’s order of disestablishment is subject to judi-
aside. §:
-cial review. In N. L. R. B. v. Fansteel Metallurgical Corp.,
306 U. S. 240, 257, this Court stated :
‘The authority to require affirmative action to “ef-
fectuate the policies’ of the Act is broad but it is not
unlimited. It has the essential limitations which ad-
— in the very policies of the Act which the Board in- ~
vokes.’’ *
- Whether administrative agencies validly apply the legis-
lative standards set up and whether they act within thé
authority conferred or go beyond it are appropriate ques-
- ° tions for judicial review. The scope of review extends not
only to arbitrary and « capricious interpretations of the stat-
ute but also to erroneous ones. Federal Radio Commission —
v. Nelson Bros. Co.; 289 U. 8. 266, 276; Federal Communi-
cations Commission v. : Pottsville Broadcasting Co., 309 U. S.
134, 144, 145.
Congress did not intend to ites inside unaffiliated labor
; organizations. Report of the Senate Committee on Educag
tion and Labor, May 2, 1935, Senate Report No. 573, 74th
Congress, First Session (p. 10): —
‘‘This bill does nothing to outhaw free and indepen-
dent organizations of workers who by their own choice |
limit their cooperative . activities to the limits of one.
j company. 9? _ uF
| Report’ of House Committee on Labor to the Conimittee *
of the Whole House on the State of the U nion, June 19, 1935,
A ‘ ’ santas
en S Nelateeisc-Guenuciouahdnthale toate ornl treacle Ree ar er eee eee OT TT en gees
House Report No. 1147; 74th Congress, First Session (p..
18) : : ee ’
‘‘Nothing:in the bill prohibits the formation of a com-
pany unien if by that term is meant an organization of
’ workers confined by their own volition to the béun-
_ daries of a particular plant or employer.”’ _ a
Congress only intended to eliminate ‘‘controllédNabor or- —
ganizations’? (Appendix II, imfra). Report of Senate
- Committee on Education and Labor, May 2, 1935, Senate
CV
Report No. 573, 74th Corgress, First Session (p. 10): .
‘‘The so-called ‘company union’ features .of the bill
are designed to prevent int@rference*by employers with
organizations of their workers that serve or might -
serve as collective bargaining agencies. Such interfer-.
ence exists when employers .actively participate in
framing the-constitution or by-laws of labor organiza-
- tions; or when, by provisions in thé constitution or by-
laws, changes in the structure or the:organization can- ©
not be made without the coysent of the-employer. It
exists when they participate\in the internal manage-
“ment or elections of a labor organization or when they
supervise the agenda or procedure of meetings. It is
- impossible to catalog all the practices that might con-
stitute interference which may rest upon subtle but
conscious economic: pressure exérted by virtue of the
employment relationship. The question is one of fact
in each case. And where several of these interferences
exist in combination the employer may be said to-domi- ,
nate the labor organization a overriding the will of the
- employees.”? = “
“<= We have pointed out above that the Act was devised to
protect the right to organize, to encourage the process of .
bargaining, and to make secure the bargaining agency irre-—
spective of the type of labor organization adopted. by the °
employees. The type of union to be éliminated is only the
controlled union, which does not represent the free choice ©
of employees or which is incapable Brest as a bar-
gainirig agency. All other unions, respective of whether
they are inside or outside unions, affiliated or unaffiliated
unions, come within the protection of the Act. . |
o
40 :
: Although the Board has wide discretion in the selection of + —
a remedy, yet a remedy which this Court finds'to be in con-
flict with the purposes of the Act is beyond the scope of the
Board’s discretionary power. Otherwise, the Board would
be the final arbiter in the construction of the statute under
which it exists.
_ The court below soteialaadl that the Board was in error
in issuing its orders of withdrawal of recognition and dis-
establishment in: the case at bar. The majority opinion, -
while reaching the same conclusion as the dissenting opin- .
ion on this particular point, reasoned along lines heretofore
discussed. Judge Treanor based his decision on alternative
i rig are presently pertinent (110 F. (2d) 516-.
517 ):
8 © © And it follows from the nature aad fanstion
- of an order of disestablishment of a bargaining agent.
that the policy of the act will not be effectuated by
such an order if the agency disestablished thereby iz
actually the free choice of a majority of the members
of the bargaining unit and is genuinely free to repre-
sent the interests of the employees in their relation
to the employer. Under such circumstances, an order
of disestablishment would frustrate, not effectuate, the _
policy of the ‘Act..
‘‘Since I Believe there was no substantial evidence
to support the Board’s conclusion that petitioner’s .
acts either rendered the Independent incapable of serv- -
ing petitioner’s employees as a genuine bargaining
representative, or. rendered its continued. recognition
by petitioner an: obstacle to collective bargaining
- through freely chosen representatives, I conchide that
the ee portion of the Board’ s order was.
invalid.’’
That there may be a factual situation which calls for eel
cease and desist order but‘not a disestablishment order was ~
anticipated by this Court in MN. L. R. B. v. Pennsylvania
Greyhound Lines, 303 U. S. 261, ae this Court stated at
page 270:
‘“We may assume that there are situations in which
the Doard would not be. warranted i in concluding that.
z
S
41 -
, there was any occasion for withdrawal of employer —
- recognition of an. existing union before an election by
employes under section 9(c), even though it had
ordered the employer to cease unfair labor practices. oh
In N.L.R.B. v. N ewport News Shipb uilding and Dry Dock:
— Co., 308 U. S. 241, it was stated on page 250:
**Sec. 10(c), was not intended to give the Board
power of punishment or retribution for past wrongs ~
or errors. Action under that section must be limited
.to the effectuation of the policies of the Act: One of.
- these is that the employees shall be free to ome wuch
' form of organization as they wish.’’ ;
In N.L.R.B: v. Pacific Greyhound Lines, Ine:, 303 U.S.
‘272, and in Consolidated Edison Co. v. N. L. R. B., 305 .
U. 8. 197; cited on page 43 of the Board’s brief and all of
_the cases cited on page 44 of the Board’s brief there was
~ present the element of company control ovér the union held
properly disestablished which is lacking in this case.
' The distinction between a’‘‘prophylactic’’? remedy such
as‘a cease and desist order under the Act and a ‘‘correc-).
tive’’ remedy, such as disestablishment order, was pointed
_ out by Mr. Justice Brandeis in his dissenting opinion in
Federal Trade Commission v. Gratz, 253 U. S. 421, 434:
‘*(1) Instead of attempting to inflict’ punishment |
for having done prohibited acts, instead of enjoining” -
‘the continuance of prohibited combinations and com-
pelling disintegration of those formed in violation of -
law, the act undertook to preserve competition. through
supervisory action of the Commission. The potency
of accomplished facts had already been demonstrated:
The task of the Commission was to protect competitive ©
business from further inroads.by monopoly. It was to
be ever vigilant. If it-discovered that any business con-
cern had used any practice which would be likely to
result in public injury—because irfits nature it would _
tend to aid or develop into a restraint of. trade—the ..
Commission was directed to intervene, before any act
- should be done or condition arise violative of the Anti-
Trust Act. And it should do this by filing a complaint
‘with a view tv a thorough niag reais and, if’ —
or Oe
49
\
be, ‘the i issue of an order. Iis action was to be prophy-
‘lactic. Its purpose in respect to restraints of trade was
prevention of.diseased business conditions, not cure.’’
Where no condition of domination or control of a unien
cs ever existed, but at -the most. intermeddling that might
have a tendency t» lead to control in the futute, tlie-eor-
rective remedy of disestablishment is improper. Ii addi-
tion, as the dissenting judge below pointed ‘out, disestab-
lishment on the present record would ‘‘frustrate’’ rather
\
than “‘effectuate the policies of the Act.’’
Conclusion of Point I.
There is ‘no evidence of a ‘*settled -conviction’’ by. the
- employees that the Company desired a particular type of
labor organization and, i in the absence of such evidence and
a8 finding thereon, the Board’s argument is improper.
The intention of Congress i is appa rent. First, the Act was
not to be interpreted as eliminating so-called inside un-
affiliated unions ; second, domination means ‘‘an overriding
and fourth, one of the main .objectives was to encourage
the process of collective. bargaining to lessen disputes bur-
‘densome to commerce.
Here, the Company recognized and bargained with the
type ‘of union which Congress intended to protect. The
bargaining between the Company and the Independent was
of advantage to the employees i@ that they obtained many
benefits, and was of advantage to the Company and the
_ public in’ that there were no disputes burdensome to com-
"merece. 9
‘The Board’s order’ demonstrates that the Board
wishes to destroy the form of organization chosen by the
employees. Ii so doing ‘it has adopted an unreasonable
4 . yo . ‘ ?
of the will;’’ third, interference ‘means participation in; *
—— interpretation of the Act and has sagt violated the legis-
aes lative standards. it
“ne Mom TAREE SOR ISS ise nee: reat -
ST eae ae eae eee
43 ae
The Board seeks this Court’s, approval of a formula ‘im-
that the Independent was dominated. This formula is as
ployer participated followed ly an inside unaffiliated labor
'. organization, that labor.organization must of necessity be
_ regarded as dominated in law.
from ‘certain factual situations conclusions ‘of coercion,
Clayton Act, 38 Stat. 730; Norris-LaGuardia Act, 47 Stat.
70; Congressional Record, Vol. 79, 74th Congress, First
Session, page 7969.) By concluding domination of the
Independent from the mere presence of the Plan instead
of considering the. evidence the Board has © fallen into
similar error. We respectfully urge that the Court reject
the formula and require proof of Yomination in fact, or
proof of,an, overriding of the will of the employees when
they chose the Independent. ~ ‘
. properly devised and used by the Board in concluding
follows: Given a plan of representation in which the em-
‘Because in the past some courts reached automatically 4
Congress was impelled to pass remedial legislation. (See _
. 3) a
» *
a
3
Ir:
THERE IS NO SUBSTANTIAL EVIDENCE TO SUPPORT THE
BOARD’S FINDINGS THAT THE COMPANY VIOLATED SEC-
ba TIONS 8 (1) AND 8 (3) OF THE ACT. ,
ae A. Karbel 1 Was Properly- Discharged for Inefficiency.
_ Moreover There Was No Proof That the Company Had
.Knowledge of. His Membership in the Amalgamated.
The decision of the Board finds thatthe Company dis-
eriminated in regard to Karbel’s hire and tenure .of em-
ployment, thereby discouraging membership in the Amal- .
gamated (R. 1544). . It ordered Karbel’s reinstatement to
his former position and the payment of back wages.
The Board in its brief adopts a new theory that Karbel
was discharged because he refused Belov’s alleged request
that he join the Independent (Bd. brief, -p. 54). Although .
_ the Board i in its decision and order found that Karbel re-.
fused to join the Independent when solicited by Belov, after
considering that fact with the evidénce that he joined the
Amalgamated, the Board concluded ‘‘that the real-reason’’
for the discharge was that he joined the Amalgamated (R.
1544). Thas the Board in weighing the evidence
for the purpose of determining the: Company’ S rea- —
son for discharging Karbel rejected the fact that he re-
fused to join the Independent as the basi’ for its finding.
It is noteworthy that the Company could not have been
making an example. of- Karbel by discharging him for.
refusing to join the Independent bevanse, as the Board
found, Karbel was not-giveffany reason for his discharge
(R. .1544)) In any event the attempt of the Board in its
brief to change the reason for its conclusion is improper.
_ We contend that the sole issue presented by the deci-
sion and order is whether. the Company discharged Kar-
bel ‘because he joined the Amalgamated. By his own .
testimony no one eee he joined that union (R. 567).° We
ua
LPB GI IRE OT NR
ty
also contend that the Board in now attempting to change
the basis for the original finding of discrimination recog-
_ nizes the essential weakness of Karbel’s claim that he was
discriminated agningt.. This weakness we shall farther
demonstrate. |
Karbel was employed by the Company in March, 1937. ;
He worked for three months, until May 19, 1937, when he
was discharged for inefficiency-(R. 562). He nad worked
for the Company between 1925 and 1932 (R. 560, 561).
-Karbel’s testimony shows that he was illiterate (R. 560-
.. 568). He worked as a chipper, which entails the removal
_ of rough spots on castings (R. 561). :
- The record shows that Karbel joined the Amalgamated
_ in the latter part of April, 1937 (R. 562). There ‘is no
evidence whatsoever that he was an active member, of the
union or that he-wore his union button in the plant. He
testified specifically that he told no one that. he joined the
Amalgamated. He stated that no one knew that-he joined - :
. the Amalgamated (R. 567). Therefore, as the court below
recognized, an indispensable element is lacking in the - -
‘Board’s case, that is, the Company’s knowledge that Kar-.
bel was a member of the Amalgamated. ’ ,
The Board in its brief at this time seeks to supply this
essential missing fact by stating that the Company’s al-
leged labor spy ‘‘was at that time a member and commit- .
teeman of the Amalgamated and attended its meetings’’
(Bd. brief, p. 54, footnote, 35). Supposition of this kind
. does not supply a missing finding, _and, furthermore,
we have pointed out (supra, p. 66) that . -Cousland’s al- _
leged surveillance completely stopped. in " October, 1936 .
(R. 121, 585, 1535). Salmons testified that Cousland
took no part in the Amalgamated’s. meetings (R. 145,146),
- and likewise there i is no evidence that Karbel ever attended
an Amalgamated =
GRID vg orton
_ .Without a showing that the Company knew of Karbel’s
membership the Company cannot be said to-have discrimi-
nated against him with. relation to his hire and tenure of
employment by reason of his ' membership in that union.
‘ Ballston-Stillwater Knitting Co. v. N. L. R. B., , 98. F. (2d)
758 (C. C. A: 2). |
Karbel. was discharged because he was unable to do the
| amount of work that the average employee of the Com- _
pany doing similar work was able to perform. The record
sub: tantiates the following facts: Labor costs in Karbel’s
dep: tment were rising (R. 1072). McKinney, the fore-
ffan, examined various labor cards, including Karbel’s, and
made frequent. visits to the night shakeout gang in which
Karbel. worked to determine the reason for the rise. On
these visits he would see how much the men had accom- |
plished from the time they started work and would check
up the following morning to see how much they actually.
performed (R. 1073). Karbel was on a piecework basis
and his work, as well as the work of, others, was easily
checked. McKinney observed that Karbel and Cumorich .
(Cumorich is considered, infra, p. 50). were inefficient and .
McKinney warned them about. their Jack of production (R.
1077). McKinney then instructed William Peters, the time
study expert, to check on their labor cards (R. 1077). “7
William Peters examined the time cards of Karbel and
“compared them with the time cards of five other workmen.
He also rechecked his findings with a chart f t frequently used
‘ in foundries in connection with the bonus payment plan (R. ee
1270, 1271, 1415). The Company had made usé of the chaft
in the past and had found it to be true and correct
(R. 1271). The chart reduces cleaning and grinding
operations in foundries to manits, a term denoting the _
_ unit.of measurement of labor required to do a particular
operation (R. 1270). :
oe
EPEAT NR: nti ee seepage Ce EBLE ORE SY WON IT OG RN TI Mal AID ON TREE OE OLN ABM TRE OF OF RIN PLOT MN DG OAT BO ary See ae Oa meme Oe
/
EMO PEt Se byte?
, eo PRS
wr Ee Rie ey Sehy et: SRM lt cas cgi an
; FE EE ST EE OI ELIE TR.
47
Peters’ findings were set forth in a ‘recap sheet, Re-
spondent’s Exhibit 31 (R. 1419). It shows that on a total
-_ of $115.89 worth of work performed by Karbel the Company
lost $43:34.. The other men in the department with whom .
Karbel had been compared gained about 28 per cent over -
the normal whereas Karbel lost 37 per cent (R. 127 1, 1272).
Peters’ findings were reported: to McKinney. and Karbel
was discharged.
.The Board attacks Peters’ findings as follows: First,
the Board points out that each casting is assigned by the
foreman to a particular workman for cleaning and it would
_ be entirely possible for the fore:nan habitually to assign the- -
dirtiest castings to one particular chipper (R. 1543). This
is pure insinuation which is unsiipported in the record. On
the contrary, McKinney testified that no one particular ©
chipper or grinder would be singled out to do less desirable.
work because it would not be possiblé to run a modern shop.
that way. McKinney further stated that it would not be the
fair or right thing to do and a fore:nan could not get the
respect of his men if such a practice prevailed (R. 1035,
1083). Karbel’made no claim that he received dirtier cast-
ings than the other workmen.
Sécondly, the Board maintains that conditions ‘on the
- night shift differed from those of the day shift, and that
Peters admitted than none of the other five so. chosen for
comparison worked on the night shift (Decision, R. 1543,
1544). However, Peters also testified that there is no sub: ©
_ stantial difference in the day and night work that is -per-
‘ formed by chippers and. that night chippers do not get
dirtier work than day chippers (R. 1279).
Thirdly, the Board attacks’ the time studies on the ground
- that the hourly rate of the five employees used for the pur--
pose of comparison was different and in most cases higher
than that of Karbel (R. 1544). _Here again the Board’s con- oe,
jecture lacks the basis of evidence. Peters testified that the
: : _o
, 8.
five men were taken from an entire group and were selected
because they performed similar work and that the rates
that were applied to the other five men were practically pat
identical to those on which Karbel worked. Peters further
testified that there may be 2 tenths of 1 per cent difference
and that would not be enough to vary the accuracy of the
time study (R. 1273, 1274; 1976). Even if the hourly rate
of the five was different from Karbel’s the result of the
time study would not be altered. (R. 1278, 1279).
_ Lastly, the Board contends that ‘the work of the men -
was somewhat dissimilar, different piece prices on each’
job had been established and the total time allotted varied
from individual to individual (R. 1544). However, Peters
~ . gelected the men because of the almost identical work’
they performed (R. 1275), and the uncontroverted testi-
mony is that while there is a different class of work
on the castings, some of them. being large and some small,
and the conditicn of the castings may change, yet these mat-
_ ters average out themselves ‘(R. 1035- -1036).
While the Board, according to its decision, was not im-
pressed with Peters’ testimony, the Trial Examiner thought
the opposite. He characterized Peters as an os. (R.
~ . 1279). :
The respondent had a positive reason for its dinthaes of
Karbel. We Tespectfully submit that it furnished credible
and substantial. e idénce to prove this reason. This evi-:
dence is uncontr overted by the Board, except by insinuation ee
and conjecture. No evidence was introduced by the Board
‘in opposition to Peters or McKinney except Karbel’s own
statement that he was a good worker and that Belov did not
‘know the reason for his layoff. We have considered Belov’s
position previously. (supra, p. 29). ‘The complete dis-
Tegird of the Company’ s time studies without any. proof
that they were not made .in good faith was unjustified.
Au employers have wide latitude i in employing and dis-
PPE IEEIORON. NSS BT Ee HEME NI a
49
charging employees. _The only requirement of the Act is
that the employee must not be discharged on account of
union activities and union affiliations. Wilson & Co., Inc. v.
N. L. R. B., 103 F. (2d) 243, 250 (C. C. A. 8); N. L. R. B. v.
- Union Pacific Stages, Inc., 99 F. (2d) 153, 168 (C.-C. A-9).
It was said in-N-L.R.B.v. Thompson Products, Inc.,.97
F. (2d) 13,17 (C. C. A. 6) that. 2 see ee
‘‘Interference with the rig'* of an employer to ¢e-
termine when an employee i: ..efficient should not‘be. -
lightly indulged in when applying the Labor Relations
Act and * * * the evideuce suould be strong and
convincing that he was discharged for union activities —
before’ reinstatement. by an administrative board.’’
In addition the Board conjectures that it was an unusual
thing for men discharged from the night shift to be paid in
cash (R. 1542}. The decision states that customarily
they were paid off by the day foreman, McKinney, who —
‘had..ultimate authority over all employees in the steel
cleaning room, including the night shift (R. 1542). There |
is no evidence that the Company has not always paid —
im cash. One witness testified that he was given his -pay
envelope when he was laid off (R..624). The Board carries:
its speculation ad infinitum when it finally says that ‘‘an
unusual procedure of giving Karbel his dismissal pay was
-. adopted, a procedure which prevented him from facing Mc-
Kinney or the workers on the day shift’’ (R. 1544).
Had Karbel wished to face McKinney he could have done-so
irrespective of whether he had to call for his pay envelope.
Any supervisor of a large group of men is bound to lay off
or discharge a considerable number over a period of time.
It was improper to infer discrimination from this act. The
Board drew the inference that Karbel was discharged in an
unusual manner because he was paid off in cash. From.
ie this inference the Board inferred that McKinney did not —
want to face Karbel. From that inference, the Board in- ©
ferred that Karbel was discharged because of his member-
. membership in the Amalgamated (BR. 1544). It ordered
np Tae 50
eee 4 :
ship in- the. Amalgamated. Such pyramiding of inferénces
is condemned in N. L. R. B.v. Empire Furniture Corp., 107
F. (2d) 92, 95 (C. C. A. 6).
_We respectfully submit that no valid\reason was pointed
out in the Board’s decision why the time studies made by.
the’ Company were not to be believed.. Unless it can be |
shown: clearly that they were not bona fide, they demon-
strate that the Company had a valid cause for the dis-
charge of Karbel. Karbel was an inefficient, .workman.
Even had he been an efficient workman, the necessary
requirement that the Company had knowledge of his
union affiliations is lacking.” There is no proper finding ~
-“oi its violation of sectioa 8 (1) or section 8 (3) of the |
Act. re
B. Cumorich Was Properly Discharged. for Inefficiency.
Moreover, There Was No Proof That the Company ‘Had
‘Knowledge of His Membership in the Amalgamated.
- The Board dia that -by discharging Nick Cumorich
. the respondent (Company) discriminated in regard to his
hire and. tenure of employment, thereby discouraging
Cumorich’s reinstatement to his former position and the
payment of back wages at his average cormnge prior to,
his discharge (Decision, R. 1554).
The reason for the discharge of Cuniorich was identical |
to.that of Karbel (supra; p. 46). Cumorich was em-
ployed by the Company for six months prior to his
discharge. . He started in December, 1936, and was dis-
charged May 19, 1937 (R. 409). He was a common laborer
for the most part and yercormed some work’ as a grinder
in the foundry (R. 412). Fa a.
~ He was. laid off on the same day as Karbel; he worked
on the same shift as Karbel..
“Gamorich joined the Amalgamated in. the” latter part
"of April, 1937 (R. 409). “There is no showing whatsoever
in the record that ‘he was active in the Amalgamated; or
‘that he wore a union button; or that the Company had any
knowledge of his membership in the Amalgamated (R.
409). Therefore we adopt the same arguments and cite
the same anthorities as were madé and cited with refer-
ence to Karbel (supra, p. 46).
| The Board.in its brief has treated Karbel mer Cumorich
_ jointly and argues that Cumorich also .was discharged be-
~. eause he refused to join the Independent. The Board .
‘in its decision -and order stated that the real reason for
the discharge of. Cumorich was’ the fact he joined the
Amalgamated (R. 1544). We refer. to our discussion of
- Karbel on this — (supra, p. 44).
_ Peters made a Study of Cumorich’s work and whilevit..
was difficult. to find’a basis of comparison, nevertheless-
from his studies he found that there was a loss of approxi-:
~ mately 47° per cent on Cumorich (R.: 1272, ‘1419. See
Respondent’s Exhibit 32, R, 1271, 1272). - )
Cumorich was hired as a chipper and sindeis He was
used as a laborer fora period of time,: to become. accus-
tomed to the work and to await afdpportunity to locate
on a chipping and grinding post. When. thé opportunity ‘
‘arose he was assigned to grinding small ‘castings in the
mill roo1a and after a. trial’ of about seven weeks was found: a
to be unfit for the job: for which he was hired. | He was
discharged after it was discovered that his production
was about 35 per cent below the average (R. 1031).
The Board points to no tangible: evidence for its re-
‘fusal to accept the time, study evidence of Peters. The
Board finds that Cumorich rarely’ worked on piecework,
since laborers are paid on an hourly basis and as a result
thé efficiency rating based entirely on Gumorich’s capacity .
on piecework would not be a true test of his relative
‘ «e
ae :
ee ae e . .
capability (R. 1543), The.Board compleiely omits the
testimony showing that Peters’ study was based not
onty upon. comparison with other men, as in the case
_of Karbel, but’ it was also based upon Respondent’s
Exhibit 30, which sets forth the normal rate on the clean-
ing and grinding of castings. A. comparison was made ~
for both Karbel and Cumorich -by use of the chart and the
computations showed that Cumg tch’s loss was 47 per
cent (R. 1272).
The testimony of Peters devine: Cumorich’s loss by’
the Manit chart to be 47 per cent is corroborative of
McKinney’s testimony that he observed Cumorich and
Karbel to be substandaéd workers, (R. 1074). Here again ;
there is no justification in’ the- record: for the Board.
~ to refuse e positive testimony of McKinney and Peters
when no controverting, evidence is present in the record.
All the evidence shows that the Company did not know
of Cumorich’s union affiliations: and that he was -properly |
discharged for inefficiency. The : findings ef the.Board |
that the Company violated sections 8(1) and‘8(3) of the
Ac by aiid tg Osmorich are enarty erroneous.
f
: ©. Kalamarie Was Properly Laid: Off for Lack of Work.
— -1549,.1555), o .
"Moreover No One Took His J ob.
? The Board. found that the ‘Company discharged Kala-
' marie because of his union imembership and activities and
ordered. reinstatement ‘and the ys of back wages (R.
The Board contends that Nalamaris: an are welder, was
laid off out of his usual seniority’ position and that work-
men wha had less seniority were retained. We contend
‘that Kalamarie was properly laid off as an arc welder due .
a lack of work under the Company’s policy of seniority.
- and that he had no right to acter back to his former oceupa-
tion of burner. ° :
eo,
PELE E RMS LEIOLET. TRE PAIS <6 26 Spt eh reg Dye Sak AD TY at peey Shs vert
as SEE ADS Ses Vipeun
58
‘Kalamarie ioe RESPOND two veal’ seryice with
the Company, being hired November. 11, 1935, and laid. off
November 30, 1937 _(B. 621). His first occupation was that
of helper in the foundry (R. 628). Early in 1936 he was
promoted to the job of burner in the steel cleaning room
of the foundry and at his own insistencé was promoted to.
the job of arc welder in August, 1937 :(R. 630, 1065, 1066).
The last promotion caine after he joined the Caen cuaanaaey
in March, 1937_(R. 621).
In the latter part of Caliber: 1937, ‘the Company’s busi-
néss was sharply reduced. Of 583 employees in the foundry, —
- 100 were laid off during a period of five months beginning _
in November. The output of the foundry dropped from
‘794 tons in March; 1937, to°448 tons in November, 1937,
and to.250 tons in February, 1938 (R. 937, 938). The Com-
pany was forced to reduce the number of its employees and :
“ faced the problem of maintaining a force sufficient to oper-
ate efficiently at a-lowerslevel. .
The’ Company.-+had an established par ae ‘seniority a
_ policy. This. was expressly found by the Board in holding.
that the discharge of “Bozurich was not discriminatory (R.
1547). The reason for this policy was ; that the jfferent jobs .
requited different training and in a large la it became
_, essertial to retain skilled workmen to han the. different
jobs. The Board in its brief states that this policy was only
| -tentdtive (Bd. brief, p. 56). However, this is contrary'to. the:
‘ * evidence. ‘and: the Board’ ‘8 express findthg above eforred
_ to (R. 624, 1547). . eae ER a
i}
The application ef this policy to Kalamarie is as a to
lows : the: steel and iron foundry, operated in counecti
with the plant is divid~4 into 14 separate and distinet de-
partments (See Respondent’s Exhibits 6 to 19 and 6-A to -
19-A, R. 1374,1392, consisting of seniority lists). Hach de-
‘partment is divided into occupations, for example, the steel
: cleaning department. has within it the following occupa-
- tions: grindérs,- chippers, cut-off. en, cut-off men,
p> | ;
f P *»
+. ; . Hy °
. ° s
; ° .
ices . - }? . 4 a v
\
ete Lenape tg oa
dad
Ba ARES aes
Sa
Mae 88:
ca “8 rs
, ‘ : be ‘
~ . *
a ~ 54
. , .
’ - . “ io
truiinee sand blast operator’, oven tenders, are and gas
_ Welders, arc welder checkers, inspectors and laborers ( Re-
spondent’s Exhibit 6-A, R. 1374).
‘Each one of these occupations has a separate seniority |
classification list. Kalamarie appears on Respondent’s Ex- —
hibit 6-A as’ an are welder, in which position. he had been |
engaged since August, 1937. The various octupations were
established because they required different degrees. of:
- skill. An are welder uses electricity to heat a metal rod
and then deposits the molten metal in the cavities of cast-
ings inorder fo finish ‘hem. ‘The gas welder uses an acety-.
lene tarch and oxygen to heat the castings and then replaces
broker sections and remakes them so as to finish them
nr (R. 955). It was uncontroverted that more experi-
ence and skill were requiréd in the occupation of gas welder
._ than, in the occupation of arc welder (R. 959). Moreover, a
gas welder. received a higher rate of pay (R. 1116). A ecut-
.. off man or burner cuts off risers. on casts (R. 1114). A
laborer (cut-off) must have sufficient ability with a torch
to cut large pieces of. scrap metal into smaller pieces,
thus enablin gt them to melt in the cupola without cluttering
it, (R. 1115). .
With the lack of work in November, 1937, both arc
-welders, C. Novak and Kalamarie, were laid off. C. Novak,
having less seniority than Kalamarie, was-laid off one day
previous’ (Respondents Exhibit 6-A, R. 1374). Deskns
and Murphy were gas and are welders (referred to as com- |
bination welders). They were the only two welders re-
maining in the foundry. Deskus had less and Murphy had }
more. seniority. than Kalamarie but Deskus was retained
because the company needed two gas weiders until Jan-
uary, 1938, when Deskus was laid off (R. 958, 1374). The
are:welding during this period was done by these two com-
bination weld Had the company laid off Deskus instead
of Ramer, production ‘would have been obstructed -
because it uld have had only one gas welder (R. 958).
2
La DIPOG EAT IO T BR OEE A OP IL LOS BENT NEY ees ful Adah Bh Taek: chins abc teh Soe a | ean) ne a
LUE ae se RT
Dee oe ee 3 Sas 2g oe oe ee a
hig ee
- 55
Accordingly, Kalamarie was properly laid off according -
to seniority in the occupation of arc welder. No one took . et. os
~his-place,as there was not sufficient work to be performed _ ) <7 ee
’ in that occupation. This fact-ie-important as indicating
an absence: of discrimination. 2
The Board’s conclusion in its decision and order is that
an exception to the occupational seniority policy should
- have been made for Kalamarie and that he should have
been stepped back and displaced either Kouna, Thiele or
Melcoskey (R. 1548). Kouna, Thiele and Melcoskey (none
of them are welders), who had less plant seniority than
Kalamarie, were laid off subsequent-to him. - Kouna: was
laid off January 5, 1938, and Thiele and Melcoskey on
March 11, 1938. Kouna was designated as a laborer. (cut-
: off), Thiele as a cut-off man and Meleoskvy as a chipper.
(Respondent’s. Exhibit 6-A, R. 1374). past
The reason for the company ’s refusal to:make an excep-
tion to the seniority policy for Kalamarie is that such a
practice would disrupt the-efficiency of the plant. Morley,
foreman in the foundry, testified that such a policy in the
event of lay-offs might leave some necessary occupations
without any qualified workers (R. 1024, 1025). Skeates, the
foundry superintendent, testified similarly (R. 961). Berry
testified that the plant Would be in.a chaotic condition if this
_ system were followed becase 0% TA employs were
skilled mex After absence from a job fo ny considerable oe
periof#a worker would hayg to learn the job again because -
of ednstant changes in eq! ipment and methods and this
ss of efficieficy (R. 1088 and
Moreover, Berry stated-that if the system were
in the eyent of lay-offs it would have to be fol- —
of rehirings and men who had been laid - »
{Aime would have to become readjusted
/. to jobs they formbrly held (R. 1205).
However, the rpason for the Board’s conclusion that a
x
_ rating (R. 1064-1066). The Company would not have given
him the promotion had it not deemed it permanent at thé
56 .
there should have been an exception in Kalamarie’s case
te the Company’s seniority policy is that Kalamarie would
_- not have takenthe promotion if. he had known he would .
_ thereby forfeit his seniority (R. 1548). Kalamarie desired
promotion to the job of arc welder and he could not have
the new job without the consequénces of a new ‘seniority
time it was granted (R. 968, 988, 989). Moreover, when
‘Kalamarie was: trapsferred to the job of arc welder the
have been impossible to keep that policy objective and.
efficiency at its maximum.
The Board in its brief has added another fact as a basis ~
for its conclusion that an exception to the policy should .
have been made for Kalamarie by relying on the testimony
Company was satisfying his request for a wage increase and ©
a promotion (R. 1064- 1066). No slackening of work for are
‘welders was anticipated (R. 1069). If the Company made
exceptions to the occupational-sefiiority policy it would
carry out its fundamental aim, which was to keep the bacon
of Kalamarie that he Was promised that he could step back
to his’ former occupation (B¢. brief, pp. 56-57). The
‘Board made no finding of such a promise in its decision
_and order. This alleged promise was denied by his fore- -
\Y
man—in fact his foreman told him he would lose his senior-
ity if he- took the promotion (R. 1066-1068), and where
evidence is controverted only the findings of the Board in -
‘its decision and order can be relied upon. ( See authority
cited on p. 29 of this brief.) -
Finally the Board found that Kalamarie was the only
one laid off who was hired in 1935 (R. 1548). No inference
_ean be drawn from this fact in -view of the Company’s
strict adherence to its lay-off policy. The fact that such
was the case at the time of the hearing does not mean that
e. others who had been hired previous to Kalamarie were not
laid off afterwards.
. - P 42 . .
a Pes PA aeeeae Sa es ree sae conte Orn ws ny _— . "i
ae my eS A Se) ea + ERRORS ER STATE VOR Pals a " ae s
te ie USM? a NR ae oa a ak Vee hc OO
i ; cH
. 57 : . ; a
By finding that the company discriminated against
. Kalamarie because of its failure to give him a job in |
_another occupation, the Board assumed managerial author-
ity over che Company’s business and insists that the Com-
' pany substitute the Board’s seniority policy for that which
was in use by. ‘the Company. The Act does not empower the
Board to arrogate such rights of management. National
Labor Relations Board v. Jones & Laughlin Steel vere
301 U. S. 1, 45, 46: :
“The Act does not sitectns with the normal exer-
. cise of the right of the employer to select its employees
or to discharge them; that the employer ‘may not,
under cover of that right, intimidate or coerce its em-
ployees with respect to their self-organization and rep-
resentation and. on the other hand, the Board is not
entitled to make its authority a pretext for interfer- ©
ence with the right of discharge when that right i is ex-
ercised for other reasons than such intimidation and
coercion. shin 7
Kalamarie was laid off because of the drastic reduction
_ of employment.in the foundry and in styet accordance
with the Company’s policy, which was a fairand reasorable
one (R. 624). The policy contended for by the Board is an
“ unlawful encroachment upon the right of management to
plan its production and direct its working forces in accord-
ancegvith a policy that suits its particular needs. No excep-
tion was made either for or against Kalamarie. All the
evidence shows that he was promoted at his own request to .
_ the.job of arc welder after he had joined: the Amalgamated
-and that the promotion was intended by both him and the
Company to be permanent.. Moreover, after his lay-off no .
one took his place. Accordingly, the Board erroneously
found and concluded that the Company’ violated sections
8 (1) and 8 (3) of the Act in respect of Kalamarie.
ATOR IRNI ces
, an ey
D. Salmons#Was Properly Discharged for Engaging in
Extraneous Activities on Company Time, Thereby Caus-
_ ing Inefficiency and. aie cearen of’ the nian sl 8
~ Personnel. .
The Trial Exarhiner 1 found that the Shideoee of Salmons a
was not discriminatory within the meaning of the Act, and .
that the complaint as to him should be dismissed (R.,
1481). The Board’s decision and order overruled the
Trial Examiner and found that Salmons was discharged
because of his membership in the Amalgamated and his
activitigs in its behalf (R., 1540).
By virtue of the Company’s. rehiring Salmons on Decem-
ber 21, 1936, as a result of mediation by Beman and Dis-
» Ser, agents: of. the Board, then associated with the 13th.
Regional Office, the Board found that Salmons was not en-
- titled to back pay and his continuous employment by the
Company obviated reinstatement. Accordingly, the Board’s
decision and order with reference to Salmons went merely
to the 8(1) charges. Since this entire incident took place
and was closed by reinstatement over: four months before
. the Independent even started to organize it has no pro-
bative value on the domination i Issue. "4
The court below held that there was no substantial evi-
denee. that Salmons was discriminatorily discharged.
We contend that Salmons’ discharge was due to his ac-
tivity on behalf of the Amalgamated during working hours,
. with the accompanying impairment of his efficiency and tbe
efficiency of other employees whom he frequently solicited
and engaged in conversations about unions.
Salmons had been in the maintenance department doing
electrical work for about 14 years prior to his discharge
(R.,.142). His duties took him to various parts of the
-plant (R., 170-171). He became interested in the Amalga-
mated early in September, 1936 (R., 152-153). ‘The Board .
. characterizes Salmons’ interest -in the Atudigamated as the
2
ma
sid BY APIS OIG ere ie sake sta een x en _—— .
RE EES EE ERLE REIN I RON Ra RRR a er
‘ ° ‘
{s
result of his dissatisfaction with the Plan, but Salmons was_
unable to state any important conditions of employment.
with which he was dissatisfied (R., 1537): He mentioned
_ specifically the occupational disease of silicosis which had —
been contracted in the past by some of the men, in the foun-
_dry, but he admitted that the Company had taken measur és
to prevent such diseases and had recompensed those who
had contracted it and nad given them easier ata (R., 186- -
187). :
. Salmons admitted union activities on Gesiemi time, and |
the record is replete with instances of such misconduct (R.,
196, 208). He passed out CIO application cards to the
men in the plant during working hours (R., 196, 208). He
circulated dround the plant during the course of his duties,
and if he obtained the. opportunity, would say saneiing to
- the-men about the union (R., 171). . |
' These admissions corroborate the testimony of Berry,
who had received information of Salmons’ activities hy
Company time from the supervisory force (R., 1130):
was told that Salmons passed out application sao on
Company time and property (R., 1129-30). pes
_ Berry testified that on og about Septentber 15, 1936,
while making his morning ropnds, he saw Salmons talking
to one ‘‘Long John,’’ a san@slinger operator. » About ten
minutes later he noticed that Salmons was still talking to
him. He asked Salmons if there was anything wrong, and
Salmons replied that there was something wrong with the
motor. Berry then asked the operator if the motor was .
running and he replied that it was running all right. Berry
then told Salmons. to go on his way and keep moving (R.,
.1131-1132). Later in the day, Berry asked the operator
what Salmons was doing and he was told that Salmons
was soliciting his membership in the CIO: and further that
. on several occasions the switch was pulled on the sand-: |
slinger and then Salmons would take the opportunity ta
ee
cS
eDiates eS MET a
Tae
ie
> fi
ah
Sank
oy
oe
ie
ne
a
|
e
ae
ie
me
rs
>
HG
| ort
dit -
ae
Laer "i
> .
i
rages
Tag
54
> age
baad
e é
+ coed .
ane te
es
<—e
2a
a a s
Sees wa age
| 60.
come over, “ostensibly to see what was wrong, but in reality
2 to. ror him to join the CIO* (Rf, 1132). . ,
“his | ident? as well as Salmons’ own admission that
he-was aware-of the gonsequences of his union activities
| on Company time, forced the conclusion that Salmons y was
e put on. notice (B., 1539, 153). rea
oe After ‘the sandslinger incident, es continued $i .. |
ceive information from supervisors regarding Salmons’
.
activities on' Company time (R.., 1132), ‘As ‘a consequence,
“he discharged Salmons.6n September 21, 1936 (R,, 153, -
' 1182). ‘The Board’s decision finds that Berry accused
Salmons of spreading union propaganda (R., 1538). -
Berry and Conroy, the production superintendent, festi- 3
" , fied that Salmons was told that he was discharged for using
_ more of the Company’s time. organizing than working (R.,
1122-1123, 1132). Their version is not inconsistent with
~ tle Board’s finding, that Salmons was discharged for _
eae ‘spreading union propaganda”, but adds the: Company’s
_. reason for the discharge, that is, Galanin engaged in these
vgs _ union activities on Company-time. 'The Board’s: accept-
* anee of Salmons’ version should have included his admis-
sion that he did spend Company time spreading union Prop-
aganda. However, the Trial Examiner stated in his inter-
mediate report with reference to Salmons (R., 1481) :.
“Tn view of the record on this case dnd Salmons’ . -
frank admiissions, the discharge was not discrimina-- -
. tory within thé meaning of the Act.”, 3
_ As we have pointed out, Salmons was celived on De-
eember. 21 after mediation by the Board, on the express un-
: , derstanding that he would refrain from union activities on
Company time. The Company desiring to show the nego-
: tiations which led-up to Salmons’ rehiring and the condi-
tions*upon which he was rehired sought subpoenas for Be-
man, Regional Director, and Disser, Field Investigator.
_’ The Trial Examiner denied the Company’s application ‘for.
es ee" the rascal made AY ‘offer of |
” 61 oS
| = which 5 was peteaad by the. Trial Examiner @: 1134
1135) but was accepted i in sud Board’s decision and order
(BR, 1520). | ‘
Berry testified and it is ides that he nego-
tiated with Beman arid Disser and agreed to take back
‘Salmons because he was told by these agents of the Board —
that there would be adverse newspaper publicity and high ~
litigation expenses unless Salmons was rehired (R., 1136-
1137).° In keeping with his agreement, Berry intervjewed
Salmons and offered him a job as an electrician, which was .
substantially the same as his old job (R., 1136-1137).
'. The Board found th ‘t was expressly understood that
: Salmons was not to enga_” ‘\ union activities on Company
time (B.,.155, 1538). Salmons testified that Berry told him ~
‘+ when he was rehired. that ‘‘there will be no more ranning )
y around the plant; there will be no more o ”? to -
_ which he. (Salmons) replied: “‘No, there will be nq organ-
_ izing in the plant but there will be lots onthe outside”
we, (R., 155). Significantly, Salmons also testified that ‘ ‘Berry .
did not caré what he (Salmons) did off Company tirae’”.
(R., 178). *
.The Board argues that Salmons’ efforts did. not inter-
fere with his work (Bd. brief, p. 48), but the inevitable
results of Salmons’ aforesaid activities were interference
with his ( Salmons’) work and the work of the men he
solifited. Accordingly, the. Company was justified in. its :
discharge of Salmons. ~ ‘
The true meaning and intent. of section: 8(1) of the Act |
is not to bestow upon the employee the unlimited right to
engage in activity without reference. to time or place. ‘The
- ’ employer may insist that such activity ‘be “—— in out-
’ ‘pide of working hours.
ag
ee
oe)
Mie ye ey of the Board ‘That the Hiring of Frank
ee Bee ee - Solintko’ as Conditioned on Peter Solinko’s. —
eee nt Has No, Basis in the Record.
: fare ee ee) The Board found that the Company conditioned its hiring
ye, ate ee eres ae of Frank ‘Solinko, the 8on of Peter Solinko, on Peter
nto . a Solinko’s joining the ‘Independent (R: 1550).. The findings _
of the Board are directed at the 8 (1) charge. There is no
- question of reinstatement or back pay involved. Since a |
blanket 8 (1) cease and desist order was enforced by the
. vouertte - court below, the only reason for discussing this incident is
<s ieee hs | . _ to:show that the Board’s finding in this respect is not sup-
meny. ee ‘ ported by substantial evidence and further that since this
$e incident took place after the Independent was organized
‘and recognized it had ro relevancy on whether the over-
whelming choice of the Independent was free or coerced.
The Board, as its brief points out, credited, the testimony. -
earns ig _ of the two Solinkos over a different version given by.
. : Stasky and over Kovatch’s denial of any participation in .
. Es 1 eas fs the incident (Bd. btief, p. 19).- An examination of their.
‘ fe ie eae testimony shows that the employment. of Frank was not !
| : . conditioned. on Pete’s joining the Independent. .
Frank, the son, said that the day before he went to work
he met his father (Pete) in the office. of Stasky.. When .
'.. asked if Stasky .said anything about the Amalgamated,
i “Frank said that Stasky asked how strong the C. I. 0. was
: ,...... but that he (Frank) ‘‘didn’t pay no attention’’ (R. 270).
of a Frank said his father left the office but that he stayed for
se le >: g ten minutes to fill out another application blank and that .
Mies 8 after Stasky looked it over Stasky sent him to the doctor
: | gee aed to be examined (R. 265). Frank followed the directions of @#
oe. . Stasky and was examined that day.and went to work the
ee oe next morning (R. 266). _ 7
ss ss ithe father’s story is that when he west t the ollee bis
Ceara C nchetell niet meus mamta vena ened acetal
.
.)
° :. (Stasky) did not care’ ‘if you pay dues—the . Company~
: i: os 63, ; a Se ahs a 7 2 2
Kovatch and. join the Independent while his son. sinyed See ud :
‘in the office. However,;Pete then relates that he didrst * : ;
seek out Kovatch and that when Kovatch came by and ee Fo :
solicited him he refused to join the Independent, and that he 5 ies) bs
did not join the Independent until the next day after his Bas a
son started to’ work. Pete said that he did not mow =~ eaeee
whether Frank was hired the day of- the interview or not
(R. 252) but ‘Frank said he’ was hired that day, that he
started to work the-next morning (R. 266).. Since Pete did - a
not join the Independent until the next day, the Board’s — eM we
. finding that Frank’s employment was conditioned on Pete’s - a.
_ joining the Independent has no basis in fact because Frank . a Ve
_was hired and startéd to work before Pete joined. Neither = = .
Frank nor. Pete: said anything about showing — an ~ c fae
Independent membership card. _. ‘ae Sag ae es
_ Furthermore, both the father and Rigo belonged to the Be ee
Amalgamated as well as the IndepenWent (R. 244, 267). a ie ;
‘ The father joined the Amalgamated first, while ‘the con.
_ joined thy Independent first (R. 246, 271). ’ G Hid 2
- Pete, the fathef, testified he could not read, and his testis re
mony. is confused '(R. 245). However, Pete quotes Stasky Ce
as telling him when he was laid off in January, 1938, that he “a ad
don’t have anything to do with it” and also that Stasky © i tl
said, ‘‘It’s your union and the Company has nothing to do . , |
with it” (B., 261). Frank . testified . that Stasky mever-—. ~~
talked to him about unions (R. 270). Thus, in the testi- |
oe
_. mony of the Solinkos alone, disregarding the nony of ier
§ and Kovatch, the Board’s finding i is orted ' oe.
Ba “There 15 Né Substantial videnoe of Repionage, . Hie are
The Board found that the’ Company utilized Couslind = JF ee
_for- the purpose of espionage and thereby interfered a oe CRIS PA na
Mi “ee nate of the ployeny guarialent Ne? eae of i sop eae eS NRA SO ca
2 ae a ag ohne,
: _ G ; ‘ ; ay ta i coy
; . : . : ue
. ‘ : vite e axed ‘id y 5
4 é ‘ . < J < ep sieg co. it . e. es
J - ° z P re t 4 « ‘‘ ’
” : D . % . ) fe
ee ae the Act (RB. 1587 37). The lower court sustained
© —,° 4: : the Board’s findings and order as to labor espionage. We
ease a . ¢ontend that there is no substantial evidence of any report- :
Paks is . ing on union activities and that the Board, in arriving at its
:— '-. findings, emplgyed the use of inferences in the presence of
: 4 | controverting stimpny. ( : *
— _. . Cousland was not ‘one of the 12 confidential operatives
Bs of the National Metal Trades Association who reported on’
. unio matters, but wasan old employee ‘with more than
sooty “20 years’ service4who reported to*the Association current ~
“A pens “. ‘ ° eonditions in the plant, excluding union activities (R. 660,
; sane 611, 113). ‘The Association relayed these. reports to ‘the
yr _. ~~. company (R.° 113, 588, 1157). The. Board’s,, witnesses
-.. Cousland and Abbott, and the.Company’s witness, Berry,
: Ul * © ail testified that Cousland reported on safety, sanitation, -
“ ie dissatisfaction with piecework’ rates, productign and tool;,
5 ema e 04 fe “ “ing methods, efficiency and time-study matters (R. 113,.
a | of 114,120, 1159, 584), yet thé Board, in opposition to this
one ge |. __ positive testimony; finds that’ Cousland reported on union
= activities. This finding is based solely upon an inference
of an alleged anti-union policy of the National Metal 3
s a Trades Association, the Company’s membership therejn
a ee the absénce of Cousland’s reports (R. 1536, 1537).
b.. -° Cousland was paid an average of $9. per month by the -
: | Association, which amount ‘was to cover his expenses. The —
| _ Assdciation then billed the Company for this sum. The
“.—--. books and records of the Agdeciation which were pro-
- duced by the Board during the course of the pene sub-—
e a ease stantiate, these’ payments. (R. 599). -
-- «4. * he Board found that there was a clear indication that
ee 2. AR the principal bond, betwéen the Cympany and the Associa-
ba - °° tion: was that of anti-union policy and that Cousland *
egg fo served ‘that policy (R. 1536). In order to sustain this
aes ‘, @ wie me pes a out Saat a none of the correspond
i ee ‘ 2 -¢
"ence between the Company and the Association relates ee,
time study or piecework dissatisfaction, investigation a,
which is supposed to. have been the purpose of the Com-
pany in hiring Cousland through the N. M. T. A. (B. en ae tare
1536). The Company did not hire Cousland through . ae Me
the N. M. T: A. Cousland ‘had been workiag for the iz ;
Company for more than: two years when ‘he formed his.
- association with the N. M. T. A. (BR. 112, 113). Thecorre- .
"spondence relating to time~stidy, piecework dissatisfac- 6 eel ©
tion, .safety; tooling and production methods was not ~ ee | |
produced because it’ was not kept by either the Companyor ts : ene:
the Association (R. 1157, 586). “The only correspondence * ; Sa rahe
rs remaining was jptroduced in evidence as Board’s Exhibits 8 -° - : 7
18 and 18a'(R. 1321-1336). Tt indicated that the Com- i a
pany was interested in. eniployer-employee relationships. me tea :
. The Board: has inferred that the Association was vice © 8 =. ee
-lently anti-union: arid then infers that the-principal bond é ee ie Retake
between the Company the Association was that of °° : SoF pice
anti-union policy from the fat_of correspondence between a.
-. the Association and the Company. However, the corre | ro
£
. spondence reveals no adoption by the ‘Company of any.
such policy of the Association and ‘6n the contrary indi- _
. Cates iepagann swith the Association’s policy hos
| 1381). _ ;
- The Board found that Cxesiand: was ‘foneed to resign aes ae
from the Amalgamated in May, 1937, when his role as an ‘ oe
undercover agent was made public-by the Senate Sub- .. _. |
_ committee on Civil Liberties (R. 1535-1536). The only = |.
' . evidence in the record as to the reason for Cousland ree =* =|" meee
signing is his statement that he dropped out of the Amal. oe Me i ey
“gamated because ‘‘I wanted to be decent enough with Mr. . = | °°’ °° >
- Sahnon to tell hini I had turned over ‘to the other one’ © - ~~ | - wor
- (RB. 122). The Board also found, that Cousland became : a tae oes
active as a committee member of the: Amalgamated (RB. ss ra see
1536) The record: shows that Cousland was never eotive “se | Bee
= Ret. 2
Ne. APE ENE: Rae ee ae } : : ; -
a . oo n pt ° : e *.
\ N . ics a : Sete -
. 2 : ia “pe 2 os . pee & Se
8 be % : es \ ae
) in the Amalgamated and the Board’ chief witness Salmons 2
‘ 1537). No reason wha
land's pay for writing the reports was. insignificant com-
&
. a . r 4 e
sh . 66 é A 7
00 testified (B. 145, 146).
Every\ piece of positive evidence establishes that Cous-
land’s re rts jon these innocuous matters ceased in Oe
tober, 1936 (BR. 121, 585). ‘In the face of this evidence the
Board finds that his relati nship to the company as a labor by
spy did not terminate ugtil exposure in March, 1937 (R.
i 2asOn fever is advanced by the Board to
substantiate this finding.. Theré- were no reports after
_. October, 1946. The reports previous to that time did not. 2 |
_Fefer to union activities. The finding has no basis in the
record.
. The Compe’ 8 diiinte | in the Association and the ps
manner in which Cousland reported are accepted by the -
Board in preference to the positive testimony of Abbott,
Couslatid: and Berry, which discloses the following uncon-
troverted facts: (1) Cousland’s reports stopped in Octo-“
ber, 1936, whereas organizational activities became ‘conse-
quential ia April, 1937; {2) the reparts were concerned |
with, dissatisfagtion of ‘workmen with piecework rates, --:
safety, sanitation, production and ‘tooling ‘methods (RB. 22,
. 23, 1159, 584); (3) Cousland was not placed in the same _
- Category in the books and records of the “Association.
_ as those men who had been doing undercover work on
labor and organizational matters (BR. 606, 607) ; (4) Cous-.
pared to the pay of those who were doing undercover work ©
on labor! and organizational matters (BR. 599, 612); (5) °
: Consland had been employed by the Company for 20 years,
_ was paid by the Company as a regular employee and had.: -
" been -reporting om these matters when there was no.
ne” “semblance of a labor si aaysaeseameaah ene the. jeer !
is" "plant.
~. Therefore, we reapéctfally. polunit that there is a “total :
ak of 2 aae of ied soto on union or , Srpamin sal x
| ee
> ne
. ig Book” Wag
Ch ee “%
ey 4 7) ‘
. : iy oy.
Bas ; EB
; a. :
\ @ a 2
; \ o ® s —
i a
3 a3 ao <
. a3 o> aa
Go ot.
2 = ) ey 2
é ba ¥ x ‘. ae
: ee Se Ss
ere Et ere |
>,
Henny KE; Sevranra
e
a”
Owen FarmwzaTHer,
‘Lez C. Sxaw, .
*
%
°
Attorneys for’ Link-Belt Company,
¥
120 South La Salle ‘Street, -
Chi
.
°
«
oo
7a
6
.
;
a
fo,
‘ a”
-
°
Oo
°
O
Ves
? .
os, e
nae The pertinent provisions of the National Labor Rela-
APPENDIX:
“ : ba . .
s 4 , ° . 4
~
"” WATTONAL LABOR RELATIONS ACT. - |
o
~ tions Act (49 Stat. 1449; 29 U.S. C., Supp. V, Sec. 151)
- -are as follows: rece. Oy
-
Findings and Policy. Section 1.: * * * It is here
declared to be the policy of the United States to elim-
inate tle causes of ceftain substantial obstructions to
tions of their employment or other mutual aid or pro- ;
tection.
: izati
Hag Soa to bargain collectively through representatives.
employer— > . Ne ,
(1) ‘Fo interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees
in the exercise of the rights guaranteed in on 7. -
(2) To dominate or interfere with the formation o1
administration of any labor. organization cr con-
~ tribute financial or other support. to te 82
- ‘such unfair labor practice, then the Board shall state
_ (3) By discrimination in regard to hire or tenure
of employment or any term or condition of employ- .
> ment to encourage or discourage membership in ‘any
labor organization: * * *. ~ | ES aoe ©
Szo. 10. sg erect
Site SOR.
fe) * 2 If upon all the testimony taken the |
‘Board ‘shall be of the opinion that any person
in the complaint has engaged in or is engaging in any
o
,
.
\\
aver
Dig
i" ae
i
ie) SBC 2a
} f
‘ at
a!
rt
;
yon es
gal
eo rss
be
rf
;
fi.
>
ae
.
.
wowace reeuen Desnansca Wal
.
on a AN ALI TN re meant om wer crs ter
.
af
we tf tire record i
~* Script o e€ entire record in-
s a .
its findings of fact and shall
- Séryed’on such person an order reanj
cease and desist
es
ment of employees with or ‘without.
effectuate the policies of this Act. i
(e) The Board. shall have pore to petition
trict, respectively, wherein ‘the
in question occurred or wherein
+ clreuit court of appéals of the
“ing the Court of Appeals of the District of Columbia),
3 catioe pier es ere oe meals
Fis from such w air labor practice, -
: and to take such affirmative action, including reinstate. -
to which appli. - :
cation ma be ‘made are in vacation, any district court
unfair labor practice
such person resides or
business, for the enfore ent of such order
and for sprrenriate _temporai ief or restraining ©
ce
the pleadings and te
rtify and file in ‘the court a tran. '
the proceeding, including
stimony upon which such orden,
was entered and the findings and order of _the Board.” >
* * “The findings of the
supported by evidence,
Board:As to the facts, if ~ |
Shall be conclusive. * * ¢ |
le jurisdiction of the court shall be exclusive and its
- Judgment and decree shall be final; except that. the
the Hels Phare
was made to the _
ed, and ‘by the Su:
tes upon: writ of. *
. Same shall be subject to review by
circuit court of —— if application
district court as
ereinabove provid
preme Court of. the’ United - Sta
certiorari or certifica
atid’ 240 of the Judicial Code,
tion as’ provided
title 28, sees. 346 and 347).
Af) <8 o% 3%’ he endings
facts, if supported, by evi ence, shall
_ be conclusive. Pays
of the Board as “to the “
as amended (U. S. C.,:
\;
in like manner hed
(we ABP
_ GHRONOLOGICAL EXTRACTS FROM DEBATES IN THE SENATE
_| | AND HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES AND COMMITTEE RE
> . NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS ACT TO COMPANY UNIONS.
= Report-of the Senate Committee‘on Education and Labor’
oni §. 2936, a bill-to create a National Industrial Relations.
Board, May 26, 1934.’ Senate Report No. 1184, 73rd Con-.
ges, Second Session, pp. 4, 5: kc eee
* “The first unfair labor practice restates the familiar |
é ee
- law already enacted by Congress in section 2 of the
Norris-La Guardia Act ¢47 Stat. 70; U.S. C., title 29,
~ gec. 102), in section 77 (p) and (q) of the 1933 amend-
ments to the Bankruptcy Act (47 Stat. 1481; U. 8. C.,4°
t. title 11, sec. 205 (p) and (q}), in section 7 (e). of the
act creating the office of Federal Coordinator of Trans-
_ portation (48 Stat. 214; U.S. C., title 49, sec. 257 (e)),
in section 2 of the Railway Labor Act of 1926 (44 Stat.
All, U.S. C., title 45, sec. 152) and in section 7 (a) of
_ the National Industrial Recovery, Act’ (48 Stat. 198;
4 U. 8. C., title 15; sec. 706 (a)). The language restrains:
employers from attempting by interference or coercion _ :
. to impair the exercise ‘by employees of rights. which
? are admitted everywhere to be the basis of industrial -
ho less. than political democracy. A .worker “mn the
field of industry, like a citizen in the field of govern-
ment, ought to be free to form or join organizatiorig;‘to
designate representatives, and to engage in concerted e
activities, And in Texas & New Orleans Railroad Co.
° «vy, Brotherhood of Railway Clerks (281 U. 8S. 548°
_ | (1930)) the Supreme Court of: the United States (in
"'-a decision froméwhich there was no dissent) upheld a -
_ Federal statute recognizing these rights. Indeed the |
_, Statute Lang by the Supreme Court was in terms —
‘broader than this bill, for it forbade an — ‘not.
- ‘merely to interfere with or coerce his employees, but
; even to ‘influence’ them. ~ ee see
pane, ak banlte 3, at * | oe ae
- The third t
air labor practice is one that the com-
mittee has considered with arent care. There was pre-
sented to the,committee much testimony from Govern- .
9
\ bi, Ven
oe: ‘ ; be e A .
Be | t, z ¥ t. . : x . es 79 ; . : :
r ment officers, workers, and represerttatives of labor to
organizations of their own emplo ictatir
’, | terms of their constitutions and ter feed by rete
: % to- let these labor a — their constitu.
me 2 amar 2 t OF tne employer, by dictating -
Se _ to the. organization officials the pte ati
- aA esi
\
‘*Yet these abuses do not seenir to the committee so .
Qu
Py
@©
2,
®
=
a
B
d
|
errnnentes
_ » “*0f one plant or one employer. Nothing in the bill pre-
&
\ ee
\ ieee : ‘
sd 7 ‘ ° °
lations with their workers or from rticipating in
group insurance, mutual welfare, pension syst and
other such activities. The only prohibition is against
the sham or dummy union-which is ‘dominated by the.
employer, which is supported by the loyer, which - r
- gannot change its rules or.regulations without his con- — a4
% ase d which cannot live excépt by the grace .of the HEPES
.- employer’s whims.’’. - ee pe Poe: eee | ie
. ~§estimony of Arno P. Mowitz,s repregenting Ful
_ Fashioned Hosiery Association, before the Senate Com-'__
mittee on Education and Labor, 74th Congress, First Ses--
gion. - Hearings on S. 1958, pp. 304-305: ° - ‘ « oh
. ‘<We believe that the provisions of this bill undoub :
he favor the kind of activities which we think will
‘lk 7. not be fair. We find that while you have eliminated
|. the word ‘influence’ from last year’s bill, you never- BS Bek
theless have significant wording here which leads-us to . HERD
i
erent ear opt feeeie sent one eye ne ban Ores
F > tee ae
wo <4 :
- go back to the old principle, and that is this: You. sa¥
we may not dominate and interfere andghose are terms
> which need and require definition. | , : ail a ie.
, . . ee. : . 2 - - @ , e * ° : : ‘ ti
_ “We do not know what that. nfeans except to limit - Bee ae
— ‘the employment of definitions of the words .- |) j-
. 0 ‘ F . t er
minate o. interfere’. -
;
‘The Chairman [Senator Walsh]: The purpose is ry ue
_. to limit those words as you have stated. - SES. | ok
_. “My, Mowitz:. We come then to this, that*our main — a oy
objection to the practical'phase of this billis that you = = = 5 |
tie the employers’ hands in'an attempt to arrive at - ieee
amicable. relation and working’ terms with his em- ee
. ployees. wa OM Ss ay
~ he Chairman: I do not think there is an i hee a
in this bill to prevent an employer when his employees, eae 4
‘the men and ‘women are aboat to organs from post- ira
aE: ‘ing a notice, or writing each an individual letter, or oe ae
® ~ Desonally stating to each that he thinks their best in- === | 4°
terest is Ang forma — Svanean Pip is violently 7 |
.. opposed -80 who is ‘ organize a on ae
‘le —s anion. I do not understand there is anything in this ee
.” ‘pill to:prevent an émployer from.doing that, and that .
‘is Fe struck out the word ‘influence’. t would ld Pee e
-’ ‘be influence, and nof interference. . Rees . se tre tta
“Senator Wagner: I think you are getting fright- <3
re
aoe ened with words.”’ z
eee 4 ag ae
-\
i
f
'
;
‘
ee
+]
te
he
ee Jatt g . F - ¥t foe ee
- _ estinony of John D. House, member, of the Federal —
ee ie | - ' Labor Union: of Goodyear Tire & Rubber Co. employees,
Re ‘ * before the Senate Committee on Education and Labor, 74th
* ae | |. * _Songress, First Session. Hearings on 8, 1958, pp. 587.
; ; S “Senator Walsh? When it comes to the be aga of
_ oercion or interference, that is a different thi g. We
ee eee are now talking about‘influence. In this bill originally,
: the word ‘influence’ was included, to prevent the em-
ee oe 3 ployer nang enemas, and.so forth, and we struck the _
el. _.. Word ‘tfluefice’ out, because we felt that an inte |
s
- a not be potas from piney — -
aes or or against any particular organization he |
PSUR ater ee detrimental 5 the welfare of his workingmen.
: i: . , Of course they would be left free to reject his advice
ae _. and views and not to be interfered with if they did not
Bahasa ~cheose to accept it. So that I understand. ‘you to say
: that all you have been doing:is in a peaceabjé way, try- -
| eee . ing to argue it and persuade these employees that your .
/ organization is better than the one they ve, for their’
* Bee -: OWn Sai ee a oe We We eee Fiahe
Page ~~ “Mr. House: That is true.’ The whole question
; eicee FE a or hinge 6n a definition of what. constitutes inter-.
| | BD Gee erence... ee - pai ep ia ceeds
Ba SS Be ios © "The Chairman: That is a difficult situation. Co-
er : eee ercion ‘is more easily definable, but interference. would
an | ae not be, bet I personally do not think that pomoeebly
ee ea irguing for or against a particular course of action, is
aes rr ce. Doyou? . thing a : ee
| a ee _ “*Mr. House:. Here is one thing where it mi
oom . interference. You must realize that a man marking on
Paes _ a@ job for a pees Mag an inherent fear of losing his
ei ’ job, so that when the employer takes a definite. stand
advises its employees that he favors certain plans,
their wills are corrupted because fear unless they
: _do as he wants them to do, they will lose their job, and.
sg dus a ON ~~ without the protection of a bona fide labor vhion, they
| og Bs . Rip ett s - are erless to protect themselves and are therefoge.
9S Ce f of losing their jobs if they ingur the dis-
eee 3 “sae ' pleasure or ill willofthe boss. . * . a
“The Chairman: this bill is enacted, if it is.
be discharged without an
. if he can prove that the
Sead Ese) JR 7 oo sus fa reason for his dismiseal is because he did not take the’
antine : : | advice of his employer and because he chose some other
| is Bs , ala Che ae
?
. @ ‘ . - ° S ;
. ° -
: . “ o ,
' H 7 :
. + :
F . ’ ‘ Sc
‘ - z iecesioninis
5 y - Md ”
- *, > > eae ° ‘ Ko . bila 3
; ® : ~ a i. ee |
j
. ~ Statement of Senator Wagner :
* “74th Congress, First Session, May 15, 1935. Congressiqnal —
Record, Vol. 79, pp. 7569-7570:
° €%,
1 pe y
organization different from. the my ong he . and that |
e
is one.of the arguments made for bill by its pro-
- ponents, that it seeks to remove the economic neoeere 7
- . that:thé employer possesses by reason of his ability to
discharge a man if their minds do not meet on a ques- —
tion of what form or character or organization. they
should join.”’ re : : ;
Report of the Senate Committee on Education ahd Labor
on §. 1958, May 2, 1935. Senate Report No.
Congress, First Session, p. 10: . a, & :
‘“‘This bill does nothing to outlaw free and inde-
pendent organizations of workers who by their. own:
_ choice limit their cooperative activities to.the | mits of |
one company.
_ The so-called. ‘company-union’ features of ‘the bill”
are fesigned to prevent, interference by employers wi A
organizations of their workers. that serve or
serve as coll
ference exists when _
: employers: actively particr
friming the constitution or bylaws of labor ofgani-:
tions; or: when, by provisions in thé constitution or. -
ws, changes in the structure of the organization
gannot be made without the consent of the’ employer.
: "It exists when they participate in the internal manage-
ment. or elections of & ponte Se, mayer or when they
. It is
t con-
stitute interférence, which-may rest upon subtle but
ure of meeti
“The Problem of the Company Union. \
s@ = * © 'The undue influence. which the employer
exerts over the suppos free agent
may take other forms. 7
domination of the formation of ‘he constitution
573, 74th:
to the Senaté on 8. 1958, e
5 As ee ce eae
may consist in er
or ty:
ac
4
ective bargaining agencies. Such ‘inter- ce :
lgwa of a labor organization. The essence of inter- .
16 7
: : J
“ference is that the workers’ organization, instead of
‘° being absolutely free and independent as an organic .~
oa ie is subjected in ‘some way. to the employer’s
———— rom —
%
Debate in the Senate 6n §. 1958, 74th Congress, First.
faa | oe Session, May 16, 1935. Congressional Record, Vol. 79, .
‘s ety Bs Dre oa et rege a
| oe ~ . “Mr, Borah: It Has\been stated over and over again —
by the critics of the bill*that the bill prohibits the com- -
pany union.’ There is nothing in: the bill which pre-.
bits a group.of men coming together and organizing
_.@ company union if they themselves, the workers, de-
eo sire a remy nad union. The intention is to prevent
waite _ ..- companies from me ti and septrouing a-union in
g making the organization: I want to see the working:
3 - ; _... + ‘taan free to join a union or to remain out of a union.
4 ‘I want ~vorking- men free to form any kind of a union
if it is freely, formed; that is, formed of the free will
e of the employees. This bill does not do what so many .
ft. ee me ce Ae er
| Report of the House Committee on Labor to the.Com- °
mittee of the Whole House on the State of the Union, June
-. °° 10,1935: House: Report No. 1147, 74th Congress, First
“Session, pp.18,19: . ty ve *
_-. Nothing in rine # segrenvnn the formation of a -
ws company union, if. rm is meant an organi- |
Bh zation. of: workers confined by their own volition to the
.. boundaries of a particular plant or employer. What
is intended to make such organization the free choice
-of the workers, and not a choice dictated by forms of -
: Gi paar: ‘ it ‘interference which are weighty precisely because of thé
Mere | - existenée of the employer-employee relationship. 2%
“Tf shovld be noted finally that the employer can be
said to ‘dominate’ the ‘formation or administration of ©
a labor organization’ where several of these forms of
op rn ne
“ | *- interference exist in combination, and he is able there-_.
Me | * : : ‘to corrupt or override completely the will of em- °
Debates in the House of Representatives pursuant to
_ HL Res. 263, resolving the House into a Committee of the
cs ‘ evrnd
e as : LD weak gees a ba
‘Whole House on the State of the Union for consideration
of S. 1958, June 19, 1935. Soon Record,. Vol. 79, '
p. 9687:
* ~My, Eckwall: Under this dill i is it-not a-fact that
. they can still have Company: unions not affiliated with -.
‘any other union?
Sees 1 Connery: As the employees want to have ‘a
___-»-eompany union in any plant and they vote for & com.
‘
— 99
pany union, seg can have i it. :
7 * oP
° ° °
oat
. <
“¢
o * .
*
o <<
b 3 ry -8 ’
4
3
a ee
e e ’ fad ry 3 2
a ve
2
: ° 2
’ . : “s o
‘
a
: . o
: ¢ %
- ‘ ° s
» j - »
> : -
> e
Q 3s ®
fi . ’
e . .
ba .
;
a =
‘ é % e
& eS ;
® t :
to
:
J P ?
s
.
?
£
3
‘ e e
° ,
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.