Supplemental Brief — Kaliardos v. General Motors Corp.
Supreme Court brief1995
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
BSCLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
7\ A | 1030-D North Crooks Road
ESANGe Vi DeLee.
Y
Oo
a
pa
}>
PWM
aa
oa
Bs
p>—
Pr $44
>
Clewson. Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
LEX RHODES,P.C.
LAB I.D.# 90/01023/105
pace 2
REVIEW SUMMARY
x reviewing information and analytical data regarding the
composition of BASF anticorrosion wax coating $51Z001l, it is my
opinion the ingredients or ingredient ecuivalents which are specified
in claims 1 of U.S. Patent 3,959,450 and of U.S. Patent 4,356,036 are
present in BASF anticorrosion wax coating $512Z001. The following is a
tabular summary of the ingredients, or ingredient equivaients, which
re specified in claims 1 of U.S. Patent 3,959,450 and of U.S. Patent
4,356,036 and are j-resent in BASF anticorrosion wax coating $512001.
IGREDIENT BASIS FOR OPINION
3.0 l. Absolute Analytical Laboratory (AAL)
analyses of BASF liquid sample $512001
2. General Motors,BASF, and BASF supplier
Materiai Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
3. BASF laboratory analysis of BASF $512001
Microcrys<a:i.in
iD
wn
re
.
Absoiute Analytical Laboratory (AAL)
analyses of BASF liquid sample S512001
z. General Motors,BASF, and BASF supplier
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
3. BASF laboratory analysis of BASF $512001
Perchioroethviene 1. Absolute Analytical Laboratory (AAL)
analyses of BASF liquid sample $512001
2. AAL analyses of anticorrosion wax
coatings obtained from 1984 Olds Cierra
3. BASF laboratory analysis of BASF $512001
Petroleum Cistiilsate 1. General Motors,BASF, and BASF supplier
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
2. American Society for Testing and
Materials (ASTM) “Manual on Hydrocarbon
Analysis" Table I
—-a- =
-S2-€ STAN i. Gentssi HMorors,BASF, and SASF supplier
Matsci.ail Safety Sata Sneets (MSOS)
a. Che sicel Abstracts Service (CAS)
kettrunce search Stearic Acic/surfactant
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D Norn Crooks Road
Cicwscn, Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
Surfactant (cont. )
elating Agent
INGRESIENT
Aluminium or tine Paste
Mie tds: vetabics
v
Wex
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
LAB 1.D.# 90/01023/105
page 3
PATENT NO. 3,959,530
BASIS FOR OPINION
3. Absolute Analytical Laboratory (AAL)
report on GM MSDS of 998-1128.
4. Literature review of commercial
surfactants.
5. AAL analyses of anticorrosion wax
coatings obtained from auto scrapings
1. General Motors,BASF, and BASF supplier
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
2. Chemical Abstracts Service (CAS)
reference search Stearic Acid/ligand and
P.P. Methy Diamine/ligand
3. Absolute Analytical Laboratory (AAL)
report on BASF liquid sample $51Z001
4. Literature review of ligands/chelating
agents.
PATENT NO. 4,356,036
BASIS FOR OPINION
1. Absolute Analytical Laboratory (AAL)
analyses of BASF liquid sample $512001
2. General Motors,BASF, and BASF supplicr
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
AAL analyses of anticorrosion wax
ccatings obtained from 1984 Olds Cierra
Ww
.
1. Absolute Analytical Laboratory (AAL)
analyses of BASF liquid sample $512001
2. Gen-ral Motors,SAS?F, and BASF susplier
Mnt.rial Safety Gata Sheets (MS5S)
3. EXS iabcoratory analvsis of BASF $5.20C2
ABSOLUTE :
ANALYTIC AL ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
My at: 1030-D North Crooks Road
Vil eLree,\ Fenl "Michigan 480%
Ciowson, Michigcn 48017
LABORATORY ' 313-435-5100
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
PAB I.N.8 90/01023/105
page 4
INGREDIENT BASIS FOR OPINION
Aromatic Kycrocardcen 1. BASF supplier (Neville Co.) MSDSs and
Resin; R&B 70-14CC product literature.
2. General Motors,BASF, and BASF supplier
Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
3. BASF laboratory analysis of BASF $512Z001
4. BASF formula cards and batch information
5. Absolute Analytical Laboratory (AAL)
analyses of BASF liquid sample S$512z001
Chlorinated Rubber having 1. AAL analyses of BASF liquid sample
a combined chlorine $512001
content of at least 66% 2. AAL analyses of anticorrosion wax
coatings’ obtained from 1984 Olds Cierra
ates Suifonzte 1. AAL analyses of BASF liquid sample
$512001
2. AAL analyses of anticorrosion wax
coatings obtained from 1984 Olds Cierra
3. AAL analyses of BASF liquid sample
$51zZ0C1l
Cnlorinatec Scoivent 1. AAL analyses of BASF liquid sample
$512001
2. AAL analyses of anticorrosion wax
coatings obtained from 1984 Olds Cierra
BASF laboratory analysis of BASF $512001
tw
.
-
.
Aromatic Eyérccerbon General Motors,BASF, and BASF supplier
Solvert Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
2. American Society for Testing and
Materials (ASTM) “Manual on Hydrocarbon
Analysis" Table I
Spirics 1. Generai Motors,BASF, and BASF supplier
Materiel Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
American Society for Testing and
Materials (ASTM) “Manual on Hydrocarbon
Analvsis™ Tabie I
2. DASE formula cards and satch information
NO
10.
ye a a
3
ey
ve)
5
he
ct
¢
fon
@
10
a |
ABSOLUIL ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson. Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
ALEX RECDES,P.C.
LAB I.D.# 90/01023/105
pege 5
Saar? TEPOS Cr RASF ANTI-CCRROSION WAX COATING $51i200i .
1.0 PERCHLORCETEYLENE
1.1 Two types of wax based antirust samples were analysed by our
laboratory. One type consisted of scrapings of various wax based
antirust samyles obtained from the interior surfaces of car doors. The
second type ccnsisted of a Droduction line sample of $51Z001 (Inmont
998-1126). Perchlorcethylene was detectee in anticorrosion waxes in
"ur laborator:: using a technique known as dual column gas
chromategrarn- with the electron Capture detector (see Byrd deposition
- The sensitivity of this technique is particularly
-€s2 types of samples when one considers sensitivity
and selectivi-v. The sensitivity and the selectivity of the electron
capture ce*ccter sliows for detection limits three-five orcers of
cater than that obtainable by the mass spectrometer
1.1.3 Bases veon SASF Laboratory tests {see Ramesh deposition) the
Sém@pie Of awluminiond anticorrosion wax tested at the BASF laboratory
7
710 in hexane. Approximately two (2 ul) microliters of
Mx Ture was injected into the cas chromatogranh/mass spectrometer.
ai.
sesh sig
a | ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY :
LACAN AA onc |
SLABORATORY
313-435-5100
ALEX RHCDES,P.C.
LAB I1.D.# 90/01023/105
ase 6
i @|
Because the cancsity cf nexane is 6.66C3 (see enclosure #2) two
microliters of the solvent would have a mass of approximatley 1.32
milligrams (Z ul x 0.6603 mg/ul=1.32 mg) of which ten percent is the
sampie is the sample. This amounts to 132 micrograms (1.32 mg x .l=
0.132 mg cr 132 micrograms) of sample injected. Once injected the
- sample wouls oc further split (typically 1:50-100) reducing the effect
amount going to the mass spectrometer to 1.32- 2.64 micrograms (130
micrograms , 50-i1C0 = 1.32-2.64 micrograms). Using a routine
detection limit of 10 nanograms for the mass spectrometer, the method
used by BASF cculd only detect concentrations of perchloroethvlene
wnich were creater then 7,690 parts per million (ppm) or 0.76 %
perchiorcethylene in the sample. This is an optimum estimate based
upon 160 zsrcent Gissolution of the semple which was not reported
(Ramesh ce: isitior}).
1.1.2 Ev ccen*rast che method used in our laboratery utilized
semplcs havine a@ mass in the range of 0.1-0.5 grams which were sealed
in a vial with a volume of approximately 1.5 ml. The sealed vial was
heatec to liberate vavors of perchloroethylene present afterwnich a
12.
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clowson, Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
&LEX RHODES,P.c.
LAB I.D.é 90/01023/105
pace 7
sample ~0.5-ji mj takea for énalysis. aA conservative estimate of
effective Sample werss injected would be 33 mg (0.5m1/1.5m)] x 100mg=33
my). Since PiCog ram detection limits “ee routine with the Clectrcon
capture Getcctor (see cAaclosure #163) then one could conservatively
expect to be able +o detect 30.3 Parts per trillion (ppt)
~}2
perchlcroeth-lene (10 Crams cof perchloroethylene-detection
#2
simit/3.3xi90 ¢rems of sample= 0.C0C000000030 or 30ppt). This
represent: cover ore hundred million times greater sensitivity than
could be ashieveg using the SASF method. Our detections limit along
with dual caisan confirmation by gas chromatography is an appropriate
method of Enéivsis and identification when the analyte is below the
Getection Lirit of the MASS spectrometer.
1.1.3 tie nete chat the Ecp metnod was not previously used until the
necc arose to éncivse low levels of berchloroethylene in the
Scréping sannles taken from the G.mM. doors. Que prior reports
(see Byrd Sepesiticen exhitit 46° dia not use the Ecp technique
because @lectrcn Ceptere Cetector was not available and installeg in
~~“ a eT res ‘ a & ™ ~ te _ ° - ; -~; =
Cur ces c: ~ SORTCST APA uel &lcer these reoorts were issuec, therefore
we sk tae bt ee fean’ CUS t¥ie 4% ¢ analvsis.
pe
S :
ALYTICAL anni ocean =
PW! il Ciewson. Michigan 48047
oO ATORY 313-435-5100
ALEX RHODES, P.C.
LAB I.D.# 90,/01023/105
I~
1.1.4 The anaivsis weriormed sy the EASF laboratory with tne gas
iD
chromatocrarh electron cépture detector does not provide evicence
that perchicrcetnviense and toluene coelute.
performec cn 2 D5-624 column indicate that toluene and
perchlioroethyiene do not coelute and are well resolved (see enclosure
with the cclumn manufacturer (J & W Scientific;Redondo,California).
che manufacturer stated that toluene and perchloroethyene do not
coelute under the analytical conditions used. The column manufacturer
further stated that toluene would not interfer due to its low relative
responce to the electron capture detector. Additional information
obtaines Fras cur tests indicate that toluene at very high
concentrations (cé. 1-2 ¢ toluene) result in extremely small signals
from th2 clactron casture Getector corresponding to less than 20
Micrevolts «.c¢ =.closure #4). Small responses of the electron capture
Getector cc =.ioh concentrations of toluene should be borne in mind
wnen examinizcg the BASF laboratory results with the electron capture
Getector.
14.
. BSOLUTE
psa ia ABSOLUIL ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
‘ a ~ >
1030-D Nortn Crooks Road
a
a . P iM 4 N\A Lar wll Clawson. Michigan 48017
LAB ° PATO &8 Y 31
513-435-5100
¥ 24%S show that it is not possible for toluene
to produce the signal reported by BASF to the toluene standard
(exhibit #5) which depicts Signals of ~750 millivolts to corresponding
to “O" amount of standard of toluene. Rather the BASF results indicate
contamination cf the BASF standard with perchloroethylene. Another
implication of this is that the RASF laboratory was detecting
perchioroethylene in the anticorrosion sample (see enclosure #6) as
Videnced by the peak at 3.497 minutes. Lack of rigorous methodology
led to the improper conclusicn that toluene and perchloroethylene
coelute (ses Ramesh deposition exhibit #1).
1.1.5 The rescrt issused by Chemical Industrial Services, Inc. on
March 24, 19€2, it is not inconsistent our test results with respect
to perchlerclethayiene or the analytical capabilities of an industrial
testing lab such as Chemical Industrial Services, Inc. It is only in
recent years that aralytical techniques and information were available
regarding trace and ultratrace determinations. This type of analysis
is @ highly speciotized area and not the province of industrial
LS.
FST AVAIL ABI
UTE .
Late) ene
VN ae L Clawson, Michigan 48017
Cc. SItaeOR ATO 8 Y ; 313-435-5100
ALEX REODES
LAB 1.D 9
laboratories, such as Chemical Industrial Services, Inc. We further
nete that tne type of instrumentation required to do this analysis was
not cresent at my visizc to Chemical Industrial Services, Inc. Lastly,
upon expnlainince the technique tc Mr. Ray of Chemical Industrial
Services, inc., he concurred with the findings of our laboratory.
~.0 PETROLEUM DISTILLATES AND AROMATIC SOLVENTS |
2.1 The presence of cetroleum distillates and aromatic solvents in the
BASF coatinc is discolsed bv =he MSDS°s of BASF suppliers. “he
patent 3,95¢,4:20 ssecifies that a petrcieum distillate having a
boiling point rénce between 350-380 F. Patent # 4,356,036 specifies an
aromatic hvdrecarben solvent. The Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS)
supplicd ky BASF crecify solvents having aromatic constituents as
major cons=:tuents. The Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS) supplied
by BASF srecify solvents having major constituents that are petroleum
Gerivcd distillates heaving a boiling point range between 350-380 F.
- 7
_
~——
inc peints of various sclvents used by BASF in the
formuiaticr of the £512001 ANTI-BUST (see enclosure #7) as called out
3
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson, Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
LAB I.D.# 96/01023/105
pace lj
in tbs: formulary cards were comparca ta the corresponding BASF MSOS“s
(See Cnelosure $95 reported boiltiy point data. the solvents, when
generic solvent descriptions were used, were also compared to an
American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM) “Manual of
Hydrocarbon Analysis" hydrocarbon characteristic table (see enclosure
#8). Our resuits Orr tabulated below:
PASF CODE # MSDS SP (F) MANUAL BP RANGE (F) COMMENT
SP0624 313-355 258-354 UNION CHEMICAL
SP0603 210-360 - ASHLAND CHEMICAL
CAS :8052-41-3
SPO504 3i1€-360 258-384 ASHLAND CEEMICAL
PZ61€5 313-338 303-384 UNITED STATE
BRONZE POWDERS
SP0604 325-384 303-384 SHELL
2.1.2 te rete that che “Manual of Hydrocarbon Analysis" indicates that
the boiling roint of 2 Cll hydcrocarbons, such as used in Union
Chemicals Surer ign Flash Naptha (BSASP additive code SP0624), has a
listed boiling point of 384 F. This is not reflected in the MSDS
corresponcing to S=Cé24, however, this component would have such a
~~. aes’. -* weee a
boiling peirs. The manual 2:
i
a
a)
”
if)
t 4
J
ey
‘cicates that the boiling point
Cs 2 21 fiver creheas, seen ss sot in Union Chemicals Super Eigh
1?.
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1036-D North Crooks Roag
Clewson. Michigan 48047
313-435-5109
ALEX RHODES, F.C.
LAB I.D.# 90/610223/105
page J2
Flas> Naptha ‘SASF additive code SPC524), has a listec boiling point
1@)
hh
Ww
uw
lw
|
.
"
~
S|
'
-~
ov
r examples can be found in the other listed BASF
2.1.2 The aromatic nydrocarbons content of solvents used by BASF in
the formulation of tne $$17001 ANTI-RUST (see enclosure #9) as called
out ‘in the ‘crmulary card were compared to the corresponding MSDS‘s
aromatic hvérocarzcons Gata. The solvents, when generic solvent
€escriptions were supplied, were also compared to an ASTM hydrocarbon
Characteristic tazrle (see enclosure #8). Our results our tabulated
below:
BASF CODE = 2STM MANUAL MSDS LATA 3 AROMATIC TYPE
SPOE624 PRES =Y. C-10 xXYLENES
UNICN CH=éM. PRESZAS 20-45 TRIMETHYLBENZENE
AMSCG SCLV PPESEXT NA CUMENE
2435 PAESEST 95 TOTAL AROMATICS
PRESENT NA MONOBENZENES
PRESENT NA AROMATIC NAPHTHENES
a,
we
te te tr”
1030-D Nortn Crooks Rood
3 UTE
ALY.TICAL ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
Pa
U Nat Cicwson. Micnigen 48017
ATCRY ' 513-435-5100
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
LAB I.5.#% 90,/01023/105
BASF CODE = ASTM MANUAL MSDS DATA 3 AROMATIC TYPE
SPO604 FRESENT goed TRIMETEYLBENZENES
ASHLAND £RESENT NA MONOBENZENES
MINERAL SPTS. PRESENT NA AROMATIC NAPHTHENES
SPO604 PRESEKT 10-11 AROMATICS
SHELL PRESENT NA MONOBENZENES -
MINERAL SPTS. PRESENT NA AROMATIC NAPHTHENES
2.1.4 In summary the tables indicate that solvents used by BASF in
‘he formulaticn of the $512007. ANTI-RUST (see enclosure #7) as called
out in the formulary: cards contain mineral spirits, aromatic
hycrocarbons, ance pctroleum derived Gistiliates with constituents with
boiiing soints between 350-380 F. We note that the aromatic components
ere =Ct Sreicnt in “trace” quantities, rather the constituents
represent maior components. Another important consideration is the use
Of Scivent compatable with the Ross Wax 160 (see enclosure #10) which
the méenuiactusar identified as hot naphtha, xvlene, toluene, carbitol,
isopronanol cr trichicroethylene. The first three of the listed
SO°WLRtS ares arumctie hydrocarbons or contain aromatic hydrocarbons
(ag.nsphtha! are annear on the fcrementioned tables.
19.
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clewson. Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
LAB I.D.# 90/01023/105
page 14 |
3.1 Tne evicence presented in numerous BASF MSDSs, laboratory results
and in the scientific and industrial literature indicate that a
titer Pavetreet cen rue dette prevent oom the WASK tormulbation 35124001
ANTI-RUST.
3.1.1 The MSDS forms of GM and BASF suppliers (see enclosure #11) list
stearic acid as one of the ingredients. Examples of stearic acids use
are incicéeted Sy the listing of stearic acid by a chemical standards
Supplier (see enclosure #12). Kh search of chemical abstracts (see
enclosure #13) identified severa!: references with respect to stearic
3.1.2 Althmouch stearic acid is classified as a anionic surfactant,
never the less it is a surfactant and produces the desired surface
enercy changes with respect to manner of use and efficacy when
com-arcd to nonieni« surfactants.
20.
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
A 1030-5 Nortn Creoks Roca
ALL Clawson, Micnigan 48017
Y 313-435-5100
EX RHCCES,P.C.
4B I.D.# 90/01023/105
paac 15
4.0 CHELAT iW: AGiIN'Y
4.1 Examination of the ingredients listed on the submitted MSDS forms
used by GM and BASF suppliers (see enclosure 711,14) list stearic acid
(C.A.S. # 57-11-4) anc P.P. Methyl Diamine (C.A.S. # 101-77-9) as
ingredients. Soth chemicals possess ligands (see enclosure #15,see
Byrd depositicn exhibit 4196) which are capable of binding to metals.
4.1.1 Stearic acié is shown to be chelating agent in references
through chemical abstracts searches (see enclosure #15). The
carboxyl group on the stearic acid is the ligand which binds to the
metal (see Byrds Cenosition 106aj. The alkyl portion of the stearic
acid would wiied in the wax matrix and the ligand portion would locate
On the extisr surface of the wax where the ligand could bind to
MCtui.
4.1.2 P.P. Meth.! Siamine has been SnO0wn to be a chelating ascent in
references throush chemical abstracts and literature searches (see
¢
enclosure #15,see Byrd deposition exhibit f#106). The amine groups of
P.P. Methyi Diamine are the ligands which bind to metal {see Byrds
= 3628 (C.&.8. # S7-11-4) and P.p. Methyl Diamine
1 ARES
IX
/o\\ AAP Mb
‘ee, 3 ee ee we ee ee
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson. Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
ALEX RHCDES,P.C.
LAS I.D.# 90/0102
page id
(C.A.S. # 101-77-9) can bind metals. In this way they are used
and function in & similar fashion to N,N,N’,N -tetrakis (2-
hydroxypropyl!) ethylenediamine.
5.0 AROMATIC EYDROCARBOCN RESINS
S.1 Tne coatince of Patent ¢ 4,356,036 includes an aromatic hydrocarbon
“esin. Cur review of the Material Safety Data Sheets (MSDS) supplied
by BASF lists several products having hydrocarbon resins as the
primary constituent. BASF used an assortment of the hydrocarbon resins
which nac softenince points between 70-140 C.
5.1.1 We note chat all the SASF MSDS°s which have been supplied,
indicate thrt SASF «usec hydrocarbon resins with a R&B softening point
between 70-140C. = tabulation of hydrocarbon resin and their
respective ring «end ball softeninc temperatures are given below:
RING & BALL (Cj
RRO1CS 103
RRO1L52 105
SUPPLIER/TYPR
NEVILLE CEEMICAL
NEVCHEM 100 RESIN
NEVILLE CHEMICAL
LX-685 125 RESIN
HERCULES
22.
QO
be-
>
* _ “ ——_ _— ~
. — = . . . . . — - - n
ae ~ c ARK” rou a a
PALI ISL t VAAL we FAL HIATT Y
ar ma « -
j | \oe a
r¢ be
4 / INC ~(OOKS KOOC
a. | 4 ‘ \ ' ‘ ‘ *W/tar \A “"IMAmnm AQNM4a?
wee WS Ly OY DV es Li LA i ov Ow v ood
ee
‘1 ~
4) \
\ NYLABORATO
\ in sesasionseesssesniasiesti
rR i ila pa ete ie eT ~— stanmapenpiinatrnieniis “_ ee ave siencienesittnenes
‘ \ P °
} Pr A~ welt ; ~+ ~+ + - n+ - r 7 Whe Racr r "4 + B , tC - . +
obhe€ fal Berman ee “CC tra ~WLGLINCT DY SHoLt --1€M]) mit ru MN ( di
r CT om 17QaQ° a . } - TIA AAY A RIN + rom .
S ss IG2TOCN camer -~) f : ey p “RUST inAicas . > Drecanca
Aof da legs b ewei SEMDLE Of WReVuus BNL ERS st 24s4icCates the re Csence
a anh = i 3 . Uare ata. roc * Ms ¢ - ) be os + 1H man: -
~*~ @1 aromatic NVQrocarbon ££5lNn. IN1sS was al cne £ Ltmon Oo!
rs 75 4 Biss >. a ur eh recran+ + - ~ nroaca “2 ~ $ ar y ~ on
4 K at © Nd a & Ws tf) «espe ws 4 LOU Lile éMLCSCNHC OL aii 2aloma ©
~ a X
5 1 : AA : ; - 1 ,° A .
faroceaerhban racin ~ + ) QQ7 RH oh mola + cc { | ye TT on
yMa2UCec TpDon 4Ga2d a 52 G a 4 oO / WaACCH Samp le WE OILS Vi ANIL
;S4
JIL ew
> + : 7 - i . < . , 4 =e? ae _
| 2 Th e = alverec «és ~e > . 19a hatch la at ec ON} on jom
e J = il Gaal aa A a Ac a L198 / VMaALCT) ALE Ol ~M~ILLUU! RUOlL
> 7 > Nacn + — . \ 2 a = } \
> at | . r 2 j ¢t KW Mice Iam ak r Loh Tor > Ian >xN1i b+ )
=U ua wit aéa iP Ss @ i Sin0OSM) NRamMc oil > ~ He &4WU ii 2xnidit
Ja . 4 .
-“- = nee AF “hHlorin nes 7 mere mo reye / c
ot Sewer e tes We CHOLOTL ated r usSlna 7; Yrolysis as
15tmersa:-e. te c ‘Cer romot v¥,. phar ) ,n l1CAtac Of
ee ae aes | ‘ ‘ 2. -vectc rom p< ty ge, ms } Ld Cates Vk
vyoa.n? reo =i - se LK rOCArKAS uTeale«esi ebalelettl which
Veeaaa 4a2U9i.d & hw as a Yul WOT) Ife-yeVs Ve LC 6MAUUUCTS Wild Cl)
) 2 be
~ “> a - r- ro es ant — .S ~~ ww heen FO es ek > sch
424Ca win | -,ci(Ce of se GSLVUMETIC Ave -~OCarbdon £eSin.
} 2 mt = O iin — ee IMO eaten bh & Code
* = m @« ~ ~ ~ — ~ = Ve Gwe — meets he \ Ce & = ~ ame wD _ UC —
Tem + 2 as + 4 —" c- . oo . - +
Cc cope ue ~j,~+h- . <_< " ,s - c Ss - — ¢ > ri ¢
.) > 7 »t } ,< } = a | Y TY 4 4
baa at G2lOCarben ~ waar VNCVLi le lus = &é2 ] i) uUSed --Ull Lys
" — . “ " ¥ P - r , > a Arto —" ‘ dade >
< o . ei ‘ 5 he sa . : Pe NE T-orrved Mee ¢ + ¥ jInaAl
> te 38s =» &£eit vc CesCS sae od ad VUdl SNTTI SW? Go 414145 Lur tse Z 4 41G4 J
’ — 1 7A 1 an
i — — ‘ ve okt ak Pe we “a +a S & kh - £32 Khatisas =~} At
eo aii Cr we 8 J = aw ‘er 3 om JU ZT i ré wad uu 4Lii R&E VC wee?) = 2U
eee 1G™g _- on
~ WN 4 i
23.
as
— Ob RE -—' ee
\
‘7 ABSOLUTE
oN ANALYTICAL ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
o\'"/!'’°/! A} 1 A A N 1030-D North Crooks Roed
om \\ Vy US Clawson. Michigan 48017
JYOLABORATORY 313-435-5100
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
LAB I.D-# 90/01023/105
page 18
6.0 BARIUM SULFONATES
6.1 Our laboratory testing indicate that barium was found in an Inmont
=
formuiation nm some wax scapings found in the field.
i
and
6.1.1 Barium sulfonate is composed of barium and sulfonate salts. For
barium sulfonate to be present both barium and sulfur elements must be
detected. Cur orevious tests indicate the presence of barium, a more
recent test indicates that sulfur is present in the Inmont sample 998-
1128.
6.1.2 Rarium sulfonate is commonly regarded as a surfactant
(enclosure
sn?
wa
Sulfonates listed on MSDSs
for GM formulation
icium sulfonate, lead sulfonate and calcium
lignosultcnate.
4.9 CHLORINATED RUSBER
7.. Our labcrator. testing indicates that chlorinated rubber with a
combined chlorine content of at least 66 % was present in the BASF
$51200i formulaticn and in wax scapings from GM automobiles taken in
the field. This is based upon analysis (Byrd deposition exhibit #19)
verformed with
in our laboratory with a chlorinated rubber with a
least 6 % commercially available as
24.
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson, Michigan 48047
313-435-5100
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
30100 TELEGRAPH RO.,STE. 460
BINGHAM FARMS,MI 48025
ATTN: ALEX RHODES
RE: SUMMARY OF RECENT LABORATORY RESULTS WITH RESPECT TO PATENTS
#3,959,530 & 4,356,036.
A summary of our test results on coating materials Obtained from
inner surfaces of doors of recent model cars are tabulated on the
attached sheet. This report is an interim report on this subject.
We note that further tests are in progress on coatings from other
doors obtained in the field.
Absolute Analytical Laboratory,
Lit Enel RS
David W. Bvrd
Laboratory Director
aka
enclosures
a ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
AL! Clawson, Michigan 48017
LABORATORY 343-43$-5100
eee
page 2
ALEX RECDES,P.C.
LAB I.D.# 91/01023/221
1. Q ANALYTICAL SUMMARY *
Bat
1989 ELDORADO
PARAMETER FRONT RIGHT METHOD
SS SSS SSS SS SS LS TS TS TS TV TST TT ESSA SBS 2S8 2S SSS SS SSS SSE SSUES VESAS AS SS SS TV SBSH
ZINC : PRESENT ATOMIC ABSORBTION SPECTROPHOTOMETRY
CHLORINATED SOLVENT :PRESENT SH/GAS CHROMOTOGRAPHY/HECD&PID
SH=STATIC HEADSPACE
HECD&PID ARE DETECTOR TYPES
ish « See
26.
i ih i, ee, thle
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN QIVISION
NICOLAS KALIARDOS,
Plaintiff,
Civil Action
Vv. No. 88-CV-73729-DT
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION, Hon. Paul V. Gadola
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
COMPANY, NATIONAL STARCH &
CHEMICAL CORPORATION, and
BEAZER EAST, INC.,
Defendants.
PATRICIA MAREK, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
1. I am a Vice President of Daubert one of the
defendants in Civil Action 88 CV 73729 DT. |
2. I have a B.S. in Chemistry, a B.S. in Chemical
Engineering, and a M.S. in Analytical Chemistry.
3. I have been employed at Daubert since 1969, and
have held various positions in analytical chemistry, quality
control and research and development. During that time I Save
become fully familiar with all of Daubert's controls and proce-
dures for formulating and mixing its products, testing the raw
materials, sand controlling the composition and quality of the
products. I am the person most familiar with Daubert's records
and procedures by which it keeps data and information relative to
its formulations and products.
001552 27
EXHIBIT F
4. I am personally aware of all products which have
been sold to General Motors. ™
5. Daubert has only sold three wax-type rust-control
products to General Motors. They are identified as Nox-Rust x- |
151, Nox-Rust X-170 and Nox-Rust X-175.
6. Attachment 1 lists the ingredients of the Nox-Rust
X-151 product. This product is a wax-type product that contains
a small amount of an aluminum paste. Due to the addition of the
aluminum paste, the product has a silver color.
7. Attachment 2 lists the ingredients of Nox-Rust X-
170. This product is a clear wax-type product.
8. Attachment 3 lists the ingredients of Nox-Rust x- |
175. This product is a clear brush-on composition and sold as a
service item. The ingredients of the X-175 product are essential-
ly the same as the X-170 product, except that clay was added to
make the product thicker for brush-on application.
9. X-151 was sold to General Motors during the period §
1979 to 1986. It no longer is being made or sold. X-170 was sold
to General Motors from June, 1984 to the present, although the
sales have declined drastically and are now very small. X-175 was jf
supplied to General Motors for only a short period of time and in}
small quantities.
10. The three Nox-Rust products X-151, X-170 and X-175
were developed totally independently by Daubert. We did not §
receive any formulas or samples from General Motors or any other
supplier which related to or assisted us in the development of
these products. Daubert started its business in 1935 making anti-
“—
001554
i)
~@~
Pwr™
corrosion coatings, has developed extensive expertise in its
fifty-plus years as a -chemical coipany, and did not need any
~. —_
assistance in developing products t) meet the specifications and
needs of General Motors.
11. X-151 was prepared br Daubert over the period from
(975-78 to meet ¢eneral Motors Specification 998-1128. Nox-Rust
4-151 was approved by General Motars in 1978 and first sold to
taem in February 1979. The formula of X-151 remained basically
the same from 1979 to 1986. This is substantiated by the batch
Sheets which shov the ingredients cf each and every batch of Nox-
Rust X-151 which was made and sold by Daubert to GM. Copies of
these records have been supplied in their entirety to Kaliardos'
attorneys.
12. Nox-Rust X-170 was prepared by Daubert pursuant to
General Motors Specification 998-2150. It was first sold to
General Motors in 1984 and has renained basically the same ever
Since. This is substantiated by the batch sheets which show the
ingredients of each and every batch of Nox-Rust X-170 which was
made and sold by Daubert to GM. Copies of these records have been
supplied in their entirety to Kaliardos' attorneys.
13. As to Nox-Rust X-175, only two smali quantities
were prepared in the lab and no large quantities or "batches" were
ever made. Thus there are no batch sheets available for this
product. The ingredients used to make the xX-175 products are
included in Attachment 3. These documents have also been provided
to Kaliardos' attorneys.
29.
-0015s5
Baooxs & Kustman
1000 TOWN CENTER
-SECOND FLOOR
SOUTHFIELD, MI 48075
(313) 358-4400
14. Unde my supervision, various quality contr
procedures were followed whfeh assured that each batch ef X~-15
X-170 and X-175 contained the specific components of the requisi
formula and in the appropriate amounts. The batch operato
specifically followed the formulations and mixing instructions
indicated on the batch sheets. Quality control procedures w
utilized during the preparation of eich of the batches to ens:
that the final products met the requisite standards aad specifi
tions. The batch sheets recorded and depicted all of the ingre
ents, mixing steps, quality control testing and other proced
utilized for each batch.
15. Other than X-151 which contains aluminum paste
other wax-type composition containing aluminum or zinc paste
been sold to General Motors. xX-170 is the only current wax-
coating being sold to General Motors by Daubert.
16. None of the three Nox-Rust products sold to Gen
Motors, namely X-151, X-170 and X-175, contain the follo
materials specified in the claims of U.S. Patent No. 3,959,5
a) perchlorethylene; or
b) petroleum distillate having a boiling
ranging between 350° and 380° F;
c) nonionic surfactant;
d) nonylphenoxypoly (ethyleneoxy) ethanol;
e) N, N, N', N' = tetrakis (2-hydroxypropy]}
ethylenediamine. |
17. Also, none of these three Nox-Rust products sd
General Motors c--tain the following materials specified
i
fF
30.
001556
state .. on oe» &
a ae
LAW OFFICES
Brooxs & KuSHMAN
1000 TOWN CENTER
-SECOND FLOOR
SOUTHFIELD, MI 48075
(313) 358-4400
claims of U.S. Patent No. 4,356,036:
a) chlorinated rubber;
b) chlorinated rubber having a combined chlorine
content of at least 66%;
c) chlorinated solvent;
d) aromatic hydrocarbon solvent; and
e) mineral spirits
In addition, the X-170 and X-175 products do not contain an
aluminum or zinc paste, and the X-151 product does not contain
"neutral barium sulfonate" which are specified in the claims of
the 4,356,036 patent.
18. Based on my experience and knowledge, Daubert wae
never manufactured at any time or sold to any customer any wax~
type rust-control coating compositions containing any of the items
specified in Paragraphs 16 znd 17 above.
19. The X-151, X-170 and xX-175 records which are
identified above in Paragraphs 11-13 and which were provided to
Kaliardos' counsel prove that none of the items specified in
Paragraphs 16 and 17 were ever added to or included in the Daubert
Nox-Rust products. These records and batch sheets detail every
quantity and batch of Nox-Rust X-151, X-170 and X-175 products
which were ever made or sold by Daubert to GM.
20. I supplied quantities of the Nox-Rust X-151 and X-
170 products to our attorneys who in turn supplied them to Shrade}
Laboratories in Detroit, Michigan for analytical testings. It i:
my understanding that such analytical testing proved that neithe
a
0015 Q7 31.
==."
product contained any evidence of perchlorethylene or chlorinated
rubber. ~
21. I have reviewed the October, 1989 report by |
Absolute Analytical Laboratories which contained the results of
alleged analytical testing on a 1984 Buick Skyhawk door (Attach- |
ment 4). The coating product apparently found and tested on that
door could not have been a product supplied by Daubert. Not only
does that analysis show the presence of perchlorethylene and
chlorinated rubber which were not present in any of Daubert's
coatings, but it also indicates that no trace of aluminum was
found. I understand that GM has identified that 1984 Skyhawk door
as one being made at its assembly plant in Leeds, Missouri. I]
personally examined the records of Daubert and found that the only i
product supplied by Daubert to that Leeds plant through 1984 was
the Noex=Rus<t X-151 product which contains aluminum and has a
a
silver color.
Dated: November __, 1991 Re FN lig £2 JQ24 é k , .
Patricia Marek :
STATE OF ILLINOIS )
) Ss.
COUNTY OF DuPage )
Subscribed and sworn to before me this x / day of |
November, 1991. |
BK
aL bsset\ head ot. cwepen ot
LAW OFFICES
‘ooKs & KusHMAN “ OFFICIAL SEAL ”* No 5
Yer ry lic Hi
200 TOWN CENTER ‘ GERALDINE M. SERAPONAS Pagin
.ENTY-SECOND FLOOR KUTARY SUBLIC. STATE OF ILLINOIS f. ror County a aa ae
SOUTHFIELD, MI 48075 “Y CCMMISSION EXPIRES 11/7/94 My Commission Expires:_// ;
(313) 358-4400 ”
001558 32.
PWT ron CPA oH c nrevnmro Trem “AT TOmM
VINE LEU © TATES MsevrsMivl wLWUUAL
FAC TODA rom Tor ~t MTCLRLITCAA
SASTERN DISTRICT OF } HIGAN
CAIIPVwoS8 Mar Nees eer KY
©OOUTHERN Vivi WIN
AIT OANr Ae ABYTTrapnnge
MaUVVvuAyD RALLZARKUOS
. + . o> bet aa
> > ~~ + ~~ Vie ret *%
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION.
BASF CORPORATION. DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC. H.B. FUL
COMPANY, NATIONAL STARCH &
CHEMICAL CORPORATION, and BEA
EAST, INC., jointly and sever
Defendants.
AFFIDAVIT OF NICOLAS KALIARDOS
STATE OF MICHIGAN )
) Ss
COUNTY OF OAKLAND )
i was born in Detroit Michigan on December 26, 1926. In
1934, when I was eight years old, Y mother took me and my
brother to live in Greece because she was unable to ad
life in America. My father remained in America and sent money
to Greece to Support my mother, my brother and I. I remained in
Greece until 1945. When I was 15 years old, I joined a Group of
Greek partisans and fought with them in the mountains of
northern Greece.
After the war, I returned to the United States, served
in the u.s. Army, got married, bought a cleaning business,
Sa ~ 2 + o 7 : ~, + x \
reisec a family and nvented th
I have never attended college. My knowledge of
chemistry was acquired in Greek schools, from reading bcoks,
from product literature, from chemical company employees and
from experience. My familiarity with the Greek language helped
me because many chemical words are derived from Greek words.
My interest in coatings began when I purchased a 1968
Pontiac from Causley Pontiac, Detroit, Michigan. I noticed that
the car had a white substance on the black vinyl top. After
several unsuccessful attempts of the car dealer to remove the
white substance, I began to experiment with chemicals that I had
at my cleaning business for removing stains and waterproofing
garments. I purchased other chemicals and obtained free samples
from chemical companies.
After many experiments, I invented a product which
removed the white stain and improved the finish of the vinyl
top. I was very pleased that I was able to do something which a
General Motors dealer could not do. I thought that General
Motors would be interested in my product. Through a mutual
friend, I was introduced to a DuPont sales representative, Mr.
Charles King. General Motors was one of Mr. King's accounts for
paints and coatings.
I named my product Sinowax 6 inl. Mr. King took
samples of Sinowax 6 in 1 to the Fisher Body Division of General
Motors in 1971. Mr. King told me that Fisher Body would buy
Sinowax 6 in 1 if it would protect bare steel against
corrosion. Fisher Body supplied Mr. King with bare steel test
34.
PDMS? AI ON RE CS AERTS
EPI
panels which I coated and Fisher Bocy tested for corrosion.
In the beginning Fisher Body wanted a coating which
would withstand 24 hours of salt spray. Later they wanted more
resistance to salt spray and added other requirements. Fisher
Body needed a coating which would protect the bottom of vehicle
doors against corrosion. From 1971 through 1981 I continued to
experiment and to supply different formulations to Fisher Body.
I worked 7 days a week and long hours each day on the Fisher
Body anti-corrosion requirements. This work involved thousands
of hours of my time. During my experiments, I changed the
ingredients in the formulas and the amounts of the ingredients.
I constructed a salt spray fixture and.ran corrosion tests.
From about 1972 to 1981 I continuously brought samples
to the Fisher Body Corrosion Laboratory. I was never
compensated for the samples nor were any unused samples returned
to me. During some months I delivered several samples to the
Fisher Body Lab. I also visited the Lab frequently and
discussed the results of the tests with the Corrosion Lab
engineers. The engineers always commented favorably on the test
results but refused to allow me to see or have copies of the
reports. Tests of my coating at outside laboratories also
proved that the coating met the General Motors'corresion
requirements.
On May 25, 1976 I was granted U.S. Patent No. 3,959,530
('530 Patent). The patent covers an anti-corrosion coating
containing wax, a chlorinated solvent, mineral spirits, a
surfactant and a chelating agent.
Wax is used because it is waterproof and remains pliable
in cold and hot weather. I first used wax because it was
available at my cleaning plant for waterproofing garments. I
noticed that when I waterproofed garments, the wax coated the
metal buttons of the garments and improved their appearance.
The chlorinated solvent prevents the coating from
separating and sagging. I discovered this when I was
experimenting with the bare metal test panels which General
Motors gave me to coat. I noticed that the panels were covered
with a thin film of oil. I discovered that when I added
perchloroethylene to my test samples, the perchlorethylene
helped the wax to adhere to the surface. I also discovered that
the perchlorethylene evaporated very quickly. This prevented
the coating from sagging. I found out that perchloroethylene
was a very important ingredient for meeting the General Motors
corrosion requirements.
The corrosion of General Motors' doors during the 1970's
was a unique corrosion problem. The doors were constructed of
an outer steel panel joined to a steel inner panel. The General
Motors engineers called the joint which extended around a door a
hem flange. The hem flange consisted of a turned up flange on
the outer panel which extended around the inner panel. At the
bottom of the door there was a gap where the outer panel and
inner panel were joined together by the hem flange. The gap
+ otitis, ta
extended across the entire bottom of the door. At the bottom
‘ Cc
rt
door there were small drain holes. However, the drain holes
were above the hem flange and gap.
Because it was not possible to locate the drain holes
it was not possible to remove all of the oil from
the bare inner surfaces at the bottom of the door. Some of the
oil collected in the gap and remained on the bare steel
surfaces. Another condition which caused the corrosion problem
was that a very thin coating was required because it had to be
sprayed inside of the doors. Also, the coating needed to spread
over the entire surface of the metal. Thin coatings tended to
sag. Thick coatings were difficult to apply and had
unacceptable drying times.
Chlorinated solvents (e.g. perchloroethylene) are very
powerful solvents for dissolving oil. They also evaporate very
guickly. There are no other solvents which I am aware of which
are more effective in penetrating oil and evaporate more quickly
than the chlorinated solvents. I discovered that when a
chlorinated solvent was added to the coating, it made a major
improvement. It quickly penetrated the oil on the bare steel at
the bottom of the doors and evaporated quickly. This caused the
coating to immediately contact the surface of the bare metal and
to set up without sagging. Adherence of the coating was
significantly improved.
The surfactant (Igepal) is used in the coating because
it improves its spreadibility. It is important to cover ail of
37.
the bare metal. Also, the improved spreadability helps a worker
to properly apply the coating because it is Gifficult to see the
entire inside surface of a door when the coating is sprayed into
the door.
The chelating agent (Quadrol) further improves the
adherence of the coating to the bare metal. I discovered .this
when I was developing the coating. I also found that it is
effective for preventing materials, and in particular aluminum
and zinc, from settling in the coating before it is applied to
the doors.
The mineral spirits act as a carrier for the other
materials. They are much lower in cost than the
perchloroethylene. They are used to dissolve the wax when the
the wax is heated. The method of preparing the coating is
disclosed in my patent.
From 1974 through 1979 I experimented with a welded zinc
coating which I was informed General Motors needed. A number of
samples were prepared and tested at the Fisher Body Corrosion
Lab. This work did not result in a commercially successful
coating. However, some of the results were incorporated into
the '036 Patent.
The ‘036 Patent covers an anti-corrosion coating
containing a wax, an aluminum or zinc paste, a chlorinated
solvent, barium sulfonate, an aromatic hydrocarbon resin,
chlorinated rubber, an aromatic hydrocarbon solvent and mineral
spirits.
j
|
|
|
Corrosion Lab, called me on the telephone and reque
Sted a Sample
of my wax coating for atest. mr. Latsko told me the testing
WaS to establish that my coating was Suitable for the
vehicle doors. He also told me that he knew that my prod:
W
beg
@)
c
a
oF
oO
te)
re)
oO
le to meet their requirements. In February, 19709
Daniel Hogan, a Fisher Body test engineer, told me that my
coating was the only coating that Passed all the Corrosion
tests. Afterwards, I continued to experiment and improve the
coatings. In May of 1980, I haa @ heart attack and was
hospitalized. In August, 1980,
two gallons of my coating for « final test to John Bubak, a
Fisher Body Purchasing agent. In October, 1980, Mr. Bubak
informed me that my coating didn't Pass their tests. Mr. Bubak
also informed me that I would not have receiv
Order even if
manufacturer.
The coating which is described and Claimed in the "036
Patent was developed to meet corrosion requirements, given to me
by Fisher Body Corrosion engineers.
The aluminum Paste was added to the coating in late 1978
to meet the requirement of General Moters Material Specification
8 of a coating containing aluminum. The barium Sulfonate
nm protection. The
Wax and Chlorinated Solvent are used for the reasons Previously
Given. The Chlorinated rubber has a high resistance to acids
33,
and alkalies. It is needed to pass the General Motors car
detergent solution test in which a coated test sample is
immersed in a strong alkaline solution. The chlorinated rubber
also improves the resistance to salt spray. The aromatic
hydrocarbon solvent is used to dissolve the resin and is present
in the aluminum paste; the mineral spirits acts as a carrier.
The many tests which I have conducted convince me that
all of these ingredients are needed in a coating applied to bare
steel surfaces, if the coating is to meet General Motor's
corrosion tests.
-
“Nicolas Kaliardos ~
-
caer ler '!
“ : e . ( }
i’ fe af ee ae LY
Subscribed and sworn to before me Pe ila
this, 19th Gay of December, 1991
, _-—<
= ta ee
Mabey t faa, SI I a vs
CARP MLA MUM LANE
Citas leantty, A
wT .- -<(BLk asc 17, 1993
TY Ait,
KYy Con
nT “Tr CTATIS a aaa coal aA; Tt
UNITED STATES DYSTRICT COUR
ere ? nraom T nn Ty T “a ’
EASTERN DISTRICT F MICHIGAN
enor mrs cT
SOUTHERN DIVISION
tT ATraAcC ATTARNOCG
NICOLAS KALIARVUS
Plaintiff, Civil Action
OO ial al ' Q2 may 72790 7
Case No. 88-CV-/5/29-U4
Hon. Paul V. Gadola
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION,
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
COMPANY, NATIONAL STARCH &
CHEMICAL CORPORATION, and BEAZER
EAST, INC., jointly and severally,
Defendants.
AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID W. BYRD
STATE OF MICHIGAN )
) $s:
COUNTY OF OAKLAND )
I am the Laboratory Director of the Absolute Analytical
Laboratory, Inc. at 1030-D North Crooks Road, Clawson,
Michigan. The Absolute Analytical Laboratory is a chemical
laboratory which specializes in the analyses of inorganic and
organic materials. I have Bachelors and Masters degrees in the
Biological Sciences and a Masters Degree in Chemical
Engineering. My education and experience are summarized in 4
Resume which is attached and marked Exhibit "A".
Samples of wax anti-corrosion coatings were taken from
the interiors of 1984 Buick Skyhawk and 1989 Cadillac Eldorado
doors and analyzed at the Absolute Analytical Laboratory. I am
intimately familiar with the procedures and results of the
analyses because I have personallYconducted the analyses.
The results of the analyses are attached and marked
“Attachment B” (1984 Skyhawk) and “Attachment C” (1989
Eldorado). A sample of the 1989 Eldorado coating was forwarded
to Charles Evans and Associates, Redwood City, California for
further analysis. Charles Evans and Associates is a well Known
analytical laboratory which specializes in materials
characterization. A summary of the Charles Evans lab analysis
is attached and marked “Exhibit "“D".
I am familar with U.S. Patent No. 3,959,530 and U.S.
Patent No. 4,356,036, having reviewed the patents, including
their claims. I have also reviewed Daubert Industries, Inc.
documents relating to the compositions of Daubert wax-type
anti-corrosion coatings Nox Rust X-15l1 and Nox Rust X-170. The
documents disclose that Nox Rust X-15l1 corresponds to General
Motors material specification 998-1228 and that Nox Rust X-170
corresponds to General Motors material specification 998-2150.
Claim 1 of U.S. Patent No. 3,959,530 defines a wax
coating containing a wax residue such as paraffin and
microcrystalline wax; perchloroethylene; a petroleum distillate |
having a boiling point ranging between 350° and 380°F, a |
nonionic surfactant such as nonylphenoxypoly(ethyleneoxy )ethanol
and a small amount of [N,N,N'‘',N‘'-tetrakis(2-hydroxypropyl) -
ethylenediamine].
After reviewing the results of the laboratory analysis
of the 1984 Skyhawk coating and the Daubert documents, I am of
u@)
t
b
4
¢
tu
ct
18)
a
2)
J
oO
rth
ct
es
@
rw
|
OQ
a
F
be
@
be
ct
7)
O
rt
|
b
m@
-
-
(
rt
Cc
—
Patent No. 4,356,036 is present in Daubert Nox Rust X-15] This
Spinion is based on the following. Daubert has admitted in its
Gocuments tnat Nox Rust X-151 contains microcrystalline we. an
aromatic hycrocarbon resin having a softening point, R and 8 £
pe ar 140° c barium sulfonate; an aromatic hydrocarbor
solvent; a hydrocarbon solvent, and mineral spirits. My
analysis of the 1984 Buick Skyhawk coating disclosed the
presence of zinc; and chlorinated rubber having a combined
chlorine content of at least 66% (i.e. Parlon).
After reviewing the results of the laboratory analyses
of the 1989 Cadillac Eldorado coating at my laboratory and at
the Charles Evans laboratary and the Daubert documents, I am of
the opinion that each of the ingredients or their equivalents of
U.S. Patent No. 3,959,530 is present in Daubert Nox Rust X-170.
This opinion is based on the following. Daubert has admitted in
its documents that Nox Rust X-170 contains wax and a petroleum
Gistillate having a boiling point ranging between 350° and
380°F. My analysis of the Eldorado coating disclosed the
presence of a4 surfactant in the 1989 Eldorado coating, i.e. a
dispersent equivalent in action and function to a surfactant
such as nonylphenoxypoly(ethyleneoxy)ethanol. My analysis of
the Eldorado coating also disclosed the presence of a methlyene
Orinate solvent equivalent in action and function
to perchloroethylene. The Charles Evans analysis disclosed the
avid W.
D
o
-~Infringement
Non
of
Summary
for
44.
uw)
wT ei)
‘ G - .
re r ” }
H ~ + CG
G a i CG ey
4) ) Q O w wv >
o~4 red Ww) 4) |
O .e) au Wd r4 vu O
U ,) ' e O J W) WV) 44
U UO G d WY Pt O
Yo 3p c we ge 7
4@) v @ OQ A) vy +)
' @ hi . o OU G ” Fe
@ ' 8) oO a) j
> Cc 1) UO - r ha , O
{ _ = @ G 10] 10) O O mt by
J a C 8) 4 =, 4) 3) N4 a4 4 :
0 ti) w di €. 0)
Ay . ; Pes 5 . . ri) Ss O )
> “er pee eee g¢ & 2 2 Ss
, p w 0 Y S Ww G O 14 z .e {J
* i) iw © op) G hi wy an
” ne wu wv Hi wv i 16) 4
<f re) ie by 4) a 4 hy co Q) ve)
- a er rs, > o Oo ” % 4
” Vv QO I GC G ne) oO” ra O }
> E } U 0 i] wv 2, G
> Se 3 oe Cc ha a ) v s J
| x oF Y} ba ( 4? vu (. Q) °3
a. O w o Y ”w Oo v v a
‘ on Ww 2 . 2 2. “a £
mt . O et rf , ae O ey 4 )
™ om | 08) a | J A, ra) i? Eee 4
hl A > 4 £ p yl v Ww p
No 6 pa 4) @ & rf ) Q) y¥ 00) J)
mW ny Fs ov ea J O) >1 et
uj @ ie a: iy - OM cl + 2
ag > O G4 rf ro t i) 08) v) A. 8)
0) | E4 Oo Gi O Q @ ne @ 8)
um W 48) O hi O ot se) { rf {
° os “ ee) 4 + ae a C =
ov U | ad - O ? bi > oO + by u) Hi U" fc!
c | n WY) 4? a O C OV ha c; w
0 -- Do eo @. ol ao Yo i ee a
A ’ j ° ~—a O Ww U rf VY) ey i? ba by
Ay, os 2 | iT ) E W g au j v
% Hi rd 4 pre c by O . ~ u) ( , MS
O - sH ev 6 | — ie) 3 { v 5 9 ba a U
Jo. *@ « & 10) et W”) Q — ‘ YU O _ uv)
OUZM™ «i UD ©) Vv wv Vv hi 4) () * 0) ¢
MH 2%OO O ¢ HH > wv Y ri Ae) v ut af v x +?
Mm i HH AY Wy M9 vu hy fy U (VJ ps ha ? 3 ws U
O « b+ Wd | {) KG 4) ' oF O Ee ha rt
fem -€O s wv h4 . Vv 'F ne) . 2 @) {
OONZO+ A 3 M4 ee. Poe. A ee, A _.
2, Ay ti U | It, 0 (J > a » OU )
MH «3 Z | fis © < O . () bi of
J O a ps « Hi O rt O 3) A ) 1D
CUH ZU | mee 1 J rf 4 )
m VikH .s ' i) f+ wu $i ¢; . | x \
. i) ly 2D A, Pe “4 ical Zz © ba 118) w ‘ OF 1) W)
ZNAZWMN ci ae i» Oo 4) }) 6) U = by rf +
We ZAonrte = oO » Oo” O: Ss bi Cs oO Y iS @)
OmrHOO WW Ww) ) 0) rt O O O 4 “0 O, < ()
re
@
{
2)
iS conducted by Dr. James Johnson, our most
som 4 4 ta at tao+
n2iGiss¥ ~UEei.locieG Cnemise
T < : = S| Fm tee ; -
‘ i em intimately familar with the
memthn4a cé re ~ _
2Sting and have personally reviewed the test
Sample was first
ograpny using a heated head
Space and an electron capture
:
detector THis test identified perchloroethylene in the 3
a
mm 7 Th + a ae ~ -~ i and 4 ,
Samy e semple was then analyzed using GC/MS with selected $
4
Sn _ all ae ie aalin A an ad e +o — - _ o a al
ion monitoring (SiM) This is a very sophisticated and specific
> Far i Aenes He-4 a 3 /
test tor identifying chemical compounds. The GC/MS-SIM test
analysis positively con
firmed the presence of
amount of perchloroethylene in the sample could not
na 5 Tolle | GS, wate> or other
materials.
y,
¥ “Br
. Paul S. ‘Epstein
n to before me |
1 caov-otDecember, 1991
a
:
fh
f
ALEX RHODES
Notory Public, Ockions Crain. of
My Commemesmon Expucsa A001 26. 1994
_-“A
ACt.23¢ in ~aesntetew Coun
16.
ee OR
ANANICAL
MAMMA
4030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson. Michigan 48017
Cc
LABORATORY
313-435-5100
DECEMBER 30,1991
ALEX RHODES,?.C
30100 TELEGRAPH RD.,STE. 460
BINGHAM FARMS,MI 48025
ATTN:ALEX RHODES
RE: ELECTRON SPECTROSCOPY FOR CHEMICAL ANALYSIS (ESCA) LABORATORY
RESULTS WITH RESPECT TO PATENTS #3,959,530 & 4,356,036. 1989 ELDORADO
FRONT PASSENGER DOOR.
Coating materials obtained from the bottom inner surfaces of a
1989 Eldorado door were sent to Charies Evans and Associates (Redwood,
Ca) to determine the presence of zinc, organohalides, and chelating
agents. The followina is a summary and discussion of the test results
from the ESCA analysis. The ESCA results indicate that zinc,
chlorinated organic, sulfur oxide(s), and chealating functional groups
were found to be vresent in the referenced coating.
Zinc was detected using ESCA at approximately 3.5 %. The Eldorado
coating was found to contain zinc in our laboratory using Atomic
Absorption Spectropnotometry (reports 91.01022.221 and 91.01023.228)
The presence of ligands which are the functional groups of
rind sce agents were found. Several ligands were detected including
carbonyl, carboxylate, amines and hydroxvl functional groups (see
exhihis 106a ). All of the functional groups detected are capable of
forming a complex or coordination compound by sharing electron
density
with with metal ions.
The test cata also indicates the presence of organocnlorine
comvounds. With respect to the patents, the ores nee of chlorinated
solvents and chlorinated volymers would be indicated by the vresence
of erganochlorine compounds. This is consistent with the chlorinated
solvent methviene chloride which was found in the Eldorado coating
(report 91.01023.228). The presence of other organochlorine compounds
such as chlorinated rubbers is indicated hy the elevated levels of
organochlorine compounds (~ 0.3 %) relative to the trace levels of
methvlene chloride (< Q.q0001 @).
ABSOLUTE |
ANALYTICAL Si NAS
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson, Michigan 48017
LABORATORY 313-435-5100
page 2
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
LAB I.9.#& 91/01023/229
ESCA analvsis also detected the presence cf sulfur oxides.
ulfur oxides would be consistent with the presence of sulfonate
ompounds.
A tabular summary of data taken together from ESCA analysis
erformed by Charles Evans and Associates and our laboratory are
ummarized on page three of this report. We note that much of the data
btained here is not consistent with the MSDS which we have available
or these products.
Absolute Analvtical Laboratory,
U
Dav W.
By ks Director
48.
CAL
1030-6 North Crooks Roag
me Clawson, Michigan 48017
~itble oe ye TORY 3
TABLE OF ANALYTICAL RESUL °S
989 ELDORADO RIGHT PASSENCRp DOOR
PARAMET PED METHOD
t
Conductivisy Detecto+
RPACTANTS
LIGAND FENCTIONALIT IPS
‘CHELATING FUNCTIONS)
hte
ELF (IQ OXIDIZED FORM
49,
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
NICOLAS KALIARDOS,
Plaintiff, Civil Action
Case No. 88-CV-73729-DT
vs.
HON. Paul V. Gadola
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION,
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
COMPANY, NATIONAL STARCH &
CHEMICAL CORPORATION, and BEAZER
EAST, INC., jointly and severally,
Defendants.
AFFIDAVIT OF DARYL P. STRANDBERGH
STATE OF MICHIGAN )
) SS
COUNTY OF OAKLAND )
I am the Manager of Organic Laboratory Services, Clayton
Environmental Consultants, Inc., Novi, Michigan. Clayton
Environmental Consultants, Inc. provides analytical chemistry
services relating to industrial hygiene and the environment. I
have Bachelor in Chemistry and MBA Degrees from the University
of Michigan, Dearborn.
In January, 1950, the Clayton Novi laboratory analysed a
Sample of General Motors 998-1128 coating and a sample from a
1984 Oldsmobile Cierra. Testing at the Novi laboratory did not
reveal the presence of tetrachloroethene (also known as
tetrachloroethylene).
001185
TAB N"
el
The remainder of the 998-1128 sample was sent to our
Windsor, Canada laboratory for further analysis (Note: there was
insufficient Sample Cierra for re-analysis). Testing at the
Windsor laboratory was conducted by Dr. Paul S. Epstein and
Dr. James Johnson. Analysis of Sample 998-1128 was performed at
the Windsor laboratory by GC/MS using selected ion monitoring
(SIM). The GC/MS-SIM employed parameters specific for
tetrachloroethene. This procedure provided greater sensitivity
for tetrachloroethene. The presence of tetrachloroethene in the
998-1128 sample was positively confirmed at the Windsor
laboratory using GC/MS and the static headspace technique. I do
not disagree with the results of the Windsor laboratory.
The analysis of mixtures may require the application of
alternate test methods to determine whether an ingredient is
present in a mixture. It is not uncommon for a test method to
be inadequate for detecting 4 specific ingredient because of
limitations of the test method.
A copy of the Clayton Environmental laboratory final
report is attached. f~
eee A ~
a eee ~Strandbefgh
4
Subscribed and sworn to before me
thi as ham cember, 1991
Oe ot: + 4
aoe pute, one +04
901186
51.
Clayton Environmental Consultants, Inc.
2245 Roethel Drive « Novi, Michigan 48050 © (313) 444-1770
April 5, 1990
Mr. Alex Rhodes, Esa.
24700 Northwestern Highway
Suite 412
Soutnfieid, Ml 48075
Clayton Project No. 62922-17
Dear Mr. Rhodes:
The following is our report for Samples 998-1128 and Cierra
(VIN 1C3AJ19E&200406799) Wax Scraping, received on January 2. 1990, for
Qualitative analysis. The purpose of this analysis was to determine the presence of
tetrachioroethene and volatile aromatic hydrocarbons in both samples.
The analysis was performed by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS)
using dynamic headspace analysis and general scanning techniques. A portion of
sample was weighed and placed in a glass vessel. The vessel was sealed and heated to
90 °C. Helium was passed through the glass vessel at 60 cubic centimeters/minute
for 14 minutes. The effluent was collected by cryogenic focusing using liquid
nitrogen (-150 °C) to trap the purgeable compounds. After purging, the cryogenic
trap was rapidly heated with a helium flow to transfer the collected organics into a
GC/MS ior anatysis. Using the dynamic headspace technique, aromatic compounds
were detected in both samples. Tetrachloroethene was not detected. The results are
provided in the attached table.
Based on our discussions of the data generated from the GC/MS analysis of Samples
998-1128 and Cierra, Sampie 998-1128 was sent to our Windsor laboratory for
Static headspace analysis of tetrachloroethene by gas chromatography using an
electron capture detector (GC/ECD). The GC/ECOD analysis was performed to
improve analytical sensitivity for tetrachloroethene. Insufficient sample remained
to reanatyze Sample Cierra. A 0.80-gram portion of Sample 998-1128 was placed
in 40-cc bottle and sealed with a Tefion liner. The bottle was heated to 80 °C for 30
minutes and a portion of the headspace was injected onto the GC/ECD for analysis.
Tetrachioroethene was detected based on the static headspace GC/ECD analysis. The
results are provided in the attached table.
Confirmation of tetrachioroethene in Sample 998-1128 was performed by GC/MS
using selected lon monitoring (SIM). The GC/MS-SIM technique employed
parameters specific for tetrachiorcethene, which provided greater sensitivity for
tetractioroethene. Tetrachioroethene was positively confirmed using GC/MS and the
static headspace technique.
We appreciate the opportunity to be of assistance to you. If you Nave any questions.
please call me at (313) 344-2650.
incgrely,
S
Daryl 2. (Pie
Director, Organic Laboratory Services
OPS/
Atachmen 001187
Cee 6 te . --. -
Analytical Results
for
Mr. Alex Rhodes, Esq.
Clayton Project No. 62922-17
Dynamic Headspace Static Headspace”
GC/MS GC/MS GC/ECD GC/MS (SI
Sample Sample Sample Sample
998-1128 __clera__ 998-1128 998-1128
Ethy! benzene Sulfur dioxide Tetrachicroethene Tetrachloroett
Toluene Acetaidenyoe
Xylenes Heptanal
Methy! cyclohexane Benzaidettyde
Dimethyl cyciohexanes Trimethy! benzene
Decane Octanal
Undecane 1-Pheny! ethanone
Additional unknown hydrocarbons Nonanal
Dodecanese
Oecanal
"Analyses specific for tetrachioroethene onty.
DISTRICT COURT
ICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
VitLUu - KALI WU.
Plaintiff, Civil Action
Case No. 88-CV-73729-DT
Hon. Paul V. Gadola
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATI
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
prciedig sis , NATIONAL STARCH &
HEMICAL CORPORATION, and BEAZER
nae INC., jointly and severally,
‘
Defendants
AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID W. BYRD
STATE OF MICHIGAN
“”
“
COUNTY OF OAKLAND )
David W. Byrd, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
1. That I have an M.S. degree in Biological Science,
Wayne State University, post graduate credits in chemistry, and
am a member in good standing of The American Chemical Society,
ANACHEM anc the Chromatography Society.
2 That I am the owner of Absolute Analytical
“Laboratory, 1030-D Crooks Road, Clawson, Michigan, which is in
tne business of tr
ace organic and inorganic chemical analyses of
> Mm}
3. That from December, 1987 to the present,
—
nduccted laboratory analyses at the Absolute Analytical
COC119 ie
Laboratory of samples of a BASF anti-corrosi<
on coating and
scrapings of this coating taken from General Motors’ vehicles
4 That I reviewed BASF and General Motors documents,
technica
1ical literature and deposition testimonies of BASF and
General Motors employees relating to the B
»
SF $51Z001 coating.
S. That I also reviewed U.S. Patents Nos. 3,959,530
and 4,356,036, including the specifications and claims.
6. That after reviewing the above information, it is
my opinion that the BASF anti-corrosion coating contains all of
the ingredients or well known equivalents of the ingredients
specified in claim 1 of U.S. Patent No. 3,959,530 and claim 1
y,
+
@)
rh
U.S. Patent No. 4,356,036.
Further deponent sayeth not.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 2nd day of January, 1992
ea
_ / ( id y ;
4 Mh rand CO VNA Pg m& iNi
TL TRONG BCL ARE
—_ vo SRelams *: eS “Aearty, Ma
”.
Sree. METS bey IF see
COCLA
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
NICOLAS KALIARDOS,
Plaintiff, Civil Action
Case No. 88-CV-73729-DT
vs.
Hon. Paul V. Gadola
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION,
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
COMPANY, NATIONAL STARCH &
CHEMICAL CORPORATION, and BEAZER
EAST, INC., jointly and severally,
Defendants.
| AFFIDAVIT OF DAVID W. BYRD
STATE OF MICHIGAN )
) SS;
COUNTY OF OAKLAND )
I am the Laboratory Director of the Absolute Analytical i
Laboratory, Inc. at 1030-D North Crooks Road, Clawson, :
Michigan. The Absolute Analytical Laboratory is a chemical
laboratory which specializes in the analyses of inorganic and
organic materials. I have Bachelor and Master degrees in the
a EE
Biological Sciences. My education and experience are summarized
in a Resume which is attached and marked Byrd Exhibit "A".
A sample of General Motors 998-2150 wax type
anti-corrosion coating was taken from a 1989 Cadillac Eldorado
at the Absolute Analytical Laboratory and analyzed to identify
whether certain ingredients were in the coating. A portion of
56.
the door with the coating in place was removed at our laboratory
and sent to Charles Evans and Associates, Inc. laboratory in
Redwood City, California, which specializes in material
characterization.
Our analysis detected the presence of wax, zinc,
methylene chloride, and chlorinated organic compounds. zinc was
detected using Flame Atomic Absorption Spectrophotrometry;
methylene chloride was detected using Static Headspace Gas
Chromatography with an Electrolytic Conductivity Detector;
surfactants were detected using Methylene Blue Active
Substances. A summary of our test results is attached and
marked Byrd Exhibit “B”.
The sample which was forwarded to Charles Evans and
Associates was analyzed using the method of Electron
Spectroscopy for Chemical Analysis (ESCA). The Charles Evans
laboratory detected zinc, ligands (including carbony!,
carboxalate, amines and hydroxyl functional groups), and
organochloride compounds. These results are consistent with the
presence of a chelating agent, chlorinated compounds and zinc in
the sample.
I have reviewed H.B. Fuller Material Safety Data
Sheets, a production batch card, a Code Sheet, and supplier
information of the ingredients for their wax-type anti-corrosion
coating WC-2291 which corresponds to General Motors
anti-corrosion coating 998-2150. The H.B. Fuller documents do
not disclose all of the ingredients of the coating.
I have also reviewed U.S. Patent Nos. 3,959,530 and
U.S. 4,356,036, including the claims. Claim 1 of U.S. Patent
No. 3,959,530 defines a wax coating comprising a wax residue
such as paraffin and microcrystalline wax; perchloroethylene; a
petroleum distillate having a boiling point ranging between
350° and 380°F, a nonionic surfactant such as
nonylphenoxypoly (ethyleneoxy)ethanol and a small amount of
(N,N,N',N'-tetrakis(2-hydroxypropv1 ) -ethylenediamine].
Claim 1 of U.S. Patent No. 4,356,036 defines a wax
coating comprising a mixture of aluminum paste or zinc paste
containing aluminum or zinc flakes and a solvent,
microcrystalline wax, aromatic hydrocarbon resin having a
softening point, R and B, of 70" 6. - 166° C., chlorinated
rubber having a combined chlorine content of at least 66%,
neutral barium sulfonate, a chlorinated solvent, an aromatic
hydrocarbon solvent and mineral spirits.
After reviewing the results of the laboratory analyses
of the 1989 Cadillac Eldorado coating at my laboratory and at
the Charles Evans laboratory and the H.B. Fuller documents, I am
of the opinion that each of the ingredients or their equivalents
of U.S. Patent No. 3,959,530 is present in H.B. Fuller
anti-corrosion coating WC-2291. H.B. Fuller has admitted in its
documents that its coating contains wax and a petroleum
Gistillate having a boiling point ranging between 350° and
380°F.
My analysis of the Eldorado coating disclosed the
presence of a surfactant in the 1989 Eldorado coating, i.e. a
dispersent equivalent in ection and function to a surfactant
such as nonylphenoxypoly(ethyleneoxy)ethanol; methlyene
chloride, and a chlorinated solvent equivalent in action and
function to perchloroethylene. The Charles Evans analysis
disclosed the presence of chelating agents, i.e. substances
equivalent in action and function to (N,N,N',N' -tetrakis
(2-hydroxypropyl )ethylenediamine].
Although many of the ingredients of claim 1 of U.S.
Patent No. 4,356,036 were identified, sufficient information is
not available to form an opinion of whether H.B. Fuller WC-2291
infringes claim l’‘of U.S. Patent No. 4,356,036.
/ david W. Byrd
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 2nd day of January, 1992
‘fir f)
Motone Fate. Latour Conenty, Mi
Ray DOTA. PRE SA. 17, 1998
Q
X ABSOLUTE
\ ANALYTICAL ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
\ Ciawson. Michigan 48017
LABORATORY 313-435-5100
JULY 14,1992
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
30100 TELEGRAPH RD.,STE. 460
BINGHAM FARMS,MI 48025
RE:
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :H.B. FULLER FORMULATION WC-2291 & WC-2291-P
ANALYSIS REQUESTED :AROMATIC AND CHLORINATED CMPDS.
HHS/GC-PID-ELCD
PURCHASE ORDER : VERBAL
LABORATORY # :92.01023.266
Samples of the referenced H.B.Fuller products were analysed for
the presence of aromatic hydrocarbons and volatile chlorinated
solvents. Our test results are tabulated on the attached pages.
If you have questions or are in need of additional service please
feel free to contact us at your earliest convenience. )
Absolute Analytical Laboratory,
David W. Byr
Laboratory Pirector
AR1/92
60.
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson, Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
CLIENT :ALEX RHODES,P.C
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :H.B. FULLER FORMULATION WC-2291 & WC-229]-
P
ANALYSIS REQUESTED : AROMATIC AND CHLORINATED CMPDS.
HHS/GC-PID-ELCD
LABORATORY # :92.01023.266
1.0 SAMPLE PREPARATION
1.1 SAMPLE DESCRIPTION TABLE
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION
1 QUART CONTAINER MARKED "WC-2291"
1 QUART CONTAINER MARKED “WC-229]-p"
1.1.2 The wax coating samples (ca. 1 gram) were placed into 40 ml
vials with a silicone-teflon septa for head space sampling. The
containerized samples were incubated at 90 C for approximately one
hour. Desorbed volatiles were obtained by puncturing the container
and obtaining a sample of the headspace volume which was subsequently
injected into the gas chromatograph. The Operational conditions of the
gas chromatograph were:
T(inject) : COC C T(column) : program T(detect): 200 C
Tlinitial): 40 C T(rate) : E« T( final) s 350 ¢
T(hold) : 5 MIN Flow mlsec-@C:8.0
Detector 1: PID Detector 2: HECD
Column: 530 um x 30 m. 3.0 um DB624.
The resulting chromatograms were compared to standards of aromatic
hydrocarbons and chlorinated hydrocarbons for identification purposes.
2.0 TEST RESULTS
2.1 TABULATED DATA FOR AROMATIC HYDROCARBONS
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION AROMATIC COMPOUNDS COMMENTS
WC-229] DETECTED Benzene, toluene,
eae CAS Rae ehts Ras ves ae
ethylbenzene, xyienes
ir? > ? HST TET : ‘ lue >
WC-2291-P DETECTEI Benzene, toluene,
} » 7 : 7D ~ Pex lonac
ethylbenzene, xylenes
6l.
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson, Michigan 48017
313-435-5100
page 3
CLIENT :ALEX RHODES,P.C.
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :H.B. FULLER FORMULATION WC-2291 & WC-2291-
P
ANALYSIS REQUESTED : AROMATIC AND CHLORINATED CMPDS.
HHS/GC-PID-ELCD
LABORATORY # 792.01023.266
2.2 TABULATED DATA FOR CHLORINATED HYDROCARBONS
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION CHLORINATED COMPOUNDS COMMENTS
wWC-2291 DETECTED 1,l-dichloroethene
WC-2291-P DETECTED 1,l-dichloroethene
3.0 DISCUSSION
3.1 Our tests show that aromatic hydrocarbons such as benzene,
toluene, ethylbenzene and xylenes are found in both the Fuller
formulation designated “WC-2291" and “WC-2291-P". Additionally, our
test show that 1,1l1-dichloroethene, a volatile chlorinated hydrocarbon,
are present in the reference wax coating materials.
62.
A A | A ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
Lar Wa
1030-D North Crooks Road
Clawsen, Michigan 48047 |
LABORATORY 313-435-5109
ee
ALEX. RHODES,P.G..
30100 TELEGRAPH RD.,STE. 460
BINGHAM FARMS,Mi 48025
ATTN: ALEX RHODES
ae
RE:
PROJECT :KALIARDOS v. GENERAL MOTORS et al.
ANALYSIS REQUESTED . :COMMENTS ON MOTION é
PURCHASE ORDER : VERBAL
LABORATORY # 7:92.01023.241
The following is a responce to the Motion to Strike Affidavit of
David W. Byrd.
Ce ee ee ne ey
1.0 THE CHARLES EVANS SCOPE OF WORK
l.2 The motion which you have provided covers numerous references to
test paramezers which were not included in the scope of work which
nad been cequested of Charles Evans and Associates. The specific
items which were requested were the presence of ligands or chealating
compounds. This is sufficiently clear from my communication to Dr.
Edgell dated December 9,1991 which is in your possession. Because of
the limitations of the test method we did not request that ESCA be
usec tc:
Setermine the presence of methylene chloride.
Determine the presence of surfactants.
Identify a specific chealating agent.
Determine specific molecular forms of organochlorine
compounds detected.
The nature of the defendants queries directed during Dr. Edgell’s
depost:on reflect a lack of understanding of the use of the ESCA test
method.
1.2 After completion of the testing Dr. Edgell sent a fax of the ESCA
laboratory results. I called Dr. Edgell and discussed the results. At
that time I confirmed that ligands were detected. The data on the
carbon bonding clearly denotes the presence ligands namely carbonyl,
carhoxylate amd amines. Further the test showec that organochlorine
compounds, sulfur oxides and zine were detected. This data was used to
augment other laboratory data obtained in our laboratory (refer to
report 91.01C023.223). ESCA was used as exclusive evidence for the
Presence c= a chealating acent.
m» tw NM eo
. * . a
63.
ee = Ee
a ih ime ae ae te a ee ee
Maer C7 °SE Ja: 62°" GSSOLUT aSUF. =Y
ic ‘ ‘
~— Sew ~
ABR OWTE
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
ha Mhadl |
1030-0 North Crooks Road
Clawson, Michigan 48017
LABORATORY 313-435-5100
page 2
CLIENT :ALEX RHODES,P.C.
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :KALIARDOS v. GENERAL MOTORS et al.
ANALYSIS REQUESTED :COMMENTS ON MOTION
LABORATORY ¢ 7:92.01023.241
1.3 The fact that zine is in the oxidized form would be consistent
with the common usage of zinc as a sacrificial metal which would be
oxidized (rusted) instead of the metal of the door. In this
perspective it is consistent with the intended application of Zinc as
a constituent of an anticorrosion product. The fact that ESCA only
provides surface information is again consistent and predicted with
the form of zinc found on the surface of the coating.
THE PRESENCE OF LIGANDS
Formualtions which use metallosulfonates, i.e. calcium sulfonate,
barium suifonate, etc., constitute metal complexes which make use of
ligands to complex the metal. Calcium sulfonate is listed as an
ingredient in H.B. Fuller’s product WC-2291.
WR) BS
~~
3.0 THE PRESENCE OF SURFACTANTS
3.1 Tests performed in our laboratory (91.01023.229) show that
surfactants are present in the anticorrosion sample obtained from the
door of a 1989 Eldorado.
3.1 Calcium sulfonate is classified as surfactant. Calcium sulfonate
is listed as an ingredient in H.B. Fuller’s product WC-2291. See
summary report on BASF ANTI-CORROSION WAX COATING $512001 (report
90.01023.xxx).
I= you have cuestions or are in need of additional service piease
fee. free tO contact us at your earliest convenience.
Absolute Analytical Laboratory,
David W. Byrd
Lapcratory Director
6:
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
NICOLAS KALLIARDOS,
Plaintiff, Civil Action
Case No. 88-CV-73729-DT
vs.
HON. PAUL V. GADOLA
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION,
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
COMPANY, NATIONAL STARCH &
CHEMICAL CORPORATION, and BEAZER
FAST, INC., jointly and severally,
Defendants.
AFFIDAVIT OF JAMES P. JOHNSON, PH.D.
COMMONWEALTH OF CANADA )
) SS:
PROVINCE OF ONTARIO . )
James P. Johnson, being first duly Sworn, deposes and says:
1. I make this affidavit om my own personal knowledge.
3. I have a Ph.D. degree in Chemistry which was awarded to me by
McMasters University, Hamilton, Ontario, Canada in 1983.
4. I am experienced in the development: of analytical methods for
chemical analysis. I am also experienced in modern instrumental methods of
chemical analysis, including, gas chromatography and mass spectrometry. I have
also used USPEA, ASTM, NIOSH, MOE and other analytical methods to meet clients '
needs.
-i-
> > Tt = ae
65.
5. In February, 1990 I was employed at Clayton Envirormental
Consultants, Canadian Operations. My position was Technical Supervisor,
Laboratory Services.
6. On February 7, 1990 I was given a sample of No. 794542 (Clayton
Project No. 62922-17) by Laboratory Supervisor Dr. Paul Epstein with
instructions to analyse the sample for the presence of tetrachlorvcethere .
(cammonly referred to as perchloroethylene).
7. The sample 794542 was a viscous liquid similar in appearance to
plastic model silver paint.
8. On March 1, 1990, I personally performed an analysis of the sample
using the method of gas chromotography/heated headspace/ECD.
9. During the analysis, the air quality of the laboratory was analyzed
and found to be free of contaminants.
et
10. I placed .8 grams of the sample in a sealed 40 ml. glass bottle
and heated the sample at 80 degrees centigrade for thirty minutes.
1l. The sample solidified during the heating.
12. After heating the sample, I removed 1 microliter from the head
space with a syringe and injected the 1 microliter into a gas chromatograph.
The response was high and exceeded the linear calibration limit of the scale.
13. I then removed 1/2 microliter with the syringe and injected it
into the gas chromatograph and obtained a reading on the scale. I repeated the
procedure 3 times by removing various amounts of the sample and injecting it
into the gas chromatograp. Each injection detected tetrachloroethene in the
sample.
14. After the analysis of the sample using the gas chromatograph was
completed, the solidified sample was analyzed using a gas chromatograph/mass
66.
spectrometer (GC/MS) with selective ion monitoring. Dr. Epstein and myself
were present during the analysis. The results positively confirmed that
tetrachloroethene was an ingredient of the sample.
15. I have reviewed an affidavit of Dr. Paul Epstein, a copy of which
is attached. I find this affidavit to be trve.
‘j F(pd
L 7 wns { 24,1244
Jamey P. Jonnsom./ Ph.D. ~
Subscriped and sworn to before me
at Clayton Emvirormental Consultants,
Canadian Cperations, 949 McDougall Ave.
Wimisor, Ontario, Canada
this _ Gay of May, 1992
WwW
67.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
NICOLAS KALIARDOS,
Plaintiff, Civil Action
Case No. 88-CV~-73729-DT
vs.
Hon. Paul V. Gadola
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION,
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
COMPANY, NATIONAL STARCH &
CHEMICAL CORPORATION, and BEAZER
EAST, INC., jointly and severally,
Defendants.
VIT_OF i °O
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
) Ss
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
Franklin C. Schoonover, being first duly sworn, deposes
and says:
1. I have a degree in manufacturing engineering from the
General Motors Institute, Flint, Michigan.
2. I am experienced in automobile engineering and
manufacturing, having been employed in the automobile industry
for over thirty (30) years.
3. My experience includes six (6) years in
manufacturing, General Motors Fisher Body Division, Cadillac
Plant, Detroit, Michigan. This experience includes one (1) year
as a production supervisor and one (1) year as a general foreman
68.
69. :
SCSI ELE EE RTE CELE A OC, TOE MET ae
in the paint department.
4. My experience also includes twenty-five (25) years at
the Ford Motor Company, Dearborn, Michigan. This experience
included vehicle design engineering, management and product
planning.
5S. My job titles at Ford included Product Design
Engineer, Manager of the Safety and Services Department, and
Chief Product Planning Analyst for safety, damageability and
corrosion. I was also represented Ford legal representative on
the Damageability Committee of the SAE (Society of Automotive
Engineers).
6. On May 31, 1989, I examined used General Motors'
vehicles at Highway Auto Parts, 29231 Groesbeck Highway (M-97),
Roseville, Michigan. The purpose of my examination was to
identify General Motors' vehicles which were in an “as
manufactured" condition for obtaining samples of anti-corrosion
coatings.
7. Present, during my examination, were Nicolas
Kaliardos and David W. Byrd.
8. I examined the vehicles for evidence of repairs,
removal or penetration of vapor barriers, drill holes and plugs
for applying after-market coatings, paint mis-matches of top
coats and primers, and traces of other coatings on top coats.
If any such evidence existed, I rejected the vehicles as being
unsuitable.
9. I identified as being in an "as manufactured"
-_-
condition, a 1984 Buick Skyhawk (Vehicle Identification No.
1G4AS2703EK526551) and a 1983 Oldsmobile Cierra (Vehicle
Identification No. 1G3AJ19E2DD406799).
10. Mr. David W. Byrd took samples of a wax coating from
the interior of the Oldsmobile Cierra door in my presence for
analysis at the Absolute Analytical Laboratory, Clawson,
Michigan.
11. One of the 1984 Buick Skyhawk doors was removed
from the vehicle in my presence by a Highway Auto Parts'
employee. I personally delivered the door to the Absolute
Analytical Laboratory, Clawson, Michigan.
12. If called to testify at trial, I will testify that
the anti-corrosion coatings on the interior surfaces of the 1983
Oldsmobile Cierra and the 1984 Buick Skyhawk were part of the
original equipment of the vehicles.
Further Deponent sayeth not. _
e jt rit fo
he fr fee VA er Jae, ae e
’ Franklin C. Schoonover
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this 21st day of August, 1992.
1?
Carmelina Mullane, Notary Public,
Oakland County, Michigan
; My Commission Expires: March 17, 1993
ABSOLUTE ANALYT ICAL LABORATORY
4030-D Nortn Crooks Roac
Clawson, Michigan 48047
313-435-5100
SEPTEMBER 17,1992
ALEX RHODES, P.C-
30100 TELEGRAPH RD.,STE. 460
BINGHAM FARMS ,MI 48025
RE:
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :H.B. FULLER FORMULATION WC-2291 & WC-2291-P
ANALYSIS REQUESTED :AROMATIC AND CHLORINATED CMPDS.
HHS/GC-PID-ELCD
PURCHASE ORDER : VERBAL
LABORATORY 4 292.01023.266-REPRINT.
Samples of the referenced formuiations were analysed for the
presence of aromatic hydrocarbons and volatile chlorinated solvents.
Our test results are tabulated on the attached pages.
If you have guestions or are in need of additional service please
feel free to contact us at your earliest convenience.
Absolute Analytical Laboratory:
AR1/932
ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
4030-D North Crooks Road
Clawson, Michigan 48017
LABORATORY 313-435-5100
ABSOLUTE
+
page 2
CLIENT :ALEX RHODES,P.C.
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :H.B. FULLER FORMULATION WC-2291 & WC-2291-P
ANALYSIS REQUESTED :AROMATIC AND CHLORINATED CMPDS.
HHS/GC~PID-ELCD
LABORATORY # :92.01023.266
ANALYTICAL SECTION
1.0 SAMPLE PREPARATION
1.1 SAMPLE DESCRIPTION TABLE
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION
1 QUART CONTAINER MARKED “WC-2291"
1 QUART CONTAINER MARKED “WC-2291-P"
1.1.2 The wax coating samples (ca. 1 gram) were placed into 40 ml
vials with a silicone-teflon septa for head space sampling. The
containerized samples were incubated at 90 C for approximately one
hour. Desorbed volatiles were obtained by puncturing the container
and obtaining a sample of the headspace volume which was subsequently
injected into the gas chromatograph. The operational conditions of the
gas chromatograph were:
T(inject) : COC C T(column) :_program T(detect): 200 C
T(initial): 40 Cc T(rate) : Ss ¢ Stsaneé? = 62. 358 ©
T(hold) 73 MIN ____ Flow misec-@C:8.0
Detector 1: PID Detector 2: HECD
Column: 530 um x 30 m. 3.0 um DB624.
The resulting chromatograms were compared to standards of aromatic
hydrocarbons and chlorinated hydrocarbons for identification purposes.
ee.
f<
2.0 TEST RESULTS ; !
2.1 TABULATED DATA FOR AROMATIC HYDROCARBONS
¢
Se ato ECO DICAL ap
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION AROMATIC COMPOUNDS COMMENTS
WwC=-2291 DETECTED Benzene, toluene, ;
ethylbenzene, xylenes
WC-2291-P DETECTED Benzene, toluene,
ethylbenzene, xylenes
ic ales
S2
84:13PM RESOLUTE LABORATORY
ABSOLUTE
ANALYTIC AL ABSOLUTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
l
1039-D North Crooks Rooc
Clawson, Micnigen 48017
My getting.
313-435-5100
BPLABORATORY
page 3
CLIENT ;ALEX RHODES,P.C.
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION °=H.B. FULLER FORMULATION WC-2291 & WC-2291-pP
ANALYSIS REQUESTED sAROMATIC AND CHLORINATED CMPDS.
HHS/GC-PID-ELCD
LABORATORY #¢# 792.01023.266
2.2 TABULATED DATA FOR CHLORINATED AYDROCARBONS
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION CELORINATED COMPOUNDS COMMENTS
WC-2291 DETECTED 1,l-dichloroethene
WC-2291-p DETECTED 1,1-dichloroethene
3.0 DISCUSSION
3.1 Our tests show that aromatic hydrocarb
toluene, ethylbenzene and xylenes are foun
formulation designated "“wc-2291" ana "WC-2291]-p*
test show that 1,1-dichloroethene, a volatile ch
are present in the reference wax
Ons such as benzene,
d in both the Fuller
- Additionally, our
lorinated hydrocarbon,
coating materials.
43
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
NICOLAS KALIARDOS,
Plaintiff, Civil Action
Case No. 88-CV-73729-DT
vs.
Hon. Paul V. Gadola
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION,
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
COMPANY, and H.B. FULLER AUTOMOTIVE
PRODUCTS, INC., jointly and severally,
Defendants.
/
DAV OF DARRELL W. RIDLING
STATE OF MICHIGAN)
} ss
COUNTY OF OAKLAND)
Darrell W. Ridling, being first duly sworn, deposes and
says:
1. I am the Plant Manager of Automotive Finishes, Inc.,
Dearborn, Michigan, and its subsidiary Brighton Coatings, Inc.,
Brighton, Michigan.
2. I have been employed in the manufacture of coatings
for thirty-six (36) years. My work experience includes
twenty-two (22) years at the Inmont (BASF) Milford Avenue
Detroit Plant. I left Inmont in 1978.
3. My employment at the Milford Plant included batch
making, mill loading and quality control, and various management
positions.
COQO8Z8S
74.
4. Iam familiar with the Inmont (BASF) $51Z001 wax
anti-corrosion coating. This coating was manufactured while I
was employed at the Milford Avenue Plant to meet General Motors
Material Specification 998-1128.
5S. At Inmont, I advanced from Production Worker to the
position of Superintendent of the Resin Plant.
6. I am very familiar with the manufacture of coatings,
including the preparation and use of production batch sheets and
quality control.
7. From 1982 to 1990, I was the Chief Officer and the
Majority Stockholder of Brighton Paint Manufacturing Inc. |
8. I have reviewed seven 1984 Daubert NOX RUST X-151
production batch sheets, General Motors Material Specification
998-1128, and a Daubert Material Safety Sheet, copies of which
are attached. I have also reviewed a letter to General Motors
from a Daubert Product Manager, Michael A. Dwyer. Mr. Dwyer's
letter indicates that NOX RUST X-151 was manufactured to meet
General Motors Material Specification 998-1128.
9. General Motors Material Specification 998-1128
requires the solid content of the coating to be established at
the time of approval and set forth in the Material Safety Data
Sheet.
10. General Motors suppliers are required to certify
that each shipment complies with the requirements of General
Motors Material Specification 998-1128.
75.
ll. Defects in the attached Daubert batch sheets cause
me to believe that the Daubert sheets are false or altered.
12. The defects include (1) missing information, (2)
failure to comply with the quality control parameter of percent
solids, (3) inconsistent data, (4) excessive batch overages,
(5S) large variations in viscosity and (5) additions of excessive
amounts of naphtha.
jf A Pol r /_-
\ = / ) ef ( :
Any Ww Jf,
Darrell W. Ridling ¥ a
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this _*"“% day of September, 1992.
7 .
f teh / i y 7 oe i
;
_-2 MA * 2. -Notary Public,
“-"“" l County, Michigan
My Commission Expires: TP Cae
76.
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
NICOLAS KALIARDOS,
Plaintiff, Civil Action
Case No. 88-CV-73729-DI
vs.
Hon. Paul V. Gadola
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION, BASF
CORPORATION, DAUBERT INDUSTRIES, IN.,
H.B. FULLER COMPANY, and H.B. FULLER
AUTOMOTIVE, INC., jointly and severally,
Defendants.
DA’ OF DA W. BYRD
STATE OF MICHIGAN )
)SS
COUNTY OF OAKLAND )
David W. Byrd, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
I am the owner and Laboratory Director of the Absolute Analytical -
Laboratory, Inc., 1034-D Crooks Road, Clawson, Michigan. I have a B.S. and
M.S. Degree in Biological Science. I am presently completing the course
requirements for a Masters Degree in Chemical Engineering at Wayne State
University. My professional memberships include the American Chemical Society,
ANACHEM, and the Chromatography Society. I have over fourteen years of
analytical laboratory experience.
I have reviewed U.S. Patent No. 4,356,036, including the claims, H.B.
Fuller WC-2291 and WC 2291-P Material Safety Data Sheets, and H.B. Fuller
Automotive, Inc. doaments relating to the manufacture of Wax Type
Anti-Corrosion coating WC-2291 and WC-2291-P.
Claim 1 of U.S. Patent No. 3,959,530 defines a coating composition
77.
consisting essentially of a mixture of wax residue such as paraffin ard
microcrystalline wax, perchloroethylene, a petroleum distillate having a
boiling point ranging between 350° and 380°F., and a nonionic surfactant
such as nonylphenoxypoly (ethyeneoxy) ethanol and a small amount of
(N,N,N',N'-tetrakis (2-hydroxypropyl) ethylenediamine].
Fuller Material Safety Data Sheet WC-2291 lists the ingredients of a
coating as consisting of microcrystalline wax, VM & P Naphtha, aliphatic oil
(Hydro-treated), calcium sulfonate, paraffinic wax and an aliphatic resin.
Fuller Material Safety Data Sheet WC-2291-P lists the ingredients of a coating
Which are the same as WC-2291 except for the added ingredient of mineral
spirits.
I also conducted an analyses of Fuller coatings WC-2291 and WC-2291-P
for chlorinated solvents. The analyses detected the chlorinated solvent 1,1,
dichlorcethene and the aromatic solvents benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene, xylene
in both the WC-2291 and WC-2291-P coatings.
I have also analysed wax coatings taken from the bottams of the
interiors of late model General Motors' doors. Before I removed the samples
from their doors, I inspected the interior of the doors and found no evidence
that the wax type coating which I analyzed was other than an original factory
coating.
The vehicle doors from which I took samples consisted of a 1987
Chevrolet Celebrity VIN 1G1AW51R8H6211705, a 1988 Oldsmobile Delta 88, VIN
IG3HN545C7JM316919, and a 1991 Pontiac Grand Prix, VIN 1G2WI/54T6MF263626.
My analyses of the samples of wax coatings taken from the Genera.
Motors' doors detected microcrystalline wax in samples fram each of the three
doors; perchloroethylene in the samples from the 1987 Celebrity amd 1988
78.
Oldsmobile doors; methylene chloride in the sample from the 1991 Pontiac door;
and zinc and surfactants in the sample from the 1991 Pontiac Grand Prix Door.
I also forwarded a sample from the 1991 Pontiac door to the Charles
Evans and Associates Laboratory in Redwood City, California for an ESCA
analysis (Electron Spectroscopy for Chemical Analyses). The ESCA detected
evidence of organochlorine compounds, sulfur in oxidized form, and ligand
functionalities (chelating functionalities) .
I have compared the ingredients of claim 1 of U.S. Patent No.
3,959,530 with the ingredients listed in H.B. Fuller Batch Sheet for WC-2291-P
Batch No. AO10991 and my analyses of the WC-2291-P coating.
U.S. Patent No._3,959,530 -2291-P
Mixture of a Wax Residue Multi Wax ML 445
Perchlorcethylene 1,1 dichlorethene
Petroleum Distillate Mineral Spirits
B.P. = 350° and 380°F ‘
Nonionic Surfactant Lockhart Neutral Barium
Sulfonate 3605
(N,N,N' ,N'-tetrakis lubrizol 2087 (a dispersion
(2-hydroxypropy1) of a Metallo-Canmplex
ethylenediamine}
(chelating agent)
The comparison shows that the H.B. Fuller wax type anti-corrosion
coating has the ingredients or their equivalents of claim 1 of U.S. Patent No.
3,959,530.
Further deponent sayeth net.
Subscribed and sworn to before me
this.19th day of October, 1992
ye a i :
. ot ee | “a. .tnie 4 A a ~ od
CARITAS PILANE
eee, Coens Corts. 0 aw
wey Our gs teeta. V7. Ved 7 9 S
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF MICHIGAN
SOUTHERN DIVISION
NICOLAS KALIARDOS,
Plaintiff, Civil Action
Case No. 88-CV-73729-DI
vs.
Hon. Paul V. Gadola
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION,
BASF CORPORATION, DAUBERT
INDUSTRIES, INC., H.B. FULLER
COMPANY, and H.B. FULLER AUTOMOTIVE
INDUSTRIES; INC., jointly and severally,
Defendants.
One
AFFIDAVIT OF DR. PETER O. WARNER
STATE OF MICHIGAN )
COUNTY OF WAYNE )
Dr. Peter 0. Warner, being duly sworn, deposes and says:
I am the Director of Technical Services, Wayne County Air Pollution
Control Laboratory, Detroit, Michigan and a member of the adjunct faculty of
Wayne State University, Department of Occupational and Envirormmental Health.
was President of the Association of Analytical Chemists in 1976. In 1979 I
received the Anachem Fellow Award. I am presently Chairman of Air and Waste
Management Association, Technical Committee EE-6. In 1990 I was Chairman of
the AWMA Specialty Conference, Detroit, Michigan.
I have a Ph.D. Degree in Analytical Chemistry. This degree was
awarded to me by Wayne State University in 1964. Additional professional
experience, awards, amd offices in professional societies, together with
technical articles I have authored are summarized in the attached resume.
80. |
a ee i a a eee ee
a ee ee ee ae EE St
I am intimately familiar with perchlorcethylene, air pollutants and
air sampling and am the author of the textbook Analysis of Air Pollutants, New
york, John Wiley, Inc., 1976. I have worked with perchlorvcethylene in
preparing formulations for industrial use.
I have reviewed Shrader Laboratories, Inc. Report No. A61501 and
A61502 and Clayton Environmental Consultants, Inc. Report of Project No.
62922-17 for the purpose of providing an opinion of whether the
perchlorcethylene detected in samples are contaminants caused by urban
atmospheric pollution.
In my opinion, neither the 24.8 ppb perchlorcethylene which Shraeder
Laboratories, Inc. detected in sample A61502 or the 91 ppm perchlorvethylene
which Clayton Environmental Consultants, Inc. detected in sample 998-1128 are
contaminants caused by atmospheric pollution.
Air sampling data indicates that perchlorocethylene in an urban
atmosphere is within a range of .07 to .30 ppb. This is substantially below
the 24.8 ppb and 91 ppm levels of perchloroethylene which the laboratories
detected in the samples.
I am not aware of any wax materials having an affinity to absorb
chlorinated solvents from the atmosphere and concentrate the chlorinated
solvents to produce levels higher than the levels absorbed from the atmosphere.
I know of no mechanism by which this absorption/concentration could
take place.
Ay / Cee. fi Aen.
Dr. Peter 0. Warner
Subscribed and sworn to before me
P f LA
this _//.~' day of October, 1992
81.
| Ye ABsotute =]
oN AN ALY, TIC AL ae: Ai \UTE ANALYTICAL LABORATORY
Me As ff A Mel | pda trict
\ iO » {
ara SiG rAToO Rs 313-435-5100
ns
ALEX RHODES,P.C.
30100 TELEGRAPH ROAD;SUITE 460
BINGHAM FARMS,MI 49025
ATTN: ALEX RHODES
RE:
PROJECT > EQUIVALENCE TESTING
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :ANTI-RUST COATING
TEST OBJECTIVE :SURFACE TENSION AND ADHESION TESTING
ij} ABSOLUTE LAB I.D.# >:93.01623.1762
DATE REPORTED >12/30/93
At your request Abswlute Analytical Inc. has; performed
laboratory testing to demonstrate equivalence of chemical substitutes
present in General Motors 998-1128/998-2150 wax type anti-corrosion
coating, manufactured by BASF Corporation, Daube:t industries, Inc.
and H. B. Fuller Automotive Products,Inc.; and the ingredients in the
claims of U.S. Patents Nos. 3,959,530 and 4,356,036. Specifically we
have performed testing with respect to surface active properties,
chelation, and surface degreasing properties. The tests which we have
performed to evaluate equivalency include measures of surface tension
and adhesion. The criteria used to ascribe equivalence is determined
by the definition of any two substances which perform substantially
the same overall function, in substantially the same way, to obtain
substantially the same overall result.
It should be noted that the chemical substances which were tested are
well known and that the equivalence of these sub::tances in the
subject coatings were previously developed in Aflidavits and
depositions of David W. Byrd.
IIE ES) ne SBN aR SARL SO by! os. oy
Be ssh
SUMMARY
Our testing for equivalence with respect to surfactants properties,
chelation, and chlorinated solvent surface degreasing properties
demonstrate equivalency to those chemical agents specified in the
Claims of U.S. Patent Nos 3,959,530 and 4,356,036. From our test
survey we can say that:
1. the following agents are equivalent to tle [gepal in surface
active properties when mixed with the symuthetic mixture of
Anti-Rust Compound 998-1128 formula number $512Z001 (formula
date 10-23-74):
stearic acid
barium sulfonate
calcium sulfonate
lead sulfonate
82.
~.
Absolute Analytical Laboratory
Clawson, Michigan
313.435.5100
page 2
CLIENT -ALEX RHODES,P.C.
PROJECT >EQUIVALENCE TESTING
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION >ANTI~RUST COATING
TEST OBJECTIVE -SURFACE TENSION AND ADHESION TESTING
ABSOLUTE LAB I.D.# >93.01023.1762
SUMMARY (continued)
2. the following agents are equivalent to the Quadrol in surface
chelating properties when mixed with the synthetic mixture of
Anti-Rust Compound 998-1128 formula number $51Z001 (formula
date 10-23-74):
methylenedianiline
barium sulfonate
calcium sulfonate
lead sulfonate
3. the following agents are equivalent to the perchloroethene in
Surface degreasing properties when mixed with the synthetic
mixture of Anti-Rust Compound 998-1128 formula number $512Z001
(formula date 10-23-74) which was modified to include 1 %
Igepal and 0.5 % Quadrol.
methylene chloride
trichloroethylene
1,1 dichloroethene
TEST OUTLINE
The materials were divided into three groups based upon their
functions in the wax type anti-corrosion coating under investigation.
These groups consisted of surfactants (surface «tive agents),
chelating agents, and chlorinated solvents. In cases were dual
functions were ascribed to a chemical substance it was included in
both test series.
The ingredient and its functional equivalent were evaluated by
testing in a wax type anti-corrosion coating. The wax-type coating
used for the test series was Supplied by Nicolas Kaliardos together
with a BASF $512001 (GM998~-1128) Master Formula Sheet which Mr.
Kaliardos stated was used for preparing the coating (see attached
copy).
83.
AbscYute Analytical Laboratory
Clawson, Michigan
313.435.5100
page 3
CLIENT -ALEX RHODES,I’.C.
PROJECT >tQUIVALENCE TESTING
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :ANTI-RUST COATING
TEST OBJECTIVE :SURFACE TENSION AND ADIIi. LON ‘TESTING
ABSOLUTE LAB I.D.# >93.01023.1762
1.0 SURFACTANTS
1.1 Surfactants are surface active agents which reduce the surface
tension of liquids. The reduction of the surface tension of a liquid
will allow for the greater dispersal of the liquid. With respect to
the wax coatings the function of the surfactant is to improve the
ability the coating to spread over the surface of the metal. The
measurement of surface tension is a widely practiced method for the
assessment of surface active agents. Specifically, we have performed
surface tension measurements of a synthetic mixture of Anti~Rust
Compound 998-1128 formula number $51Z001 (formula date 10-23-74)
which was diluted with xylene in order to effect surface measurement.
Surface tension measurements of the Anti-Rust coating mixed with
Igepal were compared to surface tension measurements of the same
Anti-Rust coating 998-1128 in combination with the following
compounds:
stearic acid
barium sulfonate
calcium sulfonate
lead sulfonate
1.2 The mixtures were evaluated for surface tension reduction using
the capillary tube method as outlined in Findlay's Practical Physical
Chemistry, 8th edition, pages 94-97. Our results are tabulated on the
attached data sheets (see table I).
2.0 ADHESION EVALUATION OF CHELATING MIXTURES
2.1 The chelating agents bind to metals and allow for the greater
solution of metals. The inclusion of the chelating agent Quadrol
resulted in better binding to the metal substrat::. [n order to
evaluate equivalence of Quadrol we have performed adhesion
measurements of a synthetic mixture of Anti-Rust Compound 998-1128
formula number S51Z001 (formula date 10-23-74) and Quadrol to
determine if surface activity equivalence exists between the
Anti-Rust Compound 998-1128 when combined with the following
compounds:
methy lenedianiline
barium sulfonate
calcium sulfonate
lead «wl ---:
84.
Absolute Analytical Laboratory
Clawson, Michigan
313.435.5100
page ¢4
a. :ALEX RHODES,P.C.-
ROJECT : EQUIVALENCE TESTING
SAMPLE DESCRIPTION :ANTI-RUST COATING
TEST OBJECTIVE -SURFACE TENSION AND ADHESION TESTING
ABSOLUTE LAB I.D.# :93.01023.1762
2.2 The assessment of the chelating agent upon the various test
mixtures was evaluated by applying the test mixture to 4 metal
substrate as a film. The dried film was then evaluated for adhesion
using the American Society for Testing Materials test method D
3359-90 "Standard Test Methods for Measuring Adhesion by Tape Test".
Our test results are tabulated in table II (see attachment).
3.0 ADHESION EVALUATION OF CHLORINATED ANTI-RUST MIXTURES
3.1 The chlorinated solvents in Anti-Rust formulations act as
degreasing agents which improve adhesion to the metal substrate which
may be covered with a mill oil or similar protective oil. In order to
evaluate equivalence of perchloroethene in Anti-Rust formulations we
have performed adhesion measurements of a synthetic mixture of
Anti-Rust Compound 998-1128 formula number $51Z001 (formula date
19-23-74) which was modified to include 1 % Igepal and 0.5 % Quadrol.
We refer to this mixture as “B". To "Bt we have added the following
chlorinated solvents:
methylene chloride
trichloroethylene
1,1 dichloroethene
3.2 The assessment of the chlorinated solvents upon the various test
mixtures was evaluated by applying the test mixture to 4 metal
substrate which been treated with a film of mill oil. The dried film
was then evaluated for adhesion using the American Society for
Testing Materials test method D 3359-90 “Standard Test Methods for
Measuring Adhesion by Tape Test". Our test results are tabulated in
table III (see attachment).
If you have questions or are in need of additional service please
feel free to contact us at your earliest convenience.
Absolute Analytical Laboratory,
Mess !
. {
,
David W. Byrd,M.-S.
Laboratory Director
enclosures (4)
85.
TABULAR SURMMARY OF TEST DATAz_ REPORT 93.01023.1762
I. SURFACTANTS
TREATMENT TEST i TEST 2 | TEST3 | AVE
20ml A+O.2 g IGEPAL 16.0 16.0 16.0 16.0
20ml A+0.2 g STEARIC ACID is.5 45.3 33.5 1535
20ml A+0.2 g BARIUM SULFONATE 16.0 16.0 16.2 16.07
20ml A+O.2 g LEAD SULFONATE 16.2 16.2 16.0 16.13
20ml A+1.0 g CALCIUM SULFONATE 16.2 16.1 16.2 16.17
II. ADHESION EVALUATION OF CHELATING MIXTURES
The tables IIA., IIB., AND III. refer to the Standard Test Methods
for Measuring Adhesion by Tape Test (ASTM D 3359-90). Tables IIA.
and III. involve Test Method A: X-Cut Tape Test. Table IIB.
involves Test Method B: Cross-Cut Tape Test.
TABLE IIA.
TREATMENT TEST 1A TEST 2A
A + .5% QUADROL 1 1
A + .5% MDA 1 1
A + .5% BARIUM SULFONATE 1 1
A + .5% CALCIUM SULFONATE 1 1
A + .5% LEAD SULFONATE 1 1
TABLE IIB.
TREATMENT TEST 1B TEST 2B TEST 3B
A + .5% QUADROL 1 1 2
A + .5% MDA 1 1 2
A + .1% BARIUM SULFONATE 2 2 N.T
A + .5% CALCIUM SULFONATE y 3 2
A + .5% °-LEAD SULFONATE 3 3 3
86.
III. ADHESION EVALUATION OF CHLORINATED ANTI-RUST MIXTURES
In all treatments we have used the submitted synthetic mixture of
Anti-Rust Compound 9981128 (formula $51Z001 10/23/74) pilus 1 %
Igepal and 0.5% Quadrol. We refer to this mixture as "B". These
formulations were tested on a metal substrate which had be covered
with a thin film of mill oil.
TABLE III.
| TREATMENT TEST 1A TEST 2A
B + PERCHLOROETHENE 2 2
B + METHYLENE CHLORIDE 2 2
B + TRICHLORETHYLENE 2 2
B + 1,1 DICHLORETHENE 2 2
87.
TABLE OF TEST MATERIALS
~~
COMMON NAME
ACTIVE INGRIEDIENT
SUPPLIER
MDA~(13,245-4)
4,4-METHYLENEDIANILINE
ALDRICH
BARIUM SULFONATE
BARIUM PETRONATE
WITCO (36504)
. CALCIUM
SULFONATE
CALCIUM ALKYLARYL~-
SULFONATE (VANCORR 073)
R.T. VANDERBILT
(48451)
NA-SUL-LS (3839)
LEAD SULFONATE
KING INDUSTRIES
QUADROL
N,N,N',N'-TETRAKIS (2-HY
DROXYPROPYL ) ETHYLEDIAMINE
BASF (588540)
STEARIC ACID
INDUSTRENE 7018
WITCO (93271011)
PERCHLOROETHENE PERCHLOROETHENE DOW CHEMICAL
DICHLOROETHENE 1,1-DICHLOROETHENE 99% CHEM SERVICE
(119-32B)
IGEPAL IGEPAL CO-530 RHONE-POULENC
TRICHLOROETHENE TECH GRADE TROY SCIENTIFIC
88.
- ‘wwe TON MILE Me. PU. OUA SOU
WARREN, MICH. 48090
MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET
SECTION |
PRODUCT NAME OR NUMGER (as « agceers on ace: bis
wWC-2291 |
FACTUREA S NAME EMEAGENCY TELEP
pias * » FULLER AUTOMOTIVE PRODUCTS, INC. | (313) Eee NO
13650 EAST TEN MILE ROAD, WARREN, MI 48089 18-966-3206
MAZAROCLS MATERIAL DESCAIPTION. PROPER SHIPPING NAME. MAZARO CLASS. HAZARO 10 NO. (49 CFA 172.101)
COMPOUND VEHICLE SEALER - FLAMMABLE LIQUID N.O.S. UN 1993
ACOIMONAL MACARO CLASSES 14s aooncaoie: e
NONE
CREMICAL FAAULY FORMULA
HYDROCARBON MIXTURE
ACORESS :Numoer, Street. Gey, State anc Zio Coce: | MANUFACTURER'S 0-U-N.S NO. |
“ALL INGREDIENTS LISTED SECTION Il — INGREDIENTS
ON TSCA INVENTORY. (list all ingredients)
CAS REG:STRY NO Gs.
Usted as s Carcinogen
CHEMICAL NAME(S) in NTP. LARC of OSHA
1910lz) (so@ctyi
63231-60-7 |15$30] MICROCRYSTALLINE WAX NONE
€032-32-4% | 20+40| VM & P NAPHTHA | NONE
RET ALIPHATIC OIL CHYDRO-TREATED) | NONE
pizeo-e5-5 | stiol _catcium suLFONATE NONE
sco2-74-2 | stiol _pararinic wax NONE
2742-16-1 lislsol atrPHatic HYDROCARBON RESIN NONE
-
|
|
|
|
|
:
A
SECTION Ill — PHYSICAL DATA
BOING FOINT 244 SPECIFIC GRAVITY (H,0 = 1) fo 1
264 | -9 eS
VAPOR PRESSURE : (%
SC Manly Cog | CAEN VOLATIE BY VOLUME |. | PERCENT SOUD BY ra
VA RB Re 3 7
POR CENSITY iA.a @ 15 | a | EVAPORATION RATE TOLUENE” lo.us | | |
SCLUBILITY IN WATER | NIL l ore | N/A | | |
D seta.
MARANCE ANO COOR CapweL COLORED LIQUID - MILD ODOR | SM gaS ase ERD SOUT |
SECTION IV — FIRE AND EXPLOSION HAZARD DATA
FLASH POINT meinod usea FLAMMAGLE UMITS; _ ise ‘ is:
a= , T.C.C. | 1 i co
ewe NGUISAING MECLA C02, DRY CHEMICAL, FOAM
SPECAL AE FIGKENG PROCEZEQURES
—_—eee
thaw WATER MAY BE INEFFECTIVE DUE TO FROTHING. |
|
UNUSUAL FRE ANO EXPLOSION HALAAOS MAY GIVE OFF CO ON COMBUSTION. FLAMMABLE
| SOLVENTS HEAVIER THAN AIR.
eee ee
RE — THAESHOLO UMIT Va
ee ee ee | weananssi8ce exPnsuRe uaa cia 350 MG/M
HEADACHES OR DIZZINESS | Owen Umit Go MAC S00 PPM
oo SECTION V-HEALTH ....ZARD DATA =
PRIMAAY ROUTES OF ENTAY inmaravenXZ Stun Contact (; Otner isoecity!
EMERGENCY ANO FIAST UO PROCEDURES REMOVE TO FRESH AIR.
=
SECTION VI-REACTIVITY DATA
UNSTAGLE | | CONDITIONS TO AVOID —.
- . |
papery (stagie | XX] SPARKS OR OPEN FLAMES ee
INCOMPA?. BILITY imatenaa to avo! STRONG OXIDIZERS é ies
en 6=—S oe MAY. GIVE OFF CO ON. COMBUSTION. am
nee MAY OCCUR CONDITIONS TO AVOID “3
POLYMERIZATION WiLL NOT OCCUR xX N/A : ae |
‘ ee
SECTION ViI-SPILL OR LEAK PROCEDURES | ,
bist Be cPTiLS Vices SANT. N SMALL SPILLS; AVOID SPARKS on |
AMES. = | q
WASTE CiSPOSAL METHOD DISPOSE OF IN ACCORDANCE. WITH LOCAL, STATE, AND cha
RCRA RASAARCC 5 WASTE NO. (40 CFA 261.23) D001 | ; i
VOLATILE ORGANI COMPOUND (VOC! las packaged. munus wateri 2.6 LBS. ee,
CX Bneorencas 2. figs io Anaiyucal —___—_sevgal re 7
_ SECTION VIII-SPECIAL PROTECTION INFORMATION = J
RESPIRATORY PAGTECTION (soeaty YO! ves. IF MAC OF 500 PPM 1S EXCEEDED (CHARCOAL). 3
j LOCAL EXHAUST ISoeaty Rater Bee PLANT REQUIREMENT — | SPECAL none 3
VENTILATION | MECHANICAL (Genera (Soeaty Ravee oO FEET PER MINUTE OTHER NONE 7
ae .
PROTECTIVE GLOVES (spectty toe! Sa TREE Z| eve PROTECTION ts0eatv voe! SHIELD BER PLANT RE-|
OTHER PROTECT VE EQUIPMENT NONE QUIREMENTS . .
SECTION. !.-SPECIAL PRECAUTIONS asd ee
PECANS 10 OE TAIN DRAMAS AO SISS 37 )2u pay FROM OPEN FLAME, STORE:
INSIDE BELOW 95°F. wee
OTHER PRECAUTIONS NONE x ro cate See rags ’
) —_
: REV 5/8/90 eee
DATE PREPARED: MAY 15, 1989 vr
NAME: -- MIKE PELLNY
TITLE: RED TECENICAL DIRECTOR
SIGNATURE: - \wibwe TALL
Ys 4h ak Oe {|
H.8. FULLER AUTOMCTIVE PRODUCTS, INC.
12650 €& TEN MILE AD., 20. BOX 3C6
WARREN, MICH. 48090
MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET
aA ti
SECTION |
PROOQUCT NAME OR NUMBGEA (a3 « a00ears on jane i,
WwC=2291-P _
MANUFACTURER'S OMOTIVE PRODUCTS INC . | sis). TELEPHONE NO. '
HeB. FULLER AUT ODUCTS, INC. (313) 776-5000 |
Street. accu
eet eS IM ERST TEN MILE BORGO WARREN, MI 48089 - —_18-366-3206 |
| HAZAROOUS MATEAIAL DESCAIPTION, PROPER SHIPPING NAME, 4ALAAO AF ARO IO
COMPOUND BODY SEALER - FLAMMABLE LIQUID/FLAMMAGLE LIQUID’ ROS’ Liquin |
ACOITIONAL HAZARD CLASSES ias acoucanie:
NONE |
CHEMICAL FAMILY FORMULA
PETROLEUM DISTILLATES | MIXTURE |
XALL INGREDIENTS LISTED SECTION Il — INGREDIENTS
ON TSCA INVENTORY. (list all ingredients)
e
CAS REGISTRY NO. | =w| mv CHEMICAL NAME(S) ia NTP LARC or OSA
191Ciz) (specify)
63231-60-7 | 20430] MICROCRYSTALLINE WAX l NONE
8032-32-4% {30-40 VM & P NAPHTHA NONE |
64741-88-4 [1-5 ALIPHATIC OIL - SEVERELY HYDROGENATED| NONE
61289-86-4 {| stio; - CALCIUM SULFONATE , | NONE |
8002-74-2 5-10] PARAFINIC WAX - - l NONE
68231-47-5 |10+20| ALIPHATIC RESIN ae
8032-32-4 1¢5 | -MINERAL SPIRITS | NONE |
| | |
| | |
[ | rs.
SECTION Ill — PHYSICAL DATA
BOIUNG act on “ SPECAIC GAAVITY in, oe) b g3al v 0.c 12.8 |
—— PRESSURE” 2 PERCENT VOLATILE 3Y VOLUME (%) | 60 | nan? an 6Y 60% |
WaPOR OENSITY (41h « 1) [4.4 | EVAPORATION Rate ( 7m 640.4) : :
SOLUBILITY IN WaTER | wil "= [N/A |
APPEARANCE ANC COCA npweL COLORED LIQUID - MILD ODOR Se a
SECTION IV — FIRE AND EXPLOSION HAZARD DATA
FLASH POINT 50 ee is menos used tT CC. eo ats . —— z =
EXTINGUISHING MEDLA
C02, ORY CHEMICAL, FOAM
WATER MAY BE INEFFECTIVE OUE TO FROTHING.
SPECAL ARE AGHTING PROCEDURES
UNUSUAL ARE ANO EXPLOSION HAZAAOS
FLAMMABLE SOLVENTS, HEAVIER THAN AIR.
PU terr-! —
SECTION V-HEALTH HAZARD DATA
TRKAESROLO UMIT VALLE ——
PEauissi8ts SxPSURE Lint Cm— MAC 500
HEADACHE OR DIZZINESS; MAY REMOVE OIL FROM SKIN] O™EAUMT CS
EFFECTS CF OVEREXKPOSURE — Canaiuons to Awa |
PRIMAAY ROUTES OF ENTAY tanaauon OX Shun Contact Oiner (specty! »
EMERGENCY ANNO MAST AO PROCEQURES REMOVE TO FRESH ALR.
- SECTION VI-REACTIVITY DATA
| CONGINONS 70 VOID sparks OR OPEN FLAMES. ; mae
ey | es |
| UNS7 ABLE |
INCIMPAT. BILITY (matenas ta avarc!
‘ __ STRONG OXIDIZERS. .
MATARO CUS SESS MPOsInON mncoucts: “MAY FORM CO2 - CO ON COMBUSTION.
mazancous = | A | CENGIFENS TO AvGIO”"<TRONG OXIDIZERS
POLYMERIZATICN | Wil NOTOCSUA | X94 8 =OPEN FLAMES
SECTION Vil-SPILL OR LEAK PROCEDURES
STEPS TS 3E TAKEN IN CASE MATERIAL IS AELEASED OA SAILLED
AVOID SPARKS OR OPEN FLAMES.
eminence coleiniinies DISPOSE OF IN ACCORDANCE WITH LOCAL, STATE, AND FEDERAL REGULAT!
CERCLA (Suserrunai REPORTAGLE QUANTITY lan toss ONE POUND = (CERCLA STATUTORY RQ)
ACRA mAZAROOUS WASTE NO. (40 CFA 261-23) D001
2.8
| © Anasyneat
VOLATILE ORGANIC SSMPOQUNO (VOC) (as pacaaged. minus water!
XE Theormess 2-8 gat syqai
SECTION VIll-SPECIAL PROTECTION INFORMATION
RESPIRATCRY PROTECZION isoecty Yee YES) =1F MAC OF 500 PPM IS EXCEEDED CCHARCCAL)=
LOCAL EXMAUST (Soeaty Aste: SPECA
60 FEET PER MINUTE| O™E
PROTECTIVE GLOVES (sceaty tvoe R . ANLINES9 FE PROTECTION (speaty tvoe! EYE SH Eto PER \
OTHEA PROTECT VE EQUIPMENT NONE PLANT REQUI REME!
VENTILATION
MECHANICAL (Generau (Soeaty Aate!
| SECTION i IX- SPECIAL PRECAUTIONS as
PRECAUTIONS 50 06 TAKEN Oe HAMAS SO Tene Alay BRON OPEN PLANES AND SPARKS
OTHER PRECAUNONS
ee
VAPORS HEAVIER THAN AIR. Pst
4
—
REV 9/13/89
DATE PREPARED: MAY 15, 1989 REV 4/4/90
NAME: sana MIKE PELLNY ---:
TITLE: RED TECHMYCAL DIRECTOR
SIGNATURE: - + \uls Ya 92.
- fue
Y
GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION >
MATERIAL SAFETY DATA SHEET
SECTION |
PRODUCT NAME OR NUMBER (as «t appears on lave!) | GM COMMON COOE me
Nox Rust X-170 19 A- 31st )
MANUFACTURER'S NAME EMERGENCY TELEPHONE NO. |
Daubert Chemical Company 312-496-7350
ADORESS (Number. Street. City. State ana Zip Code) | MANUFACTURER'S 0-U-N-S NO.
4700 S. Central Ave., Chicago, IL 60638
a... - g |
-<RZARDOUS MATERIAL DESCRIPTION, PROPER SHIPPING NAME. HAZARD CLASS. HAZARD IO NO. (49 CFR 172.101)
Flammable Liquid
ADDITIONAL HAZARD CLASSES (as applicable)
CHEMICAL FAMILY FORMULA
| wWax/Resin Dispersion |
seu
SECTION Ii — INGREDIENTS
(list all ingredients)
RE OE a es Used a 4 Crcinagen
1910(z) (specify)
8032-32-4 | 42| | VMsP Naptha NO
164742-61-6 <20| | Petroleum Wax NO
94742-16-1 k4o| Hydrocarbon Resin NO
5619-S6-1 |< 3 Barium Sulfonates NO
a F
7631-86-9 | T| | Silica NO
b4741597=3_and/or | Petroleum Oil (Severely solvent refined NO
<10 land/or severely hydro treated) |
|
|
SECTION Ill — PHYSICAL DATA
BOILING POINT SPECIFIC GRAVITY (H,0 =1)
230+¢ Cc 2 lo .8 és
Vv PRESSURE ye PERCENT VOLATILE BY VOLUME (%) | 46 * PERCENT SOLIO BY
@ *f “c Cmmie Cipsi «WEIGHT (%) 60
VAPOR DENSITY (AiR = 1)
EVAPORATION RATE Buty let)
1 Ace:
tate 0.45
SOLUBILITY IN WATER pH =
IL A
APPEARANCE AND OCOR . .
Tan co cored viscous liquid/soivent odor
—————
iS MATERIAL: LIQUID! Soup |
GAS __PASTE~ ER
|
j
SECTION IV — FIRE AND EXPLOSION HAZARD DATA
| FLASH POINT .\™riti- ) method used [rAMuaste LIMITS | LEL T UeL
x RE SE ae TCC aN 6.0
1 * ; P
SPECIAL FIRE FIGHTING PROCEDURES areat as petroleum solvent fire
£ .
Ort — ee
UNUSUAL FIRE ANO EXPLOSION HAZARCS es -
None ae
935
~ + id
SECTION V-HEALTH HAZARD DATA
| €FF=CTS OF OVEREXPOSUBE — Conditions to Avoid THRESHOLD LIMIT VALUE (> 200
1 Fre oF ERO eas rade Pon “ | Fomecescere Re ALE Cate
| Drowsiness OTHER Limit C=)
=
PRIMARY ROUTES OF ENTRY innatation Ye Skin Comact () Other (specify)
Y FIAST AiO PR 7 , ;
EMERGENCY AND PINST AD PROCEOURES Remove to fresh air. Seek medical attention.
SECTION VI- REACTIVITY DATA
UNSTABLE CONDITIONS TO AvVOIO
STABILITY
STABLE |X
INCOMPATIBILITY (materials to avoid) Oxidiz ing agents
HAZARDOUS MAY OCCUR CONDITIONS TO AVOIO
POLYMERIZATION | WILL NOT OCCUR Xx
SECTION VII-SPILL OR LEAK PROCEDURES
STEPS TO BE TAKEN IN CASE MATERIAL IS RELEASED OR SPILLEO
Eliminate all source of icnition.
Absorb into inert media and remove.
WASTE DISPOSAL METHOO
Treat as petroleum solvent /wax blend.
CERCLA (Superfund) REPORTABLE QUANTITY (in ibs)
RCRA HAZARDOUS WASTE NO. (40 CFR 261.33) DOO]
VOLATILE ORGANIC COMPOUND (VOC) (as packaged. minus water)
% Theoreticas 2-89 pga | 5 Anatyticst —___s/gat
SECTION Vill-SPECIAL PROTECTION INFORMATION
RESTUCH FRESROS SERVER TC-23c-50
Sufficient if not SPECIAL
SSntined to smatl a
VENTILATION [MECHANICAL (General) (Specify —~ OTHER
PROTECTIVE GLOVES (specify type). | EYE PROTECTION (specify wpe) Goggles
OTHER PROTECTIVE EQUIPMENT
SECTION IX-SPECIAL PRECAUTIONS
PRECAUTIONS TO BE TAKEN IN HANOLING AND STORING Store away from high heat and open
flames.
OTHER PRECAUTIONS
Satler agrees Not'to assert any Claim (other than a claim tor 6 patent Infringement)
against General Motors Corporation for any use or disclosure of any technical data
or information disclosed in connection with thus questionnaire.
PLEASE COMPLETE QUESTIONNAIRE Name (print)
AND RETURN TO: : oe
Signature _ 5
<>
‘See Chief Chemist
Oste
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.