Transcript of Record — James v. Dravo Contracting Co.
Supreme Court brief1937
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
- TIT’
&
This is A suit in equity of which this Court has original
jurisdiction. Equitable jurisdiction-is claimed for the rea- .
son that the plaintiff is threatened with the invasion and
denial of certain rights guaranteed to-it by the Constitution
of the United Stétes and with imminent and irreparable - -
injury, loss ‘and damage, and the plaintiff is without an
adequate and complete remedy at law therefor.
( .
¢ Jurisdiction oO se
— The greands upon which the jurisdiction of this Court.
‘is invoked and depends are as follows: .
(a) This is a suit of a civil nature, in equity, between citi-
zens of different States, as hereinbefore alleged. .
(b) The amount in controversy herein, exclusive of in-
terest and costs, exceeds the sum of three thousand dollars
($3,000). ; e.g
[fol.4] _(c) This suit) arises under the Constitution and
Laws of the United States of America, for the reason that
the enforcement against the plaintiff by the defendant of
the provisions of a statute of the State of West Virginia,
commonly known as the ‘‘ West Virginia. Gross Sales and
Income Tax Law”’ (Article 13, Chapter 11, Official Code of
West Virginia, 1931, and amendments thereto),.in various
particulars as hereinafter set forth, is violative of Article
- I, Section 8, Paragraph 3, of the Constitution of the United
States of America, in that the enforcement of said statute
would constitute the imposition by a State of a direct tax
and burden on interstate commerce. _
(d) Also, this suit arises under the Constitution, and
Laws of the United States of America, for the reasoQ that
the enforcement against the plaintiff by the defendant of
said statute in various particulary as hereinafter set forth
is violative of Article I, Section 8, Paragraph 3, of the Con-
stitution of the United States, in that the enforcement of _
said statute would constitute the imposition of a direct —
tax and burden by a State ypon the United States in the
regulation, control, and improvement of the navigable
°. A
rivers, whic po is incidental to the power to regulate
commerceAetween the States and with foreig nations.
(e) Also, this suit arises under the Constitution and
Laws of the United States.pf America, for the reason that
the enforcement against the. plaintiff by the defendant of _
said statute in various particulars as hereinafter set forth | .
is violative of Article I, Section 8, Paragraph 17, of: the
Constitution of the United States, in that the enforcement :
-[fol.5] of said statute would constitute legislation by a 1g
State over property and places in respect of which tae 4
United States of America has exclusive legislative power
and authority and the imposition of a State tax for the
privilege of carrying on business within territory over
which the United States of America has exclusive legisla-
tive power, and authority. % |
(f)° Also, this suit arises under the Constitution and Laws as.
. of the United States of. America, for the reason that the
enforcement against the plaintiff by the defendant of said
statute in various particulars as hereinafter set forth is
violative of Section 1 of the Fourteenth: Amendment to the
Constitution of the United States, in that the enforcement
of said statute would abridgg the privileges or immunities
_ of plaintiff as a citizen of the United States and would
= deprive the plaintiff of its property, wittout due process
of law and deny to it the equal protection of the laws.
V :
This suit is brought for the purpose of enjoihing and re-
straining the enforcement, operation, and execution against
the plainffif of the provisions of said Gross Sales and In-
come Tax Law and specifically to enjoin the defendant .
in his individual right and as-State Tax Commissioner from
collecting from the plaintiff, under color of. the provisions
of the said statute, the amount of money assessed{ against
the plaintiff by the defendant and to secure a judgment or
decree that said assessment is invalid. ip at = :
- The said Gross Sales and Income Tax Law of West Vir-
ginia is Article 13, Chapter 11, Code of West Virginia,
1931, and‘as amended May 26, 1933, effective May 27, 1933,
“and approved by the Governor. A true copy of said Act
[fol. 6] as originally enacted and as subsequently amended
is filed herewith, marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 1,”’ and
made a part hereof. ~ scree ;
Rt
_
VI
The Plaintiff
Upon information and belief : pei
The plaintiff, The Dravo Contracting Company, has been
for many years and is now engaged in the general construc-
tion business with headquarters in the State of Pennsyl-
vania. The operations of the’ plaintiff are conducted in
various States throughout the United States, in addition to
the State of Pennsylvania, and including the State of West
Virginia. The said plaintiff has not had or maintained and
does not now have or maintain.any office or place of general
business within the territorial boundaries of the State of
West Virginia. The plaintiff, however, has been duly regis-
tered, qualified, and licensed under the laws of the State of
West Virginia to do business in said State as a foreign
corporation since the year 1922, and has paid annually all
license taxes.and fees required of it as such foreign cor-
poration. The privilege taxes assessed against plaintiff,
as hereinafter set forth, are in addition to all such license
taxes. Plaintiff avers that it has annually, prior to the
years 1933 and 1934, made return ‘of its gross earnings
to the Tax Commissioner of the State of West Virignia
and has paid the gross sales tax thereon. During the years
1933 and 1934 the business transacted by plaintiff in the
State of West Virginia consisted in part of ordinary intra-
state business and in part of the performance of four con-'
tracts with the United States. Government, hereinafter
more particularly described. Plaintiff made return of its
gross earnings from its intrastate business for the said
years 1933 and 1934 to the /Tax Commissioner of the State.
of West Virginia and paid the gross incom¢ tax upon said
gross earnings. In said returns for the/ years 1933 and
1934, however, plaintiff stated upon the face thereof that
the same did not inc}tide’the proceeds derived from its con-
tracts with the United States of America. Plaintiff ex-
[fol. 7} cluded from its said returns the. proceeds of its
government contracts for the reason that plaintiff was
advised by counsel and believed and does now believe. and,
therefore, avers that said Gross Sales and Income Tax Law
of the State of. West Virginia, in so far as it attempts to
-impose a tax upon the gross proceeds from plaintiff’s gov;
ernment contracts, is unconstitutional and void. .
4
-
cn
Vil
Upon information and belief :
That subsequent to the filing of plaintiff’s gross sales
and income tax returns for the years 1933 and 1934 in the
manner above set forth, the defendant, Fred L. Fox, as-
State Tax Commissioner of the State of West Virginia,
demanded that plaintiff include in its said returns the gross ©
proceeds of plaintiff’s contracts with the United States
‘Government, but plaintiff refused so to do for the reasons
‘ hereinbefore stated. Thereupon the defendant demanded
of plaintiff a statement of the amount of the gross proceeds
derived by it from its government contracts for said years.
Plaintiff by letters, expressly reserving its rights to contest
the legality of said tax and its liability therefor, furnished
- said information, which is as follows:
Gross proceeds of income from United States Govern-
mentcontracts : “he
From uary 1, 1933, to May 26, 1933... .. $701,591.99
From Ma 1933, to December 31, 1933.. $1,501,344.67
¥rom January 1, 1934, to December 31, 1934 $4,431,525.63 ©
all of which said sums were paid by the United States by
checks or vouchers delivered to thé plaintiff at Pittsburgh,
Pennsylvania. | | |
VI -
’ Upon information and belief: ,
The defendant, Fred L. Fox, State Tax Commissioner _
as aforesaid, purporting to act under the authority vested - -
in him by the law of West Virginia aforesaid, has proceeded
to make and has made an assessment against plaintiff for
[fol..8] the calendar years 1933 and 1934 upon the. gross
receipts of money received during that period by plaintiff
from the United States of America, under the contracts
hereinafter more particularly described, in the following
amounts: ; of ;
From January 1,-1933, to May 26, 1933:
WE a or eseeus Te ~ $2,092.78.
So os ea ds ec bee Dee 774.33
. —_ $2,867.11
. From May 27, 1933, to December 31, 1933: 4
NE gassed Yee eer ee $30,011.89
WANE so oc vos cc ins ees ius ~ 6,302.50 ~
: . 36,314.39
m,
6
From January 1, 1934, to December 31, 1934:
ee ee, OPO Lee ae $88,605.51 -
ee ferry 7,974.50 :
= 96,580.01
$135,761.51 ©
And said Fred L. Fox, on the 15th day of July, 1935, |
notified plaintiff of.said assessment and by letter further
notified plaintiff that, unless said tax and penalties in the
aggregate amount of $135,761.51, assessed by him on the
_gross receipts of plaintiff for the years 1933 and 1934, —
treceived from the United States of America.under the said
written contracts, was paid immediately, he, the said Fred
L. Fox, would be forced to proceed in aecordance with the
law to collect the same and to distrain on the property of
plaintiff to collect said tax. A copy of said letter and assess-
ments from the defendant is herewith filed, marked ‘‘Plain- —
tiff’s Exhibit No. 2,’ and made a part hereof:
1D.¢
Plaintiff avérs that, as a part of its general construction
business, it has been engaged for many years in the busi-
ness-of building and constructing locks and dams upon
navigable rivers in the United States and in making, fabri-.
cating, and supplying the materials, and in furnishing the
labor for the building and construction thereof. Plaintiff
has owned for many years and now owns, maintains, and
operates at’ Neville Island, in Allegheny County, in the State
_ [fol. 9] of Pennsylvania, large industrial factories and mills
for molding, shaping, and fabricating steel and other metal
_ work, for testing and inspecting the same, and for the stor-
age thereof. Plaintiff has kept and keeps employed a large
number of workmen who are trained and skilled in the work
‘of properly construtting: locks and dams, and for a long
time has owned, maintained, and operated equipment and
machinery specially adapted to the gonstruction of locks
and. dams. | i. |
: D.4
During the years 1932 and 1933 plaintiff entered into four
written contracts, hereinafter more specifically described, -
with the United States of America, to furnish all labor and .
materials and perform all work required for the construc- —
tion of certain locks and dams for the improvement of navi-
% 6
' gation and transportation on the Kanawha ar J Ohio
Rivers.”
Each of said four contracts was dttered into and executed
by plaintiff, The Dravo Contracting Company, at Neville
Island, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Said contracts were exe-
cuted by and in behalf of the United States of America at
‘Huntington, West Virginia, by the duly authorized agent
and representative of the War Department of the United
States of America, namely, the District Engineer of the
United States Army, and were delivered to plaintiff by the |
United States of America at Pittsburgh, Pennsylvayia.
Said contracts are more particularly described: as follows:
(a) A written contract dated August 30, 1932, between
plaintiff and the United States of Amerita, whereby plain-
tiff agreed to furnish all labor and materials and to perform
all work required for the construction of a roller gate dam
and for the installation of a permanent upper lock gate at
‘the Marmet Lock and Dam in the Kanawha River in Kana- |.
wha County, West Virginia, near the Town of Marmet in said
State, about nine miles aboye the City of Charleston and
[fol. 10] ‘sixty-eight miles above the junction of said Kan-
awha River and the Ohio River. In consideration of the
furnishing of said materials and-labor and the performance
of ‘said work, the United States of America agreed to pay
the plaintiff a sum based on designations. and unit rates
specified in said contract, a true and correct copy of which,
with specifications and schedules, is filed herewith, marked
‘*Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 3,¥ and made a part hereof.
(b) A written contract dated November 26, 1932, be-
tween plaintiff and the United States of: America, whereby
plaintiff agréed to furnish all labor and matérials and to
perform all work ‘required for constructing a lock (Lock
‘*B’’), a roller gate dam, alterations to the upper miter gate © \_
of existing Lock ‘‘A”’, a power‘house on the river wall of
_ Lock ‘‘A”, and furnishing and installing the power house
‘machinery, and lock illumination . system, at London in -
Kanawha County, West Virginia, in consideration whereof
the United States of America agreed to pay the plaintiff
a sum based on designations and unit rates specified in the
nee appended to said contract, which contract and
_ schedule are filed herewith, marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s —
No. 4’’, and made a part hereof,
8 - -
(c) A written contract dated October 24, 1933, between
plaintiff and the United States of America, whereby plain-
‘tiff agreed to furnish all labor and materials anc to perform
all work required to construct twin locks in the Kanawha
River near the Town of Winfield in Putnam County, West
Virginia, and, at the same place, a central contro tion
_ on the river wall of Lock. ‘‘A’’, and to furnish and install -
the central contre! station machinery, tow haulage units,
‘and lock. illumination and signal light systems, in considera-
tion whereof the United States of America agreed to pay
plaintiff a spm-based on designations and unit prices speci-
fied in said contract, a copy of which is herewith filed,
marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 5’’, and. made a part
hereof. — ,
[fol.41] (d) A written contract dated December 21, 1933,
between plaintiff and the United States of America, whereby
plaintiff agreed to furnish all labor and materials and to
perform all -work required for constructing two parallel
locks, including guide and guard walls, gates, and gate -
operating machinery, valves and valve operating machinery,
and piping, in-the Qhio River near the Town of Gallipolis,
Ohio, but within the geographical boundaries of the State
of West Virginia, in Mason County in said State, in con-
sideration whereof the United States of America agyeed
to pay plaintiff a sum based on designations and unit prices
specified in a schedule appended to- said contract, which
said contract and schedule are herewith filed, marked
‘¢Plaintiff’s Exhibit Nox6,”’ and made a part-hereof.
XI
Upon information and belief:
- The locks, dams, and appurtenant structures aforesaid,
for which the plaintiff furnished'the labor and materials _
under the contracts aforesaid, were built \and constructed,
and are being built and constructed under the direction
and control of the United States, acting through the
War Department thereof. The United, States employed,
placed and maintained in general charge of construc-
tion as aforesaid, a representative designated as the
‘‘Céntracting : Officer,’ and also at all times maintained
at each of said places of cénstruction a corps of civil engi-
neers and representatives for the purpose of supervising,
directing, and inspecting the building of said locks and dams
— ‘ ”
, .
and appurtenant structures and for the purpose of inspect-
ing and supervising the materials and the labor that wen
into the construction of same. '
By the previsions of said contracts the United States re-
tained and exercised power and authority to direct when
the plaintiff should proceed with said work; to make changes ~
in the drawings and specifications for said construction
through its representative, the Contracting Officer; and the
_ [fol. 12] plaintiff was required to conform to the changes
so made. The United States further retained and exercised :
‘the right to inspect, examine, and test all material and work-
manship, to decide whether equipment or material was equal
to any particular standard stipulated for in the specifica-
tions, to approve the makers of machinery, mechanical or
other equipmentrequired, and to require that full informa-
_ tid concerning all materials or articles used in said work
be furnished the Contracting Officer. The United “tates
: further retained and exercised the right to require plaintiff
to dismiss from work any employee deemed by said Contract- es
ing Officer to be incompetent, careless, or insubordinate or .
otherwise objectionable, and to-pass upon the competency _ -
of the foreman or superintendent placed upen said work.
The decision of the United States, acting through the Con-
tracting Officer, was final and conclusive upon the plaintiff
in all matters concerning delay in the work and any increased
cost resulting therefrom. The United States retained and
exercised the power to fix the hours of work for laborers and
mechanics, to impose a penalty in case any laborers or me- .
chanics were required or permitted to labor more than eight
hours in any one day, and to determine the kind of labor to
' be employed. The United States retained and exercised the
exclusive and sole power to decide all disputes arising under +
said contract and its decisions rendered through its repre-
sentative and the War Department were binding and con-
: clusive upon the plaintiff. The United States further re- —
tained and exercised the power to prohibit any decrease in
: the size of the plant employed by plaintiff and to require the
employment of additional men and larger plant and equip-
ment, if the rates of progress specified were not maintained
by plaintiff. The United 4 further retained the power
to prescribé‘the sanitary and safety requirements> to which
60 ntl
satiate dade Ioteaneid
' the plaintiff was compelled to conform. The United States
: retained and exercised.the power to prescribe conditions and
Ry
oo LY
methods for blasting, to direct when shoring could be used :
in making excavations, ahd to limit the use of drilling ma-
chines and broaching outfits. The United States further re-.
'_ tained and exercised the power to direct the length of piling
to be used, to control the kind of stone to be used in ripraps
(fol. 13] and to be placed in derrick stone protection, to waive
the required tests on cement in case of emergency, to decide
_ the sufficiency of all test of ageregaté, and to pres@ribe the
strength and density of the admixture of concrete. The
United States further retained and exercised the powgs to
approve the adequacy and dependability of the concrete ,
mixing plant, and to direct when and at what temperatures ,
concrete could be placed ; to determine when joints should be
made; to determine and approve the type, size, shape,
quality, and strength of all materials fcr concrete forms; to
require the making of expansion joints; to decide upon re-
quirements for concrete forms; and to authorize and pre-
scribe the weight of steel castings, nickel steel castings, iron
castings, steel forgings, and other similar materials re-
- quired under said contract; to pass upon the mechanical and
physical properties of all materials used; to pass upon the
qualifications and efficiency of welders used in said construc- —
_ tion; to require the painting and repainting of all steel and
iron according to the judgment of the inspector ; to authorize
by special permission the welding, burning, and torch cutting .
of any materials; and to direct and control the method of
assembly and erection of the.roller gates. The United States ©
retained and exercised the power to prescribe the manner,
methods, and means for the fabrication-and construction of
all machinery and materials and all-work to be done in the
erection and construction of said locks, dams, and appur-
tenant buildings and structures. Plaintiff avers that the |
contracts aforesaid were the method and plaintiff was the
means and instrumentality used by the United States of
America in the.construction of said locks‘and dams.
XII :
Plaintiff proceeded to orm its said contracts above
recited and, duying the years 1933 1934, completed the
performance of its contracts for Work a} Marmet and Lon-
don hereinbefore described in Subparagraphs (a) and (b) °
of Paragraph X, supra. Plaintiff further avers that it com-
[fol. 14] pleted the performance of its contract at Winfield
‘
: oe
described in Subparagraph (c) of Paragraph X.in February,
1935. . Plaintiff has partially, performed its contract for
wouk at Gallipolis hereinbefore described in Subparagraph
_ (da) of Paragraph X, and is now engaged in the further per-
formance of said contract in accordance with the terms
: thereof. For the work so performed by plaintiff under its
said contracts with the United States of America and in ag-
cordance with the terms and provisions thereof and the desjg-
nations and unit prices specified therein, plaintiff cab |
during the years 1933 and 1934, the gross sums hereinbefore
alleged in Paragraph VII. .
XU
| Prior to the making of each of the contracts aforesaid, the
- United States.invited offers for bids for the furnishing of
materials and labor in the construction of said works, and
plaintiff made its:bid pursuant to said invitations, based
uponcealculations as to the cost to it of the materials and
labor to be furnished in the construction of each of the works
covered by said contracts; and in making each ‘of said bids,
the plaintiff did not include within the amount thereof any
‘sum whatsoever for the payment of the tax which the said
defendant, the State Tax Commissioner of West Virginia, /
is now seeking to collect from the plaintiff. - ~ ®
XIV
Plaintiff avers that its said-bids for furnishing materials
and labor in the construction of the works above described
were made upon invitation of the United States Government
forwarded to plaintiff at Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, through
the United States Mail, and said bids and the bonds accom-
panying same were in writing and were made and executed
by the plaintiff in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, and were de-
livered to the United States Engineer’s Office at Huntingfon,
West Virginia.
[fol. 15] XV
Plaintiff, in compliance with and in performance of said
contracts with the United States, manufactured, fabricated,
sampled, tested, and inspected lock gates, roller dams, strue-
tural steel, machinery, tools, and other apparatus and equip-.
ment at the-plaintiff’s factdries and mills at Neville Island ~
in the State of Pennsylvania. Plaintiff avers that the United
-
ae
‘ ‘~~
a
tes made iii payment for many of said articles so manu-
sn ; and, upon information and belief, avers that by
virtue of the provisions of said contracts, title to such articles.
became vested in the United States outside the State of West
Virginia. By orders sent fromJits office at Pittsburgh,
Pennsylyania, plaintiff purehased ffom persons outside the-
State of West Virginia vast quantities of other materials
for use in the performance of said contracts, such as cement,
sand, lumber, bolts, rivets, steel, tools, implements, cables,
machinéfy, and other materials and equipment. Plaintiff
stored much of said material so manufaétured or purchased
at its plant at Neville Island or elsewhere outside the State
of West Virginia. Plaintiff further owned or leased various
river craft specially adapted for use in the construction of
said locks and dams, such as barges, dredges, derrick boats,
and other craft fitted out with machinery and equipment
suitable for such purpose. Plaintiff transported and car-
ried or caused to be transported and carried by rail or upon
the navigable rivers alh of said articles so manufactured or
purchased, as well-as repair and. replacement parts therefor,
from other States into the State of West Virginia: Plain- —
tiff also transported or caused to be transported from other -—
States into the State of West Virginia the barges, dredges,
derrick boats, and other craft above mentioned. In the
transportation and carriage of said materials, the plaintiff |
used towboats and barges owned and operated by plaintiff
and towboats and barges chartered or rented from, or oper-
ated by, other persons. Plaintiff, at its expense, brought
into the State of West Virginia a large kumber- ‘of experi-
enced and skilled workmen regularly employed by it; and .
(fol. 16] employed and hired, outside the State of West Vir-
ginia, other experienced and skilled workmen and artisans
who were citizens and residents of other States than the
State of West Virginia, and brought them into the State of -
West Virginia because of their particular skill and fitness
for the work. Plaintiff, upon information-and belief, avers
that the manufacture, fabrication, testing, inspection, and
storage of articles and materials outside of the State of West
Virgimia, and the purchase and storage of other materials
outside of said State for subsequent transportation into, and.
incorporation in the work in, said State, and the subsequent
shipment thereof, by. rail and river, into said State of West
Virginia, and the ve of barges, steamboats, and other
~
‘of West Virginia,
erecting of said muterialsy equipment, and machinery into
the said locks and dams in West Virginia, were continuous, ©
river craft on-the navigable rivers between other States and
the State of West Virginia, the transportation of skilled
_ workmen end artisans into said State, and various other acts,
matters, and things doffe by plaintiff in the performance of
its said contracts with the United States, constituted com-
merce among the several States, or transactions and busi-
ness entirely outside the State of West Virginia. Plaintiff
avers, upon information and‘belief, that gross income from
_the acfs performed and things done by it in the performance
of said contracts constituting interstate commerce or
‘transactions entirely outside the State of West Virginia,
,
amounted to approximately 60% of the entire*zross income >
from said contracts. ‘
; XVI
car sk ©
_ Upon information and belief: .
Plaintiff further avers that the acts performed and things
done by it in the performance of its contracts above referred
to, consisting of the manufacture, purchase, and storage of
articles, materials, and equipment, and the transportation
_ thereof into the State of West Virginia, the le&sing of various
river craft and the movement of said river craft, owned or
_ ledsed by the plaintiff, between other States and the State
of West Virginia, and the transportation of workmen into
he State of West Virginia, as set forth in detail in Para-
-[fel. 17] graph XV hereof, and constituting commerce among
the several States, or transactions entirely outside the State
Ssciine with.the placing, building, and
uninterrupted, and related acts, all done in the performance,
by the plaintiff, of a single contract obligation, to-wit, the
furnishing of the materials and labor and work for the coh-
struction of said locks and dams, tespectively, as provided
for in said respective contracts with the United States of
America. eo .
: —
Plaintiff avers that the gross income received by it from,
the United States under said contracts covered.the sest and
expense of all acts performed and things done by it in the
performance of its contracts aforesaid, consisting of the "
manufacture, purchase, and storage of articles, materials, -
' and equipment, and the transportation thereof into the State
‘ ‘ rans oer
Ras aa ef
i
> ore
va
of West Virginia, the leasing of various river craft and the
movement of said river craft, owned or leased: by the plain-
tiff, between other States and the State of West Virginia,
and the transportation of workmen into the State of West
Virginia, as set forth in detail in Paragraph XV hereof, and
constituting commerce among the several States, or trans-
actions entirely outside the State of West Virginia, as well
as the cost of placing, building, and erecting the materials,
equipment, and machinery furnished by it as aforesaid at
the respective sites of the work, without’separation or segre- |
gation of any kind whatsoever. Plaintiff further avers that,
under the schedules of designations and unit prices con-
tained in said contracts, the portion of the gross receipts
for the various items of material and labor, entering into the
various units designated in said schedules, are not separated
or segregated. . Upon information and belief, that the Gross
Sales and Income Tax Law of the State of West Virginia
contains no provision whereby the items making up the gTOss
income, subject to said tax, may be separated as between in-
[fol. 18] come from intrastate business, income from inter-
state business, and income from transactions consummated
——* outside said State.
XVII
Upon information .and belief :— a
The contracts aforesaid were made and entered into by or
on behalf of the United States of America, pursuant to the
powers expressly or impliedly granted to the Federal Gov-
ernment by the Constitution of the United States. Article
I, Section 8, Subdivision 3, of said Constitution grants to
Congress the power to regulate commerce with foreign
nations and among the several States. The same provision
grants the incidental power to control, regulate, and improve
the navigable streams of the country. Article I, Section 8,
Subdivision-17, of said Constitution grants Congress the
power to exercise exclusive legislation éver all places pur-
chased by the United States by the consent of the legislature
of the State in which the same shall be, for the erection of
-
‘needful buildings. Plaintiff avers the contracts aforesaid.
for the construction of locks, dams, and appurtenant build-.
ings and structures were made and entered into by or on be-
half of the United States pursuant to said powers to regulate.
commerce with bieats nations and among the several States;
15
to control, regulate, and improve the navigable streams of .
the country, and to legislate exclusively over all places pur-~
chased by the United States with the consent of the Legisla-
ture, for the erection of needful buildings, and were and are
the means and method of conducting said operations adopted
by the United States of America for the exercise and per-
formance of its proper governmental functions:
a
[fol. 19] mais. XIX
‘Upon information and belief:
That prior to the execution and delivery of the contracts
aforesaid, all preliminary surveys, examinations and ‘re-
\_ ports, required by law, were duly made and submitted, the
~ necessary. approvals of the Chief of Engineers of the War
Department and of the Secretary of War were given and
transmitted, and the work to be performed was duly au-. XN
thorized by Congress, including the necessary appropria-
tions for the payment of the money stipulated for. Plain-
tiff is advised, believes, and therefore avers that every act,
matter, and thing necessary or requisite to the validity-of.
said contracts was performed and accomplished, and. that
said contracts constitated binding — of the United
States of America. ;
XX
_ Upon information and belief : ;
The @nawha and Ohio Rivers, upon which said locks -
and dams were, and are being, constructed and erected by
plaintiff, are navigable rivers of the United States. For,
more than fifty years the United States has been engaged ee
in the improvement of navigation thereon. In 1875 the
construction of twelve locks and dams -on the Kanawha
River-was authorized by Act of Congress. In 1879 the
acquisition of lands for dam sites and locks was authorized
_and an appropriation was made for the payment therefor.
Shortly thereafter locks and dams were constructed in said
river by the United States and they have ever since been |
operated and maintained, through appropriations made.
by Congress.. During said.period of more than fifty years,
‘as aforesaid,and to this’date, the United States has con-
tinuously made vast expenditures of money in the improve-
' ment of said -Kanawha River in furtherance of navigation,
commerce, and public use. The Kanawha River is tributary
to the Ohio and Mississippi River systems. Said rivers, to-
‘4
é
16
gether with their gther tributaries, are navigable streams -
[fol. 20] and have long ‘been important arteries of river
commerce among the several States and with foreign na-
tions. The locks, dams, ‘and appurtenant buildings, con- _
structed and being constructed by plaintiff under the con-.
tracts herein referred to, are necessary instrumentalities
in the maintenance, improvement, and advancement of navi-
gation upon the Kanawha River portion of said inland
waterways system. Said locks, dams, and appurtenant
buildings are for the maintenance and further development
<a the canalization of said Kanawha and Ohio Rivers and
for the replacement of existing obsolete structures. Plain-
tiff is advised, believes, and therefore avers that said locks
and dams are instrumentalities of interstate and foreign
commerce, and that the furnishing of labor and material for
the construction thereof is, in itself, interstate commerce.
There are filed herewith, as part hereof, two printed letters
_ from the Secretary of War to the Speaker of ‘the House
of Representatives of the Congress of the United States,
designated, respectively, ‘‘House of Representatives, 70th
Congress, 1st Session, Document 190’’ and ‘‘ House of Rep-
resentatives, 73rd Congress, 1st Session, Document 31,’’
and marked ‘‘Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 7”’ and ‘‘Plaintiff’s
Exhibit No. 8,’’ respectively, showing the history of the
development and maintenance of commerce on the Kanawha
River by the United States, and the éxaminations and sur-
veys of said River preliminary to the construction of said
locks and dams.
XXII
Plaintiff is further informed, believes, and therefore
avers that all the lands upon which said locks, dams, and
appurtenant buildings were constructed, were acquired by
purchase by the United States from the persons owning the
same, for said purpose; that the State of West Virginia
has duly and lawfully given its consent and approval to
said acquisition of said lands by ‘the United States of Amer-
ica; and that all the work of erecting said locks, dams, and
pr buildings under the contracts aforesaid was
performed upon lands so purchased by the United States of
America. . ;
?
a ee inane. “an
17
(fol. 21] XX -
Gross Sales Tax Statutes
Upon information and belief: —
That there was enacted by the Legislature of West Vir- |
ginia, at an extraordinary session in the year 1925, an Act
known as Chapter 1, Acts of Qne Thousand Nine Hundred
Twenty-five, Extraordinary Session of the Legislature of
West Virginia, with the following title:
‘‘An Act to provide for the raising of additional public
revenue by a tax upon the privilege of engaging in certain
occupations ; to provide for the ascertainment, assessment,
ee
and collection of such tax; to provide penalties for violation ye :
of the terms hereof; and to repeal certain statutes.’’
By the provisions of the Act of 1925 aforesaid, it was ex-
. pressly provided that the taxes, thereby assessed and levied,
were privilege taxes against persons on account of business
activities, and that any person continuing in any business,
for which such privilege tax was imposed, was deemed .
thereby to have applied for and to have duly obtained from
the State of West Virginia a license to engage in and con-
duct such business for the current tax year upon the con-
dition that the tax accruing to the State of West Virginia
under the provisions of said Act would-be paid, and that
such person would thereby be duly licensed to engage in -
and conduct such business. The Act of 1925 aforesaid was
incorporated and placed in, and reenacted at the time of
the adoption of, the Official Code‘of West Virginia, and
. made apart thereof by Article 13, Chapter 11, Code of West —
Virginia, effective January 1, 1931. Section 2 thereof pro-
vided, in part, as follows: 7
‘‘There is hereby levied and shall be collected annual
privilege taxes against the persons, on account of the busi-
ness activities, and in the amounts to be determined by
the application of rates against values or gross income as
the case may be, as follows:
7 * * " -* an *
[fol.22] ‘‘(e) Upon every person engaging or continuing
. within this State in the business of contracting, the tax shall
be equal to three-tenths of.one per cent of the gross income
of the business; * * *”
2—625
-—?
18
By Chapter 33, Acts of the Legislature, at its First
Extraordinary Session for the year 1933, the Legislature
amended and reenacted said Article 13, Chapt-r 11, of the
Code of West Virginia, One Thousand Nine Hundred
Thirtyone, which said“Act was made effective on May 27,
1933, the title of which is as follows: — |
¥*An Act to provide for the raising of additional public
revenue by amending and reenacting article thirteen, chap-
ter eleven of the code of West Virginia, one thousand nine
hundred, thirty-one, relating to business and occupation
taxes, by repealing all of sections one through seventeen, ©
inclusive, and enacting and reenacting.sections one through
twenty-three, inclusive; and providing for and imposing a
privilege tax upon the exercise of certain privileges in the
state, by repealing sections eighty-one through eighty-four,
inclusive, article twelve, chapter eleven of said code; and
enacting a new article to be designated article twelve-(a),
chapter,eleven of said code.’’
Section 2, Article 13, Chapter 11, of the Code of West
Virginia of 1931, as amended by Chapter 33, Acts of the
. Legislature of West Virginia, at its First Extraordinary
=
Session in the year 1933, provides, in part, as follows:’-
‘‘There is hereby levied and shall be collected annual
-privilege taxes against the persons, on account of the busi-
ness and other activities, and in the amounts to be deter-
mined by the application of rates against values or gross
incorie, as. follows:
* * e “i is >
‘‘(e) Upon every person engaging or continuing within
this State in the business of contracting, the tax shall be
equal to two per cent, of the gross income of the busi-
ness; * * * 99 ?
[fol. 23] By said statute, privilege taxes for the years 1933
and 1934 were imposed upon the business of contracting at
the following rates: for the period -from January 1, 1933,
to May 26, 1933, inclusive, three-tenths of one per cent of
_ the gross income of the business; and for the period from
May 27, 1933, to December 31, 1934, inclusive, two per ‘cent
of the gross income of the business.
<
.
3 ie ellos - C2 me
hauteehe tale Uae dape DRG IATL tink NL i Bs ED sient Pt Bice
XXIII
Upon information and belief:
That the aforementioned laws.incorporated in Article 13,
Chapter 11, of the Code of West Virginia; One Tiousand
Nine Hundred Thirty-one, and the amendments and reen-
actments thereof, were enactéd forcthe. express and sole
purpose of providing revenues for the State of West Vir-
ginia and not as regulatory measures; and the revenues
realized thereby become a part of the general funds of the
State of West Virginia in the State Treasury thereof, and ©
are for the general purpose of the State Government.
Said Acts contain no provision for the separation or
segregation of gross income derived from intrastate busi- _
ness from gross income derived from interstate business,
or from transactions’ entirely outside the State of West
_ Virginia, with respect to the tax imposed upon the privilege.
of engaging in the business of contracting. Said Acts fur-
ther expressly provide that the tax imposed thereby shall
be in addition to all other licenses and taxes levied by law
as a condition precedent to engaging in any business, trade,
or calling. Plaintiff is advised, believes, and therefore
__ avers that the privilege taxes imposed by said Act are in _
addition to other taxes for. the benefit of the State of West
_ Virginia, levied on property, real ang ersonal, Plaintiff
is further advised, believes, and therefore avers that, under
the provisions of said Act governing the assessment of said
privilege taxes by the Tax Commissioner, in the event that
the taxpayer fails or refuses to make a return, either in
whole or in part, the assessment of the tax by the Tax Com-
missioner is final as to any person who refuses to make a
return. . | . | .
[fol. 24] ‘ss XXIV
Upon information and belief:
* . That during the years 1933 and 1934 plaintiff owned and
maintained in the State of West Virginia certain personal
property and equipment for use in the construction of the
‘locks and dams aforesaid under plaintiff’s contract with
the United States. Under the laws of the State of West
Virginia, said personal property was subject to the tax ‘in
the respective counties of said State in which the same was
located. Plaintiff made returns’ of said property to the
Assessors of Kanawha County, Putnam County, and Mason
20
County, respectively, and paid the taxes thereon to the State
of West Virginia through the Sheriff and ex-officio Treas-
urer of each of said counties where said personal property
was located. The total amount of taxes paid to the State
of West Virginia on said personal property for the years
1933 and 1934 was ehees 62, the respective payments being
as follows:
To the Sheriff of Kanawha County, 1968.......-. $1,912.28
To the Sheriff of Kanawha County, 1934........ 1,242.12
To the Sheriff of Putnam County, 1934........ *. 1,423.50
To the Sheriff of Mason County, 1934........... 1,212.72
Total... 2... as beats ee $5,790.62
Plaintiff. avers that the only property owned by plaintiff.
in West Virginia is that used in the construction of said
locks and dams.
| XXV.
Plaintiff further avers, upon information and belief, that
the law of the State of West Virginia embodied in said
Article 13, Chapter 11, of the Code of West Virginia, 1931,
and the amendments thereto, if construed to be applicable
to the plaintiff with respect to~the proceeds received by
plaintiff under its said contracts with the United States
Government, is void, invalid, and contrary to and in viola-
[fol. 25] tion of the Constitution of the United States and
the amendments thereto, and is unenforcible for the fol-
Ie
lowing reasons: /
(a) Said Act violates and is in conflict with Article L
Section 8, Subdivision 3, of the Constitution of the United
States, which provides: —
‘‘The Congress shall have the power * * * to regu-
late commerce with foreign nations - among the several
States ; 39?
in that sshd statute imposes a direct tax, amounting to 2%
of the’contract price or gross receipts, upon contracts pro-
viding .for the performance of labor and the furnishing of —
materials, a large part of which constitutes commerce
among the several states, without any provision for the
segregation and separation of the portion of the income.
derived from interstate commerce from the portion thereof
.
21
derived from intrastate commerce, which tax is a burden on
and hindrance to said interstate commerce. -
Said Act further violates and is in conflict with said.
Article I, Section 8, Subdivision 3, of the Constitution of the
United States, in that it imposes a direct tax, amounting ~
to 2% of the cost of the work, upon the exercise by the
Government of the United States of its incidental power to
regulate, control, and improve the navigable streams of
*this country, which tax is a burden on ahd hindrance to
the exercise of said power. ,
Said Act further violates and ts in conflict with Article
I, Section 8, Subdivision 3, of the Constitution of the United
States, in that it imposes a direct tax, amounting to 2% of
the cost of the work, on the erection of locks and dams.
in navigable waters of the United States, which erection of
locks and dams is, in itself, interstate commerce, and which
[fol. 26] tax is a burden thereon and a hindrance thereto.
(b) Said Act violates and is in conflict with Article I,
Section 8, Subdivision 17, of the Constitution of the United
States, which provides as follows: | ‘ |
“e , 5
‘The Congress shall have power * * * to exercise
exclusive legislation in all cases whatsoever over such dis- .
trict (not exceeding ten miles square) and may, by cession
of particular States and the acceptance of Congress, be-
come the seat of government of the United States, and to
exercise like authority over all places purchased by the con-
Sent of. the Legislature of the State in which the same shall
be, for the erection of forts, magazines, arsenals, dockyards,
and other needful buildings ;’’
_in that said Act constitutes legislation by a State in respect
of property and places over which the United States of
America has exclusive legislative power and authority and
in that said Act imposes‘a state tax for the privilege of
carrying on business within territory under the exclusive
legislative power and authority of the United States.
(c) Said Act violates and is in conflict with the Four-
teenth Amendment, Section 1, of the Constitution of the
United States, which provides as follows:
‘“‘No State shall make or enforce any law which shall
. abridge the privileges or immunities of citizens of the
United States; nor shall any State deprive any person of
- oe
{
|
22
life, liberty, or property without due process of law, nor
deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal pro-
tection of the laws ; ae
- in that it imposes a direct tax and burden on the plaintiff
in the exercise of its rights to do business in interstate
commerce and imposes a direct tax and burden on the man-
_ ufacture of articles and the transaction of business outside
of the State of West Virginia.
[f61. 27] ; - - XXVI.
‘ Plaintiff further avers, upon are and belief, that
_ the actions‘of the defendant,,Fred L. Fox, as State Tax
Commissioner of the State of "West Virginia, in making the
- assessment aforésaid, for the yéars 1933 and 1934, respec-
tively, upon the gross receipts of money received by your
plaintiff from the United States of America under its con-
tracts aforesaid and the said threatened act to proceed in
accordance with-the law to collect the same and to distrain
on the property of plaintiff to collect said tax, under color
of the authority provided. in said Gross Sales and Income -
Tax Law, are invalid and. void..
MMi | XXVIII
Plaintiff avers, upon information and belief, that unless :
_ the defendant Tax Commissioner is enjoined and restrained
from collecting the tax assessed against plaintiff as afore-
said and. unless said assessment is declared invalid, plain-
tiff will sustain irreparable loss, damage, and injury, for
the following reasons: )
(a) Because a tax inpased, due, ana rr under said -
Artide 13, Chapter 11, of the Code of West Virginia, 1931,
and amendmeitts thereto, i is a debt to the State of West Vir-
ginia and a lien upon the property used.in the business or
_ occupation upon whieh said tax is imposed and has the
same priority as the lien of a general property tax and con- |
stitutes a cloud upon the title-to the property of your plain-
tiff within the ‘territorial limits of the State of West
Virginia; -
-(b) The said Act further provides en statutody penal-
ties for any default or failure in the payment of any tax
¢. assessed thereunder; : | :
a
[fol. 28] (c) The said Act further authorizes the defend- :
ant as Tax Commissioner to distrain upon any goods, chat- :
tels, or intangibles represented by negotiable evidences of
indebtedness, for the amount of all taxes and penalties ac-
crued and unpaid under said Act; if
(d) The lien provided for by said Act and the threatened .
distraint, if levied, would stop, or materially interfere with, ~
the performance, by plaintiff, of work under its contract
with the United States Government;
., (e) Because the tax assessed by the defendant against
the plaintiff for failure to include in its Gross Sales and In-
come Tax Return for the years 1933 and 1934 the gross
proceeds of its contracts with the United States Govern-
ment is, according to the provisions of said act, final as to
__ plaintiff;
(f): Because “the tax assessed against plaintiff on the
gross income from its government contracts is wholly void
and illegal and the statute under which the same was as-
sessed: is wholly inapplicable to said portion of plaintiff’s-
. gross income. The remedies for errors and irregularities
_ provided for in said statute are likewise inapplicable ;
(g) There is no remedy provided under the laws of the
State of West Virginia whereby the plaintiff could compel -
. repayment to it of any money paid as taxes to the defend-
ant, whether said taxes be paid voluntarily by the plaintiff
or be illegally collected from the plaintiff by seizure and
sale of its property as threatened by said State Tax Com- ’
missioner ;
[fol. 29] (h) After the entry of any~judgment or decree
in favor of the plaintiff for the recovery of said money, the
appropriation of money by the Legislaturej of the State of
West. Virginia to satisfy any such judgment or decree
would rest entirely and solely within the discretion of the: |
members thereof, and there is no method to compel the ~
Legislature to make such appropriation.
‘XXVIII_—Cy.
. Continuing and recurring attempts by the defendant or
any successor as State Tax Commissioner to assess and col- s
lect taxes under said Gross Sales and Income Tax Law will i
lead to a multiplicity of suits. i |
24 | eR
Plaintiff avers that if has no adequate remedyat law and
is wholly without, remedy save in a court of equity.
Wuenrerore, and inasmuch as plaintiff is remegiless in
the premises, according to either the laws of the State of
West Virginia or of the United States, or under the com-
mon Jaw, and is remediable only in this Honorable Court,
and to the end that the -plaintiff may be saved from the
aforesaid heavy statutory penalties, may not be subjected
to distraints which will otherwise result, may not suffer
great and irreparable injury, loss and damage, may be per-
mitted to pursue and carry on its businégs under said con-
tracts withoyt unlawful hindrance and obstructions, and
may not be subjected to illegal liens and clouds on, and:
seizure of,:its property at the instance of-the defendant,
plaintiff prays as follows: —
[f6l.30] First. That the said\Fred L. ‘Fox, individually ,
and as State Tax Commissioneft of the State of West Vir-
ginia, his assistants, agents, offiegrs, servants, employees,
and attorneys, be temporarily and permanently enjoined,
inhibited, and restrained from proceeding further and from —
making any levy upon any property of plaintiff located
within fhe State of West Virginia, and from interfering
with the plaintiff, and its rights, in any manner whatso-
ever, by reason of any such: purported assessment ‘by the
said defendant, Fred L. Fox, as State Tax Commissioner
as aforesaid, upon the gross receipts of money received by _
plaintiff during the years 1933-and 1934, respectively, from
the United States of America, under and by virtue of the
said written contracts between plaintiff and the said the
United States of America; and from attempting to col- —
lect from plaintiff in any manner, any sum as a tax under
said Gross Sales and Income Tax Law of West Virginia;
Second. ‘That this Court will hold and actordingly de-
cree that the law of the State of West Virginia, commonly
known as the ‘‘Gross Sales and Income Tax Law,”’ incor-
porated in the Code of West Virginia of 1931 and amend-
ments thereto, violates the Constitution of the United
States of America and is unconstitutional and void in so
far as the said law attempts to give the said defendant,
Fred L. Fox, State Tax Commissioner of the State of West
Virginia, or any other officer or agent of said State, any ~
a
power or authority to make any ‘assessment upon the gross
receipts\of roney received by plaintiff for carrying out
and performing the provisions of the writtén contracts
aforesaid, between plaintiff and the United States of
’ America; s
_° Third. That’ the aforedaid assessment by the defendant
af gross sales and income taxes claimed to be due the State
- of West Virginia for the years 1933 and 1934 in the aggre-
gate amount of $135,761.51 be adjudged invalid and void;
Fourth. That this Court cause to be issuefl the neces-
sary.process and subpenas by the Clerk of this’ Court, di-
rected to said defendant herein, requiring him to be pres-
ent and appear at a time to be fixed by this Court and then’
and there answer the allegations ane averments of this
bill; fl oe ale Fa
(fol. 31] Fifth. That a copy ef this bill; ordet, ‘and sal
pena be served upon the Honorable H. G. Kump, Gov-
ernor of the State of West Virginia, and upon the Honor-
able Homer A. Holt, Attorney General of the State of West
Virginia ;
Sixth. That a temporary restraining order be granted by
this Court instanter restraining the defendant, his as-
sistants, agents, officers, servants, employees, and attor-
neys, as above prayed, until a hearing can be had upon this ©
bill; .
Seventh. That the matters set forth in this bill of com- Be : «
plaint be heard and determined by this Court upon a d o2- .
. to be named by this Court, and that the Court provide -
' héaring by three judges, as provided. by ‘law, after due
notice thereof;
Eighth. And that this oSurt grant unto this plaintiff .
such other, further, general and special relief in the prem- }
ises as the case may require and as this Court may deem fit. _ §
And plaintiff will ever pray, etc. — 4
The Dravo Contracting Company, a Corporation Or- — |
ganized and Existing.under the Laws of the State
of Pennsylvania, Plaintiff, by Counsel, Koontz,
Huributt & Revercomb, Moorhead & Knox, At-.
torneys for Plaintiff. W. C. Revercomb, W. El-
liott Nefflen, Solicitors.
[fol. 32], Duly sworn to by J. 8. Miller. Jur@omitied-in — ,
- printing. : |
Ca
oe
es eee
i -
.
‘
x
o ~*~
PS
\
\
26
[fol. 33] . Exutsrr No. 1 Tro Brut or CoMPLAINT ,
.: * "Revenue Law 1933
The Gross Sales and Income Tax Law
Committee Substitute for Senate Bill No. 1, An Act of the
———_ of West Virginia
— May 26, 1933; in effect May 27, 1933 ; approved =
‘the Governor]
e
An Act to provide for the raising of additional public reve-
‘nue by amending and reenacting article thirteen, chapter ;
eleven of the code of West Virginia, one thousand nine
hundred thirty-one, relating to business. and occupa-
tion taxes, by repealing all of sections one through seven-
teen, inclusive, and enacting and reenacting sections one .
through twenty-three, inclusiye; and providing for and-
imposing a privilege tax upon the exercise of certain
privileges in the state, by repealing sections eighty-one
through eighty-four, inclusive, article twelve, chapter
eleven of said code; and enacting a new article to be
designated article twelve- (a), chapter eleven of said code.
Be it enacted by: the Legislature of West Virginia:
¢That sections one through seventeen, inclusive, article .
thirteen, chapter eleven of the code of West: Virginia, one |
. thousand nine hundred thirty-one, be and are hereby re-
pealed and sections one through twenty-three,. inclusive,
be and are. hereby enacted in lieu thereof; and that sections
eighty-one through eighty-four, inclusive, article twelve,
chapter eleven of said code be and are hereby repealed and
article twelve-(a) be and is hereby enacted.and added to
chapter eleven.
Section 1. ‘When.used in this: article, the term ‘*person”’
or the term ‘‘compary’’ oupestaarehip, joint advent in-
cludes any individual, firm,-copartnership, joint adventure, |
association, corporation, trust‘or any other. group or com-.
bination acting as a unit, and the’ plural as well as the .
Singular number, unless the intention ” give a more limited
meaning is disclosed by the context.
“‘Tax year’’ or ‘‘taxable year’’ means either the calen-
dar year, or the taxpayer’s fiscal year when permission is
Fae sists dh : ,
27
obtained from the tax commissioner to use.same as the tax
period in lieu of the calendar year.
‘‘Sale’’ or ‘‘sales’’ includes the exchange of properties
as well as the sale thereof for money, every closed trans- .
action constituting a sale.
‘“‘Taxpayer”’ means any person liable for any tax here-
under. °
‘‘Gross income”? means the gross receipts of the tax-
payér received as compensation for personal services and
the gross receipts of the taxpayer derived from trade, busi-
ness, commerce or sales and the value proceeding or accru-
ing from the sale of tangible: property (real or. pers Sonal),
or service, or both, and all receipts by reason of tke invest-
ment of the capital of the business engaged in, Including
interest, discount, rentals, royalties, fees or other emolu-
ments however designated and without any deductions on
account of the cost of property sold, the cost of materials
used, labor costs, taxes, royalties, interest or discount paid
or any other expense whatsoever. —
‘‘Business,’?’ as used in this article, shall include all
_activities engaged in or caused to be engaged in with the
ebject of gain or economic benefit either direct or indirect.
The production of raw materials or manufactured prod- .
ucts, which are used or consumed in the ‘main business,
Shall be deemed business engaged in taxable in the class
in which it falls.
-‘Gross proceeds of sales’? means the value actually pro-
eceding from the sale of tangible property without any de-
. duction on account of the cost of property sold or expenses
of any kind. The.words ‘‘gross income’’ and ‘‘gross
proceeds of sales’ shall not be construed to include cash
discounts allowed and taken on sales; the proceeds of sale
of goods, wares or merchandise returned by customers
when the sale price is refunded either in cash or by credit;
or the sale price of any article accepted as part payment
on any new article sold, if the full sale “goad of the new
article is included i in the ‘‘gross income” 0 r ‘‘gross pro-
“ceeds of sales’’.
‘‘Service business or calling”? shall include all nonprofes-
sional activities engaged in for other persons for a consid-
eration, which involve the rendering of a service as dis-
tinguished from the production or sale of tangible prop- ©
a
erty, but shall not include the services rendered by an em-
ployee to his employer. . >
The classification of ‘‘wholesaler’’ or ‘‘jobber’’ shall
apply gnly to a person doing a bel css jobbing ©
business, known to the trade as such, selling to licensed
retail merchants or jobbers, or to others i in wholesale quan-
tities and at wholesale prices.
_ See. 2. There i is hereby levied and shall be collected an-
nual privilege taxes against the persons, on account of the —
business and other activities, and in the amounts to be
determined by the application of rates against values: or
gross income, as follows:
(a) Upon every person engaging or continuing within
this state in the business of producing for sale, profit or
commercial use any natural resource products, the amount
of such tax to be equal to the value of-the articles produced
as shown by the gross proceeds dérived from the sale
thereof by the producer, except as her-inafter provided,
multiplied by the respective rates as follows: Coal, one per
' cent; limestone or sandstone, quarried or mined, one and
: one-half per cent; oil, three. per cent; natural gas, in excess
of the value of five thousand ‘dollars, six per cent; blast fur- .
nace slag, three per cent; sand, gravel or other mineral’
product, not quarried or mined, ‘three per cent; timber, one
and one-half per cent; other natural: resource products, two
per cent. The measure of this tax is the value of.the entire
production in this state, regardless of the place of sale or
the fact that delivery may be made to points outside the ..
state.
(b) Upon every person engaging or continuing within
this state in the business of manufacturing, compounding,
or preparing for sale, profit, or commercial use, either
directly or through the activity of others in whole or part,
any article or articles, substance or substances, commodity
or commodities, or electric power not produced by public
utilities taxable under other provisions of this section, the
amount of the tax to be equal to the value of the articles,
substance; commodities or electric power manufactured,
compounded or prepared for sale, as shown by the gross
proceeds derived from the sale thereof by the manufac-
turer ar person compounding or preparing the same (ex-
cept as hereinafter provided), multiplied by a rate of three-
_ tenths of one per cent--The measure of this tax is the value
of the entire product manufactured, compounded, or pre-
pared in this state for sale, profit or commercial use, re-
gardless of the place of sale or the fact that deliveries may
be made to points outside the state. -
If any person liable for any tax under subdivisions (a)
or (b) shall ship or transport his products or any part
thereof out of the state without making sale of such prod-
ucts, the value of the products in the condition or form in
which they exist immediately before transportation: out of
the state shall be the basis for the assessment of the tax im-
posed in said subdivision; and the tax commissioner shall
prescribe — and uniform rules for ascertaining such
value.
In determining value, however, as regards sales from one
to another of affiliated companies or persons, or under
other circumstances where the relation between the buyer
and seller is such that the gross proceeds from the sale are
not indicative of the true value of the subject matter of the
sale, the tax commissioner shall prescribe uniform and
equitable rules for determining the value upon which such
privilege tax shall be levied, -corresponding as nearly as
possible to the gross proceeds from the sale of similar
products of like-qualfty or character where no common in-
terest exists between the buyer and seller but the circum-
stances and conditions are otherwise similar.
(c) Upon every pers0n engaging or continuing within
this state in the business of sélling any tangible property
whatsoever, real or personal, except sales by any person
engaging or continuing in the business of horticulture,
agriculture or grazing, stocks, bonds or other evidences of
indebtedness, there is likewise hereby levied, and shall be |
collected, a tax equivalent to three-fourths of one per cent
of the gross income of the business, except that in the case
of a wholesaler or jobber, the tax shall be equal to fifteen -
one-hundredths of one per cent of the gross income of the
business ;
(d) Upon any person engaging or continuing within this
state in any public service or utility business, except rail-.
road, railroad car, express, pipe line, telephone. and tele-
graph companies, water carriers by steamboat or steam-
ship and motor vehicle carriers, there is likewise hereby
30
‘levied and shall be collected taxes on account of the business ©
engaged in equal to the gross income of the business multi-
plied by the respective rates as follows: Street and inter- ~
urban and electric-railways, one per cent; water companies, -
four per cent, except as to incéme from municipally owned
water plants; electric light and power companies, four per
cent-on sales and demand charges for domestic purposes
and commercial lighting and three per cent on sales and
demand charges for all other purposes, except as to income
from .municipally owned plants producing or purchasing
electricity -and distributing same; natural gas companies,
three per cent on the gross income, said gross income for
this purpose to be determined by deducting from gross in-
come from all sales to consumers the amount of the tax .
paid by the taxpayer under subdivision (a). of this section;
toll bridge companies, three per cent; and upon all other
public service or utility business, two per cent. The meas-
_ ure of this tax shall not include gross income derived from
commerce between this state and other states of the United
States or between this state and foreign countries.
(e) Upon every person engaging. or continuing within
this e‘ate in the business of contracting, the tax shall be
equal to two pér cent of the gross income of the business; —
(f) Upon every person engaging or continuing within’
this state in the business of banking, the tax shall be equal
.to five-tenths of one per cent of the gross income of the
_ business ;
(g) Upon every person engaging or continuing within .
' this state in the business of operating a theater, opera
house, moving picture show, vaudeville, amusement park,
dance hall, skating rink, race track, radio broadcasting
station or any other place at which amusements are offered
to the public, the tax shall be equal to' one and one-half per
cent of the gross income of the business ;
(h) Upon every person engaging or continuing within
this state in any service business or calling not otherwise
specifically taxed under this act, there is likewise Hereby
levied and shall be collected a tax equal to one per cent of
the gross income of any such business;
(i) Upon every person engaging or continuing within
this state in any business, profession, trade, occupation or
<= — ee eS Seeman cree teleeeea a
5 ate ae
calling not included in Yhe preceding subdivisions or any
other provision of this act (but not including a person en-
- gaging or continuing in the business of horticulture, agri-
culture or grazing) there is likewise hereby levied and shall
‘be collected, a tax equal to one per cent of the gross income
| of any such activity. This subdivision shall apply to the.
gross incomes of persons taxable under other subdivisions
‘hereof not derived from the exercise of privileges taxable
thereunder. .
: Gross income included in ‘the measure of the tax under
q subdivisions (a) and (b) hereof, except in the case of pro-
: duction of natural gas, shall neither be added nor deducted
in computing the tax levied under the other subdivisions of .
this article. ”
A person exercising any privilege taxable under subdivi-
sions (a) or (b) of this section and engaging in the busi-
ness of selling his. natural resource or manufactured prod-
ucts at retail in this state shall be required to make returns
of the gross proceeds of such retail sales and pay the tax
imposed in subdivision (c) of this section for the privilege
of engaging in the business of selling such natural resource
or manufactured products at retail in this state. But any
person exercising any privilege taxable under subdivisions
(a) or (b) of this section and engaging in the business of
selling his natural resource or manufactured products to ©
manufacturers, wholesalers or jobbers,. and in the case of
limestone, sand, gravel or other mineral product, to com-
* mercial: consumers, shall not be required to pay the tax
imposed in subdivision (c) of this section for the privilege
of selling such natural resource e products . or manufactured
‘products at wholesale.
[fol.34] Manufacturers exercising any stile taxable :
undey subdivision (b) of this section shall not be required -
to p&y the tax imposed in subdivision (c) of this section — —
for the privilege of selling their manufactured products
for delivery outside of this state, but the gross income de-
rived from the sale of such manufactured products outside
‘ of this state shall be included in determining the measure
of the tax imposed on such manufacturer in said subdivi-
sion (b).
__ A person exercising privileges taxable under the other
‘subdivisions of this section, producing coal, oil, natural - |
gas, minerals, timber or other natural resource ‘products 4
en ee ee
* aii
‘ it
32
the production of which is taxable under subdivision (a),
and using or consuming same in his business, shall be
deemed to be engaged in the business of mining and pro-
ducing coal, oil, natural gas, minerals, timber or other
natural resqurce products for sale profit or commercial
use, and shall be required to make returns on:account of
the production of the business showing the gross -proceeds
or equivalent in accordance with uniform and equitable
‘rules for determining the value upon which such privilege
tax shall be levied, corresponding as nearly as possible to
the gross proceeds from the sale of similar products of
like quality or character by other taxpayers, which rules
the tax commissioner shall prescribe.
Sec. 3. There shall be an exemption in every case, except *
as to the privileges taxable under section two-(i) of this
article, of twenty-five dollars in amount of tax computed
under the provisions of this artitle. A person exercising
a privilege taxable hereunder for a fractional part of a tax
. year shall be entitled to an exemption of the sum bearing
the proportion to twenty-five dollars that the period of
time the privilege is exercised bears to a whole year.
Only one exemption shall be allowed to any one person,
whether he exercise one or more privileges taxable here- ©
under.
In computing the ne levied under section two-(i) of this
article, there shall be deducted from ‘gross income an .
exemption of six dollars in amount of tax, plus an exemp-
tion of four dollars in the case of a married person living
with a spouse-actually dependent upon such person for
support, and an additional exemption of two dollars for
each person actually dependent upon the taxpayer; but the
maximum exemption in every case shall be twenty-four .
dollars. A person exercising any privilege taxable under
section two-(i) of this article, whose gross income exceeds
six hundred dollars, if single or if married and not living
with husband or wife, or whose gross income exceeds one
- thousand dollars, if married and living with husband or
wife dependent upon such person for support, shall file a
return or returns as required by sections four and five of
this article.
The provisions of this article shall not apply to: (a) In-
surance companies which pay the state of West Virginia
a tax upon pan (b) —- — banks not having
—__— —- t= SO Re inser > re ne ie ern ag its ti
’
3
a. capital stock represented by shares and nonprofit mutual
_ building and loan associations operated for the exclusive
benefit of their members; (c) nonprofit cemetery com-
panies Organized and operated for the exclusive benefit of
their members; (d) societies, organizations and, associa-
tions organized and operated for the exclusive benefit of
their members and not for profit; and (e) corporations,
associations and societies organized and operated exclu-
sively for religious or charitable purposes.
Sec. 4. The taxes levied hereunder shall be payable in
quarterly installments on or before the expiration of thirty
days from the end of the quarter in which they accrue.
The taxpayer shall, within thirty days from the expiration
of each quarter, make out. an estimate of the tax for which
he is liable for such quarter, verify the same by oath, and
mail the same togethér with a remittance in the form re-
quired by section eleven of this article for the amount of’
the tax, to the office of the tax commissioner. The tax com-
missioner, if he deems it necessary to insure payment of
the tax, may require return and payment under this section
for-other than quarter year periods. ‘In estimating the
amount of the tax due for each quarter the taxpayer may
deduct one-fourth of the total exemption allowed for the
year. When the total tax for which any person is liable
under this article does not exceed the sum of one hundred
dollars in any year, the taxpayer may pay the same quar-
terly as aforesaid or pay the same.at the end of the month
‘next following the close of the tax year.
Sec. 5. On or before thirty days after the end of the tax
year each person liable for the payment of a tax under sec- -
tion two of this article shall make a return showing the
gross proceeds of sales or gross income of business, trade
or calling, and compute the amount of tax chargeable
‘ against him in accordance with the provisions of this
article and deduct the amount of quarterly payments (as
hereinbefore provided), if any, and transmit with his re-
port a remittance in the form required by section eleven of
this article covering the residue of the tax chargeable |
against him to the office of the tax commissioner; such re-
turn shall be verified by the oath of the taxpayer, if made
by an individual, or by the oath of the president, vice presi-
3—625
ii)’
Hille '
34
-
‘dent, secretary or treasurer of a corporation, Gf made’ on
behalf of a corporation. If made on behalf of a. partner-
ship, joint adventure, association, trust, or any other group
or combination acting as a unit, any individual delegated
by such.firm, copartnership, joint adventure, association,
trust or any other group or combination acting as a unit,
shall make the oath on behalf of the taxpayer. If for any
reason it is not practicable for the.individual taxpayer to
make'the oath, the same may be made by any duly author-
ized agent. The tax commissioner, for good cause shown,
imay extend the’time for making the annual return on the
application of any taxpayer and grant such reasonable ad-|
ditional time within which to make the same as may, by
him, be deémed advisable.
- Sec. 6. If the taxpayer shall make any error. in comput--
ing the tax assessable against him, the tax commissioner’
shall correct such error or reassess the proper amount of
taxes, and. notify the taxpayer of his action by mailing to
him promptly a copy of the corrected assessment, and any
additional tax for which such taxpayer may be liable shall
be paid within ten days after the receipt of such statement.
If the amount already paid exceeds that: which should
have been paid on the basis of the tax'so recomputed, the
excess so paid shall be immediately refunded to the tax-
payer upon the requisition of the tax commissioner to the
state auditor, who.shall issue his warrant on the treasurer,
which shall be payable out of any funds available for ‘the
purpose. The taxpayer may, at his election, apply an over-
payment credit to taxes subsequently accruing hereunder.
Sec. 7.4lf any person fail or refuse to make a return,
either in whole or in part, or if the tax commissioner has _
reasonable ground to believe that any return made is so de-
ficient as not to form the basis of a satisfactory assessment
of the tax, he may proceed as he deems best to obtain in- ~
formation on which to base the assessment of the tax. The
tax commissioner may by himself or his duly. appointed .
agent, make examination of the books, records and papers,
and audit the accounts of any such person, and may take
the evidence, administered by himself or’his agent, on oath,
of ary.person who he may believe shall be in possession ‘of
any relevant information. As soon as possible after pro-
curing such information as he may be able to,obtain as to
”
9
35
‘any person failing or refusing to make a return, the tax
commissioner shall proceed to assess the tax and shall
notify the person assessed of the amount of the tax. The
assessment of the tax by the tax commissioner shall be final
as to any person who refused to make a return.
Sec. 8. If any person, having made the return and paid
_ the tax as provided by this article, feels aggrieved by the
assessment so made upon him for any year by the tax com-
missioner, he may apply to the board of public works by
’ petition, in~writing, within thirty days after notice is
mailed tp him by the tax commissioner, for a hearing and a
correction of the amount of the tax so assessed upon him
by the tax commissioner, in which petition shall be set forth
the reasons why such hearings should be granted and the
amount such tax should be reduced. The board shall
promptly consider such petition, and may grant such hear-
ing or deny the same. If denied, the petitioner shall be
forthwith notified thereof; if granted, the board shall
notify the petitioner of the time and place fixed for such
hearing. After such hearing, the board may make such
order in the matter as may appear to it just and lawful, and
shall furnish a copy of such order to the petitioner. Any
person improperly charged with any tax and required to
pay the same may recover the amount paid, together with
interest, in any proper-action or suit against the tax com-
missioner, and the circuit court of the county in which the
taxpayer resides or is located shall have original jurisdic-
tion of any action to recover any tax improperly. collected.
It shall not be necessary for the taxpayer to protest against
the payment of the tax or to make any demand to have the
same refunded in order to maintain such suit. In any suit a
to recover taxes paid or to collect taxes, the court shall ad-
judge costs to such extent and in such manner as may be
deemed equitable. Upon presentation of a certified copy
of a judgment so obtained, the auditor shall issue his war-
rant upon any funds in the treasury available for the pay-
ment thereof. . | iy
No injunction shall be awarded by ‘any court or judge to
restrain the collection of the taxes imposed by this article,
or any part of them, due from any person, except upon the
ground that the assessment thereof was in violation of the
constitution of the United States, or of this state; or that
$e . be y _—
the same were fraudulently assessed; or that there wasa
mistake made in the amount of taxes assessed upon such
person. In the latter case, no such injunction shall be
* awarded, unless application shall first have been made to
the board of public works to correct the alleged mistake
and the board shalt have refused to do so, which fact shall
be stated in the bill, and unless the complainant shall have
paid into the treasury of the state all taxes appearing by
the bill of complaint to be owing. .,
Section 9. The assessment of taxes herein made and the
returns required therefor shall be for the year ending on
the thirty-first day of December. If the taxpayer, in exer-
cising a privilege taxable under fhis article, keeps the .
: - books reflecting the sanie on a basis other than the calendar
year, he may, with the assent of the tax commissioner,
make his annual returns and pay. taxes for the year cover-
. ‘ing his accounting period, as shown by the male ‘of keep- .
ing his books.
Sec. 10. The tax imposed by tl this article shall be in addi-
tion to all other licenses-and taxes levied by law as a condi-
tion precedent to engaging in any business, trade or call- - .
ing. A person exercising a privilege taxable under this ©
article; subject to the payment of all licenses and chargés
- which are condition precedent to exercising the privilege
taxed, may exercise the privilege for the current tax year.
upon the condition that he shall pay the tax accruing under
this article. ,
Sec. 11. All remittances of taxes imposed by this article
shall be made to the tax commissioner, by bank draft, cer-
_. tified check, cashier’s' check, money order, or certificate of
deposit, who shall issue his receipts therefor to the tax-
payers and shall pay the moneys into the:state-treasury to .
be kept and accounted for as provided by law.
Sec. 12. A tax due and unpaid under this article shall be
a debt due the state and shall be a lien upon the property
used in the butiness or occupation upon which it is im-
posed. The lien shall have the same priority as the Ken of
the general property tax. A penalty of five per cent of the
tax shall be added for any default for thirty days or less
and for each succeeding thirty days elapsing before pay-
ment there shall be added an additional penalty of one per
.. =
— ' ee YE ROT ATE AES pratt : ro > 3 ’
37
cent.. The additional one per cent penalty shall not apply
until a ten day notice of delinquency shall have been sent
to the taxpayer. -
Sec. 13. The tax commissioner may by himself, or a von
appointed agent mentioned in section oe of this
article, collect taxes due and. unpaid. wuder - -this article,
together with all accrued penalties, by action ‘in assumpsit,
motion for judgment, or other ‘appropriate proceeding in
the circuit court of the county in which the privilege taxed
_ had been exercised. ‘After delinquency shall have con-
tinued sixty days, the. tax commissioner may proceed, by
himself. or agent, in the circuit court ofthe county in which
the privilege taxed had been exercised to obtain an. injunc-
tion restraining the further exercise of the privilege until
full payment shall have been made; of all taxes and penal-
ties due under this article. In any proceeding under this
section upon judgment or decree for the plaintiff he shall
be’ awarded his costs. :
Sec. 14. The tax imposed by this article shall be a lien
upon the property of any person subject to the provisions
hereof who shall sell out his business or stock of goods, or
shall quit business, and such person shall be required to
make the return provided for under section five of this
article within thirty days after the date he sold out his
business or stock of goods, or quit business, and his suc- .
cessor in business shall be required to withhold sufficient
of the purchase money to cover the amount of f such taxes
due and unpaid until such time as the former owner shall
produce a receipt from the tax commissioner showing that
the taxes have ben paid. If the purchaser, of a business or
stock of goods shall fail to withhold purchase money as
above provided, and the taxes shall be due and unpaid after
the thirty day period allowed, hé-shall be personally liable
for the payment of the taxes accrued and unpaid on ac-
count of the operation of the business by the former owner.
Sec. 15. The secretary of state shall withhold the issu-
ance of-any certificate of dissolution or withdrawal in the
case of any corporation organized under: the laws of this
state, or organized under the laws of, another state and ~
admitted to do business in this state, until the receipt of a
motice from the tax commissioner to the effect thatthe tax
levied under this article against any such corporation has
38 ;
o -
been paid or provided for, if any such corporation is a tax-
payer under this article, or until he shall be notified by the
tax commissioner that the sac nie is not subject to. pay a-
tax hereunder.
Sec. 16. All state, county and district officers and agents ©
| making contracts on behalf of the state of West Virginia
or any political subdivision thereof shall withhold payment |
in the final settlement of such-contracts until the receipt
of a certificate from the tax'comihissioner to the effect that
all taxes levied or accrued under this act against the con- -
tractor with respect to such edntracts have been paid.
See. 17.- In the distribution, voluntary or compulsory, i in
receivership, bankruptcy or otherwise, of the estate of any
person, firm or corporation,-.all taxes due and unpaid under
this article shall’ be paid from the first money available for _
distribution in priority to all claims, except taxes and debts -
due the United States. Any person charged with the ad-
ministration of an estate who shall violate the provisions.
of this section shall be personally liable for any taxes
accrued and unpaid under tnis article, which are chargeable
- against the person, firm or ——— whose estate is in
administration.
~ See. 18. The tex commissioner may, with the approval _
"of the governor, appoint. not more than twelve agents for
the entire state for the collection of delinquent taxes, de-
linquent license taxes and all penalties; all delinquent
taxes, delinquent license taxes and all penalties so collected
shall be, hy the tax commissioner, covered into the state
treasury to the credit of the state general fund. The salarv
of every such agent appointed shall be determined by the
state tax commissioner v and with the approval of the
governor.
~ [fol..35] ‘Sloe. 19. The tax commissioner for the more in.
tive collection of the tax may file with the clerk of the county
court of any county a certified copy of an assessment of taxes.
under this article.. A certificate so filed shall be recorded
in a book provided for the purpose and thereafter shall con-
stitute binding notice of the lien created by this article upon
all lands of the taxpayer located in the county as against all —
_ parties. whose interest arose after such recordation. Upon
payment ‘of taxes delinquent under this article the lien of
which shall have been recorded the tax commissioner shall
certify in duplicate the fact and amoukt of payment and the -
-. balance due, if any and shall forward the certificates, one to
the taxpayer and one to the clerk of the county court of the
county where the taxpayer shall have been listed as delin-
_ quent. The clerk of the county court shall record the cer-
- tificate in the book in which releases are recorded, without
payment of. any additional fee. From the date that such a
certificate is admitted to record the land of the taxpayer
in the county shall be free from any lien for taxes under this
article accrued to the date that the certificate was issued.
Sec. 20. The tax commissioner may distrain upon any ~
goods, chattels, or intangibles represented: by negotiable’
evidences of indebtedness, “of any taxpayer delinquent under
this/article for the amount of all taxes and penalties accrued
and unpaid hereunder. The commissioner may require the
aSsistance of the,sheriff of any county of the state in levying . -
such distress in the county of which such sheriff is an-officer.
A sheriff so collecting taxes due hereunder shall be entitled
to,compensation in the amount of all penalties collected over
and above the principal amount of the tax due, but in no case
shall such compensation exceed twenty-five dollars. All
-taxes and penalties so collected shall be reported within ten
days after collection to the tax commissioner, wha shall pre-
scribe by general regulation the manner of remittance of
such funds and of allowing the collecting officer the com-
} pensation. due him under this section.
Sec. 21. It shall be unlawful for any person to ‘refuse to
make the return provided.to be made in section five of this
article; or to make any false, or fraudulent return or false
statement in any return, with intent to defraud the state or
- to evade the payment of the tax, or any part thereof, imposéd
' by this article; or for any person to aid or. abet another in
any attempt to evade the payment of the tax, or any part
thereof, imposed by this atticle; or for the president, vice
president, secretary or treasurer ‘of any corporation to make
or permit to be made for any corporation or association any
.. false return, or any false statemént in any-return required
in this article, with the intent to evade the payment of any
tax hereunder. And any person violating any of the provi-
- gions of this section shall be guilty of s misdemeanor and,
on conviction thereof, shall be fined not more than one thou-
40
sand dollars or imprisoned not exceeding one year in the |
county jail or punished.by both fine and imprisonment, at
- the discretion of the court, within the limitations aforesaid.
In addition to the foregoing penalties, any person who shall
knowingly swear to or verify any false or fraudulent return,
or any return containing any false or fraudulent statement,
with the intent aforesaid, shall be guilty of the offense of
false swearing, and, on conviction thereof, shall be punished
in the manner provided by law. Any corporation for which
a false.return, or a return containing a false statement, as.
aforesaid, shall be made, sigh guilty of a misdemeanor
and shall be punished by a fipé of not more than one thou- ©
sand dollars. The circuit axfd criminal courts of the county
in which the offender resides, or, if a corporation, in whieh
it carries on business, shall have concurrent ; jurisdiction to
enforce this section.
Sec. 22. The administration of this article is vested in
and shall be exercised by the tax commissioner who shall pre-
scribe forms and reasonable rules of procedure in con-
formity with this article for the making of returns and for
the ascertainment, assessment and collection of the taxes .
imposed hereunder; and the enforcement of any of the pro-.
visions of this article i in any of the courts of the state shall
be under the exclusive jurisdiction of the tax commissioner,
who shall require the assistance of and act through the prose-
cuting attorney of any county where suit is brought; but the
prosecuting attorney of any county shall receive no fees or
compensation for services rendered in enforcing this article
in addition to the salary paid by the county to such officer.
Sec. 23. If a part of this article is for any reason declared
unconstitutional, or otherwise invalid, the decision of the
court shall not affect the validity of any remaining portion.
Article 12-A—Transportation Privilege Tax Law ,
Section 1. When used in this article the term ‘‘company’”’
shall include any partnership, joint adventure, joint stock
. company or association.
The phrase ‘‘motor vehicle carrier’’ shall mean any per-
son engaged in the transportation of passengers or prop-
erty, or both, for compensation by motor propelled vehicle
for the operation of which a permit or certificate of con-
venience or convenience and necessity is required by law.
\ na a 41
sa r
The term ‘‘ton-mile’’ shall be a unit of transportation —
meaning transportation of one net ton in weight a distance
of one mile. oi | .
The term ‘‘passenger-mile’’. means the transportation of
one passenger a distance of one mile. ‘
The term ‘‘car-mile’’ means the operation of a railroad
car Over a distance of one mile.
The term ‘‘barrel-mile’’ means the transportation of the.
equivalent of a barrel of oil a distance of one mile.
. The phrase ‘‘one thousand cubic -feet-mile’’ means the
transportation of one thousand cubic feet of gas, measured
at sixty degrees Fahrenheit and a pressure of thirty inches"
of mercury a distance of one mile. _
The term ‘‘wire-mile’’ means the equivalent of a single
metallic telephone or telegraph conductor one mile in length:
Sec. 2. Every railroad corporation doing business in the
state shall pay an annual privilege tax for each calendar
year for the privilege of doing business in the state. The
_ tax shall be five-tenths of one per cent of the value of the
total property, tangible and intangible, of the corporation in
the state as determined by the assessment made during the
calendar year by the board of public works for the purposes
of the general property tax. .
It is the purpose of this section to levy a privilege tax
upon railroad corporations for the privilege of engaging in
~ business conducted entirely within this state, and it is not
intended to impose any tax or charge upon. interstate or
foreign commerce. The return required for purposes of
‘the general property tax shall suffice for purposes of this
section. . 7
No public corporation of the state shall levy a license or
privilege tax on the business taxed under this section.
Sec. 3. Every person or corporation operating a steam-
boat, steamship or other floating property for the transpor-
tation of passeng’ ’s or freight, and’ doing business within
the state shall pay to the state an annual privilege tax for
each calendar year. The tax shall be two and one-half per
cent of the gross income from business beginning and end-
ing entirely within the.state and a like percentage of its re- -
maining gross income earned within the state, to be deter-
mined as follows: , .
Ascertain the. total gross income from all business not
confined to this state which begins, ends or passes through
PEYLIGIN AS eh 8 ste Les F
* - t
Sh Pie cigs, 250M 4
ii by
ye
49.
the state and determine both the total ton-miles of freight
so hauled and the ton-miles of such business actually done.
within the limits of this state. The tax shall be Sssessed
against a sum bearing the proportion to the amount:of gross
income so determined that the ton-miles of such business
done in-this state bear to the total ton-miles of such business.
"This tax shall be in addition to all other license taxes or
vharges to which such taxpayers are subject under the law
of this state, and shall be measured in terms of gross income
for the year ending December thirty-first preceding.
Sec. 4. Every motor vehicle carrier operating on the pub- -
lic highways of this state and every railroad car corpora-
tion, express corporation or company, pipe line corporation,
telephone and telegraph corporation doing business in the
state shall pay to the state an annual privilege tax for each
calendar year for the privilege of doing business in the
state. This tax shall be equal to the gross income from all
business beginning and ending within the state multiplied
by the respective rates as follows: Motor vehicle carriers,
railroad car corporations, express corporations or compa-
nies, one and one-half per cent ; pipe line corporations, three
and one-half per cent; telephone corporations two and three-
. , fourths per cent; and telegraph corporations, five per cent.
Sec. 5. In addition to the tax imposed in the preceding
sections, every motor vehicle carrier operating on the public
highways of the state and every railroad corporation, rail-
road car corporation, express corporation or company, pipe
line corporation, telephone and telegraph corporation doing
business in this state shall pay an annual privilege tax for
each calendar year for the privilege of doing business in
the state, to be determined as follows:
(a) The tax .as.to motor vehicle carriers shall be equal
to one and one-half per cent of the net income earned within
the state, such income to be determined by ascertaining a
sum bearing'the proportion to the total net income from -
_ passenger and freight traffic that the business done in West
‘Virginia, measured in passenger-miles of passengers car- |
ried in the state as to passenger traffic, and in ton-miles as
to freight traffic, bears to all business done, measured in like
fashion ; .
(b) The tax as to railroad corporations shall be equal to
four per cent of the net income earned within the state, such ©
-
a
43
income to be determined by ascertaining a sum bearing the
proportion to total net income of the corporation that its
business done in West V irginia, measured in ton-miles, bears
to all business done, measured in like fashion ; ae
(c) The tax as to railroad car corporations and as to
express corporations or companies shall be one and one-
half per cent of net income earned within the state, such |
income to be determined by ascertaining a sum bearing the
proportion to the total net income of the corporation or eom-
pany that its business done in West Virginia, measured in
car-miles of car operation, bears to all business done,
measured in like fashion; — : eae |
(d) The tax as to pipe line corporations shall be three and
one-half per cent of net income earned within the state, such
'- income to be ‘determined by ascertaining a sum bearing the
proportion to the total net income of the corporation that
its business done in West ‘Virginia, measured in barrel-
miles in the case of oil and of thousand cubic feeét-miles in
' . the case of gas, bears to all business done, measured in like
’
fashion ;.
(e) The tax as to telephone and telegraph corporations
shall be two and three-fourths per cent of net income earned
- within the state as to telephone corporations, and five per.
cent.as to telegraph corporations, such income to be deter-
_ mined by ascertaining a sum bearing the proportion to the *
total net income of the corporation that its business done
in West Virginia, measured in wire-miles, bears tg all busi-
ness done, measured :in like fashion ; |
: hoa
.(f) In computing the tax imposed by this séction tha total
net income of a taxpayer, who shall have been taxed. ander
the preceding section, shall be reduced by an amount bearing
‘the proportion to such total net income that the gross in-
come of the taxpayer which is the measure of the tax under
the preceding section bears to its total gross income from
all business done wherever conducted. This section shall
not apply to a taxpayer taxed under the preceding section .
and engaged exclusively in business within this state.
Sec. 6. The taxpayer under this article shall file an annual
return with the state tax commissioner upon a form pre-
_ seribed by the commissioner setting out the following: and
‘such other information as that officer may deem necessary
44
or useful in aid of the assessment and computation of the
tax:
(1) The gross income, from all business done within the
state, namely, business beginning and ending entirely within
the state;
(2) The total gross income of the business wherever con-
ducted ; |
(3) The net income of the hethnnes wherever conducted.
For this purpose the determination of net income for pur-
poses of the net income tax due the government of the
United States under the laws of the United States shall be
taken as final ;
(4) The total amount of business done in this state,
measured in the units hereinbefore prescribed. The tax
commissioner may designate a single month in the tax year
as the period for which the amount of business done in this
state, measured in the units hereinbefore prescribed, shall
-be reported and shall fix the total amount of business done
in the state for the whole tax year by multiplying the amount
determined for the designated month by twelve. -For the
tax period from the date this act takes effect through De- —
cember thirty-first, one thousand ‘nine hundred thirty-three,
the tax commissioner may designate any month in that
period for purposes hereof ; :
(5) The total amount of business done, wherever con-
ducted, measured in the units hereinbefore prescribed.
Every return shall be signed and sworn to by the tax-.
"payer, if .a natural person, and if a corporation, shall be
signed and sworn to by its president, vice president, secre-
tary or principal accounting officer. A return may be made
at the same time and as a supplement to the return required
for purposes of the general property tax and the tax com-
missioner may make use of relevant information in both in -
assessing the tax imposed by this article.
Sec. 7. The assessment of taxes under this article and
the returns required therefor shall be for the-year ending
on the thirty-first day of December. If the taxpayer in
exercising a privilege taxable under this article, keeps the
books reflecting the same on a basis other than the calendar
year, he may, with the assent of the tax commissioner, make
his annual returns and pay taxes for the year covering his
accounting period as shown by the method of keeping his
books. In case of the exercise of a privilege taxable here-
under for a fractional part of a tax year, the tax shall be
computed in like proportion to the tax for a full year.
Sec. 8. The total amount of tax imposed by this ‘article
shall be. paid.on or before the first day of April following
the close of the calendar year, or if the return should be
made on the basis of a taxpayer’s fiscal year, then, on the
first day of the fourth month following the close of the
fiscal year. The taxpayer may by writing, filed with the
tax commissioner, elect to pay the fax.in four equal quar-
terly installments in which case the first installment shall be
paid on the date hereinabove prescribed, the second install-:
ment shall be paid on the first day of the fourth month, the ~
third installment shall be paid on the first day of the seventh
month, and the fourth installment on the first day of the
tenth month, after such date. :
(fol. 36] Sec. 9. The tax imposed under this article shall be
in addition to all license taxes or charges to which the privi-
leges taxed herein are subject under the law of this state.
It is the purpose of this article. to rest a fair share of the
tax burden, commensurate with the benefits received, upon
those exercising privileges taxed hereby within this state.
Sec. 10. The amount of the tax imposed by this article
shall be a debt due the state and shall be a lien on all the
property and assets of the taxpayers within the state prior
to all other liens and charges except the lien of property
taxes with which the lien hereby created shall be on a parity.
A penalty of one per cent per month shall be added to the ~
amount of the tax for each month of delinquency and shall
be secured by the lien herein provided. ie
. See.11. The tax commissioner shall, between the first and
fifteenth day of February in every year, mail a notice of
delinquency, together with a statement of the total amount
of taxes and penalties due, to the last known postoffice ad-
dress of each. delinquent taxpayer. The cost of publication
hereunder shall be paid by the tax commissioner, when al- °
.lowed by the board of public works, out of the moneys in —
the treasury.
46 |
Not less than thirty days after giving notice of delinquency
‘as provided in the preceding paragraph the tax commis-
sioner shall certify to the secretary of state a list of all tax-
payers delinquent under this article. The secretary of state
shall preserve the list in his office and a certificate from him
that any taxpayer mentioned in such certificate is delinquent
in the payment. ‘of. the tax imposed by this article shall be
prima facie evidence thereof. Within thirty days after re-
ceipt of such certificate by the secretary of state it shall be
the duty of the attorney general to institute a suit in equity
in Kanawha county, in the name of the’state, in which such
delinquent taxpayers shall be made defendants. In thé -
bill so filed it shall be sufficient to allege that the defendants
’ have failed to pay taxes hereunder, and that each of them
justly owes the state the amount of privilege tax and pen-
alties stated therein, which amount shall be computed up
to the first day of the month succeeding that in which the
bill was filed. No such defendant shall plead that the tax
commissioner failed to give notice .as prescribed in this
section. |
If upon the hearing of such suit it shall appear to. the
court. that any defendant has failed to pay any such tax
and accrued penalties, the court shall enter a decree against
such defendant for the amount due, including the costs of
- the proceeding or such portion thereof as the court shall
apportion to be paid by such defendant. If the decree be
‘not paid when made the court shall enter a decree forfeit-
it: be a domestie corporation, revoking the franchises and
ing the charter, rights and n evoke such defendant, if.
privileges to hold property and tr
sact business in the
state, if it be a foreign corporation, and revoking all fran- ‘
. chises, licenses and privileges to conduct the business en-
gaged in if such defendant be an individual. ‘The money
decreed may be collected by the tax commissioner as other
claims due the state are collected.
The court. may on motion of the attorney general grant:
an injunction against any such defendant restraining the
exercise of any privilege or the transaction of any business
within the state until such decree including the costs be paid.
When two or more taxpayers are ingloded in one suit the
court shall apportion the cost thereof/among them as it may
deem just. |
feseS ant : o yt
47
Sec. 12. It shall be unlawful for any person to refuse to
make the return required to be made by section six of this
_ article; or to make any false or fraudulent return or false
Statement in any return, with intent to defraud the state or
to evade the payment of the tax, or any part thereof, im-
posed by this article; or for any person to aid or abet
another in any attempt to evade the payment of the tax,
or any part thereof, imposed by this article; or for the
president, vice president, secretary or treasurer of any cor-
poration to make, or permit to be made, for any corporation
or association any false return or any false statement in
any return required in this article, with the intent to evade
the payment of any tax hereunder. A person violating any
.of the provisions of this section shall be guilty of a misde-
meanor, and, on conviction thereof, shall be fined not more
than one thousand dollars or imprisoned not exceeding oné —
_ year in the county jail or, punished by both fine and -im-
prisonment, at the discretion of the court, within the limita-
tions aforesaid. ‘In addition to the foregoing penalties, any
person who shall knowingly swear to or verify any false
_ or fraudulent return, or any return containing any false or
fraudulent statement, with the intent aforesaid, shall be
guilty of the offense of false swearing, and, on conviction
_ thereof, shall.be punished in the manner provided by law.
Any corporation for which a false return, or a return con-
taining a false statement as aforesaid shall be made, shall
be guilty of a misdemeanor and may be punished by a fine
of not more than one thousand dollars. The circuit and
criminal courts of the county in which the offender resides,
or, if a corporation, in which -it carries on business, shall
have concurrent jurisdiction to enforce this section,
Sea 13. If a part of this article is for any reason declared
unconstitutional, or otherwise invalid, the decision of the
court shall not affect the validity of any remaining portion.
vs
48 |
[fol. 37] * “Copy. .
-Puarntirr’s Exursit No. 2¥0 Brut or CoMPLaInt
, wy, July 15, 1935.
Dravo Contracting Company, 302 Penn Ave., Pitts-
burgh, Pa. ~s
Please Refer to File No. 56-608
GENTLEMEN : | ;
I am enclosing herewith certified copies of gross sales
tax returns and assessments made up in this office showing
tax and penalty due the State of West Virginia in the
amount of $135,761.51 for the years 1933 and 1934.
Unless this sum is paid immediately, I shall be forced to
proceed in accordance with the law to collect same and to
distrain on your property to collect said tax. -
Yours very truly, —, State Tax Commis-’
sioner.
WM:ec
_ Ene.—
>
Pp
/
—
Sate) Ae CASON OER ny Ok FETUS
“VAM ‘NOLSAITUVHO 91¢l XOd UANQISSINNOO XVL soo kf. en Oq 0} UINJoL SIYL “XBL, wus!" Se[Bg SsOIH—-TOZ W1OT
e \
t
RE NI aaTHa auVv AAAVdXV HL Ad GALY Oday TAOGV SWA.LI XO WALI FHL HALIM WOCT—eE-TE-8
INIGNOdSANAOD SATAGAHOS Uc AINGAHOS AUVLINAWAIddAs GHL TLIND ALATdWOOD LON SI NUNLaAY SIAL
, ¥ ADVd NO GAGINOSaNd HLVO AG daldIyaA AG tah NYNnLad SIH.L
eoeneecessedeceoocs ' a eveveccccoccceccoccccesceccoccevoceedeccece H sousleq 0} [830], >: |
mnnneeemmeneenie aman on H euj] 10d’ sv onp xe} [8303 dn oyBU 0} pesojoue aoueyqiuioy i
" (‘Uinjey [enuuy jo Bully ey} Joy uoIsuszxe UB pojUBIZ ~
; useq eavy pus = pordde savy oym sidhedxe} woz AjuO paiynber st uInjer A[10718NH yp)
Sem eeeeenes Hee eeeenwewne Q 183°. Cerro) $ “1H ulPp weeeeee eee ewer eeeee m » "Id pag $ 1d puz $ “ID WT
TT; 4982 TRIOL HIGGNA SV SNUALIA GALVWILSA NO TGVW AXOAOLAYAH SINAWAVd 1
. ' _ 00° oor$ Jod 8}]U99 puv SIBI[OP UI UMOYS 918 SazByY :070N
1 F 72 s4Teued ' ‘dIVd TLLNO SAVA 0 DNIawaoons HOVE %Z% ANV ‘SxXvd 0g sul
£ %G9—UVEX XVL AC do ason UaLIV SAVA. OF NIHLIM TIid NI XVL AVd OL FUNTIVA Od SALLTVNGG
seoveens ovBpescevescsorecressssessy EE tn pi cr ecceearaes preetercerotee terre apart aera eT ger eee “oD Sexe’ JO JUNOUIS [iol
QL1 2602" 3 | P a 0OL “H
saneneyelounsuessennescocssranacenene ee |e eral dovetenenente h -onpesseedlivenmsseredicen-nessnenancencscssenliiedvansenen scons ee sossoutsnq rey30 [8 ‘ewoout s¥015 “DH
( o
ay CUR Cot et we 00°T ee Bara eee Wee SossoUlsnd JUsUlEsNUIY “BUIODUT BS0IF) “yy
arpa i ciatiekctiaaapa . Sn ee: Ste eee we ok = oe ~ ; :
a | 3602 oF RE | Tész6S™ | GO | OOOH" THESTS msouqeng Bupowsyu0 ‘omonu] ROI)“
SC ieeiieneuraes RE aos ee Bees Beem ane mae. ves lp sary yn ‘qnd Jeyj}0 puy 8," "YW 4S
eoermccreers locecencceesseeecsesseeccoees 09° weeceesceens lececeessanerenstene reese | [ances ereeees peeenieeoncnenting ceccoqocoocs eoccseecenencncergochorsl gr" seruvdwi0 iamod pus ua) 104
! : \ ~vefe ‘sseidxe ‘ydeiZeje, ‘auoydayay,
i
ER ii, keel carer acetals 00°T ee ces FR es ees, ce tee mens SS eur] edid puv 8,°yy “yy ureayS
sossaee enemies - proetefnnneenlfpeee ern squeg_
- : . :B@WODUT B80ID) “CJ
re ey ren co’ ws [ovrrerees foreeenecasererecerereses | aosssorere-—"* “SIBIVSI[OUM JO OWIOIUI SSOI5)
aa PSN =} pee Sore. 3 HL ; (soswqoind Jo 4900 0/¥ pemoire Boyonpep ON)
r erp x of? pany "2 ah of PSAS FpSq ||T “S49U30 pur siojrezau Jo euNOU} S801F) *O -
ee er rarrae sS3Izpus ~“BOus TETAS =|) szaungoejnyRUl eN{TA ssolt) “Gg
“; cFOINS EPIL. FO. eelgrass Jaquil} puv spessurUL 0910
4819 eu} £3 74189
kg teu wet en peig *T apa Poteet sed 'cinjUN
See cewerewes ban cc ewnreeeceeeneceseapeese 00°I Cer cecccons: [eeccecesecesecesocecces eeerecerees ee errs | errr rns beer rrr rrr ras separeonincuivennstumsescesncomntemeneginsenonnts hai |
~ . . ar’ $ ee ee “¢ seeeeeqseucdocecsoeseseseceee- cons $ Shaiea gra ecaniphinaetakbtnenes ¢ l eeecce eceses ““|w09
: mee ae See Boe i : ‘veeneneess @ aN[PA SS01N) *Y .
LINNOWVY ‘9 C0'00r$ LNIOWY SNOILGTWAXG “f INQOWY F WALI ‘I oa
Yad ALVA *S aTAVXVL “PF SSO4D “% .
« ¢
(NUNIGU ONIUVdaUd GUOdsa ‘g GOVd 4O LOOM LY AMOON] SSOUH AO NOILINIAgG Gas) ’
VINISHIA ISAM NI G4LONGNOO SSANISNA—XVI AO NOLLV.LAdWOO ° '
cocccccccccosccccnccccocccccccccces ———e—eee | maN (61) cuemeinee heen peau plo ‘os yu (81) CC EUANyer S14} &q pe1aa0d )
poised 04} hom oulvu $31 esuByo uoryB10d.100 a ee jueym ‘os JT (gI) o"juaInjer styz Aq pateaod posed 343 pond
sseursng 31nb 10 aajossip wo1zB10d109 au} Pid es LBIULSITA 38944 Ul SSOUISNG Op 0} poz}IWpE ueYyM ‘uUoI}BIOdI09 UBIaI0J B J] (pT)
eran jungZeq ssoursng wey M (sry 0988 7eYyM JO SMBl BYR Jepuy, (BI) fo Epeqeszodioour wey ‘uorzei0di09 & JT (TT)
1 a
Qaccoccccccscconcecccccsocconcouconsougpecsoccccccccousclocssovescece Foes qa tatay HI Ad GAUTAOD GOlad JO GNF woud SAV 0€ NIHLIM
an jwoys 04 ‘pjos ssduysnq J] (BOT) |...... 3 ee ao A
qsniy ‘8 pu’ L SNOILSAND OL | SUAMSNV MOHS LSNW
ase eee “ee ae Gee) > SSOIppe pus euleu peYydEisosseipps qNOUM sUINeY
OMEN Charm IA anaereRR ES BO eveccecee er uoIyBLOssYy ,
juinjei sty} Aq per9a0d poised Zutanp sid...
‘ssoutsnq yinb ao ‘Ajsedoid ano drysi0ui18g
Jo asodsip esjmioyyzo 10 [Jas Nod piq (6) "eg *ys.ings}4 td :
jsavoh | woRexodI0G | . or
‘
xoulIoy 10Z peyy suinjzer olay (g) Sa . *kareduog. ZuT{ 0817 NOD Soavig
unZeq ssoutsnq ue L t pat :
junsoq q ueym (L) 909-96
acer eee TT = | 7
Pe ee ee ae 8 Zuo0jeq nod yoy 0F BsBlo 943 x Aq ayeoIpul pus ssoippe pus oulvu j1esuy
— _, eeene a nr >
ne S peng quaey a. os WINQOY Sulisdeig (peAojdwe jr) qs0dxgy episjng jo sseippy pus auleN (9) /
Sse sotiesnitiey SEM 5.0. ‘schabindabicehsabsinediemniinnibacas BA “AM, Ul SHIOM Jo}YO 40 ssoursng Jo so¥I[q Tedyourg (9) |
viantndnditnsd SHARE : “ea ud») mmgssttd (22MO 980g) we qdey ee qunosoy “jo syoog (Pp)
ee: Vee SuTrisesp ies peyonpuog sseursng 70 eInjeN (g)
deguttttataas CR ol 3 Vg 8 tt a worpIwaA Wed 10 (2) BEET PUM zwex Jog (1) |
SIMO AVEANE £0 HSH 0d tT] st ssuary'] 8a[6g 8801—NUNLAY IVANNV—VINIDUIA ISAM JO ALVIS
Oe
20
CE
(g§ e8ed Jo yooy uojzIUgep eeg) [ eBeud ‘Zz a Jed sw ‘ssoulsng Jo eulooU] S80I5 [WOT (9)
oe BEd10AUT JO Bz uo pazonpep pus paMol[e JI sJUNOOSIp apBly, (oy
(0-9 2NYy 20s) S1GUIOJSNI 04 BaoToAUut $,1aABdxe} Ul pepnpoul saZieyo yyAlaIg (Ff)
Jeuioysnd Aq payonpep pus sed10aut JO. aoey uo umMoys SJUNODSIP YysED ( 8).
2... Ayyenuue 000‘0T$ JO 2381 4B UOIGWdUIexe dyIDedg (7)
| wd ‘g uuinjod Jed se peullels suoizdwiexes ppy
“? ° ines en a ““{ oZed ‘yp uwunyoo Jed sv ‘ssguisng zo @Ul0dUT 88025) a[qexey, (1)
330° ‘g1¥1/0G ‘ m4 *JO9194} g 0}.Z SUUIN[OD UI SaIIjUe Jadozd 34} JO
Suyyeu oy} Aq pozojduoy useaq sey ‘{ e3ed ‘SAaXV.L 40 NOILLVLNdWOO 10}jJ@ poindasd aq 0} 81 ajnpayos sry.
(4j10d01g a1auey Suljjesg FO ssoutsnq ou Ul peseZue suosieg [|B fq pesn oq OL) ‘O @TINGAHOS
LNONOKV
-
=
-
© °
“sesnéo 10430 10 syqap peq jo
7UN0d08 UO s9s80] Jo ‘asuedxe 19Y4}O IO SUOISSIWIUOD IOZ UOIZONpep qnoyqas A10j085 ‘q "0 ‘J saciid uo peseq oq 04 solid s3BIsAY—s3}ON
y
* peure3qo glun pzepusys i3ed aorad q8aM0] pus qwoysty 3381S (TT)
pesn i ‘szlun uotjyonpoad prepueys u* peseq Gun ar eo1id e3vi0a¥ pus uoljonpoid Moys ‘ULIOJIUN YOU s1B szIUN JT (OT)
- jposn st fun uorjonpoid qyM (6)
AAALAAAABA
ALAA ALAAAAAAAAAAAAA
I eZed ‘Z uuin[od Jed sev ‘seoroaut Aq uMOYsS 8B ‘gpao00ld SI[BS SsOIF5 [8}0], (8)
AAAABAAAAA
AAAAI ALABRASZAAARZAXAAA
: . ; ; , a-9_eny
depun poeydulexe S19ul0}sNd 0} SedIOAUI 4g,r0kedxey Ul Pepnpoul sesiByo Wyse (L)°
“(9a0qe g¢ pus pg‘z‘T Suez! JO UNS 9Y4} 6q 0} § “109 UI JUNOWB 94} ‘g ‘Z ‘T 103U0) s9AVd
-x8} JO sp10d01 Aq UMOYsS 8B ‘spadd0id so]¥s Ss013 pu¥ od1ud eSeieae 4yndyno 1870], (9)
XXXXZXXXXX
i *(O-6 2INY 99g) -Y Wey] JepuN poziodei1 yonpoid Jo onjea exIBH (¢)
XXXXXXXXX}
XXXNIAAAAAAARAAXRAXA
‘
S9DIOAUL JO 9B} .UO pajyonpep pus pamoyls Pit ‘squUNOOSIP opery, (PF)
xxxxxxxxx
XYVYWIiXAAARXRARNRRXEXKX
>
Jowoysnd Aq payoNpep pus sad10Aur Jo soBz oY} UO UMOYS FI syUNodsIp yseg (¢§)
[ .
AAALZALZXXX
ARZXXIiAAAAAAZAAAAAASZAA
f ~Ayyenuue 000‘O0T$ FO 2381 4B UOIGdUIaxe aytoedg (2)
:[ a3ed ‘g uumyjoo Jed se peullelo suorjduiexe ppy
3 AAAAAAXXEX
ARAZIAAAAZAAAARAXRAAA
T o3ed ‘pf uwnjoo Jed sv onjea afqexey, (T)
wee
8}1UQ, UoTOhporg
Ul yndynQ [ej0J,
(T)
9 | siellog
yup
a Jed ad11g
LNOOKV osBIOAY
“ (8) (2)
*JOo19Y) 9 04 ajoyou
sie ‘T a3ed ‘SAXV.L AO NOLLV.LNdWOO ad persdaud oq 02 SI ajnpayos SL
(‘esp 10 4youg ‘a[eg 4 aby sepipwy Buised
01g suosieg, pus siapunodui0g ae Aq posn\ oq ee en) ‘a AINGAHOS
es *f) a[npa” os ‘aepun “a9 ‘sequal {9 qupease Jepun ssouisng — en
*SOsNBd I9Yy}O JO Syqop pq Jo yuUNOCDoe UO sesso] ‘9dIId BurT[es
7O 4yno suse wee sUOISsTUIUI0D ‘asuodxe 19y}0 10 Bulljes 10y WOIJON pep Noy ‘q °O “ZF sedlud uo peseq oq 0} 9011d 93B10Ay—2}0N
Jequiy, Jo pury
‘49 ‘U0} 4A0Ys 10 Buoy Ek SR Oey nd eh Wade paureyqo soorad 4somo] pus 4S0y31y 27838 (6)
peonpoid [to jo apein ATER RESUAE SEEPS ECRNI NS TENN SE IIT Ons SETS PourU [BOD JO ures 9789S (OT)
. A
SAALZAAZRA
AAAAI AAAAZAAAAAAAAA
LB9 soul] JO UNS) peonpoid Jequil}, 10 S[elouN Jo on[eAa 1830, (8)
PB
AAAAAAAAA
AAAA| XXZAEXXAXXXXXXX
“349 ‘SULINPOVJNUBUL UY. pasn on] BA JoxYIVU pus sd11d 9Bv19ABe “4yndynoO (1).
-gp10004 8,104edxe} Aq UMOYS SB ‘Kpesd01d sales sso1g pus solid aBeiaae 4Yndyng (9)
T esed ‘Zz uuinjoo sed sv- ‘qy3teaz pus ‘psonpoid requir} 10 s[BiaUuIW Jo on[BA [BIO], (g)
A btu. d. | XXXXEXXAXXAXNXXA
AAAAAAAAD
AAAAAAAAA
AAAA|XAAXEAXAARARARA
s
Pe Oe @ @ ¢
f
Lo
oe (W-9 any 9a) Spss001g S8;¥G Ul PapN[oUl sosieyp BysIe1g = (F)
ieuojsnd Aq pezyonpep Aqyenqo8 SODIOAU! FO GOVT OY} UO UMOYS FI SJUNOISIp YsBQ = (§)_
; Ajyenuue 000‘0T$ JO 9981 9B UOIWdUIexe dyIDedG = §=._- (Z)
:T eded ‘g uuin[oo ied SB peulleyo x acs PPV
.
U
g AAaAaAaaA Aaa
AAAAIZEXXAAAXXAMEXA
ogress “Tt eSed ‘pf uunyjoo sed ‘se ‘anyea efqexey, (T)
z
ca
*8} 8181/0
2 < 9 T yun
ded 9d1ig
LNQOKV osesay
(8) (Z)
~sqran, woxonporg
Uy 3NdynO [so],
i ;
"J0aI94} 9 0% Z suumnjos ur sa11},Ud sadoad 242 jo —— 24} 4q pajajduiog useq
sey ‘[ e8ed ‘SaxV.L AO NOLLV.LAdWOO a peredeid oq 03 8] ajnpayos STYyy,
(‘zequity, jo srsonporg, pus ‘s[e1aulfy 10430
| pue ‘sep 4t0 [80D JO sieonporg pus ee | Aq pesh oq OL) “VY @INGAHOS
WOUd GOIWAd AHL YAAOD NUNLAY SIHL JO SATNGAHOS TIV.
*
?
ee
OV
pus {1aaccs}eyM osuedxe zeyjo Aue 10 ‘pred yunoosip 10 480103U! ‘g3809 JOB] “P2IsN STel1ezVUll JO S09 ‘pjos Azzedoid. jo 3809 4} FO zunos08
uo uoKoNpep Aus ynoyyA PUB pezsUsisep 10AeMoYy eyaoumny
seoursng 24} jo [eydwo oy} JO JueUTjseAut 04} FO YOSEF q penisoe 10 fenjzow ‘s}dyeoer [Ie pus ‘yQ0q 10 ‘ao1Ales
fyx0ci03
he
" sgassor JO JUNI’ UO SUOT;oOnpep AUS qnoyyta
Oued 10430 10 ‘sez ‘garqpeAor ‘gpejuer ‘yUNMOOSIp ‘}8010;U! Buipnyout
10 (teu Jo [ee1)
e[qiSusz Jo oes oy} WorZ Butnis08 10 pessoid apnea ouy suBoUl qo8 oy} JO. [ WO!}Oes Aepun pou ap se ,,{euloou] s#015,,
*kyaodoig e[qiZuey, Zurjjes Jo ssoursng——HD alnpeyss zapun peziodei ewooul S018 O[QUXB} OY} Ul PepNpoul oq OF St Qd1A10s 9Y} WOIZ Bulstis
ewlooUu! 88 ey} SSOUTSNG UIBUl ay} OF [BIUSPLOUl SI}: pewozied od1Ales 104}0 10 sitedei oy} pus S$doid. 91q{3u8} - eles oy} JO 3s]sU09
‘Zulyeziepun ‘sseursng iieder ofiqowlozne ‘szUBINGIsSel SE yonhs ‘pauiquios Ajzedoid oqi3usz pus sojAies
© Set oy} Uy (q) pus “970 ‘g[ejue1 e8vies ‘9}¥}89 [Bet JO Surjuer ‘satusduiod JUsWIyseAUl
‘solusduioo aousinsu awoy ‘ssoursng 338iex01q
yousse se Yons ‘o[Aies JO o[8s Ot} ul (8) Suljs{su0d sessoulsnq esiaduios. ) e_npeysg sepun qander 0 ‘perin siokedx¥I—A LON
an t o8ed ‘2 amunyoo aed se ‘x0hedxe], jo spaooer Aq umoys SB (MOTEq uorrayep 228) auiosuy soit) [830], (F)
. siswioysnd Aq paqon pap pus seofoaul jo eoey uo UMOYS FT sjunossip yseg (g)
neneinn aqeceeeeesceeecsereree . oe syenuue 000‘ot$s zo 781.32 woryduiexe ayeds (z)
:] e8ed “g uwmnyoo ‘zed sv ‘paulrelo suorjduiexe ppy
3 ~<a ad . { e8ed ‘p uumnjoo Jed se junoule e[quxEL (1)
° *Joa194} g 0} Z SUUINIOD UT Se}7}Ue szedoid oy} jo
LNNOKV Buyyeu oy) Lq pozaiduroy useq svy ‘, Sed “SAXVL AO NOLLV.LAd WOOD 49758 posedasd oq 0} 5} aynpeyrs STYL
| bee *(sanpdyos Zurpeo
-o1d ey} Ul pepnyouy jou ssoulsng ul pesesue suosied [je jo g eBed “uoruyep eeg—eouloouy ss01p) “DH qaINaGaHOSs
(1 eed ‘z *109 zed sv ‘19hBdxBy, JO Sp10ver Aq UMOYS SB MOTO GUIODUT SSOIL) FO uortuyep eeg) eulodU] S801f) [FOL (r)
= +, sonnets ney si9uojsnd Aq pezyoNpep PUB SIdTOAUL JO 90BF wo uUMOYS JI SJUNOCSSIP YSBH (8)
‘ig ieaerirmeniecinneacaent Hare : Ayyenuue Q00‘OT$ Fo e782 38 woHdutoxe oyroeds (2)
7 . ' 3] eBed ‘g uuinyod red sv ‘peurelo suclydulexe ppy
t ecccccccccccccdeoccccesococcoososesccossosoossoooosooooosoorg® a : I esed 7 wuinyjoo aed sB qunous a[qexey, (1)
, 7 , "yoo124} g 9} Z SuuINOo Ul sa1izue redo # oy jo
LNNORV Zuryeu oy) <q poyajduog wseq svy ‘; e3ed ‘SAXVL JO NOLLVLNdWNOO Ja}J8 poredosd oq 0} 8} e[Npeyrs SI4L
~ > e* - (‘q wey] ‘p eBed suorjonsysut ees) “Y 24} JZepun
peuyep se ‘sesseuisng JueWlesnWe Ul pesesue suosied sos aSed ‘uoltjiuyep xeg—euloou] ss01y) “JT qINGaHOSs
(o3ed JO JOoZ UOIzIUYeEP 99S) T o3ed ‘g uvanyoo aed sv ‘zofhedxey, JO sprover Aq UMOYS SB ‘quioouy ss01F [830] ‘(r)
. siswojsns Aq peyonpep pus S9OIOAUL JO GBF UO UMOYS Ft sjUNodsIp YysB_ -(g)
¢
om eles renee” " , Ayyenuue 900‘OT$ Jo av 48 WoRydutoxe oyyoeds (Z)
:] eBed ‘g uumyjoo sed se ‘paulo suotjduiexe ppy
é mceacencnenr eine eee [ eBed ‘p uumnjoo sed sw JunoWe o[qUxeL (1) -
y
: *yoo104} 9 0} Z SuUUINOD UI Jgue 19doid ey} 30
aon Zupyeu oy) 4q poyafduoy useq svy ‘t e3ed ‘SAXVL 40 NOLLVLAdNOO J9}J8 peredosd oq 03 8} S[npeyrs ST4L
7 ' .*(g eBed Jo Joos ye owloo
) -U] #8012 JO UOT}UYEP 25 *Bulzowr}UOD Jo sseulsNq OY} Ut pesesuq sucsieg [[y Jo euooUy sso) “A AINGAHOS-
- (aBed jo yoo; uortuyep geg) ‘T eBud ‘g uuinjoo ‘zed sv ‘spi0cei 8, reAvdxuy, Aq UmoYys SB UOT] ssoir [#70], (9)
' ssoutsng ey8zsI0jul Wosy ewOoU S801 (F)
: ~---" gzguojsnd Aq pezyonpep pus SI}OAUT JO OBZ UO UMOYS J] SJUNCISIP YS¥H (g)
“neeesATENUUB OOO'OTS JO OF8I 3B UOTdwexe oyjoeds (Z)
., ot :[ eBed ‘g uumnjoo ted sv ‘pounsyo suotjdulexe ppy
$ . T o8ed ‘> uuinjoo 1ed se euloouy S801 e/qUxE Tl? (1)
‘ ath . ' -joorarf} 9 0} Z SuUINJOD Uy sayzjUe Jedozd oy} jo
LNNOKV Zuyyeur oy) fq pozatduoy useq suy ‘; o8ed ‘SAXVL dO NOLLVLAAWOD 29738 pazedead oq 07 81 2[NPIHPs STEL
; *(setztTI9a o1qnd zey}0 pus ‘seyuedui0s zemod pus 3ySI] 911300/0 ‘geoidxe ‘ydviee} ‘euoyde/ey ‘gouty odid sv3 pus
Ltd “speoryyer qo0138 ‘speolyjel wives ‘syuBq JO ts aSed Jo 700s 9B WOTUyeP 2eg] euoouy s801H) “d K ig fe tekcs: 4) >)
OL : ; woud dOlmad AHL YAAOO NUNLAA SIL AO sa7NGaHOS TIV
: .
: ° ‘ ~ T Vv . .
| Ete eee 6r streceeeeres eneeMecerererecesscseceee: eccccccocce jo sep ceccceccccecocococes ay uo soaidxe uOIss1WW0D tw }
"(eq Avw ose oy) SB ‘SaIne¥er, 10 A1t}01908 ‘uapisead-aota ; Sats ’ -
‘quepisesd :uorjes0ds09 © Jo J]BYeq UO epwU gt ‘81713. [PIOWO) ; u Si .
ecccces cc ctoccoccocecoses+cecee Gcecsecccccccocccccssceeeerescodoes scececocenecccecoeecoseooecceoooeres . “a19qNg A18,0N . , by wAVpyYY Suyey a
; SE ie se)? of ae ee eine oe ate eee 1209yO JO [89g
”~ ss, % (safhedxey jo oureny) " ; 2 . ‘
ee he 61 amerenen re nee ae Aep eeccccecooccoesocece sty} aw ai0jeq poqriseqns pue, 03 wiomg
_ “S@BSO'l XO SASNGdXad UAHLO AO AUOAVT AO SGOOD dO LSOO dO LNNODO
= SNOLLONGAG ON ZNOONI SSOYD ONILYOdSY NI 3#43 pus ‘posed. SUM GIN} OY) YOY wor; spiooad pu szoded "54004
peursiio YUM PUB UIN}e1 OG) UI Peyoda SsauIsNg ey} YIM ser UTE, ATYBnoI0Y St UINje1 a4} Zuluzis uosied 943 9eyI pus fuInjel Zul
. “yeu saAvdxe} oy} JO Spicce2 pus siaded ‘syx00q je O 94} WO UPHBR e29m peyiodes uoss-"} saan3y ey} yey) faefnoa¥d Azeae pus
Wi JO ySeq ay} OF ‘eB “UINZer S14, BuAuBduiCdv 10 07 PeYyozIe S7St] 10 4st] [BUOIZIPpE
) ag
US Ul puY qUeWe;TIs ArejUaWe;ddns ey) UI PUY UINZe1 SuIOFZeI0; oy} UI perequUe ‘(sjuNdWIY PUY suUOIZEUS sep 07 fe YyI0q) swe pu -
pecgpeegscessssesesssess ecccecececescns er ceceeeeecseeeeeceeeensseesseeeeeneses seeeeees eee eeeeseseseneeeseseses eens qeees sees eeeeeeeeneees coeseceeesoseees. oe
S}09uIa7;8}s Oy) 384) Avems Ajuuajos Op ~~~ sees
as “ . ;
HLVO
. ‘NUNLaY SIHL 40 LUVd
VY SWOOSE ASHL ‘GSHOVLLVY OS NAHM ‘GSEHOVLLVY 2a GINOHS NOLLVWHOANI AUVSSHOAN AHL DNINIVINOO
SLAZHS ALVUVdES ‘SNOILVLON YO SWALI UAdOUd TIV YALNA OL LNAIOIANSNI SI NUNLAY SINL NO AOVdS AHL Al
v
@ ‘ e* ; . C
a oe bi Soe ae : ‘anp Sexe} FO JUNOUIS poszeUII}se
« 84} JOJ souBziMIel Aq patusduiosse poa\nbas aq [[[M uInjer pazewtyse Ajiozrenb.yyInoy & suinjoy [enuuy jo Bully eyy 103 pemorye
@18 SUOISU9}X9 UlaIOyYM Sased [[B,Uf “yoB oy Aq Ppoqiiasaid polisd 94} UIYZIA SpeUl 9q JOUUBS UANzot ples oy} AyM suosval syyeA[[Ny
9784s 4SnUI ——. yons AUY ‘dUlI} JO UOISUS}X9 UB IOJ IBUOISS(UAIOD XB} 9Y} OF BPBUI oq P[NOYS poried Aep A414} pres UTYyzIM
ear - uorzeotdde yduoid ,‘avak x¥yz,, ay} JO asof[d ay} Woy .SsABp .AZIIYZ UTYQIM ‘ST 9BY} ‘ABT Aq peqiiosaid aut, ay} UIYJIM UInjel [enuUs
baa Sly ey pus azajdwoo youyed uosvei Aue 10J JaAVdxe} 94} YIyA Ul SesBo [[B Uy] ‘poised ajqeuosval & IO} UINjel, [enuUe ayy ZuL[y
: JOY OWI} BY} puszx9 saXedxe} dy} Jo uUorzeodde UO ABU JBUOISSIWUWOD XB} ay} aseo Jenoyied Auw YI UMOYS asnBd poo¥ 10g ,, 180A
on OR JO pue 04} woz skep AZILY} UIYPIA pa[y pus epeuUl oq YSN UINjzer [enuue syL “CATIA Ad OL SI NUNLad IWANNV NGHM
*sUuldz] Butpaseid 84} Ul PepNyoul you sseuIsnq 19430 Aue Ut 8383S SIU} ULYIIM Zutmmutquoo 10 Sut3e3ue jo aZartatad euL ‘) WALI
‘atjqnd 9y} peleyo o18 SJUsUesNWe YY 3e soe[d 19430 AuB IO ‘yOBIy BOB ‘HULL BuQeYs ‘[[ey sou"p ‘yaed JUsWosnue ‘e[[IAspNea ‘mous
ainjaid: Sutaow ‘asnoy viedo ‘a1ze0y} ¥ Zuryeiado Jo ssoutsng ay} Ul 27BzF SITY} UTYZM SZutnulzUod JO SurseZue jo aZaptauid ey, “qq WALI
: -Zuryoe11U09 jo SSaUISNd dy} Ul 9383S SITY UTYZIM ZutnuryUOD 10 suiseZua fo aZaaud sayy “A WALI
; ‘satusdui0s ao{aras orqnd Jayjo pus satuedwos Jamod pue 4Yy3I] d13z0a]2 ‘ssaidxa ‘ydei3a[>3 ‘quoydaa3 ‘seurt edid seZ pus [io
‘PBOITIVI 399148 ‘pBOITIVI Was Zuryjeisdo ‘Zuryueg Jo ssautsng ay} Ul 33ezS STUZ UY Buinurjuoo IO Zu1ZeZue jo sZaiatid sayy ‘d WALI
° ‘Aysodoid a[qiZue} Aue “Buryyjeas jo ‘ssouisnq jeu UI 9384s Sly} UIYZA Zummurjzuo. 10 ZurseZue jo aZattaud sy, ‘DO WALI
ie " ‘asn JO yyoud ‘ayes OZ SatytpowUI0g IO SadUBysqns ‘sezIzAe AUB sTES
_ LOZ ‘Busedeid 10 Zulpunoduios ‘Zutinjoeynueul JO ssauisnd ey} Ul 93BIS STY} UTUITA Zutnutquos 10 Zulsesue jo aZotauid aul, “‘G WALI
* , _‘asn Jo ‘yyoid ‘ayes 1oy aqui} Buronpoad pue Zurjey 10 ‘syonpord [ereurul 13430 1O puwS “SUO}SEUIT ‘$B [einjeu ‘10 ‘180.
. fue ‘asn to “yord ‘ates 107 Butonpoid pus Zurutw Jo ssoursnq dy} UL agByS SITY UTYIZAL ZutnulzUOD IO Sursesue so asapialid oy, “VY WALI
we : "MBI XBI, BSUgoYT SeTBG Ss@Iy. ey] Japun xB} AUB IOF [QUIT ‘(, MB] XBy, asueor'y saleg.
. _SBOIN) dU} Jopupy, SUInfey jenuuy sey Tres OuUM,, ‘ePAOgs Sulpeey veg) ‘uossed Aue suBeuT ‘mofeq pasn se ,,‘1aAedxe},, pom sug
“JQUOISSTUIUIOD KB], 2381g a4} Aq AIessed0U pauldep JI ‘UOIZBOYIIEA 0} yoofqns ‘1aAVdx¥} By} JO Sp1ODII BY} WOIJ peatiep eq ysnUl poyioder
qunows dyy, ‘eq Avul asvo 94} SB ‘aulooUT sso13 10 spoaooid sajes ssoid ‘any[ea Sso1Z JO JUNOW [BNJOe 94} MOYS ysNUt uiInjel [enuus sy,
; : a NYnLaAa IVANNV dO NOILVUVd aad IO YwANNVW SNINUAONOD F
; r ‘uinje1 94} Aq pateaocd yQWOUL YoBe OF EE"Eggss St UoWWduIsxe 9y} ‘spiOM JeYyy~ Al—
zeak |[NJ B 0} siveq ssouIsnq UI peZeSue si oy YoIyM Sulinp euty Jo ported ay} SB OO'OOO'OTS 93 WoIQBer SUIS oY} SIvEeq YoY 00°000‘0T$
. yo wins 04} jo y4ed yey) Jo uorydulexe UB 07 po[}iqUe St JaABdxE} 94} ‘gah @ UBY} SSa_ JO polzed B SIaA0d UINJe1 9Y} J] ‘sseutsnq 8,104
[[nJ B yuory paatsap ‘aq AvuL as¥o ay} SB ‘awWOIUI Sso1Z 10 spad001d sa [Bs SSOIB ‘an[VA SSOIZ ay} WOIF B[QUMOT[S SI UgIZdUIexe eAogs ey, .
. = ; 5 ! ? 3 - A . « UIney
[enuuy jo uoijwiedeig Jo JauuBy_ BuIUIZDU0D,, SuIpBey 94} Jopun ‘moleq UMOYS BIB ‘IapI0 UT ‘xBI FO Syoafqns 9Y} ‘JOB 9Y} BulMoyog xB}
ay} JO eqns oy} uodn spuedep uorduiexe siyz Jo uoIqwodde ey, “epeuUl SI xB} 94} JO uorjzeynduids a10faq ‘auloou! sso1Z 10 en[BA sso1Z
. « .
-
. , ‘sajws JO spesdoid ssoiZ Siy Ulo1y pajyonpep eq 0} SI pus JokVdxe, YoRa paoye st Ajpenuue OO OOO‘OT$ FO 2381 OY} 48 UOIZduUIExe dytoeds 8.
‘(ul10y S14} JO G PUB zg o3ed uo sapnpeyog dag) ‘s1aAVdxe} JO SASSBlD UTBPIID OJ YOR 9Y} Ul pepiaoid suorjzduiexe 1904}0 0} UOI}Ipps Uy
an ee - . . 00°000°0T$ AO NOLLAWAXT OLMIOAdS AHL ONINYAINOO” ; , |
anes ‘BIUIBITA 3S9AA JO SPIS]NO peyonpuod SI ssouIsnq 94} Jo [[@ 10 Aue jou IO
JeyyeYA ‘suorye10d109 JO ased 9y} UI ‘10 “OU IO YN'NDO‘OT$ JOAO 0} JUNOUB SULOOUI ss0iZ3 10 spseo0id —, ssoiZ ‘an[@a sso1Z Jey} 1eyzeyA
JO. SSa]prBBel ‘suinjel syBUt 07 re pues ae Y ey} Jepun peitnber are sseutsng ul pasesue pun B SB ZUl}os UOTZsUIqUIOD IO noizZ
Jeyjo Aue 1O 83Sn1} ‘seinjueape yuiof ‘sdiysieuzzed-oo ‘suzy ‘STENPTAIPUL “SUOIZBIOOSSE ‘Qtseuop pues UsIe10y ‘suolzE10d10j—:330N
: . . ‘ _ “BIULBILA 3894 JO 2787g ey} UI SsauIsng
ul peseZue ‘y1un & sB ZuI~B cnidealbie 10 dnoiZ 19430 Auv 10 sysni}z ‘sernquaaps jaro ‘sdrysioujred-oo ‘suzy ‘stenpiarpur [Ty (8)
( pt ; ‘BIUTZIIA 3S9M JO 2787 94} UT SSoUISNG’ Op 0} pojIWps suotzei0odi0d uZte10y [fy (2)
” ~*. “"BIUIZILA 4S9Mj JO 93BIG 24} JO SMB 9Y} JEpUN Zurjstxe pues peziuesi0 SUOTIBIDOSSB pue suonesodi09 [Ty (T) |
MV'I XVL ASNAOIT SA'TVS SSOuD AHL YAAGNN SNUALAY IVOANNV AVA TIVHS OHM
- SNUMEAA TVANNV OL SV SNOLLONULSNI , 7
e
4
GEGNG Shr serene recent me nnn nn nen ernns erga cantt iar eaten BI nee eon eae eEGC_ CS $ s04I0ND 481
AO BONN SV SNUNLIY cauyuiass NO 30VW 340401343H SLNaWAYd
a” « —
SISTERS ESSA =EE== NOLLAWEXE $S37 3NG SIXVL
ei --------------------- sseulsng ul pe6oBue Ajjony20 poled ayy 40, YUOW 40d BOTS JO 9410 MY) 10 40. AyonuuoSzg JO @j0s 40 UO|jGwexe ssey |
(Re ASS PALATE saxvi 4O LNNOWYV IwLiOl fF .
|
;
2
3
g
$
N
if
YR 8 &, 8 8
= « €¥a a
a
“ee nal . Tss ks ke 38029 2/0 pemoy gh eye
_——_—],---- uo snpep ON PUD SIB}IOJwY JO SUIODU! SHO “D
™N
© een
a ; : gqracoconwecene eonncanencacesn= 6 Ayjonuuo Qoo’s$
‘é jo “OW INpPep epnjru; suoljdwexe) spS jOJNION
$ = : eouiBs1A 359A Ul SS@UISNG OP 0} Pess/WIpPO
way “u01j0s0ds02 UBies05 © 4) (EL) * #100 (249 : yO SMD) @yy JePUN PayOsoduOsUy (| |) |
rai , ~~ {SEUSHL GEVIAOD GOIWEd 40 GNI WOULSAVG OF NIHLIA |
GBAIZDEY 36 ASNW NG SEXVL WEACD OL NOBHD HLM NUNLEU SIMD
——uoy 09 ‘jos Sseussng 41 (01) wu + 7
A °
‘sseursng we 2 Fg anoA | Gngusouss0g | eg “Wing? 32 td
sousoy 0p woHos0dso5 * ‘fuednon BuyoEs}UO) eawag
| _¢ oo gneg € ter (L) , a : ) ;
wpeud
“PUTTER GS peorpuca sseursng yoesmon (9)
Meow ‘DAM Ul DOM JOIYD 20 SBOUIENG JO BIO}g JOdIIUIIg (CS) -
000
pesive8D
?PeD
Sez PGEAAETT Tg (971110 8804) 10 14031 810 yuncozy yo syoog (b)
"gPug 408A SOCK WOU "POS/, $1 409A 107514 41 (E) |
(30VdS SIHL 3SN LON OG) ——"ty 00g. pz tog 4 (Zz) 2 SSet Persea si) -
XD] S0jOg SsOI)—UANJOYy jONUUY—OIUIBIIA 480A 40 9303S |
’ itt 4
VA A xoe
eh
| 960d “7 uwinjoa Aq uMoYs $0 aanate J (p 260d UO UOljiuljep aes) ausODU] SSOI5 jOIOL (E)
sis sihedanceiieetetaaidhdovadibonadscai bmn nn nn nnn nnn nnn=: “SNOILdW3X3 3ZIWA3LI
* - ------- | 260d ‘¢ uNjo2 Aq UMOYS SO ‘pauuID]> SUoI;dWexZ (Z)
‘dav
TITRA R RRR REESE KKK — == ——— 1. BBOd ‘fy UNIO. AG UMOYS SO” ‘aui02u| S$$OID) BFGOxO} (|)
wD | BOHOg _
Oai94} g 0} Z SUWN\OD
i emi sedesd ey 90 Guyyou “u Aq peyeyduos useq sou "| 960d ‘S3xvL 4O NOILVLNdWOD 40350 pesodaud 9q of $1 ainpeyrs stu
v (‘soqppdwuoy eBouemeg pun .
‘soquodmey ‘sng ceoyuodwe) ts] ‘peanjroynucyy ‘soquodwe> e6pizg [10] ‘seruodwes seq josunjopy ‘seruod :
LANNOWV “wo Js0Mog puc 3ySr] 24132043 ‘soquoduoy 10304 ‘shomyoy 214320]g PUO UOGuNIsZU] “300135 Dia pesn 54 6)) ‘G ae
&
he!
co
€ eT re ee ey et se eee Ss9w0}sN> i S@D0AU! $,JaA0dx0} u! papnjour ‘kup j! ‘seBs0y> viens (€).
° *SNOLLGW3X3 JZIWSLI
SEN ee
ateeaes aia tiaianebabaioniatctstindaetaaiataantaineeimaamenimaaneaaiane pale sea | 260d ’¢ meangee Aq unous SO ‘pawid)> Suoidwaxy (7)
: ‘ -d0v .
TD egeaaes nes Se rE ae eee eee ae ee I a6od ‘py uwinjo> Aq — SO ‘@UIODU| SSOID BIGOXOL (|)
wD 820)}00 | "yoasayy BO} Z ~ SUNOS
Ul SajUue Jedoid ayy 4O Bulyow 243 Aq pajyajdwio> useq soy ‘| | ood ‘S€AXVL JO NOILVLNdWOD 49430 pasodaid aq 04 $1 ainpayrs sit
: oy & ("Ayiodosg 9jq16u0y Suyyos 40 ssovysnq oy) ened suossad jo Aq pesn.aq OL) “D> 3NdGIHIS
AINNOWV . : | SA i °
il ” me Re | RK SR EES CS | 260d ‘7. uwinjoo sad sp “euageaan Aq umoys so ‘SP99201q S3]OS SSOsJD JOJO] (SC)
ee ter ieee '
“a a xxx xX X x SJBWOSND 0} Sa>10AU! $,4aA0dx0} Ul Papnjau Aun 31 ‘sa6soy> 4yy6iasy (by
~ “ : fi ag ie l " a60d ‘Z uwinjod 4ad so ‘spaasoid sajps ssos6 puo ‘anid a6010A0 "yNdyno jOJ0O] (€)
7 - ee ee eee ee
See hy Te ge al re *SNOILdW3X3 aZIWall
. xxxxx | x x x XX KX KX | TOTTN Mee Ae ey pe nT ee ee {| 260d ’¢ uwnjo> Aq uMoOYUsS SO ‘pawiDid suol}dwaxg (Z)
: : | ‘dav
@G [PE AC | Oe ee | 260d ‘p uwinjod 4G uMoys Sd ‘anfOA |;qQOxD] (|)
a & 4 ' * ; -
‘SD .—s * | un) s3ur) . -sooseus g ©} Z SUWUN|OD U! sal4jUuB yadosd ayy yo BuIyOW ayy
' 49g 82!4g © UuOIJINPOId Aq paspjduio> -ueeq soy ‘| e600 ‘s3xVL 4O NOILVINdWOD 42340 \Rasbdaid aq 0} $1 ajnpayrs siyL
aBousay ul 3ndyno jojo,” :
LINAOWV slay ("28f) 40 ‘p1y04q ‘2]0g 405 |
—_ - my Buyodog Suosidg Pus SIZpUNOdWO ‘ssdiNj20ynNUOW Aq pssn 241) ‘@ 31NG3HOS
2 (€) (Z) (1) c
sss cae Homan" ysquilL $0 PUI (OL)
ae | “sasuadxa
124yj0 40 ‘plod saiyjDAos ‘aud Burjjas jo yno aut plod suolssiuiui0> 404 uolanpap dNOYIIM “G'O'} sa21ud uo pasdq aq 0} a2I1d 26019AY—310N]
re ere ere er ee paonpoud j10 40 apps (6) ~~~ ~~~ ~~~ ~~~ pau [00D yo woas a4DI¢ (g)
CPS CLE ("232 ‘uo, ysoys 4o Buoj) pasn syiuf) (2) ae catenin NO Businp pauiojdo sadiid ysamoj pud ysay6iy tail I (9)
. [L(b) Pud [€) 40. sais | @N|OA JaxHIOW PUD spaadoid sajD$s ‘ad1Id Spo%ea0 "yndyno JOI0L @)
: "i aus ae 24a ‘Guunasiynuows UL pasn an|DA snout puo ‘anid aBo1aad '3NndyNO (p 'g
See S eee r eee Tene a eee) spaac0id sa}0s ssoi6 puo ‘a2isd a6019A0 ' 4ndano (€)
es cs eserenanetieraieeennareenentesien esti ies i nnn ne ewe wenn eneenn nine 7
free Parr ae are lor Oars D ny eee eS: “* SNOILdW3Xx3 3ZIW3LI
; 8 4§ BORSS TARAS SS eee | 860d ‘¢€ uwnjo> Aq umous SO pawior suoidwax3 (7)
:aagv
$ c% ex ea eee eee eee ae Ja Vaan as ee eee tee ae are ee | 260d ‘p uwinjo> Aq uMoys so ‘anjoa 2190x011)
‘8 | suo11I00 wun sjiup) >
! i! odoid 6
49d 9214 UOHINPOd Aq payajdwo2 useq soy ‘| e60d 'saxya 40° NOlLVinawo> “soyjo pavoderd °q oO fe eee od
‘ wGorray .- Ul NDING jOJOL
LANNOWV (‘oquizy, JO sso2nposg Puc ‘Bois e20usny 4380;g i
‘s}os9U;Wy 40430 isi ‘8D ‘110 ‘10D 40 a ee ™ pesn eqoy) “Y 371NGaHOS
qf
a)
bP
Ree ToT Oy ar ee Beet ee AY ee ee See ee ‘SNOLLdWaX3 3ZIW3LI
| 260d ‘¢ uwinjo> Aq uMoYs sO ‘pauuio}> suaijdwax 3 (7)
“Gav
| 260d ‘p uwnjo> 47 UMoUS SD. ‘yuMOWD ajqoxKN) (1)
. 3)
$10}|09
LNNOWY
‘pooseys B 04 Z sUWINIOD
ul Saujue sedoud ey} yo Gulyow a4} Aq pajyajawo> useq soy ‘| a60d ‘S3xwL 4O NOILWLNdWOD 40340 pasodaid aq oO: s! aNPaYyrs sI4L
("S9jnpoyrs Buporod
l
| 260d ‘¢ UWNjo> Aq UMOYS SO ‘pawId)/> SUdIydwax] (7)
:-dqv
Se eee ee | 260d ‘p uwnio> Aq uMOYs SO ‘yuNMOWO @jqoxoy (1)
. \ *pO@s9U} B OF Z SUWIN|OD
Peed ee ohn a at { ®60d.'7 uwinjo> Aq umoys SO “ssaulsng 4O (fp a6od uo UOIJIUlZSP BS) BWODU] SSOID jOJO] (E€) -
‘8D
*
6 ("24qQNd bys 0} P219jj0 B10 SyUQWESN WO Yr4YA 30 820;4 104;0 AUD 40 ‘uO1j03¢ Bu
~§802pO01g OIPRY ‘42041 D204 ‘HUIY SuLsOyS ‘1}044 22U0g ‘yO g JUSWIOSNUNY ‘a)!AOPMOA ‘MOUS O4Nj>14 Cu |
LNNOWV “AoW ‘9snopy 019dQ ‘21,0044 © Buyos0do yo ssoursng oys u! 6 uinusyuo2 40 Bu;SoBue suocssed Aq pesn 9g 04) “5 21NG3HIS
ee ee ee ee | 860d *Z uwnjo> Aq' umoys SO ‘ssaulsng 40 (b 260d UO UO!JIUIZSP BAS) .BWIOdU] SSOID [OJO] (E)
ak laa all a Kn :SNOILdWax3 3ZIW3LIY
a eee re re ee ee ee ee | e600 ‘¢ — Aq UMOYS SO ‘pawidj>*Sucl;}dwex (Z)
: | \ av
ee are er fe ee ne eee oer Kea irate cate | 260d ‘¢ uwinjo> Aq UMOYS SO ‘yUNMOWD ajGOxD] (|)
‘4D SID}|OQ be ‘yoasayus B OF z suwinjo>
ul Saiajua sadosd ay} 40 Suryow ayy Aq payajdwo> useq soy ‘| a0d “S3xv1 JO NOILWLNdWOD 42440 pasodaid 9q 04 S) aiNpayrs S141
LNNOWY vs (‘Guryuog yo —s ey) ul Buinuyuos 40 6u/606ue suossed Aq pasn 9g 04) “4 31NGIHIS
Fae ee on eae | 260d ’Z uwinjo> Ag uMoYs SO ‘ssauIsNe yo (p'a60d uo UOIUIap aas) @wo ru} SSOJS 1030 1 (€)
Se eeee Seer eee ee ee er ere es Ve ee =meF =" = SNOLLAW3Xa SZIW3LI
%
Se ee eee te et OAS he tree Re ae a6od ‘¢€ uwnjo> Aq uMoyUs SO ‘pawidj> Suqiydwax 3 (7)
= ~J ‘dav
NC er ee ee at hE eee Raed ae eo ea | 260d ‘p uwinjo> Aq uMOYUS SO ‘yuUMOWD a/GOxD] (|)
‘3D $1010 . ‘ ‘ my 8 ©} Z SUuWN}OD
ul satjue sadosd ayy 40 Buryow ayy Aq pdjajdwo> udaeq soy ‘| @60d “s3axvi 4O NOILVINdWOD 42450 pasodaid aq @ Ss! ajMpeyrs SI4L
(*6u1yj2044u0> yo ssoursng 94) UI Buinuiguo> 10 6u:6o6ue suosiod Aq pesn, eq 01) “3 FINGIHIS
-
-
nal Pola 94s 49A0D UsNJoY S14) 4O SINPOYIAS ITY
me
; CO re ee —~@ys UO Sasidxa UOCIssHUWOS Ay;
('®Q ADW 9602 943 SO ‘JaINSD|sy 40 AJD}98I285 ‘JUSPISOIg-O21A 3 | ‘Sane As ; / : 1ADD1 6Buino "
‘JUBPISE1q :U01}040ds09 D 40 4/049q YO BpOW 41 “OINIL 10121940) . isc eR cae {ce bo ances ee
owen i a ip ah = Spl et Maa Doak At ee eee ee ee - | 4821440 40 |S Jf
. (4@ADdxOY yO BWON) . :
Se ee ee ceed wate rer ye a 6L TTT tt go AOp “> > $1yy Bus 84049q Paqi4DSqns PUD OF WJOMS .
»— '§3SN3dX3 YSHLO YO YOSW1 YO SGOOD JO 1SOD 4O. LNNODDV NO. 30VW 343M SNOILINGIA ON 3WODNI SSOUD ONILYOd3y
“ ‘ N] 3943 puo ‘pasodaid som usnjas ay} Yr214YM Wosy Spsora4 PUD Ssadod ‘SyOOd jOUIBI40 ays GyIm PUD UNjas B44 U! PdjJOdas SSAUISNG yy YIM 4D1;!WI04
: _ AyyBnosoys si winjas ays BuruBis uossed ayy 404} pud ‘UsNyas Bul yow JaA0dx0} BY} 4O Sps0da4 PUD Suadod ‘syoog jOUIGi4O ayy WiO1y UBD} 319M paysod
: : -91 uoasaU) SaunB1y ay} 304} 140j;ND1}40d AsaAB PUD YIDa U! 4391402 PUD and} 'yaih3q puo aBpajmouy Aw 40 489q a4} 0}. asD wuNyas SI4y BurAUDdWI0D20 40 0}
P®YIOD}4YO S}Sij 4O 4S!) JOUOIZIPPO AUD UI PUD jUaUWZD}s AJDJUaWajddNs a4} UI PUD UWINj\aI BuroBasdy Jy} Ul Pasdjyua (SyUNMOWD pUud suoij0uBisap 0} SO 440qQ)
SW9}! PUD S}UGWI9}O}S 94} JOU} JOBMS AjUWAjOS Op § ~~~ ST ae ACES OO ee A ee ae et eee
. Mees ERTS, one ae H1LVO
4 ~ . 2
. “NUNLIY SIHL JO LUVd V 3WOD3E AHL ‘GIHDVLLY OS NIHM !Q3HDVLLV 38 GINOHS NOILVWYOSNI AUYVSSIDIN
JHL ONINIVLNOD SLIIHS 3LVUYVdIS ‘SNOILVLON YO SW3LI YIdOUd TIV YILNI OL LNIIDIZSNSNI SI.NYNLIY SIHL NO dovdS 3HL J!
"J9ABOS}OUM |SUadxa 4ay}ZO AUD JO PIDd 4yUNODSIP 40 4sa4a}U! '$2130403 ‘SOxXD} ‘S}SOD 4OQD| “'pasn s}O14aJOW 4O 4SO> aus ‘pjos Ajsadoud yo 4S02 ays 40
yuno220 uO suoI}2Npap AUD nous! PUD pajOUBIsap saAamoYy SyUBUIN|OWWD 494IO 410°S9}¥ ‘SayyjOAOs ‘Ssj/D}Uds ‘JUNOISIP ‘ysauajur GOuipnjoui ‘ui pabobua
ssauisng ay} 4O jO}JIdOD aU} 4O JUSwySaAU! ay} yO UOSD|s Aq Sydiar—a1 |jO PUD “YjyOG 4O ‘AD!AJaS 4O ‘(jOuosiad 40. j0a1) Aysadoud ajqibuD} yo ajoOs ayy woud g
Buins220 40 Buipaaroud anjOA ay} PUD SajOS 40 a2:aWIWIOD ‘ssaUISNG ‘aPD4} Ws} PaAIJap 49ADGxXD} ay} 40 S}dI9D94 ssoi6 ay} suDaW ,,aWOdU! SSOID,,
»AWOONI SSOUD,, WH3L FHL JO NOILINISIO “¥ ‘
. | . 3 -
(‘Mojaq ,,awoou! ssos6,, Oo UOIJIUIyaP Bag) ‘ssaUIsNG ayy yO ,,aworuU! ssol6,, 34} HH WIL 4epun- yoda.
JOUS paxo} AjjO>D1j19ads SS1MIBYIO JOU BusjjO> 40. ssauisng adiAsas AuD ui o1uiBs1A ysaQq UIYy!IM Burnulyu0> 40 6ui6o6ua uosuad AiaAQ HH WIL!
5 : : fe (‘Mojaq ,,awo2u! ssos6,, 4O UOI}IUIYaP BBS) “SsaUISNG ay} 4O ,,aUIODU! yw 2 aus W3LI Japun 4jodas yous ‘21qQnd auy O}
P219jjO 91D SJUBWASNWD YIIYM 4D a2Dj)d 494yZO AUD 40 ‘UO!}03s BUIySODPOOIG OIPDI ‘420443 BD04 ‘HUIJ Burfoys ‘j0y a2uOp ‘ysOd yUaWasSNWD ‘a|)!AaPNDA
‘mous a4njoid-Buiaow ‘asnoy osado ‘4a}0a4} 0 Buijosado 40 ssau'sng pus ur O1UIBsIA ySaAQQ UIYyIM Bulnulyu0> 40 6u:606ua uossad AsaAQR xy) WILI-
; : | ("Mojaq ,,awodru! SsoJB,; yo UOIyIUIYaP Bag) “ssauIsNq ayy 40
ee ,eworu! ssoi6,, a44 4 WIL! 49PUN yoda. |jOYs BuryuDg 40 ssauisng ayy ui DIUIBIA 499\\ Uys! Burnul}u0> 40 Bui6oBua uosiad AsaAQZ 4 WIL
, i tae (‘Mojaq .,,aworu! ssos6,, yO UOIIUIYaP BAS) ‘“sSaUISNG B44 4O ©
,,Pworu! ssos6,, ayy 3 WIL 49pun ysodas jjOYys Gui132023U0> yo sSauIsNg ayy UI DIBA 4SaAA UIYIIM Buinuiju02 40 Bui6o6ua uossad AsanQ 3 WIL
: ene ae (‘Mojaq ,,eworuU! Ssos6,, yO UOIJIUIYaP Bag) ‘“SSaISNg ay} 4O ,,awOo>dUI
ssou6,, 843 (pb OF |) G WLI J9pUN ysodas jjOUs “Y-Z1 2}>2H4y 4aPUN pexos SeUOdUIO? WOIjOys0dsUDsy 494j0 PUD ‘shomjios ‘saruDdwo2 au0ydajay puo
ydosBaj03 adeoxe ‘sai31)13N 21)GNd 4ayjo |jO puod ‘sa1UddWO> aBpiiq |{j0} ‘s1O}NGIASIP SOB jOuNyoOU ‘sa1uDdwio> 4aj0M ‘saiuDdWwo> samod pud 4Y461 314339/2
‘SADMIID4 3143398 PUD ‘UOQGUN4asU! ‘398435 = ZIA ‘SassauISNg A4yt]1yN Buimoyjoy ayy ur QruiBsa asaa~a ul Guinuijyuo> so Bui606ua uossad AuaAQ GQ WIL!
(‘Aojaq ,,awioru! ssosB,, yO UOIjiUIyaP Bas) “‘SsaUISNG ay} 40 ,,aWODU! ssou6, aus (Z 40/pud |) D WIL! apun ysodas |jDYs
‘JOuossad 40 |0as ‘4aAvosyOYM Ajysadosd 2)q!6u0} Aud Burjjas yo ssauisng au} u! O1UIBsIA ySaAQ UIYIIM Buinuifuo>d so GuiBoGua uassad AsaaQZD WIL. ae
ieee ‘GSN |DIDsaWWOD JO ‘y1yO1d ‘a1DS' 40} Paiddaid JO PapuNodwO? ‘painy
-2DyNUdW 34a ‘Saj31ZI0 YINS 4/0 yO ‘(aPOUW's! BjOS OU B1BYM ONIDA SajO JO spuo) sajos "yO Spaar0id ssosB aus g WIL] 4aPUN ysodas jjOYs, ‘sa1yipoUWOS
JO AjyIpOWUOd. ‘S22UDJSGNS 4O a>UD}sqns ‘saj21340 4O 3j91440 AUD “440d UI JO BjOYM U! ‘S4BYIO 4O AJIAIVDO BY4 YyBnosys 40 AjydasIP J9UY}Ia ‘BSN jO1DsBUIWOD-4O
313040 ‘aj0s 40y Bulsodasd 40 ‘Guipunoduio> ‘Burunys0jnuow 40 sauisnq ayy ur o1uIBsIA ysaAQ UIYyyIM Buinuljyuo> 40 BuiBobua uosiad AsaAZ gg WALI
; ‘ ; ‘@SN jOIDIaUIWOD JO ‘414010 ‘a]DS 40} PadNpod 4o Pauiw syonposd
a2inosas jOunyOU |jO yo ‘(apOw S$! a]OS OU Baym aNjDA’ SajDs JO/PUD) SajOS\jo spaaroid ssosB ays (¢ OF |) Y WSL! 2apUN jsoda. {jOYs s}onposd a24snosas
jOunyou Aud asn jO12;aWIWO? JO y1jo1d ‘ajOs 40} Buldnpoid yo ssauisng ayy ul OIUIBsIA 4SaAQ UIYIIM Buinulju0> 40 Gui6bobua uosuad AsaAQ WW W3LI
SJILIAILOV anaes | 40 NOILVDISISSVID ‘€
‘ -
ee, mes ‘ ‘uoiysodosd ul padnpas $1 uolydwigxa ay} ‘108A xD} 'D yO ysOd O 40} pasi>d
-saxa $1 aGBajiAisd ayy 4; “seB6aj!Alsd as0W 40 BuO asidsaxa ay 4aY4yaYM UOSIGd BIO AUD 0} PaMo)|D Bulag Uo!;dWaxa aUO AjUO ‘aAISMHYDU! ‘}4 0} YW Sway) JapUN
Payndwo> xo2 yo yuNOWO UF SUDIJOP aAly-AjUaM] (1) ‘“Spae20sd sajOs ssouH Aq UMOYS SD AN|DA WOo4} Pa}INpap aq OF ‘AljONUUD OO'O00'SS 4O YUOI;dwaxa
ud ‘sua2npaid SOB jOsnjzOU yo aso> ayy Uj (9) ‘S@l4jUNOD UBIas0f pud ByOJs S14} UBAMJaq 40 ‘SS1D}S P2JIUL) Ys 4O SBJOJS 4BYJO PUD 3JDjs S14, UBIMIaq
@2s@WWOD WO1y PaAluap aworu! ssos6 ‘SaIyNIyM D11GNd yo aSOD 3Yy Uj (C) | “S4PUINSUOD O} S2jOS |/O WO1y BUUODU! ssoi6 wojy UOIJINPAP 0. SD paMmojjO (WO!)
.-2Nposd). €-\y was] 4apUN saizij1y3M SOB jounyou Aq plod xo} ay} yO JUMOWY (pf) ,, SA/OS 40 spaearoid ssoi6,, 40 ,,awodul 5 4 au} Ul papnjou: Ss! 3131440
Mau BUY JO adIUd ajDs |jNy |Uy 4! “PjOS aj21440 Mau AUD UO yUaWADM 440d SO p|3da3>0 3131410 AUD 40 add ajOS (€) “spas © YsO> Ul 4dyyI9 PapuNnjas Si
° a21sd ajOs 84} UaYM SsaWOysN>D Aq Pausnjas asipudyrsaw 40 Sas0M “SPOOG jo ajOS yO SPp|a201g (7). “SA/OS UO UBD} PUD PaAfoj|O SyUNOISIP YSOD (1)
&
gO ’ . } : P
y, G3MOTIV SNOILINGIG GNV SNOILdWIXd “7
: . ye ‘pDIuIBsiA 3SAAA 4O apis
-§NO PaJNpuOr Ss! SsaUIsNg ays 40 ||O 4O AUD yOu JO 49YZ@YM ‘SUO!}O1OGIOD 4O SDI Ay} Ul 40 ‘xD. D yO yUaWADd ay) SasINbas BUOP ssaUISNG 4O YUNOWD 3\44
JaUJ@YM JO SSajps0Bas SUINjas axOW OF ‘SUOIZO]NBay PUD sajny ays 4apuN “Pasinba. 40 DiuiBslA ySaAQ Ul Ssaursng ul paboGua yun 0 so Gwiy20 UO!DUIG
-wo> 40 dnoi6 sayjo Aud 40 s3ysnijy ‘SaunyUaApo guiol ‘sdiyssaujysod-o5 ‘suuly.‘sjONpiAipul ‘SUOI}DIDOSSD “D1'"*WOP PUD UBIas04 ‘SUO!}DJOdJOD :340N)
| : en by edaen | ‘DIUIBsrA SO 4 2103S Ys
ul ssauisng ui pa6o6ua ‘y1uN Oo sO Gu1j20 UO!}OUIqWO? 40 dnos6 4ayjo AUD 4 S3sn4y ‘SauNyuaApD juUI0! ‘sdiyssauyspd-od ‘suusty ‘sjOMpiAIpui fy (2)
ees 1 ‘DIUIBIIA 3SAM YO 2403S ayy UI SSaUISNG OP O} Pays!WPO SUOIyosOd40> UBI9205 |) > (4)
‘DIUIBJIA 3SAAA JO 23035 aU JO SMO] a4) YaPUN BUNYSIxa PUD pazIUDBio SUO!}DID0SSO PUD SUO!I}OI0GI02 |)\Y (2)
}
ve ~
\ °
SNUNLIY TVANNYV a4 OL aauiNdsy SNOSYad t
SNUNLIY TWANNV OL SV SNOILONULSNI :
%
%
‘NI G3Td IV WaAVaXVL LPS A® Q3L¥Od3u ZAOBY SWaL! YO Woo! vE-Ol
Wall 3Hi HLIA ONIGNOssSNHOD SBINGIHDS WO FINGINDS. AVVANIWITddNS 3H1L TWANN 31974WOD LON SI NBNLIY SIHL
¥ 39Vd NO GagidISa¥d HLVO AG GzidIIA aq ISNW NUNLIY SIHL
=e eer Se Srp esuDj0q 1eA0> 0} GSSOTONS SINWLLIWSY W
0s PLEL “$] SalLIvNad .
ts sogss ta aaa is fc tei caer a ee Ne $ 49310ND PE ~~~ -—— seen gg fr°rew Soooee $ 10430ND 451
Te | : x "BONN S¥ SNUNLIY GILWWI1S3 NO JOVW FYOICMTUIH SLNAWAVA “7
mas “ts $c98e Se ore try tee pr cin sata hati iain mie a 9 ey. 9-7 NOILdw3x3 $$31 3NG SaxvL “> -
onl Sz OS etal atateatataatataatataatae “sseursng ul pe6oBue Ajjony20 pose Oy} 404 YJUOW 40d BOTS 40, 9104 O44 40 40 AyjoNUUD SZ$ 40 9404 40 Uoljduexe 97
io “TT ogee * eet Sie SS ee eee ineieenheneensntannnner anne y weet ee. ae $3XVi 'JO LNNOWY TWLOL ‘f
| oot |xounsen| cot. Te) LE @woour ssos6—sseuIsng 49440 IV “H
S7%Z SL ost ‘phaptemnaiactrion esti, @woru! ssos6—sessoulsng juawesnwy ‘5
os" xO4INS ON eo wwe eee TT -~=—»sS»§s§rtr--Stti‘S™;C;COOCNC! aut ss0s6-—Oulyuog “4
Ts| oc9ea} © "| ol ge |szsteee Selscstsw | t—t~*s ee ee re
OO'E oo't 007 "3 ~(Se}UOdWo2 U01}0440d
le a 4 = puo ‘sAom0s ‘sa}uDdwo2 eu0Y4de/e;
a puo 180193, ydaoxe) SONNE 219%. U0 HIV
OS'+ os'l oOo'e ‘peieunen? tgprdveesnigne 7 bse4 se6pig 1101 .
. ‘se1uodwos $05 |OJNJON !(se@6s042 Puowep puo @
: | : So a 4
00'8, 00% oo'v a ! (Gus, Yr) |,wWoO Pu sesodund >1;seWwWop seBs04> puow 4
r r -@P..PUD S9jOS) SB/UDDWOD JeMOg PUD 446!) 314430/9 :
os‘! os’ oo"! ee or es en 31333013 puo- ‘uBquNsej,U| ‘388155 ; ¢
*z0U0 : ee” :
Mz ‘| YL st Jz--~“sesoyound 40 . [ —" ssajosejouM 4° suorul sso15
3802 2/0 Ppemojjo s84sO . i
SL’ xoynson | Sz’ | | |~~~"uosnpep on PYO SIB/I0j8y JO BWODU) _— |
sv si oF ae ed Hee sy2npoid P2sNy20jNUDW ONj|OA SBjOS S80ID “g ’
—
se GRIN the” Ten out o “jUSeUSSeS goconwcecontoceces S}2Nposd @2uNOses JOINYHU 44 Wj
}| pue BOD Bl} OA’ eq Us Tammy
; rrded Pett, tomes. Atel.” Warten cme Sieh A smi Deere Ratatat P
StZ peSnZ T Pade oes UO , BT A 7804 jo pu ‘peuiw Jo persion @uojyspuos 40 eunqeeury
WH 8 apes i.--------—-----—- (AJONUUC 000'S$
er ; pod Pas “x0 le 6 fo uowanpep apnjou; suci;dwexe) $06 jOJNjJON
OS'+ oH, . 00 haat opeiebateanonie’s Boys e20usNy 4S0jq ‘}!0 ‘peujw 40
’ cena yOu yonposd joseurw 4e4yjZO 40 e@A0s6 ‘puos
— $] osis | os $ | ool | $ $ 9 grrr eter rece esenpoennensenvecesoesssoss joo>
i !UOIJINPOId BNIDA SajOS SSOIH “'W
; ee “wsnyey
ANNOWY 19391 . | COOLS 40d | COLES 40d ANNOWY Avodwoscy snw ANNOWY wail ‘i
4 i KONE o40y 7ieVXVi ‘+ @NPaYyrs 11049 ssoyud ‘7
| tL on a J SNOLLEWEXE OE i ,
( XVL 40. NOILVLNdWOD ;
e* —_ . ioe ;, :$49Ujs0d |}0 yo S@WOU aaiG ‘diyssauysOd © 4) (81) 4
‘ auiou MAN (11) ! @wou PIO (91) ! gpaGuoy? auiou som (G1) °
: esiauans EWOYM 0} ‘pjos ssoursnq $1 (pl) ! Zd1UIBs1A 3S@AA U! SS@UISNG OP OJ Pa4j!/WUpPO 4
uayA “UOIjOs0ds02 UBI9I05 © 44 (E Ly ¢ 930g (Z1)-: Fa 40 SMD} ays sapun payosodsoouy (||) ' &§
; 5 “*A@aY3IHL GIYIJAOD “aonuad 40 GN3 woud SAva Of NIHLIM ;
; : G3A13934 = ASNW 3NG SAXV1 YIAOD OL NOIHD HLIAM NUNLIY SIHL :
Zusoym oO} ‘pjos sseulsng 4} (OL) sna, :
euaye ‘OS 4, (06) "eee ‘ try @
guanyes siys Aq wey in ;
Peserc2 poied Buiinp ;
‘sseuysng 31ND 40 ‘Ajsedoud 4noA Giyssauys0g *eg *yBingsd3td B
yO @sodsip SamsEYO 40 169 NOK PIG ‘S) ‘ . S|
014040007)
¢8s004 JULIO} 404 . <Kuedwon 2uTpoeRsZUOD OAeIG
Pay SuuNges B19 (8) .
, ssoursng (L) JONPrAipuy ‘
é ! , fed
ss 809°95 4
. , }
»weHD
2940 ~ guTqoesz udp Pas2npuo> ssauisng yO BNJON (9) | ;
Asuow "DAM Ut SIO #@1YD 40 SS@UISNG 4O B20}q |ODIDUI4g (S) id
_ saa —seg TysINgSTT a (90 #80g) 10 44a 810 yunod>y 40 $YO0g (b) ' §
Pea ¢Pug 402, $20g UaYM ‘Pasf) 5! 109A JO>S1-e$) (€) ; ;
[3DvdS SIHL 3SN LON OG] “wold (Z) BSE TL TE*Segq Pepa 208A 404 (1) j
xXDE $9j0S ite Sliews encuy—omaiA 3SOAA JO 93035
“VA r “NOLSETBVHD ‘SITL xoe "MENOISSIWWOD XV1 BiVis % popsasey OG O} UINIOL HEL “XV SETVES SSOND—I0E “—
\ Ad09 | : mm
. . e ‘
}
e ‘ P .
t .
' ; y a
-
8 . ae
. *
’ —
eee eet pen ee ee eee “""""SNOLLAW3X3 SZIWSLI
. Tapes Ss treet cose hone t e600 “€ UUinjoo Aq UMoYs $0 ‘pew0)> Suodwexg (7) ”
- :aQv, —
a et ee ee & — TTT T=" | 860d “py UWINjOD Aq UMOYS SO ‘aWO DU) S015 aGOxOY (|)
a
: Ode) @ OF 7 SUM?
_ Mt SeINe Jedold ous 40 urHOW sus Aq peyedwor Useq $04 “1 860d ‘SEXVL 40 NOILVANGWOD 40140 pasodesd oq ci t sinpeuse Ouse
$401|09 ees, (seyuodwme> e6osemes puc
° ‘setuodwo) A194 ‘seuodwo> s09 pesnjr0jnuow ‘so1uodwo> a6pug Yo) “souedwe $05 JOURJON ‘seve
° ANNOWwY “MOD 19MOd PUO IYI] 21412043 ‘SoUOdWOD 49404 “thompoY >44499)9 PUD UOqunsd4u) ‘400115 Aq POEN 9q _, @ 21NG3Hs
SEARETREG? tows amen akiearee ; ———— eee ==
: : ~~" 4 260d ‘7 uwinjo> Aq “MOUS SO “SsaUISNG jo (» a600d UC MONIUIZ9p B9S) BuUIOdIU) SSOID joe), (4)
a ae es oye ae ih soe eee, 0} SBD0AU! $,49A00x0) UW! PapnNjou: “AUO }! ‘sa6s04> syGrasy (€)
’ 4 e
eS Rhee NM en! Ce cad re eg a ee nea. SNOLLdW3XF 3ZIW3LI
, TDD Cate arr am "TT" | 8600 "€ UUN!OD Aq UMoUSs Sv Pawo: SUudNGwaKZ (7)
. “:0GV
’ _E Geeta Sere er ater ee eer eee ETT TTT SET TT TSR === 1 BBOD “} UNO? Aq UMOYS SD ‘awor SS2se) PIQOXOY (1)
a. : : |
.. $40})9Q ake ; - 2 ; - gORIPUZ FY Yo SuwNOD
bi UI SalszUa Jsacosd ayy jo Suryow a4; Aq pajejdwo> uaaq Soy ‘| 960d ‘S3xXVL JO NOILVALNdWOD 42330 paiodaia #4 Sh QNPau sy sty
: (“Aqsadosg 94q:6u0) Bunjas jo ssoursng ayy uw pe6o6ua Suosaod 4j0 Aq pdsn aq oy; ‘3 3 Na3zHds
aNnowv © . | , S : ;
‘ e XX KK | KKK KKK KX KX: i li ian | a60d ‘7 uwinjoo sad so *Sa210au! Aq uMoys so 'spaaroig $9]05 Sait . 3 (6)
a A MASERU FP RRS SE EE [OOH ----=-- SIPWOISND OF SBD!0AU! $,saA0dx0} UI Papnyo2u! ‘AUD: 31 ‘saBuorg> yuS ay cp
rs rr ees prea ee | 260d ‘7 uwnjo2 ad so ‘spaar0id S2|0s ssos6 pud ‘adi1d OBosaav ‘yndyr.0 jojo] (€)
i a wr wren ee ne a ee a ee EE Sea Na A ae ea eae oo ie ee
« : iF .
mt i RMAs re ar nee ee ee eS USNOILAW3X3 3ZIWG il,
: xX KXXK XK KX KK XK XK Nr ee ee eee | e600 ’¢ uwnjo> Aq UMOYS SO ‘pauy'd)> Suc!fdwar z (7)
; | ‘ ; f :qaqv' ,
SPAR eke eee yee Shep ea eee | 860d “pf Uuinjo>s Aq umcys sD ‘anjoa 2)GoxDy (|)
es. = aed : masa meee
ed ‘sD S4O}10Q wury sy1un, '¥024944 8 0} Z SUWNIOD UI SaI4;Ua 4adosd 94) Jo BUIADW oN)
« 49g 911g | UOolZoNpos :AQ Ppajyejdwo> uaeq soy ‘| a6o0d ‘SIXVL 4O NOILVINdWOD 49440 posodesd aq Of Ss: anpaYy.5 si |
yo —_2 Bossy | ubanding yo, | ;
LINNOWY | ("9SP] 40 “g1y04q ‘B05 404 ae
2 ; | . |$aj2144y Gursodasg suossag puo Ssapunodwos ‘saainyooynuow Aq pasn 29 °L) ‘@ FING3IHDS
(€) (2) ob x
Dina, era pees isan hoe rea : —. f$aguacKa
4AWIO 40-‘pIOd saiyjOAO4 ‘a9z1-4d Buijjos yo yno sjyuabo P!lOd suorssiwwo> 104 UOHONPED INOYIIM “qo'y Sar1ud UO PasDg aq Oo; a2DINd BB0i9AY—- 219Ky3
SSRN naan nme — eh 0 PUN 101) ----- TTT TTT PBIMPOIT 10 4O aposd (6) LSE =" BaUnGs [OOD JO WIG 21015 (9)
TOTS ET ESTES (°D4a\ UO} Y4OYS 4O Buoy) pasn soto.) | ena ae pee TTT" peuad GBurznp pauinyge saciuc ISOM9] PUD*yssyHiy a1D4 (9)
; (Cub) PuE (€) jo Wns} anjor yaxs0W puo sp292010 Sajos “eaiig'aBosIn9 “sncinc 1404 (S)
‘ re Rae “7777 D3a ‘Bwinisoynuow ul pasn ANjDA, ;ayxs0W pho ‘a314d aBOs39A0 ynding (t)
ae ; .
Pe , : Barna hac Po an Iie tte Jancis ciao rs Cv Si gta. SP9a201C SajVS $scs6 pud ‘adI4d aBOIdAD ‘Ind*ng «¢)
: j { é 193 puo : O“€
~ ‘ ES Se ORE WR Gs ee = 4 ew nh els We eh ea Se www we we os wee oe’ are caaa Se ee Sate ee ee aE ae
ie Fe) ea Teo eT eee Poe POE ee Deed OO ESET TTS" SNOILIWIXS 3ZIWILI
x . NUK | x a HN RK femnnnn nn San oe = | 260d ‘¢ uuunjo>: Aq umoys oS simi SUuONduaxz (7)
a. ; \ ‘dav
“-$ | XXX K | KK KK MK KX xX | -=------------ HE oh dca on Peake nt yg ea uwinjo> Aq umMous so ‘QNJOA aIqoxoOy { 1)
ao ™ —s wun, | sup) | | “_ go z ‘ ry @ sadoid © Guryd
a ‘ yOasouy 4 UWINjOD ul S3alsjua sados 4 4° Guryow au,
; : 48d 92!4q UO! INpolg # Aq Payajdwo> uaaq Soy “| e600 ‘S3xVv1 4O NOILVLNdWOD 42340 pasodaid aq os 9 aeden SIQL
aBosaay Mt 3Nd3NOE jD30 4 | ; i
LANnNOWvV Jee ("49quii] 40 S492Nposg puo ‘BdjS a20uUINy 4ysO4g . ¢
7 ' : “SJOADUIW 4240 PUD ‘SoH ‘119 ‘JOD 4 SaB2nposg pul ssauiw Aq pesn 2q*0L) “Y J1NGIHIS
(f) : (2) (v) .
iatininith eae tg oe So nesnssn "Ody poldag 24s 4BA0D UANZOY S14) YO SIINP|YIS Jy ©
RAR RAL s
29
80
r-
¢
Saenneneaenenmeiis 3 wannnnnneemennnnmintet sip ec et aincle sy: wannnena hanna; §NOLLAW3X8 aun
> . i : : ‘aqv -
ba it alan hlclnaire aceite ite ene te eee 260d "y uwnjo> uous so ~s ajqoxoy ({)
‘SD
7
uw
‘posse, 8 04 Z ‘suusryeo
ul saajue sedoud @4s JO Buryow ey Aq pajajdwo> useq soy ‘| 2600 “S3xwi 4O NOILWLNdWOD 42440 pesodesd. aq 0} S! BINPaYyrS SI4L
_ _ ("894npayrg Busparasd :
®y) 49pUN pexoy AjjoO>r1y190ds 10U sroursng 9214408 Auo nt Susnuyuos 40 CuSetue suossod "Aq posm 9g 04) “H FINGIHDS
-- a —
Ps er ge ay ee eee sat pat ana ease ee are “S Noliawaxa 3ZIW3LI
ee ee $-----------pon=- - ne ee ee | 2600 ‘€ uwnjo> Aq umoys so ‘pauiio)2 Suoiytusax3 (2)
A)
7 | nd
: “ ' ?
4 "s08s84) 8 OF Z SUWINIOD
+, Ul S@Ljue sadoud ays 40 Guees 24s Aq pajya}duior useq soy “| 260d ‘S3xWv1 4O NOILWLNdWOD 49440 pasodaid ag 04 $1 ajnpayrs S14,
('2NGNE 9ys.09 Pos9}4o 210 SyUoWOENUT Y>IYyA 40 2044 s0yI0 AUD 40 ‘uoHDYS Bu
~™
ANNOWV
-sso2pooig o1pey “42014 8204 “yury BUNDNS “19H 290g ‘20g Wowssny ‘oyAspNoA ‘moys osnyrig Bu
nt.
Seg ee ee ey l — 'Z Wwinjoo Aq uMoYs so be nae 4° (b a6od uo UOI}IUTVap 2as) Pworuj S$Os5 (OO (£)
\
se esi poriivianennsenthetiiebinsiniiaiglite be monwanerentsineemnmee gigantea 3IZIW3LI
eee : wesenencenen nn nnnnnnnenn nnn == Pe SeK eer. Ae aanyes ‘ie maw SO ‘pawid)>, Suoijdwaxg (2)
ye ‘ ‘aq0v
AERP OR Aane RSH eS SSR ENS SeNS SSS eRaENaE SSR seasEnEeneees | 260d ‘p uunjor Aq uMoys so ‘unows ajqoxb[ "1 )
4
‘wD
‘-yooueus B 03 7 surg
ul salajue sodoud ays 40 Curyow Sq Aq paya/dwor uVeq soy ‘| e0d ‘S3XxV1 JO NOILWLMdWOD 44,0 pasodesd 0q 04 51 aINpeyrs SI4L"
(‘Surquog 40 ssoursng ayy uy Guinuyuo> 20 Gus6oBue sucssed Aq posn 0g 04) “4 F1NGIHDS
ee "
—— = —
aaa aaa aaa we: Maren abean Xt a ame ee ee atta SNOLLAW3X3 aZIWaL
eg ee eee TOSS Seg Sones new ee sa se eens s= | 860d “¢ uwNjo2 Aq UMoYs SO ‘pausd)> teneduanes (Z)
: ‘dav
err | 260d ‘» uwinjo> Aq uMoys SO “yUNoWD aqoxoy (1)
“HD
, : .
” ‘yooueys B 01 °7 suwnyo>
ul $a144Uue Jadosd oy 4O Buryow ayy Aq peseyeweo waeq $04 ‘| 260d 'S3xv1 JO NOILWINdWOS 49440 Pasodasd oq 04 $1 aiNpayrs S14,
, {6ug2044u0> 40 ssoussng oy Suynuyjuos 40 GusSobue suossed Aq posn oq 04 ) ‘3 7INGIHDS
RR SS Mate ANREP HORA A ee, pr a cata wOsy POHID OY) 49A0D UANJOY 8141 40 S2INPOYPS ITY
se «| ‘etnoy, o10dg SEE Sa ry ee ST Sees eer Sn Ee » aNnaaHIs
OO RL Gente
eee ee l . 7 ways Aq una SO ‘ssaursng 40 (p a60d uo: uoutuiyep @9s) awo2u| sing 1x04 (€)
SR ere ag nett ee ee eee nacre | a6od ‘¢ uwinjoo Aq umoys SO ‘pawioj> Suowduiax3 (Z) |
‘ ' 2 ° :gav
sain Laat aeebasicaaeonsaasaaenn anatecetn sinetetmnmanante | 260d ‘p uwnjo> Aq umMoys so ‘yuNOWO aj)qoxo St )
5 2 a 6
> 2 . ; ‘ ; ; px
f < ; ‘
o. 8 ‘ 640
j a : =F ; e :
. rtaben | Metal a oe eae | mo ~~ ayy UO Sasidxa UOISSILUWOS AW
. (®qQ ABW aS05 By} SD ‘JOINSD9I, 40 AJDJaIDaS ‘jUaPIS9Ig-32!A ; “4 sd Aso ; ( . iy me tay Bulyno
_ ‘4UaPISesg :U01,DI0dJO> © 4O 4J04eQ UO apOWw 4! ‘aI1) 1D Pic. yg, ». + J yaopiyyy Guyot U
__.2_ WuePtterd :Y0}0s0d102 © 40 j0U8d UO | Spou 21 "OL LOO) ___ wae Conn nnn ne en Bienen m= | gBTTYO 4O 1095 J
(4aADdxo yO BWON) ‘ ‘i ' : . :
SaaS SSeS SSS Soe See ee ee oe at ee ae ah eee ae OR ene ee ee ee ena oe Aop > ~;* S14} Buu asOJaq Paqisasqns pud O} UIOMG
‘S3SN3dX3 YSJHLO YO YOSV1 YO SGOOD JO 1SOD 40 INNODDV NO -3QVW 34Y3M SNOILINGIG ON 3WODNI SSOYD ONILYOdIY
NI 3043 pud ‘pasodaid som usunyas ayy .yr14yM Wosy Sps0ras PUD ssadod ‘sxo0q jOU!6}10 ayy YIIM PUD UNJa4 BYy UI _pa}s0dad SsauIsNg 94) YIM 401/104
AjyBnos0ys s! usnjyas ayy BuiuGis uossad 84) yOu PUD ‘usNjyas Gulyow 49ADdxd} ayy JO $pso2a4 pud ssadod ‘syoo0qg jOul61j0 ayy Wo1y Ua}O} a1aM pajy4sod
-as uoasaUy SauNBly ayy 304} /40jND!1}40d AsSAa PUD YD U! 4944102 PUD ans} ‘ya!11aq PUD aBHpajmouy Aw yO ysaq BY} OF ‘BID UsNJa4 SI4Y BuiAuddwior30 JO O}-
.
P2YI0}30 $}S1] JO 4S1) JOUOIZIPPD AUD UF PUD yUaWU4D}s AsDJUaWajddNs |Yyy Ul PUD UINY—ds BuioBas0y a4} ul pasajyua (S}UMOWD PUD suOd!;OUBISap O} SD '4ysOq)
SW}! PUD S}UaW9}0jS BY} 304} JO|MS AjUWajOS OP ‘ ; .
.
HLVO
. aa
_ “NYNLIY SIHL JO LYUVd V IWODTE AFHL ‘Q3HDVLLV O> N3HM ‘G3HOVLLVY 34 GIMOHS NOILVWYOINI AYVSSIDIN |
3HL ONINIVLNOD SL33HS 3LVUVdIS ‘SNOILVLON YO SW3LI YIdOUd TIV YILNI OL LNFIDISSNSNI SI NUNLIY SIHL NO 39VdS 3HL
~~
+ "s@AVOS}OYM asuadxa 419430 AUD JO PIDd jyUNODSIP 40 yspsajU! ‘SA1y}OAO1 ‘SaxD4 ‘S}SOD 4OGD) ‘PasSN SjOD149}0U 4O ¥SOD BY} ‘PjOS Aysadoud jo 4sOD ayy 40
yuNQZ2D UO SUO!}INpap AUD -}noUy!IM PUD payOUBisap saaamoy spUaNjOWA 4ayJO 40 Saa}¥ ‘Sa1s}OAOI ‘S/DjUd4 ‘yunoosip ‘ysasajui Guipnjoui “ul pabobua
SSBUISN BY} 4O JO¥IdDD ayy yO yUaWySaAU! a4 yO YOSD|s Aq S}dIaz—a1 {0 PUD ‘YyOq JO ‘adIAJaS 40 (|OUOSIAd JO }0a4) AjsadoudajqiBucy yo ajos ayy wos
Buinsd20 40 Buipaacoid anjoA ay} Puod sajDs 10 a2saWIWIOD ‘ssaUISNg *aPD4y WOsy PaAldap 4aAODdxD} aY4y 40 SydIara4 ssoi6 ay} SUDaW ,,aWODU! SSQJ5),,
»IWOONI SSOUD,, WYIL 3HL JO NOLLINId3G y
,
/ : J (‘Mojaq ,,awoou! ssos6,, 40 uo uaps) ‘ssauisng ayy jo ,,awooui ssos6,, aus HH WALI 49PUN ys0dau-
JJOYS Paxoy AjjOr1y!2ads asimsayjyO you BuijjO> 40 ssauisnq adiAsas*AUD us O1UIGIIA 4SaAQ UIYIIM Buinuijuod, 4o Bui6bo06ua uosuad AiaAQ H WIL!
(‘Mojaqg ,,aworu! ssos6,, yO UOIZIUIWaP BAG) ‘“ssaUIsNg ay} 4O ,,aWorU! sso.6,, ie 5 W3LI 4epun ysodas joys ‘21;GQnd ayy oO}
P2s9jj0 31D SyUaWaSNWD YIYM 4D a2d0)d 4aYyJO AUD 4O ‘UO}}04S BUIysDDPDOIG OIPDs ‘439044 B04 ‘HUIJ Buiyoys ‘jjOy a2uOp ‘ysDd yUaWAasSNWUD ‘a}|/!ABPNOA
‘MOUS a4Ny21d-BulAdw ‘asnoy dsado ‘1a}0a4} OD Buijouado 40 ssauisng ayy UI DIUIGIIA 4ySAAA UIYLIM Buinuijuo> 40 GuiBbobua uossad AuaAQZ * WIALI
(‘Mojaq ,,aworu! ssos6* yo UOIJIUIJaP aa>) “sSaUISNG ay} 40
,,ausoou! ssoi6,, 243 4 WALI 42puN jysodas |jOys Buryudg yo ssauisng ayy UI OIUIGIIA 4SaAQ UIYIM Buinuijuod so Gui6boGua uosuad AsaAZ 4 WILI
it : (‘Mojaq ,,awoou! ssos6,, yo UOIJIUIYaP. aag) “ssauisnq ayy 40
,2worou! ssoi6,, 244 3 WIL 4epun yuodas {j0Yys 6u13204j;U02 yo ssauIsng ayy ul OIUIBsIA ySaAq UIYYIM BuInulzU02, 40 Bui6bo6ua uosiad AlaaAQ 3 WIL
aie ("Mojaq ,,aworu! ssos6,, yO UOIJIUIYaP |aS) “SseUISNG a4} 4O ,,aWIOIU!
ssos6,, 243 (pb 0} |) G WIL! 2@PpUN ysodas |jOYs “W-Z1 B}>2H4y 4ePUN pexoy sojUDdWOD wo1j0js0dsud4y 494jC pud ‘sADM!04 ‘S2}UDdWO>D auoydajay puo
ydos60;9) ydeoxe ‘sai}1)!3n 21)qQNd ayo {JO PUD ‘sa!UddWO? aBpiiq |j0F ‘ssO}NGIZJSIP SOB jOuNyoU ‘sa1UDdWO? 420M ‘Sa1UDdWOD samod pud 4461 314333)8
'SADMII04 214329]9 PUD ‘UOGUN4azU! ‘39943 = ZIA ‘SassaUISNG AyI!13N. Buimoyjoy aya Ur QiUIGarA ySaAQ U! Buinu!jzu0> 40 Bul606ua Lossed Aang «WALI
4 (‘Mojaq ,,aworu! sso16,30 UOIs!UIyaP aag) ‘ssauisnq ayj yo ,,aworu! ssosB,, ays (7 40/puod 1) D W3LI 4apun jysodas j;0ys
‘yOuOSIad 40 |Das ‘4aABOS}OYM Ajysadosd 3)q!5u04 Aud Buljjas 4Q ssauisng ayy ul O1UIBs1A ysaQQ, UIYy!IM Buinuijuo> 40 Bui6bo6ua uossad AiaAgZ WIL
‘9SN jOIDI@WIWIO? 40 ‘314010 ‘ajDS Oy Pasodasd 40 papuNodwO? ‘pasny
-2DjNUDW 1338 ‘S3]I1ZID YINS 4JO yO ‘(aPOW S! ajOS OU B4BYM AN|DA SajOS 4O/PUD) sajOs yo Spaaroid ssos6 ays g WIL! JepuNn }4odas {JOYS ‘Sal}ipOUWO?
JO Ayipowwo> ‘Sd2UDjSqNS 40 a2DUDysqns ‘saj244JO 4O aj31Z40 AUD ‘340d UI 40 BjOYM Ul. ‘SIBYIO 4O AZIAIVIO BYyI YBNOIY) 10 Ajy2aiIp sayyia ‘asn ;D!DszaWWOD IDB
31y04d ‘aos 40} Bursodaid 40 ‘Buipunodwo> ‘Buunjyo0ynuoW 40 ssauisng ayy u! OJUIBIIA ysaAQ UIYyIM Buinuljzu0> JO 6ui6o06ua uossad Asaag- “Gg WILI
: ‘aSN jO1DsaWWOD JO ‘y1y04d ‘ajDS 404 Parnpod 4o paul syoNposd
a2unosas jDuNyOU |jD yO ‘(aPOW S! ajOS OU e194M AN|DA SajDS JO/pUD) SajOs 4o spaarosd ssouB ayy (G OF 1) Y WALI 4epun ys0daa {JOYS SyINposd |aduNo0se4
jOanyou Aud asn jO!2saWIWO? JO 414010 ‘ajOS 40} Buldnposd jo ssauisng ayy Ui DIUIBIIA 38a UIYIIM Buinulju0>.40 Bulbo6ya uosuad AyaagZ “WY WIL! . .
SIILIAILOV SSINISNG JO NOILVOIAISSVID “E
y ‘uoizsodosd ul padnpas Si UoIdwigxe 34} ‘109A xd} D 40 340d OD 40} pasid
Au 0} paMmo|jO Bulag uel;dwiaxa auo AjUO ‘aAIsNjduU! ‘}{ OF \y SWa}| JapUN”
_ payndwo> xd} yo JuMOWD U! SIDIJOP aAIj-A}UBM] (1) "spaar0sd: sajos ssou6 Aq uMOYsS SO anjOA wos pay2Npap aq o9 ‘AjjONUUD OO'O00'S$ 4O UO!;dWaxa
ud ‘sua2npoud SOB jOuNyOU yO |BsDD ayy Ul (9) - ‘S214jUNOD UBIas0y PUD 9}DjS S14} UBBMJ9G 4O ‘S2}DIS Pa}!U) 94s 4O SA}0jS 4940 PU 3jD}S SI4Z UBIMJaq
@2saUWO? WOly PaAtuep aworu! ssosB ‘saiy1113N BI;GNd yo asO> aYyy Ul (G) “S4@UINSUOD C4 SAjDS |jO WOsy BLUOSU! sso16 wooly UOIJINPap OD SD PaMo}jO (UO!)
-npoid) ¢-\y wa}; sapuNn saizii3n sob aia Aq piod x03 ay} 4O yuNMOW (fp) ,,"SA}OS yO spaaroid ssoi6,, JO ,,awo du! ssoi6,, ay} U! papnjru! S! 9j21340
MOU aUy JO adIUd ajOs jjNy aYy 4! ‘PJOS 3j21440 MaU AUD UO yUaWADd 440d SO paydad20 3/91340 Aud 40 adiud ajDS (€) ‘}!Pa1> Aq 40 YsO> ul’ wayyla papunyas S|
a21ud ajOs ay} UaYM, SiaWO}SN> Aq PausNyas asIPUDYrIaW 4O SasDM ‘spooB 40 3j0S jO Spaar0ig (7) ‘“SA}OS UO UAyYO} PUD PaMo]|O syuNOdsIP Yysn* (1).
- '@3MOTIV SNOILINGIG GNV SNOILdW3X3 “7 +
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.