Appendix — Morrison v. United States
Supreme Court brief2003
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
la
APPENDIX A— Order and Opinion of The Six Circuit
Court of Appeals Remanding for reimposition of THE
fine filed Feb 24, 2003
UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE SIXTH CIRCUIT
No. 01-2107
D.C. No. 99-71069
United States of America
Plaintiff-Appeallee,
Alice Pauley, Joseph Morrison
Defendants - Appellants,
Appeal from the United States
District Court for the Eastern District
of Michigan at Detroit.
George E. Woods, District Judge.
Argued and Submitted; January 28, 2003
Decided and Filed: February 24, 2003
Before: GUY AND MOORE, Circuit Judges:
BECKWITH, District Judge.
2a
The Honorable Sandra S. Beckwith, United States
District Judge for the Southern District of Ohio, sitting by
designation.
Opinion by Judge Karen Nelson Moore
OPINION
KAREN NELSON MOORE, Circuit Judge. The
United States, which had been granted summary
judgment on its Clean Water Act action against
defendants Alice Pauley and Joseph Morrison, appeals
from the district court’s sua sponte order that vacated the
$25,000 fine that the district court had previously
imposed. Because the district court lacked the power to
grant such relief sua sponte, we REVERSE the district
court.
I. BACKGROUND
On March 5, 1999, the United States filed a complaint
against Alice Pauley and her father, Samuel Pauely, who
together owned certain real property on Harsens Island,
Michigan; Joseph Morrison , who claimed to have an
ownership interest in the property; and John Horvath, a
construction contractor. The compliant alleged that the
defendants violated the Clean Water Act by trenching,
grading, and filling wetlands on the Pauleys’ property
3a
without a permit. The complaint sought a civil fine and
an injunction requiring the defendants to restore the
property to its natural condition.
On October 31, 2000, U.S. District Judge Cleland
awarded summary judgment to the United States. The
court found that the defendants had “discharged a
pollutant, from a source point, into navigable waters of
the United States, without a permit, “Joints Appendix”
(“J.A.”) at 29, within the meaning of the Clean Water
Act. Accordingly, the court scheduled a penalty hearing
on February 8, 2001, to determine the scope of any relief.
At the hearing, the government presented a consent
decree between the United States and defendant Samuel
Pauley. Samuel Pauley, who had quit claimed his
interest in the property to Alice Pauley and Joseph
Morrison on January 26, 2001, shortly before the
scheduled penalty hearing, agreed to hire a contractor to
restore the property. Accordingly to the consent decree,
Samuel Pauley who would hire a contractor to remove
all fill material from the wetland by May 15, 2001. The
consent decree was contingent on either Samue! Pauley
receiving permission from the new owners, Alice Pauley
and her husband, Joseph Morrison, to enter the property
and complete the restoration or on a court order
requiring the new owners to permit him the necessary
access. On February 8, 2001, the court ordered Alice
Pauley to “Allow access to the property by the
4a
Contractors and Corps of Engineers to complete the
restoration as set forth in the Consent Decree. “ J.A.” at
81.
Before considering a civil penalty, the court
adjourned the penalty hearing for six weeks so that Alice
Pauley and Joseph Morrison could retain counsel. When
the hearing resumed, and the defendants informed the
court that they would precede pro se, Judge Cleland
imposed a $25,000 fine against Alice Pauley and Joseph
Morrison for their Clean Water Act violations. The fine
was imposed pursuant to 33 U.S.C. § 1319 (d), which
authorizes civil penalties up to $25,000 per day of
violation and requires the court to consider the
seriousness of the violation, any history of violations
good faith efforts to comply with requirements, the
impact of the fine on the offender, and any other factors
that “justice may require.” 33 U.S.C. § 1319 (d).
Granting the United States’s request to imposed the
maximum fine allowed for one day of violation, Judge
Cleland noted that the land had been in violation for
approximately six years. Although the scope of the
violation was not huge, Judge Cleland said, as it affected
only a small piece of land, Alice Pauley’s and Joseph
Morrison’s history of refusing to comply with the law
warranted the fine. Judge Cleland said that they had
failed to keep their promises that they would remedy the
violation, and he cited the “ strong indications that the
defendants were essentially, stringing the Corps along
and trying to see if ...the Corps would simply give up
5a
after a period of time.”J.A.” at 245. The court also
considered Alice Pauley’s and Joseph Morrison’s
economic situations and the costs to the government of
their intransigence before imposing the $25,000 fine.
Despite the injunction, Alice Pauley refused Samuel
Pauley, the contractor, and the Army Corps of Engineers
access to the property to comply with the terms of the
settlement. According to the United States, Alice Pauley
sent the government a letter in late February stating that
“we have decided that we will NOT allow any one on
our property,” and that “we do not plan on being bullied
into anything especially by the Court or the Plaintiff(s).”
J.A. at 83-84. On May 9, 2001, the government received a
letter from Samuel Pauley’s attorney, who stated that on
at least five separate occasions, Alice Pauley had told
Samuel Pauley that she would not allow him or his
contractor access to the property. That day, the United
States filed an emergency motion to enforce the consent
decree. Judge Cleland disqualified himself, and the case
was reassigned to U.S. District Judge Woods.
At the hearing on the United States emergency
motion Judge Woods appears to have succeeded in
convincing Alice Pauley to comply with the courts order.
However, Judge Woods also vacated sua sponte the
$25,000 fine that Judge Cleland had levied against Alice
Pauley and Joseph Morrison. Judge Woods announced
early in the hearing, “The Court expects the imposition of
fines will not motivate Alice Pauley to comply. I told you
I’m not impressed with fines. I’m not interested in fines
6a
being imposed.” J.A. at 263. Then, after recounting the
case’s history, Judge Woods invited Alice Pauley to the
lectern and announced, “Tell you what I'm going to
do right now. I’m setting aside [the] $25,000 fine. I don’t
think it serves any purpose at all and I do not feel that it
is a sword hanging over your head at all.” J.A. at 273. In
denying the United States’s motion to reconsider, Judge
Woods said, “I’ve set aside the $25,000 fine which may
have had something to do with getting this baby settled.
So be it. It’s set aside.” J.A. at 288. Judge Woods entered
an order vacating the civil penalty.
The United States timely appealed from the order
vacating the civil penalty and we have jurisdiction
pursuant to 28 U.S. C. §1291.
II. ANALYSIS
As Judge Cleland’s comments in imposing the $25,000
fine indicate, Alice Pauley and Joseph Morrison have a
history of obstructing the Corp’s efforts to enforce the
Clean Water Act and to remedy the violations on Alice
Pauley’s property. Accordingly, when the case came
before judge Woods on the United States emergency
motion to compei compliance, Judge Woods on the
United States emergency motion to compel compliance,
Judge Woods was understandably prepared to use
whatever tools he had available to accomplish
compliance with the court's earlier injunction. However,
vacating sua sponte one order in
ee
7a
an effort to encourage a party to comply with another
order was not, under our precedent, an available tool.
Judge Woods did not explicitly indicate the basis on
which he vacated the $25,000 civil penalty, but we
interpret the district court as having relieved the
defendants from a final judgment pursuant to Federal
Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(6), as this rule most nearly
describes the districts court's action. Rule 60(b)(6)
provides that, “[o]n motion and upon such terms as are
just, the court may relieve a party or a party’s legal
representative from a final judgment’ for ‘any ..reason
justifying relief from the operation of the judgment.’ Fed
R. Civ. P. 60(b)(6). The civil fine from which the district
court granted relief constituted a final judgment, as it
had been imposed in connection with a judgment
granting summary judgment with respect to all of the
plaintiff's claims against all remaining defendants. That
the district court had maintained jurisdiction to ensure
that the injunctive relief was properly accomplished is
irrelevant for purposes of determining whether the grant
of summary judgment and imposition of a civil penalty
constituted final judgment, as “the court may enter a
final and appealable judgment and s till retain
jurisdiction over the action so as to make sure that its
order is applied correctly.” 10 Charles Alan Wright,
Arthur R. Miller, & Mary Kay Kane, Federal Practice and
procedure § 2651 at 14 (3d ed. 1998) (interpreting Fed. R.
SS
8a
P. 54 (a), which defines “judgment” as used in Federal
Rules of Civil Procedure). Accordingly, the question is
whether the Rule 60 (b) relief was properly granted. We
review orders granting relief from a prior order under
Rule (60) (b) for abuse of discretion, but we review
questions of law de novo. Blackard v. Memphis area Med.
~ Ctr. For Women, Inc., 262F.3D 568,572 (6% Cir.2001) ,cert.
denied,-U.S.-, 122 S. Ct. 1908 (May 13, 2002).
We have held that a district court may not sua sponte
grant relief to pursuant to Rule 60 (b)! In Eaton v.
Jamrog, 984 F. 2d. 760 (6 Cir. 1993, we reasoned that
because Rule 60 (6) explicitly requires relief under the
rule to occur “on motion,” courts may not grant such
relief except upon “a motion from the affected party. Id.
at 762; accord Lewts v. Alexander, 987F. 2d. 392,396 (6" Cir.
1993) (“Eaton decided... that a district court may not act
sua sponte to grant relief from judgment through Rule 60
(b).”) Here, no motion for Rule 60 (b) relief was made.
Accordingly, under our precedents the order vacating
the relief exceeded the district court’s authority.
1
Circuits are split on the question whether a district court may
grant Rule 60 (b) relief sua sponte. The Tenth Circuit
agrees with our view that such relief is impermissible. See Dow v.
(Cont'd)
9a
We also note that even if the district court had the
authority to vacate the order, district courts should not
use their authority under Rule 60 (b) to reward parties’
contempt of prior orders. The initial district judge had
imposed the fine after carefully considering the factors
required under 33 U.S.C. § 1319 (d), and _ the fine’s
purposed was to punish violations of the Clean Water
Act, not to induce these offenders to remedy the
violation. Of course, if any of the consideration listed in
(Cont'd)
Baird, 389 F.2d 882, 884-85 (10% Cir. 1968) (nothing that whereas Rule
60 (a) permits the district court to correct clerical errors “of its own
initiative,” Rule 60 (b) permits corrections only upon
motion). The Second, Forth, Fifth and Ninth Circuits have held that
such sua sponte is permissible. See Fort Knox Music Inc. V. Baptiste,
257 F.3D 108, 111 (2d Cir. 2001) (“While normally such relief is
sought by motion of a party, see Fed.R.Cir.P.60 (b), nothing forbids
the court to grant such relief sua sponte.”): Kingvision Pay-Per-View
Ltd v. Lake Alice Bar, 168 F..3d 347, 351 (9% Cir. 1999) (reasoning that
although rule say “on motion,’ it “ does not explicitly say” by a
party,” suggesting that the relief could be on the court’s own
motion); McDowell v. Celebrezze, 310 F.2d 43, 44 (5% Cir. 1962) (“The
Court could initiate this on its own motion.”); United States v. Jacobs,
298 F.2d 469, 472 (4thCir. 1961) (“The rule need not necessarily be
read as depriving the court of the power to act in the interest of
justice in an unusual case in which its attention has been directed to
the necessity for relief by means other than a motion.”).
ee
En
10a
Sec 1319 (d), such as the economic impact that the
judgment would have on the offenders, had changed,
Relief from the judgment might have been appropriate.
Similarly, upon motion of a party, the district court
might have used it Rule 60 (b) authority to grant relief in
the presence of “exceptional or extraordinary
circumstances” that this court held are necessary for
relief under Rule 60 (b) (6) in Hopper V. Euclid Manor
Nursing Home, Inc,. 867 F. 2d 291, 294 (6" Cir. 1989).
However, those circumstances are not present here.
Rather, the only unusual circumstance present was the
defendants intransigently refused to comply with the
districts court’s order to allow access to the property for
remediation. Vacating a prior order for the sole purpose
of inducing compliance with another order would
reward contempt. .
This case is somewhat analogous to the circumstances
that we faced in Hopper. There a prevailing plaintiff was
required to pay certain costs pursuant to Rule 68, because
the plaintiff had refused the defendant's offer to settle for
an amount that turned out to be greater than the nominal
damages that the plaintiff was ultimately awarded. The
district court then used Rule 60 (b) (6) to vacate the earlier
judgment in favor of the plaintiff, and the court entered
judgment in favor of the defendant, a move that rendered
Rule 68 inapplicable. See Hopper, 867 F.2d at 293. We
reversed. Because the district court had “sought to negate
the operation of Rule 68” which encourages plaintiffs to
lla
consider settlement offers seriously lest the plaintiff win a
smaller judgment and be forced to pay cost, and because
granting Rule 60(b) relief would reward the plaintiff's
refusal to accept an appropriate settlement offer. Id. at
294-95. Similarly, here granting relief from the civil
penalty served to reward the defendants’ refusal to
comply with court orders.
The district court’s sole purpose in vacating the civil
fine here was not, of course, to reward the defendants’
disregard of the law. The district court’s primary
purpose appears to have been to remedy the violation of
the Clean Water Act. That purpose was appropriate, and
Judge Woods noted that the hearing on the emergency
motion to comply had resulted in a new settlement.
defendants intransigently refused to comply with the
district court’s order to allow access to the property for
remediation. There was, however, nothing to settle:
Judge Cleland had already determined that Alice Pauley
and Joseph Morrison had an obligation to permit
contractors to remedy a violation, and he had ordered
them to comply. The problem was not that the parties
failed to agree on an appropriate resolution, but that
Alice Pauley and Joseph Morrison had refused to fulfill
their court-ordered obligations. Alice Pauley’s and
Joseph Morrison’s blatant refusal to comply with a court
order would have warranted conternpt proceedings, but
certainly not rewarded for their obstruction.
12a
III CONCLUSION
Because the district Court did not have the power to
vacate the civil penalty sua sponte, we REVERSE and
REMAND for reimposition of the fine.
13a
APPENDIX B - ORDER ASSESSING A CIVIL
PENALTY AS TO DEFENDANTS ALICE PAULEY
MORRISON AND JOSEPH MORRISON, ONLY
DATED MARCH 30, 2001
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN
DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN SOUTHERN DIVISION
Case No: 99-71069
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiffs,
Vv.
SAMUEL PAULEY, ALICE PAUELY, JOSEPH
MORRISON and JOHN HORVATH, jointly and
severally,
Defendants.
ORDER ASSESSING A CIVIL PENALTY AS TO
DEFENDANTS ALICE PAULEY MORRISON AND
JOSEPH MORRISON, ONLY
This court having granted the plaintiff, United States of
America's, Motion for Summary Judgment as to
defendants Samuel Pauley, Alice Pauley Morrison! and
' In documents filed with the Court, defendant Alice Pauley, has
stated that her name is Alice Pauley Morrison.
14a
Joseph Morrison; plaintiff having filed a Motion for
Injunctive Relief and Civil Penalties as to defendants
Samuel Pauley, Alice Pauley Morrison and Joseph
Morrison; defendant Samuel Pauley having entered into
a Consent Judgment to restore the wetlands in question;
and evidentiary hearing having been held on the
assessment of civil penalty and testimony taken; and the
Court being fully advised in all premises;
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED for reasons stated on the
record on March 27, 2001 that a civil penalty of Twenty-
Five Thousand dollars ($25,000.00), is imposed against
defendants Alice Pauley Morrison and Joseph Morrison
jointly and severally, together with interest as allowed
by law.
DATED March 30, 2001
‘s/ Robert Cleland
ROBERT H. CLELAND
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
a
15a
APPENDIX C—JUDGMENT FOR PLAINTFF FOR
$25,000.00 DOLLARS - DATED MARCH 39, 2001
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN
DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN SOUTHERN DIVISION
No: 99-71069
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
Vv.
SAMUEL PAUELY, ALICE PAULEY, JOSEPH
MORRISON and JOHN HORVATH, jointly and
severally,
Defendants,
ORDER RE: $ 25,000.00 JUDGMENT
This action having come before the Court, the issues
having been fully adjudicated and a decision having
been duly rendered:
IT IS ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that plaintiff,
United States of America, recover a civil penalty from
defendants Alice Pauley Morrison and Joseph Morrison,
jointly and severally, a civil penalty in the amount of
Twenty-Five Thousand dollars ( $25,000.)
16a
x
Defendant's Alice Pauley Morrison and Joseph
Morrison shall pay the said civil penalty by a check
made payable to the United States of America, c/o
Geneva Halliday, Assistant United States Attorney, U.S.
Attorney’s Office, 211 W. Fort Street, Suite 2001, Detroit,
Michigan 48226. The $25,000 civil penalty is due to
plaintiff, United States of America upon entry of this
judgment. Plaintiff shall be entitled to interest as
provided by law from the date of this judgment until
satisfied.
DATED: 30, March 2001
s/ Robert H. Cleland
ROBERT H. CLELAND
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
17a
APPENDIX D—ORDER OF THE UNITED STATES
DISTRICT VACATING, $ 25,000.00 JUDGMENT FOR
PLAINTIFF - DATED AND FILED JUNE 07, 2001
UNITED STATES DISTRICT OURT EASTERN
DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN SOUTHERN DIVISION
No: 99-71069
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Plaintiff,
SAMUEL PAULEY, ALICE PAUELY, JOSEPH
MORRISON, and JOHN HORVATH, jointly and
severally,
Defendants,
ORDER RE: VACATING §$ 25,000.00 JUDGMENT
On February 8, 2001, a Consent Decree was entered
into between plaintiff, United States of America and
defendant, Samuel Pauely, wherein he agreed to restore
the property in question pursuant to the terms set forth
on the Consent Decree. On February 8, 2001, the
Honorable Robert H. Cleland, United States District
; Judge for the Eastern District of Michigan, entered an
Order ordering that defendant, Alice Pauley (Morrison)
PPA L DDT IA IRAE ERE PESTER "1
18a
shall allow access to the property by the contractor and
the Corps of Engineers to complete the restoration set
forth in the Consent Decree with Defendant Samuel
Pauley. On May 9, 2001, plaintiff filed an Emergency
Motion to Enforce the Consent Decree as to Samuel
Pauley and to enforce the Order requiring Alice Pauley
(Morrison) to allow access to the property. Attached to
the motion was a letter from the attorney for defendant,
Samuel Pauley, indication that his client was not going
to be able to restore the property in question because
Alice Pauley (Morrison) had advised her father, Samuel
Pauley, that she would not allow access for him and his
contractors to the site to do the restoration.
A hearing was held on plaintiff's Motion to Enforce
the Consent Decree as to Samuel Pauley and Order as to
Defendant Alice Pauley (Morrison) on May 29, 2001. At
the hearing Alice Pauley Morrison agreed on the record,
that she would allow access to the property by the
contractors to complete the restoration set forth in the
Consent Decree and by the Corps of Engineers to allow
inspection as set forth in the Consent Decree.
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that Alice Pauley Morrison
shall allow access to the property by the contractor and
Corps of Engineers so that the restoration can be
completed as set forth and under the terms in the
original Consent Decree. It is further ordered that the
restoration be completed as soon as possible, but in any
event no later that July 15, 2001.
19a
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that defendants Alice and
Joseph Morrison’s Motion for a Stay Pending Appeal is
DENIED.
It is further ordered that the judgment awarding
plaintiff a civil penalty from defendants Alice Pauley
Morrison and Joseph Morrison in the amount of $25,000
entered by the Honorable Robert H. Cleland on March
30, 2001 is VACATED. IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that
plaintiffs oral motion for r consideration of the
vacating of the Judgment of $25,000 is DENIED.
DATED: June 07, 2001
s/ George E. Woods
GEORGE E. WOODS
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
20a
APPENDIX E—ORDER OF THE UNITED STATES
DISTRICT COURT REINSTATING $25,000
JUDGMENT DATED AND FILED MARCH 17, 2003
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA,
Plaintiff,
Vv.
SAMUEL PAUELY, ALICE PAULEY, JOSEPH
MORRISON, and JOHN HORVATH, jointly and
severally,
Defendants,
ORDER RE: REINSTATING 25,000 JUDGMENT
On February 24, 2003 the United States Court of
Appeals for the Sixth Circuit held that this Court lacked
the power to vacate, sua sponte, a $25,000 fine imposed
against Defendants Alice Pauely and Joseph Morrison.
The appellant court remanded the matter for
reimposition of the fine.
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the March 30, 2001
civil penalty entered against Defendant Alice Pauely
Morrison and Joseph Morrison, jointly and severally, in
the amount of $25,000 shall be, and hereby is reinstated.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that Alice Pauley
Morrison and Joseph Morrison shall pay the penalty by
a check made payable to the United States of America, in
2la
care of Geneva Halliday, Assistant United States
Attorney, U.S. Attorney’s Office, 211 W. Fort Street,
Suite, 2001 Detroit, Michigan, 48226. Plaintiff shall be
entitled to interest as provided by law.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
DATED MARCH 17, 2003
s/ George E. Woods
GEORGE E.WOODS
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
Copies mailed this date to:
James K. O’Brien, Esq
Geneva S. Halliday, Esq
Alice Pauley Morrison and Joseph Morrison
United States Marshal Service
=
ws
ts
“a
.
i
4
>
he
hes
e
i
ae
cS
He
4
a
q
S|
o.
'
x
x
Y
¥
=
t
.
i
&
z=
APPENDIX F—JAY’S TREATY- ARTICLE II, PARA 2-
IDENTIFIES THE INTERNATION BORDER
BETWEEN THE UNITED STATES AND CANADA
Jay’s Treaty 1794 : Article II Paragraph 2
His Majesty will withdraw all his troops and
garrisons from all posts and places within the boundary
lines assigned by the treaty of peace to the United States.
This evacuation shall take place on or before the first day
of June, one thousand seven hundred and ninety-six, and
all the proper measures shall in the interval be taken by
concert between the Government of the United States
and is Majesty’s Governor General in America for
settling the previous arrangements which may be
necessary respecting the delivery of the said post:
The United States in the mean time, at their
discretion, extending their settlements to any part within
the said boundary line, except within the precincts or
jurisdiction of any of the said posts. All settlers and
traders, within the precincts or jurisdiction of the said
posts, shall continue to enjoy, unmolested, all their
property of every kind, and shall be protected therein.
They shall be at full liberty to remain there, or to move
with all or any part of their effects; and it shall also be
free to them to sell their lands, houses or effects; or to
retain the property thereof, at their discretion; such of
ta ROTEL
ent ret
Sa UB 6 Ae AR a aie NIE ATT GE A sk 4 MRA IRIG BS YO TIP EU SSS Se RR MH ERLE Oe MLTR ny
tay
23a
them as shall continue to reside with the said boundary
lines, shall not be compelled to become citizens of the
United States, or to take any oath of allegiance to the
Government thereof; but they shall be a full liberty so to
do if they think proper, and they shall make and declare
their election within one year after the evacuation
aforesaid. And all persons who shall continue there after
the expiration of the said year, without having declared
their intention of remaining subjects of His Britarinic
Majesty, shall be considered as having elected to become
citizens of the United States.
a aerate
24a
APPENDIX G—TREATY OF PARIS 1783- IDENTIES
THE INTERNATIONAL BOUNDARIES BETWEEN
THE UNITED STATES AND CANADA
The Treaty of Paris 1783
Article 2
And that all disputes which might arise in future on the
subject of boundaries of the said United States may be
prevented, it is hereby agreed and declared, that the
following are and shall be their boundaries, viz.; from
the northwest angle of Nova Scotia, viz.; that nagle
which is formed by a line drawn due north from the
source of St. Croix River to the highlands; along the said
highlands which divide those rivers that empty
themselves into the river Lawrence, from those which
fall into the Atlantic Ocean, to the northwestermost head
of Connecticut River; thence down along the middle of
that river to the forty-fifth degree of north latitude; from
thence by a line due west on said latitude until it strikes
the river Iroquois or Cataraquy; thence along the middle
of said river into Lake Ontario; through the middle of
said lake until it strikes the communication by water
between that lake and Lake Erie; thence along the
middle of said communication into Lake Erie, through
the middle of said lake until it arrives at the water
communication between that lake and Lake Huron;
thence along the middle of said water communication
into Lake Huron,
RW IIT BPG NE Sey
25a
thence through the middle of said lake to the water
communication between that lake and Lake Superior;
thence through Lake Superior northward of the Isles
Royal and Phelipeaux to the Long Lake; thence through
the middle of said Long Lake and the water
communication between it and the Lake of the Woods,
to the said Lake of the Woods; thence through the said
lake to the most north western most point thereof, and
from thence on a due west course to the river
Mississippi; thence by a line to be drawn along the
middle of the said river Mississippi until it shall intersect
the northernmost part of the thirty-first degree of north
latitude, South, by a line to be drawn due east from the
determination of the line last mentioned in the latitude
of thirty-one degrees of the equator, to the middle of the
river Apalachicola or Catahouche; thence along the idle
thereof to its junction with the Flint River, thence straight
to the head of Saint Mary’s River; and thence down
along the middle of Saint Mary’s River to the Atlantic
Ocean; East, by a line to be drawn along the middle of
the river Saint Croix, from its mouth in the Bay of Fundy
to its source, and from its source directly north to the
aforesaid is highlands which divide the rivers that fall
into the Atlantic Ocean from those which fall into the
river Saint Lawrence; comprehending all islands within
twenty leagues of any part of the shores of the United
States, and lying between lines to be drawn due east
from the points where the aforesaid boundaries between
Nova Scotia on the one pat and East Florida on the other
26a
shall, respectively, touch the Bay of Fundy and the
Atlantic Ocean, excepting such islands as now are or
heretofore have been within the limits of the said of
Nova Scotia.
27a
APPENDIX H-TREATY OF GREENVILLE:
STATUTES AT LARGE VOLUME VII PAGE 491
DATED AUGUST 3, 1795 INDIAN LAND CESSIONS
IN THE UNITED STATES 1794 TO 1894 U.S. SERIAL
SET, NUMBER 4015, 56™ CONGRESS, 15T SESSION
PAGES 654-655:
AMERICAN STATE PAPERS
SENATE, 4™ CONGRESS, 15T SESSION INDIAN
AFFAIRS; VOLUME 1 PAGE 562, NO. 67
Description of cession or reservation: The Ottawa and
Chippewa nations of Indians cede to the U.S. all the
tracts of country within the following boundaries:
Beginning at the mouth of Grand River lf Lake Michigan
on then. Bank thereof and following up the same to the
line called for in the first article of the treaty of Chicago
of August 29, 1821: thence in a direct line to the head of
Thunder Bay river: thence with the line established by
the Treaty of Saganaw of Sept 24, 1819, to the mouth of
said river; thence NE to the boundary line in Lake Huron
between the U.S. and British providence of Upper
Canada: thence northwestwardly following the said line
as established by the commissioners acting under the
treaty of Ghent, through the straits, and river St Mary’s
to a point in Lake Superior N. of the mouth of Gitchy
Seebing or Chocolate river; thence S. to the mouth of
said river and up its channel to the source thereof; thence
in a direct line to the head of the Skonawba river of
28a
Green bay; thence down the S. bank of said river to its
mouth; thence in a direct line through the ship channel
into Green bay to the outer part thereof; thence S. to a
point in Like Michigan W. of the North cape or entrance
of Grand river, and thence E. to the place of beginning at
the cape aforesaid, comprehending all the lands and
islands within these limits not hereinafter reserved.
From the forgoing cession said tribes reserve for their
own use, to be held in common, the following tracts for
the term of five years and no longer except by
permission of the U.S.
1. One tract of 50,000 acres to be located on
LittleTraverse Bay.
2. One tract of 20,000 acres to be located on the N.
shore of Grand Traverse bay.
3. One tract of 70,000 acres to be located on or N. of
the Pierire Marquetta river.
4. One tract of 1,000 acres to be located Chingassanoo
or the Big Sail, on the Cheboigan.
~ One tract of 1,000 acres to be located by
Mujeekewis, on Thunder Bay River
There shall be reserved for the Chippewas living N. of
the straits of Michilmackinc the following tracts, viz:
1. One tract of 3 miles square on the N. shore of said
straits between Point-au-Barbe and Mille Coquin
river, including the fishing grounds in front
thereof.
9.
29a
One tract of 3 miles square on the N. shore of said
straits between Pointe-au-Barbe and Mille Coquin
river, including the fishing grounds in front
thereof.
The Beaver islands of Lake Michigan for the use
of Beaver Island Indians.
Round island opposite Michilimackinac as place
of encampment for the Indians.
The islands uf the Chenos with a part of the
adjacent N. coast of Lake Huron corresponding in
length and 1 mile in dept.
Sugar island, with its islets, in the river of St.
Mary’s.
Six hundred and forty acres at the mission of
Little Rapids.
A tract commencing at the mouth of
Pississowining river. S. Pointlroquois; thence
running up said stream to its forks; thence
westward in a direct line to the Rid Water lakes;
thence across the portage to the Tacquimenon
river and down the same to its mouth, including
the small islands and fishing grounds in fromt of
this reservation.
Six hundred and forty acres and:Grand Island
10. Two thousand acres on the mainland S. of Grand
island.
11. Two sections on the northern extremity of Green
Bay, to be located by a council of chiefs.
crea
30a
It is understood that the reservation for a place of
fishing and encampment made under the treaty of
St. Mary’s of June 16, 1820 remains unaffected by
this treaty.
It is agreed that as soon as the said Indians desire
it, a deputation shall be sent to the W. of the
Mississippi river, and to the country between
Lake Superior and Mississippi, to select a suitable
place for the final settlement of said Indians,
which the U.S. will forever guarantee and secure
to said Indians.
3la
APPENDIX E-NORTHWEST ORDINANCE ARTICLE
5, ARTICLE 6
July 13, 1787
An Ordinance for the government of the Territory of the
United States northwest of the River Ohio.
Be it ordained by the United States in Congress
assembled, that the said territory, for the purposes of
temporary government, be one district, subject, however,
to be divided into two districts, as future circumstances
may, in the opinion of Congress, make it expedient.
Be it ordained by the authority aforesaid, That the
estates, both of resident and nonresident proprietors in
the said territory, dying interstate, shall descent to, and
be distributed among their children, and the descendants
of a deceased child, in equal parts; the descendants of a
deceased child or grandchild to take the share of their
jeceased parent in equal parts among
them: And where there shall be no children or
descendants, then in equal parts to the next of kin in
equal degree; and among collaterals, the children of a
deceased brother or sister of the interstate shall have, in
equal parts among them, their deceased parents’ share;
and there shall in no case be a distinction
between kindred of the whole and half blood; saving, in
all cases, to the widow of the interstate her third part of
the real estate for life, and one third part of the personal
estate; and this law relative to descents and dower, shall
remain in full force until altered by the legislature of the
32a
district. And until the governor and judges shall adopt
laws as hereinafter mentioned, estates in the said
territory may be devised or bequeathed by wills in
writing, signed and sealed by him or her in whom the
estate may be (being of full age), and attested by three
witnesses; and real estates may be conveyed by lease and
release, or bargain and sale, signed, sealed and delivered
by the person being of full age, in whom the estate may
be, and attested by two witnesses, provided such wills be
duly proved, and such conveyances be acknowledged, or
the execution thereof duly proved, and be recorded
within one year after proper magistrates, courts, and
registers shall be appointed for that purpose; and
personal property may be transferred by delivery;
saving, however to the French and Canadian inhabitants,
and other settlers of the Kaskaskies, St. Vincents and the
neighboring villages who have heretofore professed
themselves citizens of Virginia, their laws and customs
now in force among them, relative to the descent and
conveyance, of property.
Be it ordained by the authority aforesaid, That there
shall be appointed from time to time by Congress, a
governor, whose commission shall continue in force for
the term of three years, unless sooner revoked by
Congress; he shali reside in the district, and have a
freehold estate therein in 1,000 acres of land, while in the
exercise of his office. There shall be appointed from time
to time by Congress, a secretary, whose commission shall
continue in force for four years unless sooner revoked; he
33a
shall reside in the district, and have a freehold estate
therein in 500 acres of land, while in the exercise of his
office. It shall be his duty to keep and preserve the acts
and laws passed by the legislature, and the public
records of the district, and the proceedings of the
governor in his executive department, and transmit
authentic copies of such acts and proceedings, every six
months, to the Secretary of Congress: There shall also be
appointed a court to consist of three judges, any two of
whom to form a court, who shall have a common law
jurisdiction, and reside in the district, and have each
therein a freehold estate in 500 acres of land while in the
exercise of their offices; and their commissions shall
continue in force during good behavior.
The governor and judges, or a majority of them, shall
adopt and publish in the district such laws of the original
States, criminal and civil, as may be necessary and best
suited to the circumstances of the district, and report
them to Congress from time to time: which laws shall be
in force in the district until the organization of the
General Assembly therein, unless disapproved of by
Congress; but afterwards the Legislature shall have
authority to alter them as they shall think fit.
The governor, for the time being, shall be commander
in chief of the militia, appoint and commission all
officers in the same below the rank of general officers; all
general officers shall be appointed and commissioned by
Congress. Previous to the organization of the general
assembly, the governor
34a
shall appoint such magistrates and other civil officers
in each county or township, as he shall find necessary for
the preservation of the peace and good order in the
same: After the general assembly shall be organized, the
powers and duties of the magistrates and other
civil officers shall be regulated and defined by the said
assembly; but all magistrates and other civil officers not
herein otherwise directed, shall during the continuance
of this temporary government, be appointed by the
governor.
For the prevention of crimes and injuries, the laws to
be adopted or made shall have force in all parts of the
district, and for the execution of process, criminal and
civil, the governor shall make proper divisions
thereof; and he shall proceed from time to time as
circumstances may require, to lay out the parts of the
district in which the Indian titles shall have been
extinguished, into counties and townships, subject,
however, to such alterations as may thereafter be made
by the legislature.
So soon as there shall be five thousand free male
inhabitants of full age in the district, upon giving proof
thereof to the governor, they shall receive authority, with
time and place, to elect a representative from their
counties or townships to represent them in the general
assembly: Provided, That, for every five hundred free
male inhabitants, there shall be one representative, and
so on progressively with the number of free male
inhabitants shall the right of representation increase,
35a
until the number of representatives shall amount to
twenty five; after which, the number and proportion of
representatives shall be regulated by the legislature:
Provided, That no person be eligible or qualified to act as
a representative unless he shall have been a citizen
of one of the United States three years, and be a resident
in the district, or unless he shall have resided in the
district three years; and, in either case, shall
likewise hold in his own right, in fee simple, two
hundred acres of land within the same; Provided, also,
That a freehold in fifty acres of land in the district,
having been a citizen of one of the states, and being
resident in the district, or the like freehold and two years
residence in the district, shall be necessary to qualify a
man as an elector of a representative.
The representatives thus elected, shall serve for the
term of two years; and, in case of the death of a
representative, or removal from office, the governor shall
issue a writ to the county or township for which he was
a member, to elect another in his stead, to serve for the
residue of the term.
The general assembly or legislature shall consist of
the governor, legislative council, and a house of
representatives. The Legislative Council shall consist of
five members, to continue in office five years, unless
sooner removed by Congress; any three of whom to be a
quorum: and the members of the Council shall be
nominated and appointed in the following manner, to
36a
wit: As soon as representatives shall be elected, the
Governor shall appoint a time and place for them to
meet together; and, when met, they shall nominate ten
persons, residents in the district, and each possessed of a
freehold in five hundred acres of land, and return their
names to Congress; five of whom Congress shall appoint
and commission to serve as aforesaid; and, whenever a
vacancy shall happen in the council, by death or removal
from office, the house of representatives shall nominate
two persons, qualified as aforesaid, for each vacancy,
and return their names to Congress; one of whom
congress shall appoint and commission for the residue of
the term. And every five years, four months at least
before the expiration of the time of service of the
members of council, the said house shall nominate ten
persons, qualified as aforesaid, and return their names to
Congress; five of whom Congress shall appoint and
commission to serve as members of the council five
years, unless sooner removed. And the governor,
legislative council, and house of representatives, shall
have authority to make laws in all cases, for the good
government of the district, not repugnant to the
principles and articles in this ordinance established and
declared. And all bills, having passed by a majority in
the house, and by a majority in the council, shall be
referred to the governor for his assent; but no bill, or
legislative
37a
act whatever, shall be of any force without his assent.
The governor shall have power to convene, prorogue,
and dissolve the general assembly, when, in his opinion,
it shall be expedient.
The governor, judges, legislative council, secretary,
and such other officers as Congress shall appoint in the
district, shall take an oath or affirmation of fidelity and
of office; the governor before the president of congress,
and all other officers before the Governor. As soon as a
legislature shall be formed in the district, the council and
house assembled in one room, shall have authority, by
joint ballot, to elect a delegate to Congress, who shall
have a seat in Congress, with a right of debating but not
voting during this temporary government.
And, for extending the fundamenta! principles of civil
and religious liberty, which form the basis whereon
these republics, their laws and constitutions are erected;
to fix and establish those principles as the basis of all
laws, constitutions, and governments, which forever
hereafter shall be formed in the said territory: to provide
also for the establishment of States, and permanent
government therein, and for their admission to a share in
the federal councils on an equal footing with the original
States, at as early periods as may be consistent with the
general interest: It is hereby ordained and declared by
the authority aforesaid, That the following articles shall
be considered as articles of compact between the original
States and the people and States in the said territory and
38a
forever remain unalterable, unless by common consent,
to wit:
Article I.
No person, demeaning himself in a peaceable and
orderly manner, shall ever be molested on account of his
mode of worship or religious sentiments, in the said
territory. ?
Article II.
The inhabitants of the said territory shall always be
erititled to the benefits of the writ of habeas corpus, and
of the trial by jury; of a proportionate representation of
the people in the legislature; and of judicial proceedings
according to the course of the common law. All persons
shall be liable, unless for capital offenses, where the
proof shall be evident or the presumption great. All fines
shall be moderate; and no cruel or unusual punishments
shall be inflicted. No man shall be deprived of his liberty
or property, but by the judgment of his peers or the law
of the land; and, should the public exigencies make it
necessary, for the common preservation, to take any
person's property, or to demand his particular services,
full compensation shall be made for the same. And, in
the just preservation of rights and property, it is
understood and declared, that no law ought ever to be
made, or have force in the said territory, that shall, in
any manner whatever, interfere with or affect private
39a
contracts or engagements, bona fide, and without fraud,
previously formed.
Article III.
Religion, morality, and knowledge, being necessary to
good government and the happiness of mankind,
schools and the means of education shall forever be
encouraged. The utmost good faith shall always be
observed towards the Indians; their lands and property
shall never be taken from them without their consent;
and, in their property, rights, and liberty, they shall
never be invaded or disturbed, unless in just and lawfui
wars authorized by Congress; but laws founded in
justice and humanity, shall from time to time be made
for preventing wrongs being done to them, and for
preserving peace and friendship with them.
Article IV.
The said territory, and the States which may be formed
therein, shall forever remain a part of this Confederacy
of the United States of America, subject to the Articles of
Confederation, and to such alterations therein as shall be
constitutionally made; and to all the acts and ordinances
of the United States in Congress assembled, conformable
thereto. The inhabitants and settlers in the said territory
shall be subject to pay a part of the federal debts
contracted or to be contracted, and a proportional part of
the expenses of government, to be apportioned on them
by Congress according to the same common rule and
measure by which apportionments thereof shall be made
40a
on the other States; and the taxes for paying their
proportion shall be laid and levied by the authority and
direction of the Legislatures of the district or districts, or
new States, as in the original States, within the time
agreed upon by the United States in Congress
assembled. The legislatures of those districts or new
States, shall never interfere with the primary disposal of
the soil by the United States in Congress assembled, nor
with any regulations Congress may find necessary for
securing the title in such soil to the bona fide purchasers.
No tax shall be imposed on lands the property of the
United States; and, in no case, shall nonresident
proprietors be taxed higher than residents. The
navigable waters leading into the Mississippi and St.
Lawrence, and the carrying places between the same,
shall be common highways and forever free, as well to
the inhabitants of the said territory as to the citizens of
the United States, and those of any other States that may
be admitted into the confederacy, without any tax,
impost, or duty therefore.
Article V.
There shall be formed in the said territory, not less than
three nor more than five States; and the boundaries of
the States, as soon as Virginia shall alter her act of
cession, and consent to the same, shall become fixed and
established as follows, to wit: The western State in the
said territory, shall be bounded by the Mississippi, the
Ohio, and Wabash Rivers; a direct line drawn from the
Wabash and Post Vincents, due North, to the territorial
4la
line between the United States and Canada; and, by the
said territorial line, to the Lake of the Woods and
Mississippi. The middle State shall be bounded by the
said direct line, the Wabash from Post Vincents to the
Ohio, by the Ohio, by a direct line, drawn due north
from the mouth of the Great Miami, to the said territorial
line, and by the said territorial line. The eastern State
shall be bounded by the last mentioned direct line, the
Ohio, Pennsylvania, and the said territorial line:
Provided, however, and it is further understood and
declared, that the boundaries of these three States shall
be subject so far to be altered, that, if Congress shall
hereafter find it expedient, they shall have authority to
form one or two States in that part of the said territory
which lies north of an east and west line drawn through
the southerly bend or extreme of Lake Michigan. And,
whenever any of the said States shall have sixty
thousand free inhabitants therein, such State shall be
admitted, by its delegates, into the Congress of the
United States, on an equal footing with the original
States in all respects whatever, and shall be at liberty to
form a permanent constitution and State government:
Provided, the constitution and government so to be
formed, shall be republican, and in conformity to the
principles contained in these articles; and, so far as it can
be consistent with the general interest of the
confederacy, such admission shall be allowed at an
earlier period, and when there may be a less number of
free inhabitants in the State than sixty thousand.
42a
Article VI.
There shall be neither slavery nor involuntary servitude
in the said territory, otherwise than in the punishment of
crimes whereof the party shall have been duly convicted:
Provided, always, That any person escaping into the
same, from whom labor or service is lawfully claimed in
any one of the original States, such fugitive may be
lawfully reclaimed and conveyed to the person claiming
his or her labor or service as aforesaid. Be it ordained by
the authority aforesaid, that the resolutions of the 23rd of
April, 1784, relative to the subject of this ordinance, be,
and the same are hereby repealed and declared null and
void.
43a
APPENDIX J - HUMAN RIGHTS 1948 -ARTICLE 7
Human Rights 1948 - Article 7
All are equal before the law and are entitled without
discrimination to equal protection of the law. All are
entitled to-equal protection against any discrimination in
violation of this Declaration and against and incitement
to such discrimination.
~
44a
APPENDIX K- HOUSE JOINT RESOLUTION 1514,
SEC 3,4,5,
The Declaration on the
granting of Independence of Colonial
Peoples (1960)
The Declaration on the granting of Independence ot
Colonial Countries and Peoples (1960) 2. All,persons
have the right to self-determination by virtue of that
right they freely determine their political status and
freely pursue the economic, social cultural development.
3), Inadequacy of political, economic, social or
educational preparedness should never serve as a
pretext for delaying independence. All armed action or
repressive measures of all kinds directed against
dependant peoples shall cease in order to enable them to
exercise peacefully and freely their rights to complete
independence, and the integrity of their national
territory shall be respected. 5). Immediate steps shall be
taken, in trust and Non-Self-Governing Territories or all
other territories, without any conditions or reservations,
in accordance with their freely expressed will and desire,
without and distinction as to race, creed or color in order
to enable them to enjoy complete independence and
freedom.
45a
APPENDIX L -HOUSE JOINT RESOLUTION 3103
SEC 1,2,3,
The legal status of Combatants
Struggling against alien dominations and
Racist regimes in accordance to the
Geneva Convention 1949
The legal status of Combatants struggling against alien
dominations and racist regeims, was agreed to in 1973.
It affirms that “the continuation of colonialism in all its
forms and manifestations, as noted in General Assembly
resolution 2621 (XXV) of 12 October 1970,_is a crime and
that colonial peoples have the inherent
right to struggle by all necessary_means at their
disposal against colonial Powers and alien domination in
exercise of their_rights of self-determination...”
1). The struggle of peoples under colonial and alien
domination and racist regimes for the implementation of
their right to self-determination_and independence is
legitimate and in full accordance with the principles of
international law.
2). Any attempt to suppress the struggle against
colonial and alien domination and racist regimes is
incompatible with the Charter of the United Nations, the
Declaration on Principles of International Law
concerning Friendly Relations and Co-operation among
States in accordance with the Charter of the United
Nations, the Universal declaration of Human Rights and
the Declaration on the granting of Independence to
46a
Colonial countries and peoples and constitutes a threat
to international peace and security.
3). The armed conflicts involving the struggle of
peoples against colonial and alien domination and racist
regimes are to be regarded as international armed
conflicts in the sense of the 1949 Geneva Conventions
and the legal status envisaged to apply to the combatants
in the 1949 Geneva Convention and other international
instruments is to apply to the persons engaged in armed
struggle against colonial and alien domination and racist
regimes
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.