Appellants Brief — City of Dawson v. Columbia Avenue Saving Fund, Safe Deposit, Title & Trust Co.
Supreme Court brief1905
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(19,152.) :
IN THE :
Supreme Court of the United States.
Octroger TrERM, 1904.
No. 154.
THE CITY OF DAWSON, APPELLANT,
* v8.
THE COLUMBIA AVENUE SAVINGS FUND, SAFE
DEPOSIT, TITLE AND TRUST COMPANY.
BRIEF IN BEHALF OF APPELLANT.
SUMMARIZED NARRATIVE.
On June 11, 1886, the city of Dawson, in the State of
Georgia, submitted to its voters the question as to whether
the expense of waterworks should be incurred. The ordi-
nance and notice failed to specify the amount of debt
proposed, as required by law. More than two-thirds of the
voters cast their ballots in favor of the expense, and the
result was declared July 18, 1886. Thereupon, the city
officials made some attempts to secure a system of water-
works, but with no definite results.
4 bout four years later, the then city council entered into
the contract with R. L. Bennett which forms the basis of
thissuit. Neither in the negotiations leading thereto nor
in the contract was there any reference to the election as
8310—1
Pe oe eee
PBEM PME NS RG A OLA CR DR Oe set a
2
the authority thereof, or asan inducement thereto. This con-
tract was in the form of an ordinance adopted February 21,
1890, and was in substance as follows (pr. rec. 288):
R. L. Bennett, his associates, successors, and assigns,
who were to be incorporated as the Dawson Water-
works Company, were granted the exclusive right
for ninety-nine years to construct, maintain, and
operate a complete and thorough system of water-
works for the purpose of supplying the city and its
inhabitants with water for protection against fires
and for domestic, sanitary, and other useful purposes.
The exclusive right end privilege of excavating and
laying water pipes and mains along the streets of
the city was also conferred, as well as the right to
erect necessary buildings, tanks, ete.
The reservoir was required to be of not less than
forty thousand gallons’ capacity and of safficient
height to produce such pressure on the mains that
from any hydrant on the principal streets a stream
of water would be projected in still air fifty feet high,
through one hundred feet of fire hose and one-inch
nozzle, and the company was required to continue
during its existence, to furnish a sufficient supply of
water for the purposes named, unless prevented by
unavoidable and providential cause, in which-event
it should be allowed a reasonable time within which
to make repairs, after which, should it fail to furnish
such supply of water, its franchise from that fact
should be forfeited.
The company was required to enlarge its system
from time to time to meet the increased demands
consequent upon the growth of the city.
In consideration of guarantee by the company that
the city would have for twenty years, and as long
thereafter as the company should operate the water-
works, a free and unrestricted use of water for fire
protection, and fire plugs of approved pattern at
convenient places, the city obligated itself to pay to
the water company, or to such trust company as the
water company might elect as trustee for its bonds,
the sum of $2,000 annually for twenty years, payable
in semi-annual instalments, and the city was re-
PO SRN CEP BS ees oak aS : ‘piegeetin 0 epee a
3
quired to make provision each year for the payment
of the stipulated rental by a tax levy.
In consideration of the agreement by the water
company to furnish public municipal buildings and
fountains with water, the city obligated itself to
remit such license fees and taxes as might there-
after be assessed by the city against the water
company.
Assent was given by the city to the charter that
might be obtained by the water company, conferring
upon it the exclusive franchise to construct, main-
tain and operate a system of waterworks in the city.
It was provided that the provisions of the ordi-
nance should be mutually binding upon the city
and R. L. Bennett, and associates, and the company
to be organized by them. .
This ordinance was accepted by R. L. Bennett and con-
stituted the contract between him and the city. On March
17, 1891, the contract was assigned by Bennett to the
American Pipe Manufacturing Company, which, on August
20, 1891, assigned the same to the Dawson Waterworks
Company, which had become incorporated.
On June 27, 1894, the then city council passed a resolu-
tion declining to carry out the contract.
On October 4, 1894, the city council ordered an election
to determine whether bonds should be issued to the amount
of $35,000, to erect waterworks and provide electric lights
for the city. The election was held December 12, 1894,
and the result was in favor of the issuance of bonds, and
$10,000 of said bonds were issued and sold and the proceeds
used in erecting ar electric plant. The remainder of the
bonds has not yet been disposed of, the city having been
subsequently restrained by order of the court in this cause.
In December, 1894, in pursuance of resolution of the city
council, the mayor notified the water company that unless
a new agreement was reached the city would not be bound
by the contract after January 1, 1895. In pursuance of said
ot . ~ , - Nee SER IRIS ae ee
.
sy
&
LAN lig are
sek RPT
RA RCIA DE is 3 eat : » ' 3a SOR
d
resolution the city refused to pay the water rental for
1895. The water company brought suit in the Superior
Court for Terrell County, Georgia, for the 1895 instalments,
claiming that the contract was valid and binding for twenty
years, and that it had earned the rental for said year. The
city pleaded that it had not used the water; that the water
was unfit for use, and contended that the contract was not
binding as alleged, because the debt created thereby was
contrary to the inhibition of the State constitution, the
mandatory requirements of law not having been complied
with. The Superior Court directed a verdict for plaintiff,
and thereupon the city excepted, and the cause was
carried on appeal to the Supreme Court of Georgia.
The cause was argued and reargued before said court,
which, on March 14, 1899, rendered an exhaustive decision
(106 Ga. 696-737), reversing the court below and sustain-
ing the contention of the city, and holding in substance as
follows:
1. Without preliminary sanction of a popular vote,
as required by the constitution, a municipal corpora-
tion can not contract for a supply of water, on the
credit of the city, for a longer period than one year;
and a contract, which by its terms is to run for
twenty years, each year’s supply to be paid for
semi-annually, is operative from year to year, so long
as neither party renounces or repudiates it.
2. Even if no legislation is necessary to authorize
a municipal corporation to hold an election to deter-
mine whether a debt other than a bonded indebted-
ness shall be incurred, an election held pursuant to
an ordinance and notice which do not state the
amount of debt to be incurred, will not be sufficient
to authorize a contract incurring an indebtedness.
3. Where one enters into a contract with a munic-
ipal corporation which is void because opposed to
the constitution and laws of this State, and contrary
to its settled public policy, complete performance on
the part of such person will not prevent the munic-
ipal corporation from pleading its want of power, or
the illegality of the contract.
Ke * ot ee UA ane ee,
See - B
hr aR
o
4. The city has the right to make a contract for
water supply for one year, provided it has in the
treasury a sufficient sum to pay therefor, or if such
sum can be secured by lawful taxation levied during
the year in which the contract is made. While a
contract for a longer period is illegal, yet where the
other parties to such a contract have complied with
their part, the city is liable for the amount stipulated
in the contract for each year that it received the
benefits thereof.
Complainant’s Bill.
On May 1, 1899, less than two months after the decision
of the Supreme Court, the Columbia Avenue Savings Fund,
Safe Deposit, Title and Trust Company, a Pennsylvania
corporation, through the same counsel who had represented
the waterworks company, filed a bill in the Circuit Court of
the United States for the Fifth Circuit against the Dawson
Waterworks Company, the city of Dawson, and certain in-
dividuals in their representative capacity as officers of said
city. The bill alleged in substance as follows (pr. rec. 1):
That on September 1, 1891, the Dawson Water-
works Company created complainant trustee for its
first mortgage bonds, covering $40,000, the deed of
trust conveying as security the real and personal
property, rights, franchises, ete., and in particular
the income payable to said company or to the trustee
of its bondholders by virtue of the contract with the
city of Dawson; that the bonds were dated Septem-
ber 1, 1891, and payable September 1, 1916, and
had been sold to procure the money to construct the
system of waterworks in the city of Dawson.
The contract contained in the ordinance of Feb-
ruary 21, 1890, was alleged, cited, and described, as
well as the election of 1886. That the water company
~ had constructed a system of waterworks in accord-
ance with the requirements of said contract; that
the system had been tested and found to be satis-
factory ; that the city had, on August 12, 1891, by
resolution, accepted the system as complying with
<
z
ff
*
“arias tse
SAA EA OA
Bat tgs,
| ree Sg BAabiNe Ree
6
the contract; that the water company had continued
to maintain and operate the system in compliance
with the contract, and that the city had continuously
enjoyed the fire protection provided thereby.
That it was understood by the city when it made
the contract that the money required to construct
the waterworks was to be procured in whole or in
part by the issue of bonds of the water company,
and to make them more salable the city had agreed
to pay to the trustee for the bondholders the annual
rental stipulated in the contract, thus inviting in-
vestors to purchase the bonds upon the faith that
the city would observe its obligation.
That after using the water without complaint for
several years the city council, on June 27, 1894,
adopted a resolution declining to further carry out
its contract, assigning as the reason therefor that
the contract created an indebtedness forbidden by
the constitution of the State, and was, therefore, not
binding upon the city; that the water company had
in no way failed to comply with its contract; that at
the time the resolution was adopted the city was
considering the purchase of the waterworks, and it
was its purpose in repudiating the contract to destroy
the value of the property by withdrawing the reve-
nue necessary to its existence, thereby forcing the
company to sell at such a price as would be satisfac-
tory to the city; that in pursuance of this scheme an
equitable petition was filed in the State court by
certain taxpayers against the city and the water
company, seeking to enjoin the city from paying the
rentals accruing under the contract on the ground
that the contract was void under the constitution
and laws of Georgia. The petition was denied. It
was charged that the suit was instituted at the in-
stance of the city.
That since December 31, 1894, the city had re-
fused to pay or make any provision for the pay-
ment of water rentals under the contract which it
had prior to that time recognized; that in December,
1894, the city council, through its mayor, notified
the water company that a resolution had been
adopted declaring that the city would not be liable
NEO NRL Sire NL are am
7
on the contract after January 1, 1895; that the city
had continuously, since January 1, 1895, availed
itself of the fire protection afforded by the water
system, thereby taking the benefits, though declining
to carry out the obligations of the contract; that the
public ordinances providing for the use of the water
by the fire department had never been repealed, nor
had the department been forbidden to use the water;
that no other means of fire protection had been pro-
vided by the city; that apparatus had been furnished
the city fire department for using the water, and
members of the fire department were given tax ex-
emptions in consideration of their services; that the
mayor and members of the council, as well as other
citizens, had subsequently assisted in the use of
water at various fires.
That the water company declined to acquiesce in
the repudiation of the contract by the city, and gave
notice that it would continue to furnish water with
the required pressure, for fire protection; that it had
observed the requirements of the contract; that not-
withstanding the water company had at all times
held itself in readiness to furnish water for municipal
buildings and fountains, the city had assessed and
attempted to collect taxes for the year 1895.
That it was the purpose of the city to sell bonds
and erect its own system of waterworks and dispense
with the fire protection afforded under the existing
contract; that it was the city’s plan to repudiate the
contract, but nevertheless to continue to use the
water until such time as it should sell its bonds and
erect its own waterworks; that the Supreme Court
of Georgia having decided that the contract between
the city and the water company was void, the city
was engaged in an effort to sell its bonds for the pur-
pose of erecting a system of waterworks in violation
of its contract and in destruction of the rights of the
water company and the holders of its bonds.
That the water company had no property except
its plantand the value of said contract, the abroga-
tion of which would result in almost complete
destruction of the value of its property, as the com-
pany would be in no position to compete suc-
PAS cine Cag 1
— |
TE TAN A CAS EB EIT BOR ALON EES EE BETS EAI
cessfully for the patronage of private consumers,
That the water company, recognizing complain-
ant’s duty to the bondholders, had (since the said
decision of the Georgia Supreme Court) yielded to
complainant’s demand that in future it should have
the exclusive right to collect from the city of Daw-
son all rentals accruing under the contract for the
year 1896, and subsequent years, and the city had
been notified thereof.
That the bonds of the water company had been
first sold to the American Pipe Manufacturing Com-
pan,’, which in turn sold them in open market, and
the same are now held by different persons; that said
pipe manufacturing company is engaged in the con-
4 struction of waterworks, and frequently receives pay-
3 ment in bonds, and consequently has frequent occa-
4 sions to sell such bonds, and is therefore interested
in seeing that the obligations thereof are duly pro-
tected; that said pipe manufacturing company had
paid all the interest due on the bonds from January
1, 1896, to March 1, 1899, inclusive, as the water
company could not do so, because of the failure of
the city of Dawson to pay the rentals during said
years; that said pipe manufacturing company was
unwilling to advance further sums, and had called
upon complainant, as trustee, to demand and collect
the rentals from the city of Dawson, so as to enable
the pipe manufacturing company to recover the in-
terest advanced.
F
rvave Soria g o
abe LL Saw eel e
"TR
The bill prayed that the city be enjoined from erecting,
operating, using, ete., any system of waterworks other than
those of the water company for fire protection, or from enter-
ing into any other contract with reference to any other water
system, or for supply of water for fire protection, or from
selling bonds for any such purpose in violation of said con-
tract with the Dawson Waterworks Company, and from col-
lecting any city tax or license fees from said company. Also
that the contract be declared valid and binding upon the
parties, and that the same be specifically enforced, and that
complainants recover all rentals due, with interest.
jalan ase AR RETR es
169 a la bt)
Pe RE hi Nant
a
>»
z
%
2
Signa » ee Re et coed - . Dia Peay Pte ee:
i}
et a
Defendants’ Demurrer and Answer.
The court having granted a restraining order and rule
nisi, the defendants for cause filed objections to the juris-
diction of the court, in substance as follows (pr. rec. 40, 51,
53, and 60):
That the Dawson Water Company, a Georgia cor-
poration, was the real complainant in said bill, which
was fraudulent and collusive, and filed since the ren-
dition of the judgment by the Supreme Court of
Georgia in the case of said water company versus the
city of Dawson, declaring that the contract between
the parties was void; that the bill was filed in the
name of the present complainant, tnder the newly
created right of action, for the purpose of avoiding
the judgment of said Supreme Court, which was con-
clusive as to all questions raised; that under the alle-
gations of the bill there was no jurisdiction.
Whereupon the defendants prayed that the court
proceed no further, but dismiss the bill for want of
jurisdiction.
For further cause defendants charged that there
was no equity in the bill; that the only right of
action alleged was one at law to recover rentals; that
the allegations in the bill showed only a contract
which was void, and had been declared so, and that
there was no contract at all between complainant
and defendants.
That the contract between the company and the
city was void ab initio, because the city had no
power to make such a contract as alleged; that on
the 14th day of March, 1899, the Supreme Court of
Georgia, in the case of the Dawson Water Company
vs. the City of Dawson, in a suit for alleged rentals
under said contract for the year 1895, had decided
that under the constitution and laws of the State of
Georgia, and its settled policy, this very contract
was ab initio void.
Wherefore defendants said that all questions now
raised by complainants were res judicata.
For answer defendants denied that the city had
entered into the alleged contract with the full
:
&
bi
x
7
f
3
B
bro
PALS AR AA a Re Tiiw
RAR SO CEI ES
:
3
im
s
10
knowledge and free assent of its inhahitants. They
charged that the notice and resolution for the elec-
tion on said water contract were void for uncer-
tainty and had been sodeclared by theSupreme Court;
that when said election was called and held, neither
the said R. L. Bennett nor the waterworks company,
nor said contract had ever been contemplated by
the voters of the city or by its officials; that the votes
at said election were cast in the belief that the city
proposed either to build or buy waterworks; that
the so-called contract with R. L. Bennett was un-
. dertaken without regard to said election and with-
out any sanction by the electors of the city and
without any opportunity of sanction by them.
They denied that the inhabitants of the city had
accepted the contract as the act of the city, or that
the same had been acquiesced in by every one;
they charged that there had been objection to the
contract from the beginning, which had grown with
the experience of the people with said contract until
it had ripened into litigation.
They admitted that the city had accepted the
waterworks at the time as meeting the requirements
of the contract, but charged that their fitness and
efficiency was of short duration, while the contract
required that they should be continuous; they de-
nied that the waterworks company had carried out
its contract since the acceptance of the system.
They admitted payment by the city of the rentals
prior to the year 1895; they admitted renouncing
the contract in June, 1894, as illegal and exorbi-
tant, but alleged that the city was desirous of doing
what was right by the water company, and just and
best for the people of the city, and negotiated for a
fair and legal contract with the company; that the
company treated its overtures with ridicule; that
since then the cityhad not recognized the contract,
and that no official, as such, has used the water since
January 1, 1895; they denied any effort to force the
company to sell its system to the city.
They charged that the water system was and had
been during all the years mentioned, defective, in-
sufficient, unreliable and aimost unserviceable as a
SFA Sates ee RUN 9 ON RR ORR SNS FO aE AS
11
means for protecting the city from fire; that the re-
quired amount of pressure had not existed during
this time; that the system had not been kept in
proper condition, and that the works were and had
been unsatisfactory and had almost entirely failed of
results on occasions of fires; that the system was
worse than worthless to the city, for instead of being
a protection, its existence, and the litigation con-
nected therewith, had prevented and was preventing
the construction of adequate and sufficient works;
that during all these years the company had notice
and knowledge of the inefficiency of said system, and
on one occasion, in June, 1897, after the system had
failed to be of service in preventing the burning of
the Whitchard and Green houses, by agreement sev-
eral citizens and J. A. Horseley, superintendent of
the system, the next day made a test, being furnished
with 100 feet of new and clean hose and one inch
nozzle, as provided by the contract, and the pressure
failed to throw the water vertically in still air more
than thirty feet; that in and since 1894 there had
been no substantial deterioration or improvement in
the system.
That the contract alleged for remission of taxes
was void, and had been so declared by the Supreme
Court of Georgia; that the city had not used the
water under the terms of the so-called contract, and
that the taxes assessed against the water company
for 1895 and subsequent years were unpaid.
That the city had the right to build, or buy, and
operate waterworks upon complying with the require-
ments of the State constitution.
That complaimant had failed to assert any right
to collect water rentals or to give notice to the city
of its intention to do so, and had allowed the water
company to collect the rentals prior to the year 1895,
and to litigate for the rentals for said year as sole
claimant thereof, until it had reached an adverse
decision, when the Supreme Court of the State ad-
judged the contract null and void, and all questions
now raised having been decided adversely, it was
too late for complainant, as subsequent transferee,
to litigate the same question in a different jurisdiction.
BLADER THI BELLE ae
el aN a RE
12
Defendants charged that the water company did
not and could not, under the constitution and laws
of Georgia, have such an exclusive franchise as
alleged by complainant; that the city, its property
owners and inhabitants, had been and were being
greatly damaged by the existence of the present sys-
tem and the continued litigation by the water com-
pany and its privy, the complainant; that according
to complainant’s bill, the water company was in-
solvent and could not improve and repair its system
so as to satisfy the requirements of the city, and not-
withstanding that fact, the said company, through
: complainant, was stubbornly insisting on the en-
forcement of the so-called contract, requiring exorbi-
tant payments for next to worthless service.
i
by
je
LN ER
Amendments to Bill and Answer.
The court heard the rule on June 9, 1899, and on June
27, 1899, before a decision was rendered, the complainant
amended its bill, setting up a Federal question, and alleging
in substance as follows (pr. ree. 36, 51):
That notwithstanding the bonds of the water com-
pany were marketed on the faith of said contract, and
that the water system had been erected at great ex-
pense, and the company had complied with the
conditions of the contract, the city had, by ordinance
and conduct, attempted to impair the obligations of
said contract and that its action was in destruction
of the security of the bondholders under the contract,
and protection thereof guaranteed by the Constitu-
tion of the United States; that the city had attempted
to violate the obligation of said contract, contrary to
the Constitution of the United States, which prohibits
any State from passing any law impairing the
obligations of contracts, and, under the color of
authority given it by the charter, the city had not
only adopted such ordinance, but was proceeding to
carry the same into effect.
That the wrongful conduct of the city in refusing
to be bound by the obligations of the contract, and
to destroy without compensation the property values
Bes . * SION NR NR ID
Ps
Bs
L?
3
13
dependent upon the exclusive franchise guarantee
by said contract, and its threat to erect a rival
system of waterworks, would have the effect of de-
priving the bondholders of their property without
due process of law, contrary to the protection guar-
anteed by the Constitution of the United States.
That after the decision against it by the Supreme
Court of Georgia, the water company had_ notified
complainant that it would take no steps to collect the
water rentals accruing after January 1, 1896, or
looking to the enforcement of the contract and the
protection of the bondholders, and that said company
was without means to pay the instalments of interest
and could not now make necessary repairs and im-
provements.
The defendants answered the foregoing amendment in
substance as follows:
They denied the allegations of the bill as amended
and reiterated that the suit was collusive and ‘insti-
tuted to evade the decision of the State Supreme Court;
that the water company had constantly demanded pay-
ment of the rentals in its own right, without notice or
intimation that complainant had any right to collect
the same; that upon the promulgation of the decis-
ion of the Supreme Court of Georgia, the waterworks
company (who was the real complainant), and also
the superintendent of the company, had declared
that litigation had just begun, and they would now
enforce their alleged rights in the United States
courts,
That the water company had failed from the year
1895 to the year 1899, inclusive, to carry out its
contract, and had left the property of the city of
Dawson at the mercy of fires during all that period.
That the defendants had passed no ordinance in
impairment of any valid contract, and had made no
contract, and had done no act tending to destroy
property without due compensation therefor; they
admitted holding an election to authorize a bond
issue, the proceeds of which would be applied to the
erection of waterworks.
eh Se, Seah
Cl DLL PS
pee Plight SLCC:
6 ae, Seine Rs EAs
Baw idea Ente
er Cee a eg
14
They denied any contractual relation with the
complainant and admitted having never complained
about the waterworks to the complainant, because
the city never knew or suspected that it was the
lawful guardian of the water company, and therefore
entitled to notice.
The cause was heard, and thereupon, on September 16,
1899, the court granted an order for an injunction pendente
lite, with leave to the defendants to apply to the court,
after thirty days, for a test of the ability of the water com-
pany to perform its obligations under the contract. From
this order the city prosecuted an appeal to the Circuit Court
of Appeals, which court, without regard to the merits of the
controversy, dismissed the appeal on the ground that an
appeal would not lie to that court from an order granting
an interlocutory injunction in a case involving the applica-
tion of the Constitution of the United States (Dawson vs.
Columbia Avenue, 102 Fed. 200).
On July 8, 1901, after argument, the circuit court over-
ruled defendants’ demurrer, holding the law and equity to
be with the complainant.
On December 2, 1901, by consent, the cause was referred
to W. A. Wimbish, Master in Chancery, to hear evidence
and make report on all matters in issue. The material por-
tions of the testimony will be referred to in the ‘“ Specifica-
tion of Errors” and in the “Argument,” infra.
REPORT OF THE MASTER.
The hearing took place in March and April, 1902. The
complainant and the city of Dawson appeared and were
represented by counsel, but there was no appearance for the
water company. After argument the Master submitted his
report, which was in substance as follows (pr. rec. 77):
Findings of Fact.
1. That the result of the election of June 11, 1886,
was not in contemplation of the parties to the con-
tract made in 1890, between the city of Dawson and
R. L. Bennett, and therefore constituted no author-
ity for the city to enter into said contract; that the
contract was made without reference to said election,
and was not induced thereby.
2. That the contract was, in substance, as stated,
supra, in this narrative, and the water company had
become transferee thereof, as also stated.
3. That the city of Dawson had express notice
that bonds were to be issued to construct the water-
works.
4. That the city designated and accepted the
source of water supply.
5. That after completion the system was tested by
the city, and by formal resolution was accepted as
coming up to the requirements of the contract.
6. That the water company issued bonds aggre-
gating $40,000, giving mortgage to complainant as
trustee, as alleged in complainant’s bill; that the
issue of bonds was accepted by the American Pipe
Manufacturing Company in payment for construe-
tion of the works ; that the bonds were subsequently
sold to bona fide purchasers at prices varying from
923 to 100, the aggregate derived amounting to
$37,927.23 ; that the waterworks, after acceptance
by the city, were operated for several years to the
mutual satisfaction of the parties, during which time
the city paid the rentals as they fell due, and ap-
pears to have made no complaint either with refer-
ence to the quality or quantity of the water or the
efficiency of the service ; that in May, 1894, the city
opened negotiations looking to the purchase of the
system, and the result was a failure to agree; that
on June 27, 1894, the city renounced the contract
because ultra vires, and appointed a committee to
make such arrangements as would be satisfactory to
the city and the waterworks company ; that the
water company declined to acquiesce in the
abrogation of the contract; that on Decem-
ber 14, 1894, the city notified the company
that unless a new agreement was reached as to sub-
sequent use of the water, it would not be liable
under the contract after January 1, 1895; that the
Ss
=
ape
Wi Gy
CeO LON ahi Se 8S
Bese
aS
ie alte
Stein
Bd 2t KRM A
Bivins ati CTS ALTE SARA R IS ARE a ilar hI
Nea a a Sl RNR Sint NE ale PEA EE ae
16
water company declined to enter into a new agree-
ment and notified the city that it would continue to
perform the requirements of the contract ; that in
1895 the company continued to furnish water for
the use of the city; that the system of the company
was only used at one fire during said vear; that since
that time the water had been used on occasions of
numerous fires, and the city officials participated in
the use of the water, claiming that they were not
acting in their official capacity, but as private
citizens in emergencies, their acts being unauthorized
by the city; that the city fire department was main-
tained since 1894, as it had been in preceding years,
and the city continued to furnish fire apparatus to
the fire department, and to grant tax exemptions to
the members thereof; that no other means of fire
protection was afforded by the city, and it did not
forbid the use of the water by the fire department
and must have known that it was being used; that
notwithstanding the repudiation of the contract, the
city had continued to enjoy the fire protection
afforded by the water company, as it did prior to
repudiation.
8. (This finding relates to the quality of the water
furnished, and is quoted in full in the specification
of error No. 26, infra.)
9. (This finding relates to pressure, and is quoted
in full in specification of error No. 26.)
10. That for three and a half years prior to the
repudiation of the contract, the water supply was
taken from the source designated and approved by
the city, and during these vears the surface washings
flowed into the stream during times of rain, and on
such occasions the water was muddy; that there was
no requiremet by the city for the water company
to protect the water shed, nor was there any require-
ment that the water be filtered, or that the tower be
increased in height or capacity; that the city predi-
vated its right to renounce the contract upon the
want of authority in the preceding administration to
bind the city, and because it regarded the contract
as unfair and exorbitant; that the evident purpose
of the city was to either purchase the works ata
a oe Ta od oe
os)
17
price satisfactory to it, or to make a new agreement
on more favorable terms, or to construct and operate
its own system; that, failing to agree with the com-
pany, the city proposed to issue bonds and construct
itsown waterworks.
11. That during the years succeeding 1895 the
only water furnished by the company for municipal
buildings was through one opening. No water was
supplied for fountains, none having been maintained
by the city.
12. That the city levied an ad valorem tax on the
water company for the year 1895, but the tax had
not been paid by the company.
13. That no application had been made by the city
to test the water system, as provided by order of the
court of September 16, 1899.
14. ‘That subsequent to the date of the decision of
the Supreme Court of Georgia, in the case of the
Waterworks Company vs. City of Dawson, the com-
pany had assigned to complainant the exclusive
right to demand and collect the water rentals.
15. That the revenues of the water company from
and including the year 1895, exclusive of rentals
¢laimed to be due by the city, had been insufficient
to pay the operating expenses and fixed charges.
16. That the American Pipe Manufacturing Com-
pany had loaned to the water company from time to
time funds to meet the accruing interest on the bonds
of the water company, from September 1, 1895, to
March 1, 1899, aggregating $8,560; that the water
©mpany had paid said interest to the complainant ;
tiat the transaction between the pipe company and
tie water company was merely a loan from the former
to the latter, and there was no express agreement
that the former should be subrogated to the rights of
bondholders in the interest coupons.
17. That the complainant was without notice of
ligation between the water company and the city of
Dawson until after the decision of the Supreme Court
oi Georgia, dated March 14, 1899.
8310—2
18
Conclusions of Law by the Master.
I.
That the only effect of the transfer by the water
company to complainant of the right to collect the
renials, in so far as concerns the want of jurisdiction,
was to create the diversity of citizenship necessary to
a suit in the Federal court; but since in this case a
Federal question sufficient to independently sustain
the jurisdiction was presented, it was immaterial to
inquire what motive prompted the water company
to make the assignment to complainant; that the
court, in overruling defendants’ demurrer for want of
equity, adjudicated the right of complainant to main-
tain its suit.
II.
1. That the plea of res judicata had no application
because complainant was not privy in right and
estate to the water company in the State court suit
as to be conclusively bound thereby, since a mort-
gagee is privy in estate to a mortgagor only as to
the actions begun before the mortgage was given.
2. That this court was not bound to follow the de-
cision of the Supreme Court of Georgia, declaring
the contract in question to be void, because a debt
was thereby incurred within the inhibition of the
State constitution, but should exercise its independ-
ent judgment in regard to the contract, because there
had not been such a settled course of judicial decisions
in Georgia, on the question, at the time of the making
of the contract as to constrain the courts of the
United States to follow the later decisions of the
State court. (In reaching this conclusion the various
decisions of the Supreme Court of Georgia on the
question of inhibited indebtedness were cited and
construed, the Master disagreeing with the conclu-
sion of the Supreme Court in Dawson Water Com-
pany vs. City of Dawson, as to the force, effect, and
consistency of the various decisions of said court, ren-
dered prior to the date of the contract in question.
The Master’s analysis will be considered in the argu-
ment which is to follow, under “Stare Decisis.”
ee ee . SASS OE REED OLE A SRE RL Sot.
19
3. That, contrary to the decision of the Supreme
Court of Georgia, he found that the contract in ques-
tion did not create a debt within the meaning of the
State constitution, and that the question was not an
open one in this forum, citing the case of Walla
Walla vs. Walla Walla Water Co., 172 U. S.1, as
conclusive; that the contract contemplated that the
watercompany should maintain and perform specified
service for a period of twenty years, and the city was
obligated to pay $2,000 per annum for the service;
that if the water company should fail to perform the
service, the city would be under no obligation to pay;
that in no event was it liable to pay any instalment
for service until the service had been rendered.
4. That the grant of franchise to the water com-
pany was in consideration of the performance of a
public service, and after performance by the grantee
became a contract protected by the Constitution of
the United States; that as an incident to the prin-
cipal undertaking the city had power to grant to
the company the use of its streets and the exclusive
right to supply the city and its inhabitants with
water; that while the contract did not in terms ex-
press an agreement that the city would not, during
the twenty years it contracted to take water, erect its
own system for the purpose of supplying the inhab-
itants with water, yet such was the fair implication
and reasonable intendment of the contract; that it
Was unnecessary to decide whether the grant of the
exclusive franchise for ninety-nine years was valid;
that the city, having induced the expenditure of
money on the face of the promise that it would
grant the exclusive use of the streets for pipes and
mains by the water company, and having contracted
to pay for the use of the water for fire protection for
twenty years, would not be permitted in equity to
disregard its agreement by entering into competi-
tion with the water company before the expiration
of the contractual term.
5, That during periods of continuous rainfall the
water supply was muddy and to some extent con-
taminated by surface washings; that at times the
reservoir leaked, and the required pressure was not
Sort |
Fy
a
4
3
*s
2
a
4a
a
| eee Pplenitereatictiads
Sewio~
20
at all times maintained ; that the quality of the water
was the same as it had been during the years the
city accepted it as satisfactory ; that the water shed
and its condition was substantially the same then
as now; that the contract did not require the water
to be other than that furnished in its natural state
from the designated source of supply; or that it
should be filtered or otherwise rendered fit for do-
mestic use; that prior to the repudiation of the con-
tract no complaint as to the pressure or quality of
the water had been made, nor had objection of any
kind been presented ; that no complaint had been
made until the filing of defendants’ answer, and within
a reasonable time thereafter the company erected a
new standpipe of larger capacity and greater press-
ure; that, under the circumstances, the city could
not invoke a forfeiture, nor plead the facts as a
defense to the right of complainant to relief.
6. That the agreement between the city and the
yater company, which provided for commutation of
city taxes in consideration of water to be furnished
for municipal buildings and public fountains, was
void under the constitution and laws of Georgia, but
that the water company, upon an accounting, would
be entitled to have credit for the value of the water
actually supplied under the agreement.
7. That the interest which matured from Septem-
ber 1, 1895, to March 1, 1899, was paid by the w&ter
company from funds loaned to it for the purpose by
the American Pipe Manufacturing Company, and
the interest having been so paid, the complainant
was not entitled to recover in behalf of the pipe com-
pany, the indebtedness represented by the coupons
having been extinguished ; that the complainant,
having once received payment, can not enforce it
again in the interest of the pipe company, who was
not a party to the contract and was not in privity
with complainant.
8. That, under the Constitution and laws of the
United States, the ordinance of the city denying
liability on the contract with the water company was
legislation affecting the obligation of the contract ;
that the voters of the city, having authorized the
ani
Bae ot:
LMI LAE ORDERED AE IRANI IAS DEA AOE
issue of bonds for the construction of waterworks to
be operated by the city, the complainant was entitled
to equitable relief to prevent impairment of its rights
under the contract; that the contract was an essen-
tial part of the security of the bondholders, the right
of the complainant to collect the water rentals in de-
fault of payment of interest by the water company
being confirmed in the mortgage given to secure the
bonds, and the exclusive right to make such collec-
tions having been assigned, after default, to com-
plainant; that complainant was entitled to an
injunction forbidding the city from constructing or
operating a system of waterworks in competition
with those of the company, or for the purpose of
supplying the city with water for fire protection and
municipal use; that since it appears that the water
company owns ho property other than that covered
by the mortgage to the trustee, so that a suit for
damages against it would not measure up to the
standard of an adequate legal remedy, the complain-
ant is also entitled to a mandatory injunction requir-
ing the city and the water company to perform the
contract as essential to the protection of the security
for the bonds.
General Conclusions of the Master.
1. That the objection to the jurisdiction was not
well founded, inasmuch as the Jurisdiction rested
upon the Federal question presented, without regard
to the citizenship of the parties.
2. That the doctrine of res judicata was not ap-
plicable to the complainant for the reason that com-
plainant was not a party or privy to the State court
suit.
3. That this court is not bound to follow the de-
cisions of the Supreme Court of Georgia, rendered
after the contract had been made and the rights of
complainant thereunder acquired; that the decisions
of the State courts, prior to the execution of the con-
tract, had not been so long and firmly established as
to constitute a rule of property.
4. That the contract between the city and the com-
Oe BEE ERAS TEST 2 eect |
EE IE ae = CE VENA ENTE POM
eee ee tio
——
|
SSA IN MELE ONS
22
pany did not create a debt within the meaning of the
constitution and laws of Georgia, and that the same
was valid and enforceable.
5. That the exclusive franchise granted by the
city to the water company could not be revoked by
the city in its own interest, nor could its value be
impaired by competition on the part of the city
within the twenty years during which the city agreed
to take and pay for water for fire protection.
6. That the city could not forfeit the rights and
franchises of the water company for inefficient
service or for failure to supply water of a higher
quality or purity, nor could it plead such facts in
bar to the equitable relief sought.
7. That the agreement to accept water for use in
commutation of city taxes was void under the laws
of Georgia.
8. That complainant was not entitled to enforce in
this suit any rights that the American Pipe Manu-
facturing Company may have acquired by reason of
having furnished the water company with funds to
pay maturing interest coupons on its bonds.
4
#
4
7
S
a
Ni
¥
%
Pate
Relief Recommended by the Master.
1. That the contract between the city and the
water company be declared to be valid, binding, and
enforceable.
2. That an injunction be granted complainant
prohibiting the city from negotiating or disposing
of the bonds authorized to be used to construct a
water system by the city, and from constructing or
operating any water system in the city of Dawson
for supplying either the city or its inhabitants with
water for tire protection or domestic use.
3. That the city be enjoined from revoking or at-
tempting to revoke the rights and franchises granted
to the water company during the term of twenty
years, within which it contracted to take and pay
for the water.
4. That the city should pay complainant the water
rentals from January 1, 1896, with interest on each
instalment thereof as the same matured, at the legal
rate.
5. That an accounting be had between the parties
to the suit to ascertain what is due by the city for
water furnished by the water company under the
agreement made in commutation of taxes, and the
value of the water so supplied should be allowed as
acredit against the demand of the city for ad valorem
taxes on the property of the water company ; that
until such accounting be had, and until the city pay
over the amount found to be due for water, the city
be enjoined from proceeding with the collection of
the taxes until such accounting and settlement.
6. That the city and the water company be re-
quired to specifically perform the contract forming
the subject of this suit, and to that end a mandatory
injunction be issued.
The Master made report on April 27, 1903, and the city
filed exceptions thereto. The court overruled all the ex-
ceptions and rendered final degree on August 3, 1908 (pr.
rec. 166). The report was confirmed in all respects, the
decree being framed to measure the recommendations of the
Master. An appeal brings the case before this court.
SPECIFICATION OF ERRORS.
It is assigned that the court below erred (see pr. rec.
175-219) :
1. In not dismissing complainant’s bill for want of juris-
diction, because under the pleadings there was no diversity
of citizenship, the water company, the real complainant, and
the city, the defendant, both being Georgia corporations,
the assignment of the cause of action to the nominal com-
plainant being ficticious, merely colorable, and without
interest, and for the purpose of conferring Federal juris-
diction.
2. In overruling defendants’ demurrer to the jurisdiction,
because there was no Federal question presented, the city
having passed no law impairing the obligations of the con-
me
tract with the water company, and having taken no action
tending to deprive the bondholders of the water compauy
of their property without due process of law.
3. In not dismissing said bill for want of jurisdiction,
because under the pleadings there was no Federal question
involved or other ground of jurisdiction, the alleged Federal
question being predicated upon an alleged contract such as
was expressly forbidden by the constitution of Georgia.
4. In not dismissing said bill for want of jurisdiction,
because (1) there was no equity therein, the only right of
action set up being a common law right, and only enforee-
able as such; (2) there was no contract or facts set forth to
sustain equitable jurisdiction ; (3) the alleged right of re-
covery was one for water rents, which could only be deter-
mined in a proceeding at law; and (4) the only right set
up requiring equitable remedy to protect, namely, the ex-
clusive franchise in favor of the water company, if such as
alleged, could not exist under the constitution of Georgia.
5. In not dismissing said bill for want of jurisdiction, be-
cause complainant had an adequate and complete remedy
at law, it appearing from the pleadings that equitable juris-
diction was solely invoked to protect from impairment an
alleged exclusive franchise such as the city of Dawson
never conferred and never had the power to grant.
6. In entering said decree, because all questions and
issues raised by the bill were res judicata, the appellants
having set forth in their answer that on the I4th day of
March, 1899, the Supreme Court of Georgia, in a suit for
rentals for the year 1895, by the Dawson Waterworks Com-
pany vs. the City of Dawson, under the very contract form-
ing the subject of the present suit, decided and adjudged
that under the constitution and laws of Georgia, and its set-
tled policy, said contract was void ab initio, these appellants
then and now contending that by said judgment, and the
proof thereof which was duly presented, the complainant
was estopped and coucluded, as well as the water company,
25
its interest being identical with that of the water company,
the water company being the real complainant and not a
defendant as pretended, the suit being collusive and_ficti-
tious for the purpose of avoiding said judgment, the nomi-
nal complainant having become the assignee of the cause of
action since the date of said judgment.
7. In entering said decree adjudging that complainant
recover of the city of Dawson the sum of the water rentals
accruing since 1895, because the contract between the city
and the company was only operative from year to year
until renounced, and having been declared so by the Su-
preme Court of Georgia, the highest court for the construe-
tion of the laws of said State, the Federal court was in duty
hound to follow the deeision of said court.
8. In entering said decree adjudging the recovery prayed
for, because the court should have followed the decision of
said Supreme Court which declared that the contract was
void, said decision being declaratory of a rule of property
which had already been established by said court in various
decisions rendered prior and subsequent to the date of the
contract between the city and the said company, said State
court having never made any decision previous to said date
in conflict with its determination of any material issue de-
cided in the case of Dawson Waterworks Company vs. the
City of Dawson.
9. In adjudging the contract between the city and the
water company to be valid, binding, and enforceable, and
that the ordinances and conduct of the city, whereby it was
sought to invalidate said contract, were unconstitutional, as
secking to impair the obligation of said contract, because
the city says that under the pleadings, evidence, and law,
the obligation of the contract alleged and adjudged to be
impaired, did not exist, namely, the alleged grant of an ex-
clusive franchise by the city to the water company,
10. In enjoining the city from erecting any system of
waterworks to supply water for fire protection or to furnish
a)
j
{
;
a
3
:
@
|
i inthe ER IS EA aces.
de pa elo
5 Cai Sie te Be
I id Migs Be i
s
26
the inhabitants of said city with water for domestic, sani-
tary, and other purposes, or from contracting with any per-
son for the construction, operation, or use of any water
system, or for water for fire protection or other municipal
purposes, or from laying water mains in the streets of said
city, ete., because such decree could be lawfully granted
only on the ground that the water company had acquired
in its grant an exclusive franchise to construct, maintain,
own, and operate its works in the city, such as the munic-
ipal corporation had no power under its charter or other-
wise to confer.
11. In entering such decree against the city, because the
sworn answers of the defendants and the weight of the evi-
dence adduced at the hearing showed that the inhabitants
of the city were greatly in need of a sufficient supply of
water for fire protection and for domestic, sanitary, and other
useful purposes, it being the right and the imperative duty
of said municipal corporation to provide such supply of
water, which had not been and was not being furnished by
the water company, and not within the ability of the exist-
ing system to furnish it.
12. In enjoining the city from erecting waterworks of its
own and from using the streets for distributing the water,
because under the pleadings, the evidence and the law of
contract obligation, and as a matter of fact the city never
made any agreement, valid or invalid, not to erect water-
works of its own and use its streets for the purpose of dis-
tributing water, and under its charter and the State constitu-
tion it could not have made any such valid agreement.
13. In entering said decree, because under the pleadings
the former officers of the city, the waterworks company, and
the complainant, had no power, by contract or otherwise, to
deprive the inhabitants of said municipality of their right
under the law to a suitable supply of water and from a
competitive source if need be.
14. In granting said decree, because the alleged perform-
BEEP OT COS LE PAINS RA UNAS LTE OPO SET BET RIAN SON
27
ance of said contract by the water company was denied in
the sworn answers of defendants, and the evidence adduced
at the hearing showed that said company had failed during
the years for which rentals were claimed, namely, 1896,
1897, 1898, and 1899, to the date of the filing of the bill,
io perform the alleged contract so as to be entitled to receive
the rentals claimed to be due.
15. In adjudging that complainant recover of the city the
water rentals accruing since January 1, 1896, because it
did not appear from the evidence or otherwise that said
rentals had been earned by the water company by perform-
ance of its alleged contract.
16. In enjoining the city from levying and enforcing, in
violation of said contract, the collection of any city tax or
license fee against the property of the water company,
stipulated in said contract to be paid in water, because the
court having found the agreement providing for such com-
mutation to be void, it was unlawful for it to arrest the levy
and process of collection of taxes and license fees.
17. In adjudging that complainant recover future instal-
ments of water rentals during the life of the alleged contract,
because the right of recovery of such instalments would de-
pend upon the performance by the water company of its
part of the contract, it being in contravention of law to de-
cree recovery in advance of performance, and before the in-
stalments could be due, in event of performance.
18. In adjudging, at the instance ofa third party with no
duties to perform, that the city and the water company be
required to specifically perform the contract between them
and to comply with their respective obligations arising and
to arise thereunder, and that to such end an injunction be
issued requiring specific performance, because the remedy
of specific performance can not be properly so invoked, and
as thus applied is not justified by the terms of the contract
and the law applicable thereto.
19. In taxing this defendant with the compensation of
EEE: ON YSIS
NMSA Oye Rens eee ee
OS EBLE S
>
3
a
3.
£
2
Lge
PRO LO Stet A ane oP ree SEPM a Hore ae Hae ORS
28
the Special Master, because no good reason appears why the
city should bear the entire burden of the litigation.
20. In allowing the sum of $2,000 as compensation to
the Master, because such amount is excessive when meas-
ured with the service performed.
(Overruled Exceptions to Master’s Report.)
21. In overruling the first exception of law, which was as
follows (pr. ree. 1380-5):
By numerous witnesses the city proposed to prove by
what occurred at various fires that the waterworks, as con-
structed and operated, did not come up to the requirements
of the contract as to pressure. The testimony offered is
briefed as follows :
By A. J. Baldwin (pr. rec. 515): That at the fires
that destroved the residences of F. L. Parks, one in
the year 1898 and one in the vear 1899, the hose
» was attached to the plugs of the Dawson Water-
works Company, not over 400 feet away, on one of
the principal streets of the city, and the force from
the same was not sufficient to do anything towards
extinguishing the said fires; and the building in
each instance was burned down; that the force of
pressure from said hydrants was so weak that those
trying to throw the water on the fire could not get
near enough to throw the streams on the fire,
although they did stand within 40 or 50 feet of the
building.
That witness witnessed the fire that destroyed the
Dawson Oil Mill, in Dawson, on the 4th of January,
1899. The mill was in full operation and supplied
with 200 feet of standard hose, same kind and size
of nozzle as the city’s hose. This hose was immedi-
ately attached to the Dawson Waterworks Company’s
hydrant, 15 feet from the corner of said mill, by the
hands, and turned on said fire. The pressure of said
water was so weak it was entirely insufficient to pre-
vent the burning of said building, although attached
and put to work very promptly, and in consequence
of said weak pressure thus used, those using the hose
were unable to stay near enough to the fire to throw
WE edict STD
s
29
water on it. That the pressure at the time was not
sufficient to throw the water over 30 feet high with
a one-inch nozzle attached to the hose. The mill
was on one of the principal streets of the city and one
of the lowest points, being ten feet lower than the base
of the standpipe of the waterworks company.
Witness saw the fire which destroyed the Farnum
House, in April, 1898, being near his place of busi-
ness. Fire caught in kitchen, low one-story building,
pot more than fifteen or twenty feet high, and the
streams of water from the waterworks did not and
could not reach more than 25 feet high on that oc-
casion. Don’t know whether the nozzle was } or one
inch, but it was one or the other. On this occasion
witness was hit by the stream of water with its full
pressure in the face while standing within eight feet
of the nozzle and suffered no inconvenience from it,
except slight strangulation. At the time this hap-
pened the nozzle was not more than about 50 feet
from the plug. Witness can not state the length of
the hose. Witness could not state positively what
the length of the hose was. It was probably 150
feet. Eight buildings were destroyed on this occasion,
and the fire was never checked until the people were
able to get the steam fire engine belonging to said
city at work, when the flames were subdued by said
engine. That from his own experience with fires, he
knows that a pressure equal to that agreed to be fur-
nished by the Dawson Waterworks Company, viz, 50
feet vertically in still air, this fire could have been
extinguished with the apparatus then in hand and
with the hose being used, with slight damage to the
hotel and kitchen. Witness was at the fire that de-
stroyed the J. R. Smith residence, May 1, 1899. The
plug to which the hose was attached at said fire was
about 400 feet from said residence, and the pressure
was not sufficient to throw the stream over a chimney
26 feet 4 inches high. Witness measured the chim-
ney and saw the failure.
By J. S. Lowry (pr. rec. 516): That after the hose
was attached to the hydrants of the waterworks com-
pany on one of the principal streets of the city, when
an effort was made to extinguish the Farnum house
| Ne es
30
fire, the water could be thrown barely to the top of
the kitchen, one-story part of the building, not over
22 or 23 feet high.
By F. M. Jennings (pr. rec. 516): As to the dry
kiln fire in 1899, that the stream was never over 25
feet high; and that at the Grier residence, consumed
in 1898, the pressure was not sufficient to throw the
water on a servant’s house in the yard, not more
than 20 or 25 feet high; and that he saw a man carry
the nozzle nearly to the top of said house and pour
the water from it. It would not have thrown a
stream. Also the Parks fire in 1899, the pressure
was not sufficient to throw a stream to the top of the
house, it not being more than 30 feet high. And also
substantially the same as to the oil mill fire.
By A. M. Raines (pr. rec. 516): That at the oil
mill fire the pressure was so weak that in order for
witness to throw the water on the end of the stable,
which was adjoining said property, and it was not
more than fifteen feet high, witness was compelled
to put the end of his thumb over the nozzle so as to
make it squirt a small stream on said stable and
keep it from catching fire from the heat of the other
fires. That said property was on one of the principal
streets of the city. Witness was at the Parks fire, and
in order to prevent the building on the opposite side
of the street from catching fire it was necessary to go
on top of the veranda so as to be able to throw the
water from the hose on the roof of said building,
which was a one-story building not more than 20
feet high.
sy FE. L. Rainey (pr. rec. 516): That the stream at
the Grier fire in 1898 could not be thrown to the
top of a one-story frame house not more than 20 feet
high. That at the Parks fire the stream could not be
thrown more than 15 feet high; and that it was
necessary to get the water on top of the house, 24
feet high, to carry the nozzle to the place where
needed and let the water pour out.
By A. J. Carver (pr. ree. 517): That when the
Farnum house burned in 1898, he noticed that the
pressure from the hydrants of the waterworks com-
pany was very poor and inadequate at first, but that
tinted |
31
later the pressure was very much better. The cause of
this improvement witness is not able to state, as the
city’s fire engine was soon put in operation and the
water pumped from the cisterns of the city, as well
as from the hydrauts.
By Charles Deubler (pr. rec. 517): As to the Bald-
win & Company and Geise dry-kiln fire in 1896, that
the pressure was wholly insufficient to throw a stream
more than 25 feet high; that at the Variety Works
fire the pressure was lacking and the fire engine had
to be called into requisition to accomplish anything.
By J. R. Mercer (pr. rec. 517): That at the Parks
fire in 1899 the pressure from the hydrants was so
inadequate the holder of the nozzle had to get on
top of an adjacent building in order to get water
there, and that the water could not be thrown more
than 30 feet high.
By W. F. Locke (pr. ree. 517): That at the Whitch-
ard fire in June, 1897, the waterworks company’s
hydrants were insufficient to throw water 20 feet
away from the nozzle.
By F. E. Clark (pr. ree. 517): That he attended
the fire which burned the residence of Robert Smith
in Dawson in 1899, and that the pressure was not
sufficient to throw a stream over a chimney about
25 feet high at said fire.
By T. L. Guerry (pr. ree. 517): That he was at the
Bob Smith fire in May, 1899; that there were about
200 feet of hose attached to the hydrant, and there
Was not enough pressure to get the water on top of
a chimney 25 feet high.
By C. 1. Evarts (pr. ree. 517): That he attended
the fire which burned the residence of Mr. Hamilton,
September 20,1898, in Dawson: that 400 feet of
hose were used. Fire was within 400 feet of the
pumping station of the Dawson Waterworks Com-
pany, said county (Terrell), the hose being attached
toa plug of said company, and the water could not
be gotten from the nozzle to the top of the veranda,
12 feet high.
By W. E. Riordan (pr. ree. 517): That he was present
at the lumber kiln fire in Dawson in 1896, and that
the pressure of the water from the hydrants of the
ae
ia Race eieivelitiion, +.
tea?
The
waterworks company was not sufficient, during his
observation, to throw the water ten feet from the
nozzle.
Master ruled as follows (pr. ree 514, 517):
The question now under consideration is not the
effect of this evidence, but its relevancy to the extent
of making it admissible. Should the Master err in
excluding testimony, the result would be to put the
parties to additional expense, cost, and delay; and for
that reason I am liberal in my views, that is, I try to
be, as to the admissibility of the testimony. Never-
theless, if I am clear that testimony is not relevant,
and should not be admitted, I feel I should not
admit it.
Now the contract in this ease provides for the con-
struction of a system according to the specifications
given, and that there should be erected a reservoir of
a certain capacity, and of such a height as to afford a
pressure under the circumstances stated in the ordi-
nanee. As to the system, it is provided that the sys-
tem shall be thorough and complete and that a sup-
ply of water for the purposes stated shall be main-
tained. I think that imposed on the waterworks
company the duty of maintaining an efficient system
of keeping a sufficient supply of water on hand.
Now any evidence showing that this reservoir was
not of the required height would be entirely admis-
sible. Any evidence showing that under the test pro-
vided in this contract, or under conditions substan-
tially the same, showing that the contract was not
complied with, I think would be admissible. I shall
permit you to prove that the tank leaked. You may
introduce evidence to show, if you choose and can,
that the tank was not kept filled with water. You
may also introduce evidence to show, if you can,
under these conditions, or conditions substantially
like these, that the pressure was not sufficient to raise
the water 50 feet vertically, in still air. I shall per-
mit you to show that there was a total failure of
pressure for a greater or less length of time; and if
the failure is total, then there is no pressure.
— " > +s 2 INE EE A ain,
3 Sa “4
33
I hardly think we can go into the realm of specula-
tion as to what the pressure would be under condi-
tions which vary substantially and materially from
these laid down in the ordinance. In other words,
whether the water pressure was weak and continued
so for a short length of time under conditions that
surrounded the lumber kiln fire.
I hardly see how that illustrates the issue at all.
I will permit you to introduce evidence to show that
the company has not in any respect maintained its
system as it should have done. As I have admitted
evidence to show that there was a new tank made, I
will admit evidence showing that the tank leaked.
You may show that the pipes throughout the city
Were not properly maintained or flushed; and that
the source of supply has been allowed to be con-
taminated ; and that the service was improper. I
will permit all that; but I don’t think I should
permit evidence as to what occurred at particular
fires under conditions totally dissimilar from those
stated in the contract.
Mr. Guerry: Your Honor’s ruling, as I understand
it, I would like to show in the record, as invoked
upon the offer to prove certain facts, which I have
stated, by these particular witnesses, your Honor
rules I can not prove.
The Master: You stated that you expected to
prove?
Mr. Guerry: By way of illustration.
The Master: In conformity with my general ruling
I will exclude the evidence offered, unless it is pro-
posed to show in connection therewith that there was
a total failure of pressure, or that the surrounding
circumstances were substantially the same as those
laid down in the contract fora test. If you can
come up to these conditions you may proceed.
The city says that the rejection of the proposed evidence
Was a material error of law on a vital issue in the case, Viz:
whether the system of waterworks, as constructed and oper-
ated, came up to the requirements of the contract as to
pressure, the same being relevant and otherwise competent,
8310—3
wate are,
Pedic cst ott teriiewmncthatiien
ie
5
ih
os
am
a
2
Ey
*
bs
534
eA
4
¥
2
2
+s
ot
%
te
RIAN CLA Ee AES GAN ARAL RD APTI LS Ra? PRY IS BD
34
and the city insists upon a reopening of the case so that
this testimony may be heard, considered, and given due
effect, together with such other testimony of the same char-
acter as the witnesses would give upon re-examination in
connection with that already reported on the same issue.
92. In overruling the second exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 135):
The city says that the two principal issues of facts arising
under the law and actually made by the pleadings were (1)
whether the waterworks company had performed its con-
tract as to pressure, both in the construction of its system
and in its service, and (2) whether it had performed its con-
tract in the kind of water supplied, and that the Master
erred in failing and refusing to decide both of these ques-
tions.
93. In overruling the third exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 135):
The city submits that a material issue arising under the
law and actually made by the pleadings was whether the
water company performed its contract as to pressure, both
in construction of its system and in its service, and the
Master failed and refused to make any findings upon this
issue, and that by such failure and refusal he committed
an error of law.
24. In overruling the fourth exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 135):
The city submits that a material issue arising under the
law and actually made by the pleadings was whether the
waterworks company had performed its contract in the kind
of water supplied, and the Master failed and refused to
make any finding upon this issue, and that he by such fail-
ure and refusal committed an error of law.
25. In overruling the fifth exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 135):
That the Master erred in law in finding against the city,
and in recommending the relief as granted or any recovery
RAT RAE BUI ted eC ONT ale ORR REINER
by complainant, because the right to relief and recovery de-
pended upon the performance by the waterworks company
of its contract as to pressure, both in construction of its
system and in service, and upon performance of its contract
to supply water suitable for domestic, sanitary, and other
useful purposes, there being no finding by the Master that
the company had performed its contract in either particular,
he having failed and refused to find in favor of such
performance.
26. In overruling the sixth exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 136):
That the Master erred in finding and recommending that
an injunction be granted complainant against the city; that
the city pay the complainant the water rentals due and un-
paid from January 1, 1896, with interest, and that the city
be required to specifically perform the contract forming the
subject of the suit, when under the law and pleadings there
was no right of recovery or relief without performance by
the water company of its contract to continue during the
existence of the contract to furnish a sufficient supply of
water to produce such a pressure in the mains that from any
hydrant located on the principal streets a stream of water
would be projected 50 feet vertically in still air through 100
feet of fire hose, with one-inch nozzle attached, and to sup-
ply the city and its inhabitants with water suitable for do-
mestic, sanitary, and other useful purposes, the Master
having not found that said contract had been performed,
but having found, in effect, on the contrary, that the same
had not been performed in his findings of fact, as follows
(pr. rec. 90):
VIII.
“The source of water supply adopted by the water
company from among those designated by the city
consisted of a running stream, into which directly
flowed the water of what is known as Dunn’s Spring,
some four hundred yards above the take-in of the
oe |
2
ot
SMEDLEY RAO SRS
Ada Sem gee ING Ay
nee.
yea
. Sin iat cee
RO Oh Me NAST ROE RIDE GE ERIN TELE BAT PE Da 4 SANT NN
36
water company. These waters were among those
analyzed by the State chemist, and by him pro-
nounced safe and pure. The water shed does not
cover an extended area. The stream above flows
through land which is more or less marshy, and
upon which there is considerable vegetable growth.
The surface water from adjoining hills on one side
of the stream flows in above the point of supply.
On the crest of these hills are several small resi-
dences, the washings from whose premises flow into
the stream. There is also on the water shed a scaf-
fold, which has been used from time to time for the
slaughtering of cattle in a small way. The stream
from which the water supply is derived is not pro-
tected from these surface washings by means of dikes
or other devices. The condition of the water shed is
substantially the same now as it was at the time of
the selection and as it has been since. The evidence
does not disclose when the slaughtering of cattle
began, ot how extended it lias been. The water is
not filtered, but taken directly from the stream and
pumped to a stand pipe or reservoir in the city, from
which it is distributed by gravitation through mains
and pipes to consumers.
“T find from the evidence that at certain seasons
of the year the water is safe and pure, as shown by
the analysis of the State chemist; at other seasons,
during periods of continuous rainfall, the water is
muddy and must to some extent be contaminated
by reason of the surface washings from the water
shed as described. It was disclosed in the evidence
that an analysis of the water had been made at the
instance of the city or some of its citizens, but this
analysis was not offered in evidence, nor was any
expert evidence as to the quality of the water intro-
duced, excepting the analysis of the State chemist as
above referred to.
“The general assembly of the State of Georgia
passed an act, approved September 7, 1891, for the
protection of the water supply of the waterworks for
the city of Dawson. By this act it was made unlaw-
ful to obstruct or interfere with the flow of the
stream, or pollute or contaminate in any way or by
CANISTERS LSE TRC
37
any means the water of the stream or water shed, so
as to effect in any degree the quality or purity of the
water. It was made unlawful to place or deposit any
dead animal or vegetable matter in the swamp bor-
dering on and surrounding the stream, its springs
and branches, so as to effect the purity and quality
of the water. The violation of these provisions was
declared to be a misdemeanor. The police supervis-
ion of the marshal and policemen of the city of Daw-
son was extended over the water shed, and the
officers were empowered to make arrests therein for
violation of the provisions of the act. The ordinance
of the city of Dawson made it the duty of the mayor
to appoint three members of the council, whose duty
it should be to superintend the waterworks and
water supply of the city, and to see that the owners
of the waterworks company complied with their
obligations in furnishing water to said city and pri-
vate individuals (City Code, paragraph 242),
IX.
“The water company erected a reservoir exceeding
in capacity that required by the contract. The height
of this reservoir from its bottom to the surface of the
earth below was 65 feet. Upon a test by the city it
was ascertained and declared that the system met
with the requirements of the contract, and I there-
fore find that the reservoir was of the prescribed
height and capacity. Much evidence was introduced
and offered to show that sufficient pressure had not
constantly been maintained. It appears that on one
occasion the reservoir was found to be empty, but
this occurred shortly after the construction of the
waterworks and before the repudiation of the con-
tract by the city, and is therefore not material to be
considered in the present case. At times the reservoir
leaked. On one oceasion the local superintendent of
the water company tested the pressure from a point
on what is known as an end pipe. The water failed
to reach a height of fifty feet vertically. It was
shown that this test was a voluntary act of the local
superintendent without notice to the officers and
= ee a eee
ene Pred ie fe geet eS
3 ee ie Tiss ia
38
owners of the waterworks company or to the city.
Gauges indicating the height of the water in the
standpipe, and the consequent pressure, ‘were placed
at the pumping station of the water company and
also in the engine house of the city fire department.
Excepting on rare occasions the reservoir was kept
supplied with water sufficient to produce the required
pressure. No complaint concerning the character of
the service or the amount of the pressure was made
to the water company until after the institution of
the present suit. The water company has since
erected a new reservoir of more than double the
capacity required in the contract and of a greater
height than the first reservoir, Since the erection of
this new reservoir there has been no complaint or
question as to the pressure.”
27. In overruling the seventh exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. ree. 137):
That the Master erred in his first conclusion of law (pr.
rec. 94) in finding that the court had jurisdiction of the
cause on the ground that a Federal question was involved,
because such question depended upon the existence of an
exclusive franchise which did not exist.
28. In overruling the eighth exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 137):
That the Master erred in his first conclusion of law (pr.
rec. 94) in finding that there was equity in complainant's
bill, because there was no equity in said bill, and the com-
plainant had an adequate and complete remedy at law.
29. In overruling the ninth exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 138):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of iaw
(subd. 1, pr. ree. 95) in finding in favor of complainant upon
the question of res judicata raised in the city’s answer, the
city having pleaded that prior to the filing of said bill the
Supreme Court of Georgia, in the case of the Dawson Water-
works Company vs. the City of Dawson, had adjudged the
contract sued on in said bill to be void ab initio, and that
Ne NOSE A pe SE RG RE NS RITA NO NEN
39
complainant was mere privy and assignee of the cause of
action involved in the decision of said Supreme Court and
had become such since said decision wes rendered, and that
all the issues made by said bill were res judicata as to com-
plainant as well as to the water company, the facts so
pleaded having been duly proved.
30. In overruling the tenth exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 138):
That the Master erred in his said second conclusion of
law (subd. 1, pr. rec. 95) in finding that complainant was
not a privy of the waterworks company as to the suit in the
said court so as to be conclusively bound thereby, and that
the doctrine of res judicata did not apply to it, notwith-
standing, and in face of the fact, that it appeared from the
pleadings that complainant had become assignee of the
cause of action subsequent to the rendition of the decision
of the State Supreme Court.
31. In overruling the eleventh exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 138):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 2, pr. rec. 96) in finding that the contract sued on
was valid, notwithstanding the Supreme Court of Georgia
had repeatedly held that such contracts were void, and in
holding that the Federal court was not bound to follow the
decision of the Supreme Court of said State as to the valid-
ity of the contract in question, because the city says that
under the law of the United States and the decisions of the
Supreme Court of the United States, it was the bounden
duty of the Federal court to follow the decision of the Su-
preme Court of the State, rendered in construing the consti-
tution of the State, and the contract made in said State and
governed by its constitution and laws, because it appeared
from the decisions of the Supreme Court of Georgia that
said court had never made any decision contrary to its de-
cision in the case of the Dawson Waterworks Company vs,
the City of Dawson.
—
/
:
:
$
4
NR SSE LY
40
32. In overruling the twelfth exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 138) :
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 3, pr. rec. 103) in finding that the contract in ques-
tion did not create a debt within the meaning of the Georgia
constitution, because prior to the filing of the bill the Su-
preme Court of Georgia had decided in numerous cases that
such contracts did incur such debts.
33. Inoverruling the thirteenth exception of law, which was
as follows (pr. ree, 189):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 4, pr. rec. 106) in finding that the water company had
an exclusive franchise to occupy the streets and maintain a
water system in said city by virtue of said contract, because,
under the laws of Georgia, no such franchise could be
granted by the city, no such power having been delegated
to it by charter or otherwise.
34. In overruling the fourteenth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. ree. 139):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 4, pr. ree. 106) in finding that the city after making
the contract had no right to establish and maintain a water
system of its own, or use the strects of the city, in competi-
tion with the water company during the life of said con-
tract, because the city says that such construction of the
contract made the same the grant of an exclusive franchise
by the city to the water company, which grant the city had
no power to make, from its charter or otherwise, and because
that if the city had no power to make such a grant it had
no power to estop itself from denying that it had made the
same.
35. In overruling the fifteenth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec, 139):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd, 5, pr. rec. 107) in finding that there was no require-
ment in the contract that the quality of water should be
6 ON he RE RENE eciehihinienieiee ..)
41
other than that taken in its natural state from the source
of supply designated and accepted by the city, because the
city says that the contract required the water supply to be
suitable for domestic, sanitary, and other useful purposes,
and it was the duty of the water company, under the con-
tract, to supply such water. The city submits that to test
the water at a time when it was suitable for the objects re-
quired, and afterwards allow it to become otherwise, and to
supply it to the citizens when wholly unfit simply because
it had been accepted when fit, would not only be a violation
of the contract, but a gross fraud upon the citizens and the
city,
36. In overruling the sixteenth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. ree. 140):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 5, pr. ree. 108) in finding that the city could not in-
voke a forfeiture or plead that the water supplied was not
lit for domestic, sanitary, or other useful purposes, as a de-
fense to the right of complainant to relief, because the city
says that before the complainant ean rightfully recover,
the water company must have performed its contract in
this particular, and have proved such performance, since
complainant’s right of recovery and relief is based by the
bill upon the alleged performance by the company, which
was denied by the city.
37. In overruling the seventeenth exception of law, which
Was as follows (pr. rec. 140):
That the Master erred in his seeond conclusion of law
(subd. 8, pr. ree. 110) in finding that complainant was en-
titled to an injunetion forbidding the city to construct or
maintain waterworks of its own in competition with those
of the company, because such injunction could issue only
upon the ground that the water company had an exclusive
franchise to the streets of said city for such purpose, when
such franchise coild not lawfully exist in the State of
Georgia.
2
~
8
“|
“eG
oy
%
+
| AE tN
38. In overruling the eighteenth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 140):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 8, pr. rec. 110) in finding that complainant was en-
titled to a mandatory injunction requiring the city and the
water company to specifically perform the contract as es-
sential to the protection of the security for the bonds, be-
cause the city says (1) that said contract is void ; (2) that
prior to the filing of the bill the Supreme Court of Georgia
had declared the same to be void, and (3) that the com-
plainant is bound by the decision of said court as privy,
it being shown by the proof and found by the Master that
its right to sue was acquired subsequent to the rendition of
said decision.
39. In overruling the nineteenth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. ree. 141):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 8, pr. rec. 110) in finding that the city and the water
company should be required to specifically perform said
contract because the same was not of such nature as to
justify the remedy of specific performance, as the justice of
performance on the city’s part would depend upon previous
performance on the part of the water company, which pre-
vious performance can not be assumed in advance as the
basis of a decree for specific performance.
40. In overruling the twentieth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 141):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 8, pr. ree. 110) in finding that complainant was en-
titled to a mandatory injunction against the city and the
water company requiring specific performance of the con-
tract as essential to the protection of the security for the
bonds, because there is no law of specific performance which
provides that the two opposite parties to a contract may be
required in advance to perform such contract for the bene-
fit of a third person having no obligation thereunder.
43
41. In overruling the twenty-first exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 141):
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 8, pr. rec. 110) in finding that it should be required
to pay complainant the rentals stipulated in the contract,
because under the constitution and laws of Georgia, under
which the city exists as a municipality, the contract was
void and was so declared by the Supreme Court of the
State, and the officials of the city would have no right to
make such payments, as it would be a misappropriation of
the funds of the city, and in violation by such officials of
their oaths of office.
42. In overruling the twenty-second exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. ree. 141) :
That the Master erred in his second conclusion of law
(subd. 8, pr. ree. 110) in finding that the complainant was
entitled to a decree requiring the city and the water
company to specifically perform the contract between them,
because the law of specific performance is not applicable to
such a contract, and the remedy is not appropriate in such
a case.
43. In overruling the twenty-third exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. rec. 141):
That the Master erred in his first general conclusion (pr.
rec. 113) in finding that the objection to the jurisdiction
was not well founded, inasmuch as the jurisdiction rested
upon the Federal question presented, without regard to the
citizenship of the parties, because the city says that the
alleged Federal question depended upon the existence of
an exclusive franchise, which did not and could not exist
under the laws of Georgia, and that there was no inter-
ference threatened as to the franchise of the water company
in so faras it lawfully existed.
44. In overruling the twenty-fourth exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. rec. 142):
That the Master erred in his second general conclusion (pr.
|
wa
$
BS
* 4
ht Se RABE IRE Oe
2 aerate
ip ina haa Ainktc elas wo aA.
ASSN
Ne wire ats x
ye er
“ ura.
2
5
44
rec. 113), in finding that the doctrine of res judicata was not
applicable to the complainant, for the reason that the com-
plainant was not privy to the State court suit, because the
city says that under the law the complainant was such
privy, and the water company, as shown by the proof and
found by the Master, was payee of the water rentals, in ex-
clusive control of the contract and of the right to collect the
rentals up to and after the rendition of the decision of the
Supreme Court of the State, the complainant having be-
come assignee of the right to collect the rentals.
45. In overruling the twenty-fifth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 142):
That the Master erred in his third general conclusion
(pr. rec. 113), in finding that this court was under no obli-
gation to follow the decision of the highest court of the
State, rendered after the contract had been entered into, and
in finding that the decisions of the State court on the ques-
tion involved were not so long and firmly established as to
constitute a rule of property, and that this court will decide
independently whether there was a contract, the obligation
of which has been impaired.
46. In overruling the twenty-sixth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 142):
That the Master erred in his fourth general conclusion
(pr. rec. 113) in finding that the contract did not create a
debt within the meaning of the constitution and laws of
Georgia, but that such contract was valid and enforceable,
because the city says that such finding is an erroneous con-
struction of said constitution and laws, and in violation
thereof, as construed in decisions by the highest court in the
State. The city further says that the finding of the Master
is contrary to his ruling upon the main issues in the case,
namely: That the plaintiff had the right to recover such
debt without performance and without proof of performance,
and in the teeth of its own decision that there had not been
performance on the part of the water company so as to
ide BRL RE a PORTO ee RO. ONAL ne
45
entitle it or the complainant to recover rentals on the ground
that the same had been earned by performance.
47. In overruling the twenty-seventh exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. rec. 143) :
That the Master erred in his fifth general conclusion (pr.
rec. 113) in finding that the so-called exclusive franchise
granted by the city can not be revoked by the city in its
own interest, and that its value could not be impaired by
competition on the part of the city itself within the term
of twenty years during which the city had obligated itself
to take and pay for the water for fire protection, because
there was no exclusive franchise and there was no attempt
or intention on the part of the city to revoke any franchise
held by the water company.
48. In overruling the twenty-eighth exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. ree. 143):
That the Master erred in his sixth general conclusion (pr.
rec. 113) in finding that the city could not, under the facts
of the case, forfeit the rights and franchises of the water
company for insufficient service or for failure to supply
water of a higher quality of purity, or plead such facts in
bar of the equitable relief sought, because the city says that
there had been no attempt on its part to forfeit any rights
or franchises of the water company on any ground whatso-
ever, and that no such attempt of forfeiture was alleged in
the bill except as to the exclusive franchise which did not
exist, and because the contract required water suitable for
domestic, sanitary, and other useful purposes, and the city
had the right to plead the failure of the water company to
supply such water.
49. In overruling the twenty-ninth exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. rec. 143):
That the Master erred in his first reeommendation (pr.
rec. 114) that the contract in question be declared to be
valid, binding, and enforcible.
Papen
46
50. In overruling the thirtieth exception of ‘law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 143) :
That the Master erred in his second recommendation (pr.
rec. 114) that an injunction be granted prohibiting the city
from negotiating or disposing of bonds authorized to be
used in the construction of a water system, and from con-
structing or operating any system of waterworks in the city
for the purpose of supplying either the city or the inhab-
itants with water for fire protection or domestic use, because,
under the constitution and laws of Georgia, it is not only its
right but its duty to do so, since it appears in effect, as found
by the Master, that the city and its inhabitants are not be-
ing sufficiently supplied with water suitable for the purposes
of the contract.
51. In overruling the thirty-first exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. ree. 144):
That the Master erred in his third recommendation (pr. rec.
114) that the city be enjoined from revoking or attempting
to revoke the rights and franchises granted to the water
company under the contract during the term of twenty
years it contracted to pay for water, because it was not
alleged and did not appear that the city had revoked or
attempted to revoke any rights or franchises of the com-
pany under the contract during said term.
52. In overruling the thirty-second exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. ree. 144):
That the Master erred in his fourth recommendation
(pr. rec. 114) that the city shall pay to complainant all
water rentals accruing from January 1, 1896, because the
contract for the payment of said rentals is null and void,
and further that proof of performance of the contract by
the company would, at least, be prerequisite to any right-
ful recovery of such rentals, and the Master found in
effect that there had been no such performance.
53. In overruling the thirty-third exception of law
which was as follows (pr. rec. 144):
SPP BNE Lee . PGA PLN
47
That the Master erred in his fifth recommendation (pr.
rec. 114) to the effect that the collection of taxes due the
city should await an accounting to ascertain what might be
due the water company for such water as may have been
used by the city itself, because the taxes being due, and so
held, the court had no authority to arrest the process of col-
lection thereof, for the reason stated by the Master.
54. In overruling the thirty-fourth exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. rec. 144):
That the Master erred in his sixth recommendation (pr.
rec. 114) that the city and water company be required to
specifically perform the contract, because that if said com-
pany was performing its contract, as alleged, there was no
ground for a decree for specific performance, and if the
water company was not performing its contract, the com-
plainant had no right to recover water rentals, the contract
not being one which can be specifically enforced under the
law, and the practice of the United States courts, since per-
formance on the part of the city would be necessarily de-
pendent upon performance on the part of the company, and
no court would have right to assume in advance that the
water company would be able and would perform its con-
tract with the city.
55. In overruling the thirty-fifth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. ree. 145):
After being served by the Master with the draft of his
report, the city appeared and made the following suggestion :
That the Master had omitted a material fact proved by
one of the witnesses of complainant, viz. F. A. Ruggles,
as follows (pr. ree. 334):
That he (witness) removed the timber of the old tank
when it was torn down (since the filing of the bill) in
order to construct a new one; that there was at that time
in the bottom of the old tank four inches (in depth) of
foul and muddy sediment.
Witness had testified to this fact, and inasmuch as he
Neate cast et amon Se
reel
%
4
tae ei de
ON Se Me ad Nae
Mot Ate WEA E
ata Re Bs RUM bos
‘a
guns
48
was introduced by the complainant and his testimony was
undisputed, it established a fact of vital importance as
showing one of the causes for contamination of the water
supply, and as a fact disproving the contention of complain-
ant that the water company had, up to that date, performed
its contract in supplying the right kind of water to the citi-
zens of Dawson. The Master admitted the truth of the alle-
gations of the city upon this point, refusing the suggestion
on the ground that his report should not be burdened with
statement of evidence, but should be confined to the find-
ings of the ultimate facts.
The city charges that the Master erred in not making
such report and finding originally, and in not doing so in
compliance with its suggestion, because the testimony was
too brief to be burdensome, and coming from an uncontra-
dicted witness of complainant, it established a vital and ul-
timate fact, viz: That the water supplied from the old tank
was not suitable for domestic, sanitary, and other useful
purposes, as required by the contract.
56. In overruling the thirty-sixth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 146):
The city submitted as a suggestion of change in the orig-
inal draft of the Master’s report, that James H. Daws, super-
intendent of the waterworks, a witness for complainant, tes-
tified as follows (pr. ree. 357):
The Dawson Waterworks Company had charge of
the original litigation and all these demands against
the city of Dawson for water rentals up to the de-
cision of the Supreme Court of Georgia, already re-
ferred to.
As this testimony was from one of complainant’s wit-
nesses, and as it was undisputed, it established a material
fact which should have been reported to the court. The
Master refused the suggestion on the ground that the testi-
mony would be burdensome and the finding would not be
of an ultimate fact.
MAGA cilia Rs AP RV oe aS CARS RANA MATE Ae Tal) OL Ca’? CRIES» VERANO eae sar
The city says that the Master erred, because the testimony
established the fact that the water company had charge of
all demands for water rentals, and the original litigation for
sume, up to the date of the decision of the Supreme Court
of Georgia, already referred to, and complainant, as privy,
was therefore concluded as to all’such demands based upon
an assignment made subsequent to the date of said decision.
57. In overruling the thirty-seventh exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. rec. 146):
The city made the following suggestion of change in the
Master’s report, viz: that J. A. Horsley, superintendent of
tle waterworks and witness for complainant, testified as fol-
lows (pr. rec. 368 ) :
My recollection is during the year 1900, and may
be 1899 and 1900, during the very driest season, the
pressure went down three or four times. It was run
down so there was no pressure. Several times early
in the morning it would not run out of the hydrant.
Was this way I suppose two or three times.
This testimony being from complainant’s witness and not
contradicted, established a material fact relevant. to the
question raised by the pleadings as to whether the water
company had complied with its contract as to pressure.
The city charges that the constant existence of the re-
quired minimum pressure was vital and the very essence of
the contract, and the failure of such pressure as shown by
this witness, without sufficient excuse, violated the contract
and destroyed the right of recovery, and that the Master
erred in refusing to change his report as suggested.
8. In overruling the thirty-eighth exception of law,
which was as follows (pr. ree. 147):
The city submitted a suggestion of change in the Master’s
report, namely, that J. A. Horsley, witness of complainant,
testified as follows (pr. ree. 372):
Occasionally they (the pecple) would tell me in
effect that the water was muddy and unfit for use
8310—4
waren
om
4
‘3
x6
a
eat y
See ati aE Ee et
Hy PMG eK PEew.S wv
ME Bee au htia Ae eae ce
gt lel tee
Care
WT IM ad SHR OO BG
50
and smelled badly, and the pressure was insufficient,
for instance on these water ends, and asked me to
flush that main so that the water would clear up, and
I would do it. They said the water was muddy,
Once or twice they would tell me about its being
muddy somewhat, smelling badly. During that time
I remember complaints made several times about the
pressure. My recollection about the first complaint
was made during the Whitchard and Green fires in
1897. I have seen buzzards up there (on the tank)
in the day.
Inasmuch as this testimony was from complainant’s wit-
ness and undisputed, the facts testified to became established
and were vitally material. This evidence brought home full
notice of complaints to the water company, both as to
pressure and unsuitability of the water, the testimony of this
complainant’s witness being in direct contradiction to the
allegations of no notice contained in complainant’s bill.
It is charged that the testimony established ultimate and
controlling facts, and that the Master erred in refusing the
city’s suggestion.
59. In overruling the thirty-ninth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. ree. 148):
The city suggested to the Master that the two principal
issues of fact were (1) whether the water company had per-
formed its contract as to pressure, both in the proper con-
struction of its system and in its service, and (2) whether it
had performed its contract in the kind of water supplied,
and that the Master should change his report as to find in
the negative on both propositions.
The city says that the Master erred in refusing its sugges-
tion, because his own report, in finding of facts numbers
8 and 9, shows that he had in effect reached such conclu-
sion.
60. In overruling the fortieth exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. rec. 148):
That the Master erred in finding and recommending any
ld a die a aaa PALI Y TAN VMN A, 9 2 Wve POLL LLG EEL BIE OLY LITE ANIM i
. ta
51
recovery or relief in favor of the complainant, because
under the law, pleadings, and facts as found by the Master
himsclf, there was no right of recovery or relief, and the
city submitted that the Master misconstrued the contract
and misconceived the issues made by the law and plead-
ings, Which were whether the water company had performed
its contract by keeping up the required pressure, and by
furnishing the citizens with the proper kind of water, and
that before complainant had any right of recovery it was
incumbent upon it to prove that the water company had
performed its contract in both of these particulars during
each period of time for which complainant sued to recover,
and during the entire time in order to entitle it to injune-
tion or to any decree for specifie performance. The Master
made no formal findings upon either of these issues, but
his findings of fact numbers 8 and 9 clearly negatived the
proposition that the water company had performed its con-
tract In every particular.
61. In overruling the forty-first exception of law, which
was as follows (pr. ree. 150):
That the Master erred in law in recommending and find-
ing asa matter of law that the city should pay the com-
plainant the sum of the water rentals accruing since January
1, 1896, because the city says that the Master made no
finding of fact to this effect or upon which could be justified
such a recommendation or finding of law.
62. In overruling the first exception of fact, which was
as follows (pr. ree. 150):
That the master erred in his sixth finding of fact (pr. ree.
"0), viz: That no other means for fire protection was af-
forded by the city (than that ofthe water company), so that
it must have been recognized that in any emergency of fire
resert_ to the use of the water of the water company was
necessary and inevitable, and that the city did not forbid
the use of this water for its fire department and must have
known that it was being continuously so used, because the
0 ae Se REESE SS
52
city says that the evidence showed that the city had other
means ‘for fire protection, viz, the same it had before the
waterworks were constructed ; that the city did forbid the
use of the water by the fire department, and it notified the
company through its superintendent that the contract was
atan end,
In support of this exception the city refers to the contrary
findings in the same finding of the Master, that the city on
December 14, 1894, notified the water company that unless
a new agreement could be reached for the use of the water
after January 1, 1895, the city would not be liable under
the contract after that date. In further support of this
exception the city also refers to the following testimony (pr.
rec. 504):
By A. J. Baldwin, mayor: T was mayor of Dawson
in 1894-95-96; remember the action of the mayor
and council relative to the abandonment of the con-
tract with the waterworks company in August, 1894.
After that I wrote the waterworks company at the
request of the council, in December, giving the com-
pany notice of the action of the city. The letter is the
one that is in evidence. I gave notice to Mr. Hors-
lev, the superintendent, the latter part of 1894, or
early in January, | think in 1894, that the city
would not be bound for water any more. I also noti-
fied Bill Patterson, the colored firenvan, and R. A.
Bishop, foreman of the Mechanies’ Fire Company.
When I notified Horsley IT told him in substance
about the letter I wrote that the city was not bound
for the water any longer; that we were not going to
carry out the contract made by the former council.
We did not consider it binding; that the council had
repudiated the contract. [told him council would not
be liable for any water. (For letter of Baldwin. re-
ferred to, see rep. of evidence, p. 329.) The city had
same volunteer fire company after January 1, 1895,
it had before. City didn’t exercise authority over fire
company 1895-96-97-98-99, but gave tax exemp-
tions. It was necessary to have fire company to oper-
ate the engine and chemical engine we had even if
* water , CNEIO ED BYES SUNIL Rare NIN Yea
Oy oe
3
there was no waterworks. We had a supply of water
independent of the waterworks, in six cisterns in the
streets. ‘The city gave no direction to firemen or fire
organizations during the years named to use water of
the company; never gave them any authority to use
it; they knew the contract had been abandoned by
my having notified the parties. They had no au-
thority so far as the city was concerned, during these
years, to use the water of the water company. If the
city gave any direction for them to use it | never knew
it. The mayor gave no such direction or permission.
After 94 I never did, and never empowered anyone
else to do so. | was mayor in 1895. Was at bakery
fire. The people used the company’s water there, My
recollection is that I took hold of the hose then as T
have at all fires. I do not think that I handled the
nozzle. I didn’t assist as mayor any more than I did
when I was not an official. | helped use some of the
water. Even now if I go to fires and see it is neces-
sary I take hold. I did at any time during 1895-96-
97. I was mayor during these three years. I always
took an active part; helped to use the hose. I did
take hold of the nozzle if I could use it. If Mr. Horse
ley ever notified me that they expected the city of
Dawson to pay for the water, I don’t recollect it.
By Dr. J. G. Dean (pr. rece. 537); Member of council
since 1894 to present time. During this time have
seen water used by any and everybody ; saw people
to whom city had given exemptions use water just
as individuals; was present and saw it: think other
members of the council were present and saw it.
Never forbid them from using it, strictly, so far as I
know ; used the apparatus kept in the building be-
longing to the city, which were returned after the
fire; returned by those who hod exemptions and
others, Bought new hose 95 and °96. Had the same
arrangements after January, 95, we had before. Fire
engine not used except ina few of the fires; not over
two or three.
By R. L. Melton (pr. rec. 570): In 1894-5 was
alderman and chairman of fire committee which had
especial jurisdiction over fire department. Remember
Bioware pee eo Oy Se
Lea LY ne . =
54
action of council in 1894 in renunciation of water
company’s contract, Soon after that had two cisterns
pumped full of water and Roberts overhaul engine,
This was about the first of 1895, The fire company
had a row about that time and went to picces,
Bishop managed one of the fire companies at the
variety works. I notified him we had nothing more
to do with the city waterworks and must have noth-
ing more to do with the hose. The city waterworks
attached their hose to the variety works. I told Mr.
Roberts we had no contract with the waterworks
company and he could not use their water any more.
By John Seay (pr. rec. 576): From ’94 to 98 | was
chief of police, this city. The organization of the fire
department was very poor, I thought. I was mem-
ber of the fire company. The paid fire department
was organized about 1899. Up to this time, during
those years, most everybody in general that got there
first did the work of putting out the fires. It was the
work not of any particular organization, but gener-
ally of the crowd that assembled. I always tried to
get there. I remember one time taking the reel over
to Dr. Dean’s; don’t think there was a man that be-
longed to the fire company there except Robert
Baldwin. He helped pull it over there. ‘There were
sixteen in squad. We were the only two firemen in
it: and two negroes helped us, not members.
Chas. Deubler (pr. rec. 619): Resident sinee 73.
Have been in council off and on ever since have
been here. Have been chairman of the fire commit-
tee, engineer, etc. Engineer ever since they got an
engine, except one or two years I quit. I have had
experience in dealing with water for fire plugs and
engines, hose and nozzle, for the purpose of extin-
guishing fires ever since I have been here. 1 think
since they bought the engine in ‘85; somewhere
along that time. Since then have been familiar with
the different kinds of apparatus the city owned for
fire purposes, which consisted first of a chemical en-
gine, 120 gallons, hose reels, steam fire engine, two
reels. During those years they kept from 600 to
1500 feet of hose. One reel carried the other 400.
The nozzles run from half an inch to an inch.
bay be 20et kaerer 70m | eae eerie,
:
;
ae |
wt
63. In overruling the second exception of fact, which was
as follows (pr. ree, 153):
That the Master erred in his sixth finding of fact (pr. ree.
90), viz, in finding that notwithstanding the city had re-
pudiated the contract it continued to enjoy the fire protec-
tion afforded by the water company and to use the water
for that purpose, in the same manner and to the same ex-
tent that it did prior to its repudiation of the contract,
because the proof showed not only a renunciation of the
contract by the city but the abandonment of the water sys-
tem and the means it afforded for the extinguishment of
fires, and that the use thereafter of the water of the com-
pany was by the people, indiscriminate, including the
officials of the city, who were not acting in official capacity
or from any authority of the city. In support of this ex-
ception the city refers to the brief of evidence contained in
the preceding exception of fact.
64. In overruling the third exception of fact, which was
as follows (pr. ree. 158):
That the Master erred in his eighth finding (pr. ree. 90)
of fact, (1) in making a partial report only of the facts ; (2)
in finding that the condition of the waterworks was sub-
stantially the same as it was at the time of selection, because
the evidence showed that the scaffold and slaughter pen
was begun and maintained after the selection of the source
of water supply; (3) in not finding the causes of contamina-
tion as shown by the undisputed evidence; (4)in not finding
that the causes of contamination, viz, the slaughter of
cattle, leavings of offal, drainage from surface closets, were
without the limits and jurisdiction of the municipality ; (5)
in not finding that the water company had failed after full
notice of the causes of contamination to protect the water
supply, and (6) in not finding from the undisputed evidence
that beeause of such contamination, the water furnished to
the citizens of Dawson was so muddy, filthy, and offensive
. TT ee
56
to the smell as to be unfit to drink or to use in cooking,
washing, or bathing.
In support of this exception the city submits in sub-
stance of the following testimony :
By John Seay (pr. rec. 585): Was marshal of city
1897, '98, 99 ; during that time complaint was made
to me about something stinking at the branch at the
source of the waterworks. Mr. J. A. Horseley, super-
intendent of the waterworks, and I went up there
and in about fifty yards of the mouth of the inlet
pipe where they got their water from, in the stream
that runs into the inlet pipe, there was a dead horse,
His rump was in the water. He was in a very bad
fix; he was rotten. When we pulled him out, the
hide and stuff. I don’t remember whether he saw the
horse pulled out or not. I think he made the negro
do it. I think the complaint was made by somebody
and Mr. Horsley went up there hunting for it; did
not know at the time it was up there. I don’t think
Mr. Horsley knew it was there until that day he
went up and hunted for it. The complaint was prob-
ably made to Horsley, and me and Mr. Horsley
went up there together. I don’t know that I knew
it my duty to protect the water supply. I knew it
my duty to move it as soon as I found it there. It
was out of the city limits, probably forty or fifty
feet.
By J. W. F. Lowry (pr. rec. 592): Am mayor of
Dawson. I know location of waterworks company’s
i
a
x
3
>
“—
plant and = surroundings; have seen source of
x water supply and arrangement by which con-
4 ducted; where it is appropriated by the com-
4 pany; have examined all the premises up to as far
‘ asa spring is designated from which water was to
; be used to supply the town; Dunn’s Spring. The
3 branch extends a great way beyond that. The land
a through which this branch flows and in which the
i springs are located, above the waterworks company,
: is a dark, murky, muddy swamp; and the contami-
3 nation of the land, especially on the west side, is
4 situated so that all the washings from six to eight
j residences and the other houses are necessarily
i
is a
LE IAL ANE PSE AAR SDL I Pw Ss OE OPORTO RE GF
57
thrown into this branch. That drainage is now
contaminated by the surface washings from privies,
horse lots, and the butcher pens. The driftings from
these places ali run into this branch. The whole
swamp is very largely covered with vegetable mat-
ter, especially above Dunn’s Spring. Nothing what-
ever has been done by the waterworks company to
protect this spring or their outlets or this branch
above the mouth of the inlet pipe which leads into
their waterworks; and as nothing in the way of pro-
tection to prevent the flowing of the surface waters
from these settlements I have spoken of along the
whole side on the west, into these springs and other
branches and the main branch above the inlet pipe,
it is an absolute fact that all this water does flow
into that place. I have had in my family as much
experience with this water of the company as it is
possible for my family to have, I suppose ; have had
the waterin my house and yard since the beginning.
The water has varied. In dry weather the water is
clear and apparently fit for use, and but for the fact
that we know the contaminated sources from which
it came, we might use it for drinking purposes. I
have never used it for that purpose because of the
source from which it is brought. Sometimes it is
very nice for bathing and sometimes it is wholly
unfit for bathing. It is permeated with mud as red
as mud can make water by flowing into it; I could
not tell what proportion of time. I know this—we
have not had any rain here of any consequence in
eight or ten days, and the water has not cleared up
from it yet. I have tried to use the water for
bathing purposes; generally use it in bath tubs,
I have on several occasions filled the bath tub
with water and it was so bad I could not use it;
let it out again. Used it almost every week for
bathing purposes. It is very objectionable, still we
have no other source from which we get bathing
water. It is not at all fit, I think, for laundry pur-
poses; never heard of anybody using it for that.
Hardly fit for cooking purposes; still we used it for
that; boiled it; by that means we hope to destroy
the germs, disease-producing germs, that might be
maar seoREr NN iim %
ah ity 5
ah secu
3
i
.
¥
a
2
3
+
z
3
x
te
=
:
a
a)
4
Ni]
eS)
2
=
4
4
v
K
3
8
5
Nea
s
*
+
8
a
:
q
3
x
~
;
;
FE
$
58
in it. We used it for that because it is so inconvenient
to get other water. Some have built an artesian well
in our neighborhood because of the fact that it is
unfit for use for drinking. The neighbors joined in
and dug an artesian well. This has been done by
two or three others in town that I know of; maybe
three.
By A. M. Raines (pr. ree. 605): I know Adams’
butcher pen testified about. It is located 200 yards,
to the best of my judgment, above the inlet pipe they
got their water from. ‘The drainage from this butcher
pen flows into the branch the water company gets
its water supply from. This butcher pen has been
used almost continuously for the last three or four
years. The cattle that are butchered are kept right
there. The offal is thrown down there on the ground,
from where the drainage goes into the branch that
the water company get their supply from. The
butcher pen is for the public market. I have a farm
beyond this butcher pen and I go backward
and forward to that farm and have seen beeves
butchered there on various occasions. I have used
the water of the company since 1898. It has been
very muddy and filthy at various times. Sometimes
it would stink. We have never drank the water at
all; have been afraid to drink it. We tote water from
the artesian well to drink; cook with this water
sometimes. The time it got to stinking so bad we
quit using it for drinking purposes. Where this
butcher pen is located is on the private property of
Mr. Adams and outside of the city limits.
By R. J. Sewn, (pr. ree. 608): Am a butcher.
Butchered out here at Mr. Adams four months year
before last; know where waterworks station is; the
butcher pen is on the hill about 300 yards above
the station. Year before last during four months I
butchered out there, sometimes three cows a day,
sometimes one every day; left the offal there; hogs
got some of it; don’t know what went with balance;
suppose the buzzards got it; saw buzzards there. By
offal I mean the entrails of animals and contents.
Don’t know of any occasion when the offal was taken
away. The surface water from there went into the
see eS Bu SS TEE NEP ORS ater 2st y & ene
59
branch that supplied the waterworks. I have seen
cows butchered there this year since Christmas.
Some days I wouldn’t kill any cattle out there at
all; some days would kill one; some days four or
five; three or four. Didn’t keep the place clean; offal
left there on the ground; Adams had hogs there;
they had access; Adams’ house about 300 yards.
By R. F. Simmons, (pr. rec. 601): Know pump-
ing station waterworks company and where they get
the water from; know the creek well; know
there is a butcher pen two or three hundred yards
above, northwest; above waterworks station two or
three hundred yards. I don’t know any way the
water could go from there except towards the creek;
I know the butcher pen has been used; have seen
them butchering several times; they throw the offal
to the hogs; have seen them eating it; that butcher
pen has been there two or three years, maybe more;
Adams kept the market here in town and supplied
the town to some extent. I think the butchering
has been going on there two or three years.
By W. F. Locke (pr. ree. 614): Have been using
water of the waterworks company seven or eight
years. Used it possibly two weeks for drinking pur-
poses two or three years ago. Later I got the boy to
bring us water from the pump in the business part
of the town. Bought a filter and used the water of
the waterworks company for ten days or two weeks,
and quit using it on account of the filth that had
accumulated in the filter. At times the water is
muddy and unfit for use. On one or two occasions
odor was so bad would not use it for drinking pur-
poses but had water brought from well; that was
about four years ago; think I have used the water
since 1894. Have not noticed any offensive odor for
the past year or two. I noticed once or twice the
first year I moved around where I am now living.
I detected offensive odor more than once or twice.
Two occasions I refused to bathe in the water be-
sause of the offensive odor; possibly noticed it four
or five times; don’t think that was when the water
ras very muddy; don’t remember whether the water
was very low; don’t know what caused the offensive
Pe ee eee ee
a sea
R
f.
‘
z
“
2
*
3
4
*
4
a
“9
rs
i enitteckeniin eb icticinn
eee eee ata Ae eT
60
odor, but don’t think it was mud; never used it for
drinking purposes except the two weeks that I
spoke of.
By Walter Christy (pr. rec. 616): Living here about
twelve years; know property of waterworks com-
pany; well acquainted with the surroundings, and
the creek and spring up there; I lived out there at
my grandmother’s a year, "90 or °91; since then
have visited up there frequently, constantly. There
are some houses on the hillside on the west, and a
butcher’s pen about 150 yards from the stream up
there that supplied the waterworks. Mr. Adams did
the butchering there for two or three years back. I
understand he used it in December of last year. He
used it for butchering cattle; I have been there and
seen him butchering a good many times; I suppose
thirty or forty times during the last two years.
Offal and excrement from the cattle is left on the
ground for the hogs; don’t know that they always
consumed it. In case of rain the surface water from
where the offal was thrown, where this butcher pen
is located, goes into this branch from which the
pumping station gets their water. No other source
for it to go to. Don’t know whether they are using
the butcher pen now or not; have not been there
since February or March. Sometimes there would
be more offal than at others; sometimes two cattle;
that is as much as I have seen at one time. Have
seen offal there when fresh and when it had been
there for some time; about one hundred yards from
the creek; never measured it. I know it is on the
hillside, and there is no other way for the water to
go except into that stream. Where the cattle is
butchered there is a slope toward the branch. The
ditch goes from the pond into the creek. From the
butcher pen it does not drain into the pond. The
pond is back in another direction. The pond is dry
most of the time. The ditch from the pond runs into
the branch.
By Dr. L. C. Goneke (pr. rec. 639): Practicing phy-
sician eighteen years; lived in Dawson twelve years.
Have been using the water of the waterworks com-
pany ever since but until last two months. Drank it
PORES A, AIRES RR WT RIES « a NOES ah POA
61
for a short while; used it after that for irrigating
garden, yard, and for bath tub, kitchen, watering
stock, etc.; could not use it as drinking water;
caused indigestion. Wife and I quit using it on that
account. Used it for bathing purposes. At times it
would not be used at all. Entirely too muddy and
had an offensive odor. Quite a number of times this
was the case during my experience with it after rains.
I attributed it to the effect of rain on the water. Pe-
culiar offensive odor when I turned it on in bath
tub; didn’t use it at all; impossible to say how many
times; quite a number in my experience. About as
definite as I can be, I suppose about six or eight times
in one month and once in two or three months. I
attributed it to the rains. In dry weather water was
very clear and very good for stock uses and bathing
purposes. Could not use it as much as I needed for
irrigating purposes. At that time I was notified to
hold up on it, by Mr. Horsley, the superintendent.
That was the time when I appeared to need it par-
ticularly for irrigating; paid for it during the winter
when I had no use for it. I state as a physician, hav-
ing used this water and having had experience with
it, I consider it very unwholesome. Not speaking as a
physician, I consider it good for bathing purposes,
except at times when it became muddy. I consider
it good for cooking purposes as soon as it was boiled.
Quite a number of times I could not use it for irri-
gating purposes, in the summer when it was very
dry; could not tell what year; near midsummer. i
could not tell to save my life what year, only from
being put on notice several times during my experi-
ence with the water. Not the same summer; three
or four summers They have been every summer I
use it; I can not be positive about the number of
summers. Quite a number of times; six or eight
times; something like that; don’t think all one year
or season. When I was notified to that effect it was
during exceptionally dry times in summer.
By J. S. Lowry (pr. rec. 650): Have lived in
Dawson twenty-five years; in ’92 lived on Main
street; had water pipe run in rear door to be used
for cooking purposes; tried to use it for cooking
62
purposes and could not; muddy and had a bad odor
in 792, in the spring and summer. We cut it off then
and since I have been living on Lee street and tried
it again this summer; tried it last year. Got it in
my yard and every once and a while I tried it; same
trouble was the result last year and the same trouble
this year; has red color to it and is offensive. Was |
member of council in ’94. Made no complaint
officially, made no complaint personally or request
: for improvement. I quit it.
3 Dr. A. R. Lamar (pr. ree. 651): Physician eight
years; been living in Terrell all that time; Dawson
two years and a half or more. Have had experience
with the water of the Dawson Waterworks Company;
have been using it for irrigating garden and in barn;
have used it part of the time for cooking purposes
and in the bath room. Did not use it for drinking
purposes; found it was bad; had an odor that was
offensive. I also saw if you draw it from the hydrant
and let it stay over night in the pitcher it would
have an odor about it; would have an odor most of
the time after setting a while. I consider it unwhole-
some, so much I did not drink it. It was all right
for cooking purposes if boiled. Have never used it
for drinking purposes when I could get any other;
been using artesian water from town pump. What
I say about this water is based on actual test, so far
as drinking. I have noticed it is offensive; very
often. If you draw it out of the hydrant and let
it stand over night in bucket or pitcher, it will
always have a bad odor. I have let it stay over night
in a bucket or pitcher to see, about 365 days ina
year, It is not always offensive in the morning, but
nearly always so. Running water, as I understand
it, purifies itself by coming in contact with the air,
and standing water, especially if there is any nitro-
genous matter In it, putrifies. My idea is that stand-
ingall night in a pitcher it putrifies. If the water was
pure I would not expect it to putrify. I mean by
nitrogenous matter in it, vegetable and animal
matier; inorganic; that causes the putrifaction.
By Chas. Deubler (pr. ree. 654): Live right across
the street from new tank, top of it is open; of the old
OL eA A
a
Ni dny teie
Biiicunns:
SUR NAT LACES OO OREM RRR a oR AOAC NENA
63
one was covered. I have seen buzzards roosting on
the new standpipe at different times in the daytime, as
many assix there at one time. It has been so within
the last two weeks. You can see them there most any
time in the day, as many as one, roosting there, as
far back as directly after it was built. Itis a roosting
place for buzzards; they roost awhile, then sail off
and another will come.
By A. J. Baldwin (pr. rec. 612): The school here
in our present condition is supplied with artesian
well water; has been for five years, because the board
and teachers at that time considered the waterworks’
water as unfit for use in the school. I am a member
of the board. I was at the time of the meeting and
acquiesced in it; the board acquiesced in it. I think
it was on the recommendation of the superintendent
and the complaints of the people and teachers at
that time. It was verbally condemned by the con-
current action of the committee. Had to pay $5 a
month to have water hauled to the school. Had
water connected at the school with the city water, I
think soon after the waterworks were put in. They
have kept it there all the time until three or four
years ago.
By J. A. Horsley (pr. ree. 667): Superintendent of
water system and witness for complainant. 1 reported
the dead horse to the chief of police, because I knew
it was wrong to let it stay there, people getting water
from that stream. As soon as I disesvered it was up
there I went to the chief of police at once. For eight
or nine months I spent much of my time in the en-
gine house where the water is pumped. I have spent
my other time around on the streets about in differ-
ent places; I go down and inspect things oceasion-
ally as superintendent. I don’t stay there regularly.
I don’t stay at the standpipe regularly. I stay about
on the streets engaged in other business, real estate
and life insurance. Don’t know whose horse it was
that died in the branch; understood it was a negro’s.
Did not know he was there before he died (page 135).
Occasionally the people told me the water was muddy,
unfit for use, smelled badly, and pressure was in-
sufficient, for instance on these water ends, and asked
wala atin = Gea tia WS aa
peeatis ieee tees Bowe mgs BY Gye Re an nee i
64
me to flush mains so the water would clear, and J
did it. During that time I remember complaints
made several times about pressure. My recollection
of first complaint, Witchard and Green fire, ’97.
Have seen buzzards on tank in day.
By F. A. Ruggles, witness for complainaut (pr. rec.
344): I removed the timbers of the old tank when
it was torn down and ordered to construct a new one.
There was at that time at the bottom of said old tank
four inches in depth of foul and muddy sediment.
The city, in support of this same exception, refers to the
affidavit of George Calloway, employee of the waterworks
company, filed by consent of Master and counsel on both
sides of the case as evidence in the case, May 29, 1902 (pr.
rec. 753), and another of the same witness, June 3, 1902 (pr.
rec. 755), and after the re-examination of the other witnesses
orally, proving the discovery, in the water tower of the com-
pany, of three dead and decayed buzzards in May, 1902.
The city refrains from encumbering the record in briefing
all of the testimony to the same effect as the above, inas-
much as the same was not contradicted to any extent in any
material particular, and inasmuch as the Master himself has
found, informally but in effect, that the water was not kept
in a condition suitable for the purposes intended.
65. In overruling the fourth exception of fact, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 160):
That the Master erred in not finding that the water sup-
plied to the citizensof Dawson from January 1,1896, up to the
filing of his report was not suitable for domestic, sanitary,
and other useful purposes. In support of this exception the
city refers to the testimony briefed in support of exception
of fact No. 3. Said testimony was not contradicted to any
extent in any material particular.
66. In overruling the fifth exception of fact, which was as
follows (pr. ree. 160):
That the Master erred in finding (findings of fact, No. 9,
pr. rec. 92), that except on rare occasions the reservoir was
RRA IINAE LRG AGM POON YIN PORE in He PG RRS ME
65
kept supplied with water sufficient to produce the required
pressure, because he should have found from the evidence
that the water company had not performed its contract as
to pressure, and that its service had not been adequate or
reliable to the extent required by the contract.
In support of this exception the following brief of the
evidence is submitted :
By W. R. Baldwin (pr. ree. 501): When the cap
was taken off the plug at the kiln fire water would
not come out at first, but solid, soft mud. I suppose
a half minute; might not have been so long before
the water came; commenced coming mud. I saw the
mud come out and I stopped and looked at it. The
hose was two or three feet from it when the mud
came. By the time the hose got there I suppose one-
third water came and the rest mud. When it first
came out it was solid, soft mud. It was coming out
of the end of the hydrant. It was on Main street
about 100 yards from the public square. It was on
the principal street in the city, about a block from
the business center.
By A. J. Baldwin (pr. rec. 512): After the three
houses burned at Green and Whitchard fire, 1897,
a day or two Mr. Horsley told me they were go-
ing to make a testand I went with him. He took
100 feet of new hose furnished by him and went
over there and attached it to the plug in front of
Mr. Melton’s, the same plug that played on these
buildings of Green and Whitchard. Had two sec-
tions of hose, fifty feet each, new, attached to the
plug, a one-inch nozzle, and the water barely went
above the electric light pole. It was turned on full.
It went not exceeding five feet above the pole.
The pole was 25 feet high. The height of the
water did not exceed thirty feet. The air was still
enough to make a straight stream; ordinary con-
dition of air; no interference with stream by wind.
This was in 1897, No change had been made in
the waterworks from ’94 up to this time, that I
know of, and none from the date of that. test up
to the time the new tank was built. The Green
8310—5
<sy swore
2
'
F
4
sf
N
%
%
2
NS
66
and Whitchard houses were burned up. T remember
the Grier and McClellan fires in ’98 on Lee street.
The distance from the plug to the building there
was 80 feet, and the house sets inside some 25 feet ;
100 feet, I would say, from the plug, excepting the
width of the sidewalk. There was no unnecessary
amount of hose. There was only one line of hose
from the plug.
By J. G. Dean (pr. ree. 589). The old tank from
the ground to the bottom of the tank was 59 feet and
7 inches. Mr. Baldwin and I measured it. For several
years before it was torn down it leaked badly, never
possible to fill it entirely, at least for several years
before it was torndown. Might possibly by pumping
all the time get it full. During these years it was not
generally kept full; it leaked so badly; it was pos-
sibly kept two-thirds or about three-fourths fall. The
present tank is forty feet higher than the other.
By Dr. W. B. Cheatham (pr. ree. 555): During ’96-
97-99, I think twice, I can remember no more posi-
tively than that, I found the standpipe empty; one
time in the day and the other at night. I tried to
draw some water in my bath tub, is the way I know
it wasempiy. At another time I thought it was‘
frozen. The weather was all right the first time, I
think it was in the spring; not cold water. There was
no water in the tank at all; could get no flow. I told
Mr. Horsley and he stated to me, I think upon in-
vestigation, that this standpipe was empty. It was
empty twice; not on account of any freeze; been
stopped up several times by freezes. It was twice, I
think that Mr. Horsley admitted, that the pipe was
empty. The fault of the engineer or somebody ; I
don’t know who. The last time I found it empty it
was between ‘97 and ‘99. Tecan not say what year
prior to that time it was. Where I live the surface is
lower than the surface at the standpipe. I investi-
gated all around and the water would not run from
my faucet in my house; during ’95-6-7-8, the stand-
pipe was rotten and leaked. It was leaking all along.
I saw it; a considerable stream would pour out. be-
tween the whole body of it; between the staves where
they came together; twenty feet from sidewalk; in-
<t ~ CSS EN CR Re AIRE Breer:
67
terfered with passage. Sometimes you would have
to go around on the other side of the street to get out
of the spray of the water from it. It would wet the
sidewalk so it was almost impassible, especially
when ladies would walk around it. Horsley admitted
to me that the standpipe was in a bad condition, in
conversation about six months before this bill was
filed. I remember the test on one occasion on College
street, of the pressure, very well. Mr. Horsley, the
superintendent, was present. I was there by accident,
passing by to see a patient. They attached the hose,
turned on the stream, and threw the water twenty
or twenty-five feet, or probably thirty feet high. It
Was some new hose they had; 100 feet. The force of
the water was turned on. Mr. Horsley manipulated
it. From what I could see the test was made fairly
and fully. The air seemed to be pretty still. I noticed
that no currents were affecting the stream to blow it
one way or the other; seemed to be what you would
all still air. The water went from twenty to thirty
feet. I noticed the height of it. That was on one of
the principal streets of the city.
By John Seay (pr. ree. 577): I remember the Me-
Clellan fire in June, ’98, very well, but not the date.
Only one that I remember. I noticed the use of
the hose on that occasion; ean not exactly give you
the length of the hose; can give you the distance
of the plug to the fire; don’t think there were but
three sections of the hose used; don’t know what
the length of the hose was; some thirty, some fifty
feet to a section. It is even 100 feet from the plug to
the eaves of the house. I measured that: I do not
remember that there was any surplus hose used on
that occasion; did not have hold of it myself; T
don’t think the hose was 100 feet; the water was
fully turned on: there was only one line of hose from
that plug; it was the size of nozzle used all the time:
it was the usual nozzle; I think it was a pretty day ;
don’t think there was any storm concealed: no
storm; in my recollection it was still: the hose was
about 20 feet; they got there with the hose, but
could not get the water on it; we threw the hose up
and down, trying to make the water go further; hit
68
on top of the house about twenty or twenty-five feet ;
didn’t go on the roof of the house; it did go.on the
eaves; the water went about twenty or twenty-five
feet high ; not over twenty-five.
By F. M. McNulty (pr. ree. 588): Lived in Dawson
since ’81; alderman at one time; remember the Me-
Clellan fire very well, but not the year; I suppose it
was 100 feet from the plug to the McClellan house,
that was on fire; I think I turned the water on; I
turned it on properly; I don’t think the hose was
over 100 or 150 feet; they didn’t have any hose to
spare ; I don’t think there was over 100 feet, though
I won't be positive; they had an inch nozzle; the
city had an inch nozzle and some three-fourths of an
inch; this was the city nozzle; there was not any
pressure on this occasion; threw the water about to
the eaves of the house, twelve or fifteen feet from the
ground; tried to throw the water and could not; did
not have pressure enough ; was not force enough be-
hind it; don’t remember any disturbances in the air;
this was on one of the principal streets of the city;
got an old door and held it up front of the men
holding the nozzle; got up to the house as close as
they could that way; couldu’t throw the water on
top of the house; I remember the test made by
Horsley and others in 1897 at Doc Melton’s; I was
there; Andrew Baldwin was there and Mr. Horsley;
I remember those two; had 100 feet of hose ; madea
full and fair test; Mr. Horsley conducted this, when
it was made with the new 100 feet of hose; the air
was very calm; it was a one-inch nozzle; Horsley
turned the water on; threw the water in every way
on that occasion; would throw vertically, and the
highest it went was 25 or 30 feet.
By C. Deubler (pr. rec. 620): I remember the Me-
Clellan fire. Very poor amount of pressure on that
occasion; threw the water about 20 or 25 feet. The
air was still at the McClellan fire, Parks fire, Green
and Witchard fire, and the dry kiln fire when I was
present. I will state from my observation of the way
the water was thrown and handled and manipulated
on this occasion; that there was not sufficient pres-
sure from the waterworks company to have thrown
SG SER a ED i EES PI I RE, ELS TE
69
water through 100 feet of hose, one inch nozzle, in
still air, vertically, fifty feet; there was not pressure
enough. (The Master allowed this testimony over
objection after the witness stated his experience with
water and fires.) I remember the old tower; lived
75 or 100 yards, right across the street, in 1895-6-
7-8, until it was replaced; it was ina leaky condi-
tion. After filling it about half full, further up it
leaked; like filling a basket. It leaked all around;
shot out in big streams, in some places as big as my
hand. Had large streams and small ones all around
the staves, running up and down. When the wind
was blowing the water would reach my porch. Don’t
think the tank had been filled in several years (p.
511). It could not be.
By J. P. Allen (pr. rec. 642): Acting in capacity
of engineer for the waterworks company at the sta-
tion. Water muddy, right smart. It was deficient in
quantity; was not enough of it for filling the tank ;
that was true right smart; had to run the pump
slow ; been times in which you could not get enough
to fill it at all during dry weather. The stand pipe
in town was very leaky. I would get it full before I
would quit: has taken as long as six hours. My
instructions were to keep it full in ease of fire.
I was required to keep it full. It would be hard to
do sometimes. I have to keep the pumps going day
and night, and then it would not get full, the tank
leaked so bad. Sometimes the water was very muddy
and sandy when it was dry, on account of the sue-
tion. The water was low down and it would suck
sand. The sand would finally clog in the well, and
would have to pump sand; would cut out the
plungers and valves. Water was very druggy when
it was low. I did not drink the water. It was not fit
to drink. I thought it was unclean. In opening the
pumps I noticed an inch of corrosion and mud clean
to the well part of the pump. There was a kind of
offensive odor like you will find in muddy streams.
I thought the inlet pipe should have been cleaned
out. I don’t know if I did not mention it to Mr.
Horsley that there should be made a hole to keep
the same out. Would be sucked up through the
pump. The pump is what kept that from filling up,
I suppose; never was cleaned, to my knowledge. |
was employed as engineer for thirty days by Mr.
Horsley.
On cross-examination: Q. It was filled all the time
you ran the pumps during that exceptionally dry
spell? Just took longer to fill it? A. Don’t think
they had sufficient water to fill it; kept running the
pumps.
By E. J. Cameron (pr. rec. 654): Age 29. Am
chief fire department Dawson ; have had experience
12 years ; from bottom to head of this department;
since November, ’99. Since present tower have
noticed the absence of pressure once that I know of.
For twenty minutes, I suppose. I know there was no
water in the tower; no water came up here in the
engine from spigot. It was six or seven months ago,
: I immediately notified Mr. Baldwin and Mr. Deub-
: ler; thought there might be a burst in the main, or
something to cause the leak, or the tank run dry,
4 without their knowing about it. One Saturday morn-
4 ing I started to wash the wagen and the boy com-
plained there was no water coming out of the faucet.
I went and tried the faucet and there was none.
Went and tried it again in about twenty minutes
and the water was coming in full pressure. I don’t
know sir how long it had been empty.
By Horsley, superintendent waterworks company
(pr. ree. 368): During the summer of 1900, maybe
1899 and 1900, during the very dry season, the
pressure went down three or four times, so low there
3 was no pressure. Several times early in the morning
* it would not run out of the hydrant. It was this way,
3 I suppose, two or three times.
67. In overruling the sixth exception of fact, which was
was as follows (pr. rec. 165):
That the Master erred in his ninth finding (pr. rec. 92)
that “No complaint concerning the character of the service
or the amount of the pressure was made to the water com-
pany after the institution of the present suit,” because such
ana Seales Wine ae Te Tike t
vl
finding is contrary to the evidence and to the undisputed
testimony of complainant’s own witness, Superintendent
Horsley. See brief of his testimony, exception of fact
No. 3.
68. In overruling the seventh exception of fact, which
was as follows (pr. ree, 165):
That the Master erred in his third finding of fact (pr. rec.
87) “that the city had express notice that bonds were to be
issued and sold for the purpose of procuring the money
with which to construct the waterworks plant, and that the
city acquiesced in this arrangement,” because the evidence
showed that such notice was not received until after the
contract was made and much of the work done by the
water company toward construction.
69. In overruling the eighth exception of fact, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 165) :
That the Master erred in not finding that prior to the
date of the assignment of the cause of action of com plain-
ant, the water company not only had demanded payment
of the water rentals, but also had entire control of the con-
tract, said fact having been proven by the uncontradicted
testimony of James H. Daws, superintendent of the water
system and witness for complainant (pr. ree. 357).
0. In overruling the ninth exception of fact, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 165):
That the Master erred in his fifteenth finding of faet (pr.
rec. 93), because the same was wholly irrelevant,
71. In overruling the tenth exception of fact, which was
as follows (pr. rec. 165):
That the Master erred in finding for the company the
right to recover water rentals and all other relief, because
the evidence not only failed to show that the water company
performel its contract as to pressure or kind of water or
otherwise, but the uncontradicted testimony showed quite
the contrary.
Par DV EERO Coat
eer Nese
~1
te
ARGUMENT.
Demurrer to Jurisdiction.
Prior to the filing of the bill the city of Dawson was a
stranger to the complaining trustee. The contract between
the city and the water company was made before the com-
pany gave the mortgage to complainant, and the city had
no part in the transaction between the company and com-
plainant. Therefore no liability against the city and in favor
of the complainant could accrue except such as arose or arises
under and out of the contract the city made with the com-
pany. Hence, under the averments of the bill, the com-
plainant could have no claim against the city unless the
same claim had accrued against the water company. Comer
vs. Sheehan, 74 Ala. 457; Jones, Mort., 773-4.
When the bill was filed, the complainant as trustee for
the bondholders had no accrued demand against either the
city or the water company, there having been no default.
The water rentals were only mortgaged to secure payment
of the interest on the bonds. The court below found (Mas-
ter’s Concl. of Law, No. 2, subd. 7, pr. rec. 110) that all
interest maturing prior to the assignment of the rentals by
the water company to complainant had been paid and that
the indebtedness represented by the coupons on the bonds
having been extinguished, the complainant could not enforce
payment a second time in the interest of the American Pipe
Company, not a party to the suit, which had loaned the
money to the water company.
Since, at the date of the filing of the bill, the bondholders
had no demand to satisfy against either the water company
or the city, complainant’s bill was fictitious and simulated,
at least to the extent of its claim to recover the accrued
rentals.
Complainant had notice of the litigation between the
water company and the city, and of the judgment of the
BAAS IR BE ATS DETREI 09, ORAS A tet ashley SIO
Supreme Court of the State adverse to the water company
when it took the assignment of the rentals, and it is patent
on the face of the bill that the assignment was merely col-
orable, not in satisfaction of any accrued demand, and for
no other purpose than to confer Federal jurisdiction, so that
the right to collect rentals could be litigated in a different
jurisdiction, and, notwithstanding the identity of interest,
the water company was made defendant, otherwise the ap-
parent diversity of citizenship could not have been obtained.
The matured coupons having been paid, the bondholders
had no interest in or lien on the accrued rentals proposed
to be enforced by the suit, and under the circumstances of
the transfer as set forth in the bill and so found in effect by
the court below, the demand for rentals accruing prior to
the date of the suit was made by complainant, not as trus-
tee for the bondholders, but as such for the benefit of the
water company; the assignment was fictitious and the suit
collusive and should have been dismissed. Williams. vs.
Nottawa, 104 U.S. 209; Hayden vs. Manning, 106 id. 586;
Hawes vs, Oakland, 104}id. 459. It should have been dismissed
because the transfer was not absolute, but merely colorable
(Maxfield vs. Levy, 2 Dall. 381, and 4 id. 330: Barney vs.
Baltimore, 6 Wall. 280, 288), and collusive. Marvin vs. Ellis,
9 Fed. 367; Coffin vs. Haggin, 11 id. 219. If the water
company is the real party and complainant’s interest nomi-
nal, the bill should have been dismissed. Smith vs. Kerno-
chen, 7 How. 216.
Besides, it seems well settled that a mortgage given bya
water company, covering rentals accruing under a contract
with a city, can not clothe the mortgagee with the right to
maintain an action against the city in a Federal court where
the mortgagor and the city are both corporations of the
same State. American Waterworks vs. Home Water, 115
Med. 171, citing N. Y. Guaranty vs. Memphis Water, 107
U.S. 205; Eau Claire vs. Payson, 46 C. C. A. 466, on re-
hearing 48 C. C. A. 608.
|
a
74
In extending the jurisdiction of the Federal courts, Con-
gress was “specially careful to guard against the conse-
quences of collusive transfers,” and by section 5 of the act
of 1875, c. 237, it imposed the duty on the Federal courts
of their own motion to dismiss suits the moment anything
of the kind appeared. Congress had in view the protection
of the courts as well as of parties against frauds upon Fed-
eral jurisdiction (Williams vs. Nottawa, 104 U.S. 211), and
the suit of a collusive transferee is entitled to no considera-
tion even though he be the real party in interest as to a part
of the cause of action, he being only colorable assignee as to
the remainder (id. 212), and if jurisdiction was first ob-
tained by a collusive transfer, the suit should be dismissed
and the parties remitted to their original rights, notwith-
standing that since the filing thereof, and before action of
the court, the transferee’s part had become, from accumu-
lated interest, sufficient to invoke Federal jurisdiction (id.
212).
It was the duty of the court below to have ascertained
the matter in controversy and to have arranged the parties
according to interest, and when so arranged, if it appeared
that citizens of the same State were parties on both sides of
the controversy, the court had no jurisdistion, Pac. R. R.
Co. vs. Ketchum, 101 U. S. 298; Barney vs. Latham, 103
id. 211; Removal Cases, 100 id. 457; Walsh vs. Memphis, 6
Fed. 797; Saginaw vs. Saginaw, 28 id. 529; Covert vs. Wal-
dron, 33 id. 312 (authorities cited) ; Pittsburg vs. Baltimore,
61 id. 709; Tug River vs. Brigel, 67 id. 629; Oberlin vs.
Blair, 70 id. 414; National Bank vs. Radford, 80 id. 572.
According to interest, a Georgia corporation was com-
plainant and a Georgia corporation was respondent. The
bill should have been dismissed for want of jurisdiction.
Federal Question—Equitable Jurisdiction.
No Federal question was alleged in the original bill.
Defendants demurred to the jurisdiction for want of citizen-
BeOS LAER AMT LE MENON ED A ot FON, IT
75
ship and complainant alleged a Federal question by amend-
ment to prevent the dismissal of the bill. The court below
decided that a Federal question was presented, and that it
was not concerned as to what motive prompted the simulated
assignment, and it refused to arrange the parties according
to interest.
Now what Federal question was presented by the amended
bill? The object of the suit was (1) to enforce collection of
water rentals; (2) to prevent the city from violating its
agreement to commute taxes; and (3) to protect from im-
pairment the exclusive franchise alleged to have been
granted the water company.
It is settled that a breach is not the impairment of the
binding force of a valid contract within the inhibition of
the Federal Constitution, and that the remedy therefor and
for refusal to pay accrued rentals would be a suit at law.
Tex. & R. R. Co. vs. Marshall, 136 U.S. 393: Marble vs.
Ripley, 10 Wall. 358; St. Paul Gas vs. St Paul, 181 U. S.
142; Raton Water vs. Raton, 174 id. 360; Lehigh Water vs.
Easton, 121 id. 392; Fergus Falls vs. Fergus Falls Water,
72 Fed. 873.
It has been held (American Waterworks vs. Home Water,
115 Fed. 172) that—
“A right of action against a city to recover water
rentals claimed to be due under a contract is at law,
and a Federal court of equity is without jurisdiction
to enforce the payment of such rentals, even where
it has acquired jurisdiction to determine other mat-
ters in controversy between the parties.”
And that (p. 181) the general rule that a court of equity
having once obtained jurisdiction of a cause should retain
it, does not apply in causes of this kind in the Federal
courts, because-—
“The Seventh Amendment to the Constitution
guarantees, in all legal controversies where the value
in controversy shall exceed $20, the right of trial by
:
«
=
+4
iE dine Paes AR
W Waser ER as,
s
4
4
a
:
4
3
4
MU Orta Bee Ma SARS 2 POR AR nike Rk NF
76
jury. That provision would be defeated if a strictly
legal question could be tried by a court of equity
(Hipp vs. Babin, 19 How. 271; Whitehead vs. Shat-
tuck, 138 U. S. 146; Scott vs. Neely, 140 U.S. 106).”
No Federal question or ground for equitable jurisdiction
could be involved in the mere renunciation of the contract
or refusal to pay rentals.
The court below itself eliminated any such question or
ground with regard to the agreement to commute taxes by
declaring that agreement void (Master’s conc. of law, No. 2,
subd. 6, pr. ree. 110).
The Federal question and its correlative in this case, the
equitable jurisdiction, must then of necessity be predicated
solely on the impairment of the exclusive franchise alleged
to exist in favor of the water company and so held to exist
by the court below.
The fundamental question of jurisdiction, first of this
court and then of the court from which the record comes,
presents itself in every writ or appeal, and must be an-
swered by the court, whether propounded by counsel or not.
Defiance Water vs. Defiance, 191 U.S. 194; Mansfield vs.
Swan, 111 id. 382.
Even presupposing a valid contract as the basis of this
suit, this court has no jurisdiction because, on the face of
the pleadings, there has been no impairment of the obliga-
tion of the contract in a constitutional sense.
In the early period of our judicial history there was some
confusion of the term “ obligation” with the word “ con-
tract,” respecting the constitutional inhibition against the
passage of laws by States impairing the obligation of con-
tracts, but this court seized the first opportunity presented
and decided that the Constitution used the word “ obliga-
tion” advisedly (Sturges vs. Crowninshield, 4 Wheat. 197;
Ogden vs. Saunders, 12 Wheat. 269), and that mere annul-
ments or breaches of contract were not within its purview.
REIT OE AON Sek ERE Re Fe BT
77
“The terms ‘contract’ and ‘ obligation,’ although
sometimes used loosely as convertible terms, do not
properly i
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.