Transcript of Record — Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co. v. Rochester
Supreme Court brief1900
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
(17,305. )
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES.
OCTOBER TERM, 18099.
No. 217.
THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS AND CLARKE COMPANY
PETITIONER,
VS.
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER, GEORGE W. ALDRIDGE,
WILLIAM W. BARNARD, AND JOHN W. SCHROTH,
COMPOSING THE EXECUTIVE BOARD OF THE CITY
OF ROCHESTER.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND. CIRCUIT.
INDEX.
Original, Print,
Caption... ..cc cere recrececcrceererssereceereens a 1
Transcript from the cireuit court of the United States for the naeth-
ern district of New York... .......ccsceees cscesccccsccseseces 1 ]
Bill of Complaint... ... 0.0 ce ceeceesecoesssccescesesaces ees l 1
Schedule B-- Resolutions of the executive board of the city
of Rochester, January 12, 1893............. 16 10
C—(Not set Out)........5. cee ee eee eencresees ; 17 10
D—(Not set Out)... 0. cer eee cece reece has 17 10
Angswer....... feta kes en 2b hee se) ea eet eS ; 18 11
Ev idence for comaialaned ; ee a ee ware ay 26 16
Testimony of Edwin H. Durlingaene A rer avo 27 16
Minutes of executive board..........--+-5 cece e cece cece 89 59
Testimony of John F. Moffett...........-5+.---++.0005- 4 62
PSG Th COMM sai oe sess aise igewweentaes 119 80
Exhibit 1 of March 24, 1894—Letter of Moffett, Hodg-
kins & Clarke Co. to Geo. W. Aldridge, Jan. 11, 1893... 128 86
Exhibit 2 of March 24, 1894—Restraining order of January
Se errr yr te rr 132 88
Exhibit 1 B, March 10, 1894—Proposal, &.......... +++. 134 8y
INDEX.
Original. Print.
Exhibit 1 A, March 10, 1894—Rochester water works, 1892,
notice of letting and forms of proposal, contract, and spec-
ifications for contract No. 2, for constructing steel-pipe
conduit and appurtenances for the city of Rochester,
N
Evidence for defendants.......---+:sresesrrscrerssr :
Testimony of Emil Kuichling
Thomas J. Neville
Gaylord Thompson
Edwin A. Fisher... ©. .----s:ese8 sere
Frederick C. Lauer, Jr.......---+e-28 eeeee
Emil Kuichling (recalled)
Commissioner’s certificate
Stipulation as to testimony :
Testimony of Alphonse Fteley.... -----++s+)sss5 ss
Exhibits offered
Exhibits A, B, C, and D—(Not set out) oun
Exhibit E—Notice of executive board, December 3, 1892...
Exhibit A, November 14, 1896—Rochester water works,
1892, notice of letting and forms of proposal, contract,
and specifications for contract No. 1, for constructing
masonry water conduit, tunnel, and gate-house for the
city of Rochester, N. :
Exhibit B, November 14, 1896—Proposals, &ec. .
Summary of proposals, con-
tract No. 1
Subpeena
Marshal’s return he ae es
Precipe for appearance for defendants
Replication
Restraining order
Order for injunction pendente lite. ....--++-200000eeere renee :
Consent to substitution of defendants’ attorney
Order substituting defendants’ attorney..----.---+--++-s0500°
Order substituting complainant’s attorneys
Consent to substitution of complainant’s attorneys....--.
Petition on appeal
Petition for appeal
Bond for damages and costs
Clerk’s certificate
Concurring opinion of Shipman, J
Writ of certiorari and return
MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO, VS. CITY OF ROCHESTER.
a United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit.
Tue Morrerr, Hopexins & Cranky Company, Complainant, }
Appellee,
vs.
Tue City or Rocuester, Georce W. ALpripae, WILLIAM W.
Barnard, and John W. Schroth, Composing the Executive
Board of the City of Rochester, Defendants, Appellants.
Transcript of Record.
Appeal from the circuit court of the United States for the northern
district of New York.
[Stamped :] United States circuit court of appeals, second circuit.
Filed Dec. 18, 1897. William Parkin, clerk.
1 United States Circuit Court, Northern District of New York.
In Equity.
Morrett, Hopaxins & CLARKE COMPANY )
against
Tue Ciry or Rocuester, George W. ALDRIDGE, WILLIAM W.
Barnard, and John U. Schroth, Composing the Executive Board
of the City of Rochester.
To the honorable the judges of the United States circuit court for
the northern district of New York :
The Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Company, a corporation duly
organized and incorporated under and pursuant to the laws of the
State of New Jersey, and engaged in the business of contractors, and
being a citizen of the State of New Jersey, brings this its bill of
complaint against the City of Rochester, a municipal corporation
duly organized and incorporated under and pursuant to the
2 laws of the State of New York, and George W. Aldridge, Wil-
liam W. Barnard and John U. Schroth, composing the exec-
utive board of the city of Rochester, all of whom are citizens of the
State of New York, and inhabitants of the northern district of said
State of New York, and residents therein, and thereupon your ora-
tor complains and says:
That the executive board of the city of Rochester has under the
provisions of the charter of said city, control of the water works
thereof, aud of the coustruction of all extensions and additions, im-
provements and repairs of the same, and is authorized to let con-
tracts for such extensions and additions of its works as may from
time to time be deemed necessary. That heretofore, to wit, on or
about the 10th day of December, 1892, the said executive board de-
termined to make certain improvements and extensions and addi-
tions to the water works of the said city of Rochester, among ot
2 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. vs.
things, to construct a masonry conduit for a distance of 12,000 feet
from Hemlock lake, northward, aud proposed to enter into the con-
tract with suitable persons or corporations for the performance of
such work, the contract thus to be entered into being known as
contract No. 1.
That at the same time said executive board also determined to
construct a riveted steel pipe conduit, 38 inches or 40 inches in di-
ameter, and all the required appurtenances thereto, commencing at
the north end of said masonry conduit and terminating at Mt. Hope
reservoir ip the city of Rochester ; the length of such conduit being
about 140,000 feet, and the suid executive board proposed to enter
into a contract with suitable persons ot corporations for the con-
struction of said last-named conduit, which contract was known as
contract No. 2.
3 That the said executive board thereupon, through its en-
gineer, prepared yoluminous specifications, proposals and
directions relative to such proposed contracts, the same being em-
bodied in printed form and covering in the aggregate about 300
closely printed pages, and specifying elaborately and with infinite
detail the requirements of the said executive board, the method in
which the work contemplated was to be performed, the character of
the materials required to be furnished, and the tests to which said
materials were to be subjected. A copy is hereto annexed, marked
Schedule D, and is hereby, with other schedules hereto annexed,
made a part of the bill of complaint.
That the said executive board did not give public notice of its
purpose of letting said contracts until on or about the 10th day of
December, 1892, and on said day notice was given to contractors of
the fact that sealed bids or proposals for the work contemplated
with respect to said masonry conduit and riveted steel pipe conduit
would be received at the office of said executive board in the city of
Rochester, N. Y., until 12 o'clock at noon of December 23, 1892, at
which time and place such bids as might have been submitted were
to be publicly opened by the chairman of said board and read.
That your orator, which is engaged in the business of contracting,
has an office in the city of New York, where it keeps employed its
engineers, and whose duty it is to prepare proposals upon work of
the character contemplated by said executive board. That the
officers of your orator were engaged during the month of December
in important and distracting occupations connected with their busi-
ness, which required them to delegate the duties ordinarily per-
formed by them, with respect to proposals of the character
4 hereinbefore described, to their subordinates. ‘That the
agents of your orator, althoagh they exercised due diligence
to possess themselves of copies of the forms of proposal of contract
and specification prepared by the engineer of the said city of
Rochester, were unable to procure the same until on or about the
15th day of December, 1892. That upon receiving said printed in-
formation the engineer of your orator, who is charged with the ex-
amination of said proposal of contract and specifications, and with
the preparation of your orator’s bid thereon, proceeded to the city
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 3
of Rochester on the 20th day of December, 1892, having attempted to
familiarize himselfin the meantime with the terms of said proposed
contracts, and there conferred with the engineer of the said execu-
tive board, visited the line of the proposed conduit, and thereupon
proceeded with the preparation of your orator’s proposal for the
work contemplated by said contracts, known as Nos. 1 and 2.
That the labor devolving upon him in the period of time
allowed for the preparation of the proposals for said work rendered
the said engineer nervous and confused, so that in transcribing the
figures prepared by bim for insertion in form of proposal prepared
by the engineer of the said executive board he accidentally and un-
intentionally made certain clerical errors, which your orator will
now proceed to describe.
That said contract No. 2 submitted to the contractors for consid-
eration two different routes over 8,000 feet of the 140,000 of the said
proposed steel conduit, said routes being designated in said printed
form of proposal and specifications as “ A” and “ B,” and the board
reserved the right of electing either of said routes, aud the further
electing to require a 38-inch pipe ora 40-inch pipe as the pipe to be
furnished by said contractors.
5 That route “A” was located in the alluvial flats through
which the Honeoye creek meanders, and involved several
crossings of the existing and former channels of said creek. Route
“ B” was located wholly on the west side of Honeoye creek, and re-
quired the construction of a tunnel with the necessary shafts, inlet
and overflow chambers, manholes and other appurtenances.
The specifications and form of proposal with reference to route
“A” involved 61 different items and quantities of work and ma-
terials. The specifications and form of proposal as to route “ B ” in-
volved 75 different items and quantities of work and materials in
addition thereto. That among the items of route “B” was that
known as “d,” which was described in the form of proposal in the
following language: “ For all earth excavations in open trenches or
oes for the masonry and pipe conduit, entrance and overflow cham-
ers, gate vaults, blow-offs, pipe overflows, bridges, railroad cross-
ings, creek crossings, and culverts carried under said conduit,
including bracing and sheeting, back-filling of trenchesand masonry,
making embankments and other final disposal of the excavated ma-
terial with haul of 1,000 feet or less, bailing and draining, and all
incidental work.”
That item “d” in route “ A” was in preeisely the same language
as that just quoted. That the quantities for said item as prepared
by the engineer declared that the quantity of excavation contem-
plated by said items was 184,000 cubic feet of earth. That tiie same
item in each route referred to precisely the same work.
That your orator and its engineer intended to bid for said work
the sum of $.70 per cubic yard, which sum was a fair and reason-
able price ior the said work. That in the proposal relating
6 to route “ A” your orator’s engineer inserted in the blank pro-
vided for that purposes in said printed proposal furnished
by the defendant, both in words and figures, the sum of $.70. That
+ THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
through inadvertence, confusion, accident and mistake the said en-
ineer, in the haste of transcribing his memoranda into the printed
‘orm of proposal, inserted as the price for said work the sum of $.50
per cubic yard, the difference between the price thus inserted iu the
proposal relating to route “B” for the same work for which said
proposal for route “ A ” had been prepared, and the price intended
to be charged therefor by your orator was some $36,800.00. That
the sum of $.50 per cubic yard of earth excavation under specifica-
tions as prepared by the engineer for the defendants, is a wholly in-
adequate and insu cient price for such work. ‘hat the said pro-
posal for route “ ” also contained an item in the following language,
to wit: “‘h. For all earth excavation in tunnel, including all
necessary bracing, timbering, lighting, ventilating, removal and
back-filling and other final disposal of the excavated material with
haul of 1,000 feet or less, pumping, bailing and draining, and all
incidental work.” That defendants’ engineer estimated the quantity
of excavation required under this item of the proposed contract at
2,000 cubic yards. ‘That it was the intention and purpose of your
orator and its engineer in the preparation of its proposal for said
work to charge for such earth excavation the sum of $15.00 per
eubie yard, which was a fair and reasonable charge for such work.
That in the haste and confusion of the preparation of said proposals
by your orator’s engineer, and in transcribing his figures into said
riuted form of proposal prepared by the defendants’ engineer, by
inadvertence, accident and mistake, your orator’s engineer, who is ex-
tremely near-sighted, instead of specifying the sam of $15.00
7 per cubic yard for said work, inserted in the blank left for
that purpose the sum of $1.50 per cubic yard. That the said
sum was a grossly inadequate and insufficient price of said work,
and was far below what would be the actual cost to your orator for
this work under the most favorable circumstances. That the differ-
ence of the bid for said item work as inserted in said printed proposal,
and as intended to be inserted therefor therein, is the sum of
$27,000.
That your orator’s engineer, in the preparation of said proposals
was so limited as to time that he did not actually complete filling
out of the blanks relative to route “B ” in said contract No. 2 until
12 o’clock at noon on the 23d day of December, 1892, and neither
he, nor any of the officers of your orator were able after the filling
out of said blank to re-examine or compare or confirm the accuracy
of the figures inserted therein.
Your orator further says that the defendant in its requirements
of oontractors provided that each proposal should be accompanied
by a bond, executed by two or more freeholders of the State of New
York, or surety companies, incorporated under the laws of said
State in the penal sum of $90,000, conditioned that the person, firm
or corporation, making a bid for said work, if it should be accepted
would perform the work or furnish the materials or both, mentioned
in the proposal of such firm or corporation, and at such time or
place as might be required by said board, would euter into a con-
tract in accordance with said notice to contractors with the city of
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 5
Rechester. That your orator precured the execution of such a bond
with Henry D. Lyman and the American Surety Co., as sureties,
said bond being executed in the eity of New York by your orator
and said sureties. That at the time of the execution of said
8 boud the proposal annexed thereto was entirely in blank, the
said engineer being then at the city of Rochester engaged in
the preparation of his figures. That said bond was brought to the
city of Rochester by one of the officers of your orator on the said
23d day of December, 1892. That in the short time elapsing be-
tween his arrival at the said city and the time of the presentation
of proposals to said executive board it was impossible to insert in
said pamphlet containing said bond the proposals of your orator for
the work contemplated by contracts Nos. 1 and 2, or either of them.
That accordingly, the prices for the work contemplated by said
several contracts were inserted in other and different pamphlets of
the same general character as that containing said bond, but were
not signed or in any way executed by vour orator or by any of its
officers in its behalf. That after the filling in of said items in said
printed forms of proposal as hereinbefore described, your orator
placed into a single package the said pamphlet containing said bond
and the pamphlets containing its proposals for said contracts num-
bers 1 and 2. That it was led to believe by these defendants and
their officers that although the masonry conduit and riveted steel
pipe conduit were separately described they constituted a continuous
piece of work and that a person, firm or corporation, bidding upon
both sections of said conduit whose bids were lower in the aggregate
than the bids of any other contractors for the same work should be
awarded the coatract therefor. That with this understanding and
with the intention and purpose of making a single proposition for
the entire work your orator deposited said package containing the
proposals for the work contemplated upon both sections with the
said executive board. That the notice to contractors prepared by
the said defendants provided that every bid for the masonry
9 conduit should be enclosed in a sealed envelope endorsed,
“Proposal for performing contract No. 1, Rochester water-
works conduit,” and that every bid for the riveted steel pipe conduit
should be enclosed in a sealed envelope and endorsed, “ Proposal for
the performing of contract No. 2, Rochester water-works conduit.”
That your orator did not comply with said provision, but addressed
the package in which both said- proposals were contained to the ex-
ecutive board of the city of Rochester.
That immediately upon presenting to the executive board of the
city of Rochester the said proposals, the same were opened by the
direction of the chairman of the said board, George W. Aldridge,
and upon his observing the form in which your orator’s proposals
were presented he declared them to be informal and not in compli-
ance with the requirements adopted by the, executive board in its
notice to contractors, and that they could not be received. That
they were nevertheless read together with the other proposals which
were presented at the same time by other persons, firms and cor-
porations. That the proposal of your orator fur line “B” in con-
ae aL
—s
6 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. vs.
tract No. 2 was read by the clerk of said executive board in the
resence of the members of said board before any other proposals
for the work on said line were read. That immediately upon read-
ing item “d” relating to earth excavation in open trenches, the
engineer of your orator, who prepared said proposals, informed the
members of the said executive board that the price which had been
read, to wit, $.50 per cubic yard, was a clerical error, that it was the
urpose and intent of your orator to charge for said work the sum
of $.75 ner cubic yard, the same price charged for the identical
work on line “A.” That the aggregate of the proposals for
10 the work described in contract No. 1 by the several bidders
for said work are as follows:
W. H. Jones & Son, Rochester. ....-eeeeeeeeeetee? $262,518 00
Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus.. ..csccesccccesesess 385,977 5
Rochester Construction Co....seeereeereeereerrees 394,500 00
Carroll-Porter Boiler & Tank Co.....csse0 seeereee 399,006 00
N. L. Bayer & Co... seers seereeces Poererr ec 415,967 00
Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co....-eeeeecereeerees 473,790 00
That the various bids made by firms and corporations who made
proposals under the specifications of contract No. 2, and the bids of
each of said firms and corporations for each item of said work ap-
pears in the tabulated statement of which a copy is hereto annexed
and marked Schedule “A.” That the price charged by each of said
bidders for earth excavation in open trench on route “A” were as
follows:
Your orator....+++++5 gS gig he ehh aeneees 70 cts. per cu. yd.
Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus.....--eeeeeerees 75 cts. “ .
Rochester Construction Co.....++eseeesrerrtts 80 cts. _ "
Carroll-Porter Boiler & Tank Co....-.-eeeeeee sce. * *
That the prices charged for the same work upon route “ B,” as
inserted in the proposals, were as follows :
Your orator.....++2 essen ada Sepaen earns 50 ets. per cu. yd.
Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus.... eee e reece ta. “
Rochester Construction Co.... eeereerrertttts 80 ets. * =
Carroll-Porter Boiler & Tank Co.. ---++++eees 85 cts. “
That the prices charged by the various bidders upon the propo-
sals for performing contract No. 2, for earth excavations in tunne
upon route “ B,” as contained in their proposals as deposited with
the defendants, were as follows:
Vests GONE ian soos + ease sarsrensreesee esse s* $1.50 per cu. yd.
Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus.....-eeeeeeereee 15.00 ss ss
Carroll-Porter Boiler & Tank Co...eceeeeeeees un0lC~SS:C‘ ’
Rochester Construction Serr tt no *
il That the aggregate prices charged by the several bidders
in their proposals for work on route “ B” aforesaid, are as
follows:
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. ‘ 7
a ee ee re eee yor
Whitmore, Rauber & Co............ neeeeeees ..+- 1,180,195 00
Carroll-Porter Boiler and Tank Co...... ves tated es ene oe
Rochester Construction Co..............e2+0++ «++ 1,849,935 00
That allowing to your orator the amount of its errors, viz., $63,800,
in addition to the prices inserted in the printed proposal for the
work on route “ B” as aforesaid, the total amount charged by your
orator for a 38-inch pipe for said route “B” would amount to
$921,354.50. That said corrected sum is $208,842.50 less than the
next lowest bid for said work, to wit, that of the firm of Whitmore,
Rauber & Vincinus. That the aggregate of the bids of your orator
for the work described in the contract No. 1 and the corrected bid
for the work of laying a 38-inch pipe upon route “ B” is $1,395,142.50.
That the said sum is considerably less than the aggregate bids of
any other contractor bidding upon the work described in said con-
tracts Nos. land 2. That the aggregate of your orator’s bid on
contract No. 1, and its bid as presented for a 38-inch pipe on line
“ B,” — $1,331,342.50, which sum is largely below the aggregate of
any two other bids for the work described in contract No. 1 and the
work of laying a 38-inch pipe on line “ B.”
Your orator further complains and says that the defendants, not-
withstanding the rights and equities of your orator, intending to take
undue, improper and unconscionable advantage of the form and
manner in which its proposals for said work under contracts Nos. 1
and 2 were presented to the executive board of the city of Rochester
and of the clerical errors aud mistakes contained in its pro-
12 posal for work ou line “B” of said contract No. 2, on or
about the 10th day of January, 1898, notified your orator
that the said defendants proposed to enter into a contract for the
work described in the proposals for contract No. 1 with W. H.
Jones & Son, although the proposals of your orator for the work
under both contracts were the lowest in the aggregate of any pro-
posals for the entire work contemplated by said defendants. That
thereupon, on the 11th day of January, 1893, before any official
action with respect to letting said contracts was taken by the de-
fendauts herein, your orator protested against the dividing of said
proposals and letting the work described in contracts Nos. 1 and 2
separately, and insisted that said defendant was bound to either
enter into a contract with it for the entire work described under
both contracts or none at all. That at the same time your orator
informed the defendants of the clerical errors that had been com-
mitted by its engineer in the entering of the statement of his prices
for the work on line “8B” with respect to the earth excavations in
the trench and in the tunnel, and demanded that the said executive
board should permit your orator to correct said errors. That it
further demanded that the contract for both sections of work in its
entirety should be awarded to it at the corrected prices, or that it
might be allowed to withdraw its proposals and that the same
should be returned to it. That thereafter and on the 12th day of
January, 18938, the defendants, composing the executive board of
8 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE UO. VS.
the city of Rochester, N. Y., acting in bad faith, and with the pur-
se of taking an unfair, undue and unconscionable advantage
of the clerical errors committed by the engineer of your ora-
tor aforesaid, the commission of which the said efendants
conceded, the executive board adopted the resolutions
13 which are hereto annexed and marked Schedule “ B,”
and caused copies thereof to be served on your orator
on the 14th day of January, 1893, and the said defendants now
propose, in conformity with said resolutions so adopted by said
executive board, to insist upon the execution by your orator of the
contract for laying a 38-inch pipe on route “ B” for the prices in-
serted by your orator’s engineer in said proposal deposited with
said executive board. That said defendants intend, in case your
orator shall fail to enter into the contract so required by said
defendants, to declare your orator in default and the bond executed
by it as aforesaid, a copy of which is hereto annexed and marked
Schedule “ ©,” forfeited, and thereupon to proceed to enforce the
nalty of said bond. That the said threatened action of the
defendauts is contrary to good conscience and good morals, and a
violation of the terms and conditions upon which said proposals
were invited by them, and in contravention of the expressed in-
tention, purpose and rights of your orator. That said proposed
action of the defendants, unless restrained by this honorable court,
would cause your orator irreparable injury for which he had no
adequate remedy at law. That the matter in dispute between your
orator and the defendants, exclusive of interest and costs, exceeds
the sum or value of $2,000.
And forasmuch as your orator can have no adequate relief except
in this court, and to the end, therefore, that the defendants may, if
they can, show why your orator should not have the relief hereby
prayed, and may make a full disclosure and discovery of all the
matters aforesaid, and according to the best and utmost of their
knowledge, remembrance, information and belief, full, true, direct
and perfect answer make to the matters hereinbefore stated
14 and charged; but not under oath, an answer under oath be-
ing hereby expressly waived. And your orator prays:
That the said proposals for laying a 38-inch pipe on line “ B”
may be reformed and amended so that the price charged for earth
excavation in open trench shall be seventy cents per eubie yard in-
stead of fifty cents per cubic yard, and that the price for earth ex-
cavation in the tunnel may be reformed and amended so as to
entitle your orators to $15 per eubic yard instead of $1.50 per cubic
yard ; or that said proposal be entirely rescinded, cancelled and de-
clared null and void ; that the defendants, composing the executive
board of the city of Rochester, be either required to enter into a
contract with your orators for the work described under contract
No. 1, and also for laying a 38-inch pipe on line “ B,” under con-
tract No. 2, at the price so reformed and corrected, or that the bids
of your orator for the whole of said work be rejected as an entirety.
And your orator further prays that the defendants and each and
every of them and their several clerks, attorneys and agents, be per-
ESE CLT Coe -
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 9
petually restrained and enjoined by a writ of injunction to be
granted by your honors, issued out of and under the seal of your
court from in any way declaring your orator in default with respect
to the sp yarumes made by it for the work of laying a 38-inch pipe on
line “ B” aforesaid, and furnishing the materials therefor, or from
declaring the bound executed by and in behalf of your orator, for-
feited, or from in any manner suing upon or attempting to enforce
or collect the said bond, or from entering into contract No. 1 with
any other person or corporation.
And your orator further prays that a provisional or preliminary
injunction be issued restraining the said defendants in like manner
as prayed for with respect to the perpetual injunction of this
15 honorable court, pending this cause, and for such other and
further relief as the equity of the case may require and to
your honors may seem meet.
May it please your honors to grant unto your orator not only a
writ of injunction conformable to the prayer of this bill, but also a
writ of subpeena of the United States of America directed to the
City of Rochester and to the said George W. Aldridge, William W.
Barnard, and John U. Schroth, composing the executive board of
the city of Rochester, N. Y., commanditty them on a day certain to
appear and answer to this bill of complaint, and to abide and per-
form such order and deeree as to the court shall seem proper and
required by the principles of equity and good conscience.
JENNEY & MARSHALL,
Solicitors for the Complainant.
LOUIS MARSHAL., Complainant’s Counsel.
MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO.,
By C. T. MOFFETT, See’y.
Unitep Srates oF AMERICA, -
Northern District of New York, Onondaga County,
On this 18th day of January, 1893, before me personally appeared
C. Todd Moffett, the secretary of The Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke
Company, the complainant above named, who, being by me duly
sworn, deposes and says that he is the secretary of the Moffett,
Hodgkins & Clarke Company and is familiar with its business.
That he has read the foregoing bill of complaint and knows the
contents thereof,and that the same is true to his own knowl-
16 edge, except as to the matters therein stated on information
and belief, and as to those matters he believed it to be true.
C. TODD MOFFETT.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 18th day of January,
1893.
' BENJ. STOLZ,
[L. s.] Notary Public, Onondaga Co., N. Y.
2—R
10 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
ScHEDULE B.
Orrice oF THE Executive Boarb,
Rocuesrer, N. Y., Jan. 12, 1893.
By Mr. ScHROTH:
Resolved, That the proposal of the Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke
Co., of New York, N. Y., submitted on Dee. 23, 1892, for the con-
struction of a riveted steel pipe conduit 38 inches in diameter, and
all the required appurtenances thereto, commencing at the north
end of the contemplated masonry conduit near the village of Hem-
lock Lake, Livingston Co., N. Y., and terminating at Mt. Hope res-
ervoir, in the cily of Rochester, N. Y., and by route “ B” as described
in the notice of letting for said work, be and the same is hereby
accepted, and that said work be and hereby is awarded to said
Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co.
By Mr. ScHRoTH :
Resolved, That the Moffett, Hodgkins and Clarke Co., of New
York, be and they are herewith required to attend at the office of
this board, along with the sureties to be offered by said company,
on or before Thursday, Jan. 19, 1893, and to execute at that
17 time the contract for the performance of the work of con-
structing a riveted steel pipe conduit 38 inches in diameter,
aud all the required appurtenauces thereto, by route “ B,” from the
north end of the contemplated masonry conduit near the village of
Hemlock Lake, Livingston Co., N. Y., to Mt. Hope reservoir in the
city of Rochester, N. Y., and that the failure of such attendance
and execution will be regarded as an abandonment of intentiou on
the part of said Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co. to perform said
work.
By Mr. ScHRoTH:
Resolved, Chat the clerk be, and he is hereby directed to cause
immediate legal service of notice of award of contract to be made
on the Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co., of New York, N. Y., in ac-
cordance with the foregoing resolutions.
I hereby certify that the foregoing resolutions were adopted at a
meeting of the executive board of the city of Rochester, N. Y., held
at the office of said board on Jan. 12, 1893, and that the same are
true copies of the minutes of said meeting.
THOS. J. NEVILLE,
Clerk of Executive Board.
Schedule C appears at page 41 to 48 of Exhibit{Contract No. 2,
which follows the oral testimony.
Schedule D is the same as Exhibit Contract No. 2.
ie
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. il
18 United States Circuit Court, Northern District of New York.
Tue Morrert, Hopekins & CLARKE Com- )
pany, Complainant,
v8.
Tue City oF Rocuester and Greorce W.
Aldridge, William W. Barnard, and John rIn Equity. No. 6182.
U. Schroth, Composing the Executive
Board of the City of Rochester, Defend-
ants. }
The joint and several answer of The City of Rochester and of George
W. Aldridge, William W. Barnard, and John U. Schroth, com-
posing the executive board of the city of Rochester, the above-
named defendants, to the bill of complaint in the above-entitled
action.
In answer to said bill said defendants say as follows:
I. They admit that said defendants, comprising the executive
board, have, pursuant to the statute in such case made and pro-
vided, coutrol of the water works of said city, and of the construc-
tion of all’extensions and additions, improvements aud repairs of
the same, and are authorized to let contracts for such constructions,
extensions and additions, as may, from time to time, be deemed
necessary.
19 They admit that said executive board did determine and
propose to enter ito contract No. 1, to construct a masonry
conduit, as set forth in said bill of complaint.
‘They admit that said executive board also determined and pro-
posed to enter into contract No. 2, to construct a riveted steel pipe
conduit, as set forth in said bill of complaint.
They admit that said executive board did prepare proper specifi-
cations, proposals and directions relative to said proposed contracts,
ina printed form, specifying the requirements of said executive
board, the method in which the work contemplated was to be per-
formed, the character of the materials required to be furnished, and
the tests to which said materials were to be subjected.
They admit that said executive board did give legal and proper
public notice, as required by the statute in such case made and
provided, of its purpose of letting said contract, and requiring such
contractors to submit sealed bids or proposals for the work con-
templated in the aforesaid contracts.
They admit that the executive board required, among other
things, that the proposals for coutract No. 2 should be accom-
panied with a bond, executed by two or more sureties, or by a
security company incorporated under the laws of the State of New
York, in the penal sum of ninety thousand dollars, conditioned
that the person, firm or corporation making a bid for such work, if
it should be accepted by said executive board, would perform the
work or furnish the materials, or both, meutioned in the proposal
of such firm or corporation, at such time or place as might be re-
12 HE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE UO. V8.
quired by said board, and would euter into a contract with said
city of Rochester in accordance with the notice of said executive
board to contractors.
They admit that said complainant did, on the 22d day of
20 December, 1892, duly procure the execution of the bond re-
quired as aforesaid, and annexed the same to the proposal of
said complainants for said contract No. 2.
II. They do not know and cannot set forth as to their belief, or
otherwise, whether said complainant was or is a corporation duly
incorporated and organized, was or is engaged in the business of
contracting in the State of New Jersey, and has, or had, its office in
the city of New York, where it keeps employed its engineers, whose
duty is to prepare proposals upon work of the character contem-
plated by the aforesaid contracts; or whether the officers of the
complainant were, during the month of December, 1892, engaged
in important and distracting occupations connected with their
business, which required them to delegate to their subordinates the
duties ordinarily performed by them with respect to proposals of
the character hereinbefore described, or whether the complainant,
or its agents, were unable to procure before the 15th day of said
December, copies of the form of said contract, und proposals for
the contract and specifications prepared by the engineer of said
city ; or whether the labor devolving upon the engineer of the com-
plainant rendered him nervous and confused, so that in transcribing
the figures prepared by him for insertion in the form of said pro-
posal prepared by said engineer of said executive board, he ac-
cidentally and unintentionally made certain errors described in the
complainant’s bill of complaint; or whether, through inadvertence,
confusion, accident and mistake, the engineer of said complainant,
in the haste in transcribing his memorandum into the printed form
of proposal for route B, did insert, as the price for the work set forth
in item d, the sum of fifty cents per cubie yard, instead of
21 seventy cents; or whether said price of fifty cents per cubic
yard is wholly inadequate and insufficient for such work;
or whether the engineer of said complainant did, in the haste and
confusion of the preparation of said proposals, in transcribing his
figures on the printed form of said proposal, insert the sum of $1.50
per cubic yard for item h, of route B, in said contract No. 2, to wit:
“ For all earth excavation in tunnel, including all necessary brac-
ing, timbering, lighting, ventilating, removal and back-filling and
other final disposal of the excavated material, with a haul of 1,000
feet or less, pumping, bailing and draining, and all incidental
works,” instead of the sum of $15.00 per eubie yard for such work ;
or whether the price of $1.50 per cubic yard is a grossly inadequate
and insufficient price for said work ; or whether the engineer of said
complainant was in any way limited in doing his work for said
complainant to complete his proposal for said contract to said
executive board ; or whether said complainant was led to believe
by said defendants, or any of its officers, that said contracts Nos. 1
and 2 would be let jointly, and not separately ; or whether the
complainant’s proposal for said contract No. 2 was, by said execu-
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC,
tive board, declared informal, and the same could not be received ;
or whether the complainant’s engineer did, before said executive
board upon the day said proposals were canvassed by said board,
notify said board that the price which had been read for item d, of
route B, in said contract No. 2, of fifty cents per cubie yard was a
clerical error.
III. Said defendants allege and state the fact to be that said
executive board having full power and control over the water works
of said city, did determine to let contracts for the construc-
22 tion of a conduit or conduits for additional water supply for
said city, and did cause its said engineer to prepare proper,
full and accurate specifications, proposals and directions relative to
such construction in a printed form specifying the requirements of
said board, the methods in which the work contemplated was to be
performed, the character of the materials required to be furnished
and the tests to which said materials were to be subjected; that
said executive board did give full, legal and proper aaitle notice as
required by the statute in such case made and provided to all
persons desiring to bid upon the aforesaid contracts, designating
therein the time and place, to wit, December 238, 1892, at the office
of the executive board in the city hall of said city, to the effect
that each and every bid upon the several contracts proposed, should
be enclosed in a sealed envelope addressed to said executive board,
and so sealed and addressed, seal be delivered to the clerk of said
board, and after said proposal had once been so delivered the same
could not be withdrawn; that said notice further required of all
persons making bids for said contracts that the prices for every
separate item of work named in said proposal should be plainly
and distinetly written in ink, both in words and figures, in the
proper blanks left therefor; that said complainant’s engineer re-
ceived all communications and explanations requested by him from
said executive board and its engineer, and all the plans, specifica-
tions and information were at the complainant’s command before
its submission of the proposals for said contract.
Said defendants further allege and state the fact to be that on
account of the treacherous subsoil disclosed by borings along said
route A, and the more favorable soil disclosed along said
23 route B, in contract No. 2, the latter route would be the less
expensive, and that the prices complained of in the com-
plainant’s bill of complaint were reasonable and fair values of the
work set forth therein, and said defendants deny that any clerical
error or mistakes were and are contaiued in said proposals.
Said defendants further allege and state the fact to be that if said
items complained of in said route B, are less than the average
amounts bid by the competitive bidders for said contract, the
amounts were knowingly and inteutionaily so inserted by com-
plainant’s engineer, with the intent and purpose to make for said
complainant a bid known as an “unbalanced bid,” to wit, in which
the contractor will give a low price for one kind of work or material
and an unusually bigh price for another kind or work or materials
in the same contract with the hope that the quantity of work or
14 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE co. VS.
materials for which a low price is bid will be reduced while the
quality of materials or work for which a high price is bid will be
increased, thus making up on the high price bid sufficient to give
the contractor a large prokt upou the whole work ; said complainant
did bid upon some items in said contract No.2 a price far in excess
of a reasonable price for the same, thus making said bid for said
route B, contract No. 2,an unbalanced bid, enabling said complain-
ant to realize upon the completion of the work far in excess of the
amount based upon the estimates of defendants’ engineer.
Said defendants further allege and state the fact to be that in pur-
suance of the notice to contractors accompan ying the proposals for
said contracts said executive board did award to W. H. Jones & Sons,
contract No. 1, they being the lowest bidders for the same, and to this
complainant contract No.2, it being the lowest bidder for the same, and
deny that said award of said contract to said complainant was
24 made by said executive board with the intent to take undue, |
improper and unconscionable advantage of the form and man-
ner in which its proposals for said work under contracts Nos. 1 and
2 were presented to said executive board, or that said executive
board acted in bad faith and awarded said contract for the purpose
of taking au unfair, undue and unconscionable advantage of the
alleged clerical errors claimed to have been committed by the en-
gineer of said complainant.
Suid defendants further allege and state the fact to be that on the
12th day of December, 1892, and by the resolution annexed to the
complainant’s bill of complaint (marked Schedule B), said executive
board duly and legally awarded to said complainant the con-
tract for the construction of the conduit by route B, in contract No.
2, and thet said complainant was duly notified to attend at the
office of said executive board with its sureties to execute said pro-
posed contract, and that said complainant, without sufficient reason
or excuse and with intent to defraud said defeadants, did refuse and
neglect to enter into said contract, and said defendants deny that
said complainant is entitled to the relief, or any part thereof, in the
said complaint demanded, and they respectfully submit that the
injunction awarded against them by this honorable court on the
15th day of February, 1893, ought to be dissolved, and that the said
bill ought to be dismissed, with costs,
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER.
RICHARD CURRAN, Mayor.
THE EXECUTIVE BOARD OF SAID
CITY.
JOHN U. SCHROTH, Chairman.
Cc. D. KIEHEL,
Solicitor and of Counsel for Defendants, Rochester, N. Y.
25 Unirep States oF AMERICA, ae
Northern District of New York, Monroe County, J”
On this 3d day of November, 1893, before me personally appeared
Richard Curran, the mayor of the city of Rochester, one of the de-
\
m
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 15
fendants above named, who, being by me duly sworn, deposes and
says that, the is the present mayor of said city of Rochester; that
he has heard read the foregoing answer and knows the contents
thereof, and that the same is true to the best of his knowledge so
far as concerns the acts and deeds of said city and himself, and so
much thereof as concerns the acts and deeds of any other person or
persons, he believes it to be true.
RICHARD CURRAN.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 8d day of November,
1893
CHARLES P. LEE,
[L. s.] Notary Public.
The complainant thereupon filed a replication in the usual form.
Unitep Srates or AMERICA, \ ‘a
Northern District of New York, Monroe County, g
John U. Schroth, being duly sworn, deposes and says that he is
the chairman of the executive board, a department of the city of
Rochester, and one of the defendants above named, and is familiar
with the business of said board; that he has heard read the fore-
going answer, and knows the contents thereof, and that the same is
true to his own knowledge except as to those matters which
26 are therein stated to be alleged upon information and belief,
and as to those matters he believes it to be true.
JOHN U. SCHROTH,
Chairman Ex. Board.
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 83d day of November,
1893.
CHARLES P. LEE,
[L. s.] Notary Public.
16 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
United States District Court, Northern District of New York. In
Equity.
Morrert, Hopexins & CLARKE CoMPANY
against
Tur Crry or Rocnester, GeorGe W. ALDRIDGE, WittiaM W.
Barnard, and John U. Schroth, Composing the Executive Board
of the City of Rochester.
‘Testimony on behalf of the complainant, taken under and pursuant
to the 67th rule of the supreme court as amended, before Stuart
Taylor, Esq., a notary public, pursuant to stipulation, at the
27 city of New York, March 10th, 1894, pursuant to notice duly
given.
Appearances.
Louis Marshall and Joseph Mullen, Esqs., for complainant.
G. D. Kiehel, Esq., for all the defendants.
Epwarp H. Burtinaame, called as a witness in behalf of the
complainant, being duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct examination by Mr. MARSHALL:
Q. Where do you reside?
A. Providence, Rhode Island.
Q. What is your occupation ?
A. Civil engineer.
Q. And your age?
A. 57.
Q. How long have you been a civil engineer ? ,
A. Since about 19 years of age; I began at 18 or 20—37 years.
Q. What experience have you had as a civil engineer?
A. A very mixed one—railroad work, water works, city work,
municipal work.
Q. Have you participated in the construction of water works?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And also railroads?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was your employment in the year 1892?
A. In the early part of 1892 I was engaged in finishing the water-
works system at Peoria, Illinois. In June, 1892, I came to New
York and had charge of the general engineering for Moffett, Hodg-
kins & Clarke Company.
. The complainant in this action?
. Yes, sir.
_ Well, what work did you do?
. For them?
Yes?
_ During that time I was part of the time engaged in examina-
tion and surveys for the full supply of Jersey City, and other
28 things during the time. It was partially built—finished—
during that year ; some of the water-works work at Carthage ;
rOrOPrO
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER FET AI., ETC. 17
I also had charge of the railroad construction for the Gouverneur
and Oswegatchie road, and in charge of all the general work of the
firm standing over—fifteen different plants that were improved and
changed in various ways during that period.
Q. How long had you been in the employment of the Moffett,
Hodgkins & Clarke Company in one way or the other?
A. For that time for over seven years.
Q. Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Company was a corporation ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Organized under the laws of New Jersey ?
A. So I understand.
Q. Who were the officers of that corporation ?
A. J. F. Moffett, president; J. V. Clarke, treasurer; H. C. Hodg-
kins, vice-president.
Q. Who was the engineer who had charge of the engineering of
that corporation ?
A. Mr. Hodgkins.
Q. Were the others practical engineers ?
A. Not to my knowledge. Mr. Clarke, I will say, I believe is au
engineer, but practically | know nothing about it. He had no con-
nection with the engineering operations of the firm.
. What were his duties in the corporation ?
. Treasurer.
. Had charge of the finances?
Had charge of the financial portion of the business.
ne Mr. Moffett, what did he attend to?
wee
Yes?
General business.
He was not an engineer?
No, sir.
. During the year 1892 was Mr. Hodgkins actively engaged in
the work of the corporation ?
29 A. He was not; he was incapacitated by illness most of
the time except for a little time in the early summer.
—Q. Pa you state what the nature of his illness was during that
time ?
A. I can state not from actual knowledge, but if 1 understand, he
was during the summer suffering from an attack of appendicitis.
Q. So that he was entirely disqualified during the latter part of
1892 from doing any work ?
A. He was unable to attend to any work from some time, I think,
in July until late in the fall. He came to the office for a few times,
but took no active charge of anything. I was appointed chief en-
gineer in the firm probably for that reason.
CouNSEL FOR Derenpants: ‘That was in 1892?
The Witness: Yes, sir.
Q. Up to that time Mr. Hodgkins had sole charge and supervision
of the engineering department?
A. The general engineering department of the firm.
Q. . the corporation you mean ?
—R
OPLPOPOPO>O
18 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
A. The corporation I should say.
Q. And when any bidding was done or work was to be done who
had charge of the preparation of specifications or bids?
CounseL ror Derenpants: When—before you were there ?
Mr. MarsHat: No; befure he became engineer he was connected
with it.
A. Bids were generally prepared ——
CounsEL For Derenpant-: If you don’t know of your own knowl-
edge don’t say.
A. I will speak so far as my knowledge is concerned of work I
was concerned in. I always made my own calculations and sub-
mitted them to Mr. Hodgkins before the final action was taken upon
them. We generally used to consult together ; beyond my own ex-
perience and my own work I know uothing.
30 Q. But up to the time when you became chief engineer had
you ever made any bids for work except under the super-
vision of Mr. Hodgkins?
A. No, sir. I would modify that, however, by saying this. I
can’t say that the bids were sent to the office. Sometimes person-
ally I was unable to meet Mr. Hodgkins, and they were left at the
office ostensibly for his examination.
Q. They were left at the office for his examination ?
A. Yes.
Q. During the fall of 1892, particularly during the month of De-
cember, 1892, what cau you say as to the condition of affairs in the
office of Moffett, Hodgkins and Clarke Company so far as their en-
gagements and business is concerned ?
4. Mr. Moffett was absent from the office most of the time.
Q. Do you know what he was engaged in?
A. I think he was in Chicago, though I did not attempt to locate
him particularly. My impression is that he was on some company
business in Chicago, but of that I am not convinced. Mr. Hodg-
kins had at that time been able to come to the office for a few times,
but not practically to attend to business.
Q. Aud do you know what Mr. Clarke was principally engaged
in at that time?
A. No, sir; I don’t.
Q. Will you refresh your recollection—the Jersey City water-works
matter ?
A. Yes, tie Jersey City matter—that did occupy a large amount.
Now, I remember, as you recall it, Mr. Clarke being absorbed in that,
and my own time was largely taken up with it at that period.
Q. Will you state what the nature of the work was you were el-
gaged in with respect to the Jersey City water-works matter?
‘A. It was an examination of the whole water-shed connected with
the watershed of one branch of the Passaic river, investi-
31 gation of the flow of that river, surveys for reservoirs, stor-
ages for distributing reservoir, calculations for a conduit, and
other work in various ways connected with that.
Q. Interviews with public authorities ?
™
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL, ETC. 19
A. Mr. Clarke took charge of that end of the business largely.
Q. But you had charge of the engineering?
A. I had charge of the specific engineering.
Q. Can you give us an idea of the extent of the work contem-
lated ?
F A. The work contemplated the building of a stone masonry dam
at Old Bulton a height of 85 or 90 feet; a storage reservoir on the
Upper Rockaway covering 600 acres; the raising of one dam upon
a branch of the Rockaway at Dixon’s pond to the height of 47 feet ;
and provisions for making use of Gleen pond and Lake Delmont—
dams wanted at this point, and then the building of a main line of
conduit 28 miles.
Q. Tunnelling the mountain ?
A. Tunnelling the Hook mountains and the mountain back of
Paterson.
Q. In reference to draining the water—sewerage ?
A. Yes; there were other plans for taking off the sewerage of
Dover, Rockaway and Upper Bulton—anything that interfered with
the purity of that water supply. It was a very complicated thing.
Q. It was a complicated system designed for the supply of Jersey
City with 50 million gallons a day. What was the amount of
money involved in that contract ?
A. Between three and a half and five millions, depending upon
the methods employed and the extent to which the work was car-
ried. We thought the expense to eomplete it would be in the
neighborhood of uve millions.
Q. The work was very exacting and distracting, wasn’t it?
32 Counsel for defendants objects to the question.
Mr. MarsHaL_: I waive that question.
Q. What was the first information you had as to the intention of
the city of Rochester to build a new pipe line or conduit line for its
water works?
A. The first definite information was the advice of the “ Engineer-
ing News.” I can’t recall the date. It was the week before the
letting of the contract—about the 10th or 12th December; some-
where in that vicinity.
Q. Who called your attention to that advertisement ?
A. I don’t remember. I always read the“ News” and look those
things over. It was talked about in the office, but whether I noticed
it first or not I can’t say.
Q. Were you detailed to perform any duty with respect to the
preparing of bids for the work described in this notice?
A. I was instructed to go there and look over the ground.
Q. Where?
A. Rochester, and examine the ground, and make out a bid for
the work if I thought it worth while.
Q. When was that that you were so instructed ?
A. It was, I think, on the Saturday before—the bids were to be
let the next week. The day Iam rusty upon. I dou’t remember
those dates.
20 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. Where was Mr. Hodgkins at that time?
A. [had seen Mr. Hodgkins. He had been at the office either
Friday or Saturday, and we talked the matter over. I asked him
if he would go; he said he could not go.
Counsel for defendants objects to the conversation.
Conversation stricken out.
Q. What was his condition of health at that time?
A. He was unable io go. His condition would not allow him.
33 CounskL For DerenpAnts: I submit that is not proper,
and move that it be stricken out as a conclusion.
Answer stricken out.
Q. He did not go?
A. He did not go. .
Q. What did you observe as to his condition of health at that
time?
A. That he was unable to attend to business generally.
Q. Was he feeble?
A. He could come to the office for an hour or so. He could not
stay ; he would go back.
Q. He has been in bad health ever since, has he?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. He has not done any active work?
A. He has done no active work since a year ago last July.
Q. What did you next do after this interview which led to your
going to Rochester?
’ A. I went to Carthage on Saturday night—Friday night or Satur-
day night—to inspeet the work that was going on there. On Sun-
day I drove to Gouverneur, and on Sunday night I left Gouverneur
for Rochester.
Q. When did you arrive there?
A. Monday morning.
Q. Was it midnight, wasn’t it?
A. Some time in the night. I took the night train from Syra-
cuse.
Q. Prior to that time did you have any blanks for filling in your
bids upon that work ?
A. [ bad received one or two—the first—I think the first one. I
was no farther than the first two—whether the one or the two before
leaving New York I am unable to say.
Q. You mean the contracts, contract No. 1 and contract No. 2, as
they will be termed hereafter in this record?
A. Yes.
Q. There were four different blanks ?
A. There were four blanks, four sets of specifications for four
branches of the work, or alternate styles of work—kinds of work—
different kinds of work.
34 Q. Did you receive them all at one time or in sections?
A. No, I did not get them——
Q. Did not get them how ?
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 21
A. Together.
Q. Contracts 3 and 4 related to laying and furnishing cast-iron
pipe?
A. These I did not receive in time to make any figure or calcu-
lation on,
Q. I have correctly stated what contracts 3 and 4 related to—the
laying of cast-iron pipe?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You did not repair then any bids for them ?
A. No, sir.
Q. For what reason ?
A. I had no time after receiving the plans and specifications—
these specifications.
Q. Contract No. 1 related to what?
A. To the first section of the work, almost wholly in tunnel from
the counection to Hemlock lake.
Q. Masonry tunnel?
A. Yes.
Q. Contract No. 2 related to what ?
A. To the laying of steel pipe from the termination of the section
covered by the contract No. 1 for distributing reservoir with alter-
nate routes.
Q. What were those routes denominated ?
A. “ Route A” and “ route B.”
Q. What was “route A”?
A. “ Route A” was a more direct line following the valley of the
Honeoye creek.
Q. “ Route A” then, as I understand, was located in the alluvial
flats through which the creek flows, and involved
of the existing and former channels of the creek ?
A. Yes.
Q. And “route B” was situated on the west side of Honeoye
creek and required the construction of a tunnel, with the necessary
shafts, inlet and overflow chambers, manholes and other appur-
tenances?
A. It did.
Q. What was the length of the line which was contem-
plated to be construeted by contract No. 2?
A. The leugth from section 1 to the
Q. The total length of the line from the inflow of the Hemlock
lake to the city of Rochester ?
A. Can I refresh my memory by reference to notes?
Q. Yes,sir. Well, it is about 140,000 feet steel conduit, wasn’t it?
A. I can tell by reference; I don’t trust my memory in this
thing—140,000 feet.
Q. And what portion of that 140,000 feet was identical in routes
A and B? ,
A. All excepting—the only difference was the space where route
B deflected from the main line for this tunnel.
Q. That was about 8,000 feet in length ?
A. Yes, sir.
several crossings
35
22 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. So that in contract No. 2, 132,000 feet of the line was identical
in routes A and B?
A. The same.
Q. And the only portion, therefore, of the entire line as to which
ws was any difference in the two routes was this 8,000 feet of this
ine?
. This deflection of 8,000 feet for the proposed tunnel to avoid
the flat.
Q. So that, so far as the earth excavation was concerned, it was
practically the same excavation that was contemplated under routes
A and B?
A. The same thing.
Q. After you got to Rochester—I think it will not be disputed
that the day of the week you mention was the 19th December, 1892?
A. Reference to the dates has gone from my mind. Perhaps | have
the date here in my notes. Friday was the 234 December, 1593.
The 19th was Monday. I got there between Sunday night aud
Monday en time. Monday was my first day 'o Rochester.
Q. Your first day in Rochester was Mou lay, Doce ver 19th,
1892? Fare
A. Yes, sir.
36 Q. And the bids were to be presented ”
A. On Friday, the 23d.
Q. At what time of the day ?
A. 12 o’clock.
Q. Will you state what you did after you reached Rochester ou
the 19th December ?
A. I spent the day iu the office of Mr. Kinchling looking over
these plans and spelling over the matter as near as I could.
Q. Who was Mr. Kinchling ?
A. He was chief engineer of ‘he water works. I don’t know what
his actual title was; he was chief engineer of the water works—I
suppose of the city.
CouNsEL FOR DEFENDANTS: Chief engineer of the water works.
Q. What conference did you have with him?
A. Merely examining the plans in his office and obtaining some
data in relation to the work, with his assistants and with himself.
Q. What else did you do on that day?
A. That was all. That took the whole day.
Q. Before that when had you seen any maps of it?
A. I had seen nothing, knew nothing; the work was eutirely
fresh to me on Monday morning.
Q. Had you seen the specifications?
A. I bad read one and two.
Q. When did you first get the specifications of No. 2?
A. The latter part of the week previous; Friday and Saturday I
received them.
Q. I show you a pamphlet endorsed “ Rochester water works,
1892. Notice of letting and form of proposal, contract and specifi-
cations for contract No. 2 for constructing steel-pipe conduit and
-_
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 23
appurtenances for the city of Rochester, New York,” and ask you
whether that is the document which you received the latter part of
the week previous to the letting (handing witness pamphlet)?
A. It is.
37 Q. Did you receive a similar painphlet which relates to
contract No. 1?
A. I did.
Q. And was that about the same thickness as this—as No. 2?
A. Generally about the some sized book.
Q. This pamphlet which relates to contract No. 2 has, in addition
to several pages devoted to diagrams, how many pages?
A. 165.
Q. And the pamphlet relating to contract No. 1, in addition to
the number of pages devoted to diagrams of masonry work, con-
tained how many pages?
A. 97.
Q. Will you state from an examination of this book how many
items and quantities of work were involved in the bidding upon
route A of contract No. 2?
A. 61. ;
Q. Will you state how many items and quantities of work it was
unecessary for you to consider and bid upon under route B of con-
tract No. 2?
A. 75.
Q. There was included in this pamphlet, in the proposal, a speci-
fication of each item of work aud the materials which were to be
furnished ?
A. There were.
Q. The same is true of contract No. 1, is it not, as to there being
a large number of items on which bids were to be made?
A. There were a large number of items; yes.
Q. Can you tell me how many items there were under contract
No.1?
A. 44.
Q. And the proposals comprehended the bidding of a gross sun
for the entire work, or how was the bidding arranged ?
A. It was arranged by quantities.
Q. Not a gross sum for the entire work, but a sum for each quan-
tity?
A. Each work as may be increased and decreased by the actual de-
mand and work itself.
38 Q. And there was also an estimate made by the engineer
as to the probable quantity of each of the classes of work and
materials which was to be required by the performance of the con-
tract?
A. The amount of the materials to be used or handled was given
in each case and the price carried out. -
Mr. Marshall offers iv evidence the pamphlets referred to by the
witness.
Marked respectively “ Exhibits ‘1 A’ and ‘1 B’”
24 TIE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. You have stated that you had an interview with Mr. Kinch-
ling on the first day you were there. What did you do after that
with reference to the preparation of bids?
A. On the second day I went over the line of the proposed conduit,
the entire length of it, walked the length of it except five or six
miles through meadows near the reservoir; we omitted that—ac-
companied with some of his assistants.
Q. Went over the ground with Mr. Kinchling’s assistants?
A. Went over the ground proposed to be occupied, where the
conduit was to be.
What was the distance of that walk ?
140,000 feet.
Had you ever been over the ground before?
Never had seen it before.
Had you ever been in Rochester before?
Yes, sir.
But you had not gone over the work?
" Not been over the work at all. Had not been in Rochester
or several years.
_ How long did that examination take?
A. It occupied a whole day; we returned late in the evening.
Q. What was the next thing you did?
A. The next day was given to making up memoranda from which
to make a bid, studying the bids, &c.
Q. Did you have any people to confer with with reference
39 to the prices of materials?
A. I saw some parties in Rochester with reference to some
materials; some I could not obtain any prices for—materials that
needed to be looked up along the line, and I did not have time, and
did not succeed in obtaining any satisfactory information about.
Q. People who proposed to furnish the pipe?
A. With the pipe—I spent the larger part of this day in making
up this memoranda of the cost of furnishing a pipe for this work—
taken up almost entirely with that.
Q. Talked the matter over with representatives of various manu-
facturers of pipe?
A. Yes.
Q. The third day?
A. On the third day with representative of a firm at Syracuse.
Q. Mr. Stuart W herland?
A. No, sir; the foreman—Mr. Rantan, of the Porter Manufactur-
ing Company of Syracuse.
Q. How much time did you spend with him in going over figures
and estimates ?
A. From his arrival—from about nine in the morning, or early
in the morning, till the middle of the afternoon.
Q. That required considerable calculation, did it?
A. Yes, sir, it required a good deal of calculation. They did not
give us time enough as it was.
Q. Did you have other calculations to make besides those with
respect to the pipe conduit itself?
POrPOPOre
©
THE CITY OF ROCHKSTER ET AL., £TC. 25
A. Yes, sir, masonry calculations, and earth, timbering, &c.
Q. Give us an idea of the character of the calculations.
A. In the tunnel work it was necessary to consider these things
that enter into the driving of a tunnel and the working of a tunnel,
taking care of the water, taking care of the refuse material from the
tunnel, the timbering, the character of the ground to be considered,
and contingencies to be taken into account as to this—those
40 contingencies there having to be provided for. The cost of
delivering material was to be obtained along the line, or to
be estimated, where it could be obtained—everything of that sort
pertaining to these different items that make up the contract.
Q. You made calculations as to all those matters ?
A. Yes.
Q. In doing so did you have reference to the diagrams which are
annexed to this pamphlet ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Exhibits 1 A and 1B?
A. Yes, sir; these were the basis of the calculations.
Q. What other calculations did you make besides those with ref-
erence to the tunnelling ?
A. In reference to the earth excavation for the trenches, and the
rock. The trenches were somewhat uncertain—very uncertain ;
from it being in the open part of the line a great deal of hard-pan
or soft rock was included. I will correct that. The engineer recog-
nized but two classes of material—earth and solid rock. There was
a large amount of what is known among engineers as “ hard-pan ”
and some of a kind of a soft rock which he declined to consider solid
rock, and on which there was a chance for a great deal of difference
in making up an estimate for the cost of the work. That required
a good deal of thought.
Q. His directions as to that matter were all indicated by the
specifications which you had carefully studied and considered ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. So far as the contract and specification was concerned, did you
also have to examine that carefully ?
A. Yes, sir, it was part of the work of the day.
Q. In connection with your preparation ?
A. It was inseparable; it was all connected together.
Q. In contract No. 2 will you state how many paragraphs there
were in the specifications ?
A. 326.
41 Q. How many paragraphs were there iv the specifications
of contract No 1?
A. 182.
Q. What did you do after you had made these various calcula-
tions, and a talk with these various gentlemen who were to give
you information as to the price of materials, &c.?
A. That finished up the day on Wednesday, and on Thursday I
was still at work upon this—making out my figures.
Q. Making your calculations?
A. Yes, sir.
26 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE UO. VS.
Q. Your memoranda?
A. And was obliged to spend quite a part of the day on Thurs-
day in trying to obtain prices in Rochester connected with mason-
work and brick-work for which I did not obtain any satisfactory
prices anywhere.
be Your purpose was to ascertain the local market value of
abor ?
A. Of labor and material that went into this construction. It
varies with every place ‘where work is done.
Q. And in the absence of information on that subject what did
you do?
A. I did the best I could. I figured upon what I could do it for
in other places—what I had been doing.
Q. That related principally, I suppose, to contract No. 1—with
reference to the mason-work.
A. Yes, partially ; No. 2 had some of the masonry in that tunnel.
On the item of hauling, which isa large item, and work of that
sort I spent considerable time without much satisfaction to myself.
Q. Describe how you made your various memoranda?
A. These memoranda were made and left on Thursday night. I
had intended to close the whole business, but was waiting for a set
of the blanks with an executed bond to be attacheu. The bond
was to be attached to this, and I did not want to make out a set
until I made it out permanently, and Mr. Moffett was to be there.
I wished to consult with him before taking the chances on
42 some things, before filiing the blanks, not in an engineering
point of view, but simply to know his views concerning the
price and margin it was safe to work on. Those blanks did not
reach me, and Mr. Moffett did not reach there until Friday morn-
ing.
é. The day on which the bids were to be submitted ?
A. To be opened.
Q. When Mr. Moffett came did he bring you this document, Ex-
hibit 1 B (handing witness exhibit)?
A. Either that or a similar one.
Q. That is it?
A. Oh, yes, that is it; yes, sir; but Mr. Moffett did not reach me
until about 10 o’clock Friday morning.
Q. “ Exhibit 1 B” exactly the same as “ Exhibit 1 A,” with the
exception that from pages 38 to 47 were filled out and executed by
Moffett, Hodgkins and Clarke Company and the American Surety
Company, those pages being the bond required to be furnished by
the bidder ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. All other pages were blank ?
A. Yes, sir; it was not filled up at all; there was no time to
enter them.
(J. It had been your purpose to enter your prices in this pamphlet,
“Exhibit 1 B”?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And the same is true with respect to contract No. 1?
4i38
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 27
A. Yes; the same applies to both—both in the same condition.
Q. State what wus done after Mr. Moffett came with these docu-
ments.
A. Before he got there I found that there was only one way to
have all the blanks ready, and at 9 o’clock I commenced upon the
copies I had—between 8 and 9—-and worked as rapidly as I could
filling them up.
Q. Filling in the prices?
A. Filling in the prices; yes. When he came in it was too late
to discuss anything with him and fill the blanks he had brought ;
so after half an hour’s talk Mr. Moffett says—“Go on and fill it up.”
43 Counsel for defendants objects to the latter portion of the
answer, and moves that it be stricken out.
Latter part of answer stricken out.
A. (Continuing :) I did go on and fill it up as well as I could.
Q. You did fill it in under Mr. Moffett’s instructions?
A. I filled it in. I would say that those fillings were made up
from scattered memoranda, and I had not even time to check it in
the least. I did not go over it—did not compare it with the memo-
randa I had. In fact, it was past 12 o’clock, a minute or two, when
we entered the room of the executive board of Rochester.
Q. And up to that time you had been engaged ?
A. I had been working every moment since I started on this that
morning. Shall I state how they were presented ?
Q. No; but what you did before you presented them ; you were
engaged in filling out these blanks?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. These blanks referring to the prices which you made for
each of the items of work and quantities of material which were to
be furnished ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. In route A will you refer to this proposal of Exhibit 1 A and
Exhibit 1 B, and read the form of bid which was prepared which
related to earth excavation in open trenches or pits?
A. “For all earth excavations in open trenches or pits, for the
masonry and pipe conduit, entrance and overflow chambers, gate
vaults, blow-offs, pipe overflows, bridges, railroad crossings, creek
crossings, and culverts carried under said conduit, including bracing
and sheeting, back-filling of trenches and masonry, making etnbank-
ments and other final disposal of the excavated material with haul
of 1,000 feet or less, bailings and draining and other incidental
work. The sum of — per cubic yard.”
44 Q. That is kuown as “ subdivision D” ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. “Subdivision D, route A”?
A. Yes.
Q. Does subdivision D of route B, relating to earth excavation
in open pits, in any respect differ in phraseology from subdivision
D of route A relating to the same work ?
A. It does not.
28 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. They are in identically the same language?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was the quantity of earth exeavation specified by the
defendants in their notice for bids of earth excavation under
route A?
A. 184,000 cubic yards.
Q. How much did they state the estimate to be of earth excava-
tion under route B?
A. The same.
Q. It was the same work?
A. It was identically the same work.
CounNsEL FOR DEFENDANTS: He said the same amount.
Q. The same quantity ?
A. The same quantity.
Counset FoR Derenpants: It was a different locality, wasn’t it?
The 8,000 feet was a different locality ?
Q. So far as the earth excavation was referred to?
A. The same in each case; the same thing. I have it in my
memoranda; the same thing in every respect.
Q. What was the amount as filled in in the bid as presented
to the executive board for earth excavation, subdivision D of
route A?
A. $.70 per cubic yard.
Q. How much was the amount which was filled in in the bid as
proposed for the earth excavation subdivision D of route B?
A. $.50; that was our bid as filled in.
45 Q. You are familiar with the fair market value of earth
excavation, are you, as an engineer?
I think Iam. Iam.
You have done a great deal and bid for a great deal of it?
. Yes, sir.
Know the prices paid for it?
Yes, sir.
{n various markets?
. For forty years.
” What was the fair market value of the work described in sub-
division D of route A and route B of contract No. 2?
A. The market value of it was what I had given in route A—
$.70.
Q. The fair market value?
A. Yes, sir; $.70 to $.75—$.70 was a low value for it.
Q. What do you say as to the price—$.50 a cubic yard—being a
sufficient price for it, a sufficient compensation for it?
A. I would not take it at $.50. It could not be done for $.50.
With the kind of material there was there it could nut be done for
$.50.
Q. Will you state how it happened that you filled in the blank,
subdivision D under route A, at $.70, and the blank subdivision D
of route B, at $.50 per cubic yard?
OPororer
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 29
A. In making up this estimate, as I said previously, there were
pencilled memoranda, and among other calculations that this work
ordinarily would be worth $.50 a yard where there was nothing to
be considered beyond earth or medium excavation; but making
the addition in it for bard excavation, $.70 was as little as it could
be done fora yard. In the first route A,I had laid that aside
altogether, and in the ade took the $.50 without considering what
it applied to; it was merely mechanical. In copying I took the
wrong memoranda, that was all. There was no intention
Q. Was there any intention on your part to make any difference
in the price paid for earth excavation under subdivision D of routes
B and A respectively ?
46 Counsel for defeudauts objects to the question as incompe-
tent and immaterial.
A. There was none.
Q. Will you state as to whether or not what your nervous condi-
tion was on the morning of that day on which you filled out these
blanks?
A. I was overcome very much with it, and nervous over the delay
about the matter, and also the trouble which I had had in getting
things together ; Mr. Moffett’s slowness in appearing. The magni-
tude of the work seemed to me that it demanded more time than I
had to make the bids in; and I was in that condition that I was
not fit to make a bid.
Q. Was your mind confused ?
A. Yes, sir; I don’t like to acknowledge it ; in the haste to finish
it up, knowiug that there was danger in not getting to the room in
time, and the general confusion in which the thing was, I was not
fit to make the bid.
Counsel for defendants moves that the portion of the answer, “ I
was not fit to make the bid,” be stricken out as not being evidence,
and as incompetent and immaterial.
Q. What do you mean by saying you were not fit to make a
bid ?
Counsel for defendants objects to the question as incompetent and
immaterial.
A. Well, I was in a nervous condition ; that is all.
Q. Did I understand you to say that in making this bid of $.50
per cubic yard for earth excavation under subdivision D of route R
you made a mistake?
A. I did.
Q. Aud that that bid was made unintentionally ?
A. That was unintentional. ,
Q. And your purpose was to make a bid of $.70 per eubic yard ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What other mistake did you make in the bid as presented as
relating to route B?
30 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
47 A. For hauling the earth excavation in the tunnel I car-
ried out $1.50 without considering anything except the mere
moving of the earth. The bounds of the calculation or the allow-
ance for the work necessary to remove the earth was ten times the
amount of the mere excavation, and this was left out entirely.
Q. What was it your purpose to bid for that work ?
A. It should have been $15 instead of $1.50. There was no sense
or reason in $1.50.
Q. What was the fair market value of the earth excavation in
tunnel as described in subdivision H of route B of this proposal?
A. The fair price for it with ordinary working would be from $8
to $10. It would be as much as I intended to put in, but there was
contingencies to be allowed for which I intended to cover.
Q. What do you say as to the sufficiency of $1.50 per cubic yard ?
A. It would merely hand the dirt into the carsand keep the work
moving without any allowance for any work preparatory for it or
connected with it.
Q. Could you have it done for $1.50, or anything like that?
A. No, sir.
Q. The quantities stated in the advertisement of cubic yards of
earth excavation in tunnel for masonry contract was 2,000 cubic
yards?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And your intention was to bid $15 a cubic yard?
A. Yes.
Q. That to cover all contingencies and give a profit?
A. Yes.
2 What experience have you had in earth excavations in tun-
nels?
A. Back in the sixties I was in charge of tunnel-work, including
both rock and earth excavation, in Schoolville coal-fields, Pennsyl-
vania, for four years, and between 1880 and 1883, or one of
48 those years, had the entire charge of the construction of the
tunnel under the Hudson river, at this point here, between
Jersey City and New York, which is wholly in earth or in silt.
Those have been my main experiences in tunnel-driving.
Q. So that you were well acquainted with the cost and value of
work of that sort?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. So that in making your proposal of $1.50 it was purely a mis-
take on your part?
A.A atin entirely.
Q. Not at all intentional?
A. It was not intentional, no.
Q. After you had completed the filling in of these various pro-
posals of contracts 1 and 2 what did you do with them?
A. They were tied together—rolled together with the contracts
and blanks that Mr. Moffett brought.
Q. Containing the bond?
A. Containing the bond, and submitted together, fastened in that
loose way, I think, with a rubber band—tied together in some way.
+
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 31
Q. Were they put in an envelope, do you know ?
A. We had no envelope; it was not an envelope. They were
rolled up in a piece of brown paper.
Q. What was doue with them after you had rolled them to-
gether?
A. They were taken to the room and handed to the clerk of the
board.
Q. For the city of Rochester?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And the defendants composing the executive board of the
city of Rochester were present at that time?
A. So far as I know.
Q. Mr. Aldridge, Mr. Barnard and Mr. Schroth?
A. I remember Mr. Aldridge, and understood that the others were
there.
Q. Who went with you at that time?
A. Mr. Moffett.
Q. Do you remember anybody else present at the time?
49 A. There were present R. D. Wood & Co.’s general agent,
I can’t recall his name. I will think of it later. There were
also present Mr. Porter, of the Carroll-Porter Boiler Manufacturing
Company of Pittsburgh. He and the representative of R. D. Wood
were the only gentlemen of my acquaintance present.
Q. Beside Mr. Moffett ?
A. Yes, sir. Garrett is the name of the representative of R. D.
Wood & Company who was present. With him was another repre-
sevtative of theirs, but I cannot recall his name.
Q. To whom did you deliver these bids? —
A. To the clerk.
Q. Mr. Neville?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were there other bids presented at the same time by other
people ?
A. There were.
Q. Do you remember the names of some of the people?
A. I can give them from my memoranda here. Rochester Con-
struction Company, N. L. Bayer & Co., W. H. Jones & Son, Whit-
more, Rauber & Vicinus, Chambers & Casey, and the Carroll-Porter
— of Pittsburg—that is not exactly the legal name, but that
will do.
Q. What was done with the bids?
A. They were opened and read.
Q. Do you remember which was opened first, contract 1 or 2?
A. Contract 1 was opened first and read.
Q. Upon contract No. 1 the aggregate bids were—do I correctly
state them—W. H. Jones & Co., Rochester, $292,518; Whit-
more, Rauber & Vicinus, $385,997.50; Rochester Construetion Co.
$394,500; Carroll Porter Boiler and Tank Co., $400,146; N. L
Bayer & Co., $415,967.50; Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co., $473,790
is that correct ?
A. Yes, sir.
32 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. After the bids on contract No. 1 had been opened, will
50 —_—-you state what was done with reference to opening the bids
on contract No. 2?
A. The bids of No. 2 were opened and——
Q. Whose bid was opened first ?
A. Moffett, Hodgkins and Clarke Co. were read first.
Q. Before any other bids?
A. Yes.
Q. Will you state what occurred when that was read, and who
read it?
A. Mr. Neville, the clerk, read it. In reading the second per-.
tion——
Q. After your bid was read what occurred ?
A. In reading the second portion of the bid——
Q. That relates to route B?
A. Yes, sir; route B—and when the item of earth for open
trenches was reached, 184,000 eubie yards at $.50, I immediately
stopped the clerk, interrupted the clerk and said if it read $.50 it
was a mistake—it was intended to be the same as in route A, $.70.
I corrected that on the spot.
Q. What did he say?
A. Previously, the remark had been made that our bid was
informal, that it was not worth readiug—it was not to be considered
anyway.
Counsel for defendants objects.
Q. Who made the statement ?
A. One of the board of commissioners made that statement
plainly.
Q. One of the executive board, you mean ?
A. My impression is Mr. Aldridge.
Q. Did he state in what respect it was informal ?
A. That it was not in the shape that the other bids were.
Q. Anything else said upon that subject ?
A. Some explanation was made of it, and it was again repeated
that it was informal, but that they would read it and see what it
was. After I made this correction the clerk went on to read the
bid.
Q. Then the other bids were read ?
A. Yes.
Q. The total amount of the bid of Moffett, Hodgkins and
51 Clarke Company for the 38-inch pipe was $903,324; for the
40-inch pipe, $939,494; of Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus for
the 38-inch pipe, $1,123,920; for the 40-inch pipe, $1,164,900 ; of
the Carroll-Porter Co. for the 38-inch pipe, $1,208,002; for the 40-
inch pipe, $1,225,352; of the Rochester Construction Company for
a 38-inch pipe, $1,331,885, and 40-inch pipe, $1,352,985. Is that
correct ?
A. Yes.
Q. Upon route B the total amount of the bid by Moffett, Hodg-
kins and Clarke Company for 38-inch pipe was $857,552.50; for a
Ce at bed Oto DR
oles
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 33
40-inch pipe, $893,472.50; of Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus, a 38-
inch pipe, $1,130,195, and for a 40-inch pipe, $1,170,885; Carroll-
Porter Co., 38-inch pipe, $1,215,382; 40-inch pipe, $1,232,612; of
the Ruchester Construction Company, 38-inch pipe, $1,349,935 ; for
a 40-inch pipe, $1,377,785. Is that correct on route B?
A. I have not got tue figures—yes, sir.
Q. What was bid by Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus on route A
for earth excavations?
A. $.75.
@. Per cubie yard ?
A. Yes.
Q. What did they bid for earth excavation under route B?
A. The same.
~—— Q. $.75 per cubic yard?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was bid by the Carroll-Porter Co. for earth excavation
| under route A?
A. $.85.
Q. A cubic yard?
A. In both cases.
Q. And on route B?
A. $.85.
Q. Per cubic yard?
A. Yes.
QQ. How much was bid by the Rochester Construction Co. for
earth excavation under route A?
A. $.80.
Q. How much did they bid for earth excavation under route B?
A. $.80.
Q. There was not any rock excavation in tunnel under route A?
A. Not in tunnel.
52 Q. Under route B what was bid by Whitmore, Rauber &
Vicinus for earth excavation in tunnel ?
A. $15.
Q. How much by the Carroll-Porter Co.?
A. $12.
Q. By the Rochester Construction Company ?
A. $12.
Q. $12 per cubic foot?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Moffett, Hodgkins and Clarke Co., $1.50?
A. I suppose it is down. I have got it down here $15. That is
the way it went on to the bid.
Q. Your item of $1.50 was inadvertent?
A. Yes, sir.
. Anc also your item of $.50 in earth excavation under route B?
. Yes, sir.
A
Q. The error you made in each instance was a clerical error?
A
. It was.
. What was the difference in dollars upon the quantities esti-
34 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. Vs.
ated of earth excavation, estimated by the defendants, between
$.70 per cubic foot and $0.50 on route B?
A. $36,800.
Q. What is the difference in dollars upon the quantity of earth
excavation in tunnel between the price of $15 per cubic yard and
$1.50 a cubic yard?
A. $27,000.
Making an aggregate of——?
$63,000.
Yes.
. What is the condition of your eyesight?
I am a little near-sighted.
You are very near-sighted, are you not?
. Sometimes, and sometimes I am not.
. Explain ?
A. Iam liable to some kind of an affection of my eyes. Some-
times they are a great deal worse than others; sometimes I am
obliged to wear glasses, sometimes I do not.
Q. Usually you do not?
A. I do not.
Q. Were any of these mistakes you made attributable to your
near-sightedness ?
OPOPOPore
53 Counsel for defendants objects.
Question stricken out.
Q. Was your eyesight at all affected on that day while you were
transcribing your memoranda into the proposals?
A. It was; if there is any nervous trouble my eyes are always
worse—confusing nature.
Q. Were you at Rochester at any time after the 23d December,
1892, the day of the presentation of the bids, on this business, so as
to have any interview with the members of the executive board ?
A. I never had any interview.
Q. The bids on both of these contracts were put together in one
packet ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. They were not separately put into separate envelopes, sealed
and endorsed ?
A. They were in one package—delivered together as one package.
Q. Then there was no separate envelope around each of these
proposals?
A. No, sir.
Q. Nothing with the words, “Proposals for performing contract
No. 1, Rochester water-works conduit,” or for performing contract
No. 2?
A. No, sir.
Q. Nothing of that sort ?
A. No, sir.
Q. Will you describe what this mason-work was under contract
No. 1? Was that for only part of the route?
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 35
A. Contract No. 1—that was the tunnel portion of it. That was
at the commencement of the route, the in-take or commencing, just
beyond the in-take from Hemlock lake, and extending through the
high ridge there. It was the commencement of the conduit.
Q. So that contract No. 1 and contract No. 2 represent a continu-
ous piece of work ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What was your understanding on the subject of the two bids
being really connected together as a single proposition to do the
entire work ?
Counsel for defendants objects to the question as incompe-
54 tent and immaterial, and as a conclusion of fact. If there is
any information he received, or anything he can show in the
papers to that effect, he can say it.
A. My understanding, as far as it went, was that the two went
together. It was talked as one job.
Counsel for defendants objects unles. the witness tells who talked
it, and moves that the answer be stricken out as incompetent, imma-
terial and hearsay.
Q. Were you a stockholder in the Moffett, Hodgkins and Clarke
Company ?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you have any interest in that concern at all ?
A. No.
. Merely an employee?
. Yes, sir; that is all.
And were you paid a yearly salary? -
. Yes, sir; a yearly salary.
>rO>o;
Cross-examination by CounseL FoR DEFENDANTS :
Q. How long a period were you in the employ of Moffett, Hodg-
kins and Clarke Co. before this work of the Rochester water works ?
A. I was continuaily with them for seven years previously to
this. My engagement with them dated back from October, 1885.
Q. And from that time you were regularly in their employ as
their chief engineer ?
A. No, sir; I was the chief engineer only during the last year.
Q. What was your employment before that time, from 1885
down ?
A. In the construction of separate water works for them at differ-
ent points in the country.
Q. That is, after the contracts had been let to them, you took
charge of the construction ?
A. The work was ordinarily contract work ; it was ordinarily
work for bidding on. The work I completed when I came
55 here was a piece of work involving an expenditure of a
million and a half at Peoria, Illinois. I rebuilt that entire
system.
,
3F THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. V3.
Which they had built themsel ves——?
. They had.
And then afterwards disposed of it if they got a chance ?
. No, sir; built it as they did the other works.
. If I understand you correctly, during the time you were with
them they built or constructed water works and maintained and
operated them ?
A. Eitber one or both. At Jackson, Mississippi, I made the con-
tract there subject to Mr. Hodgkins’ approval, and built the work
and turned over the proceeds to them. I did the same at Carthage,
in this State. Those were two of the contract jobs done during the
time by myself.
Q. And you had personal supervision of the entire work ?
A. I had entire charge of the work.
Q. You made all the specifications and plans ?
A. Specifications and plans. In the case of Jackson not one of
the firm ever sew it—saw only the balance [ returned into it when
the job was finished.
Q. Was that the same fact with regard to the Carthage work ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. So in those particular works you did not consult with any of
the company or officers of the company in the manner of construc-
tion ?
A. After the plans were agreed upon by Mr. Hodgkins there was
no further consultation with the company; the work was in my
hands entirely.
Q. When you speak of Mr. Hodgkins having agreed upon the
plans, what do you mean ?
A. I mean that when plans of any contract were made during his
active connection with the xirm as their chief engineer I always
consulted with him about it. The Carthage work was not. It
came under my own control.
56 Q. And then after you became the chief engineer of course
that consultation was abandoned?
A. Except so far as he was able—two or three times he was
able—to hold a talk in his private chamber.
Q. But it was understood between you and the firm that you had
exclusive charge of it ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And if there was any consultation between you and Mr. Hodg-
kins it was purely accidental ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How many people were employed by this company in their
engineering department during the time that you were the engi-
neer?
A. Do you want the names ?
Q. Yes, if you have them.
A. A few. Eugene Carroll, in charge of the construction of Butte,
Montana, water works, a job representing a million dollars; H.N. P.
Dole, in charge of Carthage ; E. W. Dewey, chief assistant ; E. George
Ferris, in charge of the construction of the Gouverueur aud Oswe-
LPore
a
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL. KETC. 37
gatchie road; H. W. Tamkin, assistant engineer; L. W. Richard-
son, Jacob Harman. He is now city engineer at Peoria.
Q. Well, a man at that time?
A. Yes, sir. I don’t think of others at present.
Q. Any draughtsmen that were in the employ of the company ?
A. Mr. Tamkin. He was in charge of the drawing-room in the
office.
Q. Have any assistant ?
A. He had one assistant; I can’t give his name; I don’t remem-
ber his name. A man who was in charge of Butte and Callesville ;
those are all I recollect now. There are other men nominally at
work subject to them, but not in acive employment after I became
chief.
Q. They could be called at any time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How many were there of them?
A. My son, who is now in charge of Clinton, Missouri, and
57 assistant on the work at Peoria. I willstopatthat. I don’t
recall any other name.
Q. Were there any more whose names you can’t recall who were
nominally in their employ ?
A. I say that I stop there.
Q. What do you mean by saying “ I stop there”?
A. I don’t have any more. These other men were in our em-
yloy.
Q. These men you have named as having charge of the different
works in the different places were people in charge from the very
beginning, were they not?
A. Yes, sir; generally. Sometimes they were put upon work
after it had been started, if occasion required.
Q. And in this Rochester job you were sent to take charge of
that, were you not?
A. No, sir.
Q. You were sent to make a bid, were you not?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. This Jersey City job that you have spoken of, was that making
out plans and specifications for the purpose of receiving bids ?
A. No, sir.
Q. What was it?
A. It was making out and submitting to Jersey City plans and
specifications on which works would be built and the city to pay a
certain price per gallon for the water furnished.
Q. You were then sent out by your company to make an estimate
of the expense that you could build it for, for the Jersey City au-
thorities ?
A. Yes, sir—not for the Jersey City authorities, but to supply
them with water at a certain price under conditions of construction
that should be satisfactory to the city of Jersey City and their engi-
neer.
Q. Did you have charge of that?
A. Yes, sir.
38 THE MOFFETT, HODGn!NS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. Who else was with you in making this estimate and examina-
tion there?
A. In the first place Mr. Cook was concerned—E. W.
58 Cook—he was upon the work for a little while and went to
Cleveland, Ohio; Mr. Dewey. Mr. Bandine was associated
with me in a general way in the collection of some material and
the making of some surveys, but it was mainly in my own hands.
1 gene you had been employed on that matter for how long a
eri
: A. Since June, 1892, since I returned from Peoria.
Q. The work then by the 1st of December was principally done?
A. The work was done so far as to submit the matter to the Jersey
City council.
Q. The work that was necessary during the month of December
I suppose was more of work to see whether you could secure the job
with the city authorities ?
A. Well, I was concerned at the same time in and we were operat-
ing 47 plants, and | had every extension, everything that pertained
to these different plants, come into the office for my supervision,
examination and approval before anything was done.
Q. You had men in charge in every one of those places ?
A. Certainly.
Q. And they simply made reports to you to the chief office ?
A. Mainly maps, reports, but there were additions and exten-
sions constantly asked for at different points.
Q. And you had people in your office that had charge of certain
points that did the detailed work ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And there were no reports coming in from this Jersey City
job after the Ist of December?
A. The Jersey City job was such that every few days something
was wanted concerning it.
Q. But the main work which devolved upon you as its engineer
had been done upon the grounds by the Ist of December?
A. Nomore than Mr. Kinchling’s work in connection with
59 Rochester was concerned. An engineer's work is never done
until his work is constructed.
Q. There was nothing in Jersey City where there was to be any-
thing definite in regard to a contract ?
A. Don’t understand you.
Q. They had not anything consummated so that the contract
was to be let by the 1st Deceinber, or by the time that the Rochester
matter came up; you were siinply prospecting ?
A. It was prospecting up to the time—I was trying to refresh my
memory enough to tell you that bids had been received up to that
time. I don’t remember; I[ can’t say, but as I said before there was
not a week but there was some of this work pertaining to Jersey
City in my office. It was not until long after this thing—it has
been a complicated thing with a great many ins and outs.
Q. You can’t remember when you first heard of this Rochester
job?
mY
THE CITY O¥ ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 39
A. I first heard of it when it was first published in the “ Engi-
neering News.” No, sir, I can’t remember when I first heard of it.
I can remember when I got my specifications.
Q. Can you tell me when you got the first book or pamphlet from
Rochester for this job ?
A. 12th of December.
Q. 12th of December ?
A. Yes, sir, that was my remembrance of it.
Q. You, of course, had written to Rochester for it before that ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And this was received by you by mail from Rochester in
answer to that letter?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do you remember what you wrote to Rochester ?
A. What I wrote to them—how?
Q. What you wanted ?
A. I wrote as I did where any bid is advertised asking for a copy.
Q. Can you tell me from recollection what the contents of that
letter was, or what vou asked for?
A. I asked for a copy of the specification.
60 Q. On the 12th of December, what did you receive?
A. I received one of those on one day and one the next.
I said the 12th—that is my remembrance of it. It was not earlier
than the 12th, and it might have been the 13th or 14th. They
came, one following the other—a day apart at least.
Q. A day apart?
A. Yes, sir; my memory of dates is confused.
Q. And as soon as you received this pamphlet I presume you
commenced to read it aud examine it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And by Saturday, or by the 17th, which is Saturday of the week
before the bids were opened, you had read both of the contracts,
namely, contracts No. 1 and 2, and understood them ?
A. I had read them. I don’t say I understood them. You could
not understand them until you were on the ground.
Q. You could not understand them both specifically ?
A. Not for me to know what was to be done and what was wanted.
Q. But you understood what the work was that was to be done
and what the materials were that were to be furnished ?
A. In a general way. I could not tell what parties engaged in
the manufacture of steel pipe would supply it for.
Q. You could, however, from the plans and specifications tell the
work that was expected in the contract to do?
A. The general work.
Q. You could not tell what the prices would be that you would
have to pay for the work and material that you needed ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Otherwise you could fully appreciate what wus contained in
those pamphlet works ?
A. I could understand in a general way what was wanted.
40 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. Now, when you speak of a large number of items, are
61 those items in your opinion anything extraordinary in any
way at all, or is that pamphletin your opinion extraordinary
in any way at all?
A. Is it extraordinary in some of its requirements?
Q. What do you mean by saying “ in some of its requirements ”?
A. In the requirement in regard to steel it is extraordinary—out
of the ordinary.
Q. Tell me what you think is extraordinary in regard to steel?
A. The * $c specifications as regards the temper and constitu-
ents of steel.
Q. Is there anything extraordinary or unusual in open trenches
and excavations iu tunnel ?
A. There is nothing extraordinary beyond this, that you can’t
determine anything about it until you have been over the ground.
Q. I don’t ask you as to your capacity or ability to determine be-
fore you go upon the ground; I merely want to know whether
there is anything extraordinary in the manner of specifying, or in
the language of the contracts, or in the notice to contractors ¢
A. There is one point in relation to the exeavation which is un-
common, and that is in the classification. There should have been
three classifications instead of two—solid rock, loose rock or hard-
pan, and earth or gravel. ’
Q. So you consider that the chief engineer in using the words
“earth excavation,” and including in that the hard-pan, as you
term it, is the only thing which to your mind is of an unusual or
extraordinary character?
A. I did not say it was the only thing.
Q. Well, what else is there if it is not the only thing?
A. I don’t understand your relation to “ extraordinary character.”
I say, and I can only make myself plain by saying, that the only
way [ could determine the character of that work, the work in the
tunnel or the kind of excavation iv the trenches, was to go on the
ground and see it.
62 Q. L appreciate that, but what I want to know is whether
in the statement of the different items there is anything un-
usual or anything ambiguous, or anything that you could not under-
stand at the time that you examined and read the pamphlets—the
printed pamphlets forwarded you ?
A. Well, I certainly could not understand the character of that
excavation of the trenches, as I said before.
Q. You mean by that that you could not tell the character of the
ground before you went over it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Further than that you could fully appreciate it, could you
not?
A. Well, that isa very broad term to say I could fully understand
it. I don’t know as I ain able to say that.
Q. Tell me in what particular you could not understand it; I
want to know something definite about it?
A. Well, I understood in a general way what he wanted done, but
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER KT AL., ETC. 41
I could not understand it definitely enough to make up my mind
about it until I had been over the ground, and had seen it.
Q. ‘To make up your mind about it in what particular ?
A. In relation to the cost of it.
Q. But you understood fully what was wanted by the en-
gineer in the several items, or rather as to the item of earth excava-
tion in tunnelling, did you not?
A. I might understand what he meant by earth excavation, but
I could not tell what the character of that earth was until I got
there. There is all the difference in the world between earth ex-
cavation where it is simply earth and gravel, or excavation of a
sliding clay or anything of that sort.
Recess.
Q. When you read subdivision d of Bin contract No. 2, which
reads as follows: “ For all earth excavations in open trenches
63 or pits, for the masonry and pipe conduit, entrance and over-
flow chambers, gate vaults, blow-offs, pipe overflows, bridges,
railroad crossings, creek crossings, and culverts carried under said
conduit, including bracing and sheeting, back-filling of trenches and
masonry, aking embankments and other final disposal of the ex-
cavated material with haul of 1,000 feet or less, bailing and drain-
ing, and all incidental work,” you understood fully what was meant
by that?
A. Yes, I understood it.
Q. You understood it?
A. I want to qualify my answer. I understood this thing in the
way that an engineer would understand it, but as to its details not
enough to bid upon it.
Q. When you say “as to its details,” do you mean that you have
to acquire a knowledge of the local prices of this work ?
A. No; a knowledge of the character of the work itself.
Q. Of the character of the work itself as it appears upon the
grounds ?
A. Yes.
Q. Otherwise you understood that fully ?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, there was not anything in these specifications but what
you could understand as fully as you could that item which you
have read, so far as you now can recollect?
A. Well, I should reply in the same way as I did in the others.
Q. That you could ?
A. With the modification of the details to be determined upon
the ground ; that is the only way I could answer.
Q. And those things which you designate “ details” are the local
prices and the location of the
A. The location of the line and the character of the material to
be encountered in the work.
Q. Is it not the fact that a great number of the items in either
route A or route B of contract No. 2 are repeated in different forms?
A. They are.
42 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS 4 CLARKE CO. VS.
64 Q. What proportion of them ?
A. Perhaps that question could be answered by getting
the difference in the items. I should say about one-third of them
were changed. I could hardly tell; it requires to compare item
by item to say. They don’t follow the same in each case. *
Q. One-third of the items in either route are a repetition of the
other two thirds?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That is the usual way of engineers to draw up specifications
for the benefit of contractors, is it not?
A. Yes; work is very seldom let without specification.
Q. That is the usual way for drawing up specifications so as to
meet every possible contingency ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. So when you speak of 61 items you do not wish to convey the
fact that it is by any means complicated by reason of that, do you?
A. The more the items the more complicated. Yes; it is com-
plicated by the addition of every item, no more so than every other
specification.
Q. Do you wish to say that the specifications in this matter have
made the work more complicated than it could otherwise be speci-
fied ?
A. That is asking me to pass judgment on the specifications—
whether they are more complicated than need be?
Q. Yes.
A. I don’t know that they are. I did not say that they were.
Q. The first day that you arrived in Rochester was on Monday,
the 19th, I believe ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you consumed that day by examining the plaus in the
office of the engineer?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you make such an examination that you fully understood
them ?
A. Yes; I understood them so far—I should qualify it the same
way—yes; I understood the plans.
65 Q. And the engineer and his assistants gave you all the
assistance that was asked by you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And isit your opinion that you ought to have consumed more
time in the examination of those plans than you did on that Mon-
day ?
A. Not necessarily.
Q. On the second day I believe you walked over the line ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where did you begin your walking?
A. I bezin—I feel my memory fails me as to the station that is
nearest the Rush reservoir.
Q. You began with the Rush reservoir?
A. No, sir; the nearest station to this proposed line.
Q. At Mount Hope?
he
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER FT AI., ETC, 43
A. I don’t remember ; I can’t recall that station.
: Q. Is it Mount Hope reservoir?
3 A. I don’t know. I did not go to the reservoir; I went to the
| station nearest—where the engineer recommended us to commence
the examination of the line; below that was through meadows and
| level ground where there was no special difficulty to be encountered
in the work. But what was the name of the station I don’t know.
Q. You mean a railroad station ?
A. Yes, sir; a railroad station. We went up on the railroad.
Q. Red creek was it?
A. I cannot remember, although you might give the name. I
am not familiar with it, but I know it. With the map at reach I
could tell you where I was, otherwise I can’t.
Q. Well, we will have the map at reach then. I have not got
. that map with me. You walked then from a station uear Roches-
ter to Hemlock lake ?
A. I went up the line to the lake.
Q. And began at some station near Rochester, the name of which
you cannot now remeinber ? |
, A. Yes.
| 66 Q. Who was with you?
A. An assistant in the office.
Q. Was it Skinner? Describe the man if you can.
A. He wasa short, small man.
Q. Thin?
A. Rather thin.
) Q. Light complexion ?
A. That is too much. He was one of Mr. Kinchling’s assistants,
and who had been over the line with other parties. He was sl.ort,
but whether sandy or dark I don’t remember. ‘The engineer of the
Rochester Construction Company was along, and his name I have
forgotten—he is a man engaged in New York here on one of the
| dams of the Croton Co., I think—aund Mr. Peck.
Q. In going over that route, I presume you saw all that it was
necessary to see?
A. I saw all that I could in one day.
4 Was it necessary to consume any more time in that particular
work ?
A. I don’t kuow that it was.
Q. And you arrived at Hemlock lake in time to fully understand
the location of the line?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. On the following day, which was Wednesday, you, I under-
stand, were making up a memorandum to make a bid ?
A. Most of the day with Rantan of the Porter Manufacturing
Company of Syracuse. He was there and went with me over the
-~ manufacturing business. We took that whole day for it,
nearly.
Q. And that was to obtain the price of steel pipes which were
necessary for contract No. 2?
_ A. Yes, sir.
44 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. You did not ascertain the price of anything else from him ?
A. Oh, no.
Q. Did you consume the entire day ?
A. Not all day with him particularly.
67 Q. How much of the day did you consume?
A. | think he left about three o’clock—two or three.
Q. What did vou do after 3 o’cloek ?
A. Busy with the other part, with the other calculations.
Q. What particular part were you busy with after you left him?
A. I can’t tell you—went over the whole thing. I took up the
balance of it and went over it as well as I could.
Q. Give me what line or what particular part ?
A. Starting with the first item and following through, whatever
they were. I took them up consecutively as they came along.
When I came to material I could not determine anything that
could be obtained locally upon; I left that to be examined the next
day, looked over the next day.
Q. These specifieations are divided into the following main heads:
First, the work on excavation
A. There are two kinds of excavation.
Q. Well, I mean general? Second, the masonry; third, the cast-
iron pipe; fourth, the vitrified earthenware pipe; and fifth, the
appurtenances and appliances connected with the pipes; and sixth,
the steel conduit pipe. Is not thata division of the entire specifica-
tions under general heads?
A. You could make it so, yes.
Q. Now, upon which of these heads were you engaged after 3
o’clock on Wednesday, if you can remember ?
A. I can’t remember.
Q. Can you tell me whether you made any inquiries in regard to
the masonry work, the prices of it?
A. I did not go out of my room that afternoon after Mr. Rantan
left. I was busy going over my own memoranda of the day before
as to the character of the ground to see as far as I could what pro-
portion of it was likely to be earth and hard-pan, together making
the two things that were included under “ earth,” to see how far |
had to haul the pipe from different stations and different
68 points to get to the line, how far other material was to be
hauled from the data I obtained the first day ; and with other
matters of that sort, I don’t think, as I remember it now, I went out
of my room in my hotel that afternoon.
Q. So then you were engaged in figuring out vour estimates upon
the data that you received the day before, and those that you re-
ceived from Mr. Rantan on that day ?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you finish that figuring upon Wednesday ?
A. No, sir; I had not finished it even Friday morning.
A. Well, I did not ask you that; I ask you with regard to this
Wednesday ?
A. No, sir.
Q. On Thursday what did you do?
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 45
A. I travelled over the city of Rochester pretty extensively.
Q. For what purpose?
A. Tried to obtain prices on masonry, brick, to see where brick
could be obtained and delivered up there at different points where
brick would be required; and vitrified pipe and other materials
coming into this, and the general character of labor at Rochester
and everything of that kind.
Q. What concern did you eonsult with upon that day for the
purpose of ascertaining the prices of brick ?
~ A. I can’t give you a vame there; I can’t remember names any-
where.
Q. How many concerns did you call on?
A. I could not tell you.
Q. How much of the day did you consume in calling upon dif-
ferent firms for the purpose of ascertaining prices?
A. I was busy with it all day; I did not do any work in my room
that day.
Q. Give me the time?
A. I can’t do it.
Q. Can you state from what time in the morning until any tim
in the afternoon?
A. From the time I got my breakfast until supper.
69 Q. What time did you get breakfast ?
A. I don’t know.
Q. Did you consume the entire time from the time you got break-
fast until supper ?
A. I can’t give you—for pity’s sake, don’t ask me any more.
Mr. Marsuati: Answer as definitely as you can.
The Witness: I can’t tell anything more than that.
(J. Can you tell me whether you consumed two hours or five
hours for the purpose of ascertaining the prices of material and
labor ?
A. I can’t tell youanything more than what I have said, that the
day was used up in outside examination of this thing.
Q. Did you do any figuring up that day at all?
A. I] did in the evening.
Q. How much.+ime did you consume in the evening in figur-
ing ?
A. I went to bed, I think, between 11 and 12—most of the time.
Q. What time did you begin ?
A. I don’t know.
Q. Well, give me your best recollection.
Mr. MARSHALL: As near as you can state.
A. Well, I began as soon as I had finished my supper. I can’t
tell the time when that was. I spent an hour and a half of that
time with some one who called on me at the hotel; it had no refer-
ence to it—but as to that I can’t tell.
Q. An hour and a half with you after supper ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That had no reference to this work at all?
A. No, sir.
46. THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE UO. VS.
Q. And did you receive any other calls during the day, or have
any consultations, or spend any time wit! any other parties with refer-
ence to matters that did not concern this ecutract ?
A. I think I stopped at ose gentleman’s office and did not
70 fiud him in, if I remember rightly—some such thing as
that—I looked for him and could not find him.
Q. You can’t give me the number of places you called upon that
day, Thursday, for the purpose of ascertaining the data ?
A. No, sir; I can’t.
Q. Tell me what portions of the city you went to?
A. I don’t remember where I went. [ don’t know very much
about Rochester as far as streets or parts of the city are concerned.
I simply went to parties that were given me as dealers or handlers
of material, or men who would be apt to be familiar with the prices
of the work. I never made any memoranda of those things, aud I
don’t remember names. I met one man in the street here and don’t
recall his name, although I know him fer 20 years.
Q. Tell me where you called upon these people, whether their
offices were in Powers’ building or any of the other buildings of the
city, or whether you went into the outskirts, and give me the piaces
you went?
A. I could not give you the places. As I remember now, I went
to one stone yard, but I don’t remember that name, and I can’t tell
you where it was. It was not a great way from Powers’ hotel.
. Was it Brady’s ?
. Yes, sir.
. Was it Plymouth avenue and the canal—Brady’s stone yard ?
I don’t know where Plymouth avenue is.
Do you remember it was not far from the hotel?
Yes, sir.
How much time did you consume there ?
I don’t know.
An hour or a half hour?
I can’t tell.
Your best recollection ?
Well, call it an hour.
No more than an hour ?
I don’t know.
Q. Where else did you call on that day? If you can’t
71 give me the name, give me the place?
A. I can’t give you those things. I have no memorandum,
and I did not charge my mind with them at all.
Q. How far did you go away from Powers’ hotel on that day in
attempting to ascertain these values?
A. I can’t tell you that. I have no means of measuring the dis-
tance.
Q. Can you give me any place that you went besides the stone
yard that was near the hotel you have spoken of?
A. No.
Q. And you cannot state the names, or the fact that you called
upon anybody else besides the stone-yard people?
POP>OPOrerorere
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 47
A. I stated the fact that I did call at several places.
Q. Where are those places?
A. I state the same as I did before, that I can’t tell you.
Q. When you speak of “several places” tell me how many you
have in mind?
A. I have said all Icon. I can’t.
Q. Several may mean 10 and it may mean 2. I want you to give
me your recollection of the number of places you ealled on?
A. Well, I can’t give it to you.
Q. Have you any idea of the number?
A. No, sir.
Q. Were they as many as five?
A. I said I had no idea of the number, and I shvuld think that
covers it. I can’t tell you.
Q. Tell me the business that the parties upon whom you called
that day were engaged in?
A. I called upon stonemen, pipemen, vitrified pipe, lumbermen;
I called upon men who had teams—hauling—brickmen.
Q. Anybody else?
A. Don’t remember anybody else.
Q. Can you state now that you called upon anybody else
72 besides Brady for stone, or besides the one near Powers’ hotel
for stone, or for the price of stone?
. I think I did—several houses.
Who else?
. I don’t know.
Well, how many more, then ?
. I dou’t know.
Was it one more?
. I don’t know.
Well, do you know whether you called upon any more?
. Well, I don’t know. If it is necessary for me to say “ I don’t
know ” all the afternoon I will go on.
Q. All right; I don’t care what you say. Now tell me whom or
how many you called upon for brick or vitrified pipe?
A. I have merely the general remembrance that I called upon
them, and I can answer “ I don’t know ” till night.
Q. Can you state as a fact that you called upon any one man for
vitrified pipe?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who was it and where was it?
A. I don’t know.
Q. Do you know whether you called upon more than one?
A. I don’t know.
Q. Can you state the fact that you called upon any one person for
lumber ?
A. I did.
Q. How many did you call upon?
A. I don’t know.
Q. Did you call upon one?
>POrPOPOPO>
48 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. Vs.
A. Yes, more than two. I have got to the end; I don’t know
any more.
Q. Then you have no recollection of calling on more than two
men engaged iu the business of lumber ?
A. I have answered it before as plainly as I ean ; I don’t remem-
ber how many.
Q. Can you say then——
A. I say I did call upon two, but how many more I don’t know.
Q. You have no recollection of calling upon any more?
A. I have no recollection further.
Q. Have you a recollection of calling on anybody for team-
iny?
73 A. I called upon several men who were either owners of
teams, or familiar with work.
Q. Where were they when you called upon them ?
A. I cannot locate them.
Q. How many men have you now a recollection of calling upon
who were in the business of teaming?
A. I could only say one or two men.
Q. Have you any recollection of more than two ?
A. No definite recollection; might have been six; I don’t re-
member.
Q. You have no recollection of more than two?
A. Nothing definite. :
Q. Have you a recollection of the fact of calling upon anybody y
else upon any other business than you have testified to here ? o }
A. I don’t remember whether I did or not. [ took everything [
could think of as having any bearing on what I wanted to find out
and went as far as | could to learn it, but where I went and whom
I talked to J did not consider worth remembering.
Q. And I believe you have stated it is a fact that you cannot tell 4
of any place that you went to except this brick yard outside of |
Powers’. :
A. I can’t tell you the name of a person to whom I went.
Q. No, no; the fact that you went to any place outside of Powers’
hotel on that Thursday besides this stone yard.
A. I told you I went to several lumber parties and men engaged
in brick. I thought I had said it as plain as I could.
Mr. MarsHaLi: And people who did teaming?
The Witness Yes, sir.
Q. That is all you can say about it ?
A. Yes, sir. ‘ 4
Q. There were copies of this contract—of the blank form of con-
tract left in New York at the company’s office when you left on
the 12th? ‘
74 A. No, there were not. There were no blanks left there.
Q. Did you send any blanks from Rochester to them ?
A. I don’t know whether I sent them or whether they were sent-— j
the application had been made and they were sent direct from
Rochester. i
Q. When were they sent, if you know ?
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER KT AL., ETC. 49
A. Ido not know. After I left—or at least they reached there .
after I left.
Q. Had you finished your calculations, or your figuring rather,
on the night of Thursday ?
A. [had gone over the whole ground. There were still some
matters that 1 was uncertain what to do with or what price to put
upon; and I had not tabulated or put into consecutive shape any-
thing on this coutract No. 2, and No. L was in rather a confused
condition.
Q. The main figuring had been gone over, and the only thing
that remained for you to do was to put your prices on the tabulated
form and to consult with Mr. Moffett as to the prices that you had
given ?
A. Yes.
Q. Have him exercise his judgment in regard to it?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, were you in communication with the house in New
York during your stay in Rochester?
A. I suppose—yes, I know I was in communication with them.
Q. Telegraphic or mail communication ?
A. I was telegraphing them to hurry up this bond business, and
my remembrance is that the telegram saying that Mr. Moffett
would be there on Thursday night. I may be wrong.
Q. When did you telegraph to that effect?
A. I don’t remember. I asked for him to be there whenever I
did telegraph—lI don’t know.
75 Q. Do you remember when you asked him to be there ?
A. Lasked him tu be there on Thursday. The date | was
in was on Tuesday.
Q. Your recollection is that you received a letter from him—from
somebody—that he would be there on Thursday ?
A. Tbat he was on his way.
Q. If Mr. Moffett had arrived on Thursday you would have been,
capable of doing those things and making those prices you were
still undecided upon on Thursday ?
A. It would have been done on Thursday night after I came in.
Q. So that the work that you really delayed was due to Moffett’s
delay and tardiness in not coming to Rochester in time?
A. That is the size of it.
Q. And when he did come on Thursday morning, of course every-
thing was in a rush, inasmuch as you were obliged to be there by
12 o'clock Friday noon ?
A. Yes.
Q. The blank form in which the bond was executed and the one
in which the prices were put in were tied together by you, and in
the one you specified that they should be read and considered
jointly % ;
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you submitted them for each contract jointly as one con-
tract?
. Yes, sir.
50 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS @ CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. The fact is, Mr. Burlingame, that in regard to excavations it
is more difficult to ascertain the character of the excavations in the
tunnel than it is in the pipe line?
A. My recollection of that tunnel line is that there could have
been more borings made. I may be off on that, but that is my re-
membrance of it, and that the character of the material was deter-
mined somewhat from the borings. It was impossible in either case,
it was a blind matter to judge with all the examination you could
make of either the pipe line or the tunnel line, because you had so
much in the pipe-line excavation of the character I arrived
76 ~— at before, a sort of hard-pan and loose rock which did not
show upon the surface.
Q. Do I understand you to say that it was quite difficult, more
difficult to ascertain that character of the excavation in the tunnel
contract than it was in the pipe-line contract?
A. It was not a great deal of difference about either one. As I
said before it was blind excepting from the borings that had been
made. Those borings determined as far as they went. We knew
what was there—that is a pretty difficult question to answer. I
don’t know as I could say.
Q. There was as much information given to you on that subject as
there is usually given upon matters of that kind?
A. Yes.
Q. And it was not more difficult for you to ascertain the character
of the excavation than in any other contract?
A. The same, I guess, in either case when you are guessing below
the surface.
Mr. MarsHaL_: Where the excavation is in trench or in tun-
nel ?
The Witness: Yes; your surface indications are not reliable.
Q. Route B was quite high ground, diverting from a straight
line?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Route A was the straight line, but went through a marsh or
low land?
. A meadow.
. On Honeoye creek ?
Yes, several creek crossings.
. How many creek crossings were there?
. I think it is specitied there, five or seven.
. You look it up (banding witness paper).
. Six crossings.
The character of the excavation through the meadows known
as route A was, so far as you could judge at the time that you walked
along the line, liable to have considerable quicksand, wasn’t
OPOPOrop
it?
77 A. It was liable to have. There was nothing visible at
the time.
Q. In making your estimates did not you take into corsideration
in route A that there was a pussibility of quicksand through the
8,000 feet in Honeoye valley?
ea sacra rr ‘
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL, ETC. 61
A. I made no special provision for it.
Q. Is not it a fact that you considered at the time you made
these estimates or prepared this bid that the quicksands were liable
to be in route A?
A. I considered there was liable to be quicksand there, but I did
not consider it a very difficult matter to get over.
Q. And wasn’t it your opinion that there was no quicksand in
route B?
A. I don’t think there were any quicksands there; I remember _
particularly about that—that there were any. I was thinking at
the first part of that there was a liability to some, and I also have
a faint recollection that quicksand had been struck on the borings
on the line of that tunnel. I am very confident that my attention
was called to the quicksand in the tunnel itself.
~ Q. Do you mean the tunnel in route B?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How much of the tunnel was there in route B?
A. It was not very long; the amount of cubic yards is given ;
the account tells you that—the leugth.
Q. Was not the principal part of the excavation in route B open
trench excavation ?
A. No, sir, it was mainly in tunnel—ronte B after it left the other
line until it came back to the other line there was a large amount
of it. The proportion I cannot remember. The tunnel occupied
a fair part of that line, and it was either in clay—the borings
showed clay, and at one end they showed quicksand. They had
not been close enough together to determine what the full material
would be.
78 Q. And your recollection now is that quicksands were
shown by the borings on route B? .
A. At one point in that tannel—that is my recollection of it.
Q. Can you state from the contract how much earth excavation
in open trenches there was in route B?
A. The total?
Q. Yes, as you recollect it?
A. About 180,000 feet, the same as there was in the route.
Q. I mean that part of route B which alternates with route A?
A. No, sir.
Q. How much of that part of route B which took the part of
route A was there to be tur -«lled ?
Rica I cannot remember th: distanee. They are shown upon the
plans.
Q. You had figured upon $.50 per cubic yard for open trenches
excavation during your figuring for this contract, had not you?
A. I had figured that that was a fair price for doing ordiuary
earth and gravel excavation. That is what I had figured it. That
estimate of $.50 was made without consi leration of the extra work
to be encountered in this bid—material which I spoke of before.
Q. Which you designated as hard-pan ?
A. Yes, sir, loose rock.
Mr. MarsHaA.: And the haul?
THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
The Wirness: Yes, sir, including all the items that go to make
up the cost of handling that material.
Q. Did not you include in your figure of $.50 per cubic yard the
haul?
A. The haul under 1,000 feet.
Q. And you considered the haul under 1,000 feet in the compu-
tation or in your figures for the loose-earth excavation and bard-
pan, too, did you not?
A. No, sir, $.50-——
Q. $.70 I say?
A. Oh, $.70 cents. Yes.
79 Q. So, then, the difference between the $.50 and the $.70
was the difference of cost by reason of bard-pan ?
A. Well, I should include quicksand the same as hard-pan on the
other end of the line.
Q. The quicksand, including the hard-pan ?
A. No, but the hard-pan, including the quicksand. It is}about
as hard to excavate where there is quicksand as it is where there is
hard-pan—very little difference in handling the material.
Q. Did you submit your figures to Mr. Moffett ?
A. Not to go over them. We had no time to go over them after
he came.
Q. After having written in your figures in the book, did you look
them over at all?
A. No, sir, I had no time.
Q. Did you make auy correction ?
A. I think I had raised that $.50 to $.75.
Mr. MarsuHatv: $.75?
The Witness: $.70.
Q. Where did you raise $.50 to $.70?
A. In route A.
Q. In route A?
A. That is my remembrance of it. If I did not raise it I had
made it at $.70—had carried it out as $.50 for ordinary work and
then made it $.70, aud I think there was a correction made to that
effect in route A.
. You head first inserted in subdivision D of route A $.50?
. That is my remembrance.
Wrote it out or spelled it out in figures?
. I think so.
And you had also written out in subdivision D of route B $.50?
. The same as I had in the other.
The same as you had in route A ?
Yes, sir.
. That was done before you made the correction of $.70 in
route A ?
A. I don’t think it was. I don’t remember as to how. I don’t
think that I went over the last route B there. I don’t think
80 I had time to compare it or check it with anything.
Q. Can you now remember when you discovered that $.50
in that subdivision of route A was not what you wanted ?
©
OrPOroror
——
53
A. The moment I wrote it. It was not enough. I changed it.
It was not enough. I took the figure from my memoranda of $.50.
Q. The moment you wrote that you discovered you had not
enough and put in $.70 in it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And did you fill out the both of the items in route A before
you filled out any of the prices in route B?
. My remembrance is that I did. I took it along.
Took it along from page to page?
. I think so.
When you came to route D you wrote $.50 in ?
. Yes, sir.
. And left it that way ?
. Yes, sir.
. Did you know what subdivision D of route B was when you
put in $.50?
A. I certainly knew what it was, but I have previously explained
that I wrote this just as fast 2s I could take them from iny memo-
randa, hurrying to get through, and put them just as they were
originally on the pencil memoranda that had been made.
Q. When did you hear on Friday morning of the time that Mr.
Moffett was to arrive in Rochester, if you heard at all?
A. I don’t remember that I heard at all. I was waiting for him
constantly.
Q. You waited for him, asI understand, until 9 o’clock ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And then you concluded that you would make out these
figures without him?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, you made a mistake, as you claim, in item H of route
B, which is earth excavation in tunnel, by inserting $1.50 per cubic
yard?
A. Yes, sir.
81 Q. Do you remember how many cubic yards there were
estimated by the engineer as earth excavation in tunnel?
A. 2,000.
«y. How did you make that mistake ?
A. In figuring up the matter of appliances that were necessary,
taking care of the water and everything in the tunnel, I had made
that by itself. I came then to consider the handling of the mate-
rial and I put $1.50 as ample for digging it out, the men digging
it out. I went on and filled this up without paying any attention
to the general calculation for the appliances necessary to drive that
tunnel. As I read it over, $1.50 seeined a large amount to me, an
amount enough for removing so much earth. I did not give the
matter thought, and did not notice it until after the thing
was over. ;
Q. As I have understood you in your examination here, the
earth excavation in tunnel in route B is about the same as the
earth excavation in tunnel in contract No. 1, is it not?
A. Yes, sir.
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC.
O>rOorOro>
54 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. The work in either is the same?
A. Yes, sir; about the same—a little more favorable perhaps in
the larger tunnel than this because there is more work to be done.
a -' u% more favorable—you mean in contract No. 1 or 2?
. No. 1.
Q. Don’t you remember how many cubic yards of earth excava-
tion in contract No. 1 was to be had?
A. 1,500
Q. And you made a mistake in giving that estimate?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You gave that as a dollar and a half a cubic yard?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And the total amount you made for contract No. 1 was some
$73,000 higher than the next highest bid, was it?
A. No, sir; $58,000.
Q. Is not the next highest bid $415,967 ?
A. Yes, sir.
82 Q. Then your bid for contract No. 1 was some $58,000
more than the next highest bid for that contract?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you claim now that vou made a mistake in the price of
$1 per cubic yard for “item I” in contract No. 1?
A. Yes, sir; I should have made that $10 instead of one. I did
not discover that until I saw this $15. It was another mistake iu
that same one.
Q. Is there any other mistake that you made in contract No. 1?
A. Yes, sir; there is.
Q. What is the mistake that you made in that?
A. There is carried out here, brick-work, $27 a cubic yard. It
should have been $27 a thousand. The calculation was all made
on it, and instead of reducing the thousand to cubie yards it was
left standing at $27 a thousand, and it should have been $18—two-
thirds of that.
Q. That was a mistake that would have offset the mistake you
made on earth excavation in tunnel ?
A. No, sir.
Q. Would not it in part?
A. Small part.
Q. Is there any other mistake that you made in your bid for
route B in contract No. 2?
A. I don’t know; I will see. Except that same $27 carried out
there. It was used straight along.
Mr. MarsHaLL: You mean the brick ?
The Witness: Yes, sir.
Q. Then you made the same mistake in brick masonry, Portland
cement, tunnel and shafts, in route B of contract No. 2 that you
made in a corresponding item of coutract No. 1?
A. Yes, sir; the same figures are right straig) t through.
Q. The mistake in the item of brick masonry, Portland cement,
tunnel and shafts would offset in part the mistake that you made
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 55
in item D of route B, contract No. 2—that is a mistake in the other
direction? -
83 Mr. MarsHA.t: It would be only infinitesimal.
A. It is very small. :
Q. Which means that the bid for the masonry is larger than its
fair value and the bid for item D is smaller than its fair value?
. Yes, sir.
Have you ever-heard of unbalanced bids?
Yes, sir, 1 have a great many times.
You know how to make them, I suppose ?
I never made them.
I did not ask you that?
. I don’t krow how, not practically.
. You know about them ?
. I know that they are made, and I kuow tinat in this case 1 had
no intention of making anything but a straightforward bid; the
mistakes, as an engineer, I am ashamed to own, and I am obliged
to do it.
Q. These things I have called your attention to would be desig-
nated as unbalanced bids, would they not ?
A. If there was anything to be gained by them I would. If there
was nothing to be gained I don’t know what object there would be
in making an unbalanced bid.
Q. There are some other items there which are far above the
value given by the other contractors, are there not? For instance,
cut-stone masonry and copings; you give $50 a cubic yard, and the
next highest bid only $40 a cubic yard ; is not that so?
A. This is another——
Q. Is not that so?
A. My bid is the larger, and I doubt if any one of them could
have put it in for less than $50; $40 to $45 would be the cost of it.
In a bid of that size I would make this explanation, that such small
items as that are seldom figured very closely where there is but a
few of them to be considered.
Q. Is not it the fact that you as a skilled engineer are
84 capable of judging the amount of work as well as the
engineer who furnishes you with the specifications and plans?
A. What do you mean ?
Q. The amount of work, the amount of excavation necessary ?
A. Well, I den’t understand you.
Q. Are not you capable of judging the amount of work by going
over the grounds and taking the borings and taking the dimensions
as weil as the engineer who furnished you with the specifications
and plans?
A. You mean that I could go there, and in one day satisfy my-
self as to a matter that a man with a corps of eight or ten assistants
would take a year to determine.
Q. I mean from that data that he gave you, by the actual meas-
urement whether you are not capable of judging, and whether it is
not a fact that you do base your estimates upon your own judgment
POPOPOPopr
56 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE UO. VS.
rather than upon the judgment of the engineer who furnishes you
with these specifications ?
A. I base my estimate upon my judgment of the character of the
materials, and take his quautities absolute. One day’s examination
could not have satisfied me whether his quantities were right or
wrong.
Q. You wish to say then that you depended upon his quantities
absolutely ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Never exercised your judgment at all?
A. No, sir; in that case I did not question his quantities.
Q. You did not call the attention of the clerk, when contract No.
1 was read, to your mistake which you had testified to in regard to
“item I”?
A. What is that?
Q. Earth excavation in tunnel?
A. No, sir; for I did not notice it.
Q. Did not notice it even then ?
A. No, sir; I did not. I did not notice it when my bid was read
for route B.
85 Q. And the only thing that you noticed and called the
clerk’s attention to, or the parties’ attention to, at the time of
the canvassing of the bids was the item of $1.50 per cubic yard for
earth excavation in open trenches in route B, contract No. 2?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You don’t wish to say that by reason of your not using any
glasses during the work that you made those mistakes ?
A. No, sir; it was due to my confusion and hurry.
Q. You were considerably exercised by the fact that Mr. Moffett
did not put in an appearance ?
A. Yes, sir; and by the fact that the time was getting so near.
Q. And you got uneasy because you did not want to take the re-
sponsibility ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And finally Mr. Moffett put in an appearance, and he came in
so late you could not do justice to the work ?
A. Yes.
Q. What facts were there or what information was there that led
you to believe that these two contracts were to be let as one?
A. We had the general idea that the thing was going together,
that there was a certain amouut of work to be done, that one man
could do the whole thing, or one concern, in better shape than if
there was two or three hands; and merely taking it in a general
way I supposed the whole thing would go together. I had no
knowledge of it specially.
Q. You had received no such information ?
A. No, sir.
Q. There was nothing to intimate to you from the papers that
such was the case?
A. No, sir.
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL. ETC. 57
Q. On the other kand, there was a separate contract for contract
No. 1 and for contract No. 2?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you were particularly requested in the notice to
86 contractors in each of the pamphlets to put your bids in an
envelope, and address them to the executive board sepa-
rately ? re
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And with all that information, and with all these facts before
you, you still came to the conclusion that these two contracts were
to be let as one?
ratty did not come to any special conclusion about it. I sup-
osed.
, Q. You received the impression then that these contracts were to
be let as one?
A. Yes.
Q. You are not in the employ of Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co.
now, are you?
. No, sir.
When did you leave their employ ?
. Last August.
Who have they employed since then ?
I don’t think they lave employed any one.
Why?
. Not in existence.
Have they gone out of business?
. Yes, sir; at least they are in limbo—don’t know what condi-
tion you would call it.
. Well, now, what does that meat ?
A. Well, in the receiver’s hands; we will put it that way.
Q. A receiver has been appoiuted for the company since then ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. You did not notice either, when the bids were canvassed by
the executive board, that you had made a mistake with regard to
the masonry ?
A. I did not notice anything further than that.
Q. $.50 on the earth excavation—is that right?
A. Yes, sir.
POPOPOPO>
©
Redirect examination by Mr. MARSHALL:
Q. So far as the different engineers in the employ of Moffett,
Hodgkins & Clarke were concerned, they had special duties to per-
form ?
A. They had all special duties.
Q. They uever had any experience of bidding on work of this
character? .
A. Some of them had, but not much.
87 Q. And they would not have been of any particular use
to you in the matter?
A. No use to me at all.
58 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Q. And they were also engaged in other matters?
A. They were all engaged at that time.
Q. So far as the quicksand is concerned in route A, did that enter
into your mind at all in fixing the price at $.70 a cubic yard?
A. No; I luoked upon that as about the same thing as the hard-
pan, not making any special difference. I never have had any
serious trouble from quicksand—never apprehended any.
Q. So that the increase from $.50 to $.70 in your original caleula-
tion was not caused by the item of quicksand ?
A. No, sir.
Q. And the quicksand was the same as hard-pan as far as the
difficulties and the cost of handling is concerned ?
A. Yes, sir; the quicksand was but a small proportion of the
whole amount of the work.
Q. When you came to fill in Exhibit 1 A under subdivision B of
route A you had originally written the $.50?
A. Yes.
Q. And you discovered the mistake and corrected that?
A. Yes.
Q. But when you came to subdivision D of route B?
A. Without making any correction. Route B—I had no time to
go over it, or anything else, to see what I had.
Q. And you did your work mechanically ?
A. Yes.
Counsel for the defendants objects to the last answer, and moves
that it be stricken out as leading.
Answer stricken out by consent.
Q. Did you go over these figures at all with Mr. Moffett after you
had written them in?
j A. No, sir.
88 Q. Did you yourself go through them for the purpose of
making any correction or alteration of any portions?
A. No, sir; I had no time.
Q. So far as this unbalanced bid was concerned, what do you
say?
A. There was not the slightest intention. There was gross care-
lessness on my part, confusion or call it what you please. There
was no intention of making any unbalanced bid. There was no
reason for it.
Counsel for the defendants objects to the latter part of the answer.
Portion objected to stricken out by consent.
Q. It was not your purpose ?
A. It was not my purpose at all.
Q. Did you get mstructions from Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke or
any of the officers of that company to put in an unbalanced bid, or
make you figure up on the theory of an unbalanced bid ?
Counsel for the defendants objects to the question as incompetent
and immaterial and calling for hearsay evidence.
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 59
A. I had no instructions from them whatever concerning the bid
at all only to use my best judgment.
Q. You used the expression—you were guilty of gross careless-
ness—what do you mean by that?
Counsel for the defendants objects to the question upon the
ground that the words show for themselves, also as incompetent
and immaterial.
A. I say that I was careless in allowing the bid to go before the
commissioners without my careful scrutiny and guing over it again
to check it up.
Q. And your reason for having dene that was what ?
Counsel for the defendants objects on the ground that it is in-
competent and immaterial and a conclusion and improper evi-
dence.
A. Because I had no time to.
89 Q. In making your calculations and in doing whatever
work you did in this matter did you act in guod faith ?
A. I did throughout.
Q. And did you make every effort to be as careful as you could
possibly be in your figures?
Counsel for the defendants objects to the question as leading, in-
competent and immaterial.
A. I made every effort to.
(Signed) EDWIN H. BURLINGAME.
Mr. MarsHALL: I offer in evidence from the minutes of the ex-
ecutive board of the city of Rochester under date of December 23d,
1892, the following:
“ Proposals for New Conduit.
Proposals for the new water conduit from Hemlock Lake well re-
ceived and canvassed, and action on the award of contract de-
ferred.”
I also offer iv evidence the following from the minutes of the
proceedings of the same body of January 12th, 1893:
“Present: Messrs. Barnard, Schroth and Aldridge.
Mr. Aldridge in the chair.
Communications.
Communication received from Messrs. Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke
Co. was ordered filed.
By Mr. Sc-rorH: Resolved, That the proposal of the Moffett,
Hodgkins & Clarke Co. of New York, N. Y., submitted on Decem-
ber 23d, 1892, for the construction of a riveted steel pipe conduit,
38 inches in diameter, and all the required appurtenances thereto,
commencing at the north end of the contemplated masoury
90 = conduit, near the village of Hemlock Lake, Livingston Co.,
N. Y., and terminating at Mt. Hope reservoir, in the city of
60 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. VS.
Rochester, N. Y., and by route ‘B’ as described in the notice of
letting for said work, be, and the same is hereby accepted, and that
said work be and hereby is awarded to said Moffett, Hodgkins &
Clarke Co.
Adopted.
By Mr. Scurotu: Resolved, That the Moffett, Hodgkins & Clark
Co., of New York, be and they are herewith required to attend at
the office of this board, along with the sureties to be offered by said
company, on or before Thursday, January 19, 1893, and to execute
at that time the contract for the performance of the work of con-
structing a riveted steel pipe conduit, 38 inches in diameter, and all
the required appurtenances thereto by route ‘B’ from the north
end of the contemplated masonry conduit, near the village of
Hemlock Lake, Livingston Co., N. Y., to Mt. Hope reservoir, in the
city of Rochester, N. Y., and that the failure to such attendance and
execution will be regarded as an abandonment of intention on the
part of said Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co. to perform said work.
Adopted.
By Mr. Scurota: Resolved, That the clerk be, and he hereby is,
directed to cuuse immediate legal service of notice of award of con-
tract to be made on the Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co., of New
York, N. Y., in accordance with the foregoing resolutions.
Adopted.”
Mr. MarsHatt: I offer in evidence the notice that was served on
defendants by the Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Co., referred
91 to in the minutes of the executive board last referred to
which is marked “ Exhibit 2,” of March 10th, 1894.
I next offer in evidence the following from the proceedings of the
executive board for the city of Rochester of January 20th, 1898:
“Present: Messrs. Barnard, Schroth and Aldridge. Mr. Aldridge
in the chair.
Minutes of the last meeting approved as published.
Mr. Schroth reported to the board that an equity subpeena, bill of
complaint and temporary injunction was served upon the board
and the city of Rochester in an action in the United States circuit
court, northern district of New York, between Moffett, Hodgkins &
Clarke Co. vs. The City of Rochester and The Executive Board,
praying that the proposals of said company submitted to the board
on the 23d day of December, 1892, for contract No. 2 for construct-
ing a steel-pipe conduit and appurtenances, for the additional water
supply of said city be entirely rescinded, cancelled and declared
null and void, or that said proposal be corrected and amended to
certain particulars thereto named, and enjoining this board and its
agents from declaring the complainants in default with respeet in
such proposal, and from declaring the bond executed on behalf of
said company forfeited, and from in any manner suing upon or at-
tempting to enforce or collect the said bond.”
Counsel for defendants objects to the following resolution, which
is read in evidence by Mr. Marshall as a continuation of the minutes
se
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL., ETC. 61
of the meeting of the executive board of January 20th, 1893, upon
the ground that it is incompetent aud immaterial.
92 Mr. Marshall (coutinuing reading):
“ By Mr. Scuroru:
By virtue of the power conferred upon the executive board by the
charter of the city of Rochester, N. Y., be it—
Resolved, That the proposal of Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus, of
Rochester, N. Y., submitted December 23d, 1892, for the eonstruc-
tion of a riveted steel pipe conduit, thirty-eight (38) inches in diam-
eter, and all of the required appurtenances thereto, commencing at
the north end of the contemplated masonry conduit, near the village
of Hemlock Lake, Livingston county, N. Y., and terminating at
Mt. Hope reservoir, in the city of Rochester, N. Y., and by ‘route A,’
as described in the notice of letting for said work, be, and the same
hereby is, accepted, and said work be, and hereby is, awarded to
said Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus, who are herewith required to
attend at the office of said executive board, along with the sureties
to be offered by said firm, on or before Thursday, January 26th,
1895, and to execute, at that time, a contract for the performance of
the work of constructing a riveted steel pipe conduit thirty-eight
(38) inches in diameter, and all of the required appurtenances
thereto, by ‘route A’ aforesaid, and that the failure of such attend-
ance and execution of said contract is hereby declared an abandon-
ment of intention and a default on the part of said Whitmore,
Rauber & Vicinus to perform said work and execute said contract.
Adopted.”
Counsel for defendants objects to the reading in evidence by Mr.
Marshall of the following resolution, being included in the
93 minutes of the proceediugs of January 20th, 1893, on the
ground that it is incompetent and immaterial.
Mr. Marshall (continuing the reading) :
“By Mr. Scurora :
Resolved, That the clerk of this board be, and he hereby is, di-
rected to cause the immediate legal service of the notice of the award
of said contract to be made on Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus, of
Rochester, N. Y., in accordance with the foregoing resolution.
Adopted.”
Mr. MarsHati: Without going through the minutes wiil you
concede that a contract was subsequently entered into between
Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus and the city of Rochester ?
Mr. Krenev: I object to it as incompetent and immaterial.
Mr. Marsuati: The fact you admit?
Mr. K1iEHEL: Yes. '
Mr. MarsHatv: But its competency and materiality you object to?
Mr. KigtHer: Yes.
Counsel for defendants admits the fact that a contract was entered
into subsequently between Whitmore, Rauber & Vicinus and the
2 THE MOFFETT, HODGKINS & CLARKE CO. V3.
city of Rochester, but objects to the introduction of the evidence
upon the grounds that it is incompetent and immaterial.
Adjourned to March 24th at 10 o’clock a. m.
94 Bg pursuant to adjournment at New York, on March 24th,
Appearances.
Joseph Mullen, Esq., for plaintiff; Louis Marshall, Esq., of coun- (
sel; C. D. Kiehel, Esq., for defendants.
Joun F. Morrett, a witness called in behalf of the complainant,
having been duly sworn, testifies as follows :
Direct examination by Mr. MARSHALL:
Q. Mr. Moffett, where do you reside?
A. In the city of Watertown, New York.
Q. Were you an officer of the Moffett, Hodgkins & Ciarke Com-
pany ? '
A. I was.
Q. In the year 1892, and since that time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What office did you hold ?
A. The office of president.
Q. The Moffett, Hodgkins & Clarke Company is a corporation or-
ganized under the laws of the State of New Jersey ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who was the engineer who was connected with the Moffett,
Hodgkins & Clarke Company who had the active supervision of the
several engineering works done by your curporation ?
A. At what time?
Q. During the vear 1892—which one of your officers ?
A. Mr. E. H. Burlingame was our chief engineer.
Q. Which member, which officer had the general charge ?
A. Mr. Henry C. Hodgkins had general charge, oversight, of the
engineering department of the business.
Q. Mr. Burlingame was what?
A. Was what we term chief engineer.
95 Q. He was a superintendent ?
A. He was an employee.
Q. Superintendent of Mr. Hodgkins? |
A. Yes, superintendent of Mr. Hodgkins. |
Q. When any important work was undertaken or any important
building was done by your concern on public works prior to the
time when Mr. Hodgkins became ill in 1892, who had charge of
that?
A. Mr. Hodgkins did all the general oversight of it.
Q. When did Mr. Hodgkins become ill in 1892?
A. Some time just before Thanksgiving day—it must have been
about November, or shortly after the middle of November.
Q. Was the nature of his illness such as to render hit unable to
attend to his business?
sninrne tesa ieraenesrcecatiimmaeeasill
THE CITY OF ROCHESTER ET AL, ETO, 63
A. Yes, sir; he had typhoid fever.
Q. And in December, 1892, he was not at all engaged in any
work for the company ?
A. No, sir; he was sick at home.
Q. Did you learn, during the month of December, 1892, the fact
that the city of Rochester was advertising for bids upon work con-
nected with its water-works system ?
A. I did.
Q. What, if anything, did you have to do with respect to the
work of preparing bids for a contract?
A. You mean what I had personally to do?
Q. Yes; what was your first connection with it after you learned
of the fact that the city was advertising ?
A. I went to Rochester, and
day that they opened the bids.
Q. Before that had you given any instructions to Mr. Burlingam
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.