Opposition Brief — New York, NH & HR Co. v. Bezue

Supreme Court brief1932

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

FILE COPY

‘SUPREME COURT OF THE

UNITED STATES |

OCTOBER TERM—1931:

c —_

No. 263.

&

er °s

' _ NEW YORK, NEW HAVEN AND HARTFORD

RAILROAD COMPANY,

~ é | Petitioner,

vs. oe

CLARENCE BEZUE. —

| ?

La

BRIEF IN OPPOSITION TO PETITION

FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI.

Tuomas J. O’Neitx, fone

Attorney for Plaintiff-Respondent.

.

a J. O’Net,

CuaRLEs D. Lewis,

Of Counsel.

red

* - CHARLES WaTsON RUSSELL, Printer

_ SUBJECT INDEX.

em

a 2 PAGE

Brief in Opposition to Petition for Writ of Cer-

tioraTi ... ee eee rece eects siesePeuseunes 1-13

1—The Opinions of the. Courts Below ..... oe

Jurisdiction ...... CO ea

I11.—Statement a i Ce ealaeceeniacsd «oe

IV.—Specifications a Wea on ies ‘ 4-5 -

V.—Argument ee ne ete eer 5

A. The evidence established that the plain- |

tiff below was engaged in interstate com- —

merce as matter of law because the es- 5

sential faets of his general employment ji

at the time of his injury are undisputed

and indisputable: ........--- nines —_ 5

B. He was an unskilled laborer, plant serv-- |

ice employee, at défendant’s. mainten-

ance roundhouse, engaged in his general |

unassigned work so closely related to in-

terstate commerce as to be a part of it 4)

C. He was engaged in aiding to maintain in

efficient condition as part of his general

maintenance and plant service, for effec-

tive use, a-locomotive used exclusively in

interstate commerce while it.was under-

going a statutory boiler wash and in-

cidental maintenance repairs ........-- 5-6

~

ii ane INDEX.

PAGE

D. He was engaged in aiding to maintain in,

efficient condition for effective service in

interstate commerce a locomotive which

in this particular case was an instrn-

mentality .of interstate commerce not

withdrawn.from such commerce ...... oe

Conclusion ..:...-5+.+eeeeeeeeeee: pace nee a ee

TABLE OF CASES CITED.

Atkins v. Payne, 109 Ka. 477, certiorari denied,

257 U. S. 658 :e ded oe eK RED MOSES Fae SEP ORES ae

pL. & W. R. R: Co. v. Yourkonis, 220. Fed, 429,

page 433,; writ of error ee 238 U. S.

OR rere ere reer ere 4,5, 12

_ + Erie R. RB. Co. v. Collins, 253 = & : eres . 5,8

‘Erie R. BR. Co. v. Szary, 253 U. 8S. 86 ...:...... 5,8

Erie R. R. Co. v. Welsh, 242 U. S. 303 ........ 13

Krie R. R. Co. v. Winfield, 244 U.S. 170 ...... 8

Flack v. D. L. & W. R. R. Lo., 45 Fed. (2) 683,

— certiorari enied seeees greeted , ee

{ Hiser v. Davis, 234 N. Y. 300 Leheateeenrersens 5,9

Tlonardo v. Erie -R: R. Co., 103 N. J. L. 4 a 5,8

_ Knéwles v. N. Y.; ;N. H.& H.R. R. Co, 223 N. ¥. ;

a Snr nar rrrr rs rere s Cn ee 9 .

Lusk v. Bandy, -76 Okla. 108; 184 Pac. 144 .:.. 610 .

Matter of Guida, 183 N. Y. App: Div. 822 wai

ODA Ny Y. 712 ..cccecccccccccssessnceters "5,9

Minneapolis & St. Louis R. R. Co. v. Winters,

242: ‘U. S. 353 ...... biwsueee eer Or eT il

~

lil

a

“~

a

a.

wy. C. BR. RB. Co..v. Carr, 238 U. ae... “9,12

NY.C. R. R. Co. v. Marcone, 281 US. 345 .... 5,8

N. Y. C. R. R..Co. v. Porter, 249 U. S. 168 . 13

- Oglesby v. St. Louis & 8. F. RB. RB. Co., 218 Mo:

79; certiorari denied 277 U.S. 587

"Pederson v. D. L. & WR. R. Co., 229 U. S. 146

“galvo v. N. Y. U0. B.'R: Co., 216 N. Y. App. Div. -

592

So. B. R. Co. v. Plunkett, 244 U.S. 371

‘St. Louis R. R. Co. v. cai 229 U. S. 156

. |

TABLE OF STATUTES CITED.

Act of Cong., April 22, 1908, C. 149,, See. 1, 35

Stat. 65 .

Act of Cong., April 5,

Stat. 21 ;

_ PAGE |

| Supreme roe of po United States

—Oorosen Term, 1931.

/

~~

°.

Tue New Yorx, New Haven anv.

Hartrorp Rartroap Company, |

Petitioner, | ‘

4

, : No. 263. o @® |

tno | Vs. ao . ; * >

: . Crarence Bezvz,

-"

Brief in Opposition to Petitioy for Wrest"

of Certiorari. , 1

_ The i emaeninees of a Courts Below... -

_ The New York Court of Appeals ' opinions are re-

ported:in 257 N. Y.°480 (R., 511-519). 5

The New York Appellate Division, Second Siiacess |

- ment, wrote no opinion. Its memorandum decision is

reported in 232 N. Y. App. Div. 840 (R., 508).

- The: Trial Court (Mr. Justice John E. Mack) wrote

no opinion (R., 500).

-preme Court, Putnam County, on September 4th, Octo-

_ The Appellate Division of the New York Supreme

- Court,. Second Department, directed that unless the

~ plaintiff stipulate to reduce the ‘verdict to the sum of

the New York Court of Appeals, and that Court af-—

‘The sole question is whether 4T not this is a case in

_to review the judgment below.

_Personal injuries, under the #ederal Employers’ Lia-

bility Act (Act of Con., April 22, 1908, C. 149, Sec. 1,

_ Div. 840) that. the judgment and order be reversed

’ upon.the law and facts and a new trial granted. The |

Jurisdiction.

‘The plaintiff below does: not ‘eontend that this Court.

is. without ‘jurisdiction to. review the judgment herein-

which this Court should exerf#iSe its supervisory powers .- -

oe aoner |

Statement of the Case.

This action was instituted to recover damages for

35 Stat. 65, and Act of April 5, 1910. C.-143, Sec. 1,

36 Stat. 291).

- The issues came on for trial before Mr. J ustice John

E. Mack and a jury sitting in the New York State Su-

ber 2nd, 3rd,‘9th and 10th, 1930, and resulted in a ver-

dict for the plaintiff in the sum of $60,000 (R., 1,453)...

$50,000, in which evyént the judgment and order ap-

pealed frém were unanimously - affirmed (232 N. Y. App.

plaintiff stipulated to accept this reduction’ (R., 1,503-

507), and the judgment as SO modified was ‘unanimously

The. defendant as matter “of right then appealed to

es 3 rm ;

firmed the judgment and order. of. the Appellate Divi-

sion (257 N. Y. 480; R., 520-521) and the judgment and

order herein sought to be reviewed were thereafter —

entered pn the 2nd day of June, 1931 ‘(R., 520-521).

. © . * * * « *

: Plaintiff, a married ‘man, 31 years old, had bas en-

gaged in the labor gang at defendant’s maintenance .

roundhoftse at Maybrook, N. ‘Y,, for.a period of. ap- ,

proximately a year, first as_an engine wiper, and then .

at times operating a portable electtic truck, and work-

ing as a member of defendant’s unskilled labor-gang at

this maintenance roundhouse.

_ On September 2, 1929, plaintiffewas injured while he

was helping to-roll a pair of wheels belonging to de-

. fendant’s engine No. 3221, which Bad been for two years

exclusively used in interstate commerce (R., 289-291) ~

ind Which engine could not get back to defendant's. -

main line in New England without being -in interstate

commerce, whether it ran: light, hauled a train; or was

hauled (deadheaded) over the New York-Connecticut

, State line, and which engine actually continued i in inter- »-

’ state service two days after the accident (R., 289- 291)

and has continued ever since in such service, because it

was of the 2-10-2 Sante Fe type used for freight service

only. in heavy eross-mountain interstate trips between

Maybrook, N. Y. and points in Connecticut (R., 269,

294) and which engine at the time of the accident was

undergoing a statutory, boiler wash (R., 270) and in ©

service maintenance repairs (R., 245). of which the mov-

ing of the wheels was an incident (R., 338). Plaintiff

was thrown over the journal of said ‘wheels on his back ,

on the hard packed cinders between the tracks when _

the foreman without warning kicked a block from under —

the wheels, causing them to roll towards plaintiff.

_. We will nof further ‘refer to the undisputed facts be-

eause to do so riareaae require their being set forth prac- -

. 4

v%

. tically verbatiri.” .We have, however, marshalled ‘such —

facts in their proper plgce under the title ‘‘Argument”’ | -

in this brief. . te

_Iv.

Specifications of Errors.

The Trial Court, the Appellate Division and the —

York Court of Appeals all held that the plaintiff, as

niatter of law, was engaged in interstate commerce at

the time he was injured., © :

‘The Trial Court so concluded for the reason that it

| considered this engine No. 3221 was an instrumentality*

of. interstate commerce ‘and not withdrawn from such

commerce. The Court of Appeals, in its opinion, stated

- affirmatively that it considered it unnecessary to de-: -

cide this question because it held that, upon the undis-

puted evidence, plaintiff was a “plant service employee,

engaged in the. defendant’s maintenance roundhouse,

and that his service to defendant involved: constant in-

terétate’ commerce maiWtenance repair and inspection,

' and that he therefore was at all times ceed en-

gaged interstate commerce. - . |

As heretofore stated,. the Appellate. Division dia not

write any opinion.

The record ‘presents nio disputed ovine as to the

plaintiff’s work,’ and no, divergent. inferences are de-

ducible from the evidence; and, therefore, it was surely

' a matter of law as to whether or not he was engaged -

in interstate commerce, and,:as ‘long as sich evidence

re clearly. showed that: ‘the plaintiff. was engeged jn inter-—

- state commerce, it is’ immaterial upon what theory ee.’

‘law the various Courts: herein have based their respec-

tive decisions. (D. L. d W. R, R. Co. v. Yurkonis, 220

Fed. 429, page 433, Sia J.: “We — this. was a

ee a We eee) 5 lg

% right sendincion or the wrong reason.”’ Writ of error: |

dismissed, 238 U. S. 439) and euch differences of opin-

ion certainly should not constitute a reviewable ques: -

tion, if plaintiff below was, in the opinion of this Court, »

actually engaged in interstate commerce, as matter of ~

law, even, if for reasons not found by the Courts below.

“oe

we | ; ; ¥ |

. Argument... oe

* | “ A. a . ; .

The evidence established that the plaintiff

. below was engaged in interstate commerce

as matter of law because the essential facts

of his general employment at the time of his.

injury are undisputed and indisputable.

a

8B. —

‘He was a an 1 unskilled laborer, plant service

-employee, at defendant’s maintenance

rotindhouse, ongaged in his general unas-.

signed work so closely related to interstate

commerce as to bé a part of it (N..¥. CO. R. RB.

Co. v. Marcone, 281 U. S. 345; Erie R. R. Co.

v, Colfins, 253 U. 8S. 77; ‘Erie R. R. Co. 37.

Seary, 258 U. S. 86; IUonardo v. Erie. R. R&R.

Co., 108 N. J. L. 4; Salwo v. N.Y. C. R. R. Co.,

216 N. Y: App. ‘Div. 592; Matter. of Guida,

183 N. Y. App. Div. 822, aff'd. 224 H. ¥. 712;.

Hiser v. Davis, 234 N. Y. 300).

: Mee c. ; .

He was engaged in aiding to maintain in “|

efficient condition as part of ‘his general

a | a

maintenance and plant service, for effective

use, a locomotive used exclusively in inter-—

state commerce while it was undergoing a

statutory boiler wash and. incidental main-

‘ ' tonangp repairs (Lusk v. Bandy, 76 Okla.

108).

ele

6

._

» : D.

He was engaged in aiding to maintain in

efficient condition for effective service in in-

tersiate commerce a locomotive which in

this particular case was an instrumentality —

of interstate commerce not withdrawn from

such commerce (Oglesby v. St. Louis & 8S. F.

R. R. Co., 218;Mo. 79; certiorarj denied QI7

U. 8.587; Flack v. D. L. & W. R. R._Co., 45 ——

Fed. (2) 683, certiorari denied.

Bezue was an unskilled laborer engaged in defend-

ant’s maintenance roundhouse (R., 175-279, 147-148,

335) located at the west end (7U- miles across the New

-York-Connecticut State -line, R., 311) of defendant’s

system and its only’ interstate commerce route from its

main. line and branches in New England_te-New York .

——and was thus. at all time an interstate commerce em-

ployee. ; :

He ‘‘was engaged. in a » plant service, ”? as the New

York Court ‘of Appeals said (R., 513): An almost

- similar expression to petitioner’s admission in its brief

in the:- New York Appellate Division (232 N. Y. App.

Div. 840) at Page 21, ‘‘In substance it was plaintiff’s

work to keep locomotives in good repair.’’ 3

What locomotives? F'reig&t locomotives, used in peti-

‘tioher’s cross-mountain, New York-Connecticut, :inter-

~ 7 |

state service, since, only one or two smaller locomotives °

were used in a passenger sérvice of ore train daily be- ©

‘tween Maybrook and. Poughkeepsie, N. Y. (Plaintiff’s

Exhibit 15A, —_— 16, R:, 464-470; R., 149, 267, 271-273,

280). ars a .

This entinoce, N. Y., maintenance eee ree was

for the stabling and ‘dsily maintenance of such freight

locomotives. during daily inspection and maintenance

up-keep; and their regular thirty day statutory boiler

washes and maintenance up-keep, whereas for their -com-

plete overhauling, rebuilding and general repair work

at the end of approximately every eighteen months or

_ after the locomotive had accumulated approximately

35,000 miles of .service the petitioner maintained at Read-

ville, Mass. a general out- of service repair shop (R.,

__ 245-246, 337-339).

_ This arrangement, we bélieve, to be identical with the

situation arising in Oglésby v. R. R. Co., 218 Mo. 79,

certiorari denied 277 U. 8. 584, where the Missouri

Court emphasized the fact, that the repairs were made .

in a.roundhouse ‘where maintenance repairs were made, .

_ and that the ‘railroad company . maintained .a . repair

shop at a distant_point-where general, extensive and

heavy repairs and alterations were made.

The evidence in the case at bar established that no

ie complete dismantling or general, or out-of-service re-

pair jobs were.done at Maybrook, N. Y. (R., 246). |

What were plaintiff’s general duties in this mainten-

’ ance roundhouse?

At times he operated. a email portable electric truck

with a.crane (R., 470) made himself generally useful —

about the premises, either with the truck and crane or

in person, in aiding or personally doing general main- -

tenance work in oiling locomotives; pulling down. grease

boxes and getting grease; and greasing the locomotives; _

.

‘

. adjusting couplers; adjusting brake shoes; :; pressure

. tanks; taking driving shafts off, and putting them on; ©

keeping locomotives continually in service in ingerstate

commerce; pulling up springs; oiling springs; ‘easing

_. collars ; fixing draw-bars; changing pumps and’ pilots; |

removing and réplacing air-compressors and . brackets

and water pumps; bringing material to the engines for

_-maintenance repairs, removing and replacing pistons

from engine cylinders and ‘any and all work required -

about this maintenance roundhouse on such engines in

the unskilled labor class (R., 145-147; 151;. 190-196).

His. work required from 20. ‘minutes to a few hours

(R., 151). '

_° He was regularly wichiaiiameile day in and day. out

(R., 147-148) and was so employed up to and at the

time of the accident, since unskilled labor was ‘used in

rolling wheels (the identical job plaintiff was doing — |

_ when injured) putting things in position for mechanics, |

. cleaning windows, operating coal pockets; dumping coal . :

and yore a turntable (R., 335).

In fact, p intiff worked, day in and day out, on hot

or live engines ready forgwse and actually used immedi-

‘ately thereafter (R., 147, 148, 152). This was “admitted

_by the petitioner in the Court of Appeals ee’ s

Brief, Pages® 20-21).

Under this uncontroverted evidence Besus was e-

gaged as an unskilled laborer in defendant’s mainten-

ance roundhouse at Maybrook, N. Y. in work so closely

related to interstate commerce as to be a part of it.

Erie R. R.°Co. v. Winfield, 244 U. S. 170. °

. St. Louis R..R. Co. v. Seale, 229 U.S. 156. ,

Erie R. R: Co. v. Collins, 253 U. 8. 77.

: N. Y. C. R. R. Co. v. Marcone, 281 US. 345.

'. ‘Erie R. R. Cov. Seary, 253 U. S. 86.

Monardo v. Erie R. R. betas 103 N. J. L. 4.

-—N

: \

a

er ine v. N. Y.,N. HH. & H. R. R. Co., 223

: N. Y.+513.

Hiser v. Davis, 234 N. Y. 300. :

Matter of Guida, 183.N. Y. App. Div. 822, »

* affm’d. 224 N. Y. 712.

Salvo v. N. Y. C. B. R. Co., 216 N. Y. App.

. Dw. 592, ;

What Besus was actually doing at the time of his in- —

jury we believe is immaterial, as he might have been -

doing nothing at.all and still have been engaged in in-

terstate commerce-as matter of law as this Court said

in MN. YC. R. R. Co. v. Carr, 238 U. S. 260, “The

question is not to be decided by considering the physical

position of.the employee at the moment of the injury.’’

Aside from the question of Bezue’s being engaged in

interstate commerce, as matter of law, by reason of his

general unassigned employment at defendant’s miain-

' tenance roundhouse, he was engaged in interstate com-

merce by reason of the fact that he was actually doing

work incident to the thirty attad ee boiler wash .

(R., 270, 248, 338).

The particular locomative (No. 3221) had been, ‘was

* and’ still is used exclusively in interstate commerce.

- From September 3, 1927 to the day of the trial October

10; 1930, except ‘when undergoing general out of. service

repairs and practically reconstruction at Readville,

Mass., from September 2, 1927, to October 11, 1927;

February 15, 1929 to March 27, 1929; and June 3, 1930,

to July 1, 1930. (Petitioner’s stipulation, R., 289, 290,

291; Plaintiff's Exhibit A 14, B. C. R., 458-462).

This particular locomotive had undeigone Similar _

boiler washes while being used. exclusively in the May-

_ brook, 'N. Y. and ‘Connecticut freight service on Novem-

ber 14, 1927, January 23, 1928; February 25, 1928;

Y. 10>

pril 2, 1928; May 8, 1928; June 10, 1928; July 17, .

1928; September 5, 1928; October 11, 1928; Novem. .

ber 26,1928; May 3, 1929; June 10, 1929; July 17,

1929, and the ,one at the time of this accident, August

24, 1929. All of which were at the petitioner’s mainten- —

ase: roundhouse at Maybrook, N. Y. (R., 337). |

There was nothing unusual about this boiler. wash as

.’ they usually took from 3 to 6 days or more (R., 245) |

the moving of the wheels was incident to the boiler wash- -

(R., 338), am ‘petitioner’s general ‘maintenance super-

tendent testified that as a. matter ‘of fact. there were

other engines im for boiler washes where the repairs

were heavier, and that the repairs on 3221 were not ex-

ceptional but common to this thirty day boiler wash —

period (R.,. 339, 340).

Such testimony was to be expected as this particular

locomotive had been practically rebuilt on its last trip to

defendant’s out-of-service general repair shop at. Read-

_ ville, Mass,. between February, 15 and March ‘27, 1929,

and had had three boiler washes with maintenance re-

pairs in the interim on- May 3, June 10 - July 17, .

1929, .

” An employee injured while making a boiler. ert on a

‘locomotive used exclusively in interstate commerce is

engaged in interstate commerce (Lusk v. Bandy, .76_

Okla. 108; 184 Pac. 144).. Why ‘should doing work in-

cident to the boiler wash change the our of the

employment? \

While the New York Court. of Appeals did not deem.

it mgreneary in deciding this case.to consider the ques-

tion'of this particular locomotive’s character as: an in- -

strumentality of interstate commerce not withdrawn

from euch commerce, we believe, that it was at the time

‘of plaintiff’s injury such. an ipstrumentality because of

its uninterrupted. exclusive use, the defendant’s abso-

e*

6" | , ee

lute inability to use said locomotive for any’ other kind,

of commerce because of its peculiar type and that the -

fact that no matter how said locomotive was taken ‘back

to’ its main line in the State of Connecticut it must’.

either take\ part in-an interstate commerce movement 4

be a part of it.

. ? The testimony also showed that .no out- of-service

repairs were made at Maybrook, Y., and were. only -

made at Readville, Mass., so that we ave an. identical

situation in the case at bar with Oglesby v. R. R. Co.,

218 Mo..79, where: this Court denied certiorari, 277

U.S. 587, and a very similar situation to the case of —

Atkins v..Payne, 109 Ka. 477, where this Court: also

denied, certiorari, 257 U. S. 658. | -

We are not concerned here with many of the de-

cisions of this Court following its pronouncements in.

. Minneapolis & St. Louis R. R. Co. v. Winters, 242 U. 8

, 353, where the opinion stated ‘that ‘an engine .as such

is not permanently devoted to any kind of traffic, Pgs

Its next work, so far as appears, might be interstate or

confined to Iowa, as it should Happen * -* *.’’ ‘.

Every case that we know of where this Court has

rendered an opinion in relation to a locomotive as an

instrumentality of interstate commerce has had in it

facts justifying the conclusion that the locomotive

might, although previously used in interstate commerce,

be used in intrastate commerce on its next run after the b

. accident.

Khere are no such Saale in this record. In “tact the

facts are to the contrary. First, as to the peculiar type

of, locomotive. Second, as to its exclusive use for years

before the accident, dnd as to ‘ts actual use.after the

. accident, and third, the peculiar geographical situation

’ of defendant’s maintenance roundhouse being at the .

weste ~ end of its railroad system and -only 70 miles -

;

5

ay |

a. - Pp A pee 12.

oe approximately. from ‘the. ew eich Rinses State .

line prohibited this locomotive being anything else. bot | }

an’ instrumentality tof interstate ‘commerce unless its . “

_ services were completely dispensed with and they.were -

-not, as far as the record goes for on the date-of the ~

_ trial some 13 months after the accident it. was still in

this vervice, ~

: As we understand ‘the joni laid down by this Siena, a.

’ in that each case must be decided in the light of the

a particular facts proven with.a view of determining ‘in-

, terstate commerce, N. Y. 0. RR. Co. v. Cart, 238 U. 8.

260, sind we therefore will not discusg the cases cited in

petitioner’s brief believing them ce lg because the ©

"questions: here raised wer¢ not decided ‘on Anything like

or near the particular-facts proven in the case at bar.

Petitioner’s point B.raises:no question sufficient to

warrant the granting of a. writ of certiorari. ©

_Retitioner has: contended in the Courts below the

-game as here that plaintiff was not engaged ‘in inter-

state commerce at all and yet tries to becloud the clear

cut issue of law by suggesting ‘‘at the most the plaintiff

presented a fact. question naan should have been sub-

mitted to the jury.’’

This argumient has failed to impress any of the thir-

‘teen judges of the three courts below and we still be-

lieve: it is absolutely untenable. . , .

The fact that the judges of the various successive

State courts may have differed in their reasoning as to.

the principle applicable does not.cause a jury question

to be presented. (D. L. dW: R: R. Co. v. Yorkinus, 220

Fed. 429, writ of error dismissed, 238 U. S. 439.)

; Interstate commerce is never a question for the jury

if the. essential facts concerning employment are not in :

dispute, and admit no divergent inferences.

< a

e

| 1B

In such a.case te Court is requiréd nlite: as to :

: ‘interstate. commerce as matter of -law. :

WN. ¥.C. R. R. Co. v: Portet, 249 U. 8. 168; Bo. R. R.

Co. v. Plunkett, 244 U. 8,371; Erie R. R. Co. v. Welsh, ae

+ 242 U.S. 303; ‘Pederson v. D. L. é-W. R. * Co., 229

iat %

— st - Conclusion.

It is, therefore respectfully submitted that there is

nothing shown by.the petitioner i in this case calling for |

the exercise by this Court of its supervisory ‘powers to.»

‘review the judgment of the. Geurt of Appeals of the

State of New York and petitioner’s application for a

i Write of certiorari should be denied with costs.

. THomas J..O’NemL,

Attorney for Plaintiff-Respondent.

Tuomas J. O’Neuu, | 2

Cuaries D. Lewis, |

Of Counsel.

nk

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.

Opposition Brief — New York, NH & HR Co. v. Bezue · 284 U.S. 415 | Frix