Transcript of Record — Powers-Kennedy Co. v. Concrete Co.
Supreme Court brief1930
Ask Donna
What actually matters in this document.
Text
town i ue ys Nee s ce
136 ——
TRANSCRIPT OF RECORD
Supreme Court of the United States
OCTOBER TERM, 19297 / 790
No. 528 of
CONCRETH MIXING & CONVEYING COMPANY,
PETITIONER,
vs.
R. C. STORRIE & COMPANY
ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
PETITION FOR CERTIORARI FILED NOVEMBER 5, 1928
CERTIORARI GRANTED DECEMBER 10, 1928
(33,837)
(33,837)
SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITEDSTATES
OCTOBER TERM, 1928
No. 528
CONCRETE MIXING & CONVEYING COMPANY,
PETITIONER,
vs.
R. C. STORRIE & COMPANY
bd
-ON WRIT OF CERTIORARI TO THE UNITED STATES CIRCUIT
e COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
INDEX ;
Page
Record from the district court of the United States, western district
OE Rs oe ven ce ereseevendncteesecesev isc enesess se neuus 6 1
RI lr crica a VCs ad ce Va e RANE TEA ROLE CNRS CK GEA irae Webeae :
et i EN or Corel acdc se ane gece hs one wee Meee ire & 3
EP Gn 44.0 cebu Awe taee nan 0s 6040 4k0 bev ueteneaeeekens 6 s
Order. granting motion to strike. ....cccccusesccecicccecvseess 9
PI IAC GN CAVEAT CL AAWN NG TORRANCE YOUU EIU NEAINO AWS Ct hla wibs OKs 10
SS, SY TI ine bead cncueeyceeek Vv Ne CKUS Vasuaewawens 18
Order denying motion for continuance, etc...............0.00- 39
Ue Oe Ce ig 050 6 6 ees te Or CURES NUN OC ETEEN QC Ue NAO COEDS 41
--Demand that plaintiff admit genuineness of publications... ...... 59
Notice and invitation to witness tests...........0.0. 0.00 eens 61
Order “settling statement of proceedings and narrative of tes-
2 er ree eer: rt. ee ee eee Se cceUS went re wen ews 3
Statement of proceedings and narrative of testimony........ 69
ee Perr eee ee Tee CCT Re TEE TRE eee 69
EU Se PR ees Coke eN NS NV4V 000 COMUNE SANE Ue ee ESO 70
Jupp & Derweint rn (iNc.), PRINTERS, WASHINGTON, D. C., JANUARY 31, 1929
IN DEX.
Page
mewcemy Of Toy ©, TIaCWey . ovis cv vino s Venton duecicensaces 71
ky SII ga dws heehee wind Osu cd selarenites 7s
Moy C, Backiey (receiied) ... 0.2... ccesecss S4
SHITE Y TIOUPNUON. 6/5:..8.5 so oe sos 0 ee ee cok Pane wats SS
ae) IE a kon Kb wan W Wier ieee wie cb bs Oo
& Oe FIN, oh o's anc eae ech eaesas 123
f eC IW evan el ueccus ce nat eue 129
i a ies ahve dathodundy cass ours 135
$ ee WN 6c ee ee ae es oehewas xo 155
H Ee Ua wats Waly 1N7
3 NN ce EOIN, cn spe S dale caw ee cua w GWabees 197
3 SY SR O56 6 har 5 DKKW eed Kise coke eL ne ees 202
se UNcp RUE OME SAMAR ct ciael Ws Soule cle Gen ceiaw alot sO ea eee POD
CMTE POMMEO Se RO ecaa yc see ee 214
SOE GN I oi NE cineca cary eal cun es 219
I Wd REINS aes hes ow wie his waked ok Naas ek 254
SSeorse TW WVarner. «. 3 os ssa oe oak oe Hine eeee P41 it
BPRS A TEINS iets og escent cSt eoainte min enone are. 287
eS a NI 4 raed nga sealed nin % Wake Alera 301
aCe BE. . Cs 1A) Cag ae ea 329
PAGTOV Ce POMC a Ou can be wise eicie Sn oe be os aT
RN Ee MOI cee uy STE ere 356
Oe OI ray an PS ee se ea uy hea 10 puns 'swee naan 359
weumony Of Jonepe C. ThOwWe cio d sc cn creates ovtcceves 368
Seer OF EE. ,. POW WEIE. oocc rice s new cew kd cnwcdeveans 3SS
Colloguy between court and counsel............0.....00008- 397
Bemis Of TD. STROUP 6 os es Snes bes keh nteee 403
oy (. Hackley (recalled) ......0. sels ooees 22% 420
i i heciwdd andyeGde ee du kwelde aawwe du 442
ay 1S Re ao dv oy as diewawiud sense ewe ewe 44
Wes: ees By a 0 4d carve dco ee rennd eases an 476
Colloquy between court and coumsel.......... 000. cece ee ees 520
Testimony of Arthur I. Robinson (reealled)................ 523
KR. C. Oxenham (recalled)................-. 57)
Shirley Houghton (recalled)................ 531
Frederick Ray (recailed)...cccccccccccscccecs 534
Harry I. Kirkland (recalled)............... OT
See Wee CODEINE Dv cevoccccvcaticecvevée DOS
Arthur TP. Robinson (reealled).............. 571
Colloquy between court and counsel. ........... 0060000000 575
De GE TONED By CA: cccececcdcovtcvseceves cooee 878
Order approving narrative of testimony. ................000005 On
Se UL eves dervescnvaevebadotudesvessedceesecsens 610
- PE SAC o hee beueeeeképbebdcuecdededescutes coicetscuser 622
Petition for appeal and order allowing same.................. 623
EE On UNE 6c ar oss ov C0 ase o er ewe eek sede sbokeuewes 624
ee ee IN a bo:0 bo ene ces ed ose rai oun seh) bu eeee ee bb cade 6AG
Order directing transmission of exhibits..................000. OAD
Pome Gar SURUMOUTNE GE SROONE. cc ccccvesedenceseceteccovéces 649
Defendant's priwecipe for transcript of record................0.. 656
Clerk’s certificate............ ee re
Citation and service.......cecceees eee wee sig. atareren eialalas sere ae
Proceedings in the United States circuit court of appeals, ninth
CRIME vic aie o's wes RL oe als WINieieie ote Ste eet PE ee Sree Tr Ror
Argument and submission........-5. 0. cee cere eee eee eee eee eens
Order directing filing of opinion and decree..... pena Sia Stew ateieeceteis
Opinion, Gilbert, J..... deere wens aaheieere Pere ete Mem nears Pe IES BAI
DCCTCE .nccscces are S ure eae Rr er ner genre tr i A ee ee
Order denying petition for rehearing... ....-... eee eee cece reece
Order staying mandate. ......... 566s cere eee eee eee ene eees eerie
Cleves COPTIRCATC ..6.6oc ccc cc sive cect peo ess cee tinwitios Pr Ne
Order allowing certiorari... ... 6... cece ee ee ee ee eens eenchorelere a speraters
NAMES AND ADDRESSES OF COUNSEL.
Messrs. WILLIAMS, BRADBURY, McCALEB &
HINKLE, Solicitors for Appellant,
1315 Monadnock Block, Chicago, Illinois.
Messrs. BATTLE, HULBERT & HELSELL, So-
licitors for Appellant,
901 Alaska Building, Seattle, Washington.
CHARLES E. TOWNSEND, Esquire, Solicitors
for Appellee,
San Francisco, California.
Messrs. CHADWICK, McMICKEN, RAMSEY &
RUPP, Solicitors for Appellee,
660 Colman Building, Seattle, Washington.
[1*]
In the District Court of the United States for the
Western District of Washington, Northern Di-
vision.
IN EQUITY—No. 394.
CONCRETE MIXING AND CONVEYING COM-
PANY,
Plaintiff,
vs.
R. C. STORRIE & COMPANY, a Partnership,
Defendant.
*Page-number appearing at the foot of page of original certified
Transcript of Record.
7
&
%
’
2 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
PLACITA.
Pleas in the District Court of the United States
for the Western District of Washington, Northern
Division, begun and held at the United States court-
room in the City of Seattle, in said District and
Division, before the Honorable George M. Bour-
quin, District Judge of the United States for the
District of Montana, sitting by assignment in said
District and Division, on the 13th day of Septem-
ber, in the year of our Lord one thousand nine hun-
dred and twenty-seven, being one of the days of the
regular May term of said court begun on Tuesday,
the third day of May, 1927, and of our Independence
the one hundred and fifty-second year. Present,
Honorable George M. Bourquin.
E. B. BENN,
Marshal.
Ed. M. Lakin,
Clerk.
[Endorsed]: Filed Mar. 1, 1928. [2]
us. R. C. Storrie d& Company.
United States District Court, Western District of
Washington.
IN EQUITY—No. 394.
CONCRETE MIXING AND CONVEYING COM-
PANY,
Plaintiff,
vs.
R. C. STORRIE & COMPANY, a Partnership,
Defendants.
BILL OF COMPLAINT.
Plaintiff, for complaint against defendants, ‘al-
leges as follows:
(1) Plaintiff, Concrete Mixing and Conveying
Company, is a corporation organized and existing
under and by virtue of the laws of the State of
Illinois, having its principal place of business at
Chicago, in the County of Cook and State of IIli-
nois. Defendants, Robert C. Storrie and Robert
G. Muir, are partners doing business as R. C.
Storrie & Company, and have a regular and estab-
lished place of business at Seattle, in the County
of King and State of Washington, within the West-
ern District of Washington, within which district
they have committed acts of infringement of plain-
tiff’s patent, of which complaint is made herein.
(2) John H. MeMichael being, prior to January
14, 1907, the original, first and sole inventor of cer-
tain new and useful improvements in method of and
AOS
4 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
apparatus for transporting and treating concrete,
lawfully filed and prosecuted an application for
United States letters patent therefor, and having
complied in all respects with the statutes, and hav-
ing duly assigned said invention and application to
plaintiff by mesne assignments, United States pat-
ent No. 1,127,660 was lawfully granted and is-
sued [3] pursuant to said application to plain-
tiff on February 9, 1915.
Said invention of John H. McMichael was new
and useful, not known or use@!by others in this
country before his invention thereof, not patented
or described in any printed publication anywhere
before his invention or more than two years prior
to said application for United States patent there-
for, not in public use on sale in the United States
for more than two years prior to said application
for United States letters patent therefor, not pat-
ented in any foreign country by him or his legal
representatives on an application filed more than
one year before his said application for United
States letters patent, and not abandoned. Said
United States letters patent No. 1,127,660 is now in
full force and is hereby proffered and ready to be
produced before the court.
(3) The invention patented in the aforesaid
patent No. 1,127,660 is of great utility and has
. been introduced into public use by the plaintiff, and
the public generally has acquiesced in and acknowl-
edged the utility of said invention, and the validity
of said letters patent, and the plaintiff’s exclusive
rights canes |
————
—
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 5
(4) Plaintiff is and always has been the sole
owner of said United States letters patent No.
1,127,660 and of all rights of action for infringe-
ment thereof.
(5) Plaintiff alleges that defendants have here-
tofore recognized the validity of said patent and
plaintiff’s exclusive rights thereunder, and are es-
topped to deny the validity of said patent, by rea-
son of the following facts:
On or about March 15, 1916, Pacific Concrete
Placing Company, a firm of San Francisco, Cali-
fornia, was licensed by plaintiff, to use the inven-
tion of said patent in the State of [4] California
and, under certain conditions, was empowered by
plaintiff to grant sublicenses to use the invention of
said patent in the State of California, but not else-
where. Prior to March 15, 1916, defendants unlaw-
fully and wrongfully constructed two machines em-
bodying the invention of said patent and were using
or preparing to use said machines in the construc-
tion of the so-called ‘‘Twin Peaks Tunnel”’ located
in the City and County of San Francisco, Califor-
nia. Defendants, being advised that said machines
were infringements of said patents, on or about
March 15, 1916, entered into a written contract with
said Pacific Concrete Placing Company. By said
contract defendants recognized the validity of said
patent and plaintiff’s ownership thereof, and se-
cured the right and license to use said two machines
in connection with said ‘‘Twin Peaks Tunnel’ but
not otherwise. In said contract defendants agreed,
inter alia, that they would not, without the written
Oy ee a eee
6 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
consent of the Pacific Concrete Placing Company
(and said consent never was given), use said ma-
chines, or either of them, upon any other work
than said Twin Peaks Tunnel, and defendants fur-
ther agreed that, upon the completion of the work
at the said Twin Peaks Tunnel, said machines were
to become the property of Pacific Concrete Placing
Company and were to be delivered by defendants to
Pacific Concrete Placing Company. Said contract
is still in force and effect. All of the obligations
of plaintiff and Pacific Concrete Placing Company,
under said contract, have been performed but said
contract is exeeutory on the part of defendants.
Defendants still retain possession of said machines.
(6) Im violation of plaintiff’s rights under said
patent No. 1,127,660, and without any authority,
within six years prior to the amendment of this
suit, within the Western District of [5] Wash-
ington, and elsewhere in the United States, defend-
ants have infringed plaintiff's exclusive. rights
granted by said patent, and more particularly have
infringed Claims 1, 2, 17, 18, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25,
27, 28, 29, 30, 34, and 35 thereof, as follows, to wit:
(a) By making and (or) using and (or)
selling apparatus embodying said patented in-
vention.
(b) By using one or both of the taachines
mentioned in paragraph 5 hereof in the con-
struction of a tunnel forming part of the so-
ealled ‘“‘Skagit River Profject’’ located near
Rockport, State of Washington.
en eo oC oe
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 7
(c) By using at said tunnel forming part
of said Skagit River project other machines
embodying said patented invention.
Defendants continue to make, use and sell in-
fringing machines in violation of plaintiff’s rights,
and in infringement of said patent, whereby plain-
tiff has been, and is being, greatly and irreparably
damaged and whereby defendants have obtained,
and are obtaining, large profits which in equity be-
long to plaintiff, the amount of which damage and
profits cannot be ascertained except by an account-
ing.
Plaintiff, therefore, prays:
(a) That defendants be required to answer this
bill of complaint, but not under oath, answer under
oath being hereby expressly waived.
(b) That the Court grant a preliminary injunc-
tion pending this suit and a perpetual injunction
restraining defendants, their agents, employees and
confederates from making, using or vending devices
embodying said patented invention, and from offer-
ing or advertising so to do, and from aiding or
abetting or in any way contributing to the infringe-
ment of said patent. [6]
(c) That this cause be referred to a Master to
make and report an account of damages and profits
accruing from defendant's infringement of said
patent, and that plaintiff have judginent for the
damages and profits so found and for the costs of
this suit.
8 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(d) That plaintiff have such other and further
relief as equity may require.
CONCRETE MIXING AN ” CONVEYING
COMPANY,
By EDWARD WRAY,
President.
BATTLE, HULBERT,
GATES & HELSELL,
901 Alaska Bldg., Seattle,
LYON A. WILLIAMS,
ALBERT G. M. WEBB,
Of Counsel.
State of [llinois,
County of Cook,—ss.
On January 23d, 1924, at Chicago, Illinois, before
me personally appeared Edward Wray, who being
first duly sworn, testified that he is the President
of Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company, the
plaintiff named in the foregoing bill of complaint;
that he signed the same as such officer; and that he
has read the bill of complaint and believes the alle-
gations thereof to be true.
[Seal] (Sgd.) J. DAVID DICKMAN,
Notary Public. [7]
{Title of Court and Cause. |
MOTION TO STRIKE.
Now come the defendants and move the Court
to strike out paragraph 5 of the bill of complaint:
vs. R. C. Storrie d&: Company. _ 9
(1) Because said paragraph alleges matter ir-
relevant and impertinent to the issues of the bill, in
‘that it sets out the terms of a Jicense agreement,
pleading conclusions of law that the same license
agreement is now in force and effect and thereby
rendering uncertain the issue of the bill of com-
plaint, which otherwise is drawn as a bill for in-
fringement of a patent; and
(2) Because said paragraph 5 does not set forth
ultimate facts:
WHEREFORE, defendants pray for an order
from the Court striking said paragraph.
CHADWICK, McMICKEN, RAMSEY &
RUPP,
By G. WRIGHT ARNOLD.
G. WRIGHT ARNOLD,
Solicitors for Defendants.
Service of within motion to strike and receipt of
copy admitted this 18th day of April, 1924.
WILLIAMS, BRADBURY, McCALEB &
PIERCE and
BATTLE, HULBERT, GATES & HEL-
SELL,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
Filed Apr. 18, 1924. [8]
[Title of Court and Cause. ]
ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO STRIKE.
This cause coming on for hearing upon the mo-
tion of the defendant to strike from the bill of com-
PURED NOTe HIS PERT + Eee
” Des wa
an ~]
10 Concrete Miging and Conveying Company
plaint on file herein paragraph five thereof, plain-
tiff appearing by Messrs. Battle, Hulbert, Gates &
Helsell, its attorneys, and defendant appearing by
Mr. G. Wright Arnold, its attorney, and the cause
having been argued and submitted to the Court—
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED that,
said motion to strike paragraph five be, and the
same is, hereby granted.
To the entry of the foregoing order the plaintiff
excepts and its exception is duly allowed.
Done in open court this 23 day of May, 1924.
JEREMIAH NETERER,
Judge.
O. K. as to form. a é
G. WRIGHT ARNOLD.
Filed May 23, 1924. [9]
[Title of Court and Cause. ]
ANSWER.
To the Honorable Judge of the District Court of
the United States for the Western District of
Washington, Northern Division.
In answer to the bill of complaint defendant says:
I.
That they are not informed, save by the said bill
of complaint, whether the plaintiff is a corporation
organized and existing dinder and by virtue of the
laws of the State of Illinois having its principal
place of business at Chicago, County of Cook, State
of Illinois, and therefore deny the same.
vs. It. C. Storrie & Company. 11
IT.
Deny upon information and belief that they have
at any time committed, or are committing, any in-
fringement upon any letters patent of plaintiff
within said Western District of Washington or
elsewhere.
ITT.
Deny upon information and belief that prior to
January 14, 1907, or at any time, John H. Mce-
Michael was an original or first or sole inventor of
any new or useful improvements in Method of and
Apparatus for Transporting and Treating Con-
crete. Defendant admits that letters patent of the
United States No. 1,127,660 were issued February
9, 1915, upon an application of the said [10] Me-
Michael, but whether said patent was duly applied
for or granted according to law, defendant is not
informed save by said bill, and, therefore, denies
that there was secured to the said John H. Me-
Michael or to his heirs at law any exclusive right
to make, use and vend the alleged invention known
as improvements in Method of and Apparatus for
Transporting and Treating Concrete throughout the
United States and the territories thereof. Defend-
ant further answering denies that the said bill of
complaint sets forth with that degree of particu-
larity required by the provisions of sections 4886
and 4887 of the Revised Statutes of the United
States, that patent No. 1,127,660 is good or valid
or that all of the requirements of the Statutes have
been complied with in securing the issuance of said
patent; denies that said patent No. 1,127,660 is good
ae ee as 1 ae ee ee aan
| a ae aaa ee
——
12 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
or valid in law, denies that the alleged invention
thereof was novel or required invention for its pro-
duction, denies that it contained patentable nov-
elty, denies that it was not known or used by others
in this country before the alleged invention or dis-
covery thereof by the said McMichael, denies that
it was not patented or described in any printed
publication in this or any foreign country before his
alleged invention or discovery thereof, or more than
two years before his application for patent therefor,
denies that it was not in public use or on sale in this
country for more than two years prior to his said
application, denies that it was not patented by him
or his legal representatives in any foreign country
on an application filed by him or them more than
twelve months prior to the filing of said application
in this country, and denies that said alleged inven-
tion had not been abandoned by him.
IV.
Denies each and every allegation in paragraph 3.
[11] Defendant is not informed, save by said bill
of complaint, whether the plaintiff is and always
has been the sole owner of said United States letters
patent No. 1,127,660 and of all rights of action for
infringement thereof, and therefore denies the same.
V.
Denies each and every allegation in paragraph 6,
provided further nothing in this answering para-
graph contained shall be construed as admitting
directly or indirectly for any purpose or purposes
whatsoever the existence of paragraph 5 of the bill
_——
OE Sg Ua ar! SA ATO a ERT Re TE ae
vs. R. C. Storrie &d Company. - 13
of complaint of the plaintiff, which paragraph 5
has heretofore been stricken as per order of record,
and particularly denies that defendant continues to
make, use and sell infringing machines in violation
of plaintiff’s rights and infringement of said patent
No. 1,127,660, and denies that plaintiff has been, and
is being, greatly and irreparably damaged, and
denies that defendant is obtaining and has obtained
large profits which inequity belong to plaintiff, the
amount of which damage and profits cannot be as-
certained except by accounting, provided further
nothing in this answering paragraph contained shall
be construed as admitting directly or indirectly for
any purpose or purposes whatsoever the existence of
paragraph 5 of the bill of complaint of the plaintiff,
which paragraph 5 has heretofore been stricken as
per order of record.
And by way of a FIRST AFFIRMATIVE DE-
FENSKE, defendant avers:
I.
That said patent No. 1,127,660 and particularly
claims 1, 2, 17, 18, 20, 22, 23, 24, 25, 27, 28, 29, 30, 34
and 35 thereof, which claims alone are alleged to be
infringed in said bill of complaint, are null and
void, because the said John H. [12] McMichael is
not the original, first or true inventor of the device
described and claimed therein, but that the same and
all substantial and material parts thereof were long
prior to the supposed and alleged invention thereof
by the said McMichael, described and/or patented,
and/or illustrated in and by the following mentioned
prior letters patent:
wa A Ey are a
a tne EM OX -
14 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
Brit.
sé
Germ.
[13]
Patent No.
285,047
65,149
347,196
99,055
268,305
759,750
837,622
267,318
279,034
408,201
894,813
951,754
179,055
837,113
23,594
12,758
18,394
873,345
747,396
727,030
609,744
773,665
818,776
730,884
864,471
531,379
519,599
276,879
602,349
741,116
Date.
Sept. 18, 1883
May 28, 1867
Aug. 10, 1886
Feb. 15, 1898
Nov. 28, 1882
May 10, 1904
Dee. © 4, 1906
Nov. 14, 1882
June 5, 1883
July 30, 1889
Aug. = 4, 1908
Mar. 8, 1910
June 20, 1876
Nov. 27, 1906
Oct. 28, 1896
June 30, 1894
Dec. 10, 1907
Dec. 22, 1903
May 9, 1903
Aug. 23, 18938
Nov. 1, 1904
Apr. 24, 1906
June 16, 1903
Aug. 27 1907
Dec. 25, 1894
May _ 8, 1894
May 1, 1883
Apr. 12, 1898
Oct. 18, 1903
Inventor,
J. Lewis
S. W. Wood
G. Pohle
S. C. Davidson
L. L. Smith
i. Rosenthal
J. D. James
J. W. Beach
L. Smith
J. S. Wallace
J. W. Buzzell et al.
J. W. Buzzell et al.
F. C. Prindle
E. Phillips
Bothner
Trewent
L. Kolsche
W. L. Canniff
Neal Farnham
b. C. Tilghman, Jr.
C. T. Hennig
J. D. Murray
J. D. Murray
L. K. Davis
W. H. Kelly
J. EK. Mathewson
C. Bloemendal
M. Randolph
W. A. McCool
M. A. DeFrance
_"
us. R. C. Storrie & Company. 15
Patent No. Date. Inventor.
671,303 Apr. 2, 1901 <A. G. Warren
791,176 May 30, 1905 F. W. Breidster
274,778 Mar. 27, 1883 J. B. Hyde
327,210 Sept. 29, 1885 W. Westlake
752,598 Feb. 16, 1904 G. M. Sehwend
847,270 Mar. 12, 1907 F. M. Wise
798,118 Apr. 26, 1904 F. Sticker
632,147 Aug. 29, 1899 CC. S. Robinson
and in various other patents and publications at the
present time unknown to defendant but which de-
fendant prays leave to add by way of amendment
to this answer as soon as discovered. The above-
named patents and any others which may hereafter
be found defendant craves leave to produce and ex-
hibit to the Court at any hearing of this case, and
desires the same to be considered as annexed to and
deemed a part of this answer.
By way of a SECOND AFFIRMATIVE DE-
FENSE, defendant avers:
II.
That in the state of the art which existed at the
time said patent No. 1,127,660 was applied for, it
did not require invention to produce the device and
method described and claimed in said patent. De-
fendant further avers that said claims of said patent
are narrowed, restricted and limited by reason of
admissions of the said McMichael and of his attor-
ney during the prosecution [14] of the applica-
tion thereof in the Patent Office; that broader
claims originally made in said application were re-
eR
ma gtaer™, « ei ieee!
te ad
POEM IO RR ae
OIE MST Pace RE
16 Concrete Mizing and Conveying Company
jected and that said rejections were acquiesced in by
said MeMichael, and such broader claims were
erased and narrower and more limited and restricted
claims inserted, whereby said plaintiff is estopped
to ask for any bread construction of the said claims
and has abandoned to the public any alleged broad
invention originally claimed, and said patent if
valid is limited in its scope to every particular
detail ef construction shown, described and claimed
therein, as will appear in the certified copy of the
file wrapper and contents, which defendant craves
leave to produce and exhibit to the court at any
hearing of this case, and desires the same to be con-
sidered as annexed to and deemed a part of this
answer.
And by way of a THIRD AFFIRMATIVE DE-
FENSE, defendant avers:
IL.
That said patent No. 1,127,660 does not set forth
an operative device for constructing a water pres-
sure tunnel, which type of tunnel defendant is con-
structing and is known as the ‘*Skagit River Pro-
ject.”’
And by way of a FOURTH AFFIRMATIVE
DEFENSE, defendant avers:
IV.
That said John H. MeMichael named in the bill of
complaint was not the original, first and/or true
inventor of the whole or any substantial part of the
things deseribed in the said claims alleged to be
infringed of the patent in suit, but that the same of
i
vs. R. C. Storrie d& Company. 17
all substantial parts thereof were old in the art and
were commonly known to the publie and made, sold
and [15] used in the United States long prior
to the respective alleged invention of the said Me-
Michael, and were also so known and so used more
than two years prior to his application for patent,
and were so known to and used by the Ransome Con-
crete Machinery Company of Dunellen, New Jersey,
in 1905.
All of these matters and things defendant is ready
and willing to aver, maintain and prove as this
Honorable Court may direct, and humbly prays to
be hence dismissed with its costs and charges in this
behalf most wrongfully sustained.
R. C. STORRIE & COMPANY,
Defendant.
CHADWICK, McMICKEN, RAMSEY &
RUPP,
G. WRIGHT ARNOLD,
Solicitors for Defendants.
Service of the within answer and receipt of copy
admitted this 28th day of May, 1924.
BATTLE, HULBERT, GATES & HEL-
SELL,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
Filed May 28, 1924. [16]
et
(pp pret ce ee rey perme et ee ee
pa
18 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
/
|
:
:
:
MS. Mra) ee Oe “ew ti Ce
ee ae ee
Pl, in Gt ws
*
os me OOD 2 Mets rca el Be CE
dy ty
[Title of Court and Cause. ]
AMENDMENT TO ANSWER.
Come now the defendants above named, by their
counsel, and by leave of Court first had and ob-
tained, amend their answer as follows:
Paragraph I of First Affirmative Defense, page 5
of the answer, after ‘*6382,147, Aug. 29, 1899, C, 8S.
Robinson,’* add the following additional patents,
publications, prior uses and prior inventions:
Patent No.
7,060
45,153
47,793
80,225
86,289
92,985
99,360
4,953
122,498
7)
140,692
146,357
147,780
167,384
185,216
204,725
220,293
224,197
233,499
Jan.
Jan.
Nov.
May
July
Jan.
July
Feb.
June
Jan.
July
Jan.
Feb.
Sept.
Dee.
June
Oct.
Feb.
Oct.
Date.
6, 1809
29, 1850
22, 1864
23, 1865
71, 1868
26, 1869
27, 1869
1, 1870
1872
2, 1872
8, 1873
1874
1874
7, 1875
12, 1876
11, 1878
7, 1879
3, 1880
19, 1880
Inventor.
Upham
Potts
Gunning
Brear
Robertson
Duvall
McKinley
Sickels
Sickles (Reissue)
Smith
Faucett
Prall
Milner
Boeklen
Cranston
Gunning
Knapp
Maguire et al.
Frizell
[18]
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company.
Patent No.
240,265
250,602
267,318
273,623
274,103
274,104
277,137
298,990
300,333
318,859
327,307
327,308
338,138
355,251
371,006
416,180
425,624
435,142
450,062
461,429
461,430
461,431
464,771
468,365
472,072
487,606
487,639
491,843
495,359
497,427
Date.
April 19, 1881
Dec. 6, 1881
Nov. 14, 1882
March 6, 1883
March 20, 1883
March 20, 1883
May _ 8, 1883
May 20, 1884
June 10, 1884
May 26, 1885
Sept. 29, 1885
Sept. 29, 1885
March 16, 1856
Dec. 28, 1856
Oct. 4, 1887
Dee. 3, 1889
Apr. 15, 1890
Aug. 26, 1890
April 7, 1891
Oct. 20, 1891
Oct. 20, 1891
Oct. 20, 1891
Dee. 8, 1891
Feb. 9, 1892
April 5, 1892
Dee. 6, 1892
Dec. 6, 1892
Feb. 14, 1893
April 11, 1893
May 16, 1893
19
Inventor.
Palmer
Thiollier et al.
Beach
Smith
Ayres
Ayres
Von Schmidt
Leedy
Von Schmidt
Bowers
Peters
Peters
Buell
Bowers
Waits
Neukirch
O'Neil
Harris
Estes
Frasch
Frasch
Frasch
Harris
Robbins
Patterson
Church
Pohle
Kauser
MeClave
Hussey & Harsen
PERN ia DEA SATS Bet ck Des he HT) ROLE cr oS Lh ORE RNS OST NS AS Qh RN Fe
20 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
Patent No. Date. Inventor. “
901,215 July 11, 1893 Schubert
921,883 June 26, 1894 Holland
023,838 July 31, 1894 Hussey
526,529 Sept. 25, 1894 Hussey
526,530 Sept. 25, 1894 Hussey
026,531 Sept. 25, 1894 Hussey
526,652 Sept. 25, 1894 Hussey
528,449 Oct. 30, 1894 Staley !
542,620 July 16, 1895 Bacon |
542,622 July 16, 1895 Bacon |
d00, 704 March 3, 1986 Hussey
999,785 March\3, 1896 Misic & Foster |
968,445 Sept. 29, 1896 Kennedy
568,742 Oct. 6, 1896 Church
977,022 Feb. 23, 1897 Wallwork & Wells
987,126 July 27, 1897 McAdams
592,037 Oct. 19, 1897 Young & Shaw
593,013 Nov. 2, 1897 Fisher
093,151 Nov. 2, 1897 Zohe
997,023 Jan. 11, 1898 Saunders
600,703 March 15, 1898 Andrews
601,521 March 29, 1898 Melcher
[19] |
11,675 June 28, 1898 ‘Titus (Reissue)
609,350 Aug. 16, 1898 Jones
619,727 Feb. 21, 1899 Davis
620,414 Feb. 28, 1899 Burger
635,270 Oct. 17, 1899 Rix & Donahoo
636,279 Nov. 7, 1899 Newhouse
646,640 April 3, 1900 Evans
656,994 Aug. 28, 1900 Munn
—
[20]
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company.
Date.
Patent No.
660,946
669,192
669,409
674,021
676,128
676,129
704,608
707,840
715,548
734,773
738,326
749,206
749,488
758,360
759,100
759,357
759,706
778,878
799,642
800,127
810,989
814,601
May 3,
May 10,
May 10,
Jan. 3,
Sept. 19,
Sept. 19,
Jan. 30,
March 6,
Nov. 12,
May 17%,
1900
1901
1901
4, 1901
1901
1901
1902
1902
1902
1903
1903
1904
2, 1904
1904
1904
1904
1904
1905
1905
1905
1906
1906
1907
1910
(application filed
Nov. 2, 1905)
Dec. 6,
1910
(application filed
October 30, 1903)
Inventor.
Butler
Whisler
Dunn
See
Goldie
Goldie
Young & Shaw
Goldie
Cary
Stuart
Higgins
Limbert
King
Harris
Harris
Edison
Harris
Moir
Frasch
Frasch
Steinert
Harris
Frasch
Mellvrid
Fraseh
22 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
Patent No. Date. Inventor.
988,995 April 11, 1911 Frasch
(application filed
rs October 30, 1903)
Brit. 2,539 1868 Crampton
™ 4,400 Dec. 18, 1875 = Dueckham
4,277 1882 :
“8451 Oct. 13, 1884 Gordon
” 15,348 Dec. 14, 1885 Duekham
‘ o,221 1886 Greathead
ie 11,346 Aug. 8, 1888 Neukirch
French 5,707 Dec. 8, 1838 Triger i
Societe des
322,237 June 19, 1902. Etablissements 8.
Grauer & Cie,
German 37,503 Sept. 29, 1885 Poetsch |
7 42,513 Feb. 17, 1887 Jeziorsky
2s 46,842 July 24, 1888 = Neukirch
' 25,399
PUBLICATIONS.
The Pohlé Air Lift Pump—1893—Catalog—New
York.
The Pohlé Air Lift) Pump—1s894 Catalog—New
York.
Engineering & Mining Journal, Dec. 28, 1898 (pages
271 to 278, inclusive), Article by C. A, Stete-
feldt.
‘Engineering News,’ July 12, 1894 (pp. 260 to 264,
inclusive), Article by L. B. Merriam.
Rockford, Illinois ‘*Star,’* October 14, 1893. [21]
‘The Democrat,’? Bambridge, Georgia, Feb. 15,
1894.
us. R. C. Storrie &: Company. 23
Joliet, Illinois, ‘‘Daily Republican,’? March 15,
1894.
Ashbury Park ‘‘Journal,’’? April 20, 1894.
‘‘Pumping by the Air Lift Method’’ (8rd Pohle
Catalog) (Press of Moss Engraving Co.).
‘Air Lift Pumping,’ by Edward A. Rix, San
Francisco, March 1, 1904.
‘*Petroleum—A History of the Oil Region of
Venango County, Pennsylvania,”’ by Rev. 8S. J.
M. Eaton, Philadephia, J. P. Skelly & Co.,
732 Chestnut St., 1866 (pages 186 and 1387).
Rogers *‘Pumps and Hydraulies,’’? 1905—Pubhshed
by Theo. Audel & Company, New York and
London (pages 79 to 90, inclusive).
‘Compressed Air Information or Cyclopedia Con-
taining Practical Papers on the Production,
Transmission and Use otf Compressed Air,”
Edited by W. L. Sanders, published by ‘*Com-
pressed Air,’ 26 Cortlandt St., New York—
Copyright 1903, by ‘‘Compressed <Air,’’ and
particularly pages 81, 181, 182, 183, 249, 250,
343, 594 to 599, inclusive, 602, 603, 656, 657, 663,
664, 665, 691, 829, 830, 847 to 862, inclusive,
1017, 1018 to 1032, 1040 to 1050, inclusive, 1144
and 1145.
‘Compressed Air, Its Production, Uses and Ap-
plications,” by Gardner D. Hiscox, Fourth
Edition, published by Norman W. Henley &
Co., 132 Nassau St., New York, 1903, ‘‘Copy-
right, 1901, by Norman W. Henley & Co.”
(Chapter XXXII, and particularly pages 711
to 729),
24 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
‘‘Journal of the Franklin Institute,’’ Volume 140
of 1895 (pp. 46 and 47).
‘‘Harper’s Weekly,’”’ Issue of January 28, 1893
(pp. 89 and 90).
Catolog No. 73 of the Intersoll-Sergeant Drill Co.,
First Edition, 1905, entitled ‘‘Water Lifted by
Compressed Air.”’
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. II, New York, June, 1897,
No. 4 (p. 234).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. II, New York, Sept., 1897,
No. 7 (page 295).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. III, New York, March,
1898, No. 1 (page 403).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. III, New York, April 1898,
No. 2 (page 420).
‘‘Compressed Air,’? Vol. VIII, New York, April
1903, No. 2 (pages 223, 230. and 231). [22]
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. VIII, New York, January
1904, No. 11 (pp. 2723 to 2735, inclusive).
‘‘Dredging Operations and Appliances’’—Proceed-
ings of the Institution of Civil Engineers,
March 1, 1887, London, re Duckham’s Pneu-
matic Dredfer.
‘‘Baker’s Treatise on Masonry Construction’’—
Wiley & Sons (1899), (particularly pages 272
and 291).
“TIT Knight’s Mechanical Dictionary”? (pp. 28, 29,
30, 49, 420-422, inclusive).
“The Engineering Record,’’ Vol. 54, Oct. 20, 1906
(pp. 424 to 427, inclusive).
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 25
WS ARE:
“‘Railroad Gazette, A Journal of Transportation,
Engineering and Railroad News,’’ April 20,
1906, Vol. 40, No. 16 (pp. 404 to 406, inclusive).
‘“‘Engineering News,’’ Oct. 19, 1905, Vol. LIV,
No. 16 (pp. 407 to 409, inclusive).
‘‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil
Engineers,’’ July 1879, Vol. 8 (pp. 186 to 188,
inclusive).
‘‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil
Engineers,’’ Dec. 1892, Vol. 27 (pp. 659, 662,
663, 664, 665 and 666).
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Society of Civil
Engineers, 1896, Paper No. 2873, Vol. CX XIII
(pp. 62, 63 and 64).
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Institution of
Civil Engineers, 1887, Paper No. 2157, Vol.
LXXXIX (pp. 2 to 32, inclusive).
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Institution of
Civil Engineers, 1896, Paper No. 2784, Vol.
CXXV (p. 303).
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Institution of
Civil Engineers, 1896, Paper No. 2784, Vol.
CXXV (p. 386).
Transactions of the Institution of Naval Architects,
1898, Vol. XL (pp. 127 to 131, inclusive, and °
plates XXX and XXX1I).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Jan. 1902, Vol. 6, No. 11 (pp.
1655 to 1659, inclusive).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ August 1902, Vol. 7, No. 6
(pp. 1941 to 1943, inclusive). [23]
‘Compressed Air,’’ March 1903, Vol. 8, No. 6 (pp.
2515 and 2516).
yoy
PRL de LE SATE OD. ea
26 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ September 1903, Vol. 8, No. 7
(pp. 2566 and 2567).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ October 1903, Vol. 8, No. 8
(pp. 2594 to 2598, inclusive).
‘Compressed Air,’’? May 1904, Vol. 9, No. 3 (pp.
2911 to 2922, inclusive).
‘‘Compressed Air,”’ June 1904, Vol. 9, No. 4 (pp.
2975 and 2976).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ January 1905, Vol. 9, No. 8
(p. 3320).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ February 1905, Voi. 9, No. 12
(pp. 3347 to 3355, inclusive).
‘Compressed Air,’’ December 1905, Vol. 10, No. 10
(pp. 3792 to 3795, inclusive).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ February 1906, Vol. 10, No. 12
(p. 3897).
‘‘Compressed Air,’? September 1903, Vol. 8, No. 7
(p. 3572).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ April 1903, Vol. 8, No. 2, (pp.
2330 and 2331).
‘Compressed Air,”’ June 1896, Vol. 1, No. 4 (p. 3).
Book by George Frederick Zimmer, ‘* The Mechani-
cal Handling of Material,—being a treatise on
the handling of material such as gold, ore, tim-
ber, and seed by automatic or semi-automatic
machinery,’ published by D. Van Nostrand
Co., New York, 1905 (pp. 107 to 116, inclusive).
‘Engineering News,’’ October 11, 1906, Vol. LVI,
No. 15 (pp. 374 and 375).
‘*Revue Generale des Chemins de Fer et des Tram-
ways,’’ Vol. XXIX, No. 1 (pp. 529 to 4539, in-
clusive) (1906).
BW idgiesvei ee NN REY i
ce
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 27
‘‘Centralblatt der Bauverwaltung,’’ Feb. 21, 1891,
XI year, No. 8 (pp. 73 to 75); No. 9, February
28, 1891 (pp. 84 and 85). [24]
‘Zeitschrift des Vereines Deutscher Ingenieure,”’
Dec. 7, 1901, Vol. XXXXV, No. 49 (pp. 1756
and 1757).
‘‘Zentrallblatt der Bauverwaltung,’’ Oct. 17, 1903,
No. XXLLL year, No. 83 (pp. 517 and 518, with
illustrations 1 and 2 on p. 516).
‘‘Le Genie Civil,’’ March 19, 1904, Vol. XLIV,
No. 20 (pp. 314 to 317, inclusive).
‘Zeitschrift des Vereines Deutscher Ingenieure,”’’
July 16, 1904, Vol. 48, No. 29 (pp. 1080 and
1081).
‘‘Le Genie Civil,’’ Dee. 29, 1900, Vol. XXXVITI,
No. 9 (p. 145).
‘‘Le Genie Civil,’? Sept. 21, 1895, Vol. XX VII,
No. 21 (pp. 327 to 329, inclusive).
‘‘Tunnel Shields,’? by William Charles Cowper-
thwait, 1905 (Fig. 56, pp. 94 and 95).
Eighth Annual Report of the Boston Transit Com-
mission.
‘*Engineering News,’’ January 25, 1902 (pp. 74, 75
and 76).
Cockburn Barrow Machine Co. ‘*Catalogue C,”’
Jersey City, N. J.. U. S. A. (particularly
p. 100).
‘*Engineering News,’’ January 9, 1902, Vol. XLVIT,
Part 2 (pp. 35 and 36).
‘*Engineering News,”’ February 6, 1902, Vol.
XLV Ii, No. 6 (p. 113).
ht
—
i
wh
<
F
28 Concrete Mizing and Conveying Company
‘*Transactions of the American Society of Civil
Engineers," Vol. XXIX, Sept. 1893 (pp. 639
to 643, inclusive, together with Plate No. 1,
illustrative of the article).
‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil
Engineers,” Vol. XXX, December 1893 (pp.
379 to 583, inclusive).
‘‘Engineering Record,” March 12, 1904 (pp. 329,
330 and 331).
‘Engineering Record,” Mar. 4, 1905 (pp. 232 to
235, inclusive).
‘Engineering News,’ Mar. 7, 1891, Vol. XXV,
No. 10 (pp. 200 and 221). [25]
‘*Engineering News.”* Sept. 12, 1895, Vol. XXXIV,
No. 11 (p. 165).
*-Le Genie Civil."* Sept. 21, 1895, Vol. XX VII, No.
21 (p. 327).
‘*Le Genie Civil.” Dec. 29, 1900, Vol. XXXVITI,
No. 9 (p. 145).
‘Construction Capacity and Cost of Operating
Dredging Machines of Several Types in Recent
Exeavations of Large Magnitude,’’ by John
Bogart, being communication 3 in Section 2 of
the I. X. International Navigation Congress,
1502 (pp. 10 and 1i and also title page).
‘Engineering News.” June 13, 1895 (Illustration
appearing oppesite page 3758 and also pp. 379
and 38U).
‘Engineering News,” June 13, 1895 (pp. 384, 385,
386 and 3s7).
**Engineering Record,” Jan. 6, 1900 (pp. 2, 3 and
4).
ED A= Srp r Ht ac Mats ce oh aT en ee ee ee a ae eae a
-— —-
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 29
‘“‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil
Engineers,’ Vol. XX XI, January 1894 (pp. 70
and 71).
‘“‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil
Engineers,’ Vol. XX XI, May 1894 (pp. 492
and 493).
Paragraph I of the Fourth Affirmative Defense,
page 7 of the Answer, after “‘Ransome Concrete
Machinery Company of Dunellen, New Jersey, in
1905,’’ and the following:
Com pany”
onveying
380 Concrete Mixing and C
SOWYS Popul) oq}
UT doeqMs[O pur “Vg ‘Ysings}ig JV
‘S9IVIG poaytug oy}
UI doyMaS[O puw “vg ‘YSings}tg VW
‘SOHAS popu) oq}
UL deYAMas[o pue ‘oIlgg ‘teuUTuUT,)
“auay, ‘siydwoyy “eg ‘ysinqsyig 1y
‘SOPVJY PIU 9} UL aloyMosyo
pue ‘viutoyyey ut [pe ‘orepng, pure
AAO PJXg_ poy ‘oswuray uvg py
‘SOPUY POPU oY} UL oLotMosyo
pue ‘emiiojyeg ul [pe ‘orvpny, puv
MAO Jujg_ poy ‘oostuvaiy uvg py
‘IS, JO aorxgq
“Ud
‘Gsangsyitg
“td
‘YBaNGs} tg
SHPO
‘OOSDUBLY Ug
“SHPO
‘OOSTOULLY Ug
“yep
‘OOSLULY UNS
‘QOUIPINe
‘pvoriVy viava;ssuueg
‘puoi
“HY Surauuoy oro
‘stuMag "D "VY
[oz]
‘XI uysny
‘Xt CV pavaps
‘OUIUN
a
>
A 2 Ee
vs. R. C. Storric d& Company.
"SOPBIS Popul)
ay} Ul ddaqaasya pur “ey ‘anyding }V
"Sd}PVJG popUs) oy} Ul
d1IYMS]O puv “py “UO, sMmoO.Laudg }V
"SayVJG PoHUG oY} UL oto AMros[o
pue ‘ytoX MON ‘APL YOR AON FV
‘SaJVIG popu 9G} UL alot Mos[o
puv ‘yaoxX MON ‘APL YOR MON FV
"SaqV}G popu 9y} UL alo Maso
pue “[yp ‘osvoryD “eg “ysings}td +V
‘S9}PVPG pops) of}
UI adayMosTa pue “Vg ‘YsINgs}td IV
‘S8}BPS pops) ot}
ur alayaasfa puv “eq “YsIngs}}td IV
9S] JO aor
“ery ‘anygding
‘puvp Arey
“uiog smo.iudg
‘y10K MON
‘AULD YAOK MON
‘yO K MON
‘AY YAOK MON
“TIT ‘osworyy
“ed
‘erqdpapelqd
“Bd
‘YSAngs} ld
‘QOUIPISI
“og angding uomp
“OD PAG puvpAseyy
‘suopuneyg "T “AA
“O09
[Jaq Juvatsag-[]os103uT
‘19a MO “UL
“og coywyg VAC
‘PPO “AL “SOUL
* *QUU NT
Bert
32 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
“SOPEIS Popul)
oy} Ul aloyMasta pue “ey ‘AoTMoIg
“ey “anyding ‘tmosstp_ ‘vyoy tv
“SO}EYS POPUL)
94} Ul dtaqyMosta pue “ery ‘AaTMoIgQ WV
“SOPEYS Popuyy
oY} UI aloyMes[a pue “ey ‘AoTMOID WV
“BOPSYS Popul)
oY} Ul aLoyMosTa pue “ey ‘inyding iy
“B9PEYS Popul)
94} UI alaqMosta pue “ey ‘inyding }V
4 "SOPEYS Popul)
oq} Ul dloyMes[a pue “eT ‘inqgding }V
"S}B1G Pa}UG 9} UI a1eyAasta
pue “ey ‘Aamorg “ey ‘anyqding 1V
‘IS JO d0VI
‘TANOSSTY “BIO
“ery ‘UMOSULIVI
“ery ‘AaTMOLD
‘SUBITIQ) MON
‘sexay, ‘JuUOUNvog
“ey ‘anyding
“ery ‘inyding
‘Q0UIPISIIY
‘SILIVE]T “9 Owly
“\joqqy WOLATY
[12]
‘wosnq “WW “AA
‘SUIAT “J punuIpy
‘suluulayy “7T uyor
‘TTOMXV I "M JENWULS
‘TOAD YY UA
“oUIvN
33
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company.
| ‘SO}VIG Popul) oy}
UL edoyAMos[a pu ‘OIyQ “Weulouly
“quay, ‘stydwey “eq “Ysings}tq V
"SoyBYG popu) oy} url
aLoyMosya pue !yxIOX MON ‘APO YOR
MON {Aaszope MON ‘A}IQ Aostae FV
"SOzEYS POUL) IY}
UI a1oqyMosta puv ‘veuLIpuy ‘gj10de'] 1V
"S$aje}Q popu 9G} Ul aL MeSTo
pure “ery ‘suvajIQ MON “TIT ‘osvoryD 3V
"$9819
poeytuy eG} Ul s1oyMesTe pue ‘£98.10 f°
MON ‘asuvIQ yey “ssp “W0sog 7V
"S8}B}S popu {)
ay} Ul stoyMes[a pur “TIT ‘osvotyy 1V
"so}e}g pe}uf) oq}
UI aLeyMas[a pue “ey ‘sUBeTIQ MON FV
‘aS JO dR
“FILO
‘BdIUOTT BUCY
‘£9S10 f° MON
‘AytIQ) Aosa9 ¢°
"uu0n
‘UdAvH{ MON
“III ‘osvoryy
“ssvy ‘U0}sod
“TIT ‘osvory
“TJ ‘oseorgD
‘QOUIPTSO YY
‘ppoy ‘SOUL
‘Kuedwuoy surypoe jy
9 MOoLIVg wing)
“ap “aryte'y “A MA
“OQ prot
[rey = [eajuo/-stoury{L
‘Tezzng “ML
‘AaPOYV “A “O
aya *§ ‘SOG
“OUI NT
34 Concrete Miring and Conveying Company
"S8}EIS Popul
24} UI deYyMas[O pue fsseyy ‘U0}
“Ssoq ‘yIoX MIN ‘APO YOR MAN FV
"SOIVID POPUL OY} UT Ilo AMosjo
pure “oy ‘sthoyy YW “sseyy ‘uoysog fy
SoWVIG peylug, 94} UL dLaqAosto
pue “oy ‘stnoyT 1g “sseyq ‘uojsog VW
"SO}VIG pal) 9G} Ul Loy Mosfo
pue “oy, ‘stnoyT }Q “sseyq ‘uojsog TV
‘SOIVIG psyUy oY} Ul dLeqyMoasyo
pue “oy ‘stnoy yg “ssey_ ‘Uojsog FV
"S9}LVIG
poevug sy} UL dIoyMas[a pur “ssvyT
‘uojsog ‘yIOX MON ‘AH YOR MON FV
‘OS(] JO wvId
“WU
‘POLO
"YOK MON ‘AYO
puv[s] suo'yT
"yO K MON
‘AHI YOK MIN
"YOK MON
‘A}IQ YAOA MON
"yao K MON
‘APL YLOX MON
“YLO MONT
‘APT YAO MON
‘QOUIPISOY
‘PPTULO NITY “dT “SOUL
[36]
‘Aydanyy ‘¢ peipuy
‘TIUVGNIN poly]
‘UBUULLIOTY “9 AA
‘WRISIG ‘004)
“LOTIVYS “VY
“OUIU NT
Veale TK Ml
35
us. R. C. Storrie d Company.
"S9}BIS pozytuy) oy}
UL dlo4Mes[a puv ‘AssIae MON ‘AITO
Aasiap Syilox MON ‘AY YIOK MON JV
"S9}EYS poytuy) oy}
UL d1oGAos[a puv ‘Assdar MIN ‘AJIO
Aasief? !y10X MEN ‘A119 YIOX MON IV
"SO}BIS Pe} 9Y} ur arayMasya
pue !y10ox may ‘A}I9 YOK MIN 4V
‘S}BIS poyU) oy} Ul aloyMasta pur
““SSRIY ‘Wosog ‘Aostape MON ‘AYO
AVSAIP SYIOK MIN ‘AID YOK MIN FV
‘S9}ES Pou) ay}
UL dLoYAos[a puv ‘AVsdar MAN ‘AJIQ
Asia fyIOX man ‘A419 YIOX MIN FV
‘IS JO vorxjig
‘AVSIO MON
‘AVL Aosta ¢*
*AOS.1O[? MONT
‘AW Aosta p
‘AVS.1Of? MONT
‘AVI Aas f*
"YIOK MON
‘AY YLOK MON
"YIOK MON
‘AVL YOK MIN
‘QOUIPISIY
‘UST 93.1004)
‘A[[OUUOD “UL AA
‘PLATO Soure ¢
‘plojueg *N "
‘HEH “d “V ydasor
“QUIEN
2 RIO Oe
36 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
"S3}8}S Popul)
ay} Ul edayaasfa pus “ey ‘AaTMOID FV
"89}8}S popya{)
ay} Ul dloyAMas[sa pure “VT ‘£I[MOIN, FW
"S948 Popul)
ay} UT ILoyMasTa pur “evry ‘Ko]MOID) FW
"So}BIG po PUL) 9}
UI alayMosya pus “ey “suUBITIQ MON FV
"SO}BYS
pez}tUy 24} Ul sLoYMasTo PUB ‘epllo[
Ysa, Ay pue wey woesjod
emprey ysvoy seq epuopy yt UO
*$0}81S
peu 94} Ul eLleyMesTe pus ‘eplsol,
4soy, Ady pue TBI weesjoq
semprey ysvog yseq epwo,, q} UO
‘aSt) JO a08[q
OB] ‘KoTMOLAD
“ery ‘AaTMOL)
“ery ‘AaTMOLD
6.
FUEOD
‘ooSTOUBI YT UPS
‘eplto[
‘suTysnsny "}S
“TT ‘osvoryD
‘Q0UaPISE YY
‘deel UNOL
‘oyURAy “ove
‘eyuo[peyT “OD ‘SOL
‘ppeyueet) “S “MA
‘FLOpIIqO “OD
‘UIMd] “OD “V
‘SUIRN
y safe sath wee
37
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company.
“BOPBIS Popul)
ay} Ul ateayMas[a pure ‘ey ‘YeuUBA
BG ‘ep ‘uoIsua}xq ysoA, AdY
‘AVM[IEY JSVOL) JSVYL VPLLO[Y 94} UO
"SO}VIG popuy
dy} UL atayMos[a puBv fey ‘YVUULA
Ug f'R[y ‘UOISUDIXm YSoA, ADM
‘AUMIIVY JSVOD) JSUT CPLIO[Y oY} UG
“B8PBIS PopMt()
oy} UL deyMospa puR fey “qeu
-UVALY f'R[ ‘WOISUD}XW JSOA\ AY
‘AUM[IVY 4SVOD 4SeY eVpluol,y ey} UO
[62] ‘sa}eyg peyUy
94} UI aleymosta pue “ey ‘Ao[MOID FV
‘a8f) JO 0R[gG
“el “Tuer
“el ‘TUIeryy
“Bp “TUT
“ery ‘AdTMOL()
‘QOUIPIS9Y
‘TOUIV MA “J, 28.1004)
‘U0}}09 4Soudy
‘UOSTIM “TT ANI
‘slopuey ‘¢ UeTyoIH
‘Ue N
-=-
Company
onveying
g and C
rin
38 Concrete M
"S8PBYS PHU’) 9G} ul
DLO MOISPO PUB TRMOT SUWOStIpR]Y }loyp LV
‘SOVPS Popul) oy}
I DLO Mas[o PUR SYIPR) SOUUGSHiE LY
"S9}VIG Pops] 9G} UL dLoyMasjo
pue ‘yIoX MON ‘AYIQ YOK MON FV
"SO}VJY PoPUY 94} UI a1oyM
-as[a puv ‘Aosiape MAN ‘A}IQ Aosta VV
"SOIVIW Pop)
a4} Ul doy Moespo pu ier “YLUUVA
VQ Up ‘UOTSHOINTD = Jso qq Ao
‘LUMIIEY, YSvO,) JSS LPLLO[.P IY, UC
‘aS JO aarIq
be
FEO
‘ooSLOURI URg
be bs
FMEO
‘OOSLURI UNG
‘YOR MON
‘A}LQ YAO MON
‘AOSLOP? MON
‘A}LQ Avso rp?
“Rp “TURTyy
‘QUIPISOY
NYY “a
‘JAVMMAVIL ELV
‘syood) “H “OD
9310g9T “DH
‘Suly “f pavypry
“OUI
At EA
us. R. C. Storrie & Company. 39
and by others at present unknown to defendant but
whose names and locations defendants pray leave
to add by amendment when discovered.
CHADWICK, MceMICKEN, RAMSEY
& RUPP,
STEPHEN F. CHADWICK,
Solicitors for Defendant.
CHAS. E. TOWNSEND,
WM. A. LOFTUS,
Of Counsel.
Dated: July 7, 1927.
Copy of within amendment to answer received
this 7th day of Juty, 1927.
BATTLE, HULBERT & HELSELL,
Attorneys for Plaintiff.
Filed July 7, 1927. [30]
—_—_—————
[Title of Court and Cause. |
ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR CONTINU-
ANCE AND DIRECTING DEFENDANT
TO FILE BILL OF PARTICULARS.
This matter coming on for hearing before the
above-entitled court and the parties hereto, by their
respective counsel, having heretofore submitted to
the Court in chambers the defendant's motion for
continuance herein and the plaintiff’s motion for a
bill of particulars herein, and the Court having con-
sidered said motions and the affidavits herein and
the arguments of counsel, and having announced its
conclusion,—
40 Concrete Mizing and Conveying Company
NOW, THEREFORE, conformably to the con-
clusion heretofore announced, it is by the Court
CONSIDERED, ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND
DECREED that the motion for continuance herein
be and the same is hereby denied, to which ruling on
the part of the Court the defendant excepts and its
exception is hereby allowed.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED
AND DECREED that the ruling of the Court upon
the motion fer continuance is without prejudice to
the defendant moving the Court for leave to sup-
plement its record upon trial by the deposition of
such witnesses and the submission of such testimony
as could not have been obtained at the trial by the
exercise of due diligence. [31]
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED, ADJUDGED
AND DECREED. upen the consideration of the
motion for a bill of particulars herein, that the de-
fendant, on or before the 6th day of September,
1927, make designation in good faith of such United
States patents and fereign patents, and such pub-
lieations, and such prior uses, as will be relied upon
by the defendant at the trial of the above-entitled
cause, and that such designation be without preju-
dice to defendant relying upon other United States
patents, foreign patents, publications, and prior
uses, as May be reasonably shown to be necessary
to the proper defense of the above-entitled cause,
because of the evidence produced at the trial on the
part of the plaintiff? herein, and that all matters of
cost in connection with the granting of the bill of
particulars herein be addressed to the Court at the
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 41
time of the trial of the above-entitled cause, to all
of which the defendant excepts and its exception is
allowed,
Done in open court this 2 day of September, 1927.
JEREMIAH NETERER,
Judge.
O. K. form
CHADWICK, MeM. R. & R.,
For Deft.
BATTLE, HULBERT & HELSELL,
Attys. for PIff.
Filed Sep. 2, 1927. [32]
[Title of Court and Cause. ]
DEFENDANT'S BILL OF PARTICULARS.
Now comes the defendant above named, and pur-
suant to order of Court gives the following lists of
patents, publications, and prior uses, which as far
as it is advised at present, and without prejudice
to correction and enlargement or modification, as
may develop or as the Court may direct, will offer
at the trial either by way of anticipation or to show
the state of the art:
420 Conerete Mixing and Conveying Company
Patent
Number.
7,060
45,153
47,793
99,360
4,953
122,498
204,725
233,499
250,602
Patent
Number.
273,025
274.103
298,990
327,307
338,138
416,180
425,624
240,265
472,072
487,606
487,639
497,427
523,838
926,529
UNITED STATES PATENTS.
Date.
Jan. 6,
Jan. 29,
Nov. 22,
May 23,
Feb. 1,
June 18,
Jan. 2,
June 11,
Oct. 19,
Dec. 6,
1809
1850
1864
1865
1870
1872
1872
1878
1880
1881
Inventor.
Upham.
Potts.
Gunning.
Brear.
Sickels.
Sickles (Reissue).
Smith.
Gunning.
Frizell.
Thiollier et al.
[33:3]
UNITED STATES PATENTS.
(Continued. )
Date.
Mar. 6,
Mar. 20,
May 20,
Sep. 29,
Mar. 16,
Dec. 3,
Apr. 15,
Apr. 19,
Apr. 5,
Dec. 6,
Dec. 6,
May 16,
July 31,
Sep.
1883
1883
1884
1885
1886
1889
1890
1881
1892
1892
1892
1895
1894
1894
Inventor.
Smith.
Ayres.
Leedy.
Peters.
Buell.
Neukireh,
O'Neil.
Palmer.
Patterson,
Church.
Pohle.
Hlussey and Harsen.,
‘Hussey.
Hussey.
Patent.
Number.
526,530
526,531
526,652
542,620
542,622
555,704
68,445
568,742
577,522
597,023
635,270
636,279
646,640
660,946
Patent
Number,
669,409
676,128
671,302
676,129
707,840
734,773
738,326
747,396
749,206
759,100
799,642
—
i
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 43
Date. Inventor.
Sep. 25, 1894 Hussey.
Sep. 25, 1894 Hussey.
Sep. 25, 1894 Hussey.
July 16, 1895 Bacon.
July 16, 1895 Bacon.
Mar. 3, 1896 Hussey.
Sep. 29, 1896 Kennedy.
Oct. 6, 1896 Church.
Feb. 23, 1897 Wallwork and Wells.
Jan. 11, 1898 Saunders,
Oct. 17, 1899 Rix and Donahoo.
Noy. 7, 1899 Newhouse.
Apr. 3, 1900 Evans.
Oct. 30, 1900 Butler. [34]
"NITED STATES PATENTS.
(Continued. )
Date. Inventor.
Mar. 5, 1901 Dunn.
June 11, 1901 Goldie.
Apr. 2, 1901 Warren.
June 11, 1901 Goldie.
Aug. 26, 1902 Goldie.
July 28, 1903 Stuart.
Sep. 8, 1903 Higyins.
Dee, 22, 1903 Farnham
Jan. 12, 1904 Limbert.
May — 3, 1904 Harris.
Sep. 19, 1905 Frasch,
44 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
Patent
Number. Date. Inventor.
800,127 Sep. 19, 1905 Frasch.
814,601 Mar. 6, 1906 Harris.
873,345 Dec. 10, 1907 Caniff (Filed Oct. 29,
1906).
870,620 Nov. 12, 1907 Frasch.
958,421 May 17, 1910 Mellvrid (filed Nov. 2
1905).
977,444 Dee. 6, 1910 Frasch (filed Oct. 30,
1903).
988,995 Apr. 11, 1911 Frasch (filed Oct. 30,
1903).
778,878 Jan. 3, 1905 Moir.
BRITISH PATENTS.
4,400 Dec. 18, 1875 Duckham.
8,451 Oct. 13, 1884 Gordon.
' 15,348 Dec. 14,1885 Duckham.
j 5,221 1886 Greathead.
4 11,456 Aug. 8, 1888 Neukirch. [35]
: FRENCH PATENTS.
Patent
Number. Date. Inventor.
5,707 Dec. 8, 1838 Triger.
$22,227 June 19, 1902 Grauer & Cie.
GERMAN PATENTS.
42,513 Feb. 17, 1887 Jeziorskyy
46,842 July 24, 1888 Neukirch.
18,394 Oct. 16, 1881 Ludwig Kolsche.
37,503 Sep. 29, 1885 Poetsch.
, .
PIO Vex a
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 45
PUBLICATIONS.
The Pohlé Air Lift Pump—1894 Catalog—New
York.
‘‘Air Lift Pumping,’ by Edward A. Rix, San
rancisco, March 1, 1904.
‘‘Compressed Air Information or Cyclopedia Con-
taining Practical Papers on the Production,
Transmission and Use of Compressed Air,”’
Edited by W. L. Saunders, published by ‘‘Com-
pressed Air,’’ 26 Cortlandt St., New York—
Copyright 1903, by ‘‘Compressed Air,’’ and
particularly pages 81, 181, 182, 183, 249, 250,
343, 594, to 599, inclusive, 602, 603, 656, 657, 4
663, 664, 665, 691, 829, 830, 847 to 862, inclusive, .f
1017, 1018 to 1032, 1040 to 1050, inclusive, 1144
and 1145.
‘‘Compressed Air, Its Production, Uses and Appli-
cations’’ by Gardner D. Hiscox, Fourth Edition,
published by Norman W. Henley & Co., 132
Nassau St., New York, 1903, ‘‘Copyright, 1901,
by Norman W. Henley & Co.’’ (Chapter
XXXII, and particularly pages 711 to 729).
‘*Harper’s Weekly,’’ Issue of January 28, 1893
(pp. 89 and 90).
Catalog No. 73 ot the Ingersoll-Sergeant Drill Co.,
First Edition, 1905, entitled ‘‘Water Lifted by
Compressed Air.”’
‘**Compressed Air,’’ Vol. II, New York, June, 1897,
No. 4 (p. 234).
“‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. II, New York, September,
1897, No. 7 (page 295). [36]
a ENE LOT EE TST STEN PGT IO TRS Me peRteA
46 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
PUBLICATIONS.
(Continued. )
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. Ili, New York, March
1898, No. 1 (Page 403).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. ITI, New York, April,
1898, No. 2 (Page 420).
‘*Compressed Air,’’ Vol. VIII, New York, April,
1903, No. 2 (Pages 223, 230 and 231).
‘Compressed Air,’’ Vol. VIII, New York, January
1904, No. 11 (pp. 2723, to 2735 inclusive).
‘*Dredging Operations and Appliances’’—Proceed-
ings of the Institution of Civil Engineers,
March 1, 1887, London, re Dueckman’s Pneu-
matie Dredger.
‘‘Baker’s Treatise on Masonry Construction’’—
Wiley & Sons (1899) (particularly pages 272
and 291).
‘*T Knight’s Mechanical Dictionary”’ (pp. 28, 29, 30,
49, 420-422 inclusive).
‘“‘The Engineering Record, ‘‘ Vol. 54, Oet. 20, 1906
(pp. 424 to 427, inclusive).
‘‘Railroad Gazette, A Journal of Transportation,
Engineering and Railroad News.’’ April 20,
1906, Vol. 40, No. 16 (pp. 404 to 406, inclusive),
‘‘Engineering News,’’ Oct. 19, 1905, Vol. LIV, No.
16 (pp. 407 to 409, inclusive),
“Transactions of the American Society of Civil
Engineers,’’ July 1879, Vol. 8 (pp. 186 to 188,
inclusive).
‘“‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil
Engineers,’’ Dec. 1892, Vol. 27 (pp. 659, 662,
663, 664, 665 and 666),
—
us. R. C. Storrie d& Company. 47
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Society of Civil
Engineers, 1896, Paper No. 2873, Vol. CX XIII
(pp. 62, 63 and 64),
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Institution of
Civil Engineers, 1887, Paper No. 2157, Vol.
LXXXIX (pp. 2 to 32, inelusive),
Minutes of the Proceedings 01 the Institution of
Civil Engineers, 1896, Paper No. 2784, Vol.
CXXV (p. 303),
Minutes of the Proceedings of the Institution of
Civil Engineers, 1896, Paper No. 2784, Vol.
CXXV (p. 386). [37]
PUBLICATIONS.
(Continued. )
Transactions of the Institution of Naval Archi-
tects, 1898, Vol. XL (pp. 127 to 131, inclusive,
and plats XXX and XXXII).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ Jan. 1902, Vol. 6, No. 1i (pp.
1655 to 1659, inclusive).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ August 1902, Vol. 7, No. 6 (pp.
1941 to 1943, inclusive).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ March, 1903, Vol. 8, No. 6, No.
6 (pp. 2515 and 2516).
‘*Compressed Air,’? September 1903, Vol 8, No. 7+
(pp. 2566 and 2567).
“Compressed Air,’’? October 1903, Vol. 8, No. 8 (pp.
2594 to 2598, inclusive).
‘**Compressed Air,’? May 1904, Vol. 9, No. 3 (pp.
2911 to 2922, inclusive).
‘*Compressed Air,’? June 1904, Vol. 9, No. 4 (pp.
2975 and 2976).
CRE Pee eaT Erte ae
|
ER OA AE OLS plea OE Ne BS NI et pee PS
48 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ January 1905, Vol. 9, No. 8 (p.
3320).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ February 1905, Vol. 9, No. 12
(pp. 3347 to 3355, inclusive).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ December 1905, Vol. 10, No. 10
(pp. 3792 to 3795, inclusive).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ February 1906, Vol. 9, No. 12
(p. 3897).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ September 1903, Vol. 8, No. 7
(p. 3572).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ April 1903, Vol. 8, No. 2 (pp.
—-- 2330 and 2331).
‘‘Compressed Air,’’ June 1896, Vol. 1, No. 4 (p. 3).
Book by George Frederick Zimmer, ‘‘The Mechani-
cal Handling of Material,—being treatise on the
handling of material such as gold, ore, timber,
and seed by automatic or semi-automatic ma-
chinery,’’ published by D. Van Nostrand Co.,
New York, 1905 (pp. 107 to 116), inclusive).
‘‘Engineering News,’’ October 11, 1906, vol. LVI,
No. 15 (pp. 374 and 375).
‘‘Revue Generale des Chemins de Fer et des Tram-
ways,’’ Vol. XXIX, No. 1 (pp. 529 to 539, in-
clusive) (1906). [38]
PUBLICATIONS.
(Continued. )
‘‘Contrablatt der Bauverwaltung,’’ Feb. 21, 189],
XI year, No. 8 (pp. 73 to 75) No. 9, February
28, 1891 (pp. 84 and 85).
F vs. R. C. Storrie d Company. _ 49
‘‘Zeitschrift des Vereines Deutscher Ingenieure,”’
Dec. 7, 1901, Vol. XXXXV, No. 49 (pp. 1756 ;
and 1757). :
‘‘Zentrallblatt der Bauverwaltung,’’ Oct. 17, 1903, i
:
No. XXLLL year, No. 83 (pp. 517 and 518,
with illustrations 1 and 2 on p. 516).
‘‘Le Genie Civil,’’ March 19, 1904, Vol. XLIV, No.
20 (pp. 314 to 317, inclusive).
‘‘Zeitschraft des Vereines Deutscher Ingenieure,”’
July 16, 1904, Vol. 48, No. 29 (pp. 1080 and
1081).
‘‘Le Genie Civil,’’? Dec. 29, 1900, Vol. XX XVIII,
No. 9 (p. 145).
‘‘Le Genie Civil,’’ Sept. 21, 1895, Vol. XX VII, No.
21 (pp. 327 to 329, inclusive).
‘“‘Tunnel Shields,’ by William Charles Cowper-
thwait, 1905 (Fig. 56, pp. 94 and 95).
Eighth Annual Report of the Boston Transit Com-
mission.
‘‘Engineering News,’’ January 25, 1902 (pp. 74, 79
and 76).
‘‘Cockburn Barrow Machine Co. ‘‘Catalogue C,”’
Jersey City, N. J., U. S. A. (particularly p.
100).
. ‘Engineering News,’’ January 9, 1902, Vol.
XLVII, part 2 (pp. 35 and 36).
‘‘Engineering News,’ February 6, 1902, Vol.
XLVII, No. 6 (p. 113).
‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil En-
gineers,’’ Vol. XXIX, Sept. 1893 (p. 639 to p.
643, inclusive, together with Plats No. 1, illus-
trative of the article).
WH Conerete Mixing and Conveying Company
‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil En-
gineers,’’ Vol. XXX, December 1893 (pp. 579
to 583, inclusive).
‘*Engineering Record,’? March 12, 1904 (pp. 329,
330 and 331). [89]
PUBLICATIONS.
(Continued. )
‘‘Engineering Record,’? Mar. 4, 1905 (pp. 232 to
235, inclusive).
‘*Engineering News,’’ Mar. 7, 1891, Vol. X XV, No.
10 (pp. 200 and 221).
‘*Engineering News,’’ Sept. 12, 1895, Vol. XXXIV,
No. 11 (p. 163).
‘*Le Genie Civil,’’ Sept. 21, 1895, Vol. XX VII, No.
21 (p. 327).
‘‘Le Genie Civil,’’ Dee. 29, 1900, Vol. XX XVII,
No. 9 (p. 145).
‘*Construction Capacity and Cost of Operating
Dredging Machines of Several Types in Re-
cent Excavations of Large Magnitude,’’ by
_ John Bogart, being communication 3, in Sec-
tion 2 of the I. X. International? Navigation
Congress, 1902 (pp. 10 and 11 and also title
page). |
‘‘Engineering News,’’ June 13, 1895 (Illustration
appearing opposite page 378 and also pp. 379
and 380).
‘‘Engineering News,’’ June 13, 1895 (pp. 384, 385,
386 and 387).
eae so aed -
vs. R. C. Storrie d& Company. 51
“Engineering Record,’ Jan. 6, 1900 (pp. 2, 3, and
4).
“Transactions of the American Society of Civil En-
gineers,’"’ Vol. XXXI, January 1894 (pp. 70
and 71).
‘‘Transactions of the American Society of Civil En-
gineers,’’ Vol. XX XI, May 1894 (pp. 492 and
493). .
re et
Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
iD
S2}8}5 Po}TUQ ay}
Uy eleymes[a pue “vg ‘qsIngs}}iq iV “ed ‘Ysingsytq ‘Ppoy “MA ‘SOUT,
"S9}BIG pa}ytuQ sq} ‘peor
UT eteymes[a pue “vg “YSIngs}tq iV “ed ‘Gsingsyigq -[ley SZuljoeuu0pQ = o1yoO
‘OS JO v0vIg ‘9DUIPISEY ‘OWeN
(‘panurju0g )
‘aSO wold GNV NOILLNAANI YOINd
‘Sa}BIG paytug ay}
Ur aTeqmesya pue ‘orgg ‘yeuUTUTD “BIUIOJ Lor]
“uuay, ‘siqdweyy “eg ‘qaings}}ig }V -¥Q ‘oospurrg ug ‘stuusg ‘0 “"V
S338} Pe}tUL oY} UT e1dymaste
pue ‘BIuloJIeQ Ul [je ‘areiny, pus *‘wIUIOJ
aq[tA01g ‘pug pey ‘oostouvlg ueg iW -l[¥Q ‘oostouvig urg
aS) JO aug ‘soUapIsay
‘ASO YOrdd GNV NOLINGANI YOrdd
‘XTY “V preapy
‘aule NT
'
|
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company.
SS CaP BS ras
*S9}BLS
peu oy} ut steqmMasta puv ‘fosi0¢
MON ‘aSuvIQ yseq ‘ssey_ ‘uojsog }V
"S8zZBIS popu) oy}
Ul s1dyMasT?e pus “wT ‘SUvITIO AION FV
"S8}8}S pops)
aq} Ul slaqMesTa pue “vy ‘ingding iV
"S97z8IS poyuy)
aq} UT adaqmasta puv “ey “Inqding +V
"S9}B}G PIU) of} Ul sLoqMesto
pue “ey ‘Aapmorg “wy ‘anqding iV
"S8}8}S Popul)
ay} UT araqMesta pus “vy] ‘inqd[ng iV
"SOZVIG PIU of} Ul slayMasyo
pue ‘y10X MON ‘AND FOR MON FV
‘9S f) JO 908d
“sseyy ‘uoj}sog
“TI ‘osvoryD
‘suUBaTIQ AON
“ery ‘anqding
“ery ‘inqding
‘ey ‘angd[ug
‘y10K MON
‘AY YAOK MON
"souspIsey
a eeetiome: RS Et ER SOR A a IRL ic | maa naam
‘ezzng “M Lf
‘yea “S ‘SOUL
‘suday ‘WT punupy
‘TJOMXBIT “AA Ponuleg
‘TaAIVYy “YUM
“og anqd[ng worm
‘sopuneg "T "M
‘QUIeN
D4 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
—
:
“Grkt oe Pn ae ee es
"807818
poy) oY} UL dLeYMesTa pue “ssey
‘Uojsog ‘YIOX MON ‘APD YIOX MON FV
"$0181.90
Poul) 94} UT sLoyMosyTa puv “ssey
ee YIOK MON ‘AUD YIOA MON YW
‘S0}81Q pd}IUG 94} UI
sLeyMosya puv “yIOX MON ‘A}IO YO
MeN ‘Avstoe MON ‘AUIQ Avstae YW
‘SOP Popul) 94}
UI BLeyMOSTo pus ‘eULIpUT ‘9}10ge'T IV
‘S818}Q Po}IUA) 94} Ul~ereyMasTa
pue “ey ‘suvafiQ MeN “TIT ‘o8voryD 1V
aS) JO v0RITG
“YO ‘}lorjeq
‘YOK MONT
‘AYO Y1IOX MON
‘Aas
-19f MAN ‘AYID Aosta pr
“UUo0D ‘UdARFT MONT
“TIT ‘osvoryy
‘goUaPISOY
[t¥]
‘YOTULONIW “q “Soy,
‘LOTTEYS “VY
‘Auvduloy ouryo
-VY Y MoLIVgG uanqyo0g
“If ‘UDpIeT “HM
“O09
peorpiVy [erj}ueD-stour]]
‘aUBN
oo
'sa}8}1Q pazuy
= oq} Ul o1oqyMosTa pue “eT ‘AopMoIg YW “ery ‘Aopmory ‘eyursy “ov le
5 ‘S9}8}S popu)
S 4} Ur oreymosya puv “ery ‘Ka[MOIQ FV “ery ‘aT MO.1/) ‘eyud[pe{ ‘ ‘Sor
Ss "S9}B}S Popul) oy) “BTULLOF
.Q. Ul dOYMoSTa pue “VT ‘suUvITIG MON JV -T[e@9 ‘OoslouBiy urg ‘pleyueely “SM
5 ‘S0JBJG Pe}IUGQ eq} Ul sLayAes[a ‘fas .
Hm pue ‘y1oX MON ‘APIO YIOX MON YV -19¢ MON ‘AIO Aossa fr ‘pIIA[LI Sou er
: aS) Jo vov[g ‘aouspIsey “oUle NT
> (panuryu09)
‘ASN YOINd GNV NOILNAANT YOldd
*
Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
56
"So}BYS Poztuy)
04} Ul oeyMostea pue “eH ‘qeu
-UBABY ‘'eLT ‘UOTSUa}x” YsoA4 ADV
‘AVMIIVY 4SVOD 4SVY Bplo[y oy}, uO
"SayeyS Peztu/)
24} UL odieqyMesta pus “ey ‘qeu
-UBABG ‘BL ‘UOTSUa}xy ysaA4 AOY
‘AVMUY JSVOD YSVY Vplo[,Y] I} UO
'S9}BIS popu yy)
oq} Ul s1eqMosta pue “ery ‘AaTMOID FV
"89}8}S popta/)
aq} UI s1eqMoasta pue “ey ‘AaTMOID FV
‘aS JO veg
‘epliopg ‘wel
“eplio, yy ‘Tuer
“ery ‘AayMoIy
“ery ‘AaTMOoID
‘Q0U9PISAY
10}}09 4souIq
‘UOSTIM "T ANI
‘s1apuey “f UepyorH
‘usein) TOL
‘aUIe NT
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company.
‘Sd}B}G Pou oq} UT aleyMasya
pue ‘y10X MON ‘A}IQ YIOX MON FV
"S9}BPS POPUL) 9G} Ul 919M
-asjo pue ‘Aasiepe MON ‘AYO Aas19e VW
‘SoyepS poyuyy)
94} UL oJoyMosta pue “ey ‘qeu
-UvACg ‘Bq ‘UOIsUd}xq ysoA4 AOY
‘AUMTIVY 4SVOY ysey Vplojq ey} uO
"S9}eYS Poyuyy
94} Ul odeyMosta pue “BH ‘qWeu
-UBARS ‘BLT ‘UOIsSUa}XxG ISOM AY
‘AVM[IVY JSVOD sey Bplo[y eq} uO
aS) Jo soe g
— ee en ee ee eee oo eT
‘yO X MON
‘AVL YAOK MON
‘fas
-19f MAN ‘AyD Aasaop
‘eplio,y ‘Tweryy
‘eployy ‘tuelyy
‘Q0UdPISIY
[zr]
‘syool) “H ‘0
‘910g ‘0 “H
‘Suly “f preqory
‘JoUIv MA “IT, 93100
‘QUI’ NT
Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
08
‘sJULpUdJoq] OJ SAVUI0}VV
‘dd AY FY AUSINVY ONAMOTIVW “MOLMAVHO
‘ANHSNMOL ‘A SATYVHO
‘saoyjo Alqissod pure
*SO}eIG pola oq} Ul "VULLLOJ TITUS
JLITFMOS[I PUB SVMOT “UOSIPRIY Ploy PV ‘OOSLURA YT UR . “UNY “GY
‘SOJVIG poy sy} ur "VIMO FTV
dIYMISTO pue “spy “YSIMgsytq FV ‘OOSLIURAY WRG ‘VAVMYALTY “FV
A
‘OS, JO v0VI[q | ‘dUIPISIyy “OUIBN
(*ponutjuo, ) )
USO wold GNV NOLLNAANI YOLUd
on ae VF CARMEN gt AiR rR RIE ee
wa
Service of copy of the within defendants’ bill of
day of September,
vs. R. C. Storrie d& Company. a9
particulars admitted this
A. D. 1927.
For Plaintiff.
Filed Sep. 6, 1927. [43]
[Title of Court and Cause. ]
DEFENDANTS’ DEMAND UNDER EQUITY
RULE 58 THAT PLAINTIFF ADMIT IN !
WRITING THE GENUINENESS OF PUB-
LICATIONS.
To Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company, and
to to Battle, Hulbert, Gates & Helsell, and to
Messrs. Williams, Bradbury, McCaleb & Hinkle,
Its Solicitors and Counsel :
Come now the defendants above named and, under
Equity Rule 58, make demand of the plaintiff above
named that plaintiff admit:
1. The genuineness of the patents and publica-
tions listed in our bill of particulars served this day
on counsel for plaintiff;
2. That the dates of issuance of said patents,
United States and Foreign, and the dates of appli-
cation of the said United States patents appearing
on the printed or photostat copies thereof are true
and correct, subject to correction if error found;
3. That the dates of publication and the name
of the publisher or author, of the said several pub-
lications, are correct;
OB Pts LP a
DREGE A AE A eh. *
60 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
4. That the photostat copies of such publications
or portions. thereof and heretofore offered in evi-
dence in connection with the New York depositions
in the eases of this plaintiff vs. Great Western
Power Company, In Equity—No. 1804, pending in
the United States District Court for the Northern
District of California, Southern Division; and of
the Plaintiff vs. Stone & Webster, Incorporated,
Equity—No. 2747, pending in the United States
District Court, District of Massachusetts, and dup-
licates of which photostats have heretofore been
furnished counsel for plaintiff, are true and correct
copies of the originals of the [44] pages of such
publications or portions thereof as purported.
If such admissions be not made within five (5)
days from service hereof, defendant will move the
Court for costs of proving said patents, publica-
tions, and documents, irrespective of the outcome
of the suit.
R. C, STORRIE & COMPANY (a Partner-
ship).
By CHARLES E. TOWNSEND,
CHADWICK, McMICKEN, RAMSEY &
RUPP,
Its Attorneys.
[Endorsed]: Copy received.
Date Sept. 6, 1927.
BATTLE, HULBERT & HELSELL,
[Endorsed]: Filed Sep. 6, 1927. [45]
;
vs. R. C. Storrie d Company. 61
[Title of Court and Cause. ]
NOTICE AND INVITATION OF DEFENDANT
TO WITNESS TESTS.
To Concrete Mixing & Conveying Company, a
Corporation, and to Williams, Bradbury, Mc-
Caleb and Hinckle, and to Carey Van Fleet,
Esq., and Battle, Hulbert & Helsell, Its Attor-
neys.
You are hereby advised that on Wednesday,
September seventh, 1927, at 4:00 P. M., a series
of tests in the handling of various cementitious
mixtures, including concrete, by compressed air, will
be run at the East Portal of Sunset Tunnel,
Municipal Railways Project, in the City and County
of San Francisco, California. The evidence, testi-
mony, and results of said tests and the machines
there and then to be used will be adduced and used
in connection with the trail or trails of one or the
other or all of the following suits based on the
MeMichael patent No. 1,127,660 of February 9th,
1915, and brought by said Concrete Mixing and
Conveying Company, and now pending, to wit:
62 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
‘‘In the District Court of the United States, for
the Western District of Washington, Northern
Division.
CONCRETE MIXING & CONVEYING COM-
PANY,
Plaintiff,
vs.
R. C. STORRIE & COMPANY, a Partnership,
Defendant.
IN EQUERY—No. 394.”
‘‘In the United States District Court, for the
Northern District of California, Division Three.
CONCRETE MIXING & CONVEYING COM-
PANY,
Plaintiff,
vs.
GREAT WESTERN POWER COMPANY OF
CALIFORNIA,
Defendant.
IN EQUITY—No. 1804.” [46]
‘‘In the United States District Court, for the Dis-
trict of Massachusetts.
CONCRETE MIXING & CONVEYING COM-
PANY,
Plaintiff,
\ vs.
sia: AND WEBSTER, INCORPORATED,
\ Defendant.
\ IN EQUITY—No. 2747.”
“
vs. R. C. Storrie d& Company. 63
You and plaintiff’s experts are invited to be pres-
ent and to witness said tests.
CHAS. E. TOWNSEND,
Attorney for the Foregoing Defendants.
CHADWICK, McMICKEN, RAMSEY
& RUPP.
[ Endorsed]: Copy received.
Dated Sept. 3, 1927.
BATTLE, HULBERT & HELSELL.
[Endorsed]: Filed Sep. 6, 1927. [47]
[Title of Court and Cause. ]
ORDER SETTLING STATEMENT OF PRO.
CEEDINGS AND NARRATIVE OF TESTI-
MONY.
This cause coming on for hearing this 14th day of
February, 1928, upon the motion of the plaintiff
for an order approving the statement of proceed-
ings and narrative of testimony given at the trial of
the above-entitled action and upon the proposed
amendments, additions and objections of the de-
fendant thereto; the plaintiff and defendant being
represented by their respective solicitors,—
NOW, THEREFORE, IT IS ORDERED that
copies of the depositions of William Keever, S. W.
Maxwell, Nicklen J. Landers, John Green, Joseph
G. Menlenka, Jac. Frankel, Edmund F. Ivens, Will-
ee owe
64 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
iam H. Larkin, and Thomas S. Leake, in the exact
language of the witnesses, be certified by* the Clerk
of this court and sent to the Cireuit Court of
Appeals at San Francisco, California, as a part of
the record on appeal herein. |
That the amendments proposed by the defendant
be allowed and made a part of the said narrative of
testimony with the following changes and excep-
tions:
The last paragraph of the first proposed amenc-
ment [48] be changed to read as follows:
“Mr. WILLIAMS.—We have elected to rely
upon a somewhat less number of the claims of
the patent in suit than are set up in our bill
of complaint. We shall rely upon claims 1, 2,
17, 18, 24, 29, 34 and 35 of this patent.”’
In lieu of the amendment after line 26, page 1,
insert the following between lines 26 and 27:
‘*Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 4 objected to as not
pertinent and not competent. Objection over-
ruled and exception noted.”’ ~
In lieu of the amendment in line 7, page 2, insert
the following between lines 6 and 7, page 2:
“Defendant objected to plaintiff’s Exhibit
No. 10 as not pertinent and not competent.
Objection overruled and exception noted.”’
The amendment to line 26, page 6, be allowed
and there be added to the same the following:
“The above question objected to as not ger-
maine and objections sustained.
oe
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 65
That from line 14, on page 22, to the end of line
16, on page 22, be stricken and the following in-
serted:
“‘Q. Now, when you first learned of this
McMichael apparatus and method, were you in
a position where the matter was presented to
you for your consideration on behalf of a’ con-
tracting concern? A. Yes, sir.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—Objected to as irrele-
vant and immaterial.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—This is merely pee
nary.
- The COURT.—Overruled. Proceed to what
is material.”’
That the balance of the amendment proposed on
page 22 be omitted.
That the proposed amendment on page 27 be
allowed and that there be inserted prior to said
amendment, the following words:
““Q. What, approximately, is the weight of
a cubic yard of concrete? A. About two
to
That the proposed amendment to strike out a
portion of page 55 be denied.
That the proposed amendment in lines 22 and
“* page 56, be changed to read as follows:
Insert ‘“‘Over objection that no proper foun-
dation was laid, witness testified; ‘properly
mixed concrete forming matevials do not have
the quality of flowing as do liquids.’ ’’
The statement by Mr. Townsend on page 12-g of
the proposed amendment be omitted.
sah y
66 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
That the proposed amendment in line 20, page
206, line 8 page 216, line 5 page 249, be denied.
That in lieu of all amendments proposed from
line 15, page 251 to line 30 on page 255, substitute
the exact testimony given by question and answer
as shown from line 24 at page 439 to the end of the
testimony on page 448 of the transcript of testi-
mony. [49] |
In lieu of the amendments proposed from line
19, page 257, to line 1, page 264, substitute the
testimony given by question and answer as shown in
the transcript of the testimony from line 11, page
451, to the end of the testimony on page 470.
The amendment proposed after line 16, on page
266, is denied.
The first six lines of the proposed amendment
after line 23, page 266 be allowed; the balance of
said proposed amendment be denied.
In lieu of all amendments from line 24, page 270
to line 15, page 273, there be substituted all of the
testimony by question and answer shown in the
transcript of testimony from line 30, page 520, to
the end of the testimony at page 529.
The proposed amendment in line 12, line 18 and
line 19, page 280, be allowed.
That the proposed amendments in line 27 and
line 30, page 280 be denied.
That the proposed amendment to line 5 in page
281 and to lines 5 to 10, page 284 be denied.
That the proposed amendment to strike out a
portion from line 21 on page 284 to line 1 on page
285 be denied.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 67
That the proposed amendment after line 13, at
page 285 be denied.
In lieu of the proposed amendment to strike out
a\portion of page 285 from line 20 to line 30, inelu-
sive, be denied and there be substituted in lieu
thereof the testimony given by question and answer
as shown in the transcript of testimony from line
21, page 545 to line 22, page 546.
The proposed amendment in line 2, page 286 be |
denied.
That the proposed amendments in lines 7, 17 and
24, page 286 be allowed.
That the proposed amendment to strike out from
lines 3 to 5 on page 288 be denied.
That the proposed amendment to strike out from
line 17 on page 302 to line 27 on page 303 be denied.
That the amendment to strike out from line 3 to
line 14 on page 305 be allowed and that there be
added thereto, at the end, the following:
‘‘A. Yes, sir.”
The proposed amendment after line 16, page 305
be denied.
The proposed amendment to strike out from line
20 on page 305 to line 5 on page 306 be denied. [50]
The proposed amendment to strike out from line
19 to line 24 on page 307 be denied.
That the proposed amendment after line 24, page
311, be allowed and there be added to said amend-
ment, at the end thereof, all of the statements of
counsel from line 29 on page 583 to line 21 on page
084 of the transcript of testimony.
AB i i i 2) a om
Fe IE i comers erp
J
;
:
|
SESS ci lca Aaa Ta ICE apis orton oe
68 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
Entered.
BOURQUIN,
District Judge.
[Endorsed]: Filed Feb. 14, 1928. [51]
ae
[Title of Court and Cause. ]
NOTICE RE FILING PRAECIPE AND FIL-
ING STATEMENT OF TESTIMONY.
Messrs. Chadwick, MeMicken, Ramsey & Rupp,
Attorneys for Defendant,
Seattle, Washington.
Gentlemen:
Please be informed that the plaintiff has this day
filed a praecipe in the above-entitled cause and has
prepared and this day lodged with the Clerk of the
United States District Court at Seattle, Washing-
ton, for your examination, a statement, largely in
narrative form, of the testimony and depositions
specified in such praecipe.
Also please take notice that on January 18, 1928,
at 10:00 o’clock A. M., or as soon thereafter as
counsel can be heard, we shall ask the Court to
approve the said statement of the evidence and to
enter an order in the form hereunto annexed.
WILLIAMS, BRADBURY, McCALEB &
HINKLE,
BATTLE, HULBERT & HELSELL,
Counsel for Plaintiff.
Seattle, Washington, January 7, 1928.
————
_——
Received a copy of the above notice and copies
of the therein mentioned praecipe and draft order
this 7th day of January, 1928,
WM. A. LOFTUS,
CHARLES E. TOWNSEND,
S. F. CHADWICK,
| Counsel for Defendants.
Filed Jan. 7, 1928. [52]
vs. R. C. Storrie.d& Company. 69
Oe
[Title of Court and Cause.] i
STATEMENT OF PROCEEDINGS BEFORE
JUDGE BOURQUIN, AND NARRATIVE
OF TESTIMONY.
BE IT REMEMBERED, That heretofore and
on, to wit, September 13, 1927, at the hour of ten
o’clock A. M. the above-entitled cause came on reg-
ularly for hearing in the above-entitled court and
before the Honorable George W. Bourquin, sitting
without a jury. The plaintiff appearing by Lynn
A. Williams, Esq., C. C. Bradbury, Esq., and A. G.
McCaleb, Esq. (of Messrs. Williams, Bradbury,
McCaleb & Hinkle), and Frank P. Helsell, Esq.
(of Messrs. Battle, Hulbert’& Helsell), its attorneys
and counsel; the defendant appearing by Charles
E. Townsend, Esq., and William A. Loftus, Esq.
(of Messrs. Townsend, Loftus & Abbett), and
Stephen F. Chadwick, Esq. (of Messrs. Chadwick,
McMicken, Ramsey & Rupp), its attorneys and
counsel.
%
SA OER WAR oe omg CL: A a
wee rah
70 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
Mr. WILLIAMS.— We have elected to
reply upon a somewhat less number of the claims
of the patent in suit than are set up in our bill of
complaint. We shall rely upon claims 1, 2, 17, 18,
24, 29, 34 and 35 of this patent.
After statements to the Court, Mr. Lynn A.
Williams, for plaintiff, and Mr. Charles E. Town-
send, for defendant, the following [53] exhibits
were received in evidence in behalf of the plaintiff:
(1) A certified copy of articles of incorporation
of the plaintiff company as Plaintiff’s Ex-
hibit No. 1.
(2) A certificate of good standing of the plaintiff
company as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 2.
(3) <A certified copy of letters patent in suit to
MeMichael No. 1,127,600, as Plaintiff’s Ex-
hibit No. 3.
(4) The entire record in the suit of Concrete
Mixing & Conveying Company vs. Ulen Con-
tracting Corperation, as Plaintiff’s Exhibit
No. 4.
Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 4 objected to as not per-
tinent and not competent. Objection overruled and
exception noted.
(5) A eertified copy of the opinion of Judge
Learned Hand in Concrete Mixing & Con-
veying Company vs. Ulen Contracting Cor-
poration, as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 5.
(6) <A certified copy of the opinion of Judge
Augustus N. Hand in Concrete Mixing &
Conveying Company vs. Ulen Contracting
Corporation, as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 7.
[54]
De RE
FR TB RG
eee
vs. R. C. Storrie d& Company. 71
(7) A certified copy of the decree in Concrete
Company vs. Ulen was admitted in evidence
as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 8.
(8) <A certified copy of the Mandate of the Court
of Appeals in Concrete vs. Ulen was ad-
mitted in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit
No. 9.
(9) <A certified copy of the decree on the Mandate
in Concrete vs. Ulen was admitted in evi-
dence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 10.
Defendant objected to Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 10
as not pertinent and not competent. Objection
overruled and exception noted.
(10) The entire record in the case of Concrete
Mixing & Conveying Company vs. Powers-
Kennedy Company was admitted in evi-
dence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 11.
TESTIMONY OF ROY C. HACKLEY, FOR
PLAINTIFF.
ROY C. HACKLEY, plaintiff’s witness.’
My name is Roy C. Hackley. I am 47 years of
age, and reside at Berkeley, California. I am a
construction engineer. I am interested in the busi-
ness of selling or leasing apparatus for the pneu-
matic placing of concrete. I saw the apparatus
used by R. C. Storrie & Company in lining the
Skagit River tunnel. I designed that apparatus
and installed it or superintended its installation. I
saw it in operation. I continued to work on the
Skagit job until the completion of the contract. I
ee et
ET OIE
—
72 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.)
did not have anything to do with the designing of
a pneumatic concrete placing apparatus which was
employed by this same R. C. Storrie & Company in
connection with the Twin Peaks job in California.
I saw the pneumatic placing equipment which was
used by R. C. Storrie & Company on the Twin Peaks
job. A portion of the apparatus which was used
by R. C. Storrie & Company on the Twin Peaks
job was also employed in the Skagit River job, that
is to say, one of the concrete guns or placers which
had been used on the Twin Peaks job was used on
the Skagit River job. [55]
The apparatus which the Storrie Company first
used on the Twin Peaks job, and subsequently used
on the Skagit River job, was a vertical container
which held about ten cubic feet of mixed concrete.
{t had a door at the top to close it, an air intake
near [56] the top and two air pipes leading to
the elbow at the bottom of the container. This
apparatus was used on the Skagit job at the be-
ginning, but was later discontinued,
Having had called to my attention a certified copy
of an application for United States patent, filed on
March 26, 1924, by Roy C. Hackley, Serial No. .
702,056, I say that I am the Roy C. Hackley who
executed and filed such application for United
States patent.
Q. Now, I call your attention particularly to the
certified copy of a so-called cancelled drawing in
the matter of that application and to the first
photographic reproduction of a drawing as it ap-
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 73
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.)
pears in this certified copy of the file-wrapper and
also to the specification of this application for
patent, beginning on line 29 of page 5, and ending
on line 13 of page 8 of the specification, and I ask
you whether these illustrate and describe the ap-
paratus which you say you designed and which was
used by the defendant R. C. Storrie Company on
this Skagit River project?
A. Yes, that is correct.
Q. Now, did all of the detail of the apparatus as
used on the Skagit River job by Storrie & Com-
pany correspond exacily with what is shown in your
patent application drawing? I ask particularly
relative to the point at which the air-pipes enter the
chambers. Do they enter at the end or enter at the
sides ?
A. They enter at the end and at different points
on the bottom. ,
Q. This patent drawing shows they all enter at
the end, does it not?
A. No, it does not. [57]
Q. Can you point to one here shown as entering
somewhere other than at the end?
A. One end is there and one there and one in here.
Q. The end you say—the end, as you say, but
they enter, do they not, all of them, in this patent
drawing— ‘
A. (Interrupting.) They enter at the end, yes,
but they enter there at those points.
Q. In the apparatus as employed on the Skagit
“are oe oer
Ne Per
PELLETED SANE Ege Me geeaEte PRRAR INE oon > -
lie Seite Dida
a 2
Diiticiciniicc centre iets eRe cisco nso BT Fp A TENSES CSO RE
74 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.)
River Tunnel do they all enter at the end in that
fashion (indicating) or in some other way?
A. In the first one they entered at those points—
they entered at the bottom—
®. (Interrupting.) They entered or ended?
A. The air left the pipe at the same points.
Q. I am asking you where the pipes entered into
the chamber. Did they enter at the end, as shown
on this patent drawing, or did they enter the cham-
ber at the side?
A. On the first tried machine they entered at the
end and on the bottom.
(). Some on the bottom?
A. Yes, sir, some on the bottom—those same
points.
@. Will you look at this, drawing and state
whether this correctly represents the arrangement
of the pipes and particularly the way in which they
enter the chamber in the apparatus as used on the
Skagit River project?
A. Your pipe is incorrect.
@. The one which is marked 27-A?
A. That pipe is incorrect (indicating). That
pipe is incorrect (indicating.) And that pipe is in-
correct—the location.
@. Wasn’t there in that apparatus a pipe which
was cast at the end at this point? [58]
A. No, there was not, marked 29.
@. Marked 29, yes.
A. No, there was not.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 75
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.)
Q. And you say that there was no pipe corres-
ponding with the one marked 27-A?
A. That pipe did not enter that way.
Q. How did it enter?
A. This pipe entered at the end (indicating) and
this pipe entered at the bottom in a similar manner
to that. It was not a right angle.
Q. Is the illustration of the manner in which
pipe 26-A enters substantially correct ?
A. Substantially correct, yes. There was an
angle there. It did not have that direct right
angle.
Q. More of a bend in there?
A. More of a bend in there.
Q. Was there more than one of these apparatuses
employed on the Skagit River Project, that is, ap-
paratus that you designed?
A. Yes, there were several.
Q. There were several ? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Were they all identically alike?
A. The principle was the same in ail of them.
Q. But the bends and ends in those things dif-
fered— .
A. (Interrupting.) That was only used a very
short time,
Q. This one, as shown here (indicating) ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Subsequently the air pipes all came in from
the end?
A. Subsequently the air pipes all came in from
the end. They came in through the end, but they
— :
> ea” et
me.
76 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.)
terminated at the same point that they show there.
[59]
Q. That is, after the first one—
A. (Interrupting.) They terminated—they came
in through the end but they terminated at the same
point that they show there.
Q. After the first—
A. (Interrupting.) They terminated as shown
on the patent drawing.
Q. In all the machines they so terminated, didn’t
they ? A. Yes, sir.
Q. That is, the pipes corresponding with those
marked on this last drawing 27-A, 26-A, 25-—A,
there were such pipes in all of the several placers
but the method in which they were led in differ in
the successive machines. __
A. Yes, sir. This led in so that the air came di-
rectly on a line with the bottom of each one.
Q. Do you attribute any difference in mode of
operation to those slight differences which you al-
luded to? A. No; no difference.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—We offer in evidence the par-
tions of the Hackley file-wrapper and drawings
identified by the witness—that would be the peti-
tion, the oath, the specification as originally filed,
the first drawing and the cancelled drawing. We
ask that they be marked as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No.
12.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—That is objected to, your
Honor, for the reason that they are bringing in the
entire file of proceedings of the Patent Office in
Pa
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 7
connection with a patent that is not the patent in
suit. <A plain copy of the patent as finally issued
would serve the purpose. This only serves to en-
cumber the record and increase the cost.
The COURT.—What is the object? [60]
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Well, counsel were very care-
ful to offer not the entire file-wrapper, but a limited
part of the specifications and drawings which this
witness has testified are descriptive of the appa-
ratus used by the defendant.
The COURT.—Upon that statement they will be
admitted. Proceed.
(Whereupon the Hackley File was admitted in
evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit. 12.)
Mr. WILLIAMS.—-And I offer in evidence the
large drawing identified by the witness, marked
‘““Defendant’s Apparatus,” and ask that it be
marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 13.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—We object to that as no
proper foundation having been laid. We do not
know anything about this drawing. The witness
has said that it is not a correct drawing of his ap-
paratus.
The COURT.—It will be rejected at this time.
Make one, if you can, based upon the witness’ testi-
mony.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I would like to have this
drawing ‘that the witness has testified regarding
marked for identification as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 13.
The COURT.—It may be so marked. i
(Whereupon a drawing was identified as Plain-
tiff’s Exhibit 13.)
ae Fears
BOSE OE a OLE RS Ser? 2 De aol PC a. SES SR a ee
78 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.) «
Cross-examination.
Q. What was the occasion, Mr. Hackley, of get-
ting up that gun?
A. The unsatisfactory working of the gun that
we had used at first. ‘The work was unsatisfactory
to the engineers in charge of the job for the City of
Seattle.
(The above question objected to as not germane
and objection sustained). [61]
The old gun was used on the Skagit River for
possibly twokmonths. The Hackley gun was used
on the Skagit. River job until the completion of
the contract. That was approximately a year and
a half.
TESTIMONY OF R. C. OXENHAM, FOR
PLAINTIFF.
R. C. OXENHAM, plaintiff’s witness.
My name is R. C. Oxenham. I am 34 years old.
I reside at Chicago, Lllinois. I was in a tunnel
forming part-of the gorge plant of the Skagit River
project of the city of Seattle, located in the State
of Washington, near Rockport, on October 10, 1923.
I was accompanied on this visit by Mr. Albert G.
McCaleb. R. C. Storrie & Company was doing
work on that tunnel. I saw a pneumatic concrete
placing apparatus in operation in the tunnel at that
time. I have photographs which were taken at the
time of my visit and which illustrate what I saw.
I produce four of these photographs. These
eooO~___ Sub ab ie _
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company.
(Testimony of R. C. Oxenham.)
photographs were taken in my presence. They are
flashlight photographs.
(The four photographs marked respectively
14-A, 14-B, 14-C and 14-D were admitted in evi-
dence as plaintiff’s exhibits.)
Q. Can you produce a drawing of the machine
made by you or at your instance in accordance with
your observation made at that time?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Will you do so. (Witness produces draw-
ing.)
Mr. WILLIAMS.—We offer in evidence the two
drawings produced by the witness and ask that
they be marked Plaintiff’s Exhibits 15-A and B,
respectively.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—Objected to as not suffi-
ciently proven.
The COURT.—Interrogate your witness further
to see if he is competent—if he made them accur-
ately. [62]
Q. Just tell what you did in examining the ap-
paratus which you saw there at that time.
A. Well, we examined both the exterior and the
interior of the machine.
Q. How did you examine the interior.
A. Why, we had the man that was operating the
concrete placer machine open up the door. When
the door was opened why we examined it by means
of our flashlight on the inside and tested the air
that was coming out of the different pipes.
Q. Did you see where the various pipes led ?
“
a
SS
ic
5
e
=
=
5
¥
80 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of R. C. Oxenham.)
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Where they were directed? A. Yes, sir.
Q. You saw that with your own eyes, did you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you see the pipe valves? Perhaps you
had better name the things that you saw there—just
the parts that you saw.
A. Well, we saw the metal chamber and the open-
ing.
Q. What opening do you mean?
A. The opening on the top of the machine
whereby they put the concrete in. .
@. Did you see the concrete go in there?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Was the opening left open?
A. No, not after the concrete was put in. It was
closed tight.
Now, what else did you see?
We saw the various air pipes.
How many?
There were five in all. One was closed.
Which one was closed?
No. 29 on there.
How did you determine that? [63]
Why, when the top was opened why we put
our hand in there and the man turned the valve on
and there was no air came out of there. It was
Po rPoPOoPe
capped.
Q. Did you see the pipe from the outside—this
capped pipe? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, these other pipes on the bottom, how did
you observe them?
vs. R. C. Storrie &: Company. 81
(Testimony of R. C. Oxenham.)
A. We examined them carefully and saw that
some of them extended downwardly and along the
side or on the outside of the chamber and entered
the chamber at various points along the bottom of
the chamber.
Did you determine where they terminated.
We did.
Those several pipes?
Yes, sir.
By looking at them? A. Yes, sir.
Did you make any notes or memoranda of
what you saw at that time? A. Yes, sir.
Q. How soon were these drawings prepared after
your examination of the apparatus. .
A. Why, I should say about a month; when we
got back to Chicago.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Now, again I offer the draw-
ings. Just let me ask one question.
Q. Do these drawings which you have produced
accurately and correctly illustrate what you ob-
served as you have described? A. Yes, sir.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Again we offer them in evi-
dence and ask that they be marked Plaintiff’s Ex-
hibits 15-A and 15-B.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—We object to that. They
only represent the opinion of this witness and no
proper foundation has been laid. [64]
The COURT.-—Let me see them. Are you a
draftsman ?
OOPOoOPES
82 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of R. C. Oxenham.)
A. No, sir. ~~.
(By the COURT.)
Q. Did you make these? A. No, sir.
Q. You did not make them? A. No, sir.
The COURT.—I doubt whether they are prop-
erly admissible or competent. Of course, the ob-
jection is not made on that ground. They will be
admitted over objection. If not entitled to con-
sideration the Court will give them none. For the
sake of the record counsel’s exception will be noted.
Proceed. Anything further with the witness?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I think not.
(The drawings produced by the witness were re-
ceived in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibits Nos. 15-A
and 15-B.) [65] :
Cross-examination.
I am office manager for C. C. Erd & Company—
mortgage loans. I was going west on my vacation
at the time I visited the Skagit River project. I
had had no particular interest in concrete machin-
ery before that time. I had never seen any ma-
chines of that sort before that time. I have seen
some of these machines since that time. About two
and a half yards of concrete was placed in the ma-
chine which I saw at the Skagit River project. I
say two and a half cubic yards because it looked
that way to Mr. MeCaleb and me, and then I asked
the man that operated the gun and he said it was
around two and a half cubic yards. [66]
Q. You took his word for it; is that right?
A. Well, his word and Mr. MecCaleb’s.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 83
(Testimony of R. C. Oxenham.)
Q. And had that machine been used before that
charge was put in that you observed—had it been
in use ?
A. Yes, they were using the machine when we got
up to the tunnel.
Was it within the tunnel or outside?
Inside of the tunnel.
How far from the mouth of the tunnel?
Approximately halfway up the tunnel.
What distance would that be?
One mile.
Was it dark in there?
. Well, there were electric lights every now and
then. You could at least see your way going up
the tunnel, and we had a guide with us.
Q. When you looked into the machine or recep-
tacle there with your headlights, how much concrete
was in the bottom.
A. Well, when we looked in—he let us look in
after the concrete had gone through into the dis-
charge pipe.
Q. Were the sides—was the inside of the recep-
tacle polished and clean or did they have concrete
sticking to them?
A. It was kind of watery stuff. It was not what
you would call clean.
Q. That was in the“bottom ?
A. Yes, kind of aggregated down there.
Q. Did you measure any of those pipes at the
time yourself? A. No.
POPOPODS
“Peet EM ore
ne Bod on ete
84 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of R. C. Oxenham. )
Q. You took no measurements, I suppose, at the
time? [67]
A. Not of the pipes. I measured the main cham-
ber—-stepped it-off with our feet the best we could.
Q. Any operation that was given of that machine
you accepted as told you by the operators or by Mr.
McCaleb ?
A. Well, I had a very good idea myself after
looking at it just how the machine operated and so
forth. I did not take their word for everything.
Q. But you took their word for some things?
A. Some of the technical points, yes, sir.
Q. When the air was turned on, and how it was
turned on, and where?
A. Well, we could tell that by the valves there,
and also when he let us look inside of the chamber
when it was opened.
Q. Who made the sketches that are here?
A. They were made in Mr. McCaleb’s office.
TESTIMONY OF ROY C. HACKLEY, FOR
PLAINTIFF (RECALLED).
ROY C. HACKLEY, recalled for plaintiff.
Q. Mr. Hackley, will you look at these photo-
graphs that Mr. Oxenham produced and state
whether they appear to represent the apparatus
designed by you, or one of the apparatuses designed
by you and used in the Skagit Tunnel by R. C.
Storrie & Company. Just say whether it does or
not. A. It does.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 85
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.)
Q. Are those proper photographs of this appara-
tus ? A. They appear so to me.
Q. Better take the chair. Let me call your atten-
tion particularly to what appears to be a pipe lead-
ing in at the end of the chamber which point on this
photograph is marked 25 in red. A. Yes. [68]
Q. Was there such a pipe in one of those appara-
tuses ? A. Such a pipe was not used.
Q. Was it capped inside?
A. It may have been capped but it was not used.
If it was, someone capped it.
Q. Well, at any rate—
The COURT. — (Interrupting.) He has an-
swered that fully. It was not used.
Q. Now, there is illustrated on this drawing
Plaintiff’s Exhibit No.—what was this number for
identification—No. 13 for identification a pipe lead-
ing into the chamber at 29 and corresponding in its
location and size with the one shown as 29 on that
photograph ?
A. The photograph does not show as much as is
shown there. I cannot say exactly.
Q. Well, all that the photograph does not show is
the cap on the inside; is that right?
A. It does not show the connection with the
manifold. It does not show where that pipe came
from. ©
Q. Looking at this other photograph—the last
one in this series. That does show it connected to
the manifold, does it?
86 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.)
A. That does show it connected to the manifold,
yes, sir.
Q. Let us not spend much time on this, Mr. Hack-
ley, unless it is necessary. Isn’t it true that in that
apparatus there was an unused pipe leading down
to the pipe in substantially the way shown at 29—
A. (Interrupting.) There was with one of those
guns, yes.
Q. Now, won’t you look at these photographs also
and state whether they show the air pipes leading
down on the outside of the chamber—the pipes
which subsequently were connected in some way to
the bottom of [69] the chamber to jets directed
toward the outlet?
A. They show them on the outside and leaving
on the bottom.
@. And that is the way it was arranged on at
least one of these machines? A. Yes, sir.
Q. These photographs show also the inclination
on which the chamber was set, do they not?
A. That inclination was not intentional.
Q. Well, it is present in this photograph, isn’t it?
A. I do not know what the grade is—what the
grade of that tunnel was, whether it was a three and
a half per cent grade or not. And I do not know
Which direction that was in.
Q. Well, at any rate, the photograph shows the
chambers set on an inclination?
A. It shows the chamber set on an inclination
with the track.
Q. And the chambers were so set in some in-
stances on this work, were they not?
at
F
a
:
f
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 87
(Testimony of Roy C. Hackley.)
A. Not intentionally.
The COURT.—Cross-examine.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I think now with this further
testimony I shall offer in evidence the drawing
_ which was formerly marked for identification as
Exhibit 18. I think that is sufficiently established
now.
The WITNESS.—That pipe never was in there.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—29 you mean?
The WITNESS.—Yes.
The COURT.—The objection will be sustained.
Get a correct drawing made and you ean produce
it, and do not produce one that may mislead the
Court. Cross-examine if you have anything with
this witness. Proceed with the cross-examination.
[70]
Cross-examination.
(By Mr. TOWNSEND.)
Q. So pipe 29 which you see in this machine was
not used if put on in subsequent machines?
A. No, it was not.
(). Did you ever at any time admit air into your
gun anywhere except at the bottom / A. No.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—That is all.
(Witness excused. )
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I will recall Mr. Oxenham
again.
The COURT.—What is this witness for?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—lI want to ask him particularly
about this pipe 27-4, whether he saw that identical
APONTE as
ea
ee ee
Paseo —
88 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Shirley Houghton.)
one extending up there in that manner. It is a
matter of utter insignificance, I grant you that—
The COURT.—Well, we will not hear him now.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—It is incompetent.
The COURT.—Call your next witness if you have
one.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Your Honor, I think I shall
offer by the téstimony of Mr. Oxenham to show
that he observed that particular pipe extending in
that way.
The COURT.—Do not recall him now. If you
have another witness proceed or you rest. Take
vour choice. The Court assumes that counsel has
prepared his case outside of court on his time and
is not preparing it on mine, and if you have any
witnesses I want you to present them with some
degree of diligence and not wait and wait and
wait. [71]
TESTIMONY OF SHIRLEY HOUGHTON, FOR
PLAINTIFF.
SHIRLEY HOUGHTON, plaintiff's witness.
My name is Shirley Houghton. I am 44 years
old. I live at San Francisco, California, and am
a construction engineer. I saw pneumatic concrete
placing machines which were used by R. C. Storrie
& Company at several different places. The first
place I saw such a machine used by the defendant
was on the Mile Rock tunnel at San Francisco.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 89
(Testimony of Shirley Houghton.)
Mr. TOWNSEND.—If your Honor please, I ob-
ject to any testimony in regard to this different
work done outside of this district. This is a suit
laid on the Skagit River job.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—If the Court please, the pat-
ents are as broad as the United States and any act
of infringement anywhere, of course the defendant
is liable for it.
The COURT.—What infringement have you
charged—
Mr. WILLIAMS.—We have charged simply in-
fringement.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—What they are trying to do
your Honor, is to prove an estoppel which they have
not pleaded and which they tried to plead in para-
graph 5 of the bill of complaint and which was
struck out. If you will read paragraph 5, that is
what they are getting at, and they brought this
gentleman from San Francisco and the paragraph
5 was struck out by order of Court on motion of
the defendant. So they are not permitted now to
offer proof of an alleged estoppel.
The COURT.—Was paragraph 5 stricken from
your complaint?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Yes, your Honor.
The COURT.—You may show the use of the ma-
chine, but nothing in respect to the estoppel pleaded.
* . . . * . > . .
A. It was about the year 1914, to the best of my
recollection. [72]
90 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Shirley Houghton.)
Q. Now, how did you come to see that machine
at that time?
Mr. TOWNSEND.—That is objected to as irrele-
vant and immaterial.
The COURT.—Sustained. I do not care how he
got there.
WITNESS.—It was the so-called McMichael ma-
chine. I know it was the McMichael machine be-
cause I was the licensee of the Concrete Mixing &
Conveying Company for the Western section of
the country, and in that capacity we entered into
a contract with Storrie & Company for the installa-
tion of these machines. The partnership of which
I was one of the members installed that first ma-
chine which I saw in the Mile Rock tunnel. The
name of that partnership was Pacific Concrete
Placing Company. I next saw pneumatic concrete
placing machines used by the defendant on the
Twin Peaks tunnel in San Francisco.
@. Will you describe the machines in a general
way which you there saw?
A. The machines were the McMichael type of
mchines with additional air ports added to the side
and the heel of the elbow. I investigated as Mr.
Storrie had told us that he would put our machines
on that job. We later found out that he had built
machines of his own manufacture and put them on
there. We went out to investigate and see.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I move that the answer be
stricken as not responsive.
—— FASE Be A a RR
.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 91
(Testimony of Shirley Houghton.)
The COURT.—It will be stricken. [73]
The machines which the Storrie Company used
on the Twin Peaks job were not McMichael ma-
chines furnished by me as an agent or licensee of
the plaintiff. These machines which I saw on the
Twin Peaks job were vertical in type, Similar in
construction to the McMichael machines which were
installed on the Mile Rock tunnel, except that they
were of larger capacity and were provided with a
few additional air ports leading into the shell of
the machine. I made complaint or representation
to the Storrie Company relative to its use of these
machines not furnished by me or by the plaintiff.
As a result of this complaint, R. C. Storrie & Com-
pany entered into a compromise contract, with us
under which they paid us royalty for the use of
_ these machines and agreed to return the machines
to us at the completion of the Twin Peaks job.
Cross-examination.
(By Mr. TOWNSEND.)
Q. On the Mile Rock job where you say that a
so-called McMichael gun was used, where was the
air chamber into that receptacle?
A. It was admitted at several different points.
There were air ports on the shell of the vertical—
there was a sort of a cone-shaped receiver around
the shell as well as into the heel of the exhaust elbow
on the bottom of the shell.
Q. Where you had air coming into this Me-
Michael receptacle at the tope and on the material
92 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Shirley Houghton.)
and then you also had air coming into the elbow
outside of the sheil and adjacent to the outlet to
impel the concrete through the discharge pipe?
A. It would depend upon the operator just how
he might admit the air. He could not admit it
around the shell [74] if he so desired and he
could admit it at the bottom or he could admit it
on the shell or at the bottom simultaneously or in
between. Different operators use a little different
practice in the exact manner in which they admit
the air into the chambers containing the concrete
materials. ;
Q. A so-called chamber jet was outside of the
receptacle, wasn’t it, where it entered the elbow?
A. The air jet?
Q. Yes.
A. The air port into the heel of the elbow could
be termed a jet. It was into the mixer compart-
ment as there was no division between the elbow
and the conical chamber of the mixer.
Q. And all the air did not go into the receptacle
then but some of it went into the discharge pipe
and separate of the shell.
A. It could go up into the receptacle.
. I am asking as to the layout of the pipe.
You refer to this particular job?
Yes. A. The Twin Peaks job?
I am speaking of the Mile Rock job.
The Mile Rock job?
Yes.
OPoope
Ma ee ae 1 REIN . ay
so i 8 LK 4b OB Ee Ra SU ETS STINE Sa
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 98
(Testimony of Shirley Houghton.)
A. As I said before that would be the way the
operator would happen to handle his valves as to
where the air would go first.
Q. He might let some in at the top of the recep-
tacle or he might let some in at the heel outside of
the receptacle, is that right? [75]
A. He might do it simultaneously or he might do
it in behind—using one valve as ahead of the other
—or he might use the other one first. It depends
on the condition along the pipe-line and what he
wished to accomplish.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—That is all.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—That is all.
TESTIMONY OF H. B. KIRKLAND, FOR
PLAINTIFF.
H. B. KIRKLAND, plaintiff’s witness.
My name is H. B. Kirkland. My age is 46. I
reside at Evanston, Illinois. I am chief engineer
of Concrete Mixing & Conveying Company. I have
occupied this position as chief engineer since 1913.
I was trained as an engineer. I have been engaged
in the practice of engineering.
Q. Now, what briefly is the business of the plain-
tiff, the Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company ?
A. Manufacturing and leasing and the operation
of pneumatic machines for concrete placing.
Q. What kind of pneumatic machines?
A. Concrete machines-—pneumatie concrete ma-
chines.
4 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
Q. Are vou familiar with the McMichael patent ?
Have you read it? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Does the Concrete Mixing and Conveying
Company lease machines purporting to embody the
invention of the McMichael patent ? A. Yes, sir.
WITNESS.—I produce a photograph of the com-
mercial apparatus as leased by the plaintiff.
(The photograph produced by the witness was
admitted in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 16.)
[76]
Q. How long has the plaintiff been making or
having made and leasing apparatus such as is shown
in this photograph ?
A. Since about 1909, I think.
* * * * * * * * *
Q. Well, from your personal knowledge how
long? A. Since 1913.
WITNESS.—I produce a cross- section drawing
of the pneumatic placing apparatus” of the Me-
Michael patent as manufactured and leased by the
plaintiff, and I also produce a drawing showing
[77] the pipe connections. This is the commer-
cial form of the plaintiff’s apparatus.
(The drawings produced by the witness were ad-
mitted in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 17,
Drawings A and B.)
These drawings which I have produced represent
the details of the construction of the commercial
device as shown in the photograph just produced
by me.
Sue eee = apie al ated ¢ : Se) ae ~ rs oe eee
_—_
vs. R. C. Storrie d& Company. 95
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland. )
A. Yes, sir; I have a book here with several pic-
tures in it showing construction jobs.
Q. Won't you turn over these photographs of
this booklet and state rapidly what they show in a
eeneral way.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—Your Honor, we object to
this unless some foundation is shown that this man
or his company took and made these jobs or did
the work on them and that he took these photo-
graphs. If he simply gathered haphazard here and
there photographs on various work, of course it is
nothing but hearsay and irrelevant and incompe-
tent.
The COURT.—Prove their competency if you
desire. I do not think that they have been proven
yet. The objection is good.
Q. These photographs which you say you have
here, were they taken by you or at your instance ?
A. Some of them were on jobs where I supervised
the installation of the machanes.
Q. Did you see the work on all of the jobs which
you have photographs of here?
A. Most of them; not all of them.
Q. Do the photographs illustrate what you saw
on those jobs, and about those jobs?
A. Yes, sir. [78]
Q. Were those the jobs on which this MeMichael
pneumatic placing apparatus was used?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do the photographs show that apparatus in
use?
96 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
A. Some of the photographs show the machines
in the tunnel.
Q. Now, won’t you turn over the photographs
in that book and state what is shown by those you
have personal knowledge of. That is where you
saw the work yourself and either took the photo-
graphs or had them taken.
A. Here is a view of the interior of the Diana
Tunnel on the Louisville and Nashville Railway,
showing tha discharge pipes and the forms.
Q. You will have to speak louder. Talk to me.
Hold your voice up.
A. Here is a view of the interior of the St: Louis
Water Works Tunnel showing the discharge pipe
owing over the top of the forms.
The COURT.—What point will this make clear
in the patent itself? No controversy over the fact
that this concrete is shot out through this pipe and
over the forms, I have no doubt.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I presume there will not be,
but the photographs will show how it is done and
the situations in which it is done, which I think is
important.
The COURT.—I cannot see how it will help us
at a decision at all. The question is whether their
machine is your machine; whether your patent is
valid and whether they are using machines like
yours. Proceed. [79]
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Well, I should like to offer
in evidence the book of photographs as Plaintiff’s
Exhibit 18.
. nel
eo + eS
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 97
Mr. TOWNSEND.—The offer is objected to on
the ground that it is incompetent, irrelevant and
immaterial and not bearing on any issues of the
case.
The COURT.—Let me see the book.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—The patent is not particu-
larly concerned with the building of tunnels. It
has to do with transportation of concrete. These
photographs also show interior tunnel construction.
The COURT.—Objection sustained. It is not
necessary at all. Proceed with the witness.
(Book of photographs identified as Plaintiff’s
Exhibit 18 and admission in evidence denied.)
Q. I think T will ask you, Mr. Kirkland, to ex-
plain or describe very briefly how a concrete lined
tunnel is built. I do not want you to go into any
elaborate detail.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I make the same objection,
your Honor, that this is a patent that speaks for
itself.
The COURT.—Yes.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—And it mentions the word
‘“‘tunnel’’ only once.
The COURT.—Sustained.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—This patent is addressed to
persons skilled in the art, and I should like an op-
portunity to make a record of the condition of the
art and the art in which it is to be employed. I
understand that the Court sustains the objection.
I would like to have the question read.
4
|
98 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
(Whereupon question was read as follows: [80]
‘*T think I will ask you, Mr. Kirkland, to explain
or describe very briefly how a concrete lined tunnel
is built. I do not want you to go into any elaborate
detail.’’)
The COURT.—I cannot see how that is necessary,
The question is this machine, how it functions and
how it is made in relation to the parts; whether the
machines of the defendant infringe your patent.
But as to how a piece of work is carried on or how
tunnels are excavated, I cannot see how that will
enlighten us any. If it should appear that it is
competent after their case, you will have a chance
on rebuttal. Objection sustained.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I would like to have an ex-
ception,
The COURT.—Note it.
The MeMichael apparatus has been used mainly
in tunnel work for lining the tunnels with concrete.
I first learned about the use of this McMichael
apparatus in Cleveland, Ohio. I heard that Me-
Michael was experimenting with a machine on the
Dennison Viaduct where he was placing concrete
through a 6” pipe, 80’ in height. I was then engi-
necr for the contractor in charge of the con-
struction of the Rocky River Bridge there. This
was in 1909. Since that time I have been familiar
with the use of these McMichael apparatuses and
their methods. This has been my business with
the plaintiff company, since 1913.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 99
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
In reply to a request by counsel that I name some
of the tunnels or other large projects upon which
contractors have, under lease or otherwise, used the
MeMichael apparatus of the plaintiff company in
the lining and handling of concrete, I will say that
we have lined the St. Louis Water Works Tunnel,
[81] ¢ tunnel about 2400 feet long and 8 feet
in diameter; the Summit Tunnel of the C. B. &
Q. Railroad in Wyoming; a couple of tunnels for
the city of Memphis Water Works—rather drain-
age 16 feet in diameter, under air pressure. The
Diana Tunnel of the L. & N. Railroad. Several
tunnels on the Southern Pacific. I think there
were nineteen tunnels altogether there. The New
York ‘Subway work, the Chicago Water Works
eight miles long, and the Wilson Avenue tunnel.
I here produce a list of tunnel jobs, being tun-
nel jobs constructed by the use of the McMichael
apparatus, under license or lease from the plain-
tiff company.
(The list of jobs produced by the witness was
admitted in evidence as Plaintiff's Exhibit No. 19.)
Q. Now when you first learned of this Me-
Michael apparatus and method were you in a po-
sition where the matter was presented to you for
your consideration on behalf of a contracting con-
cern ? A. Yes, sir.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—Objected to as irrelevant
and immaterial.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—This is merely preliminary,
100 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
The COURT.—Overruled. Proceed to what is
material.
WITNESS.—At that time I was engineer for
the contractor of the Rocky River Bridge built
in Cleveland, Ohio and we thought of using it
for placing concrete in the arches of that bridge.
The arches were the longest in the world.
Q. And with what conclusion? Did you confer
with their people about it?
A. Yes, I conferred with the contractor.
Q. You speak so softly. I barely can hear you.
A. Yes. We conferred with the concern in the
contracting [82] business.
Q. And what was that contracting company—
what was its name?
A. I have forgotten that.
The COURT.—Well, if he has forgotten, pass
on. [83]
Q. What was your conclusion after having the
MeMichael matter proposed to you for use in that
work?
Mr. TOWNSEND.—We object, your Honor, on
the ground that this is not proper.
The COURT.—What is the object of this?
' Mr. WILLIAMS.—I want to show that engi-
neers, when this plan of operation was first pro-
posed regarded it as an impossible matter of
achievement, and to show what the state of feel-
ing in the art was relative to the thing proposed.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—That adds nothing to what
the patent shows itself. They must stand on the
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 101
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
patent and not on whether or not we are to come
within it.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Of course we must stand
upon the patent, but I believe we are entitled to
show what the condition of the engineers—what
the feeling of the engineers, what the belief of the
engineers in regard to this art was at the time
that this proposal was first made.
The COURT.—I cannot see that it is material.
You can show what the art was and how far it
has expanded it, if you desire. Objection will be
sustained,
Q. To what extent does the pneumatic placing
of concrete by the means and method of the Me-
Michael patent gun come into use in connection
with the lining of tunnels?
A. Practically every tunnel of importance in
the country to-day uses the pneumatic method of
lining.
Q. Is this method an apparatus of special value
in tunnel work as compared with other concrete
work such as paving or building operations? [84]
A. I should say that the use of pneumatic meth-
ods, in comparison to old methods, save—one costs
one-third or one-half of what the old method cost.
Q. In connection with what class of work?
A. Tunnel lining. That is, in drdinary tunnels.
Of course, tunnels that are build under air pres-
sure, in that case they save a great deal more.
Q. Is there any reason why this McMichael
2 Es . @
Cae ate SESE OOS OO 4 ee
102 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
method and apparatus is of such special utility or
value in tunnel work as compared wib other con-
erete work. For example, in foundation walls or
building floors.
A. I don’t think that I understand you.
Q. Well, you have said that this apparatus and
this method was used to the exclusion of every-
thing else in tunnel lining, haven't you?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. It is not so used to.the exclusion of every-
thing else in making concrete buildings ?
A. No, sir.
Q. Why is it that it is used exclusively and to
the exclusion of everything else in tunnel werk?
A. Because of the cost of air.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I object to thac statement
by counsel. In the first place it is not the testi-
mony of the witness, and in the second place it is
not proven, and they cannot prove it.
The COURT.—Cannot prove what?
Mr. TOWNSEND.—Cannot prove that this
pneumatic placing of concrete is exclusively used
in tunnel work.
The COURT.—He has not said so. That shows
for ‘itself. The difficulties of placing it are more
in tunnel work than outdoors, of course?) He may
answer. [85]
A. The cost of making air is a big factor in the
placing of concrete pneumatically, and would pro-
hibit its use in ordinary outside work where there
is not much—
>
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 103
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
Q. (Interrupting.) Did you hear the answer
that Judge Bourquin just gave?
The COURT.—Do not let him approve my
statements in advance. Those things are obvious.
I do not always need to be told that two and two
. make four. I might, sometimes.
Practically every tunnel of importance in the
country is now lined by the pneumatic method of
placing concrete. I have made it my _ business
since 1913 to learn about these tunnel jobs as they
came along and to try to get the contract for the
use of this apparatus. This has been my main
business since 1913.
Q. Now, did vou in that way or in the course of
your work as chief engineer of the plaintiff com-
pany here learn of the project of the City of Seat-
tle ‘to build this Skagit River Tunnel?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, when did vou learn of that? If you
‘~have correspondence or anything to aid your recol-
lection get it out and refresh vour recollection and
then state the facts.
A. I have some correspondence here, dated in
January of 1921 with Mr. Uhden, Chief Engineer
of the Skagit River Power Company. I called on
Mr. Uhden about that time out here in Seattle.
Q. You say that he was the engineer of the
Power Company; is that what you said?
A. Chief engineer of the project for the city of
Seattle, I mean. [86]
Ce ee : ' -
104 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
Q. And what representations did you make to
him and he to you, briefly?
A. Well, I told him about the pneumatic method
and of its advantages for tunnel work such as seal-
ing the rock tightly and making unnecessary a
good deal of grouting that is ordinarily done, and
show him pictures of the use of the machine, and
urged him to use it on the Skagit Tunnel.
Q. How did you first learn of the Skagit River
project? By a communication of Mr. Uhden to
you or in some other way?
A. He wrote us asking for information. He
sent us a copy of the cross-section of the tunnel.
Q. Do you have the correspondence here which
passed between him and you or your company ?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. That was in about 1921? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, do you know whether the correspon-
3 dence and your personal visit and representations
to Mr. Uhden led to the specification of the use of
the pneumatic method of the McMichael patent
or any pneumatic method in the lining of this
Skagit River Tunnel? A. Yes, sir.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I object to this as incom-
petent, irrelevant and immaterial. ‘
The COURT.—What is the object of this?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I want to show that it was
at the instance of this plaintiff that the city and
the engineers became interested in this pneumatic
placement and the answer to that will show that
they specified [87] that it should be used on the
no FT a we
ae AMR IAI Rist tetas das bse ad RAR
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 105
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
job and then the contracts were let to R. C. Storrie
& Company, and they used a method which we say
is the infringing method.
The COURT.—That is te only question,
whether it was an infringing method or not. That
is the only question, and how they came to use It
is immaterial. Objection sustained.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Exception. I should like to
have noted.
Q. What, approximately, is the weight of a cu-
bic yard of concrete? A. About two tons
Q. Are you familiar with the use of this Me-
Michael apparatus and method in the lining of the
Twin Peaks Tunnel at San Francisco ?
A. I know of it.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I object to that as im-
msterial. It has been gone into by the previous
witness. There is no charge that that is an in-
fringement.
The COURT.—How is that?
Mr. TOWNSEND.—There is no charge that the
Twin Peak work is an infringement.
Mr. WILLIAMS—Well, I grant .you that that
particular question was an immaterial one I will
ask another, if I may.
Q. How far has concrete to your knowledge
been conveyed through the duct or conduit of the
McMichael apparature commercially and as feas-
ibly practiced ?
A. 4,900 feet, I understand in the Twin Peaks
Tunnel in San Francisco.
a> he
TOUR WE Ee Pee
PPS IST
rw ee oe ree
‘
Aaa Ss CAME RM ak bac 6
RAPE EASE OR oe
~~ . «ee
106 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
Q. What is the highest elevation to which con-
crete has been carried by the use of this mechani-
cal apparatus and method, as far as you know?
A. 105 cubic feet is the highest that we have
had— _ [88]
Q. (Interrupting) 105 cubic feet?
A. 105 feet, rather, is the highest that we have
had any occasion to shoot it.
Q. In the use of this MeMichael apparatus—let
me ask you first, have you operated this apparatus
yourself ? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And have you taught other people how to do
it? A. Yes, sir.
Q. And you know how it operates?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Let me ask you whether or not the proper
mixture of the ingredients of the concrete as made
in the chamber of this apparatus is fully pre-
served through its passage and discharge into the
form where it is to be set? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is there any separation of the cement or the
sand from the rock in an objectionable manner or
degree ! A. No, sir.
Q. How long does it take to discharge a batch
of conerete materials from the chamber of this
MeMichael apparatus ?
A. It is just a matter of seconds. [89]
Q. How rapidly does it propel it through the
conduit ?
A. I think about five seconds per hundred lineal
feet of pipe.
|
er eee re
_—_ - . A nin Ply a a il a a
r —
yw
:
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 107
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
Q. When the concrete is conveyed through the
duct or conduit of the MeMichael apparatus and
reaches the form or the key of a tunnel arch in
which the concrete is to be set, what is the effect
of the discharge of that concrete upon the concrete
itself—the quality and characteristics of the con-
crete ?
A. The concrete, weighing perhaps a ton is dis-
charged from the end of the pipe into a tunnel
form where concrete has been previously put, and
discharges into the previously placed concrete
with such force, going perhaps 60 miles an hour
that it gives it a tremendous shock so that the
whole mass will quake and it makes a very dense
mixture and packs it in solidly.
(). How does concrete thus formed by the use ot
this method and apparatus compare in quality
with concrete formed by hand manipulation—put
in place by hand and tamped by hand?
A. Concrete tamped by hand is very likely to be
porous whereas pneumatic conerete is very dense
and fills up the spaces against the rock much more
tightly than could possibly be done by hand; also
in tunnels where there is timber used, it is neces-
sary to pack in the concrete in all the vacant
spaces which is impossible by hand and always
shows up with th® pneumatic method.
@. How far into a form can concrete be placed
or thrown by hand processes and tamped ?
A. Just as far as a man can reach with a stick
or shovel to tamp it with. [90]
POMEL ES, RINE Tn sen 89
OE BP Oana Re ae a
108 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
Q. How far is that?
A. A few feet—three or four feet.
Q. How far can—is concrete carried from the
end of the discharge duct of the McMichael appa-
ratus to the place in the form at which it is to
set ?
A. About 20 feet. The end of the pipe is usu-
ally carried to within 20 feet of the rear of the
forms.
Q. Is the pipe carried over the form and be-
tween the form and the rough interior of the ex-
cavated tunnel? A. Yes, sir. -
Q. How far can concrete be conveyed partly
through the duct and partly after it reaches the
end of the duct beyond the immediate end of the
torm ?
A. Well, the form can be any convenient length
—it may be 40 and it may be 60 feet, and the pipe
that discharges the concrete is carried over the top
of it to within 20 feet of the back end. |.
Q. What has been the custom in the commercial
use of this apparatus in so far as you know as to
the length of form through or by which the con-
crete has been carried or conveyed to the point at
which it is to set?
A. We have had forms 20, 40 and even 80 feet.
Where the forms are short, we have them placed
in several places.
Q. How far can forms project beyond the point
at which the concrete is delivered if hand methods
were employed? What would be the maximum?
7
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 109
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
A. I should say six feet.
Q. What air pressure—what degree of air pres-
sure is commercially used in the operation of this
McMichael apparatus and method?
A. From 80 to 120 pounds. [91]
Q. What is the capacity per hour—that is how
many yards per hour of concrete can be handled
and delivered from one of these MeMichael ma-
chines in accordance with your experience with
them.
A. Well, 60—about 60 yards.—That would be
about 240,000 pounds.
Q. What is the diameter of the duct of conduit
of this McMichael apparatus as ordinarily used
in practice? A. I didn’t get that.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Read the question, please.
(Question read as follows: ‘‘Q. What is the di-
ameter of the duct or conduit of this McMichae!
apparatus as ordinarily used in practice ?’’)
A. Six or eight inches.
Q. Can you produce a sample of concrete such
as is produced or that has been produced by the
use of this mechanical apparatus? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is that broken to show the texture—
A. (Interrupting.) Yes.
Q. (Interrupting.) —Of the iinished concrete?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Is that here? A. Yes, sir.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—We offer in evidence and
ask that it be marked Plaintiff’s Exhibit 20. Is
that here somewhere? Is this what you offer?
nd ee oe
;
4
110 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
A. Yes. That is New York Subway concrete.
(Whereupon piece of concrete was admitted in
evidence as Plaintiff's Exhibit 20.) [92]
Q. Perhaps you had better state how you char-
acterize the quality of the concrete exhibited by
this sample.
A. That is a homogeneous mixture and is char-
acteristic of good conerete. It is dense—that is
about all dense,
Q. Impervious to moisture, is it—water flowing
through it.
A. Well, not entirely. It will become damp, but
it is not porous like some concrete placed by hand.
Q. Have the apparatus or the machines manu-
factured and leased by the plaintiff company been
stamped or marked with the word *‘ Patentee’’ and
the date of the McMichael patent that is, Febru-
‘ary 9th, 1925? A. Yes sir.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—If they have a mark, your
Honor, we would like to see it. If it is a plate,
they should produce the plate.
The COURT.—Oh, I do not know. At any rate
there is nothing before the Court. Proceed.
Q. Is John H. McMichael, the patentee, living?
A. Mr. MeMichael died about 1919.
Q. Now, when was it that concrete came into
common use—how long ago?
A. Well, I should say that the lining of tunnels
with concrete came in with the making of side-
walls by concrete. Perhaps before 1900.
Q. Well, how long before?
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 111
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
A. As far back as 1880.
Q. Now, have you here in Seattle an example of
the MeMichael machine as manufactured and
leased by the plaintiff and which is available to
be exhibited to court and counsel? [93]
A. Yes, sir, It is the Starr Machinery Com-
pany in Seattle. There we have a couple of ma-
chines,
Mr. WILLIAMS.—That I hesitate to offer in
evidence, your Honor. It is a mile and a half
from here. It is a heavy piece of apparatus. I
invite the Court and counsel to observe that this
noon recess or at the conclusion of court or at any
time that suits the convenience of the Court.
The COURT.—Well, not now. If the Court
ever thinks that he wants to see it, it can be shown
later.
@. Let me see. You referred to the correspon-
dence you had with Mr, Uhden, and produced
that. I think I have neglected to offer it in evi-
dence. I do offer it now, as Plaintiff’s Exhibit
No. 21.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—The correspondence, I un-
derstand, was rejected.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I beg your pardon?
Mr. TOWNSEND.—You are referring to the
correspondence ?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Yes.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—That was rejected on ob-
jection,
eet abe oe ee See
i, Lea! Ge RRUEAN TT LI OTe pa eee ‘
112 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
The COURT.—It has not been offered before, I
do not believe.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I object to it on the ground
that it is—
The COURT.—(Interrupting.) Sustained.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Exception I would _ your
Honor.
The COURT.—Anything further with this wit-
ness? If not, you may cross-examine.
Mr. WILLMMS.—I have another question, I
think. ‘|
The COURT.—Bring it forward, counse’. [94]
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I would like to have
marked for identification merely these letters
which we have offered to put in evidence and as
to which the Court has sustained the objection of
counsel. I understand that they do not go in evi-
dence. I would like, however, to have them
marked for identification. ;
The COURT.—That can be done.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—As exhibit 21 that would be.
And that I should like to have done also with the
photographs in the book, or the book of photo-
graphs. That would be marked for identification
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 18.
The COURT.—That may be done.
(Whereupon correspondence between the plain-
tiff company and Mr. Uhden was marked for iden-
tification Plaintiff’s Exhibit 21 and denied in evi-
dence and book of photographs was marked Plain-
ee eS Te Rep OO AE EGU
Te het”
eh RIE A
~_ i."
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. \113
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
tiff’s Exhibit 18 for identification and -denied i
evidence. )
Mr. WILLIAMS.—That is all now.
Cross-examination.
(By Mr. TOWNSEND.)
Q. Mr. Kirkland, who prepared this list marked
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 19 of alleged jobs on which
your apparatus was used? A. I did.
Q. Did you notice that there were a great many
duplications on there?
A. I went through our files to get the names of
jobs that we had done and I did probably get
some duplications. dd
Q. I call your attention and the attention of the
Court [95] to the fact that all these that are
marked with a pencil check appear in duplicate.
In other words, the same job is mentigned twice?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Did you have any object in aeiea it—
making the list appearing longer?
A. I didn’t know that it had been duplicated.
Q. Now, do you recall any objections that the
alleged users made to the use of concrete placed
by the so-called McMichael method and difficulties
that these users were caused ? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Yes.
A. Everybody has troubles occasionally at the
beginning—learning to use’ the pneumatic method.
Q. So this list does not represent a contented
|
|
114 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
lot of users or one of those from whom no objection
was received ?
A. After they had become acquainted with the
use of the machine they had no objections.
Q. Do you recall the use in, the Pennsylvania
Tunnel and their experience with it?
A. No, sir. .
Q. That within the last year or two or so—com-
paratively recently they had to expend a hundred
thousand dollars in going over the work that was
supposed to be done by the so-called MeMichael
method or gun?
A. I do not know about any such thing.
@. You haven’t heard of that? A. No, sir.
_Q. Have you heard of any trouble from the
Southern Pacific? [96]
A. No, sir. They are using it now.
Q. What is the character of gun that they are
using? What style?
A. They are using the vertical type.
Q. Do you know that of your own knowledge or
just from reports that are coming to you?
A. From reports that I have received.
Q. Merely hearsay?
(Witness does not answer.)
Q. You said that the passing of concrete or ma-
terial through the pipe was approximately 100 feet
every five seconds? A. Yes, sir, approximately.
Q. What measurements have you made to deter-
mine velocities in any instance?
a
St ere So,
.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 115
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
A. That estimate is by observation although we
have since made measurements that will accurately
determine the velocity.
Q. What was the observation you referred to,
visual or what? A. Visual.
Q. At what point?
A. At various points along the delivery path.
Q. How would you observe the operation inside
of an iron pipe that was opaque?
A. By listening to the slugs going through.
Q. You base it then partly upon your sense of
hearing ? A. Yes, sir.
Q. It was largely a matter of guess as to how fast
it was going, wasn’t it? [97]
A. Well, you can guess it pretty approximately.
Q. You said that one of the desirable features of
the use of the so-called McMichael gun in placing
concrete in tunnels and against forms was the ve-
locity or the violence of the discharge?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Do I understand you correctly?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And that that violent discharge gave a com-
pacted product at the deposit point? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Now, if you were to discharge some other
material at equal velocity or of equal density by
compressed air would you get that same compact-
ness ? A. If it was of equal density.
Q. Of equal velocity—of equal density and with
equal velocity? 7
a ii mamma ——
peed tlh AOR LY La pe is AA Baile A aNd AIR ART at OTN on
116 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
A. And the material had the same velocity, cer-
tainly.
Q. So that blowing any material through a pipe
where the velocity was the same—strike that out.
What proportions of sand, cement and rock or
gravel and water do you recommend for use in your
machine ?
A. Well, any proportion that aggregates cement,
rock and water will be carried through the machine
and discharged through it.
Q. Any proportion of the rock, do you mean or
any of che ingredients? ,
A. Any proportions of the ingredients.
Q. Any proportion of the given ingredients?
A. Yes, except the discharge of rock alone. That
would [98] not be successful.
Q. Rock alone would not be concrete? A. No.
Q. But it would go through your apparatus,
would it?
A. Rock alone might cause trouble in getting
through.
Q. Well, assume that we have water with it. I
did not intend to blow dry rock.
A. Even with water it might cause trouble.
Q. Sand and water would blow through your
apparatus, too, would it rfot?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I object, your Honor, to these
questions which are not germane to the direct and
they are rather speculative. They are not germane
and not niaterial to what would happen.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 117
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
Mr. TOWNSEND.—It is a matter of proportion.
Here is the plaintiff’s own engineer. We would
like to know what his machine would handle and
what material it is adapted for.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—The question is whether it
would do these things and not whether it does.
The COURT.—He has been telling us with what
speed it moves. I think you can ask him what pro-
portions it will handle. Read the question.
(Whereupon question was read as follows: ‘‘Q.
Sand and water would blow through your apparatus
too, would it not?’’)
A. Yes.
Q. Sand and cement too would blow through,
mixed with water, would it not?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I make the same objection.
[99]
The COURT.—Objection overruled.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. And cement and water in mobile proportion
would also blow through the machine, would it
not?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—Same objection.
The COURT.—He may answer. I think those
are all obvious.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Taking the mixture which you call concrete
and which you say can be mixed in any proportion
with respect to any ingredient—what effect has
cement upon the mixture. Does it retard the flow
or facilitate its flow?
PIE MIO em a UP.
118 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
A. It does ‘not flow through the pipe. It is forced
through by pressure.
Q. I beg your pardon?
A. It does not flow through the pipe. It is forced
through by pressure.
Q. Well, blown through, isn’t it?
A. Well, not like a stream. It is forced through
by the expansion of the air.
Q. I am speaking about its traveling through.
A. Yes, sir.
Q. In that sense I used the word ‘‘flow’’ like
blowing or traversing, or whatever it is. Does the
cement facilitate its movement or retard its move-
ment ?
A. I do not think that I would want to say that
it would retard it. J am not sure that it does. I
guess it might.
Q. Well, isn’t it a fact that a certain amount of
cement [100] is a lubricant to the movement of
the mixture through the pipe?
A. Well, putting lime into it makes it more of
a lubricant.
Q. Then that would make it more so?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. The addition of lime? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Speaking, however, of cement that is added
to the rock and sand and water—cement has a lub-
ricating effect of some degree, has it not?
A. I should say so.
Q. Will you be good enough, by reference to
; eens |
;
§
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 119
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
Plaintiff’s Exhibit 17-B, show to the Court where
the air comes into the receptacle?
A. In this machine there are four air ports at
the top and one at the bottom at the heel of the
discharge elbow.
Q. Will you be good enough to mark with the
Court’s permission the air port at the top with the
letter ‘‘A’’ and a lead arrow?
A. (Witness marks same.) That is ‘‘A’’ and
here is the—looking down at the machine shows
‘A’? here, and ‘‘A’’ here, and ‘‘A’’ here, and
‘A’? here (indicating). All machines are con-
nected up in that way.
Q. Now, will you be good enough to indicate the
lower air line by the letter ‘‘B’’?
A. This is it (indicates and marks).
Q. Now, the pipe that I am pointing to, mark
that ‘‘C,’’ and tell us what that is.
A. That pipe line is the air supply line for the —
lower [101] inlet.
Q. Is that what you might call a siphon jet, or
an injected jet through ‘‘C’’ to point ‘‘D’’?
A. It is a pressure jet.
Q. And that blows directly into the outlet pipe?
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Will you mark the outlet pipe by the letter
**T—’'?
(Witness marks same.)
Q. Now, in this photograph of the so-called com-
mercial machine, Exhibit 16, will you indicate by
lead arrows where the pipe ‘‘C-B”’ enters?
120 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.)
A. That is ‘‘B.”’
Q. Mark that ‘‘B’’ please and mark that ‘‘C.”’
(Witness marks same.)
Q. Now, in the McMichael patent where is the
pipe that corresponds to ‘‘C-B’’—-I am showing
you an enlargement of the McMichael drawing.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I object, if the Court please,
to this question on the ground that it is not ger-
mane. The witness has not testified to the details
of the patent. We havea witness whom we expect
to call, Mr. Ray, who is competent in a way that
I am sure that Mr. Kirkland is not, to answer such
question.
The COURT.—I suppose the patent shows all
these things for itself and I do not know where it
would better the case any to have the witness point
out where the pipe is on the patent.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I do not want to encroach
upon your prerogative.
The COURT.—It is not that, but you are simply
taking [102] up time uselessly.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I just want to ask in regard
to two features.
The COURT.—yYou introduced the drawings.
You are supposed to indicate something to the
Court, and I suppose the other side is entitled to
cross-examination, to a limited extent. Be brief,
huwever. Objection will be overruled. Proceed.
A. This pipe, this is the pipe that carries to the
interior of the machine at the bottom.
Q. Tam, is marked ‘‘ten’’ with a continuation
‘
| vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 121
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.) :
down through the body of the concrete, is that
correct? A. Yes, sir. Exhibit 10 is the pipe.
Q. Yes. A. Yes. |
Mr. WILLIAMS.—It shows for itself.
The COURT.—Yes, undoubtedly.
Mr. LOFTUS.—He has been testifying about
this McMichael apparatus and what it will do, and
it is competent to show what that apparatus was
and how it compared with the McMichael drawings.
The COURT.—It shows for itself and the draw-
ings show for themselves. Proceed, Counsel.
Q. In your so-called commercial machine as
shown either in Exhibit 16 or 17-A or 17-B here
you have this—you have this ‘‘24’’ that appears
in the McMichael patent.
A. We occasionally use that when a machine is
sunk in a pit.
Q. That is not my question. Does that appear
in these drawings, 17-B or 17-A or in the photo-
graph 16% [103] A. That is the discharge pipe.
Q. You have no traps, 24, or “‘U”’ bend shown
in either of these so-called McMichael structures?
The COURT.—Well, he said so, and they show
for themselves.
Q. Now, here is an enlargement. Does this cor-
rectly represent that so-called McMichael machine ¢
A. Yes, sir.
Q. Which is the structure you use to-day.
A. Both of them are used to-day.
Q. The Ransome Concrete Machinery Company,
is that your licensee? A. Yes, sir.
a ie) —*
re Pe MAR OY eed: RA
122 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of H. B. Kirkland.) - «a
Q. And both of these machines according to your
understanding, come within the McMichael patent?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I offer this enlargement as
Defendant’s Exhibit ‘‘A’’ for Identification.
The COURT.—We will have one series of exhibit
numbers. What is the next number?
Mr. TOWNSEND.—May I give it the number
that will follow my deposition exhibits and eall
it 133?
The COURT.—Yes, you may.
(Whereupon enlargements of McMichael ma-
chine admitted in evidence as Defendant’s Exhibit
133.)
Redirect Examination.
When in the use of a vertical MeMichael machine
which is quite high, it is difficult to raise the con-
crete up to the top of it and dump it into the ma-
chine, we dig a pit and sink the machine down
into so that the top of the machine will come at
a convenient height for dumping the materials into
it. In that case have to have the “U”’ bend to
carry the discharge [104] out of the pit and on
through to its destination. The ‘*U’’ bend is still
used under these circumstances,
(Whereupon an adjournment was taken at 12:00
o'clock to 2:00 o'clock of the same day.)
September 13, 1927, 2:00 P. M.
Court convened pursuant to adjournment.
All parties present.
i
;
ae
-
TESTIMONY OF ARTHUR P. ROBINSON,
FOR PLAINTIFF.
ARTHUR P. ROBINSON, plaiutiff’s witness.
My name is Arthur P. iiobinson. I am 40 years
old. I reside at Plainfield, New Jersey, and I
am sales manager of the Ransome Concrete Ma-
chinery Company.
I heard the examination this morning of one of
the witnesses, during which examination reference
was made on cross-examination to the pneumatic
concrete placing machines manufactured by the
Ransome Company under the license of the Con-
erete Mixing & Conveying Company. The com-
pany with which I am connected is that Ransome
Company.
I produce an illustration of the commercial ma-
chine put\out by the Ransome Concrete Machinery
Company under its license. This illustration is a
photograph. \ It shows a small 7’ machine.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—That we offer in evidence and
ask that it be marked Plaintiff's Exhibit 22.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—I object to that as incom-
petent, irrelevant and immaterial.
The COURT.—What is the object of that? Have
you got that in already, Counsel?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—It is a somewhat different
machine. This is a horizontal form of the ma-
chine. What we have put in thus far is the ver-
tical type. [105]
124 Conerete Mixing and Convey ying, Company
(Testimony of Arthur P. Robinson.)
(The photograph showing the small 7’ horizontal
machine was admitted in evidence as Plaintiff’s
Exhibit No. 22.)
I also submit a blue-print of the same 7’ hori-
zontal machine.
(The blue-print of the 7’ horizontal machine was
admitted in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 23.)
I produce a photograph of the larger machine and
also a drawing of the larger machine. [106]
(The photograph of the larger McMichael type
machine of the Ransome Company was admitted
in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 24, and the
blue-print of the same machine was admitted in
evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 25.)
Q. Mr. Robinson, now in what way does the
Ransome Company put out these machines?
A. We lease them.
Q. To whom? A. To contractors.
Q. For what kind of work?
A. Mainly for lining of tunnels and subways.
Q. Can you name some of the tunnel jobs on
which you have used or on which you have leased
these machines under this license?
A. Sebago Lake, Maine, water tunnel; Boston
Revere Beach Railroad, Boston; East Boston Rail-
road tunnel; special work on various New York
subway jobs; four now working on Philadelphia
store tunnels; three working on the Illinois Cen-
tral tunnel Ozark Mountains in Illinois; four work-
ing on the power development at Calderwood,
Tenn. I believe we have now working under lease
_—_
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 125
(Testimony of Arthur P. Robinson.)
that have not been returned in the United States
twenty-seven.
Q. Do you have a complete list of those jobs here?
A. , sir, I have.
Q. That you can submit? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Willyou produce it, and we offer that in
evidence and ask that it be admitted in evidence
as Plaintiff’s Exhibit 26.
(The list of jobs on which the McMichael type
machine of the Ransome Company was used was
admitted in evidence as Plaintiff’s Exhibit No. 26.)
[107]
I have been connected with the Ransome Company
directly since 1915 and indirectly since 1909. I am
familiar with the manufacturers of concrete mixing
and handling machinery, and know who they are.
Q. Who are some of these prominent concerns
engaged in that business?
A. Kerr & Company, Milwaukee; T. L. Smith &
Company, Milwaukee; Chain Belt Company, Mil-
‘waukee; The Lakewood Company, Cleveland; Con-
struction Machinery Company, Waterloo, Iowa, and
the Yeager Company of Columbus, Ohio.
The COURT.—That is enough.
Q. Have these or other manufacturers of such
machinery and regularly engaged in the business of
making and selling concrete mixing and handling
machinery, sold or leased machines for the pneu-
matic conveyance of concrete? A. No, sir.
Q. I beg your pardon? A. No, sir.
:
126 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Arthur P. Robinson.)
Q. Have all of these concerns, in so far as you are
aware, respected the McMichael patent in suit?
A. Yes, sir.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—That is objected to as in-
competent, irrelevant and immaterial.
The COURT.—Sustained.
Q. Do you have available here a sample of these
MeMichael machines put out by the Ransome Com-
pany ?
A. There is one in the warehouse or store of the
Star Machinery Company.
Q. Where is that?
A. Seventeen hundred and something First Ave-
nue South here in Seattle. [108]
Mr. WILLIAMS.—We offer to make an inspec-
tion of that machine available to Court and counsel
during or after the trial.. That is all.
The COURT.—Cross-examine.
Cross-examination.
(By Mr. TOWNSEND.)
Q. Are both of these machines which are repre-
sented in those photographs, Plaintiff’s Exhibit 22
and Plaintiff’s Exhibit 24 screw driven?
A. No. They are motor driven.
Q. Do you have a screw in each of those types
of machines?
A. Yes, sir. The blue-print shows that distinctly.
Q. The screw is shown there? A. Yes, sir.
Q. Isn’t it a fact that you have abandoned the
use of the screw? A. No, sir.
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 127
(Testimony of Arthur P. Robinson.)
Q. Isn’t it a fact that the screw was proved a
failure ? A. No, sir.
Q..And that you are now using the Hackley con-
struction ? A. No, sir.
Q. Isn’t it a fact that you are now infringing the
Hackley patent ?
Mr. WILLIAMS.—I object as calling for a con-
clusion.
The COURT.—Sustained.
Q. Isn’t it a fact that these two machines have
proven a failure on at least one job here in the
West?
A. It would not say that they have proved a
failure. They completed the job of that. They did
not use the screw, if that is what you mean. They
took the screw out. [109]
Q. They took the screw out? A. Yes, sir.
Q. What did they do?
A. They put an air jet in the back.
Q. They put an air jet in the bottom and blew it
longitudinally in the bottom of the cement con-
tainer? SS
A. I couldn’t tell you where they put the air jets.
They put it in the back so that they blow it for-
ward, yes, sir.
Q. Was that the Cascade job?
A. That was the Grant Smith job at Selah.
Q. Do you use the vertical gun now or sell it at
the present time?
A. I don’t believe that we have any out in opera-
bad
i i a ee ae ey
¢
eee |
SEES
128 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of Arthur P. Robinson.)
tion. We have some at the plant and we have put
some out, yes, sir.
Q. You have supplanted all your so-called vertical
guns with horizontal guns, haven’t you, of the type
of Exhibit 22 and 24?
A. We are putting out almost entirely the hori-
zontal type of gun, yes, sir. _
Q. Referring to Exhibit drawing No. 25 repre-
senting the large type cf gun? A. Yes, sir.
Q. What is the capacity of that gun?
A. Fourteen cubie feet of mixed concrete.
Q. Now, when the screw was taken out in this gun
where were the air jets placed ?
A. I don’t know. I wasn’t on that job.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—That is all. [110]
Redirect Examination.
By Mr. WILLIAMS.—What is the reason, Mr.
Robinson, why yor are now largely supplying the
horizontal type of gun rather than the vertical type?
Mr. TOWNSEND.—Objected to for the reason
that it is of no importance.
The COURT.—Well, you brought it out.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—Oh, very well.
The COURT.—I do not think it is, but you
brought it out in the first instance. He may answer.
A. What was the question again?
(Question read as follows:)
Q. What is the reason, Mr. Robinson, why you
are now largely supplying the horizontal type of
gun rather than the vertical type?
-
vs. R. C. Storrie & Company. 129
(Testimony of Arthur P. Robinson.)
A. Two reasons—three reasons, I would say.
First, we get a smaller air consumption than we got
with the vertical type of gun; secondly, we practi-
cally do away entirely with the tendency of block-
ing due to the even speed; and third there is a very
considerable saving in the overall height. The
recent practice is that the machines follow the forms
and in small tunnels you cannot get the vertical
machine in.
Mr. WILLIAMS.—That is all.
- The COURT.—Call your next witness.
Mr. TOWNSEND.—Approximate the date,
please, when you went to the horizontal type?
A. I think I have got it on the back of here, but
I am not sure. I would say in 1925. [111]
TESTIMONY OF O. R. BROCK, FOR PLAIN-
TIFF.
O. R. BROCK, plaintiff’s witness.
My name is O. R. Brock. My age is 47, and I
reside in Seattle at 619-12th Avenue. My oceupa-
tion is mining and concreting in tunnels. In 1923
or thereabouts I was employed by R. C. Storrie
Company, the defendant here. I was engaged in
concrete work as a foreman. I had charge of the
concrete work at nights. I did not operate any
concrete placing apparatus that was used in lining
the Skagit tunnel, but I had men working for me
who did this work. I saw the placing machines
that were there used. My duties were to give my
Rewee- Pee
——
|
130 Concrete Mixing and Conveying Company
(Testimony of O. R. Brock.)
men orders to go ahead and build the forms and get
the concrete in from the outside of the tunnel into
the mixers. The operation of the concrete placing
machines came under my supervision, and I learned
what the construction of those machines was.
Q. Will you describe those machines?
A. Those machines ?
Q. Yes.
A. Well, I would describe those machines—which
way do you mean—the way they were working or
operated ?
A AOE BOOB La ihe SD Gis SAIN ai al Hl al
* ~—- OS Bon ss
¥
“{ a : :
i's WY. No. Can you describe how they were made, in
I
F a general way ? A. How they were made?
9 Q. Yes.
A. Well, they were made from steel and kind
of shaped—I think they were sixteen feet long
and a filling on top where we put the concrete in
there and we had manifolds with air where we got
the concrete out of the gun. We had four walls
and an eight-inch pipe where the air put the con-
erete through the pipe and [112] replaced it
behind the form
This text is long and has been trimmed here. Open the source document for the complete record.
This is a copy of a public record, reproduced as it was published. It is not legal advice, and it may not be the version a court would rely on. Check the official source before you cite it.