Transcript of Record — Mantle Lamp Co. v. Aluminum Products Co.
Supreme Court brief1937
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
| Supreme Court as the Wnited States
Ocroser Term, A. D. 1936. .
aa
THE MANTLE LAMP COMPANY OF AMERICA,
Petitioner,
vs.
ALUMINUM PRODUCTS COMPANY, a Corporation,
Respondent.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT OF
APPEALS POR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT.
RECORD
INDEX.
Index to Printed Record of proceedings in U. S. District
Court: EID, By AP POL EN PERL T CTE EET Te i
Certificate of Clerk to Printed Record............- 479
Index to Record of proceedings in U. S. Circuit Court of
Appeals:
ESO ee Pere rere Pere eT ee eee «, 481
Appearance for appellant ....... riverrririe Te 481
Appearance for appellee ..........-.-2-eeeeee cues 482
Order of Apr. 9, 1935, setting cause for hearing.... 482
Hearing, cause taken under advisement May 28, 1935 483
Questions certified to U.S. Supreme Court........ 484
Mandate of Supreme Court .... .........--4-005- 488
Petition to set cause for further hearing......... .. 489
Exhibit A—Mandate of Supreme Court........ 490
Order of June 11, 1936, vacating order taking cause
under advisement and re-setting cause for’ re-
argument at October Session, 1936 ............-. 491
Re-Argument, Nov. 9, 1936 ...........--eeeeeeeee 492
Opinion by Sparks, J., filed Nov. 28, 1936.......... 493
Decree, entered Nov. 28, 1936.............:0 ee enue 494
Reference to issuance of Mandate on Dec. 22, 1936.. 495
Petition to recall Mandate .............ccsscecees 495
Order of Dec. 30, 1936, recalling Mandate. Serer eres 497
oh ene nbaeest éwaaas 499
et ee Ne *
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
IN THE
United States Circuit Court of nprals
For the Seventh Circuit
No. 5412
THE MANTLE LAMP COMPANY OF AMERICA,
Appellant,
vs. ,
ALUMINUM PRODUCTS COMPANY, a corporation,
Appellee.
Counacl for Appellant: Counael for Appellee:
MR. GEORGE |. HAIGHT, MR. WILLIAM NEVARRE CROMWELL,
MR. W.H. F. MILLAR,
Appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Northern D‘strict
of Dlinols, Eastern Division.
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD FILED DEC. 29, 1934.
PRINTED RECORD. ;
Ynited States Circuit Court of Appeals —
For the Seventh Girevit
No.5412
ee
THE MANTLE LAMP COMPANY OF AMERICA,
_—_ - Appellant,
vs. :
ALUMINUM PRODUCTS COMPANY, a conPoRaTion,
Appellee.
ounsel for Appellant; Counsel for Appellee:
MR. GEORGE I. HAIGHT, MR. WILLIAM NEVARRE CROMWELL,
MR. W.H. F. MILLAR,
ppeal from the District @ourt of the United States for the Northern District
of Illinois, Eastern Division.
i wnt ret Mheniratis* >
ed
«
q
4
Placi
Bill «
Meti
~ Stipr
Ansv
Not
Stip
tre
Plair
Cert
INDEX.
matte ..wccccacsocnccdosvissebantab een? ass aaauan 1
ill of complaint........ LeepeeakeGuee een paeeaeees 2
lotion to Gimgnias. . 0... .scccccccssocneneeksauuaeeeeees 6
tipulation of facts..............--¢ Ree eee tice @
nswer of defendant..............0.eeeeeeeceeeeeeees 15
lotion Of GeleOeeO. ooee.c so ccsccsnan snnenhaneeae ene 24
tipulation that uncertified copies of patents may be in-
troduced im evidence, O66... ..-.cccsscscssessuseuswane 25
STATEMENT OF EVIDENCE.
laintiff’s Witnesses:
Brainerd, Peart 3. ......isiecscsetaeueceeree 172, 46
Davis, Cortland W ....<ccasscpessantuaaeeeee 192, 29
Johnaom, Vietoe B. ...056 scccsdetaunssseueeeeee 209, 71
Low, Harey Wos.cccscncsvcccstnsastasess eee 173
Meissner, William Wallace....................0.- 27
Preeba, Bert Gu... ssc sss encase ceeaauns ccs 66
Simeoneon, WIG « «occ sccdasctas onsen eee 205
Terry, Prewk ©... .6..5c0itessesee eee 205, 60
Whine, Allee: Ds. os06sdteitesavasdecessaeseeee 181
efendant’s Witnesses:
Aapetion, Teles Fa. iiccacs cc beds neeasce es eee 87
ee GC os oi. cn-c'cpad ccc eoesd eee 92
Dodien. TENN Beis fos is cacndunseccuaveenees 171, 162
Demian Cam 2. oic6 dnc 0d45eaieseeeesae 149
a: Cia cg x ods or csetadeusdavalecasereerin 147
Murray, Norris Fay............ inionas oreerrr 171, 83
I. “IE TEAL os 6 6 6 4 40 54 baw Ke oad ae OG 166, 97
i, eee Gb NddANAE EA Soe 93
ne a a ee een 215
i
PuainTiFF’s EXHIBIts.
> Intro-
duced tno
evidence
at page
No. 1—Certified copy of Patent No. 1,435,199, L. V.
D. Blair. Mov. 14, 1983.....-2-0cccccececcces. 6
No. 2—Certified copy of bill of complaint filed in
District Court for Northern Distrfct of Ohio,
case of Mantle Lamp vs. Geo. H. Bowman Co... 26
No. 3—Certified copy of Opinion of C. C. A. 6th
Circuit, case of Mantle Lamp vs. Geo. H. Bow-
MM he ie erent ere RERE PRUE Es ake 27
No. 4—Certified copy of Answer of defendant, filed
in District Court for Northern District of Ohio,
case of Mantle Lamp vs. Geo. H. Bowman Co. 27
No. 5—Certified copy of Decree under Mandate,
District Court for Northern District: of Ohio,
case of Mantle Lamp vs. Geo. H. Bowman Co... 27
No. 6—Alleged infringing jug.................. 28
No. 7—Bill of sale from Carson, Pirie, Scott & Co. 28 »
- No. 8—Drawing made by witness Terry of first
PE A ees a ecias easy aan fine ae
No. 9—Advertisement from ‘‘Sporting Goods
ee a ge ae eae wecae ita ss 68
No. 10—sAdvertisement from ‘‘Hardware Age’’.. 68
No. 11—Advertising circular ................... 68
No. 12—Aluminum jacketed jar made by plaintiff 75
No. 13—Green jacketed jar made by plaintiff..... 75
No. 14—U. S. Patent No. 1,477,101, P. H. Brainard,
fe | ere rere err ere rey 82
No. 15—-U. S. Patent No. 1,489,059, P. H. Brainard,
a ee ererrrerrrrery rier ry 82
‘ No. 16—Drawing of vacuum gauge........... 180-200
No. 16-A—Drawing of necks of Heath device.....
No. 17—’’. S. Patent No. 1,071,817, W. Stanley,
a S| Weer rrr rrrrrr rer rer 200
No. 18—Keep-Longer contract .........+++++++: 213
Repro
duced
at page
342
216
220
438
444
241
- 243
396
245
DerenpDaxT’s ExuHpits.
aunts
‘tage
' No, 1—Fragment of broken jug.......-.. aes 90
No. 2—Drawing of early Macomb jug............ 90
No. 3—Drawing of second Macomb jug:......... 90 -
No. +—Drawing of third Macomb jug............ 90
No. 5—Patent No. 13093 (Reissue) Burger &
Aschenbrenner, Mar. 15, 1910................. 104
No. 5-a—Patent No. 46,640, M. M. Clark, Mar. 7,
ee oe er a a ae ea od a A oe 106
No. 5-b—Patent No. 184,256, J. C. Moore, Nov. 14,.
NS re ee Sale ee ed a aie ee 107
No. 5-e—-Patent No. 211,092, E. A. Heath, Jan. 7,
en ae ner Se Perea rae Pree 108
No. 5-d—Patent No. 358,732, C. E. Clisbee, Mar. 1,
PU oo Ata eee Ae a ey oes 111
No. 5-e—Patent No. 438,149, J. W. Fox, Oct. 14,
are scare ia ree eee eae 112
No. 5-f—Patent No. 884,582, H. Henn, Apr. 14, 1908 113
No. 5-g—Patent No. 900,075, G. P. Altenberg, Oct.
S. Peery eerr re rer tr Tritt rer er eer ere 114
No. 5-h—Patent No. 922,174, J. G. Lyman, May 18,
ee ee Pamere Pers Stee a ee 116
No. 5-i--Patent No. 1,002,009, L. R. Steel, Aug. 29, -
Be wins ME ARMS ENERO Ke ERED ERATE ore
No. 5-j—Patent No. 1,067,072, L. R. Steel, July 8,
SE a cckaa ade uyaewkce a eieeeeeeeess opie wes 118
No. 5-k—Patent No. 1,119,968, S. Le Sieur, Dec.
rrr ee rst Career ee 119
No. 5-l—Patent No. 1,116,266, L. Sturges, Nov. 23,
REPEC Terr tere Rye Oe eT pre 120
Repro-
duced
at page
249
251
253
410
iv
me
‘crpese
No. 5-n—Patent No. 1,309,967, Simonson & Blair,
Assignors, July 15, 1919. ... 2... ....seceeeeees 123
No. 5-o—Patent No. 1,333,795, Davis & Sunderlin,
EE ES a Wwe algas aude W6ebhudne das seaeses 123
No. 5-p—Patent No. 1,362,740, Rood & Johnson,
OCs ese kan cae shee chee os ckewnee 125 ©
No. 5-q—Patent No. 1,431,189, H. M. Smith, Oct
ES a ee Peer ree 127
No. 5-r—Patent No. 1,497,764, Simonson, ef al.,
I IDs 5 5 6050006000 Cewisdcisccestewens 128
No. 5-s—French Patent No. 403,574, Primas-
Gesellschaft Ritzhaupt & Co., published Nov. 8,
Ee a as ee Guess benmepabesaceudss 129
No. 5-t—French Patent No. 411,568, Lodo & Gas-
send, published June 20, 1910............---+. 130
No. 6—Page from Knight’s Mechanical Diction-
ary, published 1874............- Bere ccteee 134
No. 7—Jug manufactured by plaintiff........... 149
No. &—Memoranda of tests by Bowen........ “a
No. 8-A—Defendant’s jug with litharge seal...... 172
No. 8-B—Defendant’s jug with no seal........... 172
No. 8-C—Defendant’s jug with plaster of Paris
ee cea na enbesessadsssesesseecsoeaee 172
No. 8-D—Deféndant’s jug similar to Pltf.’s Ex. 6 172
No. 8-E—Plaintiff’s jar ......-...-.--++++++++- 172
No. 8-F—Defendant’s jar with sulphur seal...... 172
No. 9—Bottle of Zonolite.......... ENP TOOT EY 171
No. 10—File wrapper and Contents of U.S. Patent
No. 1,435,199 granted to L. V. D. Blair, Assignor
to The Mantle Lamp Co. of America, Nov. 14,
EEN Sh Pen PP er ee Tee Te ere eee, 181
ee ce pnesae sen Sbebede secede deersinseesc
Decree, entered July 20, 1934. ......-.----eeeeererceees
v
ee dS eae eee eeaaanas 326
EE I SIS ino oh oak seb sb ucnauicccconese lous 327
Sy INI NN go oe Sn be aes on 329
EE IN wanes e<eucsuuldeencsunaadende obese ake 329
Stipulation re condensed statement of evidence......... 331
Order re transmittal of original exhibits to Circuit Court
Oe IE Gh cn eek oss 6 4eke see cin Lee 332
Orders extending time for filing praecipe, lodging state-
ment of evidence and for filing transcript of record in
Cireuit Court of Appeaills................cccccece 333-334
Pe CHO WII 6 6G s oh Shc choc ucue eee 335
Appellees objections to praecipe, and motion to strike... 338
Order of Dec. 14, 1934 denying appellees motion to strike 339
a Unitep States Letters Patent.
No. 1,435,199, L. V. D. Blair, Nov. 14, 1922.............. 342
No. 46,640, M. M. Clark, Mar. 7, 1865.................. 348
No. 184,256, J. C. Moore, Nov. 14, 1876................. 352
No. 211,092, E. A. Heath, Jan. 7, 1879.................. 356
No. 358,732, C. E. Clisbee, Mar. 1,1887............¢.... 360
No. 438,149, J. W. Fox, Oct. 14, 1890.................. 366
No. 884,582, H. Henn, Apr. 14, 1908..:................. 370
No. 900,075, G. P. Altenberg, Oct. 6,1908............... 374
No. 922,174, J. G. Lyman, May 18, 1909............... 378
No. 13,093 (Reissue) Burger & Aschenbrenner, Mar. 15,
poe 4520 $i a shkdo deh eaddeea eee aaeedee ee oe 382
No. 1,002,009, L. R. Steel, Aug. 29,1911................ 386
No. 1,067,072, L. R. Steel, July 8,1913.........-........ 390
No. 1,071,817, W. Stanley, _ = . eres 396
No. 1,119,968, S. Le Sieur, Dec. 8, 1914............. .... 402
No. 1,161,266, L. Sturges, Nov. 23,1915................. 406
No. 1,199,772, J. J. Engel, Oct. 3, 1916....... PP gre 410
No. 1,309,967, Simonson & Blair, Assignors, July 15, 1919 413
No. 1,333,795, Davis & Sunderlin, Mar. | eee 420
vi
No. 1,362,740, Rood & Johnson, Dec. OR, Bn ss TP ienc ss 426
No. 1,431,189, H. M. Smith, Oct. 10, 1922................ 430
No. 1,477,101, P. H. Brainard, ae: > eee 438
No. 1,489,059, P. H. Brainard, Apr. 1, 1924..... coaneeaaes 444
No. 1,497,764, W. W. Simonson, et al., June 17, 1924..... 448
Translation of French Patent No. 403,574, Primas-Gesell-
-schaft Ritzhaupt & Co., published Nov. 8, 1999 oe waa 467
Translation of French Patent No. 411,568, Lodo and Gas-
send, published June 20, 1910.......---+-+2++++sgeees 473
Certificate of Clerk........------eeeereeeeeeeees -.... @
Ca oc ican cdacedcnendeceasecdangsesaces ereree 478
Order allowing certiorari >: ~ 499
1 Pleas in the District Court of the United States for Placita.
the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, begun
and held at the United States Court Room, in the City of Chi-
cago, in said District and Division, before the Honorable
John P. Barnes, District Judge of the United States for the
Northern District of Illinois on Thirtieth day of July, in the
year‘of our-Lord one thousand nine hundred and Thirty-four,
being one of the days of the regular July Term of said Court,
begun Monday, the Second day of July, and of our Independ-
ence the 158th year.
Present:
Honorable John P. Barnes.
William H. McDonnell, U. S. Marshal.
Charles M. Bates, Clerk.
. 21,
2 _ _ BM of Complaint.
2 Ix THe Distaicr Court or THE Unirep States,
Northern District of Illinois,
Eastern Division.
The Mantle Lamp Company of |
America, a corporation,
Plaintiff,
vs. , :
Aluminum Products Company, a
corporation,
Defendant. |
Be It Remembered, that the above-entitled action was com-
menced by the filing of the following Bill of Complaint in the
above-entitled cause in the office of the Clerk of the District
Court of the United States for the Northern District of Illi-
—_ Eastern Division, on this the 2lst day of November,
3 In tHe Distaict Count OF THE Unitep States.
e © (Caption) ° *°
BILL OF COMPLAINT.
To the Honorable, the Judges of the United States District
Court, for the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Divi-
sion:
The Mantle Lamp Company of America, a corporation,
brings this, its Bill of Complaint, against the Aluminum Prod-
ucts Company, a corporation, and says:
1. That the plaintiff, The Mantle Lamp Company of Amer-
ica, is a corporation duly organized and existing under and
by virtue of the laws of the State of Illinois and having its
principal office and place of business in Chicago, in said
State. ;
29 That the defendant, Aluminum Products Company, is
a corporation organized and existing under and by virtue of
the laws of the State of Illinois and is a citizen and in-
4 ~ habitant of the State of Illinois, with a place ef business
at Lemont, Illinois, within the said Northern District of
Bill of Complaint. 3
[linois, Eastern Division, wherein it committed the acts of
infringement hereinafter complained of.
3 That the jurisdiction of the court depends upon the Pat-
ent Laws of the United States.
4 That heretofore, on to-wit » October 29, 1919, Lewis Van
Deventer Blair, a citizen of the United States, residing at
Chicago in the State of Illinois, was the first, true and orig-
inal wiventor of a certain new and useful improvement in
Heat-Insulated Receptacles, not known or used in this coun-
try and not patented or described in any printed publication
in this or any foreign country before his said invention or
discovery thereof and not more than two years prior to his
hereinafter recited application for a patent therefor and not
in public use or on sale for more than two years prior to his °
hereinafter recited application for a patent therefor, and no
plication for a foreign patent for said invention was filed
more than twelve months prior to the filing of the application
in this country, and said invention was not abandoned to the
blic.
5 That said Lewis Van Deventer Blair being, as afore-
said, the original, first and true inventor of said improve-
ments, within the meaning of the Statutes of the United States
then in force and being entitled to a patent thereon under the
provisigns of said statutes, did file in the United States Pat-
ent Office an application for Letters Patent on said invention
and on the 14th day of November, 1922, all of the require-
ments of the statutes of the United States then in force hav-
ing been duly complied with, Letters Patent of the United
States No. 1,435,199 were duly issued on said application
5 to The Mantle Lamp Company of America, a corporation
of Illinois, to whom the said invention and said applica-
tion for Letters Patent thereon had previously been duly as-
signed by an instrument in writing, duly exeouted and deliv-
ered by said Lewis Van Devanter Blair, and recorded in the
Patent Office of the United States.
6. That plaintiff has expended large sums of money in
making the invention of said Letters Patent profitable to itself
and useful to the public; that said invention has been and is
of great benefit and advantage to the public and the public
have generally acknowledged and acquiesced in the rights of
plaintiff thereunder, and that a large number of devices em-
bedying the invention of said Letters Patent have been made’.
and sold by the plaintiff. |
7. That the said defendant has infringed upon said Let-
4 Bill of Complaint.
ters Patent since the date of said Letters Patent and prior to
the filing of this bill, by making or causing to be made, using
or causing to be used, and selling or causing to be sold, within
this district and elsewhere in the United States, heat-insulated
receptacles made in accordance with and embodying the in-
vention set forth in the said patent, willfully and without the
consent of the plaintiff and is continuing to do so, and has
derived unlawful gains and profits from such infringement
which the plaintiff would otherwise have received but for
such infringement and has thereby been caused irreparable
damage.
6 8 That the plaintiff has given to the public notice of
the aforesaid Letters Patent and the plaintiff’s mghts
thereunder, by marking the receptacles manufactured by it
under said Letters Patent in accordance. with the statute in
such cases made and provided.
9. That in the month of December 1927 and prior thereto,
The Geo. H. Bowman Company, 4 dealer in heat-insulated re-
ceptacles and other commodities in the City of Cleveland,
Sfite of Ohio, was vending and selling heat-insulated recep-
tacles embodying the invention set forth in and in intringe-
ment and violation of the rights of plaintiff under said Let-
ters Patent No. 1,435,199; that on the 18th day of January,
1928, the said The Mantle Lamp Company of America,
brought its bill in equity in the District Court of the United
States, for the Northern District of Ohio, Eastern Division,
against the said, The Geo. H. Bowman Company, and in said
suit complained that the defendant had infringed and threat-
ened the further infringement of the said Letters Patent No.
1,435,199; that the said defendant filed its answer to the said
bill of complaint and the said cause came on to be heard on
the pleadings and proofs and was argued before the Honor-
able S. H. West, Judge of the said District Court; and on the
12th day of September, 1929, the court ordered a decree for
the defendant and against the plaintiff and denying the valid-
ity of the said Letters Patent No. 1,435,199 for want of
7 invention; that thereafter and on the 19th day of Novem-
ber 1929 the plaintiff prayed an appeal from the said de-
cree of the District Court to the United States Circuit Court
of Appeals. for the Sixth Circuit and filed therein its assign-
ment of errors; that thereafter the said cause came on to be
heard before the Judges of the United States Circuit Court
of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, upon.the record, briefs and
arguments of counsel and that upon consideration of the
\
\
Bill of Complaint. 5
proofs, briefs, and arguments the Circuit Court of Appeals
for the Sixth Circuit, in an opinion filed November 3, 1931,
reversed the finding of the District Court and remanded the
said cause to the said District Court with instructions to en-
ter a decree affirming the validity of the said Letters Patent
No. 1,435,199, and finding that the defendant had infringed
claim one (1) of said patent and without prejudice to any
rights of the plaintiff under any other claim, and that a per-
petual injunction, as prayed for, restraining the defendant
from infringing said Letters Patent issue and said decree
was accordingly thereafter signed and filed in the said Dis-
trict Court on the 11th day of May, 1932, and the said perpet-
nal injunction was thereupon ordered to be granted and is-
aed.
10. Wherefore, plaintiff prays for a preliminary injunc-
tion, pending this suit, and for a permanent injunction issu-
ing out of and under the seal of this court, enjoining and re-
straining the said defendant, the Aluminum Products Com-
pany, a corporation, its officers, directors, solicitors, clerks,
servants, agents, attorneys, and workmen, and each of them,
from infringing upon said Letters Patent; that the defendant
account to the plaintiff for the profits made by it and for
8 the damages sustained by the plaintiff; that plaintiff re-
cover the costs and disbursements of this suit, and plain-
tiff prays for such other and further relief as may appear
proper and be agreeable to equity; that a writ of subpoena
may be issued under the seal of this court directed to the
above named defendant, Aluminum Products Company, a cor-
poration, commanding it to appear and answer this bill of
complaint, but not under oath the answer under oath being -
hereby expressly waived. 7 .
Tue Mantite Lamp Company OF AMERICA,
By Victor S. Jonnson,
President.
State of Ilinois,
County of Cook. sa
Before me, the undersigned, a Notary Public in and for the
county and State aforesaid, this 7th day of September, A. D.
1932, personally appeared Victor S. Johnson, and made
oath that he is President of The Mantle Lamp Company of
America, the plaintiff named in the foregoing bill; that he
has read the said bill, knows the contents thereof, and that —
6 Motion to Dismiss.
the same is true as he verily believes, except as to such mat-
ters as are alleged upon information and belief and as to
those matters he verily believes them to be true; that he sub-
scribed to the foregoing bill and that he had authority so to
do.
Witness my hand and Notarial Seal the day and year afore.
said.
H. M. Junker,
(Seal) Notary Public.
My Commission Expires Oct. 2, 1932.
Georce I. Haicurt,
W. H. F. Mriuak,
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
9 And on, to‘wit, the 24th day of December, 1932 came
the Defendant by its attorneys and fifed in the Clerk’s
office of said Court a-certain Motion to Dismiss in words and
figures following, to wit:
10 In THE Districr Court OF THE Unitep SraTEes.
* °* (Caption) °
MOTION TO DISMISS.
Now comes Aluminum Products Company, a corporation,
the defendant in the above entitled suit and moves the court
to dismiss the bill of complaint filed in the above entitled
cause, upon grounds and reasons therefor, as follows:
x i
Because this cause of action is based solely upon a patent,
viz. Blair patent No. 1,435,199 granted November 14, 1922,
which said patent on May 28, 1927 was decreed to be invalid
by the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sev-
enth Circuit, "in Monarch Company, Inc. and Therm-A-Jug
Company, Inc. v. Mantle Lamp Company of America (the
plainiiff herein) Docket No. 3889 and reported in 22 F. (2nd)
95, in which rehearing was denied December 5, 1927.
Motion to Dismiss. 7
H —2—
Because the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Seventh Circuit in the case of Monarch Company, Inc., v. The
Mantle Lamp Company of America (the plaintiff herein)
Docket No. 4012 (not reported) again found Blair patent
1.435,199 invalid and issued its mandate to the District Court
of the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, on Octo-
ber 8, 1928 to enjoin the plaintiff herein from further prose-
cating a suit which it had brought in the United States Die-
trict Court at Kansas City and from bringing or prosecuting
any other suits under Blair patent 1,435,199 against the Mon-
arch Company’s customers, jobbers, dealers, agents and dis-
tributors at any time or place.
a
Because this cause of action is based solely upon a patent,
riz. Blair patent No. 1,435,199 granted November 14, 1922,
shich said patent is wholly invalid inasmuch as no disclaimer
has been made as required in Sections 65 and 71, Title 35
U.S. Code, (Revised Statutes Sections 4917 and 4922) as to
daims 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 21, 22, 23, 24 of said
Blair patent 1,435,190 which were held invalid by the United
States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on
May 28, 1927, in the case of Macon Mfg. Co. v. Mantle Lamp
Company of America (the plaintiff herein) Docket No. 3812,
reported in 22 F. (2nd) 93. in which case rehearing was .de-
tied by said Circuit Court of Appeals on December 5, 1937.
_
Because the plaintiff Mantle Lamp Company of America
has in its bill of complaint disregarded and failed to set
12 forth and inform this court concerning the following liti-
gation in the United States Circnit Court of Appeals for
the Seventh Circuit andsethe Supreme Court of the United
States involving the Blair patent 1,435,199:
1. The decision of the United States Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Seventh Circuit in the contested case of Macomb
Mfa. Co. v. Mantle Lamp Company of America, Docket No.
3812. reported in 22 F. (2nd) 93, in which all of the claims of
the Blair patent 1,435,199 that were relied upon in said case,
8 Motion to Dismiss.
namely claims 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 21, 22, 23,
24, were declared invalid.
2. The decision of the United States Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Seventh Circuit in the contested case of Monarch
Company Inc., and Therm-A-Jug Company, Inc. v. Mantle
Lamp Company of America, Docket No. 3889, reported in 22
F. (2nd) 95, in which the Blair patent, 1,435,199 was declared
invalid. ;
3. The decision of the United States Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Seventh Circuit in the contested case of Mon-
arch Company, Inc., v. Mantle Lamp Company of America,
Docket No. 4012, (not reported) in which the Blair patent
1,435,199 was declared invalid and an injunction decreed
against the Mantle Lamp Company of America (the present
plaintiff) to refrain from prosecuting and bringing suits on
said Blair patent.
4. The decision of the United States Supreme Court
13 in the case of The Mantle Lamp Company of America,
Petitioner, v. The George H. Bowman Company, Re-
spondent, Docket No. 673, reported in 285 U.S. 545, in which
the Supreme Court denied the petition of The Mantle Lamp
Company of America, for a writ of certiorari. to the United
States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit to re-
view the decision of that court in.which claim 1 of Blair pat-
ent 1,435,199 was held valid, said suit not having been con-
tested, the decision of which is reported in 53 F. (2nd) 441,
and which suit has been referred to in the bill of complaint
herein, the ground upon which said writ of certiorari- was
prayed being that the decision of the Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Sixth Circuit was in conflict with the decision of
the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in the
ease of The Mantle Lamp Company of America v. Macomb
Manufacturing Company, 22 F. (2nd) 93.
Evcene M. Gites,
Harvey S. Hanson,
Solicitors for Defendant.
14 And on, to wit, the 21st day of January, 1933-came the
parties by their attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s office
of said Court @ certain Stipulation in words and figures fol-
lowing, to wit:
Stipulation of Facts. 9
15 Ix tHe District Court or THE Unrrep States.
° ° (Caption) ° °
STIPULATION.
In accordance with the oral stipulafion ma?~ by the solici-
tors appearing for the respective parties herern, in open court
at the argument before the Honorable George E. Q. John-
son, United States District Judge, on Wednesdiy, January
19, 1933, in connection with plaintiff’s motion for a prelimi-
nary injunction, ~
' It is hereby stipulated and agreed by and between the par-
ties hereto by their respective solicitors that the following
matters relating to prior litigation in the United States Cir-
enit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit and the United
States Supreme Court are admitted by the plaintiff herein:
1. The plaintiff herein, The Mantle Lamp Company of
America is the same The Mantle Lamp Company of America
which was a party in the case of Macomb Mfg. Company, ap-
pellant-defendant, vs. The Mantle Lamp Company of America,
appellee-plaintiff, in the United States Circuit Court of A
peals for the Seventh Circuit, which case was docketed in said
court as No. 3812, that in said case the Blair patent No.
16 1,435,199 granted November 14, 1922, which is thé patent
in suit herein, was held to be invalid as to claims 1, 4, 5, 6,
7,10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 21, 22, 23 and 24 by said United
States Cirenit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in
its opinion dated May 28, 1927, in which case rehearing was
denied by said United States Circuit Court*o? Appeals for the
Seventh Circuit on December 5, 1927, that said opinion of said
Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit is as re-
ported-in 22 Federal Reporter (2nd) 93, and that following
denial of rehearing of said cause on December 5, 1927, the
United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Cir-
cuit in said case No. 3812, forthwith issued its mandate and
the bill of complaint was thereupon promptly dismissed and
the cause thereby finally concluded.
2. The plaintiff herein, The Mantle Lamp Company of
America is the same The Mantle Lamp Company of America
which was a party in the case of Monarch Company, Inc., and
Therm-A~Jug Company, Inc., appellants-plaintiffs, ». The
Mantle Lamp Company of America, appellee-defendant, in
the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh
Filed Jan. 2
1988.
10 Stipulation of Facts.
Circuit, which case was docketed in said court as No. 3889 and
in which case the Blair patent No. 1,435,199 granted Novem-
ber 14, 1922, which is the patent in suit herein, was involved
by counter claim made by said appellee-defendant, and that
said United States Circyit Court of Appeals for the Seventh
Circuit held said patent invalid in its opinion dated May 28,
1927, which said opinion is as reported in 22 Federal Reporter
. (2nd) 95, as follows:
Appellants filed suit against appellee for unfair competi-
tion in the sale of heat-insulated receptacles designed to
17 keep hot liquids hot and cold liquids cold. Appellee filed
a counterclaim charging that plaintiffs, in making their
receptacles, infringed patent No. 1,435,199, owned by appellee
and considered in the case of Macomb Manufacturing Co. v.
Mantle Lamp Co, (No, 3812) 22 F. (2d) 93, decided this day.
The court dismissed the bill of complaint for want of equity,
upheld the counterclaim, and adjudged the patent valid and
infringed as to the same claims relied on in No, 3812. The
only question presented upon the issue of unfair competition -
is whether the decree was right upon the evidence. We have
examined the evidence, and are satisfied that it does not war-
rant a decree for appellants upon this issue. That part of
the decree dismissing the bill of complaint is affirmed.
But we cannot approve the decree upon the patent branch
of the case. For the reasons stated in our opinion in the Ma-
comb Case, we hold the patent invalid. This part of the de-
cree is reversed, with direction to dismiss the counterclaim.
Costs shall be divided equally between the parties.”’
and that following denial of rehearing of said cause on De-
cember 5, 1927, the United States Circuit Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit in said case No. 3889 forthwith issued
its mandate and the bill of complaint and counterclaim were
thereupon promptly dismissed and the cause thereby finally
concluded.
3. The plaintiff herein, The Mantle Lamp Company of
America is the same The Mantle Lamp Company of America
which was a party in the case of The Monarch Company, Inc
and The Therm-A-Juq Company, Inc., Appellants-Plaintiffs
vy. The Mantle Lamp Company of America, Appellee-Defend- _
ant, in the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Seventh Circuit, which case was docketed in said court as No.
4012, and in which case the Blair patent No. 1,435,199 granted
November 14, 1922, which is the patent in suit herein, was 1n-
Stipulation of Facts. 11
volved, and that in said case said United States Circuit
18 Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on October-2,
1928, made and entered its decree which is as follows:
“This cause coming on to be heard this second day of Octo-
ber, 1928, upon due consideration, it is now ordered that the
Order and Decree entered by the District Court January 12,
1928 denying and overruling plaintiff’s motion for a prelimi- .
nary injunction in conformity with the prayer of the bill of
complaint be and the same is hereby reversed with costs and
that this cause be, and the same is hereby remanded to the
said District Court of the Northern District of Illinois, East-
erm Division, with directions to immediately order the issu-
ance of a temporary injunction pending the final determina-
tion of this cause restraining The Mantle Lamp Company of
America, its officers, counselors, attorneys, solicitors, trustees,
agents, clerks, employees, servants, workmen, and those in
active concert and participating with them;
1—From prosecuting or taking any further action in the
suit of the Mantle Lamp Company of America v. The Cutino
Company, pending in the United States District Court for
the Western District of Missouri, as Equity No. 546, involv-
tig the structures made by the plaintiffs, The Monarch Com-
pany, Inc., and the Therm-A-Jug Company, Inc., and adjudi-
ated by. the Court of Appéals of the Seventh Circuit in the
case of The Monarch Company, Inc., and The Therm-A-Jug
Company, Inc. v. The Mantle Lamp Company of America, No.
889 or bringing or prosecuting any suit against The Mon-
arch Company, Inc., or The Therm-A-Jug Company, Inc. or
their customers, involving the issues of unfair comeptition
ind infringement of the Blair patent No. 1,435,199 adjudi-
rated by the Court of Appeals of the Seventh Circuit in said
case No. 3889.
2—From bringing and prosecuting any other suits under
aid Blair patent No. i,435,199, issued November 14, 1922,
ainst plaintiffs or either of them or their customers, (job-
ters, dealers, agents or distributors) at any time or in any
3—From threatening orally or in writing, directly or in-
directly, plaintiffs or-either of them or their customers, un-
ter or with respect to said Blair patent No. 1,435,199; dated
November 14, 1922.’ .
4. The plaintiff herein, The Mantle Lamp Company of
3 America is the same The Mantle Lamp Company of Amer-
ica which was a party in the case of The Mantle Lamp
12 _ Stipulation of Facts.
aaa de America, Petitioner, v. The Geo. H. Bowman
Company, Respondent in the Supreme Court of the United
States, docket number 673, upon Petition for Writ of Cer-
tiorari to the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
to review a cause wherein the decision and decree of the Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, rendered and en-
tered November 3, 1931, in which said cause an answer was
filed but defendant did not appear at the trial nor offer any
evidence in support of its answer, and which said cause is re-
ferred to and relied upon in plaintiff’s bill of complaint and
motion for preliminary injunction herein, found claim 1 of
.the Blair patent 1,435,199, which is the patent in suit here-
in, valid and infringed and which said Petition for Writ of
Certiorari set up the decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals
‘for the Seventh Circuit in the case of The Mantle Lamp Com-
pany of America v. Macomb Mfg. Co. 22 Fed. (2nd) 93 in
which claims 1, 4, 5, 6, 7,.10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17,18, 21, 22, 23 and
24 were held to be-invalid for lack of invention and as a ground
in support of said petition the diversity of opinions and de-
cision between the Sixth and Seventh Circuit Court of Ap
peal in the above cases was urged and that on March 14, 1932
the said Petition for Writ of Certiorari was denied and that
the denial of said petition was reported in 285 U. S. 545, 76
L. Ed. 936.
5. That the following ‘matters which were set up in de- -
fendant’s motion to dismiss the bill of complaint:
90 herein shall be taken and considered: by the Court 4s a
part of defendant’s reply in opposition to plaintiff’s mo- -
tion for preliminary injunction:
pa
Because this cause of action is based solely upon a patent,
viz. Blair patent No. 1,435,199, granted November 14, 1922,
which said patent on May 28, 1927 was decreed to be invalid
' by the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh
Circuit, in Monarch Company, Inc. and Therm-A-Jug Com-
pany; Inc. v. Mantle Lamp Company of America (the plain-
tiff herein) Docket No. 3889 and reported in 22 F. (2nd) 9,
in which rehearing was denied December 5, 1927.
— se
Because the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Seventh Circuit in the case of Monarch Company, Inc., v. The
Stipulation of Facts. 13
Mantle Lamp Company of America (the plaintiff herein)
Docket No. 4012 (not reported) again found Blair patent
1,435,199 invalid and issued its mandate to the District Court
of the Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, on Oc-
tober 8, 1928 to enjoin the plaintiff herein from further prose-
cating a suit which it had brought in the United States Dis:
trict Court at Kansas City and from bringing or prosecuting
any other suits under Blair patent 1,435,199 against the Mon-
arch Company’s customers, jobbers, dealers, agents and dis-
tributors at any time or place.
a 3
Because this cause of action is based solely upon a patent,
wz. Blair patent No. 1,435,199 granted November 14, 1922,
which said patent is wholly invalid inasmuch as no disclaimer
has-been made as required in Sections 65 and 71, Title 35
U. S. Code, (Revised Statutes Sections 4917 and 4922) as to
daims 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 11,.12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 21, 22, 23, 24 of said
Blair patent 1,435,199 which were held invalid by the United
States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on
May 28, 1927 in the case of Macomb Mfg. Co. v. Mantle Lamp
Company of America (the plaintiff herein) Docket No. 3812,
reported in 22 F. (2nd) 93, in which case rehearing was de-
tied by said Circuit Court of Appeals on December 5, 1927. .
Because the plaintiff Mantle Lamp Company of America
has in its bill of complaint disregarded and failed to set forth
and inform this court concerning the following litigation in
the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh
Cireuit and the Supreme Court of the United States involv-
ing the Blair patent 1,435,199:
1. The decision of the United States Circuit Court of Ap-
peals for the Seventh Circuit in the contested case of Macomb
Ufg. Co. v. Mantle Lamp Company of America, Docket No.
3812, reported in 22 F. (2nd) 93, in which all of the claims of
the Blair patent 1,435,199 that were relied upon in said case,
tamely claims 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 21, 22, 23,
4, were declared invalid. |
. 2. The decision of the United States Circuit Court
2 of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in the contested case
of’ Monarch Company Inc., and Therm-A-Jug Company,
14 Stipulation of Facts.
Inc. v. Mantle Lamp Company of America, Docket No. 3889
reported in 22 F. (2nd) 95, in which the Blair patent 1,435,199
' *was declared invalid.
3. The decision of the United States Circuit Court of Ap.
peals for the Seventh Circuit in the contested case of Monarch
Company, Inc., v. Mantle Lamp Company of America, Docket
- No. 4012, (not reported) in which the Blair patent 1,435,199
was declared invalid and an injunction decreed against the
Mantle Lamp Company of America (the present plaintiff) to
refrain from prosecuting and bringing suits on said Blair
patent.
4. The decision of the United States Supreme Court in
the case of The Mantle Lamp Company of America, Peti-
tioner, 'v. The George H. Bowman Company, Respondent,
Docket No. 673, reported in 285 U. S. 545, in which the Su-
preme Court denied the petition of The Mantle Lamp Com-
pany of America, for a writ of certiorari to the United States
Cireuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit to review the
decision of that court in which claim 1 of Blair patent 1,435,-
199 was held valid, said suit not having beey contested, the -
decision of which is reported in 53 F. (2nd) 441, and which |
suit has been referred to in the bill of complaint herein, the
ground upon which said writ of certiorari was prayed being
that the decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals for the
93 Sixth Circuit was in conflict with the decision of the Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit in the
case of The Mantle Lamp Company of America v. Macomb
Manufacturing Company, 22 F. (2nd) 93.
Gro. I. Hatontr
W. H. F. Mritar
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
Evoene M. Gries ‘
Harvey L. Hanson
Solicitors for Defendant.
January 20, 1933.
24 And on. to wit, the 23rd day of January, 1933 came the
Defendant by its attorneys and filed in the Cierk’s office
of said Court a certain Answer in words and figures follow-
ing, to wit:
Answer of Defendant. 15
% Iw tae District Covar or tHe Unrrep Srares.
* °* (Caption) * *
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT, ALUMINUM PRODUCTS
COMPANY, TO THE BILL OF, COMPLAINT OF
PLAINTIFF, THE MANTLE LAMP COMPANY OF
AMERICA.
1. This defendant admits the allegations in paragraph 1
of the bill of complaint relative to the corporate capacity,
principal office and place of business of the plaintiff.
2. This defendant admits the allegations in paragraph 2 of
the bill of complaint relative to the corporation capacity, citi-
vnship and place of business of defendant, but denies the
allegations and statement in said paragraph 2 of the bill of
complaint that the defendant has committed thy acts of in-
fringement complained of in the biil of complaent.
3. This defen2ent admits for the purposes of the present
suit the jurisdiction of the court as set up in the paragraph 3
of the bill of complaint.
4. This defendant denies each and every allegation and
statement contained in paragraph 4 of the bill of com-
plaint.
% 5. This defendant admits the issuance of the Letters
Patent identified in paragraph 5 of the bill of complaint
to The Mantle Lamp Company of America, a corporation of
llinois, but denies each and every other allegation in para-
graph 5 of said bill of complaint.
Filed Jan.
1933. =
6. This defendant denies each and every allegation con-—
tained in paragraphs 6, 7 and 8 of the bill of complaint.
7. This defendant as to the allegations of paragraph 9
of the bill of complaint admits only that on the 18th day of
January, 1928 the Mantle Lamp Company of America brought
its bill in equity in the District Court of United States, for
the Northern District of Ohio,.Eastern Division, against The
Geo. H. Bowman’ Company and in said suit complained that
The Geo. H. Bowman Gompany had infringed and threatened
the further infringement of Letters Patent No. 1,435,199; ad-
mits that an answer was filed in-the name of The Geo. H.
Bowman Company to the said bill of. complaint and that the
said cause came on to be heard before the Honorable S. H.
West, Judge of said District Court; admits that on the 12th
day of September, 1929 the court ordered a decree for The
UE in aeration
ee OL sa
> in i , ,
rene Dt ag 06 Rt ORL oak tied
16 Answer of Defendant.
Geo. H. Bowman Company against The Mantle Lamp Com-
pany of America and denying the validity of the Letters Pat-
ent 1,435,199 for want of invention; admits that thereafter
and on the 19th day of November, 1929 The Mantle Lamp
Company of America prayed an appeal from the said decree
of the District Court to the United States Court of Appeals
for the Sixth Circuit and filed therein its assignment of er-
rors; admits that thereafter the said cause came on to be
_heard before the Judges of the United States Circuit Court
of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit and that the Circuit
297 Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in an opinion filed
November 3, 1931 reversed the decree of the District
Court with instructions to enter the usual decree for said
plaintiff on claim 1 of Letters Patent No. 1,435,199 and with-
out prejudice to any rights of said plaintiff under any other
claim, but this defendant denies each and every other allega-
tion, statement and representation in paragraph 9 which is
not specifically admitted herein, and denies the inference of
said paragraph 9 that the case set up therein was a regularly
contested controversy and this defendant avers that the infor-
mation given by plaintiff in paragraph 9 is incomplete, mis-
leading and deceptive and that, contrary to what would nat-
urally be understood from the matters as they are set out in
paragraph 9 and the purpose for which they are presumed to
have been recited in this bill of complaint, the suit of The
Mantle Lamp Company of America against The Geo. H. Bow-
man Company was not a contested case,—that, although an
answer was filed in the name of The Geo. H. Bowman Com-”
pany, no evidence was offered by The Geo. H. Bowman Com-
pany,—that the only evidence offered was that of The Mantle.
Lamp Company of ‘America,—that the said evidence of The
Mantle Lamp Company of America was offered and the tes-
timony of its witnesses taken without any opposition or cross-
examination by The Geo. H. Bowman Company, that’ prior
patents set up in defense in the answer of The Geo. H. Bow-
man Company were furnished and put into evidence by The
Mantle Lamp Company of America and a favorable decision
on claim 1 of the Blair patent No. 1,435,199 thus obtained in
which the Blair patent in the suit and the prior art pat-
28 ents set up in the answer of The Geo. H. Bowman Com-
pany were considered in the light of the unopposed testi-
mony of The Mantle Lamp Company of America witnesses
that had not been subjected to cross examination,—that no
briefs were filed on behalf of The Geo. H. Bowman Company
Answer of Defendant. 17
in the said District Court or in the Court of Appeals for the
Sixth Circuit, that there was no appearance or argument for
or on behalf of The Geo. H. Bowman Company at the hearing
of said cause in the District Court of the United States for
| the Northern District of Ohio, Eastern Division, before the
Honorable S. H. West, Judge of said District Court,—that
there was no appearance or argument for or on behalf of The
Geo. H. Bowman Company at the hearing of said cause in
the Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit,—and that the de-
cision of the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit
set up and relied-upon by complainant herein is of no force
or effect whatsoever in establishing validity of the Blair pat-
ett No. 1,435,199, or claim I thereof, or in establishing any
right on the part of plaintiff to any of the relief sought herein.
8. This defendant further answering the bill of complaint
avers that the Blair Patent No. 1,435,199 has been involved
mfavorably in other litigation to which the present plaintiff
was a party and in regard to which said other litigation no
information is given in the bill of complaint,—and as to such
other litigation this defendant avers that: ©
A. The plaintiff herein, The Mantle Lamp Company of
America was a party in the fully contested case of Ma-
% comb Mfg. Company, appellant-defendant, v. The Mantle
Lamp Company of America, appellee-plaintif, in the
United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Cir-
ait, which case was docketed in said court as No. 3812, that
mn said case the Blair patent No. 1,435,199 granted November
14, 1922, which is the patent in suit herein, was held to be
‘invalid as to claims 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 11,-12, 13; 14, 17, 18, 21,
2, 23 and 24 by said United States Circuit Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit in its opinion dated May 28, 1927, in
vhich case rehearing was denied by said United States Cir-
ait Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on December 5,
1927, and that following denial of rehearing of said cause on
December 5, 1927, the United States Circuit Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit in said case No. 3812, forthwith is-
med its mandate and the bill of complaint was thereupon
promptly dismissed and the cause thereby finally concluded.
B. The plaintiff herein, The Mantle Lamp Company of
America was a party in the fully contested case of Monarch
Company, Inc., and Therm-A-Jug Company, Inc., appel-
lnts-plaintiffs,v. The Mantle Lamp Company of America,
wpellee-defendant, in the United States Circuit Court of
Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, which case was docketed in
18 Answer of Defendant.
_ said court as No. 3889 and in which case the Blair patent No,
1,435,199 granted November 14, 1922, which is the patent in
suit herein, was involved by counter claim made by said ap.
pelee-defendant, and that said United States Circuit Court
of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit held said patent
3 30 invalid in its opinion dated May 28, 1927, and that fol-
: lowing denial of rehearing of said cause on December 5,
‘ 1927, the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sev-
nth Circuit in.said case No. 3889 forthwith issued its man-
te and the bill of complaint and counter-claim were there-
upon promptly dismissed and the cause thereby finally con-
qluded.
C. The plaintiff herein, The Mantle Lomp Company of
America was a party in the fully contested case of The Mon-
arch Company, Inc., and The Therm-A-Jug Company, Inc.,
Appellants-Plaintiffs v. The Mantle Lamp Company of Amer-
ica, Appellee-Defendant, in the United States Circuit Court
of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, which case was dovketed
in said court as No. 4012, and in which case the Blair patent
-_ No. 1,435,199 granted November 14, 1922, which is the patent
in suit herein, was involved, and that in said case said United
States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on
October 2, 1928, made and entered its decree enjoining the
plaintiff herein from bringing, prosecuting or threatening
suit under the Blair patent No. 1,435,199 against certain par-
ties mentioned and referred to therein.
D. The plaintiff herein, The Mantle Lamp Company of
America was a party in the case of The Mantle Lamp Com-
pany of America, Petitioner, v. The Geo. H. Bowman Com-
pany, Respondent in the Supreme Court of the United States,
docket number 673, upon Petition for Writ of Certiorari to
7 the Circuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit to re,
31 view the cause set up in paragraph 9 of the bill of com-
plaint herein wherein the decision and decree of the Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit, rendered and en-
tered November 3, 1931, found claim 1 of the Blair Patent
1,435,199 valid and infringed, and said Petition for Writ of
Certierari set up the decision of the Cireuit Court of Appeals
for the Seventh Circuit in the case of The Mane Lamp Com-
pany of America v. Macomb Mfg. Co. in which claims 1, 4, 9,
6, 7, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 21, 92, 23 and 24-were held to be
‘nvalid for lack of invention and as a ground in support of
‘said petition the diversity of opinion and decision between the
Sixth and Seventh Circuit Courts of Appeal in the above
ay Ronin AGES
eet in ict Arce ag AG ON DP tak ira Mowe
at teats
LEI RN ES FPO I NS ORR ID
. = _
Answer of Defendant. 19
cases Was urged and that on March 14, 1932 the said Petition
for Writ of Certiorari was denied, and this defendant avers
that by reason of the litigation mentioned in the above sec-
tions A, B, C and D of this paragraph and the findings, de-
cisions, decrees and orders of the respective courts therein the
Blair Patent No. 1,435,199, and each and every claim there-
of is wholly invalid and ineffective to entitle the plaintiff to
any of the relief sought herein.
9. The defendant further answering the bill of eomplaint
avers that no disclaimer as required by the statutes of the
United States has been made and/or filed-in the United States
Patent Office, in connection with Blair Patent 1,435,199, as to
daims 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 21, 22, 23 and 24
thereof which were held invalid by the United States Circuit
Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit on May 28, 1927 in
the case of Macomb Mfg. Co. v. The Mantle Lamp Com-
32 pany of America, Docket No. 3812, referred-to in Sec-
tion A of paragraph 8 hereof, and that because no dis-
cdaimer has been filed as aforesaid Blair Patent No. 1,435,-
199 is entirely invalid.
10. This defendant further avers that the plaintiff herein
well knowing at the time it filed its bill of complaint that in
view of the matters set up in paragraph 8 herein it was not
entitled to the relief sought by it in its bill of complaint,—and
well knowing at the time it filed its bill of complaint that the
Blair Patent No. 1,435,199 was invalid because no disclaimer
had been filed as required by the United States statutes as set
out in Paragraph 9 herein, and well knowing at the time it
fled its bill of complaint that the actual proceedings referred.
to in paragraph 9 of its bill of complaint did not establish
any right to the relief sought herein, has wilfully, deliber-
ately and intentionally set forth and portrayed the proceed-
ings in the Bowman case that is recited in paragraph 9 of its
bill of complaint so that it appeared to be an ordinary con-
tested patent infringement case and has wilfully, deliberately
and intentionally omitted from its bill of complaint informa-
tion with respect to the proceedings set out in paragraph 9
of its bill of complaint all of which is essential for a complete
and fair understanding of said proceedings and the effect
thereof as to said Blair patent, and has likewise wilfully, de-
lberately and intentionally omitted from its bill of complaint
nformation regarding the other litigation set ‘up in para-
graph 8 of this answer in order that this Court might not be
informed as to the true situation with respect to the Blair
patent No. 1,435,199, and that because of such wilful, delib-
4 ahi »
‘abl watt
20 Answer of Defendant.
erate and intentional misrepresentations and omissions, the
plaintiff is not entitled to any relief which it seeks through its
bill of complaint.
33 11. This defendant, further answering the bill of com-
plaint has long prior to the filing of its bill of complaint
had knowledge of the acts of defendant complained of in the
bill of complaint and that because of its long delay in offering
an objection to said acts and its long delay after knowledge
of defendant’s said acts in bringing its bill of complaint, the
complainant is not entitled to any relief prayed for herein.
12. This defendant, further answering the bill of com-
plaint, avers that said Letters Patent 1,435,199 and each of .
the claims thereof is invalid and void for the following rea-
sons:
(a) Because the specification of said letters patent is in-
complete and indefinite and does not set forth the alleged
invention in such full, clear, concise and exact terms as to
enable persons skilled in the art to which it appertains, or
with which it is most clearly connected, to make, construct
and use the same, does not particularly point out and defi-.
nitely claim the parts, improvements or combinations consti-
tuting the alleged invention as required by the statutes of the
United States.
(b) Because the said Blair letters patent do not disclose
patentable subject matter of invention or discovery within
the meaning of the patent law, but, on the contrary, set forth
and describe only old: and familiar constructions and devices
of common and ordinary knowledge, practice and manufac-
ture long prior to the alleged invention thereof by the said
Blair, and within the knowledge, reach and disposal of any
skilled worker or mechanic in the art to which the alleged
34 invention relates, and in the analogous arts at the time
of, and for many years before, the alleged invention of
Blair, and that the structure and details thereof set forth
in said patent represented nothing more than the usual and
expected mechanical skill commonly employed by workers in
such arts. ,
(c) Because the subject matter of said patent was not
invention,.contained no patentable novelty and was not a new
improvement in the art.
(d) Because the claims of said patent 1,435,199 do not de-
fine patentable combinations of elements as required by the
statutes of the United States, but recite merely aggregations
of old well known elements to produce old and well known
results.
Answer of Defendant. 21
(e) Because Blair was not the original, first and sole in-
ventor of the alleged invention or improvement described
and claimed in said letters patent, or of any material or sub-
stantial part thereof, but that on the contrary, the same and
every material and substantial part thereof, had been, long
prior to the alleged invention of Blair, patented and/or de-
scribed in divers patents and printed publications, as herein-
after stated, and in others to which defendant prays leave to
refer hereafter, by amendment or otherwise, when it has fully
ascertained the same, the several patents being also set up as
printed publications:
United States Letters Patent
Number
13,093
46,640
147,459
184,256
211,092
358,732
386,231
438,149
707,634
797,577
820,347
884,582
900,075
916,814
916,815
922,174
928,002 .
930,204
1,000,172
1,002,009
1,029,364
1,033,398
1,056,971
1,067,072
1,071,817
1,084,453
1,119,968
1,161,261
1,199,772
1,307,907
1,309,967 -
Inventor
Burger & Aschenbrenner
Clark
Wiesebrock
Moore
Heath
Clisbee
Bassler
Fox
Place
Heylandt
Burger & Aschenbrenner
Henn
Altenberg
Williams
‘Williams
Lyman
Paalen
Marsh & Thompson
Hopkins
Steel .
Hartwig
Heylandt
Coleman
Steel
Stanley ‘
St. Vrain Le Sieur -
St. Vrain Le Sieur
Sturges
Engel
Simonson & Blair
Simonson & Blair
Date
March 15,
Mar.
Feb.
Nov.
Jan.
Mar.
July
Oct.
Aug.
Aug.
May
Apr.
Oct.
Mar.
Mar.
May
July
Aug.
Aug.
Aug.
June -
July
Mar.
July
Sept.
Jan.
Dec. -
Nov.
Oct.
June
July
22 Answer of Defendant.
Number | Inventor Date
1,333,795° Davis & Sunderlin Mar. 16, 1920
1,362,740 Rood & Johnson Dec. 21, 1920
1,431,189 Smith Oct. 10, 1929
1,497,764 Simonson & Blair June 17, 1924
British Letters Patent
835 of 1881 to E. J. Gaskell et al.
817 of 1893 to Johnston.
1,910 of 1911 to Dommel.
French Letters Patent
380,824 Van Wye Dec. 18, 1907
403,572 Marchet . June 1, 1909
403,574 - Societe Primas Gessel-
Schaft Ritzhaupt & Co. June 1, 1909
411,568 L. Lodo et al June 20, 1910
Publications
Knight’s American Mechanical Dictionary
published by J. B. Ford and Company in New York,
U.S. A. in 1874, page 507.
36 (f) Because Blair was not the true, original, first, and
sole inventor of any patentable improvements forming
subject matter of said letters.patent 1,435,199, but that vari-
ous persons at various places have had knowledge and made ©
use of the things alleged to be patented, and of every material
and substantial part thereof long prior to the alleged inven-
tion by the said Blair and that the following is the list of
names and addresses of said users, said addresses being also
the places where the uses occurred and knowledge was had:
Name Address
The Therm-A-Jug Company Webster City, Iowa
The Monarch Company, Inc. Webster City, lowa
Guy Burton a Webster City, Iowa
William B. Rood > Webster City, lowa
Charles W. Owens \ Webster City, Iowa
Ernest S. Johnson ~~ | Webster City, lowa
William Tweedie Webster City, lowa
_ Federal Mfg. Co. . Des Moines, lowa
' National Mfg. Co. Des Moines, Iowa
Stanley Insulating Company Great Barrington, Mass.
Herbert M. Smith Great Barrington, Mass.
Answer of Defendant. 23
and the officers, employees and agents of the named com-
ies at the company addresses and elsewhere in the United
States and each of the individuals named in the foregoing
patents at the addresses therein given and elsewhere,—
and this defendant is not now advised of the names and ad-
dresses Of additional persons and places of use although
making diligent search therefor, but prays leave of this Hon-
orable Court to insert said names and addresses of said per-
sons and places of use by amendment to this answer as soon '
as ascertained.
13. This defendant further answering avers that said
patent 1,435,199 is so limited and narrowed down to
37 specific features of the heat insulated receptacles dis-
closed therein, by proceedings in and in connection with
the prosecution of the application in the Patent Office which
resulted in the obtaining of said patent that said patent is
not entitled to a construction to include defendant’s alleged
es structure.
Wherefore the defendant denies that_it has done any act
or thing, or is doing any act or thing or intends to do any
act or thing in violation of any right, exclusive or otherwise,
belonging to the plaintiff, or alleged to be seeured to plain-
tiff by said letters patent, and denies that plaintiff is entitled.
to any relief of any nature in respect to the matters prayed
for in the bill of complaint; and defendant prays that the bill
of complaint herein be dismissed with costs to the defendant.
AtumINuM Propucts CoMPany
By Evcene M. Gries
Harvey L. Hanson
Its Solicitors.
3% And on, to wit, the 27th day of October, 1933, came
the Defendant by its attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s
fice of said Court a certain Notice in words and figures
following, to wit:
24 Notice.
39 In tHE Unitep States District Court.
* * (Caption) ° ° |
NOTICE. |
Mr. George I. Haight, .
1041 The Rookery,
Chicago, Illinois
and
Mr. W. H. F. Millar,
First National Bank Bldg.,
Chicago, Illinois,
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
Gentlemen: .
Please take notice that at the trial of the above entitled
cause the defendant, Aluminum Products Company, besides
the defenses set up in its answer, will rely upon the further
defense of invalidity of Letters Patent No. 1,435,199 because
of previous invention and knowledge of the subject matter
thereof by various persons other than Lewis Van Deventer
Blair, as follows, to-wit: |
Because Blair was not the original and first inventor or
discoverer of any material and substantial part of the sub-
. ject matter of. Letters Patent No. 1,435,199, and the alleged
- invention or improvements of said letters patent were previ-
ously known to and invented or discovered by various
40 persons and at-various places long prior to the alleged
invention or discovery thereof by. said Blair, and more
particularly by the following named persons at the places
mentioned :
Name Address
Reinhold Burger Berlin, Germany
Albert Aschenbrenner Berlin, Germany
Moses M. Clark Monroe, New York.
Friedrich #. Wiesebrock New York, New York
Engene A. Heath New York, New York
Clarence E. Clisbee Boston, Massachusetts
John H. Bassler Myerstown, Pennsylvania
John W. Fox Cleveland, Ohio
George P. Altenburg Cincinnati, Ohio
Paulus Heylandt Erfurt, Germany
Huber Henn Berlin, Germany
Stipulation. 25
Name Address |
David Arthur Williams Represa, California
John G. Lyman Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
George A. Marsh Marshville, N. Carolina ~
Hiram H. Thompson Washington, D. C.
John S. Hopkins Brooklyn, New York
- Leonard R. Steel Cleveland, Ohio
Robert Hartwig Berlin, Germany
Christian Wilhelm Paulus Heylandt Schulau, Germany
Clyde J. Coleman New York, New York
Gustav Robert Paalen Berlin, Germany
St. Vrain Le Sieur East St. Louis, Illinois
John J. Engel Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania
William W. Simonson Cincinnati, Ohio
William B. Rood Webster City, Iowa
Herbert Me Smith Great Barrington, Mass.
Ernest S. Johnson Webster City, Iowa
Lee Sturgis Chicago, [linois
William Stanley Great Barrington, Mass.
Cortland W. Davis Chicago, Illinois
Frank R. Sunderlin Chicago, Dlinois
James F. Place Glenridge, New Jersey
.WriuiaMm Navarre CROMWELL,
Solicitor for Defendant.
Receipt of a copy of the foregoing notice is hereby ac-
knowledged and service of the same is hereby accepted this
2th day of September, 1933. ‘alls
Georce I. Hatcutr
W. iH. F. Mrizar .
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
41. And on, to wit, the 27th day of October, 1933, came
the parties by their attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s
ofice of said Court a certain Stipulation in words and fig-
ures following, to wit:
42. _ I~ roe District Court or THE Untrep States.
°* © (Caption) ° °
STIPULATION.
_ It is hereby stipulated and agreed, by and between coun-
sel for the partfes hereto, that uncertified printed or photo- .
Filed Oct. 27,
1938.
26 Statement of Evidence.
graphic copies of United States and foreign patents and
printed publications may be introduced and admitted in evi-
dence, subject to correction for error if any there be, as proof
of such patents and printed publications, and that the dates
of filing, sealing, delivery or publication, as recited therein,
and the stamped dates of receipt by the United States Patent
Office appearing on copies of foreign patents, shall be taken
as estublishing such dates, without further proof, subject to
correction for errors. *
W. H. F. Mriias
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
Wurm Navarre Cromwe.t,
Solicitor for Defendant.
43 Endorsed: District Court of the United States. * °
(Caption) * °* Condensed Narrative Statement of
Evidence. Filed Dec 141934 Charles M. Bates Clerk Lodged
Nov 27 1934 Charles M. Bates, Clerk.
1 44 Before the Honorable John P. Barnes, District
Judge. °
Trial had from October 24, 1933 to October 30, 1933.
Appearances: —
For the Plaintiff,—George I. Haight, W. H. F.
- Millar, Chicago, Illinois.
For the Defendant,—William Navarre Cromwell,
Chicago, Illinois. ,
2 Mr. Millar: Certified copy of patent in suit offered in
evidence as PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 1.
Mr. Cromygl]l: Objected to for the reason that be-
cause of the decisions of the Circuit Court of Ap-
45 peals, this patent is not a valid grant, has no status
before this court and in the circumstances is en-
tirely incompetent upon which to base any claim or right
of action by the plaintiff.
The Court: Objection overruled.
(Admitted as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1).
3 Mr. Millar: We offer in evidence certified copy of
bill of complaint in the action of ‘‘The Mantle Lamp
Company of America, Plaintiff, v. The George H. Bow-
man Company, Defendant, in Equity, No. 2506, United
States District Court, Northern District of Ohio, East-
ern Division’, as PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT »
«
Statement of Evidence. 27
Mr. Cromwell: Same objection’as made to Plaintiff’s
Exhibit 1.
Mr. Millar: Plaintiff’s Fxhibit 2 is material because
plaintiff is relying to a certain extent and has set up in
its pleadings the decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals
in the Sixth Circuit, so we are now by the bill of com-
plaint and the answer and the decree endeavoring to
show what the proceedings were that took place and
what the issues were.. The records in the other two cases
in the Seventh Circuit are here. It would be convenient
for the court to put this in evidence in the re¢ord in this
ease. The findings of the Sixth Circuit Court of
46 Appeals is law but may not be controlling on the
' court, but the files have to be submitted subject to
factual proof on the issues here.
The Court: Objection sustained. The decision ofthe
Sixth Circuit Court of appeals is authority, good, bar
or indifferent. You may at the same time show me the
records of the District Court in Ohio, of the Circuit Court
of Appeals uf the Sixth Circuit, which I will consider in
interpreting that authority but I don’t see that it is evi-
dence here. Objection sustained.
Mr. Millar: Certified copy of opinion of the Circuit
Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit in the same case,
offered in evidence.
Mr. Cromwell: Same objection.
The Court: Same ruling.
Mr. Millar: Certified copy of answer in the District
- Court in the same case, offered in evidence.
Mr. Cromwell: Same objection.
The Court: Same ruling.
Mr. Millar: Certified copy of decree under mandate
of District Court in the same cause, offered in evidence
as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 5.
Mr. Cromwel!: Same objection.
The Court: Same ruling.
Mr. Millar: To which rulings we except.
47 WILLIAM WALLACE MEISSNER, called as wit-
ness on behalf of plaintiff, testified as follows:
My name is William Wallace Meissner and I live in
Itasca, Illinois. My occupation is that of sales super-
visor for The Mantle Lamp Company, the plaintiff. I
,
28
6
a:
9
10
1
Statement of Evidence.
have been connected with The Mantle Lamp Company
for eleven years.
The document you hand me I have seen before. I re.
- ceived it when I bought one of these Alladin jars from
Carson, Pirie, Scott & Company, a bill of payment. It .
is in the same condition as when..I received it with the
exception of pencil memorandum I made at time I pui-
chased this jar. The words ‘‘Manufactured by the
Aluminum Products Company, La Grange, IIlinois,”’ are
in my handwriting. I received the document on July 13,
when I purchased a jar.
I have seen the jar marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6 for
identification. It is the jar I purchased from Carson,
Pirie, Scott, to which I have just referred.
48 The jar has been cut open and a rag inserted and
the stopper is missing, otherwise the jar is in the
same condition as when I purchased it.
I made a pencil memorandum ‘‘Purchased by Meis,
sner Carson, Pirie, Scott & Company’’ on the bottom of
the jar when I purchased it, from Carson, Pirie, Scott.
The neck of the jar has been opened up and examined.
There was a cup cap on top of the stopper. ries,
I visited the plant of the defendant Aluminum Prod-
ucts Company in March, 1932. I purchased a jar of this
type from them. I am familiar with its structure. This
jar, Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6 for identification, is manufac-
tured by the Aluminum Products Company.
Jar received in evidence as PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT
‘Bill-of Carson, Pirie, Scott & Company, for purchase
- jar, réceived in evidence as PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT
49 Cross-Examination by Mr. Cromwell.
My pencil memorandum of Plaintiff’s Exhibit 7 leads
me to believe that jar referred to was made by Aluminum
Products Company. :
The construction and label on Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6
indicates that jar was made by Aluminum Products Com-
pany. because I bought a jar of the same type from the
Aluminum Products Company in March 1932. The Jar
probably can be obtained; it may be in my possession.
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. - 29
122 50 CORTLAND W. DAVIS, called as witness on be-
half of plaintiff, testified as follows:
My name is Cortland W. Davis. I live in Alexandria,
Indiana. My occupation is that of Mechanical Engineer,
for the Mantle Lamp Company of America and have
been connected with them for approximately twenty-
three years, in charge of the manufacturing and of re-
‘search work.
I attended Cornell Uaiversity, Ithaca, New York and
was graduated therefrom on June 20, 1907 with the de-
gree of mechanical engineer.
I have had experience in the preparation of applica:
tions for patents and the prosecution of patent applica-
. tions before the patent board for practically the duration
of my employment with the Mantle Lamp Company of
America.
I have had experience in research and experimental
work with regard to heat insulated receptacles; being in
charge of research of the company my work has been
the overseeing of all work done in that line by the com-
pany.
I am a registered patent solicitor having had ex-
perience in the prosecution of patent applications
51 ‘personally. before the patent office other than the
United States, in several foreign countries in Europe.
I am familiar with the structure of the device, Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 6. This article is a heat insulated con-
tainer of the non-vacuum type. It has an outer metallic
jacket in multiple sections joined together by a circum-
ferential seam within the jacket and an inner vitreous
container bonded to the neck to the outer jacket, and be-
tween the outside of the inner container and the inside
of the metal jacket comminuted insulating material is
positioned. The container also is provided with a cork,
but no cap in this particular exhibit.
The material between the necks of the jacket and con-
tainer consists largely of: sulphur its function being to
form a bond between the neck of the inner container and
the contracted neck of the outer jack, uniting the two
mechanically, and also preventing moisture entering in
the space between the inmer container and the outer
jacket.
Pe en eee eran Cee ee? eet Be. 2 Set eee ok a
30
16
17
18
19
Statement of Evidence.
The upper extremety of the outer jacket has a con.
tracted threaded section and an inturned annular lip ex.
tending over the inner container. The purpose of the in-
turned flange is to facilitate the assembly of the con-
tainer to the jacket and to afford protection to the
52 frangible container. I am familiar. with the sub.
stances that may be used as a bond, as the bond de-
scribed is used. There are many synthetic materials,
synthetic resins, plaster of paris, sulphur, anything that
may be introduced and will solidify in place to perform
its function. Sulphur as used in that container is sub-
.stantially non-porus.
When I first saw this jar if was not‘in the condition
I now find it. At my direction these cuts were made in
the jar, one at the lower extremity and one at the upper
extremity. After having made those cuts I found the
material between the jacket and the container was dry
sawdust. One of the cuts exposes the neck of the con-
tainer, the neck ef the jacket is cut away. :
With reference to the outer side of the neck of the
container there is an annular groove, encircling the outer
surface of the inner container of the nek.
When the inner container is placed within the outer
jacket and molteh sulphur is poured into the space be-
tween the two necks, or the neck of the outer jacket and
the inner container, sulphur when it solidifies becomes
an interlocking element which bonds the outer jacket and
the inner container. My means df this interlocking bond
the container is supportable in that jacket.
53 _.The stepper is positioned within the jar when in
use. It has a flange provided with a rubber gasket
whith rests on the tap of the container and a depending
section which goes into the mouth of the inner jacket and
is loose and spaced apart from the inner onl .
I am familiar with the properties of that type of sul-
phur with respect Wo its ability to conduct heat. It is
in the class of non-conductor. &
The inner container is: made of earthenware. It is
inherently frangible; easiiy broken. The container has
an inner surface that has been glazed, vitrified. In the
manufacture of earthenware containers, the manufac-
turers put a ceramic material, known as a slip, which.
glazes its inner surface and the outer side of this con-
tainer is not glazed. It is mugh and partially porous.
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. 31
The characteristic of a-glazed or vitreous surface is
waterproof. no,
I have had experience in endeavoring to seal or join
a vitreous substance to a metal substance. Some of the
usual methods of joining metal to metal, it may be inter-
locked by folds, soldered, brazed, welded, several dif-
_ferent methods of joining metal to metal. None of those
20
21
methods are available for joining a vitreous substance
and a metallic substance as used in that jar.
_I have made, or have had made under my direc-
d4 tion, tests to determine the efficiency of various
types of heat insulated receptacles; that included an -
examination of receptacles other than those made in ac-
cordance with the Blair patent. ’ :
In heat insulated receptacles of the non-vacuum type,
- insofar as efficiency is concerned, if the centainer had
contact with the jacket at more than one place, contacts
between the inner container and the outer jacket would
lessen the efficiency because of heat conducted through:
the contact.
I have had experience to determine the relative ef-
ficiency of containers of that type where the material be-
tween the walls of the container and the jacket were on
the one hand dry and on the other hand moist: , As a heat
insulated receptacle the dry is decidedly more efficient.
A container having both a metallic ‘jacket and a metal-
lic inner container is Jess efficient that a container with
a vitreous inner container.
The principal path of heat loss in the device, Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 6, is at the top, at the point where the in-
ner container and the outer jacket are joined. ‘ :
With respect to moisture which may get between the
walls of the container and the jacket, the proper seal or
bonding material precludes the entrance of moisture in
that junction. The seal or material I find in Plain-
99 tiff’s Exhibit 6 does so act to preclude moisture.
I am familiar with the patent in suit. It is my
opinion that claims of Plaintiff’s Exhibit 1 read on Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 6.
Q. Will you kindly indicate to us which ones are so
read in this Exhibit 67 fo:
Mr. Cromwell: I object to this line of examination.
It seems to me it is the function. of this Court to deter-
mine the reading. Mechanical construction is to be in-
’ ra
eee ‘ >
23
24
25
Statement of Evidence.
»
terpreted by this witness, but the interpretation of these
claims is essentially the function. of the Court.
The Court: I suppose the Court is to detérmine
whether or not there is an infringement and that is a
conclusion, and perhaps what he has asked fer is a con-
clusion. Bgt I don’t think that is the exact question.
~. Mr. Cromwell: Let’s have the question read.
(Question read by the reporter.)
Mr. Cromwell: It is essentially an interpretation of
- those claims, your Honor.
The Court: Yes, but I don’t think it is the exact ques-
tion the Court is called to _pass upon. He is qualified as
an expert in this matter and I think the Court is entitled
to the benefit of his testimony and to the benefit of your
cross examination. Objection overruled. .
Mr. Cromwell: Exception.
56 The Witness: I have a file copy of this Exhibit
1. On this copy I have read the claims and in m
judgment No. 1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18,
21, 22, 23, 24, and these claims recite elements which I
find in Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6.
The Court: Which ones did you omit, 2 and 16?
Mr. Haight: 2, 15, 16, 19, and 20, if the court please.
Between the device here, Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6 and the
device disclosed in the patent I find very little diference
structually. Functionally, ne difference.
The ‘structual differences I find are, in the Blair device
a glass stopper has been used, while in Exhibit 6 an
aluminum stopper has been used.
In the Blair device an inner vitreous container is
57 used, which is of glass, while in Exhibit 6 the inner
container is of vitreous earthenware. There is a
difference in the. general shape and configuration. No
other essential difference between the two.
In Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6, the comminuted material in-
_terposed in the space between the outer wall of the inner
container and the inner wall of the outer jacket prevents
convective air currents and the transmission of heat from
the inner container to the outer jacket, and also tends to
limit pendulous movement of the inner container. The
sawdust material is considered a non-conductor of heat.
“The material between the container and the jacked.
would lessen the indentation of the outer jacket if it
was subject to shock and possibly preclude the breaking
of the frangible container.
26
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. 33
Cross-Examination by Mr. Cromwell.
I testified in the other litigations, the Monarch suit
and the Macomb Manufacturing Company suit, involv-
ing the same patent. *
As to what I meant by pendulous movement 4s a char-
acteristic of the inner container, any container suspended
in its upper extremity with the balance of the container
free will inherently possess a slight. amount of pendu-
lous movement, It is inevitable. Swinging, jarring,
58 striking something, induces that pendulous move-
ment. In swinging an article if you hit it against
something, q little vibration or a little movement. The
degree of that pendulous movement in a container of this
sort. would be very slight. It is difficult to measure and
— to decimals of an inch, but I would ‘say very
slight. .
6. Have you ever made any tests to determine that?
A. None, only having a container enipty to feel of
it and see—
I asked you if you had made those tests.
I have made those tests.
And what have those tests indicated? .
What I have said it did, move slightly.
How did you determine that?
Hearing it, seeing it move, very slight movement.
You say it is practically infinitesimal and yet you
POPOPO
©
say ‘you saw it.
A. You can feel it give.
Q. Where did you feel it?
A. Inmy hands. —
Q. Where did you put your hands when you felt that
movement? “.
A. Take one of these receptacles, when the inner con-
tainer— . ;
. *Q. You are referring to Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6?
‘ A. This type of receptacle. When the inner con-
tainer is bonded to the top, without the bottom jacket be-
ing secured. to the upper section and inverted without the
filling that is in it, before any of the material is in-
jected between, you can feel a slight movement by strain-
ing at the bottom of the inner container.
09 Q. That is an abnormal condition, isn’t it?
A. -No, normal. .
Q. You say without there being any filling in it. That
28
29
30
bond covered by this patent or disclosed in this patent
Statement of Evidence.
would be an abnormal condition of that container
wouldn’t it?
A. I wouldn’t say so, no.
Q. How can it be normal if you haven’t got that pack.
ing in it between the inner container and the jacket?
A. The material that is packed isn’t rigid enough or
substantial enough to resist that pendulous movement.
It may limjg it slightly, but is wouldn’t entirely over-
come it.
The maximum movement of that container when there
is not any packing in between the container and the jacket
is possibly more than there would be if the packing was
there. I cannot tell in some decimal of an inch. |
60 didn’t ever make any test, only by feeling it and de-
termining that such a movement existed. .No meas-
urement of movement was taken. I could see it, feel it.
I saw and felt the movement. I could see the bottom was
moving relative to the other section. The container was
within the jacket of the jar at the time I made this test.
I tried to explain that the test I made was when the lower ©
section of the outer container was not secured to the
upper section so that the bottom of the inner container
was entirely open and could be readily seen and moved.
There was no insulating material in the jacket or casing,
other than the bond where it was secured at the top, it
was perfectly free. It was not a free body. The charac-
‘ter of the bond by which that container was supported
from the top of that jacket was an organic bond. In the
particular tests which I made the material of the bond
was an indurated organic material of. the type invented
by this same inventor, Mr. Blair, and a co-worker, Mr.
Simonson. I believe it is covered by a patent owned by
The Mantle Lamp Company. I think the so-called Si-
monson & Blair patent.
United States Letters Patent 1,309,967, dated July 15,
1919, granted to Mantle Lamp Company of America as
the assignee of William W. Simonson and Louis V. D.
Blair is the patent just referred to, and it wgs the com-
position covered by this patent and disclosed in this pat-
ent that constituted the bond of the receptacle that
61 I saw this movement in; that character of bond has
been used continuously by The Mantle Lamp Con-
62 pany in its jugs. There has been some difference—
no substantial difference—in the constituency of the
31
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. 35
and that which is used by the Mantle Lamp Company in
its Jug. Originally a certain amount of carbon was in-
cluded with the synthetic gum that Mr. Blair and Simon-
son developed, and there were lead derivatives of that
gum used in some early models, but later practically the
untreated resinous material was used without the car-
bon. The present constituency of the bond which I have
just described, is the present composition that the Mantle
Lamp Company used in its jugs.
' I said I could readily detect the degree of that move-
ment of the container with respect to the part from which
it was suspended. How much movement there was de-
pends upon the force that is exerted on the container, I
found there was a flex in the jacket sufficient to allow
pendulous movement and that pendulous movement in
the bottom of the inner container can be readily seen
and felt. :
Q. Was the top of the jacket to which that container
was then connected supported by anything?
A. The top of the jacket?
Q. Yes, to which the container was connected, was
that top—
A. It was just sitting on a table or on a bench.
Q. What was the exact operation that you performed
to find out what that movement was? Tell us that, will
you?
63 A. I will repeat that. In the manufacture of
these jars, the actual jacket is in several sections or
parts and the simplest way of assembling the inner con-
tainer to the outer jacket—
Q. I am not concerned with that.
A. I am trying to explain.
Q. I am asking you to tell me how you determined
that was supported at the time you made the test—
Mr. Millar: I submit the witness be allowed to answer.
Mr, Cromwell: I want to get this determined.
The Court: I think he can answer. How, if at all,
was the top of the jacket supported at the time yon made
the test?
Mr. Cromwell: That is the idea.
The Witness: It was bonded by this Simonson Blair
material.
Mr. Cromwell: Q. I understand, Mr. Davis, that the
crock or the earthenware receptacle or container was
_ bonded to this metallic part of the jug.
36. Statement of Evidence. 7
A. The upper section.
Q. At the top.
A. Yes, at the top.
Q. But this particular top of the jug was not con-
with the lower part of the jug at that time, was
it
_A. That is right.
And if I understand you further, you had this jug
sitting on a table for supp: rt.
A. Yes. :
. And it was really the support given by the
64 table that sustained the weight of the jug, wasn’t it?
A. It was in an inverted position sitting on the
table, yes.
Q. And supported by the table.
A. Yes.
Now, I ask, if you please, what did you do to de-
termine the character of the movement that you said
you felt; what kind of test did you subject the thing to!
A. If you will hold this in an inverted position—
. Well, was that what you did then? ,
A. —and hold one hand on. the jacket and the other
34 hand on the container -and exert a strain between the
two you can feel the flex of one relative to the other.
Q. You were imposing a manual force there, that isn’t
imposed on the jug or the container when it is in use.
A. I apprehend that swinging this jar and striking
something will induce a force of a similar nature. —
Q. How did that particular test you made that day
approach a test when you are-swinging it and striking
it against some object, how did it approach that? Now,
tell us.
A. I don’t quite understand the question very clearly.
-Q. Well, you say, as a matter af fact, if you hit that
container against an object there wil be a movement of
A. Yes.
65 You didn’t hit that against any object, did you,
that day? | as ee.
A. Ihave hit many of them—
Q. I am talking about the time you say the test was
made. Confine yourself to that.
A. The test I am taking about, the jug was not as
sembled, completely assembled. |
Q. Then, as a matter of fact, if I understand your
<
35
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. 37
position correctly, the only way you determined the rela-
tive movement, or pendulous movement, if you please,
was because you took that jug and you moved the jug
itself, that is the earthenware container with reference
to the metal cap with which it was connected.
A. Yes, that is right.
- Q. Couldn’t you determine the degree of movement
at that time?
A. Possibly, if I had been interested.
Q. Then, you were not interested in determining that.
A. No, other than to know that such a movement
existed.
Q. In other words, all you wanted to do was find
whether or not there was a flex in the metal.
A. That is right.
Q. When you put pressure on the rimless jug—
A. There was a flex, yes.
Now, as a matter of fact, would that compare with
the conditions to which the jug would be subjected when
in the assembled form in its commercial aspect and in
use, tell us\that?
A & ement would be lessened when it is
66 assembled, béCause of the limitation of the move-
ment by the packing matcrial.
Q. And that movement, if the jug was in the assembled
condition you refer to, would be practically infinitesimal.
A. I wouldn’t say that, no, but it would be very slight.
Q. Why do you make that statement, ‘‘You wouldn’t
say that’’? | ,
A. Because there is no way of measuring it.
Q. Then, as a matter.of fact, it is so infinitesimal you
couldn’t find it.
A. You have no way of measuring it after it is as-
sembled. It is a principal of engineering and physics
that any body suspended in a pendulous position and
swung and suddenly stopped, there will be a slight pendu-
lous movement of that body, depending upon the flexi-
bility of its support.
Q. What effect would that pendulous movement of
_that earthenware crock have on the—
A. Why, continuous pendulous movement of a fair de-
gree would tend to weaken and possibly rupture a bonding
material so that it would not be waterproof. It is there-
fore desirable to limit that movement and to retain the
37
Statement of Evidence.
waterproof characteristics of the intervening bond be.
tween the jacket and the container.
Q: How do you limit that movement?
67 A. By this comminuted packing material. ©
Q. But you said a few minutes ago that was not
packed hard enough to do that. How do you reconcile
your answer to that, previous statement?
A. Iam talking of a completed jar when I talked just
a minute ago here.
You are talking about the commercial ‘jar of the
Mantle Lamp Company, aren’t you?
A. Yes.
Q. And in that jar that comminuted material is
packed without any degree of special thickness or density,
isn’t it?
No, it is packed with a certain degree of density.
Is it tamped down?
Yes.
It is tamped down in what way?
Why, men shove it down with their hands.
. And they get it so compact, do they, that the com-
minuted material itself will hold that earthenware crock
from any lateral movement.
A. No, they limit it, but not hold it.
Q. What do you mean by limit it? What is the limi-
tation of the movement? '
A. It isa difficult matter to express the relative move- -
ment.
Q. Mr. Davis, you have qualified as a mechanical en-
gineer. .
A. I have, yes; I ;
Q. And you have béen discussing the plaintiff’s strue-
tures and Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6, which purports to
68 be the defendant’s structure.
A. Yes.
Q. I want to know, if you please, why and how you
have been able to determine any movement whatever in
the jugs in their assembled form. . That is what I am -
asking you about. :
A. T have never determined it in the ascenthteh form,
but I know as an etgineer that it exists.
In Plaintiff’s Exbit 6, the principal path of heat con-
ductivity is through the necks where the two ele-
69 menfs are joined together. That is the outer jacket
and the inner container. If you have a heated liquid
ePorop>
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. 39
in the jug, the entire inner container is at a thermal po-
tential from outside here. We will assume that the ma-
terial or the contents of the container is heated relative
to the atmosphere in which the container is positioned.
If there is a difference in thermal potential between the
two, the forces of neutraiization will work and there
will be a gradual dissipation through every possible out-
let, and because the top of the inner container with a
fall jar is practically as warm as the bottom, at that point
you will always feel the outer container warmer at the
top than you will at the bottom. The tendency of heat is
to rise and you can always put your hands on the top
and it will be much warmer, so the greatest loss will he
where the outer jacket-is the hottest. :
The heat rises and the restricted path of heat is
through the crock up to the neck. of the crock and it passes
through the bond to the metallic neck of the jacket. That
is one path. There would be another path in Plaintiff’s
Exhibit 6. From the entire surface of the inner container
there is a slight heat transfer to.the outer jacket where
it is radiated, but the greater part of the heat is trans-
mitted at the points where they join. That is very clear.
Every time when the inner container is filled with a
70 heated liquid by touching with the hand it is very
easily determined where the greatest heat is, and it
may be safely considered that the greatst loss is at the
point where the outer jacket is the hottest, but other parts
of the outer jacket are warm. Toa small degree the heat
will go directly from the crock through the insulated
filler material through side walls of the metalic jacket.
There is a slight transfer, that is inevitable. Through
the entire“ body of the outer jacket and the neck, thosa
are the only paths of conductivity for heat in Plaintiff’s
Exhibit*6.
The corkage unit might cause a loss of heat. The bot-
tom ef the cork-might become heated and it might be so
made it could transfer heat to the cup cap surrounding
it and therefore waste it, which would be the path that
way. The heat rising comes in contact with the stopper,
being metal, and in contact with the cup, the heat would
transfer from the stopper to the cup and from the cup
then down to the threaded neck of the container with
which the cup is engaged, and it would transfer generally
throughout its structure.
Q. Will you kindly examine Plaintiff’s Exhibit No..1,
Statement of Evidence.
being the copy of the patent in suit, and state whether
or not you find in the specifications of that patent the
word ‘‘pendulous’’?
A. That is difficult for me to read. May I read from
mine?
The Court: Do you want it, or are you asking the
71 witness?
Mr. Cromwell: Yes, I am asking him to point it
eut. ;
__ The Court:* It is in.5 and also in 7.
= Mr. Cromwell: I am asking about the specification
The Witness: It ¥s in 5.
Mr. Cromwell: I am asking if it is in the specifica
tion. ;
A. I haven’t esamined the entire specification,
whether it is there or not, I don’t know. Page 2, line 30
says: ‘This substance is packed witl» spfficient density
_ to prevent violent pendulous movement of the container
occasioned by shock administered from without the re-
ceptacle.’’
Q. Is that the only place where that occurs?
A. No. ,
Q. Where else?
A. In the claims.
Q. I said in the specification.
A. The original question was im the patent
Q. I asked you in the specification.
A. You changéd the question.
Q. No, I did not. I asked specifically in the speg#fi-
cation. .
A. May I have the question read?
The Court: Well, that might give you some satisfac-
tion, but it wont be of much help.
A. I find it in that place.
72 Mr. Cromwell: Q. You don’t, find it in any other
place then, except that point, do you? :
A. Thaven’t as yet, no. That is the only place I have
determined it.
. At the point to which you have called attention,
it says that this substance is packed with sufficient density
to prevent Violent pendulous movement?
A. Yes.
73 In packing we force the comminuted materia’ into
it with our hands so that it is relatively tight, so
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. 41
that it will] afford some protection against the pendulous
movement. That is what is meant by the language there.
The temperatures that are usually found in these jugs
depends on whether hot or cold contents are placed in
them.’
Q. Let’s take the hot. What i is the maximum temper-.
ature of a substance that, you would put in there iff
liquid? ll
A. It would have té be under 212 degrees, as riear
boiling as practical. If you want to keep the contents
for a long period of time, I suppose it should be as hot
as possible when it is introduced
Q. What I ani trying*to bring out is you don’t get
excessively hot temperatures from the contents?’
A. Well, hot is not a definite expression. Idon’t un-
derstand you. As to whether I call 212 degrees, the boil-
ing point, excessively hot temperature, relative to water
it is hot.
Q. IL say excessively hot.
A. Normally hot.
Q. Exeessively hot.
A. I don’t understand your ‘‘excessively hot’’ char-
acterization.
Q. You could have temperature of four or five hun-
dred degrees in some substances?
A. That would not be excessive. Four or five
74 hundred degrees is a low temperature relative to
some objects but with reference to what I pat in
this jug, yes, that is out of the question.
Q. That is excessively hot?
A. It cannot be done.
Q. So, as a matter of fact, when you put contents in
there of 212 degrees you are not putting an excessively
hot temperature in there, are you?
75 A.- As hot as it can be puf in.
Q. I say excessively,
A. Your Honor, ‘to an engineer the words “‘ex-
cessively hot’’ are not understood. ~
The Court: If you can’t understand it, you can’t
answer it.
A. I work with 2000 degrees and 3000.
Mr. Cromwell: Q. What can’t you understand about
the question?
A. If you would refer to specific degrees i in Fahren-
heit, I could answer.
‘42
45
” tht
47
48
Statement of Evidence.
Q. I did. I said 212 degrees.
A. 212 degrees is hot for water.
Q. But not excessively hot for a substance that would
go in that jug.
A. Itis normal. That is what the jug is designed for.
Q. But not excessively hot?
A. No.
Q. That is what I have been trying to get you to ex.
plain. :
The word ‘‘bond”’ in lines 61 to 72, page 1 of the speci-
fications of the Blair patent in suit, means an intervening,
interlocking element which joins two bodies together. In
figure 2 ef the drawing of this Blair patent I believe the
bond is indi¢ated there by numeral 14. This bond is sup-
posed to be a low conductor of heat. The bond is formed
of a similar material that is disclosed and covered in the
Simonson and Blair patent. The material las been
changed. * ~ |
76 In the passage of heat from the conductor, 11, to °
the outside shell, the lip, 6, is almost in contact with
the upper extremity, 13, of the imner container and it is
barely possible that a certain amount of loss develops
at that point because of either direct contact or the very
narrow separation. I have not made any test specifi-
eally for determining that purpose. Of the total joss of
heat of the container, I venture that fully- half of the
total loss of heat exists at the neck of the two, and that
loss would go through/the bond of low conductivity. If
lip, 6, was in direct cortact with the inner container pos-
sibly more would go through that way than would through
the bond. AYhe amount of the bond between the. lip and
the upper neck of the container is re‘atively small. As
compared with the bond itself, I would judge there would
be a greater heat loss there at the lip, under those cir-
cumstanees. I said half would be lost at the neck. I
didn’t specifically state that half would be through the
bond. It would be my opinion that half of it would go |
through the bond, because of the exposed area there,
and possibly another half through the lip, but that would
be a conjecture, a guess on my part. a
77 + With reference to the filler in the jug, Plaintiff's.
Exhibit 6, between the necks, is largely sulphur.
Whether other ingredients have been added to the sul-
phur, I couldn’t state, but I have determined this is sub-
stantially sulphur by burning some of it. The charac
49°
31
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. 43
teristic Sulphur fumes and smell is evident. As to
whether I intend to convey by that expression ‘‘largel
sulphur’’ that there was semething else in it beside sul-
phur, there may be; not to my knowledge. As to whether,
so far as my understanding of, that filler is congerned, it
is only sulphur, I didn® maké a chemical anal¥sis other
than to determine the principal ingredient of the bond
was sulphur. I didn’t say it was sulphur. To detey-
mine whether that was all sulphur a careful chemic
analysis would have to be made. Impurities might exist
with the sulphur. Sulphur is derived from ground, one
of the elements of the universe. It is classified as a
mineral substance.
The material of which the borid of the Mantle Lamp
Company jug is derived is organic, largely the base of it
‘is resin known as shellac. Differences sa-thie two bonds -
could be set up, one. being an organic substance and the
other being inorganic.
In the jug, Plaintiff’s Exhibit 6,. one groove is all I
fad in the neck. The sulphur has penetrated that groove,
interlocked with it and in that respect the sulphur has a
rigid ffxed relation to the neck of the crock.
78 In figure 2 of the drawing of the Blair patent in
suit, there is no groove in the neck of the container,
11 and the bond is shown only in contact with the outer
surface of the neck.
Besides plaster of paris and these synthetic substances
used as bonds, there is a material disclosed by Simon-
son and Blair that is a synthetic material. There are
many other resins. Litharge could be used: as a bond.
‘May I make myself clear on this point? A bond used
between these two jackets becomes a bond when it in-
terlocks. Plaster of paris and sulphur have the tendency
of cleaving from smooth surfaces and on a smooth sur-
face they wouldn’t function as a bond, but when posi-
tioned between threads of the outer jacket and positioned
between inner walls or recesses of the container it in-
terlocks and then functions as a bond. The bond of the
Blair patent has the characteristic of also being a seal:
The purpose is to preclude the entrance of moisture to
the comminuted packing material between the inner con-
tainer and the outer jacket and that entrance would be
very definitely detrimental to the insulated material be-
tween the outer jacket and the inner container. In the
Statement of Evidence.
bond of the Blair patent it is essential to exelude mois.
ture to have a commercial device.
79 If some material other than sawdust were nsed
as insulating, body between the container and the
jacket, the queStfon of whether or not moisture would
be present would affect the insulating qualities of that
material. No moist material is as good an insulator as
a dry material. The reason for that is, that water trans-
fers heat very readily, a very fair conductor of heat. It
is very definitely the aim of this bond of the Blair pat.
ent, not only to tie these parts together at the necky but
also to exclude moisture at that point.
Q. Mr. Blair, is there any difference in the relative
conductivity of the bond that is used in the Blair pat-
ent in suit and the material of the container 11?
A. Are you addressing the question to me?
Q. Yes.
A. You spoke to me as Mr. Blair.
Q. Pardon me, Mr. Davis.
A. The question. 1 didn’t listen to.
(Question read by the reporter).
A. Material where?
Q. Material of the neck 11, the neck. ;
A. I consider. that the organic material is a better
insulator than the sulphur, more desirable as a bond in
that type of device.
Q. “I don’t think you have answered the question, Mr.
Davis. Will you read the question.
(Question read.) .
80 Q. You didn’t get the question, Mr. Davis.
A. Pardon me?
Q. I am asking you as to whether or not there is any
difference in the relative heat conductivity of the bond
of the Blair patent and the material, the earthenware, of
hich the container, 11, is formed? .
The container, 11, is glass, which has-very low heat”
conductivity and the bond, 14, also has a very low heat
conductivity. They would both be considered heat in-
sulators. I have made no tes¢ as to the relative heat con-
ductivity between the glass of this Blair bottle and the
bond, 14. Such tests wouldn’t mean very much, because
there are many types of glass. I know that these two
substances are both relatively poor heat conductors.
have never made tests between these two substances.
In the change that has been made in the bond in the
Testimony of Cortland W. Davis. 45
Mantle Lamp Company jug, between the neck of the
jacket and the neck of the container, there is no physi-
cal difference between that substance and what is set
forth in the Simonson and Blair patent, just a cheaper
bond used. The original bond was rather expensive.
That material is very slightly elastic, yielding, not to
any degree. It does have very small yielding qualities,
‘possibly a slight amount, I never tested it to find the
degree of elasticity.
81] Redirect Examination by Mr. Millar.
Mr. Davis, will You examine the Blair patent andg
tell us whether or not, in your opinion, the patent is lim-
ited to the use of the particular bond described in the
Simonson and Blair patent?
Mr. Cromwell: I think that is a question for the Court
to determine as to the limitations of that patent, not for
. this witness to explain.
The Court: Let him answer. Overruled.
Mr. Millar: You have been examining him about it
all the time.
A. In the claims, the first few claims I have read, I
find no characterization of the bond other than bond ma-
terial, no specific description of the bond as such.
Mr. Davis, will you kindly examine page 2, lane
72, and thereafter, and tell us whether or not after hav-
ing read those few lines, you consider that the Blair pat-
ent is limited to the particular bond described in the
Simonson ani Blair patent?
Mr. Cromwell: I offer the same objection, your
Honor.
‘ The Court. Overruled.
A. In the lines referred to I see the statement that
the bond disclosed is preferably a type fully described _
in United States Letters Patent No. 1,309,967, and
82 that this particular bond is especially useful inas-
much as it may be fused in situ at a temperature
lower than that of glass. As to whether, in view of the
use of the word ‘‘preferably’’ in line 73, I consider his
bond.limited to the Simonson and Blair substance, I in-
terpret those words that the inventor desired to use the
bond disclosed, a type which he considered preferable
for the work.
46
o7
08
59
Statement of Evidence.
Mr. Cromwell: I move to strike out the question ang
the answer as a conclusion. :
Thé Court: Let it stand.
(Recess until 2:00 o’ctock.)
83 PEARL H. BRAINARD, called as witness on be-
half of. Plaintiff, testified as follows:
My name is Pearl H.-Brainard. I live at Monmouth,
Illinois. Am a manufacturer of poultry supplies and
prior to 1920 I was a manufacturer of poultry supplies,
manufacturing poultry fountains and feeders including
chicken waterers. The chicken waterer was made with’
an inner container of steel. The wall between was
packed with shavings to insulate it. .
. With whom were you connected in the year 1920?
A. Well, I just don’t remember the dates.
Mr. Cromwell: If the Court please, may the witness
answer just a little louder?
The Court: Speak a little louder, Mr. Witness.
A. I can’t remember the date at that time, where I
was. At the time I made insulated chicken waterers, I
was connected with the American Steel Products Com-
pany of Monmouth, Illinois.
Q. Did you ever live in Monmouth?
A. I mean Macomb, instead of Monmouth. I was as-
sociated with the Macomb Manufacturing Company. in
the capacity of President. The same Macomb Manv-
facturing Company that was a party fo the suit of The
Mantle Lamp Company vs. the Macomb Manufacturing
Company. In addition to the manufacture of poultry
furniture, the Macomb Manufactuting Company made
insulated jugs. I do not recall when they began to
84 manufacture insulated jugs—not the date. I was
associated with the Macomb Manufacturing Com-
pany when they — to manufacture insulated jugs.
I refer to heat insulated receptacles.
The first heat insulated receptacles manufactured by
the Macomb Manufacturing Company, the inner jacket
was made of earthenware. The interior of the earthen-
ware container was glazed white, had a groov¢ in the
neck, a steel breast was drawn around in this
85 groove and solderd along the edges; the body of
the steel jacket was attached to the breast and 1n-
4
60
61
62
Testimony of Pearl H. Brainard. 47
sulated with cork. It had a stopper, cap and bail. As
to, whether there was any material in contact with the
neck of the container.at.the slot, other than the jacket,
I don’t believe I know what you mean. As to whether
I can draw up a picture of the container or have drawn
up such a picture, I have. I drew this, this morning.
I have marked the breast with the letter ‘‘A’’, the
slot ‘‘B’’ and the container ‘‘C’’. No other material
was disposed between the breast and the container at
the slot. The steel breast was merely contracted into
.a slotted neck.
(Document received as PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT 8.)
I did not testify in the case of The Mantle Lamp Com-
pany of America versus the Macomb Manufacturing
Company, tried in the Federal Court in Springfield, Hli-
nois, nor in the case of the Therm-A-Jug Company and
the Monarch Company versus the Mantle Lamp Com-
pany of America, tried in the United States District
86 Court in Chicago, Illinois. I did testify in the case
of The Mantle Lamp Company of America versus
George H. Bowman Company tried in the Federal Court
‘ in Cleveland. The Macomb Manufacturing Company
manufactured and sold about fifteen hundred heat. in-
sulated receptacles of the type shown in Plaintiff’s Ex-
hibit 8. They continued to manufacture jars as shown
in Exhibit 8 through the summer of the first year they
started, and thereafter continued to manufacture heat
insulated receptacles.
In the heat insulated receptacles manufactured by the
‘Macomb Manutacturing Company, the inner container
was made of earthenware, with a steel jacket. The neck
was extended over the top of the earthenware container.
The neck had a cam-screw shape and there was cement
bond poured in between the steel jacket and the earthen-
ware container. There was insulated cork between the
walls of the container and the jacket. The bond was
plaster paris and Portland cement.
Q. Did the Macomb Manufacturing Company. there-
after make any changes in the construction of the heat
insulated receptacles which they were making?
A. Do you mean after that time?
Q. After the type you have last described.
A. I wasn’t there after that.
48
Statement of Evidence.
Q. You were not there?
87 ms No, I was not connected with the firm after
that.
How effective, or how efficient did the bond made
of Portland cement and plaster of paris prove to be!
A. I don’t believe I can answer that, any more.
You don’t know?
A. It has been so long since.
Q. Can you describe a little more particularly the
neck of the container with reference to any irregularities
that may have appeared on the outside thereof?
A. I don’t believe I know what you mean.
Q. Was it a smooth surface on the outside of the neck
of the container?
A. That was a threaded neck.
How about the neck of the jacket?
A. Well, that is what I mean; it was a threaded neck,
on the jacket. There were irregularities on the neck of
the container. The container had some grooves in it,
one or two, I don’t remember which. Circumferential
grooves running around it.
Tell us the position of the bond with reference to
the necks, and particularly with reference to the screw
threads on those grooves? '
Mr. Cromwell: I object to the leading type of this ex-
amination. You are certainly putting it into his mouth
when you are talking about the construction, as you have
in the last question. ;
88 The Court: Overruled.
A. This cement in liquid form was poured in
around the neck, and formed in the screw on the neck,
and the grooves on the inner container.
As I remember it, I left the Macomb Manufacturing
Company in 1925. I don’t remember how many of the
second heat-insulated receptacles of the type I have last
described were manufactured and sold by the Macomb
Manufacturing Company up until the time I left. I don’t
believe I do have any idea on the subject, unless the sec-
ond year, the second year there were probably 50,000
made. Beyond that, I don‘t remember. Probably 50,000
the second year. As to how efficient I found this second
type of heat insulated reeeptacle to be, as compared
with the first one, if you mean how long it would hold the
Testimony of Pearl H. Brainard. 49
temperature, from memory I just don’t know. You know
it has been so long ago.
Q. Can you tell why the manufacture and sale of the
first type, the type found in Plaintiff’s Exhibit 8, was
discontinued ?
A. It would not hold the heat as long as the second
type.
R9 Cross-Examination by Mr. Cromwell.
At this time I was engaged in the business of manu-
facturing poultry supplies. I aim located at Monmouth,
Illinois. I am manufacturing as a company, as an IIli-
nois corporation. The name of my company is Vac
Manufacturing Company.
As to how long I have been engaged in the manufac-
ture of the poultry supplies down there, [I started in
Macomb in 1907. Referring to Monmouth, I think I
moved there in 1925 from Macomb and started at that
time.
I was President of the Macomb Manufacturing Com-
pany. I don’t remember how long I was president. As
president of the Macomb Manufacturing Company I was,
at that time, acquainted with the employees.
As to who it was that made these jugs that I say wére
made as the first jugs, I designed the jug. I did not make
the jug. The workmen helped me. I don’t remember
who the workmen were who did that. That is so long
ago. I don’t remember what year it was when these jugs
were first made.
Q. Didn't you testify in that Bowman case that it was
in 1921.
A. I don’t remember that. As I remember, it was
1920, but I am not sure, I can’t just recall.
Q. In your examination in the Bowman case you
90 were asked this question:
**Q. When, if you know, did the Macomb Manu-
facturing Company start the manufacture of heat insu-
lated receptacles of the non-vacuum type?’’
and your answer was:
*“*A. 1921, I think.’’
Was that a correct statement?
A. I don’t know now. I just don’t remember that
date. It has been several years ago.
~ 50 Statement of Evidence.
Q. Didn’t you know at the time you gave this testi.
mony?
A: I expect I looked at the records.
Q. That 1921 was the date that you testified to?
A. I expect I looked up records, but I have forgotten
about that.
Q. How many workmen were employed at the Ma-
comb Manufacturing Company 4n making these jugs in®
1921?
A. I don’t remember.
Q. Were you not acquainted, as President of that
company, with working conditions and the force down
there?
t time, but it has been so long ago I
have forgotten about that, how many men were there.
Q. What circumstande caused you to testify in the
Bowman case?
A. You mean why did I testify?
91 Q. Yes. .
A. Mr. Johnson asked me fo testify.
68 Q. And what did Mr. Johnson say to you when he
asked you to testify in the Bowman case.
A. That—I don’t remember anything in particular.
Q. You don’t remember any of the conversation at
all?
A. No, sir. :
Q. Have you any understanding with the Mantle
Lamp Company that you will get a license to manufac-
ture under this patent if it is sustained?
A. No, sir.
Q. This Blair patent?
A. No, sir.
Q. Was any consideration paid to you for testifying
in that Bowman case?
A. Expenses.
. Where was that testimony taken?
A. Cleveland, Ohio.
Q. And you went from Monmouth to Cleveland to
testify?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. No inducement was held out to you by the Mantle
Lamp Company for that testimony?
A. No, sir.
70
Testimony of Pearl H. Brainard. ol
Q. What caused your separation from the Macomb—
. Manufacturing Company?
A. Well, I don’t know exactly what it was.
(). Were you not asked to resign by your Beard of
Directors?
92 A. I think I was froze out of the company, yes.
Q. Whrat do you mean by that?
A. I was voted out.
Q. And What was the circumstance by which you were
voted out, da you’ k&w.
A. No, sir. They wanted to get the royalty, I think,
as near as I found out.
What royalty do you refer to?
A. I was getting a royalty on a patent on the jug
at that time, and they wanted it; either that or to elimi-
nate the royalty, I don’t know which. ~
Q. You mean they were manufacturing a jug under
some patent or patents, of yours?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you were being paid a royalty for it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And they wanted to get you out, so they would
aa that royalty, is that it?
A. I thmk so.
_Q. Did you have any contract with them as to the
payment of that royalty?
I did. |
Was that contract in writing?
Yes, sir.
How long did that contract continue?
I don’t remember, any more.
When did it begin?
I don’t remember that date. The date, when we
started to make them.
Q. I callgyour attention to United States Letters
93 Patent 1,489,059, dated April 21, 1924, to Pearl H.
Brainard, of Macomb, Illinois. Please examine that
patent, and say whether or not you are the Pearl H.
Brainard to whom that patent was granted.
Mr. Millar: If you Honor please, I object to that,
unless it is going to be marked for identification, or of-
fered in evidence.
Mr. Cromwell: I wil! come to that in due time.
Mr. Millar: -That is my objection.
E pOPOPOp>
Statement of Evidence. |
Mr. Cromwell: He spoke about manufacturing these
jugs, your Honor, and he has made a sketch, and this
is for comparative purposes.
Mr. Millar: I will withdraw my objection.
The Witness: A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Cromwell: Q Was that the patent, or one of the
patents which you had the license af*ement under?
A. That is one of them.
Q. I will call your attention to United States Letters
Patent 1,477,101, dated December 11,_1923, and granted
to Pearl H. Brainard, of Macomb, Illinois. Please ex
amine that patent, and state whether or not you recag
nize that patent.
A. Yes, sir.
~Q. Are yon the Pearl H. Brainard to whom that pat-
ent was granted?
A. Yes.
Q. And did this patent figure in that license agree-
ment also?
A. Yes, sir.
94 Q. Now, was the construction disclosed in Patent
1,477,101, the one that succeeded the construction
disclosed in patent 14890597
I think that is shown for the mode of assembling.
_ Now, will you look at Plaintiff's Exhibit 8, and
the drawings of Patent 1,489,059, and compare the two
structures there; and I ask you whether there are any
differences.
- A. I did not draw the handle, is all. It shows the
grooves. That is what I was trying to draw.
Q. Then,.barring the handle, or the bail of the jug,
the manner in which the top of the shell is connected to
the earthenware crock is the same in the sketch marked
Plaintiff’s E€hibit 8 as in Patent, 1,489,059?
A. As near as I could draw it, yes.
Q. Were there any constructions made by you be-
tween the time that the construction of this sketch marked
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 8 was produced, and the structure of
this Patent 14890597
A. You mean beween these two? (Indicating).
A. Let’s see. You mean this one? (indicating). .
Q. Yes.
A. Yes, sir. This was the later one.
Q. Yes.
A.
Q
Testimony of Pearl H. Brainard.,
Q. Yes.
A. I don’t remember that.
Q. Did you change the structure at all?
A
e
Not until it was changed from this to the other
Q. Changed from what to what?
95 A. To this type (Indicating).
Q. That is the one in Patent No. 1477101?
A. Yes.-> ;
So what you did was just to préguce this which was
shown in Patent 1489059, and then, without any change
in any other structure at all, or producing any other
structure, you went over to what is shown in Patent
1477101, is that right?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, what was the occasion, Mr. Brainard, of
changing over to this form of jug that is shown in Patent
No. 1477101?
A. Well, this was sort of hand-made, and it was
changed over to this one here, because we could stamp
that out, and get a bond in here (indicating). This ather,
we had no way of doing this by hand.
Q. What were your duties as president of the Macomb
Manufacturing Company?
A. I operated the plant in those days. We didn’t
have many workmen.
Q. Didn’t you, as a matter of fact, conduct the sales
policies of the Macomb Manufacturing Company?
A. I conducted the sales, yes.
Q. Weren’t you on the road a great deal in pursuance
of that?
A. Some of the time; part of the time I was in the
factory.
Q. And when you were on the road, did you find any in-
stances of other jugs of this type that were being put
96 out by other manufacturers?
A. You mean of this first type?
Q. After the first type was developed.
A. The second?
Q. Yes.
A. I think there were some on the market, but I just
can’t recall much about that now. I think théy all came
out about the same time, as I remember it.
‘Q. Didn’t you go back to your factory, as a matter
—=—— | yer ee we
74
Statement of Evidence.
of fact, and tell your employes that they had to have a
better jug than the one shown in your first patent?
A. =No, sir. I wouldn’t tell them. I would get it out
myself.
Q. You wouldn’t tell your employees about it?
A. No; we very probably didn’t have many to tell in
those days.
Q. Did you have anyone to assist you in designing
that particular jug that is shown in that second patent!
A. No, sir.
Q. Yon did that all by yourself?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Who made the dies for the production of these
jugs? :
A. The Swayn Manufacturing Company, of St. Louis.
Q. Did the Swayn representative ever come up to
your plant in connection with the production of these
jugs and talk with you about them?
97 A. I don’t remember that.
Q. You don’t remember any trip at all?
A. I just don’t remember, unless it was some repairs,
or something; that I cannot answer. .
Q. I think you said you made fifteen hundred of the .
jugs shown in that first patent, or as shown in the sketch,
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 8, is that correct?
A. As uear as I can remember, yes. .
Q. Over what period of time were those fifteen hun-
dred made? .
A. That was in the spring and summer of the first -
year of manufacturing, the summer season.
Q. And then did you continue the manufacture of
that jug?
A. Yes.
Q. What did you make in 1922?
A. I just don’t know the dates, but the second jug
was this Patent No. 1477101, that was the second jug.
Q. That was the second jug?
A. Yes.
. Now, isn’t it a fact that you made more than fif-
teen hundred of those first jugs?
A.” I just can’t tell exactly. That was just my guess,
it has been so long ago, I have no records.
Q. Did + ou have any trade-name for those jugs when
you first put them on the market?
~
on
Testimony of Pearl H. Brainard. 55
A. Well, I don’t know whether it was-on the first
ones.
Q. Any trade-mark?
98 A. Yes, we had a trade-name, but I don’t know
whether it was on the first ones or not.
Q. What did you call them?
A. ‘‘Little Brown Jug.”’
Q. Were the first jugs you produced called that by
that name?
A. I don’t think the first ones were, no. There were
some made; how many, I don’t know.
Q. Did you make any of the ‘‘Little Brown Jugs,’’
such as shown in that first patent, in 1923?
A. I rather thing that we commenced the name of that
in the middle of the season sometime.
Q. No, I am asking you whether or not you made jugs
like shown in the first patent there, and,. likewise, as
shown in this sketch, Plaintiff’s Exhibit 8, in the year
19237
A. We only made them the first year, and I just don’t
remember the first year we started.
Q. Then, as I understand it, you made the fifteen
- hundred jugs in the year 1921; and in 1922 and 1923,
you did not make any more of that type of jug?
A. We made it the first year, we made this type here
(indicating).
Q. That is, on the first patent?
A. Whatever date that was. Then we never made it
after that.
Q. You never made any more of those afterwards?
A. No.
Q. I think you said you had difficulty in anchoring,
or making fast the top of the jug, that is, the metal
container, the metal jacket, in the groove in the
99 neck of the earthenware crock or container. What
was the reason for that?
A. It had to be put in there by hand.
Q. What was the form of the cement that you put in?
Was it the Portland cement you referred to? I think
you said that.
A. The first ones we made, we did not cement, we
filed up around the top of the breast, because the jug
was rough around there. We didn’t commence to cement
until the second year.
56
—_— sn
Ladin
Statement of Evidence...
Q. Did you change the form of that joint at all?
A. The second year? Oh, yes, we changed the mate.
rial.
Q. I mean, with respect to this first jug that you made
in 1921.
A. Well, the second jug was nothing like it.
Q. I am talking about the jug you made in 192,
which you said was the first jug you made.
A. Well, I don’t remember the date. The first jug we
miade had no bond, only just the cement around the.top,
of the breast, to cover up the roughness of the jug.
Q. You said you had difficulty in making that hold
fast, didn’t you?
A. Yes, that’s right, we did. !
Q. Did you make any other change at that point in
that particular jug? .
A. No.
Q. To make that joint fast?
100 <A. No, we didn’t. We might have changed in the
kind of cement used, I don’t remember about that,
whether it was Portland cement or not.
Q. But you did not change the point of application
of the cement at all, did you?
A. Not that year, not the first year.
Did you do it in the second year?
A. We made a new type of jug.
Q. Yes, that’s what I thought.
A. Yes.
_ I believe you said you had fifty thousand jugs alto-
gether. What did those fifty thousand jugs include?
A. Well, I estimated it; I don’t know whether that is
the exact amgunt, but as near as I can remember, the
second year we made fifty thousand.
Q. The second year?
A, Yes.
. That was the year 1922?
A. That I don’t remember, the date. It was the sec-
ond year of manufacture.
Q. Whik you were president of the Macomb Manufac-
turing Company, did you sell out to Hemp & Company?
A. No. That was after I left there.
Hemp & Company acquired the business of the
Macomb Manufacturing Company, didn’t they?
A. Yes, they have, so I heard.
Testimony of Pearl H. Brainard. 57
Mr. Millar: I object, if your Honor please. Not cross-
examination.
101 The Witness: A. (Continuing) That ‘is only
what I hear. It is hearsay. They are operating it,
as I understand it, now.
The Court: What is the objection?
Mr. Millar: Who they sold out to is not material here;
and even if it were material, that is not a proper way to
prove it.
Mr. Cromwell: I am endeavoring to establish the
status of this witness. I think I have a right to test this
man’s credibility, and so on. ‘
The Court: Let him answer.
Mr. Cromwell: Q. What was the answer?
(Answer read by the reporter)
Mr. Cromwell: Q. I was talking about the time that
you were with the Macomb Manufacturing Company.
A. Pardon me.
Q. You left before they went out of business, is that
it? ~
A. y&. sir.
Q. I wish you would explain just a little more fully
the conditions under which you testified in the Bowman
case, and how you were asked to give that testimony.
A. I just don’t remember how that was any more.
Mr. Johnson asked me if I would go down to Cleveland
and testify, that’s all I remember. .I used to manufac-
ture jugs. That’s all I recall any more. There was
nothing in particular that I know of.
Q. You mean Mr. Victor Johnson sitting here, this
gentleman?
102 A. Yes.
Q. He asked you, did he?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you went down and testified?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What did Mr. Johnson say to you about the facts
of this development of yours? Did he say anything?
A. Not that I remember of, anything in particular
now.
Did he ask you, as a matter of fact, whether or not
your jug was giving satisfaction?
A. No, sir, I don’t think so; I don’t think that he did.
Q. Did he ask you anything about changing over to
94
95
Statement of Evidence.
the type of jugs shown in the second patent that I showed
you?
_ A. No, sir.
Q. Just ordinarily approached you, without any sng.
gestion at all of what he wanted to ask you, or what you
would testify about?
A. I remember nothing in particular he asked me any
more.
Q. You did not indicate anything until you got on the
stand down there, did you?
A. Not that I remember. .
Q. As to what your developments were in jug Making,
and the sales of those jugs? |
A. Not that I remember of.
Mr. Cromwell: That is all, your Honor.
103 I did not testify in the case of The Mantle Lamp
Company versus the Macomb Manufacturing Com-
pany, tried in the Federal Court in Springfield, Illinois.
I did not testify in the case of the Therm-A-Jug Com-
pany and the Monarch Company versus The Mantle
Lamp Company, tried in the District Court in Chicago,
Illinois.
I did testify in the case of The Mantle Lamp Company
of America versus George H. Bowman Company, tried
in the Federal Court at Cleveland, Ohio.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Cromwell.
My present business is life insurance. I am not a prac: _
tical glass worker. I tried to make bottles myself. I
did not suéeceed. You know you experiment around a
factory, you like to do the work. IJ depended upon the
skilled glass worker to make the bottles when I was with
the Icy Hot Company.
Thermos bottles, so-called, are being sold today. Those
Thermos bottles, consist of the interior receptacle formed
of the double wall evacuated bottle, within the metal con-
tainer. / .
The Icy Hot Bottle Company went out of business the
latter part of 1924; There was a merger effected between
ourselves and the American Thermos Bottle Company,
and I retained my interest and became vice-president of
the American Thermos Bottle Company.
Testimony of Pearl H. Brainard. 59
104 Redirect Examination by Mr. Millar.
I can’t tell exactly for how long a period I have known
Victor S. Johnson. For a number of years. May be
ten years. I knew him prior to the time he asked me to
come to Cleveland and testify. I don’t remember for
how long a time prior to that, several years. I don’t
know exactly. As-to whether I had relations, business
relations with “him, just meeting him is all. I knew him
as a competitor. I happened to be here to testify today
because Mr. Johnson asked me. He called me up and
asked me to come here and testify.
Before I testified in Cleveland I think I did talk to
you about it but I don’t remember the conversation and
I talked to you today about it.
My attention being directed to the two patents to which
Counsel has called my attention and being asked to exam-
ine the one numbered 1,489,059, with particular refer-
ence to the daté the application was filed, that filing date
is December 29, 1921 and looking at the other one num-
bered 1,477,101, that is a smaller number than the other
number. The filing date on the one with the smaller num-
ber, is January 25, 1923. Yes, the patent with the larger
' number was filed before that one with the smaller num-
81
ber. One was filed in 1921 and one in 1923.
Q. Which of those has the smaller number? ©
105 <A. 1921. |
Q. No, the number of the patent up here in the
right-hand corner.
Mr. Cromwell: I submit, your Honor, the patents
speak for themselves in that respect.
Mr. Millar: All right.
The Court: Sustained.
Mr. Millar: That is true. It does speak for itself.
The Witness: 1923 has the smallest patent number.
Mr. Millar: All right. Now, on examination of those
_ two filing dates, does that refresh your recollection with
respect to the dates you began the manufacture of heat
insulated receptacles of any kind?.
A. I don’t know whether it .was filed the same year
we started to manufacture them, or the next year.
’ It was about that time, but I don’t remember the dates.
My attention being called to Patent 1,489,059 that was
my idea of what an efficient heat-insulated receptacle
would be on the date I filed my application. ©
83
Statement of Evidence.
My attention being dirgcted to Patent 1,477,101, that
was my idea on January 25, 1923, of what an efficient
heat insulated receptacle shorld be.
106 FRANK C. TERRY, a witness called on behalf of
( .e plaintiff, testified as follows:
My name is Frank C. Terry. I live in Cincinnati, Ohio.
Right now I am in the insurance business; have been
about a year and a half. Prior to that time I was a
manufacturer of-vacuum bottles. Have been engaged in
the manufacture of vacuum bottles since the spring of
1908, up until about two years and a half ago. During
that time I was associated with The Icy Hot Bottle Com-
pany, the American Thermos Bottle Company, and the
Keapsit Bottle Company. Vacuum bottles were first
placed on sale in America in 1906. Had no connection
with any vacuum bottle manufacturer in 1906. In 1908
I was associated with The Icy Hot. Botile Company of
Cincinnati. I knew George P. Altenberg, president and
founder of the Iey Hot Bottle Company.
The vacuum bottle manufactured by the Iey Hot Bottle
Company in 1908, was a glass bottle blown into another
glass bottle and welded at the neck. Then a bottom was
formed by heating the outer glass bottle, and forming a
bottom. A hole was left in the outer bottle, so that it
could be attached to a vacuum pump; the air was pumped
out of the space between the two glass walls. That was
what was known as the filler. After the vacuum was
pumped out, @he glass filler was then inserted “into a
metal outer container. At that time, we anchored
107 the glass filler at the neck by cementing it with this
white substance, plaster of paris. At the bottom,
there was a fiber pad to rest the filler on. The glass was
welded at the neck. That was accomplished by putting it
onto the fire, and forming the neck, and when the glass
was soft, naturally it would weld together. The cylin-
ders out of which the outer and inner glass containers
are made in a vacuum bottle are called pistons. —
couldn’t tell you exactly how thick is the glass of which
the pistons is made, but it is very thin glass, much
thinner than any common table-ware, or even high grade
table-ware.
oD
yu
~Testimony of Frank C. Terry. 61
The George P. Altenberg, to whom United States Let-
ters Patent No. 900075 were issued, dated October 6, 1908,
is the same George P. Altenberg with whom I was asso-
ciated in business.
That patent describes the vacuum bottles manufactured
by the Iey Hot Bottle Company in 1908 and thereafter.
The experience of the Icey Hot Bottle Company, with
reference to plaster of paris around the neck of the
vacuum bottle, between the outer wall and the metallic
easing, was very unfortunate. Plaster of paris would
not adhere readily to the glass or the metal; it would
crumble, causing the filler to drop down into that felt
pad, where it rested. Then, when anybody poured
108 water into the bottle, to use the bottle, or when they
would immerse it into water, to wash it, the water
would seep down between the glass filler and the outer
metal casing, and it. would create a terrible odor.
On the outside neck of the outer piston, there was’ no
groove or corrugation in the glass. The complete filler
in a vacuum bottle, of a pint, was around eight ounces.
The Icy Hot Bottle Company continued to manufac-
ture vacuum bottles of the type just described, up to
about 1911. They then changed their type of vacuum
bottles. We eliminated the ‘plaster of paris at the neck
and made the outer metal cases with a removable bottom.
Then we inserted the glass filler through the bottom,
placed a rf ber ring at the neck of the glass filler, pushed
it up and kept it in place by a tripod metal spring at the
bottom, consequently, when you pvt the bottom of the
outer metal case onto the outer metal case, the spring
would hold the filler tight up against that rubber gasket
at the neck. The Icy Hot Bottle Company continued to
make vacuum bottles of the type I have last described
up to 1924..
In the year 1917 or 1918 experiménts were made by the
Icy Hot Bottle Company in an effort to produce a
199 large size vacuum bottle. We were very anxious to
produce a vacuum container of one gallon or more,
principally because we wanted the Government to adopt.
them for army use; we had some glass pistons made of
the larger sizes and started to experiment in the making
of a large glass vacuum “filler. We found that the glass
blowers, then men in our factory who would heat the
glass and shape it the way we wanted it, every time they
wy = Vn. oO PY ea
87
89
90
Statement of Evidence.
drew the bottom of the outer glass piston, they would
get it down so thin that the thing would collapse in their
hands, just like egg shells. We continued those experi.
ments for some time and found that we could not make a
commercially satisfactory vacuum container of one gal- |
lon capacity, so we never even submitted the samples to
the Government. We did not conduct any other experi-
ments at that. time, endeavoring to make a larger insv-
lated receptacle. We had that in mind. There were a
lot of experiments, all with the view of making a gallon
or larger size container.
The type of jars or vacuum bottle that had been sold
by the Icy Hot Bottle Company prior to 1920, for picnic
use, was the quart size bottle. We pushed that particu.
lar size bottle for picnics and automobile’ outings.
The sale of the quart bottle, in 1921, started to go
down. I first saw a heat insulated receptacle of non-
vacuum type the latter part of 1920. I bought it for
11 the factory. -It was the Aladdin Jug, made by The
Mantle Lamp Company of Chicago. We took it up
to our experimental room and tore it apart.’ We wanted
to see what they had, whether we could go into making
a similar jug, because they were poaching on our sales.
Thereafter the Icey Hot Bottle Company made a heat
insulated receptacle of the non-vacuum type.
We tore apart the Aladdin Jug, saw what they had
put in that space between the two containers and de-
cided to go right ahead and make one similar to it: The
difference was that we made the non-vacuum gallon jug
similar to the Icey Hot Bottle; we took the inner con-
tainer, put a heavy rubber ring around the neck, and then
pushed that up and rested the inner container on a metal
tripod spring which rested on the bottom of the outer
container. ,
Between the walls of the container and the jacket we
used several kinds of material, but finally decided on
chipped cork, or ground cork. There was nothing else
around the neck of the bottle, except that rubber ring.
This jar would keep contents hot or cold between four
and five hours. :
The Aladdin Thermalware Jar manufactured by the
Mantle Lamp Company of America with reference to its
efficiency as a heat insulator, compared with that of the
jar manufactured by the Icy Hot Bottle Company, 12
a ed ed
91
Testimony of Frank C. Terry. 63
actual test, kept things hot or cold between seven and
eight hours.
111 Iused the Aladdin Jug, a heat insulated receptacle
of the non-vacuum type, for my own personal use
in my own automobile.
The Icy Hot Bottle Company continued the mannfac-
ture and sale of the heat insulated non-vacuum vessel I
have just described for about three and a half years.
They are not now manufacturing them. They did not
discontinue to manufacture them while I was still with
them. They continyed to make these jugs after the
merger of the Icy Hot Bottle Company with the Amer-
ican -Thermos Bottle Company, the latter part of 1924.
In the manufacture of making a.vacuum bottle filler
there are two glass pistons required, like a water glass
without a bottom; a eylinder. One is larger than the
other. The smaller one is inserted into the larger one.
The operator holds the piston in one hand, puts it over a
gas fire, until it becomes soft. He shapes it with his little
tool that he has, welds the two pistons together at the
neck. He then turns it around, heats the bottom of the
outer piston, shapes that into a round bottom, leaving a
small hole and a glass tube is inserted then, so that the
glass tube can then be attached to the vacuum pump
and the air pumped out of the base between the two
pistons. During this process of manufacture, he rotates —
the two pistons between his hands, while they are in the
fire.
112 The percentage of breakage in the vacuum bottles
of the pint size, small size, would probably run
around eight or ten per cent. That is only in the precess
with the glass blowers. That does not count the break-
age in the pumping of it with pumps. Tt percentage
of loss in drawing the vacuum would run ‘gine three
per cent.
The percentage of loss in the manufacture of the
vacuum bottle fillers, including the loss in drawing the
vacuum, of a quart size bottle, up to the pumping opera-
tion, would run around twelve or fourteen per cent and
about 24 or three per cent on the pumps.
We made larger vacuum bottles than one quart, we
found the breakage on the larger size to run up as high
as forty and fifty per cent and more. The gallon bottles
93 are the ones I am speaking about. In the manufacture
eet De a ae cc A ent ee
94
96
Statement of Evidence.
of the larger size vacuum bottles, when the glass is in
the fire, with a larger container like that, he has the flame
working in one spot on that glass, when he turns it
around and starts heating the other part of the glass,
the part that he has already heated starts to cool off and
cracks. When the glass is drawn by the glass blower,
naturally he pulls more glass on a large container and
makes the wall of the container that much thinner; it is
as thin, almost, as an egg shell. I consider a vacuum
bottle a very frail article.
113. I did not testify in the case of The Mantle Lamp.
Company versus the Macomb Manufacturing Com-
pany, tried in the’ Federal Court in Springfield, Illinois.
I did not testify in the case of the Therm-A-Jug Com-
pany and the Monarch Company versus The Mantle Lamp
Company, tried in the District Court in Chicago, Illinois.
I did testify in the case of The Mantle Lamp Company
of- America versus George H. Bowman Cortpany, tried
in the Federal Court at. Cleveland, Ohio.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Cromwell.
My present business is life insurance. I am not a
practical glass worker. I depended upon the skilled
glass worker to make the bottles when I was with the ley
Hot Company.
* Thermos bottles, so-called, are being sold today. Those
Thermos bottles, consist of the interior receptacle formed
of the double wall evacuated bottle, within the metal con-
tainert,
The Iey Hot Bottle Company went out of business the
latter part of 1924; there was a merger affected between
ourselves and the American Thermos Bottle Company,
and I retained my interest and became vice-president of
the American Thermos Bottle Company.
114 We tried to make these large thermos bottles, or
vacuum bottles in the gallon size and did not suc-
ceed. We ther turned our attention to the making of
these non-vac jugs. We made some of those and sold
them. We continued to make those about three and a
half years. I should say we made around 150 to 200,000
altogether. |
I did not say on my direct examination that I made
about thirty-five hundred, not that I remember. That
97
98
Testimony of Frank C. Terry. &
might have been the first year when we started, but I
know we went into production later on and made them
by the carload. That was the bottle, or the jug, that
had tripod support for the inner container, and that was
the jug also in which there was a rubber gasket about the
mouth of the earthenware container, formed the joint at
the top with the metal outside casing.
That was the type we continued to sell and we made
a hundred thousand or 150,000, approximately. That
construction was not changed at all, not in that particu-
lar, so that throughout the manufacture and sale of these
hundred or 150,000 non-vacuum jugs we had that inner
container supported at the bottom by this tripod with a
rubber gasket around the neck of the earthenware vessel.
I do not recall that we were notified of infringe-
115 ment by The Mantle Company of America of their
patent when we are manufacturing these non-vacuum
jugs. As far as I remember, we continued to manufac-
ture them unmolested by The Mantle Lamp Company dur-
ing the period of their manufacture.
‘Everything I have said about the construction of this
non-vacuum bottle or jug I have testified from memory.
I have no records with me, no drawings before me, not
even one of the bottles before me. I have one of those
bottles today like I made. There must be one around the
house somewhere. I don’t know whether I have one. I
suppose if it is necessary I could pick one up, because we
sold some right here in Chicago.
In the Icey Hot Bottle Company we had a manufactur-
ing end of it, and a sales organization and an engineer-
ing organization. We employed about 350 to 400 people
in the factory, about sixty in the office and we had about
thirty salesmen. We had one engineer, Lindahl, who
was chief of our experimental department and he had
three assistants, draftsmen and technical men, who would
be given a problem to solve and whip into shape. Lin-
dahl was killed, Walsh is @ive, but I have lost track of
him, and another one, whose name I[ cannot recall right
now. I have the list at home. I suppose if necessary I
could get you those names. Counsel for the Mantle Lamp
Company of America have not asked me to produce one
- these non-vacuum jugs that were manufactured back
there.
Mr. Johnson contacted me in connection with my testi-
66
99
101
Statement of Evidence.
mony in this case. I have known Mr. Johnson for a
116 number of years Originally, when he asked me to
testify in Cleveland he said, ‘* Well now listen, Terry,
you have been in the vacuum bottle game, you are a pio.
neer in this country, one of the first ones in this country.
You know all about that, you know all about your jug.
I have a suit on up to Cleveland. Can you run up to
Cleveland.’’ I said ‘‘Sure.’’ So I jumped up there on
the train, got there one morning about half past eigit.
At ten o’clock we were in Court, stayed there one day
and then I went back to Cincinnati. ;
In this particular instance I received a letter from him
and he asked me to get in touch with him by ’phone. |
called him and asked him what was on his mind. and he
said ‘‘I have got another one of those suits on.”’ “If
you have got nothing special on, can you come up for it
to Chicago when you are needed.’’ I said ‘‘Yes.’’ Last
Saturday I got a telegram from Mr. Millar, at Cincin-
nati, telling me that this suit would be on Tuesday and if
possible to get here. I got here yesterday around noon
and here I am.
I got out of the vacuum bottle business the beginning
of 1930. I had been associated then with the Keapsit
Bottle Company, that was my own company. I did not
go into the making of jugs or larger containers. Just spe-
cialized on pints and quarts and lunch kits.
-117 BERT S. PRESBA, called as a witness on behalf of
plaintiff, testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Millar.
My name is Bert S. Presba. I live at 1010 Maple Ave-
nue, Evanston, Illinois. {am Vice-President of The Man-
tle Lamp Company of America. I have been an officer
of The Mantle Lamp Company for twenty-one years. For
the past fifteen years I have been director of advertising
and sales for The Mantle Lamp Company. I am familiar
with the articles manufactured and sold by The Mantle
Lamp Company during that time. I am familiar with
the heat insulated receptacles manufactured and sold by
The Mantle Lamp Company of America.
I recognize both of the receptacles held in your hand.
102
103
104
Testimony of Bert S. Presba. 67
‘They are both Aladdin Jars, manufactured by the Alad-
din Industries, the associate company: of The Mantle
Lamp Company of America.
Considerable advertising has been done by The Mantle
Lamp Company featuring these Aladdin Thermalware
Jars, over a period of fourteen years. Some-of the me-
diums. in which advertising appeared are th Saturday
Evening Post, Liberty Magazine, Ladies’ Home Journal,
Women’s Home Companion, Good Housekeeping, Na-
ture Magazine, and various outdoor publications, such as
Field & Stream, Sportsmen’s Magazine, Outdoor
118 Life, and various trade papers, such as Sporting
Goods Journal, Good Hardware, and three or four
othets, I don’t just recall the names of.
During the last fourteen years Aladdin Thermalware
Jars have been advertised and sold continuously, during
certain seasons of the year. Not every month of the
year, but each year continuously since 1920.
I know of my own knowledge approximately the amount
of sales of Aladdin Thermalware Jars, about $2,400,-
000.00. The amount spent in advertising these jars in
the various publications and other mediums I have men-
tioned amounts to a little over $300,000.00. Other media
of advertising used besides magazines and papers was
radio advertising. It was done each season for the last
five years, from probably twenty-five or thirty radio sta-
tions, averaging once a week from about October until
February from each of those stations. Some of the bet-
ter known stations from which such advertising was done
are W.L.W. Cincinnati; K.D.K.A. Pittebyrgh; W-.H.O.
Des Moines; W.L.S. Chicago. — ;
(Plaintiff’s Exhibits 9, 10, and 11 for identification, so
marked.) | .
I have heretofore seen Plaintiff’s Exhibit 9 for identi-
fication. I first saw it about April 1924. That is the type
of trade paper advertising we have been doing. It ap-
119 peared in the Sporting Goods Dealer, shown on the
heading of this reproduction, but it also appeared in
three or four trade papers, such as Sporting Goods, Good
Hardware and Drug Magazine, as I recall it.
I have heretofore seen Plaintiff’s Exhibit 10 for iden-
tification: That appeared in Hardware Age, April 1924,
I hve heretofore seen Plaintiff’s Exhibit 11 for identi-
fication. That is a broadside sent out to about 100,000
68
105
106
107
108
109 °
Statement of Evidence.
dealers, both drug and hardware, in which we make an
announcement of the advertising that we are doing in
consumer magazines and present our sales’ program. |
mean by ‘‘broadside’’ a circular of advertising matter.
(PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBITS. 9, 10, AND 11 offered
and received in evidence and were marked Plaintiff's Ex.
hibits 9, 10 and 11.)
Cross-Examination by Mr. Cromwell.
I said we spent about $300,000.00 in advertising and
also that we have used about thirty radio stations. The
cost to bradcast over these radio stations depends upon
how much time you use. I haven’t the slightest idea
what the particular announcement that we used in this
ease cost. K.D.K.A. in Pittsburgh is one of several
120 large broadcasting stations in the country, and the
cost of broadcasting over that station is a pretty
heavy item. I don’t know how much we paid K.D.K.A.
for advertising Aladdin Jars because we tie up several
articles in the same broadcast, Kerosene Mantle Lamp,
Aladdin Electrical Lamp, Aladdin Vacuum Bottles.
The item of $300,000.00 is distributable to the item of
advertising our Aladdin jugs as nearly as it is possible
to distribute it. $309,00.00 was the figure. To divide the
proportion of that amount that went to the advertising
of our jugs as against the other items in all the maga-
zines is easy, but about the radio is very difficult. The
broadcasting was directed to all of our products, on about
thirty stations. This broadcasting was done over a pe-
riod of the last five years. We did not use all thirty sta-
tions at one time. We might be using eighty at one time
and might be using a half dozen at another time. I don’t
know what the fact is as to whether we used eight or six,
or whatever the number was, at one time. I just told
you we used eighty sometimes and six at other times.
I am in charge of the advertising account. Am director
of advertising. It all comes under my control. I can’t
tell, except in that way, what proportion of that amount
went to this advertising. .The accounting department
could tell what proportion we distributed. Mr. A. C.
121 Thomson, the chief accountant, no doubt could give
us that-information. The amount per year we spend
in advertising, varies. I can’t give you some approx
110
111
Testimony of Bert S. Presba. 69
mation of the amount if you are going to use that as an
average. We might pay anywhere from ten thousand to
a hundred thousand.
I will have to refer to my notes to see how much we
spent in the 1932 for advertising these jugs. The notes
are a memorandum I made of the record I keep in my
own department from year to year. I cannot carry in
my mind what we spent each year for twenty years. The
data I have before me was taken from the records which °
I myself keep. Approximately for the year 1932, $4300.00;
for 1933 so far, $1100.00. I understand you are talking
about jugs; for 1931, about $300.00; 1930, $1900.00; 1929,
$5400.00; 1928, $2200.00; 1927, $36,000. 1926, $44,000.00.
I am giving the round figures. For 1925, $52,000.00;
1924, $78,800.00; 1923, $40,500.00; 1922, $18, 000.00.
We began to sell these jugs in 1920. For 1921, $12,-
000.00; for 1920, $11,000.00. Prior to that time we had
not sold any jugs. 1919, that was about the time we
started. So from 1920 to 1933, these amounts approxi-
mately indicate the expenditures that I made for adver-
tising these jugs.
In the accounting department, I think, is segregated
the proportion of these respective amounts for these
years that went to the radio advertising. As far as my
record is concerned, I keep it as an advertising expendi-
ture. I do not break it down.
The form of advertising comprehended by the
122 items I have just given, I have referred to in my
previous testimony; magazines, newspapers, trade
papers, and lastly radio.
The Mantle Lamp Company is manufacturing jugs to-
day, such as have just been introduced in evidence, or
identified.
(Plaintiff’s Exhibits 12 and 13, marked for identifica-
tion.)
There has been no period during which the manufac-
ture of these jugs was stopped; only seasonal, between
seasons we may stop prodiction, but not from year to
_ There has been continuous manufacture season-
ably
Some of the other stations besides K.D.K. A. are
W.L.W. Cincinnati: W.L.S. Chicago: W.H.O. Chicago;
K.M.O.X. St. Louis; W.T.C.O. -Minneanolis; K.F.M.X.
Shenandoah, Iowa; K.M.B.C. Kansas City. If I would
70
113
114
115
Statement of Evidence.
think a little bit, I could probably give you fifty more
we have used. We have used as high as eighty, but at
no one time. We have used as high as eighty stations
at different times advertising these jugs. We have got
the entire group, practically, of the radio broadcasting
stations for this purpose. The number of people reached
by this advertising I guess would be a hundred million.
You may be reaching a hundred million with each broad.’
cast and you can multiply that by the number of broad-
casts. Altogether. we run broadcasts from about the
123 first of October until the first of February; it varies;
some stations we’used only one broadcast a week;
others we use every day of the week; some use straight
announcements, and the others we use fifteen minutes,
sometimes half an hour. There is no standard. I can’t
tell you specifically without itemizing each station, what
we use. You would repeat it, you would reach them over
again on each broadcast.
Redirect Examination by Mr. Millar.
The total amount I stated had been used for advertis-
ing purposes, during that period, is* specifically for ad-
vertising Aladdin Jars. The amount expended by The
Mantle Lamp Company for advertising all of its prod-
ucts, including jars, is very much larger than the figures
I mentioned. :
‘The items featured in those broadcasting programs are
Aladdin Kerosene Mantle Lamps primarily, then at the
close of the program, we announce to the listeners they
can obtain this product at local Aladdin dealers, and
along with that we méntion there are also available Alad-
‘din Electric Lamps, Lamp Shades, -Aladdin Jugs and
Jars, and Aladdin Vacuum Bottles. P
124 The Mantle Lamp Company of America, with ref-
erence to the charges made for broadcasting pro-
grams allocated to the account for Aladdin Thermalware
Jars, make their distribution on the books according to
the way we in the advertising department direct them.
Whrn the invoice is received from the radio station, we
116 determine what proportion of it might have been devoted
to the advertising of each different product; if it is only
a sentence or two, announcing one of our products, it 1s
divided proportionately; it may be only a few dollars as
Festtmony of Victor S. Johnson. 71
charged against that product. We split the invoice up
and pass it through okay to the accounting department
_ for their distribution.
Recross Examination by Mr. Cromwell.
This expenditure of $300,000.00 was devoted to just
Aladdin Jugs alone. Whatever was used for advertising
the other products such as Kerosene Lamps and so forth,
was in excess of the $300,000.00 and this $300,000.00 was
expended over the period from 1920 to 1933.
117 125 VICTOR S. JOHNSON, called as a witness on be-
half of plaintiff, testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Millar.
- My name is Victor S. Johnson. I live at 303 South
Grove Avenue, Oak Park, Illinois. I am president of The
Mantle a Company of America and Aladdin Indus-
tries, Inc. I have been president of the Mantle Lamp
118 Company of America since the ineorporation of the com-
pany in 1908. My duties as President of The Mantle
Lamp Company of America include the supervision of
_ the patent department of The Mantle Lamp Company.
I have invented devices myself and applications for.
patent have been issued on a number of them. -
The Mantle Lamp Company of America has patent ap-
plications pending at the present time in excess of one
hundred.
9 No application is filed and no amendment is inserted
unless it has my approval. I am familiar with heat in-
sulated receptacles of the non-vacuum
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.