Transcript of Record — PF Petersen Baking Co. v. Bryan
Supreme Court brief1934
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
|
|
\
4
‘SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED D STATES, :
eee _ OCTOBER TERM, 1933, |
‘No. 203
_P.-F. PETERSEN BAKING COMPANY, SCHULZE
. BAKING COMPANY, CONTINENTAL BAKING
COMPANY, ET AL. APPELLANTS, Pe o.
ae ye
eae os U8. Me
CHARLES W.. BRYAN, AS GOVERNOR OF THE -
STATE OF NEBRASKA, AND DWIGHT F. FEL-
.. TON, AS DEPUTY SECRET ARY OF THE DEPART-
- , . MENT OF 7 wienieen OF THE STATE OF
SS NEBRASKA g. 7
" ; , 2
iv APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF, THE BESTE nod
as ; NEBRASKA |
ou
. ——— | :
ee 7 So : ie Original Print
4 Peosbetiins in supreme court of Nebensin . ore rer Terre tT 1 1
| COPEOM. 00 .ccccccepecesecices amie (omitted: in printing) . i 1
Record from district court of Lancaster County............ 3 ee
| eee eee evunteenase (omitted in printing) .. 3
Temporary restraining order............cccccssecceess ise: EN 1
- _ Bond on restraining order...... (omitted in printing) .. S ..
a Notice of filing amended petition,.............. nesses 7 wa
' _° Amended. petition................ SamoweSSe ccc eesccees 8 3
we * Exhibit “a’ "nS Holl No. Sl......<.... enueda. 2 ae 24
yo Seer —-Exhibit “B” aww, nd regulations: governing en- — 3
forcement of standard bread loaf law............ 38 25
EE Ec Lauudbdsiubescatnsesduescdekewudies saceas ‘ 40 27
' Exhibit “A”—Rules and regulations with reference aan
ee to enforcement of act...... te ccccccssccce wounwes 422° @
| ae ok Ts 48° (9
WEED. cntivdiannpudenvadesssccecers eer eer 45 31
Jupp & DETWEILER (Inc. ),. Printers, ‘WASHINGTON, D. C., NovEMBER 8, 1933
wt
im, eae of
a
ACG AA LALOR ET OE
“s 2
vad
INDEX _
oe
Order overruling’ — for new trial..... eeevcccccces ; 60
Notice of appeal . "ity Wee WIG NIelaieeiste/e oeeeee orandeaeorus -62
Argument. and. submission LReewae ee ewne peed wnefoesevne nes ; 63s.
Judgment reer eee eee res Peer ere eT eee eee eee ee 65
Opinion, Goss, J.....c6.6.. ck ee er ee 7 ee ae 7 oa
Motion for reheaxing , a Se ee Sever ecceeesecnceees es Soe 1%
Order denying reliearing cree eee eeeeees Pe are Sete aed 88
Order. staying mandate...... ogfoccerveccccecccens Gerace wiureteretels ” 85
_ Petition for appeal, assignments: of error, and prayer for re-
versal... Cette er eeaeaeereeeees cekaewevomenns Se bane ~ 87
Order allow ins appeal chair eeakebe phiawe ianpekatawsia oe
Supersedeas bond appeal seseeeey -(omitted, in obidinis as
Citation and servic®. ..5 ccc ccc c cone anes in printing) -
‘Stipulation an th bill of exceptions...¢....ccccccecsessees o
Order settling bill of exceptions. ..:2...... bivGusuesrenaves
Priecipe for transcript of record... ........ cece ee eee bas een
Clerk’s certificates. . gy. ......-. .-. (omitted in printing)..
Bill of excepticus:. by 3 ae eer cccetccecccesccced Posse
- Appearancés ........ Cp etsanessnrosear Hegwiesgeget 6° 6
CCHCLON © 66 8:6 0.8, siaigadse's OC OC Rp eee
Stipulation as to certain faetsos. oo...) ec cece lee e eee tee
Offers «in OVIMORCE eee e ee eee eee eee ee cian ates 7
; Stipulation as to certain. evidence...... OOK Seek
Svidence presented by plaintiffs in case’ of Jay Burns *
Baking €o. et al. vs. Bryan et al............ andes
¥Testimony of Dr. Harry Snyder..... vrerey ae ceeee
Jay ae eg ale
‘Petes Ge — coece ceccetios
Charles W. Ortman...... oT Re
RE. BE ooo ees nececiccscccncs,
ogee Milton Petersen),......i/.....+. jases
\ ee ‘a - a Helfrich. (ks Ca patind sh qn eece's
Pee C. S. Jarnagin...\%/...... 6... ee. .
3. ’ yk ek i canes
Affidavit of P. O. L. Petersert and’J. T. Stewart....
Exhibits Pe, lll a lt "Tables showing results”
of experiments in bread baking ia ewknces eens
Summary of Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 6.......6...6.....
- Affidavit of George F; Wilberg...... ae yaa eae al
_Exhibit. “K-14"—Table- showing” Fesults of ex-
periments in bread Ee ee
Plaintiffs’ Exhibit 1—Meteorological summary.*....
Plaintiffs’ Exhjbit 4—Comparative table of formule -
Plaintiffs’ - a 1931-H—Statement of Louis W.
~ : £eknng ses ee nen cnnsseeeN ate dienneaceeens
. Evidende. presented by plaintiffs in case of Petersen
Baking Co. et al: vs. Weaver et-al..............0006
.
FEELIN RE
. ° .
mm . k Se nrc eh ee etic cock eit bia acitte
Ae TE Be SNR SER ye OY LER | oH * = Ree oh "
anemia xe
: Original |
Motion for new trinl....... ieuwmaane aco euabn es acecek 5G.
39 -
43
, ie ae ee 4 INDEX -— ce ee
ae “7 8: R x, ‘. Original Print
« a Testimony of Dr. Harry E.-Barnard./...........- 109 125 rg
Sai Ske , Fred) Hannegan......... seven bes ee) eee b> °
& : Louis Sommer.....,-eeeeees vue Se. a
ie 2 Albert: Wohlner.....+... Kochaeey Peper — or Se
Robert A: Laughlin........ Or an ae 14
P Oluf Vetersen..... ses eeccecees pore T28 AT
Bert Francis.... oose ees setnecneneens wr 138.
ey namie BP. F, Peternem.....scccccccees On ile, WT MB
ws Se ' < -Kdward B, Foster....... pt incitiea Te
: ddgar Schulze. —_ eerree ven Oe 53
_,,_ Harald D,- Fa Mir 3 ee eeeteeeretiee 16 155
Plaintiffs’ Exhibl-2—Table of evaporation tests. 168 160
Kvidertee presented by defendants in ¢use of Jay Burn ‘
Baking Co, et al. vs. Bryan et: ee nai neni ware ais 165. - 161
ee. Testimony of William: F. Cléett... Ee APOE 165 161
—_ ee. - Defendants’ Exhibits 16 and 17-Advertixements.... | 174 166
| ' Evidence presented by fefendants in case of Petersen ‘| |
; Baking Co, et al. vs. Wenven Oe A sameness sieners « 167 .
Lae a eS Testimony of John W. Hines..... ks Ota: =
, ©. D. Whee: «60. .0005. eC 182
‘Henry L.“Epner.......+++- pene eee Zi 196 a
‘Samuel W. “Bafley......0...0.. Snag . 225 | 198 2
’ L. J. OSS ES _ 229 201
ale B,C fo cores cc ccc csee. BA - 204.
se, Motos wanes sijiwereves weveree vee | 285 205
Re ee Elwin S. Marthir,...,..2.¢.00.. eee , 239 . 207
7 ‘Millard’ V Robbins bien oe —. ee. Ss
7.2 2 weer aaharen attlenstecs” a>," ae
Henry W. Wehr.. we edjenes Peer . 243 ° 210.
oan . Lorenzo D. Pickard...:..:./...0.... 245. ‘211
“ih . Ernest V.. Gibson... . 0.02.0 eeeeee 249. .--214
; : Paes a Charles P. Ehlers......:...... picnawe 232 8 216
it oe, ; sn George A.. Dant.....ccrcvseee Seperse 6257 219
. ee 7 Charles 5. Cramer....... 2.000 anus: ee 226
om, _-Paul J. Brickley.....-.ssnceseoees .. 279 232.
RE Se Ec kc cwccvescoscvesed 1. 281 . Tee
_ Joseph Poehiman............0..2.20. "284 236
Frank Kylimann...... ROTO: =
ne ie Ivy L. Miller..:.......... sslecids ace 6288 237
‘° ie See es Qt0o DB. TMW...ccvcccccccccccccccecs
ies Frank Treutman...,......... Scanian
nn onan scnncdepacccseen
Mts KE. L. -Uffelmann........ er San ieee
\ Jhmes M. Tracy...... eisnedinaicasd aainiaeas
George Meineys.............+++-- maa
Exhibts 30 to 33-——Tables of evaporation tests.::...
- ‘xhibit 34—Temperature .and humidity record .. ¥an
. Exhibit -35—Table of weight tests..../.............
Exhibits 37 te 39—Tables of a ienatee tests.%....
aa , t
.
eT ys en. ee eee 4
‘ae Te | ei .
em, wt Original
axinibit 40-n—Aftidayit ef Hl, W. Wehr. ‘i ie inane 827.
Ixhibit 40-b—affidavit of H.W. Wehr,.pe eet. 82007
Ixhibit 40-c—Table of welght-tests..... be eeee neces ., 382
Summary of Exhibits 36 and 1 to 60, inic ‘lusive. . 333°. -
Exhibit 1931-I—Excerpts from Miscellaneous Publi-
cations; Bureau of Standards........... ceseeume 335
Stipulation ‘for taking depositions, ..... cncoecccsvececs San
Testimony of Milton Vetérsen...... weccsescccsenses S46
. ‘Ralph R. Smith...... pinkie Satan ; 372.
; > R. A Laughlin...... gensdeecacessees 377
George ‘J. Mascott..... ehanadaa oo ° 384
"UP. Bi: Petersen... ..ccccccccweccsvccce | S00
.'° 3B. Sherman Whitney. (ents Pevekcesg: nO
me Joe Carr. .....45. seesecteereceecesees 892
‘Carl beer... ‘ican ror ree on:
dxhibit 1931- -A—Statement re production and sales..... 397
Ixhibit. 1931-b—Evaparation tests.........cee. cece eens " 398
Exhibit ° 1931-c—Computition of moisture and solids hee
ME davcaccsteedie tune ccih bu du cudar tenure as 401
oxhibits 1931-d to 1931-g—Meteorological summaries, os
May to August, |) ne Séevepenesesscote coos. 42
Order setting bill of exceptions iveeee easeeees soecccccosce * MM
. Clerk's certificate... . eo seepedecccecs (omitted in. printing) -- 408
Reporter’ WW SUID 4. 0.6 occ evevecees (omitted in printing)... ‘408
Statement of points te be relied upon artd designation as to
Printing FECOPY....ccsccces ee ewcccees Peover ecccccasoeccs 409
° . t
. ¢ :
. wv
. . 7
og
Ss
—
Print -
316°"
[fols. 0 &1&2] *. [Captions omitted] a ee a
-[fol. 3] | (Original petition omitted.) \, és a
Sanne ? ae
?
IN DISTRICT COURT. OF LANCASTER COUNTY, —
“STATE OF NEBRASKA “
_ 2. F. Perersgn Baxino Company, Senutze Bakine Com-
PANY, Continental Baking Company,: General Baking.
Company, Quaker Baking.Company, Corporations, for
Themselves and Others Similarly Situated, Plaintiffs,
oe ae a ne: .
panes +. . Tk
Onan.es W. Bryan, ‘as Governor of the State of Nebraska,
and Dwight F. Felton, as Deputy. Secretary,of the’ De-
partment .of Agriculture’ of the” State’ of Nebraska,
_+ Defendants
'” lion, duly verified, and the application therein for an -in-
' House Roll-51, and.of the rules
Junction to restrain-the enforcement of the provisions of
the Act of the Legislature of Nebraska for 1931, known as
- [fol. 4] Secretary’ of Agriculture théreunder. ian
_Now’ therefore, the hearing for a temporary injunction is
; set in the District Court room of Lancaster County at the
Court House in Lincoln, Lancaster County, Nebraska, on
This cause coming on to be heard ‘Apon plaintiff ’s peti--
Temporary Restrat®inc Orver—Filed July 22, 1 o
promulgated by the Deputy
Be the 21st day of September,'1931, at'10:00 A. M., or as soon .
thereafter as council can be’ heard, and of which hearing.
the notice ‘required by law shall be given to the deféndants
2
and each of them, and to. the Attorney General, and ‘the -
court being of the opinion that great and irrepar Je injury
will be suffered by the plaintiffs in that they will‘be’subject _.
to arrest and fine and their property will be taken for. vio-
lation. of the provisions of said act and the rules above
referred to, all of ‘which it is — by plaintiffs are un-
constitutional.and void, thereforé a temporary restraining
‘. order is hereby granted to the plaintiffs, restraining the de-
fendants and each of them, their agents and employees and
208 Bae,
1
; [fol. 7] In District Cgurt or Lancaster County
; ‘To Honorable ©. A. Sorensen, Attorney- General, attorney
. filed in the office of the Clerk of this Court, Lincoln, Lan-
caster County, Nebraska, an amended petition, a copy of
_ which- amended petition is herewith delivered to you.
| [fol. 8] | Due-service of the within notice of filing amended . .
> ’ [File endofsement omitted.]. .
[fols. 5 & 6] Bond on ‘restraining order for $1,000.00, ap-
“proved and filed July 22, 1931, omitted in printing.
e oan o. a a
: hereby acknowledged at Omaha, Douglas County, Nebraska, .
this 5th day of September, 1931.° =| : 3
all persons claiming to act under their authority, direction
or control, from in any way enforcing the provisions of the
said House Roll 51 or the rules promulgated thereunder,
_this order to be in effect only upon the giving of bond by —
plaintiffs in the sum of $1,000.00, condition as required by
_law, and this order to remain in force until the hearing and’
determination of the application for a temporary injunction
upon notice as aforesaid. : a 2D Senge
Dated this 23rd day of July, 1931, at Lincoln, Nebraska, .
eg .- Fred Shepherd, Judge of District Court.
[ File endorsement omitted.].
," ~
. ¢
_— °
en , e . : % ‘
es ;
: . [Title omitted] _ |
’ NOTicr OF Fnjne AMENDED Perition—Filed Stpt. d, 1931.
for defendants herein: ‘ ane
You are hereby notified that the plaintiffs herein have -
* John. ©: Grover, Harold D. LeMar, Attorneys for
~ Plaintiffs. 7 : | |
s
’
petition, together with a copy of said amended petition, is
’ C. A. Sorenson, Attorney General, Attorney for De-
fendants, by R. R. Strehlow, Assistant. Attorney |
General. Sai
.
oe ; : ; : ‘ ; r) ‘5
“ , > In Disraicr Court or LaNCasTER County
Mi — + [Title omitted}
* AMENDED Perrtt0n—Filed Sept. 5, 1931
«
Plaintiffs, and each of them, for. cause of enti against
the enna) and each of me, state: fae
i" cep .
‘ . «i = a
That. the: ‘plaintiff, 1 P. F. Petersen Baking Company, is a
corporation, organized under.the laws of the State of Ne-
_ [fol.9] braska and is-a citizen and resident thereof, main- |
taining offices at Omaha in Said state; that plaintiff Schulze ;
Baking Company of Omaha, ebraska, is a corporation |
organized under the laws of the State of Illinois and that
it is a citizen and resident of said state; that the plaintiff
Continental Baking Company, Omaha, Nebraska, is a cor- °
poraticn organized under the laws of. Delaware and is a
citizen and resident of said state; that thé.General Baking
. Company> Omaha, Nebraska, is a corporation organized ;
‘ under the laws of the State of New York, and is a citizen
and resident thereof ; that the plaintiff Quaker Baking Com-
pany, Council Bluffs, Iowa, is a corporation organized
_ under the laws of the State of Maine and is a citizen and :
resident thereof; that-each of the foregoing named cor-
porations are engaged, at th locations Stated, in the whole-
sale baking and distribution of bread in the State of Ne-
braska, with the exception of the Quaker Baking Company,
which is engaged in wholesale baking of bread i in Council.
Bluffs, Towa, and the cee of a part thereof in the
State of: Nebraska.
2
“That this action is brought for the purpose of having
declared invalid and unconstitutional the law known as
'” House Roll 51, passed by the Legislature of Nebraska in
1931, and being an amendment to Sections 89-142, 89-143,
89-144 and 89-145, Compiled Statutes of Nebraska, 1929,
known as the Nebraska Bread Law, which fixes. standard
- weights, and which unless enjoined will become effective
August 2nd, 1931, and Which the defendant, Charles W.
| Bryan threatens to make speretive July 22nd, 1931; that
Si ahintateatanenioaiacinah babiineobenmeme nna!
tonne
bs i . . .
eon b
: : : * .
— x ly
:
* . -
2 " .- e . .
there are many a of — and dealers therein through-
; out the State of Nebraska in addition to plaintiffs, who
are affected: by.the Nebraska Bread Law, and. whose ‘per-
sonal liberty will — wrongfully and unlawfully invaded and .
_ whose property will be taken without due process. of law,
and who will be denied the equa®protection of the law by:
[fol. 10] the enforcement of such Nebraska Bread Law;
that the question- involved are those common and of gen-
eral interest throughout the State, not only to all the bread
- bakers and bread ta but to all the bread consumers in
such state, as the quality: of the bread will be effected by
the enforcement of the law; that all suéh so effected by and -
interested i in the.law. are so numerous,that it is impractical
to bring them all before the court and therefore plaintiffs
Spring this action for themselves and each of them, and also.
for all others similarly ‘situated...
: $s
That the defendant Charles W. Bryan is the duly elected,
qualified and acting Governor of the State of Nebraska and
by virtue of his office is charged with the duty of executing
and administering the laws of the State of Nebraska and
of supervising and directing the work of the Department
of Agriculture, and is aided therein: under the law by the
defendant, Dwight F. Felton, who is the duly appointed, —
. qualified and acting Deputy Secretary of-the Department
eof Agriculture of the State of Nebraska, there being no
secretary, appointed ; that ‘the said defendants, pursuant to
the duties of their respective offices, will unless-enjoined by
' the court, enforce the «provisions of the Nebraska Bread
| Law, and because of the inability of plaintiffs to comply
‘with such law,.said defendants will thus subject plaintiffs Se
to arrest and will impose on plaintiffs and others similarly °
situated restrictions which_are unreasonable and arbitrary
. and in violation of the 14th Amendment ‘to the United sg
States Constitution, and Section III of Article 1, and Sec-
tion 25 of Article I and Section I Article II], Constitution
of Nebraska, with consequent loss to plaintiffs and others
similarly situated, of their liberty and property in viola-—
- [fol. 11] tion. of their: rights, and further violates the 6th
Amendment to the United States Constitution, and Article |
I Section XI, dnd Article II Section I of the Constitution
of Nebr aska, as hereinafter related. .
4 ‘
. That the plaintiff, P. F. Petersen Baking Company, has —
a paid: up capital stock: of $200,000.00, that it commenced:
business in”1891, and sells\its products in the State of
Nebraska and other states” surrounding, that,\its present -
output of. bread exceeds ten ion loaves annually with
a value of about $1,000,000.00$ that the plaintiff Schulze
Baking Company has a paid up capital stock in excess of
$1,000,000.00, commenceed business in 1906, and that its pres-
ent output of, bread is over seven million, with a ¥alue of
about $500,000; that the Continental Baking Company has
a paid up capital stock of more than $1,000,000.00 and with
its predecessors in their branch at Omaha has been doing
business since 1913. That the annual output of such Qmaha
plant is: about 10,000,000 loaves of bread with a value of
about $1,000,000.00; that the plaintiff General Baking Com-
pany has a paid up capital stoek in excess of $1,000,000.00, -
and with its predecessors in the branch at Omaha has bee
doing business since about 1925, has an annual ‘output of -
about 3,000,000 loaves, with a value of about -$250,000.00;
that the plaintiff Quaker Baking Company las a paid up
capital stock of $134,000.00 and with its predecessor has.
been doing business since 1905, that its annual output is
about 3,000,000 loaves of bread, with a value of about $250,- _
000.00, and that the other plaintiffs are doing business on
a commensurately large seale, and that the principle busi- °
ness of all the plaintiff bakers.is that of baking bread; that
all such plaintiff bakers have sufficient equipment and plant
for the supply of the present orders of patrons and for the
baking and selling respectively of tlie requisite quality and
- size of loaves of bread demanded by. the. consuming public, .
and in which various business- the said plaintiffs have ;
[fol. 12] built up a profitable trade, but which trade will be .
largely lost if the. maximum provisions. of the Nebraska
.Bread Law be enforced and such business- will thereby be
irreparably injured and damaged in‘more than: $50,000.00.
5 de
_ That the Legislature of Nebraska in 1921 enacted a stand-
ard weight bread.law, which is found in Sections :7612 to
7615 Compiled Statutes of Nebraska for 1922, wherein
Standard weights for loaves of bread to apply during
' twenty-four hours after baking were fixed with’a tolerance
6
of two. ounces per pound over such shi ard weight, and
that the United States Supreme Court held’ in. 264 U. Ss.
004 that such excess tolerance-provision of two ourices to
the pound loaf of bread subjected the bakers and sellers of
-. “bread: to restrictions which are unreasonable and arbitrary
. , and are repugnent to the 14th Amendment to the United
. States Constitution; that thereupon the Legislature of Ne-
braska 1927 amended sections 7612 and 7614 of the said
Compiled Statutes of Nebraska for 1922 by passing an
amendment which provided for three and one-half ounces
‘excess tolerange to the pound of bread, and which also pro-
vided for one ounce under the specified weights to the
.- pound on individual loaves, which.amendment was duly
approved by the Governor, and that the United States Dis-
trict Court for the District of Nebraska, Lincoln Division,
in a case in which the P. F. Petersen Baking Company,
et-al., was plaintiff and Arthur Weaver, Governor, et al.,
was defendant, being designated number 261, Equity, held
the said Amendment to be arbitrary and unreasonable and .
invalid: under the provisions of. the 14th Amehdment ” the
Constitution of the United States.
6
That thdreupon in 1931 the Legislature of Nebraska.
amended said a gw by passing House Roll Number 51,
a copy of whiéh is hereto attached, marked exhibit ‘‘A’’,
and by referen ade a part hereof, and which said amend-
[fol. 13] ment: pretides that every loaf of bread made for
. sale in the State $f Nebraska shall be of the following
weights avoirdupois one-half pound, one pound, one and —
one-half pounds, and also in eXact multiples of one pound
and of no other weights, and providing that, none of the
_provisions of the said act shall apply to fancy bread and
further provides that the Secretary of Agriculture shall .
be empowered to prescribe reasonable-tolerances, or varia-.
tions in excess, but not under the weights mentioned ‘within
which all loaves shall be baked and also the time for which
-said weight shall be maintained, and further provides that
violation ‘thereof shall be punished by a fine of not less
than. $10.00 and not more than $100.00. That under and
by virtue of the said House Roll 51, duly passed by the —
Nebraska Legislature and approved by. the Governor on
_ the 21st day of April, 1931, the atti a of Ag-
%
7
‘riculture has adopted a approved rules and regulations
for the observance of the plaintiffs and all others similarly
situated, a copy of which rules and regulations a a
attached, _marked exhibit ‘‘B’’, and by reference made
part thereof, and which said regulations among other things
‘provide that the exgess tolerances permitted shall be ene —
ounce per one half pound, two ounces per pound, and 10%
upon all larger loaves of bread shall be allowed in excess
of the minimum weights, which said tolerances shall apply
for a period of twelve hours after baking. That unless
- restrained by suitable order of this’ court the said Honse-
Roll 51 will become effective on or about the 2nd day of
August, 1931, and the Department of Agriculture will at-
tempt to enforce- provisions of the said rules and regula-
tions adopted by the Deputy Secretery of “Agriculture in
:,an attempt to define and enforce the s: 4a House Roll 51.
o
7
“That for many years the — popular loaf ‘with the con-
suming public in the State of Nebraska and in the surround-
ing states have been loaves retailing at 8¢, or two loaves
for 15¢, 10¢ per loaf, and 13¢ pér loaf or two loaves for
_ [fol. 14] 25¢; that the weights thereof and of all other
leaves made by the bakers have for years fluctuated in ac-
- cordance with the market price of the ingredients contained _
in such loaves, that is, when the price-of-in ients. ad-—
-,. vaneed the weights of the loaves have been correspondingly
decreased and when the price: of ingredients was lowered .
the weights of the loaves have been correspondingly: in-
creased, the quality of such loaves remaining the same at
all time-; that the minimum weight of such loaves sold to ©
the consuming publie is printed upon the wrapper | of all .
wrapped bread so that the purchaser of the loaf is advised
of the weight of aad loaf ‘which he. is a and pay-
ing for...
‘ g
That no dissatisfaction has ever been expressed by the
> bread buying public in the State of Nebraska with the ar-
rangement and plan indicated, the public demand being
almost wholly for.a high quality of bread rather than for
any given weight or size of loaf, and that the demand of
the standard’ and high aeaid of bread a been ——
e.2
aa
m
ee ea |
by the bakers: under the arrangement and plan aforesaid
of making the weight and size of the loaf correspond with |
the fluctuation of thd price of the ingredients used in mak-
_ing such bread; and that there has never been and is not
now any demand by the bread consuming public for a fixed
weight of loaf of bread or for any particularly: or stated
size in ‘preference to the quality of the loaf, which is the
principal.consgideration. | ?
That there is no standard quality of bread under any ex- .
-isting law, nor will there be under the provisions and terms
of the amended bread law, as it is not possible from the
nature of bread to standardize its quality; that poor bread.
- 1s composed of few or many ingredients according to the |
judgment of the individual baker and the demands of his’
consumers, that some of such ingredients are flour, water, #
[fol. 15] salt, yeast, sugar, malt, shortening; milk and all. - :
of which tho- pure vary in their richness or strength with
» . @ consequent wide variation in the richness or quality ‘of
» bread baked. therefrom, though all of such: various quali-
y ties of ingredients and resulting bread are ppre and whole-
3p +=. Some and in accordance with the requirements of the Pure.
§-—. Food Law. *. That the use of various ingredients containing
_-——s- Varying quantities of richness and food value, effects ma-
terially the alteration or variation in weights. of loaves of
. epread; that among the things contributing to produce un-
.» avoidable and uncontrollable variation in the ‘weights of
;-§. loaves of bread during the after baking are (a) the water
“content of the wheat, the flour,. dough and the bread, which
‘water content varies and is beyond the control of the baker ;
. (b)-the gluten content of the flour in which a rich gluten
_ content requires a greater proportion of water than does -
/ a lesser quantity of gluten, resulting in greater consequent
‘ / evaporation of. moisture in the better gluten quality in a
/ given period; (c) exact weights and measurements of dough
before entering the. oven cannot be attained under known
/-- _ , existing processes, and during the process of mixing, divid-
| _ ing, rounding; and and baking, certain uncontrol-able losses
occur; (d) losses in weight while the dough is -being fixed,
during fermentation, during preparation, while the bread
* . is in the oven, after baking and before wrapping, after
+ wrapping and before sale, which losses vary and cannot.
be avoided or controlled. _
=
LOUD IEAL L TEL MLO IEE LIS OLE LIL VIELE IE ALI ET Me
. = ° .
10 , ; leg ~~ : ”
‘That the flour used in alii bread requires ‘the addi. ae
tion: of from 54 to 65 percent of its weight in moistyre in
order that it may be made into dough suitable for baking, . .
the amount added te the said flour being based upon the -
_ quality of the flour and the. condition of storage thereof. . ver
That during the baking process this moisture content _ Si eed
reduced by evaporation to from 25 to 38 percent which ~
‘evaporation depends largely upon the quality of, the: in-:
gredients used, the temperature and humidity of the bakery
ané of the oven, the temperature. and humidity of the at-
{fol. 16] mosphere after baking wherein the bread may be —~_
kept, and other uncontrollable elements; that owineto the .
fermentation which takes Se after it is
mixed and, before it is inse in the oven it is necessary
in order to. obfain the, best results, to place such dough in
the ovens at a given stage of the fermentation, which must
be done regardless of the temperature of the oven at such
time; that ‘thé particular stage of fermentation above re-_ .
ferred to is variable in time depending upon the charaeter ©
" ‘and quality of the ingredients used and the prevailing con-
ditions’ of temperature and humidity at the time. That
it is fot possible to maintain. a uniform heat in all parts-
of the ownes and in all ovens during the time that the
_loaves of bread are being inserted ther ein and during the
: baking process, with? a’ consequent variation in moisture
content ‘of the dough and of the bread. That this evapora-
_ tion, which. vafiations depending upon’ “heat, humidity and
other uncontrollable elements, continues so long as mois-
ture remains in, the loaf, or until | equalized with the sur-
rounding air. ; _ @ | a
; 11 . eis:
That'the modern bakery uses one or more of two general
types ofovens, one of which is described as a traveling
oven, and the other type of which is. known as the peel
oven. That in general the traveling ovdh is best described
as a traveling tunnel from eight to twelve feet ‘in width and
.from thirty-five to one hundred. and twenty feet in length,’
- in which the loaves of dough are inserted at one end of the
-oven, traveling slowly throughout the length of the oven e
and being’ discharged at the other end thereof as baked - -
loaves; that during the said traveling process . the said
»
a
loaves pass .thru several baking . compartments in which -
‘they are, subjected to varying degrees of temperature and °
humidity, which are. not readily controllable, but which the
baker attempts to off-set by varying the speed of travel of
| (fol. 17] the loaves of bread; that under present conditions;
it is not possible to so accurately control the heat, humidity
and speed of travel of the said loaves of bread that all will
be subjected to the same amount of evaporation and that
- as a consequence various loaves: being submitted to vary-
ing degrees to heat, humidity. and speed of travel, result
in baked loaves of -varying weights depending ‘upon such
varying evaporation. That ‘the other type of oven known
as the peel oven is one having a capacity of a large number
__of loaves at one time in which there is‘one opening in the
oven thru which the dough.is inserted and thru which same
opening the baked loaves’ of bread are withdrawn, this
‘process being termed loading and unloading the oven; that -
only four to six loaves either of dough or bread ean be
‘handled at one operation, those first loaded into the oven
being shoved to the rear thereof and the last being inserted -
are ‘placed - in: the front; of the oven, and which loading
process requires from/ three to ten minutes, depending
upon the amount of Joaves to be loaded, the speed of the
_. operator and the conditions | under which operated; that
Py
after baking, the loaves’ in the front oven are unloaded -’ . °
first, the unloading. process taking place from the forward
end of oven to the rear; with the resalt that the loaves first.
loaded into the oven are the » last’loaves to be ‘unloaded, this
unloading process also requiring from.three to ten minutes,
with the result that the loaves-in the.rear of the oven are -
subjected to‘the intense heat of .the oven running in the
-. neighborliood of 400° Fahrenheit, for a period of time
‘varying from six to twenty minutes longer than the loaves
in the front of the oven, resulting in greater evaporation
in the ldaves in the back of the oven than those in the front,
with consequent variation in weight of the loaves at the.
end of the baking process even though the said loaves were - ° |
all the same weight when inserted in ' the oven.
“That in the process of: the. manufaeture ‘of bread inclarge -
. bakeries such -as those of the -plaintiffs, the scaling or
Ffol. ie — of thé dough is done by a machine known
PANY ALANS ONS OREN ITE EOL EN LTS OST IRE LEN TERM AER ALN LIES OEE SVE EES LIN IEE RENEE RESEND MRE LL SM
™ - 11
as a scaling innabitinn: in “whith machine the dough is by
volume compressed into a compartment, variable in size,
which compartment is adjustable to provide the required
amount of dough for a desired size loaf: That this process
‘ constitutes scaling by volume rather than by actual weight
'. of the dough, and that this is the only, practical method
known for scaling dough in large quantities for plants
_ having a large production, and that owing to the nature of —
the process of scaling variation in the amount-of dough |
scaled for given loaves will result from the amount of gas
present in the dough and. with numerous other elements,
resulting. ‘in. a variation in the amount of dough placed in | ;
the pan; that in order to obtain a loaf of bread weighing
nof‘lesssthan one pound at any time within 12 hours after —
baking, it is necessary to insert into the oven a sufficient
quantity of:dough inorder that allowances for losses in the
| dividing and moulding process and for evaporation losses
in the baking, cooling and wrapping process may not re-
duce that loaf below the minimum weight during ‘said — pe-
riod, and it’becomes necessary to‘scale“a sufficient amount
of dough which will frequently result ‘in a loaf of bread
exceeding the two ounce tolerance above said one pound
_ weight; that owing to the constant variation in the time
.: taken for.the evaporation of the moisture in both the dough f
and bread; and in order to allow for the constant variation.
‘in the amount of evaporation, taking place, it is necessary
to scale such a quantity of dough as will, after making due ©
+ allowances for the greatest evaporation possible, result in
a loaf of bread weighimg at’ least one pound continuously
for a period of twelve ho fter baking; that owing to
additionsi to the dough resulting from the use. of dusting
flour, pan grease, and to pieces ~ dough dislodging from
one loaf and attaching themselves to the: next loaf, it is nec- |
* essary for the baker to, scale a quantity of dough as near
the one pound unit as is possible in order that the same . ©
may not exceed in weight the excess ease: allowed ad
said rules. — | hein
\[fol. 19] ee B. .
That oantte the best elterts of the baker it is impossible
to so regulate the mechanical. scaling, evaporation and other
invisable losses to the extent that his loaf will never drop .
below: - minimum — fixed by statute without scaling |
a ;
b \
\
\
e |
A : ; \
screens ee — saeares: .
Weer are ee Ba Sig nak eal a tied
‘
,
SEODN ORL LEI LOOL LEN RTE OTE
, .
rs,
12 a
é
' such an amount of dough that additions in weight to the
loaf, such as.dusting flour, pan grease and dislodged pieces
- of dough, may frequently so add to the weight of the loaf’ -
‘that upon completion of the baking process it, will-exceed the
_ maximum toleratice permitted by thé rules of the Depart-
-ment of Agriculture. That in order to insufethat the baked
_ Specified period therein.” I.
ee sy bere ae |
- law nor more than the maximum fixed by-rule during the. _
_ That though the amount of moisture evaporation and the | ©
- consequent shrinkage in the various loaves of bread will.
vary widely under different and varying atmospheric con-
ditions, the food valué of the. loaf baked from the same.
formula and ingredients remain the same/so that loaf of °
bread baked from pieces of dough.scaled the same amount -
will contain the same food value although weighing different - —
amounts upon completion’of thé baking process or within.
a period of twelve hours thereafter; and that as a result
- [fol. 20] thereof, although fhe.purchaser may obtain a loaf
of bréad' varying in’ weight from another loaf of the same
specified weight, the loaf purchased contains equal food
value with the other af. | ;
ede 15 |
That under -the plan and arrangement of graduating. the
weight of the loaf in aécordance witfi the fluctuaction of *
‘the market price of ingredients as naw practiced by plain-
tiff bakers and others, the quality of bread has been pre-’
served and the buying public has at all times shared ratably
in the increase or decrease in the. market price of ingredi- .
ents without any deterioration in the quality of ‘the bread -
Ley
tS
a
o-
_ consumed ; that alles the Nebraska Bread Law, shuuld the’
cost of the ingredients used in the loaf of bread increase by.
a fraction of a cent per loaf, the price to the consumer, if
the quality thereof ‘is to be maintained, wil of necessity’ be
raised a‘full cent, since the cent is the lowest unit of money
in circulation and i in that event the retailer and the baker
‘will make more than: a normal-profit and the consuming
publi®will pay more for its bread than it:is now paying and
‘, more than it should pay after making due allowance for-the
usual margin of profit in the production of. bread, which
margins ordinarily do not exceed six-tenths. of a cent per
loaf for the baker, and in this manner the Nebraska Bread ©
Law, if put into effect, will be detfmental to. and against
. the best interest of the consuming public and will i in no D way
or manner be beneficial to that _
16 -
¥. Ps
- That under the modern Piet process one barrel of flour
_weighing 196 pounds produces approximately three hun-
dred loaves of bread weighing one-pound each, so that be-
cause the minimum unit of money is one éent it will neces-
sarily be impossible to give the bread consuming public the
. -benefit of a reduction in price of flour unless ‘the cost of
.such flour to the baker is reduceds$3.00 per barrel, and thus
. [fol. 21] the Nebraska Bread Law will to such extent, if up-
_held, again in its operdtion and effect be contrary to the i in- ©
terest of thé bread wiaieree:: public.
R oe
17 : 8h,
. That betaine the price for. bina Lisaliesite by usage and
‘Custom: largely standardized and "rE according to °
size, bakers of. bread will, ‘if the Nabraska Bread’ Law be-
comes effective,'i in order to comply with such standardized
and. stabilized sizes obviously be obliged to lower the quality |
of the bread upon.an increase in the price of ingredients in
order to maintain the usual margin of profit, and once again __
such Nebraska Bread Law will in its operation, if upheld,
be detrimental to and against the-interest of the bread con-
suming public, hence the vital interest of that publi¢ in the
defeat of such law.’ het
i: a : .
: That the majority of the plaintift bakers are engaged i oe
_ the wholesale baking « of bread on @ large scale = that such
14
' bi
<w 4
plaintiffs supply approximately one-third or sipaesot the »
total quantity of bakers bread consumed in the state of Ne-
braska ; that in all such large bakeries the process of bread
- baking ‘is more or less ey “eg ‘all of the time ‘except
during one day in the week, which is set apart for cleaning
and renovating purposes in each bakery, and that therefore
because of the exactions of the business and thé latk of con-
tinuous and constant transportation facilities, it is not pos-
sible to make immediate delivery of bread as it is baked
. to retail dealers throughout the state, and the products of
such larger bakers usually do not leave the bakery until six
_- to twelve hours after the bread is wrapped; that during this
period of time large quantities of baked bread are displayed
and kept in the bakery. That under the rules adopted by
the Department of Agriculture the tolerances provided
for, loaves of bread shall apply for a period of twelve hours’
after baking and shall be determined by averaging the
[fol. 22] weight of not less than five loaves of a given and
specified weight and manufacture, if available, and there is
no provision made in said rules as to the place where the
weighing shall be made. That: after the loaves of bread |
have been discharged from the’ oven in all bakeries of the
plaintiffs herein and of others similarly situated, the bread ™:
is permitted to ¢ool for a period of time, varying from two
to four hours before wrapping in order that ‘the gases may
be permitted to escape and-the loaf become sufficiently
_” solidified that it will not be injured in the wrapping machine
process, and that the rules of the Secretary of Agriculture,
- which provide for the application of tolerances fora period
of twelve hours after baking, fails to define or disclose at
what period of the process the baking is completed, whether
it is at the time of diséHiarge from the oven, at the time of
_ completion of the cooling process, or at the time of comple-
tion of, the wrapping thereof; and that during the time that
the loaves of bread are still retained in the. bakeries of the
plaintiffs_and others similarly situated, they are inter-
mingled with all of the other loaves of the same size and
ie _-aMfanufacture so that.it is impossible for the baker himself,
for inspectors of the Department.of Agriculture, or for any
other person, to determine at what hour the: baking of such
loaf ‘or loaves was'completed, and that when inspectors of
the Department of Agriculture attempt’ to average the
weight of five leaves of bread of a given size and manu-
fe?
ec ke ee. 15
: &
facture, it is'impossible even though said weighing process
takes place in the plant, for theibaker himself to determine
whether all of the five loaves have, been baked within the
preceding twelve hours or whether a portion of Said loaves
are older. That under the rules of the Department of Ag-
riculture this weighing process by the Department of Agri-
‘culture may take place after delivery of the loaves of bread
to the retail dealer and that from the size, appearance, ©
~ shape or feeling of the loaf of bread it is impossible for the -~
[fol. 23] inspector or any other pérson to determine whether
the loaves at that time weighed are more or leSs than twelve .
hours of age, even if it were fully determined as to when the
baking process was completed and when the period of time |
covered ‘by aesabeane commenced to run. :
19
That in practically every city, town and village. in the
State’ of Nebraska there are retail bakers who bake small
amounts of bread from two to fgur times per day, acéerd-
ing to the demand of the consumers in their immediate
vicinity, and who sell their bread over the counter direct to
the local consumer almost immediately after baking so that —
such retail bakers’ bread is not kept on hand subject to the
weighing process for a perioa of more than three hours
after baking and such bread is thus not subject to so much
evaporation as the bread: of the larger wholesale bakers,
and in the plant of the said small retail baker the loaf may
‘be protected by the baker himself from evaporation,
whereas the loaf of the wholesale baker, passing as it does
from the hands of. the wholesaler to those of the retail
grocer, may be subjected to the weighing process after the
time when it passes from the control of the baker himself
into the hands of the retail grocer who is under the statute
not subject to penalties for violation thereof and who may |
permit the said loaves to be displayed in places and under
conditions where evaporation is greatiy increased, thereby
‘eausing. the baker to be guilty of.a violation of the act -in
question ; that as a result thereof-the operation of the stat-
uté in question is not equal ae the citizens of the state..
s +» 20
is That the nsiinede of restaurants ro oe the State of
Nebraska are large purchasers of bread, and such restau- )
16.
-. rants have found from experience that the most satisfactory
[fol. 24] loaf for them to purchase and which they demand.
for their trade, is a loaf of a width, height and thickness’
which will fit mechanical toasters, manufactured for ‘restau- .
rant use, and none of which are known to these plaintiffs. to
be manufactured in the State of Nebraska or to be con-
structed in sizes and shapes which will under all circum-
stances fit-the sizes of loaves permitted under the statute
in question. That as a result of this condition the majority
of restaurants take a loaf of bread very long and thin in
shape because such !oaf is more economical than the ordi.
nary loaf, having fewer ends and crusts, and is capable of |
being cut into a larger number of slices without being awk-.
ward to handle and which loaves of bread frequently weigh
in the neighborhood of twenty-eight or twenty-nine ounces,
and wherein evaporation -is more rapid.’ That to require
the bakers of bread in Nebraska, and particularly the plain-
tiffs herein, many of whom enjoy 2 very satisfactory res-
taurant trade, to construct their loaves of a given weight
rather than to permit them to construct it of a size and
shape demanded by the restaurant keeper and fit the me-
chanical appliances of the restaurant keeper, will result in
the bakers losing the restaurant business and the restau-
rant keeper establishing equipment for the manufacture of
his own bread in the size desired, or will require the restau-
rant keeper :to purchase bread manufaétured -in bakeries
outside the State of Nebraska. a
21
. That in order to attempt to comply with the provisions of
the Nebraska Bread Law by the plaintiff bakers, it will re-
_. quire a radival change in the equipment of the bakeries and
_ In the methods and processes now used in baking bread,.
which chatige in ¢quipment, methods and processes will en-
- tail costs and expenses to each baker running into thousands"
of dollars, varying in accordance with the capacity and size
of the bakery, and aggregating for plaintiffs more than
$10,000.00, all of which cost and expense will be of no bene-
fit to either the baker, the dealer or the consuming public,
(fol. 25] and there will also be an irreparable loss to plain-
tiffs of many thousands of dollars in under weight and over
weight bread, which will result from the enforcement of the
a
}. ae
‘law, which bread will be illegal under the law and not sub-
ject to sale and will result in great economic loss.
_ That fora period of a great many years one of the most
popular loaves manufactured in the State of Nebraska on
account of its-size, shape and price, is. the loaf of ‘bread
weighing approximately twenty ounces, wholesaling at 8¢
and retailing at 10¢, which loaf of bread is in particular
demand by the consuming: public in ‘rural ‘communities.
owing possibly to the size of families and’ the demand for.
wholesome bread at a price figuring in even coin units; that
~ as a result thereof fully thirty three and one-third per cent :
of the white bread manufactured: by the plaintiffs herein- oh -
is a loaf of bread weighing approximately twenty ounces,
which loaf is nat permitted to be manufactured 'by the 1931
Nebraska Bread Law. That in no line of manufacturing .
business in the State of Nebraska is there greater competi-
tion than for the baker, to whom every’ retail baker and
every housewife:are active or potential competitors); that
to refuse to the bakers of Nebraska the. right to manufac- |
ture the twenty ounce loaf of bread, popular as it is with: _
the cansuming public and embracing approximately one-
third of the total white bread production,’ will result ina -
large number of housewives resuming home baking, ‘with
the consequent loss of a large and undeterminable propor-
_ tion of the business of the plaintiffs herein,.and others simi-
larly situated, and will render useless thé large present in-
vestment of the plaintiffs and others in pans and wrapping
». . . paper for said twenty ounce loaf.
23
That. ner the provisions of the 1931 Nebraska Bread
Law the provisions of the. act do not apply to fancy breads,
while both the statute and the rules of the Department of
[fol. 26] Agriculture fail to define or determine what shall
constitute fancy bread, whether the same applies to dark
- breads, mut breads, raisin bread, hearth breads, or whether
its application refers to white ‘breads manufactured with.
whole milk or other wholesome ingredients; that for that
reason the statute is so indefinite that the plaintiff bakers
and others similarly situated are unable to determine
whether their bread will come within the classification. of
2203
‘0 on
fancy bread and thereby be relieved from the provisions of
the statute, or whether they will be classified. as not manu- ”
facturing. fancy bread and therefore subject to the provi-
sion of the statute. — ‘
| | Nees
' That a new development has taken place in fhe baking ¢
industry within the past three years wherein the bakers are
manitfacturing, offering to their trade and selling a loaf of
bread which is sliced before wrapping and is thereby made
more. rgadily ‘usable by the housewife; that the demand
for the sliced bread has grown to such large proportion
during this short period of-time that a large percentage of
certain sizes of bread. manafactured and sold by the bakers
of. Nebraska is now sliced. That owing to the slicing proc-
ess and to the wrapping of this sliced bread, greater areas
of the bread itself are exposed to evaporation with conse-
- quent greater evaporation in sliced bread: than in unsliced
hread, thereby resulting it: greater and more rapid loss of
weight in the sliced loaf; that.the rules of: the Department
make no.exception for sliced bread and allow no different
tolerance for sliced bread than for the unsliced loaf. That
for the reasons above stated it becomes more nearly impos-
sible to maintain a sliced loaf-of bread within the limits of .
tolerance fixed by the rule of the Department of Agricul-.
ture than for any other loaf, and that by the enforcement
of the rules so laid down by the Department of Agriculture
the bakers will be practically prohibited from manufactur-
ing and selling a sliced loaf’ of bread, which is in itself a
[fol. 27] wholesome product and an added convenience
greatly'in demand by the consuming public. —
| - 2 .
That it is the custom of large bakeries such as those op-
erated by the plaintiffs herei, that bread is placed in the -
_ store of retail grocers, ‘permitted to remain there for a
period of time approximately forty-eight hours. and if un-
sold at the end‘of that time to return the same day to the
baker, thereafter selling the same as stale bread at-a re-
duced price, and which stale return frequently attain- large
proportions; that this bread, though having lost part of
its palatability thru loss of moisture contained in the loaf |
al r = ‘
«
“or iginally, still containe all of the food value that it had .
at the time it came from the oven, and ig still.a wholesome ~
food for the human system, much in demand by certain in-
stitutions and by poor and needy families; that during the/
period of forty-eight hours or longer. during which the loaf
of bread is permitted.to remain.in the hands of the retail
grocer under the varying conditions of heat and humidity eo
and the methods of display for such merchandise in the
“grocery store, varying degrees of loss of evaporation will
result, so that many loaves will have lost sufficient moisture
that their weight will be below the minimum fixed by stat-.
ute and above the tolerance weight fixed for the next ——
smaller sized loaf and therefore will not be permitted to be
sold under the provisions of the 1931 Nebraska Bread Law,
thereby resulting in great economic loss to the bakers and
great hardship to poor families regularly purchasing the
said stale bread at the present time at reduced prices.
| | 26 : |
That said House Roll 51 as adopted is in violation of
Section 14 of Article III of the Constitution of Nebraska
in that the title of said act fails to state clearly the subject |
~ [fol. 28] matter of the bill, the subject matter as stated in
the title thereto has. reference to the adoption of a stand-_
ard loaf of bread for the State of. Nebraska and to provide
a penalty for the violation thereof and to repeal the sec-
tions in the 1929 Compiled Statutes containing the previous
Bread Weight Law. That in fact the act itself contains a
grant of power to the Department of Agriculture and a
grant to the Secretary of Agriculture of Legislative author-.
‘ity to adopt ‘rules establishing numerous loaves of bread
as standard, to fix tolerances and to provide length of time
within which loaves must, maintain the specified weight, and
that the said act further provides not for a standard loaf —
of bread as stated in the title of. the act, but for loaves of
one-half pound size, one pound size, one and one-half. pound
size, and other loaves-in multiples of one pound and by im-
plication provides for twin leaf of bread and for fancy
breads, all of which are not embraced within the title of
-the act.’ .
t
DN AC Oy Oe NAA Ar 6 ole Cae cls Lat Waren see
-
= ‘ees
That the Nebraska Bread Law as adopted in House Roll
51 is contrary — and in violation of Section I Article III of
;
c ‘ "3 ™
- A ‘ : ; et a a EEE OEE, “NTA IIE a
. . > *
20
the Constitution of the State of ‘Nebraska, which provides
-that ‘‘the Legislative authority of the state shall be vested
in a Legislature consisting of a Senate and House of Rep-
_ resentatives’’, in that the said Nebraska Bread Weight Law
fails.to define an offense but attempts to pass’ to-a minis-
terial officer of the executive department legislative author-
ity: to define the offense of selling over weight or short’
weight bread, and to provide rules for the enforcement of ~ ~~
the act having the authority of law.
28
That the N ebraska Bread Law above referred to is con- .
trary to and in violation of the Constitution of the State of
Nebraska as above referred to in the further particular
[fol. 29] that the legislative authority above referred to is
delegated to the Secretary of Agriculture, an office which
is not filled; the office now being, in charge of. the Deputy ~
Secretary of Agriculture, Dwight F. Felton, defendant
herein. That under the delegation of power above referred
to to make rules, no power is granted to. this Deputy. Sec-
retary of Agriculture, to the Governor, or to any other per-.
son or official, but is attempted to be delegated to the Sec-
retary of Agriculture only. That under the attempted del-
' egation ‘of legislature authority the Deputy Secretary of
Agriculture has adopted and attémpted to make official cer-
tain rules which. are shown. by exhibit ‘‘B’’ hereto at-
tached, all of which said rules are adopted under the alleged
_autherity of said statute but _of which rules those num-
_ bered one to eight inclusive, rule ten, rules twelve, thirteen
_ and fourteen are without any authority whatever of said
statute; that rule ee the same being stated
in the statute itself; that rule eleven is arbitrary, unfair
- and unreasonable ir that it fails-to define what shall con- rs
_ Stitute fancy bread, but leaves the: power of definition en-
tirely in the hands of the Secretary of Agriculture without
apprizing :thése plaintiffs or others’ similarly situated of
what shall constitute fancy bread; that rule fifteen is: arbi-
trary and unjust in that it provides for weighing of a small
number of loaves only, which loaves.if available are to be
of a given lot of the same marking and manufacture; that
rule sixteen is arbitrary, unfair and unreasonable. in that
~ it fixes a tolerance of one ounce one the one-half pound loaf, |
21 |
two ounces on the pound loaf, and 10% on all larger loaves
_of. bread, which said ‘tolerance is arbitrary, unreasonable
and so small that under the operation of natural laws the
bakers are unable to comply with the same under the con--
ditions of heat and humidity prevailing in Nebraska, and —
__is further unfair in that whereas on the one pound loaf of
bread a tolerance of two. ounces is permitted, on the one
———~[ fol- 36] -aad_one- half pound loaf, in which evaporation is
- greater and consequent loss of weight is larger, a tolerance
of only 2.4 ounces is: permitted, and on the two pound loaf
a tolerance -of only 3.2 ounces is permitted, and on three
“ponnd loaves a tolerance of only 4.8 ounces is permitted.
‘And the said rules are further unreasonable and arbitrary
-in that rule seventeeen makes tolerances applicable for a_
period of twelve hours after baking without defining com-
pletion of the baking process, or specifying when, where
- or how the weighing shall be completed, and in the further
particular that. the. period of time during which the said
bread is required to remain within the tolerances fixed is
unfair and unreasonable, and in that no provision is made
/ for the disposition of any bread not falling within the speci-.
fied tolerances, or older than the time of weighing even
/ though within said tolerances. Sina
. wt!) ee
29 os
- That the said Nebraska Bread Law is contrary to and in
‘violation of Section I of the 14th Amendment to the Con-
stitution of the United States, which provides ‘‘no state
shall make or enforce any law which shall * * * deny
to any person within its. jurisdiction the equal protection
of the laws’’, and it further violates Section I of thé 14th.
Amendment to the Constitution of the ‘United States, and
' Section 25 of Article I of the Constitution. of the State of -
Nebraska, which provides that there shall be no discrimina-
tion between citizeys of the United States in respect to the
acquisition, ownership, possession, ‘enjoyment or de-cent —
of ‘property in that it provides that ‘‘every loaf of bread
made for sale in the State of Nebraska’’ shall be of the
specified weights, thereby under. one construction. thereof .
it*attempts to regulate the operations of bakers situated
outside the State “of. Nebraska engaged in interstate com-
merce and shipping bread into the state, or under the other.
22
ee
construction thereof requiring bakeries situated within the
State of Nebraska to comply with the requirements of said -
_ [fol. 31] Bread Weight Law and permitting bakeries situ-
ated outside the State of Nebraska to have privileges as
to weights and tolerances not permitted to the bakers of
Nebraska, thereby placing the bakers of Nebraska at a dis- .
advantage and irreparably damaging their business.
30
_ That the Nebraska Bread Law is contrary to and in vio-
lation of Section I of the 14th Amendment to the Constitu-
tion of the United States, which provides ‘‘no state shall
make or-enforce any law which shall * * * deprive any
person of life, liberty.or property without due. process of
law; nor deny to any person within ‘its jurisdiction the |
equal ‘protection of the law’’, and *4 also violates Section
III of Article I of the Constitution of the State of
' Nebraska, which provides ‘‘no persona shall be deprived of
life, liberty or property. without due process of law’’ for
such Nebraska Bread Law will, if enforced, deprive the
_ plaintiffs and each of them and others similarly situated,
.of their liberty and their. property without"due\ process: of
law and such bread law also. denies to the citizens of the
State of Nebraska the equal protection of the law and their
constitutional freedom’ of contract; that such Nebraska
Bread Law is not passed under any proper exercise of the
police power of the State.of Nebraska and that such law
has no-relation whatever to the public wel-are or the public ©
health, but is contrary and adverse thereto ; and such law |
if enforced is arbitrary, unreasonable and oppressive and
is ‘an unwarranted interference with the constitutional
.
‘rights and privileges of plaintiffs and each of them and of |
all others similarly situated, all done under the guise of
police protection. 3 ite ce ae
: ; 31
That plaintiff and each of. them and all others similarly a
situated have no adequate remedy at law in the premises;
- that the enforcement of the Nebraska Bread Law. as
amended by the Legislature.in‘1931 will entail a. multiplicity
_ of suits and consequent large expense to the plaintiffs and
-[fol.32] other litiga-tes; that if the enforcement of said —
law be not enjoined, plaintiffs and each of them: and all
others similarly situated, will. sustain immeasuredble dam-
Pe
23.
age and —s injery te their businesg and property _
in that on and after August 2d, 1931, when the amended
law will go into effect, unigss its enforcement be enjoined,
. plaintiffs and others similarly situated will not only be sub-
. ject to arrest and fine because of their inability to comply
with the provisions of the law or of the rules adopted
thereunder, but this will entail consequent loss of liberty |
and property; and the larger bakers who manufacture and °
sell the greatest quantity of bakers bread consumed in the
State of: Nebraska will be unable to dispose of. their prod-
ucts because of not conforming to the requirements of the
bread law for the abnormal period provided for weighing
and this while the validity of the law is still undetermined,
‘and therefore plaintiffs and each of them and.those in like
situatjon will thereby hav@diverted and will, lose their
regular trade and custom and the good will of their, busi-
velopment and by large expenditures;of money, and valu--
able property will thus be permanently impaired and lost.
Plaintiffs therefore appeal to a Court of Equity to enjoin
the threatened wrongful invasion ‘by the defendants of the
rights gnd liberty and of property and of contract of the
ness and trade so built up edit period of years of de-
plaintiffs and all other similarly sit tuated.
Wherefore plaintiffs and each of them pray:
First. That the court order and ‘decree that the provi- —
sion of House Roll 51, passed by the Legislature of the -
State. of Nebraska in 1931, amending the- Nebraska Bread
Law, is unconstitutional and invahd, and that all. defend-
ants and each of them, their agents and employees and all
. persons claiming to act under their authority, direction or
control, or that of either of them be permanently enjoined
[fols. 33-35] from i in any way enforcing said law.
Second. That peiaitians final hearing the court issue hi
. porary injunction, and that pending hearing t®ereon the.
court issue temporary restraining order, restraining de-
fendants and each of them, their agents and employees, and
all persons claiming to act under their authority, di-
réction or control, or. of ‘either of them, from in any way. .
enforcing the. provisions of the Nebraska Bread Law as ,
amended. |
in printing.
24
Third. That plaintiff's and each of them may have such :
other and further relief in the premises as may to the court
seem just..and equitable. eee
Fourth. And for the costs and disbursements of this
action. ee , De aa ae ,
: “John C. Grover, Harold D. LeMar, Attorneys for
_ Plaintiffs. , ~ f DLE aie
Duly sworn. to by P. F. Petersen et al. Jurats omitted
-_ : /
[fol. 36] Exuisirt ‘‘A’’ ‘to Amenven/ Peririos
' /
House Roll No. ik
_ Introduced by. Representative Ed /A. Smith, of Douglas
| Tifle
An act to establish a standard loaf of bread for the State
of Nebraska; provide.a penalty for the violation of said
act; and to repeal Section- 89-142, 89-143, 89-144 and 89-.
145. Compiled ‘Statutes of’.Nebraska, 1929. :
Be it enacted by‘the People of the State of Nebraska:
Section 1. Tt shall be the duty of the Department of .. -
Agriculture to énforce all provisions of this act. It shall.
-make or cause to be made all necessary examinations and
shall have authority to promulgate such rules and ‘regula-
tions as are necessary to promptly and effectively enforce
the provisions of this act. — di |
Section 2. Every. loaf of bread made for sale in the State
~ of Nebraska shall be of the following weights avoirdupois ;
one-half pound, one pound, one and: one-half pounds, and .—
also. in exact multiples of. one pound. and of no other
weights. Whenever twin or multiple loaves are baked, the
weights herein specified shall apply to each unit of the twin
or multiple loaf, provided that a twin one and one-half
pound loaf may be made and sold, but’ units of said loaf
. ‘must not be sold separately; Provided that none of the
provisions of this act shall apply to fancy breads.
25
~ Section 4. The Se Secrétary of Agriculture shall prescribe
» reasonable tolerances or variations i in excess, but not under
the weights mentioned in the preceeding section; within -
which all loaves shall be baked, and also the - dana which
said weights shall be maintained.
‘Section 4. Any. persona, firm or corporation violating ‘
“Tok 37] any. of the provisions.of this Act, shall be pun- ~
ished by a fine of not less than ten dollars nor more than
one hundred dollars. |
Section 5. That ssid Reolicns 89-142, 89. 143, 89. 144 and .
89-145, Compiled Statutes of Nebraska, 1929, are rice
“repealed.
Max Kier, Speaker of the House. Vernon D. An-
drews, Chief Clerk of the House. Theodore W.
Metcalfe, President of the Senate.. George C.
Snow, Secretary ofthe Senate. / 2 99°. |
_ Approved April 21, 1931, 12 701 o "dock P.: M. et oat
Charles W. Bryan, Governor.
This. is to. ccrtity that the» ‘within House Roll No. 51
oieinesed in the House and passed Legislature at its
Forti-Seventh Session on the 15th day of April, 1931.
Vernon D. Andrews, Chief Clerk of the ‘House. ss
[fol. 38] : _ Exuisrr —_ ae PETITION
Rules and Regulations Governing the Enforcement of the
‘Standard Bread Loaf Law.
1. Every bakery must be: properly ‘lighted, drained,
plumbed and ventilated and conducted with strict regard
to the influence of “such conditions upon the health of all:
persons therein employed.
2. The floor, side walls, ceilings, furniture, sintateilon:
implements and’ mathinery of every bakery and: all cars,
trucks and vehicles used in the transportation of all bakery
food products. shall be at no time kept in an’ at ea, un-
healthful and/or unsanitary conditions. pie
, & All trucks, trays, boxes, baskets, buckets and other. .
receptacles, chutes, platforms, racks, tables, shelves and .
26 |
o 6 i
all knives, saws, diane and other. utensil and machinery
must .be thoroughly cleansed daily and the clothing of
operators, employees, clerks or other persons therein em-
‘ployed must be clean.
‘A. The side walls and. ceilings. of every. bakery elt be —
brick, cement, plastered, wainscoted or ceiled with metal or |
lumber and shall be oil painted or kept well lime washed
‘and all interior wood work in every bakery shall be kept
well oiled or painted with oil paints or lime washed and kept:
clean and every building, room, basement or cellar shall
have an impermeable floor made of cement or tile laid in
cement, brick, ‘wood or other suitable non-absorbent mate-
rial which can be flushed and washed clean with water.
‘5. The> doors, windows and other openings of every
_. bakery shall, during the fly season, “be fitted with self-clos-
ing screen deors. and wire window screens of not, coarser
Tt
than fourteen ‘mesh wire gauze. .'\.\ .
6. Every ‘bakery must. have ‘convenient ‘toilet’ ‘or Koliet
‘rooms separate and. apart from the bakery. .The floors of
[fo]. 39] such toilet rooms: shall be of cement, tile, wood,
- brick or otker non-absorbent material and shall be kept i ma §-
- thoroughly clean.and sanitary condition. Such toilet’ shall
_ be furnished with. separate ventilating flues, or pipes, dis- ,
~~charging into soil. pipes, or on outside of the building. °
Lavoratories-and:- wash rooms sh i be supplied with soap, ©
’ water and towels, and all persons e oyed i in the bakery
must before beginning work or after visi the toilet wash
their hands and arms thoroughly in clean wa ot |
7. No person shall be allowed to live or sleep in’ BAX room
of the bakery. ¥ a
8. No person afflicted with any infectious, contagious, or
veriereal disease shall be permitted to qere | in any manner
in any bakery. = |
9. Loaves of bread made for sale’ in the State of Nebraska
shall only beof thé sizes specified by law.
10, The name and the net weight of the bakery product
~ must be clearly. printed on the outside of the ‘wrapper if |
wrapped previous to the time of. sale.
. 11. Fancy bread, as defined by the Secretary of Agricut-
ture of the State of Nebraska, shall not be considered as
‘coming ‘within 7” scope of the law.
aa
oT
“Ye. Milk bread i is » the. bread cheatin by baking a wheat
bread doug in which not less than one-third of the water
* ingredient has been replaced’by milk or the constituents of
milk solids in proportions normal for le milk. lt con-
forms to the moisture limitation for wheat bread.
13. Rye bread is the bread obtained. by baking a dough
which differs from wheat dough in that no less than. one-
third of the flour ingredients has been replaced by rye flour.
-It conforms to the moisture limitations for wheat bread.
[fol. 40] 14. Raisin bread is the bread obtained by baking .
wheat bread dongh, to which have been added sound raisins
in quantity equivalent to at least 3 ounces for each pound of |
- the baked product and which may contain proportions of
sweetening and shortening ingredients greater than those
commonly - used in wheat bread dough.
15. Weights shall be determined by averaging the weight
of not less than five loaves of a given lot, of the same mark- i
- ing and manufacture, if available.
16. A tolerance of one ounce per half pound loaf; two.
ounces per pound loaf and 10% of all larger loaves of bread ;
shall be allowed in excess of the minimum weight.
17. Tolerances shall apply for a ‘Period. of twelve hours.
after baking. °
[File endorsement omitted. ].
‘In District Court oF LANCASTER COUNTY ,
[Title omitted]
- Answer—Filed Sept: 30, 1931
Come now the’ defendants and for answer to the peti-
tion of the plaintiffs state:
I
Admit the allegations in paragraph ‘‘I”’ of the petition;
[fol. 41] admit that the defendant Charles W. Bryan is the
duly elected, qualified and acting Governor of the State of
Nebraska, and that the defendant Dwight F. Felton is the
- duly appointed, qualified and acting deputy secretary of the
“7
28
Department of Agriculture, there. below no secretary.
thereof ; admit that said defendants will unless enjoined ‘by ° |
' this Court enforce the provisions of House Roll No. 51, now
‘Chapter 162, Session Laws of Nebraska for 1931; admit
the passage of said House Roll No. 51 by the 1931 session
_ of the Legislature of Nebraska, and admit that said House
—-\' Roll No. 51 does not permit the sale in Nebraska of a 20 °: -
ounce loaf. of bread.” ;
| II,
‘The defendants deny each and every: allegation saiditlinad
in said petition except’ such allegations as in paragraph
‘1’? have been admitted to be true.
II
_. Further answering defendants: allege that under ‘the:
4 authority of said: House Roll No. 51, the Department ‘of’
Agriculture of the State of Nebraska on the 19th day of ©.
September, 1931, adopted rules and regulations with refer-
ence to.the enforcement of said Act, a copy of which rules
and regulations is hereto attached, marked “Exhibit a” *
and by reference made a part hereof.
Wherefore defendants pray that the petition of the plain-
tiffs be dismissed and that they recover their costs herein
expended.
Charles W. Bryan, as Governor of. the State of
Nebraska, and Dwight F. Felton, as Deputy Secre-
tary of the Department of Agriculture of the State
of Nebraska, Defendants, by C. A. Sorensen, At-
torney General; R. R. Strehlow, Attorneys.
[fol. 42] Duly sworn to by Dwight F. Felton. Jurat.
omitted in printing. i
Exuisit ‘‘A’’ To ANSWER
State of Nebraska, Department of Agriculture
By virtue and under the authority of House Roll No. 51,
Chapter 162, Session Laws of Nebraska for 1931, the fol-
lowing rules and Tegulations are hereby prescribed and
- promulgated :
»"
on
I. The tolerance and/or excess variation, in’ weight of
‘bread baked for sale in Nebraska shall not exceed:
(a) One and one-half ounces for one-half pound loaves.
_ (b) Three ounces for. one pound loaves.
(c) Four and one-half ounces for one and one-half pound
loaves. - ;
(d) Six ounces for two. pound loaves.
(e) The same relative tolerance for loaves of larger
size permitted to be sold under said Act.
II. Bread for sale in Nebraska shall be so made and
baked that it will maintain after cooling its required mini- -
[fol. 43] mum weight for not less than twelve hours under
normal conditions... The baker of such bread, however, shall
not be responsible for the- maintenance. of said minimum
weight after delivering the same to a retail dealer or. con-
sumer, or to a transportation agency in Nebraska for de- —
: livery to a retail dealer or consumer. .
III. Weights shall be determined by averaging: the weight
of not less than five loaves, if available, of a given lot of
bread of the same grade, size, and baking.
IV. These rules shall not apply to fancy breads. .
V. These rules and regulations supersede all other rules:
and regulations heretofore made. an
Dated this 19th day of September, 1931.
(Signed) Dwight F. Felton, Deputy Secretary of
Agriculture. (Signed). Charles W. Bryan, Gov-
ernor. ;
[File endorsement omitted.]
In District Court oF LaNcasTER County
[Title omitted]
Repty—Filed Oct, 28, 1931
The plaintiffs, for reply. to the new matter - forth j in:
. paragraph three of defendant’s answer, ‘allege as follows:
[fol. 44] ee
That the rules adopted on September 19th, -1931, by the
Deputy Secretary of Agriculture under alleged .authority
| — 3
.
- *,
— e a e =
. «
° °
° ¥ « .
.
contained in House Roll 51, were not made in good faith
but were adopted with the intention of evading and circum:
venting the issues of this action, and were ‘adopted during
the pendency of this action after the commencement thereof,
and during the time when the defendants and each of them _
were restrained by a temporary restraining order from
doing any act or thing looking to the enforcement of said
House Roll 51. - “a
"30
2 ‘
Further: replying to said new matter set forth in said
- Paragraph three plaintiffs allege that under said House
Roll 51 the Deputy Secretary of ‘Agriculture, there being’
no Secretary of Agriculture, is without any ‘power or au-
thority to adopt. or promulgate any rules whatever.
a
For further reply to said Paragraph three the plaintiffs
allege that even though said rules were.otherwise legal they
are promulgated under an unlawful delegation of Legis-
lative authority, are indefinite and uncertain, and are ar-
bitrary and unreasonable, thereby violating Article Two,
Section One, and Article Three Section One of the Con-
stitution of Nebraska, the Sixth Amendment to the Consti-
_ tution of the United States and Article One Section Eleven
"of the Constitution of Nebraska, and the Fourteenth Amend-
--Ment to the Constitution of the United States, and Article
One Sections Three and Twenty-five of the Constitution of
Nebraska. ij: |
Wherefore plaintiffs pray judgment as applied for in the
petition herein filed. °
_ John C. Grover, Harold D. Le Mar, Attorneys for
Plaintiffs. : a
[fol.45] Duly sworn to by P. F. Petersen. Jurat omitted
im printing. .
a
- ' 7
In District Court or LANCASTER County
| 111-290
P. F, Perersen Baxine Company et al., Plaintiffs,
, _vs.
Cuar.es. W. Bryan, as Gereninn of the State of Nebraska,
et al., Defendants .
‘Decree —Jan. 30, 1932.
This action is a suit for an —— to sehiehiin the
enforcement of the Standard Weight. Bread Law. The plain-
tiffs are bakers and contend that the law, Chapter 164 of
the Laws of. 1931, is unconstitutional and void as in con-
travention of the Fourteenth Amendment to the Federal
' [fol. 46] Constitution, claiming:
1. That it would be impossible for bakers to sina with,
the requirements of said law in that a baker cannot ‘con-
trol the evaporation, otherwise ¢alled tolerance or shrink,’
of a loaf of bread-after it is baked. They claim that the
shrinkage or tolerance is controlled by evaporation of water
contents of the bread and also. affected by the atmospheric
conditions on the baking days. : Plaintiffs contend, there-
fore, that the law is arbitrary and unreasonable: —
2. They also contend that it is unreasonable and arbitrary
in that it prohibits the sale of bread loaves of other than
half pound, one pound, one pound and a half or multiples
of a pound loaf; thus prohibiting the sale of a twenty ounce
‘loaf, which they claim is the most popular ‘size loaf now
offered on the market and which i is demanded by - buying
public:
3. That the law eutenteuss the state constitution in that
it delegates legislative power’ to an administrative officer
in that the Act gives the state Secretary of Agriculture the
sole power of fixing the amount of tolerance allowable:
4. That the enforcement. of the law would deprive the
bakers of property without due process of law in that to
compel them to comply with the law imposes a financial loss
upon bakers:° |
5. That the purpose of the Act is an unreasonable and |
- unnecessary attempt to prevent fraud by the bakers upon
_ the buying public, and contend that it would prohibit the.
baker from giving to the purchasing public the -benefit of
the fluctuating price of flour and other bread ingredients,
and to that extent, at least, is detrimental to the buying
public rather than beneficial : y, .
6. In addition to the foregoing complaints plaintiffs claim
that the whole Act is indefinite and uncertain in that it
.[fol. 47] fails to define reasonable tolerance to be fixed by
the Secretary of Agriculture; fails to define the crime of
Selling overweight bread; fails to. define ‘‘fancy bread’’;
/fails to fix the time for which tolerance shall prevail; fails
_ to specify inj detail the powers‘ and duties of the Secretary
of Agriculture in fixing the tolerance; and fails ‘to make
clear’’ whether the Act applies to bread for sale in Ne-
braska or bread baked in Nebraska and sold outside of Ne-
braska; and also that the Act is broader than the title and
therefore unconstitutional. °
. The whole subject and history of the enactment of the
_ Standard Weight Bread Law ‘in ‘Nebraska has been a con-
troverted question for a number of years. ‘The first Act of
1921 (Chapter 2 Laws of 1921) was held to be constitu.
. tional by the Nebraska Supreme Court and on appeal to the -
Supreme Court of the United States was held unconstitu-
tional by that court in the case of J ay Burns Co. vs. Bryan, -
Governor, decided in 1924.‘ The main feature in that Act
contested was that it allowed a tolerance or shrink of only.
. two ounces per pound. In other words it permitted a
shrink of two ounces per pound, in a loaf of bread twenty-
four hours after baking, and no more. The Supreme Court
of the United States, by a majority opinion, held: that a
_. tolerance of two ounces was not sufficient and that its im- .
' position was unreasonable and arbitrary.
A dissenting opinion by Justice Brandeis, concurred in by
- Justice Holmes, stated that in their opinion there was suffi-
cient evidence in the record, then: before that court,.to. sup-
port a different conclusion than that reached by the ma-
jority of the court. Justice Brandeis contends that was a
matter entirely in the discretion of the legislature and
Stated expressly that to weigh the sufficiency of thé evidence
Yn
was for the court to tdi an attitude of ‘super Legislative
[fol: 48]. power or abilities.’’
Following that decision the etalon enacted Chapter
146, Laws of 1927. This second act attempted to correct the »
evils of the first, and fixed the tolerance at one ounce under
_ and three and-& half ounces over fhe fixed weight in twenty-
four hours, anid provided that the baker should be liable for
a misdemeanor for-the sale of bread which he baked if the
shrinkage or tolerance should exceed the stated ‘allowance.
This Act, in turn, was attacked in the Federal District
Court of Nebraska. Three judges sitting held the second
law unconstitutional in that it made the baker liable for the
. penalty, and guilty of a misdemeanor, for bread sold by a
retailer After it had left the custody and control of the baker..
‘In other words, as this court views it, the Federal Court de-
cision made that part of the act void which made the whoie-
sale baker liable for the misdemeanor. due to shrinkage
of bread that may have been caused by the improper care
by: a retail grocer exposing the bread to atmospheric condi-
. tions over whieh the baker ‘himself had no control. This
decision expressly holds that the court could not say but:
' that the inclusion of that provision was the inducement to
the passage of the whole act, and therefore declared the -
whole void, but apparently not disapproving the tolerance -~
provision. “
‘The legislature again enacted a Standard Bread Law in
1931 when the Act now in question was passed. ‘Chapter
162, Laws.of 1931. This Act provides that the Secretary of |
. Agriculture shall provide a reasonable tolerance for the en-
forcement of the Act thus attempting to cure the objectional |
feature found in the second by the Federal District Court. °
The present law requires bread baked for sale in Ne-
- braska should be only loaves of one-half pound, one pound,
one and one-half pounds, two pounds and multiples of
[fel. 49] pounds for larger loaves, and provides that the
| Secretary of Agriculture shall prescribe reasonable toler-
ance or variations, and expressly provides that no tolerance
for less than the weights fixed above should be allowed.
Under the first rules and regulations prescitibed by the Sec- .
retary of Agriculture a tolerance of two ounces to the-
3—203
pound was fixed and this suit was filed claiming the toler-
ance as thus fixed was unreasonable, and ‘the act was void,
as determined and decided by the Supreme Court of the
United States. Thereafter, and before the trial. of this
case, the Secretary of Agriculture published new rules fix-.
ing the excess tolerance at three ounces per pound. The
plaintiffs now contend that this case must be decided under
the rules existing at the time the suit was filed.
The record submitted to’ the court in the case now under
consideration is, by agreement of, parties, a stipulated
typewritten copy of the record and evidence on which the
first case was submitted to the Supreme Court of the United~ :
States, together with a typewritten copy of the same evi-
dence submitted to the Federal District Court.in the second
case, and also some additional typewritten matter together
~ with one or two witnesses who gave oral testimony, pri-
-- marily directed to the question of the interpretation of the
words ‘‘fancy bread’’ as used in the present law. It con-
sists mainly of statements of bakers and expert chemists
‘In ‘narrative form, the great bulk of which is purely argu-
ment, pro and con, as to the merits of any standard weight °
bread law. This matter should properly have been sub-
mitted to the legislature in determining the question of
whether or not there is need of such a law.
., The whole record discloses that the great balk of the -
bread sold to the consuming public is now baked in large
bakeries; that each baker, apparently, has his own formula
for making bread ;.that some of the bakers have a particu-
lar size and weight loaves and advertise them under vari-
ous trade names; that at the present time a large propor-
[fol. 50] tion of the -bread sold by the large bakers
is wrapped in waxed paper with printed trade names, ete.,.
thereon; that bakers ship bread long distances and sell
throughout this. and. bordering states, and non-resident
_bakers ship bread into Nebraska; that at the present time.
a large proportion of the bread baked is what is called”
twenty. ounce loaves, otherwise known as the Pullman loaf;
that most of the bakers, and particularly all of the large
_ bakers, in making white or common bread, use mixing ma-
chines in preparing the dough for the oven; that the dough
which goes.into each loaf is scaled-and cut to size by a scal-
ing machine, that can be set for different sizes. Some of < |
the bakers testified that while these scaling machines do
, 35
not canada with mathematical. accuracy, and that in Ge
operation there is loose flour scattered. about to prevent
sticking and often particles of this loose flour or dough
will fasten to or chip off, and some witnesses say they can-
‘not, with certainty, seale the dough so as to produce an
: exact weight loaf. Others say that dough can be scaled
so as to produce a loaf within a fraction of an ounce of a
" desired loaf of bread. Thére is much testimony of, bakers
and expert chemists, officers and employees of bakers’ as-
‘sociations and large flouring mills which goes into detail
-. as to conditions causing shrinkage or tolerance or’ evap-
oration in bread from the time the dough 1 is‘mixed until the
baked bread is sold to the consumer, in periods of from
one to sixty hours or more.
All these matters are of a character which, in the view
of this court, should properly have been submitted to the
‘legislature and undoubtedly were. It is not for the eourt
to determine the need and necessity of legislation upori ~
such subjects. That is wholly a question for legislative
determination. However, if upon a proper trial it is shown
tothe court that it ‘were impossible, or practically so, for
~ bakers to comply with such a law the court would hold it
[fol. 51] to be unreasonable, depending, of course; upon the
record. submitted.to the court. But in the record now be-
fore this court there is very much of a dispute on the ques-
tion of whether or not bakers can comply with the tolerance
provision of this Act. As this court reads the record it ~
cannot fairly be studied without a conclusion that that .
question is. wholly, one of weighing - the evidence on the
respective sides; that is, there is ‘evidence of witnesses who
testified that such a law cannot:be complied with, and on
the other hand .there is competent evidence, and testi-
~ mony, from which it ¢an only fairly be concluded that it
can be complied’ with, and that without much difficulty.
Some testified that: they made tests for determining this
_ very question under the requirements of the present Stand.
-ard Weight Bread Law and that they had no difficulty in ~
scaling their breads so as to easily comply with the pro-
visions of the law. Tabulated results of tests substantiated
these statements. Another testifies, and has computed a
table of results, of experiments made of bread from various
bakers: which. he purchased at retail stores and showed
that they shipped this bread from Omaha to as far as Den-:
SE ERED ROOT OY
Pen
ver, Colewndia, amd Cheyenne, Wyoming, that the bread
was unleaded af these points and returned to Omaha.
Weights were taken at the time the bread was purchased,
soon after baking, and again upon the return from these
trips and at stated intervals thereafter. The records show
that only one case of such shipped biead skewed a shrink
of two and one-half ounces or more. Other witnesses tes-
tified to tests and careful weights being taken, the weighing
being at stated intervals of six and twelve hour periods
..from immediately after baking until more than seventy-
' two hours thereafter. .Some loaves showed a shrink or
tolerance in excess of two, possibly two and a half ounces,
and in a few instances possibly three onces, but on cross-
\ examination this witness said that he made no attempt, in
XO either the baking or scaling of the dough, to comply with
[fol. 52] the present bread law or its regulations ‘as estab-
_ lished by the Secretary of Agriculture, He stated that he
\merely followed orders as given him by his superior and —
that he made no attempt, in the test at least, to ahely
with the bread law. Other-bakers and expert chemists em- . .
ployed by large baking associations and flouring mills, who
_ were \undoubtedly. efficient and. competent,. testified \they -
made tests by scaling and baking dough and thereafter
weighing at certain intervals, and on cross-examination -
stated that\they were not trying, at the time, to comply with
the Nebraska Bread Law Most of these expert witnesses’ |
were residents of, and made their tests in, other states.
Schedules of‘other.tests showed that at least some bakers .
_ could and do comply with the tolerance provision. One
testified that he operated numerous large bakeries, oné in
‘Omaha and at other “central points. The substance of
this testimony was that he had made tests for the purpose
of determining whether ‘he could comply with the Nebraska
Bread Law and the result_of such tests, both with his own .
baking’ and the purchase of many other brands of bread.
Weights taken at various intervals showed that.the toler-
ance provision could be complied with. See defendant’s ©
exhibits 37, 38, 39 and 40 to 400, pages 324 to 330.
One of plaintiffs’ ‘witnesses stated that he could comply
with the tolerance provision of the bread law but that it
‘ would be necessary to use a lower quality of ingredients
than he thought ought: to be used. In other words a lower
grade of bread-would be produced. And he frankly stated
37
that he thought that any bread should be based on nutritive
contents rather than on weight. = = = = a
~ One Lincoln baker testified that:during the period of the
appeal in the first case, there being no supersedeas, he did
bake bread: under the then existing law, but said that the
cost and overhead was greater than had he not been com-
plying with the law, . .
[fol.53] One baker says much about the financial loss that
his company would suffer if compelled to comply. with the
present law. The loss partly being in the profits now- de-
rived from the sale of breads the size of which would be
prohibited under the: present law. It would also require
him to procure considerable new equipment, particularly
pans of the size necessary under the proposed law and, too,
that there is.considerable oiled paper on hand in which the
present size loaves are wrapped. He claims that all this
would have to be discarded and wasted. Other bakers gave
like general testimony. It is the opinion’of this particular
court that that matter is wholly a question for legislative
. determination. I think it must be’ conceded that every
regulatory legislation, if otherwise proper, necessarily en-
tails some expense and some extra cost upon those whom it
attempts to regulate. ae a
‘Another contention of the plaintiffs is that to limit the
size of loaves to. standard pounds and half pounds and mul-
tiples thereof would prevent the baker from varying the
size of his loaf to meet the fluctuation of the cost of ingredi-
ents, and therefore prevent the baker from giving the con-
- sumer the benefit of the lower cost of ingredients. The
answer: to that is set forth in this record by testimony of
other bakers that there is nothing to prevent the baker
from varying the price of his loaf. That also, in the opin-
ion of.this court, is a matter wholly for the legislature to
determine. — eo ;
While this court, of course, must hold that the holding of
the Supreme Court of the United States in the Burns case _
is binding upon this court to the extent that a tolerance of
two ounces per pound would beunreasonable, nevertheless
this court is firmly of the conclusion that the record now
before us discloses the fact that even at a two ounce toler-
anée such a law could, under modern baking conditions, be
complied with without a great deal of difficulty, admitting,
[fol. 54] however, that there is evidence to the contrary..
~piéqu
* oe JN
* Ee se” eee Wee Be Os, » MO
But in the \opinioh of this court the conflict in ‘evidence
_ would be wholly a matter-for the legislature to determine’
, and not for the court: / .
. "—~Under~the tolerance allowance first fixed by the Secre- -
. tary-of_Agriculture: of two ourices per pound this court
\ would: feel obliged to hold that the weight of the evidence,
_- ‘as established by the record now, would be to the effect that,
even a tivo ounce tolerancé could and in fact had been*com- ._
plied with-by bakers of this state, However, the Secretary
. of Agriculture has adopted new rules fixing an excess -
‘ tolerance of thrée ounces. - This. court finds that under the ~
evidence in this*cade
-a tolerance, as threé.ounces, is sufficient.and that such a
tolerance requirement gould readily be complied with by
..' bakers affected... SS Sa
In answer to the contention of plaintiffs that this, court —
should not take into consideration the new rules adopted |
' Subsequent to the filing of this case, this court feels that:
its duty is otherwise and that if it did hold that the toler-.
ance as first fixed was unreasonable it. would merely result
\ . in‘a néw tule being: adopted and another suit filed to test:
~ . the reasonableriéss of thé new rule. s SOG a
That: brings us to the question of ‘whether or not the -
whole Act is void as delegating -legislative powers to an
‘ administrative officer in that the Act authorizés the Secre-
“=. -fary of Agriculture to, prescribe reasonable tolerance. — It
;- ‘.~must be‘remembered that both-the courts of this state and
- also the Supreme Court of the United States has held that
regulation of weights of bread by adoption ef a standard .
__- Weight law is a proper subject. of legislation. Many other
“ states have such laws which have been in force for a num-
_ ber of years. Some-of them not-unlike the law. now in ques-
w*
‘tion in this suit.’ ae ras te erage
_ The experiments in-this state in the two..previous Acts
in which the legislature attempted ‘on two different occa- ©
' [fol. 55]. sions ‘to fix tolerancé that would be lawful have
“resulted disastrously,. and by. this Act the legislature; be-’
cause of the apparent inability of the legislature to. fix. a
definite reasonable tolerance, now seeks to avoid unreason-
ableness by ‘making -provisions so that the Secretary of
... Agriculture can* meet varying atmospheric ‘conditions,
- , Which bakers claim might arise and which materially af-. .
fect .the bread. shrinkage. _Under the -present law: if, as .
.
*
° an
~.. 2m. %
there can be no question but that such | }
oe ae
-_ sometimes happens in Nebraska, an excessively hot, dry
season should occur then, as bakers say, under such condi- ;
tions there is an excessive shrink in hread weight, the
Secretary of Agriculture could -immediately, if, necessary,
provide for such condition. Therefore it seems to this
_court that the legislature has thus wisely provided for
“what the ‘courts-have chosen to ‘call an administrative de-
tail, which under the present day broad field of govern-.
ment is necessary. .We therefore conclude that the Act is
not objectionable for that reason.
Plaintiffs attack the law ddaiming that the provision ex-
~empting ‘‘fancy bread’? is so indefinite as to make the law
unintelligible and claim that there is ‘no such term known. .
. among bakers. We think that the term exempting ‘‘fancy
bread”? i is sufficiently definite in that the necessary opinion
or conclusion is that a fair interpretation of the act is that
other than fancy bread or in other words common white
bread does fall-within ‘the law.. This court does not. see
merit in other objections.
* In view of the foregoing conclusions the = finds gen-
- erally against the plaintiffs and in favor of the.defendant,
therefore the plaintiffs’ petition is herewith dismissed and
the restraining order heretofore issued is dissolved. and -
vacated. And in case plaintiffs shall appeal herefrom and .
desire ‘to supersede » this judgment, supersedeas bond is
hereby fixed in the amount of $1,000.00.
Done at Lincoln, Nebraska, January 30, 1932.:
To all of which plaintiffs, except.
| J. H. Broady, Judge.
a
‘[fol. 56]. In District Court OF LANCASTER County »
[Title omitted]
Motion FOR New Trrar—Filed Feb. 2, 1932
Plaintiffs move the court to set aside the decree herein’
and grant a new trial for the following reasons: ==. *,
p That the decrée is not sustained by sufficient evidence,
2. That the decree i is contrary -to law.
: 3. On account of errors of. law occurring at the trial and
aly exeepted to by the plaintiffs.
|
40
4. That the court’s finding that the principal involved in .
the 1921 Nebraska Bread Weight Law (Chapter 2 Laws of
1921) permitted a shrinkage of two ounces per pound is
not. sustained by the evidence. |
5. That*the court’s finding that the Supreme: Court of
the United States held the said 1921 Nebraska Bread
Weight Law unconstitutional upon the grounds that the
tolerance of two ounces permitted therein was not suffi-
[fol. 57} cierit, is not sustained by the evidence.
6. That the court’s finding that the United States Dis-
trict Court for Nebraska is passing upon the constitu-
tionality of Chapter 146 Laws of 1927 held the same un- :
constitutional, but did not disapprove the tolerance pro-.
vision, is.not sustained by the evidence.
7. That the court’s finding that the first rules-and regu-
lations prescribed by the Secretary of Agriculture fixed a -
tolerance of two ounces per pound is not sustained by the
evidence.
‘8. That the court’s finding that the Secretary of Agri--
culture before the trial of this case published new rules is _
not sustained by the evidence.
9. That the court’s finding that the evidence presented
in this cause is purely argumentative, pro and con, as to the
merits of any standard bread weight law, is not. sustained ©
by the evidence. -— .
“10. That the court’s finding that a large proportion of
the bread sold by the Nebraska bakers isgwrapped in wax
paper, is not sustained by the evidence. - ane
11. That the court’s finding that a large proportion of
the ‘bread baked in Nebraska is ‘‘what is called the 20-
ounce*loaves, otherwise known as the Pullman Loaf”, is
not sustained by the evidence. |
12. That’ the court’s finding that said bakers testified
that it is possible to produce a loaf of bread within a frac-
tion of an ounce of the desired weight, is not sustained by
the evidence. :
13. That the court’s finding that, many bakers testified
that ‘they were able to comply with the requirements of the
present bread weight law is not supported by the evidence. -
14. That the court’s finding that under a previous law
bakers complied therewith, ‘‘there being no meepee,
_is contrary to the evidence.
[fol. 58] 15. That the court’s finding that it is possible to
vary the price of a loaf of bread to reflect flictuation of
costs in ingredients, is net sustained by the evidence.
16. That the court’s finding that a two ounce tolerance
can be complied with ‘‘under modern baking conditions’’,
~ even though the Supreme Court of the United States held
differently, is not sustained by the evidence.
17. That the court’s finding that the Secretary of Agri-
culture promulgated any rules whatsoever for the enforce-
ment vf this act, is not sustained by the evidence.
18. That the court’s finding that the Secretary of Agri-
culture has adopted new rules’ fixing an excess tolerance
af three ounces is not sustained by the evidence.
19. That the court’s finding that ‘‘under the evidence i in
this case there can be no question but that such, a tolerance
_as three ounces is sufficient, and that such a tolerance re-
“quirement could readily be complied with by bakers
effected’’, is not sustained by the evidence.
20. That the court’s finding that the delegation of Legis-
lative authority to adopt rules fixing reasonable tolerances
is a delegation of authority to provide an ‘administrative .
. detail’’, is not sustained by the evidence.
21. That the court’s finding that the term “fancy bread” .
is all bread other than common white bread, is not sustained
‘by the evidence. ,
22. That the. court mnt in holding -under the evidence
and under the decision of the United States Supreme Court
in the J. Burns Baking Company versus Bryan that ‘‘the
weight of the evidence as established by the record now
[fol. 59] would be to the effect that even a two ounce tol-
- erance could and in fact had been ae with — the
bakers of this State.
. 23, That the court erred. in deciding this cause upon the
bases of the rules of tolerance adopted by the Deputy Sec-
retary of Agriculture subsequent to the institution of this
. suit, for the reason that plaintiff. was- entitled to havea -
41°"
PEGE ‘
LOTR TRE ALT Menem ter
Oe eRe er
(42 |
determination made upon the invasion of its property rights
as of the time of filing of. suit.
24. That the court erred in deciding the cause upon the
bases of the rules of tolerance adopted by the Deputy Sec-
retary of Agriculture subsequent to the institution of ‘this’.
suit for the réason that the conclusion of the court is with-
out any evidence to support it.
25. That the court erred in holding that ify upon a proper .
trial it is shown: to the court that it were impossible, or
practically so, for bakers to comply with such a law the
court would hold it unreasgnable for the reason that there
i$ no eviderice to’sustain it. . :
26. That the court erred in holding that the experiments
in shrinkage on tolerances introduced by the plaintiffs were.
‘not entitled to consideration on account of the same having
_ been made on regular run of products rather than upon a
specific attempt to comply with the law, for the reason that
the same is contrary to the law and is not sustained by
the ev idence.
27, That: the court erred in holding that it is a Linniain-
tive function to weigh the conflicting evidence as to the
reasonableness of a statute, and that the weight of said
ev idence i is nota function of the court.
28. That the court erred in failing to give _consideration
to the invalidity of the said acts under the 6th Amendment
_to the Constitution of the United States and. the 14th:
Amendment to the Constitution of the United States as
.[fol. 60] presented by paragraphs three, twenty-nine’ and
. thirty of plaintiffs’ petition, paragraphs three, twenty-nine
and thirty of plaintiffs’ amended — and paragraph
three of plaintiffs’ reply. :
29. The court erred generally in finding for: the defend-
ants and against the plaintiffs for the reason that any ex-
cess tolerance is arbitrary and unreasonable and in viola- _
tion of the 14th Amendment of the Constitution of the:
United States, and Article One Section Three, and. Article
One Section Twenty-five of the Constitution of Nebraska.
John C. Grover, mae D. LeMar, Attorneys for
Plaintiffs. 4
[File endorsement amedig
43>
--. ¥e DistTRIcT CouRT oF LaNCASTER County
*
.
[Title omitted]
’ ORDER OvERRULING Motion FOR NEw Pine th 5, 1932 .
This cause now comes on to be heard on the motion of the
plaintiffs to set aside the judment of the court heretofore
[fol. 61] rendered and entered herein, and for a new trial
-of this Gause, and is submitted to the court, on due con-
sideration whereof, the Court doth overrule said motion,
to which plaintiffs except, and plaintiffs are given forty
days from rising of court to serve bill of exceptions.
Supersedeas bond for appeal fixed at $1,000.00.
(Supersedeas bond, appearing in. District Court tran-
script at page 91, omitted. )
[fol. 62] In District Court OF LancasTER CouNnTY
| [Title omitted] _
Notice oF AppeaL—Filed Feb. 9, 1932.
To the defendants above named and to C. A. — and
R. R. Strehlow, attorneys for defendants:
You and each of you, and all persons interested, are
‘hereby notified that the above named plaintiffs intend to ap-
peal the above named case’ to the Supreme Court of the
State of Nebraska.
Jolin C. Grover, Harold. D. LeMar, Attorneys for .
- Plaintiffs.
[File endorsement omitted. ]
[fols. 63 & 64] In SuPREME Court or NEBRASKA
. ARGUMENT AND SuBMIssIon—Jan. 5, 1933
. The following causes were argued by counsel and sub-
mitted to the court:
- * 28356. P. F. Petersen Baking Co. v. Bryan. Appeal,
Lancaster County.
44
[fols. 65 & 66] In Supreme Courr or NEBRASKA
| . No. 28356 :
P. F. Petersen Bakine Co. et al. Appellants,
Vv. a
CHARLES W.: Bryan, as Governor of Nebraska, et al.,
me Appellees.
Appeal from the District Court of ‘Lancaster County
- ‘J upb¢MENT—March 2, 1933 -*
This cause coming on to be heard upon appeal from the
district court of Lancaster county, was argued by counsel
- and submitted to-the court; upon due consideration whereof, °
the — finds no error apparent in the record of the pro-
ceedings and judgment of said district court. It is, there-
. fore, ee ee adjudged that said judgment
of the district court .be, and hereby is, affirmed, and that
. appellees recover of and from appellants their costs herein
* expended, taxed at $—; for all of which execution is hereby
awarded, and that a mandate issue accordingly.
| Charles A. Goss, Chief Justice.
[fol. 67] In Supreme Court or NEBRASKA #
28356
,
P. F. Perersen Baxtne Co.,
Ws
Bryan ‘
Orinion—Filed March 2, 1933
1. The making or selling of. bread is a business subject to
police regulation. |
2. Legislatures, not courts, are primarily the judges of i
necessities, for police regulation and courts can interfere
only when such regulation exceeds a reasonable exercise
of authority. Schmidinger v. City of. Chicago, 226 U. S.
578. a as
45
3. Mere inconvenience to those conducting a business sub-
_’ ject to police regulation does not vitiate the exercise of the
_ power to regulate. ite
4.,An act of the legislature fixing standard weights of
bread loaves and providing for excess tolerances, but. re-—
mitting to the secretary. of agriculture the fixing by regu-
lation of reasonable tolerances, does not amount to a dele-
gation of legislative power.
' 5. “Where one complains that regulations promulgated
under legislative authority by a state board’are nnreason- _
able and oppressive, he should seek relief by applying to
‘that board to modify them.’”? Red ‘‘C’’ Oil Mfg. Co. v.
Board of Agriculture of North Carolina, 22 U. S. 380.
[fol.68] 6. The act to establish a standard loaf of bréad .
(Laws 1931, ch. 162; Comp. St. Supp. 1931, sees. .89-169 to
89-172) authorizing reasonable excess tolérances to be fixed
_ by the state secretary of agriculture, which tolerances were °
established at the rate of three ounces to each pound of the
. respective standard loaves, held not violative of the State
- Constitution or of.the Fourteenth Amendment of the Con-
stitution of the United States, in the respects complained of.
[fol.69] Heard Before Goss, C. J.; Rose, Dean, Good,
‘Eberly, Day, and Paine, JJ. .
Goss, C. J.:
Plaintiffs sued for an injunction to prevent the enforce-—
ment of ‘‘An act to establish a standard loaf‘ of bread’’
and making a violation a misdemeanor. Laws 1931, ch.
162; Comp. St. Supp: 1931, sees. 89-169 to 89-172. . From a
decree rendering a judgment for defendants, plaintiffs ap-
peal. Under the Code of Civil Procedure the appeal is for
trial de novo. Comp. St. 1929, sec. 20-1925.° 7
Section 1 of the act charged the department of agricul-
ture with the- duty. of enforcement and authorized it to
_ promulgate necessary rules and regulations. Sections 2 -
and 3 follow:
“See, 2. Every loaf’ cf bread made for sale in the state
of Nebraska shall be of the following weights avoirdupois:
One-half pound, one pound, one and one-half pounds, and
also in exact multiples of one pound and of no other weights.
46 | ig ee tyke Oe coe ers
Whenever twin or multiple loaves are baked, the weights
herein specified shall apply to each unit of the twin or
multiple loaf, provided that a twin one and one-half pound
loaf may be made and sold, but units of said loaf must not
be sold separately: Provided that none of the provisions
ef this act shall apply to fancy breads. |
‘‘Sec. 3. The secretary of agriculture shall prescribe’
reasonable tolerances or variations in excess, but not under -
the weights mentioned in the preceding section, within which.
all loaves shall be baked, and also the time for which said -
[fol. 70] weights shall be maintained.’’ °
The secretary of the department of agriculture .duly
- promulgated rules and regulations. .He prescribed that
tolerances should not exceed one and one-half ounces for
half-pound loaves, three ounces for pound loaves, four and.
. one-half ounces for oné and one-half pound loaves, six
ounces for two pound loaves and the sante relative tolerance
“for loaves of larger size. The rules provided that bread ©
_ for sale in Nebraska should maintain its required minimum
weight for not less than twelve hours under-normal condi- _
-tions, but that the baker should not: be held responsible for —
the maintenance of the minimum weight after delivery to
a retail dealer or consumer or to a- transportation agency
- in Nebraska for delivery to a-retail dealer or consumer;
. and provided that weights shall be determined by averaging
the weight of not less than five loaves, if available, of a
given lot of bread of the same grade, size and baking.
The act in question repealed an existing law passed in
1921 and amended in 1927. The 1921 law was ‘the subject
of litigation in 1922. It was sustained in the district court
and the judgment of this court affirmed the validity of the.
act. Burns Baking Co. v. McKelvie, 108 Neb. 674. On
error: proceedings the United States Supreme Court, two
members dissenting, reversed the judgment of this court-on
the ground that the tolerance was unreasonable and arbi-
trary and therefore repugnant to the Fourteenth Amend-
ment. Burns Baking Co. v. Bryan, 264 U. S. 504.. That -
court found from the evidence that it was ‘‘impossible to
[fol. 71] manufacture good bread in the regular way with-
out frequently exceeding. the prescribed tolerance and in-
curring the burden of penalties prescribed by the statute.”’
The act of 1921 (Laws of 1921, ch. 2), there considered,
e
47
‘provided for a ‘tlivemee at the rate of. two ownces per
pound, to be maintained at least twenty-four hours after”
‘ baking; averaged by weighing not less than twenty-five
loaves of any one unit. The act of 1931, attacked here, by
its authorized regulations, increased the tolerance to three
ounces per pound, to be iaintained not less than twelve
hours under normal conditions, averaged by weighing not -
less than five loaves. But the regulation relieved the baker
from maintaining the weights after delivery.
We deem it unnecessary to review in detail the testimony
of the numerous witnesses for both parties as to the prac-
ticability of compliance. with the tolerance as now fixed.
It is sufficient ‘to state our conclusions of fact in respect
thereto. Actual tests of regular run of bread baked by the
plaintiffs and purchased from them indicate that the tol- -
erance is ample. The evidence shows that bakers having’
plants‘in many states comply with quite similar provisions |
in laws and ordinances in some of. these states and from
choice pursue the same methods as to weights in the other
states where they do business but where such laws and
regulations do not, exist. We find that the great pre-
ponderance of the evidence shows that’ plaintiffs, and others
~ similarly’ situated for whom they sue, may readily. comply
with the weight and tolerance —— of the ——
[fol. 72] act. :
Plaintiffs argué that’ the title is oat broad onal to.
prohibit weights of bread of certain types’ now baked.
. The’ evidence applicable to this point refers. especially to
a twenty-ounce loaf. We are of the opinion that an act to ©
establish a standard loaf of bread and to prohibit viola-
tions is broad. enough to prohibit other than standard sizes
as fixed by the act. While it might i inconvenience the all
to shorten or lengthen the twenty-ounce. loaf, so as to make
one of legal weight; or to adjust their appliances so as to.
- make prescribed sizes, these are matters generally for con-
_ sideration by the legislature.and not by the court.. The .
making dnd selling: of bread is a business subject to police
regulation. Coprts can interfere only when regulations .
: arbitrarily exceed a reasonable exercise of authority. Mere -
‘inconvenience to those conducting a business subject ‘to
police regulation does not vitiate the exercise of the power.
Schmidinger v. City of Chicago, 226 U. S. 578; Burns Bak-
‘ing Co. v. peinanas 108 Neb. 674.
6...
It is claimed that the act unlawfully delegates legislative.
authority in violation of section 1, art. IE of the Consti-
tution of Nebraska. ‘Such delegation to an administrative
body as took place here is a part of the settled legislative
policy of this state. -Section 71-2302, Comp. St. 1929, places
sanitation and quarantine under the department of public
welfare, authorizes it to adopt and publish reasonable rules
and regulations and provides a penalty for violation of such
rules and regulations. Section 75-201 gives the state 4@Al-
way commission power to late rates and service of
[fol. 73] railroads and all other intrastate common carriers
and, under section 75-218,-a violation of any order is a mis-
demeanor subject to penalty. -Other instances might be ..
”! ited.
_ lations for inspection-and to adopt such standards*of safety .
‘not in.conflict with the’ act as it might deem necessary to
. .The. legislature of North Carolina put oil ‘inspection
under’ the ¢ommissioner of agriculture of that state. It
authorized the board of agriculture to make rules and Fegu-
provide the people of the state with satisfactory illuminat-
ing oil. Section 8 of the act (Public Laws N. Car. 1909, |
ch. 554) made. a violation a misdémeanor. .The supreme
court of the United States held that remitting to the proper
“State board the establishment of rules and regulations to
determine what oils measure up to such standards did ‘not
amount to a delegation of legislative powers. Red ‘‘(”
Oil Mfg. Co. v. Board of Agriculture of North Carolina, 222
U. S. 380, and cases cited on page 394. There the North
Carolina board of agriculture was granted widér authority
than the Nebraska secretary of agriculture was given in the
. present. instance. Neither was granted nor. exercised
‘purely legislative powers. In each instance tthe. authority _
was administrative :in its nature. Its: use by’ the adminis-
_trative department was essential to. the complete and wise
exercise of the powers of the legislative department’ of the
state government. It resulted in constitutional cooperation.
between the legislative arid executive branches...
. [fol. 74]. Plaintiffs assert that the act is indefinite and |
uncertain and alleges several specifications. If these have
not been met by. what we have already said in. deciding that
the act fixed: the standards and the regulations merely for-
warded them, we think what was further decided in Red ~
““C”’ Oil Mfg. Co. v. Board of Agriculture of North Caro- °
. ee
49.
tien: supra, disposes of them: ‘‘Where one complains that
regulations promulgated under legislative authority by a
state board are unreasonable and oppressive, he should
seek relief by applying to that board to modify them.’?
«In/their main brief the plaintiffs say: ‘‘No contention
\ is made that the legislature is unable to fix minimum.
\ weights so long as minimum weights specified are reason- |
- able, and that the law as. passed i is designed to prevent de-.
eeption and fraud upon ‘the public by means of short
- weights.’’ .A-secondary purpose is to prevent unfair com- |
petition by dishonest bakers resulting in injury to the ¢on-
- suming public. Plaintiffs urge that the act is unreasonable
and arbitrary because it prohibits a maximum weight in
each size of standard loaf.. The very provision against per-
‘ mitting excess of more than three ounces to the pound
prevents short weight frauds. Neither the act itself nor the
regulation prescribed by the Secertary of Agriculture re-
‘.quires wrapping, labelling or branding of loaves. Bakers
may make as a pound loaf one perfectly legal but weighing
19 ounces and sell it as a substitute for the present twenty-
ounce loaf which some of the plaintiffs greatly favor. It
_. may or may not deceive the consumer accustomed to a
[fols. 75 & 76] twenty-ounce loaf:. Whether it deceive him. -
-or not, no action will lie because the loaf is within the toler-
~ ance provided by the act. But, if the baker make a loaf’
weighing 1914 ounces, a purchasing consumer may be actu-
ally and legally defr auded by believing it is one of the.
former twenty-ounce loaves. Or an undiscriminating pur-
chaser may even.be deceived into thinking it ‘a’ pound and a
half loaf. “Thus, in a very practical way, it is demonstrated
that the state attempts to prevent short weights by pro-
. hibiting excess tolerance or. variation. That is the plain
— intent of the law. = em :
_ “We. cannot cover in detail other particulars urged by ap- |‘
pellants. We do not find them available to secure a re-
versal of the judgment of the district court. We are of the
opinion that the act and regulations complained of are
not violative of the state Constitution nor of the Four-
teenth Amendment of the Constitution of the United States.
- The judgment.of the district court is
‘Affirmed. er ee
| 4—203
50, o
[fol. 7 7] [File endorsement omitted. ]
hey een — ge
[fol. 78] Ly Supreme Court OF NEBRASKA a
- * [Pitle omitted] |
eae Motion FOR Renearinc—Filed April 7, 4933.
To the ab& Chief’ Justice and Associate Justices of |
the Supre 0 f Nebraska:
Come -noW the appellants in the. above entitled cause and
respectfully move the Court for a rehearing and reconsid- ‘
(fol. 79} eration thereof, because certain issues submitted
. to the Court and decisive of the case have béen overlooked
by the Court, and“because the decision of the Cetrt is in
conflict with the 6th and 14th Amendments to the Constitu-
tion of the United States, and with the.controlling decisions
of the Courts in the following partictlars, to wit: : ,
1. Inthe Nebraska Bread: Weight law and rules and regu-
lations adopted pursuant thereto, the surplus or’ excess tol-’
eranggs are arbitrary, discretionary and void; serve nod
useful purpose; are not nécgssary for the protection of pur-
chasers against imposition and fraud; are not calculated to
effectuate that=purpose, and subject bakers and: sellers of
bread to restrictions which are unreasonable and arbitrary,
afd the said law and rules -and regulations are therefore, - -
a violation of the 14th Amendment to the Constitution of the
United States. Perr ee |
2. The Court in holding that the surplus or excess toler- ©
ance are constitutional and valid is in conflict with the deci-
_ sion of the Suprenie Court of the United States in the case
- of Jay Burns Baking Company vs. Bryan et al., 264 U. S.
504, and contrary to the decisions of the United States’ and
State courts in controlling decisions thereon as follows:
__» . Holsum Baking Company vs. Greene, 45 Fed. (2nd) '
~ 238. Seale is. naa ee ce
P. F. Petersen Baking Co. vs. Weaver et al. (copy of .
opinion attached to appellant’s original brief}. .
State vs. Curran, 220 Ala. 4, 6, 124 So. 909, 912. ° .
.. State vs. Curran, 23 Ala. App. 275, 124 So::911.-
Quaker Baking Co vs. Herring et al. (opinion March
29, 1983, as yet unreported. Copy of relevant part -
as Exhibit ‘‘A’’ hereto). | |
a ~
<
51
[fol. 80] «3. The shiniaiee as fixed by the iene, Secretary
of Agriculture at the time of the institutiqn of this suit and
for months thereafter were one ounce per half. pound loaf,
two ounces per pound loaf and 10 per- cent of all larger.
loaves of bread in excess of the specified minimum weights. ™
- which tolerances were held unconstitutional by the Supreme
Court of the United States in the Burns case.
4. The testimony of. witnesses for both plaintiffs and de-
fendants is that the#olerances fixed are inadequate and im-
passible of performance. !
5. These impossible. tolerances: must. be ee | fot .:
twelve hours after baking. |
6..No provision is made in the law « as to ‘the ‘place of
weighing the bread or the number of laaves to be weighed.
7. The law: attempts to establish a criminal offense but
fails to define the obligations of bakers and sellers of bread
with the degree of certainty required of criminal statutes
i~
j
d
4
and is therefore in violation of the 6th Amendment to the cs
Constitutio#t of the United States.
8. The act ae attemps to =—_ legislative au- :
ie: : thority... ;
9. The act arbitrarily prohibits the manufacture of a
" twenty. ounce loaf of bread which is of gréater demand than _ ,
loaves of any other, weight and that it is impossible to sup,
plant the said twenty ounce loaf of bread. with a nineteen |
- ounce loaf as set forth in the court’s decision without vio- -
lating the excess tolerance provision ‘of the rules’ of the
Deputy Secretary of Agriculture.
10. That the act is a violation of the 6th and 14th aul
ments to the Constitutiom of tke United States.
For the foregoing reasons it is respectfully urged; that ~
‘[fols. 81 & 82] this petition for a rehearing be granted and
that the case be reconsideréd by the Court, |
' Respectfully submitted. +
~ John C.: Grover, Harold D. LeMar, Attorneys for.
| Appellants.
@: a
7 KES Kye
. [fols. 83 & 84] In Supreme Court oF NepRaska
*
52
v
[Title ontitted] gy
Born Denyine REHEaRINc—M 3, 1933
This cause coming on to be ard upon motion.of appel-- — *
lants for a rehearing. herefii, was submitted to the court; —
‘upon due consideratioy whereof, the court finds no probable
error in the judgment: of this court heretofore entered ©
herein. It is, thereforé, considered, ordered and adjudged -
that Said motion for rehearing be, and hereby is, overruled, \
and a rehearing herein is denied. |
Charles A: Goss, Chief J ustice, ; aa
ye
al
[fols. 85 & 86] In Supreme Court or NEBRASKA
_ eo -[Title omitted] | , ‘ ws
ORDER Srayine ManpaTs—May 13, 1933 |
On motion of: appellants for order. withholding mandate
herein, it is by the court ordered that mandate be ordered’ |
withheld pending appeal of this case to United States Su- > ’
preme Court. = xe ee ae
‘ harles A. Goss, Chief Justice. °
SEES
[fol.87]. © Ex, A. @. HLT.
‘In SuPREME Court or THE UNITED States
{Title omitted] _
PETITION For APPEAL, ASSIGNMENT OF Errors, AND PRAYER
For Reversat—Filed June 1, 1933
Petition for Appeal ,
, Considering themselves airgrieved by: the final decision of
the Supreme Court of the State of N ebraska, in the above
entitled cause, the appellants (plaintiffs) therein, P: F.
.
’
f F . .
* . ee Bay eros A tT OR
og a eon rye ih shies (fer HS oe at TENG pat
.
‘4 *
oe |
: q ° 53
hla cise Baking evaiibie: Schulze Baking ‘Cae , Con- —
- ‘tinental Baking Company, General Baking Company,
‘4 Quaker Baki Company, ‘Corporations, for»themselves
' " .and others similarly situated, hereby pray that an appeal
_. he allowed to the Supreme Court of the United States
herein, and for-an order fixing the amount of the appeal
bond thereon; that the amount “of the appeal ‘bond be —
for costs and also for supersedeas:
Assignment of Errors |
a? +
« And the Appellants (Plaintiffs) P. F. Potienein Baking
Company, Schulze Baking Company, Continental Baking
Company, General Baking Company, Quaker Baking Com- -
pany, Corporations for ‘themselves and others similarly -
situated, assign’ the following errors in the record and an
céedings i in the said cause: ©
I Phat the Supreme Court of Nebraska erred in ding
’ and holding that the maximum tolerance over the weights:
‘ fixed by the statute, rules:and regulations adopted there-
[fol. 88] under, did not violate the due process and equal .
protection clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment to the .
Constitution of the United States, and i in holding that said —
maximum tolerance served ‘a useful purpose; .was neces-
sary for the protection of purchasers against imposition
and fraud, was calculated to effectuate that purpose, and .‘
that it did not subject bakers and sellers of bread to re-.
_ strictions which are unreasonable and arbitrary,*and was
\ not an improper exercise of the police power of -the state.
_ 2..That the Supreme Court of Nebraska erred in ‘finding
and holding that the unlimited power to prescribe excess”
tolerarices, “the time for weights must: be maintained, and
to define. ““faney breads’’ vested by the statute in tue Sec-
_Tetary of Agriculture, a ministerial officer, was reasonable
- . and valid, and not contrary to the due p¥otess and equal
prote tion clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment to the
_ Constitution of the United States.«
3. That the Supreme Court of Nebraska erred in finding
ua hoiding that the provisions of the statute and the rules
and regulations adopted thereunder with respect to the
time, place, possession and particular loaves of: bread re-
quired to comply with the statute, the violation of any one—
a
_ are not so vague that men of common intelligéneé must of — .
‘necessity guess at their ‘neaning but.have th definiteness =a
_, the Constitution of tlie United States, .
_ 7 (plaintiffs’) rieht-to do business, violating the due process —
and holding that_the- appellants (plaintiffs) were not en-
ee
<a
of which, irrespective of negligence, under the statute, |
would subject the appellants (plaintiffs) to: a fine, is-rea-
sonable-and valid and not an arbitrary restriction upon
plaintiffs’ right to do, business, and not: in violation of the _
due process and equal protection clauses of the Fourteenth.
‘Amendment to the Constitution of the United States.
4. That the Supreme Court of Nebraska erred’in finding
and: holding that said statute and rules and regulations
‘adopted thereunder. providing tolerances which were. im-
>
. ‘loaves: of bread within this tolerance for an unreasonable ~ |
Jéength of time, was not unreasonable and arbitrary and in
~ the manufacture (but not the sale) of loaves of bread dif-
_ failure of the statute, rules and regulations to define the
~ offense, and are not in violation of the due process and ~
‘valid exercise of the police’ power ‘of the state, anit not _an——— a
. possible of performance, and requiring the maintenance oe
viglation of the due pfocess and equal protection clauses of.
fhe Fourteenth Amendment to the Constitution of the
United States: © ae ise GCL ae =
. 9. That the Supreme Court of Nebraska erred in: finding
and holding that. the t8rm ‘‘fancy breads’” used in the
statute, rules and regulations, which describes no known
commodity, and thé provisions of the statute prohibiting
a.
[fols. 89-101] fering from the Standard weights; and the
crire of manufacturing over-weight bread, are sufficient]
explicit to inform appellants (plaintiffs ) what conditions
will make them liable to the penalties of the statute and
and certainty required es creating a new -
equal protection clauses of the Fourteenth Amendment to
6. That the Supreme Court of Nebraska erred in*finding -
and holding that the statute,‘and the rules afid regulations. °
thereunder prohibiting the 20 ounce loaf of bread.was a
‘arbitrary and- unreasonable -restriction—upon appellants’
and equal protection clauses of the Fourteenth. Amendment a
to the Constitution of the United States. ae
7. That the Supreine Court of Nebraska erred in finding ;"
r) : . ‘f
*
— 59
&
7 titled , to the injunction prayed tor 4 in their petition under
the provisions of: the due process and equal protection.
‘clauses of the Fourteenth acces to the Constitution
of the ian ae States.. :
Prayer for Heversal
For whet errors the Appellants pudaig), 2. F. Peter-
sen Baking Company, Schulze Baking Comipany, Continen-
.. tal Baking Company, General. Baking Company, Quaker
_ Baking Company, Corporations, for themselves and others
similarly situated, pray that said judgment and decree of
} the Supreme Court of the State of Nebraska dated March
* _ 2,'1933 in the above entitled cause be reversed and a judg--
ment be réndered in favor of said ai daa a oreel
r and for costs.
+P. F. Petersen’ ‘Baking. Company, itinlce: Baking
_ *Company,. Continental Baking Compariy, General
“ Baking Company, Quaker Baking Company, Cor-
. . porations, for Themselyes' and Others Similarly.
‘3. . Situated, by John C. Grover,-Harold D. _LeMar,
F Counsel for Appellants (Plaintiffs).. |
[File endorsement omitted.]
[fols. 102-106] Ex. C. G.° i. .. Lae
In SUPREME Court oF THE’ Usama & Srazes, OctosER ‘Term,
ee area iE 1933
t.
No. —
P. F. Petersen Baxine Company, Scuuuze Baxine Com-
pany, Continental Baking Company, General Baking |
Company, Quaker Baking Company, Corporations, for
- Themselves and Others |. Similarly Situated, Appellants :
( Plaiatiffs), 6 .
: ne
——— v. 4
———
ee ee one
Cerantan W. Bryan, as , Guveiaor of the State of. Nebraska,
' and Dwight F. Feiton, as Deputy Secretary of the De-’- -
partment of Agriculture of the State, of Nebraska, Ap-
pellees (Defendants)\ |
Geet ALLow1ne AprgaL—Filed J ‘une <i 1933 sd
_» he Appellants (Plaintiffs) in the above entitled wei.
and each of them, having prayed for the allowance of an .
2c . ¥ mo .
; ar ‘ : ‘ ® 9
—_— “ee *
one a se baw ' é - .
ogy ts ill 4 . ate . . ° A :
. 4 4
.
——
eid
ee
Rohe . (2
appeal in this cause to the Supremé Court of the:United |
_ Statds frorti the judgment and decreé made and entered in
‘the above entitled suit by the Supreme Court of the State
of Nebraska.on the 2nd day of March, 1933, and from Bach «.
_and every part thereof, and having presented and filed
their petition for. appeal, assignment of errorsyand prayer
eo. 4 for reversal, and. statement as to jurisdiction. on appeal,.
“ * " purstant’ to the statutes and the rules of the Supreme
Court of the United States in such case made and provided .
_/ It is nowhere ordered that an appeal be,.and the same .
: “is hereby, allowed to the Supreme Court of the United .
_. States from the Supreme Court of the State of Nebraska in |
® ’.. . this cause,.as provided by law, and it is further ordered” cate
that the Clerk of the Supreme Court vf Nebraska shall -
_ prepate and certify a transcript of the record, proceedings, ~
judgment and decree in this: cause and transmit the same
to the Supreme Court, of the United States, so that lie shall _
. have the same in said Court-within forty days of this date.
. And it is further ordered that ‘security for costs on
appeal be ‘fixed ‘in the sum of One ‘Thousand : Dollars
=. ($1,000.00), and that bond be given therefor, and that’ said
q -. .bond when approved and filed shall serve-as a Supersedeas.
Charles A. Goss, Chief' Justice of the Supreme Court -
of the State of Nebraska. a : pinst
=. Dated June 1st, 1933.
| -\[File ‘eridorsement mmitiagY
ok PRE esi:
[fols. 107-110] Supersedeas bon
approved and filed June 1, 1933,
. 5 = oe] ‘
d on appeal for $1,000.00,
omitted in printing, ©”
[fals. 111-116] Citation in usual form, showing service on .
‘Charles W.. Bryan, and Dwight F. Felton, filed June 15,
1933, omitted in -printing. 8 ar eae
[fol 117] Ex F- @. LT. |
i Supreme Courr or THE Unrrep States _ | :
awe [Title-omitted] ieee
; ’ STIPULATION Concerning, Bru oF Excerrions—Fjled J une
. Ce ae 1, 1933
It is stipulated by and between th
: e parties hereto,
through their respective counsel, that th
e following consti-
a
—
7 ben the bill of exceptions caidas all the evidence ey
‘that is necessary ‘to present clearly the queStians of law in- ~~"
volved in the rulings to which ‘exceptions are reserved, all
: as required by, Rule 8 of the Rules of the- ‘Supreme Court.
'. of the United States.
~ *. John C. Grover, Harold D. ‘LeMar, "Counacl for: “Ap-
pellants. Paul F.. Good, Attorney General, by.
Geo. W. Ayres;Assistant Attorney General, Coun-
sel for. ia weenie | | |
gee ; a ae
gee 6 . . * . ° . +
Pee ee e
[fols. 118 & 119] Ly Supreme Court OF THE Unitep States
a. [Title omitted]
" Onpiin Serriing, Bit or Excerrions—Filed ‘June 1, 1933 ;
State, OF NEBRASKA, $s:
‘The attached. bill of exceptions consisting of Volume &
pages 1.to 407, inclusive, is allowed as such. and i is ordered
- made a part of the record herein. —
Charles A.-Goss, Chief. J ustice of the Supreme Court:
of Nebraska... ; i
“, : ?
A
/ \File ideale oinitied.]
4 -. . [fol 120] : . BX. GG GH. T. |
"In Supreme Court or tHE Unirep States —
[Title omitted).
Pascns FOR TRANSCRIPT OF Recorp—Filed J une 1, 1933
‘To the Wcnornlde George Turner, Clerk of the Supreme Aa
. ‘Court of the State of Nebraska: \ ae
~.. In the certified transcript of the record in the above én-
titled cause to be made and transmitted ‘to the Supreme
Court of the United States pursuant to ati order allowing
& —* ‘dated. June Ast, 1933, — by the Honorable
a
‘ Oiatlin A “Goss, ° Chief siialti of the a eme Cis of
_ Nebratka, kindly incorporate the:following:
1, Record entry of ‘ling of. original petition.
Temporary restraining order. is ban age ee
Bond on temporary restraining order. . & 7
Record entry of notice of filing amended petition. _
Amended petition.
Exhibit ‘‘A”’ attached to amended petition.
Exhibit ‘‘B’’ attached to amended —.
Answer filed by defendants.
9. Exhibit ‘A’ attached to answer.
ae 10. Reply filed by plaintiffs.
bee 11. Bill of exceptions and stipulation, and order,
os ' 12. Decree of" ‘District Court of Lancaster County, °
* - Nebraska. 2 : hoor
13. Motion for new trial. ae ies
14. Order denying new trial. ) oe —<o
15: Record entry showing filing of Preci -in District,
-Court. oa aie
_ 16, Record entry showing filin
: Supreme Court of Nebraska.
» [fols. 121-133} ‘Opini inion. of Supreme Conrt of Ne:
braska.
Ersunre nny
ra) hotics of appeal ‘to |
Decree of the Seivesite Suast of ebenitin on sive: ,
| ' 19. Record entry of filing of motion for stay of mandate. :
— . 20. Motion for rehearin ;
- . 21. Record egtry of order staying rhandate.
22. Order overruling motion for rehearing,
23. Petition for appeal to the United: States Supreme
Court, Assignment of Errors, and: Prayer for Reversal. —
24. Appellants’ Statement as to jurisdiction on appeal,
parsuant to Rule 12 of the Supreme Court of the United ~-
States. —.
25. Order allowing appeal to the United States Supreme’
‘Court.
26. Supersedeas Bond on appeal and approval thereof.
27. Citation with return thereon.
28. This precipe. Kd ey Bas
29. All journal entries in their proper order. aa eae a) hee
Py ’
-P. F. Petersen Baking Company, Schulze’ Baking
Company, Continental’ Baking Company, Géneral
Baking Company, ‘Quaker Baking: Company, by .
. John C: Grover, Harold D, LeMar, rape ‘for
F - Appellants i tcacoa :
has = “a Woe ‘ ~ . 59
_ Received: ‘copy of ‘the foregoing Pracipe this Ist day of |
' June, 1933. my
Paiil F. Go, Attorney General ; .. Gen. W:. Avion, Ss
Assistan veniar’gs “Does Counsel for —
”
‘[File ce sean omitted. 4
[fol. 134] ‘Clerk’ s certificate to eeatavine transeript omit- .
ted in printing. )
a fols. 25) Be it remenibeved that on June 21, 1933, there
- was filed in the office of the Clerk of said Supreme Court of’:
Nebraska a bill of ¢xceptions reduced to narrative form —
‘from the original bill of exceptions. filed in said office ort
_Mareh 30, 1932, stipulatedAo be the bill of exceptions em-*
bodying all the. evidence that is necessary to:present clearly
the questions of law to which exceptions are;reserved as -
required by. the rules of.the Suggfeme Court’ of the United
‘States, and so allowed and ord d by the Supreme Court
of Nebraska, which bill of esceptons | is in the words. and
figures following, . to wit: nae :
3
“fol. 6] In Disrarcr Count OF Lawcasren, County, Mi EBRASKA
to eo a :
P. F, PETERSON ‘aise. ComPany, "Scitutze Barixe Com- -
pany, ‘Continental Baking. Company, General Baking |
. Company, Quaker Baking. Company, Corporations, for ;
_ Themselves and Others Similarly Situated, _——
Sy °
a .
CHarLEs W. Bryax, Gevernor of. the State of Nebraska, |
and Dwight F. Felton; eputy fiecretary of the De-
partment of. Agriculture: ‘tor the State of — :
_ Defendants -
rae is a Exceptions—Filed Sune 21, 1933 °
‘APPEARANCES "a
penn J ohn. ©. Grover. and Harold D: LeMar- appear-
ing as attorneys for plaintiffs and Messrs. C. A. Sorenson,”
’
.
. ‘ . aw ° .
. ‘ : e , P
: . ‘ \ ° : a? ° ets ®
* & t ; Tie .
, . . - a a | rm
Dips Nes > - ak Te ta ee thet sate ' , 2 » y alia Ain Satara i iia
. n ° ¥ » ° . - ie
; . 5
; o
‘
’
rine sd. irs...
~ |
~
| 60 | : ‘ , ; ° ss
Attorney General..of the State of Nebraska, and, RR.
Strehlow appearing as attorneys for detendants.. ae
Lincoln, Nebraska, Mar. 22, 1932.” IX,
Received of the attorneys for the plaintiffs, for examina-
_ tion and amendmenrff; the within draft of a‘ Bill of Excep-
tions. : eee , ae
i C. A. Sorensen; Attorneys for Defendants. |
~ Lincoln, Nebraska, Mar. 22, 1932.
_. We herewith return the withwin. Bill of Exceptions, here- — -
_ tofore subraitted for examination and amendment, and |
propose: no amendments. thereto. as: : nM
rs C. A. Sorensen, Attorneysxfor Defendants.
*. [fol.7] ‘, . * Qaprion” ae ace. 4
'. Beit ren&mbered that at the September, 1931, Term of .
. the Distric’ Court of Lancaster County, Nebraska, to-wit:
November 24, 1931, that being. one of the days of said term,
- the cause of P. F.. Petersen Baking Company et al., Plain-
' tiffs, vs. Charles W. Bryan, Governor of the State. of
- Nebraska, et al., Defendants,.came qn for hearing before
Honorable J. H. Proady, one of. the Judges of said court,
and the plaintiffs and the defendants each to“maintain the
issues on their respective parts, adduced testimony and
* offered evidence, and all of said evidence and testimony, all
of the. objections thereto, with the grounds therefor; all of
the rulings. of the court on such objections, together with
all of: the exceptions to such rulings made and taken at the
time having been by the plaintiffs herein reduced to writ-
ing in this their Bill of Exceptions, and said plaintiffs. hav-
ing served the same upon the ‘Attorneys for the defend-
ants for examination and amendment, as required by’ law,
said plaintiffs now pray the court before whom said cause
_ Was tried that said Bill of Exceptions ‘may be now settled,
allowed, sealed and.made'a part Of the record in said cause’
in said court. |
- [fol.8] Mr. Le: Mar:. Plaintiffs offer in evidence the fol.
lowing evidence presented at the trial in the District Court
of Lancaster. County, Nebraska, of the cause wherein the
hed 7
Hay Burns Baking ‘Company, et al., were plaintiffs, and
Charles W. Bryan as “Governor. of Nebraska, et al., were
defendants, and Which suit ‘involved the constitutionality
of the 1921 Nébraska Bread Weight Law, which reads as
. follows: ee ae oie anole
(Mr. LeMar here reads from the-depositions -filed herein
on ‘October 20, 1931, beginning’ at page 7 thereof, being
\. page 33 of this Bill of Exceptions.) Pe
- The testimony of Dr. Harry Snyder beginning on page
9 of said depositions (page 35 of this Bill of Exceptions) -
- was read to the court by Mr. LeMar for the plaintiffs.
Mr. Lé Mar: ‘I want particularly to cali the court’s at- ~
tention to the Exhibit on page 88. ee
Recess. , j
» 3 SrirpuLaTion as TO CerTaIn Facts
It is stipulated and agreed that the rules and regulations
alleged in-the petition, as issued by the Deputy. Secretary
of Agriculture, were in force and effect and the rules and
regulations at the time of the filing of the petition. .
It is stipulated and agreed by and between the parties
that, the rules arid regulations set out inthe answer of the
- defendants were adopted September 19, 1931, by the.De- .
- ° [fol.9]- partment of Agriculture under the authority of
House Roll No. 51, subject.to the objection to the right of °
the Department: of. Agriculture to adopt these rules and
regulations when an injunction is pending against them.
Pon, A temporary restraining order was issued. And subject
to the usual objection to such adoption. ar
Orrers in EvipeNce
Mr. Le Mar: Plaintiffs offer in evidence the entire rec-
ord of evidence on behalf of plaintiffs and defendants by
stipulation heretofore filed in this court under date of Oc-
tober 20, 1931. (Mr. LeMar continues reading such testi- —
mony to the court.) = = -- ie eer?
It 1fow being 12:00 o’clock noon, ‘the court took an ad-
jouryment until 2:00 o’clock P.M. the same day.
. a
7 Q a e / ' i
"62
2: :00 o'clock P. M. Vein’ 24, 1931.
One met pursuant to adjournment and oe —
proceedings were had and done, to-wit : : 7
(Reading of testimony filed i in this court on October 20th,
1931, was cgptinued by Mr. Le Mar.)
Mr. Le Mar: The next testimony is my own. I was not
} acting as attorney at that time. I think it should be dis-
. wegarded under the circumstances. And that completes
the testimony on the-part of plaintiffs taken under the 1921
and 1927 Laws. *
Plaintiffs rest.
LS ees DEFENDANT’s Case
Mr. Strehlow: Beginning with page 158 of the testimony
ea filed in this court on October 20, 1931, defendants offer in
evidence the testimony of William F. Cluett and of all wit-
nesses appearing In said transcript thereafter.
Said testimony, beginning at 158 of said transcript (page
184 of fhis Bill of Exceptions) and continuing until the
end of same, was read in evidence by Mr. Strehlow.
[fols. 11 &12] - November 25, 1931, 9:00 o ‘clock. AM.
Court met pursuant to adjournment and the following
proceedings were had and done, to-wit :
“Mr. Lé Mar: Plaintiffs offer in evidence the depositions
taken on. behalf of plaintiffs on the 22nd day of September, ©
1931, in Omaha, Nebraska. Said depositions being a part —
_of the record of evidence filed i in this court i in n this case on
October 20, 1931.
(Said Dencatiions | are read to the court “a Mr. Le Mar.
(Said depositions are found at pages 349-533 of ae Bill
of Exceptions. ) ;
Plaintiffs rest.
Defendants rest.
_ Testimony closed.
- [fol. 13] Ix District Court orLaNCasTER County
[Title omitted].
- STIPULATION a8 TO CERTaty ‘Evience
. f
It is stipplated and agreed by and between the parties
- to the above entitled suit, through their respective attor-—
neys, that the gvidence in the case of Jay Burns Baking
Company, et all _plaintiffs, vs. Charles: W. Bryan as Gov-
ernor of the State of Nebraska; ‘et al.,defendants, from the
transcript of record, case number 94 in the October term
of the Supreme Court of the United States, and the evi-
dence in the case of P. F. Petersen Baking Company, et al., ,
plaintiffs, vs. Arthur J. Weaver as Governor of the State
of Nebraska, et al., defendants, Equity Docket 261, Federal —
District Court of Nebraska, Lincoln Division, as contained
in this transcript, as well as the depositions taken.in this _
case, may be received in evidence in the vase at bar, subject
[fol. 14] to objection at the trial as to relevancy and ma-
teriality of the evidence offered, it being ‘ particularly
agreed that the weight of the evidence taken in the two
previous. cases is to be considered in connection with the’
particular, statute and*the time when given as to its appli-
eability to the case at bar. ~ 2 ae -
John-C. Grover, H.-D. Le:Mar, Attorneys for Plain-
tiffs. C. A. Sorensen, per R. R. S., Attorney Gen-
eral, ‘State of Nebraska; R. R. Strehlow, Special
Assistant Attorney Genetal, Attorneys for De-
fendants. . ’ ae
[fol. 15] Evipence PRESENTED IN THE-CASE OF Jay Burws
_ Baxine OpMPany ET AL. vs. CHARLES W. Bryan, as Gov-
- ERNOR OF THE STaTE OF NEBRASEA, ET AL. :
The following evidence was presented at the trial in the
District Court of Lancaster County, Nébraska, of the cause
wherein the Jay Burns Baking Company, et al., were Plain-
tiffs and Charles W. Bryan as Governor of Nebraska, et al., —
were Defendants, and which suit involved the constitution-
ality of the 1921 Nebraska Bread Weight Law which was
as follows: — * |
64
_ “See. 7612. Departinent of Agriculture to Enforce.—It
shall be the duty of the. department of agriculture to en-
force all provisions of this ‘act.. It shall make or cause to
_be made all necessary examinations and shall have author-
-ity to promulgate such rules and regulations as are neces- __
sary to promptly and ‘effectively enforce the provisions of
this act.”’
_ “See. 7613. Bread, Standards of Weight.—Every loaf of ©
bread ntade or procured for the purpose of sale, sold, ex-
posed or offered for sale in the State of Nebraska shall be
the: following weights’ avoirdupois, one-half pound, one
pound, one and one-half pounds, and also in exact multi-
ples of one pound and of no other weights. Every loaf of
bread shall be made of pure flour. and wholesome ingredi-
[fol. 16] ents and shall be free from any injurious or dele-
terious substance. Whenever twin or multiple loaves dre
baked, the weights herein specified shall apply to each unit ~
of the twin or multiple loaf.’’ -
‘Sec. 7614. Tolerance, How Determined—A tolerance at
the rate ‘of two ounces per pound in excess of the standard
weights herein fixed shall be allowed and no more,. pro-.
» vided, that the ‘standard weights herein prescribed shall
be determined by averaging. the weight of not less than.
twenty-five loaves of any one unit and such average
shall not be less than the minimum nor more than the maxi-
' mum prescribed by this act. All weights shall be deter- . —
' mined on the premises where bread is manufactured: or.
_baked and shall apply for a period of at least twenty-four
hours after baking: Provided, that bread shipped into this
state shall he weighed where sold or exposed for sale.”?*
“Sec, 7615: Penalties for Violation.—Any person, firm.
or corporation violating any of the provisions of this act,
shall be punished by a fine of not less than ten dollars nor’
more than one hundred dollars or by imprisonment in the -
county jail for not more than thirty days: Provided, how-
ever, that upon-the second and all subsequent convictions
for the violation of any of the provisions of this act such
offender shall be punished by a fine of not less than fifty
[fol. 17] dollars nor more than one hundred dollars, or by
imprisonment in the county jail for not moré than ninety
days.’” i
-
a
my)
Dr. Harry Cuvee, a witness. in alae of the plaintiffs,
testified as follows: =
i am chemist for the Bussett- Miller Milling Company, —
_ Minneapolis and have been for thirteen years or more. My
work for the past thirty-two years ‘has been in connection °
gith bread flour ana food nutrition. During that time I
carried on experiments to ascertain the digestibility and.
nutritive value of different kinds of bread for the United
States: Department of Agriculture Where I am now we
have a well equipped laboratory and experimental bakery,
run much the same as a commercial. .bakery.
I am familiar with the constituents of bread and its
method of baking. Flour owes its bread-making charac-
teristics to gluten, which is the body, or substance resulting |
from the mixture of flour with water, forming dough. » ‘No
other cereal than wheat contains such material in quantity
as wheat: flour, In bread making water is necessary, the
amount being governed by the kind of flour used. * In the |
. low gluten flour a minimum of water is reqnired and in
~ the high gluten flour more water is required. Gluten is
the: material which gives the bread-making value and is:
[fol.18] included in the term protein. So flours which
have the largest amount of gluten make the best bread or.
that which has the highest food value. Low gluten. flours
are of the starchy kind and have a much la lower. food'value-——~ J
_The weight of a loaf of bread depends in large degree upon
the character of the ingredients used. The more water
there is in dough, the greater the, evaporation, and the ©
greater the variation in weight between the dough and the
finished product. In making bread from a high gluten
- flour, the. baker must use about 60% of water in mixing
the dough. The baker does not know of the. moisture con--
tent in flour as it varies with quality and aera in the g
place where the flour. is kept.
Low gluten flour, or low quality flour, does not take the
high absorption of water and a poorer quality of bread re- «
sults thari from the high gluten.or better grades of flour.
The best flour requires more water than. the poorer onsen
of flour. — —-
By 60% of water I mean 60 pounds of water to the 100
-- pounds of flour in the dough. - In baking bread there is a
. § 203
es 66
; es of uncontrollable elements. On account: of the gas
~° and moisture’in the dough, the baker cannot weigh the wet
mass of dough with accuracy to insure a loaf of bread of a °
. given weight; and:no two pieces of dough are exactly alike
. ‘owing to the errors arising in handling it, evaporation. of -
moisture and gas. Flour making has been practically the
. [fol’ 19]: same since about 1880. - aie a
- . Other factors entering. into the evaporation from a loaf.
‘2. - of bread are the size and shape of the loaf, the duration of +
" _ the baking, and the temperature of the oven. The acnnion es
the better grades of. flour used in making the best bread
hold a greater proportion of water than the lower. grades..
Wheat flour is in a class by. itself and so bread is unique.
It comprises 50% oi .he family dietary. | .
ly thus necessarily follows and is.a fact that the best
» bread, that is, bread made from the best flour, contains more |
_*. moisture when it is baked than does -bygad baked from a
poor quality of flour, and hence’ the bod quality of bread °
will have more moisture evaporated from it than will the :
_ poorer quality of bread as the latter, has léss moisture to .
start with. The best #ad will: dry out more and faster .
_ than the’ poorer quality ‘of bread. ‘After a loaf of bréad Pe
__ is baked it is only the water which is evaporated which thus ~ Fd
— . makes a change in ‘the weight of the loaf, but there is no |
~ \ difference in the food value of the loaf. It is the same
food value after evaporation as ‘it was before the evapora- °
tion. The only difference in weight is the moisture content
of the loaf, and a loaf of bread weighing only 15% ounces ‘is
_ of the same nutritive value as when it weighed 19 ounces.
_ Bread made from a poor er starehy flour has less protein -
_[fol. 20] in it:than is’ contained in good bread made from.”
good flour, and thus in the consumption of the poorer
- _ quality of bread, some other food, such as eggs or meat
having high protein content must be used to obtain a suffi-
cient amount of protein. In fact‘a loaf of bread ‘of low
protein content would require an egg or an egg and a half
to raise it to the leyel of protein content in the loaf made
~ from good flour or-flour of high gluten. content, and which
_ has the-greater quantity of moisture in it. In other words,
. the poor- quality of bread will not furnish the requisite’
amount of nutritive material and so must be supplemented.
with more expensive food, and besides the poorer quality ©
of bread is less appetizing, and the family using the poorer —
‘ e-
.
67
7 Of
quality of bread thus eats less bread than would otherwise |
be consumed, and in turn eats more of other and more ex-
pensive food materials, and thus the cost of living is in-
‘ereased because of the low consumption of a poor quality
“of bread. The other and more expensive foods are neces-
sary to obtain the necessary quantity of. protein in order
to have a well balanced ratiqn. The consumer must get the
“necessary quantity of protein, and if he does: not'get.it from
bread he must get it from’other and more expensive foods. —
A good quality of bread supplies more than any other food, |
the best quality nutrients and at less expense. oe ;
Wheat varies from year to year in its gluten arg ra
‘owing. to soil and climatic conditions, and this fact S
-[fol. 21] recognized by the. millers” in buying wheat from
different: parts of the country. ‘Seite
— * ‘The deakad today is for the best quality of bread, that
: ‘\ “is; bread made from high gluten flour, and the public jis -
* right, because such bread is more digestible than the poorer
| quality. Poor bread does not arouse the digestive organs
/ and so is not digested without ‘additional expenditure of
energy in the body, and so poor breads are not digested
with the full degree of ease, comfort and satisfaction as
are breads made from the best flour. In other words, poor
bread is a greater tax on the human system in its consump-
tion than is good bread. See Ceca ee
In the experiments which I made it was found that a
loaf of bread weighing. 18 ounces when it came from the
oven would lose in moisture content about 2 1/5 ounces.
_ That was the average. Many of the loaves exceed that.
° From the experiments made and the results obtained it’
~ is-not possible for a baker to make bread at all times and.
under all climatic conditions and have a loaf of bread which © .
will weigh just out af the oven not to exceed 18 ounces and
which im. the 24 hour period following will not lose more,
than two ounces. : ‘That might be done on. certain days, .but
there are days when it is absolutely impossible to make
bread to conform to both the-maximum arid the minimum
weight during the 24 hour period after baking. The two.
[fol. 22] controlling factors are temperature and humidity
and these vary.from day to day‘in different parts of the
country. On some days the humidity approaches satura-
tion, which means 80% ‘or 90%, and then on hot, dry days,
the nature of bread is such that it will dry out more than
a . a .
: . a
; E . :
m . =
. 6
a AER RAVI ENN E IOC ELEM EIEN, MIO 8 SPREE AREY ELIOT ELE LE ESET TIS
bd
+ eee
is co eae
two ounces to the pound’ within 24 hours after baking. The
conditions of humidity and temperature. change during the
day so that the baker starting to make bread and’ not know-
‘ing definitely -his oven conditions, who puts in enough
deugh to have a legal loaf at the end of the 24 hour period a
may have a loaf coming.out of the oven in excéss of the
maximum weight, because the loaf in baking has not lost: ”
as mucN moisture as was anticipated. There is no nu-.
_ tritive value in what is lost, namely: the moisture.
In the course of a few hours’ the loaf might soon become
_a legal loaf not exceeding 18 ounces in weight, but before
‘the close of the 24 hour period, on account of the evapora-
tion of the moisture, the loaf might then bécome illégal: by
being under weight, that is, the pound loaf may weigh less.
than 16 ounces, although the: baker used every effort to
. Make the loaf legal. The law under consideration makes.
a criminal of a-baker for deviations in weight which. are -
- absolutely beyond the baker’s control.
What I have said applies to 25 loaves as-well as to one ;
loaf, anc *>e average of the 25 would be just about the ¥
[fol..23] same as the weight of the one loaf. and that might
_ bestrue of any number of loaves passing through the same
conditions of temperature‘and humidity. The tendency of
the loaves is to. become equalized as they give off the mois-
ture, and the surrounding atmosphere takes it up after |
the loaves: leave the oven. .. aa
In the. United States Food Law it. is provided ‘in the
regulations that discrepancies in weight or measure; due -
_. exclusively to differences in atmospheric conditions in vari-
- ous places and which unavoidably result from the ordinary
and customary exposure of the packages to evaporation or *
to the absorption of. water, shall not be.considered, but are
allowable tolerations and are not, a violation of the law;
that is to say, if a loaf of bread is a legal loaf when-it
leaves the oven, it makes no difference under the Federal:
Law, how many. ounces it loses in weight after that time,
-because climatic conditions are beyond the ‘control .of the .
baker. In the law,. bread as such is not specified, but the
law:applies.to all food-stuffs. %
The present tendency is to improve the quality of farm '
products, and if a law is such as to discourage the use >
of the best article such as wheat, then that article has a
- more limited market. -So a law.that would discriminate
‘ . \-
- 69
against the. production and use of the best flour would dis-
courage the production of the best wheat, and the farmer .
{fol. 24] would have more encouragement to. raise a poorer |
‘quality of grain.. The baker would come nearer to com- =
plying with the law by making bread ‘from poor flour: of
low absorption, but. even with such flour there would come
days and times when even bread made from such would
-not comply with the law. I can see no way by which the ‘
baker can comply with the law having both a minimum
_- and a maximum weight by ‘the use of either poor flour:or.—
the best flour, though everything will be done on his part
’ naturally to lessen variation in weight in the 24 hour period
_after baking. But I know of no way that would be suc- |
: eessful in making a loaf of bread that would at all times’.
and. under all conditions. comply with the maximum and
. ° minimum weight law. ets : : = ,
“The reason why the bakers will usé the poorer qualities
of flour is because there is less moisture therein conse-
. quently less evaporation from the bread after itws baked.
The poorer flours nia@ke bread which has a less evaporation
- of moisture in a given time than better flours. In my ex-
eriments, made inJuly and August, the loayes were
weighed as soon as cool enough and were-again weighed at
‘- the end of the 24 hour period. The expe iments were made
under normal conditions and as near “as possible to the
actual conditions of handling bread that exist in the bakery
* [fol. 25] and the store. We usually made 25 loaves or'so
Gxt egch batch, making duplicate tests and the average
we@ébts were determined by weighing the 25 loaves. We
used the tests the strong gluten, or high absorption: flour
such as is‘ utd in bread making, that being the best quality
of flour, and which is always higher in price, of course, *
than the poorer qualities. The high gluten flour commands ~
a better price, and the price paid depends upon the abun-. ..
dance, or otherwise, of the best quality of wheat. There is
a difference at times of \$1.00 a barrel between the best
wheat flour and the poorer grade or starchy. flour, so that
the baker of the poorer quality of bread makes a.greater
profit if the bread be sold at the same price. The public
_ demand is for the best bread because it is moist and is ©
-more satisfying than the poorer bread. As said by Dr’
- Taylor, chief, advisor to Mr. Hoover during the war:
“Ifa bread does not look like good bread, keep like good |
bread, or taste like good bread, and in addition does not
aa Bala aes ak ll niall PLES a MELEE, NEPEAN IE . - Ri ete BRP EE REECE ORS SRNR SEL TES NER I COLI
a how ee aoe |
ee (with the consumer) as does good bread, the senti-
_ ment of the: pore turns against ~~. ; :
—« 70
Dr. Taylor is a recognizéd sathority on bread and was
a government expert during the war. .
'.* The trade generally, beth millers
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.