Transcript of Record — United States Repair & Guarantee Co. v. Assyrian Asphalt Co.
Supreme Court brief1902
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1900.
No. 277.
UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY COMPANY,
PETITIONER,
re
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COUR
OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
Cricaco:
Tne Guetrnore-Warren Peintixne Co.,
58 Dearborn Street.
1800.
Original. Print.
Plea- weyers
Bill of complaint
Subpwem@....---- ee Rees Fe
Return to writ of subperna.....
Answer to bill of complaint
Notice of exception to answer...... -.«+--
Exception to QDOWEF.. ..-.. 666 -- eens ne rene ete
Order of Sept. 11, 1897, to expunge 7th paragraph of
answer: that answer may stand as amended, and that
replication be filed instanter.... ..
Order of Sept. 11, 1897, as to taking of proofs. ......
Stipulation. ...-.-.65++ «6 i Gnbt eaves
Complainant's Evidence—
Stipulation...
Deposition of Melville KE. Dayton (expert)
Deposition of Henry R. Kasson. ,
Agreement of Sept. 4, 1897, between Barber As-
phalt Paving Company and City of St. Joseph,
Deposition of William Y. Warren...
Deposition of J. H. Cranford... ..
Deposition of William H. Lober.
Deposition of Henry N. Moss.....0---.--
Complainant's Exhibit Defendant's Device
Defendant's Evidence—
Exhibits offered in evidence.....-...
Deposition of Lewis M. SESE e TT CCT TT.
Defendant’s Exhibit Defendant's Valves (drawing }
Complainant's Exhibit Smith Drawing...
Defendant's Exhibits— ff,
Crochet French patent No. 137,208... ..
Official description of machines and processes, ete.
Annales des Ponts et Chausses, 1561
Bridge and Highway Annals........--- ++ +--+:
Memoires et Compte-Renudu des Travaux de In
Societe des Ingenieurs Civils...
Kepert on asphalt and bitamen, ete...
1
3
i4
15
16
iv
#u
21
21
22
95
482
29
440
Ss
a3
114
117
123
Iau
i4]
144
140
155
17H
178
Isl
183
vine
233
247
2
3
io
1]
i}
i4
16
Plate 1— Asphalt roads and roasting furnace.. 263 199
Pilate Il—Asphalt roaster yr ' 265 = 9oy
Plate I1[— Portable boiler, ete. . 267 903
Page from ++ Engineering,’ Mare 18, 1870 269 965
Minutes of Proceedings of the lostitution of Civil
Engineers, Vol. XLII... 271 207
Annales des Ponts et Chausses, 1S79 3) By
Bridge and Highway Annals.. BUR 989
Minutes of Proceedings of the institution of Civil
Engineers, Vol. LX 314 248
L) Asphalte, Sou Origine, Sa Preparation Les Ap.
plications. .. .. oS B24 953
Leon Malo—*+ ‘ Asphalt, Its Origin, Its Preparation
and Its Application’ . 335 965
Writ of Certiorari. S4h QT]
Stipalation...... . ; S42 979
Return to writ of sortior: ari 442 79
Complainant's Rebuttal Evidence
Notice 343 273
Deposition of Charles Edward Foster (expert) S46 ©6974
Stipulation.. 426 129
pepadtion 2 of Philip W. Henry 27 397
6 ‘ Henry J. Warren -. St
‘y olnes W. Foster j44 4il
$56 O38
458 338
‘ William H. Lobe 441 340
** Henry R. Kasson S7 63
440 347
‘ Charles H. Burwinkle $52 349
és ‘+ Eugene G. Schwendeman 454 351
“ * Volney W. Foster 544 411
3S 338
456 353
Stipulation 461 355
Notary’s Certificate 462 356
Stipulation as to affidavits Soe 464 357
AGidevit of A. L. Barber ia 455- 358
: * Stevenson Towle 470 = - 361
* Clifford Richardson .. 473 ° 363
Edward P. North ve 478-367
Deposition of Melville E. Dayton (expert) 29 23
co
iii
Deposition of Volney W. Foster..............- 438 338
456 353
5444
eee ey ee gery Ceti Ps ta 419
‘ \@idavit of R. C. Ruthven... . 0. 05. sess. SOL 4
Complainant’s Rebuttal Exhibits—
( io rea onan Foster eagery ere so
ts No. 3........ 569 499
Order of May 1, 1899, setting cause hie hearing...... 570 430
Heuring ..... Re teehee ete 430
Order of June 24, 1899, setting hearing on motion for
rehearing .... wiiéa 571 451
Hearing on motion for rehearing . . 572 431
Order of July 19, 189%, overruling motion for rehearing 572 «431
Decree ane 572 432
Petitiou for ‘appeal .. 574 454
Assignment of errors 574 435
Order allowing appeal 575-435
Bond on appeal. . 576 456
Stipulation as to printed record . 577 437
Precipe for transeript . 578 438
Clerk's certificate . 578 438
Citation PS ee 579 43%
Patent exbibits — :
No. §. 701, Feb. 3. 1852, J. A. Y- a % . 551 442
145,822, Dec. 23, 1873, C. . Waterbury. 5S4 446
Re-issue No. 5,697, Dee. 23, Po MC. Bogin -, 58s 450
157,559, Dec. 8, 1874, C. G. Waterbury... 592 454
++ 169,439, Nov. 2, 1875, J. P. Hayes........ 598 460
* 184,628, Nov. 21, 1876, 1. Kendrick ..... 603 464
* 269,368, Dec. 19, 1882, A. F. Zimmerling . . 608 470
383.346, May 23. 21865, Jd. B.-Can.. ....-.: 6 476
501,536, July 1S, 1893, A. H. Perkins... <. 090- 468
* 501,537, July 18, 1803, A. H. Perkins...... 626 485
+ 517,199, Mar. 27, 1894, A. H. Perkins...... 630 492
531.648, Jan. 1, 1895, C. Risdon et al...... 634 496
542,349, July 9, 1895, A. H. Perkins....... 638 500
- 552,013, Jan. 14, 1896, H. W. Laster...... 644 506
* 560,599, May 19, 1896, A. H. Perkins...... 650 512
Motion of ¢ ‘omplainant for diminution of record ‘and
granting writ of certiorari............-.-...-.-... 661 522
Order granting above..... 662 523
Order allowing use of records ‘printed i in the court
below. eee er papers i er so O88 836
iv
Order setting cause for hearing.
Order making certain exhibits « part of the record
Opinion of Judge Kohlsaat ' ee
Clerk's certificate . :
Hearing...
Opinion U nited States Circuit Court of Appeals
Decree '
Clerk's vertifieate
Writ of certiorari.
Return of writ of certiorari.
Stipulation as to record
» oe
+ om ec ae
wo i WM NM bo
. oO or
~~? o
-
08 S
CERTIFIED COPY OF THE RECORD UNDER SUBDI-
VISION 3 OF RULE 3, S8PREME COURT RULES.
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD.
IN THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF
APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT.
October Term, A. D. 1899
United States Repair and Guaranty Company,
Appellant,
VS:
\ssyrian Asphalt Company, Appellee
\ppeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for the
Northern District of Ilinois, Northern Division.
Transcript of Record filed September 5, 1899.
(stamped) fled Nov. 18, 1899.
EDWARD M. HOLLOWAY,
Clerk U.S. Cireuit Court of Appeals, Seventh Cirenit
Printed Record
2 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. YB.
I Pleas in the Circuit Court of the United States for the
Northern District of Illinois Northern Division in. Chancery
sitting at the United States Court room, in the City of Chicago,
in said District and Division, before the Honorable Christian Cc
Kohlsaat, District Judge of the United States for the Northem
District of Illinois, on Thursday, the twenty-seventh day of July
being one of the days of the Regular July Term of said Court. ip
the year of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and ninety-nine,
and of our independence the one hundred and twenty-fourth year
S. W. BURNHAM,
Clerk.
United States Repair and Guaranty Com-
pany, In Chancery.
- 24534
Assyrian Asphalt Company and James
P. Mallette.
Be it remembered that on this day to-wit: the twelfth day of
June, 1897, came the complainant in said entitled cause by its
solicitors and filed in the clerk's office of said court a certain Bill
of Complaint, which said .Bill of Complaint is in the words and
figures following to-wit:
3 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
For the Northern District of Ilinots.
In Chancery. No. 24534-
United States Repair & Guaranty Co. }
vs.
Assyrian Asphalt Company and James f
P. Mallette.
BILL OF COMPLAINT.
Your Orator, United States Repair & Guaranty Company, a
corporation organized and existing under and by virtue of the
laws of the State of Illinois, a citizen of said State of Illinois, and
having its principal place of business uP the City of Chicago, in
said state, brings this, its bill of complaint, against the Assynan
Asphalt Company, a corporation organized and doing business
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 3
under and by virtue of the laws of the State of Illinois, and hav-
ing its principal place of business at Chicago, in said Northern
Division of said Northern District of Ilinois, and a citizen of
sail State of Ilinois, and James P. Mallette, who, your ora-
4 tor is informed and believes, is a citizen of said State of IIli-
nois. residing in said Northern Division of said Northern Dis-
trict of Illinois, and is sued herein both individually and as presi-
dent of the said defendant corporation.
And thereupon your Orator complains and says that before
the 8th day of March, 1893, Amos H. Perkins was the true, orig-
inal and first inventor of certain new and useful Improvements in
“Method of Repairing Asphalt Pavements.” fully described and
claimed in the Letters Patent hereinafter mentioned. and which
improvements, thus patented, had not, before his invention and
discovery thereof, been known or used by others in this country
or described in any printed publication in this or any foreign
country, and which had not, for more than two years prior to
the date of his application for a patent therefor, as hereinafter
mentioned, been in public use or on sale in this country.
Your Orator further shows unto your Honors that the said
Amos H. Perkins being so, as aforesaid, the first and
original inventor and discoverer of said improved “Method
of Repairing Asphalt Pavements,” made application in due form
of law to the proper department of the Government of
the United States for Letters Patent therefor, in
accordance with the then existing Acts of Congress; and at or
about the same time, by an instrument in writing, duly
executed and delivered the said Perkins assigned
to the Western Paving & Supply Co., of Chicago, in the County
of Cook and State of TMlinois, all his right, title and interest in
and to said invention and in and to anv Letters Patent that
5 might be issued therefor, in and by which instrument the
Commissioner of Patents was requested to issue any Letters
Patent which might thereafter be granted upon and pursuant to
said application to the said Western Paving & Supply Co., accord-
ing to the terms of said assignment; and thereupon, after due pro-
ceedings had, Letters Patent of the United States numbered sor,
$37. and bearing date the 18th day of July, 1893. were. in pursu-
ance of law, duly granted and issued, under the seal of the Patent
Office of the United States. signed by the Secretary of the In
terior and countersigned by the Commissioner of Patents, and
delivered to said Western Paving & Supply Co., as the assignee
of the said Amos H. Perkins, for the said improved “Method of
Repairing Asphalt Pavements,” whereby there was granted and
4 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. YB.
secured to the said Western Paving & Supply Co., and to its sye.
cessors and assigns, for the term of seventeen (17) years (rom and
after the date of said Letters Patent, the sole and exclusive right
and liberty of making, using and vending to others to be used
the said invention set forth in said Letters Patent, as will more
fully appear by said Letters Patent, or a duly authenticated copy
thereof, in Court to be produced and to your Honors exhibited,
an uncertified copy of the specifications, claims and drawings of
the said patent being hereto attached and made a part of this bill
of complaint and marked “Exhibit A.”
And your Orator further shows that, after the issuance of said
Letters Patent No. 501,537, your Orator became, and now is, by
virtue of a certain mesne assignment, the sole and” exclusive
owner of all legal and equitable title, of every name and
6 nature, in, to and under the aforesaid Letters Patent, inclyd-
ing all rights of recovery of damages, savings, profits and
license fees, for any and all infringements of the said Letters Pat-
ent had any time subsequent to the issuance thereof, as by said
mesne assignment, or a duly authenticated copy thereof, here in
court to be produced, will more fully and at large annear.
And thereupon your Orator further complains and says that,
before the 30th day of July, 1894, Amos H. Perkins was the true,
original and first inventor of certain new and useful “Improve
ments in Apparatus for Repairing Asphalt Pavements,” fully de
scribed and claimed in the Letters Patent hereinafter mentioned,
and which improvements, thus patented, had not, before his in-
vention and discovery thereof, been known or used by others in
this country, or described in any printed publication in this or
any foreign country, and which had not, for more than two years
prior to the date of his application for a patent therefore, as here-
inafter mentioned, been in public use or on sale in this country.
And thereupon your Orator further complains and says that
before the 15th day of June, 1895, Amos H. Perkins was the true,
orivinal and first inventor of certain other useful “Improvements
in Apparatus for Repairing Asphalt Pavements,” fully described
and claimed in the Letters Patent hereinafter mentioned, and
which improvements, thus patented, had not, before his inven-
tion and discovery thereof, been known or used by others in this
country. or described in any printed publication in this or any
foreign country. and which had not, for more than two years
prior to the date of this application for a patent therefor, as
7 hereinafter mentioned, been in public use or on sale in this
country.
And your Orator further shows unto your Honors that the
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY, 5
said Amos H. Perkins, being so, as aforesaid, the first and original
inventor of said “Improvements in Apparatus for Repairing As-
phalt |’avements,” made application in due form of law to the
proper department of the Government of the United States for
Letters Patent therefor, on Tuly 30th, 1894, and June 15th, 1895,
respectively, in accordance with the then existing Acts of Con-
ss and, at or about the same times, the said Amos H. Perkins
did assign the right, title and interest in, to and under the said
applications and any Letters Patent which might thereafter issue
upon said applications, to your Orator, the United States Repair
& Guaranty Company, by certain instruments in writing, duly
executed and delivered by the said Amos H. Perkins, in and by
which said instruments, the Commissioner of Patents was re-
quested to issue any Letters Patent which might thereafter be
granted upon and pursuant to said applications to the said United
States Repair & Guaranty Company, according to the terms. of
said assignments and thereupon, after due proceedings had, Let-
ters Patent of the United States No. 542,349 and No. 560,599,
bearing date the oth day of July, 1895, and the roth day of May,
1896, respectively, were, in pursuance of law, duly granted and
issued, under the seal of the Patent Office of the United States,
signed by the Secretary of the Interior, and countersigned by the
Commissioner of Patents, and delivered to the said United States
Repair & Guaranty Company, as the assignee of the said Amos
H. Perkins, for said improvements, as described in the appli-
& catior§ggaforesaid, whereby there was granted and secured to
your Ofator, the United States Repair & Guaranty Company,
its successors and assigns, for the term of seventeen (17) years
from the dates of said Letters Patent, respectively, the full and ex-
clusive right and liberty of making, using and vending to others
to be used, the said improvements and inventions set forth in said
Letters Patent, as will more fully appear by said Letters Patent,
or duly authenticated copies thereof, in court to be produced and
to vour Honors exhibited, uncertified copies of the specifications,
claims and drawings of the said patents being hereto attached and
made a part of this bill of complaint and marked “Exhibit B” and
“Exhibit C.”
And vour Orator further shows that, by virtue of the premises,
your Orator became and now is entitled to all the rights and priv-
ileges granted and secured, by said Letters Patents, and is now
the sole and exclusive owner of all legal and equitable title of
every name and nature in, to and under the aforesaid Letters Pat-
ent No. 542,349 and No. 560,599, including all rights of recovery
-<
6 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.
of damages, savings, profits and license fees for any and all in-
fringements of the said Letters Patent had any time subsequent
to the issuance thereof, respectively, as will more fully appear by
said assignments, or duly authenticated copies thereof, in court
to be produced.
Your Orator further shows unto your Honors that each of the
inventions described and claimed in said three Letters |’atent,
respectively, is capable of being used conjointly with every
9 other invention described and claimed in said three Letters
Patent, respectively, in the art of repairing asphalt pave-
ments; and that the defendants have practiced, and are now prac-
ticing, the method disclosed in said Letters Patent No. 501,537,
and in so doing have made and used, and are now making and
using apparatus which embodies, in whole or in part, the inven-
tions described and claimed in said Letters Patent No. 542,349
and No. 560,599.
And vour Orator further shows unto your Honors that it has
brought the aforesaid inventions into widespread public use in a
great many cities and towns throughout the United States, and
that the development of said inventions and the introduction
thereof into public use has necessitated the exnenditure of large
sums of money, which have been spent in this behalf by vour
Orator; that the said patented inventions are, and have been
proven, of great value and of great benefit to the public and profit
to your Orator; and that the exclusive rights therem of your Ora-
tor have been generally recognized and acquiesced in by the trade
and by the public at large, and, as your Orator is informed and be-
lieves your Orator has continued to be, and now ts, in the exclusive
possession of such rights secured in and by said Letters Patent, as
aforesaid, except for the unlawful, illegal and injurious disregard
and infringement thereof by the said defendant.
And your Orator further shows unto your Honors that said
defendants, Assyrian Asphalt Company and James P. Mallette,
and each of them, have been duly notified by your Orator of the
existence of said Letters Patent No. 501,537, No. 542.349
10) «60and No. 560,599 and of your Orator’s aforesaid title therein,
thereto and thereunder
And your Orator further shows, upon information and belief,
that, well knowing the premises and the nghts secured to vour
Orator, as aforesaid, contriving to injure vour Orator and to de-
‘priv e it of the benefit and advantages which might. and other-
wise would, accrue to it from said inventions and discoveries, at
divers times and occasions prior to the time of filing this, your
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. T
Orator's Bill of Complaint, and since the granting and delivery
of the Letters Patent aforesaid, and since your Orator’s rights in
the premises were acquired, as aforesaid, wholly without the
license or allowance, and against the will of your Orator and in
violation of its rights secured by the aforesaid Letters Patent
No. £01,537 No. 542,349 and No. 560,599, and in infringement
of the afores#id Letters Patent No. 501,537, No. 542,349 and No.
c60,5.9, the said defendants James P. Mallette and Assyrian As-
phalt Company, under the immediate supervision, direction and
control of the defendant, James P. Mallette, as President, have at
and within said Northern District of Illinois, and elsewhere. un-
lawfully, wrongfully and in defiance of the rights of your Orator,
practiced and employed the method of repairing asphalt pave-
ments described and claimed in said Letters Patent No. 501,537
and made and constructed, or caused to be made and constructed,
for use, and used, and are now making, constructing and using
numbers of apparatus for repairing asphalt pavements substan-
tially ike, and upon the plan and principle, and in imitation of,
‘and embracing in each of said apparatus, either the whole or
11 one or more, of the said inventions or improvements con-
tained in said Letters Patent No. 542.349 and No. 560.599
or substantial and material parts thereof. That is to say, the de-
fendants have, at the time and place aforesaid. unlawfully ane
wrongfully and in defiance of the rights of your Orator, secured
by sat! ' etters Patent No. 501,537, No. 542.349 and No. 569.599,
and in infringement of said Letters Patent. and wholly without
your Orator’s consent, made apparatus embracing the invention
described and claimed in claim one of Letters Patent No. 542,-
349 and claims one, two. three, four and five of Letters Patent
No. 560,599 or substantial and material parts thereof, and used
the apparatus so constructed, or caused the same to be done, in
practicing the method of repairing asphalt pavements described
and claimed in claim one of Letters Patent No. 501,537; and they,
the defendants, continue so to do and to cause by others to be
used, the apparatus constructed in infringement of said Letters
Patent No. £42,349 and No. 560,<99 in practicing the method in
infringement of patent No, 501,537, as aforesaid, and in violation
and defiance of the rights secured to your Orator thereby as
aforesaid, and to your Orator’s great and irreparable loss and in-
jury and by which your Orator has been. and still is being, de-
prived of great gains and profits, which it might, and otherwise
would, have obtained, but which have been received and enjoved
and are being received and enjoyed, by the said defendants by and
through their aforesaid unlawful acts and doings. And although
8 UNITED STATE® REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Ys.
the said defendants have made and realized large profits, gains
and advantages from the use of said inventions and discoveries,
to what extent and how much they have been profited your
12 Orator does not know and prays a full and complete discoy-
ery thereof.
And vour Orator further shows that the use of the aforesaid
inventions and discoveries by the said defendants, and their prep-
aration for and avowed determination to continue the same, and
their other unlawful acts, encourage and induce others to jn.
fringe said Letters Patent in disregard of your Orator's rights
and to its great loss and injury.
And inasmuch as your Orator can have no adequate relief. ex.
cept in this Honorable Court, and to the end that the defendants
may be compelled to account for and pay to your Orator the in-
come, gains and profits thus unlawfully derived, or which might
have been derived, from the violation of the rights of your Orator
aforesaid, as well as the damages therefor, and be restrained from
any violation of such rights, your Orator prays that your Honors
may grant a writ of injunction pernetually restrainine the defend-
ants, said Assyrian Asphalt Company and James P. Mallette, both
individually and as President, and each of them, their and each of
their attornevs, solicitors, clerks, officers, employes, servants,
agents, and workmen, and all claiming or holding through or
under them from, in any and every form and manner, from mak-
ing, using or selling any apparatus which shall in anywise consist.
in whole or in part, of or embrace in any form or manner whatso-
ever the inventions in said Letters Patent No. 542,349 and No
360,=99 claimed: and from in any form and manner using, em-
ploying or practicing the process or method, and each and every
part thereof. for repairing asphalt pavements which shall corre-
spond, in-whole or in part. to the process or method in said
13 Letters Patent No. 501.537 claimed; and that the use and
sale of any apparatus made in accordance with your Orator's
said Letters Patent No. =42.349 and 560,599 and embracing any
port or feature claimed therein, that is now in possession of the
defendants, or either of them, or their, and each of, their attor-
neys, solicitors, clerks, officers, employes, servants, agents or
workmen, may be enjoined and that the same may be destroyed
or del'vered up to your Orator for that purpose.
And may it please vour Honors to grant unto your Orator a
writ of injunction conformable to the prayer of this Bill and also
a writ of subpoena of the United States directed to the said de
fendants, said Assyrian Asphalt Company and James P. Mallette,
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 9
commanding them and each of them to appear and answer this
Bill of Complaint, but not under oath (an answer under oath
being hereby expressly waived), and to abide by and perform such
orders and decrees in the premises as to the Court shall seem
meet and be required by the principles of equity and good con-
science
And your Orator, as in duty bound, will ever prav, etc.
UNITED STATES REPAIR & GUARANTY COMPANY,
By VOLNEY W. FOSTER,
President.
RAYMOND & OMOHUNDRO,
Solicitors for Complainant.
JAMES H. RAYMOND,
Of Counsel. —
State of Illinois, =
County of Cook. }—
Volney W. Foster, being duly sworn, denoses and says that he
-is the president of said United States Repair & Guaranty Com-
pany, complainant in the foregoing bill of complaint; that he has
heard the said bill of complaint read and knows the contents
thereof, and that the same is true, except as to such matters as
are herein stated on information and belief, and as to them he
believes them to be true; and that he verily believes that the said
Amos H. Perkins was the original and first inventor of the im-
provements patented, as therein alleged, in and by United States
Letters Patent No. 501,537, of July 18, 1893, No. 542,349 of July
goth, 1895, and No. 560,599 of May roth, 1806
VOLNEY W. FOSTER.
14 Subscribed and sworn to before me this 11th day of June,
A. D. 1897
WILLIAM O. BELT,
(Seal.) Notary Public.
(Endorsed) Filed June 12, 1897
S. W. BURNHAM,
Clerk.
10 UNITED STATES RPPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.
On the same day to-wit the twelfth day of June, 1897, a writ of
Subpoena issued out of the clerk’s office of said court directed to
the Marshal of said District to execute, which said writ together -
with the Memorandum thereto attached and the Marshal's return
thereon endorsed is in the words and figures following to-wit:
SUBPOENA.
United States of America,
Northern District of Illinois, > ss.
Northern Division. (
The United States of America To Assyrian Asphalt Company
and James P. Mallette, Greeting:
We command you and every of you that you appear before our
judges of our Circuit Court of the United States of America for
the Northern District of Illinois, at Chicago in the Northern Di-
vision of said District, on the first Monday in the month of July
next, to answer the bill of complaint of United States Repair and
Guaranty Company this day filed in the clerk’s office of said court
in said city of Chicago, then and there to receive and abide by
such judgment and decree as shall then or thereafter be made,
upon pain of judgment being pronounced against you by default.
To the Marshal of the Northern District of Illinois to execute.
Witness the Hon. Melville W. Fuller, Chief Justice of the
United States of America, at Chicago aforesaid, this 12th day of
June in the vear of our Lord one thousand eight hundred and
ninety-seven
S. W. BURNHAM,
(Seal.) Clerk.
MEMORANDUM.
The above named defendants are notified that unless they
and each of them shall enter their appearance in the clerk’s office
of said court at Chicago aforesaid, on or before the day to which
the above writ if returnable the complainant's bill will be taken
against them as confessed and a decree entered accordingly.
S. W. BURNHAM.,
Clerk.
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 11
MARSHAL’S RETURN.
I have served the within writ within my district in the follow-
ing manner to-wit:
Upon the Assyrian Asphalt Company therein named on the
12th day of June A. D. 1897, by leaving a true copy of the same
with James P. Mallette, President of the said company. Upon
James P. Mallette therein named on the 12th day of June A. D.
1897 by delivering a true copy of the same to him, personally.
J. W. ARNOLD,
U. S. Marshal.
By H. R. CLARK,
Deputy.
S. W. BURNHAM,
Clerk.
(Endorsed) Filed June 14, 1897.
Afterwards to-wit: on the fourteenth day of August, 1897,
came the defendants in said entitled cause by their solicitors and
filed in the clerk's office of said court their Answer, which said
answer is in the words and figures following to-wit:
16 UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT.
Northern District of Illinois
Northern Division.
U.S. Repair & Guaranty Company
= In Chancery
Assyrian Asphalt Company, and James -y,, 24,534.
P. Mallette. nt
ANSWER.
Filed Aug. 14th, 1897.
Joint Answer of the Assyrian Asphalt Company (a corporation),
and James P. Mallette, Defendants, to the Bill of Complaint of
U.S. Repair & Guaranty Company, Complainant.
These Defendants, now and at all times hereafter reserving
unto themselves all and all manner of benefit or advantage by ex-
wv UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. VB.
ception or otherwise, which can or may be had or taken to the
manifold errors, uncertainties, insufficiencies and imperfections jn
said Bill of Complaint contained, for Answer to said Bill, or to sq
much and such parts thereof as these Defendants ace advised, it
is necessary for them to make unto, answer and say:
I. Defendants are not advised, save as stated by the Bill of
Complaint, that the Complainant is a corporation duly oryanized
ang existing as alleged in said Bill; they therefore deny the alle
gation in that regard and leave the same to be proven as Com.
plainant may be advised. Defendants further answering admit
that said Assyrian Asphalt Company is a corporation duly organ.
ized and existing under the laws of the State of Illinois and hay-
ing its principal place of business at Chicago in the northern judi-
cial District of said State, and that said James P. Mallette, named
as co-defendant is the President of said Assyrian Asphalt Com-
pany.
II. Upon information and belief Defendants admit that the
letters patent sued on herein, viz: (A) No. 501,537, Method of
Repairing Asphalt Pavements, July 18, 1893: (B) No. 542,349,
Apparatus for Repairing Asphalt Pavements, July 9, 1895; (C)
560,599, Apparatus for Repairing Asphalt Pavements, May 19,
1896, were issued in due form on applications filed in that behalf
by one Amos H. Perkins of Chicago, Illinois, alleging himself to be
the first and original inventor of the subject-matter set forth and
claimed respectively therein.
These defendants deny that said Perkins was in fact such
inventor, but on the contrary allege that in view of the then
known state of the art no invention was requisite to produce
said several supposed improvements at the time each of them
respectively was by said Perkins first devised
III. Upon information and belief respondents deny that said
Perkins was the true, original and first inventor of the subject-
matter in said pretended Letters Patent set forth; they deny that
the alleged improvements disclosed therein constituted a new and
useful invention within the meaning of the Patent Law at the
time said improvements were first devised by said Perkins; they
deny that said improvements or substantially the same were not
known or used in this country or had not been patented or de-
scribed in anv printed publication in this or in any foreign coun-
trv before the clleged invention thereof by said Perkins.
IV. Further answering, respondents sav that, except as al-
leved by the Bill of Complaint, they have no knowledge of the
several assignments, mesne or final, by which the interest in said
alleged invention and Letters Patent were conveyed unto com-
plainant; respondents do not admit that the exclusive right of
‘7
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY, 13
making, using and vending to others to be used the improve-
ments set forth by said Letters Patent No. 501,537 is vested in
the complainant; and accordingly respondents leave the com-
plainant to prove the several allegations of the bill concerning
the exclusive right and title in said complainant under the Let-
ters l'atent aforesaid as it may be advised.
V. .Upon information and belief, respondents do not admit
that the improvements and inventions patented as aforesaid have
been in the exclusive possession and enjoyment of the complain-
ant nor that the same are of great value and profit to sald com-
plainant; respondents do not admit that the alleged improve-
ments have been extensively introduced in public use, nor that
the same have been received with great favor by the public, or
that the public generally has acquiesced in the alleeed exclusive
right of comnlainant under said Letters Patent, and respondents
call for strict proof thereof.
VI. Defendants admit that said Assyrian Asphalt Company,
under «lirection of said Mallette as president,isengaged from time
to time in the business of repairing asphalt pavements, and in
such business has occasion to follow well-known methods in mak-
ing said repairs and to employ certain tools and appliance in and
about the same. But defendants deny that said Mallette save as
president of the defendant herein is engaged in such business and
further deny upon information and belief, that the practices fol-
lowed and the appliances used in repairing asphalt pavements or
any of them do in any wise infringe upon exclusive rights law-
fully secured by Letters Patent unto said complainant.
18 “VII. Upon information and belief, defndants allege
that the pretended inventions respectively defined bv the
several Letters Patent and the claims thereof here in suit were——
long prior to the supposed discovery or devising thereof by said
Perkins—known to various other persons and were disclosed or
described in various antecedent natents and printed publication
at present unknown to these defendants, but which they are dili-
gently seeking to identify and when discovered, crave leave by
apt amendment at the foot of this answer or otherwise as the
Court may direct, to set forth and specify in detail for further
defense in the action, as by statute allowed.
VIII. Respondents deny that said complainant has any right
to an account for damages, profits, gains, charges or costs, to be
recovered fram these respondents; they deny said: complainant’s
right to any injunction, provisional or perpetual, and deny that
said complainant is entitled to any other or further relief whatever
against these respondents
a4 UNITED STATES RPPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.
All of which matters and things these defendants are ready to
aver and maintain and prove as this Honorable Court may direct:
without this that any other matter, cause or thing in complain-
ant’s said bill of complaint contained, material or necessary for
these respondents to make answer unto, and not herein and here.
by well and sufficiently answered, confessed, traversed, avoided
or denied, is true to the knowledge and belief of these respond.
ents; wherefore these respondents humbly pray to be hence dis-
missed with their reasonable costs and charges in this behalf most
wrongfully sustained.
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY,
JAMES P. MALLETTE,
By PEIRCE & FISHER,
Solicitors for Defendants,
LEROY D. THOMAN,
Of Counsel ;
*Note. Paragraph VII expunged by order of court September
rith, 1897.
(Endorsed) Filed Aug. 14, 1897
S. W. BURNHAM,
Clerk.
19 Afterwards to-wit: on the ninth dav of September, 1897,
came the complainant by its solicitor and filed in the clerk's
office of said court a certain Notice and Exception to answer,
which said Notice and Exception are in words and figures follow-
ing to-wit:
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY.
NOTICE AND EXCEPTION TO ANSWER.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
For the Northern District of Illinois.
Northern Division.
United States Repair and Guaranty Com-
pany, In Equity.
vs. General No. 24,534
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.
To Mr. Leroy LD. Thoman, Solicitor for the defendants, Marquette
Bldg., Chicago:
We hand you herewith a copy of our exception to paragraph
VII of your answer in the above entitled cause together with a
copy of an order of court which we shall ask to be entered pursu-
ant thereto, and beg to notify you that the same will come on
for hearing before his honor, William J. Allen holding said Cir-
_ cuit Court, at his chambers Saturday morning next, September
ith, 1897, at g o'clock A. M. The judge, at our suggestion, has
made this appointment, our suggestion being that we desire the
pleadings to be promptly settled.
Very respectfully,
RAYMOND & OMOHUNDRO.,
Solicitors for Complainant.
J. H. RAYMOND,
Of Counsel.
Service accepted this 8th day of September, 1897.
LEROY D. THOMAN,
Solicitor for defendant.
14 UNITED STATFs RBPAtR AND GUARANTY CoO. vs,
20 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED
STATES.
For the Northern District of Illinois.
Northern Division.
United States Repair & Guaranty Com.
pany, In Equity.
vs. General No. 24534
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.
EXCEPTION TO ANSWER.
For Insufficiency and Impertinence.
Exception taken by the above named complainant to the joint
answer of the defendants for insufficiency and impertinence.
For that, whereas, in the first, second, third, fourth and fifth
paragraphs of the complainant's bill of complaint, it is alleged
in the usual form and words uniformly employed, in such bills of
complaint, and not necessary here to be set out in extenso, that
the said Amos H. Perkins “was the true, original and first inven-
tor of certain new and useful ‘Improvements in Method of Re-
pairing Asphalt Pavements’ and in ‘Improvements in Apparatus
for Repairing Asphalt Pavements’ the said defendants have not
in and bv their answer filed August 14th, 1897, according to the
best of their knowledge. remembrance. information and belief,
answered the said allegations in said bill of complaint contained
hut do, in and by paragraph VII of their said answer reply to the
said allegations of said bill as follows to-wit:
“VIT. Upon information and belief defendants allege that the
pretended inventions respectively defined by the several letters
patent and the claims thereof herein suit were—long prior to the
supposed discovery or devising thereof by said Perkins—known
to various other persons and were disclosed or described in vari-
ous antecedent patents and printed publications, at present un-
known to these defendants, but which they are diligently seeking
to identify and when discovered, crave leave by apt amendment
at the foot of this answer or otherwise as the court may direct,
to set forth and specify in detail for further defense in the action
as by statute allowed.”
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 7
In which particular the said complainant is advised that the
said answer of the defendants is evasive, impertinent and insuf-
ficient and that the said paragraph should be stricken from
21 the said answer; and the complainant prays that the said
answer may be, by order of court, amended accordingly.
JAMES H. RAYMOND,
Solicitor and of Counsel for the Complainant.
Chicago, September 8th, 1897.
(Endorsed) Filed Sept. oth, 1897.
S. W. BURNHAM,
Clerk.
Afterwards to-wit on the eleventh day of September, in the
July term of said court, 1897, in the records of proceedings there-
of in said entitled cause before the Hon. William J. Allen, District
judge, appear the following entries to-wit:
ORDER OF SEPTEMBER 11, 1897.
United States Repair and Guaranty Com-
pany,
vs.
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.
24534-
Upon the coming on to be heard of the complainant's excep-
tion for insufficiency and impertinence to the seventh paragraph
of the defendant’s answer, and both parties having been heard.
It is ordered:
First: That the said seventh paragraph of the said answer
shall be, and the same is hereby expunged.
Second: That the said answer may stand as thus amended
and
Third: That the complainant may file instanter a replication
to said answer.
18 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY co. vs.
ORDER OF SEPTEMBER 11, 1897.
United States Repair and Guaranty Com-
pany,
om, 24534.
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.
The parties being before the court upon the excentions of the
complainant to the VII Paragraph of defendants’ answer, which
Exceptions were sustained, upon the suggestion of the com.
22 plainant, both parties having been heard. It is Ordered that
the complainant herein shall have to and including the 1st
day of October, 1897, for adducing its proofs in chief, that the
defendant shall have from the 2nd day of October until the 13th
day of November, 1897, inclusive, in which to take their proofs
in support of their joint answer: and that the complainant shail
have from the 15th day of November until the 11th day of De-
cember, 1897, inclusive, in which to take its evidence in re-
buttal.
(General Replication filed September 11, 1897.)
Afterwards to-wit on the fourteenth dav of September, 1897,
there was filed in the clerk's office of said court a certain Stipula-
tion, which said Stipulation is in the words and figures follow-
ing, to-wit:
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY.
STIPULATION.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
For the Northern District of Hlinois.
Northern Division.
United States Repair & Guaranty Com-
pany,
VS.
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.
In Chancery
General No
It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the parties
hereto as follows:
That each of the parties may adduce evidence herein upon rea-
sonable notice in writing before any notary public or other offi-
cer, authorized to administer oaths and all evidence so taken shall
be used and considered the same as if taken in all respects in full
compliance with the 67th Rule in Equity.
That each of the parties shall have the right to retain until the
hearing all their respective exhibits introduced herein, subject to
full and free examination by opposing counsel at all reasonable
times
That each party shall furnish to the other, without charge, full
copies of all testimony taken herein as the same shall be adduced
and copies of all drawings and similar documentary exhibits.
That the record herein on behalf of each party shall be printed
as provided by the rules of this court, and the cost of pre
23 paring such printed record, with exhibits, shall be taxable
herein as costs in this case; provided, however, that such
printed records shall in all respects comply with the rules of the
Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit: that not less
than fiftv comtes of each record shall be printed and that each
party shall in their respective printed records embody copies of
all their respective paper exhibits in the cause
That Patent Office printed copies of the specifications and
drawings of all United States Letters Patent and Blue Books of
British Letters Patent may be used in evidence without certifica-
tion, but subject to correction for errors, if any.
That copies of assignments of United States Letters Patent.
duly certified to by the Patent Office. mav be introduced in evi-
dence with the same force and effect as if the originals thereof
_— mee
20 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY Co. Vs.
were introduced and execution thereof duly proven, but subject
to correction for errors, if any.
RAYMOND & OMOHUNDRO,
Solicitors for Complai
PEIRCE & FISHER, _———
Solicitors for Defendants.
Chicago, September 13th, 1897.
(Endorsed) Filed Sept. 14th, 1897
S. W. BURNHAM.
Clerk.
25 IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF
ILLINOIS, NORTHERN DIVISION
United States Repair & Guaranty Com-
| yany :
a Gen. No. 24,534.
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al
COMPLAINANT'S PROOFS.
Testimony taken and evidence adduced on behalf of complain-
ant, pursuant to the attached notice, before E. B. Sherman, Esq.,
one of the Masters in Chancery of said Court, beginning at 10
o'clock a. m., on Wednesday, September 15, 1897.
Present: Mr. O. R. Barnett, of Raymond & Omohundro, so-
licitors for complainant; Mr. James H. Pierce, of Pierce & Fisher,
solicitors for defendants
Thereupon it was stipulated by and between the solicitors for
the respective parties hereto as follows:
STIPULATION.
It is agreed between counsel for the respective parties, that the
Complainant company is a corperation duly organized and exist-
img under the laws of the State of Illinois in keening with the
final certificate duly issued and dated October 20, A. D. 1893.
26 Also, that Complainant company is the owner of Perkins
Letters Patent No. 501,537, for method of repairing asphalt
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 91
yements, dated July 18, 1893, and issued unto the Western
Paving and Supply Company, as grantee, by virtue of an assign-
ment in writing from said Western Paving and Supply Co. unto
said complainant, dated Jan. 1st, 1894, and then delivered and
dyly recorded as required by law, prior to the commencement of
this suit. The assignment last referred to conveys unto said
complainant “all claims and demands of whatever kind for royal-
ties, damages and profits accrued or to accrue for each and every
use of said improvement and inventions, or any or all of them.”
Further proof respecting the above particulars is hereby
waived
Thereupon complainant's solicitor offers in evidence Patent
Office printed copies of United States Letters Patent No. so1,-
537. issued July 18, 1893, to the Western Pavine and Supply
Company as assignee of Amos H. Perkins; No. 542.349, issued
july 9, 1895, to United States Repair & Guaranty Company, as
assignee of Amos H. Perkins; No. 560,599, issued May 19, 1896,
to United States fiepair & Guaranty Company as assignee of
Amos H. Perkins,“and the same are thereupon marked respec-
tively Complainant's Exhibit “Perkins Method Patent,” “Com-
plainant’s Exhibit Perkins Apparatus Patent No. 1,” “Complain-
ant's Exhibit Perkins Apparatus Patent No. 2.”
27 Thereupon complainant's solicitor presented a certain
stipulation duly signed by the solicitors for the respective
parties hereto and duly entitled in this cause, which stipulation
is in the words and figures following:
It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the parties
hereto, and by their respective solicitors, that the following facts
are admitted to be true and shall be, and shall be considered as,
evidence in this cause as fully as if duly proven in any usual
manner
FIRST. That subsequent to the dates of the patents herein
sued upon, and prior to the commencement of this suit, the De-
fendant, Assyrian Asphalt Company, has caused to be made for
it and has used apparatus for repairing asphalt pavement: and
that the drawing hereto attached, entitled in this case and marked
“Complainant's Exhibit, Defendant’s Device,” is a correct draw-
ing of so much and such parts of such apparatus as it purports
to show. .
SECOND. That the defendant, Assyrian Asphalt Company.
subsequent to the date of Letters Patent No. 501,537. herein sued
upon, and prior to the commencement of this suit, has used said
apparatus and caused said apparatus to be used in the repairing
99 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY Co. ys.
of asphalt pavements in the City of Chicago, Illinois. j; the fo}.
lowing manner:
(1.)_ The tank of said apparatus being supplied with any suit.
able oil, an initial pressure is created in said tank by the use of
the air pump thereto attached. which pressure causes the ojl jp
said tank to be discharged through the burners under the hood
or shield of said apparatus, and. upon said oil being ignited
28 in said burners, a blast of flame is projected horizontally yp-
der said hood or shield. and in such manner as to heat 3
portion of the supply pipe leading from said tank to said burners
2.) Said apparatus is placed over the portion of the nave
ment to be repaired and said burners. having been so ignited. the
portion of the pavement under the hood of said apparatus js
exposed to the heat from the blast of flame from said burners
until said portion of such pavement is sufficiently softened to the
depth of one-half inch, or more
(3.) Said apparatus being then removed from the portion of
the pavement to be repaired, that part of the asphalt of the
pavement which has been so softened is thereupon scraped ont
with rakes, hoes or suitable tools to the depth of a half inch or
more.
(4.) After such softened material is <o scraped away and re-
moved, fresh asphalt composition in a heated state is filled into
the depression or space so scraped out, and is thereupon leveled:
smoothed and burnished with heated irons and the other usgal
tools for such purposes, so as to bring the new material m such
repaired place to the same level and make such patched portion
of the pavement continuous with the original pavement imme-
diately surrounding and adjacent to such patch or repair
RAYMOND & OMOHUNDRO.
Solicitors for Complainant
PEIRCE & FISHER,
Solicitors for Defendants
a. ae
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY, 23
29 Whereupon MELVILLE E. DAYTON, a witness produced
on behalf of complainat, being first duly sworn, testified
as (Allows:
_1. Vlease state your name, age, residence and occupation?
A. Melville E. Dayton; upwards of fifty years of age; occupa-
tion, expert mechanic..
©. 2. Viease state what education and experience you have
had tending to qualify you to testify as an expert in patent
causes’
Adjourned to 2 o'clock p. m.
2 o'clock p. m.
Met pursuant to adjournment.
A. | have, for more than twenty-five years last past been
engaged in the analysis of mechanisms, the description and def-
inition of inventions as solicitor of patents, and the comparison
of mechanisms with each other and with the descriptions and
claims of patents. For more than twenty vears last past I have
‘estified many times each year as an expert witness in patent
suits and concerning mechanical constructions, their correspond-
ence with or differences from other structures and their respon-
siveness or lack of responsiveness to the descriptions and claims
of letters patent. For these labors | was prepared by a natural
aptitude for mechanics, by a study of the science of mechanics,
by learning the machnist’s trade and by the study and practice of
mechanical drawing.
©. 3 Have you read and do you understand the drawings,
specification and claims of Letters Patent of the United
30 States No. 501,537, 542.349, 560,599, being the Letters Pa:-
ent herein sued upon?
\. [I have and do.
‘) 4. Please state your understanding of the inventions sect
forth in the specification of Letters Patent No. 501,537 and
clamed im the claim 1 thereof, and set forth in the specification
ond drawings of Letters Patent No. 542,349 and claimed in claim
| thereof: and set forth in the specification and drawings of Let-
iers Patent No. 560,599, and claimed in the five claims thereof.
li, your answer please take up these patents in their chronolog-
ica’ order and state fully your reasons for any conclusions whiclt
may be stated by your
A. The first of the three patents mentioned in the question,
to wit, No. 501,537, relates to a method of repairing the surface
o4 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Ya
of asphalt pavements. Each of the remaining two patents, tg
wit, No. 542.349 and 560,599, relates to apparatus for corr
cut the method set forth in the first of the three patents. The
method patent No. 501,537, not only describes in words the
method therein set forth ‘and claimed, but it also iustrates an
apnaratus which may be employed in practicing the method re.
ferred to, although the patent (as it states) is not restricted to
the use of this particular apparatus. Inasmuch as the operation
of the apparatus may be taken to indicate what the descriptive
part of the patent means in some particulars, and especially with
respect to the application of heat to a pavement to be repaired.
I will, at the outset, briefly describe the construction and action
of such apparatus as it is shown and described in the drawings
and specifications.
31 A tank for holding gasoline or inflammable oil js
supported upon a pair of wheels in a horizontal Position,
and from one end of the tank projects a frame work that supports
a low hood, say 1 to 3 feet wide and 3. 4 Or 5 feet long, beneath
which a flame or a number of flames are produced from the in-
flammable material contained in the tank, such material being
supplied to the flames or to the burners by a suitable pipe or
pipes and under pressure of air or gas in the fluid tank. From
the end of the tank opposite the hood and burners project han-
dles by which a person may move the apparatus about from place
to place to bring the hood and flame over a spot in the pave-
ment to be repaired and to shift it to enlarge the field of opera-
tion of the flames in case the defective spot in the navement is
larger than the hood. An air pump is connected to the tank
by which a suitable pressure may be applied to the liquid to give
the desired “blast” at the flames and a pressure vauge on the
tank enables the operator to determine the Pressure in the tank
and to maintain it at the proper limit
The particular feature in the action of this apparatus to which
attention is called is the blast. It is also to be noticed in connec.
tion with this feature that the hood measurably confines the
ames to the dimensions of the hood
Now turning to the specifications of this patent 501,537, which
is for “the method of repairing asphalt pavement,” the object is
stated in these words:
“My invention is designed to produce a method whereby
the repairing of asphalt pavements mav be quickly and
cheaply accomplished and a neater appearing pavement be
32 attamed after repairing than has heretofore been the case.”
After describing the old method of repairing such pave
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 25
ments, a pointing out the defects of such old method, the spec-
ification goes on to say: :
“In practicing my invention, however, I subject the spot
to be repaired and the surrounding edges to such a degree
of heat that the surface asphalt, not only the exact spot to
be repaired but the surrounding nortion to a ereater or less
degree, is reduced to the soft pliable state in which it was
originally laid. With a rake or other suitable instrument it
js then agitated and mixed with enough new material to
fill up the spot to be repaired. It is then subjected to the
usta! finishing operations of ironing and burnishing.”
After a statement concerning apparatus that may be used and
after a special description of the particular apparatus shown in
the drawing, the specification repeats somewhat more at leneth
the steps of the method, including reference to mixing new ma-
terial with the old and softened material, and concludes with two
claims, the first of which omits mention of the mixing of the old
and new material, which step is snecifically set forth in the sec-
ond claim. The said first claim, being that here in suit and re-
ferred to in the question, reads as follows:
“1 The method of repairing asphalt pavements which
consists in subjecting the spot to be renaired to heat, adding
new material and smoothing and burnishing it, substantially
as described.”
In stating how the apparatus shown in the patent is em-
33. ployed, “in subjecting the spot to be repaired to heat,” the
specification (at line 70, page 1), says:
“As explained above. when it ts desired to repair a spot
the apparatus is moved adjacent thereto with the burners
directly above the spot. These soon reduce the surface
asphalt both at the spot and at the surrounding edges to
a phable state, the strong blast causing not only the imme-
diate surface, but the particles deep down to be melted and
vet not burned.”
It appears from the specification that nrior to the invention
of this method, after cutting out the asphalt which forms the
surface material of the pavement, at and around the spot to be
repaired, tar or its equivalent was arnlied to the surface of the
excavation in the old material and the new material was applied
upon this tar and then smoothed and ironed in the ustal way.
The tar referred to was for the purpose of cementing the old to
the new material and holding the patch in place, or, as the patent
has it, “the tar acting as a solder to hold the new material in
place.”
9% UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. vs.
The method here described and claimed dispenses with the
use of tar or other “solder” or cement the old matenal he
directly united to the new and forming therewith a COntinagys
body practically as before the repair wa% made. or hefore the
defect appeared.
The advantages of the new method are set forth in the patent
in contrast to the defects of the former method in which the
patch was secured to the navement by the tar. Speaking (line
31, page 1) of the tar system of patching or repairing, the patent
says:
“When completed, however, the line or joint het ween the
34 old hardened material and the new material has been plainly
discernible, and more often there has been more or less of a
ridge. Again this new block of material by reason of frost
or from other causes is frequently torn loose from its sol-
dered connection with the old material thus necessitating
new repairs.”
In the new method there is no tar emploved between the old
and the new material, but, after having heated the old material by
the blast so as to reduce it to substantially the same soft or
melted condition in which it was oricinalls applied, the new ma-
terial added forms an immediate and perfect union with the old
material without the necessity for tar or anv other interposed
cement or “solder.” This intimate union of the old and new
materials takes place at all points of their contact, beneath as well
as at the edges, makes the patch intevral with the pavement and
obviates all the faults in the old method
In this connection it should be stated that while the patent
makes no mention of the removal of any of the old material. in
practice the surface of the old material. after being melted or
softened. is taken off to a little depth. say half an inch to an inch.
as found convenient by doing this, the powdered cement whici:
was applied to the original surface of the navement when fresh,
and any and all impurities and foreign substances which may
have been pressed into the surface of the pavement in use. are
removed and a fresh surface of asphalt composition 18 exposed for
union with the new similar material added to fill the place level
with the general pavement around it
35 Patent No. 542.349 is exclusively for an improvement in
apparatus of the general character illustrated and described
in the method patent just above considered. In such former ap-
paratus only the burners themseélves were immediately exposed to
the flames beneath the hood and the vaporization of the hauid
fuel took place mainly or exclusively at or immediately adjacent
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 27
to the points of its emergence, or at the perforations through
which it «scaped to form the flames. In the patent 542.349 the
pipe whi supplies the burner is so arranged as to be directly
exposed '¢ the flames so that the liquid in the supply pipe is
vaporize’ and a back pressure is thereby produced through the
pipe in the supply tank. As a consequence, it became unneces-
sary to frequently pump air into the tank or reservoir to keep up
the required pressure to give the blast. The air pump was, how-
ever, present in the apparatus and used to give the initial pres-
sure in starting the CARE by reason of the back vres-
ere resulting from the vapor@™Rion of the hydro-carbon liquid
in the supply pipe, it became necessary to operate the air pump
at short intervals.
The patent savs:
“The objects of my invention are to have the apparatus
of such character that the heat of the burners may be uti-
lized to produce and maintain pressure in the fuel tank,
whereby a more uniform heat is produced. * * *”
The first clam (which is that in suit, and which pertains to
this feature of the improvement) reads as follows:
“In an apparatus for sepairing asphalt pavements, the
combination with a series of hooded fluid burners and a
reservoir for supplying fuel thereto, said reservoir and burn-
ers being portably mounted, of a supply pipe connecting the
36 reservoir with the burners and exposed to the heat of the
burners, substantially as described.”
The manner in which the supply pipe is “exposed to the heat
of the burners” is most clearly indicated in Fig. 3, of this paten:,
which shows the hood provided with a longitudinal slit or open-
ing in its top of about the width of the large supply pipe, and the
supply pipe placed in this slit so as to present its lower surfac-
directly to the heat of the flames.
Patent No. 560,599, being the third patent in suit, sets forth
several improvements in the same general kind of apparatus for
repairing asphalt pavement. The object of the improvements here
described and claimed will be learned from the following state-
ment, beginning at line 17 of the specification, preceding which
refernce is made to patents No. 500,556 and 517,191 and might
have been made to patent 542,349:
“In said patents are shown blasts of flame or super-heated
air directed vertically upon the pavement and under the
hoods designed to contine the heat to the part of the pave-
ment intended to be repaired. I have found by practice that
while such an apparatus is thoroughly effective in accom-
UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Vs.
plishing the desired result it is open to the objection that
the heat, under the influence of the strong blast and wi
will escape around the edges of the hood, and thus soften
more of the old pavement than is desired, thereby increas:
the labor and cost of repair. This objection is parti
prominent when it is desired to repair narrow cracks jn the
pavement, and as the hood of these prior machines cannot
rest directly upon the ground, so as to confine the heat to
the limits thereof without smothering or objectionably re.
ducing the flame-jets, this objection cannot be overcome in
the class of machines in which hooded burners are employed,
A further and more serious objection, developed by prac-
tice, is the burning out of the valves of the numerous burn-
ers necesarily employed, which even’ the shields can not effec.
tively protect against the intense heat to which they are
subjected, except for but a short time, and, furthermore,
it is necessary with stich burners to employ a high grade
of gasoline or naphtha. The prime object of this invention
is to overcome all of these objections by dispensing with all
valved burners and by delivering the heat to the surface to
be repaired by horizontal instead of vertical blasts.
Another object is to enable the confinement of the heat
to the limits of the hood and thereby avoid the objection
incident to the heating of the unworn pavement beyond the
limit of the hood.”
In this patent the hood is arranged to lie upon the pavement,
along its edges, when in use. for the purpose of confining the
flame more certainly to the limits of the hood. The hood is
practically closed at its end adjacent to the reservoir. being pro-
vided with a vertical head having slits or holes of ample dimen-
sions to admit the passage of the pipes and burners or flames
from the burners and to supply air to the flames within the
hood. At the opposite end the hood is open. The supply pipe
leads into the hood and is extended therein by means of a coil
or coils, to expose ample extent of the pipe to insure vaporiza-
tion of the hydro-carbon liquid before it reaches the burners, so
that the vapor alone is emitted to the flames. The burners are
mere orifices or nozzles without valves, so that they will not clog
or become obstructed, and the use of such open nozzles is facili-
tated by the provision of the vaporizing coils referred to and the
emission of vapor only at the burners. The supply of liquid to
the coil is in this, as in the former construction, controlled by 2
suitable valve in the supply pipe between the hood and reservoir.
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 29
The burner nozzles are arranged in a horizontal position so
as to send the flame lengthwise of the hood and horizontally
over and along the surface to be treated. The burner noz-
gles may stand wholly without the hood and adjacent to its head
fin front of the openings in the head) or they may project
through openings im the head into the hood. The employment
of valveless burners or nozzles in connection with the vaporizing
coil leading to the burners, enables a cruder and cheaper quality
of oil to be used with perfect success.
The claims are five in number, all involved in this suit, and
read as follows:
“1. In*an apparatus for repairing asphalt pavements, the
combination with a hood, of one or more burners arranged
to discharge horizontally into the hood, said hood being
closed at the top, sides and one end thereof, and arranged to
confine the heat to the limits of the same, substantially as
described.
2. In an apparatus for repairing ‘asphalt pavements, the
combination with a hood open at one end thereof, of one or
more burners arranged to discharge into the other end of
said hood, said hood being arranged to confine the heat to
the limits of the same, substantially as described.
3. In an apparatus for repairing asphalt pavements, the
combination with a hood, closed at one end and open at the
other and provided with one or more perforations in the
closed end thereof, of one or more burners arranged to dis-
charge into the hood through said perforations, said hood
being arranged to confine the heat to the limits thereof,
substantially as described.
4. In an apparatus for repairing asphalt pavements. the
combination with a portably-mounted reservoir. a hood, and
a supply-pipe leading from said reservoir and disposed un-
derneath the hood, of one or more burners connected with
saul pipe and arranged to discharge horizontally into the
hood, said hood being arranged to confine the heat to the
limits thereof, substantially as described.
5. In an apparatus for repairing asphalt pavements, the
39 combination with a portably-mounted reservoir, a hood.
closed at its top, sides, and one end thereof, and a supply-
pipe leading from said reservoir underneath the hood and
terminating at a point beyond one end of the hood, of one
or more burners connected with said supply-pipe and ar-
UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. vs.
ranged to discharge horizontally into the hood substan
tially as described.”
Adjourned to. Thursday. September 16, 1897, .at 15 O'clock
a. m.
September 16 18g7.
Met pursuant to adjournment,
Present as before.
Direct examination of Melville E Dayton continued
A. (Answer continued.) The terms “arranged to confine the
heat to the limits of the same” (to the limits of the hood), have
reference to the feature of construction by which the hood, when
lowered to the ground will come in contact along its lower edges,
or practically so, with the surface of the pavement. In the prior
machines it would appear that the lower edges of the hood when
held horizontal would be a little above the surface of the pave-
ment, Or, when allowed to touch the pavement, it would do so
only at its outer or more remote end and a considerable space
would exist beneath its edges at other points. The hood is
shown in the prior patent as having four depending sides and it
would be a requisite, therefore, that the Operator maintam his
hold upon the handle and thereby sustain the hood a proper dis-
tance throurhout its length above the pavement. Being “ar-
ranged” to drop upon the pavement and to touch or proximate
it throughout the length of the hood, requires that one end
40 of the hood be open and permits the operator to detach his
hold, the machine being properly poised on its axle to al
low the hood to drop to the ground
The first two claims of patent, 560,599, are differentiated
mainly with reference to the opening left in one side or end of
the hood. In the first claim the hood is said specifically to be
“closed at the top, sides and one end.” In claim 2 the hood és
said to be “open at one end thereof” without being said to be
closed at the opposite end, as in the first claim. This is based
on the statement in the patent found at line 110, et seq., of page
2, which provides for the possibility of leaving the hood open,
under some circumstances, at the two opposite ends
Claim 3 is differentiated from claim 1 by omitting to specify
the horizontal direction of the discharge of the burners Claim 4
is differentiated from claim 1 by making the disposition of the
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 31
supply ppe “underneath the hood” (the coil) a specific feature.
Clim < involves the feature of carrying the supply pipe under-
neath the hood and then out of the hood where it is provided
or connected with “one or more burners,”’ here, as in claims 1
and 4, (istinetly specified as “arranged to discharge horizontally
into the hood.”
Q. 5 Referring to the first part of your answer to question 4,
please ste whether, according to vour understanding of Letters
Patent \o. 542,349 and £60,599, the apparatus therein described
and claumed in claim 1 of the first of these patents and in the
five clainis of the second of them is necessarily limited, by the
patents, to use in the practice of the method described and
claimed in Letters Patent No. 501,537?
A. The remark made by me and referred to in the question,
as | understand it, is as follows:
41 Each of the remaining two patents No. 542,349 and
s60,599, relates to apparatus for carrying out the method set
forth in the first of the three patents.”
I do not understand that the machine patents referred. to are
restricted to the use of the apparatus in the practice of the method
described and claimed in Letters Patent No. 501,537, but that
said machine patents cover said machines equally for all uses for
which they are adapted, notwithstanding said machines appear
to have been devised, primarily, for the practice of the previously
devised method of repairing asphalt pavement.
Whereupon Complainant's solicitor offers in evidence a
certain drawing marked “Complainant’s Exhibit Defend-
ants’ Device”, which is admitted to be the same drawing
which ts specified in the stipulation of facts between the par-
ties hereto, which is set forth at length on pages 2 and 3 of
the typewritten copy of this record.
(). 6 Have you read the stipulation of facts between the
parties hereto, which is set forth at length on pages 2 and 3 of
the typewritten copy of this record, and have you examined the
drawing marked “Complainant’s Exhibit Defendants’ Device.”
which is referred to in said stipulation, and do you understand
the construction shown in said drawing and the method of using
the apparatus so shown in the repair of asphalt pavement, as de-
scribed in said stipulation?
\. [ have and do
©. 7. Please compare the apparatus shown in “Complainant's
Exhibit Defendants’ Device” with the invention shown and de-
scribed in the drawings and specification of Letters Patent No.
Re UNITED stares REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Ys.
4
542.349, and particularly claimed in clair 1, thereof, and
42 also with the inventions described and shown in the speci.
fication and drawings of Letters Patent No. 560,599, and
specifically claimed in the five claims thereof, pointing out iq
answer wherein the construction of said defendant.’ device
is the same as or differs from the inventions so described and
claimed in said Letters Patent, and give in your answer {j
your reasons for any conclusions which may be stated by
In making this comparison you may, if you deem desirable, make
on said drawing of defendants’ device such marks or letters of
identification as you may see fit.
A. .I have applied to the drawing “Complainant's Exhibit
Defendants’ Device” the same letters of reference which are
plied to the corresponding parts in the later machine patent No,
560.599, with which the more extended comparison of Detend-
ants’ device is required to be made under the question. Said
drawing of Defendants’ device contains three figures, Fig. 1 is a
top or plan view with a part of the hood top broken away to show
the disposition of the supply pipe within the hood. Fig. 2 is an
end view of the hood looking at the closed end thereof. and Fig.
3 is a side elevation of the entire machine.
Placing this drawing of Defendants’ device along side the
drawing Fig. 1 of the patent in suit, No. 560,599, it is visually
evident that the machines have a general correspondence. The
reservoirs D and the hoods H of the two machines are substan-
tially alike in their relation to each other and to the carrying
wheels C, while the hoods are in both cases ngidly connected with
the wheel-supported reservoir by the same extended bars A,
which are bent alike in both cases to form the handle B. In
43 the patent the bars A extend back a distance above the hood
H, and are connected with the latter by the rigid straps G,
while in the Defendants’ device said bars A are bent downward
between the wheels and the hood so as to lie upon the hood and
are connected with the latter by the bolts g. In the patent the
supply pipe | emerges from the top of the reservoir D (though -
extending within the reservoir to near the bottom thereof) and
thence passes rearwardly and downwardly to a point opposite the
adjacent closed end of the hood through which it passes to form
a coil beneath the hood, as best shown in Figs. 2 and 4 of the
patent. In the drawing of defendants’ device this supply pipe |
emerges from the bottom of the reservoir D, and passes first
latterly and thence rearwardly through the adjacent closed end of
the hood to form the coil beneath the latter. In both cases alike
e
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 33
the supp!» pipe, after being extended and disposed suitably be-
neath and within the hood, projects at its end J’ out from the
hood through the closed end thereof, where it is laterally ex-
tended near the end of the hood, its lateral extension being pro-
yided with valveless “permanently open rozzles N,” which are
arranged to direct the flame jets horizontally into the hood to-
wards the open end thereof and around the coil of the supply
_ In the several figures of the patent drawing these nozzles
N are shown wholly external to the hood and adjacent to open-
ings in the closed end thereof, but the patent provides that they
mav extend beneath the hood and they are so shown in the
drawing of Defendants’ device. In both the patent and the draw-
ing of Defendants’ device the supply pipe is provided with a
hand valve L for regulating the supply of oil to the coil and
burners, and also with a further valve K, which the patent
44 says may desirably be a “cock valve” when gasolene or other
light oils are employed, and may be a “non-return or check-
valve’ when heavier oils are employed. When the lighter oils
are emploved and K is a cock-valve, the back pressure produced
by vaporization in the coil of the supply pipe beneath the hood,
will maintain the pressure in the reservoir more or less perfectly,
and obviate the necessity of entire reliance upon the air pump
to keep up such pressure; but when heavier oils are employed for
juel, the patent says “I prefer to rely upon the artificial pressure
obtained by means of the air pump, and substitute for the cock-
valve K a non-return check valve, which will permit the flow of
the oil under pressure from the tank to the burner, but will pre-
vent the return thereof or of the gas-generated in the pipes ex-
posed to the heat of the burners.”
In the drawings of the Defendants’ device the reservoir B, is
provided with a pressure gauge F, and is connécted with an air
pump FE. In the drawing of the patent this air pump is per-
manently mounted on the reservoir or frame, and is connected
by a rigid metal pipe with the valved pipe leading from the top
of the reservoir, while in the drawing of Defendants’ device the
air pump is not mounted rigidly on the frame and is connected
with the valved inlet to the reservoir by a flexible tube which I
have marked E’ In practice with the Defendants’ device, the air
pump will be placed on the ground as shown in Figs. 1 and 3, for
operation, but when the machine is to be shifted about the air
pump is laid upon the machine as I have indicated in dotted lines
in Fig. 3. The tank in both cases is provided with a suitable
inlet by which it may be filled
{™
/
34 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY Co. ys.
The differences with reference to the frame co
45 uniting the hood to the wheel-supported reservoir in ¢
two machines and in the arrangement of the SUPP!y pipe be.
tween the reservoir and the hood are manifestly merely
ical and wholly immaterial. The arrangement of the supply pig
J beneath and within the hood to form a circular coil. as shows
in the drawing of Defendants’ device, is also manifestly not an
essential difference from the arrangement of said supply pipe as
shown in Figs. 2, 4 and 5 of the drawing of the patent. There
are, therefore, no essential differences between Defendante’ de-
vice and the machine shown and described in Complainant's
patent 560,599. As to the valve K, I am informed that in De
fendants’ machine it is actually a check-valve or non-return valys.
which is one of the two forms of valve expressly provided for in
this Complainant's patent 560,599. The differences with
to the air pump are purely mechanical and have no relati n what-
ever to the operation of the machine and, as the air pump is not
a novel device in this patent 560,599, and is not dependent
a rigid connection with the reservoir or machine frame for its
Operation, as contemplated in said patent, the Defendants’ de-
vice here presents no essential difference from the device shown
in the patent.
Defendants’ device being in construction essentially the device
of the patent 560,599, it has necessarily the same mode of oper-
ation and the same adaptation for use, whether in connection
with asphalt pavement or otherwise. The specification of the
patent reads as literally to the Defendants’ device as it does to
that shown in the patent. I quote from the specifications as
applicable to Defendants’ device, the following (line 61, p. 2):
“* * * jets of flame are delivered to the hood at the
one end thereof and pass along under the hood out of the
46 forward open end thereof, thus serving to heat that portion
of the pavement covered by the hood in its passage through
the hood. To insure the heating of only so much of the
pavement as is covered by the hood. the hood may be al-
lowed to rest directly on the pavement, which can not be
done with hoods wherein vertically disposed blasts are em-
ployed, and as the ground in conjunction with the hood, in
point of fact constitutes a horizontal flue for the heat or
flame jet, even though the hood does not snugly fit the sur-
face of the ground, there will be a tendency to draw air in
at the side edges of the hood rather than to expel the heat
out from under the side edges. * * *
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 35
’ “The disposition of the supply pipe under the hood serves
to convert the liquid fuel into a gas which [in the case when
the valve K is not a check-valve, but is a cock-valve, as when
lighter oils are used] backs up and stores pressure in the
tank \, while at the same time supplying gas to the burners,
and by employing the horizontally disposed open burners
without valves I am enabled to use with perfect success a
very low gtade of crude petroleum. [In which case the
valve K will be a check-valve.] This feature is of great im-
portance in the economical use of a heater of this kind, for
with the heaters in which valved burners were employed it
was necessary to use a grade of gasolene costing from nine
to twelve cents a gallon, while I have successfully operated
a machine constructed in accordance with my present inven-
tion with crude petroleum costing but three cents per gal-
lon. Furthermore, there are no burners to be burned out,
with the attendant delay and expense occasioned thereby,
and a much more practical and satisfactory result is pro-
duced in the use of the machine.”
Adjourned to 2 o'clock, p. m.
2 o'clock, p. m.
(Answer continued.) The Defendant's device responds as fully
to the claims of the patent 560,599, as it does to the draw-
47 ings and specificatién proper, meeting them not only liter-
ally. but in full spirit and purpose. Under the stipulation
submitted to me, Defendants’ device is “an apparatus for repair-
ing asphalt pavements,” as specified at the opening of each of
the claims of this patent in suit. Reading the first claim thereto
said Defendants’ device presents:
“the combination with a hood of one or more burners ar-
ranged to discharge horizontally into the hood, said hood
being closed at the top, sides and one end thereof, and ar-
ranged to confine the heat to the limits of the same, sub-
stantially as described”
and shown in the patent in suit.
Reading claim 2 to said Defendants’ device, the device presents
“the combination with a hood open at one end thereof of
one or more burners arranged to discharge into the other
end of said hood, said hood being arranged to confine. the
heat to the limits of the same.” .
Having claim 3 in mind, Defendants’ device contains
“the combination with a hood closed at one end and open
at the other and provided with one or more'perforations in
a6 UNITED STATES BEPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. ys
the closed end thereof, of one or more burners arranged to
discharge into the hood through said perforations. said hood
being arranged to confine the heat to the limits thereof”
I do not think the claim necessarily implies that the
terminate outside the end of the hood and that the ‘lames are
made to pass through holes in the hood, or to exclude the pro-
jection of the nozzles through the holes-in the hood, so long as
the flames begotten or initiated at or adjacent to the closed end
of the hood having perforations, may sweep along the length of
the hood to the opposite open end thereof. Hence, | regard
defendant's device as answering to claim 3 just quoted from,
48 Defendants’ device responds to claim 4 in that it contains
“the combination with a portably mounted reservoir, 3
hood, and a supply pipe leading from said reservoir and dis-
posed underneath the hood, of one or more burners con-
nected with said pipe and arranged to discharge horizon-
tally into the hood, said hood being arranged to confine the
heat to the limits thereof.”
In like manner Defendants’ device answers to claim 5 since it
presents
“the combination with a portably mounted reservoir, a
hood, closed at the top, sides, and one end thereof and 2
supply pipe leading from said reservoir underneath the hood
and terminating at a point beyond one end of the hood, of
one or more burners connected with said supply pipe and
arranged to discharge horizontally into the hood.”
Taking up the patent number 542,349 in suit, and claim 1
thereof, the character of the valve which I have marked K in the
drawing of Defendants’ device may be important in the com-
parison of said device with the patent.
In the patent, as already pointed out, the supply pipe leading
to the burners is directly exposed to the flame blast beneath the
hood and, in the absence of an effective check-valve in said sup-
ply pipe, by reason of such exposure thereof to the flame blast
produces a back pressure in the reservoir, and thus obviates the
need for so frequent manipulation of the air pump. The first
claim (which is the claim in suit) only calls for the exposure of
the supply pipe “to the heat of the burners” and there are advan-
tages other than that of giving the back pressure in the reservoir
resulting from such exposure of the supply pipe. But the patent
refers to no other advantage than that of producing such
49 back pressure, and this back pressure will be prevented, and
the only advantage mentioned in the patent will be defeated,
if the valve which I have marked K in the drawing of Defend-
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 37
ants’ device be an effective check-valve. Hence, notwithstanding
Defendants apparatus may, as it certainly does, answer to the
terms of claim 1 of patent 542,349, it may not be held to conflict
with tha: claim, taken in connection with the specification, when
Defendants’ valve K is an effective check-valve and not a “cock-
yalve” or one-way plug.
The supply-pipe, being extended in a coil under the hood in
Defendants’ device, is most effectively “exposed to the heat of
the burners,” and Defendants’ device, therefore, responds per-
fectly to the terms of claim 1 of patent 542,340, which reads,
_ “1, In an apparatus for repairing asphalt pavements the
combination with a series of hooded fluid burners and a res-
ervoir for supplying fuel thereto, said reservoir and burners
being portably mounted, of a supply pipe connecting the res-
ervoir with the burners and exposed to the heat of the burn-
ers, substantially as described.”
The advantage which | have referred to as being present in
this construction other and independently of the advantage of
back pressure which is mentioned in the patent, is that such ex-
posure of the supply pipe constitutes the supply pipe itself a vapor
generator back of the burners so that only vapor is emitted in
the flame jets. This advantage is present in the apparatus
whether the valve K of the drawings of Defendants’ device be
a check-valve or an open valve, or whether a valve of either de-
scription be present in the supply pipe or not. The advantage
mentioned in the patent will be realized only if the valve at K
be an open valve or if it be a check-valve of such defective con-
struction or defective operation as will allow the vapor or
30 so-called gas to flow back towards the reservoir and give or
maintain the desired pressure in said reservoir.
Not having carefully inspected this valve in Defendants’ ma-
chine I can not say from personal observation whether it is a
“cock-valve” or a check-valve, or whether, if it be a check-valve.
it be of such construction or such defective operation as to actu-
ally permit a back-flow of vapor past it. I only know that a
valve externally resembling a “cock-valve” is there present in
Defendants’ machine, and that it is said by one of Defendants’
men who appears to be familiar with the construction of-the
machine to be a check-valve.
Wherefore. I repeat in conclusion, that Defendants’ machine
responds to the terms of claim 1 of the patent 542,349, and will
have one of the advantages of the construction defined in said
clam, but that whether or not it has the other advantage and
38 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY co. vs.
the only one mentioned in the patent, will depend, first,
whether or not the valve K in the drawing of-Defendants’ devies
is in fact a check-valve or an open one; and, second, unon 4
if said valve be of check-valve construction, it is actually ve
to the reservoir.
to prevent back passage of vapor from the exposed supply pipe |
©. 8. Take up the method patent No. 501,537, and compare
with it, and especially with claim 1 thereof. the method of repair.
ing asphalt pavements set forth in the stipulation referred to ig
my last question.
A. It is my opiriion that the stipulated operation performed
by Defendants with Defendants’ machine in the repair of pave.
ments is a practice of the invention set forth in saitl method
patent and defined in claim 1 thereof.
5! Defendants’ device being an apparatus which applies heat
to the surface of the pavement by means of a blast
essentially as contemplated in the method patent in Suit, and as.
performed by the adequate apparatus shown in said method patent
in suit, it is evident that the same degree of heat may be applied
in the same expeditious, certain and effective way by Defend —
ants’ device as by the device shown in the letters patent. Its
also evident from the terms of the stipulation that the method
in suit is complied with by Defendants with respect to the degree
and extent of the melting or softening of the surface asphalt at
and around a defective spot in the pavement, that is contemplated
in the method patent in suit. It is further evident that in such
use of Defendants’ device and in the repair of pavements in part
by the use of said device by Defendants, the use of tar or any
other cement or “solder” is obviated, that the union between
the patch of new material and the old pavement is direct. imme-
diate and complete without the intervention of an interposed
body of tar or like material, and that the joint need, therefore,
present none of the disadvantages, objections or defects in respect
either of appearance or of effectiveness, which distinguished the
old tar joint and which are obviated by the method here in con-
troversy.
The seraping off of the surface of the old pavement after soft-
ening it, to the extent of half an inch or so, is not, in my opin-
ion, a departure from the invention set forth in the patent, and is
only what I understand the patentee of Complainant's patent
promptly commenced to do in the early practice of the method
referred to. Moreover, it is, in my judgment, only what a ju-
dicious workman would do in order to get rid of the powdered
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 39
material and impurities originally placed upon the surface of
the pavement or subsequently accumulated therein, so as to
give a fresh surface of the old material for contact and union
with the fresh new material added. It is only a question of add-
ing so much more of the new material to make up for the old
material scraped away. The statements of the stipulation as to
what Defendants have done clearly answer to the terms of claim 1
of this patent which I again quote as follows:
“1. The method of repairing asphalt pavements which
consists In subjecting the spot to be repaired to heat, adding
new material and smoothing and burnishing, substantially as
described.”
There are three steps or process elements enumerated in this
claim, to wit: First, “subieeting the spot to be repaired to heat”;
second, ‘adding new material’; and third, “smoothing and bur-
nishing.’ These are all performed in the same order by the De-
fendants. The separate steps, are, moreover, essentially the same
in kind in Defendant's practice, as set forth in the patent. The
beat is applied to the spot to be repaired with a flame blast. The
new material added is the same in condition and character; it is
not tar or anv. part tar, but is solely the asphalt composition like
that of the old pavement. and in the soft condition and heated
state in which said composition is and was originally applied.
The smoothing and burnishing is the same step in both cases,
being the old and familiar operation performed by means of
heated metal tamping and smoothing irons long before used in
leveling and smoothing original asphalt pavement surfaces.
The results of Defendants’ operation are also the same as the
results set forth in the patent. The use of tar or equivalent
interposed cement is obviated, and nothing of this nature
53 exists between the patch and the original pavement in the
completed job. On the other hand, there is a direct union
hetween homogeneous materials and, as a consequence, there is
a perfect continuity in annearance as well as in fact, and there is
no lability of the breaking away of the patch from the pavement
by the yielding of an interposed cement. In addition to these
results relating to the character and efficiency of the completed
work, there is also the same result as to the expedition and cheap-
ness with which the work of rep2ir may be effected. There is.
therefore, perfect identity between the method practiced by De-
fendants and that set forth in the patent and specified in claim 1
thereof, with respect to the nature and order of the steps invoived
and to the results and advantages claimed. If the removal by
40 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Vs.
Defendants of a shallow portion of the surface asphalt whieh jg
not mentioned in the patent, though practiced by Complai
be regarded as a difference from the patent, it is, nevert
in my judgment, not a departure from the patent, but ic
an addition of a step to the three stens enumerated, and on
which, moreover, does not affect the character or resul: of said
three steps further than that it is a prudent expedient to make
said three steps the more effective.
I do not overlook the fact that the specification of the patent
§01,537 provides for an additional step, namely, the agitation or
stirring up of the softened material of the old pavement prélim-
inary to the addition of the new material. But this is not included
in claim 1 here in suit. On the other hand it annears to be ex.
pressly excluded from said claim by its specific inclusion in claim
2. Moreover, such stirring or agitation of the old material
54 can have no other effect than to roughen its surface and to
thus allow parts of the new material to intermingle or inter-
lock with parts of the old, and this is practically accomplished,
im my understanding, by the removal or raking of a shallow por-
tion off of the old pavement, as practiced alike by Defendant and
Complainant.
In view of the foregoing considerations. | regard the operatics
of repairing asphalt pavements with the aid of the flame blast
apparatus, all as set forth in the stipulation referred to. as being
# oractice of the method set forth in the complainant's patent
NO. 501,537, and specified in claim 1 thereof.
Adjourned to Friday, September 17. 1897, at to o'clock a m
September 17, 1897.
Met pursuant to adjournment.
Present. as before
O. 9. Please state whether or not the inventions specifically
claimed in the seven claims herein sued upon are capable of con-
joint use?
A. They are.
©. 10. Does the valve K shown in the drawing of Defendants
device, appear from the face of that drawing to be in anv essential
particular different from the valve K shown in Fig. 1 of the draw-
ines of the apparatus patent No. 560.590
A. It does nat.
©. 11. Is there anything which appears on the face of the
drawing of Defendants’ device, or in the stipulation herein re
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 41
lating thereto, which in any way indicates or intimates that the
valve K is other than a cock-valve?
. 55 A. There is not.
©. 12. Deo you know under whose direction the drawing
of Defendants’ device, here in evidence, was made?
A. It was prepared under the direction of Mr. Smith, a prac-
tical man in the employ of the defendant, who, after I had pro-
duced a rough sketch, was called in by Defendants’ counsel to
direct the preparation of the finished drawing or tracing referred
to, to wit, “Complainant's Exhibit, Defendants’ Device.”
Cross-Examination by Mr. J. H. Peirce.
X. Q. 13. Suppose it should appear, as a matter of fact, that
the valve K, as used in Defendants’ device, was not a “cock-valve”
but was a “check-valve,” what of it?
' A. In that case, which I considered in my answer to question
7, and as I there stated, there would, in my opinion, be a ques-
tion for the Court to determine whether or not Defendants
device or apparatus infringes the first claim of the apparatus pat-
ent No. 542,349, because, although the Defendants’ device ap-
pears to respond fully to the terms of said claim and would, in
the supposed casé, realize a certain advantage of the construction
defined in that claim, it would not realize the particular advan-
tage set forth in said patent specification. :
X. QO. 14. You speak of producing a “rough sketch" after
which this exhibit drawing, “Defendants’ Device” was prepared
under Mr. Smith's direction; who made the rough sketch re
ferred to?
A. I did.
X. Q. 15. Did such sketch purport to show Defendants’ ma-
chine?
36 =©6 A. It did so purport, and it did so show, in general and
roughly
X. 0. 16. Had you seen Defendants’ machine before the sketch
was made?
A. IT had.
X. Q. 17. Was such machine then in operation?
A. It was not.
X. Q. 18. Did said machine have a valve at the place marked
K, in this exhibit Defendants’ Device”?
A. It did, as to external appearance
X. Q. 19. What sort of a valve did it appear to be to you?
42 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Va.
A. ‘Having a squared plug in its top, I took it to be a stop.
cock or valve of the one-way plug order.
X. Q. 20. On that machine was there an adjacent valve, as
at the point marked L on the “Defendants’ Device”?
A. There was a hand-wheel valve.
X. Q. 21. The hand-wheel valve mentioned would be of the
“one way order,” would it not?
A. Not of the one-way plug order, but of the order known as
globe-valve, in which the stem projecting from the hand-wheel is
a screw, and is provided with a disk at its lower end having a
tapered edge which seats in a tapered seat or passage in the hori-
zontal portion of the deflected diaphram within the globe or bulb
of the casing. This valve has only a single passage which
be opened a greater or less distance Ly rotation of the screw stem af
the hand-wheel and is especially intended and adapted to
the flow of the liquid fuel as well as to shut off the flow enti i
57 X.Q. 22. What would the one-way plug valve K do, Which
the globe-valve L, adjacent thereto, would not?
A. It would serve: here as a general protection against the
mischievous opening of the pipe and the discharge of the contents
of the reservoir when the apparatus is lying about out of use. It
is provided only with a square for a wrench, and, therefore, requires
a special tool to open it. On the other hand, the globe-valve, with
its always present hand-wheel, besides being liable to be started
open by an accidental movement of the hand-wheel, presents a tempt-
ing means to a small boy for opening the valve
X. Q. 23. Who made this exhibit “Defendants’ Device”?
A. Mr. Rheem, a draughtsman in this city
X.Q. 24. At whose request did Mr. Rheem make it?
A. It was requested by counsel for Complainant that a careful
drawing be made by Mr. Rheem to meet the full approval of
counsel for Defendants, in place of the temporary and rough
sketch which I had produced, and for use in connection with the
stipulation which accompanies the drawing
X. Q. 25. At the time Mr. Rheem received his first instruc-
tions respecting this exhibit “Defendants’ Device,” he was in
attendance at the office of Mr. Raymond, counsel for Complain-
ant, was he not?
A. He was
X. Q. 26. Who were there beside, at that meeting?
A. Counsel for Defendants, the Mr. Smith heretofore referred
ASSYRIAN ABPHALT COMPANY. 43
tp as one of Defendant's employes, and Mr. Culmer, an officer of
the defendant company.
X. 0.-27. Did you hear Mr. Smith say that the valve
marked K on this exhibit drawing “Defendants’ Device,”
was a check-valve?
Mr. Barnett: Objected to as immaterial.
A. I did, and I have so stated in my direct.
X. Q. 28. After this exhibit drawing was finished, do you
know that Mr. Smith’s attention was specifically directed to the
appearance of valve K, as shown on the drawing, and which seems
to show it as a cock-valve?
A. I do not know, but I do know that it corresponds in ap-
nce, externally, with the description given to Mr. Rheem
and myself bv Mr. Smith at the interview referred to, and I will
add, that its external appearance is consistent with its being a
check-valve of the particular kind Mr. Smith stated it to be at
that time, namely, a check-valve having a hinged depending flap
which closes upon a vertical or inclined seat around a horizontal
opening or passage. This is a form of check-valve which is not
common, I believe, so that I was first led to take the valve to be
a stop-valve, which it also resembles externally.
X. QO. 29. The Perkins Patents here in controversy relate to
the repair of asphalt pavements; what is an asphalt pavement?
A. It is a pavement of which the surface layer is a composi-
tion into which asphalt enters as an ingredient. The pavement
as now made usually comprises a foundation or bed-laver of grout,
a laver resting upon the grout, of broken stones cemented to-
gether by asphalt, the fragments of stone being about half or
three-quarters of an inch in diameter, and a top layer of asphal:
composition composed of about seventy-five per cent sand,
39 fifteen per cent asphaltum containing a small quantity of
residuum oil, and ten per cent of lime stone flour. The
foundation course or bed of grout may be several inches in thick-
ness, the intermediate layer or binder of broken stone and asphalt
is about an inch or an inch and a half in thickness, and the super-
ficial laver of asphalt composition is about an inch and a half
or two inches in thickness. A sprinkline of fine granulated ce-
ment is thrown or swept over the top of the pavement after it
has been smoothed and leveled, and this may be said to form a
part of the pavement, inasmuch as it adheres to and becomes
embedded in the immediate surface of the asphalt layer.
X. 0. 30. What is the “asphaltum” which you mention as an
ingredient in the top layer of “asphalt comnosition”?
44 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. vs,
A. It is a mineral product of a bituminous character, as T gq,
derstand it, sometimes called mineral tar.
X. Q. 31. Do you know that this “asphaltum”’ melts at abou:
the temperature of boiling water?
A. I do not know it specifically from any experiments of
observation of the exact temperature at which it melts, but |
should say that that would be the fact.
X. Q. 32. From the Century Dictionary, under the title
“asphalt” the statement is: “In the United States the substance
so named is commonly made of refuse tar from gas houses mixed
with slaked lime and gravel. Also called asphaltic cement.” Ifa
pavement had a top layer in which the “refuse tar from
houses” was employed in lieu of the asphaltum or “mineral tar,”
would the repair of such a pavement, according to the Perking
inventions, be an infringement thereof?
60 A. I don’t know of any reason why it would not be.
X. Q. 33. You are aware, I suppose, that the early asphalt
pavements at Washington employed the tar or pitch from
houses in lieu of the asphaltum or mineral tar, as an ingredient
for the top layer of the pavements: am I correct?
A. I don’t know whether or not that is the fact.
X. O. 34. Are the several. Perkins inventions here in suit
applicable for the repair of sidewalks, allevs, viaducts, sub-way,
tunnels and cellars, as well as for the repair of pavements?
A. I suppose the question means the flooring of the places
referred to, and in that case I understand them to be pavements
in fact, and to come under the term pavement as employed in
the patents.
X. QO. 35. Will you give us an idea of the nature and causes
of the defects in a pavement which leads to a resort to these sey-
eral Perkins inventions for the purpose of repairs.
Mr. Barnett: Question objected to as immaterial and
irrelevant.
A. I don’t know that I can do so as to all the causes which
practical men in the art of asphalt pavements have discovered.
I have observed cracks in pavements which seemed to have been
produced by contraction under extreme changes in temperature,
and others which appeared to have resulted from heaving. |
have also observed depressions (which constitute defects), which
2ppeared to have resulted from local settling: and I have also
observed broken spots in pavements whefe the suriace is dis-
61 integrated, from what special cause I do not know. I have
also observed defects resulting from a car running off the
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 45
track upon the pavement, perhaps before becoming completely
set and hardened, or when in some degree softened by extreme
heat of the sun. IT have also seen spots where injury to the pave-
ment has been inflicted by the stamping of a horse, left to stand
for a long time in one place. Further than these, | do not now
Il.
<3 © 36. Are said Perkins inventions directed to the repair
of any other than the top layer of pavements made up as you
state, of the asphalt composition?
A I think not. That is to say, the method claim pertains
exclusively, as I understand it, to the repair of the surface of
asphalt pavements, and the machine patents, in so far as they
relate to the use of the machine there described in the repair of
asphalt navements, are intended specially to carrv out, or assist
in carrying out, the method of the process patent. There is, of
course, nothing to prevent the use of the machines for any pur-
for which they are adapted, including a treatment of, say,
the binder course of a pavement, if necessary, or the softening
of the surface of a Klondike gold mine.
Adjourned to 2 o'clock p. m.
2 wo clock p. m.
X. ©. 37. In repairine pavements according to the method
claimed under Perkins Pat. No. 501,537, what result ensues on
“subjecting the spot to be repaired to heat" which would not
ensue if such heat were omitted?
A. The heating contemplated in this patent is such as to
melt the top of the asphalt layer to some suitable depth and to
reduce it to the condition of softness in which it was originally
laid; this is the immediate result. As a further result the
62 old surface material is adapted to be removed or broken up
by raking or otherwise, so as to present fresh and broken sur-
faces for contact with new material added; and, as a still further
result, the new material applied in a heated state is adapted to
be amalgamated with the old material at the edges and bottom
ef the patch (so to call it) and thus, tipon the application of the
tamping and smoothing irons, will form an imperceptible and
integral joint
X. ©. 38. Owing to disintegration at a given spot, let us
assume that the top portion of the pavement there, i. e. the
asphalt composition layer. has quite disappeared thus exposing
the binder layer next beneath. The operator sweeps the spot
clean, heats it with a charcoal brazier or salamander fire, sprinkles
46 UNITED STATES KBPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Va.
a dope of coal tar or liquid asphaltum—heated—about the border
and over the surface of the exposed binder layer; fills the hole
with fresh, hot asphalt composition, levels, stamps and burnishes
the filling and finishes the job: Would such procedure involye
the practice of Perkins’ method as claimed by patent No,
§01,537?
Mr. Barnett: Question is objected to as being indefinite
unless it shall indicate more clearly what is meant by “the
spot” which is assumed to be heated with a charcoal brazier
or salamander fire, whether the exposed binder layer or oth-
erwise.
Mr. Peirce: Mr. Witness, do you understand my ques.
tion?
Mr. Barnett: This last question is further objected to,
as whether the witness understands the question or not is
not material unless the question is sufficiently clear on its
63 face for the purpose of this record, or, unless the witness sees
fit to state what his understanding of it is.
A. Replying to the last question which asks if | understand
the question preceding it. I answer that I think I do.
X. QO. 39. In such view kindly proceed to deal with my hypo-
thetical question, i. e., X. Q. 38.
A. I do not think it would.
X. Q. 40. Why would such procedure not involve said Perkins
method ?
A. Primarily such procedure would be the old tar method of
patching, and, in the nature of the case, that is, by reason of the
application of the tar, union and even contact of the old and
new materials of the pavement will be prevented. The integrity
of the patch with the body of the pavement aimed at and accom.
plished by the method of the patent is, therefore, impossible. and
the advantages of such integrity of the parts, as set forth in the
patent, are unachieved. On the other hand, all the defects oftthe
old tar method of patching which the patent seeks to obviate,
are present. It appears to me to be a feature of the patented
method, or a characteristic of the steps of applying the new ma-
terial, that the new material is placed into direct contact with
the old, as if the claim read “adding new material in direct con-
tact with the old material and smoothing and burnishing it.”
X. O. 41. The conditions otherwise being the saine as stated
by my hypothetical question, let us suppose that the top layer
of asphalt composition is two inches thick; is disintegrated to
the depth of one inch, and that the remaining inch, on being
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 47
softened by the salamander fire, is raked off clean, leaving
64 the binder layer exnosed, while the subsequent procedure
defined by the question, i. e., sprinkling the spot with dope,
et seq., is still preserved. Wouldguch a mode of treatment fall
within said Perkins method, and if not, why not?
A. In my judgment it would not and for the sufficient reason
iven in answer to cross question 40.
X. O. 42. And what do you sav if the softened remnant of the
asphalt layer were left in situ after heating but were coated wit!
the hot tar or asphaltum and the filling and finishine of the spots.
were proceeded with as defined by my hypothetical question X. Q.
?
A. | would say the same as in answer to said X. O. 38, which
is given in answer to X. Q. 40, and in my last answer.
There is, at best, in the supposed procedure a failure to com-
ply with the step of “adding new material” which, according to
the patent, is the adding of new material directly in contact with
the old, such new material being the asphalt composition and not
the different material of tar or its equivalent, melted asphalt. In
other words, the supposed procedure does not involve the aboli-
tion of a cement or what the patent calls a “solder.”
X. Q. 43. Recurring to the procedure defined by method
claim 1, in Perkins’ Pat. No. 501,537, do you say that the terms
thereof would be satished if the spot to be repaired were heated
by means of a brazier or salamander fire, in lieu of the gasoline
burner fire set forth by the patent; the conditions otherwise being
the same as defined by said claim?
A. Lam not able to say. I believe that a brazier with a fresh
and properly charged fire in it could be used for the purpose of
heating the surface of the asphalt layer with the effect con-
65 templated in the patent, namely, that of melting the “surface
asphalt” and reducing it to the condition of softness in which
it was first laid and suitable for its being raked or scraped -o
expose its inner and fresh surfaces for direct union with similar
new asphalt composition, as proposed in the patent in suit. I,
therefore, believe that a brazier could be employed for the work
of heating referred to in the patent, but whether the patent is
restricted to the use of a blast-flame in fulfillment of the stated
object of accomplishing the repairing “quickly and cheaply” is,
it seems to me, a question which will depend, first, upon whether
the blast is, in fact, more expeditious and cheaper than the brazier
system of heating and, second, whether the prior art which the
defense may develop, shall show a necessity for so restricting
an UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Ya.
the patent-and claim. I am unable to state what the relative mer.
its of the two heating devices are, or what the prior art may
finally show to be old.
X. O. 44. Which device is capable of developing the higher
heat; the gasoline burner disclosed by Perkins’ Pat. No 501,537,
or the ordinary charcoal brazier or salamander?
A. I am unable to say, not having made comparison of the
two.
X. Q. 45. You have no opinion upon this point which you
would venture to express? \
A. I have none. As to the brazier. it is obvious that its ae
tion will depend upon the distance at which it is supported over
the pavement, upon the condition of the fire therein. upon the
draft of the fire as affecting the rapidity of combustion and the
incandescence of the coals, &ec.
X. Q. 46. Suppose you were to kindle a bright, low fire
66 directly on the spot to be repaired, would the heat thence
obtained suffice to satisfy the prescription of method claim 1
in Perkins’ Pat. No. 501,537: the conditions otherwise being the
same as there stated?
A. I do not think it would. A bright log fire is a good thing
with which to thaw out frozen ground to a considerable depth,
as [ have seen it employed in making street, sewer and water pipe
repairs, and it would be a good enough thine with which to burn
and melt out the entire depth of an asphalt pavement. or for soft-
ening it in cold weather so that it could be chopped out: but it is
not, in my judgment, a suitable means for making a limited repair
in the “surface asphalt” of a pavement where the object is to heat
and soften a limited extent of area and depth and with substan-
tial uniformity, so that the repair may be restricted practically to
the defect to be remedied and waste or unnecessary consumption
of new material may be avoided. All such wood fires as are de-
scribed in the question are liable, in the nature of the case. to heat
to different degrees different parts of the underlying surface and
to burn some portions while failing to adequately heat others
X. Q. 47. Should the wood fire in question “burn some por-
tions” of the pavement. what specific ingredient or ingredients
thereof is thus “burned”?
\. This appears to me to be a question in chemistry in which
Iam not an expert, but, answering to the best of my ability, 1
understand that the sand which forms about seventy-five per cent.
of the composition is not burned: the limestone powder is not
burned and the non-combustible elements of the asphalt and of
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 49
the residuum oil are not burned, but that the carbon of the
asphalt and of the oil are burned.
xX. Q. 48. If the asphaltum present as an ingredient of
the composition layer is not burned or coked under the con-
ditions stated, do you say that such ingredient is non-combust-
le?
4 | understand that there are non-combustible clements in
the asphaltum and in the residuum oil, and that after the combus.
tion of such combustible materials as are at present in these in-
ients, and the volatilization of such constituents as will be
ihus acted upon and thereby eliminated, it is my understanding
that incombustible and non-coherent constituents are left.
X. Q. 49. So far as the asphaltum present in the top pave-
ment laver is “burnt” by the heat of the wood fire, as suggested.
the asphaltum loses its cohesion; am I correct?
A. It is my understasding that the overheating resulting in
what is called “burning’’ of asphaltum composition used in pave-
ments, whether performed by one means of heating or another, is
destructive of the cohesiveness and generally ofthe usefulness of
the material for paving purposes.
X. Q. 50. Do you understand that the “heat” described in
claim 1 of Perkins’ Pat. No. 501,537 is such as will melt (without
“burning’’) the composition beneath and thus bring it to sub-
stantially the same degree of softnéss as the new material to be
added ?
A. The heat described in the patent is such as to effect the
result stated in the question, and the apparatus for supplying the
heat, being capable of regulation as to the flames, would seem to
be such as might be able to give this result. The language of the
patent is (page 1, line 79):
f8 “As explained above when it is desired to repair a spot the
apparatus is moved adjacent therete with the burners direct-
ly above the spot. These soon reduce the surface asphalt
both at the spot and at the surrounding edges to a pliable
state, the strong blast causing not only the immediate sur-
face, but the particles deep down to be melted and yet not
burned.”
Elsewhere, to-wit, in the sentence beginning at line 39, page!.
the surface asphalt is said to be “reduced to the soft pliable state
in which it is originally laid.”
X.Q0. 51. If the degree of heat were such.as to not only melt
but also to burn the immediate surface and as well “the particles
deep down”, would such procedure be an infringement of Perkins’
z
at
50 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. vs.
method claim 1; assuming that the old layer thus burned were
raked away clean before the new filling was supplied.
A. I think it would. There must be a melting in advanee of
the burning and the removal of the burned part would leave the
unburned and melted part in condition for direct union with new
material added to fill the place. This might be regarded as per.
haps, in a degree, a wasteful mode of employing the Process, or,
on the other hand, as an economical mode, in view of the less care
that would be required in regulating the heat or time of e
and in view of the purpose to in any case take off the immediate
surface as the best means of obtaining a fresh surface for contact
and union with the new material to be added.
X. Q. 52. If the operator, after heating and raking off the
burned material as suggested in my last question, should leave
the spot to cool down and later return there again, softening the
edges of the hole by piling the hot new material thereon, then
coating the edges and bottom with hot tar or asphaltum and
finally raking the new material into the depression, and
69 smoothing and finishing as usual. Would such practice he in
accord with the subject-matter specified by claim 1 of Per.
Rins’ Pat. No. 501,537?
A. I do net know that I exactly understand the question, It
assumes that the asphalt around the excavation made after heat-
ing is first allowed to cool and harden and is then again heated by
piling hot new material upon the old surface around the excaya-
tion so that the edges of said excavation are, as | understand it,
in a soft condition when the new material is pushed into the hole
from around it to fill the latter. But before pushing the new ma-
terial into the hole the edges and bottom of the hole are coated
with tar. After the hole is filled with the hot new material I am
not certain whether the “raking” mentioned in the question in-
volves the mixing of the old material around the margin with the
new material inserted in the hole and with the tar anplied to the
edres of the hole, or not. If the old and new asphalt materials
ere mixed with each other and with the originally interposed tar,
then I should think that, as to the edges, there might be sucha
direct union of the old and new material as the patent contem-
plates, both being only somewhat reduced or diluted by the added
tar. If there be no such inter-raking of old and new materials
there would, in my judgment, be no practice of-the invention at
any part of the repair
X. Q. 53. And would your answer be the same if the dope of
hot tar or asphaltum, suggested by the question, were omitted?
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 51
A. No. There would then be no question, in my judgment,
that the invention of the patent would be practiced.
Adjourned to September 18, 1897, at 10 o'clock a. m.
September 18, 1897.
Met pursuant to adjournment. *
Present. as before.
Cross-Examination of Melville E. Dayton continued by Mr.
Peirce.
Mr. Peirce: Before proceeding with the further examina-
tion of the witness, I desire to say that: Since the testimony
of Mr. Dayton—Complainant’s expert—was begun, I have
been informed, for the first time, that it is customary prac-
tice with the defendant Co., in making asphalt navement re-
pairs to apply a coat or “solder” of melted asphaltum to the
clean, exposed surfaces of the hole or spot just before the
new asphaltum composition ts filled in. Whether this is the
invariable practice, I do not know thus far.
The stipulation between the parties now of record and
which deals with Defendants’ repair procedure is silent on
the detail above specified, and I regret that such particular
should have been overlooked, although | was ignorant of the
fact, and suppose that the Defendants’ employes with whom
I conferred, did not recognize the seeming significance of
the detail.
At present I am trying to verify the correctness of my
information touching the use of the “solder” of melted as-
phaltum as stated with the endeavor to rectify the omission
of said stipulation on such poimt or to permit Complainant to
offer testimony directed to this partieular of Defendants
practice, as counsel may be advised.
Mr. Barnett: Solicitor for complainant objects to the
above statement at this point, before the completion of the
deposition of Mr. Dayton, his deposition having proceeded
thus far on the stipulated statement of facts, and the re-
direct examination oi this witness as so far planned by solic-
itor for complainant being intended to bear directly on the
points involved in the statement of Mr. Peirce. Such re-
direct examination, necessarilyghaving to follow the state-
ment of Mr. Peirce made at this time, and the witness’ an-
swers thereto may seem to be influenced by the statement of
Mr. Peirce when such, in fact, is not the case.
52 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. ys.
Further, Complainant's solicitor submits that in -
the stipulation of facts which has been agreed to by the par.
ties hereto and, as he understands, after submission to Mr
Culmer, an officer and practical man of the Defendant Com.
pany, he described the method used by the Defendant Com.
panv as he was informed that it actually was practiced in the
making of small repairs, and without involving the use of a
coating of tar, liquid asphaltum or other “solder.”
X. Q. 54. What specific quality inheres in coal tar hich ren.
ders it objectionable as a “solder” or dope when applied to the
exposed surface of the spot to be repaired just prior to filling in
the new asphalt composition?
A. Referring to the patent for a reply on this question, and
having reference to the use of the tar “solder” as employed in the
prior art recognized by the patent (in which prior art | judge that
there was no material heating or softening of the material around
the excavation, and that such surrounding material was not
72 ina soft condition at the time of applying the tar), I under.
stand that the quality in the tar which caused it to serve asa
solder or connection between the old and new material was its
adhesiveness. The statement of the patent is (line 12, page 1):
“When the [old] material has been removed the depres-
sion thus made is thoroughly cleaned and given a coat or
dressing of tar. New material in a heated state has then
been placed in the depression and been ironed down and
smoothed off in the usual manner of finishing, the tar acting
as a solder to hold the new material in nlace
The objectionable feature of this interposed tar thus applied to
unite the practically hard and unheated wall of the excavation to
the maretm or surface of the new material, is that it forms a dis-
tinct body of material which is not homogeneous with the ma-
terials between which it is interposed (being destitute of those
ingredients which in the pavement give strength and perman-
nence), and that it is liable, therefore, to give way and to release
the patch under strains due to changes of temperature, for exam-
ple. when the pavement is subjected to further use. Another ob
jectionable feature mentioned in the patent and due, evidently, to
its being a material different from the composition to which it is
applied, is that it is unsightly, making, as the patent Says, a
“plainly discernible” line
X. QO. <5. Would the same objection exist if melted asphaltum
were used as a “solder” instead of hot coal tar, or coal tar pitch?
A. Tam unable to speak concerning any specific differences
which may. exist between tar, referred to in the patent, and as
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 53
phaltum, but I have heretofore regarded the two equivalents
73 and as productive of the same objectionable results in use by
the former method described in the patent. To anticipate
somewhat a statement which I expect to be afforded opportunity
to make hereafter in this examination, but here confining myself
to this question, I should say that the objectionable results of the
use of any material such as melted tar or asphalt will be, in large
measure. due to the condition of hardness of the wall or surface
to which the tar or asphalt is applied for the purpose of serving
asa “solder.” In other words, when applied to a hot and disinte-
grated and broken or loose surface, the hot material applied as a
dope may be dissipated by penetration, or even by mixing in the
act of its application, so as to lose its identity to a greater or less
extent, and there may be a difference of which I can not now
speak between the tar referred to in the patent, and the asphalt
referred to in the question.
X. O. 56. Why can you not now—as well as later on—speak
of the possible difference between the tar referred to in the patent
and the asphaltum referred to by my question just prior?
A. Because | have made no direct comparison of the two, and
because, without such comparison, I am unable to say whether or
not there is a difference.
X. O. 57. By making no “direct comparison” do you mean
you have made or observed no direct experiments, or merely that
you have made no direct discussion between the two in the testi-
mony thus far?
A. I mean that | have made no experiments or observations
in the nature of a comparison.
X. QO. 58. According to Perkins’ Pat. No. 501,537 (p. 1, line
Rs). the blast flame is said to cause:
74 “Not only the immediate surface, but the particles deep
down to be melted and yet not burned.”
This avoidance of “burning” as specified, is it of the inciment
sort such as a flap-jack experiences when it escapes scorching, or
is it of the extreme sort, as when the flap-jack shrivels up and
consumes away to an ash?
A. It is not necessary to be either of these. [ understand the
term “burned” to have reference, in the patent, to the condition
produced by heat in which the material said to be burned is in-
jured for the purpose a pavement, and I understand the whole
statement of the patent referred to in the question, as being de-
scriptive of a result of an operation capable of performance by the
apparatus mentioned in the preceding sentences of the same pat-
Ba UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. vs,
ent. The burning of the surface of a flap-jack (and I am an
on flap-jacks) which consists only in the browning of the surface
along with the cooking of the interior, is not harmful to the arti.
cle for its intended purpose, but the burning which causes it 4g
shrivel and turn to ash, as described in the question, is, on the
other hand, destructive of the flap-jack for food purposes
X. O. 59. With the description existing as at present in the
Perkins Pat. No. 501,537, Defendants expect to show in due
course, that the application for such patent originally contained
a claim as follows, viz: ;
“3. The method of repairing asphalt pavements which
consists in subjecting the spot to be repaired to a str
blast of heat, adding new material and smoothing and bur.
nishing it, substantially as described.”
On comparison of such claim with present claim 1, of said pat-
ent it appears that the spot to be repaired is subjected in one
instance, to “a strong blast of heat” while in the other or
75 patent claim 1, it is subjected “to heat.” What force, if any,
' do you give to the words “strong blast of heat” in distine-
tion from the more general term of “heat”?
Mr. Barnett: Objected to for the reason that the ques-
tion calls for a consideration by the witnéss of a segregated
part of the contents of the file wrapper of the application for
the patent mentioned, without giving the witness an Oppor-
tunity to consider the quoted phrase and alleged original
claim with legitimate reference to the whole of the contents
of the file wrapper
\. I prefer to express no opinion on the matter inquired of in
the question, because I have not seen the file wrapper and con-
tents, and do not know under what circumstances the alleged
original claim was supplanted by the first claim of the patent.
X. Q. 60. For your fuller information I desire to say that the
application for such patent originally contained, as I am informed,
the existing claims 1 and 2, and the additional claim 3 I have
quoted, but none other beside. The description and drawing of
the patent were the same when said claim 3 Was originally present
as such description and drawing now appear in the patent. With
this further explanation, do you choose to respond to my prior
question?
Mr. Barnett: The last objection is repeated, and this
question is further objected to as asking the witness to give
an answer based upon Mr. Peirce’s conclusions as to a part
of the contents of the file w rapper of the application for this
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 55
patent. It is further objected that nothing contained in the
file wrapper can have any significance, or can be properly
considered by the witness except in the light of the entire
contents of the file wrapper, including the letters of rejection
an! any references therein cited, if in fact, there were any
such letters of rejection or references. And Defendants’ so-
licitor having here in his possession at this examination the
original office file of the application for this patent as kept
by the solicitors who obtained this patent, he is requested to
submit the same to the witness, if he desires to examine the
witness in this connection.
Mr. Peirce: By my question I have laid before the wit-
ness all of the material, including description, drawing and
claim, which were laid before the Patent Office, as I under-
stand, by Perkins’ solicitors, who are Complainants’ counsel
in this cause, at the time the application was originally en-
tered. Presumably some distinction was attempted to be
drawn between the use of “heat” as specified by patent claim
i, and the use of “a strong blast of heat” as specified by
original claim 3 now eliminated. I asked the witness to act
upon the data which Messrs. Raymond & Omohundro pre-
sented to the Patent Office, and which the Patent Office had
occasion to consider in dealing with the application as orig-
inally filed.
Mr. Dayton, will you kindly answer my question?
Mr. Barnett: In view of the preceding explanation by De-
fendants’ solicitor, it is further objected that it is utterly im-
material what distinction the patentee’s solicitors attempted
to draw in their first draft of the claims submitted to the
Patent Office; and, further, that a comparison of the first
draft of the claims with the claims as actually allowed. is
utterly immaterial except when considered with relation to
the data before the applicant's attorneys when the claims
were put into the form in which they were allowed, and espe-
cially unless considered with relation to any communication
from the Patent Office tu the applicant with relation there-
to, as to the existence of such communications, if any, and as
to the contents of which the witness has not been informed.
The last question corrects a misapprehension into which I
was led by the preceding question, and it gmay have begotten
some further misapprehension, although on its face it appears
perfectly intelligible and fair. Answering as | understand the
question. which is:
“What force, if any, do you give to the words ‘strong blast
\
\
56 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. vA.
of heat in distinction from the more general term of ‘heat’
I reply that “strong blast of heat” is, as counsel Says, less “
eral” than the term “heat,” and this is true even if the term
“heat” as employed in claim 1 of the patent be understood to
mean “blast of heat”, because a “blast of heat” may be éither
“strong” ot weak, or it may be of intermediate force.
X. QO. 61. Referring to the apparatus invention here in suit,
viz., Perkins Pat. No. 542,349, and Perkins Pat. No. 560,599. do
you say that the improvements there set forth would be practiced
if the carrying wheels employed to sustain the oil tank were omit.
ted and supporting legs used instead?
Mr. Barnett: Question objected to as in substance ask.
78 ing the witness to state a matter of law, to-wit, whether a
given construction would be an infringement, or, as the ques.
tion savs, “a practice” of the invention of these patents,
While the witness may, as 4 matter of mechanics give his
opinion as to identity or otherwise, of stated constructions,
he is not authorized to say whether a given construction
would, as a matter of law. be a practice of the invention.
A. ° The carrying wheels referred to in the question are the
devices which make the annaratus a “portably mounted” one, as
distinguished from being merely a portable apparatus, which
might exist without wheels. The words “portably mounted” are
found, I believe, in only three of the machine claims in suit, to-
wit, claim 1 of patent 542,349, and claims 4 and 5 of patent 560,
599. It is mv understanding that wheels or their equivalent as 4
“mounting” are called for by said claims which contain the words
“portably mounted,” said terms being limitations upon these
claims. I have no opinion to express as to the remaining claims,
that being clearly a matter of construction resting wholly with
the Court
X. Q. 62. The machines of these Perkins apparatus patents
being otherwise unchanged, suppose the blast flame burners with
appurtenant pipe and hood, instead of extending horizontally
rear the floor, were turned vertically upward so as to present the
flame against an upright wall from which it was desired to re-
move a coating of paint and sand by scorching. Would that
change involve a different embodiment of the device?
A. The arts for which the two machines are respectively
adapted are widely remote, and the change in the machine,
79 supposed in the question, appears to be a material one in
that it is one necessary to adapt it for the different art. But
this is not all the change or difference between the two machines,
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 57
sithough no other is mentioned in the question. A machine of
suitable <ive to remove paint from a vertical wall and otherwise
of proper organization for the purpose, would, in these particu-
lars alone. be unadapted for the repair of pavements, and vice
versa.
Adjourned to 2 o'clock P. M.
r 2 o'clock. P, M.
Re-Direct Examination.
rgd
R. D. O. 63. Mr. Dayton, accordiagAo your an
of the rior art in the repair of asphalt pavements, as it is referr
toin the specifications of Perkins’ method patent, did a necessity
exist in the practice of such prior art for the use of tar or some
equivalent substance as a cement between the exposed edges and
surfaces of a spot to be repaired and the new asphalt composition
added thereto in the making of such repairs?
A. Such necessity did exist, as I understand it, and for the
reason that in such old procedure there was no material softening
of the old asphalt composition about the excavation made and.
therefore, no possibility of making a continuous or jointless re-
pair by the addition of new material. The tar was requisite as a
cement or “solder,” to hold the patch in place. _
R. D. Q. 64. In this connection, and as contrasted with the
cld method in which.the necessity for the use of such a cement
existed, please state in what manner the Perkins method of the
patent in suit obviates the necessity for the use of such cement?
A. By the reduction by heat of the old material to the
8 soft condition in which it was originally laid, and by the
direct contact of the heated new material with the heated
and softened old material.
R. D. Q. 65. So that if, in the repair of an asphalt pavement
the old material is melted and reduced to its original condition of
softness and a part of the old pavement has been removed so as
to expose fresh surfaces, and hot, fresh asphalt composition is
brought into immediate contact with such exposed and softened
surfaces of the old pavement so as to cause an intermingling and
union between the old and new material whe the new material is
tamped and burnished, there will be no useful reason, so far as
you can see, for using a dope or cement of any kind between the
new and old materials, will there? :
Mr. Peirce: I would like to suggest to Complainant's
counsel that he frame his questions in a less “leading” fash-
UNITED STATES REPAIR aND GUARANTY CO. Ys.
ion to obviate a formal objection for their obvious unfaie
ness, in suggesting an answer to the witness.
A. That is my understanding of the fact.
R. D. Q. 66. If a repair be made in the manner set forth in
the preceding question, except that before adding hot new as.
phalt paving composition to the exposed, fresh surfaces of the old
pavement and while such exposed surfaces of the old pa
are still soft and heated, a very light’ coat of hot melted asphalt be
applied to such exposed surfaces, and the hot, fresh composition
be added immediately thereafter, what do you consider would be-
come of the dope so applied; what purpose, if any, in the i
of such repair, would the dope so applied serve; and what effect
would such use of the dope have upon such method of iri
an asphalt pavement. as compared with the method of the
81 first claim of the Perkins method patent here sued upon? [n
this connection [ call your attention to your answers herein
to cross questions 38, 40, 42 and <2.
A. Upon a further reflection which I gave to the general
cross questions to which I am referred in the concluding part of
the above interrogatory, I had been led to think that a thin apph-
cation of hot and, therefore, melted asphalt between a hot, soft,
broken and porous marginal wall of an excavation in the surface
of an asphalt pavement and the new asphalt composition, would,
upon the tamping and further heating by the smoothing iron of
the surfaces at the joint or union, be largely dissipated by a
tion into both the old material and the new, and that by reason
of the roughness of the old material at the edge of the excavation
resulting from its having been broken away when hot, and by
reason of the thinness of the asphalt dope, there would be a prac-
tical union between the old and the new asphalt composition
brought together notwithstanding the application of such dope.
In making my answers to the before mentioned cross-questions,
[ had in mind (as indicated in some of said answers) the use of a
dope like that of the acknowledged prior art, which, by its quan-
tity and consistency, and by reason of the hard and substantially
non-porous condition of the edge of old material, formed a sep-
tum which kept the old and new asphalt composition apart and
prevented the union,contemplated in the Perkins method patent.
Reflection given to the matter between sessions of yesterday and
to-day has led me to think that the literal condition of the cross-
questions referred to might be complied with without the objec-
tionable consequences attending the use of an interposede tar
solder between the old and new material set forth in the
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 5D
&2 patent, and with substantially the same advantageous results
set {orth in the patent as belonging to the new method there
disclose’. To this extent I wish to modify my answer to X. Q.
38, 39 40, 41, 42 and §2.
Assuming the results to be as stated from the conditions named
in the question and the foregoing part of this answer, it is my
understanding that the dope would serve no useful purpose in
making the repair, and would have no material effect towards the
impairment of the integral union contemplated in the method of
the patent referred to, and that the joint would neither present
the appearance of a demarking line on the surface of the repaired
pavement, nor in any considerable degree tend to-render separa-
tion of the patch likely under changes of temperature and such
other strains as are applied to the pavement in use.
In view of Mr. Pierce's statement upon the record ‘at the open-
ing of this morning's session, I beg to add that the conclusions
above expressed were reached upon consideration of this matter
ina wakeful hour of last night, and that I announced to counsel
for Complainant before coming to this room this morning my
desire to qualify my previous answers above mentioned, as I have
here done.
R. D. Q. 67. In your opinion, then, would a method of repair
of asphalt pavements, otherwise the same as the method described
in the Perkins method patent here sued upon and claimed in claim
i thereof, but in which a dope of thin, hot asphalt, as referred to
by vou in your last Answer, is interposed between the hot new
material and the hot old material, but without in fact preventing
an intermixture and union between the new and old mate-
83 rial materially differ, in fact, from the method of claim 1 of
the Perkins method patent here in suit?
A. In my opinion it would not.
R. D. Q. 68. What is your opinion as to whether, as a matter
of fact, any ordinary brush coat of hot liquid tar, or hot melted
asphalt, applied between the heated and softened edves of a spot
of asphalt pavement to be repaired and new hot asnhalt compo-
sition applied to such spot for the purpose of repair, would actu-
ally prevent the intermixture and union between the old and new
asphalt composition, as contemplated by the Perkins method
patent in suit?
A. Such a coating as would be applied by a brush, if the as
phalt of tar were“ highly heated and therefore thin, would prac-
tically cease to be a coating by reason of its absorption, and, in
my judgment. would not defeat, or be inco®&sistent with, the
60 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. V8.
method set forth in the Perkins method patent in suit ang
claimed in the first claim thereof, the old material about the re.
pair being in a hot and soft condition and the junc: ure of og
and new material being operated upon by a hot tamping ang
smoothing iron, as referred to in the patent.
R. D. Q. 69. - What do you say as to whether the avoidance of
the Perkins method patent here in suit in the practice of g
method in which a dope or solder between the old and new m. ,
terials is used, but which ts otherwise the same as the method of
the Perkins patent, depends upon the question of fact as to
whether the dope actually \used or the conditions under which it
was applied are such as to actually prevent a union and intermix
ture of the old and new materials?
A. I think it depends altogether upon the question of fact
&4 as to the character of the union between the old and new
pavement compositions. I regard integrity of the old and
new materials as a primary requisite of the Perkins invention, and
if this result be attained by the use of the steps enumerated in the
claim in suit, I think that the useless insertion of a thin, hot, as-
phalt paint which would be dissipated and would not prevent the
substantial union and continuity of the new and old material,
would not constitute an avoidance of the patent and claim in suit.
R. D. Q. 70. What do you understand was the purpose served
by the heat “sometimes” used in the prior art as referred to in the
specifications of the method patent here in suit?
A. In the repair of asphalt pavements by the old method, it
was customary to chop out the defective part to the bottom of
the asphalt laver. Sometimes. and especially in cold weather,
this asphalt layer became hard and brittle, so that, in striking it
with an axe, to make the boundary of the hole, it would crack
and break. Moreover, it would be quite difficult to penetrate
with the mattock in forming this circumscribed line of the pro-
posed excavation and correspondingly difficult to be cut out by
the pick within that line. The heating referred to in the patent
as having been “sometimes” apphed “to the spot to soften the
“material so that it-may be more easily removed” was, as I under-
stand it, such a heat as would merely render the material more
casily penetrable by the axe and pick, and not at all such a heat-
ing as would give to the material at and around the spot the
softness which it possessed when originally laid, or suitable to
direct union with new materials.
R. D. Q. 71. Did such heating as was practiced in the
prior art serve to facilitate the cementing or attaching of the
patch or new material to the pavement being repaired?
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 61
A. | do not understand that it ever did.
R. D. Q. 72. What do you say as to the terms of claim 1 of
the Perkins method patent here in suit on their face, covering any
method of repairing asphalt pavement by the addition of new as-
phalt composition, in which a heating of the pavement to be re-
paired is utilized to facilitate or bring about a perfect union be-
tween the new and old material?
A. It does not doit. The claim specifies a series of three steps
of which only one step is. the heating of the old pavement ma-
terial, or the surface thereof, to a greater or less denth. Each of
these steps is necessary to effect a compliance with the claim.
But it is, | think, true that the claim covers any procedure which
involves the steps specified and in which, by the heating of the
old material where the new is to be joined with it. such joining is
made a substantially integral union of the old and new sub-
stances, the new material being understood to be hot at the time
of its application. .
R. D. QO. 72. Is or is it not true that by the use of the method
of claim 1 of the Perkins patent herein sued upon, it is practical,
in repairing asphalt pavements, to make what are known as
“skim’’ patches or repairs; that is, repairs in the neighborhood of
@ half inch thick as comoared with repairs in which the entire
depth of the asphalt layer is dug out, and how does the Perkins
method compare with the prior art in this respect, if vou know?
A. I answer the first part of the question affirmatively.
86 Answering the second part of the question: The Perkins
method differs whollv from the old art, as I understand it,
in that such “skim” patching was not known in the earlier art.
*e — ae ore iat 2
Re-Cross Examination by Mr. Peirce.
R. X. Q. 74. Would the conditions of nrocedure set out by
Perkins method patent No. 501,537, and defined in claim 1 there-
of, be satished if no part of the old material were removed front
the hole after being heated to properly soften such material. but
were left in situ and were merely raked over to expose fresh sur-
faces preparatory to the adition of the new hot asphalt composi-
tion with subsequent treatment, as by said claim specified?
A. As I understand the question, it would.
MELVIN E. DAYTON.
Duly certified to by E. B. Sherman, Master.
Master's fees paid by Complainant, $83.80.
62 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. Vs.
IN THE CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS.
United States Repair & Guaranty
Company In Chancery.
vs. No. 24,534.
Assyrian Asphalt Company et al.
The parties met for the purpose of continuing the evidence for
the Complainant, pursuant to the following notice. duly entitled
herein:
“To Messrs. Peirce & Fisher,
Solicitors for Defendants:
Please take notice that on Thursday next, September
23rd, 1897, before Frank H. Drury, a Notary Public in and
for the County of Cook, in the State of Illinois, we shall
87 proceed, at 2 o'clock p. m., to take the testimony of Henry
R. Kasson, of 818 Wyandotte St., Kansas City, Missoun,
in behalf of the Complainant, at Room 1515 Monadnock
Block, Chicago, at which time and place you are invited to
be present for the purpose of cross-examining the said wir-
ness and of examining exhibits to his deposition which may
then be irt: oduced in evidence
Very respectfully,
RAYMOND & OMOHUNDRO.
Solicitors for Complainant.
Chicago, September 20th, 1897
Service of the above notice accepted this 20th day of Sep-
tember, 1897.
PEIRCE & FISHER,
Solicitors for Defendants.”
Present: Mr. George P. Fisher. Jr., of Peirce & Fisher, Solici-
tors for the Defendants, and Mr. James H. Raymond, of Ray-
mond & Oniohwndro, Solicitors for the Complainant.
And thereupon the following proceeding were had:
Mr H!}NRY R. KASSON, a witness produced on behalf of
Complainant, having been first duly sworn, testified as follows:
_7s. What is your name, age, residence and occupation?
A. Henry R. Kasson; age 39; Kansas City, Mo.; District Su-
perintendent of the Barber Asphalt Paving Company.
Q. llease state generally what the district referred to in your
last answer covered?
A. It covers all the cities on the Missouri River and lying west
of the nver in which the Barber Asphalt Company operates.
88 ©. 77. Since what year have you been employed by or
connected with the Barber Asphalt Paving Company?
A. Since 1888.
. 78. Since that date you Itave been continuously con-
nected with that Company and generally informed as to its busi-
ness being during all the succeeding years in charge of some part
of this work, have you?
A. I have.
Q. 79. Please state whether or not since 1888 your occupation
and experience have been such as to qualiiy you to testify as to
what has been done both in and outside of the district which you
mentioned in the matter of repairing of asphalt pavements?
A. They have.
Q. 80. Please state whether, in the experience and employ-
ment referred to, you have heard of and considered anything
known as “The Perkins Method” or “The Perkins Apparatus”
for making repairs in asphalt pavements?
A. I have.
Q. 8&1. I am asking you questions which relate solely to the
commercial conditions since 1888 of the repairs of asphalt pave-
ments, without reference whatever to what patents may or may
not have been issued. I wish now that you would, in your own
wav, make answers to two questions:
First. What, in the trade, has been recognized as the “Per-
kins Method,” and the “Perkins Apparatus”; and
Second. What has been recognized in the trade, since 1&8.
by the terms “‘skim-patching” and “surface-heating?”
Ro Counsel for defendants objects to the first of the fore-
going questions as immaterial and irrelevant unless the
identity of the so-called “Perkins Method” and “Perkins
Apparatus” is first established with the method and appara-
tus set forth in the patents here in suit
64 UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY CO. YA.
A. It has generally been understood in the trade since the ins
troduction of the “Perkins Method” of the repairs of asphalt
pavements that it meant the softening of the surface of the
asphalt wearing coat to such a degree that a portion of the olf
| surface could be removed by scraping or otherwise anil a new
turface raked and rolled in in order that the part repaired should
conform with the contour of the surrounding pavement. By the
“Perkins Apparatus,” it has been generally understood in the
trade since its invention that it applied to a machine or apparatus
for producing the necessary heat to soften the surface of the
asphalt wearing colt, in order that enough of the wearing suriace
could be removed by scraping or otherwise so that a fresti. clean
surface could be had, in order that new material could he made
to adhere to the surface so prepared.
The term “skim-patching” has been generally recognized in
the trade as the removal of small defects in the new work as it
was being laid, such as foot marks, roller marks, small low places,
by removing small portions of the asphalt wearing surface by
means of hot shovels, hot smoothers or any other means hy which
a small portion of the surface could be removed and fresh material
used to make a new surface that would conform with the con-
tour of the surrounding pavement or obliterate the toot marks
or roller marks. The term “surface heating’’ has been always
go understood in the «trade to relate solely to the “Perkins
Method” of making repairs in asphalt pavements
©. 82. In all your experiénce, has there been, prior to vour
knowledge of the Perkins improvements, any application of heax
in the repairing of an asphalt pavement, besides the “skim patch-
ing” to which you have referred, which either covered or made
ready the spot to be repaired, both as to horizontal lines and to
vertical lines, or either or both of them?
Counsel for Defendant objects to the foregoing question
as indefinite, in that it is not made plain whether the “Per.
kins improvements” therein referred to have relation to the
patented inventions in the suit or not.
A. The only other means of which I have knowledge was
the covering of small places or defects to be repaired with hot
sand.
©. 83. Now I will ask you whether or not in all your experi-
ence and knowledge about this art since 1888 the application of
heat by what you have come to know in the trade as the “Per-
kins Method” and the “Perkins Apparatus” has obviated the use
of picks and axes or any other tool which related to the methods
{
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 65
jous') employed. Please answer this question in your own
way and give any facts which may be within your own knowl-
edge for any part of the answer you may make.
Counsel for Defendants objects to the question as imma-
teric! and irrelevant in that the identity of the “Method”
and ‘“Annaratus” therein referred to with the method and
apparatus defined by the claims of the patents in suit has
not been established.
A. The use of the “Perkins Method” of repairing asphalt
g! pavements has obviated to a very large extent the neces-
sity of cutting out or removing the surface by means of
picks, axes or other tools. Prior to the use of the “Perkins
Method” repairs to asphalt pavements were entirely made by
the cutting out and removing of the entire asphalt wearing sur-
face to the concrete.
QO. 84. Prior to the disclosure of what you say has come to
be known in the trade as the “Perkins Method” and the “Perkins
Apparatus,” was there, so far as your knowledge and experience
goes, anv method or practice which, by heat, would reduce the
part to be removed into a state for removal clear down to the
foundation upon which it was originally put?
Same objection.
A. There was not.
QO. &s. You may please state from such knowledge as you
have, whether or not your Company, the Barber Asphalt Paving
Co., has in any way acknowledged or acquiesced in what we have
called the “Perkins improvements” and more especially referred
to as the “Perkins Method” and the “Perkins Apparatus’’?
Same objection.
A. I have been notified by the proper officials of my Com-
pany that they had acquired, by license, the right to use the
“Perkins Method” and the “Perkins Apparatus” for making re-
pairs in asphalt pavements.
0. 86. Referring especially to the words “acknowledged or
zequiesced’”” in my last question, please state whether in any way
you were a party to any investigation by the Barber Asphalt
Paving Co. of the “Perkins Method and Apparatuses” before
o2 the license mghts were acquired, to which you refer, and
please state what the result of that investigation was?
Counsel for Defendant objects to the questions as imma-
terial and irrelevant.
A. By directions of the general officers of my Company I in-
vestigated as to whether there were any means by which heat
UNITED STATES REPAIR AND GUARANTY ©O. Ys.
had ever been successfully applied for preparing asphalt
surfaces for repairs. I found that previous to the introduction
of the “Perkins Method” no means had ever been found by which
heat could be used for the preparing of the asphalt wear
surface for repairs in a general and economical manner. The only
methods for applying heat that I could discover before the ttse
of the “Perkins Method” were those that I have already Lestified
to regarding the making of small repairs in new work by the use
of hot shovels, hot smoothers or hot sand, all of which were
extremely satisfactory and very expensive.
Solicitor for Complainant proffers in evidence an onginal
copy of a contract between the Barber Asphalt Paving Co,
and the City of St. Josenh, Mo., made and entered into
September oth, 1897, the same covering the repairs for
asphalt pavements in said city for the period of five years
from the date thereof. ;
Thereupon it was agreed and stipulated by the solicitors
for the respective parties that the following copy thereof is
a true, full and correct copy of the original, to wit:
93 ARTICLE OF AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE BAR-
BER ASPHALT PAVING COMPANY AND
THE CITY OF ST. JOSEPH, MO.
This agreement made and eritered into this ninth day of Sep-
tember, 1897. by and between the Barber Asphalt Paving Com-
pany, a corporation duly organized and existing under and by
virtue of the laws of the State of West Virginia, party of the
first part, and the City of St. Joseph, a municipal corporation
organized and existing under and by virtue of the laws of the
State ef Missouri, party of the second part
Witnesseth: That said party of the first part for and in consid-
eration of the covenants and agreementsof said party ofthe second
part hereinafter contained, hereby covenants, promises and agrees
to and with said party of the second part that it, said party of
the first part, shall and will furnish all materials and perform all
the work necessary to repair in a good, substantial and work-
manlike manner for a term of five years from and after the first
day of October, 1897, all the asphalt pavements on the streets
in the City of St Joseph, excepting the parts of such asphalt
pavements as are required to be kept in repair by the Street
Railway Companies, operating their lines in said city, in com-
pliance with the following
©
ASSYRIAN ASPHALT COMPANY. 3 67
SPECIFICATIONS:
“KINDS OF REPAIR.
The general repairs as to the wearing surface will be of two
- kinds. ist. When it is necessary to cut out the asphalt to the
concrete. 2nd. Skimming.
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.