Transcript of Record — American Fruit Growers, Inc. v. Brogdex Co.
Supreme Court brief1931
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
“CLERK'S S COPY.
Vol. 1
_TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
Picci Court of the United States ©
OCTOBER TERM, 1930
Oe No. 48
ees
AMERICAN FRUET GROWERS, INC., PETITIONER, |
Vs. ; * \
BROGDEX COMPANY
Lae
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO ‘THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT eet i
f ‘OURT OF APPE ALS FOR THE THIRD CIRCUIT
f
ce ; PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED FEBRUARY 15, 1930
- CERTIORARI GRANTED MARCH 17, 1930
(34,798)
es
S,
eet 3
Pm
SS (34,798) ee
_ SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES ,
ies OCTOBER TERM, 1930
: “No. 48 re
t ' ms.
AMERICAN. FRUIT GROWERS, INC PETITIONER,
: 4 “Ys. of wee
BROGDEX COMPANY - |
“ ea Wee ; :
a gal
aes) ee WRIT ‘OF CE RTLORARL. TO THE UNITED STATES. CIR che.
/ ‘ . COURT OF APPEALS FORTHE THIRD ‘incor’ y
<a 2h eae aye OT, 2 i
aX +g ~ _Original* Print ~ rf?
’ * “Record from district court of the United States, district of Bo ANiscne
,. DelAWATES. 00.6 c cess ede cceccerseeeees pistesenser posses 1 Jd
Docket entries..... pakhps teheb rentals sweater ys Ratetcas L fs 1
‘72 Gi ae SO, ok K oa Kean ectn cbs apivevesar’ Perce ie “,
» Amended ANSWET. «2.2. eee ee ee Teer ere TTT ewes os eee) ae 6
_ Stipulation as to, facts, ete. ei uGe bwin es oes eegecees 20. 414. |
Opin. | ey Se ere er Neches eee erry ee + Naa mo
Interlocutory SD Alan ee aa oat exis wns keene fies See
',. . Assignments of: error....... Livasvaeeneee Se Bie etietee ae a.
- Statement of evidence..... asee PeWbae ea enaeebpcanees ae i
. ~ Appearances of counsel..:...... eileen Wkgaaees st ee Oe:
aig Plaintiff's opening statemeht. veg ace Siciseanewers vee. <u 23 °
-. Jupp & DE?WEILER (INC.), PRINTERS, Wasauseran, D. C., JUNE 27, 1930 2
ert = . A 7 ® ° : , ¢ :
t y reo ‘G . ae
e 1) . J rs “ ° *
ara’ > © +), Original Print
“Testimoniy of Cginald TL. “a0 aes soccecewe . BP 24
See a : ise Wols PETES STE yee D4" 49
: . [ 3s zi S . a fe Oe
Ae :
a i.
‘
: eee. Reims. Knox. (recalled. oie sk. ae BQ,
e oe : : Fred C, Jatobs.... Leeeceseverrmes mee, “Gs "$a:
ee >. Bee ‘Harry WwW. Pierce. beeen ¢ visa Wae dei ctsiee anes (. 57
; m nae tS <a Ci OMNES G8 Sow oe GENE Aye . 96.7 6O
e ea ate 3°: Dee B, BRinner. 252. ccecsctecivessés (2 \o
2 ‘ ES . . Charles I. .Cartwright:...;...,./.... Ol: es
3 Ges Ug ene Se ee > | 100 —. 80
3 ee ‘ a: fae ea cng Wee, ase 104: = Ba
| eS ae cae eee a 6
: | se ’ Staffotd W. Austin....o...0655. 0.006 112 *!* 99°
“2 . William R.-Millar...........03..505)/115 .° 93°
. 3 ie ts . Jesse -J. Parrish... nine . gS oe sees | 124. }. ~9g °.
: ; Brnest M.: Brogden........ceeecceeee ) 123 99
| / - |S * Siemaee (, Bilapaer so ee3 ies ays 1 380. . 105
j eC Henry C. Fuller......:.... sees evens | ade 3 RA
“: "Ernest M. Brogden. (recalled) ......; aye © >? Sand
; a ee ee ery renee ‘144° 116° At
Albert -H. Morgan. ewes erSewcnys Bre 170 137 \
Frank C.' Bishop..:..... be ieccdeeep 2M TD) er oe
‘Alfred’ R. Sandlin,........ eaewa cs cite.) Gee < aS
; Samuel L. Harris......... vPks's Staats VS: 5 G4.
Pei 3 Alfred L. Sandtin (recalled) .. kevsse ued) See 16 ‘
yr : Wikliam T. Du Preéy......2.06..06% 5, 2B IT
‘Edward L. Markell... PCT ek ees era
‘John R. Winston. oe lee ieee. 264 eo
Herbert C. Gore........ Per Cres. See -: On 1
William M. Scott........ Mewtgeelenis 900 288
‘Villiam R. Barger..:.. ecebsd Sqesctoeed - 291 236
* Carl L, Alsberg........... ueieaawes 329° 368
‘ Lee B. Skinner (recaYed).,.:..:...., | 878 208.
Allan H. MeIntyre..2.2..... poheees realhe “386. 31, }
_Bronson C, Skinner (recalled). rinse OOO = BIB.
- John F, Bauchelle....... Rivccocagess 39D 325
” Colloquy. betw een court and counsel... ..: reeeeeckee 416 - 839-
Testimony of Charles A. Meyer. . cece eed pee “Ws
* Antone C: Barke...<:...0i.5......- ae
4 ", ' “Walter A. Boone. . bees tree bivcsen Le ;
: | eco) q ME TR, MEO. oooh Sec eke \.
:* Wiliam #.: Clifton... .s.iesecerenss ‘e
yan Leland D. ee Peer aoe
: ares: ' Gilbert T.. Ballantyne....... ieee re
a Charles R. Pilkington....../.......0.
Frank FE. Skelly ...e.... py iuarke a ee
fare George Wood, oe ec ec eee ccrscesb sees
J ot eM aves cosh eave ks ies Senn teds
: Mis T TRNIG, oso esc ceveve posix cece
i Fae MS SON ee Boer rey:
> ey se -. George W. PRRs. ei cee sec cing ss es
. ‘Fred J. Burden. .....ne..sseesee sees
° 7 }
e i. F Pay :
4 w~ ~. fore 2
cia emeeteer
4—“Citrus Fruits nd Their Culture, is a
. .
“HL. Harold Hurkg (1904), pp.477-479.- 31. . G20.-
» 1°, §-Califérnia Chitivator, April 14, 1905; eae
0 ie Causes 0 ¥ Citrus Fruit, Deciiy,” by:
; . How arf Powell 3 s 06. sde0se 35 623
Sone ; 6 ote Handling o& Fruit for ‘Transpor- ; at
ae aise _ tation,” by G. H: eye elk, reprint ‘
¥ POT ens from Year Book of Nepartment of ~~ =
saree Agficulture, 1905....,... SCY AN Se ee 47 632
£. Mors 7—Proceedings of twentieth annual meet-
ie “ing of Florida State Horticultural — -
; ft Society, May, 1907, “The Influence
2 *: 8, t
ake mfe mast in : \ ss sh :
:
FE. \
ae
E
|
: 2 . vy,
—_~ ve
a
a
PT SON ee
. . 2
co
ae
&
‘ ee Stefi Print -
Testimony of Walter A. Robinsun,..¢..... 2... eee DIB 4D
/ Kirby, L. Chiltony......; a yee BBO. 07"
wales Jomas—Mecks. ENA a EP ERP mon nk ale HSS - 479
Gus Tay EOE RED PEE te Peek Se 591 481
Sens _ .Gamalier W. Pehnes nue Ch be-cesianses 602 490
Be ics ts MUM cle sere a O07> 495.»
wee {pos 3. MUIR oii ops hv isviowvateses * 610 496
panerres ft. engen icine egdnaenaeg oo vaaleale: i
ie) AT a Ml cose Se acon 627 Bt
. * " Shadrach D. Manning. txpee om . 630 513
Notice re.taking of testimony....... Pe ere CM D260.
’ festimony .of William S:; Hart..:............ pre " G88 "528
A : Mis, Laura Sacie bietis Cie ees i Ciehty aes G6: , 550°"
eee ie Mrs. ys ge: | pk A a Aap ecga ERB 679 5D3
PD AS ON Fereatiia 3. Booth. o>. <+.. eS 682556
ay ; William Bi, TORE 5. 00.0 Iestineees *. CA 562
Stipulation re record, «2.4 Cain aercie ras onde aes ‘ 696 ‘BUGS
_ OrderF approving stipulation re record...... Pt PENS see «©6096. BG
Suipulated precipe for transcript of record. iene ¢ G97 G7
Order ,approv ius. stipulated priecipe...s.,..4..5......0¢ ee: Bab)
“Clerk's: certificate. .2..0050.5... (omitted in pr inting)-. 701 -
: Pro ‘eedings in United: ‘States circuit court of Sppedh, third ;
Ne. ek beh no or s Mxneeveknredeses Vis hs 702 50
Order designating judge’, Fe ts eee APPT Mar atta Ae oedeo oN aOR. \.. St0\,
Argumeht and iathaiadions: heeeeese. (omitted in printing) . 703 \
Opinion, Davis, TS ae Bias woke eee Biv awova dcacdie ‘sort 104 571
Deckee ....6.: rae dan addoae neva crasitua teatro Wass 713 578
Petition for rehearing........... Sens ukieaaie wiigeus sags ‘ 714 Bsyit)
Order denying PODOUTING ins Sac ca Nec cee etieGcdee ence ; 723 *HS3
Clerk’ vedas inhety ny an nin RETR ERAT EOE OEE fies (omitted in printing) .. 72
‘Plaintiff's Exhibit. 1 Brogdén and Trow bridge U.S. patent ; if 2
Seat ~ . (No. 1,529,461. March 10, 1925, in suit = 1585
He eye Bulletin No. 139, University of Cali- * :
I" fornia, February, ‘1902, “Orange and. : ea eee 7
} | . ‘Lemon Rot,” by ©. W. Woodworth... 11 cS a
‘ | 3--Florida Agriculturalist, September 28, C
} oy | 5 1906, “How te Prevent Decay. of Our eae
| ie igi Citrus Frui sta, ; bag mee puew AU isS ne 3 616
x ; \ : \y
gone aicadd i a ; wh eee Nt \>
Ror hn \.
: Original Print
“a . Of Packing Methods the C arrying: fare sc cs
A en . Qualities of Citrus Fr ts,” by L. S.°\,
Sa Or ‘Tenny - bin terdeile sb ks ees Nesiw es vesen’ 67 G19
Plaintitfts Exhibit 8—Bulletin:No, 123, U. 8. Depattment of . /
Oe ¥ -Agricilture, ‘’The Decay of Wranges pon .
Uae -- While in Transit. from. Calffornia,” “* . ae
: Mareli 31, 1908; by" G. Harvuld Powell ee thise
9—Procoedtnigs ut ‘txenty “Aet annual Suck
al eae ates tural Society, May, 40s, atti : =
+ of Shipping and Puig —, by W. S. : heen
i Bee eho eel § Ghee Sache ve Races 11°. 25° A
10—Circular No. 19, -U. Si S ieeaNnie MOF 9, * fie
_~ Agriculture, “Phe Beeay of Flora, | ‘
ae Oranges While in: a ransit and, ee ee
tp geese "the Market,") by U.S. Te MANY, 2s c.\ TBR” -° 79g
11—American Review = Reviews;” RR NS OS
in, te Bs? > “Improved Methods of Fruit- Huan.
: ne Be . “ <. diing,” by F. Ji: io | eek ea ape tes bed 302. 9° FET.
zx ; a Pes 12—Circuiar No. 26, U.S. Department of Sar .
Ane tx , Agriculture, *Some Factbrs ‘Affect- ee NE RON, ,
pres) re Aa ing the Keeping Qidalities of -Amer- x"
eS ican Lemons,” by R. H. True....... DY. -. TSB) 4: Sy
'18~-Proceedings of twenty- second annual ae :
A ee Ch meeting of - Florida State Horticul- ; ;
tural Society, May, 1909, “Packing < seen
and Shipping Citrus Fruits,” by Ta. aay
A A NE os Reina se ve ee Cae 219 -| 808
:. : 14—Proceedings of twenty: ‘third * annual’ Be
. io oo ‘meeting of . Florida’ State Horticul-
=. eo . .- turgl*Society,.May, 1910, “< Jauses of ey
4 pigs: wee Defay of Florida Orangts. in Transit es ;
“ ais to’ Market,” ‘by A. V-Stubenrawch.”. a BS se)
: .15—Proceedings of twenty,fourth annual, irae BN scene teat
- Meeting of Florida State’ Horticul-
Z tural Society, May, INIT) “Stem: end —
ig Shae ee Roe and Gummosis,” ee 2 Be .
7A Fawcett ...... Oro Ee EPs rye faye . 283 864 \
» 18—Circdlar, Citrus’ Protective League, om ze oN
os We February 4, 1911, ““The ‘Decay: in ae ae: ON
Citrus Fruits While in Transit.” by *
o3j -G. Harold Powell...........:. Seae, Oe SSA
‘¥° - 17—Circular , -No. : 2, 2c ttrus rotective re: oe
= ete ' Leaigu - February 18, 1911, “The © « enn.
Bie ae Progention of Décay in Cit 1, ees ;
oP oe Harold Powell. eeesak _ 888: aig ye’ ‘
18—Bulletin -D. S) Department of Agri- . 5S a
culture, July 13, 1911, “The Rela-- ee |
tion of Handlipg to Decay in Cali- fy EN ne
ns _ fornia Navel Oranges . Senson ‘of : a
. *. 1910-11,” ~~ A.V. Stubenrauch. . 310 eae ee
Re em *:
;
. . . .
. bd > ay « PLES
’ : f oes on ee ;
ie. : os : #2. Sves
P . . - 7
” ed rae | : ey pour we
? = . -
< :
Ss . .
oF fe) ae ee ae | erent
A ead or ees 2: re ks Original Print 5 .. :
: Plaintiff's Exhibit 19—Biilletin Xo. 108, buiversity of Flor- : a
, ida, November, 1911," Apistessa of Tg |
; e; .. Citrus Eryits,” lly” Rolfs, | Faweett <M ie : ‘| Soha
wake A! fae Saree Wire riicetaskcNeor ss see Son. ROT; eer
eins 26-—Proceedings ‘of / twenty- fifth age : 2 oe
aes _ * meeting of Plorida State Horticul- gaa" -. X
A Meee -tural Society, May, 1912, “The Rela-,. » : .
Eigse § Kin oo or , Hon- of He dS to Decay of For-. SEEN \ \ 5 :
i | Beiter, wae ida Oranges in Transit and an .the Ee rene at «ae
+ \ I i Market,” by H.-J. Ramsey......... 5 S267 902 aCe jae
pial’ ane = se 24 —"The. Handliig amr Precooling of - pe . :
fee Wael eo rn ‘Fruits for Transportation,” by, A.°V, rec ves \
, \ / - Stubenriuch, DIZ. 2. oe eee ele cee eters B48 - 928- \\-
be ae _ 22-—Letter,,. Fyuit, Noveniber, 112, 2) pages: - Ration SEEN ’
\ Xo 1 80-65; “Fruit Handling’ ‘and “Pret... °° 4 2 8 » i
i sana cooling Investigations,” 3 yw A.-V « - 5
/ Stibenrauch ...... tS es RC ee p20 Ky
6 oo. \ the ie B3—P roceedings “of ‘twenty-sixth annual Eek. f\ os -
” ' ee ee “meeting of Florida State Horticul--- +7.) = ; 3
ene cas 7) tural “Society, May, INS, 7Cltrus -.- ¢ * ee 4
ees \ Arta ts Fruit Handling and, Sora dO "bs A.. . Bd
TR ae McKay net eeet ee Vee ee Cogs) Bee <2 OR fe" .
~ if nde ag 24. Bulletin. Na 65, 3 Th. S. Department of Rare vs a e
eps 5 Agriculiure, Mareh 28,304 “Rae. : ft, Peo e z
* merce sles is tors Governing the Succ @ssful! Ship. Nee $ .:
A neta: Fe ment of Oranges “from Farida,” My a he ee
x ma ie “ ALV: Stubentquch. Oe ee yao > OT” +
a 25—Bulletin No.. 7, Board “of Commis- | has 2 .
; Qi eat “stoners. f Agri¢uiture, Porto ‘Rice AS wear 7 é
“The Handling’ of- —Lorto | Ric an : .
s2 Oranges, © Grapefruit, and. Pte = -
: ey apples,” by Ce-iv. Mant... Se .205 4G, “foot — Soran
Oe Gece | RS 26—P roceédings of twenty -seventh amngal ee oe nee
4 £ meeting, of Florida’ State Herticul-. — , A, \ £
fie > tural Society, April-May,» 1914, ea ee ea eae a
ian wees “Pack fng wand one Citrus © -<. : “aya °
aie "* Fpnits,? by 'S. F. Poole. ces... eee. AGS ANGE »
~ Seis 2i--Agricultural Gazette of- New w. Seuth™ ; aoe Sake
= a ee Wales, Vol. ‘XY, November 2; 1914, iar fe 2% -\
, . ‘ungus and. Other Diseases ee
a ap Citrus Trees”. 4 ot les a ao , 492° °." 1075 aa
et wv See ‘28--'The ‘Siopida Grower, “Nol. -X, No. Br a i 3
foi ee pe a Ts Me SS eee Oia saute wT dT
Beret 29-_Porte rico Trott Vo WiTL, Net, 2. S., iu
eit . - Recember 23,. 1914, pp..5-7, “The Rot ie ee -
ee a eae co eS Vitrus’ ‘PF rplt'™ i os \eeccns cacy SOL. SSD Ae :
z ; 30—Proceedings, of the thi enty-eighth an- 3 to ee ae y
-\\ ee ’ i — nual meeting. of Fipriday State ie rt: - =
ay Fo? yah = DE spiny Society, April, 1915, ieee 506} 1084
fi A r x9 :
si ij netninem :
vi ; ~~): bee,
\ - a , ° . ‘
| a j2—Bulletin No, 696, U.S. Departinent of
Agricultuge, November 105, Wd,
“Handling and | Shipping’ us
a : a Fruits in the Gulf States,” by EL.
. Ray, ....-- ewes TrTTTi Titi rie
ob -Citrus Fruits.” 195, by J. dliot
‘i Me Celh .kcvecovadssnctsvgescesse code
S1—Proceedings 6f forty eigith California
State Fruit) Growers’ Convention,
“The Causes of Unnecessary Decay
>. in Lemons,” by RL. Willits......
35— Standard Cyelppedia of-tortieulture,
*. >. OF as Tf Bailey, pp. S8G7- i eee
3 ; fe=42uarterty Bulletin ofthe State DP lant
Board of Ble rida, Oetober, 1017,
— * Beard of Florida, July, 11S... .%.
__ 88=-The California Citrograph, July, 120
lt 39—Monthly Bulletin of Department of
Agriculture, California, September,
120, “Decay in Citrus Fruits Dur.
ing Transportation,” by O. F. Burger
40—The Cilifornia’, Citrograph, , Marteh,
121, “Need of Care to Prevent Blue
Mold Decay in Transit,” by H. J
"RAMHCY cvccccccescvscccsoes eeeees
41 —Cirenlar No, 265, U.S. Department of
Agricujture, October, 125, “Com
mercial Contrel of Citrus Stem-end
gg Bate pears Se veeeeu sees cboocceve
Depiriment. of Agriculture, 125
“The. Oecurrence of Bine . Mold on
Citrus Fruits.” by W. M. Carne....
i AnieMoan Proits” 2h, dy Samuel
Fraser, . 1), PT, 2TH, Oe, a.
hi —lantiet, U. Journal of Agricultural
/ ‘ethreh, gfe 31. 124, “Prelimi-
ee Results With the Borax Treat-
nek of Citrus Fruits for the Pre-
vention of Blue Mold Ret™.........
45—The* Florida Grower,” November 1,
. 1924, “Controiling Biue Mold Rot of
Citrus Fruits with Borax Solution,”
by Fulton and Winston........++-
.
. .
- _
.
‘
37- Quarterly Bulletty of the State Pant
oS -f 42-Leaflet No. 114, Western “Australia
4 '” Original
Plaintif’s Exhibit 31 —Cireular, U.S. Department of Agri-
1 i Sy i culture, 1915, “The Relation of
Washing to Decay in Washington
e+ i e Navel Oranges.” seison 1914-15". .
TSS
Gl
Gs
we
“nie
on
Sie
LWT
12
1200
1215
Pa
Plaintiff's Exhibit 46—Bulletins.of Florida Citrus Exchange
to subexchanges and association
WUNOPS 6. eee eee eenae ‘sotnce seer
47—The Citrus Industry, February, 1925,
“Preliminary Report of the Effect
of Hot Water, Hot and Cold Borax
Solution’ on Scale Insects,” by W.
W. Yothers.. rare ehsvasdvests
_ ds-The California: Cltregraph, March,
Original
1925, “Treating Ofanges with Borax °
Solution for Control of, Biue and
ree m7 Mold,” by W, R. Barger...
19—Proceeding is of thirty-eighth anunel
meeting of Florida State Horticul-
stural. Society, April, 1925, “The ,
Borax Treatment, of Citrus Fruit
for Prevention of ‘Decay, ‘ by H.R.
Fulton ...cccedevecs Cvevosvece ooes
Journal ef - Agricultural , Research,
Vol, XXX, No, 2, January 15, 1925,
“Borax us a Disinfectant for Citrus
Fruits,’ ‘by Barger and Hawkins. .
“Borax as a Preventive of Decayy”
\ by J. W. Anflrews. 0 ....- ceresedes
“The Cultivation of Citrus Fruits,”
1926, by Hi. Harold Hume, yp. 485-
A eee sie Qpetececcelecsone
58—Fulfon & Bowman U- s. patent No.
1.557.757, October 20, M25... 5.2
4 Pulton & Bowwah U. 8. patent No.
1.557.758, October 20, 1925.",....+- .
5% Barger, Hukill & Hawkins U. 8. pate
ent No, 1,550,723, November 3, 1925
i6—Fulton, & Bowman U. 8. patent. No.
(: st The Florida Grower, October.10, 1925, A
|
1500558, Noveuiber 4. ae
57-—Fulton & Bowmay U. 8. patent. No..
AS 50, November 10, 1925....-++ '
5&8—Fulton & Bowman U. &. patent No.
L521.938, February % 126.....6-+
no—Rarger & Hawkins 'U. 8. patent No.
- 1,508,697, September 7, 1026.....55-
6O—Letter, EB. Gl Dezell, “December 19,
1924, “to all shippers,” California
Fruit Growers’ Pxchange.....-+++
G1—Letter, E.G, Deze}, June 20, 1924, “to
all shippers,” California Fruit Grow-
evs’ Exchange, with report of tests
annexed ..... cde ghevsegepadsoverss
¢
* vil
“1312
Vill 4 INDEX.
.
: c i ; \ 4 P : ey
Original Print ;
* Plaintiff's Exhibit 62—Bulletins. of California Fruit ‘Grow.
ers’ Exhange “to, all shippers”,..... TA2 1329
t3—Cireular No. 524, Fruit Growers’ Sup- .
ply. CO. ce cceseeecces ev dues Fae, 1338
‘G4—Chart showing specific gravity “of
‘borax solutions....... ine i Geaseio TS Lisy
- 5—Circular, Chase & Co., suminary-decay
; analysis ae db tbe seRee 757 1340
_ 66—Le@tter, H. ¢ Fulton to J.B. thience, 7.
‘November 17, 1924... ......5.. 0008 eee by) ae
» 67—License agreement, dated September
ae ; 9, 1924, between Brogdex Co.. of
Florida and Mutual Orange Dis-
IID i cbutcticawecenciceues Ta Sa
tS—License agreement, dated June - 18,
1926, between Brogdex Co, and’ Skin-
ner Machinery, Sales’ Co............ ,' 32 i130
* ¢—Brogdex drawing of Haines City, . .
. Florida, plant of defendant........ TS5 1362
10-64 regdex drawing of Volusia Growers,
a Ine., plant, De Land, Florida..;... 786 |
71—Brogdex drawing of New Smyrna,
Mims, and Cocoa, Florida, plants.. | 787 162
? License agreement, June 24, 1926, be-
tween Skinner Machinery Sales Co
and Brockett & Varrish.......... oo ‘om 1383
. 73—Lease-from Skinner Machinery Sales
.” Co. to Brockett & Parrish.........0 7H 1372
_* 74—Bulletin No. 495, U, 8. Bureau of -
; . Standards, “A Radiometric Investi-
gation of the Germicidal Action of
Ultra-Viotet Radiation,” by Coblentz
and Fulton. ads eh oedibas ba% aT
; 75 —Bulletins of Florida Citrus Exchange
P ' with license and lease agreement
_ with Zeltrocide Chemical Corpora-
ME Gaccevapteiebivetbicces scare 853° 1419
76—Delivery sip of Downing’s Grocery &
oy Meat Market to Rialto Heights ‘As-
_ sociation, Californian. ............2. S77 TSS
77—Bil. Blue Goose Pharmacy to Rialto
‘ ’ Heights: RABGETRITOM, cc cccsvovcssce S78 1405
Py. -Th- Delivery slip of Downin Grocery me
_ and Meat Market to Rialto Heights .
‘ _Assoviation, California............. ST TH
7>—DBills ¢three) of Needham Brothers to -
ie. ’ Rialto Heights Association......... S80 TAM
* 80—Shipping order Pacifie Coast Borax
- Co, to Rialto Heights Association.. 883) 1455
‘81—Torrell and Bryant U. S. patent No.
oa 144.993, December 28, 1900....0.... 88a 1435
wg ;
a i a
“& , oie }
. . TRQEX. ix
' 8, ne pty Original Print
Plaintitt’s Exhibit $2—Telegram, April 28, “Po26, B.C. Skin-
ner to The Brogdex CO. rac ccceee sso. 1441
s$2-A—Confirmation “of telegrain, Exhibit
Be. Bovsccbas peespenderes Secveose aD. 14424
; $3—“Problems in Shipping Citrus Fruits,” ee
by A, Sandlin...... piheeetbaehwees SUO THe
s4—Check of E. V; Bauchelle to talto
eHeights Association.....-+-...+.+++ SOT “WA
S4-A—Bill of Rialto Heights Association ae
to J. F.. Bauchelle..... 0-000 +-eee 88 1447
85—" Insecticides, Fungicides, and., Weed- ;
killers,” 1913, ‘by E., Boureart, pp.
OF ent DB oid cudvinicsives sieti’ CU MAT | I>
s6—"The Phy siologie af Effect of Various Bes
Agents on the Development of Some |
Molds,” by Bitting, p. 5 (addition to
Defendant's Exhibit No. 17)....... . 02 1,
- Pefendant’s Exhibit, 1—Defendant’s decay sheets, season Le on <4
. : 1924-25-....9500050: yin mebudenes 4 Hd3
ree ae . 2—Degfendant’s decay sheets, ‘season :
; oe 1925-26 ....... Tree recta Ra
\ ; 3—Circulars of defendant to: packing a ee
“4 wo house Managers. ....eeeees coves 907, 1458
; . 4—Cireulars of defendant to packing — '
A Pa ‘ - house managers, ré use of borax. | 912 4462
6.’ ns 5—Letter, October 17, .1921, »E.. M. ;
ee’ asa Brogden to A. B. Michael, with
a ee memorandum, “A Few ‘Brogdex’
Experiments, ete.” annexed....- 915 ~ 1464
—Articles of incorporation of Anti-. —
ty septic Fruit and Egg Packing Ce. 922 1470
k 7—Bishop U, 8. patent No. 638,899, ‘
pe October 8, 1901...4...5 edeokee 927 1473
: S—Chart, tests of Blue Mold decay.. 929-147
—Report of Dr. H.C. Gore on exper!- “
Ba ments with boric acid.......... 981-1475
10—Cireular No. 27, August, 1922, U. 5S.-
Department of Agriculture,
“Some Experiments with a-Boric- ~_ .
acid Canning Powder”...... sees DEK. 1480
/11- —Bulletin No. 109, U. S. Department a ss
of Agriculture; “The Molds of »
12—Annual report, Cominissioner of -
Agriculture, 1878, “Borax as a .
' . Preservative of Butter,” p. 577... 965-104
13—Journal d’Agriculture Practique, seer
+ 1888, January -19, ‘Vol, 46/1, pp. ‘
. 95-76, translation. ......6.--++++ 967 = 1506
Cigars and-Their Prevention”.... 958 1495
\}?
. | ‘Agee INDEX, | 2
: ; Original Print
Defendant’ s Exhibit 14—Proceedings of Indiana Academy of -
Science, 1909, ‘The Effect of Pre-
- servatives on the Development of
Penicillium,” by Katherine G. ines
or NE cele alae esate. es eee
15—Flolia Microbriologica, 1912, “On
the Effect of Boric Acid» and
ter Several Other Compounds Upon
5 \ "+. the Development of Penicillium
: \ ‘ Glaucum and Aspergillus Niger,”
' CrMRSIAtION.: 0. bivscocenevecsescs MTT) 116
16—“Inseoticides, Fungicides and Weed- © 7
killers,’ by EK. Boureart, 1913....0 984 1521,
17-—"The .Efféct’ of Certain Agents on :
ae the Development of Some Molds,” ‘
| eR A rr O87 = 1525
18—Chemistry of VPlants,. “Action of
Borie Acid on Germination,” by
Z
2
J. Morel, translation...... peoee 008° (1805
_ - 19Spear TA. pagent No.-§7 1,224, -Ate
et, EE LOOT ce ss pe stnobcnecioess CD re be
.20—Donn U. S, patent No, 161,944,
r April 13, eX (OMS 1005 46
21—Am Ende U. s.*patent No. 187,056, ,
: March6, 1877... jp cestanedsne 100TH
22—Jourdes U>S; patent No. 199,209; ioe.
Januaty 18, 1878....0...0000s- 1007 1548
or 3—Jannasch U, S. patent No. 216, fi4,
: ae + Jaume 10, 187... vspccaccecs 1008 = 1550
| 24—Fagersten U. S. patent No. 271); at
: November | rr 1009 1552.
25—Hauff U.S. patent No. 234;567,
; November 16, 1880........ eReere 1010) 1554
; - 26—Grier U, S, patent No. 268,004, No-° * :
vember 28, 9882.........-00.055 1911 155%
_ 27—Humiston U. 8. patent No. 270,89, -- |
January 23, ysis guenvepesce? 1012 1558
‘ _ 28—-Pielsticker U.S. patent. No, 281,-
-864,July 17, 1088....5...2% veve 1013 1550)
29—Morris and Parker U. 8. patent No. ;
556,471, March 17, 1896......... 115 1563
' 80—De Sturfer U. S. patent No, 694,301, - Si de
February 25; 3902...........0% se 156
31—Peters U. S. patent: No. 1,245, 380, eh es
; November 6, 1917...........%.. 118 = 1568 |
, ‘ pt ee U.’S. patent No. 1, 400,086, .
F , ' December 13, 1921........++65.- 10233 it \..
sa 33—Olsson British patent No. sone. of
1869 ...... sbsvdeVecksscocetees SEB’ 2%)
34—Wilkins British patent No. 2438 of oes
1880 ee ee ee | 1032 3 1584
met. 2 oS we S
Original * Print
Defendant's ieee sca 35—Nawrocki British patent No. 4910 »
OF SOB. ck ockcaw ee nsebeteeeree - 1083 1585
36—Wilkins British aes No. 140 of
\ —* SRE eS cbc deuce bee eRe ts seeess 1055 1587 -
37—Barff British patent No. 1332 of Rae ae
ee ere rer sete 1088 1500
38—Wetter British patent. } No. 3823 of. he OO
\ FOS oss esvesens bantoevs gee phe 1010) | DOS -
39-—Townsend., British patent No. 6154 ‘
Yo ree nets. Piet 1042 ‘45 +4
- 40—Storer British patent No. ny of ».
, BBB j..cervocccceseedeeteceders, 108G (1508 /
_ 41 Hasler British parent No. 9145 Uf i |:
: | TAOB \i cr coceciccvccesececoters 1048, 1601
. Now a 42—Harvey ie pafent No. 25,512 of , :
. ; < one BOOB o\ic oc cvosgonce piceseasess 050 Tes
f 43—The Horticulturalist's Rule Book,
j ee eee 1808 ..1.... inieep avaledaonse’ Ries 1055 | non
: >. . 44—Letter, L. D. Niles to W. F. Cnn,
‘September 29, 1909... 0. eeeeedons 1048 [asi
We 35—-Letter, L.)D. Niles to Hon. Wash- H
ington Conner, March 24, 1909... | 1059 | 1614
Clerk's coftifientd. s.ce;s00 ears o> ¢ Copuidted in olteiiesy., 2 1060,
Order alléwing certiorari...) ....+- \eeeeeene: vetted i
ty \
~ ;
° /
e
; , |
\
° : ae
ERIN S S, ~— . a ‘ gue a ; . : ons “ ecpeeenmenies
e
P
——
as
°
%
8
: | |
; | |
PI ' |
‘
La | | |
: pe
;
. ; ; .
, ~ |
°
= : | |
; | |
5 ys
3 :
- 4 7 ,
; - | |
~ | | |
° | sate 7
gs ‘ = : , 7 |
IOI PLN RRR ERTL IN OTF EMI 20h On Gt eR Hts tne nemacmss fies revertcntee ga Nig ae
$ " : cs | ,
—— 5 ;
. * “s |
. . . mo
°. x -¥é
‘ . » | . ye ry oy
?
“Efols. a&1] Ae
IN UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT, DISTRICT
3 : a DELAWARE
Pd
ae No. 593, In Equity —
pay Broapex Company, Plaintiff,
Meee ve
es | f : ; * . ; fee ;
| AMERICAN Frogs Growers, IxconPoRaTED, Defendant /
ee oo wee
4
ae
Ly
: ; “Docker ‘Eris: ie ee ie
’ ioe : ; : r.
Pe ;
eit 15¢ 1926.: Bill of complaint filed ; same day ae
issued, returnable May. 5, 1926.
Apr, 15; 1926. Marshal returns on aubpena, ‘‘Served,’”
- &c.; same day writ filed.
- Apr.. 30, 1926. et to Commissioner of Patents mailed _
and copy filed.
May . 5, 1926. Defendant appears by Ward; Gray & Ward,
its solicitors; same day precipe filed.
=~ May 45, 1926,-Stipylation filed; same day order extending
ee | time to file answer until May 20, 1926¥ :
/
" game day order filed.
: {fol 2] “May 14, 1926, Stipulation filed; same day ordef
“extending time to file answer until June
: ; 4, 1926; same day order filed.
June 4, 1926.. Answer filed.
Sept. 2 24, 1926. Stipulation filed; same- day order extend: ;
ing time for taking depositions &c,; same _
: day order filed.
Dec, 24, 1926. Depositions of William Sylvester / Hart,
Mrs, Laura Crews and Mrs. Carfie Tan- /
ner, taken ‘dn behalf of plaintiff, filed. .
Dee. 27, 1926. Order. granting leave to amend answer; same .
- day amendment and order filed.
_ Dee. 27, 1926. Depositions of George Wood, A. J. Davis,
. E. D: Howard, Albert H. Morgan and A.
Sr oe P. Kelly on 1 behailf of defendant, filed.
ve Y
vie
* BS
secre
Dee.
Jan.
» 27, 1926. Depositions of George W, Palmer , Fred # %
tGuiden, Walter \.’Robinson, Kirby Lind.
3 . «© ‘Chilton, Jonas Meeks, and Gus Taylor On - ste
oe ts bebalf-of defendant) filed. 7” -
sitions of Gamalhel Wyatt dlolmes,. H..
Allen, A. _R.. Sandlin, S. L. Harris,
fa Minos EK. Miller, J. C.Thompson, Albert
E. Barnes and Shadrach D. Manning on
‘/ behalf of defendant filed. ° |
18, 1927. Defendant’s motion’ for a continuance, to.
29, 1926, De
J amend ayswer and for leave. to take: depo: es
hice sitions, with affidavits of H. H. Warner,
‘filed. |
: / |
[fol 3] Jan. 18, 1927, ‘Affidavit - ‘of Roy I’, Steward on!
| Jan.
Jan.
Jan..
- Feb. |
“Feb:
| Apr.
. Aug.
Sept.
Sept.
Sept.
{
Ra
“eet.
“behalf of plaintiff filed,
j fan 18, 1927. Hearing; same “day order de “aying: -motions.”
of defendant ime. day order filed
19, 1927. Depositions of Jeremiah Burns Booth’ and.
Wm. K.-Turner’ taken on behalf of =~
So. ee
21, 1927, -Stipulittion filéd; same day ordet granting :
, leave “to_file amendment to auswer; samy
\day order and amendment filed. ees
31, 199 . Trial before the ¢ ‘ourt, ss
“a 2. 3 4, gf 1927.- Trial be fore the ¢ ‘ourt.
. 1927. Record of proceedings at trial, filed.
g, 1927. Hearing on pleadings and proofs. °
3.. 1927 . Opinion vf Court, filed. pase
26, 19: 27, Hearing du se ‘ttle ‘ment of decree: > same day .
‘dee Tee ef patent. valid and infringed
and that i unetion ” issue ; same ay said
decree filed, ‘\
26, 1927. Injunction. issued, |
27, 1927. ‘Marshal returns on Injunction, ‘Served,’ .
@ &ec.; same day writ filed.
«
eg
.
26, 1927. Petition of defendant for appeal with as-
signments of error, filed; same day order
_. _ -tillowing appeal, bond in thie suin of $500; | -
same day order filed. ;
98, 1927. Motion of defendant for dipersedcas and
ae, | injunction, filed ; same ua? hear-.
. ing on said motion. ”
-
, ve ° aS Rie ae a eee
. en pensercnemaeeaea aren 4 RE eT et aS wre acannon ws a NRaES NTE suas ee er re
: , 7
tr * : 2 ee & : ; Ae - t
ot : Voom
: " [fol. 4] Nov. 2, 1927. Order approving Sind of ‘defend.
Rs ~ant-on-appeal” in the sum of $500, -with °
eae “Standard Accident. Insurance Company, ~
‘as surety; same day\bond filed. . =
- Nov"22, 1927. Citation issued..
Now 22, 1927. Citation with. ACE of* service en-
“ _dorsed thereon, filed: |
Dee. 9, 1927. Order approving stipulation as to ivaanetipe
- -= of record; same day order and stipula-—
‘tion filed. ta es
et
ffol. ie ds U sire Sr ares District Court
get pelt : ; ;
(Title omitted].
| Brit, OF - Comprar —F jled April 15,' 1926
To the 5 Hosptebte the Sade ‘of the District Court of the 2
United States for the District of Delaware: Wee
i
That. the plaintiff, Brogdex Company, hice corpora:
Pi OFieanized and existing utider the laws of the State of
Florida, having a régular and established place of business
at Winter Haven, Florida;:and a principal place of busi- - 7
ness at Los Angeles, California; that the defeiidant, Amer-
ican F ruit: Growers, Incorporated, is a corporation organ-
ized and existing under, the laws of the State of Delaware,
with an office and place of business at W ilmington, Dela-
ware. .
a
‘The plaintiff for its bill of complaint alleges:
se 2 That this is a “suit foi the inf riniomenit of Tetters:
et: se of the United: Stati: ‘and the jurisdiction. of this &
~ ‘Court is inv oked under the patent laws of the United States. |
3. That prior to August 13, 1923, Ernest M. Brogden, re-
siding at Santa Monica, Los Angeles County, .California,
and’ Miles L. Trowbridge, residing at ‘Palms, Los_An-
[fol. 6]. gelées _ County, California, both citizens of the F
United States; weye the original, first and joint . inven-
' - tors of certain: see and useful improvements in. Art of
| a Fresh Fruit for Market, not gach i or ‘waned by
. . ; -* \:
(ign z 3 ; ;
re eee Oe PMT ap CIA, nes RAH OtSN Ea SN ee
. e €
‘others before their. i inv ention or discov ery tharsak a not: A
>. in publie use or on Sale in this country for more thin two, 72%
2 years prigr to their application in thisscountry ‘for ‘letters!
‘therefor, and not: pritented or-deseribed in any, printed
_ publication in this ar any foreign commtry batore their in- |
_Vention or discovery, ‘thereof, or: for more than two years
prior to their applic ation Yor patent dhe refor in this coun-
try, not abandoned, not, first, patente or caused: to: he pat -
ented by them or their le val Teprese tatives- of assigns. itt |
any foreign COUBEDY Upon wn applicition: ti dl mote than
twelve months prior Jo, the filing of ‘their app lication for. €
g ~~" patent yn: this. COUnLEY 3 ; anh thi at esa be rhe ~ te Brovile ay s Og
@ and Miles. L, Trowbridge. did, ow Augtist 13, 1923, duly file Puen
in the U nited States Paterit Office an. applic ation? in writing
for. Jetters - patent! of the.€ ited States tor ‘said. inve btton, der ont:
and having complied. with all the, requirements of? law-in =
2) that be halt, ‘Letter rs Patent of thet nite d- States of Ameiva. s
g |. (No. 129,461, dated March 10, 1925; bearing the pritted © -—-
q a Stiame afd stunatiréeot the © ONUIB TSS taner of Pate nts, ate sf
tested’ by a Law BK ‘amuigier duly designated: Jy the Toss
missioner r, and sf iiled - with the seal of the. Patent Office”
“and. duly - recorded, were: duly granted ariel issned in the
name, of the Pnited States of Ameriea.to said Ernest M.
Brogden and Miles L. “Trowbridge, unde T and in aceord
anee with the provisions of, {fie thea existing At: itutes of.
“the United States and rules of. practioy in the Mrited States
Patent, Office, AS by refere nee to said patent, pr to a. ‘duly’
“authenticated copy theréof herd in Court’ 14, he produced,
will more. fully and at large appar, ° 7. e
.
' ° oe
‘
: } :
[fol. 7] -—: That: the pl thintiff’ hy “nasint TF ats ‘in writ’
duly recorded in the U ited Stites Pate an 14, bee: Ae,
and is’ now, and. hasfbeen since Abe. date lot} issie Aah by
letters patent, the sole owner oF said lott ne patent and - ony
‘of any: and all claims for profit’ and dami Kes ‘arising Quy pared
of any and all infringements. 6f said. letters patent, as Ny’
- feferencé to, said assignments, or diily nuthe atjeated copes Ss.
thereof, herein Court to be _prodiixed, will more fully and
“at ae Se th Oe eae aan nee 1 eA : \
e
5; That, plaimitt lias krinted Hieasios under said lettors :
‘atest tp a considerabjé nymber of paekers of fresh eitruk
fruit, who have /treated and: are treating lark e quantities
‘ / : : bes Pee + \ “4
~ —— 1 ati — eure ve — Hes
eis game, In accordance with. the invention of. said. letters |
7 patent; that plaintiff has expended lurge ‘sums of money ,
Vi fin sae said invention: profitable. to itself and useful to | ie
-.< the public ; that said inv ention ,has been ‘and is of great,
“> henetit’and advantage to tie public, and the public gen: |
aes 2 Oe ally have’ acknowledged and acquiesced \i in the rights of;
| “plant thtreunder. Soa grey,
Lis
: ‘
. Tet!
b
Pe: q ee at | the defendnt, ‘Said ‘Aiabeicah Fruit Growers,
infringe «f upon said letters patent. hy’ treating large quan-_
‘tities of fresh ¢itrus fruits, including oranges: and grape-
eae in accordance, with the vet set forth in said
letters paterit,; ‘and by: selling the fruits treated in this.
BN.) judicial ‘districh ‘her » United States, with
\ : Te consent af the vlaintif, and | is continuing to do so,
| nl has. derived vblawful gains and profits from such in-’
[ ee ~ fringemoyt, Which plaintiff would. 6 arose eve, receiv ed,
a2. and that./defendant - ‘has, by ‘sue ‘ gnfringemen ~ eaused: ir
. * reparalte sdamage - to plaintiff; parte, plaintiff would,
eee but, Tor thre wrongful ‘acts. and 4 mee of said defendant
ines othe TS acting ii conéert With: it, have made large gy
> {fol. s] gains, profits. and pa Ani Aes the practice of.
the invention set forth in. said -letfers: patent; that the:
plaintiat, would, but. for the. w rongful acts and ° ‘doings of”
‘said defendant and othexs aeting ii éancert withJit, now
‘he ‘able to exelusivelt: use-the said invention secured to it ..
me by said let {ters patent with ine réeased profit and xv antares:
oo et the it, because’ of the. wrongful] acts and ddings of the*
es dete ndant and: others acting in concert. with jt, the. plaintift —
ae hag’ been and: gow YS prevented and hindered from so doing;
fand the plaintiff believes that/ it. will realize large gains
and profits from Said inventiqn, and Jétters patent .if- in-
fringement by said defendant ¢ nd its. confederites shill
ate an i ' 22 Paine ¥ | : Ae : )
That. the defendant, “sitiq American Fruit Growers;
icaceinenions ‘was duly’ notified of said Jetters patent, No.
1,529, 461, of plaintift’y rights thereunder, and of defqnd-
ae ant’s aforesaid infringement of .said letters patent, but
\ defendant’ continued, after T such notice, to practice the Said
‘ ath. of fresh tras fit and have iol and are selling ‘the aa \
J theorpptiats both glone and: in: concert | with others, has’ “Tn
6
process of treating fruit and to sell ‘the resultant treated
fruit, all in accordance with and embodying the invention
\-set forth in and patented i in and by said letters patent..
Wherefore plaintiff prays that a writ of. injunction, ‘is-
sue out of and under the seal of this Court, enjoining and
restraining the defendant, American Fruit Growers,. In-
corporated, its officers, directors, associates, attorneys,
_ solicitors, clerks, servants, agents ‘and workmen from in-
fringing upon said letters fmtent; that said defendant ae-
count for and pay over to plaintiff the profits: made by it’
and the damage sustained by -plaintiff, by reason of said_
defendant's infringement afcresaid; that the matter: of
such damages and. profits be referred to a Master of this
Court with instructions to ascertain and assess. the same
and report thereon to this Court; that upon the rendition
-[fol. 9] of. said report the actyal damages ascertained and
a atesessed be trebled in view of the willful and unjusf in-
fringement by said defendant; and that plaintiff recover
. the costs and disbursements of this suit; and plaintiff prays
for such other and furtlier relief, as may appear prope rand
agreeable to Equity.
Plaintiff hereby waives verification of defendant :
answer. .
Brogdex Company, by (Sed.) Wm. G. Mah: aff,
Solicitor for Plaintiff. (Sed.) Charles Neave, 3
Nassau Street, New York City; .(Sed.) Melville.
Church, McGill Building. Wash ngton, D. «.;
(Sed.) R..F. Steward, 700 Tenth Se N. W..
Washington, D. C., of Counsel for Plaintiff.
* _ 4 ~
i
[fol. 10] In Unrrep States Disrrict Court
ANSWER AS Amexprp—Filed June 4, 1926 °
/
The defendait, American Fruit Growers, Incorporated,
: answering the bill of complaint herein, alleges:
“
* Amendments filed December 27, 1926, and Seleary 21,:
1927.
“Say
/ 1. Defendant admits that it is a corporation organized
and existing under the laws of the State of Delaware with
~ an office and place of business at Wilmington, Delaware;
defendant is not informed, save by the allegations of- the }
pill of complaint, as to the corporate character of the plain--
tiff, its citizenship oer place of business, and leaves the plain-...
tiff to its proof therepf. ¢
9” Defendant admits that this action is in form a suit for
infringement of Letters Patent of the United States and
that this Court has jurisdiction thereof.
— > Defendant admits that an application, for Letters
Patent of the United States was duly filed in the United
States Patent Office on August 13, 1923,’ in- the names of
Ernest. M. Brogden and Miles L. Trowbridgé, and: that
thereafter, to wit, on March. 10, 1925, Patent No: 1,529,461
iesned on such ‘appliéation in the names of said Brogden
and Trowbridge, but defendant denies that the said Brog-
den‘and Trowbridge were: the original, first and joint in- .
ventors of the alleged new and useful improvements in the
art of preparihg fresh fruit for market purporting to be
cet forth in said application or im said letters patent, and
defendant denies that the same was not known or used
by others in this country hefore their alleged invention ,
or discovery’ thertof; denies that the same were not
patented of deseribed,jn any printed publication in this
{fol. 1} or anys foreign country before their alleged in-
vention or discovery thereef or more than two years prior
to the said application for letters patent; denies that the
samé were notin public use or on sale inthe United States
for more than two years prior to the sald application for
letters patent; and defendant denies on iformation cand :
belief that the same were not abandoned by the said Brog- -
den and Trowbridge; denies som information and: belief
that ihe same were not -first patented or caused to be pat-
ented by them or their legal representatives or assigns in
any foreign country on an application fifed more than.
twelve months prior to the filing of the application for
patent in this country, and denies that the said Brogden
| and Trowbridge did in all respects comply with the re-
quirements of the law in such cases made and provided,
4. The defendant has no > know ledge or information sufi-
- cient to form a belief as to whether by assignment in writ-.
ing or otherwise the whole or any part of the right, title
and interest in and to the said alleged i invention of the said
Brogden and Trowbridge, or in and to the said letters
patent therefor, or the right to Fecov er damages or profits
‘for the infringement of such patent passéd to or’ were
acquired by the plaintiff, Brogder C ompany, and therefore
denies the allegations of paragraph 4 of the bill of com-
plaint and leaves the plainthtt to its proof thereof.”
5. Defendant denies the allegations of paragraph %. of .
the. bill of complaint and in further answer thereof, defend-
ant alleges that the public generally have not ‘ac enineeal:
in the alleged rights of. plaintiff to said patent No. 1,529,461,
but on the contrary, the publie generally and the fruit-
growing and packing industry .in particuair,- regard said
patent as invalid and void.
{fol.12] 6. Defendant denies that it has at any time or
_/jm any manner’ infriiiged ‘upon said letters patent, and
‘denies that it has, without the consent ofthe plaintiff,
treated citrus fruits in accordance with any intention set
forth in said letters patent, and denies that it sold friiit
so treated in this judicial district/or elsewhere in the United
States; arid defendant denies that plaintiffs entitled to
‘any profits. made by this deferdtint in.any. manner what-
soever; denies that defendant has been, damaged by any
action whatsoever of defendant ; aml denies each and every
charge of infringement and each and every of the allega-
tions contained in paragraph 6 of said bill of complaint.
7. Defendant denies that it has received sufficient or any
notice of said Letters Patent No. 1,529,461 or of plaintiff's
alleged rights. thereunder, or of defe ndant’s alleged in-
Sringeasent thereof.
And further answering, defendant alleges :
. ‘8. That the said Letters Patent No. 1, 529,461 were issued
with claims of invention other than, and different and dis-
tinct from, the invention or inventions set forth and ¢laimed
in the original application for said letters patent and with-
out any new or additional oath by the applicant, such as -—
cf
CONDE
.
eae eee te” Zee tan Saree OE oe ree ee oe epeeen Dye Ons) eraaies. «0, Pee
‘ ,
iz ; ; £ : 9
: |
is required by the statute as a condition of the grant of —
letters patent, and for that reason the said letters patent
were and are void. .
9. That the said Letters Patent No. 1,529,461 were and
are invalid and void because the alleged inventions and
discoveries described and claimed therein, and all the-ma-
. -terial and substantial parts thereof, had been, prior tothe .
alleged invention and discovery thereof by said Brogden
and Trowbridge, patented, described and published in the
. following United States and foreign letters patnt: -
- [fol. 13] United States Letters Patent
“No. 67,921, Aug. 20, 1867, Spear.
4 161,944, Apr. 13, 1875, Donn.
‘187,956, Mar. 6, 1877, Ende.
* ° 199,209, Jan. 15, 1878, Jourdes. —
“ 916,414, June 10, 1879, Jan sch.
«991,541, Nov. 11, 1879, Fagersten-\-
‘6. 999,042, June 22, 1880, Holland. /
“984.567, Nov. 16, 1880, Hauff. | /
" «968,094, Nov. 28, 1882, Grier. ; :
| «© 970,899, Jan. 23, 1883, Humiston.
_ 981,554, July 17, 1883, Maria.
«413,249, Oct. 22, 1889, Wuerpel.
F 556,471, Mar. 17, 1896, Morris et al...
© 683,899, Oct. 8, 1901, Bishop.. |
1,166,588, Jan. 4, 1916, Hoffman.
* 1,245,380, Nov. 6, 1917, Peters.
© ~7_ 400,086, Dec. 13, 1921, MeDill.
‘ °4.450,408, Apr. 3, 1923, Brooks. - .
“ 694,301," Feb. 25, 1902, De Sturler.
-
-~
British Letters Patent
' No. 2438, June 16, 1880, Wilkins.
“4910, Nov. 25, 1880, Nawrocki.
‘¢° 1332, Mar#25, 1881, Barff. . «
‘« 3823, Sept. 2, 1881, Wetter.
© 6134, Dec. 23, 1882, Townsend.
* Added by amendment December 27, 1926.
Loe ORT Cats o 59 R,
= .
No.. 9145, May 8, 1893, Hiusler. =. ~
‘* 25512, — of 1906, Harvey.
A 2744," Aug. 4, 1875, eo oe aa
#* 140," Jan. 12, 1881; Wilkins.
sa mos Jan. 5, 1888, Storer.
' 3325,*° Feb. 15, 18: 5, Bev ertdge. ,
known it prays leave, by proper amendment, tO insert in
this answer.
10. That the said Letters Patent No. 1,529,461 were and
are invalid and void, because the alleged inventions pur-
porting to lnc patented and deseribed and claimed in. said
letters patent. and every material and substantial part
the said Brogden and Trowbr ‘idge, published ‘and dese ribed
in: ,
1878,’’ page 577, published’ by the Government Printing
_Office at Washington, 1879..
-pages. 75-76, 46° Annee Tome 1, pobliehed by Libarie:
Agricole De La Maison Rustique, Rue Jacob, 26, A Paris.
‘*Proeeedings of the Indiana Academy of Salone e, 1909,"
‘pages 391 through 410, published at Indiana, 1910.
‘*Folio Microbiologica,’’ I. -Jahrgang, 1912, pages 342
through 358, published by Administration und Verlag der
‘Folia Microbiologica ; Phosnisatrant’ 18, Delft.
wood & Son, 8 Broadway, Ludgate, EB. C., 1913.
“The Effect of Certain Agents on the Dev elopment ‘of
Some Moulds,” by K. G. Bitting, particularly pages _5, 24
[fol. 15] through 27, 46 and 47 thereof, published by. Glass
‘ont: Asso. of -America, Chicago, Til., 1913.
>
* Added by amendment December 27, 1926.
+ List. of Publications added by amendment. December
_ 27, 1926. é Ag |
“*Journal d’Agriculture Pratique,”’ ‘January 19, 1883,
‘Insecticides, Pungicides and -Weedkillers,’’ by E."Bour-_
cart, pages 109 and 110, published in London, Scott, Green; °.
4“ 1893," June 21, 1869, Olsson. ris a mas
‘{fol. 14] also in other United States ‘and foreign letters,
patent now unknown to this defendant, but which when -
thereof, were, prior to the supposed invention thereof by’:
#* Annual Report of the Commissioner of Agric ultute,
o>
‘ ° .
5
.
™ .
r . ‘ — ——*
- ° — = r ° F
«>
~4*Comptes: Rendu des. Seances al L’ Academie jes ae
Scienees, Volume 114, January-June; 1892, pages 131 -
- through 133, particularly the last, published by Gauthier-
Villars et’ Kils, Quai des Grands- Augustins, 55, 1892,’ e ;
and in-addition in numerous printed publications now og
‘known to this defendant. but which, when ascertained,. it —
prays leave by. proper amendment to insert in this an-.
swer. | ,
11. That said staid Patent No. 1:529, 461 were and are
valid and void, because the.said Brogden and. Trowbridge.
were not the original-and first inventors or discoverers of
- the alleged invention or inventions purporting to be pat-
ented in and by said letters patent, but that the same, and
every material and substantial part thereof, were, prior to
the. ‘alleged invention thereof by the said - Brogden and
Trowbridge, imvented, if there is ‘any patentable invention.
dese ribed and/or claimed therein, by or known to and used_
~ by the. patentees of the foregoing United-States Letsers
Patent set forth in the ninth paragraph hereof, whose resi-|
~ dentes are stated in their respeetive patents, at their said
places of residenée, and elsew here, | :
"FS. Pond, now dead, for merly of Tavares and Eustis,
Florida, at Tavares and Eustis, Florida;
B. F. Chilton, now dead,: formerly of New Symrna,
Florida, in the packing houses of the Ronnoe Groves at
* .New’Smyrna, Florida; |
George W. Palmer, of Empori la, Florida, at Emporia,
Florida; , ,
[il. t6] J.C. Thompson, of Tavares, Florida, at Tavares,
Florida ; ga ne rae ; tee ar
Albert E. Barnes, of Miami, Florida, at Ocala, Florida;
W. J.. Krome, .of Homestead, : Florida, at -Homestead,
_ Florida;
'T. J. Peters, of Peters, Florida, at Peters, Woride:
A. J: Davis, of Corona, b sept, at ‘Corona, Cali-
fornia;
EK. D. Howard, of Duarte, » California, at Corona, Cali-
fornia ; 7 7X ~
— * List added by Amendment Dullinbes 27, 1926.
e , ‘ .
. *
o ° .
: . . »
eat tae ) , s =
- . me yrs , ‘ : , py ne ne
. . ®
.
, 7 4 ‘
Albert H. Morse, of pane, | California, at Rialto, vali.
‘fornia; ;
and by. other persons whose names : ind residences ‘are, not
at present known to-this defendant, mut which, when ascer-,
tained, it prays leave by proper . a rendment’ to insert in
this answer.
f2. That the said Brogden and ‘Trowbridge surreptiti-.
ously and unjustly obtained said? Letters Patent No. 1,529,-
~ 461 for that which was in fact invented by J. R. Winston,
of Orlando, Florida, and William R. Barger . of Riverside,
California, both formerly scientific research workers of the
Department of Agriculture stationed at Orlando, Florida,
who were using reasonable diligence in adapting anel per-
fecting the, same, and -’y~others* whese names ‘and resi- .
_ dences arenot ‘at present known to this defendant, but
.
which, when ascertained, ‘it prays leave by. proper dmend-
- ment to insert in this answer, Al eerie
vs : 7
13. That said Letters Patent No. 1,529,461 were and are
invalid and voN because the alleged.inventions purporting |
to be patented therein were in public atse or on sale in the.
(fol. 17]- United States by the said’ Brogden. and ‘Trow-
bridge at their p&aices of residence for more than two years
prior to any application for letters "patent for said alleged
invention by said Brogden and ,Trowbridge, and that the *
said alleged invention of Lette ‘rs Patent No. 1,529,461 were
abandoned: to the public by said Brogden and. T rowbridge,
. “That wai Letters Patent No. 1,529,461 were and’
: \ . ‘ae
are © "ieevalle and void because the alleged-.inventions pur-
porting. to be patented therein were, for more than two
- years. prior to any application for letters patent for said
alleged invention by said Brogden. and Trowbridge, in -pub-
lie use and on sale in the United Sfates. by the following
‘persons at the: places indicated:
F. S. Pond, now dead, formerly éf Tavares and Kustis,
Florida, at Tavares and Eustis, Florida;
; \
1927. oa
\° New species 14 inserted by amer: ndment January 21,
13
B. F. Chilton, now dead, formerly of New Smyrna,
Florida, in the packing houses ‘of the Ronnoe Groves at.
New Smyrna, Flovida; |. ae
George W. Palmer, of Emporia, ‘Florida, at Emporia, \
: Florida ; . .
PJ. CT oo Tevaten, Florida, at Oc sla Florida;
W. J. J<rome, Homestead, Florida, at Homestead,
ereray? eth
J. Peters, of. Peters, Florida, at ‘Betevs Florida ;
4 J. Davis, orona, California, at Corona, California ;
[fol. 18] EK. DDlowara of Duarte, California, at Corona,
California;
Albert H. Morgan, of Rialto, California, at Rialto, Cali-
fornia. hee
“15. That the said Letters Patent No. i. 529, 461 were and. ie
dre invalid 4 void because the invention or inventions. -
purporting be patented thereby did not constitute pat-
~ entable novelty or inve tion within the meaning of the pat. ;
--ent law, in view of the
of what Was common knywledge on the part of those skilled
prior state of the art and in view
in the art, all prior to.the date of the alleged invention *
of the said letters patent’ by r the: sald Brogden and Trow-.
bridge,
16. That said Latises Patent No. 1, 528,461 were and are -
invalid and void, because for the purpose of deceiving the
public the description: and specification filed by said. Brog- —
den and -T rowbridge in the, United States Patent Office |
were made to contain less than.the whole truth relev ant to
their alleged invention, or more than was necessary to pro-
‘duce the, desired effect.
17; That on aecount’of the proceedings of the said rod.
den and Trowbridge in the prosecution of their applica-
tion in the United States Patent Office and of tlie decisions
of the United States Patent Office .reridered. and. filed’ in
. the course of said proceedings, in ‘which, decisions et
Brogden and Trowbridge acquiesced, the ‘plaintiff . i
“estopped to assert that the’ said letters patent are ae a
- scope fo cover any method of preparing fruit for market -
or any fruit prepared and sold by- this defendant.
18. That prior to the filing of the application for. Let- -
: ” ters patent No. 1,529,461, and-also while said application .-
ra \ ¢
was ‘pcaaiag | int e U nited States Piatesat fic ®, “the U ited”
ffol. [9] States . Pepartanent of Agric ulture,” with full _
knowledge of plainitlaygd the: Said) Brogden and Trow.
bridge, recomme nidedd wr fruit growers throughout, the coun:
try, 1 got! the thoes of\preparing trait for market e titres
7 Dor ih part the alleged faite tee purporting
ta: Fes CoV er red by the said hetters Patent No. 1520 461, and
plaintil| and ‘the said Brog en and. Trowbridge acqiie iced x
in, said r \vcomfheridation by the Department of Agric ulture:
and disk wot-at any tire assert leo the United States De ‘part
ment of Agriculture or anyone that _— caged of the
proc wanes oO recomine “tie der a c onstitated - , bras te " - the et
—
ficcn awserting “that the peractiee df : Nay Proce as recom
mended by. the t hited Stafes De partite “ook Agriculture.
with the acruie arene ‘of plaint itf anid shy ce Browde th ane :
Trowbridye or the product “of sun h pects \ con tute in- rate
fringement Gf said letters patent.” Tee ee oN acy tye fs “
19:* That «lattins h3 throtah woof sank [atts ri Pati nt Nae
Lovesed are invitbiel anel i ae atiew ft owls Oh iE c+. thet
an art, machine, manufacture or eotipostion of matter
within the meaniig of the patent statutes, ard ts therefore |.
unpatentable, peer eda Oe oY SU ar ee : oN perc.
; | .
Sarge hess fore the elefe niu yrs Wve Unt the Wall of compladat
be disthissed with coals, é aS .
Sah Ward, Grav & W aa Nalicitors for The nd
ant. Ww. Be Morton, ‘R qT; M. Me Cready, of Cann x
Lo
a
sel.
‘2
[fol 20}. ° Is .Usrrem Stared Destetot Cowrt:
Sripviarion: 4 TO Frets, rte ) Filed Se fsteth cae t 24 1928
Pei % a ae Ee i aT 4 ae
& F
Téis hereby, stipulated and agri vit as RP
: That the plaintiff Brogdex C ‘Giapany 13a corporation
organized ‘and Ptiating under the: awaonf the State of. /
°
ii es
sera ge tn ame pores Sgn
* Adah | by. Amendment Dolwber 97, 1926. Pac
a . mre Y ee jan : Ks y ¢ 215.
Fiorida, having it regular. and eet tabliah/d place ‘of busi = s+
ness at Winter Haven, Flowida: andia h adeaces te plage acs:
business at dios Ange ‘le 8, i ‘alifornia. 3 ay Taina
~
Thi it the “tninditt Hroxden Ae ompany is ow and has. co
Le sinee the dete of Iss of Said: lette a patentsin suit
Xo. LOO 461 the sole owne r of Said le thers patent and of
dmv and-all- éjaims for profits and dama res dirising foul’ of
an Vand all an fringe une nts of anid lette Ts! py vent, oft
~
That at-the ‘trial ph the ‘she ¢
Pate ae COffien: copie: ‘s of spe ifte
ters Patents of the. Anite
Jactte ts: ¥ tent ay Gre ii}
ontithod dause! printed”
sons. nad drawittes of Let. < '
late ~ nd photost: iat copies of.
/
«
mis bre” introduced: and shall bre rece ived in evidene i bs with/
the sathe hore end effe ot We a ivinaal letters patents or duly
rt fiend COP Mes the reat, as to all the facts set forth in Sail &
printed: copes 4, OF photasts Wy, ne Fadiig the date a of a
as stan thereof; aiid that, f hatost: at Opie sof priblic ations ae
: ee bat introduced and sMall be received in, evidence with es
es She nine forces and wffoet iis the originals, and: ‘that suc h
<3 Subli int ini i* Were prililistded aeti ‘the Fespective ‘dates they
> beds ar pt Inporting to be this dy Iter. of pubdie ation j all subject
eye tn correr tign ‘by. othe T proof.
Pe
4 T hint ont the ial qf the above . autitled | Hise the plain.
‘ie will rely on 16: npon claims 1,2. 8, 4 hi, G, 7,9 . 14,15
‘16777, Athy Ney a Be 93 2g) Oh, 26,. oF aid 2 sof the i
ie patent in suit, No. La, 461. ase : Sapir bye = ae 3,
‘ ried ~
fr . .
. fol 211. : That the times for taking depositions hefore/
frial of wits nom Te vidifg inore than 190. miles from the +8 :
\: place of | trial be « ite ride «dl nx follows, the ig eas nting = |
Ne Those of tie sdainstitt ‘iid de: Le nd int ny) lo November 5
1926 and réhatting de positions: hy either h teaied UP. to. No. e
\vember 1h, 16 a a:
\ (Ned 4 aiy m. ‘G.. Maha Sélic ‘ifor tm laintiff. - ate
oN : (Sed.} Charles Neate, Counsel. (Sed.) A: C. , |
\ Gray, Splieftor fer Defendant. (Sgd.) W.B. Mor-
\ ‘ton, (Sed. ye RK. M, Met ‘ready, of Counsel, - °
\ i " hg le
1926. :
Perit an and other forvien countries / iy
oe
pa
> Ts -UsireeSecres Disraiiy Cover : |
1
Ovtsios- Filed August 3, 1927 Tapes
The’ elimination or redur tion of decay of eitrys frait dur-
1 ing transportation tw market aero s “the prob lem de alt
with in the pate ut in suit No. i 12.461 hegeg 6 Mare ho
‘Brie: ( ompay), the plaintiff, The deny Birt to
prevented is due mainly to Rarimitic Pung, /penicillian Ay
blue mold; the spores of whie h tind lodgermeny and germity ile,
most Frequently itt lesions in the skin of the fruit She 4,
patentye’s solution of the problem is St! “that in these char.
acteriytie’ claims: a opel eat aaata
~ {fol 2b) eB Tn’ the preparation of fre sh: fruit we market t,
; ethe provess whic lr comprises sulije eting fruit-to the a tion
of an aqueotis solution of borax, the fuiglity, strength and.
temperature of the treating solution, avd the duration of
the treatment, being such that expose ea or skin trssues
of the fruit are effeetively impregirated with borax and
rendered resistant: to blue mold decay, while at the same |
time the fruit ix not scalded nor rx its freshness or edibility
otherwise substantially Spee ees Can
°
nt * 26.. Fresh citrus fruit of Which the rind or skin carries
borax. ‘in amNunt that i rs Very small bait: sities ‘ent to render Bess
thre fruit resistant to tee = mold dec ay eR. :
2
1,-2, 4, To? inclu. *,_
rroduet® claims are
: Other process chaima, Tn suit are Nod
sive, 9 and 14.40.18 inclusive ther
“Nos, 23 te. 25.inelusive, |
The defendgnt, American Yr rN\it “Grog ers, Incorporated, . . -
admits’ that! + dips its fruit in bora solution to check’ —
: “blue mold decay. This practice: it Strks ta justify hy. the
disclosures;of the prior art and by asserted prior uses. a.
—eontends that the process of the ‘patent in suit evabraces.
broadly” at uses of polations of re eae of boron, partic-
a S
|
stab lished, he yond.questipn. Th -. were #0: shh td ey 7
: sind in ‘solution, ihn of Writ a were both hot and cold. The
eae oa “neéuef a hot solution of horic sige its salts: to. ores ent, the :
growth pf funya aor ‘trol upon cured meats by immersiy
~ oradipping them ‘Thtlo the, solution, was disclosed ~ early
- 1879. As arly. as LANS/Vorie acid andoits salts were ws $:
in pac ‘King material auth as’ sahwalust, chatt and sh in gf
fol. 237 for the. preservation, at “all kinds of ‘frésh ffu
Rosin wets ave or their travisportation to, near or. digtrit
tharke ts," : It Was evel pene ray species ofapenic ‘il. We
ligm. tholds Were more or les affeetec by borj acid and.
its salts Vet the eek before me dise Joses ith equal
: certain “that, notwithstanidi iv the wall: known fropertics
of the borei ry: adica},. neg per bx’ fhe teach) ngs! with.
re spect to. its particylar uses and thanner-of use found in-
the later eo bliiont for aduarter 6f a century. the-search *
“for wd specifictfor the; blue mpld decay of citrus fruit during
trantport ition cantifue d tuihabated, hut in vain. @hemicals *
wt widely varsingdegrees of toxicity were tried and aban- ©
donned.» Every trialof new means, of whatsoever « haractgy, ,
for reducing the decay ended but in 4 return to the:convie-
+ tion that in-the Jong taught and tong: ‘practiced: -eareful |
> handing of tO fruit and avoids ince of wounds, and bruises’
ay the only hope of minimizing the decay. In this —
“standing alone and linaided, every injured oraige was
oul. -{f shipped; the’ injured. orange became a otbint
“agency: for: the. spreadof decay. To éliminate the loss |
_ arising, directly from the exelusion of the inju red orange’
cand the far greater indirect loss- from. its inclusion, in--
adverte tit or otherwise, in- the. shipmeiit,: a remec y/supple-
. . menting ctreful bandijng was long desired.’ ‘and) greatly |
~. needed?” Brogden and [Pr rowbridge were the first, to supply
it. They departhd from the idea that: no: relief /Was to ‘be.
ee had gave by morpsand) more « ‘areful handling or by. the, use’
f of shemfeals so thxiéas to destroy the mold and ypores and
.turned to the-usp of fi mold inhibiting reagent comprising
the’ horic ; acid raflical |to render the surface of the fruit, and
partieul: arly the -Wwoui ds, unfavorable as a medium for blue
Aas development /Bat their invention; as’ L understand.
it, ® not thefmere use oO borax or boric acid, nor of the use
Of that force iia ) specific. manner, but it consists in- the.
ad be a
# ers oe La,
oy 'O ass t . ‘
] ° ; bo tle f.
118%... \ ; od bag
4 [fol. 24] subjection of a specific olsjoct to the influence of a. *-
“specific force acting through a specific mode of application
to produce a specific result, See Robinson on Patents ¢
261-263. Such process is nowhere found in the disclosures of
he prior art though it is trne that, viewed retrospec tively ;
ndgignoring the long unsuccessful search for a remedy, :
he claimed process would seem to be wanting in invention
he the disclosures of the prior art. Yet, | am convinced >
that the long, unsuccessful search must stand-as a bar to
such conclusion unless tle failure sooner to resort to the
claimed process is satisfactorily explained. “Solved prob:
lams frequently, beget conclusions ‘that. the solution was
logically deducible from ‘the prior art but’ such after-the,
event views are’ unavailing when inconsistent with prior
efforts and failures, particularly if the result was greatly
needed and Jong sought. Walker, Sees, 26 and 42. The de-
eay directly attributable to blue mold amointed in some
eases: to as much as 30 to 40 percent. of dhe shipments, The
resulting losses were enormous. Time and-time again the
shippers,in their distress turned to the Department. of
Agriculture but to their inquiry the. uniform answer
throughout the years, unti? the invention of Brogden and
Trowbridge, was the despairing one that nothing had been
found that-could be put into the wash that was effective
against blue mold, that **the only thing th do is to keep the
. fruit free from injuries.’’ The only explanation offered by
the defendant of the-iong. search and failure is the theory ~
that the Pure Food and Drugs Act of 1906, 34 Stat, 768,
acted as a deterfent to the use of borax as.a food preserva-
tive... But, aside from the fact that-by the ¢laimed process
only the skin or non-edible portion of the citrus fruit isim-
_Preghated with the borax,.the record discloses that prior . ,
‘to the passage of the act the Department experimented with ° .”
{fol. 25] the treatment of citrus fruits. with borie acid to
prevent blue mold decay and abandoned the experiments -
because of*the conclusion that no permanent check of the
‘growth of the fungus was obtainable thereby. “Moreover, —-
it likewise discloses that thereafter the Department re-
ported to the growers from time to time that it had experi-
mented with the-use of antiseptics, disinfectants and fungi-
cides in the wash and that it had not obtained any results
‘that were worth noting. This evidence renders impossible
_—. o
.
19°
. a conclusion that the long delay in the arrival at the solu-
tion of.the problem was ig genet De Pure Food and
Drugs Act. Consequently, | must conchide that invention
was not Wanting and that the process claims are valid un-
less invalidated by the alleged prior uses. <
Tbe alle ged prior uses relied upon are many. . That borax
was used in the preparation of citrus fruits for market by
several persons prior to the date of the invention in suit
cannot, | think, be seriously questioned, But borax is a
cleansing agent and/frequently nsed as a Washing powder
as well as an antiseptic and preservative. That it was used
by anyone prioy to Brogden and ‘Trowbridge for the pur-
pose of preventing decay gud in such manner as effectively
to prevent decay or otherwise.than as a washing powder is
not established by the evidence with that degree of certainty ¢
which is yequired with respect to prior uses,
The cases relied upon to show invalidity of the product
claims wre cases dealing with a manufacture under the tariff
acts and not under the patent law. That term, as uséed-in
the patent law, is broad enough, as | understand it, to in-
clude the product of the product claims in suit. -;
As the claims in,suit are valjd and as the defendant not
only uses borax but uses it in the specific manner and for
[fol. 26] the specific purpose called for by the claims ‘in
suit, the prayers of the bill must be granted. -
(Sed.) Hugh M. Morris, J.
*
August 3, 1927.
——
In Unirep Stares District Court
Ixrentocutory Deener—Filed September 26, 1927
Anck now, to wit, this twenty-sixth day of September, A.’
D. 1927, this cause having come on to be ‘heard at thi¢ term,
and argued by counsel fot .the respective parties; anid
thereupon, upon consideration thereof, it is ordered, ad-
judged and deereed as follows, viz.: * °
1, That Ernest M. Brogden and Miles L. Trowbridge,
were the first, original and jqint inventors of the inventions |
described in and Saray recited in claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5,
6,7,9, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 23, 24, 25 and 26 and each of them, °
/
- , ae , all
- of United States Letite P Patent No. 1, 529,461, issued March
10, 1925, for Improvements in the Art of Preparing Fresh
Fruit for Market. .
2. That said ‘Letters: ‘Patent No. 1,529,461, are, as te said
claims ‘1, 2, 3, 4,5, 6, 7, 9, 14, 15, 16,17, 18, 23, 24, 25 and
26, and each of. them, good and valid in law and that the
title to said inventions and letters patent, including all
claims and demands for infringement of said letters. patent —
is duly, vested in the plaintiff, Brogdex Company,
. That the defendant, Americ an Fruit -Growers, Incor-
porated, has infringed upon claims.1, 2, 3, 4, 5; 6,-7, 9), 14,
{fol. 27] 15, 16, 17 and 18 of said Letters Patent No, 1,529
461, by treating fruit in accordance with the methods dt-
scribed in and secured by the said claims, and each of
them, and also has infringed upon claims 23, 24, 25 and 26°
thereof, and each of them, by making and vending to others
treated fruit embodying the invention dese ‘ribed in and se-
cured by the said claims, and each of thems, -- ,
4. That. the plaimtiff do recover from said defendant,
American Fruit Growers, Incorporated, the profits which
it has derived, received or made by reason of its aforesaid
infringement iipon said claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 14, 15, 16,
17, 18, 23, 24, 25 and 26, and each of —~ of said Letters
Patent No. 1,529,461, and that the plainti® do also recover
from said defendant any and al) damages it has sustained
by reason of said infringemeny the account to be taken and
stated and the damages to be axsexsed by proceedings-ap-———
r pie for such | purpose.
5. That a perpetual injunction isste out of and under
te ‘seal of this Court directed to said defendant, American
Fruit Growers, Incorporated, and its officers, directors,
associates, attorneys, solicitors, clerks, servants, agents °°
‘and workmen, and all claiming or holding under or throwgh
said deferidant, enjoining and restraining them, and each
of them, during the remainder of the term for'whieli said
Letters Patent No. 1,529,461, were orgnay be granted, from
using or practicing any process embodying the invention
described in said letters patent and secured by any of said —
’ elaims 1, 2, 3, 4,5, 6,.7, 9, 14, 15, 16, 17, and 18, thereof, and ©
from the manufacture, sale, or use, in any manner, of
)
,
“<9 ” NE I IO OLE LOI LEAL AE, TES te ¥
treated fruit embodying and containing the ‘itirentiois de-
scribed in said letters patent and secured by any of said
claims 23, 24, 20 and 26 thereof.
‘[fol. 28] 6. That the plaintiff do recover from defendant
‘its taxable costs and disbursements in this Court, and that
the question of ine rease of damages as prayed for-in the
pil of complaint be. reserved -until the. coming in of the
Master’s report.
(Sed.) Hugh M. Morris, United States District Judge.
I~ Unitreo States Districr Court
<SS__AssionMeENT or ¥ffors—Filed October 26, 1927 _
~ Now comes the above-named defendant, American. Fruit
(rowers, Incorporated, by its solicitors, and presents with
its accompanying petition for appeal from the interlocu-
tory degree entered hérein on the twenty-sixth day of Sep-
tember,1927, the following assignment of errors;
The Court was in error:
» 1. In holding that Ernest M. invent and Miles L. Trow-
bridge were the first, original and joint inventors of the
inepatigie described in and particularly recited in claims —
= 5, 6, 7, 9, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 23, 24, 25 and 26 and
each of them, of United States Letters Patent No. 1,529,461
~"Fssued March 10, 1925, for Improvements i in the Art of Pre- .
paring Fresh Fruét for Market.
. In holding that said Letters Patent No. 1,529,461, are
as ra said claims 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 9, 14, 15, 16,17, 18, : 23, 24,
25 and 26, and each of them, good and valid in law and that. .
the title to said inventions and letters patent, including all —
claims and demands for infringement of said letters patent,
is duly vested i in the plaintiff, Brogdex Company.
(fol. 29] 3.-In holding. that the defendant, American Fruit
Growers, Incorporated, has infringed. upen claims 1, 2,-3,
- 4,5, 6, 7, 9, 14, 15, 16, 17 and 18 of said Letters Patent No.
1,529 461, by treating fruit in accordance with the methods
described in and ‘secured. by the 2 claims, and each of .
J them, and also has parge upon claims 23, 24, 25 and 26
me ' +
29
thereof, and each of them, by making and vending to others/
treated frujt embodying the invention described in and see
cured by the said claims, and each of them.
4. In holding tliat the plaintiff recover any profits or:
damages from the defendant afid in ordering an, accounting
on oof a and damages. :
In ordering that a perpetual injunction issue.
In ordering that the plaintiff recover from defendant
any aka and disbursements: - ‘
. In.not ordering the bill of complaint dismissed.
(Sgd.) A. C. Gray, (Sed.) E.. KE. Berl, ‘Solicitors¢for
Defendant-Appellant. . . (Sed.) George E. Middle-
- ton, of Counsel. rae
October 26, 1927.
(fol. 30] In Usrrep States Distyict Court 3
| in Rquity, No. 593
Daiecat ‘Company, Plaintiff,
ef Re : mA BX Ph osinca i
AMERICAN Fruir GnoWens’ InconroraTeD, Defendant ‘
Statement of Evidence © |
Wilmington, Delaware, Monday,
January 31st, 1927, at 11.30 o’clock A. M.
Before Hon. Hugh M-Morris, | . 8S. District Judge
APPEARANCES OF @ouNSEL" . | é
Charles, Neave, Ksq., Melville Church, Esq., Roy F.
Steward, Esq., and William G. Mahaffy, Esq. ‘ Alexander :
C. Neave, Esq., of Counsel for. Plaintiff.
R. T. M. McCready, Esq., W. B. Morton, Esq., George E.
Middleton, Esq., Ward, Gray & Ward, Begs, by E. E. Berl,
Esq., of Counsel for Defendant, |
Be ets aa aes. clan iorah Sects ah ee eee nee ihe ter Se eet a heh ArenaNet, reine wag i PTO NRE
)
*\
[fol. 31 ] PLAINTIFF 's Orexinc STATEMENT
Mr. Neave,\after opening for plaintiff,.proceeds and asks
the Court if if\wants to hear’ from the deféndant’s counsel
before Mr. Neaye begins the: proofs for the plaintiff.
The Court inyuires whether counsel for the -defendant
prefers to state: the issues from his standpoint before the
ease opens or resekve that tntil after the plaintiff closes.
fr. Morton, for the defendant, states that he would
rather reservezit until after the plaintiff closes..
Whereupon, Mr. Neave states that it is agreed that the
plaintiff, the Brogdex Company, is a corporation organized
and existing under the laws of the State of Florida, having
a. regular and established place of business at Winter
Haven, Florida, and a principal plice of business at Los
Angeles, California; that it is agreed that printed Patent
Office ‘copies of specifications and drawings of United
States Patents and photostat copies of foreign patents may
be introduced and shall be received in evidence with the
same. force and effect as, originals or duly certified copies,
as to all facts set forth in those printed ¢opies or photo- _.
_ stats, including- dates of. issuance thereof; and that photo-
stat copies of publications may he introduced ‘and shall be
received in evidence with the same force and effect as the
originals, and that such publications were published on the
respective dates they pear purporting to be the dates of pub-
' lication; all subject: to correction by other proof. °
Mr..Neave offers in evidence a printed Patent Office copy ~
of the patent in suit, being Patent No. 1,529,461. : ‘a
(The same was received:in evidence and marked “Plain- |
tiff’s -Exhibit-No. 1.°’) , |
The plaintiff, by Mr. Neave, then states that it’ relies
upon claims 1 to,7 inclusive ; 9, 14 to'18 inclusive; and 23 to
[fol. 32] 26 inclusive; that it is agreed that the plaintiffs.
now, and-tas beén since the issue of the patent in suit, the
sole owner of said patent and of any and all claims for ~
profits and damages arising out of any and. all ofthe. in-
. fringements thereof; that it is agreed that the attorneys for
~ the plaintiff on April 3, 1926, and again on April 10, 1926, .
~ addressed to the defendant potices of the. plaintiff’s owner-
_ ship of the’ patents and ‘the defendant’s alleged infringe-
z 4 . & .
. ia ai P
—_—_— en
* *s
ment ‘thereof, and that these lette ‘rs were both: received on’
April 13th.
Th Court: asks if. that “is stipulated, aa counsel for dv-
fendant answers in| the affirmative.
Plaintiff ’s Exhibits Nos. 2 through 59 are offered and r Fe-
ceived in evidence subject to the following limitation:
_<
*
Mr. Neave: I assume it to be understood [ am offering
’. this in evidence as showing the information ‘that was (lis- .
seminated in the.art, not as proof of the cor reetness OL the
facts, as. stated here, because many of them are ‘incorre
but as proof of what the art was being tanght in those days.
It was agreed that Plaintiff's Exhibit’ 44 whs reprinted
in The Citrus Industry, published in 1925, and’ that Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 50 was reprinted in The Citrus Industry for .
_— 1925. i |
Plaintiff's Proof Goose, \ : ss .
\
Reaixat v L. K NOX
- Reraiarp. L. Knox, of Dicauons: California, | éalled agal
witness on behalf of the plaintiff, testified as follows:
” Direct - examination :
: I have been connected with the citrus industry since Tees
cember, 1899. At that time I was in the office of the Cali-
fornia Fruit Growers’ Exchange i in ‘Los- Angeles ‘and worked
[fol. 33] up’ through the various departments -and was .
transferred. to San Francisco in 1906, after the fire, where
I was assistant agept until 1908, when I came to Pomdéna in.
the capacity of assistant manager of the San Antonio Fruit
Exchange and in 1917 I became manager of the San An-
tonio Fruit Exchange and that is my present position.
-The San Antonio Friit Exchange i is part of the Califor-
nia Fruit Growers’ Exchange; it is one of the twenty -two
_ district exchanges. The district exchange is: composed of —
. associations in a particular locality and it acts as the sell- .
ing agent of those associations. There are twenty-two of
these districts exchanges and they’ combine to form the
California Fruit Growers’ Exchange, which is the clearing-
house and Provites the > facility through which these twenty-: °
5 c » —
, 30 mispunaice! Sa teen 74 . 7 — . < ‘ 4 ay
‘ >? ° - -
. . . - 5 ~ :
Ui
25
two units’ sell. The growe rs themselves do tot directly -
self their fruity The srower s form the assoc stem and then:
the association picks, paeks -and ships the fruit Nnd then
‘groups of associations aré formed in these localities and —
form the district exchange. Phe San Antonio Fruit Ex-
‘change is one of the district exchanges of the’ California
Fruit Growers. ae
There are sever associatrons ia~our San “Antonio - Kix. ;
change and nine packing houses. The Ater age annual pack
of fruit of our San. Antonio Exchange is about. four Ahous-
“and cars or 1,600,000. boxes, and that would represe nt ahout
§ per cent of the total of the ¢ ‘alifornia Fruit Growers’
Exchange) shipments. This . includes 12f,000 boxes of
lemons afid about 10,000) to 12,000) hexes! of grape fruit.
The balanee is: all oranges. — Our exchange is one ‘of: lie
largest. Tama director of the. ¢ California VE ruit Growers’
Exehange. , re
Prior to, 1925 ther ‘re Was mue ‘ly ‘loss i in the inclirs trv in ge n
eral due to the blue mold decay of fruit, We have esti
tated from time to time.that prior to 1924 the losses would
run from one million dollars *o oro as high as two
[fol. 34] million -dolkars ino a .vear, We have certain
periods of time where the loss will run very heavy WY ei period
where the fruit is shipped immediately after-a Fain or heavy
windstorm, and in those periods we have sometimes as
high as 30 per cent-of the cars showing \yuite heavy deea
Our losses from our actual. records wonld rnin pera
‘thirty to fifty theusand dollars in a week in those periods.
Sometimes ' ‘those periods extend. for ten or twelve weeks.
Those will happen periodically from year to year. In
those: periods the losses were from 50 cents to as high as
a dollar’a box on ev ery box that. shows deeay in the decay
‘ars. These figures include-all kinds of deeav. Most of
- the deeay would-be blue mold ; that i is What is commonly the
cause of the heavy decay. The’ figures I have: given do not
necessarily relate t6 a period prior to 1924. Our heaviest.
losses would’ be. prior-to that time.. :
All but one of our associations use in their packing
houses the borax treatment: under, license from the patent
in suit. * This borax treatment is generally. used in the fol-
lowing manner: The borax is’ put into a large soaking tank
and the fruit immersed i in that solution and f rom there it
‘Prior to * iber. thea’ coef are } j ’
Boy Ostler itm arn ry? wet ? te tT? ern “* 7) Ipe nh . | tle rh an ne
t? Ld ‘ " | M ; ,
careful haricll hiv ryrhel Crre'tr reirys ’ ; » f tat Ti" .
was treeel th t it tty * wield ith « . on cptvest bi} booty, in. don ine the.
: : a . ra .
} Prtit.te the pee Att “ fpertise i! if In wee ry doreeryelieete Cleat ws
could contre! from the tree: te the car! Oerexchartte fur
nishes the pe kin . crew ‘thal o‘atound te iek the Yrspit
‘in practically every instance, “Sometimes the growed huigls
the trot te tHe various’ ex bin rugge’: scwlhieh sen’ thie rach 1
‘houses, but mostly
‘The Lor of
jected to’ in picking if one id not careful are elipper eats, oe
that is, jury ‘Teor The ebip pers, lope ate say aeat + nt the -
box, nails In fe i éking box, anything ef thi it kid etich
will prinetiire, the skin. These careful pie kid and hanching
methods were net successful im preventing deeav, They.
reduced it but did not prey entit./ Y on nnderstane, just to
get that ‘point: clear, wevliave dead brus h in trees ands
picker will serch the orange wi hout any fanit of his, an B
%e r y :
Tbe sen iaatren:
‘is that Tang cess are Jikely to bee sub
— . ‘ ——_ .
baa aad esa at n . ong
. ae °. 8 ie re RMIT P SE hey. aa a
—— . ’
‘
pot grief procect aloie: ial times = ancl f they eed io } calhy
+ ow,
injur the eKits 1% that’ way. “Ti is iN jury lu ie sin Which,
giver the grouble- fe atin se Ne
We bay) bad Reed SUCCESS 1 ith ing deviry by pre-
cucHuy ma rel ripe ration, bul we » have Nways had lu ild-
prqes Uproud ved} ube audi thie iran 2 Weces=it) for:
more aby iakh wit) pheime: aude thuse conditions decuuse here
[fob id ha sielayed’ the slupinent-ol fruit and sunply re-
‘ farded! the secay. and we hac disxuster unless sha Were nol
| ver cate! fy! ae ust. waht reat his. Lt en tithe Mi aut: ol Netriger-
ation jaan a tendeney to decay more fapidly: Prior Xo 1923
we hind weer heard of any succe ssfui method of ¢ anal
‘blue wivld piles thin feducny it by careful operauon
# | wae fagiihat dleo witha so-called Brogdex ¥ Process, \l
Mider ht iro: That ae jaragiin eating of the frmit whicd,
we werd sAperume, linge wath: trom the time Mr. Brogden
cite tof Kis formas - in 22.. dMe itive “stigated in’d oh We
*
.
svacle experi pie tite core thie paraftin Tremtient im 1922 and we |
shia ped: Senumue reiaily, under that proc: ss. Kaeh Sof our
seve esty i On ~ advan vil SOE mone ‘ la he tp de ‘ve f ype thie
proceso Mir: Ii rode mn. We sot wood results from the use
«4
‘er would ry (1° inte ve ry he "AY. \ dee “ay.
ltirst heard of borax sor any. boric he id Kompsindl being - .
sid | in connection with fruits in the f ful} of 1923 from’ Mr,
Brag len and Mr. Brogden’s company.: We used a borax”
ee the. fall of MS in ong pure king house, the Col?
lege Heights Orange & Lemon Association of ¢ ‘laremont, on ;
the last end of our oranie At that time we were trymeg to
that wh were using ethylene gas for bringing out the color:
On di fruit and we got sever re'spotting on tha: partic nar
lot of shipmetit<so that we conld-not s: ay that we got good *
bring oft the-color on the Valencias and it was at thetime ~
/
resitt. from the borax: that. fall. Then the Brogdex. Com-~ 1
pany made" an experimental cilpmant of loose fruit to’
Cle veland (6 show us that the decay or spotting condition
Was notdue to the treatment of the borax but rather to.
he “irexing methods we: were using. This shipment was
returned. from Cle ‘veland imthe same ear and it came hack:
ina ny Rata car and the fruit Was solid and. did not.
have bhie mold decay. ‘That led us to believe that there
[fol. 37] was merit in the“borax so that we went ahead =
use it commercially next year in another house.
*
i
4
a Ox. ke Bisener \ oe . ; Cees ect
This Kussing that | spoke-of Wits used to bring oul the
‘color on the V ale he las after they are turifed green, ie they
are allowed to hang on the-tree during the SUIMMe LanOn this,
we gas the, Valencias to bring out the yellow Coldr,
} In the yearvatier this éxperimentat shipment Lo Cleve-
| aad in 1924, we put the borax process’ into another of Gur
packing hotises, the. \W alnut: Fruit. Growers’ Association.
en operation of the borax treatment attually began in
- that Housé sometime in the varly part of 1924, the installa-
‘tion was made in thet fall of 1925. ‘They went throdgh the -
entire year without refrigeration and with no decay. Their ; .
shipthent ‘as - ree all was about 112,000 boxes. More than ,
~~ 50 per cent. of their “shipments were refrigerated before
“they used this’ Brogdite treatment, xe
The average refrigerating “cost, such as, for shipping
to eastern marketS, Chieago and New York is about 19
scents a box. - Theresare 462. boxes in an orange load. 1.
“believe it would be 462 at that*time in 1924. Ane time we |
“were cherie onc 411. But at that time it would ‘be 462. ;
-
Q. 73. How soon after the borax treatment was installed
—in- your: Walnut House did you get it into other packing
Cie in your exchange? bee oath |
A. The following year because of the. remarkable record
of the season of 1924 at the Walnut House.
@. 744 You have not ‘wot. it in all your: ‘houses. now? -
A. I said all of them. dn. the: following season the Reser-
voir Street Horse of the Pomona Fruit Growers Exchange
_did not ins lit that year because they did not have time'
to put in} he equipment’ before the packing season started.
. They had two packing houses and the West Ontario Citrus
- Association decided not to Use it and| they are not using’ ~
it at this time. a . :
[ fol. 38]. The San. Antonio Kixchange houses that put in
the borax: treatment after the successful use of the horax
cal ‘Walnut found that they reduced their decay very mate-_
Yially and we had a little trouble at the. Indian Hills Citrus
Association the first year we used there -in their Navels,.-
init all of them reduced it v ery, materially. .
Our season begins in the fall of cach year. .We reduced |:
the number of ears we had to refrigerate i in 1924 and 1925
_ by about—in other words, we iced that year about 15 per
t
a
>
cent, of. our shipments: as against the norinal refrigeration
of about 65 to 70 per cent. Our season begins Nov ember 1
- of e ich year and’ ends October 3, vhich makes us name
~ two years ina season. We pick an pack practically all -
the yeal, Ontside of one month, pro ie in our district,
‘may be six weeks in the year, we are}not-packing..- :
* The-Walnut House shipped\in 1925 withouit refrigeration.
. They have shipped for tliree sy ears NOW without refrigera-
. tion. I cannot recall just off hand what was: the amount -
=. of their shipments in the 1924-1925 season, bat it was aro und
112,000 the year prior. On refreshing my recolleciion I
tak say that the total shipments of the San Antonio Ex-
change for that season were $70,691 boxes,. or 2,176 car- —
_loads. I.see that -we experienced - during - the-season of
1924-1925 deeay in ‘less than one per-cent:. of |
-shipped. We made. test shipments Kast, of cars \hipped «
under refrigeration and of ¢ ars shipped under venti lation.
We have'done that for two years now. We found that on
_ direct. shipment . where we processed the fruit and then.
- shipped one car under ventilation‘and one ear under refrig-
‘eration that the fruit’ under ventilation looked as well and
sold: as well as the fruit under refrigeration. ‘The ship- >
tients: were shipped as far as New York. By, process’ I
mean \using this Brogdite process. We then: proved to”
ourselves that you can, ship: just as successfully with: just
[fol..39]-as littledecay under ventilation as uidet refriger-
~ ation. All the purchasers do not. agree with ts.” There is
me prejudice on the part’of the trade’ that ‘has beek built .
up_for. years ‘against ventilated cars’ coming in atenothers .
hegin to refrigerate, atid especially during the wren. sum-
mer weatiier, which i is, the cause really of our not shipping
entirely under ventilation all of the processed frnit.
Valenciiis and Naveéls . fare different kinds: of oranges
growii in the ‘same Joeality, ‘the. Navels of course, in our
district: come’ in\from January to the first or middle é6f”
May ‘and then they are immediately followed by the Valen--,
cla shipments the: rest of the season. I have spoken of
‘gassing Valencias. .Navels are not usually gassed but in
certain districts like Tulare, .they gas the early Navels, to.
bring out the’color. . ‘ SP ee
: élse the pre- -cooling of fruit, which is simply ‘a refrigera-
\ ,
he ears.
Neg ts eA
’ ° -
ae ° - rt
A
‘
°.
In our district we have} developed, more than any one v
, 30.
tion b> do air circulated over the fruits. We store the
fruit in large rooms and then play the cool air over them,
That enables us to store jarga quantities of fruit/and hold
the fruit for more favorable markets. That is the reason
for our holding fruit at all, to tide over a glutted market .
or too heavy shipments and régulate ouf\distribution in
that way. Before we used the Brogdite, which is the borax
process, we ,held fruit in this way. We could hold the .
. fruit not ovgr twelve days or two weeks commereially, We
have held the fruit anywhere from 30 to as high ay 67 days
commercially, since we have been using the Brogdex Com-
pan’ process, and‘then shipped without decay. In 1924
and 1925 when our oranges were in condition that we
thought ought to come off the trees, we kept in-our pre-
coolers and then we shipped the provessed shipmeyts up
the Coast -by steamer to Seattle and Vancouver ‘under ven-
tilation, but-the shipment is hard on the fruit under ventila-
(fol. 40} tion, and even after the frit had been held that
length of time we had no complaints. We had never been.
- able to do hat to the same extent before we ‘used the Brog- |
ss. We had shipped bw steamer and had suffered
ecay by steamer anipmente, even when we did not
ie fruit. ,
ve previously said that while i in 1924 we got the borax
tment going in all the San Antonio exchange houses,
: treatment the following years and they used it in the
season of 1925- 1926. They are still ysing it. The Park
lite treatment, and the Sebes oir mg was not, the
Avenue honsé practically eliminated rei rigeratipnt,
and went through the season withont any decay ; while the
Resprvoif Street house, the refrigerated fruit, quite a_per-
centage, as I recall, about 70 per cent. of thebs fruit, did
‘not have as good a decay. record as the Park AVenue house,
which was the reason for the subsequent installation in the
Reservoir Street house. When I say that the-Park Ave-
>
' +h
: 9 etm sen h. peewee tied aid *. ~~ "Orr +8 ~ emg ote yar 7
teference to the Reservoir Street hopse and the other ;
~
31°
} . 7] ae ed °
nye house went through the season without any decay, I
do not mean that literally we got the f ruit through without .
any decay at all. I mean commercial decay, which would be
_to es When there is less than three per cent.
we ¢all it
ease. . 4
‘In the season of 1925-1926, when both the Park Avenue
house and the Reservoir Street house Were using the Brog-
dite Brogdex system, the record of decay of the Reservoir
Street-houise was better than the Park Avenue house, and
we were interested in that direct comparison, because -the
fruit was being picked by the same picking gangs in both
[fol. 41] houses, and packed under the same management, |
so that it was the best comparisan, we have, and we made
up a better record for the Reservoir Street house that year,
because it draws its fruit from the easfgrn section of our
actically sound. It sells in practically evéry
district where the fruit is a little hardierYhan tle western
section, which would show that under the treatment the
weaker fruit in 1924-1925 was benefited # the extent that-it
showed a better result than the hatdier fruit, and then
when the borax'treatment was put into the Reservoir Street
* house, the normal condition of less decay at the Reservoir
Street house prevailed again: I meon by ‘*weak fruit,’’ a
fruit that would be inclined to mature earlier than the fruit
from the eastern) section of our district where the soil gon-
ditions are different. That is not.the ordinary. meaning of .
the term ‘‘ weak’! because you can use weak fruit or poorly.
_ handled fruit, for some condition that applied in mechanical
handling; but I was speaking of weaker fruif*in this con- -
nection from soil or climatic conditions,
The extent to which /a certain percentage of decay in a
ear of fruit affects th¢ amount obtained from the fruit de-.
pends on the markef. If you have a strong markét, we
would allow, possibl¢ less than 5 per cent,, and say 3 per -
cent. was Go merciatly sound, and allow the excess over
3 pér cent. but on a declining market, or a glutted market,
we would, I take it, allow the 5 per cent., hut possibly more,
in order to sell the car. <1 should say our discount would be
fully 5 per cent., and possibly more-on the average. We
have made gains this past year from 25 cents to a dollar
a box on the niarket,through our ability to hold fruit longer .
in the prefeooler, due to the borax.
. 7 . .
= -
» woerng: lo te ve = +. ~~
t , F
a2 . ; : °
So far I have been talking more particulatly about”
oranges. Our exchange has had experience with the treat-
ment of lemons by this Brdgdex Company process. At our
lerhon house. we asked the Brogdex Company to make an
| fol. 42] installation there in the season 1924-1925, and have
treated the fruit in that house from that time on. Lemons —
are handled somewhat differently from oranges. They are
picked all the time; every month of thesyear, but we store
| lemons; that is, store them without refrigération as used *
in oranges to cure them. Lemons are picked hard and
green, if we can get them in that stage, while oranges are
picked ripe. These hardened green lemons are stored in the
basément in sonie place and allowed to cure. We will hold -
them sometimes over two months; thats, two months; it.
may be two and a half months in extreme cases. In this
period, during this curing process, some decay goes on.
By using the Brégdex-borax process we have reduced our
storage*decay very materially, bringing it-down to prac «
‘tically nothing. The’decay thaf gets on lemons is a blue,
and green mold decay. We eall blue and green mold all
the same thing: commercialy. There are other forms of
decay, but that is the most common. Before we store our |
Yemons for two months’ curing we_treat them with the
borax solution. We do not treat them with paraffin. .
We have always shipped to foreign countries, but we
have been able to ship more successfully under the borax
y+ treatment than before, and the requests come in for fruit
“treated with’ borax; that ‘is, regardless of whether it is
‘Mreated with the Brogdite or the Governmert formula.
Fruit treated by the **Government formula’ is called by
the Exchange ‘‘borated’’; that is the term we apply to fruit - |
‘treated under that process, and it is the same practically
as the Brogdite. Vattous associations or exchanges that —
are a part of the California*¥¥uit Growers: Exchange use |
!
this borax ‘treatment, so-called. Our San Antonio Ex-
change is the only one of the oe exchange of the Fruit *
Growers Exchange that uses rogdite process under
license outside of one other house that I understand is
licensed. :
[fol. 48] Q. 138. And of all the other exchanges and as-
sociations, the. California Frnit Growers Exchange uses
this borated stuff, or this borax?
ont ee peter rpe meg a ee ~* ee wie
A. Not under license—all that use borax, yes. oe
Q. 139. And how many use borax? Te |
+ A, I could not say in numbers, but the majority use the
- borated. treatment. i :
tis We were familiar With the work done by Mr. Powell and
, other experts of the United States Department of Agricul-
ture, in trying to eliminate blue mold decay losses. We.
were very much interested at the time he was making those
tests. I kifew Mr. Powell.’ Those were handling and ship-
‘ping tests which would demonstrate to us the necessity for _
eareful handling in comparison with rough and careless
handling. ras se ; ;
One of the publications which was’ put in evidence this
morning contains an artiele by R. L. Willits, of Corona. I -
have known him since 1916. In 1916 he, was-connected with
"the A: F. Call Estate Packing House. He is still connected
with that house as manager, and he has been the manager)
of that Kouse since 1913, as I understand. He is one of niy
‘¢o-directors in the California Fruit Growers Exchange.
°
‘There was _a_s0-called Borax Committee appointed by the 3
California Fruit Growers Exchange.. Mr. Willits was
| chairman: of that committee. Mr. E. G. Dezell is the gen-
° eral manager of the California Fruit Growers Exchange
and-he was in 1924. | : } oe
The function of the California Fruit Growers’ Exchange
is to attend to the marketing and to assist the various pack- .
_ ers and growers in the best way of, handling fruit, by way of
giving information to them. It does everything of that
kind, even to advising. them as to what methods to use in
controlling insects, or-in the handling of fruit, anything of.
that kind that affects the industry ‘as a whole. The ‘way’
that is done by the California Fruit Growers Exchange is by
(fol. 44] circularizing all.the associations, and by keeping:
them constantly informed of everything. (Witness is
handed a paper.) “ This is a circular addressed to all ship- \
pers by Mr. Dezell on the borax treatment, control of blue ~
mold decay by the horax treatment. We received this cir-
cular and it is the kind of thing that comes to out éxchange
house regularly. _ The information that was in hi cireu-
lar-came to us and to others in this California Fruit Grow-
3—48
|
| Lg Fo
. ' s ‘ ! ;
;
. ° : 2 » . 5
ey | 2
: -
‘ °
‘ers Association at that time, and was generally dissemi-
nated to évery shipper. (Circular offered and received in-
evidénce and marked ‘*Plaintiff’s Exhibit. No. 60.7’)
*
Crégs- egemination: , ne tt
\eccnem
I found out about the sian in our, fruit by. tlie inspec-
tion reports from our agents. Our) inspectors are in the
Kast, or wherever the markets are, and they report back
to us the percentage of decay. They would report 1 pér
cent. or even the decayed orange in the box that they in-
spect. They do not inspect all, the oranges. ’: They simply
- inspect say from six to-ten boxes in a car from different
‘parts of the car, more if the car shows decay, and less. if
‘the car is sound, on inspection of a few boxes.
The Brogdite is the borax treatnient. The Brogdex we
consider’ the application of the paraffin to the fruit after
it has gone through the other process. The Brogdex treat- -
ment was put ont first.. The Brogdex treatment was simply
the paraffin coating on the fruit, the one. application or the
one. process. We first became ‘interested in the Brogdex .
treatment in the fall of 1921. We had our association di-
rectors and managers look into that Brogdex treatment.
' J did not say that a number of our association people
had invested in the Brogdex Company. - We.had advanced
money to Mr. Brogden; | thik then it was the Brogden,
Taworth & Ricketts Company. Wehidvanced on machinery /
[fol. 45] installations, because, as We understood it then, °
' they were in need of ftinds.to make that development, and /
we.were Willing to go that far’ in helping ‘develop what we;
thought then was an experimental process, but no invest-,
ear he all of any kind. I am not a stockholder in th
plaintiff company , here.’
~ Claims were made for this Brogdex treatment w hen it was
‘first put out, before the Brogdite was added, that it would
stop blue mold decay.’ eee
X Q. 170. Very> extravagant elaims were made for ithe
benefit of this Brogdex treatment, were there not? ;
A. Well, you might call them axtrav agant claims, but I
thirk at that time Mr.. Brogden had the idea the Brdgdex
treatment, would. eliminate refrigeration or tlie negessity
‘for it. Some people eall that “extravagant.” }
. }
}
~ not? |
-represented to me to be serve
pe teh eV lee :, $6
“xe. 171. It was claimed it would eliminate decay, just
like you now:claim thé Brogdite eliminates decay, was it -
A. Yes. Sere |
But the Brogdex treatment was
nating decay. As I say, ye woulgl have success, or what:
we thought was success, over aperiod, and then run into_
yery heavy decay. We were thén. trying to ship certain
jots under ventilation, but the Br gdex could not do it alone.
No representation was made fo us as|to what it was as
far as the ingredients. It was simply understood ,by us —
that it was a paradgfin ‘Bratt I do not remember that ..
ot Lndneiatil in elimi- ° .
it was claimed that the Brogdex treatment alone was a com-
bination. of thirteen chemicals and materials. “There was
that is-all that we knew, so far as'the ingredients were con- ’
cerned. The original promoter -of' the.
‘some oil in it, as we understood, to ine the wax, but
Brogdex treatment
‘was Brogden, Ricketts & Haworth: ~They formed the com-
pany we dealt with originally: |
|
[fol. 46] My attention is called'to a eircular issued appar- "+:
ently by that company. I do not remember this circular.
I think that possibly it was gotten. out in Florida, from the
letterhead. I see it mentions a small paper box method of
- distributing the fruit. I never saw a scheme of that kind. _
“I do not recall this_circular_at-all.-Lhis-cireular-enumer>——~
renee DRT a
ates some ten advantages, and states*the conibination of
thirteen chemicals and materials designbd for the following
purposes. I will state which [of tose ten purposes were
b
36 - | Loy
--never any extravagant claims made, but simply the. discus-
sions as to what the process could: do, and we then jgave
“our opinion as' to what we thought “could be-done if it worked.
out as he thought, to eliminate the necessity for i icing and
« yefrigeration, and the use of cold storage at the receiving
“end; ‘‘increase the keeping facilities so as to do away. with
the necessity: of keeping fruit in temporary market condi-
tions;’’ and that is true owing to the present development,
to enable dealers to handle citrus fruits who did not handle
’ . them because of cold storage. He made such a statement;
and ‘‘to enable the small paper. box method to be used to
[fol. 47] distribute through to the consumer in ‘chain
. stores.’’ I never heard that statement. It further says—. -
.“*to increase the polish. and cleanliness, making the fruit
more attractive.’’ That’ would be the natural conse-
quences; ‘‘to do away with -the necessity of having fruit ‘
with excessive bulge, and the attendant damage to the fruit, .
resulting from the crushing force applied to ‘the box.’*' A
similar ‘claint was made and. that is true under the wax
treatment.’ A box of Brogdexed fruit leaving the ‘packing
lionse should -reach the market: with more bulge and. be a
fuller box than un-Brogdexed fruit leavi ing a packing house
with twice the bulge. "That might be an exaggeration, but
. that claim has heen proven out to some extent, thus increas-. . ’
ing the volume of the number of: boxes. ‘This -applies-te——
Florida fruit to be sent by ordinary ventilated tramp steam- © .
-ersto domestic and: European ports. That.claim was never ©
‘made to us, buf we have done it, not with the Brogdex alone -
“but under the present treatment. I would not call those
‘extravagant claims, if they were made with the knowledge .. -
‘on the part of the shipper, that it was an experiment, eek
we understood the whole thing was.
_ These claims as acts were not justified. by the Brogdex.
treatment alone.| I do not remember that it was ¢laimed’
for the Brogdex .alone, that it made an air-tight ¢overing -
on the fruit; and in that way prevented decay. -I do remem-
ber talking to the Pathologist at the Riverside = yeriment, |
Station as to that, and he claimed any sealingof ithe fruit. °.
* entirely would he‘ wnsound, -hecause of the neckssity for .
__ freeing the gases. + remember—that-in our experiments *
» where we treated the fruit with thé wax by hand we got.
» “@ : too heavy a coating and that the fruit went down. By
, , o
ae |
je Z -
° " , ,
“~~
37:
“went down’? I mean de cayed, rotted there tiahiie. spoiled
in its flavor. Our managers all knew from the start. that
‘too heavy an application, or a sealing entirely of the fruit
- ‘[fol. 48] cells or pores would injure: ‘the fruit. We under-—
- stood that condition to apply. I understood the Brogdex
treatment to be a sealing of the fruit, but not an entire
sealing of the fruit. Mr. Br rogden, as I recall, claimed it
breathed through the stem. . He always, claimed it had a
method of breathing or livi ing. I cannot say what his idea.
oe -
We have nine packing aki in: our district, Tn my
direct examination I described the Brogdite process as in--
stalled in one of our houses. The Brogdite treatment is
“applied in that house in the following manner: We have
large soaking tank filled with water in which is placed
Ris borax;. and the fruit is submerged in that, and then i 1s
earried on ‘a conveyor to the. brushes, that is a roller con-.
veyor, elevator, rather, two- cylinder brushes - where it is:
scrubbed on-those br ushes with the-spray, -with -the borax
| © solution on it, and then from that it is low ered with what.
they calta bull wheel to another. immersion or bath of borax
‘ “where it is the same as the water ini the soaking tank, and
\ is then from that taken on a belt or.one tier as you might ©
* eall it, and pure water is spray ed on it, to rinse eff the ex-
cess borax, and from that it is carried to the driers and
through the regular packing house machinery, until it) gets
‘to the wax application, which in turn is sprayed on from
atomizers and run over brushes, to clean the fruit and get
the excess wax off. - eas
The Brogdite process does not include the paraffin.
There are two steps. The Brogdex which includeq paraffin
alone came out first: In -deseribing the Brogdite*process
alone I should have stopped on the berax.’ We still use the
Brogdex treatment. _We-use both the borax and the Brog- .
~ dex, which would he the application of paraffin to the fruit.’
CMe We call the Brogdex system the combined treatment some- .
"| times. Poe e
ie understand. that in Flor ida paraffin lias. eas applied to
_ fruit for a Jone time for such purposes _as_ polishing the
; [fol. 49] fruit. I hail nevé ‘y known the use of paraffin as an »
: actual. commercial - process in’California. TI suppose the,’
‘Parker: Polisher did originate in California, if if was named
Parker, because she is a. machinery 1 a ee
e.
y.4 mg ee 2 arnt ‘ ode.
os.”
. - be — A
op svar Re nee UpE One: RAEN ELL SE LIRA RY ONES ILA II, VCS LIS OR REBT sg
The firures whic WA gi ve as to the Yee ‘ity stim: es, were
not taken from machine decay’ ‘records vf our houses. We.
cept as close tab ws ‘we could on our decay records, because.
we were in those years experimenting, and trim: to satisfy.
ourselves that we had ¢ ot a benefit frdm these processes,
so that in.that stateme nt | made, ‘T suppose you refer to the sR
statement as. to. oug hbusess? which was- an-actual record. |
The loss for the year on'decay would: ine. to be ‘an estimate |
‘taken from the records, but that i is ‘impossible to arrive at
unless you take eacli-particular car, or arrive vat it aveu-
rately, but it would be a conservative «stim: oS -The per:
centages of the ease Which B ' wave were taken from fhe
records. . Our Joss resulting: therefrom was simply my esti- ,
mate but that estimate was based ou the losses from actual
records. ‘* *
- ‘Fhe West GRario Citrus’ Association . of Wardd,. -one of
the houses in our- -exchange, did not use the Brogdex Sys-
tem. ~ Their figures-or decay last year would show a greater
percentage. of. cars decayed than, I \would say, practically
all our other houses; but I couldn’t give you that. “In going
over the. decay record I understand that is—whether I have
that with me~or not, the decay records.ef the California’
' Fruit: Growers \Exchange—that decay recotd would show °°
Bey. have had a higher percentage of cars showing decay @
an most of our other houses. That is from the actual
records, but I could not give ypu the percentage.
I can not givé off hand the record for decay: for 1924-1925
for the California Exchange; 1924-1925 was: the frost year.
The. Califdrnia Exchange keeps: its’ record on~percentage .-
’ [fol. 50] of cars that show decay, not on the percentage of
actual: ‘decay. The figure ~we have is the percentage of cars
which show any decay regardless of amount. . I think I have-
this: figure for .the seasons of 1924-1925. and 1925- 1926.
(The witness is asked to get those figures.) . The season, —
as I explained, is from November 1st to October 31st,.and —
we call that season. of 1925-1926, including the two years
but one season. In-1925- 1926 the season was over Novem-
ber 31st. {
‘ Pre-cooling is the pahoone we use in California i in refrig:
: erating fruit by the circujation of cold. air over the.fruit;
_ what we call a dry air circulation, and that afr is brought
down to the. temperature we want the room or the. fruit 3 :
~~
je
a od
brought downto. T hat practice is not: mer °” for the pur-
pose of storage but we pre-coot before’shippin. Originally
it was a combination ‘of refrigeration plus sturage,. but not
‘for holding purposes. We felt it was better refrigeration. |
‘. © When we ‘pre-cool the.fruit, which is done before the fruit: ;
eo loaded.in the ear, in addition we ice the car prior to load-
ing the fruit into the cag. - We do not ice in transit, that -
unless the car has been held out an unusual length of
i ne, W e place the ice in solid blocks in the car and then ~
that car is supposed to go: througli to destination without -
: ‘ever touching it,. because the fruit is brought down to say
32 or 34 degrees and xcts as refrigeration, ‘The purpose.
of pre-¢ooling. is primarily to get better refrigeration. . We~
take the.boxes as a.unit instead of the car and getting it
under refrigeration that much quicker. You see the minute
. abox is packed, if goes down by a “conveyor into th the pre-
- \eooling room where it i ‘immediately under refrigeration ;.
| but primarily we took it for: better refr igeration. There is
no question about its. effectiv xa | for that purpose:
(fol. 51] =X (221. Do. you use pre-coolitig’ refrigeration’
merely\‘to check decay or is it used also to” prom re the
freshness of the fruit? .. ee Pe eres
A. For both. ... - ace pee Gas
XQ. 222. And even if the fFuit aid not decay! you woele:
‘Want to eool it or refrigerate it. fo. aie prt: fresh until it
~ reached the market, # that right?
A. Yes, that is true, except.as I. ated that inwictnmeata:
we have made—-and may I answer that so you, will under-
stand it. That is, go into this.part of it? | |
—-aX Q. 223. I hope so. |. ”. > Canale? Eee
- ~-
/
i.
A>The experiments that\we have made have convinced -
is that with the “wax treatment we can do away with at’,
least’a great part of our-refrigeration, beeause'it, does pre-
serve the freshness of the fruit; but you “understand under
certain market conditions and under certain maturity con-
ditions and with the trade prejudiced against the ventilated
cars, because of the fact that they had been: refrigerated _
Leman years, - that we-can“not afford to take d large block of
.
market conditions: and not Tefrigetate. _— where fruit is |
<f &
soaks. ee lh aa wont oy . 99 - — ~—f
fruit and go against ‘the prejudice or go against’ certain | ; . i
California to. New York, we can 0 just-as well under ven-
tilation. I am conyinced of, that.’
“When. we ship, under ventilation, we do not chill { tlie ear.
before it starts. You see, iftw
cooler. and hold it there ‘eth of time, we would prefer .
to refrigerate because of the fact that we have found that —
~ thére-is a. certain weakening effect t6 that refriger ‘ation, ,
and yet under the pre- -cooling, witli this dry % ur cir culation,
as against storage, there is. not the deterioration in that
fruit as there would -be_ynder certaii other conditions, as:
there would be in refrigeration, so that’ we haye gone as
long as sixty-seven days in thé pre-cooler and then shipped *
the fruit under ventilation East with no bad results at all.
‘ Ffol. 52] And in that case we chill the fruit. but that - is sim-
ply an exception. If we shipped uuder ventilation, nor-
mally we would take it right off the floor and ship it in the
‘car. ea .
The method of .shipmeat asf upon the Ristusity of
the fruit. We. ventilate the cars now whe rite. eastern
_territory is down to zero. If our Navels are matured the
first;of Mareh we -w ould start’ to refrifer ‘ate. We would
‘not treat the fruit. If is not then a ease of weathemcondi-
tions: but a ease of “the ‘maturity of the fruit; but in the -
greater part of the season, of course, the Weather is warm
“in the Bast and: we have to refrigerate on that account. Re-
“membering that the temperature. in ‘Califprnia «is much. ,
-warmer even than the eastern ‘temper ratug ‘crossing the
desert, so that we have to take into conside ation the ‘tem:
- perature there as well.as here. We hav e to consider the
. temperature the whole length of the journey and the ma-
turity of the fruit in determining how we are going fo ship, :
IT think I have read Dr. Powell’s bulletin, No. 123, on
careful handling. It was one of the. bulletins introduced —
by plainttff’ s counsel this morning. t could not identify it,’
‘but IT am sure I. have read evety bulletin of Dr. Powell’ s
issued i in. California. T'eain not recall just what it.savs, but
T would say that I have read every Dulletin of Mr. Powell’s.
beeausé that'is a part-of our work, to. keep up on. those
things. Dr. Powell’s’ writings on this subject are. consid-’
ered: authentic and truthfally ropresditt the conditions that
@ \
| \
Hit our fruit into the pre- |
sold quickly and‘shipped direct to eerfain markets, like.
i
~
4
&,
Y
maaan ‘he purports. to dedortbe, We consider ‘ed lim as an expert:
oSson that, line from his training so that. where he ‘deseribes
“4” existing conditions, in C ies a J would concede that that “s
was a correct description. aN} ae
_” J first Heard that the. Br dee process: consisted of a bo-.
rax treatment, F believe, some time in 1924. It was in the
-fall-of 1923 that we. haifa le
; (fol#53] name of Brogdex, \No disclosure. was thade -of
| what it consisted of, that is, not to my knowledge, not. tor :
Le my recolléction, anyway.) Ne | RS
“<} s§ When we hold fruit storage, Yhatz 4S; "woh taraze: in.
“our preécoolers, we call. ‘Ahem, there is-a ‘refrigerant used
all the time. for circulating cool air-over the fruit. The air:
is circulated over ammonia pipes, and ind the’ fruit. Tt
“is. a method ‘of cold’ ‘storage.
| hetvé seen the’ patent ‘in suit but 1 do- nad kiiow when.
it was issued. (Leis told by counsel that it was ‘issued on
Mareh 10, 1925.) T first learned that. the-Brogdite treat-"
ment consisted vl ‘dipping the fruit in bor ax before that ‘datogge
bute] could not_say. whether: T heard it from the Brogdite
people or from our ow a people. They were making tests
aN then: of the solution,.«or an analysis of the solution; so that
we knew pretty well. what wa as init." i would say that from
the Exghange’s or from our ‘association men, not from.my ~ *
own tesfs or analysis. ae 5 eg ee
Kaen “Redirect examination : ” we ; are
: ay f : “te, is : : .
I: S ee of ae ree money to’ Mr. 3rogden in connec- ¥
|
tion with tlie Brogdite system. »We got that money back.
«- When the machiier y was installed in the houses. 1 think a
sh refund or that allowane eof -that install: tron! was made. by
the Brogdex. [have no: financial interest of aw kind inthe
~ phaintiff -ompany. We liave no interést: in ‘the cuteome
-of this suit except that.we have felt right along that’ the
ee) “dscovery was of such importance to. the industry that the”
ones who developed it ere entitled to: consideration. That --
. is the feeling of our board of dire:tors. '1 came East for the
. purpese of. testifying . in this ease. Lam heing paid my ex-.
_"penses ;, my travelling expenses and nothing else, Our di-
_reetors w ere willing that we should come East to testify for.
, the reason. af have already stated. =
.
Tt was used then justin the)
+ /
[fol. 54). James*‘Worstencnorr - - >
= James Woisrencrorr, of Walnut, California, called @s a
witwess on behalf of the plaintiff, and having been first duly.
sworn, testified as fellows:
ese . Direet. examination : s-
; I am secretary and manager of the Walnut F ruit: Grow- .
; s ° ers Associition which is a part of the San Antonio Fruit —
= 4 -Lhave tachahout-trenty-one crience .
; - an the citrus. fruit iralustry. | vuiiaieaanls asa laborer in
\ q the houses in.1905, with the Park Avenue house, Pomona.
! Later, L'was made foreman of ‘the Indian Jhilh Packing
- - -]louse at North Pomona and I.was foréman of the Zanta
2.
Packing House, and F eame back’and was made foreman of
+. ~~ the-Pomena-House and 1 have been with the Walnut-™ruit
-j _ Growers Association, secretary, and manager, since. 1915,
The average year lv shipments of the Walnut iF ruit Associa
ation up to date is about 300 éars. | This year we expect
to ship about 450. “There are ahout 400 boxes to.a car.
We do not handle lemons; we handle oranges and grape-
fruit. Most of the shipments are oranges. ;
During my experience in the fruit business, J have kept
in close touch with fhe developments of the industry and
the various methods of treating fruit used by other houses
fdr that is part of my-business. -We have alw ays had to
contend .with blue mold deeay. .
I have come in contact with G. Harold Powell... When
came to make his experimeéenfs on fruit and T was assigned
‘to help him with the fruit. -When T say ‘help him,’’ I mean
T was just 2 lalygwer in the house and | had to get fruit for
at thattime with the Department ofAgriculture. 1 saw
him in subseqi vears. After that he was general man-
[fol. 55] ager ef the ifornia Fruit Growers Exchange.
Pow éll’s report? which are published in the Government ’s
‘Bulletin No. 123, which Mr. Morton, counsel for defendant,
referred to. We read all those reports, that came to us in
the matter of business and were brought to us; we would
read them. Mr. Poyell in that hameises and others, recom-
Ts.
and help him stack it and such-like. Ie was connected -
I knéw him-til*he died a few years ago. I liave.read Mr.
l was ‘working’ at tlie Pomona Packing House Mr. Powell .
\-
mends for controlling decay careful handling and the usesof
ice to retard the development of decay. While | was work-
ing With Mr.-Powell, or during any other time, he did. not
recommend {to me any other means of preventive dechy
than careful handling and of course refrigeration as-a aid
** to it. *
I first heard of the Brogdite. process in 1922 3, in the lat
ter part of the vear. I first heard oftfrom My. Brogden
_* _jn connection with some experimonts ho war-trrine 3¢ the
s
College Heights: Citrus Association; At the. W. aljnt.As-
sociation they had installed the: Brogden treatment, that
is, the paraffin treatment, prior to that time. The-B srogdite -
<or borax treatment was put in to the’ Walnut Association
-jn-1923-1924. They camu enced installing machinery about
“thie latter part of 1923, and we commented st py Ta
_ the Brogdite and the paraffin system in about {
ie first- week
in January of 1924. I did not know at that time what was
in the solution. -l found out, | should imagine, in about
iwo or three months. 1 know Mr. Brogden told me at the;
time that if I knew what was in.it I-would laugh, it was! *
so simple. I found borax was in it. - : i
The stréngth of borax solution used at the’ W Saunt Asi: ;
sociation varies. ‘We have a regular schedule that isused
by the Brogdex Company and that is put up for the oper-
ator-to work accordingly by.. It is on.the pereentage, T
should say, from six to eight. I would not’ be exact. “Tt runs
about ten pounds to: the gallon, I think. ° ‘The reason for
tabulations of any kind is that there are different temper-
atures of water. The strength solution which we used dur-
(fol. 56] ing our use was about six to eight... I would not be
exaet; it is somewhere around that. : G
I will describe just now, without going inte the minutest
details, but: just generally; ‘how this borax solution is used:
at the Walnut Association. The borax comes-in sacks to
our ‘operator. takes that. and puts it in—we have a large
soaking or dumping tank < probably about eighteen to twenty
feet long, and he mixes this borax in the water until -he
gets the required solution, then the oranges are dumped
into that and there is a great big long submerger—paddles
7 that: come over and they take all the oranges underneath
| 80 that there is no question but what sy orange is sub-
‘ * ’ b>. . ° ~
the packing house furnished by the Brogdex people and —
e
a
| By i
me rged.. From uy ‘re they go to the washer wii re they are
i sprayed by the.s Ame solution.< They come back -wider the
~ washer in the sine solution*egain. From there they go
-under a spray of lear water; from there they go into the:
drier. The drier goes the length of the packing house, It
comes back and. from there. they go into, the: Brogdexer,
» | + which is‘tlie paraffin, that we put, on, and from there they-
. ' go to-the graders. — - .
| .,. When we first began to use this borax, we made. quite a
EES lot -of tests of the-treatment. ‘Phey-consisted of. tests of
1 fruit ‘injured, fruit not injured, fruit inoculated, for blue *
| -mold. 1 might say that those tests were all put up by -
.
.“ ‘and under the supervision of the field department of the ( Cal:
\ fornia ‘Fruit Growers’ Kxchange;. Mr.. Ramsey and, Mr,
“Nelson; -—-Mr. Nelson particularly conducted the experi--
ments... -E>was present: during the conducting of these ex-
perinverts and took partanr-them—Fheyvere comductedt al
the Walnut Packing ‘House. Mr. Nelson was it charge of
» the experiments and we gave him all the assistance possi--
ble. Mr. Barger came in dyri ing ‘a time; he was there some
‘of the time. We hada tremendous amount of people there
at the time. ‘ These jexperiments were conducted in Janu-
-[fol. 57]. ary and February, 1924. The .Field Department
kept records of these tests. (Witness ghown a report.)
T snseeh is a oo of Lu tests i Was : speaking of. event
. e e -
inane saionss Sata eT! 9-9,
those | headed, “Tests 9 to 2? aanttlen fro i tip W aheat
House. Thest tests go on to the other numbered tests also.
The other tests-referred to in this repott | am familiar with ;.
also;'the tests of, the other houses, ~Rediands Gold Buekle
Association.. They were also magle by. ourshouse fromm fruit .
gotten from those other houses and made in conjunction
with our own fruit. -d think in the report it gives, some
Tulare County tests. Of:course, we were not familiar with
those. ° Tho&8e were conducted.tp in Tulare County.; All
‘we got were the reports from the Field Department. : (The
report ‘is offered and received in evidence. and marked.
-Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 61.’’) - With reference to these
tests of which T have been speaking, there were some of.
« the Brogdex- people there at that time, that is, from. the
Brogdex Company in | California, ‘When I speak of ‘the. *
os *
Bain} pi reer tah bees
| Brogdex Company T mean the Siiied als-of the Brogdex Com-
pany.. Mr. 3rogden himself was present ‘at these tests}
“Mr. Barke was there, and the presidént. of the conipany was
in once. or tw ice, Mr. Wallace. ‘Lhere were quite | a few of
them. “There w as nothing kept seeret as to the materials
being used, We had all kinds of people come in.” Asa
matter of fact, we had some people ¢ take away a. era a
i the powder that Mr. Brogden put into. thé water to test
. Mr. Willits, of Corona,-was one of them. eo :
"We get the reports from the California Exchar ee that
. show the.shipments, the arrivals. and the ‘condition and the |
4 sales of the fruit, which give us.a thorough understanding ape
«. of the general condition of the fruit throughout the coun->
. try. These reports are sent to us every day. Kvery pack-
ing housé manager. gets them, every shipper: gets them.
There is quite a difference in these reports.__F'rom_ certain —.. ats
~ --ffok 58) districts fruit is weaker; there may be heavier
— » - soil; we may have had quite.a little of rain, foggy: condi-
tions will weaken the fruit and naturally will cause more
decay... ° aes \
Prior to using the borax treatment at the W alnut House .
probably 80 to 90 per cent, I w ould i imagine, of our fruit
- would go under refrigeration. Since the Brogdite system
- has been used we haven’t used a pound of ice. 1924:25 was
the first year we put_the process beand- we-shipped-unc sic OS
standard ventilation and have been ever since, .
: We have found the carrying: qualities of the fr uiit under
‘standard ventilation to be very Satisfactory. Our decay.
for the first year’was about half of one ‘per cents the see-
~ond year about two-fifths of one per cent., and last year.
one-per cent. Now, when I speak-of that, if I may explain
that, Mr. Neave, when I say ‘‘per cent.;’? we get a Teport
from our inspectors in the Mast and Siey specify on that
report how many boxes of orangés they have examined and
‘whether they found any. ‘deeayed and they specify the num-
| her of oranges decayed, and these figures that I am giving
. you are the-summary— x: total of, the amounts of oranges
; that they examined, with the amount of decay they found in
: those boxes, ; That is ‘the average for the season. This
.. pereentige js. not the percentage of the cars shipped that
Show ed the decay, nt the pereentage of the oynges exam-
* Se \ : “ ; 2 sor
+”. jined that showed decam. So; if I say one per cent., I mean
‘2 fof the oranges‘examined they found one ‘orange’ out of gne
hundred that shoved decay
ee A’ fair’estimate of, pefriger ating costs in 1 shipping roi’) iF
. . |California to New York” is $80 to $90 a cay.’ WL’. our? +
: | shipments of fruit show, for instance, 5-per cent decay, 2
there are losses-other ‘than the loss of that: amount of fruit. oe
‘from'deeay. “There is a ‘financial loss. “The financial los:
; amounts sometimes to a good deal mbrethan 5 per ce of Bh
the value of a sound car, particularly if the market is ww cbt.
[fol.59] There are other 8 savings effected through the use
of: the Brogdite treatment as we have’ used it; there are
quite a few, both definite and indefinite. For instance,. =
| there; is an actual ‘saving on ice in a @ar which w ould: prob
| ably pmount in-our case fo $60 46 $70 acar. .That is after’:
papi f for the cost of \wAeaar and outfit. Thien, of
course; there are. other savings. We are enabled to pack.
fruit because we have-Heen satisfied by.our. experience, that + ;
it will hokl and giyé satisfaction to the trade that Mee
‘it would have: Deen impossible to put in our. gr rade—that
we, W wonld'paf hav e tried to put in our grade. We can now
pack fruit that shows some abrasions on the surface, fruit
Ww + whieh otherwise-we: would. have had-to intstruet our graders
te throw out. We would not have dared to go to market
“with it beeaiie we would have been practically’ sure of =: -
decay. Then, again, we do not have, to put quite’ as much
fruit in_the-hoX as we used to. Wei do not have to pack
“—4tquife as high because of the use of the paraffin. process |
| with the borax treatment. prevents ‘the fruit from shrinking
‘and we can ‘pack k it#irm at the packing house and it will —
come to the market in that condition, Whereas, if it had -
not the paraffin process on it would show some shrinkage.
'We pecbebiy caitt-twvo-or_three pounds of fruit to a box
that way. Then, of course, we have ses mavhinety and all
that that is taken ¢ are of by the company
& :
s
The following colloquy took phice: : 5
The Court; You mean, Mr. Neave, that you do not rely |
upon that two or three pounds’ of fruit® oe resulting :
| from the paraftty process?., .-7 + | 3 or Bw
Mr, Neéaye:' No, © {2-4}. eh eee
|
|
i
|
i
j
}
Pea,
4a
Saat
“The ‘Court: You are not relying mpon, that at ‘ill?
Mr.- Neave: No.
0) Leaving ois the Seed: I think that from $150;
0 £180 a car would be a conservative estimate of our sav-- |
: ings due to the use of the borax treatment per car of packed,
{-uit, ‘taking into. account the saying of shipping under ven-:
_ filation' and the decreased percéntage of culls and decreased
decay’ and so forth.’ Singe, we started this borax treatment-——~
we have extended our markets. We were enabled to ga
into markets and hold our trade-where formerly | we could.
" tot. : For -instanee, ‘we now ship. as far south as New. Or-
“leans; as far north as Vancouver and Seattle, as far east
iis Montreal, and wwe ship all that without. refrigeration
coes ventilated, And, not ‘onky that). but we have worked
up a ae there for. our. brands which: before we did not
have, I'do not mean. by that'that our brands or our fruit _
‘is.any better than anybody’ s else, but the fruit does not’.
decay aud naturally they call forit: W hat .they ns is
sound. fruit; fruit the willkep a aiid. that has been a big. ap
‘advantage to-us in our individual packing house. . - :
“We have a source of knowledge as to the percentage of
the citrus’ fruit in California that is being treated by .the
. -hoyax process.: We. get.the. size list of the California Fruit —
(rowers se te every day and that list is‘ marked, :
“Brogdex’’ or ‘*borated’’ or whafever—Slaterized, I think
if was. That is a process-that has gove out, and also, of
- course, I have knowledge from my individual experience’
in visiting packing houses that I knew were using the borax
process. Visiting other houses is quite generally done." It
is quite common amongst ihe managers: to go from one
house’ to- another to see what we could find, ‘The percent-
age of citrus’ fruit in California’ that is’ being treated -by. a.
| borax _process, either by the Brog rdite process or other fruit
that is boratedy 4s quite heayy, I would say. I would im-*
agine almost 80 or 90 per jcent. now. There. are other
houses. that. are using that. same. process that it does not
show on thé size list; I mean, that are using the ‘borax. I
[fol. 61] - know. that because I have been in. them. I had
” not, before’ I heard of the. Brogdite - ‘process, éver known
‘of heard of anybody: using: borax. in connection with fruit,
We all, more or: yless, would. use Gold Dust and washing
a z e x eo,
ot Le
. ae se pdiedes and tuft like that. wh i ir iad io-chiogse btw eca re-
=
y\
; 4 ¢ ‘ . : Pa
ae ee : 6 a
: . . * ;
Shek tom - seal " SFA aan oa H ¥
RARDIN Rien £5) cin OS ab ‘ Sas 3 ss ‘ %§ *
. *.
‘ ©
of 2 : -
. . e 7 .
1 Sian
Ait 2S
i. 2 3
“frigeration ond the horax treatment, I- word: want the
bor treatment undoubtedly. © - aoa -
d
As} a “nieniber of the Californja ¥ nuit Growers s Exchange,
our ‘Qgsoci lafiom was emtitled to help from its organization,
‘The iC alifornia Fruit- Beowaes Exchange have. ‘a field, de-
"Pariment hat’ Come aroun, well,” every day ; sometimes +
tavice adi Lv, they, inspec ‘ted us angh inspected the ‘oe eradé aud
the‘jp rack and the fruit and citried ideas ftom oye packing
“heuge to: another ‘and, they help. and: assist ‘ll ot those’ mem-
“pores Té sce if we & ‘Ap. improve, our: methous i in any way Mr.
Winsey isthead_of ‘the field departmetit now.
not make any -liffereree to,me at ‘all financigily whieh’ way .
this suit turns out, bat morally we think’ that when’ people
“work dike that,the owght to have their
titled to anything dev eloped ; they oughi to get’ tha benefit *
tte ; 3 S
i have: Bite fmane ‘ial interest er other interest in the, ige: ot x
“dex C ompany or in: the. subject mafter‘gf ‘this suit. It does:
< they aré ene. oF
of it: at-least that is eae opinion of. ‘All our “people, ‘Ecame oe
hdr “(3 just to testify. 1 this’ suit by.ordér of mx hoard
‘directors. : ‘Al I am- getting out of it is my t eling® ex:
pénses. I might say ‘that mv assaciationy, Sthe board of
«directors are paying my ‘salary while Tam-here, —
‘Our house was the first one that shrpped fruit under ven-
: til ation instead of ter rigeration to. aly. Jarge-exten{ com-—
ae We did meet with some opposition on ‘the part
of purchasers or other-people. There.was.and is leet
edly: from. the trade some comehack on\it. W e found that
ir in-several: cases—something new, theltr ade were not ac-
_customed to see fruit come’ in in- summer, or even ‘in the
ths 62] latter part of the Navel: ‘seasow, Without ice. It
vas naturiil. that they should have. that discussed, but T
think ‘they pr actic: lv got’ over that: Pai ~
Saf ‘A's “to. thip introduction’ of the. borax isdntinent in the’
Walnut Packing Flouge—we tried the Brogdex treatment,
e., {hie par affin tréatment, in 1923, and it was not the ste-
.
‘ess that we hoped. And thew we found out that’ Mr. Brog- -
den - ws condueting tests“ ‘up in Tulare, County with the |
Brogdite process which he had tried at the ‘olleg¢ Heights
‘House, and that he was making these tests under the diree-
tion of the Field Department: of the ¢ California Fruit Grow-
“ane Weenie and ‘of course, we were Eee
intdnsely in-
ot
4
ae re
" \-we
though it — he a very § good thing for ‘eo
os
“a¥
: terested ip Sci ain: we talked, over the iiites with them
and the apsults.of the tests w ere so favorable that we felt *
owedlit- to thé ‘indystry to try it-out. It Iooked as Pi
oe cure Caps examination” Renta oe
7, so)
I cann i say that the opinion, : just expressed as to our
prefererifes in thé oute ome of this case reflects; the opinion.
of the® California Fruit‘ Growe’S Exchange generally.’ -I
“was speqking for myself... 1 might explain that. I, person-
~ ally, wad criticized. ‘tet liftle for going ahead with this. °- |
process, {taking this ¢hainc¢ as it might, be, bécause we were
not absq utely sure that
back from ‘the growers of these other fruits that they are
using” thp bor ax and not paying g for ft tand.we are, so there
may be :} little natural preference. :T/can our speak for my-
elf and
~ rectors»
with the}process, which they are bound to he by the results
* they hav} obtained. 1 have not: had iny expression of opin-.”. .
ffol. 63]. on from the directors of the California Exchange ne
‘ “as to’ thelr preference. in-this suit. I do: ‘not know what ce
- they thinifabout it. , Ms -” .
L estimated that 80.to 90 per cént. of the ‘Fruit. re Cali-
treated with borax. We.-arrive at that figure. “§
by the shipping lists of the California Fruit Growers, Ex-
are marked “borated’’ where they are using -
>
‘fornia was
change whi
the borax a'}d there is a tremendous majority there. Weé
know some c
My figur¢ was\taken frofi the reports from the California
_ Fruit Growers\| Exchange, plus. such knowledge as I may: .
of individua] houses that I~have-been in ~
that are not on the list. I would i imagine undoubtedly that
personally hav
the greater par} of this 90 per cent. is made up: by the
houses on the list.
yw se Ri ras
By:
|
1e thing wonld prove successful °.
“commertially, but it did and ag it is-now we get some talk
iot for the board of direc ors. e’ board: of di- —
f my association ‘are ver’ Tavordlity infpressed :: ‘
: our other organizations are using it, and of
course afl thd San. Antonio, Exchange is-using it.. “Another:
_ «+ Organization is using it through all. their packing. housés and
" there cd a es that are not marked that are using it. ,
2 understand that all: the houses of the .
fox ‘
RRS aes eS Se Ses haa
Cae aie
:
terized. I can-not tell much,
° that was tried out by the Charter Oak Association; some
kind of a salt treatment; but I understand it was ngt sue-
cessful.. The greatest. - -benefit. of ‘it that There was the.
si be Dan fps ile an las oa i - pO iss
FASE i Sel lat DIRE te eh gal
, e - ~
rs ae /
‘
ye Antonio Fruit Vizeuange: except ‘the West Oritatio,
are licensees of the Brogdex a ecto ‘
treatment that.I éalted Sla:
about it. It was a treatment -
T have referred to anothe
fact that it kept-the people in this: packing house free from
-volds. ‘I do not know that this process: is-sed any where
now. ‘1 do. ‘not know whether there is-any borax in that —
-: tr eatment.. 4 do not kiiow much. about: zi,.> ‘
The per cent. of fruit which we throw out, as sculls’ depe ndy
a great deal on thie season. That will vary. Our averag
last year had about 4. per cent.. It depends a yxreat dea
—if you: get a year where-there is a good deal of rain or
there is “good deal: of jwind, naturally, you: get more culls.
tfol. 64] I sity: that last year it was about -4.por cent., that
is ane offhand. Those are culls which we did not’ market:
. We keép an-absolute. recor ‘d of the culls.
Last year was'a fair year in our district, with eoowd:
to the injury to the fruit, perhaps not’ quite fair because
‘we hada little more wind than in some districts.. ‘Tl awould
, it was not quite a fair -vear3 bécausé -we had quite a
ban Sane It Was not what | will eall ain ‘extraordinatily
bad year. I cannot say ‘offhand whether 1924- 192 D was bet-
“ter or ‘worse: tlran last year. I know this iach, that our
- cullage has been 3 or 4 per cent. less since we used the borax:
treatment- than it was before. I am referring to the erttire
- year, comparing a ye rw here ve did not use! the bor: ix with
.-one in which we did. mere
Different weather conditions would not sevadenily make —
‘quite that much differenee‘in the amount of our.cnils.. The -
difference. in the culls that I wanted,to brite to you was
that | we were enabled to pack more fr uit than otherwise
we would have been able to if-we did net have the, borax *.
treatment. This difference resides both in the decrease in»
the. amount of culls we throw -away . and in that. some
fruit that we otherwise would throw away with some par-
‘ticular kind of an injury on it we now pack.
We do not use pre- edoling. at all.
«The figures T gaye ds to decay were taken from our rec-
ords... - siete } sedorn at the span sufficiently recently to
a = ‘ p a J ‘ \ 7% . nak sini
¥ sonneane Siam dul . wi ‘ is . P Spates
i aren Ainge , ence Precwece ; f ae
e ; a aera ‘ ; .
s
~
-
\
.
nt
)
Soe ay oe, Sa pek |
have them’ pretty well in mirid. q have the exact figttres
for the three: years that’ we liave had the Brogdite and
BrogdeX system. I have’ not got the figures for. any. pre-:
-viots years but_I can tel} you what they were. They were
a good, deal more than ‘that. Our average decay over a.
| period of ‘Six. or \ ybv ‘en’ years would run around 5 per cent,
Phe years Ishave in mind are from 1923 back,, 1923, 1922,
' [fol. 65] 1921 T and BO forth. T have not got thé figures for
those individual years, ap just have the general average: I.
—éannot-reeall w hat-our-figure was for any one year but Pe
ean recall this, that ‘the general average was_around 5 per
. ¢cent.-and we had it ‘up and we had ‘it down. I do not par- ~
ticularly recall any one figure that, went into that average... .
We. took them together to get the general average. We.
have heen troubled so little w ehh decay that we have not
been taking aah notice of it. I have not our aetual deeay “’
figure.for any year prior:to. 1923 here but T have the actual
gars for 1924, 1925. and 1926. Slams
>
XQ. 136. You estimated the saving on the car of fruit
as. about $150? . eat 4 ee : i
“<A. Yes, sir. 7 3 wet oats ue ONS es
X-Q. 137; Can you give me “tha items that you used in
®
making yp that sum? 4
' ALWe figured approximately $70 on eae alone’ “ q
We ean figure three or four pounds of fruit to’a box. We :
‘ean figure the extra amount of fruit that we can pack which’.
“othérwise we would not be abie to. There-is.also- the ma- .
-chinery Which: is supplied in the cost of the. process which
~ we did not have to pay‘for, for instance for brushes alone, *
we would change our brushes four times a year and we would
‘have to pay $250 each time we changed our brishes. We
do not have to do that at all. We have our soaking tank
and washer put in place. ‘I may say that we have no al-
‘lowance. practically: to make for decay but it would: bring ©’
it up to that figure. You have over half- of it on, the refrig: .
eration alone. :
« XQ. 138: The refrigeration alone 7 is the omy item that a
“you have any accurate figure ont
*A. 0: course, the rest is estimate.
XQ. 1139. Is mere’ estimate? _ :
VA. It is an éstimate and we know itis there. Pils aa ae
:
{ -
c
mc
f
»
{tol 66] Redirect examination :
‘In answer to a previous question , I am told that I snid
we. used ten pounds of borax to a gallon of water. Ten
ounces is what I should have said,
In making up my estimate of $150 IL included the say-
ing of three or four pounds on each box, ‘The saying of *
two or three pounds a box is due to the combination of both
processes, hut primarily to the “paraflin, treatment. The
_ paraffin treatment, would not, in itself, be effective if we did
not use’ the horax, We could net have shipped ‘under ven-
tilation without the combination of the two processes. The
amount of my estimate with respect to the saving of two or
three pounds a box was between $25 to sie “It carga on
the price of the fruit. ' !
Recross-examination : : ;
, The figures I have just given are - the saving per car.
Recah. Knox
Reotavp L. Kwox, recalled, testified as follows:
Cross-Examination By ‘Mr. Morton (resumed)
I have been asked our figures on decay for the’ season of.
124-25, i. e., the average or per cent of cars showing de-
cay of the California Fruit Growers Exchange shipments.
I have simply a copy of that record which shows 6.4 per
cent of the cars shipped thaf show deeay? That is the basis
on which the reeord is kept. That is all,oranges. That does ~
not give the per cent. of decay but the percentage. of cars
- that: showed deeay without regard to the amoumt of decay
_ in each car. have not, got the corresponding figure for .
1925-26 ; that is up at the hotek . We could not gét it at this —
“{fol. 67] time, but I *erified it. It is eleven and a fraction
per cen{. We ean give that to you and verify jt later on.
The first figure for 1924-1925 was 6.4 per cent. I know
how many of the houses of the California Exchange were
using Brogdex and Brogdite, I mean the whole process, in -
- 1924-25. That would be the year we all put it in at the San
: .
7
f ’ .
, ° a
. - 2 «
P é . ‘ . om ¢@ « oe
Z . ‘ e 4
. ee
Antonio Exchange with the exception of the Reservoir
Stréet house. In 1924-25, the Azusa house was the only -
house of the whole California Exchange, other than, those
_ of our own district exchange (San Antonio), that was using
the complete Brogdite-Brogdex process. In 1925-26, we
simply added the Reservoir Street house of our district ex-
_-change, while the same outside shippers of the California ~ ,
Exchange continued to use borax. No other houses of the’
California Exchange were using the Brogdite process under
that name in‘1926. .Today our (San Antonio) houses-with
the exception of West Ontario, and this Azusa Orange Com-
pany, are the only California Exchange houses using the
complete Brogdite-Brogdex process; but there are other
houses of the California Fruit Growers Exchange that are
using borax. Other houses:of the California Exchange
were also using borax ‘in, 1924-25, besides those Ihave
mentioned as using it under the | name of Brogdite, but not
Le a Ln
o
to'the, same extent asnow. ~- eter he
aA ‘The following colloquy took place:
Mr. Neave: Mr. Morton, you previously asked him about
those bulletins, No. 123. Fin you show him the part that
you referred to becanse he ‘should know just what agit he
- is endorsing.
Mr. Morton: No sinettaalen part except the bulletin pur-
ports to describe the condition that Mr. Powell found when
. he w vin out there and what ought to be 7“ in the way
of improving those éoriditions.
[fol. 68] . Mr. Neave»; Af your: question was whether he
' particularly studied fhe condition. « .° .
Mr. Morton: Yes, ‘whether-his deseri tion of the condi-
tion when he found this ‘high percentage of decay was a
correct statement of the conditions prevailing at that time.
_ If there is any part of it that the witness does not want to
endorse hé may look it over and if there igang that he |
wishes to take exception to, he can say so.
_ While the next witness-is testifinyg, I will lookjever tl is
report.
When I gave Mr. Morton the figures of 6 per cent. and 11
per cent., that was a percentage with reference to all of the
houses of. the California Fruit Growers Exchange. It in-
cludes the houses that used the Brogdite process under.
,
‘
‘ .
ee eae ee See ee
+ ae ny 8 $
os Wwe
.
.
z
license tres the Brogdex Coaameiy. and’ also those that ..
used the borated processes and those using no process if
there were any such. : >
- About 65 or 66 per cent of the oranges’ from California *
are packed by Exchange houses as/distinguished from the
independent. We have about 71 or 72 per cent of the total
packed but in oranges about 65 to 66 per cent. . I refer to
the California Fruit Growers Hxchange, .
‘FRED C. JACOBS
Frep C. Jacos, of Pomona, Cal. i called as aw rituess on
‘behalf of. the plaintiff, being first duly sworn, testified as .
follows:
Direct examination :
Lam secretary and thanager of the Chiviasaes Citrus
Association of Claremont, California. This association is |
a member of the Sdn Antonio Fruit Exchange. I have heen |
[fol. 69) manager of tliat association a little over eight
years. ‘I had .previous experiénce in the citrus industry.
In 1912 I was bookkeeper at the Pomona Fruit Growers
Association at Pomona and afterwards assistant manager
and I took my present position in'1919, and I have held it
ever since. The San Antonio Exchange is a sub- exchange
of the California Fruit Growers Exchange.
The California Fruit Growers Exchange maintains a
field department that’ I come in contact with. This field
department is headed by a manager and there are quite a
number of inspectors, I do not know how many, perhaps
20 or 30, and their duty is to visit each packing house every
day when we are in operation and supervise the pack and
ive us any advice they can as to improvements in the
ethods, if there is anything new that comes up that is of
benefit and it is passed around to all the packing house
managers. (Mr. Neave refers to. several articles, in evi-
dence for plaintiff, written by J. H. Ramsey in 1912, 1914,
1915 and 1921.) .
‘I know J. H. Ramsey. He-isthe Field Manager of the
California Fruit | Growers Exchange a he was in that
-
position in 1924. The, Field Department in- addition to:
- sending inspectors around issues periodically bulletins giv- .
ing adyice to the sub- exchanges and the shippers,-and so
forth. (Witness is shown bulletins or circulars headed ©
“California Fruit Growers Exchange, Field Department”’ -
addressed to all shippers, dated December 20, 1921, De-
cember 21, 1921, January 4, 1924, and April 8, 1924.) These
are bulletins from the Field Department of the California |
_. Fruit Growers Exchange that I as manager received at the
time or about the time which they are dated. These are
representative of the kind of information and assistance
that we get from the California Fruit Growers Exchan ey 7
Field Department. Mr. ~Neave offers these bulletins ‘in
evidence. bs baie
fol. 70] . “(Bulletins “received in esadence and marked
“Plaintiff” s Exhibit No. 62.’’)
The Fruit Growers Supply Company is an cbinatation’
that is composed or. rather owned by the members of the
California Fruit Growers Exchange. It is what you would:
eall a buying organization of the Exchange, that is, they. buy
. our packing material. I can not say definitely how long it »
. has been’ in existence; more than fifteen years. I do not’
reeall receiving from them prior to 1924, any circulars offer-
ing to sell us borax. (Witness is shown a circular of that or-
ganization that is dated February 16, 1925.) That is a cir-
cular with. which T am familiar and which T received at
the time. That is the first cireular that I can recall having
had from them offering borax. *“(Mr. Neave offers in evi-
dence the circular of the Fruit Growers Supply Company.)
(Cireular received in evidence and marked “Plaintiff's
Exhibit No. 63.’) .
Since being manager of the association of which T am
now manager, I have been in close touch with the develop-
ments in the industry and in close touch with what people |
around me have been using. Prior to 1923 or 1924 -blue
‘ mold deeay was our big trouble. ‘Prior to those-dates, prior
to 1923, I did not-know‘of or-hear of the use of borax in —
connection with fresh fruit.
We are just finishing our second- season using the. borax
treatment under the license of the-Brogdex Company. .The
Se
°
. ° 7
‘06
. process consists of dumping oranges.into a large tank in
which is*a mixture of horax,; the fruit travels through that
| onto the brushes where it is again sprinkled with the same
. water and it then returns to another soaking tank and
+ finally has a light rinse of. clear water and after _that ‘it
goes on the. dryer, and after it is tlioroughly dried it goes
onto, the brushes where the paraffin is put on with a kind
[fol. 71] of anatomizer. The strength ofthe borax solution
runs about 7 per cent. . In 1922-23 out of 508 cars of Navels
shipped we had 38 that showed over 3 per cent. decay, and ‘
that was 7.5 per.cent. “In 1923-24 out of 412 cars, we had
86 show over 3 per cent. decay which is 20.8 per cent, This, .°
- was prior to the time ‘when we used th e borax treatment.
' Since ‘we have used the borax treatment our percentages of
decay for the two years following were just exactly-alike;'
they were an even 4 per cent., showing decay, thatis, showin ing
any commercial decay The size of our shipments in‘19 m4. ;
25, was 371 cars and in 1925-26, 200. Those are just N Navels
because Valencias-are a small percentage and they are not
susceptible to,.decay and | did not compile the figure on the
Valencia. -
- The figure that I oem just giv en shows a considerable
- . decrease in. the percentage of decay since we used the borax:
treatment. \I would. ‘say it was a very remarkable decrease
in percentage. It is en cutting itin half, as com-
pared with the 1922-23 season and much more than that
on the following season, ge there was quitea heavy de-
cay in 1923-24, 20 per cent. was very large: We have _
' made comparative shipments iced and ventilated, to deter- |»
~* mine how borax-treated fruit would carry under each of
these conditions. We havé made two or three checks, a.
ear that would be shipped under ventilation, shipped at.)
the same ;time and to the same market as one shipped /
_ under refrigeration and. there was no difference, no ad- \:
vantage to be referred to in any shipmeht. There was no
advantage in. price. , \
I came East just to testify in this case. I have no in- \/
terest in the Brogdex Contpany, direet or indirect. 7 (
: : f
, /
~ Cross: examination: St ate a ee, a4
The California Fruit Growers Exchange is ‘made up of °.
a number of what might be éalled local exchanges. ‘I under-
57.
: [fol. 72]. stand’ there are 22 sub- exchanges and those 22
f sub-exchanges are made up approximately of 220 packing
houses: My’ understanding is‘that only the seven packing
‘houses of the San Antonio E xchange and the one in Azusa
are using this Brogdite borax treatment jas licensees. I
have no knowledge of any others. In 1922-23 and .1923-
24, in neither of these seasons did we use Any borax treat-*
ment. We experimented with the wax treatment, the’Brog- ‘
dex-part of the system with a few cars hack in 1922, I be-
lieve it was, but only in a*very small way.: We decided to
let the other houses do the experimenting and we would
watch the result. That did not affect: our figures here at >» @-
all because they were so small. The other-heuses’that . are
using the borax so faras-T know, are not ‘licensees.
| as Tsaid before, the only ones that I know of that are_
licensees. are the San’Antonio houses and the one in Azusa.
_ [know thére are cary a large number of houses using borax
but I do not\know 1] how many. The formula that they-are
using, is spoken of as Government formula. * I have a copy
by Dr. Barger, I believe it is of what that formula consists, ¥
I do not remember off hand what the percentage is, ¥ ,
.. er 5 ms
We aoeee
—————
. ara * Harr We Pisce |
Harry W. Pierce, of ‘Cla¥emont: ‘Cal, Zalled as a witness
on behalf of: the plaintiff, tes tified as follows: ie
- Direct examination : x | 7
I am seeretary and ianager of the College Heights Ok
ange and Lemon i 8 which is:a member of the
San Antoni have been manager of
the College Heights ‘Aseociation for three-years. I started
in the citrus industry in 1904 and put in one year in the
(fol. 73]. Pomona house as f foreman and then I left the in-
‘dustry and came: back to if in 1914 in the fall. I then took ‘
a position as Field’ May ager of a.local packing house in
LaVeriie. T held that un til 1919 when I took the field work
at the, “Pomona packing! houses and followed that in the
fall of 1922 ‘as manager ‘of Indian Hill Citrus Association
Pe followed ‘that in doves fall of 1924 in my ,present posi-
ion. si | :
58 : : ° ° a : iF | & . he \ nes
The sisiaina’ pack of the College Heights - Association of
‘which I am secretary and manager will be ahout five hun-
dred cars of. oranges and three ‘hundred: cars—ef lemons,
.. Our association uses the borax anc n treatment under’:
- - * lieense: from the Brogdes ‘ompany. I have heard the last
j ‘two w ) witnesses testify as to how they used it. Weuseitin «
«fhe same way ‘on the oranges and to some extent the samie
way on the-lemons ‘except with the lemons they are. not—
treated atthe same.time. They are treated’w “it h the borax
~ when they are first picked and then. we store them and
affer tiiey are cured and ready to: pack then we treat them -
‘.with the wax. We first oh the borax and parafiin treat- _
c
ment commercially in. 1925. For the season of 1923-24,
t3 per cent. if I eceniae it, of the cars shipped from
-Jour asséeiation showed cdeeay I have the figures here.
, In 1923 we shipped 641 cars of oranges and 13.3 per cent.
of the. total ears shipped showed decay, i. e., 99 cars: In
the 1923%and 1924 season which extended from..November *
1923 to October 1924, we shipped 358 ears. Of these, 48
cars or 41.8 per cent! showed decay. None of the fruit-in
‘them was’ treated with borax. In 1924-25--that was the
first season we used the borax paraffin {rez tment. The or:
anges were practically all shipped in the 1924 year ; fhere
were 491 cars shipped and 45 showed decay or 8 per rent,
In 1925-26, that.is, the fall of 1925 and the year of 1926,
out of 344 cars, 25 sliowed decay or 6.7 per cent.
Prior, to’ 1924 we used no methods in the atempt to con-
tro] devay excepting to insist on-eareful handling of the
[fol. 74] frnit-and then ret tarding if as mue h as. possible
with pre-cooling and icing: An average of 70.to'7 7) per:
cent. of the orange output was customarily pre-cooled or
+ refrigerated. In our present practice, the percentage of
our, fruit Which we refrigerate is controlled a good deal
by the market and the condition of the fruit as to the de-
’ sirability of holding. thé fruit. Tn 1925 we. refrigerated
only 9 per cent. of our } Navels, while in 1926 we refrigerated |
‘more than that owing to the fact that we held them in the-
pre- -cooler to, regulate the shipments, and after holding them
> in the iced condition we did not Teel it was desirable
ship them under ventilation.” We found that we coul#hold.,
this fruit as treated by the borax —— ip e pre-
‘common at_all.
fifty-four days.’ Before we used the borax treatment we
did not hold any fruit in a precooler. that long. ‘We did/
* not dare try it. I did not knéw or hear of the use of borax
~~ $n connection with fruit prior to 1923... ie
m4 We also treat: lemons ;by means of this borax, Before
“we used the borax treatment on lemons our approximate
" decay in storage w ould run round from. 3 to 5 yer. cent. .
. Since we used tie hor: ax there is practically one at all. -
‘A tree-ripe lemon.is one that turns yellow: oy the tree and
is to all appearances ripe and ready to use. Before we
had the. borax, treatment a good many o these tree-ripe
lemons went to the byproduct plant and some were’ shipped '
to close markets. The- by-product planf i is‘the place where
they work the lemon up and get tlie lethon oil and the citric
I think the. longést ‘shipment we had was /
acid-and other: things. - We now lave: more lemons thane ;
the market will suse to advantage Consequently we are
sending some lémons to this afgresaid by-; oduct plant
which would’ be perfectly -all right to ship. anywhere. We
merely’send them to the |by-pre@duet. plant because they are
fol. 75] the cheapest grade ¢ lemon we have and-we have
a certain percentage, we ‘hate to. get rid. of other than by
shipping and that is the pfethod we tise but-they would'be_
_/perfeetly all right to ship if there was a mai
large to handle ‘them./ We could ship to Ustant markets.
_(Witness. ‘is handed a paper.) This is/merely a chart
that is got out hy’ the Pacific Coast Borax ‘Company to/
. show the spieity gravity ae We shopld snide on our iv
pany {o thé Nba C Odpany, “hey futuis 1. the charts
from the Supply Company. We use the el in.our plant.
‘We have them nailed on the wall, w here the operator can
~ see what. Ais figures are, read with these testing’ instru-
ments.” He hats an instrument tliat he puts into’ this borax
solution to get the ‘specific g ‘rity. From the chart,. in
conjunction with that instrament, he ean tell what the con-
not Heccive charts ofthis sort. That is, they did not send
et sufficiently -
centration of the of this « is at any temperattire. We did
SPOR ARIA cortpire ER
/
them because they are selling their as get them are
« rts
spocudeaain
eli GRR os
sz
Ppa ek
*to that time.
started to
sa Og ate . rts . : ;
> } 3 Seite,’ y ° M : a
a . ngs Sa * . } . 7 °
e+ a » E .
eo, ‘ ; ee.
° .
60 . bar ehoscee
ise
thém out to every yone:. We get them by ‘asking for them.
‘I got that? one..
“do not “remember just When ; sorhething
like-a year-agy’
/'This is. something that came into existence,
as far as I Know, about.a year or two ago, when they first
ing housgs. tek eae fo oe pe
marred Dante S Kxhibit; No. i. pes
re previously ne asked about’ the: bor: ax. treatment
I hever saw anything of. this sort prior
(The _shart is: pfteten and. received ‘in evidence and
iandle the borax from this @ympany to the pack-.
“Avith the tree-ripe lemops. ‘We can now ship them to a
‘ distance W hich we could not do before. %
-[fol. 76] Cross-examination:
In 1924 64 per cent. of ow cars W ere ited: This is on.
Navels alone, 64 per cent. were iced, and in 1925 there were |
8*per cent. iced. That is,“all our Navels for hig of those
a years. I have not got the. umber of ‘ears for each
ear, the actual. number. T have the iaber coe boxes in
“3996. but I have not got it for 1925, The other cars were
eal under standard ventilation.’ They: were shipped in
' two ways. The oranges were not cooled. he fore they weit
into the e ar but- were taken from the packing house i and li-.
rectly packed into the car. As T have: previously § ‘Said we *
had spprombtaly ts per cent, dee ay in 1922-23, approxi: -
mately 11 per cent. m 1923-24 Me hose were the two-sea-
sons that we tid ot use hotax. In 1924-25 we hed 8 per:
cent. decay and in\1925-26 we had 6.7 7. These last two
years we did use the borax tre: itment.
¢ «
Swsev 0. Crrase
°
_Swsuy 0. C HASE, “of Sanford, Florida, called as a wit-
“ness on behalf of the plaintiff, testified.as follows: /
x Direct examination:
ee on ae
e _f
-T am‘at present connected with Chase & Cothpany; of
Orlando, Pinte { am acca gi of: the: sees They. - Z
61
aa acest at be ie oy Rs oss -
are packers of ztuit. I gave birth to the company in 1888.
er was a grower and packer in 1888. There were a great
" many growers non-producing ‘in Florida at that. time. So.
@ that I got. into the business about as early as Florida got |
into the fruit business. I have been working 1 in the citrus
industry there all the timé frofa then till yow with the ex-
ception of about- four years. After the destructive freeze
“of 1894 and T895.we were temporarily: out. 6f the business
~: till the industry came ba
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.