Appendix — Fusheng Liu v. Koninklijke Philips Electronics, N.V.

Supreme Court brief2010

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

la

APPENDIX A— MEMORANDUM OF THE UNITED

STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH

CIRCUIT FILED JULY 1, 2009

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

NINTH CIRCUIT

No. 08-16763.

KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS ELECTRONICS, N.V,

Plaintiff-Appellee,

v.

Fusheng LIU, AKA Liu Fusheng, AKA Fu Sheng Liu,

Defendant-Appellant,

and

KXD Technology, Inc.; Astar Electronics, Inc.; Astar

Electronics USA, Inc.; Shenzhen KXD Multimedia Co.,

Ltd.; Shenzhen Kaixinda Electronics Co. Ltd.; KXD

Digital Entertainment, Ltd.; Jingyi Luo, AKA James

Luo; Sungale Group, Inc.; Sungale Electronics

(Shenzhen), Ltd.; Amoi Electronics, Inc.; Amoi

Electronics Co., Ltd.; Amoi Electronics, Ltd.; China

Electronics Corporation; Amoisonic Electronics, Inc.;

International Norcent Technology, Inc.; Norcent

Holdings, Inc.; Shanghai Hongsheng Technology Co.,

Ltd.; Shenzhen Newland Electronic Industry Co., Ltd.;

Desay A&V (USA) Inc.; Desay A&V Science &

2a

Appendix A

Technology Co., Ltd.; Desay Holdings Co., Ltd.; Xoro

Electronics (Shanghai) Ltd.; Shenzhen Xoro Electronics

Co. Ltd.; Mas Elektronik AG Corporation; Shenzhen

Oriental Digital Technology Co., Ltd.,

Defendants.

Argued and Submitted June 3, 2009.

Filed July 1, 2009.

Before: RAWLINSON and BYBEE, Circuit Judges,

and BURNS FN’, District Judge.

MEMORANDUM EFN**

Fusheng Liu (Liu) appeals from the district court’s

entry of default judgment against him. However, because

Liu failed to file a motion in the district court under

either Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 55(c) or 60(b)

seeking to set aside the second entry of default or entry

of default judgment, Consorzio del Prosciutto di Parma

v. Domain Name Clearing Company, LLC, 346 F.3d

1198, 1195 (9th Cir. 2008) mandates dismissal. Liu’s

“argument that service was insufficient is not a matter

properly before this court.” Jd.

* The Honorable Larry Burns, United States District

Judge for the Southern District of California, sitting by

designation.

** This disposition is not appropriate for publication and

is not precedent except as provided by 9th Cir. R. 36-3.

sa

Appendix A

Nothing in Rule 27 of the Federal Rules of Appellate

Procedure or the Rules of the Ninth Circuit required

Appellee to file a motion to dismiss the appeal before

raising Liu’s failure to seek relief from the default

judgment.

APPEAL DISMISSED.

4a

APPENDIX B — ORDER OF THE UNITED STATES

DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF

NEVADA FILED FEBRUARY 4, 2008

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

DISTRICT OF NEVADA

Case No.: 2:05-cv-015382-RLH-GWF

Case No.: 2:06-cv-00101-RLH-GWF

KONINKLIJKE PHILIPS ELECTRONICS N.V,

a Netherlands Corporation,

Plaintiff,

vs.

KXD TECHNOLOGY, INC.; ASTAR ELECTRONICS,

INC.; ASTAR ELECTRONICS USA, INC.;

SHENZHEN KXD MULTIMEDIA CO., LTD.;

SHENZHEN KAIXINDA ELECTRONICS CO., LTD.;

KXD DIGITAL ENTERTAINMENT, LTD.; JINGYI

LUO, a/k/a JAMES LUO; FUSHENG LIU, a/k/a LIU

FUSHENG, a/k/a FU SHENG LIU; SUNGALE

GROUP, INC.; SUNGALE ELECTRONICS

(SHENZHEN), LTD.; AMOI ELECTRONICS, INC.;

AMOI ELECTRONICS CO., LTD.; AMOI

ELECTRONICS, LTD.; CHINA ELECTRONICS

CORPORATION; AMOISONIC ELECTRONIC

ELECTRONICS, INC.; INTERNATIONAL

NORCET TECHNOLOGY, INC.; NORCENT

HOLDINGS, INC.; SHANGHAI HONGSHENG

TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD.; SHENZHEN NEWLAND

ELECTRONIC INDUSTRY CO., LTD.; DESAY A&V

Sa

Appendix B

(USA), INC.; DESAY A&V SCIENCE &

TECHNOLOGY CoO., LTD.; DESAY HOLDINGS CoO.,

LTD.; XORO ELECTRONICS (SHANGHAD), LTD.;

SHENZHEN XORO ELECTRONICS Co., LTD.; MAS

ELEKTRONIK AG CORPORATION; SHENZHEN

ORIENTAL DIGITAL TECHNOLOGY CO., LTD.; and

JOHN DOES 1 THROUGH 20,

Defendants.

ORDER

(Motion to Set Aside Entry of Default-#809)

Before the Court is Defendant Fusheng Liu’s

Motion for Relief from Default and to Quash Service

of Summons and Complaint (#809) (the “Motion”),

filed December 17, 2007. The Court has also considered

Plaintiff’s Opposition (#814), filed January 4, 2008, and

Defendant’s Reply (#816), filed January 15, 2008.

BACKGROUND

Defendant is President of corporations KXD Digital

Entertainment, Ltd., Shenzhen KXD Multimedia Co.,

Ltd. and Shenzhen Kaixinda Electronics Co., Ltd; and

is the former President of KXD Technology, Inc. All

these corporations are currently Defendants in the

instant case.

On September 19, 2007, the Court granted

Plaintiff’s motion to amend the Complaint to add

6a

Appendix B

Fusheng Liu as a Defendant. The First Amended

Complaint (“FAC”) was filed on September 27, 2007.

Summons was issued on October 1, 2007. On October 2,

2007, Plaintiff left a copy of the Summons and FAC at

Fusheng Liu’s home located at 1825 Carlisle Drive, San

Marino, California 91108, with a person named Annie

An. Annie An is either the nanny or babysitter of

Defendant’s children. Defendant was not at home at the

time service was made, but his wife and children were.

On October 3, 2007, Plaintiff mailed the same papers to

the San Marino address.

On November 8, 2007, Plaintiff moved for entry of

Clerk’s default against Defendant. On November 9,

2007, the Clerk entered default against Fusheng Liu.

On December 17, 2007, Defendant brought the instant

Motion to set aside default and quash service of process.

For the reasons stated below the Court grants

Defendant’s Motion. The Court also gives Plaintiff leave

to serve Defendant by publication.

DISCUSSION

I. Standard for Setting Aside Default

A court may set aside an entry of default “for good

cause shown.” Fed. R. Civ. P 55(c). Failure to properly

serve a defendant with process pursuant to Fed. R. Civ.

P 4 constitutes good cause to set aside an entry of

default. See generally Veeck v. Commodity Enters., Inc.,

487 F.2d 423, 425-26 (9th Cir. 1973) (failure to serve

Ta

Appendix B

properly constituted a lack of jurisdiction to enter

default judgment, thus default judgment was set aside);

Mason v. Genisco Tech. Corp., 960 F.2d 849, 851 (9th

Cir. 1992) (default judgment is void where a plaintiff fails

to serve process properly). The Court finds that process

was never properly served on Defendant Fusheng Liu

and thus grants the Motion to Set Aside Entry of Default

and Motion to Quash Service of Process (Dkt. #809).

A. Service of Summons and Complaint

Plaintiff argues that the service effected on

Ms. Annie An on October 2, 2007, should be sufficient

as to Defendant. Plaintiff also contends that because

Defendant was aware of the litigation default should not

be set aside. The Court disagrees. The Supreme Court

has held that it is a bedrock principle that “[a]n individual

or entity named as a defendant is not obliged to engage

in litigation unless notified of the action, and brought

under a court’s authority, by formal process.” Murphy

Bros., Inc. v. Michetti Pipe Stringing, Inc., 526 U.S.

344, 347 (1999) (emphasis added) (thirty-day time line

to remove case to federal court did not begin when

defendant received a file-stamped facsimile of the

complaint, but only after formal service of process

obliged defendant to engage in litigation).

There is no dispute that Defendant Fusheng Liu is

aware of the action and has been for a long time;

however, only recently was Fusheng Liu named as a

Defendant in the FAC and the Court finds that Plaintiff

has failed to bring him under the Court’s authority by

formal process.

8a

Appendix B

(1) Rules Governing Service Upon

Individuals Within United States

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure (“FRCP”) 4 governs

service of process. According to FRCP 4(e) service may

be made upon individuals within the United States

according to FRCP 4(e)(2) or by the laws of the state (a)

where the action is pending, or (b) where the defendant

is served. Therefore, compliance with either the

Federal, Nevada or California rules of service upon an

individual within the United States apply to Defendant.

Each set of rules allows for service by satisfying three

basic elements: (a) by leaving copies of the Summons

and Complaint at the defendant’s “dwelling” or “usual

place of abode”; (b) with someone “of suitable age and

discretion” or who is “competent... [and] at least 18

years of age”; and (c) who “resides”, is “residing” or is a

“member of the household.” See Fed. R. Civ. P 4(e)(2)(B),

Nev. R. Civ. P 4(d)(6), Cal. C. Civ. P § 415.20(b).

(a) Dwelling or Usual Place of Abode

The Court finds that under any of these sets of rules

that the San Marino property is a dwelling or usual place

of abode for Defendant. There is no dispute that he visits

the property multiple times throughout the year. There

is also no dispute that his wife and children were there

for at least half of last year, including the time of service.

There is no dispute that he owns the residence.

Therefore, the Court finds that the San Marino property

satisfies this element of the rules. See Stars’ Desert Inn

Hotel & Country Club, Inc. v. Hwang, 105 F:3d 521, 524

9a

Appendix B

(citing Natl Dev. Co. v. Triad Holding Corp., 930 F.2d

253, 257 (2d Cir. 1991) for the proposition that a person

can have more than one dwelling house or usual place

of abode for purposes of the rule).

(6) Someone of Suitable Age, Discretion,

and Competency

No one disputes whether Annie An was of suitable

age, discretion, or competency. Therefore, the Court

finds that this element is satisfied.

(c) Resides, Residing, or is a Member of

the Household

This element is where Plaintiff has failed to meet

its burden of proper service. There is no admissible

evidence that Annie An resided, or was a member of

the household, at the time of service. Plaintiff only

submits the declaration of Tim Santoni as evidence that

Annie An was a resident. On September 21, 2007, Mr.

Santoni was searching the San Marino home for

counterfeit products. He states in his declaration:

“During my search, I was informed that one of the rooms

in the household belonged to ‘the children’s nanny.’ . . .

When we looked in the nanny’s room, it was clear that

someone was living there, as there were woman’s clothes

in drawers and other personal belongings in the room.”

(Dkt. #814, Santoni Decl. 9 4.)

Therefore, the only evidence that the Annie An

resided in the home is based on inadmissible hearsay.

10a

Appendix B

There is also no foundation as to who told Mr. Santoni

this information. Furthermore, Defendant submits the

declaration of his wife Qin Zhou which states that the

clothes and personal belongings in the room are hers.

(Dkt. #816, Zhou Decl. 7 12.) Zhou also declares that

Annie An did not reside in the San Marino home. (Jd. at

1 6.)

Because there is no admissible evidence that Annie

An is a resident or memher of the household, the Court

finds that she does not satisfy the third element of the

relevant service statutes. The Court therefore finds the

service was improper. Therefore, Defendant’s Motion

is granted.

Given the difficulty presented in serving Defendant,

the Court will allow Plaintiff to serve Defendant by

publication. The Court finds that Defendant resides out

of the state, that a cause of action exists against him,

and that he is a proper party to the action.

CONCLUSION

Accordingly, and for good cause appearing,

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Fusheng Liu’s

Motion to Set Aside Entry of Default and Motion to

Quash Service of Process (#809) is GRANTED as

follows:

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Clerk’s

Entry of Default (#801) is hereby VACATED and service

lla

Appendix B

of process is QUASHED only as to Defendant Fusheng

Liu.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Plaintiff shall

mail another copy of the Summons and Complaint to

Fusheng Liu’s San Marino home address through the

post office.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Plaintiff may

serve process by publication in accord with Nev. R. Civ.

P. 4(e)(1). Publication will only be required in a local

Nevada newspaper because Defendants already have

actual notice of these proceedings. Therefore, the

publication shall run once a week, in the Las Vegas

Review-Journal or Las Vegas Sun for a period of four

weeks. This will constitute service on the Defendant.

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Fusheng Liu’s

answer is due twenty (20) days after service of process

is completed.

Dated: February 4, 2008.

s/ Roger L. Hunt

ROGER L. HUNT

Chief United States District Judge

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.