Opinion — United States Repair & Guarantee Co. v. Assyrian Asphalt Co.

Supreme Court brief1902

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Supreme Court of the Gnited States.

No. 61.—Ocrozer Term, 1901.

The United States Repair and Guaranty |) On writ of certiorari to the

Company, Petitioner, United States Circuit Court

v8. of Appeals for the Seventh

The Assyrian Asphalt Company. Circuit.

[January 6, 1902.]

Mr. Justice McKenna delivered the opinion of the Court.

This suit was originally brought for the infringements of three letters

patent issued to the petitioner as assignee of Amos Perkins. ‘The patents

were respectively numbered 501,537, 542,349 and 560,599, and were dated

respectively 18th July, 1893, 9th July, 1895 and the 19th of May, 1896.

The first, 501,537, was for an improved “Method of repairing asphalt

pavements ;” the other numbers were for “Improvement in apparatus for

repairing asphalt pavements.”

The bill contained the usual allegations of invention and infringement,

and prayed an injunction,

The answer admitted the issue of the patents, but denied that Perkins

was the original and first inventor of the subject matter or that the im-

provements therein disclosed constituted new and useful inventions within

the meaning of the patent laws, or that said improvements were not known

or used in this country, or had not been patented or described in any

printed publication in this or in foreign countries. before the alleged in-

vention thereof by Perkins.

The petitioner dismissed the bill as to patent number 542/349. Upon

the hearing the Circuit Court sustained the apparatus patent number

560,599, finding that the Assyrian Asphalt Company had infringed upon

that apparatus, and ordered an injunction and a reference for an account-

ing. The Method patent number 501,537 was adjudged invalid, and the

court said :

“From the evidence in this suit regarding the prior state of the art, and

the argument before me, I find that the term ‘asphalt’ is not limited in its

meaning to the Trinidad deposit, or the so-called ‘American mixture,’ but

includes as well the bituminous paving material used in France and else-

where, comprising natural rock asphalt and compositions of bitumen and

lime or sand particles, and that the claims of the Perkins Method patent

are so broad with reference to the application of heat to the repair of asphalt

pavements, that they are anticipated by the Crochet patent, and are invalid,”

2 Repair & Guaranty Co. vs. Asphalt Co.

The petitioner took an appeal to the Court of Appeals, and that court

affirmed the judgment of the Circuit Court. ( -) The case

was then brought here by a certiorari.

_ The proceedings here are only concerned with the Method patent

number 501,537. The letters patent describe the invention as follows:

“ My invention is designed to produce a method whereby the repairin

of sphalt pavements may be quickly and cheaply accom vara gpatiry

neater appearing pavement be obtained after repairing than has heretofore

been the case.

“Heretofore in the — it has been customary to dig out with a

pick or other instrument the surface material around the spot to be repaired,

sometimes applying heat to the spot to soften the material so that it may

be more easily removed. When the material has been removed the

depression thus made is thoroughly cleaned and given a coat or dressing

of tar. New material in a heated state has then been placed in the

depression and been ironed down and smoothed off in the usual manner of

finishing, the tar acting as a solder to hold the new material in place.

When completed, however, the line or joint between the old hardened

material con the new material has been plainly discernible and more often

there has been more or less of a ridge. Again this new block of material,

by reason of frost or from other causes, is frequently torn loose from its

soldered connection with the old material, thus necessitating new repairs.

In practicing my invention, however, I subject the spot to be repaired and

the surrounding edges to such a degree of heat that the surface asphalt,

not only the exact spot to be repaired but the surrounding portion, to a

greater or less degree, is reduced to the soft pliable state in which it is

originally laid. With a rake or other suitable instrument it is then

agitated and mixed with enough new material to fill up the spot to be

repaired. It is then subjected to the usual finishing operation of ironing

and burnishing. The heating of the surface may be accomplished in va-

rious ways and by means of various forms of apparatus, and while I have

herein shown but one form for accomplishing the result, yet I would have

it understood that I do not limit myself to any particular form of appa-

ratus for carrying out my invention.”

The apparatus described consists of a suitable tank mounted on a wheel

for carrying gasoline. The tank is connected with a series of horizontal

pipes which carry a series of burners, and “ project a flame downward

against the pavement.”

“In carrying out the invention A represents a suitable tank for carrying

gasoline mounted on the wheeled frame B and connected by the pipe C

with a series of horizontal pipes, D. These pipes D carry a series of

burners, E, which pass through a hood or shield, F, and project a flame

downward against the pavement. Pressure is then obtained upon the

gasoline to force it to the burners and to produce a blast by means of an

air pump, G, mounted upon the tank.”

The letters patent further say :

“The apparatus is also provided with a handle, H, whereby the operator

may readily move it to the desired spot. Now as would be seen by turn

ing on as many of the burners as are desired,a strong blast of heat is pro-

Repair & Guaranty Co. vs, Asphalt Co. 3

jected against the surface of the asphalt and readily melts it. As ex-

_ plained above, when it is desired to repair a spot the apparatus is moved

adjacent thereto with the burners directly above the spot. These soon

rales the surface asphalt, both at the spot and at the surrounding edges,

to a pliable state, the strong blast causing not only the immediate surface,

but the particles deep down, to be melted and yet not burned. With a

rake or other suitable instrument the operator then agitates or stirs up the

for the purpose of uniting the parts or sections of material, and is done

without any distinct dividing line between the old and new material. In

with and becomes a part of the old material. As stated above, while

heating the spot to be repaired the surrounding edges or portions must be

heated toa greater or less degree, and the new material is worked into these

edges as well as in the spot to be repaired, so that when hardened it is

practically impossible to tell where the pavoment has been repaired.

“1. The method of repairing asphalt pavenaatn, which consists in sub-

jecting the spot to be repaired to heat, adding new material and smoothing

and burnishing it, substantially as described,

“2. The method of repairing asphalt pavements, which consists in subject-

ing the spot to be repaired to heat until the material is softened, gitating

it and mixing with it new material, and finally smoothing and burnishing

it, substantially as described.” ;

Infringement is only asserted of the first claim, and, considering the

language of the claim and of the specifications, it seems impossible to

heat to the spot to be repaired. Aud the patentee did not confine him-

self tothe particular apparatus he described. That, he said, was “one

form of accomplishing the result. He would have it understood, he said,

that he did not confine himself “to any particular form of apparatus for

carrying out” his invention, and the independence of his method from

any form of apparatus is brought out by contrast of what had been done

and what he proposed to do as an improvement. What had been done

soften the material, so that it might more easily be removed. And the new

the exact spot to be repaired, but the surrounding material, to a greater

or less degree, will be reduced to the soft, pliable state in which it was

originally laid. Here we have the comparison of the two methods. The

old was to take ont the surface material around the spot to be repaired,

sometimes applying heat to soften such material. The new method was to

4 Repair & Guaranty Co. vs. Asphalt Co.

apply heat, not only to the exact spot to be repaired, but the surrounding

edges. What, then, was the advantage of the new method? The patent

tells us. In the old method the depression made by the removal of mate-

rial was “ thoroughly cleaned and given a coat or dressing of tar.” The tar

. acted as a solder, but the joint between the old and the new material was

discernible, and often a ridge was formed, and the adhesion of the materials

yielded to frost and other causes. The new method dispenses with the tar

and its consequences. It substituted the melting of the surrounding edges,

producing a union and coalescing of the old and new material, making a

better appearing and more lasting repair. If the method and effect of

the patent be different from this, we are unable to discern it from the

patent or from the testimony. Indeed, there is no other difference estab-

lished by the testimony. One of the expert witnesses of the petitioner

testified as follows:

“It is further evident that in such. use of defendants’ device and in the

repair of pavements in part by the use of said device by defendants, the

use of tar or any other cement or ‘solder’ is obviated, that the union

between the patch of new material and the old pavement is direct. imme-

diate and complete without the intervention of an interposed body of tar

or like materia', and that the joint need, therefore, present none of the

disadvantages, objections or defects in respect either of appearance or of

effectiveness, which distinguished the old tar joint and which are obviated

by the method here in controversy.

* * * * *

“There are three steps or process elements enumerated in this claim, to

wit: First, ‘subjecting the spot to be repaired to heat;’ second, ‘adding

new material;’ and third, ‘smoothing and burnishing.’ These are all

perfurmed in the same order by the defendants. The separate steps, are,

moreover, essentially the same in kind in defendant’s practice, as set forth

in the patent. ‘The heat is applied to the spot to be repaired with a flame

blast. The new material added is the same in condition and character;

it is not tar or any part tar, but is solely the asphalt composition like that

of the old pavement, and in the soft condition and heated state in which

said composition is and was originally applied. The smoothing and

burnishing is the same step in both cases, being the old and familiar opera-

tion performed by means of heated metal tamping and smoothing irons

long before used in leveling and smoothing original asphalt pavement

surfaces.”

And he further testified :

“ It appears to me to be a feature of the patented method, or a charac-

teristic of the steps of applying the new material, that the new material is

placed into direct contact with the old, as if the claim read ‘adding new

material in direct contact with the old material and smoothing and burn-

ishing it.’”

In other words, the mixing of the old and new material around the

edges of the excavation and “adding of ‘new material in direct contact

with the old material, smoothing and burnishing it,” is the essence of the

Repair & Guaranty Co. vs. Asphalt Co. 5

invention, and so ungualifiedly is this true that a witness of petitioner tes-

tified that if the heat which was applied not only melted, but burned the

immediate surface and as well “ the particles deep down,” and the material

thus burned raked away clean before new material was applied, the

method of the patent would be followed.

As thus described, was there anything in the art which preceded the

Perkins method and took from it the claim of

The Cireuit Court and the Circuit Court of Appeals found that a patent

issued to Paul Crochet, June 11, 1880, in France, had that effect, and we

concur in the finding. The process described in the Crochet patent is for

the “ Preparation and Recharging of Compressed Asphalt Roadways.”

The following is the specification of the patent:

pper part of the laye

are taken off by

ich perform the office of a rake; said scraper

arging can be

e in spots, and

re Repair & Guaranty Co. vs. Asphalt Co.

diminish the gpcngat of _ box to the oe i A coma F; wfeable

manceuver the car over the pavement. is system, especially appli

for streets of com asphalt, can be equally employed to repair and

recharge streets of bitumen.

“Telaim as my invention my system for reparation and recharge of

asphalt roadways, presenting as distinctive dasetntitian the points

lowing :

“ Tet. ‘The softening of the upper surface of the asphalt layer at the part

to be repaired, and the removal of such upper surface by means of a toothed

scraper which striates the part remaining.

“2d. Recharging, by the addition upon the surface thus softened, of

an asphalt layer of convenient thickness, which is stamped by the usual

means.

“3d. The movable furnace which I have combined to such end, accord-

ing to the conditions described and represented.”

The similarity, if not identity, of the patents is manifest, and it would

seem unnecessary to enlarge upon their resemblance. They are both

methods of repairing asphalt roadways ; they both apply heat to the spot to

be repaired ; the old material is removed in the Crochet patent; in the

Perkins patent it is reduced to the state in which it was originally laid,

then agitated and mixed with new material. But this agitation and mix-

ing of old and new material is not necessary to the method. It may be

advisable to do or not to do, a witness testified. But further, the Perkins

patent calls for a heating of the surrounding edges of the spot to be re-

paired, to make continuity between the spot repaired and the surrounding

pavement. The Crochet patent has not this detail in words, but it is

clearly implied. Describing the prior art, the Crochet patent says:

“ . . . the operator generally delimits with a pick the part which is

to be replaced and takes therefrom the asphalt; but it is rare that this

operation has not for consequence the starting of the adjacent portions which

are sound, swelling them up in such wise that at the end of a little while

it is necessary to report them in their turn.” His method, he says, “sur-

presses such inconveniences,” and the repeated passing of the heating ap

paratus over the pavement has the effect that the new coat forms with

the old “a thickness without break in continuity, and it does not at all im-

pair the neighboring portions.” Surely, considering the method of this

patent alone, it did not require the exercise of invention to pass to or con-

ceive the Perkins method. Besides, that conception had the aid of other

publications. In some of them the application of heat is mentioned as

necessary in the original construction of asphalt pavements and also in their

repair. In a work entitled “Asphalt, its Origin, its Preparation and its

Application,” by Leon Malo, published in Paris in 1888, the repair of

pavements after excavations and deteriorations was described. In making

excavations two precautions were recommended, and the second consisted,

the author said—

Repair & Guaranty Co. vs, Asphalt Co, 7

“ In heating the rims of the halted bed which limit (i. e., define)

the whole ona bef pouring in’ the hot powder destined to repair the

part la cking.”

“The wheels of vehicles encounter the disintegrated parts, digging there

a hole vig Ge it be not promptly repaired—finishes by deepening itself

crumbles, and if overheated becomes as inert as sand; whereas the asphalt

of the Perkins patent melts under the action of heat and has “a peculiar

of Appeals; the patent does not Support them. Before the time of either

patent the world knew that heat disintegrated some things and melted

others, and we cannot concede invention to the thought that that might

virtue resulting from a peculiar application of heat, there is nothing in

the record to show that Perkins was aware of it. He certainly did not

8 3 ’ Repair & Guaranty Co. vs. Asphalt Co.

‘is independent of his apparatus. He says in his patent: “The heating

of the surface may be accomplished in various ways and by means of

various forms of apparatus, and while I have herein shown but one form

for accomplishing the result, yet I would have it understood that I do not

limit myself to any particular form of apparatus for carrying out my

invention.” —. :

And what is claimed is, as we have seen, “the subjecting the spot to be

repaired to heat.”

In further answer to the contention we may quote the Circuit Court of

Appeals as follows :

“Another objection to the proposed limitation of the claim by making it

read ‘a blast of heat,’ or ‘a strong blast of heat,’ in lieu of the unquali-

fied word ‘heat,’ is in the fact that the third claim, which contained the

additional words, was withdrawn by the patentee upon a ruling or declara-

tion of the Patent Office that the first and third claims were the same in

substance and could not both be permitted to remain in the case. That

was not merely a casual expression of opinion by an examiner, but was in

effect a requirement that one or the other of the claims be withdrawn, and

no reason is perceived for not applying the ordinary rule. Having volun-

tarily abandoned the claim for a method limited to the use of ‘a blast of

heat,’ the patentee or his assignee may not now insist that a broad claim,

containing no suggestion of such intention, shall nevertheless be subjected

by construction to the same restriction. This point, in view of the reser-

vation weer considered, is unimportant and might be passed, but it is to

be observed that if the third claim was withdrawn by mistake, a correction

should have been sought in the Patent Office, either by a surrender and

reissue, or eapeeatd by a new application. It is not within the rightful

power of the courts to enlarge or restrict the scope of patents which by

mistake were issued in terms too narrow or too broad to cover the inven-

tion, however manifest the fact and extent of the mistake may be shown

to have been.”

Decree affirmed.

True copy.

Olerk Sapreme Court, U. S.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.