Transcript of Record — Schnell v. the Vallescura
Supreme Court brief1934
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
oye
a4
Bis
i
*
ti
+ oe ewe
ite
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1934.
No. 134
ah Inte foe eeenliall
: HARRY SCHNELL AND SAMUEL SCHNELL, CO-
: PARTNERS DOING BUSINESS AS H. SCHNELL
& CO., PETITIONERS,
} ve
* ‘HE STEAMSHIP “VALLESCURA”, HER ENGINES,
a ETC., LLOYD MEDITERRANEO.
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SECOND CIRCUIT.
INDEX.
Original Print
Record from D. C. U. 8S., Southern New York.............. 1 1
PL cc cGnneWnsacseeedaceebaeedsoastouseenaeeecs 1 1
DET DARE Nabe eddebba ys 658060000600000000460000500 008 qd 3
dd, ToL EET CCeT TREE ORT. TLE e ECCT ER TE TTT Tee 9 6
SROERUEO DP CORIMEBDE onc nc cccccvicccscrdevenccs 22 14
ne er CO Covececccauteaveacntesus cannes 25 16
DEE GRGRERERRGAGRAGARS KAD OOK GOcb EC OCRESEN SS 25 16
Testimony of Charles M. Lee .......ccccscccceces 26 16
Marry L. Silverman ............... 31 20
: SEE BED Aocicancoanscnsesccece 32 21
is TI BEE anccasccssasescseescs 50 35
Be: Morris Levy (recalled) ............ 81 59
SE BI EE. Sh beds ccaccsccnseceses 84 62
George A. Costello .............05. 97 71
WR We GO cecccocccesnes 101 74
WOE A. GRU ncn ccccnccussccccs 143 109
Leroy A. Matthews .......ccccceees 166 127
Charles M. Lee (recalled).:........ 196 149
Walter G. Cocks (recalled) ........ 199 152
SS Gs GHEE KKccconccecesecies 201 153
Jupp & Derwerter (Inc.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., Octroper 12, 1934.
—497-C.
INDEX
Original
GQOMOGEF ccccsscvnsevccccccsescesscccccccsscsnes 216
Testimony of Bautista Monton ...............++-- 225
Testimony of B. Dulbecco ...... 2... eee e eee ee eees 279
Libellant’s exhibit No. 6—Bill of lading ........... 296
9—Report of refund of duty 296a
11-1la—Letters dated Decem-
ber 5, 1925, and Decem-
he Poe 297
12—Letter dated December
12, 1925, and envelope.. 299
Claimant’s exhibit A—Extract from discharging book 300a
B—Extract from discharging book 300b
C—Extract from discharging book 301
D—Extract from discharging book 302
E—Comparative chart .......... 303
Exhibits in deposition of B. Dulbecco:
1—Htowage Plan ..cccccccccsccccccccvccseces 305
eS cae eneccvencensncdsenenstesssteese 307
4—Copies of 1Ogs ........ccececccccccccccces 312
Opinion, Thacher, J. ......cccccscccsccccccsecccceces 318
Interlocutory decree ........ cece ccccceccesccceveecs 323
_ Statement of evidence before Special Commissioner.... 325
Captton cccccccccsccccccccccccccccccccesesccaces 325
COMOGUY nn vccccccccvcccvescaceetecccces tiaknces 325
Testimony of Harry Schnell .......-...seeeeeeees 329
Tom Lam Forte ..cccccccccstscccecs 351
Taye BiBn .ncccccccccccvcccsecvece 354
DONO ccc ccccccccncccccccccccccccccscescceces 376
Testimony of B. Dulbecco ........ ee eee cece eeeeees 392
Salvatore Irrera ...ccccccccccccees 398
Giuseppe Barone ..........e.eeeee- 405
Report of Special Commissioner ...........+-+eeeeee: 419
Claimant’s exceptions to report of Special Commissioner 427
Opinion, Caffey, D. J. 2.1... eee eee eeeees vandatewene ts 430
Final decree .......- pase ereeccrcccacceeebenseessesese 431
Notice of appeal ........ccccccccccccccccccsccecscces 433
Allowance of appeal ....... cece eee e cee eeeeeeeneens 434
Assignment of errors ........ eee e eee eter eeeeeees aoe
Stipulation as to exhibits ...........- see eeeeeeeeeeeee 439
Stipulation as to record ......-. cece cece cece eccecees 440
Clerk’s certificate............. (omitted in printing).. 441
Proceedings in U. 8. C. C. A., Second Circuit.............- 442
Opinion, Chase, J. .........2ce cece cceeccccccsceeccceeeeee 442
TOMMMORE nn ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccsessccescccecs 448
Clerk’s certificate .....cccccccccccccccccccece iTTro Tort 450
Order allowing certiorari ..... i evadeaers icekR ee meee -. 451
164
171
215
228A
228B
a )
[fols. a-1]
IN UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, SOUTHERN
DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
Harry Scone. and Samve. ScHNELL, Co-partners, Doing
Business as H. Schnell & Co., Libellants,
VS.
Steamer ‘‘Vatiescura’’, Luoyp MepiTerraneEo, Respondent
1925
Dee. 15.
Dec. 28.
Dec. 29.
1926
Apr. 16.
Apr. 27.
Sept. 22.
1928
Nov. 21.
[fol. 2]
Nov. 22.
1929
Apr. 24,
Apr. 24,
Apr. 27.
1932
June 3.
STATEMENT
Filed libel and stipulation for costs and issued
monition—Returnable December 29, 1925.
Filed claim, stipulation for costs and stipulation
for value.
Filed monition—Attached notice given.
Filed answer.
Filed exceptions to claimant’s interrogatories.
Filed note of issue and notice of trial (October).
Thomas D. Thacher, J. Case tried. Libellants—
4 witnesses and 10 Exhibits. Claimant—Ad-
journed to November 22nd, 1928.
Thomas D. Thacher, J. Trial resumed. Libel-
lants—3 witnesses, 4 éxhibits and 1 deposition.
Claimant—3 witnesses, 6 exhibits and 1 deposi-
tion. Case submitted.
Filed opinion #5280—Thacher, J.—Enter decree
for Libellant,
Filed minutes of trial.
Filed interlocutory decree with reference to Wil-
liam Parkin—Thacher, J.
Filed order for commission to Italy—Mack, J.
June 3.-Filed order for commission to Italy—Mack, J.
June 3,
June 22.
Filed order for commission to Italy—Mack, J.
Filed (3) cross interrogatories to B. Dulbecco,
S. Irrera and G. Barone.
1—134
Apr.
Apr.
Apr.
May
May
May
May
May 31.
17.
. Filed interrogatories addressed to Captain Dul-
becco.
. Filed stipulation settling interrogatories to Cap-
tain B. Dulbecco.
. Filed stipulation settling interrogatories to G.
Barone.
. Filed interrogatories addressed to G. Barone.
. Filed interrogatories addressed to S. Irrera.
. Filed stipulation settling interrogatories to S.
Irrera.
. Issued commissions—Genoa, Italy (Barone).
. Issued commissions—Genoa, Italy (Dulbecco).
Issued commissions—Genoa, Italy (Irrera).
. Filed commissions from Genoa, Italy (Barone)
L. & R.
. Filed commissions from Genoa, Italy (Irrera)
L. & R.
. Filed commissions from Genoa, Italy (Dulbecco)
L, & R.
. Filed report of Commissioner—Total damages
with interest to April 14, 1933—$14,475.14.
. Filed transcript of minutes of hearing before
Commissioner.
. Filed exhibits before Commissioner.
. Filed exceptions to Commissioner’s report.
L. & R.
. Filed note of issue. Motion to overrule excep-
tions. Returnable April 28, 1933.
. Filed notice of motion to overrule exceptions.
. Filed opinion #7788—Caffey, J.—Exceptions
overruled.
Report confirmed, Interest to be added on $11,-
262.71 from April 14, 1933.
Filed Bill of costs—$627. 75—J J.
18. Filed final decree. Libellant to recever $14,538.96
g.2
July
17.
and costs of $627.75—Caffey, J. J. & J.
Filed note of issue. Order to show cause to make
order of New York County Supreme Court ef-
fective, etc. Returnable June 2, 1933.
Filed notice of appeal and order allowing same
—Bondy, J. L&R.
July 17. Filed assignment or errors. L. & R.
July 17. Filed bond on appeal for $250.00—National
Surety Company. L. & R.
Jaly 17. Filed bond on appeal for $16,500.00—National
Surety Company. L. & R.
Aug. 10. Filed stipulation and order extending time to file
record on appeal to September 9, 1933.
Aug. 16. Filed order extending term of this Court to Sep-
tember 9, 1933—Patterson, J. L. & R.
Aug. 21. Filed consent to order permitting claimant to
withdraw depositions and exhibits for prepar-
ing record on appeal—Patterson, J. L. & R.
In Unrrep States District Court
LIBet
To the Honorable Judges of the District Court of the
United States, for the Southern District of Néy York:
The libel and complaint of Harry Schnell and Samuel
Schnell, co-partners, doing business as H. Schnell & Co.,
against the Steamer called “‘Vallescura’’, her engines,
boilers, apparel and furniture, and against all persons in-
tervening for their interests therein, in a cause of contract,
civil and maritime, alleges as follows:
First: That on and during all the dates and times herein-
after mentioned, the Libellant was and stil] is a co-
(fol. &] partnership consisting of Harry Schnell and Sam-
uel Schnell, doing business in the Borough of Manhattan,
City of New York, under the firm name and style of H.
Schnell & Co., and within the jurisdiction of this Court.
Second: That the Steamer ‘‘Vallescura’? is now within
the Port of New York and within the jurisdiction of this
Honorable Court.
Third: That on or about the oth day of N ovember, 1925,
Bautista Monton & Co. shipped and placed on board the
Steamship ‘‘Vallescura’’, then lying in the Port of Gan.
dia, Kingdom of Spain, 16,043 crates of onions, marked
“‘Bautista Monton, Benjamin Brines and Lore Romen”’, in
good order and condition, to be carried to the Port of New
York and there to be delivered in like good order and con-
dition as when shipped to the order of Chatham-Phoenix
National Bank & Trust Company, in consideration of the
payment made of a certain freight. That thereafter, bill
of lading was issued, signed and delivered to the shipper
vy the duly authorized representative of the S/S ‘‘Valles-
cura’’, marked ‘‘Bill of Lading #4’’.
Fourth: That on or about the 5th day of November, 1925,
Bautista Monton & Co. shipped and placed on board the
Steamship ‘‘Vallescura’’, then lying in the Port of Gandia,
Kingdom of Spain, 766 half cases of onions, marked
‘Bautista Monton’’, in good order and condition, to be
carried to the Port of New York and there to be delivered
in like good order and condition as when shipped, to the
[fol.6] order of themselves, in consideration of the pay-
ment made of a certain freight. That thereafter, bill of
lading was issued, signed and delivered to the shipper by
the duly authorized representative of the S/S ‘‘Valles-
eura’’, marked ‘‘Bill of Lading #5.’’
Fifth: That on or about the 10th day of November, 1925,
Bautista Monton & Co, shipped and placed on board the
Steamship ‘‘Vallescura’’, then lying in the Port of Denia,
Kingdom of Spain, 8,957 crates of onions, marked ‘‘ Bau-
tista Monton, Superior Onions’’, in good order and condi-
tion, to be carried to the Port of New York and there to be
delivered in like good order and condition as when shipped,
to the order of Chatham-Phoenix National Bank & Trust
Company, in consideration of the payment made of a cer-
tain freight. That thereafter, bill of lading was issued,
signed and delivered to the shipper by the duly authorized
representative of the S/S Bh cial marked ‘‘Bill of
Lading #10’’.
Sixth: That on or about the 10th day of November, 1925,
Bautista Monton & Co. shipped and placed on board the
Steamship ‘‘Vallescura’’, then lying i in the Port of Denia,
Kingdom of Spain, 433 crates of onions, marked ‘‘ Bautista
Monton”’ and 66 half cases of onions, rharked ‘‘ Bautista
Monton #5’’, in good order and condition, to be carried
to the Port of New York and there to be delivered in like
good order and condition as when shipped, to the order of
themselves, in consideration of the payment of a certain
5
freight. That thereafter, bill of lading was issued, signed
(fol. 7] and delivered to the shipper by the duly authorized
representative of the S/S ‘*Vallescura’”’, marked ‘Bill of
Lading #9”,
damaged by and through the negligence of the S/S ‘Valles.
cura’’, in respect to the loading, stowing, custody, care and
proper delivery of the said merchandise, and by and
through the unseaworthiness of the said S/S “‘Vallescura’’.
Kighth: That prior to the commencement of this action
as aforesaid and prior to the arrival of the said S/S
Ninth: That by reason of the premises, your libellants
have sustained damages in the sum of Seventeen thousand,
five hundred ($17,500.00) dollars, as nearly as the same can
now be estimated, no part of which has been paid, although
duly demanded. :
[fol.8] Tenth: That all and singular the premises are
true and within the admiralty and maritime jurisdiction of
the United States and of this Honorable Court.
Wherefore, the libellants pray that process in due form
of law and in accordance with the course and practice of
this Honorable Court in causes of admiralty and maritime
jurisdiction,
6
hundred ($17,500.00) dollars, with interest and costs, and
that the said vessel may be condemned and sold to pay the
same, and that the libellants may have such other and
further relief in the premises as may be just and equitable. .
Joffe & Joffe, Proctors for Libellants, Office & Post
Office Address: 141 Broadway, Borough of Man-
hattan, City of New York.
o
[fol.9] Duly sworn to by Harry Schnell. Jurat omitted
in printing.
In Unrrep States District Court
ANSWER
To the Honorable Judges of the District Court of the
United States, for the Southern District of New York:
The answer of Lloyd Mediterraneo, claimant of the
steamship Vallescura, her engines, boilers, &c., to the libel
and complaint of Harry Schnell and Samuel Schnell, co-
partners doing business as H. Schnell & Co., in an alleged
cause of contract, civil and maritime, alleges, upon infor-
mation and belief, as follows:
First: The claimant denies that it has any knowledge or
[fol. 10] information sufficient to enable it to form a belief
as to the article marked ‘‘First’’ of the libel.
Second: The claimant admits the allegations of the ar-
ticle marked ‘‘Second’’ of the libel.
Third: The claimant admits that on or about November
5, 1925, Bautista Monton shipped and placed on board the
steamship Vallescura, then lying in the port of Gandia,
16,042 packages said by the shipper to be crates containing
onions and consigned to Chatham-Phoenix National Bank
& Trust Company, and that a valid bill of lading was is-
sued on behalf of the master covering the said cargo. Ex-
cept as herein admitted, qualified ¢r denied the claimant
“denies the allegations of the article marked ‘‘Third”’ of
the libel.
Fourth: The claimant admits that on or dbout November
5, 1925, Bautista Monton shipped and placed on board the
steamship Vallescura, then lying in the port of Gandia,
7
Fifth: The claimant admits that on or about November
10, 1925, Bautista Monton shipped and placed on board the
(fol. 11] & Trust Company, and that a valid bill of lading
Sixth: The claimant admits that on or about November
10, 1925, Bautista Monton shipped and placed on board the
steamship Vallescura, then lying in the port of Denia, 499
packages said by the shipper to be 433 crates and 66 half
cases containing onions and consigned to order, and that
a valid bill of lading was issued on behalf of the master
covering the said cargo. Except as herein admitted, quali-
fied or denied the claimant denies the allegations of the
article marked ‘‘Sixth”’ of the libel.
Seventh: The claimant admits that thereafter on or
about December 8, 1925, the said steamship Vallescura
arrived at the port of New York and it alleges that the
said merchandise mentioned above was delivered to the
of Gandia and Denia, and it denies that the said merchan-
dise was not delivered in the same order and condition that
it was in when received for shipment. Except as herein
admitted, qualified or denied the claimant denies the alle-
gations of the article marked ‘‘Seventh’’ of the libel.
Kighth: The claimant denies that it has any knowledge
(fol. 12] or information sufficient to enable it to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegations of the article marked
“‘Eighth”’ of the libel.
Ninth: The claimant denies the allegations of the article
marked ‘‘Ninth’’ of the libel.
8
Tenth: The claimant admits the admiralty and maritime
jurisdiction of the United States and of this Honorable
Court. But it denies that all and singular the premises
are true. ;
Further Answering and for a Complete and Separate
Defense Herein
Eleventh: The claimant alleges that before there was
shipped and put on board the steamship Vallescura at the
ports of Gandia and Denia the merchandise referred to in
the articles marked ‘‘Third,’’ ‘‘Fourth,’’ ‘‘Fifth’’ and
‘‘Sixth’’ of this answer, and at all times mentioned in this
answer and the libel herein, it exercised due diligence to
make the vessel in all respects seaworthy and properly
manned, equipped and supplied pursuant to and in accord-
ance with the terms and provisions of the Act of Congress
of the United States of America, approved February 13,
1893, commonly known as the Harter Act. The respondent
further alleges that prior to and at the time of the ship-
ment of the cargo in question and at all the times men-
tioned in this answer and in the libel herein the said vessel
was in all respects seaworthy and properly manned,
equipped and supplied, and that if any loss or damage was
sustained by the said merchandise, or any portion thereof,
{fol. 13] such loss or damage was due to causes for which,
under the terms and provisions of the said Act of Con-
gress, neither the vessel nor her owner, master, agents or
representatives were liable. The claimant claims and in-
vokes the protection of the exemptions accorded the vessel
and her owner by the terms and provisions of the said Act
of Congress and denies all liability for any loss or damage
that occurred through causes exempted by the same.
Further Answering and for a Complete and Separate
Defense Herein
Twelfth: The claimant admits that on or about Novem-
ber 5, 1925, there was shipped and placed on board the
steamship Vallescura, then lying at the port of Gandia,
16,043 packages said by the shipper to be crates of onions,
and 763 packages said by the shipper to be half cases of
onions, and that on or about November 10, 1925, there was
shipped and placed on board the said steamship, then lying
in the port of Denia, 8957 packages said by the shipper to
' 9
433 packages said by the shipper to be
d 66 packages said by the shipper to
ns, all of which merchandise the claim-
delivered to the shipper on behalf of the master by the
[fol. 14] duly authorized agent of the said vessel; that the
ontain the following provisions:
‘*Shipped in apparent good order and condition by Bau-
tista Monton in and upon the steamship Vallescura * * *
the following packages, said to contain lawful merchandise
as hereinafter specified * * * to be delivered from
3. Weight, measurement, gauge, contents, quantity, qual-
ity, condition, brand and value unknown * * *>)
The claimant denies that it has any knowledge or infor.
mation sufficient to enable it to form a belief as to the con.
tents of the said crates and half cases, or as to the econdi-
tion of the alleged contents thereof. The claimant further
denies that the said merchandise was not delivered in the
same order and condition as it was in when received for
shipment at the above mentioned ports.
Further Answering and for a Complete and Separate
Defense Herein
Thirteenth: The claimant alleges that the
dise referred to in the articles marked
(fol. 15] “Fifth” and ‘‘Sixth’*were carried subject to con-
10
set forth in the said bills of lading; that the said merchan-
dise was carried under the terms and provisions of, and
subject to, the conditions and exemptions set forth in the
said bills of lading, and that among other provisions the
said bills of lading provided as follows:
‘*1, Owners to be exempt from loss or damage caused by
the Act of God, * * * loss or damage resulting from
any of the following perils, whether arising from the negli-
gence, default or error in judgment of the pilot, master,
* * °* heat or fire at sea * * °* wunseaworthiness of
the ship at the commencement or at any period of the voy-
age arising from breakage of shafts or any latent defect
in hull, machinery, or appurtenances, or from the conse-
quences of any damage or injury thereto, howsoever such
damage or injury may be caused, collision, stranding,
straining, or other perils of the seas, rivers, * * *°.’’
The claimant alleges that at all times mentioned in this
answer and in the libel where the said merchandise was in
the custody of the master, agents, or other representatives
of the said vessel, all reasorfable and due care and diligence
[fol. 16] in the handling, stowing, discharging and in every
way guarding and protecting said merchandise from loss,
damage or injury was exercised; that during the voyage
very severe weather was encountered, causing the vessel to
labor heavily, roll, pitch, strain and ship large quantities of
water; that if any loss or damage was sustained by the
said merchandise, or any portion thereof, such loss or
damage was due to causes for which, under the terms and
provisions of the said bills of lading, neither the vessel
nor her master, owner, agents or representatives were re-
sponsible, and was not due to any cause or event arising
through any fault or negligence on the part of the said
vessel, her master, owner, agents or representatives.
The claimant while specifically setting forth above cer-
tain provisions of the said bills of lading prays leave to
refer to the same at the trial of this cause and submit the
same in evidence and have the benefit of any and all provi-
sions contained therein relating to the matter in contro-
versy herein, including those enumerated above as well as
those not so enumerated.
11
Further Answering and for a Complete and Separate
Defense Herein
Fourteenth: The claimant alleges that the said bills of
lading referred to above contain, among other provisions,
the following:
“3. ° © * Contents * * « and value unknown
and not accountable for loss or damage resulting from
(fol. 17] stowage, sweating, leakage, breakage, pilferage,
wastage, rust, decay, rain, spray, frost, thaw, effect of cli-
mate or-heat of hold * * deterioration in quality,
defects, * * * contact with * * or evaporation
from any other goods, * * *»
The claimant alleges that if any loss or damage was sus-
tained by the said merchandise, or any portion thereof,
such loss or damage was due to causes for which, under the
terms and provisions of the said bills of lading, neither the
vessel nor her master, Owner, agents or servants was re-
sponsible, and was not due to any cause or event arising
through any fault or negligence on the part of the Vessel,
her master, owner, agents or representatives in respect to
the handling, stowing, discharging, and in every way guard-
ing and protecting the said merchandise from loss or in-
jury.
The claimant while specifically setting forth above cer-
tain provisions of the said bills of lading prays leave to
refer to the same at the trial of this cause and submit the
same in evidence and have the benefit of any and all provi-
sions contained therein relating to the matter in contro-
versy herein, including those enumerated above as well as
those not so enumerated.
Further Answering and for a Complete and Separate
Defense Herein
Fifteenth: The claimant alleges that the bills of lading
referred to above contain, among others, the following «
provisions:
(fol. 18] <8, Simultaneously with the ship being ready to
unload the above mentioned goods, or any part thereof, the
consignee of the said goods is hereby bound to be ready to
receive the same from the ship’s side, either on the wharf
or quay at which the ship may lie for discharge or into
12
lighters provided with a sufficient number of men to receive
and stow the said goods therein, and in default thereof, the
master or agent of the ship, and the Collector of above port,
are hereby authorized to enter the said goods at the Cus-
tom House, and land, warehouse, or place them in lighter,
without notice to, and at the risk and expense of, the said
consignee of the goods wa they leave the deck of the
ship.’?
The claimant alleges that the consignee failed or refused
to take delivery of the said merchandise, as proyided for
in the above mentioned provision of the bills of lading, and
that if the said merchandise were damaged, or any portion
thereof was lost, it was due solely to the failure of the con-
signees to take proptr delivery of the said merchandise, as
provided for in the above mentioned bills of lading provi-
sions.
Further Answering and for a Complete and Separate
Defense Herein -
Sixteenth: The claimant alleges that the aforementioned
bills of lading contain the following provision, among
others:
[fol. 19] ‘‘10. The ship owner is not to be liable for any
damage to any goods which are capable of being covered
by insurance, nor for any claim, notice of which is not given
before the removal of the goods, nor for claims for damage
or detention of goods under through bills of lading where
the damage i is done or detention occurs whilst the goods are
not in the possession of the ship owner. * *
22. The carrying company shall under no circumstances
be responsible for any loss or damage whatever, caused or
arising before the goods come within reach of, or after leav-
ing the tackles of their vessel, for the purpose of transship-
ment or any other purpose whatsoever.
24. Notice of any claim arising under this bill of lading
must be given by the consignee to the steamer’s agent at
the port of destination, within 48 hours after the landing
13
of, or failure to deliver goods, and the claim to be preferred
within 90 days from the date hereof at, the Offices of the
owner of the steamer * * #»)
e libellant failed t
urs afte
» 88 required b
Further Answering and for a Complete and Separate
Defense Herein
Seventeenth: The claimant alleges that the aforemen-
tioned bills of lading contain the following provision,
among others:
ance, nor for any el
the removal of nor for any package
above the value of $200 unless bills of lading be signed
therefor, with the value therein expressed, and a special
agreement made.”’
14
Wherefore the claimant prays this Honorable Court that
the libel herein be dismissed; that this Court enter a decree
for the claimant, together with all costs and disbursements;
and that the claimant'may have such other and further re-
lief in the premises as in law and justice it may be entitled
to receive.
Loomis & Ruebush, Proctors for Claimant, 52 Broad-
way, Manhattan, New York City.
Duly sworn to by M. N. Giannont. Jurat omitted in
printing. 3
[fol. 22] In Unrtep States District Court
INTERROGATORIES BY CLAIMANT
Interrogatories Propounded to the Libellant to Be
Answered under Oath
1. How many of the alleged crates of onions were (a)
damaged; (b) short; (c) slack?
2. How many of the alleged half cases of onions were
(a) damaged; (b) short; (c) slack?
3. (a) State for each crate separately the percentage of
damage to that crate? (b) State for each half case sepa-
rately the percentage of damage to that half case?
4. (a) State for each crate separately the percentage of
rately the percentage of shortage in that DA Ase’ 8eP2-
[fol. 23] 5. (a) State for each crate separately the per-
centage of slack in that crate? (b) State for each half case
separately the percentage of slack in that half case?
6. If any individual case or crate showed damage and/or
shortage, and/or slackage, state the percentage of each re-
spectively?
7. In stating the above requested information, if you
have not already done so, kindly state the mark or number
of each case separately so that the percentage of (a) dam-
age, (b) shortage, (c) slackage, may be determined for each
individual case.
15
9. State (a) the kind of alleged onions and (b) their
grade? ¢
[fol. 24] consul, also the consul’s certificate of the value
(in dollars of the United States of America) of the eur.
rency in use at the ports of shipment at the time of ship-
ment?
signees of the cargo within 48 hours after the cargo was
landed from the ship’s tackle?
1. 80 (a) state the date when such claim was made,
and (b) attach to your answers to these interrogatories a
true copy of such claim ag made?
16. Were the onions in question put into crates and half
cases at the ports of Gandia and Denia, respectively?
17. If not, state where they were crated?
16
carrier’s agent at the ports of Gandia and Denia, re-
spectively?
20. If not, how long prior to the time they were delivered
to the carrier for shipment were they put into the crates
[fol. 25] and half cases, respectively.
Loomis & Ruebush, Proctors for Claimant.
In Unirep States District Court, SourHern District or
sf _ New Yorr
No. 91-109
Harry ScHNELL and SaMvEL ScHNELL, Co-partners, Doing
Business as H. Schnell & Company, Libellants,
vs.
S. S. Vaniescura, Respondent
Statement of Evidence.
Before Hon. Thos. D. Thacher, District Judge
New York, 3 P. M., November 21, 1928.
Appearances: |
Messrs. Joffe & Joffe (Mr. Joseph Joffe), Proctors for
Libellants.
Messrs. Loomis & Ruebush (Mr. Loomis), Proctors for
Claimant.
The claims of the libel and answer are stated.
[fol. 26] CHartes M. Ler, being duly sworn and examined
as a witness for the libellants, testifies:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. Where do you live, Mr. Lee?
A. 499 West 158th Street, New York City.
Q. And you are employed by the United States Govern-
ment?
A. Yes.
17
Q. In what department? .
A. The Record Division of the Custom House, New York.
Q. And did you on behalf of your Department produce
here the manifest as called for in the subpoena?
A. I have, yes, sir.
Q. Have you got it with you?
A. I have.
Mr. Joffe: I will introduce in evidence the manifest,
dated Dec. 7, 1925, of the steamship Valléscura, produced
by the United States Government from its files at the Cus-
tom House; and I wish to read into the record the master’s
oath on entry of vessel from forggn port; it shows that
“the vessel began its voyage at San Phelen—_—
Mr. Loomis: I suggest that you read it.
The Court: Go ahead and read such portions as you
want.
veyor’s certificate attached to said manifest, which is as
follows: ‘‘We hereby return of our action in respect of the
discharging steamer Vallescura from Gandia, which ar-
rived at the port of New York Dec. 7, 1925, and discharged
Dee. 12, 1925. E. Q. Gans, H. B. Curran, Discharging In-
spectors, Jan. 18, 1926. I have examined the above de-
scribed return and certify it to be correct. @. M. Brewer,
Deputy Surveyor.”
(Received and marked Libellants’ Exhibit 2 of this date.)
Mr. Joffe: Tam reading now from the U. §. Inspectors’
report of the differences between the manifest and the dis.
charge, and particularly from the second page thereof:
Bautista Monton, 13 crates Onions, consignee order, page
or entry No. 2. I am now reading from the manifest indi-
cating the different types of cargo on board. (To Mr.
2—134
18
Loomis) And we have a copy of this manifest, instead
of my reading so many of these——
Mr. Loomis: We don’t have them.
Mr. Joffe: Gandia Red pepper, 1850 cases; Denia, al-
monds, 22600; Peanut bags, 250 cases ; onions, 25,446 crates,
832 half cases; 5000 marked half boxes, but it doesn’t indi-
cate what merchandise it was; if the Court please, I don’t
want to eliminate that. San Feliu, 27 cases, one used house-
hold furniture ; 8 cases of used household furniture; 20 bales
of corks, 15 bales of corks, 1,046 bales of cork shavings ; 1069
[fol. 28] bales of the same cork shavings; 1500 of the same
cork shavings; Palamos, 7976 crates of cork board; 101
crates of cork; insulation for lathing and slabs, 14 cases
of cork bobbins, 88 bales of corks, 176 bales of cork discs, 1
bale manufacturing cork—altogether 9387 packages of dif-
ferent kinds of cork or cork waste.
The Court: What has the cork got to do with the onions?
Mr. Joffe: We wiil explain that after a while. That was
a particular cargo as we will show; I am introducing this
on the question of stowage. An additional 12,003 packages
of different cork board and cork shavings.
Q. Did you produce also from the records of your De-
partment the consumption entry on the merchandise
shipped to H. Schnell & Company, and are the papers which
I am holding in my hand the papers which I mention?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Joffe: I introduce and ask the Court to consider in
evidence the original documents produced by this witness
from the United States Custom House designated as Entry
No. 11, 12,755 import No. 813,138 dutiable consumption
entry Collection District No. 10; Dec. 14, 1925, Port of New
York, imported by H. Schnell & Company, vessel steamship
Vallescura. And I offer in evidence the original bill of
lading attached to the said entry protest from the Depart-
ment above mentioned, and ask the Court for permission
to introduce copies of such bills of lading subject to the
{fol. 29] comparison of my opponent.
(Received and marked Libellants’ Exhibits 3, 4, 5 and
6, of this date.)
Mr. Joffe: I offer in evidence a copy of the certificate
of the Department of Health which is part of the consump-
tion entry to which mention was made, and ask for permis-
19
sion to introduce a certified copy so that I may return the
one I hold in my hand to the United States Government.
(Received and marked Libellants’ Exhibit 7 of this date.)
Mr. Joffe: I offer in evidence the report of the Acting
9499, made by H. Schnell & Company under date of Dec,
10, 1925, relieving them on the records for allowance for
purpose stated, and return will be made in accordance
with the results obtained.
(Received and marked Libellants’ Exhibit 8, of this date.)
Mr. Joffe: I offer in evidence certified copy of the report
of the refund of duty by reason of the commodity being
New York, Dec. 24, 1925, coming from the United States
Customs Service under No. 159106, 138,138, and ask the
Court to accept a certified copy issued by the United States
Mr. Loomis: I don’t see any statement on this paper to
the effect as quoted about the goods being unfit for human
consumption.
Mr. Joffe: I will withdraw that characterization; that is
shown by the Board of Health.
(Received and marked Libellants’ Exhibit 9, of this date.)
It is conceded that the endorsements on the bill of lading
to H. Schnell & Company are genuine.
Mr. Joffe: (To the witness.) Will you please see that I
give you back all of your papers, sir?
The Witness: Yes,
Mr. Loomis: I don’t have any cross-examination, but I
should like the witness to remain available, in case I want
20
(The witness is instructed by the Court to keep the papers
so they may be available.)
[fol.31] Harry L. Srtverman, being duly sworn and ex-
amined as a witness for the libellants, testifies:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. Where do you reside, Mr. Silverman?
A. 9219-168th Place, Jamaica, New York.
Q. And what is your occupation?
A. Clerk.
Q. In what Department?
A. Department of Health of the City of New York.
Q. Have you produced the original records of that De-
partment?
A. I have.
Q. Is that the original record of your Department taken
off your files?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Joffe: I offer the record in evidence, if the Court
please, and ask permission to read from it, that being an
official paper which must be returned to the Department
of Health of the City of New York.
The Court: Yes.
Mr. Joffe (reading) : ‘‘Name, S. S. Vallescura, Location,
Pier 3, Bureau of Registration No. —. Meat or vegetables
or milk; condemnation weight 155,350 lbs. To the Chief of
Division of Food inspection, Department of Health, New
York City, on Dec. 23, 1925, A. M., I made an inspection
on the pier of the above, and condemned the following
unsound foodstuffs: Cargo of Onions, consignee H. Schnell
& Co., marks, Joseph Roman, Bautista Monton, marked
packages 3,107, 3,090 crates, 1744 cases, received for con-
[{fol. 32] demnation, result of overhauling. Consignee H.
Schnell & Company, S. S. Vallescura. Yes. Date of ar-
rival Dec. 5, 1925, ordered overhauled, No. Voyage No.
Overhaul completed on 22/25; cargo discharged Dec. 12,
1925.’’
21
Q. You don’t make these condemnations yourself?
A. No, sir.
Q. Do you know who the Inspector was who made the
condemnation ?
A. Yes.
Q. What is his name?
A. Walter Schailly.
Q. Do you know where he is now?
A. I do not.
No cross-examination.
Morris Levy, being duly sworn and examined as a witness
for the libellants, testifies:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. Mr. Levy, where do you reside?
A. 835 and 7 West 178th Street, New York City.
Q. And what is your occupation?
A. Inspector of Customs.
Q. At what port?
A. At the port of New York.
Q. And how long were you an Inspector of Customs at
the Port of New York?
A. About nine years,
Q. And to what particular Department are you assigned?
A. Surveyors’ Department.
Q. And how long have you been surveying cargoes com-
ing into the port of New York?
A. About 71% years,
(fol. 33] Q. And how long have you been surveying Onion
cargoes in the port of New York?
A. For the same length of time.
. And the majority of these cargoes arrive from Spain?
A. The majority of them do—-well it would be conjecture
Q. Well, it isn’t so important. Tell me how many cargoes
do you examine as part of your duties as a surveyor of
cargoes in the port of New York, particularly with refer-
ence to onions?
A. For how long a period of time?
Q. During any one year. I don’t want you to be exact,
about how many?
A. I should say from about 50 to 70 cargoes.
Q. Did you pursuant to the order of your superiors make
an examination of a cargo of onions on the steamship Val-
lescura in the port of New York on or about December 6,
1925?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you make a survey of the cargo that came on
the steamship Vallescura—I don’t mean whether you make
the survey on the ships, you don’t make surveys on ships?
A. I don’t make surveys, I make examination of the
cargo when it is landed on the pier.
Q. You don’t go into the steamer and examine it?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you make such an examination of the cargo of
onions on the steamship Vallescura sometime in December,
1925?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Have you produced the original record of your de-
termination as to that examination?
A. Yes, sir.
[fol. 34] Q. Will that record refresh your recollection as
to what you did and what you examined and what you
found?
A. Yes.
Q. Will you please consult that record?
Mr. Loomis: Did you make that record?
The Witness: Yes. Do you want me to read the record?
Q. No. Does it refresh your recollection?
A. Well, I have, since yesterday I have covered the record
and I think I could answer your questions with reference
to this examination from memory.
Q. Before I ask you the next question, is the certificate
Exhibit 9 introduced here a certified copy made from the
records of your Department as to your examination?
A. I will have to compare that with my official here, if
you will allow me.
Q. Well, go ahead.
A. Yes, sir.
various sized crates, in my record, my record here is a
transcript of the Custom House permit, which shows the
total quantity irrespective of sizes, while this record here
shows the quantities with the individual sizes of crates,
which is now shown in this record; with the exception of
that, and in so far as it relates to percentages or degree,
it agrees with my record.
Do you remember your examination of this particular
cargo?
A. Well, since I have been subpoenaed; of course, prior
to that I don’t remember, but since I have refreshed my
[fol. 35] memory, and my name appears on this record,
I must answer Yes,
Q. You mustn’t answer Yes unless you remember the ex-
amination of that cargo. What do you mean, Yes or No.
. Yes.
Q. Where did you examine it?
A. At Pier 3, Tomkinsville, Staten Island.
Q. Did you examine Spanish onions cargo before that
date?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Fer how many years?
A. Prior to December, 1925—__
The Court: He said he had been doing it for seven years.
Q° Will you please tell us exaetly what you did with
refere
Q. That claim is made for refund of duty, isn’t it?
A. That claim advises the Collector to make an examina-
tion of the onions and to determine what allowance shall
be made on account of decay under the provisions of the
Rte
A. Upon receipt of this so-called claim for allowance
of decay I proceeded to the pier.
Q. Do you remember what date?
A. On December the 21st.
[fol. 36] Q. Yes.
A. And the representative of the importer was there and
I apprised him of this so-called claim and inquired as to
whether they wanted me to take action on it, which is the
usual procedure; he said Yes, and he designated his pack-
ers to open up a certain percentage, a representative por-
tion of the crates whick were singled out by myself. Now,
there were three sizes of crates, 32s, 50s and 72s respec-
tively, and half cases. The entire lot was examined, that
is to say abont 15 per cent. of the importation. Of the 32
size there was about 65 crates examined, and the result
of the examination showed about 48 or 49 per cent decay.
Of the 50 size, which were in the majority, there was about
800 crates examined, and that showed a percentage of decay
amounting to about 56 per cent, and the 72 size crates about
500 were repacked in bags, and that showed about a 48
per cent decay; and finally the half of the cases 42 were
repacked under our supervision and that showed about a
32 per cent decay.
Q. The packages that are examined are taken at random
at your demand; you pick them out and tell them what packs
to take?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What examination did you make of these onions, did
you handle them in your hands?
A. Well, the onions are handled mostly by the packers
under my direction, or under my supervision; my purpose
is to see that the onion which is really decayed, is discarded
in order to insure an accurate examination.
Q. And will you please tell us what you saw as to the
condition of the onions.
A. Well, I had occasion to at random pick up an onion
to examine it, as it is my duty to do it, and most of the
[fol. 37] onions that I picked up, as near as I can remember,
were slimy beneath the skin.
ig ‘>, Q. Did you open the onions, cut them?
” A. Occasionally I would cut one to see whether the decay
permeated the heart of the onion.
Q. And what did you find?
25
2
A. Well, in most of the onions I examined they were
pretty sound in the heart.
Q. That is the decay came from the outside of the onion?
A. Most of them.
Q. What was the condition of the onion as known in the
trade?
A. Well, they term it as cooked, or baked—words to that
effect.
Q. And what does that designation——
cooked or baked.
The Court: What he calls it doesn’t make any difference,
What is the use of saying some person described the case
as so and so, what we are interested in is what the condi-
tion of these onions was. If you were dealing with some-
body’s admission in regard to the onion who used that
term you might do it, but here is the man who saw the
Q. Will you please describe in more detail the condition
of the onions which you saw discharged from the steamship
Vallescura?
A. Of course, it happened so long ago, it is hazy, and I
[fol. 38] have some recollection on account of the extraor-
dinary amount of decay, but most of the onions I picked,
as near as I can remember, were more or less slimy; some
may have had a little bud,. but the majority of them were
under the skin.
from your experience what caused such condition, or the
approximate cause of such condition?
A. In my capacity as an inspector I am not required
to determine the region of the-decay.
Q. I didn’t ask you that; are you in a position to an-
swer after making that examination what was the approxi-
mate cause of the condition you saw?
Objected to.
A. I could only hazard a guess.
Cross-examined.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. Mr. Levy, just one or two questions: You did say,
did you not, that you had been examining from 50 to 75
cargoes during the 742 years?
A. Approximately I suppose—I might correct that by
saying 50 or 75 importations.
- Q. Importations which might not include—
A. A cargo would mean a collection of importations.
Q. One steamer might include several importations?
A. That is right.
Q. And I suppose that all of those examinations you made
were made because similar applications for claims for re-
fund of duty had been made?
A. Yes, sir.
[fol. 39] Q. And those examinations were made on the
piers where the onions had been discharged?
A. At the piers, and in a few instances, not many, at so-
called weight auction sales rooms.
Q. And in those 50 or 75 cases yearly would you sim-
ilarly have the onions re-packed and the bad assorted from
the good?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And in those 50 or 75 cases did you find that the claims
were good and that the refund should be made?
A. In some instances cargoes were in pretty good shape,
and in other instances they had a slight amount of decay,
just a small amount, and in rare cases, of course, a high
percentage of decay.
Q. I haven’t asked about the percentage; I asked whether
you allowed a claim for refund in the cases you examined?
A. Whether I had allowed a claim?
Q. Yes, whether you had approved the claim for a re-
fund to be made?
A. I didn’t approve the claim, but I reported the result
of the examination.
Q. In all of the cases you examined you did find some
decay, did you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. In all the 50 or 75 cargoes a year you do find some
decay
A. Some decay.
27
Q. And in those cases that you find some decay you re-
port that back to the Customs authorities, and on the basis
of that any allowance for refund is made?
A. Yes, sir. ,
Q. So there was nothing strange or unusual about your
Teporting decay in the other cases as well, is that true?
es, sir.
Q. Now, you didn’t see these onions on thefier until the
2nd of December, did you?
A. I believe my examination took place on the 21st of
[fol. 40] December to the 28th; I will have to refer to this
book; for I looked over this yesterday when I got my
The Court: Just look again,
The Witness: The examination was made from the 14th
to the 21st, inclusive.
Q. By you?
. Yes, sir.
Q. I thought you said you hadn’t done it until the 21st;
I thought you said you had not gone to the pier until the
21st of December?
A. No, according to this record here I must have been
on the pier the 14th; if I said the 21st it was the first time
I made a mistake.
Q. Well, then, your previous testimony you thean to say
was wrong?
A. Beginning the 21st was wrong, yes.
Q. You are sure now that you went over on the 14th?
A. The 14th to the 21st, inclusive.
‘ €n you went on the 14th, had all of the onions been
discharged from the ship?
A. I coudn’t say, I presume though they had, the ship
arrived——
Q. Do your records thére indicate——
A. I wouldn’t make any such statement, because that
would be indicated in the Inspector’s manifest record.
The Court: He asked you if your records showed how
long you were there.
The Witness: Yes, sir.
Q. How long were you on the the pier?
A. Do you mean during the course of the day?
Yes. :
A. I should say at least-——
[fol.41] Q. Does your record show?
A. No, sir; it just gives the month, the day and the year.
’ Q. Is there angers in your record that states that you
were there at the pier on the 14th?
A. In the record introduced, or my own record here?
The Court: Just read the entry that you showed me,
where it says, Commenced—
The Witness: Commenced December 14, 1925, finished
December 21, 1925, examination at Pier 3, Tompkinsville,
Staten Island, Discharging Inspectors, L. L. Petersen and
H. E. Curran, Repacking by importers later.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. May that not refer to the discharging of these goods
from the steamer, since you name the inspectors there you
said the inspectors would attend to the watching of the
goods discharged from the steamer?
A. No, this record has nothing to do with the discharging
inspection.
Q. Why do you mention their names?
A. This book is so gotten up that the regulations require
the insertion of their names for a matter of record in case
they have a return.
Q. But their duty relates to the discharge?
A. Their duties are confined to the supervision or the
unloading of the vessel.
Q. Well, that is just the point, inasmuch as that entry
reading Commenced 14th December and finished 21st De-
cember is coupled with their names, isn’t it a fair assump-
tion to make that those two dates refer to the two dates
[fol. 42] during which the unloading of the steamer was in
progress? Don’t you know that she arrived here on the
12th?
Objected to.
A. The ship previously entered on the 7th.
Q. But the discharge?
A. That I don’t know.
Q. Isn’t it a fair assumption to make that those entries
saying Commenced 14th and finished 21st refer to the dis-
charge of the onions from the ship rather than to your
examination of the onions after they were discharged from
the ship?
~ By the Court:
Q. What do they refer to?
A. These here dates refer to the dates that I actually
examined the cargo. The first date—
Mr. Joffee; What were you going to say?
The Witness: The 14th there mayn’t have been sufficient
cargo landed for me to make examination, and the——
Q. Are you able to Say you examined some onions on
December 14th?
A. IT examined size 39 crates and size 50 on the 14th, 15th,
16th and 17th, and the 72 on the 18th and 19th, and the
half cases were examined on the 21st.
Q. And those are all entered in your book under those
dates?
A. Those are all entered in my book under those dates.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. Can you tell me how long you were on the pier on
those respective dates?
A. I should say six hours or so in the course of a day,
[fol. 43] perhaps seven hours; I usually allowed a little
time to travel back and forth from Staten Island.
Q. You have no independent recollection of that except
from your records there?
A. I had to refer to the records because I examine So
many cargoes of all descriptions I would have to refer to
the record.
Q. You have no independent recollection of the matter
except from the entries in the book?
A. None.
Q. Prior to your examination had any of the onions been
re-packed or re-conditioned?
A. Prior to the examination—they may have been, but
I can’t say for sure. e
Q. Of course, if they had been repacked before you ex-
amined them and the bad onions assorted from the good——
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It wouldn’t be a fair test, would it, as to what the
crates would have shown prior to the re-packing ?
A. No, sir, it wouldn’t.
Redirect examination,
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. Now, Mr. Levy, when you were asked as to the ex-
amination of 75 importations—you are only examining
cargo on which claim is made for refund of duty—is that
correct ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. So that before you make an examination there is al-
ready a claim that something is due from the Government
for the refund of duty, is that correct?
A. Yes.
Q. And you only have to report as to what you find?
A. Yes.
Q. Now, let me put to you this plain language: After you
examined your record, do you now remember just how
that cargo looked, just now I mean without refreshment
{fol. 44] of memory by your record? Do you picture, if I
may use the expression, the cargo that you examined on
December 21st at Pier 3, Tompkinsville, Stapleton, ——
County, New York, can you now picture the cargo?
A. Onions all look alike in every cargo; the only thing
I remember about it there was an unusual amount of de-
cay, a very rare case, and they showed—I remember an
instance, and I believe it was this particular ship, or there
was a cargo that was landed in Staten Island
Objected to.
Q. I only want you to tell us and the Judge and all of us
will understand your hesitations—do you remember the
cargo now after you have read you book and gone over
it since yesterday, as you explained it here?
A. Well, that question you asked me at the beginning as
to the kinds of decay; I stated that those onions that I
picked up to examine, that I occasionally cut open to see
the source of rot or decay showed slimy——
Q. So you do say——
The Court: Let him answer.
A. (Continued.) And some showed of course the usual
decay from the stem of the bud, most of them were slimy
and showed if picked up—would feel warm, so to speak.
31
By the Court:
Q. Is that your present recollection?
A. That is all my recollection.
[fol.45] Q. You have a present recollection to that ex-
tent?
A. Yes.
Q. You have now a present recollection?
A. Yes, sir,
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. Have you been told that there were out of the entire
shipment of some 26,000 cases or crates—there were only
3,000 that were condemned? Do you know that?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Now, that wil] indicate a percentage of only about
11 per cent., wouldn’t it. How can you reconcile the per-
sons, perhaps for that of expense, and they just repack,
and they continue what is known as plugging.
The Court: What do you mean by that?
The Witness: It means where a rotten onion is apparent
from the outside, it is replaced by a g0od onion, but the
whole crate is not——
(fol. 46] Q. But yon don’t think the importer, where he
had 50 or 60 per cent. decay in a case would treat it as a
sound case, do you? °
A. In this particular case they may have delivered from
the pier without re-packing.
But you don’t know anything about it?
A. I know it was a practice——
Q. But you don’t know anything about that at all?
A. I don’t know anything about that at all.
eon A AARRIOERETPReRE Ft
Q. If there had been a re-package corresponding to what
you found in the way of percentage of damage, instead of
3,000 cases being condemned, 13,000 should have been con-
demned, shouldn’t they?
A. 13?
Q. Yes, 13,000?
A. I wouldn’t say 13. There is 38, and 42 for the half
cases-——
Q. Didn’t you say 56 for one——
A. Of course, the crates would average 50, but then there
is half cases only 32 per cent.
Q. There were not very many of those?
A. About 800 and some odd.
Q. It would be approximately half of the ship; that
would be bad on the basis of your percentage?
A. Yes.
Q. And yet you know that there were only 3,000 out of
26,000 condemned after they were repacked?
A. Of course, I don’t know that.
The Court: You ought to explain what you mean by
condemned.
Mr. Loomis: Condemned by the Board of Health.
The Court: Do you know how many were condemned by
the Board of Health?
The Witness: No, sir. It is in the record.
[fol.47] Q. And how many cases do you think altogether
you examined?
A. I examined about 1400 packages of the various sizes.
Q. Out of the entire 26,000?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. And yon picked out the packages yourself for the ex-
amination; you suggested, I mean, the packages to be
examined?
A. I selected packages, getting representative packages,
and required the importers’ labor to do the re-packing.
Q. Now, Mr. Loomis asked you whether it was possible
for anyone to repack the cargo before you arrived and for
you to examine a repacked package; do you know the dif-
ference between an original package and a repacked pack-
age?
A. Yes, sir.
33
Q. Could you tell by looking at it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. So would it be possible for anyone to mistake in ex-'
amination a re-packed package for an original one?
A. No, sir,
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. You did say that you couldn’t tell whether they had
been re-packed or not when you saw them?
Q. Well, did you know whether they were repacked or
not?
A. They had been re-packed before.
(fol. 48] Q. I thought you told me right after that that
it would have made a big difference in the percentage of
bad onions you found in the crate if the re-packing had been
done before you made your examination?
A. The re-packing hadn’t been done before.
Q. Didn’t you say it would have made a big difference?
A. The way I understand the question——
By the Court:
Q. I rather gathered that what you meant was that you
made a difference in the Health Department, is that it3
ment, and then you wandered off into a statement of re-
& way to explain that difference; now just what did you
mean by that?
A. I misunderstood his question ; I thought the question
put to me was whether they began re-packing the onions
because the packages are selected by me, and if any pack-
age shows that it has been re-packed it would show evidence
3—134
34
in it of the breaking of the wire or the re-hammered nails
in the crate, it would be easily detected by a man doing the
work.
[fol.49] By Mr. Loomis:
Q. I understand you now to say that you think they had
not been re-packed when you examined them?
A. Those that I actually examined were not re-packed
before I made the examination.
Q. If they were re-packed they would be better onions,
wouldn’t they?
The Court says they weren’t re-packed.
By the Court:
Q. Let me ask you: Have you any recollection whether
the condition you found in these boxes of onions that you
did examine was more or less uniform with respect to all of
the boxes you examined?
A. Yes, sir, they would be five per cent. re-packing of a
lot-——
Q. Don’t bring in re-packing. You went to this dock
as I understand it and you examined certain cases or pack-
ages of onions; you have told us that you found these onions
in the condition that you have described; I now ask you
whether the condition was a condition which was uniform
with respect to all of the boxes you examined or not?
A. Yes, sir.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. And did you notice whether the onions were chiefly
damaged on the outside of the box or on the inside of the
box or crate, at the heart of the crate, or whether the dam-
age was uniformly spread throughout the crate?
A. Well, I can’t remember that, coming down to the fine
points——
{fol. 50] Q. That isn’t a very fine point; you told counsel
for the libellants a moment ago that you had a picture of
the thing independently of the little book you hold in your
hand; now you say you examined 1400 crates there; can’t
you tell me how the damage was spread out throughout
the crate, or was it concentrated in some particular part
of the crate?
A. No, it was spread throughout the crate.
35
Q. Uniform throughout the crate?
A. Uniform throughout.
Harry ScHneE , being duly sworn and examined as a
witness for the libellant, testifies:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Joffe:
. Where do you reside, Mr. Schnell?
. Lawrence, Long Island.
That is in Nassau County?
. Nassau County.
Where is your place of business?
- 323 Washington Street, New York City.
Are you in partnership with your brother?
. Yes, sir.
. What is his name?
. Samuel Schnell.
. You were the consignee of the large cargo of onions
received from the steamship Vallescura in December, 1925?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long have you been in the business of importing
Spanish or other foreign onions?
A. About 16 years.
([fol.51] Q. And what is the approximate amount of car-
goes received during any one year?
rPOrPOrPOPObDO
©
The Court: I really don’t care.
Mr. Joffe: IT want to qualify him as an expert, your
Honor, that is the reason I am asking him—not to show his
importance.
The Court: All right, go on.
A. Over half a million packages a season.
Q. And how are the Spanish onions packed that come
into this country? °
A. In crates; that crate there (pointing to one in the
Court Room) represents the packages of Spanish onions.
Q. That is the smallest package that comes into this
country?
A. That is the smallest, and there are other sizes.
Q. What other sizes—how are they packed?
. Half cases, also full cases.
. What is the approximate weight of a crate?
. From 46-to 48 pounds.
. And a half case?
..65 to 68 pounds. /
. And of a case?
. 138 pounds.
Q. And are all of the packages that come into this country
from Spain packed the same way whether they are shipped
to you or any other importer in the United States?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, do you remember the steamer Vallescura?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you have occasion to go on the pier at the time of
the arrival of the steamer?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. When did you go on the pier?
A. The 7th of December.
[fol.52] Q. What pier did you go to?
A. It was Staten Island, one of the very old piers, a
wooden pier I believe it was.
Q. And when you arrived on the pier was the steamer
docked?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were the hatches opened?
A. No.
Q. Did you wait till they were opened?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you go on the steamer?
A. As soon as the deck cargo was discharged then they
opened the hatches.
Q. What was the deck cargo if you know?
A. Cork.
Q. Did you see whether the deck cargo covered the
hatches?
A. Yes, sir, it covered a lot of hatches and other space
on the steamer. :
Q. That is, the deck was solidly covered, including the
hatches?
A. Not the whole deck, but wherever there was no pas-
sage—that is they left passage for them to pass.
Q. Did you wait until the hatches were open?
A. I waited until they untied the canvass on the hatches
and they opened up the hatches.
P 37
Q. Did you see the cargo of onions in the hatch?
A. No.
Q. Did you look for it?
A. I was on the deck looking down in each and every hold
but I didn’t see no onions.
Q. What did you see?
A. Some dried fruit, like almonds, I believe, raisins, and
some peanuts or some other commodity.
Q. How long did you remain on the pier?
A. I remained on the pier till some onions commenced
to come out from the hatches.
Q. Did you examine the onions that came out from the
[fol. 53] hatches? -
A. I have examined them, yes.
Q. And please describe the condition of the onions?
A. The onions were in very poor condition, decayed, over-
heated and slimy.
Q. Did you open any crates or packages of onions?
A. Yes.
Q. Just explain it?
A. I opened some crates and I took out the onions and I
examined every one, and I was on the pier for quite some
time seeing to quite a few onions which were out, and after
I was all through with the examination I went back to my
office.
Q. Did you see any onions open?
A. Plenty,
Q. And please describe what you found on cutting them.
A. I found the onions inside were O K, the damage was
on the surface, the first, second and third tiers.
The Court: What do you mean by that, tiers?
The Witness: The first three skins. ~
Q. After the examination which you have just described
did you go back to the steamer?
A. I was back on the pier several times.
Q. I want to know whether you went back on the steamer
—did you go back to look at the hatches after they started
to discharge the onions?
A. No, I didn’t go back any more after I saw how the
onions came out. I was more than entirely blue about the
cargo. .
Q. From your experience in examining onion cargoes can
you tell the approximate cause for the condition described
by you in the cargo found on the steamer Vallescura?
38
[fol. 54] Objected to.
Sustained as to the form.
Q. Are you in a position to state the approximate cause
of the condition of the cargo as described by you as you
found it on the steamer Vallescura?
A. Yes.
Objected to—he didn’t see it.
The Court: He has answered, I will let it stand.
Mr. Joffe: If that is your objection I will withdraw it;
I have no intention to tell him, he examined it on the
steamer.
Q. Will you tell us what in your opinion was the approxi-
mate cause of the condition in which you found the onions?
Mr. Loomis: Objected to.
The Court: Objection sustained; I assume the objection
is not as to the qualification of the witness.
Q. Have you see different cargoes arriving in the port of
New York for the last 16 years?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And have you had occasion to investigate the cause of
the condition of such cargoes from time to time?
A. Yes.
Q. Have you seen cargoes prior to the arrival of the
Vallescura on December 5 or 7, 1925, that were damaged by
lack of ventilation?
Objected to.
The Court: We all know that onions are damaged by
lack of ventilation—certainly in this Court—what of it?
[fol. 55] If you want to prove what happened on the ship
you will have to get the people who saw them.
- Mr. Joffe: The purpose of my——
The Court: Don’t offer perfectly incompetent opinion
from a witness who says he can’t make his answers with
any certainty whatsoever.
Mr. Joffe: It isn’t the first time we are offering this
Court such testimony. |
The Court: This isn’t the first time that it has been ac-
cepted—it hasn’t been accepted at all, by me.
Mr. Joffe: Not by your Honor;—the purpose of this
proof is to show that a person who deals in onions for
years is able to examine an onion and tell from its condi-
39
tion what caused that condition. It is true I may be able to
prove that by other witnesses who saw the trip and were
there, but those witnesses are usually the people in the em-
ploy of the Steamship Company. I intend and desire to
prove by this witness that the condition of these onions was
caused, in his opinion, from his experience, by certain con-
ditions—I don’t want to mention them so I would be stat-
ing what they were—and it is for that purpose I am asking
these questions.
The Court: You haven’t gone about it in the right way.
Mr, Joffe: If the objection is that my questions are not
proper
The Court: I will have to rule on your questions as you
put them.
[fol. 56] Q. Now Mr. Schnell, have you seen cargoes prior
to the arrival of the Vallescura on December 5 or 7, 1925,
that were damaged by lack of ventilation.
Objected to.
The Court: Objection sustained. He may answer it if
you want.
Mr. Loomis: He would have to speculate there.
A. Yes.
Q. Have you in your experience as a dealer in onions
had occasion to store onions?
A. Yes, sir,
Q. Have you watched the storing of onions and seen the
different effects and studied the different effects on such
onions of the lack of ventilation?
A. Yes, sir. ’
@ Are you ih a position, trom all your experience as
you have described, to tell from an examination of the
onion what caused that condition?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Can you tell us, Mr. Schnell, from your examination
of onions on the steamer Vallescura, with any amount of
certainty, what was the approximate cause, in your opinion,
of the damage to the onions as you found them?
Objected to.
‘Sustained as to form.
Q. Can you tell us, Mr. Schnell, from the examination
of the onions that you made in this case on the steamer
40
Vallescura, and from your past experience, with reasonable
[{fol. 57] certainty the proximate cause of the damage to
the onions as you saw it?
Mr, Loomis: Objected to. This witness never saw the
onions until they came out of the ship and were on the
pier; he confessedly doesn’t know what their condition had
been, where they were picked, how they were stowed and
where they were stowed; it is pure conjecture.
The Court: He may answer the question Yes or No;
taking into consideration all of the circumstances that
might have produced such an effect he may answer whether
he can state with reasonable certainty that any particular
cause was a cause of this damage.
Q. You heard what the Judge said?
A. It is a——
Q. Now——
A. Yes.
Q. Will you please tell us what it was due to?
Mr. Loomis: I object.
The Court: You may cross examine the witness.
Cross examined by Mr. Loomis:
Q. You didn’t see the onions until they came on to the
pier? 3
A. I saw them when they removed the cargo from the
onions, I saw them inside the hatch,
Q. Did you see any damaged onions when they came on
the pier?
A. No; I saw them on the pier.
[fol. 58] Q. You didn’t see any damage in the ship—you
didn’t see any onions on the ship at all?
A. I didn’t examine them on the ship.
Q. You didn’t see any onions on the ship at all?
A. I saw the onions in the hatch after the cargo was re-
moved.
Q. I thought you said you didn’t see any onions when
you looked into the hatch?
A. I couldn’t see them until the other cargo, the almonds
and raisins and other cargo that was on top was removed.
Q. Well, you don’t mean to say that you know where
the onions were stowed, do you?
A. I saw them inside in the hatches.
Q. Can you tell us where they were stowe- ’
A. They were stowed in the front hatches.
Q. In what holds?
A. I believe it was in 1, 2 and 3 holds, to the best of
my recollection.
Q. What are the agencies that cause decay in onions?
A. Excessive heat.
Q. By agencies I mean——
A. Poor stowage.
Q. What is the thing that makes the decay—what is it
that really decays the onion?
A. Bad stowage,
Q. Isn’t it bacteria?
A. No.
By the Court:
Q. Are you assuming those facts in undertaking to make
this answer?
A. That onions of the nature that those came in, it is
not——— |
Q. You said they were properly packed and selected—
you are assuming all that?
A. Yes.
The Court: Objection sustained. You have been simply
[fol. 59] wasting time for half an hour; I know as much
as he does—that they decay if they don’t have enough
ventilation. How can he go to a dock and say it happened
by something on the vessel; he says it happened after they
went on, they were decayed by your men that he employed.
Go on to your next question.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. When you saw the onions in the hatch, Mr. Schnell,
did you see any spaces left for ventilation?
. No.
Q. Did you immediately upon.examination of the onions
report the condition of them or the dock?
_A. When I got back to the office I reported to the steam-
ship agents.
Q. I mean before you left the dock, did you speak to the
delivery clerk or superintendent of the dock?
A. I don’t recollect that, there were several men, I don’t
remember who it was in particular.
42
Q. Was anyone with you in examining the onions?
A. My brother.
Q. Anyone else?
A. I also had one of the men working for me who was
also on the pier to open up the packages.
Q. Was Mr. Gil with you?
A. Mr. Gil was on the pier as well.
Cross-examined by Mr. Loomis:
Q. Mr. Schnell, where was this pier to which you went?
A. Staten Island.
Q. You don’t remember the number?
A. I think it was Pier 3.
[fol.60] Q. What time in the morning did you get there?
A. Early before noon.
Q. Well, what time?
A. Between nine and ten o’clock.
Q. And you mean to say that they hadn’t started dis-
charging any of the cargo at that time?
A. Not the onions, they had discharged the cork from
the deck of the steamer.
Q. But by the time you got there they had discharged
the cargo of cork?
A. No, they were working on the cork.
Q. What I asked you was whether when you arrived
there the discharge had commenced?
A. The general cargo?
Q. Had discharging from the ship commenced when you
got there?
. I saw the cork being discharged.
That was the cork that was being discharged, was it?
. Yes.
Was that being taken out of the hatches of the ship?
. From the top of the deck.
That was being taken from the top of the deck?
. Yes.
Wasn’t any being taken out of the hatches?
. No.
. And you didn’t go on board the ship while the cork
was being discharged?
A. No.
Q. You waited until it had all been discharged?
A. Yes.
Sopeopepeorer
43
Q. Did I understand you to say on your direct examina-
tion that you had seen cork stowed on top of the hatches?
Yes, sir.
Q. You don’t know whether that had just been placed
there temporarily while the discharge was going on, of
course, do you?
[fol.61] A. I don’t know whether they placed it there
temporarily or otherwise.
Q. You won’t go so far as to say that it had been stowed
on top of the hatch covers on the way across—would you
go as far as to say that?
A. Yes.
Q. It is your contention then that the hatches had been
stowed over with cork all the time, although they were in
the course of discharging the cork when you reached the
ship?
A. Yes, but I was there also when they took off the can-
vas.
Q. How long were you waiting on the pier before you
went on?
A. I waited some time.
Q. Well, tell us how long?
A. When I got on the pier I saw the cargo——
Q. Tell us how long you were waiting there from the
time——
A. It may be four or may be five hours, I didn’t look at
the watch.
Q. You think you were waiting on the pier four hours
before you went on the ship?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you reached there at nine or ten o’clock?
A. Yes.
Q. And you went on the ship at three or four o’clock in
the afternoon?
A. Yes.
Q. Were you all the time outside, or inside sitting down?
A. I was on the pier sitting down.
Q. The pier is a closed pier
A. It is an old pier.
Q. Is it a closed pier?
A. It is badly broken up—I don’t know what you mean
by closed.
The Court: Has it got a roof over it?
The Witness: It has a shed.
44
{fol.62] Q. Now. when you were standing, you were
standing during those four hours on the shed?
A. On the pier.
Q. Were you in the shed or outside of it?
A. In the shed.
Q. And you were never outside of the shed, were you?
A. I was out for lunch, during the lunch hour.
Q. I mean from the time you went on to the pier to the
time you left the pier, except for luncheon, you were not
cutside the shed?
A. No.
Q. Whereabouts on the pier was the steamer located,
on which side of the pier?
A. On the uptown side.
Q. The north side?
A. Yes, the north side.
Q. Was she bow in or bow out?
A. I didn’t examine the bow.
Q. What? :
A. I didn’t examine the bow of the ship, I wasn’t inter-
ested in the ship, whether she was standing one way or
the other.
Q. How long is the pier?
A. Two sections the pier has, there is a front section and
a rear section.
How long is it?
A pretty long pier, I didn’t measure it.
A thousand feet?
I don’t think so; possibly 300 feet.
300 feet?
I don’t know, I say possibly 300 feet.
It was one of the new piers that the City built?
No, it was a very old pier, and the floors and every
side was broken in.
Q. You weren’t pleased with the pier?
A. You asked me if it was old or new, and it was very
old.
{fol.63] Q. And it was 300 feet long; so the steamer oc-
cupied the whole length of the pier.
A. No, the steamer was only on the first section.
Q. So the steamer occupied about one-half the length
of the pier?
A. I couldn’t tell you.
Q. She occupied only one section?
POPOPOoOPO
45
A. It looked to me as if she occupied part of the first
section.
Q. So the other section was not occupied?
A. Unless it was occupied by some other steamer, I
don’t know.
Q. You think there were two steamers lying there?
A. I don’t know, I wasn’t interested in any other steamer,
Q. How long did this steamer appear to be that carried
the onions?
A. I have no idea.
Q. Was it half as long as the pier?
A. I couldn’t tell you whether it was half or three-quar-
ters.
Q. You say she occupied one-half the section, and there
were two sections—that would make the steamer half of
255?
A. I don’t say she occupied the full section, but she was
on the first part of the section.
Q. What is your best judgment of the length of the
steamer? You say you were on her?
A. I don’t know what her length or breadth or depth
was,
Q. If she was less than half the length of the pier she
would have to be less than 750 feet long, wouldn’t she?
_ A. T can’t tell you.
Q. You don’t know much about the steamer, but you .
state you saw a great deal of the stowage of the steamer,
and all that? ?
A. I just tell you what I saw.
Q. You saw the steamer, can’t you tell us the size of it?
[fol.64] A. I am sorry, I didn’t take more notice.
Q. But you were standing there for over four hours be-
sile the ship?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Are you really sure that you were on the steamer at
all that afternoon after they got the cargo discharged?
A. I was on the steamer.
Q. Are you sure of that? =
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is it a practice of yours to go on steamers that come
into this port?
A. Why certainly, I go on many steamers,
Q. Did anybody invite you to go on?
46
A. I take that much privilege, I have a cargo of so many
packages, the Steamship Company never stop me.
Q. You take that privilege?
A. Yes, I do go.
Q. And you went over there confessedly to see whether
you couldn’t prove some damage against the steamer?
A. No, I went there because I owned the cargo.
Q. But you couldn’t get your cargo any sooner by going
on the steamer?
A. It was my privilege to be there and see what is what;
I was anxious to see the onions. :
Q. It was for the purpose of seeing if you could prove
any damage?
A. To see the onions.
Q. To see whether they were stowed properly?
A. To see the cargo in general, the onion cargo.
Q. You would have seen it on the pier shortly; why did
you want to see it on the steamer?
A. I have been doing it on every steamer.
Q. Why do you do it; you say you didn’t have any invi-
tation to go on, you toak the privilege?
A. To see that everything is in order, to see whether there
[{fol. 65] is any damage there, and how soon they will come
out, and how soon I may expect to see them.
Q. Do you go on to see whether it is stowed properly?
A. For every purpose,
\ Q. To see whether it was stowed properly in the hatch?
A. Yes, as well as to see how soon the cargo will come
out.
Q. Of course, when they opened the hatches you couldn’t
see all the way back into the after part of a hold, could you?
A. No, I couldn’t see anything but cargo there, general
cargo on top. .
Q. I say you couldn’t see the after part of the hold, all
you could see was the well of a hatch when they opened
the hatches?
A. Just the size of the hatch.
* Q. All you could see was the well of the hatch, and the
cargo was stowed right up in it
A. Yes. .
Q. And it was there that you saw what you described as
raisins and nuts?
A. Dried fruit.
47
Q. You couldn’t see in, you could only see the well of
the hatch?
A. Yes, that is all.
Q. Now in what holds did you see even that, the well of
the hatch, what holds were they, do you remember?
A. The holds in each hatch; there was I believe five,
there was 1 and 2 front, and 3 rear,
Q. You looked down in the hatches 1, 2 and 3?
A. I looked in hatch 4— whatever hatches there were there
I went from hatch to hatch.
Q. You mean to say that you looked down into each of
the hatches of the steamer?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were you present at each one when the tarpaulins
were taken off?
(fol. 66] A. I wasn’t present at each one when they were
taken off, I saw them taken off.
Q. You couldn’t see them al] taken off surely when you
were standing at one hatch?
A. Surely you could see them.
Q. How could you see through the bridge?
A. When you stand on the pier, on the floor, you can see
what is going on on the deck of the ship, the ship was a
low ship, it wasn’t one of those very high ships.
Q. You don’t mean to say that your eyes when you stand
on the pier are level with the top of the ship?
A. With that ship it was, I could see everything that was
going on on top of the hatches.
-Q. So you didn’t look up when you were standing there?
A. I looked up as every human being would do.
By the Court: :
Q. He is inquiring whether you looked up when you saw
these hatch covers taken off ; were they level with your eye
or how did you look?
A. Just as I stood on the pier, I looked straight up, I
saw everything going on.
By Mr. Loomis: -
Q. You looked straight up?
A. I looked over the ship.
Q. You said you looked up, straight up, and now you say
you looked over the top of the ship:
A. I don’t know what you want.
48
By the Court:
Q. He wants to know in what direction you looked as
you stood on your feet on the pier, up, down, or straight
{fol. 67] ahead, or straight up?
A. Well, over the ship.
Q. Well, how far above your head was the rail of the
ship?
A. I don’t think it was—I doubt if it was 20 inches.
Q. The top of the rail?
A. That was the edge of the ship?
Q. Well, whatever was between you and the men on the
deck.
A. I don’t think there was any rail on that steamer the
way the cargo was stowed, there wasn’t any rail.
Q. And the edge of the deck you think was 22 ft. above
your head? }
A. About 20 inches.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. The edge of the ship was 20 inches pl the top of
your head?
A. But if you stood from a distance it was very simple
to see what is going on always, a little away from the
steamer.
By the Court:
Q. You stood how far away? aA
A. Six or seven ‘feet away from the side of the pier.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. How could you, you know the shed comes out to the
edge of the pier; how could you stand six feet away when
the shed itself extends right out?
A. The same way as they unload the cargo, the shed is
there as well, and still they unload the cargo, so it gives
plenty of space.
Q. Now, it appears you were standing inside of the shed
looking out through a door?
A. Yes.
Q. All right. Well, how could you see deasinisee but the
hatch visible through that door; how could you look out ©
and see the other parts of the ship?
' 49
A. I made it my business to see.
[fol.68] Q. As you were standing there, six feet from the
edge of the pier, looking through a door, you could see only
the hatch immediately in front of you; you couldn’t look
through the walls of the shed and see the hatches forward
and aft?
A. There are a number of open places on the pier.
Q. But there are doors: it isn’t one continuous opening?
A. There they are very wide doors, I am sure you know
the size of those doors as well as I do. |
Q. How wide are they, as you think?
A. Oh, I judge 15 or 20 ft.
Q. And how much is the distance of the wall, the part
of the shed, between each door?
A. Possibly 10 ft. or so.
Q. So when you stood back inside on the shed looking
out at the hatch in front of you you couldn’t see the other
hatches on the steamer, could you? ,
A. I could very well see every hatch, for I could go from
one door to the other and look at it.
(Adjourned until 10.30 A. M., Nov. 22, 1928.)
91-109. Before: Hon. Thomas D. Thacher, D. J.
November 22, 1928, 10:30 a. m.
Same Appearances.
S. S. Vallescura.
Harry Scunett, resumes the stand for further exami-
nation by Mr. Loomis: :
Q. I was cross-examining you last night when you left
the stand in respect to the amount of the deck of the ship
[fol. 69] Vallescura you could see while standing on the
pier, and my recollection is, that you thought you could see
the whole of the ship from where you stood.
A. The whole of the ship? No. I was on board of the
steamer,
Q. You afterwards went on board?
A. Yes, sir,
4—134
50
Q. You could not see the various hatches from where
you stood on the deck of the pier?
A. I saw the tarpaulin being taken from those hatches.
Q. Could you see the hatches themselves from the deck
of the pier?
A. When I went on board the steamer, that was the place.
Q. You are not answering my question.
A. Probably it must have been low tide. I saw the tar-
paulin being taken off from the hatches.
Q. You have not answered my question yet.
A. Please repeat it.
Q. Could you see the hatches themselves as you stood on
the deck?
A. I saw the place, that is, I saw where they took out
the tarpaulin from the hatches; I saw the hatches, sure.
Q. Could you see from where you stood, the hatches
themselves?
A. Imean, the hatch coamings, you don’t mean the inside,
do you? The outside, yes.
Q. The hatch coaming?
A. The frame, yes, where the hatches are, that’s what I
saw.
Q. As you stood on the deck of the pier?
A. Yes. ae
Q. You saw that after the cloth had been taken off?
A. I saw that when they took off the tarpaulin.
Q. You could not see it while the cloth was still on there,
could you?
A. No.
Q. So that the time when you first saw the hatches as you
stood on the deck of the pier, was after the cloth had been
[fol. 70] removed from the deck of the ship?
A. You mean, when I was standing on the pier?
Q. Yes.
A. After the cloth was removed, then the laborers, the
longshoremen, were taking those tarpaulins from the
hatches,
Q. And it was then that you went on board?
A. That was the second time I went on board.
Q. You had been on board previously?
A. Yes. .
Q. When were you on board previously, first? ?
A. When I got on the pier.
Q. You went on board when you got on the pier?
51
A. Yes, sure,
Q. But then the cloth was still on?
A. Yes,
Q. And the hatches were still covered?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And then it was that you saw, I suppose, each of
those hatch openings, not only closed with tarpaulins, but
actually covered with cargo stowed on top?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. There is no doubt about that in your mind?
A. Not at all.
Q. Do you claim to be an expert on onion deterioration,
or are you just an expert in the buying and selling of on-
ions?
A. I have handled onions for about fifteen or sixteen
years,
Q. You are not answering my question.
A. I do know a good deal about my onions through my
experience in handling onions year in and year out.
Q. Do you claim to be anything more than an expert in
the buying and selling of onions?
A. I claim to know the onion business as far as the keep-
ing qualities and condition of onions as good as any man
in the line of the onion business,
[fol.71] Q. I do not doubt that you know the business as
well as any man. Do you claim to be an expert on the theory
of onion deterioration? :
A. As to quality and conditions?
Q. No.
A. Keeping quality?
Q. As to onion deterioration. As to what causes deterio-
ration of onions.
A. Yes. '
Q. What is it that causes deterioration? It is germs
that come into the onion, or germs that are already within
the onion, or what is it that causes the deterioration?
A. Lack of ventilation, poor storage and excess of mois-
ture while the onions are in the field, or excessive heat. ~
Q. I know all those things. We do not need an expert
to tell us that. Do those external physical conditions of
themselves produce the damage, or do they set in operation
germs and bacteria that are within the onions already, or
get into the onions from the outside and incubate them and
thereby cause deterioration?
52
A. If any onion that is defective by any disease when she .
is growing, during the time they pick those onions they
can tell the difference between bad ones and good ones.
Q. What causes disease in onions?
A. Excessive moisture,
Q. You are getting the physical condition.
Q. There is some bacteria, a little animal organism that
causes it?
A. In onions, as far as onions go, there may be some, but
I have not seen any yet. I have not seen that yet.
Q. You do not know anything about bacteria? t
A. Not as far as onions, because I have had many onions,
and I have never found diseased onions.
Q. You do not think you could see the bacteria?
{fol.72] A. If the onions decay, I presume I could see it.
Q. I am talking about bacteria that would cause the
disease. :
A. The onion disease of that nature would be in the heart
of the onion not in the surface of the onion.
Q. You are arguing. Could you see the bacteria them-
selves that produced the decay in onions?
. The onions has to be cut open to see it. “
Q. Could you see the bacteria if you cut the onion open?
A. Yes.
Q. How big are they?
A. Not very big.
Q.
A.
>
Big enough to see with the naked eye?
A black spot would show inside in the heart of the
onion.
Q. Are they big enough to be seen with the naked eye?
A. Some more and some less.
Q. Could you see them crawling around?
A. No, you could not see them crawling around.
Q. Do you claim to be an expert on the bacteria that
produces decay in onions? Can you tell me how many
different kinds there are?
A. No, I am sorry, I cannot.
Q. You do not know anything about these bacteria, or
their classification, or how many there are?
A. No.
Q. That is all.
Redirect examination.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. From your experience of fifteen years, could you tell
whether the onion was a diseased onior or a healthy onion?
A. Yes, by cutting it open.
Q. Could you tell it by looking at the onion and handling
it, without opening the onion?
A. I would, if it is very badly diseased I would.
[fol.73} Q. Can you tell the court where the onion is at-
tacked when it is a diseased onion?
Mr. Loorais: I object to that question, unless the witness
is prepared to say that there is only one way.
Q. Can you tell the court where the onion is attacked
when it is a diseased onion? What portion of the onion?
Mr. Loomis: I object.
Objection overruled.
A. Always where the stump of the onion is, in most cases,
that is.
Mr. Loomis: I also object on the ground that he says
he knows nothing about bacteria.
The Court: There may not be any bacteria. That is an
assumption of your own. He says he knows what a rotten
onion is.
Q. Were the onions that you saw on the ‘‘Vallescura”’
that yeu examined, diseased onions? ts
A. No, sir.
Q. Were they healthy onions?
A. They were very healthy onions as far as being free
from any disease.
Q. I show you an onion and I ask you if that is the usual
type of Spanish onion? |
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is the onion I am exhibiting to you, a healthy onion?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Will you indicate to the court, please where the first
evidence of any disease that is known in the United States
(fol. 74] which attacks onions is indicated immediately as
it attacks the onion?
54 =
A. On this side of the onion it would be soft and watery,
showing that it has defects, it does not dry out, mature
properly.
Q. And if you were to push your finger at that particular
point, what would happen if the onion was diseased?
A. There would be an empty space here and it would show
so much dampness, not matured properly.
Q. Will it show any discoloration?
A. If it is diseased?
Q. Yes, surely.
Q. In what form?
A. A bad color; but not the natural color.
Q. Can you tell the court, from your experience, how the
onion looks if it was confined to a place without ventilation
or excessive heat, for a period of say from two to three
weeks?
A. It should show slime, if lack of ventilation, excess of
heat, it would be slimy.
Q. Where?
A. Under this first shell.
Q. And the longer it was in such a confinement, will the
slime go beyond the first layer of the onion?
A. It would go as far as the third tier, one, two, three
tiers.
Q. And if left there for a very long time, then would it
consume the entire onion?
A. It would go gradually. It would take a longer time to
go through the entire onion.
Q. And the deterioration of which you speak, would take
longer under those conditions, going outside to inside?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And deterioration caused in a diseased onion, will go
from inside to the outside?
{fel. 75] <A. Yes, sir, it will show right here at the end of
the onion. oe
Q. Will you please cut this onion open?
A. Which way?
Q. Cut this one open one way and we will cut another
one open the other way. (Witness cuts the onion.)
Q. Now, will you please cut the onion long ways?
A. (Witness cuts another onion.)
Q. Now, are these two onions that you opened for the
court, known as an absolutely perfect onion?
- 55
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How long is it since it came from Spain?
A. From the steamer Levanza, which was here about Six
weeks ago.
Q. Did it have any special care?
A. No, as far as if my possession, none whatever.
j Q. And it came in the ordinary way on the steamer?
£2 We left it on the floor with ventilation. '
Mr. Loomis: I object.
The Court: He got it in the course of business.
Q. Now, Mr. Schnell, after you saw the condition of the
onions on the day you were on the pier, on the S. S. Valles-
cura, did you go over to the Lord Marine Corporation?
A. When I came to my office I called them up and I asked
for the parties who had charge of the Vallescura, and I
told them the condition of the onions, and told them that
I intended to hold them responsible. I also further com-
plained to them that on the fifth of December, I wrote a
letter to the agent telling him that the cold weather at the
[fol. 76] time of the year may be expected any minute and
he should be kind enough and place that steamer on a pier
. where it would be well protected in cold weather. He has
acknowledged that letter to me and promised that he would
do so.
Mr. Joffe: I ask you to produce, Mr. Loomis, our letter
to you of December fifth, which was answered by your let-
ter to us of December seventh. I offer both letters in evi-
dence as one exhibit,
Mr. Loomis: I have no objection.
(Received and marked Libellant’s Exhibit 11.)
Q. Did you go to see the Mutual Lord Marine Corpora-
tion?
A. Yes, I have been in his office. That was a day or
two later.
Q. Did you speak to any person there?
A. I spoke to the agent, and I told him how bad the cargo
was and that I intended to hold them responsible, and I
also referred to his letter that he would take proper care
from freezing, but it seems that he has not carried out what
he promises. He placed the steamer on one of the pooresy
piers available.
56
Mr. Loomis: I move to strike that out, ‘‘it seems’’.
The Court: No, that is what he fold him.
Q. Did you after that visit send a registered letter to
the Mutual Corporation?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. Joffe: I call for the letter of December 12, 1925,
Mr. Loomis.
“ [fol.77] Q. I show you this letter and I ask you whether
that is the letter?
A. Yes, sir ; this is the letter.
Mr. Joffe: I offer it in evidence.
(Received and marked Libellant’s Exhibit 12.)
Mr. Loomis: No objection.
Q. Mr. Schnell, did you repack all of your onions on
the pier?
A. No, just a portion of the cargo.
Q. What portion of the cargo, if you remember?
A. Repacked probably seven to eight thousand packages.
Q. And what did you do with the balance of the cargo?
A. The balance of the cargo was removed by lighters to
a store house.
Q. Do you remember the name of the store house?
A. I think it is the Standard Milling Corporation.
Q. Where is that store house?
A. Somewhere in Jersey City.
Q. Do you remember how many packages you sent there?
A. To be accurate, you will have to let me see the record.
Q. I will show you the record and see if that refreshes
your recollection as to the number of packages that were
removed to the warehouse.
A. Yes, this is the quantity that we removed to the store
house.
Q. How many?
A. About fifteen thousand.
Q. Now, Mr. Schnell, are there records in the State of
New Jersey by the Board of Health of any cargo——
[fol. 78] The Court: I am not going into the details of
damage. You have already shown that there was some
damage.
57
Q. There was something said about the last cargo com-
ing into the Port of New York around December. Will you
tell the Court what is the end of the shipping season with
reference to the Spanish onions, and how late cargoes of
Spanish onions are usually received in the port of New
York.
A. They are usually received up to the end of March.
We bring in onions during April and May from Spain.
Q. How late did you bring in onions during the season
of 1925-26, from December, running into 1926?
A. Until the end of March.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. You say there are fifteen thousand crates of onions
that you had taken on lighters over to a warehouse in New
Jersey?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. There were three thousand odd cases that were con-
demned by the Board of Health, were there not?
@ A. Out of the part that they had repacked on the pier,
there were about three thousand left.
Q. What became of the difference between the fifteen
thousand that you had in the New Jersey warehouse, and
the three thousand that were condemned by the Board of
Health? :
A. We shipped some of the repacked ones to our trade
and we also shipped some originally to our trade.
Q. And the onions that you shipped to the trade were
not sent to the warehouse in New J ersey?
A. No, these were repacked and shipped out of town,
[fol.79] Q. And the onions so shipped to the trade ac-
counted for the difference between those condemned by the
Board of Health and those which were taken to the ware-
house in New Jersey?
g A. Yes. o
Q. Were those taken to the warehouse in Jersey sound,
healthy onions? -
A. They were the same cargo that came out in the origi-
nal condition.
Q. Were they in the original condition?
A. They were in the original condition, the same as those
that were repacked, the same lot that we repacked.
58
Q. Were they in good condition, those you took to the
warehouse in New Jersey?
A. No, those were in poor condition.
Q. Were those rou shipped to the trade in good condi-
tion?
A. Those we repacked were sound.
Q. How about those that you shipped to the trade?
The Court: He said that he repacked them and made
them good.
Q. There would be a difference of about eight thousand
crates between the fifteen thousand shipped to New Jer-
sey and the three thousand condemned by the Board of
Health?
A. Whatever the difference is we shipped. We took a
few in to our store by trucks from the ship.
Q. I want to know whether those eight thousand cases
which you shipped to the trade were in good condition?
A. Repacked. We repacked them and shipped them.
Q. They were in good condition?
A. After they were repacked they were sound, surely.
[fol. 80] Q. Well, now, let me see. I want to get this
straight. You say there were fifteen thousand taken to
New Jersey?
A. The receipts are there.
Q. Is that what you said a moment ago?
A. About fifteen thousand packages.
Q. That would leave eleven thousand approximately?
A. We sent a few to the store, maybe a thousand or eight
hundred, I don’t know exactly unless I refer to the records.
Q. Take that eleven thousand that I spoke about.
A. Yes.
_ Q. When you separated them and divided them and re-
packed them,—you repacked them?
A. I repacked those on the ship, some, but some I believe
I shipped originally, I believe twelve hundred I shipped
originally.
Q. Without repacking at all?
A. Without repacking at all.
Q. Were they in good condition?
A. No, the party to sell them for my account at the best
possible price. They were not repacked.
Q. Did you tell the buyer that they were in bad condi-
tion?
F meesuaacee
A. Why, surely, I told them that they were to be sold
for my account.
Q. So, those that you did not repack at all, did you send
them to somebody to be sold for your account?
A. J. A. Blumgarten, Detroit, Michigan.
Q. That would leave approximately ten thousand odd
crates out of the eleven thousand lot?
A. Yes.
Q. Did you repack all of those ten thousand?
A. I repacked those with the exception of those I took
to the store. Those I did not repack,
Q. How many were there of those?
A. About a thousand. I can tell you by the records.
[fol.81] Q. So that that would leave about nine thousand
of the eleven thousand lot?
A. Around that.
Q. Did you repack all of the nine thousand?
A. Yes.
Q. After you had repacked them, they made three thou-
sand cases of bad onions, didn’t they, and left six thousand
cases of good onions?
A. About those figures, yes.
Q. In other words, the damage was about one-third of
that nine thousand lot?
A. Yes, about one-third, yes.
Examination of witness closed.
Mr. Joffe: Mr. Levy was very much perturbed about one
question he was asked, and I want to relieve him of some
worry.
Morris Levy, recalled.
Direct examination. |
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. Mr. Levy, tell the court, please, whether you called
me up this morning?
A. Yes, sir; I telephoned to your office this morning.
Q. Did you have a conversation with me?
A. Yes, sir.
-
60
Q. And you told me you had found certain records in
your office?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Have you produced those records?
A. I have them on my person.
Q. Will you let us have them?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What are those records?
A. It is a memorandum record that I keep, or that I use,
[fol. 82] when I go to piers to make examination of car-
goes, and from that I transcribe it into an official document.
Q. The book you hold now is kept particularly for this
particular cargo, or does it include other cargoes from
day to day?
A. It includes, I should say, about forty other examina-
tions.
Q. Will you please look as to the date of your examina-
tions of the ‘‘Vallescura’’ and tell us whether you have
anything there to show the number of packages that were
repacked on the pier, and the number of packages that were
shipped to the warehouse?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And tell us what they were.
A. I have a notation here with reference to this particu-
lar lot of onions.
Q. On what page of your book?
A. Page forty-seven.
Q. What does it say?
Mr. Loomis: Is this a book in the custody of the Custom-
house Department of the United States?
The Witness: No, sir; it is a Treasury Department book
that is given to us to use in making the reports, from which
they are transcribed into their books.
The Court: Is it taken from the files of the Custom House?
The Witness: It is taken from my file. I have it in my
locker in the Custom House.
Mr. Loomis: Where are the original memoranda from
which that book is made up? ,
[fol. 83] The Witness: I had it here yesterday and took
it back to the Custom House.
The Court: What you took back was the dock book.
The Witness: Yes, sir.
61
The Court: Yes,
The Witness: Yes, sir.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. I thought you just told counsel for the libellant in
your direct examination that the book was made up from
notes that you had made?
The Court: These are the notes,
A. This is a book we use on the pier, and the official
record is transcribed from that.
Mr. Loomis: That was made on the pier?
The Witness: Yes, sir. The only record from this book,
transcribed, is the record that refers to the result of the
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. What does it show? How many packages were re-
packed on the pier and how many were shipped to the ware-
house?
A. 1407 packages were repacked on the pier for customs
purposes.
[fol. 84] Q. How many were shipped to the warehouses,
if you know, from your record?.
A. 14,891 crates.
Cross-examination,
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. Did you count them yourself ?
A. I didn’t count them, no. |
Q. Somebody gave you those figures?
‘These records were obtained from the inspectors, or
the delivery officers, |
Q. Somebody gave you those figures?
A. Yes, those figures were given to me.
62
Mr. Loomis: I object to that testimony and ask that it
be stricken from the record.
The Court: It will stand subject to your objection.
JosrPH M. Gm, a witness called on behalf of the libellant,
being duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. Mr. Gil, where do you reside?
A. 1018 Summit Avenue, New York City.
Q. And you are a native of Spain?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What business are you in?
A. I am representing in this country a group of growers
and shippers of Spanish onions.
Q. How long have you been interested in the Spanish
onion business as importer of Spanish onions?
[fol. 85] A. Fourteen years in this country and four years
in Great Britain.
Q. And during all that time you were a representative of
the importers of Spanish onions?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And prior to going to Great Britain, were you inter-
ested in growing Spanish onions in Spain?
A. Well, I was born there, right as you would say, among
the onion fields.
Q. Were you in Spain during the year 1925?
A. I was.
Q. During what months?
A. I was in Spain since May till November.
Q. Did you know of the cargo of Spanish onions that
came on the S. S. Vallescura from Spain to New York?
A. Yes,
Q. Where did you see that cargo in the first instance?
Tell us about the date and the place where you saw it?
A. I saw part of that cargo in Granada and part in
Denia.
Q. Where?
A. The first time I saw the cargo was in the packing
house before the onions were being packed.
63
Q. In crates and half cases?
A. Before they were placed in crates. That was the first
time I saw the onions.
Q. Did you examine the onions?
A. I did.
Q. Please describe to the court the condition of the onions
you saw at that time.
The Court: What relation did he have to this business?
Q. What interest did you have in the seeing of the
TSnions?
A. As part of my business. I was in Spain visiting my
principals and it was my business to go to different packing
houses.
(fol. 86] Q. And it was your business to examine the car-
goes that were leaving Spain for New York?
A. Yes, sir. I made it my business.
The Court: To examine all the onions you saw in Spain?
The Witness: Not all.
The Court: What relation did you have to this shipment 4
The Witness: I had no relations whatsoever with this.
Mr. Joffe: He does not understand the word, ‘‘relation”’.
The Court: He seems to be a very intelligent man. He
said he had no relations with this cargo whatsoever.
Q. Do you sell onions to Mr. Schnell?
A. I do.
Q. And you sell them every year?
Yes, sir.
Q. What interest did you have in examining these onions
in Spain? Please tell us.
Mr. Loomis: I object.
The Court: He may answer.
A. Well, Mr. Mentone told me he had an order for Mr.
Schnell and while I was in the agent’s office of the steam-
ship company, Mr. Mentone said, ‘‘Would you like to come
to the packing house’? | said I wouldn’t mind, so know-
ing that these onions were Mr. Schnell’s, [ examined very
carefully the onions Mr. Mentone had in his packing house,
- How many onions do you sell a year to Mr. Schnell?
[fol.87] A. About three hundred thousand packages a
64
Q. Year in and year out?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Will you now tell us what you saw? Describe the con-
dition of the onions as you saw them in the packing house
in Denia.
The Court: Did you have any relations with Mr. Men-
tone?
The Witness: He was a friend of mine.
The Court: You had no interest in this shipment in a
business way?
The Witness: No, I was not financially interested in
them.
Q. Tell us what you saw.
A. The onions I saw there in the packing house were be-
ing selected, different sizes, fifties in one pile, seventy-twos
in another pile.
The Court: What are those?
The Witness: These crates come in three different sizes,
and the girls select them in different sizes, grade them, big-
ger onions to smaller and still smaller onions.
A. (Continued.) And while they were doing this selecting,
I looked at some of these onions, and they were very, very
sound and a bright kind of onion.
Q. Was it a healthy onion?
A. Very healthy.
Q. Had it any evidence of any disease?
A. Not from where these onions came from.
Q. Are you acquainted with the diseases of onions?
A. In some respects, yes.
[fol. 88] Q. Have you seen them on the fields before they
are gathered?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you see these onions before they were placed on
the steamer?
A. Yes.
Q. Where?
A. I saw them after being packed, I saw them in the pack-
ing house and then I saw them on the pier.
Q. Were the onions marked by a special mark?
A. Yes, they had ‘‘Mentone, Benjamin Bryan and Joseph
Dronin.’’
Q. Did you see the onions leave the field for the steamer?
A. I saw some in Granada.
Q. How were they delivered to the steamer?
A. Small carts.
Q. From the dock to the steamer?
A. Stevedores or longshoremen take one crate and put
it inside a lighter, one by one.
Q. They delivered to the steamer by lighters?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you could see the steamer from the port?
A. Yes, it is only two miles outside in the stream.
Q. What was the condition of the onions when you saw
them before they were placed on the lighters to go to the
steamer?
A. They were very good.
Q. Were they in the same condition as you saw them in
the packing house?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Except that they were crated?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The court asked you what you meant by assorting
them. Will you please explain in what designations and
quantities onions come in crates? What is meant by
seventy-twos, and what is meant by fifties?
[fol. 89] A. There are three different sizes of crates;
one crafe contains seventy-two onions, which is that crate
there, that is the medium size. Then comes a bigger size,
which contains fifty onions to the crate. And then comes a
bigger onion that contains thirty-two onions, which is a
very large onion.
When you say, bigger sized crates, you mean that
there were fewer onions to the crate, but that the crate is
about the same?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That is the difference? It is only the size of the onion
that differs?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The weight of the onions is about the same?
A. That is correct. 4
Q. When did you leave Spain?
A. The fifth of November.
Q. On what steamer?
A. I left from Cherbourg on the Berengaria.
5—134
66
Q. When did you arrive in the port of New York?
A. I believe it was the thirteenth or fourteenth of No-
vember.
Q. Did you go to the pier with Mr. Schnell, Pier 3, at
Stapleton, to see the cargo of the Vallescura?
A. I did.
Q. Did you see it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were you on the steamer?
A. No.
Q. Where did you see it?
A. I saw it on the pier.
Q. Will you please tell the court the condition of the
onions as you saw them on the pier, that came out of the
steamer Vallescura? I am referring now to the same
onions by the same marks, for Mr. Schnell?
A. Well, I couldn’t believe my own eyes when I saw those
onions?
The Court: Strike out the answer.
[fol. 90] Q. Please answer the question. Tell the court the
condition of the onions as you saw them on the pier, that
came out of the steamer Vallescura.
A. They were in a terrible condition.
Mr. Loomis: I object.
A. The condition of the onions I saw, they were heated
and as known to the trade, baked onions.
Q. Please describe exactly, in as simple language as you
can.
Mr. Loomis: May I ask to have the last answer stricken
out.
The Court: It may stand for what it is worth.
A. They were slimy and just like slimy, soft, the first and
second layers of skins were just like as though they had
been baked.
Q. Did you handle the onions?
A. I did.
Q. Did you open them?
A. I did.
Q. Were they hard in the heart of the onion, firm?
A. When I cut them, they were exactly as I saw them in
Spain, sound and healthy.
- @
Q. And on the outside, the first two layers of the onion
were slimy? ,
A. Yes, the tissues were all burned.
Q. You spoke of the onion being baked. Is that a trade
description of a certain type of onion?
Mr. Loomis: I object&
The Court: The description is all that I will pay atten-
tion to.
(fol. 91] Q. Mr. Gil, from your experience, and from be-
ing interested in the Spanish onion business for the last
eighteen or twenty years, can you tell whether the onions
which you saw in Denia and Granada in Spain were dis-
eased onions?
A. No.
Q. From your experience, were they in condition for
shipment to the Port of New York?
A. Yes, excellent condition.
Q. From your experience as a person interested in the
business for the last eighteen years, would you say on your
examination in the port of New York that the onions that
arrived on the S. S. Vallescura were diseased onions?
A. No, they were not diseased.
Q. Are you ina position to tell us what was the approxi-
mate cause of the damage to those onions, from your ex-
amination?
Mr. Loomis: I object.
Objection sustained.
Q. Can you tell us from your examinations, from your
examination of the onions, what was the cause of that con-
dition?
Mr. Loomis: Same objection.
Objection sustained.
The Court: I shall require you to state a hypothetical
question first, and then ask whether he can answer it with
reasonable certainty.
Q. Mr. Gil, will you please take into consideration your
examination of the onions in Denia and Valencia, the condi-
{fol. 92] tion in which they were packed as you saw them,
the examination of the onions in New York as they came
out of the steamer Vallescura; can you tell us with reason-
able certainty from your experience as a person dealing in
68
onions for the last eighteen years, as to the reasonable
cause of that condition of the onion when it arrived in the
Port of New York?
Mr. Loomis: I object to that.
Objection sustained.
The Court: Assuming that these onions were received on
board that steamer in the condition in which you saw them,
and were received in New York from the steamer in the
condition in which you saw them on the dock, can you, in
the light of your experience, state with reasonable certainty
whether the difference which you noted in their condition,
was due to any cause arising before they were put on board
the steamer. Can you answer that question with reason-
able certainty? Answer it, yes or no.
The Witness: In my opinion
The Court: No. Answer it, yes or no. Can you answer
it with reasonable certainty?
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: It is not a mere guess?
The Witness: No. I can answer that.
The Court: In other words, this question is put to you
for an answer upon which this court would be justified in
[fol. 93] relying upon a well-founded opinion. Can you
answer the question in that sense?
The Witness: Yes, I can.
Q. Mr. Gil, will you please take into consideration your
examination of the onions in Denia and Valencia, the con-
dition in which they were packed as you saw them, the ex-
amination of the onions in New York as they came out of
the steamer Vallescura; can you tell us with reasonable
certainty from your experience as a person dealing in
onions for the last eighteen years, as to the reasonable
cause of that condition of the onion when it arrived in the
Port of New York?
A. These onions were damaged——
The Court: No. I have not asked you to state how they
were damaged. I am asking you to state whether or not
they could have been damaged by any cause arising before
they were put on board the vessel.
The Witness: No.
Q. Can you tell us what, in vour opinion, was the cause
of the condition as you saw them in the Port of New York?
69
Mr. Loomis: I object.
Objection sustained. Exception.
Mr. Joffe: Unless your Honor does not want me to go
beyond this, I want to go a little further than your Honor’s
question.
The Court: I do not see how you can form the basis of
[fol. 94] any such question, because you are asking him to
exclude things that we do not know anything about. You
want to ask him to say what caused it. It may have been
caused by a hundred different things on board the ship.
Mr. Joffe: No, I do not ask him what happened on board
of the ship, but what caused it.
The Court: Exactly. He said it was caused by nothing
before it got on board the vessel. Now you want to go
further and ask him what caused it. He cannot say that.
Mr. Joffe: A doctor examining the limb of a person can
tell whether it was caused by a blow, or a cut, or some
foreign matter coming into contact. So these people con-
stantly dealing in onions can state the conditions.
The Court: You may limit your question, but the way
you are putting it is absurd. How can he say what caused
it?
Q. Can you tell us what caused that condition that you
found the onions to be in on examination of the cargo at
the Port of New York? Yes or no.
Mr. Loomis: I object.
Objection sustained.
Exception.
Cross-examination.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. Mr. Gil, did you make an examination at both of those
ports at which the onions were loaded, Denia and Granada?
A. I saw them being loaded in Granada.
[fol. 95] Q. Did you also see them being loaded in Denia?
A. No.
Q. How far out in the stream was the steamer anchored
when you saw the lighters proceeding towards her with the
onions?
A. A couple of miles. C
Q. Do you know anything about the effect had upon
onions by bacteria?
A. I do not.
70
Q. You are not an expert in connection with the effect
of bacteria upon onions?
A. My knowledge of onions is all practical. I never made
any studies in universities, as far as bacteria or any other
disease.
Q. Therefore, you know nothing about that?
A. I know something about the diseases.
Q. You know nothing about bacteria and their effect
upon onions?
A. I do not know the effect of bacteria.
Q. While you had no financial interest in these onions,
why was it, then, that you not only examined them over
there, but when you came back to New York, you made it
your business to go down to Staten Island and look at
them on the pier?
A. Because I told Mr. Schnell that his lot of onions on the
Vallescura were very——
Q. I don’t want that.
A. Why did go?
Q. I want to know why.
The Court: You opened a very wide gate with that,
‘‘why.’’ Why did you go down to the pier when you did
not have any interest in it?
A. When I arrived from Spain on the thirftenth or the
fourteenth of November, I informed Mr. Schnell that his
[fol. 96] lot of onions that went on the steamer on the Valle-
‘ scura were exceptionally fine, that he had a very fine cargo
of onions afloat.
Mr. Loomis: I ask that that b> stricken out.
The Court: You asked him why.
A. (Continued.) And when the steamer arrived, Mr.
Schnell said, ‘‘ You must have been blind on these onions.”’
I said, ‘‘They’re sound like bells.’’ ‘‘You come with me
down to the pier.’’ And we opened onions and I said,
‘‘There they are, healthy like a bell, sound.’’ These
onions had been damaged for lack of ventilation.
Mr. Loomis: I ask that that be stricken out.
A. That is my conversation with Mr. Schnell.
The Court: You may strike out everything after he said
he would go down to the pier.
71
The Court: And so you went to the pier?
The Witness: Yes,
‘ A. (Continued.) And Mr. Schnell,
Q. Mr. Schnell had already seen the onions prior to this
conversation he had had with you?
A. When?
Q. He said he had already seen thé onions on the pier?
A. He told me that the onions were no good, that they
~ were a damaged cargo.
Q. And he said that you must have been blind when you
(fol. 97] said that they were in good condition when they
left the other side?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. When did you actually get on board the Berengaria?
A. I left from Cherbourg on the seventh of November.
Q. Where had you been on the sixth of November?
A. I suppose I was travelling between Spain and France.
- Do you know where you were on the fifth of Novem-
ber?
A. Still in Spain.
Q. Where?
A. Barcelona.
Q. Where were you on the fourth?
A. In Granada.
Q. You left Granada on the 4th of November?
A. Yes, sir.
(Examination of witness closed. )
Georce A. CosTELLo, a witness called on behalf of the
— libellant, being duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Joffe: R
Q. You have produced certain records pursuant to a sub-
poena?
A. Yes, sir. |
Q. From what department?
A. Quarantine Control,~-the Plant Quarantine Control
and Administration, Departnient of Agriculture.
72
Q. Have you those records with yout
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The department acts under the Fruit and Vegetable
Quarantine, the United States Department of Agriculture?
A. Yes, sir.
[fol. 98] Q. And examinations made under the different
regulations are passed by that department?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were these goods permitted to.enter the port of New
York after examination?
Mr. Loomis: Perhaps he is not qualified.
Q. Please let us have the report.
A. Yes.
Q. Did you produce entry 813138, dated the 14th of De-
cember, 1928, permit 1102, Spain, importer H. Schnell &
Co., vessel Vallescura, date of arrival December 8, 1925,
Mr. Loomis: I object to this.
The Court: Strike that question all out.
The Court: Did you produce that, paper from your files?
The Witness: Yes, sir.
Mr. Joffe: I offer it in evidence as a report of the United
States Government, and I ask that it be read into the
record so that I can return it to the witness.
Mr. Loomis: I have no objection.
(Paper marked Libellant’s Exhibit 13 reads as follows) :
Entry No. 813138, 12/14/25, permit No. 1102, Spain, im-
porter H. Schnell & Co., vessel Vallescura, 3 S. I. Date of
arrival, December 8/25.
Quantity of onions 25533 crates.
Kind of onions marks 83% half cases.
Inspected and released December 15/25.
EK. Kostal, Inspector of Federal Horticultural Board.
[fol. 99] Condition, twenty to twenty-five per cent. decay
and sprouting.
Packing, wood cases.
Remarks. A poor cargo.
Q. Did you make an examination of this cargo?
A. I am not an inspector.
Q. You know nothing about it?
A. No, sir.
73
Mr. Joffe: I offer in evidence regulation six of the United
States Department of Agriculture Inspection, and its noti-
fication of importation of fruits and vegetables, I ask to
have it marked for identification and the convenience of
the court.
(Marked for identification Libellant’s Exhibit 14.)
Mr. Joffe: I also want to call the court’s attention in this
report to the word,—that where the word ‘‘fumigation’’,
or ‘‘fumigated’’ is, there is a blank, showing, I suppose,
that no fumigation was made.
Mr. Loomis: That is merely a supposition.
Q. Can you tell us if this cargo was fumigated, whether
any remarks would be placed right beyond the word, ‘‘fumi-
gated’’?
Mr. Loomis: I object to that. This witness does not know
that.
The Court: He could tell what the office practice was. He
may examine him as to the practice in the office, filling up
the cards or leaving them blank.
[fol. 100] Q. Do you know the practice in your office?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Have you examined a number of cards like the one
produced by you today?
es, sir.
Q. Is it the custom of your office to indicate whether the
goods were fumigated or not?
Mr. Loomis: I object to that on the ground that it is im-
material what the custom was.
The Court: The custom may be some evidence. I will
take it.
A. I might explain about the card. Those are used in
making up records for cotton waste that require fumiga-
tion, and that is why we have the word, ‘‘fumigated’’ on
there. It is for the cotton waste fumigation.
The Court: Do onions require fumigation?
The Witness: No, sir.
Q. If onions are diseased, the department refuses a per-
mit, doesn’t it?
74
Mr. Loomis: I object.
Mr. Joffe: It is a regulation of the department.
The Court: Does it apply specifically to the onions?
Mr. Joffe: Yes, sir; fruit and vegetables. Before you
could get a permit from a United States Custom House
Department, you must get a permit from them permitting
the entry. »
[fol. 101] The Court: You are saying, if a crate of onions
has one diseased onion it it, you disinfect it?
_Mr. Joffe: No. I will show your Honor the regulation.
The Court: I think you assume altogether too much. What
does, ‘‘infestation’’, mean? I suppose that means by some
carrier, as applied principally to plants.
~ Mr. Joffe: I offer in evidence the deposition of Mr. Men-
tone.
(Libellant’s case closed.)
Vincent J. Martinez, a witness called on behalf of the
claimant, being duly sworn, testified as follows:
Direct examination.
By Mr. Loomis:
Q. What is your business?
A. I am secretary-treasurer of the Mutual Lloyd Marine
Corporation, steamship agents and brokers.
Q. How long have you been connected with that corpora-
tion?
A. Since 1923.
Q. And you were with them in that capacity in 1925, No-
vember and December?
A. I was secretary in 1925.
Q. Describe briefly what your duties were at that time in
connection with that position?
A. At that time I was chief clerk at the pier and super-
[fol. 102] intendent of discharging and loading steamers.
Q. Did those duties require you to stay at the pier for a
considerable period of time? |
A. They did.
Q. Do you recall in that connection the steamer, Valle-
scura, and the trip she made to this port where she arrived,
75
I believe, on or about the fifth or seventh of December,
1925?
A. She arrived on December fifth.
Q. Do you remember that independently, or do you need
to refresh your recollection from the documents?
A. I remember it, but at the same time I must refresh it,
but I have a very good idea that it arrived on a Saturday
morning.
Q. Can you, by refreshing your recollection from your
book, tell which date Saturday morning was? What was
the date of the month?
A. Saturday, December 5, 1925.
Q. Where did she go immediately she came into the port?
A. She stopped at Quarantine, and they left Quarantine
around ten o’clock and she was berthed around eleven
o’clock on Saturday morning.
‘ ere was that berth at which she was tied up?
A. North side, Pier 3, Staten Island.
Q. Do you remember whether she was bow in or stern in?
A. She was bow in.
- How many sections were there to Pier 3, Staten
Island?
A. They called it three sections.
Q. Into which section did the steamer go when she im-
mediately came into her berth?
he came into the inner section.
Q. That is, the inshore section?
A. That is the in-shore section.
(fol. 103] Q. Was it one, two or three?
A. You might call it section number one.
Q. Did she discharge any of her cargo on Saturday, De-
cember the fifth?
- No, sir, she did not. We rigged up the steamer for
discharge.
Q. Rigged it?
Yes, sir, rigged it.
Q. Did that work, or did it not, consume the rest of Sat-
urday? -
A. Well, it went into about two p. m. in the afternoon.
Q. That was Saturday afternoon?
A. Yes, sir, that was Saturday afternoon.
When did the discharge of the steamer actually
begin?
76
A. The first thing Monday morning.
Q. At what time?
A. At eight o’clock.
Q. At eight o’clock? .
A. At eight o’clock, yes, sir.
Q. Were you present at the pier at that time?
A. I was.
Q. What was the first thing done prior to the commenc-
ing of the discharge?
A. Well, the steamer arrived with booms up and they
were just arranging around the deck there, tightening up
the booms, and seeing that everything was in working or-
der, so that no accident would happen during the discharge.
And skids were put up from the pier alongside of the
steamer and a ‘few net slings were put up number one
hatch and number two hatch, where the steamer was fur-
ther away from the-pier.
Q. That is, the middle of the steamer would be flush
against the side of the pier?
A. That is right.
Q. And both ends of the steamer would be a little dis-
tance off the side, since they shaped in?
A. Yes, sir.
[fol. 104] Q. When were the hatches of the steamer first
opened?
A. Number one and number two and number six hatch,
they had the covers on but they were not attached to the
square of the hatch.
Q. What do you mean by, covers?
A. The canvas covers, tarpaulins over the hatch.
Q. Pieces of wood? Wooden covers?
A. Wooden covers and tarpaulins.
Q. They were laid over the hatch coamings, but were not
fastened?
A. Not fastened, no sir.
Q. That was at what time Monday morning?
A. That was when the steamer arrived on Saturday
morning.
Q. When were her hatches first opened?
A. The hatches in fact, we might say, were opened, they
were opened when she arrived, but they were covered on
account of it was raining that day.
Q. You mean to say the wooden doors were taken off and
the tarpaulins opened?
77
A. At the forward part of the square of the hatch they
had the wooden doors off, about two or three boards, but
the canvas covering was over the opening.
Q. And when was the canvas cover and the boards all
removed first from the hatches before the discharge of
the cargo?
A. The canvas covers were removed on Saturday morn-
ing and on Monday morning we took off the rest of the
wooden covers off the hatch.
Q. Do you mean to say that the canvas covers were taken
off after the rain ceased?
A. Yes,
Q. And before the commencement of the discharge, when
were the wooden covers taken off ?
A. The first thing Monday morning.
Q. You mean at eight o’clock?
A. Eight o’clock.
[fol. 105] Q. Were you on the steamer when the hatches
were SO uncovered?
A. I was down about seven-thirty in the morning.
Q. Were you on the steamer when the hatches were
opeued in that fashion?
A. I was.
Q. And did you see them SO opened?
A. I did.
The Court: Were those wooden covers solid hatch
covers?
The Witness: Yes, sir, hatch covers right across,
Q. Were the wooden covers solid, all one big board?
A. No, sir, two sections.
Q. Describe the wooden pieces that made up the hatch
covers,
A. Well, they are about two and a half feet by six feet,
You are now describing a board?
A. Yes, sir, two anda half by six,
Q. And how thick?
A. About three inches thick. °
Q. And how many of those boards were there to each
hatch of the steamer?
Mr. Joffe: He answered that they were in two sections.
The Court: He may answer it again. I want to know
what he means by two sections.
78
Q. How many of such boards are there to each hatch of
the steamer?
A. How many?
Q. Yes. How many of such boards are there to each
hatch of the steamer?
[fol. 106] A. Well, they all vary according to the size of
the square of the hatch.
The Court: Is the hatch cover a solid board structure?
The Witness: No, sir, that is all in small sections. All
boards about six feet long by two and a half wide.
The Court: But solid planking?
The Witness: Yes, sir, solid planking.
Q. And there are a number of those boards?
A. Yes, there might have been twenty or twenty-five.
Q. For each hatch?
A. For each hatch.
Q. And when the hatch is covered preparatory to the
ship’s going to sea, those boards I suppose are closely tied
together? ,
A. They are all tight and staunch.
Q. And then they are battened down?
A. And then they are battened down, with iron pieces
running along the side. The iron pieces go in first, and
the wooden pieces go on top and the three tarpaulins are
battened down over that.
Q. You said that these hatch covers, consisting of
boards, the tarpaulins already having been removed, the
boards were taken off at eight o’clock Monday morning?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That was the seventh of December?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was there anything on top of the hatches than these
boards you have described?
A. No, sir.
The Court: When?
[fol. 107] Q. At what time are you speaking of?
A. When the steamer arrived.
Q. That is, Saturday, the fifth?
A. Saturday the fifth.
Q. Did you see her on that day?
A. I did see her that day.
Q. You were down at the pier that day?
A. I was down at the pier that day.
Q. Were you on her that day?
A. I was. 7 %
Q. Was there anything on top of the hatch doors on Mon-
day morning when you went there?
_A. No, sir.
Q. Did the steamer carry any deck cargo?
A. She did. .
Q. What was that cargo?
The Court: I thought you said that the hatches were open
when the vessel arrived.
The Witness: Number one, two and six hatch.
The Court: Were the hatch covers taken off of those?
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: I have another note that the wooden covers
remained there until Monday at eight o’clock.
The Witness: Yes, sir.
The Court: Then the hatches were not opened?
The Witness: Well, when the canvas is off a hatch we
consider that open.
The Court: Tell us exactly what was done from the time
you first saw this ship, with reference to these hatches.
You saw her on Saturday. What did they do with the
hatches on Saturday?
[fol. 108] A. On Saturday I saw one, two and six hatch
and the covers, the canvas covers, were partly on to the
square of the hatch and the forward part of the hatch had
two of the boards off the square of the hatch.
Mr. Loomis: So that there was an actual opening in the
hatch, so that you could look down into the hold?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That was one, two and six?
A. That was one, two and six.
Q. You said something about a rainfall?
A. It was raining the morning she arrived.
Q. Was it raining at the time these hatches were open
in the manner you describe, or did it commence to rain
afterwards? .
A. I don’t remember.
80
Q. Was it raining at any time while the hatches were
open in the manner you have described?
A. I don’t remember that.
The Court: You told me a moment ago that these hatch
covers were solid planking, and I inferred from that, that
you could not take out any individual boards.
The Witness: I think you misunderstood me. I said
they were not solid planking, they were solid in the sense
that each plank is a solid plank, but it is not solid all across,
not all across the square of the hatch.
The Court: The caver over these hatches was composed
of individual boards?
The Witness: Individual boards. I can show you a dia-
gram of them.
[fol. 109] The Court: It was an ordinary hatch cover with
individual planks?
The Witness: Yes, sir.
(2. Now, Mr. Martinez, you say that some of those boards
were off of the hatches on Saturday morning?
A. They were when I saw them, yes.
Q. And as I understand it, neither at that time nor on
Monday morning, when you went to the ship at eight
o’clock, was there anything loaded or stowed on top of the
hatches?
A. There was not. Not on one, two and six.
Q. Did the vessel carry any deck cargo?
A. She did.
Q. What was that composed of?
A. Crates of cork insulation.
Q. What is that?
A. Crates of cork insulation.
Q. By insulation, you mean cork that is used for the pur-
pose of separating or insulating?
A. For insulating refrigerators. I don’t know what
other use they may have for it, but it is manufactured cork
insulation.
Q. Will you describe how that was stowed on the
steamer’s deck?
A. That was stowed in the fore part, and the after part
of her number four hatch on the port side and the star-
board side of the deck.
Q. Of the number four hatch?
A. Of the number four hatch.
81
Q. Do you remember whether al] of the cork that the
steamer carried was carried on deck on that way?
A. No, sir.
Q. You don’t recall that?
A. No, it was not carried on deck.
Q. It was not carried on deck?
A. It was not carried on deck.
[fol.110] Q. Some of the cargo was stowed below the
deck ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was any of that cork cargo that was carried on deck,
stowed over any of the hatches?
A. Yes, it was.
Q. What hatch or hatches was it stowed over?
A. Over the number four hatch.
Q. Was that the only hatch it was stowed over?
A. I believe it was, yes, sir.
Q. Was there any of that cork cargo on deck that was
stowed over hatches one, two or six?
A. There was not.
Q. Now, after the steamer commenced discharging Mon-
day morning, what was the first cargo discharged from the
steamer?
A. A cargo of onions. |
Q. From what hatches was this cargo of onions ‘taken
out?
A. Of the number one, two and six.
Q. And where were they placed after being taken’ out
of these hatches, one two and six?
A. They were placed in section one, of pier three.
Q. And you have already said that that was the in-shore
section?
A. Yes.
Q. Do you recall about whén the discharge of the onions
was completed?
A. About Tuesday afternoon, five p. m. .
Q. Was any other cargo besides the onions discharged
from the steamer between eight o’clock on Monday morn-
ing and five o’clock on Tuesday afternoon?
A. We discharged some case goods and we discharged
& few bags of almonds and peanuts, I believe.
Q. Did they come out after the onions were discharged,
6—134
82
or before the onions were discharged, or contempora-
neously with the discharge of the onions?
[fol.111] A. They came out contemporaneously with the
discharge of the onions.
Q. And from what hatches did they come oft?
A. They came out of No. 2 hatch.
Q. Number two-hatch?
A. Number two hatch.
Q. Now, after the onions were discharged in the manner
you have stated, and I think you said some almonds and
peanuts, case goods; now, after those goods were dis-
charged, did there still remain cargo in or on the steamer?
A. Yes.
Q. Was that also/ discharged at that section of the pier?
A. No, sir; at five p. m. on Tuesday afternoon we pulled
the steamer back into the second section.
Q. You pulled her out, toward the out-shore end?
A. Yes, sir; section two and three.
Q. To sections two and three of the pier?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. How was the steamer pulled out from section one to
sections two and three?
A. With her own power.
Q. And then at about what hour was that? Tuesday
afternoon after five?
A. That was five o’clock in the afternoon.
Q. Was any discharging continued on that day from the
steamer?
A. No. They resumed discharging again on Wednesday
morning.
Q. What cargo was discharged on and after Wednesday
morning?
A. The balance of the cargo that remained in the steamer
was cork, and the balance of general cargo that was left
there.
Q. When was the deck cargo of cork discharged?
A. The deck cargo of cork was discharged after the
onions were discharged on the pier.
{fol.112] Q. Was the deck cargo discharged after the
steamer had been moved from section one to sections two
and three?
A. Yes, that is right.
83
Q. That is to say, no cargo, cork deck cargo, was dis-
charged while the steamer was in section number one?
A. No; the first thing they wanted discharged was the
onions, and that was the first thing to come out.
Q. Now, were you in the steamer’s hgld or hatches prior
to the commencing of her discharge on Monday morning,
or were you not?
A. I was down the three hatches where the onions were
stowed.
Q. That was one, two and six?
A. That was one, two and six.
Q. Will you kindly describe as nearly as you can recol-
lect, the character of the stowage that you saw in those
holds?
A. Well, it was stowed over the crates of cork insulation.
Q. What were stowed over the crates of cork insulation?
A. Crates of onions. And in number one they ran all
across the floor and about eight or nine high.
Q. Eight or nine cases high?
A. Eight or nine tiers high. And there was about the
height of a man, I would say six feet, head room between
the deck of the steamer and where the top tier of the onions
Was.
Q. In other words, by head, you mean,—correct me if I
am wrong,—the distance between the top of the top tier of
onion crates and the ceiling, the roof of the hold?
A. That space was vacant.
Q. About how many feet?
A. About six feet.
Q. Was that the same in holds one, two and six?
(fol. 113] A. In hold number two there was a little more.
There was about eight or ten feet.
Q. And was the six feet you refer to in number one?
A. The six feet I refer to was-in number one.
Q. And eight or ten in number two?
A. And eight or ten in number two.
Q. And in number six? 7
A. That was about the same as number one.
Q. About six feet?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was there in any of those three holds any cargo
stowed on top of the onions?
No, sir.
a4
The Court: How many tiers were there in number two?
The Witness: About the same height as in the ngmber
one; nine tiers.
Q. And in number six?
A. About the same as number one.
Q. Now, will you describe as nearly as you can the
method of stowage of the crates and the cases?
A. They were stowed head and head.
Q. And by that description, head and head, could you
say just what you mean, in other words?
A. One crate over the other on its head.
Q. We had a crate here a moment ago. Which of these
sides is the head?
A. The top, with the red label. _ Hither side you could
call a head.
Q. You mean, either the top or the bottom?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And how does the thickness of those two boards com-
pare with the thickness of the other strips that are around
the box?
A. The thickness of the head is practically twice as thick
as the other boards.
[fol.114] Q. Both heads are the thick boards?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And they are about twice as thick as the other strips
around?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And is it or is it not correct stowage so to stow crates
of onions?
Mr. Joffe: I object.
The Court: That is sustained. There is no claim of the
breakage of the crates, so that I do not see that it makes
any difference.
Mr. Loomis: So that, there being no question as to the
proper method of the actual stowage of the crates and
cases, I won’t go into that?
Mr. Joffe: I do not make any such concession as that.
We have here experts for that purpose.
The Court: All I meant was that I do not think that
there is any claim that it was improper to stow them head
to head.
Mr. Joffe: No, we are not claiming that head to head is
improper stowage.
85
Q. Mr. Martinez, then, just tell us how they were stowed
with respect to each other? You said they were stowed
head and head, but how were they bound together, or re-
lated together, in the ship?
A. One tier ran right across fore and aft, and then there
was another tier running across athwartship. That went
all the way across the floor. Then, the following tier on
top of that was the same way, only the tier that ran fore
and aft bound the tier which ran -thwartship.
Q. In taking the bottom tier, we will say,—take eight or
[fol. 115] ten crates. Just tel] us in your own words how
they would be stowed together? Would they be stowed
side by side, or how? And what Re a be used,
ad
if any? ;
A. The blocking would: be used by its own crate.
Q. How many crates would be stowed up side by side?
A. Well, if you tiered them on the pier, and stowed them
in the hold, that’s a different thing. If you take the whole
width of the steamer as far as cargo battens go, and then
the next tier would be stowed exactly over that only in a
different manner, that is, with the tier which ran fore and
aft, that would be blocking the tier that ran athwartship.
Q. Were there or were there not any air spaces left be-
tween the cases as they were stowed, and describe such if
there were any?
A. Well, in the number one there was air space around
the onions from the cargo battens. In number two and
number one also over the onions, that is, between the ceil-
ing and the top tier of the onions. In number two in the
forward part of the hatch they were stowed, and there was
an air space of two feet running all the way between the two
tiers, and number six was also stowed as rfumber one was.
Q. Have you seen many onion cargoes delivered int
this port? &
A. I have seen quite a few.
Q. How many such cargoes do you suppose you have
- seen in your capacity as steamship clerk delivered in New
York? y
A. Well, probably since 1912 I have seen forty, thirty
or forty cargoes. We had four in the year 1925, prior to
the Vallescura arriving.
Q. And was there anything unusual about this stowage
of these onions from what the other cargoes that you have
described were?
86
[fol. 116] Mr. Joffe: I object.
Objection sustained.
Q. Have you been in the same employ of this particular
respondenb all that time, all these years?
A. No, sir. Only since 1923 with that particular one,
but I was with other steamship lines prior to that.
Q. You were with other steamship lines prior to going
with them?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. They were the agents of the Vallescura, as I under-
stand it?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was it part of your duties to inspect the stowage of
the cargoes of onions and other cargoes by going down into
the ships and examining them when the ships arrived here?
A. It is part of it, yes, sir.
Q. And it is one of your duties to determine whether the
cargo is well stowed or not well stowed?
A. It is, for our own information.
Q. Who was the owner of the Vallescura?
A. The Lloyd Mediterranean.
Q. And your company was the agent of the Lloyd Medi-
terranean?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And did the Vallescura make other trips beside this
particular one to this port?
A. She did.
Q. Do you remember what she looked like, and in gen-
eral what kind of a ship she was?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. I suppose you were on her a number of times besides
this particular trip?
A. Yes.
Q. Did she or did she not have any bulwarks running
along the side, or rails, along the sides of the main deck?
A. Yes, sir, she did have.
[fol.117] Q. What were they made of? Plates?
<A. Steel plating.
Q. Were they solid bulwarks, running alone so that you
could see throvgh if you looked?
A. Yes, they were, and open at each side of the hatches.
Q. That is to say, they were capable of being opened?
A. Capable of being opened, yes, sir.
87
Q. Do you remember whether the steamer Vallescura on
this particular trip was laden to her plimsol marks when
she arrived?
A. No, sir.
Q. What was the ordinary deadweight tonnage of the
ship that she would take when laden to her plimsol marks?
A. Her deadweight tonnage is 7800 tons.
Q. How many tons did she have on, approximately, on
this trip, when she arrived?
A. About nineteen hundred.
Q. How did that effect her draft in the water?
A. It affected her draft a great deal. That steamer fully
loaded draws about twenty-five feet.
Q. And what did she draw on this particular occasion?
A. She would draw about twelve foot six or thirteen
feet.
Q. Was that a mean of twelve foot six or thirteen feet?
A. Mean, yes sir. She was about eleven feet forward,
thirteen foot six aft.
Q. That would make a mean of something like twelve
feet?
A. Yes.
The Court: What freeboard did she have when you saw
her?
The Witness: Six foot freeboard.
The Court: When you saw her at the docks?
[fol.118] The Witness: You mean, from the plimsol
mark, or from the waterline?
The Court: As she lay in the water.
The Witness: As she lay in the water, from her draft,
she had about thirty feet.
The Court: Thirty feet?
The Witness: Thirty feet.
The Court: How high is the pier from the water?
The Witness: At high tide it might be about three feet
high from the water.
The Court: And at low tide?-
The Witness: At low tide, I don’t know the kind of drop
there is there; it might be five feet or six feet.
Q. And in that connection, will you tell us how deep the
holds of the ship are in which these onions were?
A. In that steamer, about thirty feet deep.
88
Q. The cargo hold itself is about thirty feet deep?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Have you ever seen Mr. Schnell before?
A. Yes. |
Q. Do you know him?
A. I know who he is, yes, sir.
Q. Can you say whether or not he was at the pier on
Monday morning, the seventh of December, when the
steamer commenced to discharge onions?
A. When the steamer commenced discharging the onions,
Mr. Sam Schnell was on the pier.
Q. He was there at eight o’clock on that Monday morn-
ing?
A. I won’t say exactly eight o’clock. He was down there
some time that day.
[fol.119] Q. And was that the Mr. Schnell that testified
here?
A. No, sir.
Q. I suppose he is his brother?
A. I believe so.
Q. Do you see Mr. Samuel Schnell in court?
A. No, sir, he is not here.
Q. When did you first see Mr. Harry Schnell down at
the pier?
A. It was on a Monday there. He came down later on,
probably around noon time.
Q. Around noon time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you see Mr. Schnell, either one, at any time, com-
mence to open the crates of onions and take some out to
examine them, or their employees?
A. I did, yes.
Q. When was that?
A. When they started repacking.
Q. Had you, or had you not, seen them open any boxes
prior to their starting repacking?
A. Prior?
Q. Yes.
A. No, sir, they did not. Rien
Q. You had not seen them open any prior?
A. No, sir. (a
Q. When did the repacking commence? a
89
A. The repacking, I think it was around December four-
teenth or December twelfth. I have a memo of it. I can
look it up.
Q. Yes. Tell us when it was.
(Witness refers to book.) December 14.
Q. It was on December 14th?
A. December 14th.
Q. And you had not seen any crates opened by anybody
prior to that time? _
A. We opened some crates down—no, sir.
Q. You started to say, ‘We opened some crates.”? You
(fol. 120] thought you had some record of that, but you
have not, I take it?
A. No, sir.
Q. Did you see any of the onions after they were opened,
after you saw crates opened?
A. We examined the onions from the first day they
started to discharge. I mean, the superficial examination.
Q. Looking at the onions inside of the crates?
A. Looking at them from the outside without cutting or
any interior examination.
Q. Just describe in a general way what the condition was
as you saw it. Just describe it.
A. The crates were dry and the onion appeared ripe and
also dry.
Q. Was that all the observation you had to make of it?
. We made another observation on December eighth.
Crates dry. Onions appeared to be O. K., and we had the
cargo on the pier covered with tarpaulins and paper.
Q. Why did you cover them with tarpaulins and paper?
A. In case frost might set in and damage the cargo, and
it was also requested by Mr. Schnell.
Q. Did you notice any sprouting there?
A. Yes, we did notice some sprouting. We noticed some
sprouting when I examined them in the hold, and some
onions you could see had some black spots and bruises, and
also had a film of dry dirt. That I remember very plainly
because I particularly remarked about the film of dry dirt.
Q. Was that dirt? Were these spots black spots?
A. Yes. |
Q. And that was a sort of film of dirt?
A. Yes, it might be.
90
[fol. 121] Q. You don’t know what the dirt was?
A. I don’t know what the dirt was, no, sir.
Q. You noticed that both in the hold and when they were
on the pier?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Ihave a book here. Did that come from your records?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you have anything to do with the preparation of
that book? |
A. I did.
Q. It is the delivery book, is it not?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The book for the delivery of the cargo from the pier?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. What does it contain in general?
A. It contains a receipt of the cargo delivered to the
consignee.
Q. Delivery from the pier to the consignee?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you take receipts from the consignees when they
took their goods away from the pier?
A. I took receipts from the consignee for the complete
cargo.
Q. And how many cases and crates approximately were
there in the complete cargo?
A. 25433 crates 83214 cases.
Q. Will you tell us when the twenty-five thousand odd
crates and cases were delivered, lot by lot, and how they
were receipted for?
A. Delivery started on December 15th. We delivered
three truck loads and one lighter load.
Q. Was that all on that day?
A. That was all on that day, yes, sir. From the con-
signees or the order given by ‘the consignee by the party
taking delivery.
Q. Did they actually sign the book?
A. Yes, sir, they did.
[fol. 122] Q. Was it receipted for as a clean delivery or
not?
A. It was.
Mr. Joffe: I object to that as incompetent, irrelevant
and immaterial.
a
91
The Court: Objection sustained. The book speaks for
itself.
Mr. Joffe: I have no objection to the book being received
in evidence.
Q. Can you by refreshing your recollection from the book
tell us whether those lots were receipted for as a clean de-
livery?
Mr. Joffe: I object. The book is the best evidence.
Objection sustained. :
The Court: The consignees sign that book?
The Witness: The consignee signed on the book, yes, sir.
Q. Will you show me the page that has those three de-
liveries you spoke about to the fifteenth of December?
A. The pages are not numbered here; but this is it.
Q. Are all the entries and figures on the page that you
have indicated to me in the delivery book, in your hand
writing, or in somebody else’s handwriting? I am speak-
ing of everything but the signature.
A. They are all in my handwriting.
Q. Are the signatures here, the signatures of the people
that took delivery?
A. The respeetive people who took delivery of that mer-
chandise.
(fol. 123] Q. Are the entries there correct?
Yes, sir.
Mr. Loomis: I offer that particular page in evidence.
Mr. Joffe: I have no objection to the page and the sig-
of our employees, but I have objection to anything above
the page which has no part in the thing that they signed for.
Mr. Loomis: That is understood.
Mr. Joffe: You will see what hapyened on the line on
the top.
Mr. Loomis: Oh, we do insist on that. The argument has
been made here that all the lots taken away from the pier
were not good. rn
The Court: I will overrule the objection and receive it.
You may argue that point.
(Book at that page marked in evidence, Respondent’s Ex-
hibit A.)
Q. Now, will you take the same delivery book after that
page ‘‘A’’, and show us the next page that contains a record
of the delivery of some of these onions?
A. The next page shows a delivery of half cases of onions
which were delivered on December 15, 16, 17, 18, 19.
Q. How many lots?
A. Six.
Q. And the handwriting again on that page, other than
the signatures, is your handwriting?
A. With the exception of two lots which my assistant
entered here.
Q. Which are those two lots?
A. The second and the last entries.
[fol. 124] Q. Are you, or are you not, able to say whether
those entries are correct?
A. They are correct.
Q. You verified them at the time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And.the signatures there are the signatures of the
persons that took the delivery of those respective lots
opposite their names?
A. That is right.
Mr. Loomis: I offer that page in evidence.
(Page marked: Claimant’s Exhibit B.)
Q. And were those deliveries on that page by truck, or
by lighter, the page marked ‘‘ Exhibit B’’?
A. All by truck.
Q. Now, the next page; show us that as a record of de-
livery?
A. December 17, 9, 9, 21-22. *
Q. It that all shown on the page, or does it run over to
the following page?
A. It runs over to the following page.
Q. And is all that your handwriting on there, except for
the signatures?
A. With the exception of four entries.
Q. Were those made by your assistant?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Are the entries on that page, and the Exhibit B, the
page we have just marked in evidence, correct?
A. They are.
93
Q. Are the entries on the page immediately following,
that contains the left-over from the preceding page, correct?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And the signatures there are the signatures of the
persons that took delivery of the respective lots from the
pier?
A. They are.
(fol. 125] Mr. Loomis: I offer in evidence the page of
which we have been speaking, together with the page imme-
diately following, which contains the continuation.
(Pages marked: Claimant’s Exhibits C and D.)
Q. Now, are there any other pages in the book that con-
tain notations of deliveries made of lots of those onions?
A. No.
Q. And are the pages that you have indicated, the com-
plete record af such delivery of onions as was made from
your pier?
A. Right.
Q. That is, Exhibits A, B, C and D?
A. Yes, sir,
Cross-examination.
By Mr. Joffe:
Q. Would you have delivered one package of this cargo
to anyone other than the persons signing this book?
A. What persons?
Q. The person taking the cargo?
. No.
Q. If he wanted to sign for you a
would you have permitted him to tak
dock? An ordinary paper, ‘‘Received So-&-So’’? Answer
yes or no. Would you insist on him signing thi
book? Answer yes or no, please,
A. I can’t answer that. Receipts are taken in the deliv-
ery book.
Q. So no one can remove merghandise unless they sign
the delivery book? \
A. Absolutely.
Q. And if they don’t want to si
can’t have their merchandise? -
A. They must follow our system of delivery,
?
gn the delivery book, they
94
Q. If they do not sign your delivery book, they cannot
[fol. 126] have their merchandise?
A. If we have no delivery book, _ we have them sign
a delivery book?
Q. If they do not sign your delivery on which you give
them for their signature, they cannot have the merchan-
dise?
A. If we have no delivery book, we have a receipt, and
we have them sign a receipt.
Q. You had a delivery book in this case?
A. We did.
Q. And unless the person taking the merchandise off
your dock, wanted to take delivery, they could not get
it without signing your book?
A. That is the delivery book.
Q. And there was no other way, except by signing the
delivery book?
A. There is no other place in the port of New York that
they can get it.
Q. What was your occupation?
A. My occupation was chief clerk and superintendent of
the pier.
Q. Where was your office?
A. On the pier.
Q. What part of the pier?
A. The south side, on section one.
Q. You stayed in your office most of the time, didn’t you?
A. No.
Q. You walked around the pier during the discharge of
the steamer?
A. During the discharge of the steamer I walked around
the pier.
Q. And as your duty of delivery clerk, you have to ex-
amine the steamer before it began to discharge?
A. Not as the duty of delivery clerk, but as being an
officer of my corporation.
Q. Were you an officer of your corporation in 1925?
A. Yes.
[fol. 127] Q What was your office?
A. Secretary.
Q. And because you, were secretary, you esti all the
examinations you testified to? bs
A. I did. i beg your pardon. What is that question?
is 4
~
95
Q. Didn’t you hear it?
A. No.
Q. And because you were secretary, you made all the
examinations you testified to?
A. I made all tht examinations, yes.
Q. You had a plan, a cargo plan, of this steamer, didn’t
you?
. I don’t believe we had, no.
The steamer came into port without a cargo plan?
They do occasionally, yes, sir.
What did they do in this case?
. They had no plan. I didn ’t see any plan.
You did not?
No.
. That was rather unusual, for a steamer to come into
the port without a cargo plan showing where the cargo
was stowed?
A. No, that is not unusual,
Q. It is not?
A. No, sir.
Q. Do you remember examining hatches one, two and six?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you make that examination because you found
that in hatches one, two and six, were onions?
A. I did.
Q. You were not interested in the other hatches?
A. We were not.
Q. Will you tell us the dimension of your hatches one,
two and six? Were they the same?
A. No; one and six were about the same and two was
larger.
Q. Will you tell us the dimension of the cargo compart-
ments in one and six?
A. The cubic dimensions?
[fol.128] Q. About how large is one and six, if they were
about the same?
A. Are you talking of the dimensions of the hold or of
the hatch? -
A. The dimensions of the hold.
—You want an approximate figure?
Yes.
A.. Well, number one would be about forty-five feet wide,
at some points, and less than that at some other points of
OPOPOoPOpD
the
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.