Opposition Brief — Environmental Protection Agency v. Coalition for Clean Air

Supreme Court brief1993

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

Court, U.S.

FILED

| DEC. 18 1992

?

No. 92-798 | OFRICE OF THE GLERK

in THE SUPREME COURT OF THE WRITER STATES

OCTOBER TERM, 1992

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION

AGENCY, et al., PETITIONERS,

v.

COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR, INC., et ai.,

RESPONDENTS

On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari

To the United States Court Of Appeals

For The Ninth Circuit

OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO FILE

BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE

ALAN C. WALTNER*

Law Offices of Alan Waltner

1736 Franklin Street, 8th Floor

Oakland, CA 94612

(510) 465-4494

TRENT ORR

96 Manchester Street

San Francisco, CA 94110

(415) 206-0898

Counsel for Respondents

*Counsel of Record

— ©

CO.

and

—_—

bs

aa

:

1 4

4 4

) . 3

: ,

a

at . > see

~ m he

3 a

, F 4

° e

+) : :

s a

Ty :

. A “a

4“ ‘ ~ : :

: Dns

~ 4 . :

; ma

we z a

wx

g:

,

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

STATUTES AND REGULATIONS

Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 7401 et seq.:

§110(c), 42 U.S.C. § 7410(c) (Supp. II

Se ee ee a ee re. ce 5

§110(i), 42 U.S.C. § 7410(i) (Supp. I]

a ce ay eee U oe ee 05 4

§302(y), 42 U.S.C. § 7602(y) (Supp. II

PN Lee ie cet eet Ce val 6 ale eta Ae 3,4

ee I Se a eb a a ea 1

ee Se I cea Cc es ee bee a eh ee ea es ye

MISCELLANEOUS

55 Fed. Reg. (1990)

1h THE SUPREME COURT OF THE HITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM, 1992

No. 92-798

UNITED STATES ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION

AGENCY, et al., PETITIONERS,

Vv,

COALITION FOR CLEAN AIR, INC., e¢ al.,

RESPONDENTS

On Petition For A Writ Of Certiorari

To the United States Court Of Appeals

For The Ninth Circuit

OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO FILE

BRIEF AMICUS CURIAE

The Coalition for Clean Air and Sierra Club (jointly, the

“Coalition")' oppose the motion for leave to file a brief amicus

curiae filed by the law firm of Latham & Watkins, counsel for

Respondent Southern California Edison Company in these

proceedings, on behalf of the Los Angeles Area Chamber of

Commerce ("Chamber").

‘Respondents Coalition for Clean Air and Sierra Club are not-for-profit

corporations that do not have publicly traded stock, or parent or subsidiary

corporations. Sup. Ct. R. 29.1.

2

Southern California Edison Company ("Edison"), a major

utility company in the Southern California area and a party to the

proceedings below, which we are informed is a member of the

Chamber, elected not to file a brief in support of the

Environmental Protection Agency’s ("EPA") petition for writ of

certiorari within the twenty day period required under Supreme

Court Rule 12.4. Instead, after the Coalition’s brief had been

dispatched to the printer,” the Coalition was informed that the

Chamber, represented by the same law firm as Edison, intended

to file a brief on behalf of its members, including Edison. The

practical effect of this approach was to prevent the Coalition

from addressing in the brief in opposition the points made by

Southern California industrial interests, including Edison. For

that reason, this opposition is being filed.

Moreover, the Chamber presents essentially the same

arguments as does EPA regarding the potential impacts of air

quality regulation on the Southern California economy. Not

surprisingly, the Chamber’s brief suffers from the same

fundamental flaws as does EPA’s. First, the Chamber assumes

without providing any direct support that partial federal planning

will be more expensive and less efficient than planning based

solely on state and local authorities. Indeed, the South Coast Air

Quality Management District has provided clear evidence to the

contrary in its brief in opposition -- that the least costly set of

regulations will need to include federal measures. Pure

argument, rather than citation to evidence, by EPA, the

Chamber, and by the Southern California Association of

The Coalition was informed the afternoon of Friday, December 4 that

the Chamber intended to file its brief the next Monday. No previous

notice had been provided and the Coalition had relied upon Edison’s failure

to file a supporting brief within the twenty day period in selecting the

issues to present in its opposition.

3

Governments ("SCAG"), does not support the proposition that

the federal implementation plan ("FIP") will be inefficient.

Second, as with EPA and SCAG, the Chamber assumes that

the FIP will need to be complete in and of itself, rather than

filling gaps and building upon the state plan that has already been

submitted to EPA. This argument ignores the added flexibility

built into the definition of FIPs by the 1990 Amendments, as

well as the nature of the FIP that EPA actually proposed in

September, 1990. 42 U.S.C. § 7602(y) (Supp. II 1990); 55 Fed.

Reg. 36,458 (1990):

The term "Federal implementation plan" means a plan (or

portion thereof) promulgated by the Administrator to fill all

or a portion of a gap or otherwise correct all or a portion

of an inadequacy in a State implementation plan, and which

includes enforceable emissions limitations or other control

measures, means or techniques (including economic

incentives, such as marketable permits or auctions of

emissions allowances), and provides for attainment of the

relevant national ambient air quality standard.

The Chamber’s repeated reference to “two layers of

environmental regulations" and "an across-the-board strategy . .

. adopted in addition to existing state and local standards" is a

straw man. Chamber Brief at 3, 6, 9 (emphasis in original).

Under the new FIP definition, EPA clearly does not need to

include controls already included in the state plan, and the FIP

*The Southern California Association of Governments, party to the

proceedings below, filed a second petition for writ of certiorari in this

case, rather than filing a brief in support of EPA’s petition within the

twenty day period under Rule 12.4. In order to move this matter forward,

the Coalition’s opposition to SCAG’s petition is being filed this same date. |

maaan

4

can be partial and supportive, rather than complete in and of

itself.

Similarly, the Chamber’s argument that the federal plan will

be required before state planning efforts can take place ignores

the fact that a state plan has already been submitted and is

presently pending before the EPA. 55 Fed. Reg. 36,458 (1990).

EPA proposed to approve the control measures in this state plan

in September, 1990, but has not yet finalized that action. Jd.

The Chamber’s suggestion (Chamber Brief at 7), that EPA can

or should ignore this pending state plan submission until 1994

when additional matters must be addressed, inappropriately seeks

to continue the implementation plan gap in the South Coast that

underlies this action. The 1994 deadline for additional state plan

submissions under the 1990 Amendments is an outside limit and

there is absolutely no support in the statute for the suggestion

that presently pending state plan submissions should be ignored

until that date. c

The Chamber’s concern that the FIP will be hastily

developed (Chamber Brief at 8) ignores the role of the District

Court in setting an appropriate schedule, and the mutual interest

of all parties, including the Coalition, that EPA be given

sufficient time to develop an efficient, well documented and

appropriate plan based upon full public participation. The

Chamber’s suggestions to the contrary are pure speculation.

Also speculative and incorrect is the Chamber’s suggestion

that EPA’s direct FIP regulations will be less susceptible to

change than comparable state-initiated implementation plan

provisions. Chamber Brief at 8. However, once approved by

EPA as part of an implementation plan, state measures can only

be changed or removed through a subsequent EPA rulemaking or

order -- just the same as with federally-adopted measures. 42

5

U.S.C. §§ 7410(i), 7602(q) (Supp. II 1990). Adopted state

implementation plan provisions are no more or less flexible than

federal implementation plan requirements. In fact, EPA’s

proposed FIP primarily contained measures that, “would be

rescinded or their requirements lessened if State and local efforts

suffice . . . ," making clear that obsolete measures would not be

retained. 55 Fed. Reg. at 36,500 (1990).

Finally, the nature of the Chamber’s arguments illustrates

that this is fundamentally a political matter that was resolved by

Congress in the 1990 Amendments through the compromise

language selected in Section 110(c), continuing EPA’s FIP

obligations where SIP disapproval occurs, but relaxing the

requirements of the FIP through the new FIP definition. The

only appropriate lobbying, however, was that lobbying directed

to Congress, and the Chamber’s lobbying efforts before this

Court should be disregarded.

Respectfully submitted,

ALAN WALTNER*

Law Offices of Alan C. Waltner

1736 Franklin Street, 8th Floor

Oakland, CA 94612

(510) 465-4494

TRENT ORR

96 Manchester Street

San Francisco, CA 94110

(415) 206-0898

Counsel for Respondents

*Counsel of Record

December 18, 1992

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.