Transcript of Record — United States v. Idaho

Supreme Court brief1936

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

ee

nes, eee

VOL. H

TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OCTOBER ‘TERM, 1935

No. 420

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, THE INTERSTATE

COMMERCE COMMISSION, AND THE OREGON SHORT

LINE RAILROAD COMPANY, APPELLANTS

| vs. :

THE STATE OF IDAHO, AND J. D. RIGNEY, ET AL., CON-

STITUTING AND AS THE PUBLIC UTILITIES COM-

MISSION OF THE STATE OF IDAHO

APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT OF THE UNITED STATES FOR

THE DISTRICT OF UTAH

FILED SEPTEMBER 4, 1935

2

?

af

ERR INENRE TSA I RMR EA sar RR UNNI te

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OcToBER TERM, 1935

No. 420

THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA, THE INTERSTATE

COMMERCE COMMISSION, AND THE OREGON SHORT-

LINE RAILROAD COMPANY, APPELLANTS

vs.

THE STATE OF IDAHO, AND J. D. RIGNEY, ET AL., CON-

STITUTING AND AS THE PUBLIC UFILITIES COM-

MISSION OF THE STATE OF IDAHO

,

APPEAL FROM THE DISTRICT COURT ‘OF THE UNITED STATES FOR

“THE DISTRICT OF UTAH

INDEX ,

Original Print

Record from D. C. U. S., District of Utah_........-.....-.---- 376 =. 237

Plaintiffs’ exhibit B—Exhibits filed at hearing before I. C. C.,

Finance Docket No. 90196_.--_......-.-.-----2..-.---- 376 . 237

Complainant’s exhibit 1—Contract between Director

F ' General of Railroads and Idaho Coal Mines Co., Sept.

GQ, Foe wuwansutccncsaccnsgucheenétsessnsacsunaen 377 = 237

Bee Br-GRD, dh deccsccactsnvenasanats Facing 388 242

Contract between Oregon Short Line R. R. Co. .and

Idaho Coal Mines Co., March 17, 1920__._.____- 389 - 243

SG PR, .ntactdanupsnenndaanaane Facing 395 246

Complainant’s exhibits 3 to 7, ine. —Statements showing

cost of work performed and maintenance—Talbot

Ps caccucacsagensasnnseunensenaeankaaeal 396 247

Complainant’s exhibit 8—Statement showing investment

in road and. equipment, ‘leased lines, etc_-_- ~------- 401 249

Complainant’s exhibits 9 and 10—Statements showing

. operating revenues and —- railway tax accruals,

Taacicapadssctecscsdassbasisnsndenaadiahaskans 402 250

Complainant’s exhibits 11 and 12—Statements of revenue ;

freight, showing cars and tons, etc................_.- 404 252

a

" INDEX

Record from D. C. U.8., District Utah—Continued. - ;

Plaintiffs’ exhibit B, ete.—Confinued. Original Print

Complainant’s exhibits 13 and 14—Statements showing ~

carload shipments. of coal originating at Talbot, Idaho,

BB ooo cnn ccsocecccnncooneseoooodocessoso== ee 406 254

Complainant’s exhibit 15—Statement of carload ship-

ments (other than coal) from and ta points on Talbot

Branch. ......-----------2---<2--02-0---2°°"°"""" 409 257

Defendant’s exhibit 16—Statement showing selected

Gnancial statistics, comparative statistics for other

lines, ote... ...-----+------------290-----°°"""=~"" 414 260

Complainant’s exhibit 17—Statement of carload ship- ;

ments of coal from Wyoming and Utah mines-------- 433 272

Complainant’s exhibit 19—Statement of rates in cents

-per ton on coal, etc...----------------------------; 434 272

Complainant’s exhibits 20 and 21—Supplements No. 7

and 5 to O. 8. L. R. R. Tariff ..---------------------

Defendant’s exhibit 25—Summary of report of the Teton

Céad Mine... ....---------+-----<--------2------"

Complainant’s exhibit 29—Report on property of Teton

Coal Co. as of Apr. 26, 1924------------------------

Complainant’s exhibit 30—Amended complaint before

Publie Utilities Commission of Idaho, Case No. F-550-

Applicant’s exhibit 34—Statement showing tons of coal

received Jan. 1 to Oct. 31, 1932,°from Talbot and

Dygert, Idaho, ete-- ------------------------- noone

Applicant’s. exbfoits 37 and 38—Statements showing tons

of coal received at stations on O. 8. L. R. R., ete.--.---

Applicant’s exhibit 39—Statement showing operating

revenues, expenses, railway tax accruals,-etc-.--------

Applicant’s exhibit 40—Statement showing carload ship-

ments (other than coal) from and to points on Talbot

Branch, ete......-----------------------------"-""

Applicants exhibit 41—Statement showing estimated

: revenues and expenses of Talbot Branch, etc -- -------

Clerk’s certificate---.-------------------------------°-77

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 237

376 In United States District Court, Wistaies of Utah

Plaintiff's exhibit B .

Interstate Commerce Commission, Washington

I, George B. McGinty, Secretary of the Interstate Commerce

Commission, do hereby certify that the attached are true copies of

exhibits filed at the hearing held May 16 and 17, 1932, before Exam-

iner Sullivan, at. Pocatello, Idaho, and of exhibits filed at the hear-

ing or in response to requests made at the hearing held December 15,

1932, before Examiner Clifford, at Pocatello, Idaho, in Finance

‘Docket No. 9096, Oregon Short Line Railroad Company Abandon- -

ment, the originals of which are now on file and of record in the

office of this Commission. -

In witness whereof I have hereunto set my hand and affixed the

Seal of said Commission this 29th day of December, A. D. 1934.

[SEAL] sok ' Grorce B. McGinry, ©

Secretary of the Interstate Commerce Commiission.

3i7 Exhibit 1

' Interstate Commerce Commijssion. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 1. Witness Smith. Compiainant’s, Defendant’s, Commission’s.

Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, reporter. -

Contract A. C. E. No: 4090—Audit No. 10608—between W. G.

McAdoo, Director General of Railroads, United States Railroad

Administration, and Idaho Coal Mines Company

; Construction of Branch Line Tetonia, Idaho, to the Teton Coal’

Mines (approximately 9.05 miles) —

378 This agreement, made and entered into this 4th day of Sep-

tember 1918, by and between W. G. McAdoo, Director General

of Railroads, United States Railroad Administration, operating the

Oregon Short Line Railroad (hereinafter called the Director Gen-

eral), party of the first part, and the Idaho Coal Mines Company,

a corporation of the State of (hereinafter called the Coal

Company), party of the second part, witnesseth: ; ,

That in consideration of the benefits and advantages to be re-

ceived by each of the parties hereto, through the construction, oper-

| - ation, and maintenance of a branch line railroad approximately 9.05

miles long, extending in a southwesterly direction from a connec-

tion with the’ Teton Valley Branch of the Oregon Short Line Rail-

road just south of Tetonia, Idaho, to the Teton Coal Mines, in the

location substantially as shown in yellow on the attached print

marked “Exhibit A”, which is hereby made a part hereof,-and in

F IDAHO ET AL. -

238 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE 0

further consideration of the covenants and agreements herein con-

tained, it is hereby mutually agreed and stipulated as follows:

1. Right of Way: The Coal Company hereby agrees that it will,

at its sole cost and expense, convey or Cause -ta be conveyed to the

- Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, by deeds satisfactory fo the

Assistant Chief Engineer of the Oregon Short Line Railroad, all

land necessary for right of way for the censtruction, operation, and .

maintenance of said branch line over private property and outside

of the right of way or lands of said Oregon Short Line Rail-

379 road Company, and to procure Tor and in the name of the

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company authority and fran-

chises satisfactory to said Assistant Chief Engineer necessary for

the construction, maintenance, and operation of said branch line

‘Exhibit A. It is further agreed that the cost of labor and niaterial

:n connection with the construction of the main line and sidings and

the cost of labor and material for the construction of mine tracks

from switch point to clearance point, is to be borne by the Director

General and that the cost of all labor and material in connection

with the construction of the remainder of said mine tracks, shown

in green on attached print marked “Exhibit B”, which .is made a

rt hereof, is to be borne by. the Coal Company.

3. Deposit of Estimated Cost: The estimated cost to the Director

General for the necessary labor and material in connection with the

construction, of that portion of said mine tracks between clearance

points, as shown in green on said Exhibit B, is Fifty-Eight Thov-

sand ($58,000.00) Dollars, which amount the Coal Company hereby

to deposit with the proper representative of the Director

General, in.amounts as required by the Assistant Chief Engineer

. of the Oregon Short Line Railroad.

380 4. It is mutually agreed by the parties hereto that if, after

the completion of the said trackage, the actial cost of the

portion of the labor and material to be paid for by the Coal Com-

pany as provided for in this agreement, shall be less than the amount

deposited, the difference shall be returned to the Coal Company, but

if the cost of that portion of the labor and material to be paid for

' by the. Coal Company shall exceed the amount deposited by the

Coal Company, the Coal Company agrees to pay to the Direstor

General an amount equal to such excess.

5. Ownership of Trackage: It is hereby mutually agreed between

of the Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, and also, that the

Coal Company shall have no right, title, or ownership in said track-

UNITED STATES ET AL. YS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 239

age, nor in the rails, cross ties or other material with which said _

trackage is laid. |

6. It is further mutually agreed between the parties hereto that

that portion of the mine tracks between clearance points, as shown in -

green on said Exhibit B, shall be and remain the property of the

Coal Company, it being understood-that said mine tracks are to be

constructed on land to be obtained by the ‘Oregon Short Line Rail-

road Company from the United States of America by virtue of filing

ma

“a 7. Director General to Have Use of. Mine Tracks: The

381 Director General shall have the right to use said mine tracks

and any part thereof for the business of the Oregon Short

Line Railroad and such other railroads, persons or shippers can

direct. or for the business of any other person or shipper and shall

have the right to extend same and construct other tracks therefrom

in order to reach and serve other shippers or industries adjacent

thereto; Provided, however, that“the business of the Oregon Short

Line Railroad and such other railroads, persons or shippers can

be handled on said trackage without serious inconvenience or detri-

ment to the business of the Coal Company, and; Provided, further,

that im the event any person or shipper may desire to establish an

industry along and adjacent to said trackage, or have constructed

an industry track as an extension thereto, or as a Spur therefrom,

for the purpose of serving an industry ‘or industries to be located

along and adjacent to such extension or such spur, the Coal Com-

pany shall consent thereto and shall consent to’ the use of said

trackage by the Director General for serying such industry or in-

dustries as may be located along and adjacent to said trackage

or along and adjacent to such extensions thereto or such spurs con-

_ hecting therewith, upon the payment to the Coal Company by such

persons or shippers of an equitable proportion of the original cost

borne by the Coal Company for the construction of said trackage,

and also an equitable proportion of the cost and expense for main-

tenance, repair and renewal thereof, from and after the establish-

ment of such industries along and adjacent to said trackage, or along

and adjacent to such extensions thereto or such spurs connecting

therewith. me

382 8. Maintenance of Trackage: It is mutually agreed between

the parties hereto that the Director General shall maintain,

Tepair, and renew all trackage constructed under this agreement,

and that the Coal Company shall pay to the Director General the

entire cost and expense incurred in the maintenance, repair, and

renewal of that portion of said mine tracks between clearance points

shown in green on said Exhibit B, such payments to be made -by the

Coal Company to the Director General within thirty (30) days

_~ the rendition of properly certified bills therefor by the Director

neral.

9. Proximity of Structures: The Coal Cempany agrees that on

all tracks on which Oregon Short Line Railroad engines operate

a

*

‘

3

4

Bs

4

240 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

or switch cars it will not pile, or permit to be piled, any lumber or

other material whatsoever’ within a distance of ten feet from the

center line of any track and that it will not erect, or permit to be

erected, any building or other structure within a distance of eight

feet six inches from the center line of any of said tracks, the over-

head clearance of any structures to be not less than twenty-four feet

above top of rail of said tracks; provided, however, that platforms

not.exceeding an elevation of four feet above the top of the nearest

track rail may be placed and maintained at a distance of not less

than seven feet three inches from the center. line of track. The

Coal Company further agrees that all doors, windows, or gates

shall be of the sliding type or shall open toward the inside of the

‘building or enclosure where such building or enclosure is so located .

-that the said doors, windows or gates, when open, wouid

383 swing closer than eight (8) feet, six (6) inches to the center

line of said track; it being understood that- this agreement

grants no right to the Coal Company to erect or maintain any build-

ing or structure, or to place or store any material, on the property of

the Oregon Short Line Railroad Company.

10. Permission to be Obtained by Coal Company for erection of

Poles, Wires, Etc., over or undér tracks: The Coal Company fur-

ther agrees that it will not locate or permit the location or erection of

any poles, beams, pipes, wires, structures, or other obstructions over

or under said tracks without the written consent of the Director

General.

11. Coal Company to Promptly Load and Unload Cars: The Coal

Company shall load and unload promptly all cars that may be set

~ on said trackage for loading and unloading by it, it being understood

that cars in the vicinity of the tipple and scales are to be handled

solely by the Coal Company by means of gravity and that the Diree-

- tor General will not be required to operate on the scale or tipple

tracks. ,

- 12. Liability: The Coal Company agrees to protect, indemnify,

save harmless, and defend the Director General and’ the Oregon:

Short Line Railroad Company from and against all suits, damages,

and claims of all abutting. property owners on account of the con-

struction, maintenance, or operation of said proposed mine tracks.

- 13. The Coal Company further agrees and binds itself, its suc-

cessors and assigns, to indemnify and save harmless the said Di-

rector General and the Oregon Short Line Railroad Company

384 from and against all manner of claims, damages, actions, causes

of action, debts,*dues,. liabilities, judgments, and costs arising

or that may hereafter arise, or be claimed or that may in any way

be predicated upon damages to or the destruction of any property

whatsoever, and injuries to or the death of any persons, whomsoever,

caused or contributed to by the construction, maintenance, or opera-

tion of said proposed mine tracks, except such as are caused or di-

rectly contributed to by the negligence of the said Director General

a

UNITED STATES ET AL, VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 24]

and the said Oregon Short Line Railroad Company or their agents,

servants, or employes, while operating on said track; and further

agrees, at the request of the said Director General and the said

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, or either of them, to defend,

at its own sole cost and expense, any and all suits or actiens growing

out of or predicated in any manner upon any of the matters or

things aforesaid and agrees that the Director General and the Oregon

Short Line Railroad Company shall not be responsible for any dam-

age to or loss of contents of cars by fire or any other cause whatso-

ever, after cars are placed for loading or unloading, the liability of

the Director General and the Oregon Short Line Railroad Company

not to begin until.the car or cars shall have been switched from said

mine tracks to the main line for transportation, unless such loss be

caused or directly contributed to by the negligence of the Director

General or the Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, their agents,

servants, or employes; that the Coal Company will pay promptly,

in cash, for any and sll damages that may be done

385 to cars caused or directly contributed to by the negligence of

the Coal Company, its servants, agents, or employes, while

cars are on said mine tracks for loading or unloading by the said

Coal Company. .

14. The Coal Company agrees to hold the Director General and

the Oregon Short Line Railroad-Company harmless and to’ indem-

nify them from any and all liability and claim for damages to the

Coal Company’s own property or to property in its custody or con-

trol arising from fire caused by the operation of engines, trains, or

cars on trackage constructed under this agreement, and the Coal

Company further agrees that it will take out no insurance on its

property in this vicinity containing conditions or provisions which

will permit the insurance companies to make claim against or recover

damages from the Director General or the Oregon Short Line Rail-

road Company on account of loss by fire which such insurance com-_

panies may be obliged to pay to the-Coal Company. | ’

_ 15. Termination of Agreement: It is understood and agreed that

the Director General, after giving sixty (60) days’ written notice

to the Coal Company, shall be privileged to-terminate this agree-

ment and to discontinue the operation of the said mine tracks, and

to take up the rails, ties, and other materials with which said tracks

are constructed and to remove and use the same at any point on the

Oregon Short Line Railroad for any purpose without let or hin-

drance or molestation on the part of the Coal Company in the event

that— ) |

386 (a) the Coal Company ceases for a continuous period of

one year, the doing of business in an active and substantial

way over the said mine tracks,

~.(b) the Coal’Company shall fail, to keep and perform each and

every obligation, condition, and stipulation stated in or resulting

under this agreement, or |

ee ee errr

Hes eee

Cr RR Te

Per acer an ey

Bi i ty ate ae

&

3

3

4

242 ' UNITED STATES ‘ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL,

(c) the Director General -is required by law, ordinance, or police |

regulations, or changed conditions to elevate or depress or other-

wise change the tracks of the said Oregon Short Line Railroad at -

or near the location of the said mine tracks so as to make it imprac-

° ticable in the judgment of the Director General to continue the op-

-eration of said mine tracks.

16. It is understood and agreed, however, in the event the said

rails, ties, and other materials with which said mine tracks are con-

structed are taken up-and removed by the Director General for any

of the causes mentioned in sub-paragraph (c) of Section Fifteen

(15) hereof, the Director General shall pay to the Coal Company a

sum of money which shall équal the then salvage value of all mate-

rials which are taken up and removed from that portion of the said

inine tracks between clearance points, as shown ih green on said

Exhibit B. |

17. It is further agreed that the Coal Company shall have no re-

course or redress of any charscter against the Director General or

the Oregon Short Line Railroad Company when this agreement is

terminated and said mine tracks are taken up and said materials are

moved away as herein provided.

18. Successors and Assig® -* Tl is agreement shall be binding upon

and inure to the bem . vu. -ne Director General and his suc-

387. vessors in office and tue Coal Company, its successors and as-

signs; and it is agreed that upon the termination of Federal

control of the Oregon Short Line Railroad and the resumption of

operation of said railroad by Oregon Short Line Railroad Company,

the covenants and conditions in this agreement contained shall inure

to the benefit of said Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, its suc-

cessors and assigns. |

In witness whereof, the parties hereto have caused this instrument

to be executed on the day and year first herein written.

. W. G. McAnoo,

Director General of Railroads, operating Oregon

. 3 Sort Line Railroad.

_ By H. V. Puarrt, -

General Manager, Oregon Short Line Railroad.

Witness:

H. E. ScuHett.

IpaHo Coat Mines CoMPANy,

- By R.S. Tareor,

. Its President. -

Witness:

E. L. Cosy.

Attest:

Secretary.

Approved :

C. STRADLEY,

Asst. Chief Engineer.

[seaL] 7 .

=~

f

a

3

L

1

~--s ween =

‘

a ee ee

|

Castle Bk,

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 243 ©

389 Contract A. ©. E. No. 442)—Audit No. — between Oregon

Short Line Railroad Co. and Idaho Coal Mines Co.

Operation of Teton -Coal Spur near. Tetonia, Idaho

300 SYNOPSIS

Date: 3-17-20. J AS Pes

Parties: Oregon Short Line Railroad Company (Railroad Com-

pany), Idaho Coal Mines Company (Coal Company).

Subject : Operation of track ftom the Teton: Valley Branch of the

Oregon Short Line Railroad to Coal mines of the Idaho Coal Mines ©

Company. © oy | :

Whereas, track was constructed during the period of Federal con-

_trol a portien of which crosses a forest reserve, and the Railroad

Company has not yet entered into any agreement: for operation across

said forest reserve, and the Coal Company desires to arrange for

operation to and from its coal mines. — : -

Agreement: 1. Unless prehibited by the United States Govern-

ment or other regulative authority, the Railroad Company agrees

to operate to and from said coal mines subject to published tariffs.

2. Coal Company shall pay promptly for damage done to cars.

3. (1) If Railroad Company is forbidden té operate over said

forest resérve it shall be released from all obligations hereunder;

(2) This agreement shall not be construed as an acknowledgment by

the Railroad Company of the propriety of.charges by the Govern-

ment for the cost of. construction or an admission of ownership of

track by the Railroad Company. ;

4. Railroad Company may cancel this agreement on 60 days’ notice

in the event that (a) the Coal Company ceases for period of 1 year

the doing of business; (b) the Coal Company fails to keep ‘its obli-

gations hereunder; (c) the Railroad Company is required by law to

change its tracks so as to make operation impracticable.

5. In the event of termination of this agreement, the Coal Com-

‘pany shall be without recourse against the Railroad Co.

6. Agreement effective on the date first herein written.

7. Agreement binding upon successors and assigns.

Execution.

391 COPY

This agreement, made and entered into this 17th day of March,

A. D. 1920,-by and between Oregon Short Line Railroad Company,

a corporation of the State of Utah (hereinafter called “Railroad -

Company”), party of the first part, and Idaho Coal Mines Com-

pany, a corporation of the State of Idaho (hereinafter called “Coal -

' Company”), party of the second part, witnesseth, That:

Whereas, on the 28th day of December 1917, the President of the

‘United States under authority of law took over for the purpose of

43764—vol. 11-362 |

. 244 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

. operation, various railroads of the United States, including the Ore-

gon Short Line Railroad, and operated said railroads from said

date to the 1st day of March A. D. 1920; and

Whereas, during the operation of the Oregon Short Line Rail-

road, as aforesaid, a certain spur track (hereinafter referred to as

“track”) was constructed in the location described as follows:

“Beginning at a point in the center line of present main track of

the Teton Basin Branch of the Oregon Short Line Railroad, said _

point being in the Southeast Quarter of the Southeast Quarter

(SEY, SE) of Section Thirty-two (32), Township Six (6) North,

Range Forty-five (45) East of the Boise Meridian, State of Idaho,

whence the Northwest corner of Section Five (5), Township Five:

(5) Township Five (5) North, Range Forty-five (45) East of the

‘Boise Meridian, bears South eighty-five degrees and twenty-two

minutes West S. 85°22’ W.) four thousand ninety and four-tenths .

(4090.4) feet distant; thence in a general Southwesterly direction,

to a point in the Southeast Quarter of the Northeas: Quarter (SE\4

NE) of Section Thirty-one (31), Township Five (5) North, Range

Forty-four (44) East of the Boise Meridian, whence the Northeast

corner of said Section Thirty-one (31) bears North thirty-seven

_ degrees and forty-seven minutes East (N. 37°47’ E.) two thousand

ninety-seven and seven-tenths (2097.7) feet distant, a length of nine

and one hundred fifty-six thousandths (9.156) miles, the same being

upon the surveyed lands of the United States.”

Whereas, the construction of the said track has been completed

from the switch point to the tipple of the Coal Company so far as is

necessary in order for the same to be operated for the transporta-

tion of freight thereon; and ,

‘Whereas, a portion of the said track is located over and across

a forest reserve of the United States, and-the Railroad Company

has not as yet entered into any agreement with the Department

of the Interior, covering the operation of trains, engines, and cars

of the Railroad Company upon and over that portion of said track

located upon said forest reserve; and

392 Whereas, the Railroad Company has filed with the De

partment of the Interior a map showing the location of the

said track, as hereinabove described, which said map has not been

approved by the said Department owing to the fact that the Rail-

road Company has refused to execute an agreement required by the

Department of the Interior, respecting the construction and opera-

tion of the said track over the said forest reserve; and

- Whereas, the Railroad Company intends to prosecute a claim

against the United States of America based upon the construction of

the said track, under the provisions of the standard contract ‘entered

into between the Director General of Railroads, acting on behalf

_of the United States and the President, and the Oregon Short Line

Railroad Gompany under date of February 14, 1919, and in com-

pliance with the act of Congress commonly known as the Federal

Control Act approved March 21, 1918; and

-

.

Oe ee ee ee a a a ——

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 245

Whereas, the Coal Company desires to arrange with the Kail-

road Company to operate the engines arid cars of the Railroad

Company over the said track for the transportation of freight in

both directions between the coal mines of the Coal Company and

the Teton Branch of the Railroad Company, subject to the premises

hereinabove set out, and subject to the covenants and agreements.

hereinafter set forth to be kept and performed by the Coal Company,

and subject, further, to all conditions in this contract named limit-

‘ing the powers of the parties hereto to contract for the operation

of engines and cars over fht said track. ;

Now, therefore, for.and in consideration of the premises, it is

hereby agreed betwetn the parties hereto, as follows:

1. Unless prohibited by the Government of the United States,

or ‘other lawful regulative authority, the Railroad Company agrees

to operate its engines and trains over the said track each way between

the coal tipple of the Coal Company and the Teton Branch of the

Railroad Company for the handling of the business of the Coal

Company subject to such tariff rates as may be in effect for such

service at the time such service is performed.

2. The Coal Company shall pay promptly to the Railroad Com-

pany in cash for any and all damages to cars of the Railroad Com-

pany while in such service for the Coal Company caused’ by or

through the negligence of the Coal Compaiy, or the meghignace of

the agents or employees of the Coal Company.

3. It is expressly agreed between the parties hereto that this agree-

ment is made subject to the following conditions, and that without

such conditions being stipulated the Railroad Company would net

enter into the said agreement: (1) that the Railroad Company may

be prevented and forbidden by the Government of the United

States to operate its engines and cars over said track where the same

crosses the forest reserve as aforesaid, and that in the event of

393 such prevention, this.agreement shall cease and terminate and

. the Railroad Company shall be relieved of any and all obli-

gations. thereunder; (2) that this agreement shall not be construed

as an acknowledgment on the part of the Railroad Company that

it may properly be charged by the Government of the United States

with the cost of construction of the said track; or that the cost which

the Government of the United States may attempt to charge the

Railroad Company for the construction thereof is for the proper

sum or sums of money; or that the Railroad Company is the owner

of the said track or enters into this agreement under the agreed or

tacit assumption or understanding that it is the owner of the said

track.

. 4. The Railroad Company, after giving sixty (60) days’ written

notice to the Coal Company of its intention so to do, shall be privi-

leged to terminate this agreement and to discontinue the operation

of its engines and cars over the said track, in the event that:

a,

eee a” A

UCR isch trash dewikereants 2

246 . UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL,

(a). The’ Coal Company ceases for a continuous period of one

year doing business in an active and substantial way over. the said

track ; '

(b) The Coal Company shall fail to keep and perform each and °

every obligation, condition, and stipulation stated in or resulting

under this agreement; — :

(c) The Railroad Company, is required by law, ordinance, or

police regulations, or changed conditions to elevate or depress or

otherwise change the tracks of the Railroad Company at or near

the location of the said track so as to make it impracticable, in

the judgment of the Railroad Company, to continue to operate its

engines and cars over the same.

.5. Inthe event of the termination of this contract, howsoever, the

Coal Company shall be without recourse or redress of any character

against the Railroad Company. es

6. This agreement shall take effect upon the day and year first

herein written, and shall continue in full force and effect until ter-

minated as herein provided.

7, This agreement shall be binding upon and inure to the benefit

of the Railroad Company, its successors, and assigns, and the Coal

: Company, and the successors and assigns of the Coal Company.

394 In Witness Whereof, the parties hereto have caused this

agreement to be executed the day and year first herein written.

Orecon Suortr Line Ratiroap CoMPAny,

By (Sgd.) C: R..Gray,_.

- Its President.

Witness:

(Sgd.). P. Riepon.

IpaHo Coat Mines Company,

By (Sgd.) R. S. Taxsor, ;

Its President.

Witness : :

(Sgd.) E. J. Gromisu.

Attest :

‘ [szav] (Sgd.) H. T: Wares, *

Secretary.

Approved as to Form:

: are (Sgd.) Geo. H. Smirx,

; | : General Attorney.

Approved as to Execution: 40 !

(Sgd.) Geo. H. SmirTs,

| General Attorney.

A. C. E. O. |

2/24-20.

- + 90006 169

= 9006 ) 9

4 4'Om 600*6 1 07

has

sabia A, ces veeueiive

114 4SbvMMS B4S +1 0g 10brr: rm Naa te wife

bg Le Md 6 {SLe8 ipso 44, 1) 60124 Ob

‘ . oer

r

| i

vi

Sais segree

'

Van 4S jg F00+O*L OM S44 L0G 7S —

> we \

= bl ys : “sg, K,

S 4 see jaan we

1°23 N44 YOM g6O*t) HS 1 Hie ML

ear a ol

o . , . 5

a S s ; P + Bie

: £3 a6m i

Lon 4k ong td fail oe oe

Mele

elie i

oor bale id ADS '

mon a.

$7082 fans

” ; Kt {a auf

ee > rite | om 44h

} YWOHOIO™ E5046 OFS BSt- addi,

HAL UIOm ag 666°9) 191-7 2.1160! De e649 -———

na atgt} hehe,

1 THOR 74 40608 | ee

ee RRA ER

DROSS ig PydOeH ING 3d 7HO8C= : oie

x

‘

ned

bax4 2°"

! t

~~ tae

georres 36 OF

vw 40 0 ‘

‘

wy 40 99

* o

or.

7°?

‘ ve

: ett’. BARE ie 5 “A :

—— Wate a ,

t 350 8335; alow \* -w 3

. ’ 4) Fs

3

ean ’ E

be:

—* %:

ie

.

-

fay ‘’ -

At

' § \

“

. “

os

ann

SesBe. -+-

‘ ~az |

Wf --- ERS

Sw @ wes Sak aeeth js m

—-. 4

A i!

A )

' "

SY) 4 Bursting 0040-5 We tLieg |’

ie

m

J

* 3 0

\ ga’ poe, OT

VaqQre!

A 3 4et. 9acs0s 106 caret

ane = pert

= ors ore 9 ve

Sas Teh

5409 ’

\

4

‘\

‘

\

js \

x

- \ :

p \

\

\

* » Bete. offi oom

44, VOW Yq 066°P! 191-7 Li.0! 2

1 Seeger Paar et Baga rS) ah a =

~} Lia aseerneys 8.45 +104 tober) 2d b86FM ane te

ted Dd USL08 1,El- PEN AL 7. > ap

{

Van AALS ig b00+0*L EN MAL LOW 7S

‘ — wi

: t “73S —* a ‘ 44) hs Wendl ~S } > pga

j ta WS. S Fe aM eg bRIS yt. 406 1$8e§

e —toey eh ‘\t ” e | : 4

F be “wh \ j

3

-+ 3d “fey

-

| : 3! - 2. -

a ed sos BRN.

is ee 4 ? a

aS 6 ' OOS gn

¢ or Bledé aes { ' : \ See. eset

aw] ~ocnt. 3. he ee B55

Laat #§ ? WE > * oe cows Rand.

1g TTT 4068 1g: 04 OF ves i i

t a rt Si |

$35: 253 Erp: e ‘

pe: | pts eR = = r o-

ee} YOHHO207 gSO+b PFS YSt-aiddi, ores 350006 Tad 2a (9016 Ey : ' ,

9

#909

Nn” sa vy"

neg gure”, ,3c8

ie ‘ ‘

nas 4.0 200°"

y* vibe)

i ‘

, i)

, wsieithe x

A)? Oe $ : ? .

° gars \ - ; wet

n ured | sbowd , ue @

40152 pees aw Oy \ my \ we yon, 27" ;

,, wow 6” ai ! Or al yrs :

’ ¢ ? tig qret

. 4 ® 75

be? A _1 é gag 885 o>

7 A oe at dor ve

‘ ytee vit

. 2 5 989"

t

\

- \

L .

\

1

\ .

- °

’ \

F \

\

. \

. Broo

‘ Y \ ;

\ i.

\

\

is vom, “4 - - “e

Py eats ce aE "

4 “ . _ _ .

«aad

he th oY he

= i

“= @

‘ 4 e ¢

s* 2

ay

< oe.”

Sat

; . a=”

yii-k

.. Mit:

? wictg

2-2 €89

3S te

x -

z .

: 7

.

€ .

‘ -

, bs Re

eae’ .

3 ;

>

YA

sf

»”

Hay ur * ¥

| Ee! Senne

116 sSOPH HS B4S +104 r0brr, 2d Ob6m Raa

5 To 4d Dd (SL08 1 Ble REN 441 T> LE OND

, '

Gals sa gone

c {

Fan +, 8S ig 60000%L OM MALL OW;

i+ fy |

SOs ) ey

1238 "41 WOM Abo LY HS) BH

a : “4g 73 fetus” ig Otis lg *. 40¢ t$8e§ Uu

waa Ne 7, |

e ’ 6 ;

— 8 : Len 44 gored Med ids

~

.

.

z

co

4

”

c

*

>

°

a

~-

w

=

-_*

-

4

i

i

é

:

Fo Read Nena Br 6 Sin Nia sete

149990 Pc [41903 POT? SPR Sig mssgSO RT Lo

se wr /

RC 10°17 C L+t6'L seg PL. tain Trh.

RC. OTL CL Tre NOS ore L 8075) PC Treo?

er.

$! ROT Tre. WEL O+008 Pt Sm Tre NTA

a@

aie

EXHIBIT "8°

OREGON maton pink HATLRoat

: CONSTR OCTION

TETONER TO TITON Coan. BERD ase

PROPOSED LAYOUT OF TRACKAGE AT COAL MINE

~™ Ate emo" “Gun a” .

Gomer One wears OFF ce Oe.t Lane arr view

CCvBES svauet ce 8:0

Drews te) OL Teste A 11 @ weeds fi

¥ LEGEND

OSRLRR Trecks

Coal Company's Tracks

APES 86 RE

Fal GS Sree

erie.

Rae gs

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 247

-396 Enhabit 3

Docket No. 9096

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Ex-

hibit No. 3. Witness Brown. Complainant’sy, Defendant’s Com-

mission’s. Date 5-6-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Cost of work performed during September, October, and November 1924 at

various locations MP 0.0 to MP 9.0 in connection with rehabilitation. of

Talbot Branch

ce ALLEL IOLA ES T9208. 7% |.....--.-- $268. 74

ac picisss edeeteccssaeenamecemeumenens J-=-| 3, 507. 54 | $231.60 | 3, 739.14

Resheve emobomizment ... .........-. 22... 2222s .cccec nee ncn-seo-oee-- Y ae 2, 837.34 265.19 | 3, 102. 53

Ne: RS SSL IDS LOENESEPRO NEDA EIS N80 164.12 | | ' 164.12

0 A Ea LOL eM Er ee Ta 6,613.62 | 660.91 | 7,274.53

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, Engineering re

397 Exhibit 4

Docket No. 9096

, __ Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket . No. oa » Fin. Ex-

hibit No. 4. Witness Brown. Complainant’sy, Dv’» dant’s, Com-

mission’s. Date 5-16-32. F rank Otterstrom, repo. -r.

Cost work performed in connection with construction of: wye tracks at end

of Talbot Branch during 1924 &@ 1925

Remissstins GttRRncccnngeneesssccadienceseescescnssencssnes ----- $353.81

16-span bridge oyer Horseshoe ee 8, 456. 30

13-epan bridge over Horseshoe Creek._.............--...--........ 7,072.83

Cost of cross tiles, switch ties and bridge ties.........-- escticeianindeasibitaat 1,116. 87

Value of 2,406 1. f. SH 90-ARA Rail___................_-._.._..._ 739. 95

Frogs, ‘switches, tie plates, and small fittings (includes inside guard

TF 1, 041.11

Labor handiing track material and installing trackage-...____..---- 5, 252. 06

SE sa esctinncinnnshenetieitns diccinindaitiitelinsiliindiniatininnhdeaitheisdiggieanspinsiiininadmenmaties 22, 082. 93

a Short Line Railroad Company, a it Department.

398 | Exhibit 5 s

Docket No. 9096

; - Interstate Commerce .Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Ex-

hibit No. 5. Witness Br®wn. Complainant’sy, Defendant’s, Com-

mission’s. Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, reporter.

Statement showing estimated cost of maintaining Talbot ~ae during year |

1932

New Cross Ties, 800 pieces__.__..._______- a acs did _ $1, 048

SH Cross Ties, 350 pieces._........_..___-_-- Ricsinuigsinstaiaimiaiaintetenipiensiiens 173

A TE eT 69

Reclaimed Track Spikes, 1,800 pounds____ — 33

Various Culvert Renewals and Repairs. , : 300

403

610

7

248% _ UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

Statement of estimated cost ‘maintaining Talbot Branch—Continued

as oe ninaenpeaennanieann jac “See

Work Trains, etc., Plowing Snow-__.--. poe eeaeneneaanananinineasenanisen meamreisecnahcna 300

Material Store Expenses bnadnnianionin cepeintnaseiveimnenchehdhtamdnenensneianeiancicasensen emesis 57

Tool Charges\_- —_— — en 36

Contingencies. sniceinsn engin noe elie if 324-

’ Total, Labor, $1,630; Material, $1,969__......._..---...--------- 8, 569

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, Engineering Department.

390 +. 5 Ewhibit 6

Docket No. 9096

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 6. Witness Brown. Complainant’s y, Defendant’s, Commis-

sion’s. Date 5-16-82. Frank W. Otterstrom, reporter.

Statement showing estimated cost of maintaining Talbot Branch during year

1933

New Cross Ties, ‘1,500 De Ee es

i. «. < <{ 2_._ eee Rete Teor 98

. SH Tie Plates, 3,000. pleces..........-.-.-..._—.-~--..-.-—--------- 90

‘Reclaimed Track Spikes, 2,400 pounds__----------------------------- 44°

_ Various Cuivert Renewals. and Repairs_ liaise ie cules ia ai amass 450

‘ ae a a paren A as cciatguas be ced cnsn oh Ae eae ee 525

o * fll - 610

Work Trains—Unloading II cessncetcnenecrntictseceioannanietieniiinmpenaliocseamnnsitns 75

Were Wetec ccccchecnncccccecn en cccccwpeccmsnqesenceassunhnone 139

' Work Trains, etc., Plowing Snow_-_-_--- feniecianii aicnanaathana 300

Material Store Os i A RE AE IER See Lichen aedeacallins 70

Tool Charges = s ccipeiiaedniaicbacpmme ilgili “41 7

. Contingencies__- sang tall <tc xis a cape gu ep cana teas 441

Total, Labor, $1, 825 : I 4, 848

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company, Engineering Department.

400° Ewhibit 7

Docket No. 9096 ;

Interstate Canis Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 7. Witness Brown. Complainant’s ¥, Defendant’s, Commis-

sion’s. Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, reporter.

Statement showing estimated cost of maintaining Talbot Branch during year

, «1984

New Cross Ties, 1,850 pieces_#s--...---------- hesdacnahcdasedhaabaibcciaaadbiaasaicneantaiseaiatl $2, 423

oer Tmt TA. Te BE non ook ck vee een een ens 309 :

G4 Tie Pidtes, 3,700 pleces................- +... --- ; a FEY ill .

Reclaimed Track Spikes, 3,000 pounds_-_--~-~.---- = diaktlsalih hetnabsaisiaisiasdaciiatandaal 56 |

Various‘ Culvert Renewals and Repairs_____------------------~--~--- 600

Cost of Renewing Ties__----~-------~---------------------+-------- - 648°

Cost of Surfacing Track_-_-- sath otis 810

Work Trains—Unloading Cinders___.-.------------------------------ 150

Te inivcinrbinparicimaenninninnnaimmamiiion : * 139:

Work Train, etc., Plewing:- Snow---- Se eee ee a ae ae

*Mistetiel Gtere Mapetees.... nn neni cee enn see

Tool Charges aoe Ee ee LE EG Re OPE ee

IG ate ineenccncnnsntionnny ----—=. a 568

Total, Labor, $2,302; Material, $3,954 6, 256

Bao Short Line Railroad Company, Engineering Department.

249

«

~~ :

"SE6L (06 INAV “GeIN ‘AD eXWT IBg ‘2=OWO 8,10};pNy

“NqQeq—sjiUEY ATOR T qujor pus yuemdinby ‘sonuescy AvamIeyY o[qrjoe[[oouy ‘stenso0y xB ABaiey ‘sesuedxg 3uljeiedQ sepnyauy ¢

‘HpPeQ—syuey AI[JoVy yujor pus ‘“yueudmby” ‘sonueaey 3uy3810dO sepn[ouy ;

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. .

a eT 2g'e 281 oo" a ‘2 COR SLRS Wai so Zeer USI “FI

99 “126 ‘8zz ‘Z $2 °L09 ‘BPI ‘IT 86 "E88 ‘Zag ‘g L¥ 'L¥6 ‘196% O€ ‘9ST ‘She 88 ‘ALE ‘See 29 ‘CES ‘916 ‘i BR ot ak ne oe

g2°¢ gL°9 92'S GL°¢ 92° : . >. a PEON EI ASS JUOCUIISOAT] JO JUGDIOg “ZI

60 ‘SEF ‘E96 ‘8 £F 061 ‘219 ‘FF ZO ‘OTF ‘666 ‘8 ZL "809 ‘O0T ‘6 &b 'bI6 ‘E96 ‘8 9€ 006 ‘606 ‘8 06 ‘99% “E98 ‘8 ips pita aaa ie eign qv UOjeOdsuBlT, =.

: ; Jopun pens00e SABY P[NoYys yoy sZuyusIe| *[]

Ze > Ze SIZ 88°E €9°9 e¢°¢ : i y Saar (ecigigs Stes Gt JUGUISAAT] JO JUGIIEg ‘OT

$9 ‘OTS “FEL ‘9 89 ‘289 ‘229 ‘ee 40 920 ‘20F ‘€ 92 “199 ‘SPT ‘9 EI 8Sz ‘S09 ‘8 86 "2ZE ‘b29 ‘8 Bod... iebeaeneetegen. emlooUT Zurjyeledo ABITIBI JON °6

Z8 ‘FPL ‘S69 ‘8z 60 “PZL ‘SLE ‘EFT £2 ‘789 ‘OS0 ‘bz GZ “FOP ‘P81 ‘8Z =|: $9 “BLE ‘ZEST ‘TE 69 ‘129 “S6F-'08 SF ‘I¥9 ‘608 ‘6z Roe isthe any ean ¢ S}}Gep—eouro0ou] Zulyesedg “g

98 19% ‘Ot ‘oe ‘QOE*IST“ZLT =| 22 802 ‘89% ‘2Z 09 "996 ‘ZeE ‘ve L9 ‘GEE ‘8E8 ‘68 LE “WS ‘690 ‘6¢ od 8. Sa eeeeeeanatee 1 8}{pe1o—ouml00U] BuyyBIEdO *Z

92 648 ‘S88 ‘col - "868 ‘6ZP ‘BLL 9 “SLZF ‘TIS ‘9ST 66 ‘OIL ‘692 ‘8ST 10 ‘IS% ‘OZ ‘SST LL ‘88L "¥S6 ‘PST OF ereee eat. 1° ee WO?}841OGSUBI} JO BOJAIOS OY}

: : é pesn pus 1oj prey Ayredod jo enyea 978 v9

OT ‘810 ‘68 08 ‘060 ‘Sz ‘F $6 “819 ‘258 96 ‘STS ‘248 96 “BIS ‘L¥8 96 ‘STS ‘248 J: SR aaa aba ite as eet: 0D Avamey ogoeg

ite UIOY}ION OY} 0} peses] seul] JO eNTBA—sseT “¢

26 "168 “FEL ‘OST =| 2968 bL9‘eRL | T9266 ‘RCE ‘ZCI | FE'SEz ‘LIT ‘BST | 96°6QL ‘299901 | ZZ ‘208 ee (eee ee ene 1830.1, “F

98 “298 ‘OTS ‘E Ze 6e FSS ‘ZT §~=—s|.—«HO. 69 ‘OEE ‘E PF ‘LPS ‘229 ‘E” 88 610 ‘029 ‘Ee 62 'OT9 ‘ves ‘e 89 ‘916 ‘008 ‘g 77777"*" "-serddns pu [e]1038ur Jo onjea—snid “g

62 "POL ‘8F6 ‘8 Lb TSS ‘ShL ‘bh | | OE BLL ‘EBL‘Z™.. | 09 829 ‘bz ‘6 99 "902 ‘Zz ‘6 10 ‘BLE ‘222 ‘6 ok.) > BR ebeneeeats pezesedo seul] pesee] jo onfeA—snjg *Z

LL 99% ‘S12 ‘HHIS | EB SBE ‘OLE ‘TeLs | Ie 08S ‘Sez ‘ObIS| 10 OLE ‘OZZ ‘OPIS | ZH ‘ERS ‘SoZ ‘EMIS | ZF GIF ‘S90 ‘EFI$ | 29 “CZF ‘9OT oc a! fae tt jueurdinbe pus pvol Uy yUeMysSeAu] “|

Bsvl0A Vy 18701, TS61 0861 “6261 8261 2261

apnea 7 193]

poled I8eX-¢ 381g Jequiedeq, pepue vox

0} 186 I ‘1G 4aquavagq papua suvafi ip

pup sasuadzea ‘sburusva ssos6 ‘sarddne"puv porsayow

-ureldurog

puayoo ay) 40f hupdwog pvospwy aur

IS61-L86I ‘porsed svah-¢ iof abvsaav pun yvj0} ‘aarsnpous ‘TE6]

T 1404S) U0ba1g ay} fo *9}a ‘amoour Burzosado fivmrps yau ‘sarv}

‘saul pasva) ‘yuamdinba pup phoy ut yuawmjsaauy—fuvdwo) pvospoy aurvy qoyg uobai—¢

, ‘IaOday “W01}s10}IO “AA YUBIY “FE-9I-¢ eq s,uoIsstuUIOD ‘squepueseq ‘As,quB

‘Wyoorddiy AA “Y SSOUTAA “8 ON FQIYXY “UL 9606 ‘ON JH0q ‘uorssrurUIOD VIIUWIOD 0} B4S19}UT

3 8 ON 0490 “9 ‘OI ise

8 QUA

tov

“ger ‘oe Tadv ‘GIN ‘4310 OAVT 118s “COWO 8,107} Pn V

€8°FIT ‘89 10°S89 ‘#9. | 89 $80 ‘6h 19 ‘E98 ‘Ee LE “S89"8Z ug “986 ‘el GL ‘691 ‘OT cma rr EO LE RES WOyeP peysqnumooy (LT)

7 28 ‘62P ‘E er 009 ‘10 “1€Z ‘ST 7 a) 08 "969 ‘8 28 ‘818 ‘E 6F 696 ‘S ee Se alltel (a1Qep) euooUy Buj;e1ed0 AGATE ION (91) .

ee rreunia: Sactcmeaas weimcrmuaa UP, Seemeeennnnnnt nr cr asecaad|scaseduagancos|nossecessescepns connsnenevooweceeererer Sect "S) iain: Ei a7

f 49 6II $6 “201 ge 020 ‘T 96 "$29 ‘I 8S "68 09 79% GE 68E £9 “889 ‘T PEATE ROL RAIN wqsp you—syuer yueuIdIND (41

Betas desacecalsvauesdastegua|ennasees seseee asses eee SSeS My nen res ata i gal ee ee ne SEAS Speiumereeaesncl gare Senusael ABATE O[G1}90[[00T /) £1)

° :

fr 20 se OIE t 8b 6b ‘S ZL ‘O12 ‘FI 61 ‘ese 2 '66L‘L zegss‘e == |: 61 09'S £9 169 ‘8 rae oe (s1qep) euoouy Suyeredo ABM T}CY 1).

q - 99-989 sen lower lesumey [truer [eevect jecwet [wr U ITI genes aed sores [BIOL (11)

OL “828 ‘I 88 7% ‘b 2 600 ‘ST 12 99% % 1g ‘cer'9 + | OF 697% 06 ‘092 ‘6 £9 ‘169 ‘8 eee sonueadel JA0 sesuedx A (OT)

9h 616 ‘I orn lwomer lee, [eras | ecsooe =| ev ze. $= | ugeeng sesuedxe Buyyes0d0 [P01 (6)

“gy SOFT 99 "62 Gi “S21 9T “E9T GZ “BLT LS ‘89 92 “LL w% CL REAR TRAIAN RAINE AS TF yereuep) (8)

Ei 96 StI 9 BLT 60 ‘OFL 0 ShL O€ “LLI ‘T £6 Z8F 61 ‘OeL SERS. eeteseheeaereaairmcee our] TVY—uopeyodsuBlL (Z) -

< 99 gt eI 1h $9 90 ZL 18°WL ¥6 Of 60 ‘SE RARE: eemermereneerees WELL (9)

en ae 10°€9 99 ZHE o8 "668 OI Z9E GI OST gI ‘BIZ adi “jueuudinbe Jo souBuesuTe Ww 8

QD yhL't w80I'y = | EB TIL'ZE | BOTT LL'scy'L . | 6L TEES 88 12h F 8b 940 ‘8 r semnpons}s pus AGM JO GOUBUSITIG, (F

gi ; SASNZdxz

. «oho 50 ‘981 | 69 026 ZS “162% 8h 608 % 86 ‘908 —< — r77--o—_" * senueael SupeIOO THIOL =» (8)

te ¥6 19 ¥6 (01 00°9° | BL 00°06 | 89 HT. S162 eae aa -sonsaaiaeeescenstene a &} i

£9 “618 OL SII$ GL 66S Zo “60 ‘ZS 9L ‘ZBL ‘ZS 96 “SILS 96 "880 ‘I$ 6L 790 ‘I$ wqayerd (1)

& — ; : | SEONTALE

a | .

= 1e6I oe61 6z61 S61 zl 9261 en be ty 7 wey

| :

a : ‘garenjour.‘TE61 ‘1g 4aquaceq 7 ‘Ye6r ‘GT fin}? ‘psousumos a1am suorypsado aq0p oY} wouf ‘oynp] ‘10q10,L, 0

QA uowuns joqzv,y, ‘younsgg 10970, 247 fo quyap paypjnunsop pup ‘aworut burzosado fiomprps jou “you—esquas figuprovf qurol ‘yau—squas yuo

4 -dinba ‘sanuaaas Anmjivs a791j0a2]/00UNn ‘sppnison xv} fipmpins ‘sasuadze burjvsado ‘sanuaaes burjyosadQ—fiundmoy poospny eUyT 1404S) uobeiQ

: F ; & ¢

e , . . ° " rf ‘

: royodayy “WOTISIENO “MAUI “Be-II-G SC “S.uorssurIOD “syuBpueyeq AS AUS

| 6 ‘ON 30490q s0usUly ‘ODI fate

er a 3 ii

250

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 251

403 Exhibit 10 . a 4

I. C. C. Finance Docket No. 10

Interstate Commerce Commission. ‘Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 10. Witness, A. Whipprecht. Complainant’s ¥, Defendant’s,

Commission’s. Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter. |

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company—Operating revenues, operating expenses,

railway ta@ accruals, uncollectible railway revenues, equipment rents—net,

joint facility rents—net, and net railway operating income of the Talbot

Branch, Talbot Junction to Talbot, Idaho, for the period January 1 to March

31, inel., 1932, and accumulated deficit since Judy 15, 1924

Jan. 1 to

Item . March 31,

incl. 1932

REVENUES

BFreent Meeks a leknnnnamakica hain, Ue amaned acadahae en enaeckinee cadena sheanenesadecubie $69. 25

oes ie nya ap oon et EEE Se EE RSL: SEE aii

. (3) Total operating revenues.._____ SSSA EL SR ED 69. 25

. ‘ EXPENSES =

( Maintenance of way and 0 SN toed SLL AES ae OE ee 265. 11

I i ee sacacabandemacecac 246. 92

u _ SRS See eee Dias Rah aang a aae keh d ndncdaoaatediak 17. 41

In 418. 01

EEE Ca a PSE. Ponesdcadedhaadédentenmens 44. 02

(9) I ait cen latent ncdinchtudndos peskbdewiasseedanaianes 891. 47

tle a, AES ED act OEE PES Lae a RA fae 822. 22

ae aces RTS NRE RE a ea IAI a RTM REY 359. 14

(12) Railway operating income (debit).....................-.....-.-- Bre eccae discean 1, 181. 36

ee rae eeacel CREE

nn apni SeE rie an 63. 80

co RE a a Te es em

(16) Net railway operating income (debit). ...............-.....222..---------------- 1, 245. 16

(17) Accumulated deficit since July 15, 1924... ne eee een eee enne neve ee eneee 59, 359. 99

Auditor’s Office, Salt Lake City, Utah, May 5, 1932.

43764—vol. 11—36-——-3

252 UNITED STATES ET AL,-VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

404 | Exhibit 11

I. C. C. Docket No. 11

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 11. Witness R. Whipprecht. Complainant’sy, Defendant’s,

Commission’s. Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company—Statement of revenue freight, showing

cars and tons of carload freight and tons of less than carload freight, by

commodities, originating on and destined to points on the Talbot Branch 8eg-

regated by years as to forwarded from and received on the Branch, for the

period sad 15, 1924, te Dec. 31, 1931, ine. ‘

|

Originating at points on the Talbot Branch Destined to points on the Talbot Branch

Year Commodity Tons Commodity Tons

aa

auleses i es & unite

Auditor’s Office, Salt Lake City, Utah, April 28, 1932. -

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 258

405 vie Ewhibit 12 -

1. C. C. Docket No. 12

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 12. Witness R. Whipprecht. Complainant’sy, Defendant’s,

Commission’s. Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company—Statement of revenue freight; showing

cars and tons of carload freight and tons of less than carload freight, by.

commodities, originating on and destined to points on the Talbot Branch 8eg-

regated as to forwarded from and received on the Branch, for the period

January 1, 1932 to March 31, 1932, inclusive

Originating at points on ‘the Talbot Branch Destined to points on the Talbot Branch

Year Commodity Cars | Tons Commodity. Cars | Tons

DO Fk nicn sss cccasissndatonas 11 379

ROR sss soncktactiescd 11 379

ee

De ee

wn

>

4

=

u

e3)

m

&

B

<q

a

m

=)

F

A

P

254

enueAey enueacy enueasy jar enuessy enueAey

00°" "H 00 ‘MH 00 "HY a tae 2 bytes nti 00 ‘a 'H , [00 (ae 10H.

‘1 'S"O “180 LT g°O cme seas oe a's iat eae 1°30} 8 quest ene

1£61 9g6t cet. 9261

oaienmjous ‘TE6r ‘Tg ‘00d 0} ‘F86T ‘oy Ane pomad ay) 40} szusod uonjnunsap puD supoh fq anusaas “0D ‘HY “U “T ‘8 ‘O

pup suo, Bujnoys ‘oynpy ‘40910,, 70 Ousyn14H140 p00 Jo squamdyys ppojivo Burn oys quaweinig—Auvdwog poospoy aur] 140U8 UobatO °

‘1lodey U10.1}812}4 *M YURI Ze-9T-8 078 *, WOISSTUIUIOL) ‘s juBpUuszoq ‘AS,jue

qeyooq, “UOTSsTUIUOL) QOIGUIOL) 9}8}S.10}UT

ST ON ROOM ‘0 ‘OD ‘I

sr nat 808

‘Ze6I ‘ZI AB ‘Quin ‘A31,) eX] 318g ‘COMO 8,40;;pny

“yoZhC] WIOlg—"ALON 1

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS, STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

LSE bb OR bf peice 1870,

POge BESS meted saeco) OYBP] ‘10870 4

LIl | 99 01z e Reezene: OYBP] ‘30101 A

Te OO Ce KERRI” OUP] “tOo/)

eterna. ONSP] ‘sTTey UAT,

19% 29 “LOI WED eter egaseseise > oqupy ‘eya070,1,

981 1S 009 AD scab amabesisens: oyspy ‘At

niches 08 ‘ZIT og T ceidaasbaaa oa Raqtaes ‘

i aaa Mactan SONI Cg

POE Ge Unie ROMER EmanERsETierse.. ouBp] aeine:

OFZ 98 Z6I WS wrngesecacse. Jiplghisicaie rae od

956 UNIFED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET Aly

408 Exhibit 14

sé. G. Docket No. 14

‘Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin., Exhibit

No. 14. Witness R. Whipprecht. Complainant’sy, Defendant’s, Com- »

mission’s. Date 5-16-32, Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Oregon Short Line Railroad Company.—Statement showing carload shipments of

coal originating at Talbot, Idaho, showing tons and O. SB. L., R. R. Co. revenue

by destination points for the period January 1, 1932, to March 31, 1932,

inclusive Q :

O. 8. L.

Destination Points . Tons | R. R. Co.

Revenue

Tee Ee ry ae 54.00

Pyke Siding --...---------------- Kc nandisicicdeciannnnehidsnasrhrsasniat Senet ee eens 161 209. 61

Be REE cnnnatpevndnstsseenennteneesseeteen en DinteneeaeeDeeEnTennOS OOS SS* 90 117.

) quscacdetnsatasssssasesesssssassesasesnasseeeesesaons 163 81.35

Bi BAIT « cnsinnetbapancacannnsaiasnecnnesnsetesinsssnitetntssse=aePeeseeereenneseee 35 48. 99

in sini kk aaah ARAAAAMATEEEEEA ALAA DSARAEAEOEEEB ELLOS ESS) 379 511.8

1 Note—From Dygert. _ : ;

Auditor’s Office, Salt Lake City, Utah, May 12, 1932.

3s

409

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

* Ewhibit 16

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096. Fin. Exhibit

No. 15. Witness R. Whipprecht. Complainant’sy, Defeffdant’s, Com-

mission’s. Date 5-16-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Oregon Short Line Railroad Co.—Statement of Carload Shipments (Other than

‘ Coal) from and to Points on the Talbot Branch Showing Date of Shipment,

Point of Origin and Destination, Consignor or Consignee, Commodity, Tons.

and Oregon Short Line R. R. Co. Revenue Segregated by Years as to For-

warded from and Received on the Branch, for the

December 31, 1931, Inclusive

257

Period July 15, 1924, to

Point of CO. 8.2

*Daneet os , R..R.

: Consigner or Con- *| Commodity | Tons} Co.

shipment , 3 Seer signee Reve-

Origin Destination & bd

; nue

®

FORWARD-

ED FROM

eee Pi acsainadnapatutcnnsssntnadceanckcbossvseeue ndekedauace f<csn ae beabsena[aaandalecceanca

Roasoee Dygert;"Fdaho---..| Ogden, Utah__-- Sterling H. Nelson | Wheat.......| 44] 345.86

0. ,

Re he ee et) | ae ae ee

Oe do.........-.---| Blackfoot, Idaho- Set Farmers |.....do........| 51 ee

g. Co.

Zee Nae do.......-.:-..-| Salt Lake City, | Inter Ocean Eleva- | Oats._.......| 35] 245.23

. tor Co. .- .

SSaerere Raver OBn.nccccscnsonss) Ogden, Utah. ... aus H. Nelson | Wheat.......| 46. 358.26

oO.

Srey freer EEE DEEME | YR RREnAS, |e Ree SEPP ese me oe ee ae fe

eee ee a TO SES RE ET ESRI Tonea Semenees a5 a

EE SRE do.......-..-::-].....do........-..] Sperry Elevator Co.|___--do......__| 46 357.38

Oe! do.......-..--..| San Bernardino, | Teton Valley Power |____-do._......| 46] 170.89

* Calif. & Mig. Co.

Total--..... ton dipsmamibiaplaniicndinann nianiatintncotiintlssnnnnadsoadsics 385 |2, 638.77

stan Dygert; Idaho.....| Kansas City, | 8, H. Nelson Co....| Wheat.......|_ 32| 109.01

P oO. ‘ :

Bence em cos i ctitknsatones oe Sate City, | Sterling H. Nelson | Oats____-_..- 29 | 185.90

. ah. 0. ‘

are See do............:.| Thornton,Idaho. inter Qaeen BVO}... G0ccuc0s.-| “41 1 116,56

tor Co. . :

Saar eee Wi cesocacsanss a City, | 8. H. Nelson Co.---] Wheat......:]} 45] 154.24

oO. ?

SESE, eee io TO SE” NEES VERS See nee eee 44 148. 08

SSS He do.......--.--..] Ogden, Utah_...| Sperry Elevator Co- 42°| 324.11

SERS SRD EEE: 8s, AS oe Basin Grain 47 | 370.06

0.

Seeoeee! Meare ee eT ee eT

A Se do.........-.-.-[2----d0_-....--...] Globe Grain & Mill- |___--do_......-| 26] 203.23

ing Co. | ’

a ee ECO CE TROL ECCT ERTS: OID CERI E PP ener ee WT 8 a

Coe He do.......-.-.-..] Thornton, Idaho} Inter Ocean Eleva- |_...do.-......| 60| 19249

tor Co. :

NN SSS Tm ee 443 |2, 406. 36

+

ewnanen nnn Dygert, Idaho------ *4, Valle jo, | Sperry Flour Co-..-| Wheat.__.__- -55 | 229.06

alif.

_ ee SY do........----.| Ogden, Utah.._.| Sperry Elevator Co.|_....do__.....| 50] 392.76

CE aE See a : os 30 | 234.00

Se eee | Seer ae: ER 42 327. 35

Oe ee ees eS 31 245. 41

ye AE: See ee 40 | 312.63

eee See | eee Fr Sa da 34] 142.94

- Calif.

Tae ee “ae Sas Ta SSE ereoree! Beek weet Gee iene

ee ee ee eee Pe eee ee “eee Se

a ae OB sg ecaacains ee ee City, es H.. Nelson |..-.-do.-.-.--| 31 87

i 0. }

258

¥

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

| Exhibit 15—Continued

Oregon Short Line Railroad Co.—Statement of Carload Shipments, etc._—Con

e Point of

p--+F Constgnes Con- | Commodity

Origin Destination

FORWARD-

ED FROM

BRANCH ‘ .

1987 |

io Dygert, Idaho..... Ogden, Utab...- Gicds Grain & MAME .

0. ‘

i eo sane Be. -cossnccescaaceged BO. o.cqeccce}oc 2 Ge « 2c ccceceseoe] oe Ge. sessed

pC Sage! err ee sae Ye Gis c6eesd

1 a BBs cavcesdcanes San , =e Bailey & Sons.....--.|----- do.

‘ Catt... --ccdl acsuccosnscodonsdisscannctipeoseninasens Can een

1998

: ne Dygert, Idaho Coulam, Idaho..' Arthur Caldwell. ...| Lumber......

3-22 do Ucon, I _..| Ueon Russett Grow-| Potatoes...

ers.

ee See See eee or

Idaho Falls Bonded | ----- , ea

a” a ey er

dsho.. ee ey oneaiael ee

=| aay Elevator Co. Waess esegpad

ey BO. < capcceccescalcqesBocccase

Sterling H. Nelson |----- Bis ecesed

Co.

E. O. Muir Co..-.... TEES

ceed BD. .cecccoccccece)scoedMeccccces

2 cil nsnetsnonasenaeneaned , ae

eat ee ae eee

aaa Be. .cccccacceccos]sscedeasesese

al , (as eS

eae: BO. ncacscscececs|cocedMacsseséc

aided Oe... concccccocdiecsedccacesse

Cl | (Ret ee aa

. C. Jacobsen......- Potatoes. .

E. O. Muir Co....-- RE

cael BB ncconccccceecalcccsdMcccccces

Pacific Fruit & | Potatoes...-.-.

uce C

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET “AL.

E whibit 15—Continued

Oregon Short Line Railroad Co. —Statement of Carload Shipments, etc—Con.

259

Point of 0.8.L

Date of ? R. R,

; Consignor or Con- | Commodity |Tons| Co,

shipment ose signee Reve-

Origin Destination : nue

RECEIVED

ON BRANCH : P

1995 -

- a Tetonia, Idaho... _. Talbot, sare... Teton Coal Co.___.. a ‘9}" 15.00

| aR Caldwell, Idaho..._|_.... ee Se ey “Re eee Rails, Angle 55 | 487.95

Bars,Spikes ;

eens 64 | 502.95

==

422 «(1088 ;

2-3...| Victor, Idaho..._._. Talbot, Idaho-. ee - Bear Coal Co.| Hay......._- 13 18. 02

eer Bete (| NE TRE _ _ EE SE “RENE L EE eee i adesiikiasia u 15. 00

| Sener i Vetiowstene, pened GPosdcoscces Teton Coal Co. ..... Boilers... .... 20 | 174.00

on shes

, Bucoda, Wn_......}..._. ee oe RR ee Lumber...... 32 186.18

i niininl GN, BE. cnccccalecced | SSS a ERE SESS i ctinasmes 2 | 250.

* Beare tneeare, CE <a RASS PR ERAS Machi ---| 27] 19280

en enefee, Wn__..../...._ i dstcssandceds ___ ANG Lumber...... 22; 130.19

, ae: Se eet! eee Pee 149 | 967.08

| as Dupont, Wn-____.. Talbot, Idaho Teton Coal Co._.._. senptesives. 2 15 | 407.96

ee Tetonia, Idaho.____}__. SEES Cava | ST sin sisieigthe ll- 15. 00

10-3... .... Driggs, Idaho... _._|..__- TDs cn ccncccapecosd do-.-......... ..| Lumber-_..:.. 16} 25.34

snes Weicnausbesdbibbaedicluasitsacastcoumudies ee 42 448.30

EE Eugene, Ore....__- Dygert, Idaho. .| Teton Coal Co_____- Machinery...| 20 | . 235.00

10-18_...... Lentz Jet., Ore. ____|..... ieniosaeaia G. W. Edging.-_.__- Lumber...... 46 | 226.54

NE SEI OEE, SEE geniesenennens 66 461.54

——_—_—__ + _________}

1929 ‘

ae Rawlins, Wyo. ___. Dygert, Idaho. . 1." Explora- | Pipe......... 27| 154.12

0.

EE SS SL A EE aT 27 |. 154.12

980 a

«fh

iticnnesd Ririe, Idaho........ Dygert, Idaho..| Grand Teton Oil | Iron Pipe....| 48| 378.11

° 0. °

;, Parco, Wyo......_. ae Tee Grand Teton Coal ba - = Iron 48 | 202.78

ee Bixby, Calif....___|____. Te Richfield O11 Co. of | Oil WellMa-| 24 | 225.48

Calif. chinery. e P

ae Eee Ane le mae | ea ee EERE me a a sical 46 | 433.06

m eS a ”

LOCAL

MOVEMENT

on

BRaNcn—

FORWARDED

AND RE-

CRIVED

[3 petemeos Talbot Jet., Idaho..| Talbot, Idaho...| Teton Coal Co_____. Gravel__..... 50| 40.00

en ee 7 So “SR a ER OS RE hLgeaDy 8 40.00

2 Ss = == <<] 8] $8

ee _ ES SSS QO Spy _ SECs Sey “Kea. 2.

etapesediesand A MEY dscentdiindicckdl Piitinsnuseataiadiinned isaidenl | 400

EE ! LL ED SRT ey 250 | 200.00

— FE RR ENT ans nogmmmnaiediendl 250 | 200.00

Audi's On, Sat Lake City, Ub, May 1, 1

43764—vol. u—36——4 ; -M

260

414

Interstate Commerce Commission.

Eahibit 16

UNITED STATES, ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 16. Witness, B. L. Penn. Complainant’s, Defendant’s, Com-

mission’s. Date, 6-16-82. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

Application Oo

Before the Interstate Commerce Commission

Finance Docket No. 9096

Railroad Between Talbot Jct. and Talbot, Idaho

EXHIBIT SHOWING

f O. S: L. R. R. Zor Permission to Abandon a Line of

1. Selected financial statistics taken from annual reports. of O. S.

L. B. B.toP.U.C.L. ©

_ 2, Comparative statistics for other lines’ and regions and districts ©

as reported to the I. C. C.

3. Carloadings for O. S. L. R. R. in Idaho compared with west-

ern district and the United States.

415-416 Oregon Short Line Railroad Co. —Comporative general balance sheet,

' 5.year period, 1927 to 1931, inclusive.

ASSET SIDE

J

a F Balance at close of year

4 5 Item

< a 1931 1930 1929 1928 1927

s

‘INVESTMENTS 2

701 Investment. in road and

equipment...........-..... 46, 238, 580. 31/146, 220, 310. 01/143, 755, 543. 42 143, 055, 419. 42/142, 106, 475. 67 .

702 | Improvements on leased

railway property.-.....-|--------------|--------------|--------------|--------------]--------------

703 | Sinking funds-_---..-------}- Sol cnasbs cacul nesses kas Zene|nsacbecesennes SRR ees Eee

704 | Deposits in leu of mort-

gaged property sold-.--- _ 1,613. 78 BARE Tle oc ccncxecansfacsaccessenacslsacudannaonsas

705 ooo ee physical

Moe ciehahamhias a cede 103, 452. 38 103, 328. 67 1038, 155. 67 103, 154. 62 103, 087. 35

706 Investments in affiliated j

com ies: -

A Stocks. Lcsin Ramee a 51, 604, 100. 46] 51, 694, 100. 46) 51, 694, 100. 46) 51, 694, 100. 46} 51, 694, 100. 46

5 — De ia tadneta 26, 471, 980. 00 26, 471, 980. 00 26, 471, 980. 00 26, 471, 980. 00 26, 471, 980. 00

ES A aS RRS ee Pree Sees Sa

: D) Advanices.._...--- 12, 332, 534. 69| 12, 276,708. 10) 12, 202, 635. 06) 11, 169, 245. 88) 11, 189, 648. 58

707 | Other investments e

rrr 41, 083, 079. 78] 41, 083, 079. 78 ag 179, 879. 78] 52,774, 572. 44] 50, 204, 108. 1¢

oF ee 1, 712, 800. 00} 1, 712, 800. 00 1, 712, 300. 00} 2, 105, 978. 50 L, 663, 178. 50

oe ca Wicasncsaccacs snccdsncncdeadianesnsaneeqns | sacnesdeeendcabebadcaanascaae

D) Advances-.........|--------------]--------------]--------------]--------------|-------- Peper

(E) Miscellaneous. ---|.--.----------|--------------]--------------|--------------]------------9"

CURRENT ASSETS ;

6) CMMs des scaexduanssanen 1, 012, 803. 93 758, 255. 34 662, 805.41 | 1,084,913.53 | 1, 104, 425. 45

709 ——— loans and de- ‘

710 whine dr drafts and depaaits. ee eee gia % 000. 00 me 000. 00, “$i aaa 380

pecial deposits --...-...-- , 600. , 560. : ‘ ’

712 | Loans and pills 9 Siang egreneet RIPR tan oe 1,728.85 | ° ” "900.00

713 and car-service ‘

balances receivable-_.-.- 836, 120.15 | 1, 055, 432. 95 817, 001. 46 925, 031.65 | 1, 137, 805. 28

714 | Net balance receivable ; ‘ :

from agents and con- :

ductors...« 125, 432. 03 154, 556. 05 169, 421. 63 231, 756. 16 171, 197.49.

Total investments. -|279, 638, 141. 40/279, 563, 908. 15/285, 120, 094. 39) 287, 374, 451. 32/283, 432, 578. 72

ST ee ee

PSUS al che Renee

Ce ee ee ee

UNITED STATES ET AL. V8. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 261,

| Evhibit 1 6—Continued

Oregon Short Line Railroad Co Comparative general balance sheet, etce.—Con.

- ASSET SIDE ;

- ‘3 Balance at close of year

) :

° g Item

b r=] 1931 1930 1928 19% ivz7

CURRENT ASSETS—Con. ? :

715 | Miscellaneous accounts re-

: Ss 318, 995. 67 445, 892.50] - 356, 446.03 638, 301. 24 354, 050. 61

- 716 | Material and supplies____- , 336, 639.04) 3, 622, 247. 43) 3, 570, 019. 88] 3, 524, 516. 3, 500, 916. 68

717 | Interest and dividends re- : : :

a SS: 607, 193. 78 607, 199. 91 607, 209. 47 615, 909. B04, 120. 36

718 | Rents receivable--_-__.__._- 3, 798. 4, 011. 95 3, 881. 4, 063. 06

719 | Other current assets... .... 7, 435. 11 52, 211. 31 15, 188. 61 27, 645. 77 23, 303. 88

Total current assets.| 6, 267,017.71] 6,757, 423.96] 6, 233, 228. 83] 26, 879, 008. 90) 27, 908, 302. 67

_DEFERRED ASSETS * iS |

‘72 | Working fund advances... 8, 909. 15 11,310.23] ‘11, 524.73 16, 232. 9, 201. 88

ve Wha Geen eee ae Ean: eRe iaena (amma tmaes

722 | Other deferred assets ___..- 97, 026. 85 94, 626. 05 53, 970. 74 65, 251. 47 60, 800. 57

Total deferred assets. 105, 936.00} 105, 936. 28 65, 495. 47 81, 484. 15] 70, 002. 45

UNADJUSTED DEBITS : ;

723 | Rents and insurance pre-

miums paid in advance__ 133. 50 123. 10 93. 60 80. a 70. 00

poe eS eee Se eens a ee ie iusmenaals

FO ae SEAS ee CR eeEe MeanEsseNnEN e

72%) Property abandoned :

— le to operating ‘

De RSE | ee ee Se i” aera

7 Other unadjusted debits--. 745, 221.77 854, 383. 84 852, 194. 55 887, 032. 044, 541. 93

728 | Securities issued or as- M

CO Se | Se Sees ene A ee aren

729 | Securities issued or as- i

we eR ERS, OE eS Ree! es ee kes, Sn ae

Total unadjusted ;

| RE 745, 355. 27 854, 506. 94 852, 288. 15 887, 113. 49 044, 611. 93

Grand total.......-. 286, 756, 450. 38}287, 281, 775. 33/292, 271, 104. 84/315, 222, 057. 86/312, 355, 495. 77

417 ¢ LIABILITY SIDE

STOCK A ‘

751 | Capital Stock......._.___- 100, 000, 000. 00/100, 000, 000. 00/100, 000, 000. 00; 100, 000, 000. 100, 000, 000.00 .

752 — liability for conver-

SECO) SEE Ea Sere as A Ta, aa AA a

753 | Premium on capital stock -|--.......----2]-- SPE EC CCE DEUCE an EES (ADSI

Total Stock-........ 100, 000, 000. 00/100, 000, 000. 00) 100, 000, 000. 00/100, 000, 000. 60/100, 000, 000. 00

GOVERNMENTAL GRANTS 5

754 | Grants in aid of construc-

tion Mh -nennnnonenenecousinr 206, 379. 55 202, 687. 05 201, 348. 61 196, 439. 37 193, 978. 43

LONG-TERM DEBT .

755 | Funded debt unmatured_-| 75, 545, 000. 00 75, 545, 000. 00) 75, 545, 000. 00 120, 545,000. = 545, a

Aa eens Tipirehianty nanmameetS ‘nents

757 | Nonnegotiable debt to

‘ ted companies:

‘* NE es a lea ee en 5d Guana locnannancad Uaekeanakdadannents inennennanns

B). Open accounts....} 7, 597,300.17} 6, 778, 264. 65) 12, 993, 271. 06|.............. iibincanecsines

Total long-term debt 83, 142, 300. 17) 82, 323, 264. 65) 88, 538, 271. 06/120, 545, 000. 00) 190, 545, 000. 00

CURRENT LIABILITIES

SE SELLE CLL, LE TD CE

759 | Traffic and secacie

balances payable....._.- 152, 086. 86 187, 486. 36 152, 128,38 157, 693. 63} 149, 714. 66

t

Oregon Short se Railroad Co. —Comparative general balance sheet, etc-—Con.

»

Ewhibit 16—Continued

LIABILITY SIDE

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

a

~ .

=)

. 3 mutants at close of year

4 E Item ;

< =] 1931 1930 1929. 1928 1927

CURRENT LIABILITIES—Ccor. : a

760 | Audited accounts and 5 ; :

wages payable-_....-.---- 1, 506, 328.27) 1, 868, 640. 97 2, 120, 554.61] 2,798, 530. 13

761 a —— - wane accounts ;

PEO 14, 554. 51, 14, 329. 48 13, 190. 45 11, 206. 55

762 | In et casas’ anoald., 825, 798. 50 842, 078. 50 860, 953. 50 , 786.

763 | Dividends matured unpaid) --------------]--------------]-------------- prsnrrnn nnn enn nnn

764 | Funded debt matu

onpeté............-.----- 46, 000. 549, 000. 00 22, 000. 3, 000. 00

785 — dividends de-

766 | Unmatured i an Pe er) ak ae RTS Qe Pri ee ee

SS Se eS 143, 540. 00 143, 540. 00 293, 540. 293, 540. 00

767 | Unmstured rents accrued. 18, 347. 20 26, 634. 91 25, 705. 29 37, 854. 70

768 | Other current nt liabilities... 41, 588. 22 55, 648. 38 65, 703. 11 52, 168. 06

Total current liabili- ; ;

GE centdacnsancied 2, 783, 643. 05) 3, 651, 900. 62 3, 548, 340.59; 4, 203, 898. 91

DEFERBED LIABILITIES

769 Leningy for provident ,

418 las

770 | Other deferred liabilities -- 35, 638. 75 78, 710. 31 45, 224. 55 63, 331. 51 81, 531. 23

Total deferred liabii- ;

ee 35, 638. 75 78, 710. 31 45, 224. 55 63, 331. 51 81, 531.3

UNADJUSTED CREDITS :

771 | Tax liability ---..-.---.--- 1, 459, 504. 66) 1, 821, 106. 29 2, 497, 475.63] 1,906, 850.22) 1 672, 829.31

772'| Premium on funded debt -|---.----------]--------------]--------------|--nnnrr nnn penn

773 | Insurance and casualty

CIE onancdsecatacens 809, 278. 33 740, 096.18} - 658, 988. 69 612, 991. 79 548, 445. 76

774 | Operating reserves. -------|--------------|--------<-25--|---00007>" A Er

775 | Accrued depreciation—

asa 132, 166. 88 112, 943. 30 94, 455. 77 79, 581. 42 65, 195. 75

776 ecrued depreciation— 2°

Equipment. ------------ 14, 762, 623. 64| 14, 161, 240. 65 13, 643, 939. 08} 13, 043, 316 37| 12, 927, 593. 10

717 | A de ion—

Miscellaneous physical :

778 Other unadjusted credits. 1, 876, 536. 13 "7; 602, 640. 33| 1, 598, 195. 48 "15967; 670. -68| 2, 103, 200. 56

Total unadjusted :

TT 18, 740, 109. 64| 18, 437, 926.75) 18, 493, 054. 65| 17, 410, 419. 48) 17, 317, 354. 48

CORPORATE SURPLUS

779 Additions to property

through income" and

Sa ar 6, 528, 205. 28 6, 529, 626. 08 6, 525, 031. 23) 6, 509, 639. 53 6, 508, 155. 68

F debt retired

through income and

CE costianatcanancnns 536, 828. 66 536, 828. 66 538, 828. 66 536, 828. 66 536, 828. 66

781 | Si fund reserves. ...-|--~-.---------]-----2--------]---------2-- == fo-ne sen nnnnnnnfonwnnnnnnonen

782 — fund

783 Approp EAs) ee A SAN BT mapa: pupTeepeet

cally invested._.-.| 14, 294, 901. 08| 14, 294, 901.08) 14, 294, 901. 08} 14, 204, 901. 08 14, 294, 901. 08

Total appropriated | -

. us......___---| 21,359, 935. 02) 21, 361, 355. 82 21, 356, 760. 97| 21, 341, 369.27 21, 339, 885. 42

784 | Profit and loss, credit bal- ;

ee err 60, 687, 689. 62, 094, 187. 59, 984, 544. 38) 52, 117, 157. 64 48, 673, 847. 30

Total corporate ; eS: ‘

i oe a eel 82, 047, 624. 72) 83, 455, 543. 52) 81, 341, 305. 35| 73, 458, 526. 91 70; 013, 732.72

Grand total-_....-- 286, 786, 450. 38|287, 281, 775, 33|292, 271, 104. 84/315, 222, 057. 86/312, 355, 495. 77

LOL EL PT TE EE RY PBS ha: > RI It re een

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS

TH TLB PIS ZI | ST 'SEO ‘TL “HT | COROT ‘ShL ‘HT | 68 °LZ0'OLE TT | FI E89 '09G'R [o-oo yoswehjosvenensaveeny eur uy s8011) €

20 ‘O9T ‘oE9 ‘*b Ly 189 ‘e886 | 6F'6K0 ‘zh =| OC ELT ‘COR’. | IE FIT ‘269 oO ae aah iil at aah ln dah ch euloou] Zulyeedou0N [810], a

89 982 T 16 ‘292 retaereonseusses 00°¢ OES Pireenn rece veresssseesnenctesv}icerseevenenseewsnsvensuavesqun euroouy snoeueyjeosiyy | 619 &

TAUNTED CO SRMEethED deipbtgaenemeos SEAS tod, CE geReN DEES Rear a Kee SeTUBdUI0D 10430 UOJ} SMOTINGIIIUOD | 8I9 “a

Sateen ot RATT RS eee Uaeeariaanbes Day vite citnat: woe TTT EET Tees" """"""""409H papuny UO suINyuTeId Jo esealey | LIF Ld

ada "> RB: SMart COONAN ENaC Gants, Seem cimeriedat: aes maces. SPUN} GAIESOI 19430 PUB ZUTHUIS WIOIJ OUODUT | OIG

SF C02 ‘Ty OT "29 ‘Le 6F ‘208 ‘92 89°892 ‘es pL '18h 61 ee eee a eer errr th ee 8}UN0908 PUB S9}}]}INDes pepuNjuN w10Ij euTOoUT | GIS H

¥6 “WP ‘Zzz ‘T ees Sewers POPC ee, [PSUR Tee foo 8" ss hesersesseseessdecewesheccesesisnssseetueeves 89}}]INIes pepuny w10Ij euTEDUT | $19 {

00 “60 ‘TIL ‘% Ol “SZ ‘190'S §=—| QO'208 ‘STE .| 00 'OPS ‘099% | OOGOL ‘SER T |--= 7 Tnnrrnrrttrrrrtteenn enter nen en ee nnn e nese nes “"--guroouy puepyatq | £19 3

96 “S82 6 88 ‘TST ‘6 ee a eee a _ dasa Sesabom Ag ie eegesiiis ee Yo1g—so} edoid peyeiedo ater eg | ZI

¥8 89 9° 08 ‘S£0 ‘6 9€ ‘IE ‘9 aI ‘998% erage neta stent tntele as trigbity Gaiden Ayiodoid [wojshyd Zuyyesedouou snoouspjoosi | 11S t

OF 'B¥z ‘FF 20 ‘Z6E ‘08 $F ‘816 ‘89 66 ‘ETT ‘29 29 "109 ‘ez tt” SAR ead expences ode) ‘ates phlei vies @uL09U} yueI snoguBT[eOsI | O19 =

rT 6Iz ‘so BL “SOL ‘9 Th 892 ‘29 22 969 ‘29 ZS 699 ‘29 "re Reet atta aa EN (ERRNO e ee PBor JO see] WI0Ij EMT | 609

£6°89L ‘eZ, | 68 GOL ‘OFT 8 600 ‘OST ZE 26S ‘SbI PI ‘916 ‘Zor Tinea aka ant ania ie AORN ROh ecracAN Shape eUIOsUy yUed A4I[108} UTOL | BOE

WO '8t9 ‘9 12 962 ‘9 99 ‘219 ‘b ¥8 692 ‘9 Dy SSD Regie maeateeepeiatcideeetsbil bere ur bnighisbtnaieh to ddehese ras bhd: queuldjnbe x10m uI0Ij JUeY | 209

ee ee ee itor Gh Laan iinet tats mmm: ij. j= .. &) |

92 ‘L¥0 ‘961 - | 00 ‘98> ‘69T £E “609 ‘T0Z OL '8E9 ‘S9T 98-“98T ‘SFI Pecan artes soe aes Nee Bites Ree sehen lise S180 U}81}-103T' ur0yj 4Uex | GOS

£8 “ILL ‘0 $8 'SLb ‘ZZ £9 "229 ‘61 _» 3 AU <0 ADR aenaeteeeeneconmieccis mosepetahsedeiageistetegecoos wm boy quey | 109

WROTE ARRE NS tee | oman aataeairgata wih aatabarhaate cipieedatalcintl yulei la iair alana et ecabe ait 1 dal eihat €-@OUBTRq F{PolQ—SIBO 443]OIj JO 1] | LOE

GHMOON! ONILVUAGONON ‘I :

be TTS ‘BLz ‘8 99 "EFS ‘268 ‘6 S “EFT ‘£08 ‘6 £9 “P98 ‘99b ‘2 ik AR RNa eae aie alah eur0ou] Zu1;e1ed0 [8}0,7,

Eom Linco pseeaebe, Daaemieebnied) Aboteebaen ae ‘sperma aed debhacebar awa apairecnhds noite eo euI0OUy Zuy}e1ed0 snosuBT [ss PY

bite LAS DOA Ie: celeb ociopebieies letras: |... Te eeseensss==""Kqradoid Zayje1edo snoeuvy[eostur uo sexes, | SES

MRR IGR i Mees Gers eR otis “Sunteebge gaat lichlekaeakdes ues Deikgie dedi idescabectairs aan SUO}{BIEdO SNOEUB[s0s}UI UTOI] ENUGAGI ey

SR ARAN SEIS SORES: PUR DeNEReS proc[prcprcicotctcrssesssstecrsssosssss2-"""5""=====gqgragiado snosUs|[eos|ur Jo sesuedxy | ¥EE

oneet a eNNS RNAS: cubated sete aes ponenne boss|ocscccscscanescccscecarorasaos-==-=----=--=-gHOIgBIOdO SNOOUBI[OOSIUI U0} soNUEAey | 209

ve “TTS “82z ‘8 99 "EFS ‘268 ‘6 | PS EbT ‘C086 *| £9 FES ‘OOF ‘2 €8 898 ‘E99 |-- RN oer he Dod oe me eee feesoveeseceseeseeguaeaes Buyye10do Ava rexy

10 00e'e 88 ‘169 29 989 ‘% 68 78h T PUT | forwn or oarserseseresenecosescereqeraraeecoccescorsonssigmmeags Apmsres eraroeroogn | ese

£9 “920 ‘92z ‘8 0 ‘16z ‘b ‘e £8 ZLZ ‘101 ‘F 40 ‘928 ‘90% ‘E i ED Te Ra anal alate cin hahaha hata nina cates dics iach, spensooe xB} ABMITeY | ZE9

$6861 ‘299 ‘TT §| €z‘9zZ ‘zee ‘st | 66'Z90‘206 ‘EI | 90°S99‘bZ8 ‘OI | 8b '6Ob ‘bE, SEE lata aia aa ahh cl ads incre suo}}eJedo ABA[TEI UOJ] ONUGAGI JON

WD '1b9 ‘Zr ‘bz €E SHI ‘688 ‘Gz | BB 'ZTF‘S99'9z | LE ‘zEZ ‘ZIT ‘ez | L8°6IT ‘COP st Reveuseweusheandenersseuevinvsendeeneees Sababapeteta nedobe tai. sesuedxe Zulye10do ABMIBY | TES

89 "SEL ‘666 ‘CE 99 PLB TEL ‘SE | SOLE ZOD ‘GE | SP29G‘TGGES | GE GIO‘LET ‘ZZ [-- "* nooo nnn nnn rrr nn nen nee nnn enen SeNUeAes ZuTIBEdO ABAIIBY | 109

; ° ; ; : AMOONI ONILVURdO ‘I '

Lz61 8261 6261 O86T TS6I .

Joquinu

u104] queasy

—I804 04} 0} o[qeoi[dde yunoury

garenjour ‘TEET 02 LEE ‘savah oy? 40f yunosop awosuy—‘o0p poo.wwy eury w40yg) u0baiQ GIF

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL

3 *sein3Yy ped sezwo{puy 1

8% “PIG ‘986 ‘9 86 22 ‘PL ‘S* | ST “BSL ‘909 '8 eR, CN, Sooner eran etre neers renee tn EE; euloou] ZuTywiede AvMIVI- ON |

88 ‘CPL ‘LZP ‘T L9 “160 ‘69% ‘€ amore. i tecaomees | ORcseI ene | [ort Beds SSO] PUB 1GOId 0} PelIejsUBI} BOUB[Eq EULOOU]

Lv “261 ‘000 F 00 ‘000 ‘000 ‘6. | 00°000 ‘000 = | 00°000‘000*F Syoranantwncasnssannewanremensoee ee oe SS te ee a

ee ce vaste er ciate tgs ielatea| (agai arrestee crak! eps ak cranes’ | aetna (IR ecgenpe Gee ussae yes = aero nore as <a es eTIOOUI JO suoy}slidoidde SnoousB[[sosiw | gee ”

rc cegiavemheache ek “Kia sR Rk DRS WACSIRACOE NGI SMRSUNNes Tneiies (NERE NE ER ae EP aUsOoUT YBNOIY} poystnsuljxe yUMODSTP. Y903S | sos

Reeie ee ee wae Ee See Te era ee te oT A a ne) a aoa 2-2 2------]--------------------------- Ay redoid peolshyd Ul yWEUT}SeAUT 10} pozelidosdde ouloouy |. -

00 “000 ‘000 “+ 00 000 ‘000 | 00°900‘000‘% | 00°000‘000*R =f Shp che ake N GR Ea Be RL eumoguy jo suoryelidpidde pueplaiq | e99-

ere eS er et SPUNy OAJOSeI 19430 PUB JUTAUIS'0} poljdde euroouy | Zs¢

. ; AAOONI LON 4@ NOILISOdSIC “AI

SE "SES “BZF ‘ 19 “160 ‘69% ‘L 89 '9h9'ZEL ‘2 | £€°680'80Z'9 =| 08 "81 Mee " areaceoaianabdaiehai de AN @UIOOU! 19N

90 “‘9eF ‘OBE ‘L ov eer ‘z9e‘L -| Sb'LHG‘Z10'L | 99 BeB‘T99‘S | FE SEE ZOS'G © |-~TTTTn @ULOOU] SSOI3 MOI} SUO!JONPOP [BIOL

£0 “16 ‘bI eh OFF ‘ST $8 "612 ‘LT 68 “bL1'T * | TERS cr reseneasionudewceaypairzeieeenit tenes SeBIBYO SUTOOU] sNOEUBTOOSIW, | ISS /

I aes ian ean oti meals Daman inn bieieumaey (ial anne ener enn n nn nnne nance eersssteseeeo- "8" “sgrmBd M100 19470 0} PeLlesUB1} EMO] | OGG

ue SSlb ea: Neen ee ne a Creat tata Tatatatate (late ~~ WO] }BZ]UBZIO.{UOUI}SOA UT JO souBueUIB WY 6S’

ee ee a MR eT Sige ey 4 ee ee ae eee ee ea Aieak haces ee Ten meee Seas ess wees Sees S TE pepunj UO ZUNOOSIp Jo UONBZjIOULy | Se

0€ 926 ‘2 49°20 ‘OT +0 690 ‘E 1 29.406 ‘S 86.°99T ‘9 ~ | aaa ERSTE A SEED EN RA EE Mie 2 ae 3qep pepunjun uo 4se1ez0] | LH

00 “OLF ‘ZIT ‘S 00-OLF Zits | 92-0ee ‘Zo6‘r | OO OLE Zie's | OODLE Zee [~~7n nr a ed 49ep pepuny UO 380I0)0] | 9bg

ce pnmaEee co eedamie ive aaiemite 8 WEF ‘IZ SF “GOI ‘69% weceecenccreccnccesccesotesctscere orate 777" 8807 —soy}zodoud pezesedo Ayoyeredeg | o49

Ce FOF ¥9 Z8Z 66 “OLZ 96 £82 LL ‘SSS ernatee ee een ee tee ee te eee S[BN.109B XB} SNOGUBT[OOSTW, | FF9

£8997 CE “LBL 99 "S6E 99 "E68 ON Migr ee ee iin bal EEC RRR ET SjUe1 SNOGUBTSOSI WT |. E49

¥E “26 19F L686 19h 2 "60 ‘TOF TZ “£86 ‘894 ae eta pee ee aed po woreeeccescessso "7 Speol PesEel 40j400H | Ze

90 "£29 ‘194 ZI “LIS ‘LET £8 “SIT ‘Ost GO “b2T ‘OFT 69 "620 ‘81 sgn SSRN NSN RE ASP OCIA. CRIP RITE syues A4IT}0¥) YUTOL | 1+S

¥6 029 ‘E 61 062 ‘2 ZI “982 ‘€ 09 ‘OS ‘Z 28 “ees ‘T icons ni Aah ssi is ph SAIC AR RIN ata eGR queudMbe y10M 10} 4UeY | OFS

Ree ee Pee ee ee ee ee a aeeoeast wenn nn nnn nnn cnn nnn nnn ne nn ncn nn neren ners teceecoororee=-""-gugmdmbe BUF} 40} 30% | BES

L¥ “861 ‘LOE 26 ‘SIL ‘OSE 18,920 ‘9z8 ¥Z ‘L0S ‘ZTE DD septs iat ARETE RIOR ARENT SEED S1B0 UYB1}-J03 Jo} quoy | seg

OL "626 ‘Eo 18 "LO ‘89 69 “612 ‘0eI TL “29L ‘SFI + | $9992 ‘I8 Si sch RLA RERUN CORY chet RAS PRCA SALI RENT Sane EP AE ~~ S8ATJOUIOOO] 10} MEY | Leg

80 “LOZ ‘296 $9999 ‘SIT 'T 9L S49 “E86 Gb FL9 ‘SSO ‘T TT ec gs cterac cis tuto iat cia cite cenaaiatans: | Niall soURlEg 31G9q—SIB9 44BTOIj JO OATH | OES

= I i i

QAHOONI SSOUD WOU SNOLLINGIC “I

Lz61 861 6261 Oe6t 1e61 ’

3 wey] aay

—e0k oy} 03 o[qBoi[dde yunoury

penuyw0og—sarenpous ‘Tg61 07 Le6I supah oy) sof unosoD suooUT—'oD Pro“pwY sUYT 140Ys U0ba40 02%

a

z

4

FE

,

E

a ar See

:

‘

STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 265

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS.

‘o°'O'!

0} 191389 Jo Spodey [wnuTy Wold

“seNZyY pel SeyBFPTT 1

0008028909 | GO'ssT ‘b60'Z9 | 00'MN9 We8 ‘8g | Go'ROT ‘ZIT ‘ZG | OO'LHR ELDER [~~~~ non on nor mn nnn mre enter enn nee n nn nn ns Jeoys eoUBTBG 07 peLIE;sUBI) COULTEG

00 'S8t ¥60'%9 | OO'MG ‘Has ‘8G | COBOL ‘ZIT Ze | OO'LHR ‘GLO ‘RE | OO'QOE REE ‘LE [-~~~no nono nn nnn r nner nn ern nnn nnn nee nnn enn nen nnens = 1004 Jo SupUUSeq 38 COUNTER

2 eT kT Ok RE kt a & Se i ete et tee Iv04 ZUjINp esBes0U] JON

00 "660 ‘600 > 00 "829 ‘ITT 00 ‘Zoe ‘EIT 00 "Zoe ‘se GTS WH. — POPP ete mrrowencccoceecnccccccesccccccccscecccccestbeccccccoccccess 3804 SUpINP $7}QEP [BOL

00 (908 ‘OT 00 012 ‘9 00 ‘089 ‘te 00 £22 ‘I COWBD — [rrmesrereeceneencreeecennncrecenenceecncescercccseresconsccencscescscnsnednn MjQep sNoeAwILOs} Wi

PCa Ue kee rie Bae Ree SRS wen eRnenE RRR WinebeeeeenaseeneeameeeneRnCeRERtEnRnnnERnt? ME ||| me

00 FIL ‘69 00 “£22 ‘O01 WO OF ‘tr 00 “s¥9 ‘ee 00 6tz.'21 a RR CTA POEM TIE ER juemd|Abe pus peor perzyei uo s807[

_ Btenetantenceceslenecesneanseeeee| snnanceneaeecene|aneassnasseccrec|anscnnnnenecenee|seeeseerecetecaseaarecensesnneereerarssnescecseeeeeecete “Sntdins Jo Su0} WIdOIdds snoeaEl|oIs} WL

ELLIE EIDE EE! PEE CE LA IAEA S AEE. eocssececsececcooaperrarcesevececccerserore=ap¢=etpiaas imma aetna eas

0O"1e Ts 00 969 + 00 ‘t6e ‘ST 00 "Ve “I OO VOID rrrn nnn neeh ence n en nen enone een eceenenee Aqedoad [eoj84.gd a }700UI3804 UT Jo} per dv snidang

CaN: GE SOO Bae hel) TREORRREER RORREEEE -eeseeeeeNaheteEeaREneaeeatE bare. snidins jo saoy} de pueplaicd

ay I Wd) WLIO WRI TO DS OER RE RN AmeONNeNe

NYT SOS) EMEC APRESS BL AOReeeD and! “ee pee SCS” RRR aa a ata aa atin ir aerate agrees @WIOOU] WO PallejsuBs) GOUBTeg 4149CT

00 "668 ‘c99 % GOEL TEES | CO'UL USL § | CORIO ISDS § | CO TER UEST [~~ ~~“ “oomonenen nn nennnnnenennernnnororeronerncsensenenoresenses 1¥04 Supp S}Pesd [%70.L

00 "woot 00298 ‘t 00 'sa0 688"E | 00'LEy + MIRE a. penance epemcnncsDea pT ma RTS GARR NELURE ARRAN URIS DSLR EL. Spas SNOEUET[I0ST

0O'1ze ‘Tr 00 ‘969 ‘+ 00 '26E ‘ST 00 ‘Wet ‘I ——; HRI sapcep eas ages aacagetssnceeca NAC ans “paes aad ta ld NNN RSP suo} BAO]

00 ver ‘Z 0O'lIZ ‘> 00 "600 ‘f 00 'SIh 9 GPU. — PROAMF OC Ct rereoowoocccconescencecccccecswcccspsocesooscosaqecacssosso sam a8284920A0 o[qeUpunjalu yy

Seececesorcecccelocccevccscocces GOT GRR [Ott t tee eteee ti eses esses scores tfoceccceccccccccccccccescocccccoccccccrencccoccosccososetccsosscvesoccors® 9) eumlood} persed

ou: 00 ‘Oey 00 oF 00 's8 MES are nce PARRA? LIAO RRS IERTI SETAE IEEE plos yueudmbe paw peos Go 101d

COU BVT «=| COOMBES | CO MOTELS | OO'ZOO'OOPE § | COERL*LED'T [oon nn nnn nm neem nnn nnn nnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnnennnnnn ns @ULOOU] MOI} PALIE;SUBI} GOULTEQ 3}Pel_)

1281 0861 6261 8261 Lz61 <

—Te "Seq Suypue 30d,

1861 ‘1g °20q Ouspus potsed savefi-g ‘oD “y -Yy eur] j40Yg Uuobesg ‘yuno220 880] pun pfosg

266 °

+

‘UNITED STATES ET AL. VS, STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

“OD “A "AH SAW] 1G PUY sees SOT “OD PeOoITeY oul’ 11048 WOSO “OD UONBI|ABN P PROMISY TOIZUTGs¥ A -WOSCO :spwos FU} MOTIO} OY) SOpBOU}

ooze “ON IEUIEIBIg “O °O “I :AIZ0qINY

“‘psoeyY opsoeg Woyay) Ul pepnpouy ¢

, POs 6O78O/PUT ¢.

Ms") ‘a “YH Opped oyu)

§ 9pjoeg woyaK +

090 ‘6 008 ‘99 ote ‘69 912 ‘89 830 ‘99 vis ‘gor * | $29 ‘OST OF ‘OL eR eae RAMEN AB LOT OEE NOES 2 WO} WATVAVH [OL

get 80 ills 969 £6h« ZRE 96F ‘t ee ee sso] PUB Igor 07 perze;sUBI) OM0OT]

ad a] SI ez" 98 £99 % 096 ‘9 te} Se ee ne euloouy JO sUOHwAdosdde [6}0,L

ot vot L19 08‘ eRy «£99 % \| 096 ‘9 Mt ~ss--787"7""7"“gmydans pus urvody JO suopywyadoudde puep}ald

eee ves 6% ¢, 618'T R0F « 980 ‘t ao '8 ERE, secnerinanecomnananaencrss SELDEN PAII 08 HY ouLoouy 39N

OLt % oes ‘I 129't mL% 08 008 % \L¥e'9 ee eulogy Zuyje1edo AmTIey 10N

PAG ta. AA Webel. webbed abet wert sete Sesswecesecece|osesesqpecoccsiocesoncescorscccosess*** "BERR BEC oyu 10d sesus0A V

gee ‘129 ‘96z '61| exz ‘B00 ‘916 ‘S| eze ‘vee ‘08 't] 260 ‘siz ‘918 't| 260 ‘zee ‘ez ‘t| ver ‘L¥o‘vH0'l| Sze ‘eRe ‘z99 | OOF ‘ZHI ‘ERT [o*"--nnn TTT TTT WO}zSzITEIIAe [830.1

ea ‘L698 =| OKO 'GUZ ‘S| WOE WOT Ts | GOI 096 RE | GBI ‘HOI ‘Wee | Eze ‘ooL"s § | ev 'TEO'G =| BBI'RID TTT Ss0| PUB I90Id 07 peLdejsuIBIy eMCON]

Ove ‘CO0 ‘BOT «| OUS‘LIO'TL §=| IIe 'RHO') «=| EVE '7Z8'Z9 | WOR OLI'b =| HEB 'OI ‘9Z =| HCR ‘DI ‘He te SE. SDAA AEE KE Cuneees 5 areeeeeee AS,

TOI ‘EVs ‘BE | OBO DOT THI | ZL ‘SET «| HET ‘EHOZOT | GLL'GzO'es =| HER‘OIE 9G =| HEB ‘IZ 19% t ~-S-sse=e-=-""-gnydINs PUB GUTOOU] Jo SUO}IB}Idosdds puepyaid

986 OOT ‘Thi =| OBTLZ6'OR = | 66 "L165 206 ‘ZLL ‘101 | eRe ‘226 ‘6s | H90 RISES | TIEZHATE | SBI'BID nee eee eee enone eecomt Sursezedo @uldod} 19N

coz ‘szoez9 §«— | SiO RY ‘OOR | EvR ‘LOIS § | HHO 'MAD'RIT | Sci ‘BETO | TEP ‘ZO ‘be | 996‘00L6I | BCO'LOW'E | ormmoouy Suyyesodo LBmIVY ION

Ver, TH ee ‘VEL 109 “le £¥6 ‘99 628 ‘BF 628 6 ee. ee ork ere peresedo peoy JO S11

1219; 0110199 A 1110189 AA 1110189 yu1984shg , 1°80

T0150 A “qinog 18170@,) tyON ‘aa q‘a

swig pean) - :

2}1781C. U10}89M, UT STO{ZEx ™

"| Sepp ym posodwoo

a]0YM D SD 8aIDIK pajtuy) ay) pus 7014j8tp UL9jISAN Ut 849141D9 ; : y

‘TS61 s0af svpuaps oy) 40f°Y “Yd ') PuD“y “Y “T'S 'O 24) fo sways owoous puv uoryo2spoprd00 Durmoys juawaqnis Zep

UNITED STATES ‘ET AL. V5. STATE OF IDAHO: BT AL,

423

267

Statement showing fived charges and net auneshe and number of times

fired — were earned for the five-year period ending Dec. 31, 1981.

0.8. L. R. R.

Subject

1330

Rent for Leased .oae

Miscellaneous

Interest on funded ‘debi

Total Fixed charges_.__

Net income

Total “Fixed Charges”

and “Net Incomo’’._.

Number of © Times

Charges earned

463, 084

3, 312, 470

2, 904

11, 011, 371

13, 054, 311

9, 987, 841

Interest on unfunded debt__.

Amortization of discount on

’ funded d ebt

; ae Fixed Charges...

Net Incom

Total ‘‘Fixed Charges’”’

and “Net income’’__-

Number s t Times Fixed

44, 064, 172

10, 671, 057

44, 257, 401

10, 571, 262

38, 718, 716

-31, 842, 311

55, 124, 158

54, 928, 458

49, 289, 978

42, 292, 619 |.

_o 498

5.15.| -

4. 66

4.05

“UNION PACIFIC SYSTEM}!

oo

-

Interest on oe cow be debt___.

Amortization of Discount on

funded debt

3

Total Fixed Charges__-

Net Income

: “Total “Fixed Charges”

and “‘Net Income’’___

Number of Times Fixed

Charges earned

489, 647

6, 787

22, 276, 139

172, 401

108, 859

479, 709

6, 893

21, 737, 354

145, 119

- 108, 859

456, 21

7, 60

19, 838, 447

* 206, 490

108, 859

23, 053, 833

50, 036, 689

22, 477, 934

53, 186, 783

“| 20, 617, 316

29, 988, 084

110, 063, 759

219, 474, 300

78, 090, 522

75, 664, 717

50, 605, 400

329, 538, 059

of

3.37

2.45

2.99"

; ned Figures

not cite figures shown are taken from previous years.

omy Atal ee nited States’, Annual Reports to the

Statement No. 3260.

¥rom “Statistics of Rail-

Public Utilities Commateston of Idaho, and I. C. ©.

* Union Pacific System Includes: 0. W. R, & N. Co., L.A. & 8. L. R. R.,0.8. LE. R.R., U. P. R. R..

43764—-vol. 11—36——5

268 UNITED.STATES ET AL. V8. STATE OF PAHO BT AL.

nd net income and number of times fixed charges were

% | yagng |. SUEDE SSRNER SEER*R EEEES SONESS

g | Beaaa | .

& \-gyy | Senge ABESRE B98GR2 AESSEA SRSESE |.

ET | BSE | aaeaee queeee duced eedkes 4888:

2 dis scene? Gagade SSMSSy Sesesy aeEEEE

2 =O: a , ) Teese 3.

g , | RBSSAR SaGsRs Sez2ee RERERR S8ECE=

E & | seeeed £8682 beekss gagssi eieess

3 | 2 | seassq dagsed see's degted CA88=8

ow a ‘ = i

¥i |

83 z, | S2eg82 NeBReS senda Setees REEREE

sz | Hf | sagged sdeadl Sddaka ceddes SCZEKe

: F = idsuse Henssg Stecsy WAakRs SEE8=8 +

S |geq_ | Guegad GuRaGN GB2ESE dauas2 Faget

2 | #8 | gdadea seeded “""°SS Geeees Gaede

= EgS AaAddad - Serr 2 aactetetes gv

$1 te ; i «

Q ©

8 | gy SEE82R ANSERK EERRRS SSSSE RRRAEA

=| aa mreererrerermertrrr@ iti Mt

& Eee) ft eit aecelid sof Sit eddecye Saididsg

© ge. Ain

2 |, | See8a8 desneg degnee eaznke 2508ge

S| Sx, | gyeidd ceeeae sisted Sddeed HSsaes |

3 | #28 Sdadsg encddg ssdedg Sagads SSSSSs | 7

. | 4. -

_. Soaaag ekeacs Geysee fe3u96 E8528

S| §. || gaaaad secede S88tte saecae Gdedde

~ -aA aa -< - dade s ered

3

33 |__| gauges SebR88 AggEcs aesuee $5923 i

gS bay | seeuse Sealed eesaaa detics 2008 |

S$ | é4 addled gidgag Moers Edsdag SELES

gee Ear i

eo ; preety EGEEG TEETER EEEELE-LELEEL IA

: LEE EHELEL TELL TELELE PLM |

SELLE RLELEE EELLEE ELELEL TLETBE Ts:

a giiliELilipiiiibgial ie

4 bobo Pog aly

3 Poa a gt

2 EHP EEE: CARSEE giPEE EEE: FF

y ceotaar euenaa"2U86de > SOAE"yREREE™ | =

2 5

Zz S § 8

IES i a te Se

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. . 269

427 Statement showing number of times fived charges were earned by the

“ 0. 8. L. R. R. and Union Pacific System compared with Class I carriers

in western district and United States as a whole for the 5-year period

ending Deo. 31, 1931 ‘

|

it

S#ZERESN

:

£

—

o |i

Statement showing net income and rate of return based on Interstate

Commerce Commission valuation and carrier's book value

OREGON SHORT LINE RAILROAD COMPANY

1. C. C. Valuation as of V

Ww tal

LC.C. apital

Carrier's Book Value (Accounts 701 and as of Valuation Date... .-................... 1

Excess, Carrier's Book Value over I. C. C. Value as of Valuation Date........:...____- ,

,

1927 1928 1929 1930

Investment in Road and Equi

Materials and Supplies,

708, 716 150,711,818 | 147, 664,549 | 147, 988, 368 150, 600, 812

LC.C. Valuation 9, 049, 230 9, 049, 230 9, 049, 230 9, 049, 230

Net Investment for Fate making pur- :

141, 662, 588 | 138,615,619 | 128,930,138 | 141, 551, 582

6, 936, 914 8, 574, 323 8, 605, 758 6, 148, 561

4 90% 6. 19% 6 19% 434%

4.0% ‘5.81% |, 5.82% | 4. 8%

‘

Aathority: Annual reports to P. U. C. L. and from I. C. C.

rr UNION PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY

LC. C: valuation as of valuation daté

Excess

Net in

27, 574, 669

Authorit r From reports to Interstate Commerce Commission, annual statistics of Railways of U. 8.

and from direct information from I. C. C. ss ;

270

400 F

UNION PACIFIC SYSTEM!

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

~r

I. C. C. Valuation as of Valuation Dates ?......--------------------------+-++------2----7- 520, 881, 843. 00

Working Capital Included in I. C. C. Valuation. ----- SS LITT

I. C. C. Valuation less Working Capital ----------------------- a eens patiolbaieia 775. 0

Carrier's Book Value (Accounts 701 and 702) as of Valuation Date... ---------------------- 678, 511, 100. 00

Excess, Carrier's Book Value over I. C. C. Valuation as of valuation dates. -------------- 345. 00

1927 1928 - 1929 1930 ©

Investment in Road and Equipment, Materials and f

Supplies, and Cash; Accounts 701, 702, 708, 716....| 868, 741; 241 | 878, 302,629 | 893, 762, 566 | 912, 637, 924

Excess of Carrier’s Book Value over I. C. C. Valua- . ;

ee kaa teeanene ns esenaeans am 174, 202, 345 | 174, 202,345 | 174, 202,345 | 174, 202, 345

Net Investment for rate making pyrposes- ---..----- 694, 638, 896 | 704, 100, 284 | 719, 560,221 | 738, 435, 579

Net Railway Operating Income- ------.--- icaempns 39, 483,390 | 43,818,995 | 45,325.568 | 35, 297, 722

Rate of Return on I. C. C. Valuation Brought up to

PE I a ES EEE 5. 68% 6. 22% 6. 30% 4.78% .

Rate of Return on Carrier’s Book Value------------ 4. 58% 4.99% 5.07% 3.87% °

- ye From reports toI.C.C. Annual Statistics of Railways of U. S., and from direct information

‘om I. C. ‘ 4

1 Includes 0.-W. R. & N., 0. S. L., L. A. & S. L., and Union Pacific, °

2 Valuation Docket No. 329—June 30, 1916; Valuation Docket No. 1007—June 30, 1916; Valuation Docket

No. 26—June 30, 1914; Valuation Docket No. 1060—June 30, 1919; Valuation Docket. No. 102—June 30, 1916.

Statement showing number of carloads of revenue freight originated at

stations on Oregon Short Line in Idaho for years 1927 to 1931, inclu-

sive, compared with carloads originated in Western District and United

States, also percentage comparison using carloadings for 1929 as 100

431

percent

5 a Northwestern | Central western | Southwestern Total United

8 region - region region States

nated

Carloads Index; Carloads Index Carloads |Index| Carloads |Index| Carloads | Index

89 | 7 22.905 97 | 7,411, 808 96 | 3, 944, 320 51, 635, 806 98

100 } 7, 24., 410 97 | 7,601, 190 98 | 4,115,712 98 | 51, 589, 887 98

100 | 7, 447, 923 100 | 7, 726, 832 100 | 4, 220, 437 100 | 52,827,925 100

4 | 6, 366, 268 85 | 6,863,779 89 | 3,760, 949 89 | 45,877, 974 87

87 | 4,770, 332 64 | 5,710, 143 74 | 3,177, 969 75 | 37, 272,371 74

Authority: Monthly Reports O. 8. L. to P. U.C.1. Infotmation Bulletin of American Railway Ass’D.

: UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.: 271

} :

' 432 Statement showing number of cars of freight forwarded from Stations on”

: Victor Branch of Oregon Short Line as to commodities shown’ below for

the years 1928 to 1932, inclusive, and the first 3 months of 1932 :

3 3 =,/5 /34 a ; ,

g 2 sii< | 33 Z

> S a ee a S/ES/esio | a | 8

i) e/2)2)]2/ 2 |22|s*/ 22/2/23] 3

=) OlO!l|BE le la [o™lg 38 o/ala

1] 152] 989 2 2 | a ae 619

11} 165] 787 3 42; os] ‘1/...... 217 | 376

Ga 3 5 See oe |b et et 2| 331 | 365

aosass 76 | 587 1 1 1 | eee ed ee

pea 2 | nen TOS UN TOE NE eg BE

E - = .

& F

B/2/F/2/2 1/4] 8/2 Z/13/¢4

2}|A}o;aAl/olel[a ie; a]/e] s

ees eee Soe 95 hi 2 eae A ee 33 7] 260 |_____. 266

SOREN E RCE. 5 aes 149 } 2 awe, 34 9] 249 |.--___ 86

SEC GoRE Rie: gi ) ees. 3 See 36 je | soe 5

_ OTe Toi Lips 165 |.....- 15 1| 583 5] 28] 14 1

CREO HE SUE earn | aoe | eee Sew Coes

=i 3a |2 3 3 3

a be [= °o

are Ee oa z |S /@ |8

& | 32/35 g™ | #a 38/08/08

2/3 2/2 |se/3 wee f ie

P/E le le | 2/28/21] 8/2 [2 fz

‘@l aia [Ss je ls (2 12818 18 &

cee 11 1 2 ven ee ee

eee Bf..8 St... 8): Bree

9 i teres _Y Saas COR 60 | 2,260

7 § Re ie coe eee 164 | 2, 202

R* Mieteiastiasonbiintaensnnceiate te. _) “SRS Ree DB hissistes 3| 268

Authority: O. S. L. monthly reports filed with P. U. C. I.

DAYS

: .

272 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

433 ° (“oe Sie ae |

1... C. Docket No. 1758

Oregon Short Line Railioad Company—Statement of carload shipnients of

coal from Wyoming: and Utah mines to Snake River Valley points, Blackfoot

to Idaho Falls including all points on branch lines connecting with main

line at those points; showing tons to each destination station, for the year

1931 °

- Destination Station Tons Destination Station Tons

po ae 6 17,966 || Egin, Idaho........-.-.------------------- 277

Wapello, Idaho. .:.........-.....- = hae ee Oe Tt Pim FOO. . «ooo ced cnsnigasdncncnsnene 38

SO Se eres ea 1,906 || Parker, Idabd...............--..---.------ 142

Shelley, Idaho- ---- EI ee 4, 594 || Pyke, Idaho---_--- Re eee 1, 442

Cotton, Idaho---------- ey een 213 || Grainville, Idaho- --....------------------- 70

Tdamo Walls, 1dano.......----..-s222006-0- 43, 360 || Drummond, Idaho lll e

Cg Sg SS Sa eee re a8) Vetoma; Idano............-.< 247

Wie SNE. ogg pcan chancsancdaunncamnee sd 1, 467 || Driggs, Idaho---- £ 438

Rigby, Idaho. -.......-....--..------------ 4, 567 || Victor, Idaho- --- 411

pe Pe eeeees 161 {| Collins, Idaho-- - - 106

co SS ee ree ree 473 || Moreland, Idaho-. ; 951

_ Rexburg, Idaho-.-------- RESO ee . 8,109 || Arco, Idaho.............--------;--------- 1, 756

Sugar City, Idaho......----..----- 8,812 || Moore, Idaho..........---..---- _ eee > a

8t. Anthony, Idaho ; 6, 327 || Darlington, Idaho---.-.-------------------- 73

Chester, Idaho------ Gt EARL RANG. 0 cba S coca acewcnesdcncsenssess RS)

Ashton, Idaho-- 2,087 |] Mackay, Idaho. -.....---.---------------- 1, 829

Lincoln, Idaho---- 1, 207 || Rockford, Idaho-----.-------- See a ee 154

Iona, Idaho.------ 730 1) Pines, 106n0....-..--=.~--.-nc02+--5--<- 166

IOAGM. WOOO. o.oo. 52 25cta5.deesn-ns<n5- 70 || Springfield, Idaho- ---..-.---.------------- 135

eS ere rere 1, 384 || Sterling, Idaho-........----------------- as 450

Byrne, Idaho. ....-...........--..---=---- ann 1) Ahemmoon, hian0.......-...........=..---- 2, 338

Newdale, Idaho...........-.------ anaes 550 || Goshen, Idaho-.--..-..----------------.----- 141

Colteman, THANG... -..-2.<---<<.6254055-566 SGN, 1} OR SUING. .0-c-c556s0cnn65 Pepe pee e een eeee 389

PORE. TONDO. « « icccnsceassnnacssassssssus 401 1] Getratd, Idaho. ........--.-......-...---- 69

RieMNWIe, BOON. «coc nncancocenssees-<- 612 1) Ammion, Ideho- .........--...-..=-----.-- 433

Moenan, Tdahe. ......-..........-+--25<--- 781 || West Yellowstone, Mont--.-.-.------------ 209

Pian, 1GGN0.......2 <<. asso ceecasn+<ccaq 70 :

MeGmenOs. TARO... . .2- 2.22 556022-5--2<0% 71 SOU csiccaceccsss Mises oteases 119, 489

Auditor's Office, Salt Lake City, Utah, April 28, 1932.

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 17. Witness R. Whipprecht. Complainant’s vy, Defendant’s,

Commission’s. Date 5-16-82. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter. |

4 434 Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096—Fin.

- _ Exhibit No. 19. Witness Counsel. Complainant's y, Defend-

arit’s, Commission’s. Date, 5-17-1932. Frank W. Otterstrom,

Reporter.

lack

9

a

8

, Idaho,

Talbot

SSBSSS9S83

eee ee a ee *

et et et et et et

SSLSBR8S99283

Slack | Lump; Nut

Utah, from mines located in

Nut

yoming, and from Talbot, Idaho,

:

oS

H

=

8

3

S

t+

>

—

Ss

Kemmerer-Rock

Wyoming Mines in

Springs District

f coal were made from Talbot

OD OD OD OD SH et tt gt

Slack | Lump

RRRERRARS

OD G2 OD 09 09 OD 09 OD OD

. -

Nut

Peery

OD OD OD OD SH et et tt gt

Utah Mines in Castle

Gate District

Lump

SSRBSSESSEY

UNITED STATES ET AL, VS. STATE OF IDAHO Ef AL.

mines located in the Castle Gate district. in

the Kemnerer-Rock Springs district in W

to points in Idaho where shipments o

during the year 1931

Statement of rates in cents per ton of 2

Ot. ABURORY. ....<...0<ccce

MR rir foes et eat

pO

PI anne cone enuuk

Reet ores

Cotton.

‘

'

'

'

'

'

'

'

'

Li iy

485 Edmonds. ..-........-

'

:

'

: ‘

' '

' ‘

: H

' ' '

' ' '

MB M H

Ss.

Beas =

B88

oO Qo

UoAe

lished.

5.25 | No specific rate pub-

rgency surcharge.

5. 50

5. 50

L. Tariff 4301-A PUCU No. 563. From Wyoming &

6¢ per ton so-called eme:

5. 65

Oo. S.

yoming add

B. Tariff 6020-C, I. C. C. 3808.

, Idaho.

5. 90

0 rails from Utah and W

y from Talbot

Authorit

;Uaks

| BESS eee

WO Soa as re he aie

' Po eee

NoTe.—T

Tariff

Utah

eNO so oS

West Yellowstone__.._____.

Drig;

Vic

Moore

ee

8

> Sterlin

ee ae eR TN ET! OTe ae

eT Se te —

274 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

436 Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096-Fin.

Exhibit No. 20. Witness counsel. Complainant’sy, Defend-

ant’s, Commission’s. Date 5-17-1932. Frank W. Oiterstrom,

Reporter. . : 7

Only one Supplement to this Tariff will be in effect at any time.

Sup. No. 7 to O. S. L. R. R—I. C. C. No. 2076 (Cancels Sup. No.

6). Sup. No. 7 contains all changes from the original Tariff that

are effective on the date hereof.

United States Railroad: Administration

W. G. McAdoo, Director General of Railroads. ..

Oregon Short Line Railroad and Union Pacific Railroad (Fx5 No.

6) in Connection With Camas Prairie Railroad (Fx5 No. 3), Great

Northern Railway (Fx4 No. 200), Northern Pacific Railroad (Fx2

No. 101), Oregon-Washington Railroad & Navigation Lines (Fx5

No. 3), Southern Pacific Company (Fx5 No. 2), (Oregon Lines),

Spokane, Portland & Seattle Ry. (Fx4 No. 24).

%

Supplement No. 7 (Cancels Sup. No. 6),

Sup. No, 7 contains all changes to Joint. Freight Tariff—o. S. L.

No. 2112-I, S. P. & S. No. 501-D, O.-W. R. & N. No. 157-D, U. P.

No. 2052-A; Nor. Pac. No. 991-H, So. Pac. No. 264-L (Which took

effett_ September 20, 1917), applying on soft coal, all kinds, carloads

(except blacksmith coal) from Cumberland, Diamondville, Kem-

merer, Rock Springs, Superior, Wyoming, and points shown herein,

to stations on the Oregon-Washington Railroad & Navigation Lines,

_ Southern Pacific Co. (Oregon Lines), Northern Pacific Railway,

Great Northern Ry., Spokane, Portland & Seattle Ry. and Camas

Prairie R. R., in Oregon, Washington, Idaho, and Montana as shown

herein.

‘Refer to tariff and amend as shown herein.

Published for the Director General of Railroads and filed on one

day’s notice with the Interstate Commerce Commission * under

Freight Rate Authority No. 3660 of the Director, Division of

Traffic, United .States Railroad Administration, dated January 6, '

1919.

Issued January 9, 1919. Effective January 16, 1919 (Except as

noted in individual items). b>

; J. A. Reeves,

General Freight Agent, °

Oregon Short Line R. R.,

Salt Lake City, Utah.”

_ Folio 94. (File 17623) (900). . .

= — <<

437

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

275

Rules

Item y12-A cancels 12

Combination of commodity rates -

When the total charges on a through continuous movement of Soft

Coal are constructed by combination of separately established Class

or Commodity rates applying to and from junction points, first deter-

mine the through combination of rates in effect on June 24, 1918, and

then increase such through combination of rates by the amount

shown below:

Where the rate was—

0 to 49 cents per ton

50 to 99 cents per ton_____________

$1.00 to $1.99 per ton_____________

$2.00 to $2.99 per ton____________

$3.00 or higher per ton_____-~_____

Increase

---------------- 15 cents per net ton,of 2,000 pounds.

-- 20 cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds.

-- 30 cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds,

-- 40 cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds.

-- 50 cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds.

Effective December 6, 1918, in Sup. 6. (File 33253.)

25-A cancels 25 change

List of Stations taking same rates as Cumberland, Rock Springs,

and Almy, Wyo.

ETE

Beetx Buttes............4..... Wyo.

2 Ra ea Ae: Utah °

ae sidan Wyo.

Ocoee Wyo

Diamondville_._-______________ Wyo.

I titania ncaa wuee canes Wyo...

Glencoe____________ Pe Wyo

aaa. Utah

eae aint een oS oe ae Wyo.

Ee CE GT Se Wyo

oa ste om nck oak sen

Moyer Junction............._.. Wyo.

North Kemmerer___________.__ Wyo

Point of Mooks................ Wyo

RTE RE I Wyo

AGE Wyo

meme Eigtings.. Wyo.

ce, PR IT Wyo

_ . SRS Saas Wyo.

t®Talbot____(File 25377) ______ Idaho

_ & Refer to Tariff and change headings on pages 10 to 14, incl., to read as follows:

& Cents per ton

~ Ratein Dollars .

of 2,000 Ibs.

From Cumberland, ~ a

Index} Wyo., Réck Springs, |= _ | & R

No Wyo., Almy, Wyo., | 3 8 E

and points shown in | & g 2 3

Item 25-A to— co |.= z

a= | 3 a

ag] & ne

En| 3

so t=] 3s

ns) Z a

0. W. R. & N. CO.

*1 | *Lime, Oré., to and in- :

cluding 4.70 | 4.20 , .3.90

*16 | La Grande, Ore__.____.

- 17 | *Island City, Ore______ 4.80 | 4.30 | 4.00

*18 | *Pierces, Ore., to and

including 90 | 4.40] 4.20

3 | aking Glass, Ore.

g Glass, Ore___

%25 | *Rondowa, Ore....___. 5. 10 4.60 | 4.30

%26 | *Vincent, Ore.....____- }6 20 | 4.70] 4.40

%27 | *Minam, Ore..._______

Rate in Dollars

& Cents per ton

of 2,000 Ibs.

From Cumberland, => >

Index| Wyo., Rock Springs,| 2 _ | & R

No Wyo., Almy, Wyo., I 8 z

* |«# and points shown in | @ ai 3s 2

* Item 25-A to— co] = a

: e=i' 3] 8

; 1)

as} & oy

Ee| e138

— 4 7)

O. W. B. & N. CO.—contd.

%&28 | Wallowa, Ore_____.__.. 5.30 | 480) 450

oe a. — Pineaasicasibsndiel

a wynne, Ore__..____-

%31 | Enterprise, Ore____.___ 5.40 | 4.90} 4.70

%&32 | Joseph, Ore______..____ ,

*%33 _—— Ore., to and in-

cluding .70 | 4.20] 3.90

%*47 | Pendleton, Ore__.____. Z

*48 | *Birch, Ore., to and in-

cluding 90 | 4.40 | 4.20

%52 | Pilot Rock, Ore_..-..__

ES LR TIY LE LL IE ET TT NE I I I TT TR

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE .OF IDAHO ET AL.

Y

-——TIndex

No.

: Rate in Dollars Rate in Dollars

& Cents per ton & Cents per ton

of 2,000 lbs. of 2,000 Ibs.

om ~~ Cumberland, zs a“ From. Cumberland, = my

~ Rock Springs, | = _ | & ® |lndex| Wy¥0- Rock Springs, 2 afta] aR-

Wyo., Almy, Wyo., | S& g a ie Wyo., Almy, Wyo.,| SR] g a

and points shownin| qj $ = * |. and points shown in | @& g| $ 3

Item 25-A to— zs 3 3 Item 25-A to— 33 3 Ps

an R woias|?s

agi =| 4 as| =|

— } + 13)

heel 3 3 3 t=] 3

n Z a. y Zz a

O. W.R. & N.co.—contd. 0. W.R. & N. CO.—contd.

Rieth, Ore., to and in- \.70 er bend SBoardy ong LEME E

cluding ki . y oardman, Oreg------- 4.901 4.40} 4.20

Umatilla, Ore_...--.--- %333 | Messner, Oreg.-------- ; ‘ .

*Saxe, Ore., to and in- %334 | Irrigon, Oreg......-----

cludin .70 | 4.70 | 4.20 || #335 |*Shutler, Oreg_-..-.---- 5.20 |-4.70 | 4.40

Kennewick, Wash.--.- %336 |*Rack Creek, Oreg--..--

*Leslie, Wash., to and %337 |*Barnett, Oreg--_.------- 5.30 | 4.80 | 4.50

including ‘ .80 | 4.80] 4.30 Le wena =

North Yakima, Wash-. : “a es cree

“Husneriat, Wash., to %&340 |*Speece, Oreg.-_-.------- 5.40 | 4.90 | 4.70

and including * 164.70 | 4.70 | 4.20 bird pgs ee ‘ :

*Joseph, Idaho--------- ondon, Oreg-_.....---- .

ay 1918, 4343 Arlington, Oreg., to

up. 2 . 4351 and * aoraeae Biggs,

Fort ‘Tae, Idaho.___| 4.90 | 4.90 | 4.40 ; “eae teeters | 4.90 | 4.40] 4.20

RNa ag Idaho_-_--| 5.10 | 5.10 | 4.60 Lm “Grebe, on PEERS: ee re

*Bundy, Idaho---.----- _ SS . . 3

sremenih. ROARO.....-.- fs, 30 | 5.30 | 4.80 || #354 Wasco, | eee

Culdesac, Idaho---..--- 355 *Klondike, Oreg., to

Reuben’s, Idaho-_.--.-- ° 280 and oe Maro, .

*Craig Junction, Idaho-|}5.90 | 5.90 | 5.40 ee 5.40 | 4.90] 470

Volimer, a ‘ *&361 *Erskinville, Oreg... 2.- \s. 70 | 5.20! 4.90

Ferdinand 1dahe---~--H6.00 | 6.00 | 6.00 | NS | es Grow heand |

Geaeville: Tdaho....7|}82 | 6-20 | 5.70 || #306 |) Groene, S78 | 5 oo | 5.40] 5.0

*Canyon, Wash., to 367 '|*Free Bridge, Oreg......| 5.20 | 4.70 | 4.40

— gn .70 | 4.70 | 4.20 = Me aye a a \5 50 | 5.00 |. 4.80

naville, Idaho-------- : , jua@e,-Oreg....--- a ae : ue

*Linfor, Idaho, to and *%370 |*Tunnel One, Oreg P

_qneludin Q 4.90 |.4.90 | 4.40 wen goes po 5.20] 4.90

mith; Idaho..-.-....-- aupin, Oreg.......-_-- 2

*Steamboat, Idaho, to |} ~ 4373 *McLennans, Oreg., to

and including 5.20°| 5.20] 4.70 4379 and including South

*Paragon, Idaho--.-.-- . Jordan, Oreg....__..-| 5.90 | 5.40] 5.20

== 1918, : see, 1918, :

n Su n Su

*Pine Creek, Idano___-| 4.70 | 4.70 | 4.20 || %380 deene. Oreg., to

—— oo 1918, *%390 poe | samen Bend, <* - -

i SY re San oes Ceres | ee Gee | Ameren er mr 4 5. 5.

q@*Sweeney, Idaho- - -.- 4.70 | 4.70 | §4.70 4391 ominiey, Oreg., to and

$4. 20 #429 including Portland,

Effective December 6, ' 1 SRS RSA 4.90 | 4.40] 420

1918, in Sup. 6. Effective aa 8, 1918,

*silver : Concen- in Sup. 4 3

rator, Idaho-.-_-_..--- .

Penance mn poy .70 | 4.70 | 4.20 8. P. & 8. RY.

Ww ne, Idaho.

Arizona Tunnel, Idaho. % 430 | Linnton, Oreg___....__- 5.30 | 4.80] 4.50

—_—— Ida- Effective —_— 1918,

alk es Pa eked .70 | 4.70 14.20 . in Sup

sborne, Idaho-_-_---- . %431 | Astoria, ne Sa keer aie 5.70 | 5.70} 5.70

*Sampling Works, (da- : “

ont yo including |}4.70 | 4.70 4. 20 80. PAC. CO. (OREGON

urke, Idaho__--...--- :

Effective June 25, 1918, ‘

wae & ; % 432 Fe werynag i ree 7.10 | 6.80 | 6.60

ows, OFeg........-. ective June 25,1918, |’:

Rg Jct., Oreg- - - - -|}+.90 4.40) 420 in Sup. 2. -

i a

a ea) ate | Oe a8 OO. -

Mme org - eee Re ie 433 , Vancouver, | 4.90 | 4:90} 4.00

Tone, Oreg 2222. |}5 7 | +70 | 4.40 |] 955 |eRenapp, Wash cco |}520 | 520) 620

"soraan, Ofet........... ; 4436 Ridgefield, Wash., to

Lexington, Oreg_....._- 5.30 | 4.80] 4.50 *476 and including, Se-

Heppner, Oreg.-.__-_-- Sttle, Wash... .....- 5.70 | 5.70 | 5.70

Footnotes at end of table.’

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 277

From Cumberland,

Wyo., Rock Springs,

Wyo.; Almy, Wyo.,

and points shown in

Item 25-A to—

Nut (See Item 20)

Slack (See Item 20)

Lump and R of M

(See Item 20)

Nut (See Item 20)

®. PAC. CO. (OREGON NOR. PAC. RY.

N

*Ross, Mont.,

egeding

Aurora, Oreg..-

Hubbard, Oreg., to

= including Sa-

SReabEES Se BERREESD 5

OT. NORTHERN RY.

*Mountain Jct., Mont_.

*Woodville, Mont

Oreg., to

and inclu Ash-

ding

~ te

and including

See

Effective June 25, 1918,

Sup. 2.

ROUTING .

index Nos. Via And Via

245 to 260, inel., 271 to 313, Silver Bow, | Nor. Pac. Ry.

incl., 316, 317 and 318. Mont.

Effective Oct. 27, 1918, in ©

Sup. 6. ‘

ts consigned to Bunker Hill Smelter Co. or Federal Mini Co., Agent Kellogg-Wardner

collect charges. - = ins

¥, Idaho, need not be prepaid.

- Freight for such stations must be prepaid.

ies via Hun , Ore. .

é ine betwéen Talbot Junction and Talbot is still under the control of the Construction Department, -

- &nd the only trains operated are construction trai running at irregular intervals. Freight will be accepted

2 shown herein for movement upon such trains,”

278 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

440 ° Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin:

Exhibit No. 21. Witness counsel. Complainant’s, defend-

ant’s, Commission’s.. Date 5-17-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, reporter.

Sup. No. 5 to P. U. C. U. No. 48. Filed fo account of Non-

Federal Controlled Lines. Sup. No. 5 to O. S. L. R. R.—I. C. C.

No. 2075. (Cancels Sup. No. 4.) Sup. No. 5 contains: all changes

from the original Tariff that are effective on the date hereof.

United States Railroad Administration

W. G. McAdoo, Director General of Railroads

- Oregon Short Line Railroad in connection with Bamberger Electric

Railroad (Fx5 No. 7), Butte, Anaconda & Pacific Railway (F x4 No.

40), Pacific & Idaho Northern Railway (Fx2 No. 73), Union

Pacific Railroad (Fx5 No. 6). : Ea

Supplement No. 5 (Cancels Sup. No. 4)

Sup. No. 5 contains all. changes to local and joint freight tariff,

O. S. L. No. 2026-H, U. P. No. 2022-A, P. & I. N. No. O. S. 94-A,

B., A. & P. No. 442-E (Which took effect October 4, 1917) applying

on soft coal, all kinds, carloads (Except blacksmith coal) from Cum-

berland, Diamondville, Kemmerer, Rock Springs, Superior, Wyo-

ming, and other points shown herein, to points in Utah, Idaho, Wyo-

ming, Montana, and Oregon.

Refer to tariff and amend as shown herein.

Issued January 9, 1919. Effective January 16, 1919 (“xcept as

noted on individual items).

J. A. REEVES,

General Freight Agent,

Oregon Short Line R. R.,

: , Salt Lake City, Utah.

Folio 94. File 1303-77-1 (800).

Rules

Item 12-A cancels 12 change

Combination of commodity rates.

When the total charges on a through continuous movement ae

constructed by combination of separately established _ class or com-

modity rates applying to and from junction points, first determine

the through combination of rates in effect on June 24, 1918, and

then increase such through combination of rates by ‘the amount

specified below. ee

Where rate in effect on June 24, 1918, was: Increase

0 to 49 cents per ton.--------------- 15 cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds.

50 to 99 cents per ton.-------------- 20 cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds.

$1.00 to $1.99 per ton___.--.------.-30 cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds.

$2.00 to $2.99 per ton--------------- 40 cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds.

$3.00 or higher per ton___--.-----.--50.cents per net ton of 2,000 pounds.

_ Published for the Director General of Railroads, and filed on one

day’s notice with the Interstate Commerce Commission under

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 279

- Freight Rate Authority No. 19 of the Director, Division of Traffic,

United States Railroad Administration, dated July 2, 1918.

Effective Jan. 16, 1919, except when in connection with B. E. R. R.,

B, A. & P. Ry. or P. & I. N. Ry., which becomes effective Feb. 15,

. & P ; .

List of stations from which Cumberland rates apply

30-A cancels 30 change © .

chk niimineninih amuse es te Wyo.

I iit ditntiin Stew asidnamah Wyo. | Moyer Junction__._____________ Wyo.

a ere Wyo. | North Kemmerer______._______ Wyo.

RE Se ee . oy “Sa eee See es phar Wyo.

| ER eae J, 38 2 eee _---Idaho.

aA ihn os haa acacia a ara aed Wyo pee

Published for the Director General of Railroads and filed on one

day’s notice with the Interstate Commerce Commission under

Freight Rate Authority No. 3660 of the Director, Division of Traffic,

United States Railroad Administration, dated January 6, 1919. }

Soft Coal—Carloads (Rates in Dollars and Cents per Ton

of 2,000 Pounds) :

FROM4&@| Cumberland and Rock

‘* Springs, Wyo., and- points | Almy; Wyo., and points

shown in Items 30-A and shown in Item 25

Index 35

no.

Other | ‘| Other

thanNut| Nut Slack |thanNut} Nut | Slack

and Slack and Slack

‘To (See Item 15) (See Item 15)

0. 8. L. B. R.

' 1] Granger, Wyo., to and including. .-_-

1 ee creas Se] ae] eel tel te) ae

0s, » Wyo., to and including._--- :

$| Moret, Wiss winding | GER | Sues! Gust 2) 20) 20

ts) ct., Wyo., to an uding-- :

Jee Gt.10| @tr10} Gers ly 2:00 _ 200) = 200

13 | *Carlston, Wyo., to and including....| @2.00 @2. 00 @2. 00 } 2.00 2.00 2.0

[fp Saree “200 | ai00 | Be: o0

‘egram, o, to and including - -_- f 4 ,

2 | Montpelier, Idaho... oT. OH. 7 | @1.70] O70 |f — a 4a

S| one on @20} @220/ @220!1 oo! o| 299

: Paris, Tdalho. nn O12} Of2.00) Of2.00

escadero, 0, to and including-- , ;

SiGhthaniae. @2.20} @220] @2.00 220; 220) 260

%5 | Alexander, Idaho........-.......-... { Sio20 |} ©2600] @200/{ 28) 260] 20

_ 36] Grace, SGehe...................2-2..- { gue } @2. 80 @2.20 |; - ne 2. 80 2.20

%*37 | *Way, Idaho, to and including. _.___. @z2, 60 2.

47| McCammon, Idaho...” Oye w |} O200] O200/{ FH |} 260) 200

ji... _ RIES TRE

SE BR ciinsnnesnasaniasascanas @2.60} @260} @220 260) 260} 220

50 | Portneuf, Idaho.............__..._____

%51 | Pocatello, Idaho......... 2. 60 2. 60 2.20 2. 60 2. 60 2. 20

%52 | *Batise Springs, Idaho, to and includ-

P += eee, 3.10 3.10 2. 60 3.10 3. 10 2. 60

#58 | American Falls, Idaho._---------2 =>

Footnotes at end of table.

280. «UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

Soft Coal—Carloads (Rates in Dollars and Cents per Ton

of 2,000 Pounds)

»

7

ete con po A Sows is item 25

FROM«s@"| Cum

. Index

no.

Other .

than Nut}; Nut Slack then et Nut | Slack

and Slack lack

To— (See Item 15) (See Item 15)

0. 8. L. BR. n.—continued

59 *Martha, Idaho, to and including. . 3.70 |. 3.70

67 | Minidok®s faho, to and including... | rt _ = el 8 10 si, aoe

ceq' daho, Ss ° ©

Paul 233 |}? s20|- “2e0l, stoi a0) 2%

4.20 3.70 3.30 420} 370| 390

3.90 “2901 ¢.

| 3) 3.30) 230 sie) °° 2%

sh 30 |} 3.70 3.30 aot 370 3.30

3} fro]. a30 se 3o |} 270] 380

£3) 3.70 3.30 If id} 3.70} 3.30>

4.2 3.70 3.30 4.20| 3.70) 330

Judi 4.20 3.30 2.80 420)\ 330) 290

Sos | Fn, Taso, to sid ineldlng. =| st : oo

ni 0, to and including. .....

; , 370 3.30 3.70) 230

108 | *Haggardt, [daho........-.<--------=- 00 00

109 eee idaho eo *

e110. | “Amsterdam, Idabo.......----------- 4” 3.70 3.30 420} 370| 39

wil} | Rogerson. tno, to and induding 4.20

u ’ 0, 5

ae | ieee eee} ep ie) sel eer ae) te

ax, 0 il ssaccse

xix ‘Shostione, Edad ie } 3.00 3.30) 310 3.90} 330) 310

, Idaho, including...

196 Emmett, I rhs RC OD 42 3.70 3.30 42} 370 3.30

#197 | *Plaza, Idaho-........-------**+*- _ a

198 |. Montour, Ida... -----------=>- 4404 «439 3.70 aa} 290| 370

%199 | Horse Shoe Bend, Idaho...

#200 | *Gardena, Idaho. ..---------------- }} 470) 4m] 390 470| 420) 39

#202 | *Mains, Idaho, toand including....--\\| 4 go 440 ‘. ao} 440) 42

—- Idaho, to and including..... } 5.20 4.70 440 5.20 4.70 4”

daho

- %&213 “il ar), [dabo, to and including.

227 WOGUD co taconcccenccccssneses } 42 3.70 3.30 42} 370) 3%

*228 x an, Oregom......--- , scesesoess 40 3.80 3.70 4.40 3. 80 3.70

* $229 | *Adrian, Oregom......-----=---**00" 4.70 42 3.90 4.70 4.20 38

%&230 | *Napton, Oregon... ~..----- ETE OTE

#231 | *McCoard, Idaho... .-.----------9° } 40) 40 4.20 400} 440) 42”

*%232 | Homedale, Idabo......-------+*++--*

233 | *Arcadia, Oregom... ..--------98eee- =

*ZA | *Malheur Jct., Oregon ...----------- 4.2 3.70 3.30 “42)| 3.70 3%

235 0 dD, OTEZOM... .-- nen en wnnnn es

Lins Se Sea sacheaeree rane mace } 4.70 42 3.00 470) 420) 30

Hou | "Hope Oragoa ons} ewe] awe] 4m] 4m) tel te

423 | *Harper, Oregon... ...--------*---- 5.2 4.70 4.40 5.2) 470 4”

We2A5 *Namorf, Oregom...--------<-------" "6.40 4.90 4.70 5.40) 49 47

fue | cBohne, Orgel} ao] am) aoe] km] Bm) AE

|) oe 88] 8 0) 40

be hy “eaeeneesenneonenes filed Med Miliiaied Miata Mae an

Footnotes at end of table.

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ETAL. 28]

AEE on ET Ton

of 2,000 Pounds ”

“Bprines, Wr. ——™ pint ee Hy , and points

Items 30- Livy 4)

To—

0. 8. |. B. R.—continued

c ,

iran. Oregon, to and = a

Idaho

*Catrock, Idaho, to and including. ---

New Meadows, Te caiaiaae

0. 8. L. RB. BR.

*Jonathan, Idaho, to and including...

* Blakes,

ost i,

Sy

Huntington, Ore

. AL. ~~~ Sey 25, 191

B. £. R. R.

a ~ Lake City, Utah, to and includ-

-

-

al nd 2d xl a od

3 8SsssE

* -

Preeerrr

=

8 88 88 sseseses

=

ss

=

=

BBpEeeE Sp ~ - 2-2-7

J

=

i)

-

ad ale

we

8 3 38 hh AL

SSBssxs 28 2 sese2s

Be pws

88 88

ME ae oe

TL nae ee

REI OS ee OS

‘282 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

Soft Coal—Carloads (Rates in Dollars and Cents per Ton

of 2,000 Pounds)

FROM«@| Cumberland and_ Rock ;

. Springs, Wyo., and points | Almy, Wyo., and points

shown in Items 30-A and shown in Item 25

Index 35

ro.

Other oi Other |

: than Nut} Nut Slack |than Nut} Nut | Slack

and Slack 4 and Slack

To— - (See item 15) (See Item 15)

O. 8. L. 8. R.—continued

383 | *Belmont, Utah... :....-------------- ' . sol sa

S| Fielding, Dean 00 | caso] as] oreol{ 0) skim] stm

396 | *Estép, Utah......-.....------------- ' 200\° 2

387 *Washakie, Utah 2-222 2.--------- @2.80| @280} @280|{ 38>] gol so

lortage, Utah....----.------.--------

339 | *Woodruff, Idaho, to and including--|\ ’ 2.80 2. 80

LR 9 7 ap sapdaliceepnenenanaesnate } @3.10| @3.10| @3.10 a

: : @2. 60 200 || 2.20} 2.00

206 | Baleares, Utab.....-.-------0----0020-0 { S220 |} O20] ©2.00 em | a 41.50

, ey

Z 2. 20

395 | *Call’s Fort, Utah, to and including..|_ 2.60 + ao 2. 20 2.00

423 | §§*Lewiston, Utah -..-.---.--.------ Gy2.20 |} 2.60} 2.00 $0 |f 12-00] 11.50

= ae, saeme, to and including- ---| Ae } @2.60! . @2.00 2.20 2.20 2.00

reston, SE. a tnacessemidedadoancaee be

429 | *Hammond, Utah, to and including--| 2. 60 } @2. 60 @2.00 { . 2.20 2. 20 2.00

£3 | eat Guo ioand iia | #04 arent Bers he

eston, aho, to and inciuding----- a } 1 2.20 2.00

oF | Ceted See aad inainding | “GRO Gane Beas Gere

‘ wan e, Idaho, to and including- ; 3 2. 2.00

Ant Se Rs cecchcnkceacdael @§2. 20 } @2.60} @2.00 { 9390 \ 2.60

444 *Tyhee, ss. inknuceo’ eniaeanees 3. 10 3.00 2. 60 3.10} 3.00 2. 60

ons Pig Fay 25, 1918, in Sup. 3).

” peaepaamrereamnes cies 3. 10 3.00 2. 60

446 | *Gibson, Idaho----....--.------------- 3.10 3. 00 2. 60

447 | *Younsg, Idaho. .......-.....---------- a ap peed }

448 | Blackfoot, Idaho. -.....-.....---.---- ore] on! azo} 310) 300) 20

W440 | *Collins, Idaho------.---------------- 3. 30 3 3.30 “

St Semen ME... goss Li nedensacusuaes y ‘ 3.30| 3.30 3. 30

a .,.......... 7 ip te ae oe }

#452 | *Moreland Jet., Ida_.....2.....------- °s.a0 3.70 3.20 \ 3.90} 3.70| 3.30

. 4. ; ./

#453 |.*Rockford, Idaho.........--:--------- @s.10] @x10 ‘O27 \ 4.00} 3.70] 3.30

%454 | *Virden, Idaho, to and including----- 4. 20 A , 2 - 3.30

460 | Aberdeen, Idaho. .....-.----------- { @3.30 3. 30 @2.70 4.20] 3.70

#461 | *Taber, Idaho. -----.----------------- 00 @3. 00 @2.7 _ 3.90] 3.70 3. 30

462 | *Furey, Idaho, to and including. ----- OF 3.70 3. 30 } 4.20 3.70 3.30

471 | Mackay, Idaho..-.-----.------.------- Oo 20 oes 30 @2.70 , 7

472 | *Wapello, Idaho, to and including---- 2 = at zak Tt ee Ts or

477 | *Bach, Idaho... ---.----.------------- §3. 10 |.....- LEP TREE " | poet Seteeo

478 | Idaho Falls, Idaho 3. 20 3.00 2. 80 3.20} 3.00 2.80

i cae, Se Sst ee 2a.

7 2, ee, ee pee ye ‘ 5 Ree) SS es Perr Ce

3. 60

; 3. 20 3.10 3. 60

W481 | Iona, Idaho.....---------------------- 83 @2.0| @1.80| §3. a0 |} 320] 3.10

4 é 3. 80 3.20 3. 10 3:80} 3.20] 3.10

482 | sMilo, Idaho. -..-------------------- aad Bian S| Waar mom

183 » Idaho.....------------------- @2.00 | @2.00 | @i.80 |... 2... ooo

ss . 20 3.10 a3 3. 20 3.10

ies i DO nin cots ek iaansone 5°) RES eRe IIE: $3. 10 |.......-]--------

cabs . 3 1.9 = Cee Ee SK

4c | “RIESE dake to and inctuding seo, sil aio | ae [SiO

ens Hennassen<<assenceensees i Giese: temas ) eee See

1.90] @1.90| © @1.80 |-.--..----]--------|----3-7

#489 | *Parkinson, Idaho.......---------- ...|f @ 310

of a) —apanmmnonmeeeners BR] Wiad Mod MEY: ~| Biota’ Bn

Footnotes at end of table. :

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. . 283

Soft Coal—Carloads (Rates in Dollars and Cents per Ton

of 2,000 Pounds)

FROM 4@-| Cumberland and Rock | -

“Springs, Wyo., and points | Almy, Wyo., and points.

shown in Items 30-A and shown in Item 25

Index 35 C-

no. ;

Other Other

thanNut} Nut Slack |thanNut} Nut | Slack

and Slack and’ Slack7

To— - (See Item 15) (See Item 15)

O. 8. L. R. R.—continued ii 3 3

@1. 70 @1.70 @1.70 4.20 70 3. 10

491 | Newdale, Idaho. -...-_........... ace a0 3.70 3.10 Ser: | QeeRN Imerem

#492 | *St. Leon, Idaho... ic 1.) ae

Oe FPO, BE inn cncrnngsosgsnanans @2 00 | @2.00 ey Gia. ae eee

: ; 2.00 | @2.00 | SS Ree Sepere

494 | *Coltman, Idaho, to and including. _- ‘

is | “Lewin tdako sm netomat | 890) Sato aa | aa | ai

Geet Gio! @tet. is.

Pt Dien, BONG... 2 3.10 3. 20 3.10 40 3. 20 3.10

4.10} 3.60; 3.10 4.10| 3.60] 3.10

0s | “Ametim, S0ebe.. ....-..2555....22...2 Pe ok ee 2 Deck Eee ie

4.20 3.70 3.10! 42] 370| 3.10 . oe

ers ey BAO occas ss gi er ey Sl) Seana ees

; 1.70] @1.70 NE ee

- 500 | *Edmonds, Idaho, to and including_- , 3

#604 | *Pyke, Idaho... 2... ‘Obie bit OE ko j

3. 80 3. 20 2.80 3. 80 3. 20 2. 80 .

SUE) RG, BOO ooo tect ccscnnce oe oe ae ae ef eae Semen 43

cals 1.90] @1.90 (|) SORES eae spalemetiC 3

506 | *Lorenzo, Idaho, to and including-__-_ @

608 | *Winder, Idaho... 2... oT cet i) Oe

@1. 70 @1.70 kf Se SRE Ee a

609 | Rexburg, Idaho_________- i ama named 4.10 3. 60 2. 80 4.10 2. 60 2. 80

: eee _ tS OE SRR le kd SSRs ee ee

; @1. 70 @1. 70 —. A er PEER Ra

810 | Sugar City, Idaho.....-....-._._:_._. é = 3.70 2. 80 P = 3.70 2. 80

. 4.20| 3.70) 3.10 4.20} 3.70| 3. 10

nl) WO Me, SIN ne Py “ee eae: > ye, eae

n " 2, et SERA EN WERK Bee eee

' lm oe YS Seer Seer see :

512 | St. Anthony, Idaho_______.___.______ 4. 20 3.70 3.10 4. 20 3. 70 3.10 a

: Py 10 oY ye Lo Seen Meares .

: 1. 60 1. 60 - ) Se) Se ee ‘

513 | *T win Groves, Idaho___.._._.___.___-

a er | ied i PT al

. @1. 40 @1. 40 @1. 40 4.20 3.70 3. 30

515 | Ashton, Idaho.__.___.__ Phe ree < 2 3.70 3. 30 tt eee Me yest

6 | Marysville, Idabo..:..---....---.- gt] get] gio |__*®| 87 | eas

S17 | *Graifiville, Idaho... { ot4] oro} oni A) 2%] 87

tis | Drummond, Idaho.................-. { o130| org0|, argo). *%) 3%] 2%

80 | Prana, Lahn nnenenenenn {of B| ota| ote). ] #a | “se

8 | Lament, Labo. eeenene nnn {ot8| ots) grel.*| *@| 8% F

oe re, SOG se { Ae ST eS re eee ae 7

a2}. *Judkina, Idaho......°..... 4.90 | 4. 40 4. 20 4.90 4.40 4. 20

MB) Fel, dahon nnn Gt] ot] ot Bl tm] #0) £2

624 | Tetonia, Idaho... { 60] Oo} ool | AO) -£™

“saul * ; 5. 20 4.70] * 4.40 5.20] 470] 440

_ 52444) *Talbot Junction, Idaho......._._.__- { @. 80 ©. 80 tf et Bi wd paar

Footnotes at end of table.

i

rs

LF SEAT EN YOON AF CY

EMAL IL I Ie ee PT TO Oe

284 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO. ET AL.

Soft Coal—Carloads (Rates in Dollars and Cents per Ton

of 2,000 Pounds)

¢ FROMa«@| Cumberland and Rock

: : Springs, Wyo., and points any, Wyo., and points

; shown in Items 30-A and shown in Item 25

Index 35 :

no. ‘

Other Other :

; than Nut Nut Slack |thanNut| Nut | Slack

: and Slack and Slack

L

To— (See Item 15) (See Item 15)

0. 8. L. RB. R.—continued

525 | *Loosli Idaho 5. 20 4.70 4:40 5. 20 4.70 |" 4.40

ee ah °> © oo ee 5.20| 4.70| 4.40

‘ 5 " ls 4. 40

526 | Driggs, Idaho- ----------------------- @1.00 @1.00 OES EES ESE TEER, a

527 | Victor, Idaho-.-.----- eucaataansnae Mokee gt . . = : . 5. 40 4,90 4.70

Ne i. 40 Or ae | ote CRY SRO SRE

528'| ‘*Ingling, Idaho... .------------------- 4.20 3.70 3. 30 420} 3.70) 3.30

, 4. 40 3.90 3.70 4. 40 3. 90 3.70

529 | *Warren River, Idaho---------------- Pi ¢ — ‘i 3 “Sie lS aepeeaties Seeeeren

530 | *Payne, Idaho, to and including. .-... 3.20| + 3.20 3.20) 3.20] 3.20] 3.2

535 | *Hawgood, Idaho---.-_-.--------- oS > | Vy Gee et Ae, Se

536 | Hamer, Idaho, to and including 2. 40 , ae MO oS Sennen aaBlosaanecn

Sat Bie WO. cc concccacc-scssegecs 3. 20 2, 20 3. 20 3. 20 3.20

540 “High Bridge, Idaho, to and including @2.60 e #60 |.---. 30 bao faa

Eg © ee eer . f j ;

544 | *Snowline, Mont., to and including--|f @2.70 @2. 70 Soy ay 8 Eee! SAS eae

B47 | Dell, MOU. «65. 2222-5200555-000052555 -3, 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20

548 | *McKnight, Mont., to and including.|f @2. 90 @2. 90 Op 1) eee hee arenas Cama

551 | Armstead, Mont. .-..-.-..-----..------ 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 $. 20 3. 20

= et —« to and including.--- @3. 4 7 = a = Beene ae eT ats

ae aid adad 3. : i ;

*&557 | Apex, Mont., to and including--.----- 3. 20 3. 20 * 3.20 3..20 3. 20 3.20

%570 | Butte, Mont---.----------------------

B., A. & P. RY. ." .

%571 | Butte, Mont., to and including-------

581 | *Brown’s, Mont.......------- eaeip 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20 3. 20

*%&582 oe a effective June 25, — has <a <i 7 “a

Ge ae : : q : ,

3. 60 3, 60 3.,60 3. 60 3. 60 3.60

583 | *Section Sixteen Siding, Mont puxeneae @3. 90 @3,90 P* .% Cede Remateak Risen

584 | Stuart, Mont., effective sune 25, 1918, .

SS ee errr 3.90 3. 90 3.90 3.90 3.90 3.9

t The line from Talbot Junction to Talbot is still under-the control of the Construction Department, and

the _ trains operated are construction trains, running at irregular intervals. Freight will be accepted as

shown herein for movement upon such trains.

t — only from Cumberland, Wyo., and points shown in Item 30-A. .

3 ll not apply from Talbot, Idaho.

Reduction.

* No agent. Freight for such stations must _be prepaid.

Shipments consigned to Pacific Lime & Gypsum Co., Gypsum, Ore., need not be prepaid. Agent

Huntington, Ore., will collect charges. ;

* Reissue.

Applies only from Grass Creek and Coalville, Utah.

ine run coal and nut run coal. : ;

+ — consigned to the Amalgamated Sugar Co. at Lewiston Spur, Utah, may be accepted charges

collect. '

@Applies only from Talbot, Idaho.

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

Item ! Commodity’. Between And mae pe

*70-B | Coal, soft, all kinds, carloads | aS | ee Kemmerer, Wyo-.......- $10. 00

Cancels (except Blacksmith Coal). (File 21960)

70-A —— June 25, 1918, in Sup.

é Kemmerer, ,) ae 10. 00

° : Mine No. 1, Wyo. __.... 12. 00

*75-B | Coal, soft, all kinds, carlosds |{Elkol, Wyo_._...--._-_- o. Kemmerer, Wyo... 12. 50

Cancels (except Blacksmith Coal).. So 15. 00

75-A (File 21960) Quealy, Wyo......-..... 15.00

Effective June 25, 1918, in Sup. |]Glencoe, Wyo___-______- Kemmerer, Wyo-.-_..... 10. 00

hi No. Kemmerer, Wyo....{Qhesiy, Wyo wa}

* Reissue.

444 Exhibit 25

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No. 9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 25. - Witness, Samuels. Complainant’s, Defendant’s y, Com-

mission’s. Date, 5-17-32. Frank W. Otterstrom, Reporter.

ROBERT H. BRADFORD REPORT.—SUMMARY OF REPORT OF THE TETON COAL

MINE LOCATION anit

The Teton Coal Company’s property is located 12. miles west of

Driggs, Idaho, near the east base of the Big Hole mountains. The

group of patented claims cover an area of 1,080 acres and include

ten inclined parallel seams of coal extending two anda half miles

in length. The group embraces the principal coal seams of the

entire field, representing the ouly known commercial coal in the

state of Idahg.

The mine is served by a well-constructed standard-gauge branch

of the Oregon Short Line Railroad ten miles long, connecting with

the main line at a point near the town of Tetonia.

Tonnage estimate

The ten workable coal seams already discovered on these claims

have a combined thickness of fifty-three feet of coal. Assuming

they can be mined for one-half mile on the dip and that they con- -

tinue for a distance of two miles along the strike, there are approxi-

-mately 44,000,000 tons of coal in these claims, allowing 1,300 tons

per foot acre. At 10 cents per ton, the Government minimum leas-

ing charge, this amounts to $4,400,000.00 worth of coal.

“=? EL ee: Oe —

286 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

The seams are of high-grade bituminous coal, low in ash and

moisture and high in heating value. In comparison with Utah

and Wyoming coals, the proximate analyses show:

Volatile Fixed B.T.U.

Moisture|” Ash matter carbon

Teton Coa} (Brown Bear Seam)- ------------------- 2. 32 2.5 40.75 54. 43 14, 260

Teton Coal (Progress EN ea ene 2. 55 3. 00 40. 00 54. 45 13, 700

Rock Springs Wyo. (U. sf ) aa 6.4 5. 61 36. 14 51. 60 12, 110

Coalville, Utah. --.-..------------------------------ 7.5 4. 80 40. 08 46.9 11, 750

445 Free burning qualities of the Teton coal

The free burning qualities of the Teton coal show a decided

superiority over most western coals.

Lumps of the coal, upon being heated, evolve a light free-burning

gas that ignites readily and burns with an almost smokeless flame.

As the heat from the burning gas penetrates the coal the lump’ ~

swells and cracks open and the fixed carbon ignites and burns as a

porous coherént coke. One needs but to watch the burning coal

through the open heater door to see clearly the favorable result of

the free-burning gases evolved from the expanding lumps igniting

and burning completely without soot or smoke. °

The working tunnel

The mine is worked through a tunnel now nearly a mile long,

cross-cutting the tilted rock strata. The entrance or portal of the

tunnel being located on a branch of Horseshoe Creek and at an ele-

vation 6,515 feet above sea-level. The surface workings, including

the Power-house, the Tipple, Saw-mill, and the Shops, are contiguous

to the portal of the tunnel, as is also the thriving little town of Sam,

Idaho, but recently given a daily mail service. sieee hy

The tunnel passes through alternating strata of sand stone, shales, *

‘and slates with occasional thin beds of coal impregnated with clay,

until at a distance in of 4,680 feet it cross-cuts the Brown Bear. seam -

four and a half feet thick .of clean Bituminous coal of excellent

quality. From here an air shaft driven upward to the surface is

630 feet long.

The Brown Bear workings have now been extended to the left:

(south) of the tunnel for a distance of over 800 feet, to the right

(north) 550 feet, the seam maintaining uniform thickness of high

grade coal for the quarter of a mile.

446 Eighty-four feet further in, the tunnel cuts the Progress

: seam, seven and a half feet thick at this point, of cleam coal

similar to that of the Brown Bear seam and parallel to the Brown

Bear in its position.

a . —— - = = -

- “ — a ™ & :

- - Peeters ~—— —

a

_ UNITED STATES ET Al, VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 287

The workings to the right (north) in the Progress seam have

. reached a distance of 270 feet from the tunnel and to the left a dis-

‘tance of 250 feet. This seam shows very clean coal, breaking largely

in lump sizes at the faces, where the seam is fully ten feet thick.

The cross-cut haulage tunnel has been advanced to date, April 29,

1927, to a distance of 295 feet from the Brown Bear seam, or a total

distance of a mile from the portal of the tunnel. Besides the

Progress seam two other workable seams have already been cut. The

aim is to push the advance of the tunnel until all the coal seams are

reached.

The two shifts are no’ advancing the tunnel nine or ten feet per

day.

. Power hautage

A Fordson tractor with wheels adapted to the mine track is no.

in use hauling trains of empties’ into the mine and of loaded cars

out. The tunnel driven with one-half of one per cent grade in

favor of the loaded éars furnished fall sufficient for the proper drain-

age of the water from the few water-dripping zones in the mine.

As many as twenty empties can be hauled in at ene trip and as many

loaded cars controlled on the outward journey. About twenty min-

utes will be required for’a round trip when proper switching facil-

‘ities are finished at the coal gangways. ‘ The trains are made up by

both man and horses, tramming of the cars from the gangways to

the haulage tunnel.

The tipple

An up-to-date tipple near the mine prepares the coal for market.

The tipple machinery is housed in a new building 80 by 100

447 feet and 80 feet high, erected on the hillside above the railroad

track, and less than a quarter of a mile on a gentle down-

grade from the mouth of the tunnel. Here the coai is screened, hand-

picked, and distributed to the awaiting railroad cars. The capacity

of the tipple is 1,000 tons in 8 hours.

Expenditures

In addition to the purchase: of the claims, near.a half million dol-

lars have been expended in the development of the mine, and’the con-

struction of the surface plant, including the tipple, the power-house,

the railroad switches and scales, ard the living quarters.

Dated May 19, 1927.

| 7 ; ‘Rosert H. Braprorp.

448 } Exhibit 29 .

Interstate Commerce Commission. Docket No..9096 Fin. Exhibit

No. 29. Witness McAuliffe. Complainant’s, Defendant’s, Commis-

sion’s. Date 5-17-32. Frank W. Otterstror, reporter.

288 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

REPORT ON PROPERTY QF TETON COAL COMPANY, AS OF DATE OF APRIL

26TH, 1924

,

Prospecting and Development: Prospecting has been conducted in

the Teton Valley area for more than twenty years and a number of

small wagon mines have been operated by various parties from time

to time. These wagon mines have worked small areas of crop coal

and what is known of this field: has been gathered from these mine

workings and a rather limited number of prospect pits opened at

certain points on the outcrop. One of these wagon mines, the Brown

Bear Mine, which was opened up by a Mr, Hillman, who lived at this

mine and operated it for some sixteen years, is the only place at which

coal is now being extracted in this area.

The owners of .the various small wagon mines which have been

operated’ in this area and a number of other parties, among whom

have been the Union Pacific Coal Company, have prospected this

field from time to, time and a number of geologists ies engineers

have visited the area and reported on it. An exainination of the only

openings now available on the property and a careful study of the

reports of prospecting and of the geological surveys that have been

made since this coal was first discovered show that so far there has

not been proven in this field any continuous area of coal sufficiently

large to justify operation of other than small wagon mines such as

have been operated in the past. |

The development of this field to date has proven:

449 ° Ist. The existence of several seams of coal some of the

seams being of good quality; the most important seams being

the Brown Bear, the Horseshoe, and the Boise.

. 2nd. That these coal measures are probably a continuation of the

Frontier coal formation, which is the coal bearing formation of the

Kemmerer coal field.

3rd. That even‘ the better seams contain considerable impurities

which, on account of the steep pitch of the coal measures, it will be —

impossible to separate from the clean coal in the mine. |

4th. That the seam’ throughout the entire area generally approach

the perpendicular dipping 60 to’70 degrees in a westerly direction.

5th. That the area is very badly faulted, to the west there being

a fault movement of more than 10,000 feet which cuts off the coal

measures; to the east there possibly being a similar large fault; to

the south there being a badly broken faulted area with faults run-

ning in all directions. Cross faults running at right angles to the

strike of the seam occur throughout the area, but not enough pros-

pecting has been done to definitely determine the number or extent

of these faults. | ; ;

6th. That on account of the nature of the coal and the steep pitch

a large percentage of slack coal will be produced from any operation.

The development of the field has failed to prove:

1st. Surface continuity of the seams over any great area.

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 289

2nd. Any definite correlation of the various outcrops.

3rd. Continuity of the seams at depth, there being only one point

on the property where coal has hee worked or exposed at a greater

depth than 150 feet from the outcrop. : :

4th. The definite location of the faults and the fault areas.

The prospecting and development so far done on this property

has shown the existence of coal in numerous areas, but before any

definite assurance can be held that areas of mineable coal of suffi-

_ cient extent to justify the expénditure necessary to open up a

450 railroad shipping mine are present on this property, consid-

erable more prospecting, including drilling, to prove the con-

tinuity of the seams at depth, must be done. Lacking this informa-

tion, an estimation of the amount of coal present is merely a matter

of guess-work, as so far the showing made only warrants the state-

ment that there would appear to be areas of coal present sufficient

for the operation of small local or wagon. mines for a number. of

ears.

: The only point at which coal is now being mined in this area

is at the Brown Bear Mine which has been operated as a wagon.

mine, supplying coal to the surrounding country, this coal being

hauled from the mine‘in wagons. The present management of this

property have so operated this wagon mine during the past winter,

producing a maximum of some forty tons of coal a day, and an

examination of the Brown Bear Mine indicates that at this locality

there is sufficient coal ahead of the present workings to permit the

operation of this mine at-the same tonnage for a number of years.

Quality of:Coal: The coal seam in the Brown Bear Mine dips

64 degrees in a westerly direction and averages about 5’2”’ in thick-

ness, with an average of 14’’ of impurities distributed through the

seam, leaving about 48’’ of clean coal. In the process of mining

this steeply pitching seam, the impurities become thoroughly mixed.

with the clean coal-so that the mine-run coal as hoisted ‘from the

mine is very dirty and of inferior quality. The large lumps picked

by hand from the mine-run coal and sold as lump coal to

451 the wagon trade are clean coal, and analysis shows this lump

coal to be equal in quality to the coal found in the coal fields

of Utah and Wyoming. The fine coal, however, mixed as it is

with the impurities present in the seam is very dirty, and could not

be profitably sold in competition with the fine coal produced in

Utah and Wyoming.

The reports of the prospecting done and the operation .conducted

at other points by small wagon mines show that the same conditions

exist at other points on the property where the coal seams have been

exposed, and indicate that should an attempt be made to market the

slack coal produced from this area it could not be profitably sold -

unless separated from the dirt in the seam. This separation would

require a heavy capital expenditure for jigs, storage bins, water

Separators, and coal dryers, with an attendant high labor cost, no

_

290 ‘UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

system whether that of the air cleaning or mechanical spiralizing

methods yet perfected to a point of successfully taking the place of:

the coal washer.

‘Present Operation: The Brown Bear Mine which is located ap- .

proximately a mile and’ a quarter northwest of the. terminus of the

‘branch railroad line -built to this property during the government

‘control period was first developed by.a tunnel cutting the seam about

_ eighty feet below the crop. From this tunnel, entries were driven

in both directions along the strike of the seam and from this entry

coal was mined vnutil faults were encountered, cutting off the seam.

A slope was then driven in the coal, this slope having recently been

extended to a point approximately 500 feet from the outcrop, and

the coal.now being produced comes from entries driven to the north

from. this slope.

452 The coal was formerly mined by short breasts driven di-

rectly up the pitch, the coal being drawn off at chutes on the

level haulage road and then trammed by hand to the slope. Recently

the system of mining has been changed to a‘stepped long wall sys-

tem, but so far this system has not reached the point where it can

be determined. whether or not it wili be successful. Above the

coal there is forty feet of sand rock, and the’ long wall system left

"after the coal is removed. It seems extremely doubtful whether this

sand rock will so break as to permit controlling the breaking line

‘behind the coal face, and if this should be the case, great difficulties

will be encountered in this system of mining if any large areas are

opened up by this method. _ .

The equipment at this mine and the method of development are

adequate for a small wagon mine of this character, but are not

suitable for any great increase in output, although it is possible,

that providing the long wall system proves successful and that an

adequate supply of labor is available, that a maximum of 75 tons

a day might be secured from this mine.

Proposed Operations: A few years after the discovery of coal in

this area it was suggested by an engineer prospecting this field

(Mr. G. Caetani in 1906) that in the event of large areas of mjneable

and marketable coal being uncovered, the proper method of min-

ing would be to drive a long tunnel from a point near the present

terminus of the branch railroad built by the Railroad Ad-

453 ministration to this property in a westerly direction for the

purpose of cutting the various seams of coal. Later en-

gineers, examining the property, have apparently endorsed this sug-

gestion, and when this property came into the hands of Mr. Talbot

he started driving this tunnel. The tunnel was driven a total dis

tance of 778 feet and was timbered: with inadequate timbering for

about half the distance. . . x

The present owners have cleaned up the tunnel to a point approxi--

mately 350 feet from the mouth, where they have encountered &

large fall. In view of the fact that the inside half ofthe tunnel

_—

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. . 29]

was not timbered, that the rock encountered, judging from the waste

on the dump, was very soft, and that this tunnel intersects the

bedding ‘planes approximately at right angles, it appears likely

that. numerous falls have taken place and that considerable money

must be spent in cleaning up the tunnel to the face. No work had

been done in this tunnel since 1922 until the present owners com-

menced thé work of cleaning up the tunnel, which was about the

first of April .1926. ; so .

The first seam of mineable coal which they expect to encounter

in this tunnel is the Brown Rear seam, which, according to their

estimate, should be reached at a distance of 4,060, intersected at

5,600 feet from the ‘tunnel mouth. After the tunnel is cleaned up

to the face there must still be driven 3,282 feet before this seam is

reached, and it will probably take not less than a year to drive the

tunnel this distance. © As

-The tunnel is projected to strike*the Brown Bear and other coal

seams at a point where little prospecting has been done. on the

outcrop and very little is known as to the presence of the

454 seams in this area. It is estimated that it will cost about

$20 a foot to drive and properly timber the tunnel, and on

this basis an expenditure of approximately $65,000 will be required

before the Brown Bear seam can be reached. Before making such a

large expenditure good: judgment would indicate-the advisability

of doing some drilling in the area to be tapped by this tunnel to °

prove the existence of the seams of coal; for a known charactertistic

of the Frontier formation to which these’ coal seams are assigned

by the U. S. Geological Survey, is the pinching out of the seam

at relatively shallow depth. At present the tunnel can be regarded

only in the light of a prospect, and very expensive prospecting, at

that, and until the tunnel reaches the coal or until this aréa is

drilled no assurance can be given as to the development of any con-

siderable tonnage from this tunnel. Certainly the engineer who

suggested the plan of driving a tunnel to intersect the coal seams

did not anticipate that such would be put underway until the exist-.

ence of the seams at tunnel elevation had been proven.

If the present plan of driving this tunnel is carried out it will take

5

at least one year before mineable coal can be reached, and if, on -

reaching this distance, the Brown Bear seam is found to bein such

condition as to permit of mining operations it will require another

_six months before any.appreciable amount of coal can be produced.

-During this period the only coal that*the Teton Coal Company

plan to mine from this property: will come from the present Brown

Bear mine, which is located at a point approximately 7,000 feet.

455 distant from the railroad tracks and at an elevation 400 feet

higher than the tracks. Any coal offered for railroad ship-

ment during the next 18 months must be hauled by wagons from

the mine to the railroad, and as this wagon road is in very bad con-

dition during a large portion of the year, there is no assurance that

~ 292 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

the company will be able to ship coal continuously from this point,

If adequate labor can be secured and if no difficulties are encoun-

tered with the Long Wall system of mining, which has been recently

introduced in the Brown Bear mine, it might be possible to produce

a maximum of 75 tons a day from this mine, of which not to exceed

50 tons would be coal of sufficient purity to be shipped, so that for

. a period of at least 18 months it appears that one car a day is the

maximum coal which can possibly be offered from this property.

The proposed plan of development by the tunnel of this property

will require the expenditure of not less than $250,000 to secure an

output of 300 tons a day, this on the assumption that the tunnel, if

completed, will find the coal measures in good condition at depth,

not however including the large expenditures which should be made

for further prospecting and drilling before.any more work is done

in the tunnel.

Competition with other coals.: Assuming that an area of coal sufi-

cient to justify larger operations is proven on the property, either

by drilling or by the completion of the tunnel, there are several

factors which militate against the successful development and

456 operation of a commercial shipping mine on this property.

Although the analysis of the clean coal from the seam is satis

factory, there is so much dirt and impurities in the seam which, on

- account of the steep pitch, will be so thoroughly mixed with the coal

coming from the mime, as to render the smaller sizes practically

unsalable, leaving only the larger lumps which can lg handpicked

from the mine-run coal for profitable disposition. It is an axiom of

coal mining that the success: of a mine is dependent on securing a

proper market for the screenings and from this property this will

be very difficult or impossible; whenever any large quantity of screen-

ings are to be disposed of. .

"At the present time a limited quantity of the coal is being pro-

duced at the wagon mine at a cost which enables a profit to be shown,

this due to a large extent to the lower wages paid than are customary

at large operations. The present wage scale ranges from $4.50 a day

for. outside labor to $6.00 a day for miners, as compared with $6.94

~ for outside labor and about: $12.00 a day to miners in the Utah and-

Wyoming fields where the wage scale is established by agreement be-

tween the operators and the miners’ union. At present, in common

with other-wagon mines, there is no miners’ union at this time, but

should operations be attempted on a larger scale undoubtedly a union

would be formed and a wage agreement corresponding to the Utah

and Wyoming wage scale would be put into effect. This would in-

crease the cost of production at least 50% and taken in connection

with the difficult mining conditions and the very poor quality of the

fine coal, would mean that the property could not be operated

457 at a profit even though a small profit can be shown from the

present wagon mine. Assuming that a suitable area of good

-

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF. IDAHO ET AL. 293

coal should be proven, another feature which would militate against

the successful operation of the property as a railroad shipping mine-

(the coal coming into direct competition with the Utah and Wyom-

ing coal), is that the pitch of the coal seams would preclude any sys-

tem of mechanival loading of the coal. Mechanical loading is being

rapidly introduced into the Utah sand Wyoming mines with very

satisfactory results and it is soon ‘expected to so reduce the cost of

production as to largely offset-any freight differential which might

properly favor the Teton préperty. eer

Supplementary to, and~confirming the conclusions of the under-

signed arrived at by a personal inspection of the -property, and- an

analysis of the reports covering the explorations made for the Oregon

Short Line Railroad, an examination of the three Government Bul-

letins covering this field has likewise been made, from which the

following conclusions are abstracted :

Studies made of Teton Basin Coal Field by the U. S. Geological

Survey and U. S. Bureau of Mines

Three separate investigations of this field were made for the two _

departments of the U. S. Government charged with the study of coal

and coal fields, viz: Bulletin 541, of the U. S. Geological Survey, pub-

lished in 1914; Bulletin 166, of the U. S. Bureau of Mines, published

in 1919; and Bulletin 716, U. S. Geological Survey, published in

1921. The conclusions set forth in these government bulletins

458 made as they are made by disinterested, highly trained geolo-

gists and mining engineers, have a definite.value in the con-

sideration of the congitions that surround an undeveloped coal field

such as the Teton Basin field. . Bulletin 541 contains a report on the

Teton Basin field by E. G. Woodruff. Geologist, who examined same

in 1912. From this report. we quote as follows: |

“As the development of such a field would be of great advantage to

a large tributary region containing extensive mining and agricul-

tural developments, and ‘as samples from the field seemed to corrobo-

rate the rumor regarding the quality of the coal, the writer in 1912

made a hasty examination of the field to determine its prospective

‘value. He found that the reports concerning the quality of the coal

were substantially correct, but that the beds are so broken by faults

and the area known to be underlain by the beds is so small that the

_ field will probably never supply more than the local market and

‘ean not become a ‘factor in the development of the general region

of the Snake River valley” (Page 379). :

In concluding his report, Mr. Woodruff said :

“The Horseshoe district contains beds of excellent coal thick

enough to be mined profitably if they were horizontal, but the steep

dip of the and the numerous faults render mining’ expensive,

difficult, and uncartain. The beds are irregular in thickness and

extent. One of them most probably extends throughout the district,

LPAI SL A OT _

PRINT Sy APTOS

STE ELT CATT ET Y

MN TT I a

< rey 7

' 904 UNITED STATES ET:AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

but others are certainly less extensive. Timber and water are abun-

dant, especially water, the supply of which far exceeds the require-

ments for mining. The district is situated in a region where there

+s considerable local demand for coal for domestic fuel that now is

supplied from mines at a distance. From the data obtained the

writer concludes that this district caf profitably. supply a domestic

trade for a long time, but that it can not be reckoned as a factor in

the great coal trade of the Rocky Mountain region” (Page 388).

Bulletin 166 contains a chapter on the Teton Basin field by Geo.

Watkin Evans, Geologist and Mining ‘Engineer, from which we

quote as fellows: | j |

459 “A reliable estimate as to the probable tonnage of this field

ean not be drawn. The continuity of the beds has been

determined. along the strike, but the depth to which they extend

below surface is still an unknown factor. By referring to figure

2 (P. 92), it will be noticed that Woodruff represents a fault as

occurring to the westward and that with depth the coal beds are

completely cut off. = : ;

“If Woedruff’s assumption is true, the coal beds would only

reach a limited depth, and it is now known what this depth might

be. The beds have been traced along their strike for approximately

2-miles. Assuming that they continue along the dip for half a mile,

there would be a square mile of coal area in each bed. The Bell

Gulch. and the Horseshoe outcrops, no doubt, represent the same

bed. These two outcrops average about 9 feet of coal. This bed if

it proves to be a separate bed from the Brown Bear bed, and will

average 6 feet of minable coal, would be expected to contain 4,992,000

tons, on the basis of 1,300 tons to the foot-acre, which is a close

enough basis, considering the accuracy of the data at hand. On |

the same basis, the Brown Bear bed, if the average thickness be

taken as 4 feet, would comprise 3,330,000. tons, and the Boise bed,

assuming an average thickness of 31% feet, would contain 2,912,000

tons. Thus, the total for the three beds would be more than eleven

millions of tons. No one is justified in assuming that this amount of

coal has been proved in this district, but the foregoing figures are

given as a suggestion of the probable tonnage. The actual tonnage

can be determined only by actual gangway and slope development”

(Page -96). os pee

Under the caption “Transportation”, Mr. Evans whose inspection

preceeded the construction of the Tetonia Branch some two years,

found the coal then mined moved out over very poor wagon roads.

His comment 6n the conditions as they then existed and which vary

little from the conditions today, is well expressed by the following:

“It might be well before a railroad is constructed into this dis-

trict to improve the present road; in fact, to build a new coal road

_on a right-hand bank of Horseshoe Creek and establish a uniform

grade from the mouth of the canyon to the coal-mine. By using

_engines .of the caterpillar tractor type, trains of wagons of proper

1 i a ai rh A ake eo CR a ce a et Aa LE ce - :

oi es SE Sai a Saat i thal yng a, kichet aes ew oe, Pe iY

. - ‘ Pe

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS: STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 295

design could be hauled during the summer months from the mine

to the railroad, and during the winter months when snow is on

the ground runners could be placed under these wagons in-

460 . stead of wheels. In this manner the freight rate could be

materially reduced, the field could be more thoroughly de- -

veloped, and a definite mineable tonnage blocked out” (Page 103).

It is quite evident from this recommendation that Mr. Evans did

not feel justified in recommending a material mining or railroad

investment until a definite tonnage of mineable coal was found.

Bulletin 716 contains a third study made by the Government on

the Teton Basin field, Mr. Geo. R. Mansfield, Geologist spending in

the summer of 1917 two months with-camp outfit and helpers in

. this field. In his summary, of results, Mr. Mansfield reached the

following conclusions: '

“The only part. of the Teton: Basin that is producing coal at the

present time is the Horseshoe district. Though conditions in this

district are such that large-seale development is probably imprac-

ticable, work now in progress, will doubtless make possible a some-

what greater yield than that of previous seasons. There is little

chance that workable coal ‘beds will be discovered elsewhere in the

basin” (Page 124). : :

In commenting on the identical property under consideration, he

further said: ae

“The properties recently consolidated under the name Teton Valley

Coal-Co. were transferred in December 1917 , to mineral operators

from Seattle and Spokane. :

“According to Bell 20 beds ranging in thickness from 6 inches to

10 feet have been identified by surface work throughout a linear

extent of 2 miles, and three of these beds have been rather exten-

sively developed. The number of beds present can only be. con-

jectured until much underground work has been done and a detailed

knowledge of the structure obtained. The beds can not well be

traced at the surface because of the thick cover of rock debris and

vegetation. There may be as many as 20 beds or even more, but

practically all of those prospected, except the beds on which the

four mines described below are located, have given little or no

promise of commercial value. Probably some of the openings now

regarded as exposures of distinct beds ma _ prove to be

461 onthe same bed. There seems little doubt that the Horseshoe

and Bellcut mines are so located. On page 139 reasons are

given for thinking that the Brown Bear and Boise mines may be

on the same bed as the Horseshoe and Bellcut mines” (Pages

140-141),

. The reference to page 139 reads us follows:

“If the coal beds are parts of « closely folded syncline they would

be likely to vary in thickness with their location in the fold. Parts

of the bed nearer the axial region or bottom of the trough would be

thicker than parts of the bed-on the limbs or sides. The thickness °

296 UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL.

of the portions on the limbs would vary with the amount and char- |

acter of the shearing stresses developed during the deformation of

the rocks. These stresses would also cause the thinning or disap-

pearance of clay or shale beds on the limbs of the fold and their

thickening in the axial region. The same stresses would also de-

velop throughout the coal lines of cleavage or parting which would

cause it to break easily or crumble when extracted. The crumbling ~

of the coal is one of the disadvantageous features in mining in this

field” (Page 139). !

In his final conclusions Mr. Mansfield makes the following

statement: — .

“The area in which coal beds of commercial grade occur is not as

large as was formerly supposed and probably does not exceed 3 or

4 square miles. The shattered condition of much of the coal, due

to rock movements, is unfavorable for handling and transportation.

For this reason only a relatively: small proportion of the output is .

likely to command a favorable price, and much of it must continue

to be sold locally as run of mine or fine coal at low prices. The

steep dip of the coal bed makes mining difficult and expensive and

induces caving, such as has already blocked workings that might

otherwise be productive. The variable and faulted character of the

coal limits the extent to which a given mine can be worked. The

disposal of water in the mines will increase the cost-of production

in those workings that lie beneath the level of the tunnel. If the

projected improvements are completed and sufficiently favorable

prices can be obtained for the product to offset the installation, oper-

ation, and amortization charges, there is probably enough coal in

the ground to keep the mine running for a number of years. The

future activity of the mines will depend in large measure on how —

well the operators are able to compete with Utah or Wyoming coals —

of equal or better grade (See table. P..152), shipped in by rail.

462 “An account of the Horseshoe’ district by G. W. Evans, pub-

~ lished since the completion of the present paper, gives a de-

scription in which the geologic features are based on Woodruff’s

report. Although an estimate of 11,000,000 tons is given by Evans,

he is careful to add the following qualifying statement, which should

not be overlooked ; ‘No one is justified in assuming that this amount

of coal has-been proved in this district—the actual tonnage can be

determined only by actual gangway and slope development’ ” (Pages

143-144): : /

The carefully worked out conclusions of these men who are de-

tached from any commercial influence will always command the

respectful consideration of experienced mining men.

Conclusion

The conclusions reached after a thorough examination of the pres-

ent mine, and of all the coal seams now exposed, as well as a careful

study and analysis of the reports of prospectors, geologists, and engl:

UNITED STATES ET AL. VS. STATE OF IDAHO ET AL. 297

neers made during the past twenty odd years, and an investigation

as to the conditions under which the branch railroad line was built

by the Railroad Administration, are— 3

.- Ist. There are undoubtedly coal deposits of: considerable extent

present in this area, the seams generally lying almost perpendicular

and containing considerable impurities.

2nd. Although there is coal present in this area, the prospecting,

development.and geological studies of more than twenty years have

not disclosed an area of provén coal sufficient to justify operations

appreciably larger than the wagon mines which have been operated

in the past. ; bi

8rd. Although various estimates have been made as to the probable

quantity of coal in this area, all such estimates, when made by Gov-

ernment geologists and engineers and other competent authorities,

have been qualified with statements that these estimates were based

_ on certain assumptions which could only be determined by

463 further prospecting, development or drilling. The earlier

estimates give as high as 30,000,000 tons of coal in this area,

while later estimates made by competent authorities scale this down

to 2,500,000 tohs, indicating that the more ‘prospecting and greater

knowledge of the field did not bear out the earlier predictions as to

tonnage. All of the available reports made on the field, however,

agree in one particular, in that they do not point out any definite ©

area of proven coal sufficient to warrant mining operations on a large

scale,

. 4th. A study of the field and of the results of prospecting and de-

velopment done over a 20-year p

This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Transcript of Record — United States v. Idaho · 298 U.S. 105 | Frix