Transcript of Record — Rasmussen v. Idaho
Supreme Court brief1901
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Fea © FUF&
(17,658. )
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER “RRM, Iss<>9.
No. 544.
R. RASMUSSEN, PLAINTIFF IN) ERROR,
Us.
THE STATE OF IDAHO.
IN ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF IDAHO.
INDEN.
Origingl, Prat.
Pe Nee ba pang sb smk oe bases enews are ; a 1
Transcript from the district court... ..........0..0.0..0..0...0-0- I 1
RE ora a Cenk set sduae sccehe eae eke A eaeeeie coe 1 l
RS srt bine watdeNs «oA vada wees seas vs : 2
Order taking demurrer under advisement...... 0.0 ............ 2 2
Order overruling demurrer... SP es Pear eae” 2 2
Order overruling motion to quash ................. 3 2
Order beginning trial, Kke......... 3 2
Se ated c's o's as onc a AE SCS ie erat aoe 4 3
IR SE iss 5 cans sive « wcdcn de Geom eevocacces 4 3
Demurrer to information .... en 5 4
Motion to quash information... .... ils Uae sid 6 5
Notice of appeal ..... 5 Panett pie a, Beer rye ee ray 7 5
Ns chingaudathoeedsisskaviandestae: vanes 7 6
Motion to quash.... ; 8 6
CC cer res sah kicsnklasnacaivncavkek. snwk 8 6
ONIN Sos chs ok na pba ous 5:.0.40be ean awes nd 10 rj
I Ge ety DNNUN 5 65 5556 oe vce o 5 snmd ens esam 11 8
ere Sees ete ee ‘ 15 ll
C—O
Jepp & Derwerter, Parwrers, Wasatxaton, D.C., Marc 21, 1900,
If INDEX.
Orivinat
PRE ONMONE ol walkin eenincy esas ere Crekas Sevis i Iti
PONE EG WEE DNEE Soin ncns casa waoeeed secur cee: It
Defendant’s exceptions to instructions......0.......... is
EMIS NG, T= PLOCMIMAION .. 6.26 cc isc c ries cesses u
Assignment of errors.......0.....666 eo eee CA Ree ae 20
Judge's certificate to bill of exceptions. 2. ......0..0.... |
Clerk’s certificate............. Pe eR OE Cn Tee 21 3
Affidavit of Arthur Brown................... + Py ak ee 29 1K
Order extending time to file transeript............. ley oD 4 te 23 16
oes, CE Ee 0 Oe Satan ky Largs plese es cakes 24 i7
MT aR AS Ree oad aeons ec ce crn n ys bah ecneaies Grane ticks s 25 iv
Cuaer granting time to Ble briel. .... 2.0 occ ce cccsccccccescesns aH »
Order for continuance.......... AEE ene Gla AR OS gi eae ree 6 ”
Order taking cause under advisement ... ....0........4. Tae y 24
SUMING 5 6k cvc 5 ons meet PUN a oe RR none wegen, 6 oe RC aT 4
END ONIN: 6) oi bab usu tae 22 see mae ese os 3S 4
PONS. kp Sc eeeenicce ss aa ee eee Sees seats $! %
EE I air Seine a vince led Dabs kee eonme ek oe cathieRs s $33 %
Order allowing writ of error ......0.......... een ee a eee ; 45 ®
ME NMEON UOM D Cc cece hs bradaeadnee koe. vaedsWachs 46 os
| RY Va nee an ee eer ere ere tere free V7 a
ree NONI WOME 655 55. kcie essa ccas ses ao ear ore 4 3
re os i, whack Sina ho eee Vows SARE TCR EPA REE Coys A] 3
Ce CIS i woe eos ckeel cask Siena aap eeee ees s 52 2
Rk. RASMUSSEN Vs. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 1
a In ihe Supreme Court of the State of Idalio, November Term,
1S.
STATE oF IpAno, Respondent, )
vs. > No. 577.
R. Rasmussen, Appellant. J
Transcript on Appeal. ‘
Appeal from the district court of the fifth judicial district of the
State of Idaho in and for Oneida county.
Arthur Brown, 5. C. Winters, and John J. Guheen, attorneys for
appellant; S. H. Hays, attorney general for the State.
Filed Sept. 20, 1899.
SOL. HASBROUCK, Clerk.
1 County Attorney's Information.
Inthe District Court, Fifth Judicial District of Idaho, in and for
Oneida County.
Srate OF Ipauno, Plaintiff,
v8.
R. Rasmussen, Defendant. j
In the district court of the fifth judicial district of Idaho, sitting in
and for Oneida county, June term, 1899.
R. Rasmussen is accused by the county attorney of Oneida county,
in the fifth judicial district of the State of Idaho, by this informa-
tion of the crime of driving sheep into the State of Idaho from the
county of Box Elder, State of Utah, in violation of the proclamation
of the governor of the State of Idaho, committed as follows, to wit:
The said R. Rasmussen, on the 20th day of April, 1899, at the
county of Oneida and State of Idaho, and prior to the filing of this
information did drive and cause to be driven from the county of
Box Elder, Utah, into the county of Oneida, State of Idaho, three
bands of sheep, which sheep so driven had been held, ranged and
herded in said county of Box Elder, Utah, between the 12th day of
April, 1899, and the said 20th day of April, 1899, against and in
violation of the proclamation of the governor of the State of Idaho,
issued and published on the 12th day of April, 1899.
That the said R. Rasmussen waived examination upon said
charge before a committing magistrate of Malad precinct, in said
county of Oneida, and was by said magistrate held to answer said
charge in this court.
Db. ©. McDOUGALL,
County Attorney.
1—544
2 R. RASMUSSEN Vs. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
Endorsed: In the district court, fifth judicial district of
2 Idaho,in and for Oneida county. State of Idaho, plaintiff,
vs. R. Rasmussen, defendant. County attorney’s in!ormation
filed 1n open district court and made a record of this court this the
12th day of June, 1890. D. J. Reynolds, clerk, by W. 1} Thews,
deputy. DOC. MeDougall, county attorney. Names of witnesses:
Peter Johnson, Griffeth Davis, David 8S. Thomas, James Morris,
Court Record, June 12, 1899.
In the District Court, Fifth Judicial District of Idaho, in and for
Oneida County.
State oF Ipano, Plaintiff,
vs.
R. Rasmussen, Defendant.
On this day the above-named defendant came into court to be
arraigned upou the information heretofore filed against lim, the
said defendant, the clerk thereupon, under the direction of the court,
read the information heretofore tiled against hin, the said defend-
ant, under the name of R. Rasmussen, and asked him if that was
his true name, to which he replied that it was, aud upon being asked
to plead, and being informed of his rights in the premises took the
statutory time in which to plead to the information.
(June 15, Same Court and Cause.)
Now comes the defendant in the above-entitled action and inter
poses a deruurrer to the information neretofore filed in said cause,
after argument by counsel for and against the said demurrer, and
the court not being fully advised of and concerning the said demurrer
took the same under advisement.
(June 14, Same Court and Cause.)
The demurrer heretofore interposed by the defendant, and
3 the court having taken the same under consideration, aud
being fully advised of aud concerning the same, overruled
the said demurrer, to which ruling counsel for the defendant ex-
cepted, whereupon the defendant entered his plea of “ not guilty.”
(Same Court and Cause.)
The motion heretofore interposed to quash the information here-
tofore filed in this action, and the same having been duly consid-
ered, by the court, it is ordered that the said motion be and the
sume is hereby denied. To which ruling the defendawt’s counsel
excepted, whereupon defendant entered bis pl-a of not guilty.
(Same Court and Cause and Date.)
On this day came on regularly for trial the above-entitled cause,
D. ©. McDougall, John A. Bagley and Geo. E. Gray, Esqs., appear
_— A Ao a1
RK. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 3
ing on part of the prosecution, and Messrs. Winters and Guheen
and Arthur Brown appearing on part of the defendant, the clerk
thereupon, under direction of the court, placed in the jury-box the
names of the persons heretofore summonsed to serve as jurors and
proceeded to draw therefrom a jury: and the following is the jury
duly sworn to well and truly try the matter in issue, and a true
verdict render according to the law and the evidence, viz: Charles
Munn, John Larsen, Ben. D. Jones, Thomas Daniels, Sr. Jobu
Mandry, Morgan P. Jones, William MeDermit, John L. Thomas,
Richard Morse, Charles Walker, L. 8. Barnard and D. P. Davis.
Whereupon counsel for plaintiff stated the case to the jury on part
of the prosecution, and R. Rasmussen, the defendant in the case,
was called to the witness stand, by consent of counsel was duly
sworn, examined and cross-examined on part of the prosecution.
and here the evidence closed, defendant having introduced
4 no witnesses, the cause was thereupon submitted to the jury
without argument, the court instructed the jury in the law
as to its duty; whereupon the said jury retired to deliberate upon
their verdict, with Hugh Jones duly sworn an officer to take charge
of the said jury and keep them together in some private and con-
venient place and return them into court when they had agreed
upon their verdict.
And now on this same day came the jury into court, all being
called and found to be present, were asked by the court if they had
agreed on their verdict, they, through their foreman, answered they
had, and presented to the court their verdict which was filed by
the clerk and recorded in the following language, to wit:
STATE OF Ipano)
vs. >
R. Rasmussen. J
We the jury, duly sworn to try the above-entitled action, find
the defendant guilty.
CHARLES MUNN, Foreman.
(June 15, Same Court and Cause.)
The defendant with bis attorney with his alforneys came into
court, the defendant was duly informed by the court of the nature
of the information found against him for the crime of driving
sheep into the State of Idaho, from Box Elder county, in violation
of the governor’s proclamation, committed on the 20th day of April,
1899. Of the arraigument and plea of not guilty. The defendant
was then asked if he had any legal cause to show why judgment
should not be pronounced against him; to which he replied that
he had none, and no sufficient cause being shown or appearing to
the court, — thereupon rendered its judgment, that whereas the said
R. Rasmussen, having been duly convicted of crime of violating
the governor's proclamation, it is therefore ordered, adjudged
5 and decreed, that the said R. Rasmussen is guilty of the
crime of violating the governor's proclamation, and that the
4 R. KASMUSSEN Vs. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
said R. Rasmussen be and he is hereby fined in the sum of three
hundred dollars and costs of this acticn.
Demurrer.
In the District Court, Fifth Judicial District, in and for the County
of Oneida, State of Idaho.
STaTe oF IpaHo, Plaintiff, )
va. ya
R. Rasmussen, Defendant. }
Comes now the defendant in the above-entitled action and demurs
to the information heretofore filed in said cause, and for grounds of
demurrer says:
Ist.
That said information does not state facts sufticient to constitute
a public offense, or any offense known to the laws of the State of
Idaho.
2d.
That said information is ambiguous, unintelligible and uncertain,
in this: It is uncertain as to whether the proclamation of the
governor of the State of Idaho was violated by holding sheep in
Box Elder county, Utah, or by driving them into the State of Idaho.
It is also ambiguous as to whether the defendant is charged with
violating the proclamation of the governor of Idaho, or of violating
some law of the State of Idaho. It is unintelligible and uncertain
as to what proclamation of the governor of the State of Idalo defend-
ant is accused of violating. It is also ambiguous and uncertain
as to whether the defendant, or some one else, held, ranged or
herded the said sheep in Box Elder county, Utah, between the 12th
day of April, 1899, and the 15th day of April, 1899; it is also
6 uncertain as to whether defendant received said sheep in
charge before, or after, the issuance and publication of said
proclamation; it is also uncertain as to whether defendant upon
entering the county of Oneida with said sheep forthwith notified
the deputy inspector of said county of Oneida of his entering said
county.
Wherefore defendant asks to be dismissed and discharged.
WINTERS & GUHEEN awyp
ARTHUR BROWN,
Attorneys for Defendant.
Filed 13th day of June, 1899.
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. v
Motion to Quash Information.
In the District Court, Fifth Judicial District, in and for Oneida
County, Idaho.
Srate oF Ipano, Plaintiff,
vs.
R. Rasmussen, Defendant.
Comes now the defendant and moves the court to quash the in-
formation heretofore filed in said action, and to discharge the de-
fendant for the following reasons :
Ist. That said defendant never was examined upon the charge
mentioned in said information before any officer authorized to hold
examinations.
24d. That said defendant was never committed upon said charge
by any magistrate in the State of Idaho.
WINTERS & GUHEEN anpb
ARTHUR BROWN,
Attorneys for Defendant.
Filed June 13, 1899.
7 Notice of Appeal.
In the District Court, Fifth Judicial District of Idaho, in and for
Oneida County.
STATE OF IpaAHo, Plaintiff, )
vs.
R. Rasmussen, Defendant. J
The above-named defendant hereby appeals aud gives notice of
appeal from the judgment and conviction rendered in said cause,
onthe loth day of June, 1899, and from the whole of the same
to the supreme court of the State of Idaho.
ARTHUR BROWN,
8S. C. WINTERS,
Attorneys for Defendant.
June 15, 1899.
Service of a copy of the foregoing notice is hereby admitted.
June 15, 1899.
JOHN E. BAGLEY,
GEORGE E. GRAY,
D. C. McDOUGALL,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
Filed June 15, 1899.
6 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
Bill of Exceptions.
In the District Court, Fifuh Judicial District, in and for the County
of Oneida, State of Idaho. 7
STATE OF IDAHO, Plaintiff, )
vs.
R. Rasmussen, Distondivat |
In the above-entitled cause the said defendant was arraigned in
the said court on the 13th day of June, 1899.
At the time of bis arraignment, the prosecution appeared by
D. C. MeDougall, prosecuting attorney, and by John Bagley, asso-
ciate counsel, and the said defendant by S. C. Winters and
8 Arthur Brown, his counsel. The defendant, by his counsel,
made a motion to quash the indictment, which motion was
in writing, and is hereto annexed; at the same time thie defend-
ant, bv his counsel, filed a demurrer hereto annexed.
Motion to Quash Information.
(Title of the Court and Cause.)
Comes now the defendant, and moved the court to quash the in-
formation heretofore filed in said action, and to discharge the de-
fendant for the following reasons:
Ist. That said defendant never was examined upon thie charge
mentioned in said information, before any officer authorized to hold
examinations.
2d. That said defendant was never committed upon said charge
by any magistrate in the State of Idaho.
WINTERS & GUHEEN ayxp
ARTHUR BROWN,
Attorneys for Defendant.
Demurrer.
(Title of the Court and Cause.)
Comes now the defendant in the above-entitled action, and de
murs to the information heretofore filed in said cause, and for
grounds of demurrer says:
Ist. That said information does not state facts sufficient to con-
stitute a public offense, or any offense known to the laws of the
State of Idaho.
2d. That said information is ambiguous, unintelligible and un-
certain in this: It is uncertain as to whether the proclamation of
the governor of the State of Idaho was violated by holding sheep in
Box Elder county, Utah, or by driving them into the State of
9 Idaho. It is also ambiguous as to whether the defendant
is charged with violating a proclamation of the governor of
ee eee BY Cee Ba ed
Frew” FRI e
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 7
Idaho, or of violating some law of the State of Idaho. It is unin-
telligibie and uncertain as to what proclamation of the governor
o the State of Idaho defendant is accused of violating. It is
also ambiguous and uncertain as to whether the defendant, or some
one else, held, ranged, or herded the said sheep in Box Elder county,
Utah, between the 12th day of April, 1899, and the 15th day of
April, 1899. It is also uncertain as to whether the defendant
received the said sheep in charge before, or after, the issuance and
publication of said proclamation ; it is also uncertain as to whether
defendant, upou entering the county of Oneida with said sheep,
forthwith notified the deputy inspector of said county of Oneida of
his entering said county.
Wherefore defendant asks to be dismissed and discharged.
WINTERS & GUHEEN anp
ARTHUR BROWN,
Attorneys for Defendant.
On the said 13th day of June, 1899, said motion to quash the
indictment and demurrer came on for argument, said counsel ap-
pearing for the defendant, and arguing the same, and the prosecuting
attorney and associate counsel appearing for the State, and arguing
the same, Which motion and demurrer were taken into considera-
tion by the court, and after due consideration thereof the court
denied the said motion to quash and overruled the said demurrer,
and thereupon the said defendant pleaded to the information, not
guilty.
On the said 14th day of June said cause came on for trial, at
which the following proceedings were had:
10 Ist.
Plaintiff offers in evidence document marked “ Plaintiff’s Ex-
hibit I.”
Mr. Brown: We object to it, if your honor please, and object to
the introduction of any of this testimony, for the reason :
Ist.
That there is no information stating any crime.
2d.
_ There is no statement or allegation of this proclamation in the
information ; it does not recite it or state it in substance; the facts
of this proclamation are not stated in the information.
3d.
This document is not authenticated in a manner to entitle it to
received in evidence. This document purports to be a procla-
mation of the governor of the State of Idaho. It isan act of the
executive that must be proven, the statutes say, by the records, but
atall events there must be a certified copy of it. The records, of
course, are kept at the State department at Boise, but there must be
8 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO,
a true copy of the original, aad there is no such certificate here if
I have read it right. It could not be the original, the original
must be preserved and filed at Boise; this has never been liled any.
where. It does not purport to be a certified, and for that reason we
object to it.
Court: Objections overruled.
Exceptions to the ruling of the court.
Mr. Brown: The defendant is here, and at the suggestion of the
prosecution I offer him as a witness, and waive any objection on
the ground that he is the defendant, and permit him to be sworn
as a witness, although the evidence might criminate himself.
11 Mr. BaGiry: This is done to expedite matters, in order to
prevent sending into the country for another witness.
. Rasmussen, being first duly sworn, testified as follows:
. What is your name?
R. Rasmussen.
. Residence ?
. My residence—Spring City, Utah.
. What is your occupation ?
. Handling sheep.
. You are the defendant in this case ?
. Yes, sir.
Q. I will ask you if you brought or caused to be brought, any sheep
into the State of Idaho, in the county of Oneida, on or about the 20th
day of April, 1899?
A. No, sir.
Q. You say you did not?
A. I did not.
Q. Do you own any sheep, Mr. Rasmussen ?
A. No, sir.
Mr. Brown: Let me ask him a question.
Q. You were herding for Kuollins and their sheep were brought
in about that time?
A. Not about that time.
Q. When was it?
A. About the 12th or 13th.
By Mr. BaGriey:
Q. Did you have any sheep in charge between the 12th and 20th
of April, 1899?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. In what eapacity did you have these sheep in charge, I mean
as herder or owner?
A. As foreman.
Q. As such foreman you were directing the management of these
sheep and saw to the herding of them ?
A. Yes,sir; mostly.
Q. Where were these sheep ranged, held or herded from the 12th
day of April up to the 20th day of April, 1899?
LOPOPOPO mw
_—
R. RASMUSSEN VS, THE STATE OF IDAHO, 9
A. You might say they were not ranged any place; we were
driving them during that time.
Q. Where were they during the 12th day of April, 1899 ?
A. Box Elder county.
Q. State of Utah ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where did you move them from there up to the 20th day of
April ?
A. From there I moved them into Idaho.
Q. Into what county ?
A. I think they came into Cassia county, and from = there into
Oneida county.
12 Q. Did you bring them inte Oneida county ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. About what date did they enter Oneida county ?
A. About the 16th or 17th.
Q. Of April, 1899?
A. Part of them.
Q. About how many sheep were there that were brought from
Box Elder county, Utah, into Oneida county, Idaho?
A. Six herds, I think.
Q. How many head did they aggregate ?
A. About 15,900.
Q. As | understand you had these sheep in charge as foreman ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And under your directions and instructions they were brought
from Box Elder county, Utah, into Oneida county, Idaho?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. These sheep were held and herded or driven to Box Elder
county, Utah, after the 12th day of April, 1899, and before the 20th
day of April, 1899 ?
A. Yes, sir; they were driven through Box Elder county.
Q. And they were brought into Oneida county, Idaho, after they
had been driven through Box Elder county, Utah?
A. Yes, sir.
Cross-examination by Mr. Browy :
Q. You were foreman, for whom were you working ?
A. A. J. Knollin & Co.
Q. Were these sheep which you had charge of wintered ?
_ Mr. Bagiey: We think this is immaterial; object to it as being
Immaterial and irrelevant.
Mr. Brown: As J understand the facts to be a part of these sheep
Were wintered near Gunnison, in southern Utah, and not near the
counties nentioned, and herded and held there, and this spring
were driven by what is known as the western route, west of Salt Lake,
through Box Elder into Cassia, and from Cassia into Oneida county.
offer to show that.
The Courr: You may show it.
2—544
10 R. RASMUSSEN Ys. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
Q. They were wintered between here and [daho—Blackroek,
Utah, I mean ?
13 A. Blackrock, Utah; ves, sir.
Q. Did | understand you to say part of them were wip.
tered in Idaho?
A. No, sir.
Q. Not any part, but in the vicinity of Blackrock, Utah ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What county?
A. Millard county.
Q. What time in the spring did you move them from there?
A. We started from there the 20th of January.
Q. What route did vou take?
A. | came around through Snake valley by Deep creck.
(). West of Salt Lake?
A. West of Salt Lake.
(Q). Op through the Deep Creek country ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Whereabouts did you get into the Box Elder country, if you
know ?
A. Right southeast of Tacoma.
Q. How long were you in driving through Box Elder county?
A. About 25 days.
Q. Did you drive directly through it?
A. As near as I could. We traveled right along.
Q. Aud you arrived in Idaho, in the county of Cassia?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And from the county of Cassia drove into the county of
Oneida ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What time did you arrive at the county of Cassia?
A. The first herds arrived there about the 12th of April, on the
12th of April.
Q. On the 12th of April?
A. On the 12th of April, I think.
Q). Wheo did you arrive in the county of Oneida ?
A. Some time about the 16th.
(). Did your sheep have the scabdies or scab ?
(Objected to as incompetent and immaterial. Objections sus-
tained )
Mr. Brows: I offer to show that none of the sheep that he drove
into Cassia county had the scab or seabbdies, that not one of the
sheep that he drove into Oneida county had the seab or scabbies, ot
any other disease.
The Courr: [ don’t think it would make any difference ; the ob-
jection is sustained.
Defendant excepts to the ruling of the court. :
14 Mr. Brown: I will add that they did not have any indica-
tions or hint of having any disease, whatever, at the time
they came into Cassia county, or Oneida county.
——
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDATIO. 1]
I suppose this is subject to the same ruling ?
The Court: Yes.
(Exception.)
Q. Did you know, when you entered the county of Cassia, of the
wxistence of this proclamation that has been read here ?
(Objected to as incompetent, immaterial, and irrelevant. Objee-
tion sustained. Exception.)
Q. Did you know of this proclamation that has been offered in
evidence at the time you drove into Oneida county ?
(Objected to as incompetent, irrelevant, and immaterial. Same
ruling. Exception.)
Q. I asked if you knew it. [ will make it stronger, if you had
ever heard or been informed anything about it ?
(Same objection. Same ruling. Exception.)
Redirect.
By Mr. BaGuey :
Q. Mr. Rasmussen, you are familiar with the range—that is, the
sheep range, through Box Elder county, Utah, into Oneida county,
Idaho, are you not?
A. Yes, sir; part of it.
Q. In driving your sheep through Box Elder county and into
Oneida county. Idaho, did you drive them over the usual ordinary
sheep range and trail?
A. Why, part of the way.
Q. What part of it?
A. Well, different parts: from Oneida, part way we came over
the trail; or from Tacoma, rather.
Q. Then you drove your sheep over the same trail and range
that other sheep passing from that country into this country, would
range ?
A. Yes, sir; part of the time.
Q. While they were in Box Elder county they were on that
1s range and trail that had been traveled by other sheep, and
was ordinarily traveled by sheep, coming from the winter
range into Idaho?
A. Yes, sir; part of the time.
State rests.
The defense now moves for a nonsuit on the following grounds:
Ist.
No offense is alleged in the information.
2d.
No offense has been proven by the evidence.
——
12 R. RASMUSSEN Vs. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
3d.
The governor was not authorized to make any proclamation.
4th.
The event in which the statutes authorizing the governor to make
a proclamation, to wit, that he had good reasons to believe that seab
or infectious disease had become epidemic in the localities men-
tioned, is not certified to by him, or proven by any other witness or
witnesses.
jth.
There is no proper proof of any proclamation.
6th.
if hl . ® ® . .
There is no publication of any proclamation shown whatever.
7th.
No proof.that any of the sheep were diseased, or that they had
any need of being quarantined.
8th.
This is not the proper county in which to bring suit, but the
county of Cassia is.
Motion overruled by the court. Defendant excepts.
Defendant rests.
16 Mr. Brows : I now move for a verdict of the jury and that
the court direct the jury to return a verdict, for all the
reasons which I named in the motion for nonsuit, just above
submitted, a verdict of the jury of acquittal, not guilty, for all the
reasons I suggest, I need not repeat.
(Motion denied. Defendant excepts.)
The following instructions were requested by the defendant and
refused by the court:
Ist. Upon the undisputed facts of this case, the jury should
return a verdict of not guilty.
(Refused.)
To which refusal counsel for defendant excepted.
2d. If the jury find that the sheep involved in this case first
came into Cassia county from Box Elder, then that is the proper
county iv which to bring prosecution, and the jury should acquit.
(Refused.)
To which refusal counsel for defendant excepted.
Instructions to the Jury.
The court will instruct the jury that the law in regards to this
case is as follows:
Whenever the governor of the State of Idaho has reason to
believe that scab or any infectious disease of sheep has become
_—
epidemic in certain localities in any other State or Territory. or
that conditions exist that render sheep likely to convey this disease,
he must thereupon, by proclamation, designate such localities and
rohibit the importation from there of any sheep into the State,
except under such restrictions as, after consultation with the State
sheep inspector, he may deem proper. Any person or corporation,
ho, after publication of such proclamation, receives in charge
any such sheep, from any of the prohibited districts, and
17 _—i transports, conveys or drives the same to and within the
limits of any of the counties of this State, is punishable ov
a fine not exceeding $1,000 nor less than $200, and is liable for all
damages that may be sustained, by any person by reason of the im-
portation or the transportation of such prohibited sheep. Upon the
issuing of such proclamation the owners, or person in charge of any
sheep, being shipped into Idaho against which quarantine has been
declared, must forthwith notify the deputy inspector of the county
into which said sheep may come, of such arrivai,and the owner, or
person in charge, must not allow any sheep that is quarantined to
pass over or upon any public highway, or upon ranges occupied by
any other sheep, or within five miles of any corral in which sheep
are usually corraled, until such sheep have first been inspected, and
any person failing to comply with the provisions of this section are
punishable, as provided by section 1 of the act, and is liable for all
damages sustained by any person by reason of the failure to comply
with the provisions of this section.
The court further instructs the jury that if the defendant did,
between the 12th day of April and the 20th day of April, 1899, drive,
or cause to be driven from the county of Box Elder, Utah, into the
tounty of Oneida, State of Idaho, bands of sheep, being drive» from
the prohibited sections, embodied in the governor’s proclamation,
then the defendant is guilty as charged in the information.
The court further instructs the jury that the defendant is pre-
sumed to be innocent until proven guilty by the prosecution beyond
a reasonable doubt.
You are the sole judges of the evidence that has been introduced
in this case, and will be governed by it in making up your
verdict.
18 The court further instructs you that under the law the
governor had a right to issue the proclamation as stated in
the information, and if the defendant violated the provisions of that
proclamation he also violated the provisions of the law that I have
read to you in this charge.
Ten of you may agree on a verdict.
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 13
Defendanant’s Exceptions to the Instructions of the Court.
The defendant excepts to the refusal to charge as requested by
the defendant in each of his requests.
The defendant excepts to the charge of the court, reading the
so-called statute of Idaho,as the law in the case. (Paragraph 1.)
The defendant excepts to the charge that if the defendant drove
14 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
into Oneida county bands of sheep, being driven from the county
embodied in the proclamation, that they should find the defendant
guilty. (Paragraph 2.)
And the defendant excepts to the charge that the governor had
the right to issue the proclamation, which was read i: evidenee.
(Paragraph 3.)
The defendant excepts to the charge that ifthe defendant violated
the proclamation then it was the same as violating the law and
they should find him guilty, or in substance about that. (Para.
graph 4.)
I hereby certify that the within isa full, true, and correct copy
of all the evidence in the above-entitled case. :
N. GALLAGHER,
Court Reporter.
19 Exuresir to Birt or Exceptions No. 1.
Proclamation Scheduling Certain Localities on Account of Scab or
Scabbies.
Stare or Ipano, Executive Orrice.
Whereas, I have received statements from reliable wool-growers
and stock-raisers of the State of Idaho, said statements being supple-
mented by affidavits of reputable persons, all to the effect that the
disease known as seab or scabbies is epidemic among sheep in cer-
tain localities or districts, viz: in the county of Cache, State of
Utah ; the county of Box Elder, State of Utah, and the county of
Elko, in the State of Nevada, and, whereas, it is known that sheep
from said districts are annually moved, driven or imported into the
State of Idaho, and if so moved would thereby spread infection and
disease on the ranges and among the sheep of this State, which
act would result in great disaster. Now, therefore, I, Frank Steun-
enberg, governor of the State of Idaho, by virtue of authority in me
vested, and after due consultation with the State sheep inspector, do
hereby prohibit the importation, driving or moving into the State
of Idaho of all sheep now being held, herded or ranged, within said
infected district, viz: the county of Cache, in the State of Utah:
the county of Box Elder, in the State of Utah, and the county of
Elko, in the State of Nevada, or which may hereafter be held,
herded or ranged within said infected districts, for a period of 60
days from and after the date of this proclamation ; after the ter-
mination of said 60 days sheep can be moved into this State only
upon compliance with all laws of the State of Idaho regarding the
inspection and dipping of sheep.
In witness whereof, 1 have hereunto set my hand and
20 caused to be affixed the great seal of the State. Done at
Boise, the capital, this 12th day of April, in the year of our
Lord one thousand eight hundred and ninety-nine.
[sEaL.] FRANK STEUNENBERG.
By the governor:
M. PATRIE,
Secretary of State.
— .
R. KASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF iDAHO. 15
Assigninents of Errors.
The court erred:
Ist. In denying the motion to quash.
94. In overruling the demurrer.
3g. In admitting in evidence the document called “ Proclamation
of the governor,” and overruling the objections of counsel for the
defendant thereto.
4th. In sustaining the objection of counsel for the prosecution to
uestion to defendant: “ Did your sheep have scab or scabbies?”
5th. In sustaining objections to question to defendant: “ Did
they (the sheep) have any indication of any disease? ”
6th. In sustaining objections of question to defendant: “ Did you
know when you entered into the county of Cassia with these sheep
of the existence of the proclamation which was now read here?”
7th. In sustaining objection to question to defendant: “ Did you
know of this proclamation that has been offered in evidence at the
time you drove into Oneida county r
Sth. In sustaining question to defendant: “ Had you ever heard
or been informed anything about it (the proclamation)?”
Oth. In overruling defendant’s motion for nonsuit.
21 10th. In overruling a direction to the jury to find for de-
fendant, upon the reasons vamed in the motion for nonsuit.
llth. In refusing to charge as — request No. 1.
12th. In refusing to charge as in request No. 2.
13th. In charging the jury in paragraph No. 1, viz: reading the
so-ealled statutes of Idaho as the law in the case.
14th. In charging the jury that if defendant drove into Oneida
county bands of sheep, being driven from the prohibited sections
embodied in the governor's proclamation, then the defendant is
guilty. (Paragraph 2.)
1th. In charging that the governor had the right to issue the
proclamation read in evidence. (Paragraph 3.)
16th. In charging that if the defendant violated the proclamation
he also violated the provisions of the law. (Paragraph 4.)
ARTHUR BROWN,
Ss. C. WINTERS,
Attorneys for Defendant.
The foregoing bill of exceptions having been submitted to counsei
for the prosecution, and admitted to be correct, it is settled by me,
the judge of said court, this 15th day of June, 1899, at the request
of counsel for the defendant. The foregoing bill contains all the
evidence in said cause.
JOSEPH C. RICH, Judge.
State oF IDAHO, bs :
County of Oneida, {~~
I, D. J. Reynolds, clerk of the district court in the fifth judicial
district of the State of Idaho, in and for Oneida county, do hereby
16 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
certify that the foregoing transcript contains a full, true and
22 correct copy of the record, notice of appeal and all bills of ex.
ception in said action.
Witness my band and the seal of said court this 9th day of Sep.
tember, 1899.
D. J. REYNOLDS, Clerk
Supreme Court of the State of Idaho.
Strate or Ipano, Plaintiff and Respondent, }
vs. .
R. Rasmussen, Defendant and Appellant. j
Stare oF Uran, POF
County of Salt Lake, {°° °
Arthur Brown, being first daly sworn, says: I was the attorney
for the above-named defendant upon the trial in the court below,
and I prepared a bill of exceptions and took an appeal therein on
or about the 14th day of June, 1899. At that time I gave thie clerk
directions to immediately prepare a transcript of the entire record
and transmit to the clerk of this court, and make arrangements
with him to pay him for it when he would know what the amount
was. The clerk promised to do it at once. Since that time from
time to time I have written asking its performance, and he now
tells me that it was bis deputy that was there and he has negleeted
to prepare the transcript on appeal, but he has them now ready.
Under the circumstances I ask for an order extending the time
within which to file said transcript.
ARTHUR BROWN.
Subseribed and sworn to before me this 5th day of September,
1899.
FRANK C. LEA,
Notary Public.
23 On reading the affidavit of Arthur Brown, counsel for ap-
pellant in the above-entitled cause, it is hereby ordered that
the time for serving and filing the transcript on appeal herein is
hereby extended to and including the 14th day of September, 1899.
Dated September 5, 1899.
JO. WALDO HUSTON,
Chief Justice of Supreme Court.
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 17
4 Inthe Supreme Court of the State of Idaho, January Term,
1900.
Filed January 23d, 1900. Sol. Hasbrouck, Clerk.
Strate or Ipano, Respondent, )
>
v8.
R. Raswessen, Appellant. |
Syllabus.
An act of the Idaho legislature, establishing quarantine against
diseased sheep, ete., passed on March 13, 1899, held not to be in
contravention of section 5, article 1, nor section 2, article 4, of
the Constitution of the United States.
Appeal from district court of Oneida county, Hon. Joseph C. Rich,
district judge. Affirmed.
Arthur Brown, S. C. Winters, & John J. Guheen for appellant;
§. H. Hays, attorney general, for State.
% Hustox, ©. J.:
The appellant was convicted of a violation of the provisions of
ay act of the legislature of Idaho and the proclamation of the
governor issued under and in obedience to the command of said
statutes; from which judgment this appeal is taken. The said act
isas follows:
“Secy10oN 1. Whenever the governor of the State of Idaho has
reason to believe that scab or any other infectious disease of sheep
has become epidemic in certain localities in any other State or Ter-
ritory, or that conditions exist that render slieep likely to convey
disease, he must thereupon, by proclamation, designate such locali-
ties and prehibit the importation from them of any sheep into the
State except under such restrictions as, after consultation with the
State sheep inspector, he may deem proper.
Any person or corporation who, after publication of such procla-
mation, receives in charge any such sheep from any of the probibited
districts and transports, conveys or drives the same to and within
the limits of any of the counties of this State is punishable by fine
not exceeding $1,000, nor less than $200, and is liable for all
damages that may be sustained by any person by reason of the im-
portation or transportation of such prohibited sheep.
_ See. 2. Upon issuing such proclamation, the owners or persons
in charge of any sheep being shipped into Idaho, against which
quarantine has been declared, must forthwith notify the deputy
inspector of the county into which such sheep first come, of such
arrival, and such owner or persons in charge must not allow any
sheep so quarantined to pass over or upon any public highway, or
upon the ranges occupied by other sheep, or within five miles
2% of any corral in which sheep are usually corralled until such
sheep have first been inspected, and any person failing to
3—d44
18 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
comply with the provisions of this section is punishable as provided
in section one of this act and is liable for all damages sustained by
any person by reason of the failure to comply with the provisions
of this section.”
On the 12th day of April, 1899, the governor of Idaho, in com.
pliance with the provisions of said act, issued the following proela.
mation:
Srate oF Ipano, Executive Orrice,
Whereas I have received statements from reliable wool-growers
and stock-raisers of the State of Idaho, said statements being sup.
plemeuted by affidavits of reputable persons, all to the effect that
the disease known as scab or scabdies is epidemic among sheep in
certain localities or districts, viz., in the county of Cache, State of
Utah; the county of Box Elder, State of Utah, and the county of
Elko, in the State of Nevada; and whereas it is known that sheep
from said districts are annually moved, driven, or imported into
the State of Idaho, and if so moved would thereby spread intection
and disease on the ranges and among the sheep of this State, which
act would result in great disaster:
Now, therefore, I, Frank Steu-enberg, governor of the State of
Idaho, by virtue of authority in me vested and after due consul-
tation with the State sheep inspector, do hereby prohibit the impor-
tation, driving, or moving into the State of Idaho of all sheep now
being held, herded, or ranged within said infected district, viz,
the county of Cache, in the State of Utah; the county of Box
Elder, in the State of Utah, and the county of Elko, in the
27 State of Nevada, or which may hereafter be held, herded, or
ranged within said infected districts, for a period of 60 days
from and after the date of this proclamation. After the termination
of said 60 days sheep can be moved into this State only upon com-
pliance with alllaws of the State of Idaho regarding the inspection
and dipping of sheep.
In witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand and caused to
be affixed the great seal of the State.
Done at Boise, the vapital, this 12th day of April, in the year of
our Lord one thousand eight hundred and ninety-nine.
(seat. ] FRANK STEUNENBERG.
By the governor:
M. PATRIE,
Secretary of State.
While there are some sixteen assignments of error in this case,
it is conceded by counsel for appellant that the important
question involved is the constitutionality of the act of the legisla
ture of Idaho under which the conviction was had. .
It is claimed that this case comes within the reasoning of this
court in the ease of The State v. Duckworth, 51 Pac, 456. In that
case the defendant was convicted of a violation of an act of the
legislature of Idaho, passed in 1895 and amended in 1897; section
6 of which act provides as follows:
_ ,
RK. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 19
“Section 6. Any person, persons, company, corporation or asso-
ciation intending to bring, or cause to be brought from any other
State or Territory into any of the counties of the State of Idaho, any
sheep, he or they must first notify the deputy sheep inspector of
the district or county nearest to the point of entrance into this State
that at a fixed date he will be witnin twenty miles from the State
line at a designated point, with said sheep for inspection ;
9g sand it shall be the duty of the deputy sheep inspector to
examine such sheep within three days, and if pronounced
sound, to immediately dip such sheep once, and then upon being
tendered his compensation as hereinafter provided, issue a permit
allowing such sheep to enter this State subject to such regulations
asare enforced on resident sheep. But 1 such sheep are found
sabby or infected with any contagious or infectious disease, then
the deputy sheep inspector must dip said sheep twice with an inter-
val of from eight to fifteen days between dipping and then issue a@
permit for said sheep to enter said State under the same regulations
as heretofore provided ; provided, however, that all sheep must
enter said State within three days from final dipping, otherwise
permit so issued shall be null and void. And any person or persons
violating any of the provisions of this section shall be deemed
guilty of a misdemeanor, and upon conviction, they shall be pun-
ished by a fine of not less than one hundred (3100.00) dollars, nor
more than three hundred ($300) dollars, or by imprisonment in the
county jail not less than two months nor more than six months or
by both such fines and imprisonment; provided, that any person,
persons, company, corporation or association bringing or causing to
be brought any sheep into any counties of this State in violation of
the provisions of this act, shall be fined in addition to the penalty
imposed in this section, five cents per head, for every sheep so
brought into this State, which shall be a lien on said sheep ; and it
shall be the duty of the deputy sheep inspector to seize and hold
such sheep by such means as he deems best, for a period of ten days,
and if said sum is not paid within that period, to advertise and sell
said sheep, or as many of the same as may be necessary to satisfy
and pay such fine and costs.”
And section 14 of the law of 1895 provides as follows :
pa “See. 14. It shall be unlawful for any person, persons, com-
pany, corporation or association, owning, controlling or
managing any ferry-boat, toll bridge, car, steamboat or other things
used for transportation, to allow any sheep to be carried thereon,
unless the party in charge of said sheep shall first produce a certifi-
cate from 2 deputy sheep inspector appointed under this act, that
said sheep are free from scab, seabbies or other infectious or con-
tagious disease. Any violation of this section shail be deemed a
misdemeanor and punishable by a fine of not less than one hundred
dollars nor more than two hundred and fifty dollars.”
_A comparison of the act of 1897 with that of the act ander ques-
tion will, we think, disclose a greater difference than existed between
the law of Missouri held by the Supreme Court of the United States
to be invalid in Railrood vs. Husen, 95 U.S., 469, and the law of
20 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
Kausas, the validity of which was sustained by the same court jy
Missouri, K. & F. R’y Co. vs. Haber, 18 Supreme Court Rep., 483,
The statute under consideration in the case of State vs. Duck worth,
supra, prohibited the introduction into this State in any mauuner or
form, or the transportation through the State in any way or by any
means, of any sheep until same had been inspected by a sheep
inspector of Idaho, which inspection must be made 20 miles beyond
the State line of Idaho, and all sheep must be dipped at least once,
and, if found infeeted, twice before they were allowed to enter the
State, and all this to be done by a sheep inspector of Idaho, twenty
miles beyond the line of the State. The law of 1899 was iucended
as a quarantine law. It does not exclude atl sheep, but only such
as from the fact of their coming from an infected district are liable
tv import disease. The statute of 1899, under which appel-
30 lant was convicted, is simply a quarantine law, nothing
more, nothing less. We do not understand that it is, or ever
was, an essential to the enforcement of a quarantine that the faet
of the existence of the disease in the subject of the quarantine should
be primarily established. As we understand, it is a preventive
measure. It will hardly be claimed, we apprehend, that the State
has not the power to prevent, by legisiative enactment, the intro-
duction within its boundaries of diseased animals, and this is all
that the act under consideration purports or is intended to accom-
plish.
The chief of the Bureau of Auimal Industry, in his report to the
Secretary of Agriculture dated March 15, 1898, says: “In the
United States some sections have been overrun with sheep seab,
and many persons engaged in the sheep industry have been forced
to forsake it because of their losses from this disease. It is probable
that in its destruction of invested capital sheep seab is second ouly
to hog cholera among our animal diseases. The large flocks of the
Plains and Rocky Mountain region and the feeding stations further
east have suffered severely, and are constantly sending diseased
animals to the great stock yards of this country.” ~The same officer
states in his letter transmitting his report to the Secretary of Agri-
culture: “ The disease known as scab is one of the most serious
drawbacks to the sheep industry, and results in enormous financial
losses. Yet despite its insidious nature, its ease of transmission, its
severe effects, and its prevalence in certain localities, it is a disease
which yields readily to proper treatment.” That the length of time
of quarantine fixed by the Idaho statute is not excessive is, we
think, shown by the rules laid down by the authority already
31 cited: ‘“(1.) Seabby sheep should never be driven upon a
public road. (2.) Sheds in which seabby sheep have been
kept should be thoroughly cleaned, disinfected, and aired, and
should be left unused tor at least four weeks, better two months,
before clean sheep are placed in them. (3.) Fields in which seabby
sheep have been kept should stand vacant at least four weeks (better
six or eight) before bein, used for clean sheep. (4.) A drenching
rain will frequently serve to disinfect a pasture, but it is well to
whitewash the posts against which scabby sheep have rubbed.
Fea” FF
Kk. RASMUSSEN Vs. THE STATE OF IDAHO. y 4 |
Even after observing the precautions here given it is not possible
ty absolutely guarantee that there will be no re-infection, but the
srobabilities are against ay
Report of chief of Bureau of Animal Industry, 1898, with
this author-ative statement before them, the legislature of Idaho
enacted the law under consideration. That under the condi-
tions established and recoguized some legislation was necessary for
the effective prevention of the spread of this disease among the
sheep of this State must be conceded, and we are clearly of the
opinion that that adopted by the legislature was the most effective
and the least objectionable that could have been adopted.
Counsel for appellant speaks somewhat contemptuously of these
reports of the Bureau of Animal Industry to the Secretary of Agri-
culture of the United States, but we notice they are cited as authority
by the Supreme Court of the United States in Kimmish v. Bail, 9
Supreme Court Reports, 277. The Supreme Court in the last-
mentioned ease, in drawing the distinction between it and the case
of Railroad Co. vs, Husen, 95 U.S., 465, says: “ The decision in
that case (Railroad Co. v. Husen) rested upon the ground that no
discrimination was made by the law of Missouri in the transporta-
tion forbidden between sound cattle and diseased, and this cireum-
stance is prominently put forth in the opinion.”
32 The same distinction appears between the Idaho law of
1895 and 1897 and the law of 1599. The law of 1895 and
1897 prohibited the bringing into the State of any sheep until the
same had been inspected and treated by an Idaho sheep inspector
twenty miles beyond the State line. ‘The law of 1899 and the
proclamation of the governor thereunder quarantines sheep coming
from an infected district or locality before permitting them to be
driven into this State.
Our legislature, in rightful recognition of the large and constantly
increasing importance of the sheep industry as one of the most im-
portant elements of the wealth and resources of the State have
enacted most stringent and comprehensive laws for the protection
of those animals from disease. But what avails the enactment or the
enforcement of laws for the protection of sheep within the State, if
we are to be constantly subject to an invasion of sheep from the
infected districts of adjoining States or counties, and we do not
think that a law made simply and solely for the protection of the
sheep of this State from infection by the introduction into the
State of sheep from a known infected district can in any way be
said to interfere with commerce between the States or abridge the
rights of citizens of other States within this State. The law only
required persous who desire to drive sheep into this State from
known infected districts to be subject to the same rules and regula-
tions for the prevention and cure of disease among their sheep so
sought to be driven into this State as is required of our own
citizens.
The Supreme Court of the United States in Missouri, K. & T. R’y
Co. v. Haber, 1S Sup. Court Reporter, 488, which is, we believe, the
22 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
latest expression of that court upon this question, says:
33 “ Neither corporations nor individuals are entitled, by force
alone of the Constitution of the United States and without
liability for injuries resulting therefrom to others, to bring into one
State from another State cattle liable to import or capable of com-
municating disease to domestic cattle. The contrary catnot be
affirmed under any sound interpretation of the Constitution. This
court, while sustaining the power of the Congress to regulate com-
merce among the States, has steadily adhered to the principle that
the States possess because they have never surrendered the power
to protect the public health, the public morals, and the public
safety by any legislation appropriate to that end which does not
encroach upon rights guarantied by the National Constitution, nor
come in conflict with the acts of Congress passed in pursuance of
that instrument. Although the powers of a State must in their
exercise give way to a power exerted by Congress under the Con-
stitution, it has never been adjudged that that instrument, by its
own force, gives any one the right to introduce into a State, against
its will, cattle so affected with disease that their presence in the
State will be dangerous to domestic cattle.” We can see but little
difference in principle between the case of Missouri, K. & 'T. R’y Co.
vs. Haber and the case under consideration.
The Kansas statute under consideration in that case made any
person or persons bringing into that State any cattle liable or
capable of communicating ‘Texas splenic or Spanish fever to any
domestic cattle of that State liable for all damages that might be
sustained by reason of the communication of said disease. “ Proof
that the cattle which such person or persons are charged with ship-
ping, driving or keeping or which are claimed to have com-
34 municated the said disease were brought into this State from
south of the thirty-seventh parallel of north latitude, shalt be
taken as prima facie evidence that such cattle were between the
first day of February and the first day of December of the year in
which the offense was committed, capable of communicating and
liable to import Texas splenic or Spanish fever within the meaning
of this act, and that the owner or owners, person or persons in
charge of such cattle had full knowledge and notice thereof ;” and
this statute was upheld by the United States Supreme Court against
a contention predicated upon the same lines contended for by the
appellant in this ease, to wit, the limit of the power of the State in
the matter of public regulations.
The contention of appellant that because it was not shown that
any of the sheep driven by him into this State were diseased, or
that he was not permitted, although ready to prove that none of
said sheep were diseased, cannot be entertained. The appellant
himself testified that he had the sheep in Box Elder county, Utah,
which is designated in the proclamation of the governor as one of
the infected districts, and against which quarantine had been de
clared for the period of twenty-five days. The fact that these sheep
came directly from an infected district was sufficient to establish
their capability and liability to communicate disease.
—_
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 23
The authorities upon the disease known as “ sheep scab” say that
it may be communicated by contact of one sheep with another or
indirectly from tags of wool or from fences, posts, ete., against which
sabby sheep have rubbed, or from the places where the sheep have
heen “ bedded down.” See report of chief of Bureau of Animal In-
dustry, 1898. What protection, then, have the sheep-growers of
Idaho without the aid of just such preventive laws as that under
consideration ?
We have examined and considered the various assignments
35 of error set out in appellant’s brief, and we do not think that
any of them present reversible error. Appellant claims that
the venue is viot properly laid. We do not think this contention
can obatin. The bringing into any county of the State sheep from
the proscribed districts is an offence, and prosecution therefor may
be instituted in any county where the sheep are found. We do not
think the act delegates to the governor legislative power. It simply
requires him to act when he ascertains that certain conditions exist.
— This is not a delegation of legislative power, as we understand it.
Having ascertained, through entirely proper and legitemate methods,
the existence of the exigency which under the law required him to
act, he did so. He could not have done otherwise without being
obnoxious to the charge of dereliction in official duty. The claim
that the law discriminates against the citizens of Utah is entirely
unsupported. We think most, if not all, of the other questions raised
in.the assignment of errors have been disposed of in this opinion.
The judgment of the district court is affirmed, with costs to
respondent.
Quarles, J., and Sullivan, J., coneur.
36 SratTe oF IDAHO, 83:
Supreme Court.
Boise, Ipano, Oct. 13, 1899.
Court met pursuant to adjournment—present, Hon. Joseph W.
Huston, chief justice; Hon. Ralph P. Quarles, justice, and the offi-
cers of the court—when the following (among other) proceeding-
were had, to wit :
SraTE OF IDAHO, Respondent, )
v8. No. 577.
R. Rasmussen, Appellant. {
Ordered that the attorney general be, and he is hereby, granted
until the first day of the November, 1899, term within which to
serve and file a brief in the above-entitled cause.
State oF IDAHO, 8s :
Supreme Court.
Borse, IpaHo, Dec. 5, 1899.
Court met pursuant to adjournment—present, Hon. Joseph W.
Huston, cheif justice; Hon. Ralph P. Quarles, justice; Hon. Isaac
24 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO,
N. Sullivan, justice, and the officers of the court—when the follow.
ing (among other) prodeedings were lad, to wit:
Us
SraTeE oF Ipano, Respondent,
. No. 577.
Rt. Rasmussen, Appellant.
It is ordered that this cause be, and the same hereby is, continued
for the term.
37 Same Title of Court and Cause.
Jan. 10, 1900,
This cause having been heretofore set for hearing on this day,
the same was called. Arthur Brown appeared for appellant and
Attorney General S. H. Hays for the State. After argument by
respective counsel, the court ordered the cause taken under advyise-
ment,
Same Title of Court and Cause.
JANUARY 24, 1900.
This cause having been heretofore submitted and taken under
advisement by the court, and the court having fully considered the
same, now,on this day, the cause was again called, and the decision
of the court is delivered by Chief Justice Huston, to the effect that
the judgment of the court below be affirmed.
It is therefore considered, adjudged, and decreed by the court that
the judgment of the district court of the fifth judicial district in and
for the county of Oneida in the above-entitled cause be, and the
same hereby is, affirmed.
Costs awarded to the respondent.
38 In the Supreme Court of the State of Idaho.
Strate oF Ipano, Respondent,
vs. Petition for Writ of Error.
R. Rasmussen, Appellant.
Now come- the said defendant and says that in the final judgmeut
rendered by the supreme court of the State of Idaho on the twenty-
fourth day of January, 1900, and in the proceedings had thereto
certain errors were committed, to the prejudice of said defendant,
which will more in detail appear from the assiguments of error to
be filed as a part of this petition; and petitioner further shows that
in the final judgment and decree of the fifth judicial district court
of the State of Idaho in and for Oneida county and in the final judg-
ment of the supreme court of the State of Idaho a decision was had
and made in said cause where was drawn in question the validity ofa
statute of the State of Idaho on the ground of its being repugnant
to the Constitution of the United States, to wit: It was repugnant
to section 8, article 1, of the Constitution of the United States, and
repugnant to section 2, article 4, of the Constitution of the United
States; that the defeudant in this cause was arrested, tried, and con-
—-—_—
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 25
yicted in the said district court of the fifth judicial district of Idaho
of an alleged offence, stated in the indictment, for driving sheep frum
the county of Box Elder, State of Utah, into the county of Oneida,
State of Idaho, between the 12th day of April, 1899, and the 20th
day of April, 1899, against and in violation of a proclamation of
the governor of the State of Idaho issued and published on the 12th
day of April, 1899; that on the trial of said cause it was
99 claimed that the said defendant had violated a statute of
Idaho, which reads as follows:
“ Whenever the governor of the State of Idaho has reason to be-
lieve that scab or any other infectious disease of sheep has become epi-
demic in certain localities in any other State or Territory, or that
conditions exist that render sheep likely to convey disease, he must
thereupon by proclamation, designate such localities and prohibit
the importation from them of any sheep into the State, except under
such restrictions as, after consultation with the State sheep inspector,
he may deem proper,” and of a proclamation issued thereunder, a
copy of which is hereto annexed and made a part hereof. Your
petitioner further shows that on the trial of said cause your peti-
tioner, by his counsel, set up aud claimed that the said act of the
legislature of Idaho and the said proclamation of the governor of
Idaho were repugnant to the Constitution of the United States, in
that they were repugnant to the clauses above named, to wit, sec-
tion 8, article 2, of the Constitution of the United States, and section
9 article 4, of the Constitution of the United States, and the validity
of the said acts were drawn in question during said trial; that such
proceedings were had after the conviction of the said defendant
that the said cause was appealed to the supreme court of the State
of Idaho, and in the supreme court of Idaho the validity of the said
acts of the legislature and the governor were drawn in question as
being contrary to the Constitution of the United States in the sec-
tions named; that upon the trial of said cause in the district court
the trial court held that the said acts of the legislature and the
governor were valid and not contrary to the Constitution of the
United States, and the supreme court of the State of Idaho held
upon the appeal thereto from the said conviction that the said acts
of the legislature and the governor were valid and held in favor of
their validity.
40 Wherefore this defendant prays that a writ of error may be
issue- in his behalf from the supreme court of the State of
Idaho for the correction of the errors so complained of, and that the
transcript, papers, and records in this cause, duly authenticated,
may be sent to the Supreme Court of the United States.
ARTHUR BROWN,
HENRY P. HENDERSON,
Attorneys for Defendant.
4—d44
——
26 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
41 Proclamation Scheduling Certain Localities on Account of Scab
or Scabbies.
State or Ipauo,
EXxcUvIVE OFFice.
Whereas I have received statements from reliable wool-growers
aud stock-raisers of the State of Idaho, said statements being su
plemented by affidavits of reputable persons, all to the effect that
the disease known as scab or scabbies is epidemic among thie sheep
in certain localities or districts, viz., in the county — Cache, State of
Utah ; the county of Box Elder, State of Utah, and the county of
Elko, in the State of Nevada and whereas it is known that sheep
from said districts are anuually moved, driven, or imported into the
State of Idaho, and if so moved would thereby spread infection and
disease on the ranges and among the sheep of this State, which aet
would result in great disaster:
Now, therefore, 1, Frank Steunenberg, governor of the State of
Idaho, by virtue of authority in me vested and after due consulta-
tion with the State sheep inspector, do hereby prohibit the importa-
tion, driving, or moving into the State of Idaho of all sheep now
being held, herded, or ranged wituin ihe said infected district-,
viz., the county of Cache, in the State of Utah; the county of Box
Elder, in the State of Utah, and the county of Elko, in the State of
Nevada, or which may hereafter be held, herded, or ranged within
said infected districts for a period of 60 days from and after the date
of this proclamation; after the termination of said 60 days sheep
can be moved into this State only upon compliance with all the
laws of the State of Idaho regarding the inspection and dipping of
sheep.
In witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand and cause- to
be affixed the great seal of the State.
* Done at Boisé, the capital, this 12th day of April, in the
42 year of our Lord, ont thousand eight hundred and ninety-
nine.
[SEAL.] FRANK STEUNENBERG.
By the governor:
M. PATRIE,
Secretary of State.
Filed February 16th, 1900.
SOL. HASBROUCK, Clerk.
43 In the Supreme Court of the United States.
R. Rasmussen, Plaintiff in Error,
vs. | Assignment of Errors.
Tue Srarte or Ipano, Defendant in Error.
Now comes the above-named plaintiff in error, by Arthur Brown
and Henry P. Henderson, his attorneys, and says that in the record
_
and proceedings in the above-entitled cause there is manifest error,
in this, to wit:
1. That the supreme court of the State of Idaho erred in sustain-
ing the validity of the act of the legislature of the State of Idaho,
Session Laws 1899, page 452, as fully set forth in the record and
briefs in this cause.
9 The supreme court of tiie State of Idaho erred in sustaining
the validity and power of the proclamation of the governor exelud-
ing certain sheep from the State of Idaho on the ground of scabbies.
3. The supreme court of the State of Idaho erred in holding that
the act of the legislature of the State of Idaho, Session Laws 1899,
e 452, and the proclamation of the governor thereunder was not
in violation of section 8, article 1, of the Constitution of the United
States.
4. The supreme court of the State of Idaho erred in holding that
the act of the legislature, Session Laws 1899, page 452, and the
proclamation thereunder was not in violation of section 2, article 4,
of the Constitution of the United States.
5. The supreme court of Idaho erred in sustaining the trial court
in each of the following particulars in which the trial court erred,
and the plaintiff in error herein assigns as error each of the follow-
ing assignments made in the supreme court of the State of Idaho
to the ruling of the the trial court.
The court erred :
44 Ist. In denying the motion to quash.
2d. In overruling the demurrer.
8d. In admitting in evidence the document called “ Proclamation
of the governor,” and overruling the objection of counsel for the
defendant thereto.
4th. In sustaining the objection of counsel for the prosecution to
question to defendant: “ Did your sheep have scab or scabbies ?”
5th. In sustaining objection to question to defendant: “ Did they
(the sheep) have any indication of any disease? .
6th. In sustaining objection to question to defendant: “ Did you
know of this proclamation that has been offered in evidence at the
time you drove into Oneida county?”
7th. In sustaining question to defendant: “ Had you ever heard
or been informed anything about it (the preclamation)?”
8th. In overruling defendant’s motion for nonsuit.
9h. In overruling a direction to the jury to find for defendant
upon the reasons named in the motion for nonsuit.
10th. In refusing to charge as request No. 1.
lith. In charging the jury in paragraph No, 1, viz., reading the
so-called statutes of Idaho as the law in the case.
12th. In charging the jury that if defendant drove into Oneida
county bands of sheep, being driven from thie prohibited section
‘embodied in the governor’s proclamation, then the defendant is
guilty. (Paragraph 2.)
13th. In charging that the governor had the right to issue the
proclamation read in evidence. (Paragraph 3.)
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 27
——
14th. In charging that if thedefendant violated the proclaination
he also violated the provisions of law. (Paragraph 4.)
ARTHUR BROWN,
HENRY P. HENDERSON,
Attorneys for PUUf in Error.
28 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THK STATE OF IDAHO.
Filed Feb. 16th, 1900.
SOL. HASBROUCK, Clerk.
45 In the Supreme Court of the State of Idaho.
State oF IpaHo, Respondent,
v8. Allowance of Writ of Error,
R. Rasmussen, Appellant.
On the twelfth day of February, 1900, came the said defendant,
by his attorney, Arthur Brown, and filed and presented herein a
petition prayiug for the allowance of a writ of error intended to be
urged by the defendant, praying also that the transcript of the
records and proceedings and papers upon which the judgment
herein was rendered and duly authenticated may be sent to the
Supreme Court of the United States, and that such fall and further
proceedings may be had as may be proper in the premises.
In consideration thereof I, Joseph W. Huston, chief justice of the
supreme court of the State of Idaho, do hereby allow the writ of
error upon the defendant’s giving bond according to law in the sum
of five hundred dollars, which shall operate as a supersedeas bond,
and bail, pending proceedings on writ of error tothe Supreme Court
of the United States.
JOSEPH W. HUSTON,
Chief Justice.
Filed Feb. 16, 1900.
SOL. HASBROUCK, Clerf.
46 In the Supreme Court of the United States.
US.
R. Rasmussen, Plaintiff in Error,
Citation.
THE Srate or Ipano, Defendant in Error.
The United States of America to the State of !daho, Greeting:
You are hereby cited and admonished to be and appear at the Su-
preme Court of the United States, to be holden at Washington, in
the District of Columbia, within thirty days from the date of this
citation, pursuant to the writ of error filed in the clerk’s office of the
supreme court of the State of Idaho, at Boise, Idaho, wherein R.
Rasmussen is plaintiff in error and The State of Idaho is defend-
ant in error, to show cause, if any there be, why a judgment in the
said writ of error mentioned should not be corrected and speedy
justice should not be done to the parties in that behalf.
Witness the Honorable Melville W. Fuller, Chief Justice of the
—
said Supreme Court of the United States, this 12th day of Febru-
ary, in the year of our Lord one thousand nine hundred.
: JOSEPH W. HUSTON,
Chief Justice Supreme Court of Idaho.
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 29
-ttest: — -—.
Due service of the foregoing citation by copy personally served
and of annexed petition in error, allowance and assignment in
error is hereby adinitted this 16th day of February, 1900.
SAMUEL H. HAYS,
Atty Gen’l.
Filed Feb. 16th, 1900.
SOL. HASBROUCK, Clerk.
47 In the Supreme Court of the State of Idaho.
v8.
Tue State or IpAno, ae
R. Rasmussen, Appellant.
Know all men by these presents that we, R. Rasmussen, as prin-
cipal, and the Fidelity and Deposit Company of Maryland, a corpo-
ration organized and existing under the laws of the State of Mary-
land, duly authorized by its charter to become sole surety upon
bonds as surety, are held and firmly bound unto the State of Idaho
in the full and just sum of five hundred ($500.00) dollars, to be paid
to the said State of Idaho, its certain attorneys and assigns; to which
payment, well and truly to be made, we bind ourselves and each of us,
jointly and severally, and our and each of our successors, representa-
tives, and assigns, firmly by these presents.
Sealed with our seals and dated this 14th day of February, A. D.
1900.
Whereas lately, in the supreme court of the State of Idaho, in a
suit pending in the said court between said defendant, R. Ras-
mussen, and The State of Idaho, plaintiff, a judgment was rendered
against the said defendant, and the said defendant having obtained
a writ of error and filed a copy thereof in the clerk’s office of the
said court to reverse the judgment of the aforesaid suit, and a cita-
tion directed to the said State of Idaho, citing and admonishing it
to be and appear in the Supreme Court of the United States, to be
holden at Washington, in the District of Columbia :
Now, the condition of the above obligation is such that if
48 the — R. Rasmussen shall prosecute said writ of error to
effect, and, if he fails to make said plea good, answer all
costs, and will appear in the district court of the fifth district of the
State of Idaho in and for the county of Oneida, and will at all
times render himself amenable to its orders and process and ap-
pear for judgment and surrender himself in execution thereof,
then the above obligation to be void ; else to remain in full force and
virtue.
In witness whereof the said R. Rasmussen has subscribed his
name and the Fidelity and Deposit Company of Maryland has
30 R. RASMUSSEN YS. THE STATE OF IDAHO,
caused this bond to be executed in its corporate name, attested with
its corporate seal, by its local director, pursuant to a resolution of
the board of directors of the Fidelity and Deposit Company of Mary.
land duly passed and adopted Apr. 5th, 1899.
R. RASMUSSEN,
By ARTHUR BROWN, tify.
Witness :
[CORPORATE SEAL. | FIDELITY & DEPOSIT
CO. OF MD.,
By M. 8S. PENDERGAST,
Member Local Board of Directors.
Attest: R. B. WHITTEMORE, Gen’l Ag’t.
Srate or Uran, ig:
County of Salt Lake, j ~ °
M. S. Pendergast, being first duly sworn, deposes and says:
I am a member of the local board of directors of the Fidelity and
Deposit Company of Maryland, the surety on the foregoing bond;
that said surety company is a corporation organized under the laws
of the State of Maryland, and said corporation has 4 paid-up capital
stock of $1,500,000 and a surplus fund of $1,500,000.
M. 8. PENDERGAST.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 14th day of Feb., A. D.
[SEAL.] R. B. WHITTEMORE,
Notary Public.
49 In the Supreme Court of the State of Idaho.
vs.
Tue State or Ipano, Respondent,
R. Rasmussen, Appellant.
On reading the foregoing bond executed in behalf of the said de-
fendant, as principal, and by the Fidelity and Deposit Company of
Maryland, as surety, the same is hereby accepted as sufficient bond
on appeal and the same is approved by me and is accepted asa
recognizance and bail for the said defendant during the hearing of
said cause in the supreme court.
JO. WALDO HUSTON,
Chief Justice Sup. Ct. of Idaho.
R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO. 31
50 In the Supreme Court of the State of Idaho.
Tue State or Ipano, Respondent, )
v8. >
R. Rasmussen, Appellant. j
SraTteE OF IDAHO, |} sa
County of Ada, {~
Sherman G. King, being duly sworn, says: I am the agent of the
Fidelity and Deposit Company of Maryland, organized for the pur-
pose of becoming surety in proper cases; that said company has
filed due proof with the secretary of state of the State of Idaho
that it possesses the qualifications under the act of the legislature,
Laws of 189), page 337, providing for companies being sureties on
recognizanees and bonds, and has received a certificate from the said
secretary of state setting forth that said company has qualified and
is authorized to do business under said act; that said prouof was
filed less than one year ago and and said certificate is in full force
and effect.
SHERMAN G. KING.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 19 day of February,
1900.
[SEAL. ] WALTER S. WALKER,
Notary Public.
Filed Feb. 19th, 1900.
SOL. HASBROUCK, Clerk.
dl Tue UNITED STaTes OF AMERICA, 88:
The President of the United States of America to the honorable the
judges of the supreme court of the State of Idaho, Greeting :
Because in the record and proceedings, as also in the rendition of
the judgment of a suit which is in the said supreme court of the
State of Idaho, before you, being the highest court of law or equity
of said State in which a decision could be had in said State between
The State of Idaho, plaintiff, and R. Rasmussen, defendant, wherein
was drawn in question the validity of an act of the legislature of
the State of Idaho and of the governor thereof, to wit, the validity
of the statute of the State of Idaho of Session Laws 1899, page 452,
aud the proclamation issued in pursuance thereof on the 12th da
of April, 1899, and whereas the decision was in favor of the validity
of said act of the legislature, and manifest error has happened, to
the great injury and damage of the said defendant, R. Rasmussen,
as by the petition for writ appears, we, being willing that error, if
any hath been, should be duty corrected and full and speedy justice
done to the parties aforesaid in this behalf,do command you, if
judgment therein be given, that then and under your seal, distinctly
and openly, you send the record and proceedings aforesaid, with
all things concerning the same, to the Supreme Court of the United
States, together with this writ, so that you may have the same at
32 R. RASMUSSEN VS. THE STATE OF IDAHO.
Washington within sixty days of the date hereof, and that, the
record and proceedings aforesaid being inspected, the said Supreme
Court may cause further to be done therein to correct that error
what of right and according to the laws and customs of the United
States should be done.
Witness the Hon. Melville W. Fuller, Chief Justice of the said
Supreme Court, the 15th day of February, A. D. 1900.
[Seal United States Circuit Court, Idaho. }
A. L. RICHARDSON,
Clerk United States Circuit Court
of North Circuit, District of Idaho.
Allowed by—
JOSEPH W. HUSTON,
Chief Justice of the State of Idaho.
52 In the Supreme Court of the United States.
R. Rasmussen, Plaintiff in Error,
v8.
THe State or Ipano, Defendant in Error.
Unitep Srates or AMERICA, |
State of Idaho, j
1, Sol. Hasbrouck, clerk of the supreme court of the State of
Idaho, by virtue of the foregoing writ of error and in obedience
thereto, do hereby certify that the foregoing 53 pages, numbered
from 1 to 53, inclusive, contain a full, true, and complete transeript
of the record and proceedings had in said court in the case of R.
Rasmussen, plaintiff in error, against The State of Idaho, cefendant
in error, as the same remain of record and on file in said cause. I
further certify that at the time the said writ of error was filed in
the office of the clerk of said court the plaintiff in error lodged with
me, as clerk of said supreme court, in said office, a copy of said writ
of error.
Witness my hand and the seal of said supreme court this 20 day
of February, A. D. 1900.
{Seal of Supreme Court, State of Idaho. ]
SOL. HASBROUCK, Clerk.
88 -
Endorsed on cover: File No., 17,658. Idaho supreme court |
Term No., 544. R. Rasmussen, plaintiff in error, vs. The State of
Idaho. Filed February 28th, 1900.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.