Reply Brief — 640 Broadway Renaissance Co. v. John Eisner, et al. and 15 Other Cases Consolidated for Purposes of a Joint Appeal
Supreme Court brief1996
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
Sunamme Gourl, 0.5
em wet
~
\
——
, MAR 27 1996
No. 95-959
-..
t row
CLIN
EEE SECS SOT
In The
Supreme Court of the United States
o--
October Term, 1995
640 BROADWAY RENAISSANCE CO.,
Petitioner,
VS.
JOHN EISNER, et al. and 15 Other Cases Consolidated for
Purposes cf a Joint Appeal,
Respondents.
On Petition for Writ of Certiorari to the Supreme Court
of the State of New York, Appellate Division,
First Judicial Department
REPLY BRIEF FOR PETITIONER
MARTIN R. FINE
Counsel of Record
Attorney for Petitioner
644 Broadway
New York, New York 10012
(212) 477-1155
TABLE OF CONTENTS
| - FEDERAL QUESTIONS HAVE BEEN RAISED
FOR MORE THAN 10 YEARS - THE NEW YORK
COURTS HAVE SIMPLY IGNORED THEM.......................... 1
ll - THIS CASE IS OF GREAT PUBLIC IMPORT-
ANCE BECAUSE (a) IT DIRECTLY AFFECTS
THE ECONOMIC FUTURE OF MORE THAN
800 SUBSTANTIAL BUILDINGS IN NEW YORK:
(B) MANY BUILDINGS HAVE MORTGAGES FROM
BANKS WHICH ARE EITHER FEDERALLY INSURED
OR REGULATED; (C) THIS UNFETTERED
STATE SEIZURE OF PROPERTY WILL SEV-
ERELY IMPACT ON THE FUTURE OF PRIVATE
INVESTMENT IN REAL ESTATE, BANKING AND
FINANCE IN THE CITY AND STATE OF NEW YORK,
IPED, EPUGO, OATIONALLY oon oncccuscscesccccsessesesoseeeesesce.-.-.... 4
lll - IF A STATE LEGISLATURE IS PERMITTED
TO RETROACTIVELY ENACT MASSIVE
UNCONSTITUTIONAL VIOLATIONS, BY THE
SIMPLE USE OF SELF-CREATED ‘EMERGENCY’
VERBIAGE, THEN THERE IS NO
SI i 5
IV. THIS RETROACTIVE LEGISLATIVE GRANTING
OF PROPERTY RIGHTS TO PERSONS WHO,
BY DEFINITION, COMMITTED CRIMINAL ACTS
BY ILLEGALLY RESIDING IN “LOFT’ BUILDINGS,
EITHER AS A REWARD FOR THEIR PAST
ii.
CRIMINAL CONDUCT OR AS “PUNISHMENT” TO
OWNER - IS AN UNCONSTITUTIONAL SEIZURE
OF PETITIONER’S PROPERTY AND IMPAIR-
MENT OF CORTTIRIG T ....iecssstnvesssiesesseunsbabessssestebececs
V - NEITHER SFriING REALTY CO. V. NEW
YORK CITY LOFT BOARD NOR 640 BROAD-
WAY RENAISSANCE CO. V. CUOMO ET AL,
ARE CONTROLLING PRECEDENT HEREIN...................
VI - THE RESPONDENTS “SPECIAL PERMIT”
ARGUMENTS ARE PURE RED HERRINGG.................0..0...
CONGLIUGIOIN.. ...0<.::1ssssicnssdisisvacasaataaaaaatbnadiniaiie
8
|
i
|
|
Q.
iii.
TABLE OF CONTENTS-REPLY APPENDIX
EXCERPT FROM PETITIONER'S BRIEF
DATED SEPTEMBER 21, 1994 TO NY
APPELLATE DIVISION.
RIDER ANNEXED TO AND MADE PART OF
INTERIM MULTIPLE DWELLING
REGISTRATION APPLICATION.
AFFIDAVIT OF HYMAN SCHERMER
SWORN TO APRIL 15, 1993.
EXCERPTS OF LEASE CLAUSES ALL
ABROGATED BY THE “LOFT LAWS”
OMITTED
LOFT SOARD RULES & REGULATIONS
(EXCERPTS) DATED JANUARY 27, 1983.
VILLAGE VOICE ADVERTISEMENT,
FEBRUARY 13, 1996, p. 99.
LOFT BOARD RULES (EXCERPTS) -
NOVEMBER 30, 1982.
LETTER FROM LOFT BOARD (EXCERPTS)
TO LOFT OWNERS DATED DECEMBER 29.
1983
N.Y. TIMES ARTICLE DATED OCTOBER 21.
1986.
1982 LOFT LAW AMENDMENTS
(EXCERPTS).
ABSTRACT FROM THE “FEDERALIST
PAPERS”; PENGUIN BOOKS EDITION,
1987.
107a
ll7a
l4la
l44a
149a
154a
CC.
DD.
EE.
FF.
GG.
HH.
iv.
page
N.Y. TIMES ARTICLE DATED
JUNE 12, 1988. 158a
EXTRACTS FROM AFFIDAVIT OF
PLAINTIFF DATED JUNE 28, 1989 IN
SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFF’S MOTION
FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT. 164a
EXTRACTS FROM AFFIDAVIT IN
OPPOSITION TO CROSS MOTION
IN SECTION 1983 CASE. 178a
EXTRACTS FROM AFFIDAVIT OF
BRUCE H. WIENER, DATED MARCH 10,
1995, IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR
REARGU MENT, OR ALTERNATIVELY,
LEAVE TO APPEAL TO THE COURT
OF APPEALS. 189a
EXTRACTS FROM AFFIDAVIT OF
JOSEPH P. LOMBARD!, DATED
MARCH 10, 1995, IN SUPPORT
OF MOTION FOR REARGUMENT,
OR ALTERNATIVELY, LEAVE TO
APPEAL TO THE COURT OF
APPEALS. 193a
EXTRACTS FROM REPLY AFFIR-
MATION OF BRUCE H. WIENER
DATED 3/24/95 IN FURTHER
SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR
REARGUMENT, OR ALTERNA-
TIVELY, LEAVE TO APPPEAL
TO THE COURT OF APPEALS 195a
LOFT BOARD REGULATIONS,
MAY 1983 199a
EWR GRAS:
Ve
TABLE OF AUTHORITIES
Cases Cited:
Agins v. Tiburon, 447 U.S. 255, 260 (1980)
Lindsey v. Normet, 405 U.S.56, 72-74 (1972)
Nollan v. Califomia Coastal Com-
mission, 483 U.S. 825 (1987)
North Shore Cycles, Inc. v. Yahama
Motor Corp. , 919 F2d 1041
(5th Cir. 1990).
Rizzo v. Goode, 423 US 362 (1976)
640 Broadway Renaissance Co. v. Cuomo,
740 F. Supp.1023 (S.D.N.Y. 1990), affd,
927 F.2d 593 (1991), cert. denied, 500
U.S. 933, 1 11S. Ct. 2054,114 L. Ed.2d
459 (1991)
Spring Realty Co. v. New York City
Loft Board,127 Misc. 2d 1090,487
N.Y.S. 2d 973 (Sup. Ct., N.Y. Co.
1985), affd, 117 A.D. 2d 1029,
498 N.Y.S. 2d 241 (ist Dep't 1986),
affd as modified on other grounds,
69 N.Y. 2d 657, 5 11 N.Y.S.2d 830,
503 N.E. 2d 1367 (1986), appea/
dismissed for want of a substantial
federal question, 482 U.S.911, 107
S. Ct. 3179, 96 L.Ed. 2d 668 (1987)
3,9
Other Authorities:
Rent Stabilization Law of 1974. McKinney's Unconsol. Laws
§§8600 et seq.
Page
8,9
8,9
vi.
Board of Regents v. Roth, 408 U.S.564 (1972)
Collins v. Youngblood, 110 S.Ct, 110 S.Ct 2715 (1990)
Gulfside Distributors, inc. V. Becco. Lid.
985F2d (11thCir. 1993)
Keystone Bituminous Coal Assn. V. DeBenedictus, 480 U.S.
470
Loretto v. Teleprompter ManhattanCATV, 458 US4 19
(1982)..
Lucas v. Carolina Coastal Comnyssion, 120 L.Ed.2d 798
(1992) and cases cited therein
McDonald's Com. v. Nelson, 822 F. Supp. 597, affd Holiday
Inns Franchising, inc. V. Branstad, 29 F.3d 383, cert.
Den’'d.,lowa v. Holiday inns Franchising, inc., 115 S.Ct. 613.
National Collegiate Athletic Ass'n v. Miller, 795
F_ Supp. 1476, (D.Nev. 1992) aff'd 10 F.3d 633,
cert. den'd., 114 S.Ct. 1543 (Tarkanian)
19th Street Associates v. State of New York,
N.Y.L.J.7/20/90, p. 22 col.5, S.CtNY Co.), affd., 1st Dept.
N.Y.L.J. 4/25/91, p. 24
Selective Service System v. Minnesota Public interest
Research Group., 468 U.S. 841 (1984)
Vemon v. Cassadaga Valley Cent. Schoo! Dist,
49 F.3d 886. (2d Cir. 1995
Washington ex rei Seattie Trust Co. V. Roberge, 278 U.S.
116 (1928)
Tyson & Bro. V. Banton, 273 U.S. 418
vii.
Multiple Dwelling Law - all sections
Loft Board “Rules” and “Regulations’(hundreds of pages) -
not codified - including, in part, those reproduced by
Petitioner - these are purportedly issued pursuant to a
Mayoral “executive Order’. (See App."H"; "V" ; “X" and “Il”,
6.9.)
le
REPLY - | - FEDERAL QUESTIONS HAVE BEEN
RAISED FOR MORE THAN 10 YEARS - THE NEW
YORK COURTS HAVE SIMPLY IGNORED THEM.
Tenants-Respondents make clear misrepresentations to
the Court by claiming Petitioner “never raised any Federal
question in the State Court proceedings.” In fact, Petitioner
devoted pages 36 through 39 of its Brief in the Supreme
Court, 1st Dept. App. Div. (September 21, 1994 - Appendix
Q) - to Federal questions. Furthermore, Petitioner raised
federal constitutional questions at the “Loft Board” hearings
themselves; See, Loft Board Order in 1988, Appendix “P”’,
pp. 98, 99; Petitioner stated in its Interim Multiple Dwelling
application, dated 1983, that it was filed “under protest” and
“under duress”, and attached a two page Rider setting forth
constitutional objections (Appendix R). In IMD renewal
application dated August 14, 1991, Petitioner stated:
“THIS ‘INTERIM MULTIPLE DWELLING’
REGISTRATION IS FILED UNDER DURESS, UNDER
PROTEST, AND UNDER THREAT OF CRIMINAL
PROSECUTION. NO VOLUNTARY WAIVER IS INTENDED
OF ANY CONSTITUTIONAL OR OTHER LEGAL RIGHTS
THAT OWNER OF THE BUILDING POSSESSES UNDER
FEDERAL OR STATE LAW, COMMON LAW, OR THE
EXPIRED LEASES FOR THE PREMISES.” (EMPHASIS IN
ORIGINAL)
Furthermore, in Petitioner's Notice of Motion for Leave to
Appeal to New York Court of Appeals, one of the questions
presented was:
“2. Does the Loft Law's effect, as applied by the IAS Court
and the Appellate Division, of a permanent forfeiture of rent
that accrued prior to a landiord’s compliance with the
legalization timetables of the 1992 amendments to the Loft
Law constitute an unconstitutional regulatory and physical
taking of property.”
All these documents were public records served upon
Respondents and part of Record below.
The real issue herein is whether the Legislature can
retroactively reward Respondents’ criminal behavior, by
confiscating from Petitioner, and granting to Respondents
more than a million dollars of rent monies owed, plus
granting estates, contrary to owner's fundamental ownership
rights, all as part of a retroactive legislative scheme to
2.
transfer substantially all aspect of real estate ownership to
the illegal occupants.
The Loft Laws did create this confiscation of rent from
Petitioner (from four years to eight years, in some cases),
because all these Respondents’ leases expired prior to or in
1984, and respondents are only holding over by virtue of
legislative leaseholds retroactively granted to them by the
loft Laws - thus making the Multiple Dwelling Law, Sec. 301
“forfeiture provisions” applicable. Were it not for the Loft
Laws (of which §301 is a part), Petitioner would not have to
suffer these retroactively-imposed, forced (lifetime or longer) |
leaseholds, and Respondents’ claims to 4-8 years of rent-
free use of owner's building - based solely upon their own
deliberate illegal conduct - would fail.’
Furthermore, there was no “public emergency”; simply the
greedy desire of a vocai group of a few thousand who
persuaded the Legislature into retroactively granting them
leaseholds in total annihilation of property rights, and jease
contracts that were voluntarily made at arms length. This
action is to recover four to eight years of rent owed by
various tenants, assignees, sublessees and other occupants
of the building, up to and including August, 1992. This
_ legislative transfer of assets to Respondents from Petitioner
\ iS confiscatory and punitive.’
\ Furthermore, Petitioner has substantially renovated the
building since 1982°. The Loft Laws, to rub salt into wounds,
not only required a multi-million dollar conversion of the
building, retroactively imposed upon it - as a gratuitous
windfall and reward to the Legisiatively-favored tenants - but
also forced the payment of an extortionate monetary penalty,
* Attached as App “W" is a recent ad in “Village Voice” newspaper
wherein a non rent paying occupant of this building is purporting to “sell”
“his” loft for $35,000, with a “lifetime” lease. He has paid no rent since
1987.
? Another misrepresentation to this Court by Respondents is that
Petitioner did nothing to comply with the Loft Laws since 1982 - that is
preposterous. in fact, as Respondents admit, Petitioner first filed
registration under the Loft Law in 1983, soon after the law was passed -
but under protest and duress.
* See Appendix "S*.
Tee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee ee
ye Ss eee Oe eee
3.
to a New York City agency, caiculated at $9-11 per square
foot of building* - more than $400,000.
The entire basis of this legislation is the deliberate and
willful criminal occupation of the buildings by the
Respondents - by sleeping in the building - after they signed
leases specifically covenanting not to do so. Even assuming
arguendo that the landiord knew of this illegal occupation by
the tenants, it was the tenants who did the illegal occupation
- not the owner. The Legislature cannot reward these
criminal activities of Respondents by granting of permanent
interests in the real estate by retroactive legislative fiat, and
confiscating years of rent payments; The forfeiture of the
rent, necessary to “legalize” the building, is also totally
perverse and counter productive; thus there is no rational
relationship to any purported problem’.
Since the Loft Laws were totally retroactive, there was no
opportunity to avoid “compliance”. The illusory “hardship”
exemption lapsed by statute five years before this building
was designated, and before a “coverage” application was
filed; furthermore the purported “exemption” required
“registration” under the statute, with huge forfeit of rights:
including the forced recording of a covenant running with the
land for 15 years (MDL §285-2): (rendering | title
unmarketable, and violating mortgage provisions); and
required swom affidavits of complex financial information
with respect to future income, expense and capital
investment that was unknown or unknowable. The
regulations defining “hardship” were published after the
exemption period expired. Furthermore, since the statute
contained no definition of “hardship”: it is therefore obvious,
* Of course the Petitioner legally fought and protested this extortionate
monetary seizure since it was totally retroactive and confiscatory; the
legislative scheme later dropped this extortionate requirement .
: Tenants are not bound by any obligation of any kind and are free to
vacate the premises at any time, without any penalty or obligation, and are
legislatively granted “rights” to sell to strangers, property of the owner and
to usurp and pocket such proceeds to their own use and benefit. This is in
addition to all the monies that were converted by Respondents who sublet
their lofts (at large profits), and did not pay rent to Petitioner, and/or “sold”
“their” lofts for large sums, while paying no rent. (See App. W)
4.
as admitted, why no such “hardship” exemption was ever
granted. While it is true that Petitioner lawfully resisted the
increasingly-confiscatory and burdensome and bankrupting
features of the retroactive Loft Laws and resisted the
seizures by Legislature of its fundamental property rights,
with their gratuitous transfer to Respondents, this is not
“without explanation or excuse”. The specific damages to
Petitioner in this action, (confiscating more than a million
dollars of rents owed to it since before September 1992), is
only the tip of the iceberg of the staggering damage and
imposed burdens upon the Petitioner herein, which have
wiped out the concept of property ownership by the whim of
the Legislature, for this particular speciai interest group.
li - THIS CASE IS OF GREAT PUBLIC IMPORTANCE
BECAUSE (a) IT DIRECTLY AFFECTS THE
ECONOMIC ‘FUTURE OF MORE THAN 800
SUBSTANTIAL BUILDINGS IN NEW YORK; (B)
MANY BUILDINGS HAVE MORTGAGES FROM
BANKS WHICH ARE EITHER FEDERALLY INSURED
OR REGULATED; (C) THIS UNFETTERED STATE
SEIZURE OF PROPERTY WILL SEVERELY IMPACT
ON THE FUTURE OF PRIVATE INVESTMENT IN
REAL ESTATE, BANKING AND FINANCE IN THE
CITY AND STATE OF NEW YORK, AND, ERGO,
NATIONALLY.
The fundamental rights of private property ownership
have been eviscerated, by this retroactive confiscation of
four to eight years rent (and vast other property rights) at the
expense of the Petitioner. in the instant case the legislation
was the direct and proximate cause of the bankruptcy of
Petitioner herein, and said bankruptcy caused the default in
a million dollar mortgage held by a national bank (“L.S.B.”);
this bank, which like many others, had and has extensive
mortgage loans on office/loft buildings in the amounts of
hundreds of millions, if not billions of dollars; these are all put
at risk by this legislative destruction of private property.
Eee Le Oe ee ae Lee eee ee eee ee
5.
Without rent payments there is no “real estate”. L.S.B. was
itself forced into insolvency.®
it is not merely 640 Broadway which has been legislatively
bankrupted - and deprived of rental income (4-8 years worth)
retroactively, but at least 800 building owners in New York
are at risk. Who will be the target of the next political raid on
private property ownership by the next vocal political group to
curry legislative favor (next? Teamsters? Doctors? Felons?
Plumbers? Firemen? Grand-mothers? ice-Skaters?
Shoemakers?); many other groups-as well as so-called
“artists"-are groups supposedly worthy of legislative
“protection”, but the legislature has no constitutional right to
take owners property rights, and hand them over to a favored
few, unless the state pays for the taking. What limits are
there on the legislature at all, if this kind of arbitrary and
irrational, retroactive seizure and redistribution of property
rights is permitted?’ This case is of great public importance
to the preservation of private property rights in New York and
the United States, and certiorari should be granted to
prevent this banana republic legislation from spreading like
the corrupt fungus it is.
iil - IF A STATE LEGISLATURE IS PERMITTED TO
RETROACTIVELY ENACT MASSIVE UNCON-
STITUTIONAL VIOLATIONS, BY THE SIMPLE USE
OF SELF-CREATED ‘EMERGENCY’ VERBIAGE,
THEN THERE IS NO CONSTITUTION.
* LS.B. carried many mortgage loans on its books, which became
uncollectable after the Loft Laws took effect, and thereafter. L.S.B. had a
forced sale of its million dollar mortgage for $350,000 (directly incurring a
$650,000 capital loss); many banks, have had and will suffer huge losses
in their mortgage portfolios; losses to the banks, federal insurers and/or
stock holders, - or the taxpayers.
” Can the Legislature constitutionally grant auto owners parked in a
certain garage last night, the right to permanently occupy that space, at a
fixed and much lower rental than previously agreed to, and retroactively
require that not only the garage owner polish and wax the car every night,
but also fill it up with gasoline, replace the tires every year, and rebuild the
parking space into a heated, air conditioned garage with sufficient
plumbing facilities to maintain a chauffeurs apartment-all at no additional
cost and, in fact, lowering the agreed upon rent for the space and aiso
nullifying a legally contracted cost of living increase clause?
6.
It cannot be disputed that the New York Legislature,
pushed by a small vocal minority of so called “artists”,
retroactively singled out more than 800 buildings in New York
and imposed upon them horrendous and permanent financial
and legal burdens, and granted to these few thousand
tenants (and even strangers) long term estates in owner's
property - based solely upon the illegal sleeping in these
buildings by these same tenants, for a retroactively and
arbitrarily defined period of April 1,1980 to December 1,
1981 - which period ended 6 months prior to the date of
passage of the law in June, 1982. It has never been denied
that these arbitrary and retroactive dates chosen - which
resulted in 640 Broadway's “designation” as a “loft building” -
were established from the existing lists of members of loft
tenants associations. This was pure special interest
legislation, where the legislature retroactively took a very
staggering and bankrupting legal and eco-nomic burdens
upon these retroactively targeted owners *. The seizure of
rent income is the seizure of the real estate itself:
furthermore, the Loft Laws rent forfeitures are not rationally
related to any legitimate state purpose. Agins v. Tiburon, 447
U.S. 255, 260 (1980). Nollan v. Califomia Coastal Com-
mission, 483 U.S. 825 (1987)..° Lindsey v. Normet, supra.
The Loft Laws grant these deliberate illegal hold-over
tenants, as a reward for their past illegal conduct, rent-free
occupation of owner's premises for indefinite periods, and
legally enforceable long-term interests in the building -
creating a new breed of “nobility” - this is proscribed by the
Constitution. °
* under the guise of a purported “emergency” in the residential housing
market in New York City (said purported “emergency” being a legisiative
continuation of the Congressional deciaration of emergency of 1943 -
when the nation was involved in the greatest worid war in history).
* Even if the Legislature had the power to totally abrogate leases, it
could not constitutionally delegate that power to actual tenants and their
political cohorts - all appointed by the Mayor. The entire “Loft Board’
structure is self-interested and unconstitutional.
*° These college educated, white-collar “yuppies” - wealthy and Social
Register members, are not “starving artists"; all are profiteering from the
7.
Accordingly, summary judgment should have been
granted to Owner, for at least the long overdue rents for 4-8
years. The failure to so apply the 1992 Loft Law
Amendments works an unlawful seizure, constitutes a clear
taking of private property without just compensation, and
impairs basic lease contracts. The 1992 Amendments were
supposedly passed to remove many unconstitutional
features of prior law. if this Court permits Legislatures carte
blanche nullification of all constitutional rights by the simple
deciarative use of the word “emergency”, then the
Constitution is rendered totally meaningless.
Furthermore, the retroactive application of the Rent
Stablization Laws of 1974, McKinneys Unconsol. Laws
§§8600, ef seg. which imposes vast new financial and legal
burdens upon owner, never contracted (or paid for) violates
or negates virtually every substantive clause of the lease the
owner agreed to (See App. “M”); if legislatures can do this
by writing “emergency”, then no property owner, or society is
safe.
IV. THIS RETROACTIVE LEGISLATIVE GRANTING
OF PROPERTY RIGHTS TO PERSONS WHO, BY
DEFINITION, COMMITTED CRIMINAL ACTS BY ILL-
EGALLY RESIDING IN “LOFT’ BUILDINGS, EITHER
AS A REWARD FOR THEIR PAST CRIMINAL CON-
DUCT OR AS “PUNISHMENT” TO OWNER - IS AN
UNCONSTITUTIONAL SEIZURE OF PETITIONER’S
PROPERTY AND IMPAIRMENT O= CONTRACT.
The sole beneficiaries of the Loft Laws were persons
illegally residing in non-residential buildings during the
retroactively selected 1980/1981 period. The Loft Laws of
June, 1982, abrogated virtually every provision of existing
leases, and every single legisiative change is of direct benefit
to the tenant, and a burden upon the landiord. '' Just a few:
Loft Laws, subletting and “selling” “their” lofts to strangers, in total violation
of the lease, and enjoying large windfalls such as this million dollars in
rent - the absence of which made, and makes it impossible for the building
owner to comply with the stated objective of “legalizing” the building, in
any event.
‘This mandatory retroactive compliance with residential rules alone,
retroactively subjects the building to a vast panoply of building laws, codes
8.
(1) The fixed term of the lease is extended to an indefinite
term, which has reached twelve (12) extra years already
under the statutory scheme, and which is designed to be life-
time or permanent. (See, MDL §§286-13); “Rent Stabilization
Laws”. Supra; (2) As here, M.D.L.§302 directly prohibits and
confiscates the collection of all rent or use and occupancy
owed and unpaid by Respondents through September, 1992;
(3) vast new repair, services, expenditures and other
financial and legal obligations and renovation requirements
contrary to the express terms of the lease are imposed; (4)
the rent is retroactively lowered; (5) the reasonable cost of
living increases are abrogated. The Legisiature had no
constitutional authority to transfer virtually the entire bundie
of property rights (especially rent payments) from the owner
to the tenant retroactively, North Shore Cycles, Inc. v.
Yamaha Motor Com., 919 F2d 1041 (5th Circuit, 1990) to
grant long-term leaseholds totally abro-gating the contract
between the parties and imposing crushing financial burdens
upon the owner, in direct contravention of the explicit
provisions in the lease. This total destruction of contractual
expectations is clearly substantial impairment in violation of
contract clause. If this retroactive legisiation is constitutional,
then all contracts are essentially being written with invisible
ink, and not worth the paper upon which they are printed. "
V - NEITHER SPRING REALTY CO. V. NEW YORK
CITY LOFT BOARD NOR 640 BROADWAY
RENAISSANCE CO. V. CUOMO ET AL, ARE
CONTROLLING PRECEDENT HEREIN.
Spring Realty, supra, was premature and speculative,
since there was no “designated” building under the Loft
Laws; here is an actual case and controversy, after official
“designation” by the Loft Board in 1988, which caused actual
damage and bankruptcy. The Supreme Court properly
declined to review Spring Realty for “want of a substantial
federal question” because, the record clearly indicated, Loft
and statutes that relate solely to residential buildings and not to
commercial buildings. See Appendix “U" for partial list.
‘2 Also making impossible the so-called “legalization” of the building,
including the huge expenses of removing and replacing ail the illegal work
done by tenants, with no permits or licensed contractors.
9.
Laws had never been applied to those buildings; under Art.
lll, Sec. 1 of the Constitution, federal courts only have
jurisdiction over actual cases and controversies. Rizzo y.
Goode, 423 U.S. 362 (1976)"*. Since Spring Realty’s
buildings were not “designated” by the Loft Board, and no
actual damage or taking was proved, Spring Realty was
wanting a substantial federal question: but the exact
in 1990, there had no by the New York
Courts that, as here, Petitioner permanently forfeiting 4-
8 years of rent payments; the 1992 legislation sued under
collect any rents or use and occupancy due since 1980.
However, the N.Y. Courts, in the instant action, failed and
refused to appropriately apply the 1992 Amendments,
thereby unconstitutionally confiscating Petitioners 4 to 8
years of rent." |
V - THE RESPONDENTS “SPECIAL PERMIT”
ARGUMENTS ARE PURE RED HERRINGS.
it is true that Petitioner voluntarily filed a special permit
application to the City Planning Commission in 1982 - but
this was before the passage of the Loft Laws on June 21,
affirmatively required to obtain a di Zoning variance or “special
permit” In Spring Reatty, the City claimed no present showing of a taking
prematurity and conjecture, and that owners were
Petitioner was rendered because it could not collect any rent or
use and '
“* Furthermore, 640 Renaissance v. Cuomo was an action
ia a i |
10.
1982, which drastically and fundamentally changed all the
legal, financial and physical rules applicable thereto. The
retroactive imposition of the Loft Laws made the “special
permit” ruinous and inevitably bankrupting, as happened
here. Under the Loft Laws, the “special permit” became a
mandated expropriation by the Legislature. (See, App. “FF”,
‘GG’ ,“HH’). It was the specific obligation of the tenant under
the lease to do all required construction and all “code
compliance work” (App. “M” & “T”), including legal wiring and
plumbing. The Loft Laws retroactively changed all legal and
financial burdens from the tenant to the landiord. Thus, the
forced 1982 “special permit” became extortionate; and was
made totally irrelevant by the 1987 amendments to Loft
Laws; and no longer required, voluntary or desirable”.
CONCLUSION
This Court should grant certiorari and, thereafter hold that
the Loft Laws and amendments must be applied to permit
collection of past and accrued rent and use and occupancy
due; the 1992 Loft Law amendments were supposedly
“remedial” in nature and must be constitutionally construed
SO as to avoid this extortionate rent confiscation. Otherwise
an unconstitutional forfeiture of huge rent arrears results. if
this legislation, which retroactively seizes and redistributes
the fundamental rights of property ownership, as applied
here, is constitutional, then there are no contracts, and there
is no Constitution.
Dated: New York, N.Y Respectfully submitted.
March 25, 1996 MARTIN R. FINE
Attorney for Petitioner
644 Broadway, NY, NY 10012
*° With the Respondents refusal to permit access and other obstructionist
tactics, it is ludicrous to fault Petitioner for not “legalizing” the building as a
Class A multiple dwelling after 14 years since the Loft Law was passed, it
has simply been financially, structuraily, legally, and procedurally imposs-
ible for Petitioner to do so. The City Loft Board admitted in a letter to all
Loft Owners dated Dec. 23, 1993, (App. “Y"), that only 27% of buildings
had been “legalized” after eleven years. Furthermore, in September 1991,
under duress and protest, Petitioner duly registered the buiiding and was
forced by the Loft Board to pay ali the prior years “filing fees”, including the
filing fes for the years covered by the within action.
107a
APPENDIX Q
Excerpt from Petitioner's Brief dated September
21, 1994 to NY Appellate Division
G. The 1992 Loft Law Amendments Must
Be Given Retroative Effect in Order to
Avoid nstitutional j f Pro
In order to avoid an unconstitutional taking of
property, the Loft Law, as amended, must be
interpreted so as to remove the statutory imped-
iment to rent collection retroactively, as well as
prospectively, once the loft building has been
registered and is in compliance with the Loft Law.
A retroactive and permanent forfeiture of more
than four (4) years of rent payments, by legislative
fiat alone, would violate the New York State
Constitution, Article 1, Sections 6 and 7, which
provide respectively:
No person shall be deprived life, liberty
or property without due process of law.
Private property shail not be taken for
public use without just Compensation.
-36-
Based upon the Court of Appeals’ holding in
Seawall Associates v. Citv of New York, 74 N.Y.2d |
92, 544 N.Y.S.2d 542 (1989), the Loft Law, if
interpreted by the courts to effect a permanent
forfeiture of all rent due and owing to Renaissance
for the period 1988 to 1992, would constitute both
a regulatory taking and a physical taking of
Renaissance's property and its fundamental right,
as a property owner, to collect rent for the use and
occupancy of its property.
108a
In order to avoid an unconstitutional taking, this
Court must and should interpret the 1992
amendment to the Loft Law to mean that, once an
owner has registered the building under the Loft
Law, and has been deemed in compliance with the
Loft Law, all rent owed should be collectible. This
Court should construe the Loft Law so as to permit
the owner to collect its rents due, without a
forfeiture, as provided for in the lease agreements,
or the value of the use and occupancy of the
owners real estate, as well as the value of the
multitude of services required to be provided by
all other costs of operation.
As aptly noted by the Court of Appeals in
“Moreover, to constitute a physical
taking, the occupation [of private property]
need not be by the goverment itself, but
may be by third parties under its authority
(Loretto v. Teleiprompter Manhattan
CATV Corp., supra, at 432, 433, n.9, 102
S.Ct.at 3174, 3175, n.9)...”
-37-
Although the Supreme Court has not passed on
the specific issue of whether the loss of
possessory interests, including the right to exclude,
resulting from tenancies coerced by the
government would constitute a per se physical
taking, we believe that it would. indeed, it is
difficult to see how such forced occupancy of one’s
property could not do so. By any ordinary
standard, such interference with an owner's rights
to possession and exclusion is far more offensive
and invasive than the easements in Kaiser Aetna
or Nollan or the installation of CATV equipment in
Lorettg. (citations omitted)
By contrast, Local Law No. 9 totally prohibits
the sole use entirely permissible before the
enactment of the law for which investment
The Loft Law, with its coerced conversion of loft
buildings to rent reuigatred residential buildings for
“artists,” cannot constitutionally be interpreted to
impose a permanent
-38-
110a
forfeiture of rent. The collection of rent is the most
fundamental aspect of real estate ownership. The
Legislature cannot, through retroactive
“regulation,” simply take away or forfeit that
fundamental property right, for any length of time,
through “regulatory” legislation without violating the
New York State Constitution. In order to avoid
such constitutional violation and permanent
forfeiture of property rights, the Court should
properly grant retroactive effect io the 1992 Loft
Law amendments so as to permit an owner in
compliance to recover all rents due and owing.
-39-
llla
R.1l
RIDER ANNEXED TO AND MADE PART OF INTERIM
MULTIPLE DWELLING REGISTRATION APPLICTION
THIS INTERIM MULTIPLE DWELLING
REGISTRATION APPLICATION IS BEING FILED UNDER
PROTEST AND UNDER DURESS.
Article 7C of the Multiple Dwelling Law, and Section
284(a) of the Multiple Dwelling Law, as it purports to apply to
these promises, is unconstitutional and unlawful for numerous
reasons including, but not limited to the following:
(1) Article 7C of the Multiple Dwelling Law constitutes
an unconstitutional taking of applicant’s property without due
process of law.
(2) Article 7C of the Multiple Dwelling Law constitutes
an impairment of the obligation of contracts of Article l,
Section 10 of the United States Constitution, and Title 42,
United States Code, Sec. 1983.
(3) Article 7C of the Multiple Dwelling Law constitutes
an unlawful and unconstitutional delegation of legislative
authority in violation of the New York State Constitution and
the New York City Charter and Administrative Code to a group
of private individuals purporting to constitute the “New York
City Loft Board”.
(4) Article 7C of the Multiple Dwelling Law as it
purports to apply to these premises and the Interim Multiple
Dwelling Application promulgated by the “New York City Loft
Board” constitutes a invasion of privacy and requires
information to be supplied by the applicant which constitutes an
invasion of privacy and a taking of property without due
process of law and without compensation therefor in violation
of the New York State and United States Constitutions.
112a
R- 2
(5) Section 1105 of the New York State Charter and the
so-called “Mayor’s Executive Order 66” and the purported
rules and regulations relating to registration of interim multiple
dwellings purportedly promulgated by the New York City Loft
Board, Dated November 30, 1982, are unconstitutional, illegal
and an unlawful delegation of legislative authority and together
constitute an unconstitutional taking of applicant’s property
without due process of law and without compensation therefore
in violation of the New York State and United States
Constitutions.
THEREFORE, THIS APPLICATION IS FILED BY
640 BROADWAY RENAISSANCE CO., UNDER PROTEST
AND UNDER DURESS, AND DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A
WAIVER OF ANY LEGAL OR CONSTITUTIONAL
RIGHTS OF APPLICANT.
SN ribs Aies
APPENDIX C$ —
Exhibit V - Affidavit Of Hyman Schermer Sworn To April 15, 1983 (1302-1316)
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK: COUNTY OF NEW YORK
640 BROADWAY RENAISSANCE COMPANY,
Debtor-in-Possession index No. 29602/92
Plaintiff, AFFIDAVIT IN SUPPORT
OF PLAINTIFF'S MOTION
~against-
TO BE CONSOLIDATED
NANCY HOFFMAN, a/k/a NANCY GEISMAN WITH INDEX NUMBERS:
a/k/a NANCY HOFFMAN GEISMAN,
Z3IONV2
Defendants 2383192
STATE OF NEW YORK )
, ) ss.:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
HYMAN SCHERMER, being duly swom, deposes and
Says:
1. | am a licensed real estate broker and real estate
Salesman for over 20 years. | make this affidavit in support
of the Plaintiff's motions in the above matters, (all 16 cases)
with the 15 other tenants (or former tenants) at the premises
640 Broadway, New York, New York.
2. | was the broker involved in the purchase of this
building in 1978/79 by 640 Broadway Renaissance
Company, and | inspected the building many times in
1978/79, in the process of selling it. At that time, it was a
ll4a
virtually abandoned and empty broken-down manufacturing
building; in the past twelve
1
years or so, 640 Broadway Renaissance Company has
virtually completely renovated this building, replacing all the
major systems, including, but not limited to: (1 ) installing a
new boiler in 1988 (See Exhibits) (after the Loft Board
decision) ; (2) redoing the elevator (see contracts) , lobby,
hallways and staircases (see photos), the roof and main
plumbing and electrical systems, and all public areas.
3. It has also installed new mailboxes, a new
intercom system, and new front doors. See photos and copy
of contract.
4. Contrary to the claims of the holdover tenants in this
building, they are working and living in one of the finest and
best loft buildings - at artificially depressed and subsidized
rents.
5. The net effect of their claims, if granted, would be
to have the tenants steal more than a million dollars in back
rent, (ranging from five to 8 years) - based solely upon their
own fraudulent and illegal conduct.
6. The loft laws were not meant to, and do not cause
any forfeiture of rent - while the tenants were willfully using
and occupying the premises, as holdover tenants, they must
pay for their use and occupancy; the entire real estate
system fundamental to our society and economy is based
upon that simple fact. Without the assurance of rent
payments, buildings and cities cannot be built, financed or
maintained and it would be against public policy to permit
these tenants to just rip-off a million dollars of back rent -
which will reduce the value of the
2
building for real estate purposes, and assist these confessed
illegal occupiers and reward them for their misdemeanors.
See, Multiple Dwelling Law § 304.1.)
115a
r # Furthermore, to grant the tenants even further ill-
gotten gains will greatly reduce the value of all real estate in
New York State, and discourage investment in New York
across the board as Still further evidence - if the statute is so
interpreted that the New York State constitutional guarantee
of protection of private property is a meaningless phrase.
8. The plaintiff has invested hundreds of thousands
of dollars in rehabilitating and reconstructing this virtually
abandoned building, and totally renovated it and it is now
fully rented, with a waiting list!! It has become a highly
desirable building, and is considered one of the finest lost
buildings in the City. it was the first "Empire State Building”
(see attached), with spacious lofts of approximately 2,000
Sq.ft each (larger than the average single family home) with
beautiful large windows on three sides of the building, and
beautiful architectural details and high ceilings; | would be
proud to rent these lofts to anybody - and there are no visible
“hazardous” or “unsafe” conditions in the building (those are
utter and self-serving lies from the tenants, designed to
bolster their claims for not paying many years’ rent, solely
because of their own willful breach of the state's criminal
code and the city's zoning laws.
9. | recently visited and inspected the building (in the
3
winter of 1992) and carefully examined Loft Unit 7E, which
had been recently vacated by one defendant, Nancy
Hoffman. THE LOFT WAS ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL,
LUXURIOUS AND HIGHLY DESIRABLE. in my professional!
opinion, it had a rental value of at least $2,300 per month,
and would be exceedingly easy to rent at that price. (I have
been advised that it is already rented)
10. The photographs submitted as Exhibits
demonstrate how nice, clean and well maintained this loft,
and the building are, and how desirable, and not
“hazardous”. (That is attempted revisionist history by the
tenants]
iia 4
1l6a
$3, | personally tested all the plumbing fixtures in the
Loft 7E kitchen and bathroom, and they all worked properly;
the water pressure and the elevators were running fine, and
there were no hazardous conditions of any kind visible in the
lobby, stairwells, or any public or private areas. | would be
proud to show the Court this building - and cordially invite
Special Term to do so - because the tenants are plainly lying
- for pure greed - in order to reap an unconscionable and
unjust enrichment of pocketing the money for use and
occupancy that rightfully belongs to the owners of the
building.
/s/
HYMAN SCHERMER
SWORN To before me this
of April, 1993.
/s/
Notary Public
1l7a
APPENDIX T
Excerpts of lease - Additional clauses - all abrogated by “Loft
Laws”.
3. Alterations: Tenant shall make no changes in or to the
demised premises of any nature without Landlord's prior
written consent. . . .All fixtures and all paneling, partitions,
railings and like installations, installed in the premises at any
time, either by Tenant or by Landiord in Tenant's behalf.
shall, upon installation, become the property of Landlord and
shall remain upon and be surrendered with the demised
premises unless Landiord, by notice to Tenant no later than
twenty days prior to the date fixed as the termination of this
lease, elects to relinquish Landiord’s right thereto and to
have them removed by Tenant, in which event, the same
shall be removed from the premises by Tenant prior to the
expiration of the lease, at Tenant's expense. Nothing in this
article shall be construed to give Landiord title to or to
prevent Tenant’s removal of trade fixtures, moveable office
furniture and equipment, but upon removal of any such from
the premises or upon removal of other installations as may
be required by Landiord, Tenant shall immediately and at its
expense, repair and restore the premises to the condition
existing prior to installation and repair any damage to the
demised premises or the building due to such removal. . .
Tenant shall, before making any alterations, additions,
installations or improvements, at its expense, obtain all
permits, approvals and certificates required by any
governmental or quasi-govemmental bodies and (upon
completion) certificates of final approval thereof and shail
deliver promptly duplicates of all such permits, approvals and
certificates to Landlord and Tenant agrees to Carry and will
Cause Tenant's contractors and sub-contractors to carry such
workman’s compensation, general liability, personal and
property damage insurance as Landiord may require. . .
4. Repairs: .. . (See Appendix “M”) If the demised premises
be or become infested with vermin, Tenant shall at Tenant's
118a
expense, cause the same to be exterminated from time to
time to the satisfaction of Landlord. . .
6. .. .Except as provided in Article 29 hereof, nothing
herein shall require Tenant to make structural repairs or
alterations unless Tenant has by its manner of use of the
demised premises or method of operation therein, violated
any such laws, ordinances, orders, rules, regulations or
requirements with respect thereto. Tenant may, after
securing Landlord to Landiord’s satisfaction against all
damages, interest, penalties and expenses, including, but
not limited to, reasonable attommeys fees, by cash deposit or
by surety bond in an amount and in a company satisfactory
to Landlord, contest and appeal any such laws, ordinances,
orders, rules, regulations or requirements provided same is
done with all reasonable promptness and provided such
appeal shail not subject Landiord to prosecution for a
criminal offense or constitute a default under any lease or
mortgage under which Landlord may be obligated, or cause
the demised premises or any part thereof to be condemned
or vacated. Tenant shail not do or permit any act or thing to
be done in or to the demised premises which is contrary to
law, or which will invalidate or be in conflict with public
liability, fire or other policies of insurance at any time carried
by or for the benefit of Landlord with respect to the demised
premises or the building of which the demised premises form
a part, or which shall or might subject Landiord to any liability
or responsibility to any person or for property damage, nor
shall Tenant keep anything in the demised premises except
as now or hereafter permitted by the Fire Department, Board
of Fire Underwriters, Fire insurance Rating Organization or
other authority having jurisdiction, and then only in such
manner and such quantity so as not to increase the rate for
fir insurance applicable to the building, nor use the premises
in a manner which will increase the insurance rate for the
building or any property located therein over that in effect
prior to the commencement of Tenant’s occupancy. Tenant
shall pay all costs, expenses, fines, penalties or damages,
which may be imposed upon Landlord by reason of Tenant's
failure to comply with the provisions of this article and if by
119a
reason of such failure the fire insurance rate shall, at the
beginning of this lease or at any time thereafter, be higher
13. Access to Premises: Landiord or Landiord’s agents shall
have the right (but shall not be obligated) to enter the
iii
120a
demised premises in any emergency at any time, and, at
other reasonable times, to examine the same and to make
such repairs, replacements and improvements as Landlord
may deem necessary and reasonable desirable to the
demised premises or to any other portion of the building or
which Landiord may elect to perform following Tenant's
failure to make repairs or perform any work which Tenant is
obligated to perform under this lease, or for the purpose of
complying with laws, regulations and other directions of
govemmental authorities. wit
18. Remedies of Landiord and Waiver of Redemption: In
case of any such default, re-entry, expiration and/or
dispossess by summary proceedings or otherwise, (a) the
rent shall be come due thereupon and be paid up to the time
of such re-entry, dispossess and/or expiration, together with
such expenses as Landlord may incur for legal expenses,
attorneys’ fees, brokerage, and/or putting the demised
premises in good order, or for preparing the same for re-
rental; (b) Landlord may re-let the premises or any part or
parts thereof, either in the name of Landlord or otherwise, for
a term or terms, which may at Landiord’s option be less than
or exceed the period which would otherwise have constituted
the balance of the term of this lease and may grant
concessions or free rent or charge a higher rental than that in
this lease, and/or (c) Tenant or the legal representatives of
Tenant shall also pay Landlord as liquidated damages for the
failure of Tenant to observe and perform said Tenant's
covenants herein contained, any deficiency between the rent
hereby reserved and/or covenanted to be paid and the net
amount, if any, of the rents collected on account of the lease
or leases of the demised premises for each month of the
period which would otherwise have constituted the balance
of the term of this lease.
12la
19. _ Fees and Expenses: if tenant shall default in the
observance or performance of any term or covenant on
tenant's part to be observed or performed under or by virtue
of any of the terms or provisions in any article of this lease,
then, unless otherwise provided elsewhere in this lease,
landiord may immediately or at any time thereafter and
without notice perform the obligation of tenant thereunder,
and if landlord, in connection therewith or in connection with
any default by tenant in the covenant to pay rent hereunder,
makes any expenditures or incurs any obligations for the
payment of money, including but not limited to attomey’s
fees, in instituting, Prosecuting or defending any action or
proceeding, such sums so paid or obligations incurred with
interest and costs shall be deemed to be additional rent
hereunder and shall be paid by tenant to landlord within five
(5) days of rendition of any bill or statement to tenant
therefor, and if tenant’s lease term shall have expired at the
time of making of such expenditures or incurring of such
obligations, such sums shall be recoverable by landiord as
damages. * °° ;
20. No Representations by Landlord: Neitner Landiord nor
Landiord’s agents have made any representations or
promises with respect to the physical condition of the
building, the land upon which it is erected or the demised
premises, the rents, leases, expenses of operation or any
other matter or thing affecting or related to the premises
except as herein expressly set forth and no rights,
easements or licenses are acquired by Tenant by implication
or otherwise except as expressly set forth in the provisions of
this lease. Tenant has inspected the building and the
demised premises and is thoroughly acquainted with their
condition, and agrees to take the same “as is” and
acknowledges that the taking of possession of the demised
premises by Tenant shall be conclusive evidence that the
Said premises and the building of which the same form a part
were in good and satisfactory condition at the time such
possession was so taken, except as to latent defects.
122a
All
understanding and agreements heretofore made between
the parties hereto are merged in this contract, which alone
fully and completely expresses the agreement between
Landiord and Tenant and any executory agreement hereafter
made shail be ineffective to change, modify, discharge or
effect as abandonment of it in whole or in part, unless such
executory agreement is in writing and signed by the party
against whom enforcement of the change, modification,
discharge or abandonment is sought.
21. End of Term: Upon the expiration or other termination of
the term of this lease, Tenant shall quit and surrender to
Landiord the demised premises, broom clean, in good order
and condition, ordinary wear excepted, and Tenant shall
remove all its property. Tenant's obligation to observe or
perform this covenant shall survive the expiration or other
termination of this lease. if the last day of the term of this
lease or any renewal thereof, falls on Sunday, this lease
shall expire at noon on the preceding Saturday unless it be a
legal holiday in which case it shall expire at noon on the
preceding business day.
24. No Waiver. The failure of Landiord to seek redress for
violation of, or to insist upon the strict performance of any
covenant or condition of this lease or of any of the Rules or
Regulations set forth or hereafter adopted by Landiord, shall
not prevent a subsequent act which would have originally
constituted a violation from having all the force and effect of
an original violation. The receipt by Landiord of rent with
knowledge of the breach of any covenant of this lease shall
not be deemed a waiver of such breach and no provision of
this lease shall be deemed a waiver of such breach and no
provision of this lease shall be deemed to have been waived
by Landiord unless such waiver be in writing signed by
1 andiosd ies eo “pe
30. Elevators, Heat, Cleaning: As long as Tenant is not in
Gefault under any of the covenants this lease Landiord
(b) furnish heat to the demised premises, when and
required by law, on business days from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m.
and on Saturdays from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m.:; (c) at Landiord’s
Cause to be kept clean the public halls and public
of the building, which are used in common by ail
:
of independently contracting for the removal of such rubbish
and refuse in the event that Tenant does not wish to have
same done by employees of Landiord «.-
be due from, and payable by, Tenant
the amount thereof shall be deemed to
be, and be paid as, additional rent.
124a
39. Permits: Tenant covenants that Tenant will not use or
suffer or permit any person to use the demised premises for
any unlawful purpose and to obtain and maintain at Tenant's
sole cost and expense ail licenses and permits from any and
all governmental authorities having jurisdiction of the
demised premises which may be necessary for the conduct
of Tenant’s business therein. Tenant further covenants to
comply with applicable laws, resolutions, codes, rules and
regulations of any department, bureau, agency or any
govemmental authority having jurisdiction over the operation,
occupancy, maintenance and use of the demised premises
for the purposes set forth herein. Tenant will indemnify and
save Landlord harmless from and against any claims,
penalties, loss, damage or expense imposed by reason of a
violation of any applicable law or the rules and regulations of
govemmental authorities having jurisdiction thereof related to
Tenant's use and occupancy.
40. Indemnity: Tenant agrees to indemnify and save
harmless Landiord against and from ail claims by or on
behalf of any person or persons, firm or firms, corporation or
corporations, arising from any work or thing whatsoever done
by or on behalf of Tenant, in or about the demised premises,
and will further indemnify and save Landlord harmiess
against and from and all claims arising from any breach or
default on the part of Tenant in the performance of any
covenant or agreement on the part of tenant to be
performed, pursuant to the terms of this lease, or arising
from any act or negligence of Tenant, or any of its agents,
contractors, servants, employees or licensees, and from and
against all costs, reasonable counsel fees, expenses and
liabilities incurred in or about any such claim or action or
proceeding brought thereon; and in case any action or
proceeding be brought against Landiord by reason of any
such claim, Tenant, upon notice from Landiord, covenants to
resist or defend, at Tenants expense, such action or
proceeding by counsel reasonably satisfactory to Landlord.
125a
54. T OF LIVING A TMENT: Recognizing the
length of the term of the lease granted Tenant and
inflationary tendencies in recent years, Tenant agrees that in
the event the “Consumer Price index” published by the
Bureau of Labor Statistics of the U.S. Department of Labor
(1967 = 100) for New York/Northeasten New Jersey area for
“All items” (hereinafter called the “Price Index”), or successor
or substitute index appropriately adjusted, reflects an
increase after the commencement date of this lease in the
cost of living over and above such costs as reflected by such
Price Index as it exists for the month of November 1980
(hereinafter called the “Base Month”) the fixed rent payable
hereunder shall be increased in accordance with the
following:
(a) There shall be no adjustment until the month
of December 1981. On the first day of December 1981 and
each December 1st thereafter throughout the term, there
shall be an adjustment in the amount of said fixed rent based
on the difference between the Price index as it exists on the
Base Month and the Price Index for the calendar month of
the date of such adjustment.
(b) The percentage increase thus determined shall
be multiplied by the annual fixed rent payable hereunder and
this sum shall represent the annual increase in such rent for
the twelve (12) months next ensuing, commencing with such
December adjustment month, provided that no such
adjustment shall result in a decrease in the fixed rent below
the fixed rent Payable by Tenant under the terms of this
lease. @ #
126a
55. Maintenance: Tenant shall maintain the premises in a
proper manner and in a general state of cleanliness. Tenant
shall, at Tenant’s sole cost and expense, arrange for the
removal of and shall cause to be removed all refuse and
rubbish from the demised premises in a manner which shall
at all times comply with (a) such rules and regulations as, in
the judgment of the Landiord, are necessary or desirable for
the proper operation of the Building and (b) all applicable
laws, orders, ordinances, rules and regulations of the
Sanitation Department and Board of Health of New York City
and of any other governmental authority having jurisdiction
over the demised premises or the operations conducted
therein.
56. No Representations: Tenant acknowledges that Tenant
is fully familiar with the condition of the Building and the
demised premises. Tenant therefore agrees to accept the
demised premises “as is” and in whatever state or condition
they may be in at the commencement of the term of this
lease. Landlord shall not be obligated to do any work or
make any repairs, alterations, or improvements in or to the
demised premises, except as specifically set forth in this
lease.
62. Tenant shall supply and install all fixtures by Tenant at
Tenant's own cost and expense. Tenant also recognizes
and agrees that the Tenant must obtain the written consent
of the landiord for all alteration work to be done on the
premises in advance for all such work being done. Tenant
further recognizes and agrees that because this is a fireproof
building, that all partition work must be done with metal studs
and with 5/8” sheet rock on both sides. Tenant further
recognizes, understands and covenants that the use of any
wooden studs or partitions in the premises will be both a
violation of the lease and a violation of the applicable
building laws and codes and tenant covenants and agrees
not to use any non-fireproof materials in any such
construction work.
127a
63. Tenant also recognizes and understands that all
plumbing work must be done or approved by a licensed
plumber and will submit all plumbing plan to the landlord for
landiord’s prior written approval before such work is
commenced.
64. Tenant recognizes, agrees and covenants that all waste
and vent lines must be made or properly sized cast iron or
galvanized iron pipe and that the use of plastic pipe is not
legal in new York City. Tenant further reconizes and agrees
that if copper tubing is used, said copper tubing must be
figid copper tubing and that the use of flexible copper tubing
is not lawful or permitted and will also be a violation of the
lease.
65. Tenant recognizes, agrees and covenants that all
electrica!' work must be done and filed by a New York City
licensed electrician. Tenant shall supply copies of ail
electrical installation drawings to the Landiord prior to such
installation.
66. Tenant shall require all of its contractors plumbers and
electricians to supply to the Landlord a certificate of
insurance naming the Landiord as an additional insured prior
to the commencement of any work by said contractor,
plumber or electrician.
eta
LOFT BOARD
Rules and Regulations
Pursuant to Section 1105 of the New York City Charter,
Article 7-C of the Multiple Dwelling Law, and Mayor’s
Executive Order No. 66, the New York City Loft Board hereby
promulgates the following Rules and Regulations Relating to
Registration of Interim Multiple Dwellings and Minimum
Housing Standards for Interim Multiple Dwellings.
Section 1 Definitions
A. Landlord -
As used in these regulations, the term “landlord” shall
mean the owner of an interim multiple dwelling, the lessee of a
whole building part of which is an interim multiple dwelling, or
the agent or other person having control of such a dwelling.
B. Residential Occupant -
As used in these regulations, the term “residential
occupant” shall mean an occupant of an interim multiple
dwelling eligible for protection under Article 7-C of the New
York State Multiple Dwelling Law.
Section2 Registration of Interim Multiple Dwellings
A. The following “Information and Instruction to Owners,
Lessees and Agents of Interim Multiple Dwellings” constitute
the procedures for registration of Interim Multiple Dwellings
pursuant to Section 284(2) of Article 7-C of the New York
State Multiple Dwelling Law. Applications for registration shall
be in a form promulgated by the Loft Board.
129a
New York City Loft Board
116 Nassau Street
New York, NY 10038
566-1438
INFORMATION AND INSTRUCTIONS
TO OWNERS, LESSEES AND AGENTS
OF INTERIM MULTIPLE DWELLINGS
A new state law, Article 7-C of the Multiple Dwelling
Law, effective June 21, 1982, required the establishment of a
New York City Loft Board to foresee the legalization of
residential lofts. The law defines as an “interim multiple
dwelling” a building or a portion thereof in an area which
allows residential use, which: (1) at any time was occupied for
manufacturing, commercial or warehouse purposes; (2) on
December first, nineteen hundred eighty-one was occupied for
residential purposes since April first, nineteen hundred eighty
as the residence or home of any three or more families living
independently of one another; and (3) lacks a certificate of
compliance or occupancy pursuant to section three hundred one
of the Multiple Dwelling Law. In addition, in an interim
multiple dwelling residential occupants in units first occupied
after April 1, 1980 and prior to April 1, 1981 shall be qualified
for protection pursuant to Article 7-C. A reduction in the
number of occupied residential units in a building after
December 1, 1981 shall not eliminate the protections of Article
7-C for any remaining residential occupants qualified for such
protections.
Section 284(2) requires the registration of all interim
multiple dwellings. These instructions are being sent to, or are
available to, landlords of buildings which are believed to be
interim multiple dwellings. (See 4. below.) If additional forms
are required for other buildings, or if there are any questions,
contact the above office.
130a
INSTRUCTIONS - INTERIM MULTIPLE DWELLING
REGISTRATION APPLICATION - PART A
1. PRINT, using black ink only, all information in
completing the registration form. Detach this Information and
Instruction sheet and RETURN copies of the form, when
completed, to:
“LM.D.” REGISTRATION
NEW YORK CITY LOFT BOARD
116 NASSAU STREET
NEW YORK, NEW YORK 10038
Registration forms must be filed for all Interim Multiple
Dwellings by January 31, 1983 to avoid payment of an initial
registration fee.
see
8. APPLICATIONS MUST BE COMPLETED IN
ITS ENTIRETY. LEGIBLE COPIES OF THE CURRENT
LEASE OR, WHERE THERE IS NO CURRENT LEASE,
THE MOST RECENT LEASE AGREEMENT (INCLUDING
ALL EXECUTED RIDERS, AMENDMENTS, MODIFICA-
TIONS AND EXTENSIONS) FOR ALL RESIDENTIALLY
OCCUPIED UNITS MUST BE ATTACHED REGARDLESS
OF THE COMMERCIAL, RESIDENTIAL, OR MANUFAC-
TURING NATURE OF THE LEASE. IF NO LEASE
EXISTS OR EXISTED, ATTACH A SIGNED STATEMENT
OUTLINING THE MOST RECENT RENTAL
AGREEMENT.
zee
AN APPLICATION WILL NOT BE ACCEPTED,
AND AN IMD REGISTRATION NUMBER WILL NOT BE
ASSIGNED, UNLESS ALL QUESTIONS ARE ANSWERED
IN FULL AND ALL REQUIRED LEASES ARE
13la
ATTACHED. If a particular question or piece of information is
inapplicable or not available enter NOT APPLICABLE and
attach a signed statement explaining the reasons. The content of
an application will be reviewed prior to acceptance.
ese
If the owner, lessee, agent or other person is a
corporation, other than a corporation listed as exempt from the
provisions of the Multiple Dwelling Law § 325, the names,
business and residence addresses and phone numbers of its
officers must be listed on the form.
Other officers, including treasurer or chief fiscal
officer, and stockholders who own or control at least 10% of
the corporation’s stock must be listed on a separate attachment.
If the owner, lessee, agent or other person is other than
an individual or a corporation, the names, business and
residential addresses and phone numbers for each general
partner or participant in a partnership or joint venture must be
listed on a separate attachment.
AT LEAST ONE OF THE PHONE NUMBERS
ENTERED ON THE FORM MUST BE A CONFIDENTIAL
TELEPHONE NUMBER WHERE A RESPONSIBLE
PARTY CAN REASONABLY BE EXPECTED TO BE
REACHED AT ALL TIMES FOR EMERGENCIES. SUCH
NUMBER(S) MUST BE WITHIN 50 MILES RADIUS OF
NEW YORK CITY LIMITS AND MUST BE INDICATED
ON A SEPARATE SIGNED SHEET OF PAPER AND
ATTACHED TO THE APPLICATION.
‘
11. All owners, lessees of whole buildings, and
agents or other persons having control of the premises who file
for I.M.D. Registration Numbers agree to provide the
minimum housing maintenance standards established or to be
132a
established by the Loft Board to all residentially occupied units
for as long as the I.M.D. Registration Number is valid.
B. Landlords of interim multiple dwellings for which an
IMD Registration Number has been issued, shall be deemed to
be compliance with the registration provisions of Article 7-C
and shall be entitled to claim rents becoming due after the date
of issuance of the IMD Registration Number, in summary
proceedings, pursuant to Section 285(1) of Article 7-C of the
Multiple Dwelling Law.
Finding that there are a significant number of ongoing
disputes between landlords and residential occupants in loft
dwellings over payment of past due rents and that Article 7-C
did not intend to authorize landlords to recover past due rents
from residents occupying premises which may not qualify for
coverage under Article 7-C, the Loft Board believes that
landlords’ right to recover for past due rents pursuant to
Section 285(1) of the Multiple Dwelling Law should be stayed
until the question of coverage of an IMD has been resolved.
Landlords who waive their right to contest coverage by
executing a written waiver in a form acceptable to the Loft
Board or whose coverage dispute has been resolved by a
determination that the premises in question are covered by
Article 7-C and who have met the requirements of subdivision
2(A) of this rule shall be deemed in full compliance with the
registration provisions of Article 7-C in order to claim past due
rent payable from residential occupants pursuant to Section
285(1) of the Multiple Dwelling Law.
Section 284(2) of Article 7-C requires owners, lessees of
whole buildings and agents of interim multiple dwellings (i.e.
applicable non-residential loft buildings) to file with the Loft
133a
Board a notice in conformity with Section 325 of the Multiple
Dwelling Law and with rules and regulations promulgated by
the Loft Board. This Rule, which established filing procedures
conforms to MDL Section 325 while making additions in
several important respects.
Second, owners, lessees and agents are required to submit the
current, or most recent lease for each residentially occupied
information on these leases will be kept confidential. Third,
those who file for IMD registration will agree to provide the
minimum housing maintenance standards established by the
Loft Board to all residentially occupied units.
Article 7-C, Section 282 authorizes the Loft Board to
standards in interim multiple dwellings. The Loft Board held
public hearings concerning minimum housing maintenance
standards on October 27, 1982 and November 10, 1982.
Landlords, tenants and concerned citizens testified.
I do hereby certify that good cause exists for waiving
the requirement that thirty days shall first elapse after
publication in THE CITY RECORD and that the foregoing
Regulations shall become effective on the date of publication.
Dated: January 27, 1983
Filed with the City Clerk: January 27, 1983
Ls/
CARL B. WEISBROD
Chairman
ar
134a
APPENDIX W
VILLAGE VOICE
February 13, 1996
P. 99
LOFTS FOR RENT 6180
Noho Bdwy-Studio for Sale:
Fixture Fee. Lifetime ise $640./mo
950saft finished. Darkrm, live/work.
$35k cash/a deal!
(212)873-1581
LOFT BOARD
Notice of Seog vm of and nity to
Comment on New Rules clating to
Registration Of Interi -
Dwellings and
Minimum Housing Maintenance Standards for
Interim Multiple Dwellings Addressing
i Dangerous to Human Life and
Safety
Pursuant to Section 1105 of the New York City Charter
and by virtue of the authority vested in me as Chairman of the
New York City Loft Board by Mayor’s Executive Order No.
66 the following Rules Relating to Registration of Interim
Multiple Dwellings and Minimum Housing Maintenance
Standards for Interim Multiple Dwellings Addressing
Conditions Dangerous to Human Life and Safety are hereby
promulgated to be immediately effective.
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN,
PURSUANT TO SUBDIVISION E OF
SECTION 1105 OF THE CITY CHARTER, THAT interested
persons may comment in writing on the following Rules,
which are effective immediately. Written comment regarding
the Rules may be submitted to the undersigned, addressed to
him at his office at 116 Nassau Street, New York, NY 10038
not later than January S, 1983. Comments will be duly
considered prior to the promulgation of permanent regulations
on this matter.
Section | Definitions
A. Landlord - As used in these emergency
regulations, the term “landlord” shall mean the owner of an
interim multiple dwelling, the lessee of a whole building part of
136a
K-2
which is an interim multiple dwelling, or the agent or other
person having control of such a dweiling.
B. Residential Occupant - As used in these emergency
regulations, the term “residential occupant” shall mean an
occupant of an interim multiple dwelling qualified for
protection under Article 7-C of the New York State Multiple
Dwelling Law.
Section2 Registration of Interim Multiple Dwellings
A. The following “Information and Instruction to
Owners, Lessees and Agents of Presumptive Interim Multipic
Dwellings” and “Interim Multiple Dwelling Registration
Application - Part “A” constitute the procedures for registration
of Interim Multiple Dwellings pursuant to Section 284(2) of
Article 7-C of the New York State Multiple Dwelling Law:
(See separate Form and Instructions)
ses
Section3 Minimwn Housing Maintenance Standards
For Interim Multiple Dwellings
A. Landlords of interim multiple dwellings shall
provide the following minimum housing maintenance services
to residential occupants qualified for the protection of Article 7-
C of the Multiple Dwelling Law:
1. Water Supply and Drainage - . . .
2. Heat-...
E. It is the objective of the Loft Board that residential
occupants receive heat seven days a week. The Board will
[
137a
X-3
mandate such services, through additional and expanded rules
and regulations, as buildings move toward legalization.
3. Hot Water -...
4. Electricity -...
5. Gas -...
6. Smoke Detectors - . . .
7. Public Lighting - . . .
8. Entrance Door Security - . . .
9. Elevator Service - . ..
EXPLANATION }
In June 1982 a new Article 7-C of the Multiple
Dwelling Law was enacted. Article 7-C provides a framework
whereby most of the City’s living lofts will be brought up to
minimum health and safety standards as well as brought under
a system of rent regulation and minimum housing maintenance
standards. Article 7-C required the Mayor to appoint a Loft
Board to oversee this process. The Mayor established the Loft
Board, pursuant to Executive Order No. 66, on September 30,
1982. Section 284(2) of Article 7-C requires owners, lessees
of whole buildings and agents of interim multiple (i.e.
applicable non-residential loft buildings) to file with the Loft
Board a notice in conformity with Section 325 of the Multiple
Dwelling Law and with rules and regulations promulgated by
the Loft Board. This Rule, which establishes an emergency
filing procedure and application, conforms to MDL Section 325
while making additions in several important respects. It permits
owners, lessees and agents to file with the Loft Board without
J
138a
X-4
waiving their rights to contest coverage before the Loft Board.
Those wishing to contest coverage, however, must do so by
letter within 30 days of the issuance of the IMD registration
number and so inform their occupants. Second, owners,
lessees and agents are required to submit the current, or more
recent lease for each residentially occupied unit along with IMD
Registration Applications. All identifying information on these
leases will be kept confidential. Third, those who file for IMD
registration will agree to provide the minimum housing
maintenance standards established by the Loft Board to all
residentially occupied units.
Article 7-C, Section 282 authorizes the Loft Board to
establish, after public hearings, minimum housing maintenance
standards in interim multiple dwellings. The Loft Board held
public hearings concerning minimum housing maintenance
standards on October 27, 1982 and November 10, 1982.
to provide and maintain the standards regarding waiter, utilities,
hot water, heat and other services required pursuant to this
Rule constitute a condition dangerous to human life and safety.
A procedure for landlords or interim multiple dwellings
to file with the Loft Board is necessary so that the Board, and
other City agencies, may determine which buildings are subject
to Article 7-C of the Multiple Dwelling Law and which
residential occupants are subject to the protections of said
Article 7-C including the housing maintenance standards
required by this Rule.
— eo
139a
KS
8. This application must be completed in its entirety.
Legible copies of the current lease or, where there is no current
lease, the most recent lease agreement (including all executed
riders, amendments, modifications and extensions) for all
residentially occupied units must be attached regardless of the
commercial, residential, or manufacturing nature of the lease.
All personal and confidential information on leases will not be
available under the Freedom of Information Act. The
application will not be accepted, and a registration number will
NOT be assigned, unless ALL questions are answered in full
and all required leases are attached. If a particular question or
piece of information is inapplicable, enter NOT APPLICABLE.
The contest of the application will be reviewed prior to
acceptance.
seks
11. All owners, lessees of whole buildings, and agents
or other persons having control of the premises who file for
I.M.D. Registration Numbers agree to provide the minimum
housing maintenance standards established or to be established
by the Loft Board to all residentially occupied units for as long
as the I.M.D. Registration Number is valid, provided however,
that an I.M.D. Registration Number shall not be deemed
invalid solely if a residential occupant shall withhold the
payment of any rent then due.
sz
13. An identification sign containing the building,
address, the interim dwelling registration number assigned by
the Loft Board for the purpose of identifying the building and
the owner and managing agent shall be posted in every interim
multiple dwelling within five (5) business days after the
issuance of the I.M.D. Registration Number. The manner and
location of the sign must comply with rules prescribed by the
140a
x-6
sk *
Article 7-C, Section 282 authorizes the Loft Board to
establish, after public hearings, minimum housing maintenance
standards in interim multiple dwellings. The Loft Board held
public hearings concerning minimum housing maintenance
standards on October 27, 1982 and November 10, 1982.
Landlords, tenants and concerned citizens testified. The failure
to provide and maintain the standards regarding water, utilities,
hot water, heat and other services required pursuant to this
Rule constitute a condition dangerous to human life and safety.
A procedure for landlords or interim multiple dwellings
to file with the Loft Board is necessary so that the Board, and
other City agencies, may determine which buildings are subject
to Article 7-C of the Multiple Dwelling Law and which
residential occupants are subject to the protections of said
Article 7-C including the housing maintenance standards
required by this Rule.
FINDING AND STATEMENT | |
find
As Chairman of the New York City Loft Board, I
that the imminent peril to the public health and safety caused by
the existence of unsafe conditions in interim multiple dwellings
and the absence of a filing system permitting the efficient
identification of such interim multiple dwellings, requires
adoption of the foregoing Rule and that the observance of the
requirement of notice and opportunity for comment in writing
would be contrary to the public interest. The foregoing Rule is
therefore adopted to become effective on the date of publication
in the City Record.
Dated: November 20, 1982
Filed with the City Clerk: November 30, 1982
/sL
CARL B. WEISBROD
Chairman
l4la
APPENDIX Y
EXCERPTS FROM LOFT BOARD LETTER
ANDREW E. ScHuLrz RUUDOLPH RINALDI
CHAIRMAN
LEE FAWKES
DIRECTOR
COMMISSIONER
DEPARTMENT OF BUILDINGS
EX OFFICIIO)
New York City Loft Board Chuck Delaney
Municipal Building - 23rd Floor South Samuel A. Jacobs
One Centre St- Room 2358 Cynthia Navaretta
New York, New York 10007 Gerard Proefriedt
(212) 669-4375 Elizabeth R. Wilde
Members
December 29, 1993
Dear IMD Owner or Representative:
There are a number of developments to communicate to
you as we conclude another year and approach a new
administration.
New Rules: The Loft Board has promulgated a series of
new rules, effective December 6, 1993, involving non-
institutional loans, Rent Guidelines Board (RGB) rent
increases, and time limitations on coverage, rent overcharge
and registrati ications.
registration ae ot
Proposed Rules: The Loft Board is also considering a
package of revisions in its Code Compliance Regulations.
The aim is to review these rules in light of our experience to
date and to correct any areas which we find have not worked
well in practice. Since this set of rules is being utilized by an
increasing volume of buildings, we want to be sure they have
been carefully reviewed and refined. Our Particular goal is to
make changes where where existing rules have contributed
to delays and recourse to the administrative hearings
process. The issues of elevators, rent adjustment exclusions
based on deferred maintenance and preexisting violations,
and the narrative statement and rent adjustment applications
processes have been the initial priorities. We expect to have
a final package developed in the next few months with a
hearing by Spring. 7 = es
Extensions: There has been an extraordinary volume of
requests for extension of the October 1, 1993 building pennit
deadiine.
While it is encouraging that many more owners than
before are actively responding to our mailings and engaging
themselves in the leqgalization oracace tha hamn, wi.”
142a
has also presented administrative burdens, since this new
category of applications has been devised at a time of
diminishing staff resources. For those owners who may still
need further extensions, there are several steps which can
be taken to ease processing time for the next round. First,
the owner and architect should decide who is making the
application, rather than each making a separate application.
The person with the most direct knowledge should make the
application. In the first round of extension requests, any
building with duplicate filings was handied after buildings with
one filing, and the same approach will be taken in the next
round. Second, if the tenants support the extension
application, the applicant should have them so advise us.
Contested applications will be reviewed after uncontested
ones, and the 25 day response time must be permitted to
run, if there is no expression of tenant support or prior
opportunity to comment. as
Total IMD’s to be legalized:
December 1992 - 784
December 1993 - 810
Buildings with C’s of O:
December 1992 - 195 (25%)
December 1993 - 215 (27%)
Buildings wi
oft rd ion:
December 1992 - 209 (27%)
December 1993 - 263 (32%)
Statements Filed:
December 1992 - 191 (24%)
December 1993 - 200 (25%)
Buildings with an Alteration
Application Filed:
December 1992 - 122 (16%)
December 1993 - 103 (13%)
Building w/o an Alteration
143a
Application Filed:
December 1992 - 68 (9%)
December 1993 - 31 (4%)
Registration: There has also been an increased level of
registration compliance. Whereas last year, there were 29
buildings unregistered and 167 whose registration was not
current, this year with a larger IMD universe there are 21
unregistered and 145 not currently registered. For owners
who are unable to complete registration due to outstanding
fines, we have been able in many cases to work out time
payment agreements which spread repayment over the
registration period. Contact our registration unit for details.
Another round of enforcement proceedings, seeking
additional fines for non-registration or non-current
year, A »+#
eductic af ages: The Loft Board lost
another two positions and $50,000 in personnel funding,
effective July 1, 1993, in the latest round of fiscal Cut-backs.
Particularly hard hit has been the hearings staff, which has
now been reduced from five full-time and one per-diem
hearing officers to a total of three, one of whom must also
supervise the unit. While we will all continue to do our best
to respond to pending applications, you should understand
that there is a significant backlog and that our resources for
responding have continued to diminish.
| hope this update has been helpful. Our best wishes for
the holiday season and the new year ahead.
Yours truly,
Lee Fawkes
| hope this update has been helpful. Our best wishes for
the holiday season and the new year ahead.
Z
144a
Copyright (c) 1986 The New York Times Company;
The New York Times
October 21, 1986, Tuesday, Late City Final Edition
SECTION: _ Section B; Page 1, Column 3; Metropolitan
Desk
LENGTH: 1013 words
HEADLINE: SUITABLE FOR FRAMING;
CITY MAKES IT OFFICIAL: THEY’RE
ARTISTS
BYLINE: By GEORGIA DULLEA
BODY:
FIFTEEN years after the Museum of Modern Art
acquired its first work by Benny Andrews, and four years after
the National Endowment for the Arts named him director of its
visual arts program, an advisory committee to the city’s
Department of Cultural Affairs sat in a conference room the
other night pondering whether he was a professional artist.
They concluded he was. The 55-year-old painter was relieved.
Last month the panel, the Artist’s Certification Committee, had
postponed action on Mr. Andrews’s application for official
Status as an artist because of a technicality. “I forgot to sign my
name,” he said, rolling his eyes. “We artists don’t always think
about dotting ‘i’s’ and crossing ‘t’s.’”
Breaking New Ground
When Mr. Andrews and 29 other men and women
joineu the ranks of the city’s 5,000 certified artists last week,
they were not only following in the steps of Willem de
Kooning, Red Grooms ‘ed ah Katz, but also breaking new
ground in the 15-year-old certification program. Theirs were
the first applications to be approved under formal, written
regulations rather than an informal process that has mystified a
generation of professionals in the creative arts.
The chief reason so many artists submit themselves to
the process is that certification entitles them to legally live and
work in commercial or industrial zones like SoHo where
spaces are large and filled with light and rents are — or once
were —- low.
A Seal and a Signature
Other artists say certification — in the form of a notarized
certificate, suitable for framing, bearing the silver seal of the
Cultural Affairs Department and the signature of Commissioner
Bess Myerson — looks good on grant applications. It is also
said to impress the Internal Revenue Service.
“Primarily our applications come from New York,”
said the program’s coordinator, Joseph Giordano, “but we get
them from other parts of the country and the world — Spain,
Israel, France, Canada, Italy, India. If they meet our criteria,
we certify them.”
As he spoke the telephone rang in his office at 2
Columbus Circle. The caller, a multimedia artist, told Mr.
Giordano he would not divulge his Social Security number on
his application. “Why does Bess Myerson want my Social
Security number?” he asked.
Mr. Giordano, a painter before becoming a bureaucrat,
decided not to press the matter. “With artists,” he said, “you’ve
got to be careful about issues of personal freedom.”
A Mystery, Even to Applicants
146a
The Artist’s Certification Committee has long been
something of a mystery body, even to artists. Created in 1971,
the 18 artists, art educators and administrators from various
disciplines meet 10 times a year. Of the 600 applicants whose
credentials are considered each year, 75 percent are said to
receive certificates.
Until recently, however, no written rules on
certification existed and the procedure has long been the subject
of lore. Chuck DeLaney, a photographer and a tenant
representative on the Loft Board, says stories are still told in
SoHo of nonartists who submitted their children’s
fingerpaintings and were certified within a week.
A couple of weeks ago, Mr. Giordano visited several
real-estate agencies in SoHo, posing as a prospective loft
buyer. He said that at each space he was shown, he asked the
agent, “Don’t you need some kind of artist’s certificate to live
here?” Invariably, he said, the reply was “Don’t worry about
it” or “Do you know any artists?”
Rent-An-Artist
The question was an allusion to the “rent-an-artist”
scheme, he said, in which nonartists rent out small corners of
lofts to people in berets.
One reason the formal regulations were drafted was to
discourage nonartists from moving into artists’ districts. “The
city is concerned that our fine artists have places to live and
work, and SoHo was set aside for that purpose,” Ms. Myerson
said.
According to a lawyer for the department, Susan B.
Rothschild, the regulations basically codify past procedure.
One change makes the certificate valid as long as the artist
remains at the same address. In the past, artists had to be
recertified every three years.
147a
Documentation Needed
An artist is defined as one “engaged in the fine arts, not
the commercial arts, including but not necessarily limited to
painting, sculpture, choreography, filmakin g and the
composition of music, regularly and on a professional basis.”
Extensive documentation is required. A visual artist
must submit 15 to 20 slides or photographs of recent work, in
addition to a resume, review clippings, show Catalogues and
references.
“What we do,” said Rovert Blakely, a painter on the
committee, “is review their materials — slides, tapes, films,
anything that proves they’re out there in the real world
functioning as a real artists. When we’re really confused, rather
than turn them down, we’ll make a studio visit, which usually
clears things up.”
When the artist lives in SoHo or NoHo, the process is
more complex. These areas are designated artists’ joint living-
working districts.
A ‘Di ing’ C a
“By law,” Mr. Blakely said, “we’re bound to take the
space needed into consideration. Theoretically, an artist like
Joseph Cornell, who makes little boxes, wouldn’t need the
same space as Rivera, the Mexican muralist.”
Ms. Myerson, who has observed the committee at
work, describes them as “very intense and arduous.”
“T've watched these people poring over credentials of
artists to prove that they are fine artists, not commercial
artists,” she said. “They examine slides, Signatures on
paintings and in some instances they’ve discovered fraudulent
representation. They’re discerning.” Doris Diether, a dance
ee
148a
critic and former committee member, recalled the case of an
applicant who photographed paintings on display and
submitted the slides as samples of his own work.
“Someone on the committee laughed and said, ‘Oh,
come on. That’s So-and-So’s work,” she said. “The supposed
artist was very indignant when we turned him down.”
GRAPHIC: Photo of Benny Andrews and wife Nene
Humphrey (NYT/Dith Pran)
SUBJECT: ART; ZONING
ORGANIZATION: CULTURAL AFFAIRS, NEW YORK
CITY DEPARTMENT OF
NAME: GIORDANO, JOSEPH; DULLEA, GEORGIA;
ANDREWS, BENNY
GEOGRAPHIC: NEW YORK CITY; SOHO (NYC)
149a
APPENDIX AA
STATE OF NEW YORK
8958
IN SENATE
June 29, 1992
AN ACT to amend the multiple dwelling law, in relation to the
legalization of interim multiple dwellings and to amend
chapter 349 of the laws of 1982 amending the multiple
dwelling law relating to the legalization of de facto multiple
dwellings in cities of over one million, in relation to
terminating such legalization.
The People of the State of New York, represented in Senate
and Assembly, do enact as follows:
Section 1. Subdivision 1 of section 284 of the multiple
dwelling law, as added by chapter 349 of the laws of 1982, is
amended to read as follows:
1. (Il) The owner of an interim multiple dwelling (A) shall file
an alteration application within nine montsh from the effective
date of the act which added this article, and B) shall take all
reasonable and necessary action to obtain an approved
alteration permit within twelve months from such effective
and (D) shall take all reasonable and necessary action to
obtain a certificate of occupancy as a class A multiple
dwelling for the residential portions of the building or
" EXPLANATION - Matter in italics (underscored) is
new; matter in brackets 3h is old Law to be
omitted.
ram, 4 Mads | peggeese
152a
amended to read as follows: 2. (i) Prior to compliance with
safety and fire protection standards of article seven-B of this
chapter, residential occupants qualified for protection
enti aiiinime ae
and shall pay the same rent, including escalations, specified
in their lease or rental agreement to the extent to which such
lease of rental agreement remains in effect or, in the
absence of a lease or rental agreement, the same rent most
recently paid and accepted by the owner, if there is no lease
or other rental agreement in effect, rent adjustments prior to
article seven-B compliance shall be in conformity with
guidelines to be set by the loft board for such residential
occupants within six months from the effective date of this
7
AT ADR Neel
Oe ie SS a aD PER Rae Ye, ee
a) = ets ~. % rs nee ea ae
7 lent aa is AEE lee NT aN Dd 9, RR hd Oi cA che RN ON RE elie aihnsitiit eB allen acne
WD ala ida.
Ge i Si a. Poems ee. Mohn eh aes 8
153a
{E) Owners who obtained an alteration perm
Sec. 3 Section 277 of the multiple dwelling law is amended
by adding a new subdivision 16 to read as follows:
1 . j § anda ste ; : ibe
ai i
Sec. 4. Section 3. of chapter 349 of the laws of 1982
amending the multiple dwelling law relating to the legalization
of interim multiple dwellings, as amended by chapter 226 of
the laws of 1992, is amended to read as follows:
Sec. 3. Effective date and termination. This act shall take
effect immediately. The provisions of this act and all
regulations, orders and requirements thereunder shall
terminate [ . ' HEHE
besilel thei idertial—t 4
Hective-dete-in—-whiel termination-shalt bined
yeare-from-the-effective-date] June 30, 1996.
153%a
Sec. 5. This act shall take effect immediately and shall be
deemed to have been in fuil force and effect on and after
June 21, 1992.
154a
APPENDIX BB
NUMBER XXXIX
THE FEDERALIST
THE CONFORMITY OF THE PLAN TO
REPUBLICAN PRINCIPLES:
skh
... Could any further proof be required of the
republican complexion of this system, the most decisive one
might be found in its absolute prohibition of titles of nobility,
both under the federal and the State governments; and in its
express guaranty of the republican form to each of the
latter...
PUBLIus [Madison]
NUMBER XLIV
THE SAME VIEW CONTINUED AND
CONCLUDED
... Bills of attainder, ex post facto laws, and laws
impairing the obligation of contracts, are contrary to the first
principles of the social compact and to every principle of sound
legislation. The two former are expressly prohibited by the
declarations prefixed to some of the State constitutions, and all
of them are prohibited by the spirit and scope of these
fundamental charters. Our own experience has taught us,
nevertheless, that additional fences against these dangers ought
not to be omitted. Very properly, therefore, have the
convention added this constitutional bulwark in favor of
personal security and private rights; and I am much deceived if
they have not, in so doing, as faithfully consulted the genuine
sentiments as the undoubted comes of their constituents. The
sober people of America are weary of the fluctuating policy
which has directed the public councils. They have seen with
regret and indignation that sudden changes and legislative
interferences, in cases affecting personal rights, become jobs in
the hands of enterprising and influential speculators, and snares
to the more industrious and less informed part of the
community. They have seen, too, that one legislative
interference is but the first link of a long chain of repetitions,
every subsequent interference being naturally produced by the
effects of the preceding. They very rightly infer, therefore, that
some thorough reform is wanting, which will banish
speculations on public measures, inspire a general prudence
and industry, and give a regular course to the business of
seciety. The prohibition with respect to titles of nobility is
copied from the Articles of Confederation and needs no
comment.
ses
PUBLIUs [Madison]
Oe
NUMBER LXXXIV
CONCERNING SEVERAL MISCELLANEOUS
OBJECTIONS
The establishment of the writ of habeas corpus, the prohibition
of ex post facto laws, and of TITLES OF NOBILITY, toe
which we have no corresponding prohibition in our
Constitution, are perhaps greater securities to liberty and
republicanism than any it contains. The creation of crimes after
the commission of the fact, or in other words, the subjecting of
men to punishment for things which, when they were done,
were breaches of no law, and the practice of arbitrary
156a
imprisonments, have been, in all ages, the favorite and most
formidable instruments of tyranny. The observations of the
judicious Blackstone, in reference to the latter, are well worthy
of recital: “To bereave a man of life [says he] or by violence to
vee
\hurrying hin: to jail, where his sufferings are unknown or
forgotten, is a less public, a less striking, and therefore a more
dangerous engine of arbitrary government.”
ses
-- Nothing need be said to illustrate the importance of
the prohibition of titles of nobility. This may truly be
denominated the cornerstone of republican government: for so
long as they are excluded there can never be serious danger that
the government will be any other than that of the people. ...
eee
PuBLius [Hamilton]
NUMBER LXXXV
CONCLUSION
n ses
The additional securities to republican government, to
liberty, and;to property, to be derived from the adoption of the
plan under consideration, consist chiefly in the restraints which
157a
the preservation of the Union will impose on local factions and
insurrections, and on the ambition of powerful individuals in
single States who might acquire credit and influence enough
from leaders and favorites to become the despots of the people;
in the diminution of the opportunities to foreign intrigue, which
the dissolution of the Confederacy would invite and facilitate;
in the prevention of extensive military establishments, which
could not fail to grow out of wars between the States in a
disunited sit. ition; in the express guaranty of a republican form
of government to each; in the absolute and universal exclusion
of titles of nobility; and in the precautions against the repetition
of those practices on the part of the State governments which
have undermined the foundations of property and credit, have
planted mutual distrust in the breasts of all classes of citizens,
and have occasioned an almost universal prostration of morals.
se
PUBLIUS [Hamilton]
158a
APPENDIX CC
Copyright (c) 1988 The New York Times Company;
The New York Times
June 12, 1988, Sunday, Late City Final Edition
SECTION: _ Section 10; Page 11, Column 1; Real Estate
Desk
LENGTH: 1424 Words
HEADLINE: IF YOU’RE THINKING OF LIVING IN:
SoHo
BYLINE: By MARK McCAIN
BODY:
THAT chic and gritty district of Manhattan known as
SoHo should post a warning at its borders: Only rich artists
need apply. For what was once a refuge for painters seeking
cheap space to work on huge canvases has been bid up like the
prices of Warhol knickknacks at a Sotheby’s auction.
Along narrow, cobblestoned streets, loft buildings from
a century ago — when Manhattan boasted manufacturing
muscle — now house sculptors, painters and people simply
willing to pay the price.
Technically, only city-certified artists can move into
SoHo, except for a few buildings open to anyone. The theory
is that artists need large, inexpensive spaces to create their
work. But frenzied demand for Manhattan housing is pushing
that theory beyond its limits.
On Wooster Street, a 7,500-square-foot loft has been
transformed into a fantasyland of more than a dozen rooms
159a
dressed up with architectural artifacts like marble fireplaces.
It’s for sale at $2.3 million.
There are cheaper lofts, of course, but below $500,000
the options are limited and modest. The raw loft space, decrepit
and dirty, that attracted artists to SoHo a decade ago is rarely
for sale today. When a building at 123 Greene Street became a
residential co-op recently, the unrenovated 4,000-square-foot
floors sold briskly for about $800,000 apiece.
“Ten, 15 years ago when artists first came here, a lot of
them vere young and living together,” said Anthony Dapolito,
who has been watching the neighborhood from his bakery on
Prince Street for half a century. “Now they all have babies and
they’re just like everyone else. They're interested in day-care
centers and schools. They want playgrounds.”
But no one left room for playgrounds in SoHo, which
is zoned for manufacturing. So its metamorphosis from factory
grime to family comforts is incomplete.
And that appeals to many of the residents, who enjoy
the eclectic, often volatile mix of artistic and commercial forces
in this 33-block district, named SoHo because it extends south
of Houston Street to Canal Street. Even to tourists who crowd
the streets on weekends, the incongruity is hard to miss.
Within a few yards of Fanelli Cafe, a friendly beer-and-
burger joint at Prince and Mercer Streets, there are a lumber
yard, an art gallery, a machine shop, a fashion boutique, and a
store with more photography books than nearly any competitor
in North America.
Most of SoHo lies within a historic district created in
1971 to protect “the largest concentration of cast-iron facades
anywhere in the world.” Greene Street is especially rich in
ornate columns, entwined serpents, pilasters and arches.
160a
Even before the Italianate cast-iron architecture began
emerging in the late 1860's, SoHo had a commercial appeal.
Warehouses and stables lined the streets — having pushed out
the modest clapboard houses of blacksmiths and other workers
who moved in after farmers sold off their acreage in the late
1700’s.
Although the formal lines of historic SoHo are rigid, its
neighborhood spirit is fluid, spreading north and west,while
Chinatown edges up from the southeast. Its free-spirited
disdain of boundaries helps make SoHo a creative, cnaotic
place. It would rather assault senses than assuage them.
That rebellious spirit carries over into regulatory
matters. Unreliable freight elevators converted illegally to
passenger use are common. So are dozens of other building-
code violations. Some co-ops lack certificates of occupancy,
which New York City requires of all residential structures. For
a buyer, that means a deal must be all cash because banks will
Since 1971, when a zoning resolution was adopted to
allow living-working quarters in SoHo, new residents have
been required to be certified as artists by the Department of
Cultural Affairs.
But many people who would be hard pressed to draw a
stick figure have moved into SoHo without certification. So
last fall, in an admission of past enforcement failures and a
vow of future vigilance, the city offered amnesty to SoHo
residents who broke the rules.
Since then, co-op boards and real estate brokers have
been reluctant to sidestep certification. The city has yet to
display a hard-line stance, but people fear the City will initiate
eviction proceedings against new residents who flout it.
léla
“Like manufacturers, artists use their space to create
their work, so we feel we’re justified in making a special
exception for them,” said Susan B. Rothschild, counsel to the
Department of Cultural Affairs. “It’s the artists who are largely
responsible for the excitement and vitality of SoHo today.”
Above half of the 4,000 residential lofts in SoHo are
rental, but they are difficult to find on the market. And for the
people who live within them, they often are difficult to hang
onto only becavse of their murky legal status.
“Tt’s not the typical nature of artists to become involved
with lawyers, bureaucracy and paperwork — but we’ve
become pros at it,” said Marie Dormuth, an artist who moved
into a loft on Canal Street 11 years ago. “Nearly every artist I
know has very expensive legal counsel.”
Part of their legal time is focused on 1985 regulations
the city Loft Board adopted to force renovations in nearly
1,000 residential loft buildings with health, safety or fire code
violations. First, debate raged over how renovation costs
should be shared; now tenant activists fear that hundreds will
be evicted from buildings where owners cannot, or will not,
remove violations by the 1992 deadline.
“It’s a real distraction from our work, but we have to
fight because this housing stock is a rare resource that belongs
to the artists,” Ms. Dormuth declared. “We pioneered this
neighborhood, and we're still a strong group, even though
now we've surrounded by gilded French restaurants and
boutiques.”
IT is those restaurants and boutiques — along with the
art galleries — that define SoHo for many visitors. From Dean
& DeLuca, a cornucopia of fresh and exotic foods, to
Chanterelle, the only downtown restaurant to earn four stars
from The New York Times restaurant critic, good food is never
far way in SoHo.
162a
Nor is provocative art. In addition to the roster of
famous galleries operated by the likes of Max Protech, Diane
Brown and Leo Castelli, new galleries seemingly germinate
overnight.
Throughout SoHo, a core of establishments have
prospered for more than a decade — while a dizzying parade of
others pass through, often nipped by rising rents, especially
along the prime retail street, West Broadway.
“It’s like West Broadway gets a personality makeover
at least once a year,” said David Matthews, a dancer who lives
on Greene Street. “Right now it’s all fancy boutiques and
cafes, although some kitschy galleries and T-shirt shops have
opened up to tap the tourist market.”
Yet as a community created within an old
manufacturing district, SoHo lags behind in basics like
supermarkets, barbershops and variety stores. Schools, too,
tend to be outside the neighborhood.
Parents in SoHo can choose among more than a dozen
private and parochial schools elsewhere in downtown
Manhattan, and three public elementary schools: P.S. 3 at 490
Hudson Street, P.S. 41 at 116 West 11th Street and P.S. 234
at 334 Greenwich Street. The High School for Humanities,
about 20 blocks north at 351 West 18th Street, is a frequent
choice for older stuxjents.
“Like every other community we have lots of little
problems,” said Mr. Dapolito, the 67-year-old baker, “but
SoHo has survived the years well — and so have I. When
everyone was eating Wonder Bread and TipTop I thought it
was the end of the world for bakeries. But these artists, they go
wild for my bread.
io3a
“I don’t think we could have gotten a better class of
people than the artists,” he added. “They’re intelligent, they're
hard working and they’re nonviolent.”
GAZETTEER
Population: 8,400 (1980 census).
Median household income: $36,400 (1985 estimate)
Median 2,000-square-foot loft price: $535,000.
Median 2,000-square-foot loft rent: $3,250.
Rush-hour commutation to midtown: 15 minutes on the IRT,
BMT or IND line, 20 minutes by bus on the major avenues.
Councilwoman: Miriam Friedlander, Democrat.
Blazing Barrels: In the 1800's firefighters called SoHo “Hell’s
Hundred Acres” because of fires that broke out repeatedly in
warehouses overcrowded with cloth, chemicals and other
flammables — spurring owners to began erecting brick and
cast-iron warehouses around 1870.
GRAPHIC: Photos of Chanterelle restaurant at 89 Grand
Street; interior of Dean & DeLuca, exotic food store at 121
Prince Street (NYT/Peter Freed); map of SoHo (NYT)
SUBJECT: SOCIAL CONDITIONS AND TRENDS;
GEOGRAPHIC PROFILES
NAME: MCCAIN, MARK
GEOGRAPHIC: NEW YORK CITY; SOHO AREA (SOUTH
HOUSTON INDUSTRIAL DISTRICT) (NYC)
APPENDIX DD 164a
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
x
640 BROADWAY RENAISSANCE
COMPANY,
: AFFIDAVIT IN
Plaintiff, : SUPPORT OF
: PLAINTIFF’S
- against - : MOTION FOR
: SUMMARY
MARIO CUOMO, as Governor of : JUDGMENT
The State of New York, et ai., :
Defendant. :
x
STATE OF NEW YORK _)
) ss.:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK )
MARTIN R. FINE, being duly sworn, deposes and
says:
***
13. It is also an undeniable fact that 640 Broadway is
not structurally suited as a multiple dwelling. In order to make
the building suitable for residential use, major structural
changes would be required, including the installation of
fireproof walls, stairways and fire escapes, as well as the
installation of new elevators and substantially new plumbing,
heating and electrical systems. in addition, the Owner would
have to comply with a myriad of City and State laws which
only apply to the operation of residential buildings, but not to
commercial buildings.
165a
manufacturing enterprises. While there had been illegal
residential use prior to plaintiff’s purchase, in fact, the plaintiff
eliminated such use by removing all the residential tenants after
the plaintiff took title.
_ ees
18. In each instance, the lease was the product of an
arms-length transaction with a well-educated, sophisticated
adult who either was represented by, or had access to an
attorney. In each instance, the premises were vacant, the
occupant who executed the lease had a residence elsewhere and
expressly represented to the Owner that the unit would not be
used as a residence. The occupants further represented that they
knew it was illegal to reside in the building; that they would
comply with all laws relating to the use of the premises; and
that they would indemnify the Owner and hold it harmless from
any claims, penalties, loss, damage or expense, including
attorneys fees, incurred because of their illegal use of the
premises.
19. The plaintiff had good reason to insist upon each
occupant’s specific promise that the unit would not be used as a
residence. It is a well-known fact that in the late 1970’s it
became quite chic to live in commercial loft buildings in lower
Manhattan. It was to protect the plaintiff from those
adventurous individuals who were willing to flaunt the building
code and applicable zoning laws, that this building owner
insisted upon specific written assurances from all prospective
tenants that they would use their units solely for commercial
purposes, and would indemnify the plaintiff against all
damages resulting from any illegal use. Moreover, their leases
specifically required the tenants to pay for the cost of any
subsequently required building improvement or changes.
20. Had the prospective tenants not made those specific
written representations, the plaintiff never would have entered
into any lease agreements with them. —
s**
166a
a. Paragraph 30 of the lease requires the
landlord to provide heat and elevator service only on business
days from 8 a.m. until 6 p.m. and on Saturdays from 8 a.m.
until 1 p.m. The landlord is not required to furnish these
services in the evenings, on Saturday afternoons, or on
Sundays.
b. Also pursuant to Paragraph 30, the tenant is
obligated “to pay Landlord the cost of removal of any of
tenant’s refuse and rubbish from the building; and pursuant to
Paragraph 4, the tenant is obligated to arrange and pay for the
extermination of vermin.
c. Pursuant to Paragraph 41, the tenant is
obligated to “replace all damaged or broken plate glass or other
glass in or about the demised premises.”
d. Pursuant to Paragraph 42, the tenant at its
sole cost and expense shall be solely responsible for and pay
for all utilities and/or services used and required by tenant,
including electricity and gas and water.”
¢. Pursuant to Paragraph 39, the tenant is
obligated to “obtain and maintain at Tenants’ sole cost and
expense all licenses and permits from any and all governmental
authorities having jurisdiction of the demised premises which
may be necessary for the conduct of Tenant’s business
therein.”
167a
f. Pursuant to Paragraph 78, the tenant is
obligated to maintain a $500,000.00 liability insurance policy
in effect for the benefit of the landlord and the tenant.
g. Pursuant to Paragraph 54, the landlord is
entitled to periodic rent increases based on the Consumer Price
Index.
h. Pursuant to Paragraph 72, the tenants agreed
to accept the demised premises “as is” in its condition at the
commencement of the lease term.
sx
26. The foregoing provisions are found only in
commercial leases. Clearly, these were not residential leases.
The plaintiff never agreed to provide those services which are
required for residential tenants. In determining the rent, which
was freely negotiated, the plaintiff did not factor in the cost of
providing residential services, because the leases were
commercial, not residential in nature, and because the building
was zoned for manufacturing and office use only. Neither did
the rents reflect the enormous costs that would be involved in
converting the building into a legal multiple dwelling, even if
that were legally and structurally possible.
31. Moreover, my attorneys advise me that these
deliberate violations by the occupants constitute a criminal
offense under Section 304(1) of the New York State Multiple
Dwelling Law, which provides that every person who violates
or assists in the violation of the multiple dwelling law shall be
guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by fines and/or
imprisonment. N.Y. Mult. Dwell. Law §304(1) (McKinney
1986).
sae
168a
33. Besides their illegal residential use, the occupants
have violated their leases by their deliberate failure to quit and
surrender the premises upon the expiration of their lease terms.
34. All of the leases at issue here were first executed in
the period between 1978 and 1982. Each was a standard
commercial loft lease which provided for a short term of
between two to six years. All of these leases, except one, have
expired.3 Annexed hereto as Exhibit F is a list of the occupants
and the execution and expiration dates of their leases.
***
Moreover all of the occupants assert the right to reside
on the premises indefinitely under the protection of the Loft
Law, which, they claim, permits them to live in their units rent
free.
36. The occupants have violated their leases in other
ways. Primary among these violations is the persistent failure
on the part of the occupants to pay rent, rent increases, and/or
use and occupancy for their units.
37. Since the determination of the Loft Board, none of
the occupants have paid rent. Furthermore, many occupants, in
reliance upon the provisions of the Loft Law, stopped paying
rent after its enactment. For instance, Hannah Eshel has not
paid rent since October of 1984 and owes an amount in excess
of $70,000.00. Other occupants owe amounts ranging from
$10,500.00 to $36,000.00. At the present time, the Owner is
owed rent, additional rent and/or use and occupancy in the
amount of at least $465,017.94 (calculated at the rates called
for in the expired leases). Annexed hereto as Exhibit G is a list
of the rent arrears for each unit as well as their current market
values.
ee
169a
THE OWNER’S ATTEMPTS TO
IMPROVE CONDITIONS AT 640 BROADWAY
43. Extensive renovations and repairs were made to
upgrade the building and to cure the building and fire code
violations that the previous tenants had caused. For instance, a
new boiler was installed in 1988 at a cost of approximately
$45,000.00, which is more than adequate to meet the needs of
a commercial loft building operated in a manner consistent with
the requirements of the leases. In addition to general
renovations in the public areas, a new front door, mail boxes,
an intercom security system were installed at the Owner’s
expense, although not required by the leases.
47. In 1982 after the passage of the Loft Law, the
Owner abandoned its attempt to alter the permissible use of the
building because of the statute’s oppressive and confiscatory
provisions. Thus when the plaintiff made a good faith effort to
legally convert the building to residential use, the City would
not allow it; and now that the plaintiff vehemently objects, the
State and City, under the pain of non-collection of rent, and the
imposition of crushing penalties, seek to force the Owner to
apply for a discretionary zoning change and totally change the
existing certificate of occupancy and force the unwanted
conversion of 640 Broadway into a multiple dwelling. This is
in direct violation of the leases, the existing certificate of
occupancy and the zoning laws.
51. Among at OO the Loft Law established
an administrative body called the Loft Board (MDL §282). The
Loft Board consists of from four to nine members who
purportedly represent the public, the real estate industry, loft
residential tenants, and loft manufacturing interests, but in fact
are all political appointees of the Mayor of the City of New
York and serve at his whim and pleasure.*
52. Among other duties, the Loft Board is charged with
the responsibility of determining which buildings are covered
by the Loft Law. The Loft Board also issues regulations,
which currently exceed several hundred pages, and further
totally negate the basic rights of property owners like the
plaintiff.
55. The economic impact of this scheme on an owner
such as the plaintiff is devastating. Not only must an owner
bear ail of the economic risk throughout a conversion process
which could take several years, but it is certain that the owner
will not recoup any expenses for an extended period of time,
and will never recoup all of the conversion costs. These
Statutory provisions are in direct conflict with the leases for 640
Broadway which obligate the tenants to pay for the cost of all
“non-structural repairs” and all other legally required building
alterations (Exhibit E, Pars. 4, 6, 39, 55, 69).
58. As originally enacted, the Loft Law contained a
mechanism for exemptions from coverage for those buildings
for which compliance would cause an “unjustifiable hardship”
(MDL §285(2)). Hardship exemptions were purportedly
available in cases where the cost of compliance rendered the
residential conversion infeasible. However, those hardship
l7la
provisions (which were both speculative and illusory) lapsed
prior to the finding by the Loft Board that 640 Broadway was
covered by the Loft Law (MDL §285[2)).
59. Thus, even though the residential conversion of this
building will cause the plaintiff devastating economic hardship,
there exists no statutory basis for avoiding compliance with the
Loft Law. Moreover, it is a matter of public record that no
hardship exemption has ever been granted.
i
63. Apparently the legislature determined that because
artists supposedly require large amounts of space for their
work, and because the financial remunerations of artists are
supposedly “small,” the conversion of former manufacturing
and commercial loft buildings should be encouraged to provide
housing for artists. However, in conjunction with Article 7-C
(the Loft Law) these statutes do more than merely encourage
housing for artists, they mandate the conscription and the
forced conversion of certain targeted buildings for that purpose
without paying the Owner for the property rights that have
clearly been seized.
65. The end result of this statutory scheme is that the
owners of these arbitrarily selected commercial loft buildings
are being compelled to subsidize artists in the pursuit of their
alleged artistic endeavors by the State of New York which has
gratuitously turned over virtually all of the Owner’s basic
property rights to the illegal residential tenants. Incredibly, the
whole legislative scheme is premised upon the deliberate
criminal acts of these tenants.
172a
67. In essence, this amounts to a “reward” to the
tenants for their deliberate illegal occupation of the premises in
knowing iolation of the leases, the certificate of occupancy,
the building code and the zoning laws. This “reward” consists
of the grant of virtual life estates in the premises to the
occupants, and a forcible and massive turnover of the Owner’s
property rights to former tenants without just compensation.
80. The total effect of the Loft Law is to confiscate the
building from the plaintiff and to give essential long-term
control of the property to the occupants, thereby rewarding
them for their deliberate violations of the law and their leases.
81. Pursuant to the Loft Law, the fact that illegal
residential use violates the law and the leases cannot serve as a
basis for removing the illegal-use tenants, nor can the fact that
the leases long ago expired (MDL §286). These restrictions
demonstrate the coercive heart of the Statute and its confiscatory
nature.
82. Under the Loft Law, there is one and only one way
that affected owners can recover any rent or the value of the use
and occupancy of the units in the building. According to the
Loft Law, only affected owners who are “in compliance” with
the statute can recover rent. In order to be in compliance with
the Loft Law, an affected owner must Capitulate to the
confiscatory provisions of that law. The owner must register
with the Loft Board and must comply with a schedule, the end
of which is the forced conversion of the building to a legal
multiple dwelling at huge and uncompensated expense. And
before any of the work can even begin, the plaintiff must apply
for and be granted a discretionary zoning change known as a
“special permit,” which may never be granted, which may take
years to obtain, and which is subject to the discretionary review
by the Community Planning Board, the City Planning
172ka
tree
84. By permitting the occupants to remain in long-term
residential rent-free occupancy, the State has authorized the
virtual seizure by the occupants of the Owner’s building, and
the State has affirmatively granted the former tenants legal
estates in the property. The Owner never authorized, and in fact
expressly prohibited residential use; the State authorized that. It
was not the Owner who authorized the former tenants to remain
in occupancy after the expiration of their leases; the State did
that. The Owner never authorized indefinite lease renewals; the
State did that. The Owner never authorized the occupants to
live in the building rent free; the State did that.
a
86. The right to collect rent on leased property is the
most fundamental right of property ownership, without which
the entire American system of real estate ownership and
financing would collapse.
92. Thus, the Loft Law requires the Owner to permit
the permanent physical occupation of its building by third
parties arbitrarily selected by the State and who now exercise
their complete dominion over the property, and the Owner has
no control over the timing, extent or nature of the invasion or
its Cost.
93. In deciding this motion, I respectfully urge this
court to consider the fact that the only commodity that a
property owner like the plaintiff has to sell is the use and
occupancy of the space within its building. It is the plaintiff’ s
only stock in trade. To deprive the Owner of the monetary
value of the property, and all of its rights to use, possess or
rent the property is to extinguish virtually all rights of
ownership.
173a
THE LOFT LAW AND RELATED STATUTES
IMPOSE AN UNFAIR BURDEN ON THE OWNER
TO SUBSIDIZE ARTISTS
100. Here, the subsidy takes two forms. First, the
Owner is required to rehabilitate this almost 100 year-old
commercial structure at a cost of nearly Two Million Dollars in
order to make it suitable for residential use. Moreover, because
only certain costs can be passed on to the occupants, and even
though these costs must be amortized over a ten or fifteen year
period, full recoupment is unlikely. The second form of
subsidy occurs because the Owner is compelled to totally
renovate its existing commercial building to provide living
quarters for artists indefinitely and at reduced and strictly
controlled rents under the Emergency Tenant Protection Act of
1974,
se
103. While subsidized housing for “artists”, like
housing for the elderly or the homeless, may be commendable
government programs, it is simply unfair and unconstitutional
to impose the entire economic cost of remedying such social
problems on a small group of arbitrarily selected owners like
the plaintiff.
THE STATUTORY SCHEME IS NOT RATIONALLY
RELATED TO ITS STATED PURPOSE
104. My attorneys advise me that in order for a statute
which treats citizens unequally to pass constitutional muster, it
must be rationally related to a legitimate state purpose.
105. Articles 7-B and 7-C, in conjunction with the
Zoning Resolution, are not rationally related to the stated
174a
purpose of providing low-income artist with inexpensive
housing and work space. Most of the persons protected by
these laws are not artists, nor are they in a low-income bracket,
and of those who are artists, many do not require large
living/work quarters for the pursuit of their artistic endeavors.
106. Annexed hereto as Exhibit L is a recent article
from the New York Times which noted that the median 2,000
square-foot loft price in SoHo is $535,000.00; the median
2,000 square-foot rent is $3,250.00; and the median househoid
income is $36,400.00. N.Y. Times, June 12, 1988, §10, p.
11, col. 1. While the neighborhood in which 640 Broadway is
located may have been pioneered by artists seeking inexpensive
work space, it is now populated by chic and expensive
boutiques, galleries and restaurants. Technically, only certified
artists are entitled to loft spaces, but as a practical matter as the
New York Times warned, “[o]nly rich artists need apply.” /d.
109. The Owner of 640 Broadway has relied in good
faith on the existing zoning regulations which prohibit the
residential use of this building, as well as the lawfully issued
certificate of occupancy for commercial use, which dates back
to 1966. This certificate of occupancy cannot be recalled,
cancelled or vacated at the whim of the government.
110. The government should not be permitted to
compel the plaintiff to apply for a change in the existing zoning
or certificate of occupancy for this building. The plaintiff has a
vested property right in the existing certificate of occupancy
issued to the building and the zoning classification which
permit the building to be used only for commercial and office
purposes. Not only is this the only lawful use, but it is the only
175a
use that the plaintiff desires, and the only use permitted in the
occupants’ leases.
111. In addition to depriving the Owner of the right to
decide the lawful use to which its building will be put, the Loft
Law also deprives the Owner of the right to decide how it will
invest its money, and forces the Owner into a new business —
residential housing — at enormous and uncompensated
expense. In order to bring the building into full compliance
with the applicable multiple dwelling laws, the Owner will have
to spend upwards of Two Million Dollars to attempt to obtain a
type of zoning variance called a “special permit” it does not
want; to make major structural alterations and improvement
which it does not desire or need; so that the building can be
116. Thus, the Loft Law has substantially altered the
contractual relationship between the defendant-occupants and
the Owner, and has superimposed additional obligations
conspicuously beyond what the Owner agreed to undertake.
117. My attorneys advise me that this constitutes an
unconstitutional impairment of the obligations of a private
contrary in violation of Article I, §10 of the United States
Constitution.
118. The determination of whether a building is
covered by the Loft Law depends in part upon whether a
residential certificate of occupancy had been issued to that
building prior to the effective date of the statute (MDL
§281(1)). Thus, the legislature created two classes of loft
buildings, and imposed different obligations on the owners in
these separate classes. It is only the owners of the applicable
buildings who had not obtained residential certificates of
occupancy by June 21, 1982 the date of the enactment of the
Loft Law, who are compelled by the Loft Law to convert their
buildings to residential use and who are thereafter subjected to
rent control.
2168
120. In fact, the imposition of rent control is counter-
productive, because rather than provide an incentive to owners
to undertake these massive rehabilitation projects, the law
makes it virtually impossible for the affected owners to obtain
financing for or recoup their forced investments. Clearly, by
cavalierly subjecting these buildings to commercial rent control,
the Loft Law goes far beyond its stated purpose.
121. My attorneys advised me that a statute which
creates an impermissible classification which bears no rational
relation to a legitimate government objective is violative of the
equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment.
aor
123. What the Loft law did was to reward a specific
and identifiable group of tenants for their wrongdoing by
retroactively transferring to them a bundle of property rights,
and then compelling a select group of commercial building
owners to provide lifetime subsidies to these lawbreakers in the
form of costly building improvements, controlled rents, and the
forced dedication of the building to the tenants’ control.
124. Although the Loft Law was allegedly enacted to
alleviate a housing emergency, the application of Article 7-C to
the owners of buildings classified as interim multiple dwellings
and not to other commercial and/or residential property owners
rests on grounds wholly irrelevant to the achievement of the
state’s objectives.
125. Moreover, although the Owner and other
commercial loft landlords subject to the Loft Law have not been
convicted of any crime, these severe punishments have been
inflicted upon them by the New York State Legislature in
violation of the Bill of Attainder Clause of the United States
Conetionl
126. The economic impact on the affected owners is
devastating. This commercial building owner will be compelled
to undertake renovations costing up to Two Million Dollars,
and is the consigned to the arbitrary and capricious limitations
on income set by the Loft Law. The building is subjected to the
most strict form of rent control and is consequently drastically
diminished in value, and the Owner is forever stripped of his
property rights in the fixtures and numerous other basic
property rights. These economic burdens are further
compounded by the confiscation of the Owner’s property rights
to decide the lawful use to which the building will be put; to
choose its tenants; and to negotiate the terms of its leases and
even to collect rent for an extended period of time.
127. Not only is the punishment severe, but it is also
inescapable. The Loft Law, originally contained a speculative
and illusory “hardship exemption,” but those provisions
expired, and are no longer available to owners like the plaintiff
whose buildings have recently been determined to be covered
by the law. Consequently, even though compliance with the
Loft Law will cause a devastating economic hardship, there is
128. For all of the foregoing reasons, it is respectfully
requested that this Court grant the plaintiff's motion for
summary judgment on all of the constitutional claims asserted
in Counts 1 through 9 of the complaint together with such other
ls/ MARTIN R. FINE
Sworn to before me this
28th day of June, 1989
Notary Public
APPENDIX EE
178a
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK i
640 BROADWAY RENAISSANCE
COMPANY, a New York Partnership : ia” elgl
Plaintiff, : OPPOSITION
: TOCROSS-
-against- : MOTION
MARIO CUOMO, as Governor of
The State of New York, A
STATE OF NEW YORK )
SS.:
COUNTY OF NEW YORK)
MARTIN R. FINE, being duly sworn, deposes and
says:
7. Rather than change the law so as to encourage the
permissive conversion of loft buildings, instead the City and
the State adopted a program which made such conversions
compulsory and confiscatory. The compulsion includes the fact
that if an owner does not convert, he cannot remove the illegal
residential tenants from possession, and for as long as the
illegal conditions created by the tenants’ occupancy exist, the
owner cannot collect rent and, without rent, will lose the
building by City confiscation.
179a
10. Any claimed “emergency” which may have existed,
was totally self-created by the loft tenants’ utter disregard for
the clear provisions of law and their leases. In the plaintiff’s
case, the residential use of the lofts was prohibited both by
zoning, fire, safety and building laws. In disobeying these
laws and in dishonoring their leases, the tenants created any
“emergency” which may have existed. The truth of the matter is
that the only “emergency” was that the tenants’ leases had
expired by their own terms, which the tenants did not like.
12. If there was any “emergency,” it was caused by the
deliberate and illegal acts of the very same tenants who now
claim lifetime residential estates in the plaintiff’s commercial
building based solely upon their illegal use and occupation
under a short-term commercial lease.
13. But even if there was an “emergency,” it is clear
that it was not so wide-spread so as to constitute a “public”
problem. Rather, the Loft Law represented an attempt by
government to reward, for political reasons, an arbitrarily and
pre-selected group of tenants for their own illegal activities.
14. That the purported emergency was not widespread,
is evidenced by Paragraph 18 of the affidavit of Lee Fawkes in
which he admits that since 1982, only 120 buildings have fully
complied with the Loft Law, while another 290 have begun the
legalization process. Moreover, a recent article in the New
York Law Journal reported that there are nearly 650 loft
buildings in New York City which are not in compliance with
the Loft Law. Anderson, Loft Landlords Limited on Suits for
Back Rent, N.Y.L.J., July 10, 1989, p. 1, col. 3. A copy of
this article is annexed hereto as Exhibit “A.” Thus, it appears
that a total of only approximately 1,000 buildings are affected
by the Loft Law out of the hundreds of thousands of buildings
located in New York City.
in0a
15. Neither can it be disputed that the “covered” tenants
were pre-selected for coverage. Despite the fact that the Loft
Law took effect on June 21, 1982, it applied only to tenants
who had been in residential occupancy during the period of
April 1, 1980 through December 1, 1981.
ee °?@
17. Thus even before the Loft Law was enacted, the
City knew the addresses of the affected buildings and the
names of most, if not all, of the tenants who would be affected.
Therefore, by definition, this was special interest legislation.
18. Furthermore, lists of buildings and affected tenants
were compiled by an organization of loft tenants known as the
Lower Manhattan Loft Tenants Association. This list was made
available to the City and State government, who worked in
conjunction with the Manhattan Loft Tenants Association to
prepare the legislation which was ultimately adopted by the
State Legislature.
* re
36. It is a matter of public record that the Loft Board
consists of a group of persons appointed by the Mayor of the
City of New York, who serve at his whim and will. These
politically-connected hacks do not represent the interests of
property owners. To the contrary, the Loft Board has proven
itself to be nothing more than a group of puppets whose strings
are pulled by pro-tenant political interests in the City of New
York.
37. On the nine (9) members on the Loft Board, only
one (1) purportedly represents the real estate industry. Hence,
persons such as labor leaders and loft tenants have been
delegated the majority power to totally control the plaintiff’s
building. These individuals have been given the power to
a
18la
dictate allowable rents, the duration of the leases, and the
Services that must be provided. In enacting the Loft Law, the
State took away from the Property owners the right to make
these fundamental business decisions, and gave the right to
persons having no economic interest in the building. Clearly,
such a vast delegation of virtually all of the property owner’s
rights to an anti-owner political group constitutes a seizure in
its most classic constitutional sense.
38. In reality, the deck was stacked against the plaintiff
the day the Loft Board hearings began. As is virtually the case
with every decision it makes, the Loft Board, by a vote of ej ght
to one, ruled against the owner. The Owner never expected the
Loft Board to do anything, other than issue such a one-sided,
% Pe
49. The first deficiency in the defendants’ argument is
that just because the plaintiff became aware that the tenants had
freely and voluntarily elected to flout the law by illegally living
in their units, did not make such acts lawful.
50. The second deficiency in the defendants’ analysis is
that just because the plaintiff became aware that the tenants had
freely and voluntarily elected to flout the law by illegally living
in their units, did not make the leases any less enforceable than
they were on the day that the tenants agreed to abide by the
terms, Covenants and conditions contained in those leases,
which leases all contain “no waiver” and “no oral modification”
Clauses.
51. The most frightening deficiency inherent in the
defendants’ argument is that because the plaintiff became aware
of the tenants’ contemptuous disregard for law and lease, that
in some perverse way, gave the state the right to seize the
182a
plaintiff's property and to transfer it to the tenants. Apparently,
the unspoken sentiment is that because the tenants violated the
law and breached their leases, it is the plaintiff who should be
punished, not because the plaintiff was the wrongdoer, but
rather because it became aware of the wrongdoing
52. The attitude manifested by the defendants ex-
emplifies what the plaintiff claims is fundamentally wrong with
the Loft Law. Their entire argument is build upon a disregard
of the fact, which is basic to the Loft Law, that loft tenants
committed deliberate criminal acts by living in their units, and
that as a result, it is the owner who is being punished by the
confiscation and conscription of his building.
53. This is a classical example of a Bill of Attainder.
Through no fault of its own, the plaintiff is being punished by
an act of the legislature, without any trial for the deliberate
wrongdoing of its tenants. Despite what the Governor-
defendant says in his memorandum of law — that statutes have
rarely been invalidated on this ground — does not mean that
this Constitutional provision has any less force or effect than it
did when it was inserted into the Constitution by the founding
Fathers.
te
66. In 1980, two years before the enactment of the
Loft Law, the City adopted the Relocation Incentive Program
which required owners of loft buildings in certain areas of the
City who wanted to convert their buildings to multiple
dwellings to pay a substantial “conversion contribution” before
they could obtain an alteration permit. In the case of 640
Broadway, this “contribution” would initially have amounted to
$440,000.00. (Originally the “conversion contribution” was
$4.50 per square foot, but it was raised to $9.00, the then to
$11.00 per square foot.) Buildings required to pay the
183a
“conversion contribution” were called “applicable buildings.”
In order to be an applicable building, space in the building must
have been used for certain industrial purposes on August 31,
1980, or if vacant on that date, used for industrial purposes
within three (3) years of that date. This included virtually every
old commercial building in downtown Manhattan, including
640 Broadway.
7” 46
68. With the enactment of the Loft Law in 1982, which
mandated involuntary residential conversions, the very real
possibility existed that the owners of loft buildings would have
to pay both the costs of converting the building to a multiple
dwelling, and the “contribution” to the relocation program.3 To
qualify for an exemption, an application had to be filed with the
Board of Standards and Appeals by September 1, 1983, so on
January 4, 1983, the plaintiff filed an application in order to
avoid having to pay this so-called “contribution.” It was not a
change of use or zoning change application, and after the Loft
Law was enacted, the plaintiff never filed any further variance
of use or zoning change applications.
69. Annexed to that alteration application was a
Building Department order which stated that 640 Broadway
was an “applicable building,” and that the plaintiff would have
to make the “conversion contribution.” Thus, the alteration
application was filed by the Owner for the sole purpose of
avoiding the mandatory conversion contribution to the New
York City Business Relocation Assistance Corporation. A copy
of the Building Department order is annexed hereto as Exhibit
7 :
70. Notably, in the prior year, the plaintiff filed a
required “preliminary application” under protest in which the
Owner stated in part:
“With respect to these premises, Sec. 15 of the
Zoning Resolution as it appears to require
‘conversion contributions’ of $9.00 per square foot
3 In order to avoid this double confiscation, the Loft Law was amended in
1987 to provide that buildings subject to the Loft Law would be exempt
from paying any “conversion contributions.” MDL §285(3).
184a
to be paid to the City is illegal and unconstitutional.
By the execution of these documents, the
undersigned in no way waives its rights to protest
or seek judicial relief, or commence or maintain
any other legal proceedings to declare that said
extortionate fee being claimed by the City is illegal
and unconstitutional and owner reserves all rights
with respect thereto.”
71. Thereafter, in August of 1983, the occupants of
640 Broadway filed their “coverage” application with the Loft
Board. Almost five years later, on April 28, 1988, that
application was granted, when twenty (20) units were found to
be “covered” by the Loft Law. Despite of the the fact that the
plaintiff only rented seventeen (17) units, twenty (20) were
found to be covered by the Loft Law. The additional three (3)
units came into existence in violation of the Building Code and
the leases when the tenants “subdivided” units without the
plaintiff’s consent. ose
85. As originally enacted, the Loft Law contained a
mechanism for exemption from coverage for those buildings
for which compliance would cause an “unjustifiable hardship”
(MDL §285(2)). However, the owners of buildings subject to
the law were required to submit hardship applications to the
Loft Board within nine (9) months of the establishment of the
Loft Board. The City-defendants claim that the Loft Board
notified the owners of buildings which “appeared to be subject
to Article 7-C” of the June 30, 1983 deadline for hardship
applications. (City Mem. Law, pp. 31-32).
@e0
tant a
185a
88. Even more ludicrous was the legal requirement that
the owners submit sworn affidavits speculating on the total cost
of the building renovations and the other costs of compliance
(e.g., the cost of obtaining a zoning variance), as well as
projecting the operating income and expenses after the
conversion was complete. Obviously, compliance was
impossible because all of these numbers were unknown. A
copy of these so-called “hardship” regulations is annexed
hereto as Exhibit “I.”
ee
101. Paragraphs 39 and 40 of the leases served a
different purpose. Those paragraphs provided that if a tenant
used a unit for a purpose which violated the law or which
violated his or her lease, the tenant would indemnify plaintiff
and hold it harmless from any claims, penalties, loss, damage
or expense, including attorneys’ fees.
102. In making the leases, the plaintiff never agreed to
accept the tenants as anything other than commercial tenants.
They were never accepted as residential tenants. Plaintiff
prohibited them from being residential tenants. The plaintiff
never agreed to provide the sort of services which would have
to be provided to residential tenants. In determining the rent,
which was freely negotiated, the plaintiff did not factor in the
cost of iding residential services because the leases were
commercial, not residential in nature. Neither did the rents
reflect the enormous costs that would be involved in converting
the building into a legal multiple dwelling, if that was even
legally or structurally possible.
186a
103. The standard leases at 640 Broadway were
commercial in nature and were not residential for the following
reasons:
a. Paragraph 4 required the tenant to make all
non-structural repz‘rs at tenant’ s sole cost and expense.
b. Paragraph 29 required the tenant to pay the
costs of installing a sprinkler system if same became necessary,
and to do everything else to comply with all applicable laws,
building codes and regulations [also { 6].
c. Paragraph 30 required the landlord to provide
heat only on business days from 8:00 a.m. until 6:00 p.m. and
on Saturdays from 8:00 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. The landlord was
not required to furnish heat in the evening, on Saturdays after
1:00 p.m. or on Sundays.
+R
g. Pursuant to Paragraph 41 the tenant was
obligated to “replace all damaged or broken plate glass or other
glass in or about the demised premises.”
h. Pursuant to Paragraph 42 the tenant “at its
sole cost and expense shall be solely responsible for and pay
for all utilities and/or services used and required by tenant,
including electricity and gas and water.”
i. Pursuant to Paragraph 54 the landlord was
entitled to periodic rent increases based upon increases in the
Consumer Price Index.
j. Pursuant to Paragraph 66 the tenant “shall
require all its contractors, plumbers and electricians to supply
to the landlord a certificate of insurance naming the landlord as
an additional insured prior to the commencement of any work
by said contractor, plumber or electrician.”
187a
k. Paragraph 72 provides that the tenant agrees
“to accept the demised premises ‘as is’ in its condition as of the
date” of the lease.
ee)
104. The foregoing are the sorts of provisions found
only in commercial leases. For the defendants to now contend
that the occupants of 640 Broadway possess the lifetime ri ghts
of residential tenants, is to make a mockery of the leases and to
totally destroy the plaintiff's property rights. In effect, they
argue that it does not matter what the leases said. If the tenants
want to violate the leases and numerous civil and Criminal laws
by living in their units, and if the government wants to step in
and give its legal “stamp of approval” to such violations and
grant lifetime estates to a retroactively selected group of
individuals, arbitrarily defined, the landlord is powerless to
object, or so the defendants would have this court believe.
105. An examination of the various court decisions,
briefs and jurisdictionally statement in the Spring Realty case,
shows that these contract provisions were not before the court
in that case and accordingly, there is no reason to prevent this
Court from deciding the very specific contract impairment
claims which the plaintiff raises. Furthermore, no
determination had been made in Spring Realty Co. that the
ouildings were covered by the Loft Law and therefore that case
is irrelevant.
130. In addition, the City-defendants repeatedly state
that the owners of interim multiple dwellings are “merely”
expected to comply with “minimal housing standards.” It
seems naive in the extreme to consider “minimal,” the
mandatory and undisputed investment of Two Million Dollars
which would be necessary to convert this 100-year-old
commercial structure into a multiple dwelling.
eee
ae
188a
these purported violations have since been corrected, the threat
of future enforcement proceedings and harsh penalties is
continuous and very real.
132. Clearly, the economic injury that is central to any
ripeness inquiry is present in this case. The seizure of the
building by the tenants is compounded by their persistent
failure over the last several years to pay any rent or use and
occupancy in reliance upon the Loft Law. At the present time,
the Owner is owed rent, rent increases and use and occupancy
in excess of $600,000.00.
133. There is nothing “abstract” about the uninvited
physical occupation of the plaintiff's property by the present
occupants. There is nothing “hypothetical” about the residential
use of the premises in contravention of the commercial leases,
the building’s certificate of occupancy, the building code and
local zoning laws. There is nothing more “concrete” than the
illegal sublets, assignments and subdivisions that have taken
place in some of the units without the Owner’s consent, or the
non-payment of rent over the past several years.
134. In conclusion, the plaintiff has already suffered
severe economic injury; the threat of even greater future harm is
imminent, the Loft Board’s determination of coverage is final;
the cost of compliance is exhorbitant; and the impossible to
comply with “application” for a “hardship” exemption,
previously illusory if not futile, is absolutely precluded by the
expiration of such exemptions. It is therefore difficult to
imagine a legal controversy which is more “ripe” for immediate
judicial review. Furthermore, this case raises substantial federal
questions which should be decided on the merits.
WHEREFORE, the plaintiff respectfully prays that its
motion for summary judgment be granted, that the defendants’
eee Oe
189A
APPENDIX FF
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF
NEW YORK;APPELLATE DIVISION:
FIRST DEPARTMENT
640 BROADWAY RENAISSANCE CO.
Plaintiff-Appeliant
-against-
JOHN EISNER, et al,
Defendants-Respondents.
AFFIRMATION IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR
REARGUMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY, LEAVE TO APPEAL
TO THE COURT OF APPEALS
BRUCE H. WIENER...
3. Reargument or, altematively, leave to appeal to the
Court of Appeals should be granted for several reasons.
First, the Court inexplicably ignored the issues raised by the
summary judgment motions, and relied solely upon the
Tenants’ attomeys’s unsupported allegation (made in reply)
that Renaissance “deliberately withdrew’ ite special permit
application. Such an allegation, in fact, was not included in
the Tenants’ single affidavit (of the reputed leader of the
Tenant's Association) submitted in support of their own
motions. Thus, based upon the Tenants’ attomey’s
submission, Renaissance was not obligated to come forward
with proof regarding its special permit application, but rather
submitted an affidavit denying all of the Tenants’ baseless
claims. Renaissance vehemently disputed Tenants’
unsubstantiated claims regarding its ‘intent’, thereby at least
creating an issue of fact which warranted the denial of
Summary judgment. in fact, the accompanying affidavit of
Joseph Pell Lombardi, Renaissance’s architect, finally puts
an end to the issue of Renaissance’s withdrawal of the
190a
special permit application and explains that it was done
because of changes in the law. The Court inexplicably
ignored the many issues of fact, and proceeded to determine
the appeal as if this case were not a summary judgment
case
4 The Court, however, failed to acknowledge that
Renaissance registered the Building with the Loft Board in
September, 1991 and renewed its registrations as required.
Renaissance aiso timely filed an alteration appiication with
the Department of Buildings in September, 1992 — prior to
the October, 1992 deadline. Thus, the Court compounded
the erroneous findings of the IAS Court that Renaissance
had done nothing toward legalization, and ail of
Respondents’ claims in that regard were sharply disputed by
Renaissance and raised issues of fact which should not have
been summarily disposed of by this Court.
7... The leases have since expired but they all provided
for the payment of rent on a monthly basis along with a
yearly cost of living adjustment.
8. Most of the Tenants stopped paying rent to
Renaissance in or about September 1988, .. . apparently in
an effort to compel a sale of the Building or to force
Renaissance into bankruptcy .. . As a result of the Tenants’
rent strike, Renaissance was forced to file a petition in
bankruptcy, seeking relief under the applicable provisions of
the bankruptcy laws. . . .
... fn. Contrary to the IAS Court's erroneous finding,
Renaissance registered the Building with the Loft Board in
September, 1991 . . . and renewed its registration in July,
1992 and thereafter, Renaissance aiso filed a timely
alteration application with the Department of Buildings on
September 26, 1992...
19la
17. Renaissance did, in fact, apply to the CPC for a
special permit on June 3, 1983 , but was later compelied
to withdraw the application in October 1985, which had not
been acted upon, because of changes in the law. See,
accompanying affidavit of Joseph Pell Lombardi. which
Clearly puts this fabricated “issue” to rest. Prior to the
was to frustrate the Loft Law, then Renaissance could have
immediately withdrawn its application the same month. upon
the enactment of the Loft Law. The record irrefutably shows
that it did not, and belies Tenants’ purely speculative
allegations.
18. in any event, the 1992 amendments to the Loft
Law, which do not require a special permit, superseded the
1988 Loft Board order, stating that coverage is contingent
upon Renaissance’s obtaining a special permit.
19. In addition, any requirement of a special permit was
evidently eliminated by the 1987 amendments to the Loft
Law, and subsequently confirmed in City of New York v
State of New York, index No. 44141/88, decided October 27.
1989 (Gnaried, J.), affd, 171 A.D.2d 629, 568 N.Y.S.2d 323
(ist Dept. 1997). In that case the City wished, among other
things, to enforce the Zoning Resolution requirement of a
special permit, and claimed, in part, that the 1987 Loft Law
amendments were unconstitutional and void because they
effectively repealed the City Zoning Resolution requiring
This Court affirmed and upheld the 1987 Loft Law that
apparently did away with the need for any special permit.
192a
20. Thus, after the City of New York lawsuit, it became
apparent that, by superseding state statute, the Loft Board
did not have the power even to make coverage contingent
upon Renaissance’s obtaining a special permit, because
such permits were no longer required by law. in addition,
there is likewise no requirement for such special permit in the
1992 amendments to the Loft Law. Thus, because of the
amendments, which clearly override the Loft Board order and
do make clear that no special permit is required,
Renaissance has not, and is not in violation of any law of
Loft Law Order. ..
23. Aithough the Court did not specifically state that the
1992 amendments are not retroactive, the Court did hold that
Renaissance is not entitied to its benefits retroactively
purportedly because Renaissance did not apply for a special
permit. As demonstrated herein, a special permit is not
required, and such requirement was eliminated even before
the Tenants went on their “rent strike.” At present, the only
requirement is for the filing of an alteration application, which
Renaissance filed so as to be fully entitled to the law's
benefits.
28. The Court's Order and interpretation adversely affects
the constitutional rights of landiords and their ability to collect
past due rents, and be able to pay for legalization expenses
and the maintenance of upkeep of their buildings. At the
same time the Court's Order results in an undeserved
windfall to the Tenants.
Dated: New York, New York
March 10, 1995
/s/
BRUCE H. WIENER
193a
APPENDIX GG
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF
NEW YORK; APPELLATE DIVISION;
FIRST DEPARTMENT
x
640 BROADWAY RENAISSANCE CO
Plaintiff-Appeliant, INDEX x23830/82
-against-
JOHN EISNER, ET AL,
Defendants-Respondents.
x
AFFIDAVIT OF JOSEPH PELL LOMBARDI IN SUPPORT OF
MOTION FOR REARGUMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY,
LEAVE TO APPEAL TO... COURT OF APPEALS
STATE OF NEW YORK
COUNTY OF NEW YORK
JOSEPH PELL LOMBARDI, being duly swom, deposes
Says:
2. lam... a registered architect and have performed
architectural work for Renaissance since at least 1979 in
connection with the building located at 640 Broadway, New
York. . . When | first inspected the Building, it was a factory
building which was virtually empty. Renaissance purchased
the Building after a mortgage foreciosure at which time it was
nearly abandoned and in terrible condition. Over the years
since my first visit, the Building has been totally renovated by
Renaissance and rnajor capital improvements have been
made.
3. In or about June, 1982, Renaissance filed a special
permit application with the City Planning Commission (“CPC”)
pursuant to section 74-782 of the Zoning Resolutions
(R.724). Renaissance withdrew that application in October
1985 (R.749).
194a
.. .5. Although Renaissance, through me, withdrew its
special permit application, it did not do so to thwart the
legalization process in any way or for any nefarious purpose.
Rather, Renaissance was compelled to withdraw the
application because of changes in the law. Notably,
Renaissance did not withdraw the application (in 1985)
because of the passage of the Loft Law, as has been alleged
by the Tenants, since the application was received by the
CPC on June 3, 1982, and the Loft Law became effective
only a few weeks later, o7i June 21, 1982.
6. Simply put, the CPC informed Renaissance that it
would no longer continue to process such special permit
applications, as jurisdiction had been transferred to the
Board of Standards and Appeals. in fact, CPC informed
Renaissance, by letter, that if the special permit application
were withdrawn, it would be converted to an occupant-
initiated Residential Loft Occupancy Determination
Application... .
7. Hence, Renaissance was compelled to withdraw its
application, arid did not do so for the purpose of frustrating
the legalization process. The withdrawal of the permit
application was solely the result of changes in the law.
Notably, the application was withdrawn over three (3) years
after its submission, and the failure of the CPC to complete
its processing.
8. In fact, Renaissance, which has long sine filed its
alteration application and obtained a building permit, never
needed to renew its special permit application because such
a requirement was eliminated.
/S/ JOSEPH PELL LOMBARDI
Sworn to before me this
___day of March 1995.
195a
APPENDIX HH
SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
APPELLATE DIVISION:
FIRST DEPARTMENT
640 BROADWAY RENAIISANCE CO..,
Plaintiff-Appeliant,
-against-
JOHN EISNER, et. Al.,
Defendants-Respondent,
-and-
15 Other Cases Consolidated for
Purposes of a Joint Appeal.
REPLY AFFIRMATION IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF
MOTION FOR REARGUMENT OR, ALTERNATIVELY.
LEAVE TO APPEAL TO THE COURT OF APPEALS.
New York County Clerk’s Index No. 23830/92
BRUCE H. WIENER, an attorney duly admitted to practice in
the courts of this State, under penalty or perjury, affirms as
follows:
3. It is apparent that the Court did not consider many of
Renaissance’s arguments raised in its briefs on appeal
inasmuch as the Order appeared to focus solely on the “red
Herring” raised by Respondents’ counsel — that Renaissance
“deliberately withdrew’ its special permit application. This
Court, however, did not address the most important issue of
fact as to the reason behind the withdrawal which, in and of
itself, precludes summary judgment. Renaissance, in fact,
was instructed by the city agency to withdraw its application
and, as set forth herein, at the same time went forward with
its application for a determination of loft occupancy, a
necessary prerequisite to the issuance of any special permit.
ee
$$$
_——$— $$$ <<
LL
196a
4. Contrary to the record, the facts and the applicable law,
the Court summarily affirmed the IAS Cvourt’s erroneous
“finding,” based upon pure speculation of counsel, that
Renaissance is not in compliance with the Loft Law because
it “deliberately withdrew’ its special permit application.
Neither the Court nor the Respondents addressed the fact
that the 1992 amendments to the Loft Law do not require the
filing of a special permit application to be in compliance with
the statute, and that the 1987 Loft Law amendments actually
eliminated any such requirement.
5. Renaissance submits the affidavit of its architect Joseph
P. Lombardi so that the issue of the “withdrawal” of the
special permit can be put into proper perspective and
demonstrated to be the total “red herring” that it is (and that it
Clearly cannot be the basis for summarily dismissing
Renaissance’s substantial rent claims). Mr. Lombardi’s
affidavit is based upon his person knowledge...
8. Respondents disregard the fact that the 1992
amendments to the Loft Law do not require the filing of a
special permit application to be in compliance with the
Statute. Notably, neither the 1988 Loft Board Order which
made coverage under the Loft Law “contingent” upon
Renaissance’s obtaining a special permit, nor the Loft Law
itself, imposed any deadline for filing such application or
obtaining siuch permit. In any event, the enactment of the
1987 and 1992 amendments did away with the requirement
for a special permit such that “reapplication” for a special
permit was rendered unnecessary.
9. Furthermore, the 1987 and 1992 amendments
supercede the 1988 Loft Board Order so heavily relied upon
by the Court. The fact that Renaissance withdrew the
special permit application under instructions from the City
Planning Commission (“CPC”), does not lead to the
“inevitabie conclusion” that Renaissance did not take all
necessary and reasonable steps to iegalize the Building.
The affidavit of Mr. Lombardi is meant to challe
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.