Petition for Writ of Certiorari — Marvin v. Fraternal Order of Eagles Aerie #200 (No. 08-657)
Supreme Court brief2008
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Supegane Coun, US.
\V VQ 08-657 0CT 04 2008
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
Lawrence D. Marvin,
Petioner
Vv.
Fraternal Order of Eagles Aerie #200,
Respondents
On petition for Wnt of Certiorari to the
Nebraska Supreme Court
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
(MR.) LAWRENCE D. MARVIN
Pro se
IOOF Building Suite 201
635 North Main Street
Fremont, Nebraska 68025
1-402-372-8978
American citizen pro se
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
Lawrence D. Marvin,
Petioner
v.
Fraternal Order of Eagles Aerie #200,
Respondents
On petition for Writ of Certiorari to the
Nebraska Supreme Court
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
(MR.) LAWRENCE D. MARVIN
Pro se
IOOF Building Suite 201
635 North Main Street
Fremont, Nebraska 68025
1-402-372-8978
American citizen pro se
l
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
Were the Latino church tenants of Marvin’s
basement assembly-community rooms entitled
to Life Safety enforcement, by local and state
fire officials?
Would the results of this matter have been
better, had Marvin asked the County Sheriff,
instead of the Fire Chief and Nebraska Fire
Marshal Deputy to remove the trespassing
obstruction from Marvin’s land?
Does the U.S. Patriot Act of 2001 and the
Nebraska Terrorism Revised Statutes 28-300,
28-310 and 28-311.01 prevent Marvin from
forcefully removing a trespassing obstruction
from his fire exit egress walkway permanent
route, using self help?
Shouldn’t this civil conviction of conversion be
overruled, reversed, or amended?
Why didn’t the RESPONDENT take posses-
sion of the UNIT when they heard the loud
pop when Marvin snipped the power to the
unit and they knew Marvin was out there?
Why wasn’t Marvin granted IMMUNITY, in-
stead of civil conviction of conversion for obey-
ing Life Safety Codes and Nebraska Statutes
and Regulations in removing the trespassing
obstruction?
Is it an act of terrorism to hire and pay an
i
7. continued)
10.
Et,
12.
operative to obstruct a permanent fire exit
egress walkway route, violating NRS 81-514
and 81-538 federal CFR 1910.36?
Why didn’t the Court see extenuating circum-
stances or extra ordinary circumstances on
the removal of the trespassing unit-obstruc-
tion?
Why didn’t the Court see habitual contempt of
Court Order #23784?
Isn’t the act of PERJURY completed or con-
sumated when the respondent accepts dam-
ages for food when they knew exactly when
Marvin cut the power to the trespassing unit-
obstruction, and they could have removed the
food, so they willfully wasted the food and with
inadequate proof of what was wasted from the
refrigerated unit, by doing nothing and testi
fying that the unit was there at 9 P.M.?
Was it blatant RACISM and HATE CRIME
to obstruct the fire exit egress of Latinos rent-
ing Marvin's assembly community rooms and
then refusing to remove the obstruction?
Do the federal CFR 1910.36 and the Nebraska
LIFE SAFETY CODES and Revised Statutes
prevent Marvin from using self-help in remov-
ing a trespassing obstruction from his fire exit
egress walkway permanent route, so he can’t
obey his Nebraska and Fremont occupancy
permits for various floors in his large building?
13.
14.
15.
16.
feok
~]
18.
19.
20.
ill
Why wasn’t Marvin allowed JUSTIFICATION
in removing the obstruction for unpaid fiat
lease (s) and the obstruction owners refusing
to leave, instead of civil conversion?
Is Lawrence Marvin intitled to Equal Protec-
tion under our laws?
Do provincial interpretations of law take pre-
cedence over national interpretation of law?
Do U.S. RICCO laws suppliment protections
to Lawrence Marvin against repeated trespass
and refusal to leave, by an organization?
Why didn’t the Court PRE-EMPT the ruling of
civil conversion?
Why didn’t the Court see EXIGENT CIRCUOM-
STANCES on the removal of the trespassing
obstruction?
Does this case show that a single solitary
American citizen is helpless against an organ-
ization?
Why didn’t the RESPONDENT take posses-
sion of the UNIT when telephoned by Marvin’s
attorney, within 24 hours of removal?
Wasn’t the RESPONDENTS full intention to
replace the unit back on Marvin's property,
which they did?
lV
Did the Court comprehend that the second
unit also violated, POSTED PROPERTY, and
COURT ORDER #23784, and failure to pay
FIAT LEASE RENT and other required ex-
penses?
Isn’t the act of FRAUD completed or con-
sumated when the RESPONDENT accepts
the supersedeous bond money which Marvin
placed in control of the Dodge County Court?
Shouldn’t the damages for food loss be over-
ruled or reversed for no proof?
Marvin didn’t know his rights and could have
been harmed or injured by the power to the
trespassing obstruction, so what were Mar-
vin’s rights?
Do terrorists and Hate Crime participants fire
bomb churches both occupied and unoccupied?
Can and should we negotiate with terrorists?
Aren’t FIAT LEASES an illegal contract and
are Courts allowed to rule in favor of the FLAT
LEASOR by 100%?
At what point is an American citizen allowed
to use SELF-DEFENSE and is this self-help?
At what point is an American citizen allowed
to be aGOOD SAMARITAN and use self-help?
At what point is an American citizen allowed
31. continued)
32.
to use CITIZEN ARREST by using self-help?
Why should the Nebraska Court system penal-
ize Marvin for not choosing to create a new
zig-zag maze around the trespassing obstruc-
tion of Marvin’s fire exit egress walkway per-
manent route?
Did the local and state authorities get the
trespassing obstruction removed when Marvin
asked for their intervention?
Why didn’t the Court see the fraudulent
CLAIM for food damages?
Why didn’t the Court read the TERRORISM
viewpoint that Marvin testified to in his
DEPOSITION?
Why didn’t the Court assess terroristic threats
against all officers of the organization for plac-
ing the obstruction on Marvin’s exit egress?
Why didn’t the Court assess terroristic threats
against at least some officers of the organiza-
tion refusing to unobstruct Marvin’s exit
egress?
Why didn’t the Court credit Marvin with mon-
etary assessment against the FLAT LEASE (8S)
of trespass?
Does it violate our RICCO laws to hire and
pay an operative to obstruct a permanent fire
39. continued)
exit egress walkway route?
Is it first degree criminal trespass to hire an
operative to trespass on posted property and
obstruct a fire exit egress and willfully fail or
refuse to remove it when requested by the
landowner?
Should the Fraternal Order of Eagles Aerie
#200 have obeyed the Court Order #23784?
Is this civil conviction for conversion under
the same Constitution and Rule of Law which
Marvin served his country to defend, or is it
erroneous?
Why was Marvin never told by the Fire Chief
or the Nebraska Fire Marshal Deputy to have
the County Sheriff remove the trespassing
unit obstructing Marvin’s exit egress?
Vil
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDINGS
Lawrence D. Marvin
Pro se petitioner
IOOF Building
635 North Main Street
Fremont, Nebraska 68025
Fraternal Order of Eagles Aerie #200
represented by
S. Nicholas Boggy
Sidner, Svoboda, Schilke, Thomsen
Holtorf, Boggy, and Nick
340 East Military Avenue
Fremont, Nebraska 68025
vill
RELATED PROCEEDINGS
Court Order #23784 REMEDY for Marvin,
ordering FOE Aerie #200 to get off and stay off Mar-
vin’s land. (see Court Exhibit #3)
iX
TABLE OF CONTENTS
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDING B........................vii
RELATED PROCEEDINGG.......................0006
TABLE OF CONTENTS
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Constitutional Provisions
Statutory Provisions
Evidentiary Provisions
Other Materials
Unconstitutional to require citizens to condone
and/or finance criminal behavior
Clean Hands Doctrine-Old English Court of
Equity
U.C.C. to enforce Civil Rights
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
OPINIONS BELOW
JURISDICTION
CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY................... 5
Provisions Involved
Xx
STATEMENT OF THE CASE................cccsssccscssssssseees 6
Proceedings Below
Statement of Relevant Facts
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION.......... 8
NENT vcicicneacanilecevexsineskarscanisevseachuessuscuoucanseeeas 13
INDEX TO APPENDICES............... ie ivevetehians 15
A) Dodge County Court Decision
B) Dodge County Court history of case and its
final order
]
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
NONE - Just general knowledge of three branches of
government.
The Declaration of Independence
The Constitution of the United States of America
84th Congress 2nd Session House Decument #459
Government Printing Office
Washington, 1956
Major Joint Tortfeaser
Nebraska Revised Statutes
81-501 through 81-541 Assembly Building Permit
28-520 through 28-521 Trespass
28-300 through 28-311.01 Terrorism
Federal CFR 1910.36.
Abuse of Process
Abuse of Discretion
The Commercial Clause of U.S. Constitution with
Protection under the law. Civil Rights Act 1964
2
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
Petitioner Lawrence D. Marvin respectfully
petitions and prays that a Writ of Certiorari be is-
sued to review the numerous errors, oversights,
misunderstandings and the Nebraska Supreme
Court refusal to hear Marvin’s petition for Further
Appeal, because the Respondents had No Right to be
there and to obstruct Marvin’s fire exit egress, and
on modern day Terrorism, HATE CRIMES, and re-
peated First Degree Criminal Trespass over 30 years
by Respondent, and no EXTENUATING CIRCUM-
STANCES, or mitigating circumstances to reduce the
damages set by the Dodge County Court of Nebraska,
for Respondent being a Joint Tortfeasor.
3
OPINIONS BELOW
‘ Dodge County Court reproduced appeal as
Case Number CI05-1045. Judgement March 9, 2007
2. Dodge County District Court Case Number
CJ07-223. Same as County Court July 6, 2007
3. Nebraska Court of Appeals Case Number
A-07-0857. Same as County Court
4. Nebraska Supreme Court Case Number has
not been assigned. July 16, 2008. Refused Petition
for further review
4
JURISDICTION
Nebraska Court System, had uncontested Ju-
risdiction, neither party objected to jurisdiction.
5
CONSTITUTIONAL AND STATUTORY
PROVISIONS INVOLVED
This petition for Writ of Certiorari implicates
the Fourteenth Amendment to our United States
Constitution, The Patriot Act of 2001, Ricco laws, as
well as failure to consider Nebraska Life Safety Stat-
utes, trespass statutes, Terrorism statutes, and con-
tempt of Court Order and refusal to leave Marvin's
property, also federal CFR 1910.36 through 1910.36
(f) (2).
The Fourteenth Amendment in relevant part
as follows:
All persons born or naturalized in the United
States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof,
are citizens of the United States and of the
State wherein they reside. No State shall
make or enforce any law which shall abridge
the privileges or immunities of citizens of the
United States; nor shall any State deprive any
person of life, liberty, or property, without due
process of law; nor deny to any person within
its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.
U.S. Constitution Amend. XIV, sec. 1.
This petition for Writ of Certiorari also quotes
excerpts from Nebraska Revised Statutes 81-502,
81-514, 81-538, 81-527, Court Order #23784 which is
in Exhibit in file, and regulatory building occupancy
permits for Marvin’s assembly areas in his building.
6
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
A. PROCEEDINGS BELOW
Petitioner was convicted of conversion, while
Paragraph 3. reads, “While it is uncontroverted that
the condenser unit belonging to the plaintiff was
trespassing on the defendant’s property, the Court
can find no defense for the defendant’s actions of con-
verting the plaintiffs property.”
The Court makes no comment that the deten-
dant testified that the condenser was obstructing
plaintiffs exit egress and defendant had the non-
delegatable duty to remove the condenser unit. So,
defendant is now petitioning the United States Su-
preme Court on the enforce federal CFR1910.36 and
other remedies.
7
B. STATEMENT OF RELEVANT FACTS
As Mr. Marvin’s petition for Writ of Certiorari
focuses on the facts of unclean hands doctrine that
1) the Respondents were not authorized to be on Mr.
Marvin’s property; by virtue of Court Order #23784:
NRS 81-514: Fremont Fire Chief visit requested by
Marvin: and the registered letter from Marvin to get
off his property. 2) There was not proof of actual
damage for food, plus adequate notice was given to
remove the food and remove the unit; 3) While Mar-
vin’s attorney did not present a formal bill to the
Court, the Attorney for the Respondent did ask for
the amount owed by his client and Mr. Marvin pre-
sented those figures at that time verbally since the
Respondent knew that they created and used fiat
leases and were now being documented in violating
laws, Court Order, Regulations, and Marvin’s prop-
erty rights, so any damages should have been only a
credit against the fiat lease(s). Upon civil tort con-
version Judgement, Marvin authorized his attorney
to appeal to Dodge County District Court. During
Court session Mr. Marvin wanted to appeal to Judge
Samson but Judge Samson ordered the attorney to
control his client, so I did not appeal. So where was
justice?
Mr. Marvin authorized his attorney to appeal
to the Nebraska Court of Appeals and this was done
by, paper only. Then Mr. Marvin decided to continue
the appeal process pro se. The Nebraska Supreme
Court rejected Marvin’s petition for further review
on July 16, 2008, so now Marvin is requesting A Writ
of Certiorari for this very important and unusual ap-
peal about Life Safety, protection and unclean hands
of the Respondent.
8
REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION
Respondent had no right to obstruct Peti-
tioner’s fire exit egress permanent walkway route, so
they have unclean hands.
The Respondents had no proof of actual dam-
ages, just allegations, and why wasn’t anything
worth saving removed when the Fire Chief made his
visit on request of Petitioner, and also the Petitioner
sent a registered letter to get off his posted property
and that he had already won the remedy #23784 in
which the Dodge County District Court Ordered the
Respondent to get off and stay off Petitioners prop-
erty so this is more unclean hands of stare decisis.
Why wasn’t the trespassing obstruction con-
sidered abandoned like a car in a private parking
lot or items abandoned in a rented storage unit for
non-payment? We need new case law covering such
brazen and yes, criminal behavior by the Respon-
dent. While Nebraska criminal statutes start with
chapter 28- but life Safety Codes and building oc-
cupancy statutes and state regulations have 81-538
which is a new misdemeanor criminal count each day
of violation, so this is a civil law and should be used
in this TORT case.
Couldn’t just one Nebraska Judge comprehend
that this so called innocent cow was intentionally
tethered with three leashes documented in the bill-
ings from Fremont Electric wiring the unit and Ar-
don Refrigeration with two coolant lines for circula-
tion of the coolant, yet the Respondent is so innocent
with these unclean hands.
We need new case law for unclean hands, so
wrongful behavior like the Respondents does not
receive nor deserve 100% of any alleged damages,
9
especially when it is so clear that they could have
mitigated any damages by removing their claimed
property or asking this Petitioner for another day
or two, which would have incurred more liability
on themselves if dozens of Latinos from Marvin’s
Building were killed or injured as a direct result of
the obstructed FIRE EXIT EGRESS PERMANENT
WALKWAY ROUTE. The Respondents think that it
is funny to leave this Petitioner at full risk of pos-
sibly millions of dollars for loss of lives and injuries
caused by the Respondent and its agents or opera-
tives trespassing on this Petitioners property and
also violating the Court Order REMEDY or solution
of Exhibit #3 in this court file.
If it took the CONTRACTOR five hours to
install the unit in the middle of This Petitioners fire
exit egress, then the contractor could have removed
said obstruction in less cime and without damage to
the unit.
After the 9/11 ATTACK IN 2001, many of us
Americans feel vulnerable to BULLIES, TERROR-
ISTS, GANGS, AND SO FORTH. The Patriot Act
of 2001 prohibits charity organizations with IRS
tax exemption from funding unlawful acts, so this
Petitioner prays for this Supreme Court to suspend
the tax exemption for the Respondent, and suspend
the Respondents liquor license, and suspend the
Respondents building occupancy permit until the
Respondnent can convince this Honorable Court that
the Respondents are capable of obeying all our laws,
regulations, court orders, and this Petitioners prop-
erty rights.
Petitioner requests the United States Supreme
Court to use its discretionary authority to review this
petition for federal question of our Life Safety Codes,
10
federal CFR 1910.36 through 1910.36(f)(2); Equal
Protection under Law, Amendment 14 of our United
States Constitution; Uniform Commercial Codes for
racism and Hate crimes; Patriot Act of 2001 and the
self help used by the Americans September 11, 2001
United Airlines Flight 93 “Let’s Roll”.
This Petitioner was a volunteer fireman for 32
years as an avocation, and saw devastation live and
even more devastation in training films and TV, but
as a first responder. He had a duty to remove any
obstruction from his FIRE EXIT EGRESS PERMA-
NENT WALKWAY ROUTE as owner of said build-
ing and this duty is not delegateable to any one else,
however since the Respondent has an easement over
this same fire exit egress permanent walkway route,
they have a very same duty to see that said fire exit
egress permanent walkway route is not obstructed,
but they are above the law and so innocent of wrong-
ful behavior and Nebraska Court System thinks or
believes such wrongful behavior should be rewarded
with 100% damages? So this Petitioner appeals for
justice.
Respondents did create an unilateral FIAT
LEASE and did use that fiat lease while impos-
ing the high risk of dozens of deaths and dozens of
injuries due to the OBSTRUCTED fire exit egress
permanent walkway route. What is that value and
why shouldn’t any damages done by Petitioner be
only used as a credit on the unpaid fiat lease(S), plus
the next two fiat leases documented in this case file
which clearly violate Court Order #23784 as STARE
DECISIS.
This Petitioner’s SELF-HELP was only used
when everything else failed to get the Respondents
off his fire exit egress permanent walkway route, so
11
Petitioners self-help was a nonviolent way to address
this wrong.
It is critical for our United States Supreme
Court to send a message that the Respondent also
can not act above the law and receive 100% of alleged
damages, while paying nothing for the multiple fiat
leases which violates our multiple laws, regulations,
Court Order-star decisis, registered letter to get off,
and posted property, and visit by the paid local Fire
Chief, and refusing to remove it.
Petitioner doesn’t believe that our Constitu-
tion gave authority to the Nebraska Court System to
obligate a citizen to accomodate criminal behavior let
alone to finance criminal behavior with a 100% dam-
age award when the Court also entered in its decision
that the Respondent Trespassed. Isn’t that wrongful
behavior?
CONVERSION - Justification 342F.Supp. 1048,
1062; showing of a sufficient reason in court why
defendant did what he is called upon to answer for so
as to excuse LIABILITY. In Tort law a PUBLIC
NECESSITY will provide a complete justification and
Marvin testified in court that the occupancy permits,
for his large 18,000 square foot building consisting
of four floors, required him to immediately remove
obstructions to his fire exits and exit egress walkway
permanent route, exigent circumstance and Marvin’s
attorney presented a copy of the previously awarded
REMEDY ordering the Eagles to get off Marvin’s
land and stay off, Marvin’s attorney also put into
exhibit a copy of the registered letter from Marvin to
the Eagles to get off and of the previous Court Order,
and Eagles Secty Bob Niles testified that he and the
12
Fremont Fire Chief did talk about Marvin’s request
to have the obstructed fire exit egress immediately
cleared of the obstruction, and Bob Niles testified
that he and Sam Denoyer and others read Marvin’s
registered letter. So Marvin should have had re-
duced damages or no damages at all for the repeated
contumacy and the trespass which qualifies for
first degree criminal trespass and terrorism threats
against Marvin’s Latino tenants and Marvin’s family,
as Marvin testified to in his DEPOSITION required
by the Eagles in which Secty Bob Niles attended the
entire Deposition.
13
CONCLUSION
We Americans desperately need new case law for Life
Safety Codes to aid government enforcement and citi-
zens enforcement of rights and duties to Life Safety
Codes of property owners or deep pocket TORT VIC-
TIMS. Whereas government failed to enforce the
numerous STATUTES and REGULATIONS, and
STARE DECISIS of Court Order #23784, for both
buildings, so duties or obligations entraped Lawrence
Marvin under duress to fulfill his nondelegateable
duties to Life Safety Codes of his OCCUPANCY
PERMIT TO PROVIDE UNBLOCKED OR UNOB-
STRUCTED FIRE EXIT EGRESS PERMANENT
WALKWAY ROUTE for himself, his family, his ten-
ants and all PUBLIC GUESTS whether Latino or out
of state guests in his 18,000 square foot building, and
also GOOD SAMARITAN and DEEP POCKETS LI-
ABILITY RISKS for the fraternal brothers and sis-
ters and the PUBLIC of Respondents 21,000 square
foot building whose occupants also exit over Marvin's
same four feet by 89 feet of property, so over 700
persons, at capacity, by FEDERAL REGULATIONS,
USE Marvin’s property for Life Safety egress, and
all three lower Nebraska Courts acknowledged that
this Life Safety egress route was obstructed, but er-
roneously ruled that Marvin should have condoned
this WRONG and accommodate the wrong doer and
basically provide financing for criminal trespass and
criminal obstruction of egress, by awarding 100% of
unproven alleged damages to the Respondent whose
hands were NOT CLEAN HANDS. The Respondent
should only get $1.00 (one dollar) as NOMINAL
DAMAGES AND IT SHOULD ONLY BE A CREDIT
against the VERY CLEARLY DOCUMENTED
14
IN TENTIONAL FIAT LEASES that have not been
paid by Respondent.
This petitioner is petitioning this Supreme
Court for relief from the injustices of the Nebraska
Court System in its not finding extenuating and
exigent circumstances to at least reduce alleged dam-
ages, due to respondents unclean hands and Joint
Tortefeasor, and any damages should have been only
a credit against the multiple fiat leases documented
in this case. And that fiat lease property is subject
to removal and sale for non-payment of rents, rather
than the conviction of conversion. Especially after
Remedy Court Order #23784, the registered letter
to quit or get off Marvin’s posted land, and after the
Fremont Fire Chief's visit with Bob Niles on request
of Lawrence Marvin. Bob Niles and Sam Denoyer
and others very clearly violated our Life Safety Codes
101 of Nebraska Revised Statutes 81-502, 81-514,
and 81-538; 28-520 and 28-1411, and 28-300 or 28-
310, and section 28-311.01 terroristic threats, and
racism, against Marvin’s Latino tenants, are compel-
ling reasons listed the unfair, unjust, unlawful and
believed unconstitutional reasons set forth above; a
Writ of Certiorari should be permited to review the
Judgement, opinion, errors of omission and or com-
mission by the Nebraska Court System.
Dated OO Dndeae. }, 200 §
Respectfully submitted
(Mr.) Lawrence D. Marvin
IOOF Building Suite 201
635 North Main Street
Fremont, Nebraska 68025
1-402-372-8978
American Citizen pro se
15
APPENDICES
A) County Court of Dodge County
Case No CI05-1045
Nebraska Fraternal order of Eagles,
Aerie #200 - Plaintiff
VS
Lawrence D. Marvin - Defendant
March 9, 2007
This bench trial on the plaintiffs first and second
causes of action and the defendant’s counterclaim
came before the Court on December 11, 2006. Ap-
pearing in court were S. Nicholas Boggy as counsel
for the plaintiff and Daniel Bracht as counsel for and
with the defendant, Lawrence Marvin. The Court
heard sworn testimony from Samuel Denoyer, Ardon
Toelle, Bob Niles and Lawrence Marvin. The Court
received Exhibits 1 through 23 into evidence. The
Court heard argument from counsel and took this
matter under advisement with leave to file briefs in
this matter. The Court subsequently received a brief
from Mr. Boggy and Mr. Bracht.
The Court, from the evidence presented and
being duly advised in the premises, hereby finds and
orders as follows:
PLAINTIFF’S FIRST CAUSE OF ACTION
1. The tort of conversion is any distinct act of
dominion wrongfully exerted over another’s personal
16
property in denial of or inconsistent with the rights of
the owner or secured party. Otto Farms v. First Na-
tional Bank of York, 228 Neb. 287, 422 N.W. 2d 331
(1988); Jessen v. Blackard, 159 Neb. 103, 65 N.W. 2d
345 (1954).
2. The plaintiff has met its burden of proof for
the tort of conversion based on the defendant’s letter
(Exhibit No. 4) and the defendant’s testimony on di-
rect examination by Mr. Boggy in which he stated he
knew it was the plaintiffs property, he took pruning
shears and cut the electrical and freon lines, he did
not advise the plaintiff that he had the unit, that he
considered the property forfeited, and that he owned
it.
3. While it is uncontroverted that the con-
denser unit belonging to the plaintiff was trespassing
on the defendant’s property, the Court can find no
defense for the defendant’s actions of converting the
plaintiffs property. The measure of damages regard-
ing the conversion of the condenser unit, is the mar-
ket value of the converted property at the time and
place of conversion. Otto Farms, 228 Neb. at 293,
422 N.W. 2d at 336. See also NJI 2d 4.27 (Damages
- Conversion of Property). The testimony of Arden
Toelle and Exhibits 12 and 13 establish the market
value of the converted property at the time of conver-
sion.
4. The plaintiff has pled special damages for
the spoilage of food and beverage resulting from the
defendant’s conversion of the condenser unit. Accord-
ing to Nebraska Jury Instructions, special damages
may be pled and evidenced in a conversion action.
NJI 2d 4.27-1. The plaintiff established special dam-
ages by the testimony of Bob Niles and Exhibit 16.
17
The Court further finds that the spoilage of inven-
tory is the proximate cause of the defendant’s conver-
sion for the condenser unit and that special damages
should be awarded. The Court is not allowing the
payment of plaintiffs officials for amounts that have
not been expended by the plaintiff. therefore, the la-
bor damages stated in Exhibit 17 will not be allowed.
PLAINTIFF’S SECOND CASE OF ACTION
5. The plaintiffs second cause of action for
damages to the plaintiffs concrete wall is denied for
lack of proof of damages. The Court will not address
the issue of statute of limitations defense due to the
lack of proof of damages. For this reason, the plain-
tiffs second cause of action for damages is denied.
The Court further finds that the county court lacks
subject matter jurisdiction to enter any form of in-
junctive relief as to the conduct of the parties in this
matter.
DEFENDANT'S COUNTERCLAIM
6. The defendant’s counterclaim is denied for
lack of proof of damages.
JUDGMENT
7. The Court awards damages for conversion
in favor of the plaintiff and against the defendant in
amount of $4,005.28, and special damages in favor of
the plaintiff and against the defendant in the amount
of $1,089.00 for a total judgment of $5,094.28, plus
costs of this action in the amount of $42.00.
BY THE COURT:
18
B) County Court of Dodge County Nebraska
Case No CI 107-223
Nebraska Fraternal Order of Eagles,
Aerie #200 - Plaintiff
vs
Lawrence D. Marvin - Defendant
July 6, 2007
The matter of the appeal from the decision
of the County Court came on for hearing on July
3, 2007. The Appellant/Defendant was present in
person and represented by his attorney, Daniel P.
Bracht. The attorney for the Appellee/Plaintiff S.
Nicholas Boggy was present in person. Evidence was
received. Arguments made.
Judgment of the County Court was filed on
March 9, 2007 and the Appellant/Defendant timely
filed a Notice of Appeal on April 6, 2007. The Bill of
Exceptions was filed on May 9, 2007. The Statement
of Errors was filed approximately 41 days later, on
June 29, 2007.
In appeals from the County Court, the District
Court shall review the case for error appearing on
the record made in the County Court. Consideration
of the cause will be limited to errors properly as-
signed and discussed.
When reviewing a judgment for errors appear-
ing on the record, the inquiry is whether the deci-
sion conforms to the law, is supported by competent
evidence and is neither arbitrary, unreasonable nor
19
capricious.
Upon reviewing the record on appeal from
the Dodge County Court, and after presentation of
the arguments, the COURT FINDS AND ORDERS
THAT:
1. The County Court did not err in regard to
the law and that there was competent evidence to
support the finding that the Plaintiff had met its bur-
den of proof for the tort of conversion. Additionally,
assuming without deciding that the County Court
erred in the receipt of Exhibit 16, such err would be
harmless as other testimony setting forth the amount
of damages had previously been received without
objection. Therefore, the Court finds that the award
of special damages was established by competent evi-
dence and , therefore, was not err. Lastly, the Court
finds that the County Court did not err in entering
judgment in favor of the Plaintiff and against the
Defendant and in denying the Defendant’s Counter-
claim.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that the Judg-
ment of the Dodge County Court be and hereby is
affirmed.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that this matter
be, and hereby is, remanded to the Dodge County
Court for execution of the Judgment in accordance
with this Order.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Clerk of
the District Court certify a copy of this order to the
Dodge County Court, along with costs incurred in
this court.
Dated this 6th day of July, 2007.
BY THE COURT
20
fe IN THE NEBRASKA COURT OF APPEALS
Case N. A-07-857
Fraternal Order of Eagles Aerie #200, Appellee
vs
Lawrence D. Marvir, Appellant.
May 27, 2008
SIEVERS, MOORE, and CASSEL, Judges.
SIEVERS, Judge.
Pursuant to authority granted to this court under
Neb. Ct. R. of Prac. 11B(1) (rev. 2006), this case was
ordered submitted without oral argument.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The Fraternal Order of Eagles Aerie #200
(Eagles) owns property at 649 North Main Street in
Fremont, Nebraska, where the business and social
activities of the lodge are conducted. Immediately to
the south is property owned by Lawrence D. Marvin.
The property line between the Eagles’ real estate and
Marvin’s real estate lies approximately 12 inches
south of the Eagles’ building and the Eagles have an
easement of approximately 36 inches on the north
edge of Marvin’s real estate. The easement is limited
in purpose to that of a fire escape and exit plus an
entrance to the building located on the Eagles’ real
estate. From the photos and testimony the area in
question could be described as a rather junky and
21
and narrow alleyway or walkway.
As a result of a lawsuit filed in the district
court for Dodge County, a judgment was entered on
February 27, 1980, in which the court found that the
Eagles had encroached upon Marvin’s property “by
erecting two air conditioning units without [Mar-
vin’s] permission.” After finding that Marvin had no
adequate remedy of law, the Eagles were enjoined
from encroaching upon Marvin’s property “as set
forth above and [Eagles] is ordered to remove the two
air conditioning units within 90 days from [the] date
hereof.’ In approximately 1987, there was additional
litigation between these parties to enforce the above-
described injunction by a contempt proceeding. That
matter did not proceed to judgment, as the Eagles re-
moved the offending unit from the area of easement.
In early April 2004, it was determined that
the Eagles’ walk-in cooler, where various food and
beverage items were stored, was going bad. The air
conditioner/condenser, then located on the roof of the
Eagles building, was checked and it was determined
that a new unit was necessary with a degree of ur-
gency. Evidence adduced by the Eagles was that
because of the need to get the new unit operational
quickly, it was placed temporarily on cement blocks
between Marvin’s building and the Eagles’ building-
-on the easement area--rather than up on the roof
where the old unit was located. The Eagles’ evidence
was that no one in a position of authority a the time
of these occurrences was aware of the past litigation
and court orders involving the easement between the
two buildings.
On April 16, 2004, the Eagles received a letter
22
from Marvin which is in evidence as exhibit 4. Sum-
marized, the letter asserted that the new air condi-
tioner/condenser was trespassing on Marvin’s land
and that he had asked the Fremont Fire Chief and
the Deputy Nebraska Fire Marshall to have the Ea-
gles remove the air conditioner/condenser within 48
hours. Marvin’s letter asserted that he would “en-
force my right, at my convenience and in my way...”
after 48 hours from when the Eagles received his
letter if the unit was not removed. Marvin’s letter
closed with the assertion: “I consider said air condi-
tioning unit donated and forfeited to me.”
After receiving Marvin’s letter, Robert Niles,
the secretary of the Eagles, made arrangements for
a survey with the intent that if the unit was not ina
proper place or was in violation of earlier court pro-
ceedings, it would be moved.
However, on April 26, Niles learned that the
air conditioner/condenser was gone so he called po-
lice, as well as Arden Toelle of Toelle Refrigeration.
Toelle testified that when he arrived he found that
the electrical lines to the air conditioner/condenser
had been cut, although power was still in the line;
the refrigeration lines were gone; and the entire unit
was gone. Toelle located a replacement unit in South
Dakota and installed it on April 28, 2004. Niles
testified that the removal of the air conditioner/con-
denser caused the Eagles to loose beverage and food
products in the cooler having a value of $1,089.72,
and they had the cost of getting and installing a new
unit.
PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
The Eagles sued Marvin on July 7, 2005. In
23
legal elements necessary to prove a conversion. Mar-
vin admittedly removed the air conditioner/condens-
er and admittedly still had it in his possession at the
time of the trial. It is true that the evidence shows
a technical trespass by placement of the air condi-
tioner/condenser within the area of the easement and
outside of the purposes of the easement.
Conversion has been defined as “...any distinct
act of dominion wrongfully exerted over another’s
personal property in denial of or inconsistent with
his rights therein.” Allen v. Dealer Assistance, Inc.,
207 Neb. 455, 460,299 N.W.2d 744,747 (1980). In
Polley v. Shoemaker, 201 Neb. 91,266 N.W.2d 222
(1978), the Supreme Court pointed out that the tort
of conversion is confined to those “major interferenc-
es with the chattel, or with the plaintiffs rights in it,
which are so serious, and so important as to justify
the forced judicial sale to the defendant.” 201 Neb. at
95, 266 N.W.2d at 225.
We do not believe that it can seriously be
contended that the cutting of the power and refriger-
ant lines to the air conditioner/condenser along with
hauling it away and secreting it from the Eagles does
not satisfy the requirement of a serious or major
interference with the chattel! owned by the Eagles.
Marvin’s defense, as we understand it, is that be-
cause a trespass was occurring and he is under a
duty to mitigate damages, cutting the unit loose from
its connections and hauling it away was merely miti-
gation of damages. Marvin advances the argument
despite the absence of any evidence of definable dam-
ages flowing from the placement of the unit over the
boundary line for this brief period of time. Obvious-
ly, Marvin engaged in self-help but such went beyond
24
simply getting the unit off of his easement. Rather,
Marvin damaged the unit by cutting the power and
refrigerant lines, took possession of it, and secreted it
from the Eagles.
The facts of this case indisputably prove a
conversion. While it is relatively easy to imagine cir-
cumstances in which self-help would be justified and
lawful in the face of a trespass in order to mitigate
damages, the trespass by the Eagles was hardly of
the kind that Marivn would be justified in bypassing
the lawful remedies and resorting to self-help--partic-
ular of the kind engaged in here.
Marvin complains of the trial court’s admis-
sion of exhibit 16, a handwritten listing of food items
that the Eagles claimed were spoiled by removal of
the air conditioner/condenser. The supporting testi-
mony for exhibit 16 was from Robert Niles, secretary
of the Eagles club, who testified that one of his job
duties was to pay bills, including for food and bever-
ages. Niles testified that he, along with Mark and
Rose Grude, the cooks, sat down and examined in-
voices and bills as well as the weights of the damaged
meat and prepared the list. However, Niles admit-
ted that the writing was Rose Grude’s and therefore
he did not prepare the document. However, Niles
further testified that he was present and person-
ally examined the invoices for the price per pound as
well as the poundage of the spoiled meat which Rose
Grude wrote down to formulate exhibit 16, totaling
$1,089.72 for lost food and beverage. The district
court found that even if exhibit 16 was improperly
admitted over the hearsay and foundation objection
of Marvin, there was testimony proving the
25
amounts contained thereon and therefore the judg-
ment for damaged food and beverage was not errone-
ous. After reviewing the evidence, the district court
did not err in so concluding.
CONCLUSION
Marvin’s assignments of error are without
merit and the affirmance of the county court’s judg-
ment by the district court is hereby affirmed.
AFFIRMED.
26
D) NEBRASKA SUPREME COURT
AND NEBRASKA COURT OF APPEALS
OFFICE OF THE CLERK
P.O. BOX 98910
2413 STATE CAPITOL BUILDING
LINCOLN, NE 68509
(402) 471-3731
July 16, 2008
Daniel P. Bracht
BRACHT LAW FIRM
127 E. Walnut Street*
P.O. Box 252
West Point, NE 68788
IN CASE OF: A-07-000857, Fraternal Order of
Eagles Aerie #200 v. Marvin
The following internal procedural submission
or filing by a party:
Pet Appellant for Further Review & Brf sub-
mitted or filed 06/23/08 has been reviewed by the
. court and the following order entered:
Petition for further review overruled
Respectfully,
CLERK OF THE SUPREME COURT
AND COURT OF APPEALS
27
IMPORTANT NOTICE
Due to the reduced number of cases awaiting sub-
mission to the Supreme Court and Court of Appeals,
and as part of the courts’ continuing efforts to reduce
case-processing time, future requests for brief
date extensions will be closely scrutinized. See
Neb. Ct. R. of Prac. 6F and 9A. Pursuant to Neb. Ct.
R. of Prac. 10A, if an appellant’s default for failure
to file briefs is issued, appellant “is required to file
a brief within 10 days after receipt of such notice.
Appellant’s failure to file a brief in response to the
notice of default subjects the appeal to dismissal.”
PLEASE BE ADVISED THAT THESE RULES
WILL BE STRICTLY ENFORCED.
28
E) IN THE DISTRICT COURT OF
DODGE COUNTY, NEBRASKA
CASE NO. CI07-223
FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES, Aerie#200,
Plaintiff,
VS.
LAWRENCE D. MARVIN,
Defendant.
AUGUST 20, 2008
Now on this 20th day of August, 2008, this
matter came before the Honorable John E. Samson,
District Judge, on the mandate of the Nebraska
Court of Appeals filed herein on the 19th day of Au-
gust, 2008.
The Court being fully advised in the premisis
FINDS, ORDERS, ADJUDGES, AND DECREES:
1. That the Mandate of the Nebraska Court of
Appeals affirming the appeal of the judgment of this
Court shall be spread upon the Judgment records of
this Court as required by law; and
2. That the costs of appeal to the foregoing
court are hereby ordered to be paid by Appellant and
are taxed at $122.00.
BY THE COURT:
29
F) IN THE COUNTY COURT OF DODGE
COUNTY, NEBRASKA
FRATERNAL ORDER OF EAGLES, Aerie #200,
Plaintiff,
VS.
LAWRENCE D. MARVIN,
Defendant.
AUGUST 25, 2008
THIS MATTER came on for hearing on the 28th day
of July, 2008, on the Motion of the Plaintiff for an
order directing that payment of the supersedeas bond
in the amount of $5,500.00 deposited with this Court
by the Defendant be paid to the Plaintiff. The Plain-
tiff appeared by its attorney, S. Nicholas Boggy. The
Defendant, Lawrence D. Marvin, appeared person-
ally and pro se. Evidence was adduced and the Court
being advised in the premises finds as follows:
1. On the 16th day of July, 2008, the Nebras-
ka Supreme Court overruled the Defendant’s petition
for further review.
2. Subsequent to the Supreme Court’s ruling,
the Defendant filed a “Desire of Stay of the Mandate
or Motion Recalling the Mandate” with the Nebraska
Supreme Court.
3. On the 15th day of August, 2008, the Ne-
braska Court of Appeals issued a mandate for this
Court to enter judgment in conformity with the judg-
ment and opinion of this Court, which mandate was
filed with the District Court of Dodge County on
30
August 19, 2008, and with this Court on August 20,
2008.
4. Through July 28, 2008, the total amount
of the judgment, including interest, plus costs, was
$5,698.08.
IT IS THEREFORE ORDERED that the Clerk
of the County Court shall pay the sum of $5,500.00,
earlier deposited by the Defendant, Lawrence D.
Marvin, to the Plaintiff, Fraternal Order of Eagles,
Aerie #200.
BY THE COURT:
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.