Petition for ReHearing — Southeastern Rubber Recycling v. Alabama Department of Public Health

Supreme Court brief2005

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

OF THE CLERK

IN THE

Supreme Court of the Anited States

Ex PARTE SOUTHEASTERN RUBBER RECYCLING,

a division of Sunrise Garden Mart, Inc.,

Petitioner,

and ;

| STAN SULLIVAN,

(In re: Southeastern Rubber Recycling, et al. v.

State Department of Public Health, et al.)

Respondent.

Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the

Supreme Court of Alabama

PETITION FOR REHEARING

ALVIN T. PRESTWOOD *

TARA S. KNEE

PRESTWOOD & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

350 Adams Avenue (36104)

Post Office Box 1910

Montgomery, AL 36102-1910

(334) 264-6401

* Counsel of Record Counsel for the Petitioners

LEAL ALINE ENTREE A TERRE “ANSARI OG IS MS

WILSON-EPES PRINTING CO., INC. — (202) 789-0096 — WASHINGTON, D.C. 20001

QUESTION PRESENTED

Would it be appropriate for the Court to reconsider its

decision of February 22, 2005 denying the petition for a writ

of certiorari upon this petition for rehearing, upon the

substantial grounds not previously presented, to wit: The

State statutory provisions regulating the disposal of scrap

tires were altered effective on October 1, 2004 significantly

changing the responsibilities of governmental agencies with

the enactment of the Alabama Scrap Tire Environmental

Quality Act, Ala. Code 1975, §22-40A-1 et seq. (App.

2a-24a).

TABLE OF CONTENTS

QUESTION PRESENTED ...............ccccoccccssssscesssoercsseeees

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES ..................scccssscssseseeneeeeees

BPE PR BRIM © cocesccoscecccssccesnsesocontsenesencsscncessenconsonssaeoqoute

SEY saseescccssecccssscncusnsusscnensncnsonssoctuesscanennensensenes

Sad UE A PUPUIY ccnsanccasecescsesesecessosnssccsecsnesocnesnsetionsonnsnense

(ili)

iv

TABLE OF AUTHORITIES

CASES | Page

Monroe v. Valhalla Cemetery Company, Inc.,

749 So. 2d 470, 473-474 (Ala. 1999)... 4

Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation v. R.A.

Gray & Co., 467 U.S. 717, 730 (1984).............. 4

United States v. Sperry Corp., 493 U.S. 52, 64

ESE ssbohiashisciniodnsitiolstiiahdieahatiahcaehanndibaaiabinnnniadaanauinbas 4

Usery v. Turner Elkhorn Mining Co., 428 U.S. 1,

Fe asiccsosteiinenscdedeipsiciniis bacieelearhaeikidamiemuaatith 4

STATUTES AND RULES

Code of Alabama 1975, §22-27-2(6) ............:ccc00 r

Code of Alabama 1975, §22-40-1 et seq. ..............

Code of Alabama 1975, §22-40A-1 et seq............... Ry 3

- Code of Alabama 1975, §22-40-8................c..cceeee

Code of Alabama 1975, §22-40-9..00...........cccceeeees

Code of Alabama 1975, §22-40A-3(4) ..................

Code of Alabama 1975, §22-40-A-11(a)...............

Code of Alabama 1975, §22-40A-22.................00..

Rule 44.2 of the Supreme Court Rules ..................

—= WWWWWWd

IN THE

Supreme Court of the Anited States

No. 04-824

Ex PARTE SOUTHEASTERN RUBBER RECYCLING,

a division of Sunrise Garden Mart, Inc.,

Petitioner,

and-

STAN SULLIVAN,

(In re: Southeastern Rubber Recycling, et al. v.

State Department of Public Health, et al.)

Respondent.

Petition for a Writ of Certiorari to the

Supreme Court of Alabama

: PETITION FOR REHEARING

The petition for a writ of certiorari was denied on February

22, 2005, and this petition for rehearing is respectfully

submitted pursuant to the provisions of Rule 44.2 of the

Supreme Court Rules.

STATEMENT OF THE CASE!

In the Petition for Writ of Certiorari, the basic federal issue

was the appearance of bias on the part of an elected trial

judge. The Petitioners also raised, on pages 10-14 of the

petition, the issue of the arbitrary and unreasonable procedure

' The original statement of the case is presented at pages 2-4 of

the Petitioners’ Petition for Writ of Certiorari, and it will not be re-

peated herein.

2

that the Defendants were enforcing upon the Petitioners at

their used tire collection and disposal facility. The Petitioners

included in the initial Petition references to Ala. Code §22-

40-1 et seq., 1975, which contained provisions that were in

effect at the time of the issuance of the challenged decisions

of the state courts. Subsequent to the issuance of those

decisions, uowever, the provisions of the Alabama Scrap Tire

Environmental Quality Act became effective on October 1,

2004 (§22-40A-1 et seq.) (App. 2a-24a), replacing the former

provisions found in §22-40-1 et seg. (App. Pet. 39a-57a).

DISCUSSION

In the Petitioners’ original submission filed on December

16, 2004, it was contended that the federal due process rights

of the Petitioners had been violated because of the appearance

of bias on the part of the presiding trial judge, coupled with

the alleged arbitrary and capricious nature of the challenged

court decisions. In partial support of this position, the

Petitioners referred, at pages 10-11 of their Petition, to state

legislation designated as the Scrap Tire Disposal Act, Alla.

Code 1975, §22-40-1 et seg., to demonstrate that the state

courts sanctioned regulatory actions of an agency which

lacked the authority to act as it had done. The contention

even then was that the chief responsibility for regulating

scrap disposal was primarily lodged with the Alabama

Department of Environmental Management (“ADEM”), and

not with the Alabama Department of Public Health

(“ADPH”).

While the Scrap Tire Disposal Act, Ala. Code 1975, §22-

40-1 et seg. was in effect and was to be enforced during the

periods complained of in the original Petition, it now appears

that the Petitioners probably should have also advised the

Court upon that original submission of this case that the

statute cited had been repealed effective on October |, 2004,

and replaced by the Alabama Scrap Tire Environmental

3 ~

Quality Act, Ala. Code 1975, §22-40A-1 ef seq. as of that

date. The new enactment may be said to have supported the

previous contentions of the Petitioners regarding the legis-

lative intent to restrict the role of ADPH in cases involving

the disposal of scrap tires and to have clarified the intent that

ADEM would have that responsibility.

Under §22-40-8, law enforcement responsibility over scrap

tires was given to either the ADPH or ADEM, with fines

payable to ADPH.(§22-40-9). With the enactment of the

Alabama Scrap Tire Environmental Quality Act, the “depart-

ment” is defined as “[t]he Alabama Department of Environ-

mental Management (ADEM) or its successor organization or

organizations having similar responsibility.” (§22-40A-3(4))

(App. 3a). In §22-40A-11(a) (App. 13a), one of ADEM’s re-

sponsibilities is stated as follows:

The department is designated by this chapter as the

administrating agency for this chapter including admin-

istering remediation and enforcement programs;

provided, however, the department may enter into

delegation agreements with county commissions for

enforcement of this chapter. The department is hereby

authorized to carry out the purposes of this chapter and

is empowered to administer and enforce this chapter

using the authorities granted to it by the Environmental

Management Act.

The new replacement provisions also provide for funding !o

ADEM for enforcing the Act, pursuant to dunt 40A-22, and

not to ADPH. €App. 23a)

Due to these legislative changes in statutory provisions,

ADPH apparently does not now possess any significant

legislative authority to enforce the new statutory provisions,

although it is vigorously purporting to do so in the present

State court litigation.

The appropriate consideration relevant to the issues now

presented is whether the new Act’s provisions would be

4 _

applied retroactively to the case now pending in the state

courts. There is a wealth of federal and state caselaw on the

issue of the retroactive application of a statute. In United States

v. Sperry Corp., 493 U.S. 52, 64 (1989), this Court said:

“Retroactive legislation does have to meet a burden not

faced by legislation that has only future effects. ‘It does

follow...that what Congress can legislate prospectively it

can legislate retrospectively. The retroactive aspects of

-legislation, as well as the prospective aspects must meet

the test of due process, and the justifications for the

latter may not suffice for the former.’ But that burden is

met simply by showing that the retroactive applications

of the legislation is itself justified by a rational

legislative purpose.” Pension Benefit Guaranty Corpo-

ration v. R.A. Gray & Co., 467 U.S. 717, 730 (1984)

(quoting Usery v. Turner Elkhorn Mining Co., 428 U.S.

1, 16-17 [1976)]).

(citation omitted). This same general concept is adopted by

Alabama in Monroe v. Valhalla Cemetery Company, Inc., 749

So. 2d 470, 473-474 (Ala. 1999).

To further compound the Petitioners’ due process concerns,

the trial judge in his order of January 6, 2003, declared that

the facility of the Petitioners was an “unauthorized tire

dump.” (App. Pet. 8a). Under Ala. Code §22-27-2(6)(1975),

the definition of an unauthorized dump is a type o¢ “solid

waste disposal site.” (App. Pet. 33a). Solid waste disposals

are to be regulated by ADEM, not ADPH, and ADPH only

had the authority to abate the nuisance of mosquitoes. (App.

Pet. 35a-36a). Thus, the trial judge appears to have ignored

even the then-existing controlling statutory provisions.

The Alabama Scrap Tire Environmental Quality Act now

affords the Petitioners certain rights through “an admin-

istrative process” (App. 19a) and exact penalties for non-

compliance are established (App. 19a-20a). If the new

legislation is applied retroactively to the Petitioners’ current

5

state litigation and appellate process, their conduct would

apparently be measured by the new standards.

CONCLUSION

For the foregoing reasons, it is respectfully requested that

this Court grant a rehearing in this cause and issue its Writ of

Certiorari to review the decisions of the lower courts. While

the original Petition correctly laid out the existing law in

effect at the time the challenged state court decisions were

rendered, it is felt that the subsequent replacement of some of

the relevant statutory provisions should be taken into account,

and particularly because the state court proceedings are still

in progress.

Respectfully submitted,

ALVIN T. PRESTWOOD *

TARA S. KNEE

PRESTWOOD & ASSOCIATES, P.C.

350 Adams Avenue (36104)

- Post Office Box 1910

Montgomery, AL 36102-1910

(334) 264-6401

* Counsel of Record Counsel for the Petitioners

\

APPENDIX

POD NT I

la

APPENDIX

Supreme Court of the United States

i Office of the Clerk

Washington, DC 20543-0001

William K. Suter

Clerk of the Court

(202) 479-3011

February 22, 2005

Mr. Alvin T. Prestwood

350 Adams Avenue

Post Office Box 1910

-Montgomery, AL 36102-1910

Re: Southeastern Rubber Recycling, a Division of Sunrise

Garden Mart, Inc., et al.

v. Alabama Department of Public Health, et al.

No. 04-824

Dear Mr. Prestwood:

The Court today entered the following order in the above-

entitled case:

The petition for a writ of certiorari is denied.

Sincerely,

/s/ WILLIAM K. SUTER

William K. Suter, Clerk

2a

Section 22-40-1

Short title.

This chapter shall be known and may he cited as the

Alabama Scrap Tire Environmental Quality Act.

Section 22-40A-2

Legislative findings; purpose.

(a) The Legislature finds as follows:

(1) The Alabama Scrap Tire Study Commission (STSC)

submitted a report as required by Section 22-40-10,

Code of Alabama 1975, and SJR 152, adapted May 11,

2000. The section and the resolution both directed the

STSC to study the present law and recommend revisions

that are needed. The report from the STSC recom-

mended substantial changes to the present law, which

are incorporated into this chapter. The study and report

were necessary to address the estimated 14 to 20 million

tires stockpiled or illegally dumped.

(2) This state generates over five million scrap tires

annually. Of these tires, an estimated two million are

recycled annually and an estimated two million are

disposed of legally in landfills. Many of the remaining

tires are disposed of illegally and therefore may present

a public health and/or environmental threat to the

citizens of Alabama.

(b) This chapter has the following stated purposes, to:

(1) Remediate existing scrap tire stockpiles and pre-

vent the formation of new ones.

(2) Provide a uniform, statewide system of regulation of

scrap tires from the point of generation to the point

of end use or disposal, to include a statewide scrap

tire manifest system, and effective enforcement of scrap

tire laws.

3a

(3) Stimulate end use market development activities.

(4) Provide an adequate funding mechanism to clean up

scrap tire piles, to provide for responsible enforcement

of scrap tire laws, and to assist in promoting end use

markets.

(5) Implement other recommendations contained in the

report of the STSC.

Section 22-40A-3

Definitions.

The following terms shall have the following meanings

unless the context clearly indicates otherwise:

(1) APPROVED. Authorized, certified, permitted by, or

meets standards of a regulatory authority.

(2) CLEANUP. For purposes of this chapter, cleanup

means the cleaning up, remediation, control, or removal

of scrap tires from the environment.

(3) CONSUMER, a. For purposes of this chapter a

consumer is defined as either: = -

1. A retail purchaser.

2. A dealer who buys a tire to be installed on a vehicle

for resale.

b. A wholesale purchaser who buys tires for resale is not con-

sidered a consumer.

—

(4) DEPARTMENT. The Alabama Department of En-

vironmental Management (ADEM) or its successor

organization or organizations having similar responsibility.

(5) DISPOSAL. For purposes of this chapter, “disposal”

shall be the deposit of a tire in a permitted landfill.

(6) ENFORCEMENT OFFICER. An employee of the

department, or the person appointed by the county

4a

commission to enforce this chapter, and any deputy

enforcement officers enforcing this chapter under the

supervision of the enforcement officer, and which

county commission has a delegation agreement with the

department.

(7) FUEL USER. A processor which uses tire derived

fuel as a source of energy and has been permitted by the

department or local air pollution contro] agency for the

use of tire derived fuel. \

(8) INNOCENT LANDOWNER. Any person, company,

corporation, or governmental entity holding an interest

in real property upon which scrap tires are discarded

illegally by another party without specific permission

from the holder of the real property interest, provided the

holder took reasonable steps to prevent foreseeable acts

of illegal disposal.

(9) PERMITTED LANDFILL. Any landfill that is per-

mitted by the department,

(10) PERMITTED PROCESSOR. Any person engaged

in the processing of tires as defined in this section that

has received the proper permit from the department. A

retreader is not considered a processor,

(11) PERMITTED TRANSPORTER. A person who has

received the proper transporter permit from the depart-

ment.

(12) PERSON. Any individual, organization, business,

or entity, whether or not organized for profit.

(13) PROCESSED TIRE MATERIAL. Any material

produced from tires or tire materials through any

chemical, physical, or thermal process, including, but

not limited to, baling.

Sa

(14) PROCESSING. For purposes of tire processing, the

term includes any of the following activities related to

pneumatic tires;

a. Evaluating, transferring. or sorting tires to deter-

mine their suitability for reuse as used tires or for

retreading.

b. The compression and binding of whole tires or

processed tire material, or baling.

c. Shredding, reducing, or altering tires by any phys-

ical, chemical, or thermal process, including, specif-

ically, the burning of tires as a fuel,

d. Incorporating whole scrap tires into any end use

product or structure where the scrap tire is not decon-

structed into its component parts.

e. Punching or stamping products from whole scrap

tires or producing processed tire material, crumb, or

ground rubber product, whether or not that product is

held for sale or used in the facility to produce an end

product.

(15) RECYCLING or REUSE. A use of scrap tire or

processed tire materials other than for land disposal,

including, but not limited to, new products, rubber modi-

fied asphalt, civil engineering applications, or fuel use.

(16) REGISTERED RECEIVER. Either a class one

receiver or class two receiver defined as:

a. Class one receivers are retail tire dealers, retread-

ers, and used tire dealers.

b. Class two receivers include all other receivers of

scrap tires, other than class one receivers, that gen-

erate or accumulate a minimum of 10 scrap tires in a

year, specifically including, among others, any

component of government, vehicle fleet maintenance

6a

or dismantling, rental or sales operations, or any other

activity that generates scrap tires, whether or not

organized for profit.

(17) REMEDEATION. This term is synonymous with

“cleanup.”

(18) REPLACEMENT TIRE. Any pneumatic tire sold to

the consumer regardless of whether or not mounted on a

rim or wheel.

(19) RESPONSIBLE PARTY or PERSON RESPONSI-

BLE. With respect to the remediation of any accum-

ulation of scrap tires on any property, the person who

deposited the tires on the property, if known and if

different than the person who holds title to the property.

(20) RETAIL TIRE DEALER. For purposes of this

chapter, a retail tire dealer shall include any person

selling replacement tires to the consumer, whether or not

mounted on a rim.

(21) RETREADED CASING REPLACEMENT TIRE.

Any retreaded casing sold to the consumer, regardless of

whether or not mounted on a rim or wheel.

(22) RETREADER. Any person engaged in the retread-

ing of used tires.

(23) SCRAP TIRE. Any pneumatic tire no longer suit-

able or useable for its original purpose and, in addition,

includes, but is not limited to, all tires with a manu-

facturing defect, except those that are in the process of

being returned to the manufacturer for a refund.

(24) SCRAP TIRE COMMISSION (STC). The com-

mission established in this chapter.

(25) SCRAP TIRE ENVIRONMENTAL. FEE. The fee

established by this chapter, to be collected on the

purchase of replacement tires.

Ta

(26) SCRAP ‘TIRE FUND (STF). The separate fund

established by this chapter.

(27) SCRAP TIRE STUDY COMMISSION (STSC).

The commission created by Sections 22-40-1 to

22-40-11, inclusive.

(28) SOLID WASTE DISPOSAL ACT. Chapter 27 of

this title.

(29) THREAT. A condition creating a substantial prob-

ability of harm, where the probability and potential

extent of harm makes it reasonably necessary to take

immediate action to prevent, reduce, or mitigate damage

to persons, property, the environment, natural resources,

or the public health and safety.

(30) TIRE DEALER. Any person engaged in the sale of

tires to the consumer, whether or not mounted on a rim

or wheel.

(31) TIRE DERIVED FUEL (TDF). Any tire or proc-

essed tire material intended for use as fuel.

(32) USED REPLACEMENT TIRE. Any pneumatic tire

that is capa>le of reuse as a tire, directly or following

repair, regrooving, or retread, excluding any processed

tire material, end use product or by-product derived from

scrap tires, that meets the following requirements:

a. If a tire is designed for highway use it must still

have more than two thirty-seconds inch of tread.

b. The tire is stored in a rack or a stack, but not in a

pile, in a manner consistent with National Fire Protec-

tion Association guidelines for tire storage, as well as

vector control standards.

c. The tire is stored in a manner to allow inspection of

each individual tire.

8a

Section 22-40A-4

Accumulation and exposure limits.

(a) No person may accumulate more than 100 scrap tires,

except aS a permitted processor; registered receiver, or

permitted landfill.

(b) No person may expose accumulated scrap tires to the

elements for more than 30 days.

(c) A class one receiver as defined in Section 22-40A-3 may

accumulate up to 1,500 scrap tires, or a higher number as set

by regulation of the department for those engaged in used

tire sales.

(d) A class two receiver as defined in Section 22-40A-3 may

accumulate up to 300 tires. Provided, however, that class

two receivers that are tire manufacturers are excluded from

the 300-tire limit, provided the tires are not exposed to the

elements.

Section 22-40A-5

Cleanup; reports; regulations; remediation management.

(a) Accumulations of scrap tires for whatever purpose, not in

accordance with this chapter, shall be removed by the person

responsible for the creation or the maintenance of the

accumulation, or if the person responsible is not determined,

by the landowner if the landowner does not qualify as an

innocent landowner.

(b) All persons with more than 100 scrap tires on their prop-

erty who are not registered receivers of scrap tires or a per-

mitted processor shall report this fact to the department and

provide the number of scrap tires and the location. This re-

port shall be made no later than 12 months after Septem-

ber 1, 2003.

9a

(c) The department shall establish by regulations a ranking

system for remediation, and shall award all contracts for

cleanup in accordance with this ranking system.

(d) The department shall provide regulations for cleanup,

which shall apply to all cleanups.

(e) Department cleanup action shall be carried out in accord-

ance with any applicable state contracting requirements.

(f) The overall management of the remediation of all scrap

tires within the State of Alabama is the responsibility of the

department.

(g) Each cleanup contractor shall satisfy all relevant laws,

regulations, or other legal ordinances during the cleanup.

Section 22-40A-6

Receivers generally.

(a) For purposes of this chapter, there shall be two classes of

receivers, class one receivers and class two receivers as

defined in Section 22-40A-3.

(b) Receivers of both classes are required to use a permitted

transporter to haul tires for disposal, for further end proc-

essing, or for further evaluation by another business, except

as provided in subsection (c).

(c) Class one receivers are not required to use a permitted

transporter for purposes of transporting their tires or their

customers’ tires between their business locations or between a

customer site and the receiver.

(d) Class one receivers are not required io obtain a permit as a

transporter, as otherwise required under Section 22-40A-7,

for transporting scrap tires for disposal or further processing.

(e) All receivers shall register without fee with the depart-

ment and obtain a receiver number and vehicle decals, at no

cost, equal to the number of vehicles in the receiver’s fleet

10a

used to transport scrap tires. Decals shall be carried visibly in

or on the vehicle, in accordance with department regulations.

Section 22-40A-7 — ~

Transportation of scrap tires; permits.

(a) No person, except a properly registered class one receiver,

may engage in the transportation of scrap tires, whether or not

for profit, without holding a valid transporter permit issued by

the department, unless otherwise exempted by this chapter or

unless allowed by department regulation, if he or she trans-

ports more than eight scrap tires at any one time. An

application for a permit shall be made in the form required by

the department and provide such information as the depart-

ment may, by regulation, require.

(b) The department, by regulation, may set higher tire trans-

portation limits than provided in subsection (a) for special

situations, such as an authorized amnesty program.

—

(c) Permitted transporters shall receive decals equal in num-

ber to the number of vehicles in the transporter’s fleet, at no

cost. Decals shall be visibly displayed in or on the vehicle, in

accordance with department regulations.

(d) Persons making applications as transporters shall pay an

application fee as determined by the department. Applicants

shall provide information that the department requires by

regulation.

(e) Transporter permits shall he valid for three years, unless

revoked for violating this chapter or the department’s

regulations.

(f) Transporters shall deliver scrap tires that have been

properly manifested as required by Section 22-40A-9 and

departmental regulations, only to either of the following:

(1) A receiver, processor, or other transporter, permitted

or registered under this chapter.

lla

(2) A permitted landfill.

(g) Transporter decals shall be displayed in conformance with

regulations issued by the department on any vehicle engaged

in the collection and transportation of scrap tires and may be

transferred only to vehicles owned and operated by that

business.

(h) All class one receivers who are transporting used or scrap

tires for their own purposes shall maintain inside the vehicle

during transport appropriate documentation that each such

transport is for his or her own use and for the indicated

purpose.

(i) Both intrastate and interstate transport of used and scrap

tires are subject to regulation by the department.

Section 22-40A-8

Processing of scrap tires; permits.

(a) No person may engage in the processing of scrap tires, as

defined herein, whether or not organized for profit, unless the

person holds a valid processor permit issued by the depart-

ment.

(b) The department, by regulation, shall set operational re-

quirements for processors, including limitations on the maxi-

mum number of tires that may be on site, whether processed

or unprocessed. The department shall also establish by regu-

- lation requirements for mobile processors.

(c) Each applicant for a processor’s permit shall pay an ap-

plication fee as determined by the department by regulation,

and shall provide information that the department requires by

regulation. Application shall be made in the form required by

the department.

(d) Permits issued by the department to scrap tire processors

shall be valid for a five-year period, unless revoked for cause.

12a

(e) Class one receivers are not required to hold processor

permits in order to engage in the evaluation of tires collected

during the course of their business as suitable for reuse as

tires or as casings for retreading.

(f) A fuel user may operate without obtaining a processor

permit and must register as a fuel user with the department on

forms prepared by the department The fuel user must store

tires or TDF in compliance with storage regulations estab-

lished by the department.

(g) Any facility that produces an end use material or product

from ground or crumb rubber derived from scrap tires that has

been purchased from another facility, or any facility using the

component parts of scrap tires or processed tire material as a

substitute raw material, is exempt from the requirement of

being permitted as a processor pursuant to this section. Any

facility seeking an exemption must register with the depart-

ment on forms prepared by the department.

Section 22-40A-9

Manifests; out-of-state tires transported into Alabama.

(a) The department shall develop and promulgate a manifest

through rulemaking.

(b) All scrap tire receivers, transporters, processors, and land-

fills are required to use a written manifest as prescribed in

this section and as provided by regulations of the department.

The manifest shall be originated by the receiver and shall

identify the quantity of tires transported, stored, or processed,

and other information as the department may require. The

manifest shall be distributed by the department and be re-

quired to accompany the transportation, storage, and process-

ing of scrap tires until the tires are processed or disposed.

(c) A copy of each complete manifest shall be forwarded

monthly to the receiver by the processor(s) or landfill(s) to

which scrap tires are delivered. Records shall be retained by

13a

the receiver for a minimum of three years, or as otherwise

required by the department.

(d) The department may establish regulations for transport of

out-of-state tires into Alabama.

Section 22-40A-10

Financial assurance.

(a) The department shall, by regulation, establish the finan-

cial assurance levels and methods that are to be set to provide

funds to abate any problems created as a result of a failure by

the transporter or processor to properly manage scrap tires.

(b) Receivers of either class are not required to post financial

assurance.

(c) Permitted transporters and processors shall post financial

assurance. A fuel user that registers with the department shall

post financial assurance if the user stores whole tires or shred-

ded tires in excess of amounts the department establishes by

regulation.

Section 22-40A-11

Administration and enforcement.

(a) The department is designated by this chapter as the ad-

ministrating agency for this chapter including administering

remediation and enforcement programs; provided, however,

the department may enter into delegation agreements with

county commissions for enforcement of this chapter. The de-

partment is hereby authorized to carry out the purposes of this

chapter and is empowered to administer and enforce this

chapter using the authorities granted to it by the Environ-

mental Management Act.

(b) The department shall develop and manage a remediation

contract program for cleanup, management, or disposal of

scrap tires.

14a

(c) The department may by regulation exempt certain tires

under this chapter.

(d) The department shall administer the program in a way to

ensure enforcement of the chapter in all counties.

(e) Department funds and resources as provided by the Scrap

Tire Fund (STF) may be used for support of on-going training

for delegated county programs.

(f) The department, after holding a hearing in accordance

with the procedures set forth by regulation, may revoke,

suspend, or deny a receiver registration or deny a processor or

transporter a permit based on the requirements or this chapter.

(g) Those funds collected by the department for violations

pursuant to this chapter shall he directed to the Scrap Tire

Fund, except for a portion of those funds directed to the de-

partment to cover expenses to obtain .a penalty.

(h) The department, by regulation, may develop other incen-

tive programs to reduce illegal scrap tire disposal.

Section 22-40A-12

Delegation agreements; county responsibilities.

County commissions may request primacy on enforcement

and establish delegation agreements with the department for

enforcement of this chapter. The department shall establish

by regulation the procedures for delegation. Counties that

wish to voluntarily establish such delegation agreements with

the department for local enforcement shall have the fallowing

responsibilities:

(1) Provide quarterly reports to the department on all

scrap tire activities within that quarter on a form pre-

pared and provided by the department.

(2) Provide written investigation reports to the depart-

ment within 10 days of the initial investigation.

15a

(3) Investigate all reports and complaints regarding scrap

tires within the respective county.

(4) Investigate illegal dumping of scrap tires.

(5) Review manifests of scrap tires at businesses.

Section 22-40A-13 |

End use market development grants program.

The Alabama Department of Economic and Community

Affairs (ADECA) is designated as the department of state

government responsible for development and management

of an end use market development grants program. The cost

of administration of these. grants shall not exceed five percent

of the funds allocated for the ADECA grant program.

ADECA may choose to negotiate agreements with any person

to participate in the end use marketing development grants

program.

Section 22-40A-14

Scrap tire environmental fee. THIS SECTION WAS

ASSIGNED BY THE CODE COMMISSIONER. THIS

SECTION HAS NOT BEEN CODIFIED BY THE

LEGISLATURE.

(a) A scrap tire environmental fee shall be collected at the

point of sale from the consumer on replacement tires, whether

or not the tires are mounted on a rim or wheel, in the amount

of one dollar ($1) per tire, and shall be remitted to the Depart-

ment of Revenue on a monthly basis. Out-of-state tires, such

as fleet tires, not purchased in the State of Alabama must be

returned to the point of origin for disposal or the scrap tire

environmental fee shall be imposed for each tire brought into

the state and must be remitted to the Department of Revenue.

In addition, the scrap tire environmental fee shall be collected

on a retreaded casing replacement tire when sold to a

consumer.

l6a

(b) The fees imposed by subsection (a) shall be paid monthly

to the Department of Revenue by the 20th day of the

following month, accompanied by forms as prescribed by the

Department of Revenue. The forms shall contain a printed

declaration that the information is being reported under

penalty of perjury and shall be subscribed by the person who

completes the forms, showing the number of tires subject to

the environmental fee and such other information as the

Department of Revenue may require.

(c) The tire dealer may retain five percent of the fees col-

lected per each report timely filed, to cover costs associated

with the collection and payment of the fee to the Department

of Revenue. No recovery of administrative costs shall be

allowed, nor any monies retained by a tire dealer, from any

scrap tire environmental fees that are not paid before becom-

ing delinquent.

(d) The fee imposed in subsection (a) shall be collected and

administered by the Department of Revenue in accordance

with Chapter 2A of Title 40. The Department of Revenue

shall also impose interest on any scrap tire environmental fee

paid after the due date in accordance with Section 40-1-44.

(e) The Department of Revenue may promulgate and enforce

rules and regulations to effectuate the scrap tire environ-

mental fee provisions of this chapter. All rules and regula-

tions promulgated shall have the same force and effect of law.

(f) In addition to any and all other funds heretofore or here-

after appropriated, there is hereby appropriated from the State

General Fund to the Department of Revenue, to offset its

costs to implement and administer this chapter, as a first

charge against the fees collected pursuant to this chapter, for

the fiscal year ending September 30, 2003, the sum of sixty

thousand dollars ($60,000). Every year thereafter as a first

17a

charge against the revenues collected, an amount of revenue

shall be appropriated to the Department of Revenue to offset

its costs of collection.

Section 22-40A-15

Distribution of fee proceeds.

The net proceeds of the scrap tire environmental fee levied by

Section 22-40A-14 shall be distributed as follows:

(1) To pay the costs of remediation, abatement, removal, or

other remedial action within the Tange of 45 percent to 75

percent of monies deposited to the Scrap Tire Fund during the

previous budget year, including equipment, labor, supplies,

and materials related to tire stockpiles throughout the state,

including all approved costs incurred by other public agencies

involved in these activities by contract with the department.

(2) To pay the costs of the department associated with the

development and enforcement of regulations, not to exceed

20 percent of monies deposited to the Scrap Tire Fund during

the previous budget year, including personnel, training,

materials, and equipment relating to administration of this

chapter and for the training of enforcement personnel within

the department, county, and other governmental organiza-

tions. Funds not expended by the department during a budget

year shall be returned to the Scrap Tire Fund not later than

January 1 following the end of the budget year.

(3) To administer a program, within the range of zero percent

to 20 percent of monies deposited to the Scrap Tire Fund

during the previous budget year, managed by ADECA, di-

rected at promoting and developing markets as an alternative

to the landfill disposal of scrap tires or processed tire material

as an end use. ADECA or its successor organization shall be

so authorized by this chapter for these purposes.

(4) To fund the programs delegated by the department to

counties for enforcement of regulations, not to exceed 10

18a

percent of monies deposited to the Scrap Tire Fund during the

previous budget year, including personnel, training, materials,

and equipment relating to administration of this chapter.

(5) To pay the tire retailer, not to exceed five percent of fees

collected, for collection and accounting costs associated with

collection of the fee and the monthly distribution to the De-

partment of Revenue, as specified in subsection (c) of Section

22-40A-14.

(6) To pay the costs of administration of the Department of

Revenue, not to exceed two percent of monies, to include the

first charge against revenues pursuant to subsection (f) of

Section 22-40A-14, deposited to the Scrap Tire Fund during

the previous budget year, associated with establishment of the

Scrap Tire Fund and for the receipt of funds from all income

sources pursuant to this chapter, disbursements, and auditing

revenues in the Scrap Tire Fund.

Section 22-40A-16

Disposition of funds.

(a) All fees, interest, or other income distributed to the Scrap

Tire Fund shall be used only for the purposes specified in this

chapter.

(b) All monies derived from fines and violations of this chap-

ter that are collected by county enforcement programs pursu-

ant to this chapter shall be distributed to the county for use

only in the enforcement program. 7

Section 22-40A-17

Evaluation of suspected property; notice; costs.

(a) The department or its designated representatives may ac-

cess property suspected of containing scrap tires for the

purpose of evaluation of the threat to public health, the envi-

ronment, and safety.

19a

(b) The department, by regulation, shall establish an admin-

istrative process to provide the responsible party, other than

the innocent landowner, notice of obligation to remediate

scrap tires found that are in violation of this chapter. If the

responsible party fails or refuses to remediate the scrap tires,

the department or its contractor or subcontractors shall be

granted access to the property for the sole purpose of reme-

diation of the scrap tires.

(c) The department may recover the full cost associated with

the remediation, including legal expenses, from the responsi-

ble party, other than an innocent landowner.

(d) As long as an innocent landowner is working coopera-

tively with the department or its representative to clean up the

site, the innocent landowner shall not be liable for costs of

cleanup. Subsequent to cleanup, the innocent landowners

shall cooperate with the department to prevent further tire

-dumping on the relevant site.

Section 22-40A-18

Violations.

Any of the following actions shall constitute a violation:

(1) Transporting scrap tires in violation of this chapter.

(2) Delivering scrap tires to a facility not approved to

accept tires pursuant to this chapter.

(3) Illegal storage or disposal of processed tire material.

Section 22-40A-19

Penalties.

(a) Disposing of scrap tires in violation of this chapter shall

constitute a Class C felony.

(b) Any person convicted of disposing or processing of scrap

tires in violation or this chapter shall also be personally and

20a

financially responsible for the proper removal of the scrap

tires according to this chapter and any rules or regulations

promulgated by the department.

(c) Any person who knowingly or recklessly makes any false

statement or representation in any document used to comply

with this chapter is liable for a civil penalty for each violation

or, for continuing violations, for each day that the violation

continues, in accordance with subdivisions (17) to (20), inclu-

sive, of Section 22-22A-5.

(d) The enforcement officers may issue citations for any

violation of this chapter, and upon conviction, the violator or

violators shall be fined a minimum of three hundred dollars

($300) for each separate violation.

(e) In addition to the financial responsibility required by

subsection (b), a fine of five dollars ($5) per tire shall be

assessed against any party who transfers, transports, or stores

scrap tires in violation of this chapter, which fee shall be in

addition to all other fines or penalties assessed under this

chapter.

(f) In the enforcement of this chapter, department employees

and county enforcement officers shall have all authority

granted to the license inspector pursuant to Section 40-12-10,

and in addition, may investigate any and all reported viola-

tions of this chapter within the county, and may independ-

ently monitor all scrap tire receivers, transporters, and proces-

sors within the county for compliance with this chapter. The

enforcement officer may issue citations using the Uniform

Non-Traffic Citation and Complaint as provided under Rule

20 of the Alabama Rules of Judicial Administration. The

enforcement officer in each county shall share information

regarding possible violations in another county with the

enforcement officer for that county.

2la

Section 22-40A-20

Applicability to government organizations.

All governmental organizations, whether federal, state, or

other local governing bodies, shall be exempt from the

payment of fees associated with all provisions of this chapter.

These organizations shall comply with all statutory and regu-

latory provisions of this chapter regarding the storage, trans-

port, processing, cleanup, and disposal of scrap tires.

Section 22-40A-21

Scrap Tire Commission.

(a) There is created the Scrap Tire Commission (STC) to

review the implementation of this chapter, including the scrap

tire program, and recommend changes to this chapter to the

Legislature, as needed. The STC shall establish procedures

for its operations. On September 1, 2003, the present monies

received under the existing Alabama Scrap Tire Study

Commission (STSC) are transferred to the Scrap Tire Fund

created herein.

(b) The Scrap Tire Commission shall be comprised of the

following individuals or their designees or a representative of

each of the authorities listed below:

(1) The State Health Officer.

(2) The Director of the Alabama Department of Envi-

ronmental Management.

(3) The Director of the Alabama Department of Eco-

nomic and Community Affairs (ADECA).

(4) The Association of County Commissions of Ala-

bama.

(5) The Alabama Tire Dealers Association shall be rep-

resented by two members, one of which shall be the

president of the association.

22a

(6) The Rubber Manufacturers Association.

(7) A representative of the scrap tire industry, appointed

by the Governor.

(8) A representative of the scrap tire processing indus-

try, appointed by the Lieutenant Governor.

(9) A representative of the environmental community,

appointed by the Speaker of the House of Representa-

tives.

(10) A representative of the scrap tire class two receiv-

ers, appointed by-the Business Council of Alabama.

(c) The STC shall review the implementation of the law and

effectiveness of the revenue derived from the law to accom-

plish the intended purposes and advise the Legislature and the

department as appropriate.

(d) The STC shall meet quarterly for the first two years at a

minimum, and thereafter as determined by the STC, but no

less than annually. The department and ADECA shall report

scrap tire program status to the STC at each regularly called

meeting of the STC. Expenses of the STC shall be paid from

the Scrap Tire Fund.

(e) Members of the STC shall be reimbursed for expenses

when attending meetings representing the STC from the

Scrap Tire Fund. Reimbursement shall be approved and certi-

fied by the director upon receipt of appropriate documenta-

tion in accordance with Sections 36-7-1 through 36-7-42.

(f) After seven years or upon the recommendation of the

STC and the department, the Legislature shall consider reduc-

ing that portion of the scrap tire environmental fee directed

towards cleanup. Provided, that any reduction in the scrap tire

environmental fee shall become effective October | following

the year in which the STC and the department concur that a

reduction is in order. However, the fee shall not be reduced

below fifty cents ($.50) in order to assure adequate enforce-

23a

ment of the law by the department and cooperating counties

and to fund unanticipated cleanups, as needed.

(g) The STC shall establish the percentages for distribution

of funds that accumulate in the Scrap Tire Fund, except as

otherwise specified by this chapter.

(h) Prior to the promulgation of any proposed regulation

dealing with this chapter, the department shall receive the

approval of the STC. The STC shall provide the department a

response to its request for approval within 60 days of receipt

of such request unless such other time is mutually agreed

upon by the department and the STC.

(i) STSC members representing those entities specified in

subsection (b) shall continue as members of the new STC un-

less or until replacements are appointed.

(j) After September 1, 2003, existing members of the STSC,

or their replacements who become members of the STC, must

meet within 90 days. The department shall notify the STC of

the time and place of the initial meeting.

(k) The department and ADECA, through the STC, shall re-

port biennially to the Legislature on the activities of the scrap

tire programs authorized by this chapter, including recom-

mendations. Such reports shall be submitted by the STC.

Section 22-40A-22

Scrap Tire Fund.

(a) A Scrap Tire Fund (STF), separate from the State General

Fund, is created for carrying out this chapter.

(b) All monies within the STF shall be continuously appro-

priated. All monies remaining in the Department of Public

Health, designated for the present STSC, after payment of all

outstanding expenses, shall be transferred to the department

for program implementation by September 1, 2003, and

all monies collected by the Alabama Department of Public

24a

Health pursuant to the previous scrap tire program, including,

but not limited to, license fees, which accrue after September

2003, shall be transferred to the department on October 1,

2004.

(c) The STF is authorized to receive funds from other sources

outside the scrap tire environmental fee, including interest

generated from the STF, grants, allotments, and contributions,

whether public or private.

Section 22-49A-23

Implementation of chapter.

The department shall implement this chapter to the extent

funds are provided by the STF.

Section 22-40A-24

Chapter ineffective upon abolition of scrap tire environ-

mental fee.

ion In the event the scrap tire environmental fee on replacement

tires imposed by Section 22-40A-14 is abolished, as deter-

mined by the Department of Revenue, this chapter shall be

null and void and of no other force or effect of law.

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.