Transcript of Record — Standard Parts Co. v. Peck
Supreme Court brief1924
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Supreme Court of the United States.
OCTOBER TERM, 1930
Nees
THE PERMUTIT COMPANY, PETITIONER,
v8.
GRAVER CORPORATION
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED 8TATES CIRCUIT COURT
OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED JANUARY 13, 1931
CERTIORARI GRANTED MARCH 2, 1931
(35,585)
Supreme Court of the Anited States.
Ocroser Tzrm, A. D. 1930.
No.
THE PERMUTIT COMPANY,
Petitioner,
v8.
GRAVER CORPORATION, :
Respondent.
ON PREBTITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES
CIRCUIT COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT.
RECORD
Drury W. Cooper, Eseq.,
Mirrorp C. Massie, Esq.,
q Grorce A. Cunitron, Esq.,
Auuan C. Bakewe.1, Esq.,
Counsel for Petitioner.
Grorcz L. Wirzxrnson, Eso,
Cuaruzs L. Byron, Esq,
Counsel for Respondent.
INDEX.
Index to record of proceedings in the District Court of the
United States for the Northern District of Illinois,
SSS TEES a a ee ee ee i
I ce demeab ssedee cheese 671
Index to record of proceedings in the United States Cir-
cuit Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit:
RRR GPa rere ret ere re ree 673
Appearance of counsel for appellant, filed June 4,
Er rere ree rere rN eer re ee 673
Appearance of counsel for appellee, filed June 6, 1930 674
Appearance of counsel for appellant, filed June 19,
eta eee ee Lalu ve gad asuenews 675
Stipulation, filed July 15, 1930, relative to time for
filing briefs and requesting case be set down for
SUE GG, By, BI 6 vec ccc ccc ncccieccccvsss 676
Order of July 15, 1930 pursuant to stipulation...... 677
UN TE I oo vd cep eccudicesecacceccess 678
Opinion by Evans, C. J., filed Oct. 20, 1930.......... 679
Decree, entered Oct. 20, 1930...................... 691
Stipulation { » stay mandate, filed Oct. 30, 1930...... 692
Order of Oct. 30, 1930, staying mandate until further
oe a gloss ads 5 ucualy os aa aan 693
ee seh oun kwnwc x Ge hub ua anos 695
Unite States Gieuit ourt of Hapenls
For the Seventh Circuit
Ocroser Term, A. D. 1929.
No. 4390
THE PERMUTIT COMPANY,
Appellant,
vs.
GRAVER CORPORATION,
Appellee.
Counsel for Appellant:
MR. DRURY W. COOPER,
MR. MITFORD C, MASSIE,
MR. GEORGE A. CHRITTON,
MR, ALLAN C. BAKEWELL,
Counsel for Appellee:
MR. GEORGE L, WILKINSON,
MR. CHARLES L, BYRON,
Appeal frou the District Court of the United States for the Northern District
of Tilinois, Eastern Division.
|
:
cick Veer es
4 bal ae) SD ERS A SPOT EY LCP IAD ONO OMS Ms OS DIMMED SUNY” Meee ee ee
PAGE
Ss hae ance eee R Seah Ob Hob kahSnane ewes 1
Se” ctirceecadekcesdenaeantbadneKe ens 2
cs picccathins ¢ sgkeeGAOs ROARK DAES RA EES - KEK OKERKA 8
Demand under Equity Rule 58....................... 16
Letter, Mar. 18, 1920, The Permutit Co. to Dr. Chas.
LE cidade oneekeednenadokeanss haces 17
Stipulation to amend answer, and approval of Judge,
i ec cakctedinceeeknnantencease tens 18
EE ee re ee ee are 19
Stipulation to amend answer filed Sept. 5, 1929......... 20
Narrative Statement of Evidence.
Plaintiffs’ Witnesses:
a ois bss weaken eee mees 156, 32
a is oa eaves we ale ae ee 173
ERS Er eee ghee rR aA 184
idan es ae bd an ens whee ek edannnene 156
EE eee ee os eee heacad 154, 85, 22
Waterman, Frank N. ................ Da ak hse eta dh aaa 48
Defendants’ Witnesses:
ee eked eo 147
NS ne ae 193
NS ES ter ere an er irre 190, 148
EE tik wide desis sae bus on eens 189
Ms bos dunn ddvs vende nedaboenaens 186, 90
EE Sh eec kel kat edwehed ee cavmedeenankon 133
I he coi i a 188
Order approving Statement of Evidence .............. 196
Intro-
ducedin Repro-
evidence duced
atpage at page
Plaintiffs’ Exhibits:
A—U. S. Patent No. 1, 195, 923, R. Gans, Aug.
tt Mek bbae peered danepeooese 21 584
B—Volume of exhibits marked as follows:
No. 1—Stipulation as to certain facts, as
ie pd eeesenaene ee 21 197
No. 2—Defendants’ Bulletin dated Feb. 1,
iy EE a 21 199
No. 3—Defendants’ Bulletin dated June
EE a 21 209
No. 4—Defendants’ Bulletin dated Oct.
EE Re a 21 222
No. 5—Defendants’ ‘‘Model-D’’ Bulletin. 21 251
No. 6—Blueprint C-243 ................ 21 =—261
No. 7—Biueprint C-242 ................ 21 38263
No. 8—Blueprint C-240 ................ 21 3265
No. 9—Defendants’ ‘‘Model C’’ Bulletin. 21 267
No. 10—Defendants’ Bulletin ‘‘Soft
Water for Textile Purposes”’.... 214277
No. 11—Deposition of Sheridan S. Moston 21 279
Deposition of Samuel B. Applebaum. 21 280
Deposition of Arthur E. Howlett.... 21 3
No. 12—Photostat, ‘‘ Typical Precipitation
tt dent ieenensnnes 21 309
No. 13—Bulletin of Agricultural Station.. 21
No. 14—Photograph of piece of seale.... 21
No. 15—Page from publication ‘‘Power’’ 21
No. 16-—-Bulletin of Agricultural Station.. 21
No. 17—Page from publication ‘‘Canning
SE Det ca ntbcnndeedeseeiipewese 21
No. 18—Stipulation of plaintiffs’ test of
Mar. 27, 1909 and attached blueprints.. 21 3i1l
Blueprint ZW-338-A ............... 21 319
Blueprint ZW-608 .................
I IE oc Cnn ecctacecconsa 21
No. 20—Stipulation of plaintiffs’ second
test of May 15, 1929 and attached ex-
NEED 55000 6knenececeneeaacasensancee 21
Letter, May 15, 1929, Cooper, Kerr &
Dunham to Byron ............ 21
Letter, May 15, 1929, Byrou to
Cooper, Kerr & Dunham ......... 21
ee 21
C—Sketch made by Witness Tiger .......... 28
D—Sketch made by Witness Tiger.......... 28
E—Sketch made by Witness Tiger.......... 28
F—Photograph of paraffine sheet found in bot-
tom of tank in March test (marked for id.). 45
G—Sketch made by Witness Waterman...... 59
H—Sample of excelsior from excelsior bed
gg. ee een 145
I—Sketch prepared by Witness Hammer..... 159
J-—-Deposition of Francis Payne Mason...... 184
Deposition of Adolph Carl Noé......... 184
Deposition of Henry L. Nachman........ 184
Deposition of Felix Stern............... 184
Deposition of Sigmund Waldbott........ 184
Deposition of Alfred O. Lee............. 184
Deposition of George O. Haas........... 184
Deposition of Abram Lipsky............ 184
Deposition of Otto Luthy............... 184
Deposition of Carl V. Bertsche......... 184
Deposition of Alfred Mueller........... 184
Deposition of Dr. Alexander Green...... 184
Deposition of Bernard R. Regan........
Deposition of John W. Scholl...........
343
lv
Intro-
ducedin Repre-
evidence duced
atpage «ut page
K—Complete parsing by Dr. Scholl (Pltfs.’
Ms TE Se endincdivkonnhecdnedéussesedas 184 437
L—Comparative arrangement (Pltfs.’ Ex. 52) 184 444
M—Haas manuscript translation Gans’ article
SN GUE bac dad aendedadeweedesesan 184 445
Excerpts from testimony of Alfred Mueller.. 184 184
Defendants’ Exhibits:
No. 14—Pail of zeolite .................... 106
No. 15—Rubber gasket ....................- 106
Ps PT a vedachestwccvcesdsccusues 106
No. 17—Can of excelsior ................... 103
No. 18—Report of Permutit Co. dated Mar. 16,
1927 to Florida Filter Corp. .............. 154 = 455
No. 19—Rundschau device ................. 106
No. 20—Stipulation as to certain exhibits,
PE ED sh bbc db ccedsdaacceceanacens 89 457
No. 21—Agreed English translation of Ger-
Fe SU ah asbvansakuneanecceses 89
No. 22—Agreed English translation of Ger-
man Law on protection of Gebrauchsmuster 89
No. 23—Langner testimony in American Chain
Gt SD cc eaiwcecd cessed tecsaenseussures 89
No. 24—Rundschau article of Jan. 27,1909... 89 461
No. 25—Translation of Exhibit No. 24....... 89 465
No. 26—Enlargement of drawings in Rund-
I I kb ves cas beans cndeusxeeees 89 469
No. 27—Article from ‘‘The Practical Engi-
neer’’ June 4, 1909 with Affidavit of Edward
eee Pet re rT re rr mre 89 471
No. 28—Gebrauchsmuster No. 341,512 (Draw-
ing only reproduced) ..........ccisescecs 89 664
No. 29—Translation of Gebrauchsmuster 341,-
Dt cvbaevessGuedudses ocue bakwareke whine 89 665
No. 30—Gebrauchsmuster No. 313,671 (Draw-
Me CU DOIN on occ db cccceciavcens 89 660
EEL RSTRNT EOI OPEN SEES VISE I OSS LY CIN OT TAN reser recast mene a
Intro-
evidence
at page
No. 31—Translation of Exhibit 30........... 89
No. 32—Feldhoff article of Sept. 7, 1907
(drawing only reproduced)............... 89
No. 33—Translation of Feldhoff article of
Me I SE hh bndeséasénevexiescdess 89
No. 34—German Patent No. 211,064, to H.
SMIOE BOM. TR, BOG ccc ccccnccdccvcvcses 89
No. 35—Translation of Leister patent No. 211,-
Cs SE ne caddsontveceacaaecacess 89
No. 36—Down-flow softener in Permutit vs.
DE Wawieashthaee dean dibesbaaudasaale 89
No. 37—Down-flow softener in Permutit vs.
ME tints dwbntadkadsadsabedacesccuss 89
No. 38—Up-flow softener in Permutit vs.
SEE cbatebscunndhid wacnbiew ones. 89
No. 39—Up-flow softener in Permutit vs.
EE SG nV ad us chcduadiasudce a bescels 89
No. 40—Defendants’ drawing No. ZW-718, of
Rundschau water softener ............... 89
No. 41—Stipulation re. tests of defendant at
Hawthorne Laundry Service on Sept. 12,
OE ANE NO oiidb dh vielen aewhecetacacs 89
No. 42—Stipulation with notice, motion, affi-
davit of James Q. Rice and disclaimer at-
PE: Wtuddecbdedeannndneedesedd sidan uss 89
No. 48—Stipulation re: testimony of certain
witnesses as it appears in transcript of rec-
ord in Sixth Circuit, case of Permutit vs.
MEE. dead dshun eeediedeeiconeenk ics 89
No. 44—Deposition mentioned in Ex. 43...... 89
No. 45—Stipulation of Oct. 18, 1929 re: cer-
Oe Ss ON ikniccsncddsenivacaccesne 89
Deposition of Alfred Mueller from record
Pe I cls wane oxemuwe kascse 89
501
505
509
510
511
—
Intro- |
ducedin Repro- |
evidence duced ©
atpage at page
No. 46—Stipulation of Oct. 19, 1929 that Gans
article appeared in ‘‘Chemische Industrie’’
US EE cA Wh cacacencscntansea 89 512
No. 47—Gans article of Apr. 15, 1909 in
eh | 89 513
No. 48—British Patent No. 3870 of 1911 to
cena chee chttaeecetnncnes 89 647
No. 49—U. S. Patent No. 1,276,629, T. R. Dug-
i ED scence ckaaesnennawnane 89 638
No. 50—U. S. Patent No. 943,535, R. Gans,
— § 8 A ee 89 631
No. 51—Reissue Patent No. 13,688, R. Gans, |
ee ceelaakwnvetnnaeensee en 89 635
No. 52—U. S. Patent No. 478,261, O. H., W. M.
& I. H. Jewell, July 5, 1892...............+ 89 590
No. 53—U. S. Patent No. 678,532, F. E. Bach-
= Ee 89 614
No. 54—U. S. Patent No 630,870, V. C. Dries-
cic cc nesanbeeee as 89 602 |
No. 55—U. S. Patent No. 632,091, F. Bom-
I, Be, TI Be occ hs cccccewccncese 89 608
No. 56—U. S. Patent No. 707,899, F. Bom-
I I Ge BEE aeccvaccecnscennnnes 89
No. 57—U. S. Patent No. 519,565, F. Bom-
EE is Ka cdevcesccessccesss 89
No. 58—U. S. Patent No. 960,887, R. Gans,
PC cekdecabencaneadeanannen'ens 89
No. 59—Stipulation dated Oct. 25, 1929, re:
iid cncenhan eet wnaeecne 89
No. 60—Weiss thesis (drawings only repro-
IE Eee ee ee 89
No. 61—Translation of Weiss thesis ......... 89
No. 62—Letter, Mar. 18, 1920, Duggan to Dr.
EE rT OTT an 89
ph hank aa ESOS SON TAS Sey toes getty RRB OS IM RAINY SENG EE LOS Tg NB
Intro-
ducedin Repro-
evidence duced
atpage at page
No. 64—Blueprint showing curve referred to
MM EEE Sohhe ek bnkckacacxceccnancs< 95 549
No. 65—Certified copy of Gans File Wrapper
We IE Eh. b occ b ase meadaedc Kiinceas
No. 66—Blueprint showing exterior of softener
at Des Plaines River sewage plant........ 193 553
No. 67—Model G machine built by Duro Cor-
EE PERG hens KvRKAK eb Waskadesccexcs 195
Memorandum of the Court filed Jan. 20, 1930.......... 555
OE OE is bein xndn anus ee nevanesaces 570
Order extending time for filing record................. 571
NO OE ink anne eceannccesensccccveccess 572
PD OE GOUT ow. ec ccccaccnccccuues, 572
Guan amowing append .... 2... . oko e cece cccccesss. 574
ROE MANS OER a Kit a wee wnnce sana un cd ekdccce, 574
Stipulation that foregoing is complete record.......... 576
Stipulation re: Exhibits ............................. 577
i el ee 577
Unirep States Lerrers PATENT.
No. 1,195,923, R. Gans, ees, hee, heer eer 584
No. 478,261, O. H., W. M. & I. H. Jewell, July 5, 1892... 590
No. 519,565, F. Bommarius, May 8, 1894............... 598
No. 630,870, V. C. Driesbach, Aug. ne 602
No. 632,091, F. Bommarius, Aug. 29, 1899.............. 608
No. 678,532, F. E. Bachman, July 16, 1901.............. 614
No. 707,899, F. Bommarius, Aug. 26, 1902.............. 624
No. 943,535, R. Gans, Dee. ne 631
No. 960, 887, R. Gans, June SLES 633
No. 13,688, ( Reissue) R. Gans, Feb. | 635
No. 1,276,629, T. R. Duggan, Aug. 20,1918.............. 638
British Patent No. 3870 of 1911 to Wm. E. Evans (Defts.’
PFC ERK ret eenentncinnshhsescievessuse os 647
= ieee
RN MPL Ry NE age
viii
Translation of German Patent No. 211,064, H. Leister,
See. Th, THD Cate.” TER. GB) 2... coc ccscccsvccsccess
Drawing of Gebrauchsmuster No. 313,671 (Defts.’ Ex.
SO PTT rr eT TT eT er ererer TT Terr rer Terr errs
.. Translation of Gebrauchsmuster No. 313,671 (Defts.’
_ | Perr rerrerrre Terr eri rier ieee The
Drawing of Gebrauchsmuster No. 341,512 (Defts.’ Ex.
TD ake cdsnnsekasesenspecticetesensascnsaneacsasnes
SE Nea bchednedebeesiveracnercenpednesxeeessansen ms
CR GE GD nk noc cece scsccnsanccsccsececcens
GE cen bcewas cbenecnedeencvdencessens cecsesaneed
Stipulation regarding printing transcript of record.....
SUPE ESIN AEG EST IG ear ey
1 Pleas in the District Court of the United States for the
Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, begun and
held at the United States Court Room, in the City of Chicago,
in said District and Division, before the Honorable Walter C.
Lindley, District Judge of the United States for the Northern
District of Illinois on twenty-fourth day of January, in the
year of our Lord one thousand nine hundred and thirty, being
one of the days of the regular December Term of said Court,
begun Monday, the 16th day of December, and of our Inde-
pendence the 154th year.
Present :
Honorable Walter C. Lindley, District J udge.
H. C. W. Laubenheimer, U. S. Marshal.
Charles M. Bates, Clerk.
rb. 23, 1928.
2 Bul of Complaint.
2 In THE District Court or THE UniTEep STaTEs
Northern District of Illinois
Eastern Division
The Permutit Company,
Plaintiff
vs. No. 9709
Graver Corporation,
Defendant.
Be It Remembered, that the above-entitled action was com-
menced by the filing of the following Bill of Complaint in the
above-entitled cause, in the office of the Clerk of the District
Court of the United States for the Northern District of IMi-
nois, Eastern Division, on this the 23rd day of February,
A. D. 1928, to-wit:
3 : > * (eptee) * *
Plaintiff, for its bill of complaint, alleges:
1. That the plaintiff, The Permutit Company, is a corpora-
tion organized and existing under the laws of and a citizen
of the State of Delaware, and has a place of business in Wil-
mington, in said State, and that the defendant, Graver Cor.
poration, is a corporation organized and existing under the
laws of and is a citizen of the State of Illinois, and has its
rincipal place of business in the City of Chicago, in said
tate, and in the Northern District of Tlinoia, Eastern Divi-
sion, and is a resident and inhabitant of said City and North-
ern District, Eastern Division.
2. That the jurisdiction of the Court depends upon the pat-
ent laws of the United States.
3. That letters patent of the United States, No. 1,195,923,
for water softening apparatus, were duly granted on August
22, 1916, to J. D. Riedel Actiengeselischaft, as the assignee of
Robert Gans, under and in accordance with the provisions of
the then existing Statutes of the United States, as by said
patent, or a duly authenticated copy thereof, here in court
to be produced, will fully and at large appear; and that
4 the plaintiff, by an assignment in writing dated November
10, 1916, duly recorded in the United States Patent Offi
then became and has ever since been and is now the owner
the entire right, title and interest in and to said patent and of
AN ae ae pe SF
Bill of Complaint. 3
» No. 1,348,977,
n roducing same,
j rge Leonard
provisions of
e United States, as by said pat-
py thereof, here in court to be
rge appear; and
recorded in the
were duly grant
patent and of all
and in equity, for profits and
e, because of in ringement
y said assignments, luly certified copies
— of the United
n
arge appear, and
that pla grant thereof and
is now the owner tle and interest in
and to said paten and demands, both
t law and in
8, Bor pencer patents
been of great bene age to the pub-
; that the public has gen and acquiesced
4 Bill of Complaint.
in the rights of the plaintiff and its said predecessors there-
under; and that defendant has had due notice of said letters
patent and each of them and of the rights of plaintiff and its
predecessors thereunder.
7. That the defendant, by making or causing to be made,
and selling or causing to be sold, and using or causing to be
used, in the Northern District of Illinois, and elswhere in the
United States, water softening apparatus made in accordance
with and embodying the inventions and improvements set
forth in said Gans letters patent No. 1,195,923, and more
particularly the inventions and improvements set forth in
claims 1 and 5 thereof, and by making or causing to be —_
and selling or causing to be sold, a water softening compoun
embodying the inventions and improvements described |
claimed in said Borrowman patent No. 1,348,977, and by -sing
or causing to be used a process of purifying water embodyi
the inventions and improvements described and dein
6 in said Spencer patent No. 1,455,363, has, wilfully and
without the consent of the plaintiff, as to said Gans and
Spencer patents, and of plaintiff and its predecessors in
ownership as to said Borrowman patent, since the respective
dates of said letters patent and within six years prior to the
filing of this bill of complaint, infringed upon said Gans, Bor-
rowman and Spencer letters patent, and each of them, and is
still continuing so to do, and has derived unlawful gains and
profits from such infringements, which plaintiff would other-
wise have received and enjoyed from and under said Gans and
Spencer patents and which plaintiff and its predecessors in
the ownership thereof would otherwise have received and en-
joyed from and under said Borrowman patent; and that de-
fendant has by its said infringement of said Gans and Spencer
patents caused damage to plaintiff, and by its said infringes
ment of said Borrowman patent caused damage to plaintiff
and its predecessors in the ownership thereof; and that said
damage arising from defendant’s infringement of said three
letters patent, and each of them, will be irreparable unless
defendant be enjoined from further infringement thereof.
8. That plaintiff, on or about the 3lst day of July, 1919,
brought a-.suit in the United States District Court for the
Western District of New York against Harvey Laundry Com
pany for infringement of said Gans patent 1,195,923; that
later the Refinite Company, of Omaha, Nebraska, intervened
as and became a party defendant thereto; that after trial on
pleadings and proofs, said Court, on or about July 6, 1921,
entered an interlocutory decree holding that, as to claims 1
Bill of Complaint. 5
and 5 thereof, said patent was valid and had been in-
7 fringed by the defendants, which decree was duly affirmed
by the United States Circuit Court of — for the
Second Circuit on an appeal therefrom by sai defendants ;
that on or about August 9, 1927, a final decree to the same
effect was duly entered in said suit az to the validity and in-
fringement of said claims 1 and 5 of said Gans patent and
also directing judgment in favor of plaintiff and against the
defendants for the gains and profits realized by them from
their infringements ; and that, except for an appeal now pend-
ing by the defendant Refinite Company as to the amount of
the money judgment therein — it, said decree is now
in all respects in full force and effect; as by duly authentt-
cated copies of said interlocutory and final decrees, here in
court to be produced, will more fully and at large appear.
9. That plaintiff, on or about the 9th day of October, 1918,
brought suit in the United States District Court for the East.
ern District of Michigan, against Frank L. Wadhams and
others, for infringement of the Gans patent No. 1,195,923 here
in suit; that later the Borromite Company of America inter-
vened as and was joined as a party defendant to said suit;
that after the trial of said suit said District Court held the
patent invalid and thereupon entered a decree dismissing
laintiff’s bill of complaint therein; that an appeal was taken
y plaintiff to the United States Circuit Court of Appeals for
the Sixth Circuit from said decree; that thereafter and after
due proceedings therein said Circuit Court of Appeals re-
versed the said decree and in its mandate duly issued and filed
in said District Court directed said Court to enter a decree
for plaintiff on claims 1 and 6 of said Gans patent; that
thereafter an order was duly entered in said District
8 Court on said Mandate; that thereafter a supplemental
bill was filed by plaintiff praying that the Wayne Com-
pany of South Bend, Indiana, be joined as a party defendant
to said suit; and that thereafter and on or about December
23, 1927, a final decree was entered in said suit in favor of
plaintiff and against all of said defendants, including said
Wayne Company, holding claim 1 and 5 of said Gans patent
valid and to have been infringed by said defendants, which
decree is still in full force and effect; as by a duly authenti-
cated copy of said decree, here in court to be produced, will
more fully and at large appear.
10. That plaintiff, on or about the 28th day of June, 1923,
brought suit in the United States District Court for the South-
ern District of New York, against Paige & Jones Chemical
ee ee Org ae
6 Bill of Complaint.
Company, Inc., for infringement of said Gans patent here in
suit, and immediately thereafter a motion for preliminary in-
junction against said defendant was made by plaintiff and an
order was duly entered thereon granting said motion as to
claim 1 of said Gans paient 1,195,923; that no appeal was
taken by said defendant from said order; that later another
motion for preliminary injunction was made by plaintiff
against said defendant as to other types of softeners manu-
factured and sold by it and an order was duly entered thereon
granting said motion as to claim 5 of said Gans patent; that,
on appeal from said order by said defendant, the United
States Circuit Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit
affirmed said order except as to certain of such other soft-
eners which it directed in its mandate should be further con-
sidered and disposed of at the trial; that thereafter and on or
about February 17, 1928, a final decree was duly entered in
said suit in favor of plaintiff and against said defendant
9 holding, as to claims 1 and 5 thereof, that said Gans pat-
ent No. 1,195,923 was valid and had been infringed by all
of the aforesaid softeners manufactured and sold by said de-
fendant, including those which said Circuit Court of Appeals
directed should be further considered and disposed of at the
trial and that said decree is now in full force and effect; as
by duly authenticated copies of said injunction orders and
decree here in court to be produced, will more fully and at
large appear.
11. That plaintiff, on or about the 6th day of February,
1928, brought suit in the United States District Court for the
Southern District of New York, against Paige & Jones Chem-
ical Company, Inc., for infringement of said Borrowman pat-
ent No. 1,348,977, and Spencer patent No. 1,455,363, and that
thereafter and on or about February 17, 1928, a decree, on
consent, was duly entered therein, with said defendant’s con-
sent, sustaining said patents and each of them, finding in-
fringement thereof by said defendant and granting an injunc-
tion against further infringement thereof by said defendant.
Wherefore, plaintiff prays for writs of injunction as well
provisional as permanent, issuing out of and under the seal
of this court, enjoining and restraining the defendant, Graver
Corporation, its officers, directors, clerks, attorneys, servants,
agents and workmen, from infringing upon said letters pat-
ent and each of them; that said defendant account to plaintiff
for the profits made by it and the damages sustained by said
plaintiff, because of its infringements of said Gans and Spen-
Bill of Complaint. 7
cer patents, No. 1,195,923 and No. 1,455,363, and by plain-
10 tiff and its predecessors in the ownership thereof use
of its infringement of said S3orrowman patent No. 1,348,-
977; that the plaintiff recover the costs and disbursements of
this suit; and that plaintiff may have such other and further
relief as may appear proper and be agreeable to equity; that
said defendant be required to answer this bill of complaint,
but not under oath, plaintiff hereby waiving verification of
defendant’s answer.
Tue Permutir Company
by H. KarecsHerm
President.
Purr, Sawyer, Rick & Kennepy,
220 Broadway, New York City,
DyrenFrortTH, Lez, Curitron & WIzEs,
Solicitors and of counsel for plainttff.
James C. Rice Marquette Building, Chicago, Ill.
Gzorce A. CHRITTON
Of Counsel. -
State of New York, ™
County of New York. ’
H. KRIEGSHEIM, being first duly sworn, deposes and
says that he is the President of The Permutit Company, plain-
tiff above named, that he has read the foregoing bill of com-
plaint subscribed by him on behalf of said Company and
knows the contents thereof, and that the same is true of his
own knowledge, except as to those matters therein stated to
be alleged upon information and belief, and that as to those
matters he believes it to be true.
H. KrizcsHEIM
Subscribed and sworn to before me this 21st day of Febru-
ary, 1922.
ArtTuur E. MarcanTE,
(Seal) Notary Public.
New York Co. Clerks No. 47
New York Co. Register’s No, 9048
Kings Co. Clerks No. 461
Kings Co. Register’s No. 9645
My commission expires Mar. 30, 1929.
11 Exhibits marked: Exhibit A, Exhibit B, and Exhibit
C hereto attached, but not copied.
(Endorsed) Filed Feb. 23, 1928. Charles M. Bates, Clerk.
€ Answer.
19a, 12 And on, to wit, the 18th day of April, 1928, came the
; defendant by its attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s office
of said Court a certain Answer in words and figures following,
to wit:
13 * °* (Caption) ° *
ANSWER.
To the Honorable the Judges of the United States District
Court, Northern District of Illinois, Eastern Division:
Now Comes Defendant, and for answer unto the Bill of
, Complaint says:
1. Defendant denies each and every allegation in the Bill
of Complaint contained, except as hereinafter admitted or
specifically answered or avoided.
2. Defendant admits that it is a corporation organized
under the laws of the State of Illinois, and for the purposes
of this suit, has a place of business in the City of Chicago,
State of Illinois, but denies that it has committed any acts of
oo in the Northern District of Illinois, or else
where.
3. Defendant admits that Letters Patent No. 1,195,923 was
issued on August 22, 1916, to J. B. Riedel, Aktiengesellschaft,
but denies that Robert Gans was at any time the true, original
or first inventor of said alleged improvements, and that said
Letters Patent was granted upon proper application, and that
said Letters Patent is or was valid; but on the contrary
14 defendant alleges, as hereinafter more particularly
stated, that said Letters Patent is wholly invalid; fhat
the mechanism therein described and claimed was not new;
that the same had been known, described and used and pat-
ented prior to the alleged invention thereof by the said Rob-
ert Gans, and was in public use and on sale in this country
before Gans’ alleged invention thereof, and more than two
— prior to the filing of the Gans application for Letters
atent.
4. Defendant is not advised except by the Bill of Com-
plaint whether or not due and proper assignment was made
by the said Robert Gans to said J. D. Riedel Aktiengesellschaft,
and that proper assignment was made by the latter to plain-
tiff herein covering the aforesaid Letters Patent, and for
profits and damages accrued or to accrue because of infringe-
ment thereof, and therefore calls upon plaintiff to make
proper proof of same.
RES ELEGANS ES IS IRE TTL! BLEND BEEN STL NI TR
Answer. 9
5. Defendant admits that Letters Patent No. 1,348,977
was issued August 10, 1920, to George Leonard Borrowman,
for Water Softening Compound and Method of Producing
Same, but denies that said George Leonard Borrowman was
at any time the true, original or first inventor of said alleged
improvements, and that said Letters Patent was granted upon
proper application, and that said Letters Patent is or was
valid; but on the contrary, defendant alleges, as hereinafter
more particularly stated, that said Letters Patent is wholly
invalid ; that the compound and method of producing same
therein described and claimed were not new; that the same
had been known, described and used and patented prior to
the alleged invention thereof by the said George Leonard
Borrowman, and was in public use and on sale in this country
before Borrowman’s alleged invention thereof, and more than
two years prior to the filing of the Borrowman application
for Letters Patent.
15 6. Defendant is not advised except by the Bill of Com-
plaint whether or not due and proper assignment was
made to plaintiff covering the aforesaid Letters Patent, in-
cluding the rights of recovery of profits and damages accrued
or to accrue because of the infringement of said Letters Pa-
tent, and therefore calls upon plaintiff to make proper proof
of same.
7. Defendant admits that Letters Patent No. 1,455,363 was
issued May 15, 1923, to The Permutit Company, for a Process
of Purifying Water, but denies that Arthur C. Spencer was
at any time the true, original or first inventor of said alleged
improvements, and that said Letters Patent was granted upon
proper application, and that said Letters Patent is or was
valid; but on the contrary, defendant alleges, as hereinafter
more particularly stated, that said Letters Patent is wholly
invalid; that the process therein described and claimed was
not new; that the same had been known, described and used
and patented prior to the alleged invention thereof by the
said Arthur C. Spencer, and was in public use and on sale
in this country before Spencer’s alleged invention thereof, and
more than two years prior to the filing of the Spencer applica-
tion for Letters Patent.
8. Defendant is not advised except by the Bill of Com-
plaint whether or not due and proper assignment was made
by the said Arthur C. Spencer to plaintiff covering the afore-
said Letters Patent and for profits and damages accrued or
to accrue because of infringement thereof, and therefore calls
upon plaintiff to make proper proof of same.
10 Answer.
9. Defendant denies each and every etn set forth in
Paragraph No. 6 of the Bill of Complaint.
16 10. Answering Paragraph No. 7 of the Bill of Com-
plaint, defendant denies past or present infringement of
said Gans, Borrowman and Spencer Letters Patent, and de
nies each and every other allegation set forth in said para-
graph.
11. Defendant is not advised except by the Bill of Com-
plaint, with respect to the suits, mandates, decrees or injune-
tional orders referred to in Paragraphs Nos. 8, 9, 10 and 11
of the Bill of Complaint, and therefore calls upon plaintiff to
make proper proof of the same.
12. The defendant is informed and believes, and therefore
avers the fact to be, that said Letters Patent No. 1,195,923,
and each of the claims thereof, is invalid and void for the
following reasons:
a—Because Robert Gans, the patentee of said Letters Pa-
tent No. 1,195,923, was not the first and original inventor of
the alleged improvements described and claimed in said Let-
ters Patent, but the same thing, in all material and essential
features, was, previous to the alleged invention by said Robert
Gans, and more than two years before the date of the applica-
tion for the said Letters Patent No. 1,195,923, fully described
and set forth in the following Letters Patent of the United
— and foreign countries and in other publications, as fol-
Ows:
United States Patents:
W. Jasper No. 47,308 Apr. 18, 1865
F. Bommarius No. 632,091 Aug. 29, 1899
J. J. MeTighe No. 391,328 Oct. 16, 1888
G. D. Gerson No. 402,433 Apr. 30, 1889
. H. & I. H. Jewell No. 418,186 Dec. 31, 1889
. H. Jewell No. 423,430 Mar. 18, 1890
. H. Jewell No. 418,335 Dec. 31, 1889
. H. & W. H. Jewell No. 425,573 Apr. 15, 1890
. H. Jewell No. 377,389 Feb. 7, 1888
H. Jewell No. 377,390 Feb. 7, 1888
H. & I. H. Jewell No. 413,671 Oct. 29, 1889
vis & Riddell No. 450,223 Apr. 14, 1891
. L. Duggan No. 1,276,629 Aug. 20, 1918
. P. Allen No. 538,720 May 7, 1895
. B. Heideman No. 547,547 Oct. 8, 1895
O. H. Jewell, et al. No. 478,261 July 5, 1892
J. M. Davidson No. 544,566 Aug. 13, 1895
T. H. Boyer No. 554,858 Feb. 18, 1896
ejojoyo)
ojo}~)
9
Py
&
Answer. 11
W. M. Deichler No. 613,194 Oct. 25, 1898
V. C. Driesback No. 630,670 Aug. 15, 1899
F. Bommarius No. 707,899 Aug. 26, 1902
F. E. Bachman No. 678,532 July 18, 1901
R. Gans No. 943,535 Dec. 14, 1909
(Reissue) No. 13,688 Feb. 17, 1914
Massaciu & Newman No. 1,202,557 Qct. 24, 1916
(In part continuation of appl’n filed Nov. 18, 1910)
R. Gans No. 960,687 June 7, 1910.
Foreign Patents:
British patent—Wetter No. 26,842 of 1909
British patent—Evans No. 3,870 of 1911
German patent—F’. Harm No. 95,447 of June 2, 1896
German patent—Riedel Akt——Ges. No. 197,111 of Oct. 26,
1906
German patent—H. Leister No. 211,084 of June 24, 1909
German Gebrauchsmuster, J. D. Riedel, Akt. No. 313,671 of
June 27, 1907
German Gebrauchsmuster, August Neumann, No. 341,650 of
May 15, 1908
German Gebrauchsmuster, August Neumann No. 342,212 of
May 19, 1908
German Gebrauchsmuster, August Neumann No. 341,512 of
June 15, 1908.
Publications :
Pages 59 to 69, inclusive, of Vol. 3 of ‘‘V Internationaler
Kongress fur Angewandte Chemie, Berlin, 1903’’.
Page 1078 of ‘‘Chemiker Zeitung, 1903, No. 87.’’
Pages 691-°92 of ‘‘Chemiker Zeitung, 1907, No. 55.’’
Page 246 of ‘‘Best Sugar Manufacture & Refining, Ware,
Pages 367 to 369, inclusive, of ‘‘Outlines of Industrial
Chemistry—Thorp, 1898.’’
Pages 1172 and 1173 of ‘‘ Journal Society Chemical Indus-
try, Dec. 15, 1908.’’
‘‘Modern Methods of Water Purification,’? Don & Chris-
holm, 1913, second edition, pages 188 to 193, inclusive; pages
254 to 256, inclusive, and page 250. ;
Centralblatt fur die Zuckerindustrie #49, XV. Jahrg,
Magdeburg, 7 September, 1907, pp. 1307-1310.
18 Centralblatt fur die Zuckerindustrie, Magedeburg, 16
November, 1907, No. 7, XVI. Jahr, pp. 172-174 and 373-
4,
Poggendorfs Annalen Bd. 105 of 1858, p. 132.
12 Answer.
Landwirtschaft] Versuchsatationen, Dresden, Bd. 2, 1859,
p. 113 et seq., Dr. E. Peters.
Die Deutsche Zuckerindustrie, Berlin, Apr. 12 and 19, 1901,
7 Landwirtschaft] Versuchsatationen, Berlin, Bd. 55, 1901, p.
149, Dr. A. Rumpler.
Jahrbuch der Kgl. Preuss. Geolog. Landesenstalt und
Berga-Kademic feer 1905, Bd. XXVII., Heft 1, Berlin, p.
180-181.
Jahrbuch der Kgl. Preuss. Geolog. Landesanstalt und
Berga-Kademic feer 1906, Bd. XXVII., Heft 1, Berlin, p. 79.
Catalog of Permutit Filter Co. G.m.b.H. Berlin N-39. (Ex-
hibit 47 in Buffalo case).
Catalog of Permutit Filter Co. G.m.b.H. advertising the
‘‘Aquaril’’ Filter. (Exhibit 48 in Buffalo case).
Zeitschrift fur Angewandte Chemie und Zentralblatt fur
technische Chemie, Heft 2, Leipsig, May 28, 1909, pages 1019
to 1024.
Chemische Industrie, April 15, 1909, Vol. 32, pp. 197 to 199,
wherein appears the article ‘‘Ueber die technische Bedeutung
der Permutite, (der kunstlichen zeolithartigen Verbiundun-
gen)’’ von Dr. Gans.
Technische Rundschau, supplement of Berliner Tageblatt,
January 27 and January 28, 1909, pages 43 and 44, an article
entitled ‘‘Wasserreinigungs-Verfahren mit Permutit.’’
Die Saison, for October 1908, No. 241, p. 1025, wherein ap-
pears ihe article ‘‘Weichwasser-Filter, Aquaricl.’’
and in many other Letters Patent and printed publications
not known to this defendant, but the data concerning which
when discovered thereafter, the defendant prays leave of
court to furnish and incorporate herein by suitable amend-
ment. ;
19 b—Because the said alleged invention of the said
Robert Gans, in every material and substantial part
thereof, was known to and used by and was the completed
invention of others in this country prior to the alleged inven-
tion thereof by the said Robert Gans, and was in public use
and on sale in this country for more than two years prior to
the filing of the application for said Letters Patent No. 1,195,-
923; and the names and residences of the persons who in-
vented or who had prior knowledge of the thing patented,
and the places where and the names of the persons by whom
it was publicly used and on sale in this country for more than
Answer. 13
two years prior to the filing of the application for said Let-
ters Patent are as follows: :
Name Residence Place of Public Use & Sale
Omar H. Jewell—Chicago, Illinois—Chicago, Illinois :
O. H. Jewell Filter Co.—Chicago, Ill.—Chicago, Illinois
Charles P. Allen—Denver, Colorado—Denver, Colorado and
elsewhere ; a ’
Chester B. Davis, Edward H. Riddell—Chicago, Illinois—Chi-
cago, Illinois and elsewhere
University Hospital—Kansas City, Mo.—Kansas City, Mo.
since 1902
Samuel Hird & Sons—Passaic, New Jersey—Passaic, New
Jersey.
13. The defendant is informed and believes, and therefore
avers the fact to be, that Letters Patent No. 1,348,977, issued
August 10, 1920, to George Leonard Borrowman, and each of
the claims thereof, is invalid and void for the following rea-
sons:
a—Because George Leonard Borrowman, the patentee of
said Letters Patent No. 1,348,977, was not the first and orig-
inal inventor of the alleged improvements described and
claimed in said Letters Patent, but the same thing, in all ma-
terial and essential features, was, previous to the alleged in-
vention by said George Leonard Borrowman, and more
20 than two years before the date of the application for the
said Letters Patent No. 1,348,977, fully described and set
forth in the following Letters Patent of the United States
and foreign countries and in other publications as follows:
Geo. H. Widner No. 1,207,896 Dec. 12, 1916
Robert Gans No. 951,641 Mar. 8, 1910
Robert Gans No. 914,403 Mar. 9, 1909.
Valerius Kobalt No. 1,147,515 July 20, 1915
Robert Gans No. 1,121,490 Dec. 15, 1914
Robert Gans No. 943,535 Dec. 14, 1909
Robert Gans (Reissue) No. 13,688 Feb. 17, 1914,
and in many other Letters Patent and printed publications
not known to this defendant, but the data concerning which
when discovered thereafter, the defendant prays leaye of
court to furnish and incorporate herein by suitable amend-
ment.
b—Because the said alleged invention of the said George
Leonard Borrowman, in every material and substantial part
thereof, was known to and used by and was the completed
invention of others in this country prior to the alleged in-
vention thereof by the said George Leonard Borrowman,
14 Answer.
and was in public use and on sale in this country for more
than two years prior to the filing of the application for said
Letters Patent No. 1,195,923; and the names and residences
of the persons who invented or who had prior knowledge of
the thing patented, and the places where and the names of
the persons by whom it was publicly used and on sale in this
country for more than two years prior to the filing of the
application for said Letters Patent are as follows:
Place of Pub-
Neme : Residence lic Use & Sale
Geo. H. Widner DesMoines, Iowa DesMoines, Iowa
Valerius Kokelt Berlin, Germany
21 14. The defendant is informed and believes, and there-
fore avers the fact to be, that Letters Patent No. 1,455,-
363, issued May 15, 1923, to Arthur C. Spencer, and each of
the claims thereof, is invalid and void for the following rea-
sOns :
a—Because Arthur C. Spencer, the patentee of said Letters
Patent No. 1,455,363, was not the first and original inventor
of the alleged improvements described and claimed in said
Letters Patent, but the same thing, in all material and essen-
tial features, was, previous to the alleged invention by said
Arthur C. Spencer, and more than two years before the date
of the application for the said Letters Patent No. 1,455,383,
fully described and set forth in the following Letters Patent
of the United States and foreign countries and in other pub-
lications as follows:
Cornelius Massaciu No. 1,202,557 Oct. 24, 1916.
Ferdinand Blumental No. 1,212,007 Jan. 9, 1917
Adalbert Kolb No. 1,193,794 Aug. 8, 1916.
Adalbert Kolb No. 1,193,795 Aug. 8, 1916.
Permutit Filter Co. Br. 26,094 of 1910.
Deutsche-Filtercompagne Br. 3,057 of 1912.
Pages 683-684 of Dana’s System of Mineralogy, 6th Edi-
tion, John Wiley & Sons, New York.
Page 200, ‘‘Agriculture in Some of Its Relations With
we ° by Storer, 4th Edition, 1892, Vol. 1, Chapter
Encyclopedia Britannia, 11th Edition.
and in many other Letters Patent and printed publications
not known to this defendant, but the data concerning which
when discovered thereafter, the defendant prays leave of
court to furnish and incorporate herein by suitable amend-
ment.
EPSON ERE ELE BREIL LLL ENO BE ROGY EPTE LINEA OSE SLATE SES BLINN TERE NE RH
Answer. 15
22 b—Because the said alleged invention of the said Ar-
thur C. Spencer, in every material and substantial part
thereof, was known to and used by and was the completed
invention of others in this country prior to the alleged in-
vention thereof by the said Arthur C. Spencer, and was in
ublic use and on sale in this country for more than two years
prior to the filing of the application for said Letters Patent
No. 1,455,363; and the names and residences of the persons
who invented or who had prior knowledge of the thing pat-
ented, and the places where and the names of the persons by
whom it was publicly used and on sale in this country for
more than two years prior to the filing of the application
for said Letters Patent are as follows:
Place of Public
Name Residence Use & Sale
Ferdinand Blumental Cologne-Brannsfeld,
Germany
c—Because the said inventions purported to be covered by
said Letters Patent Nos. 1,195,923, 1,348,977 and 1,455,383, and
particularly set forth in the claims thereof, are devoid of
‘substantial novelty in view of the well-known state of the art,
and in each case does not constitute patentable subject-matter
or invention or discovery within the meaning of the statute.
- @—Because said Letters Patent Nos. 1,195,923, 1,348,977
and 1,455,363, set forth and describe old and familiar means
of common knowledge and in common use long prior to the
alleged invention thereof by said respective patentees, Rob-
ert Gans, George Leonard Borrowman and Arthur C. Spencer,
and that said alleged improvements required for their pro-
duction only the exercise of ordinary skill and knowledge of
those skilled in the art to which said inventions belong, and
in analogous arts, and that the details of construction and
23 the steps in the processes and methods required nothing
more than the merest mechanical skill commonly em-
ployed in the work where such alleged inventions might be
utilized.
15. The defendant further avers, upon information and
belief, that the claims of said Letters Patent Nos. 1,195,923,
1,348,977 and 1,455,363 are so limited and restricted by the
prior art, as well as by the acts of said respective inventors
and their duly authorized attorneys in prosecuting the appli-
cations for said Letters Patent, and particularly by the limi-
tations and restrictions made therein under the requirements
of the Commissioner of Patents during the proceedings in
the Patent Office while said applications were pending there-
BR SRB HT TAUPO EY Ue oR ER PRY bane neni ae cast am
PP ALS ELIE
MIE SEIS MES
|
. 26, 1930.
16 Demand Under Equity Rule 58.
in, as to exclude therefrom any constructions sold by the
defendant, and said Letters Patent are thereby limited and
restricted to the particular construction, arrangement and de
scription of parts, and processes and methods shown and de
scribed in said Letters Patent, and the plaintiff is therefor
estopped from obtaining a broader construction of said
claims, such as would include any structure made or sold
defendant or any processes or methods used by defendant.
16. Defendant denies that it has done any act or thing or
is doing any act or thing, or proposes to do any act or thing
in violation of any alleged rights, exclusive or otherwise, be.
longing to plaintiff or secured by it by said Letters Patent
Nos. 1,195,923, 1,348,977 and 1,454,363, or that the plaintiff is
entitled to an injunction or any other relief whatsoever,
24 Wherefore, the defendant prays—
That the Bill of Complaint be dismissed and the rea.
sonable costs and charges incurred by the defendant be taxed
against the plaintiff; and
That the defendant may have such other and further relief
as the circumstances may require.
Graver CorPoRATION
By Wrixinson, Huxuey, Byron & Knicut
Solicitors for Defendant.
Cuas. L. Byron
Of Counsel.
April 11, 1928.
(Endorsed) Filed Apr. 18, 1928. Charles M. Bates Clerk
25 And on, to wit, the 26th day of August, A. D. 1923,
came the Defendant by its attorneys and filed in ths
Clerk’s office of said Court a certain Demand Under Equity
Rule 58 in words and figures following, to wit:
26 ‘* * (Caption) * °
DEMAND UNDER EQUITY RULE 58.
Messrs. Cooper, Kerr & Dunham,
Counsel for Plaintiff,
42 Broadway,
New York, N. Y.
Gentlemen :
Pursuant to Equity Rule No. 58, demand is hereby made
t
Demand Under Equity Rule 58. 17
by defendant upon plaintiff to admit, in writing, the execu-
tion or genuineness of a letter dated March 18, 1920, and
addressed to Dr. Chas. F. McKenna, 50 Church Street New
York, N. Y., and written by or on behalf of plaintiff, and
signed by Thomas R. Duggan as technical manager of the
plaintiff corporation, a copy of which letter is hereto at-
ched.
ss Respectfully,
Wrxrinson, Huxiey, Byron & Knicut
Counsel for Defendant.
Chicago, Illinois.
August 23, 1929.
Service of the above Demand Under Rule 58 is hereby
a this 23d day of August, 1929, by and on behalf
of plaintiff.
Gzorce A. Curitron
Solicitor for Plaintiff.
27 The Permutit Company
440 Fourth Ave.
New York
March 18th, 1920.
Dr. Chas. F. McKenna,
50 Church Street,
New York, N. Y.
Dear Doctor McKenna :—
When talking with you over the phone a few days since,
I promised to send you some of the literature of this Com.
pany so that you might be acquainted with what we do.
We really are what you could call ‘‘Water Doctors’’, and
if anyone having any trouble with their water will kindly
send us a sample and particulars of the trouble they have,
we will undertake to cure it by some method or another,
mostly the ‘‘Permutit’’ Process but we do not confine our-
selves to that. We always hold ourselves open to any process
which might meet the particular case in hand, as there are
cases, though very few, in which the ‘‘Permutit”’ process
may not be suitable. When we have a case of this kind we
do not hesitate to suggest other kinds of processes, but we
have yet to find one which can not be treated by the ‘‘Per-
mutit”? process. There might be commercial reasons why it
would not go in but they are few and far between.
The process is a very simple one as you will notice by the
iteratures which we enclose. It is nothing more or less than a
filter but the bed, instead of being sand or some other mate-
18 Stipulation to Amend Answer.
rial, is a zeolite which is manufactured in our factory in
Brooklyn. Through this water passes, and in passing the
mineral constituents Calcium and Magnesium are exchan
for the corresponding Sodium salts so that all hardening
materials are taken from the water, leaving a water of abso-
lutely zero hardness which, as you know, is impossible to be
obtained by any of the older processes in existence—not even
hot lime soda will do it although that is not a bad process,
The apparatus is simpler than any other and requires less
attention, being practically foolproof.
Should you at any time come across any clients looking for
a process which will take up less room than the larger
28 methods require, we shall always be pleased to discuss
matters with you and either work through you as the
consulting man or take up the matter directly with any client
you may introduce to us.
We have now several thousand plants in operation, vary-
ing from 500 gallons per day water treated to as many as
3,000,000 gallons per day, without considering Government
plants and the like. You will notice in a Government bulletin
which we are sending you that the process is on record as
being worth consideration and we have several other inter-
esting pamphlets which you will no doubt cast your eyes over
and give us the benefit of your wide connection should occa-
sion arise.
Thanking you for your kind consideration, we are
Yours very truly,
' Tse Permutir Company
Taos. R. Duaaan,
Technical Manager.
TRD:MK
Enclosures
(Endorsed) Filed Aug. 26-1929 Charles M. Bates, Clerk.
29 And on, to wit, the 26th day of August, 1929, came the
parties by their attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s office
of said Court a certain Stipulation in words and figures fol-
lowing, to wit:
30 ° * (epties) * *°
STIPULATION.
It Is Hereby Stipulated, by and between the parties hereto,
that defendant may amend its Answer as follows:
LAS EU OIL ELE NL ILI CRANE NAMA RRR
Answer to Demand. 19
By adding to paragraph (a), page 4, line 6, after ‘‘and’’
the word —/or— | a
By adding to the list of publications on pages 5 and 6 of
the Answer, the following:
Pages 721 and 722 of ‘‘The Practical Engineer’, June 4,
909.
; Das Mangan im Grundwasser und seine Beseitigung, Dis-
sertation zur Erlangung der akademischen Wiirde eines
Doktor-Ingenieurs, eingereicht am 8. Juni 1909, von Weiss,
Stadtbaumeister in Glogau, Miindliche Prafung am 27. April
910.
Grorce A. CHRITTON
Solicitor for Plaintiff
Wuxinson, Huxtey, Byron & Knicut °
Counsel for Defendant.
Chicago, Illinois
August 23, 1929.
Approved
Wa rer C. Linpiey
United States District Judge.
(Endorsed) Filed Aug. 26, 1929 Charles M. Bates Clerk
1 And on, to wit, the 31st day of August, A. D. 1929, came
the plaintiff by its attorneys and filed in the Clerk’s of-
fice of said Court a certain Answer to Demand in words and
figures following, to wit:
32 -* fee *
ANSWER TO DEMAND.
Filed Aug 31, 1929.
Messrs. Wilkinson, Huxley, Byron & Knight
Solicitors for Defendant,
First National Bank Building,
Chicago, {]l.
Sirs:
Plaintiff, pursuant to Equity Rule 58 and without waiver
of exceptions and objections, admits the letter dated March
18, 1920 addressed to Dr. Chas. F. McKenna, 50 Church
Street, New York, N. Y., a copy of which is annexed to de-
mand of defendant dated August 23, 1929, was written on be-
EELS MESSI IER NPE PON SIM TE PHC BYRNE SION A MeO MH RE RR IN OR oe
20 Stipulation to Amend Answer.
half of plaintiff and signed by Thomas R. Duggan as its tech.
nical manger.
Respectfully,
DyrenrortH, Lee, Curitton & WILEs,
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
August 29th 1929.
‘Service of the foregoing answer to demand and the re
—_ of a copy thereof admitted this 29th day of August
1929.
Wirkinson, Huxiry, Byron & Kyieat,
Solicitors for Defendamt,
(Endorsed) Filed Aug. 31-1929 Charles M. Bates Clerk
33 And on, to wit, the 5th day of September, A. D. 1929,
came the parties hereto by their attorneys and filed in
the Clerk’s office of said Court a certain Stipulation in words
and figures following, to wit:
5, 1929.
34 ° ° @aptien.) ° *
STIPULATION
It Is Hereby Stipulated, by and between the parties hereto,
that defendant may amend its Answer as follows:
By adding to the list of publications on pages 5 and 6 of
the Answer, the worst
Chemische Industrie, Vol. 32, No. 8 (632), pp. 197-200
April 15, 1909, On the Technical Significance of the Permutits
(Artificial Zeolitic Compounds), by Dr. R. Gans, Director of
the Geonomic Laboratory of the Konig] Geologische Lande
sanstalt in Berlin.
DyrenrortH, LEE, Curitron & WILEs,
Solicitors for Plaintiff.
Wuxinson, Huxiey, Byron & Knicut,
Counsel for Defendam.
Chicago, Illinois
September 4th, 1929
Approved :
United States District Judge .
(Endorsed) Filed Sept 5-1929 Charles M. Bates Clerk.
35 (Endorsed) * * (Caption.) * * Stipulation.
See NI iM OSTA CARRERE RONEN A a _~d
Statement of Evidence. 21
was filed in the Clerk’s office of said court a certain
Narrative Statement of Testimony, in words and figures fol-
lowing, to-wit:
37 * ° (Caption) * *
NARRATIVE STATEMENT OF TESTIMONY
Be it remembered that on the trial of the above entitled
case in the District Court of the United States for the North-
ern District of Illinois, Eastern Division, before Honorable
Walter C. Lindley, Judge of said Court, the following pro-
ceedings were had, to wit:
Trial commenced October 29, 1929.
PLAINTIFF’S PRIMA FACIE TESTIMONY
Plaintiff offered in evidence a copy of the Gans patent in
suit No. 1,195,923, said patent being marked plaintiff’s Ex-
hibit A.
38 Plaintiff offered in evidence certain stipulations and
exhibits bound in a single volume, said volume being
marked plaintiff’s Exhibit B and contains the following :—
1. Stipulation dated March 30, 1929.
2. Defendant’s bulletin dated February 1, 1923. (Pl. Ex.
10 on Preliminary Injunction.)
3. Defendant’s bulletin dated June 1, 1925. (Pl. Ex. 11
on Preliminary Injunction. )
4. Defendant’s bulletin dated October 15, 1927. (Pl. Ex.
12 on Preliminary Injunction.
5. Defendant’s Model ‘‘D”’ bulletin. (PI. Ex. 13 on Pre-
liminary Injunction. )
6. Blueprint No. C-243. (Pl. Ex. 14 on Preliminary In-
junction.)
7. Blueprint No. C-242. (Pl. Ex. 15 on Preliminary In-
junction.)
8. Blueprint No. C-240. (Pl. Ex. 16 on Preliminary In-
junction.)
9. Defendant’s Model ‘‘C’’ bulletin. (Pl. Ex. 30 on Pre-
liminary Injunction. )
10. Defendant’s bulletin ‘‘Soft Water for Textile Pur-
poses.’’ (PI. Ex. 31 on Preliminary Injunction.)
11. Depositions of Morton, Applebaum and Howard.
36 And on to-wit: the 8th day of May, A. DL. 1930, there "4,
Statement of Evidence.
Exhibit 4 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 5 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 7 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 8 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 9 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 10 referred to in depositions.
Exhibit 12 referred to in depositions.
. Stipulation of Plaintiff’s test of March 27, 1909
attached blueprints:
Blueprint -338-A
Blueprint ZW-608
Blueprint C-1941
20. Stipulation of Plaintiff’s second test of May 15, 1%
and attached exhibits.
Letter—Cooper, Kerr & Dunham to Mr. Byron.
Letter—Mr. Byron to Cooper, Kerr & Dunham.
Blueprint G-259.
39 HOWARD L. TIGER, being first duly sworn on behalf of
plaintiff, testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Cooper.
My name is Howard L. Tiger, I live at 240 West 98t
Street, New York City. I am an engineer with the Per
mutit Company, plaintiff here. I have been connected wit
it almost eleven years. I was technically educated; I tod
an rs course at New York University, obtained my
Bachelor’s Degree in 1918 and Engineer’s Degree the folle
ing year. I was in the employ of some other companies for
short period following my graduation, but for about elev
years with the plaintiff. I am Assistant Technical Manager
with the plaintiff. I have to do with its output and the qu
tity of its output; where the devices are put into use
what purposes they serve.
At counsel’s request I have taken from the books of
plaintiff, figures which show the output for years beginni
with the year 1919.
Mr. Cooper: I may explain to your Honor that in t
stipulated testimony the plaintiff’s business up to a part di
1919 is included in the papers in Exhibit B and I am simph
carrying it on from that point.
40 Q. Will you give the figures that represent the plai
tiff’s output of these water softeners and the zeolite
that go with them and the appurtenant apparatus?
Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 23
Mr. Byron: Your Honor, of course, this is entirely imma-
terial and impertinent, and I see no reason why it should go
in. I have no great objection, but it is simply immaterial.
The Court: I suppose the purpose is to show the com-
mercial success. 1 don’t know as. it is very material, but he
may answer. Q
The Witness: (Continuing) During the year 1919 the
Company’s turn-over amounted to approximately $800,000.
During successive years it increased until in the year 1928
the Company’s turn-over amounted to approximately
$2,500,000. During the same year 1928 the business of the
Company’s licensees amounted to about six or seven hun-
dred thousand dollars, making a total of something over
$3,000,000 for the year 1928. During 1929 the rate of output
has been approximately the same as 1928.
When I spoke of turn-over I meant output, that is, the
sales.
In the textile industry these water softeners have had a
very marked effect. Whereas in previous years the textile
manufacturer was limited in his location by the need for an
abundant supply of soft water, the advent and development
of the zeolite water softeners has made him practically inde-
ndent of the hardness of the water. He is now, there-
41 fore, free to choose his location for other reasons because
he now knows that he can be assured of an absolutely
soft water supply by the use of the zeolite softener.
We can see an example of this development in the rayon
industry, which is a comparatively new industry. We can
find rayon factories located in various parts ef the coun-
try, where the water is hard, as, for instance, the big Du-
pont factories at Boffalo, where the water is hard, as the
water is at Chicago, the Great Lakes, and we can find rayon
companies in Pennsylvania in hard water districts, in con-
tradistinction to the location of the other textile industries
which previously sought natural soft water locations and
therefore concentrated in such districts as New England
anc the south.
The piaintiff’s business in household softeners amounted
to approximately 300 to 500 thousand dollars per annum, and
the business of its licensees for household softeners in the
year 1928 amounted to approximately $400,000 per annum,
at that rate.
I would say about $150 to $200 per unit would be an aver-
age figure to represent the individual selling price of the
plaintiff’s water softeners of the size for domestic use. And
24 Statement of Evidence.
as to its licensees, their average is probably a liittle lo
I would say about $100 a unit. |
42 I am familiar with the defendant’s water softenen
here which have been conveniently identified as to cop
struction by the defendant as its 1923 kind, being a down
flow softener and then its 1925 down-flow softener an
thirdly its 1927 up-flow softener. I am the author of th
three diagrammatic drawings illustrating the flow unde
various conditions in the defendant’s 1923, 1925 and 199
softeners.
Taking those three drawings which were known on the pre
liminary injunction motion as Plaintiff’s Exhibits 14, 15 an
16, and which are included in the Exhibit B in the trial,]
will explain first the conditions of flow in the defendant’
down-flow softener of 1923, represented by the diagram Ex
hibit 14 on the injunction motion.
Starting with normal operation, which is labeled, ‘‘Softes
-ing’’ in the upper left hand figure, in this figure the cours
of flow is as follows: the hard water enters through the Pe
6, passes upwardly through the pipe 7, out of the end o
pipe 9, which terminates inside the softener near the top
The water then passes downwardly through the zeolite be
into the collector system marked 4, out through the pipe I
and 11, through the meter 30 to service.
43 When the softener has softened its capacity of wate
it requires back-washing. That is described in Fig. 2 m
the drawing. The course of flow is as follows: the har
water enters through the inlet pipe 6, passing through pipe
12 and 10 into the softener and then out of the distributia
system at the bottom of the softener, upwardly through th
gravel supporting layers and the zeolite bed and out at th
top of the softener through pipes 9, 8 and 13 to waste. Dur
ing this operation—it is called back-washing because it is th
reverse direction of flow to what we had in the preceding
- operation. Its effect, if carried out at the proper rate, is t
remove from the zeolite the suspended matter or dirt anf
slime which has accumulated on the surface of that bed dur.
ing the softening of the water.
The proper rate of back-washing a softener is one thal
causes the zeolite bed to obtain a semi-suspended conditior
so that the granules of zeolite can rub against each othe
and the dirt can be loosened from the zeolites and carrie
off by the stream of water, into the sewer.
In the third condition shown on the Sub-Fig. 3 on thi
same exhibit, the zeolite bed is now ready to be regenerate
Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 25:
or revivified by the salt solution and in Fig. 3 this is ac-
complished by opening the valve in the brine inlet line, that
is, the line eonnecting the brine preparation tank with the
44 softener itself. This permits the brine to enter through
the distribution system 15 whence it passes downwardly
through the zeolite bed, out through the collector manifold
at the bottom of the softener and out through pipe 16 to
waste.
The next operation is to rinse out of the softener the
brine which is still contained in there, and that is carried
out in the operation of regenerating or rinsing. In this op-
eration the hard water enters through the pipe 6, 7 and 8
and passes into the softener through the pipe 9, and then
downwardly through the zeolite bed and down to the bot-
tom of the softener, out through the manifold 4—the mani-
fold means the collecting apc through the manifold 4
and the pipe 16 to waste. is operation is carried out until
the water coming out of the softener is soft and the softener
is now ready to be placed in operation again for softening.
I will take up the defendant’s other softening apparatus
put out in the year 1925 as the various operations are illus-
trated on tho ‘drawing, which is plaintiff’s exhibit 15. This
is also a down-flow softener, that is, the water is softened
by passing downwardly through the bed of zeolite. In Fig. 1
in the upper lefthand corner the softening operation is illus-
trated. In this operation the hard water enters through the
pipe 6, 7, 8, enters the softener through the pipe 9 and
45 then passes downwardly through the zeolite bed, down
to the bottom of the softener through the notched ring
21, out of the pipe 10 to service. When the softener has soft-
ened all the water it can, the bed is back-washed. That oper-
ation is illustrated in Fig. 2. In this operation the hard
water enters pipe 6, _— through pipe 12, 11, 10, down to
the bottom of the softener, out through the openings in the
notched collar 21, upwardly through the supporting screen
20, and then through the gravel supporting layer and then
through the zeolite bed, out of the pipe 9, 8, 16, 17, to waste.
When the bed has been properly back-washed the softener
is ready for regeneration. That operation is illustrated in
Fig. 3 at the lower left hand. In this operation the brine is
introduced into the softener from the brine tank by means
of a water ejector; it happens in this case, passes in through
pipe 22, 8, 9, downwardly through the zeolite bed, down to
the bottom of the softener through the supporting plate,
26 Statement of Evidence.
through the notches in the collar, out through pipe 10, 18, 17,
to waste.
After the requisite amount of brine has been passed into
the softener, it is necessary to rinse the softener free from
salt. That operation is illustrated in Fig 4. In this opera.
tion the hard water enters through Pipe 6, 7, 8, 9, passes in
at the top of the softener, downwardly through the zeolite
bed to the supporting gravel layer, then through the perfo.
rated screen 20 and then down to the bottom of the softener
through the notches in the ring collar 21 and then out.
46 wardly through the pipe 10, 18, 17, to waste. This oper-
ation is carried on until the effluent of the softener is
soft and the unit is now ready to be placed in service again.
In like manner I will take up the defendant’s up-flow
softener of 1927 in connection with the drawing made and
which was known as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 16 on the preliminary
injunction motion. This is an illustration of an up-flow soft-
ener, that is, the water during the softening operation passes
upwardly through the zeolite bed. The normal operation of
softening is illustrated in Fig. 1 in the upper lefthand cor.
ner. In this operation the hard water enters through the
meter at 30, the pipe 11, the pipe 10, passes down to the bot-
tom of the softener, then upwardly through the supporting
screen plate 20, then through the gravel layers 3, then up-
wardly through the zeolite bed 2 and out at the top of the
softener through pipe 9, 8, 7 and 6 to service.
When the softener has softened all the water for which
its capacity is rated, it requires regeneration. This operation
is illustrated in Fig. 2. In that figure the brine is passed
into the softener by means of an injector through pipe line
22, then through the end of pipe 9 into the top of the soft-
ener, then downward through the zeolite bed, through the
gravel layer to the supporting screen 20, down to the bottom
of the softener and through the notches in the collar, out
through.pipe 10, 18 and 17 to waste.
47 When the requisite amount of brine has been intro-
duced the softener requires rinsing or washing, as illus-
trated in Fig. 3 of the drawing. In this operation the hard
water enters through the meter and pipe line 11, 7, 8, 9,
passes in at the top of the softener, downward through the
zeolite bed, down through the gravel layers, through the sup-
porting screen 20 to the bottom of the softener, through the
notches in the ring collar 21 at the bottom, upwardly through
pipe 10, 18, 17, to waste. When that operation is completed
it is necessary to displace from the softener the hard water
Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 27
which is lying above the zeolite bed, that hard water having
been introduced during the previous rinsing operation. To
accomplish this hard water displacement or rewashing,
which is illustrated in Fig. 4 on the drawing, the hard water
is admitted through pipe line 11 and 10 and passes down to
the bottom of the softener, out through the notches in ring
21, upwardly through the screen, through the gravel layer
through the zeelite bed, out of the top of the softener
through pipe line 9, 8, 17, to waste until the effluent is soft,
at which time the softener is again ready to be placed in op-
eration.
Now, with reference to this diagram I have just been con-
sidering, these devices that resemble circles with crosses
through them, are just turn-on and shut-off valves. The
48 symbol c indicates a condition of closure and the symbol
o the condition of being open.
I have prepared sketches to show what changes would be
necessary in the defendant’s down-flow softener of 1925 to
make it into an up-flow softener of the 1927 variety. This
sketch which I have marked number 1 in the upper right-
hand corner is an illustration of the Graver 1925 down-flow
softener. I have noted on this sketch with red arrows the
positions to which two valves would have to be changed in
order to so arrange this softener that it could be operated
as an up-flow. In order to make that clearer, I have illus-
trated the softener with the valves in those new positions on
this second sketch marked number 2 in the upper right hand
corner. With this new location of the valves the pipe line
that was formerly the hard water inlet now becomes the soft
water outlet, the pipe that was the soft water outlet is now
the hard water inlet, so that this softener can be operated as
an up-flow softener.
The Court: Those are the only changes necessary?
The Witness: A change in the position of these two valves
and the change or reversal of the soft water connection with
the hard water connection.
49 I have prepared also a third sketch, which illustrates
how the softener of the type illustrated on sketch num-
ber 2 could again be changed so as to operate down-flow.
This change I have again illustrated in red. It shows that
by connecting the soft water outlet to the pipe which comes
out of the bottom of the softener instead of to the position
it occupies on sketch number 2 we have a softener which can
again be operated down-flow.
(Three sketches made by witness Tiger received in evi-
28 Statement of Evidence.
dence and marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBITS C, D and E.)
Now, on the three drawings which I previously explained,
the lightly dotted area at the right hand side of those vari-
ous figures of Plaintiff’s Exhibits 14, 15, and 16 on the in-
junction motion, illustrate approximately the position ana
extent of the zeolite beds as they are in the defendant’s soft-
eners and above that dotted area on the right hand side of
each of those drawings is space.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Byron.
50 Mr. Byron: Q. Your position, Mr. Tiger, in discussing
_ these three free hand sketches and the necessary changes
to change from an up-flow to a down-flow by shifting the posi-
tion of a few valves and changing the piping a little bit in-
dicates, I suppose, that you take the position that there is
no difference between an up-flow softener and a down-flow
softener, is that correct?
Mr. Cooper: Your Honor please, there again I am not
calling the witness on any matter of opinion, but simply on
a matter of fact.
Mr. Byron: Well, they have talked about the same thing.
The Court: I understand the examination of this witness
was confined to the question of how he changed it from one
form to the other. He gave no statement of any conclusion
or any opinion upon his part as to whether or not the change
lie invention or whether it had any significance at
Mr. Byron: Q. Then the change is a simple one, is it?
A. I would say it is.
Q. And you would say that a plumber could make those
changes?
51 Mr. Cooper: There again I will make an objection.
The Court: Sustained. This witness simply answered
this question. He says, ‘‘I changed it from that’’ and then
he said he changed it from ‘‘this to this.’’ ‘‘I changed two
valves and changed my connections on the soft water and the
hard water and I made it from a down-flow to an up-flow.”’
He did not express any opinion about it, but merely stated a
fact.
Mr. Byron: Q. In connection with Plaintiff’s Exhibit 16,
plaintiff’s injunctional motion, you stated with respect to
Fig. number 4 that the back-washing or re-washing, as it is
called in Fig. 4, the function of that was to wash out the
29
Testimony of Howard L. Tiger.
hard water above the bed of zeolite into the waste pipe, is
that correct?
A. That’s what I said. ,
Q. Now, if there is salt in the bottom portion of that
casing during that re-washing operation, that salt will have
a regenerative value or effect upon the upper layer of har-
dened zeolites, will it not?
A. That would depend upon a number of factors.
Q. I said, if there is salt it will have a regenerative ef-
fect?
A. That will depend upon several factors.
Q. What are the factors?
52 A. It would depend upon the extent of exhaustion of
these upper layers of zeolite and it would depend upon
the strength of the brine solution and it would depend upon
the quantity of the brine solution and it would depend upon
the rate of passing that brine solution upwardly through the
bed and it would depend upon the distribution of that brine
through the bed and perhaps some other factors that I don’t
think of offhand.
Q. Well, if all these conditions existed, you would get a
regenerating action, would you not?
A. If all what?
If the conditions which you mentioned prevailed.
A. I did not mention any conditions. I don’t think I men-
tioned any conditions.
Q. Well, you say under certain conditions is so and so
were a fact.
A. I mentioned they were factors which involved whether
the brine would regenerate or would not, but I did not men-
tion any conditions.
Q. Well, on the assumption, then, that there was a sodium
salt solution sufficiently strong:in the bottom of the casing
to have a regenerative action on that upper layer of har-
dened zeolites, when that sodium salt solution is washed
up through the bed it would then regenerate that hardened
layer of zeolites, would it not?
53 A. If the zeolites were hardened and if the sodium
salt solution were strong enough to regenerate the zeo-
lites and if the sodium salt solution came in contact with the ;
zeolites it would have some regenerating effect. i
Q. Referring to Plaintiff’s Exhibit 16, offered on the ;
motion for preliminary injunction, the pipe 10 which extends
upwardly, according to the sketch upwardly, centrally of the
a
a
A
i |
30 Statement of Evidence.
casing, is not connected to the lowest point of the casing, is
it?
A. It is according to what you mean by the word ‘‘con-
nected.”’
Q. I am asking you whether or not that pipe 10 is con-
nected to the lowest point of the casing. The answer is yes
or no.
A. Why, the pipe is not physically connected to the lowest
point.
Q. It is not connected to the lowest point of the: casing,
then, is it?
54 <A. Not physically connected to the lowest point.
Q. That’s the best answer you will give the court, is
it?
A. That’s the best answer I can give, yes, sir.
Q. It is not mechanically connected to the lowest point of
the casing, is it?
Mr. Cooper: Is not the question how far the outlet of the
pipe is from the casing?
The Court: It is practically obvious to the Court that the
pipe does not rest upon or touch the lowest part of the con-
tainer. Therefore it could not possibly be connected with
the lowest point of the casing. It is perfectly obvious to me,
and I don’t need this witness or any other witness to tell me
it is or it is not. The diagram shows itself that it does not
touch the bottom, it rests upon something else. Let’s not
waste any time and don’t quibble, Mr. Witness.
The Witness: (Continuing) Now, that back-washing to
which I referred in Figure 4 of Plaintiff’s Exhibit 16, is a
back-washing in the usual manner, there is nothing peculiar
about it, at all. With respect to Plaintiff’s Exhibit 15, the
bach-washing in Fig. 2 is done in the usual manner; there is
nothing peculiar about that.
55 The plaintiff’s business for the year 1928 was $2,500, |
000 and the rest was made up by the business of licen-
sees. Now, then, this plaintiff, in addition to manufacturing
tanks in which zeolites are disposed, also is in the business of
producing zeolites and selling zeolites as such. And the zeo-
lite business as such, as distinguished from its tanks, is in-
cluded in this large sum of $2,500,000 to which I refer. I
believe I stated that licenses under this Gans patent in suit
have brought in six hundred to seven hundred thousand dol-
lars a year, we will say for the year 1928. Licensees pay on
up-flow softeners exclusively, so far as I know. I am of the
| Testimony of Howard L. Tiger. 31
opinion, then, that an up-flow softener is commercially oper-
able for producing good commercial results. ;
The good result in the textile industry, for example, is a
result directly of the softening ability of the zeolite water
softener system. The zeolite mineral itself cannot soften the
water unless it is placed and made into an apparatus.
Mr. Byron: Q. Please state whether or not zeolites are
capable of softening water.
Mr. Cooper: That gets on the expert side, if your Honor
lease.
Mr. Byron: This man was qualified as an engineer.
The Court: He has not testified to anything on direct to
make that proper cross examination. This witness has tes-
tified here about certain facts. He has testified as to how
56 he understands these particular water softeners illus-
trated in these particular exhibits used in the temporary
injunction case 14, 15 and 16 operate.
Mr. Byron: That is true, your Honor.
The Court: He has not told why they operate so. He
has traced the course of the water.
Mr. Byron: Has not he also, your Honor, stated the great
commercial value of these things?
The Court: He has testified that they sold last year some
$2,500,000 worth of products and that the licensee sold some
$600,000 worth.
Mr. Byron: And that the textile industries were located
in places where there was hard water because they could
use this zeolite water softener for softening the water.
The Court: Yes.
Mr. Byron: Now, I want to know if it is the zeolite that
softens the water or the casing of the softener that softens
the water.
The Court: You are wasting our time on that.
i Byron: Possibly so, but I would like to get an answer,
if I can.
The Court: Sustained. I understand there is not any
patent on these zeolites, on the product of zeolites.
Mr. Byron: Expired long ago.
57 The Court: That’s what I mean. There is no pres-
ent, no existing patent.
Mr. Cooper: Oh, there is in .some forms.
Mr. Wilkinson: May I ask just a question?
The Court: Yes.
Mr. Wilkinson: Q. The advantage to the industries that
you have referred to as being capable of location where
32 Statement of Evidence.
there is merely hard water and not soft water is due to ther
being available a suitable and satisfactory water softener, ig
that correct? j
A. That’s it, precisely.
58 EDWIN W. HAMMER, being first duly sworn, on behalf
of plaintiff, testified as follows: ,
Direct Examination by Mr. Cooper.
My name is Edwin W. Hammer, I am a consulting engineer,
with office in New York City. I am a mechanical engineer. |,
have given water softeners of the Kind involved in this case
in their construction and application, considerable thoug
and attention. -I was in attendance at the tests made at the
plaintiff’s establishment at Brooklyn, New York, the one set
on the 27th of March, 1929, and the other on the 15th of May,
1929. There are separate stipulations regarding certain fact
in those tests. :
As a result of those tests in Brooklyn on those two occa
sions I came to very definite conclusions that there was no
salt pool formed at the bottom in defendant’s 1925 down-flow
softeners and its 1927 up-flow softeners after the regeneration
and washing. !
59 The Court: In either one?
A. In neither one, and that none could be formed in
either of those constructions under normal operation.
The Witness: (Continuing) There are several bases, for
my statement of opinion, but I may say that the primary one
comes from the fact that the pipe which opens downwardly
near the bottom of the shell in the tank comes within a short
distance of the bottom of the shell. Of course, it will be un-
derstood that if the open end—
The Court: How near the bottom does it come, in inches?
A. I understand it is 3ysths inches.
The Court: 37sth inches?
A. Yes, and the pipe itself is a 2} inch pipe. Of course,
the court will apprehend that if the open-ended pipe were
brought down so as to press against the lower end of the tank,
water would be prevented from flowing into the pipe. |
The Court: There would not be any outlet? |
The Witness: It could not get in or out. Therefore it is
raised a certain distance and being raised a certain distance,
Testimony of Edwin W. Hammer. 33
and a certain short distance, and there being a definite flow
of water into it through that pipe it means that there is and
must be a definite rate of flow of that liquid a that pipe.
I made a certain calculation which showed that at 60
60 gallons per minute, substantially the rate of flow used in
these tests, there would be a velocity through that pipe
of about 235 lineal feet per minute, in the pipe. And I also
found that with that flow of 60 gallons per minute, which is a
flow that must come through the crown ring which surrounds
the lower end of that pipe and which separates the lower end
of that pipe from the balance of the compartment, the water
must flow through the openings in that crown ring at about
32 feet per minute. So that as the ring is 16 inches in di-
ameter, there must be an increase in velocity in about eight
inches from 32 feet a minute at the ring to 235 feet a minute
at the pipe, which means a tremendous acceleration in reach-
ing the pipe, which is an acceleration comparable to the action
of a fluid in an injector or an ejector, with which the Court
may be familiar and which will force everything that is in
the neighborhood of the end of that pipe into the pipe, either
as a result of a partial vacuum which you may consider to be
formed, or by reason of the great molecular friction of one
particle of fluid upon another. In other words, we know that
if we have, say a bath tub, for example, full of water, the
water has to run out and the same thing happens here and
there is a tremendous acceleration within a very short dis-
tance. The rate of flow was a rate which was settled upon as
a result of the general instruction of defendant’s bulletins
relating to these matters. We ran the water through as
rapidly as possible.
61 The Court: Was that all the direction that was given?
The Witness: That was all the data that was sub-
mitted.
The Court: And in that process what size is the inflow
pipe, two and a half inches?
The Witness: I believe it was the same size.
The Court: The outlet pipe was two and a half inches?
The Witness: Yes.
The Court: The passage was two and a half inches? —
The Witness: Yes, sir; with the pressure that was avail-
able, and considerable resistance that was offered by the bed.
The Court: Of course, we might take a variable quantity,
a variable weight, because if the pressure of the water supply
es happened to rise, the capacity would have to be
owered.
34 Statement of Evidence.
The Witness: The court must understand that if a softener
is installed in a location, for example in your home, and the
sewer pipe is not large enough to carry off the effluent by the
waste and the fresh water coming into the house is not coming
through a pipe large enough to give the proper amount of
water, the proper pressure, your device is not apt to work
satisfactorily and to give you the results that are to be ex-
pected if you have a proper layout.
The Court: In other words, the pressure would not be, or
the momentum would not be enough?
The Witness: No; it would not do its work properly.
62 This rate of flow which I have mentioned, was a quite
usual rate of flow for water softeners of the size and kind
that was tested there and is comparable to the size or area of
bed that is employed because it is desirable to get from four
to six gallons per minute per square foot of bed. That is a
broad and pretty general rate to establish.
As the result sf my study and examination of the various
defendant’s water softeners which are here involved, I would
say as to the practicability of using the type known as the
1925 down-flow for an my A softening movement that there
is nothing to prevent its use. It is merely a matter, as Mr.
Tiger has pointed out, of connecting it up for that special
purpose. The apparatus is there and adaptable to either use.
The Court: You agree with him that yor can change it by
—— two valves and two water pipes?
The Witness: Yes, sir. I make a similar answer with re-
spect to the possibility of using the 1927 up-‘low for the down-
flow operation ; these characteristics which are present in that
tank assembled as it is make it adaptable for either use when
properly connected.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Byron.
. Mr. Hammer, I believe you have made the statement
that the size of the pipe through which the raw water
63 passes into the casing is the same size as the pipe through
which the water is ejected from the casing?
A. Well, I am a little uncertain as to that. I do not re-
member whether it was two inches or two and a half.
Q. If you do not know, then your calculations may be
wrong?
A. No. No; my calculations rogarding—the calculations
I have given were based on a two and a half inch at the exit.
Q. You don’t know anything about the inlet pipe?
Lie a ig es a SSIES ELS ETLVIEDLLE PERE LEE LINE GE IIE A MY :
TE RATES rea ee oe,
Testimony of Edwin W. Hammer. 35
A. I cannot at the moment just remember what that was..
Q. You will agree with me, I assume, that you cannot put
into the casing any more water than you take out of the cas-
ing?
we No; but you can put it in at a different rate than you
can take it out.
Q. But if the diameter of that ejection pipe is the same
diameter as the inflow pipe and you have a steady flow of
water through the casing, then the rate of flow through each
of those pipes must be identical?
A. Yes.
Q. That is correct?
A. Yes.
Q. Regardless of how fast the water may go through the
notches ?
A. Yes.
64 Q. Then water going through the notches may go at
a relatively high speed and then they are stopped, they
cannot get out of the ejection pipe any faster than the ejection
ipe will let it out; can it, or any faster than the water itself
ows into the casing; is that correct?
A. No; it is not correct at all.
Q. If it is not correct, then you would soon have your cas-
ing empty of weter, wouldn’t you?
A. No; because you have the same amount of water going
out as comes in, as you say. Now, the distribution of veloci-
ties in the path depends on the relative areas. You have a
certain area in each one of these areas in the crown ring.
The Court: I think you both have the same idea, but you
are talking at cross purposes.
The Witness: Possibly.
The Court: You agree with the statement he just made.
Mr. Byron: That is, the in-flow rate and the out-flow rate
are identical.
The Court: Not necessarily.
The Witness: Not necessarily.
The Court: The inlet pipe may be of small diameter, be-
cause the diameter of the intake pipe and the outlet pipe have
a direct influence or bearing in determining that. .
65 Mr. Byron: That is correct; but we are going on the
assumption these sizes are identical.
The Witness: You may make any assumption you please.
Mr. Byron: There is not much point in talking about
SAS LR
36 Statement of Evidence.
— and pressure unless we get down to something
definite.
The Witness: (Continuing) Looking at plaintiff’s exhibit
16, there are notches in the lower plate for permitting the
passage of water down through that plate within the confines
of the collar 21. So then there would be a flow of water down
through that plate within the confines of the collar. That
flow of water would have a tendency to slow up the water
passing diametrically inward through that collar to the extent
that there is frictional contact between those streams of water
if they abutt each other to any extent, there will be a modifi-
cation.
It is hardly among the possibilities with that special con.
struction that the components of their forces in their various
paths of movement may resist each other, although they may
modify the relative velocities by reason of the angles of
impact.
I think it is in a measure true that the water passing
through that lower perforated plate within the confines of the
collar 21 will have a retarding action upon the water passing
diametrically through the notches of that collar. I would be
inclined to think, however, that the opposite would be the
66 case in that the water flowing through the large openi
might tend to dam back, and probably would materi
dam back, any water running down through those two little
components in the plate itself, because you have components
there of nine square inches through which the water may pass
readily, whereas those holes in the pipe are very small.
As a result of these different pressures and the component
of forces, I would say there could not be a swirling action in
there that is not a direct flow towards the ejection pipe; for
it has what you call a hydraulic propulsion, which forces
everything into that plate, because the velocity is high. I
know it is true, as a matter of fact, as a matter of engineering
experience, it can’t be anything else.
y cale:lations, however, did not contemplate the open-
ings through this lower plate 20, just above the collar 21, and
that would modify these figures to some extent. Sufficient
pressure of water is normally used in a softener to get the
desired rate of flow.
I could not give a figure of twelve or fifteen or twenty or
a hundred or three pounds because it will depend upon the
depth of the bed, the size of the pipe, the length of the pipes
and so on, but you must organize your system so as to get
Testimony of Edwin W. Hammer. 37
enough water through there, irrespective of what that pres-
sure is.
67 — If we assume in the first instance that we have no in-
flow of water at all but that the tank is filled, I don’t know
how fast the water, based on my calculations will pass through
these notches in the pipe as a matter of gravity action. I
don’t know what two pounds’ pressure of supply water would
do in that bed. I can’t say what flow there would be if there
were ten pounds’ or twenty pounds’ pressure or anything.
I would have to make some observations and tests. The figures
I have given are absolutely not purely theoretical. They are
based on the amount of water flowing out of that device and
on the size of the pipe and the amount of water flowin bein
in your possession, it is simply a matter of calculating the
rate at which that water was flowing.
I don’t know what the pressures are. In determining how
much water was flowing in, the amount of water that is flow-
ing in, the amount of pipe through which it passes, the pres-
sure is a matter of indifference. If the pressure were five
pounds and you increased it to twenty-five pounds, there
would be an increased velocity, because there would be more
water flowing. It does make a difference, but certainly with
the actual amount of flow it is a matter of indifference as to
what the pressure is that is forcing it.
68 I made my calculations upon the softener we used in
Brooklyn in those tests, the defendant’s up-flow softener.
Collar 21 in that particular softener also had notches up
around its upper rim, there were at least three and perhaps
four notches having an area of two square inches each, and
if that was the case it would slow down the velocity at the
crown ring to increase the acceleration between that ring and
the opening in the pipe.
If the water were flowing in through notches at the top of
this ring and flowing down through the apertures through the
plate 20, the total velocity of water or the total quantity of
water passing through the lower notches would be greatly re-
duced because there are more channels through which a given
quantity may flow.
I did not take the notches in the upper portion of the collar
into account when I was figuring, because I recognized that
not having seen those upper notches I did not know whether
there were three or four or whether there were any actually
there at all, but I made a calculation based on the four square
openings of nine square inches each and with the full recogni-
tion that if those V-shaped notches were also there, whether
38 Statement of Evidence.
there were three or whether there were four, that the effect
would be to change the rate of acceleration in the eight incheg
between that ring and the opening of the pipe. In other words,
the rate of flow at each one of those openings would be slower,
but would still have to accelerate until eight inches suc.
69 ceeded it and to the 235 feet per minute in the pipe.
Q. Now, let’s get this right here. We have water
coming in the notches at the bottom of this plate at a certain
velocity. I have just drawn a little sketch here. Now let's
assume that we have some water flowing down in this direc.
tion (indicating), the water flowing vertically downwardly
acting to overcome, to retard the movement of water in the
horizontal direction, is it not?
A. I have already stated that it might have some effect
of that nature but that the probability is that the main flow —
coming through those large openings would rather tend to dam
back the flow through the little holes in the plate.
. Why do you say that; why shouldn’t it be just as much
the other way?
A. Not at all. The one is a little volume and the other
is a large volume, and the big fellow is going to have the
major effect.
. Did you measure the apertures in the plate 20 to de
termine that fact?
A. No.
Q. Then how do you know?
A. Because I know they are small and I know that the
others are big.
Q. An eight or three-sixteenth?
A. Three square inches in these four openings.
70 . As a matter of fact then, you do not know the ac-
tual condition which existed down there as to measure-
ments of apertures, all of the apertures?
Re Not in detail, but I know pretty exactly what happens
there.
Q. Well, now, Mr. Hammer, what would be the effect if
some of the notches in the lower portion of the collar 21 were
plugged?
A. It would increase the rate of flow through the other
remaining openings.
Q. Yes. Well, now, explain to the court just why there
was a ribbon of paraffine down inside of the bottom of that
casing in the first test and found directly opposite the notches
outside of the ring, as set forth in the first stipulation?
A. Of course, I do not know the precise facts certainly,
Testimony of Edwin W. Hammer. 39
but I have a very definite idea as to what happened, which I
would be glad to give you if you want it. ;
Q. It would increase the velocity, according to your idea
of things, of the water passing through the remaining
notches?
A. If that was present when the flow was taking place
and it tended to dam up one of those openings, yes, but I
don’t think that was the case.
71 Q. You do not know?
A. Nobody knows.
Q. Well, = do know this, do you noi, that at the close
of the test defendant requested the ~~ of feeling up
into the bottom of that casing; that the privilege was granted
to Dr. Moses, an expert, practical expert for the defendant.
Dr. Moses pulled off his coat, got in the casing and opened it
up. After it was opened up he reached up into that opening
and felt around the collar and pulled out a great big crumpled
ribbon of paraffine, just outside of the notches of that ring,
don’t you?
Mr. Cooper: Don’t say great big crumpled ribbon of
paraffine. Say what it was in dimensions, if you know.
Mr. Byron: Did you bring it with you?
Mr. Cooper: I mean there was some statement. If you
are going to make any mention of it, I am perfectly willing to
have it stated in size, but not in a pictorial way.
The Witness: Perhaps it is just as well for me to explain
that situaiton, as I understand it. It may save a great deal
of trouble.
Mr. Byron: Yes, I think it is rather embarrassing. I think
you better do that.
A. In the actual construction that was used in Brooklyn
there was an opening, an artificial opening made at the
72 very bottom of the tank and a plug had been made to fit
in that opening, the purpose of that being to give an
opportunity for connecting a test valve at that point so that
the fluid might be drawn of at that point. It had been ar-
ranged that when that plug had been inserted in the openi
the space above it should be filled with paraffine so that the
surface at the top of the plug would be flush with the inside
bottom of the tank. In other words, the paraffine was an
artificial floor for the tank at that particular point.
The Court: How big was the plug?
A. Oh, in the neighborhood of three or four inches in
diameter.
The Court: And when it was inserted do you mean to say
40 Statement of Evidence.
that there was a discrepancy between this top and the floor
of the container?
Yes, sir; which was filled in by paraffine so as to re-
store as nearly as possible the natural configuration.
The Court: No declivity.
A. Right. Before Mr. Moses made this observation to
which the question refers, that plug had been withdrawn and
that ribbon of paraffine that was left behind, which I am posi-
tive was a ribbon which was cut out of that artificial floor by
the process of removal of that plug and was not a ribbon of
paraffine that could have gotten in there in any other way,
now where the doctor found that ribbon I do not know,
73 but I am positive that there was no ribbon at the time the
test was made and that the ribbon was a consequence of
taking out the plug and nothing else.
Mr. Byron: Q. Now, as a matter of fact, do you recall
when that plug was taken out whether or not the paraffine
around the rim of that plug was smooth and discolored into
a sort of a bronze yellow and did not show any marks of a new
cut on it?
A. No;Ido not recognize any such condition.
Q. Well, if that plug were removed from the central open-
ing could it be possible in withdrawing that plug downwardly
in this direction (illustrating) that the paraffine might get
away from here on that outside of the collar.
A. Yes; when the doctor put his hand in there and reached
around.
Q. That is, you think he was a little bit dishonest about it!
A. Oh, absolutely not; but I think it was a natural con-
sequence of the mechanical reaching in there that that thing
happened.
Mr. Byron: That is all I want to say on that point.
Mr. Cooper: Here is a photograph of the piece of paraffine.
Do you want it? (Exhibiting photograph to Mr. Byron.)
The Witness: (Continuing) Referring to plaintiff’s test of
defendant’s up-flow softener of March 27, 1929. At the end
of fifteen minutes, at the end of fifteen minutes down-washing,
it is stated in the stipulation that there were 220 parts
74 per million of chloride in the bottom of the casing, not
220 parts per million chlorine. The difference between
chlorine and chloride is that chlorine is a constituent of
chloride. It is expressed by the chloride radical CL. Then
at the end of the twenty minute wash there were still forty-six
parts per million. I should say that was neutral water for
water softener purposes. Forty is the same as zero so far
as the chlorine is concerned; the saltiness, you know, we can-
Testimony of Edwin W. Hammer. 41
not tell from those figures. At the end of twenty-five minutes
there were seventeen p.p.m. of CL; that indicates that there
is something down there that is not just plain water, that is,
there is some CL there, just as there is some CL in every
sample of water everywhere. : |
Then, after that twenty-five minutes of washing there was
a fifteen minutes lapse, and as a result of that fifteen minutes
lapse the concentration of the solution at the bottom of the
casing increased up to 22 p.p.m. of Cl, at the side of the tank
above the plate. eis
Q. All right. Now, what is that 20, what does that indi-
cate, side cock R is that at the side or at the center?
A. That represents a sample that was taken from the bot-
tom of the tank just inside of the crown ring that we have
talked about. Pyrat
Q. Just inside of this crown ring here (indicating) ?
es, sir.
7% QQ. All right, that is an increased concentration, be
it ever so small, that is an increased concentration, is it
not?
A. I will not say so, because at that same time at the
center cock, which is at the exact center, there was less salt
than there was in the effluent, the effluent was 17 and here
we have something at 16.
The Witness: (Continuing) The next fifteen minute mark,
at the center cock, at the end of the second fifteen minute time
there was 27 p.p.m. of CL., that shows that some of the salt
in the tank had worked down, worked its way down into the
floor down below. That shows that after 25 minutes that con-
centrate was at about the figure of 50 gallons per minute,
there was salt in the bed which was now settled down into
the casing. And the side cock at R shows 32 p.p.m. of CL.
The 27 p.p.m. is at the exact center, but 32 is just inside of
the ring and the 29 is up on the side of the tank.
Now, then, another fifteen minutes lapse. At the bottom
of page six of that stipulation. And then at the center cock
that concentration increased to 52 p.p.m. of CL. That means
still more salt was coming down out of the bed even after the
twenty-five minute washing. There is no doubt there was a
little more salt then than any other time, but at the same time
we must remember what a very small amount of salt 52 or
16 or 17 parts per million may be. It is almost in-
76 finitesmal. For example, I think it will be of interest for
me to show the court what 8000 parts per million of
actual salt was when taken from the center cock at the end of
42 Statement of Evidence. =
the test, where there was the greatest concentration, due to
the fact that there was a vermiform appendix where the fluid
could not get out, and I will hand that to the court for hig
observation, 8000 per million. ;
Q. I think I can show a sample for that myself. Now,
then, after all of this washing downwardly for twenty-five
minutes, it was then necessary in order to get the salt out to
wash upwardly, and, as a matter of fact, it took ten minutes
of upward washing to get the water in the same condition ig
so far as chloride or chlorine content is concerned in the
effluent as in the incoming pipe; that is correct, is it not, ten
minutes?
A. No; less than ten minutes that took place.
Q. Iam just taking the stipulation at page 7.
A. Well, yes, in effect you are right. In other a at
the end of ten minutes conditions were the same, the inflow
and the outflow, but I want to say right there, Mr. Byron, I
think it is necessary that I should, that that result was not
dependent at all upon the effect of anything that had been
in the bottom of that tank.
Why not?
A. Because that water had not gotten up there.
77 Q. What water had not gotten up there? You mean
to say that it would take over ten minutes for the water
in the bottom of this tank to get to the bottom of the tank?
A. I mean this: That there was in that tank a condition
of softness which is not represented by these 6 or 10 or 12
parts per million chlorine; that was reached before any of
the fluid in the bottom of the tank reached the top of the tank.
In other words, soft water, what your associates call soft
water, commercially soft water, was obtained before the water
in the bottom of that tank got to the top of that tank, so that
for the purpose of water softening or regeneration, the water
in the bottom of that tank had nothing to do with it.
Q. Well, frankly, I do not know what you are vetting at,
but I will ask another question. Water passing upwardly
through the bed of zeolite will carry salt with it and do
something. Is that what you have in mind?
A. It may or may not, depending entirely on circum-
stances, and I don’t believe that any small amount of salt that
there was in that tank had anything to do with any regenera-
tion that took place. What happened there in that second
wash was that the hard water plugged at the top of the tank,
was drawn up and sent to waste, and it went to waste until
soft water was recognized, when it was available to get into
Testimony of Edwin W. Hammer. 43
the distribution system, but until that soft water condition
had been reached by getting rid of the hard water plug at the
top, none of it went into the circulation.
78 Q. In this medicine bottle that you showed to the
court, in how big a sample was that salt present?
A. Eleven cubic centimeters.
Q. Eleven cubic centimeters?
The Court: What was the content of the water, hard water,
that the chlorine passed into this sample, do you know?
Mr. Byron: Six p.p.m.
The Witness: That was the chloride content of the water.
The Court: Yes.
The Witness: But that did not represent the hardness
of the water.
The Court: I understand, but I mean so far as the chlorine
was concerned, that was the per cent?
A. Yes.
Mr. Byron: After that twenty-five minute wash.
The Court: The question was how much chloride was in
the water?
Mr. Byron: Q. Now, Mr. Hammer, if we had a plain
water, hard water, rinse water and passed—referring to
plaintiff’s exhibit 16, and passed that water upwardly through
the soft bed, which is soft with the exception of an upper
layer of zeolite, will not that rinse water transfer from the
soft portion to the hard portion as it may be just carried
by that — water and soften—
. No.
79 Q. —and regenerate the upper layer?
A. No; I don’t think so, and if you want the reason
for it I can give you the reason. For general regenerating
purposes it is necessary to have half a pound of salt for
every one thousand grains of hardness that has to be re-
moved, and under those circumstances we had here fifty
cubic feet of zeolites, which represented 150,000 grains of
hardness, or rather that was the capacity. If it absorbed
150,000 it required a half a pound of salt to regenerate those,
which meant 75 pounds por actually 75 pounds of salt was
used for regenerating purposes; 75 pounds of salt of 31 gal-
lons of concentrated brine is quite a lot and is not comparable
at all to the minute proportions that we are considering now.
So that I do not think that there will be any regeneration or
transfer on the way up through that bed by reason of the
hard water that is admitted at the bottom.
Q. I suppose that you and your associate, Mr. Waterman,
44 Statement of Evidence..
who is also a patent expert in this case, agree on that mat-
ter, do you not?
The Witness: I can’t give any opinion as to Mr. Water.
man’s views. If you should tell me Mr. Waterman took a
contrary view I would want to read what he said before |
passed on the statement at all.
Mr. Byron: Assuming that Mr. Waterman stated witn re
spect to the Leister patent, and you recall that 1s a aowu soft-
ening machine an up regeneration and up washing, s0 as
80 a result in up washing the lower layer of zeolites would
become hardened. Then when we start to soften water
again by passing it downwardly through it, assume that Mr.
Waterman said that the water passing downwardly through
the soft zeolites would soften or tend to soften a hard layer
of zeolites at the bottom; what would you say as to the ac-
curacy of his theory?
Mr. Cooper: I think I will object to that. I don’t believe
the question in its present form is competent. What Mr.
Waterman is assumed to have said is, to my mind, consider-
ably hitched up with what counsel assumes he was talking
about in his explanatory introduction.
The Court: ell, it doesn’t make any difference whether
Mr. Waterman said it or not. He miy test his theory as an
expert by the proper question, which submit a really hypo-
thetical condition and whether or not he agrees with it he
may answer that without reference to the question.
The Witness: I would only say that while the statement
might be correct as to a tendency, the practical effect would
be negligible.
Redirect Examination by Mr. Cooper.
The Witness: In my last answer, I was not carrying on
the assumption all of the conditions that have been given in
my preceding answer with respect to what was taken place
in Brooklyn, I was simply taking the assumption as
81 stated that under some conditions there might be a ten-
dency, but it would be so slight as to be negligible as a
practical matter.
Attached to the stipulation relative to the first Brooklyn
test is a drawing marked C 1941, and this drawing shows
the center cock Q, which is the cock through which the ll
cubic centimeters were drawn which contained the small spec-
imen of salt in the bottle.
As to what relation these 11 cubic centimeters bear to the
Testimony of Edwin W. Hammer. 45
small pipe which terminates in that cock Q, it will be ob-
served that there is a passageway leading from the bottom
of the tank to that center cock Q, and it was calculated that
the cubic contents of that — would be about seven
or eight cubic centimeters and the effort was made to draw
that amount of fluid out through the cock Q and to measure
how much concentrated brine had gone down into that verm-
iform appendix, as I call it, and the fact was that we got
eleven cubic centimeters in that sample and it was in that
sample that we found there was a concentration of 8000 parts
per million, because just above it it practically disappeared.
Mr. Cooper: Some reference having been made on the
cross-examination to the paraffine sheets which was discov-
ered in the bottom of this tank on the first test, that is, the
March test, I will ask you if that was photographed upon a
scale and if this is a photograph of the piece of paraffine.
82 The Witness: It was so plstessanined and I under-
stand that is the photograph of that particular thing.
Mr. Byron: I do not want to be technical about that, but
the witness says he so understands. If that is the best he
can say, then I say it is objected to as hearsay.
The Court: Well, it is not offered as yet.
Mr. Cooper: No. I will have it marked for identification
as counsel is somewhat extreme.
(The photograph was marked for identification ‘‘Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit ,
Mr. Cooper: Does this photograph, plaintiff’s exhibit F
for identification, in connection with the scale on it, accord
with your recollection of the size of the article in question
at the time it came to light?
The Witness: Yes, it does.
The Witness: (Continuing) These opinions as to this
salt pool which I have expressed on cross-examination and
on direct examination, are not based altogether upon this
first set of tests of March 27th about which I have been par-
ticularly cross-examined; we made another test on the 15th
of May which was more restricted in the matter of time dur-
ing which the washing action took place, but which reached
the same general character of results. The results were of
the same order as those found in the first test.
83 Recross Examination by Mr. Byron.
The Witness: 11 cubic centimeters is about a tablespoon-
“y ; yd "ate 11 cubic centimeters is 6/100 of a cubic inch ;
is | L
46 Statement of Evidence.
The water which was used in both the first test and the
second test for rinsing was the ordinary Brooklyn water, ar.
tificially treated for hardening it an increased amount, it
had been raised to 312 grains of parts per million of hard.
ness; all that appears in the stipulation. The ordinary hard.
ness of the Brooklyn water is two grains per gallon or 349
parts per million. The Brooklyn city water was artificially
hardened from 34.2 up to the figure 312.
All of the water was used from a single tank. The water
had been especially prepared for before, a tank of water had
been prepared with which to carry on these experiments, |
these demonstrations, and that water had a chlorine content
of six parts per million and a hardness of 312. My recollec.
tion is the material used for hardening was calcium carbonate
or sulphate, calcium sulphate.
84 I don’t know whether you will find water in nature
that is made up largely, so far as chemistry is concerned,
of calcium sulphate. It is a matter of a gypsum deposit and
whether the water used comes through a deposit, and so on,
but I don’t know to what extent you will find it. Now, in this
water containing calcium sulphate, I don’t know as rinsed
through the soft bed in rinsing, what the calcium sulphate
changes to.
Q. Well, there is sodium in the bed, is there not, that is
the softening element in that bed?
Yes, sir.
Q. So your knowledge of engineering and being a scien-
tific man, you would naturally suppose, would you not, that
the calcium sulphate is changed into sodium sulphate; that
seems reasonable, doesn’t it?
A. That might be the case, but I don’t know.
Q. Well, now, then, do you happen to know what effect
sodium sulphate has upon the reaction to the standard soap
test?
A. No; I do not.
Q. Well, what is the standard soap test to determine
whether or not a water is soft?
A. There is a standard soap solution employed for the
purpose known as B & B soap solution, generally commer-
cially the rough test is to take a few drops of that B & B
soap solution—
You know it is five drops. It is five drops isn’t
it?
Testimony of Edwin W. Hammer. Ey i
85 A. A few in a sample of 40 cubic centimeters of the
water to be tested, and then a sample with this soap
solution in it is violently agitated to see whether, as a mat-
ter of fact, a suds will be formed on the surface of that sam-
ple that will persist in the neighborhood of five minutes. If
the amount used is five drops or less and suds are formed
when agitated in a sample of 40 cubic centimeters, then the
conclusion is that you have soft water.
The Witness: (Continuing) I don’t know, as a matter
of fact, that water containing sodium sulphate resists the
soap test far more than any other water even in nature, I
do not know that as a fact. What knowledge I have acquired
about zeolite water softening and chemical reactions and one
thing and another upon which I have been examined, is my
knowledge which I have acquired in preparation for this
series of litigations, to some extent, of course, but it is based
upon the general information that goes back many years. It
is not sufficiently great to pass upon chemical reactions and
so on; I don’t attempt to assume even to myself that I am
achemist. I know certain things that happened, yes, pretty
er.
Q. You know that water is softened and that the bed can
be regenerated and a few general things?
A. Those are little things I know.
Mr. Cooper: This is a general examination.
Mr. Byron: There are some very important general things
I want.
8 The Court: The answer may stand.
Mr. Byron: Q. Your business is just acting as a pat-
ent expert in cases in which you are retained; that is correct:
is it not?
A. When I am retained for that purpose. Otherwise I
do general engineering.
Q. How much of your time is taken up with experting
in patent cases?
A. About fifty per cent of my time.
The Court? What?
A. About fifty per cent of my time in actual testifying
md preparing for testimony.
“a
a
48 Statement of Evidence.
87 FRANK N. WATERMAN, being first duly sworn
behalf of plaintiff, testified as follows:
Direct Examination by Mr. Cooper.
My name is Frank N. Waterman. I reside at Summit
New Jersey. My office is in New York City. I am a consult.
ing engineer.
Q. hat are your qualifications as consulting engineer by
en and practical experience?
A. was educated in Cornell University. Then I tooks
course—
Mr. Byron: I am perfectly willing to admit his qualifics
tions as a patent expert.
Mr. Cooper: I have not asked him at all about his qual
ifications for a patent expert. I asked his qualifications as
to a consulting engineer. Will you admit hen or do yu
want me to go on?
Mr. Byron: As a patent expert.
Mr. Cooper: I will insist on qualifying him. You should
not interrupt if you are not going to concede the answer te
the question.
The Witness: (Continuing) —in Mechanical Engi
ing. I also attended Brooklyn Polytechnic Institute where I
took my Master’s Degree, Master of Science. For a consid-
erable number of years I was engaged in the practice of
88 my profession as an engineer in the design, construction
and operation of machinery of various kinds, and in 190
I started at my consulting practice, which has been widely
varied, involving a great deal of design, construction and in-
vestigation work of appliances of many kinds. The investi-
gation of the value and operativeness of new inventions, if
there is any, in connection with the obtaining of patents, and
in testifying and preparing for testimony in litigations in
volving patents.
I have had to do with this Gans patent and the industrial
application of zeolites. I have devoted a great deal of time
to the subject for a good many years. I don’t remember et-
actly how many; I should say about twelve years, and I have
testified in some litigation and given affidavits in others. I
have made many tests and investigations of the operation of
zeolites and water softeners and observed them in their com-
mercial application in many different locations and uses.
I do not pretend to be a chemist. I had two years of chem-
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 49
istry in college, one re devoted to qualitative and quanti-
tative analytical work, but I never posed as a chemist.
I have an understanding of the meaning of the terms hard
water, soft water and zeolites as they are used in connection
with a controversy of this sort. This term hard water is not
definite, soft water is more or less definite.
89 The Court: They are comparative terms.
The Witness: Comparative terms and the term ze-
olites as used in this particular art have quite a definite sig-
nificance.
The Witness: (Continuing) The zeolites that I have enu-
merated are of three types. The early type that we knew
first and for a considerable number of years was known as
the permutit. It is an artificial zeolite which is produced by
a melting pot at very high temperature.
Then there is a zeolite which is hardly more than the nat-
ural mineral glauconite. It is often called green sand. It
is made by an appropriate treatment of the natural sand.
And then there is another type of the zeolite which I have
known chiefly as permutit P, which I understand is the same
as the zeolite also on the market known as decalco. Those
are both artificial products, made however not by heating but
by chemical precipitation process.
The three different zeolites have the same type of zeolitic
action, exchange action, but their physical properties are
somewhat different.
For example, glauconite is the heaviest. It weighs, air
dried, at about 105 degrees centigrade, if I remember rightly,
about ninety pounds a cubic foot. And the permutit M, the
early permutit, weighs not much more than half of that. Then
the permutit P, and the decalco weigh about sixty pounds,
90 as I remember it. They are in other words somewhat
heavier than the furnace product, but not so heavy as
the natural product.
Q. I will first state to you an assumption, namely you
may assume that the proper interpretation of Claim 1 of
the patent in suit, is limited by a disclaimer to down-flow,
and that the proper interpretation of claim 5, both claims
involving a free space above the bed of the zeolite, so that
the zeolite bed can be lifted or held in partial suspense; now
Pr that assumption I will ask you to make an explanation
the disclosures of the patent in suit with reference to what
is particularly pointed out in these claims.
tr. Wilkinson: I object to the question, your Honor. That
question is really one for the court. It is a matter of in-
50 Statement of Evidence.
terpretating the claims of the court, rather than for an ex.
rt witness to advise the court how the claims should be
interpreted. I have heard your = very clearly, and
I think it is very clearly calling for the witness to do that
which is the province of the court.
Mr. Cooper: I asked him to assume an interpretation of
the claims, and then to assume the interpretation of the pat-
ent with reference to the matters that are covered by the
—, I did not ask the witness to interpret the claims at
91 Mr. Wilkinson: You are asking him to interpret the
claims
Mr. Cooper: I simply asked the witness for a classifica-
tion of the disclosures of the patent.
Mr. Wilkinson: For an interpretation of the claim. You
do not know whether the court is going to give that inter-
pretation to the claims or not.
Mr. Cooper: I am taking a chance on that, just as if it
was a question of insanity or otherwise, I put to the witness
the assumption that the facts are thus and so. I am asking
his opinion. Now, I am asking the witness on this assum
tion, which confines his attention to certain things, to explain
what is shown in the patent.
The Court: Why can’t you leave that assumption out en-
tirely and ask him the question?
Mr. Cooper: I am perfectly willing to, so that we get
back on the contentious ground as to what the claims mean,
which is what counsel is trying to keep me out of, and what
I tried to anticipate in the beginning.
Mr. Wilkinson: We shall leave that to the court, for the
court to pass upon what the claims mean, and not the wit-
ness.
The Court: I think the question is quite ingenious.
92 Mr. Cooper: I suppose it was the sort of ingenuity
that any counsel had to indulge for the purpose of putting
a question to an expert witness. In other words I am per-
fectly frank about the matter, if your Honor please, I am
taking the claims on the interpretation put on them by the
court.
The Court: Now this man comes here as a witness for
the purpose of interpretation of the patent?
Mr. Cooper: No I am not putting him on for that.
The Court: That is what you are asking him.
Mr. Cooper: No, I am asking him to explain the disclo-
sure.
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 51
The Court: What is a disclosure? Your question is what
do these claims disclose. Does that not mean to interpret ?
How shall these words be interpreted, these phrases, these
clauses? What do they mean?
After all the question is what do these claims mean. Now,
you are saying to him we will assume that these claims mean
first of all that the conditions named in your assumption ex-
ist, we will assume that the claim means so and 80; now with
that assumption, what do the claims mean?
Mr. Cooper: If your Honor please, I do not want to worry
about the thing at all. I am just asking a plain question.
Q. Will you please give a short explanation of the dis-
closures of the patent in suit, and you may confine yourself
in explaining it as largely as possible to those things
93 that are referred to in claims 1 and 5, as distinguished
from what may in addition be referred to in other claims
which are not here in question.
A. I assume it is not necessary to dwell upon the nature
of zeolites, or what is hard water. I will assume that water
which does not lather readily with soap is water that needs
to be softened, and is subject to treatment in a water softener,
and the patent asked about discloses a water softening ap-
paratus which makes use of the properties of zeolites in an
eficient manner.
The zeolites have the property of exchanging bases. That
is to say they can be conceived of as consisting of a sort of
skeleton of silicate clothed with alumina associated with some
other base, and if that base happens to be sodium or potas-
sium, then when water containing lime or magnesium, the
hardening constituents of water, pass over it under proper
conditions, the zeolite will give out sodium and take in ex-
change the hardening constituents calcium and magnesia
found in the water, and from this comes the name exchange
base silicates, sometimes applied in lieu of the term ze-
olite.
4% The term zeolite, as a matter of fact, originally meant
a mineral that boils when you heat it, but it was found
that minerals having that property did have an exchange
property, and those that had that property are more fre-
quently called exchange base silicates.
is exchange takes place under quite definite chemical
laws, and the apparatus to handle it effectively to produce
continuous softening must operate in conformity with the
fundamental laws of operation of material, and the patent
therefore sets forth.
-
52 Statement of Evidence.
I call attention to page 1, line 19 that an apparatus is to
be so as to be capable of continuous use, and again at ling
28, whereby they can be continuously used. Again at line 10),
capable of continuous use.
he patent in other words purports to set forth an
paratus in which this property of zeolites may be practically
nseable as a continuously available apparatus not requirings
constant renewal of zeolites.
In relation to the character of the zeolites the patent points
out that they must have certain physical as well as chemical .
characteristics.
I call attention in that connection particularly to the.
sage beginning at the line 30 where, in addition to the hi
exchange capacity for softening and high exchange ca.
95 pacity for regeneration, it is specified that they must bk
able to stand the physical abuse that is encountered in
the natural operation. They must be large enough to permit
the percolation of water hesethooush, not material which
would not allow the readily trickling of water through it.
The apparatus shown in Figs. 1, 2 and 3, consists of a cas-
ing having near the bottom a perforated metal plate d, and
also near the top a perforated metal plate c. The bottom plated
has a layer of gravel or quartz upon it, upon which is the
bed of zeolitic material indicated by f. The perforated platec
is some distance above the top of the zeolitic bed, and it car.
ries a layer of quartz. It forms no part of the softener
whatever, but the patent explains that it may be employed
for the purpose of removing the mechanical impurities, me
chanically introduced impurities as distinguished from chem-
ically dissolved impurities, by what is often known as me
chanical filtration.
The action of the zeolitic material is what I have some
times referred to as a flying exchange. That is it is a con
tact phenomena which takes place as the water passes. It is
therefore necessary that the water should have contact with
the grains, which is of chemical intimacy, so that such an
exchange can take place.
The Court: Does it take place almost immediately upon
contact?
96 The Witness: It is almost immediate, yes. Very quick.
And it is to impress that idea that I have called it a sort
of flying exchange.
The presence of dirt on the surface of the zeolites makes
that necessary intimacy of contact difficult.
The Court: Impairs the efficiency.
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 53
The Witness: Impairs the efficiency, and that is the pur-
pose of seeing that the water is reasonably free from turbid-
ity when it comes to the zeolite bed. ;
Figs. 2 and 3 are not especially involved in the claims 1
and 5, as they have to do with the stirring apparatus which
the patentee says may be an advantage in connection with
the back wash operation, which back wash operation occurs
in the normal cycle of the apparatus for the purpose of free-
ing the zeolites from slime, turbidity and so forth that they
may have picked up while the water is en route through
them.
The softening operation is described, beginning for exam-
ple at page 1 line 66. It. passes in the pipe & in Fig. 1 up
into the top of the softener out through that funnel shaped
outlet indicated by the pipe k, and then passes down through
the casing, encountering first the quartz e, and then after
traveling a sufficient distance it comes down to the zeolite
bed, and thence out, after passing clear through, and through
the bottom strainer out through the conical screen i into the
pipe j, and through the valve u to the soft water line.
97 The zeolites have a certain amount of exchangeable
sodium, and in any given structure effectively utilize a
certain proportion of that exchangeable sodium before water
begins to show evidences of hardness, as indicated by the so-
called B and B. That of course does not mean that all of
the exchangeable sodium in the bed has been given up in any
structure whatever. That is to say it is a physical impos-
sibility in any structure to utilize all of the exchangeable
sodium in the zeolite.
Now the efficiency of the structure is determined by whether
it does or does not utilize to a practical commercial degree
the exchange properties of the zeolitic bed.
Beginning at line 82 of page 1, the patentee says:
‘After the softening property of the zeolites has been
exhausted or reduced, which can be readily ascertained by
testing the water passed through”’,
he then proceeds to describe the regenerating process.
In other words one user may have one standard of water
that he wants, another may have another standard. If for
example in a dye works it is extremely important that there
never should be the slightest trace of hardness, then that only
partially reduces the exchange power, because you would stop
before the water ran hard at all. Or you might run until the
water tested a little bit hard, and then regenerate. That is
what I understand is referred to.
—
o+ Statement of Evidence.
98 He then proceeds from that point on to describe the
regenerating process through the rest of that paragra
In the regenerating process water is passed from a suita
container, not shown, through the valve o as shown in Fig.
and passes thence up into the top of the tank in the same
manner as the water did before, coming out through the con.
ical piece i, and passes down through the casing encounteri
of course the several layers of material on the way, a
coming out at the pipe j and passing to waste through the
valve p.
This passage of the salt solution through the zeolite bed
has the effect of reversing the exchange which took place dur.
ing the water softening operation. During that operation the
water was softened and the zeolites were hardened. Duri
the regenerating operation the zeolites were softened and the
water hardened. That process depends upon establishing a
correct density grading, and the sodium zeolite takes calcium
— readily than the hardened or calcium zeolite takes so
um.
The Court: Would you use sodium potassium or sodium
chloride?
The Witness: Yes, either of those could be used.
The Court: Sodium chloride is mere ordinary table salt
The Witness: Mere ordinary table salt, yes. In other
words a fairly concentrated solution of sodium chloride is re
quired for the purpose of rejuvinating the zeolites.
99 The Court: Do those zeolites continue year after year
to retain the mechanical properties?
The Witness: Yes. They last for years, and that is the
point of what the patentee says about continuous use, and of
the properties that the zeolites have to have in the passage!
called your Honor’s attention to. That is they have to stand
that usage for a long period. As the patent points out the
bed has got to be back washed, cleaned. Back wash means
the lifting of the bed by a current of water sufficiently strong
so as to lift the zeolites, loosen them up, rub them together,
and detach slime and all the elements that go to make up
turbid water, and pass them to waste.
The difficult thing in any bed of that kind is to get water
to flow through it uniformly. It is extremely difficult to pre
vent water from taking a preferred route, what is called char
neling, and it is this raising up of the bed in back washing,
boiling it, which makes it expand somewhere ordinarily in
the neighborhood of 20 or 25 percent where the washing is
quite violent, but say from 10 to 25 per cent increase in bulk
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 55
through this back wash operation, that gives the usefulness
of the free space that appears in the patent, above the top
of the permutit; the nearest obstruction above which in the
patent is the grating or perforated plate c.
100 During that process the levitation effect of water is
proportional, to the ratio of area to weight, and as all
weight varies with the cube of the dimensions while the area
only varies with the square, as the particles get square they
get, from the patentee’s viewpoint, lighter. That is the water
levitates the smaller particles more easily than it does the
larger particles, but it also gives a bigger area to accelerate.
That is a bigger area in proportion to their weight. It sim-
ply follows from that natural fact that area varies with the
square of the dimension and weight with the cube, so that the
bed is arranged in virtue of that ability to expand, and chan-
neling is prevented.
strong brine, and which is also contaminated with hardness,
should not get into the soft water line, and therefore the pat-
101__I think I have now referred to all of the features of
the construction which according to my understanding
are indicated by the descriptive language of the claims 1 and
5.
102 Wednesday, October 30, 1929,
Ten o’clock a. m.
The Witness: ( Continuing) I shall explain a little
farther the matter of channeling on which I touched somewhat
yesterday; channeling is a phenomena occurring in the filtra-
tion of water through zeolites, which means the selection of
is to tend to enlarge such channels and to quickly exhaust
t
§
3 Jom tes =% 5 - .
BI sone cee SURAT Be err arene aces ornee SUD ERO E ae ssp ATES sr sie sees
EE EDR ES eras vn RTE aNeRE, Mee SORT maranatEg
COLSTON Oona ome eres
x
56 Statement of Evidence.
the exchange capacity of the zeolites along such paths and
therefore to pass untreated water, unsoftened water, directly
through into the effluent. The formation of channels is due
to a number of causes, in fact the whole subject is rather a
complex one. It is due, to, for example, unequal resistance
of the bed, due to lack of grading or due to the very inclu
sion of air or the speed of air from the water passi
through, to the accumulation of dirt or to anything that will
cause or promote bacterial action under which the zeolites
tend to adhere to one another and form so-called mud balk.
All of these effects are causes of channels and there are per-
haps others.
It is a phenomena that can be exceedingly troublesome and
that is promoted by anything which constrains the bed. With
appropriate grade of the bed in down-flow softeners this dif.
ficulty gives very little trouble.
103 I was present as it appears from the stipulations at
— demonstrations in Brooklyn on March 27th and May
15th.
As a result of those tests I would say as to the presence
after regenerating and washing of a salt pool at the bottom
of the defendant’s 1925 down-flow and 1927 up-flow filter that
since the steps of regeneration and rinsing are the same in
the 1925 and 1927 softeners, and the construction of the means
for taking water from the bottom of the casing or the sand,
it will not be necessary in making answer to distinguish be
tween the two, and therefore while I shall refer, of course,
to the tests which were made with up-flow softening, the an-
swer will apply to both. In answering the question I will
understand the word ‘‘pool’’ to mean a certain amount of
liquid at the bottom of the casing, which amount cannot ex-
ceed that that would be contained in the casing below the
bottom of the outlet pipe which contains more salt at the
end of the downward rinsing operation than is found at
levels higher than the bottom of the pipe.
The tests showed that no pool existed. Tests were run in
somewhat different manners. There were two, one occurring
in March and the other in May, and the first test was run in
accordance with the instructions given in the bulletin of the
Graver Company, which at that time I knew as Exhibit 12.
On page 10 of the bulletin under the headings ‘‘3’’ and ‘‘4”,
at the bottom of page 10, and which also bears the cap-
104 tions ‘‘Washing”’ and ‘‘Rewash’’, the instruction is given
to wash with a downward flow ‘‘until test shows the salt
is completely washed out’’. The first two lines of paragraph
4 then state:
PEELE EE LINE EEN TY TI SOR EON aps ec ra.
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 57
“The softener is now reconditioned and ready for serv-
after this operation was completed, the washing being car-
ried on until there was a very small salt content as indicated
by the chlorine test, the softener was allowed to stand for
something over an hour, as I remember it. I can give the
exact time by looking it a The water was first tested, of
course, immediately tested, and it was found that the salt
content continually increased with time. Now, salt water is
heavy, and the salt which was in the bed above this bottom
continually settled down into the lower part, thus show-
ing that the space at the very bottom below the pipe had
been drained out in the process of washing until it was of a
much lower salt content than the space above, as indicated
by the fact that when the salt was given time to settle down
from above it did so and greatly increased the strength of
the salt in the bottom. Of course, the total salt that was in-
volved at any time was absolutely trifling. For example in
the first test, the first sample drawn after the little petcock
had been emptied showed 28 parts per million of chloride
content, which was equal to about one-quarter of a grain or
about one twenty-six thousandth part of a pound, which, of
course, is a negligible amount of salt from the point of view
either of salt or of any chemical effect that it would have
upon the bed. It would have, in fact, no effect upon the
bed.
105 The second sample drawn, the first sample was a little
over a drinking glass full, the second sample was about
a drinking glass full, was very much less salty.
The Court: Is not this shown by the stipulation?
A. Yes, in terms of parts per million, which is not very
intelligible. I was merely converting it to grains. It was in
fact, just about two-tenths of a grain.
The Witness: (Continuing) The second test was made
for three reasons, first, a small shaving of paraffin was found
in the bottom of the casing at the end of the test after the
water was drawn off to permit inspection, and while I do not
believe that that shaving was there during the test, neverthe-
less it did raise a question; second, the method of sampling
left a small pipe sticking down which necessarily did retain
some salt solution, and a different connection for drawing out
water was arranged that did not require any paraffin and
which had a perfectly flush normal bottom without the
106 use of paraffin, the paraffin having been used in the first
instance for the purpose of making a flush, normal bot-
tom in the casing. And it was decided also to adopt a dif-
*
Ra OR Tey PAE enero ersa at esononemennmmaadly
ie Se aa nt)
B
F
¥
}
58 Statement of Evidence.
ferent procedure and draw off the entire contents of the a
called pool and see whether it made any difference in the
ening of the water. That is, in the subsequent softening of
the water. And it was found that this drawing off of seve,
and one-half gallons, which is the maximum possible extent,
allowing no space for the water to turn into the pipe whic
could possibly be called a pool, and this having been draw,
off, it was found that the structure behaved exactly as be
fore, the soft water came, and it was also found that the cos
tents of the pool contained less salt than the effluent, show.
ing that the connection by which water was removed from
the tank was an effective connection to the very bottom. -
Comparing the defendant’s down-flow softener of 1923, its
down-flow softener of 1925 and its up-flow softener of 19%
with the disclosures of the Gans patent in suit, as I have de
scribed them, I will assume that the structure is understood
in each case and make the comparison with that understand.
ing. Referring to the 1923 softener, as described in Exhibit
10, it comprises a casing within which there is a bed of gravel
and on top of that a bed of zeolites or alumino-silicates, hay-
ing the water-softening property. The piping provides a
means for introducing water into the top and withdrawi
it from the bottom for the softening cycle and for
107 ting off that supply of water when the softening capacity
of the zeolite bed. is exhausted, and also it has means con-
sisting of a tank in which salt ma_ »e dissolved and piping
and means for forcing the salt solution through the piping
into the casing for the regeneration of the zeolite bed and the
structure is in all of these respects such as I have stated that
I understood was disclosed in the Gans patent.
At the bottom of the casing there is a manifold of outlets
which take water from the bottom of the casing and which
enables the salt solution to be completely removed.
The 1925 softener is in general similar and what I have
said applies to that softener with the exception of the con-
struction by which the connection is made to the bottom of
the casing in a functional or operative sense. In this instance
the manifold which was found in the 1923 softener is not
present and the concrete bottom which was present in the
1923 softener is omitted. Instead a pipe is taken into the
casing and turned down towards the bottom and approaches
within a short distance of the bottom. This may be seen
from the cut on page four of the bulletin, which is marked
Exhibit 11 in my copy. Surrounding the end of this pipe
and about eight inches from its center I believe is a ring of
ae
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 59
considerable depth, which forms a sort of local well around
the end of the pipe and the bottom edge of this ring where
it rests upon the bottom of this a notched to admit
of the flow of water along the curved bottom of the casing.
Now, the water flowing in through the notches in the ring
108 has two effects. First, it is directed y the notches along
the bottom, second, the total area of the notches is large
as compared to the area of the pipe up which the water must
flow. The result is that the water is directed along the bot-
tom by the notches and is accelerated from a very slow rate
where it passes through the notches to a very high rate where
it passes into the pipe.
ow, in hydraulic design where water has to flow into
ipes, the method which I was taught in college for doing that
is illustrated on a small sketch which I produce, by which the
so-called stream lines in which water naturally flows are ap-
roximated as nearly as possible. The method which I was
taught was to take a center at each side of a pipe driven from
the wall by the radius of the pipe, and with that point as a
center strike a quarter circle, then with the same point as a
center and the diameter of the pipe as a radius strike another
circle and that is the distance controlled by this second water
cycle. It is the distance in which water flowing freely would
be drawn in a pipe up which there was a suction flow or a
pressure flow. Now, that means that such a pipe free in the
water is assumed to draw from a distance below its end equal
to its own internal diameter.
Now, in this structure which is shown in Exhibit 11 the
water is brought along the bottom of the casing. The water
tends to flow owing to its momentum in straight lines, and as
the bottom of the casing is continually curved upward
109 the water hugs the upper side of the lower wall or bot-
tom of the casing and drives before it whatever was
there originally. So that the flow up the pipe, which at the
rate of 60 gallons per minute figured out, as Mr. Hammer
ve it yesterday, I think it was 235 feet per minute, calls
or an exceedingly rapid acceleration of the water as it flows
in along the bottom and the connection which is made in this
1925 softener is thus operably a connection to the bottom of
the tank of the casing, preventing the formation of any strati-
fied pool of solution different from that going into the pipe.
(Sketch made by Witness Waterman received in evidence
and marked PLAINTIFF’S EXHIBIT G.)
The Witness: (Continuing) Without repeating what I
have said with respect to the 1923 softener, I will merely say
60 Statement of Evidence.
that according to my understanding of its functioning and_ace-
cording to the tests which were made at Brooklyn, this strue-
ture also has a connection to the lowest point of the casi
for removing the salt solution. Of course, I do not say that
that is a physical connection. The end of the pipe does not
touch the bottom of the casing, but functionally it is effective
to draw from the bottom of the casing as though it were in
fact mechanically connected thereto in the manner shown in
the patent.
The construction shown in Exhibit 12 illustrating the 1927
softener is in all substantial respects the same as that of
the 1923 and 1925 softeners. There has been a slight modif-
cation of the piping by which the softener is more —
110 adapted for up-flow softening, and the description whi
I have referred to on page 10 describes an up-flow cycle
of softening, the regeneration and rinsing being conducted in
the same manner as in the preceding 1925 softener, and the
construction at the bottom functioning in the same way as
I have just described with respect to that 1925 softener. There
is, therefore, the casing, the bed of sand, or gravel, the ze-
olite bed, and means for introducing water for softening and
withdrawing it and for interrupting the flow and for intro-
ducing salt solution for regenerating and for drawing the
salt solution out from the bottom of the tank. According to
my understanding of the constructions and of the patent
therefor each of the three structures inquired about in the
uestion is substantially such a structure as is described in
the patent and functions in substantially the same way for
the same purpose and result.
In all cases, that is, in each of three defendant’s ap-
paratus there is a free bed with a space above it in which
oe may rise and expand and be graded as I have de
scribed.
Cross-Examination by Mr. Byron.
The Wtiness: Referring to page 137 of the testimony
which reads ‘‘This exchange takes place under quite
111 definite chemical laws,’’ I was referring to the ex-
change of bases in the zeolites from sodium to calcium
magnesia, and so forth; I say ‘‘this change takes place under
quite definite chemical laws.’’ I have in mind the law, if
that is the proper word for it, of the affinity of the zeolites
and the law known as the law of mass action in so far as that
applies to this set of conditions that we are dealing with.
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 61
The law of mass action says that when one solution is sub-
mitted to the action of the zeolite, the other constituent is
being understood for brevity that we are here dealing, let
us say, with sodium in one and calcium in the other, the
ratio of the two will be initially a certain value. The
ratio at the termination of the exchange will be the same in
the liquid as in the zeolites and equal to the original sodium-
calcium ratio, modified by the greater preference that the
zeolite shows for calcium as compared to sodium. Those are
the laws that I had in mind.
I have no doubt about that that is the mass law but I sup-
pose your use of the word ‘‘certain’’ might—
I did not bring any authority on that, but that’s in all the
books. The res. of physical chemistry will give you the
law of mass action and I myself interpreted that for the pur-
pose of the particular conditions that we are dealing with.
Mr. Byron: Well, do you think that probably mass action
might have something to do and primarily to do with the
speed of transfer from oue base to the other rather than all
this that you have defined?
112 The Witness: Well, the law of mass action, of course,
goes farther than I have stated.
Mr. Byron: That was not a complete answer, then?
The Witness: Well, I qualified it. Yes, I consider that
was a complete answér. I qualified it as far as it has any
application here in ordinary circumstances of use of the ap-
paratus, as I understand it. Now, of course, time does enter
and you might expand my statement of the law of mass ac-
tion by saying that the speed of the reaction is in proportion
to the relative concentration or the difference of concentra-
tion. I might add that the entire mathematics of the appli-
cation of the law of mass action is rather complicated. Veer
early in my connection with the use of zeolites, I reduced
those mathematies to terms which applied to zeolitic action
and then made an elaborate series of tests to check up that
application and the results of the equations were confirmed
when the two laws that I have mentioned are taken into con-
sideration.
Q. Now, what do you think about this law of mass action?
This is in a book called ‘‘Outlines of Theoretical Chemistry”’
by Frederick H. Getman, published in the year 1922, and in
that book on page 304 under the paragraph marked, ‘‘The
law of mass action’’ in italics and quoting Guldberg and
Waage, the mass action is defined as this:
.... Ree at
62 Statement of Evidence.
113 ‘The rate, or speed, of a chemical reaction is propor.
tional to the active masses of the reacting substances
resent at that time’’,
you agree with that definition?
A. Yes. My equations are based on that and conform to
it, but it is only necessary to bear in mind to see what the
application is that the rate, the time that is, in which the
action may take place is determined by the rate of flow of
the liquid through the casing.
The Witness: (Continuing) I referred in my testi
to this transfer as a flying exchange. That is, as I told his
Honor yesterday, it is not instantaneous but takes = 80
quickly that there is no harm in rding it as such.
On that same page, page 137 of the testimony, in‘ addition
to stating, ‘‘This exchange takes place under quite definite
chemical laws’’ you continue to say, ‘‘and the apparatus to
handle it effectively to produce continuous softening must
operate in conformity with the fundamental laws of opers-
tion of the material.’’ I will explain what I mean by that—
the matter of the free bed and the yong: Ay grading.
Another matter that I had in mind was this, that if you take
a pound of zeolites or a quantity of zeolites, let us say hay-
ing an eumene a of 100 grains of calcium, in terms
of calcium carbonate, — you take water having that amount
of calcium carbonate or its equivalent and you stir them up
in a bucket, stir them up violently, give them all the time
you please and you will not get soft water. Although
114 the zeolite is capable of taking that amount of calcium
out of water under suitable conditions, you stir them up
in a pail and you will not get soft water. You will get about
a 50-50 relation, that is, part of the calcium will go into the
zeolite and part of the soda will come from the zeolite into
the water, but it will not be soft. So that’s one way in whic
you can not treat water with zeolites and get the soft-
ening action. I had in mind, therefore, the fact that under
such circumstances as I have mentioned, if you want to get some
soft water you must form the zeolites in the form of a bed,
introduce the water in such a manner that it may flow evenly
through the bed, and assuming the same conditions as before
where I referred to mixing in the tub, you will then get soft
water until the contamination produced, contamination of
the zeolites oe pe by the softening action has extended
through the and there has been some hardening action at
the bottom, then the water will run hard and it will rm
progressively harder as that bottom layer begins to be more
tt ee
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 63
and more contaminated. When the lime gradient, I will put it
that way, the lime gradient in the bed, from top to bottom
reaches the zeolites at the bottom, then the water begins to
run hard.
115 Now, I spoke about these fundamental laws of opera-
tion and material and so on, I didn’t say the patent there-
fore sets them forth. The patent does not go into text mat-
ters. Yes, I still use the words ‘‘And the patent therefore
sets forth’’, because the zeolite has to be operated in accord-
ance with the laws that govern its action. The patentee sets
forth an apparatus which is conformable to those laws.
Whether he knows the laws or not, he does set forth an ap-
ratus which is conformable to those laws and in which the
result, both of softening and regenerating, can be carried on
as he says through continuous use.
Actually in the patent the tank is not given a dimension,
it describes the structure and shows it in the drawing. It
does not give the quantity of zeolite in the tank, that is im-
material. It does not give the rate of flow of water to be
softened. It does not give the concentration of the regener-
ation solution to be used.
One looking at this Gans patent would not have to do more
experimenting to soften water and to regenerate the ex-
hausted zeolities, than is the rule in carrying out a patent.
Your statements are true, Gans does not teach how much
zeolite shall be used, he does not teach what the rate of flow
of the water shall be in softening, he does not teach the con-
centration of the salt for regenerating the zeolites, if by
teach you mean going into the terms, statement by terms. If
you mean by teach to be able to build an apparatus and op-
erate it commercially from his patent, there would be no
difficulty in doing that.
116 You call my attention to page 1, line 19, where he re-
fers to an apparatus so as to be capable of continuous
we, and ask whether the word ‘‘capable’’ describes in my
nind any definite structure. I do not comprehend your ques-
tion. The patent itself says, ‘‘The present invention has for
its object an apparatus in which the zeolites or alumino-sil-
icates can be used in a filter and be regenerated therein so as
to be capable of continuous use for the softening of water.”’ :
Asked if Gans in his patent defines what he considers to ’
be a capable structure, int to the whole description of ;
the specification and the showing of the drawings that the
_ is such a structure. ere is no difficulty about
7 MIRE aA Rea
ee 3 Statement of Evidence.
I said that in the softening of water by means of zeolity
and the regeneration of the zeolites by a sodium salt sok.
tion, it is necessary that the water should have contact wit
the grains; if they are separated by dirt or slime, the sof,
ening action will not take place. You ask if a particuly
portion of water to be softened does not directly contact with
the grain, but there is an intermediate globule of water, wil
that transfer to the water to be softened the softening e&
sodium from the zeolite to that water to be softened; yu
are asking now apparently the ultimate mechanism of natan
I do not w that and, so far as I know, nobody else dow
What authorities there are on that I do know, the thing]
was talking about as a matter of experience, is that if
zeolite is coated with slime or dirt it won’t exchange.
is all that I meant to convey. I had no thought of going
117 into nature’s ultimate processes. That is to say, this
property that nature has given these zeolites
itself in this apparatus. Now, whether nature passes on
effect from molecule to molecule, I don’t know, and I don’t
think anybody else does. But what I do know is that if yn
put an impervious coating around your granule, so that th
water cannot, in the sense of an exchange, touch it, then ya
will not get the ex . When I say in contact I mean
such contact as nature demands before the exchange can tak
place.
I have defined back-wash as an operation in th? norm
cycle of the apparatus for freeing the zeolites from slim
turbidity, and so forth; that is one of its functioss. That
of my testimony I say that back-washng mea
by a current of water sufficienly
the zeolites, loosen them, rub them together
the slime and all the elements that go other
turbid water, and pass them on to waste. When Gas speals
of back-wash he means that the bed of zeolites is eqpable and
the conditions prevail for lifting and loosening tlat bed o
zeolites up, to boil them up, the zeolites put in a state of semi-
suspension and the bed expanded. Without yun dey look
through the patent, because I have not read it fromthat pom!
Testimony of Frank N. Waterman. 65
of view, I should say Gans means that invariably about
118 back-washing; but I can’t 7 that positively, of course,
I don’t know his meaning. If you will pardon me, I do
not know what Gans meant and I have not undertaken to say.
I only have intended to say what it conveys to me. I am
explaining, and have been throughout, what Gans means to
me.
Mr. Byron: All that Gans has to say about back-washing,
regardless of what it may do, or any inferences we may draw
as to what back-washing does, let us refer to page 1 of the
Gans patent, the two last lines thereof, beginning at line 109:
‘‘As shown in Figures 2 and 3, means may be provided for
stirring the zeolites, as for example in washing, (‘back-wash-
ing’) to remove impurities mechanically taken up by the ze-
oites.’’
Then he describes the stirrer, and down in line 13:
“In back-washing the silicates by passing a current of
water therethrough in the reverse direction from suitable con-
nection in the usual manner for the purpose of removing
slime, mechanically collected matters, etc. this stirring is ad-
vantageous.’’
So everything, all the attributes of this back-washing,
which is referred to in the Gans patent, is done in the usual
manner.
The Witness: Is that a question?
Mr. Byron: Yes. F
A. Well, you can read it that way. ;
Q. Can you read it any other way?
A. Well, I have not happened to read it that way, but I
see that you are quite justified in so doing. I read it ‘‘con-
nections in the usual manner.’’
119 The Witness: (Continuing) Yes, it does speak about
connections ; from suitable connections in the usual man-
ner. I had not thought of its meaning anything else, but I
see you are quite justified in taking your reading.
Back-washing is done in sand filters with a free and u
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.