Amicus Curiae Briefm — Southview Farm v. Concerned Area Residents for the Environment
Supreme Court brief1995
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
No. 94-1316
In The
Supreme Court of the United States
October Term, 1994
+
SOUTHVIEW FARM AND RICHARD H. POPP,
Petitioners,
Vv.
CONCERNED AREA RESIDENTS FOR
THE ENVIRONMENT, et al.,
Respondents.
+
On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari
To The United States Court Of Appeals
For The Second Circuit
¢
BRIEF OF NATIONAL PORK PRODUCERS
COUNCIL, AS AMICUS CURIAE, IN SUPPORT
OF DEFENDANT-PETITIONERS’ PETITION
FOR A WRIT OF CERTIORARI
*
JOHN D. CopeLAND
P.O. Box 10383
Des Moines, Iowa 50306
(515) 223-2600
Counsel for Amicus Curiae
National Pork Producers Council
COCKLE LAW BRIEF PRINTING CO., (800) 225-6964
OR CALL COLLECT (402) 342-2831
QUESTIONS PRESENTED
A. Whether a dairy farm that uses its animal
manure to fertilize its feed crop fields is a “concentrated
animal feeding operation” and thus a point source subject
to the permit requirements of the Clean Water Act?
B. Whether manure-spreading equipment or a
depression in a farm field, neither of which directly dis-
charges pollutants into navigable waters, is a point source
subject to the permit requirements of the Clean Water
Act?
C. Whether liquid manure washed off farm fields
by a rainstorm is an “agricultural stormwater discharge”
exempt from the Clean Water Act’s definition of point
source?
D. Whether the Second Circuit Court of Appeals
should have exercised restraint and referred this matter
to the appropriate state or federal regulatory agency to be
handled within the administrative framework established
and designed specifically to address circumstances such
as those presented in this case?
il
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CESSES FOURS occ ccccsdcnnvudnensdecees
I.
Il.
Ill.
AMICUS CURIAE’S INTEREST IN THE PRO-
C RRUED «0.00 ucs +gbdegnnchnwesadess caneeaee.
FACTUAL BAL RiGee 6 ic wtnietesescecess
ASR ATICSD 6 0-40 int ced ceuneguetadeeciens See
A. WHETHER A DAIRY FARM THAT USES
ITS ANIMAL MANURE TO FERTILIZE ITS
FEED CROP FIELDS IS A “CONCEN-
TRATED ANIMAL FEEDING OPERA-
TION” AND THUS A POINT SOURCE
SUBJECT TO THE PERMIT REQUIRE-
MENTS OF THE CLEAN WATER ACT?...
1. Southview Farm is not a “concentrated
animal feeding operation” under the
most reasoned interpretation of relevant
SRAMAIOTY THUG « one oc vneswesssacns
2. Regulation of nonpoint sources is prop-
erly within the purview of the state reg-
WENNEET GHED. 6 6.0n oka ace onntisnene
B. WHETHER MANURE-SPREADING EQUIP-
MENT OR A DEPRESSION IN A FARM
FIELD, NEITHER OF WHICH DIRECTLY
DISCHARGES POLLUTANTS INTO NAVI-
GABLE WATERS, IS A POINT SOURCE
SUBJECT TO THE PERMIT REQUIRE-
MENTS OF THE CLEAN WATER ACT?...
C. WHETHER LIQUID MANURE WASHED
OFF FARM FIELDS BY A RAINSTORM IS
AN “AGRICULTURAL STORMWATER DIS-
CHARGE” EXEMPT FROM THE CLEAN
WATER ACT’S DEFINITION OF POINT
DOPE 6-4 kx akns hdres er ers eres
12
16
18
A AIAN LER AIL
ill
TABLE OF CONTENTS - Continued
Page
D. WHETHER THE SECOND CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS SHOULD HAVE EXERCISED
RESTRAINT AND REFERRED THIS MATTER
TO THE APPROPRIATE STATE OR FEDERAL
REGULATORY AGENCY TO BE HANDLED
WITHIN THE ADMINISTRATIVE FRAME-
WORK ESTABLISHED AND DESIGNED
SPECIFICALLY TO ADDRESS CIRCUM-
STANCES SUCH AS THOSE PRESENTED IN
laa bin cab ei hee eeu ead wea 19
eis Oe aks vkG oan dba due kaw aweks 21
iV
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page
Case:
Kelly v. EPA, 15 F.3d 1100 (D.C. Cir. 1994)........ 18, 20
STATUTES AND REGULATIONS:
ee Se ER ee heen na KG he Re Aas Ree Khe ds eens 3
ee ack EE ho och eendnkwead seen eedanes-s 2
ee a Gs ck ok es we ke edna ebacueer ees 6
ee cased Cea cee uaaese ieee seg eeueees 6
PP ae ETE os ban sch Ce ean ce ees eket eens svaae 6
a es a 06 58 408 460 er haste eaes anes 4,5
bt TS ene yee re eee 9
bt oD Ee er re peer en re ree ers 9, 10
ke 2 RF | ee eee err etre Paar re oper rs 9
Oe a ees sa os Soka boca en pans es 7, & W, Tl, i
Pe er ery eee rere rT eT ee eT 17
Pree. 3. Pee. Par, OP BAe. BIG. onc k ee ceenccdvvsess 5
Se Sa, Ts SOE. ba occ tecdddvensensnunses 5, 13
MISCELLANEOUS:
Copeland et al., Environmental Laws Impacting New
TOUR TAOCRIOER COPETRTIONS 6 ones cv cccceseasconasegns 14
Guide to Environmental Quality in Pork Production,
(Published by the National Pork Producers
Council Environmental Committee, Fall, 1992)...... 2
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES - Continued
Page
S. Marberry, Appeals Court Calls Manure Spreading
a ‘Point Source,’ Feepsturrs, Oct. 24, 1994, at 1..... 14
Stevens, Some Thoughts on Judicial Restraint, 66
pomcamtemn: 177 CEMEe ok dives cos cpekcceesvnsn lk 19
S. Rep. No. 370, 95th Cong., 1st Sess. 8 (1977) ....... 5
U.S.D.A. Hocs anp Pics, Dec. 1, 1993 ....... eres re 1
U.S. EPA, Office of Water, Nonpoint Source Guid-
REE F UE 66s seh etches eee 6
I. AMICUS CURIAE’S INTEREST IN THE PROCEED-
ING
National Pork Producers Council (NPPC) is a non-
governmental, voluntary organization and is the largest
commodity organization in the nation with an identified
membership. NPPC is a grassroots producer organization
made up of 45 affiliate state pork producer associations
which have 90,000 members. NPPC is headquartered in
Des Moines, Iowa and has an office in Washington, D.C.
Its major purpose is the enhancement of the quality,
production, distribution, and sale of pork and pork prod-
ucts. NPPC has an extensive environmental program that
funds environmental research, conducts educational
activities for producers, promotes science-based environ-
mental policies, and helps producers confront challenges
related to environmental law.
Pork production in the U.S. has risen steadily over
the last 40 years. Pork has annual gross sales of over $11
billion, and approximately 236,000 pork producers raise
17 billion pounds of pork. The ten leading states in hog
and pig inventory are Iowa, North Carolina, Illinois, Min-
nesota, Nebraska, Indiana, Missouri, South Dakota, Ohio,
and Kansas. Ninety-three million head were commer-
cially slaughtered in 1993 with the state of New York
ranked 31st in annual marketings of hogs in that year,
with 112,000 head. In 1993 the number of hog operations
in the U.S. totalled 235,840.!
NPPC is vitally involved in advancing pork produc-
tion interests. NPPC is actively involved in legislation
' U.S. Dep’t or AGric., Hocs & Pics (1993).
which affects hog producers nationally and closely moni-
tors federal and state laws and regulations, including
those related to environmental regulation.
NPPC’s Environmental Committee addresses key
environmental issues facing the modern pork production
facility. The Council’s Science Advisory Task Force
advises pork producers nationwide about the basic con-
siderations involved in proper environmental manage-
ment of an operation including manure application,
water quality protection, and regulatory compliance.? In
addition, NPPC has funded a thorough state-by-state
examination of laws and regulations involving environ-
mental aspects of hog production. This educational pro-
ject is being carried out by the National Center for
Agricultural Law Research and Information.
NPPC therefore has a vital interest in the subject
matter involved in this litigation. NPPC is actively
involved in advising its membership of the state and
federal laws affecting their operations and is equally
involved in representing member interests when those
laws and regulations are considered and passed. NPPC’s
amicus brief provides the court with important informa-
tion regarding the laws and regulations which apply in
the Southview case and how the outcome of this case will!
affect hog producers nationwide.
* The first joint publication of Committee and Task Force
was the Guide to Environmental Quality in Pork Production (Fall
1992).
The description of Southview’s dairy operation is not
unlike the operations of countless hog producers nation-
wide. The activity of gathering and confining animals
and managing the attendant manure from those opera-
tions by separation, storage, and eventual land applica-
tion is a common practice within the agriculture sector.
Approximately 85% of hogs are raised in confinement
where manure is collected and stored for later treatment
and/or utilization. The nature of Southview’s operation
intricately ties the facts of this case to the interests repre-
sented by NPPC and many other agricultural producers
in the country.
Il. FACTUAL BACKGROUND
The brief filed by Southview Farm with its Petition
for Writ of Certiorari contains a detailed statement of
facts. Therefore, only the following summary of facts is
set forth in this Amicus Brief.
Southview Farm operates a 2,200 head dairy farm in
rural Wyoming County, New York. Within that county,
dairy farming is the largest industry. Southview Farm's
operation involves a manure separation and storage sys-
tem and the spreading of manure on crop lands adjacent
to the animal confinement area. The action against South-
view Farm was brought as a “citizen’s suit” under the
Federal Water Pollution Control Act, renamed as the
Clean Water Act (CWA).3 The citizen's suit brought
against Southview Farm alleged violations of the CWA:
specifically Section 301(a) which prohibits the discharge
* 33 U.S.C. §§ 1251 et seq.
of pollutants. The Plaintiffs alleged violations of these
provisions through leakage of manure from Southview
Farm’s storage lagoon into local surface waters and
ground waters and from there into the Genesee River. In
addition, Plaintiffs alleged that on several occasions
Southview Farm sprayed liquid manure onto land in such
quantities that it ran into discrete rivulets, into drainage
ditches, and into adjacent surface waters that tributary
into the Genesee River, and that Southview Farm sprayed
liquid manure directly into such drainage ditches.
Ill. ARGUMENTS
A. WHETHER A DAIRY FARM THAT USES ITS
ANIMAL MANURE TO FERTILIZE ITS FEED
CROP FIELDS IS A “CONCENTRATED ANI-
MAL FEEDING OPERATION” AND THUS A
POINT SOURCE SUBJECT TO THE PERMIT
REQUIREMENTS OF THE CLEAN WATER
ACT?
1. Southview Farm is not a “concentrated
animal feeding operation” under the most
reasoned interpretation of relevant statu-
tory language.
In 1955, Congress first enacted legislation to control
the polluting of the waters of the United States.4+ Unfor-
tunately, the legislation did little to abate the amount of
pollutants pumped, washed, or dumped into our national
waters. Responding to the public demand for more strin-
gent water quality controls, Congress in 1972 passed
what was to become known as the Clean Water Act
4 42 U.S.C. §§ 7401 et seg. (West 1955).
(CWA).° In enacting the 1972 CWA, Congress more thor-
oughly addressed the long term national goal of eliminat-
ing pollutants from United States waters in order to
achieve and maintain the biological integrity of receiving
waters and the interim goal of assuring that the nation’s
waters would at least support fish, wildlife, and sporting
activities, and provide safe drinking water.®
Congress embodied in the CWA a dual regulatory
system for safeguarding the nation’s waters from pollu-
tion by expressly giving the federal government and state
governments regulatory authority over different sources
of pollution. In passing the 1972 legislation, “Congress
made a clear and precise distinction between point
sources, which would be subject to federal regulation, and
nonpoint sources, control of which was specifically
reserved to State and local governments.”” In addition
when Congress enacted the 1972 Amendments it
thoughtfully considered how to regulate agricultural
activities and, with the exception of concentrated animal
feeding operations (CAFOs), Congress chose to regulate
agricultural activities under the nonpoint source control
provisions of section 208.8
Section 208 requires each state to develop manage-
ment plans to address significant water problems. The
management plans must assess both point source and
> Id.
© 133 Cong. Reg. § 1691-01 (remarks of Leon G. Billings).
7 S. Rep. No. 370, 95th Cong., 1st Sess. 8 (1977).
5 Pub. L. No. 92-500, Section 208(b)(2)(f), 86 Stat. 816, 841,
codified as amended at 33 U.S.C. § 1288(b)(2)(f).
nonpoint source problems. Return flows from irrigated
land, runoff from manure disposal, and runoff from land
used for livestock are to be covered in the management
plans. Section 208 also requires states to specify feasible
measures for controlling nonpoint source agricultural
pollution.’
Congress defined point sources of pollution as pollu-
tion originating from a “discernable, confined and dis-
crete conveyance.”!° This definition, with the exception
of the inclusion of a CAFO, is oriented toward industrial
and municipal polluters, not agricultural operations.
Point source polluters are regulated by mandated tech-
nology-based standards and the requirement that they
obtain a National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System
(NPDES) permit from EPA prior to making discharges.!!
Congress has not chosen to specifically define what is
meant by the term “nonpoint.” However, the Environ-
mental Protection Agency, which has been delegated the
authority to implement and enforce the point source pro-
visions of the CWA, has stated that “nonpoint source
pollution does not result from a discharge at a specific,
single location (such as a single pipe) but generally
results from land runoff, precipitation, atmospheric depo-
sition, or percolation.” !?
9 Id., see also 33 U.S.C. § 1329. New York has adopted such a
program and the program has been approved by the EPA.
10 33 U.S.C. § 1362(14).
1! 33 U.S.C. § 1342.
12, U.S. EPA, Office of Water, Nonpoint Source Guidance 3
(1987).
In the 1972 CWA, Congress went to great lengths to
ensure that most agricultural activities would be classed
as nonpoint sources of pollution and thereby subject pri-
marily to state regulation. Congress did specifically
choose to regulate one limited area of agricultural activity
as a point source of pollution, Concentrated Animal Feed-
ing Operations (CAFOs). Although Congress did not
define a CAFO, CAFO is defined in the Code of Federal
Regulations for the EPA at Section 122.23(b)(3) as follows:
“Concentrated animal feeding operation” means
an “animal feeding operation” which meets the
criteria in Appendix B of this part, or which the
Director designates under paragraph (c) of this
section. !3
An agricultural livestock operation is classified as a
CAFO only if it is an “animal feeding operation” (AFO)
and the operation exceeds the minimum livestock
requirements of Appendix B.!4
An “animal feeding operation” is:
. a lot or facility (emphasis added) (other than
an aquatic animal production facility) where the
following conditions are met:
(1) Animals (other than aquatic animals)
have been, are or will be stabled or confined
and fed or maintained for a total of 45 days
Or more in any 12 month period, and
13 40 C.F.R. 122.23(b).
'* Federal regulations set forth the minimum livestock
requirement for slaughter and feeder cattle, dairy cattle, swine,
horses, turkeys, laying hens or broilers, ducks and other animal
units. See 40 C.F.R. § 122.23, Appendix B to Part 122, (a) and (b).
(2) crops, vegetation forage growth, or
post-harvest residues are not sustained in
the normal growing season over any por-
tion of the lot or facility.!5
In holding Southview Farm to be a CAFO, and
thereby a point source because it is an animal feeding
operation and “no crops ... were sustained . . . over any
portion of the lot,” the Second Circuit Court of Appeals
misconstrued the definition of an animal feeding opera-
tion. The Court of Appeals stated that the terms lot or
facility, since undefined by the regulations, should be
defined by the term “feedlot” found in 40 C.F.R.
412.10(b). Feedlot is defined as a concentrated, confined
animal growing operation for meat, milk, or egg produc-
tion, or stabling, in pens or houses wherein the animals
or poultry are fed at the place of confinement and crop or
forage growth or production is not sustained in the area of
confinement. An animal feeding operation is defined dif-
ferently, which implies that, although some animal feed-
ing operations may be feedlots, not all of these will be
defined as feedlots. The key difference in the definitions
lies in the statement that an animal feeding operation
does not include those operations which sustain crops,
vegetation or post harvest residues over any portion of the
lot or facility. Only feedlots require crops in the specific
area of confinement to avoid being classified as CAFOs.
The EPA intended animal feeding operations to be
subject to a broader definition by making the standard
more inclusive. Instead of limiting the vegetative forage
growth or crops to the area of confinement, as in the
15 40 C.F.R. 122.23(b)(1).
feedlot situation, the EPA used the terms lot or facility.
EPA Clean Air Act (CAA) regulations have traditionally
defined facility in a much broader manner. For example,
the EPA has defined facility as “all buildings, structures
and operations on one contiguous site,” in the air pro-
grams regulations (emphasis added).!© In addition, EPA
defines building, structure, facility, or installation as:
all of the pollutant-emitting activities which
belong to the same industrial grouping, are
located on one or more contiguous or adjacent
properties, and are under the control of the
Same person (or persons under common con-
| ee
EPA also has a third definition of facility which is
similar to those definitions already discussed:
“Facility” means any building, plant, installa-
tion, structure, mine, vessel or other floating
craft, location or site of operations owned,
leased, or supervised by an applicant, contrac-
tor, grantee, or borrower to be used in the per-
formance of a contract, grant, or loan. Where
location or site of operations contains or
includes more than one building, plant, installa-
tion, or structure, the entire location or site shall
be deemed to be a facility... . 18
16 40 C.F.R. 61.91(b) (1994) (section contains definitions
relating to national emission standards for emissions of radio-
nuclides other than radon from Department of Energy facili-
ties).
'7 40 C.F.R. 51.165(a)(1)(ii) (1994) (permit requirements for
air programs and requirements for preparation, adoption, and
submittal of implementation plans).
18 40 C.F.R. 15.4 (1994).
10
In its attempt to determine the meaning of a term
undefined in the applicable statute or regulation, the
court erred in not first referring to the definition of the
same term in similar statutory or regulatory language. The
court instead took the suggestion of the United States
Department of Justice and equated the language “lot or
facility” to the term “feedlot” and proceeded in its anal-
ysis from that point. By doing so the court ignored the
fact that the term “facility”, the exact term in the regula-
tion at issue, is defined in similar regulations under the
Clean Air Act (CAA) at 40 C.F.R. 51.165.
If the Second Circuit Court of Appeals had referred
to the facility definitions provided in the CAA, the court
would have had no choice but to conclude that South-
view Farm is not an animal feeding operation or a feedlot
as defined in the CWA. The Southview Farm facility
includes the confinement facility as well as the contig-
uous or adjacent land in the area of confinement on
which crops or forage are grown. The manure is applied
to the adjacent crop or forage land and the entire opera-
tion is under the control of the same person (Southview
Farm).
The inclusion of the language “lot or facility” in 40
C.F.R. 122.23(b)(ii) clearly requires a broader reading of
the regulation than that given by the Second Circuit
Court of Appeals. Obviously, the EPA has expressed a
general intent to consider an entire operation to include
the cropland that is contiguous to the confinement facili-
ties, as in this case.
By reading and defining the terms of the regulation
so narrowly, the court has in effect rendered the “crop/
11
vegetative growth” exception, that had been specifically
drafted into the definition of an AFO, a nullity. In doing
so, the court has included virtually every livestock farm
operation within the definition of an AFO; thereby poten-
tially subjecting all such operations to regulation as a
CAFO point source with the determinative factor being
the number of animals within the operation. If the court
is correct, the exception for livestock operations would
not have been necessary and would never have been
drafted into the definition of an AFO in 40 C.F.R.
122.23(b)(ii).
Additionally, if the EPA had intended the term “feed-
lot” to be included in the definition of an AFO
would have used the term “feedlot” rather than t!
guage “lot or facility.” The term “feedlot” itss
more restricted and confined area that is t
particular purpose than the language
suggests. x
The second method by which an ag:
stock operation may be classified as
EPA director may on a case-by-case deter
nate an agricultural livestock operation as
director may do so only after determining that
ation is a significant contributor (emphasis added
lution to the waters of the United States.”!%
By providing an additional method of regulating
agricultural livestock operations as CAFOs, the regula-
tions specifically provide the EPA with a means by which
to regulate operations like Southview Farm as point
19 40 C.ER. 122.23(c).
12
sources if the circumstance so warrants. This is further
proof that CAFO facilities such as Southview Farm were
never intended to be regulated as point sources under the
definition in 40 C.F.R. 122.23. In addition, the EPA has not
chosen to regulate Southview by this method.
2. Regulation of nonpoint sources is properly
within the purview of the state regulatory
agency.
Under the Clean Water Act, point sources of pollu-
tion are regulated and are required to obtain a permit,
either through the state or federal permitting scheme.
New York has obtained permission from the EPA to
implement and control its own permitting scheme for
point sources of pollution. As a result, New York has
determined that an agricultural operation which includes
the raising of livestock and the growing of crops on a
single lot or facility is not an “animal feeding operation”
and therefore is not a “concentrated animal feeding oper-
ation.”
Congressional debate over the CWA specifically con-
tains references to the proper role of the states in regulat-
ing potential polluters. In 1987, President Reagan vetoed
the 1987 amendments to the CWA because he feared that
the amendments would give the Federal Government too
much authority over farming practices. In successfully
urging the Senate to join the House to override the Presi-
dent’s veto, Senator John Chaffee of Rhode Island point-
edly stressed that nonpoint sources of pollution would
still be left to state control:
13
... the President states in his veto message that
when we get into the nonpoint pollution control
section of this bill, that this is Federal land use
planning. There is a mistake in the interpreta-
tion that was given to the President on this. It
just is not Federal land planning.
The nonpoint provisions in the bill were
carefully crafted to avoid that. The primary role
of the Federal Government in the nonpoint pro-
gram, in other words, controling [sic] pollution
from streets and runoff of fertilizers from the
farms, the primary role of the Federal Govern-
ment is to provide financial assistance to the
States which are given the lead in developing
their own programs. It is not Big Brother from
Washington telling them how to do this. The
States do this. We give them some money to
help them. We do not mandate it. Farmers are
not required to seek permission from the Fed-
eral Government to carry out their farming
practices.
We have been around long enough to know
that is a loser. That would kill the bill. Do you
think the Senators from Montana or Maine or
any of the States with large agricultural prac-
tices would vote for a measure like that? Of
course they would not.
So the administration’s arguments on that
are really red herrings.
This is a strong environmental bill, it is a
fiscally responsible bill, and it lives up to our
national goal of making the Nation’s waters
fishable and swimmable.”°
20 133 Cong. Rec. § 1691-01.
14
The State of New York has established an extensive
regulatory scheme to control both point and nonpoint
source pollution. New York obtained EPA approval to run
its state NPDES program on October 28, 1975 and estab-
lished a program implementing the CWA permitting
(NPDES) programs.?! New York has passed state laws
and adopted state regulations to require all point sources
within the state to obtain a State Pollution Discharge
Elimination System (SPDES) permit.2? New York has
always used the SPDES system for industries, but has
generally considered agricultural operations to be exempt
from permitting requirements. New York interpreted the
terms “lot” or “facility” to include structures where live-
stock were housed and adjacent cropland was used for
animal manure application. If an operation caused envi-
ronmental damage, the state issued a cease and desist
order requiring them to comply with the order.?3
New York’s interpretation is permissible in that the
EPA has never attempted to correct the state’s interpreta-
tion regarding agriculture, nor has the EPA criticized any
21 See JoHN D. Copecanp et At., Environmental Laws Impacting
New York Livestock Operations (1995) (Published by the National
Center for Agricultural Law Research and Information, 147
Waterman Hall, University of Arkansas School of Law, Fayet-
teville, AR 72701).
22 The SPDES is the New York State version of the National
Pollution Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit.
23 Steve Marberry, Appeals Court Calls Manure Spreading a
‘Point Source,’ Feepsturrs, Oct. 24, 1994, at 1. See also Joun D.
CopeLAND ET AL., Environmental Laws Impacting New York Livestock
Operations (1995) (Published by the National Center for Agri-
cultural Law Research and Information, 147 Waterman Hall,
University of Arkansas School of Law, Fayetteville, AR 72701).
15
other aspects of New York’s environmental program. In
the past, EPA has exercised authority over those pro-
grams that were deemed to be ineffective in curbing
water pollution. One of the most recent examples is the
establishment, through federal regulatory means, of a
General Permit for four of the five states in Region VI of
the United States.24 This General Permit establishes a
mechanism by which CAFOs in those states may be cov-
ered under a federal NPDES General Permit, determines
the types of discharges allowed from those operations,
and establishes requirements for land application of
waste.
The court, through the encouragement of the EPA,
has done for the EPA that which the EPA could not do
given the facts of the case; i.e., require Southview Farm to
have a permit based on a finding that it was a CAFO. If
the facts had warranted it, the EPA had the authority to
declare Southview Farm a point source, whether or not it
fell under the definition of a CAFO, if Southview Farm
was a “significant contributor” to pollution. The “signifi-
cant contributor” provision, which is a feature of both the
federal regulatory definition of AFO/CAFO and the New
York state program, allows the regulatory authority to
regulate an operation as if it were a point source polluter
even though the operation may not come under the defi-
nition of a CAFO.
Southview Farm, however, was not declared a point
source by the EPA or the state regulatory authority, even
24 The four states covered under the Region VI General
Permit are Louisiana, New Mexico, Oklahoma, and Texas.
16
after complaints had been received and investigated
regarding Southview Farm’s operations. Some of these
complaints were made by the members of the group
which later became the plaintiffs in this case. Southview
Farm’s manure handling practices were thoroughly
investigated and it was determined that Southview Farm
did not need to obtain a permit because the operation
was not a point source under the state’s CAFO definition.
Also, the facts did not warrant identifying Southview
Farm as a “significant contributor” to pollution.
Clearly, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals erred in
declaring Southview Farm to be subject to the CAFO
permitting requirements of the CWA.
B. WHETHER MANURE-SPREADING EQUIP-
MENT OR A DEPRESSION IN A FARM
FIELD, NEITHER OF WHICH DIRECTLY
DISCHARGES POLLUTANTS INTO NAVI-
GABLE WATERS, IS A POINT SOURCE SUB-
JECT TO THE PERMIT REQUIREMENTS OF
THE CLEAN WATER ACT?
The Second Circuit Court of Appeals also erred in
holding Southview Farm’s manure spreading equipment
to be a point source. To sustain a ruling that land applica-
tion vehicles are point sources would take away the dis-
tinction between nonpoint and point sources. Land
application of animal manure is a traditional nonpoint
source and to hold that the land application vehicles are
point sources would create no viable alternative for get-
ting liquid manure onto fields. If this aspect of land
application is a point source, then it is virtually impossi-
ble to use land application as a method for disposing of
17
manure. However, almost all states encourage the use of
land application by operations in order to cut down on
the disposal problems of the liquid waste. Using land
application achieves this result and creates an inexpen-
sive and less chemical dependent method of fertilization.
In fact, the EPA Region VI General Permit authorizes the
use of land application of waste generated by CAFOs
when done so in accordance with recognized practices of
good agricultural management.*> The EPA admits that the
land application of waste is a normal “agricultural prac-
tice” and when “properly applied, animal wastes provide
no more environmental risk than chemical fertilizers
which would be used on the same land”.?6
To hold that the land application of animal manure is
a point source as a result of the use of vehicles to apply
the waste would result in complete chaos in major live-
stock producing states, especially when those states
attempt to find new methods of waste disposal. To hold
that a roving piece of equipment used in the application
of waste to the land is a point source takes chaos into
pandemonium in that it raises the issue as to whether
other moving vehicles used in agricultural operations can
also be considered point sources.
If the Second Circuit Court’s ruling is allowed to
stand, the costs to producers and consumers could dra-
matically escalate. The EPA estimates there are only 6,000
potential animal feeding operations nationwide. But a
pork industry study found over 30,000 operations with
25 58 Fed. Reg. 7610, 7629 (Feb. 8, 1993).
26 Id., at 7622 (Feb. 8, 1993).
18
more than 1,000 head of swine. Since almost all of these
operations use land application as a form of manure
utilization and/or treatment, the number of permittees
will skyrocket. Those states which currently run federally
approved water quality permitting programs will be
forced to regulate even the smallest of operations as point
sources. Many agricultural operations may be forced out
of business if they are unable to find alternate sources of
disposing of animal manure or cannot bear the costs
associated with using alternate disposal methods, such as
paying for the transportation of the manure to approved
offsite places of disposal. The court’s ruling could also
affect the availability of agricultural credit by further
worsening an already difficult situation. Lenders will
have to worry about their own CWA liability if virtually
all livestock operations, which use the traditional means
of applying animal manure to adjacent crop or forage
land, are declared to be CAFOs. See Kelly v. EPA, 15 F.3d
1100 (D.C. Cir. 1994) (holding that lenders may be liable
under CERCLA).
C. WHETHER LIQUID MANURE WASHED OFF
FARM FIELDS BY A RAINSTORM IS AN
“AGRICULTURAL STORMWATER DIS-
CHARGE” EXEMPT FROM THE CLEAN
WATER ACT’S DEFINITION OF POINT
SOURCE?
The question of what Congress intended by exempt-
ing agricultural stormwater discharges from the defini-
tion of a point source has been adequately argued in the
Petition for Writ of Certiorari submitted by Petitioners.
NPPC agrees and incorporates the argument contained
19
on pages 15 through 18 of Petitioners’ brief under the
heading “Congress Expressly Exempted Agricultural
Stormwater Discharges From the Definition of Point
Source.”
D. WHETHER THE SECOND CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS SHOULD HAVE EXERCISED
RESTRAINT AND REFERRED THIS MAT-
TER TO THE APPROPRIATE STATE OR FED-
ERAL REGULATORY AGENCY TO BE
HANDLED WITHIN THE ADMINISTRATIVE
FRAMEWORK ESTABLISHED AND
DESIGNED SPECIFICALLY TO ADDRESS
CIRCUMSTANCES SUCH AS THOSE PRE-
SENTED IN THIS CASE?
In the Southview Farm case the Second Circuit would
have better served the interests of all parties concerned
by subscribing to the age old doctrine of judicial restraint
which teaches “that patience in the judicial resolution of
conflicts may sometimes produce the most desirable
result.”27 As explained in this amicus, the Second Circuit
erroneously classified Southview Farm as a point source
subject to the CAFO provisions of the CWA. The court
totally ignored the extensive regulatory scheme for both
point and nonpoint sources established by the State of
New York with the blessing of the EPA. The court also
ignored the state and federal statutory and regulatory
provisions which would have permitted action against
27 John P. Stevens, Some Thoughts on Judicial Restraint, 66
Jupicature 177, 183 (1982).
20
Southview Farm if the facts had established Southview to
be a “significant contributor” to pollution.
By deferring this matter to state regulators, the court
could have avoided the potential chaos its ruling may
create in agricultural production methods, in the state
and federal environmental regulation of agriculture, and
agricultural lending. By acting as it did, the court has
called into question the heretofore accepted agricultural
practices of thousands of farmers in dozens of states, the
existing agricultural regulatory system of no less than 20
states and the Federal Government, and has further tight-
ened the purse strings of the already weary agricultural
lenders who have an eye towards the previously men-
tioned Kelly case.
Unless the Supreme Court grants certiorari the ruling
of the Second Circuit Court of Appeals will have an
unwarranted and legally indefensible negative nation-
wide impact on livestock operations.
+
21
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, the Petition for Writ of
Certiorari filed by petitioner Southview Farm should be
granted.
Respectfully submitted,
JoHN D. CopeELAND
P.O. Box 10383
Des Moines, Iowa 50306
(515) 223-2600
Counsel for Amicus Curiae
National Pork Producers
Council
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.