Transcript of Record — Toledo Pressed Steel Co. v. Standard Parts, Inc.
Supreme Court brief1939
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
a .
‘Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1938
No. 603
-
"MONTGOMERY WARD & COMPANY, INC...
3 PETITIONER,
vs.
—s
‘THE TOLEDO PRESSED STEEL COMPANY _
| ON WAIT OF CERTIORARI TO THR UNITED STATES UIECUTR COURT 5
: OF SEER OOS CEE FORD GREE
5: ited States Circuit Court of Appeals
FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT
| eae
| THE TOLEDO a STEEL COMPANY,
>). A CORPORATION,
=*
.
| Plaintiff-Appellant,
Vs. ,
es
“MONTGOMERY WARD & COMPANY, INC,,
q A CORPORATION,
Defendant-A ppellee,
; y 7 . ; ‘
2 , FROM THE District.CourtT or THE UNITED STATES hi H
2) + FOR THE Eastern District or New York. agp
TRANSCRIPTOFRECORD ; ~~
* Darsy & Darsy,
P ae '. Solicitors for Appellant
a Samuet E. Darsy, Jr.
Wiser Owen
Of Counsel
Pigrsonr Witt icin
; - Solicitor for Appellee |
: Cant Wiener, JR.
= - Of Counsel —
INDEX
PAGE
eddeaenuheianetesnctdadbesssess 1 j
WPT TTT TTT TTT TT eer 9°
Narative | Statement of Evidence. imena bee kakaewne 18
A Se TTT il
Stipulation as to Facts and © EERE eee a - 431
SERIE, CaM nee ED . 432
Daas ee, s
ent of Errors TOT TTP OTTTT TCT TT TTT TTT 435
pabataphbencisebeteaeusaqe 438
ETE POT eT TET T TOT TT TTY TTR
Stipulation as to Appeal Bond..............- seven
Stipulation as to Contents .of Record Réaeace Cae 442
Stipulation That Record Is True Transeript. vestes Ge
Clerk’s Certificate peewhbedeguucbanes iasiinanes We ee
; ’ ; ee
Puiaintirr’s TESTIMONY _ |
Joseph E. Withrow: .
Henry T. Atno:
iv .
| Puartirr’s Resurra |
Robert A. Currie: °
PAGE
BOO veto vention dusesaavevenesvdceloecs x 167
gs AEE Ee EP Me 172
OOM esse sattexteeartiansiensacei 177
Joseph E. Withrow:
ME FANeekieVebsdeeiss lost Seeuueas 179
yicpsalede eee eee CT ere tee Ts 18]
Lyman W. Close re
WE 85 755 nacdivcorecehirsdvgbiaspels en 183
I oshbvsesecTiashseidesvassensas 1%
John C. Olsen
nn Le EE oD I ae 192
ng IES PPC SiR fet: 213
PE se s8ebthehvcdonienscevisekicc oe 240
OE, oservdisenrs ktkotccasediicae OO 241
Derenpanr’s TESTIMONY
Mathew Luckiesh : °
DO oo cecseccccscesicceolvoverersecigs, 69
EE FENG AVSe Sah gvsvnepeniaauceesc cio %
Re-direct .......... pantbenus chascound 113, 125, 128
Re-cross ........, hanes bebmekret ice eeaa 120, 127, 129
MP aiNE si st cennes De iepodaieacosd utd 130
WM Pesecdensissievcersevavciienn 130.
Ray F. Hutt ‘
OE Soa rinttisspustoseses ene ny errere .. 131
Huber O. Croft ( Deposition) :
RNa ee S06 bdbuR Rees bodies deus
SE 84059 ho Whadvetieeiccitoctcs ccc 157
BUD hsb isessrevseriaviereticuccc 8
Re-cross, ..;....... 004566080004 >enbsJalekee
Eimer C. Lundquist (Deposition) :
mia neMbidd Cee Tere TTT eee TS
ee =
v
. Lypex or Puarntirr’s Exursits
"Exhibit “
1—Copy of teil PRM bos pcdswiccices
9—Photostat of advertisement of Anthes
Offered Printed
Page Page
18 247
Force Oiler Company showing Anthes
Pe I sBeuines eve mtinpetiacsee
” 3. Photostat of advertisement of Anthes
Force Oiler Company representing de-.
vice on which Anthes Company réfused
to pay TOPGIEG, oui se ciinsecetesidss ‘?
_ 4—Circular of Tolédo truck flare..........
-§—Direction sheet of plaintiff’s truck flare
§—Certificate of approval of defendant’s
flare by Electrica I Testing Laboratories
OF FR Wo onc cesacnccctekavesss .
7—Blueprint produced by witness tnt
in his deposition showing ‘Detroit open-
SD SNE oS ih cckccuncctasmansacaces
8—Photograph identified by witness Ker-
win in his deposition showing Detroit
» CAEN. CEGED ob. co vigconecsssderic
_ $-Blueprint produced by witness Kerwin
-- in his deposition showing Detroit torch
og. POY OP PePTTT TTT Tere
10—First Toledo open-flame torch........
11—Circular illustrating ” open-flame torch,
me £ FR PO rrerr rte Trees
12—Patent dated January 11, 1927, to Mr. |
WE vbcsuedsdeesescabcaneseaesiaes
13—Improved open-flame torch manufac-
tured by plaintiff after July 15, 1928...
14—Yellow tag fastened to handle of each
torch like Exhibits 10 and 13...........
15—Sketches of experimental structures
to made by Mr. Close prior to the Toledo
Oe SO Oe Bc eine catcavisveceaadia
16—Circular showing construction of Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit: 33 higgevndexdebessrooce
17—Torch manufactured by plaintiff in ac-
cordance with the patent in suit.......
18—Drawing of Fig. 3 of the patent im suit
with claims)2, 5, 11 and 12 applied.....
19—T rick flare manufactured by plaintiff. .
20—Circular of Dietz licensed torch.......
18 253
19 255
19 257
(19° 259
19 Phys
19 Phys
20 ~=—s« 26:1
20 Phys.- © 1
20 Phys. VERE:
20 263 ne:
20.265 . |
21 Phys. -
21° Phys. | |
-23 269-287
23 438-289
23 ~=Phys-
24 86291
29 ~=—~Phys.
29 =Phys
Offered Printed
Exhibit | Page
2]-—Circular of Do-Ray licensed torch. . --
22—Circular of Shanklin licensed torch.... 29
23—Circular of Embury licensed torch... ._ 30
25—Sheet containing drawing cf defend-
ant’s flare with claims 2, 5, 11 and 12
of the patent applied................. 31
__ 26—Defendant’s (Anthes) Flare.......... 31
- 27—Circular of McCloskey open-flame torch 32
a Pa ests Hie ie Ais lr 0 32.
29—Memorandum of fuel consumption tests .
of Toledo and Anthes flares identifred
by witness Close........... vMienseas - 49
30—Wind velocity test data produced by
Witmows Clog «2.5.0 oociecocivcecece.. , 50
tests represented in Exhibit 30........ 50
32—Letter from the State of Iowa Commis-
'- gion to the plaintiff describing testing
methods -by that Commission......... 54
35—Drawing of the Bolser flare in Toledo
case . ene Whinkes caeeeiee Lt Pane ee eee 56
34—Drawing of the Kari-Keen flare in To-
wae... Aer GE rore sehenauce 56
35—Stipulation with blueprint of Anthes
flare attached thereto................ 56
36—Stipulation with copy of license agree-
ment between plaintiff and Anthes
Force Oiler Company attached........ 56
37—Currie 1928 Experimental Burner..... 170
38—Currie 1929 Experimental Burner..... 170
39—Another Currie . 1928 , Experimental |
ote opines a in eotese MO
40-—Circular of Dietz open-flame torch..... 171
41—Dietz licensed burner..:.......°...... 172
_ 42—Anthes torch identified by witness-With-
row, with the flange cut OWOF . scccccss 180
Page
Phys,
Phys,’
_ Phys,
293
©
Vil
_ Exhibit
A—Certified copy of | opinion of Circuit
* Court of Appeals in Toledo case......
B—Photostat. comprising enlarged draw-
-.’ ings taken from patent specifications of
- . patent in suit, of the Rutz patent No.
1,101,146, of the Russian patent to Mal-
cov of 1868, No. 1163, and a figure of
defendant’s burner ee |
eeeovseeeeeaeee ee eee
2
C—Volume of prior art patents peprg baaaas |
_ Unirep Srarzs Patents
. Hathawa) a RP
Almont "cess cebubens
Wall rere
’ Heston Ee 5 acctuend
Blake 453,335,....... aren
Warren 783,339... mies
Rutz et al. 1,009,184. ....0.0006
, Rutz se ee
Kahn | Ri: eee
McCloskey - 1,610,301.......0.006
Barris Patent
Salsbury - : 16,524 caKeeherkes
Russian Patents
Malcov eo Sere é one%e
Von Der Weide (< Sieee eee ar
. D—Publications set up as anticipations by
defendant. WP PORE ERAN, See Pere
E —Stipulation with reference to’ testimony-
of Oscar J. Leins......... ok aae tabs
F —Curves for all the graphs destribed by
Professor Croft ,...... geben rendes os
Inpex or DEFENDANYT’s EXxuHtsits
. Offered Printed
bo ena oo
. Page Page
67 Phys.
67 ~—- 328
67 Phys.
67 339
67° = 351
67 343
67 347
67 355
67 361
67°. 371 i
ce fF. fee
67 383 Hidi
67 387 |
67. 329°
67 325.
67 339 »
68 Phys...
391
68: Phys.
A emeprenees
- M—Certificate from the Stete of Nebraska .
. 0 tified by Professor Croft on a deposi-
viii -
| Paar: Off si
. Exhibit 4s | | Page ‘
G —Stipulation with reference to tests taken =
- after taking of deposition and with ref-
erence to test experiénces which has
been entered into between plaintiff and
defendant on March 3, 1938........... 68
H—Deposition of H. G. Croft taken Jan- * .
uary 18th Tee cE f 68
I —Structure prepared from patent draw- .
MD GE BRUT. oka ccviesinaccas cts iaie 78 Phys.
J. —Structure prepared from patent driven
ings of Salsbury. sual deceveekseeneays 90 Phys.
K—Statement entiiled ‘‘Comparison of per-
formance of plaintiff’s flare with and
without flame guard, comparison of per-
formance of plaintiff’s unprotected flare
at various wick heights, and compari-
son of performance of plaintiff’s and
COPING TGUN”” unc cod cecesenecsns 93
L—Cap of the Rutz patent mounted on
pg Retr 105 Phys.
qualifying a torch with a torch body
‘disclosed in Defendant’s Exhibit L, and
* with the Rutz structure superimposed
thereon, for sale as a flare in the State.
of Nebraska a SOR TEE ee Pe 132
N —Photographs of testing apparatus iden-
P tion taken atIowa City, Iowa; and
offered during the taking of that deposi- ’
| De sc nussca been un cu certesae erence 133: Phys.
Q —Copy of record in the preceding case m
Circuit — OF BIOGIE . ccvccscersee 133 = Phys.
ee Se, 6 Oe ee Ces aoe ah ee oT eel ae
Petition for rehearing ic nears Ueae true ree 455
Orders denying petition for Seite ace aaa ae 471
J i ICES EN ue 7eeaKE bee cure vokok. oa
htt ee ee oe oe a ee a a or ee
ee
Eastern District OF New York
Tue TOLEDO PRESSED Sree, CoMPANY, -
3 a ConPorRATION, ae
- Plaintiff,
i vs. In Equity
MontcoMERY WarD & Co, Inc, No. 8417
a CORPORATION,
Defendant.
Bill of Complaint
(Filed November 16, 1937)
- [9 THE HoNnoRABLE tHe JupeEs oF THE DistRIct 2
Courr oF THE Unitep STATES WirHIN AND FOR
tHe Eastern’ Distaict or New York,
Plaintiff, THe: ToLepo Presse Sree CoMPANY,
brings this bilk of complaint against MonTGOMERY;
Warp & Company, Inc., defendant, and for its
cause of action states as follows: 5 lee
1. Plaintiff is a corporation duly organized and
existing under and by virtue of the laws of the
_ State of Ohio” and is a citizen of Ohio, having its
‘principal office and place of business at Toledo, in
said State. } eS ie eee
Ju the Anited States Bistrict Court
9. Defendant, Montgomery, Ward & Company, 3..
Inc., is a corporation organized and existing under.
and by virtue of the laws of the State of Illinois,
is a citizen of Illinois and maintains a regular and
established place of business in the City of Jamaica
in the Eastern District of New York, where the
acts: of ‘infringement hereinafter complained of
were committed. nea ;
3 This is a suit in equity arising under the
: of United States Letters Patent No. 1,732,708,
issued to plaintiff on October 22, 1929.
patent laws of the United States, for infringement ~.
2. |
- Bill of Complaint
4 4. Heretofore and before the 25th day of De.
cember, 1928, Joseph E. Withrow and Lynian W.
_ Close, both citizens of the United States, residing
at Toledo in the State of Ohio, were the original,
. first and joint mventors of a certain new and use.”
ful Burner, not known or used by others in this
country before their invention or discovery there.
of, not patented or described in any Letters Patent
or printed publication in this or any foreign coun.
try before their invention or discovery thereof or
_ more than two years prior to their application for.
the hereinafter mentioned Letters Patent, not in
5 public use or on sale in this country for more than
- two years prior to the date of their said applica
tion for Letters Patent in the United States, not.
patented in any foreign country upon aii applica-
tion filed more than twelve months prior to their
said application for Letters Patent, and not aban-
doned to the public,’ eae ee
. 5. On or about December 26th, 1928, the said
Joseph E. Withrow and Lyman W. Close, being as
aforesaid the original, first and joint inventors of
said Burner, made due application to the Com
missioner of Patents for Letters Patent of the: |
‘6 United States for said invention, and by an instru-
ment in writing, duly executed and delivered by
them, assigned and transferred the entire right,
title and interest in and to said invention.and Let-
ters Patent to‘plaintiff herein and authorized and.
requested the Commissioner of Patents to issue the -
Letters Patent for. said. invention to said as-
signee, and having in all. respects. duly complied
‘with the conditions and requirements of the Acts
of Congress in such cases made and provided, on °
the 22nd day of October, 1929, Letters Patent of _
the United States for said invention, bearing No.
Sg
Bill of Complaint
1,732,708, signed, sealed and executed in due form ere
of law, were issued and delivered over to plain- |
tiff, as the assignee of said/Joseph EB. Withrow and :
Lyman W. Close, whereby ‘there was secured unto ~
. plaintiff and tts «successors and assigns for the |
term of-seventeen (17 ). years from said 22nd day 2 4
of October, 1929, the sole and exclusive right of
making, using and selling and of granting to others
the right to make, use and sell devices embodying
the said invention, all as by said Letters Patent,
or a duly authenticated copy theteof, here in court
to be produced and shown to Your Honors, will
more fully and at large appear, a copy of said Let- 8
ters Patent, marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1,’’ being :
attached hereto and made a part hereof. ee Ae
6. Plaintiff, since the issuance of said Letters _
Patent, has invested large sums of money and gone
to great trouble and expense in and about said in- |
' vention for the purpose of introducing the same ALLE
into general use and making it profitable to itself tf .
and useful to the public; has itself made and sold |
large numbers of construction torches and truck
flares embodying the said invention ‘and bas . |
| granted licenses thereunder to a number of manu- een
'- facturers, including Doray Lamp Company, of Chi- 9 13
cago, Illinois; K-D Lamp Company, of Cincinnati, | i
Ohio; R. E. Dietz Company, of New York, N. Y.,
Shanklin Manufacturing Company, of Springfield,
‘. Tllinois, and Embury Manufacturing Company, of
Warsaw, New York, each of which licenses has rec-
ognized the validity of said Letters Patent, and has”
manufactured and sold construction torches and/or
truck ‘flares embodying the invention of said Let-
ters Patent and paid substantial royalties to plain-
tiff thereunder. Plaintiff and its said licensees
have been and now are ready and able to =
fo
——
10
<a — S
Bill of Complaint
entire demand of the: trade and of the public for
torches and flares, embodying the invention of said
Letters Patent. :
7. Plaintiff has caused botics of its wid Letters
Patent to be given to the: public by permanently
_ Stamping ‘‘Patent No. 1,732,708’’ on each and
every embodiment of said invention sold by it since
the issuance of said Letters Patent and has re-
quired its said licensees:to similarly mark ‘all em-
-.. bodiments of said invention manufactured and sold
11
by them under their said licenses, which require- °
‘ment has been fully complied with by said ns
as plaintiff is informed and believes.
8.. Notwithstanding the ability of plaintiff and
i its said licensees to supply the requirements of the .
trade and the public with construction torches and \\
_ flares embodying the invention of said Letters
Patent, other manufacturers have disregarded
| . plaintiff’s rights under. said ‘Letters Patent and
12
have, without right or authority, m ufactured, and
“sold constructiou torches and flares in infringe-
ment thereof. In J anuary, 1934, plaintiff brought ;
sujts in the United States District Court for the _
Northerr. District of Ohio, Western Division
agains’ dealers who were selling infringing truck
flares which were manufactured by The Bolser
Corporation, of Des Moines, Iowa, and Kari-Keen
Manufacturing Company, of Sioux City, Iowa,
which manufacturers openly assumed and con- —
ducted the defense of said cases. Said suits came
'* on for hearing in said court before His Honor
Judge George P. Hahn, in May, 1935, who-entered
, a decree finding plaintiff’s said patent to be valid
and infringed by the two devices involved in said
suits. Plaintiff having waived an accounting
ageinst: said dealers who were the nominal de-
od
LS oe yy
eS oo A
Bil of Complaint
fendants of record in said causes, final decrees 13
‘were entered therein on the 29th day of June, 1935,
gnding said patent to be valid and defendants’
said structures to infringe & number of the claims
thereof... ;
-g, Prior to the commencement of this suit and
since the entry of the decree in-the causes above
‘referred to, defendant herein, Montgomery, Ward
&- Company, ‘Inc., having had notice of plaintiff’s
patent through the marking of devices made there-
~~ gnder by plaintiff and its said licansees and well
knowing. plaintiff’s rights. in the premises, in-
“fringed and still is infringing the said Letters
Patent by selling at. its regular .a
place of business at Jamaica, within\the Eastern
| throughout |
District of New York, and elsewhere
the United States, truck flares embod i
ng tne in-
‘ -yention disclosed, described and claimed in said
\\ Letters Patent, without plaintiff's license or con-
gent and in violation of plaintiff’s rights under said
Letters Patent, and is threatening to continue ‘its .
said acts of infringement, which acts of defendant
have the effect of inducing others to infringe said
Letters-Patent and of depriving plaintiff of profits
to which it is entitled as the owner of said Letters
Patent and of causing great and irreparable dam-
age and injury to plaintiff.
‘10.. The devices so sold by defendant in in-.
-fringement of plaintiff’s said Letters Patent have
“Mfd. By Anthes Force Oiler Co., Ft. Madison,
-Ta.;’? permanently stamped in the metal thereof,
and plaintiff is informed and believes and there-
fore avers-that the devices which have been sold
and are being sold by defendant in infringement
of said Letters Patent were manufactured by said
- Anthes Force Oiler Company, which company was
i. ss) pe
BP sien
a ¢
éstablished _
ie
15
16
EAD A EEE yee ek ee
6
_ Bill of Complaint
a former licensee under plaintiff’s said Letter
Patent, under which license it paid royalties to .
plaintiff on truck flares of a slightly different con-
struction than those being sold by defendant here.
in: Said Anthes Force Oiler Company having dis.
continued the payment of royalties to plaintiff on
the plea that its truck flares constructed like those
complained of ‘herein do not infringe plaintiff's
said Letters Patent, the License to it has been
terminated and it is invited to appear and. assume
the defense of this cause. The truck flares on
' which said Anthes Force Qiler Company paid
17°
royalties to plaintiff under said Letters Patent are |
illustrated in the advertisement of said company -
attached lereto and marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit 2”
and its truck flares which are being sold by defend-
ant herein are illustrated in its. advertisement atx —
tached hereto and marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit No.
' 3.°? The truck flares charged herein to infripge |
_ said, the only. difference between the burners the
closely resemble the construction of the Bolser and
Kari-Keen truck flares held to infringe as afore- .
of being that in the Bolser and Kari-Keen burners .
held by this court to infringe the air inlet openings
were located in the side of the flame guard at .
- points below the flame openings, whereas in the
truck flares heing sold. by defendant. and charged
herein to infringe the air inlet openings are lo-
_ cated in the flange portion of the flame guard which ¥7
| projects from the. wick tube and supports the re-
movable portion of the flame guard.
11. Plaintiff is informed and believes and there- :
fore avers that defendant, Montgomery, Ward &
Company, Inc., is prepared to and will, unless en- | ;
‘joined by this Honorable Court, cantiziue its said
' infringepient and cause further irreparable dam-_
'
\
Y
‘
: —
Bill of Complaint
age and injury to plaintiff for which it will have 19
“no adequate remedy at law. poe ie i,
WHEREFORE, plaintiff prays:
1. That said Letters Patent Nd. 1,732,708 may
‘be decreed to he good and ‘valid in law, and that:
plaintiff’s. title thereto may be confirmed. .
. 2 That defendant may be decreed to“have in- —
fringed said Letters Patent by the sale of truck
- fares manufactured by Anthes Force Oiler Com-
pany; of Fort Madison, lowa, and illustrated in
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 3 attached hereto. ; ae
3. . That a preliminary injunction pending this
suit and a perpetual injunction at final hearing 20
may be issued against defendant restraining andy
enjoining it, its officers, agents, attorneys, servants, )
workmen, employees, privies and_ confederates: tt S
from in any way infringing said Letters Patent |
ot any claim thereof, directly or indirectly, and
from contributing to-the infringement thereof. by
others. | . ae ;
4. That defendant may be decreed to -account
__for and pay over to plaintiff all gains: ahd profits — Ah
which have accrued to defendant and all damages mel i
which the plaintiff has suffered by reason of de-
_ fendant’s infringements of said Letters Patent,
that this cause may be referred to a Master to
take and report to the Court an account of such |
> profits and damages, that the Master may be given - .
all the powers conferred upop masters by law ‘and
21.
the rules of equity, and that the Court-may in- as
crease said damages im its discretion.as provided 1 ie
by law. * - . a
_. 5, That defendant may be decreed to pay the
_. costs, charges and disbursements of this suit and
that plaintiff may have such other and further re-
, and equity of the ease ~_
22
_ orders, directions and decrees as to Your Honors
23
‘subpoena under the seal of this Honorable Court, ,
(Notary Seal)
8
Bill af Complaint
May it please Your Honors to issue a writ of —
directed to said defendant, commanding it at a
certain*day and under a certain penalty to be and
appear before this Honorable Court, then aid
there to answer this em ag complaint (but, not _
under oath, an answer under oath being expressly,
waived), and to stand to and abide such further —
shall seem meet in the premises.
Tue Torzpo Pressep Steet Company,
Plaintiff,
By J. E. Wirsrow,
President.
Darsy & Dansy,
‘Solicitors and Counsel for Plaintiff,
Owen & Owen, ;
Nicholas Bldg, - ae
Toledo, Ohio,
of Counsel.
State of Ohio, County of Lucas, ss
On this 15th day of Sooner 1937; tid me
personally appeared J. E. Withrow, who being by
me first duly sworn, deposes and says that he is ©
President of The Toledo Pressed Steel, Company,
the plaintiff herein; that he has read the foregoing —
bill of complaint by him subscribed, and knows the
contgnts thereof, and that the same is true to his
own knowledge.except as fo matters stated to be
alleged on information and belief, and as to those —
‘matters le believes it to be true.
. Mary E. Duxgs,
Notary Public, Lucas County, Ohio:
aS
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 25
Eastern DistRIcT OF New York-
“Taz Totepo PREssED Sree, CoMPANY,
| a CORPORATION, “ P
; aintiff ,
In Equity
vs.
‘ (No. B-8417
MonTooMERY Warp & Co., Inc.,:
& CorPoRATION, *
| Defendant.
Answer of Defendant .
(Filed Dee. 22, 1937)
Now comes Mowtoomerny Wasp & Co., Inc., an 26
Illinois corporation, defendant in the above en-
titled cause, and files this its answer to the bill of |
complaint heretofore filed herein -and shows the
following : ia ; &
1. Answering paragraph numbered ‘‘1”’ of said
bill of complaint, defendant states that it is not in-
formed as to the corporate status of the plaintiff.
and the location of its office ‘and prays strict proof
thereof. . ° Sie .
9.‘ Answering paragraph numbered ‘‘2,’’ this -
defendant admits that it is a corporation organ-
- ged and existing under the laws of the State of 27
Illinois, and that it is a citizen of Illinois and mai;-
tains a place of business in the City of J amaica in
the Eastern District of New York, but denies that-
any acts of infringement of said patent were com-
mitted by it in the said Eastern Districi of New
"York or at any other place. eae |
% 3 Answering paragraph numbered “29 this i
defendant admits that this is a suit‘ equity aris- =
‘7 ing under the patent laws of the United States but
| denies “any ant. of infringement of said letters
a cc ae ‘ 7
‘
wae
28
29
10 +
Answer of Defendant
4, Answering paragraph numbered ‘‘4,” this .
defendant denies that the said Joseph E. Withrow ©
and the said Lyman W. Close, prior to December
26, 1928, were the original, first and joint inven-:
tors of a certain new and useful burner, and alleges —
that all of the claims of said patent were and are
' void for want cf novelty, and are further void as
being for agg” gations und not for patentable com-
binations; and this defendant alleges that the in-
vention claimed by said Withrow and said Close in
said patent application was well known in the art
and public property more than two years prior to
December 26, 1928, the pertinent-references thereto
being more specifically set forth in , paragraph “ogy
hereof.
5.’ Answering paragraph numbered “5, *? this:
defendant-denies that said Withrow and said Close .
were the original, first and joint inventors of the |
burner ‘deseribed in said application, but admits
the making of the application for the letters pat-
ent as alleged and admits that letters patent were
issued to said plaintiff as alleged in said para-
graph numbered ‘‘‘5,’’ but denies that said letters:
patent have any force or validity, and alleges that
all claims therein were and are void for want of
novelty and invention, as is more specifically set
forth in ‘paragraph ‘‘8’* hereof, and that said
claims are further void as being for aggregations
-and not for patentable combinations.
6. Answering paragraph numbered “66, - this
defendant states that it has no knowledge, informa-
tion or belief as to the expenditures or efforts of — |
- the plaintiff in and about. introducing the device de-
scribed in said letters patent into general use, and
in and about making it profitable to the plaintiff
and ‘useful to the public; this defendant further —
) . . + a»
——————— Scant penance as tact ACEI TsO maicanagawen peter ny eI —— eg
| 11
Answer of Defendant
states that it has no knowledge, information or be- 31
lief as to the numbers of construction torches and
- track flares ‘sold by the plaintiff or of the granting
of licenses. by the plaintiff to other manufacturers
under said letters patent, or as to the payment of -
royalties to the licensor as alleged; this defendant.
further answering states that it has mo, knowledge,
‘nformation or belief as to ‘whether or not said
plaintiff ‘and its ligensees are ready and able to sup-
ply the entire demand of the trade and the public ‘|
for torches and flares, and prays strict proof of all
of the allegations of said paragraph numbered ee
666”? ; : : : : 32
7, Answering paragraph one 1," tie. eee)
defendant states that it has no knowledge, infor- - Wi
mation nor belief of the’ allegations of said para- a4
"graph amd prays strict proof thereof:- x
. .8 Answering paragraph numbered. ‘‘8,? this - -
defendant states thatpit has no knowledge of. the
ability of the plaintiff to supply thé trade with con-
struction torches, nor of the claimed invasions of . 3
plaintiff’s alleged patent claims by other manufac- [-
turers, nor of the bringing of said suits by plain- A
tiff against dealers, nor of the said decree for said ieee }}
plaintiff in said causes, nor of the issues or claims 33
alleged to be infringed, nor of the structures of the-
- devices decreed to infringe said letters patent, and
demands strict proof thereof. : |
Further answering paragraph numbered ‘‘8,””.
this defendant! states that it was not a party to 3 .
said suits noreprivy thereto; that it took no part - |
_ in the defense of said suits, and that it was notin” Li
-
wr so <a
~~
privity with any defendant thereto, and had none} 2 A
tice or knowledge of the bringing of said suits or one tt
{ue prosecution thereof’ nor of the entry of any
decrees therein. Seon we ;
34.
_ this defendant states that it is now informed and ‘.
39
36
Answer of Defendant
Further answering paragraph numbered ‘8
believes and on such information and belief charges
- the fact to be that on the trial of said suits the
defendants therein did’ pot offer in evidence the
pertinent’ prior art, nor did the court consider or
have before it the pertinent prior art bearing on
the validity of said letters patent; that from such
‘pertinent prior art it must have appeared to the
court that the claims of said patent were and are
void for want of novelty; that the pertinent prior
art not before the court in said causes now ready to
be shown by this defendant is shown in the British
patents to -
Argand—No. 1425 of July 3, 1784,
_ Salsbury—No. 16,524 of September 3, 1895,
and in the United States patents to
Rutz—No..1,101,146 of June 23, 1914,
-VanLiew et al.—No. 941,897 of November 30, 1909,
Warren—No. 783,339 of February 21, 1905, "
and in the Russian patent to “it |
"Malcov—No. 1163 of July 9, 1968,
duly authenticated copies whereof will be produced
on the hearing of this cause.
‘This defendant further answering paragraph .
numbered ‘‘8,’’ alleges that the pertinent prior art
shows a device somewhat similar to the device dis-
closed in the aforesaid Letters Patent to Rutz, No.
1,101,146, of June 23, 1914, manufactured by the
‘Milwaukee “Gas Specialty Company of Milwaukee,
Wisconsin, and sold by that company in large num-
bers throughout the United States from approxi-
mately’ the year 1914 down. to the present date, a
specimen of which said device this defendant is
ready to produce in open court on the hearing of
this cause; and further in view of a device, said to
> . ~ -
ra es . -.
_
. ° ¢ ,
2 ’ . . R ;
13
Answer of Defendant |
be of ancient Chinese manufacture, purchased by 37 .
‘ the General Electric Company from a dealer on or
“about May 7, 1918, and on public display in its
‘museum at Nela Park, Cleveland, Ohio, for many
years thereafter, a photograph of: which said de-
vice will be produced upon the hearing of this
- cause; and this defendant further alleges that the
daims of said letters patent_cover aggregations of .
“well known elements, and are not for patentable -
combinations, and that all of the elements in the
"structure described in said letters patent or exem-
plified by said device were well known in the art
for more than ten years prior to December 26, 38°
1928. : 3 |
‘And this defendant further aver’ that the ele- .
' ments in the structure deseribed in said letters pat-
ent in suit or exemplified in said device were and |
are disclosed in the following: publications, all of
-which’were made public more than two years prior 7
to December 26,1928: Hee sarees, ae Ei tt
‘Histoire du Luminaire depuis Vepoque Ro- | Rd
maine jusqu’a XIXe Siecle by J. R. d’Allemagne, — | 4
published by Alphonse Picard, Paris, 1891, (John buat
Crerar Library, Chicago, Call No. L 62889 P - ° i |
- 100), particularly the descriptions and illustra- 39 - 14
tions on pp. 86-90, 154-5, and 272-3, and Plates _ ae on.
3, 6, 19, 20, and 29. ae
_ Das’ Beleuchtwngswesen by Ladislaus von
Benesch, published by Anton Schroll & Co.,
Vienna; 1908- (John. Crerar Library, . Chicago,
Call No. A 628.9 Q 500) -and particularly Fig.
Bete |
.. Ancient and. Modern Lighthouses by D. a ..
| _Heap, published by Ticknor & Co., Boston, 1889
_ (John, Crerar: Library, Chicago, Call” No. 627.9
‘ O 800) pp. 12-14 and Plates 2 and 3.. :
. / : if . . A oe 7. : e : % :
—_—_ P . - *
40
41
14
Answer of. Defendant
Lighthouses and Lightshige by W. H. Daven-
port Adams, published by Chas. Scribner & Co., -
New York, 1870 (John Crerar Library, Chicago,
Call No. 627.9 N 100) illustrationon p.15.
_ British Lighthouses by J. Saxby Wryde, pub- _
lished by T. Fisher Unwin, London, 1913 (John -
. Crerar Library, Chicago, Call No. 656. 9 R 307)
- illustration opposite p. 27. .
Artificial Light by M. Luckiesh, 1920 (John
Crerar Library, Chicago, Call No. 628.9 G 001 )
illustration opposite a
Further answering paragraph iia no ff
said bill of complaint, this defendant states that
the alleged invention described in said patent in
suit was described in a printed publication ,more.
‘than two years before the filing of the application
on said patent in the publication in 1856 at Lon.
don, England, of the specification of British patent ©
to Ami Argand, No. 1425 of July 3,.1784.
'. Further answering paragraph numbered ‘‘8”
this defendant avers that the devices of defendants
in said causes were and are substantially different
from the complained of devices sold by this defend-
ant; that the said complained of devices sold by. -
this defendant were. and are not made in accord-
ance with any of the claims in said patent; that
said adjudication of sdid suits has no bearing on
the issues herein by reason of the entirely differ- -
ent structure of the alleged infringing devices from _
that of the structures before the court in said suits.
: Further answering paragraph numbered ‘8,’’
defendant states that it is informed and believes
‘ and on the basis of such information and belief
charges the fact to be that said decrees of the Dis-
triet Court of the Northern District of Ohio, West-
ern pe mentioned in said bill of complaint
a . ie fo A. Pe — , i
15
Answer of Defendant
and alleged to be an adjudication of the validity of. 43
said Withrow and Close-patent in suit were entered
on the theory by the District Court which entered
‘said decrees that the substance of the invention of
said Withrow and Close patent in suit was the pro- .
tection of the flame at its. source; that it was~erro-
neously held ‘by the District Court in said causes
that the prior art patents pleaded and relied upon ©
by the defendants in said causes as showing an- 4
ticipation, namely, United States patents to:
Almond No. 193,796 of August 7, 1877, —
Blake. No. 453,335 of June 2, 1891,
~ Kahn No. 1,175,527 of March 14, 1916, 44 .
“Heston No. 270,587 of January 16, 1883, ;
Hathaway No. 147,496 of February 37, 1874,
did. not anticipate the flame guard of said Withrow:
and Close patent in suit and said District Court
held said Withrow and Close patent in suit valid
over said prior art as disclosed in said patents. _ 4
And further answering paragraph numbered . <
“39 defendant states that it is informed and be- - et.
- Teves and on the basis of such information and be- :
lief charges the fact to be that defendants in said
causes appealed said decrees of the District Court
for the Northern District of Ohio, Western Divi- 45
gion, relied upon herein as prior adjudication of 4
said Withrow and Close patent in suit to the Cir- : a
cuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit; thata . |
hearing on said appeal was had; that on or about
December 7, 1937, the said Cireuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Sixth Circuit filed an opinion in said
‘causes in which it was held that gaid Withrow and
Close patent in suit was void :for want of inveD-
- tion, on the ground that said patents last herein
‘ mentioned anticipated the said Withrow and Close
® patent in suit, and for greater certainty this de-
46
47
Sea eee aaa tense teat TEER er a yn nn
~ 16
Answer of eer
-fendant attaches hereto a true copy of said opinion
of said United States Circuit Court of Appeals for
the Sixth Circuit in said causes as Exhibit “A”
and by reference makes the same a part of this .”
- answer; and this defendant further states that the:
said Withrow and Close patent in suit is void by °
reason of having been anticipated nid the following
United States patents to
Almond No. 193;796 of August 7, 1877,
’ Blake No. 453,335 of June 2, 1891,
Kahn No. 1,175,527 of March 14, 1916,
Heston No. 270,587 of January 16, 1883,
Hathaway No. 147;496 of February 17, 1874,
which show the invalidity of said patent to With-
row and Close herein sued on.
9. Answering paragraph numbered ‘‘9,’’ this
defendant denies the allegation of-netice of plain-
tiff’s patent and: of its alleged said licenses; denies
infringing the-letters patent within .the Eastern
District of New York, or at any other place; denies
that it sells or has sold | any truck flares embodying
‘the inventions disclosed.in said letters ‘patent; de-
nies that it has injured plaintiff in any manner; and
alleges that the said ‘plaintiff’s. patent is void for
want of novelty and invention ; that even if the
_ Claims of said patent can be held to be valid for
any purpose, the complained of truck flares sold by
defendant do’ not include within their structure any
of the claims of said patent.
10. Answering paragraph numbered. 619” of
ee said bill of complaint, defendant admits that it has -
sold truck-flares from its said place of business .
marked ‘‘Mfd. by Anthes Force Oiler Co., Ft. Mad-
ison, Ia.,’? and admits that it purchased sail: truck
flares from the said Anthes Force Oiler Company,
but states that ‘t has no information or knowledge . -
17°
Answer of, Defendant
by whom said truck, flares were manufactured or 49
as to the present or former relationship of said
Anthes Force Oiler Company with plaintiff. a" s/f
Further answering paragraph numbered “10% \
defendant denies that the truck flares chagged here- |
in te infringe “closely resemble the ~iadlbotion of
Bolser and Kari-Keen truck. flares held to in-
fringe,”’ and this defendant states that subsequent
.to the filing of the bill of complaint herein the de-
erees relied on by the plaintiff were reversed by a’
decision. of the Cireuit Court of Appeals for the
Sixth Cireuit as aforesaid, and this defendant de-
nies that the said truck flares sold by defendant 50
infringe in their structure and operation: any ‘of the
claims of plaintiff’s said patent. rs, Capel
1. Answering. paragraph numbered ‘‘11”’ of
said bill of complaint, defendant denies that it has
damaged or injured or does or will damage or in-
- jure plaintiff by the sale of the complained of truck
flares, and denies that plaintiff has shown or stated
- any facts which entitle it to the issuance of any in- ie
junctional or other relief by this court enjoining or J dt
restraining this defendant ‘in'‘any way from selling |
“the complained, of truck flares, and -denies . that ae Bu
plaintiff has shown any facts entitling it to any of. 51 |
the relief against this defendant by ‘reason of its » i
| sale of the complained of truck flares. ; | ‘alt
"his defendant further avers that the complained a
_ of truek flares now being; sold by it are based in
their structure and theory of- operation upon the
_ luminescent flare, disclosed in the prior. art in the
British patent to Henry. Salsbury No. 16,524, of
the year 1895, in the Russian patént to Malcov No.
1163 of the year 1868, and in numerous prior pub-
- lications showing luminescent flares protected at .
the flame sonree, in combination with a flame guard,
ee
52
18 .
| Narratioe Statement of the Evidence
as disclosed in United States tatters Patent to a...
O. Rutz, No. 1 101,146, issued June 23, 1914, and
manufactured and sold by the Milwaukee Gas Spe-
‘Before:
cialty Company of Milwaukee, Wisconsin, for more
than ten years prior to December 26, 1928, and de-. -
fendant avers that the aforementioned structures
are in the public domain and available for the use i
of any person who so desires.
Wuenrerorg, this defendant denies that the plain-
tiff is entitled to-any of the relief prayed in its bill
of complaint and prays that the bill may be dis-
, Missed at plaintiff’ s costs.
Narrative Statement of the Evidence |
Brooklyn, New York, March 8, 1938.
Honoraste Grover My Moscowrrz,
| a District Judge.
, APPEARANCES: er
Dansy & Dany, Solicitors for the Plaintiff. SamvzL
E. Dany, Jr, Witser Owen, Of Counsel. |
AntHony Wiiuiam Detisr, Solicitor for the De-
fendant. Cant V. Wisner, Jr, Of Counsel. :
_PLAINTIFF'S CASE.
The plaintiff offered in -evidénce the following:
Deposition of Philip A. Kerwin.
‘Exhibit 1, Copy of patent in uit, Withrow aad
Close. No. 1,732,708.
_ Exhibit 2, Photostat of advertisement of Anthes
Withrow—F or. Plaintiff—Direct
as, weit :
~
Force Oiler Company showing Anthes first flare. 55) .
_-Bxhibit 3,-Photostat of advertisement of Anthes | : .
_ Force Oiler Company representing device on which aes Fi
Anthes Company refused to pay royalty...
+ Exhibit 4, Circular of Toledo truck flawe.
Exhibit 5, Direction sheet of plaintiff’s truck
flare. .
Exhibit 6, Certificate of approval of defendant’s |
flare by Electrical Testing Laboratories ‘ of. New
Thercapon, the plaintiff called as a witness
Josep E. WITHROW, who, being sworn, testified: 56
Direct Examination: by Mr. Owen:
Mr. Withrow: My name is J oseph E. Withrow.
I am one of the pater ‘ees of the patent in suit. I
i connected with the plaintiff since 1926. I -
w president of the plaintiff company ; for the
first few months, I think, I had the position of
‘treasurer. When I first became connected with the
plaintiff they were manufacturing’ the open flame.
McCloskey torch.. Later on that same year, we | |
‘went into’ production of our own toxch, which was 57 -
_an open flame torch. et A nies 6 ok et
This torch which you show me is one of the open
flame torches manufactured by us at that time.
Mr: Owen: Before going further, Your
Honor, I should like to offer in evidence a blue-
‘print produced by the witness Kerwin, in his
‘deposition, as a plaintiff’s exhibit.
(The blueprint was received in evidence and
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 7.) | a"
-T offer in evidence: a photograph which the _
_ witness Kerwin identified. _ |
err yn ee renee es tenes
°
58
_,
-Withrow—For Blaintif—Direct ,
(The. photograph was réceived -in evidence
4. and raarked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 8.)
Mr. Owen: I offer a later blueprint pro-
~ duced by the.witness Kerwin in his deposition,
- as a plaintiff ’s, exhibit. :
- (The blueprint was received in- evidence and
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 9.)
- Mr. Owen: I now. offer this open flame toréh
which the present witness has just*identified.
(The same was received in evidence and
| marked Plaintiff’s ’s Exhibit 10.) - :
The Witness: This is one of our circulars ilus-
trating this open flame torch.
Mr. Owen: I offer this circular in evidence.
' (The circular was received in evidence and
~ marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 11.)
' The Witness: That circular refers to a patent
dated January 11, 1927, on a method of fastening
_ the counterweight on the bottom of the torch. That
isa patent for an invenfion of our Mr. Close: He
*
_ 60
is vice- spresident of our company and joint pat-
entee with me’ in the patent in suit.
Mr. Owen: I offer this copy of the patent
in evidence.
(The copy of patent was received in evidence
and marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 12.)
The Witness:. The drawing of that patent rep-
resents the construction of the open flame torch
‘which has been offered as Plaintiff ’s Exhibit 10
here. In 1926, we sold 1, 121 of those torches, In
1927, we sold 26,620. In 1928, up to July the 15th,
we sold 19,689. On or about Jnly the 15th is when
we changed the burner to. what we called our im-
proved burner. - That improved: burner is repre-
. sented by this torch which you now show me.
Mr. Owen: I offer in evidence this torch
~
ope " ws Se et ee Oe
21 a
| | S
. Withrow—For Plaintiff —Direct
* with the improved burner just identified by the 61-
‘witness, = 8°: eearree
The same was received in evidence and =
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 13.) vay | |
The Witness: The principal purchasers of
torches like. these two that I have produced were
contractors and state highways. Those torches
did not give satisfactory service for their uses. We —
received many letters objecting to them. ‘
‘Mr. Owen: Now in the reeord of the Ohio
case, Your Honor, the witness read from a
_ large number_of those letters. fe
a The Court: Well, both sides seem to agree 62
that they ought to have a cap on. ‘[ -assume
that you thought it was desirable, and an im- | Pa t
provement over the old method. bis aS
Mr. Wisner: It makes the device more effi- re
cacious arainst strong winds, Your Honor. ae 1
"The Court: That is what you.aretryingto' -
prove, isn’t it, Mr. Owen? a |
The Witness:: We recommended to our custom- - 4 tae
- ers that the wick be extended an inch and a half on |; eth
these open flame torches. That recommendation —
was made by means of a yellow tag that we fast- ij
ened to the handle of each torch. an 68 ida
- Mr. Owen: This‘tag, Your Honor, reads ‘|
“Yoledo Torch. The normal length of ex- —
‘posed wick is about one and one-half inches.
Extend wick further for heavy weather condi-
_ tions.’’
i now offer the tag in evidence.
(The tag wag received in evidence and
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 14.) A
The Witness: After we had produced the im-
proved open flame torch, like Plaintiff ’g Exhibit 13,
we continued to receive objections to’ its perform-
. .
_ —_— :
64
o >
65
66
: Withrow—For Plaintiff —Direct
Oe
ance. The objections were that they: would be ex.
tinguished in extremely heavy winds and rains, -
_» The Court: That is not in dispute, is it?
Mr. Wisner: I.assume that they got a lot
of letters, Your Honor. ~
The Court: I mean that is not disputed asa
practical ‘thing,’
* Mr. Wisner: Occasionally. they | went out,
yes. :
‘The Witness: We continued our experiments in |
our efforts to overcome the objections to our open
flame torches. We were not satisfied with the
burner, and we continued to ‘experiment in an en-
, deavor to improve it. We thought we had miade a
definite step forward in the matter of the improved
burner when we started with Exhibit 13. Using
that burner as a base, we started experimenting
around the wick. Using that burner, we experi-
mented by placing structures around the wick
' on the edge of that flat surface. We built those
structures and we tried them out on that burner.
We tested them comparatively. We would take and
build a structure—as a matter of fact, the first :
~~—with structures placed on top of that burner and °
‘structure we built was compared with that one (in-_
-dicating), and if that structure was better than
what we had before, we would discard the poorer —
one, take the better one as a model and continue ex-
-perimenting, always using the best as a model.
These experiments continued several months. In
fact, it was up until the early winter of 1928.. Mr.
Close worked with me on those experiments.
I cannot produce any of the experimental devices |
which we made and tested in that time. , They were
placed in a store room, in a box in the factory at
Toledo, among other things which were not in com- .
, ‘ -
SN aes — —— ;
RIERA GENIE IONE, 2 SPREE g eer ey dante me" the aT
°
93° ¥ & —
| ne Plaintiff —Dtrect ;
\ * :
mon use. In J uly of 1929, we moved from those. 67 |
qusrters to a new loéation and somewhere in the
moving and cleaning out, the models disappeared.
' ‘We searched for them but we have not been able to
find them. I can produce Sneha’ or. drawings of
some of those experimental strnetures. Mr. Close « ~
. made the sketches just prior to our casein Toledo |
‘in 1935. - The old models—we had to make them up
_ from memory. We consulted together and re-
‘ freshed each other’s mind as to what was done and
we made those sketches which are remembrances - :
of some of the models.
‘Mr. Owen: I offer these sketches in ‘evidence vl
as on exhibit. ; +4
(The sketches were received in evidence ~~ See |
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibits 15 to "15-1, incu.
sive.) , }
“The Witness: I have an rn showing ae —
the construction of the torch? Plaintiff’s - Ex- ii j
hibit 13. oy i
.Mr. Owen: I offer this in evidence. eee
(The circular was received in evidence and x
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 16.) eo tetee
The Witness: As a result of those experiments, a4
__we produced this torch which is now shown me. _49- LS
‘That is the ‘torch of the patent in suit.
* Mr. Owen: I offer that in evidence.
(The same was received in evidence and
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 17. )
The Witness: In making these experiments, to.
overcome the objections to the open flame torch,
there were very definite limitations with reference |
to fuel and other conditions under which we were
working. The fuel had’ to be kerosene, being a
liquid fuel,:gasolene was a dangerous thing to place _
in the ‘positions where these torches were to be
nr .
-
— is aor EIR * i ;
a 2 .
4
no cite aah ala
70
71
72
:
XE ae beer rome nr rnmernninREnmeOTaRDINteT REE A ROTI
' ‘ . .
:
24 .
Withrow—For Plaintif—Direct
nsed—they were close to traffic ona other build.
ings, and often chijiren played around them.
The burner itself must necessarily be of a simple - -
construction for it to be handled by the ordinary _
laborer on street jobs. Many of the torches
to be put out at night around constructions, and it _
wonld not do to have too fine an adjustment on
them. - They. had to be made to be’ put out quickly.
Both of these conditions called for a wick burner.
The burner itself had to be of a rugged and com-
pact nature. The torches were @en hit by passing
traffic and rolled aver, and it was only a rygged.
structure that would stand up. They had to be
of a compact nature, because the weight of the.
. burner was in a location where it was a disadvan- - -
tage, particularly i in the construction torch with the
: weight. i in the bottom. The burner had to be coun- - *
terweighted, and the more weight there was in the
burner, the more, weight you had to have in the
_ bottom to give it stability. ° Of course, with the
truck torches, it was desirable td have the ss aaseeeh
rium stable too.
Mr. Owen: ‘I offer this paper in evidence. -
(The same was received in evidence and
. marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 18.)
' Mr. Owen: This is a drawing of Fig. 3 of .
the patent in suit with claims 2, 5, 11 and-12
applied.
The. Witness: Briefly, those different parts
which are represented by numerals and. by letters
_ are: <A torch body, No. 1, a wick W, a wick tubing
6a, 12a, a supporting and heat receiving flange 5a, *
.4 cap 7 with an imperforate’ top 8, with flame open-
ings 9. and air inlets 10. The heat receiving and
wick. supporting flange i is attached to the wick tube
_ 6a, 12a, and rests upon the et for the CAP,
ee ttle
: e
. a a ee see . ~ —_- —
Withrow—F or Plaintiff —Direct
and:in this manner supports the wick tube, and the 73°
cap is screwed down into that same receptacle onto”
the flange, and by this means is a heat receiving
After we had placed this patented torch on the
market, that is, like. Plaintiff’s Exhibit 17, there
were a great many:sold. The sales increased up to
_ the time of the depression. =~ :
The Court: Have you got the figures?
The Witness: I have, "Your Honor. .
. The Court: Do you want the figures on the
record? + ieee sip
.- Mr. Owen: Yes, I. would like to have that - 74
on the record. = 7 ;
The: Witness in the first year, 1929, there were |
_ 46,624 torches with Economy burners on. the .
' torches sold, and-18,359 burners sold separately, to Ff
be placed upon torches that were then in use, that = ¢ Soa
is, the old open flame torches that were then in use. af
- ‘In 1930 there were 53,422 torches sold, 5,524 sep-4
arate burners. In 1931, there were 2,953 torches’
.sold, and 4,048 separate burners. ~ These. were of
our manufacture. - is Ae ae
At that time the depression was affecting our
business quite severely; our regular business in’
other fields had practically stoppe ‘and we con-
tinged to maintain practically the same sales of
this ‘particular. item. I received letters from cus- |
tomers indicating whether of not this new torch Beare
_ withstood -high winds and rains. Those letters I | |
~ read from in the Toledo record. | |
Pee Owen: Well, if Your Honor will per- .
mit, we will just refer you to those letters ‘if -
| you are,interested in reading the excerpts.
pre Mr. Wisner: Of course, I press my objec
tion to the hearsay nature of the statements. —
a.
\ ar P
wr
-
se te .
x Sot Peng eng EEL Bee ET A
F ; :
: . Pehapeniteenge-ess soem tha RAS REEMA : ,
° - . PELE AP! EG ARETE HRA
’ ™ a ee oe
SEALE
_-*
en
76
77
78
se
26
Wullivew=Ker Plaintiff Dire
. The Court: I do ndt sedesident that. there
will be any question about it. You both agree
that it is efficient. The ‘defendants say that.
the product they are making is similar, but
they are both efficierit. ' I dgnot think you have
' to waste much time about that. I do not sup.
pose either of you would’ be producing them |
unless you thought that they were efficient, -
The Witness: The old. open flame torches such
as Plaintiff’s Exhibits 10 and 13 were not used as
warning signals on the’ public highways for parked
‘trucks and busés. |
The Court: You left off what year, was it us
1930? :
The Witness:.1931, I believe.. |
The Court: Have you the succeeding years!’ |
The Witness: _I have the succeeding years. In
1932, there were 43, 197 torches, 3,375 burners. In
1933, there were 76,919 torches, 1,904 burners. * In’
.
1934, there were 56,401 torehes, 2,151: burners.
“I did not list the Economy. burners any further.
The torches, in 1935, 134,831. In 1936, 186 479.
In. 1937, 129,739, making a’ total of all torches of.
- 780,565; and Economy burners 35,361.
The prices during most of that time, the torch -
with the Economy burner, listed at $18 per dozen, .
I think, and: now I think they are listed at $16, -
with 50 and 10 off. And the Economy burners were
sold at $4:a dozen with the same discount; at that ..
time I think the discount was 25 per cent, 25 and 5..
The date when the new torch, Exhibit’ 17, was:
placed on the market, as I-remember, January 7,
1929, was our first. invoice. Within a few months ae
after we brought out the Economy burner, the Mc- -
Closkey Torch Company followed with a burner. |
‘which was very similar to it.
2
’ ‘OT ~
_ Withrow—For Plaintiff—Direct —
-- Q63; And when did the first infringing torches
or flares appear on. the market? a
| Mr. Wisner: I object. .. .
The Court: Of coursé, that is a question I
will have to: determine. 2 ee
The Witness: The. first infringing torch to ap-
) pear on the market -was the McCloskey torch, the
- one I was just speaking of. Others appeared par- |
ticularly in 1933 and 1934, There were a number
_ of a type similar to the Bolser Corporation, and
those made by the Kari Keen Manufacturing Com-
pany. Those were the two involved in the Toledo
ease. We had three licensees at that. time, the
~-Anthes Force Oiler Company at Fort Madison,
Iowa, the K. D. Lamp Company of Cincinnati;
Ohio, and the Do-Rey Lamp Company of Chicago,
. Illinois. ae :
__ Keonomy burner is the name that we gave to our
new patented burner. We gave it that n be-
_ eanse of the economy in fuel and wick coxsump-
tion. When we put this burner out on tké market
we marked it ‘‘Patent pending’’ until the patent
was ‘issued, and then marked it with the patent
_ number. Rade NS ©
Mr. Owen: Your Honor, we have intro-
79
81
duced quite a number of drawings showing the - .
experimental: devices, and the witness did not
’ go into any detailed explanation. I would like
to ask him'to do that unless Your Honor would -
prefer not to have it.
~The Conrt:, Is it in that other record?
Mr. Owen: To some extent, yes. |
‘The Court: Is that in question at all? .
“ments, I know nothing about it, I assume they
a ,
Mr. Wisner: Whether they made the experi-
.
7 .
hel
°
_ larly cold weather.
ithrow—For
The Court: Unless it is questioned let us
. assume‘that they did. e °
~ The Witness: From ‘tie experiments which we 3
conducted in 1928 resuiting in the production of
the Economy burner, we found that some types of ©
burners would work better in some wéather con. -
ditions and others in different weather conditions,
There are some types of. burners that would fune-
tion in the wind, and the same burner that fune
tioned well in the wind might not function so well .
in calm, comparatively calm weather, on a calm
‘day. Others that would function well in calm ,
“weather would not function sd. well in windy
weather. The accumulation of carbon was particu-
larly prevalent on the calmer days and in particu-
The introduction of the’ Economy burner prac-
tically drove our open flame torches off the mar--
ket; for a short time, a year or eighteen months
thereafter, there were some sales of the old open
- flame burner, but then they stopped completely.:
The open flame. burner was not customarily used -
as a warning signal for parked trucks and buses. _
There might have, been one-or two used in an emer-
gency that I do not know about, but otherwise they
were not. The Economy burner is used for that -
purpose entirely now. Of course, there are some
other burners of ‘that type. I will say our, Econ-
omy burner and other burners of that type are
used exclusively. The only difference. in .a track
flare and the one used as a construction torch is in —
the ‘size and shape.of the torch body. The torch
flare also has what>we call a sealing cap on it -
‘ which the contractor’s torch does not. “You: can
extinguish the flame, you can blow on it and blow —
me ——
it out. ;
° . *- \ ce °
=~ ~ 3 mY aes ME my —
~~. . ; ba .
i
29
Withrow—For Plaintiff—Direct
Mr: Owen: One of-plaintiff’s truck flares:
is offered ‘n evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1°.
(Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 19 in evidence.)
The Witness: The torch is what has customarily
come to be: known as the contractors’ torch, which
is the larger size, usually spherical in shape, and
sumetimes, but not always, having a weighted bot-
tom. A flare is the.smailler torch which is used for.
guarding trucks and buses.. The burners in our
; and torches are practically the same, except
that in some of the flares we hiave what we call a
sealing cap, and thert is a slight difference in the
' -part-in which the cap screws. |
- - [Three éther manufacturers besides those pre-
~ viously mentioned - have takén licenses under the
- patent in suit. I have some circulars here showing
the constructions manufactured by our different
~ licensees-under the patent in suit.
Mr: Owen: The witness, produces cire@lars
. as follows, which I will.ask the clerk to mark as
exhibits: Te Saphe
Dietz circular, as Exhibit 20.
(Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 20 in evidence. )
Mr:Owen: .Do-Ray Superfiare circular, as
Exhibit 21. sot eo te
. (Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 21 in evidence.)
Mr. Owen: That is manufactured by the Do-
‘Ray Lamp Company, Chicago, Tilinois, and the
Dietz is manufactured by the R. E. Dietz Com-
*. pany, New York. hy se ;
Another circular of the Storm King Signal
Flate, manufactured by Shanklin Manufactur-
_ing Company of ‘Springfield, Mlinois, as Ex-
bihit’22.° : 3 aie ia
(Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 22 in evidence.)* -
Mr. Owen: Ones of: Luck-E-Lite Truck ©
88
89
90.-
. ®
30
| Withrow—For Plaintiff —Direct
Flare, diiiinaiuals by Embury Memufeectar
ing Company of Wersaw; New York.
(Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 23 in evidence.)
The Witness: -I conducted tests for the purpose -
of determining the fuel consumption of .the old
open flame Toledo torch and the patented torch.
and 19, 1935. The burners tested were the old.
flame torch, like Exhibit 10, and a torch using
an Economy ‘burner, like Exhibit 19. The summary -
of results was that the open flamé torch averaged -
4.95 ounces per hour and the flare 2.0 Ounces per
hour of fuel. Each of those tests Was conducted
over approximately eight hours. There were six
: in of tests were run’ on April 12,.15, 16, 17,
18
_ different tests of eight hours each.
Mr, Owen: I will offer that data sheet i in *
evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 24.
(Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 24 in evidence.)
The Court: Were they gn tM same size
wick?
The Witness: Yes, those were the same
size wick, Your Honor. | |
’ The Court: And under the same conditions?
The Witness: Yes, Your Honor, except that —
- in the old style torch the wick was extended
one and a half. inches as prescribed in the di-
rections for its use, and in the Economy:
burner the wick was extended an eighth of an
inch. ’
The & urt: I mean was it done at the same, .
time? |
The: Witness :. Done at the s same time, at the
same place and under the same conditions.
Mr. Owen: I offer in evidence a sheet con-
taining ‘a drawing of the defendant’s, flare,
with claims 2, 4, 11 and 12 of the ts
: applied.
bl
Withrow—For Plaintiff—Direct -
-(The sheet was received in evidence. and °
marked. Plaintiff's Exhibit 25.) ”
Myr. Wisner: Are you seéking to use the
- witness as an expert, Mr. Owen?
Mr. Owen: No. |
The Witness : This drawing shows a torch
body 7, = = wick ‘“W”’ and a wick tube ‘‘6-A’’
and ‘‘12- A. * A wick tube supporting flange {‘5-A”’
and a guard consisting of a eap, ‘‘7,’’ with an im-
perforate top ‘‘8,” with flame openings ‘‘9”’ a nd
a heat receiving and cenducting flange ‘‘11-A,”’ and
91
the air openings ‘‘10’’ in the heat conducting: .
‘flange. I have tested torches constructed like this
92
drawing made by the Anthes Force. Oiler Com- ~
‘pany Alongside of our own flare, with the Economy
burner. ‘They opérated substantially the same
_ way. The results are substantially the same. I did
not list the results myself. . I observed those re-
‘sults, however. This is an Anthes flare like. the. one
that I saw tested.
Mr. Owen: I offer it in evidence as a plain-
tiff’s exhibit. :
(The same was received in evidence and
‘marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 26.)
The Witness: In conducting tests of the Econ-
omy flare and the Anthes flare, I know that note of
the fuel consumption was taken but I was not fol-
lowing the figures on that.
‘I have an advertisement or circular of the Mc-
_Closkey open flame torgh, and one of the McClos-
key closed flame torch. This closed flame torch was
. brought out within a few months after our Eeon-
_ omy burner had been on the market. The first Mc-
Closkey open flame torch I saw was in August of
93
1925. I understand they had been in production .
since May-of - ‘ but the first ones I saw was
sone grees
32 |
Withrow—For Plaintiff —Cross
94. in August. The figures of the McCloskey open
flame torch show the proper wick Ee, as it
_ Was practically used:
Mr. Owen: The circular of the open flame
torch is offered i in evidence as a plaintiff’s eXx-
hibit.
(The decane % was received in Widence and
marked Plaintiff’s: Exhibit 27.)
Mr. Owen: I also offer in evidence the cir.
cular of the McCloskey closed flame. torch, -
(The circular was received in evidence and
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 28.)
Cross antes by Mr. Wisner :
The Witness: - My.first sateen conneéetion with
the torch field was in 1926. ;
The Court: What do you mean by that? .
The Witness: I had some money invested inthe
Toledo Preéssed* Steel Company since August cof
1925: I did not persenally , participate i in the-com-
pany until 1926. ° \
The torch which has been marked Plaintiff ’s Ex-
hibit 10 came out in November of 1926. I think the
96 cubical contents of that a is 7/10ths of a gallon.
I do not know what the cubical contents in inches
is. I cannot tell you what the inside height is from
the bottom to the top space. This structure, Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 10, was ‘superseded by: Exhibit 13.
_ Exhibit 10 was the one I tested in*contrast with
. the improved torch, Exhibit 19. Exhibit 13 was su-
perior in some of its performances, to Exhibit 10.
The wick size is three-quarters of an inch.
The Court: Did you test Exhibit sek
The Witness : No.
| The Witness: We used the earlier torch for
5 ~ D4
. ; - . ; a
> . , ix :
* ; 4 a . ‘ . «eon y fess 3
A TMG Bet Onan rane omer eae ike cienesiettat.
a s
. *
¥
a
33
Wanrey—-rer Plaintiff—Cross
comparative purposes, Your Honor. We recom-* 97
"mended a wick extension of one and a half inches.
We based our recommendation of one inch and a
half wick extension, on tests that we made, and ex-
tending the wick to get the best results in severe -
weather, and also the fact that when you put the
tyrch in use in the evening, that before morning
a considerable portion of tlfat wick was burned off,
and during the night there i is a possibility of sudden
storms, and it was necessary to at least start with
an inch and a half in order to have sufficient wick
‘to function during the night. The same kind of ..
wick is in the new improved torch, Exhibit 19, that ° 98
-was in Exhibit 10. | |
The Court : Now, what do you ‘mean, the
same what? A. The same dimension.
‘The Court: You do not mean the extension?
Mr. Wisner: No, Your Honor. It is ex- .
tended up much less. 3 oe
The Witness: Our theory was, in :making the
change from the torch with the wick tube which pro-
trudes from the top to the torch from which no wick
“tube ‘protrudes from the top, that a breeze blow-
-ing would: cool the wick tube and thereby cool the
oil, and also that the wick tube extended down into 99
the body and it could, therefore, conduct heat into
the torch body and help heat the oil in the body
itself, That. is if the oil inside the container is
_ hotter, the flare is more likely to. stay lit. Our.ex-
perience is that we can keep-it hotter by inverting . «
the. wick tube and having the extension. down in : |
rather tian up above where the wind can play on
it. We made various: experiments in all of which
we maintained the wick tube down insi We had |
already made our experiments with the wick tube sl
~ Up, and concluded that was s not Tight. as
|
. 34
Withrow—For Plaintiff —Cross
100 XQ130. So when you hein patting the hood
around the torch, one of the purposes of that hood -
is to prevent any cool’air from reaching the wick
tube? A. No. . |
The Witness: The effect the hood has on the
; wick tube is that-it reflects heat back on the tip of
_. the wick, where the foundation of the flame is, and |
also is heated and there is a conduction of heat
. through the:cap down through the flange into the
wick tube surrounding the wick at the tip. One of
' our objects in-putting this structure on was to keep ;
' that wick-tube hot.
i — - _XQ133. And keep the hrecnee—frods blowing on
tt A No, we had never thought about -the
breezes.
. XQ134. You abandoned the. sheng to prevent
| the breezes from blowing on it when you turned
i the wick tubirig upside down— A. We did not.
abandon, we had accomplished it then.
XQ135. That wus the way you did it? A. That |
was the way we did it.
XQ136. Now, the patent says something about a
dead air space. That, I assume, is the space which
exists immediately below the air ports and between n/
}. 102 the side of the flame, guarding the wick tube? K
Thai is around the wick.
ig XQ137. Around the wick, between the end of the
wick and— A. I don’t think the patent. says dead
air space.
XQ138. ) Sea . quiescent air? <A.. -A layer
of quiescent a,
-XQ139. And the positioning of these air holes is
such that that layer of quiescent air is permitted to
exist? A. It really is not quiescent air, it does not
go anywhere, it circulates around down in there, it
is not really quiescent but it is prevented from. mov-
}) Sa ne ing out of the esp. -
Ce ee en a ee eee
35
fa Withrow—For Plaintiff-—Cross
XQ140. Now, as I understand you, this particu-
lar structure is a compromise—that is, you tried
out various structures, some would work well in
calm weather and ‘some would. work well in very
stormy weather. Now, in“which particular kind of
weather is. this structure supposed fo work? A. In
both.
108
XQ141. And does it work better in calm weather
or better in stormy weather? A. It works a little ©
better with the wind blowing. —
-XQ142. Not so well in calm ‘weather? .A. ‘No.
J we were to light this torch and set it out—
whether there is any wind or not—some soot would
' jmniediately begin to accumulate around the top
burner, both on the inside’ and outside, and some
around the flame port. There would be an accumu-
lation of those particles of soot-—that is true of all
burners. Soot would accumulate around the wick
tube of such a burner as Exhibit 10. The burner
104
marked Exhibit 17 is the type of construction torch .
that we put out first, using this burner, except for
what we call a screw-collar. There is no import-
art difference, however. In these tests that we
mide, comparing the performances of the two burn-
- .ers,-we made no test between the large torch Ex-
hibit 17, and the large unprotected. torch, Exhibit
10. In connection with this. torch, Exhibit 17, we
put out some circulars. ey
-XQ149. An} in any one of those circulars which
- were offered in evidence in the previous case, was
there a statement to the effect that the toreh would
-barn in windy or rainy weather for 24 pours or
more—I refer to ‘the torch of the type of Exhibit
- 10? A. That is probably true, I don’t know.
105
XQ150. Some such statement to the effect, ‘This.
large torch will burn through wind and rain for
.
.
Lee % : oe ware
PR RE rrr eee mneremn neuen mars
ities
‘
107
108
36
Withrow—For Plaintiff—Cross
~ 106 twenty-four honrs, if necessary, on one filling,”
was made in that circular, was it note . A, I pre-
sume so.
Those tests which I summarized in Exhibit o4
were made on the .roof of our factory building at
Toledo in the day time. In those tests the wick of
the torch under test, the cpen flame torch, was an
inch and a half high and the wick of the enclosed
flame torch was one-eighth @nch high. FP did not
make any observations of:the amount of light which
the respective torches emitted, the. candle power,
the light that was.given off was suitable for the
purpose for which they were intended. There was
a wind blowing. :
_° The Court: I suppose—of cotirsé I do not. -
know if it can be agreed, but it seems to me
with the open wick there would be more light
than with the closed, ordinarily I a that
would be so. ~
Mr. Wisner: Ordinarily. . In some cases
there is and in some cases there is not.
_ The Court: I am not talking .where it is
| blowing too hard, but I am talking about where |
you light it under ordinary conditions.
' Mr. Owen: I would like to have the witness
answer that inquiry. |
The Court: All right, answer ik” ‘
‘The Witness: We weren’t interested in the
amount of light given off, because the light in
either case was sufficient for the purpose for
which the torch was intended. ,. |
I do not know how fast the air was blowing at
any time during the tests. I had not means of
measuring it. When I tested comparatively the de-
fendant’s flare and the plaintiff’s flare, there were
no such measurements made on those tests.” They
37
Withror w—For Plainti if —Cross
looked to function in the same way, and they with-
stood the same kind of wind, and in comparison
with our open flame torch the open flame torch
would go out and both the Toledo torch and the
Anthes torch would remain lighted.
The Court: When you say they went out,
was there a wind?
The Witness: Yes, there was wind.
. I didnot at any time ascertain what the fuel
bevels were in the torches which I was testing. I
did’ not participate in that; my tests were purely
of observation. When I tested Exhibit 10 and Ex-
hibit 19 we filled them up to the top, then weiglied
. ‘them and burned them, and then. reweighed them to
find out how much oil had been consumed. Re-
ferring to Exhibit 18, and the numeral 7 on, the left
’ hand of Fig. 3 of that exhibit heat was conducted
down the side of this cap, down the left side, for
example, and down into the ring unnumbered at
__ the: bottom of the cap it went around the side of-
the hole. : The heat that would go into the flange —
lla would only be through the contact that this.
particular wick tube has with 5a. There is some -
_ heat conduction in 11a other than what it receives
from 5a, but that would be from heat reflection
from the flame onto lla itself. The path of the
heat reflection I am talking about is a general heat.
enclosed within.a very small space that is radiated
- and reflected back from the walls of that small
109
110
11
space. And it is feflected from the dome 8: down to’ |
this flange lla. There is some conduction from the
flange 11a to the wick tube. Flange lla is sup-
ported itself by the flange 5a. ‘I referred to it only.
in conjunction with 5a as supporting -and heat re-
ceiving flange. The real Pint of support for the
", flange is on 5a alone. They: are supporting the’
tie tube and the wick.
ee a pete nas
t~
5 gh
112
114
38
Withrow—Por Plaintif—Rediret
Prior i my investment of inqney in the Toledo.
Pressed Steel Compary in 1925, I had had no ex-
perfnce i in ‘the manufacture of torches. !
: Redire@PEcamination by M r. Owen:
‘The Witness: The reason we did not test the open
flame torch, Exhibit 10, against the closed flame
torch, Exhibit 17, for fuel consumption was that
‘ the tests were being made to compare the Toledo
torches against. the infringers in- ‘the Toledo: case, .
. ° and the exhibits that were being used or were going
113 -
to be used were. all flares, so we were testing the
Toledo flare against. the flare of Kari Keen and —
Bolser, and that is why the flare ofthe Toledo Com- °
_ pany was used rather than the torch. We were test-
ing all three against the old open flame torch for
fuel consumption. ‘There was no difference in the ©
construction of the burner in the Economy. flare
that was used in that test, Exhibit 19, or one like
Exhibit 19, and the burner which formed a part of
the Economy torch, Exhibit 17.. The wick exten-
sion in the open flame torch like Exhibit 10, which
was tested with the Toledo flare, like Exhibit 19,
and the Bolser and Kari Keen flares, had a wick .
‘extension the same as that flare or torch was used
.in practice in the field. In other words, the ad-
justment of the wick'there was exactly the same as
' we recommended for use in thé field. And the ad-
justment of the wick in the uew Exhibit 19 flare was
the same as we recommend for use in the field. z
The Court: By the wavy, HOW _ was |
wick? 8 |
Mr. Owen: They recommend an eighth of
an inch in their: literature.
_ The Witness: In the old open flame Toledo torch
WANA 7
* . _»
° , . stl
kta ane ee ¥ = . . f 4 . =
39
Withrow—For. Plaintiff—Recross
the wick consumption would depend on: how often .115
itwas used. The consumption for over night would =~
vary from one inch to—from three-quarters of an
“inch to an inch or an inch and a quarter. Those
"wicks were eighteen inches long. I think those
wicks would probably function down to within six
or seven inches. There had to. be enough wick left
to extend to the bottom of the torch. That would
_ be approximately seven or eight inches, so that :
about ten inches could be burned.
Recross Examination by Mr. Wisner: — a
: - | 116
. The Witness: In the defendant’s structure the
heat would be reflected from all the inside surfaces
of the cap 7, and there would be some reflection as
well as conduction of the flange 11a onto the wick
_ tube. The flange lla in the defendant’s structure
does not support ‘anything; it is‘supported by the
~ wick tube. | , }
_ RXQ. Still referring to the drawing, Exhibit’
95, and defendant’s structure, the wick tube there:
is so positioned that these cool airs which were so
deleterious to the proper burning of the flare can
* play upon it, can they not? A. Yes, that is true. 117 ,
~* You are talking about the old open flame construc- cer.
ee a
_. RXQ. Yes, the air that played_onto the pro-—
truded wick tube of Exhibit 10, likewise plays upon
the wick tube of the defendant’s torch, as shown
in Exhibit 25? A. That is right. —
Redirect Examination by Mr: Owen:
RDQ. Do I understand you to say that the flange |
lla does not support anything in defendant’s struc- ate o }
wrewry eileen Achebe dainhetetisldaiiel . Borst
t , ;
7
Sinead
yamine rate ee
* ee
RO me ope oe en ot
Close—For Pleintig—Divoct :
-_—
118 ture? A. It is supported by the wick tube ; it does
119
Support. the cap 7.
RDQ. I do not recall whether I asked yon re.
garding the wick consumption in your Economy
torches and flares: A. There is practically none.’
7
In fact, we guarantee the wicks for.a year, and we —
never have had to make good on that guarantee.
Lyman W. ‘Cross. called as a linens on behalf
of the plaintiff, having been duly swornAestified . |
as follows:
Direct Ezonftion by Mr. Owen:
The Witness: I am a resident of Toledo, Ohio,
and Wee-president of the Toledo Pressed Steel
Compariy. |
The Court: Is this witness your expert -
_Mr. Owen?.
Mr. Owen:. No, Your Honor. .
The Witness: I am one of the inventors of the
patent in suit. Prior to the invention of ‘the pat-
ent in suit, after studying mechanical engineering ©
_ at the Armour Iustitute of Technology, I joined
_ 120.
the engineering department of the Griffin Wheel
Company in Chicago, and I had. considerable ex- ot
perience in plant lay-out work at Denver.
The series of drawings that Mr. Withrow pro-
duced marked Plaintiff's Exhibit .15, have * <a
written matter on them.* I placed it there. rep-
resents an explanation of the construction -and
funetion of the device so pictured. I made those. |
sketches myseif.
Tam familiar with the tests to which torches ina :
flares are subjected by the different ‘states, in de-
ciding whether they will be’ accepted for use on the
. “41: .
: Close—For Plaintiff —Direct
public highway. I havé attended such tests. in the
State of Iowa, the State of Ohio, and the Electrical
- _ [Testifig Laboratories here in New York. The tests
in Iowa consisted of a wind tunnel test to deter-
_ mine whethar or ‘not the torches would withstand a
specific wind velocity of 35 miles an hour, I believe,
I would have to check that—35 or 40 miles an.hour,
which they require in order to approve torches. for
use in the State of Iowa.
‘Tests made in Ohio were of a similar nature.
They used a wind tunnel to determine the velocity
at which the torch would burn consistently. They
set a maximum of 35 miles | an hour. We ested the
‘ torches -in that wind tunnel test and demonstrated
that'they would pass that 35 miles an hour test. In
Ohio we tested the open flame ‘Toledo torch, we *
tested the closed flame Toledo torch and the Toledo
- flare. The ones with the closed, burners passed the :
tests successfully and those without -did not. » The
Electrical Testing Laboratories here in New York
conducted tests on flares of all manufacturers, in
order to establish whether or not they would be sa‘-
isfactory for use in the State of Pennsylvania. The
_ State of Pennsylvania got up a set of specifica.
. . tions, and those specifications were followed in the
tests by the Electrical, Testing Laboratories, "not
only on our flares, but on practically all other man-
ufacturers’ flares. Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6 is ‘a fac-
simile of the report of the results offered by the |
Electrical Testing Laboratories on a test made on
' the Anthes type 8B flare. «
Q19. What ‘were those tests?
' -“Phe Court: Are they set forth there?
\ The Witness: They are, Your Honor.
- Q20. Referring to the tests set forth in that
" document, will you state how those tests were con-
.
.
.
— Loe 7
e .
- . .
‘121.
122
123 *
‘ . ;
dicen aipeErne wna Ant
een 5
42
o
Close—For Plaintiff—Direct
124 ducted in your presence, with the Toledo Economy
flare? A. There were four main tests, one of them
" was to subject a set of flares to a vibration test
125
126
per minute, with an anvil shock test on each vibra-
tion. This test continued for two hours. I wit- -
-nessed the test and saw the results of our torch —
which passed the necessary requirements. Theré
was a weatherproof test in which the flares were
lighted and subjected to a standard spray of water
at 1/10th of an inch a minute for 15 minutes, and —
then 3/100ths of an inch a minute for 30 minutes
7
‘through a quarter-inch amplitude of 300 vibrations —
and 1/100th of an inch a’ minute for 45 minutes,
during which time the torch was rotated at the rate
of 4 revolutions a minute. We passed that test.
The water was applied through a standard spray
inclined at an angle of 60 degrees, right on the wp %
of the torch and the surrounding area.
‘The third test was the visibility test, the require-
ments being: that the torch be visible for 500 feet. -
The qualifications were interpreted in- terms of ©
candle power and the candle power ef the torch was _
measured while being ‘subjected to*an air stream
of 5 miles an hour and rotated four times a minute,
at the rate of 4 revolutions a minute, and the .
amount of candle power demonstrated was at a vis-”
ibility of 500- feet. The same requirements, that
they be visible at 500 feet was invoked for a veloc-
ity of 40 miles an hour. ‘ Of course, there was more
light issued: by all torches at 5 miles an hour than
there was at.40 miles an hour, but the candle power
at 40 miles an hour was still sufficient to énable the
laboratory .to report that it was visible at 500 feet.
That 40-mile an hour test was -continued long
enough to measure the candle power.
The next dest was the reliability and ie test.
Pie ie oe ae
Close—For Pilaintiff—Direct
‘A 40 mile an hour wind was played on the torch, 127
and it was requjred to stand that wind while being
- yotated:-at thé rate of 4 revolutions a minute, for
15 minutes, and thereafter a 5 mile an hour wind -
was’ directed against the torch and it was rotated
at the rate of 4 revolutions a minute and required
to burn 11 hours and 45 ininutes, or a total of 12
‘hours if total time. That was the end of the test
and our torch passed that test also. Our burner
passed all the tests. The flare which was.tested .
was like that of Exhibit ~~ |
‘New: Hampshire, Rhode Island, Nebraska, Louis-
iana, Arkansas and several other states have re- 128
quirements similar to that of Pennsylvania. Ap- ©
proximately | two-thirds of the states now have flare
laws, and approximately one-half have Jaws similar
- to those of Pennsylvania. |
- The Court: What\are those tests Sahih cae
is, where are the flarfs used?
_ The Witness: The torches are used for
buses. and trucks, Your Honor, on the high-
ways. ,
A typical flare law regulating trafic on highways
in the State of, Arkansas reads: * :
_ “No person shall operate any motor truck ona 129
‘highway outside of a business or residence district |
* at any time from a half hour after sunset to a half
hour before sunrise, unless there shall be carried
in such vehicle a sufficient number of flares, not
less than three, or electric lanterns or other signals
capable of continuously producing three warning
lights, each visible from a distance of at least 500
feet, for a period of at least 8 hours, except that a
motor vehicle transporting inflammables may carry -
Ted reflectors in _ of the. other signals above
mentioned. ee
“4
—_—_ Ptr» @
> ors :
. Sones gota ne eee
120
44.
Close—For Plaintiff —Direct o_
“Every such flare, lantern, signal, or reflector,
shall be of a type approved by the. Commission, and
it shall. publish lists Zi hose devices which it has
approved as adeqn for the. a aoa of this
section.”? ;
The approved spivitidations a are not set up here
yt our flares, like Plaintiff’s Exhibit 19, pass these
. Various requirements.
There is an Interstate Commerce set of specif.
cations which affects vehicles engaged in interstate
> and handling materials which are inter-
131
132
state in their aspect. \/The law of the Interstate
Commerce Commissign' reads as follows:
— “On every bus, truck, or truck tractor operating
-ouviside the. corporate limits of municipalities—”
I might say that this:is Section D of No. 3 of
the Motor Carrier Safety: Regulations, gotten out
by the Interstate Commerce Commission, Item B
under No. 8, and it reads:
| “At least three flares or three red electric lan-
terns, unless the mofor vehicle is operated solely on
streets or highways which are artificially lighted at
rite each flare (liquid burning pot torch) or red
electric lantern shall be capable of being seen and -
distinguished at a disgpnce of .500 feet under
- normal atmospheric conditions; ‘each flare (pot
torch) shall be capable of burnin for not less than
12 hours in 5 miles per hour wind velocity, capable
of burning in any. air velocities from zero to 40
miles per hour, substantially constructed so as to
withstand reasonable shoeks without leaking, and
" shall be carried in a metal rack or box.’?
And then there is a footnote which reads: |
‘‘Flares (pot torches), fusees or any sigtial pro- .
duced by a flame, shall not be carried or used as .
warning signals for motor: vehicles used in the
45
‘Close—For Plaintiff —Direct
transportation of inflammable liquids in bulk and 133
‘for motor vehicles transporting compressed inflam-
mable gases ; ‘but in lieu of such flares-and fusees
three.red electric lanterns shall be carried and used
as warning signals for such vehicles.’’ ;
‘ Mr. Owen: I understand that the Anthes
‘defendant’s torch has passed all of these re-
quirements. That will not be disputed? -
_ Mr. Wisner: ‘As far’as I know. Z
“The. Witness: We first marketed our Economy
torch in January of 1929. I heard Mr. Withrow’s
testimony regarding certain fuel consumption tests :
conducted about. 1935. |I was present. at those tests 134
and can verify them. I have’ conducted tests of
the Toledo and Anthes closed type flares, for the
purposes of showing | the comparative fuel con- -
sumption. The. results ‘show that the’ fuel- con-
sumption of the two torches .was substantially the
same, under the same conditions. Those ‘tests were
conducted since February the Ist, 1938, in Toledo
on the roof of our factory building, under normal
conditions. We also conducted wind velocity tests
and fuel consumption tests and luminosity tests.
‘The wind velocity tests were ‘conducted. in the wind
tunnel at Polytechnic Institute in Brooklyn, in the 135
wind tunnel of the mechanical engineering lebora-
tory.
Oh, I think that you refer to the wind tunnel test
made in Toledo? We have a wind tunnel in Toledo,
built to the specifications suggested by a fan man- —
facturing company, and we were enabled by the
use of reduction plates on the back of this tunnel,
having a fan of fixed velocity, to -vary the speed
within certain restricted limits. The torches were
tested in front of this wind tunnel -at those various
_ speeds, under the same conditions.
Be ieee oe
Ae pink MB MOAIN SEY moe
Ne
136
138 .
6
Close—For Plaintiff —Direct
- We found that the highest speed hat: we could ~
get in that tunnel with that fan velocity wag
28 °7/10ths miles an hour. Inasmuch as 15 min-
utes was the limit on the state tests, we arbitrarily
determined that if the torch gave evidence of burn: |
‘ing continuously for more than 15 minutes, that we
would stop the test at 15 minutes.. The Anthes and
_ Toledo torches both withstood that air ns and
also the lower speeds, of course.
We also tested the old style Toledo torch under °
‘the. same conditions. At the lower speed -of
25 1/10th miles an hour the Toledo old style torch
stayed lit for 15, minutes, so in fairness we ——
that test- at that same time.
At 26 9/10ths miles an hour speed, it put the To-
ledo old style torch out in 15 seconds, whereas at a
higher speéd of 28 miles an hour the old sty'e torch.
stayed lit for 2 minutes and 30 seconds. *-This-
brings out the characteristic of that type of torch,
which is its uneertainty. At one time it will per-
form under one set of conditions, and ancther time,
under the same conditions, it will act differently.
The Court: You are testi —_ as to what
you observed?
The Witness: Yes.
In the wind velocity tests on the Toledo and
Anthes burners the-.wicks were extended one-
eighth inch. The wick in‘ the Toledo old style
burner was extended one and a half inches. We
tended those wicks a quarter of an inch.
- I haven’t given you the results of the test on the
Detroit: .At 25.1 miles per hour the Detroit stayed
lighted for five minutes. At 26.9 miles per hour it ©
stayed lighted for two minutes. At 28.7 miles per
hour it stayed lighted for fifty seconds. .
neal
‘also tested that Detroit three-wick ‘torch, and ex- °
47
* Close—For Peetiy--iired 2
“I tested the Toledo open ‘flame torch at the same~~139- -
» time. It’ staved lighted fifteen minutes ‘at 20. 1
miles per hour; for five secopds at 26.9 miles per
. hour, and thirty seconds at 28.7 miles per hour. _
We made fuel consumptioa tests running seven
- days—the devices are those shown in Plaintiff’s
Exhibit. 8. Those are the four torches tested ip
this. test. ‘The test was started on February Ist, .
continued on the 2nd, 4th, 5th, 7tix, 8th and 9th of
February, 1938, at Toledo. There ‘were various ©
time periods of four, seven, eight and a half, seven,
seven, nine, 6. 75, and 6.77 hours that were ‘covered
by: those tests, and the averages were taken of the 140
~. total fuel consumed by each of those four. torches.
That was reduced to the rate ‘of ounces per hour,
and an average of those seven tests is as follows:
The Toledo Economy. burner burned at the rate
of 1.937 ounces per hour.
> The Anth-s burner burned at the rate of 1. 633
ounces per hour. .
The Toledo old style open flame torch eine’ at
_ the rate of’4.634 ounces per hour.
The Detroit Street Railway torch burned at the
rate of 4.238 ounces per hour.. :
The Court: In the case of the old style 141
- torch, the wick was how far out?
The Witness: The old open flame torch, in -
that case the. wick was extended a length of —
one and a half inches, and on the Detroit, one- |
‘quarter of.an inch. es |
_- The Court: Is that usually the correct
" amount? .
The Witness: That is the correct amount.
The Court: Not less.
Mr. Wisner: May I point. out to Your
Honor that the Detroit Street Railway man
142
143
144
48
Close—For Plaintiff—Direct
testified that they used one-half inch exten |
sion. |
The Court: He was just saying ar his
_ experience was.
The Witness: An inchand a half is right on our .
torch on an average weather condition. You are
apt to meet extreme conditions: that you do not
know ahead of time. In those tests we had a wick |
extension. of a quarter of an inch, on each of the
three wicks of the Detroit torch. That. is torch A
on this Exhibit 8.
Q59. How did you arrive. at that tide extension?
The Court: It all comes down to. this:
- Counsel for the defendant concedes, and prop-
erly so, it seems to me, that the longer the wick.
the more oil will be consumed. Now, the dif-
ference between you is whether or not the wick
should be extended an inch and a half or less.
Mr. Owen: Yes. I will ask the witness
what his experience has been.
The Court: Because it is common sense to
realize that the longer the wicks are the r more
‘oil will be consumed.
The Witness: My experience in determining the
length of wick exposure which is desirable for all
kinds of uses of this open flame construction torch
such as shown at B in Exhibit 8 was as follows:
when we started out with that torch we wanted to
have the wick extended as little as possible; com-
'mon.sense dictated that. Complaints began to come
in because torches were going out. -Naturaily we
wanted to strengthen the flame, and we decided that
a longer wick exposure would assist in solving that: _
difficulty. And-after considerable experience ‘in et
tling complaints, making tests of our own, we found —
that an inch and a half was _about the shortest
a
* .
H . - . rey wt ig
P Sa roa) ° " ‘
= . e “
a Br 49
_ Close—Fer Plaintiff —Direct
-Jength you could bank on “over night, because we
- did not know ahead of time what kind of conditions
~ were going to be met. As we extended the wick the |
fel consumption rose, I would not say it was di- _
rectly_ proportional ‘to the exposure of the wick,
because I cannot say that definitely. _
’ Mr. Withrow’s attention was, called to some
statement that plaintiff had made in connection
with those open flame burnevs, that one of them
had burned for twenty-four hours, that might have
been one with a short wick extension or a tighter _
wick. There are so many variables that enter into
the consumption and operation and performance
of a test, it might have ‘been a tighter wick that
didn’t feed oil as freely. It would be entirely pos-
sible for one of these open flame Toledo torches to
burn for twenty-four hours under proper weather
conditions and with the proper wick extension.
I have & memorandum of the fuel consumption
‘tests of the Toledo and Anthes flares, to which I
have just’ testified. ite: |
| Mr. Owen: I offer them in. evidence as
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 29.
(Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 29 in evidence.)
The Witness: By experiment we found that one-
. quarter of an inch extension on each of the three ©
wicks in. the Detroit torch would give approxi-
- mately the same volume of flame given off by the
one and a half inch wick extension on the Toledo
‘old style torch. On the Toledo flare and Anthes
-.~ flare used. in‘those tests we had a wick extension
_of one-eighth of an inch. I have here a written re-
port on ‘the wind velocity tests of the same four
devices shown in Plaintiff’s Exhibit 8. We didn’t —
measure that ourselves, but I witnessed it meas-
ured by a Taylor anemometer produced by the De-
145
146
147
ae — : Close—For Plaintiff—Cross 2
148 Vilbiss Consipadny, whose specifications were fol-
lowed in, building the tunnel. ca
. Mr. Owen: \[he wind velocity test data
| _produiced by the witness is offered i in evidence
tm as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 30. © —_.
im (Marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 30 in n evidence.)
i, ‘The Witness: I have here-a photograph of the
wind apparatus which we used in those tests.
Mr. Owen: This photograph produced by
the witness is offered in evidence as Plaintift’s
ie : : Exhibit 31.
mf os. (Marked Plaintiff's Exhibit 31 in evidence.)
a 149 The Witness: This photograph shows the wind.
ii tunnel in our plant at Toledo a Tha already
described.
| , ‘
: |
|
le
a Cross Examination by Mr. Wisner:
_ The Witness: I do not have a copy of Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 31, the photograph of this wind tun-
nel, but I am familiar with it. ‘The photograph
purports to show a flare on a platform at the end .
z of the wind tunnel. -
nN. ‘ _ .Now, in these state tests ou which I testified,
150 the practice is to center the flame of the flare upon
the center of the wind tunnel. That was not done
in this case. I mentioned that I made some meas- _
‘urements of tle volume of the flame produced by
the Detroit. Street Railway torch, and the unpro-
\_ tected Toledo torch, with an inch and a half wick .
| cee \ extension. This negsurement was purely visual. *
We compared them visually as to size. We did.
/ > +, . mot use a photoelectric cell to take it accurately.
Hd : .. I do not know what the candle power was that was .
bP RS .. produced by the one in comparison with the candle,
{tt Pong ___ power. Bedneed by the other. We assumed they
Mapes
Ae ee Oe Pm INF se LTE MT ng
- ——
_—
ie ia diieaiiedies aie,
"
ee ee ET
J - 51 .
Close—For Plaintiff—Cross . |,
were the samie size as you would view them, thatis 151
all, When we were determining to our own satis- |
faction that an inch and avhalf wick was the most
: satisfactory extension, the test was simply that we
pulled it -out—we started with. a lower extension, :
and as they were extinguished under average
weather conditions, we raised them jp until we:
found that an inch and a half tested. the best under
average conditions on ‘several occasions, and. con-
cluded to recommend that length/ An average
weather cotidition’ is a condition that “you would
meet with from a repetition ‘of tests over a nuni-.
ber of nights, from a calm night to a windy night, 152
or arainy night, so. that you get all different condi-
tions: included. And it wasn’t.measured in miles
per hour, and T would not, know how to evaluate
it in miles’ per hour. We took wind and rain into .
account. I could not say how much rain in inches
per hour-because we did not take any _— on
that. . :
| Lwouldn’t say the torch would work hettor under
certain conditions if the wick were not out an inch —
and a half; it probably would consume. less fuel.
_Of course, if it was not extended very far it would
produce less light than if it was extended extremely 153
far. The difference. between an inch ‘and a half ©
and one inch, for instance, might be very slight to
the normal eye, but possibly it would show: con-
siderable difference in candle power. When this is
extended an inch and a half you have a great big -
_ bonfire when‘ you start, but: it settles itself down "
normally to a point where it isn’t terribly big. That
is what burns up the wick. Of course, the wind —
. burns the wick, fanning the flame off onto one side,
- and bringing the glowing embers-of the wick into ©
a charred condition is what consumes the wick. As
oe .
. ® * x ° ‘ ‘ . 5 °
° . : in ®
° t : * * .
EOE RIED §. ‘ ; ‘
, ie Py ~ .
- ; ® -)
a . , : .
.
.
#
eye
[| 154
}
'
~ 155
Hilo. 956
- .
A NE nat tap =
ae ne -
ee en tay °
a
ee
a 4
/
52
Ciose—For Pialatig=—Orone
long. as. there is oil on ‘the wick and the oil is being |
volatilized, the. wick is not being. consumed. It is
only the vapor of the vil that is being consumed _
“then. ‘But when ‘the vapors are blown’ to the op-:
posite side of the wick, leaving the extremely hot
ends of the wick in the fire, at the firing point of the
wick, you might say, they are charred and are con-
sumed by their own combustion.
A great many. States do not have any tests at
all, for example, the State of New York has no
tests or requirements for flares. They have'a flare
law, but no specifications for approval.
XQ96. The-only states maintaining state labora-
tories are Iowa, Nebraska and Minnesota, are they
not? A. Well, they use the university, the Ohio
t
~ State University, in Ohio, because I have wit-
nessed tests down there, passed those tests. And
the tests are conducted by the Highway Depart-
ment in the mechanical engineering laboratory of
Ohio State University. | )
These: states that have a law similar to the one,
for instance, in Pennsylvania, are more difficult to
qualify a torch than in other states Wecause of the
rigid requirements in ‘the specificat‘ons, as noted
in my testimony. _ Nebraska is one of those states, .
because it has practically the same law, the same
specifications. Pants °.
I did not testify that I made observations of vis-
- ibility at 500 feet on the roof of our building at
Toledo. I testified to no visibility observation. I _
did not testify that we made any attempt to test °
visibility. |
The-fuel consumption test was: made up on the
-top of our building. It was on top of a building _—
that has a factory under it, one-story factory. I
imagine the roof is about, at this particular point,
* ”
oe
Close—For Plaintiff-—Cross—
50 feet athe the ground. The torch was placed on 157
a platform which was elevated above the roof about. —
6 feet, so that the torches were away from any pro-
/tecting wall \surfaces or anything of+a similar -:
nature. They\ were burned during the day time
when we could observe whether they would stay lit.
We would light them in the early morning: and
extinguish thém at night. hee
The torch is intended to be used on the road.
That is, at an elevation of perhaps six or seven
| inches 4rom the ground with the bottom of the
.| topsh resting on the surface of the pavement. |
2 With. reference to the wind velocity test disclosed 158
in Exhibit 30, that motor which we used was not a
- variable speed motor.. That is, we put a plate with
- an orifice of varying size over the endof the wind»
tunnel. We measured the wind velocity by a Tay-
lor anemometer’in the position of the torch.
— XQ121. That is, you took the velocity reading at ,
one time, and then suvjected the torch to what you
. eonsidered to be that velocity, and then took that -
other reading, is that it? A. That is true. ,
- XQ122. So there was no continuous reading of? -
_yelocity while the torch was being burned? A. -
No; the motor had a constant speed. I wus present 159° *
continuously during these wind velocity tests,
With reference to this letter marked Plaintiff’s
Exhibit. 27 in the preceding case, tried in Toledo, ©
Ohio, I was present at some of the tests describéd
in that letter. On page 2, the third paragraph, he
* states: ‘For the wind test: a tunnel was pre-
_.pared’— He is not there discussing any test in
particular, he was discussilig the method of making
~ these tests. I saw him follow this, method before
- the date of the letter. That was probably a little
less than two years before that date. _
- 160
’ 161
162.
«4
Close—For Plaintiff —Cross
‘Mr. Wisner: -One of the last things we had
before us yesterday on adjournment was the
question of this Exhibit 27 in the Bolser case,
_ which was a letter written by one of the testing -’
engineers for thé State of Iowa which the © A
plaintiff was seeking to have put in evidence. .
The Court: I will permit anything as to the.
tests, but so far as conclusions are concerned, —
I will not be bound by any conclusions of any-
body else. ;
Mr. Owen: May I offer the Letter with that
". understanding?
The Court: Yes.
Mr. Owen: Letter from the State of Iowa
Commission, State of Iowa, to the plaintiff, is
- offered— |
’ The Court: This is offered in lieu of tes-
timony. - fat
Mr. Owen: It was marked as Exhibit 27
in the Toledo case. Possibly I had better offer
a copy of it without any markings on it. 7
(Marked Plajntiff’s Exhibit 32 in evidence.)
The Witness: I identified certain photostatic |
/ drawings marked here in Exhibit 15 as having been
made by me. They were. made long after the de-
vices which they seek to explain or disclose were
constructed. They were made from memory., And
the devices which they portray are no longer in
éxistence, as far as I know. There may have been:
some slight differences .or variations between the
actual devices and these dr: ™
I think you will find on that tag that was offered
as one of our exhibits there is an instruction not
to spread the wick. In connection with these tests
which I have testified about, in so far as I know
the wicks were used es instructed on our tag. That
Close—For Plaintiff —Redirect
is, when we tested them we did not have them
splayed, but it was all in one tightly bound com-
pact unit, the wick was just cut off as it was matte
and used in that manner.
Redirect alates by Mr. Owen:
_ The-Witness: I was asked on cross examination
whether the sketches, Plaintiff’s Exhibit 15, ac-
be curately represent the devices which we made and ©
» tested. They do not ‘differ in any substantial re-
gard from the devices which were actually made ©
and tested. They truly represent the construction
of those devices.
Recross Examination by Mr. Wisner:
°°
RXQ140. You testified on your direct examination”
with reference to the statement made in one of the.
circulars covering ithe Toledo torch which I now’
‘identify as Defendant’s Exhibit A in the preced-
ing case, appearing on pages 217 and 218 of the |
record in that case, with reference to this state-
ment as follows: ‘‘It will burn through wind and
rain for more than 24 hours, if necessary, on one
filling.’’’ That you state might have been with a
short wick? A. Well, I do not think it’ is really
necessary to: qualify thet statement, because we
have had that performance repeatedly and varia-
tions that would occur in normal construction of a
torch might affect it one way or, another, but I be-
lieve that to be a true statement of the ability of
the average torch.
"Mr. Owen: I have shanded up to Your
.Honor a copy of Judge Hahn’s opinion, and
- inasmuch as that opinion discusses the ques-
Wren
163
164 ©
165
y
.
. "
poe
166
167 -
168
56
Close—For Plaintiff—Recross
tion of infringemennt, I wish to offer a draw-
ing of the Bolser flare which was introduced
by the. defendant in the Toledo case. This I
will-ask be marked as a plaintiff’s exhibit.
(The drawing was received in evidence.and
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 33.) |
Mr. Owen: I also offer in evidence a simi-
lar drawing of the Kari-Keen flare in the To-
ledo ease.
(The drawing was received in evidence and
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 34.) i:
Mr. Owen: I now offer a stipulation en-
tered into by counsel for the respective par-
ties with reference to the use of soft copies.
One of ‘the flares sold by the defendagt in this
case is shown by the blueprint attached to the
stipulation.
(The stipulation and blueprint were received _
in evidence an’ marked as one exhibit, or
' tiff’s Exhibit 2.)
Mr. Owen: } also offer in evidence as a
plaintiff’s exhil.: stipulation relating to the
“Incorporation o! the plaintiff company and
other allegations in the. bill of complaint which
“were denied or not admitted by the answer,
and also having attached a copy of the license _
agreement between the plaintiff and the Anthes
Force Oiler Company.
(The st‘pulation was received in evidence
. and marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 36.)
——aEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEEeEEeEEEIEOeeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeeeeeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeEeeeeeeeeeee eee a
wT.
K € rwe—2or Plaintiff —Diréct
DEPOSITION OF PHILIP A. KERWIN
TAKEN MARCH 3, 1938, AT
.. TOLEDO, OHIO
_ Pump A. Kerwin, having been first duly sworn,
testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Owen:
The Witness: My name is Philip A. Kerwin; I
am 52. years of age; »»_<rintendent of Way and
‘Structures Department of Street Railways, City of
. Detroit, Michigan. I was superintendent for the De-
| verte of Street Railways since the city bought
the Detroit United Railways, May 15, 1922; pre-
vious to that I was assistant superintendent of the
D.'U. R. Lines. I was connected with the D. U.
R. Lines in that capacity for’ about five years be-
fore 1922—aboyt 1917. Previous to that I was
chief clerk of the Way and Structures Division,
from May 1, 1907.
When I first becameconnected with the Detroit
United Railways, they were using red lanterns.
They set them around the excavation in the street.
They would be broken, stolen, and the losses were
quite’substantial from those causes, and they still
are. We still supplement -them—we use both—
_ supplement the torches with the lanterns. We now
use mostly a castiron torch, kerosene torch, with a
_ three-wick cap, open flame. The castiron torch was
first used about 1913, through 1913 and 14, and
the record drawing showing the type of torch is
dated March 1, 1915. I am ‘referring to a’ blue-
print from the old Detroit United Railway’s rec-
ords. I believe it has a number on it—Drawing :
° <
DPW Mele NTN a fre + [2
No. 101-17.
y .
’ ,
Se a . aeons panes erage
170
169
7100 GE
172
173
174
vy
—«88
Kerwin--For Plaintiff—Direct .
I made this blueprint off the tracing which was
turned over to the Department of Street Railways:
with the records of the Detroit United: Railways:
I was first familiar with that tracing, or with blue-
.prints made from it in 1915. This device,. marked
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 7, which is shown in this blue-
print, was the.idea of John Kerwin, who was the
superintendent of Way and Structures at that time.
He is my uncile.. I did not bring the tracing with
me. ‘The device shown in Plaintiff’s Exhibit 7 is
a container about 81% inches high, about 5% inches
wide, fitted with a cap, a threaded cap, drilled to E.
take three wicks. That container shown in the left-
hand figure is cast iron. The figure in the upper
central part of the blueprint-is a plan view of the
- circumference of the torch. The two figures on the
‘right-hand of the print are sections—two sections,
one a cross- section, and the other a plan view of ,
_ the cap. that is drilled to hold the wicks, which
threads down into the casting. The three wick
~ holders are shown in the upper right- hand view.
They. are drilled vertically in the cap, and each one
holds a wick. In practice, the average wick exten-
sion used in that torch is ‘approximately a half an |.
inch above the top.of the cap. About a month ago
I gave one of those torches to = Close =. the
plaintiff company. a
In Plaintiff’s Exhibit 8 I recognize the device
* marked ‘‘A’’ as the one that I gave Mr. Close. It
was one carried. over from the old D. U. R. days, -
an old torch that I got gut of the store room for
him. It was in such condition that it could bé used;
it is pretty well scarred up; one of the ears knocked
off of it, and it is simply a relic; that type is not
used now any more. We started to use that type
about 1913, ‘and we used them for the first few years:
59
K orete—T' or Plaintiff —Direct
- under the city ownership—I would say up w about = "175
~ 1924 or 725.
While that type of torch was in use, we had
trouble from its being extinguished by drenching
rains, although a high wind would extinguish ‘t
also. We took precautions against having these
torches blown out or rained out by experimenting
while still in the D. U. R. ownership—that would
be before 1922—with a small umbrella covering that
- was made in two ways, trying to find the way that
would be best; one way was supporting it on three
legs rising between the wick openings; another w
was just a center pin raising up from the center 176
of the cap to carry the umbrella. We used them
for probably a couple of years. Our difficulty was
with the center pin, that in throwing the eontainer
around, it would be bent and sometimes broken,
and with both the center pin and the one ‘supported
with three legs, we still had trouble with the.
. torches being extinguished in a drenching rain or
ina very high wind, and so we concluded that those
happenings were so infrequent that we could just
_ as well get along without the cap, and we discon-
_ -tinued the use. ‘
‘+ ( ‘he blneprint of that umbrella tadde by the De’ 177° |
partment of Street Railways of the city of De- f
troit in 1926, March 24, 1926, shows the torch itself
_eut down to a 44-inch height, and it also shows
the umbrella supported on the center pin. .That,
however, while shown on ‘the drawing, we have not
-used in the Department of Street Railways owner-
ship since 1922, although if is shown in this record '
“drawing of 1926. We have never used any type |
- of umbrella since experimental days of D. U. R.
before 1922. The experimenting was done upon -
this type and the three-legged type, and although
60.
Kerwin—For Plaintiff—Direct
‘178 this is shown on the city drawing, it was never
. used since the city used the lines. These blue-
~ prints marked Plaintiff’s. Exhibits 8. and 9 are the
city drawings.
To the best of my recollection, we experimented
with this umbrella over the three wicks for a period
of a couple of years and then discarded it as giving
just as much trouble and_ having just as many
flames go out as. if we hadn’t carried it at all. It
did not remedy the defect that we were trying’ to
overcome. We have trouble today from these
torches being blown out or rained out.. For the-
179 protection of the. public under those conditions, all
excavations are protected at night time, in addition
to the mechanical protection of torches, by watch-—
man. He has many duties, takes care-of the tools,
watches them that nobody steals them, and makes
_ the rounds regularly ‘to see that the- torches are
burning, and if they are extinguished by rain or
high wind, it is his duty: to relight the torches.
The theory on which three wicks were used in-
stead of one was that if one wick were to become .
‘short and should go out, you would still have the
‘protection of the other two; and if two went out,
180 you would still have one. If a rain or high wind
puts out the flame, it is apt to put all of them out.
The idea is, sometimes the workmen are careless,
and they might have a short wick. in there that
might burn out, which would still leave a light if
the other wicks were long. If ina wind or rain
one or two of the flames were extinguished, they
_ would be relighted if one remained lighted.
I know of the closed torch like that put out by
the plaintiff in this case, The Toledo Pressed Steel
Company. It is a’ good many years ago that a
first saw that torch; that is, I don’t know. whether |
61
sony etiniad Plaintiff—Direct -
it had the cap on it when. it first came out. I
couldn a7 say exactly how ‘long I have known of the
cap; I would say it is probably eight or ten years.
‘Those have never been used by the Detroit United °
Street Railways because we have a torch designed
to take care of our peculiar circumstances. The
- torch has got to be low enough to set down in the
depth of the brick pavement. Weefind that where
we are working: in between the rails of the track,
_ the side—the street alongside, the driveways on the '
‘street alongside of the excavation are passable ;
. people, however, will follow a street car down the
track, and if the.car is traveling along at fifteen,
"protected between the rails, and so for that reason
we dig up the brick, a couple of rows of. brick ©
across the track, and set these torches down in the
- space from which the brick has been ‘removed,
_ which brings the flame just about level, or just
above the level of the brick pavement, in which
case’ the cars pass over without knocking over the
torches. That is the torch which is shown on the —
blueprint last produced, Exhibit 9. ,
Cross Examination by Mr. Wisner:
The Witness: In 1913 I was chief clerk of the
_ Way and Structures Division with the: Detroit
United Railways. I had charge of the recoids,. of
- directions issued through the superintendent to the
_ foremen on the streets, supervision over the stock,
supplies and orders that were placed. When I be-
came assistant superintendent, my duties included
more supervision of the actual jobs out on the
street. That i is, I went out occasionally observing
181
182
twenty miles an hour, and they are following right —
behind it, they go into the excavation unless it is »
183
+4.
184
185
62
K erwin—For Pletntif—Cring
the jobs | as they were ondite on them. i ‘have had
no mechanical engineering experience’ NY
‘Kerosene is the fuel used in the type of ‘torch: .
7 exemplified by the blueprint, Plaintiff’s Exhibit.7.
-I would say the diameters of the three wicks. that
were used in the torch would be about a half inch. \
print now, I would say nearer to-a quarter of an
_ I think the print would show that. Looking at the
inch; my guess was wrong. In the outermost cirele mts
in the drawing in the upper right-hand corner of
Exhibit 7 there is one shown to. have a diameter
of 34 inch, and then there is one shown to have a
diameter of 5 inch, and then there is one showing
a diameter of 11/32 inch. The smaller diameter
_ would be the hole‘in which the wick fits, that is, the
wicks were approximately 11/32 inch in diameter.
186 ©
‘I never made any observations of the amount of
“wind or rain in inches per hour which one of these
torches would withstand. They. would, however,
withstand a considerable degree of wind and an
ordinary rain. It was only a drenching rain—a
very heavy rain, that would extinguish a torch. ‘I
don’t suppose we wéuld have trouble with rain or
wind putting out a torch more than once a month.
" We use both the red lantern and the torch in
conjunction today. Referring again to Plaintiff ig.
Exhibit 9, and ‘to the drawing with the umbrella
mounted over the wicks, I have produced. no draw-
ing where a three-legged tripod was used to sup-
port the umbrella. The three legs positioned on
the structure would be outside of the ‘wick holes
and spaced in between them; that is the way I re-
__ ‘member it. This type of a cap over the wick was —
tested in rains; Jeft them out in service. I have
‘no means of stating what amount in in¢hes of rain
‘per hour they were subjected to. These particular
9
63
K erwin—For ae.
tests, about which I have just testified, were made, 187
I would say, around 1920 by the various foremen :
. in charge of _jobs. I saw the wicks in use, or the
. umbrellas in use, repeatedly. I was never present .
at any time,in which one of these structures with
the umbrella covering was extinguished in a rain.
‘That always happened through the night time when
‘the torches were out for: protection, and we would
get the report from the foreman the next morning.
- Those were the only reasons ‘for which the tox rches
would have gone out that I remember Leing re:
ported. As far as anyone actually knows, some-
body. may have blown them out for a prank, that \ 188
could have happened, but doesn’t sound plausible, \ -
I don’t think. However, anyone could put one out..
I did not make any. experiments with the extent | |
. of wick extension which was most efficacious. That
was left pretty much to’ the man on the job, but
my observation wes that it was about a half inch
of wick that would produce a good flame. I do not
recall any experiments with reference to the dis-
tance between the top.of the wick and the bottom
‘surface of the umbrella. -I think that originally
‘those umbrellas stood up higher than the inch that
is shown in this last drawing—probably two inches 189
or maybe three inches., But that is a matter of
recollection. The diameter of the threaded bolt —
which supported ‘the umbrella\was 3, inch. I don’t
recall the name of the person who made this draw- °
ing, but the approval, I know that signature and
name. That is.B.-B. Mobore, office engineer, De-
. troit Street Railways. He is living.
The watchman’s instructions were to keep those
torches filled. They are cleaned and filled every -
day by the day watchman preparatory for the night .
- work, the. same-as the lanterns are taken care of.
64
ee tee Kerwin—For Plaintiff—Cross
190 I wouldn’t say offhand how much oil they hold’ I
would have to guess at it; it could be estimated
from the measurements. ‘They were filled by un-
screwing the cap. That was unscrewed and the .
wicks adjusted and the oil was put in every day,
' after the night was over, and the night watchman
picked up the torches and brought them in; then
the day watchman’s job was to clean them ané fill
them and get them ready for the, next night again, ~
Those experiments were always made at night, that
is when the torches are burned, at night time. They
were made all year ’round; we have. work going on
191 winter and summer. Exhibit 9 is a.complete as-
sembly except that the wicks are not shown. I am
not aware of any element’ of the structure which
is omitted from this drawing.
I couldn’t say what firm we buy our wicking :
from. Prior to 1913 we used the red lantern ex-
clusively as a warning signal.’ I am not aware of
any use of torches similar to the one that is shown
“in those two blueprints prior to 1914. I ‘know that
open flame torches are being used at the present
time; whether they have a plurality of wicks or.not,
I don’t know.
192 . I never met Mr. Owen before coming in here to- ©
day. Mr. Close. called-at my: office about a month .
ago. He is the only man I have talked ‘to about
; | the case.. . “
* . These structures are made by sduian happens
| -to be the successful bidder on the castings. It may
be a Detroit foundry, or_it may be a Bay City
foundry; we advertise them for open bids. We
use these torches otherwise than in between the
rails of the streets, we set them around the ex-| |
cavations on the. pavement. The same type of low
* torch. ' We use only the\low torch now; we have no. .
Q +t ‘ : . . . \ | .
Kerwin—For site nccucsan
more of the high torches in use. The one that I 193 .
gave Mr.-Close is one of the old high torches. I
was not able to observe from our testing of these
torches whether there was any difference in per-
formance when the umbrella was placed on the holt
centered between the three wicks, and when the
umbrella was supported by the he three-legged affair _
outside of the wick. My recollection is that with
~~ gither type, the high wind or rain would extinguish |
them, so we discontinued using both types. . Most ™
|
| .
of my information about their performance would © 1
be reported by the foreman in charge of the night ae |
work. - | 194 |
Redirect Examination by Mr. Owen : . t
” : ay) |
The Witness: It was the duty of the foreman to
report to me as superintendent. .They report to
mé practically every day. These reports came to,
me in the regular course of their work. They were
80) bal, sometimes written. This um- nm
- brella was used on the high torch—that is where mt
~ it was tried out. Referring to Exhibit 9, it is 31% ;:
inch diameter of umbrella by % inch thick, and it ve
-_. was nade out, as i remember it—just cut out of 195
ordinary %%-inch steel plate and drilled to fit the
. carriage bolt; held in place to fit the head of bolt.
I will ‘indicate on Exhibit 9 by small circles where
the three studs were located which were used to
support the umbrella. Approximately,-as nearly
as I can remember, it would-be in a position be-
tween the wick openings and somewhat outside the
cfrele of the wick openings. I have indicated those
locations by an X mark with red pencil. I do not
remember. what size bolts were used for those three
supports.
66
Kerwin—For Plaintiff —Recross
196 , Recross Examination by Mr. Wisner:
The Witness: A torth such as shown: ix the
lower left-hand corner of Plaintiff’s Exhibit 9 was
made. We experimented with the umbrella and
we used the torch, but when we used the umbrella
on the torch: it was the deeper torch, it was the
8-inch -deep torch. But the method, umbrella
_ method, and appliance, was the same as we ex-
fe _ perimented with:- We have not in this low torch ©
: *. used the umbrella, although. the idea was carried —
over from the original, as shown on the drawing.
197 I couldn’t say offhand how many of such struc-
turés with the. unibrella were made, but there
would be quité a few, because the ordinary opening
“probably takes twenty torches to guard it, and we ©
have many openings, depending on the various
times-of the year—I would guess that probably
one hundred to two hundred probably were fitted
that way. These written reports I referred to were
” preserved in the file of the superintendent’s office.
ang They went with the D. U. R. Those records all
disappeared with the going out of business. All
of this was prior to the taking over of the railrogd —
198 by the city of Detroit. We were experimenting ©
, - * with the umbrella about 1920; it was previous to
ak . the time the city took the D. U. R. Lines, which
a was May, 1922. I do not remember any of the re
ports disclosing what- time of night the torches
--* : . were extinguished. I’ don’t remember that now. /
It might have been at any time during the night.
The torches were ordinarily lit about dusk; that
would depend on the season of the year.
(Certificate of uvtary omitted.)
; , ”
J °
?
4
a ns . : .
, = “ . Ores Ha 9 y ”
PT PY lon pe OAT LOLOL LOLOL: BIA C EEL CETL TI AE NEON I IRN AOE n 7
67
Defendant’s Case
DEFENDANT’S CASE
Mr. Wisner: I handed up to Your Honor a
certified copy of the opinion’ of the Circuit
Court of Appeals.
‘(The opinion was feceived in evidence and
marked Defendant’s Exhibit A:)
Mr. Wisner: [ now offer in evidence as a
199
defendant’s exhibit a photostat comprising -
enlarged’ drawings taken from the patent
specifications of the patent in suit, of the Rutz -
Patent No. 1,101,146, relied upon by the plain-
tiff; of the Russian patent to Malcov of the
200
year 1868, No. 1163, and a. pcs ef the de- .
fendant’s burner.
. (The drawing was received in evidence and
marked Defendant’s Exhibit 8B.)
Mr. ‘/isner: I offer in evidence as a de-
fendant’s exhibit a volume of patents.
(Marked Defendant’s Exhibit C in evi-
‘dence. )
The Court: Which of these are anticipa- be
_ tory patents? he
Mr. Wisner: Some of thent are state of the
art -patents.. The anticipation patents which
' we cite are very few, about four or five.
Tbe Court: Argand, Salsbury, Rutz, Van
Liew, Warren, Malcov, Almond, Blake, Kahn,
Heston and Hathaway, those are the patents?
Mr. Wisner: That we ‘rely on as —
tion.
The Court: What did’ you say your best
reference was yesterday?
Mr. Wisner: There are’ three, Rutz I con-
sider one of the best references, Maleov, the
Russian patent of 1968, No. 1163, ne hag,
201
a
Defendant’ 8 Case
202 ~—s of: July 3, 1784, No. 1425. It is the diay’
; epecification, there are no drawings. .
Mr. Wisner: I offer in evidence as Defend-
. ant’s Exhibit D, a bound volume of the photo-
static reproductions ‘of the pages relied upon
on page 5 of the answer in anticipation as pub- '
Keations. | ‘
(Marked Deferdant’ s Exhibit D in. evi-
dence.) |
I offer in evidence as Defendant’s Exhibit
E a stipulation with reference to the testi- -
, mony of Oscar J. Leins,-of Milwaukee, Wis-'
203 -consin. Notice of the taking of this deposition .
. was served on January 12, 1938.
(Marked Defendant’ s Exhibit EK, in evi-
dence.)
Mr. Wisner:- In connection with the depo-
sitiots, I offer in evidence as a defendant’s ex-
hibit the curves for all of the graphs curved
by Professor Croft, disclosing the nature of —
ne the performance of these various devices in
? the tests which he made.
_ (The curves were received in evidence wid
marked Defendant’s Exhibit F.)
— 204 Mr. Wisner: I now offer in evidence stipu- .
lation with reference to the tests taken after
the taking of the deposition, and stipulation
with reference to the test experiences which
has been entered into between plaintiff and
and defendant on March 3, 1938.
(Marked Defendant’s Exhibit G in evi-
‘ dence.)
_ Mr. Wisner: I offer the deposition of H. 0. |
Croft, taken January 18th and filed January
28th,
(Marked Defendant ’s Exhibit H ‘1 evi-
= a.) :
CB 2 Pete pager ’ a ; = ‘ .
tila se on wae Ee OT TL OT ET I ONT
(eae g ——— le omg eeee - “' - -
apmapeing _Qeeeerd = . °
a
Luckizsh—For ee
- MartHew Lvoxresx, called as a witness cn be--
half of the defendant, having been or sworn,
testified .as follows:
Direct’. Examination by Mr. Wisner:
Q1. State your name and residence, Doctor. A.
Matthew Luckiesh, Cleveland, Obiio.
Q2. What is your occupation? A. Tam the Di-
rector of the Lighting Research Laboratory of the
General , Electric Company at Nela Park, Cleve-
_land.
Q3. What has been your. educational prepara-
tion with reference to this work? A. i have a’
number. of degrees.
Q4. That is, from universities? A. es.
Q5. Has yéur. work anything to do with light
and lighting equipment? A. Entirely.
Q6. Have you written any books with reference
to such matters?. A. Quite a few.
Q7. Do the names of any of them readily occur
to you? A. Artificial Lighting, Its Influence on
Civilization, Lighting Art, Lighting Fixtures, and
Lighting Effects, Science of Seeing, and. so forth.
Q8. Have you had. anything to do with the his-.
_ torical aspects of lighting? A. I have always been
- interested i in it, and of course, we have had to know
: the background.
Q9. In your preparation for testifying in ‘thls
case did you first familiarize yourself with the de-
vices involved? A. Yes, sir. ’
Q10. Within what classification, soli in the
lighting art, would you place the product of: the
Toledo Pressed Steel Company, Plaintiff’s Exhibit
19t A A rather primitive light source, similar
to those of centuries ago.
205: -
206
207.
reese — : .
ORIEL SEARS LENE NOLES SION LLIN PIPL PELE
Le
Cer is wey
an et ee
208
209
ae - as: ”
Luckiesh—For' Defendant=-Direct
“Q11. It might be classed as‘a chimneyless hydro-
carbon burner, might it not?, A. Yes.
Q12. What sort f fuel doés it use? A. Kero- —
‘gene, signal oil, and similar things.
Q13. What are the means used for transferring
_ the oil from the reservoir to the level * the eeacé!
A. The common wick.
Q14. As the oil reaches the top of that wick
through capillarity, t:rough what process does it
pass before it gets into the condition of lumina-
tion? A. It is vaporized by the heat of the flame
and burns as a vapor.
Q15. What is the principal source of heat which _
‘vaporizes it? A. The flame. ©
210
Q1i6. And would that be true whether or not
there were a protective — for the wick? A.
Yes. ~
Qi7. Can’ you explain very ‘briefly the reasons -
why a flame of this type gives light, that is; a
hydrocarbon light? A. In general there are car-
bon particles in the flame that are heated to in- -.
—a and they give off light.
Q18. What happens to these carbon -particles
after they reach incandescence?: A. They may be
partiaily burned, some of them may not be burned,
and they can go off as soot or smoke and settle on
nearby surfaces. _
Q19. Directir g your attention now: to Fig. 1. of
the drawing on the easel, that. is the Toledo device,
will you point out on what surfaces the soot of ,
which you have just spoken would be deposited?
A: On this device the natural place would be in-
side of that top and around the air ports chiefly.
Of course, I cannot: conceive of any part of that
surface, interior surface, not Teceiving soot evebt-
arate
oe
Luckiesh—F or Defendant—Direct
Q20. Ordinarily what effect does the burning
process have on the wick? A. When the wick is ©
“not too generous it has practically no effect, as we
know from our experience, of course, with millions
of kerosene lamps and similar devices.
Q21. Will you explain what you mean by ‘‘gen-
erous’’?. A. When they pull the wick out an inch
and a half you have got practically a bonfire of
cotton fibre 6 sees ae
Q22. Will you direct your attention to Plaintiff’s ©
Exhibit 13? A. Yes. .If you want to burn up
some waste of cotton, that is the-way you would
. do it. ‘Whereas, if you want to conserve the cotton,
you would saturate it with oil and keep it saturated
and burn the oil rather than the cotton.
adequate supply of fuel. } ar he
Q24. In your earlier study of the lighting art,
which have been used to associate these two con-
‘cepts, arid in what sort of structures? A. Yes, sir.
Q25. What means, if any, do you find in the
structure appearing as Fig. 1 on the plate of draw-
_ings which have not been well-known in the art of |
* lighting devices? A. I see none.
_* Argand No. 1,425 of 17841 A. Yes, sir.
_- +» Q27. How long have you known of that_patent?
A. Twenty-five years. fea eee
Q28. What relation, if any, does the Argand
\\_ real scientific presentation of the principles, neces-
sary for good combustion and protection of light
by flames. It is the forerunner, in a sense, in a
\ male bear to the lighting art? A. It is the first’
211
212
Q23. What are the concepts which enter into any -
structure adapted to burn a hydrocarbon fuel? —
A. It will receive an adequate supply of air andan _-
have you familiarized yourself with the means .
Q26. Are you familiar with the British patent to -
{enti ae
ae
%
214
215
- A great deal in all of its aspects, all the aspects
216
ben "72. me
ac acai ad or Defendont—-Dire ct at
rather big sense, of all flame sources, or many of |
/ the flame sources that follow,
Q30. Are you familiar with any devices prior-in
date to the patent to Argand, in which means were
used in some form or other for protection or par-
tial protection of the flam» from the elements? A.
A great many of them more primitive, way back in
the centuries, many centuries.
Q31.. You have from time to time nie the
“operation of devices such as those exemplified by
the device of the patent in suit?’ A. I have.
Q32. Have you had any experience with lighting
highways. and light. protection: on highways?. A.
of highway: lighting and safety lighting, such as — |
traffic aids, traffic signals, highway lighting, head
lamps for automobiles, and even emergency lights.
Q33. If, as you say, an open flame light is sO. :
primitive, can you assign any reason why, prior
_ to the patent in suit, the bonfire construction with
an open and unprotected wick should ‘have con-
tinued in use? A. The growth of artificial light-
ing of course was largely in an interior world, and |
_ there had to be improvements raade from the true.
flame source on-account of such nuisances as odor,
flickering, soot, and so forth. Those same things
had to be done outdoors for street. lighting as was
done in many of the devices to protect them from
obvious things like rain and wind. And this is the
last vestige of the primitive source in civilization. .,
It stayed outdoors, was used in construction work
-and on highways, and occasionally in big interiors
for emergencies because it was in a sense good
enough, and has been used as a lighting device in
-, that way for use outdoors for many years.
.Q34. Now, directing your attention to the series.
73°
Luckiesh—For Defendant—Direct
uf photographs opposite page 56 of Luckiesh on 217
Artificial Light, have you seen the devices which .
are shown on that page before, or devices. similar |
to those? A. Yes, many of them. | a. |
Q36. Where did you procure those particular ; .
photographs when you were preparing the book?
A. From museums and private collections. a
— Q37. In reference to the Argand patent, which
issued in 1784, did any of the devices disclosed on
that page antedate that-patent? A. They did cer-
.. tainly antedate Argand by centuries, same of them.
Q38. In any of the devices shown.on that page do
you find an application of the concepts of protect- 218
’ jng an open flame from the elements? A. It is, a
‘metal enclosure with holes. punched in-it was a
‘common way of protecting a flame from winds and
rain, still leaving a little light to get out: . There
- are-one or two more on that page not quite so prim-
itive, but very obviously protections against rain
and wind. The lighting art is full of those i!lustra-
tions. at EaAn
Q39. None of them go so far as Argand, how-
ever, to specify surrounding and enclosing the
flame. with a metal chimney, dome, tube, or some :
such structure as that, do they? A. No. Argand’s 219
was a real scientific approach to the problem. —
Q40. From your examination of the Argand
specification, and comparison with the structure of .
the patent in suit, do you find any concept disclosed °
. in the structure of the patent in suit which is not
present in the Ar d-'specification? A.- No, I
think that Argand more than covers that of the —
Withrow device that you are referring to.
Q41. I now direct your attention to pages 14 and
15 of a book by W. H. Davenport Adams on |
. “Lighthouses and Lightships.’’. Can’ you describe
* -
. . .
. . sf . ‘
“ : j ° . js
a
HOMER peo eet a -
. ¥ yy FLITE I pS ee he BOS NP VEL RE, Bese:
+ nore
220 .
221
74
Luckiesh—F or ne
the operation of the seinttean shown in the upper
portion of page 15? A. The upper structure is a
- housing with a top and some openings on the side
in which crude fuel is burned, the side ports both
admitting air and letting light out; the little open-
ings below that first platform-from the top, or
rather, the top platform, and the larger ones be-
low, were conimonly used to let some air and draft _
up to the base of the fuel. There are a number of
drawings of this sort on record, and they are rather
crude, but the description fits that appraisal.
Q42. Would you explain the functions which the
top ports of this structure perform? <A. To pro-
‘tect the flame or the burning material obviously
from rain, and somé partial protection from wind;
likewise letting out the light. It is like a flare on a.
large scale, used -on the highways of. the ‘sea, as.
we use the little flare on the roadways. —
Q43. I wil! direct your attention to plate 48 from © |
‘‘Das Beleuchtungswesen,’’ and more particularly
to Fig. 113; I believe that is the last one in there,
on the next te the last page of plate 48.
Q44. What function would that particular device
perform? <A. That. very obviously protects thé
222 “burning material from rain. The side ports were
-also flame ports to let ight out and air ‘in, the
‘flame out on the windward side. It performed all
the functions of the modern cap.
Q45. What would be the date of that device as ©
contrasted with the Argand patent which issued in
17841 A. It is my opinion it would be centuries
preceding Argand. ,
Q46. You have seen examples of such devices in’ .
niuseums? A. ‘Museums claim them ’way back,
many centuries ago. ©
)
15
Luckiesh—For Defendant—Direct
Q47. Have you examined the patent in suit to
_any,extent? A. Yes.
Q48. I.wish to direct your. attention to line 5 of
page 1 of the specification and to line 10. In each
of those lines the word ‘‘effi@ency’’ is used. What
is the meaning of the term ‘‘efficiency’’ as applied
to lighting deviees? A? ‘Efficiency’ as applied
to ‘lighting devices is the same as, analogous to
the efficiency of a motor. For lighting: “devices it
is the light output’per unit of energy input, and
that énergy input in an electrical device is meas- |
ured in watts and watt hours, and in the case of an .
oil burner in the number of pounds of kerosene
per hour. So the efficiency of an oil lamp is the
light output in some acceptable unit, per pound of
kerosene burned per hour, or any other’ ‘accept-
able unit of measurement.
_. Q49. Is there any other basis for measuring, . the |
performance of.a lighting device? A. There is
“no other way of measuring the efficiency of a light-
ing device than that. I would rather answer it that
way. There are other ways of measuring ’ perform-
ance, but the ltimate performance of a lighiing
device that uses energy that one must pay » for and
that gives light*that is discharged and needed, it
-- measured only by the light output per unit of
energy input, or in this case kerosene burned per
hour.
Q50. We shall — time to. time dette the
course of this examination refer to the term
“efficacy.’? What meaning has that in the lighting
art? A. Efficacy is quite a different matter than.
efficiency. The.efficacy of the light source from the >
Viewpoint of the user, let us take a flare, a warning
_ Signal ona highway, it must be efficacious if it gives
enough light to be visible under given conditions.
PEP RI5 a
“993
e
224
995
| ee 760
\ -e ey Luckiesh—F or Defendant—Direct
\, 226 Now, if you asked a truck owner he would prob:
Y % ably admit that that was one definition of ‘‘effi- - ”
" “x eacy,’’? and he would also be concerned, to him it
rould be efficacious if it gave enough light at a rea-
sonable fuel consumption, and to him it would be
‘more efficacious if it. gave that same amount of ~~
light with less fuel consumption.
So we really come back, in thinking of efficacy,
- ‘we come back inevitably to efficiency, the amount
. * of light you get from the fuel that you pay for. ~ '
' Q5l, Referring again to the patent: in suit, and
particularly to-lines 63 to’ 67, you have a copy,
227 ~have you not, Doctor? A. Yes.
Q52. Of. page 1, of the specification, reading as
follows’: ‘‘The function of the disc 11 is to pre- .
vent the air entering the inside of the cap 7 from
cooling the wick 'W to such an extent that the tem-
perature of ‘the oil passing up the wick is reduced
‘ below the desired -poirit.”’?, What relation does the
‘operation there described bear to fuel consump-
tion and efficiency?) A. In general, if, as ‘a contri-
bution the oil is: heated up more in one device than
_ another, in one condition éhan another, it can’t re-
_ sult in anything else than a greater fuel consump-
228 tion, other things being equal.
Q53. Have you given any thought and study to:
‘lines 68 to 100 on page 1 of the — ‘specifica-
tions reading as follows:
‘*When the outer end of wick W is lighted the ©
. ° oil passing up the wick by. capillary action is
- «heated, thereby maintaining the oil in the region “of
‘the outer end of the wick at the proper flashing -
point. - This ‘beating of the wick is facilitated by.
- -. the reflection of heat from the dome-shaped cap.”
What is true or false about that statement? 'A-
The reflection of heat from the inside of that domie
RED ta REE ORES SERRA PEO Spire wise ae at x
77
Luckiesh—For Defendani—Direct
! or cap, that inner surface. After that device is in
operation for a few minutes it is sooted up here,
covered with loose soot, ana it cannot possibly ‘re-
- flect any appreciable amount of energy or heat.
Q54.. You.are pointing in your answer to Fig. 1
of the sheet of drawings, the Withrow device? A.
That is it. |
Q55. Exhibit BI A. You read from the patent.
229
Q56. Yes. What type of surfaces form compe-.—
tent heat or energy relectors?: A. To state it
| popularly, not exactly, as a rule the thing that re-
fiects quite a lot of light usually reflects quite a lot
of heat. That isn’t always true. ‘Stating it on the
‘. other side, there is one thing we do know and can
be absolutely certain of, and that is that carbon
black, loose black, which is called a black body in
science, it is used for many scientific purposes be-
cause it. reflects no appreciable amount: of energy,
radiant energy. It will absorb practically all of it.
Q57. Can you express in. percentage points the
approximate amount of heat or energy the cap 8
of Fig. 1 would reflect? A.- The actual sooted sur-
230
- face there would reflect not more than two or three ee
per cent. .
Q58. Of the heat which it received? A. Of the
radiant energy.
Q59. Again calling your attention ws the specifi-
‘cation of the patent in suit, and particularly to
lines 78 to 86, reading as follows:
“Air inlet openings 10 being above the lower
edge of the cap leaves a space within the cap and
above-the flange of the wick holder for compara-
tively quiescent air. This quiescent layer of air in.
» contact with the wick: holder and the restriction ‘of.
inlet ports to admit fo the wick and holder only
such air as is iteeded for combustion aids in main- ¥
. taining the heat of the wick holder and wick.”’
by re? S84 ced F
. 7T Y OTA oot er Fe YP Pe ae > BERN te
. Kr ae Se oe SN
931
;
'
2]
.
Cee ETN ES ew
e .
“ ee te
}
232
233
234
78
| Luckiesh—For Defendant—Direct
, ? > : Lay .
‘Have you formed any opinion about ‘the exist- :
‘ence of that layer of quiescent air in the structure ©.
of the patent if suit? A. It may be'reasonably —
quiescent in the state of zero wind velocity, but it
is inconceivable that you could -describe that as.
Q60. You have examined the‘ ‘patent to Maleov,
Russian patent No. 1163 of 1868? A. <I have.
Q61. And are familiar with it and its. specifica.
tion? A.- Yes. ©
_a layer of quieséent air when, there is any wind
, velocity above practically zero.
._ Mr. Wisner: J- offer i in evidence as Defend-
ant’s Exhibit I a model taken from the patent: =
drawings of the Malcov structure.
\ Mr. Darby: I have no objection to the model-
being marked i in evjdence. “I do object to those.
characterizations. I understand that you offer
_ this as illustrating what is shown in the Rus- .
sian drawings, and as applied to a burner body, ~
flare body. I accept it for that pyrpose,
‘Mr. Wisner: You are correct.
(Marked Defendant ’s a I ‘in evi-- |
dence.)
Q62. What was the effect of the device Sicteead
.in the drawings of the: patent to Malcov and ex-
emplified ° by Defendant’s Exhibit-I? A. This .
upper surface certainly protected the flame from
rain. These openings partially protected the flame
from wind, as any partial enclosure will do: o
. Q63. Does the device contain a wick? <A. Yes.
‘Q64. Do you find a wick tube in the structure?
A. Yes.
Q65. A torch body? A. Yes.
Q66.. Also a dome-shaped capt. A. Yes.
Q67. Do you find any flame openings? . A. Yes.
- Q68. What means, if any, were used for the ad-
ites eed Do : LN ree M
.
- x
' fe ; . °
a rachily AR AST AR e “mS Sa) i Sieg Mtg So Pa a RL Aichasci AERP ‘Pepe
i , . “ . * ‘ ~ .
e . ‘ed s .
-
9
x
raaseaauitie ia Defondant—Divect
“mission. of air? A. Air. had té come in the ene 235
ports, of » course, probably quiescent air would |
‘come in at the bottom, and as soon as there is a
_ breeze, as in the cage of these other ones, the wind- ~¥
ward flame forts become air ports and the leeward
ports become flame ports. »
Q69. According to the translation of the wider
specification, and. to that portion. thereof which
reads as follows: ‘‘Fig. 2 shows the regulator which —
: is longer than'the tube shown in Fig. 1. In the
_ upper portion of the regulator cemented with red
‘copper are provided perforations designated in
the drawing by~ dots. ~The ‘apper portion of the 236
~ regulator on both sides is traversed by two ares
DD connected with ring C, but. not constituting an
essential part of the burner. These arcs are.ar-
ranged for the purpose of heating the regulator
and transforming the liquid into gas.’’? >
What would be the operative effect of two arcs
DD, as shown in Fig. 4 of the drawing, Defend-
“ait’s Exhibit B? A. Of course, heat would be —
conducted from this steel surface down to this
ring, and eventually through the wick tube te the
~ wick, just | as it is in all -kerosene ahi, kerosene
lamps. 237
’ The —_— “Do you get some light just from -
' those holes in’ the top? , :
The Witness: They appear to be very small
in the drawing.
Mr. Wisner: The patent drawing hue
‘flames coming out all over the thing. |
The Court: I understand that, but I was
‘just asking whether there would be any light
from the top.
The Witness: Not appreciably. |
Q70. Now, referring again to the specification.
prpatinceee
<
=
7
Z
on page 1,— *.
| . The Court» With those holes ‘in the top,
Pale af course, thefe would not be as much protec. _
tion against. rain as there would ‘be in Fig. 1?
' The Witness: That is the Toledo flare, the
~.. Withrow patent? |
The. Court: Yes. :
Mr. Wisner: ‘Can Your Honor see that?
The Court: Yes... — -
The Witness: Of course, us holes, as
we. know by experience in punching holes in
239 ~~‘ tin cans, do not admit much rain, that is, par-
| ticularly when it. has a sloping side; because
- . . of the sfrface tension the drops of water can’t
7 get through the hole.
| _ he Court: The hoies are "rather ‘amall. °
ba eee, Are those holes described in fhe patent, the _
: | _ size of them? —
Mr. Wisner: It does not.describe rm may
it please the court, it says, “‘In the upper por-
tion of the regulator,’? this whole thing is’
ealled the regulator in the patent, ‘‘are pro-—
s, _ vided perforations designated in the drawing
240 i by dots. »? So they must be very small.
The Court: Yes. J
Q7 i, Referring back again to the ovina e
the patent in suit, and to lines 75 to 78, where it is
explained that heating of the cap conducts heat to
“the wick holding collars 12 and 6 from their sup-
porting flanges, flange 11 receiving reflected heat
and being in contact with the lower edge of \he
ri heated cap, do you find that concept in the Maleov
‘patent specification? A.. Yes, a path of metal
-_ down to the wick tube. That is true of every kero-
, + gene device thathas a holder around it. You. can-
| not avoid that, it is fundamental.
;
. , .
me = Seaeleeaianaacediaae ee aed _
, . . e~
.
Luckies h—For Defendant—Direct
®
-Q72., Are you aware e of dhy written Sunitations
about which you have been interrogated? A. I
. have run across a good many of them in the litera-
| mine. @
Bt lows: ,
“Tn .the modern oil lamp the rush of air > eh x
diffused by the wire gauze or holes at the base of
the burner, these metal ‘parts being hot also serve
to warm the oil before it reaches the burning end
combustion. id
. not a new concept when the book was published?
or disclosures of this heating of the wick tube |
ture, I think there is the sentence iii. that book of
. Diiedlng your attention to page 60 of |
_ Luckiesh on erica aes Light, where it says as fol- -
the pull of the chimmey is broken and the air is-
of the wick, thus serviig to aid vaporization. and —
That was included by you in your book, that was |
241
a
A. No.
Q74. You will notice in the specifications of' the
tare being made of<steel. In the event that it be-
what materials would suggest themselves to you’
use copper. That would ‘be about nine times as
. great as the conductivity of steel.
— Q75. And that i is thé difference i in the character
of the two metals; which is well knownt A. Yes.
Q76. Now, have you observed in operation as a
- torch of the structure in evidence, Defendant’s Ex-.
; hibit I? A. Ihave, — ‘
~ Q77. And under.what weather conditions did
and it was snowing. t
patent in suit, that it was first described as a strue-.-
came desirable to conduct heat to the wick tube, .
ag being more efficacious? A. If I would take ad-
__yantage of whatever they would give me, I would —
‘you observe that? A. A several mile an hour wind ,
7 nt orn i a see
7 :
tect re iat
—_————
82
' i ae. Lrickiesh—For Defendant—Direct
244° Q78. Heavy or light snow? A. Light snow.
, Q79.- And how did it burnt. A. Very well.
-Q80. And.in connection with your preparation of
: : this case, you are aware of cértain researches con- .
ee | ducted at the University of Iowat?. A’ Yes.
. te ieee Q81. And you were not present at any time dur-
| | . ing. any of the tests which were made? A. No.
_** Q82..Have you anything to do with research’
methods, and are you familiar with them? A. I’
y ieee ‘have spent my 27 years associated with them and —
’ devising them and correcting them. Pp -
Q83. And that is in connection: with your work
‘245 with the General Electric ¢ Company? A. Yes.
Q84. Have’ you had anything to do with methods
used in this research? A. I collaborated on the
"program of a research. approach and it was carried
> through. - =
Q85. You have examined the data. submitted by
: the testing-engineers? A. Yes. :
—. Q86. I now direct your attention to Figure 35 of
the graph ‘of Exhibit F. A. I have it. —
Q87. What does that graph tell us about the rela-
. ee ___tive-efficiency of the structure of the patent in suit
<a | ' .-qwith and without the burner cap 8t A. That
. || 246 shows— |
f- Mr. Darby: .J ust a minute. I object to that,
Hi . Your Honor, as incompetent, irrelevant and
N i oo . immaterial. I do not think that it is of any :
ik | , issue in this case.
_ The Court: Well, I will take this testimony,
but I do not think myself that this point seems
much of a basis of comparison. Mr. Witness,
you may proceed. — : é
‘The Witness: That wick is three-quarters. of an
inch in diameter (indicating an exhibit). Why
wagn't it one-quarter of an inch in diameter, why —
b
SS RO Tg aah LENDS Heer tm
5 » -
ornare oe
Luckiesh—For Defendant—Direct
was it three-quarters of an inch in diameter?. Why 247° oni a
- not compare the quarter-inch wick sticking out — f 4
1% inches, i in that black bomb, with that particular *~ } |
- device? There is no fundamental way of compar- “3. aR
_ inig, if you use the open torcli. The only way you . 1 i
arrive at a fundamental is control of all variables - uf
_ except one. The only way you can get basic,
foundational information.on the effect of a cap on eet
. efficiency is to test it on and off of a given device. | es
‘That is the research ep cagrsn ‘Se other |
way.
The Court: Have you used .that device
without any wind, with the wick up %th of
‘an inch—in a wind would. you use it Yth of
an inch? . ee
The Witness; You mean open? \ .
The Court: Yes.
The Witness: I don’t think so, mt there i is
no data indicated that you need 1% inghes
—_¢éither..
The Court: What would you say you would
heed?
The Witness: From what I know now, I 7 a
" would take a-chance on a half an inch. . if y |
(Question'87 was read by the.reporter.) m9 i |
A. This shows within the‘limits of error of data “ L / an
that that device, with a flame guard, always has A | 1
~ lower efficiency than when it has no flame guard, e Oe
that i is, for velocities from zero to 12 miles awhour. ee
"It also shows that the-efficiency in zero wind and eee
very low velacities, under a mile an hour,.is ex-
tremely low. —
_ Q88. And where are‘these torches i: ae i
‘ Doctor? A: On the ground, so'they act as a light ©
source, of the order of 5.or 6 or'7 inches above .__ :| a
the cme | : ‘
a ae
—
De ee al
251
. "wind vel ‘two feet from the ground? A. These
~ two feet above the ground the average annual —
252 velovity for seven evaporating stations over the
ties at any time? A. Oh, yes, it happened that I
found out that wind velocities increased with
drag on atmosphere, ‘and velocities close .to. the
’ for representative parts of the whole United
- feet.
3 Luckiesh—For Defendant—Direct
Q89. Have you given any study to wind veloci- |
had a good deal of flying during the war and I
height. I gave a lecture .on aerodynamics ng
those lines,’and I have had i in my mind pretty well
velocities. We know that “the earth p¥oduces a
drag, that is the movement of the earth produces a:
earth’s surface are much lower than‘at a height.
To refresh my mind, I asked Mr.’ Mize, the chief
meteorologist of the Cleveland station of the United . .
States Weather Bureau, to find me the latest data
States, and he sent down to - to check my
memory— - *
Q90: A document on the form of, the United
States Department of Agriculture, Weather Bu-
reaut A. Yes.
Q9t. And what does this document show about
were taken at evaporating stations where they. keep
the anemometer two feet above the ground. At
country, pretty well scattered, was about two miles
an hour, at two feet.. =
Now, he also gave me, the data from the Weather
Bureau station in the ‘vieinity: of the evaporating |
stations. Those stations have their’ anemometers
about 50 to 100 feet above the ground, and even at
50 to 150. feet above the ground, the average veloc-
ity, in the clear, on the anemometers used, was only
84 miles. an hour at an. average height, say, of 100
Q92. Can you _o—_ based upon the information |
Luckiesh—For Defendant—Direet
_ which you havé, what wird velocities will be at 253
about 6 inches fram the ground, on the average?
A. Well, if the average annual velocity is of the
order of two. miles an hour, two feet above ‘the
groumd, I should state that the estimate for 6 inches
- above the ground would be of the order of one mile |
‘an hour, and the actual data on. record show. very.
_ few yearly averages at 2 feet above the ground that
are mere than 2-or 244 miles an hour. «It would
be my estimate that it would be a safe contention
that at 6 inches above the ground the average wind
' velocity over the-entire year, averaged over the
, United States where the ‘Weather. Bureaus are, 254 Hi
; would, ‘be less than a mile an hour, ° = | |
1° Q93. What, in your opinion, is a fair basis for. -
| ‘eating the performance of one of these flares such. (
as Plaintiff's Exhibit 19? A. Well, you learn: , |
something definite and fundamental with zero wind mally. .
velocity. That is a basic approach that anybody oe i |
skilled ia research would make. Then if we were : } ‘|
- only going to make one more test I would say that. tie
it ought to be an average velocity, maybe. one or a '
two miles an hour, or we might extend it to double — ‘|
- that. Now, if we could not have a high efficiency 4
and good operating characteristics a8 a light source 255 ;
over the entire range, it is perfectly obvious, from |
the standpoint of design, that it should be designed |
4 for. -high efficiency and high efficacy over the miles |
. an hour wind velocities found most of the time. |
_ For example, a 20-mile an hour wind could only : |
-. blow ten per cent of the time if all the rest of the : |
time the wind was absolutely still, in order to get ft
an average of two miles an hour. If we wanted to |
take an average of one mile an ‘hour, a 20-mile an :
_” hour wind could only blow five per cent of the time
With the air still 95. per cent of the time, to have
. that ee - eo
.
° .
.
P ‘
. a vm - NP OT eet Cort OR eRRARO pay OE CTR RAR emp eee
e .
mee
.
LL LTT TOR OP TIO ae POO I, EL OP
an 4
e os) .
: es .
ba 86
. °
4
ne) Luchiesh—For Defendant—Dir i
ing chariicteristics of a devibe like this, from the
__ standpoint of the user, cularly the fuel par-
_ chaser, should be within # range of say Zero to five
“miles an. hour or zero to two miles an Hour; in that
low range. ©. >
(Q94. Referring again to Fig. 35 of Exhibit F,
— to be a graph of efficiency, will you
transfate into ordinary terms the factors which
wete taken-into account as disclosed in that grapht
A. Well, candle power is one way of measuring
light output in,a crude usage of this sort, where it .
257 is. generally horizontal. That is the mean horj-
zontal. candle. power—that is, that is what -was
* measured. When we say illumination, that means
illumination at one foot and it is taken that way.
because we may have a one-foot candle at one’ foot, ;
and we know we have one candle power source
here. Of course, fuel consumption, pounds of. kero-
sene per hour, is taken and divided aa the other, .
and the result. i is efficiency.
Q95. How was efficiency calculated by orie beng
divided by the other? “A. By the light output and
_ . some acceptable term of kerosene cme ane per
258 hour.
- Q96. Drawing your attention to Fig. 36 of De-
fendant’s Exhibit F, what are the variables shown
in that particular graph? A. Fuel consumption is
the ordinate against air velocity.
Q97. What does that. graph show? A. That
shows, with the exception of actually still air and.
velocities below 12 miles an hour, the fuel consump- -
tion’is actually increased with the flame guard, as
it should be;-i
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.