Opposition Brief — Hudson Area Area Schools Schools v. Patterson (No. 09-143)

Supreme Court brief2009

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

, Supreme Court, U.S.

Z (2 FILED

% AUG 28 2009

No. 09-143

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

HUDSON AREA SCHOOLS,

Petitioner,

v.

DAVID PATTERSON and DENA PATTERSON,

Respondents.

ON PETITION FOR A Writ OF CERTIORARI TO THE

UNITED STATES Court OF APPEALS FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

BRIEF IN OPPOSITION

JEFFREY PR ARNSON TeRRY E. HEISS

Law OFFICE OF JEFFREY Counsel of Record

P ArNSON, PLLC TERRY E. HEIss, PC.

6440 East Fulton St. 6440 East Fulton St.

Suite 201 Suite 201

Ada, MI 49301 Ada, MI 49301

(616) 676-3850 (616) 676-3850

Counsel for Respondents

2248383 g

COUNSEL PRESS

(800) 274-3321 © (SU0) 359-6859

a

QUESTION PRESENTED

Whether a school district is entitled to summary

judgment as a matter of law on the issue of deliberate

indifference to known severe, pervasive, and objectively

offensive student-on-student sexual harassment under

Davis v. Monroe County Bd. of Educ., 526 U.S. 629

(1999), where the underlying material facts are in

dispute; where taking the evidence in a light most

favorable to the non-moving party, the evidence shows

che district had knowledge that its remedial actions were

ineffective in the face of the continuing harassment, yet

the school district continued to use the same ineffective

methods; and, where the school district failed to follow

its own policies.

12

PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDINGS

AND RULE 29.6 STATEMENT

There are no parties to the proceedings other than

those listed in the caption. Respondents are not

corporate entities and are not a subsidiary or affiliate

of a publicly owned corporation.

iil

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

QUESTION PREG AE? 6s ccnevesevesesans i

PARTIES TO THE PROCEEDINGS AND

RULE 29.6 STATEMENT ...............- il

pe Rt gti) yy). yy. re iii

TABLE OF CITED AUTHORITIES ......... Vv

STATEMENT OF THE CASE ............... l

fic: IR Gd bncukieune oe40ad eeueeuaens 1

B. Course of Proceedings ................ 1

C. Counter-Statement of Issue ........... 2

A, - BRE Re as 6 kk vs os on ens baneee es 3

E. Background and Overview ............. 11

1. Pactual BACKBPOUNG 2.66. cescsceves 11

2 §eistory Of RODOTURG .. 2.66. sscee 19

3. School Policy and Its Implementation

iv

Contents

REASONS FOR DENYING THE PETITION

eevee rvreeveereeeee ee ere wee weer ee eh hlcr mc hr mC OhUh OFT PO HH FT HO

I. The Majority Below Contains a Lucid

Analysis of Facts and Procedural Standards

Regarding Summary Judgment Review

eee eeeereeereeeeeeee eee ee eeeeee eee e eee ee

II. The Majority Correctly Follows Controlling

RE d'y-040 0c 4095S O AOR ETRE es

A. The Majority Does Not Conflict With

Dawie TOE VARGO nc cc ccccccvencds

B. The Majority Below Is Not In

Conflict With The Third Circuit, As

Doe v. Bellefonte Area Sch. Dist., Is

Factually Distinguishable ..........

Ill. The Majority’s Opinion Is Not

Impractical, Rather Is Based On Sound

PERSE Pere Teor Terr eet er

Ce 9.65 0459-54405 455 4Gacuwkeeeya as

PP, A oc ny daa caee ho aes awe he

Page

Vv

TABLE OF CITED AUTHORITIES

Page

CASES

Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.,

477 U.S. 242, 106 S.Ct. 2505,

PE ECE BO CUOUED concer isevecneseeeeus 28

Bd. of County Comm’rs of Bryan County, Okla.

Breen, Gee U.S. Bet CASGE) occ cccccccves 32

Crawford v. Metro. Gov't of Nashville

and Davidson County,

__ US. __, 1298.Ct. 846,

Fe RAT CET bck eck cee rvceuceseas 28

Davis v. Monroe County Bd. of Educ.,

526 U.S. 629, 119 S.Ct. 1661,

RGD Lie GOO EON) oo vc cee wecicecees passim

Doe v. Bellefonte Area Sch. Dist.,

2003 WL 23718302 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 29, 2003),

aff ’d, 106 Fed. Appx. 798 (3rd Cir. 2004) ... passim

Doe v. Dallas Indep. Sch. Dist.,

a0 £.00 Sou (On Cir. BOG) 2... 6c ccc cece: 32

Fitzgerald v. Barnstable Sch. Comm.,

504 F.3d 165 (ist Cir. 2007) ........0.-. cess 32

Johnson v. Independent Sch. Dist.,

194 F.'Supp.2d 939 (Dist. Minn. 2002) ....... 32

vi

Cited Authorities

Page

Montgomery v. Indep. School District No. 709,

109 F.Supp.2d 1081(D. Minn. 2000) ......... 33

Morlock v. West Cent. Educ. Dist.,

46 F.Supp.2d 892 (D. Minn. 1999) ........... 33

Murrell v. Sch. Dist. No. 1, Denver, Col.,

186 F.3d 1238 (10th Cir. 1999) .............. 33

Patterson v. Hudson Area Sch.,

551 F.8d 438 (6th Cir. 2009) .............. passim

Rost v Steamboat Springs RE-2 Sch. Dist.,

511 F.3d 1114 (10th Cir. 2008) .............. 32

Schroeder v. Maumee Bd. Of Educ.,

296 F.Supp.2d 869 (N.D. Ohio 2003) ......... 33

Theno v. Tonganoxie Unified Sch. Dist. No. 464,

377 F.'Supp.2d 952 (D. Kan. 2005) .......... 33, 35

Vance v. Spencer County Pub. Sch. Dist.,

231 F.3d 253 (6th Cir. 2000) .............. passim

Wilson v. Beaumont Indep. Sch. Dist.,

144 FSupp.2d 690 (E.D. Tex. 2001) ......... 32

vil

Cited Authorities

STATUTES

oP eR eS) Se eee Sere TT reT re rr rr

ge Re | re re rere

COURT RULES

gs 2 Berea rr Tree rer re Tr

1

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

A. The Claim

On November 24, 2005, Respondents, as next friend

of Dane Patterson’, filed a complaint alleging a violation

of rights granted to Dane under Title IX of the

Education Amendment of the Civil Rights Act of 1972,

being 20 U.S.C. § 1681, et seg. The complaint alleged a

multi-year history of bullying, teasing, and sexual

harassment sufficiently severe and pervasive to deny

Dane access to the educational opportunities or benefits

provided by Hudson Area Schools (“Petitioner”).

(Complaint, Sixth Circuit Joint Appendix, hereafter

“JA”, pg. 12, 16, 125).

B. Course of Proceedings

Petitioner filed for summary judgment on April 18,

2007. Respondents filed a response on May 9, 2007. The

district court issued its Opinion and Order November

28, 2007, finding as to the Title [X claim, (1) Respondents

had met their burden as to the first prong of the Davis’

test (i.e. severe, pervasive and objectively offensive

conduct), (JA-pgs. 321-323); (2) Petitioner had

knowledge of multiple instances of student-on-student

sexual harassment of Dane, (JA-pgs. 323-324); but (3)

Petitioner was not deliberately indifferent to the sexual

harassment against Dane, because its actions were not

1 Hereafter referred to as “Dane”

* Davis v. Monroe County. Bd. of Educ., 526 U.S. 629, 653;

119 S.Ct. 1661; 143 L.Ed. 2d 839 (1999).

2

clearly unreasonable in light of known circumstances.

(JA-pgs. 324-330).

Respondents appealed to the Sixth Circuit Court,

which reversed January 6, 2009. Petitioner’s motion for

en banc review and/or reconsideration was denied

May 1, 2009. The essence of the decision of the Sixth

Circuit was material issues of fact remain and that

summary judgment was inappropriate pending

resolution of those factual issues.

C. Counter-Statement of Issue

Contrary to Petitioner’s claim, the Majority Opinion®

in the Sixth Circuit found the facts proffered by

Petitioner, as “effective responses to complaints of

harassment, policies prohibiting harassment, and

instituting programs teaching the students the danger

of harassment” (Petition, pg. 2), were in dispute which

must be resolved at trial. Patterson v. Hudson Area

Sch., 551 F.8d 488 (6th Cir. 2009). The court did not

require schools to “remedy” all offensive behavior, but

instead questioned claims of undisputed factual

assertions offered by the Petitioner. The Majority did

not alter the holding of this Honorable Court in Davis,

nor is it inconsistent with its own holding in Vance v.

Spencer County Pub. Sch. Dist., 231 F.3d 253 (6th Cir.

2000).

Just as in the Sixth Circuit, Petitioner submits a

pleading in which the offered statement of fact is replete

with references not cited to the record, contains

* Hereafter “Majority”

3

numerous factual, errors cites to references which do

not support the claimed fact, or take one fact from one

academic year and apply it to multiple years. From pages

5-9, there are at least sixteen factual claims not

supported by a citation to the record.

D. Factual Disputes

The following is a list of some significant factual

contradictions:

Bi

Petition, pg. 3: Petitioner claims all perpetrators,

once identified, were disciplined. The record fails

to show any perpetrator named in 6" and 7"

grades was disciplined. /nfra at 11-12. Most

perpetrators in 9" grade, especially the daily

harassers, also went undisciplined. /nfra at 14-

18. Unless Respondents had corroborating

evidence, Petitioner refused to take action.

(See example, JA-pg. 714). Rather than support

Dane, Petitioner’s staff discouraged complaints

with responses such as (1) “kids will be kids”,

(2) “addressing things will only make it worse”,

(3) “we don’t have enough proof and can’t do

anytning about it”, and (4) “are you sure you

want me to do something with these kids because

of the retaliation factor”. (Dane, JA-pgs. 672,

704-705, 714; David Patterson‘, JA-pgs. 802-803).

According to Dr. Warwick, Dane’s counselor, the

Petitioner treated Dane “as if he was the

problem”. (JA-pg. 174, 128).

4 Hereafter referred to as “David”

d

Petition, pg. 3: Petitioner claims a proactive and

vigorous history of investigation and disciplinary

responses to sexual harassment. Respondents

disagree.

a.

Contrary to its own policy (Code, JA-pg. 309),

Petitioner did not call the police after Dane

was sexually assaulted, refusing Dane’s

request for Petitioner to call so he would not

bear that burden and the issues it

presented. (Dena Patterson’, JA-pgs. 865-

866). The police report confirms Dena is the

complainant. (JA-pg. 259).

Petitioner’s records demonstrate only one

set of investigative notes or reports for the

three year period of harassment and only in

relationship to the sexual assault. (JA-pgs.

263-265). This lack of reporting undercuts

any claim of vigorous investigation.

As to the defacement of Dane’s main locker,

Infra at 16, Dane provided names of two

potential perpetrators, Derrick G. and Kyle

M. (Dane, JA-pgs. 712-715). While

conducting his “vigorous” investigation,

Assistant Principal Durbin never bothered

to interview either student. (Durbin, JA-pg.

433).

More often than not, Petitioner violated its

own disciplinary policies, /nfra at 11-15; 20-

> Hereafter “Dena”

5

24, thereby creating a perception within the

student body that nothing would be done in

response to bullying and harassment. /nfra

at 25-27.

3. Petition, pg 3: Petitioner’s claim, that it provided

multiple services, has been highly disputed by

Respondents in the Sixth Circuit.

a.

As part of its legal duty to evaluate Dane

for special education services, Petitioner

conducted an evaluation during the summer

after Dane’s horrendous and devastating

7 grade year. (Cates, JA-pgs. 367-370;

Dena, Appendix-pgs. 9a-10a). This event was

a one-time reactive response to Dane’s

emotional deterioration, not a proactive

measure. Nothing in the 8" or 9" grade

Individual Educational Plan (IEP) directly

addressed measures to protect Dane from

harassment by using such things as a para-

professional, an escort between classes, or

special reporting procedures. (JA-pgs. 39-

47, 216-224).

Though Petitioner provided IEPs, the

record clearly indicates Petitioner failed in

their implementation for 9° and 10" grade.

(Warwick, JA-pg. 173-176, 122-36).

Susan Mansfield did not provide services to

Dane as part of an IEP (JA-pgs. 39-47; 216-

224), nor did she personally invite Dane to

attend individual or group counseling

6

sessions. Rather, she made a generalized

statement to 7 and 8' grade students

informing them of available services.

(Mansfield, JA-pgs. 470-471). Ms. Mansfield

acknowledged Dane not accessing those

services was appropriate. (JA-pgs. 471-472).

Further, Dane did not have the capacity to

self-advocate, which precluded him from

using services that required him to initiate

contact. (Warwick, JA-pg. 174, 129-31).

Petitioner’s claim Dane was given

preferential seating to avoid his tormentors

is without merit. The 8" grade IEP (2003-

2004) states: “Seating preference, if needed,

extra time on tests, if needed.” (JA-pg. 41).

No reference is made anywhere in this [EP

to that action being implemented for Dane

to avoid harassers. The 9” grade IEP makes

no reference to preferential seating.

(JA-pgs. 216-224).

Respondents did not refuse services as

alleged. Neither psychology nor counseling

services were part of the IEP (JA-pgs. 39-

47: 216-224). Social work services were not

designated as “group” on the IEP (/d.).

Tammy Cates testified a portion of Dane’s

permanent records were missing, including

attendance records and complete interview

notes. (JA-pgs. 371-372). Though the

8'» grade IEP called for social work services

two to four times per month (JA-pg. 42),

Ms. Cates acknowledged missing

7

appointments and possibly cancelling

“groups”. (JA-pgs. 371-372, 380-381).

Instead she relied on Dane, who could not

self-advocate, Supra at 6, to be the primary

initiator of services.

The Petitioner suggests Respondents did

not cooperate in dealing with issues of sexual

harassment and special education services.

The facts are against Petitioner on this

point. Susie Mansfield _ testified

Respondents acted appropriately in relying

on Dr. Warwick as Dane’s primary mental

health provider. (JA-pgs. 470-471, 508, 518-

519). Dane’s not accessing her group

sessions was appropriate. (/d.). Ted Adams

wrote Respondents fully cooperated with

Petitioner regarding Dane. (JA-pg. 272). His

testimony confirms this point. (Adams,

Appendix-pgs. la-2a).

Petitioner asserts “Plaintiffs’ parents

refused to allow [Dane] to meet with the

High School resource teacher.” (Petition, pg.

10). This unreferenced allegation is false

and contradicted by Dena, (JA-pg. 855), and

the Adams’ letter which states the /E'P team

decided against placing Dane in the resource

room for 9" grade. (JA-pg. 271).

Petitioner’s claim of providing resource

room services to Dane for 9" grade is also

misconstrued. Initially, Petitioner refused to

allow Dane to be assigned to Mr. Adams in

4,

5.

8

9" grade in the manner assigned in 8" grade.

(Dena, JA-pg. 855). Principal Osborne did

not believe Dane should be in the resource

room for 9“ grade. (/d. at 8&3). After

Respondents begged Mr. Osborne, he

agreed to allocate 20-30 minutes each week

for Dane to meet with Mr. Adams for

consulting services, which were called

“resource room” in the IEP (Dena,

Appendix-pgs. 10a-25a; Adams, JA-pgs. 339-

340).

Petition, pg. 31: No evidence suggests “teachers

agreed to be extra vigilant in looking after

Dane.” Sixth grade teachers did discuss with

Respondents their intention to “observe the

situation and try to handle it” (Dena, JA-pg. 813),

however, such is far from “vigilance”. No similar

expression was rendered by 7th, 8", or 9" grade

teachers.

Petition, pg. 31: “Teachers” did not offer

suggestions to help Dane better cope with his

peer related problems. Rather, one 7“ grade

teacher, Scott Marry, suggested Dane seek out

extra curricular activities, such as Science

Olympiad, to help with socialization (JA-pg. 525),

which Dane was already participating in. (David,

JA-pg. 696).

Petition pg. 31: Though principal Rozeveld

offered in 7" grade to help Dane, he ceased being

available after the first day. (Dena, JA-pgs. 844-

849).

sf

8.

9.

9

The 8" grade IEP states: “Dane received below

average grades in most academic subjects”

(JA-pg. 40), which contradicts the Petitioner’s

claim that school records confirm Dane’s grades

were largely unaffected. (Petition pg. 7);

(cf Evaluation, JA-pgs. 32-33; Adams, JA-pgs.

271-273; Report Cards, JA-pgs. 201-203).

Petition, pg. 13: Petitioner did not “adopt several

policies in response to the survey of 2002”.

Counselor Mansfield testified that every

suggestion she made after the 2002 survey was

rejected. (JA-pgs. 485, 488-495). No evidence

established that the 2002 survey led to any action

by Petitioner.

Petitioner did not initiate multiple programs from

2002-2005 aimed at combating harassment and

bullying.

a. Petition, pg. 17: Petitioner claims in 2002, it

commenced the program “40 Developmental

Assets” for staff, which had nothing to do

with sexual harassment. (Osborne, JA-pg.

594).

b. After Dane was sexually assaulted and

- permanently left campus (Johnson, JA-pg.

160, 136; Osborne, JA-pgs. 613-614),

Petitioner, in the summer of 2005, started

the Campaign for Kindness. (Dunn, JA-pg.

391-392). Bonnie Dunn was _ hired

September, 2005. (Dunn, Appendix-pg. 7a).

10

ec. Contrary to Petitioner’s claim (Petition pg.

17), the undated, unsigned and

unauthenticated document referenced, at

JA-pgs. 80-81, does not support the claim

that the “Character Counts” program was

adopted in the 2003-2004 school year, nor is

it referenced in that document.

d. Petitioner’s claim it brought in a number

of speakers from 2002-2005 to speak on

issues of bullying and harassment is

misleading. The record reflects most, if not

all, of these speakers were brought in after

Dane permanently left campus and

Ms. Dunn’s hiring in September. (Osborne,

JA-pgs. 584-586; Dunn, Appendix-pg. 7a).

Ms. Dunn testified speakers brought in by

Petitioner included Mr. Jacoby (2005-06),

Mr. Tournequist (2005-06), and Mr. Dunbar

(2005-06), who spoke primarily on issues

other than bullying or anti-bullying

approaches. (JA-pgs. 395-397). Dr. Hinsley,

a former NFL football player, spoke in 2005-

06 about achieving dreams. (Johnston, JA-

pg. 157, 113). Ms. Dunn indicated she was

unaware of any speaker from the previous

two years (2005, 2006) who had been

specifically brought in to address bullying

and harassment in the school environment.

(JA-pgs. 397-398).

Respondents challenge Petitioner’s claim of

proactive approaches with their expert Glenn Stutzky,

who opined Petitioner’s methods were not proactive and

11

that its actions and claimed presentations while Dane

was on campus (“Character Counts”, “CATS”, “Flirting

anc Hurting”, “40 Developmental Assets”, and

“Bang, Bang, You’re Dead”) were not effective tools to

address or remediate bullying and harassment.

(Stutszky, JA-pgs. 283-286).

E. Background and Overview

1. Factual Background

Dane has experienced emotional and physical

trauma related to severe and pervasive sexual

harassment, which began in 6" grade and continued in

7 and 9" grades. (Warwick, JA-pgs. 170-175, 19-14, 117-

21, 132-35; Herrick, JA-pgs. 188, 193). As a result, Dane

has been psychologically unable to enter a Hudson Area

School building, since May, 2005. (Warwick, JA-pg. 175,

133-35).

In 6" grade, Dane was frequently pushed in the hall

and called names including queer, faggot, gay, and pig.

The most frequent perpetrators were: (1) Joe R., (2)

Zach W., (3) Jessie W., (4) Nick H., (5) Sabra W,, (6) Sabin

E., and (7) Kyle M. (Dane, JA-pg. 669). These students

were reported by Dane to the principal. (Id. 670-672).

The record does not disclose any disciplinary action for

these perpetrators.

Throughout the 7“ grade year, bullying and sexual

harassment of Dane continued. (Dane, JA-pg. 673).

Dane’s experience with his peers included: (1) near daily

name-calling (fag, faggot, gay, fat pig, man boobs, big

boobs), (Dane, JA-pgs. 672-674, 752-753); (2) repeatedly

12

being called Mr. Clean, a sexually derogatory term

referring to a lack of pubic hair, (/d. at 693); (3) frequent

jostling and pushing in the hallways, (/d. at 754-755);

and (4) being slapped by Brittany C. (/d. at 678). The

primary perpetrators were the same ones identified in

sixth grade and listed above. (Jd. at 673). New offensive

names surfaced including fat and man bvobs. (Id. at 689-

690). A new perpetrator, Brandon C., was also identified.

(/d.). During the second semester the Mr. Clean

connotation surfaced, (Jd. at 692-693), with Jessie W., a

named perpetrator of that incident. (Jd. at 693). The

pervasive name calling continued throughout the year

(/d.), and was reported to Principal Rozeveld, Counselor

Mansfield, and teachers. (See above; Infra at 19). The

record does not disclose any disciplinary action for these

perpetrators.

During 7" grade, Dane ate lunch alone in the band

room to avoid the harassment. (Dane, JA-pgs. 689-690).

Throughout the year, discussions occurred between

Respondents and Petitioner’s staff over poor academic

performance, sexually derogatory name-calling, and

other issues. (David, JA-pgs. 772-790, 792-806, 808;

Dena, JA-pgs. 833, 839-843). Repeatedly, Petitioners

asked what, if anything, Dane was doing to cause the

teasing and taunting; each time Petitioner responded:

“nothing”. (David, JA-pgs 777-773; Dena, JA-pg. 833).

By the end of the first semester of 7" grade, Dane

wanted to quit school. (David, JA-pgs. 785-786). Principal

Rozeveld offered to mentor Dane to help with the

struggles. Mr. Rozeveld failed to follow through after

the first day, leaving Dane to cope for himself. (Supra

at 8).

13

By the end of 7 grade, Counselor Mansfield was

sufficiently concerned about Dane and contacted

Lenawee ISD Social Worker Tammy Cates about a

special education review. (Cates, JA-pgs. 367-368). Mrs.

Mansfield and Ms. Cates filled out a referral form, which

Mrs. Patterson signed. (Moeckel, JA-pgs. 576-577;

Dena, JA-pg. 196, 18). Respondents fully cooperated

with the IEP process. (Moeckel, JA-pgs. 573-574; Cates,

JA-pgs. 369-370).

At the beginning of the 8" grade year, a Multi-

Disciplinary Evaluation Team was convened to evaluate

Dane for special education services. (JA-pgs. 204-205).

The team found Dane to be emotionally impaired under

the Individuals with Disabilities Educational Act,

20 U.S.C. § 1400, et. seq. Ud. at 204). An IEP Team

(IEPT) was convened and a special education program

developed. (IEP-8", JA-pgs. 206-214). Dane was

assigned to Mr. Adams’ resource room up to ten hours

per week. With the assignment of Mr. Adams for resource

room services, Dane was able to cope with the 8" grade

harassment and was able to learn. (Dane, JA-pgs. 694-

695).

Dane’s IEP plan was altered for the 9" grade year.

(IEP-9", JA-pgs. 216-224). Ted Adams was no longer

available for resource room services, per Principal

Osborne. (Dena, JA-pg. 854). However, Mr. Adams

testified he began teaching high school resource room

three years before his deposition, which would have been

Dane’s 9" grade year, (JA-pg. 346) Dane, per the IEPT’s

decision, remained in general education with minimal

support. (IEP-9"", JA-pgs. 218-220). Mr. Adams served

as a contact person for Dane for a total of 20 to 30

14

minutes each week. (Dena, JA-pgs. 856-857), but this

was significantly less contact than in 8" grade.

In September of the 9" grade year (2004), the

bullying and harassment experienced at the level of 7

grade resumed. (Cne, JA-pgs. 697-731). Immediately,

Dane began to hear such words as gay, fag, faggot, and

queer being directed at him. (/d. at 729-730). In addition

the jostling, bumping, pushing and shoving in the

hallways resumed. (/d. at 716-717). These things became

multiple occurrences on a near daily basis. (/d. at 716-

717, 729-730). Perpetrators were identified as: (1) Joe

R., (2) Jeff L., (3) Cody F, (4) Jessie W., and (5) Sabin E.

(Jd. at 708). Joe R., Jessie W, and Sabin EH. were

previously identified as perpetrators in 6” and 7

grade. Reports of these incidents were made by Dane

to Principal Osborne. (Id. at 703-705). The record does

not disclose any disciplinary action for these

perpetrators for these incidences.

In mid-September, the Mr. Clean label resumed,

with an incident involving (1) Billy H., (2) Sheila C., and

(3) Kelly W., (David, JA-pgs. 697-699), which brought back

negative memories from 7“ grade. (Jd. at 698). Three

persons were reported to Counselor Mansfield, who

called these students into a meeting with Dane. These

perpetrators apologized, but no disciplinary action wus

administered, (Id. at 702), since Mrs. Mansfield, as

counselor, could not administer discipline. (Mansfield,

JA-pg. 500). Instead, they were sent back to class.

(Id. at 514). School policy required referral to

administrators. The 2004 policy on bullying, which

included harassment, funnels all complaints to

15

administration. (JA-pg. 277). The Student Code of

Conduct® requires sexual harassers to be sent to the

principal. (JA-pg. 306).

On December 10, 2004, Dane’s daily planner was

defaced in class with sexually derogatory slurs—“I love

penis”, “I lick it in the ass”—and sexually explicit

drawings of a buttock and penis (Dane, JA-pgs. 721-724)

by Joe R. (/d. at 717-718) and Jeff L. (Osborne, JA-pg.

597). Dane reported the incident to the office. (Dane,

JA-pgs. 721-724). This was not Joe R.’s first incident

which Dane reported to Respondent. (Supra at 11-15).

Both students received a verbal reprimand from

Mr. Osborne. (JA-pgs. 597-598).

A second Mr. Clean incident occurred on December

14, 2004 involving Kyle M. and Jeff L. (Osborne, JA-pg.

598; Dane, JA-pgs. 724-725), in which a Mr. Clean poster

was taped to Dane’s locker. This was reported to Mr.

Osborne. (Dane, JA-pg. 725). Fach of these individuals

had been previously reported to Petitioner as harassers.

(Supra at 11-12, 14-15). Kyle received a verbal

reprimand. Jeff received a one day suspension for what

Mr. Osborne described as “teasing.” (JA-pg. 598).

Apparently his verbal reprimand four days before failed

to deter his behavior towards Dane; thereby

undercutting the Petitioner’s claim of 100%

effectiveness in its responses.

Near the end of the first semester of 9'" grade, an

incident involving Sabin E. occurred in history class

where oral presentations were made by students, using

note cards. (Dane, JA-pgs. 707-711). Sabin wrote a series

6 Hereafter “Code”

16

of words on the back of his note cards with the first card

designating “Dane”, the second “is”, the third “a”, and

the fourth “fag”. This act caused intense laughter,

humiliating Dane. (Dane, JA-pgs. 708). Sabin was

reported to Counselor Mansfield (Dane, JA-pgs. 707-

711), who called him out of class and told Sabin his action

was possibly sexual harassment. (JA-pgs. 521-522).

Contrary to policy, as referenced above, Sabin was not

referred to the principal even though this was not

Sabin’s first incident involving Dane reporting to

Petitioner. (Dane, JA-pgs. 669, 673, 675, 703).

During the second semester of this 9" grade year

(2005), Dane’s main hallway locker was vandalized by

students with permanent markers writing such things

as gay, fag, and queer, up and down the locker. (Dane,

JA-pgs. 712-716). A graphic picture was also drawn,

depicting a penis being inserted into a rectum. (David,

JA-pg. 805). The inside of Dane’s locker was also defaced

with writing including faggot, queer, and you suck penis

and other similar phrases. (7d. at 805). Mortified, Dane

ran out of the building. (Jd. at 804-805). This incident

was reported to Mr. Durbin. (Dane, JA-pg. 715). School

officials cleaned the exterior surface of the locker, after

the incident was reported, but failed to clean the interior,

leaving Dane and Mr. Adams to clean it (David, JA-pg.

806; Dane, JA-pgs. 712-713). Dane reported hearing that

Derrick G. and Kyle M. were the perpetrators. (/d. at

714-715). Kyle M. was also engaging in other acts of

teasing and ridicule of Dane over the years, including

the incident of December 14", 2004. (Dane, JA-pgs. 669,

673, 715-716, 724). (Supra at 11-12, 15).

17

On March 11, 2005, Dane’s gym locker was broken

into. His clothes were removed, urinated on, and his

tennis shoes thrown into the toilet. (Dane, JA-pgs. 726-

728). Tyler Walden reported Dane’s gym locker was also

covered with shaving cream spelling out sexually

oriented words. (JA-pg. 152, 114). A report was made to

Mr. Durbin of a name mentioned by the rumor mill — i.e.

Derrick G. (Dane, JA-pg. 727-728).

Later, in the spring of 2005, Dane went to his main

hallway locker to find a poster of “Mr. Clean” taped on

the locker. (Dane, JA-pgs. 724-726). He reported this

incident to Mr. Osborne. (/d. at 725-726).

Lastly, Dane was sexually assaulted in the locker

room after baseball practice on May 23, 2005. (Dane,

JA-pgs. 730-737). The primary perpetrator, Lance, while

naked, forced Dane into a corner, hoisted himself up onto

Dane’s shoulders and took his penis and scrotum and

rubbed them against the back of Dane’s neck and

striking the side of his face with his penis. (/d.). A

detailed description of the assault is set forth by Dane

in the police report. (JA-pg. 260). Lance attended school

the Monday after the incident, even though Principal

Osborne knew of the assault Saturday morning. (Dena,

JA-pgs. 858-859). At the end of the day on Monday,

Lance was suspended for the remaining 8-1/2 days of

the school year. (Osborne, JA-pg. 596). On June 10, 2005,

Lance was charged in the Probate Court with Assault

With Intent to Commit a Felony and Criminal Sexual

Conduct - 2"* Degree. (Records, JA-pg. 301). The

Petitioner’s internal investigation was completed in

May, 2005 (Durbin, Appendix-pg. 8a) yet, Lance was not

18

formally expelled until August, 2005. (Osborne, JA-pgs.

601-603). Dane struggled completing the year after the

assault. (See Appendix-pgs. 12a-14a, for more detail).

Another student, Nick H., closed the door and

prevented Dane’s escape from the locker room during

the assault. (Statement of Billy H. JA-pg. 264; Dane,

JA-pgs. 731-732). No punishment, as required by the

Code, was given to Nick (Code, JA-pgs. 306, 308-309);

instead a verbal reprimand was issued. (Durbin, JA-pg.

434). This incident was not Nick’s first with Dane to be

reported to the Petitioner. (Supra at 11-12). So severe

was this incident that Billy H. Reported in a written

statement, that he told Lance, “What are you doing -

Dane’s going to go off on you someday.” (Report, JA-

pg. 264).

Petitioner, at the time of the sexual assault, had a

policy of supervision in the locker room, which had not

been followed for a long of time, (Durbin, JA-pgs. 437-

439), and was not followed at the time of the assault.

(Dane, JA-pgs. 732-734).

Jeremy Beal, the varsity baseball coach, treated the

sexual assault, as a joke. (Walden, JA-pg. 153, 124; Wade,

JA-pgs. 232-233, 122-23). Convening a team meeting of

junior varsity and varsity players, Coach Beal, in front

of Dane and other players, told players they should only

joke with men who can take it - thereby implying

sexually assaulting another person was an acceptable

manner of joking, if the victim could take it. (Walden,

JA-pg. 153, 124). Coach Beal also emphatically stated

he was not going to start supervising the locker room.

(Dena, JA-pgs. 861-862).

19

The cumulative effect of these incidents, combined

with the sexual assault, psychologically and educationally

devastated Dane. (See Warwick, JA-pgs. 172-175, 119-

21, 130, 132-35, for more details). Dane has not returned

to the District or entered a District building since the

end of his 9” grade year. (Osborne, JA-pgs. 613-614).

In the aftermath of the sexual assault, Dane’s IEP

programing was modified to provide off-site home bound

services at Sacred Heart Elementary School. (IEP-10"",

JA-pgs. 235-247). This IEP was not successfully

implemented. (Warwick, JA-pgs. 173-174, 126-28). After

Dr. Warwick pointed out Petitioner’s failure to properly

implement the 10" grade IEP the IEPT reconvened and

determined that Dane should obtain future credits by

attending college courses. (Dena, JA-pg. 198, 115; IEP-

11", JA-pgs. 247-258). That program was partially

successful in that Dane did not experience bullying or

sexual harassment and actually experienced teachers

who cared and were concerned about his education.

(Dane, JA-pgs. 749-751). However, it has not been

without its challenges. (Dena, JA-pg. 198, 112-14).

2. History of Reporting

Contrary to the Petitioner’s claims, Respondents

and Dane, frequently and regularly reported issues and

incidents of bullying and sexual harassment. (Opinion,

JA-pgs. 323-324; Dane, JA-pgs. 670, 674, 678-679, 697-

698, 703-709, 714-717, 724-728, 731-747; David, JA-pgs.

788, 794, 798-799, 805-807). Staff corroborated the

extensive reporting by Respondents. (Mansfield, JA-

pgs. 505-508, 510-513, 520; Marry, JA-pgs. 534-536;

Mason, JA-pg. 561, Adams, Appendix-pgs 2a-5a).

20

3. School Policy and Its Implementation

At all relevant times Respondent published in its

student handbook a mission statement (JA-pg. 274),

which recited basic core values. To implement its mission

statement, Petitioner adopted certain policies on issues

of bullying, harassment and sexual harassment.

(Policies, JA-pgs. 275-280). The 2002 policy on

Harassment of Students stated: “Harassment of

students is prohibited, and will not be tolerated.” This

policy covered student-on-student harassment.

Harassment was defined as “inappropriate conduct

which is repeated enough, or serious enough, to

negatively impact a student’s educational, physical or

emotional well-being.” Staff repeatedly characterized

the policy as either not allowing harassment or zero

tolerance. (Manion, JA-pg. 456; Durbin, JA-pg. 414;

Marry, JA-pgs. 538-539). Sexual harassment, a sub-

category of the anti-harassment. policy, is defined to

include: a) verbal harassment or abuse, . . . c) repeated

remarks with sexual or demeaning implications, .. . e)

sexual jokes, posters, cartoons, etc.” (Policies, JA-pg.

276)

Petitioner adopted a policy in 2004 on Bullying And

Other Aggressive Behavior Towards Students. Ud. at

277-280), which stated that the board is committed to

providing “a safe, positive, productive and nurturing

education environment for all of the students,” (Ud. at

277), and stated that “aggressive behavior towards a

student, whether by other students, staff, or third party

is strictly prohibited and will not be tolerated.” (/d.).

Aggressive behavior included “inappropriate conduct

that is repeated enough, or serious encugh, to

21

negatively impact a student’s educational, physical or

emotional well-being,” (/d.). These policies are set forth

in six pages of printed policy materials. Each has a

reporting requirement with the bullying policy (which

includes harassment) requiring reporting to

administration. (JA-pg. 277). The six pages are sparsely

reflected in the nine pages of the Code. (Code, JA-pgs.

302-310). Eleven lines of those nine pages (1) discussed

sexual harassment to include “unsolicited and

unwelcome sexual comments and overtures”, (2) called

it misconduct, and (3) urged repo*'ting to administration.

(JA-pg. 304). The definition is not consistent with the

one set forth in Petitioner’s Harassment of Students

policy. (JA-pg. 276).

Contrary to Petitioner’s claims, staff is not well-

trained on these policies. Staff indicated they spent little

time training on the specific subjects of harassment,

sexual harassment and bullying. Staff varied on the

amount of time spent during in-service training on

issues of bullying and harassment. Teacher Marry

indicated staff training included 15-30 minutes on

bullying and another 15-30 on harassment. (Marry, JA-

pgs. 543-544). Teacher Mason testified staff spent

1% to 2 hours on the Code. (Mason, JA-pgs. 566-567).

Andy Wade had no training. (Wade, JA-pgs. 228-230, 19).

These are just a few examples of the inconsistencies of

staff members regarding the amount of time spent

reviewing the Code and policy in relationship to bullying,

harassment and sexual harassment.

22

Discovery confirmed inconsistent understanding by

staff of issues of harassment, sexual harassment, and

bullying. Comments included:

1.

bo

Media Director Bunting testified: (a) bullying is

a student invading the space of another student,

which regularly occurred at Hudson; (b)

harassment as the same thing as bullying; (c) she

handles bullying informally; (d) name calling,

such as gay, fag, faggot, queer and lesbian is a

frequent occurrence at Hudson; (e) she has

personally observed students shoving other

students in her classroom and in the hallways;

(f) she rarely spends more than five minutes total

in the hallways during any given day; (g) she

indicated “students will be students” thereby

minimizing the significance of these events.

(JA-pgs. 357-360).

Teacher Manion testified: (a) bullying is giving

another peson a tough time in order to demean

them; (b) harassment is the same as bullying; (c)

she has seen incidents of bullying over her years

at Hudson; (d) she has heard name calling (gay

and other sexually graphic names); (e) she has

her own standard of discipline for these things,

which did not include a formal write up and office

notification. (JA-pgs. 445-450).

Counselor Mansfield testified: (a) she could not

specifically define bullying because it included

a complex set of parameters; (b) being called fat,

fag, and gay on a regular basis was considered

bullying; (c) physical violence constituted bullying

23

or harassment; (d) being jostled or shoved into a

locker on a regular basis would be deemed

harassment; (e) being called gay, fag, faggot or

fat pig is harassment; (f) sexually oriented

graphic content painted on a locker is

harassment, as is urinating on a person’s

clothing or throwing gym shoes in a toilet. (JA-

pgs. 499-504). In the context of staff preparations

for a school year, sexual harassment was

discussed, but not as a formal agenda item at

staff meetings, and was only covered in general

cerms. (/d. at 502).

Teacher Marry testified: (a) bullying occurs

“when anyone touches or makes another student

feel unwanted or uncomfortable in my classroom

and interferes with my teaching”, and (b) sexual

harassment is worse. Responses to such

incidents are left to individual teacher’s

discretion. (JA-pgs. 538-539).

. Teacher Mason testified: (a) teasing is

intentionally saying things to hurt another

person’s feelings; (b) bullying is intimidating

someone with words or actions; (c) harassment

is repeatedly intimidating another person; (d)

she has heard students use the terms fag, gay,

faggot and queer in the serool environment.

When confronted with those issues, she refers

students to Counselor Mansfield, not

administrators. (JA-pgs. 562-564).

Teacher Adams informed Angela Johnston that

the District did not have a consistent and formal

24

plan to deal with bullying, nor the support of the

administration to respond to these issues.

(Johnston JA-pg. 158, 118-22).

These comments reveal teachers did not have a uniform

understanding of Petitioner’s Policy on “harassment”,

“sexual harassment”, and “bullying”, nor had consistent

responses towards said behaviors. This issue is

reinforced by the Affidavit of Andrew Wade, (Wade, JA-

pgs. 227-230, 17-9), who stated, as a coach and as a

permanent substitute teacher, he received no training

at all on these issues. This evidence contradicts

Petitioner’s assertion that staff is well-trained. Staff

did not recognize the mandatory requirement of the

policy on bullying to report matters to an administrator.

Supra at 14-16 (Mansfield), 22 (Bunting, Manion), 23

(Marry, Mason).

Students also were not uniformly and consistently

instructed on issues of bullying, harassment and sexual

harassment. Assistant Princinal Durbin testified that

the Code was presented to students annually at an

assembly or conducted grade-by-grade, said manner

having been used for years. (Durbin, JA-pgs. 428-429).

Teacher Marry indicated that the Code was

disseminated by teachers on the first day of each

academic year as part of first period and, if time

permitted, was reviewed with the students. He allocated

between 1-45 minutes to discuss the Code, “time

permitting”. (JA-pgs. 540-542). Teacher Mason indicated

that she spent 20-25 minutes on the first day of class

each year discussing the Code (JA-pgs. 565-566).

25

Students contradicted staff regarding presentation

of the Code. Sara Dempsey stated teachers would read

the student handbook, but not explain the terms or the

material. (JA-pgs. 133-134, 16). Ryan Hobbs indicated

teachers did not go over the Code, but rather sent the

handbook home with them. (JA-pg. 138, 19,). Emily Kline,

in 13 years of attendance at Hudson, remembered only

two occasions when teachers reviewed the Code with

her class and only by reading it without explanation.

(JA-pg. 145, 110).

As to issues of harassment in the environment,

Assistant Principal Durbin testified, (Durbin, JA-pgs.

415-421, 424-427): (a) harassment is continuous and

repeated acts of a negative nature; (b) core values of

Hudson are violated by bullying, harassment and sexual

derogatory name calling; (c) sex ally oriented language

could undermine core values, if the student doesn’t feel

safe; (d) sexually derogatory name calling is a violation

of core values; (e) repetitive name calling of gay, fag,

etc., directed towards someone violates core values;

(f) pushing and shoving someone in the hallways and

into lockers violates core values; and (g) for discipline

to be effective it must be consistent and fairly applied.

Mr. Durbin acknowledged that he was personally aware

of students that did not feel safe at school (/d. at 418),

which was supported by Sarah Dempsey. (JA-pg. 134,

113-14).

Glen Stutszky, Respondent’s expert on school

abuse, bullying and harassment, opined Petitioner was

not proactive in addressing bullying and harassment and

also lacked understanding of the condition and

environment as to these issues. (Stutzky, JA-pgs. 283-

26

286, 17-8). Bonnie Dunn acknowledged Mr. Stutszky as

a leading expert in this field. (Dunn, JA-pg. 386).

Proactive methods, which are essential in combating

a hostile environment, were not implemented in this

District. (Dunn, JA-pgs. 385-386, 398-404; Stutzky, JA-

pgs. 283-285, 17-8). Petitioner has no expert to contradict

Mr. Stutzky.

Counselor Mansfield testified, (JA-pgs. 485-494): (a)

for the 2002-2003 school year, the counseling

department (ith her efforts) conducted an all school

survey which included issues of bullying, harassment

and sexual harassment, to obtain a feel for the

environment and determine how to allocate counseling

resources; (b) the survey revealed feelings throughout

the student body of a need for counseling services

relating to areas of bullying and sexual harassment; (c)

to address issues of bullying and harassment, she

suggested programs to address these issues by raising

awareness; and (d) these items needed to be part of a

proactive approach. Her proposed proactive plan

related to bullying, harassment, and sexual

harassment was rejected by Superintendent Malnar,

who did not believe they would do any good. Immediately

thereafter, her department staff was cut and she was

unable to implement any programs.

Bonnie Dunn was hired, after the sexual assault

upon Dane, by the District as a Community and School’s

Coordinator. She conducted a student survey at the

beginning of the 2005-2006 academic year, specifically

related to bullying. (JA-pgs. 391-392), which revealed

the following results: (a) Petitioner continued to have a

bullying issue which needed to be addressed;

27

(b) students perceived bullying as a problem, that there

was not a consistent disciplinary response to these

issues, and that nothing would be done about it. She

also indicated: it takes years of effort to combat the

effects of teasing, taunting and harassment and to break

the cycle of those activities (/d. at 401); Petitioner

needed to implement a formal school wide proactive anti-

bullying program, uniform from grades K-12 to

effectively combat bullying and harassment (/d. at 385);

a consistent disciplinary policy in response to bullying,

harassment and teasing was necessary to successfully

combat these things (/d. at 406-407); and lack of a

consistent disciplinary policies created an impression

within the student body that undermines efforts to deal

with bullying and harassing (/d. at 407).

REASONS FOR DENYING THE PETITION

The Sixth Circuit Opinion is based on a lucid analysis

of the facts and procedural rules regarding summary

judgment review, does not conflict with any decision of

this Court nor any Court of Appeals, and is not

impractical. Petitioner cites to several “undisputed”

facts, which have been properly disputed by the

Respondent. In its Opinion, the Majority correctly drew

all reasonable inferences in the Respondent’s favor. The

Majority was also consistent with existing precedent and

ruled that several persuasive cases touted by Petitioner

as factually analogous were distinguishable. Petitioner

also made no attempt to distinguish a persuasive case

that the Majority described as “strikingly similar.”

Lastly, Petitioner argues that by correctly following

summary judgment standards and remanding a case

with material issues of fact back to trial, the Majority’s

28

decision is impractical and will open the floodgates of

litigation against school districts. This argument is

without merit because the Majority’s holding did not

find liability against Petitioner, but rather correctly

stated that under the present facts, the case should

proceed to trial, a decision which does not set impractical

standards. Accordingly, it is not appropriate for this

Court to grant certiorari, nor has Petitioner carried their

burden of demonstrating any “compelling reasons” for

the Petition to be granted. See Sup. Ct. R. 10.

I. The Majority Below Contains a Lucid Analysis

of Facts and Procedural Standards Regarding

Summary Judgment Review

The Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals, in Patterson,

551 F.3d at 444, cites the correct standard for reviewing

summary judgment. The Court is to review all the

evidence and “draw all reasonable inferences in favor

of the nonmoving party.” Crawford v. Metro. Guv’t of

Nashville and Davidson County, _ U.S. __, 129 S.Ct.

846, 850, FN1, 172 L.Ed.2d 650 (2009) (citations omitted).

It must also determine “whether the evidence presents

a sufficient disagreement to require submission to a jury

or whether it is so one-sided that one party must prevail

as a matter of law.” Anderson v. Liberty Lobby, Inc.,

477 U.S. 242, 251-252, 106 S.Ct. 2505, 91 L.Ed.2d 202

(1986). This Court has determined that a dispute over a

material fact is “genuine” if “the evidence is such that a

reasonable jury could return a verdict for the nonmoving

party.” Jd. at 248.

Respondent has outlined in detail many disputes of

material fact presently existing in this case. Supra at 2-

29

27. The Majority noted several disputes of material fact.

Patterson, 551 F.3d at 446, FN 6, (use of the resource

room and Mr. Adams); see also 7d. at 450, FN10,

(Petitioner’s “proactive” measures of dealing with

harassment). The Majority correctly viewed the

evidence in the light most favorable to Respondents,

and even chastised the Dissent for weighing conflicting

evidence in the moving party’s favor. /d. at 445-446, FN6.

Lastly, while the Majority correctly dismissed the

Dissent’s “100% effective” argument, the Majority

focuses on the harassment Dane suffered in the 9" grade

alone. When considering the previous years of reported

harassment, it clearly shows that Petitioner’s responses

were not 100% effective against individual harassers,

but that Petitioner had notice some students who

harassed Dane in 6 and 7 grade also harassed him

against in 9" grade. Supra at 11-14. Given the many

disputes of fact in the present case, precedent compels

the Court to draw all reasonable inferences in favor of

Respondents. The Majority correctly applied this

standard and found summary judgment was

inappropriate pending resolution of those factual issues.

II. The Majority Correctly Follows Controlling Case

Law

Petitioner asserts the Majority conflicts with this

Court’s opinion in Davis, 526 U.S. 629, and its

“progeny”. Under Davis, a plaintiff must show the

following elements to establish a prima facie case of

student-on-student sexual harassment under Title [X:

(1) the sexual harassment was so severe, pervasive,

and objectively offensive that it could be said

30

to deprive the plaintiff of access to the

educational opportunities or benefits provided

by the school;

(2) the funding recipient had actual knowledge of

the sexual harassment; and

(3) the school was deliberately indifferent to the

harassment.

Davis, at 653. The relevant inquiry at the Sixth Circuit

was whether Petitioner acted with deliberate

indifference.

“(The deliberate indifference must, at a minimum,

cause [students] to undergo” harassment or “make them

liable or vulnerable” to it. /d. at 645 (citations omitted).

While the respondent in Davis contended that expulsion

should be required for every student accused of sexually

harassing another, the Court rejected the idea that a

district must purge “their schools of actionable peer

harassment or... engage in particular disciplinary

action.” Jd. at 648. Indeed, the Court noted that “[s]chool

administrators will continue to enjoy the flexibility they

require so long as funding recipients are deemed

‘deliberately indifferent’ to acts of student-on-student

harassment only where the recipient’s response to the

harassment or lack thereof is clearly unreasonable in

light of the known circumstances.” /d.

Respondents agree a district does not have to purge

or eradicate peer harassment, but, is liable for such

harassment when its response or lack of response is

clearly unreasonable in light of the known

31

circumstances. Davis, 526 U.S. at 648. Therefore, a

school district must “merely respond to known peer

harassment in a manner that is not clearly

unreasonable.” Id. at 648-649 (Emphasis added).

A. The Majority Does Not Conflict With Davis

Nor Vance

In forming its ruling, the Sixth Circuit relied on its

decision in Vance, 231 F.3d 253. Vance correctly cited to

and analyzed the facts of that case under the Davis

standard described above. /d. at 260. The Sixth Circuit

also asserted that

where a school district has knowledge that its

remedial action is inadequate and ineffective,

it is required to take reasonable action in light

of those circumstances to eliminate behavior.

Where a school district has actual knowledge

that its efforts to remediate are ineffective,

and it continues to use those same methods

to no avail, such district has failed to act

reasonably in light of the known

circumstances.

Jd, at 261. By this statement the Sixth Circuit rejected

that Spencer County’s argument that “as long as a

school] district does something in response to

harassment, it has satisfied the standard.” /d. at 260.

This language in Vance is consistent with the holding in

Davis; in both cases, the respective districts failed to

change their remedial action despite continued

harassment against a student.

32

Petitioner makes a three-fold argument that the

Majority conflicts with existing precedent: (1) that

multiple cases suggest that any mere response satisfies

the Davis standard; (2) that certain language in the

Vance holding does not apply to this case because the

harassment suffered by Dane was not as “egregious”

and Vance is, therefore, factually distinguishable; and

(3) that the Majority’s Opinion requires schools to

“remedy” or “purge” themselves of sexual harassment

to survive at the summary judgment level.

First, as the Sixth Circuit Opinion clearly noted,

Vance rejects the notion that any response satisfies the

Davis standard. Patterson, 551 F.3d at 448. Cases cited

by Petitioner for this proposition are clearly

distinguishable: (1) Rost v. Steamboat Springs RE-2

Sch. Dist., 511 F.3d 1114, 1121-24 (10th Cir. 2008) (issues

of reporting the harassment and the school deferred to

police because it believed the incidents happened off

school grounds); (2) Doe v. Dallas Indep. Sch. Dist., 220

F.3d 380 (5th Cir. 2000) (involved sexual harassment of

a student by a teacher); (3) Fitzgerald v. Barnstable Sch.

Comm., 504 F.3d 165, 174 (1st Cir. 2007) (involved

harassment by one student, who rejected the allegations

and was found credible by the administration and the;

(4) Bd. of County Comm ’rs of Bryan County, Okla. v.

Brown, 520 U.S. 397, 407 (1997) (pre-Davis standard);

(5) Wilson v. Beaumont Indep. School Dist., 144

F.Supp.2d 690 (E.D. Tex. 2001) (distinguished at

Patterson, 551 F.3d 449, FN 8); (6) and Johnson v.

Independent Sch. Dist., 194 F.Supp.2d 939, 948 (Dist.

Minn. 2002) (also distinguished at Patterson, 551 F.3d

449, FN 8).

33

Furthermore, as noted by the Majority, Petitioner

does not attempt to distinguish analogous case law with

unfavorable rulings, specifically Theno v. Tonganowxie

Unified Sch. Dist. No. 464, 377 F.Supp.2d 952, 966

(D. Kan. 2005), which the Majority appropriately found

persuasive and “illustrative” because of the “striking

similarities” between the cases. Patterson, 551 F.3d. at

446-449. Other persuasive cases suggest certain failures

by a school district may constitute deliberate

indifference. Murrell v. Sch. Dist. No. 1, Denver, Col.,

186 F.3d 1238, 1249 (10th Cir. 1999); Morlock v. West Cent.

Educ. Dist., 46 FSupp.2d 892, 909-910 (D. Minn. 1999);

Montgomery v. Indep. School District No. 709, 109

F.Supp.2d 1081, 1095 (D. Minn. 2000); Schroeder v.

Maumee Bd. Of Educ., 296 F.Supp.2d 869, 880 (N.D. Ohio

2003).

There is sufficient case law to contradict Petitioner’s

assertion that any response is enough to satisfy the

Davis standard. The persuasive authority cited by

Petitioner is not controlling nor is factually analogous.

Indeed, Davis alone contradicts this assertion — a

district’s mere responses must not be clearly

unreasonable. Davis, 526 U.S. at 648-649.

Second, Petitioner attempts to narrowly construe

the Vance holding as applying only to cases with a similar

factual background, i.e., that offending students must

re-offend, and the school district must continue to repeat

the same ineffective responses to those offenders to

create an issue for the trier of fact as to what is clearly

unreasonable. Neither Davis, Vance, nor any post-

Vance authority asserts this proposition. Instead, Vance

rejects a minimalist response to known severe,

34

pervasive, and objectively offensive harassment against

a student. Jd. 231 F.3d at 260. Even if the Petitioner’s

standard would apply, which Respondent challenges, the

evidence in this case suggests that the Petitioner did

repeat ineffective responses against know offenders.

Supra at 11-14.

Further, the Dissent and Petitioner recite, but

misstate, several key facts in Vance. The facts, identify

several offenders from November 1992 to August 1995,

oniy some of which were re-offenders. Vance, 231 F.3d

at 256-258. The Sixth Circuit, cited to three instances

that showed Spencer’s deliberate indifference, none of

which involved a re-offending student. Jd. at 262. After

referencing these instances, the Sixth Circuit noted “in

numerous instances, Spencer continued to use the same

ineffective methods to no acknowledged avail.” /d.

Third, Petitioner misconstrues the Majority’s

holding by focusing on the use of the word “prevent”

without providing the correct context for that word.

“As explained above, Hudson’s success with individual

students did not prevent the over-all and continuing

harassment of DP a fact of which Hudson was fully

aware, and thus Hudson’s isolated success with

individual perpetrators cannot shield Hudson from

liability as a matter of law.” Patterson, 551 F'3d at 449.

Previously, the Majority had outlined the Vance

framework as to what is unreasonable. “We believe this

language makes clear that, even though a school district

takes some action in response to known harassment, if

further harassment continues, a jury is not precluded

by law from finding that the school district’s response

is clearly unreasonable.” Patterson, 551 F.3d at 448. In

35

other words, the Majority states, citing Theno, 377

F.Supp.2d 952 as persuasive authority, that continuing

harassment against a student puts a school district on

notice that its responses to said harassment may not be

effective, thus creating a potential triable issue of fact

as to whether or not the responses were clearly

unreasonable. In the present case, the trier of fact is

also required to determine what responses Petitioner

actually implemented to combat vne sexual harassment

against Dane. Patterson, 551 F'3d at 446, FN 6. Thus,

the Majority correcily followed the relevant and binding

authority.

B. The Majority Below Is Not In Conflict With

The Third Circuit, As Doe v. Bellefonte Area

School Dist., Is Factually Distinguishable

Following the drum of the Dissent, Petitioner has

touted Doe v. Bellefonte Area Sch. Dist., 2003 WL

23718302 (M.D. Pa. Sept. 29, 2003), aff’d 106 Fed. Appx.

798 (3rd Cir. 2004) as having “substantially similar facts.”

In Doe, the district court set out the pertinent facts at

2003 WL 23718302, *2-6. The facts showed that Doe

suffered systematic verbal sexual harassment with

multiple offenders over a period of several years. The

facts also showed questions regarding Doe’s reporting,

and Doe’s willingness to accept the district’s methods

of responding to the harassment.

Over the years, the responses to the harassing

students varied: (1) a two day suspension with two

detentions; (2) keeping a student apart from Doe; (3) a

verbal warning in the face of a denial from the offending

student; (4) moving Doe and his friends to a different

36

study hall; (5) a verbal warning to a student who

harassed Doe two years prior; (6) a detention; (7) an

apology with a full day detention; and (8) a three-day

suspension along with a detention for Doe after he

traded insults and sexually harassing words with

another student. Jd.

Responses in addition to disciplining offending

students included: (1) four memoranda circulated to

teachers regarding Doe’s situation and sexual

harassment; (2) a gym-class discussion on name-calling;

(3) a meeting with Doe, Doe’s parents, and school

administrators; (4) the offer of a hallway “buddy” for

Doe; (5) placing Doe on the “Anti-harassment

Committee”; (6) allowing Doe special procedures to

report harassment not given to other students; and (7)

policies, assemblies, and speakers specifically

addressing harassment. /d.

The present case and Doe are factually

distinguishable. As noted by the Majority:

Doe... is different from this case in two

material respects. First, in Doe, the school

district did more to prevent the systematic

harassment of Doe than Hudson did in instant

case. Specifically, the school district gave Doe

“e special means of reporting any additionai

harassment,” circulated memoranda specific

to Doe’s harassment issues to the faculty in

hopes of preventing future harassment, and

“held assemblies and enacted policies

addressing peer-to-peer harassment.” Doe,

106 Fed. Appx. at 809. As outlined above, when

37

viewing the facts in the light most favorable

to the Pattersons, we observe that Hudson

did not perform any of these services during

DP’s night-grade year. Thus, Doe is

distinguishable from the instant case by the

effort the school district devoted to

preventing future harassment.

Patterson, 551 F.3d 448, FN 7. Secondly, the Majority

noted that Doe neither cites to nor is bound by Vance,

rebutting the Dissent’s contention that Doe tacitly

rejected the Majority’s interpretation of Vanre.

Lastly, it should be noted the school policy in Doe

gave the district the discretion to choose the

punishment for harassing students. No punishments

were mandated. It appears that as the verbal

harassment against Doe continued, the Doe district

moved from verbal warnings to tougher punishments,

culminating into two punishments for the reported

incidents in Doe’s final year: an apology and a full day.

suspension for a student who yelled “[Doe] is sexy” out

of a classroom window, and a three day suspension for a

student with whom Doe traded sexually harassing

insults. Doe, 2003 WL 23718302, at *5.

In summary, even though harassment continued

from new offenders, the Doe district did not just repeat

the same ineffective responses. The Doe district

increased the severity of the punishment for offending

students and attempted other means at addressing the

harassment issue.

38

III. The Majority’s Opinion Is Not Impractical,

Rather Is Based On Sound Logic

Petitioner warns that the Majority, in effect, opens

the floodgates of litigation because it sets nearly

impossible standards and schools must now “prevent”

future harassment by unidentified harassers. Again,

Petitioner misconstrues the Majority’s holding.

As stated by the Sixth Circuit Majority,

[w]e emphasize that, at this state of the

litigation, the Pattersons are not required to

prove that Hudson is actually liable for the

continued harassment of DP (i.e., that

Hudson’s actions were clearly unreasonable),

but only that there is a genuine issue of

material fact as to whether Hudson was

deliberately indifferent to the harassment.

Patterson, 551 F3d at 450.

The Third Circuit, in the previously analyzed Doe v.

Bellefonte Area School Dist., states an identical

standard: “[w]e agree with the District Court that Doe

failed to adduce evidence to create a germane issue as

to whether the actions taken by the School District in

response to the allegations were clearly unreasonable

and therefore that the School District could not have

been found deliberately indifferent.” Doe, 106 Fed.Appx.

at 799.

The difference in the facts '2d to the determination.

In Doe, the court found no genuine issue of material

39

fact which suggested the district’s responses were

clearly unreasonable, thus the district, as a matter of

law, could not be found to be deliberately indifferent. In

the present case, the Sixth Circuit found that genuine

issues of material fact existed, thus Petitioner could not

be shielded from liability as a matter of law.

While the Sixth Circuit did not impose liability

against Petitioner, it allows for the possibility of a jury

to do so. Petitioner bootstrapped to its argument

confidential settlement offers between the parties in

attempt to show the potential cost to Hudson. This

settlement offer has not been made part of this record,

thus is not properly before this Court. To suggest that

the Sixth Circuit’s Opinion automatically creates or

imposes some financial liability on school districts

misconstrues the holding. With the present facts, there

is a genuine issue of material fact as to Petitioner’s

deliberate indifference, because despite continuing

harassmerit against Dane, Hudson implemented the

same responses, refusing to comply with their own

policies and procedures, and refusing to attempt any

alternative means of dealing with the harassment. This

is in direct contrast to the actions of the school district

in Doe. Thus, the Sixth Circuit’s Opinion changes

nothing, because it conforms with precedent established

in Davis and Vance, and also recognizes persuasive

authority from other districts.

40

CONCLUSION

Petitioner has not established any compelling

reasons for this Court to grant the Petition.

Respondents respectfully request this Petition be

denied.

Respectfully submitted,

TERRY E.. HEIss

Counsel of Record

TerrY E.. HEIss, PC.

6440 East Fulton St.

Suite 201

Ada, MI 49301

(616) 676-3850

JEFFREY P ARNSON

LAW OFFICE OF JEFFREY

P Arnson, PLLC

6440 East Fulton St.

Suite 201

Ada, MI 49301

(616) 676-3850

Counsel for Respondents

APPENDIX

la

Excerpt of Deposition of Ted Adams - November 7,

2006, filed in district court

Transcript - Page 10:

Q.

A.

> &

Pd

oP

Transcript - Page 11

Q.

Describe the Pattersons as parents.

The Pattersons are supportive parents. They

like to be communicated with to know the status

of their students' education. I'm speaking from

an educator's standpoint now right now.

Sure.

ere Supportive, and follow through when asked

to do something, and they in turn have

communicated things to me that they would like

followed up on.

Such as what?

Primarily academic issues, missing

assignments, slipping grades, those kind of

things.

Have you ever thought to yourself or expressed

to anyone a belief or a feeling that the

Pattersons are too involved in their children's

education?

I have never expressed that.

Do you think that they are appropriately

involved in their children's education?

From my perspective, when I have asked them

to follow up on things, and when they have

asked me to follow up on things, we get it taken

care of in the best interests of the children

eeeee

And they have offered themselves to be

available to help accomplish a good education

>

Q.

or O&

2a

for their children?

Yes.

They have asked questions of you as to what

they can do as parents to help their children's

education process?

Yes.

And you have given them suggestions, and they

have been able to follow through on those?

Yes.

Okay. I'm just trying to make sure I understand

what you are saying. Do you socialize with the

parents outside of school?

We haven't had much opportunity to do that.

We have had occasion at Science Olympiad

events to have conversations, but —

e+eee

Okay. Do you remember, as part of the MET

review or the MET evaluation and the

subsequent IEP team determinations, what the

issues were for Dane that was part of his

emotional impairment?

Transcript - Page 17:

A.

Dane -- as I remember, Dane was having

difficulties with some _ interpersonal

relationships with his peers, and his academics

were suffering. The grades were lower than

what they had been previous to that.

Do you recall at any point in time discussing

with Dane or his parents names of sexually

3a

derogatory nature being called or pointed to

him, like fag, gay, fat pig, things of that nature?

I remember just having conversations with his

parents about that, yes.

Okay. Did Dane ever discuss those kinds of

things with you or how he was feeling about his

peers?

I don't recall him directly conversing with me on

that, no. On a day-to-day basis we dealt with

fluctuations in how he was feeling, mostly about

academics though.

Transcript - Page 28:

Q.

A.

Go FF OH PH Px

In your opinion, how did Dane handle that?

Gradewise, | had a lot of communications with

the parents when things were not what I was

comfortable with, what I thought they needed to

be, what I thought they would want them to be,

and we were able to pull it together, and he

was able to put more effort into some of the

areas that maybe he had let slide for a little

while.

Did anxiety affect his school performance?

I think anxiety affects a _ lot of students'

performance.

Okay.

It may have had a factor in Dane's academic

performance.

Was some of his anxiety related to his peer

issues in that 9th grade year?

I think some anxiety may have been brought on

by negative interaction with peers.

In fact, you letter references several incidents

e

> &

4a

throughout the year that caused some setbacks,

the top of page two; right?

Specifically | was involved with the planner

incident.

What was the planner incident?

Dave Patterson had contacted me and was

concerned that

Transcript - Page 29:

Dane -- someone had graffitied in Dane's

planner, written some derogatory remarks. I

can't recall what they were at this point in time.

So lL instructed Dave to come in, and he brought

some of the pieces of the planner that had been

removed | believe, and he also said that Dane

had -- ['m trying to remember -- Dane had not

brought all of them home, but there was some of

them home. So Dave brought them in. I wasn't

comfortable with doing anything about that

situation from a disciplinary standpoint. So I

went and we found Mike Osborne and showed

him the pages of the planner and took the

information that Dave had at that point in time,

that Dane had shared with him, took the

information that Dane had shared, and I think

at that point in time I don't think there was any

more involvement on my part with the

subsequent follow-up investigation and those

kind of things.

Were some of the things written that you said

were derogatory, were they things like gay, fag,

queer, those kind of things?

I don't remember seeing those specific things

written on the pages. Like I said, I saw one

page, and [ don't remember what was written on

5a

that. And Dane had maybe crumpled up the

other pages and did not share them immediately

with Dave Patterson, and I don't know if they

came ~ later or not.

Transcript - Page 30:

Q.

A.

OPO Pp &

Apparently the page that you saw was

disconcerting enough that you sought out Mr.

Osborne?

I don't remember what exactly was said on

there, or the fact that Dave had contacted me,

and I was going to follow up to the best I could

and act as a liaison there, to make sure it got to

who could deal with that situation the best.

did Dave Patterson come in with names of

alleged perpetrators?

I believe that he did, yes, because | recall Mike

Osborne getting those names.

Okay.

I don't remember who the names were, but --

Okay. Did you find out later if any disciplinary

action had been taken as to those students?

Usually directly I don't get, because I did not

write a referral or anything. That was

something that Mr. Osborne handled. | didn't

have any direct knowledge of what might -

what consequence might have taken place.

Okay. Do you remember any other incidents

that you were referring in your letter?

Well, one incident Dane did come to me that

someone had written something on the outside

of his locker, and so I called the custodial staff,

and someone went down immediately or very

soon after and cleaned off whatever it

6a

Transcript - Page 31:

was. I don't think that I ever actually saw what

was written on the outside of his locker, but I

applauded Dane for coming to me to have it

taken care of.

It says: Dane utilized me as a resource when

students defaced his locker with sexual slurs.

So you didn't actually see the language, or was

that reported by Dane*

I believe that would have been reported by

Dane.

Dane remembers you going down third period

and helping take that off, because janitoria!

staff hadn't gotten around to that yet. Do you

remember that?

I don't remember that specifically. It -- I can't --

can't confirm that one. But that does sound like

something I weuld do.

Transcript - Page 37:

ror ©

©

A.

Okay. And you are aware of the sexual assault

that Dane experienced his 9th grade year?

Yes. Dena Patterson shared that with me.

When did you first hear about it?

It was near the end of Dane's 9th grade year, in

a phone conversation that I had with Dena.

Now, it says here: When Dane is frustrated he

turns his anxiety inside himself. His frustration

is manifested in not completing work

consistently and withdrawing from activities.

That's your experience with Dane, that as he

gets frustrated, he tends to become hard on

himself or go inside himself?

Those are things that we had discussed at the

7a

IEP and shared.

and is that consistent with what you have

observed of Dane as well?

That see ms to be a consistent pattern with

Dane, yes.

And Dane does not act out his frustrations. So

most of the time it goes inward is what you are

saying there? He's not a behavior problem asa

result of his anxieties and frustrations?

Excerpt of Deposition of Bonnie Dunn - December 4,

2006, filed in district court

Transcript - Page 2:

Bonnie, I understand that you are employed by

the Hudson Area Schools. Is that Correct?

Yes, Iam.

What is your job capacity?

Communities and schools coordinator....

serve

Transcript - Page 4:

And when did you start that position?

Last year, the beginning of the ‘05 school year.

So the ‘05-06 year?

Right

Excerpt of Deposition of Thomas Durbin - December 4,

2006, filed in district court

Transcript - Page 79:

ATL nen

8a

Q. Turning back to Mr. Patrick a minute, when

was the investigation for your part completed?

A. 1 believe it was completed within that day or

within the next half day.....

Q. Do you know when the entire investigation was

completed by Mr. Osborne or anyone else?

Q. So by the time Mr. Patrick had been suspended,

would the investigation have been completed?

A. The initial investigation, yes.

Q. Did there come a point in time when Mr.

Osborne came to you and said he had finished

his investigation and determined what to do

what, if anything else, to do with Mr. Patrick?

A. Yes. I believe he came to me and said this is

how he saw it at the time, and that he was

investigating whether it was a criminal sexual

conduct or not.

Q. And that would have been aiso in that week that

you had first learned of it?

A. In that first week? I don’t remember the time

frame.

Transcript - Page 82:

Q. Certainly by the time school was out?

A. As far as the school year?

Q. Yes.

A. Yes.

9a

Excerpt of Deposition of Dena Jean Patterson —

October 26, 2006, filed in district court

Transcript - Page 121:

A.

cane Do you recall what the purpose of the

referral was? Was it bullying issues or was it

anxiety?

It was about overall I needed to know where he’s

at. You are talking about two parents who are

hanging by a thread and we're trying to see

what he could do in the school environment to

get him through this school year to where he

will come back the next year.

Was there a specific reason that you cited for the

referral in your request?

I just told you, I know — I needed to — he was

having rouble academically. I already knew

emotionally he had issues. I didn’t need the

school to clarify that. Once I mentioned it to the

social worker did assess.

Transcript - Page 122:

Which social worker are you talking about?

Tammy Cates.

The meeting with Tammy Cates though was in

the summer after the referral, correct?

Tammy Cates took up upon herself to test Danc.

She did a simple assessment if you will...It was

an assessment that she ended up coming to —

she approached David and I and said that on

this particular form the only thing that Dane

didn’t admit to is Dane trying to kill himself.

She was very concerned. She thought it was a

good idea that we were pursuing the testing.

10a

This was a simple little — some kind of

assessment...

aeeee

> O&O PP

Are you meaning throughout the summer also?

No, no. I didn’t make myself clear. I’m sorry. I

was stating that Mr. Adams was working so

hard that we were disappointed at the next IEP.

As you know you have the IEP’s at the end of

the year, same school year, so at the end of

eighth grade is when he had the IEP for next

year. That’s when we were told we couldn't

continue with Mr. Adams.

Who told you you couldn't continue with Mr.

Adams?

Mr. Mike Osborne, the principal at the high

school.

My understanding is though that Dane did

continue with Ted Adams in ninth grade.

On a consulting basis, it was 20 to 30 minutes

per week. He was not allowed to stay on as a

resource room capacity because he was only a

middle school.

So you wanted Dane to continue with Ted

Adams on the same basis as eight grade?

We begged.

In your Answers to Interrogatories here you

stated

Transcript - Page 137:

that “We decided not to place Dane with another

high school resource room teacher.” Was it just

Mr. Adams — Mr. Adams is the only high school

resource room teacher; isn’t that correct?

lla

A. No. He’s only middle school...We were

disappointed at the end of that school year at

the IEP when Mr. Michael Osborne, the

principal stated...first of all we said we want to

have Mr. Adams, obviously Mr. Adams will be

the study skills for Dane; right? And he said no,

Mr. Adams is the middle school resource room

teacher. We begged, even if Dane doesn’t mind

coming in with eight graders could he come in

and still use Mr. Adam for resource room

because this was working...We asked — we

begged and then first thing he said, well, you

can’t pick...

eeeee

But at the end of the day he said Mr. Adams

definitely couldn’t be Dane’s resource room

teacher because he was the middle school.

So then we were faced with the choice of

putting him in the other resource room which

had the EI kinds in. Everyone at the table, Mr.

Osborne included, didn’t think that was the

place for Dane.

Was that you included, you didn’t believe that

was the place for Dane”?

A. ...1 was depending upon the professional there at

the table. Mr. Adams, Mr. Osborne, all of the

professionals at the table were stating that that

EI resource room they would have

concerns...But it was very clear that they didn’t

think that was the place.

So again the options, Mr. Osborne said,

well — and obviously I think it says 20 to 30

12a

minutes per week...And I would rather take

Mr. Adams 20 to 30 minutes than not have

anybody at all. So we have already eliminated

the EI resource

Transcript - Page 139:

rPOPo> ©

room isn’t the place, that was option A.

The other option B is to take — because

Mr. Adams — the way Mr. Osborne put it was

that Mr. Adams was willing to basically do

this and the school was allowing them —

allowing him — to do it and act in that

capacity. They would put it down for J believe

20 to 30 minutes per week but it would be on

like a consultant basis; not as a resource room

teacher. It could have been listed as resource

room and I thing it is but it’s very minimal.

Okay. So you ultimately decided that

youdidn’t want Dane with another high school

resource room teacher; 1s that correct”

Yes. From what the team decided. I don’t

think that was an ultimate decision of David

and mine....

eevee

And a meeting was set up for the next

morning; correct?

Yes, sir, at 9:00 a.m.

You appeared at the meeting, correct?

Yes, sir.

Your husband was not there; correct?

No. At that point Dane couldn’t be left alone

at home, so he stayed home with Dane while I

attended the meeting.

l3a

Q.

A.

Q.

A.

So Dane ended up coming to school around

11:30 if I’m remembering correctly?

Yes, sir.

And he ended up meeting with Mr. Osborne, is

that right?

Yes, sir. After we brought him in, yes, sir.

Transcript - Page 159:

> OD PF O&O PP &

Okay. Did Dane stay at school the rest of the

day to the best of your knowledge?

The last whatever couple of hours were left in

the day.

Just for general knowledge how long did the

school day last?

...| thing it was like 8:00 to 3:00, something

like that, ball park.

All right. .... So after that Monday was there

any resolution?

Well, we were — Monday David and I made

sure we were available after school to where

the baseball field is locates where we could

keep Dane in our sight. It was at first Dane

didn’t want to play anymore but he also knew

that everyone on the team — we knew that

Lance — at least Lance would be kicked off the

baseball team. It happened at a baseball

practice, so we’re assuming that he would be

at least kicked out of baseball. So Dane knew

if he didn’t play the team would end up

forfeiting the rest of their season and that was

l4a

a real concern for Dane because then he said

the rest of the kids...

eeeee

> &

So on then on Wednesday we're still

trying to get Dane through the week with

getting there half days, some days in the

afternoon, some days in the morning. Because

he was told that if he — he was expected to

come back to school obviously. By Tuesday he

had had a couple of kids approach him about

telling him that he better watch his back,

there were kids that wanted to kill him.

Was there a report to the school do you know?

Reported that to Mr. Osborne and Mrs.

Mansfield....

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.