Transcript of Record — American Sugar Refining Co. v. United States
Supreme Court brief1908
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(20,237.)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1906.
No. 281.
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING COMPANY OF NEW
YORK, APPELLANT;
US.
THE UNITED STATES.
APPEAL FROM THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR
THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK.
INDEX
Original. Print.
Oaer 100 TOUUTR ks ob isd csctc ances Rahs Cae Coe eree Seu ONES 1 1
Re ieee are ree nt ee ere IR ce ee hha Rete rater pee te eta me etr 2 1
POMNON-OP MIVOTEED vecccieee mak wor esses ccua yee SOE NSS oa mele, Wee 4 2
Schedule attached to petition .......0. .-sscccccsccerecces sees 9 5
Return of board of United States general appraisers.............. 10 5
Exhibit A—Protest, August 31, 1904 ........0.. 0. cece eee eee 11 6
B—Protest, September 26, 1904 © ........-.. 02.0405. 12 7
C—Protest, October 12, 1904 ..... ......... iSenees 14 7
D—Protest, October 12, 1904. ........0..cceeeeeecees 15 8
K—Protest, October 18, 1904.......... Seen aes a eee AeS 17 9
F—Protest, October 18, 1904. ......0 2.666 cece eee eee 18 10
G—Protest, October 24, 1904......... 0.60. eee cee ee 20 11
H—Protest, October 26, 1904. ......... 2202 ec eee eee 21 12
I—Protest, October 26, 1904 .......... -.. wager aes 23 13
J—Protest, October 26, 1904...........0. cece eee eee 24 13
K—Protest, October 28, 1904. .... 16. cee cee eee eee eee 26 14
—— —
Jupp & Derweiuer (INc.), Painters, Wasuinaton, D. C., DeceMBER 13, 1906.
Il INDEX.
Original. Print
Exhibit L—Letter, special deputy col!: ctor to Loarl, Novem-
ber 23, 1904..... AD MO ia ee = et ee ee 27 15
M—Letter, special deputy collectes t+» doard, Septem-
NPG eI a oscars <i onca Beataindlerh oh ccoes es se 2 16
N—Opinion of board of United States general ap-
jl ue ERIE pvr aNeigiege ©: Sa eat ae A 29 17
Application and order to take further ev iene. pene eee -rees 32 18
Return of further evidence............. 0.0000 ccc ce ec cence ceees 33 19
Stipulation as to testimony, Ke. 22... 00.2 cee eee cee eae 34 19
Evidence before the board of general appraisers. ..... sapien eieie 36 20
Testimony of Ferdinand G. Wiechmann......... 2.2... es 36 20
OME ON ON, Bocas ans cds oo Se malawi wedads 54 37
Joseph A. Deghuee........... RN re moeie ne 61 44
Edward Wolfbauer ........0....... mage toe Pe Pt 67 30
Edward Sherer..... En ere ee ee eee oe 71 dt
John H. Wainwright............. Ss oteareae's 77 59
POON ss aisha ety on esc abe ie cee Ce eeie 81 63
Edwin A. Zeller, Jr..... Reba lorainSerl ere ara rE RAs 83 65
Ernest W. Chapman ... .. ..... Ra noe eae ead 89 7
W. = DHGHOGH: |. cos secs cee ehesioes ae eee ete 91 72
We EE 1 AERO 5.5) 5 oa ie cleiererer weises sauiSe. 2+ sees 93 74
peer RS NIT ic cash iccin «TA. Kwitin viernes 107 87
Ghacles Ae OPQWi GO oie wcsaceln ac ceeds cnt civine 133 112
Andrew Braid....... Seats hemterne te eee ae 154 132
WianyC. JaeO0e .. ok hcciens cove wcae Esecn. |. 143
Ferdinand G. Weichmann (recalled) 2... 2.2.2... 171 148
Exhibit A—Regulations, Treasury Department, May 22, 1883... 175 151
B—Regulations, Treasury Department, May 13, 1895... 187 163
’—United States Coast and Geodetic Survey letter... 198 173
1—series of tests made by H. W. Wiley... 2... 2... 200 174
2—Regulations relative to the bounty on sugar of
domestic production, act of Congress approved
Ostober ¥, T6006. ...... 22. wi ceeces ces eran Se 201 175
3—Comparative tests by Sherer Bros., G. Grund, and
A. Weichert.......... SEUSS NE Ue eps wend Sereda 256 237
4—Resolutions of the Austro-Hungarian cdensiate,
Buda Pesth, June 22, 1898... ........ .....-e00. 257 228
j—Experiments by Sachs....0 2. A Ret ete eet ae 258 229
Compilations of tests made by William C. Jac pais Reokerertaccntar cee 261 232
Regulations of October 27, 1897, governing sampling and classi-
fication of imported sugars and molasses under act of July 24,
WES Scare acetal ie: saeralaynieneseuernte Wb tae dielsin’s, 2 Calwetmestakee” polatesa 325 295
Revised regulations of February 17, 1899, governing sampling
and classification of imported sugars and molasses under act
OF TJaly 2h, WS97... one ewacwcee ES ee aie Le eat te Tee 345 37
Return of evidence by referee......0 200... ee ce eee alee «ae 336
Testimony of Edwin Wolfbauer..... .............080 cee eee « Set 337
Jonn B. THarriaom. .. 2.20.66 ceceen aera eens 379
Bt RIE TN . CUTER So leila das eee wins sare - 3%
REOMNE SUNOOIN | cca rccadee fase. tw ca coh ces 400
Oo: Eh. TSS... ce wise Sie oes slew cage. ae
Creieten A. CNNRNOR ~~ Se cieks cs cede esnn 412
pg aa ean ie Pe eee ROS eee 431
Sao ioe cei ota ht ALOT LLL LALLA POLE DE DAA
INDEX lif
Original. Print.
Testimony of Harvey W. Wiley........ Cee e eer secvee O86 399
Harwood Huntington........ re eee esseen') ee 405
Harvey W. Wiley (recalled) ............ occas ee 416
CROCS TITUNG. . csccceies ae vegease Meicrekes ) ae 424
Frank W. Bennett......... SHASeevneexeeunee MOR 429
Stephen P. Sharples ........ eaters bwaNereeeS - 472 433
Gottfried Landsmann............ Ree | Oe 437
Morris Hasenclever..... ..... err ete eee 479 440
SEE NE a Gah cess caves 400d —VeCes ke eee - 485 446
PORN A UOTORS 5 44) 4 c6e- ved redo ve ear scoveve §=@OU 451
Ferdinand G. Wiechmann ..........2.. 0000 .. 494 454
Harvey W. Wiley (recalled) .........0. 0 eee 506 465
Byron D.C. Foskett.... 000... carve iw oe oe 507 466
Russell W. Moore ..... pawn aan Tercera 509 468
Samuel F. Ballo... 22... Pree ee eee 510 469
Edward Sherer (recalled) ........... EN eeeerene -» O12 47
John A. Sherer (recalled)..... pe eee sam 473
Harvey W. Wiley (recalled).... 0 ...... itanecvs ee 477
t.dward Sherer (recalled) ......0..... errr ae 6 479
Ferdinand G. Wiechmann (recalled) ........... 522 480
Exhibit A—Annual report of E. KE. H. Francis, 1883......... 524 482
B—Annual report of K. E. H. Francis, 1886......... 535 492
C—Certificate of polarization (No, 2918).... ..... 2 549 506
D—Certificate of polarization (No. 2918)....0....... 572 530
K—Certificate of polarization (No. 2918) ............ 595 553
F—Journal of Royal Agriculture and Commercial
Society of British Guiana.... .... re ... = 645 603
G—Plate and sugar readings (No, 2018) .....0....... 649 607
H—Proceedings of the third session of the Interna-
tional Commission, Paris, 1900... .. Peewee 651 610
I—Question of temperature influence on the spec ciffe
rotation of sucrose, F. G. Weichmann, Ph. D.. 662 621
J—From Zeitschrift des Vereins der Deutschen
Zucker-Industrie, vol. 51, Bo. 541, February,
te IRE A Oiled ne area “304 tess 694 651
J'—Translation of Exhibit J............ 02. ee hee 700 656
K—Dr. Alexander Herzfeld letter. ...............0. 705 661
K'—Translation of Exhibit K..... ..... 2.000.208. 706 662
L—Remarks on Dr. Wiechmann’s paper by Dr. Otto
SORIA INNMROME ee attend cna 5 Cetae's 4d SMITE SO 4 WA's A Ae 706 662
1—Sugar certificate by G. Grand SR aOrae it ae), VOR 663
2—Sharples letter containing Bennett tests.......... 708 663
3—Landsmann letter and test....0 0... ....0 0 cee eee ee 709 664
4—Hasenclever letter and test.... 0... ..... 0.0.6 e ee 7 664
5—Sherer letterand test 2 oo... eee ee ee ee . 710 666
6—Tables of importations of refined sugar ......... =. ee 667
7—Articles from ‘‘ The Sugar Beet,’’ August, 1900.... 723 679
7a— Articles from ‘ The Sugar Beet,’’ August, 1900 .. 725 680
9—Proposed amendment offered by *-r. Wiley to reso-
lution of Professor Sachs..... ........6-.00005 7
10—Tests (not set out here); see page 516 ............ 7
11—-Influence cf temperature upon the estimation of
sugar; reply by Dr. F. G. Wiechmann.......... 728 683
27 683
27 683
RSE: VAI cn i Tie a EEE 0 ARE RAPS AOE PAYEE ICP UT OPA D, we) abner ow be sony women ie ~
lV INDEX
Original. Print.
Exhibit 12a—Extracts of letters from Professor Herzfeld to Dr.
BG WN 5 cc. 5 Senleaedredoderaevra ss 729 684
12b—Extracts of letters from Professor Herzfeld to Dr.
Dy i WRMGUINOIT vivcd css ev cebaecdueeseucevies 730 685
12c—Extracts of letters from Professor Herzfeld to Dr.
B. Gy WieohWGtns . .seccccccd-avcewervece. vaes 730 685
12d—Extracts of letters from Professor Herzfeld to Dr.
BE. GNP CHOIOREL ooh ave coven wees east cee viene 730 685
12e—Letter from Professor Herzfeld to Dr. F. G. Weich-
MMMM. ey soy cee.. ke Ae Cew eee Ce TeCNae wn 731 686
Deposition of Alexander Herzfeld... ..... ........+4.. abe escn eee 733 687
Judgment of affirmance .......... cece eee cee eeeees ce eeeeeeee 741 692
Application for and allowance of appeal, oc .eee cece eee eee eee 743 693
Assignment Of OTrOra..... cece ese cree rer essere seers toerseees 745 693
aie? Geka MORE R ENT HERES) He EAS RBERS PEORPEO SCENE ERO 749 695
COIR. cs cdc vasctvsvase sce TAA CAEN tae Sr aerate 753 697
Clerk’s certificate ....... Cabaret ee UN Sea ci eee er ae ers 7h4 698
ne A II Na alten ea a es WE 68 A a) EAL IIRS: HELIN PED a Mam,
AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. VS. TIE UNITED STATES. ft
| At a Stated Term of the United States Circuit Court for
the Southern District of New York, held in the United States
Court House and Post Office Building, in the City of New York, on
the 24th day of January, 1905.
Present: Ilon. E. Henry Lacombe, Circuit Judge.
Order.
In the Matter of the Application of Tite American SuGAR REFINING
Company or New York for a Review of the Decisions of the
Board of General Appraisers as to the Rate and Amount of Duty
on Certain Merchandise Imported by said Company per Myrtle-
dene and Other Vessels. No. 3525.
On reading and filing the petition herein, it is on motion of
Parsons, Closson & Mellvaine, attorneys for the above named
petitioner, :
Ordered, that the Board of United States General Appraisers at
the Port of New York return to this Court the record and evidence
taken by them in each of the matters specified in’ said petition,
together with certified statements of the facts involved in such
nuitters and their decisions thereon.
I. HW. LACOMBE,
U.S. Crreuit Judge.
? Bond.
United States Cireuit Court for the Southern District of New York.
In the Matter of the Application of Tite AMERICAN SuGAR REFINING
Company or New York for a Review of the Decisions of the
Board of General Appraisers as to the Rate and Amount of Duty
on Certain Merchandise Imported by said Company per Myrtle-
dene and Other Vessels.
Know all men by these present, that IT, John A. Sherer, of the
City of New York, am held and firmly bound unto the United States
of America, in the sum of one hundred dollars, to be paid to the said
United States of America, for the payment of which, well and truly
to be made, 1 bind myself and my heirs, executors and adminis-
trators.
Sealed with my seal and dated the 20th day of January, 1905.
Whereas the above named The American Sugar Refining Com-
pany of New York has applied, or will apply, to the Cireuit Court
of the United States for the Southern Distriet of New York for a
review of the questions of law and fact involved in the decision of
the Board of United States General Appraisers at the port of New
York upon the entry of certain) merchandise as above men-
tioned.
1—281
2 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO, OF
3 Now, therefore, the condition of this obligation is such,
that if the above named applicant shall prosecute said matter,
application or proceeding to effect and pay all damages and costs,
if he shall fail to make said matter, application or proceeding good,
then -his obligation shall be void; otherwise the same shall be and
remain in full foree ana virtue.
Sealed and delivered and taken and acknowledged before me this
20th day of January, 1905,
JOIN A. SHLERER. [L. s.]
Unirep Srares or AMERICA,
Southern District of New York, ss:
On the 20th day of January, 1905, before me personally appeared
John A, Sherer, to me known to be the individual who executed the
above bond, who, being by me duly sworn, deposes and says, that
he is a resident of the Eastern District of New York, and that he is
worth the sum of two hundred dollars ($200) over and above all his
debts and liabilities, and duly acknowledged that he executed the
same.
[SEAL. ] ALBERT 8S. WRIGIIT,
Notary Public, N.Y. Co.
Approved,
i. W. LACOMBE,
US. Circuit Judge.
4 Cireuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of
New York.
Petition.
In the Matter of the Application of Tk AMERICAN SuGAR REFINING
Company or New York for a Review of the Decisions of the
Board of General Appraisers as to the Rate and Amount of Duty
on Certain Merchandise Imported by said Company per Myrtle-
dene and Other Vessels. No. —.
To the Honorable the Cireuit Court of the United States for the %
Southern District of New York:
Your petitioner is a corporation, duly organized and existing under
the laws of the State of New York, engaged in business as such at
the port of New York.
Your petitioner being dissatisfied with the decisions made upon
the dates mentioned in the schedule hereto annexed by the Board of
General Appraisers sustaining the decisions of the Collector of Cus-
toms as to the construction of the law and the facts respecting the
classification of, and as to the rates of duty imposed thereunder
upon, certain merchandise, to wit, the importations of sugars im-
ported per the ships entered respectively by your petitioner on the
dates and per the entry numbers set forth in the schedule hereto
annexed, respectfully makes application to this Court for a review of
a EA IESE AO I
NEW YORK V8, THE UNITED STATES, 3
the questions of law and fact involved in each of such decisions
rendered under the said respective dates, and hereby makes
5 the following concise statement of the errors of law and fact
complained of, to wit:
The said merchandise imported as above was classified and as-
sessed for duty as sugar testing by the polariscope, the number of
degrees shown by so-called and pretended polariscopic tests thereof
reported to the Collector by the United States Appraiser, and the
entries thereof were liquidated accordingly.
Your petitioner being dissatisfied with the decisions assessing
duties as aforesaid, gave notice in each case within ten days after
said liquidation and ascertainment of duty, setting forth the reason
of its objection thereto in each case, to wit, that the so-called and pre-
tended polariscopic tests upon which the said liquidations were based
were In each case the polariscopic test of the sugar increased in each
case by certain additions made thereto in pursuance only of certain
regulations promulgated by the Secretary of the Treasury on Octo-
ber 27th, S97, and again on February 17th, 1899, which regula-
tions in so far as they require the making of such additions are ille-
gal and void and contrary to the laws and the Constitution of the
United States. By reason of the classification of the said sugars as
sugars testing by polariscope the number of degrees shown by the
polariscopic test plus the addition in question, your petitioner was
in each case required to pay duty in excess of that which would have
been payable upon the sugar had it been classified in accordance
With its polariscopic test without such increase by the amount shown
in the schedule hereto annexed. The total of the additional duties
thus exacted of your petitioner in said cases is over $5,600, Where-
upon the invoices and all papers and exhibits connected therewith
were in cach of the said cases duly transmitted to the said Board of
General Appraisers, which Board proceeding to hear and determine
the questions of law and fact invelved, sustained all of the
6 Collector's said decisions in the premises.
And for the errors of law and fact in each of the decisions
aforesaid of the Board in this regard herein complained of, your
petitioner states that the said Board were in error,
I. In not holding that the addition to the number of degrees
shown by the polariscopic test of said sugars of a certain percentage
as a so-called correction for temperature, was and is an addition to
the polariscopic test prescribed by the Act of Congress, known as the
Tariff Act of July 24th, 1897: and in not holding that such addition
was and is, therefore, the imposition of an additional tax on said
sugars, by the Secretary of the Treasury, in violation of the provis-
ions of the statutes and Constitution of the United States.
II. In not holding that the Act of Congress by the phrases “test-
ing by the polariscope” and “polariscopie test” intended that the
words should have the same meaning which had been attributed
both by the trade and by the Treasury Department itself to the same
words when used in the previous Tariff Act of March 3rd, 1883.
II. In not helding that the Act of Congress in question by the
phrases “testing by the polariscope” and “polariscopic test” intended
the same polariscopic test which was then actually in force under the
then existing regulations of the Treasury Department with reference
to the ascertainment of duties upon imported sugars, and which had
heen in foree under the regulations of the Treasury Department pro-
mulgated under the said prior Act of March 8rd, 1883, under date
of May 22nd, 1883, in which prior at the same language had been
employed, and which was the only polariscopic test which
7 was then or had ever been in use by the Treasury Depart-
ment in classifving or determining the rate and amount of
duties upon imported sugars; and which was and is the only polar-
iscopic test known to the trade,
IV. In holding that any increase of temperature oceurring in
actual practice reduces the rotatory power of the sugar solution in
the polariscope or otherwise produces a jower test than that which
would be obtained at any lower temperature occurring in actual
practice,
V. In holding that the assertion of some experts and the denial
by others of the existence of any such alleged influence of tempera-
ture upon the rotatory power of sugar justifies the Secretary of the
Treasury in requiring additions to be made to the observed polar-
iscopie vest of imported sugars prescribed by law; and so increasing
the rate of duty payable upen them above that preseribed by law.
VI. In holding that the polariscopic test means “the percentage
of pure sucrose contained in sugar as ascertained by polarinietrie
estimation.”
VIL. In holding that under the existing regulations of the 'Treas-
ury Department “the percentage of pure sucrose contained in sugar”
is ascertained; either absolutely, or more approximately than by the
polariscopic test itself.
VIIE. In holding that under the existing regulations of the
Treasury Department “the percentage of pure sucrose contained in
sugar,” or anything else, is “ascertained by polarimetric estima-
tion; and in not holding that under such regulations whatever is
ascertained is ascertained only in pavt by polarimetric estimation
and in part by an arithmetrieal process of an addition to the tests
hte by the polariscope of ¢ self-styled “correction.”
8 IX. In holding that the segulations promulgated by the
Secretary of the Treasury wnder date of October 27th, 1897,
or the revised regulations promulgated by him under date of Febru-
ary 17th, 1899, in conformity with which such sugars were tested,
are reasonable regulations or ave authorized by the laws or Constitu-
tion of the United States, in so far as they require additions to be
made to the observed polariscopic test of sugar or prescribe a polar-
iscopic test different in any way from that theretofore and then and
now in use by the trade and preseribed both by the Treasury regula-
tions of May 13th, 1895, which regulations were in force at the time
of the passage of the Tariff Act in question, and the Treasury regu-
‘ations promulgated by the Treasury Department under date of May
22nd, 1883, under the Tariff Act of March 3rd, 1883.
According'y your petitioner respectfully prays this Court to order
the said Board of General Appraisers to return to this Court the
4 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO, OF
Pe ee eee Merete ie Stee Teter SS te ne er ee ee ees
NEW YORK V8, THE UNITED STATES, 5
record and evidence taken by the said Board, together with a certi-
fied statement of the facts involved in each of the said cases men-
tioned in the schedule hereto annexed, and of their decisions respect-
ively thereon, and thereupon to proceed to review said decisions and
to detertaine the questions of law and fact involved in each and
every of said cases.
AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING COMPANY
OF NEW YORK,
By C. R. HEIDE, Secretary.
PARSONS, CLOSSON & McILVAINE,
Attorneys for Petitioner,
o2 William Street, New York City, N.Y.
9 SCHEDULE.
The American Sugar Refining Company of New York.
Pro- , Entry Additional
test.? Vessel. Hate, number, duty.
23402 Myrtledene..... haan een ....- dune 27/04 1319382 $1,028.95
24830 POMNOHOHE. cee cecesdedn ooo Atay. Bl /O4 ey 389. 25
24864 Go a ee eer July 28) 04 1553580 620.56
24345 Viseania....... heey ye Nug. 10/04 163427 235.38
25465 Straits of Dover. .......... .. July 22/04 150708 595.03
24824 freer .. Aug. 24/04 73549 6v8.42
26156 Sere ST er ore eT Aug. 10. O04 }U8284 258.
26157 ERNE cin ceeee pekeeye ce keen Aug. 10/94 163426 323.87
26158 BIONOOTOT 5 2 ke adivavds Aug. 15/04 160775 267.33
26215 Rc eave dk ieee v«> veo g, Di /04 1763510 945.00
21453 2 Ae DRS FE hy June 20/04 127150 336.42
$5,628.72
10 Return,
In the Cireuit Court of the United States for the Southern District
of New York.
In the Matter of The AMerntcan SuGar Rerining Company or
New York versus Unirep Srares, Being an Appeal from a
Decision of the Board of United States General Appraisers. Suit
No. 3825.
Return of the Board of United States General Appraisers to the
Order of Hon, BE. Henry Lacombe, United States Circuit Judge.
Dated New York, Apr. 24, 1905,
The Board of United States General Appraisers, sitting at New
York, in response to the oreer of the Court in the abeve matter,
make the folowing return of the record and evidence taken by them
in the above matter, and of the facts involved therein, as ascertained
by them.
6 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
This return comprises:
(1) The protests enumerated in the importers’ petition, Nos.
134269, 142315, 142320, 142321, 142526, 142327, 142328, 142329,
142330, 142381 and 142333, which are marked, respectively, Ex-
hibits A, B, C, D, E, F, G, H, I, J and K.
(2) The copies of the reports of the collector of customs,
11 relative to said protests, which are two in number, and are
marked, respectively, Exhibits Land M.
(3) A copy of the decision of the Board, marked Exhibit N.
Exuipit A, Suir 3825.
New York, Aug. 31, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against your decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by you on 30,000 packages of sugar im-
ported per s/s Frey on the 20 day June, 1904, Entry No, 127150
for the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopic test of said sugar (which is
below No. 16 Duteh Standard in Color), which test and return are
erroneous and excessive, owing to an erroneous and incorrect. method
of testing the same by the polariscope as prescribed by the regula-
tions of the Treasury.
The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No. 16
Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates according
to the polariscopic test thereof, by which is meant and understood
to be the usual commercial polariscope test recognized and accepted
in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by methods and
instruments used by chemists engaged in the business of testing
sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chemists, manu-
facturers and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
That the method of testing sugar “by the polariscope
12 sneered by the Secretary of the ‘Treasury, and which
method was used by the Appraising officers in respect to the
sugar in question is not the usual commercial method referred to,
but differs therefrom in essential particulars, and has resulted in
erroneous and excessive tests and the consequent exaction of ex-
cessive and illegal duties upon said sugar. |
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A. DENISON, Attorney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated Ang. 29/04,
(Endorsed:) 21458. The American Sugar Ref’g Co. Frey
Sugar. 134269.
Custom House, New York. Aug. 31, 1904. Received.
Ent. Liq. Pro.
Vessel. 1904. 1904 1904.
Frey. Jun- 20. Aug. 29. Aug. 31.
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 7
Exuipir B, Surr 3825.
New York, Sept. 26, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against your decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by you on 26300 packages of sugar imported
per ss. Myrtledene on the 27th day of June, 1904. Entry No,
151952 for the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopic test of said sugar (which
13 is below No. 16 Duteh Standard in Color), which test and
return are erroneous and excessive, owing to an erroneous
and incorrect method of testing the same by the polariscope as pre
scribed by the regulations of the Treasury.
2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No, 16
Duteh Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates according
to the polariscopie test thereof, by which is meant and understood
to be the usual commercial polariscopic test recognized and accepted
in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by methods and
instruments used by chemists engaged in the business of testing
sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chemists, manufaet-
urers and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
3. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by
the Appraising officers in respect to the sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive tests
and the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal duties upon
suid sugar.
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A. DENISON, .Aftorney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated Sept. 22/04.
(Endorsed:) 23402. The American Sugar Ref'g Co. Myrtle-
dene. All Sugar Test.
142515. Custom Tlouse, New York. Sep. 26, 1904. Received.
C. Vessel. Int. Liq. Pro.
1904. 1904. 1904.
Myrtledene. Jun- 28. Sep. 22. Sep. 26.
14 Exursir C, Surr 3825.
New York, Oct. 12, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against vour decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by you on 10,522 packages of sugar imported
é
A FR:
SEASON SRE ROR IS RAR TS
8 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO, OF
per s/s Fontabelle on the 31 day of Aug. 1904, Entry No, 175669,
for the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopic test of said sugar Cwhieh is below
No, 16 Duteh Standard in Color), which test and return are errone-
ous and excessive, owing to an erroncous and incorrect: method of
testing the same by the polariscope as preseribed by the regulations
of the Treasury.
2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No. 16
Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates according
to the polariscopic test thereof, by which is meant and understood
to be the usual commercial polariscopic test recognized and accepted
in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by methods and
instruments used by chemists engaged in the business of testing
sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chemists, manufact-
urers and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
3. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury, and which method was used) by
the Appraising officers in respect to the sugar in question, is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom: in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive
15 tests and the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal
duties upon said sugar.
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A. DENISON, Attorney, IT Wall St.
Liquidated, Oct. 8/04.
(Endorsed : )—-24830—142520—The American Ref'g Co.—lFon-
tabelle—Sugar.
Custom Tlouse, New York, Oct. 12, 1904. Received.
C. Vessel. Ent. Liq. Pro.
L904. 1904. 1904.
Pontabeile. Aug. 351. Oct. 8. Oct. 12.
Exurpir D, Surr 3825.
New York, Oct, 12, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against vour decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by vou on 30.483) packages of sugar im-
ported per ss. Pennsylvania on the 28th day July, 1904. Entry
No. 155.380 for the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopic test of said sugar (which ts below
No. 16 Duteh Standard in Color) which test and return are erro-
neous and excessive, owing to an erroneous and incorrect method
EAN TAM Pav eS ee ee
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 9
of testing the same by the polariscope as prescribed by the regula-
tions of the Treasury.
16 2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No,
16 Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain
rates according to the polariscopic test thereof, by which is meant
wid understood to be the usual commercial polariscopic test recog-
nized and accepted in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained
by methods and instruments used by chemists engaged in the busi-
ness of testing sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chem-
ists, manufacturers and refiners at the time of the existing Tariff
Act.
3. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by the
Appraising officers in respect to the sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom: in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive tests
anid the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal duties upon said
sugar,
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A. DENISON, Attorney, LAT Wall St.
Liquidated Oct. 7 O4.
( Endorsed : )—24864—142321. The American Sugar Ref’g Co.
Penna. Sugar.
Custom Tlouse, New York, Oct. 13, L904. Received.
CG: Vessel. iit. Liq. Pro.
1904. 190-4. LOO4. 1904.
Penna. Jul. 29. Oct. 7. Oct. 15.
17 Exumir EK, Surr 3825,
New York, Oct. 18, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against your decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by vou on 9.275 packages of sugar imported
per s/s Vigilancia on the 10 day of Aug., 1904, Entry No, 163,427,
for the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopic test of said sugar (which is below
No, 16 Dutch Standard in Color), which test and return are erro-
neous and excessive, owing to an erroneous and incorreet method
of testing the same by the polariscope as prescribed by the regula-
tions of the Treasury.
2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No. 16
Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates according
to the polariscopic test thereof, by which is meant and understood
ORR EONS EST
3
4
a
3
4
4
|
yf
«|
4
A
|
a
Pa Nt tia eee SES sete (attr Sper —
perenne Yet Bina? Gone a i eae Ls
10 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
to be the usual commercial polariscopic test recognized and accepted
in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by methods and in-
struments used by chemists engaged in the business of testing sugar,
being methods in general use by sugar chemists, manufacturers and
refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
8. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by the
Appraising officers in respect to the sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive
18 tests and the consequent exaction of excessive and. illegal
duties upon said sugar.
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A. DENISON, JA ftorney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated Oct. 15,04.
(Endorsed : )—-25343—142326. The American Sugar Ref'g Co.—
Vigilancia—Sugar,
Custom House, New York, Oct. 18, 1904. Received.
C. Vessel. nt. Liq. Pro.
LOO. 1904. 1904.
Vigilancia. Aug. 13. Oct, 15. Oct. 18,
Exuibir FP) Surr 3825.
New York, Oct. 18, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against your decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by you on 17321 packages of sugar im-
ported per s/s. s/o Dover on the 22 day of July, 1904, Entry No.
150708 for the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopic test of said sugar (which is below
No. 16 Dutch Standard in Color}, which test and return are erro-
neous and excessive, owing to an erroneous and incorrect method of
testing the same by the polariscope as prescribed by the regulations
of the Treasury.
19 2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No.
16 Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates
according to the polariscopic test thereof, by which is meant and un-
derstood to be the usual commercial polariseopic test recognized and
accepted in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by methods
and instruments used by chemists engaged in the business of testing
sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chemists, manufac-
turers and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
8. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by
— fh al I PR Ns ROSE NA PNP RD CREA A EE PLES EE DEEN ALTE LM RUG RANA ian
a ") ~~
f NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 11
the Appraising officers in respect to the sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom in essen-
tial particulars, and ha resulted in erroneous and excessive tests
and the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal duties upou
said sugar.
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A, DENISON, Adforney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated Oct. 15, 04.
(indorsed :)— 25465, The American Sugar Ref’g Co. Sts. of
Dover. Sugar. 142827.
Custom Tlouse, New York, Oct. 19, 1904. Received.
b
C. Vessel. Ent. Liq. Pro.
1904. 1904, 1904.
Straits of Dover. Jul. 22. Oct. 15. Oct. 19.
20 -Exnipir G, Surr 3825,
New York, Oct. 24, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against your decision as to the rate and
umount of duty exacted by vou on 20490 packages of sugar imported
per s/s Falk, on the 24 day Aug., 1904. Entry No. 173349 for
the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polarisecopie test of said sugar (which is
below No, 16 Dutch Standard in Color), which test and return are
erroneous and excessive, owing to an erroneous and incorrect
method of testing the same by the polariscope as prescribed by the
regulations of the Treasury.
2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No. 16
Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates according
to the polariscopie test thereof, by which is meant and understood to
be the usual commercial polariseopic test recognized and accepted
in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by methods and in-
struments used by chemists engaged in the busines: of testing sugar,
being methods in general use by sugar chemists, manufacturers
and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
3. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by the
Appraising officers in respect to the sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive
21 tests and the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal
duties upon said sugar.
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO,
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A. DENISON, Attorney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated, Oct. 24, ’O4.
Bic
(Endorsed:) 142828—25824. The American Sugar Ref’g Co.—
Falk.—Sugar.
Custom Ilouse, New York, Oct. 24, 1904. Received.
12 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO, OF
C. Vessel. Iunt. Liq. Pro.
LOO. 190-4. 1904.
Falk. Aug. 24. Oct. 20. Oct. 24.
Exuipir El, Sturr 38825.
New York, Oct. 26, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against yvour decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by you on 9170 packages of sugar imported
per s/s Nile on the 10 day Aug., 1904, Entry No, £68254, for the
reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopic test of said sugar (which is below
No. 16 Duteh Standard in Color), which test and return are errone-
ous and excessive, owing to an erroneous and incorrect: method of
testing the same by the polariscope as prescribed by the regulations
of the Treasury.
22 2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No.
16 Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates
according to the polariscopice test thereof, by which is meant and
understood to be the usual commercial polariscope test recoguized
and accepted in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by
methods and instruments used by chemists engaged in the business
of testing sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chemists,
manufacturers and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
3. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by
the Appraising oflicers in respect to the sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive tests
and the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal duties upon
said sugar.
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A. DENISON, Atforney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated Oct. 22/04.
(Endorsed:) 26156. The American Sugar Ref’g Co. 143329.
Nile. Sugar.
Custom House, New York, Oct. 28, 1904, received.
C. Vessel. Ent. Liq. Pro.
1904. 1904. 1904.
Nile. Aug. 17. Oct. 22. Oct. 28.
Oe eR Mit Pe ae EER.
ae, FA aECT SELIM a RLY Care
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 13
oe Exner t, Surr 3825,
New York, Oct, 26, 1904,
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Sin: We hereby protest against your decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by vou on 10,000 packages of sugar im-
ported pers s Hlermiaon the 10 day Aug. 1904, Entry No, 165426,
for the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopie test of said sugar (which is below
No. 16 Duteh Standard in Color), which test and return are errone-
ous and excessive, owing to an erroneous and incorrect method of
testing the same by the polariseope as prescribed by the regulations
of the ‘Treasury.
2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No, 16
Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates according
to the polariscopie test thereof, by which is meant and understood
to be the usual commercial polariscopie test recognized and accepted
in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by methods and
instruments used by chemists engaged in the business of testing
sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chemists, manufaet-
urers and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
3. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Seeretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by
the Appraising officers in respect to the sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred ta, but differs therefrom in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive
24 tests and the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal
duties upon said sugar,
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
By W. AL DIEENTSON, AMlorney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated Oct, 22, OA,
(Endorsed:) 142880 —- 26157. The American Sugar Ref'g Co.
Hermia., Sugar.
Custom Tlouse. New York, Oet. 28, 1904. Received.
C. Vessel. Ent. Liq. Pro,
O04, 1904. 1904,
Hernia. Aug. 10. Oct, 22. Oct. 28.
Exutnir J. Surr 8825,
New York, Oct. 26, 1904,
To the Colleetor of Customs, Port of New York.
Sir: We hereby protest against your decision as to the rate and
wnount of duty exacted by you on 83852. packages of sugar im-
ae
14 MIE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO, OF
1. Said classification and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariscopic test of said sugar (whieh is below
No. 16 Duteh Standard in Color), which test and return are errone-
ous and excessive, owing to an erroneous and incorrect method of
testing the same by the polariscope as prescribed by the regulations
of the Treasury,
25 2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No.
16 Duteh Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates
according to the polariscopie test thereof, by which is meant and
understood to be the usual commercial polariscopic test recognized
and accepted in trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by
methods and instruments used by chemists engaged in the business
of testing sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chemists,
manufacturers and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
3. That the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Secretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by
the Appraising officers in respect to the sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive tests and
the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal duties upon said
sugar.
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO.
OF NEW YORK,
by W. A. DENISON, cL tforney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated, Oct. 22, *O4.
(Endorsed :) 26158—142881. The American Sugar Ref'g Co.—
Monterey—Sugar.
Custom House, New York, Oct. 28, 1904. Received.
C. Vessel. Ent. Liq. Pro.
1904. 190-4. 1904.
Monterey. Aug. 15. Oct. 22. Oct. 28.
215 Exuibir K, Surr 3825,
New York, Oct. 28, 1904.
To the Collector of Customs, Port of New York.
Str: We hereby protest against your decision as to the rate and
amount of duty exacted by you on 12600 packages of sagar im-
ported per s/s Frey on the 29 day Aug., 1904, Entry No. 176310,
for the reasons following, to wit:
1. Said classifieation and assessment are based upon the Ap-
praiser’s return of the polariseopic test of said sugar (which is below
No. 16 Dutch Standard in Color), which test and return are errone-
ous and excessive, Owing to an erroneous and incorrect: method of
NEW YORK VS, THE UNITED STATES. 15
testing the same by the polariscope as preseribed by the regulations
of the Treasury.
2. The law requires that the duty on sugar not above No. 16
Dutch Standard in Color shall be assessed at certain rates according
to the polariscopic test thereof, by which is meant and understood
to be the usual commercial polariscopic test recognized and accepted
im trade between buyer and seller as ascertained by methods and
instruments used by chemists engaged in the business of testing
sugar, being methods in general use by sugar chemists, manufact-
urers and refiners at the time of the existing tariff act.
"Phat the method of testing sugar by the polariscope prescribed
by the Seeretary of the Treasury, and which method was used by
the Appraising officers in respect to “ sugar in question is not the
usual commercial method referred to, but differs therefrom: in essen-
tial particulars, and has resulted in erroneous and excessive
27 tests and the consequent exaction of excessive and illegal
duties upon said sugar,
THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO,
OF NEW YORK,
By W. A. DENISON, fforney, 117 Wall St.
Liquidated Oct. 26 04.
( Kudorsed :) 142333—26213—The American Sugar Ref’g Co.—
Frey—Sugar.
Custom Tlouse, New York, Oct. 29, 1904—Received.
C. Vessel, ent. Liq. Pro.
190-4. 190-4. 1904.
Frey. Sept. 2. Oct. 26. Oct, 29.
Exuibir L, Strr 38825,
(Copy.)
Oflice of the Collector.
United States Customs Service, Port of New York.
NOVEMBER 23, 1904.
Board of U.S. General Appraisers, Port of New York.
GENTLEMEN: T submit the protests of the American Sugar Re-
fining Co., Nos, 28402, 24027, 24028, 24827, 2482S, 24830, 24864,
25254, D5, 25256, 25257, 25848, 25465, 25824, 26156, 26 157,
26158, 26212 ‘and 26215, against the assessment of duty as made by
this office on certain sugar imported by them in the vessels named,
the claim being made, substantis ally, that the polariscopic test
28 of the sugar as “returned by the U.S. Appraiser is too high in
consequence of the method followed by him in obtaining
the test; that the Appraiser, in obtaining the test of the sugar, should
Bs ci a A
Fi ee ad
PON ee apes SPIT re owe he toed hA took tla! Nea vial i ne BR On es meee he Meee nd oh end Hh
16 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO, OF
have followed the commercial usage rather than the method pre-
scribed by the Honorable Secretary of the Treasury.
In the ascertainment of the polari-copic test of the sugar in ques
tion the Appraiser has followed the rules laid down in Departinent’s
instructions dated February 17, ISO, TD. 20707, See paragraphs
21 to 65 inelusive.
The question at issue is similar to that which was the subject of
G. A. 4386 on protest making a similar elain,
This office rejects the claim set forth in the protests and affirms its
assessment of duty, Note GA, 4586 and TD, 25305,
Respectfully yours,
(Signed ) I. b. ESTERBROOK,
The puty Collector.
Exumir M, Surr 3825,
(Copy.)
Office of the Collector.
United States Customs Servier, Port of New York,
Serrempen 22, 1904,
Board of U.S, General Appraisers, Port of New York.
GENTLEMEN: [submit the protests of The American Sugar Re-
fining Co., Nos, 20498, 20500, 20799, 20887 and 21455, against the
assessment of duty as made by this office on certain sugar ime
ported by them in the vessels named, the claim: being made,
29) substantially, that the polariveopie test of the sugar as re-
turned by the UL S. Appraiser is too high in consequence of
the method followed by him in obtaining a test; that the Appraiser,
i obtaining the test of the sugar, should have followed the commer
Cin) usage rather than the method preseribed by the Honorable See-
retary of the Treasury,
In the ascertainment of the polariccopie test of the sugar in ques
tion the Appraiser has followed the rules laid down in Departnrent’s
instructions dated February 17, 180, TLD. 20707, See paragraphs
21 to 65 inclusive,
The question at issue is similar to that whieh was the subject
of G, A, 4886 on protests making a similar claim,
This office rejeets the claim set forth in the protests and affirms its
assessment of duty, Note G. A. 4386 and TD. 2438965,
It will be noted that protest No, 20500 is withdrawn in so far as
it relates to the items specified in the withdrawal attached,
Respectfully,
(S’y'd) If. bh. ESTERBROOK,
Deputy Collector.
lL —_ LOE RNA LENS ICR AEE A Sl
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 17
Exuimrr N, Serr 3825,
United States General Appraisers.
New York, Dee. 31, 1904,
In the Matter of Protests 30773-F, ete., of American Sugar Refining
Co, against the Assessment of Duty by the Collector of Customs at
the Port of New York, Before Board No. 3.
SOMERVILLE, General Appraiser:
The importations covered by the protests mentioned ino the ap-
petided schedule consist of sugars of the particular deserip-
30 tion shown by the several reports of the local appraiser, which
were classified and assessed for duty according to the polari-
scopic tests reported by the appraiser under paragraph 209 of the
Sugar Schedule of the tariff aet of July 24, D807, which provides
that sugars not abowe No. 16 Duteh Standard in color, “testing by
the polariscope not above seventy-five degrees,” shall be assessed) for
duty at ninety-five one-hundredths of one cent per pound, and for
every additional degree shown by the polariscopie test, thirty-five
one-thousandths of one cent per pound additional, and that frae-
tions of a degree shall he assessed in proportion, AL the sugars
in question were tested in aecordance with certain regulations for
the sompling and classification of imported sugars and molasses,
published as Troasury Synopsis TS508, and more recently as TLD.
20707, The contentions as made by the importers in their protests
are precisely the same as those heretofore made and passed on by the
Board in the ease of Tn re Bartram Bros, Jn re American Sugar Re-
fininy Co, ef al, Go AL A886 (CT. D. 20850), where the contentions
urged by the importers were briefly summarized as follows:
1. That the tests of these sugars as returned by the appraiser are
erroneous and excessive, owing to an incorrect method of testing the
same by the polariscope, as preseribed by the regulations of the Treas-
ry departinent in question,
2. That the phrase used in said paragraph 209, “Testing by the
polariscope,” must be construed to ican the steal commercial
polariscopic test as recognized and accepted in trade between buyers
and sellers of sugar at and prior to the adoptton of the tariff act of
1897,
These contentions were overruled by the Board in the ease above
cited, and the decision of the Board, after being reversed hy
a1 the Cireuit Court in Bartram rs, US. 128 Fed. Rep., 327,
was affirmed in all respeets by the Cireuit Court of Appeals for
thy second Cireuit in U.S. rx, Bartram Bros., ef a/., 181 Fed. Rep.
So3. A petition for a writ of certiorari to review said decision was
tiade to the Supreme Court, and on Dee, 5, 1904, unanimously
denied,
The questions raised in these cases being identieal in all respects
with those passed on by the Board and the courts in the decisions
2—28I
—
RIED PE 1D tae a8 A Tad PO A TN IRNS AO A EE LEC PRE LF Pte BES PIT Ow Rie Ati AAR EC A a Mi hited Pe ay
18 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
above mentioned, the protests are all overruled, and the decision of
the collector in each case is atlirmed,
(Signed) BS. WATE,
, HENDERSON M. SOMERVILLE,
EUGENE G. HAY,
Roard of U.S. General A ppravse rs,
And for a certified statement of the facts involved in said matter,
as ascertained by them, the said Board states that said: facts are fully
set forth in the decision aforementioned, and that no other faets
were ascertained by said Board than such as are shown by said de-
cision and other Exhibits hereto attached,
BUGENE G. TAY,
J. PF. FISCTIER,
Il. M. SOMERVILLE,
Boagd of . OS. General Appraise rs,
32 Form No, S354.
At a Stated Term of the Circuit Court of the United States of
America for the Southern Distriet of New York, held at the United
States Cireuit Court Rooms in the Post Office Building in the City
of New York, on the 15th day of May in the vear of our Lord one
thousand nine hundred and five.
Present: The Honorable E. Henry Lacombe, Circuit Judge,
Scrr “A,” No. 3825,
Tue Amentean SuGcar Rerisixa Company or New York
va,
The Unrrep States.
On the application of the Colleetor of the Port of New York,
through his attorney, Henry Lo Burnett, UL 8. Attorney for the
Southern District of New York,
It ix ordered that this cause be referred to Marion De Vries, Esq.,
or any one of the U.S. General Appraisers, as an oflicer of the Court,
to take and return to the Court such further evidence herein as may
be offered by the said Colleetor, and that the importers or their at-
torneys have reasonable notice of the time and place of taking such
further evidence,
EK. 1. LACOMBE,
US. Cirenit Judge.
(Enidorsed:) Suit “A” No, 3825—U. 8S. Cireuit Court, Southern
District of New York.—The American Sugar Refining Company of
New York, against The United States.—Application and order to
take further evidence.—Henry L. Burnett, U.S. Atty and Att'y
for Colleetor.-U, 8S, Cireuit Court, Southern District New York,
Filed May 15, 1996, John A. Shields, Clerk.
ww Laiprhet aha RSLS FS IPA E AEDS ALAR TL PB NP AEE IEP R LI RELDY SEO PARI
. DA Rit eUhOiA a SORE SAME AS sgt . ,
Spahr eaes 0a SIC A OURAN ‘
NEW YORK VS. TITE UNITED STATES. 19
$38 United States Cireuit Court, Sonthern District of New York.
No, 3825.
Tie American Sugar Revixnina Company ov New York
v.
Tur Unrrep Srares or America.
To the Cireuit Court of the United States for the Southern District
of New York:
The undersigned, a General Appraiser under the Act of June
1th, TSH, to whom it was referred by this Honorable Court by an
order made May 15, 1905, to take further evidence in the above-
entitled matter, do- hereby return such further evidence taken hy
he purstant to such order,
Dated, New York, Oet., 1905,
WB. HOWELL,
United States General Al ppraiser,
as an O ilive r of the Court.
|
ae | United States Cirenit Court, Southern District of New York,
No, 3825, |
Thre Awenteaxn Stearn Revintna Company or New York |
Turk Unxrrep Srates OF AMERICA,
New York, Oclober 19, 1905, |
Before Hon. William B. Howell, as Officer of the Court, |
Appearances,
For the Petitioners: Messrs, Parsons, Closson & Mellvaine (hy
Albert S. Wright, sq. ).
For the United States: Charles Duane Baker, Esq., Asst UL 8,
Attorney,
Stipulation.
In this cause it is agreed that the sugars in question were tested
wid classified in accordance with the treasury regulations of Oecto-
her 27, 1897, and of February 17th, 1899, and that the questions
raised are the same as those in the eases of Joseph FE. Bartram and
others +. The United States, Benjamin TL. Howell and others v.
The United States, and The American Sugar Refining Company»,
The United States reported in 128 Fed. Rep, 827 and in I8L Ped,
Rep. SS and it is agreed that the evidence and exhibits in those
tises contained on pages 38 to 364 inclusive and pages 373 to 734
inclusive of the Transcript of Record in those cases prepared for the
20 {HE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
Supreme Court of the United States and contained in the volume
filed herewith and identified by the signatures of Parsons,
BD Closson & Mellvaine, attorneys for the petitioners, and of
Henry L. Burnett, U.S. Attorney for the United States, are
to be treated as duly taken and introduced as evidence in this cause,
Mr. Wricut: L offer in evidence the deposition of Alexander
Herzfeld taken in this proceeding before Albert S. Wright, Notary
Public, April 28, 1905, which original deposition is already on file
with the Clerk of this Court.
Mr. Baker: I object-to the deposition offered by the learned
counsel upon the ground, first, that it appears from the face of the
deposition itself that the testimony of the witness, therein set forth,
was not taken before a Referee duly appointed by the Circuit Court
in the suit in question; second, upon the ground that the testimony
of the witness contained in said deposition, is irrelevant, Incompetent
and immaterial; and, third, upon the ground that the testimony of
the witness named in the deposition offered in evidence was not
taken in accordanes with or pursuant to the provisions of the .Nct
of 1890, known as the Customs Administrative Act.
The Rereree: The objection is sustained, on the ground that
there is no provision in the statute for the taking of depositions in
those cases de bene esse,
Admission of deposition insisted upon under Rule XI; so ad-
mitted.
Testimony closed.
36 Testimony.
{Taken in Pursuanf- to Poregoing Stipulation. |
Before the Board of U.S. General Appraisers.
In the Matter of the Protest of The American SuGar RErINING
Co., 247 69-F , 82662 3-F, 31941-F, and 25348-F ; Bartram Bros.,
J11ISO-F, and B. WL. Wowerrn, Son & Company, 3/501/4-F, 2918,
2919, 2920.
New York, Dec. 15, 1898.
Present: General Appraiser Somerville, chairman; General Ap-
praiser Tichenor, General Appraiser Wilkinson.
Appearances,
W. J. Gibson, Esq., for the Government.
A. K. Tingle, Esq., for the American Sugar Refining Co.
W. D. Goodwin, stenographer.
Ferpixanp Geriarp WrEcH MANN, called as a witness for the pro-
testants having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
sy Mr. TINGLE:
Q. Will vou give your full name, Doctor?
A. Fer-inand Gerhard Wiechmann.
ene PARTI Ne SLOPE SNE eh hic aie
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 21
Q. What is your profession?
A. Tam a chemist by profession.
Q. Of how long experience?
A. T graduated in the year 1881 from the school of mines, Colum-
bia College. 1 then pursued a post-graduate course at Columbia
university, taking my degree as doctor of philosophy in June, 1882.
During the year just referred to, | also acted as private assistant to
Professor Charles F. Chandler, professor of chemistry of the univer-
sity, In the fall of 1882 T went abroad and was inscribed as a regu-
lar student in the university of Berlin. I returned to the
OF States in TS83 and was appointed a fellow in chemistry at
Columbia university, and have served in various grades as
teacher of chemistry at the university until July, 1897, when I re-
signed. Since the fall of 1888, T may say, T have been connected
with the sugar industry in New York and vicinity. My first experi-
ence was with the Brooklyn Sugar Refining Company for two years,
and then for six months with the Havemeyer Refining Company at
Green Point. Tn the fall of that vear T accepted one with Hlavemever
& Elder's with which concern Tam now.
Q. You have given special study to the question of sugar chem-
istry?
A. T have done so since the fall of 1883.
Q. Are you acquainted with the manipulation ¢f the polari-
scope?
A. IT consider myself fully acquainted with the workings of the
polariscope.
Q. How long an experience have you had in the use of the polari-
scope?
A. Well, T have handled it off and on all the time from the fall of
1883 to the present time.
Q. Are you familiar with what is known as the commercial test
of sugar?
Mr. Ginson: One moment. T ask to have that stricken out be-
cause no such thing as the commercial test of sugar has been estab-
lished.
Mr. Tineie: T will put it this wav: Ts there a method of testing
sugar, universally known and adopted in the sugar trade, and knewn
and considered as the commercial test. by which sugars are bought
and sold in the United States and in Europe?
A. There is.
Mr. Gipson: IT object to that.
(Mr. Tincie:)
Q. Is there a test of sugar used in commerce, in buying and sell-
ing sugar—by which it is bought and sold?
A. There is.
Q. low extensive is that test used in the trade?
A. The test to which T refer, to the best of my knowledge and he-
lief, is used by all buyers and sellers in the United States. and with
perhaps only a difference of weight in sample, is employed, to the
best of my knowledge and belief, in all countries in which the buying
and selling of sugars goes on constantly.
22 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
Mr. Gisson: I object to that.
Q. Have you ever engaged in the business of buying and selling
sugar?
A. I have not.
38 Q. You have been connected with some firms as a chemist”
A. Permit me—with three concerns.
Q. With the American Sugar Retining Co., the Havemeyer and
Havemeyer and Elder?
A. Exactly.
Q. As far as your experience has gone in dealit ¢ in sugar it has
been confined to those three concerns. Did you have any other ex-
perience in testing sugar except these three?
A. As their adviser. The matter is one — which IT have given a
great deal of time and attention, and in the course of my connection
with these three concerns an opportunity has been given to
check my work with a great many chemists of Europe. They em-
ploy this particular method to which T have just referred: this is
the full extent of my knowledge.
Q. How many concerns did you come in contact with in testing
sugar in this country?
A. T have stated three, sir.
Q. Did you ever compare your tests you have given with other
chemists?
A. With the work of certain chemists of other concerus upon
which T had to pass and deliver an opinion, ves.
Q. How many?
A. That is impossible for me to tell, because the test~ are simply
sent to me.
Q. You compared how many tests in that way?
A. That is impossible to sav. T could not well do so.
Q. These three concerns are all located in Brooklyn?
A. To the best of my knowledge and belief. ves. and Greenpoint
Q. Have vou had anything to do with testing sugars for any con-
cerns in Philadelphia or Baltimore or in San Francisco”
A. T have examined sugars-———
Q. T mean for any other concerns.
A. T have tested some sugars of the so-called Spreckle- re-
finery
Q. Anv other concern there?
A. Those were exceptional cases.
Q. Any other place?
A. T have done -o in—no, T think T will answer no to that.
Mr. Girsox: T submit that on this point the beard will observe
here that at the very start of this hearing it is attempted to bring in
a distinetion by saving that there is a commercial test. There ts
no such test. and we do not propose that the board shall be misled.
T think this witness is not competent to testify on any definite, uni-
form. general custom prevailing in the sugar trade.
a a ‘ ee ee eres me SERA cape hs PE BibT ise 2 aM a ale eR Ss eonr oie
eed = ve - una
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 23
Judge SomervitLe: | think he is competent and adimit his tes-
tinony, to show, as far as his knowledge extends, what custom may
have prevailed in the trade, within his experience.
39 sy Mr. TINGLE:
Q). Please state what constitutes the commercial test of sugar, as
vou understand it, the method, used in reaching the test of sugar as
used in commerce and trade?
Mr. Gipson: I object to the use of the word “commercial” to
designate a test by that designation.
Objection overruled.
A. The commercial method of testing sugar which I believe is in
general use, is as follows.
Q. Don’t vou know that it is?
A. T know of no exception to it. In commercial practice, 26,048
grammes of sugar to be tested are weighed out in air, by means of
brass weights, and the amount so obtained is dissolved up to LOO
Mohr cubic centinretres. This is introduced into a flask which has
a value of 100 Mohr cubic centimetres at the temperature of 17.5 de-
grees centigrade; some water is introduced into this flask and the
sugar is brought into solution, and a minimum amount of clarify-
ing agent or agents necessary to give a clear solution, and a solution
of light color, are added. Then the content= of the flask are made
up to the mark on the flask which indicates 100 eubie centimetres
by the Mohr standard. The solution thus obtained is then filtered,
care being taken to avoid any concentration of the solution by
evaporation during the process of filtration. And the filtrate thi.
obtained is placed in a tube exactly 200 dnillimeters in length,
the ends of the tube being closed with glass covers, the eaps
are screwed on lightly and in’ a manner that exerts no- stress
or strain upon the glass. The tube is then placed into the
trough of the polariscope and the observer's eve ix applied to the
instrument. When a solution of sugar is thus introduced into the
field of a polariscope standing at zero, it will be observed that a
change of color or change in the intensity of the illumination is ap-
parent in the two halves of the field. The observer then, by means
of a serew, introduces a certain quartz wedge, which is an impor-
tant part of the instrument, and by this means, by the adjustment
thereof, he is enabled to compensate for the inequality of the color
produced by the sugar solution, and is able to restore equality of
tint in the illumination of the full field of the polariscope. Te
then places his eve to the glass provided for the purpose, and on a
seale he reads off a certain number, which, if the test has been prop-
erly performed, and, in the manner indicated, represents the so
called polariscopie test of the sugar; this being the basis upon
which the value of the sugar is caleulated. In other words, the in-
strument, if so handled, will indicate at once the quantity of sucrose
in the solution. T believe this is as clear as IT can make it.
Q. This method of testing sugar is the method used by the trade
24 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
generally, or universally, in the United States, and in Europe, is it?
A. As far as I know it is.
40 Q). Has the svstem been prescribed by any scientific body,
or approved by any such body?
A. This method that [have just described has been in use, com
mon use, for many years; in faet, it is the method upon which the
graduation of the instrument is based. The method just described
is the method adopted for the use of the polariscope many years
ago. It is used in many laboratories in Germany, and in the United
States it may be acknowledged as being the only method, and it is
referred to in all standard works on sugar chemistry. It is, in faet,
I may say, the only recognized method of determining the polar-
ization of sugars by the polariscope.
By Judge SoMERVILLE:
Q. Can you mention any authorities who have recognized this
method vou have just described?
A. Foremost, and first of all Professor Wiley, in his valuable
work on agricultural analysis, Freuhling & Schultz, Prof, Landolt's
work an optiches dresungsvermogen Organischer Substanzen: Doe-
tor Tucker's work on sugar analysis, and in fact PE know of no stand-
ard work on sugar but what refers to this method. Dr. Sidersky’=
work, also,
By Mr. TInGLe:
Q. Have you examined the method of testing sugar by the polar-
iscope prescribed by the Treasury Departiuent, in its regulations of
October 27, 1897?
A. I have.
Q. Can vou state how that method differs from the method you
have jusi described?
A. I can.
Q. Please so state?
A. In the method which is prescribed by ‘Treasury regulations,
just referred to, 26.048 granmics absolute are taken
Q. Is that the same as in your method?
A. But in this ease the so-called absolute @ramimies are uscd, as
care is taken to introduce certain changes in the volume in wheh
the sample is dissolved, so as to make the weight absolute weight,
that is, to render its weight to a vacuum,
The United States Treasury regulations call for this weight:
26.048, absolute weight, to be weighed in vacuo, although the actual
weight has occurred in-air. The weight so obtained is introduced
into a flask which is said to be graduated in true cubie centimetre-
instead of in the Mohr cubic centimetres. The Mohr cubie centi-
metre referred to is an arbitrary standard. After the introduction
of the solution into the tube its reading is obtained, the necessary
amount of clarifying reagents have been introduced, The solution
ix filtered, the filtrate is introduced into a polariseopic tube 200 milli-
meters in ongth, and its reading is taken. The regulations call for
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 2h
the use of two clarifying agents; subacetate of lead and
4] alumina cream, the latter to be used in twice the volume of
the subacetate of lead solution used. The solution is then
filled up to the mark which is engraved on the flask: it is then fil-
tered; the filtrate is introduced into the polarization tube, and the
polarization is taken in the instrument as TP have previously de-
scribed. But that is not all that is required in the operation pre-
scribed by the ‘Treasury Department method. A quartz plate is
next Introduced into the polariscope and its reading obtained. The
observation of a thermometre, which hangs inside of the polariscop:
booth is taken to indicate the temperature at which the observation
istmade, The quartz plate having been introduced into the trough,
a sccond observation is made, which gives the observer the reading
value of this quartz plate; this reading having been obtained, a table
of so-called sugar values is consulted. This is a table which is wuthor-
zed by the Government for the use of their men for the purpose of
those tests, and the observer ix required to look up in the table the
sugar value which corresponds to. the temperature indicated at the
time by the thermometer, hanging in the booth. Then the Compari-
son is made between the reading value of the quartz plate and the
sugar value itself, ax at that time indieated. and. if they are not
identical then a process of calculation is gone through with and a
correction introduced accordingly as the reading value of the solu-
tion or the sugar is higher or lower, as the case may be. The value
so obtained is added generally, or subtracted from the reading value
obtained from the sugar solution. and the result ix called the cor-
rected) polarization,
Q. How do the sugar values thus obtained by this method vary
from the values obtained by the commercial method that vou have
described before?
A. Tt has been my experiences that the tests obtained by the U.S,
Treasury method, just described. invariably are higher than the
tests obtained by the commercial method.
Q. What measures have vou taken to verify that fact?
A. TV have made a number of examinations of different samples of
sugar by both the U.S. Treasury method and. the commercial
method. T have particularly directed my attention in testing these
different sugars in geting sugars which should be as closely chem-
ically pure as T have been able to obtain, but which by my—
Q. Refined sugars?
A, —by my treatment, as T have said, I obtained for this pur-
pose a sugar which tested 99.98 %
By Judge Somervitie:
Q. How many tests of that kind did vou make®
A. Probably a dozen or more, sir: also T have examined raw
sugars. T have chosen for my experiments this chemically pure
‘ugar, for the purpose of showing and bringing out clearly the dif-
ference between the two methods. A chemically pure sugar,
42 if correctly examined, should test 100, That is admitted and
universally established. In following these regulations of the
26 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
U.S. Government method, T have invariably obtained results of over
100 %, ranging from 100,20 to 100,05 ; and this in the chemically
pure sugar when examined with the utmost care and skill, on a cor-
rect polariscope and under the observance of all the conditions pre-
scribed.
By Mr, TINGLe:
Q. Have you ever known any instance in trade where sugars
have been bought and sold upon euch a test; that is, the test made
by the methods adopted by the ‘Treasury Department?
A. No, sir; [ have not.
Objected to as Imm Serial; objection overruled.
Q. Do you know that the Treasury method of testing sugar Is not
used in trade and eommeree by sugar merchants and sugar chem-
ists”
Mr. Gipsox: One moment, that is entirely irrelevant.
(Wirness:) Will you repeat the question?
Q. Do you know that the Treasury method, a preseribed by the
Treasury, is not used in the trade?
A. It is my understanding that it is not.
Q. The corporation with which you are connected deals in sugars
from all parts of the world, docs it not?
A. It does.
Q. It receives sugar from all parts of the world?
A. It does.
Q. You are called upon to test sugars from all parts of the world?
A. 1 am.
Q. In the course of your experience in testing sugars, have you
ever heard of any sugar being bought and sold upon a test obtained
by the methods adopted by the Treasury Department?
A. T have not.
Q. Do you know of any scientific body or authority inthe entire
commercial world, or in the ecientifie world, that has given ap-
proval to this method of testing sugar’
A. 1 do not.
Objected to as immaterial and irrelevant.
(Wirness:) I have never heard of any scientific authority ot
society whatsoever approving of it, but IL have secured the opinion of
one of the most eminent authorities upon the subject of this method.
By Mr. Gipson:
Q. I understood you to say in your direct examination that the
method that you adopted and have referred to as the conr
45 mercial method, or mercantile method, was universally used
throughout the world, in its dealings in sugar?
A. T said it was so, to the best of my knowledge and belief.
Q. Do you know whether or not it ix used throughout Europe?
A. Yes, sir; to the best of my knowledge and belief.
‘
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 27 q
Q. Do you know whether or not this method that you say is the 7
conumercial method, is used in’ france?
A. The method to which I have referred as being the commercial 4
method, is used in France, with the exception that they have another ;
normal weight for the polariscope; instead of 26.048 grammes, and :
they have a different volume of solution. '
Q. The method that you have characterized as being used through- :
out Europe is not used in that identical form: or manner that you d
have deseribed was universal?
A. With the exception of normal weight being different to cor- 4
respond with the different graduation, otherwise the methods are :
exactly identical. ’
Q. Do they use the same flask in France? :
A. That question must be answered by saving that they always
use a flask dependent upon the weight that they make up. Tf they
use a given normal weight then they use a flask to correspond.
Austrian chemists use the normal temperature of 17.5 and the Mohr
cubic centimetre.
Q. Do they use the Mohr flask, the flask that vou have been
using?
A. They use it in Germany where our instruments are gradu-
ated——
() Don’t they use the metric flask, isn’t that known and used in
all the commercial dealings in France?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Do you know to the contrary?
AL T dow t.
Q. In regard to Belgiuin, do you know whether or not in testing
sugars by the method you have described as being universal through
all Europe, is that flask used in Belgium?
A. | don’t know.
Q Cant vou answer that, yes or no, if you have had dealings
with Belgium?
A. Not direct.
Q). Have you tested sugars from Belgium’
A. T have,
Q) Tested sugars from Belgium? Seen their test?
AUT have.
Q. Can you tell from that whether the same method was used?
A. bean say that in using a different flask, if they use a different
flask, they use a different normal weight that corresponds. ‘They
don’t use one kind of normal weight without a flask to correspond,
Q. How do vou know that?
i A. What. By reading the descriptions of the methods they
employ.
Q. | understand you have no personal knowledge, only what you
have read about it. Give the works or papers that you have read
about it?
A. Well, for instance, Prof. Sidersky of France and Prof. Francis
Sach of Brussels, have works on the subject.
=
Q. Do these books that you have specified give this method as the
method that is used?
A. It is given as the method used in Belgium, and in France.
Q. Does it state so in these books?
A. Yes.
Q). Is this the commercial method in these cases or the Govern-
ment method alone? [understood you to include the United States,
within that catagory which your method was used?
A. It is not my method.
Q. The method you have described?
A. That is the method in trade.
Q. Are you familiar with the histories in the United States of the
use of the polariscope?
A. In a general way, yes.
Q. Is this the first time that the polariscope, such as the method
in use in testing sugar under the act of 1897, has been used ini this
country ?
A. It is practically the same method as prescribed under the
bounty law of 1890.
Q. Under the sugar bounty ?
A. It is prescribed, whether it is used I cannot say.
Q. In your reading up have you not taken care to inform yourself
on that subject?
A. On these regulations?
Q. Are those regulations that are now in force under the act of
1897, so far as you know, substantially the same as they were under
the act of 1890?
A. They are similar.
Q. Do you know whether or not there was any duty on imported
sugars at that time, 1890, that required the use of the polariscope?
A. The duty on imported sugars collected by the Government
was by the commercial method.
Q. Was there any duty on sugar under the acts of 1890-94? Was
there any duty imposed upon sugar under the act of Oct. 1, 1890,
from that time up to 1894?
A. 1 don’t know; that is beyond my province.
Q. Do you know what method was used then by the Government
in testing sugar under the act of 1890?
A. To the best of my knowledge and belief they used the method
which we distinguished from the Treasury method by calling it the
commercial method.
Q. And you have just deseribed as the commercial method;
28 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
45 that method was in use by the Treasury Department, as you
understand it up to the date of these regulations (1897)?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Greson: One moment, now
Q. You were asked whether the tests by the buyers’ chemists and
the sellers’ chemists ever agreed; are the chemists known as trade
chemists, considered buyers’ chemists, or are they public chem-
ists
RERERIAM ERIE HAS
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 29
Mr. Grason: One moment, IT object to that——
Q. What are they known as?
A. As trade chemists.
Objected to.
Q. You have spoken of Dr. Wiley’s book on sugar chemistry, I
believe it is; does that contain any statement in regard to the in-
fluence of temperature on the results of testing sugar?
A. It does.
Q. What is that statement?
A. The statement of Professor Wiley, made in his work, is this:
That the influence of temperature is absolutely unappreciable, pro-
vided the solutions are made up at the same temperature at which
they are polarized, and furthermore, that the influence upon the
gyrodynat that is the specific rotatory power of the sugar, is of very
‘light importance, if of any. T have the work here.
(Book entitled “Principles and Practice of Agricultural Analysis,
vol. 8, by Harvey W. Wiley, chemist of the U.S. Department of
Agriculture,” handed to witness.)
Judge SoMERVILLE: Kindly cite the page to which you are about
to refer,
Wirness: Page 117, paragraph 108; the reference I have referred
to is short, may T be permitted to read it?
“103. Variations in specific rotatory power.—The gyrodynat of
any optically active body varies with the nature of the solvent, the
trength of the solution, and the temperature.
“Since water is the only solvent of importance in determining the
gyrodynat of sugars, it will not be necessary here to discuss the in-
fluence of the solvent. In respect to the streneth of the solution, it
has heen established that in the case ef cane sugar the gvrodynat
decreases while with dextrose it increases with the degree of con-
rentration, The influence of temperature on the gyrodynat of com-
mon sugars is not of great importance save in the case of levulose,
where it is the most important factor, the gvrodynat rapidly inereas-
ing as the temperature falls. It is of course understood that the
tbove remarks do not apply to the increase in the volume of a solution
at changed temperatures. This intluence of temperature is univers-
ally proportional to the change of volume in all eases, and
46 this volumetric change is completely eliminated when the
polarizations are made at the temperatures at which the
“lutions are completed to standard volumes.”
(Mr. TINGLE:)
— Q. You stated in your first examination that upon comparing the
tesults of your tests by the commercial method and by the Treasury
method you found that the tests were higher by the Treasury method
by some two or three-tenths, or four-tenths, something of that sort.
To what do you attribute that difference?
A. T attribute that difference to the fact that the correction for
femperatures was observed, when none is called for or justified, as
30 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO, OF
under the conditions of polarization there is no decrease in the
rotatory power of the sucrose or change of temperature in the sucrose,
Q). Is that due to errors in the methods pursued?
A. Tt is due to errors in the Government regulations.
Q. Did vou find any other errors in the Government method or
regulations, as taken from a scientific point of view?
A. There are several to which | decidedly object. In the first
place we declare to be erroneous their method of preparing the
sugar solutions for examination——
Q. Meaning, of course, for polarization?
A. They call for the use of an absolute weight, instead of weight
in-air, they call for the so-called trae cubic centimetre flask and
require that all weighings shall be referred to a vacuum, and sub
stitute the so-called trae cubie centimetre flask for the Mohr: tlask
which was intended to be used by the makers of the instruments.
I firmly maintain that the arbitrary substitution of one set of work-
ing conditions for an instrument, the use and graduation of which
are based upon a different set of working conditions, necessarily lead
to errors and the instrument cannot give the truth, Then the vital
objection is the one To have explained: that a correction for
temperature is made where the circumstances do not call for or
warrant any such correctiou——
Q. Pardon me—for the reason that———
A. That no decrease in the rotatory power of the sugar solution
occurs When the sucrose solution is polarized at the same temperature
at which it is made up, and the Government method insists upon this
very thing heing done,
Q). That is, the Govermmuent regulations require the solution to be
made up at the same temperature and then require further this
correction to be made in addition?
A. Yes, sir.
Objected to,
Q. When you say the Government regulations require that “very
thing’ meaning, of course, it requires that the solutions shall be
polarized at the same temperature at which they are made up?
A. Yes, sir. Before answering that question further, if
AZ your honor will permit me, TP have made a littl memorandum
of one or two objections, and to which, permit me to refer:
First and foremost of my objections to the Government method of
testing sugars, is the facet that they call for and employ a correction,
or so-called correction, for the decrease in the rotatory power which
the sucrose solution is assumed to have experienced in’ polarization.
It is perfectly true that if a suerose solution be made up at a
temperature of 17.5 centigrade, and polarizes, say 100% at that
temperature that, if that same solution be polarized at a temperature
of 27.5 degrees centigrade, it no longer polarizes 100, but 99.7, or
very closely thereabouts. But it is also true that a sugar solution
made uv at any degree of temperature, say 17.5, 20, 25 or 30 degrees
centigrade, and polarized at the temperature at whieh it was made
up, will invariably show the same polarization, That is, if 1 take
NEW YORK Vs. THE UNITED STATES. Ql
oe sugar and make up a solution at 17.5, and it tests 100, and if I
ike thac same sugar and prepare and polarize the solution at the
temperature of 25 degrees centigrade, it will also test 100. Tt is
with this latter condition, not with the first, that we have to deal
in practical sugar chemistry, The regulations themselves call for the
polarizing of the solution at the same temperature at whieh it was
made Up. They are so particular on this point that the Government
requires the operator to be careful not to handle the bulb of the task
with the hands during the operation for fear of changing the
temperature of the solution in the meantime. The vital objection, I
repeat, to the US. regulations, as introduced, is the correction factor,
to allow for a decrease in the rotatory power of the solution whieh
has never occurred, Following the Government method strietly
and conscientiously in every detail, | have, in polarizing sugar that
had a value of 99.98 by the universally accepted commercial method,
never found it te polarize less than 100.20, To be exact in that
instance, never less than 100.275. The average of about ten or
twelve tests have been 100.5125, ieaning, by the Government
method we succeeded in getting a chemical polarization of three-
tenths over one hundred per cent. The Government method thus
assigns toa sugar a value of fully 023 over and above 100 per cent,
The other objections which T have to make are these: The regu-
lations require the use of a normal weight which is wrong and the
use of a wrong flask. In other words, the employment of a normal
weight and flask different from those for whieh the instrument was
graduated and which its makers intended should be used to insure
correct results from: the instrument. We furthermore object to the
specification which calls for the use of alumina cream in double the
volume of subacetate of lead eniploved for clarification (page 24,
line 31), “Phe use of subacetate of lead should, in all eases, be
followed by the addition of ‘alumina cream’ in about double the
volume of the subacetate solution used, for the purpose of eom-
pleting the clarification, precipitating excess of lead, and facilitating
fil/tration.
4s In making up raw sugars it is known that this reagent
added to the solution combines with certain impurities in the
sugar solution for polariscopic observation and entail unavoida-
abie concentration of these solutions, thereby rendering the polari-
scope reading too high, We have to make up a given weight
of sugar to a given voluine, it is understood; such a precipitate
having been thus found oeeupies part of the space that ought to be
eceupied by the water with which the sugar solution is made up.
Too concentrated solutions of course mean too high polarizations,
You are given a flask, and you put into that flask your sample of
sugar, You are supposed to dissolve that in water to bring it up to
the mark indicated on the flisk. Wo must, unfortunately, in
making up suck raw solutions, add certain chemicals, which com-
bine with impurities in the raw sugars. It will be seen at onee that
the addition of subaecetate of lead and alumina eream to the solu-
tion cause space to be occupied which it was intended should be
occupied by the water, for of course two bodies exnmnot occupy the
SPIRES EBT ERT PPP
SNE tsar
re
EERE SEER Tes MIRE PMO EE,
32 {HE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
same position at the same time, and water expands at a temperature
above 4 degrees C. It is important to use as little clarifying reagent
as possible. Therefore we object to the use of subacetate and alu.
mina cream, the latter in double the quantity of the former, as re-
quired by the regulations. In my experience | have rarely found
it necessary to use alumina cream. L have it on my shelf, but
rarely use it.
Another objection that To make is—entirely aside trom the fact
that the so-called corrections are entirely unealled for and errone-
ous—rests upon the fact that the quartz plate, the mounted quartz
plate, ix made to be the basis of these corrections, Now, quartz
is a mineral substance that polarizes light. The quartz plate is intro-
duced in connection with the so-called correction for the supposed
decreased rotatory power of the sucrose solution during polarization,
We are not confronted with eouditions which bring about a decrease
in the rotary value of the sucrose solution, [desire to point out that
the very means and methods adopted by the regulations for effecting
the intended corrections are open to serious eriticism. A) sudden
change of temperature to which a mounted quartz plate is subjected,
may nuaterially permanently change its optical value. 1 have my-
self had experience with a quartz plate whieh had tested about S6
degrees Ventzke when loosely held by two springs. 1 then sub-
jected it to a certain pressure by means of screws, the temperature
remaining constant throughout; and then this plate showed an in-
crease in rotatory power which was carried up from 86 degrees to
over 100 degrees fully 14%. At this point the pressure was discon-
tinued and the plate quickly resumed its original optical value. I
may add here that Prof. Herzfeld of Berlin ¢perimented with me in
this connection. Now, furthermore, it has been my experience that
a quartz plate, which Thad for ten years and which had always
shown a value of 99.9 to 100.0 when tested against chemically pure
sugar solutions, suddenly, after a short immersion in water
49 at a temperature of 35 °C., had its rotatory value increased by
three-tenths. This change of value occurred about tive
months ago, and to the present day this plate retains this valuc of
100.3 in all temperatures between 17.5 and 33 degrees Co 1 only
want to eall attention to the danger of using such methods, which
prescribe the use of finely-mounted quartz plates, and to the faet
that when a change of this so-called standard takes place, the read-
ings are necessarily wrong.
These are the main points of my objections. There are others,
but my statements cover the points briefly without fully exhausting
your patience.
By Mr. Ginson:
Q. In following the Government method in making your experi-
ments, what plate did you use in polarizing?
A. T have used one standardized by the Government itself.
Q. What others?
A. One, the value of which T myself determined.
Q. Which one did you use in getting the results?
a el . «i
| ees ne
A. Principally my own. That one having been in use for ten
years,
Q. Without having been standardized?
A. Tt has been standardized by myself.
(). What flask did you use?
A. TL have employed both the true cubic centimeter graduated by
the Government and one graduated by myself.
Q. Which one did you use?
A. Chietly the one standardized by myself.
Q. | understood you to say that you followed strictly the Govern-
ment method?
A. | have done so,
Q. Doesn't that method require that all flasks shall be standard-
ivod by the division of weights and measures of the Coast and CGeo-
detic Survey ?
A. As TP understand, it requires all the flasks used by the Govern-
ment officials shall be.
Do vou or do you not know that for a period of about four
years the Government used this method that you have spoken of in
testing sugars on which it paid bounty?
A. T don’t know, T believe it did,
Q). Now, Doctor, in your testing by the method that you have
spoken of, you took into the consideration the temperature?
A. DT took into consideration temperature to just this extent: I
always seck to make my polarizations at the same temperature that
] make my solution,
Q. Do sugars polarize the same at all temperatures?
A, If a sugar is made up at any given temperature, whether you
make it up at 17.5 or 20 or 80: C, and polarization made at the same
temperature the result will be the same.
50 Q. Now all the instruments that you use are graduated to
polarize at a temperature of 17.57
A. T said the instrument which is in common use in the United
States, both by the Government officials and others, has been erad-
uated at the temperature of 17.5 C.
Q. Now, then, I understood you to say that you didn’t make any
allowance for the difference in temperature above or below 17.5?
A. T maintain this: 1 do not; none is ealled for.
NEW YORK Vs. THE UNITED STATES, 88
(Question read.)
A. IT make no allowance for correction for temperature beeause
none is called for in the method by which | conduct my test,
Q. You follow the instructions recommended by the makers of
these instruments?
A. I make my tests in the manner followed by every user of the
instruments, I do, yes.
Q. For the purpose of insuring exact graduation don’t the mak-
ers of these instruments require it to be at a tes perature of 17.52
A. They don’t.
Q. I understood you to testify on your direct-examination that
3—281
;
SER SSRN ot SRE RE EE ee PBL EIT 4
. ; ; aes ater FO
ee ee ae
84 HE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. GF
fluid water—that it expands beyond a temperature of four degrees
centigrade ?
A. Yes, you are correct.
Q. There would be some difference in a given -olume of water,
would there not, at any temperature above 4?
A. There would,
Q. Now, would not a solution, then, composed of water and some
other substance, say sugar for instanee—would it not vary to the
same extent then by any degree of temperature above four?
A. It would, but to such an extent it is not measurable within the
limits that we have to deal.
Q. Do you ordinarily test all these sugars that you have testified
about in a temperature of 17.5?
A. T do not.
Q. Usually made at a higher temperature are they not?
A. Nearly always.
Q. A temperature probably of eight or ten degrees higher than
that?
A. Sometimes even more than that.
Q. The average would be how much?
A. Tt depends upon our room,
Q. Probably 15 degrees higher?
A. No: varies in temperature; ino August it may reach 104, in
winter it is very much less,
(). Now, every sugar refiner, or every large dealer has his chemist
who looks after the sugar matters, does he not?
A. [ believe they have.
Q. The buyers of the sugar have a chemist and the sellers have?
A. They employ such men.
ol Q. Do you compare your tests made of the sugar for your
concern with the tests made by the chemist of the buyer, do
you not?
A. I do not.
Q. Do you ever compare it?
A. Not as a part of my regular work that does not come to me.
Q. Do vou ever compare your tests of the same sugar samples with
the tests made by any other chemists?
A. I do.
Q. It is invariable that your tests and his tests are identically the
same?
A. They are not.
(Q). Are they ever identically the same?
A. Yes, they are.
Q. In what proportion?
A. T cannot answer.
Q. Are they once in ten cases—in ten times?
A. I decline to answer.
Q. Are they the same once in 20 times?
A. T do not know.
Q. Once in 100 times?
A. T think my first answer covered all those points.
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 35
Q. You are not the chemist of either the buyer or the seller?
A. To am chemist for the American Sugar Refining Company,
stationed at Ilavemeyer & Elder’s.
Q. Now, do you know Prof. Wiley, who is here present, and do
you know Doctor Crampton?
A. T have been introduced to the gentlemen.
Q). And Mr. Braid?
A. IT have met the gentleman.
Q. Have you conversed with them on the subject of these sugar
tests?
A. T have .
Q. ITow recently?
A. Last spring, | do not exactly remember the date, T think it was
April or May: we had one conference in this building and one in
my laboratory in Brooklyn.
Q. On the subject of sugar testing?
A. It was that, ves.
Q. As to the method formulated by the Government?
A. I have.
Q). And the method pursued by yourself?
A. Came into the discussion naturally.
Q. You discussed their relative merits?
A. T did not understand the system of sugar values of the Gov-
ermiment.
Q. Do you understand them now?
A. T certainly think T do.
(). Where did you get your information, Doctor, since?
A. By exhaustive reading of the regulations and by experiments
carried out in accordance therewith,
2 Q. Were vou present last vear in Vienna at a conference
of chemists?
A. I was.
Q. You were present there during a discussion of a paper read by
Prof. Wiley?
A. May IT require that the specifie instance be recalled? There
were several papers on sugar discussed,
Q. Were you present when Doctor Wiley read his paper before
the International Congress on Practical Chemistry at Vienna?
A. T had the honor to preside at that session when Professor
Wiley read his paper.
Q. That paper was on the influence of temperature on polariza-
tion in sugars?
A. Tt was.
Q. Do you know whether the buyers and sellers who test sugars
are uniform, are they uniform?
A. T cannot say.
Q. You referred to Doctor Wiley’s book in connection with this
subject, didn’t that book approve of the method of testing sugar?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Does it give the Government method of testing sugars?
A. That T eannot savy. May T add something? His book is very
i
of
Re Fe TE pet een are
EE IIE:
INTERES
SRE
ak Rea I ll ee
36 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
thorough and I presume it does mention it, but not to my knowl-
edge.
Q. 1 understood you to sey that no scientifie body has ever ap-
proved the Government method of testing sugar?
A. Not to my knowledge.
Q. Did you ever hear of such a body as the Coast and Geodetic
Survey of the United States?
A. I have.
Q. Do you know whether or not they have ever approved these
methods?
A. 1 do not know.
Q. Is that body the highest scientific body established by law for
the adjustment of weights and measures?
A. Tam afraid Tam not competent to frame an answer to that
question on that subject—-too modest.
Q. Does the temperature have any influence on the polarization
of a quartz plate?
A. It does.
Q. What difference does it have—what influence does it: have?
A. That depends upon the manner in which the quartz plate is
presented for examination. A quartz plate is subject to a change if
exposed to an increased temperature, strain or pressure. There is
no telling how great the difference may be to which it is affected.
Q. T understood you to say on your direct-examination that there
was no difference—that of temperature.
A. IT said it made no difference with the sugar. T would not so
state in regard to the quartz plate.
53 Q. Didn't vou state on your direct or redirect-examination
that the polarization of a quartz plate, that the temperature
didn’t make any difference?
A. I did not wish to have vou understand me that way.
Q. How is the rotation produced by a sugar solution measured
by polariscopes in common use?
A. Tecan give you theories.
Q. Isn’t it measured by the quartz wedge?
A. The amount of rotation is measured by quartz wedges, ves.
Q. If that be so, will not the value of the sugar solution be dif-
ferent at varying temperatures?
A. If the quartz wedge be effected? No, it will not be to such a
degree that one could measure it on the commercial polariscope.
Q. Now, didn’t 1 understand you to say substantially, on your
redirect-examination that the principal matter of difference are he-
tween the test that vou call the commercial test and the Govern-
ment was that allowance which the Government makes for tem-
perature?
A. T understand that is a point of contention.
Q. And that the substantial matter of difference is the allowance
the Government makes for temperature?
A. There are several contributory causes, such as the use of tio
much clarifving agent; allowance for temperature and the addition
of the clarifying agents are main causes in my opinion.
beverati iy 7
LO LBO DF AES LO TE NBER VERE NI A
NEW YORK VS. TITE UNITED STATES. 37
Q. The matter of temperature leads them all, you think?
A. If this allowance for temperature were eliminated, you mean?
Q. Would you make any contest on the other minor points?
Those are the real ones, are they not?
A. No, they are certainly not.
Q. Do those other objections of yours, do they make any particu-
lar difference?
A. They certainly do; every one of them contributes to the polar-
ization of the sugar higher than the true polarization,
Q. Assuming that the Government did not make this allowance
for temperature, would there be—that being out of the way—would
there be any appreciable differences between the test of the (Grovern-
mentand that which you have described as the commercial methods?
A. T should still object,
Q. Would there be any difference, materially?
A. There might be on account of the danger introduced by the
use of the quartz plate.
Q. It would be problematical?
‘A. No, it would be a settled probability.
Q. Would it be a sure thing?
A. IT don't know: I cannot see the future,
Q. Do you know whether or not the commercial tests are some-
times higher than the tests made by the Government?
ot A. T have no knowledge of such being the fact.
Q. Have you ever heard of it?
A. This morning, when vou, to my great surprise, stated that you
had taken up a case where the tests that the Government results
were lower.
By Mr. TixGur:
Q. Is it quite reasonable that there might be great variations in
the tests due to the difference in the samples used ?
A. Certainly.
Joun A. Sierer. called as a witness for the protestants, having
been duly sworn, testified as follows:
By Mr. Tincie:
Q. Mr. Sherer, what is vour business?
A. Sugar chemist.
Q. How long an experience have you had in that business?
A. Over 20 years, polarizing.
Q. In that time have you become familiar with trade usages and
customs in buying and selling sugar and in the testing of sugar?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How did you acquire that knowledge?
A. By testing sugar for the trade,
Q. Any other awy—intercourse with the trade and familiarity
with prices?
A. T have had a great deal to do with valuations of sugars, under
the ad valorem duty, for importers and also——
PERG ISS oR a |
ce car
are
LER LT PE PINT EE
—
Nee
oe ere
s
38 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
Q. You have heard the testimony of Doctor Weichmann?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Does your experience coincide with his in regard to the so-
called commercial test?
A. It does.
Q. Do you understand what is meant by the words “polariscopic
tests” as used in the law?
Not competent, ruled out.
Q. Will vou please state, during your experience in the last 20
vears, What has been the method of testing sugar in the trade, and
by the Government, up to the date these regulations of 1897 took
effect?
A. By the trade was that described by Doctor Weichmann, his
testimony exactly.
Q. What was the method by the Government?
A. The Government method was practically the same, up to the
time of the introduction of these regulations now in force.
Q. Was sugar tested when it was dutiable at an ad valorem rate?
A. It was.
5D Q. You mean by the Government?
A. By the Government.
By Judge SoMERVILLE:
Q. How do you know?
A. T saw returns that were made.
Q. How long did that practice last, <0 far as you know?
A. During the whole of the ad valorem act of TS94 sugars were
tested by the U.S. laboratories: all imported sugars were tested and
under the method adopted previous to the adoption of the present
regulations. Under the former regulations.
By Mr. TINGLE:
Q. These regulations were what?
A. The regulations were based upon commercial methods, as
known then and now.
By General Appraiser Tronenxor:
Q. Up to the time of the issuance of the present, they were work-
ing under what regulations?
A. Regulations of 1883.
sv Mr. TINGLE:
Q. T hand you the regulations of 1883 and wish you to put it in
evidence?
A. This was under the act of March 8, 1883, department No. 62,
Secretary's office.
Q. Those regulations, a= vou understand it were in force from the
time they were issued up to the date of these regulations of October,
1897?
A. Yes, sir.
Oa ook ene
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 39
By Judge SomERVILLE:
Q. Any difference, Mr. Sherer, as you understand it, between the
method prescribed by these regulations that you have in your hand
and the method which you say was commonly adopted in the trade
in testing sugar?
A, None whatever.
By Mr. TIinGie:
Q. T hand you also the regulations under the act of August 28,
ISO4, and desire to have that also marked in evidence?
A. T see no difference between these two. There may be a differ-
ence in words, but in general they are the same.
The regulations first produced are marked in evidence Exhibit
A, 34769-F, and those last produced and referred to are marked in
evidence Exhibit B, 34769-F, December 15, 1808, respectively.
FYB) Q. Ilave vou made a Comparison between the regulations
previously in force and those you have in your hand, and the
commercial method of testing sugar and the method adopted by the
Treasury Department in October, 1807? Are vou familiar with the
last regulations?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Have vou made any experimental tests for the purpose of
showing any results between the two methods of testing?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Please state what these results are’
A. T have not them with me, but we made a series of experiments
hy both methods in my laboratory.
Q. Refreshing your memory from this paper (paper handed wit-
ness) can vou state what difference there is between the two methods
of testing sugar in results?
A. The experiments made by us showed an average difference of
four-tenths of a degrees on pure refined sugar, a sample of which we
received frome Doctor Wiechmann, the true polarization of which
was 99.98. We found the difference to be on the average four-
tenths of a degree above the commercial method.
Q. Tlow much above 100?
A. The average above 100 was .276, practically 3) 10 of the aver-
age of a number of tests.
By Judge SoMERVILLE:
Q). How many tests did you make showing that result?
A. We made ten tests at different dates.
By Mr, TInGue:
Q. Of the same sugar?
A. Of the same sugar.
Q. Have vou made any tests of raw sugar in the same way?
A. My assistant, Doctor Wolfbauer has.
Se EAT RIEU nh ale 8 NR PHD
OM Ea DERE OM ATS
»
FONE aettnte BRERA REP NS feo orah tap
<
pee
MEIN A Lt ROSA AY
40 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
By Mr. Gipson:
Q. Mr. Sherer, have vou any interest in the result of this contro-
versy involving the test of these sugars now before the board?
A. Tam employed by the American Sugar Refining Co. to look
after their interests in the matter.
Q. Is that as near as you can answer that question ?
Mr. Tineie: If your honor, please, | don’t know that that is ma-
terial what this witness’ interests may be.
(Mr. Gipson :)
Q. Is that all the interest you have in them?
A. In what cases do you allude to?
QQ. All these cases.
a7 A. No, sit; Tam employed by importers to look after their
interests,
Q. Does the result of this decision in this case affect the amount
of compensation that you will get in these casos?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. In other words, you have a contingent fee, do you, which is
concerned in these cases?
A. I have.
Q. Dependent upon the amount that will be recovered by the
importers ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Doctor, do you know whether or not the tests made by the so-
called trade chemists and those made by the official Government
chemists—do these tests that are made by the trade chemists, are
they higher than those made by Government chemists ?
A. Sometimes they are, ves.
Q. Do you know about what the percentage is?
A. No, sir,
Q. There are a great many cases in which they are substantially
the same, would they not be?
A. Very few.
Q. Now, vou spoke of these regulations having been in force since
March 5, 1883, or up to the time of the adoption of these new regu-
lations——-?
A. Yes.
Q. Well, dont vou know that under the regulations in foree in
1883, and which vou say they followed, that there was a difference
that prevailed at Boston and Philadelphia and New York between
the tests?
A. No, sir; T never heard that there was any difference really.
Q. Was it not a fact that different results were obtained in Boston
than in New York?
A. There was a difference between the chemists in Boston and
New York: T understood there was at least.
Q. You were aware that there was?
A. T had nothing to do with it.
Q. Were you in the Government service at that time?
PR RIES
ora
<n Wet Rete a ac oct SOL ony
NEW YORK YS. THE UNITED STATES. 41
A. T was not testing sugar,
Q). Is it a fact, was there a difference between the tests made at
New York and those made in Boston?
A. It was claimed there was a difference. 1 have very little
recollection of that.
Q. You spoke of making a test here of sugar that was delivered
to vou by Doctor Weichmann—by the Government method—you
spoke of that didn’t you on-——?
A. Dr. Wolfbauer, he is my assistant with me in the laboratory.
Q. Is he here?
A. Yes, sir.
5S Q. Did you make any allowance in that examination by
the Government method for temperature?
A. 1 followed the Government method exactly.
Q. Did you make any allowance for temperature in making that
test?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How much did you allow for change in temperature?
A. IT allowed—took the table as prescribed in the table of sugar
values,
Q. Kindly tell me what allowance you made?
A. T consulted their table of sugar values and followed their
directions: that depended on the temperature at which the tests were
made.
Q. At what temperature did you make the tests?
A. In varying temperatures.
Q). From what temperature to what temperature?
A. From about 22 to 35, 1 think.
Q. You made the allowance for temperature?
A. Prescribed by the table of sugar values.
Q. Did vou do it personally?
A. I did it personally.
Q. What quartz plate did you use?
A. A quartz plate graduated by the United States Coast and Geo-
detic Survey.
Q. What flask?
A. A flask graduated by the same body.
Q. How do you know?
A. T sent my quartz plate to them to be graduated—to be stand-
ardized, It was standardized by them and found to be correct.
(). How about the flask?
A. T also sent a flask, which was graduated by them
Q. And returned to you? Tow long before had this been done?
A, Within two or three months. T would like to say that this
flask—two flasks were sent from Boston, The quartz plate T sent
myself,
Q. Do you know who sent them from Boston?
A. T do not reeall. Tt was the chemist in Boston.
Q. Can you give his name?
A. T cannot give his name; he was employed by the American
Sugar Refining Company in Boston.
Brey,
42 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO, OF
Q. What value did they assign? Was it on the Mohr flask or
the cubic centimetre?
A. You mean the true cubic centimetre. They gave me_ the
value—they found my value to be correct, within 100th of a degree
at the temperature of the table which they preseribed, but at 17.5.
It was correct. They found my quartz plate to be correct. In other
words I don’t remember the——
Q. Was it correct—on what basis, on the true cubic centimetre or
on the Mohr basis?
a9 A. T would like to read the letter T received from the Coast
and Geodetic Survey office.
Letter referred to read by witness and offered in evidence by him.
Q. You offer that in evidence?
A. T will also give the letter that T received in regard to the flasks
from them if you wish. Two flasks were sent. Number one was
found to be correct at 100.07 and the number two found to be 100,06
at 17.05 degrees.
Q. Did they standardize those two flasks according to the Mohr
or cubie centimetre?
A. What they call the true cubic or absolute,
The letters referred to by witness are marked in evidence Exhibit
C, 384769—F. December 15, 1898.
Q. Do you recognize the U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey as the
highest authority in the United States on weights and measures?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did vou use the same method, Mr, Sherer, in testing sugars
that all the other chemists use?
A. Yes, sir.
rs Have you been in other laboratories to any extent?
. Yes, sir; considerable.
“ Do they all use the same?
A. They have informed me that they do. 1 /have corresponded
with every sugar chemist in the United States that T know of.
Q. Are you the chemist for any concern that buys or sells or deals
in sugar?
A. Lam.
4 What concern?
What they call a sellers’ chemist. 1 test for sellers only.
a Don’t you ordinarily then test higher than the buyer?
No, sir.
ny How do you know? Have you compared your tests that you
have made with the tests of the buyer?
A. 1 don’t compare my test with anybody’s test. T make them
as nearly accurate as T know how.
Q. Your tests are compared, are they not, with the tests of the
buyer?
A. Probably they are after they leave my hands.
Q. Are you cognizant of it?
A. No; may be accidental.
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES, 43
Q. Don’t you know as a matter of fact that the tests made on the
part of the buyer and on the part of the seller, as a usual thing
differ?
A. They very often differ,
Q. And in the same way?
A. No, net in the same way, differ both ways.
60 Q. I mean, the sellers are usually higher than the buyers?
A. That is the general impression. — It don’t always turn
a) ©
out so,
(). Is that a facet or not?
A. In the majority of cases they are.
Q. Both use the same methods”?
A. But the samples are not the same,
Q. Taken out of the sugar, aren't they?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Taken out of the sume package or bundle?
A. Yes, sir, presumably, yes.
Q. Then they arrive—the buyer and seller arrive at some come
promise between the iwo, don’t they?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. And that is the basis of the transaction or sale?
A. Yes,
Q. A polarization is not the test of sale. is it, or basis of sale?
A. Not always,
Q. They buy and sell on & mean. don’t they, between the two?
Yes, sir.
Q. You use the instrument just the same way in the laboratory
that ix directed by the manufacturer of the instrument?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Make no allowance for temperature?
A. No, sir.
Q. What is the average femperature, Doctor, of your laboratory ?
A. T should think it was about 22 at the present time, sometimes
higher,
Q. What would that be Fahrenheit?
A. About 75, 1 think. It is a matter of caleulation. We use
centigrade,
Q. Your temperature in your office would average about 75 de-
grees?
A. Yes, T think so at present.
Q. What in summer?
A. It runs up to 90,
Q. Now, about what average for the vear?
A. T don’t know on the average. We don’t regard the tempera-
Q. What temperature, Doctor, is your instrument graduated for?
A. Seventeen and a half,
Q. Do vou know why that temperature was chosen instead of
any other?
A. Because the instrument was graduated at that. Beeanse that
> . Dea eee ee ee ee ee ee ne 9 ~
ae Oe eNO NR EE EAE LB TEIN TEER RED lay i MS RS ty ,
SEMEL OTA CR
>
q
.
4
:
%
t
‘
E
SEW CRANE AM ERE NN Cl IEE AN TRIE IN te GREG LE LINE RIE ALARA ALI BLAINE MEL SUS A OE NOAA NN OSA TI
44 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
was the temperature selected. Because the temperature of four de-
grees was impracticable in ordinary work.
Q. Why eed it be graduated for any particular temperature?
A. Well, that was found necessary by the makers of the instru-
ment, TF leave that to science to explain, as Tam not a scien-
61 tist.
Q. You cannot assign any other reason than that?
A. 1 understand the reason without being able to assign it,
Q. You are familiar, are vou not, with the fact that the Govern-
ment tested sugars under what was known as the bounty act?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You are familiar with the method which has been in practice
at that time?
A. You don't mean the method adopted at present?
Q. During that tinme-—ISS83—the methed was the same as what
you now call the commercial method?
A. 1 understand so, 1 believe so.
Q. Are you familiar with the method of testing sugars in the De-
partment of Agriculture of this Government?
A. I am not,
Q. Now, Doctor, isn’t it a fact that if this matter of allowance for
temperature was left out of consideration in these sugar tests, there
would probably be no difference between the method adopted by
the Government and the results of that which ix obtained by what
you call the commercial method?
A. That is to say, if the Government didn't add for the difference
in temperature, ves, LT still think there would be a difference in
which the Government method would give higher tests,
Q. That would practically be infinitesimal, would it not?
A. No, sir: it would be quite——
Q. What difference would it make in sugar testing 99.98 by the
Government method?
A. Well, it would depend on how much clarifying ageney they
used in it,
Q). Ordinarily as you have examined——
A. There probably in that case would not be required any clar-
ifying agent to polarize it,
Q. There are cases in whieh if the temperature was left out of
consideration, that the method adopted by the trade and the de-
partment—by the Government, would be the same?
A. I say, in the pure, refined sugar like that, if the question of
temperature was left out the tests would probably be nearer.
Recess taken till 2 o'clock,
Decempen 15, 1898, v. M.
Hearing resumed.
Present: Same as before.
Joseru: A, Deauver, called as a witness for the protestants, hav-
ing been duly sworn, testilied as follows:
0 be “ee wot
ee ee
-
: NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 4h
By Mr. Tixoe:
Q. What is your profession?
A. Tam a chemist,
4 ). OF how long expericnce?
A. L graduated from the Sehool of Mines, Columbia uni-
versity, in T8900, and since then | have been employed in general
analytical laboratories in New York city, Also as private assistant to
Prof, Charles FL Chandler of Columbia university for one year, and
for the last three vears | have been assistant chemist in the New York
city food and health deparywsent laboratory,
Q. During your experience have you had oceasion to study
especially sugar chemistry?
A. T have, and took ap sugar chemistry as a study in college, and
also studied polarized light after graduation. L conducted my work
on sugar while assistant to Prof. Chandler and sinee for the food
and health deparGoent T have had sugar analysis to do as part of
my routine work in the laboratory.
(). Have you made any recent experiments or investigations
touching the methods of testing sugar by the polarisecope under the
regulations of the Treasury Department as they existed prior to
October 27, 1897, and the regulations made after that date?
A. 1 did not study the regulations as they were prior to 1897, I
compared the regulations which were adopted, 1 believe, in: 1897—
the new regulations—-compared them with the method in use by all
chemists in general.
Q. You are acquainted with ihe general method as used by
chemists in aaeaal for testing sugar, in New York?
A. T am.
Q. Do you know whether that method has been closely followed
by all chemists?
A. That ie the method accepted by all authorities that T know of,
By Judge Somenvin.e:
Q. Do you know whether or pot that method which prevailed
hefore IS97 was the one used as a basis of trade?
A. By the Government, do you mean? No T don't. T under-
stood you to say whether | know what the method was used by the
Government chemists prior to TS97,
By Mr. Tincie:
P ). You don’t know?
A. LT wish to state that T don’t know what method was used from
personal knowledge,
By Judge SoMERVILLE:
Q. Do vou know whether there was any test which was adopted
as the basis of sales of sugar in the trade prior to 1897?
A. T know there was such a method.
By Mr. Tineie:
Q. Will you look at that for a moment (Exhibit B handed to
WBA ese At 2 IIOEI A INE GLP TE LD RE LN AAS NA DE A ta Neb aS REPEL OB PBN cg hon NO BAR ie he Nan a ie Nein
46
MIE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
witness). Will you state whether that is the method pursued
is by you in making tests, which you understand to be the
method used in the trade?
A. Tt is.
Q. Have you made tests of sugar recently? State whether you
have made any recent investigations and tests of sugar by that
method and the method pointed out in the regulations of 1897?
A. T have made some investigations under that direction very
recently,
Q). Please state what they were?
A. To made a number of examinations
Mr. Ginsen: One moment——
(Wrerness:)—of sugar by both methods and compared the two,
By Judge SomeRVILLE:
Q. How many tests have you made under both methods, by way
of comparison?
A. T made eight separate tests and determinations,
By Mr. Tinane:
Q. Please state what the result of those examinations and. tests
were?
A. The material T used was so-called chemically pure sugar—
which I tested to discover that it was chemically pare—by dissolving
the normal weight, 26.048 grams of sugar to the mark of 100 cubie
centimetres, and placed that in the polariscope also 17.5 C. and
found that that polarized 100, 1 took that sume sugar and made
up my solutions and polarized it at varying temperatures, also mak-
ing up my solutions and reading at the same temperature and | found
the result run invariably above 100, varving from 2,10 to 5/10
according to the temperature
By Judge SomenviLie:
Q. You mean under the Government method now?
A. Under the Treasury method; while under the ordinary method,
the results run practically at 100, within one-tenth of 100, ae close
us any determination could be made,
By Mr. TInGLe:
Q. What flasks did vou use in making your tests under the stand
ard or commercial method?
A. T used the true cubic centimetre flask in all cases,
Q. In both cases?
A. Yes.
Q. You didn’t use the Mohr at all?
A. I didn’t use the Mohr flask at all.
Q. How did you succeed in getting the polarization of 100 since
the flasks are so different?
A. By knowing——
64 Objected to.
Question read.
+ erew of hem son * rT
ee eee) ~
5 NEW YORK Vs. THE UNITED STATES.
4?
Q. Is the Mohr flask different from the true cubic flask?
A. The volume of the Mohr is different by a different fixed
quantity,
Q). How did you get 100 in using the true thask ?
A. By knowing the difference between the Mohr thek [can make
the correction,
Q. Then you did make the correction, so practically there was ne
difference?
A. There was no difference in the aciual strength of the solution
Whether T used the Mohr thiask or the true cubie centimetre tlask.
Whenever the temperature was above 17.5 TL found that the polur-
izations by the ‘Treasury regulations run above LOO on every polar-
ization. Ai average of all my tests, (he average temperature would
be 23 degrees C,
Q. When vou polurize sugar at the same temperature at which
the solution ix prepared, does the temperature make any difference
as to the result’
A. When the solution is made up at the temperature at which it
is polarized, the tepperature makes no difference, none whatever,
Which is appreciable on the ordinary polariscope,
Q. Tn a ease of that kind where the temperature is made up, —or
the solution is made up at the same temperature at whieh it is
polarized, and the Treasury regulations are followed out strietly, vou
would add for the difference in temperature?
A. If LT followed the regulations.
Q. Well, whenever the temperature were above 17.57
A. T would add the temperature factor,
Q. Then if there is no difference in temperature, has ne effect in
other words, you would get an erroneous result?
A. T would,
Q. Tlow much?
A. That would depend upon the temperature. The result would
he erroneous by just the amount of the correction which is three
degrees.
By Judge Somervitne:
Q). What portion of a degree in the mathematical correetion for
lemperature ?
A. Tt would vary, about three-lhundredths of a degree above 17.5,
By Mr, Tinoir:
Q. At what temperature did you make these experiments?
A. From 17.5—varying temperatures, up to 33 C,
Q. How much did you add on the 33 for correction of tempera-
ture?
65 A. 1 first corrected for the use of the true centigrade flask,
then T added the difference between 17.5 and 38, multiplied
by three-hundredths. I have not the exact correction here.
By Mr. Ginson:
Q. How old are you, Mr, Deghuee?
——
Pim tee - roars.
48 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
A. Twenty-eight.
Q. Where did you get the Government quartz plate that you
used?
A. 1 used two quartz plates, one standardized by the Govern-
ment, and one that was in use in the laboratory in the American
Sugar Refining Co,
Q. Where did vou get the one furnished by the Government?
A. From Mr. Sherer.
Q. How do vou know it had been standardized?
A. By comparing it with the sugar polarization at 17.5 which
read 100, at the same time I took the reading of the quartz plate
which corresponded to it.
ri Did vou consider that sulliciont identification ?
I do.
n Where did you get the flask?
The tlask had been standardized by the U.S. Government.
a Where did you get the flask?
It was handed to me by Doctor Wolfbauer.
a How did you identify it?
I saw the letter which accompanied it which stated that this
fli = had been tested by the Government, the same number was on
the letter which was on the tlask.
Q. Do vou know of your personal knowledge that the letter re-
ferred to that identical flask ?
A. I do not.
Q. Do vou understand the Government method of testing sugar?
A. 1 think I do, ves.
Q. Will vou please state it brietly?
A. As set down in the regulations, as IT understand the Govern-
ment method, 26.048 grammes of sugar are weighed out in air, dis-
solved in water, and put into a flask whieh contains—whole volume
is 100.06 true cubie centimetres. After getting the sugar into solu-
tion, a clarifving agent in the form of lead acetate and alumina
cream are used and the sugar made up to a mark on the glass bulb
and placed in the polariscope and read at the same time the tem-
perature is noted a ee h the regulations specify: the reading is taken
of this temperature and noted, then the re ding of the quartz plate
is taken, then the polariscope reading of this quartz plate is taken
and compared with the table of sugar values, the table giving, [
believe, the sugar value of the quartz plate, and a correction is noted
on the reading of the sugar solution which corresponds to this differ-
ence between the reading of this standard quartz plate and
66 the sugar solution. After this factor of correction has been
noted the result is taken as the polariscopic test or polari-
ation of the solution.
Q. Do you add or subtract that correction?
A. If the quartz plate reads higher than the factor given in the
table of sugar values, that would mean that the instrument, accord-
ing to the Government, was reading too high at that temperature
and the factor would be subtracted: if the reverse were true, the
factor would be added.
% ‘ ED ce BURR ARE DP Fiat TP SME A Tint SBE A ry tes IETS TOE Deh at a ith a
aa RANI Ae aPC HN oe
SP LAT
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 49
Q. Does the temperature have any influence upon the polariza- :
tion of a quartz plate? ;
A. It does. P
Q. In what way? :
A. The temperature of a quartz plate varies if. the temperature 3
rises, the reading, that is the rotatory order of the quartz plate will 4
increase as the temperature rises, ;
Q. How is the polarization of the sugar solution measured in the :
polariscope in common use? ;
A. In the Government regulations do you mean by the corrected ;
regulations? ;
Q. In the polariscope in common use—how is the rotation read?
A. By reading the seale and taking that as the reading, :
Q). What has the scale got to do with it? :
A. What readings, plate do you mean?
Q. No, T mean the part of the particular instrument that measures
the rotation?
A. What it is composed of?
Q. Yes. .
A. Composed of quartz wedges,
Q. Then, if the quartz is graduated at 17.5 and the reading made
at 25, it would not have the same value?
A. Not exactly, but the difference is so slight it could not be de-
tected,
Q. There is a difference?
A. There is.
Q. How much is it?
A. It amounts to about eleven or twelve one-thousandths of a de-
gree in each degree in temperature.
Q. Then the quartz wedge does not have the same value in dif-
ferent temperatures?
A. Not exactly, no.
Q. It would take less thickness at a higher temperature than low
temperature ?
A. Yes,
Q. And the sugar solution would read lower at a higher tempera-
ture?
A. If the instrument is delicate enough to show that.
Q. Do you use a delicate instrument?
G7 A. T use the instrument that is commonly used in sugar
) laboratories.
Q. Would that be delicate enough to indicate this difference?
A. T do not think so,
Q. Does the sugar solution polarized at different temperatures
give the same reading?
A. Tf made up at the true bulk it does.
Q. Did yours when made up at 17.5 read at that same as when
they were made up at 25 and read at 25?
A. Yes, they were.
Q. T understood you to say that there was a difference in tempera-
4—281
sen mee. = Son le atch ie NR RN ot NT RRND Tae es I mT G
60 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
tures for each degree of temperature—a difference of about three-
hundredths of a degree?
A. About that.
Q. That is from your experience?
A. From my experience.
By Mr. TINGLE:
Q. That difference which you have just spoke. of, does it appear
when you make up the solution at the same temperature in which
you polarize?
A. It does not appear in the correct reading. It appears in the
corrected polarization according to the Government regulations, not
in the true reading of the sugar solution.
Q. Do you regard that as an error in the polarization or not?
A. An error in the——
Q. As erroneous, I mean?
A. The introduction of that factor, 1 do.
Epwarp Worrnaver, called as a witness for the protestants,
having been duly sworn, testified as follows:
By Mr. Tixcie:
Q. What is your profession?
A. A chemist and mechanical engineer.
Q. What experience have you had in chemistry?
A. I have had four years’ experience in the sugar business in
France, and six years in this country.
Q. During your experience in beth countries have you become
acquainted with what is) known as the standard or commercial
method of testing sugar?
A. T believe T have become acquainted with the methods in those
countries.
Q. Do the regulations of 1894 and 1883 correspond with what you
understand to be the commercial test—are they in accordance with
the commercial method of testing sugar?
A. They are not in accordance with the——
68 By Judge SoMERVILLE:
Q. You have examined the Government regulations for testing
sugar of 1883 and 1894?
A. T have not; those for bounty and those for 1897,
By Mr. TinGie:
Q. State what you understand to be the method of examination
under the standard regulations used in commerce—the standard
method?
A. The standard method in one case the Schmidt & Haensch in-
strument is used and the case in which the French method is used.
The Sebmidt & Haensch instrument is based on the Ventzke seale
which is vased on the rotatory action of the sugar made by weighing
26,018 grammes with brass weight= in the air, and dissolving the
Te pote ee a Ee ea 3 . wy “ soe - ca aiid a i a
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 51
sugar in a flask that contains 100 Mohr cubie centimetres, clarify-
ing the sugar solution, if necessary with a suflicient amount of clari-
fying agent, filling up to the mark, and polarizing the solution at the
sume temperature at which it was made up. The polarization is
made in a tube 200 millimeters in length. The reading of the scale
furnished by the Ventzke instrument will directly give the percent-
age of sugar contained in the sample. That is the commercial
method,
Q. How does that method differ from the method prescribed by
the Treasury regulations?
A. It differs in two ways from the method described. First, the
Government requires the use of a flask which does not contain 100
Mohr cubie centimetres, but 100 absolute cubie centimetres, but other-
wise the operations are practically the same as this commercial until
the end, when the readings are taken of the sugar solution. But a
quartz plate is inserted in the instrument, which quartz plate has
been furnished by the Government, with a table which psi the
different values or changes of the quartz plate according to the tem-
peratures. .\fter the reading has been taken this quartz plate is
inserted in the instrument and read, and the thermometer is read
which is suspended in the instrument, and the reading, according to
the value of the quartz plate for change in temperature, is corrected.
These are the two essential differences in the two methods—CGovern-
ment and commercial method. The first difference is, the true flask
is changed to an absolute flask, and is corrected for in the sugar table
values, and the first correction is introduced for the temperature.
That is at least the explanation of the Government method for the
ascertainment of the sugar values and the use of the quartz plate.
Q. In testing sugar in both cases, you tested that solution at the
same temperature at which it is made up?
A. In both eases.
Q. In that ease, what do vou say to this statement of correcting
for temperature?
69 a. The experiments which | have made—there is no neces-
sity for correcting for temperature. 1 find that correction for
temperature in such eases for any difference of temperature above
17.5 is not called for, it is unnecessary as the sugar will not differ
when polarized at the same temperature at which it is made up, in the
ordinary limits, | mean, ranging from 12 C. up to about 40 C.
Q. Then there is no error to be corrected on account of tempera-
ture?
A. There is none.
Q. Are the same weights used in both instruments, same normal
weights?
A. The same normal weight is used: but the Government flasks
are graduated to contain 100.06 true cubie centimetres instead of 100.
Q. Did you make some experiments with chemically pure sugar—
some tests by both methods?
A. Yes, by both methods,
Q. What was the result of those tests?
A. The result was that the polariscopic readings of the commercial
methods, and the Government method, there was a difference, the
Government method being between three and four tenths higher.
Q. Did you find that this chemically pure sugar was above 100?
_— ERR yr.s)~ a oa ese
aS
Ay Wilk AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
A. The chemically pure sugar tested by scientific tests—and it
was 99.98—I experimented to convince myself that it was free from
raffinose
Q. What was the test found by correction for temperature?
A. The test found was 100.3 about, might have been a few one
hundredths more, according to the temperature in which it| was
tested.
Q. What was the minimum?
A. The minimum was 100.2.
Q. The maximum?
A. About 1004.
By Mr. Gipson:
Q. Where did you get your quartz plate that you tested with?
A. The quartz plate was returned by the Government to Mr.
Sherer, IT am a witness that it is the same quartz plate because I
opened the box when it was returned.
Q. Did you use that plate?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. In your experiments?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That the same plate Mr. Sherer has testified about?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And the same flasks?
A. Yes, sir.
70 By General Appraiser WILKINSON :
Q. You are employed in Doctor Sherer’s oflice, are you not?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Gipson:
Q. Does the temperature have any influence on the polarization
of a quartz plate?
A. The temperature has no influence on the polarization, if the
quartz plate and the instrument are exposed to the same temperature.
Q. You don’t agree with the other two witnesses—with Dr. Weich-
mann and Doctor Deghuee? You heard their testimony on that
point?
A. Partially, no don’t fully recollect.
Q. If they testified that the temperature does influence the polari-
zation of a quartz plate, vou don’t agree if they so testified?
A. It all depends on what the circumstances are; if you take the
polariscopie instrument at the normal temperature, if you keep it at
a certain temperature then insert the quartz plate at a varying tem-
perature, then you will get various readings; if the instrument is
at the same temperature, you get the same reading all the time.
Q. Can you state whether the temperature does not influence the
quartz plate?
A. If the instrument is at the same temperature, then
Q. No, no, no, as it is ordinarily used.
A. Tf the quartz plate has got another temperature from the in-
strument—certainly the temperature has got an influence on the
quartz plate to change its reading, it will not read the same.
AA EAM al BIR TE ING ES ARES A a Rett —— ee
&
Yate
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 53 é
Q. How much?
‘ . : rd +A
A. So far as Tam able to observe it was a difference—temper- .
ature of about 12 degrees, it was 1/10. “
Q. Does an inerease of temperature increase the degrees—increase %
the polarization ?
A. Increasing the temperature increases the polariscopic power of
the quartz plate. i
Q. How is the polarization of a sugar solution measured in the E
ordinary instrument in use? F
A. It is measured by means of a system of quartz wedges.
Q. But the temperature varies and those wedges showing the ro-
tatory power of the sugar vary in different temperatures so that the
reading of the solution would vary, would it not?
A. Tf the solution was of a different temperature, ves.
Q. If you measured a piece of cloth with a vard stick and in- &
creased it in length by a higher temperature, it would make a longer §
piece of cloth? 5
A. If the cloth were increased to the same amount then you would 2
get the correct measurement. 5
Q. It would be longer, would it? *
71 A. If the cloth inereased the same amount in itself.
Q. Does the sugar solution vary in its rotations with the
temperature?
A. To my knowledge the variation is extremely slight so far as it
concerns the specific rotatory of the sugar solution.
Q. Are you acquainted with a work by the Coast and Geodetic
Survey on that point?
A. No.
Q. Are vou familiar with a work by Prof. Andrews of the In-
stitute of Technology on that point?
A. Heard about it.
Q. Never read it or studied it?
A. No.
Q. Did you read Dr. Wilev’s paper or an abstract of it on that
point which was read before the convention at Vienna?
A. Yes, sir, T read it.
Q. What does he state in regard to that?
A. As far as Tecan recollect he states that the specific rotatory power
of sugar does not change to any noticeable extent with temperature.
Q. You never read the regulations of the Government of 1883
on sugar testing?
A. No, IT don’t think so.
Q. Those of 1897 are the only ones you are familiar with?
A. And those of the bounty law, I saw those too.
Q. Those too are practically the same are they not?
A. Yes,
Q. You know what the standing is of the U.S. Coast and Geodetie
Survey—what its standing is among scientific men as to its being an
authority on weights and measures?
A. T am not informed about it.
Tne in ON Seal i PAD Tae tar aC AS Se
54 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
Q. Do you know it is the official organ established by Congress
for this country on weights and measures?
(No answer.)
Q. Are you a partner of Mr. Sherer’s?
A. No, I am in Mr. Scherer’s oftice.
Epwarp Suerer, called as a witness for the protestants, having
been duly sworn, testified as follows:
By Mr. TINGLE:
Q. State your profession, Doctor.
\. Sugar chemist.
2. Of how many years’ experience?
A. Since 1872.
2. State how you have been employed.
\. IT was in the Government service from ISSO until very re-
cently—first of November this year—and have been em-
72 ployed during that time specifically in charge of the polariza-
tion of sugar, connected with the appraisers’ office.
Q. Are you familiar with what is known as the standard or com-
mercial method of testing sugar, used generally in the trade?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was that method used by the Government in its laboratory?
A. That was substantially the one adopted by the Government
in 1880.
Q. Used from that time continuously ?
A. Used continuously, up to the recent regulations of TS97.
Q. Did you have occasion while you were in the laboratory, under
the new regulations, to make polariscopic tests of any samples of
refined sugar?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. About what time were those tests made?
A. They were mace at all times when samples of refined sugar
were received in the laboratory, not daily, almost daily.
Q. Since the new regulations?
A. In the course of the current work, during the new regulations,
as well as under the old, yes, sir.
Q. Did you make those tests strietly in accordance with the regu-
lations?
A. I did.
Q. What was the actual result yielded by those tests of refine"
sugar?
A. In many cases the polarizations obtained by the Government
method was somewhat over 100 per cent.; in very few cases it was
under 100. It was, as a rule, very close to 100, sometimes more
than 100.
Q. What is the ordinary test of foreign refined sugars?
A. The test of foreign refined sugars, such as we received in the
laboratory, prior to the use of the existing regulations, was about
99.8 per cent.: we sometimes got a sugar 99.91 but rarely.
Q. What were the tests under the new regulations?
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 55
A. Almost never under 100, sometimes more,
Q. When you spoke of 99.8, did you mean that was the maximum
or minimum or average?
A. I should not eall it an average. I should say the average
would be 99.7; the maximum would be 99.9 [ should say.
Q. How high did you ever find refined sugar to test under the
new regulations?
A. 100.4.
Q. Were those tests recorded?
A. The test reported was invariably “as over 100 per cent.”’—
when there was a higher reading, the sugar was found as 100,
(). Why was that?
A. It being manifestly absurd to. report sugar as being over 100
per cent., it was not done.
73 Q. Can you give any reason why those extraordinary tests
were obtained?
A. 1 judge it was due to errors attendant upon the system followed
in the new regulations, corrections for temperatures and the use of
the true in place.of the Mohr flask, which was intended to be used
with the instrument.
Q. Do you know what the temperature ef the laboratory was dur-
ing the time you were there after the new regulations went into
effect?
A. From about the first of June our record was kept out of the
temperature at which the polarizations were made. Prior to that
time no record was kept. When the new regulations were promul-
gated the temperature of the laboratory was observed but no record
of it was kept until about the first of June, T should say, or possibly
a little earlier—June, 1898, T mean, the present year, after the new
regulations of 1897 of the present year, along the middle of May,
possibly, we began to keep a record of the temperature in our polar-
izations.
Q. Previous to that, what was it?
A. From the time we received the polariscopes and standard flask
and quartz plates from the Coast and Geodetic Survey, the average
temperature of the leboratory was about 22 degrees C.; perhaps the
extreme 24 and the minimum 20; that was about the average up to
the time that the record was kept.
Q. What was the average after you begun to take the record?
A. During the summer the temperature rose at times. The highest
record, 1 think was 33, or possibly 34, but that was exceptional.
The temperature ranged on an average of about 27 for the hot
months. The records of the laboratory will show how that is.
Q. In your work of testing sugars did you carry out the new
regulations strictly?
A. Tn all essential particulars, T did.
Q. In what respect, if any, did you differ?
A. We found that the use of alumina cream was entirely unneces-
sary and uncalled for; we did not use it. We did not cover the
walls or filtrations with watch glasses. We found that to be im-
practicable in view of the large number of samples handled daily
56 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
and the interference with the work which it would cause. With
the exception of those two particulars we carried out the regulations
strictly.
By Mr. Gipson:
Q. Are you familiar with the polarizations of sugar under the
act of 1883?
A. I an, sir.
Q. Were you in the Government service during that time?
A. 1 was in the service when they were adopted and largely
framed them myself, so far as they concerned the polarization of
sugars.
74 Q. Did you conduct the sugar work in the polarizations at
this port under those regulations?
A. I did.
Q. Didn't the comparisons between tests made here at this port
under those regulations, and at Boston, show a difference ?
A. At one time they did.
Q. And at Philadelphia?
A. As compared with New York the difference was slight. My
impression is there was practically an agreement between the ports of
Philadelphia and New York.
Q. There was a difference between the te-ts at Philadelphia, Bos-
ton and at New York?
A. There wis between the port of New York and the port of Bos-
ton and the port of Philadelphia the ports of Boston and Philadelphia
were not in accord. The difference between Philadelphia and New
York was less than the difference between Boston and New York;
but the three ports were not in accord during a period of one or two
years, | think along about 1885.
By Judge SoMERVILLE:
Q. Do you know what the difference was caused by ?
A. 1 think T do, ves, sir; due to the error of the chemist in Bos-
ton in valuing his quartz plate, assuming that its mark which was
99.1—2 meant 99 and one-half, or 99.5; whereas, when that plate
was examined, it was found to have a value not exceeding 99.10,
the meaning of 99.1-—2 being 99.2, that was mainly the cause of the
difference.
By Mr. Gipson :
Q. Was there not a difference between the same samples tested
here and those tested ai Boston?
A. There was, yes.
Q. That was as much as 6/10 per cent.?
A. My recollection is that the difference was from four to five
tenths; it may have reached 6/10; the average difference yas not
more than 4/10.
Q. Didn't that difference continue for more than a year?
A. T should judge it was, about a vear.
Q. The quartz plate was changed at Boston?
A. A different plate was used,
| ee octet ete haem re an at a RINGS SEAT RAEN IME RATE LIN ESA ORE EARL MET a i DIME MNP NORE DIORA TOO
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 57
Q. Didn’t that difference continue after that quartz plate was
taken away?
A. Twas out of the Government service about 18 months and what
happened then [have no knowledge in regard to the matter. When
I returned to the Government service T do not recall that there was
any material difference, until perhaps the year—in the year 1890,
there was an investigation which developed a difference be-
70 tween the port of New York and Boston. [think it) was
thoroughly investigated at the time.
Q. What was the difference at that time to which you have just
referred between New York and Boston?
PROSE LEMS
Mr. Tincie: T wish to ask your honor, if this is not all imia-
terial?
Q. Did not these differences exist in 1S9O and LSOL?
A. In 1890, they did. May I be permitted——
Q. That was after the removal of the plate, was it not?
A. That was after the removal of the plate.
Q. What was the trouble then?
A. They were attributable to the mistake on the part of the Bos-
ton experts in using the true cubic instead of the Mohr flask; the
same cause which produces the difference at present between the old
and the new regulations.
Q. Where did they get the flask?
A. Doctor Leary standar-ized his flask himself and adopted the
true cubie centimetre, The report of Mr. Tittaann will explain these
differences,
Q. The true cubic centimetre flask could be used under those
regulations?
A. Not properly.
Q. Not properly; was there anything in the reeulations to pre-
vent it?
A. The regulations did not prescribe the true flask or the Mohr
flask. They prescribed the making up of the solution to 100 cubie
centimetres, but the instrument had been standardized to the Mohr,
and it was understood that it was the flask to be used in testing sugars
at that time.
Q. They followed the regulations—Doctor Leary ?
A. I don’t think he did.
Q. Strike that out. Then you noticed that there was a different
polarization of the same sugar at different temperatures?
A. T cannot say that T have under the proper conditions. ‘These
polarizations have been made at the same temperature at which the
solution is prepared. In that case T have observed no difference in
the result at varving temperatures.
Q. Does the temperature have any difference upon the polariza-
tion of a quartz plate?
A. Undoubtedly; I should say it would have some difference upon
the polarization of a quartz plate, or the value that it would have.
Q. In what direction, Mr. Sherer?
A. My impression is that the polarization would be some higher
by the inerease of temperature.
Q. Ifow is the polarization measured in the ordinary instrument?
ait Oa UY “bait ane oe ae ee
58 TITE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF "
A. I don’t understand the question,
_— read,
76 By the reading obtained when the sugar solution ts
rk in the instrument. Lf you will permit me to explain
on this matter of the change in the value of the quartz plate or
reason of the change of the temperature, | should like to say that I
consider that fully compensated in the quartz plate in the instru-
ment. The instrument has compensating quartz wedges, right and
left hand, and while it is true Chat the value may change “by any
change of temperature, the change would be compensated, under the
circumstances.
Q. There is no quartz plate in the instrument—in the sugar
solution ?
A. The instrument is constructed with quartz plates, right and
left hand, exeept for the purpose of standardizing your instrument,
it is read through the quartz plate,
Q. Tlow do you measure the rotation of the sugar solution ?
A. By the degrees recorded on the seale, in looking through the
solution at the glass, when we have obtained the equalization of
colors,
Q. What do you move, or what— when you move the milled head
soerew—that ineres-es or diminishes the thickness of the wedges?
A. When there is nothing tn the instrament and the quartz
wedges which are in front, one right and the other left, turning the
milled head, in effect is to get the neutral tint in the sugar solu.
tion, When the equalization is adjusted and with two very. dis-
tinctive shadows, it becomes necessary to diminish the thickness of
those wedges in front in order to reach the neutralized field again.
With that point reached our seale will show what the polarization
of that sugar solution is. One hundred should be the value ob-
served for pure refined sugar,
Q. Then vou measure that solution by quartz wedges, do you?
A. Well, quartz wedges are essential to the construction of the in-
strument,
Q. Don’t vou measure the rotation by quartz wedges”?
A. Yes, T should say vou did.
Q. Don't that wedge vary in rotation in’ different temperatures?
A. We measure by two quartz wedges——
Q. That is not the question, Read the question, will you please
(question read)?
A. An answer ves or no would convey a wrong impression; there
are two quartz wedges, one right hand and the other left, and a
change of temperature would be conmpensated for so that a change
in temperature does not effect the reading.
Q. Do you move both wedges?
\. Practically we move one wedge; the two wedges in the front
of the instrument are both of the same variety of quartz; but in the
rear of the instrument there are two which are not the same variety ;
one is righi and the other is left hand,
Q. Which do you move, the back or front wedges?
~
Ce a a ‘ pores
NEW YORK VS. THE UNITED STATES. 59
A. One slides over the other.
Q. You only move one wedge?
A. Moving one wedge increases or diminishes the thickness
of the two.
Q. If the temperature increased the rotation it would take a less
thickness, would it, to measure the solution or rotation?
A. I do not think I stated that the temperature increased the
rotation,
Q. Didn't you state that this temperature inereased the polariza-
tion? LT so understood you?
A. Ut diminishes the polarization of the sugar solution, [have
not observed the effect of the change of temperature on the quartz
plates. T have not made any experiment which would show whether
they changed. Tam speaking from general recollection as far as
they are concerned,
Q. Then you admit that with a decrease in temperature the polar:
ization of a sugar solution would be affected?
A. Not if it is made up and polarized at the same temperature.
Q. Tell us if,.in your opinion, the temperature increased the
polarization of the quartz plate?
A. T have made no experiments which would enable me to an-
ewer that question at all. T rather not trust to my memory. It
was an impression and T give it for what it is worth, As a matter
of fact 1 don’t know,
Q. Is it not so stated in all authorities on quartz plates?
A. At the present moment [am unable to say. T really do not
know.
Q. Have you read Doctor Wiley’: book? Isn't it so stated) in
that? Tlave vou read that?
A. T have not read Doctor Wilev's hook.
Q. Do vou know about the office of the U.S. Coast and Geodetic
Survey and weights and measures?
A. Yes.
Q. What is its standing among scientific men?
A. It is certainly the highest authority on the question of weights
and measures, | should say,
-—-
ad
Jousx THowarp Waixriaiur, called as a witness for the protes-
tants, having been duly sworn, testifies as follows:
By Mr. TIncie:
Q. What is vour profession, Doctor?
A. Tam a chemist.
Q. Have you been in the Government service?
A. T have about 15 vears, until the latter part of last April.
Q. Were you cognizant of the preparation of the regulations of
the Treasury Department of October 27, 1897—the new regulations
in regard to testing sugar?
T was.
78 Q. Were you called to Washington to consult in regard to
these regulations?
60 THE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING CO. OF
A. I was.
Q. Did you at that time call the attention of officials of the de-
partment to what you regarded as erroneous methods for testing
sugars, proposed by the regulations?
A. In general.
Mr. Ginson: One moment, | object to that.
Objection sustained,
Q. What do you regard as the——
By Judge SoMERVILLE:
Q. Are you familiar with the department regulations of 1583
to 1594
A. I am.
Q. On this subject?
By Mr. TInGie;
Q. And of 1597, the recent regulations?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You are familiar with the ditlerencee between the regulations
of 1894 and 1897, are you?
A. Lam.
Q. Have you ever made any tests under those?
A. I have made a great many tests under the regulations in force
prior to the present regulations,
Q. Did you make any under the present regulations?
A. I did.
Q. From your perusal of these new regulations what, in your
opinion, are the sources of error, or errors, in them?
Objected to; question withdrawn.
Q. Give us your opinion as an expert——are these regulations of
1897, are they defective?
A. I should say they were defective.
Q. In what respect?
A. Well, first, the Government regulations prescribe a method to
be pursued in making up the solution that is a different method
from the one upon which the graduation of this seale of the instru-
ment is based. Secondly, from the prescribing of the introduction
of a correction under conditions which the regulations themselves
take very good care to provide against; namely, the correction for
temperature. Those are the chief sources of error which were to
my mind and are quite apparent.
Q. When you spoke of against such error, you referred to what?
A. IT refer to the very part of the method in which the regula-
tions lav down a rule that all the operations in making up the test
which lead up to the final observations in the tube in the in-
79 strument itself. The regulations prescribe that the difference
of temperature shall be guarded against in the making up
of the solvtion under the same conditions of temperature, notwith-
standing, they further provide that a correction shall be made for
any temperature difference over 17.5 degrees C.
ware san thy ye pnelenee bE ge AL SUR! OUR ORRIN A NAD MC ATI NAS AT et Ne el AON ~
NEW YORK VS, THE UNITED STATES. 61
Q. In other words, a correction is made for an error that don’t
exist?
A. It so appears to my mind,
By Mr. Gipson:
Q. Now, Doctor, you have stated here, as 1 understand you to say
the temperature is Gaken all through in the operation or testing the
sugar abl one temperature?
A. 1 don’t recall?
Q. That the temperature is the same during the whole operation?
A. If the regulations are followed out as laid down.
Q. Isn't it a matter of fact that they prescribed that the instru-
ment is graduated on a test of 17.5”
A. 1 don’t understand your question, Mr. Gibson,
Q. It is graduated to that temperature by the makers?
A. Yes, that is quite correct.
Q). Isn't that a very much lower temperature than the temperature
of the room as it is connected in the appraiser's oflice in this build-
ing? :
A. At certain seasons it is.
Q). Is there any season of the year when it is as low as that?
A. In this building?
Q). Yes?
A. Tam not familiar with the present laboratory and the working
conditions. T have not been in the service since they occupied their
present quarters. My recollection is of the old laboratory,
Q. T understood you to say that the departure had been in the
use of a flask that is different than the one formerly used?
A. That is one of the changes.
Q. You think that ought not to be done?
A. | beg your pardon?
(). You think that should not have been done?
A. T ean see ne good reason. Tt introduces a serious error.
Q. Why do you admit the departure from standard temperature
and insist upon the standard flask?
A. Will you repeat the question?
Question read,
A. Why the standard temperature will have nothing to do with
it then your factor of temperature is eliminated.
Q. Why do they standardize at 17.5?
A. Simply as a convenient temperature at which the flask, the
wedge and the solution and the instrument itself are graduated
would be the same, They could use any other temperature, provided
the temperature was uniform throughout.
80 Q. Don’t those people—the makers recommend that all
these tests be made at or near that temperature—17.5?
A. Why, they do, it is a mere recommendation, however,
Q. Why do you suppose they do it?
A. T understand a recommendation of that kind would mean that
the operation should all be done at or in a room in which the tem-
perature is about 17.5. In this country it is sometimes higher.
62 {HE AMERICAN SUGAR REFINING Co. OF
By Mr. Tinate:
Q. It is all surmise.
A. 1 am asked to surmise.
By
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.