Respondents Brief — Waxham v. Smith
Supreme Court brief1935
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
INDEX.
en
STATEMENT OF CASE.....-.----:
History of this Suit..........---- sees rere reese 4
The Smith invention........---.0+++seeeeereeeee 5
Artificial incubation had made no major advance
until the Smith invention.......---+-+++++++++5
Prior litigation .......----eeeereeereeeeereereees 9
ARGUMENT.
POINT L.
THe Patent IN Suit......----- 11
The Smith process and claim 1......----++-: 11
The essentials ......--+-+ceeerrrrerrerrte? 11
(a) Mass incubation ....-.---+++++ss008* 11
(b) Moisture conservation .....--+-++-++++* 15
(c) Equalization of temperature....---< 15
(d) Maintenance of oxygen content.....- 16
(e) Staged incubation ....-----++++++" 16
The Non-Essentials ......--++++eerrerreee? 16
(1) Specific order of eggs..----- +5050" 16
(2) Shifting of eggs..-----+s-errer srr 16
(3) Curtains or nartitions.....--+++++++° 16
(4) Order not essential for heat inter-
change ....--ecceerersessrerseree® 17
The file wrapper does not require the non-
qunanttads oo cccccseuncesustestenestseereerres® 17
19
Claims not in suit contain the limitations.......---
POINT II.
PETITIONER INFRINGES...........
(a) The petitioner’s incubator...........
(b) Equalization of temperature in peti-
gg ere rire
(c) Equalization of temperature is same
iS EE s ooh os ee hac eucen seed so
(d) Testimony of petitioner’s experts....
(i) The recycling current and its ef-
fect on egg arrangement....
(ii) The current movement of air..
(e) Robbins admissions in other litigations.
(f) The Hillpot case distinguished.......
(a) TEES snak sce cccnecsenccivessces
(h) Robbins copied from Smith..........
(i) The claim in suit is not confined to
ee, ee ee
(j) The Smith patent is entitled to full
SOO occ nc cotcacecvtuvesnauwevars
(k) The prior art imposes no limitations.
POINT III.
Tue Cxuam 1s Not Vor as FunNcTIONAL...
Ce eo cud cades eet ikesetendst ae
46
49
III
CASES CITED.
Buckeye Incubator Co. v. Blum, 27 F. (2d) 333
aa | ee eerrrer rer Terre errr eer 10, 39
Cochrane v. Deener, 94 U. S. 780-788, 24 L. Ed. 139,
RP gee ere cee ree er eee are 48
Corning v. Burden, 15 How. 265, 267.............. 46
Electric Smelting & Aluminum Co. v. Pittsburg
Reduction Co., 125 F. 926-937 [C. C. A. 2d]... 42
Expanded Metal Co. v. Bradford, 214 U. S. 366.... 47
Buckeye Incubator Co. v. Hillpot, 24 F. (2) 341
BE, GC. BAUR). xc cvcevasevccanys 10, 12, 15, 16, 36, 37
Keystone Mfg. Co. v. Adams, 151 U. 8S. 139-144.... 42
Los Angeles Art Organ Co. v. Aeolian Co., 143 F.
OURO TC. Gy BFE: cc cn cvcecusinanesece: 20
McCarthy v. Lehigh Valley Railroad Co., 160 U. 8.
fl eee rrr rer rrr Tre rr Titre 41
Paper Bag Patent Case, 210 U. S. 405, 419........ 41
Risdon Locomotive Works v. Medart, 158 U. S. 68,
OF iC akansnkarccescdsntkaeaeasdssaeenaeeaiees 47
Robbins v. Petersime, 51 F. (2d) 174 [C. C. A.
POTD o cccbcavencncrecticesdecevsssuss 32, 34, 40, 42
Robinson on Patents, #485, Vol. I], p. 75......... 41
Skelton v. Baldwin, 58 F. (2) 221, 227 [C. C.
BG oc cccccknccascesaccesucceusussetesses 20
Smith v. Snow, 70 F. (2d) 564 [C. C. A. 8th]....3, 10, 12
Symington Co. v. National Castings Co., 250 U. S.
Oe gg ccccrencenyssucsscantacuseusrrens 20
The Barbed Wire Patent Case, 143 U. S. 275, 282-
NEM rre rary rer: fet at 44
Walker on Patents, Sec. 396, 6th Ed. page 484.... 41
Waxham v. Smith, 70 F. (2d) 457 [C. C. A.
DOE. cccounscavqcceerenvessensetensanas 2, 5, 13, 30
Winans v. Denmead, 15 How. 330-343..........-. 41
Wm. B. Scaife & Sons Co. v. Falls City Woolen
Mills, 209 F. 210-215 [C. C. A. 6th]........-. 20
IN THE
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 1934
No. 208
Hersert H. Waxuam, Doing Business as
Waxuam HatcHenries,
Petitioner,
vs.
Samvuet B. Smiru and Tue Buckeye Incupator Company,
Respondents.
BRIEF FOR RESPONDENTS.
Statement of Case.
In the case of Smith v. Snow (No. 102), now pending
before this Court, the same patent and substantially the
same questions of infringement are involved as in the
present case. The incubators involved in the instant case,
while differing in structural details, are the same in prin-
ciple and mode of operation, as the incubators involved
in the Snow case (Pet. Brief, p. 3). Both Wazham and
Snow rely upon the same defense with regard to the matter
of egg arrangement, each contending that he does not
2
infringe because he does not follow the exact order of egg
arrangement described in the specification of the Smith
patent, and does not shift the eggs periodically to maintain
that order. Each of these infringers of the patent repeats
the fallacy that in order to carry out the interchange of
heat, the air, as it leaves the fan, must strike the hottest
eggs first, both ignoring the obvious effect of the recycling
atr currents which make order and maintenance of order
non-essential.
in the instant case also, the party Waxham insists upon
the ‘‘file wrapper estoppel’’, maintaining that, by reason
of rejection and cancellation of broader method claims, the
patentee is estopped to contend for a fair interpretation
of the claims in issue. As in the Snow case, the petitioner
here would require that limitations be read into the claim
which neither appear therein nor were urged as considera-
tions for allowance.
In the instant case also, the petitioner insists that details
of the specific apparatus, shown in the patent, must be
found in the petitioner’s apparatus in order to find in-
fringement, overlooking the fact that the claim in suit is for
a method of incubation. Petitioner ignores completely the
admission of his own experts, that the incubator involved
in the present case carries on the process of egg incubation
by exactly the method set forth in the claim in suit. The
apparatus has been changed from that shown in the Smith
patent, but the process remains the same.
In the instant case, as in the Snow case, the peti-
tioner insists that the prior art imposes limitations upon
claim 1, which make it necessary to adopt a narrow con-
struction. In this contention the petitioner ignores the
fact that there is nothing in the art which discloses the
fundamentals of the Smith invention, 7. ¢., the combination
of the two features of setting eggs at short intervals in a
chamber or cabinet so that eggs of various ages are present
therein and the application of a forced draft or current of
air to those eggs. In this connection, the statement by
—
3
petitioner’s expert, Mr. Fouts, is particularly interesting
(R. p. 249):
‘‘T am asked whether there is a patent in the prior
art disclosing a method whereby forcing means is
provided to produce a current of air, other than
changes of temperature, in a cycle, and, with eggs in
various stages of incubation and arranged in tiers,
so that the heat from one egg will be carried from
that egg to the cooler eggs. I cannot point to any one
patent which shows all of that.’’
Finally, the petitioner contends that the claim in suit
is invalid as functional, stating that the results and func-
tions of the Smith invention can be realized only with ap-
paratus shown in the Smith patent. This argument, as
we shall show, has no applicability to this case.
In addition, this is an attack upon the validity of the
patent, and the several Courts of Appeal have universally
sustained claim 1 of the patent. There has been no dis-
senting voice and, therefore, no conflict of opinions on this
question.
The sole question concerning which there has been a con-
flict of oninion is, whether claim 1 should be given the
scope of its own terminology and the breadth to which it
is entitled by reason of the revolutionary character of
the Smith invention and its far reaching effects upon com-
mercial incubation of eggs.
We are advised that the companion case from the Eighth
Cireuit Court of Appeals (Smith v. Snow) has been set
for argument during the same week that the instant case
is set, and as the arguments in both cases will occur
substantially together, and the points involved in the
cases are the same, we respectfully refer the Court to our
brief in that case for a fuller discussion of the patent in
suit, the file wrapper, and other matters of the same gen-
eral nature. We shall confine the present brief to those
points of infringement which are peculiar to the peti-
a
4
tioner’s construction and to certain details of the evi-
dence which are not found in the Snow record. In the
instant case the testimony, relative to the inception and
original reduction to practice of the Smith invention in
the year 1915, is more complete than in the Snow case,
and more extended reference will be made thereto in this
case. In the instant case also, the movement of the air
throughout the machine was expressly admitted by the
petitioner to be in current form; in fact, there are draw-
ings and affidavits prepared by Robbins, who is de-
fending this case, which outline and define the current
movement of air. As the air moving instrumentalities
used by Snow are identical with those used by the peti-
tioner here, the joint effect of the records in the two cases
thoroughly establishes that both infringers use the re-
cycling current movement of air characteristic of the Smith
process.
History of this suit:
This suit was filed November 22, 1929, in the Southern
District of California against the petitioner, who is a
hatcheryman in Los Angeles County, operating what is
known as a Robbins #23 incubator, manufactured and sold
by John L. Robbins or the Robbins Incubator Manufactur-
ing Company of Denver, Colorado. The manufacturer
appeared and defended the suit (R. p. 180; Master’s Re-
port R. p. 27). The cause was referred to a master, David
B. Head, before whom the case was tried. The Master
reported his findings in a carefully prepared opinion (R.
pp. 27-50), holding claim 1 of the patent valid and in-
fringed. The defendant filed exceptions to the Master’s
report, but before they could be heard, the case was re-
opened before the Master on the alleged Fullington and
Lawry prior uses. The testimony on these issues was taken
by deposition, the plaintiff also taking the testimony of
Dr. Smith and corroborating witnesses, as to the date of
his successful reduction to practice. The Master filed a
5
supplemental report (R. p. 90) reaffirming the validity of
the Smith patent, and finding that Smith reduced the
invention to practice in the spring of 1915.
Again exceptions were filed, and the District Court
(Judge McCormick) overruled all the exceptions and
affirmed the Master (R. p. 106). A motion for rehearing
was denied, and on appeal the Circuit Court of Appeals
of the Ninth Cireuit affirmed the District Court. The
Court of Appeals made special reference to the Master’s
report, saying (R. p. 682; 70 F. (2d) 457, 460) :
‘‘In this case we are satisfied that the decision of
the master is correct for the reasons we have stated,
and for others which are more elaborately stated by
the master and which we need not repeat.’’
The Master’s opinion discusses the Smith patent with
more understanding of the problems to be encountered and
Smith’s solution thereof than is shown in the decisions of
many of the Courts. The Master is, we believe, the only
one who has passed upon the Smith patent after seeing
incubators in actual ‘commercial operation. His obser-
vation was (R. p. 43):
‘‘To observe one of the plaintiffs’ incubators in
operation, wherein 52,000 eggs are in process of in-
* eubation at one time, and compare it with the small
incubators of the prior art, leads to the conclusion
that Smith’s disclosure was an important departure,
revolutionizing the practice of an old art. It has
all the earmarks of a meritorious invention and must
be so credited.”’’
The Master also discussed, understandingly, the file
wrapper of the Smith patent, and his summation thereof,
at pages 36 and 37 of the record, is refreshingly clear.
The Smith invention:
When Dr. Smith first took up the study of incubation
the only incubators in use were the old, desk-like boxes
6
in which a single layer of eggs of one age were sub-
jected to heat in a still air environment. No one had
successfully practiced any other method of hatching eggs
artificially, and the number of eggs, which could success-
fully be hatched, averaged only about 300 eggs to an in-
cubator. The operations were very unsatisfactory (R. pp.
137-139). Dr. Smith’s aim was to produce some means
by which eggs could be successfully hatched in numbers
far in excess of the capabilities of the old incubators.
Starting with the year 1906 at Lykens, Ohio, Dr. Smith
built his first machine in which 30,000 eggs were set all
at one time, and out of this machine were hatched 30
chicks (R. p. 547). This first experimental machine
bankrupted the inventor (R. p. 561).
In the year 1910 his experiments again broke him
(R. p. 561). In 1912 he built an incubator of two-thou-
sand egg capacity. This incubator was equipped with a
fan and was filled with eggs all of the same age. This
was a failure because the eggs heated up too much at the
end of the run. In a preliminary test, a few trays of eggs
of different ages were taken from other incubators. Dr.
Smith did not appreciate the importance of staged-incuba-
tion for, when the incubator was operated for the com-
mercial hatch, all the eggs were set at one time, and failure
resulted (R. p. 561).
In 1913 Dr. Smith moved to Cleveland, Ohio, and built
larger machines (R. p. 538). In these machines, during
the years 1913 and 1914, the eggs were all set at one time.
As stated by Dr. Smith (R. p. 538):
‘*During the years 1913 and 1914 the hatches were
unsatisfactory. There were so many eggs with chicks
in that would die just before, or at hatching time, and
by using a thermometer we found uneven tempera-
tures, or variations in temperatures, in the various
trays. A tray of good eggs would run much higher
than a tray that contained fewer fertile eggs. In
1913 and 1914 we were setting eggs all of the same
age in one compartment.’’
and again on page 539:
‘‘In 1913 and 1914 eggs were set all at the same
time, or, in other words, the compartment was filled
with eggs and they remained there then for three
weeks until they hatched.”’
and again (Rec. p. 539):
‘‘During the years 1913 and 1914 we would always
have a bunch of eggs left in the trays with dead
chicks in them, which we attributed to the uneven
temperature and overheating of the eggs’’.
and at page 560:
‘‘The temperature of the eggs in the Cleveland
incubator, which I used during 1913 and 1914, was
not uniform. The eggs would heat up in spots and
a great many times there would be a lot of fertile
eggs would not hatch’’.
The statement in petitioner’s brief beginning at the
bottom of page 19 is erroneous. The petitioner insists that
all that Ssaith did in 1915 over his earlier practice was
to add the curtains. He added the curtains, it is true,
but he added the step of staged incubation at the same
time. It is absolutely untrue that Smith publicly used
staged incubation and forced circulation of air prior to
the hatching season of 1915.
The 1913 and 1914 experimental machines, without staged
incubation, were not as efficient as the still air type of
machine and dead chicks resulted (R. p. 539). Beginning
with the season 1915, some structural changes were made
and the eggs were set for the first tume in staged incubation
(R. pp. 536-537). When the combination of staged-incuba-
tion and forced-draft was adopted, success was attained.
The addition of staged incubation was the last step which
was taken by Smith. Without the addition of the last step
success would never have been attained.
8
The experience of Dr. Smith shows how essential to
the process is the combination of forced-draft and staged-
incubation. .
Had Dr. Smith stopped at the point reached in 1913-
1914, he would not have achieved success. Had he merely
increased the strength and velocity of the current of air,
or added the curtains, he would not have succeeded. It
was only because he combined the idea of setting the
eggs in staged incubation with his previous conceptions
of the forced draft that he solved the problem. His
success was almost instantaneous, and was so substantial
that one cannot escape the conclusion that this was an
invention of high order.
In July 1915, following the first season of successful
operation with staged-incubation, George Cugley, the
head of the old and established Buckeye Incubator Com-
pany of Springfield, Ohio, called on Dr. Smith with regard
to an invention relating to brooder stoves (R. p. 518).
At this interview Smith showed Cugley the incubators
and explained their operation. As Cugley says (R. p.
520) :
‘“‘T had told my Springfield associates about this
very unusual incubator, which was revolutionary in
that it was accomplishing the thing that we had
always regarded as impossible,’’.
Cugley got Dr. Smith’s permission to build some small
trial incubators at the Buckeye plant (R. p. 522), and
these were thoroughly tested in the hatching season of
1917. The license to Buckeye was executed at the close
of the 1917 season, after the trial period.
In 1929, when the testimony in this case was taken the
total sales of incubators by Smith and his licensee
reached over $19,000,000.00, and the total egg capacity
over 152,000,000 (R. p. 176).
Artificial incubation had made no major advance until
the Smith invention:
When Smith began his work he found the art of no
extent or importance and confined to the use of the small,
unsatisfactory cabinets. When he had completed his work
in 1915, he opened up possibilities of commercial incuba-
tion beyond the dreams of anyone connected with the
industry. The fact that, in a single room no larger than
a small bed room, 52,000 eggs can successfully be incu-
bated, is a result no one in the art had visioned. Today
thousands of persons find employment in the operation of
large commercial hatcheries, some of which employ large
numbers of hatching units. Dr. Smith, himself, in 1923
was operating a million egg hatchery in Cleveland (R. p.
134), a capacity theretofore undreamed of.
Prior litigation:*
It is not surprising that the success achieved by Smith
has excited envy and cupidity, or that many others,
viewing Smith’s success, would seek to reap some benefit
therefrom. The record of the patent through the Courts
shows the irresistible drawing power of success. Each
and every worker in this field since 1915 has adopted and
used forced circulation of air through eggs in various
stages of incubation. The infringers have never succeeded
in finding an anticipation of the Smith invention.
Two major arguments for non-infringement have been
advanced by those who have followed Smith. One is that
the patent is limited to a ‘‘current movement”’’ of air.
With this limitation we have no quarrel for, in the pres-
ent case, the petitioner has admitted that he employs
‘current movement”’ of air.
* The decisions on the Smith patent are listed on pages
2 and 3 of the respondents’ brief in the Snow case,
No. 102, q. v.
10
The other major argument is based upon the conten-
tion that, in order to achieve the equalization of tempera-
ture, or, as stated in the claim, in order to carry units
of heat from eggs in the more advanced stage to those
in the less advanced stage, the air, as it leaves the fan,
must play upon hot eggs first. The first Court to adopt
this specious argument was the Sixth Circuit in the
Petersime case (19 F. (2d) 721), and the last Court was
the Eighth Circuit in the Snow case (70 F. (2d) 564).
Between the dates of these decisions, however, the Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals of the Third Circuit had exploded
the theory in the Hillpot case (24 F. (2d) 341), and the
Cireuit Court of Appeals of the Sixth Circuit had in the
Blum case (27 F. (2d) 333), retreated from its former
holding and the Ninth Circuit, in the instant case, had
ruled that order of egg arrangement made no difference
to the achievement of Smith’s results.
As to this point the petitioner is bound by the admis-
sions of his experts that the order of egg arrangement
and the shifting of the eggs make no difference in the
Smith invention (infra, pp. 25-28).
ARGUMENT.
POINT I.
The Patent in Suit.
The Smith process and claim 1:
The history of development of mass incubation shows
that the essence of the invention is the combination of
forced draft with staged incubation. The forced draft
of air should not dry out the eggs too rapidly, and this
Smith provided for by carrying on the process in a sub-
stantially closed chamber and restricting the interchange
of air between the interior and the exterior of the chamber.
The claim is quoted below (Vol. II, p. 5):
‘‘1. The method of hatching a plurality of eggs
by arranging them at different levels in a closed
chamber having restricted openings of sufficient ca-
pacity for the escape of foul air without undue loss
of moisture and applying a current of heated air,
said current being created by means other than varia-
tions of temperature and of sufficient velocity to cir-
culate, diffuse and maintain the air throughout the
chamber at substantially the same temperature,
whereby the air will be vitalized, the moisture con-
served and the units of heat will be carried from the
eggs m the more advanced stage of incubation to
those in a less advanced stage for the purpose speci-
fied.’’
The essentials are shown by the following analysis of
the claim:
(a) The idea of mass incubation necessarily means that
the eggs are stacked in superposed trays, otherwise the
large numbers could not be incubated in the small area
12
of a Smith (or Robbins) incubator. This is covered by
the words
‘‘The method of hatching a plurality of eggs by
arranging them at different levels in a closed cham-
ber’’.
Petitioner’s witness, Prof. Dougherty, testified (R. p. 295)
that, in petitioner’s machine ‘‘eggs are arranged at differ-
ent levels’’.
In spite of this the petitioner seeks to read the phrase
‘‘at different levels’’ to mean that the eggs must be shifted
during the process. This is an ingenious argument but
fallacious, for, as pointed out by the Cireuit Court of
Appeals of the Third Circuit in the Hillpot case (24 F. (2)
341, 342):
‘‘Now it had become a practice in incubation, born
of convenience, not of necessity, to put fresh eggs
at the top of the tiers and move them down as in-
cubation progresses until the eggs that are about
to hatch are at the bottom where the chicks can be
taken out and the litter consequent upon hatching
can be easily removed. This arrangement is not
always followed. Sometimes trays of eggs in the
more advanced stage of incubation are ‘sandwiched’
between trays of eggs in less advanced stage. These
are arrangements of eggs ‘at different levels’.’’
As pointed out by the Circuit Court of Appeals of the
Eighth Circuit in the Snow case (70 F. (2d) 564, 567):
‘‘The statement of the claim is that the eggs are
arranged ‘at different levels’. This is broad enough
to cover any arrangement at more than one level’’.
The Master in the present case analyzed this phrase
correctly when he said (R. p. 48):
‘‘To find infringement it is only necessary to find
that eggs in more than one stage of incubation, ar-
ranged at more than one level in a closed chamber
with restricted openings, are subjected to the air cur-
rents previously discussed and defined.’’
13
The Court of Appeals of the Ninth Circuit in the pres-
ent case held (R. p. 681; 70 F. (2d) 457, 460):
‘‘The appellant seeks to avoid the claim of infringe-
ment by reason of the fact that the eggs in his ma-
chine are not placed in a single column with the fresh
eggs at the top and eggs which are hatching at the
bottom, but are distributed through the chamber with-
out any endeavor to place them in this exact relation-
ship. This difference is clearly immaterial where the
air in a chamber is kept at a constant and uniform
temperature and rapidly circulated. The result of
currents of air moving with high velocity would be
to transfer heat from the older eggs to the fresher
and colder eggs in either event. The important thing
is the high velocity of the air current, avoiding stag-
nation in the immediate vicinity of the eggs in later
stages of incubation.’’
Notwithstanding the overwhelming authority to the con-
trary, the petitioner insists (p. 8) that ‘‘arranging eggs
at different levels’’ necessarily means the ‘‘initial place-
ment of eggs at one level followed by periodical reloca-
tion at successively lower levels until final hatching takes
place at the bottom’’.
In order to support this point, the petitioner is forced
to insert the word ‘‘progressively’’ in his analysis of the
claim in line 2 from the bottom of page 15. But no such
word appears in Claim 1 of the patent quoted immediately
above.
The ‘‘different levels’ refers not to any progressive
shifting of.eggs but is specified to distinguish from the
small incubators of the prior art in which all the eggs were
on one level. This arrangement of the eggs at ‘different
levels’’ permits the current of air readily to reach the large
number of eggs in their various stages of incubation—all of
which is essential to the success of the large incubators
Smith created.
The claim contemplates a plurality of settings. It is
impossible to carry heat from eggs in a more advanced
14
stage to eggs in a less advanced stage, if only one setting
of eggs is in the incubator, and it is impractical to arrange
the thousands of eggs in various degrees of incubation,
except by arranging them in stacks of superposed trays:
therefore, ‘‘arranging the eggs at different levels’’ means
that eggs of different ages are at different levels.
Had Smith intended to confine himself to the pro-
gresswe arrangement of the eggs, it would have been a
simple matter to have worded his claim to convey this
meaning. The simple and direct meaning of the phrase
is that, at any time after the process has been set in
motion, we find eggs arranged at different levels, i. e.,
stacked in trays one above the other so as to conserve
the space. Nor does the specification convey any other
meaning. The opening sentence gives the answer to
petitioner’s contention where it says, lines 8 to 15, page 1:
‘‘The improved apparatus and method, is particu-
larly designed for extensive operations wherein a
chamber of large dimensions is adapted to contain
thousands of eggs in separate trays arranged in tiers
and the method of heating is such that the heated
air is adapted to the eggs im various stages of incu-
bation’’ (Vol. II, p. 4).
In the argument which accompanied the claim in suit,
it was made clear what was meant by the phrase ‘‘at
different levels’’.
‘‘Applicant by the introduction of a current pro-
duced by mechanical means distributes and diffuses
the heat throughout the egg chamber and gives an
even temperature in all parts of the chamber whereby
it is possible to place the eggs at different levels’
(R. Vol. II, p. 359).
‘‘The so-called Mammoth Incubators of recent years
are all made with the egg trays in the same horizontal
plane’ (R. Vol. II, p. 359).
And again on page 360:
‘‘Applicant’s incubator is clearly distinguished in
a a power driven current is employed to establish
15
a uniform temperature throughout the area of the
egg chamber wets the eggs can be placed at dif-
ferent levels’’
(b) The idea of moisture conservation by restricting
the interchange of foul and fresh air to a negligible per-
centage of the whole body of air is contained in the
clause :
‘tin a closed chamber having restricted openings of
sufficient capacity for the escape of foul air without
undue loss of moisture’’.
This expression necessarily brings in its train the idea
that the main body of the air is circulated over and over
again in repeated cycles. This was expressed by the Court
of Appeals of the Third Circuit in the WHillpot case
(p. 343) :
‘‘In Smith, after the air enters, there is no quick
exit. The first requisite is a closed chamber and from
this chamber no air, except foul air, escapes; the
main body is retained in the chamber and is moved
in cycles through the corridor and egg columns,
around and around, on and on, without any defined
end.”’
(c) The equalization of temperature throughout the
mass of eggs by the mechanical propulsion of a current
of air, as distinguished from ‘natural drafts’’, is con-
tained in the clause
‘fand applying a current of heated air, said current
being created by means other than variations of
temperature and of sufficient velocity to circulate,
diffuse and maintain the air throughout the chamber
at substantially the same temperature.’’
This expression has been held to limit the claim to
‘‘current’’ movement of air as distinguished, from inde-
terminate mixing or beating of the air. As there was
not present in the prior art even the beating or agitation
of air around eggs of various stages of incubation, this
limitation is, perhaps, unnecessary, but it does not confine
M2 . ial » wr . , mp ed te Meo! @ sf MOL IY CLI ae URZEAA 2 Ft EEN LE PIONS EID, PS LNG OE Pe
oe A _
16
the patent unduly here, for the petitioner employs current
movement of air (see pp. 28-36, infra).
(d) Maintaining the air at a sufficient oxygen content
to promote and maintain the life of the embryo without
too rapid drying is set forth in the phrases:
‘‘whereby the air will be vitalized, the moisture con-
served.’’
(e) The setting of the eggs in staged incubation’ and
the reciprocal interchange of heat between those eggs
which have passed over into the heat generating phase,
and those eggs which are still in the heat absorbing
phase, is expressed in the clause:
‘fand the units of heat will be carried from the eggs
in the more advanced stage of incubation to those
in a less advanced stage for the purpose specified.’’
None of the non-essentials upon which the petitioner
relies to escape infringement, appear in the claims.
(1) There is nothing in the claim which specifies that
the eggs shall be set in any specific order or that the
air as it leaves the fans shall strike the hot eggs first.
As the Court of Appeals of the Third Circuit said in the
Hillpot case (p. 343):
‘*Undoubtedly that is the preferred method described
and, certainly, that is the working of the apparatus
of claim 4, not of the apparatus of claim 5. But it
is not the working of the methods defined by claims 1
and 2 for they are not so limited in terms.’’
(2) There is nothing in the claim which requires or
makes essential progressive downward shifting of the
eggs during the process. If order of egg arrangement
is not material, then the maintenance of any order cannot
be material either.
(3) There is nothing in the claim about curtains or
partitions to direct the current flow of air. These are,
in reality, details of the apparatus of Smith, and if, peti-
tioner’s incubator employs the current movement of air,
LE TES, LRN PE RMT GLEN NR Ne SES I LS NIT TN IT ETT RES PIT TRIN RE RIT BEA CS .
17
the fact that his apparatus differs from Smith’s is of no
consequence.
(4) The particular arrangement of egg trays is not
essential to carry out the reciprocal interchange of heat
or for ‘‘heat units’’ to be carried from hot to cold eggs.
The recycling movement of air in Smith, will effect the
interchange of heat whatever be the order of egg arrange-
ment.
The file wrapper does not require any non-essentials to be
read into the claim in suit:
To secure the allowance of the claim in suit, Smith was
not compelled to insert any reference to these ‘‘non-essen-
tials’’ in the claim. The petitioner can not substantiate his
arguments for non-infringement by reference to the file
wrapper (R. Vol. II, pp. 317-377).
The Master’s analysis of the file wrapper is clear and
brushes aside the web of untruth which others have sought
to weave about this document. The Master said (R. pp.
36-37) :
« ‘*Upon the scope of the claims defendant has argued
that the file wrapper and contents of the Smith appli-
cation impose specific limitations. The contention is
that this limitation goes to the extent of limiting
Smith to an arrangement whereby the currents of air
coming from the fan must first be passed over the
eggs in the last stages of incubation and thence over
the other eggs, so that the progression is such that the
newest eggs are the last to be reached by the circu-
lating air. This must be upon a theory that the trans-
ference of heat from old to new eggs must be accom-
plished in one cycle. This limitation is not expressed
in either of the claims,* in that the claims go no
further than to say that the eggs must be arranged
‘at different levels’ and the air impelled with suf-
ficient velocity ‘to circulate, diffuse and maintain the
air throughout the chamber at substantially the same
*The Master was here referring to Claim 1, here in
issue, and also to claim 2, not now in issue.
—_—e RRO LET SI TRG EIA SY TSE. I ER ER
18
temperature,’ whereby ‘the units of heat will be car-
ried from the eggs in the more advanced stages of
incubation to those in a le&’s advanced stage.’
‘*In examining the file wrapper it is found that the
Smith application passed through the usual interchange
of ideas and comments between the examiner and so-
licitor. Claims were offered and rejected. By the paper
‘KH’ [R. Vol. II, pp. 357-360] the claims in suit were
added and allowed without comment from the ex-
aminer. Although arguments were offered prior to
that time which pointed out the specific arrangement
of old and new eggs in the Smith structure and
this point was before the examiner, no limitation
to this specific arrangement was required as to
claims 1 and 2. Having this in mind and having
previously taken note of the patented prior art, if
the examiner had felt that some limitation should
have been imposed he surely would have answered
the amendment ‘E.’ From this it is logical to
assume that the examiner had reached by that time
a full understanding of the disclosure and could
find no reason to require such limitation. The
master is unable to find that the file wrapper and
contents place any limitation upon the claims beyond
a fair construction of their language viewed in the
light of the prior art and the disclosure of the pat-
ent. There appears to be nothing in the prior art to
limit the claims to an arrangement of eggs progres-
sively as to age from bottom to top when subjected
to a forced air current. The prior art shows such
an arrangement but not in combination with a forced
draft.’’
ea
The only attempt made by the petitioner to point out
differences between Claims cancelled and the claim in
suit occurs on page 15 of the brief. The italicized parts
of the claim as allowed (in the right hand column) are
‘‘arranging them at different levels’’; the ‘‘current’’ of
air ‘‘created’’ by means other than variations of tempera-
ture. But these limitations do not free the petitioner’s
practice. The petitioner certainly arranges the eggs at
‘‘different levels’’, as can be seen simply by looking at
PRPS Too ee 9 er ’
19
the illustration of its incubator (Vol. II, p. 12). The peti-
tioner also has ‘‘current’’ movement of air, as we shall see.
The petitioner does not deny that he arranges his eggs
‘at different levels’? but states that he does not arrange
them progressively at different levels. But, as we pointed
out above, the limitation gs to progressive arrangement is
not m the claim. The petitioner also says that he does
not use ‘‘Smith’s directed and confined current of heated
air’’, He does not deny that he uses a current of air as
called for by the claim. The claim does not say anything
about a ‘‘directed and confined’’ current.
If these elements are not present in the claim in issue,
it is idle for the petitioner to contend that either of them
was added as a condition of allowance. There is, there-
fore, no file wrapper. estoppel.
As pointed out in our brief for respondent in the Snow
case (pp. 26-36), the element which was added to the
claims just before allowance, and the concurrent amend-
ment to the specification, imputed into the claim the essen-
tial of moisture conservation by the addition of the limita-
tion that the process was carried on in a substantially
closed room with the ‘‘restricted openings’’ to prevent ‘‘un-
due loss of moisture’. But the petitioner can make nothing
of this for,-in the Robbins incubator used by petitioner,
the openings for the interchange of air are such that only
one-tenth of one percent of the entire volume of air
passes to and from the machine in one circuit or cycle
(R. p. 173). 99-9/10% of the whole body of air recycles
through the machine. Thus the moisture is conserved in
the same way that Smith conserves it.
It ts noteworthy that petitioner does not point out where
the claim includes the specific order of eggs.
Claims not in suit contain the limitations upon which the
petitioner seeks to avoid the claim in suit:
It is a well known principle of claim construction that,
where a patent contains a number of claims which differ
. . - a ee ee nee
Bates : . - ums ‘ :
So ae . ~ on
20
in scope, the broader claims will not be construed as con-
taining the narrower limitations of more specific claims,
and, conversely, that the presence of the narrowing limita-
tions in the more specific claims indicates that those limita-
tions were intentionally omitted from the broader claims.*
Applying this rule to the Smith patent, it will be noted
that the curtains which constitute the central corridor are
found in claims 2, 3, 4 and 5. This element was omitted
from claim 1.
The vertically directed current is included in claims 3
and 4 but is omitted from claim 1.
It is, therefore, evident that claim 1 in snit was inten-
tionally drafted in terms of sufficient breadth to cover a
process of incubation combining staged incubation and
forced draft in a substantially closed room devoid of cur-
tains or partitions or corridors, and irrespective whether
the current of air moved in any direction or plane.
As the petitioner says in his brief (p. 22), the claim
is ‘‘simply for the function’’ (process) ‘‘that takes place
in any enclosure containing eggs at different stages of
incubation into which a current of air is directed’’. It is.
not true, as the petitioner states, that the claim covers
‘‘currents * * * generated by differences in tempera-
ture’’ for the claim specifically calls for currents ‘‘created
by means other than variations in temperature’’. Nor is
it true, as stated by the petitioner, that the process
covered by the claim was old. It was new. Neither the
petitioner, nor any other defendant, has been able to
anticipate it, and it has been held valid by every Court
which has passed upon the Smith patent.
* Symington Co. v. National Castings Co., 250 U. S.
384-385 ;
Skelton v. Baldwin, 58 F. (2) 221, 227;
Los Angeles Art Organ Co. v. Aeolian Co., 143 F.
880-885 ;
Wm. B. Scaife & Sons Co. v. Falls City Woolen Mills,
209 F. 210-215.
21
POINT II.
Petitioner Infringes.
(a) The petitioner’s incubator:
The Robbins incubator used by the petitioner is shown
in various photographs (R. Vol. II, pp. 12-16). The fans
which recirculate and cycle the air are shown at Vol. II,
pages 16-18, and the paths of the air currents are shown by
the arrows in those views subject to the slight modification
made by petitioner’s expert in concentrating more of the
return current in the space between the tilting incubation
trays and the horizontally arranged hatching trays at the
left of the incubation trays. The current of air, as it is
propelled by the large fans on the back walls of the
machine, moves outwardly over the floor, walls and ceiling,
as shown at Vol. II, page 16, and striking the front wall
turns back to the fans and moves inwardly in current
form until it reenters the fans and is again circulated.
There is no dispute about this. As the Master said
(R. p. 45):
‘‘The evidence on this point has been greatly
clarified by the substantial agreement of the experts
for both parties (Taggart and Daugherty). The
plaintiffs’ proof is in agreement with representations
made by Robbins in the case of Petersime vs. Robbins,
in the District of Colorado (plaintiffs’ Exhibit 17).
The master observed experiments on the Robbins
machine in evidence and upon a similar machine in
actual use at the Goddard Hatchery near Gardena.
The air in the Robbins machine is driven outwardly
from the sides of the fans and forwardly along the
walls of the chamber at a speed of around 900 feet
per minute. The air strikes the front wall of the
chamber and turns inwardly at about 250 feet per
minute. It passes through and around the trays
on returning to the fans at speeds varying from 40
22
to 350 feet per minute, increasing as it nears the
vortex of the fans to as high as 600 feet per minute.
Anemometer tests in machines both empty and filled
with eggs showed that the air was moving in definite
paths throughout the whole mass of eggs with per-
haps one exception along the left edge of the station-
ary trays where the outgoing and incoming air forms
eddies for the space extending two or three inches
across. This space is a very small part of the whole.’’
The eggs for the first 18 days are held in the large
tilting drum shown in three positions at the right of
the drawings at Vol. IJ, pp. 12-15. They are put in at
three day intervals, or, in other words, about 1/6th of
the capacity of the tilting drum is set at a time (R. p. 154).
No particular order is observed nor is it necessary. Each
tray of eggs, after having been in the tilting drum eighteen
days, is moved over into the hatching racks at the left,
and its space is filled with a tray of fresh eggs, so that the
drum always contains eggs in staged incubation. Directly
behind the fans are small openings for the admission of
the fresh air, and in the ceiling are the openings for the
exit of foul air. As noted above, the rate of interchange
is 1/10th of 1% of the whole body of air in motion. The
air in Robbins moves in current form in repeated cycles
over the eggs in the various stages of incubation, picking
up heat from hot eggs and distributing heat to cold eggs.
(b) The equalization of temperature in petitioner’s practice:
The interchange of heat, conservation of moisture and
recycling of air are all bound up together in Robbins.
They are all manifestations of the same thing, namely,
that in the Robbins incubator the air is propelled in
regular and defined courses in current form so that it
penetrates to every recess of the egg chamber, picking
up heat from those eggs which are hotter than the air
stream, and imparting heat to those eggs which are colder.
23
(c) The equalization of temperature in the petitioner’s
incubator is performed in the same manner as in
the Smith incubator:
The Master said (R. pp. 38-39):
‘‘It is proper to consider here the actual physical
phenomena as shown in the Smith incubator in prac-
tice. The velocity of the air as impelled by the fans
is found to be quite rapid. It is so rapid that a
particle of air in a single cycle is not apt to come
in contact with but a small number of the eggs in
the incubating compartments. For this reason, it
is not material to the process that in any one cycle
one particle of air should come successively in contact
with eggs in each stage of incubation. From the very
nature of the process this is impossible in the Smith
machine in view of the velocity of the air. However,
it is essential-that the air be circulated with such
velocity that particles of air move around all of the
eggs and that the air is so mixed and diffused that
heat units are transferred through the mass, so as to
maintain a uniform temperature. A uniform tempera-
ture is not maintained by a single unit taking heat
from an old egg and transferring it to a new egg,
but by the whole mass being circulated, mixed and
diffused so rapidly that no part of the chamber can
reach a temperature materially at variance with the
remainder of the chamber. During the process heat
is transferred by the medium of the air from the
older hot eggs to the newer cold eggs. If we disregard
the small amount of air that is constantly changing
through the restricted openings, the air is circulated
in closed cycles, and the order in which the eggs are
arranged does not seem to affect the process, so long
as the eggs are arranged at different levels so that
the circulating air may reach all of them.”’
This common sense analysis of the actual operation
of the Smith machine makes illogical any argument for
non-infringement based upon the theory that the air as
it leaves the fan must strike hot eggs first and then prog-
24
ress to cold eggs. In Smith, the equalization of tempera-
ture is carried on, not by a single passage of the air over
the eggs, but by the repeated cycling of substantially the
same body of air over and over again through the eggs.
If 99-9/10% of the air in the petitioner’s machine gets
back to the fan again and starts on another cycle, equali-
zation of temperature is carried on in the same way.
In fact, as we will point out immediately, the experts
for the petitioner specifically and definitely admitted that
neither the order in which the eggs were arranged, nor
the shifting of eggs which merely retains that order, is
essential. This is a fact which not only follows logically
from a consideration of the cyclic movement of air in the
Smith machine, but also pragmatically from an observa-
tion of the operations of infringers. The petitioner ar-
ranges his eggs in any fashion, and the same equalization
of temperature takes place. Snow (in case No. 102 in
this Court) had an elaborate system of ‘‘sandwiching’’,
but still the same results were achieved. The combinations
in which the eggs may be arranged are limited only by the
numbers of combinations which are mathematically pos-
sible; if, however, the recycling currents of air character-
istic of Smith flow over the eggs, the hot eggs will give up
their heat and cold eggs will abstract that heat from the
current of air, no matter what particular combination is
selected.
(d) The testimony of petitioner’s experts constitutes admis-
sions of infringement:
In the trial of the case the petitioner employed two
experts; the first was Mr. Samuel E. Fouts who had a
long training in the Patent Office as an Examiner, and
subsequently as a member of the Appellate Board of the
Patent Office (R. pp. 183-184). The other expert was
Robert L. Daugherty, head of the School of Mechanical
Engineering of the California Institute of Technology
(R. p. 275). The testimony of these experts cannot lightly
25
be disregarded by the petitioner, and the admissions as to
facts of infringement are binding upon him.
The two points upon which these witnesses gave valu-
able testimony were
(i) the immateriality of differences in order of egg
arrangement on the carrying on of the Smith invention;
and
(ii) the unimportance of curtains as a means to direct
current movement of air, provided the speed and volume
of the air in motion was strong enough to maintain its own
current movement throughout the cabinet.
i.
The course of the air in the Smith commercial ma-
chine is well illustrated in the drawing at Vol. II, p. 11.
There seems to be no dispute as to the facts of air recireu-
lation. If the air recirculates and recycles through the
eggs repeatedly, the equalization of heat will necessarily
take place in any arrangement of eggs. This seems to
be admitted by the petitioner at page 22 of the brief,
where it is stated:
‘‘Manifestly, if any current of air is blown over a
miscellaneous lot of articles, some at one temperature
and some at another, it will necessarily equalize the
general temperature in the chamber by removing
‘units of heat’ from the warmer articles and de-
livering ‘units of heat’ to the cooler articles.”’
This admission by the petitioner is wholly inconsistent
with the claim made at page 19 of the Petition in this
case that, in order to accomplish the equalization of tem-
perature, which is the essential of the Smith patent, ‘‘the
air must first strike the hottest eggs.’’ With the record in
this case petitioner could not rely upon any such narrow
view of the Smith invention. The statements by peti-
tioner’s witness Mr. Fouts invalidate all of petitioner’s
arguments based upon the order of egg arrangement.
a ee ee gia ness
26
As Mr. Fouts said:
‘‘In the Smith patent and incubator and w the
Robbins incubators the air is kept sufficiently humid
to prevent the excessive drying out of the eggs, and
the movement and recirculation of the same body of
air in the egg chambers contributes to that result,
and preserves a uniformity of the conditions of the
atmosphere. The admission of fresh air and the dis-
charge of foul air is limited so that the moisture
within the body of air is preserved’’ (R. p. 240).
‘(In both the Smith and the Robbins machines,
as the closed cycle of air moves through the eggs wu
maintains a constant temperature throughout the
chamber, which prevents local hot spots’’ (R. p. 241).
“But as long as you have a closed cycle or a closed
circuit of air current any eggs which are put in that
current are going either to take up heat from the
current or give off heat to the current, depending
upon whether or not they are hotter or colder than
the air in there” (R. pp. 242-243).
‘‘The same thing can be done almost ad infinitum,
or, in other words, the egg trays can be placed
in any particular arrangement and so long as a closed
circuit of air is created the heat will be carried
from the old eggs to the fresher eggs. I think that is
right’’ (R. p. 243).
‘‘In a practical sense it makes no difference as to
the purpose of the moving of the cycle of air in what
arrangement the eggs are placed relative to their age.
‘Q. That is, as respects the claims of the patent, do
you mean?
A. Yes’’’ (R. p. 248).
‘If you refer to the operation of the Smith struc-
ture it makes no difference as a final result, that is,
the air will come to a definite temperature and that
will be such as to take heat units from the hot eggs
and distribute them to some of the cold eggs. These
arrangements all come within the Smith method.
I do not believe it makes any great difference whether
or not the closed cycle is moving in a vertical plane
27
or in a horizontal plane as to its operation and it would
practically accomplish the same thing if it were tilted
in a diagonal position’’ (R. p. 244).
“Q. As the air is moving in a closed cycle, it does
not make any difference how the eggs are arranged so
long as there are different ages of incubation? A.
Only would that be true as an ultimate result. You
would finally get air throughout the whole cycle into
a temperature where it is uniform and it will pick
up heat from one egg and carry it to another egg
somewhere in the cycle” (R. p. 245).
‘‘The air within the chamber is forcibly moved in
currents in a closed cycle as distinguished from
convection currents, although a fan is not necessarily
used, but by some means other than a change of tem-
perature, or, in other words, by any mechanical means
whereby convection currents are not used. The cycle,
or current of air, moves through the body or mass of
eggs from either the upper or the lower, or from the
lower to the upper, end of the tier and in so moving
a substantially uniform temperature is maintained
throughout the chamber and the eggs, which would not
be possible without such a circulation. The air picks
up the heat units given off by the eggs in the more
advanced stages of incubation and imparts the said
heat units to eggs in the less advanced stages of in-
cubation. As the air moves in a continuous cycle
through the eggs, the direction of the air is of no
moment to obtain the broad result that you have
stated here.
The order in which the eggs are placed in the dif-
ferent stages of incubation in that current of air
for the transfer of heat is immaterial in the practical
operation of the Smith machine, although I do not
see that it makes much difference after the thing gets
going once’’ (R. pp. 246-247).
“Q. Then, as a matter of fact it is not necessary
to move the eggs but just to place them so that you
have eggs in varying stages of incubation in that
column of air or in that current of air? That is
correct, isn’t it? A. I think that is correct; yes” (R.
pp. 247-248).
28
Petitioner’s witness, Prof. Daugherty, also made
important admissions upon the immateriality of egg
arrangement.
Prof. Daugherty said:
‘*T believe that the amount of air introduced into
the Robbins incubator through the restricted inlets
and then expelled is somewhat less than one per cent
of the total amount of air in the machine, and that
means that on an average, air entering the machine
will circulate therein at least ninety-nine to one hun-
dred times before it departs’’ (R. p. 287).
‘‘Within narrow limits the circulations of air in the
Robbins incubator would equalize the temperatures
therein’’ (R. p. 294}.
“but the circulation of air in the Robbins machine
tends to maintain a constant temperature and the
same tendency occurs in the Smith machine” (R. p.
294).
Prof. Daugherty also testified that, in the Robbins
machine, the eggs are arranged at different levels; this is
directly contrary to petitioner’s present contention. This
witness testified (R. p. 295):
“‘In the Robbins machine eggs are arranged at dif-
ferent levels.’’
In view of the above admissions of the petitioner’s own
experts, it is impossible for him to insist that he has
avoided the Smith patent by merely changing the order
of egg arrangement or by failing to shift the eggs during
the incubating period, or that the phrase ‘‘arranging the
eggs at different levels’’ is not descriptive of petitioner’s
operation.
When Daugherty was on the stand, he stated the facts
as to the volume and velocity of the air movement in
the Robbins machine. From these facts it appears that
ell ° neal tah i wrung ow SOFIE TR 1 GIP Rs OE WE 4
29
Robbins secured the same current‘ movement of air
through the eggs as Smith secured,’ the simple expedi-
ent of increasing the volume and velocity of the air in
movement, so that the curtains used with the lesser air
velocities of Smith were unnecessary. It is immediately
apparent that the distinction between the Robbins machine
and the Smith patent on this point becomes one of appara-
tus merely.
The facts as to comparative volumes and velocities of
air in movement in the Smith and Robbins machines were
calculated in the Record in a joint discussion between the
Master and the two experts, Daugherty for the petitioner,
and Taggart for the respondent. This discussion occurred
at pages 300-303. It was summed up by the Master at
pages 47 and 48 of the Record:
‘‘The question is answered by the findings made as
to the currents in the Robbins incubator as compared
with the currents in the Smith machine. It was found
that there was no substantial difference in the vel-
ocity of the currents and that in both machines there
were definite currents passing through and around
eggs, with the effect of keeping them at a uniform
temperature. Over the eggs in the tilting trays the
lowest velocities were in the neighborhood of 40 feet
per minute. The absence of curtains or partitions in
the Robbins machine is compensated by increased
fam capacity. The two fans of Robbins have a ca-
pacity of approximately 12,000 cubic feet compared
with a capacity of the four in Smith of 6,000 cubic
feet per minute. It is evident that by omitting posi-
tive directing means such as partitions Robbins has
impaired the efficiency of his machine in using greater
fan capacity to obtain the same velocities. That a
process or structure is less efficiently applied than a
patent specified is no defense to a charge of infringe-
ment,—King Ax Co. vs. Hubbard, 97 Fed. 720; Elyria
Iron & Steel Co. vs. Mohegan Tube Co., 17 Fed. (2nd)
827; Standard Brands vs. Federal Yeast Corpn., 38
Fed. (2nd) 329—or that the process is carried out by
an apparatus or mode differing from that specified
in the patent—Tilgham vs. Proctor, 103 U. S. 707.’’
—— IN SORRY IO END ee - Pres or eR ene
30
This was thoroughly understood by the Court of Ap-
peals of the Ninth Circuit when it said (R. pp. 680-681;
70 F. (2d). 457, 460):
‘‘the air is forced from the periphery of the large
fan operating in the inclosed space to the walls of
the incubating chamber and follows the side walls to
the front doors where, striking those doors, it is de-
flected inward and then drawn to the center of the
fans by the suction resulting from the outward move-
ment of the air along the blades of the fan to their
periphery. In actual operation the fan is large and
moves with high velocity, so that the current of air
leaving the periphery of the fan and going outwardly
along the walls of the chamber is moving about 900
feet per minute, its speed when it strikes the front
wall of the chamber and turns inwardly is about 250
feet per minute, and as it passes through and around
the trays on returning to the fan its speed varies
from 40 to 350 feet per minute, increasing as it nears
the vortex of the fan to as high as 600 feet per minute.
There is a definite and continuous current of air util-
ized in the Waxham device moving at a velocity not
materially different from the speed of the air current 4
in the Smith patent and accomplishing substantially
the same purpose.”’
we Pa. Oe Sour
The admissions of petitioner’s witnesses, Fouts and
Daugherty, on this point are quite illuminating, and can
not be ignored by the petitioner.
Mr. Fouts said (R. p. 248):
“It makes no difference whether there is anything
to guide the air travelling in the path indicated, if the
air does travel in that path. If the air will travel
without a guiding means, and so long as it does go in
that path, it makes no difference whether or not there
ts any apparatus to guide it.’’
‘‘T think it is probably true that it might be pos-
sible to drive a body of air with sufficient force and
in sufficient volume so that the main body of that
air would travel in a definite path’’ (R. p. 249).
Daugherty said:
“~~ “There is a definite circulation of air in each ma-
chine. In Smith this definite circulation is brought
31
about by a purely mechanical arrangement, that is
to say, by the curtain which divides the central corri-
dor from the egg compartments, and almost anyone,
by a mere inspection of the machine, could tell in
what direction the air would flow through the egg
compartment because the curtain insures that.
‘**Tf the curtain were removed, then of course
there weuld be no such definite circulation established.
In the Robbins machine there is also a definite circu-
lation, but not so easily defined, because there is no
mechanical arrangement such as a curtain or partition
to compel it to flow in any particular way’ ”’ (R. p.
279).
‘*In other words, while there are obvious currents
in the Robbins machine the course is not obvious’’
(R. p. 282).
‘‘You can easily find it out if you go into the
machine with some kind of an instrument or device
when it is in operation’’ (R. p. 287).
“The Robbins machine is a substantially closed
chamber with restricted openings, which is essential
to the production or existence of the closed circuit
we have been discussing, and the circulation or
current movement in the machine is due to the
action of fans rather than to convection currents
and mere differences in temperature” (R. p. 295).
‘‘in the Robbins machine there are currents flowing
from front to back and back to front without any
mechanical partitions between the two’’ (R. p. 296).
“*The distinction is entirely one of apparatus rather
than flow of air currents themselves. In one case
there is a mechanical dividing wall and in the other
case no such mechanical dividing wall, but it is only
what I would call some of the streamline conditions
that determine the flow’’ (R. p. 296).
‘‘Q. In other words, you can get the equivalent
effect, so far as the current is concerned, by a differ-
ent capacity fan, you might say, in place of the cur-
tains, isn’t that true?
A. In some degree. By different capacity of fan,
I want to make clear that I restrict this only to the
case where you have a very much higher velocity of
32
the air particles downward, so that the inertia effect
of the air would keep it from deviating from that
downward path.
Q. But that would give the same current movement
substantially as the currents give to the less velocity
of air propelled by the fan, is that correct?
A. Yes, I think that would be true, at a high enough
velocity’’ (R. p. 297).
**Q. Now, I take it that your answer is that if
your currents were sufficiently strong, several times
the current which is used in the Smith machine, that
you could accomplish a downward current through
the corridor and upward through the eggs, without
the use of the curtain?
A. Yes’’ (R. p. 298).
(e) Robbins’ admissions in other litigation as to current
movement of air:
Robbins, the manufacturer of petitioner’s apparatus,
cannot now maintain that he employs any form of air
movement other than the ‘‘current’’ movement of air by
reason of statements made in prior litigation. Robbins v.
Petersime (51 TP. (2) 174, C. C. A. 10). The owners of
the Petersime patent, which is subsequent to the Smith
patent, claimed to have a monopoly on the incubation
of eggs by means of ‘‘agitation’’ of air through eggs
of various stages of incubation. In defending that suit,
Robbins testified that he used current circulation of air,
as brought out in this case by the examination of Robbins
(R. p. 326). The District Court at Denver held that Rob-
bins infringed the Petersime patent. Robbins then filed
the extensive petition for rehearing which constitutes
Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 17 (Vol. II, p. 23).
At page 6 of this exhibit Robbins says (R. Vol. II,
p. 30):
‘*that in the Robbins machine appreciable air currents
are produced and maintained as a necessary result
of the large fan in the rear, revolving at about two
hundred twenty revolutions per minute, and that this
fan produces a current circulation of air.’’
Ce ae ee 6 PORNO REE hes By HORI FNS o wren 20 PRC ER RETO pes —
33
And at page 7 (R. Vol. II, p. 31):
‘‘that there is appreciable and well defined current
circulation in all parts of the Robbins machine, and
that this circulation is entirely different, as hereto-
| fore stated, from the stirring and mixing of the air
in the Petersime machine’’.
and:
‘‘On the contrary in the Robbins machine the large
fan produces and maintains current circulation of
the air in all parts of the machine.’’
and:
‘‘The fan of the Robbins machine * * * must
produce current circulation’’.
With the motion for rehearing, were submitted the affida-
vits and reports of tests of two engineers who studied the
Robbins machine with accurate instruments. The papers
were accompanied by diagrams which plotted the air cur-
rents in the Robbins machine and tallied very closely with
the findings of respondent’s witness Mr. Taggart.
The following quotations will suffice:
(Page 5 of Affidavit of Morton [R. Vol. II, p. 38]):
“‘there are air currents of substantial strength as
expressed in feet-per-minute travel terms, in all parts
of the incubating and hatching sections of the Rob-
bins incubator, the travel being forward or toward
the front in the exterior portions of the chamber and
inward or toward the fan in the interior portions of
the chamber, and there are no portions of the cham-
ber where the air is dead or inactive.
Further, we find that in the Robbins incubator the
air currents are positive and continuous in the direc-
tions indicated in the diagrams and as heretofore
explained, as distinguished from the mixing and
churning effect produced on the air in the Petersime
machine.’’ (Italics ours.)
—_— ” .
34
(Page 6 of the Report [R. Vol. II, p. 53]):
‘‘This test proves conclusively that the air move-
ments are in general, in definite lines or paths, and
that in all areas a decided movement of air was
found.’’ (Italics ours.)
(Page 10 of the Report [R. Vol. II, pp. 57-58}):
‘*1, In the Robbins Incubator a definite and com-
paratively strong movement of the air in all parts of
the cabinet was found by actual test. This move-
ment in general was toward the front of the cabinet
in the outside areas of the cabinet and the return
being through the central area. A movement at all
points in the cabinet was found.’’
Fig. No. 7, attached to the report (Vol. II, p. 62) and
reproduced on the opposite page is substantially a dupli-
eate of the findings of plaintiff’s expert shown on Plaii-
tiff’s Exhibits 10, 11 and 12 (Vol. II, pp. 16, 17 and 18).
There can be no dispute as to the current movement of
air in the Robbins machine.
It is also helpful to compare the path of air travel, as
illustrated in this drawing, with the path of the air travel
in the Smith machine (Pltf.’s Ex. 5, R. Vol. II, p. 11). In
both cases the air leaves the fan in current form, strikes
the opposite side of the cabinet, and then returns to the
fan, to be recirculated through the eggs. In both cases,
the egg trays are located in the current of air which is
returning to the fans. The only difference is that the air
returning to the fan in Smith is outside of the outgoing
air stream, while in Robbins, the air returning to the fan
is inside of the outgoing air stream. This obviously is
immaterial.
The ruling of the Court of Appeals of the Tenth Circuit
in the Robbins-Petersime case, 51 F. (2d) 174, based upon
35
Last. page Plaintiffs! Exhibit 17,
ROBBINS INCUBATOR
mO.6-622
PLAN VIEW
LOOKING DOWN
AT &@ OF FAN.
srO2St+R PM.
FAN4
met ‘a = a
> ee a
PT Pd
oe te re
a ie te Na b
FRONT
THiS DIAGRAM INDicatEes
GEweRaL. AIR MOVEMENT
And DIRECTIONS
FIGURE No. FY
ROSCOE W MORTON ME. CA STILPHEN KEVE
GOLDEN, CoL°o. MAR10, 1930 DENVER COLO
36
the representations of Robbins and his engineers as to the
character of the air movement in the Robbins machine,
amounted to an adjudication that that machine infringes
the Smith patent. There are not conceivably more than
two types of air movement, either the air is in general
commotion or it is moving in current form. The former
is Petersime, the latter Smith. Robbins contended in the
Tenth Circuit that he had the latter, and the Court so
ruled.
The only distinction which the petitioner apparently
tries to make between the current movement of air in his
incubator and that in Smith is that in petitioner’s incu-
bator the air returns to the fans in ‘‘broken up currents’’
(Brief, p. 24). The only thing which serves to break up
the current in the petitioner’s incubator is the fact that
the trays are located in the current. In this respect
petitioner’s practice is not different from Smith, for in
Smith the egg trays are located in the current of air as
it returns to the fans, and serve to break up the current
in the same way. In this connection it will be observed
that the strips 28, located at the bottom of the tilting
egg racks in Smith, are not used in commercial devices
(R. p. 274), and are not included as any part of a claim
of the patent. Petitioner also says on page 6, that in
Smith the air is ‘‘compelled’’ to move in defined channels.
The movement of air in the Robbins incubator is no differ-
ent, for the force of the air as it leaves the fans ‘‘com-
pels’’ it to move in defined channels.
(f) The Hillpot case (24 F. (2) 341) distinguished:
Petitioner seeks (p. 28) to bring his practice within the
findings of the Circuit Court of Appeals of the Third
Circuit in the Hillpot case in which infringement was not
found. There is, however, the essential difference that
Hillpot did not utilize current movement of air through
the eggs, while Robbins does employ such movement of
37
air. In its findings upon the operation of the Hillpot
machine, the Court said (p. 345):
‘‘When the warm air leaves the fan there is for a
moment and for a short distance a current, but as the
force weakens the current fades, and the body of
heated air does not go to the opposite wall and mush-
room but wanders in between each of the scores of
trays and goes where it pleases.’’
Obviously the method differed in the essential of ‘‘cur-
rent’? movement of air. In the present case no such de-
fense can be made for the reasons fully discussed.
As to the absence of curtains the Court said that Hillpot
‘‘simply omitted curtains’’. The petitioner here did more
than omit the curtains. He increased the volume and
velocity of the air to such an extent that curtains were
not necessary as a directing means for the air. As peti-
tioner’s witness, Daugherty, said (R. p. 296):
‘‘In the Robbins machine there are currents flowing
from front to back and back to front without any
mechanical partitions between the two, * * * The
distinction is entirely one of apparatus rather than
flow of air currents themselves.’’
The order of egg arrangement was regarded by the
Cireuit Court of Appeals of the Third Circuit, in the
Hillpot case, as no factor in deciding the question of
infringement, for that Court said (p. 344):
‘‘But when, as in Smith, the air moves in cycles
through corridor and tiers it makes no difference after
the first cycle which way it moves through the egg
trays, whether from bottom to top or from top to
bottom, or whether it first strikes warm eggs or first
strikes cool eggs, for in every cycle after the first the
current when passing warm eggs wil] wather up their
heat units and carry them to the coo! eggs precisely
as claimed and will in the same way produce that
uniformity of temperature which is the thing sought
by the art and achieved by the invention.’’
38
It is reasonable to suppose, therefore, that if the facts
of current flow in the Hillpot machine had been shown to
be the same as in the Robbins machine, the same holding
of infringement would have followed.
(g) Summary of petitioner’s operation:
All of the steps of the Smith method are found in the
operation of the petitioner’s machine. There is no diffi-
culty in locating the closed chamber, the restricted open-
ings for the escape of foul air and openings for the
introduction of fresh air, and the eggs are arranged in
different levels in different stages of incubation.
As shown in the preceding chapters, there is also in the
petitioner’s machine the forced circulation of air in sufficient
velocity so that the air reaches the furthermost recesses
of the egg chamber. The air moves in current form from
the fans at the rear to the side walls, ceiling and floor of
the machine along which it moves until it strikes the
front of the machine. The current of air then rebounds
from the front wall and is drawn inwardly through the
egg trays to the fans. The speed of the outgoing current
in the petitioner’s machine is somewhat higher than the
speed of the outgoing current in the Smith machine, but
the speed of the returning current through the mass of
eggs is substantially the same in both machines. This
is not disputed. The eggs in the petitioner’s machine are
in the several stages of incubation, and the air, as it passes
in repeated cycles over these eggs, necessarily picks up
heat from hot eggs and distributes that heat to the cold
eggs.
Petitioner has no partitions, and, therefore, he does not
infringe the apparatus claims of the Smith patent, but he
obtains the same results by increasing the velocity of his
outgoing current so that no partitions are necessary.
The sole function performed by the curtains in the
Smith machine is to insure that the air, as it leaves the
fans overhead, will reach the lowermost hatching trays.
39
It is perfectly obvious and was admitted by petitioner’s
expert (supra, pp. 30-31) that the same results could be
obtained in the Smith machine without curtains by in-
creasing the fan power. The curtains are, in truth, but
a refinement of apparatus and their presence or absence
in no way makes or destroys the basic principle of cur-
rent circulation in the Smith machine.
This is a point which the petitioner does not and cannot
deny. Claim 1 1s for a process, not for a mechanism which
carries out the process. If, by changing the fan and
increasing the volume and velocity of the air, the process
of Smith is carried out, infringement is present.
Courts, which have dealt with the Smith patent, have
all made their decisions on the character of air move-
ment. The point is based upon the appearance of the
word ‘‘current’’ in the claims in suit. The Court of
Appeals of the Sixth Circuit said in the Blum case (27
F. (2) 333): ;
‘The result in that case rests also upon the theory
that the patent contemplates a distinct, or at least
an identifiable, current of air, flowing like a stream
in one direction.”’
The calculations of current velocity and volume show
that the increase in volume and velocity is the mechani-
cal equivalent of the curtains, for it secures the same
current movement of air as is secured in Smith. As the
claims in suit do not specify how the current shall be
secured, this change does not avoid infringement.
(h) Robbins copied from Smith:
As in the Snow case, so in the present case we find
each infringer, before he is able to construct a satisfac-
tory incubator for the mass hatching of eggs, turning
to the Smith incubator for the ideas upon which success
must be based.
It is the undisputed fact that, when Robbins, the manu-
facturer of the petitioner’s apparatus, sought to partici-
a a ~ acewd 2 ORES ORT RTE - LE OAR Rg, ea ME
40
pate in the profitable incubator field, his first efforts were
to make a substantial copy of the Petersime machine which
was subsequent to Smith. This is narrated in the Robbins-
Petersime decision by the Circuit Court of Appeals for the
Tenth Cireuit (51 F. (2d) 174):
‘‘But by way of experiment, he’’ (Robbins) ‘‘made
two machines after Petersime’s pattern, * * * He
said he did this to break up the bottling of the air
within the incubator * * *, and that he destroyed
both of these after one hatch in each, having found
them unsatisfactory. This * * * was * * ®* an
infringement of Petersime * * *%.”’’
After his unsuccessful attempt to copy Petersime, Rob-
bins made two trips to the hatchery operated by Mr. Popp
at Denver, and on each trip studied the Smith machine
in operation at that plant (R. pp. 177-178). This was
in the Fall of 1927. The filing date of Robbins’ patent
on his present machine was in the following February
(R. Vol. IT, p. 459).
Robbins was unable to make a successful incubator
which operated upon the principle of air agitation of
which Petersime was an example. He was compelled to
adopt the current circulation of air which is characteristic
of Smith. He made a deliberate study of the Smith ma-
chine, and then built his incubator to perform in exactly
the manner as the Smith incubator.
(i) The claim in suit is not confined to the exact procedure
set out in the specification, nor is it limited to the
use of the apparatus described:
While not denying the fundamental rule of claim con-
struction that it is the claim which defines the scope of
the patent, petitioner seeks, by detailed reference to the
specification at pages 4 to 9, inclusive, of its brief, to
reach the result which would follow were the specifica-
tion to be taken as the measure of the claim.
In the respondent’s brief in the Snow case (pp. 40-43),
we have referred to the fundamental authorities which
41
establish the rule that the claim is the measure of the
invention and not the specification.* As we have pointed
out above, none of the features upon which petitioner relies
are found in the claim in suit. To read limitations into the
claim from the specification is a practice which has been re-
peatedly condemned (see McCarthy v. Lehigh Valley Rail-
road Co., 160 U. S. 110-116). Even were it true that the
‘‘terms now found were chosen after rejection, to avoid
the prior art’’ (p. 9, Petitioner’s brief), this would be of
no moment, for the language as finally adopted and al-
lowed reads upon petitioner’s practice.
Nor is it necessary to read any limitations into the
claim to avoid the prior art. Such an expedient. would
be condemned by the rule in McCarthy v. Lehigh, supra,
but such limitations are not imposed by the prior art as
we will show immediately.
Although petitioner attempts to camouflage its position,
nevertheless it rests upon the fallacy that infringement
should be determined by the specification and not by the
terms of the claim. But, as stated in Walker on Patents,
Sec. 396, 6th Ed. page 484:
‘Strictly speaking, infringement of a patent is an
erroneous phrase; what is infringed are the claims
of the patent which ‘‘measure the invention’’ and
define precisely what the invention is, and the limits
beyond which one cannot pass without infringing;
therefore it is to the claims of the patent to which
one must look to determine whether there is an in-
fringement.”’
(j) The Smith patent is entitled to the full scope of its
terms by reason of its contribution to the art:
There can be no denial of the fact that the Smith patent
was revolutionary in this art, and its benefits are attested
not only by the widespread adoption and extensive use
by Smith and his licensee, the Buckeye Company, but
* Paper Bag Patent Case, 210 U. S. 405, 419; Winans v.
Denmead, 15 How. 330-343 ; Robinson on Patents, #485,
Vol. II, p. 75.
ee
42
also by the numerous infringements which have taken
place since the date of the issuance of the patent. The
real defendant in this case, Robbins, has put out a large
number of machines (Robbins v. Petersime, supra), each
one of which uses the essentials of staged incubation and
forced draft in a substantially closed incubator cabinet.
Such facts should be taken into consideration in con-
struing the patent.
Narrow or astute scrutiny of a patent should not be
indulged in for the protection of one who has adopted
the basic and generic construction of a successful pat-
ented device. As was said in Keystone Mfg. Co. v. Adams,
151 U. S. 139-144:
‘‘But when, in a class of machines so widely used
as those in question, it is made to appear that at
last, after repeated and futile attempts, a machine
has been contrived which accomplishes the result
desired, and when the Patent Office has granted a
patent to the successful inventor, the courts should
not be ready to adopt a narrow or astute construc-
tion, fatal to the grant.’’
As was stated by Judge Coxe in Electric Smelting &
Aluminum Co. v. Pittsburg Reduction Co., 125 F. 926-937:
‘‘Various other limitations upon the claims are
urged by which the defendant seeks to avoid in-
fringement. They are of the same general nature
and proceed upon the same initial fallacy, namely,
that in a generic process patent every phenomenon
observed during operation and every minute detail
described must be read into the claims and that the
least departure from the claims as so construed
avoids infringement. Neither position is tenable.
In a patent like Bradley’s the claims should be as
broad as the invention and, even if unnecessary and
unreasonable limitations are incorporated in the
claims, the court should interpret them liberally and
not permit a defendant to escape who reaches the
same result by analogous means, though he may em-
ploy additional elements and improve mechanical
appliances.’’
43
Further authorities upon this subject are noted at
pages 44 and 45 of our brief for respondent in the Snow
case.
(k) The prior art imposes no limitations upon which the
petitioner can rely:
The patents relied upon by the petitioner here are
the same as those relied upon by Snow and fully dis-
cussed in our brief for respondent in that case (pp. 45-50).
They are the same prior patents which have been re-
peatedly rejected in the unanimous ruling of the lower
Courts holding the Smith patent valid. |
For the forced draft of air the petitioner relies upon
Smith’s own experimental work which was carried on
without staged incubation. Again let us state, most
emphatically, that respondent did not admit ‘‘that all he
did in 1915 * * * was to add the curtains to his old
incubator’’ (Petitioner’s brief, p. 19). The reference to the
Record at page 545 does not support the petitioner’s state-
ment. Dr. Smith stated that the addition of the curtains
was ‘‘the most important change in the 1915 srruCTURE’’.
The repeated statements by Smith that in the preceding
years he did not employ staged incubation and which are
quoted above (pp. 6 and 7), refute petitioner’s statement
that all that Smith did in 1915 was to add the curtains.
The statement by the petitioner can be nothing less than
a deliberate attempt to mislead this Court.
Smith completed his invention covered in the claim
in suit by the addition of the final step of staged incuba-
tion, and the claim is not invalid because he had con-
ceived the other elements of his invention prior to
the addition of this ‘‘last step’. Nor should Smith
be deprived of protection because this last step may
now appear to have been simple. The failure of the
prior workers in this art, including Smith himself, to
make the combination of forced draft and staged incu-
bation is indicative of invention. As was said by this
44
Court in The Barbed Wire Patent Case, 143 U. S. 275,
282-283 :
‘‘Under such circumstances courts have not been
reluctant to sustain a patent to the man who has taken
the final step which has turned a failure into a success.
In the law of patents it is the last step that wins.
It may be strange that, considering the important
results obtained by Kelly in his patent, it did not occur
to him to substitute a coiled wire in place of the
diamond shape prong, but evidently it did not; and to
the man to whom it did ought not to be denied the
quality of inventor. There are many instances in the
reported decisions of this court where a monopoly has
been sustained in favor of the last of a series of
imventors, all of whom were groping to attain a cer-
tain result, which only the last one of the number
seemed able to grasp.’’
On the subject of staged incubation petitioner relies
upon old and discredited patents which represent futile
attempts to utilize staged incubation, all of which were
failures because they employed no effective means for
equalizing the temperature between the hot and the cold
eggs. It was only by the combination of forced draft
and staged incubation that Smith reached success, and
it is this combination which is lacking in the prior art,
but which is used by petitioner.
The so-called admission (petitioner’s brief, p. 18) that
staged incubation was old had reference to the argument
of the attorney in differentiating the Smith invention
from the Winkler patent. The attorney said (R. Vol. II,
pp. 348-349) :
‘*While it is true that in Winkler the eggs are in
various stages of incubation and have heated air
applied to them, there is no conception of applying the
heated air with a predetermined speed or velocity
that will adapt the heated air to the eggs in various
stages of incubation. In Winkler’s method there isn’t
any suggestion of giving heated air any predeter-
mined speed or velocity. There is merely employed
water jackets which heat the eggs and also the eggs
45
move from place to place by means of carriers. It is
obvious that the eggs in the advanced stages of incu-
bation are not kept from advancing beyond the desir-
able temperature by the employment of any driving
means for the heated air. The only mechanically
operated mechanism in Winkler is the mechanism for
driving the eggs and that is distinctly different from
applicant’s conception which is that of driving the air
in a way that will make it adapted to the eggs in all
stages of incubation.’’
Later on the attorney in discussing this same patent
said (R. Vol. II, p. 359):
‘‘While it is true the egg conveyor of Winkler is
arranged with one section above another he depends
entirely on having a separate heater for each section
adapted to the stage of incubation of the eggs in its
section. Furthermore although his patent was issued
as far back as 1883 his construction is not known on
the market today showing it could not have been a
success. It lacks the essential features that have
made the device of applicant a success.”’
This argument was deemed sufficient to distinguish
Smith in the Patent Office, for the claim in suit was
allowed after the filing of the argument just quoted.
Indeed the Winkler patent is quite absurd, so far as we
know, no one ever incubated eggs by rolling them down
a series of belts through separate compartments kept at
different temperatures. The petitioner follows Smith, not
Winkler.
The Stulik German patent is apparently not seriously
relied upon. It was considered by the Patent Office and
the claim allowed over it. It has no forced draft, no
circulation of air in closed cycles, and no equalization of
heat by transfer of heat units from hot to cold eggs.
Petitioner follows Smith and not Stulik.
The Zimmer patent is an absurd scheme, obviously
inoperative, for the reasons given in respondent’s brief
in the Snow case (pp. 48, 49). Again petitioner takes
Smith as his pattern for incubation and does not follow
Zimmer.
46
POINT III.
The Claim is Not Void as Functional.
At pages 21-24 of its brief the petitioner makes the
highly technical defense that Claim 1 is invalid as the
mere function of the machine.
In the present case, however, the process is not merely
the function of the machine, but constitutes a series of
steps by which a law of nature is put to work. The law.
of nature utilized by Smith is the heat curve of a develop-
ing embryo in the egg (Vol. II, p. 10). While others had
known of this, Smith was the first to utilize the fact that
an egg in the first portion of the incubating period is
deficient in heat and in the last portion of the incubating
period is an active producer of heat. Prior workers in
this art (including Smith himself before 1915) had com-
batted this law of nature. Smith was the first to harness
it and make it accomplish a useful purpose. This law of
nature he put to work by manually setting a large quantity
of eggs at fractional intervals of the total gestation period,
and applying a current of air to those eggs of sufficient
velocity to effect the equalization of temperature, without
destroying the ability of the eggs to hatch. To practice
the invention requires not only the propulsion of a current
of air in a substantially closed chamber, but also the
setting of the eggs and the natural laws of the developing
embryo and the heat transfer referred to on page 22 of
petitioner’s brief. ~
The process of the Smith patent clearly falls within that
class of inventions defined as patentable processes by this
Court in Corning v. Burden, 15 How. 265, 267:
‘‘But where the result or effect is produced by chem-
ical action, by the operation or application of some
element or power of nature, or if one substance to
another, such modes, methods, or operations, are called
processes. A new process is usually the result of
discovery; a machine, of invention. The arts of
tanning, dyeing, making waterproof cloth, vulcanizing
————s
47
India rubber, smelting ores, and numerous others,
are usually carried on by processes, as distinguished
from machines. One may discover a new and useful
improvement in the process of tanning, dyeing, &c.,
irrespective of any particular form of machinery or
mechanical device.’’
And, in distinguishing a process from the mere function
of a machine this Court said in Risdon Locomotive Works
v. Medart, 158 U. S. 68, 77:
‘Tt will be observed that, in all these cases, the process
was either a chemical one, or consisted in the use of
one of the agencies of nature for a practical purpose.’’
The claim in suit picks out from the disclosure of the
patent, the essential steps by which the result can be
secured. That this is a process within the contemplation
of the patent law is hardly to be doubted.
We do not know of any case where a ‘‘method’’ patent
has been held void as ‘‘functional’’ simply because the
patent shows a machine which will perform the ‘‘method’’.
The decision of the Supreme Court in Expanded Metal Co.
v. Bradford, 214 U. S. 366, upset the prior prevailing
notion that a process was not patentable if performed by
machinery.
The case cited by the petitioner at page 22 (Holland
Furniture Co. v. Perkins Glue Co.) is not pertinent to
the facts herein. The patent in that case related to a
composition of materials, and the owner of the patent
attempted to cover materials not specifically mentioned in
the patent, and this Court held that such expansion of the
patent would not be allowed.
All method claims are necessarily more or less fune-
tional in character, for a patentable method is a series
of steps, and when performed by a machine, the method
is necessarily the function or mode of operation of the
machine. Whether the process of incubating eggs, first
evolved by Smith, can be performed in any other ap-
paratus than the patentee’s apparatus, is answered by the
operations of the petitioner. If petitioner’s machine does
48
embody that method, then the petitioner’s statement, that
the method cannot be performed by any other apparatus,
is effectually answered. If, on the other hand, the method
of the Smith patent is not performed in the petitioner’s
machine there is no infringement. The whole question is
one of process and as was pointed out by this Court in
Cochrane v. Deener, 94 U. S. 780-788, 24 L. Ed. 139, 141:
‘‘A process is a mode of treatment of certain mate-
rials to produce a given result. It is an act, or a
series of acts, performed upon the subject-matter to
be transformed and reduced to a different state or
thing. If new and useful, it is just as patentable as
is a piece of machinery. In the language of the
patent law, it is an art. The machinery pointed out
as suitable to perform the process may or may not be
new or patentable; whilst the process itself may be
altogether new, and produce an entirely new result.
The process requires that certain things should be
done with certain substances, and in a certain order;
but the tools to be used in doing this may be of sec-
ondary consequence.’’ (Italics ours.)
There is a remarkable similarity between the facts in
the instant case and those in the last cited case. There
the invention related to the use of currents of air in
the treatment of flour. The defendant and infringer
used currents of air for the same general purpose, but
applied them in a specifically different manner, just as
petitioner here uses currents of air but applies them in a
different manner. There were differences in the machinery
employed far more substantial than any differences found
here, and the defendants claimed to have improved upon
the process just as petitioner here claims to have improved
upon the process. In that case the patented process had
revolutionized the flour industry just as Smith revolu-
tionized the incubator industry. ‘‘But,’’ said this Court
(p. 787), ‘‘it cannot be seriously denied that Cochrane’s
invention lies at the bottom of these improvements, is
involved in them, and was itself capable of beneficial use,
and was put to such use.’’
49
Conclusion.
Claim 1 of the patent contains none of the limitations
which petitioner insists upon for his defense of non-
infringement. It covers the essentials which Robbins
found it necessary to incorporate in a successful incubator
comparable in capacity to Smith’s smaller incubators.
Petitioner arranges his eggs in superposed tiers or ‘‘at dif-
ferent levels’’ in a chamber which is substantially closed so
that the moisture is conserved, and he applies a ‘‘current
of heated’’ air to the eggs. The current recycles and
recirculates as the Smith current recycles and recirculates,
and the equalization of temperature is secured in the same
way. The claim calls for a current of ‘‘sufficient velocity
to circulate, diffuse and maintain the air throughout the
chamber at substantially the same temperature’’. This
the petitioner surely employs. The admissions of his own
experts on both temperature equalization and current
movement spell infringement.
The Smith patent is entitled by its achievements and
by the absence of any anticipation to a fair interpreta-
tion of the claim in issue. Petitioner’s changes do not
avoid the claim or cause the incubator to function in
any way other than as called for in the claim. Petitioner
makes no claim that his incubator operates upon a prin-
ciple different from that of Smith or accomplishes any new
result or the same result in a different manner.
The decision of the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals
should be affirmed.
Respectfully submitted,
CHARLES NEaveE,
Ausert L. Ety,
Lreonarp S. Lyon,
Counsel for Respondents.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.