Opposition Brief — Three O Realty LLC v. New York State Urban Development Corp.

Supreme Court brief2003

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

} Pree en. mA

Sp RR

, |

Nos. 02-909, 02-910 | JAN os |

SErCE Pi rad

IN THE LE OL tee

Supreme Court of the United States

THREE O REALTY LLC,

Petitioner,

- and -

WEST 41st STREET REALTY LLC, et al.,

Petitioners,

Vv.

NEW YORK STATE URBAN DEVELOPMENT

CORPORATION, d/b/a EMPIRE STATE DEVELOPMENT

CORPORATION and 42" ST. DEVELOPMENT

PROJECT, INC.,

Respondents.

ON PETITIONS FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

TO THE APPELLATE Division, SUPREME COURT OF

New York, First JUDICIAL DEPARTMENT

BRIEF IN OPPOSITION

JosePH M. RyAn*

JOHN R. CASOLARO

SuSAN B. KALIB

CARTER LEDYARD & MILBURN LLP

2 Wall Street

New York, New York 10005

(212) 732-3200

Attorneys for Respondents

* Counsel of Record ied J

i

QUESTIONS PRESENTED

1. Given arecord replete with support for the condemning

agency’s findings of blight, is the constitutionality of the taking

undermined by Petitioners’ self-serving and unsupported

allegations that the blight findings are “pretextual”?

2. Should the condemning agency be barred from

implementing a project to cure blight merely because the project

is one of the later stages of a highly-successful multi-phased

plan?

il

STATEMENT Pursuant To

SUPREME Court RULE 29.6

Respondent New York State Urban Development

Corporation d/b/a Empire State Development Corporation

(“ESDC”) is a political subdivision of the State of New

York constituting a public benefit corporation. 42™ St.

Development Project, Inc. is a wholly-owned subsidiary of

ESDC.

lil

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

NN IID chy he'd ba Vb as ode rd eo ew en i

STATEMENT PURSUANT TO SUPREME CourT RULE 29.6 ii

TS Sic vc wes e eee secret ciebs cee ili

TAREE GP CATED AUTOOORITINS 2. www ccc cw ccc cctes Vv

Gg oe ae errr 1

A. Fee Ee POO oi. eas. 1

B. ESDC'’s Authority To Acquire The Property

et i, Cae ta ee pio use wie’ 4

oe I SEOs Ss cn cc ccc es ea ees 4

SN SBE Sy eiciid sa had Were Wao be ewe 7

ES FS, re 7

Pomt I

THE Decision BELow Is FULLY CONSISTENT

WitH WELL-ESTABLISHED CONSTITUTIONAL LAw

CO ee ene 8

A. In Reviewing Condemnation Decisions,

This Court Has Always Afforded Great

Deference To Legislative And State

ns a vic a bees 8

B. The Administrative Record Amply

Supports The Condemning Agency's

NONE Fn a Soe a aw rae cee 9

iv

Contents

Page

Pomrt I

THERE Is No Evipence THaT THE STATED

Purpose OF THE Project Is PRETEXTUAL .... 15

Pomt II

RESPONDENTS ARE Not BARRED FroM

IMPLEMENTING A Project To Cure BLIGHT

MERELY BECAUSE THE Project Is OnE OF THE

LaTeR StaGes Or A MULTI-PHASED PLAN .... 20

Pomrt IV

THERE Is No ConFiict AMONG Lower Courts

THAT WARRANTS THis Court’s REview AND

CERTIORARI SHOULD BE DENIED ........... 24

APPENDIX — Matter of New York State Urban

PONE CRE Ss Be CE. BRA RE. la

Vv

TABLE OF CITED AUTHORITIES

Page

CASES

Berman v. Parker, 348 U.S. 26, 75 S. Ct. 98 (1954) ..8, 9, 19

City of Buffalo v. J.W. Clement Co., 28 N.Y.2d 241

COB FEE sea y AG 0508s Fete eek cine ka 20, 21, 22

Danforth v. United States, 308 U.S. 271, 60 S. Ct.

Be US Ee 65 OLS NEA ea Sew hae deetawes 22

Fallbrook Irrigation District v. Bradley, 164 U.S.

S32, FF Bi Ge DOGO Ss So Oe ed aes 15

Hawaii Housing Auth. v. Midkiff, 467 U.S. 229,

EOS Tt Go GEE COED 5 cc an cobcceectccenets 8,9

Hendersonville Light & Power Co. v. Blue Ridge

Interurban R. Co., 243 U.S. 563, 37 S. Ct. 440

PRED cane hatnd WAS baer eens eeecands 15

Hughes v. Consol-Pennsylvania Co., 945 F.2d 594

EGR SOE oc baad cWaea Valder euneeiss eas 15

Jackson v. New York State Urban Dev. Corp.,

ok ee 8 4 | err 18

Joslin Mfg. Co. v. City of Providence, 262 U.S. 668,

SD Se Ce, the Vices oa doves cheese 18

Matter of New. York State Urban Dev. Corp. (Hotel

Strand), Index No. 44607/91 (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co.

PR UE o's 5 68S o cu Rabe esa ee ec itiens 17

vi

Cited Authorities

Page

Murray v. La Guardia, 291 N.Y. 320 (1943),

cert denied, 321 U.S. 771 (1944) ............. 15

Niagara Frontier Building Corp. v. State of New

York, 33 A.D.2d 130 (4" Dep’t 1969), aff’d,

SOs Ci Tae CHEERS 0:00.03 ceGrbstex chicos 22

Old Dominion Co. v. United States, 269 U.S. 55

(1DESY ein vb 0-60 EER ee eae 9

Rindge Co. v. County of Los Angeles, 262 U.S. 700

CREED ocd chev ccvsava baeneer ke terceensees 9

Rosenthal & Rosenthal, Inc. v. New York State Urban

Dev. Corp., 605 F. Supp. 612 (§.D.N.Y.), aff'd,

771 F.2d 44 (2d Cir. 1985), cert. denied, 475 U.S.

1018, 106 S. Ct. 1204 (1986) ............. 16, 17, 19

Swan Lake Hunting Club v. United States, 381 F.2d

SIRF: ABE 0 be ony etanetc sass hiees 15

United States v. Gettysburg Electric R. Co., 160 U.S.

COR CIID nin deacon hk thnks ot i ee 8

Washington-Summers, Inc. v. City of Charleston,

430 F. Supp. 1013 (S.D. W. Va. 1977) ......... 15

West 41* St. Realty Corp. v. New York State Urban

Dev. Corp., 277 A.D.2d 47 (1* Dep’t 2000),

leave to appeal denied, 96 N.Y.2d 705 (2001) .. = 23

vii

Cited Authorities

Page

UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION

Fourteenth Amendment ...............--- bowen 9

STATUTES

N.Y. Unconsol. Laws § 6254 ............-+e005 4

N.Y. Unconsol. Laws § 6260 ...........---e05: 4,15

N.Y. Unconsol. Laws § 6263 ............-+005: 4

26 Am. Jur. 2d Eminent Domain §§ 1-3 ......... 8

l

Nos. 02-909, 02-910

IN THE

Supreme Court of the United States

THREE O REALTY LLC,

Petitioner,

- and -

WEST 41st STREET REALTY LLC, et ai.,

Petitioners,

v.

NEW YORK STATE URBAN DEVELOPMENT

CORPORATION, d/b/a EMPIRE STATE DEVELOPMENT

CORPORATION and 42™ ST. DEVELOPMENT

PROJECT, INC.,

Respondents.

On Petirions FoR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI

TO THE APPELLATE Division, SUPREME COURT OF

New York, First JuDICIAL DEPARTMENT

STATEMENT OF THE CASE

A. The 42™ St. Project

The 42™ Street Development Land Use Improvement

Project (the “42™ St. Project”) involves the revitalization of

approximately 13 acres of land in the Times Square area of

2

midtown Manhattan. (R 381).' The 42™ St. Project was

developed in response to rampant crime, substandard and

insanitary conditions, undesirable uses and physical and

social blight in the area. (R 86). The New York State Urban

Development Corporation d/b/a Empire State Development

Corporation (“ESDC”) and 42™ St. Development Project, Inc.

(“42DP”) have carried out the 42™ St. Project in phases,

beginning in 1990. (R 381, 384). Each of the earlier stages

of the 42™ St. Project successfully reduced blight in the areas

affected. (R 382-85, 399-400).

The current phase of the 42™ St. Project involves

development of a long-blighted area known as Site 8 South

(the “Project”).? The Project calls for the use of ESDC’s

eminent domain power to acquire blighted, obsolete and

underutilized buildings and surface parking lots from 11

different property owners, four of whom are the Petitioners.

The Project will reinforce, improve and continue the

metamorphosis of the 42™ St. Project area by further

eliminating blighted conditions and the resultant drain on

municipal resources, enhancing tax revenues, and further

stabilizing the Times Square area. (R 373-74, 417).

' “R” citations are to the printed record in the Supreme Court

of the State of New York, Appellate Division, First Department.

The 42™ St. Project extends from 7* to 8* Avenues between 40* and

43” Streets.

? Site 8 South is across the street from the Port Authority Bus

Terminal on Eighth Avenue between 40® and 41* Streets, extending

approximately half a block east toward Seventh Avenue.

3

ESDC underscored the vital need to develop Site 8 South

in its November 2001 Determination and Findings:

The blight in the area takes various forms: socially

in disproportionate crime statistics and a tarnished

City image, particularly for visitors entering the

City at the Port Authority Bus Terminal;

physically, in obsolete buildings and underutilized

parcels; and economically, in disproportionate

drains on municipal services and underutilized tax

and employment potential. Eradication of these

continuing substandard and blighted conditions

will yield benefits for the Project area, the 42™

Street Project area, and the City. (R 373).

The proposed development will provide economic, social

and physical benefits to the City and State of New York,

and will transform a blighted, deteriorated, substandard,

insanitary and underutilized site to full productive use.

(R 373-74, 402, 417, 419-21, 640-41, 644). The Project will

reduce crime, increase employment, boost tax revenue,

and create much needed class A office space in the area.

(R 373, 630-35, 641).

As the new headquarters for The New York Times, with

an additional 700,000 square feet of office space, retail uses

at grade, and an auditorium available for public use, the

completed development will be active and alive 24 hours a

day. Retail uses will enliven the side streets inic the evening

hours, attract passers-by, and discourage the current loitering

and other anti-social behavior. (R 421). The tower itself, with

its glass facade, will provide a dramatic icon for the City’s

skyline and a visual anchor for the area. (R 425-27).

4

B. ESDC’s Authority To Acquire The Property

In 1968, the New York State legislature created ESDC

and empowered it to acquire property in any lawful manner,

pursuant to the provisions of the Eminent Domain Procedure

Law (“EDPL”). New York Urban Development Corporation

Act §§ 4 and 13, N.Y. Unconsol. Laws §§ 6254 and 6263.

In the case of land use improvement projects, ESDC is

required to make findings that the project area “is a

substandard or unsanitary area, or is in danger of becoming

a substandard or unsanitary area and tends to impair or arrest

the sound growth and development of the municipality” and

that “the plan or undertaking affords maximum participation

by private enterprise, consistent with the sound needs of the

municipality as a whole.” N.Y. Unconsol. Laws § 6260(c).

ESDC made and updated detailed findings of substandard

conditions both in its Basis for Blight Findings and the

addenda thereto (R 508-45) and in its Environmental Review

Technical Assessment (R 397-428). ESDC also concluded

that the Project will allow maximum participation by private

enterprise to provide what the City greatly needs —

employment opportunities, enhanced tax revenue, and a

renewed showing of dedication from the business community

to the City. (R 373, 630-35, 641).

C. The Decisions Below

In December 2001, Petitioners’ challenged the Project

by initiating an original proceeding in the Supreme Court of

3 This brief is submitted in opposition to the petitions for writs

of certiorari of (1) Three O Realty, LLC (no. 02-909) and (2) West

41" Street Realty LLC, EMM Realty Corp., and Times Square Garage,

Ltd. (02-910). Both petitions were filed against respondents New

York State Urban Development Corporation d/b/a eg

t”

5

the State of New York, Appellate Division, First Department.

(R 65-85). Petitioners set forth two claims in their petition.

First, they argued that the Project served a private rather than

a public purpose. This claim was supported only by

Petitioners’ own inflammatory assertions that the stated

public purpose is pretextual. Second, Petitioners asserted,

again without the slightest support, other than their

own unsubstantiated assertions, that the proposed taking

is unconstitutional because Respondents refused to

permit Petitioners to develop their properties. (West 41* St.

Pet. App. C (12a)).

On June 20, 2002, the Appellate Division unanimously

dismissed Petitioners’ challenges to ESDC’s determination

and findings. The Appellate Division decided the case by

rejecting the factual foundations of the Petitioners’

arguments. The Appellate Division found as a factual matter

that “(t]he record shows that ‘the exercise of the eminent

domain power is rationally related to a conceivable public

purpose,’ that purpose being the further reduction of the blight

that has long pervaded the subject area.” (West 41* St. Pet.

App. 10a) (citations omitted). The Appellate Division

specifically noted that “[a]n active drug trade persists” at

the site (/d. at 10a). The Appellate Division also found as a

factual matter that “the record is devoid of evidence which

(Cont'd)

Development Corporation and 42% St. Development Project, Inc.

Because both petitions object to the same urban redevelopment

project and present similar factual and legal arguments, Respondents

are submitting this single response to these petitions for the Court’s

convenience.

“Three O” citations refer to the first petition (02-909) and “West

41* St.” citations refer to the second petition (02-910).

6

would support Petitioners’ conclusory allegations that the

long-standing prospect of condemnation barred them from

ameliorating or eliminating the persistent blight in the project

area.” (West 41* St. Pet. App. 10a-11a).

On June 26, 2002, the Petitioners purported to appeal as

of right to the New York Court of Appeals. On September

12, 2002, the Court of Appeals dismissed Petitioners’

appeals, stating that “no substantial constitutional question

is directly involved.” (West 41" St. Pet. App. A (1a-2a)).

No discretionary appeal was ever sought by the Petitioners

to the Court of Appeals.

Pursuant to a condemnation proceeding in the Supreme

Court, State of New York, title to all the properties in Site 8

South was transferred to ESDC on August 19, 2002. Due to

ESDC’s relocation efforts, the site.is already half vacant. For

example, more than 120 tenants from one building have

moved and received relocation payments, and the owner of

that building accepted a multi-million dollar settlement for

its property.

At no time during the relocation process have Petitioners

attempted to seek relief from any other court. Even after the

New York Court of Appeals dismissed their appeals,

Petitioners waited nearly 90 days before filing their petitions

for writs of certiorari.

7

ARGUMENT

SUMMARY OF ARGUMENT

Petitioners allege — without any evidentiary support in

the record — that the stated public purpose of the Project is

pretextual and that they could have developed the site

themselves. On the basis of their unsupported assertions,

Petitioners are asking this Court to question well-established

precedent, which has consistently afforded great deference

to legislative judgments.

Given a record replete with support for ESDC’s blight

findings and public purpose determination, this case does

not raise any constitutional issue. The fact that this Project

will incidentally benefit private entities does not undermine

the constitutionality of the taking.

There is no evidence in the record that Petitioners ever

tried to develop Site 8 South on a private basis or that they

even had the ability to do so, since they do not control the

entire site. Their property is not permanently insulated from

condemnation merely because this Project is the latest phase

in a highly-successful multi-phased urban redevelopment

project.

8

POINT I

THE Decision BeLtow Is Futty CONSISTENT Witr WELL-

ESTABLISHED CONSTITUTIONAL LAW AND PRECEDENT

A. In Reviewing Condemnation Decisions, This

Court Has Always Afforded Great Deference To

Legislative And State Court Decisions

It has long been recognized that the power of eminent

domain, one of the most ancient and significant sovereign

prerogatives, grants government and its authorized agents

considerable latitude and discretion to take privately owned

property, without the owner’s consent, for a public use.

See generally 26 Am. Jur. 2d Eminent Domain §§ 1-3.

This Court has never held a compensated taking to be

unconstitutional.

Judicial review of a condemnation decision is narrowly

circumscribed. Berman v. Parker, 348 U.S. 26, 32, 75 S. Ct.

98, 102 (1954). This Court has long held that “it will not

substitute its judgment for a legislature’s judgment as to what

constitutes a public use ‘unless the use be palpably without

reasonable foundation.’” Hawaii Housing Auth. v. Midkiff,

467 U.S. 229, 241, 104 S. Ct. 2321, 2329 (1984) (quoting

United States v. Gettysburg Electric R. Co., 160 U.S. 668,

680 (1896)).

The Court has made clear that:

when the legislature has spoken, the public interest

has been declared in terms well-nigh conclusive.

In such cases the legislature, not the judiciary, is

the main guardian of the public needs to be served

9

by social legislation. . . . This principle admits of

no exception merely because the power of eminent

domain is involved. Berman, 348 U.S. at 33, 75

S. Ct. at 102.

Courts may reject a legislative decision to condemn

property only if the decision was not “rationally related to a

conceivable public purpose.” Midkiff, 467 U.S. 229, 241,

104 §. Ct. 2321, 2329 (1984). Judicial “deference to the

legislature’s ‘public use’ determination is required ‘until it

is shown to involve an impossibility.” Midkiff, 467 U.S. at

240, 104 S. Ct. at 2329 (quoting Berman, 348 U.S. at 32, 75

S. Ct. at 102 and Old Dominion Co. v. United States, 269

U.S. 55, 66 (1925)).

In Berman, the Court defined “[t]he concept of public

welfare [as] broad and inclusive. The values it represents

are spiritual as well as physical, aesthetic as well as

monetary.” 348 U.S. at 33, 75 S. Ct. at 102-03. It may include

beautification and the creation of a healthy, spacious, clean,

well-balanced and carefully patrolled area. Berman, 348

USS. at 33, 75 S. Ct. at 102-03. The determination of what

constitutes a public use “is influenced by local conditions;

and this Court, while enforcing the Fourteenth Amendment,

should keep in view the diversity of such conditions and

regard with great respect the judgments of state courts upon

what should be deemed public uses in any State.” Rindge

Co. v. County of Los Angeles, 262 U.S. 700, 705-06 (1923).

B. The Administrative Record Amply Supports The

Condemning Agency’s Blight Findings

The record in this proceeding is replete with findings —

and support for the findings — that Site 8 South is marked

by substandard and blighted social, physical, and economic

10

conditions, and that the acquisition and subsequent

development of Site 8 South will serve the public interest.

The record substantiates the blighted conditions plaguing

Site 8 South including, inter alia, prostitution, drug use,

underutilization, a disproportionate amount of crime and

resulting drains on municipal resources and underutilized tax

and employment potential. (R 373). Economically, Site 8 South

now provides only a fraction of its tax and employment

capability.

ESDC’s Basis for Blight Finding and the addenda thereto

detail the conditions on Site 8 South from 1981 through 2001.

(R 508-545). These findings show that blight at Site 8 South

pre-dated the 42™ St. Project, that blight continues, and that,

without public intervention, there is no reason to believe blight

will cease to exist. Despite Petitioners’ assertions that blight in

Site 8 South was exclusively a problem of the past, ESDC’s

most recent Basis for Blight Finding (Third Addendum, August

2001) outlines the existing blight in Site 8 South:

* Site 8 South is “developed only to a fraction of

[its] theoretical capacity.” It is occupied by two

large undeveloped parking lots, a parking garage,

and several relatively small, low-rise buildings;

* The buildings in Site 8 South generally present

a shabby gateway to the Times Square area,

particularly for workers, visitors, and tourists

arriving in Manhattan via the Port Authority Bus

Terminal across Eighth Avenue;

* Prostitution, drug use, and loitering are still

common along Eighth Avenue in the vicinity of

Site 8 South, particularly around the many

sex-related businesses that remain in retail

storefronts; and

11

* These unseemly uses and the resulting lack of

most desirous amenities have the secondary

effect of discouraging pedestrians from lingering

in the area, which has retarded the area’s

revitalization and adversely affected nearby

areas.

(R 544-45).

The 2001 Environmental Review Technical Assessment,

performed for ESDC by an independent environmental

consultant, spells out how Site 8 South is both underused and

underdeveloped:

[A]ll of the Site 8 S stores are inconsistent with

the overall Project’s scale, intended uses and

atmosphere. Lots 14 and 53 [the surface parking lots]

are undeveloped, and at Lot 15, the upper floors are

sealed off entirely. None of the existing uses support

the Project goals. . . . such as restoring the Project

area’s role as a positive influence on the adjacent

communities, and increasing the Project area’s

economic contribution to the City as a whole.

(R 419). The 2001 Environmental Review Technical Assessment

elaborates on the problems surrounding the sex-oriented

businesses in Site 8 South:

Approximately five adult entertainment uses operate

at Site 8 S.... Such businesses continue to

maintain exclusively sex-related merchandise and,

accordingly, continue to create the secondary effects

of blight, increased loitering, and crime.

12

Site 8 S is the only remaining 42" Street

Development Project site that still retains several

adult-related businesses. ... As a whole, these

adult related uses continue to contribute to

blighting elements on Site 8 S and within the

surrounding neighborhood.

(R 420). The 2001 Environmental Review Technical

Assessment also addresses the loitering and lack of street

traffic on portions of the Site:

Portions of Site 8 S continue to attract loitering

and other undesired street presence. Tourists

and commuters hurry in and out of the area,

discouraged by the poor street-level conditions

and the lack of positive amenities. Most of the

retail establishments close early; for most

pedestrians, this absence of positive street activity

is highlighted at night by the presence of a bar

and sex-related establishments.

(R 420-21). The 2001 Environmental Review Technical

Assessment further cautions that these unfavorable conditions

will persist in the absence of development on Site 8 South:

With the exception of Site 8 S and Site 8 N, the

blighted conditions within the [Times Square] area

are expected to disappear. In 2005, existing uses

on Site 8 S and Site 8 N otherwise would remain

inconsistent with both the Project and surrounding

areas, and would continue to discourage

pedestrian activity along the eastern side of Eighth

Avenue south of 42™ Street.

(R 421).

13

The testimony of various community leaders at

the September 2001 public hearing on the proposed

condemnation of Site 8 South provides direct support for

these conclusions. Many individuals described in detail the

physical blight, decay, economic underdevelopment, and

unseemly business and pedestrian activity that marks Site 8

South. The excerpts that follow from the transcript of the

hearing reflect the consistent agreement on the many ways

that the public will benefit from the proposed development

on Site 8 South.

Bill Daly, the director of public services for the Fashion

Center Business Improvement District, described the present

conditions of blight in Site 8 South:

The particular site we are addressing at this public

hearing now contains small storefronts that

are clustered among five adult entertainment

establishments that exist side by side and create

the atmosphere of a mini red light district.

Such a concentration of sex businesses, combined

with the low-end retail and food establishments,

provides an enclave for criminals to loiter and

drug dealers to ply their trade on the sidewalk.

It is time to finally put an end to these conditions,

and doing so will encourage the rebirth of this

part of Eighth Avenue in the West Thirties.

(R 667-68).

14

Virginia Sullivan, the acting director of the Office of

Midtown Enforcement of the Office of the Mayor, echoed

those observations:

The Mayor’s Office of Midtown Enforcement

fully supports the proposed project to further

improve conditions in this area because our tools

alone are not sufficient.

City inspectors from the Buildings, Fire and

Health Departments assigned to our Office

continually issue code violations to the businesses

in this area as well as along Eighth Avenue.

Just this past May our Office brought a nuisance

abatement action against a premise within the

proposed site, 636 Eighth Avenue, used for the

fencing of stolen goods and for the sales of drug

paraphernalia.

The proposed site also houses mostly adult use

establishments, such as adult video stores and

peep shows that are not covered by the current

Advit Use Laws since they do not fall within the

required distance of any sensitive receptor. .. .

These establishments located in the site area

attract a less than savory element who linger in

front of the establishment morning and night and

contribute to the general feeling of unsafety.

(R 669-70).

15

These statements, and others like them (R 629-32),

support ESDC’s conclusion that Site 8 South is blighted and

that the proposed development will substantially benefit the

surrounding area and the City as a whole.

POINT Il

Trere Is No Evipence Tat THE STATED

Purpose Or Tue Prosect Is PRETEXTUAL

Petitioners argue that “the taking is unconstitutional

because it is being carried out for the private purpose of

substituting one private developer for another, not for the

purported public purpose of eliminating blight.” (West 41".

St. Pet., p. 13; Three O Pet., pp. 25-26). That this Project

benefits private entities does not negate or even call into

question the valid public purpose of the Project. Under

ESDC’s enabling legislation, ESDC is required to “afford

maximum opportunity for participation by private enterprise

...” N.Y. Unconsol. Laws § 6260(c). The fact that the Project

may advance incidental private interests of the New York

Times Company and the developer of additional office space

is not unlawful and does not detract from its public purpose.

See Murray v. La Guardia, 291 N.Y. 320, 329-30 (1943),

(“{I}f, upon completion of the project the public good is

enhanced it does not matter that private interests may be

benefited.”), cert. denied, 321 U.S. 771 (1944); Hughes v.

Consol-Pennsylvania Co., 945 F.2d 594, 613 (3d Cir. 1991);

Swan Lake Hunting Club v. United States, 381 F.2d 238, 242

(5* Cir. 1967) (citing Hendersonville Light & Power Co. v.

Blue Ridge Interurban R. Co., 243 U.S. 563, 37 S. Ct. 440

(1917)); Washington-Summers, Inc. v. City of Charleston,

430 F. Supp. 1013, 1015 (S.D. W. Va. 1977) (citing Fallbrook

Irrigation District v. Bradley, 164 U.S. 112, 161-62, 17

S. Ct. 56 (1896)).

16

For Petitioners to allege instead that the stated purpose is

“pretextual” would require specific proof that the stated purposes

~ are a sham and a fraud. Rosenthal & Rosenthal, Inc. v. New

York State Urban Dev. Corp., 605 F. Supp. 612, 618 (S.D.N.Y.),

aff'd, 771 F.2d 44 (2d Cir. 1985), cert. denied, 475 U.S. 1018,

106 S. Ct. 1204. (1986). In Rosenthal & Rosenthal, Inc., the

Court considered an earlier challenge to the 42™ St. Project and

found that “it would be quite reasonable for the project planners

to conclude that this kind of large scale redevelopment, bringing

thousands of new people into the neighborhood and radically

changing the physical configuration of the area, would further

the Project’s overall goals of eliminating blight and revitalizing

Times Square.” 605 F. Supp. at 619.

There is no direct evidence nor can any inference reasonably

be drawn that the stated purpose of the Project is pretextual.

Petitioners argue this point by stating they could have eliminated

existing blight themselves if they had been “permitted”

to develop the property. (West 41* St. Pet., pp. 6-7, 14).

Yet Petitioners cite no instances of their trying to develop the

properties or any denial or interference with any application for

a construction permit, zoning variance or financing. Nor do they

cite to any regulatory action by Respondents, or any other

authority, that interfered with Petitioners’ right or ability to

develop their property. In fact, Respondents in no way interfered

with the financing or development of the Site and, in fact, have

no authority to grant or deny building permits or zoning changes.

While Petitioners contend that they could have removed

the blight themselves, this claim is entirely unsupported in the

record. In fact, the diversity of land ownership on Site 8 South

(ten relatively small separately-owned parcels) has prevented

private sector assemblage. A lower court drew this conclusion

as a factual matter during the valuation proceeding of another

| a

site in the 42™ St. Project. See Matter of New York State Urban

Dev. Corp. (Hotel Strand), Index No. 44607/91 at 7 (Sup. Ct.

N.Y. Co. Aug. 18, 1997) (“Nor was there any indication that

without condemnation [claimant’s alleged potential] assemblage

would have been undertaken privately and a market for

claimants’ parcel (or air rights) created thereby ‘within a

reasonably close future.’’’).‘

Numerous sites in Manhattan have not been developed for

decades because of such fragmented ownership, most important

for present purposes, West 42™ Street before the earlier

stages of the 42™ St. Project. Rosenthal & Rosenthal, 605

F. Supp. at 618:

Nothing in the Constitution prevents a state from

deciding that in a particular area diversity of land

ownership stands in the way of full economic

development, and that assembling a major site to be

developed as a piece is the best way to serve the

public purposes of eliminating blight, creating jobs,

and broadening the tax base.

Petitioners’ claim that existing blight will disappear in the

absence of condemnation is wholly speculative and belied by

decades of inaction at Site 8 South and neighboring properties.

This claim is also belied by the record before this Court. Site 8

South was blighted long before the inception of the 42™ St.

Project; it was blighted when Respondents issued the

Determination and Findings challenged in this proceeding;

it remains blighted.

* Pursuant to Supreme Court Rule 15.3 and 24.1(j)(3), a copy

of Matter of New York State Urban Dev. Corp. (Hotel Strand), Index

No. 44607/91 at 9a (Sup. Ct. N.Y. Co. Aug. 18, 1997) is reproduced

in resp. app. (la-13a).

18

The existence of a valid public purpose in eliminating blight

in the Times Square area has already been determined. Jackson

v. New York State Urban Dev. Corp., 67 N.Y.2d 400 (1986).

Petitioners concede the removal of blight is a valid public

purpose (Three O Pet., p. 6). Respondents are in a position to

remove the blight effectively and efficiently. This conclusion is

firmly supported in the record and it is precisely what ESDC

was created to do and has done successfully in the 42™ Street

Project to date.

By arguing that ESDC should have chosen one of the

Petitioners to develop Site 8 South, Petitioners are, in effect,

arguing that ESDC did not choose the best, most efficient or

most desirable way to go about removing blight at Site 8 South.

The necessity and expediency of a taking, however, is not a

question for the courts:

That the necessity and expediency of taking property

for public use is a legislative and not a judicial

question is not open to discussion. Adirondack

Railway v. New York City, supra, 176 U. S. at 349,

20 Sup. Ct. 460; Shoemaker v. United States, 147

U.S. 282, 298, 13 Sup. Ct. 361; United States v.

Gettysburg Electric Railway, 160 U.S. 668, 685, 16

Sup. Ct. 427; Boom Company v. Patterson, 98 U.S.

403, 406. Neither is it any longer open to question

in this court that the Legislature may confer upon a

municipality the authority to determine such

necessity for itself. Bragg v. Weaver, supra, 251

U. S. at 58, 40 Sup. Ct. 62; Sears v. City of Akron,

246 U.S. 242, 251, 38 Sup. Ct. 245. The question is

purely political, does not require a hearing, and is

not the subject of judicial inquiry.

Joslin Mfg. Co. v. City of Providence, 262 U.S. 668, 678,

43 S. Ct. 684, 689 (1923).

\

19

Petitioners also argue that this taking is unnecessary because

their own properties are not blighted. (Three O Petition, p. 20).

As the excerpts from the record cited above demonstrate, Site 8

South is entirely blighted. Two of the Petitioners herein own

the two wholly underutilized surface parking lots on the site.

Even if isolated pockets of the site were found not to be blighted,

however, the relevant inquiry focuses on the condition of the

site as a whole. Rosenthal & Rosenthal, 605 F. Supp. at 615-16,

617; 771 F.2d at 46. This Court has long held that a condemning

agency may take for a public use property “which, standing by

itself, is innocuous and unoffending.” Berman, 348 U.S. at 35,

75 S. Ct. at 104. The Court reasoned as follows:

If owner after owner were permitted to resist

these redevelopment programs on the ground

that his particular property was not bzing used against

the public interest, integrated plans for redevelopment

would suffer greatly. . . .[C]ommunity redevelopment

programs need not, by force of the Constitution, be on

a piecemeal basis — lot by lot, building by building. It

is not for the courts to oversee the choice of the

boundary line nor to sit in review on the size of a

particular project area. Once the question of the public

purpose has been decided, the amount and character

of land to be taken for the project-and the need for a

particular tract to complete the integrated plan rests in

the discretion of the legislative branch. . . . It is not for

the courts to determine whether it is necessary for

successful consummation of the project that unsafe,

unsightly, or insanitary buildings alone be taken or

whether title to the land be included, any more

than it is the function of the courts to sort and _

choose among the various parcels selected for

condemnation.

Berman, 348 U.S. at 35-6, 75 S. Ct. at 104 (citations omitted).

a aaa

20

POINT Ill

RESPONDENTS ARE Not BARRED FROM IMPLEMENTING

A Prosect To Cure Buicut MERELY BECAUSE THE

Prosect Is OnE OF THE LATER STAGES OF A

Mutt11-PHASED PLAN

Petitioners argue that inclusion of their property as part

of the 42™ St. Project prevented them from developing their

property in violation of their due process rights. (West 41"

St. Pet., pp. 16-19). They claim that because it was well-

known that their property was part of the 42™ St. Project and

might one day be condemned, they were unable to obtain

financing or long-term-tenant commitments. Petitioners then

claim that as a result of this alleged deprivation, their property

is now insulated from condemnation entirely. Petitioners’

claims are unsupported in the record as a factual matter; they

are unsupported by the cases they-cite; and they are barred

by established precedent.

Confronted with pervasive and persistent blight in older

urban and commercial areas throughout this State, the New

York State Legislature recognized the need for a sustained

effort by the public sector in conjunction with the private

sector to remedy these conditions. That Respondents have

already made substantial progress in the area does not mean

that they cannot carry out the remaining phases of the 42™

Street Project.

Petitioners do not and cannot argue that their ability to

develor their property was directly prevented by some action

of ESDC, such as refusal to issue a building permit or passing

of restrictive zoning rules. In City of Buffalo v. J.W. Clement

Co., 28 N.Y.2d 241 (1971), the New York Court of Appeals

21

addressed the de facto taking concept implicitly raised by

Petitioners:

[T]he concept of de facto taking has traditionally

been limited to situations involving a direct

invasion of the property or a direct legal restraint

on its use ... and to hold that-there can be a de

facto taking appropriation absent a physical

invasion or direct legal restraint would, needless

to say, be to do violence to a workable rule of

law. |

In City of Buffalo, the city told the property owner of its

intent to condemn, led him to move his printing business,

and then delayed several years before deciding to condemn

his property. The Court of Appeals held:

The facts herein fail to disclose any act upon the

part of the condemning authority which could

possibly be construed as an assertion of dominion

or control . .. We simply have a manifestation of

an intent to condemn and such, even considering

the protracted delay attending final appropriation,

cannot cast the municipality in liability upon the

theory of a ‘taking’ for there was no appropriation

of the property in its accepted legal sense.

City of Buffalo, 28 N.Y.2d at 255. -

The record is devoid of any facts that Respondents have

in any way restricted Petitioners’ rights to develop their

property. At best, Petitioners are claiming that their right to

develop their property was impaired as a result of public

discussion and plans to redevelop through condemnation,

22

if necessary. The planning and attendant publicity,

controversy, litigation and delay with respect to multi-billion

dollar remedial projects do not, however, rise to the level of

a de facto or regulatory taking of property.

A reduction or increase in the value of property

may occur by reason of legislation for or the

beginning or completion of a project. Such

changes in value are incidents of ownership.

They cannot be considered as ‘a taking’ in the

constitutional sense.

City of Buffalo, 28 N.Y.2d at 255 (quoting Danforth v. United

States, 308 U.S. 271, 285, 60 S. Ct. 231, 237 (1939)).

If Respondents were responsible for affirmative, value-

depressing acts that resulted in diminished property value,

Petitioners could seek damages under a theory of

condemnation blight. Niagara -Frontier Building Corp. v.

State of New York, 33 A.D.2d 130, 133 (4" Dep’t 1969), aff'd,

28 N.Y.2d 755 (1971); City of Buffalo, 28 N.Y.2d at 257-58.

Petitioners’ resulting award would “be based on the value of

the property as it would have been at the time of the de jure

taking. but for the debilitating threat of condemnation.”

28 N.Y.2d at 258. Petitioners allege no such acts because

none occurred. Even if they had occurred, the remedy is

damages in the condemnation proceeding not an injunction

against taking the property.

Petitioners also argue that Respondents actively

prevented development of Site 8 South by “litigat[ing] state-

law statutory issues all the way to the New York Court

of Appeals” and by “rebuff[ing] a formal offer by the

landowners of Site 8 South to develop the Site.” (West 41*

St. Pet., p. 17). In fact, it was two of the Petitioners herein

23

who filed an action seeking declaratory relief that acquisition

of their property was time-barred. Petitioners lost that action

and unsuccessfully appealed to the New York Court of

Appeals. 250 West 41* St. Realty Corp. v. New York State

Urban Dev. Corp., 277 A.D.2d 47 (1% Dep’t 2000), leave to

appeal denied, 96 N.Y.2d 705 (2001). The Court of Appeals

denied the requested declaratory relief.

While that action was pending, ESDC and 42DP

representatives met with more than a dozen developers,

including a principal of one of the Petitioners concerning

possible development of Site 2 South. (R 182). The principal

of Petitioner West 41* St., which only took title to property

at the Site in 2001; submitted a letter to Respondents in 1999,

stating that the plaintiffs who brought the state court action

seeking a declaratory judgment (referenced in the preceding

paragraph) would discontinue that action with prejudice if

West 41" St. were designated the sole developer of Site 8

South. (/d.) In fact, West 41* St. explained in the letter that

the plaintiffs in that action (two of the Petitioners herein)

were contractually obligated to agree to condemnation if he

became the sole developer of the Site. (/d.). Thus, the Project

would have proceeded unchallenged by several of the

Petitioners if ESDC had simply chosen the now disappointed

West 41" St. as developer, even though the public-private

partnership would create the same public use issues alleged

here.

The large size of Site 8 South mandated, and 42DP

actively searched for, a creditworthy developer with the

strong prospect of a major tenant in the private market.

West 41* St. did not present a specific proposal, did not

demonstrate to 42DP that it had financing in place, and did

not have a long-term commitment from a major tenant.

24

POINT IV

THERE Is No ConFiict AMONG Lower Courts

THAT WARRANTS THis Court’s REVIEW

AND CERTIORARI SHOULD BE DENIED

One of the Petitioners argues that “[t]here is a split in

the Circuits and the State Courts on whether pretextual blight

findings may satisfy the Takings Clause’s ‘public use’

requirement.” (Three O Pet., p. 21). The other Petitioners

argue that there is a conflict among courts as to whether it is

constitutionally permissible to take private property from one

owner in order to give it to another landowner for its private

purposes. (West 41* St. Pet., pp. 14-15). Both these arguments

are preposterous. No case has ever held that a pretextual

blight finding is sufficient to satisfy the Constitutional public

use requirement. Nor has any case in modern jurisprudence

ever held that the state may take private property for the

purely private purpose of giving it to another landowner.

Aclose review of the cases cited by Petitioners indicates

that other courts reviewing condemmation decisions routinely

apply the same principles of condemnation law as the court

did below. The only material differences between the cases

cited by Petitioners and this case are the facts and outcomes

of the respective cases. That different facts produce different

outcomes hardly suggests a conflict. The purported conflict

simply does not exist and review by this Court is unnecessary.

25

Dated: New York, New York

January 13, 2003

* Counsel of Record

Respectfully submitted,

JosepH M. Ryan*

JouHN R. CASOLARO

Susan B. KALB

CARTER LEDYARD & Mi_BuRN LLP

2 Wall Street

New York, New York 10005

(212) 732-3200

Attorneys for Respondents

APPENDIX

la

APPENDIX — MATTER OF NEW YORK STATE

URBAN DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION

(Hotel Strand)

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK

COUNTY OF NEW YORK : IAS PART 24

In the Matter of the Application of the New York State Urban

Development Corporation to acquire title in fee to certain

real property necessary for a land use improvement project

— known as

42ND STREET DEVELOPMENT PROJECT

Index No. 44607/91

Claimant: 206 WEST 43RD STREET HOTEL CORP

(HOTEL STRAND)

Block 1014, Lot 37

206-208 West 43rd Street

New York, New York

PARNESS, J.:

This is a proceeding under Article 7 of the EDL to

determine the compensation to be paid claimant in this

condemnation proceeding. Vesting date was April 18, 1990.

The subject premises was taken as part of the 42nd Street

Time Square Redevelopment Project (Project). It contains a

12 story and basement hotel with two street level store spaces

sited on a 30’ x 100' lot and is located on the-south side of

43rd Street some 100 feet west of Seventh Avenue in the

Times Square area of Manhattan (206-208 West 43rd Street).

The property was assessed at $1,260,000 (transitional

$1,072,000).

2a

Appendix

The hotel has a total of 107 rooms, 45 with private bath

and 62 without. At vesting it was closed, by court order,

because of pervasive drug activity. When operating it

appeared to be more of a SRO rooming house rather than a

‘hotel providing, basically, shelter at modest prices with

minimum tradition hotel services. The posted “day rates” can

best describe this type of hotel and some of its daily clientele.

Built in 1905, the building had been permitted to deteriorate

both physically and in the manner of its operation.

Essentially claimant’s appraiser, Albert, opined highest

and best use to be demolition of the existing structure and

utilization of the lot for high rise development either by itself

or in conjunction with adjoining properties made similarly

available for development (Tr 2667, 2677). Through his

analysis of comparable sales of properties purchased for

development, at or near the Times Square area, he found a

development land value for the subject parcel of $100 per

square foot (S/F) when a 1987 valuation date is used, and

$110 S/F for the vesting date in 1990.

Albert’s referencing of 1987 for a valuation rate is

grounded in his opinion that absent the “threat of condem-

nation” — which he contends began late in 1970’s or early

1980’s when word of the proposed project became public —

the property would have been developed as were others

in the mid Manhattan area during the heightened building

period of the 1980’s. As examples, he cites certain hotel

and other commercial construction which took place at

that time just north of the subject parcel. Such development

was spurred on in part by zoning changes which, under

certain conditions, granted an increase in the permitted

3a

Appendix

floor area ratio (FAR) from 15 to 18, resulting in increases

in buildable areas permitted on a site. Albert therefore,

in determining his land value, selects 1987 valuation date so

as to obtain the benefit of this potential enhanced FAR.

However, he also submits an alternate appraisal at the FAR

15 in affect on the date of vesting.

As another valuation approach, Albert hypothesized

retention of the-existing operating hotel for which he obtains

a value based upon analysis of comparable sales of hotels

and in his rebuttal appraisal, through income capitalization.

He then opined an additional value based upon presumed

sale of the property’s air rights to a deveioper of a neighboring

site. This is predicated again upon his assumption that private

development would have occurred in the block in which the

subject property is located absent the project.

His damage values, whether he opines sale and demolition

of existing structure, or in the alternative, retention of the

hotel and sale of air rights, of course, differ depending on

whether an FAR 15 or 18 is applied to his lot square footage.

An FAR of 18 (his valuation date 4/18/87) produces

for this expert a vacant lot value, after deducting the cost of

demolition, of $4,800,000.00 while for a FAR of 15 he finds

a vacant lot value of $4,370,000.00. °

As stated, under his alternate valuation approach, he

retains and obtains a value for the existing structure with

an additicnal value based upon a sale of unused air rights to

hypothesized adjacent development site. From his analysis

of comparable hotel sales he finds a value for the subject

da

Appendix

premises of $80 per S/F of gross building area which when

applied to the existing hotel’s 28,315 S/F results in a hotel

building value of $2,265,000.00. To this he adds an additional

$1,100,000.00 for saleable unused air rights (16,880 S/F

at $90 a S/F) to yield a total damage value of $3,365,000.00.

Condemnor’s expert, Haims, found present use as highest

and best. He obtained value through income capitalization.

From what he determined to be the hotel’s actual gross

income from room rentals, he obtained a fall-out room rate

of $30 a day. This $30 daily rate when annualized (365 days)

and applied to the 107 rooms and then subjected to a vacancy

rate of 50% which Haims opines for this hotel, results in a

gross room rental income of $600,000 (30/day x 365 days

x 107 rooms x 50% vacancy). To this he added $55,500 as

potential street level store rental income (10,000 S/F at $55

S/F) and $10,000 for potential signage income. The result is

an effective gross rental income of $668,150 (after a 5%

[$2,750] allowance for vacancy and collection loss against

non-payment-hotel income). From this gross he deducts

stabilized expenses of $434.00 (see Haims’ appraisal P. 60)

obtained through his analysis of comparable hotel expenses

yielding a net operating (NOI) income of $235,000 before

real estate taxes. He then deducted real estate taxes in the

sum of $45,854. He anticipates an increase of $9,929 over

the property’s present taxes of $35,924 as a result of the

values found for this property (P. 61 of his appraisal). After

deducting taxes, he subjected the resulting NOI of $189,146

to a capitalization rate of 11.6% which yielded his value for

this property of $1,600,000.

Sa

Appendix

Essentially, the great disparity in value conclusions is

due to the experts differing opinions as to the properties

“highest and best use”; i.e. Haims adopting present use and

Albert a future one. Highest and best use determines value

and compensation to be paid whether or not it isthe present

or existing use (Matter of the City of New York [Dexter

Motors Inc.], 21 A.D.2d, 652, aff’d, 16 New York 2d 814).

Albert contends that, but for the threat of the instant

condemnation from the late 1970’s onward, the subject

parcel’s, highest and best use was as part of a development

site and absent the project it would have been marketable

during that period at appropriate development land values.

Haims disputes this, opining that the development in the

immediate block in which the subject property was located

was precluded by various socio-economic factors, such as

crime, a large homeless population, land marking of adjoining

. theatres, and cost of assemblage.

While it is always difficult to speculate as to what would

probably have happened with the subject property had not

the project taken place, certain factors are particularly

relevant as to such probability. What certainly is relevant is

the social and economic conditions of this portion of Times

Square which conditions pre-existed the project, particularly

as to their impact upon redevelopment.

The 42nd Street Development Project had as its principal

~ purpose the elimination of blighted conditions in certain portions

of the Times Square/42nd Street area, and replacement

with attractive and economically productive uses. The project

area focused on two blocks facing 42nd Street from 7th to

6a

Appendix

8th Avenus. Included also are certain properties facing the

Port Authority Bus Terminal and others in the Times Tower

block, the “crossroads” block bounded by 7th Avenue,

Broadway 41st and 42nd Streets as well as a portion of the

block between 42nd and 43rd Streets east of Broadway.

The original development of Times Square as a central

commercial and entertainment area can be traced to the early

1900’s when it became a transportation hub due in no small

part to the new subway system. During these early periods

some of the famous commercial buildings such as the Times

Tower and Astor and Knickerbocker hotels were opened.

With legitimate theatre development, the area in the early

period became famous as the “Great White Way”. However,

by the late 1920’s and early 30’s, the area became honky

tonk. Many of the theatres in the project area were converted

to movie houses. Deterioration began and almost no

construction occurred in the project area since the early

1920’s, the legitimate theatre activity having moved to

the north.

By the time the 42nd Street project area was proposed

in the early 1980’s, as contrasted with the surrounding area

with new hotel, office and residential construction, the project

area contained either vacant lots or underutilized parcels

supported by deteriorated and obsolete buildings. The

economic and social character of the project area was

determined principally by street level retail uses which

contributed to and supported the street conditions prevailing

at that time. Such uses included 14 movie houses whose fare

consisted of either pornography, horror or martial arts. These

operated over long hours with high patron turnover and

|

0 0 OO Eo

Ta

Appendix

contained a considerable amount of illicit activity. In fact

42nd Street contained the largest concentration of sex related

businesses in the city and many were located near the area

movie houses. Contributing also to the character of the area

was the fact that 16 establishments, excluding restaurants,

sold either beer or liquor. The project area’s 20 plus fast food

shops, amusement and arcades while posing no direct

problem, did reinforce the area’s problems by providing

support and loitering areas for those engaged in questionable

street activity.

The three area “hotels”, the Strand, National and Carter

similarly provided support in part for such illegal activity as

prostitution and drug dealing. Indeed, the subject Strand

Hotel was closed for that latter reason.

Details with respect to the high degree of illegal street

or other related sordid activities which gave to the area its

unsavory reputation are set forth in greater detail statistics

in Haim’s appraisal and in the final Environmental Impact

Statement (§2, 82-87) submitted in connection with this

project. Indeed the blighted condition of the area was

recognized by the Court of Appeals in Jackson v. UDC,

67 New York 2d 400, 412 (one of the many decisions

involving unsuccessful challenges to the project).

In sum, the area pre-project had been the subject of

pervasive deterioration both physically and socially over

many years, with a long standing unsavory reputation which

resisted change or rehabilitation. Any examination as to the

project area’s potential for redevelopment absent the project

8a

Appendix

thus must be had against this historical backdrop of

area crime, loitering, deterioration and general unsavory

reputation.

Addressing specifically Albert’s development claim for

the subject property, he does not seriously urge or persuade

that any developer would build just on claimant’s 18' x 120'

lot. Such a structure would not have been economically

viable. Rather he contends that it would have been acquired

to be part of an assemblage site for a large mega building

to be developed over the eastern portion of claimant’s block

bounded on the west by the Lyric and Victory theatres and

on the east by 7th Avenue, an area of some 29,000 S/F.

However, while this valuation is grounded upon the premise

that an appropriate site would be assembled no specifics

are provided identifying by whom, how large and when.

Further, even if such hypothetical developer were considering

assembling an appropriate size site in this area he would

be immediately aware that it would be surrounded still by

the unsavory street activity that permeated the project area

and gave it its reputation. Such developer would not have

the advantage of condemnation to globally eliminate these

problems.

In addition to the deterrent effect street conditions have

had and would have in discouraging commercial investment

in redevelopment there is the further potential difficulty

in assemblage due, not only to the fact that the parcels in

this area are in different ownerships, but also because of cost

of acquisition. Purchase of and assemblage would not come

cheap or easy. These properties contain high volume and highly

profitable cash businesses which could and would resist

9a

Appendix

development (as they did this condemnation). Parenthetically,

the other project claimants’ properties, which made up

Albert’s proposed development site have submitted damage

values similarly predicated on development in the area

aggregating some $65,000,000, values even in excess of

their own vacant land values. Unlike compensation paid in

condemnation, which is fixed at market, a private assemblage

must pay what is asked.

While fair market value may take into account a parcel’s

probable assemblage with other properties such “speculative

use must be substantiated by proof of facts that indicate a

likelihood that the property would be put to such use within

a reasonable close future” (Matter of the City of New York

(Dexter Motors Inc.), supra 21 A.D.2d, 652, 653, aff'd,

16 New York 2d, 814).

In the instant case there is “no probative evidence to

support the conclusion that the other properties were available.

to form an assemblage with the subject parcel” (S. Robert

Scheur, as Trustee v. State of New York, 65 A.D.2d, 921,

Matter of City of Rochester v. Iman, 51 A.D.2d, 651). Nor

was there any indication that without condemnation such

assemblage would have been undertaken privately and a

market for claimants’ parcel (or air rights) created thereby

“within a reasonably close future”. In sum, “if the parcels

were not brought together by a taking under eminent domain

the chance of their being united by agreement or purchase

in such a way as to be available well may be regarded as too

remote and speculative to have any legitimate effect upon

the valuation” (McGovern v. City of New York, 229 U.S.

363, 372).

ee

10a

Appendix

Also significant on the probability of development at

the times suggested by claimant is the fact that the very

climate for development in the 1980’s upon which claimant

bases a market for its property, resulted in a glut of new

commercial space. So much so that the instant project was

amended to put on hold the original commercial towers

planned for the area.

Even more unpersuasive is claimants hypothesized

retention of the existing hotel with sale of excess air rights

to an adjacent site. Transfer development rights (TDR) have

limited potential recipients. In this case they would be

adjacent sites to the east and west of claimant’s parcel.

Besides claimant’s disreputable hotel, the eastern portion

of claimant’s block contained fast food establishments, bars

and other sources of beer and liquor, a pin ball arcade and an

active movie all operating on extended hours. Immediately

to the west of this area were theatres and other businesses

which similarly attracted unpalatable street activity,

conditions, which at least prior to this project, showed no

sign of change in the foreseeable future. It is not reasonable

to assume that a developer would expend sums to acquire

and put up a first class building to still be surrounded

by continuing deterioration and crime. Nor, as indicated,

are there sufficient facts to indicate when, if ever, a demand

for said TDRs would be created. What is also interesting

is that almost all other claimants’ parcels in this portion of

the project area, in order to maximize value claims, opine

retention of the existing structures with sale of unused air

rights. It is not entirely clear who is to receive all these air

rights since none have opted to be a receptor site.

ee

lla

Appendix

In sum, claimant does not persuade that there was a

reasonable probability that its property or air rights would

have been marketable for assemblage purposes. There

certainly was no hint of it prior to 1980. Indeed, the only

apparent assemblage for development in the project area was

that on a 42nd Street/8th Avenue in the 1960’s, and that failed

leaving a site that became a parking lot and remained so at

vesting.

It is therefore clear that the instant condemnation or

“threat” thereof did not effect the value of the claimant’s

property. To opine that this 18' by 120' lot or its air rights

would have been marketable at an enhanced price based upon

a need by some yet unknown site assembler for claimant’s

land or TDRs would be pure speculation and is unsupported

by the facts in this case (Scheuer v. State of New York,

65 A.D.2d 921).

“Care must be taken, however, not to substitute for reality

the mere hope of the owner that the property may be used

for some specific purpose. Therefore, in order to merit

consideration the potential user must be so reasonably

probable as to motivate a prospective purchaser in his desire

to acquire the property” (Nicholas, Law of Eminent Domain,

Section 12B.14[2], citing U.S. v. Toronto, Hamilton et al

(338 v. U.S. 396, McGovern v. New York, 229 U.S. 363).

Such has not been demonstrated herein.

The court thus concludes that highest and best use for

this property is as it existed and the compensation to be

awarded will be determined upon that basis. Though both

12a

Appendix

Haims and Albert obtained value for the hotel through

analysis of “comparable hotel sales”, to obtain an adjusted

S/F building value for the subject property, the Court finds,

because of the limited number of comparables used, and

significant difference in the hotel service and ambience

provided by these comparables in contrast with what the

Strand offered, and the exaggerated adjustments required to

obtain “comparability”, that the sales comparison approach

to value, is not persuasive in this case.

While there may be some slight entrepreneurial aspect

involved in income generation, the Court concludes that both

appraisers alternative income capitalization analyses can

more appropriately be employed herein to obtain value. The

Court adopts claimant’s $40 daily room rate (a melded rate

which takes into account a potentially higher rate for rooms

with bath and a lower one for those without). The Court

further finds that by reason of the age and condition of the

building, the minimal services provided and the fact that a

substantial number of rooms are without bath, that a 50%

vacancy rate is appropriate. The result is a gross stabilized

annual room rental income of $781,000 ($40 x 365 [days] x

107 [rooms] x .50 [vacancy rate}).

For the 10,000 s/f of available store space the Court finds

from an analysis of comparables submitted a s/f value of $60

to yield a store income of $60,000. A further income of

$15,000 is found for potential signage. The foregoing results

in a total gross building income of $856,000. From this the

Court will deduct a 5% vacancy factor from the store and

signage income ($3,750) leaving a gross effective income of

13a

Appendix

$852,250. Against this the Court will deduct stabilized

expenses in the manner suggested by Albert, as follows:

Real Estate Taxes (actual) $ 35,925

Room expense (30% of hotel income) 234,000

Energy (2.50/room/day x 365x107x.50) 48,818

Administrative (hotel) 10% of hotel income 78,100

Insurance ($2.00 room/day x 365x107x.50) 39,055

Reserves (3.5% hotel/income) 27,335

Room rehab., $3,000/room-15yr. amortization 64,031

Property operations/maintenance 58,582

($3.00 room/day x 365x.50)

‘ Management (5% of gross building income) 42,612

Total $628,458

The result is a net operating income of $223,802

($852,250 - $628,458). Adopting a capitalization rate of 11%

results in a damage value for this property of $2,034,565.

Settle order and decree.

Dated: 8/18/97 J.S.C.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.