Appendix — Gellert v. United States District Court

Supreme Court brief1995

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

NO. 94-1015

IN THE

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNI

OCTOBER TERM 1994

DANIEL G. GELLERT,

Petitioner

V.

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA,

Respondent

ON PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THE ELEVENTH CIRCUIT

APPENDIX TO RESPONSE BRIEF

In pro se by:

Daniel G. Gellert

P. O. Box 320370

Cocoa Beach, FL 32932

(407) 783-9412

TABLE OF CONTENTS

APPENDIX 1

Miami Herald Newspaper September, 1994 Article

APPENDIX 2

Petitioner's Motion for Protective Order

APPENDIX 3

U.S. Bankruptcy Court Decision

APPENDIX 4

Magistrate Report & Reommendation

APPENDIX 5

Order of Dismissal

APPENDIX 6 |

Motion to Strike Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgement

APPENDIX 7

Letter of Agreement, Document 102

APPENDIX 8

Assignment and Authorization for Voluntary Check Off

of Association Dues 12-1-7]

APPENDIX 9

Assignment and Authorization for Voluntary Check Off of

Association Dues or Contract Maintenance Fees 6-1-85

APPENDIX 10

Assignment and Authorization for Voluntary Check Off of

Association Dues or Contract Maintenance Fees 9-17-85

APPENDIX 11

ALPA Letter dated 1-21-86

APPENDIX 12

Letter to ALPA dated 1-23-86

APPENDIX 13

ALPA Letter dated 4-14-86

APPENDIX 14

ALPA Letter dated 5-21-86

APPENDIX 15

ALPA Letter dated 7-23-86

APPENDIX 16

Letter to ALPA dated 10-17-86

APPENDIX 17

ALPA Letter dated 4-6-89

APPENDIX 18

PBGC Memorandum dated 3-25-91

APPENDIX 19

PBGC Letter dated 5-7-92

APPENDIX 20

Criminal Judgement Entered Against Eastern Airlines, Inc.

Appendix 1

Retrials are granted

in 14 criminal cases

The judge was under investigation

By DAVID LYONS

Herald Staff Writer

In a decision that could cost

taxpayers millions, a federal

judge has ordercd 14 Miami

criminal cases retried, including

a high-profile bank fraud prosc-

cution, because a South Florida

judge did not recuse himself

while he was under government

scrutiny.

The most notable of the cases

includes the fraud convictions of

former Republic National Bank

Presidtnt Fred de la Mata and

fellow executives Manuel A.

Calas and Oscar Castilla, aad

businessman Ennque Fernandez.

That trial, a complicated bank

fraud case, lasted 2 ‘2 months.

Another lengthy case involved

Isrucl Abel, a U.S. citizen con-

victed of drug trafficking aflur he

was apprehended in Costa Rica,

which later protested his extradi-

Lion,

The judicial a cen-

ters on U.S. District Judge kK.

> *ichael Moore, a Coral Cables

resident who was appointcd to

the bench after a stint as director

of the U.S. Marshals Service.

Between 1992 and early this

yee prosecutors in Brooklyn,

N.Y., investigated whether

Moore <a ang improper gratu-

ities while he headed the Mar-

shals Service. Ultimately, the

government dropped its investi-

gation and determined that no

criniinal charges should be

brought.

But after hearing about the

probe, defense lawyers in 14

cases he oversaw argued that the

judge should have told them

about his situation before their

trials started and offered to

recuse himself,

Their reason: The judge might

have favored the government's

ip ee during court proccedings

in the hopes of getting a break in

his own case.

Alter reviewing the matter for

several months, U.S. Distnct

Judge William C. O’Kelley of

Atlanta agreed with the defense

lawyers. He granted new trials for

their clients.

“Quite simply, and quite uni-

versally, recusal is required

whenever impartiality might rea-

sonably be questioned,” O'Kel-

Ky wrote in an order released

onday but dated Sept. 9.

Moore was unavailable for

comment, a secretary said. -

U.S. Attorney Kendall Coffey,

whose office faces the possibility

of spending millions to retry the

Cases, as well as the task of recall-

ing countless witnesses, said

Monday that his staff is review-

ing its Options.

“It could range from seeking

reconsideration from Judge

O'Kelley, to seeking appcliate

review,” Coffey said. No new

trial dates had been set.

- SOE ETN

eer ery 2

Appendix 2

UNITED STATES COURT oP APPEALS

ELEVENTH CIRCUIT

CASE NO, 93-4928

IN RE:

DANIEL G, GELLERT,

Petitioner.

On Petition for Writ of Mandamus to the

United States District Court for the

Southern District of Florida

PETITIONER'S MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER

Petitioner, in Pro s@, moves this Court for a protective Order

from the time of receipt of this Motion, until July 5, 1994,

Petitioner will be out of this jurisdiction during that period,

as a result of the unsolved murder of Petitioner's daughter

on March 20, 1994, the need for Security considerations of

Petitioner's immediate family requires this absence to undis-

Closed location,

Petitioner has a Suggested Inbanc Rehearing pending before this

Court, and Petitioner Prays for protective relief until July

5, 1994, @s to any time for response to any order under the

federal or loca) rules in this instant cause, as Petitioner

would file for Certiorari with the Supreme Court in the 90 day

period,

Respectfully submitted,

P.O. 320370 Cocoa Beach, Fl. 32932

(407) 783-9412

Appendix 2

Te TTY,

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

I HEREBY CERTIFY that a true and correct copy of the

foregoing was sent by mail this 5 day of May

1994, to:

Robert T. Kofman & Gary Green

2200 Museum Tower

150 West Flagler St.

Miami, Fl. 33130

Mark Hicks

Suite 2402 New World Tower

100 North Biscayne Blvd.

Miami, Fl. 33132

Maurice J. Baumgarten

Suite 3300 International Place

100 Southeast Second St.

Miami, Fl. 33131

Mark Blank

Pension Benefit Guaranty Corp.

K Street, N.W.

Washington, D.C,

. _

AES 4 OA

K. Michael Moore

U.S. District Court

301 N. Miami Ave.

Miami, Fl. 33128

sateiadinte iB ost aides 2S ala es ended te

\si

DANIEL G, GELLERT

P.O. 320370

Cocoa Beach, Fl. 32932

(407) 783-9412

Appendix 3

UNITED STATES BANKRUPTCY COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK

In the Matter

of

IONOSPHERE/EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

Debtors

Case No. 89 B 10448

November 15, 1994

United States Custom House

One Bowling Green

New York, New York 10004

Hearing on Trustee’s 3rd omnibus objections to em-

ployee claims (individual employees claims and

non-employee prepetition litigation claims).

BEFORE:

HON. BURTON R. LIFLAND,

Bankruptcy Judge

Appendix 3

IONOSPHERE/EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

APPEARANCES:

VERNER, LIIPFERT, BERNHARD, McPHERSON

AND HAND, CHARTERED

Special Counsel to Trustee

600 Travis

2600 Texas Commerce Tower

Houston, Texas

BY: JOHN P. CAMPBELL, ESQ., of Counsel

and

BY: ANNE M. FERAZZAI, ESQ., of Counsel

IONOSPHERE/EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

Appendix 3

PROCEEDINGS

MR. CAMPBELL: We will now turn to the matter of

Mr. Gellert. Mr. Gellert is here and invite him to come

forward at this time.

MR. GELLERT: I was called from Houston and I was

told I would receive some documents by Fed Ex last Friday,

which I did not receive. I left for work on Saturday but the

gentleman just showed me a document. I didn’t have time

to study it. But I would like to put into evidence the exhibit,

Summary Judgement motion and the response from East-

ern and two other Court documents.

MR. CAMPBELL: May | suggest for the record, since

we are the objecting party, we outline where we are going

and then it will be his turn to put those in.

THE COURT: Yes, you are making the motion. Go

ahead.

MR. CAMPBELL: | will begin.

What we have in the matter of Mr. Gellertis actually

two lawsuits that are on file elsewhere. We have a lawsuit

Appendix 3

on page 35 of the objection. It’s described as being in the

Southern District of Florida, and it’s case number 881114.

This was case that is basically a challenge to Mr.

Gellert’s discharge, which occurred in the mid-80’s. Mr.

Gellert wasa pilot. He was terminated. He filed a grievance

pursuant to the ALPA contract. It went to a proceeding

before the Pilot System Board of Adjustment, and Mr.

Gellert did not prevail.

He filed this suit in the Southern District of Florida

claiming that Eastern violated the Railway Labor Act when

it allegedly refused to withhold dues money and pay it over

to ALPA which caused his termination because the contract

required him to pay dues.

The District Court in Florida dismissed that case and

it was appealed to the 1 Ith Circuit where the stay is in effect

and the matter is stayed up there.

Throughout this rather exhaustive litigation Mr.

Gellert has now shown that this particular lawsuit has any

merit. The law is quite clear that the discharge of an

employee, such as a pilot covered by the Railway Labor Act

Appendix 3

under a union contract is a minor dispute and that the

federal District Court lacked jurisdiction to review dis-

charges that are in fact minor disputes.

The choice made by Congress years and years,

decades and decades ago in the case where carriers, rail-

roads, and airlines, these carriers and their unions would

be required to have the equivalent of System Boards, have

a mandatory arbitration procedure, and the complaints

were to be washed through that system, and that was the

final and binding resolution of minor disputes.

And so minor disputes, as this classically is, are not

subject to review in the Federal District Court, and for that

reason we Say that the lawsuit in Florida, the first lawsuit

we mentioned, has no merit, and therefore the claim should

be disallowed and the lawsuit’s value should be submitted

at zero.

With respect to another lawsuit, this one was couched

a bit differently. It is a lawsuit which in essence is a

challenge toits termination, again in a different guise. This

is the lawsuit that the response filed to this instant

— rt _

Appendix 3

proceeding says that there is a $12 million default judge-

ment against Eastern, but there is in fact no such default.

And on that point I would proffer the testimony of Maurice

Baumgarten, who is here today, a former Eastern in-house

lawyer, who is now in private practice. But one of his

charges is to continue representing the estate in the Gellert

litigation, and he would testify there is in fact no default as

to these Debtors, $12 million or any other amount.

This lawsuit is Florida, the second lawsuit, page 13

of the reply and page 36 of the original objection, is merely

another challenge to the termination that occurred in 1986.

The same law applies; thatis, that the discharge was a minor

dispute, went toa System Board of Adjustment. He had his

bite at the apple. That was his exclusive remedy. And that’s

that.

So there is no merit to that lawsuit, and so the value

of that lawsuit should be estimated at zero. To the extent

the proof of Claim is on file for the lawsuit, why, it should

be disallowed.

MR. GELLERT: Unfortunately, the gentleman really

es

|

Appendix 3

misrepresents the facts.

THE COURT: Before we go further, there is an offer

of testimony. The witness is available. Do you want to

examine the witness? ’

MR. GELLERT: I would like to respond to his

statement first.

THE COURT: I am just asking.

MR. GELLERT: Yes. Definitely.

THE COURT: Put the witness on the stand.

MR. GELLERT: He made an opening remark. Could

I respond?

THE COURT: Hedidn’t make an opening remark. He

proffered testimony through a witness, and I am giving you

the opportunity to examine the witness.

MR. GELLERT: I would like to respond for just thirty

seconds, if I may.

THE COURT: Go ahead.

MR. GELLERT: I just wanted to respond to the fact

that he brought in that the Railway Labor Act is an exclusive

remedy here. When the Supreme Court in IAM versus - -

Appendix 3

A I don’t know how many men were on the board.

I think there were maybe two company representatives and

two union representatives and a neutral named Lawrence

Ciebel.

Q I show you this. Do you recognize this?

A Yes, this looks like one of your myriad motions

for Summary Judgement which you filed in the second

Florida case.

Q Please - -

A Let me answer.

MR. GELLERT: it is not myriad motions. |

don’t like to be put down.

THE COURT: I realize you are pro se. That was

not putting anybody down. The word “myriad” is a very

simple one, it’s one of many is what the statement is.

MR. GELLERT: This is the first Summary

Judgement motion filed against Eastern Air Lines.

THE COURT: Mr. Gellert, you don’t have to

editorialize about everything. The witness made a very

clear, concise statement, that it’s one of many, that is what

Appendix 3

the word “myriad’ means.

Q Do you recognize this?

A Yes. This was the response that I filed on behalf

of Eastern - -

Q Is it a memorandum of Law?

A Let me finish my answer.

This was the response that I filed, the response

that I filed on behalf of Eastern, which consists of a motion

to strike your Motion for Summary Judgement.

Q Is the motion to strikea proper motion against

a Summary Judgement? Is that recognized by a court of

law?

Yes.

It is. On a Summary Judgement?

Yes.

oO - O >

Is therea Memorandum of Lawattached to this

under Local Rule 71?

A I believe that this constitutes a Memorandum

of Law under local rule of the Southern District of Florida.

Q | Could you point out the Memorandum of Law,

Appendix 3

please.

A Starts with paragraph 1 and ends with para-

graph 9.

Q Did you receive a copy of this?

A I don’t believe! saw this yet. | thinkit’s the first

time I am seeing this.

Q Are you acquainted with the Supreme Court

case IAM versus Street?

A I heard of it, but I can’t tell you what is in it.

MR. GELLERT: No more questions.

REDIRECT EXAMINATION BY MR. CAMPBELL:

Q Mr. Baumgarten, do you remember the record

well enough to recall whether in 1986 or so an arbitration

proceeding was held before a one-man or a multi-man

board, whether it was under Section 102 or another section

of the ALPA contract?

A I believe it was under a section of the ALPA

contract, but I can’t tell you what section it was.

Appendix 3

MR. CAMPBELL: No further questions.

THE COURT: Thank you, sir.

MR. GELLERT: Cana proffer this as evidence

now, sir?

THE COURT: Show it to Mr. Campbell.

MR. GELLERT: (Handing)

MR. CAMPBELL: I have no objection ‘to the

admission of these pleadings.

MR. GELLERT: Mark this as Plaintiffs Ex-

hibit 1 in evidence.

THE COURT: It is received.

(The above described document was marked

Plaintiffs Exhibit 1 in evidence, as of this date.)

MR. GELLERT: This as Exhibit 2 in evidence. |

(The above described document was marked

Plaintiffs Exhibit 2 in evidence, as of this date.)

MR. GELLERT: This is Exhibit 3 in evidence.

(The above described document was marked

Plaintiffs Exhibit 3 in evidence, as of this date.)

MR. GELLERT: This is exhibit 4 in evidence.

Appendix 3 |

(The above described document was marked

Plaintiffs Exhibit 4 in evidence, as of this date.)

MR. CAMPBELL: At this point, Your Honor,

we move with respect to the first named lawsuit, which has

a Proof of Claim on file, to disallow the claim as having no

merit.

With respect to the second lawsuit, I don't

believe there is a Proof of Claim on file, but there is no

showing that lawsuit has any merit but anything other

than a discharge claim in another guise, therefore we ask

with respect to the second lawsuit its value be estimated at

zero.

MR. GELLERT: Your Honor, the U.S. District

Court received two motions to dismiss from the Defendants,

from the Debtors on that same legal argument, and they

have been both denied. Summary Judgement is pending,

and according to the local rules the Judge should decide

them within the next ten days.

It is a viable case. It is protected by the

Constitution’s lst, 5th and 14th Amendments as to the

NLR ALSTON

Appendix 3

forced collection of union dues, and all of these cases have

been resolved by the Supreme Court in favor of Plaintiffs.

The Court has recognized the constitutional provisions as

to the collection of union dues.

MR. CAMPBELL: Again, Your Honor, there is

simply no merit to the lawsuit, no merit shown, references

to various Amendments to the Constitution notwithstand-

ing, and therefore we rest on our motion.

THE COURT: With respect to motions for

Summary Judgement, isn’t there a preclusion in the

Florida Court’s Order prohibiting further motions for

Summary Judgement without leave of the Court?

THE WITNESS: Yes, there are, Your Honor.

THE COURT: I don’t see anything introduced

here that shows that there has been some dispensation

given with respect to this latest motion.

MR. GELLERT: Your Honor, the Court denied

the Summary Judgement motion until discovery was to be

completed. Discovery was completed around the 10th of

May. So at six months down the road, the Summary

Appendix 3

Judgement motion is now ripe. The document from the

Clerk of the Court above shows that it falls under the

ripeness rule. It’s been pending for over ninety days and it

should be resolved.

MR. CAMPBELL: May I ask Mr. Baumgarten

to address that, with leave of the Court?

THE COURT: I haven't heard anybody answer

my question. But, Mr. Baumgarten, since you are here and

are familiar with this matter and have identified your

familiarization with the exhibits, I will hear from you. You

are still under oath.

THE WITNESS: First of all, there is still a

pending motion to dismiss by Eastern in the case that was

pending in the Southern District of Florida. There are no

pending Summary Judgement motions by Mr. Gellert. Mr.

Gell. rt’s sole basis for seeking Summary Judgement is

because he believes that Eastern and the other Defendants

were in default for failing to file what he believes are the

necessary responses to the motions for Summary Judge-

ment which he filed.

cl ROLLA AD AE MOTI

Appendix 3

In addition, to denying Mr. Gellert’s Summary

Judgement motions and in addition to prohibiting Mr.

Gellert from filing any further Summary Judgement mo-

tions without prior leave of the Court, I believe attached to

the Trustee's reply in this case in the District Court’s Order,

the Court denied Mr. Gellert’s motion to have Eastern be

held in default. And that was the status of the case.

THE COURT: Based on - -

MR. GELLERT: Could I respond to that?

THE COURT: Sure.

MR. GELLERT: The Judge has not ruled on

the Summary Judgement motions and has not ruled on

their response. Theirresponseis in default of the procedure

under Rule 56, Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and Local

Rule 7.1 and 7.5.

The Judge ruled that Summary Judgement

motion is denied until such a time as the discovery is

complete and that leave of Court has to be obtained.

=

I did file after discovery was concluded for leave

of Court, and that is what is part of the ripeness for filing

Appendix 3

that came from the Clerk that under the local rules the

Judge should either hold a hearing and decide the case in

ten days or make a decision on those motions within ten

days.

THE COURT: Based upon this record, there

seems to be an initial set of facts which really form the

underpinning for both lawsuits. The first lawsuit has been

washed through and received the judicial determination,

and that was on appeal, as I understand it; is that correct?

MR. CAMPBELL: That is correct.

THE COURT: But there was in connection

with that lawsuit an opinion or finding by a Magistrate and

then a confirmation and a de novo reviewed by the District

Court, was it?

MR. GELLERT: That was true. That particular

lawsuit did not challenge the discharge - -

THE COURT: I understand. But you have got

two Proofs of Claim here, and I am dealing with the merits

of those Proofs of Claim.

I do not find any merit to the underlying Proof

of Claim with respect to the first lawsuit nor do I find that

Appendix 3

your contention that you have a $12 million default

judgement accurate, and I do not see that there is any

underlying merit likewise to that lawsuit.

So under all of the circumstances here, ifI were

to estimate the claim based upon a lack of merit, I would be

forced to estimate it at zero. I see little likelihood of the latest

motion being successful. |

Submit an Order.

MR. CAMPBELL: Thank you, Your Honor.

THE COURT: I ought to note for the record with

respect to the Gellert claim, that, among other things, he

asked for cert. to the Supreme Court, and | don't know

whether that is from the denial of his request for an en banc

hearing concerning a denial of amandamus of the District

Court. I take it the mandamus deals with the first lawsuit

or does that deal likewise with both lawsuits or either one?

THE WITNESS: The mandamus deals with the

second lawsuit and the District Court’s Order denying his

motions for Summary Judgement and not letting him file

any other.

Appendix 3

THE COURT: It seems like he had so many

bites at the apple that he already consumed it.

THE WITNESS: He will still be biting, Your

Honor.

ah A cI iW? PE Ze ARIENEIE te IRE «EP sm

Appendix 3

CERTIFICATE

I, ROBERT PAYENSON, a Shorthand Reporter and

Notary Public of the State of New York, do hereby certify:

That I reported the proceedings hereinbefore set

forth, and that the foregoing is a true record of the

proceedings herein.

[ further certify that I am not related to any of the

parties to this action by blood or marriage; and that | amin

no way interested in the outcome of this matter.

/s/

Appendix 4

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

CASE NO. 88-1114-Civ-SPELLMAN

DANIEL G. GELLERT,

Plaintiff,

Vv. REPORT AND RECOMMENDATION

EASTERN AIRLINES, INC.,

et. al.,

Defendants

Presently before the Court for consideration is

defendant’s Motion to dismiss (DE 11) Plaintiffs First

Amended Complaint (DE 8). The Honorable Eugene P.

Spellman, United States District Judge, referred this mat-

ter for all permissible judicial proceedings as provided by

the Magistrate’s Act and Magistrate Rules for this District.

Plaintiff seeks redress from defendant Eastern Air-

lines (EAL) for purportedly violating 45 U.S.C. Par. 152

Eleventh (b) which provides in relevant part:

any carrier or carriers as defined

in this chapter and labor

organization or labor organizations

duly designated and authorized to

represent employees in accordance

Appendix 4

with the requirements of this

Plaintiff claims a violation occurred when defendant

EAL failed to withhold certain sums of money from his

salary in order to pay the Air Lines Pilots Association (ALPA)

in satisfaction of a Letter of Agreement regarding contract

chapter shall be permitted -- ....

(b) to make agreements providing

for the deduction by such carrier

or carriers from the wages of its

or their employees in a craft or

class and payment to the labor

organization representing the craft

or class of such employees, of any

periodic dues, initiation fees, and

assessments (not including fines

and penalties) uniformly-required

as a condition or acquiring or

retaining membership: Provided,

That no such agreement shall be

effective with respect to any

individual employee until he shall

have furnished the employer with a

written assignment to the labor

organization of such membership

dues, initiation fees, and

assessments which shall be

revocable in writing after the

expiration of one year or upon the

termination date of the applicable

collective agreement, whichever

occurs sooner.

Appendix 4

~ Maintenance Fees and Check-Off entered into between

defendant EAL and ALPA. (First Amended Complaint at 2-

6). Plaintiff claims defendant EAL’s actions ultimately

caused his termination.

Stemming from these same facts, plaintiff also seeks

redress from defendant EAL pursuant to Florida Statutes

Par. 448.045 making it unlawful for two or more persons to

agree, conspire, combine or confederate together to cause

the discharge of any person in any firm or corporation (First

Amended Complaint at 9). In the final count of his

Complaint, plaintiff seeks redress from defendant United

States Aviation Underwriters Incorporated for intentional

tortious interference with the employment relationship

between plaintiff and defendant EAL (First Amended Com-

plaint at 11).

Plaintiff asserts jurisdiction as to the first count

pursuant to 28 U.S.C. Par. 1331 as well as 28 U.S.C. Par.

1337. As to the second and third counts, plaintiff relies on

pendant and pendant party jurisdiction respectively.

Appendix 4

Defendant's Motion to Dismiss

Defendant contends the conduct complained of by

plaintiff constitutes a “minor grievance" under 45 U.S.C.

Sub.Par.151, 184 which establish arbitration boards as

the exdusive forum for resolution of such disputes, thus

effectively precluding federal courts from obtaining subject

matter jurisdiction (Defendants Motion at 2). Defendant

contends that if no subject matter jurisdiction exists as to

plaintiff's first count, then the second and third counts

must also fail as they rely on the first to supply the basis for

federal jurisdiction.

In the alternative, defendant suggests that "in the

unlikely event that the Court does find subject matter

jurisdiction for Count], the court should decline to exercise

ils power to assert pendant-party jurisdiction over (defen-

dant United States Aviation Underwriters Incorporated) in

Counts I] and III of Plaintiff's First Amended Complaint" as

State court provides an adequate forum for resolution of

those claims (Defendant's Motion at 3).

Appendix 4

Analysis

Is it "Major" or "Minor"

"Major" disputes

[relate] to disputes over the

formation of collective agreements

or efforts to secure them. They

arise where there is no such

agreement or where it is sought to

change the terms of one, and

therefore the issue is not whether

an existing agreement controls the

controversy. They look to the

acquisition of rights for the

future, not to assertion of rights

claimed to have vested in the past.

Elgin, Joliet, and Eastern U. Co. v. Burley, 325 U.S..711,

723 (1945).

On the other hands, "Minor" disputes contemplate

the existence of a collective

bargaining agreement already

concluded or, at any rate, a

situation in which no effort is

made to bring about a formal change

in terms or to create a new one,

The dispute relates either to the

meaning or proper application of a

particular provision with reference

to a specific situation or to an

omitted case.

Appendix 4

Plaintiff alleges defendant (EAL) "violated 45 U.S.C. Par.

152 Eleventh (b), by denying [plaintiff] a fair opportunity

to effect the deduction . . ." (First Amended Complaint at 6,

para. 37) representing his share of the costs "of negotiating

and administering a collective agreement and of adjust-

ment and settlement of disputes" (Id. at 3, para. 14).

Plaintiff contends his complaint states neither a “major” nor

a "minor" dispute but rather states a claim arising "out of

the interpretation and construction . . ." of 45 U.S.C. Par.

152, Eleventh (b). (Supplement to Response at 2).

In essence, therefore, plaintiff contends defendant

EAL's refusal to deduct monies pursuant to the check-off

agreement as requested by plaintiff constitutes a violation

of the above-cited statute. We do not agree.

In the first place, the express language of the statute

regarding withholding fees from employee's earnings is

permissive, not mandatory. The section provides that:

“notwithstanding any further provision of this chapter...

any carrier . . . as defined in this chapter and a labor

organization . . . duly designated in accordance with the

Appendix 4

requirements of this chapter shall be_permitted...."45

U.S.C. Par. 152, Eleventh (b) (emphasis added). Plaintiff

has not alleged any mandatory duty exists on defendant

EAL’s part to withhold the funds - either from the statute

itself or from the Letter of Agreement regarding Contract

Maintenance Fees and Check-Off entered into between

defendant EAL and defendant ALPA.

Second, cases involving interpretation of 45 U.S.C.

Par. 152, Eleventh (b) typically involve interpretation of

union security agreements, Klemens v. Air Line Pilots

Ass'n, Intern., 736 F.2d 491, 496 (9th Cir. 1984), or the

method of revocation available to employees under that

section. Felter v. Southern Pacific Co., 359 U.S. 326, 333

(1959).

Finally, a careful reading of the facts alleged in

plaintiffs First Amended Complaint indicate attempts to

artfully plead a wrongful discharge in the clothing of an

alleged statutory violation.

Appendix 4

Conclusion

We are cognizant of the presumptions enjoyed by a

plaintiff when the court considers a motion to dismiss. See

Scheuer v. Rhodes, 416 U.S. 232, 236 (1974) and Conley

v. Gibson, 335 U.S. 41, 45-6 (1957). Even after affording

plaintiff all necessary presumptions, however, we cannot

escape the conclusion that the First Amended Complaint

fails to state a claim pursuant to 45 U.S.C. Par. 152.

Eleventh (b).

Regarding plaintiff's remaining two claims, we need

not look far to resolve whether they state a claim indepen-

dent of the first claim. As noted by plaintiff Counts II and

III both rely upon pendant party jurisdiction derived from

Count. If, as we have concluded, this Court has not been

presented with a viable claim in Count I, then Counts II and

III] also must fail.

For the above-noted reasons and after careful review

of the entire record in this matter, it is

RECOMMENDED that plaintiffs First Amended

Complaint be DISMISSED for failure to state a claim upon

Appendix 4

which relief can be granted.

The parties may serve and file written objections to

this Report with The Honorable Eugene P. Spellman,

United States District Judge, within ten (10) days of receipt.

See 28 U.S.C. Par. 636(b)(1)(C); United States v. Warren,

687 F.2d 347 (11th Cir. 1982), cert. denied, 460 U.S. 1087

(1983); and Hardin v. Wainwright, 678 F.2d 589 (5th Cir.

unit B 1982). See also Thomas v. Arn, 474 U.S. 140 (1985).

Dated in Miami, Florida, on this 15th day of Febru-

ary, 1989.

/s/

Samuel J. Smargon

United States Magistrate

cc: Counsel of record

Appendix 5

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

CASE NO. 88-1114-CIV-SPELLMAN

FILED APRIL 4, 1989

DANIEL G. GELLERT,

Plaintiff,

VS

EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.,

and UNITED STATES AVIATION

UNDERWRITERS INCORPORATED,

Defendants.

/s/

ORDER OF ADOPTING AND AFFIRMING

MAGISTRATE’S RECOMMENDATION AND ORDER OF

DISMISSAL

THIS CAUSE comes before the Court upon the

Magistrate's report and recommendation regarding the

Defendant's Motion to Dismiss. After a de novoreview of the

recommendation, the objections thereto, and of the record.

it is hereby

ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that this Court ADOPTS

AND AFFIRMS said recommendation and that Motion is

Appendix 5

GRANTED. This cause is DISMISSED, for failure to state

a claim upon which relief can be granted.

It is further ORDERED that the Plaintiff's Motion to

Set Aside Order Setting Case for Trial is MOOT.

DONE AND ORDERED in Chambers at Miami,

Florida this 27th day of March, 1989

/s/

UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

cc: all counsel of record

Appendix 6

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF FLORIDA

DANIEL G. GELLERT

Plaintiff, JCASE NO.90-1113

JCIV-MOORE

v. )

EASTERN AIRLINES FLXED

BENEFIT RETIREMENT INCOME

PLAN FOR PILOTS, an employee

benefit pension plan, and

EASTERN AIR LINES, INC. solely

as Administrator of such defendant

plan, et al.,

ee eee ee ee ee See eee See”

Defendants -

hase

DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO STRIKE PLAINTIFF'S

MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGEMENT

DATED APRIL 7, 1993

Defendants Eastern Airlines Fixed Benefit Retire-

ment Income Plan for Pilots, Eastern Air Lines, Inc.

("Eastern"), William R. Tegtman, Noel Honohan, and

Alan C. Gibson (hereinafter collectively referred to as

"Defendants"), hereby respectfully request that the Court

strike Plaintiffs motion for summary judgement against

Appendix 6

Defendants, dated April 7, 1993. In support thereof,

Defendants state the following:

1. On January 10, 1992, this Court ordered the

entry of a Fina] Judgement in favor of Defendants Jack

N. Mogus and Charles Copeland, following the Court’s

September 6, 1991 Order dismissing, with prejudice,

both Mogus and Copeland from this action.!

2. On or about February 19, 1992, Defendants Wil-

liam R. Tegtman, Noel Honohan and Alan C. Gibson

filed a motion for their dismissal as defendants in this

action, with prejudice, for the same reason that the

Court dismissed Mogus and Copeland as defendants, i.e.

that as individual members of the Eastern Airlines Pilot

Retirement Board a/k./a. Pension Dispute Board, they

were entitled to arbitral immunity. That motion is still

pending before the Court.

3. On February 13, 1992, the Court, sua sponte,

ordered that Plaintiffs First Amended Complaint (filed

1 Defendants Mogus and Copeland are represented by their own counsel in this action sand have

filed their own motion to stnke Plaintiff's motion for summary judgement

eS A cee ee ee Te ee

ee ee

a i nek: stl A tai 05 iti RL eA RY

Appendix 6

January 25, 1992) be stricken, because it named defen-

dants and asserted counts that the Court had previously

dismissed with prejudice.

4. On or about March 3, 1992 Plaintiff filed a so-

called Third Amended Complaint, (and a so-called

Fourth Amended Complaint) which again included

counts and named defendants which the Court previ-

ously dismissed with prejudice. In fact, Plaintiff's third

and fourth amended complaints included the same

counts contained in Plaintiffs January 25, 1992

amended complaint and named the same defendants

which were previously dismissed with prejudice pursu-

ant to the Court’s Memorandum Opinion of September

6, 1992.

- Accordingly, on March 10, 1992, Defendants filed

a Motion to Strike Plaintiffs Third and Fourth Amended

Complaints or in the alternative, for an Extension of

Time to Respond to Plaintiffs Third or Fourth Amended

Complaint. That motion is still pending before the

Court.

EE

Appendix 6

6. On or about June 25, 1992, Defendants filed a

Notice of Pendency of the motions referred to above,

notifying the Court that more than ninety (90) days had

elapsed since these motions had been filed and that no

hearing had been set on these motions.

¥ Plaintiffs summary judgement motion seeks sum-

mary judgement against the Defendants on various

counts of the third amended complaint which appear to

basically allege that Plaintiff was wrongfully terminated

in 1986 for failing to pay union dues and was wrong-

fully denied disability benefits in 1987.

8. Plaintiffs claim that he was wrongfully denied

disability benefits in 1987 was the precise claim which

this Court held was barred by the applicable statute of

limitations in its September 6, 1992 Memorandum

Opinion. Furthermore, Defendants note thai Plaintiff

unsuccessfully contested the legality of his 1986 dis-

charge before this Court in Case No. 88-1114 (Spellman,

J.), and Plaintiffs appeal to the Eleventh Circuit from

that determination has been stayed (Eleventh Circuit

aes 6 ee Cee OS PS hee |

Appendix 6

Case No. 89-5378), as a result of Eastern’s chapter 11

bankruptcy filing.

9. In view of the above, Defendants respectfully sub-

mit that the Court should strike Plaintiff's motion for

summary judgement or at the very least, rule upon

Defendant’s pending motions prior to requiring Defen-

dants to respond to Plaintiff's frivolous motion for sum-

mary judgement.

WHEREFORE, Defendants respectfully request

that the Court enter an Order striking Plaintiff's Motion

for Summary Judgement, or alternatively, staying that

motion until the Court rules on Defendant's Motion to

Strike Plaintiffs Third and Fourth Amended Complaint

or in the Alternative for Enlargement of Time Within

Which to Respond to Plaintiffs Third or Fourth

Amended Complaint and until the Court rules on the

motion of Defendants Tegtman, Honohan and Gibson

for their dismissal as defendants in this action.

Appendix 6

Respectfully submitted,

/s/

Maurice J. Baumgarten

Florida Bar No. 525324

Eastern Air Lines, Inc.

Building 16, Room 440, MIALG

Miami International Airport

Miami, Florida 33148

(305) 873-7857

Attorney for Defendants

ee a ee ee

ak Chk

3

i

2

:

:

j

4

*

2

;

j

|

a

a

a

s

a

2

i

*

4

3

:

s

a

j

Appendix 6

CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE

1, Maurice J. Baumgarten, attorney for the Defen-

dants, hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the

hereto annexed Defendant’s Motion to Strike was served by

U.S. mail this 19th day of April, 1993 to:

Daniel G. Gellert,

P. O. Box 320370

Cocoa Beach, Florida 32931

Robert T. Kofman, Esquire

Stearns, Weaver, et. al.

150 West Flagler Street

Miami, Florida 33130

Karen L. Morris, Esquire

Office of the General Counsel

Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation

2020 K Street, N.W.

Washington, DC 30006-1860

Mark Hicks, Esquire

Hicks, Anderson & Blum, P.A.

New World Tower - Suite 2402

100 North Biscayne Blvd.

Miami, Florida 33132

/s/

Maurice J. Baumgarten

Appendix 7

Document No. 102

LETTER OF AGREEMENT

regarding

CONTRACT MAINTENANCE FEES

and

CHECK-OFF

between

EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

and

THE AIR LINE PILOTS

in the service of

EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

as represented by

THE AIR LINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION

INTERNATIONAL

THIS LETTER OF AGREEMENT is made and entered into

in accordance with the provisions of the Railway Labor Act,

as amended, by and between EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

(hereinafter known as "Eastern" or"the Company"), and the

Air Line Pilots in the service of EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.,

as represented by the AIR LINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION,

INTERNATIONAL (hereinafter known as the "Association").

WITNESSETH:

It is mutually agreed:

I. CONTRACT MAINTENANCE FEE (CMF)

A. Contract Maintenance Fee Liability

1. Each pilot on the Eastern Pilots’ Senior-

ity list shall be required, as a condition of employment,

beginning sixty (60) days after the effective date of this

Letter of Agreement or sixty (60) days after the completion

of his probationary period, whichever shall last occur, (1)

to be or become a member of the Association, or (2) to pay

ine meiil

Appendix 7

to the Association a monthly contract maintenance fee

(CMF) for the administration of the Agreement and the

representation of the pilot.

2. Such monthly CMF shall be equal to the

Association’s regular monthly dues which would be re-

quired to be paid by such pilot if a member; provided that

neither membership nor the payment of a CMF shall be

required in respect to any such pilot (a) to whom member-

ship is not available upon the same terms and conditions

generally applicable to any other member, or (b) as to whom

membership was denied or terminated for any reason other

than the termination for any reason other than the failure

to tender periodic dues, initiation fees and assessments

uniformly required by the Association or the EAL-MEC as

a condition of acquiring or retaining membership. To the

extent required by law, a rebate/reduction in his dues or

CMF shall be made to any pilot properly requesting such

rebate/reduction from the Treasurer of the Association.

The Association shall treat members and non-members

alike in calculating the amounts due, in establishing the

due date of payments and in determining whether a pilot's

account is delinquent

3. The provision of Section I of this Letter

of Agreement shall not apply to those pilots who are

occupying a management position with a title of director or

above.

B. Delinquency

A If any pilot who is required under this

Letter of Agreement to make payment of a CMF becomes

delinquent in the making of such payments, the Associa-

tion shall notify such pilot by certified mail, return receipt

requested, copy to the Vice President Flight Operations and

System Chief Pilot of Eastern, or his successor or designee.

Appendix 7

2. The letter of notification shall advise the

pilot that he is delinquent in the payment of such CMF and

the total amount of money due and the period for which he

is delinquent and that he is subject to discharge as an

employee of the Company. Such letter shall also notify the

pilot that he must remit the required payment within a

period of fifteen (15) days or be discharged.

3. The notice of delinquency required un-

der this paragraph shall be deemed to be received by the

pilot, whether or not it is personally received by him, when

mailed by the Treasurer of the Association by certified mail,

return receipt requested, postage prepaid to the pilot’s last

known address, or to any other address which has been

designated by the pilot. It shall be the duty of every pilot

covered by this Agreement to notify the Association's

Membership Services Department of every change in his

home address, or of an address where the notice required

by this paragraph can be sent and received by the pilot if

the pilot’s home address is at any time unacceptable for this

purpose.

c. Certification of Delinquency

If, upon the expiration of the fifteen (15) day

period provided in Paragraph B above, the pilot still remains

delinquent, the Association shall certify in writing to the

Vice President Flight Operations and System Chief Pilot of

Eastern, or his successor or designee, copy to the pilot; that

the pilot has failed to remit payment within the grace period

allowed and is therefore to be discharged. The Vice

President Flight Operations and System Chief Pilot, or his

successor or designee, shall thereupon take the proper

steps to discharge such pilot from service of the Company

as soon as possible, and in any event within thirty (30) days

after receipt of the notice provided for herein, shall advise

the pilot of his termination.

Je Wbd heute ety wm nied el A 2 4 uk

Ms Writ tani tt CeO et A ania eat an Past Atego

Appendix 7

D. Appeal Procedure

a A protest by a pilot who is to be

discharged as a result of an interpretation or application of

the provisions of this Section of this Letter of Agreement

shall be subject to the following procedures:

2. A pilot who believes that the said

provisions have not been properly interpreted or applied, as

they pertain to him, may submit his request for review in

writing fifteen (15) days after receipt of the notification from

the Vice President Flight Operations and System Chief

Pilot, or his successor or designee as provided in Paragraph

C. The request must be sent by certified mail, return receipt

requested, to the Vice President Flight Operations and

System Chief Pilot, or his successor or designee, who will

review the protest and render a decision in writing, not later

than fifteen (15) days following receipt of the protest.

3. The Vice President Flight Opera-

tions and System Chief Pilot, or his successor or designee

shall, forward his decision to the pilot, with a copy to the

Treasurer of the Association, both by certified mail, return

receipt requested. Said decision shall be final and binding

on all interested parties, unless appealed as hereinafter

provided. Ifthe decision is not satisfactory to either the pilot

or the Association, then either may appeal within fifteen

(15) days from the receipt of the decision, by filing a notice

‘of appeal. Such notice shall be sent to the other party and

to the Vice President Flight Operations and System Chief

Pilot, or his successor or designee, by certified mail, return

receipt requested. Appeal shall be directly to a-Neutral

Referee who shall be agreed upon by the pilot and the

Association within fifteen (15) days after receipt of the notice

of appeal. In the event the parties fail to agree upon a Neutral

Referee within the specified period, either the pilot or the

Association may request the National Mediation Board to

Appendix 7

name such Neutral Referee. The hearing before the Neutral

Referee shall be held as soon as possible, and the decision

of the Neutral Referee shall be requested within thirty (30)

days after the hearing. The decision of the Neutral Referee

shall be final and binding on all parties to the dispute. The

fees and charges of such appeal and Neutral Referee shall

be borne by the party making the appeal.

E. Status Pending Appeal

1. During the period a protest is

being handled, as herein provided, and until a final deci-

sion is rendered by the Vice President Flight Operations and

System Chief Pilot, or his successor or designee, or the

Neutral Referee, the pilot shall not be discharged from the

Company nor lose any seniority rights because of non-

compliance with the terms and provisions herein. However,

a pilot unavailable for normal flight duty by reason of non-

compliance with the terms and provisions of this Letter of

Agreement or by reason of exercising the above appeal

rights shall have all monthly guarantees prorated in accor-

dance with Section 11-C of the Agreement for each day of

unavailability.

F. Discharge

A pilot discharged by the Company

under the provisions herein shall be deemed to have been

"discharged for cause."

II. DUES AND CONTRACT MAINTENANCE FEE

CHECK-OFF

A. During the life of this Letter of Agreement, the

Company will deduct from the monthly pay of each pilot

which is subject to the withholding of federal taxes and

remit to the Air Line Pilots Association membership dues

uniformly levied (not including initiation fee, fines, penal-

ties, or assessments) in accordance with Constitution and

Appendix 7

By-Laws of the Association as prescribed by the Railway

Labor Act, as amended, or the contract maintenance fee as

defined in Section I (A) above, provided such pilot voluntar-

ily executes the following agreed-upon form which will be

prepared and furnished by the Association and known as

a “Check-Off Form".

ASSIGNMENT AND AUTHORIZATION FOR

VOLUNTARY CHECK-OFF OF

ASSOCIATION DUES

OR CONTRACT MAINTENANCE FEES

To Eastern Air Lines, Inc.

I, , hereby authorize and

direct Eastern Air Lines, Inc. to deduct from my earnings

1.35% of my gross earnings as standard monthly member-

ship Association dues (or such standard monthly member-

ship dues as may hereafter be established by the Associa-

tion), or an amount equivalent to such dues which shall be

deemed a contract maintenance fee. Such amount so

deducted is hereby assigned to the AIR LINE PILOTS

ASSOCIATION, INTERNATIONAL subject to all the terms

and conditions of the Railway Labor Act, as amended, and

the provisions of the Check-Off Agreement. This assign-

ment and authorization may be revoked by me in writing

at any time. A copy of any such revocation will be sent by

me to the Chairman of the Master Executive Council.

Date

Signature of Employee

Address

Employee Number

Domicile

B. All Check-OffForms will be submitted through

Appendix 7

the President of the Association, who will forward the

original signed copy addressed to the Director-Payroll

Department of the Accounting Department, Eastern Air

Lines, Inc., Miami, Florida, or to such other official as

Eastern may from time to time designate. A properly |

executed Check-Off Form or notice of revocation received

before the 15th of any month, will become effective the first

of the month following such receipt by the Payroll Depart-

ment of the Accounting Department, Eastern Air Lines.,

Miami, Florida. Illegible or improperly executed forms will

be returned to the Chairman of the Master Executive

Council of the Association.

C. Any notice of revocation, as set forth in the

Check-Off Form, must be in writing, signed by the pilot and

delivered by certified mail, addressed to the Director-Payroll

Department of the Accounting Department, Eastern Air

Lines, Inc., Miami, Florida, or to such other official as

Eastern may from time to time designate, with a copy

delivered in the same manner by the pilot to the Chairman

of the Master Executive Council. Check-Off forms and

notices of revocation received by Eastern will be stamp-

dated on the date received by Eastern and will constitute

notice to Eastern on the date received, not when mailed.

D. Deduction of membership dues or contract

maintenance fees shall be made from each paycheck issued

provided there is a sufficient balance due the pilot at that

time after all other deductions authorized by the pilot or

required by law have been satisfied. Within a reasonable

time after the end of each month, Eastern will remit to the

Association a check in payment of all dues and contract

maintenance fees collected during that month pursuant to

outstanding and unrevoked Check-Off Forms. These

remittances will be subject to normal accounting practice

with respect to adjustments necessary because of the

methods involved in the deduction procedure.

———

I EIS Hi TE SNE SEN

Appendix 7

E. Apilotwhohasexecuted a Check-OffForm and

(1) who has been transferred or promoted to a position not

covered by the Agreement, (2) who resigns from the Com-

pany, (3) who is furloughed or laid off or is (4) otherwise

terminated from Eastern shall be deemed to have automati-

cally revoked his assignment as of the date of such action,

and if he (1) returns to a position covered by the Agreement

(2) is rehired, or (3) recalled, further deductions of Associa-

tion dues or contract maintenance fees will be made only

upon execution and receipt of another Check-Off Form.

F. Collection of any back dues or contract main-

tenance fees owed at the time of starting deductions for any

pilot, collection of dues or contract maintenance fees

missed because the pilot's earnings were not sufficient to

cover the payment of dues or contract maintenance fees in

the specified pay period and collection of dues or contract

maintenance fees missed because of accidental errors in the

accounting procedure will be the responsibility of the

Association and will not be the subject of payroll deduc-

tions, and Eastern shall not be responsible in any way

because of missed collections. It will be the Association's

responsibility to verify apparent errors with the individual

Association member before contacting Eastern’s Director-

Payroll.

G. Changes in standard monthly membership

dues or contract maintenance fees will be given effect only

upon notice by the President of the Association, delivered

in writing, to Eastern, by certified mail, and will become

effective as provided in Section II (B) for check-off authori-

zations and revocations.

H. In cases where a deduction is made which

duplicates a payment already made to the Association bya

pilot and where a deduction is not in conformity with the

provisions of the Association Constitution and By-Laws,

Appendix 7

refunds to the pilot will be made by the Association.

Ill. GENERAL

A. The Association agrees to indemnify and hold

Eastern harmless for any and all claims, awards, or judge-

ment including court costs, back pay and attorney fees,

which may result from action by any pilot or pilots or any

other person by virtue of the wrongful application or

misrepresentation of any of the terms of this letter of

Agreement.

B. This Letter of Agreement supersedes and re-

places Document No. 40, signed January 29, 1971.

C. This Letter of Agreement shall become effective

as of the first of the month following signature by all parties

and shall be subject to changes in the same manner as

specified in the Basic Pilots’ Employment Agreement be-

tween the parties hereto.

IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the parties have signed this

Letter of Agreement this 28th day of February, 1985.

FOR EASTERN AIRLINES WITNESS:

/s/

Frank Borman

Chairman, President and

Chief Executive Officer

/s/

R. J. Shipner

Vice President Flight Operations

and System Chief Pilot

Appendix 7

FOR THE AIR LINE PILOTS

IN THE SERVICE OF

EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

/s/

Henry A. Duffy, President

Air Line Pilots Association,

international

/s/

L. D. Schulte, Chairman

Master Executive Council

WITNESS

ri

Appendix 8

ASSIGNMENT AND AUTHORIZATION FOR VOLUNTARY

CHECK-OFF OF ASSOCIATION DUES

TO: EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

I, D. G. Gellert hereby authorize and direct Eastern

Air Lines, Inc. to deduct from my earnings 1.35% of my

gross earnings or standard monthly membership Associa-

tion dues (or such standard monthly membership dues as

may hereafter be established by the Association). Such

amount so deducted is hereby assigned to the AIR LINES

PILOTS ASSOCIATION, INTERNATIONAL subject to all the

terms and conditions of the Railway Labor Act, as amended,

and the provisions of the Dues Check-Off Agreement. This

assignment and authorization may be revoked by me in

writing after the expiration of one (1) year from the date

hereof, or upon the termination date of the Pilots’ Agree-

ment in effect at the time this is signed whichever occurs

sooner. A copy of any such revocation will be sent by me

to the Chairman of the Master Executive Council.

Date: 12-1-71

Signature of Employee /s/ Daniel G. Gellert

Address: 610 Poinsetta Street - Satellite Beach, FL 32937

Man Number: 32839

Base Station: JFK - NY

4

ation EA

i

:

Appendix 9

ASSIGNMENT AND AUTHORIZATION FOR

VOLUNTARY CHECK-OFF OF

ASSOCIATION DUES OR CONTRACT MAINTENANCE

FEES

To: Eastern Air Lines, Inc.

I, /s/ D. G. Gellert, hereby authorize and direct

Eastern Air Lines, Inc. to deduct from my earnings 1.35%

of my gross earnings as standard monthly membership

association dues (or such standard monthly membership

dues as may hereafter be established by the Association),

Or an amount equivalent to such dues which shall be

deemed a contract maintenance fee. Such amount so

deducted is hereby assigned to the AIR LINE PILOTS

ASSOCIATION, INTERNATIONAL subject to all the terms

and conditions of the Railway Labor Act, as amended, and

the provisions of the Check-Off Agreement. This assign-

ment and authorization may be revoked by me in writing

at any time. A copy of any such revocation will be sent by

me to the Chairman of the Master Executive Council.

DUES ONLY!

Date: June 1, 1985

Signature of Employee: /s/ D. G. Gellert

Address: P. O. Box 187, Cocoa Beach, FL 32931

Employee Number: 32938

Domicile: MIA

Attn: John Dodge

This authorization is for ALPA dues ONLY. NO

Contract maintenance fee.

I hereby demand ALPA Membership and I do have

dues deduction authorization on file (Init.)

Appendix 10

ASSIGNMENT AND AUTHORIZATION FOR VOLUNTARY

CHECK-OFF OF ASSOCIATION DUES OR CONTRACT

MAINTENANCE FEES

TO: EASTERN AIR LINES, INC.

I, /s/ D. G. Gellert, hereby authorize and direct Eastern

Air Lines, Inc. to deduct from my earnings 2.35% of my

gross earnings as standard monthly membership Associa-

tion dues (or such standard monthly membership dues as

may hereafter be established by the Association), or an

amount equivalent to such dueés which Shall be deemed a

contract maintenance fee. Such amount so deducted is

hereby assigned to the AIR LINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION,

INTERNATIONAL, subject to all the terms and conditions

of the Railway labor Act, as amended and the provisions of

the Check-OffAgreement. This assignment and authoriza-

tion may be revoked by me in writing at any time. A copy

of any such revocation will be sent by me to the Chairman

of the Master Executive Council.

Signature of Employee /s/ D. G. Gellert

Address: P. O. Box 187 - Cocoa Beach, FL 32931

Employee Number: 32938

Domicile: MIA

Date: Sept. 17, 1985

——— rl et

Appendix 11

January 21, 1986

Captain D. G. Gellert

P. O. Box 370

Cocoa Beach, Florida 32931

Dear Captain Gellert:

“ee

Captain Jim Holder, Atlanta LEC Chairman, asked me

to write you concerning your position on rejoining’

ALPA. Jim said you were based in Miami. I have for-

warded your name to Ron Rindfleisch. He will send you

} the required paper work.

Sincerely,

AIR LINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION

/s/

Steve Holbert, Chairman

Membership Committee

Eastern Council 07

Regets > 20k initiates ah bie 50 Mana RY EE he eo

SH/nb

cc: Capt. Jim Holder

. Capt. P. W. Page

AIR LINES PILOTS ASSOCIATION ATLANTA FIELD OFFICE

1007 Virginia Avenue, Suite B-200, Atlanta, GA 30354

| (404) 763-3800

Appendix 12

January 23, 1986

P. O. Box 370, Cocoa Beach, FL 32931

Mr. John J. Magee

Treasurer, ALPA

P. O. Box 1169

Herndon, VA 22070

Dear Mr. Magee:

In this separate letter, since this does not concern every one

copied in letter P 564 923 335, may I suggest that I pay the

cost of my share in the contract between EAL and ALPA,

until such a time as my ALPA membership is resolved in my

favor.

In a January 9, 1986 letter from you, I am told that now I

must pay another percent added to my contract obligation.

You told me that CMF (Contract Maintenance Fee) now was

unilaterally increased by one percent of my gross earnings.

I have made formal application for ALPA membership, and

if! am not allowed membership, or until such time, I do not

believe that I should pay monies to the general ALPA fund,

those funds beyond your cost of negotiating and enforcing

the contract and its immediate administration. Please send

to me a bill, which represents those costs only, removing

political, organizational, and all other cost that ALPA

members are required to pay.

You can not have it both ways; you can not deny to me

membership, and then demand payments in CMF which

would be the same as if] was a member. At the present time,

I do not agree with ALPA policy, and as such I should not

be forced to pay these large sums of monies without my right

to vote, dissent or otherwise express my views.

Appendix 12

Your position is that I must pay these funds or be dis-

charged, that I do not have any rights under the law, but

that I must obey all your orders and directives or you can

take my ability to earn a livelihood in my profession, is

absurd. Please be guided accordingly.

Sincerely,

/s/

D. G. Gellert

Attached to P 564 923 335

Appendix 13

AIR LINE PILOTS ASSOCIATION

1625 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W.

Washington D.C. 20036

(202) 797-4000

April 14, 1986

Captain R. J. Shipner

Vice President Flight Operations

and System Chief Pilot

Eastern Airlines

Miami International Airport

Miami, Florida 33148

Dear Captain Shipner:

I am requesting that you rescind the discharge of D.G.

Gellert, #32839, which has not yet become effective. He has

today tendered a check in the amount of $1,248.36 to the

Association in satisfaction of his contract maintenance

obligation through April 1986. Thank you for your coop-

eration.

Sincerely,

/s/

John J. Magee, Treasurer

Air Line Pilots Assn.

cc: Mr. L. D. Schulte

Captain Paul Page

Mr. Martin Soll, Esq.

Mr. D. G. Gellert

Appendix 14

May 21, 1986

Mr. D. G. Gellert

P. O. Box 370

Cocoa Beach, Florida 32931

Dear Mr. Gellert:

The Appeal Procedure contained in Document 102 between

Eastern Air Lines and the Air Line Pilots Association,

International (ALPA), (copy enclosed) requires that the pilot

and the Association agree upon a Neutral Referee. -I have

enclosed a list of Neutrals that are acceptable to the

Association. In the event that we fail to agree upon a Neutral

Referee, the pilot or the Association may petition the

national Mediation Board to name a Neutral Referee. Under

Document 102 the fees and charges of the appeal and

neutral Referee are your responsibility since you filed an

appeal.

Please advise the Association whether any of the proposed

Neutrals are acceptable to you.

Sincerely,

/s/

Felice Busto, Attorney

Legal Department

FB: jd

Certified Mail

Airline Pilots Association

1625 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036

(703) 689-2270

Appendix 15

Airline Pilots Association

1625 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036

(703) 689-2270

July 23, 1986

Mr. D. G. Gellert

P. O. Box 370

Cocoa Beach, Florida 32931

Dear Mr. Gellert:

I am writing to advise you that the Association has re-

quested Lawrence E. Seibel to arbitrate your discharge from

Eastern Airlines under Document 102. This was done

pursuant to your telephone request on July 18, 1986,

during which you selected Mr. Seibel to hear your case.

The Association, through John Loomos, will represent you

at the arbitration. Under Document 102 the costs of the

arbitration are your responsibility since you filed an appeal

in this matter.

Please feel free to contact me should you have any ques-

tions.

Sincerely,

Felice Busto, Attorney

Legal Department

Appendix 15

FB: bjb

Certified

CC:

M.E. Burke

C. Copeland

A.C. Gibson

G.T. Jehn

J. Loomos

J.J. Magee

L.D. Schulte

C. Sheppard

M.A. Soll

Appendix 16

LAURENCE E. SIEBEL

Impartial Labor Arbitrator

5523 Uppingham Street

Chevy Chase, Maryland 20815

(301) 656-9500

October 17, 1986

Felice Busto, Esq., Attorney

Legal Department ..

Airline Pilots Association International

1625 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036

John Loomos, Esq.

Airline Pilots Association, EAL-MEC Office

201 Madeira Avenue

Coral Gables, Florida 33134

Re: Captain D. G. Gellert

Eastern Airlines, Inc.

Contract Maintenance Fee

CMF Case No. 2

Dear Ms. Busto and Mr. Loomis:

There are enclosed herewith two executed Decisions in the

above styled matter.

The fee for my services is $2,000.00, which includes the

hearing, travel, and study, a total of four (4) days. The expenses

were $250.00; which included travel, etc. The total of the fee and

expenses, therefore is $2,250.00 which, I assume, is payable one-

half or $1,125.00 by each of the Parties or is payable by the Airline

Pilots Association. I leave that to you and to Mr. Soll for resolution.

Sincerely yours,

/s/

Laurence E. Seibel

Copy to:

Martin A. Soll, Esq.

Manager/Flight Agreements and Contract Administration

Eastern Airlines/Flight Operations

Miami International Airport

Miami, Florida 33148

Appendix 17

Airline Pilots Association

1625 Massachusetts Avenue, N.W.

Washington, D.C. 20036

(703) 689-2270

April 6, 1989

Mr. Daniel G. Gellert

Post Office Box 320370

Cocoa Beach, Florida 32931

Dear Mr. Gellert:

If Eastern is, as your March 27 letter suggests, threatening

you with loss of retirement benefits unless you work during

the current IAM strike and ALPA sympathy strike, this

would, of course, be unlawful. If necessary, ALPA can

recommend competent counsel to assist you should such

threats materialize, and you may feel free, despite your non-

membership status, to call the ALPA Legal Department for

such a recommendation if needed.

If you believe that ALPA has kept any sums of money which

are properly yours, please contact our Membership Services

Department for an accounting.

Sincerely,

/s/

Henry A. Duffy, President

HAD: jd

ce: J. J. Davis

Appendix 18

PENSION BENEFIT GUARANTY CORPORATION

2020 K. Street N.W. - Washington, DC 20006-1860

March 25, 1991

Memorandum

To: Anna L. Gilreath

Eastern Plans Project Coordinator

Through: David C. Lindeman, Director

Corporate Policy and Research Department

From: Ellan H. Spring

Program Policy Division, CPRD

Re: Pilots’ Disability Benefit

You have asked whether the disability benefit in the Eastern

Air Lines Fixed Benefit Retirement Income Plan for Pilots is

a guaranteeable benefit.

The pilots’ plan provides that a participant will be eligible

to receive a disability benefit ifhe becomes disabled prior to

attaining normal retirement age. permanent disability is

defined in section 3.6(b) of the plan as follows:

Permanent disability means the complete

inability of such Participant as a result of

physical or mental reasons to continue in

employment with Eastern asa pilot...

Disability resulting from intentionally self-inflicted inju-

ries, suicide attempts, substances abuse or acts of war while

a pilot is on military leave are excluded.

area anna

Appendix 18

The PBGC’s regulation or guaranteed benefits provides that

an annuity payable under the terms ofa plan for a total and

permanent disability that started before termination is a

pension benefit and therefore guaranteeable unless the

PBGC determines that the standards for determining total

and permanent disability under a plan are unreasonable or

were modified in anticipation of termination. If the PBGC

makes either determination, it will guarantee a disability

benefit only ifthe participant meets the standards set by the

Social Security Administration for determining total dis-

ability. 29 C.F.R. Par. 2613.7 (a) and (b).

The question raised with regard to the pilots plan is whether

the plan’s disability standard is a reasonable standard of

total and permanent disability.

At issue is whether an occupational" disability standard.

which only requires the participant be unable to perform

the duties of his or her particular job (and, sometimes,

‘similar" jobs), is "reasonable", or whether the plan disabil-

ity standard must be of the more restrictive type used by

Social Security (i.e., one that defines disability as inability

to engage in any substantial gainful activity) to be consid-

ered "reasonable" and thus guaranteeable.

The preambles to the proposed and final guaranteed ben-

efits regulations shed no light on this questions. However,

we believe that, if we had intended to guarantee only

disability under the Social Security type standard, the

regulation would have so provided. Further, occupational-

disability standards are not uncommon; indeed, the Civil

Service Retirement Systems uses such a standard. A plan

that utilizes an occupational-disability standard would be

funding to reflect the higher incidence of disability retire-

ments under such a standard.

Appendix 18

Conclusion

We conclude that an occupational disability standard is

perfectly acceptable as a standard for total and permanent

disability. Ifthe standard contained in a plan is reasonable

similar to either the Social Security disability standard or

is a typical occupational-disability standard, as the pilots’

standard is, disability benefits for disabilities occurring

before termination should be guaranteed. PBGC’s reserva-

tion of authority under Par. 2613.7(b) is intended to allow

us to not guarantee disability benefits where the plan

standards are unreasonable, where plan disability stan-

dards are not reasonably administered, or where the stan-

dards were modified in anticipation of plan termination.

We have discussed this issue informally with Renae Hubbard

of OGC, but have not sought that Office’s formal legal

opinion.

cc: Renae Hubbard

4

4%

i

:

}

|

j

‘

Appendix 19

May 7, 1992

To File

Larry L. Norfolk

Member, Appeals Board

Appeal 91-410, Daniel Gellert

Eastern Air Lines

The following is a record of my telephone conversa-

tion on May 7, 1992, with Bill Roberts, an attorney with the

Airline Pilots Association ("ALPA"). He is very familiar with

the agreement, and specifically with Eastern Air Lines,

(EAL), because he worked on EAL matters for quite a few

years at ALPA.

He stated that ALPA had worked with PBGC ona

number of EAL disability cases in which EAL refused to pay

out sick leave because workers were on strike, and thus

would not let them go out on disability because they had not

exhausted sick leave as required by the pension plan. he

said these pilots were in limbo when the plan terminated,

i.e. they were in a "Catch 22" situation. A number of

grievances and lawsuits were filed against EAL because

they were not reducing the sick leave of pilots and denying

their disability applications. ALPA worked with the PBGC

to resolve the outstanding disability cases after the plan

terminated.

However, this would not apply to some one who

terminated prior to the strike period. Specifically, someone

who terminated employment in 1986 would not have been

a part of the discussions with PBGC concerning exhaustion

of sick leave.

We discussed the meaning of the provisions of Sec-

tion 38 of the EAL/ALPA agreement dated 1981. He agreed

Appendix 19

that Section 38, D. 1. meant that 1 could divide the number

of days of sick leave by 15 and determine how many months

it would take to exhaust sick leave. We discussed E.2. as

it applied to pilots who were drawing workmen’s compen-

sation. He said he had not had any issues come up with

regard to this section, but would agree with my assessment

that it would seem that such a pilot would be charged

consecutive calendar days for sick leave instead of the

maximum of 15 days per month as described above.

For future reference, his telephone number at ALPA

is 703-689-2270, extension 4099.

Appendix 20

CHITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

LASTZAM DISTRICT OF WEN XORK

UNITED STATES OF AEAICA

-V- ogo INCLUDING SEWTLIiCS

OrDER SEMTLACT WG REFORH ACT

LASTERM ATALINES, DIC. deft a2.

CASE woxgsRr: CR 90-629

(Vane ef Defendant)

JANE PARVER

425 Park Avenue

Wew York, N.Y. 10022

Defendant's Attoraey and Address

Ez OLYEMCANT

7 onal quilt to count(s) 1,67, 916 917,822,025 and 436.

vas. found ty oa coustis)_ :

afters a ples of not guilty.

necoxdiagly, ths defendast is ADJUDGED guilty of such count(s), which

involve th fellowiag offenses:

PEE we EE OTR soa a

Title 18, ° e to the TA 1,7,36,37,

. eGo -

Se i eee. hate snk

pe 36.

The defendant is sentenced ag provided in pages I-through_2 of this Judguest

The seateace is Laposed pursuant to the Sentencing Reform Act of 1544. ;

LI The defendant bas bean found not guilty on count(s)

ané is éischaryed as to such counti(s). -

CE xeazecs)___Open counts (is}(are) disnissed as the sovicn of t

Unived States.

Mi the eandacesy apecial assessment 4s included in the portion of this

—— & izpeses « fins.

27 te is oxdered that: the

defendant shall pay to the Ucited States « specias

‘assessment of § which shall be-due iemediately,

Ie is ¢ z that the defendant shall notify tho United States Attor

tor tais district within 30 days of any change of residence or sailicg addres

until al} fines, restitution, costs, and special assessoents inposed by

this

Judguent are fully paid.

Defesdsnt’s Soc. Ses. wumbas:

TASTERM AIR LINES, IKC.

& . c's eas)

Miami International Airport

ts .8.D.J.

Miami, Tlorida 33148 2 ar sneee U.s i.

i beTendage’s residence address: March 20, 1991

itt..

} a

: “3 DATED

i

aXe

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Appendix — Gellert v. United States District Court · 513 U.S. 1149 | Frix