Reply Brief — Young v. Cargill

Supreme Court brief2010

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Case No. OY 1558

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED

STATES

LORENE YOUNG

Vetitioner,

CARGILL

Respondent

ON PETITION FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF

APPEALS FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUTE

REPLY TO BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

Marcia V. Forsett

1405 Greentree Ave

Bartow, FL $3830

463° 605-5859

marcialorsett@m: n.CcomM

Attorney for Petitione:

QUESTIONS PRESENTED

Is Cargill entitled to summary judgment as a

matter of baw’?

Whether Cargill is entithed to Kmploye:

Immunity based on Florida's Workers

Compensation Act Section 440.11 (2) Fla. Stat

$440.01- 440.60 C2000)

Was Lorene Young considered an employee of

Cargill?

Did Cargill know or should have known of the

danvers of the use Anhydrous Ammonia

Did the District Court and Court of Appeals err

in Concluding that summary judyment wa:

appropriate under appheable Klorida law?

TABLE OF CONTENTS

QUESTIONS PRESENTED "

TABLE OF CONTENTS 1

TABLE OFAUTHORIPTPIES Cris bD M1)

INTRODUCTION

REASONS FOR GRANTING THE PETITION. 1

\ ‘The Court of Appeals Decision conthet:

with Klomda Distmet Court of Appeals for

the 186.2" and Bt) District:

RB. Conflicts exist between various state law

and federal decision

()) Petitioner is not attempting to re-htigate

fact

DD. Petition doe present a question ol

exceptional importance worthy of thi

Courts attention

CCONCLUSION

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES CITED

Austin v the Duval County School Board Gh %

po. Zd 945 (1995)

Mippins V fantasma Productions 943 So. 2d 952

(YOOG) >

feruno v. Destiny Transportation 921 So. 2d &36

(2006)........ bas 7

Cabrera vi T's) Pavement Corp. 2 So 8d 996 Nov

ge. | | ras

Casamassima Vv. The US Lite lnsurance Co, 95&

So. 2d 1093 (2007) 9

Derogatis v. kaweett Mem] Hosp., 892 So. 2d

1079, 1081 Ci la. 2d DCA 2004).. 4

Hlolmes v. Trout, 32 US. 171, 21001833) ‘|

florn v. Tandem Health Care of Fla, Inc., 862 So

2d 938, 940 Cla. 2d DCA Z004)........ i

Sagarino v. Marriott Corp., 644 So. 2d 162, 165

(hla. 4th DCA 1994) |

Shelby Mut. Ins. Co. v. Aetna Ins. Co., 246 So. 2d

98 (Fla. 1971).. |

Stuyvesant Corp. v.§ Waterhouse, 74 So. 2d 554, 557

(Mla. 1954)..

Venezia al Kagan OF 1 no. Za 17D | bOdS9O)

Other Authoritie:

pup. Ct. R10

Cargill’ In the Belly of the Beast by Wailham

Grigsby Vergara

http://www.envio.ory. oi/articulo/4 1&3

www -recnamericatoday.org

yosemite _epa gov/opa/admpress. nst/246 7fecaGO3e6

872985257 359004044 3d/[36

SourceURI www owhsv.com/news/headhnes/4343

99297 htm]

source URL) www_laborngehts org/stop-child

labor/cocoa-Campaipn/d8&5

source URL: www.e; foundation .org/page 152 html

Source URL:

www.ktka.com/news/2006/nov/13/cargill inc faci

ny oSha citations and fi

Introduction

The respondent has not quoted the Supreme

Courts Rule number 10 properly. Therefore it 1

the respondent who misunderstands the role of

the Supreme Court. Redress of gnievance:

Reasons for denying respondents reply

he; pondent states that “A petition for awril of

certiorarn: will be granted only for one of the

following compelling reasons’! ‘This is a

misstatement of Rule 10. The rule actually

tate:

Review ona writ of certiorari is nota

matter of right, but of pyudicial discretion. A

petition for a writ of certiorari wall be

eranted only for compelling reasons. The

following, although neither controlling nor

fully measuring the Court’s discretion,

indicate the character of the reasons the

Court considers:*(Bold added for emphasi

on missing phrase)

With that being noted there 1s a conflict between

Mlorida courts of Appeals and the decision of the

US District Court for the Middle District of

Mlorida. As stated in Rule LO &Gv

Respondents reply bmnet page

“Sup. Ct kK o1O

The US District Court for the Middle District of

Florida and The Distmet Court of Appeals’ for

the 11 Cireuit decisions Do Conflict with the

Decisions of the 1*t District Court of Appeals the

Yod Pistrict, and the 5“ District, of Florida

There is a conthet with Crawtord v. Klorida

steel 478 So.2d 855 (1985) Cela ls* District),

Vustin vo. Duaval County School Board 657 So. 2d

945 (1995 ) Ula.d* District), Venezia \ leagan 671

o. 2d 175 ©1996) Cla. 5 District J, Phe

respondent states that the parallel between

Crawtord and the present case is mispuided

because there was no contract between the

peneral and special employer,Cin the Crawford

case) in this case there 1s a detailed Service

Agreement and in that agreement Section &

states that the Company(Citrus Force Staffing)

is considered an Independent Contractor

“Company shall act at all times as an

independent contractor, and nothing

contammed herein shall be construed to

create the relations hip ol prirne Ipal and

apent, or employer and employee between

Company and Cargill. ‘The Company

employees assigned to perform the

mervices for Cargill are solely the

employees of Company

Petiohoners Wnt Appendix |

(dause TZ covers insurance responsibiblitie

bhi ludiny worker: Compensation Mon Iexhibit A of

the services avreement is outlined the

responsibilities of the Company including

management and team leade Therefore if an

(Crawford there was no service contract and the

Qnmioary padpginent was deemed, then certainly

Witha service apreement Chat specifically stat

thatthe company as anandependent contractor ¢

gounatenial fact Javain stunmary padguinent should

bee denged

Phe three-part test lor an emaploymesst

redationstipas- Ol) whether there is a

contract of hire, expre or imiplicd

between an employee and the special

coiployer, (2) whether the work beiny

done at the thie of the mmjyury 1

essentially that of the special employer

and (3) whether the special employes

has the nyvht to control the details of

the worl Oluyvesaul Corp. s

Waterhouse, 74 SO 2d 554, S57 bla

LYSD) he contract for hire is the most

iniportant part ol the test, because the

coiployee loses the ripht to sue thie

pecial Gmployer at common law for

thas Cneral Emp Cy (PATI Varriott

(orp odd “WW Th 165 Clda Vth PICA 1994)

[**}] feytin Shelby Mut. fn Co Vv. Aetna In

(4 1h + ae, Chelas L971) lO OVETCOIN

tty pore tii I } a | rt miust estab!) ry Ube

f iJ Chemicon ( j Lijecre i i contract lor

bids Lies po! I nphed between thie

par cy 1 sie CmMiployer Lae CEM

ork pe ( t tt time OF The wy i

Lia ty | 1 otdae yor tial 1 pl ei 1110

{} ‘ 1< trol th detail O1 the rr}

] }¢ ] yt} t] | ] j f lij ie (-J ij iii

O44 § fat 164 eit helby Mat. In (

/f f / } bit lirst haactor

bieet ih Xp (>) brripolied

eri Clement. LA als \

(/ ad Lta OO tong slorn 1 hander

(/ LILA f j I)

I re na | j ( ryly t. Ja

(i) bby dlhed aces { Cerbaih Cquipment i

t] | 1 | ( rPomwell « nplo ee and there Wert

clual Cargill employes it the plant who were

4 Med from €oromwe Ho employe and wer

I | | J @ Jo) bb abiin (4 Plain equi] ment

| moplion of Continued vene)

f I i)t , | rt liar I

bya UT ( wabiol here

pate } qgdjior tl ]

! i! jiil rif

1) many ©) Jel (

i I midi { ripol (*]

‘ lol COotiipele

ri id luraily preter t

ypal ( rol ] ple riaice |

i bit ithus } roj tant

mil it] it. zal

l i I | (4 Ii I

} ( i pia roicrnt nda

| Ul eS tl wa

. proper

;

There is conflict between the United States

Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, and the

United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh

Caircult

In Ve GUez \ North County Transit Lstrict, 292

sd, 1049 (200%) ummary judgment wa

reversed because the protection that thi

defendant clasmed Cassuimption of risk) wa

deemed not applreatb de ‘Therefore the decision of

the tinited States Court of Appeals for the] 1”

(oreuitin this case 3s in conflict wath the United

trate (Court of Apps als for the 9 Circurt

Petitioner beheves that there is a conflict

between this case and several states (including

Florida).

The re pondent Late that under 2% US

144560), 4 civil wction in any Late court arisiney

out of the workers compensation laws of such

tate may not be removed to federal court

lblowever, on the mpstant case it wa rt pomde bil

that removed this case trom state to ledcral

eourt. The way that several states define therm

Vorkers and employers are in direct contrast to

thie Waly threat kjorida define WOrke! and

qmiployers and the respondents reply stat Chica

the US District Court for the Middle District of

Plorida used Flormda Law to decide that

cummary judgment was appropnate for Cargill

Respondent is not trying to re-hbtigate the facts

Kespondent in section © of the reply brief cite:

hlofines v. Trout, 32 US. 171 240018353)

contending that new evidence was introduced

however, this is not the case petitioner banca

added the complete service agreement that the

order from the middle district of llorida

relerences on page lLWo of the order!”

The respondent states that there 1s no question

of exceptional importance worth of this court’s

attention.

However, as the petitioner stated in the appellate

bef, thereis a question of material fact that

needs to be defined by this court

leven under the virtually certain test

there must not be a disputed issue of

material fact in order for surmimary

yudgyment to be given to the requesting

party. Hf The employer engaged in

conduct that the employer knew, based on

pror syinilar accidents or on explhieait

warnings specifically identifying a known

Appendix lof Petitioners Writ

/

danger, was virtually certain to result in

miyury o7 death to the employe es

Ourmmary judgement should not be piven

liowever, at the time of Mr: Youny:

accident, the standard was a different

tandard, a standard that allows a lowe:

threshold to be met, the determination of

conduct of the employer required the tryer

Of fact to decide “whether the cimployel

either knew or should have known that jt

conduct was substantially certain to result

minjyury or death

“Iti the evidence raises any issue of material fact

Waitas conftheting, fat wall permat different

reasonable miflerence or ifit tendsto [*840]

prove the issue i should be submitted to the

jury as a question of fact to be determined by it

Moore 175 So. 2d at GOS (citations omitted)

Trial courts must be especially cautious in

yranting Summary judgment in nevliyence case

and (27 TTIATY yudyment ; hould riot bye yrant ad

uni the facts are so crystallized that nothing

remains bue (pubesttowm: ol [**6] law." Id

ltlo the extent that the federal case

permit Stuimary judgment based on

he ft ral hale of Civil Proce tre IOAa

tnterpreted in Celotex Corp. vo Catrett

WSS ELS. 317, 1006S. Ct. 2548, G91 L. Ed

OO (LIS6) they are of limited

precedential value in Florida summas

pudement case hlorida [** 16) place

higher burden ona party movany for

Wininary judgement in state court

requiring the movant to "TSthow

conclusively that no material 1 ti

remain for trial

ia pondernt tial that thi case I il) i lated

ammonia rele a4 bigws oP thi ré pondent had

in amnondsa spillin Minnesota in October of

ZO00 Respondent had an amenonia spall

belore this incident and atter this incident in

March 2008 and has been accused of literally

destroying the lives of its workers |!

an accidentas classilied

according to Carpaill’s universal

lexicon not as a “lost time accident

but as “first aid,’ a “sheht accident

Without time off and the worker 4:

relocated “with his/her consent) and

with signed documentation to an

areca where he/she can work without

discomfort to the ingured body part.!’

The subcontractors do the most

dangerous work. ‘They are the Cargill

employees who die every year all ove

the world because they work without

any kind of securty. They are the

ones Who prune trees, clean toilets

and lft heavy sacks. They do all the

yobs with a higher probability of a

SCPIOU or deadly accident ‘They work

on scaffoldings, in silos and with

machinery where it’s easy to vet

it " > ‘

( arpill lin the Ds lly of the Beast } y Walliain Carip: by

Ve reara http IIWWW-en ho Orgy yi articulo/4 1&3

ld

lO

hurt. They work in their own country

hike migrants who work abroad do

for less pay and without rights. They

are the ones who die

Anonymously Li

Cargvillis bering sued for knowingly sourciny from

cocoa plantations that use child slave labor?

The federal yovernment and ten state:

wed Cargill Inc. for failing to comply with

emuassions Standards outlined in the Clean

Air Act. The lawsuit came after the

discovery that Cargills corn processing

plants were a major source of carbon

monoxide and volatile organic compound:

he company reached a settlement in the

suit by agreeing to spend $1380 million to

upgrade the pollution control devices at it:

plants. In addition, Cargill ayreed to pay

4

$1.6 millon in civil penalties and to

* argall lia the Be Hy of the Beast by Walham Grigsby

\

Vergara hitp M/WWW. envio org nifarts ulo/4 183

WWW Pree nae rn aboday ory

(

earmart Prd. million for environmental

projects across the country. Improved

pollution controls at Cargill facihities are

expe ted Lo reduce annual CVWISSTON by

30 OOO ton

Menvironmental Protec tion ActION

QOG/O 1/2005 <9

An affidavit released by Immipration and

Customs [enforcement (Cle) in March

2009 alleged that the Cargill Meat

Solutions plant in Dayton, Virginia

knowingly hired around 400 “unauthorized

’

and smuggled alrens Phe affidavit wa:

used to secure a search warrant for a

March ZO08 raid of the plant after it wa:

found that nearly one third of the 1,300 1-9

coiployment forms Submitted to the

Department of Homeland Security by

Cargill were suspected to have been filled

out using “fraudulently obtained or invalid

documents. [Clo inve lavators also found

yt) eyynale Cpa po

L3)90040443d/

evict rhe tha il pore Prhoant Won Were i

treate ad ditt rently in the plant by Lif?

t

forced to work up until they gave birth and

,

j

made to start working avain soon afte)

delivery

WHSYV, 04/22/20007!

The International Labor Kaghts land

C(LILRED ha sued Nestle, Archer Daniel

Midland, and ¢ areaill mn bederal District

Courtin los Angeles for involvement in

the tratfscking, torture, and forced labor of

Children who cultivate and harvest cocon

beans that the companies import from

Africa. ‘They filed sunt on behalf of a cla

of Mahan children who were trafficked

from Mah into the Ivory Coast and forced

to work twelve to fourteen hours a day

with no pay, little food and sleep, and

frequent beatings. ‘The three chaldren

acting as cla representative plaimtilts are

prerocer haniy’ QGNOnY MOU: ly ci ohn |) re

because otf feared retahlation by the farm

OWnhe!l for Whom thie \ work ed

International Labor Kaighe rund

Os/ 13/200

According a report by the lnvironmental

Justice Koundation, a London-based

nonprohit dedicated to stopping

environmental abuses, titled "White Gold

The True Cost of Cotton," an Ienvironmental

Justice Foundation report the Cargill

Cotton division of Cargill Incorporated 1

major purchaser of Uzbek cotton

CGiovernment control of the lucrative cotton

mdustry in Uzbekistan has led to

wide pread human rights abuses and

extreme poverty. International human

mghts organizations warn that leaders of

UJzbekistan have turned the country into a

lave nation" in order to che apy produc

eotton for the world market) According to

the Environment Justice Foundation

li zbekistan 1s the world's second largest

exporter OF cotton rrning thre

than pt billion in exports anmeucaiby. The

Karimov government employs unethica

PPhc UN DETTE

| reap thr

boul iv ¢ polien

benetit from | 71 Kt Titty) qd reecadode | it uit

! ruinrce

° (*] \' I ( ( ZOO OOO chaldre ! It

conscripted to manually harvest cotton

lo | mid children i y

foreed te bith ibyyt Colllilp

Phe children are oy

ngh picking quotas and most are not

mpensated tor then labor. The,

ubsist on bread and water, and man

uffer from mainutrition as a result of

hard labor and litthe looa Vdult labore.

typically earn Ie than p/ l Ld per

month

. (On June 14 VU, ocoll Garaossoehl

Cargill employee in North Pope (1) I

dent. AS a result

rill ¢ le VaALOr a

i}

Occupational sa

ition COSHA) fined Cargill

for seven alleged vi

A)

L.aminist!

ey)

federal rule mechuding a failure to

adequately train employer: te XPOS

them to the risk of bene buried by thre

grain, and not providing hfelines to

employees who walk or stand in stored

grain. Thos was the second death in Cargill

elevators in te than three year

Conclusion

ey all of the above rea I} the petitiones il }

this honorable court to prant the petition for writ

Of certiorari

ae pectfhally ubmoitted

Marcia V. Forsett

1405 Gireentree Ave

13 rrtlow | y ‘ 4)

Counsel of Record for Petitione:

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.