Opposition Brief — Environmental Protection Agency v. Coalition for Clean Air
Supreme Court brief1993
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
_ ss siete eC MES os ic tee tie Oo a a bs RRS een SE SLE SS NS — —
. Buprems Court, US
5 FILED
No. 92-798 DEC 1 7 199?
}
“pire OF THE CLERK
Supreme Court af “the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1992
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY, etal,
Petitioners,
vs.
COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR, INC., et al.,
Respondents.
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
TO THE UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
PETER M. GREENWALD
Counsel of Record
SOUTH COAST AIR QUALITY
MANAGEMENT DISTRICT
21865 Copley Drive
P. O. Box 4940
Diamond Bar, California 91765-0940
(909) 396-2301
2 ‘ ‘ , "
SOL COA é Cc 1|Y
VR SERS MER Rp ae ty
5 ta, cae Deer cs he % ig
aes
QUESTION PRESENTED
Did enactment of the 1990 Amendments to the Clean
Air Act, 42 U.S.C. §7401 et seq., continue EPA’s
preexisting obligation to complete federal implementa-
tion plans for the South Coast Air Basin to supplement
pollution control efforts of state and local governments,
given that more than twenty years of state and local air
quality planning efforts have led to the conclusion that
~ attainment of the National Ambient Air Quality Stand-
ards can only be achieved with the assistance of federal
measures?
TABLE OF CONTENTS
REASONS WHY THE PETITION
SHOULD BE DENIED
A. Summary of Argument
B. Argument
1.
y &
I a tek ae a wd
FIPs Need Not Interfere with the
Primary Role of State and Local
Authorities in Air Quality Planning. . .
FIPs Can Include Cost-Effective Con-
trol Measures which are Necessary for
Attainment but which State and Local
Governments Lack Authority to Imple-
ment, Thereby Spreading Regulatory
Burdens and Reducing Economic
NS ee aera a
EPA’s Position is Contrary to Con-
gress’ Intent to Build Upon Past
Efforts So As to Achieve Expeditious
Attainment, Rather than Commencing
the Air Quality Planning Process
0 Le aa ee
ot ST we Se ce Se ee ie. To ee
ah BLS. ES Ne See a a ee a a ee ee a ee ee
it:
5. The Section 193 Savings Clause Pro-
vides An Alternative Ground for
Affirming the Decision ........... 20
ee | ee a ee ee ee ee 25
APPENDIX
Declaration of Barry R. Wallerstein ...... Al
-iv-
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Page
Cases
Abramowitz v. EPA
S32 F.260 1671 (9th Cir. 1967). «6 ss te y ea
Mills v. United States
eee ee Be ee. oe A): | rer mere 23
State Statutes
Calif. Health & Saf. Code §40412 .......... 2
Calif. Health & Saf. Code §40460(a)......... 2
Calif. Health & Saf. Code §40469 .......... 2
Federal Statutes
42 U.S.C. §7401 et seq. (Supp. II, 1990) ....... 2
42 U.S.C. §7410(c) (Supp. II, 1990) ..... 9,10, 18
42 U.S.C. §7410(k) (Supp. II, 1990) ......... 18
Ce She se Se ae oe cee ore a eces 13
42 U.S.C. §7410(n)(1) (Supp. II, 1990). ....... 19
42 U.S.C. $751 le (Supe. 1, 19990)... ww ee 19
42 U.S.C. §7511(a)(1) (Supp. II, 1990). ....... 19
42 U.S.C. §7511a(c)(2) (Supp. II, 1990) ....... 18
42 U.S.C. §7511(e)(5) (Supp. II, 1990). ..... 43, Z>
42 U.S.C. §7512a(a)(7) (Supp. IT, 1990) ....... 15
42 U.S.C. §7515 (Supp. II, 1990). ..... 8, 9, 19, 21
42 U.S.C. §7543(e)(1) (Supp. II, 1990). ....... 16
Ce Ree ee oa eee eer ae ke ees 16
42 U.S.C. §7602(y) (Supp. II, 1990) . . . 7, 10, 22, 25
$5 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
55 Fed.Reg.
136 Cong.Rec. S.16970
(Daily Ed. Oct. 27, 1990)
Page
Regulations
SOSOEZ CISPR) 2 cc tt te tt tte 7
po Ee re 11
36458-36576 (1990). .......... 12
36460(1990) ............0.. 5
36460-61 (1990). ............ 11
36462(1990) ............ 15, 20
36464(1990) .........2.2.04. 3
36469-71 (1990)... ........2... 11
36470 (1990) .. 2... 2. eee 13
36509 (1990) .........22248. 12
36523, 29, 31-32(1990)......... 16
36532(1990) ..........64. 14,17
36533 (1990) ......2. 2c ew eee 16
SG5S7 (1990) 2 ww tweet te wwe 13
SGSTO(TS9G) 2 ww cc tee te ew 16
Legislation
Pewee eee es 8, 24
No. 92-798
In The
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
October Term, 1992
UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION AGENCY, etal.,
Petitioners,
VS.
COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR, INC., et al.,
Respondents.
BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO
PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI
Respondent South Coast Air Quality Management
District (““SCAQMD”) urges that the Environmental
Protection Agency’s (“EPA”) Petition for Writ of
Certiorari (“Petition”) be denied. The Ninth Circuit
Court of Appeals correctly held that EPA is obligated to
complete Federal Implementation Plans (“FIPs”) for
California’s South Coast Air Basin.
STATEMENT OF THE CASE
The SCAQMD incorporates the statement of facts and
historical background set forth by the Court of Appeals,
Petition at 2a-8a, and the Statement of the Case pre-
sented in the Brief in Opposition to EPA’s Petition filed
as
by Respondents Coalition for Clean Air and Sierra Club
(“Coalition Brief’). Coalition Brief at 2-8. The follow-
ing statement clarifies key points.
The South Coast Air Quality Management District
(“SCAQMD”) intervened in this action in 1988 in order
to assure that any FIPs promulgated by EPA would be
supportive of the District’s efforts to achieve clean air.
Under California law, the SCAQMD is the “sole and
exclusive agency within the South Coast Air Basin with
the responsibility for comprehensive air pollution con-
trol,” and has “the duty to represent the citizens of the
basin in influencing the decisions of other public ...
agencies ....” whose actions might affect air quality.
Calif. Health & Saf. Code §40412. The SCAQMD is
responsible for adopting a plan to achieve and maintain
the national ambient air quality standards (“NAAQS”) in
the South Coast Air Basin. Calif. Health & Saf. Code
§40460(a). The SCAQMD’s plan is to form a po‘tion of
the State Implementation Plan (“SIP”) required by the
federal Clean Air Act. Calif. Health & Saf. Code
§40469.
EPA’s obligation to prepare FIPs for the South Coast
Air Basin arose from its disapproval, pursuant to court
order in Abramowitz v. EPA, 832 F.2d 1071 (9th Cir.
1987), of the 1982 state implementation plan for the
South Coast Air Basin. Plaintiffs Coalition for Clean Air
and Sierra Club thereafter filed this action which re-
sulted in the settlement agreement and March 28, 1989
order requiring EPA to adopt FIPs for the South Coast
Air Basin. EPA proposed ozone and CO FIPs for the
South Coast in 1990. Soon after the 1990 Amendments
to the Clean Air Aci, 42 U.S.C. §7401 et seq. (Supp. II,
1990) were signed, EPA moved to vacate the order and
settlement agreement requiring promulgation of the
FIPs.
~
The SCAQMD opposed EPA’s motion because adop-
tion of federal emission control measures such as those
which could be included in a FIP will be necessary in
order for the South Coast Air Basin to attain the NAAQS
for ozone. Significant quantities of volatile organic
compounds and oxides of nitrogen — which react in the
atmosphere to form ozone — are emitted by sources
which are not subject to the regulatory jurisdiction of
state or locai agencies. Such sources, which include
aircraft, new locomotives and certain nonroad vehicles,
are subject to EPA regulatory jurisdiction. Without
federal emission control requirements applicable to such
sources, the South Coast Air Basin cannot attain the
NAAQS for ozone even if all other feasible control
measures are implemented. Appendix attached hereto at
Al-Al1l1. (Declaration of Barry Wallerstein, Excerpts of
Record at 64-76, Coalition for Clean Air, et al. v. EPA,
971 F.2d 219 (9th Cir. 1991) (Nos. 91-55383, 91-55386,
91-55634)).
The need for FIPs in the South Coast is a function of
the severe air pollution problem facing this area. The
South Coast Air Basin includes Orange County and the
nondesert portions of Los Angeles, Riverside and San
Bernardino Counties ——- an area of 10,000 square miles
with a population of over 12 million people. Because of
adverse meteorology, topography and high population
levels, the South Coast Air Basin has by far the worst
ozone and nitrogen dioxide levels in the United States,
and among the worst particulate matter and carbon
monoxide (“CO”) levels of any urbanized area in the
country. The severity and frequency of exceedances of
the NAAQS and the size of the exposed population make
air quality in the South Coast Air Basin one of the na-
tion’s most serious environmental and public health
problems. 55 Fed.Reg. 36464 (1990).
I oeineeen nec eeeenidieni ell
Due to the severity of air pollution in the South Coast,
Stringent control measures applicable to virtually every
emission source will be necessary to attain the NAAQS.
This is demonstrated by the region’s Air Quality
Management Plan (“AQMP”). On March 17, 1989, the
District adopted a revision to the AQMP for the South
Coast Air Basin which, after approval by the California
Air Resources Board (“ARB”), was submitted to EPA on
August 18, 1989 as a proposed revision to California’s
SIP. The AQMP projects attainment of the CO standard
in 2000 and the ozone standard in 2010. The AQMP is a
highly ambitious program of unprecedented scope which
includes detailed descriptions and adoption schedules for
over 140 control measures that are classified into three
tiers. Tier I includes regulations that the SCAQMD can
adopt and begin to implement in the near term using
technology that, for the most part, is available currently.
Under these regulations, the SCAQMD would strin-
gently control emissions created by industry and com-
merce. The Southern California Association of Govern-
ments would coordinate a far-reaching transportation
and land-use management program and the ARB would
require further reductions in emissions from consumer
products and mobile sources. In addition, as discussed
below, the AQMP proposes that the federal government
control emissions from certain sources subject to its
exclusive jurisdiction.
The AQMP would accomplish the remaining emission
reductions, roughly one-half of the total, through regula-
tions designed to create incentives for development of
new emission control technologies. “Tier II” measures
scheduled for adoption by 1998 would force significant
advances in technology, such as significantly reformu-
lated solvents and coatings. Tier III requirements, which
would be fully implemented by 2010, rely upon major
. P
technological breakthroughs to eliminate nearly all emis-
sions from solvents, coatings, and motor vehicles.
The AQMP includes every conceivable control meas-
ure which the District staff determined could feasibly be
implemented given today’s technology and potential
technological breakthroughs by the year 2007. EPA has
acknowledged that the SCAQMD is the largest, best
funded, and most sophisticated agency of its kind. 55
Fed.Reg. 36460 (1990). Despite inclusion of all feasible
measures, the AQMP cannot achieve attainment of the
NAAQS for ozone unless control measures applicable to
sources under exclusive federal jurisdiction are imple-
mented as proposed in the plan. Appendix at A6-A7.
While the SCAQMD opposed EPA’s effort to vacate
the FIP requirement, the District did not oppose EPA’s
alternative request to the District Court in this action to
extend the deadline for promulgation of the subject FIPs.
We believe that EPA will need additional time to deter-
mine the specific form of FIPs required by the 1990
Amendments, to evaluate the latest air quality and other
relevant data, and to propose efficient and effective
FIPs. We believe that the FIPs proposed by EPA for the
South Coast in 1990 can and should be improved in
numerous respects.
=
REASONS WHY THE PETITION
SHOULD BE DENIED
A. Summary of Argument
EPA’s Petition for Writ of Certiorari should be denied
for the following reasons:
1. EPA concedes that the issue presented herein, 7.e.,
whether or not EPA’s preexisting duty to promulgate
FIPs in California is retained under the 1990 Amend-
ments, will not recur. Petition at 26.
2. EPA also concedes that the issue presented herein
is limited to three pending cases, all of which are in the
Ninth Circuit. Jd. There is no conflict among decisions
of the circuit courts regarding this issue.
3. EPA’s position that this case presents an important
question warranting Supreme Court review consists
entirely of two policy arguments regarding the practical
effects of FIPs on state air quality planning and on
sources of pollution. These policy arguments are not
meritorious for two reasons: First, they were presented
to Congress prior to enactment of the 1990 Amendments
as support for EPA’s effort to delete language ultimately
enacted as part of Section 110(c), an effort which was
rejected by Congress, and, second, they are directly
controverted by EPA’s own actions in proposing FIPs
for the South Coast in 1990.
EPA’s first policy argument is that the Ninth Circuit
decision has precluded the federal agency from giving
the state and local authorities the opportunity to make
the first attempt to assemble the mix of pollution con-
trols they believe are appropriate to achieve the emission
reductions necessary — an opportunity they otherwise
would have had under the 1990 Amendments. Petition
=
at 11. This argument is not meritorious because the state
has already adopted a plan which has been under devel-
opment for over a decade and which demonstrates the
need for certain federal control measures to supplement
state and local requirements. Moreover, as is discussed
below, EPA’s 1990 FIP proposals demonstrate that FIPs
can be carefully tailored to preserve the state’s primary
planning role and initial opportunity to determine the
appropriate mix of air pollution controls.
The 1990 FIPs proposed to accomplish this through
two means: First, the FIP proposals were tied to a pro-
posed action by EPA to approve portions of the state
implementation plan (“SIP”) previously submitted for
the South Coast. Since, under the 1990 Amendments, a
FIP is used to “fill the gaps” in a deficient state plan,
§302(y), 42 U.S.C. §7602(y) (Supp. II, 1990), EPA was
able to reduce the scope of the FIPs by approving por-
tions of the state plan. Second, the measures which
would be most difficult and costly for emission sources
to implement were proposed in the FIPs solely as “back-
stop” measures, i.e., measures to be implemented only if
state and local governments fail to achieve emission
reductions adequate to maintain reasonable progress
towards attaining the ambient air quality standards.
None of the “extreme” measures which EPA claims may
have to be included in a FIP (Petition at 24) were pro-
posed to be implemented absent such a failure by the
state to exercise its initial opportunity to determine and
implement emission controls adequate to attain clean air
standards by the same deadlines stated in the 1990
Amendments. 55 Fed.Reg. 36362 (1990).
EPA’s second policy argument in support of its
Petition is that FIPs are inefficient and costly compared
to implementation plans prepared by state and local
governments. This argument is incorrect because many
ois
significant emission sources are beyond the scope of
state and local regulatory jurisdiction. Regulation of
such sources, which include aircraft, new locomotives
and other nonroad vehicles, will be essential for the
South Coast Air Basin to attain air quality standards.
Appendix at AS-A8. The inability of state and local
governments to adequately regulate these sources is a
major “gap” in the SIP for the South Coast which can be
filled by federal measures adopted as part of a FIP.
Absent such federal regulations, state and local authori-
ties will be required to impose severe and probably
impossible control burdens on sources subject to state
and local jurisdiction. FIPs could spread _ these
regulatory burdens across a wider class of sources and
thereby minimize economic impacts.
Finally, EPA’s position conflicts with congressional
intent to build upon past air pollution control efforts,
rather than commencing the air quality planning and
control process anew, and conflicts with the general
savings clause of the 1990 Amendments. §193, 42
U.S.C. §7515 (Supp. II, 1990). The legislative history
for the savings clause states that EPA is obligated to
“complete ongoing FIP processes” for the purposes of
“ensuring that the standards are met by the statutory
deadlines” and that “EPA has the obligation to adopt
control measures for sources which it exclusively con-
trols when those controls are necessary to help attain
national standards ....” 136 Cong.Rec. S.16970 (Daily
Ed. Oct. 27, 1990).
B. Argument
1. Introduction
The SCAQMD supports the arguments regarding the
proper interpretation of Section 110(c) of the Clean Air
Act, 42 U.S.C. §7410c (Supp. II, 1990), stated by
Respondents Coalition for Clean Air and Sierra Club in
their Brief in Opposition to EPA’s Petition. As is de-
scribed in the Coalition Brief, Section 110(c) was not
materially altered by the 1990 Amendments and, there-
fore, preexisting FIP obligations were not vitiated.
Moreover, EPA’s contemporaneous interpretation of
Section 110(c) and representation to Congress in a letter
from EPA Administrator William Reilly to House of
Representatives Speaker Foley prior to passage of the
1990 Amendments should be accorded greater weight
than the contrary interpretation subsequently stated by
EPA during the pendency of this litigation. See Coali-
tion Brief at 4-5.
The above-described arguments in the Coalition Brief
will not be repeated here. We will, instead, explain in
this brief why EPA’s policy arguments regarding the
practical effects of FIPs are unfounded. In addition, we
will explain why the Section 193 Savings Clause, 42
U.S.C. §7515 (Supp. II, 1990), provides an alternative
ground for affirming the decision of the Ninth Circuit.
The effect of the Savings Clause was fully briefed by all
parties below but, because the Ninth Circuit heid that
Section 110(c) imposes a current obligation to promul-
gate FIPs for the South Coast, it did not reach the
Savings Clause question.
ile
=
2. FIPs Need Not Interfere with the
Primary Role of State and Local
Authorities in Air Quality Planning
EPA argues that the Ninth Circuit decision makes the
federal agency “initially and primarily responsible for
developing air pollution control strategies” and has
precluded EPA from “giving the state and local authori-
ties their rightful opportunity to make the first attempt to
assemble the mix of air pollution controls they believe
are appropriate to achieve the huge emission reductions
necessary — an opportunity they would otherwise have
under the 1990 Amendments.” Petition at 11. EPA,
however, ignores the fact that the SCAQMD has already
made the first attempt to develop an appropriate mix of
air pollution controls. In fact, we have been attempting
to do so for over a decade. What our attempts have
shown us is that certain federal measures are needed in
addition to all of the state and local measures we can
muster.
EPA also ignores the fact that the Clean Air Act
clearly allows FIPs to be limited in scope to what is
necessary to support state efforts. The Amendments
define a FIP as a plan or portion thereof promulgated by
the Administrator to “fill all or a portion of a gap” or
otherwise correct an inadequacy in a state implemen-
tation plan. Section 302(y), 42 U.S.C. §7602(y) (Supp.
II, 1990). A FIP must include sufficient enforceable
emission limitations or other control measures to, in
conjunction with state and local measures, provide for
attainment of the relevant national ambient air quality
standard. IJd., see also, Section 110(c) of 1977 Act, 42
U.S.C. §7410(c) (requiring promulgation of an im-
plementation plan “or portion thereof” if state fails to
submit an adequate plan).
ane reenenatemenaemanmrnaresamamnmmmnsmmnaaaasaie
oe
EPA’s 1990 FIP proposals demonstrate how these
provisions can be used to support rather than supplant
state and local efforts. As EPA stated in its 1990 FIP
proposals:
EPA strongly supports State and loca! initia-
tives .... Wherever legally permissible, EPA’s
own proposal relies, and builds upon, and rein-
forces these initiatives. In this way, we hope to
minimize federal intrusion, avoid conflict with
and duplication of local efforts, and encourage
speedy implementation of the measures State
and local authorities wish to adopt .... EPA
has attempted to design its FIP so as to lend
maximum support to the continued develop-
ment of the State plan, and to allow it eventu-
ally to supplant the federal plan in the manner
intended by the framers of the Clean Air Act.
55 Fed.Reg. 36460-61 (1990).
Consistent with its duty to fill the gaps in the state’s
plan, EPA proposed as part of its 1990 FIP notice to take
action to approve, disapprove and defer action on provi-
sions of the state implementation plan submitted by
California for the South Coast Air Basin. 55 Fed.Reg.
36458 (1990)." By approving as much of the state plan
as possible, EPA minimized the scope of the required
FIPs.
1 The proposed actions were based on EPA’s interpretation of the
types of state measures it could approve under requirements of the
1977 version of the Clean Air Act. EPA proposed to deny full
approval and emission reduction credit for portions of the SIP
primarily because such provisions were not yet in the form of
adopted regulations or firm commitments, or relied on technologies
to be developed in the future. 55 Fed.Reg. 36469-71 (1990).
nn eeaepnaacunanpaammiiiguii A
|.
The 1990 notice then proposed FIP control require-
ments which were structured to preserve the primary role
of state and local authorities in air quality planning. To
do this, the proposed FIPs consisted of two parts: The
first was a set of “core measures” which, as EPA said,
“are expected to be technically feasible, cost-effective,
legally enforceable, and able to be implemented expe-
ditiously.” 55 Fed.Reg. 36509 (1990). These measures
consisted of reformulated gasoline requirements, stand-
ards for light-duty cars and trucks, and controls on
marine vessel tanks. The FIPs then proposed two alter-
native approaches for achieving the more difficult emis-
sions reductions to occur after 1995. Both approaches
would serve to “backstop” the SIP. In the first approach,
the “regulatory FIP,” EPA would immediately put into
place regulations requiring future emission reductions.
These regulations would be withdrawn prior to imple-
mentation if the state and local authorities implemented
measures which would achieve progress adequate to
attain the ozone and CO standards by the years 2010 and
2000, respectively (the same deadlines established in the
1990 Amendments). Under the second approach, the
“committal FIP,” EPA would offer enforceable commit-
ments to develop rules in the future in accordance with a
set schedule. Because EPA would have additional time
to develop these regulations, they could be tailored to
available technology in order to minimize economic
impacts. The committal FIP, like the regulatory FIP,
was designed as a backstop to state and local measures
and would be rescinded to the extent that the state
achieved adequate progress towards attainment. 55
Fed.Reg. 36458-36576 (1990).2 By proposing control
2 EPA adopted a schedule of reasonable further progress (RFP)
which amounts to an annual rate of reduction of 4% per year for
(continued)
ee
» S%s
measures in the form of backstops, EPA’s FIP proposal
assured that state and local authorities would have the
initial Opportunity to determine the types of control
requirements which would be imposed, and would retain
the flexibility to update the air quality plans based on the
latest data and planning.
Under the 1990 Amendments, EPA has greater
latitude to defer to state and local decisionmaking than
under the prior Act because the Amendments contain
provisions which will enable EPA to approve a greater
portion of the SIP for South Coast, thereby further
diminishing the scope of the FIPs EPA is obligated to
promulgate. For example, the 1990 Amendments, for
the first time, authorize EPA to approve SIP provisions
“which anticipate development of new control tech- ‘
niques or improvement of existing control technologies
and an attainment demonstration based on such provi-
sions.” Section 182(e)(5), 42 U.S.C. §7511a(e)(5)
(Supp. II, 1990).? The scope of the FIPs which EPA is
fn. continued)
OC and NO, and 4.5% per year for CO (based on year 2000
attainment date). EPA proposed to monitor the emission recuctions
and, if the tracking demonstrated that the required emissions
reductions would be achieved without backstops, the backstops
would be rescinded. These rates of reduction are similar to those
proposed in the SIP prepared by the SCAQMD. 55 Fed.Reg. 36537
(1990).
. Additionally, EPA is now authorized to approve a plan revision
based on a commitment to adopt specific enforceable measures by a
date certain, not later than one year after the date of approval.
$110(k)(4), 42 U.S.C. §7410(k)(4). In its notice, EPA recognized
that “if the Clean Air Act is amended before final rulemaking and
includes new requirements that alter the criteria for control measure
approval, EPA’s proposed actions, including the timetable for
submitting fully enforceable measures, will be revised to be consis-
tent with the new statutory provisions.” 55 Fed.Reg. 36470 (1990).
«ae
obligated to promulgate would therefore be reduced as
EPA approves, and thereby defers to, the products of
state and local planning efforts.
3. FIPs Can Include Cost-Effective
Control Measures which are Neces-
sary for Attainment but which State
and Local Governments Lack Auth-
ority to Implement, Thereby Spread-
ing Regulatory Burdens and Reduc-
ing Economic Impacts
EPA argues that the only type of regulatory plan that
it has the means to promulgate and implement would
necessarily consist of a limited number of severe meas-
ures that would indiscriminately force huge cutbacks in
emissions from most mobile, stationary, and area
sources. Petition at 12. EPA argues that such extreme
measures would include gas rationing, no-drive days,
limits on vehicle registration, bans on high-emitting
vehicles, and huge cutbacks in solvent use. I/d. at 24.
Such measures, EPA argues, would inflict far more
economic and social dislocation on California than
would a SIP. /d. at 23. These arguments are incorrect
as demonstrated by EPA’s own 1990 FIP proposals.
The proposed 1990 FIPs had to achieve the same goal
that exists today under the 1990 Amendments — attain-
ment of the NAAQS — but they did not contain any
control measures mandating gasoline rationing, limits on
vehicle registration or bans on high-emitting vehicles.‘
No-drive days were merely one alternative proposal in
4 EPA merely requested comments on these general topics. 55
Fed.Reg. 36532 (1990).
e
the CO FIP. With regard to cutbacks in solvent use,
the Petition does not point out that the proposed S/P also
contains extremely stringent control measures, such as a
virtual 100% elimination of volatile organic compounds
(the components of solvents, coatings and other chemi-
cals which react to form ozone). Thus, part, if not all, of
the “economic dislocation” resulting from the solvent
measures which EPA suggests would occur under a FIP
is simply a function of the enormous emission reductions
necessary to attain and is not a function of which agency
issues the control requirements.
In any case, under EPA’s 1990 FIP proposal, no
severe measures such as those described above would be
implemented by EPA in the first instance. Except for
the relatively easily implemented “core” measures, all
measures in the 1990 FIPs are “backstops” to be imple-
mented only if the state and local authorities fail to
implement control measures achieving emission reduc-
tions necessary to attain. If such failure occurred, im-
plementation of the federal measures would be triggered
only to the extent necessary to restore adequate progress
towards attainment. 55 Fed.Reg. 36462 (1990). Thus,
contrary to the Petition, the FIP can, and EPA’s 1990
proposal did, give state and local authorities the opportu-
nity to implement the most cost-effective measures pos-
sible and thereby avoid implementation of federal
measures.
Moreover, and perhaps most importantly, federal
control measures will be required in the South Coast
> The CO FIP may not be necessary at all, even if the previously-
submitted SIP is not fully approvable, because the SCAQMD has
prepared an updated CO attainment plan as required by Section
187(a)(7) of the 1990 Amendments. 42 U.S.C. §$7512a(a)(7) (Supp.
II, 1990) (requiring state to, by November 15, 1992, submit a plan to
attain the CO NAAQS).
eee aa ee
ce
District if this area is to ever attain the ambient air qual-
ity standard for ozone. The SIP for the South Coast
District includes every measure which state and local
authorities determined could feasibly be implemented.
This includes measures that would require application of
known technologies as well as substantial reliance on
measures which will only be implementable in the future
if substantial new technologies are developed, e.g.,
electric vehicles. Yet despite these ambitious plans, the
SIP barely demonstrates attainment with the national
ambient air quality standard for ozone. Appendix at A7.
Many of the control measures relied upon in the pro-
posed SIP are applicable to sources which are subject to
exclusive federal jurisdiction. These sources include
new construction and farm equipment with engines
less than 175 horsepower,° aircraft,’ and new locomo-
tives.2 These sources emit Significant quantities of air
pollutants (55 Fed.Reg. 36523, 29, 31-32 (1990)) but are
relatively uncontrolled compared to sources subject to
state and local authority. Without emission limitations
applicable to these sources, the South Coast District
cannot attain the ambient air quality standard for
ozone.” ‘This is known with certainty now; there is no
® State and local regulation is preempted by the 1990 Amendments.
§$209(e)(1), 42 U.S.C. §7543(e)(1) (Supp. II, 1990).
7 State and local regulation is preempted by §233 of the Clean Air
Act, 42 U.S.C. §7573.
8 State and local regulation of new locomotives is preempted by
Section 209(e)(1) of the Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. §7543(e)(1)
(Supp. II, 1990).
® Petition at 40a. EPA itself bas apparently concluded that at least
some of these sources must be controlled in the South Coast Air
Basin. EPA has proposed to regulate some of these sources in its
proposed FIP for the South Coast Air Basin. 55 Fed.Reg. 36533,
36570 (1990) (construction equipment and other off-highway mobile
(continued)
ee
need to await another round of SIP submittals to deter-
mine whether or not these sources must be controlled.
Absent federal controls applicable to sources subject
to exclusive federal jurisdiction, state and local authori-
ties will be required to impose severe, and in all
likelihood impossible, control requirements applicable to
sources within state and local regulatory jurisdiction.
(As discussed previously, the AQMP barely demon-
Strates attainment of the ozone NAAQS assuming imple-
mentation of all feasible measures, including the federal
control measures.) Thus, EPA’s arguments regarding
the inefficiency and cost impacts of FIPs are incorrect.
Without federal controls, the burden faced by sources
within the South Coast District would be increased,
probably to impossible levels.
In short, what is required to effectuate congressional
intent that air quality standards be attained as expe-
dittously as practicable with, as EPA states, “concern for
ensuring future economic growth and well-being,” Peti-
tion at 10, is the “federal-state partnership for the control
of air pollution” described by the Ninth Circuit. Petition
at 15a. The regulatory authorities of local, state and
federal governments must be brought to bear in a coordi-
nated fashion in order to achieve the congressional goal
of clean air in the South Coast Air Basin. A federal
implementation plan which, as Congress mandated, “fills
the gaps” in state plans, would achieve this objective.
(fn. wos a 7
sources); 36532 (1990) (limiting growth in emissions from locomo-
tives, ships and aircraft). The District has commented to EPA that
the proposed FIP does not propose to adequately regulate these
sources.
, t
4. EPA’s Position is Contrary to Con-
gress’ Intent to Build Upon Past
Efforts So As to Achieve Expedi-
tious Attainment, Rather than Com-
mencing the Air Quality Planning
Process Anew
EPA’s position is contrary to Congress’ manifest
intent because it would create a potential seven year
hiatus in needed federal control efforts. Congress’ pur-
pose in adopting the 1990 Amendments certainly was
not to make attainment of healthful air a more difficult
or lengthy process. Similarly, Congress clearly did not
intend to ignore well over a decade of effort under the
Clean Air Act by requiring the federal control process to
begin anew. Yet, as is set forth below, these are the
consequences of the EPA’s erroneous interpretation.
Under the 1990 Amendments, the state has until
November 15, 1994 to submit a SIP revision demon-
Strating that attainment of the ozone standard will timely
occur. §182(c)(2), 42 U.S.C. §7511la(c)(2) (Supp. I,
1990). EPA has one year to review such a submittal,
and two years thereafter to promulgate a FIP, §110(c),
(k), 42 U.S.C. §7410(c), (k) (Supp. II, 1990), for a total
of seven years from the date of enactment. Under EPA’s
interpretation, this is the earliest that EPA would be
required to adopt a FIP demonstrating attainment of the
ozone standard. Yet, as a result of decades of state and
local air quality planning pursuant to the Clean Air Act,
it is known today that certain federal controls will
be required and that a seven year delay in their adop-
tion would jeopardize timely attainment. Appendix at
. FC
A7-A8.!°
Contrary to EPA’s position, the entire structure of the
1990 Amendments evidences an intent to build on prior
efforts without any hiatus in planning or implementation
actions. For example, preexisting SIPs remain in effect,
§110(n)(1), 42 U.S.C. §7410(n)(1) (Supp. II, 1990),
previously-required control requirements are saved,
§193, 42 U.S.C. §7515 (Supp. II, 1990), preexisting
guidance remains in effect, Jd., and existing state
implementation plans must be augmented, not replaced,
by addition of new or enhanced control measures.
§110(n)(1), 42 U.S.C. §7410(n)(1), §182, 42 U.S.C.
§7511la (Supp. Il, 1990). The Amendments also retain
the requirement that attainment of the NAAQS occur “as
expeditiously as_ practicable.” §181, 42 U.S.C.
§7511(a)(1) (Supp. II, 1990).
Moreover, contrary to EPA’s argument, Congress did
not eliminate the fundamental element of the require-
ment that triggered EPA’s FIP obligation. That element
is the requirement that the states have an enforceable
plan which contains control measures sufficient to attain
the ambient air quality standards. In enacting the 1990
Amendments, Congress recognized state failures to meet
this requirement but chose not to eliminate or change it;
rather Congress merely specified new deadlines and
certain plan elements for achieving that same goal.
There is nothing in the SIP or proposed 1990 FIPs which
10 Emission controls applicable to many sources, including those
subject to exclusive federal jurisdiction, will require significant lead
times to develop and implement. In addition, many of the above-
described sources have long useful lives so that, to the extent that
the common oractice of applying emission standards only to new
units is followed, the public may not see any air quality benefits due
to control of these sources until well into the 21st century. Appen-
dix at A6-A8.
aaa
« -
is inconsistent with either the new attainment deadlines
or the state’s primary role in fulfilling the planning
requirements of the 1990 Amendments.!!
5. The Section 193 Savings Clause
Provides an Alternative Ground for
Affirming the Decision
Because the majority below found that the language
of Section 110(c) continued EPA’s FIP obligations, it
did not address the effect of Section 193. Petition at 8a.
However, the Savings Clause provides an alternative
basis for upholding the decision. The General Savings
Clause of the 1990 Amendments states as follows:
Each regulation, standard, rule, notice, order
and guidance promulgated or issued by the
Administrator under this Act, as in effect be-
fore the date of the enactment of the Clean Air
Act Amendments of 1990 shall remain in effect
according to its terms, except to the extent
otherwise provided under this Act, inconsistent
11 State planning procedures and SIP submittal requirements
specified in the Act would have to continue to be followed even if a
FIP is promulgated. If the state fails to submit one of the many
specifically required SIP elements (e.g., clean fuel requirements,
enhanced vehicle inspection and maintenance), the FIP process
would be triggered for such deficiency as contemplated by Congress.
To-the extent that the state submits fully approvable measures, they
could be substituted ‘or portions of the FIP if they achieve equiva-
lent emission reductions. A similar program preserving the state’s
primary role in air quality control was proposed by EPA as part of
its 1990 FIP proposal for the South Coast Air Basin. Moreover, the
attainment deadlines in the 1990 Amendments are the same as the
projected dates in both the proposed SIP for the South Coast and
EPA’s 1990 FIP proposals. 55 Fed.Reg. 36462 (1990).
o Mo
with any provision of this Act, or revised by
the Administrator. No control requirement in
effect, or required to be adopted by an order,
settlement agreement, or plan in effect before
the date of the enactment of the Clean Air Act
Amendments of 1990 in any area which is a
nonattainment area for any air pollutant may
be modified after such enactment in any man-
ner unless the modification insures equivalent
or greater emission reductions of such air
pollutant. §193, 42 U.S.C. §7515 (Supp. I,
1990). (Emphasis added.)
By its terms, the General Savings Clause is directly
applicable to the instant settlement agreement and order
to promulgate FIPs for the South Coast Air Basin. The
FIPs are to be made up of “control requirements” and
were “required to be adopted” by an “order” and “settle-
ment agreement” “in effect before the date of enactment
of the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990.” Thus,
under the General Savings Clause, the FIPs may not be
modified after enactment of the 1990 Amendments “in
any manner” unless the modification ensures equivalent
or greater emission reductions. Here, EPA is not seek-
ing to ensure equivalent or greater emission reductions;
rather, it seeks a total and unconditional elimination of
the requirement to promulgate FIPs. Congress has ex-
pressly prohibited this under Section 193.
EPA attempted to avoid the literal meaning of the
General Savings Clause by arguing that the term
“control requirement” refers only to a discrete regulation
directed at a specific source of pollution, or an order to
promulgate a FIP containing a few specific control re-
quirements. EPA argued that since the settlemeni agree-
ment and order in the instant case required development
of plans including many control measures which had not
o 29.
yet been specificaliy defined, the General Savings
Clause is inapplicable. :
The distinction which EPA invents between an order
mandating adoption of a control requirement which is
specifically defined at the time of the order, and one
which is not yet specifically defined at the time of the
order, finds no basis in the statute and is contrary to
congressional intent evidenced by the broad wording of
the savings clause. The FIPs required by the settlement
agreement and order in this case must, by definition, be
made up of “control measures,”!? a phrase certainly
encompassed within the broad term “control require-
ments.” The expansive language in the General Savings
Clause (e.g., specifying that control requirements are
preserved whether “required to be adopted by an order,
settlement agreement, or plan”) also evidences congres-
sional intent to ensure the broad applicability of the
General Savings Clause.
Moreover, the distinction between defined and un-
defined measures which EPA makes is illogical from a
policy perspective. The fact that the proposed South
Coast Air Basin FIP must contain numerous control
measures which were not specifically defined at the time
of the settlement agreement and order is a function of
the massive air quality problem this area faces, the great
number and breadth of control requirements necessary to
address the problem, and the failure of EPA to carry out
its obligation to timely disapprove the SIP and develop
12 The Clean Air Act defines a FIP as:
a plan ... which includes enforceable emission limita-
tions or other control measures, means or techniques .. .,
and provides for attainment of the relevant national
ambient air quality standard. (Emphasis added.) §302(y)
at 42 U.S.C. §7602(y) (Supp. Il, 1990).
«Mt.
FIPs. It would be anomalous to interpret the General
Savings Clause as imposing a lesser control obligation
for highly polluted areas such as the South Coast Air
Basin than for areas in which far lesser controls are
required. Moreover, under EPA’s backwards formula-
tion, the agency would be relieved of the FIP obligation
primarily because it failed to carry out its duty to disap-
prove the SIP and develop specific FIP measures in a
timely fashion. See Abramowitz v. EPA, 832 F.2d 1071
(9th Cir. 1987).
Finally, the legislative history of the General Savings
Clause demonstrates congressional intent to preserve
EPA’s obligation to promulgate FIPs. In the Congres-
sional Record for October 27, 1990, Senator Baucus,
Chairman of the Conference Committee for the 1990
Amendments, explained the purpose of the General
Savings Clause. As floor manager of the 1990 Amend-
ments and Chairman of the Conference Committee,
Senator Baucus’ remarks are entitled to substantia!
weight, Mills v. United States, 713 F.2d 1249 (7th Cir
1983). Senator Baucus stated that under the 19%
Amendments EPA need not promulgate complete Fl!
for the South Coast “based on requirements
Act.” However, according to Senator Bau
obligated to “complete ongoing FIP pr
purposes of “ensuring that the standards are ”
statutory deadlines.” In discussing ‘me = a
FIPs, Senator Baucus stated that “EPA fas ime os f
to adopt control measures for sources whict
sively controls when those controls are necesse
attain national standards or meet other requiren
o Bhs
the Act ....”'> Senator Chafee made a similar state-
ment in a colloquy with Senator Wilson.
The interpretation found in the statement of Senator
Baucus that EPA need not adopt FIPs based on the old
Act, but must complete ongoing FIP processes to assure
attainment, is directly supported by language of the 1990
13 The full statement reads as follows:
“The savings clause in the new legislation is intended to
ensure that no backsliding occurs from implementation of
adopted, currently feasible measures that EPA has
approved as part of a SIP in the past, or currently feasible
measures that EPA has added to state plans on its own
initiative or pursuant to a court order or settlement,
including a Federal Implementation Plan. We do not
intend that this savings clause requires EPA to finalize
the Federal Implementation Plan in California and
preempt the state’s and regional air quality planning that
is ongoing in Los Angeles area and will otherwise be
required under this legislation. If EPA were to promul-
gate complete new plans based on requirements of the old
Act, the area subject to those federal plans would be
deprived of the opportunity to use the significantly
revised and clearly more workable requirements of the
new legislation. We agree that this would be un-
reasonable, particularly since the proposed FIP fails to
recognize the critical role that local governments play in
reducing transportation-related emissions.
“The savings clause provides EPA with significant
discretion with respect to FIPs in California. EPA has
the obligation to adopt control measures for sources
which it exclusively controls when those controls are
necessary to help attain national standards or meet other
requirements of the Act but, beyond that, EPA should
complete ongoing FIP processes only for the purposes of
ensuring that the standards are met by the statutory
deadlines.” 136 Cong.Rec. S.16970 (Daily Ed. Oct. 27,
1990). (Emphasis added.)
ee oe Se eT
- 9s.
Amendments which provide EPA flexibility to approve
greater portions of the SIP, e.g., §182(e)(5), 42 U.S.C.
§7511(e)(5) (Supp. II, 1990), and which define a FIP
as a device to fill the remaining gaps in the state’s
attainment demonstration. §302(y), 42 U.S.C. §7602(y)
(Supp. II, 1990). The authoritative statements by the
Chair of the Conference Committee are totally incom-
patible with EPA’s position that it has absolutely no
obligation to promulgate any type of FIP in the South
Coast Air Basin. If any type of FIP obligation survives,
as it does, EPA’s position must be rejected.
CONCLUSION
For the foregoing reasons, EPA’s Petition for Writ of
Certiorari should be denied.
DATED: December 17, 1992.
Respectfully submitted,
PETER M. GREENWALD
Counsel of Record
for Respondent
SOUTH COAST AIR QUALITY
MANAGEMENT DISTRICT
APPENDIX
-A 1-
The Declaration of Barry Wallerstein as included in the
Excerpts of Record at 64-76, Coalition for Clean Air, et
al. v. EPA, 971 F.2d 219 (9th Cir. 1991) (Nos. 91-55383,
91-55386, 91-55634) reads as follows:
DECLARATION OF BARRY R. WALLERSTEIN
I, Barry R. Wallerstein, affirm and declare that the
following statements are true and correct to the best of
my knowledge and belief and are based on my personal
knowledge or on information contained in the records of
the South Coast Air Quality Management District
(“SCAQMD”) or supplied to me by employees at the
SCAQMD.
1. My name is Barry R. Wallerstein, and I am em-
ployed by the South Coast Air Quality Management
District (SCAQMD) as the Director of Planning.
2. My educational background consists of a Doc-
torate in Environmental Science and Engineering from
the University of California at Los Angeles (1988) and a
Bachelor’s (1977) and Master’s (1980) degree in Bio-
logical Science from the University of Southern
California.
3. As Director of Planning for the South Coast Air
Quality Management District I am _ responsible for
development of the Air Quality Management Plan
(AQMP or Plan) to attain federal and state air quality
Standards and all District analyses related to attainment
of federal ambient air quality standards in the South
Coast Air Basin. This inciudes: pollutant emission
control strategy development, air quality modeling,
economic impact analysis, environmental impact evalua-
tion, energy conservation and demand analysis, and
public health assessments. There are currently 75 staff
positions within the South Coast Air Quality Manage-
ment District Planning Division.
hi
4. From August 1988 until January 1989, I was an
Environmental Control Administrator for Northrop
Corporation. My duties included administration of
company-wide efforts to comply with hazardous waste
regulations and development of initiatives to promote
waste minimization.
5. From July 1984 until August 1988, I was a mem-
ber of the South Coast Air Quality Management District
staff, most recently in the Rule Development Division as
the Program Supervisor for coating and solvent rules to
implement the AQMP. Prior to that position I served as
the Program Supervisor in the Planning Division for
development of short and long-term control measures for
the 1989 Air Quality Management Plan Revision.
6. From 1982 to July 1984, I was a member of the
rule development staff in the Mobile Source Division of
the California Air Resources Board (ARB). My activi-
ties included development of ARB’s portion of the 1982
State Implementation Plan, diesel particulate standards
for passenger cars, tailpipe standards for motorcycles,
and emission test procedures for heavy-duty vehicles.
7. Prior to 1982, I was employed as a research
assistant on a variety of projects related to new energy
technologies and the effects of coastal power plants on
the marine ecosystem. Several of these projects in-
cluded evaluation of technologies currently proposed to
reduce air pollutant emissions in California.
8. The purpose of the Air Quality Management Plan
is to set forth a comprehensive program for the South
Coast Air Basin to achieve all federal and state ambient
air quality standards. The Plan is intended to‘serve as
the South Coast Air Basin portion of the State Im-
plementation Plan required by the Federal Clean Air Act.
In addition, the Plan is designed to comply with all other
requirements of the federal and California Clean Air
Acts.
%
®
i
3
3
:
7
4
r
3
-A 3-
9. The South Coast Air Basin, which comprises all of
Orange County and the non-desert portions of Los
Angeles, Riverside and San Bernardino Counties, has the
worst air quality in the nation. Despite having put into
place many strict controls, the Basin still fails to meet
the federal air quality standards for four of the six
criteria pollutants.
10. In 1989, one or more of the federal standards
were exceeded on 219 days in the Basin. The federal
ozone standard was exceeded on 120 days, over three
times as frequently in the Basin as in any other area of
the United States. The Basin was the only area in the
country to exceed the federal nitrogen dioxide standard.
It exceeded the carbon monoxide standard most fre-
quently as well, with two and one-half times as many
exceedances as the next worst area of the nation.
11. Attachment | shows the maximum pollutant
concentrations in 1989 as a percentage of the state and
federal standards. Attachment 2 shows the percentage of
days, months, or quarters which each pollutant exceeded
the standards at the most affected location.
12. The AQMP includes all the potential control
measures that could possibly be available by the year
2010 given current technology and possible technologi-
cal breakthroughs. The identified control measures are
categorized into three tiers, based upon their readiness
for implementation. Full implementation of all three
tiers will reduce ozone precursor emissions by more than
80 percent and carbon monoxide emissions by ap-
proximately 60 percent. Such emission reductions are
needed to attain federal standards. The difficulty of
achieving these reductions is clear when one realizes
that significant sources are currently controlled by over
80-90%. The AQMP thus proposes even more stringent
controls and controls applicable to every conceivable
source, from utility boilers to barbecues.
-A 4-
13. Tier I control measures are defined as those that
can be adopted in the next five years with currently
available technological applications and management
practices. Implementation (and construction) of these
measures will occur over the next twenty years. Several
of these measures are directed at the control of pollution
sources which are solely under federal jurisdiction.
14. Over 120 Tier I control measures are currently
identified in the AQMP. They reduce emissions by:
* reduction in the use of pollutant-emitting
materials:
* use of the most efficient pollution control
devices;
* programs to control fugitive emissions from
industrial processes;
* maximizing the efficiency of the transportation
infrastructure to provide less polluting forms of
transportation;
* maximizing the effectiveness of existing
measures through improved administrative
practices;
* seeking public and private commitments for the
required implementation actions.
15. Tier II requires further advancement or improve-
ment of existing Ozone and PM10 contro! technologies.
Tier II is expected to be implemented in the next ten to
fifteen years. In some cases, new technological applica-
tions not presently on the market are required, but these
could be expected to develop through continuous im-
provements and refinements to products currently
available. Regulatory intervention is employed when-
ever necessary to expedite commercialization of new
products and to mitigate future emission growth. Tier II
also includes measures which require additional funding
and/or legislative authority. Sources solely under
we *
federal jurisdiction are also targeted as part of the Tier II
control strategies.
16. The Tier II measures would reduce emissions by:
* extending current technological applications
beyond the levels historically pursued;
* regulatory intervention through technology-
forcing standards or emission charges, e.g., by
requiring a 50% reduction in solvent emissions
from coatings (which already must meet strin-
gent limits);
* developing public and private commitments for
the required implementation actions, including
additional funding and/or legislative authority
as necessary.
17. The Tier III programs are designed to bring about
technological breakthroughs to further reduce reactive
organic gas emissions to achieve the federal ozone
standard. These programs are directed at the sectors
where significant emissions still exist after implementa-
tion of Tiers I and II.
18. The Tier III programs include:
¢ Solvents and Coatings in industrial, commer-
cial, and residential applications.
* Remaining petroleum based-fuel emissions in
stationary and mobile applications.
* Unlike Tier II, which focuses on _ further
strengthening known emission controls, Tier III
calls for efforts to develop new technology to
reduce remaining emissions.
19. All three tiers of controls are needed to achieve
attainment of the federal ambient air quality standards,
including ozone and carbon monoxide. Recently com-
pleted analysis indicates, with full implementation of all
three tiers, the Basin will achieve the federal carbon
ys
monoxide standard in the year 2000 and the federal
ozone standard in the year 2010. These attainment
projections include control of emissions sources under
federal jurisdiction and without such controls attainment
will not be possible.
20. The proposed 1991 AQMP contains several
control measures aimed at controlling emissions from
sources subject to exclusive federal jurisdiction includ-
ing aircraft, locomotives, and construction equipment
and farm equipment. In addition, the AQMP proposes
measures for implementation by the federal government
which, because of practical or legal constraints, require
federal regulations to fully or effectively control their
emissions. Such sources include outer continental shelf
operations and marine vessels.
21. The above-described sources subject to federal
regulation contribute three percent of total! ROG emis-
sions and 11 percent of NO, emissions in the Basin. The
emissions reduction potential associated with these
measures is estimated to be 23 tons per day of ROG, 60
tons per day of NO,, and 32 tons per day of CO in 2010.
AQMP control measures for these federally-regulated
facilities are listed in Attachment 3. These are ex-
tremely significant emission levels, particularly in an
area such as the District which must stringently regulate
sources as small as personal deodorants in order to
attain.
22. In addition, while not currently addressed by an
AQMP measure, motor vehicles originating out-of-state
must also be characterized as sources under exclusive
federal jurisdiction. Currently, these vehicles constitute
approximately 20 percent of the in-use vehicle fleet in
the South Coast Air Quality Management District, which
corresponds to 1.2 million vehicles. Since emission
standards for out-of-state vehicles are substantially less
Stringent than California vehicles, the potential
iciieaiiaaiial
i Ba
emissions penalty associated with their operation can be
significant. The 1990 Amendments to the Clean Air Act
provide that EPA must determine whether or not to
impose “Phase II” emission standards applicable to such
“49 state” vehicles sold in 2003 and later. If EPA
decides to impose these standards, emission reductions
in the South Coast Air Basin are estimated to be as high
as six tons per day of hydrocarbons, 11 tons per day of
NO,, and 60 tons per day of CO. Such reductions would
substantially aid the District’s attainment effort and
reduce the control burden applicable to sources subject
to state and local jurisdiction.
23. Moreover, every conceivable emission reduction
that is feasible is included in the AQMP and the AQMP
barely attains the federal ozone ambient air quality
standard. Even if unforeseen or targeted technological
breakthroughs were to occur (beyond the ambitious
assumptions in the AQMP), available control measures
on federal sources would still be needed to achieve
reasonable further progress in the early to intermediate
years of Plan implementation, and to attain as ex-
peditiously as practicable or required by the Clean Air
Act.
24. If the decision to adopt control measures applica-
ble to these federally-regulated sources is delayed from
the adoption schedules set forth in Attachment 3, timely
attainment of the ozone ambient air quality standard will
be jeopardized. Controls applicable to many of these
sources (e.g., aircraft), can take years to develop and
many more years to implement. Control requirements
for mobile sources generally are only applied to new
units. This, and the long useful lives of aircraft, con-
struction equipment, locomotives, efc., would mean that
significant emission reductions would not be realized
until many years after the effective date of the emission
limits. In my opinion, attainment of the federal ozone
-A 8-
ambient air quality standard will be made substantially
more difficult if development efforts for control require-
ments applicable to the above-described sources do not
commence soon and adoption of regulations is delayed
beyond the dates set forth in Attachment 3.
I declare under penalty of perjury that the foregoing is
true and correct.
Executed this 2list day of December, 1990, at
El Monte, California.
/s/ Barry R. Wallerstein
Barry R. Wallerstein
spiepueys [er9ped pue a3e3S Jo Ue DATSed se
suot}erAquaeoUOD Fue ANTTOd wNWTXeW 686T
7-2 dAYUND1d
(sO, IENH (jenuuUR (jenuue
yyyuow) (UNoU-ve2) (Wenuuy) = 74MEU-1) —-/4NOU-t) (unoy-g) = (4NOY-1)
301xOIG + 3GIxXOIG JGIXONOW
aval JivsaIns OlWd HN4INS NADOYLIN NOSHYVD J3NOZO
rs ay ae ae cena (| 0
> pn * ’
a
on s
< ¥ — — + OO
* GYVONVLS
BH
eG
- 002
- OO€
GHYVGNVLS 1VH3034 Ba ;
GUHUVGNVLS J1iVLS By
»- OOF
GHYVGNVLS 4O LN30”3d
-A 10-
ATTACHMENT 2
SUOT}RRDOT pozeTJW FSOW FE SprepueIS TeTeped pue a3e3S
butpssoxg sieqzrend/syquow/sAeq Jo 3UuscdTed 686T
€-¢c dwynolId
‘@PpIxO!p UeHOIIJU 10) PJEPURIS JesEPS) W4d} JOYS OU PUB JjEJINS JO) PIEPULIS [BJBPS) OU S| B19 I +~
‘PJBPURIS JesePaj 10) S4ajsENb jo jUGDIEd puUe PJepUL;S |)e}S 10) SYJUOW JO }UBIIOd-
(J0,18NO (jenuve
/YWUOW) (unoy-pzZ) sanoy-vZ) (unoy-1) (unoy-L) (unoy-@g) (unou-t)
3qixoig 3aIXxOIGd JGIXONOW
*Qv31 aiv4a1ns OlWd HYNAINS NADOYLIN NOSHVD 3NOZO
1OW
puepuels
19
paepuels
GUVGNVLS 1VH3034 fe
GUVGNVLS 31VLS fy
= 0
+ OZ
+ OV
- 09
+ O8
_Y oot
OSNIGASIOX4A SUaLUVNO/SHLNOW/SAVG 40 %
‘@]Ep Jaye] & Je PauIWe}ep eq Of ,
[syue Nog [fy] UOHONPOJg PUB jUeWdO/aAeQ
9661 2661 /yvda/ioa *uoies0jdxg SOO WoOs} SUO|SSIWZ 40 }OJ}UOD S-a-d
8661 9€ Lez th S002 [syueinjjog Iv] vounesyij9e13 peoser vt
2661 ¢9 ee se 0002 [sjueinjog tty) wesory Bunyw3 YI} Jo uUeWweoeday 6
i (ssaj pue gH S21) [01Wd ‘OD *XON ‘90u)
HH p6sl 0 9S} oz . juawdinb3 wey pue UONONISUOD JOj SPyepuRIS VOIsSsIWw A Siw
a
' fi
po 2 S661 99 St ze $002-0002 [XON ‘09 ‘DOW) Wesouty Ase Wood SUO!ss}w3 M07 91+W
< U
' < L661 0 0 gb 2661 -b661 {90u] sxuel lassen eUpeW WO SUOISSIWA JO |9)}U0D CW
i
< 2661 pel 1@ ve 0002-9661 [XON ‘09 ‘DOY) WesNFy Jaf WO SUOISSIW JO JOUOD ZW
OD ON 9O0Y
(Aep/suo})
eed suoHonpey 91e&Q ‘ON
uojdopy uolssiw uoNeyUeWwajduy| aii eunseay
pesodoid pasodoid pesodoig dWOov
SOINSBIW [OMUOD | 491] ~ JUBWILIBAOL) jesopo4
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.