Transcript of Record — Sigafus v. Porter
Supreme Court brief1900
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(16.821.)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER ‘TERM, 1s0o9.
No. 48.
JAMES M. SIGAFUS, PLAINTIFF IN ERROR,
US.
DUDLEY PORTER ET AL.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT.
INDEX.
Page.
Transcript of record from the circuit court of tie United States for the
CL ATINGEIOL OF NOW: YORK. ori nish oie ie Sia sins e dn ee csiewseun l
: TT ests SW Ah nee Taian Samadi era ates wea Ow Eee l
NG Pe ete Pe arf Siear ey a tar a eet er eta ar ere 2
eva fobs sectioned KN aha dE OR CA eye Meee eek Aeuw as 3
NE eas sh ova he sn bog neue sie vant bake eka bd dundee et ekawees 4
UA NceVipa sins. c\5cd, Pee Ee CACTAS MN SY-SEE RARE E RS as CUR bea ONCE EO ll
NE MUIIRIUU GL BIORE 5 coe iigidaik US Wate Lass Me a aceey Jan waaay 20
eee Mec UKM WIROIEIONE TON WOW CESGN a io ack ee sise Dh bn bee ee eas 0s 21
Judgment .......... bearers 20008 Vas hen sals hp sane Maio wa ee Cree 23
SIN ss ems lows Ga gk hap eieAS KAN PNA YIOR TW ERS Wee SOREN Ce 25
RC dE PRINCI regs para +o A's Vee GAS toa ae aren eee iets 26
PMNACNE CT ORNIOE 25, MOTO echo ons See Abba ps ewes ene’ 26
Belle Doran... sic terinhdae arcs et naie tee ie 36
SRE Dig I 6 0. 5 REG = 05 weiss eH 43
MINN SEI ss SiS S18 8 SF x00 SA Rew acas ian 51
We AO 85 bn hs vee a isa hake 52
FRB As WOR e555 ca sce ans dX sient ney 59
PUTS Bie OO 5 aids vor SNe KER oo 63
SOME Ba a kd so d.Ss eS eis crew FESR ces 73
CNN a MN ec dne ded Laces iw pent cules 119
INDEX.
Dep sition of John L. Hobson......0... 62...
William Foster. ...
Elbridge G. Wood
SN EIN Feels Cas sear seh s0s5es
Le ee eee Cre
Edmund H. Wilson. ..... Ee eee
Wm. H. Griffith (recalled). ........
Elbridge G. Wood (recalled)... ....
Anderson C. Moorehead. ......
Tanne NN. Boteowrt... <2. 20.065...
Dudley Porter (recalled)... ...............
Albert L. Jepson (recalled)... ..
Eben FE. Olcott........ Ler See
EO ie al Siete ter ee
3 ee eee See nee Fiaavs.e's
SG On POU Sa 8B eta Wend dee sy) essence ws
Evidence for defendant... ...... 6.6 ccc. e cee
Deposition of Sherman T. Crawford. . BYE kek. wceceene
PUNE WEE cst Gare’ ;
James R: Cheatham................
CO Es IS os ageg S00.
ee ae ae ee
Bi Oe I oi en Ch xen
TEE Bs TR kes cs cceiec
EE IEC. Caters. "Ok teers ck
Sherman T. Crawford .
George Tangier .. .. .. .. oc 0.50...
Anton Happe... pase
WME Tn Sa 6k Ve
a a
James R. Cheatham (recalied)....... ..
, oe eS eee wee
John Goldworthy ...........
Frank T. Smith ..........
NE FOR iaiccieie cas nae a iss iwene ducts
Evidence for plaintiffs. .....-....... Ee
Testimony of John Wilford (cross). .......
Wm. H. Griffith (recalled). .
er Se eee ;
Anderson C. Moorehead (recalled). . .
Isaac N. Boicourt (recalled). ......
TNS NOUNS. OSs beeen aee etree se sae vee sss
nek Wa Ne GON oe hers See e edie Fees
Motion to dismiss. ..... Fee MWe EN aes Co cw
eS MR ate ters ae hacen bc ee SG saves
Defendant's requests to charge... ................---
Charge to the jury .......... Eee be PERE EE
Recugtiume bo Cumine Ges Fig Csi 5 A 8 icc ee
Motion to set aside verdict denied..................-
Judge’s certificate to bill of exceptions .. .....
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit C—Egan’s report................
A—Mining report of Good Hope
OE GS B15 5 a cink an
Consolidated
|
Plaintifle’ Exhibit No.
INDEX.
1—Ayreement between Griffith, Porter, Hob-
son, and Morse, December 18, 1893. ..
2—Subscription paper of associates. ,
3—Power of attorney from Porter, Neheon,
and Morse to Morse and Egan, Decem-
ye = Sa
4—Check of Porter. to Morse and a for
$90,000, December 22, 1895. ;
5—Check of Porter to Morse and Egan for
$60,000, December 22, 1893... ......
6—Deed, Good Hope Consolidated Mining
Co. to Gritith, December 28, 1893. .
7—Memorandum of quitclaim deed, Sigafus
NENG 5h ao eres Dos he whl a em
8—Deed, Griffith to Porter, Hobson, and
Morse, December 28, 1893.
. 9—Memorandum of quiteclaim deed, Bird
et ur. to Porter et al
. 10—Mortgage, Griffith to Sigafus, December
28, 1895. ...
. 11—Mortgage, Porter, Hobson, and Morse to
Thompson ef a/., January 9, 1894
. 13—Letter of Egan to Morse, Noy. 18, 1893.
. 14—Letter, Egan to Roberts, Noy. 19, 1893. .
. 15—Letter, Egan to Morse, Nov. 23, 1893..
. 16—Letter, Egan to Morse .... .....
. 17—Telegrams, Egan to Morse, Nov. 29, 1893.
. 18—Letter, Egan to Platt, Nov. 21, 1893 ....
. 19—Letter, Egan to Roberts................
. 20— Request of Porter et al. for issue of stoc k,
February 24, 1894
. 21—Deed, Porter, Hobson, and Morse to Good
Hope Mining Co., February 24, 1894. .
. 22—Agreement between Sigafus, Bird, and
Cen, Stee G BOO... cc cicisiccics
. 23—Agreement between Sigafus and Griffith,
po ee ere ee
. 24—Package of reports of receipts and ex-
penditures of Good Hope mine (not
set out)
ee ee es
. 25—Summary of reports showing permanent-
improvement accounts
. 26—Summary of bullion returns of Foster
and Egan periods....................
27—United States mint returns (not set out).
. 29—Letter, Cheatham to Doran, Aug. 22, 1895.
. 30—Duplicate of Exhibit 22 (not set out)..
. 31—Letter, Sigafus to Doran, Nov. 7, 1890... ;
. 32—Letter, Sigafus to Doran, Nov. 21, 1890. .
. 33—Mining report of Good Hope gold mine.
. 34—Bullion receipts given in Burnham report.
. 35—Summary of receipts for bullion (not set
IV INDEX.
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit No. 36—Agreement between Sigafos, Bind, and
Maawell, November 7, I8o2..
Defendant's Exhibit A—Letter, Egan to Sigafus, June 25, 18%)...
3—Letter, Egan to Sigafas, November 24, 1893
C—Letter, Egan to Sigafus, Novem)er 30, 1893.
B—Letter, Gritlith to Gibson, May 10, 1893...
C and D—Two promissory notes, Griflith to Sigafus,
December 28, 1893. ee
E—Letter, Griffith to Sigafus, Sept. 20, 1893...
F—Sketch (not set out) : ea
G—Statement of receipts and returns for bull-
ion shipped from Good Hope mine,
March 4, IS90, to December 27, 1893, in-
clusive SSS ae eka
H—statement as to location of samples for
A ee ere ies
I—Map (not set out) ............. Ere
J—Computation of ore in reserve, &ec.
Opinion on motion for new trial . yee Ee oeeerereet ss
Order overruling motion for new trial
Stipulation as to bill of exceptions. ........ 0 ...-. Oe
Assignment of errors. ... 2.2... ... Pe GAR LOR n Gcea oe Ress «Kae
a ee ere ere eee eee cies css SQeee
RSP ee RO Fee eee ee
I a Seka hax ounapen cs a's 5 eee eee LORNA Saas «
RU ey MEER RCRS RAS SAAN Nt AN AK boa Ore CaRAS RaSh ORS as ss
WEG OE TONER gv Sou a co xs annes Re ek wea
| geen ence
United States of America, ss.:
THE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES OF
AMERICA,
To the Judges of the Circuit Court of the United
States for the Southern District of New York:
Greeting:
Because in ‘the record and proceedings, as also
in the rendition of the judgment of a plea which is
in the said Circuit Court, before you, or some of
you, between Dudley Porter, John L. Hobson and
Charles W. Morse, plaintiffs, and James M. Siga-
fus, defendant, a manifest error hath happened, to
the great damage of the said James M. Sigafus, as
is said and appears by his complaint: We, being
willing that such error, if any hath been, should
be duly corrected, and full and speedy justice done
to the parties aforesaid in this behalf, do command
you, if judgment be therein given, that then,
under your seal, distinctly and openly, you send
the record and proceedings aforesaid, with all
things concerning the same, to the Judges of the
United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Second Circuit at the City of New York, together
with this writ, so that you have the same at the 3
said place, before the Judges aforesaid, on the 3d
day of February, 1897, that the record and proceed-
ings aforesaid being inspected, the said Judges of
the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Second Circuit may cause further to be done
therein, to correct that error, what of right and
according to the law and custom of the United
States ought to be done.
2
Witness, the Honorable Melville W.
Fuller, Chief Justice of the Supreme
Court of the United States, this
sixth day of January, in the year of
our Lord one thousand eight hun-
2
dred and ninety-seven and of the In-
dependence of the United States the
one hundred and twenty-first.
JOHN A. SHIELDS,
Clerk of the Circutt Court of the
[L. 8.] United States of America, for
the Southern District of New
York, in the Second Circuit.
The foregoing writ is hereby allowed.
E. H. LAcoMBE,
U. 8. Circuit Judge.
Unirep STATES oF AMERICA,
Southern District of New York. ss.:
I, John A. Shields, Clerk of the Circuit Court of
the United States of America, for the Southern
District of New York, in the Second Circuit, by
virtue of the foregoing writ of error, and in obe-
dience thereto, do hereby certify, that the follow-
ing pages, numbered from three to 558 inclusive,
contain a true and complete transcript of the record
and proceedings had in said court in the cause of
James M. Sigafus, plaintiff in error, against Dud-
ley Porter, John L. Hobson and Charles W. Morse,
defendants in error, as the same remain of record
and on file in said office.
In testimony whereof, I have caused
the seal of the said Court to be here-
unto affixed, at the City of New
York, in the Southern District of
New York, in the Second Circuit, this
28th day cf January, in the year of
our Lord, one thousand eight hun-
dred and ninety-seven and of the
Independence of the United States
the one hundred and twenty-first.
JOHN A. SHIELDS,
Clerk.
- |
3
UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT, 7
SoUTHERN District oF NEw YORK.
)
DupLey Porter, Jonn L. Hos-
son and Charles W. Morse,
against r
James M. SiGaFvs.
To the above-named Defendant: 8
You are hereby summoned to answer the com-
plaint in this action, and to serve a copy of your
answer on the plaintiffs’ attorneys within twenty
days after the service of this summons, exclusive
of the day of service, and in case of your failure
to appear or answer, judgment will be taken
against you by default for the relief demanded in
the complaint.
Witness the Honorable Melville W.
Fuller, Chief Justice of the United
States, at the City of New York,
this fourth day of April, in the year
one thousand eight hundred and
ninety-five.
[L. s.] JOHN A. SHIELDS,
Clerk.
STICKNEY, SPENCER & ORDWAY,
Plaintiffs’ Attorneys,
Office and Post-office Address,
31 Nassau Street,
New York City.
—
10 CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
4
For THE SOUTHERN District oF NEw York.
)
DupLey Porter, Joun L. Hos-
son and Charles W. Morse,
Plaintiffs,
against
JAMES M. SIGAFUs,
11 Defendant.
J
The plaintiffs above named, Dudley Porter, John
L. Hobson and Charles W. Morse, by Stickney,
Spencer & Ordway, their attorneys,-complain of
the defendant above named, James M. Sigafus,
and allege, upon information and belief, as follows:
I.—At all of the times herein mentioned the
plaintiffs above named were, and they are now,
each and all of them, citizens and inhabitants of
the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, and residents
12 of the City of Haverhill, in said Commonwealth of
- Massachusetts.
Il.— The defendant above named was and is a
citizen and inhabitant of the State of New York,
and of the Southern District of said State of New
York, and a resident of the City of New York, in
said State of New York.
IlI.—For some time prior to and down to, on or
- about the 28th day of December, 1393, the legal
title to certain lands and mines and mining claims
situated in the Pinacato Mining District, in the
County of Riverside, in the State of California, and
known as the Good Hope Consolidated Gold Lode
2
Mining Claim, consisting of the San Jacinto and 13
Good Hope Quartz locations, and as the “* Annex,”
adjoining the Good Hope mine on the south, to-
gether with all the dips, spurs and angles; and also
all the metals, ores, gold and silver-bearing quartz,
rock and earth therein; and also the mill and build-
ings thereupon, and certain personal property, con
sisting of mining tools, implements, &c., used in
connection with said mines, upon said premises,
was in the name of the Good Hope Consolidated
Gold Mining Company, a corporation organized
under the laws of the State of California. The de-
fendant, James M. Sigafus, was the president of
said corporation and owned the entire capital stock
of said corporation with the exception of a few
shares which were in the name of his son-in-law,
J. Everett Bird, and was, in fact, the sole beneficial
owner of said lands and mines and mining claims
and the appurtenances thereto and the property
thereupon.
IV.—During said period, and previous to the
28th day of December, 1893, the defendant, repre-
senting his own interests and those of said Good
Hope Consolidated Gold Mining Company and of
said Bird, through one William H. Griffith, entered
into negotiations with the plaintiffs for a sale to
them of said lands and mines and mining claims
and the appurtenances thereto and the property
thereupon.
V.—Dnring said period and previous to the 28th
day of December, 1+93, the plaintiffs herein entered
into negotiations for the purchase of said lands and
mines and mining claims and the appurtenances
thereto and the property thereupon; and there-
upon, and in the course of said negotiations, the
defendant falsely and fraudulently, and with the
_ intent thereby to deceive and defraud the plaintiffs,
_ represented to them, knowing said representations
to be false and fraudulent, that said lands and mines
14
—
16 and mining claims contained a large and valu-
able vein of gold-bearing ore and large and valuable
deposits of gold, and that al! of the gold-bearing
quartz im said lands and mines and mining claims
would average in milling more than $16 per ton,
and laid before the plaintiffs a false and fraudulent
report or statement in writing in regard to said
lands and mines and mining claims, made by one
Burnham, who was therein represented to be an
independent and disinterested mining engineer and
expert, and to have made a careful and complete
examination of the premises, which report or state-
ment, in substance, stated that the pay streak in
17 said mines had an average width of two feet; that
2,434 tons of ore from said mine had been milled,
and yielded an average value in gold of $23.78 per
ton; that said mines had been operated, and the
ore taken therefrom had been milled for a consider-
able length of time, to wit, for two years or more,
and that the ore produced had yielded, in gold, an
- average of $23.78 per ton; that the value of the
bullion produced from said mine, for the twelve
months ending with January, 1892, inclusive, was
$57,879.78, and that the total expense of said pro-
duction was $15,500; that the estimated total
bullion product from said mine, since its discovery
down to on or about February Ist, 1892, was
$317,879.78; that, beyond all doubt, the ore in said
mines averaged to carry at least $18 per ton in gold;
that said mines contained 44,733 tons of gold ore in
reserve, of the net value of $805,186, and also con-
tained 37,333 tons of gold ore in sight, of the net
value of $761,094, and that said mines and mining
claims had a very large prospective value in addi-
tion thereto; that the gold-bearing vein in said
mines was a permanent and lasting one, and
that said property, under energetic management,
should produce from $30,000 to $40,000 per month
net, and keep the development even with the out-
put, together with other statements of fact in re- -
gard to said lands and mines and mining property,
6
18
7
each and all of which statements were false and 19
fraudulent, representing said report to be just and
accurate and true, although knowing the same to
be false and fraudulent; and, during the course of
a mill-run of said mines, made by the plaintiffs for
the purpose of testing the value of the ores con-
tained therein, falsely and fraudulently, and with
the intent thereby to deceive and defraud the plain-
tiffs, placed, and caused to be placed, in and among
the ores to be reduced in said mill-run exceptionally
rich specimens of ore, which were not part of the
ordinary production of said mines, and placed, and
caused to be placed, therein large quantities of ex-
ceptionally rich ore, which had been mined on said 90
premises; but reserved by him over a long period of
time, and which carried gold far in excess of the
average amount carried by the ore produced from
said mines, and caused false and fraudulent repre-
sentations to be made as to the amount of ore
which was run through the mill at that time, un.
derstating the same, with the intent, and with the
result, that a much larger production of gold might
seem to be produced from the ore reduced than was
just and true; and further falsely and fraudulently,
and with the intent thereby to deceive and defraud
the plaintiffs, represented to them that certain por-
tions of said mines, from which all of the valuable
ore had been extracted, were still solid and un-
touched, and blocked up the entrance to such ex-
cavations with timber, which he falsely and fraudu-
lently stated was placed in the mine for the purpose
of support, and that it was dangerous to remove
the same, with the intent and result of thereby
preventing the plaintiffs and their representatives
from investigating the condition of said mines; and
falsely and fraudulently, and with the intent
thereby to deceive and defraud the plaintiffs,
changed certain bullion returns as to past produc-
tion, and misstated the quantities of ore producing
said bullion, so as to show a much larger and richer
production of gold from the ore mined than had, in
21
——
§
22 fact, been made; said defendant making all
of these representations, and doing and caus-
ing to be done all of these acts, with
full knowledge that the same _ were false
and fraudulent, and calculated to deceive and
defraud, and with the intent and _ result
that the same should be communicated to and
acted upon by the plaintiffs, and with the in-
tent and result thereby to deceive-and defraud the
plaintiffs, and to induce them to believe that said
lands and mines and mining claims and the appur-
tenances thereto and the property thereupon were
worth at least the sum of one million dollars, and
93 to induce them to purchase the same.
VI.—If said representations and reports and mill
run hereinbefore mentioned had been true and cor-
rect, and had accurately stated and shown tie
amount and value of the ore contained in said
mines and mining claims, said lands and mines
and mining claims and the appurtenauces
thereto and the property thereupon, would have
been reasonably worth at least the sum of one mil-
lion dollars. But, in fact, said representations and
reports and mill run hereinbefore mentioned were,
and each of them was, and were, and each of them
was, known by the defendant to be untrue and in-
24 accurate and false and fraudulent, and said lands
and mines and mining claims, and the appurte-
nance thereto and the property thereupon was, and
and was known by the defendant to be, worth
practically little or nothing.
VIil.—Thereafter, and on or about December
28th, 1893, the plaintiffs, believing said representa-
tions and reports and mill run hereinbefore men-
tioned to be true and correct, and relying thereupon
and induced thereby, purchased said lands and
mines and mining claims, and the appurtenances
thereto and the property thereupon, for the sum of
$400,000, and paid therefor to the defendant the
sum of &8150,000 in cash; and executed, and caused
9
to be executed, and delivered certain notes and 25
mortgages upon said property, aggregating the
sum of $225,000, as part of the purchase money
therefor; and have since paid to the defendant and
others large sums of money on account of said
notes and mortgages; and have paid, laid out and
expended upon said property, in the attempt to de-
velop the same, large sums of money in addition
thereto.
VIII.--By reason of the premises and of the
facts hereinbefore stated, the plaintiffs have been
deceived and defrauded by the defendant to their
damage in the sum of one million dollars. 26
1X.—The plaintiffs, throughout the trausactions
hereinbefore mentioned, were acting jointly for
their own benefit, and for the benefit of others as-
sociated with them in the enterprise, and the con-
tract of purchase hereinbefore mentioned was made
with the plaintiffs, and in their name, for their own
benefit, and that of their said associates jointly in-
terested with them, and they now sue as the trus-
tees of an express trust, in accordance with the
laws and practice of the State of New York.
X.—Ynere is involved in this suit a controversy -
between citizens of different states, and the matter
here in dispute exceeds, exclusive of interest and
costs, the sum or value of two thousand dollars.
Wherefore, the plaintiffs demand judgment
against the defendant for the sum of one million
dollars, with interest thereon from December 28th,
1893, together with the costs and disbursements of
this action.
STICKNEY, SPENCER & ORDWAY,
Plaintiffs: Attorneys.
te
-~I
10
28 SouTHERN District oF New York, oe
City and County of New York, oe
SAMUEL H. Orpway, being duly sworn, says: I
am one of the attorneys for the plaintiffs in this
action; the foregoing complaint is true to my own
knowledge, except as to the matters therein stated
to be alleged upon information and belief, and as
to those matters I believe it to be true.
The grounds of my belief as to all matters there-
in not stated upon my own knowledge are copies
of original papers and letters referring to the trans-
actions therein mentioned, and of the written state-
99 ments of witnesses to the facts therein alleged, all
of which are now in my possession, and oral and
written statements made to me and my firm by the
plaintiffs and their agents and attorneys.
The reason why this verification is not made by
the plaintiffs in this action is that neither of them
is within this county or district, where I reside
and have my office, and capable of making this
affidavit.
SAMUEL H. ORDWAY.
Sworn to before me this 4th
day of April, 1895.
30 E. W Srarr,
(SEAL. ] Notarz Public,
Kings County.
Certificate filed in New York County.
Endorsed: United States Circuit Court, Southern
District of New York—Dudley Porter and
others against James M. Sigafus—Summons
and Complaint—Stickney, Spencer & Ordway,
attorneys for plaintiffs, 31 Nassau Street, New
York City—I hereby certify that, on the 4th
—_ pamareerrcnereneas
ll
day of April, 1895, at the City of New York, in 31
my district, I personally served the within sum-
mons and complaint upon the within-named
James M. Sigafus, by exhibiting to him the
within originals and at the same time leaving
with him a copy of each thereof. John H.
McCarty, United Stctes Marshal, Southern Dis-
trict of New York Dated Aug. 30, 1895-—U. S.
Circuit Court. Filed Aug. 30, 1895. John A.
Shields, Clerk.
———_
UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT, 39
SouTHERN District or NEw YorK.
DupLey Porter, JoHN L. Hos-
son and Charles W. Morse,
Plaintiffs,
sie. | Answer. .
James M. SIGAFUS,
Defendant.
The above-named defendant, by Niles & Johnson,
his attorneys, answering the complaint of the
above-named plaintiffs, says, for his answer and
defense:
l.—That he has no knowledge or information
sufficient to form a belief that the plaintiffs, or any
of them, were citizens and inhabitants of the Com-
monwealth of Massachusetts, or residents of the
City of Haverhill, at all times mentioned in the
complaint herein, or at any time, and therefore de-
nies said allegations, and each of them.
34
12
II.—Denies that, some time prior to, or down to,
or on or about December 28th, 1893, he was the
owner of the entire capital stock of the Good Hope
Consolidated Gold Mining Company, or corpora-
tion, mentioned in the complaint, or that, with the
exception of shares in the name of his son-in-law,
James Everett Bird, or with the exception of a few
shares, he was the owner of the entire capital stock
of said corporation; and he
Iil.—Further denies that, on or about the 28th
day of December, 1893, or for some time prior
thereto, he was, in fact, the sole owner, or sole
beneficial owner, of the lands, mines, mining
claims and appurtenances thereto, or property
thereupon, or any or either of them, mentioned in
the complaint herein.
IV.—Denies that he, during said period, or
the period mentioned or referred to in the com-
plaint, and previous to the 28th day of December,
1893, or at all, representing his own interests and
those of said Good Hope Consolidated Gold Mining
Company, and of said Bird or any of such inter-
ests, or at all, entered into negotiations with the
plaintiffs for a sale to them of said lands and mines
and mining claims, and the appurtenances thereto
and property thereupon, or any of it, directly or
through one William H. Griffith.
V.—Denies that he has any knowledge or infor-
mation sufficient to form a belief as to the allega-
tions in subdivision of said complaint marked“ V”;
that during said period, and previous tothe 28th
day of December, 1893, the plaintiffs entered into
negotiations for the purchase of the land and mines
and mining claims and appurtenances or property
thereupon, or any or either of them, mentioned in
the complaint, and therefore denies each and every
of said allegations; and he denies that he has any
“13
knowledge or information sufficient to form a be- 37
lief as to any negotiations of the plaintiffs, or any
of them, in regard to, or in any way relating to,
said property prior to that date, or prior to the con-
veyance of the property by the said Company.
VI.—Denies that he. in the course of the alleged
negotiations mentioned in said complaint, or at all,
represented to the plaintiffs, or any of them, that
the lands and mines or mining claims, or any of
them, mentioned or referred to in the complaint,
comained a large or valuable vein of gold-bearing
ore, or large or valuable deposits of gold, and he in
like manner denies that he represented that all the 38
gold-bearing quartz, or any of it, in said lands or
mines or mining claims, or any of them, would
average in milling more than $16 per ton; and he
VII.—Denies that he laid before the plaintiffs, or
any of them, a report or statement in writing in
regard to said lands, or mines or mining claims, or
any of them, made by one Burnham, or by any-
body, or any report or statement in writing, in
which said Burnham, or any one, was reported and
represented to be an independent or disinterested
mining engineer or expert, or to have made a care-
ful or complete examination of the premises; and 39
he
VIII.--Denies that he laid before the plaintiffs,
or any of them, a report stating in substance as al-
leged in the complaint, or any report or statement,
stating that the pay-streak in said mines had an
average width of two feet, or stating that 2,454
tons of ore from said mine had been milled and had
yielded an average value in gold of $23.78 per ton,
or stating that said mines had been operated, and
the ore taken therefrom had been milled for a con-
siderable length of time, to wit, for two years or
more, or any length of time, or stating that the ore
40
41
14
produced in said mines had yielded in gold an aver-
age of $23.78 per ton, or stating that the value of
bullion produced from said mine for the twelve
months ending with January, 1892, inclusive, or
any length of time, was $57,879.78, or stating that
the total expense of said production was $15,500, or
stating that the estimated total bullion production
from said mine since its discovery down to about
February Ist, 1892, or for any period, was $517,-
879.78, or stating that, beyond all doubt, or beyond
any doubt, the ore in said mine averaged to carry at
least $18 per ton in gold, or stating that said mine
or mines contained. 44,733 tons of gold ore in re-
serve, or stating that the gold ore in reserve was
of the net value of $805,186, or stating that said
mines contained 37,333 tons of gold ore in sight, or
stating that such gold ore in sight was of the
net value of $761,094, or stating that said mines or
mining claims had a very large prospective value in
addition thereto, or stating that the gold-bearing
vein in said mine was a permanent and lasting one,
or stating that said property, under energetic man-
agement, should produce from $30,000 to $40,000 a
month net, and keep the development even with
the output, or containing other statements of fact
in regard to said mine, mines, mining claims, lands
and property; and he
(X.—Denies that he represented to plaintiffs, or
any of them, that said alleged report or statement,
or any report or statement, was just or accurate or
true; and he
X.—Denies that he made any of the representa-
tions, statements or reports alleged in the com.
plaint to have been made by him, or any represen-
tations, statements or reports in regard to such
property, falsely or fraudulently, or with intent
thereby to deceive or defraud the plaintiffs or any-
body; and he
eens
X1.—Denies that he knew any representations 43
made by him to said plaintiffs, or any of them, in
regard to said property, or any of it, to be false or
fraudulent.
15
XII.— Defendant, further answering, denies that
he laid before the plaintiffs, or any of them, any
false or fraudulent report or statement; and he de-
nies that he represented said alleged report or state-
ment, or any report or statement laid before plain-
tiffs, or either of them, to be just or accurate or
true, or that he knew any such report or statement,
or any part of it, to be false or fraudulent.
XIII.—Denies that during the course of a mill
run of the mines mentioned or described in the
complaint, alleged to have been made by the plain-
tiffs for the purpose of testing the value of the ores
contained therein, or any mill run alleged to have
been made by the plaintiffs, or anybody, did he
place, or caused to be placed, in or among the ores
to be reduced in said alleged mill run, exceptional-
ly rich specimens of ore, or any specimen of ores,
which were not a part of the ordinary production
of said mines; and he denies that he placed, or
caused to be placed, therein large or any quantities
of exceptionally rich ore which had been mined on
said premises, but reserved by him over a long
period of time, or which carried gold far in excess
of the average amount carried by the ore produced
from said mine, with the intent thereby to deceive
or defraud plaintiffs, or any of them, or at all; and
he denies that he caused false or fraudulent
representations to be made as to the amount of ore
which was ran through the mill at sach alleged
time; and he denies that he understated, or caused
to be understated, the same, or that he represented
to the plaintiffs or to any of them that certain
portions of said mines from which all the valuable
ore had been extracted was still solid or untouched;
and he denies that he blocked up the entrance to
45.
46
47
16
such alleged excavations with timber; and he
dehies that he falsely or fraudulently stated that
such timber or timbers was placed in the mine for
the purposes of support, or that it was dangerous
to remove the same, with the intent or result of
preventing the plaintiffs or their representatives
from investigating the condition of said mines, or
at all; and he further denies
XIV.—That he changed certain alleged bullion
returns, or any bullion returns, as to the past pro-
duction of said mine; and he denies that he mis-
stated the quantites of ore producing such bullion.
or stated or mistated the quantity of ore producing
any bullion, so as to show & larger or richer pro-
duction of gold from the ore mined in said mines
- than in fact had been made; and he
XVI.—Denies that he performed, or caused to be
performed, any of the acts or things alleged in the
complaint to have been done, or caused to be done,
by him, or made, or caused to be made, any state-
ments or misstatements, falsely or fraudulently,
or knowing the same to be false or fraudulent, or
with intent thereby to deceive or defraud the
plaintiffs, or with intent thereby to prevent the
plaintiffs or their representatives from investigating
the condition of said mine; and he further
XVII.—Denies that he made any or all of such
alleged representations with full knowledge, or any
knowledge, that the same were false or fraudulent,
or calculated to deceive or defraud, or with intent
or result that the same should be communicated to
or acted upon by the plaintiffs, or with the :ntent
or result to thereby deceive or defraud the plain-
tiffs, or in order to induce the plaintiffs to believe
that said lands, or mines, or mining claims. or ap-
purtenances thereto, or property thereupon, was
worth, at least, the sum of one million dollars, or
ean
any sum, or to induce them to purchase the same;
and he further .
17
XVIII.—Denies that he has any knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief that if the
representations and reports and mill runs men-
tioned in said complaint had been true or correct,
and had accurately stated and sworn the amount
and value of ore contained in said mine and mining
claims, said lands and mines, and mining claims,
and the appurtenances thereto, and property there-
upon, would have been reasonably worth the sum
of one million dollars.
XIX.—Denies that he made any representations,
or reports, or mill run, as alleged in said complaint,
or that any representations, reports, or mill run,
represented or made by him, were known by him
to be untrue, or inaccurate, or false, or fraudulent;
and he denies that the said lands and mines, and
mining claims, and appurtenances, and the prop-
erty thereupon, were worth little or nothing, or
were known to him to be worth little or nothing,
but on the contrary,
XX.—He denies that he has any knowledge or 51
information sufficient to form a belief as to whether
thereafter, and on the 28th day of December, 1893,
or at any time, plaintiffs, or any of them, believed
said alleged representations or reports or mill run
te be true or correct, or believing them to be true
or correct, or relying thereupon, or induced there-
by, purchased said lands and mines and mining
claims and appurtenances and property, and,
therefore, denies each and every of such allega-
tions; and he
XXI.—Denies that plaintiffs paid him thesum of
$150,000 in cash therefor; and he
52
18
XXIJ.—Denies that he has any knowledge or in-
formation sufficient to form a belief that the plain-
tiffs, or any of them, purchased said property for
the sum of $400,000; and he
XXIII.—Denies that the plaintiffs executed, or
caused to be executed, and delivered certain notes
and mortgages upon said property, aggregating the
sum of $225,000 as a part of the .purchase money
thereof upon the sale mentioned in the complaint,
or any sale,in which the defendant was interested
as in any sense as a seller; and he
XXIV.—Denies that he has any knowledge or in-
formation sufficient to form a belief that plain-
tiffs have paid to others large sums on account
of said notes or mortgages, or have paid, laid
out or expended, upon said property, in the at-
tempt to develop the same, large or any sums of
money; and he
XXV.—Denies that they have since paid or paid
at all to the defendant any sums of money on ac-
count of said notes or mortgages; and he
XXVI.—Denies that by reason of the promises,
and of the facts stated in said complaint, or at all,
have plaintiffs been deceived or defrauded by de-
fendant to their damage in the sum of one million
dollars, or any sum, or at all. .
XXVII.—Denies that he has any knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief as to whether
the plaintiffs through the transactions mentioned in
said complaint, or at all, were acting jointly for
their own benefit, or jointly for their own benefit
and the benefit of others with them associated in
the enterprise, or as to whether any contract of
purchase mentioned in the complaint was made
with the plaintiffs, and in their name, for their
own benefit and that of their said associates,
jointly interested with them, or that they now sue
as trustees of an express trust in accordance with
‘the laws and practice of the State of New York, or
any other State.
Wherefore, defendant demands judgment that
the complaint herein may be dismissed, and that he
may have his costs and disbursements in this action,
and such other or further judgment or relief as may
be proper or just to grant.
‘NILES & JOHNSON,
Defendant’s Attorneys,
Office and Post-office Address, 56
11 Wall Street,
New York City.
19
55
Southern District of New York,
SraTe OF New YORK, —
8s. :
City and County of New York,
James M. SicaFrus, being duly sworn, says: That
he is the defendant in the above-entitled action;
that he has read the foregoing answer, and knows
the contents thereof, and the same is true to his
own knowledge, except as to the matters therein:
stated to be alleged upon informatioh and belief,
and as to those matters he believes it to be true.
JAMES M. SIGAFUS.
Subscribed and sworn to
before me this 23d day
of May, 1895.
HaARRIETTE L. JOHNSON,
: Notary Public,
[sEAL.] City and County of New York.
—
58 Endorsed: United States Circuit Court, Southern
District of New York—Dudley Porter, John
L. Hobson and Charles W. Morse, plaintiffs,
against James M. Sigafus, defendant— Answer
—Niles & Johnson, attorneys for defendant, 11
Wall Street, New York City—U. S. Circuit
Court. filed May 23, 1895. John A. Shields,
‘Clerk.
-
20
‘At a Stated Term of the Circuit Court
of the United States of America for
the Southern District of New York,
59 in the Second Circuit, held at the
United States Court Rooms, in the
City of New York, on Monday, the
sixth day of April, inthe year of our
Lord one thousand eight hundred
é and ninety-six.
' Present—
The Honorable WILLIAM J. WALLACE,
Circuit Judge.
DupDLEY PorRTER et al.
60 vs.
James M. SIGAFUs.
:
Now come the plaintiffs, by Albert Stickney,
Esq., their attorney, and move the trial of this
cause.
Likewise comes the defendant, by Edmund Wet-
more, Esq., his attorney.
Thereupon a jury is impaneled and the cause pro-
ceeds to trial.
After hearing the evidence for the respective par-
ties, the argument of counsel and the charge of the — a
21
Court, the jury retire on April 16th, 1896, in charge 61
of an officer duly qualified to attend them, and upon
their return they say that they find a verdict for
the plaintiffs for the sum of three hundred and
thirty thousand two hundred and seventy-five dol-
lars ($330,275.00/100), and so they say all.
Thereupon the Court denies a motion to set aside
the verdict and for a new trial.
A stay of thirty days is granted the defendant
within which to make and serve a case, with leave
to ~urn the same into a bill of exceptions.
An extract from the minutes.
[SEAL. ] JOHN A. SHIELDS, 62
Clerk.
CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
For THE SOUTHERN District oF NEW YORK.
)
‘
DupLey Porter, JoHN L. Hos- |
son and Charles W. Morse,
Plaintiffs,
| | 63
against
James M. SIGAFUS,
Defendant.
On reading and filing the notice of motion on be-
half of defendant herein, dated April 16, 1896, and
upon the minutes of Hon. William J. Wallace,
United States Circuit Judge, before whom this ac-
tion was tried, and upon the evidence adduced upon
- the trial thereof, and exceptions Jaken by the de-
fendant on said trial and the verdict of the jury,
—y
64 the motion so noticed to set aside said verdict and
grant a new trial in the above-entitled action upon
said exceptions, and hecause said verdict is for ex-
cessive damages, and because the same is contrary
to the evidence, and against the weight of evi-
dence, and because the same is contrary to law,
and upon each and every of said grounds, and for
other order or relief, coming duly on to be heard
upon the 23d day of April, 1896; and after hearing
Edmund Wetmore, Esq., of counsel for defendant,
in support of said motion, and Albert Stickney,
Esq., of counsel for plaintiffs, in opposition thereto;
Now, upon motion of Stickney, Spencer & Ord-
65 way, attorneys for plaintiffs,
Ordered that said motion be, and the same is,
hereby denied.
22
WM. J. WALLACE.
Endorsed: U. S. Circuit Court, Southern District of
New York—Dudley Porter eé al., plaintiffs,
against James M. Sigafus, defendant —Order—
Niles & Johnson, attorneys for defendant, 11
Wall Street, New York City—U. S. Circuit
Court. filed June 20, 1896. John A. Shields,
66 Clerk.
23
CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES,
For THE SOUTHERN DiIsTRICT OF New YORK.
DupLeY Porter, Joun L. Hos- |
son and Charles W. Morse,
Plaintiffs, |
against
JaMES M. SIGAFUS,
Defendant.
ee ae A
Judgment, July 7th, 1896. ;
The issues in this action having been brought on
for trial before Hon. William J. Wallace, Circuit
Judge, and a jury, ata Circuit Court of the United
States of America, for the Southern District of New
York, in the Second Circuit, held on the 6th day of
April, 1896, at the United States Court Rooms, in
the City of New York, and the defendant appearing
by counsel, and the issues having been tried, and a
verdict for the plaintiffs having been duly rendered
on the 16th day of April, 1896, for the sum of three
hundred and thirty thousand two hundred and
seventy -five dollars ($330,275.00/100), and the costs
of said plaintiffs having been adjusted at six hundred
and forty-nine 80/100 dollars; now, on motion of
Stickney, Spencer & Ordway, Esqrs., attorneys for
the plaintiffs, it is
Adjudged, that the said plaintiffs, Dudley Porter,
John L. Hobson and Charles W. Morse, do recover
of said defendant, James M. Sigafus, the sum of
three hundred and thirty thousand two hundred
67
68
62
and seventy-five dollars ($330,275) found by the |
jury, with four thousand four hundred and two
75/100 dollars, interest thereon from the date of
24
70 said verdict, and six hundred and forty-nine 80/100
71
dollars costs, amounting in all to the sum of three
hundred and thirty-five thousand three hundred
and twenty-seven 55/100 dollars, and that said
plaintiffs have execution against the property of
said defendant, James M. Sigafus, therefor; and, it
appearing from the pleadings that the nature of
this action is such that the plaintiffs are entitled to
arrest said defendant, that the plaintiffs have exe-
cution against the person also of said defendant,
James M. Sigafus.
Judgment signed this 7th day of July, 1896.
JOHN A. SHIELDS,
Clerk.
Endorsed: United States Circuit Court,Southern Dis-
trict of New York—Dudley Porter and others
against James M. Sigafus—Judgment—Stick-
neey, Spencer & Ordway, plaintiffs’ attorneys,
85 Nassau Street, New York City—U. S. Cir-
cuit Court, filed July 7, 1896, 2.15 P. M. John
A. Shields, Clerk.
| - 25
CIRCUIT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES 73
For THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF New YORK.
nel ee
’
Dup.ey Porter, Joun L. Hos.
son and Charles W. Morse,
Complainants,
oo
against
JamEs M. SIGAFUs,
Defendant. it
CASE OR BILL OF EXCEPTIONS.
Afterward, to wit, on the 6th day of April, 1596,
and at a stated term of this Court, held at the City
of New York, to wit, on the 6th day of April, 1896,
before the Hon. William J. Wallace, the aforesaid
issues were joined as between the said parties, as
by the record more fully appears, and came on to
be tried by a jury duly empanelled and sworn for
that purpose, said trial having continued until 75
April 16th. 1896; said? plaintiff being represented by
Mr. Albert Stickney and Boyd B. Jones, and the
said defendant by Mr. Edmund Wetmore and Mr.
Henry B. Johnson; and in the course of the trial
the said counsel for defendant did take and allege
sundry exceptions to the rulings of the Court, both
as to the admission and exclusion of testimony and
to the refusal to dismiss the complaint, and to the
charge, and to the refusal to the charge, of the
Court, which said exceptions are hereinafter speci-
fically set forth.
The plaintiffs then read depositions of witnesses
called for plaintiffs.
76
77
26
James B. Doran.
JaMES B. Doran, by deposition taken April 17,
1895, on behalf of the plaintiffs, testified as fol.
lows:
I live near the Good Hope Mine, Perris, Cali-
fornia. I have been a miner for about twenty-four
years. I have done nearly every thing from a tool-
boy up to superintendency. I have worked in the
mine, have acted as boss, foreman, superintendent,
and do milling in the stamp mills. I am not an as.
sayer, but have had a great deal of practical exper-
ience in assaying. I am unable, by reason of sick-
ness, to travel.
I know James M. Sigafus, the defendant. First
met him at the Good Hope Mine in August, 1889.
. [have worked in that mine; began the latter part
78
of August, 1889, and worked unti] August, 1893,
when I was taken sick. Mr. Sigafus employed me
and gave me my instructions and paid me. While I
worked at the mine Sigafus controlled and man.
aged its operation.
A shaft is an entrance into a mine from the sur-
face for the purpose of working it. A level is an
opening driven laterally into a mine from the shaft
for the purpose of carrying ore to the shaft. A
chute is an opening from level into a stope to take
the ore from stope to level. A stope is an opening
made above a level where the ore is taken out. A
man-hole or man-way is an opening into stope
from level. Stulling is heavy timbers fastened into
the walls of a mine, and lagging is boards put on
stulls to hold the ground above.
Mine shut down for a short time a number of
times. Mr. Sigafus ordered it shut down and
started up. The first work 1 did there was the
sinking of the two shafts, the main working shaft,
and one 300 feet north of it. In November, 1893,
there were three shafts—No. 1 or South shaft; No. 2,
ae
es
Main shaft: No. 3, North shaft; there were two |
=
eee
297
James B. Doran. 79
levels, one 250 feet from the surface, and the other
350) feet from the surface. The visible length then
(November, 1893), of the first level was about 950
feet. The second level about 1,000 feet. Neither
level existed when I began to work at the time.
After I had timbered the old south shaft, Mr. Sig-
afus asked me to take charge of the mine, and I
did so until my sickness in August, 1893. I had
very good opportunities to know the width of the
ore vein. I had measured every foot of that vein
that was exposed. The average width in Novem-
ber, 1893; was 18 inches. I also know of the rich- go
ness of the ore. I panned it and made assays at
the office, I mean Mr. Sigafus and myself.
Q. Are you able to state, with substantial accu-
racy, the average richness of the ore in the Good
Hope Mine in November, 1893?
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and calling for an opinion. Ob-
_ jection overruled. To which ruling of the
Court defendant’s counsel then and there
duly excepted.
A. Yes, sir. The value was $8 per ton in free
gold, and a small value beside that in sulphurets, 81
we called it a dollar and a half per ton. I mean by
we, Sigafus and myself.
I have owned gold mines myself in three differ-
ent properties.
The end of the vein in the Good Hope Mine was
very like peas in a pod, or in other words, in little
kidneys of ore, lying laterally and vertically about
the same, odd and even, in the ground like a
checker board. In driving the drift ore would
come in and pinch out. By stoping out the
pinch up to another kidney of the ore made it look
like a continuous vein, while it was not. One half
of the ground was barren. By the ore’s pinching
28
James B. Doran.
out, I mean as we came into unexplored
ground, we encountered a kidney of ore for a
few feet, and then we _ encountered barren
ground or waste ground. There were two or
three heavy breaks in the ground exposing
barren ground for as much as a hundred feet or
more. Between these barren places there would
be ore bodies. Above the breaks sometimes it would
be ore-bearing rock, and sometimes it would not.
In these large breaks there was usually nothing,
and in the smaller ones we would generally get ore
by working up. There was one large break north
of the main working shaft in both levels—about 150
feet north of the working shaft, and another about
500 feet from the working shaft. That showed in
both levels. There was one south about fifty or
sixty feet from the shaft. It shows in both levels.
There is a long break at each end of No. 2 level.
Sigafus said he owned the mine. A number of
times Sigafus talked with me about economizing
and cutting down expenses, as it all came out of
him and was not like a company. He stated that
Mr. Bird had no money but would acquire an
interest in the mine after it had paid him,
Sigafus, back his money. I also had these talks
quite often. I could not say how often.”
Q. While you were employed at said mine, what,
if anything, did you hear said Sigafus say in regard
to what disposition or use he wanted to make of
said mine?
Objected to by defendant's counsel as im-
material; objection overruled; to which rul-
ing of the Court defendant’s counsel then -
there duly excepted.
A. He said he wanted to sell it.
Q. While you were working at said mine what,
if anything, did said Sigafus say to you about pre-
paring the mine for sale?
James B. Doran. 85
29
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as im-
material; objection overruled; to which ‘rul-
ing of the Court defendant’s counsel then
and there duly excepted.
A. His instructions to me was that he wanted to
sell it and for me to keep it in the best condition
possible; to keep all the good ore possible in sight
in the mine and to cover up all poor places and bar-
ren spots as far as I could.
Q. When did he give you said instructions, and,
if more than once, how often?
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as im- 86
material; objection overruled; to which rul-
ing of the Court defendant’s counsel then and
there duly excepted.
A. He usually gave them when he expected par-
ties to examine the mine; at different times; I don’t
remember how often.
Q. What, if anything, did you do to keep good
ore in sight?
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as im-
material; objection overruled; to which rul-
ing of the Court defendant’s counsel then and
there duly excepted. 87
A. We just didn’t take out the good places, but
left it where it could be seen andexamined. It was
by Sigafus’s orders that this was done. I car-
ried them out. He Knew it.
Q. What, if anything, did you do to cover or hide
said barren spots and poor places!
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as im-
material; objection overruled; to which rul-
ing of the Court defendant's counsel then and
there duly excepted.
A. I stulled and lagged them and covered them
. up with timbers. Sigafus knew I did it.
88
89
30
James B. Doran.
Q. “Would the samples so taken be richer or
poorer than the average of the mine?
Objected to by defendant’s counsel; objec-
tion overruled; to which ruling of the Court
defendant’s counsel then and there duly ex-
cepted.
A. They would be richer, and the difference
would be a considerable one.
Iknow John M. S. Egan. I see him, in No-
vember, 1893, at the Good Hope Mine. He was
making an examination of the property. Mr. Sig-
afus and I consulted nearly every evening. He told
me that Egan was here, inspecting the mine and
examining it, with a view of buying it for Eastern
friends. Outside-of that there was not very much
said. Sigafus said that he was very mnch afraid
of the mill test not holding up with the assays;
that the ore in the mine assayed higher than it
would mill. In November, 1893, the poor and bar-
ren spots in the mine had been hidden fo the ex-
tent of about 500 feet. All the good ore was left,
except what we dug out in driving through it to
open it up. Very little of the good ore was stoped.
The second level south had been driven 180, possi-
bly 200, feet south of the south shaft in 1892 and
1893. The last time Sigafus was in that drift he
ordered the discontinuance of the work, as there
was no ore there, and to shut up the entrance to
the drift at the shaft, so that nobody could get in
there. He said that to me. It was timbered with
shaft timbers, and lagged in behind the timbers, so
that it was not apparent that the level had been
driven south of the south shaft; he said to me that
he did not want prospective buyers to see it; it
would do no good in making the sale.
Before November, 1893, the second level north
had been driven about 800 feet north from the main
shaft. In two barren places it was timbered up.
er
James B. Doran.
31
91
The last eighty or ninety feet showed no ore, and a
raise was then driven at the point where the ore
ve out, and the material from said raise was put
into the drift to close it up, and hide that last end
of the drift. The extension of the drift beyond
’ that point could not be seen without close exami-
nation. Sigafus said he wanted to hide that poor
place, and would not have that drift drove any
further.
Q. How soon after you began the work at said
mine did Sigafus first talk of selling it? z
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as im- 92
material; objection overruled; to which rul-
ing of the Court defendant’s counsel then
and there duly excepted.
A. About four months. Most of the time I was
working at the mine. There was a trade pending
between Sigafus and somebody. I left the good
ore and covered up the barren places for a period
of about three years.
The capacity of the Bryan mill was a ton an
hour. When I went there there was a five-stamp
mill, which was taken away in the summer of
1890, and the Bryan mill was erected in February,
1891. There was about 300 tons of ore mined in 93
1889, and about twelve or fifteen hundred tons in
1890. It was milled in 1891. It averaged about
$10 per ton. In 1891 about 1,000 tons were mined.
It was milled as it was mined. In 1893 the mill
averaged about ten or twelve tons per day.
Q. Did you have any information from said Sig-
afus as to whether the operation of the mine was
profitable or otherwise? If you did, state what he
said about it, and when he said it.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent; objection overruled; to which
ruling of the Court defendant's counsel then
and there duly excepted.
95
32
James B. Doran.
A. At different times during this period of time
he said all that he wanted the mine to do was to
. pay the current expenses. That there was months
it was short, and that to make up for this shortage
he would ask me to sort the ore closer for the next
month, and get a better class of ore. The last talk
of this nature was in 1893. .
I have seen this document before. (Witness
shown paper entitled *‘ Mining Report of the Good
Hope Consolidated Gold Mine.”’) I have a copy of
it. I find thisan exact copy. It was prepared by
F. R. Burnham. I don’t know whether this is the
report itself, or only a copy. I gave Sigafus this
document in November, 1893. He never returned
it. He said he wanted to send it to Mr. W. H.
Griffith.
Q. If you know what said Burnham did to make
said report, or how he got the information from
which said report was made, state what he did,
and how he got his information.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent, irrelevant and immaterial; objec-
tion overruled; to which ruling of the Court
defendant's counsel then and there duly ex:
cepted.
A. Yes, Ido know. He first measured the ton-
nage. He measured it every ten feet on the vein
where the vein was exposed. He approximated on
all ground timbered and lagged up. He then sam
pled at each point measured. After that he assayed
the samples taken, and the ground approximated in
measurement was also approximated in value with
that which was actually sampled. He did not make
any mill test. His information he got from Mr.
Sigafus and Mr. Bird; on that he framed his report.
I saw him measure the’pay streak with a rule. I
also saw him make the measurements and take the
samples. He measured the width of the pay streak,
33
James B. Doran.
including the soft tale gouge which lay on the top
and bottom side of the vein, aud was waste mat-
ter. In taking the samples he took the pay streak,
but did not, take any of the soft talc gouge.
recited in said report?
A.. Those he got from Mr. Bird. ~ Bird was secre-
tary here at the mine at that time. I was present
that the tonnage of the ore reserves was about
95,000 tons. Sigafus knew Burnham was engaged
in preparing this report. In 1893 Sigafus was en-
gaged in operating other gold mines in New Mexico
and Arizona, and received samples at the Good
Hope Mine of very rich gold ore from the other
mines. In the winter of 1892 and 1893 we ran into
a very rich pocket. Kingsbury mined it. It would
part of it was sacked and left in stope. Sigafus
said he wanted to use it in case prospective buyers
exacted a mill test.
Egan was making a mill run in November, 1593.
I remember some rich samples being in the house.
Ishould judge there was seventy-five to a hundred
dollars worth, in coarse gold and amalgam and
sainples in the house. 1 don’t know positively.
They were high grade ore. During the mill run
I saw Sigafus put them in the mill. I was just
above -his head on the rock-crusher floor—about
twelve feet from him. I don’t think he see me at
all. I was on the floor that projected out from the
mill; by looking down I could see him, and if he
looked up he was bound to see me. The noise of
the mill would prevent hearing anything. Egan
was at the office or assay-room. There were two
keys to the office.
coarse gold which I mentioned. I remember when
97
Q. How did he obtain the returns of gold bullion .
at the time. In the spring of 1893 Sigafus said |
98
mill about a hundred dollars a ton. The richest -
99
After the time that I saw Mr. Sigafus doing
what I have just described, I never again saw the
—
100 James B. Doran.
34
Griffith was there, about in July, 1893, and at-
tempted to sell the mine. Sigafus then said the
mine was worth something. What he wanted was
a bona fide offer. If that offer was as good asa
hundred thousand dollars, he would take it. He said
after the offer he would parley with them long enough
to take out twenty or thirty thousand dollars, and
then would let them have the mine; that he was
going to sell the mine and get away from here. In
my opinion in the fall of 1893 the mine was fairly
worth $100,000—a little more or a little less.
101
Cross-examination:
My observation has been that there are rich
places and poor places in all mines. I never sawa
mine that maintains its uniformity of richness
throughout. When Mr. Sigafus consulted with me
I was his employee. I received three dollars per
day to jkeep up my expenses, with a contingency
of five per cent. on the sale of the mine, in consid-
eration of the low salary I received. I had an in-.
terest in the sale of the mine of five per cent. upon
the proceeds of such sale, to be paid to me by Mr.
Sigafus. The mine was sold in the last of Decem-
ber, 1893.
Q. Did you receive that compensation that you
expected from Mr. Sigafus upon the sale of the
mine?
A. As yet, I have not.
Q. Have you not brought a suit in the Superior
Court of Los Angeles County against Mr. Sigafus
for such commission, and also for other alleged ser-
vices performed by you, in which you claim dam-
ages for $25,000?
A. Yes, sir. That suit is still pending. He has
never been served with summons and complaint.
Q. Don’t you know that service can be made by
publication upon a non-resident defendant in this
102
35
James B. Doran.
State, and that if you. wanted to, you could have
had service upon him over a year agot
A. No; I don’t know it. The condition of my
health and pocket-book weuld not admit of it.
_ Q. Didn’t you ask Mr. Sigafus to let Burham ex-
amine the mine?
A. Imay have. I may have stated in a former
deposition that I did. I think mry memory is as
good now as it was at that time.
Q. Was it not understood by you, and agreed
between Burnham, Maxwell and yourself, that if
the mine was sold at that time that a commission
of ten per cent. from the sale of the mine was to
be divided between yout?
A. No, there was no agreement; but they said
they would give me something out of the ten per
cent.
To a question like this in my former deposition I
answered ‘‘yes.” Burnham and Maxwell were
only promotors trying to sell the mine. I think I
stated to Griswold that Mr. Sigafus asked $500,000
for the mine. I paid Griswold’s expenses to
the mine. He came at my solicitation. In the
bond to Maxwell and Burnham the price was
$350,000 net if the sale tonk place.
I guessed at the value of the coarse gold in that
pan by being familiar with that kind of material.
I don’t remember how long the pan was in the
" pitcher—several weeks, I think.
Q Did you not write to Mr. Sigafus on the 12th
day of May. 1893, in which you stated you had an
understanding with Mr. Griswold, who was contem-
plating purchasing the mine?
A. Yes; I did.
Q. Did you not state to Maxwell and Barnham,
when they were examining the mine, as tesvified to
by you, that you would see to it that they gota
bond on the mine for $500,000?
A. I don’t remember. I will not swear I did not.
103
104
105.
36
@
I don’t remember being suspicious of Maxwell and
Burnham at that time. I may have asked Mr. Siga-
fus to protect me in that connection. Mr. Sigafus
wrote to me to make them pay me a commission
out of the ten per cent. and he would pay me,
which would make two commissions. That was
the five per cent. I referred to.
Q. The negotiations carried on at that time were
upon a $500,000 valuation, were they not?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How was the weather at the Good Hope Mine
107 2% the time of the mill run by Col. Egan in No-
vember, 1893?
A. If I recollect right, the. weather was fair, but
cold. There had been a snow storm on or about
that time.
Q. The feelings between yourself and Sigafus are
not very friendly, are they?
A. I don’t feel very kindly towards him.
Q. You didn’t say anything to Col. Egan, or any
one connected with him, about what you saw Mr.
Sigafus doing at the mill with the coarse gold and
amalgam, did you?
A. No, sir.
106 Belle Doran.
108
BELLE Doran, by deposition, on behalf of the
plaintiffs, testified as follows:
I live at the Good Hope Mine, near Perris, and
am acquainted with the defendant, Mr. Sigafus. I
know Mr. Egan and Mr. Griffith. I was at the
Good Hope Mine when Mr. Egan and Mr Griffith
were there testing the mine in November, 1893. I
was then living in a house belonging to Mr. Sigafus
at the Good Hope Mine. Mr. and Mrs. Sigafus oc-
cupied the first floor; my husband and I occupied
the second floor. There wasa grate in each room,
and a chimney leading up connecting the two
37
Belle Doran.
rooms. I heard conversations between Mr. Sigafus
and his wife regarding the mill test of which I have
spoken as made by Col. Egav. During the time of
the examination I did some trading with the gro-
ceryman, and took some change up-stairs and laid
it on the mantel above the grate in my kitchen.
When I was through with my work in the evening
I went to take the change off the mantel; in doing
so I dropped it on the hearth. I got down to look
for it, and heard a conversation between Mr. and
Mrs. Sigafus about the mill test. The first words
that attracted my attention were as follows: Mrs.
Sigafus said, ‘How are they getting along with
the examination?” Mr. Sigafus answered, ‘‘ Pretty
satisfactorily, I guess.” Mrs. Sigafus said, ‘‘ How
about the mill test?” Mr. Sigafus said, ‘*I fear the
ore being put through the mill will not equal the
assays; that is all the fear I have.” There were
some other words that I did not catch. Mr. Sigafus
then said, ‘‘ Where is that pan of sulphurets and
coarse gold?” She answered him, ‘* Up-stairs, in
Mr. Doran’s kitchen.” She said, ‘‘ What are you
going to do with it?” He answered, ** Put it in the
mill, of course.” They then began talking about
some other matters, and I didn’t pay any attention
to them. Mr. and Mrs. Sigafus, during this con-
versation, were in their bed-room, directly beneath
me. I could not hear conversations from one room
to the other unless we were near the grate—the
chimney. We could hear voices and talking at any
time; we could not distinguish words unless we
were near the grate in the chimney.
Q. Was there any communication between the
lower chimney and your chimney, or how did the
sound get there?
A. There was a crack in the chimney. When
there was a fire made in the lower grate there
would be a great deal of smoke come into our
room.
110
111
112
113
114
38
Belle Doran.
The pan of sulphurets and coarse gold to whieh
Mr. Sigafus referred at that time was sitting on the
mantel in my room. My husband brought it up.
stairs to show me, but where he got it I don’t know.
Mr. and Mrs. Sigafus came with him when he
brought it up-stairs, and we discussed its contents.
At the time we were talking of the pan Mr. Sigafus
said he thought that pan contained something near
75. I have no knowledge of its value beyond what
Mr. Sigafus told me. I took the pan of sulphurets
with me to my husband’s room, and told him of
the conversation I heard. Mrs. Sigafus came up-
stairs the next morning and asked if I knew where
the pan of suiphurets was that was in my kitchen.
I told her that I did, and got the pan for her. She
had her hands full of quartz samples. I asked her
what she was going to do with them. She said,
‘*“Take them down-stairs, as Mr. Sigafus wanted
them.” She took it down-stairs. I saw Mr. Sigafus
shortly after she took the pan down stairs; he was
going south, toward the mill. He had nothing in
his hands until he got to the corner of the garden.
He then took from his pockets what appeared to
me to be quartz samples. He turned towards the
east and stood where the sun shone on the samples,
and he stood and examined them for several min-
utes. I had seen the quartz samples that Mrs.
Sigafus had in her hand before that time. They
were given to me for rich samples; I was told that
they were rich when they were given to me.
I never saw those samples again after this time.
I went. and told my husband what I had seen,
and he put on his hat and muffler, and said he
would go to the mill too.
Cross-eramination:
We occupied that house as tenant. We left the
honse in January, 1894. The settlement was made
39
Belle Doran. 115
. ja Aprilor May, 1594; it was made through Lawyer
Knight, of Los Angeles. We were to stay a couple
of weeks. Mr. Doran took sick there, and we staid
on until the sale was made. Mr. Sigafus didn’t go
off to New York, as he expected. Then, at the set-
tlement, we were charged $10 a month for every
month we were there.
Q. The relations between your family and that of
Mr. Sigafus, during the entire time you occupied
that house together, were cordial and intimate,
were they not?
A. They were, from the time we went into the 116
house until the day when Mr. and Mrs. Sigafus
went out. They ceased with the parting between
Mr. Doran and Mr. Sigafus. There is no friendship
existing between the two families. I cannot tell
the day of the month of the mill test. It was cold;
we had great trouble about keeping up fires—I re-
member that. The entire up-stairs was at our dis-
posal. Mrs. Sigafus used them also as bedrooms
for guests. and the Sigafus family occupied the
lower floor. The room immediately below my
kitchen, where I heard the conversation, was their
bedroom.
The accident of dropping my money caused me 147
to get down on the hearth right by the crack. I
could not hear their conversation unless I got down
and placed my ear by the crack near the hearth. I
do not remember the exact date. It was in the
evening. I had my ear to the crack in the chim-
ney, listening sufficiently long time to hear what
[have stated. Iremoved my ear when Mrs. Siga-
fus began to ask her husband about the mail re-
ceived that day. Idid not say anything to Mr. and
Mrs. Sigafus the next morning of the conversation
overheard the night before. I did not inform Col.
Egan or Mr. Griffith, or any one connected with. the
examination, of the conversation. I saw them ata
distance every day. We were living in the same
118
119
40
Belle Doran.
camp. I did not try to see them and speak to
them; no, sir, I did not. We were anxious to have
the mine sold. I didn’t want this particular sale to
fall through. The pan containing the sulphurets
and coarse gold was about as large as the crown of
a gentleman’s straw hat, but not quite so deep.
The pan was about half full of the material. It
had been in my room several weeks. The pan
stayed in my room on the mantel-piece for several
weeks. That is the only instance that such a thing
occurred in the house, so far as I know. I cannot
tell how much coarse quartz or gold was in the
pan, and how much of the contents was sulphurets.
When Mrs. Sigafus asked me for the pan of sul-
phurets next morning, no one was present beside
myself. When I saw Mr. Sigafus examining quartz
samples, I was standing at my kitchen table; my
attention was called to some one passing, and it was
Mr. Sigafus going towards the mill.
area
Belle Doran. 121
41
Mrs. Doran makes a diagram of the location of
. the mill, house and office, and the mill where the
test was made.
ie Sis waad cane 4e <8 ORS N
Mill :
“© ” :
129
S
es : 6. 0 eek ee ERO Ct ee ee a oa
ea ‘
: Office :
Garder “2 :
eS ees ok te bee Ree °
“es Re
He; os e+e AREER S FRE SSO
123
“A” window where I stood when I saw Mr.
Sigafus.
Sigafus stood at X, marked “B.” ‘*C,” mill
where test was made. “ D,” Company’s office.
Witness has made diagram as requested, which
the defendant offers in evidence, and asks the Com-
missioner to identify it, and attach it to the deposi-
tion as Defendant's Exhibit 1.
Ke nennl
125
126
a3
Belle Doran.
Sigafus stood at “* B,” the corner of the garden, sev-
eral minutes, as he examined several different pieces
before he started for the mill “‘C.” When he left
““B,” he went towards “C,” the mill. ‘‘A” rep-
resents the kitchen in the second story, where I was
standing. Mr. Doran at this time was in the north-
east room in the house, on the second floor, about
twenty feet, the length of the hall from where I
stood at ‘‘ A.” My husband was sitting up in his
room dressed. The first thing I said was, ** What
do you suppose has become of my samples?” I
don’t remember what answer he made. Then I
told him that I saw Sigafus with some samples of
quartz going towards the mill, and he had stopped
and examined them, and I believed they were my
samples, and I said, ‘‘ 1 wonder if he was going to
put them in the mill?” Mr. Doran said, ‘I don't
know what else he would do with them, and I guess
I wili go down tothe mill, too.” He got up and
got his hat, and I believe I helped him on with his
muffier. I was in the room with him at that time,
probably three or four minutes, then Mr. Doran
went down-stairs and passed out of the door at the
northwest corner of the house, passed along west
of the garden and went down towards the mill. It
was in the forenoon, probably about ten o'clock.
It was some time during the last of November,
1893. The first I saw of the quartz samples, he
took something out of his pocket about as large as
an orange, only irregular, perhaps two, or two and
a half inches square, something like that. I saw
him examining three anyway. It is a common oc-
currence for men to be examining ore, rock and
samples about the mine, that being their business.
I never heard any other conversation through the
medium of the crack in the chimney between Mr.
and Mrs. Sigafus before or after that time. Mr.
and Mrs. Sigafus at that time were talking in their
ordinary tone of conversation. The evening when
—
James A. Kingsbury. 127
43
they came home, after the sale of the mine, Mr.
Sigafus and Egan came up to Mr. Doran’s room;
they didn’t either sit down; they got an introduc-
tion, and said the mine would go into the hands of
the new manager.
_—
James A. KINGSBURY, by deposition, on behalf of
the plaintiffs, testified as follows: -
My age is 44. Residence, Good Hope Mine. Oc-
cupation, miner. I have worked in the Good Hope
Mine, situated in Riverside County, California.
Mr. Duran employed me. Mr. Sigafus paid me up
; to the time of the change. I worked from Decem-
ber, three years ago, UP to about the 19th of April,
1895, excepting the time the mine was shut down
about two years ago. The biggest part of the time
I was taking out ore. I know John M. S. Egan. I
seen him a short time prior to Thanksgiving Day in
1893. There was a mill run made. I was working
in what was then the second level, between the
main shaft and the shaft south—about half way be-
tween. I know James R. Cheatham. At the time
of said mill run said Cheatham was the foreman. 129
Q. At the time of said mill run did said Cheatham
make any inquiries of you concerning certain sacked
ore in the mine? If yea, state fully what he said in
making said inquiries and what you said.
128
Objected to as incompetent and immaterial;
objection overruled; to which ruling of the
Court counsel for defendant then and there
duly excepted.
A. He did ask me in regard to some ore in sacks
that was in the stope in the first level. near the sec-
ond manway, north of the main shaft. Cheatham
asked me if it was good ore and I told him it was.
130
131
132
44
James A. Kingsbury. _
Q. Who mined that ore?
A. I mined that ore. I think it was March or
April, two years ago. I sacked the ore and I guess
I put it in the sacks the same day I mined it. for
when I was working there I sorted out the best ore
that I thought, and put the rest into the chute. I
worked there two or three weeks altogether and put
the best ore in sacks. These sacks of ore was only
a portion of what I sacked there altogether. It
was hard white quartz, discolored more or less, and
it was better ore than the average of the rock
that I worked in that stope. I can say that I see
gold in it when I sacked it. I should judge the
sacks were about two-thirds full; I never weighed
it, but I should judge they would weigh about forty
pounds each.
Q. In your opinion, what was the value per ton
of said sacked ore.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent; objection overruled; to which
ruling of the Court counsel for defendant
then and there duly excepted.
A. It is pretty hard to put a value on it. In my
opinion it would run $20 per ton or more.
I was putting in the ore the same as I would if
there was no mill run; Cheatham accused me of
not taking the waste out on purpose. I was put-
ting it in just the same as I would if I was working
in the mine to-day under ordinary work.
Q. Did you hear him say anything to any other
person or give any orders to any other person about
said ore that you had sorted? If yea, state what
he said to the person about it and who that per-
son was?
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent; objection overruled; to which
ruling of the Court counsel for the defend-
ant then and there duly excepted.
oe
_ James A. Kingsbury.
45
138
A. L heard Cheatham tell Bev Boren to sort it as
he took it out of the chute into the car; that is, the
ore that I broke; and he did sort out close to a car-
load.
Q. What kind of ore was it he rejected and
sorted out?! :
A. It was ore and waste together; some waste
that would have been sent up at any other time.
Q. How much ore in weight did the cars that
were used during the mill run bold as they were
loaded during the ordinary operation of the mine?
A. I don’t know how much acar holds. During | 34
the mill run, there was some few cars I see sent up
heaping full.
In April, 1893, the mine was shut down for five
or six weeks. I was working in it on both levels
before it shut down. After it started up I went to
work on the second level, and I noticed sulphurets
or concentrates on the second level from the main
shaft to the south shaft, and after the sale of the
mine 1 noticed them vorth of the main shaft on the
lower level, and there is some there yet. I couldn’t
say whether those conceutrates were there before
the mine was shut down or not. On the first level
I did not notice any sulphurets or concentrates. I
understood that the mine was shut down because
Earnest Waters was coming to buy it.
Q. Do you know whether said Cheatham saw the
said concentrates or sulphurets concerning which
“you have been testifying to; if yea, when did he
see them, who was present when he saw them, and
what, if anything, did you hear him say about it?
135
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as im-
material and incompetent; objection over-
ruled; to which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. Before there was any mill run made, a month
or two, Cheatham asked me one day in the stope,
46
136 James A. Kingsbury.
at the same time pointing it out to me, if I had
noticed it; and I told him I had; the remark was
made by one of us—‘‘it looks as if it had been put
there.” There was no one else present beside him
and me. I saw Mr. Sigafus in the summer of 1894;
he was in the front of the house I am living in. It
was when I came home from work that I saw him.
The last thing Sigafus said to me was ‘not to
say anything.”
Cross examination:
187 Q. At any time you had the conversation as tes.
tified by you with Mr. Cheatham was Mr. Sigafus,
the defendant in this action, present?
A. No, sir.
. At any time that you received instructions
from Mr. Cheatham concerning your work in or
about the mine, was the defendant in this action,
Mr. Sigafus, present?
A. No, sir.
_ Q. Did you ever talk with Mr. Sigafus about
Cheatham’s instructions?
A. I have never talked with Mr. Sigafus about
any order or instruction that Cheatham gave me.
138 | knew of none of Mr. Sigafus’s orders to Cheat-
ham.
The ore that I sacked and broke, it was in what
we call the oid first level, in the stope near the sec-
ond man-way, north of main shaft. That was not
the only occasivn while I was employed in the mine’
that the ore was sacked.
Q. Is it not a common occurrence? .
A. I sacked a good deal of ore right through in
that stope, and this was some I had left or over-
looked. I had orders from Dora to put all of it in
the chute.
Q. You say that these were some sacks that you
had overlooked—how many sacks of ore were there
in the first instance, sacked by you?
47
James A. Kingsbury.
A. That I can’t tell, because I had sacked some
ore at least twice, and had sent it up in the sacks.
It was rich ore. I could see gold in it—rich ore—
and that is the reason it was sacked. I am not an
assayer. I never made any examination or assays
of this particuiar ore in order to. see how much it
would run to the ton.
Q. Did you pound up any of this particular ore
in a mortar to ascertain how rich it was?
A. No, sir.
Q. Lask you to state to the Court how much this
ore would run to the ton in gold?
A. $20 or over. ;
Q. You have stated that you have not the requis-
ite knowledge to make an assay, and that you
never made an assay of this particular ore, or pan-
ned any of it, or crushed it in the mortar, and still
you swear the ore would run $20 and over to the
ton—now, you were just guessing at that, were
you not?
A. It is not exactly a guess; it isa proposition I
would bet on. .
Q. Then you will not swear it would go $20 or
over per ton?
A. Of course, I could not swear to anything
more than my judgment; no one else could do it,
if they never panned any of it. Ido not know, of
my own knowledge, that the sacked ore was run
through the mill during the Egan test.
Q. How much did this ore weigh to the sack—
how many pounds? ..
A. As near as I can judge, 40 pounds. I had no
means of weighing it; never even thought that it
would come up. I never weighed any of the sacks
to see what they weighed.
Q. You stated that Cheatham accused you of not
taking the waste out on purpose— what did you
mean by that?
A. I meant just what I said; he accused me of
139
140
141
142 James A. Kingsbury.
not taking the waste out on purpose. The waste
is valueless. _I have sent up as good ore, at differ.
ent times before the Egan mill run, fully as good
as I sent up then. I commenced work in the Good
Hope Mine three years ago last December, and have
worked ever since, except when I have been sick,
or when the mine was shut down. I am a practi-
cal miner. I can’t give the correct definition of a
gold sulphuret. It is a sulphuret carrying gold,
instead of gold sulphuret.
Q. Now, tell me what a sulphuret is.
143. A. As my understanding is, that it is an iron
that is called sulphuret. I have not looked in the
dictionary to get the exact Seeeton; that is all I
know about it.
Q. Now, Mr. Kingsbury, tell me what a concen.
trate is in reference to your answer to direct-inter.
rogatory 35.
' A. Concentrates is a mineral that has been con-
centrated —separated from the rock that carries it.
That answer applies to the kind of concentrates to
which I had reference in my answer.
Q. Where did you see those sulphurets and con-
centrates that you testified to?
A. I see it through the stope between the main
144 haft and the old shaft south; also north of the
main shaft 40 or 50 feet, and on the level 500 feet
north of main shaft, about 30 foot of it, along the
ledge; all this is on the ledge, in between the hang-
ing and the foot wall. I never seen it on any other
level.. Never assayed it, socan’t tell that they car-
ried gold.
A sulphuret may or may not carry gold. I won't
swear that these sulphurets did. The concentrates
I have testified to, in my belief and judgment, car-
ried gold. I never assayed them. Cheatham asked
me if I had noticed the concentrates. One of us, I
don’t know which, said, ‘‘It looks as if it were
put on.”
James A, Kingsbury. 145
_ When Sigafus told me not to say anything, I said
that J would not.
Q. When you said, in reply, ‘‘ I would not,” what
did you have reference tof
A. I thought it was in relation to anything |
knew in regard to the mine.
Q. Did you know anything, of yourown knowl-
edge, that was damaging to the mine?
A. As near as I knew, the mill-run was not what
Icall fair and square. Also, I knew of these con-
centrates and sulphurets.
Q. Did you ever have any talk with Mr. Sigafus j4¢
concerning this Egan test?
A. No, sir.
Q. Is it not a general custom amongst all miners
that they are not to speak to strangers concerning
the mine or its workings!
A. The custom that way is the same as any ems
ployee in other business. During my work as a
miner, during all these years, I was never cautioned
but once, and that was here on this mine since the
Good Hope Company bought out Mr. Sigafus.
Graham, the superintendent, so called, cautiuned
me. As near asI can get at it, he said, ‘*T wish
you wouldn’t talk about the mine.” And I told
him I wouldu’t. 147
I have a family—a wife, one boy, and my sister-
in-law. I live in one of the Company’s houses. I
don’t pay any rent. I have lived in that house,
without paying rent, since two years ago last Sep-
tember. Mr. Sigafus never charged me any rent.
Lalso built an addition to that house. Mr. Sigafus
is not the owner of the mine now. I was hurt in
the mine; the Company pays my doctor's bills, I
think. I know they paid other men’s bills. The
doctor has not presented any bill to me for services.
He has asked me once in regard to the bill. He
asked me if Mr. Wilson has said anything to ine
about it, and Itold him no. Mr. Wilson, the super-
148
149
150
50 -
James A, Kingsbury.
intendent, first spoke to me about taking my depo-
sition. I said it was my opinion, as far as I knew,
that it was not a fair and square deal. The ore that
I broke for the Egan mill-run had been held in re-
serve ever since 1 worked there before. I can
swear that the ore I broke and put in the chute
after being re-sorted was put in the carand run out
to the shaft. I seen some of it along on the track
near the chute where it had been thrown by the
carman; I seen two or three cars of it at the sta-
tion on the level before it was sent up. I didn't
see it upon the surface. I know why it went into
the mill, it was too rich to throw over the waste
dump. I did not see it put into the mill. I didn’t
break any poor ore; this I broke for the Egan mill
was just like a tit hanging down. I had broke
some of that ore for previous mill-runs that was
made when two experts came here, and Doran and
I changed upon the experts some of the sacks. that
had been sacked and sewed by the experts and my-
self and another man to make that mill run rich,
and, as I understand it, the experts got away with
the clean-up.
Q. Then I understand that you substituted sacks
with good ore for bad ore and gave them to the ex-
perts at that time?
A. I did.
Q. You and Doran did this, did you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And when you and Doran did this you knew
you were perpetrating a fraud upon them?
A. I did. é'
Q. How much were you paid for your work at
that time?
A. $2.50 a day. I did it on orders from Doran.
Q. That—is that the James B. Doran who wasat
one time foreman of the Good Hope Mine, whose
deposition was taken in this case about a month
ago?
51
Manuel Miller.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did those experts come to examine the mine
with a view to purchasing the same?
A. That was their representations.
Q. Did not Doran bring them to the mine
A. No, sir; Mr. Bird. Mr. Sigafus was not
here.
———
MANUEL MILLER, by deposition, on behalf of the
plaintiffs, testified as follows:
My residence is Good Hope Mine, age 44 years;
occupation, & miner. I commenced to work at the
Good Hope-Mine in July, 1890. I have worked
there most of the time ever since. I know James
M. Sigafus. He paid the miners 1890, 1891, 1892,
and 1893. There was a little mill here when I first
came here. A Bryan mill was put up at the mine
after 1 went to work. When I came here they
milled the ore in the little mill. The ore mined be-
tween the time I went to work in 1890 and the
time the Bryan mill was erected was piled close to
the mill, and milled when Bryan mill was finished.
I know John M. S. Egan. I saw him the first time
he came to the mine. ‘I heard that they was going
to make a little mill run for Egan. I was mining
down in the mine. I know James R. Cheatham.
He was mine boss at the time of the mill-run.
Q. If said Cheatham gave you any instructions
or orders about your work during said mill-run,
state fully what he said.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled: to which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. He told me to put some ore that was sacked
there in the chute. That ore was put in the stope
151
152
153
154
155
156
52
William J. Cocking.
close to the second manway on the first level. |
put this ore in the chute. I didn’t count the sacks;
about a dozen, more or less; I can’t tell. It seems
to me it was good ore; whether it was very rich or
not I can’t tell; it was white and a little yellowish.
I have been mining since 1876.
Cross-examination:
The ore milled in 1890 was milled by the Bryan
mill; I don’t know what year it was milled. I
never assayed or panned out any of that ore in the
sacks. When I state it was good ore, I merely
give it as my opinion, without making any assay
or panning it. I worked in the mine underground
during the most of the time it was run.
Q. Do you know this stope where those sacks of
ore came from!
A. I don’t know where it came from; I know
where I got it. Mr. Wilson asked me to testify
here. He is Mr. Wilson, the superintendent of the
Good Hope Mine. I never spoke to him but once;
one day Mr. Doran asked me if I knew of such
sacks and if I knew who put them in the chute, so
I told him I did. I talked to Mr. Jones about it.
I heard Mr. Jones was interested in the Good Hope
Company. I live in one of the Company’s houses
with my family. I don’t pay any rent.
Wituam J. Cocke, by deposition on behalf of
the plaintiff, testified as follows:
My name is William J. Cocking; age, twenty;
residence, Good Hope Mine: occupation, working in
tle mine. I commenced here in 1893. I have
worked as a carman. A carman has to send up —
ore and waste; keep the chutes empty; keep his
—
William J. Cocking. 157
58
track clean down in the mine; when he has nothing
else to do he helps the miners. I know Mr. Egan.
I first saw him here at the mine when he first came
out from Qolorado, the first time. I saw Mr.
Sigafus at the Good Hope Mine the first time Iever
caw him. I know James R. Cheatham. Mr.
Sigafus hired me. Cheatham was foreman when I
come and he worked for Mr. Sigafus. I remember
when the Egan mill ran was made. T run a car.
Q. Did Cheatham give you any instructions as to
what you should do during said mill run? If so,
state what he said in giving said instructions, and j58
if so, what you said at the same time.
Objected to by defendant's counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled; to which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. When I went down in the morning be told
me not to send up anything until he came down;
when he came down he took me around and showed
me what chutes he wanted me to run out of, he
told me to run out of all the chutes excepting one
when Mr. Egan was down inthe mine, and I done
it. 159
Q. Which chute did he tell you not to send up
from when Egan was there?
Objected to by defendant's counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled; to which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. The chute near the second manway on the
first level on the north side of the main shaft.
Q. What directions did he give you regarding
that chute?
Objected to by defendant's counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
160
161
162
54
William J. Cocking.
ruled. To which ruling of the Court coun.
sel for defendant then and there duly ex-
cepted.
A. He told me it was ‘‘ damned rich ore and he
didn’t want Egan to see it.” I suppose he meant
Egan; he said ‘‘ them.” (End of answer.) I sent
ub from said chute as much as four cars, I am sure;
I sent up some on the first day and on the second;
it was rich-looking ore for all I know about it; it
was a red looking ore, with a little white in with it.
Q. Did Cheatham, at any time during said mill
run, after he had said to you what you have al-
ready testified to, have any further talk with you
about the ore from said chute? If yea, state fully
what that talk was—what he said and what you
said.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court coun-
sel for defendant then and there duly ex-
cepted.
A. Yes, sir; he did; he came down and wanted to
know if I had it all up, and I told him yes; he said,
‘that was good,” and that he was glad of it. (End
of answer.) I had some of it in my car once when
Egan was down in the mine, in the bottom of the
car. He did not see this ore, because I ‘had some
other ore on top of it.
Q. During said mill run did you Keep any account
of the carloads of ore that you sent up? If yea, state
when you began to keep the account and how you
kept it.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as im-
material: objection overruled. To which
ruling of the Court counsel for defendant
then and there duly excepted.
A. Yes, sir; I kept it on a tally-board down in
—
William J. Cocking.
55
the mine.
rately.
Q. If, at any time during said mill run, Cheat-
ham had any talk with you about said account,
state fully what he said and what you said, and all
about it.
I kept it truly and correctly —accu-
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court coun-
sel for defendant then and there duly ex-
cepted.
A. Yes, sir, he did; he came down in the mine
and wanted to know what in hell I was doing. I
told him I was not doing anything but sending up
ore and running the cars. He said I was sending
up one car and marking down two. I told him I
wasn’t. Then we had a little quarrel over it down
there. :
Q. If Cheatham, at that time. did anything to
your account that you kept on the tally-board of
the carloads that you sent up, state fully whet he
did.
Objected to by defendant's counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court coun-
sel for defendant then and there duly ex-
cepted.
A. Yes, sir, he did; he scratched off 15 marks
from my tally-board.
Q. Who was hoist engineer at the mine during
the mill run?
Same objection, ruling and exception.
A. Frank Whitten.
Q. If said Cheatham, before Egan came to the
mine, and before the mill run was made, said any-
thing about a purchaser coming to examine the
mine, state fully what he said, how long before the
= a
166 William J. Cocking.
said mill run that he said it, and where you aud he
were when he said it.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in.
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court coun.
sel for defendant then and there duly ex-
cepted.
A. Yes, sir; he told us there was a party coming
here to see about buying the mine; that was one
day at noon, when we were coming up the shaft—
167 about half-way up. It wasa few days before Egan
came.
Q. If, at the time referred to in the preceding
interrogatory, he gave you any order or instruc-
tions as to working in the stopes or preparing the
stopes for examination, state fully what he said.
Objected to by defendant's counse! as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court coun-
sel for defendant then and there duly ex
cepted.
A. Yes, sir; he told us this party was coming
168 and to get our places fixed up nice, and we done it.
Before Egan came to the mine we took all the loose
waste down around from the ore; we cleaned up
everything to make it look nice; all the boys in the
mine were doing the same thing. Cheatham told
us to. I could not tell just how long it was befo
the mill run. -
Just a little while after Egan went back I was
discharged. Cheatham fired me. Mr. Sigafus said
if Cheatham discharged me I would have to go.
Cross-examtnation:
Mr. Sigafus was not present when Cheatham
gave me instruction. Mr. Miller, Fred Watts,
57
William J. Cocking.
Johnnie Wilford, Frank Foster and, I forget the
other one, were about there. Cheatham’s position
at that time was foreman at the mine. I received
instructions from him as foreman before, and in
the presence of others also before. He, at this
time, did not enjoin any secrecy upon Me nor upon
any other person or persons present. The next
instructions I got from Mr. Cheatham was down
in the mine, about seven o’clock in the morning—
somewhere near eight. He came and told me to
come and he would show me what chutes to run it
out of.
Prior to the Egan test I received instructions
from Mr. Cheatham as to what chute [ was to work
in and as to what ore I was to send up. The in-
structions by Mr. Cheatham, in the presence of the
seven persons, was not an unusual occurrence.
There were three chutes. I don’t know how rich
the ore was. I have sent ore before out of that
chute. I don’t know whether it was rich ore or
not.
Q. Have you stated all the conversations between
you and Cheatham at the second time you received
instructions from him during the Egan mill run?
A. No, sir.
Q. What further instructions did he give you at
that time?
A. He told me that the ore in that chute was
damned rich ore and he didn’t want them to see it,
and to slip it up when I got a chance. He said if
he asks you where you are getting it from, and if I
had any of that ore in the car, to tell him out of
some other chute.
Q Who was present at that time beside you and
Cheatham?
A. Nobody. I slipped up out of that rich chute
about four carloads of ore.
Q. Is it not a fact that you sent up out of the
other chutes over 40 carloads!
169
170
171
172
173
174
58
William J. Cocking.
A. I wouldn’t say there were 40 carloads.
Q. Will you swear you didn’t send up 40 car.
loads?
A. I have forgotten; I wouldn’t swear that I did
or I wouldn’t swear that I didn’t. When Cheatham
marked the cars off my tally-board I told him then
I had run the cars and I wanted them; he said [
didn’t run them and to keep still or I would go on
top. After I was discharged I was never after em-
ployed by Mr. Cheatham or Mr. Sigafus. I told Siga-
fus I was discharged and asked him if Cheatham
could fire me. He said Cheatham was the foreman,
and if Cheatham said I had to go I had to go. I
worked under Mr. Cheatham for this Company.
I told Egan about running that rich ore up on him,
after I was discharged when I came back to work
for him. Cheatham at that time was working for
Egan. i told him Cheatham gave me the orders
to do it. I didn’t feel very good towards Cheatham
for firing me without any reason. I said I would
give him away when I was here last time and [
done it. I told Egan,-and he knew nothing about
it as far as | know. I wanted to keep Cheatham
out of work if I could. At that time he was work-
ing for Egan. I don’t know whether Egan fired
him or whether he quit. I said about Cheatham
that if he and [ had any more trouble we would
tight it out; I said that before several. I used the
words about Bev Boran, I got him fired. Mr.
Willson first spoke to me about giving my deposi-
tion in this case. He called me in the office and
asked me if I knew anything about it, and as I
knew he did, I told him I did. That was quite a
little while before Mr. Jones came out here. It
might be two months or more. At the time I
promised to testify I was employed by the com-
pany for whom the said Willson was_ superin-
tendent. I said nothing about what I would tes-
tify. I have discusse? the matters I have testified
ee .
Frank A. Whitten. 175
59
to with others connected with the mine. I live at
the Good Hope Mine, with my uncle, Fred
Watts. I have been employed by the present com-
pany since April or May, 1894, and have been
working for them ever since until laid off the other
day. My uncle, Fred Watts, with whom I live,
lives in one of the Company’s houses. I don’t think
he pays any rent.
Q. Did you ever have any instructions prior to
the Egan test about cleaning up?
A. Yes, sir; Mr. Cheatham used to tell us every
once in awhile to clean up our track and station 476
and make them look neat.
—————
Frank A. WHITTEN, by deposition, on behalf of
plaintiffs, testified as follows:
Iam thirty years old; reside at Good Hope Mine;
occupation, hoisting engineer. I know James M.
Sigafus. I first went to work for him in Septem-
ber or October, 1890, and except from the 13th day
of August, 1891, to some time in March, 1892, I
worked for him until he sold the mine. When I
went there there was no mill running. The Byran 477
mill was put in afterwards, as near as I can tell, in
1392; when it was put in there were two piles of
ore on the surface. They were mining but not
milling in 189!. In 1892 they were mining and
milling at the mine. I know John M. S. Egan. I
first saw him here at the mine either November or
December, 1893. There was a mill run after I first
saw him here—a week or so. I was hoisting en-
gineer. I hoisted the ore and run it into the mill
myself, and also kept tally of the number of cars.
I kept tally on a cardboard with a pencil. Mr.
Cheatham supplied them. I kept the account cor-
rectly. Mr. Cheatham took care of the cardboard.
Q. Did you have any conversation with Mr.
178
179
180
60
Frank A. Whitten.
Cheatham during the mill run about your account
and the number of cars of ore that came up? If so,
state it.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. He said my tally wasn't right; that it didn’t
tally with the boys below. (End of answer.)
Cocking and Boren kept the tally below; I didn’t
see them. They were the carmen.
Q. If during the mill run Cheatham changed any
of your tally-boards, state what change he made.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. There was a change made by Mr. Cheatham.
He said I had too many cars. I don’t remember
how many he took off. The ore was taken in an
iron car on a track; I run it myself.
Q. What instructions, if any, did Cheatham give
you during the mill run as to what you should do
during the mill run? State fully what he said in
giving said instructions to you and what you said.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. Yes, sir; he told me to keep the skip cleaned
out; Mr. Sigafus told’ me when Cheatham was
present to keep the ore cleaned up on the platform
where it had spilled off the car. (End of answer.)
All that I notied about the ore was the cars came
up loaded full, and it was what was called rich ore,
and no waste in it; the rich ore I spoke of was red
61
Frank A. Whitten.
ore; | panned it several times and it was considered
the best ore in the mine; I could see gold in it. It was
all clean and free from waste; the cars were loaded
fuller than usual, and it was apparently all good
ore all the way through; a good deal better than
any average we had had before. There is always a
considerable waste as a rule; I don’t know just how
much. There were to be sixty-one cars in that mill
run; but how many there was run I couldn’t say;
whether there was more or not; I am sure there
was sixty-one.
Q. How did you know when to stop hoisting
that ore for the mill run?
A. Cheatham told me that was all they wanted
for that test.
Q. How many carloads of ore. loaded as they
were during this test, would make a ton?
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial; objection over-
ruled. To which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. I would judge that 24 cars would make a ton.
(End of answer. )
During the test I saw Sigafus panning at the
hoist a good many times and saw him at the mill
several times. The crushing room was above the
mill There was nothing to prevent a man coming
into the crushing room without my seeing him dur-
ing the mill test. The mill made considerable
noise; it would drown out the footstep in the crush-
ing room easily.
Q. Describe the way and manner in which Siga-
fus opened up the stopes in said mine and the way
he developed said mine?
A. All that I know about the way Sigafus opened
the stopes is that when the stopes would run to
where the ore was good and wide he would stop.
181
182
183
184
185
62
Frank A. Whitten.
I know James B. Doran. During this mill run he
lived up-stairs in this house.
Cross-examination:
About 16 or 17 men were employed at the time
the Bryan mill was running. The mill at that time
was run to its full capacity. Mr Cheatham took
charge of my account; that was his business as
foreman of the mine. He always took charge of
it at the end of the month. But the Egan test
didn’t run a month. It only ran two and a-half
days. This supplying me with the cardboard to
keep the tally during the Egan test wasn’t an un-
usual circumstance. Cocking and Boren kept their
tallies below; I didn’t see them keep their tallies.
I didn’t know and cannot testify that he ever
changed my taHy at all, and my only knowledge
upon that fact is contained in my answer to the
question last preceding. I say Cheatham changed
my tally, but how many he took off I don’t know.
He didn’t remove and obliterate any tallies in my
presence while I was there. If he removed those
tallies they were removed when I was not present.
He told me he would straighten it up, and I went out
to throw some coal on the fire, and then [had to go
and run the car at the mill, and when I came back
the tally board had been straightened up; Jim said it
was all right now, but just how many he had taken
off I don’t know. I did not see him take any tal-
_ lies off. There was a change made by Mr. Cheat-
ham; he said I had too many cars; I don’t remem.
ber how many he took off. He was the only man
who had anything to do with the board at said
times, and when I came back there was a number
of them scratched off, but I don’t know how many,
and also that Cheatham told me it was all right.
I am not an expert in panning ore. I cannot tell
the richness of ore by simply looking at it. I
63
Albert L. Jepson.
couldn't tell you how often I have panned ore. My
duties was to hoist, run the cars, fire the boilers
and tram the dirt. Panning ore was not part of
the duties that I was to render my employer. I
have substantially but little knowledge of min-
ing. I don’t know that all red ore is rich; I know
that this ore I am speaking of is rich ore from
what I had panned and seen panned; I have taken
a handful of fine dirt from the box I keep samples
in of this rich—of this red ore, and put it in the pan
without putting it in the mortar, and got dozens
of colors out of it—that is, gold. Itis a fact that.
rock may show gold, and still not run $10 to the
ton. It was not an unusual occurrence for Mr.
Sigafus to be in and about the mill during the
Egan test or at any other time. I will not swear
positively that I saw James B. Doran at the mill
at any time during what was known as the Egan
run. I first spoke to Mr. Willson and Mr, Jones
concerning the matters and things 1 have testified
to in this action since the Egan test.
ALBERT L. JEPSON, called as a witness on behalf
of plaintiff, testified as follows:
Llive at the Good Hope Mine, Riverside County,
California. | have been there steady for about a
year. I worked there five years anda little over;
beginning in 1891 up until they shut down on the
ist of March, 1896. My regular business has been
running a mill there at the mine for the last four
years. I never mined a day in my life. I did any-
thing I could get to do before that. I never worked
in other mining mills at other mining properties.
I was in Mr. Sigafus’s employ for three years; up
to the time that he sold out in November or De-
cember, 1893. I had not been in entire charge of
187
189
64 | '
190 Albert L. Jepson.
the working of the mill. From 1891 Ed. Manker
and myself and a man by the name of Wiltsie were
at work there in charge of the mill besides myself,
I worked there steadily the whole of that time.
The Bryan mill was put in there the last of Jan-
uary, 1891, or the first of February. Mr. Sigafus
himself was there about two years, between Jan-
uary, 1891, and December, 1893, I think, He was
away one summer, nearly all summer. I don’t
know which he called his home, here or there.
The biggest part of the time after that Mr. Sigafus
19; Spent at the mine. His wife lived there with him.
They lived in a house that was built for them up
on the hill above the mine. The mill would run, if
in good repair, ten tons in twelve hours anyhow.
Manker and myself run it eighteen hours for some-
thing like two months. That was in 1891. I be-
gin running eighteen hours on the 19th of August,
1891. It kept up something like two months.
Q. From day to day?
A. Yes, sir; I do not know what quantities
of gold were taken out there. While I at-
tended to the mill myself I knew pretty near
what it run. The value of the ore that ran
through that mill after I run the mill myself,
I think, would average about $8. This was in
1892 and 1893. In 1891 there was so much
of the time I didn’t run it. The richest ore, I think,
that I run through at that time, was somewhere in
the neighborhood of $20. Mr. Cheatham was the
foreman of the mine during Sigafus’s ownership,
after Doran was taken ill. It was some time dur-
ing the summer, I think. I would not want to say
what month it was. I was there when Col. Egan
came to make his test or examination of the mine.
Sigafus was there. I remember the mill run that
was made for Egan. It took a part of three days,
as near as I can recollect. It might have run seven
hours the first day, and might have run eight. The
192
P 65
Albert L. Jepson.
bin was empty and we waited on that account.
We did not begin early on the very morning of the
first day. The next two days we ran twelve hours,
until they were out. I think we stopped before the
third day was out quite. We ran the whole of the
second day. The run straight through it was as
good as any they ever had. There was times it
was better.
Q. Did you notice any times when there was any
marked difference?
A. Yes, there was twice.
Q. On which day was the first of those times?
A. The second day and the third day.
Q. State to the jury exactly what you saw your-
self on the second day as to the quality of the ore
that ran through the mill.
A. Maybe I’d better explain something about
amalgamating, so that I can make them under-
stand. ;
Q. Tell them in your own way just what you
saw.
A. Ore in being ground, you have got to feed
quicksilver into the battery once an hour. That is
the way we feed it. Then there are plates that it
washes over, and a little gold is washed out, and
that catches on these plates of quicksilver. You
watch them—turn the hose on, with clean water,
and watch them; try it with your finger to see if it
is getting hard or soft. If it is getting hard, feed
more quicksilver; if it is getting soft, don’t feed as
much. During the second day I noticed the plates
were getting hard, and I had to add nearly three
times as much quicksilver, for about two hours, as
would be usual. That would indicate that the ore
was about three times as rich; three times the aver-
age richness. I noticed it again the third day, and
it was worse than it was before. I fed five or six
times as much quicksilver for about three hours.
Instead of putting it in once an hour, I put it in
193
194
195
66
Albert L. Jepson.
about every 15 or 20 minutes. The plates were
growing hard, and I went around the mill and
poured it in, so that it slopped out. That didn’t do
any good, and I took a spoon and threw some on
the plates. That was not a usual thing. It never
happened before. We don't have to use quicksilver;
only after we clean off, we put quicksilver on them
and dress them up with a brush broom and make *
them all even, like a looking-glass—more quick-
silver indicates that there is richer ore.
By the Court:
). Where is this put?
A. It is put into the mill to grind in with the
rock. When we clean the plates off perfectly
clean, and then they are dressed up again, we put
quicksilver on them then. While the mill is rup-
ning we feed it through the mill, through the bat-
tery. This very rich ore on the second day con-
tinued about three hours. That is wrong. The
second day’s run was about two hours and the third
day’s run was about three hours. The first of the
two days, when I noticed this remarkable ore, the
value was from $25 to $30 ore. On the last day it
got, in my judgment, anyhow, $100. Mr. Sigafus
was about there during that time. He was through
there several different times. He spoke to me
three times about the run. The first time he told
me to crowd the mill, and make it help sell the
mine, after we had started a while he tofd me to
never mind crowding the mill, but be sure and get
all the stuff. He meant gold. The next time he
came in he asked me if I was feeding any quick
(quicksilver) now. — 1 don’t remember what I said
to him at that time. That was the second day.
The third day he came in the same way that he did
the second day, and asked me if I was feeding any
auick. That was the time it was coming so strong
— —ez
Albert L. Jepson. 199
67
in rich ore. I told him yes, I was throwing it in
by the spoonful, and if it didn’t quit coming in that
way pretty soon, 1 was going to throw the bowl
andallin. He laughed, and went out the door
and went off. During the whole of those three
davs he was in and out. After the mine was sold,
Trun the mill up until about the middle of May. 1
never see any such ore gv through the mill after-
wards or before; not like that was at that time;
nor anything to compare with it. Imean the time
that it took these spells, that 1 would be throwing
quicksilver in so much; these spasms. 200
Cross-eramination by Mr. Johnson:
I don’t think I have stated anything here that I
did not know. When I commenced to work at this
mine, [ had never had any experience in mining or
milling. Iam here for the Good Hope Company, I
suppose. Two months that I said we worked 18
hours a day at the mill started the 19th of August,
1391. Manker was the chief mill man up to August
19, 1891, I guess.
Q. How long had you been working in the mill
at that time? 201
A. Lcommenced there and helped about the mill
in January.
Q. How long had you been working in the mill
at that time, on the 19th of August?
A. Thelped put the mill up in January, 1591.
I was nothing but a helper there; in March, 1891, I
worked on the ore. I had no experience in milling
in March, 189!. I did not have any experience as a
mill man in April, 1891, nor until August. The mill
run Is hours in August. ididn’t run it. I went home
at 6 o'clock. The screens on this mill are about eight
inches: I wouldn’t say exactly. Eight inches wide
and three feet long. These are the places where
the pulverized rock is thrown out. The mill will
6S:
Albert L. Jepson.
crush more with a twenty-six mesh than witha
forty mesh. Fifty-five mesh is so fine that water
will hardly get through, everything clogs right up.
They would not crush so much. There was some
screens in this mill called sixty. It was just like a
milk strainer. Mr. Sigafus was away from the
mine in 1891, I think. I estimate the average
richness of ore that ran through the mills by the
amount of quicksilver that I fed into it. An ounce
of quicksilver will amalgamate an ounce of gold.
Gold, in the rock, and the quicksilver will rub
together just the same as sand and water, and you
can keep adding gold to it andit will get harder,
just as mortar will, and.dry up, and you have to
chip it off sometimes, it gets that hard.
Buy Mr. Johnson:
The gold metal in the ore and the quicksilver
unite to form an amalgam?
Witness: If you get it hard it will be half and
half very near. Ittakes an ounce of quicksilver to
amalgamate with an ounce of this metal. It takes
more in winter than in summer.
A good deal more.
Q. Does it require more than this amount of
quicksilver to be thrown into the mill to reduce the
gold‘
A. When?
Q. In the mill.
A. Cause more to be thrown in?
Q. Does it require more in practical milling than
an ounce to an ounce?
A. At what time?
Q. At any time during the mill run, or any mill
run.
A. I don’t understand you. I don't know how
you mean by that.
Q. You testified that you determined the amount
—
Albert L. Jepson. 205
69
of gold that came through this mill by the amount
of quicksilver that you threw in it‘
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How much for an ounce of the gold that
comes out of the mill does it require of quicksilver
to be thrown in?
A. If you have thrown in an ounce you ought to
have two ounces of amalgam, good and hard.
Q. So that if you threw in twenty ounces of
quicksilver into the mill in the course of a day, or
a longer time, how much gold do you determine
by that ran through the mill during that time? 206
A. We could get forty ounces of amalgam.
Q. How much gold in it!
A. It ought to be twenty ounces if it is good and
clean. The quicksilver we ordinarily use in one
day is according to what the rock is. I have run
days that 1 did not use more than two or three
ounces all day and another day | would use that
many pounds. I don’t know as I could tell just
the average.
Q. If any day you used ten ounces of quicksilver
in the mill, how much gold would you judge ran
through the mill that day?
A. [would count that I had got ten ounces of
gold?
Q. It was by that method that you computed
how much the gold that ran through this mill
would run to the ton?
A. Yes, that is all the way you have got to do it,
until it is cleaned up and weighed. They know; |
don’t. At that one time that I spoke of, of the ore
coming in rich, | used a couple of pounds in that
many hours, pretty near. The finely pulverized
ore is thrown out of the mill through these screens
and lands in a trough which goes over some plates:
copper plates with silver, and then quicksilver on
them. When we commenced this mill run we cleaned
those plates, everything was cleaned up, and
207
208
210
70
Albert L. Jepson.
applied quicksilver to the plates. It is the inten-
tion to keep quicksilver on those plates during any
mill run sufficiently soft so that the gold will catch
on; just keep it in a kind of dough. Ordinarily
we did not put quicksilver on those plates during
the day.
Q. Do you testify that you never did so/
A. I never put it on only after they were cleaned
up, after starting up, while it was running.
Q. When was that?
A. In the morning sometimes when it was cold,
before starting I would puta little along the head
of the plates, right up at the top, and when it was
running after starting up
Q. Will you testify as to what yonr custom was
the first thing in the morning of each day about
applying quicksilver to the plate?
A. They aiways had to be rubbed up every six
hours. In the morning, after they had stood all
night, and this gold with the amalgam would be
too hard, I would put quicksilver on sometimes;
sometimes not.
Q. That was your ordinary custom, was it not!
A. If it needed it; if it did not need it I did
not put it on.
Q. At the end of six hours from that time, what
would you do?
A. Just stopped the mill and took a brush broom
and rubbed it all up; brightened it all up.
Q. Did you put any quicksilver on then?
A. No.
Q. Do you testify that you never sprinkled
quicksilver on the plates’at any other time than
during the mill run‘
A_ I put it on when I started up in the morning.
Q. No other time?
A. If the plates were cleaned at noon T would put
iton. We generally clean the plates at the noon
—
71
Albert L. Jepson.
hour. if there was anything on them to clean off.
Sometimes I didn’t clean them for a week.
-Q. So that ordinarily you put it on twice a day,
didn’t you?
A. No. That is what we had to watch the
plates for, to keep them just so—to feed the quick-
silver through the battery.
Q. You have made your computation, Will you
state which ounce you used, troy or avoirdupois!
A. T would guess at an ounce of quicksilver, the
same as you would guess at anything.
Q. Which kind of ounce are you speak of, of gold
—troy or avoirdupois!
A. We would take Mr. Sigafus’s scales. He had
the common scales that they have in candy stores.
Q. You used the ounces which those scales
showed?
A. Yes. They didn’t have any ounces that I saw.
He had chunks of iron on there. I don’t know what
they weighed.
Q. In speaking of quicksilver what ounce do you
use—troy or avoirdupois?
A. I don’t know which it is weighed by.
Q. Do you mean the ounces as it comes in the
can—weighed by the ounces that it is weighed by
in the can? How did you determine this! You said
that you determined the amount of gold that ran
through this mill by taking an ounce of gold to an
ounce of mercury?
A. Yes.
(). Now, what ounce of mercury did you take—
troy or avoirdupois?!
A. | judged that; I didn’t weigh it.
Q. How much in size is an ounce of mercury‘
A. If youhave got some I can pour you out about
an ounce—if you have got some and want me to
try it.
Q. Will you describe the process of cleaning up
the mill!
—
72
214 Albert L. Jepson.
A. The mill has dies in the bottom for wheels to
run. We would clean the puip out and take the
keys out from these dies, and take them all out and
clean everything out that was inside of it and put
it back.
Q. And when you so clean that out you havea
mass of pulverized waste and amalgam and sand,
haven't you?
A. Yes.
Q. How do you take the amalgam out of that?
A. We have to wash it out with pans.
915 . Is there such a process as squeezing amalgam}
A. We have to grind it and pulverize all the hard
lumps of amalgam and put more quicksilver in and
grind it until it is all soft.
Q. When you cleaned the mill was all the quick-
silver amalgamated with gold/
A. All of it was more or less amalgamated with
gold; some might be thin.
Q. Did you use any means to take away the
quicksilver that was not amalgamated, in cleaning
up!
A. It was all put in together. All has to go
through the wash, hard and soft. I don't know
what day of the week the Egan Mill test com-
menced.
Q. How much quicksilver did you put in the mill
during the Egan run?
A. I don’t know as I coulda say what I did put
in.
(). You cannot form any idea of how much, in
bulk, you put in
A. No, not altogether. I got the stuff as I fed
it, and | thought nothing about it at the time.
216
—
73
John M. S. Egan.
Joux M. 8. Ea@an, by deposition, on behalf of
plaintiffs, testified as follows:
Defendant’s counsel objects to the deposi-
tion as immaterial and incompetent and not
connected with the defendant. That there is
no evidence in the case that Egan represented
the plaintiffs, or that there existed, at that
time, between Egan and the plaintiff: any
engagement or even a knowledge of each
other.
Objection overruled. To which ruling of
the Court counsel for defendant then and
there duly excepted.
Age 45, resides at Perris, Riverside County, Cali-
fornia. Occupation, miner. I know John L. Hob-
son, Dudley Porter, C. W. Morse and James M.
Sigafus. I have known James M. Sigafus about v1
months in California. [ met him on the 16th or
17th of November, 1893, at the Good Hope Mine,
introduced by W. H. Griffith. The circumstances
of my first visit to the Good Hope Mine, when I
was introduced to Mr. Sigafus as the owner of the
property, and myself as a mining man, who had
come down to examine the property, with a view of
its purchase, in the interests of Mr. Morse and his
friends, and some of my friends. Mr. Morse directed
me to make the examination for the purpose of
verifying a certain mining report known as the
“Burnham.” The Burnham report ( Plaintiffs’
Exhibit A) was sent to me by mail to my office in
Georgetown, Colorado, in the latter part of Septem-
ber or early in October, 1893, with several other re-
ports of other mines. It was sent by James H.
Platt from Chicago. Mr. Platt was also interested
in paper mills and other industries in Denver, and
we had been interested together in mining some 12
or 13 years. The paper shown me is a copy of the
Burnham report that was sent to me with a num-
217
218
219
—
74
220 John M. S. Egan.
ber of photographs and maps to Georgetown, Colo-
rado.
Q. When you say ‘‘copy ” do you mean you ever
saw any other * original” than the paper now in
your hands?
A. No, sir.
(). Is not that the identical report you received by
mail, as first stated?
A. It is.
Paper handed to witness, marked A_ for
identification by notary, copy to be certified
221 and attached to deposition.
Immediately on my arrival the afternoon of the
16th or 17th of November, 1893, I began my exami-
nation of the mine under the instructions | have
mentioned. That examination continued until the
25th of same month. As far as I could tell Mr.
Sigafus was on the premises during the whole of
that examination. Isaw him so often, that at this
- distance of time, it’s impossible to particularly note
each occasion; but I saw him around the mine,
office, mill, house or the grounds surrounding, every
day, to the best of my recollection. Relatively, the
house, office and mill formed the three corners of
an equilaetral triangle. The sides of which were
about 300 feet. The mill, perhaps, being a little
closer to the office. On starting to make the under-
ground examination I requested Mr. Sigafus to go
into the mine with me and stay with me during
that examination. He went down the mine with
me, but did not stay very long, giving as an excuse
that he had a bad cold, and portions of the mine
were very hot and others very wet. I walked
over the surface ground covering — surface
openings in the vein, and got the idea of the course
and distances as far as possible. Mr. Sigafus
pointed out the boundary line of the section of land
within which the mining claims were contained.
—
222
75
John M. 8. Egan.
{ also asked Mr. Sigafus for his working maps of
the mine. He replied that he had none; that he
had never had the underground workings surveyed.
Rither then or during the next day he drew a rough
sketch map on a large sheet of paper, giving the
depths of the shafts, length of levels and the under-
ground workings, W hich figures I copied into my note-
book for reference during my examination. [ said to
defendant that I was making the examination for the
persons who had been associated in mining with
me—Mr. C. W. Morse and some of his friends. Mr.
Morse had intended coming with me, but the death
of his father prevented. I said the purpose ox the
examination was to verify the report called the
Burnham report that had been called to my atten-
tion, and, if the examination was satisfactory, we
would probably purchase the mine. I used the
sketch-map to copy the figures in my note-book. I
do not know what became of it after that. I did
not keep it. I don’t know whether Sigafus kept it.
To the best of my recollection, | last saw it at the
mine office in the adobe building. It was in Mr.
Sigafus’s possession, as far as I know. As to the
words on the paper I am not positive, but as to the
figures lam. This paper which I have now drawn
isa full and accurate reproduction of that sketch
or map drawn by Mr. Sigafus at that time, to the
best of my recollection.
Drawing marked B to be certified by notary
and annexed to commission.
Mr. Sigafus gave me an oral explanation of that
sketch or map. He stated that the total depth of
the main shaft was 416 feet, and that the first 259
feet had been sunk on the hanging wall, but that
at that point the drift had been driven north about
700 feet and south about 250 feet to its intersection
| with thé south shaft. Parallel levels had been
driven at points 100 feet down the shaft; that the
225
226
227
228
76
John M. 8, Egan. ,
south shaft had been sunk about 40 feet below the
lower level south, making its total depth about 395
feet. Below the lower level the main shaft was sunk
about 66 feet, and used as a sump. In connection
with this map, south of the maiu available work-
ings of the mine, he did not say that any had been
carried further than were shown. He spoke of and
pointed out to me the old caved and abandoned
works in connection with this map. He gave me
to understand, or stated, that this sketch gave the
full extent of the main openings of the mine. He
said that the first level north was being driven
ahead, but not the second level, where they were
putting up a raise to connect with blind drift that
ran from the stope in that level. I had heard of
Mr. Sigafus in Colorado. From his description of
his operations in Arizona and New Mexico, besides
the evidence at the Good Hope Mine, | considered
Mr. Sigafus a competent mining man At the col
lar of the shaft he introduced me to James R.
Cheatham as the man who had formerly been
timber-man, but, owing to the illness of Doran,
had been acting for the last two or three months
as foreman of the mine, and was now occupying
that position. During our conversation at the first
level, when Mr. Sigafus declined to accompany me
in making my examination, in Cheatham’s presence
he told me that he (Cheatham) would go with me
and explain every detail of the property, and give
me every assistance in his power—in fact, placed
Cheatham’s services at my discretion. This was
said in Mr. Cheatham’s presence. This was be-
fore I had begun my exploration of the mine. I
commenced the practical part of it as soon as Mr.
Sigafus went on the surface. To the best of my
recollection Mr. Sigafus went through the first
level with me. I next went down in the skip to
the second level. Cheatham and Griffith were with
me, and I don’t recollect now whether Sigafus was
eee
John M.S. Egan.
17
or not. We were simply walking through to look
over the mine and plan out my work. I went back
to the first level and proceeded to measure the dis-
tances between the mill holes and manways, and
the aggregate measurements of the first level north
gave about 700 feet. Those measurements were
made with a tape line or rule. After takivg the
measurements I ‘started at the first stope near the
shaft, measured its height and length between mill
holes, and, at every ten feet or so, measured the
width of the ore body, and taking samples when I
thought it judicious to do so, This was ou the first 599
level north. I went through the same method of
examination as on the first level south. I started
at the shaft, and measured from mill hole to mill
hole, and measured the height of the stopes above
the level, and measured the ore body, about every
ten feet, where practicable, and took samples on
both levels. In fact, I went through the same ope-
ration on all of them. I asked Cheatham if the
pile of debris at the end of the drift, in the second
level north, was up against the breast? He an-
swered that the drift might have been driven five
or six feet further, but that that portion of the drift
had been driven whilst he had been at work on a
neighboring mine. He stated that these main levels
only extended as far as the south shaft. This
seemed to be true. In fact, the south end of the
south shaft was boarded up. 1 also measured along
the bottom of the second level, north and south,
where practicable, and took samples; also examined
the main shaft below this level as far as possible.
In conversation Mr. Sigafus gave me the same fig-
ures orally as he had marked on the sketch map,
namely, about 700 feet north and 250 feet south for
each level. The pile of waste was at the very end
of the drift, as apparent then. They were putting
up a raise to connect with a blind drift driven from
the stope. The waste fron) this raise fell in a heap
231
—x
at the bottom of the raise, hence it looked natural
for the pile of debris to be where it was.
57 Q. Explain what you mean by a raise.
A. A raise is an opening carried up from the
bank of a drift, either to connect it with the work.
ings above, or for aid or for convenience of work-
ing, or for prospecting ground without stopping it
out.
58Q. What, if any, is the distinction between a
drift and a level?
A. A levelisa drift that is always kept open,
well timbered and equipped, and is really one of
the main arteries of the mine. Whereas between
levels a drift may be run for prospecting er ventil-
ating ground and yet not be kept open.
After the purchase was complete I was in charge
of the mine. T worked it. From the first of Jan-
uary, 189, to the middle of December the same
year. I found that, commencing about eight feet
above the bottom of the second level south, the drift
had been run south from the south shaft about 150
feet. In August, 1894, I instructed the foreman to
have the dirt cleaned away from the breast of the
second level north. After doing so, we found the
drift had been driven 80 feet further than was ap
parent in my examinationand stated to me. The
drift in the second level had been driven about 150
feet further than Sigafus’s sketch showed, south and
about 80 feet further north in all the drift had been
driven. About 225 or 230 feet further than stated
by Sigafus and Cheatham. At that time Sigafus
had owned and operated that mine, according to
his own statement to me, [ should imagine from
three to four years. At the breast of the north
drift: there was no ore whatever, only a streak of
rotten granite that had evidently ran off the vein
as we found afterward. As compared with the
rest of the mine it was barren. At the south end
the vein, or what little sign there was of it, was.
___—atil
78
John M.S. Egan.
79
John M. 8. Egan.
split up and deflected about 30 degrees and is in
hard, tight granite, and so compared with the rest
of the mine, is barren. In the north drift it was
simply a case of a mistake in judgment in losing
the vein. In the south drift it showed the termi-
nation of the ore body disclosed in the workings be-
tween the main and south shaft, and it was also evi-
dent thata great deal of expensive prospecting would
have to be done before another ore body could be
found. In fact it looked as if the vein had split
up, never to come together again. If it had so
split up, would be of no value thereafter for
working. By ore in sight is meant ore that has
been measured and sampled on one or two sides.
It is considered of great importance iu determining
prospective value of a mine and whether it will pay
to develop such ground into ore reserves. Ore in
reserve is ore that is blocked out and that can be
measured and sampled on all or nearly all sides. I
had been mining about 23 years, and had been
managing, operating and purchasing since 1880,
Q. Then, in your opinion and judgment, what
was the difference in value of that mine as indi-
cated by what you saw on that second level com-
pared with the value you would have attached to it
if you had seen the concealed portions of that level?
A. It isa hard question to answer, but I would
have made no further examination with the idea of
purchasing. I would not have advised its purchase.
The measurements I took varied from two inches
to several feet, but as there was about 200 measure-
ments taken I cannot, without my note-book, give
each measurement in detail, about 24 inches was
the average. My recollection is ¢ccurate as to that
average.
Q. After the whole interior had been exposed,
when you were workiug the mine, what did you find
the facts to be as to the average width of the ore!
A. About [8 inches. My examination of the in-
235
237
239
240
80
John M. S. Egan.
terior of the mine with Mr. Cheatham continued
three or four days. I took about 24 samples in sacks
for assay, beside others that I put into my valise,
and a number of others were panned on the sur-
face. Those were new canvas sacks especially for
the purpose.
Q. How did you collect these samples‘
A. Whenever I decided to take a sample I picked
iato a pan held either by Cheatham or myself, an
average sample of the vein filling. When this was
not practicable we laid canvas sacks and sacking on
the ground and broke down the quartz with large
or small hammers as the case required. These sam-
ples varied in size that were cut down so as to make
sample sacks full.
Q. What do you mean by cutting down samples!
A. The larger pieces were broken so they could
be thoroughly mixed. The whole mass was then
laid on the sacks and flattened out evenly; it was
then divided into four quarters. Two alternate
quarters were then thrown out; what was left was
again flattened out, requartered and the same proc-
ess gone through until two of the quarters were
small enough to fill the sacks.
Q. What was the result of this process of quar-
tering and cutting down!
A. As far as possible, it gave a fair average of
the sample taken.
I took such of the vein filling as I thought would
be handled in a large mill. Vein filling is quartz
and other matter contained within the walls of the
vein. The samples that I took, in my judgment,
fairly represented the product of the mine, as then
exposed to my examination. I did not take any
samples from the parts of the mine that had been
worked but was then concealed. There were about
24 bags. I left those bags of samples in Mr. Siga-
fus’s office near the mine. Mr. Sigafus gave me a
key for my use during my examination. I did not
_—
John M. 8. Egan. 241
81
then <now that Sigafus kept another key. Each
time I came out of the shaft I placed the samples
taken in the office, so that some of them were there
five or six days, others two or three days. The bags
were fastened with strings that had been sewn on
the side of the sack. They were not sealed. I sent
| them by express [to Frank Graham, a competent
assayor at Georgetown, Col. The result of the
assay. leaving out the richest ores, gave an average
ef $23 per ton. Before sending them to Graham I
dried them, crushed them, ground them down, and
sent them to Graham. [ don’t think I ever told o49
Mr. Sigafus the result of Graham's assay, but I may
have done so by letter.
Q. Did Mr. Sigafus, to your knowledge, take any
of those samples, or portions of them, either from
the mine or office?
A. No, sir.
I left the residue of my samples in a large iron
pan in the office, from which he proposed to take
a sample and assay it himself. A mill run was
made of the ore during my examination.
i05 Q. Within your knowledge, what did Mr.
Sigafus nave to do with that mill run?
A. Lsaw him thoroughly clean out the mill and
clean up the plates before making the mill run— ,
and after the mill ran I saw he and Jepson clean
out the mill, clean-up the plates, wash the amal-
gam, retort it and weigh it.
We had several conversations about it. He
asked me if I wanted two or three hundred tons
run. Ltold him I would like to, but that I would
only have time to run about twenty or thirty.
I requested him to have his mill men or some
one take samples of the crude ore and tail
ings every alternate hour. To the best of my rec-
ollection, every hour and at the automatic ore
feeder. I directed the mill ran to be made. I made .
the arrangements for a mill run with Mr. Sigafus
244
245
246
82
John M. 8. Egan.
and with his foreman, J. R. Cheatham. The
amount of ore was to be sixty-one cars, which we
decided would be about equivalent to twenty tons,
and that the ore should be taken from all portions
of the mine, in the manner they were then taking.
I cannot say positively how much of the time Mr.
Sigafus was present during the mill ran, but he
was around the vicinity of the mine and office and
house all the time. The mill run took three and a
half days. Tally cards were furnished by Cheat-
ham to each of the trammers on the two levels,
and another one to the engineer on top to keep
tally of the cars sent up. The ore after being
broken was thrown into chutes, whence it was
trammed to the shaft and emptied into the skip,
each car being supposed to make a skip load. It
was then hoisted to the surface, automatically
dumped into another car, and run to the mill floor.
The car was then dumped into a grizzly or iron
screen. What went through the screen fell through
into the ore bin. What failed to go through was
crushed in a small crusher and fell into the ore bin,
whence it was fed to the Bryan Mill by an auto-
matic feeder. At this point water is added to the
ore, and the ore ground and pulverized by revolving
wheels, until sufficiently fine to pass through the
screens, whence it ran over amalgam plates, and
where the gold not caught .up by quicksilver
insidethe mill was supposed to be saved. Cheatham
supplied tally boards; gave directions to the miners
and to men on the surface. It was arranged that
61 cars be brought up; Sigafus and Jepson cleaned
the mill. I saw it retorted and weighed. The re-
sult was 51 ounces in gold. That was from 20 tous
of ore stated by Cheatham and Sigafus. Both said
90 tons were sent up. I could not be present much
of the time. Was crushing and drying samples.
_ Going into the mine around the mill and one after-
—
John M. S. Egan. 247
83
noon Mr. Sigafus and I went over the surface
again.
126 Q. Did you know Doran who had been super-
intendent of the mine, and did you meet him dur-
ing the examination?!
A. At my request I was introduced to him by
Mr. Sigafus in his house. I afterwards met him
on the dump of the main shaft where we talked
together, he and Mr. Sigafus and myself. I also
met him again on bidding him good bye when I
was going away. :
127 Q. Did you believe at that time that the 94
quantity of ore run through the mill was 61 car
loads, 20 tons as stated to you by Sigafus and
Cheatham?
A. | did.
128 Q. Did you believe that the ore then run
through was a fair specimen of the ore then’taken
out of the mine?
A. I did.
129 Q. Were you aware of any tampering or any
improper practices with that ore at the time?
A. I was not. .
Q. What conversation, if any, did you have with
Sigafus as to the Burnham report?
Defendant’s counsel objects to this inter-
rogatory on the ground that there is no evi-
dence thus far introduced in the case as to
what the Burnham report was, and the orig-
inal Burnham report said to have been made
some years back is not produced or proven.
Objection overruled. To which ruling of
the Court counsel for defendant then and
there duly excepted.
A. At this distance of time I cannot recollect ail
our conversation regarding this report, especialiy
as they were carried on at different intervals dur-
250
251
252
S+
John M. 8S. Egan.
ing my visit to the Good Hope Mine; but regard.
ing this man Burnham, he showed me some photo-
graphs he had in his desk, and told me that
Burnham was a mining engineer who had visited
the mine at different intervals during one year or
more, sometimes two weeks or a month at a time;
that he had most thoroughly examined the prop
erty and was familiar with it. With regard to
figures giving bullion product, he said that they
were correct, and that the books were in the pos-
session of his son-in-law, Mr. J. Everett Bird. I
asked him about a great many details of the report,
especially regarding the tonnage of 1891, and
title to the claims—the Iron Ledge, and several
claims lyivg near the east boundary of the section,
the probability of the mine keeping on that depth,
etc.. the porphyry dyke, and other matters con-
tained in the report.
Q. Did you ask Mr. Sigafus about the product of
the mine in the year 1891, stated in the report at
$57,000, at a cost of $15,000?
Objected to ‘by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial, and on the
grounds that it is not connected with the
plaintiffs, and there is no evidence that Egan
represented the plaintiffs or that there was
any engagement between them or knowledge
of each other.
Objection overruled. To which rulling of
the Court counsel for defendant then and
there duly excepted. ;
A. As stated in my previous answer, I did; and
he said the sales of bullion as carried out were cor
rect.
Q. Did Mr. Sigafus tell you how long the mine
had been worked? If so, what did he tell you on
that point?
Same objection, ruling and exception.
parame men
John M. 8. Egan. 253
A. As Mr. Sigafus and | had become very well
acquainted with the history of the mine and his
own personal history was so mixed up with it, but
from it all I gathered that he had it about three
years.
Q. What, if anything, did he say as to the aver-
age value of the ore he had taken out himself and
the time during which he had taken it out!
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial, and on the
grounds that it is not connected with the |
- plaintiffs, and there is no evidence that Egan *
represented the plaintiffs, or that there was
any engagement between them or knowledge
of each other.
Objection overruled. To which ruling of
the Court counsel for defendant then and
there duly excepted.
A. He told me that up to the mill run of July,
August, September and October of 1893, his aver-
age value had been $20 per ton of ore milled; that
he had not milled much up to the erection of the
Bryan Mill.
Q. Do you mean that he had not milled much or 255
had not taken out much?
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial, and on the
grounds that it is not connected with the
plaintiffs, and there is no evidence that Egan
represented the plaintiffs, or that there was
any engagement between them or knowledge
of each other.
Objection overruled. To which ruling of
the Court counsel for defendant then and
there duly excepted.
A. That be had not milled much.
256
rs
257
258
86
Jobn M. 8. Egan.
Q. When did he say he had put in the Bryan
Mill?
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial, and on the
grounds that it is not connected with the
plaintiffs, and there is no evidence that Egan
represented the plaintiffs or that there was
any engagement between them or knowledge
of each other.
Objection overruled. To which ruling of
the Court counsel for defendant then and
there duly excepted.
A. I think in 1891—TI want to refresh my mem-
ory from the Burnham report. I cannot find it in
the Burnham report, but I think it was in 1891.
Q. Did Sigafus show you any reports of the
product of the mine?
A. He showed me statements of 582 tons, run
during the months of July, August, September and
October, 1893, with certificates showing that this
bullion sold for $9,600, an average of 16 18/100 per
ton, the lowest run he ever had.
Q. Was that Mr. Sigafus’s statement, that that
was the lowest run he ever had?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was done with those reports he showed
you!
A. I made a memorandum of them and he re-
tained them.
Q. Did you believe the statements shown you by
Mr. Sigafus on this point?
A. I did absolutely.
Q. Please state what is the value of ore in gold
per ton of ore indicated by the figures you gave of
the results of the mill test of fifty-one ounces and
twenty tons.
A. $36.97.
—_—
John M. S. Egan. . 259
ST
Q. Did you, while in control of the mine, keep
books and accounts of its products?
A. did. To the best of my recollection at pres-
ent it was a little over six thousand tons, and bullion
that sold for about sixty thousand dollars. I ex-
tracted the gold from that ore at the mine. The
highest rate of gold per ton that I took any month
during my superintendence was about twelve dol.
lars per ton. About two months it was as high as
that. In other months it was six dollars, seven
dollars, eight dollars a ton. Full monthly reports
were made to Mr. Elbridge G. Wood at Haverhill, ogo
Massachusetts. They were made in regular course
of business; signed by me as manager, and sent
tri-weekly and monthly. The monthly reports
showed amount of ore hoisted, analysis, cost, ship-
ment of bullion, returns. I knew the reports were
accurate. I managed the mine from January 1,
1894, to middle of December same year. During
that time I took out the best in quality and about
three-fourths in quantity of the reserve. I have
personal knowledge of the amount of gold pro-
duced in that time. I was making sales of gold
bullion. I sold througn Wells, Fargo Bank of San
Francisco, and sent to U. 8. Mint, San Francisco.
The price is fixed by mint reports. That was the
regular way of fixing prices. | received a little over
&14 or little over $15 per ounce. I sent monthly re-
ports and receipts of mint returns to the treasurer
of company. The cost of my getting out that
50,000 worth of ore, includicg mining and milling
expense, was, to my recollection, about $60,000. As
aresult of my examination at the mines in Novem-
ber, 1893, I made a report to my employers on this
mine. This paper (Plaintiffs’ Exhibit C) now shown
me is my original report. The statements of this
report were in accordance with the facts, so far as
Thad learned them from my personal observation
and the statements made to me by Sigafus and
261
bo
for}
bo
263
264
88
John M. S. Egan.
Cheatham. The figures in my report for the prod-
uct of the mine during July, August, September
and October, 1893, are the same as the statements
made to me by Mr. Sigafus. The statement in my
report as to the average of my assays being $23 re-
fers to the assays of the samples I have already
mentioned in my testimony.
Q. I call your attention to the statement of
$884.40 per ton of the value of the eight-inch streak
in the breast of the first level north. State what
the facts were in regard to that. Where did you
get the ore and how much was there of it!
A. I took samples in the breast of: the first level
north from a streak about eight inches wide. This
sample I divided into two, the larger one went with
the other sacks into the office, the smaller I took
with me and put in my valise as a sample of
sulphuret ore, and had them both assayed, and the
returns were about the same and not included in
my average.
(Answer to question as to value of gold pro
duced under witness’s management changed
to $65,000).
Q. If the drift had really ended where the de-
fendant and Cheatham said, and if the mine had
only been worked as far as they stated to you,
what, in your opinion, would have been its fair
market value in comparison with, what it was,
worked and opened as it actually had been!
A. It would be hard to give in figures, but in one
case a prospective value existed which did not in the
other.
Q. What, in your judgment, was the fair market
value of the mine if it had been worked as rep-
resented and stated to you by Sigafus and
Cheatham—with the average value of the ore, as
shown by the assay of your samples and your mill
run?
——_
89
John M. 8. Egan. 265
A. From $500,000 to $750,000.
Q. What, in your judgment, was its value with
the workings of the mine as they actually were,
and with the average value of the ore at $10 per
ton?
A. About $50,000.
Q. What was the average value per ton of
ore that you actually got out during the entire
period that you worked that mine—about one
year?
A. About $10.
Q. What was the exact depth of the south shaft o¢¢
of the mine as you found it to be by actual measure-
ment!
A. About 395 feet. During the erection of the
large mill I prepared the mine for a large output,
which took place after the completion of the large
mill, The only change in the method of working
was iu the method of pulverizing the ore. I can-
not give the exact figures, now, but there was
about $4.50 a ton increase of cost. The effect of
the change of method was a large percentage of
saving. I cannot tell how much; I would have to
refer to my books.
Q. How many men were employed by the Good
Hope Mine during your examination! 267
A. To the best of my recollectiou, Mr. Sigafus
employed five or six men in the mine. I continued
all except two in my employ.
Q. As to the product of mine in the past, what
information did you have, if any, except that given
you by Sigafus?
A. The statements in the Burnham report.
Q. Did you believe, at that time, the statements
made to you by Sigafus and Cheatham?
A. 1 did, absoiutely.
Q. On your belief in those statements, did you
invest any money of your own in the purchase of
this property, and if so, how much?
268
270
90
John M. S. Egan.
A. I did, $15,000.
Q. What reason, if any, did Mr. Sigafus state to
you as his reasons for being willing to sell the
property? State your conversation with him on that
subject fully and particularly?
A. I can’t, after this lapse of time, give the exact
terms of our several conversations, except thata
few of his phrases struck me very forcibly. Nor
can I describe them separately, as they extended to
every time I met him. He stated that he had come
to Riverside with his family, and had heard of this
Good Hope Mine. Old miner like he went to see
it. and found it in bad shape, partners fighting.
Considered it a good piece of property, so he bought
it as an occupation for his son-in-law, J. Everett
Bird, as well as for investment; that he had sup
plied Bird with plenty of money to develop the
mine; that he had spent it in a big house and
wasted the balance. Sigafus said that he thought
he would make a man and a miner out of him.
Instead of that, he was fit for nothing but a New
York bookkeeper; that all his hopes in the man’s
ability to conduct the operations of the mine were
lost, that to save the money for his grandchildren
and save his own investment he was compelled to
stay at the mine himself, as he could trust no one
else, whereas he had other large interests in New
York, Arizona and New Mexico to attend to; that
he was compelled to live at the place, it was dis-
tasteful to him, and his surroundings and associa-
tions, and in describing his troubles would some-
times burst into tears. That this was the lowest
price which he had ever offered the property for
sale, and he would not now, except to parties who
would do the mine justice; that this was the last
offer he was going to make for sale, and that if
this was not taken up that he would either shut it
down or make up his mind to exile himself to at-
tend to its development personally, as he had to
—
John M. S. Egan. 271
91
give up all hopes of doing anything with Bird or
getting any assistance from him, as his previous
training of two years in New Mexico would have
justified him in expecting; that with his own ad-
vice and assistance Bird would make a success.
This was the general style of his conversations,
and they were Numerous on this subject. Next to
a record of operations covering several months or
years, and kept honestly, in a free gold proposition,
4 mill run is the supreme test. In mines carrying
base or smelting ores, the weights obtained are
good evidence as a basis on which the ore are 979
bought and sold. In a free gold proposition the
records and the only ones are kept by the owner.
A free gold proposition is when the hold is free
from combination with other base or precious
metals. The Good Hope was 2 free gold proposi-
tion. The gold requires simply crushing and wash-
ing. A mill run would give an accurate test of
value. I was not aware the mill run was not hon:
est. I was not aware that any gold or ore was run
through the mill that did not come up at that time
regularly in the cars from the mine in the ordinary
course of mining. I made my report to Mr.
Charles W. Morse early in December, 1893, in 973
New York City. I also made oral statements to
Mr. Morse, Mr. Porter and Mr. Hobson. These
three I referred to my report and the statements
made in my report, and advised the pur-
chase. I gave to them orally a market value from
$500,000 to $750,000.
This is my original report.
_ Paper put in evidence, and ‘marked Plain-
tiffs’ Exhibit C.
Q. I call your attention to a clause in your report
where you state that the test mill run was 25 tons.
What were the facts that led you to make that
statement?
7
92
274 John M.S. Egan.
A. I noticed that the cars were very full and the
ore very dry. Hence I made that addition. I don't
think I said anything to Mr. Sigafus or Mr. Cheat-
ham as to my counting that a 25-ton run. I did
not keep any account of the number of cars myself,
but got the statement of the number of cars run
from the foreman, Cheatham. I handed the Burn.
ham report to Charles W. Morse early in December,
1893, in New York City. ~I was present at the pass.
ing of the deed in McIntyre & 'Taylor’s office, Riv-
erside, California; McIntyre & Taylor were attor-
neys for Sigafus. | Morse was there. Two certi-
fied checks, payable to Morse & Eagan, one of
$90,000 and the other of $60,000, were delivered, en-
dorsed, to the order of Sigafus, to Mr. McIntyre.
The size of the opening of the drift in the Good
Hope mine on the first level varied from 3} to 5
feet in width and from 54 to 64 feet in height on
the second level was about the same as the other.
Q. Assuming that the ore body of the Good Hope
mine had an average value of at least $17 per ton,
and that the average width of the vein was 24
inches; that the length of the vein described by the
workings was 950 feet; that the workings of the
mine consisted of the main shaft 416 feet deep and
276 the south shaft 391 feet deep, the south shaft being
250 feet distant from the main shaft, with the drift
in the first level ata depth of 250 feet from the sur-
face, 950 feet long, with the opening of from 4 to
5 feet wide, 5$ to 64 feet in height, with the drift
in the second level 350 feet below the surface, 950
feet in length, with the opening of the same size,
this drift in the second level running beneath the
first for the entire length, and assuming that there
was nothing at the end of the drift to indicate that
the vein pinched out or disappeared, what, in your
opinion, would have been the fair market value of
this property?
275
03
John M. 8. Egan.
Objected to by defendant’s counsel as in-
competent and immaterial. Objection over
ruled. To which ruling of the Court counsel
for defendant then and there duly excepted.
A. From $700,000 to $1,000,000.
Q. Assuming the same conditions, with these
modifications, that the average value of the ore
was $10 per ton; that the average width of the vein
was eighteen inches, and that the conditions on the
appar
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.