Petitioners Brief — Toledo Pressed Steel Co. v. Standard Parts, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1939
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Sussect Inbex.
| 7 PAGE
I Opinion of the Court below
‘Il Jurisdictton of this Court
ii Statement of the Case
a patent in Suit
% The conflicting decisions on ecm d of the patent
c. The prior art
d. History of the torch ican
The new evidence presented for the first: time in the
instant case 15
. Performance of the struct res 17
9. Petitioner's structure 21
\ Specification of Errors 6 7 23
| \ Sununary of argument * soe 1
I. Claims 2 and § are earegutive 29
II. The claims in suit are void for anticipation
a. Clainis 2 and 5 are anticipated by Malcov
Russian patent No. 1163 of the year
1868 35
* Claims 11 and 12 are anticipated by Rutz
patent No. 1. 101, 146 37
II. Nothing more than mechanical skill Was involved
in the association of a flame guard. similar to
the Rutz hood, with a torch body 9
IV. The patent in suit is ſor a double or dnalogous
use of the Rutz hood, and is void under the
patent statute; since the: Rutz hood can be em-
ployed without change for the purposes of the
patent in suit ee
V. If it he the holding of the Court that the Rutz
_ hood does not anticipate claims 11 and 12 then
petitioner's device does not infringe, since it is
using the Rutz hood in its device 59
VI. Infringement can be found only through a de-
} “gpa from the theory of the specification and
construing the claims to extend beyond the
invention: as construed * the Court below the
clainis are clearly void 61
VII. Conclusion 2 1 1 . 68
.
a eee
ete ara a oom a
e RR SEY Ra eee :
ma wWNN — —
oD American Fruit Growers, Inc. v. Brogdex Co., 283 U. S. 1.
Exnu ra.
: ra
Fic. 1, Photograph of flare with Rutz hood qualified in Nebrasia 9
Fi. 2, Enlarged photograph of Rutz hood used in qualification |)
Fic. 3. Graph showing efficiency curves of pe s flare with
and without flame guard | 0
Fic. 4, Circular of 0 8 first flare
Taare or C ABES Crren.
Altoona Publix Theatres v. Am. ‘Tri. Ergon Corp. 20 S
477 *
Aron v. Manhattan R. Co. 132 U. S. * . B.
Carbice Corp. v. Am. Patents de Co, 3 G.!
4120 35
Cariton v. Bokee, 17 Wall. 463 |
Concrete Appliances Co. v. Gomery, 2 U. S. 177
De Forest etc. Co. v. General Electric Co. 2 U. 8 664
Dunbar v. Meyers, 4 U. S. 199
Dwight & Lloyd etc. Co. v. Greena walt: 27 F 2d 23
Elizabeth v. American etc. Co., 97 U. S. 12
Germantown Trust Co., In re, 1 .
Grant v. Walter, 148 U. S. 847 53. 88. 5
Hobbs v. 180 U. S. 0 7
Ingersoll - ca * Worthington etc. Co., & F 24,320
Keyes v. Grant, 118 U. S. 2 a
Knay v. Morss, 180 U. S. 21 53 9
eee Ser Wome Cap *
anne Co. v. Munk, 77 F 24 261 =
~— Co. v. Radio Corp. V. S. „decided Jan ¥
‘tee! vo & Co. v. Stover Mfg. Co. 177 U. S. 485
McGrath Holding Corp. v. Anzell, $8 F 2 205
Miller v. Foree, 116 U. S. 2
National etc. Co. v. Boston etc. Co. 186 U. S. 502
New York etc. Co. v. Chain Bek Co., 254 U. S. 32 4
Paramount: Publix Corp. v. Am. Tri- Ergon Corp. 2 sot *
Peters v. Active Mig. Co. 129 U. S 530. -
iii
Nets Creager, 155 U. S. 597 1 5
net; Kennedy etc. Co. v. Concrete ete. Co. 2R2 U. S. 175 „
Rancan, In re, 1911 C. D. 267, 36 App. D. C. 95 32
Pierre v. Redpatch etc. Co., 87 F 2d 766 64
sAanher-Schroth Co. v. Cleveland Trust Co., 305 U. S. de-
„ Ike. Shore etc. Co., 121 U. 8. 617
(wandard: Parts, Inc. v. Toledo Pressed Steel Co., 93 F 2d 336 2.3
romberg Motor Devices Co. v. Zenith Carburetor Co., 73 F 2d
A 33
“extle Machine Works, ‘Ine. v. Hirsch etc, 87 F 2d 702. Aff d
edo Pressed Steel Co. v. Montgomery Ward Co., Inc., 99
F 2d 8006: : Sees 1,5
| Vandenburgh v. Truscon 8286 Co. 261. v. 8. 6 hates „
Westinghouse etc. Co. v . Wagner eic. Co., 225 U. S. 004 33. 35
ee. General Fire Ext. Co., 8 F 2d 682 58, 60
_ aded Nov. 7. 1938 : oe ae ca 62
63
U. S. 4 | 52
Thompson Spot Welder Co. v. Ford Motor Co., 265 U. 8. 445 45, 48
“Otzober woe A. D. 1938 |
bi. 603
MONTGOMERY WARD & COMPANY, INC., an Munole corporation,
Petitioner,
et.
2 rolitoo PRESSED STEEL COMPANY, an Ohio corporation,
Respondent.
-
BRIEF FOR PETITIONER.
. a
OPINION OF THE COURT BELOW.
The opinion of the United States Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Second Circuit holding valid and infringed.
patent 30 Withrow et al. No. 1,732,708, was rendered No-
rember 7, 1938 (R. 447). A petition for rehearing was de-
ued December 5, 1938 (R. 471). The opinion is n
in 99 é * 806. /
JURISDICTION OF THIS COURT.
ü The jurisdiction of this Court is based on Section
0 of the Judicial Code as amended by the Act of Feb-
raary.13, 1926, 28 U. S. C. A. Sec. 347. The jurisdiction of
the District Court arose > through. a suit brought under the
patent statute.
_ decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Cir.
2
—
2. The original date of the judgment below was Noreen
ber 7, 1938 (R. 447). A petition for rehearing (R. 455-470)
was filed November 19, 1938, within the time provided ts
the rule of the Circuit Court of Appeals, and rehearing wa:
denied December 5, 1938 (R. 471); a petition for a writ of
certiorari was filed January 19, 1939 and ‘certiorari was
allowed February 6. 1939. There is a conflict in decision
between the Second Circuit in the decision below and th
mage Standard Parts, Inc. v. The Toledo Pressed Sten
„ 93. F (2nd) 336, which aor the patent in suit void for
ic of invention. 7
II. .
STATEMENT OF THE CASE.
2. The Patent in Suit.
Withrow and Close, No. 1,772,708, the patent in suit, per
ports to cover a burner. Claims 2, 5, 11 and. 12 are sued 9
Tue device described in the claims and exemplified ©
_ respondent's. commercial structures, comprises a draw
sheet metal torch body normally sized to contain somethirt
more than a quart of kerosene, having an pening at tb
top for a wick, the wick being usually from five- eighths te
three-quarters of an inch in diameter, a wick tube sar
reznding said wick, and a flame guard positioned op th
top base of the torch body having laterally-disposed por
for the exit of flame, and smaller luterally- disposed ports
dezow the flame ports for the inlet of air for combustice
Its principal use is 28 4 highway warning signal. \
Fer. a clear understanding of the issues innolved. th
claims must be divided into two classes; 2 and 5 cover the
combination of 6 burner and a torch *. and 11 and *
are directed to the burner alone.
a
3 2 3 °
01 the © fst’ group, claim 2 is typical and specifies: . 0
(0 /a torch body having an opening for a wick, and
(>) a flame guard for said wick, mounted on the
outside of said torch body, said guard including |
(1) acap provided with an imperforate top wall
(2) lateral flame opening? — to emit
luminescent flame, and
(3) air ports.
Claim 11, which is typical of the second class, covers:
A burner comprising
(a) A wick holder having
(i) a portion in contact with the wick apd
(2) a supporting and heat- receiving flange, and
(% means enclosing a space above said flange and
surrounding the wick, except for provision for |
(1) lateral exit of flame and
(2) restrieted entrance of air for combustion.
\
1 — on the Validity of the Patent.
‘Respondent first started infringement proceedings in the
District Court at Toledo against Standard Parts, Inc., and
Huebner Supply Company, distributors of what will be re-
ferred to for convenience as the Bolser and Kari-Keen
flares, respectively, the references being to the names of
the manufacturers. The patent was held valid and jnfring-
A in an unreported opinion by the late Judge Hahn, filed in
June, 1935. This decision was reversed by the Sixth Cir-
‘ported in 93 F (2nd) 336.
Of the patent, Judge Simons said in his opinion:
Stripped of variations in nomenclature, and the
ingeniously differentiated phrases of counsel in setting
ut in an opinion by Judge Simons, without dissent, re-
4
forth the claims, the invention is for a burner with,
metal guard ta protect the flame from air currents ud
rain. The art is full of illustration and description of
metal guards for burners. * * There is sufficient sa
gestion in a burner guard when it is found in c
familiar contrivance to point the way to its use in 2
other °° °..
There is hove no sabotantial evidence of effort ges
eral 40 the industry to solve-a problem which long &
fied it. The proof is limited to experiments of th
patentees, and so far as it goes, serves to demonstra
lack of awareness of the teachings of the art rather
than the inherent difficulties of the problem itself. The
chose the long road to solution, and the patent las
does not reward mere persistence, unassociated wit
; original creative effort.“
Certiorari was granted on , November.21, 1938 to revies
this decision, in Nos. 166 and 167, October Term, 1938, tr.
reason of the-decision in the instant case on November’
1938, sustaining the validity of the patent in suit.
A few days before the rendition of the decisisn. in the
Sixth Circuit, the bill of complaint was. filed against pet
- tioner in the instant case in the United States Disin¢
Court for the Eastern District of New York. For conver
_ ience, the accused device in the instant case will be referred
to as the Anthes structure, after Anthes Force Oiler Co
pany,. the manufacturer. After a hearing, Judge Moe
witz of that Court fled an opinion, (R. 424-430), findirs
that the claims in suit were void for want of novelt.
that torch bodies and metal guards tor the protection | a
flames were well-known long prior to the filing of the apr’
cation for the patent in suit; that the claims in suit ver,
aggregative; that the claims in suit involved only w-
5
chanical skill; that the defendant (petitioner) was using a
prior art structure, and that such prior art structure could
be used without change for the pyrposes of the patent in
a | 5 |
The Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit rd
versed, in an opinion by Judge Manton, Judge Swan con-
curring, and Judge Chase dissenting without 2
_ported i in 99 F (2nd) 806. ;
In its opinion, the Cireuit Court zave the following rea-
sons for differentiating its decision from that of the Sixth
C\reuit :
This record, however, contains evidence absent in
the Standard Parts case, showing that the ‘art was in
search for this accomplishment: that others worked
unsuccessfully to solve the problem. The proof
here, not found in the Standard Parts case, showed
widely-separate, unsuccessful attempts to provide
some means which would prevent the flame from being
extinguished. Unsuccessful efforts were made over a
wos period by men. skilled in the art of burners. (R.
449.) ° * © Unauccessful attempts have been made by
competitors who had long been in the business of
manufacturing and selling open flame torches’’ (R.
200.
“The 3 does not disclose or suggest the
combination of result here obtained (R. 451)
the device here used as a warning signal—the karner
—must be considered as an entirety, that is, the oil
container, the wick, the wick tube and the p.
torch bodies and flame xuards were old, they
have never been used together to perform the function
or produce the: results of the device of the patent in
suit. If they were ever combined for any purpose, it
| a } K x 6 of g
was not to protect the flame at its source 80 as to pre
vide a small, protected chamber in which some part of
the flame would continue to burn regardiess of ou.
side weather conditions, with the greater and visibb’
part of the flame burning as a warning signal outside
the guard. This combination and use amounted to n
ö vention“ (R.
c. The rler att.
All of the patents relied on by the 6 ireuit Court a Ap.
peals. for the Sixth Cire uit were in evidence in the instar:
Fund, but were not specifically relied on by petitioner
These patents are the. following: | .
pe ne. eee No. 147,496 R. 325
BE civics 3 No. 193.786 R. 351
ß „ No. 270,57 k. 447
/ ͤ — 8 No. 453,335. R. 355
— — n
The only patent cited by. the Patent Office in prosecutict
of the patent in suit was Hathaway. No. 147,406, upes
which claim 2, as originally drafted, was rejected. (Se
Record in Nos. 166, 167, b. 99). None of the patents refer
red to by petitioner were before the Patent Office.
Petitioner below relied upon Russian patent to- Malco
No. 1163 of the year 1868 (R. 325) asx an anticipation
claims 2 and 5; on the burner structure of Rutz patent X=
1,101,146 (R. 377) as an anticipation of claims 11 and .
In addition to the Rutz patent, petitioner relied on wid
spread public use of the Rutz structure as an anticipatior
of claims Fi and 12. Wall, No.’228, 497 (R. 343) wa. refer
red to es a state-of-the-art patent showing the combina!
of a torch body and a flame guard as early as 1.
The Maleov patent is for a chinmeyless et bare.
and shows the combination. of a torch body, a u. „ A
sick tube, and a metal — enclosing the end of the wick.
The patent drawing sholws the structure with flames eman-
zune from the sides of the guard. The top of the guard is
yerforated with tiny holes. Petitioner’ s expert, Dr. Matt-
new Luckiesh', Director of Lighting Research for the Gener-
al Electrie Company, however, testified that the Malcov
top. was ‘‘imperforate,’’-in the sense that it offered pro-
terion from rain, because the surface tension of the rain
drops prevented their going through the tiny holes in the — .
top (R. 80, ff. 238-239; R. 100, f. 299).
The Rutz patent covers a flash igniter for a stove, and
the port ion of. it relied on is the cylindrical hood 8 (Fig. 1
of drawings, R. 378) having air inlet ports 7 horizontally .
disposed in the bottom flange of the hood and flame oe
“ laterally disposed i in the side walls thereof.
A device designed in acoordance with the Rutz patent
rent into commercial use and was widely sold by the Mil- |
raukee Gas Specialty Company of Milwaukee, Wisconsin.
The record shows. that A. O. Rutz, inventor of the Rutz
patent’ No. 1,101 146, designed the hood 8 to protect the
fame of the igniter from precipitated liquids, and lateral
currents of air, and that it was tested from time to time
io determine its resistance to such elements * 393, f.
17). *
Ot Rutz, petitioner's expert, Dr. Land ien testified that es
if the hood 8 were transferred to a torch body, „All the
principles of operation remain the same. (R. 127. f. 379,
RDQ 39).
As a result of the so-called flare laws, the majority of
the states have established administrational qualifications
for the use of torches on the highways, and some of the
Sates have designated laboratories for the purpose’ of
‘Fer De. Lackiesh’s record, see fA Ry» ly te
— 5 B 1576: he has had 27 years ex during which time he has
work on kerosene burners” (R. *
testing flares submitted ee the es of state higher
commissions,
It is claimed by respondent that no prior art toreh wil
pass the tests which have been promulgated. | Petitioner
procured three flash igniter guards embodying the hood é
of Me Rutz patent, from the Milwaukee Gas Speciabr
Company, mounted them suitably on commercial tore
bodies, and submitted them to the: Nebraska Departmen:
of Roads and Irrigation for qualification. They wer
promptly qualified (KR. 413-423). Photographs of the «tre
_ tures submitted are shown on pages 414 and 416 of th
record and are reproduced as Figures 1 and 2 on pages $
and 11 hereof. Respondent's witness on the point agreed |
that Nebraska was one of the most difficult states in whic
to obtain a qualification (n. 52. f. 156).
a History of the Torch Industry
pen fame torches, comprising a fuel reservoir, wict
tube and wick, have hen used for numerous purposes, pet
haps beyond the memory of man. The first use as warning
signals disclosed by the record is that of the Detroit Stree
Railway, which: began using a cast iron, three-wick 5a
torch about 1913. It ordered its torches as it required then.
from foundries, accepting the lowest. bid for the work
From this, it is a rational inference that at that time ther
was no organized manufacture of the articles.
So far as the present record: discloses, the first pers
to manufacture a stampe d. cheet steel pot torch for rener
distribution was one Mc(loskey, of Toledo, Ohio, „
gaged in this activity perhaps as early as 1925. To rote?
his structure from turning over, he weighted the bottom.
for which advance in the art he was awarded patent No
1,616,301. In 1926, respondent was manufacturing 35
torches for McCloskey, under contract, and in the latter
part of that year. réepondent 8 decided to engage
oat its first torch, weighted ‘at the bottom and similar to
McCioskey’s torch. McCloskey brought suit against re-
spondent for infri ‘er and his patent was held invalid
for anticipation by the Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Sixth Circuit in McCloskey v. The Toledo Pressed Steel Co.,
F (2nd) 12. N %
Respondent adv ertised the v ‘irtues of its open flame torch
\
as: \
“The Toledo torch will burn all 1 A.
any time, in any kind of weather. It is an all-purpose:
danger signal’’ (R. 263) 7. .
It is nevertheless said that respondent received many com-
plaints that its torch would be extinguished under severe
weather conditions, and patentees, in 1928, commenced n
seties of experiments to improve the device: ;
Their first experiments ‘consisted in making the top of
the wick tube flush with the top base of the torch body, and
projecting the wick tube into the interior of the fuel res-
weir, an example of the structure being shown in the
tireular reproduced on page 289 of the record. The theory
this structure was that the wick would corduct. heat
inside of the torch body, raising the temperature of the fuel
sad reducing the tendency to blow out. The device was
brought out in July, 1928, and sold during the balance of
that year.
| Patentee, Withrow, testified that the improvement did
wt answer all the problems, and further experiments were
made, drawings thereof being reproduced on pages 271 to
Mi of the record. The experimenters first placed a series
a plates around the sides of the wick, then (R. 275) com-
Netely housed the flame with a dome-shaped cap having
—
7e 4 page 41 hereof.
75
—
S
Ns
in the enterprise on its own behalf, at which time it brought
<=
14
ports in both the top and sides. Various types of cap
were tried, all having imperforate tops and side fam .
ports, the final result being shown on record page 287. Tk
application for patent was filed December 26, 1928, and the
torches were first offered for sale in January of 1929. The
- structure with the cap was so designed that caps could b
bold separately to previous. purchasers | of respondent's
open flame torch, and be er attached to. such tor
(R. 25. f. 74).
From 1929 to 1933, torches of the tree here involved wer
used solely as warning signals, about construction wort
In the late spring of 1933, the State of Iowa first passe
a statute. requiring trucks using the highways to carn
three torches as warning signals, and requiring the drivers
to light and place the torches about the truck wheneve
the truck stopped on the highways at night. In June d
1933,. Anthes Force Oiler Company of Fort Madison, low.
whose torch is the accused devite in the instant suit, begs
to manufacture à torch of the type shown on page 253 of
the record as licensees of respondent. In July of 1934, be
cause this type of torch with the burner positioned direct!
on the torch body, was too hot for the operator to hand
in practical operation (R. 133, f. 397), the Anthes (ompatr
changed to the present style, shown on page 297 of the
record, in which the fame guard is elevated on the wie
tube and the air inlet ports are positioned in a herizonita
flange, below the flame. This obviated the objection (x
133, f. 398).
Prior to 1933, torches 1 as such were sold ay to the com.
tracting industry engaged in street repair and road build
ing, where warning signals were necessary for unprotected
excavations, After the passage of the Iowa statute, ‘>
devices used on tracks began to be known as ‘‘flares”
Shortly after Iowa first passed a so-called flare law, a b
stantial proportion of the other states passed similar lav.
requiring trucks using the highways to carry flares of i
15
type here involved, which resulted in a . substantial
demand for flares.
‘A tabulation of respondent's “sales: of torches or flares
{rom the beginning through the year 1987 follows:
Units Sold. fe Type Sold.
1,121 omen FT
26,630 . | Ex. 10
39,000 (est. ) 5 Ex. 10, 13
46.624 1 9 .
33.422 ae
52889. Ex. 17
rr. . 17
76.919 4s) ne.
56,401 Ex. 17, 19
134.881 Ex. 17, 19
oe 186,479 Ex. 17, 19
129,739 i Ex. 17,19
* SH months for ue of Exhibit unde plaintiff
only the fgure of 19609 of Exh 10 down to. Jl 18. 1928, but chere
a er Se Se ay ee tales when Exhibit 13 was
4 ‘The New Evidence Presented forthe First Time in the
| - Instant Oase.
4 v peinted out in section b,“ supra, the Court below |
found evidence in-the record of unsuccessful attempts by
“competitors who have long been in the business of manu-
facturing and selling open flame torches’’ to solve the ö
problem said to have been solved by the patent. in suit.
The attempts so characterized consisted of two instances
valy, one effort during the period from 1922 to 1924 by a
Superintendent of Way and Structures’ of the Detroit
Street Railways, who was not a torch manufacturer nor a
wan skilled in the art of burners. He made only one at-
tempt to solve the problem, and that by placing a flat.shield —
wer the top of a pot torch having three wicks. The ex-
periment was abandoned, according to the witness who tes-
4.
*
16
tified, n the pins supporting the flat top
„Would be bent and sometimes broken * and v.
still had trouble with torches being extinguished in
drenching rain or a very high wind, and 80 we cop.
eluded that those happenings were so infrequent tha“
we could just as well get along without the cap, an
ve discontinued the use.“ (R. 59, f. 176.)
This concern still uses the open flame torch (R. 61, !
a :
The other attempt was that of Currie, the Works Mas
ager of the R. E. Dietz Company, a concern which for mar;
years_was a large manufacturer of lanterns. In 1928, whet
the experiments ‘were made, the Dietz Company WAS nots
competitor of respondent, and had never been engaged
manufacturing and selling open flame torches. The Diet:
Company found that its lantern business was sufferings
from the new torch industry (R. 168, f. 502), which, as v.
pointed out supra, apparently originated wie one Me
_ Closkey, in Toledo in 1925 or 1926.
In 1928, about a year after the Toledo torch. first came
on the market, Currie, the Works Manager of the Diet
Company, began to experiment with it, to see whether th
claims for infallibility, quoted supra, were well founded:
and discovered that it would not stand up in ‘‘a very heart
rain. There was nothing to protect: it at all.“ (R. 168!
3804.) During his experiments, Currie produced three d-
vices, one of them being Exhibit 37, which would operat
with a much lower wick and withstand a very high wind
(R. 171, f. 511. ) Currie further testified :
tried it out in the rain and it went out. It occu:
red to me that I might possibly put a flat shield ovet
the top so that the rain would not get in the center of -
the wick, that is, that thought must have been in m7
mind, but I just didn’t do it.“ (R. 175, f. 523.)
Currie claimed to have designed more than the thre
structures which he produced in Court, but the e
of the others was not accounted for.
*
/
„
17
No other evidence of widely-separate, unsuccessful at-
tempts than that here referred fo was offered. No evidence
of “unsuccessful attempt by competitors who have
jong been in the business of manufacturing and selling open
tame torches”? (referred to in the opinion of the Court
below, [B..450]) can be found i in the record. :
f. Performance of the Structures.
The ‘recitals of the specification of, the patent in suit
tate as an object: A simple and efficient attachment
for i increasing the efficiency”’ of such torches (p. 1, II. 8.10).
It is further stated (II. 93-98) : : ,
Alt has been fouid that with the above described
construction and arrangement, the oil consumption is
materially decreased. It is also found that the amount
ol wick used is likewise decreased.
Respondent seeks to substantiate its claims by evidence
of some comparative tests conducted by the patentees out-
of doors, conditions being uncontrolled, between one of its
ratly torches and a~torch containing the patent flame
mard. Samples of the types which respondent tested are
shown in the photograph on page 261: of the record. torch |
B being tested against torch C. The result of these tests
“was that the patented torch used 2.06 ounces of oil per
hour as against 4.95 ounces for the open flame torch. .
Of tests of this type, petitioner’ expert, Dr. Luckiesh,
‘eatiied (R: 83, f. 247):
“The only way you can arrive ai a fevbiminital-1 is
control of all variables except one. The only way you
_@an get basic, foundational information on the effect
‘of a cap on efficiency is to test it on and off of a given
device. That is the research approach. There is no
other way.“
He was further of the opinion that a comparison of torch
8. toreh C was not a * test of * (R. 95,
Petitioner ran a series of tests in the Engineering Lab -
oratories of the University of lowa under controlled condi.
tions, supervised by Professor Huber O. Croft, head of the
Department of Mechanical Engineering in that institution.
The results of these tests are as follow:
Ae Vel td 1 uh ‘Four Gword * yh hed — Geert
— 037 09
1.75 me oem 135
4.75 „5 25 193
85 \: 30 239
660% „ 429
TTT. | aes
As to wick consumption, Professor Croft testified :
Alt was impossible to detect any consumption in th
wick by measurement with a rule. The neare#
1,120 of an inch could be estimated. oo * 14.
. 450.)
The test for wick consumption covered a six-hour burning
| period. Z | seas
As to the proposition that the ‘addition. a the flame
guard increased the efficiency of the stracture, Professor
Croft tested devices with and without a flame guard. und“
‘still air conditions and velocities of 1.75, 4.5, 8.5, 14 and 2
miles per hour, each test being run for an hour, takin
observations of both tuel consumption and illumination
Using the term ‘‘efficiency.’’ as it is defined in the !ightix
‘art, light output per unit of energy. input {R. 75, {. 23).
Professor Croft determined that under all circums!a%*
where the open flame torch weald burn, it was more &
eiont than the patented torch, a graphic portrayal! of th‘
dein shown in Fig. 35 on page 399 of the record, repre
Adueed on page 19 hereof, as Fig. 3. Respondent offered »
evidence to substantiate its claims to efficiency, ——
—
ls Ths — — < 8 . * *
CCC ttl LORE LT ROP) S gs
PRN es SFE ely Sapa > N et > ; 3 ‘ _ „ ‘
* . .
——
— ä—ä—Üũ̃ — or oe
0
52 ; on
; : |
. ‘ ‘
‘ : 5 >
i.
—_
. U
8 .
1
—— —— — —— —
ee 7
‘
. . 0
— a ee — — —
4 ‘
5 *
sd 5
—
re
—
—
7 .
. tis
anew 2 2
R *
5 *
4
Fig. 5
Fig. 3.
„
—
0
*
2 — ä — — —
‘ 1 8
* * *.
2 ‘
„„
4 a =e nae *
1 8
*
*
*
*
*
4
ä — a sa
„
21
“While Judge Simons, speaking for the Sixth Circuit,
bound that the invention of the patent in exit is nothing
more than „for a burner with a metal guard to protect
the fame from air currents and rain.“ Judge Manton
found that patentees had developed ‘‘a ‘small protected
chamber in Which some part of the flame would continue to
barn regardless of outside weather conditions” (R. 453).
Mt ll, protected chamber. respondent's
“expert. testified (R 219) : | |
“XQ 127. The art is re plete- ith examples of air
chambers for mixing the air with fuel vapors: they
have been known ever since Argand first pointed out
their: pertinency, have they not? A. Yes, most a bure-
ere have something of that sort.
“XQ 128. So there is nothing new in such a .
ber to mix the oxygen and the vapors from the ts
sene! A. That particular fact is well known, ves.
g. Petitioner's Structure.
The alleged infringing device. differs in structural detail
from the device shown in the patent in suit, and from the
rommercial embodiment thereof manufactured by respond-
eat. | 5
‘The flame sit in petitioner’s structare is spaced above
the top base of the torch body and has its air inlet ports
berizontally positioned in the supporting flange for the
fame guard, in contrast with the laterally-positioned air
inlet ports in the side walls of the patented device.
Tue District, Nourt found that petitioner: 5
“Is using a flame guard * * ° similar to the flame
guard manufactured by the Milwaukee Gas Specialty
Company shown in defendant’s Exhibit L, except as to
the size of the flame ports, and the Court finds that tjñe
4 —
difference in size between the flame ports of ( petition.
er’s) structure and of the Rutz flame guard is imma
terial.“ (R. 430, f. 18.) 7
Professor Croft's tests of. petitioner’ + 2 respondent's
devices showed that te operated differently, the per
formance curves of petitioner’s stracture being shown ix
Pig. 11 (R. 395) and of the — in Fig. x
After the Croft tests were . 8 made
dome comparative tests of the two structures under cond:
tions different from those used by Professor Croft. Oe:
of the patentees, who made the tests, stated:
The performance results which I obtained bet weer
the Anthes and the Toledo were opposite to each othe:
but of similar quality, in the —— direction.” R
191, f. 572.) 7
This was corroborated by the . who state |
that the performance of the two torches was quite th
opposite. (R. 183, f. 548.) |
Professor Croft testified that in his epinion the reasons
for the difference in performance could be accounted for
dy the differences in construction :
ee “That is, in the Toledo flare, the wick and fan-
guard are adjacent to the top of the body of the far
and the air ports are in the sides of the flame anat.
while in the Anthes flare the wick and receptacle ar
elevated above the body of the top of the flare and
air ports are at the bottom of the flame i recep |
tacle. (R. 155, f. 464.)
One of the elements of the patent structure, pointed os!
| in lines 78 to 89 on page 1 of the specification, is as follows
Air inlet openings 10 being above the lower eds
of the cap leaves a space within the cap and above th
2 5
flange of the wick holder for comparatively quiescent
air. This quiescent layer of air in contact with the
wick holder and the restriction of the inlet ports to
_., admit to the wick and holder only such air as ib need.
ed for combustion aids in maintaining the heat of the
tinguishing the flame by high winds.
| of petitioner’s device, its expert. testified that under any
conditions of its operation, the feature of ‘a’ layer of |
quiescent aif could not exist. (R. 91, f. 271.)
| ‘SPECIFICATION OF ERRORS.
1. The Court below erred in holding that the device of
the patent in suit must be considered as an entirety, or
that it was unitary erbe, patented as an entirety. pug
2. The Court below erred in not finding that claims 2
ind 5 of the patent in suit were aggregative, and in not
applying thereto the doctrine of Lincoln Engineering. Co.
b. Stewart- Warner Corp., 303 U. S. 545. |
. The Court below erred in not finding that’ ‘claims 2
and 5 of the patent in suit were anticipated by Russian
patent to Malcov, No. 1163 of the year 1868.
4 ‘The Court below erred in not finding 8 11 and
A were anticipated by patent to. Rutz No. 1,101,146.
5. The Court below erred in finding that the prior art |
.. not t suggest the combination of the patent in suit.
| ( The Court below erred in finding as a ‘act:
„That others worked unsuccessfully to solve the
problem. * © * Unsuccessful efforts wer made over a
* — by men skilled in the art of ®urners. ett
|
wick -holder and wick. This militates against ex-
Unsuccessful attempts had been made by competiton
who had long been in the business of: manufacturing
and selling open fame torthies.° °°"
7. The Court below dered i in finding as a matter of lay
_ that the history of the art demonstrated that the accom
plishment of the patent in suit was not easy or apparent,
nor merely the work-of one skilled in the art:
8. "The Court below erred in not finding that nothing
more than mechanical skill was involved in the associktior
of a flame guard with a torch body.
9. The Court below erred in finding that the dome
shaped cap of the patent in suit was more than a flame
guard. :
10. ‘The Court below erred i in not finding that the claim:
in suit were void as being for a double or analogous ox.
for the hood of the Rutz patent No. 1,101,146, or that the
claims were invalid because the Rutz hood could be use
without chang» for the purposes of the patent in suit.
11. The Court below erred when, after finding that the
hood of the Rutz structure-did not anticipate the claim
of the patent in suit, in holding that the defendant r
fringed; since the defendant was found to be using th
Ruts. structure, the Court should have applied the maxim
That which does not anticipate cannot inf ringe.
12. The Court below erred in departing from the theo”
of operation expressed in the patent specification, where? _
the patentees had limited themselves to the type of «trv |
ture in which lateral air inlet ports are positioned t.
side walls of the flame guard so that a layer of compara
tively quiescent air may be maintained, disclosed | in the
‘specification and drawings, to find infringement on the part
ofthe petitioner.”
25
SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT.
. 1
Claims 2 and 5 are aggregative. |
Lincoln Engince ring Co. v. Stewart-Warner Corp., 5
303 U. S. 545, 549.550;
— Holding Corp. v. Anzell, 2nd Cireuit 58
F (2nd) 205; |
In re Ratican, 1911 C. D. 267, 36 App. D. C. 9
Westinghouse Electric & Mfg. Co.-v. Wagner « ae
Co., 208 U. S. 604, 614; |
Stromberg. Motor Devices Co. v. Zenith Detroit
Corp., Aud Vireuit, 73 F (2nd) 62;
Elizabeth v. Atacrican Nicholson Pavement Co.
97 U. S. 177
In re Germantown Trust Co., 57 7. (2nd) 365;
Carbice Corp. v. American Patents Development
Corp., 283 U. S. 420, 421.
| Ths claims in suit are vold fir antiolpetica. —~
4. Claims 2 24 5 are anticipated by Malcov Russian patent
No. 1163 of the year 1868.
h Claims 11 and 12 are anticipated by Rutz patent No
1.101.146.
M. 4 B. Mfg. Co. v. Munk, 2nd Circuit, N r (end)
281. 262. | <r
26
- a . III. ~ „ .
Nothing more than mechanical skill was involved in associa.
tien el a Same guard, similar to the Ruts hood, with’
"torch body. :
TDuaritos v. Bokee, 17-Wall. 4
„ Scaffolding 0 6. M Chain Belt Co., 254 U
32, 36-37 ; |
Thompson Spot Ww ts: Co. v. Ford Motor €
265 U: S. 445,447; 1
_ Keyes v. Grant, 118 ©: S. 25, 36;
Dunbar v. Meyers, 94 l“. 8. 187 ;
De Porest Radio Corp. v. General Electr
283 T. S. 664; 3
Paramount-Publix Corp. v. pean Trs Ergon
Corp., 294 V. S. 464, 474;
Concrete Appliances Co. v. Gomery, 269 U. S. 17.
185; .
— ete. Corp. v. Comerete Mira,
etc, Corp., 282 U. S. 175, 186;
Carbice Corp. v. American Patents Developme
Corp., 283 U. 8. 420, 421;
. Altoona-Publiz Theatres 0 orp. v. ae. an Tr
Ergon Corp., 294 U. S. 477, 486; :
Vandenburgh v. Truscon Steel Co., 261. U. S. 6. !.
| Textile Machine W orks, Inc. v. Louis Hirsch jes 7.
tile Machines, Inc., 2nd Cireuit, 87 F (2nd) 7%
705, aff'd. 302 U. S. 490. :
—
27
IV. |
The patent in suit is for a double or analogous use of the
« Ruts hood, and is void under the pater? statute, since the
Aut hood can be employed without change. for the pur-
poses of the patent in suit.
Aron V. Manhattan Rug. Co,, 192 U. S. 84;
Mast, Vos & Co. v. Stover Mfg. Co., 177 v. 8.
485, 493;
_ Miller v. Foree, 116 U 8. 22, 283 8
Grant x. Walter, 148 U. S. 547, 556; |
| A app v . Morss, 150 U. S. 221, 227-228;
Dicight 4 Lloyd Sinterina Co. v. Greenawalt, 2nd
Circuit, 27 F (2nd) 823;
_” Ingersoll Rand Co. v. Worthington etc. Co., 2nd
Circuit, 87 F (2nd) 32033
Potts v. Creager, 155 U. S. 597; 5
Nat'l Cash Register Co. v. Boston Cash Indi-
cator Co., 156 U. 8. 502; |
Hobbs v. Beach, 180 U. 8. 383, 392- 3933;
Rockwood v. General Fire Extinguisher Co., 2nd
Cireuit, 8 F (8) 682, 686. :
V.
in ymin of the Court that the Ruts hood does
claims 11 and 12, then petitioner’. device
‘dees not infringe, since it is using the Ruts hood in its
Peters v. Active Mfg. Co., 129 U. S. 530, 537;
> Grant v. Walter, 148 U. S. 547, 553,556;
Lapp v. Morss, 150 U. S. 221, 226;
American Fruit Growers Inc. v. Brogder 8. 283
. U. S. 1;
Rockwood v. General Fire Extinguisher Co., 2nd
Eireuit, 8 F (2nd) G82.
——— Q
28 *
VI.
Infringement can be found only through a departure fron
dhe theory of the specification and by construing the
claims to extend beyond the invention; as construed ty
the Court below the claims are clearly void.
Schriber-Schroth Co. v. Cleveland Trust Co., Nos
3-5, Oct. term, 1938, decided Nov. 7, 193
Snow v. Lake Shore d M. S. R. Co., 121 U.S. 61, -
Mackay Radio etc. Co. v. Radio Corporation, No
127, October term, 1938, decided January N.
1939;
St. Pierre v. Red patch etc. Co., Lud Cireuit. =? 7
(And) 766. .
ARGUMENT.
. Claims 2 and 5 are aggregative.
The Court below stated as one of its premises: *
‘While torch bodies and flame guards were old,
they have never been used together to perform the.
function or produce the results of the device of the
patent: in suit. xt a
The statement that both. ‘red of device are old is
abundantly apparent from the record, a perfect example
being found in Wall, No. 228,497 (R. 344). Wall's patent
vas for a chimneyless ‘‘mill-lamp”’ or ‘‘torch-lamp,’’ con-
sisting of a torch body A, a wick tube E containing a tub-
ular wick, and a burner 8 having imperforate sloping
sides and a slit in the top through which the flame played.
We have not offered Wall as anticipating, since the phrase-
ology of all of the claims in suit suggests an ‘imperforate
_ dome-shaped cap,“ and Wall has his flame opening in the
donfe-shaped. Otherwise, the Wall device is completely
comparable to that of the patent in suit. Wall in itself is
sufficient to negative the second half of the Court’s
5 They have never been used together to perform
the function or produce the results of the patent in
mut.“ a :
Unfortunately for the clarity of the issues, the Court be-
Lats ignored t the Wall patent.
top of his cap, and his form is pyramidal rather than a
oe > oe
It is further to be noted that when the device of the
patent in suit was designed, it was arranged so that ibe
dome-shaped cap or flame guard could be added to the old
open flame ‘torch previously manufactured by respondent
No change was made in the torch body, wick tube or wick.
Claim 2 purports to cover the combination of:
(a) a-torch body and
(5) a flame guard, including
() a cap with an imperforate top wall,
(2) lateral flame openings — ‘o em:
luminescent flame, and N
(3) air porta.
Claim 5 is sufficiently like claim 2 so that it needs bo
separate analysis.
Other examples of combination of torch bodies, wick and
flame guards shown in the record are Russian patent to
von der- Weide, No. 1261 of 1869 (R. 335) in which we finds
torch body A and a flame guard C, and Russian patent to
Malcov, No.. 1163 of 1868 (R. 325), in which we find the
combination of a torch body, 6 and a flame
guard d-d.
These examples clearly demonstrate that the portions
combination set forth in claims 2 and 5 was very old
the art. Let us suppose, for the sake of argument. that the
type of flame guard disclosed in the patent in suit 88.
novel. Claims 2 and 5 would nevertheless be void unde:
the doctrine of Lincoln Engineering Co. v. Stewart. No,
ner Corp., 303 U. S. 545, in which case » Mr. Jastice Robert:
said, at pages 549-550:
As we said of Gullborg i in the agers case, having
hit upon this improvement he did not patent it as such
dut attempted to claim it in combination with othe
qa .
*
old elements which performed no new function i in his
claimed combination. The patent is therefore void as |
claiming more than the applicant invented. The mere
aggregation of a number of old parts or elements
which, in the aggregation, perform or produce no new
or different function or operation than that thereto-
| | / fore performed or produced by them, is not patentable
invention. And the improvement of one part of an od
combination gives u right to claim that improvement
10 combination with other old parts which perform no
new function in the combination.”’ (Italics ours.)
As . in tiled 2 and 5, the alleged invention clear-
‘ly sought to cover the improvement of one part of an old
combination. Such a claim is clearly void, since the unim-
proved parts of the alleged combination obviously perform
no new function in the combination. The device was 80
designed, indeed, that the suppol dly novel flame guard
could be added to prior —* which remained other-
wise unchanged (R. 25, f. 74).
A case in the Court below deciding the same point was
McGrath Holding Corp. v. Aneell, 58 F (aud) 205, where it
vis said, per Judge Manton:
“Since this combination was old, the inventor of a
new form of one element cannot claim the entire com- |
dination, even though he includes his new form of ele-
ment. The combination of the old elements with
the new clamp was new, we —_ but this did not
amount to luvention. 39
“The Court alone has sought to differentiate the prin-
tiples announced in these cases without, however, referring
te them, or * to distinguish them, upon the theory
.
eee.
*
.
— — 2 en Sets hel —
that the patent in suit covers a ‘unitary structure, pat.
ented as an entirety.’’ It is stated: ;
„But the device here used us a warning A- N
burner must be considered as an entirety, that is, the
oil container, the wick, the wick tebe and the — y,
(R. ——
Such an argument overlooks the eviews proposition
that there can be no functional relationship, as kuch, be
tween a fuel or other reservoir and the means used to util.
ize the fuel. This point is clearly brought out in Ie .
Ratican, 1911, C. D. 267; 36 App. D. C. 95, a leading and
much-cited case, in tee the validity of a claim on the
’ gombination of:
A wheel. truck having ry water tank 8 and
supply and delivery pipes for said tank, and a sector:
‘Shaped delivery nome °° ce sii
was held unpatentable both by the Patent Commissioner _
and the Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia. It
was assumed for the purposes of the decision that the form
of nosale was novel, but there could be no invention is
combining it with a water tank. In re Ratican was cited
with: ‘approval by Mr. Justice Roberts i in Lincoln Engincet-
ing Co. v. Stewert-Warner Corp. 03 ö. 8. 545, 550, foot-
note 6.
Another leading case cited in footnote | 6 of the Lincols
Engineering Case referred to is In re Germantown Tra
Co. (Ct. Oustoms & Patents Appeals) 57 F (2nd) 365, 1.
volving combination claims on improvements i in fuel gauges
_, for motor vehicles. be Sin en ENS wore oot
\
\
*
able for reasons given in the Lincoln Engicering Case.
/ Similarly, there can be no patentable combination be-
tween the carburetor and the gas tank, or bet Ween a burner
and a reservoir for kerosene. The patentable novelty, if
bination with a source of fuel supply.
guard and the fuel reservoir on the theory that it was ‘‘a
. unitary structure patented as an entirety,’’ three cases
volving the question of damages are cited. The facts of
these cases cannot n be applied to the facts of the
instant case.
Reference to a ‘unitary structure” is old to the patent
law where the Court is called upon to apportion profits
when a defendant is entitled to manufacture a part of the
alleged infringing structure, or where a defendant has
added something of his own. Thus the Court said. obiter
in Westinghouse etc. Co. v. F Co., 225 U. 8. 604,
614, per Mr. Justice Lamar:
\
_ patented as an entirety, the infringer is liable for all
the profits ‘unless he can show—and the burden is on
bim to show—that a portion of them is the result. of
some other thing used by him.’ oc
But in that case, the Court did not even hold that the
Westinghouse transformer was ‘‘patented as an entirety,’’
in apportionment of profits was necessary or not.
The Second Circuit case referred r Stromberg Motor
Devices ¥. Zenith Detroit Corp., 72 F (2nd) .62, was like-
Wise an accounting case under the Mock patent on a car-
salad to. be novel, yet the claims were held to 10 3 .
any, must reside in the burner itself, and not. in its com-
As authority to justify the aggregation of the flame
\ “Where profits; are made by i Article
bat remanded it for a new hearing to determine whether
*
o _— . .
* 5 ’
pipes 6 e n aed 1
34
buretor, which was held to be a unitary structure, the
plaintiff being entitled to all the profits. This is easily
understandable since it seenis to have been agreed by the
experts an both sides that the patent was more than a
mere aggregation by combining two old devices. One:
judge, however, dissented on the ground that even the car.
buretot was not unitary and that profits should be appor.
tioned. This case might be informative if the Mock patent
had covered the gas tank as well as the carburetor, but on
the facts, it does not help.
| Elizabeth v. American Nicholson Pavement Co., 9T-U. 8.
127, the third authority referred to by the Court below, is
somewhat different, involving the question of the validity
of a combination patent for street paving, and questions of
profits. The patent covered a pavement comprising. 5
foundation, parallel-sided wood blocks, strips between the
blocks to space them and a filling of gravel and tar. None
of the alleged anticipations, combined all the elements,
much less an arrangement of the elements according to the
patent. On the question of profits, the Court characterized
the patented pavement as: A new . like a new chem
ical compound."’ eer
This is hardly the category in which respondent’ s pot |
torch and flame guard can be placed.. Not only are the
elements old, but the combination of a torch’body and flame
| guard is old, and only in the precise type of flame cuard,
with the air porta in the side walls of the guard, can s.
find s, dubious newness, if it can be found anywhere. |
It is thas apparent that the Court below has for:ibly
g lifted a principle from the law of accounting, where its
- fanetion is to determine the burden of proof, and inject’ —
it into the law of aggregations where it has no proper place.
| barden of proof not being a consideration. The creation of
4 —
*
. . —
. *
new rules of law through analogy is sometimes necessary,
but analogies can be forced only so far before the breaking
point is reached, as it is, here when one considers that
under the rule of Westinghouse etc. Co. v. Wagner etc. Co.,
25 U. S. 604, 614, quoted, even though an article be „pat.
ented as an entirety,“; the infringer has the privilege of
showing that some portion of the profits detived from. the
sale are attributable to his additions to the device.
he most recent case presenting what might be classified
as a unitary structure as respondent sees it, is Carbice
Corp. v. American Patients Development Corp., 283 U. 8.
420, 421, in which 4 refrigerating container was considered.
Of it. the C ourt said, per Mr. Justice Brandeis, at page 421: |
»The alleged invention is for the locational drrange- |
ment of materials within a- container. Whether a lo
. cational arrangement within a structure can ever be
patented as a manufacture need not be determined.
For the combination in suit lacks patentable in-
vention and novelty. Each of the elements—refriger- is
ant, material to be. refrigerated, and nnn
form its funtion i in a known way.
| An of these considerations : apply l to tlie in-
stant case, as will be pointed out more specifically under
Sections III and TV infra. , ,
II.
The 2 in suit are void for e
»
No. 1163 of the year 1868.
all of the elements specified i in laine 2 and 5 are found
in the early Russian patent to Malcov, No. 1163 of the year
1868 * 225).
a Chan 2 and $ are anticipated by Malcov Ruslan patn 2
1— whee. tonto — = ee ee —— 2
r
“Claim 2 covers the a ae of:
In a device of the class described’’ (Malcov i is ol that
class} 0
9 „) a torch body (Malcov has a: torch body)
having an opening for a wick“ eased has an op.
came for a wick) :“ and ;
Ib) a flame Fuard for said wick mounted on the:
outside of said torch body (Malcov has a flame guard
mounted on the wick tube, but respondent’ 8 contention
is that such a mounting is within the scope of ths.
ee claim) „nid guard including
(1) a cap provided with an imperforate + ion
wall, and |
(2) lateral flame openings adapted to emit a
luminesceat flame Malcov has such flame open.
-ings and shows. them emitting luminescent flame)
‘and . ined —
3) air ports.” |
Reapondent attempts to differentiate Malcov because bh
has no air ports and because he — minute perfors
tions in his top.
The minute perforations may y possibly: have been inserted:
as orifices through which gas, which burns outside as flame. =f
might | ‘be emittéd. The evidence shows, however, that Mal.
dov's top is imperforate in the sense that rain does no
_ penetrate to the intérior, by reason of the surface tension
ol the rain drops (R. 80, f. 238-239; R. 100, f. 299).
The other point of differentiation is that Malcov has onl;
one opening for the inlet of air and the emission of flame.
In this aspect, Maléov, to all practical purposes, is no .,
different from the structure of the patent in suit. Dr
» Xe
| 37 | \
Loekiesh pointed out, in reference to the operation of the
structure of the patent in suit, that the air ports did not
the apt low candle power provided by the device
ander. sucht a condition. At any winds above zero velocity,
the-air ports were not needed, because the flame ports be-
came air ports automatically (R. 88, f. 262). Respondent’s
expert agreed that in any appreciable wind, more air would
be coming in through the flame openings than through the
air openings (R. 219, f. 657, XQ 132).
Respondent's principal criticism of Malcov, however, *
been directed to the deficiences of his patent draftsman,
- and not to the inapplicability or inoperability of his device.
Contrary to the supposition of the Court below, Dr. Luck-
‘tosh bad no difficulty in understanding the operation of
Maleov (R. 103, XQ 210, ff. 308-309). It presents all of the
elements of an anticipation, in that it has all the items de-
scribed in the claims which it is alleged to anticipate, and
can operate satisfactorily for the purposes of the patent
in snit (R. 81-82, ff. 243-244). Malcov was not considered
in the Patent Office prosecution (see Record in Nos. 166, |
167, page 99).
d. Cu 11 and ‘and 12 are anticipated by Rutz patent No.
1,101, 146. n
Claim 11 covers: A burner for a construction torch
adapted to emit luminescent flame, ;
All of che language after the word“ burner“ is funetion-
al, and is directed to the purposes to which the burner is to
be put. It can furnish no basis for giving the claim a
validity to which otherwise it would not be entitled.
. Disregarding this funetional language, claim 11 covers:
) a wick holder having .
(1) a portion in contagt with the wick and
supply suffcient air at zero wind, which was the reason for
38
(2) a supporting ane heat- receiving flange, and
(5) means enclosing a space above said flange and sur.
"founding the wick except for provision for lateral exit of
flame and restricted entrance of air for combustion.
While the Rutz hood 8, shown in Patent No. 1,101,146, is
not a burner for a const ruction torch,’’ it is nevertheless
a flo:ne guard. adapted to emit luminescent flame, since, as
_ we shall point out at greater length, infra, it may be used
without any change whatsoever to achieve the results sought :
to be attained in the patent in suit.
The Rutz hood 8 is a burner; it has a flange which re
spondent. characterizes as a supporting and heat-receiving
flange, when used by petitioner in its structure; it has
„means enclosing a space above said flange and surround.
ing the wick except for provision for lateral exit of flame,”
& in the patent drawings (R. 378); and it has ‘restricted
entrance of air for combustion,“ 7 in the patent drawings
Claim 2 covers substantially the same elements as claiz
11 and is similarly anticipated by the Rutz hood. |
All of the requirements for. an anticipation are present
when the anticipating device may be used without chang
kor the purposes of the patent. ‘‘It is enough to anticipate
if the earlier device is susceptible of the new use, 2
} stands and without change. M. & B. ‘Mfg. Co., v. Munk, 2nd
Circuit, 77 F (2nd) 261, at page 262, per Judge L. Hand
The Ruiz hood 8 wa likewise not considered in the
Patent Office prosecution (see record i in Nos. 166, 167, page
a. |
5 I.
— Cc i
tion of a fldme guard, similar to the Ruts hood, with a
torch body,
While it would seem clear from the foregoing that. the.
patent in suit can have no validity in view of the prior art,
it hax nevertheless been argued at length by respondent.
that the addition of a burner cap or a flame guard, having
air inlet ports and flame outlet ports, to a torch body for
ase as a Warning signal upon the highways, was a brilliant
flach of genius upon the part of the patentees, entitling | -
them to a status of generic inventors fortified with. claims 5
broad in scope.
Patentees claim to have been popularizers of such a de-
riee, and pioneers in developing highway warning signals.
They say their device is the only one which will success-
fully satify the rigid requirements set * by state testing |
| laboratories. | |
If there were a torch industry, b came into it:
very late. Patentees were introduced to the industry. by
McCloskey, the first popularizer of sheet metal open. flame
torches, and for some time respondent produced such
‘torebes for McCloskey as a contract fabricator. Patentees
found their principal's business good and decided to engage
n it upon their own behalf. What skill in the art they had
Was acquired as they went along. ;
Sometime in 1928, it became apparent to hen that means
Would have to be provided to prevent the flame f rom being
‘atinguished by wind or rain. This consciousness existed
while their advertising literature continued to extol the
_ eleacy of the open flame torch,’ which it was represented
to prospective purchasers would burn all night, anywhere,
at any time, in any kind of weather,“ (R. 263). (See also
Ww
„Fig. 4. p. 41 hereof), Whatever be the truth of the matter,
the continued reiteration of such.a ‘claim i in the face of the
known deficiencies of the device necessarily shakes one's —
confidence in patentees’ good faith. When a manufacturer
is once impaled upon the spike of a consciously false claim, :
it is but a rational inference that claims of the functional.
superiority of a succeeding device may be equally untrue.
The point is important, in view of the present extravagant ©
claims made by the pate ntees in the specification ard on the
witness stand. 4 |
P atentees first attempted to pre- Anak the oil by extending
the ‘wick tube into the container, the desirability of which
_ Was pointed out to them if nowhere else, in the case ol
Carlton v. Bokee, 17 Wall. 463, where it waa stated:
„In (the old. lamps) the flame was set close to the
lamp, and the wick tube holding the wick was projected
downward into the oil, so that the heat of the flame
might be communicated thereto in order to render it
more fluid and susceptible to the — attractioa
ee of the wick,
which was common knowledge when that case was dociaed
in 1872. Patentees’ first effort utilized these features, and
they have been continued into the patented structure ass ;
basis for invention. It was found not to be enough, where
upon patentees placed a set of baffle plates around the wick
(R. 271-273). Salsbury produced a structure superior to
those in 1895 (R. 329). Since these left the top open so that
rain could snuff the flame, it became apparent that some
| sort of horizontal top covering was necessary. The first
. structurc of this type is shown on page 277 of the record,
and the second, shown on page 279, differs but little from
the structure ultimately adopted.
The unfcttanate aspect of these experiments lies in the
unnecessary motions in which the patentees indulged before
41
The unly real protection for
cqun construction work ot night.
Ilir;
71
i
— —
4 8
1
43
they ‘pineal a product which satisfied them. A Men
io the Patent Office file on ‘‘chimneyless hydrocarbon
tarners,’” in which category the structure in suit is placed,
rould have revealed Wall, No. 228,497, a device undoubtedly
saperior to most of the structures shown on pages 271-287
of the record. But, as Judge Simons’ comments, They
chose the long road to solution.“
Granting the truth of patentees evidence that numerous
different’ structures were attempted, very promptly upon
their becoming aware of the fact that simple partial en-
closure of the sides of the flame would not prevent rain
from putting it out, they concluded that ome sort of top °
was necessary. Their experience Was completely paralleled
by the Detroit Street Railways experimenter six years
before. |
As the Court suggested in New York Scaffolding Co. v.
Chain Belt Co., 254 U. S. 32, at pages 36-37 it is certain
hat the struggle through which these patentees went could
not have caused them sleepless nights or laborious 5
Patentees, like the inventor in the New York Scaffold
Case, were not experienced in the art in which they wer
attempting to make advances, forcibly demonstrated by the
erude nature of their original experimental structures, and
_ the comments of the Court in that case seem apt: R
gut one is forced to think that where a change
is readily made in a composite instrumentality, the
change is not the prompting | or the product of inven-
bon.“
Bat, it is id that others swiss e to attain
the achievement of the patent in suit. The Court below
bas commented i in its opinion:
„Others worked re to solve the problem.
The proof here showed widely- parte, unsue-
4
cessful attenuate. ards: E efforts were made
over a long period. by men skilled i in the art of burners.
* © * Unsuccessful attempts were made by competitor
who had long been in the business of reais:
and selling open flame torches, *’
We do not concede that if such were the case, it would
necessarily negative the conclusion that only mechanical
skill was here involved. But we submit on the record in the
instant case that the inferences drawn by the Court below
are entirely unsupported by any facts in the record.
In the Statement of the case, point d,“ we have analyzed
ä ‘the evidence offered by respondent in support of its pox
tion, and it need not be repeated * except in summary
form.
Prior to or r contemporaneously with the patentees, two
persons attempted to ‘design a torch: d would 1 not be
snypffed in wind or rain. wae
P of the De
troit Street Railways. Taking the three- wick, cast iron
torch which that company had been using since 1913, some
time in 1922 he placed a fist shield, supported by a pin
over the three wicks. The experiment continued for abou!
two years. ‘It was abandoned, and no other attempts ap
pear to have been made by the experimenter. This is bt
in instance of an effort by one skilled in the art, or of a
manufacturer or competitor of respondent. If significa’
_of anything, it indicates that the first concept which cam
to this unskilled investigator was. that of putting = fu
umbrella over the top of the flame.
Tue second attempt came after respondent's unprotected
torch was on the market, in 1928, from a manufacturer
which found it was losing some of ite lantern business to
the open fame torches. — a period of two aot three
6
devices were produced, which were offered in evidence in
Court, although others are said to have beeh tested. One
ol these devices would withstand a very high wind (R. 171.
. 511); in the rain it went out. The experimenter testified :
“Tt occurred to me that I might possibly put a flat
‘shield over the top so that thé rain would not get in
the center of the wick, that is, that thought must have
* in my mind, but I just didn't do it.“ (R. 175,
5 1. 523.) | |
Can this individual be said to 1 a person skilled i in the
art! He claimed to be indulging in a continuous and ex-
tensive research (R. 169, f. 505), but he did not do that
“‘which must have been in his mind“ and which, had it
deen done, would have led him simultaneously along the
trail of the patentees, first. to a device somewhat like that
shown on page 277 of the record, and subsequently, in all
probability, to a device closely akin to that of the patent
nuit. It is also highly significant that this experimenter
was a licensee of respondent, required under terms of its
license to support respondent in litigation (R. 173, f. 517).
It is respectfully submitted that to designate these two
wolated efforts of inexperienced experimenters as
‘Unsuccessful attempts ° by competitors who
had been long in the business of manufaet o ing and
selling open flame torches, (R. 450)
u unsound to the brink of absurdity.
A majority of the patent cases decided during the past
two decades turn on the question of whether anything more
‘than the skill of the mechanic was involved in devising the
structure upon which a patent was issued. This is a ques-
tion of fact (Thompson Spot Welder Co. v. Ford Motor
Co., 265 U. S. 445, 447; Keyes v. Grant, 118 U. S. 25, 36)
| :
aw
—
46
and upon this subject the opinions of the experts may be
considered (Dunbar v. Meyers, 94 U. S. 187).
It is the theory of the patent law that whether inventom
knew of prior art structures or not, they are presun.ed to
have designed their devices in view of all of the prior art
The question here involved is whether, in view of Russian ;
patent to Maleov, No. 1163 of 1868, Wall’s “‘mill-lamp" or
**terch-lamp’’ of 1880, and the Ratz hood of 1914, any in
vention can be said to reside in the addition of a flame
guard akin to that hood to the body of the MeCioskey torch
of 1925. This question was gone into in detail in eros
examination of the petitioner's expert, Dr. Luckiesh, on
the trial, and the following interrogation was given and
answered: ) 4 |
RX 0. It is your opinion that a man skilled in
the art, who was seeking to produce a warning fla“
in a kerosene burner that would withstand gale ve
locities as high as forty miles an hour, if he knew o!
this gas burner of Rutz, that that would at once o
to him as being adaptable and usable for the pur pos- 5
of producing that flare which would withstand gale
velocities. Do you mean to testify to that? |
„A. If he were consciously searching for something
of the sort that you describe * ° * and he knew, o!
Ruta that would occur to him automatically”
(R. 129, ff. 386-387.) )
This was the only direct evidence i in the record on the pon" |
_ and no attempt was made by respondents to refute ‘
If we assume that patentees were ‘‘consciously. sarc?
ing for an efficacious flame guard, even though: they 4
not know of the Rutz hood, so far as the record gb thet
. nevertheless produced the device of the patent in «wit:
very similar to Rutz—very promptly.
4
At about the same time, Currie of the Dietz Company
dns half-heartedly experimenting in an attempt to get.
samething better than the open flame Toledo torch. He
cannot be said to have been ‘‘consciously searching’’ for
a efficacious device, because, on his cwn testimony, he did
not do that which his experience told him he should have
done, and that which, had he done it, would have solved
the problem.
Another observation which may be pertinent is that the
device of the patent in suit did not come as an anewer to a
long-felt want. No substantial market developed until
bree and one-half years or more after the patent issued,
shen the State of Iowa, leading the procession, required
all trucks using its highways, to carry three flares, and
petitioner's heavy sales of more than 100,000 corches an-
. ually did not come until two years later, in 1935. The
record further shows that the necessity. of a protected
' torch has not yet penetrated to a very substantial user, the
Detroit Street Railways, which still seems satisfied with its
_ cast iron torch and three unprotected wicks.
A lame attempt to explain the hesitancy of the Detroit
Street Railways to adopt the improved torch was made in
the record, when respondent's witness on the point tes-
tied:
Fne protected torches) have never been used“
because we have a torch designed to take care of our
peculiar circumstances. The torch has got to be low
enough to set down in the depth of the brick pave-
ment. (R. 61, f. 181.)
Respondent makes such a torch (See record in Nos. 166,
17. page 181, Exhibit 41 A, „Model F“ torch).
Under the reasoning of De Forest Radio Corp. v. Gen-
tral Electric Co., 283 U. S8. 664, and Paramount-Publix
Corp. v. American Tri- Ergon Corp., 294 U. S. 464, 474, this
44 |
war not the filling of a long · felt wast. When the alleged
inventing was done, there was no public demand. That
_ came long after. the alleged inventive act. The device of the
patent in suit, then, would seem to be non more > than a
natural development in the art.
- . In determining whether or not mechanical skill was n
volved in the production of the patented device, the Coen
should further consider that the assemblage of the patent.
in suit involved elements all admittedly old, whether fron
kindred arts or not. This was conceded by the Court below.
The applicable principles are shown in Thompson Spot
Welder v. Ford Motor Co., 265 U. S. 445, 151; -‘Coneret:
| Appliances. Ca. *. Gomery, 269 U. S. 177, 185; Powers.
Kennedy etc. Corp. v. Concrete Mixing etc. Co., 282 U. 8
175, 186; Carbice Corp. v. American Patent Developments
Corp., 283 U. 8. 420, 421; Altoona-Publix Theatres ( orp. ¥.
_Amerwan Tri-Ergon Corp., 294 V. S. 477, 486, in all of
which decisions devices involving an assemblage of know:
elements having known functions were considered sn
found to have required pething more than mechanica
"skill.
That all of the concepts meshed and all of the mean
employed in the patented structure were-old is abundanti
borne out by the record. Disregarding the operation of th
fael reservoir, wick tube and wick, which patentees wer
trying to improve, the supposed new concepts as outline!
in the patent specification, with the record facts applicab’
- thereto, may. be classified as follows:
2. Heat reflection. The specification states: ‘‘Heatins
of the wick is facilitated by reflection -of ae from the
dome-shaped cap”’ (Il. 72-74). : % ,
This premise is fallacious. Dr. Lackiesh testified cha:
after the device had been in operation a few minutes. th
19
dome- . cap would be sooted up and could not possibly =
reflect any appreciable amount of heat. Soot, or carbon
black, is used for many scientific purposes because it re-
fects no appreciable amount of radiant | energy * 77, 1, QQ. |
33, 56).
b. Conduction. From the specification we learn:
“Heating of the wick is facilitated: by. conduction to wick-
holding collars 12 and 6 from their 0 *
H. 75-76). ee a
This feature was 1 in Dr. Luckiesh’s book on
Artificial Light, published in 1920, page 60 (R. 81), and is
true of every kerosene device that has a holder around
u“ (R. 80, Q. 71). See also Cariton v. Bokee, 17 Wall. 463,
noted above, and the deeription in the Maleov **
cation (R. 327-328, ff. 981-982).
e. Quiescent air. The specification states: |
„Air inlet openings 10 being above the low er edge of .
the cap leaves a space within the cap and above the
flange for comparatively quiescent 7.” * 9
fe
Of this feature, petitioner’s expert testified :
“Tt may be reasonably quiescent in the state of zero
vind velocity, daß it is inconceivable that you could
deseribe that as a layer of quiescent air 10 there is
any wind velocity above practicalty ~ o“ (R. 78.
. 0). f 5
d. Restriction of inlet ports. The specification states:
„The quiescent layer of air in contact with the wick
- holder and restriction of inlet ports to admit to the
wick and holder only such air as is needed for com-
ten n. —
50
Dr. Luckiesh testified: ‘In a wind, they would cease b.
_ function as air ports“ (R. 88, Q. 103). Respondent's ex.
pert agreed in principle (R. 219, XQ. 132).
e. Admission of air. Of this, the specification says
* . **Snafficient cool outer air is supplied to the end portion of
the wick through the ports 10 for * a ee
flame (I. 89.91). |
Petitioner's expert testified:
„We found by test that (the air ports) did not up.
ply enough air apparently. at zero wind. ‘That was
responsible for the extremely low candle power. If
they did not function at zero wind they are not needed
for winds above it because the flame ports become air
ports automaticaly” (R. 88, O. 103).
Respondent’ ~ expert agreed in principle * 219, 50
150.133). E-
At zero wind, the patented device with the wick extension
of one-eighth of an inch, recommended by respondent, orer
an hour period, under controlled conditions, produced 2
average of 0.047 foot candles (R. 408, Item 32), or less than
one-tenth of the candles produced by a lighted match (R
87, f. 260). Patentee Withrow admitted that the device
| did not work so well in calm weather (R. 35, f. 103).
f. Decrease ia oil consumption. The specification states
„It has been found that with the above-described construe
tion and arrangement, the oil asa Amie is material!
decreased’’ (ll. 93-96).
The tests showed that at zero wea velocity a very los
oil Sonsumption was achieved (0.037 pounds per hour). ba!
at a savage sacrifice of illumination. At average wind ve
loeitios, up to ten miles per hour, the flare with the flame
| guard consumes more fuel than the flare without (%
o1
graph, R. 401). The observations of the testing engineers
from an hour’s test under each condition, in n ok
* kerosene consumed per hour, were:
Wind Velocity Without Silla’ | With Fleme
m. p. . Pe Guard Guard
. 0.172
ore 0.193 0.255
— oe. 0.340
14.00 0.429 0.303
* 5 0.249 0.2675
This is the converse of the material reduetion“ men-
tioned in the patent specifleation, or the fifty per cent. sav-
img. which the Court below erroneously assumed was the
fact in reaching its decision.
_ Respondent sought to substantiate i its claims by compara-
tive teats between devices which were not. comparable, and
the unprotected flare it used, Exhibit 10, was not as satis-
factory a torch as Exhibit 17, which immediately preceded
extended the wick of the unprotected torch an inch and a
half, unnecessary according to petitioner's tests, which
showed the most efficient height to be one-half inch (see
sreph, R. 397). This is corroborated by the Detroit Street
Railways’ practice, which has used the half-inch extension
since 1913 (R. 58, f. 173) As the trial court pointed out:
_“It is common sense to realize that the longer the ‘wicks
are, the more oil will be consumed’’ (R. 48, f. 143).
* Protection from wind and rain. The sjiecification
mates: Another outstanding advantage resides in reduc-
ing the liability of extinguishing | the flame ad high winds
or rain“ (U. 98-100). N
*
the patented torch (R. 20, f. 60). In respondent's tests, it 1
| 52
In the opinion of Sates 3 this was all .
produced. The concept that a hood with imperforate top,
side flame openings and air ports would protect a flam
from wind and rain was not original with patentees. Rat
understood it thoroughly and designed his hood-8 with this
in mind, as early as 1914 (R. 393, f. 1177).
_ Thus nothing is left to patentees save the dubious honor
of being the popularizers of the Rutz hood 8 as the flame
guard for a highway warning signal. The fact that pa!
entees were the first introducers or popularizers is not iz
itself significant, Vandenburgh v. Truscon Steel Cor, I.
U. S. 6, 15; Textile Machine Works, Inc. v. Louis Hirsch
Textile Machines, 2nd Cireuit, 87 F (2nd) 702, 705, affirmed
2302 U. S. 490. 5
In the Vandenburgh Case, it was said, per Mr. Chet.
Justice Taft, at page 15:
But it is insisted that Vandenburgh was the first
to introduce into the field: of concrete reinforcing th
kerf and integral spur to clamp the spiral rod
It may be true that, i in the field of reinforcing concrete.
the kerf and spur had not been used before as Vander
burgh used it, but the kerf and spur were old in the ant
of kindred fields. They ‘were old in metal“ working
—
In the Textile Martes Works Case, affirmed by thi
Court in 302 U. 8. 490, it was aid. per 9 L. Hand. a
, page 705:
At may be that the W the 3 r. of
new and valuable variant, should gather the profits:
perhaps any new use should be a But the-lav
is not % -.
53
‘As a summation, all of the concepts and elements com-
prising the patented device were old and well-known when
satentees entered the art. They should have come readily ©
to the hands of any artisan who was ‘‘consciously search-
ar for a solution to the problem. Even with their tedious
methods of cut and try,“ as counsel has characterized
their efforts, patentees very. readily achieved: the desired
result. : |
IV.
The patent in suit is for a double-or analogous use of the
Ruts hood, and is void under the patent statute, since the
‘Ruts hood can be employed without change for the pur-
| poses of the patent. in suit. | :
rue trial Court found that the Rutz eal 8 may be em-
toyed without change for the purposes of the patent in
zit“ (R. 430, f. 1289).
such being the evidence i in the case, claims seeking to
monopolize a new use for that structure are void.
4 This Court has followed this principle numerous times,
‘the most applicable citations being Aron.v. Manhattan.
Railway Co., 132 U. 8. 84; Masi, Foos d Co. v. Stover Mf.
Co, 177 U. 8. 485, 493; 7 Grant v. Walter, 148-U. S. 547, 5563
Miller e. Force, 116 U. S. 22, 28; Knapp v. Morss, 150 U. 8.
21. 227-228. This principle has been applied recently in
the Second Circuit in Dwight & Lloyd Sintering Co. v.
Greenawalt, 27 F (2nd) 823; Ingersoll. Rand (Co. v. W orth-
222 etc. Co., 87 F (2nd) 320,
The instant case presents the strongést factual basis
Within the principles of the above cases that has yet ‘been
““abmitted to this Court. It has been demonstrated con-
dusively that the Rutz hood 8 can be used without change
for the purposes of the patent in = In the Statement
ort | 8
ao
af the case, we have alluded to the qualification of a set 0
la res, using the Rutz hood as a flame guard, in the State o!
Nebraska. One of respondent's witnesses testified that this
was one of the most. difficult states in which to obtains
qualification (R. 52, f. 156). Photogra v8 of the. device:
Fhich qualified are shown on pages 474, 416 of the record,
and as Figures i and 2 on pages 59 and 11 of this a brief.
In Aron v. Manhattan Railway Co., 132 U. S. 84, where
railway car gates were in question, Mr. . Matthews
pointed out the rarity of cases in which a prior art devie
can be used without any actual change, saying:
It rarely happens that old instrumentalities are &
perfectly adapted for a. use for which they were no!
originally intended as not to require any alteration d
modification. If these changes involve only the.exerei«
of ordinary mechanical skill, they do not sanction 1
patent: sand’ j in most of the adjudged cases where it ha
deen held that the application of au old device to:
new use‘ was not patentable there were changes o
\ form, proportion or organization: of this characte:
which were necessary to accomodate them to the nes
occasion.’’ |
The record presents, however, one of those rare instance
in which no changes. whatsoever in „form. ä or
organization,”’ are necessary.
Tue fact that the prior art device had never been used
in the same environment as that disclosed in the *
was considered in Mast, Foos d Co. v. Stover No. Ce
VU. S. 485, 493, which involved a patent on an inter
toothed gear for windmills. It was said, per Mr. Justice
Brown:
Martin, therefore, discovered no new function: 250
de created no new situation, except.in the limited «en
1
that he first applied an internal gearing to the old
Mast-Foos mill, which was practically identical with the
Martin patent, except in the use of an internal gear-
ing. He invéiited no new device; he used it for no 8
new purpose; he applied it to no new machine. All he
did was to apply it*to a new. purpose in a machine
aes | it. had not before been used for that purpose. =
In thé instant case, the a s torch ody « ‘is prae-
“tically identical with the (McCloskey patent R. =m ae
im the use of (a flame guard). 9
That utility alone is insufficient was the holding i in Grant
. Walter, 148 U. S. 547, a case involving the validity of a
patent on a silk winding reel. In discussing this point, the
Sourt said, per Mr. Justice Jackson, at page 356:
The most that can be said of this. Grant: patent ix
that is a a discovery of a new use for an old device
_~ Which doda not involve patentability. * * The advan-
tages claimed, for it, and which no doubt it possesses
toa considerabledegree, cannot be held to change this
_tesult, it being well settled that utility cannot control
the language of the statute which limits the benefit of
' the patent laws to things which are new as well as
useful.“ (Italics ours. 4
The prineij le applied in the’ cited ease clearly nullifies
aay advantag> which respondents seek to — the
| fact that they have produced a useful device.
Nor i is the fact that they were the first to contemplate
this use significant. In Miller v. Force, 116 U. S. 22, a case
volving a patent on tobacco plugs, it was 8 said, per Mr.
Justice Bradley, at page 28: | |
| application of an old process. or machine to a
- similar or analogous subject, with no change in the
*
*
56 3
manner of applying it. and no onal substant: tally dis
tinct in its nature, will not sustain a patent, even if.
the new form. or result has not before been con
‘templated.’ *
What patentees are attempting a effect is a a
in the usé of the Rutz hood 8 as a flame guard for highway |
warning signals, but it is the device alone which can be
patented, and not its use. This was clearly pointed out is
Knapp v. Morss, 150.U. S. 221, a ens involving the patent.
ability of an adjustable dress form, where it was s said, per
Mr. Justice Jackson, at pages 227-228: |
7 ® Bat it is well settled by the authorities that 11
end or purpose sought to be accomplished by a device is
not the subject of a patent. The. invention covered
thereby must consist of new Nd useful means of ob
- taining that end. In other words, the subject of the
patent is a device or mechanical means by which th
desired result is to be secured. (Citations omitted
Tested by these authorities, the validity of the pater:
in quéstion must be ascertained, not from a considers
tion of the purposes sought to be accomplished, but o!
the means pointed out for the attainment thereof, and
if euch mwans, adapted to effect the desired result, d.
not involve invention, they can derive no aid or sup.
port from the. end which was sought to be secured. A
that Hall did was to adapt the application of obi de
vices to a new use.
oe
‘Petitioner’ 3 expert testified on this very . thiat i
the Rutz hood § were transferred to a torch body : All the.
prizeiples of operation would remain the same. R. 12.
RDQ 339.)
— —
ei 8 7 |
W 2 have deel quoted the trial Court’s finding on this
pint. The Circuit. Court argued that even though the Rutz
apparatus would accomplish the functions and results of
the patent in suit, the patented structure must be consi-?-
ered as an entirety, and that as Rots had never been used
m combination with a torch body to produce the result of
thé patent in suit, resporident was entitled ta a patent |
| thereon, Snch a holding clearly does not square with the
principles just referred to, and cannot. be substantiated
under either the facts or the law.
| Respondent hae heretofore argued that such’ cases as
potts v. Creager, 155 U. S. 597; National Cash Register Co.
. Boston, Cash Indicator, 156 U. S. 502; and Hobbs v.
Beach, 180 U. S. 383, justify * the validity of the
patent in suit. . :
None of the cases which they cite, and others similar in
principle which may be found in the decisions of this Court,
can be applied to the instant case. In no instance can the
prior art devices referred to in those cases actually be used
vithout change for the purposes of the patent. The facts
of Hobbs v. Beach, 180 U. S. 383, are typical. The question
comcerned the validity of a patent on an automatic. box-
making machine. The closest anticipation was a certain
machine known as the Dennis and York Machine, used in
de prior art for pasting labels on newspapers. Of this, it
vas said, per us! Tustice Brown, at pager 392, 393:
“By changing the flat head and fiat platen to e
ins dies with diverging faces, and strengthening and
changing the machine in some minor particulars, it
“could be used to fasten stay-strips to box-corners. In-
deed, a model of the Dennis and York. Machine so al- |
tered, was put in evidence, and shown to be capable of
doing the work of the Beach patent, though somewhat
eradely and er: <a ca sola
Ps = | 58 a 5 . „
Such a case has clearly no applicability to the instas!
case. The Rute hood 8 requires no alteration whatsoever,
Instead of doing the work ‘crudely and imperfectly,” 1
mee every requirement of very rigid state ‘laboratory
tests. And in its use either on a gas stove or on a highwa;
flare, it was first and last a flame guard.
The Court below refers to Rockwood v. General Fir- Fr
_tinguisher Co., 2nd Circuit, 8 F (2nd) 682, in which it hek
valid a dry pipe valve for a sprinkler system. Defendas:
in that case owned a certain Crosby patent which it claimed
anticipated. By eliminating a vacuum element, the Cros:
patent could be made to function similarly to the patent n
auit. The Court, howev er, er out, page 686, per Jude.
Manton:
‘‘The tests made prove that the Crosby valve with
out the vacuum was inoperative fifty per cent. of th
time. The appellant's valve has never failed and bass
record of one hundred per cent. Therefore, even mod
ifying the apparatus of Crosby, it was not a sue
ful device, and would not. be capable of commercial a
for fire extinguishing.
Thus the authority felied ¢ on '= the Court below is reai
ly an authority in favor of petitioner. The Rutz devier
without change, will qualify in one of the most diffs!
states, Nebraska. Its performance, like that of the devie
of the patent, is one hundred per cent. according to tes!
ing standards. |
Nor does the fact that thie Rutz hood 8 was used to pr
tect the flame on a gas stove require us to consider th
. analogy of the arts here involved, although that hood a»
the dome-shaped cap of the patent in suit are both stro
tures in the art of protecting flamies from being ext inguist-
ed. It was — out if the Second Circuit ‘case of
*
innight & Lloyd derung Co. v. Greenawalt, 27 F (2nd),
23, per Judge L. Hand: |
„The use for which the apparatus was intended is
the purposes of the patent; the statute — the
‘patenting of machines, not of their uses.’
6 | eae
tir the balding of thie dert mat the Rats besd oes
not anticipate claims 11 and 12, then petitioner’s device
oe ee ee
It was found by the trial ( ‘ourt that petitioner was using
aflame guard similar to one manufactured by the Mil-
rzuker Gas Specialty Company (owners: of the Rutz pat-
eat), except as to the size of the flame ports, and the Court
uruetüre and the Rutz structure in the size of the flame
ports Was immaterial (R. 430, Finding 7).
1934, and it has been using it ever since. It is not disputed
that this structure is adequate to mee{ all of the rigid re-
‘qairements of the various state testing laboratories. The
trial Court’s finding on this subject was not disturbed by
the Circuit Court of Appeals.
The facts here sct out justify the application of the
afringe,”’ in the event the Court should be of the opinion
that the Rutz hood 8 does not ene claims 11 and 12
of the patent in suit.
(uses in which this axiom was applied are Peters v.
Active Mfg. Co., 129 U. S. 530; Grant v. Walter, 148 U.S.
Fruit Growers, Inc. v. Brogder Co., 2883 U. 8.1. .
irrelevant if it could be employed. without change for
further found: that; the difference between petitioner's -
Petitioner adopted this type of flame guard about July,
‘wel-known axiom: ‘‘That which does not anticipate cannot:
Mi, 553, 556; Knapp v. Morss, 150 U. S. 221, 226; American |
60
The — of the situation l be clearly bretgh
forth in-a theoretical suit by respondent against the Mil.
waukee Gas Specialty Company, which has been manufac.
turing and selling the Rutz hood since 1914. Three of there
hoods were furnished by the Milwaukee Gas Specialts
Company, placed on torch bodies, and submitted to th
State of Nebraska for qualification.: This constituted BUN
Claims 11 and 12 refer to the flame guard alone, and the
Milwaukee Gas Specialty Company’ 8s product was being.
~ used as n burner for a construction torch adapted to emit
luminescent flame.
Were it supposed that the 3 Gas Specialty om
pany, having the necessary dies and other equipment, d.
_ ¢ided to manufacture torches using its hood, can one thin
for a moment that it would be guilty of infringement of th
patent in suit! Such a supposition strains one's sense o!
proportion, yet it is the one which the Court below sax
tioned, since the finding of the trial Court that petitione
was using the Rutz hood was not disturbed.
The axiom which we here seek to apply is founded upot
the social necessity of protecting conscientious manafe
turers who utilize the prior arts. In the majority of pater
cases, the Court tinds: the defendant extolling the virtoe
of the prior art, while it uses the patented structure. Sue |
‘a case is Rockwood v. General Pire Extinguisher (u., 20
Cireuit. 8 F (2nd) 682, relied on by the Court below. n
which the defendant claimed a certain Crosby patent whic?
it had owned bat not used for twenty-two years, anticipated
Such is noi the instant case. The petitioner's manufacture,
believes sufficiently in the efficacy of the prior art stroctur
upon which it relies to use it, and it has been doing so for
. five years. . :
61 a:
1
e
the theory of the specification and by _ construing the
- daims to extend beyond the invention; ‘as construed by
Lone ‘are aleariy veld.
In considering the question of infringement, which in
the instant/case is inextricably ound with the question of
validity ander the prior art, the Court's premise: was:
No statement in the claims or specifications re-
- quires that the cap rest directly on the body of the
‘torch nor oa the air inlet ports be located | in the body
of the cap.“ ü
K Petitioner justifies its argument of non-infringement .
spon the proposition that it has raised its flame guard
above the top base of the torch body and placed ifs air
ports in a horizontal flange below the cap, whereas every
saggestion of the patent and the claims, if read carefully,
is that the flame zuard be mounted on the top base of the
tores body and that the air inlet ports be vertically posi-
tioned in the side of the cap. 0
Petitioner's method is the sensible way to halen the
drueture because it results, i in an upward draft of dir, by
reason whereof petitioner obtains a much better perform-
fice than respondent. at a very low wind velocity. It was
admitted by one of the patentees that. respondent's device
did not work so. well in calm weather (R. 35, f. 103) and
the reasons for this were pointed out by Dr. Luckiesh in
his statement that air does not like to turn sharp cerners’’ |
R 91. Q 133), which it would have to do to funetion at low
rind velocities in respondent's structure,
: The stractural differences are therefore significant, from
the point of view of performance, and in holding that they
| = | oe ä
had no significance on the question of infringement, the,
Court below permitted respondent to depart from the thears
put forth by its patentees in the patent specification.
The specification states (p. 1, Il. 78-87):
Air inlet openings 10 being above the lower ede.
. the cap leaves a space within the cap and abore the
flange of the wick holder for comparatively quiescer:
air. This quiescent layer of air in contact with thy
wick holder and the restriction of inlet ports to adm
to the wick and holder only such air as is needed fo:
combustion aids in maintaining the heat’ of the wie |
holder and wiek. (Italies * ee, 4a
If the device i is to operate as patentees have described i.
the air inlet ports must be above the edge of the cap. Ther
are not so positioned i in petitioner's structure.
In the recent case of Schriber-Schroth Co. v. Cleveland
Trust Co., 305 U. 8. . Nos. 3-5 October term, 1438, d
eided November 7, 1938, well-recognized principles, whit
were overlooked by the Court below, were gun stated br
Mr. Justice Stone:
he object of the statute is to require the patente
to describe his invention 90 that others may constro
and use it after the expiration of the patent and ton
form the public during the life of the patent of th
. limits of the monopoly asserted, so that it may d.
known which features may be safely used or man
factured without a license, and which may bot“
Permutit Co. v. Grater Corp., 248 U. S. 52, 60. It
lows that the patent monopoly does not extend beyond
the invention described and explained as the stata
requires, Permutit Co. v. Graver Corp., * supra. That r
cannot be enlarged by claims in the patent not «=
-
° *
* ; 2 is 3
* 8 . > .
: , * 2 °
‘ ; \
— : 7 5
. *
” 8 8 :
7 N * . 8 < N * 5 K
me “ . . :
— — — n — — . - —
05
| ported by the deseription, Snow v. Lale Shore M. S. R.
Co. 121U. S. 617, ef. Smith v. Snow, 294 U. +9, RS: ”
lu the case of Snow v. Lake Shore M. 8. R. Co., 12. 8.
22. by Mr. Justice Stone, it was said, per Mr. Jus-
icy Matthews, at page 630:
„On this appeal, it is argued, * ° that this” con-
struction of their patent is too narrow; and it is now
~.gontended that the detachment of the piston and pis-
ton rod is not an essential part of the description and
claims of the invention patented. We cannot, howevér,
but agree with the Circuit Judge, that the language of
the specification limits the first claim to a combination
in which the piston and oe rod are . from
each other
III is not admissible to adopt the argument made on
behalf of appellanta, that this language is taken as a
} were recommendation by the patentee of the manner
in which he prefers to arrange these parts of his ma-
chine. There is nothing in the context to indicate that
the patentee contemplated any alternative for the ar-
Ours.) .
Se, in ide instant case, there is nothing in the patent
petification whatsoever suggesting ‘‘any alternative“ for
the positioning of the air inlet openings above the edge of
ihe cap to permit the existence within the cap and above the
lage of a layer of comparatively quiescent air. There is
„ suggestiow anywhere in the patent that the structure
n operate without this layer of quiescent air. It. is
ally clear that by reason of the different positioning of
‘te air inlet ports in petitioner’s structure, the latter can-
sot contain 0 such feature.
8 — of the * and piston rod“ .“ (Italies
64
The principles expressed in Mackay Radio & Tel. Ce.
Inc. v. Radio Corp... U. S. , decided January 30, 18
are also applicable. Respondent has attempted to broad
en the only invention described in the application” by r
jecting its theory that the air inlet ports must be in th
side walls of the cap and above the flange to create th
layer of comparatively quiescent air.
That it is bound by the theory of the specification |
: shown in the Second Circuit case of St. Pierre v. Redpate
etc. Co., 87 F (2nd) 766, inv olving an anti-skid strap for:
tire, which, the specification said, should be drawn a
tightly as possible. around the tire. ‘It was said, per Jude
Manton, at page 767 : ’
“ae The inventor) cannot now state ‘that his comme?
cial unit is applied loosely to the wheel and claim the
as a patentable feature of his invention, since if i
consistent with his patent description.’’ (Italics ours)
Equally is the omission of ba layer of cotmparativeh
quiescent air inconsistent with the description of the
stant patent.
The Court below likewise . relies upon the statement u
the specification that the description ‘‘is by way of ills⸗
tration and not of limitation.“ to give the claims breadth
This is the trite phrifse found in most patent specification
If it has any effect, it is as a claim to equivalents, and th
ä re i elaim wouk
nullify the patent.
3 preferable alternative is to indales the presumptive
_ that patentees designed their flame guard, mounted on t
| top base of the torch body with air inlets in the ide «a!
and a layer of comparatively quiescent alr, in the light a
te Ruta hood 8 in an attempt to escape the necessary 2
validity of their patent. which the prior existence of the
9
65
Ratz hood 8 requires. The presumption is not a. violent
wx since 15,000,000 of the Rutz hoods went into public ue.
But respondent, in its grasp for a monopoly, wants all-
aclusive coverage, even to the extent of n its
aims to the breaking point.
CONCLUSION. /
As a summary, all that patentees did was add a flame
card to MeCloskey’s open flame torch which it had been
‘minufacturing. Their purpose was to protect the open
fame of the McCloskey burner from wind and weather:
Except in. periods of high winds, the open flame torch
vas more efficient as a highway warning signal than re-
pondent's device. In a high wind; the protected torch
barns with a blue flame—not the luminescent flame of the
patent claims—and is of little value as a warning xignal
K. 215, XQQ &2, 84). (This undoubtedly accounts for the
ow candle readings at fourteen miles per hour and more
see graph, Fig. 37, R. 403]. The readings at fourteen miles
per hour with and without flame guard were 1,82 und 1.02
‘oot candies, respectively, and with flame 3 at 25.6
niles per hour, 0.22 foot candles; at 4.73 miles per hour
respondent’s device with flame guard developed 10.22 foot
candies, R. 408, Items, 23, 24, 25 and 44). a
Under such circumstances, the flame guard’ 8 only value ·
it fo keep the flame lit until the wind dbaies, U nder all
conditions, the. cap, like any umbrella, feuds to anes a
deluge from [drowning the flame. /
The art of protecting open flames fyom wind or weather
u as old as civilization, as the Court will see from the
record, and must know from. the lamp and hydrocarbon
burner art. As we have shown, the Butz hood 8 met 1
the problems before patentees became interested in t»
torch industry, and it can be substituted without chart
for respondent's structure, accomplishing the identica
purpose with entire efficiency.
Giving to patentees the most favorable view of the:
patent, the alleged invention consisted in taking from tk
well-known gas burner art a structure the purpose of br:
was to protect an open flame from extinguishment by cr.
rents of air and falling liquids, and combining this str
ture with the well -known McCloskey torch.
No such development has ever been recognized by ie
Court aé rising to the dignity of an invention entitled
the monopoly given by the patent law..
All of which is respectfully e
Pata Cari v. Wisse;
Solicitor for Petitioner.
3
8
. rob 23
IN THE
Supreme e Court of the United States
October Term, A. D. 1938
No. 603
MON TOOMBERY WARD X& COMPANY, INC,
an lings corporation,
“Petitioner,
vs.
„ THE TOLEDO: PRESSED STEEL COMPANY,
an Ohio corporation,
id
HILED BY RESPONDENT FEBRUARY 11. 1939.
CARI. V. WISNER,
\NTHONY WILLEAM DELLER..
4 ARL V. Ww ISNER, IR.,
Of Ce „uncl
FILE COPY L
Respondent:
BRIEF FOR PETITIONER IN REPLY TO BRIEF
Nolteator for Petiteoner.
- Supsect INDEX.
( N references on | thee left are to respondent s brief *
PACE
7 — 8 3
o 8. Trial Court's — deference b to Sixth Ci reuit decision 2
„ Respondent's admission that prior art will produce same
results 2
Mp 12:13, Attempted differentiation of Rutz 3
1, Dr. Luckiesh’s statement on function of Rutz hood 4
1b. Dr. Litkiesh’s association of Rutz hood with wind 5
? 16, Omissions. of testimony on Malcov | | 5
19. Dr. Olsen's. tests 1 . 3
P 21, Prior art as “paper patents” RN a)
P 22, Rutz hood solves problems of patent in suit \ 7
Mp 23. 24, Dr. Olsen's unexpected results“ analyzed 7
Y B. Dr. Olsenꝰs testimony on Euere of Anthes and Toledo a
ctructures 8
. Reply to nen of “fuel saving”, acceptance 1
licensees, and respondent's “low royalty, 8
5 30-39, Inferences to be drawn from failures of other exper :
imenters 7 10
Bp. 35-36, Reply to diecussion of ‘ ‘presumption of validity” 10
% „V. Respondent a “small company” ar | 11
1 or Cask Crem
s
latins Sete Nn Co. ¢ Sample, 130 P. 145 11
Butler Mfg. Co. v. Enterprise eic. Co. 8¹ F. 2d 711 11
Chen v. Bokee, 17, Wall. 463 pike 1
Corning v. Burden, 15 How. 252 . 4 8
Fett & Co. v. Youngstown etc. Co., 181 F. 345 ; 11
L. Thropp’s Sons Co. v. Seiberling, 264 U. S. 320 „ 9
Co Fence etc. Co. v. Kitselman, 189 U. S. 8 13
Mettler v. Peabody ‘Eng. Co., 77 F. 2d 56 11
Mrs Separation etc. Corp. v. Magma — Co., 280 U. S.
| 3
ens Corp. v. Am. Tr-Engon Corp. n 8. 40 10
tadio Corp. v. Radio Eng. Laboratories. 293 U. 10
. e Co. v. Toledo etc. Co., 72 F. 21 8 11
Text Book Crrep. _ 7 /
Waller on Patents (Deller EA) Vol. 3, p. 2009. See. 701 ee
P
Pp 40-43, Infringement ale iis rea oe eee _
1 Court ol the United sates
October Term, A. D. 1938 ,
No. 603
MONTGOMERY WARD — COMPANY, INC., an Illinois corporation,
. Petitioner, ‘
vs.
THE TOLEDO PRESSED STEEL COMPANY, an Ohio corporation,
BRIEF FOR PETITIONER IN REPLY TO BRIEF
_FILED BY RESPONDENT FEBRUARY 11, 1036.
> a =."
Respondent herein, petitioner in Nos. 166, 167, filed an
original brief oa February 11, 1939, entitled not only in the
latter causes, to which petitioner herein is not a party, ‘yt
in this cause as well: It is underetood that respondent here-
in intends to file a supplemental brief, not only in causes
Nos. 166, 167, but also in this cause, after respondent'“
brief in causes Nos. 166, 167 has been filed. ,
Respondent's brief filed herein seeks to sustain the judg-
ment of the Second Circuit by reference to both records.
The treatment of the subject by respondent is so manifestly
wifair that petitioner is prompted to file this brief in order
that the errors assigned in the instant case may be fairly
presented. Farther, in some respects, respondent has de-
a
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.