Supplemental Brief — The Carib Prince
Supreme Court brief1898
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
INDEX
Statement... ers
History of the Harter Act
Evils remedied by the Harter Act
Poliey of Insurance and bill of lading
Publie Policy in relation to Carriers
What are Latent Defects
Seaworthiness of the Carib Prince
Abstract United States Statutes as to inspection of
vessels for the greater security of life and prop-
erty at sea i: ste Ra eta eee
Abstract British statutes on the same subject...
Table showing increased security to life and property
resulting therefrom. .....00...00...... ,
Decision of the German Imperial Court of Appeals
in the Princess
PAGE,
0
— Supreme Court of the Alnited States.
| |
OcTOBER TERM, 1897.
JosePHINE W. Weprprrnman.
Appellant,
against
No, 45.
THE STEAMSHIP * Carte Prince.”
her Engines, &e.. Ernest
Lecer, Claimant,
Appellee.
SUPPLEMENTARY BRIEF SUBMITTED
BY LEAVE OF THIS COURT IN SUP-
PORT OF THE DECREE BELOW.
Statement
This cause was brought here by certiorari. The decree
of the District Court, dismissing the libel was affirmed
unanimously by the Cirenit Court of Appeals. The ease is
reported in the latter Court, 35 U.S. App., 390, 15 ©. ©.
A., 885, 68 Fed. Rep., 254, and in the former Court, 63
Fed. Rep., 266.
5)
The libel was brought to recover for injury to cargo,
This was occasioned by the breaking of a rivet in the
collision bulkhead, and the consequent leakage of water
from the ballast tank in the forepeak.
The defenses were that the owner exercised due dili-
gence to make the ship seaworthy, and was, therefore,
exempt from liability under the Harter Act, that the de-
fect in the rivet was latent, and, therefore, within the
exceptions of the bill of lading, and that the defect was
not such as to make the vessel unseaworthy.
This brief is submitted on behalf of shipowners not
parties to this record, but interested to support the de-
cree, Leave was granted November 1, 1897.
First.
History of the Warter Act.
1.—The Harter Act, as finally adopted, was not hasty
legislation. It wes the outgrowth of a controversy between
shipowners, shippers and underwriters, that had been
going on, at least since 1880. This had been brought be-
fore the Association for the Reform and Codification of the
Law of Nations; before the Chambers of Commerce and
Exchanges in the great cities of America, England and
Germany. Representations had been made to the British
Government in reference to proposed legislation to settle
the controversy, and bills with a similar object had been
introduced in Congress. The earlier history of this con-
troversy is given in Chapter 3 of Wendt's Papers on
Marine Legislation, 3d Edition.
A careful examination of this discussion as to the form
of bills of lading will show :
1. That the main controversy has been whether the car-
rier should be allowed under any circumstances to exempt
himself from liability for the negligence of the master or
mariners,
2. That no objection has ever been made to exemption
from liability for injury caused by latent defects, if the
carrier use due diligence to discover and guard against
them,
Indeed, it may justly be said that until the decision of
this Court in the Caledonia, it was generally supposed by
commercial men that the carrier was not liable for latent
defects in the hull or machinery, which diligence could not
discover, even though the word, ‘latent,’ was omitted in
the bill of lading.
In the various forms of bills of lading which were pro-
posed by the shippers and commercial bodies which they
had organized in different cities, a clause is to be found
exempting the carrier ‘‘ from any latent defect in hull
or machinery."
See the New York Produce Exchange Bill of
Lading printed in full in Wheeler on Com-
mon Carriers, pp. 350-352.
In all the discussions reported in Wendt, no objection
is made to this clause.
The clause in the Produce Exchange Bill of Lading,
which caused most debate was that which exempted the
carrier from liability for losses occasioned by * negligence,
default or error in judgment of the pilot, master, mariners
or other servants of the shipowners, not resulting, however,
in any case from want of due diligence by the owners of
the ship or any of them, or by the ship’s husband or man-
ager.”’
A Congress assembled at Hamburg, in whieh ship-
ee
oWhers Were not represented, reported that it was inex-
pedient to recommend the adoption of such a clause.
Another, and more representative Congress assembled
later in London, reported in the opposite direction. The
argument on one side and the other may be briefly sum- |
marized thus :
On the part of the shippers it was contended that the
shipper had no voice in the selection of the captain and
crew, and that the shipowner should therefore be respon-
sible for their negligence, and that this would tend to in-
sure greater caution on his part, and that the earriers had
a virtual monopoly of the carrying trade.
On behalf of the carrier it was argued that the selection
of the master and mariners was not altogether in his hands,
that the governments of the different commercial countries
had instituted examinations as to the qualifications of
mariners, and that no person could be appointed to a posi-
tion as officer or engineer who had not passed such an ex-
amination; and that there was no such thing as a monopoly
of carriage by sea. In this respeet transportation by sea
differed from transportation by land. No railroad could
be built without obtaininga charter from the Government,
and without obtaining a right of way in the manner pointed
out by law, whereas anyone could become a carrier by sea
who had the capital necessary to furnish and equip a ship.
In point of faet, a great deal of the carrying trade was in
the hands of independent owners, who competed with the
great lines. And above all the argument was pressed that
there had been a complete change in the conditions under
which the carrying trade was conducted: that in the
nature of the case the owners of ships could not exercise
that personal supervision over persons employed by them
that individual owners formerly could, especially when
(as was often the case) the captain himself was one of such
OWES,
EEE
op TB RN heme Rey <r ak og ITN © +
RE SEL RTE at im ee yaa Far se ig Fs Py
No objection was made, during all the diseussion, to the
insertion of a clause exempting the shipowner from li: ibility
for latent defects, provided due diligence was used in the
inspection of the ship. The point afterwards raised by the
ingenuity of counsel that a “latent defect’? meanta defect
arising after the commencement of the voyage, was never
suggested. Obviously all the disputants assumed that ‘a
latent defect’ meant a defect actually existing at the be-
ginning of the voyage, but not discoverable by due dili-
gence. Where a subject has been so thoroughly canvassed
as was this, failure to suggest an objection is the strongest
possible evidence of approval.
The result of these manifold discussions was the com-
promise embodied in the Harter Act.
Il.—When that Act was introduced in the House of
Representatives in 1892, it prohibited the insertion of this
latter clause. It was drawn in the interest of ship-
pers exclusively. The exemptions in Section 3 of the
bill as introduced, did not help the carrier, for they were
substantially those that existed at common law. An
amendment to the third section was inserted by the House
Committee on Interstate Commerce and Navigation, which
also was really in the interest of shippers. That is to s; ay,
it allowed the carrier to agree ‘* that the vessel m: iv render
services to property in distress afloat, and tow the same to
the nearest and most convenient port of safety, without
incurring penalties for deviation in rendering such
service.”
It had been held that in the absence of such a stipula-
tion it would be a deviation to render services for the say-
ing of property at sea.
It may be noted that the only debate in the House, before
the bill went to the Senate, took place during the morning
hour; that it largely consisted of invective against. the
6
elause common in foreign bills of lading, that the contract
should be judged by the law of Great Britain or of some
other country named therein, interspersed with collateral
remarks as to the advantage of high tariff. It certainly
eould not be called aserious debate upon the merits of the
important questions involved in the bill, and does not
throw the slightest light upon the eonstrnetion to be given
to it.
The bill then went to the Senate, and a full and careful
hearing took place before the Senate Committee on Com-
meree, Before this committee appeared the representa-
tives of the shipowners, shippers, and the underwriters. In-
deed, all the great commercial bodies were represented.
Mr. Frye in reporting the bill to the Senate, stated that in
its amended form it had met the approval of all parties in
interest. and added: ‘* It had the unanimous agreement,
after long hearings, of the Committee on Commerce.”
24 Congressional Record, Part 2. p. 1180.
An examination of the amendments reported by the
Senate Committee and adopted by the Senate (which were
afterwards concurred in by the House) shows that the de-
fect in the language which is to be found in Section 2 as
printed in the Statutes at Large (27 Stat. at Large, 445) is
an error in engrossing. As passed by the Senate, and
finally by the House, the second seetion read as follows :
See, 2. That it shall not be lawful for any vessel trans-
porting merchandise or property from or between ports of
the United States of America and foreign ports, her owner,
master, agent,,or manager, to insert in any bill of lading
or shipping document any covenant or agreement whereby
the obligations of the owner or owners of said vessel fo ex-
ercise due diligence to properly equip, man, provision, and
outfit said vessel, and to make said vessel seaworthy and
capable of performing her intended voyage, or whereby
=_>_~—~" 3 - e ; a R68 RAEI 2 ANN Wea
‘
the obligations of the master, officers, agents, or servants
to carefully handle and stow her cargo and to care for and
properly deliver same, shall in any wise be lessened. weak-
ened, or avoided,”’
Report of Committee, 7/7, 1180.
It is to be observed that when this Court quote the Act
in The Delaware, 161 U.S... 470, they quote it as as it is
thus stated, although the word ¢o is omitted in the printed
Statutes at Large.
Another case (No. 83) is pending in this Court in which
the right of the carrier to limit the amount of his liability is
drawn in question, That question does not arise in this
ease, and nothing further will be said upon it. Irre-
spective of this, what are the provisions of the Harter
Act ?
1. The first section prohibits the shipowner from insert-
ing any agreement whereby he ‘shall be relieved from lia-
bility for loss or damage arising from negligence, fault or
failure in proper loading, stowage, custody, care or proper
delivery, of any and all lawful merchandise or property
committed to its or their charge.”
2. The second prohibits the shipowner from inserting
any clause whereby his obligation to exercise due dili-
gence to equip the vessel and to make her seaworthy, or
whereby the obligations of his servants to carefully handle
and stow her cargo, and to care for and properly deliver
the same, shall be lessened, weakened or avoided.
The concession by the shipper and underwriter in-
volved in this seeond section, is a limitation of the abso-
lute warranty of seaworthiness which existed at common
law, both as to the shipper and the underwriter.
3. The third section provides that if the owner shall
exercise due diligence to make the said vessel in all re-
ee talent
gee
So enact i a i hs tia
8
speets seaworthy and properly manned, equipped and sup-
plied.” neither she nor her owner shall ** be held responsi-
ble for damage or loss resulting from faults or errors in navi-
gation or in the management of said vessel.’’ The elause
declaratory of the common law as to perils of the sea, the
act of God, &e., is retained, as well as the clause that the
vessel may deviate to save property as well as life.
4. The owner is required to issue bills of lading, stating
among other things, the marks and apparent condition of
the goods shipped.
5. The violation of the statute is made a misdemeanor
punishable by fine not exceeding two thousand dollars.
6. The provisions of the statute relating to limitation of
liability by the surrender of the vessel and freight are re-
tained.
~
7. Seetions | and 4 are declared not applicable ‘to the
transportation of live animals.”
It will be seen from this summary of the act that very
important concessions were made by all parties. It is not
surprising that the result, as stated by Mr. Frye, should
have been satisfactory toall parties. The great controlling
fact, so far as the present case is concerned, is that no ob-
jection was made by any of the parties to the controversy,
to a limitation of the carrier's liability for latent defects,
provided the owner shall exercise due diligenee to make
the vessel seaworthy.
Iit.—The libellant’s counsel argues in the second point
of his brief that the exemption from latent defects as
claimed in this case is contrary to the terms of the second
section of the Act, and indulges in some grammatical gym-
nastics to prove that **due diligence’ in that section re-
lates only to the clause ‘tto properly equip, man, pro-
—
LQ RR omeiper erpe tes os
—7"_—
Vision and outfit said vessel.’ The wisdom of the Senate,
however, is commended in adding this limitation of due
diligence to this so-called ‘first obligation to properly
equip, man, provision and outfit.” But it is alleged that
the Senate carefully left the duty of seaworthiness un-
qtulified in accordance with the existing law.
Any defect in equipping, manning, provisioning or out-
fitting a vessel is quite as likely to result in damage to
cargo as a latent defect, and the lack of a sufficient num-
ber of men or of a sufficiently large quantity of provisions
would) be much more likely to result in the entire loss of
the ship than would some trifling defect in the hull. It is
hard to see, therefore, why the same wisdom which ap-
plied the qualification of **due diligence’ to such duties
on the part of the shipowner, should not also extend the
qualification to the obligation of seaworthiness. Indeed,
so far as the reason for the qualification of ‘due dili-
gence”” goes, if it were to be applied to but one class of
duties, Congress would naturally select that class which
was most difficult of absolute performance, and that is
certainly the duty of \*seaworthiness.””. An owner can
always know that his ship is properly provisioned and
sufficiently manned, and such knowledge is much easier
to obtain than it is to find a latent defect. In the former
case you Know what you are looking for, in the latter you
do not.
The very rigor of the requirements placed upon the ship-
owner, as pointed out by the libellant’s counsel, only
strengthens the contention that the Harter Act was in-
tended to change them, and it is difficult to see how this
intention could have been more plainly expressed in the
second section, without making absurd English of it,
[V.—Libellant’s advocate has expended all of his force
upon the second section of the Act, and seems to have
overlooked the third seetion entirely. Whatever argu-
ment may be indulged in as tothe second section it is
impossible to make even a plausible argument on the third,
and it is under that section that the Carib Prince is en-
titled to exemption. There the requirement of exercising
“due diligence’ is first applied to making the vessel in
all respeets seaworthy. It reads :
“Seetion 3. Thatif the owner of any vessel transporting
merchandise or property to or from any port in the United
States of America shall exercise due diligence to make the
said vessel in all respects seaworthy, and properly
manned, equipped and supplied, neither the vessel, her
owner or owners, agent or charterer, shall become or be
held responsible for damage or loss resulting from faults
or errors in navigation or in the management of said ves-
sel.” Ke, :
A fair consideration of that seetion alone shows econ-
clusively how the preceding section must be construed,
and disposes of the entire argument of the plaintiff. The
whole Act should be construed together. No reason can
be assigned for a construction of the second section which
shall make the warranty of seaworthiness absolute, while
under the third only due diligence to make her seaworthy
is required.
\V.—An old petition of the Glasgow Corn Trade Asso-
ciation is quoted to support the proposition that the
exemption of the carrier from liability for a Zafent defect
in hull would be an intolerable evil. But this petition
makes no such complaint. It complains of a clause ex-
empting the carrier from liability for a/77 defects in hull,
This would be unreasonable, and is prohibited by the
Harter Act. But when the shippers, through their Pro-
duce Exchange, formulated a bill of lading, they agreed
PURSUE SOR I ENS E EAE DS LONER NEI ERR TINA EER LISI DONS RISER IROL IR SAE LITMAN MSIE DG EEO
k
-
ES OE RRS SR Be MS ae
11
to the exemption from liability for ‘any /atent defect in
hull or machinery.”
Wheeler on Modern Law Carriers, p. 350.
And the Harter Act cannot be supposed to have gone
farther in its prohibition than the shippers th-mselves
had thus requested.
Second.
Evils remedied by Harter Act.
1.—One cardinal rule for the construction of statutes
is to consider the state of the law before the adoption of
the statute, and the evils which the statute sought to
remedy.
1. It has for many years been well settled that the rule
applicable to the construction of the contract of insurance
in case of loss, differs from that which would be applied
in the case of an action on a bill of lading.
This distinction in effect was this: That in an
action on a policy of insurance, the underwriter would
be liable for a loss, the immediate oecasion of
which was a peril of the sea, although its efficient cause
was the negligence of the master and mariners.
2 Arnould on Insurance, 655.
Orient Ins. Co. es. Adams, 123 U. S., 67.
Waters rs. Merchants’ L. Ins. Co., 11 Peters.
213.
Busk ers. Royal Ex. Ass. Co. 2 B. & Ald... 73.
12
Indeed, it was held by the Supreme Judicial Court: of
Massachusetts, that an insurance against sea perils would
eoyer a loss oceasioned by the barratry of the master,
though this was not specified,
Parkhurst es. Gloucester Ins. Co., 100 Mass.,
30.
On the other hand, in actions on bills of lading, it was
equally well settled that if the efficient cause was the
negligence of the master or mariners, the carrier would
be responsible, although the immediate cause was a sea
peril. The rigor of this latter rule has been somewhat
modified in this Court. It has held that the carrier was
not liable if the immediate cause of the loss was a peril
excepted in the bill of lading. although delay on the car-
rier’s part brought the goods into a place where and at a
time when the peril occurred. i
Railroad Co. rs. Reeves, 10 Wall, 176.
This decision was followed in
The R. D. Bibber, 2 CC. CL A. 50, 30 Fed.
Rep., S41.
In aeeord with these decisions are
Denney rs. N.Y. Central R. R. Co. 1s Gray,
41.
Hoadly rs, Northern Transp. Co.. 115 Mass.,
304.
Michigan Central RoR. es. Burrows, 33
Mich., 6.
But. nevertheless, there were numerous cases, pointed
out in these decisions, in which it was held that a sarrier ie
might be liable to the shipper for a loss of goods ocea- :
sioned by the negligence of the mariners, when he himself Zi
4
pag
ChE FETE HON Ko SRRREM SY 5 INS ene — "
Ba at fis LENE AF ON OOO I GIP ERM GEE OI OT II LY OCI RM SY
adi Sie Sc Un
13
could recover upon a policy of insurance upon the vessel,
caused by the same negligence,
On the other hand, there were cases of latent defects
where the underwriter, having paid a loss upon cargo, was
subrogated to the right of the owner of the cargo to re-
cover against the carrier, although neither the latter nor
his servants had been negligent in any particular.
2. The question in suits on bills of lading for damage to
cargo, is really one of insurance. At common law the carrier
was an insurer against all losses except those arising from
the act of God or the public enemy. The development of
the business of Insurance Companies has greatly increased
the security of shipowners. Their policies not only cover
losses arising from those perils for which the earrier was
not liable at common law, but also many others for which
the carrier was liable. This not only gives the shipper a
complete remedy, but affords protection against insol-
vency of the carrier, or his taking proceedings to limit his
liability by the surrender of his interest in the ship and
her freight then pending. This development produces a
condition, not only of greater security, but of greater jus-
tice than the common law of carriers produced.
3. There were many instances of great hardship at com-
mon law. The carrier often suffered enormous loss, suffi-
cient sometimes to produce insolvency, without any actual
fault on his part. No better illustration of this could be
furnished than the present case. It is undisputed and indis-
putable, that in the construction and equipment of the
Curib Prince no expense or pains were spared. Compe-
tent ship builders were employed, and thorough inspec-
tion given. The ship was chartered and the charterer en-
gaged the officers and crew. If there was any defect of
inspection subsequent to the ship's sailing from England,
it was the fault of servants who were never employed by
the shipowner. Yet here it is sought to make the owner
and the ship responsible for such neglect.
14
On the other hand there are many cases of gross negli-
genee from which no injurious consequences follow. The
effect of the rigorous enforcement of the common law
liability of the earrier and of the striet construction of
statutes passed for his relief, is therefore subject to two
criticisms: [Tt punishes the innocent, and it does not pun-
ish the guilty.
Undoubtedly the original tendeney of the decisions is
shown in some of the quotations on the appellant's. brief. g
A severe responsibility was imposed upon the earrier. i!
The Courts carried to the farthest extent the rigorous ©
Warranty of seaworthiness which they implied. As earry- &
ing trade has inereased and the nations have realized its i
importanee and the greatness of the public benefit és
whieh it produces, their policy has been gradually —
assuming a different form. For years this has been E.
in the direction of more careful inspection and more —
rigid requirements as to the manning, construction
and eqnipment of vessels. In this way seaworthi-
ness is secured in advance, which is certainly more
for the public interest than the imposition of a pun-
ishment for the failure to secure it. Itisthereforeequitable |
and just and in aceordanece with public poliey that the |
Legislature, while imposing rigorous requirements upon
builders and owners of ships, should provide that if they
exercise due diligence to make a vessel seaworthy (which
implies by necessary inference a strict compliance with the
requirements of statutes as to the manning, construction
and equipment of the vessels) they should be relieved from
the rigor of the common Jaw warranty of seaworthi-
hess. r
In view of the hardship often resulting from the appli, |
eation of the warranty of seaworthiness, the Harter
Aet introduced a much needed reform. Tt cannot se-
riously be contested that its provisions are not as bind-
ing upon the underwriter as they are upon the shipper and
ITE ESRI AIG TR ET I TIES ae WA ROBO G NL MEER, IB PSR RE St ZI A AB GT DON CRON
15
the shipowner. In view of the provisions of Seetion 2, if
the Court should construe them in accordance with the
argiments before mentioned, which are simply a_ state
ment of their plain language, an underwriter certainly
could not set up as a defense to an action against him
upon policies of insurance upon the cargo, that there was
a latent defect in the ship when she broke ground for the
voyage, for which the owner would not be liable under
this aet.
On this same principle, that an Act like the one under
consideration is effective to modify all relations to which,
by reasonable implication it applies, it is held that in. sal-
vage cases the value of the cargo on the salving ship need
no longer be considered, because the Harter Act allows
deviation for salvage.
The Alaska, 75 Fed. Rep., 430 (Benedict, J.).
The Florence, 65 Thid. 248 (Brown, J.).
I1.—Libelant argues that, regardless of the Harter Act.
a vessel must be absolutely seaworthy at the time of. sail-
ing, quoting from The Caledonia, 157 U.S... 124. at page
137:
As is well said by counsel for appellee, the exceptions
inacontract of carriage limit the liability, but not the
duty of the owner, and do not in the absence of express
provision protect the shipowner against the consequences
of furnishing an unsenworthy vessel.”
The fact should not be overlooked that the Harter Aet
Was passed after the decision of the Caledonia, and its
wording was unquestionably influenced by that decision.
By that Act the *\express provision’ which was absent in
the Caledonia, was intentionally supplied in Seetion 3.
Where it is provided “that if the owner of any vessel
* * * shall exercise due diligence to make the said
vessel in all respects seaworthy and properly manned,
equipped and supplied, neither the vessel, her owners, ete.,
shall become or be held responsible. * * *”
The most important question which the Court has to
decide in this case is whether or not the Harter Act has
mitigated the severity of the requirement imposed by the
Culedonia, and that case cannot be cited in this connection
to prove that the Carib Prince is liable, without begging
the question.
16
= + Nel a Te AOR,
Pee We i Se
Third.
Policy of Insurance and Bill of Lading.
In practice the policy of insurance goes with the bill of
lading; and the draft drawn against the proceeds of the
goods, on which the banker makes his advances, is secured
by both. Sometimes the insurance is expressed to be
‘with all liberties as per bill of lading,” or other equiva-
lent words. But in practice the underwriter, as between
himself and the assured, treats the policy as if it were so
expressed, and pays the loss and sues the carrier, if he
thinks there is any claim maintainable against him. This
is what was done in
The Phenix Ins. Co. es. Liverpool & G. W.
8.8. Co. ; The Montana.
22 Fed. Rep.. 715, 129 U.S., 397.
Frequently the suit is brought in the name of the shipper,
but the underwriter is the real party in interest.
It is certain that as soon as the construction of the
Harter Act is settled the customs of commerce will con-
form thereto. The insurance companies make it) their
business to insure against risks. This is what they are
paid for. Out of this they make their money. Tf this
DARE
Court hold that the true construction of the Harter Act is
to limit the absolute warranty of seaworthiness implied at
common law, so that it becomes a warranty of due dili-
gence, the risk arising from latent defects, not discover-
able by due diligence, will be borne by the underwriters,
Such their practice has already become, and such it will
continue,
Fourth.
Public Policy.
I.—The quotation is often made from the Peeside, 2
Sumner, 567, 575, that ‘every relaxation of the common
law in relation to the duties and responsibilities of the
owners of cargo ships, is founded in bad policy, and detri-
mental to the general interests of commerce.”
This statement of Mr. Justice Story, like most univer-
sal statements in regard to publie policy, is to be taken
with many deductions and limitations. It is impossible
to say that the policy of one generation must necessarily
be the poliey of another. Enough has been already said
to show that this Court in dealing with cases relating to
carriers, as well as other cases, will recognize the force of
the ancient maxim: * Cessante ratione, cessat et ipsa
ler” "This was well expressed by Lord TENTERDEN in
Stone rs. March, 6 Barn. & Cress.. 551:
* The rule is founded ona prineiple of publie poliey, and
where the public poliey ceases to operate, the rule shall
cease also.”
In Nichols rs. Eaton, 91 U.S... 716. 726.
this Court held that the poliey of the English law as to
ay
Is
the right to set apart property for the use of another, free
from the claims of his ereditors, had been changed by the
general tenor of the statutes of various States of the
Union, limiting the common law rights of ereditors, and
would no longer be enforced by American Courts of
equity.
So the Court of Appeals of New York in
DeWitt es. Barley, 9 N. Y., 371,
held that the change in legislation in regard to evidence
had changed the rule excluding evidence of the opinions
of witnesses.
In the ease of common carriers, legislation has made
great changes. The Act of Congress of March 8, 1851, 9
U.S. Statutes at Large, 635, adopted the rules of the Law
Merehant in reference to the limitation of liability of ship-
owners, to the amount of their interest in’ the vessel and
her freight then pending.
In
The Scotland, 105 U.S. 24,
this Court held that the efficacy of this rule in the United
States ‘depends upon the statute and not upon any in-
herent force of the maritime law.” But it) gave a liberal
construction to the statute and held that it applied to
foreign as well as to domestic vessels. This act has been
re-enacted by the Rev. Stat. Section 4282 to 4289.
The langnage of this Court in Providence & N. Y.S.8.
Co. rs. Hill Mfg. Co., 109 U. S., 578, 588, in reference to
the limited liability act, is especially applicable to the
ease at bar:
-- In these provisions of the statute we have sketched
in outline a scheme of laws and regulations for the benefit
of the shipping interest, the value and importance of
which to our maritime commerce can hardly be estimatect.
Nevertheless, the praetieal value of the law will largely
depend on the manner in which it isadministered. If the
bea Sots se y reap f = one
#2 Bie SENS RIEL RSD IER WOT ARN MT EN PUR AES OVI A AE IEE AL OTA Ri NE ing ik Yt AY
W
courts having the execution of it administer it in a spirit
of fairness, with the view of giving to shipowners the full
benefit of the immunities intended to be secured by it, the
encouragement it will afford to commercial operations (as
hefore stated) will be of the last importance ; but if it is
idministered with a tight and grudging hand, construing
every clause most unfavorably against the ship owner, and
allowing as little as possible to operate in his favor, the
law will hardly be worth the trouble of its enaetment.”’
Of the same statute the New York Court of Appeals
said in Chamberlain rs, Western Transportation Co.. 44
N. Y., 305, 309:
* This is not in any sense a penal statute, nor is it in
any way derogatory to natural right, and hence I know of
no rule of law that requires that it should be strietly
construed, It is true that it changes the common law,
but there can be no reason for applying the rule of striet
construction to the vast body of statute laws which change
the common law. The prior law, whether it be statute or
common law, is to prevail, unless the subsequent statute,
by a fair and proper construction, repeals or modifies it.
This statute is rather a remedial statute. It was enacted
to remedy the rigor of the common law, which it was
deemed unwise, on grounds of publie policy, to continne.
It should, therefore, be construed, if not liberally, at least
fairly, to carry out the poliey which it was enacted to
promote.”
In pursuance of this liberal policy, this Court has held
that the claimants against the shipowner are not entitled
to have the amount of any insurance on the vessel or
freight, ineluded in the stipulation for value.
The City of Norieieh, 18 UL S.. 468, 493.
The Scotland, (V8 U.S... 507.
I].—In all the eases which have been decided in the
Circuit Courts of Appeals and in the Distriet Courts, the
20
Harter Act has been treated as an act passed in pursuance
of wise poliey, and to be liberally construed.
The Silvia, 64 Fed. Rep., 607; affd., 15 C. C.
A., 362, 364; 68 Fed. Rep., 230,
The Viola, 60 Fed. Rep., 296, 298.
The E. A. Shores, Jr., 73 Fed. Rep., 342.
The Etona, 64 Fed. Rep.,880 ; Affd. 71. 7hid.
895: S.C, 38 U.S. App. 150, 18; C.C. A.,
880.
This Court is now to decide whether it will enforce the
statute of the Congress of the United States as adopted, in
the spirit in which it was passed, according to the natural
construction of its language, or whether it will by a
strained and unnatural construction, limit the benefits
whieh that Aet was intended to secure to American com-
merece. Great Britain and the nations on the Continent of
Europe allow the insertion in bills of lading of clauses
similar in effect to that now contended for. The final
debate on the Harter Act in the House shows that the
Act was passed in view of this fact, and to give to
American commerce the same freedom of contract enjoyed
in other countries.
24 Cong. Record, Part 2, pp. 1291, 1292.
If1.—The question of policy was certainly one that
Congress could determine, and has, we think, determined.
But if this question were now to be determined by this
Court. should it not hold that prevention is better than
punishment 2. The common law undertook to prevent
carelessness in the equipment of vessels by the owner,
by a pecuniary mulet whenever injury was caused by
such carelessness. Modern legislation undertakes to pre-
vent negligence by rigorous requirements as to the con-
struction of vessels, by careful inspection of them from
time to time by official inspectors, and by a rigid examina-
tion of the officers and engineers of sea-going vessels. The
rigor of these requirements has been progressively in-
PIA RPSL HEH BT Ca SR Be RRR NS a A Nps LST RUM TS AID OME SRG EWS SHER RESET MRAP MAE ENE SILANE TS
|
SS ER Fs in ek oan Ng
21
creased both in England and this country. The carrying
trade of England is far in excess of that of all other eoun-
tries in the world, and Parliament has not been backward
in recognizing this fact and in exacting from shipowners
and shipbuilders, full peformance of the duty which this
great commerce imposes,
An abstract of some of the American and English
statutes on this subject is appended to this brief.
IV.—It is argued that the bill of lading ‘:is the mea-
sure of the responsibility, but not of the duty,” of the
carrier. The duty is fulfilled when all reasonable diligence
isused. It isa matter of public interest, and is enforced
specifically by legislation.
The result of the legislation on this subject, enforced
as it has been by the enterprise and publie spirit of the
great shipbuilders and shipowners, has been to produce a
remarkable decrease in the loss of life and of prop-
erty at sea and to give to travelers by sea afar
greater security than the former policy of the Jaw
produced. Every ocean traveler, whose — experience
covers twenty years knows something of the improvements
in steamers. The analysis of official reports, which is
given in the appendix to this brief, shows the satisfactory
and remarkable results.
Thus it has turned out that the experience of a whole
generation is wiser than Mr. Justice Story, and that the
method which he thought best has proved to be inade-
quate, while another, which he never thought of, has been
developed and applied. It might as well be said that no
method of propulsion or construction of vessels would
ever be discovered that should be better than the clippers
of Judge Story’s time, as to say that public policy in ref-
erence to common carriers could never be wisely changed.
He knew nothing of collision bulkheads, of twin serews, of
a
22
iron and steel ships, or of the statutes for the inspection
and examination of ships before and after they are com-
pleted.
Indeed when that learned lawyerand great Judge died,
the propulsion of vessels by steam was in its infaney, and
seagoing vessels were usually owned by individuals, and
commonly commanded by one of the owners. The enor-
mous development of the carrying trade in the last fifty
years has led to different legislation and a different
poliey. It was well enough for him to enforce caution in
the only manner whieh lay within his power, but a better
method has now been devised. There would certainly
seem to be little justice in refusing at the present day,
to allow a shipowner to exempt himself from defects
whieh ean not be brought to light by the system of
Government examiners, and by the many preeautions which
he as foreed by law to take. It would certainly be poor
public poliey to make the carrying trade so hazardous as
to drive people out of it, or discourage the investment of
capital in it.
Fifth.
What are Latent Defects
1.-—The libellant claims that latent defects can mean only
such as could not have been originally discovered, even by
the shipbuilder, and that ‘*defects must exist which no
skill ean detect, and the effeets of which no foresight can
avert.” If this argument is logically carried out, it must
mean that even if a ship has changed hands a dozen times
the last owner is responsible for defects which might pos-
sibly have been discovered at the time of construction,
but whieh he ean only discover by tearing the ship. to
REAP ORAS SN REL MOS OES WRT HOI PREG ait ee “ eer ty ae
a <G ve
23
pieces. If such is the law there is no safety for the pur-
chasers of ships, no matter how careful they may be.
They could never know whether they were laying a basis
for future profits or future liabilities. The old maxim of
“eareat emptor” would become applicable ina very new
sense. Moreover, there is no such thing as a defect which
* yo skill can detect and the effeets of which 0 foresight
can avert.” An owner can always hire an expert to tear
his ship to pieces. The Caledonia’s shaft might have been
subjected to such a test strain that the flaw would have
been exposed.
To prove the validity of the above definition of latent
defects cases are cited, in which it is claimed that this is
the well-settled definition. But they do not support the
proposition.
Indeed, the libellant’s advocate throughout his entire
brief has sought to prove his contention by the use of the
briefest possible quotations, many of them from insurance
cases, in which of necessity the rulings would be different
from cases of the present nature. His position is proved
by these citations in the same way that any proposition,
good or bad, could be upheld by the best authority in the
world, if isolated sentences were to be taken without re-
gard to the facts of the case in which they were stated, or
the context in which they appear.
If.—When the locomotive was invented and the liability
of the carrier of passengers by land became the subject of
consideration, Courts were much impressed by the danger
to which this new method of propulsion exposed the lives
and limbs of passengers. They did not apply the rule
which had for centuries made the carrier of goods an in-
surer against all damage except that caused by the act of
God or the public enemy. But they did establish what
was avowedly a very rigorous rule; to wit, that the ear-
a
24
rier of passengers Was liable for all injuries against which
the highest degree of human skill and foresight could
have guarded. This rule was not based upon any deti
nition of the phrase ‘latent defeets.”” It did not deal
with the question as to freedom of contract. It was the
law governing the earrier’s liability in the absence of a
special contract. It was based upon the necessity of pro-
tecting lifeand limb. Hence these decisions do not touch
the point. Weare dealing with a contract: of exemption
from injury caused by latent defeets. We have already
shown that the Harter Act does not make this illegal.
And we must now consider what it means.
In the Century Dietionary the phrase under considera.
tion is thus defined :
* Larent. —Hidden, concealed. not visible or apparent,
not manifested.”
It quotes among others the following :
To evoke the /afenf genius of the nation, and to direct
it to the spheres in which it is most fitted to excel, is one
of the highest ends of enlightened statesmanship.””—
Lecky, England in Eighteenth Century, 111.
*Larent Fauci, in 7a a blemish or defeet in goods
purehased which was concealed from or not observable by
the buyer before acceptance of the goods.”
In none of these definitions and illustrative quotations
is the suggestion made that “latent’’ means that which
cannot be discovered by any amount of investigation.
Literally the word means hidden. — It is implied in the
ordinary use of the term, that what is hidden may be dis-
covered. In the quotation from Leeky, this is done by the
venius of the statesman. In all the quotations there is the
suggestion of a possible discovery. In short, latent means
that whieh is concealed, but may possibly be discovered ;
although ordinary observation would fail to bring it to
light.
Eg RW Ye RA ee II eh = <i gn aay Ae RT RL pe gic) RE OY AIS OT OE YATE PRET Te Aes Pp stiat tpt —
25
II. - The aet prohibits a clause lessening the obligation
to use due diligence. The proof shows this was used. In
short, to sustain the exemption so far as the Bill of Lading
is concerned we need only to show that the defeet was eon-
cealed. To sustain it under the Act of Congress, we must
prove that it was not discoverable by due diligence.
The latter is proved by the original and most thorough
inspection in London in the spring of 1893, and by a less
thorough, but equally careful examination by the Chief
Engineer Keeys, in August, 1893, after the hurricane (pp.
44, 45, fols. 180-133). He says the defeet was not ** dis-
coverable by inspection” (p. 45, fol. 133).
IV.—The argument is presented that ** latent “> means
that which had no existence at the beginning of the voyage,
bat was eansed afterwards by a sea peril, like the strain-
ing of a mast, by a storm, invisible externally. To this we
reply :
(7.) No exemption by contract is needed for injury
from such a souree. It would be a loss caused by a sea
peril, for whieh the earrier would not in any case be
liable.
(4.) This construction does not deal with the contract
as made. It makes one. It adds qualifying words not in
the contract at all. The words used are ‘+ Aecidents to or
latent defeets in hull” A defeet is just as latent at the
beginning of the voyage as when it is caused by a subse-
quentinjury. Latency is one thing, time when it is eansed
is another and quite a different thing. A Court has power
to declare a contract invalid. It has no power to make a
contract for the parties. © Yet that is what libellant must
do to succeed in this contention,
ve) The imphed warranty of seaworthiness extends to
the time when the vessel actually breaks ground for the
a
26
voyage, and not merely to the time when she begins to
tuke in cargo, The libellant’s quotation from
The Bugene Vesta, 28 F. R., 762,
states this proposition. Mr. Justice Brown there said :
* The theory of the law is that the implied warranty of
senworthiness shall proteet the owner of the cargo until his
poliey of insurance commences to ran.”
To the same effeet is
Bowring es. Thebaud, 56 FL R.. 520,
The exception of liability for latent defeets relieves the
shipowner from the implied absolute warranty of seaworthi-
ness, and if the implied warranty, without the exception,
would attveh immediately on placing the goods on board, a
reasonable construction of the exception can only be that
it. too, Was meant to become Operative at the same time.
No owner realizing that his liability apon an implied war-
ranty of seaworthiness began when the first bale of goods
was placed upon his ship, would make a contract whereby
his exemption from that liability was only to begin several
daaws later,
Vo The bill of lading is attaeked as an *tineoherent
and illogical document,” ‘teareless and slovenly“; and,
therefore, presumptively, to be disregarded. But, what-
ever justice there may once have been in’ this eriticism
upon old forms of bills of lading, it ean have no appliea-
tion to the form in this ease whieh is the result, as has
been shown, of most careful consideration on both sides.
The shippers have formed corporations, and have the
power that comes from united action, They have appealed
both to Courts and Legislatures, and obtained bills of
lading satisfactory to themselves, earefully drawn, and
explicit in language.
4 ~ a "Wy
Ne NS MS EAI HE EPI RT fe OETA A eater a ey
Sixth.
Scaworthiness of the Carib Prince.
The argument thus far has proceeded on the assumption
that the Caréh Prince at common law would have been
held to be not seaworthy. It is desirable certainly that
this Court should express in this case its opinion upon the
question arising on that assumption. But we do not atall
admit that the Carih Prince was not seaworthy,
I.—Seaworthiness is detined by this Court to be © fit-
hess to perform the voyage whieh her owners had under-
taken that she should perform safely, with the exceptien
of the unavoidable dangers of the river and of tire.”
The Northern Belle W Wall, 526. 529.
In the Caledonia, V7 UL S.. 124. the Court quote with
approval (p. 131) the statement by Parsons, 1 Marine Ins..
367 :
* Every person who proposes to any insurer to insure
his ship against sea perils, during a certain Voyage, im-
pliedly warrants that his ship is in every respect, ina
suitable condition to proceed and continue on that voyage,
and to encounter all common perils and dangers’ with
safety.”
Under these definitions the Carib) Prince was seawor-
thy. Even assuming that the rivet was broken when she
siiled from Trinidad, she was undoubtedly sound for the
Voyage. The defeet, if it existed then in the rivet, was
hot a defect that interfered in any way with her being
tight, sound and staunch for the voyage.
To amount to unseaworthiness a defeet must be sneh
that the vessel is really not worthy, in. the judgment of a
reasonable man, to go to sea. Every little defeet does not
make a vessel unseaworthy, even though it may result in
—y
damage to the cargo. For instance, suppose that the fresh
water tank of the Carib Prince instead of the ballast tank
had been defective, a leak in it might well have injured
some of the eargo, just as the leak in a small tank in a
passenger's stateroom might injure his baggage. But
neither of these leaks, nor the actual one in the ballast
tank of the Carib Prince would have rendered the ship
untit for navigation. The most that could have happened
was that the tank should have been emptied, and its entire
eontents run through hold No. 1. It would then have
worked its way into the bilges, and been removed by the
pumps, without at any time or in any way endangering
the existence of the ship, or rendering her diffienlt to
manage. Tnother words, no defeet can be said to render
a vessel unseaworthy unless the maximum amount. of
damage whieh ean be caused by that defeet would render
the vessel unseaworthy. Defective plating, an insufficient
erew or an ineorreet compass render a vessel unseaworthy,
only beeause with such defeets she cannot be safely
YS
navigated,
The decision of the German Imperial Court of Appeal
in Civil Cases in the Princess, of which a copy is annexed,
supports ths proposition just stated,
The injury to the eargo was caused by the act of the
Master in pumping water into the fore peak. This act of
his was not necessary inany respect for the safety of
the ship. It was simply availing himself of a econ-
venience that had been provided in. the vessel. The pro-
position may be tested by the question, Would the ves-
sel have been seaworthy if she had not been provided
with 2 ballast tank in the fore peak? Obviously, she
would. It no doubt might be sometimes convenient,
and tend, as the captain testified, to produce a better
speed, to trim the ship by the addition of water to
this ballast tank. But it eannot be said that a failure on
ESAS ERE SNES TERRA EES Bo eee a Ae AP ETO et inn BH opssmmmyssnages” TPE
20
the part of the captain to fill this tank before the ship
sailed made her in any respect unseaworthy. The case is
really analogous to the porthole cases which have been
decided in England and this country, and in which the
Courts of both countries have agreed. It has been held
that if a vessel sails with an open) porthole she is not
therby rendered unseaworthy, provided that the state of
the weather at the time she sails is such as to make the
opening of the porthole convenient and proper. The duty
of the master would be to cause the porthole to be closed
if bad weather should ensue. But the fact that the port-
hole was openat the time of sailing, when there was no
bad weather, does not make her unseaworthy.
The Silvia, 15 CC. A., 862, 68 ee Rep. 230.
Steele es, Steamship Co., 3 App.. Ca.. 72.
So in Headley es. Pinkney & Sons, 8. 8. Co... App.. Ca.
(1804) 222, the House of Lords held that a vessel which
had on board when she sailed, appliances suitable to pro-
tect an opening in the bulwarks, was not rendered unsea-
worthy by the failure of the master to put them up.
II.—In the ease at bar it is clear that the vessel was ses-
worthy when she broke ground upon her voyage. When
such is the ease it is equally well settled that the warranty
of seaworthiness does not extend to her subsequently
becoming unseaworthy, even though this be caused by the
negligence of the Master. The rule is thus stated in
Arnould on Insurance, Vol. 2 pp. 640, 642 :
‘It is enough to satisfy this warranty if the ship be
originally seaworthy for the voyage insured when she
sails on it. There is no implied warranty that the ship
shall continue seaworthy in the course of it. * Every ship?’
says Lord MANSFIELD, * must be seaworthy when she first
sails on the voyage insured, but she need not continue se
throughout the voyage” * * *
_— Se a ane AGAIN ESS SRR IN SONA ERNE RE IS NSD OREN NR aE RNAI ea in ee
‘ 3 a ROME RAE, acter em sie eens
30
“Tt makes no difference whether the state of unsea-
Worthiness be occasioned by the negligence of the master
and erew or of other parties employed by the assured upon
the business of the ship in the usual course of trade.”
IH.-——Libelant’s counsel has disregarded the testimony
that the bolt may have been crystallized by hammering,
which would make the defect a latent one even within his
own construction, and argues at great length from the testi-
mony which it isalleged proves that the broken bolt: was
improperly put in place That testimony, however, and
the lurid quotation in the appendix, are of absolutely no
force when construed in connection with other facts in the
ease.
Had the break in the bolt been eaused by the faet that
the bolt holes in the plates of the bulkhead did not. coin-
cide, the break would have been at the centre of the bolt,
and not at the end. When the red hot bolt was welded,
any Weakness in it must have been developed on the plane
Where the plates touehed, as that would have been the
point of the smallest area, and when any strain was
brought to bear against the plates, if this laek of coinei-
dences in the holes was increased, the result would) have
been that in changing their position, even slightly. the two
plates would have aeted like blades of shears, and eut the
bolt off clean, as frequently happens when a vessel goes
on the rocks. In this injury, however, the welded head of
the bolt was snapped off atthe end and the bolt was not
entin two at the centre. That facet indicates most clearly
that when the tank was being filled, the momentum of the
water thrown against the bulkhead by the pitching of the
ship sprung the entire bulkhead inward towards hold No. 1.
Such a bend in the plane of the plates would of necessity
tend to draw the bolts to a greater length, and break off
the welded heads when the limit of elasticity was reached.
In this connection it is a very significant fact that the
, Sy R NET LM DIY IE cg P GINA OMIT ELIE PORIT OIND SO pEnot cay atae see he
PALIT I LOE LEBEL SSPE : ;
—
31
bolt broken in this case was the one in the row farthest
from the side of the ship, where the springing of the
plates would have been through the greatest distance, and
the consequent pressure brought upon this bolt more
severe than that upon any of the others nearer the side of
the ship. It is only in this way that such a fracture of
this bolt could have been made. In view of Congdon’s
evidence that he has seen an entire bulkhead knocked flat
upon the ship’s bottom when a tank was filled at sea, this
broken bolt beeomes the most natural result (p. 133, fol,
308).
But even granting all of the facts urged by the libel-
lant that the bolt was defective, and that the bolt holes in
which it was placed were imperfeet, the testimony remains
unquestioned that this bolt was, in spite of those facts,
stronger than was required by Lloyds’ Register. and
capable of standing a greater strain than any master hada
right to put upon it. The libellant’s own contention, and
that of W. Clark Russell, is to the effeet that the strength
of the bolt was lessened when it was driven in. Neverthe.
less it was still strong enough to stand the water test
which was applied, in which the pressure was greater than
it could ever be with the tank absolutely full. There is
no foree whatever in the argument that it should have been
still stronger, because the required strength had been al-
ready surpassed
IV.—If the Court is to hold that the Caréh Prince Was
inseaworthy when she sailed, on the ground that this bolt
was ina damaged condition at that time, the result of such
a decision should be clearly understood. For instanee. in
the case of this voyage, suppose that when the Caréh
Prince was one day ont, she had eaught fire, and the en-
tire eargo had been destroyed. According to the libellant’s
contention, the insurance policies upon the entire cargo
—_—— OC RMOE RT NAR 5 sea BT Rep a a ‘fo 4 *y aoe OTN RAY a Tae germ NSS y ase EES
32
could have been cancelled, upon the ground that the war.
ranty of seaworthiness was broken at the time of j issuing
the policies. There is no sueh thing as unseaworthiness
as to one hold of a ship and seaworthiness as
to the rest of her. It must seem absurd to the Court
that the contagion --so to speak—of this one bulkhead.
could spread in such deadly fashion to the entire e "ATZO,
most of which could never have been affected by it under
any cirenmstances, and none of which could have been in-
jured but for the mismanagement of the captain in filling
his tank at sea
V.—The libellant’s argument that to prove the safety of
the tank it should have been filled before the vessel started
upon her voyage shows only that the Master was cert: inky
negligent in filling the tank at sea, when such a test had
not beenmade. If the tank had not been filled a defective
bolt in the bulkhead could not have caused injury to the
‘argo. His act, therefore, in so filling the tank, was the
proximate cause of the injury. And the Harter Act ex-
cuses the vessel from liability for negligence in the cap-
tain’s management. It is still good law that cansa pro-
ima, non remota spectatur.
Seventh.
The decree of the Cireuit Court of Appeals should be
affirmed with costs.
Everetr P. WHEELER.
Advoeate, with the Appellee.
Of Counsel for Atlas Steamship Co,
a
LRA ALE PLE PLATE LS IIL ENR IO NIE RRS OL EE RS Hy
_—
333
Appendix
STATUTES OF THE UNITED STATES Ly REFERENCE TO
, THE Prorreerton or Passengers AND Fretaur
ON
SHIPS.
Rerised Ntatutes OF the United Slates.
(Edition of 1875.)
Titles 48, 49, 50, 52.
Seetions 4252-4277 concerning the Transportation of
Passengers and Merchandise weve repealed by the Aet of
IS82. 2? Statutes at Large 186 (repealing clause on p. 191),
These sections are re-enactments of Statutes passed at
various times between 1855 and 1866 : and contain numer-
ous requirements for ensuring the safety of life and prop-
erty at sea, whieh are not here stated at length. beeanse
such requirements are more amply enacted in 18x92.
The following is an abstract of the latter Act:
An Aet to regulate the carriage of POUSSENYOTS hy sed,
See. 1.—(1.) Masters of steamship or other vessel, taking
emigrant passengers or other than eabin passengers
from foreign country (ports and places of foreign
country, contiguous to United States excepted), are
not allowed to bring such vessel or passengers to
any place in United States unless below specified
room space, accommodations, &e., be furnished the
passengers for the entire voyage,
2. Space required.
(@) in steamship—100 unobstructed eubie feet per
passenger—on main or first deck below main —and
120 unobstructed enbie feet per passenger on second
deck below main—not lawful to Carry passengers
on any other decks.
34
(h) in sedling vessels—110 unobstructed cubie feet
per passenger—to be carried only in deck below
main deck or ina poop or deekhouse construeted
on the main deck.
(7) Between decks or compartments, &e.—in which
passengers are carried must not be less than 6 feed
high.
(7) Children under one year not counted as passen-
gers—two children between one and eight counted
as one passenger.
3. Penalty for violation.
See. [[.—(1.) Every vessel shall have sufficient number
of berths for the proper accommodation of all pas-
sengers.
(2.) On each deck and compartment not more than 2
tiers of berths ; each berth 2 feet wide and 6 feet
long (and other details providing for comfort),
(3.) Provisions for separate male and female compart-
ments, family compartments,
berths numbered,
berths to be inspected, &e.
Penalty for violation,
See. IIL.—(1.) Adequate provision for light, air, ven-
tilation—form and number of ventilators, hateh-
Ways, companion ways, caboose, cooking-range and
other cooking apparatus: sufficient water-closets.
Penalty for violation.
Sec. [V.—Wholesome food, with reasonable quantity
of fresh provisions (= to 1} U.S. Navy rations) with
not less than 4 quarts of water, 3 meals per day,
Penalty for furnishing short allowance (except in
ease of accident). Penalty against master for viola-
tion; this does not affeet civil responsibility of
master and owners to passengers,
SLITS NI RET Ns Le LEB OE ERO Pills HE RETIN 5 PITY ETI FIN ERE Bit af
35
See. V.—Properly built and secured hospital compart-
ments (1 male and 1 female) reqnired, to be located in
upper part of ship. Vessel bringing passengers other than
cabin passengers—over 50—must have duly-qualitied sur.
geon, with medicines, appliances, &e., to treat any passen-
ger or children of passengers. Penalty for violation.
Sec, VI.—
(1.) Master authorized to maintain good discipline,
and sueh habits of cleanliness as econduce to health,
and in consequence shall cause his regulations to be
posted: up, and so to remain in accessible places in
the vessel,
(2.) Compartments of passengers to be cleaned and
co]
disinfected,
(3.) Passengers and bedding to have clear and suf-
ficient space on main deck set apart for their airing
and exercise. Penalty for violation.
sec. VIT.—
(1.) Officers, seamen, &e., prohibited from visiting
passengers’ compartments Without permission of
master. If they do, they are punishable.
(2.) Master who permits them, except for perform-
ing a necessary duty in their official capacity, pun-
ishable.
(3.) Notice to this effeet must be posted. Penalty for
violation. '
Sec. VIIL—Explosives, vitriol and other articles
likely to endanger the lives or safety of passengers, vessel,
animals, &e., not allowed to be carried except in vessels of
iron in compartments divided off by water-tight bulkheads
extending to upper deck. Penalty, &e.
36
See, XT.—Collector of customs of collection distriet or
surveyor of port may direct inspection of vessel, passen-
ger list, compartments, &e. : to be forwarded to Secretary
of Treasury where and how he shall direct.
Sec, XTL.—The tines and penalties imposed upon mas-
ter for violation of above provisions are liens Upon vessel,
and vessel may be libeled in U.S. Court.
Revised Statutes, $ 4275-4280. —Prohibition and reau-
lation of nitro-glycerine carriage. Not allowed on board
passenger vessels,
TITLE LIL.
Regulation of Steam Vessels.
Sections 4402-4403. Qualifications, appointment and
duties of Supervising Inspector-General 7. ¢.. preside at
meetings, superintend administration of steamboat. in-
speetion laws, receive all reports of inspectors, examine
accounts and report fully at stated periods to Secretary of
Treasury upon all matters pertaining to his office. and
secure correet and uniform administration of inspection
laws, rules and regulations,
4404. Qualifications and appointment of Supervising
Inspeetors. They shall be experts in steamboat affairs.
4405. Meetings of board, assignment of districts.
4406. Supervising Inspector shall wateh over all parts
of territory assigned to him, shall deal with action of
local boards of inspeetors within his distriet, and shal]
instruet them in their duties, and shall visit (when he
thinks expedient) vessels licensed, and examine their con.
REE LIL OT EME TIT BRAT
TENSE Se ea bs atic |
37
dition to find out whether provisions of this title have
heen observed and complied with by (1) Board of In-
spectors ; (2) by master and owners,
4407. Whenever Supervising Inspector finds that pro-
vision has been violated, he shall report (1) to loeal board,
or (2) cause negligent party to be prosecuted, or (3) report
to Secretary of Treasury if he thinks official has been
neglizent,
4408. Supervising Inspector to see that loeal board ex.
ecutes its duties, and (See, 4409) supervise and inspect in
districts where no loeal board exists.
4417. ** The local inspectors shall, once in every vear,
at least, upon application in writing of the master or
owner, carefully inspect the A77 of each steam vessel
within their respective distriets, and shall satisfy them
selves that every such vessel so submitted to their Inspec.
tion is of a structure suitable for the service in whieh she is
to be employed, has switable accom modations for passen-
gers and the erew, and is in condition to warrant the
belief that she may be used in navigation as a steamer
with safety to life, and that all the requirements of the
law in regard to fires, boats, pumps, hose, life preservers,
floats, anchors, cables and other things are faithfully com-
plied with; and if they deem it expedient, they may
direct the vessel to be put in motion, and may adopt any
other means to test her sufficiency and that of her equip-
ment.”
4418. Local inspectors shall inspect the boilers of all
steam vessels (1) before the same shall be used, and (2) once
at least in every year thereafter. They shall inspect all the
details of the boilers, furnaces, appurtenances, ete., and
shall satisfy themselves that such boilers, machinery and
appurtenances may be safely employed in the service pro-
38
posed in the written application without peril to life.
They shall inspeet safety valves, gauge-cocks, steam.
gauges, low-water-gauges, proper insertion of fusible
metals, adequate provision for ample water supply, means
for blowing-out provided. They shall subject the boilers
to the proper hydrostatic tests. No boiler or pipe nor
any of the connections therewith shall be approved whieh
is made in whole or in part of bad material, or is unsafe in
form or dangerous from defective workmanship, age, use,
or other cause.
4419. Inspectors must take absolute control of steam
registers, and may take absolute control of one of the
safety valves.
4420, Amount of steam) pressure allowed freight boats
on Mississippi river.
4428-4437. (4429, amended, 22 St., 310; 4430, amended,
28 St., 28; 4454, amended, 28 St., 690.) Provide for con-
struction of boilers, with plates stamped in accordance
with the provision of this title, provide punishment for
improper construction, require speeial kind of inspection
of boiler plates, require certain stamps on the plates,
punish counterfeiting of such stamps, states steam
pressure allowable in proportion to the boiler plates, spe-
cify thiekness of the boiler plates and space between the
Hues, provide for feed and connecting pipes, for safety
valves, fusible plugs, ete. and punish for obstructing
safety valves.
H438-4449, (A438, HHT, 4442, amended by 18 St, 30),
Providing that alien who has deelared his intention to
become a citizen of the United States may be licensed as
engineer or pilot; treats of the licensing of ship officers,
4438. Boards of local inspectors shall license and ‘he
sify the masters, chief mates, engineers and pilots of al]
PETERSON ER © mpi RST sEaenenR P=!
39)
steam vessels. Unlawful for person not) so licensed to
serve as such officer, and penalty of S100 for each offense,
4439. For license of master, inspector inquires as to
applicant's character, examines him as well as proof he
produces. — He must be satisfactory in respect to capacity,
experience, habits of lifeand character, — Licensed for one
Year, liable to revoeation on proof of Incompeteney of any
nature,
4440. For license of chief mate, same methods, time of
licensing and power of revocation as for master. Eexami-
nation specially direeted to his ability in lading cargo,
handling and stowing treight, in navigation and managing
steam vessels.
4441. For license of engineer, same as in 4439, 4440.
Specially examined in knowledge of steam machinery,
experience as engineer, License same time as for above
officers. Engineer assigned to class for whieh he is fitted.
If he be negligent or unskillful, inspectors may revoke and
assign him to lower grade of engineer if he be fitted there-
for.
4442. For license of pilot, regular procedure as for pre.
vious Officers.
4448. All officers licensed as herein shall assist the in.
spectors in their examination of any vessel to whieh such
officers belong, and shall point out and report defeets. In
default thereof license to be revoked.
4450. Local boards of inspectors shall investigate judi-
cially, and with all the incidents of judicial procedure,
acts of incompetency or misconduct of the officers.
4453. Local inspectors shall examine at proper times in
addition to the annual examination, and serve notice for
repairs, ete., when needed.
— ea ia
40
4462; Secretary of Treasury to make such regulations as
Inay be necessary to secure the proper exeeution of this
title.
Trr_e LIT, Cuap. IT.
Transportation of Passengers and Merchandise.
Section 4463. No steamer carrying passengers shall de-
part from any port unless she shall have in her service
fulleomplement of licensed officers and full crew, sufficient
at all times to manage the vessel,
4464. Inspectors shall state in certificate of inspection
number of passengers of each class that steamer has ae-
commodations for, and can earry with prudenee and
safety.
4470. Ships to be provided with pipes attached to boiler,
woodwork to be covered with incombustible material, ete.,
to provide against fire.
4471. Fire pumps and hose to be provided.
4472. Articles very easily ignitible, e. 7., loose hay, loose
cotton or hemp, nitro-glycerine, ete., not to be earried on
passenger vessels. Articles ignitible, but not to so great
a degree, must be stowed in incombustible chests, ete.,
away from heat or friction. Board of Supervising In-
spectors may make other provisions to guard against fire.
4473. Penalty and seizure and sale as punishment for
unlawfully carrying cotton or hemp.
4475. Dangerously explosive and combustible articles to
be securely packed, distinctly marked and separated.
4476. Penalty and criminal punishment for packing and
shipping such articles otherwise than as directed.
4477. Watchmen to be kept at night to guard against
s
Ee SES ea eye eee a RT TSE Sy RE ae PE LOO OME IO ae" INE eid, Yas Matai PAE Spree ey [Ae
4]
fire, e., and to give alarm in case of accident or disaster.
4478. Penalty and revocation of license for neglect to
keep watchmen.
4479. Fire extinguishers may be required by supervis-
ing inspectors,
4480. Wire tiller ropes (or iron chains or rods), bell-
pulls, tubes, &e., required,
4481. River steamers—Required to have boat with lines,
Ke., ready for use, and when required ; also metallic life
hoats—also (4482) life-preservers for every person on the
boat—also (4483) fire-buckets, axes, water-barrels, &e,
4484. Vessels carrying passengers on maindeck shall be
provided with permanent stairways and other means to
allow eseape to upper deek—also gangways or passages
through freight stowed on main deck.
4485. (Am. 27, Stat. 16). Captain or mate shall assign to
all main-deck passengers the space on deck they may oe-
eupy during the voyage, and sueh space must be kept
clear of freight. Freight shall not be placed so as to in-
terfere with the engineer in his work. (4486.) Penalty
for violating 4484 and 4485.
4487. River steamers to be anchored when navigation
unsafe,
4488. Life boats, &e., on ocean, lake and sound steamers
and (4489). Penalty for so neglecting (Amd. 27, Stat. 16).
Ocean and Great Lake steamers must have not less than
three water-tight eross bulkheads.
4491. Instruments, equipment, &e., for better security of
life as provided by this Title must. be first approved (1)
by Board of Supervisors, and (2) Secretary of Treasury.
4492. Barge in tow carrying passengers subject to pro-
visions of this Title.
SORA INE EE OLN Re loot eae ee SSA he ENP aes. Pie Se
Te EDN 23
42
4493. °° Whenever damage is sustained by any passen-
ger or his baggage from explosion, fire, collision or ether
cause, the master and the owner of such vessel, or either
of them, and the vessel shall be liable to eaeh and every
person so injured to the full amount of damage if. it hap-
pens through any neglect or failure to comply with the
provisions of this Title or through known defects or imper-
fections of the steaming apparatus or of the hull: and any
person sustaining loss or injury through the carelessness,
negligence or wilful misconduct. of any master, mate, en-
gineer or pilot, or his neglect or refusal to obey the laws
governing the navigation of such steamers, may sue such
Inaster, mate, engineer or pilot and recover damages for
any such injury caused by any such master, mate, engineer
or pilot.
4494-4500, Referring to publication and enforcement of
this title by penalties, &e.
ABSTRACT OF ENGLISH STATUTES REFERRED ‘TO AT PAGE
21 OF FOREGOING BRIEF.
The Merchant Shipping Act of 185}.
17 and 18 Victoria, Chapter 104.
Abbott on Shipping (13 Eng. Ed.) p. 911.
Part l.—Extends the jurisdiction of the Board of
Trade. Section 6 is as follows (p. 913) :
** The Board of Trade shall be the Department to under-
take the general superintendence of matters relating to
merchant ships and seamen, and shall be authorized to
carry into execution the provisions of this aet, and of all
en on . . eta phan OMG ‘ LAB YE TRE SABRES arrest wit
ee AIO ONES MASE PETES 2 LTO A a eS BS RES A A NE RIE ACRE TY ERE YL STMT ERAS
43
other acts relating to merchant ships and seamen in
force for the time being, other than sueh acts relating
to revenue.’
Part IT.—-Requires the registry of British ships, their
measurement, ownership, ete.
Parr IIT.—Provides regulations relating to masters and
seamen. The number of seamen on each vessel must be
reported. Examinations are required of masters and mates
(Seet. 131); anda vessel cannot put to sea till their certifi-
cates are produced (Section 136). Methods of apprentice-
ship are provided (Section 141). Whenever a seaman is
discharged the master must report his conduct, character
and qualifications to the Board of Trade (See, 176).
Parr TV.—Safety and Prevention of Accidents.
Life boats and buoys are required (Sect, 299). Com-
passes must be examined in accordance with regulations
of the Board of Trade Fire hose must be provided (Seet.
301).
Shipwright and engineer surveyors are to be appointed
by the Board of Trade to survey passenger ships (Seet,
305) and such survey shall be made in aceordance
with regulations and under the — direction of the
Board of Trade (Seet. 307). The owner half yearly
(Sect. 311) must have every passenger = steamer
surveyed by such shipwright and engineer survey-
ors (Sect. 309). The declaration of the surveyor must
contain a statement (1) that the hull is in good condition :
(2) that the partitions, boats, life-buoys, lights, signals,
compasses and the certificates of master and mates are
such and in sueh condition as required by this act ; (3)
the time for which said hull and equipments will be suffi-
cient; (5) the number of passengers whieh the ship
should carry,
44
The declaration of the engineer surveyor shall state (1)
That the machinery is proper for the serviee and in good
condition, (2) The time for which it will be sufficient.
(3) Thet the safety valve and fire hose are in) proper con.
dition. (5) How long the machinery will be in proper
condition (Seet. 309). The Board will give a certificate
embodying the return of a Surveyor (Seet. 312), whieh
must be placed in a conspicuous part of the ship (Seet.
317). The ship must not proceed on her voyage without
a certificate. A’ penalty is provided for carrying more
passengers than allowed by the certificate (Seet. 319),
Accidents must be reported to the Board of Trade
(Seet. 326).
The Passengers Act. 1855,
Is and 19 Viet., 119,
Abbott on Shipping, 13 Eng. Ed., p. 1053,
Regulates the space allotted to passengers, with a pen-
alty for carrying more.
Regulates the equipment of passenger ships, witha pen-
alty for violating these requirements
A passenger ship must be manned with an efficient erew
to the satisfaction of the emigration officer.
Cattle and certain articles forbidden as e: rgo and. bal-
last. Stowage of eargo and ballast must be approved by
emigration officer.
Merchant Shipping Act, Amendment Act. 1862.
25 and 25 Viet., C. 638.
Abbott on Shipping, 13th Eng. Edit., p. 1085.
Engineers are required to obtain certificates similar to
those of masters and mites (Seet. 5).
Chain Cables and Anchors. IS? 4.
37 & 38 Viet., C. 51.
pa Sa a OEE IO Ey EELS NRE Oe
45
Abbott on Shipping, 18th Eng. Ed., p. 1139.
Chains and anchors to be tested before sale (See. 3).
Merchant Shipping Act. 1876.
39 & 40 Viet. C., 80.
Abbott on Shipping, 13th Eng. Ed., p. 1141.
“Seet. 4. Every person who sends or attempts to send
or is party to sending or attempting to send a British ship
to sea in such unseaworthy state that the life of any per-
son is likely to be thereby endangered, shall be guilty of
a misdemeanor, unless he proves that le used all reason-
able means to insure her being sent to sea in a seaworthy
state, or that her going to sea in such unseaworthy state
was, under the circumstances, reasonable and justifiable,
and for the purposes of giving such proof, he may give
evidence in the same manner as any other witness.
Every master of a British ship who knowingly takes
the same to sea in such unseaworthy state, that the life of
any person is likely to be thereby endangered, shall be
guilty of a misdemeanor, unless he proves that her going
to sea in such unseaworthy state was, under the cireum-
stances, reasonable and justifiable, and for the purposes of
giving such proof, he may give evidence in the same man-
ner as any other witness.”’
*Seet 5. In every contract of service express or im-
plied, between the owner of a ship and the master or any
seaman thereof, and in’ every instrument of apprentice-
ship whereby any person is bound to serve as an appren-
tice on board any ship, there shall be implied, notwith-
standing any agreement to the contrary, an obligation on
the owner of the ship, that the owner of the ship and the
master and every agent charged with the loading of the
ship, or the preparing thereof for sea, or the sending
thereof to sea, shall use all reasonable means to insure the
seaworthiness of the ship for the voyage at the time when
46
the voyage commences, and to keep her ina seaworthy
condition for the voyage during the same; provided that
nothing in this section shall subject: the owner of a ship
to any liability by reason of the ship being sent to sea in
an unseaworthy state, where, owing to special eireum-
stances, the so sending thereof to sea is reasonable and
justifiable.”
When a ship is believed to be in a condition dangerous
to human life, the Board of Trade may order it to be de-
tained and surveyed. If unsafe she may be ordered per-
manently detained or until certain repairs are made.
Order of detention must be served on the eaptain of
the ship. Tf he thinks it unjust he may appeal to a
Court of survey constituted by this Aet (Sections 6
and 7).
Where a foreign ship in the United Kingdom is un-
safe because of excessive or improper loading, the above
provisions as to inspeetion and detention shall apply
(Section 13).
Any vessel arriving ina port of the United Kingdom
from any port out of the United Kingdom between the
last day of Oetober and the sixteenth day of April, if it
carries timber or heavy wood goods on deck, or light
wood to a greater height than three feet above deck,
shall be liable toa penalty (Seetion 24). The deck lines
of every vessel must be conspienously marked (See-
tion 25),
‘Sec, 26. With respect to the marking of a load
line on British ships the following provisions shall have
effect :
1. The owner of every British ship (except ships under
eighty tons register, employed solely in the coasting trade,
ships employed solely in fishing, and pleasure yachts)
shall, before entering his ship outwards from any port in
the United Kingdom upon any voyage for which he is
47
required so to enter her, or, if that is not practicable, as
soon thereafter as may be, mark upon each of her sides
amidships, or as near thereto as is practicable, in white or
yellow on a dark ground, or in black on a light ground,
a circular dise twelve inehes in diameter, witha horizontal
line eighteen inches in length drawn through — its
centre,
2a. The centre of this dise shall (be placed at such level
below the deck line marked under the provisions of this
Act, as may be so approved by the Board of Trade, and
shall) indicate a maximum load line in salt water to which
(it shall be lawful) to load the ship ;
A report must be made to the Officer of Customs of the
distance between the deck line and load line (See. 26)."*
Merchant Seamen. 1880.
43 and 44 Viet. ©. 16,
Abbott on Shipping, 13 Ed. p. 1163.
A seaman shall not be entitled to the rating of A. B.
that is to say able-bodied seamen, unless he has served
four years before the mast (See. 7).
Merchant Shipping (Carriage of Grain) Aet 1880.
43 and 44 Viet. C. 43.
Abbott on Shipping, 13 Eng. Ed., p. 1168.
See. 3. All reasonable and necessary precautions must
be taken in order to prevent the grain cargo from shifting.
If such precautions have not been taken, the master and
any agent of the owner charged with the loading shall each
be liable to a penalty of not over three hundred pounds.
The owner shall also be liable unless he shows that he
took all reasonable means to enforee the observance of this
section.
See. 4. Where a British ship is laden in the Mediter-
48
ranean or Black Sea, and bound out of Gibraltar, or where
it is loaded on the coast of North Ameriea, there shall not
be earried above the main deck any grain except what may
be needed to feed the cargo in the hold, and carried in
properly-constructed feeders. (2) In the majority of eases
(exeeptions specified) one quarter of the grain in the hold
must be put in bags supported on suitable platforms laid
upon the grain in bulk (See. 4). The master must deliver
at the consular office, the vessel's draught, the kind of
grain, method of stowage and precautions taken against
shifting (Sec. 6). The Board of Trade may appoint an
inspector who shall have the same power as an inspector
under the Merchant Shipping Act of 1854, so as to be able
to enforce the Act (See. 8).
Merchant Shipping (Life Saving Appliances) Act 1888.
51 & 52 Viet. C., 24.
Abbott on Shipping, 13 Eng. Ed., p. 1204.
The owner and master must provide the best of boats,
life jackets and other appliances for saving life (Sect. 1),
The Board of Trade is to make rules in detail, arrange-
ing ships into classes and providing what appliances each
class must have.
If these rules are not observed the Master, if in fault,
shall be fined not over fifty pounds. If the owner is in fault
he is to be fined not over one hundred pounds (See. 4). To
enforce these rules a surveyor appointed by the Board of
Trade may inspect the ship to see that it is properly pro-
vided with appliances. If defective appliances are found
notice must be given to the master or owner and to the
collector of customs. The latter shall not allow the ves-
sel to clear without a certificate from the surveyor of the
Board of Trade that the vessel has proper appliances
Merchant Shipping Act 1890.
53 Viet. C., 9.
SE ey Ae SI LN TE IN OS ES NEED IO RE RES IE NY AIRE: SARE. NE MAD ee Cam
49)
Abbott on Shipping, 13 Eng. Ed., p. 1226.
The centre of the load line dise shall indicate the maxi-
mum load line in salt water, to which it shall he lawful to
load the ship (Seet. 1).
The Board of Trade may regulate details in regard to
this matter. The Board of Trade shall appoint the com-
mittee of Lloyds Register to approve and certify the
position of the load line dise. (Seet. 2).
The foregoing acts are codified in 7 Merchant Ship-
ping Act 1894. L. R. Statutes, Vol. 31 (57 and 58 Viet.),
339: Chitty’s English Statutes 1894, Tht Shipping.
APPENDIX SHOWING THE DIMINUTION IN THE Loss” oF
LIFE AND PROPERTY AT SEA IN STEAM VESSELS, DURING
THE LAST SIX YEARS.
In the twelve years ending 1895-96, the number of. sail.
ing vessels register ‘ed and employed in the United King-
dom steadily decreased from 9,849 in) 1888 -84, to 6,373 in
1895-96. During the same period the number of steam
vessels steadily increased from 4,707 to 5,627. The total]
number decreased from 14,566 to 12,000. The size and
tonnage of steamers have also increased.
This change from sail to steam enables a smaller number
of vessels by making a larger number of trips, to do an
increased business. As each vessel makes more voyages
during the year, there isa much greater likelihood of j injury
and loss of life. In spite of this fact, the returns made to
the British Board of Trade show that the death rate h: as
decreased, These official returns cover twelve years, end.
ing 1885-96. Exe ‘eption: il losses by collision oeeasion; lly
increase the rate in a given year. For ex: unple, in 1894-95,
the Kow Shing with 1,150 Chinese soldiers on board sunk
50
as the result of a collision in the China seas. It. is
therefore just to take the average of several years. The
following is a comparison of the results of these returns
for the first six years, with those of the last six.
Per cent of lives lost (including Lascars and those not
employed during the whole vear) by wreeks or casualties
compared with the number employed,
(1) On Sailing |
_ Vessels. | (2) Steam. | (3) Total.
First six years... 9 .782/8¢ =| 189 -1/38¢ ler a 8¢
Last SIX years. a) 1.06 5/69 | 28 1/3¢ | =aih) 2/3¢
Per cent of lives lost by Wrecks, Casualties and Acei.
dents.
_() Sailing, | (2) Steam. (3) Total.
First six years.... 0 1. 39 2/30 ot 2 689 AA 92 1/90
Last six years..... 1.62 1/26 | .55 1/3% | .85 1/2%
Per cent of lives lost by wreck or casualty excluding
Lasears and those who were not employed during the
whole of the year.
(ys ) Sailing. ee 2) Steam. (3) Total.
First six years.... 80 1/86 | 40% 56 1/3%
Last six years..... 1121/8 | 99 1/a¢ | ha )9e
Per cent of deaths by all accidents compared with num-
ber employed, but excluding Lasears and those who were
not employed during the whole of the year.
Total.
Wirst stm VOORS....0 6 kc ccss 79 Loe
Last six years ........... eS 74.1/3¢
Percentage of tonnage attended with loss of life. td
total tonnage employed (exeluding Lasears and those not
employed during the whole of the vear),
(1) Sailing Vessels. (2) Steam. (3) Total.
First six years. . 2.33 1/34 1.511/6% 1.841/3¢
Last six years... 2.78 1/3¢ 1.325/6¢ 1.79 5/6¢
From these tables we perceive (1) that the percentage of
LESLIE SE 8 OLENA NENT EES. NANTES ANS Tiyt SRR RIE PURE AD OME IT RET NG He tl IES. Ti RG le 2p
ol
loss on sailing vessels is much greater than that on
Steamers. (2) That though the loss on sailing vessels has
increased in the last six years, the loss on steamers has
been so much diminished that there is a material diminu-
tion of the percentage of total loss.
B. Vessels Lost.
‘ Percentage lost to employed.
Total Loss Sailing. Loss of Steam. Total Loss.
Ist Six vears, 3.21 1/39 2.64 1/37 3.01 1/29
Last ‘“* ** 3.994 2.10 1/37 2.77 1/34
These figuiesare taken from the official abstracts of the
Returns to the Board of Trade, printed by direction of
Parliament, in 1896.
The following extract from a recent report (June 4,
1896) of the Committee appointed by the Board of Trade
to inquire into the manning of British merehant ships, con-
tains a summary fora different period (page 45) :
41. ** The great reduction in the loss of life at sea. es-
pecially in steamers, which is happily observable in recent
years, shows that the necessity for further restrictive leg-
islation has dissapeared. In the quinquennial period end-
ing 1880, the annual average loss of lives of crews of
steamers by wreck or casualty numbered 466 on a gross
tonnage of under two millions, whilst for the five years
ending 1894 it has averaged barely over 400 on a ton-
hage exceeding ten millions.”
This Committee differed as to whether or not additional]
legislation was expedient, in reference to the m: inning of
British ships. The minority dissented on the ground
that existing legislation was sufficient and also on the
ground that the nations of continental Europe were less
exacting in their requirements than the British Parliament
had been. But the correctness of the above statement. in
the minority report was not contested by any one.
52
In an account of the annual meeting of the English
Chamber of Shipping, held at London in February, 1897,
the following paragraph occurs :
‘* The question of loss of life at sea is one whieh must
always be to the fore in the mind of every one who takes
the least interest in shipping. It is good, therefore, to
know that spite of the crowded state of traffie along
our coast, there has been a steady decrease during the last
ten years in the percentage of loss of life at sea. Ship-
owners would like to see this still lower, and the president
voiced the feeling of the whole meeting when he asserted
that any well-considered scheme to reduce loss of life still
further would have their warm support and approval.”’
—Commerce. London, Feb. 24, 1897.
THE PRINCESS.
(Referred to at p. of Brief.)
Reichs-Gericht ; Civil-Sachen (Imperial Court. Civil
Cases), Vol. 25, page 104 ef seq.
Is it a part of the seaworthiness of a vessel provided by
the shipowner and carrier that she shall be provided with
the requisite (garnier) dunnage.
H. G. B. (Handels Gesetz-Bueh) 481, 560,
The exemption of the carrier under the bill of lading, in
respect of the fault (verschuld) of the master and mariners
in distinetion from the fault of the carrier himself or any
of his general agents, except the master.
I, —-Civil Senate—Decision of May 25, 1889, in the mat
ter of IT. H. B. ef a7, defendants, against Captain R. as
commander of the steamer Princess, plaintiff,
I.--Loeal Court (Land Gerieht) at Bremen.
Il.— Court of Appeal at Hambure.
ata a RQ Fig er ayte td: GPO SIO RI ALD TETRA LULL D ENOTES SAS ROPE MELE ERE Se Rt
o3
The plaintiff, who brought on the steamer Pyincess, com-
manded:by him, a cargo of cotton from Galveston to Bremen,
demands, in his capacity as master, ina suit against the eon.
signees of different portions of the cargo, payment of the
freight payable on each lot. The amount of freight is not
disputed. But the defendants replied setting up counter-
claims against the plaintiff, which hav not been sustained
by the Courts of first and second instance,
The appeal of the defendants is dismissed,
For the reasons :
* The judgment appealed from has for its subject coun-
terclaims which the defendants supported by the conten-
tion that they had suffered substantial damage from the
fact that a large number of bales, forming part of the cot-
ton consigned to them, had been injured by dirt in the
bottom (boden) of the ship and by sea water, in conse-
quence of the want of dunnage.
The defendants demand of plaintiff compensation for
the diminution in value of these bales caused’ by ab-
sence of dunnage and by neglect to clean the ship's bot-
tom (boden), and also for the expense caused them by the
inspection ; alleging that it was the duty of the shipowner
to provide sufficient dunnage.
The plaintiff denies this claim, He maintained that he
was ignorant of the alleged injury, and declared that he
had provided permanent dunnage (festes garnier), which,
however, might ‘not have sufficed to protect: the cotton
from dirt; that the vessel could not be made liable for the
damage, as the equipment of the vessel was good and suf-
ficient, and finally that the real question in the case was
that of the default of the ship's company, for whieh by
the bills of lading the ship was not liable.
Such bills unquestionably all contained the clause
* Negligence or Gefanlt of pilot, master, mariners, en-
gineers or other persons in the service of the ship, whether
D4
in navigating the ship or otherwise * * * excepted.”
The Court of first appeal found that movable dunnage had
not been provided to protect the cargo sufficiently from
the bilge water and dirt of the ships bottom, and that (as
the defendants themselves were evidently convinced in the
Court of first instance), the cause of damage was clearly
to be found therein. According to this finding of faet, to
which no exception was taken, and which is therefore
binding on the Appellate Court, the Court of first appeal
adopted the reasons for which the Court of first instance
had held under the bill of lading before the Court that the
plaintiff was not liable to the consignees of the cotton
mentioned in the bill of lading, for any damage of this
kind, which was caused by the fault or negligence of the
captain,
In this no rule of law is violated. The Land-Gericht in
its reasoning justly began with this premiss, that the
suit is brought, not by Captain R. personally but in his
capacity as representative of the owner and carrier, and
that the counterclaim in question is made against such
owner and carrier. Then the Land-Gericht refutes the
contention of defendants that it was the duty of the owner
to provide proper dunnage by the sufficient argument that
although by Article 50 of the H. G. B. the carrier must
furnish the vessel in seaworthy condition, yet that the
lack of dunnage or defective dunnage does not impair the
seaworthiness of the vessel. The duty imposed
by said article upon the carrier is indeed altogether
general. For although by a vote taken upon
the first reading (see Protocol, p. 2066), the words
‘and its equipment ” (geredschaft) following the word
“ship” in Article 470 of the Prussian bill (Entwurf)
were stricken out, this was done solely for the
purpose of giving the article a more general scope and
of preventing the inference that it did not extend to,
TELM OAPI IT Hn, PRAISING ANAL BED NEE LH ARMM RRR A 8 Ee IRR eS AEN Ee Ny oS RO
oe
the sufficieney of other appurtenances of. the ship. It
therefore certainly belongs to the seaworthiness of the ves-
sel that all instruments and appurtenances which the ship
needs in order to be able to enter upon and complete a
given voyage shall be provided and in proper condition.
The dunnage, however, is not intended to protect the vessel
or to enable it to resist winds and waves in stormy weather ;
but it consists in appliances by which the cargo is to be
protected from the sea water, which, as experience shows,
enters the ship's hold under ordinary cireumstances. and
also against contact with the dirt that may be on the bot-
tom, so that there may be seaworthiness of the vessel
though the proper dunnage be absent.
The stowage of goods is a different matter. For by this
there is to be prevented ; not only injurious effects of the
various articles upon one another, and the shifting of the
freight by the motion of the vessel and the injury thereby
threatened to the goods, but there is also to be secured
that proper trim of the vessel requisite for safe naviga-
tion; and the prevention of lateral shifting of the cargo
which would threaten danger to the vessel. From all which
it results that by insufficient or improper stowage the sea-
worthiness of the vessel may under some circumstances be
impaired,
While then the Land Gericht correctly finds that by
Article 481 of the H. G. B., it was the captain who should
have taken care to have the vessel provided with the
proper dunnage, it does not fail to recognize that the
owner and carrier, although he is not chargeable with any
fault of his own, nevertheless would) be liable for the
damage in question if he were not by the bill of lading
exempted from such liability. Finally if this last-men-
tioned exemption is approved, in this also no violation of
any rule of law ean be found, because the damage is to be
traced to an error of the capain, for which error by the
o6
clause of the bill of lading above quoted, the vessel is not
liable.
The Court of First Appealadds very properly that though
the exemption from all consequences of ‘negligence or
default of pilot, master, mariners, &e."? be exceptionally
far reaching, yet no objection can be made to it because of
the principles of German law as to freedom of contract.
This has been affirmed recently in a decision of the Civil
Senate of the Imperial Court (Reichs Gericht) Feb.6, 1889,
in the matter of the German National Bank ef @7., against
Captain W.
To conclude, there can be no doubt as both the lower
Courts held, that in the determination of the duty of a
captain under the bills of lading to be performed in a Ger-
man port. the German law must govern.
If finally the appeal is sought. to be maintained on the
ground that in the above-mentioned decision the Imperial
Court did not allow the exemption of the owner from the
claims of the consignees, upon a clause in the bill of lad-
ing precisely similar, this also appears to be irrelevant.
For in that case the decision rests upon the principle of
law that the owner cannot claim protection under such a
clause of exemption, so far as he himself or some general
agent other than the captain is at fault; and also on the
finding that this was the fact in that case, because the in-
jury to the cotton had arisen by an improper method of
stowage usual in Galveston, which was known to the
owner's agent in Galveston (by whom the bills of lading
were signed) and ignorance of which on the part of the
owner would involve culpable negligence. There is no
ground whatever for finding any such personal fault of the
plaintiff--owner in the present case.”
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.