Appendix — Kinney v. Hamilton Partners

Supreme Court brief2005

Ask Donna

What actually matters in this document.

Text

S

OY- [3S 7

No. 05-

In The

Supreme Court of the United States

DARRYL KINNEY

Petitioner

V.

HAMILTON PARTNERS

Respondent

On Petition For Writ Of Certiorari

To The Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals

PETITION FOR WRIT OF CERTIORARI

**APPENDIX”

DARRYL KINNEY

PETITIONER PRO SE

1910 Buckeridge Ct.

- Gurnee, Ill. 60031

847-338-0234

concn ae

mee Sanew AMANO A A NENA A HOE PR EPEAT + » oe

6) BORE EEET

APPENDIX A

UNITED STATES COURT of APPEALS

FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT

SUBMITTED SEPTEMBER 23, 2004

DECIDED SEPTEMBER 23, 2004

Before

Hon. FRANK H. EASTERBROOK, Circuit Judge

Hon. DIANE P. WOOD, Circuit Judge

Hon. TERRANCE T. EVANS, Circuit Judge

No. 04-2122

DARRYL KINNEY v. HAMILTON PARTNERS

ORDER

“Darryl Kinney sued his former employer, Hamilton

Partners, for race discrimination and retaliation under

Title VII, despite having entered( with the assistance

of counsel) into a severance agreement in which he

waived his right to sue. In exchange , he received

three months’ salary and Hamilton’s promise not to

contest his claim to unemployment benefits.

(1)

district court found that Kinney’s waiver was

knowing and voluntary, see Pierce v. Atchinson,

Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co.,65 F.3d562, 571(7" Cir.

1995)(identifying eight factors to consider in

determining whether a waiver of federal civil rights

was knowing and voluntary),

*After an examination of the briefs and the record,

we have concluded that oral argument is unnecesssry.

Thus, the appeal is submitted on the briefs and the

record. See Fed. R. App. P. 34(a)(2).

and so granted motion for summary judgment. A

separate state breach-of-contract claim was dismissed

without ecfeilltee:

On appeal, Kinney argues that he signed the severance

agreement under duress-namely the fear of losing his

promise not to challenge those benefits was simply part of

the bargain, and that by itself does not amount to duress.

See Pierce,65 F.3d at 569(duress is not caused merely by a

difficult bargaining position or the pressure of financial

(2)

circumstances). Kinney also claims that he was on

medication when he signed the agreement, which he says

clouded his thoughts. But as the district court noted, he

has provided no admissible evidence in support of this

claim, and his bare assertion that the medication interfered

with his will is not enough to create a ecaieas issue of

fact. Cf.id at 572(bald assertion of misrepresentation is

legally insufficient to show that a waiver was knowing

and voluntary).

AFFIRMED.

(3)

Ee en

UNITED STATES COURT of APPEALS

FOR THE SEVENTH CIRCUIT

NOVEMBER 3, 2004

Before

Hon. FRANK H. EASTERBROOK, Circuit Judge

Hon. DIANE P. WOOD, Circuit Judge

Hon. TERRANCE T. EVANS, Circuit Judge

No. 04-2122

DARRYL KINNEY v. HAMILTON PARTNERS

ORDER

Plaintiff-appellant filed a petition for a rehearing on

October 6 2004. All of the judges on the panel have

voted to deny rehearing. The petition for rehearing is

therefore DENIED.

(4)

APPENDIX B

United States District Court for the

Northern District of Illinois

Darryl W Kinney

1910 Buckeridge Court Gurnee, Illinois 60031

Case Number 1:03-cv-03905

Title: Kinney v. Hamilton Partners

Assigned Judge; Honorable George W. Lindberg

MINUTE ORDER of 4/6/04 by Hon. George W.

Lindberg:

Defendant’s motion for summary judgment is granted

(38-1). Plaintiff's State Law breach of severance

agreement claim is dismissed without prejudice.

Entered Memorandum and Order. Terminating case

Mailed notice.

This docket entry was made by the Clerk on April 7,

2004

(5)

United States District Court for the

Northern District of Illinois

Darryl W Kinney

1910 Buckeridge Court Gurnee, Illinois 60031

Case Number 1:03-cv-03905

Title: Kinney v. Hamilton Prt

George W. Lindberg: Senior United States District

Judge

MEMORANDUM AND ORDER

On June 9,2003, Plaintiff Darryl Kinn<y filed his

complaint of Employment Discriminati_ 1 against

Defendant Hamilton Partners. Plaintiff's complaint

states three claims1-{1) race discrimination in

violation of Title VII,(2) retaliation in violation of

Title VII, and (3) breach of Plaintiffs severance

agreement in violation of state law- and

asks the Court, inter alia, to grant Plaintiff

appropriate injunctive relief, lost wages,

liquidated/double damages, (front pay, compensatory

damages, punitive damages,(6)

prejudgment interest, post-judgment interest, and

costs. On February 13, 2004, Defendant filed its

motion for summary judgment. Defendants motion is

hereby granted. Legal Standard- Summary Judgment

Summary judgment will be granted only”when the

‘pleadings,depositions,answers to interrogatories, and

admissions on file, together with the affidavits, if

any,show that there is no genuine issue as to any

material fact and that the moving party is entitled to a

judgment as a matter of law.” Cerutti v. BASF Corp.,

349.F. 3d 1055,1060(7" Cir.2003)(quoting Fed.R.Civ.

P.56)

(1) See Kinney v. Hamilton Partners,No 03-

3905(N.D. II] Aug.6,2003) (order denying Defendants

motion to dismiss).

(7)

In making this determination the Court

must”’constru(e) all facts... and draw() all reasonable

inferences from those facts...in favor of the. ..non-

moving part(y)...”Id.(citation omitted). Because

Plaintiff is proceeding pro se in this civil action, he

“benefit(s) from various procedural

protections not otherwise afforded to the attorney-

litigant represented

...”2 Downs v. Westphal,78 F.3d

1252,1257(7" Cir.1996) (citation and internal

quotation marks omitted).

However, Plaintiff must still adhere to the Federal

Rules of Civil Procedure and this districts local

rules.3 Members v. Paige,140 F.3d 699,702(7"

Cir.1998)(“rules apply to uncounseled litigants and

must be enforced”). This includes compliance with

rules governing summary judgment motions.4 Little

v. Coxs Supermkts., 71 F.3d 637,641(7" Cir.1995)

(district court may strictly enforce Northern

(8)

‘

ee a ee -

District of Illinois Local Rule 56.1): Waldridge v.

Am.Hoechst Corp., 24 F.3D 918,923-24(7™

Cir.1994)(same).

Statement of facts

On February 5, 2004, the Court ordered Plaintiff to

file his response to Defendants

(2) See also Greer v Bd.of Educ. Of the City of Chicago, III.

,267 F.3d 723,727(7™ Cir.2001)(“The essence of liberal

construction is to give a pro se plaintiff a break when,

although he stumbles on a technicality, his pleading

is otherwise understandable.”) (citation omitted);

Tressel v. Comined Ins. Co. of Am., No.01-6231,

2003 WL 1626528,at *4(N.D.I11.2002) (“the Court

reads a pro se plaintiffs pleadings liberal! y”) (citation

omitted).

(3) See also Downs,78 F.3d at 1257(“pro se litigants

are not entitled to a general dispensation from the

rules of procedure or court-imposed deadlines”)

(citation and internal quotation marks omitted).

(4) See also Johnson v. Cambridge Indus., Inc, 325

(9) _

F.3d 892,898 (7" Cir. 2003) (district courts...are not

required to scour every inch of the record for

evidence that is potentially relevant to the summary

judgment motion before them”) (citations omitted);

Tressel, No. 01- 6231,2003 WL 1626528, at *4( “

the pro se litigant is still required to follow the rules

of procedure and LR 56.1’) (citation omitted).

(10)

——

summary judgment motion on or before February

27,2004. See Kinney v. Hamilton Partners,

No 03-3905(N.D..III.Feb.5,2004)(order establishing

briefing schedule for Defendants summary judgment

motion). This included Plaintiffs response to

Defendants Local Rule 56.1(a)(3) Statement of

Material Facts to Which There is No Genuine Issue.5

See N.D. Ill. L.R. 56.1(b).Nevertheless, Plaintiff

failed to file his response to Defendants statement of

material facts until March 8,2004,

ten days after the date set by ra Court. To place

Plaintiffs tardiness in perspective, Defendant timely

filed its reply brief five days before Plaintiff filed his

response to Defendants statement of material facts.6

While Plaintiff may be entitled to leniency and

greater procedural protections than Defendant( an

attorney-represented litigant), he is not “entitled to a

general dispensation from the rules of procedure or

court imposed deadlines.” Downs,78 F.3d at

(11)

1257 (citation and internal quotation omitted); see

also Members, 140 F.3d at 702(same).Additionally,

Plaintiff must comply with this Courts local rules

concerning summary judgment motions,

including Northern District of Illinois Local Rule

56.1. See Little, 71 F.3d at 641; Waldridge, 24 F .3d

at 923-24; Tressel v, Combined Ins. Co. of Am., No.

01-6231, 2003 WL 1626528, at *4 (N.D. Ill. Mar. 27,

2003). Because Plaintiff's response to Defendant’s

Statement of material Facts was not filed in a timely-

(5) Plaintiff was well aware of his obligations under

Northern District of Illinois Local Rule 56.1. See,

e.g., Kinney v. Hamilton Partners, No. 03-3905 (N.D.

Ill. Jan. 16, 2004) (order striking Plaintiff's summary

hadi motions and advising Plaintiff of

requirements of N.D. II] L.R. 56.1); (Def.’s Notice to

Pro Se Litigant Opposing Mot.For Summ. J.)

(6) Plaintiff has never offered any excuse or

justification for his failure to comply with the

Court’s February 5 Order.

(12)

Fashion, the Court will disregard the statements

Included therein.7 Even if the Court were to consider

Plaintiff's untimely response to Defendant's

statement of material facts, it would not serve to

create a genuine issue as to any

material facts. As an initial matter, the statements

included in paragraphs 1-7, 9-14, 16-20, 23-30, 32,

34 , 37-46, and 49 were not accompanied by a

citation to the record or any

other supporting material. Therefore, these statements

may be disregarded when deciding Defendant's

motion. See Smith v. Lamz, 321 F. 3d 680, 683 (7th

Cir. 2003) ("a mere Disagreement with the movant's

asserted facts is inadequate If made without reference

to specific supporting material")

(citation omitted); Little,71 F.3d at 641 ("Local Rule

56.1 makes explicit the responsibility. ..to highlight

which factual averments are in conflict as well as

what record evidence there is to confirm the

(13)

dispute.) (citation omitted); Little, 71 F.3d at 641

("Local Rule 56.1 makes explicit the responding

party's burden of controverting the

movant's position with adequate citations to

record....General principles of advocacy

suggest...that a party contesting summary judgment

has a responsibility. ..

to ‘highlight which factual averments are in conflicts

as well as what record evidence there is to confirm

the dispute.) (citation omitted); Martz v. Union

Labor Life Ins. Co. , 757 F .2d 135,138(7th Circ.

1985) ("It bears Repeating that the purpose of

summary judgment is to Determine whether there is

any genuine issue of material Fact in dispute and, if

not, to render judgment in accordance with the law as

applied to the established facts. The facts must be

established through one of the vehicles designed to

ensure reliability and veracity- depositions, answer to

interrogatories, admissions and affidavits.); N.D. Ill.

L.R. 56.1 (b) 8. (14)

(7) On March 17, 2004 Plaintiff filed "Plaintiffs

Reply toDefendants Reply to Plaintiffs Response to

Defendants Local Rule 56.1 (a) (3) Statement of

Facts to Which There Is No Genuine Issue." Plaintiff

is not authorized under Northern District Of Illinois

Local Rule 56.1 to file such a Reply, and at no time

did he obtain leave from the Court to

Do so. Because Plaintiff's March 17 filing is

inappropriate And plagued by the same procedural

defects as his Untimely March 8 response to

Defendant's statement of Material facts, it will be

disregarded. (8) Northern District of Illinois Local

Rule 56.1(b) provides, in part:

(15)

Furthermore, the exhibits and documents cited to

Support the statements included in paragraphs 8,15,

21-22, 31, 33, 35-36, and 47-47 were not properly (1)

incorporated by plaintiff's response 9 or (2)

authenticated, certified, or otherwise made admissible

or usable at trial. Cf. Lamz, 321 F. 3d at 682-83 (finding

that party "failed in In his obligation to support

controverted or additional Facts with citations to

admissible evidence" even through He "sought to support

his factual disagreements by affixing

To his brief assorted material... {without} ensur{ing}

That He attached only admissible evidence"). "To be

admissible,

Documents must be authenticated by and attached to

an Affidavit that meets the requirements of Rule

56(e) and the Affiant must be a person through whom

the exhibits could Be admitted into evidence."Scott v.

Edinburg, 346 F.3d 752, 759-60 n. 7 (7th Cir.2003)

(citation omitted).

(16)

Accordingly, the Court will not consider Exhibits

A,B,C,E, F, G, H, I, or N or the statements

purportedly derived From those exhibits. See Woods

v. City of Chicago, 234

Each party opposing a motion filed pursuant to Fed. R.

Civ. P.56 shall serve and file... a concise response to the

Movant's statement that shall contain: (A) a response

to Each numbered paragraph in the moving party's

statement, Including, in the case of any disagreement,

specific References to the affidavits, parts of the

record, and other Supporting material relied upon. All

material facts set forth In the statement required of

the moving party's statement, Including, in the case

of any disagreement, specific References to the

affidavits, parts of the record, and other

Supporting material relied upon, and (B) a statement,

Consisting of short numbered paragraphs, of any

Additional facts that require the denial of summary

Judgment, including references to the affidavits, parts

Of The record other supporting material relied upon.

(17)

All Material facts set forth in the statement required

of the Moving party will be deemed to be admitted

unlessControverted by the statement of the opposing

party. N.D.1I1. L. R. 56.1 (b) (emphasis added).

(9) Plaintiff's Exhibits A, B, C, E, F, G, H, and I were

submitted with Plaintiff's summary judgment motion.

While many of those exhibits were cited in Plaintiff's

Response to Defendant's statement of material facts,

They Were not submitted with the same.

Nevertheless, this fact is

Of little consequence in light of the other procedural

Defects that plague Plaintiff's filings.

(18)

F.3d 979, 988 (7th Cir. 2000) ("Sworn testimony is

not the The only basis on which summary judgment

may be Granted; rather, ‘the court may consider any

material that Would be admissible or usable at trial,'

_.. including Properly authenticated and admissible

documents or Exhibits.") (citations and internal

quotation marks omitted); Smith v. City of Chicago,

242 F.d 737, 741 (7th Cir. 2001) (same); Martz, 757

F.2d at 138. Indeed, it is well-established that " {s}

upporting materials designed to

to established issues of fact in a summary judgment

proceeding 'must be established through one of the

vehicles designed to ensure reliability and veracity-

depositions, answers to interrogatories, admissions

and affidavits. When a party seeks to offer evidence

through other exhibits, they must be identified by

affidavit or otherwise made admissible in evidence. "

Friedel v. City of Madison,

832 F.2D 965, 970 (7TH Cir. 1987) (citations

omitted). (19)

Finally, Plaintiff's response to Defendant's

Statement Of material facts does not incorporate or

specifically cite To the deposition transcripts marked

as Exhibits J, K, L, And M and attached to Plaintiff's

brief in response to Defendant's summary judgment

motion. Moreover, no Citations to any of the

transcripts may be found in Plaintiff's brief. These

procedural errors doom Plaintiff's Attempts to utilize

the information contained therein. Indeed, the Court

is under no duty to comb through record,

Searching for evidence that could possibly support

Plaintiff's claims. See Johnson v. Cambridge Indus;

Inc; 325 F.3D 892, 898 (7TH Cir. 2003) ("district

courts...are not required to scour every inch of the record

for evidence that is potentially relevant to the summary

judgment motion before them") citations omitted);

Lamz, 321 F.3d at 683 ("A district court is not

required to "wade through improper denials and legal

argument in search of a genuinely disputed fact.)

(20)

(citation omitted); Little 71 £3d at 641 ("It is

reasonable to assume that just as a district

court is not required to 'scour the record looking for

factual disputes," ...it is not required to scour the

party's various submissions to piece together

appropriate arguments.") (citation omitted);

Waldridge, 24 F.3d at 923-24 (district

court may strictly enforce Northern District of Illinois

Local Rule 56.1 with respect to Exhibits J, K, L, and

M, the Court will disregard those exhibits insofar as

they are Referenced by Plaintiff in response to

Defendant's motion.

Because no property supported facts or

admissible Evidence exist to controvert Defendant's

statement of Material facts, all properly supported

statements included Therein are deemed admitted.

See Lamz, 321 F. 3d at 683 ("We have consistently

held that a failure to respond by the

nonmovant as mandated by the local rules results in

(21)

an admission.") (citation omitted); N.D.I11.L. R. 56.1

(b) (3) (B) ("All materials facts set forth in the

statement of the opposing party.").

Defendant develops, owns and manages

Commercial Properties in and around Chicago,

Illinois. Plaintiff was Hired by Defendant as a

building engineer in June 2002 Upon his hiring,

Plaintiff was assigned to a group of

Building engineer in June 2002. Upon his hiring,

Plaintiff Was hired assigned to a group of buildings,

including a Facility located at 3 Hawthome in

Vernon Hills, Illinois. Initially, Plaintiff reported to

Lead Engineer Jerry McGuire.10 After McGuire

resigned in the Fall of 2002, Plaintiff reported to

Defendant's newly hired Lead Engineer, Don

Jordan. Plaintiff's formal education consists of a

GED. Plaintiff Has over fifteen years of working

experience working in The areas of heating, air

conditioning, and refrigeration and Holds a

(22)

refrigeration certification from RSES, a

Refrigeration/engineering society. Prior to accepting

(10) McGuire reported to Jim Kelly, Area Engineer.

Kelly reported to Defendant's North Region Head

Engineer, Ray Facteau. Facteau reported to

defendant's Senior Asset Manager, Rick Staback

(23)

position with Defendant, Plaintiff (1) worked for

Kraft Foods as a building engineer, (2) performed

Building Maintenance for Motorola for three and a

half years,11 and (3) completed various heating and

air conditioning projects for Heat It/ Cool It from

1989 to 1994.

During the first week of October 2002, Plaintiff

Complained to Olivia Stuart, Human Resources

Representative for Brunswick Corporation ( a tenant

of one Employee, Jim Nelson, had made

inappropriate comments To Plaintiff, including

comments about Plaintiff allegedly

"being gay". As a result of Plaintiff's complaint

Brunswick disciplined Nelson. Additionally,

Defendant independently interviewed witnesses

concerning Plaintiff's complaint.

On January 9, 2003, Plaintiff received a written

Warning from Jim Kelly, Area Engineer, following a

Dispute between Plaintifi and his direct supervisor,

(24)

Jordan 12 Shortly thereafter, Kelly met with Plaintiff

and Jordan on January 17,2003 to address the

dispute. Kelly prepared prepared written summaries

of Plaintiff's and Jordan's statements. 13 The dispute

between Plaintiff and Jordan concerned Jordan's

request that Plaintiff refused to comply with Jordan's

request that Plaintiff provide him with one of

Defendant's log books. Jordan allegedly

informed Plaintiff that if Plaintiff refused to comply

with Jordan's request, Jordan would call the police.

hieilinnss Jordan, Plaintiff what to provide

Jordan with the Requested log book and said " fuck

you" to Jordan. Plaintiff Does not dispute saying

"fuck you" to Jordan.

(11) Plaintiff filed a race discrimination charge with the Equal

Employment Opportunity Commission against Motorola.

After Settling with Motorola, Plaintiff executed a

withdrawal of his EEOC charge.

(12) Jordan did not work for Defendant prior to the date

(25)

that Plaintiff complained about Nelson to Brunswick.

(13) Plaintiff has admitted that the statement he provided

to Kelly is true and accurate.

On January 27,2003, Kelly provided Plaintiff with a

Memorandum that directed Plaintiff to improve his

Performance within forty- five days, or face termination.

Plaintiff received a copy of the memorandum, but

refused to Sign the document because he did not believe

that Kelly's Warning was justified.

Plaintiff left work early on January 29, 2003, taking a

partial Sick day. Plaintiff also called Kelly on January

29,2003 to let Him know that Plaintiff would be taking

sick days on January 30, 2003 and January 31, 2003; and

he would return to work on February 3, 2003 with a note

from his doctor. Nevertheless, Plaintiff arrived at work

on January 31, 2003 to pick up his Paycheck. That same

day, Plaintiff's cell phone was found in The parking lot of

a building managed by Defendant.

Plaintiff did not report to work on February 3, 2003 or

Notify Defendant of his absence. Kelly made several

attempts to page Plaintiff, but did not receive an answer.

Kelly informed Senior Asset Manager Rick Staback of

(27)

Plaintiff's absence and the Discovery of Plaintiff's cell

phone. Staback prepared a letter to Plaintiff advising him

that Defendant was presuming that

Plaintiff had terminated his employment with Defendant.

Plaintiff acknowledges receiving Staback's letter.

On some date propr to February 5, 2003, Staback

received an EEOC charge filed by Plaintiff against

Defendant. After Receiving the charge, Staback met with

Plaintiff on February5, 2003 and February 6, 2003 at

Defendant's offices. 14 During the February 5 and

February 6 meetings, Staback informed Plaintiff that

"because of ongoing problems. ...things

were not working out" and

(14) Plaintiff is seventy-two

inches tall and weighs 275 pounds, and admittedly was not

intimidated by Staback who is seventy- three inches tall and

weighs 175 pounds. (28)

Suggested that Plaintiff accept a "severance

arrangement" from Defendant. Staback initially offered

Plaintiff thirty days of Severance pay-with Plaintiff

rejected as insufficient. Over the

Course of the parties' February 5 and February 6

meetings, Defendant increased its settlement offer from

thirty days of Severance pay to three months of

severance pay, or $12,500.04 In fact, Plaintiff's

unemployment claim, but negotiated an

Additional month after consulting with a lawyer.

15 Defendant also agreed to accommodate Plaintiff's _

request that he be given a lump sum cash payment

instead of being paid in increments over the three- month

severance period. On February 6,2003 both Plaintiff and

Staback signed the Parties' severance agreement. The

two- page agreement Provided that Plaintiff would

receive three months of his Salary on one lump sum, less

applicable deductions, and Voluntarily withdraw his EEOC

charges. It also provided The Plaintiff would have twenty-one

days to decide (29)

whether to Sign the agreement and an additional seven

days to revoke the Agreement. The severance agreement

further advised Plaintiff To consult a lawyer prior to ‘

signing the same. Staback offered Plaintiff a copy of the

severance agreement, but Plaintiff Declined to take a

copy. Plaintiff returned to Defendant's office on February

14, 2003 (after the seven-day revocation period had

expired) to collect his severance check. 16 Plaintiff

received his severance check on that date and

endorsed the same. Honoring his contractual obligation

to withdraw his EEOC charges against Defendant,

Plaintiff also executed an EEOC Withdrawal Form on

February (15) Plaintiff contacted a lawyer, Ross Peters,

on February 5, 2003 to obtain information and advice

about his rights because he believed that he was

wrongfully discharged. Plaintiff and

Peters also discussed the issue of severance pay.

(16) Plaintiff also spoke to Peters on February 14, 2003.

(30)

In doing so, Plaintiff understood that the EEOC

would withdraw his charge of discrimination. In fact,

Plaintiff notified Defendant's counsel on March 4, 2003

that his EEOC charge against Defendant had been

withdrawa at Plaintiff 's request.

Although Defendant expressly agreed that it would not

contest Any unemployment claim filed by Plaintiff on or

after April 1, 2003, Plaintiff filed an unemployment

claim in February 2003.Notwithstanding the terms of the

severance agreement, Plaintiff also refilled a

substantially similar charge of Discrimination and

retaliation against Defendant with the

EEOC on July 8,2003. Plaintiff claims that he refiled his

EEOC charge because he believes Defendant violated the

law By "forcing {him} to sign something by using

unemployment As a pawn.” 17

Analysis

Prior to examining the factual and legal bases for

Plaintiff's Title VII claims, the Court must first determine

(31)

whether those Claims were waived by Plaintiff when he

signed the February 6 Severance agreement. Defendant

argues that by signing the February 6 severance

agreement, Plaintiff knowingly and

Voluntarily released and waived the Title VII claims that

he is Presently asserting against Defendant. This Court

agrees. I. Title VII- Race Discrimination and Retaliation

It is well- established that "a plaintiff may waive a claim

Under Title VII... as part

~

(17) Plaintiff now denies

having read the parties' February 6 severance agreement,

and claims that he instead" went by the

words that {Staback} said" and signed the document so

that he he could be released to file his unemployment

claim which was the "only concern that {Plaintiff}

had...." Nevertheless, Plaintiff has not returned or

reimbursed Defendant the $12,500.04 severance payment

provided to Plaintiff on February 14, 2003.

(32)

Of a voluntary settlement, provided that her consent to

the Release was voluntary and knowing."18

Wagner v. Nutrasweet Co., 95 F.3d 527,532 (7th Cir.

1996) (citation omitted); see also Riley v. Am. Family

Mut. Ins. Co., 881 F.2d 368, 371 (7th Cir. 1989) (same).

When determining whether a plaintiff's release of her

Title VII claims was knowing and voluntary," the Court

"must examine the totality of circumstances’ surrounding

the execution of the release."

Pierce v. Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co., 65 F.3d

562, 571(7th Cir. 1995) ( "Pierce I"). In doing so, the

Court looks to a number of factors... including, but not

limited to:

(1) the employee's education and business experience; (2)

the employee's input in negotiating the terms of the

settlement; (3) the clarity of the agreement; (4) the

amount of time the employee had for deliberation before

signing the release; (5)whether the employee actually

read the release and considered its terms before signing

(33)

it; (6) whether the employee was represented by counsel

or consulted with an attorney; (7) whether the

consideration given in exchange

for the waiver exceeded the benefits to which the

employee was already entitled by contract or law; and (8)

whether the employee's release was induced by improper

conduct on the defendant's part. Pierce I, 65 F. 3d at 571

(citations omitted); see also Nobles v.Discover Fin. Servs

,Inc, No.02- 2446, 2003 WL 22326584 at

*3 (N.D. I11. Oct. 9, 2003) (same).

Initially, Plaintiff" must come forward with specific

Evidence Sufficient to raise a question as to the validity

of the release Under the totality approach..." Pierce v

Atchison Topeka & Santa Fe RY.Co. 110 F. 3d 431, 438

( 7th Cir. 1997) Pierce II ). Indeed, " {a} bald assertion

of misrepresentation by the employer, standing alone, is

legally insuffucuent.™ Id. (citation omitted). As discussed

above, Plaintiff has failed To offer any admissible

evidence that suggests Plaintiff did not knowingly and

(34)

voluntarily release and waive his Title VII claims. This alone

would justify a

(18) Underlying this rule is an important federal policy:

the encouragement of voluntary settlement of claims."

Pierce v Atchison, Topeka & Santa Fe Ry. Co, 65 F.3d

$62, 572 (7th Cir, 1995) (Pierce I").

(35)

Finding that the February 6 severance agreement

constituted a Valid enforceable waiver of Plaintiff's Title

VII race Discrimination and retaliation claims.

Even if the Court were to continue its analysis and

presume That Plaintiff had met his burden of production,

the result Would not change. While it is true that " the

party seeking to Enforce a waiver of... rights. ..bear{s}

the burden of proving Knowing and voluntary

consent {,}" the Court is convinced

‘That Defendant would be able to satisfy its burden. See

Pierce II, 110 f. 3d at 438.

A. Representation by and/or Consultation with counsel

Discussion begins here because “‘a plaintiff who executes a

release pursuant to the advice of independent counsel, or a party

whose attorney actively negotiates the release, is presumed to

have executed the document knowingly and voluntarily absent

claims of fraud and duress.” Pierce I, 65 F .3d at 571

n.1 (citation omitted); see also Riley,881 F.2D at 372 (“This

Court has similarly refused to allow a plaintiff to escape the

consequences of a Title VII settlement entered

(36)

into under the advice of the plaintiffs chosen counsel,

although the Court was careful to note that competency of

counsel is not an appropriate inquiry to consider in evaluating

whether a settlement is knowingly reached.”) Donelson v. City

of Chicago,272 F.Supp.2d 717,728(N.D.III. 2003)(“Where the

plaintiff,with the advice of independent counsel, executes an

unambiguously-worded release of Title VII rights, the

settlement is deemed voluntary and knowing-and

hence,binding.”)(citation omitted).Here, the February 6

severance areement expressly advised Plaintiff’to consult with

an attorney before signing[the same].” The facts indicate that

Plaintiff heeded that advice. Indeed, Plaintiff spoke with an

attorney, Ross Peters, about the termination of his employment

on two occasions. Initially, Plaintiff spoke with Peters on

February 5, 2003 to discuss his legal rights with respect to his

termination of his employment and the issue of severance pay.

That conversation took place after Plaintiff received defendants

initial settlement offer from Rick Staback. Plaintiff also spoke

with Peters on February 14,2003 to inform Peters that he had

negotiated and signed a severance agreement with Defendant,

(37)

received his severance pay, and would no longer need Peters

services. These Facts establish that Plaintiff had access to and

consulted with an attorney throughout the negotiation and

signing of the severance agreement (in addition to the

revocation period following to signing of the same).

Accordingly, this Court will presume that Plaintiff

knowingly and voluntarily released and waived his Title VII

claims. In light of the fact that Plaintiff has failed to present any

admissible evidence to overcome this presumption,

the Court is justified in concluding that Plaintiffs release and

waiver are valid and enforceable.

B. Education and Business Experience

Plaintiff received the equivalent of a high school education, as

evidenced by his GED. He also has over fifteen years of

experience working in the heating, air conditioning, and

refrigeration fields and holds a refrigeration certificate from a

refrigeration/engineering society. With no admissible evidence

to the contrary, the court finds that Plaintiffs educational and

professional experience favors Defendant.19 Indeed, at least

one court in this district has stated that “[a] high school

(38)

education is usually deeded sufficient to weigh the....factor in

the defendants favor.”’ Nobles, No.2-2446,2003

WL 22326584,at *3 (Work experience. ..bolster[s] this

determination.”’) (citations omitted).

C. Input in Negotiating Terms of Severance Agreement

The Nobles court also found that “[t]he second factor... can

indicate knowledge and

(19) The fact that Plaintiff filed an

EEOC charge against Motorola also favors Defendant because

it establishes that Plaintiff had experience with filing an EEOC

discrimination charge against an employer and

settling/withdrawing the same.

(39)

voluntariness when employees

actively negotiate portions of the severance package.”

Id.(citation omitted). Here, Plaintiff actively negotiated the

severance agreement with Defendant. In fact, Plaintiff

participated in two days of meeting during which he negotiated

(1) an additional two months of severance pay, (2) the

distribution of his severance pay in one Imp sm, and (3) an

agreement that Defendant oobi not contest any unemployment

claim filed by Plaintiff on or after April 1,2003. 20 These

examples of active negotiation with respect to the severance

agreement (and accompanying release and waiver of claims)

strongly favor Defendant.

D. Clarity of Severance Agreement

The February 6 Severance Agreement consists of only two

pages and explicitly provides:

If you sign this letter which releases any and all claims that you

have or may have against Hamilton,...we offer the following

severance package: 1. Three (3) months salary in one lump sum,

less applicable deductions, payable to you on the eighth day

after you sign this Agreement. 2ment has elapsed.. One

(40)

vacation day... 4. We will provide neutral references for you. 5.

We will not coutest your unemployment claim filed on April 1,

2003 after the three months severance pay has elapsed.

In exchange for the consideration provided above, you agree to

the following: 1. On your own behalf of your heirs, executors,

sucessors and assigns, you release and forever discharge

Hamilton and all its affiliated entities and any and all of its

officers, partners, directors, employees, shareholders, affiliated |

companies, attorneys,sucessors,and assigns, from

(20) Plaintiffs active participation

in these meetings also belies his bald assertion that he was “

under medication causing unclear thought” at the time he signed

the severance agreement. (41)

any and all claims or actions, at law or in equity, judicial or

administrative, depts.,sums of money,accounts,judgments, or

demands which have arisen or may arise related to your

employment with or termination from Hamilton on or before the

date of this agreement, including but not limited to any tort or

contract claims, or claims under...Title VII of the Civil Rights

Act of 1964, the Civil Rights Act of 1991, the Civil Rights Act

of 1866,...Illinois Human Rights Act, retaliatory discharge and

any other local,state or federal statute, ordinance, regulation or

common law. You acknowledge and understand that you have

been fully compensated for all the time in

which you preformed services with us in accordance with all

state, federal and local wage and hour laws. 2. You voluntarily

agree to withdraw your EEOC Charge NO. 210 a 301645,

corresponding IDHR Charge, or any other claim or charge

against Hamilton or any of its related entities or partners. You

further agree to send the Voluntary Withdrawal Request Form,

attached as Exhibit A, to the EEOC in the attached envelope

today, February 6. These provisions explain in great detail that

by signing the agreement and accepting the severance benefits

(42)

Plaintiff was releasing, waiving, and/or foregoing any and all

claims, including any Title VII claims, he had asserted or may

possibly assert against Defendant. That Plaintiff understood

these provisions is evidenced by, inter alia,(1)Plaintiffs

subsequent withdrawal of his EEOC charge against

Defendant and (2) the fact that plaintiff informed his attorney

on February 14, 2003 that he was “going to stop the

situation. ..because[he] signed the severance agreement.”

Accordingly, this factor also favors Defendant.

E. Amount of time Plaintiff had for Deliberation Prior to

signing Severance agreement Plaintiff was given twenty one

days to consider the terms of the severance agreement prior

to signing it and another seven days after signing the

agreement to revoke the same. Moreover, the

agreement expressly provided that the seven day revocation

period could not be waived and that Plaintiff could not

receive his severance benefits until it had expired. Because

the Court has not been provided with any evidence that

suggests Plaintiff was not afforded sufficient time to make

his decision, this factor favors Defendant.

(43)

LL

a

F. Whether Plaintiff Actually Read the Severance

Agreement

and Considered its Terms Prior to Signing It

Plaintiff baldly asserts that he did not read the severance

agreement prior to signing it. 21 While this contention may

help to bolster Plaintiffs suit, it does not preclude a finding

that Plaintiff knowingly and voluntarily released and waived

his Title VII claims. First, Plaintiff was offered a copy of the

severance agreement, but chose not to take it. It would be

unjust to penalize Defendant for Plaintiff's foolhardy

decision. Second, Plaintiff was given up to twenty eight

days (twenty-one days prior to signing the agreement, and

seven days after signing the agreement)to read

and review the agreement. His failure to do so indicates that

he never intended to read and review the agreement. Finally,

Plaintiff consulted with an attorney on two occasions about

the termination of his employment and the issue of

severance pay. Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that

Plaintiff had access to assistance in reviewing the agreement

should he have desired to do so. While in some cases a

(44)

plaintiffs failure to read the agreement would favor a finding

that the release and waiver included therein

were not knowing and voluntary, it would be unjust in this

case to penalize Defendant for Plaintiffs own decision and

actions. Since no evidence was offered to establish that

Plaintiff did not have time to read the agreement, was not

afforded the opportunity

(21) The February 6 severance agreement

specifically provides that “[b]y signing this letter Agreement,

[Plaintiff] acknowledge{s] thai[he has] read it and understand[s]}

it...” Therefore, Plaintiffs signature at the bottom of the

agreement arguably belies Plaintiffs unsubstantiated claim

that he never read the agreement.

Nevertheless, the Court will abide by its duty to construe all

facts and draw all reasonable inferences in Plaintiffs favor.

(45)

To read the agreement, or received advice that he should not

or need not read the agreement, this factor favors Defendant.

See Peirce I, 65F.3d at 572(recognizing an” important

federal policy:the encouragement of voluntary settlement of

claims”).

G. Whether Consideration Given in Exchange for Waiver

Exceeded Benefits to Which Plaintiff was Already Entitled

by Contract or Law In exchange for his release and waiver

of his legal claims, Plaintiff was provided, inter alia, three

months of severance pay($12,500.04), one vacation day, and

an agreement not to contest his unemployment claim filed on

or after April 1,2003. No evidence has been offered to suggest

that these benefits were already owed to Plaintiff under an

existing contract or the law. In fact, Defendant has provided

evidence that all of the above-listed benefits were

specifically provided to Plaintiff in exchange for the

aforementioned release and waiver. Therefore, the Court

must conclude that consideration above and beyond what

Plaintiff was owed by contract or under the law is present

here. 22

(46)

H. Whether Plaintiffs Release was Induced by improper

Conduct on Defendants Part Plaintiff argues in his brief that

he signed the severance agreement” under duress” because

he had no choice but to sign the severance agreement or

have[his] unemployment stopped and get unfavorable

references to further employers.” He also claims that

he was “ under medication causing unclear thought” at the

time he signed the agreement. As an initial matter, Plaintiff

offers absolutely no admissible evidence to substantiate

these arguments. For the reason alone, they may

(22) It is worth mentioning that Plaintiff never returned the

severance pay he accepted in exchange for the release and

waiver of hiz legal claims. See Rinaldi v. World Book,Inc.,

No.00C 3573,2001 WL 477145, at *6(N.D. Ill. May 3,

2001) (“By retaining the benefits, plaintiffs ratified the

release, and the cannot now void the contract”) (citations

omitted). (47)

3e disregarded. Additionally, while “[dJuress is a defense to

an otherwise valid contract[,]” [dJuress is not shown by the

fact that one was subjected to mere annoyance, vexation,

personal embarrassment, a difficult bargaining position or

the pressure of financial circumstances. There must have

been some imposition, oppression, undue influence, or the

taking of undue advantage of the business or financial stress

or extreme necessities or weakness[es] of another. Pierce I,

65 F.3d at 569(citation omitted). As stated in Pierce I, the

“pressure of financial circumstances” imposed by a potential

denial of unemployment benefits and the “personal

embarrassment” that may result from unfavorable

employment references would not constitute duress

even if such pressure and embarrassment could be

substantiated. Finally, “one cannot successfully claim duress

as a defense to a contract when he had an alternative to

signing the agreement.” Id. Here, Plaintiff could have

continued to pursue the EEOC charge and filed a claim for

unemployment benefits despite the fact that

Defendant may have contested the same. Because he had

(48)

alternatives to signing the severance agreement, his duress

defense fails. Because the facts set fourth by Defendants do

not suggest that Plaintiff was subjected to any improper

conduct on the part of Defendant, this factor favors

Defendant. An analysis of the totality of the circumstances

establishes that Plaintiff knowingly and voluntarily released

and waived his Title VII claims against Defendant. Because

each of the Pierce I factors, the admissible evidence, and all

of the substantiated facts considered by the Court favor

Defendant, the Court finds Plaintiff

release and waiver to be valid and enforceable. In light of

that finding, there is no need to evaluate the merits of

Plaintiffs Title VII claims and summary judgment may be

granted. See Cerutti,349 F.3d at 1060.

I. Breach of Plaintiffs Severance Agreement

Because summary judgment will be entered in favor of

Defendant on all of Plaintiffs federal claims, the Court

declines to exercise supplemental jurisdiction to decide

Plaintiffs state law claim for breach of the February 6

severance agreement. See 28 U.S.C.&1367©; Ryan v. Ill.

(49)

Dept of Children & Family Servs., 185 f.3d 751,764-65(7"

Cir.1999) ORDERED; Defendants motion for summary

judgment [38] is granted. Judgment will be entered in favor

of Defendant on Plaintiffs Title VII race discrimination and

retaliation claims included in his Complaint of Employment

Discrimination [1]. Plaintiffs state law breach of severance

agreement claim is dismissed without prejudice.

28 U.S.C.&1367(c). Judgment will be set fourth on a

separate document and entered in the civil

docket. Fed. R. Civ. P. 58,79(a).

DATED: APRIL 06 2004

ENTER HON. GEORGE W. LINDBERG

(50)

APPENDIX C

United States Court of Appeals

For the Seventh Circuit

September 10, 2004

before Hon. DANIEL A. MANION, Circuit Judge

DARRYL KINNEY Appeal from the United

PLAINTIFF-APPELLANT States District Court for

V. NO.04-2122 the Northern District of

HAMILTON PARTNERS Illinois, Eastern Division

- DEFENDANT-APPELLEE No. 03 c 3905

George W. Lindberg. Judge

The following are before the court:

1. MOTION TO RECONSIDER MOTION TO

SUPPLEMENT RECORD WITH DON JORDAN

CONFESSION TAPE, filed on August 25,2004, by

the pro se appellant.

2. MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT RECORD WITH

TRANSCRiPT OF DON JORDAN CONFESSION

TAPE, filed on September 7,2004, by the pro se

(51)

appellant. IT IS ORDERED that #1 and #2 are

DENIED.

(52)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF IILINOIS

OFFICE OF THE CLERK

DARRYL W, KINNEY

1910 BUCKERIDGE COURT

GURNEE, ILL. 60031

CASE NUMBER 1:03-cv-03905

TITLE: KINNEY V. HAMILTON PRT

ASSIGNED JUDGE: HON. George W. Lindberg

MINUTE ORDER of 8/31/04 by Hon. George W.

Lindberg: Plaintiffs motion to supplement record

with transcript of confession tape of Don Jordan is

denied [70-1]. The court previously ordered the

docket clerk to supplement the record on appeal with

document number 26, See 7/14/04 order.

Additionally, the transcript enclosed with plaintiffs

motion was never properly and timely submitted to

this court and, therefore does not appear on the civil

docket for Case No. 03c 3905. As such , it will not

(53)

be added to the record on appeal. Mailed notice

(54)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

NORTHERN DISTRICT OF IILINOIS

OFFICE OF THE CLERK 7

DARRYL W, KINNEY

1910 BUCKERIDGE COURT

GURNEE, ILL. 60031

CASE NUMBER 1:03-cv-03905

TITLE: KINNEY V. HAMILTON PRT

ASSIGNED JUDGE: HON. George W. Lindberg

MINUTE ORDER of 8/9/04 by Hon. George W.

Lindberg: Plaintiffs motion to supplement record

with confession tape of Don Jordan is denied[68-1].

The court previously ordered the docket clerk to

supplement the record on appeal with document

numbers 26 and 28. See July 14,2004 order. |

|

Additionally the tape recording enclosed with

plaintiffs motion was never properly submitted to this

court and, Therefore, does not appear on the civil

docket for case no. 03c 3905. As such, it will not

(55)

be added to the record on appeal. See 1/16/04

order(Additionally, plaintiff has submitted a tape

recording labeled "Don Jordan Confession of

Hamilton Partners Activity in Retaliation Against

Darryl Kinney" as an exhibit to his summary

judgment motion(s) without first obtaining the courts

permission to do so. Is plaintiff wishes

to submit the recordings contained on that tape in

support of his summary judgment motion(s), plaintiff

must transcibe the tape into a written document and

submit the written transcript in place of the tape.)

Mailed notice

(56)

ae

To: ILLINOIS SUPREME COURT,

Memo

From: DARRYL KINNEY

CC: | HON. JUDGE GEORGE LINDBERG,

APPELLATE

JUDGE HON. DANIEL A. MANION

Date: 4/1/2005

Re: CASE 03C 3905, 04-2122 (KINNEY v

HAMILTON PARTNERS)

THIS MEMEO IS TO MAKE A TWO PAGE CHANGE IN

THE PREVIOUSLY FILED MOTION FOR SUPERVISORY,

WHICH SHOWS ADDITIONALLY THE OTHER NAMES

RECEIVING THIS MOTION BOTH HON. JUDGE

LINDBERG AND HON. JUDGE DANIEL A. MANION.

THANK YOU.

(57)

ILLINOIS SUPREME COURT

KINNEY, DARRYL W.,

Plaintiff,

Docket No.04 2122

V. Case No. 03C 3905

Judge Lindberg

HAMILTON PARTNERS, Appellate Judge

Daniel A. Manion

Defendant.

Motion for Supervisory

Plaintiff Darryl Kinney ask the Supreme Court to intervene into

the Proceedings of the for mentioned civil case currently in the

7" Circuit Court of Appeals Hon. Judge Daniel A. Manion,

from the lower court of the Northern District Hon. Judge

George W. Lindberg presiding. I ask the court to review the

evidence that will prove once and for all who has been

telling the truth in this case and — been denied the entry of

the tape and the transcript. I have attached orders and my brief,

and a copy of the tape in question along with the tape in

transcript for as requested by Hon. George W. Lindberg. I know

once heard my 3 year case that was given a Summary Judgment

(58)

to the defendant will be over with my case reversed to my favor.

I have been the only one with real evidence and have to yet

have it all added to the record or have any Judge act as if a Pro

Se even matters. See Rule 329 Amendment of Record on

Appeal.

Dated: September 15, 2004

Darryl Kinney

By:

Pro Se

847-338-0234

Darryl Kinney

1910 Buckeridge Ct.

Gurnee, Illinois 60031

(59)

AFFADAVIT OF AUTHENTICITY

I DARRYL KINNEY CERTIFY THAT ALL

DOCUMENTS HERE

AND TAPES ARE AUTHENTIC COPIES OR ORIGINALS

OF MATERIAL ENTERED IN NORTHERN DISTRICT

COURT AND THE COURT OF APPEALS.

DARRYL KINNEY

PLAINTIFF PRO SE

September 15, 2004

(60)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTICT COURT

FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF ILLINOIS

EASTERN DIVISION

Darryl Kinney

Vv

Hamilton Partners Case 03c 3905

Judge Lindberg Magistrate Judge Mason

MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT RECORD

WITH CONFESSION TAPE OF DON JORDAN

Plaintiff, Darryl Kinney acting as Pro Se herein moves pursuant

to F.R.C.P. 10 to supplement the record by adding an Exhibit

that had been introduced through out my case in your court and

was granted with my previous Motion to supplement Record

but was not sent with my record so I am entering it again alone

to stop any confusion that the court seems to be experiencing

with this Exhibit. It was entered in court and I was asked to

write the contents or parts of the tape Doc. 36, 01/30/2004 and

was talked about in the entire case before Judge Lindberg and I

have sent two copies of this tape during proceedings,

(61)

So this tape is no mystery to this court, The previous minute

order where I supplied the court with all exhibits including the

tape again. I’ve been told to pick the tape up at Judges chambers

and or have it sent to me well this is court where evidence is

heard to get to the truth and that’s what I looking for the justice

and truth of court.

Minute Order dated 6/16/04- 7/14/04

Docket# Date

*26 01/16/2004 *Exhibit J Don Jordan Tape

on reverse side of order

28 01/30/2004

Dated this 2 day of August, 2004

1910 BUCKERIDGE CT.

GURNEE, IL 60031

847-338-0234

DARRYL KINNEY(PRO

SE)

(62)

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THR 7" CIRCUIT

KINNEY, DARRYL W.

Plaintiff,

Docket No.04 2095

V. Case No. 03C 3905

Judge Lindberg

HAMILTON PARTNERS, Magisirate Judge Mason

Defendant,

MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT RECORD WITH

TRANSCRIPT OF DON JORDAN CONFESSION TAPE

This is a Plaintiffs Motion to Supplement Record with a

transcript of Don Jordan confession tape. Plaintiff ask that the

court of Appeals to consider again that Plaintiff is only seeking

the justice that he is afforded by the civil rights acts as well as

employment acts, and has not yet received. And after sending

the transcript to Judge Lindberg he still will not let my evidence

in So justice can be served when it was he who stated to do so.

1. Asa Plaintiff I have not been given the same

consideration by agencies Court Reporters, Transcribers,

etc. and in saying this after Judge Lindberg gave me the

(63)

Order to transcribe the tape not one agency with the

exception of two after calling ever listed agency from A to Z

that would not do it because ‘ae finally got enough

Attomey work would do this job on the basis of me being a

Pro Se litigant, and after Judge Lindberg’s last order

8/9/2004 denying my Motion To Supplement Record and

Stating again to transcribe it. I went to the Waukegan

Courthouse and walked into the first court that was in

session and told the court clerk there the situation I was

facing and was given a name of an agency that would do the

tape for me and the tape is being done now but not

because of me not wanting to do what the Judge asked but

because no one would do it.

2. Also in following odes the Judge asked each one of my

Motions for Summary Judgment do have transcribed asserts

of comments on the tape and I mention each assert is on that

Same tape so it is a very pertinent part of the proceeding and

even used to call tape Exhibit J fe these Motions and all

Motions that refer to it.

3. A plaintiff can prove there case when all evidence

(64)

mentioned in a case is heard and this is up to the presiding

Judge not the Defendants attorney to dictate the Judge’s

position.

4. Ihave the phone records with name, number and time

for who this was for the recording from my phone company.

This was the only time we talked after I was fired

from my job. But I was called 6 times a day by Don Jordan

until I finally returned his call, I had no need to talk to

anyone who assisted in the mistreatment of myself for

my employers reasons.

5. Rule 301. Method of Review Every final judgment of a

circuit court in a civil case Is appealable as of right. The

appeal is initiated by filing a notice of appeal. No other step

is jurisdictional. An appeal is a continuation of the

proceeding. Thus giving me the right to have evidence

admitted since there was no date of deadline given and

Plaintiff as stated could not get a transcript done. And on

these grounds I as for leniency until the tape is transcribed

or that the tape itself be heard.

Dated: September 3, 2004

Darryl Kinney (65)

By:

Pro Se

847-338-0234

Darryl Kinney

1910 Buckeridge Ct.

Gurnee, Illinois 60031

(66)

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS

FOR THR 7" CIRCUIT

KINNEY, DARRYL W.

Plaintiff,

Docket No.04 2095

V. Case No. 03C 3905

Judge Lindberg

HAMILTON PARTNERS, Magistrate Judge Mason

Defendant,

MOTION TO RECONSIDER

MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT RECORD WITH

DON JORDAN CONFESSION TAPE

The order of Hon. Daniel A. Manion is a denial to Plaintiffs

Motion to Supplement Record with Don Jordan confession

Tape. Plaintiff ask that the court of Appeals RECONSIDER

MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT RECORD WITH DON

JORDAN CONFESSION TAPE on the following grounds.

6. Asa Plaintiff I have not been given the same

consideration by agencies Court Reporters, Transcribers,

etc. and in saying this after Judge Lindberg gave me the

Order to transcribe the tape not one agency with the

(67)

exception of two after calling

ever listed agency from A to Z that would not do it because

they finally got enough Attorney work would do this job on

the basis of me being a Pro Se litigant, and after

Judge Lindberg’s last order 8/9/2004 denying my Motion

To Supplement Record and stating again to transcribe it.

I went to the Waukegan Courthouse and walked into the

first court that was in session and told the court clerk there

the situation I was facing and was given a name

of an agency that would do the tape for me and the tape is

being done now but not because of me not wanting to do

what the Judge asked but because no one would do it.

7. Also in following what the Judge asked each one of my

Motions for Summary Judgment do have transcribed asserts

of comments on the tape and I mention each assert is on that

Same tape so it is a very pertinent part of the proceeding and

even used to call tape Exhibit J in these Motions and all

Motions that refer to it.

8. A plaintiff poeanen there case when all evidence

mentioned in a case is heard and this is up to the presiding

(68)

Judge not the Defendants attorney to dictate the Judge’s

position.

9. I have the phone records with name, number and time

for who this was for the recording from my phone company.

This was the only time we talked after I was fired from my

job. But I was called 6 times a day by Don Jordan until I

finally returned his call, I had no need to talk to anyone who

assisted in the mistreatment of myself for my employers

reasons.

And on these grounds I as for leniency until the tape is

transcribed or that the tape itself be heard.

Dated: August 23, 2004

Darryl Kinney

By:

Pro Se

847-338-0234

Darryl Kinney

1910 Buckeridge Ct. Gurnee, Illinois 60031

(69)

APPENDIX D

Darryl Kinney and Don Jordan

OPERATOR; You have reached the Sprint Voice Mailbox of

815/403-6954. To leave a voice message press | or just wait

for the tone.

Darryl Kinney; Hello Don this is Darryl Kinney. And if you

want to know why you was fired you should ask Rick. Rick is

cleaning house of everybody that was involved in this little

scandal that I was fired for, which I had no reason to be written

up and then fired while I was off from work. It's been in federal

court. He's cleaning house by getting rid of all of his loose ends

which included you, probably Jim, Mike and (inaudible)

yourself because all four was involved in this lying scandal that

you guys had going. That's not the way business is done. And

there you go. Don Jordan: Hello. Darryl Kinney: Yeah Don this

is Darryl. Don Jordan: Hey buddy. How's it going?

Darryl Kinney: It's going. Don Jordan: Yeah?

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: So well I didn't know if you knew about what's

going on or not but (inaudible) you know and you were right

(70)

about quite A few things and there's no support ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: So if you stand behind me I got a question for

you, cause you don't work for them no more so it really don't

matter.

Don Jordan: Yeah, I (inaudible) about that..

Darryl Kinney: Give me, I mean if this doesn't nothing to do

with you no more give me a copy of your union card cause

they're saying even through your union lawyers said that they

knew all along--

Don Jordan: The who?

Darryl Kinney: The union lawyer that told me that Hamilton

Partners knew you was in the union all along.

Don Jordan: Yeah.

Darryl Kinney: But I'm not trying to get her into court so would

You give me a copy of your card?

Don Jordan: You know ( inaudible)?

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: I mean (inaudible) ?

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan : I mean (inaudible) (inaudible) just so you know--

(71)

Darryl Kinney: I mean basically--

Don Jordan: Just so you know--

Darryl Kinney: -- okay.

Don Jordan: -- that's not what I mean. They just made that up.

Darryl Kinney: Oh I know they made everything up. I knew that

but see now that we're in court I have to prove that they made it

up.

Don Jordan: Oh it ain't that. I mean they told me once they

hired me on to (inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: I knew it. I knew it. -

Don Jordan: I said why? And I told them I wasn't going to do it

and then I (inaudible) and said you kind of got burned

( inaudible) really

I wasn't, you know. But they were pushing for it.

Darryl Kinney: I got a question, who made Mike? I mean why

Would Mike-- see, why did Mike even-- well, I guess if they

had you doing it, they had you do it too.

Don Jordan: Why did Mike what?

Darryl Kinney: Lie and say that I tried to get him into the

union?

(72)

Don Jordan: Oh, I -- they're the crookedest (inaudible) sons of

Bitches I ever met in my life, you know.

Darryl Kinney: Believe me, I've learned this now.

Don Jordan: You know I mean I ( inaudible) different stuff,

you know and they ( inaudible) out, So you know they're some

Rotten sons of bitches.

Darryl Kinney: Believe me, I wouldn't be in court if they

wasn't. I don't think they -- if they wanted -- you know the law

is that if want to fire somebody you can just fire them, but the

shit that they took me through--

Don Jordan: Right.

Don Kinney: -- man that's ridiculous.

Don Jordan: (Inaudible) union thing never came up I wish

they never would have-- if you would have never brought it up,

I wasn't going to sit there and say obviously, you know. But

they were looking for anything and ( inaudible).

Darryi Kinney: Dude listen to me I know they was cause they

Started making it up.

Don Jordan: Oh yeah I mean they absolutely, they absolutely

Did and I'll, I ( inaudible) you're free to (inaudible) me as a

(73)

Witness and I will be a ( inaudible) witness. I got to watch what

I say to you without being subpoenaed.

Darryi Kinney: Yeah, right.

Don Jordan: You might be very surprised to what I might have

to say ( inaudible) you know cause I and I you know, signed

that Confidentiality agreement with them and, but--

Darryl Kinney : Why would they have you do this shit? I mean

dude, Look how crooked these guys are?

Don Jordan: Oh, they're the biggest crooks. They all should be

in jail as far as I'm concerned..

Darryl Kinney: Dude, they belong there all of them. I know

this. ;

Don Jordan: ( Inaudible) really do.

Darryl Kinney: If me, me and the court system works the right

way they will be. -

Don Jordan: ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: At least a couple of them will be.

Don Jordan: I think they should be. Just like you know

( inaudible)And they went after me because I was getting close

to finding out about how they were, you know scamming

(74)

money, how they were taking brides and how they, you know I

was getting way too close to knowing too much.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, well I already knew that when they

started--when Jim and he had ( inaudible) -- I know Jim Baker.

When they had their little--

Don Jordan: Oh you're talking about ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: -- side company going, when they had their little --

Don Jordan: Oh yeah.

Darryl Kinney: -- they wasn't really doing nothing.

Don Jordan: (Inaudible) yeah.

Darryl Kinney: I was like oh these guys are a bunch of--

Don Jordan: They're crooks.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: ( Inaudible) all out crooks. But anyway man I've

Been trying to find out where you've been since you and your

boy left there. I'll tell you, you know I never really got to

( inaudible) I really wasn't. I was being pressured and -- but it

wasn't me framing you. It wasn't--

Darryl Kinney: No I knew that --

Don Jordan: They would bring something up and then they

(75)

Would write you up. Did you notice I always signed everything

as a witness. I was not complainant.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah but dude here is the thing. Why did they -

~ if they through they were doing the right thing why didn't they

let me say something about it? They just wrote me up and made

me take it.

Don Jordan : Yeah.

Darryl Kinney: They wouldn't-- well, cause if you lied about it

why would you let somebody say something? I mean that

doesn't, really don't make no sense.

Don Jordan: Right exactly, you know. And, you know and, you

Know and I totally understand why you felt like you had to

make an attack on me about the union thing you know. You're-

it's like cause they're just fucking coming after you.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: But you know that's -- you know but I couldn't sit

there. You know I got a job. I couldn't sit there and say oh yeah

I did that, You know.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, but look at Mike.

Don Jordan: You understand that?

(76)

Darryl Kinney: I understand that cause you knew ( inaudible)

too.

Don Jordan: Right.

Darryl Kinney: But look at Mike, come on man. Now why

would he, He-- I don’t'--

Don Jordan: Oh I think, I think they uh, they pressured him to.

There's no doubt in my mind. Uh, that other guy who replaced

me-- :

Darryl Kinney: ( Inaudible)

Don Jordan: (I mean ( inaudible)

Darryl Kinney: Damn

Don Jordan: Yeah he couldn't take it. It's like you know what--

Darryl Kinney: But dude, I remember when you first started you

told me I was the hardest worker they had. And dude I was

busting--

Don Jordan ( Inaudible)

Darryl Kinney: -- I was busting my ass for these people.

Don Jordan: No, ( inaudible) were.

Darryl Kinney: And they screwed me.

Don Jordan: I never changed my mind about that. It was, you

(77)

know the only thing is I think they, I know they liked you

Darryl and you But I think ( inaudible) because it's going to get

( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, but see dude--

Don Jordan: You know they were really ( inaudible). They were

Saying you know, they were probably making you think that

and making me think ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, but I know ( inaudible) Rick was the

Mastermind. He was trying to --

Don Jordan: Oh he's a no good of a son of bitch.

Darryl Kinney : Oh no, he was the one who came up with this

Whole plan to get rid of me because I made a complaint about

Jim Nelson over there at Brunswick. And he--

Don Jordan: Oh yeah. You know that' s exactly why they told

me.

Darryl Kinney: Oh.

Don Jordan: Yep. That's exactly why they told me, that you had

a Business complaint against uh--

Darryl Kinney: Dude, but why didn't they just fire me and say --

Man do you know how much, dude do you know what it feels

(78)

like to come to work and know you're doing your job and no

matter what they're putting their foot on your neck and screw

you?

Don Jordan: No, I don't know because they did the same thing

to me Darryl. I know exactly what it feels like. I filed

( inaudible) against them ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Oh, you ( inaudible).

Don Kinney: It's like (inaudible) more than there (inaudible)

Because I reported them.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah

Don Jordan: I report -- I went to the EEOC and reported them.

Darryl Kinney: Dude, I did the same thing.

Don Jordan: You know and then as soon as they got the notice

after the ( inaudible) days after they got the notice they fired

me.

Darryl Kinney: They didn't do that, they got me two days after.

Don Jordan: Yeah, right. This is what I'm saying you know.

And so I said --

Darryl Kinney : While I was at home sick. Didn't even let me

come to work and do it. They did it while I'm at home sick.

(79)

Don Jordan: Yeah. You know, that was the worst fucking place

That I've ever worked in my life.

Darryl Kinney: I tell you, I'm definitely going to (inaudible)

Something.

Don Jordan: (inaudible) and I'm sorry things happened the way

they did ( inaudible) and I want you to know that.

Darryl Kinney: Right.

Don Jordan: I didn't have anything against you at all.

Darryl Kinney: Dude, I knew it wasn't you (personally). I knew

There was a strange ( inaudible and stuff but dude, it--

Don Jordan: There was never anything. They were pitting us

Against each other and they were putting us in a place where

you couldn't, you know they was backing us all, everybody into

a comer and trying to get you really.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah I know and poor Leonard, Leonard this

guy, I went by his house and he was telling me that they told

him he can't talk to me. Dude, what the hell is that? You're a

grown man and you're at home.

Don Jordan: Yeah. Yeah. Well Mike said the same thing today,

They're still ordering him about you know they told him he

(80)

couldn't talk to me. Mike's like yeah, I'll talk to who I want to

talk to.

Darryl Kinney: Damn.

Don Jordan: You know they told him that he can't talk to me or

you.

Darryl Kinney: This is wild.

Don Jordan: Essentially, you know I can't believe these people

Telling me , who I can and can't talk to on my personal

business.

Darryl Kinney: Um-hmm.

Don Jordan: He goes but they're fire me. He goes if they find

out I talked to you, Don they'll fire me.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah that's what, that's what, that's what Len

said so you know I wasn't trying to put, I wasn't trying to put

nobody on the spot so I would never tell him that he said

anything to me.

Don Jordan: But I mean it's the truth through.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah it's the truth,

Don Jordan: I'm not lying to you. I mean you said they're son of

Bitches.

(81)

Darryl Kinney: Oh yeah they're some dirty bastards.

Don Jordan: And they ( inaudible) too, you know and, and like I

Tell you ( inaudible) and it's Rick.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, ( inaudible) too.

Don Jordan: They're some dirty bastards.

Darryl Kinney: Here's the thing, Mike and Len’s still there.

Guess what, it's only a matter of time dude. Once they do this

they're going to clean house on them too.

Don Jordan: Oh Yeah. Yeah. Well Mike's got to get out of there

Now you know, but he doesn't have, you know--

Darryl Kinney: Experience.

Don Jordan: -- real, yeah the experience and the skills he should

Have and he's a little bit in a ( inaudible) hot spot but

(inaudible) right now.

Darryl Kinney:Oh. =)

Don Jordan: Um, I said well Mike I don't envy you cause you

know I could give a fuck.

Darryl Kinney: I, dude, I only need ( inaudible) you do, cause

you know what kind of guy I am. They, if they ( inaudible) like

me they did when they wanted me to better Leonard, I was like

(82)

look , don't involve me in none of that crap, just don't do it. I'm

( inaudible)

Don Jordan : Well I was the same way. I told them no but they,

got things, how can I say this? Darryl --?

Darryl Kinney: All right.

Don Jordan: I always ( inaudible) whatever, I understand, I

Understand. I that they have been trying to ( inaudible). I

Understand that you know. But you know I had to see that

myself.

Darryl Kinney: I was saying that too.

Don Jordan: You know it was like ( inaudible). So anyway the

One thing I want to say I'm sorry about the bullshit you know.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, I appreciate that you know cause--

Don Jordan: ( inaudible) and all of that shit but also going

forward you know ( inaudible) called in and I got a mouthful for

them, you know and they know that too. They're fucking trying

to make sure I stay the hell away from you.

Darryl Kinney: Cool.

Don Jordan: They know that I ain't taking fucking shit

(inaudible).

(83)

Darryl Kinney: Man you know what, I had respect for Rick

until he started lying. This dude is a lying bastard.

Don Jordan: He's the lying ass son of bitch I ever met in my

life.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: -- you're going to find out, the guy at the top is

worse.

Darryl! Kinney: ( Inaudible).

Don Jordan: Because he's allowing it.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, that's true.

Don Jordan: He's teaching them how to do it. So uh, just

(inaudible) j

You know since I've left --_

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: -- I ran into all kinds if (inaudible). I mean they

should

Be in jail. They were taking brides. Hey you know cause when

they take bribes the money has been spent and then they charge

the tenants that shit, right.

Darryl Kinney: Oh yeah they're bogus.

(84)

Don Jordan: Right, and so the tenants are getting ripped off and

These people are criminals. They should be in jail.

Darryl Kinney: Um- hmm.

Don Jordan: That's all there is to it. I wish --

Darryl Kinney ( Inaudible).

Don Jordan: Actually I did get together. I had the Department

Of Labor in it --

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: -- and for all this over time shit, you know how

They wouldn't tell you, you called in --?

Darryl Kinney: Right, right.

Don Jordan: Well Mike just called me and told me that they're

Going to have to write him a check for -- for everybody, all the

Engineers for like, I don't know $1,400.00.

Darryl] Kinney : Oh, cause I remember they wanted you take a

day off or something.

Don Jordan: Uh-huh, that's illegal. And I want to call the

Department Of Labor on them too.

Darryl Kinney: ( Inaudible) got to be too much.

Don Jordan: (Inaudible) but I'm like hey, fuck you. That just

(85)

Hurt me when they did this whole ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: It sucked.

Don Jordan: And I''m like hey you know I'm like --

Darryl Kinney: Especially since I was giving them everything I

Could. I was busting my ass for these people.

Don Jordan: And I'm saying you know, don't use me because I

Refuse to be in -- don't ( inaudible) they were using me and

(inaudible) you.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, I know.

Don Jordan: -- put me in a position where I would either you

know Either A, lose my job or B ( inaudible) one day. And J

told you a long time ago, you know I said you know Darryl,

( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Right. I remember you saying that and then all

of a sudden, all the shit (inaudible).

Don Jordan: But they were making it that way. It wasn't me

Making it that way, believe me. I mean they were putting me in

a position that Jim would call and Say -- and he was doing this

on purpose. You know have Darryl to do this. I'm like Okay.

Well why don't you tell him? Well you're his boss. All right, J'l!

(86)

have him go do it. And then you know and then ( inaudible). So

I says I'd call you. He said no I (inaudible). And I told him that

already.

Darryl Kinney: Dude, I told the truth before he even hired me

(inaudible).

Don Jordan: Right, right. But I don't know --

Darryl] Kinney: Oh right, right.

Don Jordan: -- so I go all right you know Darryl says he

(inaudible). The man's a butt.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: It's like, you know’so they were -- but they just

used me.

Darryl Kinney: To try to throw these little things out there.

Don Jordan: Right, you know to kind of distanced themselves.

Darryl Kinney: Right.

Don Jordan: But no I'm a, I'm a pretty smart fucking person and

Right now I hate the bastard. So I don't know what you got

Going on. I don't know where you're at in the process.

Darryl Kinney: All right. Hey dome a favor?

Don Jordan: ( inaudible).

(87)

Darryl Kinney: Do me a favor. I want you to do me a favor.

Send me a copy of your card, you don't work for them no more

So it really don't matter, right?

Don Jordan: No.

Darryl Kinney: Send it to my P.O Box.

Don Jordan: What is that?

Darryl Kinney: 1183 --

Don Jordan: Hold on ( inaudible)

Darryl Kinney: Rick signed his name to, to this here crap.

Don Jordan: (inaudible) but you understand that. Okay. What is

it?

Darryl Kinney: Uh, P.O Box 1183 --

Don Jordan: P.O. Box -- uh, so it's a P.O. --

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, Box 118--

Don Jordan: P.O. Box --?

Darryl Kinney: Yes.

Don Jordan: Okay, Box ( inaudible) what is it?

Darryl Kinney: 1183.

Don Jordan: 1183.

Darryl Kinney: And that's North Chicago, Illinois.

(88)

Don Jordan: North-- is an N good enough or you got to write

The whole word?

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, I just put N.

Don Jordan: Okay, north--

Darryl Kinney: C-h-g-o, that's what I put.

Don Jordan: Illinois, okay.

Darryl Kinney: And 60064.

Doa Jordan: 60064.

Darryl Kinney: And just my name, that's it.

Don Jordan: Yeah. -

Darryl Kinney: And we'll be in touch with you because it will

Definitely be soon.

Don Jordan: Yeah ( inaudible)

Darryl Kinney: All right.

Don Jordan: I will definitely be a friendly witness that's for

sure,

You know.

Darryl Kinney: Cool.

Don Jordan: They don't have power on me.

Darry! Kinney: All right.

(89)

Don Jordan: You know they still go ( inaudible) and power on

Mike and stuff like that.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, I mean he still works for him.

Don Jordan: For Mike though it's a dirty, it was a dirty shame

to. That's who I got your number from. He goes you know

Darryl sent some kind of paper. I go, oh you have his number.

I've been asking (inaudible) you got a fucking number?

(inaudible) You know they got rid of him. It's like ( inaudible)

but you were saying (inaudible) call Len, call you know -- and

I'm like fuck, he should have called me.

Darryl Kinney: Right.

Don Jordan: But anyway, I got your number and I'm glad I did.

Darryl Kinney: All right, dude.

Don Jordan: ( inaudible) I think Mike will be a very friendly

Witness too once we get this all out there.

Darryl Kinney: Actually Leonard, Leonard told me he's be a

Friendly witness ( inaudible) subpoenas. He said he can't say

nothing without being served. We're working on it.

Don Jordan: I think everybody would be, you know.

Darryl Kinney : | know Nancy would.. Nancy knows.

(90)

Don Jordan: They're all scared I mean you know they're just

scared.

Darryl Kinney: All right.

Don Jordan: _All right buddy?

Darryl Kinney: Hey, hey take it easy.

Don Jordan: Yeah I just wanted to let you know that.

Darryl Kinney: All right.

Don Jordan: Not at all ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: All right.

Don Jordan: And I hope everything comes out a little bit for

you.

Darryl Kinney: Me too.

Don Jordan: Okay.

Darryl Kinney: All right thanks.

Don Jordan: You working now or -- ?

Darryl Kinney: No.

Don Jordan: No

Darryl Kinney: No

Don Jordan: What are you doing just--?

Darryl Kinney: Just looking.

Don Jordan: Oh really? (91)

Darryl Kinney: Yeah I've been interviewing everywhere.

Don Jordan: You've been out of work this whole time?

Darryl Kinney: Dude, the whole time. That's what's ticking me

off.

Don Jordan: Oh shit ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Yeah I'm wondering just how much they-- cause

you

Know that they--

Don Jordan: Oh, oh, oh yeah listen to this.

Darryl Kinney: (inaudible).

Don Jordan: Right. So Rick ( Inaudible) calls right.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: And I told him I was ( inaudible). I know

somebody else |

That's very high up (inaudible.

Darryl Kinney: Right.

Don Jordan: ( Inaudible) and I'm talking to him and he goes

well, he

Said Rick said that if you ( inaudible) all over the place.

Darryl Kinney: That's what I'm_thinking is happening because

dude, (92)

I had a good name until I worked there. ;

Don Jordan: That's what he told me. Then the union called me.

They said guess who, we got a call from? I said who, Said, Rick

(inaudible)

Darryl Kinney: Oh really?

Don Jordan: Said uh, you're no good and (inaudible) you screw

Everyone you've ever worked for and --

Darryl Kinney: This guy.

Don Jordan: I've never screwed anybody in my life that I've

worked for and. And ( inaudible they're smearing my name. I

never (inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: You know that this guy is on the Lake County

Partners which is part of half the companies in Lake County,

don't you?

Don Jordan: What, part of what?

Darryl Kinney: Part of Lake County Partners? That's the, that's

the Board, of all business, in Lake County. They're, they're

board Members.

Don Jordan: No, I didn't know that.

Darry! Kinney: Yeah.

(93)

Don Jordan: I don't know too much about them. I just uh--

Darryl Kinney: I know and it aint good and that's why I'm

Thinking I'm having such hard time all of sudden.

Don Jordan: Oh he, believe me he goes out of his way my man.

Darry! Kinney: Oh I know that.

Don Jordan (inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Go ahead.

MS:

Don Jordan: (Inaudible) 10-4. Yeah ( inaudible) I had to

actually have something drawn up in the agreement that

( inaudible) would not (inaudible)--

Darryl Kinney: Right.

Don Jordan: -- with what do you call that? I'll tell you what it is

(inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Oh cool.

Don Jordan: But I had to freaking, I had to bargain that with

(inaudible) but he was calling everyone he knew. Luckily I am

in the union and --

Darryl! Kinney: See I didn't get to bargain anything. He used

(inaudible) board but that's why we're in court with his crazy

ass now. (94)

Don Jordan: Yeah like I said, luckily I don't think I would have

Got the work either if I wasn't in the union Darryl.

Darryl Kinney: Yeah, I understand.

Don Jordan: You know the union put me right to work and

(inaudible) I was having the-same problems you were having

(inaudible) so I'm back to work you know.

Darryl Kinney: Um-hmm.

Don Jordan: Uh, even after I got back to work he contacted my

Freaking (inaudible) employer ( inaudible) and I'm like I just

Told Him I said you know what ( inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: There you go.

Don Jordan: -- and let's forget about what he told you, you

know and-

Darryi Kinney: Start from day one.

Don Jordan: (Inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Manipulate the situation.

Don Kinney: Yes, he is.

Don Jordan: Yeah and he's very evil with it.

Darryl Kinney: Yes, he is.

Don Jordan: But anyway that's--

(95)

Darryl Kinney: All right dude. I hear you're at work now so I

Wont keep you on the phone too long.

Don Jordan: Yeah, but you know what it's good to hear from

you.

I'm sorry you know, I actually when I first met you I said we're

Going to actually become pretty good buddies.

Darryl Kinney: Who knew this company was going to turn into

this. If I had -- you know what, now I even regret even saying

Anything about that stupid bastard at Brunswick. But dude, if

somebody is doing something you can't physically go do

nothing him. That's what I'm supposed to do.

Don Jordan: Yeah, no you're right. That's exactly what you're

Supposed to do.

Don Jordan: Yeah, no you're right. That's exactly what you're

Supposed to do. But count your blessing you're gone from there

and--

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: -- and you can deal with it. But what you got to do

is--

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

(96)

Don Jordan:-- this mother fucker goes around scaring people

(inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Yeah,

Don Jordan: And make him compensate you for the harm he's

Caused (inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Yeah.

Don Jordan: And make him compensate you for the harm he's

caused (inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Hey dude, you're damn right.

Don Jordan: You know, because that's full of shit and he's got

History of it now.

Darryl Kinney: Oh yeah.

Don Jordan: He even did it to me and let me tell you, you get

me on the stand I'll tell you everything. I got (inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Oh cool. ;

Don Jordan: I got no ( inaudible) so.

Darryl Kinney: All right.

Don Jordan: But anyway ( inaudible) I'm not supposed to be

talking to anybody about anything about the case but--

Darryl] Kinney: Okay.

(97)

Don Jordan: -- I haven't really given you any information.

Darryl! Kinney: Okay.

Don Jordan: -- I haven't really given you any information.

Darryl Kinney: Okay.

Don Jordan:( Inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: Oh cool. Cool.

Don Jordan:( Inaudible).

Darryl Kinney: All right dude.

Don Jordan: All right?

Darryl Kinney: All right later.

Don Jordan: Have a good one.

LT/ Darryl Kinney & Don Jordan / 8-19-04

State of Illinois

SS:

County Of Cook

Joann M. Voss, being duly sworn, States she is a

transcriber for Voss Transcription, Inc.; says that she was

responsible for the transcription of foregoing from a tape

recording, and it is an accurate transcript thereof insofar as to

her and/ or her employees' ability and mechanical limitations

render possible. Joann M. Voss

(98)

APPENDIX E

A. Say that again.

Q. Do you recall asking Mr. Corr about me signing a severance

agreement and would that stop me from getting unemployment

and his reply was if you gave me no choice, then its of no

significance. If you gave me no choice to return to work, then

that document is of no--

A. Correct.

Q. Thank you. Did Mr. Corr ask you why I was fired?

A. I told Mr. Corr you signed the severance agreement.

Q. Did Mr. Corr ask you why was I fired?

A. You weren’t fired.

Q. Hold on one second. This is off the record for a second. You

know what, leave it on. Okay you said I wasn’t fired. Is that

your final answer?

A. You signed a severance agreement.

Q. The discussion that you and me had with Mr. Corr that was

tape-recorded you commented to Mr. Corr that I was fired. And

you and I signed a severance nina while leaving.

A. No, that’s not correct.

(99)

Q. You told Mr. Corr I wasn’t fired. You told him I quit.

MR. CONVERY: Would you at least let the witness answer the

question.

THE WITNESS: I told him you signed a severance agreement.

Could you read back what he just said for that question? BY

MR. KINNEY:

Q. Which most people that signed a severance agreement,

you're saying that they quit, right?

MR. CONVERY: Objection, foundation. Cailing for

speculation.

MR. KINNEY: He already said I resigned, which is quitting.

THE WITNESS: I'm saying that you elected to sign the

severance agreement, and you were not fired because you

resigned. You cant do both. You either resigned or fired.

In this case you chose resigning and taking a severance

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

NORTHERN DISTRICT IF ILLINOIS

EASTERN DIVISION

STATE OF ILLINOIS

COUNTY OF COOK

I, SYLVIA N. FRANKLIN, Certified Shorthand Reporter, and

notary public in and for the County of Cook and State of

Illinois, do hereby certify that RICHARD J. STABACK was by

me first duly sworn to testify the truth, the whole truth, and

nothing but the truth, and that the foregoing deposition was

recorded stenographically by me and reduced to typewriting by

me. I FURTHER CERTIFY that the foregoing transcript of the

said deposition is a true, correct, and complete transcript of the

testimony given by the said witness at the time and place

specified hereinbefore. 1 FURTHER CERTIFY that I am not a

relative or employee or attorney or counsel of any of the parties,

nor a relative or employee of such attorney or counsel, or

financially interested directly or indirectly in this action.

Conference room at Hamilton Partners?

(101)

A. Tape-recorded?

Q. Tape-recorded with a VCR that’s right next to the

receptionist there?

A. The conference room is off of the lobby.

Q. Right, right across from the elevator.

A. Right. The lobby has cameras inside that face the elevators.

Q. Right. To the left of the receptionist there is a door that

opens with a TV and VCR in it. Was this conversation

recorded? If you don’t recall, we can leave it at that.

A. Our conversation?

Q. Was our conversation in that room recorded at any time?

A. Not to my knowledge, no. Did you have a tape recorder? I

didn’t.

Q. Do you recall having Nancy Lucht change videotapes in a

tape recorder at 3 Hawthorne Parkway?

A. Did I recall having Nancy Lucht change it?

Q. Yes.

A. No, I don’t.

Q. Do you recall any taperecorders being-- well, me and you

had that conversation. Do you recall any cameras being

(102)

installed at 3 Hawthorne Parkway on the fourth floor?

A. I had cameras installed at 3 Hawthorne Parkway after you

complained.

MR. KINNEY: Thank you. And that concludes my questions.

The witness: Good.

AND FURTHER DEPONENT SAITH NOT***

(103)

UNITED STATES OF AMERICA

NORTHERN DISTRICT IF ILLINOIS

EASTERN DIVISION

STATE OF ILLINOIS

DARRYL KINNEY Plaintiff VS. HAMILTON

PARTNERS Defendants NO. 03C 3905

The deposition of MICHEAL BURBACK, called by the

Plaintiff for examination, pursuant to notice to the Federal

Rules of Civil Procedure for the United States District Courts

pertaining to the taking of depositions, taken before SYLVIA

N. FRANKLIN, Certified Shorthand and Reporter and Notary

Public within and for the County of Cook and State of Illinois,

at 219 South Dearborn Street, Suite 1429,Chicago, Illinois, on

the 17th day of December, A.D. 2003.

(The witness was sworn.)

MICHEAL BURBACK,

Having been duly sworn, was examined and testified as follows:

DIRECT EXAMINATION

By Mr. Kinney:

Q. What's your name for the record?

A. Michael Burback. (104)

Q. Mike, how long have you worked for Hamilton Partners?

A. Not quite three years.

Q. Why did you say that I tried to get you to join a union?

MR. CONVERY: Objection, foundation as to the question, but

‘you may answer.

MR. KINNEY: You know, back up. Don’t answer that question

yet. I am going to show this to you.

BY MR. KINNEY:

Q. Are you aware of the whistle blower laws in Illinois?

A. No.

Q. That means that a blower cannot tell you or threaten your job

in any way without retaliation. Anything you say here cannot be

retaliated against or you probably would be here probably with

a class action suit, that no one can tell you not to tell the truth

here. No one can coax your words on what to say. It’s a law.

MR. CONVERY: I am just going to object as to what you say

the law is.

MR KINNEY: Okay.

MR. CONVERY: The piece of paper that you have shown me, a

governor's executive order-- hold on one second. Just so you

(105)

know, this particular executive order applies to any employee of

any constitutional officer of this state who discloses

information.

MR. KINNEY: Whistle blower laws--

MR.CONVERY: If I could just finish. This particular executive

order--

MR.KINNEY: That one. Okay. Go ahead.

MR. CONVERY: Are you finished?

MR.KINNEY: Yes.

MR. CONVERY: This particular executive order applies to

employees of the State of Illinois. People who are employed by

the state not in the state. Hamilton Partners is not the State of

Illinois.

MR. KINNEY: No.

MR.CONVERY: See, this particular executive order with

respect to whistle blowers applies to the employees of the state

of Illinois.

MR.KINNEY: This here is not the actual law. This is law

telling him-- Im talking about the whistle blower law itself, not

this one. Im letting him know this law exist not only for state

(106)

employees but any employee for any company in Illinois in

Federal and State courts.

MR.CONVERY: Well, I disagree with your characterization,

and I object accordingly in the record as to what you believe the

law to say. The law of rertaliation is well founded in Federal

cases and in the Federal statutes.

MR. KINNEY: Right.

(107)

This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.

A word about cookies

We need a few to keep you signed in and the library working. The rest help us see which pages people use and where they get stuck. They stay off unless you say yes.